Horizon Funds and Horizon Investments, LLC, 63302-63305 [2020-22111]

Agencies

• SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION

[Federal Register Volume 85, Number 195 (Wednesday, October 7, 2020)]
[Notices]
[Pages 63302-63305]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2020-22111]


=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION

[Investment Company Act Release No. 34039; 812-15089]


Horizon Funds and Horizon Investments, LLC

October 1, 2020.
AGENCY: Securities and Exchange Commission (``Commission'').

ACTION: Notice.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

    Notice of an application under section 6(c) of the Investment 
Company Act of 1940 (``Act'') for an exemption from section 15(a) of 
the Act, as well as from certain disclosure requirements in rule 20a-1 
under the Act, Item 19(a)(3) of Form N-1A, Items 22(c)(1)(ii), 
22(c)(1)(iii), 22(c)(8) and 22(c)(9) of Schedule 14A under the 
Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (``1934 Act''), and sections 6-
07(2)(a), (b), and (c) of Regulation S-X (``Disclosure Requirements'').

Applicants: Horizon Funds (the ``Trust''), a Delaware statutory trust 
registered under the Act as an open-end management investment company 
with multiple series (each a ``Fund'') and Horizon Investments, LLC 
(the ``Initial Adviser''), a South Carolina limited liability company 
registered as an investment adviser under the Investment Advisers Act 
of 1940 (``Advisers Act'') that serves an investment adviser to the 
Funds (collectively with the Trust, the ``Applicants'').

Summary of Application: The requested exemption would permit Applicants 
to enter into and materially amend subadvisory agreements with 
subadvisers without shareholder approval and would grant relief from 
the Disclosure Requirements as they relate to fees paid to the 
subadvisers.

Filing Dates: The application was filed on January 10, 2020, and 
amended on July 6, 2020.

Hearing or Notification of Hearing: An order granting the requested 
relief will be issued unless the Commission orders a hearing. 
Interested persons may request a hearing by emailing the Commission's 
Secretary at [email protected] and serving applicants with a 
copy of the request by email. Hearing requests should be received by 
the Commission by 5:30 p.m. on October 26, 2020, and should be 
accompanied by proof of service on the applicants, in the form of an 
affidavit, or, for lawyers, a certificate of service. Pursuant to rule 
0-5 under the Act, hearing requests should state the nature of the 
writer's interest, any facts bearing upon the desirability of a hearing 
on the matter, the reason for the request, and the issues contested. 
Persons who wish to be notified of a hearing may request notification 
by emailing the Commission's Secretary at [email protected].

ADDRESSES: The Commission: [email protected]. The Trust and the 
Initial Adviser: 6210 Ardrey Kell Road, Suite 300, Charlotte, NC 28277.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Christine Y. Greenlees, Senior 
Counsel, at (202) 551-6879, or Daniele Marchesani, Assistant Chief 
Counsel at (202) 551-6821 (Division of Investment Management, Chief 
Counsel's Office).

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The following is a summary of the 
application. The complete application may be obtained via the 
Commission's website by searching for the file number or an Applicant 
using the ``Company'' name box, at https://www.sec.gov/search/search.htm 
or by calling (202) 551-8090.

I. Requested Exemptive Relief

    1. Applicants request an order to permit the Adviser,\1\ subject to 
the approval of the board of trustees of the Trust (collectively, the 
``Board''),\2\ including a majority of the trustees who are not 
``interested persons'' of the Trust or the Adviser, as defined in 
section 2(a)(19) of the Act (the ``Independent Trustees''), without 
obtaining shareholder approval, to: (i) Select investment sub-advisers 
(``Sub-Advisers'') for all or a portion of the assets of one or more of 
the Funds pursuant to an investment sub-advisory

[[Page 63303]]

