Citrus Canker, Citrus Greening, and Asian Citrus Psyllid; Interstate Movement of Regulated Nursery Stock, 23449-23459 [2011-10092]
Download as PDF
23449
Rules and Regulations
Federal Register
Vol. 76, No. 81
Wednesday, April 27, 2011
This section of the FEDERAL REGISTER
contains regulatory documents having general
applicability and legal effect, most of which
are keyed to and codified in the Code of
Federal Regulations, which is published under
50 titles pursuant to 44 U.S.C. 1510.
The Code of Federal Regulations is sold by
the Superintendent of Documents. Prices of
new books are listed in the first FEDERAL
REGISTER issue of each week.
DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
Animal and Plant Health Inspection
Service
7 CFR Part 301
[Docket No. APHIS–2010–0048]
RIN 0579–AD29
Citrus Canker, Citrus Greening, and
Asian Citrus Psyllid; Interstate
Movement of Regulated Nursery Stock
Animal and Plant Health
Inspection Service, USDA.
ACTION: Interim rule.
AGENCY:
We are amending the
regulations governing the interstate
movement of regulated articles from
areas quarantined for citrus canker,
citrus greening, and/or Asian citrus
psyllid (ACP) to allow the movement of
regulated nursery stock under a
certificate to any area within the United
States. In order to be eligible to move
regulated nursery stock, a nursery must
enter into a compliance agreement with
APHIS that specifies the conditions
under which the nursery stock must be
grown, maintained, and shipped. We are
also amending the regulations that allow
the movement of regulated nursery
stock from an area quarantined for ACP,
but not for citrus greening, to amend the
existing regulatory requirements for the
issuance of limited permits for the
interstate movement of the nursery
stock. We are making these changes on
an immediate basis in order to provide
nursery stock producers in areas
quarantined for citrus canker, citrus
greening, or ACP with the ability to ship
regulated nursery stock to markets
within the United States that would
otherwise be unavailable to them due to
the prohibitions and restrictions
contained in the regulations while
continuing to provide adequate
safeguards to prevent the spread of the
WReier-Aviles on DSKGBLS3C1PROD with RULES
SUMMARY:
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:29 Apr 26, 2011
Jkt 223001
three pests into currently unaffected
areas of the United States.
DATES: This interim rule is effective
April 27, 2011. We will consider all
comments that receive on or before June
27, 2011.
ADDRESSES: You may submit comments
by either of the following methods:
• Federal eRulemaking Portal: Go to
https://www.regulations.gov/fdmspublic/
component/
main?main=DocketDetail&d=APHIS2010-0048 to submit or view comments
and to view supporting and related
materials available electronically.
• Postal Mail/Commercial Delivery:
Please send one copy of your comment
to Docket No. APHIS–2010–0048,
Regulatory Analysis and Development,
PPD, APHIS, Station 3A–03.8, 4700
River Road Unit 118, Riverdale, MD
20737–1238. Please state that your
comment refers to Docket No. APHIS–
2010–0048.
Reading Room: You may read any
comments that we receive on this
docket on the Regulations.gov Web site
(see link above) or in our reading room.
The reading room is located in room
1141 of the USDA South Building, 14th
Street and Independence Avenue, SW.,
Washington, DC. Normal reading room
hours are 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., Monday
through Friday, except holidays. To be
sure someone is there to help you,
please call (202) 690–2817 before
coming.
Other Information: Additional
information about APHIS and its
programs is available on the Internet at
https://www.aphis.usda.gov.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Mr.
Osama El-Lissy, Director, Emergency
and Domestic Programs, PPQ, APHIS,
4700 River Road Unit 160, Riverdale,
MD 20737–1238; (301) 734–5459; or Ms.
Deborah L. McPartlan, Emergency and
Domestic Programs, PPQ, APHIS, 4700
River Road Unit 160, Riverdale, MD
20737–1238; (301) 734–5356.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Background
Under section 412(a) of the Plant
Protection Act (7 U.S.C. 7701 et seq.,
referred to below as the PPA), the
Secretary of Agriculture may prohibit or
restrict the movement in interstate
commerce of any plant or plant product,
if the Secretary determines that the
prohibition or restriction is necessary to
prevent the dissemination of a plant
PO 00000
Frm 00001
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
pest within the United States. Under the
PPA, the Secretary may also issue
regulations requiring plants and plant
products moved in interstate commerce
to be subject to remedial measures
determined necessary to prevent the
spread of the pest, or requiring the
plants or plant products to be
accompanied by a permit issued by the
Secretary prior to movement.
Citrus canker is a plant disease that is
caused by the bacterium Xanthomonas
citri subsp. citri that affects plants and
plant parts of citrus and citrus relatives
(Family Rutaceae). Citrus canker can
cause defoliation and other serious
damage to the leaves and twigs of
susceptible plants. It can also cause
lesions on the fruit of infected plants,
which render the fruit unmarketable,
and cause infected fruit to drop from the
trees before reaching maturity. The
aggressive A (Asiatic) strain of citrus
canker can infect susceptible plants
rapidly and lead to extensive economic
losses in commercial citrus-producing
areas. Citrus canker is known to be
present in the United States in the State
of Florida.
The regulations to prevent the
interstate spread of citrus canker are
contained in ‘‘Subpart—Citrus Canker’’
(7 CFR 301.75–1 through 301.75–14,
referred to below as the citrus canker
regulations). The citrus canker
regulations designate the State of
Florida as a quarantined area, and
restrict the interstate movement of
regulated articles from and through this
area. Regulated articles are plants and
plant parts of all species, clones,
cultivars, strains, varieties, or hybrids of
the genera Citrus and Fortunella, and all
clones, cultivars, strains, varieties and
hybrids of the species Clausena lansium
and Poncirus trifoliata. Plants and plant
parts include, among other articles,
fruit, seed, and nursery stock. The
provisions of the citrus canker
regulations that pertain to the interstate
movement of regulated nursery stock
from areas quarantined for citrus canker
are found in § 301.75–6.
Citrus greening, also known as
Huanglongbing disease of citrus, is
considered to be one of the most serious
citrus diseases in the world. Citrus
greening is a bacterial disease, caused
by strains of the bacterial pathogen
‘‘Candidatus Liberibacter asiaticus,’’ that
attacks the vascular system of host
plants. The pathogen is phloem-limited,
E:\FR\FM\27APR1.SGM
27APR1
WReier-Aviles on DSKGBLS3C1PROD with RULES
23450
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 81 / Wednesday, April 27, 2011 / Rules and Regulations
inhabiting the food-conducting tissue of
the host plant, and causes yellow
shoots, blotchy mottling and chlorosis,
reduced foliage, and tip dieback of
citrus plants. Citrus greening greatly
reduces production, destroys the
economic value of the fruit, and can kill
trees. Once infected, there is no cure for
a tree with citrus greening. In areas of
the world where the disease is endemic,
citrus trees decline and die within a few
years and may never produce usable
fruit. Citrus greening was first detected
in the United States in Miami-Dade
County, FL, in 2005, and is known to be
present in the United States in Florida
and Georgia, Puerto Rico, the U.S.
Virgin Islands, two parishes in
Louisiana, and two counties in South
Carolina.
The bacterial pathogen causing citrus
greening can be transmitted by grafting,
and under laboratory conditions, by
parasitic plants. There also is some
evidence that seed transmission may
occur. The pathogen can also be
transmitted by two insect vectors in the
family Psyllidae: Diaphorina citri
Kuwayama, the Asian citrus psyllid
(ACP), and Trioza erytreae (del
Guercio), the African citrus psyllid. ACP
can also cause economic damage to
citrus in groves and nurseries by direct
feeding. Both adults and nymphs feed
on young foliage, depleting the sap and
causing galling or curling of leaves.
High populations feeding on a citrus
shoot can kill the growing tip. ACP is
currently present in Alabama, American
Samoa,1 Florida, Georgia, Guam,
Hawaii, Louisiana, Mississippi, Puerto
Rico, Texas, the U.S. Virgin Islands, and
portions of Arizona, California, and
South Carolina. Regular surveys of
domestic commercial citrus-producing
areas indicate that the African citrus
psyllid is not present in the United
States.
The regulations to prevent the
interstate spread of citrus greening and
ACP are contained in ‘‘Subpart-Citrus
Greening and Asian Citrus Psyllid’’ (7
CFR 301.76 through 301.76–11, referred
to below as the citrus greening and ACP
regulations). The citrus greening and
ACP regulations quarantine the States of
Florida and Georgia, Puerto Rico, the
U.S. Virgin Islands, two parishes in
Louisiana, and two counties in South
Carolina due to the presence of citrus
greening, and quarantine Alabama,
Florida, Georgia, Guam, Hawaii,
Louisiana, Mississippi, Puerto Rico,
Texas, the U.S. Virgin Islands, and
1 An established population of ACP was
discovered in American Samoa in October 2010,
and the entire island has been designated a
quarantined area for ACP through administrative
action.
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:29 Apr 26, 2011
Jkt 223001
portions of Arizona, California, and
South Carolina due to the presence of
ACP. The regulations also place
restrictions on the interstate movement
of regulated articles from quarantined
areas. Regulated articles include all
plants and plant parts, except fruit, of
host species within the Family
Rutaceae.
The provisions of the citrus greening
and ACP regulations that pertain to the
interstate movement of regulated
nursery stock from areas quarantined for
citrus greening and/or ACP are found in
§§ 301.76–6 and 301.76–7. Section
301.76–6 contains specific conditions
for the issuance of certificates and
limited permits for regulated articles
moved interstate from an area
quarantined for ACP, but not for citrus
greening. Section 301.76–7 contains
specific conditions for the issuance of
certificates and limited permits for
regulated articles moved interstate from
an area quarantined for citrus greening.
Current Restrictions and Prohibitions on
the Interstate Movement of Regulated
Nursery Stock From Areas Quarantined
for Citrus Canker, Citrus Greening, and/
or ACP
As we mentioned earlier in this
document, the provisions of the citrus
canker regulations that pertain to the
interstate movement of regulated
nursery stock from areas quarantined for
citrus canker are found in § 301.75–6.
This section prohibits the interstate
movement of regulated nursery stock
from a quarantined area, and prior to the
publication of this interim rule,
provided for only two exceptions to this
general prohibition. The first exception
allowed the interstate movement of
kumquat plants, which have a natural
resistance to citrus canker, in
accordance with a protocol designed to
ensure their freedom from citrus canker
prior to movement. The other exception
allowed regulated nursery stock to be
moved interstate for immediate export.
Similarly, § 301.76–7 contains
specific conditions for the issuance of
certificates and limited permits for
regulated articles moved interstate from
areas quarantined for citrus greening,
and prohibits the interstate movement
of regulated nursery stock from such
areas. Prior to issuance of this interim
rule, there was only one exception in
§ 301.76–7 to this general prohibition on
interstate movement: Nursery stock
destined for immediate export and
shipped under a protocol designed to
ensure that it does not spread citrus
greening into currently unaffected areas
of the United States.
In contrast, our approach towards the
movement of regulated nursery stock
PO 00000
Frm 00002
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
from areas quarantined for ACP, but not
for citrus greening, has differed. This is
because, while ACP can damage citrus
nursery stock, its primary risk to
nursery stock is as a vector of the
bacterial pathogen that causes citrus
greening. The risk that the artificial
spread of ACP poses to currently
unaffected areas of the United States,
then, lies in its potential to introduce
citrus greening to those areas.
Therefore, the citrus greening and
ACP regulations currently allow the
interstate movement of regulated
nursery stock from areas quarantined for
ACP, but not for citrus greening,
provided that the nursery stock has been
subject to remedial measures to prevent
ACP from moving with the nursery
stock. Specifically, § 301.76–6 allows for
the movement of any regulated article
from an area quarantined for ACP to any
State, provided that, among other
conditions, the articles are treated with
methyl bromide and shipped in a
container that has been sealed with an
agricultural seal placed by an inspector
after treatment.
In addition, prior to publication of
this interim rule, § 301.76–6 allowed for
the movement of regulated nursery
stock to areas other than commercial
citrus-producing areas 2 under a limited
permit from an area quarantined for
ACP, but not for citrus greening,
provided that, among other conditions,
the articles were treated before
shipment with certain approved soil
drenches and foliar sprays, inspected,
and shipped in sealed containers. The
citrus greening and ACP regulations
have otherwise prohibited all other
interstate movement of regulated
nursery stock.
Requests for a Systems Approach Under
Which Citrus Nursery Stock May Be
Moved Interstate
The congressional findings set out in
section 402 of the PPA describe USDA’s
responsibility to facilitate interstate
commerce in agricultural products and
other commodities that pose a risk of
harboring plant pest in ways that will
reduce, to the extent practicable, the
risk of dissemination of plant pests. It is
APHIS’ policy to impose restrictions on
the interstate movement of host articles
that are the least restrictive measures
necessary to prevent the dissemination
of plant pests within the United States.
For several years, various individuals
and entities have requested that APHIS
implement a systems approach that
2 Commercial citrus-producing areas are
American Samoa, Arizona, California, Florida,
Guam, Hawaii, Louisiana, Northern Mariana
Islands, Puerto Rico, Texas, and U.S. Virgin Islands.
E:\FR\FM\27APR1.SGM
27APR1
WReier-Aviles on DSKGBLS3C1PROD with RULES
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 81 / Wednesday, April 27, 2011 / Rules and Regulations
could serve as the basis for allowing the
interstate movement of citrus nursery
stock to any area of the United States
from areas quarantined for citrus canker,
citrus greening, and ACP.
This request was first made by
commenters during the comment period
for an interim rule that was published
in the Federal Register on March 22,
2007 and effective on March 16, 2007
(72 FR 13423–13428, Docket No.
APHIS–2007–0032) that explicitly
prohibited the interstate movement of
citrus nursery stock, with the two
limited exceptions mentioned earlier in
this document, from the State of Florida.
The commenters stated that, in lieu of
such a general prohibition, APHIS
should recognize the Citrus Nursery
Stock Certification Program, established
by the State of Florida in December
2006 to prevent the spread of citrus
canker and citrus greening within and
from that State, as sufficient to allow the
interstate movement of nursery stock
produced in that program.
In response to those comments, we
examined the program thoroughly and
determined that certain of its provisions
did not adequately address the risk of
the spread of citrus canker or citrus
greening from Florida. We subsequently
communicated this determination to the
Florida Department of Agriculture and
Consumer Services (FDACS),
highlighting those aspects of the
approach that we considered
inadequate.
In response, FDACS requested APHIS’
assistance in crafting a systems
approach that would provide adequate
phytosanitary measures to allow the
interstate movement of citrus nursery
stock from areas quarantined for citrus
canker, citrus greening, and ACP. To
this end, APHIS convened a technical
working group, which recommended
sourcing from a pest-exclusionary
production facility and testing for all
germplasm and budwood destined for
propagation in nurseries within the
State, construction and maintenance of
pest-exclusionary production facilities
and buffer zones, safeguarding, routine
inspections, cleaning and disinfection
protocols, and other measures that
would be sufficient to address the
concerns raised in our earlier
evaluation. As a result of this
collaboration with APHIS, FDACS
presented a draft systems approach to us
for evaluation in December 2008. The
mitigation measures proposed in that
systems approach appeared consistent
with the recommendations of the
technical working group.