agreement with each Sub-Adviser (each a ``Sub-Advisory Agreement''); 
and (ii) materially amend Sub-Advisory Agreements with the Sub-
Advisers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \1\ The term ``Adviser'' means (i) the Initial Adviser, (ii) its 
successors, and (iii) any entity controlling, controlled by or under 
common control with, the Initial Adviser or its successors that 
serves as the primary adviser to a Sub-Advised Fund (as defined 
below). For the purposes of the requested order, ``successor'' is 
limited to an entity that results from a reorganization into another 
jurisdiction or a change in the type of business organization.
    \2\ The term ``Board'' also includes the board of trustees or 
directors of a future Sub-Advised Fund (as defined below), if 
different from the board of trustees of the Trust.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    2. Applicants also request an order exempting the Sub-Advised Funds 
(as defined below) from the Disclosure Requirements, which require each 
Fund to disclose fees paid to a Sub-Adviser. Applicants seek relief to 
permit each Sub-Advised Fund to disclose (as a dollar amount and a 
percentage of the Fund's net assets): (i) The aggregate fees paid to 
the Adviser and any Wholly-Owned Sub-Advisers; and (ii) the aggregate 
fees paid to Affiliated and Non-Affiliated Sub-Advisers (``Aggregate 
Fee Disclosure'').\3\ Applicants seek an exemption to permit a Sub-
Advised Fund to include only the Aggregate Fee Disclosure.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \3\ A ``Wholly-Owned Sub-Adviser'' is any investment adviser 
that is (1) an indirect or direct ``wholly-owned subsidiary'' (as 
such term is defined in section 2(a)(43) of the 1940 Act) of the 
Adviser, (2) a ``sister company'' of the Adviser that is an indirect 
or direct ``wholly-owned subsidiary'' of the same company that 
indirectly or directly wholly owns the Adviser (the Adviser's 
``parent company''), or (3) a parent company of the Adviser. A 
``Non-Affiliated Sub-Adviser'' is any investment adviser that is not 
an ``affiliated person'' (as defined in the 1940 Act) of a Fund or 
the Adviser, except to the extent that an affiliation arises solely 
because the Sub-Adviser serves as a sub-adviser to one or more 
Funds. Section 2(a)(43) of the 1940 Act defines ``wholly-owned 
subsidiary'' of a person as a company 95 per centum or more of the 
outstanding voting securities of which are, directly or indirectly, 
owned by such a person.
    \4\ Applicants note that all other items required by sections 6-
07(2)(a), (b) and (c) of Regulation S-X will be disclosed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    3. Applicants request that the relief apply to Applicants, as well 
as to any future Fund and any other existing or future registered open-
end management investment company or series thereof that intends to 
rely on the requested order in the future and that: (i) Is advised by 
the Adviser; (ii) uses the multi-manager structure described in the 
application; and (iii) complies with the terms and conditions of the 
application (each, a ``Sub-Advised Fund'').\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \5\ All registered open-end investment companies that currently 
intend to rely on the requested order are named as Applicants. Any 
entity that relies on the requested order will do so only in 
accordance with the terms and conditions contained in the 
application.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