However, because the movement of
citrus nursery stock is considered to be
a high-risk pathway for citrus canker
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:29 Apr 26, 2011
Jkt 223001
and citrus greening, and because the
introduction of citrus canker or citrus
greening into currently unaffected
commercial citrus-producing areas
could have a lasting and deleterious
effect on the U.S. industry as a whole,
we did not initiate rulemaking at that
time to establish such a systems
approach. Rather, we decided to prepare
an analysis of the risks associated with
the interstate movement of citrus
nursery stock from areas quarantined for
citrus canker, citrus greening, and ACP.
Risk Management Analysis
APHIS has prepared a risk
management analysis (RMA). The
document, titled ‘‘Interstate Movement
of Citrus and Other Rutaceous Plants for
Planting to Non-Quarantine Areas in
Any State,’’ analyzes the movement of
citrus nursery stock from areas
quarantined for citrus canker, citrus
greening, or ACP as a pathway for the
introduction of citrus canker, citrus
greening, and ACP into other areas of
the United States. Consistent with the
findings of the technical working group,
the analysis also finds that a systems
approach is necessary in order to
mitigate the risk associated with such
movement.
Because the nature of the three pests
and the manner in which they are
introduced into nursery stock vary, the
exact nature of the necessary mitigation
measures in the systems approach will
correspondingly vary based on whether
the nursery stock is produced in an area
quarantined for citrus canker, citrus
greening, or ACP, or a combination of
these three pests. However, the analysis
finds that each such systems approach
must be predicated upon two critical
elements: Pest exclusion and system
monitoring.
The analysis describes pest exclusion
as consisting of the following core
components: Testing the citrus nursery
stock that will be moved interstate for
citrus greening, certifying the nursery
stock as free of citrus greening, growing
the nursery stock in approved structures
that are constructed to exclude
introduction of the relevant pests,
maintaining a controlled space around
the structure that is free of citrus, and
safeguarding the nursery stock within
the structure to prevent pest
introduction.
The analysis describes system
monitoring as consisting of the
following core components: Inspecting
the nursery stock within the structure
on a routine basis, conducting an
unannounced inspection at least once
yearly, testing a statistically valid
sample of the plants within the nursery
for citrus greening on a recurring
PO 00000
Frm 00003
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
23451
schedule, surveying the nursery
regularly for quarantine pests,
responding to breaches of the facility
with appropriate remediation, and
maintaining quality assurance,
including but not limited to accurate
recordkeeping and labeling, as well as
standard operating procedures for
cleaning and disinfection.
The RMA may be viewed on the
Regulations.gov Web site or in our
reading room (see ADDRESSES at the
beginning of this document.) In
addition, copies may be obtained by
calling or writing to the individual
listed under FOR FURTHER INFORMATION
CONTACT. We request comment on the
analysis, especially any scientific
studies that may be pertinent.
Protocol Document
Based on the determination of the
RMA that a systems approach is
necessary to mitigate the risk associated
with the interstate movement of citrus
nursery stock from areas quarantined for
citrus canker, citrus greening, and/or
ACP, APHIS prepared a draft protocol
document that used core components
suggested in the RMA as the basis for
standards and requirements that a
nursery would have to meet in order to
move citrus nursery stock interstate
from such areas. APHIS then shared the
draft protocol with nursery stock
producers and State agricultural
officials. In response to the input we
received, we revised some of the
conditions in the protocol document to
provide alternative standards or
requirements that were equivalent to the
core components identified in the RMA.
By meeting the standards and
requirements, a nursery would be able
to obtain a certificate or limited permit 3
for the interstate movement of citrus
nursery stock from areas quarantined for
citrus canker, citrus greening, or ACP.
The protocol document is divided
into five sections. Section I provides
general requirements. Under this
section, each nursery that wishes to
obtain a certificate to move regulated
nursery stock interstate must enter into
a compliance agreement with APHIS in
which it agrees to observe the protocol’s
minimum construction standards for a
pest-exclusionary production facility;
sourcing and certification requirements
for all propagative material grown in the
facility; cleaning, disinfecting, and
safeguarding requirements for the
3 APHIS authorizes certificates to be issued when
an article can safely be moved interstate from a
quarantine area without any risk of spreading a
quarantine pest, and limited permits when, in order
to address a risk of plant pest dissemination, limits
must be placed on the distribution or utilization of
the article.
E:\FR\FM\27APR1.SGM
27APR1
WReier-Aviles on DSKGBLS3C1PROD with RULES
23452
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 81 / Wednesday, April 27, 2011 / Rules and Regulations
facility; labeling requirements for the
nursery stock maintained in the facility;
and recordkeeping and inspection
requirements.
The protocol also contains additional
conditions for interstate movement of
regulated nursery stock that the nursery
would have to agree to observe; each set
of additional conditions addresses
disease risks associated with the area in
which the nursery is located: Section II
of the protocol document sets forth
additional requirements for interstate
movement of regulated nursery stock
from areas quarantined for citrus canker;
section III, for areas quarantined for
ACP; and section IV, for areas
quarantined for citrus greening.
Section V of the protocol provides
conditions for the issuance of limited
permits for the interstate movement of
regulated nursery stock from areas that
are quarantined for ACP, but not citrus
greening. These conditions match the
requirements of § 301.76–6 in this
interim rule. Our changes to § 301.76–6
are discussed later in this rule.
The protocol document may be
viewed on the Regulations.gov Web site
or in our reading room (see ADDRESSES
at the beginning of this document). In
addition, copies may be obtained by
calling or writing to the individual
listed under FOR FURTHER INFORMATION
CONTACT. It is also available on the Plant
Protection and Quarantine (PPQ) Web
site at https://www.aphis.usda.gov/
plant_health/plant_pest_info/citrus/
index.shtml.
We believe that the procedures set
forth in the protocol document will
provide the necessary safeguards to
allow the interstate movement of citrus
nursery stock from areas quarantined for
citrus canker, citrus greening, or ACP to
any area of the United States. It may,
however, be necessary for us to propose
to update the protocol document as
circumstances warrant. We envision
that these proposed updates will usually
be nonsubstantive, and will be intended
to further delineate the protocol’s
provisions or provide additional options
to the mitigation strategies currently
contained in the document. APHIS
believes that the ability to revise the
protocol document is necessary because
new scientific information on the risks
associated with ACP, citrus greening,
and citrus canker continues to be
published at a rapid pace. As new
information comes to light, APHIS must
be able to adjust its quarantine protocols
in a flexible manner. If we are proposing
substantive modifications, however, we
will publish a notice in the Federal
Register containing the nature of and
rationale for these proposed revisions,
and requesting public comment. In such
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:29 Apr 26, 2011
Jkt 223001
instances, if, after the close of the
comment period, we continue to
consider it necessary to update the
protocol document, we will do so
accordingly. We request comment on
this approach and whether it provides
sufficient avenue for input from the
public.
Whenever we update the protocol
document, we will notify each State
agricultural official and holder of a
compliance agreement of the changes,
and compliance agreements will be
updated to reflect the updated protocol.
It will be necessary for those operating
under a compliance agreement to sign
the updated agreement in order to
continue to be eligible to continue
shipping citrus nursery stock interstate.
Other interested parties can receive
notification of these updates by
subscribing to the PPQ stakeholder
registry at https://
web01.aphis.usda.gov/
PPQStakeWeb2.nsf.
Regulatory Changes
We are amending the citrus canker
and citrus greening and ACP regulations
to reflect the findings of the RMA and
the provisions of the protocol document
and allow the interstate movement of
regulated nursery stock to any area of
the United States, under certain
conditions. To accommodate these
amendments, we are also amending
several other provisions of the citrus
canker and citrus greening and ACP
regulations that would otherwise have
been in conflict with the amendments.
Citrus Canker Regulations
As we mentioned earlier in this
document, the provisions of the citrus
canker regulations that pertain to the
interstate movement of regulated
nursery stock from areas quarantined for
citrus canker are found in § 301.75–6.
Prior to the publication of this interim
rule, paragraph (a) of § 301.75–6
explicitly prohibited the interstate
movement of regulated nursery stock
from a quarantined area, unless the
nursery stock was moved in accordance
with paragraph (b) or (c) of the section.
Paragraph (b) allowed the interstate
movement of kumquats in accordance
with a protocol designed to ensure their
freedom from citrus canker prior to
movement. Paragraph (c) stated that
nursery stock produced in a nursery
located in a quarantined area that is not
eligible for movement under paragraph
(b) of could be moved interstate only for
immediate export.
We are redesignating paragraph (c) as
paragraph (d), and adding a new
paragraph (c) in its place. This new
paragraph (c) of § 301.75–6 provides
PO 00000
Frm 00004
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
that regulated nursery stock produced in
a nursery within a quarantined area may
be moved interstate to any area within
the United States, if all of the following
conditions are met:
• The nursery in which the nursery
stock is produced has entered into a
compliance agreement with APHIS in
which it agrees to meet the relevant
construction standards, sourcing and
certification requirements, cleaning,
disinfecting, and safeguarding
requirements, labeling requirements,
and recordkeeping and inspection
requirements specified in the protocol
document described above. In addition
to being available on the APHIS Web
site, the protocol document will be
provided to the person at the time he or
she enters into the compliance
agreement. The compliance agreement
may also specify additional conditions
determined by APHIS to be necessary to
prevent the dissemination of citrus
canker under which the nursery stock
must be grown, maintained, and
shipped in order to obtain a certificate
for its movement. The compliance
agreement will specify that APHIS may
amend the agreement.
• An inspector has determined that
the nursery has adhered to all terms and
conditions of the compliance agreement.
• The nursery stock is accompanied
by a certificate issued in accordance
with § 301.75–12.
• The nursery stock is completely
enclosed in a sealed container that is
clearly labeled with the certificate and
is moved interstate in that container. We
are requiring such containers in order to
safeguard the nursery stock against
wind and rain events that may lead to
the introduction of citrus canker.
• A copy of the certificate is attached
to the consignee’s copy of the
accompanying waybill.
Because of this new paragraph (c),
there are now two paragraphs in
§ 301.75–6 which allow nursery stock to
be moved interstate for purposes other
than immediate export. As a result, we
are amending newly designated
paragraph (d) to provide that nursery
stock that is not eligible for movement
under either of the paragraphs may be
moved interstate only for immediate
export. For a similar reason, we are also
amending paragraph (a) of § 301.75–6 to
authorize interstate movement of
nursery stock under the conditions in
any of the subsequent paragraphs in the
section.
The certificate accompanying the
container and accompanying waybill of
the nursery stock being moved must be
attached in a manner that varies from
the general requirements for attachment
and disposition of certificates contained
E:\FR\FM\27APR1.SGM
27APR1
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 81 / Wednesday, April 27, 2011 / Rules and Regulations
WReier-Aviles on DSKGBLS3C1PROD with RULES
in the citrus canker regulations.
Accordingly, we are amending
paragraph (b) of § 301.75–12, which
contains general requirements for
attachment and disposition of
certificates, to exempt nursery stock
moved under the conditions of
paragraph (c) of § 301.75–6 from those
general requirements.
Prior to the publication of this interim
rule, the citrus canker regulations stated
that we would cancel a compliance
agreement if an inspector found that the
person who entered into the compliance
agreement had failed to comply with the
regulations. However, under paragraph
(c) of § 301.75–6, the conditions under
which a nursery must grow, maintain,
and ship nursery stock in order to
obtain a certificate for its movement to
any area of the United States are found
not in the citrus canker regulations
themselves, but in the compliance
agreement that the nursery has entered
into with APHIS. Accordingly, failure
by the nursery to comply with any term
or condition of the compliance
agreement could present a risk that
regulated nursery stock at the facility
becomes infected with citrus canker and
that the movement of the regulated
nursery stock presents a pathway for the
artificial spread of the disease to
unaffected areas of the United States.
Therefore, we are amending paragraph
(b) of § 301.75–13, which contains our
provisions for cancellation of a
compliance agreement, to state that
failure to comply with any term or
condition of the compliance agreement
itself will also result in cancellation of
the compliance agreement.
Finally, in § 301.75–1, the definition
of compliance agreement has described
them as being between APHIS and
persons engaged in the business of
growing or handling regulated articles.
However, because of the manner in
which compliance agreements are used
within paragraph (c) of § 301.75–6, we
consider it necessary to expand the
scope of the definition so that it also
refers to persons engaged in
maintaining, processing, packing, and
moving regulated articles. We are
amending the definition of compliance
agreement accordingly.
Citrus Greening Regulations
As we mentioned earlier in this
document, § 301.76–7 contains specific
conditions for the issuance of
certificates and limited permits for
regulated articles moved interstate from
an area quarantined for citrus greening.
Prior to the publication of this interim
rule, the only conditions for the
movement of regulated articles from an
area quarantined for citrus greening
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:29 Apr 26, 2011
Jkt 223001
were found in paragraph (a) of § 301.76–
7. This paragraph allowed for the
issuance of limited permits to move
regulated nursery stock interstate, if the
nursery stock was destined for
immediate export and shipped under a
protocol designed to ensure that it did
not present a pathway for the
introduction of citrus greening to
currently unaffected areas of the United
States. To clarify that this was the only
condition under which regulated
articles could be moved interstate from
an area quarantined for citrus greening,
paragraph (b) of § 301.76–7 stated that,
except for nursery stock for which a
limited permit has been issued in
accordance with § 301.76–7(a), no other
regulated article may be moved
interstate from an area quarantined for
citrus greening.
We are adding a new paragraph (a) to
§ 301.76–7 and redesignating paragraphs
(a) and (b) as paragraphs (b) and (c),
respectively. The new paragraph (a)
provides that, in addition to the general
conditions for issuance of a certificate,
an inspector or person operating under
a compliance agreement may issue a
certificate for interstate movement of
regulated nursery stock to any State if
all of the following conditions are met:
• The nursery in which the nursery
stock is produced has entered into a
compliance agreement with APHIS in
which it agrees to meet the relevant
construction standards, sourcing and
certification requirements, cleaning,
disinfecting, and safeguarding
requirements, labeling requirements,
and recordkeeping and inspection
requirements specified in the PPQ
protocol document. In addition to being
available on the APHIS Web site, the
protocol document will be provided to
the person at the time he or she enters
into the compliance agreement. The
compliance agreement may also specify
additional conditions determined by
APHIS to be necessary in order to
prevent the dissemination of citrus
greening under which the nursery stock
must be grown, maintained, and
shipped in order to obtain a certificate
for its movement. The compliance
agreement will also specify that APHIS
may amend the agreement.
• An inspector has determined that
the nursery has adhered to all terms and
conditions of the compliance agreement.
• The nursery stock is completely
enclosed in a sealed container that is
clearly labeled with the certificate and
is moved interstate in that container.
• A copy of the certificate is attached
to the consignee’s copy of the
accompanying waybill.
Because both paragraphs (a) and (b) of
§ 301.76–7 now contain conditions for
PO 00000
Frm 00005
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
23453
the interstate movement of regulated
nursery stock from an area quarantined
for citrus greening, we are amending
newly redesignated paragraph (c) of
§ 301.76–7 to specify that apart from
nursery stock moved in accordance with
either of those paragraphs, no other
regulated article may be moved
interstate from an area quarantined for
citrus greening.
These revisions to § 301.76–7 also
require us to make certain
nonsubstantive changes to other
sections of the citrus greening
regulations.
We currently require all regulated
nursery stock offered for commercial
sale within an area quarantined for
citrus greening to have an APHISapproved label on which a statement
alerting consumers to Federal
prohibitions regarding the interstate
movement of the article is prominently
and legibly displayed, unless the
regulations grant an exemption from the
requirement. We are amending
§ 301.76–4, which contains the labeling
requirement and the exemptions from it,
to grant such an exemption to plants
moved under paragraph (a) of § 301.76–
7, since the interstate movement of such
plants is not prohibited.
We are also amending the conditions
in the citrus greening regulations that
will lead us to cancel a compliance
agreement. We modeled these
conditions on those in the citrus canker
regulations, and are amending them for
the same reason we are amending those
in the citrus canker regulations.
ACP Regulations
As we mentioned earlier in this
document, § 301.76–6 of the ACP and
citrus greening regulations contains
specific conditions for the interstate
movement of regulated articles from
areas quarantined for ACP, but not for
citrus greening. Prior to the publication
of this interim rule, the only conditions
under which a certificate would be
issued for the interstate movement of
regulated nursery stock were found in
paragraph (a) of § 301.76–6. The
paragraph allows a certificate to be
issued for the interstate movement of
any regulated article, including citrus
nursery stock, provided that:
• The article is treated with methyl
bromide in accordance with 7 CFR part
305. That part contains our
phytosanitary treatment regulations, and
sets out standards for treatments
required in 7 CFR part 301.
• The article is shipped in a container
that has been sealed with an agricultural
seal placed by an inspector.
E:\FR\FM\27APR1.SGM
27APR1
WReier-Aviles on DSKGBLS3C1PROD with RULES
23454
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 81 / Wednesday, April 27, 2011 / Rules and Regulations
• The container that will be moved
interstate is clearly labeled with the
certificate.
• A copy of the certificate will be
attached to the consignee’s copy of the
accompanying waybill.
Because methyl bromide is
phytotoxic, that is, deadly or damaging
to propagative plants and plant parts,
producers have informed us that few
plants have been moved under these
conditions.
In addition to the conditions in
paragraph (a), prior to the issuance of
this interim rule, the only other
conditions for interstate movement of
regulated nursery stock from an area
quarantined for ACP were found in
paragraph (b) of § 301.76–6; this
paragraph provided conditions for the
issuance of limited permits for such
movement to areas other than
commercial citrus-producing areas.
We are redesignating this paragraph
as paragraph (c). We are also
substantively revising the conditions for
issuance of such a limited permit. We
discuss the revised conditions, and the
considerations that led us to revise
them, at length below.
To accommodate this redesignation,
we are also redesignating the previous
paragraph (c), which contains
conditions for the issuance of limited
permits for regulated articles intended
for consumption, for use as apparel or
as a similar personal accessory, or for
decorative use, as new paragraph (d).
We are adding a new paragraph (b) to
§ 301.76–6. This is because, based on
the findings of the RMA, we have
determined that we can provide another
set of conditions for issuance of a
certificate for the interstate movement of
regulated nursery stock from areas
quarantined only for ACP. These
conditions are:
• The nursery in which the nursery
stock is produced has entered into a
compliance agreement with APHIS in
which it agrees to meet the relevant
construction standards, sourcing and
certification requirements, cleaning,
disinfecting, and safeguarding
requirements, labeling requirements,
and recordkeeping and inspection
requirements specified in the PPQ
protocol document. In addition to being
available on the APHIS Web site, the
protocol document will be provided to
the person at the time he or she enters
into the compliance agreement. The
compliance agreement may also specify
additional conditions determined by
APHIS to be necessary in order to
prevent the spread of ACP under which
the nursery stock must be grown,
maintained, and shipped in order to
obtain a certificate for its movement. For
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:29 Apr 26, 2011
Jkt 223001
example, we may require additional
safeguarding measures beyond those
specified in the protocol document for
facilities located in areas with high
population densities of ACP. The
compliance agreement will also specify
that APHIS may amend the agreement.
• An inspector determines that the
nursery has adhered to all terms and
conditions of the compliance agreement.
• The nursery stock is completely
enclosed in a sealed container that is
clearly labeled with the certificate, and
is moved interstate in that container. We
are requiring a sealed container in order
to safeguard the nursery stock against
possible reintroduction of ACP.
• A copy of the certificate is attached
to the consignee’s copy of the
accompanying waybill.
As we mentioned above, newly
redesignated paragraph (c) of § 301.76–
6 contains conditions for issuance of a
limited permit for interstate movement
of regulated nursery stock.
Prior to the publication of this interim
rule, this paragraph provided for the
issuance of limited permits for the
interstate movement of regulated
nursery stock to areas of the United
States other than American Samoa,
Northern Mariana Islands, and those
portions of Arizona, California, and
South Carolina not quarantined due to
the presence of ACP or citrus greening,
if:
• The nursery stock is treated for ACP
with an APHIS-approved soil drench or
in-ground granular application no more
than 30 days and no fewer than 20 days
before shipment, followed by an APHISapproved foliar spray no more than 10
days before shipment. All treatments
must be applied according to their
Environmental Protection Agency label,
including directions on application,
restrictions on place of application and
other restrictions, and precautions, and
including statements pertaining to
Worker Protection Standards.
• The nursery stock is inspected by
an inspector in accordance with
§ 301.76–9 and found free of ACP.
• The nursery stock is affixed prior to
movement with a plastic or metal tag on
which the statement ‘‘Limited permit:
USDA–APHIS–PPQ. Not for distribution
in American Samoa, Northern Mariana
Islands, or those portions of AZ, CA,
and SC not quarantined due to the
presence of Asian citrus psyllid or citrus
greening’’ is prominently and legibly
displayed. If the nursery stock is
destined for movement or sale in boxes
or containers, the statement may be
printed on the box or container, or
printed on a label permanently affixed
to the box or container, provided that,
PO 00000
Frm 00006
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
in either case, the statement is
prominently and legibly displayed.
• The nursery stock is moved in a
container sealed with an agricultural
seal placed by an inspector.
• This container also prominently
and legibly displays the statement of the
limited permit.
• A copy of the limited permit is
attached to the consignee’s copy of the
accompanying waybill.
• The nursery stock is moved in
accordance with the conditions
specified on the limited permit to the
location specified on the permit.
The conditions in the regulations
before this interim rule were established
in a prior interim rule published in the
Federal Register and effective on June
17, 2010 (75 FR 34322–34336, Docket
No. APHIS–2008–0015).4 Several
commenters on the June 2010 rule
stated that certain of the conditions
unnecessarily hindered interstate
commerce. Two commenters stated that
the 10-day timeframe for the application
of soil drenches or granular applications
was impracticable for smaller
producers, who often did not know the
expected date of interstate movement of
an article that far in advance. While
recognizing the need for optimal
absorption of the soil drench, the
commenters requested a longer window
of time for the application of that
treatment.
Similarly, two commenters stated
that, by requiring the articles to be
sealed in a shipping container and
inspectors to seal each container with
an agricultural seal prior to movement,
we were, in effect, limiting shipment of
the articles to normal business hours
(8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., Monday through
Friday). The commenters stated that
their shipments traditionally have
tended to occur overnight or in the early
morning. Because of these economic
considerations, the commenters
questioned whether the conditions were
strictly necessary, especially for nursery
stock that is not destined for an area in
which ACP could become established.
In addition, around the same time that
these comments were received, State
agricultural officials from several
commercial citrus-producing States
contacted APHIS on behalf of their
producers to suggest a different scope
and timing for inspections. The officials
stated that inspections of the whole
nursery at set intervals would prove
more practicable than inspections of
plants in the days preceding shipment.
In order to respond to these comments
and requests, we first reviewed the
4 Section 301.76–4 of that rule was effective on
September 15, 2010, rather than June 17, 2010.
E:\FR\FM\27APR1.SGM
27APR1
WReier-Aviles on DSKGBLS3C1PROD with RULES
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 81 / Wednesday, April 27, 2011 / Rules and Regulations
relevant scientific literature. In
particular, we evaluated a 2008
presentation at the International
Research Conference on Huanglongbing
by P.T. Yamamoto et al., which
examined the efficacy of various
insecticides to control ACP.5 Yamamoto
and his colleagues found that the
residual effect of imidacloprid and other
soil drenches on nursery stock is
considerably longer than previously
thought—in certain instances, as long as
105 days. Yamamoto’s research suggests
that soil drenches can be applied up to
90 days and no less than 30 days prior
to shipment, provided that they are
coupled with subsequent foliar sprays
no more than 10 days before shipment.
Based on Yamamoto’s findings, we
evaluated the risk of dissemination of
ACP that would be associated with a
regulatory scheme for the movement of
citrus nursery stock from ACP
quarantined areas to areas other than
commercial citrus-producing areas
under which inspections of the entire
nursery for ACP occurred at set
intervals, soil drenches could be applied
up to 90 days before shipment, and
plants were not required to be shipped
in sealed containers.
We determined that, under the
provisions of this regulatory scheme, the
risk that ACP would be introduced to
the plants prior to shipment would be
commensurately greater. Such
introduction, however, would not
necessarily lead to further
dissemination of ACP within the United
States. Rather, the risk of such
dissemination would be directly
correlated to whether the nursery stock
transited through commercial citrusproducing areas, that is, areas where
host articles are prevalent, and climatic
conditions are conducive to ACP
becoming established in significant
population densities. If the nursery
stock were to transit such areas, as
additional mitigation measures, it
would need to be inspected and found
free of ACP no more than 72 hours
before shipment and would need to be
shipped in a container sealed with an
agricultural seal affixed by an inspector;
moreover, the seal would have to
remain affixed throughout transit and be
removed by an inspector at its
destination.
Accordingly, paragraph (c) of
§ 301.76–6 establishes two separate sets
5 Yamamoto, P.T., et al. 2008. Efficiency of
Insecticides to Control Diaphorina citri, Vector of
Huanglongbing. T. Gottwald, W. Dixon, J. Graham,
P. Berger, eds. International research conference on
Huanglongbing. Plant Management Network
International, Orlando, Florida. Copies available
from the individuals listed under FOR FURTHER
INFORMATION CONTACT.
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:29 Apr 26, 2011
Jkt 223001
of conditions for issuance of a limited
permit for interstate movement of
regulated nursery stock from areas
quarantined for ACP, but not for citrus
greening.
In addition to all general conditions
for issuance of a limited permit,
paragraphs (c)(1) through (c)(1)(vi)
provide that, if the nursery stock will
not be moved through a commercial
citrus-producing area (American Samoa,
Arizona, California, Florida, Guam,
Hawaii, the Northern Mariana Islands,
Puerto Rico, Texas, or the U.S. Virgin
Islands), an inspector or person
operating under a compliance
agreement may issue a permit for the
interstate movement of regulated
nursery stock to areas of the United
States other than Northern Mariana
Islands or those portions of Arizona and
California that are not quarantined due
to the presence of ACP or citrus
greening, if:
• The nursery in which the nursery
stock is produced has entered into a
compliance agreement with APHIS in
accordance with § 301.76–8.
• All citrus nursery stock at the
nursery has been inspected by an
inspector every 30 days, and any
findings of ACP during an inspection
have been reported to APHIS
immediately.
• The nursery stock is treated for ACP
with an APHIS-approved soil drench or
in-ground granular application no more
than 90 days and no fewer than 30 days
before shipment, followed by an APHISapproved foliar spray no more than 10
days before shipment. All treatments
must be applied according to their EPA
label, including directions on
application, restrictions on place of
application and other restrictions, and
precautions, and including statements
pertaining to Worker Protection
Standards.
• The nursery stock is affixed prior to
movement with a plastic or metal tag on
which the statement ‘‘Limited permit:
USDA–APHIS–PPQ. Not for distribution
in Northern Mariana Islands or those
portions of AZ and CA not quarantined
due to the presence of Asian citrus
psyllid or citrus greening’’ is
prominently and legibly displayed on
the obverse, and adequate information
as determined by APHIS regarding the
identity of the nursery stock and its
source of production to conduct
traceback to the nursery in which the
nursery stock was produced is
prominently and legibly printed on the
reverse. If the nursery stock is destined
for movement or sale in boxes or
containers, the statement and the
identifying information may be printed
on the box or container, or printed on
PO 00000
Frm 00007
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
23455
a label permanently affixed to the box
or container, provided that, in either
case, the statement and the identifying
information are prominently and legibly
displayed.
• A copy of the limited permit will be
attached to the consignee’s copy of the
accompanying waybill.
• The nursery stock is shipped in
accordance with the conditions
specified on the limited permit to the
destination specified on the permit.
We are requiring that the nursery
enter into a compliance agreement with
APHIS in order to ensure, among other
things, that the nursery maintains
records of inspections and treatments
for APHIS review.
We are requiring the tag on which the
limited permit statement is printed to
have adequate information as
determined by APHIS regarding the
identity of the nursery stock and its
source of production to conduct
traceback to the nursery in which the
nursery stock was produced because, as
we noted above, there is some risk
under these regulatory provisions that
ACP will be introduced to the nursery
stock at the nursery. In the event that
the soil drenches and foliar sprays do
not achieve 100 percent mortality of this
ACP prior to movement, there is a
corresponding degree of risk that live
ACP may be on the plants when they
reach their point of destination. In such
instances, APHIS will use the
information on the tags in order to
review the recordkeeping of the nursery
in which the nursery stock was
produced. While this review is ongoing,
we will also prohibit the nursery from
shipping articles interstate.
Finally, we are removing the
requirement that the nursery stock be
shipped in a sealed container because
this regulatory scheme focuses not on
the possibility that a few ACP may be
reintroduced into the nursery stock
prior to interstate movement of the
plants, but rather on the likelihood that
such reintroduction will result in the
artificial spread of ACP.
Paragraphs (c)(2) through (c)(2)(vi)
establish conditions for the issuance of
limited permits for regulated nursery
stock that will be moved through a
commercial citrus-producing area to
another area. In addition to the general
conditions for issuance of a limited
permit, an inspector or person operating
under a compliance agreement may
issue a limited permit for such
movement, if:
• All conditions for movement of
regulated nursery stock in paragraphs
(c)(1)(i) through (c)(1)(vi) of § 301.76–6,
that is, all conditions of the new
E:\FR\FM\27APR1.SGM
27APR1
23456
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 81 / Wednesday, April 27, 2011 / Rules and Regulations
WReier-Aviles on DSKGBLS3C1PROD with RULES
regulatory scheme discussed
immediately above, are fulfilled.
• The nursery stock is inspected by
an inspector on the date of shipment
and found free of ACP.
• The nursery stock is completely
enclosed in a sealed container and is
moved interstate in that container.
• The container prominently and
legibly displays the required limited
permit statement and identifying
information.
• The agricultural seal remains intact
throughout movement to the destination
specified on the limited permit.
• The agricultural seal is removed at
the destination specified on the limited
permit by an inspector.
These revisions to § 301.76–6 entail a
nonsubstantive modification to
§ 301.76–9. Prior to the publication of
this interim rule, § 301.76–9 had
provided, among other things, that all
regulated nursery stock intended for
interstate movement for immediate
export from an area quarantined for
citrus greening, as well as all regulated
nursery stock treated with soil drenches
and foliar sprays prior to interstate
movement from an area quarantined for
ACP, but not for citrus greening, had to
be inspected by an inspector no more
than 72 hours prior to movement.
However, as we mentioned above,
inspections of regulated nursery stock to
be moved interstate under a limited
permit must now take place at set
intervals and must be coupled with an
inspection on the date of shipment if the
nursery stock will transit such a
commercial citrus-producing area.
Accordingly, we are amending § 301.76–
9 so that it now refers only to citrus
nursery stock that is intended for
interstate movement for immediate
export.
These changes to the citrus canker,
citrus greening, and ACP regulations
will provide nursery stock producers in
areas quarantined for citrus canker,
citrus greening, or ACP with the ability
to ship regulated nursery stock to
markets within the United States that
would otherwise be unavailable to them
due to the prohibitions and restrictions
contained in the regulations while
continuing to provide adequate
safeguards to prevent the spread of the
three pests into currently unaffected
areas of the United States.
Immediate Action
Immediate action is warranted to
provide a degree of relief to existing
prohibitions and restrictions on the
interstate movement of regulated
nursery stock to certain nurseries who
enter into compliance agreements with
APHIS. Specifically, such action will
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:29 Apr 26, 2011
Jkt 223001
provide producers with a means to ship
regulated nursery stock to previously
unavailable markets within the United
States. Under these circumstances, the
Administrator has determined that prior
notice and opportunity for public
comment are contrary to the public
interest and that there is good cause
under 5 U.S.C. 553 for making this rule
effective less than 30 days after
publication in the Federal Register.
We will consider comments we
receive during the comment period for
this interim rule (see DATES above).
After the comment period closes, we
will publish another document in the
Federal Register in which we will
respond to the comments we receive
and finalize or, as necessary, revise the
provisions of this interim rule. APHIS
intends to publish this follow-up
document within 18 months of the
publication of this interim rule.
Executive Order 12866, Executive
Order 13563, and the Regulatory
Flexibility Act
This interim rule has been determined
to be significant for the purposes of
Executive Order 12866 and, therefore,
has been reviewed by the Office of
Management and Budget.
In accordance with 5 U.S.C. 603, we
have performed an initial regulatory
flexibility analysis regarding the
economic effects of this rule on small
entities. The analysis identifies
nurseries that produce and handle
regulated nursery stock as entities
potentially affected by this interim rule.
The analysis identifies the primary costs
of the rule as those a nursery would
need to assume in order to meet all
terms and provisions of a compliance
agreement that it has entered into with
APHIS and that specifies the conditions
under which the regulated nursery stock
at the nursery must be grown,
maintained, and shipped in order for it
to be moved interstate. While these
costs will vary from nursery to nursery,
APHIS has estimated the aggregate cost
to the industry of certain provisions that
will be found in every compliance
agreement. We estimate that the total
cost to the industry of constructing
enclosed facilities that meet our
minimum requirements will be between
$1.3 million and $3.2 million, and that
the total cost of meeting labeling
requirements for each plant propagated
in such facilities will be between
$119,070 and $340,000. We have
determined that the rule will benefit the
citrus industry in the United States by
providing nurseries in quarantined areas
with an opportunity for access to
domestic markets that would otherwise
be unavailable to them and by ensuring
PO 00000
Frm 00008
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
ongoing production of disease-free
plants, which is vital to the preservation
of both the U.S. citrus nursery stock and
U.S. citrus fruit industries.
The full analysis may be viewed on
the Regulations.gov Web site (see
ADDRESSES above for instructions for
accessing Regulations.gov) or obtained
from the person listed under FOR
FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT.
Executive Order 12372
This program/activity is listed in the
Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance
under No. 10.025 and is subject to
Executive Order 12372, which requires
intergovernmental consultation with
State and local officials. (See 7 CFR part
3015, subpart V.)
Executive Order 12988
This rule has been reviewed under
Executive Order 12988, Civil Justice
Reform. This rule: (1) Preempts all State
and local laws and regulations that are
inconsistent with this rule; (2) has no
retroactive effect; and (3) does not
require administrative proceedings
before parties may file suit in court
challenging this rule.
Paperwork Reduction Act
In accordance with section 3507(j) of
the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995
(44 U.S.C. 3501 et seq.), the information
collection and recordkeeping
requirements included in this interim
rule have been submitted for emergency
approval to the Office of Management
and Budget (OMB). OMB has assigned
control number 0579–0369 to the
information collection and
recordkeeping requirements.
We plan to request continuation of
that approval for 3 years. Please send
written comments on the 3-year
approval request to the following
addresses: (1) Office of Information and
Regulatory Affairs, OMB, Attention:
Desk Officer for APHIS, Washington, DC
20503; and (2) Docket No. APHIS–2010–
0048, Regulatory Analysis and
Development, PPD, APHIS, Station 3A–
03.8, 4700 River Road Unit 118,
Riverdale, MD 20737–1238. Please state
that your comments refer to Docket No.
APHIS–2010–0048 and send your
comments within 60 days of publication
of this rule.
This interim rule will require persons
to complete various forms and
documents. These include: Certificates,
limited permits, compliance
agreements, records of sales and
shipments, and labels.
We are soliciting comments from the
public (as well as affected agencies)
concerning our information collection
E:\FR\FM\27APR1.SGM
27APR1
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 81 / Wednesday, April 27, 2011 / Rules and Regulations
WReier-Aviles on DSKGBLS3C1PROD with RULES
and recordkeeping requirements. These
comments will help us:
(1) Evaluate whether the information
collection is necessary for the proper
performance of our agency’s functions,
including whether the information will
have practical utility;
(2) Evaluate the accuracy of our
estimate of the burden of the
information collection, including the
validity of the methodology and
assumptions used;
(3) Enhance the quality, utility, and
clarity of the information to be
collected; and
(4) Minimize the burden of the
information collection on those who are
to respond (such as through the use of
appropriate automated, electronic,
mechanical, or other technological
collection techniques or other forms of
information technology; e.g., permitting
electronic submission of responses).
Estimate of burden: Public reporting
burden for this collection of information
is estimated to average 0.1441359 hours
per response.
Respondents: Nursery owners and
operators.
Estimated annual number of
respondents: 621.
Estimated annual number of
responses per respondent: 21.2270.
Estimated annual number of
responses: 13,182.
Estimated total annual burden on
respondents: 1,900 hours. (Due to
averaging, the total annual burden hours
may not equal the product of the annual
number of responses multiplied by the
reporting burden per response.)
Copies of this information collection
can be obtained from Mrs. Celeste
Sickles, APHIS’ Information Collection
Coordinator, at (301) 851–2908.
E-Government Act Compliance
The Animal and Plant Health
Inspection Service is committed to
compliance with the E-Government Act
to promote the use of the Internet and
other information technologies, to
provide increased opportunities for
citizen access to Government
information and services, and for other
purposes. For information pertinent to
E-Government Act compliance related
to this interim rule, please contact Mrs.
Celeste Sickles, APHIS’ Information
Collection Coordinator, at (301) 851–
2908.
List of Subjects in 7 CFR Part 301
Agricultural commodities, Plant
diseases and pests, Quarantine,
Reporting and recordkeeping
requirements, Transportation.
Accordingly, we are amending 7 CFR
part 301 as follows:
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:29 Apr 26, 2011
Jkt 223001
PART 301—DOMESTIC QUARANTINE
NOTICES
1. The authority citation for part 301
continues to read as follows:
■
Authority: 7 U.S.C. 7701–7772 and 7781–
7786; 7 CFR 2.22, 2.80, and 371.3.
Section 301.75–15 issued under Sec. 204,
Title II, Public Law 106–113, 113 Stat.
1501A–293; sections 301.75–15 and 301.75–
16 issued under Sec. 203, Title II, Public Law
106–224, 114 Stat. 400 (7 U.S.C. 1421 note).
§ 301.75–1
[Amended]
2. In § 301.75–1, the definition of
compliance agreement is amended by
removing the words ‘‘growing or
handling’’ and adding the words
‘‘growing, maintaining, processing,
handling, packing, or moving’’ in their
place.
■ 3. Section 301.75–6 is amended as
follows:
■ a. By revising paragraph (a) to read as
set forth below.
■ b. By redesignating paragraph (c) as
paragraph (d).
■ c. By adding a new paragraph (c) and
a new footnote 1 to read as set forth
below.
■ d. In newly redesignated paragraph
(d), by adding the words ‘‘or paragraph
(c)’’ after the words ‘‘paragraph (b)’’.
■ e. By adding the OMB citation
‘‘(Approved by the Office of
Management and Budget under control
number 0579–0369)’’ at the end of the
section.
■
§ 301.75–6 Interstate movement of
regulated nursery stock from a quarantined
area.
(a) Regulated nursery stock may not
be moved interstate from a quarantined
area unless such movement is
authorized in this section.
*
*
*
*
*
(c) Regulated nursery stock produced
in a nursery within a quarantined area
may be moved interstate to any area
within the United States, if all of the
following conditions are met:
(1) The nursery in which the nursery
stock is produced has entered into a
compliance agreement in which it
agrees to meet the relevant construction
standards, sourcing and certification
requirements, cleaning, disinfecting,
and safeguarding requirements, labeling
requirements, and recordkeeping and
inspection requirements specified in a
PPQ protocol document. The protocol
document will be provided to the
person at the time he or she enters into
the compliance agreement.1 The
1 The protocol document is also available on the
Internet at https://www.aphis.usda.gov/
plant_health/plant_pest_info/citrus/index.shtml
and may be obtained from local Plant Protection
PO 00000
Frm 00009
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
23457
compliance agreement may also specify
additional conditions determined by
APHIS to be necessary in order to
prevent the dissemination of citrus
canker under which the nursery stock
must be grown, maintained, and
shipped in order to obtain a certificate
for its movement. The compliance
agreement will also specify that APHIS
may amend the agreement.
(2) An inspector has determined that
the nursery has adhered to all terms and
conditions of the compliance agreement.
(3) The nursery stock is accompanied
by a certificate issued in accordance
with § 301.75–12.
(4) The nursery stock is completely
enclosed in a sealed container that is
clearly labeled with the certificate and
is moved interstate in that container.
(5) A copy of the certificate is
attached to the consignee’s copy of the
accompanying waybill.
*
*
*
*
*
§ 301.75–12
[Amended]
4. In § 301.75–12, paragraph (b)(1)
introductory text is amended by adding
the words ‘‘or in § 301.75–6(c)(4)
through (c)(5) for any regulated nursery
stock,’’ after the words ‘‘for kumquat
plants’’.
■
§ 301.75–13
[Amended]
5. In § 301.75–13, paragraph (b) is
amended by adding the words ‘‘, or any
term or condition of the compliance
agreement itself’’ after the words ‘‘with
this subpart’’.
■
§ 301.76–4
[Amended]
6. In § 301.76–4, paragraph (c) is
amended by removing the words ‘‘for
immediate export under a limited
permit in accordance with § 301.76–
7(c)’’ and adding the words ‘‘in
accordance with § 301.76–7’’ in their
place.
■
§§ 301.76–8 and 301.76–9
[Amended]
7. Footnote 4 in § 301.76–8 and
footnote 5 in § 301.76–9 are
redesignated as footnotes 6 and 7,
respectively.
■ 8. Section 301.76–6 is amended as
follows:
■ a. By revising the section heading to
read as set forth below.
■ b. By redesignating paragraphs (b) and
(c) as paragraphs (c) and (d),
respectively.
■ c. By revising newly redesignated
paragraph (c) to read as set forth below
■ d. In newly redesignated paragraph
(d), by redesignating footnote 3 as
footnote 4.
■
and Quarantine offices, which are listed in
telephone directories.
E:\FR\FM\27APR1.SGM
27APR1
23458
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 81 / Wednesday, April 27, 2011 / Rules and Regulations
■ e. By adding a new paragraph (b) and
a new footnote 3 to read as set forth
below.
■ f. By adding the OMB citation
‘‘(Approved by the Office of
Management and Budget under control
number 0579–0369)’’ at the end of the
section.
§ 301.76–6 Additional conditions for
issuance of certificates and limited permits
for regulated articles moved interstate from
areas quarantined for Asian citrus psyllid,
but not for citrus greening.
WReier-Aviles on DSKGBLS3C1PROD with RULES
*
*
*
*
*
(b) Additional conditions for issuance
of a certificate; regulated nursery stock.
In addition to the general conditions for
issuance of a certificate contained in
§ 301.76–5(a), an inspector or person
operating under a compliance
agreement may issue a certificate for
interstate movement of regulated
nursery stock to any State if:
(1) The nursery in which the nursery
stock is produced has entered into a
compliance agreement with APHIS in
which it agrees to meet the relevant
construction standards, sourcing and
certification requirements, cleaning,
disinfecting, and safeguarding
requirements, labeling requirements,
and recordkeeping and inspection
requirements specified in a PPQ
protocol document. The protocol
document will be provided to the
person at the time he or she enters into
the compliance agreement.3 The
compliance agreement may also specify
additional conditions determined by
APHIS to be necessary in order to
prevent the spread of Asian citrus
psyllid under which the nursery stock
must be grown, maintained, and
shipped in order to obtain a certificate
for its movement. The compliance
agreement will also specify that APHIS
may amend the agreement.
(2) An inspector determines that the
nursery has adhered to all terms and
conditions of the compliance agreement.
(3) The nursery stock is completely
enclosed in a sealed container that is
clearly labeled with the certificate and
is moved interstate in that container.
(4) A copy of the certificate is
attached to the consignee’s copy of the
accompanying waybill.
(c) Additional conditions for issuance
of a limited permit; regulated nursery
stock. (1) Nursery stock that will not be
moved through American Samoa,
Arizona, California, Florida, Guam,
3 The protocol document is also available on the
Internet at https://www.aphis.usda.gov/
plant_health/plant_pest_info/citrus/index.shtml
and may be obtained from local Plant Protection
and Quarantine offices, which are listed in
telephone directories.
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:29 Apr 26, 2011
Jkt 223001
Hawaii, the Northern Mariana Islands,
Puerto Rico, Texas, or the U.S. Virgin
Islands. In addition to the general
conditions for the issuance of a limited
permit contained in § 301.76–5(b), an
inspector or person operating under a
compliance agreement, other than the
operator of the nursery in which the
nursery stock was produced and his or
her employees, may issue a limited
permit for the interstate movement of
regulated nursery stock through areas of
the United States other than American
Samoa, Arizona, California, Florida,
Guam, Hawaii, Louisiana, the Northern
Mariana Islands, Puerto Rico, Texas, or
the U.S. Virgin Islands, and to areas of
the United States other than Northern
Mariana Islands and those portions of
Arizona and California that are not
quarantined due to the presence of
Asian citrus psyllid or citrus greening,
if:
(i) The nursery in which the nursery
stock is produced has entered into a
compliance agreement with APHIS in
accordance with § 301.76–8;
(ii) All citrus nursery stock at the
nursery has been inspected by an
inspector every 30 days, and any
findings of Asian citrus psyllid during
an inspection have been reported to
APHIS immediately;
(iii) The nursery stock is treated for
Asian citrus psyllid with an APHISapproved soil drench or in-ground
granular application no more than 90
days and no fewer than 30 days before
shipment, followed by an APHISapproved foliar spray no more than 10
days before shipment. All treatments
must be applied according to their EPA
label, including directions on
application, restrictions on place of
application and other restrictions, and
precautions, and including statements
pertaining to Worker Protection
Standards;
(iv) The nursery stock is affixed prior
to movement with a plastic or metal tag
on which the statement ‘‘Limited permit:
USDA–APHIS–PPQ. Not for distribution
in Northern Mariana Islands or those
portions of AZ and CA not quarantined
due to the presence of Asian citrus
psyllid or citrus greening’’ is
prominently and legibly displayed on
the obverse, and adequate information
as determined by APHIS regarding the
identity of the nursery stock and its
source of production to conduct
traceback to the nursery in which the
nursery stock was produced is
prominently and legibly printed on the
reverse. If the nursery stock is destined
for movement or sale in boxes or
containers, the statement and the
identifying information may be printed
on the box or container, or printed on
PO 00000
Frm 00010
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
a label permanently affixed to the box
or container, provided that, in either
case, the statement and the identifying
information are prominently and legibly
displayed;
(v) A copy of the limited permit will
be attached to the consignee’s copy of
the accompanying waybill; and
(vi) The nursery stock is shipped in
accordance with the conditions
specified on the limited permit to the
destination specified on the permit.
(2) Nursery stock that will be moved
through American Samoa, Arizona,
California, Florida, Guam, Hawaii,
Louisiana, the Northern Mariana
Islands, Puerto Rico, Texas, or the U.S.
Virgin Islands. In addition to the general
conditions for the issuance of a limited
permit contained in § 301.76–5(b), an
inspector or person operating under a
compliance agreement may issue a
permit for the interstate movement of
regulated nursery stock through
American Samoa, Arizona, California,
Florida, Guam, Hawaii, Louisiana, the
Northern Mariana Islands, Puerto Rico,
Texas, or the U.S. Virgin Islands, and to
areas of the United States other than
Northern Mariana Islands or those
portions of Arizona and California that
are not quarantined due to the presence
of Asian citrus psyllid or citrus
greening, if:
(i) All conditions for movement of
regulated nursery stock in paragraphs
(c)(1)(i) through (c)(1)(vi) of this section
are fulfilled;
(ii) The nursery stock is inspected by
an inspector on the date of shipment
and found free of Asian citrus psyllid;
(iii) The nursery stock is completely
enclosed in a container sealed with an
agricultural seal and is moved interstate
in that container;
(iv) The container prominently and
legibly displays the statement and
identifying information specified in
paragraph (c)(1)(iv) of this section;
(v) The agricultural seal remains
intact throughout movement to the
destination specified on the limited
permit; and
(vi) The agricultural seal is removed
at the destination specified on the
limited permit by an inspector.
*
*
*
*
*
■ 9. Section 301.76–7 is amended as
follows:
■ a. By redesignating paragraphs (a) and
(b) as paragraphs (b) and (c),
respectively.
■ b. By adding a new paragraph (a) and
a new footnote 5 to read as set forth
below.
■ c. In newly redesignated paragraph
(c), by adding the words ‘‘or (b)’’ after the
words ’’ paragraph (a)’’.
E:\FR\FM\27APR1.SGM
27APR1
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 81 / Wednesday, April 27, 2011 / Rules and Regulations
■ d. By adding the OMB citation
‘‘(Approved by the Office of
Management and Budget under control
number 0579–0369)’’ at the end of the
section.
§ 301.76–7 Additional conditions for
issuance of certificates and limited permits
for regulated articles moved interstate from
areas quarantined for citrus greening.
(a) Additional conditions for the
issuance of a certificate; regulated
nursery stock produced within a nursery
located in the quarantined area. In
addition to the general conditions for
issuance of a certificate contained in
§ 301.76–5(a), an inspector or person
operating under a compliance
agreement may issue a certificate for
interstate movement of regulated
nursery stock to any State if all of the
following conditions are met:
(1) The nursery in which the nursery
stock is produced has entered into a
compliance agreement with APHIS in
which it agrees to meet the relevant
construction standards, sourcing and
certification requirements, cleaning,
disinfecting, and safeguarding
requirements, labeling requirements,
and recordkeeping and inspection
requirements specified in a PPQ
protocol document. The protocol
document will be provided to the
person at the time he or she enters into
the compliance agreement.5 The
compliance agreement may also specify
additional conditions determined by
APHIS to be necessary in order to
prevent the dissemination of citrus
greening under which the nursery stock
must be grown, maintained, and
shipped in order to obtain a certificate
for its movement. The compliance
agreement will also specify that APHIS
may amend the agreement.
(2) An inspector has determined that
the nursery has adhered to all terms and
conditions of the compliance agreement.
(3) The nursery stock is completely
enclosed in a sealed container that is
clearly labeled with the certificate and
is moved interstate in that container.
(4) A copy of the certificate is
attached to the consignee’s copy of the
accompanying waybill.
*
*
*
*
*
§ 301.76–8
[Amended]
10. Section 301.76–8 is amended as
follows:
■ a. In paragraph (b), by adding the
words ‘‘, or any term or condition of the
WReier-Aviles on DSKGBLS3C1PROD with RULES
■
5 The protocol document is also available on the
Internet at https://www.aphis.usda.gov/
plant_health/plant_pest_info/citrus/index.shtml
and may be obtained from local Plant Protection
and Quarantine offices, which are listed in
telephone directories.
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:29 Apr 26, 2011
Jkt 223001
compliance agreement itself’’ after the
words ‘‘with this subpart’’.
■ b. In the OMB citation at the end of
the section, by removing the words
‘‘number 0579–0363’’ and adding the
words ‘‘numbers 0579–0363 and 0579–
0369’’ in their place.
§ 301.76–9
[Amended]
11. Section 301.76–9 is amended by
removing the words ‘‘All regulated
nursery stock treated with soil drenches
or in-ground granular applications and
foliar sprays prior to interstate
movement from an area quarantined
only for Asian citrus psyllid, but not for
citrus greening, as well as all’’ and
adding the word ‘‘All’’ in their place.
■
Done in Washington, DC, this 21st day of
April 2011.
Edward M. Avalos,
Under Secretary for Marketing and Regulatory
Programs.
[FR Doc. 2011–10092 Filed 4–26–11; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 3410–34–P
FARM CREDIT ADMINISTRATION
12 CFR Parts 651 and 652
Federal Agricultural Mortgage
Corporation Governance and Federal
Agricultural Mortgage Corporation
Funding and Fiscal Affairs; Risk-Based
Capital Requirements
Farm Credit Administration.
ACTION: Final rule.
AGENCY:
The Farm Credit
Administration (FCA, Agency, us, or
we) issues this final rule amending our
regulations on the Risk-Based Capital
Stress Test (RBCST or model) used by
the Federal Agricultural Mortgage
Corporation (Farmer Mac). This
rulemaking updates the model to ensure
that it continues to appropriately reflect
risk in a manner consistent with
statutory requirements for calculating
Farmer Mac’s regulatory minimum
capital level under a risk-based capital
stress test. This rule updates the model
to estimate the capital requirements
associated with Farmer Mac’s statutory
authority to finance rural utility loans
and to revise the treatment of certain
secured general obligations held by
Farmer Mac as program investments.
This rule also revises the treatment of
counterparty risk on non-program
investments in the model by adjusting
the haircuts applied to those
investments to keep the model
internally consistent with revisions
made to stressed historical corporate
bond default and recovery rates.
PO 00000
Frm 00011
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
Effective date: This regulation
will be effective 30 days after
publication in the Federal Register
during which either or both Houses of
Congress are in session. We will publish
a notice of the effective date in the
Federal Register.
Compliance date: Compliance with
the changes to the model must be
achieved by the first day of the fiscal
quarter following the effective date of
the rule. All other provisions require
compliance on the effective date of this
rule.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Joseph T. Connor, Associate Director for
Policy and Analysis, Office of
Secondary Market Oversight, Farm
Credit Administration, McLean, VA
22102–5090, (703) 883–4280, TTY
(703) 883–4434;
or
Laura McFarland, Senior Counsel,
Office of the General Counsel, Farm
Credit Administration, McLean, VA
22102–5090, (703) 883–4020, TTY
(703) 883–4020.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
DATES:
I. Objective
RIN 3052–AC51
SUMMARY:
23459
The objective of this final rule is to
ensure that the RBCST for Farmer Mac
continues to determine regulatory
capital requirements in a manner
consistent with statutory requirements.
II. Background
The FCA is an independent agency in
the executive branch of the Federal
Government that, in part, serves as the
safety and soundness regulator of
Farmer Mac. The FCA regulates Farmer
Mac through the Office of Secondary
Market Oversight (OSMO). Farmer Mac
is a stockholder-owned instrumentality
of the United States, chartered by
Congress to establish a secondary
market for agricultural real estate, rural
housing mortgage loans, and rural
utilities loans. Farmer Mac also
facilitates the capital markets funding
for USDA-guaranteed farm program and
rural development loans. Section 5406
of the Food, Conservation and Energy
Act of 2008 (2008 Farm Bill) 1 amended
the definition of ‘‘qualified loan’’ in Title
VIII of the Farm Credit Act of 1971, as
amended, (Act) 2 to include rural utility
loans. This change gave Farmer Mac the
authority to purchase and guarantee
securities backed by loans to rural
electric and telephone utility
cooperatives as program business. The
1 Public Law 110–246, 122 Stat. 1651 (June 18,
2008) (repealing and replacing Pub. L. 110–234).
2 Public Law 92 181, 85 Stat. 583 (December 10,
1971).
E:\FR\FM\27APR1.SGM
27APR1
Agencies
[Federal Register Volume 76, Number 81 (Wednesday, April 27, 2011)]
[Rules and Regulations]
[Pages 23449-23459]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Printing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2011-10092]
========================================================================
Rules and Regulations
Federal Register
________________________________________________________________________
This section of the FEDERAL REGISTER contains regulatory documents
having general applicability and legal effect, most of which are keyed
to and codified in the Code of Federal Regulations, which is published
under 50 titles pursuant to 44 U.S.C. 1510.
The Code of Federal Regulations is sold by the Superintendent of Documents.
Prices of new books are listed in the first FEDERAL REGISTER issue of each
week.
========================================================================
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 81 / Wednesday, April 27, 2011 /
Rules and Regulations
[[Page 23449]]
DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service
7 CFR Part 301
[Docket No. APHIS-2010-0048]
RIN 0579-AD29
Citrus Canker, Citrus Greening, and Asian Citrus Psyllid;
Interstate Movement of Regulated Nursery Stock
AGENCY: Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service, USDA.
ACTION: Interim rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: We are amending the regulations governing the interstate
movement of regulated articles from areas quarantined for citrus
canker, citrus greening, and/or Asian citrus psyllid (ACP) to allow the
movement of regulated nursery stock under a certificate to any area
within the United States. In order to be eligible to move regulated
nursery stock, a nursery must enter into a compliance agreement with
APHIS that specifies the conditions under which the nursery stock must
be grown, maintained, and shipped. We are also amending the regulations
that allow the movement of regulated nursery stock from an area
quarantined for ACP, but not for citrus greening, to amend the existing
regulatory requirements for the issuance of limited permits for the
interstate movement of the nursery stock. We are making these changes
on an immediate basis in order to provide nursery stock producers in
areas quarantined for citrus canker, citrus greening, or ACP with the
ability to ship regulated nursery stock to markets within the United
States that would otherwise be unavailable to them due to the
prohibitions and restrictions contained in the regulations while
continuing to provide adequate safeguards to prevent the spread of the
three pests into currently unaffected areas of the United States.
DATES: This interim rule is effective April 27, 2011. We will consider
all comments that receive on or before June 27, 2011.
ADDRESSES: You may submit comments by either of the following methods:
Federal eRulemaking Portal: Go to https://www.regulations.gov/fdmspublic/component/main?main=DocketDetail&d=APHIS-2010-0048 to submit or view comments and
to view supporting and related materials available electronically.
Postal Mail/Commercial Delivery: Please send one copy of
your comment to Docket No. APHIS-2010-0048, Regulatory Analysis and
Development, PPD, APHIS, Station 3A-03.8, 4700 River Road Unit 118,
Riverdale, MD 20737-1238. Please state that your comment refers to
Docket No. APHIS-2010-0048.
Reading Room: You may read any comments that we receive on this
docket on the Regulations.gov Web site (see link above) or in our
reading room. The reading room is located in room 1141 of the USDA
South Building, 14th Street and Independence Avenue, SW., Washington,
DC. Normal reading room hours are 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., Monday through
Friday, except holidays. To be sure someone is there to help you,
please call (202) 690-2817 before coming.
Other Information: Additional information about APHIS and its
programs is available on the Internet at https://www.aphis.usda.gov.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Mr. Osama El-Lissy, Director,
Emergency and Domestic Programs, PPQ, APHIS, 4700 River Road Unit 160,
Riverdale, MD 20737-1238; (301) 734-5459; or Ms. Deborah L. McPartlan,
Emergency and Domestic Programs, PPQ, APHIS, 4700 River Road Unit 160,
Riverdale, MD 20737-1238; (301) 734-5356.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Background
Under section 412(a) of the Plant Protection Act (7 U.S.C. 7701 et
seq., referred to below as the PPA), the Secretary of Agriculture may
prohibit or restrict the movement in interstate commerce of any plant
or plant product, if the Secretary determines that the prohibition or
restriction is necessary to prevent the dissemination of a plant pest
within the United States. Under the PPA, the Secretary may also issue
regulations requiring plants and plant products moved in interstate
commerce to be subject to remedial measures determined necessary to
prevent the spread of the pest, or requiring the plants or plant
products to be accompanied by a permit issued by the Secretary prior to
movement.
Citrus canker is a plant disease that is caused by the bacterium
Xanthomonas citri subsp. citri that affects plants and plant parts of
citrus and citrus relatives (Family Rutaceae). Citrus canker can cause
defoliation and other serious damage to the leaves and twigs of
susceptible plants. It can also cause lesions on the fruit of infected
plants, which render the fruit unmarketable, and cause infected fruit
to drop from the trees before reaching maturity. The aggressive A
(Asiatic) strain of citrus canker can infect susceptible plants rapidly
and lead to extensive economic losses in commercial citrus-producing
areas. Citrus canker is known to be present in the United States in the
State of Florida.
The regulations to prevent the interstate spread of citrus canker
are contained in ``Subpart--Citrus Canker'' (7 CFR 301.75-1 through
301.75-14, referred to below as the citrus canker regulations). The
citrus canker regulations designate the State of Florida as a
quarantined area, and restrict the interstate movement of regulated
articles from and through this area. Regulated articles are plants and
plant parts of all species, clones, cultivars, strains, varieties, or
hybrids of the genera Citrus and Fortunella, and all clones, cultivars,
strains, varieties and hybrids of the species Clausena lansium and
Poncirus trifoliata. Plants and plant parts include, among other
articles, fruit, seed, and nursery stock. The provisions of the citrus
canker regulations that pertain to the interstate movement of regulated
nursery stock from areas quarantined for citrus canker are found in
Sec. 301.75-6.
Citrus greening, also known as Huanglongbing disease of citrus, is
considered to be one of the most serious citrus diseases in the world.
Citrus greening is a bacterial disease, caused by strains of the
bacterial pathogen ``Candidatus Liberibacter asiaticus,'' that attacks
the vascular system of host plants. The pathogen is phloem-limited,
[[Page 23450]]
inhabiting the food-conducting tissue of the host plant, and causes
yellow shoots, blotchy mottling and chlorosis, reduced foliage, and tip
dieback of citrus plants. Citrus greening greatly reduces production,
destroys the economic value of the fruit, and can kill trees. Once
infected, there is no cure for a tree with citrus greening. In areas of
the world where the disease is endemic, citrus trees decline and die
within a few years and may never produce usable fruit. Citrus greening
was first detected in the United States in Miami-Dade County, FL, in
2005, and is known to be present in the United States in Florida and
Georgia, Puerto Rico, the U.S. Virgin Islands, two parishes in
Louisiana, and two counties in South Carolina.
The bacterial pathogen causing citrus greening can be transmitted
by grafting, and under laboratory conditions, by parasitic plants.
There also is some evidence that seed transmission may occur. The
pathogen can also be transmitted by two insect vectors in the family
Psyllidae: Diaphorina citri Kuwayama, the Asian citrus psyllid (ACP),
and Trioza erytreae (del Guercio), the African citrus psyllid. ACP can
also cause economic damage to citrus in groves and nurseries by direct
feeding. Both adults and nymphs feed on young foliage, depleting the
sap and causing galling or curling of leaves. High populations feeding
on a citrus shoot can kill the growing tip. ACP is currently present in
Alabama, American Samoa,\1\ Florida, Georgia, Guam, Hawaii, Louisiana,
Mississippi, Puerto Rico, Texas, the U.S. Virgin Islands, and portions
of Arizona, California, and South Carolina. Regular surveys of domestic
commercial citrus-producing areas indicate that the African citrus
psyllid is not present in the United States.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ An established population of ACP was discovered in American
Samoa in October 2010, and the entire island has been designated a
quarantined area for ACP through administrative action.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The regulations to prevent the interstate spread of citrus greening
and ACP are contained in ``Subpart-Citrus Greening and Asian Citrus
Psyllid'' (7 CFR 301.76 through 301.76-11, referred to below as the
citrus greening and ACP regulations). The citrus greening and ACP
regulations quarantine the States of Florida and Georgia, Puerto Rico,
the U.S. Virgin Islands, two parishes in Louisiana, and two counties in
South Carolina due to the presence of citrus greening, and quarantine
Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Guam, Hawaii, Louisiana, Mississippi, Puerto
Rico, Texas, the U.S. Virgin Islands, and portions of Arizona,
California, and South Carolina due to the presence of ACP. The
regulations also place restrictions on the interstate movement of
regulated articles from quarantined areas. Regulated articles include
all plants and plant parts, except fruit, of host species within the
Family Rutaceae.
The provisions of the citrus greening and ACP regulations that
pertain to the interstate movement of regulated nursery stock from
areas quarantined for citrus greening and/or ACP are found in
Sec. Sec. 301.76-6 and 301.76-7. Section 301.76-6 contains specific
conditions for the issuance of certificates and limited permits for
regulated articles moved interstate from an area quarantined for ACP,
but not for citrus greening. Section 301.76-7 contains specific
conditions for the issuance of certificates and limited permits for
regulated articles moved interstate from an area quarantined for citrus
greening.
Current Restrictions and Prohibitions on the Interstate Movement of
Regulated Nursery Stock From Areas Quarantined for Citrus Canker,
Citrus Greening, and/or ACP
As we mentioned earlier in this document, the provisions of the
citrus canker regulations that pertain to the interstate movement of
regulated nursery stock from areas quarantined for citrus canker are
found in Sec. 301.75-6. This section prohibits the interstate movement
of regulated nursery stock from a quarantined area, and prior to the
publication of this interim rule, provided for only two exceptions to
this general prohibition. The first exception allowed the interstate
movement of kumquat plants, which have a natural resistance to citrus
canker, in accordance with a protocol designed to ensure their freedom
from citrus canker prior to movement. The other exception allowed
regulated nursery stock to be moved interstate for immediate export.
Similarly, Sec. 301.76-7 contains specific conditions for the
issuance of certificates and limited permits for regulated articles
moved interstate from areas quarantined for citrus greening, and
prohibits the interstate movement of regulated nursery stock from such
areas. Prior to issuance of this interim rule, there was only one
exception in Sec. 301.76-7 to this general prohibition on interstate
movement: Nursery stock destined for immediate export and shipped under
a protocol designed to ensure that it does not spread citrus greening
into currently unaffected areas of the United States.
In contrast, our approach towards the movement of regulated nursery
stock from areas quarantined for ACP, but not for citrus greening, has
differed. This is because, while ACP can damage citrus nursery stock,
its primary risk to nursery stock is as a vector of the bacterial
pathogen that causes citrus greening. The risk that the artificial
spread of ACP poses to currently unaffected areas of the United States,
then, lies in its potential to introduce citrus greening to those
areas.
Therefore, the citrus greening and ACP regulations currently allow
the interstate movement of regulated nursery stock from areas
quarantined for ACP, but not for citrus greening, provided that the
nursery stock has been subject to remedial measures to prevent ACP from
moving with the nursery stock. Specifically, Sec. 301.76-6 allows for
the movement of any regulated article from an area quarantined for ACP
to any State, provided that, among other conditions, the articles are
treated with methyl bromide and shipped in a container that has been
sealed with an agricultural seal placed by an inspector after
treatment.
In addition, prior to publication of this interim rule, Sec.
301.76-6 allowed for the movement of regulated nursery stock to areas
other than commercial citrus-producing areas \2\ under a limited permit
from an area quarantined for ACP, but not for citrus greening, provided
that, among other conditions, the articles were treated before shipment
with certain approved soil drenches and foliar sprays, inspected, and
shipped in sealed containers. The citrus greening and ACP regulations
have otherwise prohibited all other interstate movement of regulated
nursery stock.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\ Commercial citrus-producing areas are American Samoa,
Arizona, California, Florida, Guam, Hawaii, Louisiana, Northern
Mariana Islands, Puerto Rico, Texas, and U.S. Virgin Islands.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Requests for a Systems Approach Under Which Citrus Nursery Stock May Be
Moved Interstate
The congressional findings set out in section 402 of the PPA
describe USDA's responsibility to facilitate interstate commerce in
agricultural products and other commodities that pose a risk of
harboring plant pest in ways that will reduce, to the extent
practicable, the risk of dissemination of plant pests. It is APHIS'
policy to impose restrictions on the interstate movement of host
articles that are the least restrictive measures necessary to prevent
the dissemination of plant pests within the United States.
For several years, various individuals and entities have requested
that APHIS implement a systems approach that
[[Page 23451]]
could serve as the basis for allowing the interstate movement of citrus
nursery stock to any area of the United States from areas quarantined
for citrus canker, citrus greening, and ACP.
This request was first made by commenters during the comment period
for an interim rule that was published in the Federal Register on March
22, 2007 and effective on March 16, 2007 (72 FR 13423-13428, Docket No.
APHIS-2007-0032) that explicitly prohibited the interstate movement of
citrus nursery stock, with the two limited exceptions mentioned earlier
in this document, from the State of Florida. The commenters stated
that, in lieu of such a general prohibition, APHIS should recognize the
Citrus Nursery Stock Certification Program, established by the State of
Florida in December 2006 to prevent the spread of citrus canker and
citrus greening within and from that State, as sufficient to allow the
interstate movement of nursery stock produced in that program.
In response to those comments, we examined the program thoroughly
and determined that certain of its provisions did not adequately
address the risk of the spread of citrus canker or citrus greening from
Florida. We subsequently communicated this determination to the Florida
Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (FDACS), highlighting
those aspects of the approach that we considered inadequate.
In response, FDACS requested APHIS' assistance in crafting a
systems approach that would provide adequate phytosanitary measures to
allow the interstate movement of citrus nursery stock from areas
quarantined for citrus canker, citrus greening, and ACP. To this end,
APHIS convened a technical working group, which recommended sourcing
from a pest-exclusionary production facility and testing for all
germplasm and budwood destined for propagation in nurseries within the
State, construction and maintenance of pest-exclusionary production
facilities and buffer zones, safeguarding, routine inspections,
cleaning and disinfection protocols, and other measures that would be
sufficient to address the concerns raised in our earlier evaluation. As
a result of this collaboration with APHIS, FDACS presented a draft
systems approach to us for evaluation in December 2008. The mitigation
measures proposed in that systems approach appeared consistent with the
recommendations of the technical working group.
However, because the movement of citrus nursery stock is considered
to be a high-risk pathway for citrus canker and citrus greening, and
because the introduction of citrus canker or citrus greening into
currently unaffected commercial citrus-producing areas could have a
lasting and deleterious effect on the U.S. industry as a whole, we did
not initiate rulemaking at that time to establish such a systems
approach. Rather, we decided to prepare an analysis of the risks
associated with the interstate movement of citrus nursery stock from
areas quarantined for citrus canker, citrus greening, and ACP.
Risk Management Analysis
APHIS has prepared a risk management analysis (RMA). The document,
titled ``Interstate Movement of Citrus and Other Rutaceous Plants for
Planting to Non-Quarantine Areas in Any State,'' analyzes the movement
of citrus nursery stock from areas quarantined for citrus canker,
citrus greening, or ACP as a pathway for the introduction of citrus
canker, citrus greening, and ACP into other areas of the United States.
Consistent with the findings of the technical working group, the
analysis also finds that a systems approach is necessary in order to
mitigate the risk associated with such movement.
Because the nature of the three pests and the manner in which they
are introduced into nursery stock vary, the exact nature of the
necessary mitigation measures in the systems approach will
correspondingly vary based on whether the nursery stock is produced in
an area quarantined for citrus canker, citrus greening, or ACP, or a
combination of these three pests. However, the analysis finds that each
such systems approach must be predicated upon two critical elements:
Pest exclusion and system monitoring.
The analysis describes pest exclusion as consisting of the
following core components: Testing the citrus nursery stock that will
be moved interstate for citrus greening, certifying the nursery stock
as free of citrus greening, growing the nursery stock in approved
structures that are constructed to exclude introduction of the relevant
pests, maintaining a controlled space around the structure that is free
of citrus, and safeguarding the nursery stock within the structure to
prevent pest introduction.
The analysis describes system monitoring as consisting of the
following core components: Inspecting the nursery stock within the
structure on a routine basis, conducting an unannounced inspection at
least once yearly, testing a statistically valid sample of the plants
within the nursery for citrus greening on a recurring schedule,
surveying the nursery regularly for quarantine pests, responding to
breaches of the facility with appropriate remediation, and maintaining
quality assurance, including but not limited to accurate recordkeeping
and labeling, as well as standard operating procedures for cleaning and
disinfection.
The RMA may be viewed on the Regulations.gov Web site or in our
reading room (see ADDRESSES at the beginning of this document.) In
addition, copies may be obtained by calling or writing to the
individual listed under FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT. We request
comment on the analysis, especially any scientific studies that may be
pertinent.
Protocol Document
Based on the determination of the RMA that a systems approach is
necessary to mitigate the risk associated with the interstate movement
of citrus nursery stock from areas quarantined for citrus canker,
citrus greening, and/or ACP, APHIS prepared a draft protocol document
that used core components suggested in the RMA as the basis for
standards and requirements that a nursery would have to meet in order
to move citrus nursery stock interstate from such areas. APHIS then
shared the draft protocol with nursery stock producers and State
agricultural officials. In response to the input we received, we
revised some of the conditions in the protocol document to provide
alternative standards or requirements that were equivalent to the core
components identified in the RMA. By meeting the standards and
requirements, a nursery would be able to obtain a certificate or
limited permit \3\ for the interstate movement of citrus nursery stock
from areas quarantined for citrus canker, citrus greening, or ACP.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\ APHIS authorizes certificates to be issued when an article
can safely be moved interstate from a quarantine area without any
risk of spreading a quarantine pest, and limited permits when, in
order to address a risk of plant pest dissemination, limits must be
placed on the distribution or utilization of the article.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The protocol document is divided into five sections. Section I
provides general requirements. Under this section, each nursery that
wishes to obtain a certificate to move regulated nursery stock
interstate must enter into a compliance agreement with APHIS in which
it agrees to observe the protocol's minimum construction standards for
a pest-exclusionary production facility; sourcing and certification
requirements for all propagative material grown in the facility;
cleaning, disinfecting, and safeguarding requirements for the
[[Page 23452]]
facility; labeling requirements for the nursery stock maintained in the
facility; and recordkeeping and inspection requirements.
The protocol also contains additional conditions for interstate
movement of regulated nursery stock that the nursery would have to
agree to observe; each set of additional conditions addresses disease
risks associated with the area in which the nursery is located: Section
II of the protocol document sets forth additional requirements for
interstate movement of regulated nursery stock from areas quarantined
for citrus canker; section III, for areas quarantined for ACP; and
section IV, for areas quarantined for citrus greening.
Section V of the protocol provides conditions for the issuance of
limited permits for the interstate movement of regulated nursery stock
from areas that are quarantined for ACP, but not citrus greening. These
conditions match the requirements of Sec. 301.76-6 in this interim
rule. Our changes to Sec. 301.76-6 are discussed later in this rule.
The protocol document may be viewed on the Regulations.gov Web site
or in our reading room (see ADDRESSES at the beginning of this
document). In addition, copies may be obtained by calling or writing to
the individual listed under FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT. It is also
available on the Plant Protection and Quarantine (PPQ) Web site at
https://www.aphis.usda.gov/plant_health/plant_pest_info/citrus/index.shtml.
We believe that the procedures set forth in the protocol document
will provide the necessary safeguards to allow the interstate movement
of citrus nursery stock from areas quarantined for citrus canker,
citrus greening, or ACP to any area of the United States. It may,
however, be necessary for us to propose to update the protocol document
as circumstances warrant. We envision that these proposed updates will
usually be nonsubstantive, and will be intended to further delineate
the protocol's provisions or provide additional options to the
mitigation strategies currently contained in the document. APHIS
believes that the ability to revise the protocol document is necessary
because new scientific information on the risks associated with ACP,
citrus greening, and citrus canker continues to be published at a rapid
pace. As new information comes to light, APHIS must be able to adjust
its quarantine protocols in a flexible manner. If we are proposing
substantive modifications, however, we will publish a notice in the
Federal Register containing the nature of and rationale for these
proposed revisions, and requesting public comment. In such instances,
if, after the close of the comment period, we continue to consider it
necessary to update the protocol document, we will do so accordingly.
We request comment on this approach and whether it provides sufficient
avenue for input from the public.
Whenever we update the protocol document, we will notify each State
agricultural official and holder of a compliance agreement of the
changes, and compliance agreements will be updated to reflect the
updated protocol. It will be necessary for those operating under a
compliance agreement to sign the updated agreement in order to continue
to be eligible to continue shipping citrus nursery stock interstate.
Other interested parties can receive notification of these updates by
subscribing to the PPQ stakeholder registry at https://web01.aphis.usda.gov/PPQStakeWeb2.nsf.
Regulatory Changes
We are amending the citrus canker and citrus greening and ACP
regulations to reflect the findings of the RMA and the provisions of
the protocol document and allow the interstate movement of regulated
nursery stock to any area of the United States, under certain
conditions. To accommodate these amendments, we are also amending
several other provisions of the citrus canker and citrus greening and
ACP regulations that would otherwise have been in conflict with the
amendments.
Citrus Canker Regulations
As we mentioned earlier in this document, the provisions of the
citrus canker regulations that pertain to the interstate movement of
regulated nursery stock from areas quarantined for citrus canker are
found in Sec. 301.75-6. Prior to the publication of this interim rule,
paragraph (a) of Sec. 301.75-6 explicitly prohibited the interstate
movement of regulated nursery stock from a quarantined area, unless the
nursery stock was moved in accordance with paragraph (b) or (c) of the
section. Paragraph (b) allowed the interstate movement of kumquats in
accordance with a protocol designed to ensure their freedom from citrus
canker prior to movement. Paragraph (c) stated that nursery stock
produced in a nursery located in a quarantined area that is not
eligible for movement under paragraph (b) of could be moved interstate
only for immediate export.
We are redesignating paragraph (c) as paragraph (d), and adding a
new paragraph (c) in its place. This new paragraph (c) of Sec. 301.75-
6 provides that regulated nursery stock produced in a nursery within a
quarantined area may be moved interstate to any area within the United
States, if all of the following conditions are met:
The nursery in which the nursery stock is produced has
entered into a compliance agreement with APHIS in which it agrees to
meet the relevant construction standards, sourcing and certification
requirements, cleaning, disinfecting, and safeguarding requirements,
labeling requirements, and recordkeeping and inspection requirements
specified in the protocol document described above. In addition to
being available on the APHIS Web site, the protocol document will be
provided to the person at the time he or she enters into the compliance
agreement. The compliance agreement may also specify additional
conditions determined by APHIS to be necessary to prevent the
dissemination of citrus canker under which the nursery stock must be
grown, maintained, and shipped in order to obtain a certificate for its
movement. The compliance agreement will specify that APHIS may amend
the agreement.
An inspector has determined that the nursery has adhered
to all terms and conditions of the compliance agreement.
The nursery stock is accompanied by a certificate issued
in accordance with Sec. 301.75-12.
The nursery stock is completely enclosed in a sealed
container that is clearly labeled with the certificate and is moved
interstate in that container. We are requiring such containers in order
to safeguard the nursery stock against wind and rain events that may
lead to the introduction of citrus canker.
A copy of the certificate is attached to the consignee's
copy of the accompanying waybill.
Because of this new paragraph (c), there are now two paragraphs in
Sec. 301.75-6 which allow nursery stock to be moved interstate for
purposes other than immediate export. As a result, we are amending
newly designated paragraph (d) to provide that nursery stock that is
not eligible for movement under either of the paragraphs may be moved
interstate only for immediate export. For a similar reason, we are also
amending paragraph (a) of Sec. 301.75-6 to authorize interstate
movement of nursery stock under the conditions in any of the subsequent
paragraphs in the section.
The certificate accompanying the container and accompanying waybill
of the nursery stock being moved must be attached in a manner that
varies from the general requirements for attachment and disposition of
certificates contained
[[Page 23453]]
in the citrus canker regulations. Accordingly, we are amending
paragraph (b) of Sec. 301.75-12, which contains general requirements
for attachment and disposition of certificates, to exempt nursery stock
moved under the conditions of paragraph (c) of Sec. 301.75-6 from
those general requirements.
Prior to the publication of this interim rule, the citrus canker
regulations stated that we would cancel a compliance agreement if an
inspector found that the person who entered into the compliance
agreement had failed to comply with the regulations. However, under
paragraph (c) of Sec. 301.75-6, the conditions under which a nursery
must grow, maintain, and ship nursery stock in order to obtain a
certificate for its movement to any area of the United States are found
not in the citrus canker regulations themselves, but in the compliance
agreement that the nursery has entered into with APHIS. Accordingly,
failure by the nursery to comply with any term or condition of the
compliance agreement could present a risk that regulated nursery stock
at the facility becomes infected with citrus canker and that the
movement of the regulated nursery stock presents a pathway for the
artificial spread of the disease to unaffected areas of the United
States. Therefore, we are amending paragraph (b) of Sec. 301.75-13,
which contains our provisions for cancellation of a compliance
agreement, to state that failure to comply with any term or condition
of the compliance agreement itself will also result in cancellation of
the compliance agreement.
Finally, in Sec. 301.75-1, the definition of compliance agreement
has described them as being between APHIS and persons engaged in the
business of growing or handling regulated articles. However, because of
the manner in which compliance agreements are used within paragraph (c)
of Sec. 301.75-6, we consider it necessary to expand the scope of the
definition so that it also refers to persons engaged in maintaining,
processing, packing, and moving regulated articles. We are amending the
definition of compliance agreement accordingly.
Citrus Greening Regulations
As we mentioned earlier in this document, Sec. 301.76-7 contains
specific conditions for the issuance of certificates and limited
permits for regulated articles moved interstate from an area
quarantined for citrus greening.
Prior to the publication of this interim rule, the only conditions
for the movement of regulated articles from an area quarantined for
citrus greening were found in paragraph (a) of Sec. 301.76-7. This
paragraph allowed for the issuance of limited permits to move regulated
nursery stock interstate, if the nursery stock was destined for
immediate export and shipped under a protocol designed to ensure that
it did not present a pathway for the introduction of citrus greening to
currently unaffected areas of the United States. To clarify that this
was the only condition under which regulated articles could be moved
interstate from an area quarantined for citrus greening, paragraph (b)
of Sec. 301.76-7 stated that, except for nursery stock for which a
limited permit has been issued in accordance with Sec. 301.76-7(a), no
other regulated article may be moved interstate from an area
quarantined for citrus greening.
We are adding a new paragraph (a) to Sec. 301.76-7 and
redesignating paragraphs (a) and (b) as paragraphs (b) and (c),
respectively. The new paragraph (a) provides that, in addition to the
general conditions for issuance of a certificate, an inspector or
person operating under a compliance agreement may issue a certificate
for interstate movement of regulated nursery stock to any State if all
of the following conditions are met:
The nursery in which the nursery stock is produced has
entered into a compliance agreement with APHIS in which it agrees to
meet the relevant construction standards, sourcing and certification
requirements, cleaning, disinfecting, and safeguarding requirements,
labeling requirements, and recordkeeping and inspection requirements
specified in the PPQ protocol document. In addition to being available
on the APHIS Web site, the protocol document will be provided to the
person at the time he or she enters into the compliance agreement. The
compliance agreement may also specify additional conditions determined
by APHIS to be necessary in order to prevent the dissemination of
citrus greening under which the nursery stock must be grown,
maintained, and shipped in order to obtain a certificate for its
movement. The compliance agreement will also specify that APHIS may
amend the agreement.
An inspector has determined that the nursery has adhered
to all terms and conditions of the compliance agreement.
The nursery stock is completely enclosed in a sealed
container that is clearly labeled with the certificate and is moved
interstate in that container.
A copy of the certificate is attached to the consignee's
copy of the accompanying waybill.
Because both paragraphs (a) and (b) of Sec. 301.76-7 now contain
conditions for the interstate movement of regulated nursery stock from
an area quarantined for citrus greening, we are amending newly
redesignated paragraph (c) of Sec. 301.76-7 to specify that apart from
nursery stock moved in accordance with either of those paragraphs, no
other regulated article may be moved interstate from an area
quarantined for citrus greening.
These revisions to Sec. 301.76-7 also require us to make certain
nonsubstantive changes to other sections of the citrus greening
regulations.
We currently require all regulated nursery stock offered for
commercial sale within an area quarantined for citrus greening to have
an APHIS-approved label on which a statement alerting consumers to
Federal prohibitions regarding the interstate movement of the article
is prominently and legibly displayed, unless the regulations grant an
exemption from the requirement. We are amending Sec. 301.76-4, which
contains the labeling requirement and the exemptions from it, to grant
such an exemption to plants moved under paragraph (a) of Sec. 301.76-
7, since the interstate movement of such plants is not prohibited.
We are also amending the conditions in the citrus greening
regulations that will lead us to cancel a compliance agreement. We
modeled these conditions on those in the citrus canker regulations, and
are amending them for the same reason we are amending those in the
citrus canker regulations.
ACP Regulations
As we mentioned earlier in this document, Sec. 301.76-6 of the ACP
and citrus greening regulations contains specific conditions for the
interstate movement of regulated articles from areas quarantined for
ACP, but not for citrus greening. Prior to the publication of this
interim rule, the only conditions under which a certificate would be
issued for the interstate movement of regulated nursery stock were
found in paragraph (a) of Sec. 301.76-6. The paragraph allows a
certificate to be issued for the interstate movement of any regulated
article, including citrus nursery stock, provided that:
The article is treated with methyl bromide in accordance
with 7 CFR part 305. That part contains our phytosanitary treatment
regulations, and sets out standards for treatments required in 7 CFR
part 301.
The article is shipped in a container that has been sealed
with an agricultural seal placed by an inspector.
[[Page 23454]]
The container that will be moved interstate is clearly
labeled with the certificate.
A copy of the certificate will be attached to the
consignee's copy of the accompanying waybill.
Because methyl bromide is phytotoxic, that is, deadly or damaging
to propagative plants and plant parts, producers have informed us that
few plants have been moved under these conditions.
In addition to the conditions in paragraph (a), prior to the
issuance of this interim rule, the only other conditions for interstate
movement of regulated nursery stock from an area quarantined for ACP
were found in paragraph (b) of Sec. 301.76-6; this paragraph provided
conditions for the issuance of limited permits for such movement to
areas other than commercial citrus-producing areas.
We are redesignating this paragraph as paragraph (c). We are also
substantively revising the conditions for issuance of such a limited
permit. We discuss the revised conditions, and the considerations that
led us to revise them, at length below.
To accommodate this redesignation, we are also redesignating the
previous paragraph (c), which contains conditions for the issuance of
limited permits for regulated articles intended for consumption, for
use as apparel or as a similar personal accessory, or for decorative
use, as new paragraph (d).
We are adding a new paragraph (b) to Sec. 301.76-6. This is
because, based on the findings of the RMA, we have determined that we
can provide another set of conditions for issuance of a certificate for
the interstate movement of regulated nursery stock from areas
quarantined only for ACP. These conditions are:
The nursery in which the nursery stock is produced has
entered into a compliance agreement with APHIS in which it agrees to
meet the relevant construction standards, sourcing and certification
requirements, cleaning, disinfecting, and safeguarding requirements,
labeling requirements, and recordkeeping and inspection requirements
specified in the PPQ protocol document. In addition to being available
on the APHIS Web site, the protocol document will be provided to the
person at the time he or she enters into the compliance agreement. The
compliance agreement may also specify additional conditions determined
by APHIS to be necessary in order to prevent the spread of ACP under
which the nursery stock must be grown, maintained, and shipped in order
to obtain a certificate for its movement. For example, we may require
additional safeguarding measures beyond those specified in the protocol
document for facilities located in areas with high population densities
of ACP. The compliance agreement will also specify that APHIS may amend
the agreement.
An inspector determines that the nursery has adhered to
all terms and conditions of the compliance agreement.
The nursery stock is completely enclosed in a sealed
container that is clearly labeled with the certificate, and is moved
interstate in that container. We are requiring a sealed container in
order to safeguard the nursery stock against possible reintroduction of
ACP.
A copy of the certificate is attached to the consignee's
copy of the accompanying waybill.
As we mentioned above, newly redesignated paragraph (c) of Sec.
301.76-6 contains conditions for issuance of a limited permit for
interstate movement of regulated nursery stock.
Prior to the publication of this interim rule, this paragraph
provided for the issuance of limited permits for the interstate
movement of regulated nursery stock to areas of the United States other
than American Samoa, Northern Mariana Islands, and those portions of
Arizona, California, and South Carolina not quarantined due to the
presence of ACP or citrus greening, if:
The nursery stock is treated for ACP with an APHIS-
approved soil drench or in-ground granular application no more than 30
days and no fewer than 20 days before shipment, followed by an APHIS-
approved foliar spray no more than 10 days before shipment. All
treatments must be applied according to their Environmental Protection
Agency label, including directions on application, restrictions on
place of application and other restrictions, and precautions, and
including statements pertaining to Worker Protection Standards.
The nursery stock is inspected by an inspector in
accordance with Sec. 301.76-9 and found free of ACP.
The nursery stock is affixed prior to movement with a
plastic or metal tag on which the statement ``Limited permit: USDA-
APHIS-PPQ. Not for distribution in American Samoa, Northern Mariana
Islands, or those portions of AZ, CA, and SC not quarantined due to the
presence of Asian citrus psyllid or citrus greening'' is prominently
and legibly displayed. If the nursery stock is destined for movement or
sale in boxes or containers, the statement may be printed on the box or
container, or printed on a label permanently affixed to the box or
container, provided that, in either case, the statement is prominently
and legibly displayed.
The nursery stock is moved in a container sealed with an
agricultural seal placed by an inspector.
This container also prominently and legibly displays the
statement of the limited permit.
A copy of the limited permit is attached to the
consignee's copy of the accompanying waybill.
The nursery stock is moved in accordance with the
conditions specified on the limited permit to the location specified on
the permit.
The conditions in the regulations before this interim rule were
established in a prior interim rule published in the Federal Register
and effective on June 17, 2010 (75 FR 34322-34336, Docket No. APHIS-
2008-0015).\4\ Several commenters on the June 2010 rule stated that
certain of the conditions unnecessarily hindered interstate commerce.
Two commenters stated that the 10-day timeframe for the application of
soil drenches or granular applications was impracticable for smaller
producers, who often did not know the expected date of interstate
movement of an article that far in advance. While recognizing the need
for optimal absorption of the soil drench, the commenters requested a
longer window of time for the application of that treatment.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\ Section 301.76-4 of that rule was effective on September 15,
2010, rather than June 17, 2010.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Similarly, two commenters stated that, by requiring the articles to
be sealed in a shipping container and inspectors to seal each container
with an agricultural seal prior to movement, we were, in effect,
limiting shipment of the articles to normal business hours (8 a.m. to
4:30 p.m., Monday through Friday). The commenters stated that their
shipments traditionally have tended to occur overnight or in the early
morning. Because of these economic considerations, the commenters
questioned whether the conditions were strictly necessary, especially
for nursery stock that is not destined for an area in which ACP could
become established.
In addition, around the same time that these comments were
received, State agricultural officials from several commercial citrus-
producing States contacted APHIS on behalf of their producers to
suggest a different scope and timing for inspections. The officials
stated that inspections of the whole nursery at set intervals would
prove more practicable than inspections of plants in the days preceding
shipment.
In order to respond to these comments and requests, we first
reviewed the
[[Page 23455]]
relevant scientific literature. In particular, we evaluated a 2008
presentation at the International Research Conference on Huanglongbing
by P.T. Yamamoto et al., which examined the efficacy of various
insecticides to control ACP.\5\ Yamamoto and his colleagues found that
the residual effect of imidacloprid and other soil drenches on nursery
stock is considerably longer than previously thought--in certain
instances, as long as 105 days. Yamamoto's research suggests that soil
drenches can be applied up to 90 days and no less than 30 days prior to
shipment, provided that they are coupled with subsequent foliar sprays
no more than 10 days before shipment.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\ Yamamoto, P.T., et al. 2008. Efficiency of Insecticides to
Control Diaphorina citri, Vector of Huanglongbing. T. Gottwald, W.
Dixon, J. Graham, P. Berger, eds. International research conference
on Huanglongbing. Plant Management Network International, Orlando,
Florida. Copies available from the individuals listed under FOR
FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Based on Yamamoto's findings, we evaluated the risk of
dissemination of ACP that would be associated with a regulatory scheme
for the movement of citrus nursery stock from ACP quarantined areas to
areas other than commercial citrus-producing areas under which
inspections of the entire nursery for ACP occurred at set intervals,
soil drenches could be applied up to 90 days before shipment, and
plants were not required to be shipped in sealed containers.
We determined that, under the provisions of this regulatory scheme,
the risk that ACP would be introduced to the plants prior to shipment
would be commensurately greater. Such introduction, however, would not
necessarily lead to further dissemination of ACP within the United
States. Rather, the risk of such dissemination would be directly
correlated to whether the nursery stock transited through commercial
citrus-producing areas, that is, areas where host articles are
prevalent, and climatic conditions are conducive to ACP becoming
established in significant population densities. If the nursery stock
were to transit such areas, as additional mitigation measures, it would
need to be inspected and found free of ACP no more than 72 hours before
shipment and would need to be shipped in a container sealed with an
agricultural seal affixed by an inspector; moreover, the seal would
have to remain affixed throughout transit and be removed by an
inspector at its destination.
Accordingly, paragraph (c) of Sec. 301.76-6 establishes two
separate sets of conditions for issuance of a limited permit for
interstate movement of regulated nursery stock from areas quarantined
for ACP, but not for citrus greening.
In addition to all general conditions for issuance of a limited
permit, paragraphs (c)(1) through (c)(1)(vi) provide that, if the
nursery stock will not be moved through a commercial citrus-producing
area (American Samoa, Arizona, California, Florida, Guam, Hawaii, the
Northern Mariana Islands, Puerto Rico, Texas, or the U.S. Virgin
Islands), an inspector or person operating under a compliance agreement
may issue a permit for the interstate movement of regulated nursery
stock to areas of the United States other than Northern Mariana Islands
or those portions of Arizona and California that are not quarantined
due to the presence of ACP or citrus greening, if:
The nursery in which the nursery stock is produced has
entered into a compliance agreement with APHIS in accordance with Sec.
301.76-8.
All citrus nursery stock at the nursery has been inspected
by an inspector every 30 days, and any findings of ACP during an
inspection have been reported to APHIS immediately.
The nursery stock is treated for ACP with an APHIS-
approved soil drench or in-ground granular application no more than 90
days and no fewer than 30 days before shipment, followed by an APHIS-
approved foliar spray no more than 10 days before shipment. All
treatments must be applied according to their EPA label, including
directions on application, restrictions on place of application and
other restrictions, and precautions, and including statements
pertaining to Worker Protection Standards.
The nursery stock is affixed prior to movement with a
plastic or metal tag on which the statement ``Limited permit: USDA-
APHIS-PPQ. Not for distribution in Northern Mariana Islands or those
portions of AZ and CA not quarantined due to the presence of Asian
citrus psyllid or citrus greening'' is prominently and legibly
displayed on the obverse, and adequate information as determined by
APHIS regarding the identity of the nursery stock and its source of
production to conduct traceback to the nursery in which the nursery
stock was produced is prominently and legibly printed on the reverse.
If the nursery stock is destined for movement or sale in boxes or
containers, the statement and the identifying information may be
printed on the box or container, or printed on a label permanently
affixed to the box or container, provided that, in either case, the
statement and the identifying information are prominently and legibly
displayed.
A copy of the limited permit will be attached to the
consignee's copy of the accompanying waybill.
The nursery stock is shipped in accordance with the
conditions specified on the limited permit to the destination specified
on the permit.
We are requiring that the nursery enter into a compliance agreement
with APHIS in order to ensure, among other things, that the nursery
maintains records of inspections and treatments for APHIS review.
We are requiring the tag on which the limited permit statement is
printed to have adequate information as determined by APHIS regarding
the identity of the nursery stock and its source of production to
conduct traceback to the nursery in which the nursery stock was
produced because, as we noted above, there is some risk under these
regulatory provisions that ACP will be introduced to the nursery stock
at the nursery. In the event that the soil drenches and foliar sprays
do not achieve 100 percent mortality of this ACP prior to movement,
there is a corresponding degree of risk that live ACP may be on the
plants when they reach their point of destination. In such instances,
APHIS will use the information on the tags in order to review the
recordkeeping of the nursery in which the nursery stock was produced.
While this review is ongoing, we will also prohibit the nursery from
shipping articles interstate.
Finally, we are removing the requirement that the nursery stock be
shipped in a sealed container because this regulatory scheme focuses
not on the possibility that a few ACP may be reintroduced into the
nursery stock prior to interstate movement of the plants, but rather on
the likelihood that such reintroduction will result in the artificial
spread of ACP.
Paragraphs (c)(2) through (c)(2)(vi) establish conditions for the
issuance of limited permits for regulated nursery stock that will be
moved through a commercial citrus-producing area to another area. In
addition to the general conditions for issuance of a limited permit, an
inspector or person operating under a compliance agreement may issue a
limited permit for such movement, if:
All conditions for movement of regulated nursery stock in
paragraphs (c)(1)(i) through (c)(1)(vi) of Sec. 301.76-6, that is, all
conditions of the new
[[Page 23456]]
regulatory scheme discussed immediately above, are fulfilled.
The nursery stock is inspected by an inspector on the date
of shipment and found free of ACP.
The nursery stock is completely enclosed in a sealed
container and is moved interstate in that container.
The container prominently and legibly displays the
required limited permit statement and identifying information.
The agricultural seal remains intact throughout movement
to the destination specified on the limited permit.
The agricultural seal is removed at the destination
specified on the limited permit by an inspector.
These revisions to Sec. 301.76-6 entail a nonsubstantive
modification to Sec. 301.76-9. Prior to the publication of this
interim rule, Sec. 301.76-9 had provided, among other things, that all
regulated nursery stock intended for interstate movement for immediate
export from an area quarantined for citrus greening, as well as all
regulated nursery stock treated with soil drenches and foliar sprays
prior to interstate movement from an area quarantined for ACP, but not
for citrus greening, had to be inspected by an inspector no more than
72 hours prior to movement.
However, as we mentioned above, inspections of regulated nursery
stock to be moved interstate under a limited permit must now take place
at set intervals and must be coupled with an inspection on the date of
shipment if the nursery stock will transit such a commercial citrus-
producing area. Accordingly, we are amending Sec. 301.76-9 so that it
now refers only to citrus nursery stock that is intended for interstate
movement for immediate export.
These changes to the citrus canker, citrus greening, and ACP
regulations will provide nursery stock producers in areas quarantined
for citrus canker, citrus greening, or ACP with the ability to ship
regulated nursery stock to markets within the United States that would
otherwise be unavailable to them due to the prohibitions and
restrictions contained in the regulations while continuing to provide
adequate safeguards to prevent the spread of the three pests into
currently unaffected areas of the United States.
Immediate Action
Immediate action is warranted to provide a degree of relief to
existing prohibitions and restrictions on the interstate movement of
regulated nursery stock to certain nurseries who enter into compliance
agreements with APHIS. Specifically, such action will provide producers
with a means to ship regulated nursery stock to previously unavailable
markets within the United States. Under these circumstances, the
Administrator has determined that prior notice and opportunity for
public comment are contrary to the public interest and that there is
good cause under 5 U.S.C. 553 for making this rule effective less than
30 days after publication in the Federal Register.
We will consider comments we receive during the comment period for
this interim rule (see DATES above). After the comment period closes,
we will publish another document in the Federal Register in which we
will respond to the comments we receive and finalize or, as necessary,
revise the provisions of this interim rule. APHIS intends to publish
this follow-up document within 18 months of the publication of this
interim rule.
Executive Order 12866, Executive Order 13563, and the Regulatory
Flexibility Act
This interim rule has been determined to be significant for the
purposes of Executive Order 12866 and, therefore, has been reviewed by
the Office of Management and Budget.
In accordance with 5 U.S.C. 603, we have performed an initial
regulatory flexibility analysis regarding the economic effects of this
rule on small entities. The analysis identifies nurseries that produce
and handle regulated nursery stock as entities potentially affected by
this interim rule. The analysis identifies the primary costs of the
rule as those a nursery would need to assume in order to meet all terms
and provisions of a compliance agreement that it has entered into with
APHIS and that specifies the conditions under which the regulated
nursery stock at the nursery must be grown, maintained, and shipped in
order for it to be moved interstate. While these costs will vary from
nursery to nursery, APHIS has estimated the aggregate cost to the
industry of certain provisions that will be found in every compliance
agreement. We estimate that the total cost to the industry of
constructing enclosed facilities that meet our minimum requirements
will be between $1.3 million and $3.2 million, and that the total cost
of meeting labeling requirements for each plant propagated in such
facilities will be between $119,070 and $340,000. We have determined
that the rule will benefit the citrus industry in the United States by
providing nurseries in quarantined areas with an opportunity for access
to domestic markets that would otherwise be unavailable to them and by
ensuring ongoing production of disease-free plants, which is vital to
the preservation of both the U.S. citrus nursery stock and U.S. citrus
fruit industries.
The full analysis may be viewed on the Regulations.gov Web site
(see ADDRESSES above for instructions for accessing Regulations.gov) or
obtained from the person listed under FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT.
Executive Order 12372
This program/activity is listed in the Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance under No. 10.025 and is subject to Executive Order 12372,
which requires intergovernmental consultation with State and local
officials. (See 7 CFR part 3015, subpart V.)
Executive Order 12988
This rule has been reviewed under Executive Order 12988, Civil
Justice Reform. This rule: (1) Preempts all State and local laws and
regulations that are inconsistent with this rule; (2) has no
retroactive effect; and (3) does not require administrative proceedings
before parties may file suit in court challenging this rule.
Paperwork Reduction Act
In accordance with section 3507(j) of the Paperwork Reduction Act
of 1995 (44 U.S.C. 3501 et seq.), the information collection and
recordkeeping requirements included in this interim rule have been
submitted for emergency approval to the Office of Management and Budget
(OMB). OMB has assigned control number 0579-0369 to the information
collection and recordkeeping requirements.
We plan to request continuation of that approval for 3 years.
Please send written comments on the 3-year approval request to the
following addresses: (1) Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs,
OMB, Attention: Desk Officer for APHIS, Washington, DC 20503; and (2)
Docket No. APHIS-2010-0048, Regulatory Analysis and Development, PPD,
APHIS, Station 3A-03.8, 4700 River Road Unit 118, Riverdale, MD 20737-
1238. Please state that your comments refer to Docket No. APHIS-2010-
0048 and send your comments within 60 days of publication of this rule.
This interim rule will require persons to complete various forms
and documents. These include: Certificates, limited permits, compliance
agreements, records of sales and shipments, and labels.
We are soliciting comments from the public (as well as affected
agencies) concerning our information collection
[[Page 23457]]
and recordkeeping requirements. These comments will help us:
(1) Evaluate whether the information collection is necessary for
the proper performance of our agency's functions, including whether the
information will have practical utility;
(2) Evaluate the accuracy of our estimate of the burden of the
information collection, including the validity of the methodology and
assumptions used;
(3) Enhance the quality, utility, and clarity of the information to
be collected; and
(4) Minimize the burden of the information collection on those who
are to respond (such as through the use of appropriate automated,
electronic, mechanical, or other technological collection techniques or
other forms of information technology; e.g., permitting electronic
submission of responses).
Estimate of burden: Public reporting burden for this collection of
information is estimated to average 0.1441359 hours per response.
Respondents: Nursery owners and operators.
Estimated annual number of respondents: 621.
Estimated annual number of responses per respondent: 21.2270.
Estimated annual number of responses: 13,182.
Estimated total annual burden on respondents: 1,900 hours. (Due to
averaging, the total annual burden hours may not equal the product of
the annual number of responses multiplied by the reporting burden per
response.)
Copies of this information collection can be obtained from Mrs.
Celeste Sickles, APHIS' Information Collection Coordinator, at (301)
851-2908.
E-Government Act Compliance
The Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service is committed to
compliance with the E-Government Act to promote the use of the Internet
and other information technologies, to provide increased opportunities
for citizen access to Government information and services, and for
other purposes. For information pertinent to E-Government Act
compliance related to this interim rule, please contact Mrs. Celeste
Sickles, APHIS' Information Collection Coordinator, at (301) 851-2908.
List of Subjects in 7 CFR Part 301
Agricultural commodities, Plant diseases and pests, Quarantine,
Reporting and recordkeeping requirements, Transportation.
Accordingly, we are amending 7 CFR part 301 as follows:
PART 301--DOMESTIC QUARANTINE NOTICES
0
1. The authority citation for part 301 continues to read as follows:
Authority: 7 U.S.C. 7701-7772 and 7781-7786; 7 CFR 2.22, 2.80,
and 371.3.
Section 301.75-15 issued under Sec. 204, Title II, Public Law
106-113, 113 Stat. 1501A-293; sections 301.75-15 and 301.75-16
issued under Sec. 203, Title II, Public Law 106-224, 114 Stat. 400
(7 U.S.C. 1421 note).
Sec. 301.75-1 [Amended]
0
2. In Sec. 301.75-1, the definition of compliance agreement is amended
by removing the words ``growing or handling'' and adding the words
``growing, maintaining, processing, handling, packing, or moving'' in
their place.
0
3. Section 301.75-6 is amended as follows:
0
a. By revising paragraph (a) to read as set forth below.
0
b. By redesignating paragraph (c) as paragraph (d).
0
c. By adding a new paragraph (c) and a new footnote 1 to read as set
forth below.
0
d. In newly redesignated paragraph (d), by adding the words ``or
paragraph (c)'' after the words ``paragraph (b)''.
0
e. By adding the OMB citation ``(Approved by the Office of Management
and Budget under control number 0579-0369)'' at the end of the section.
Sec. 301.75-6 Interstate movement of regulated nursery stock from a
quarantined area.
(a) Regulated nursery stock may not be moved interstate from a
quarantined area unless such movement is authorized in this section.
* * * * *
(c) Regulated nursery stock produced in a nursery within