II. Management of the Sub-Advised Funds

    4. The Adviser serves or will serve as the investment adviser to 
each Sub-Advised Fund pursuant to an investment advisory agreement with 
the Fund (each an ``Investment Advisory Agreement''). Each Investment 
Advisory Agreement has been or will be approved by the Board, including 
a majority of the Independent Trustees, and by the shareholders of the 
relevant Sub-Advised Fund in the manner required by sections 15(a) and 
15(c) of the Act. The terms of these Investment Advisory Agreements 
comply or will comply with section 15(a) of the Act. Applicants are not 
seeking an exemption from the Act with respect to the Investment 
Advisory Agreements. Pursuant to the terms of each Investment Advisory 
Agreement, the Adviser, subject to the oversight of the Board, will 
provide continuous investment management for each Sub-Advised Fund. For 
its services to each Sub-Advised Fund, the Adviser receives or will 
receive an investment advisory fee from that Fund as specified in the 
applicable Investment Advisory Agreement.
    5. Consistent with the terms of each Investment Advisory Agreement, 
the Adviser may, subject to the approval of the Board, including a 
majority of the Independent Trustees, and the shareholders of the 
applicable Sub-Advised Fund (if required by applicable law), delegate 
portfolio management responsibilities of all or a portion of the assets 
of a Sub-Advised Fund to a Sub-Adviser. The Adviser will retain overall 
responsibility for the management and investment of the assets of each 
Sub-Advised Fund. This responsibility includes recommending the removal 
or replacement of Sub-Advisers, allocating the portion of that Sub-
Advised Fund's assets to any given Sub-Adviser and reallocating those 
assets as necessary from time to time.\6\ The Sub-Advisers will be 
``investment advisers'' to the Sub-Advised Funds within the meaning of 
section 2(a)(20) of the Act and will provide investment management 
services to the Funds subject to, without limitation, the requirements 
of sections 15(c) and 36(b) of the Act.\7\ The Sub-Advisers, subject to 
the oversight of the Adviser and the Board, will determine the 
securities and other investments to be purchased, sold or entered into 
by a Sub-Advised Fund's portfolio or a portion thereof, and will place 
orders with brokers or dealers that they select.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \6\ Applicants represent that if the name of any Sub-Advised 
Fund contains the name of a sub-adviser, the name of the Adviser 
that serves as the primary adviser to the Fund, or a trademark or 
trade name that is owned by or publicly used to identify the 
Adviser, will precede the name of the sub-adviser.
    \7\ The Sub-Advisers will be registered with the Commission as 
an investment adviser under the Advisers Act or not subject to such 
registration.
    \8\ A ``Sub-Adviser'' also includes an investment sub-adviser 
that provides or will provide the Adviser with a model portfolio 
reflecting a specific strategy, style or focus with respect to the 
investment of all or a portion of a Sub-Advised Fund's assets. The 
Adviser may use the model portfolio to determine the securities and 
other instruments to be purchased, sold or entered into by a Sub-
Advised Fund's portfolio or a portion thereof, and place orders with 
brokers or dealers that it selects.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    6. The Sub-Advisory Agreements will be approved by the Board, 
including a majority of the Independent Trustees, in accordance with 
sections 15(a) and 15(c) of the Act. In addition, the terms of each 
Sub-Advisory Agreement will comply fully with the requirements of 
section 15(a) of the Act. The Adviser may compensate the Sub-Advisers 
or the Sub-Advised Funds may compensate the Sub-Advisers directly.
    7. Sub-Advised Funds will inform shareholders of the hiring of a 
new Sub-Adviser pursuant to the following procedures (``Modified Notice 
and Access Procedures''): (a) Within 90 days after a new Sub-Adviser is 
hired for any Sub-Advised Fund, that Fund will send its shareholders 
either a Multi-manager Notice or a Multi-manager Notice and Multi-
manager Information Statement; \9\ and (b) the Sub-Advised Fund will 
make the Multi-manager Information Statement available on the website 
identified in the Multi-manager Notice no later than when the Multi-
manager Notice (or Multi-manager Notice and Multi-manager Information 
Statement) is first sent to shareholders, and will maintain it on that 
website for at least 90 days.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \9\ A ``Multi-manager Notice'' will be modeled on a Notice of 
internet Availability as defined in Rule 14a-16 under the 1934 Act, 
and specifically will, among other things: (a) Summarize the 
relevant information regarding the new Sub-Adviser (except as 
modified to permit Aggregate Fee Disclosure); (b) inform 
shareholders that the Multi-manager Information Statement is 
available on a website; (c) provide the website address; (d) state 
the time period during which the Multi-manager Information Statement 
will remain available on that website; (e) provide instructions for 
accessing and printing the Multi-manager Information Statement; and 
(f) instruct the shareholder that a paper or email copy of the 
Multi-manager Information Statement may be obtained, without charge, 
by contacting the Sub-Advised Fund. A ``Multi-manager Information 
Statement'' will meet the requirements of Regulation 14C, Schedule 
14C and Item 22 of Schedule 14A under the 1934 Act for an 
information statement, except as modified by the requested order to 
permit Aggregate Fee Disclosure. Multi-manager Information 
Statements will be filed with the Commission via the EDGAR system.
    \10\ In addition, Applicants represent that whenever a Sub-
Adviser is hired or terminated, or a Sub-Advisory Agreement is 
materially amended, the Sub-Advised Fund's prospectus and statement 
of additional information will be supplemented promptly pursuant to 
rule 497(e) under the Securities Act of 1933.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

III. Applicable Law

    8. Section 15(a) of the Act states, in part, that it is unlawful 
for any person to act as an investment adviser to a registered 
investment company ``except pursuant to a written contract, which 
contract, whether with such registered

[[Page 63304]]

company or with an investment adviser of such registered company, has 
been approved by the vote of a majority of the outstanding voting 
securities of such registered company.''
    9. Form N-1A is the registration statement used by open-end 
investment companies. Item 19(a)(3) of Form N-1A requires a registered 
investment company to disclose in its statement of additional 
information the method of computing the ``advisory fee payable'' by the 
investment company with respect to each investment adviser, including 
the total dollar amounts that the investment company ``paid to the 
adviser (aggregated with amounts paid to affiliated advisers, if any), 
and any advisers who are not affiliated persons of the adviser, under 
the investment advisory contract for the last three fiscal years.''
    10. Rule 20a-1 under the Act requires proxies solicited with 
respect to a registered investment company to comply with Schedule 14A 
under the 1934 Act. Items 22(c)(1)(ii), 22(c)(1)(iii), 22(c)(8) and 
22(c)(9) of Schedule 14A, taken together, require a proxy statement for 
a shareholder meeting at which the advisory contract will be voted upon 
to include the ``rate of compensation of the investment adviser,'' the 
``aggregate amount of the investment adviser's fee,'' a description of 
the ``terms of the contract to be acted upon,'' and, if a change in the 
advisory fee is proposed, the existing and proposed fees and the 
difference between the two fees.
    11. Regulation S-X sets forth the requirements for financial 
statements required to be included as part of a registered investment 
company's registration statement and shareholder reports filed with the 
Commission. Sections 6-07(2)(a), (b), and (c) of Regulation S-X require 
a registered investment company to include in its financial statements 
information about investment advisory fees.
    12. Section 6(c) of the Act provides that the Commission may exempt 
any person, security, or transaction or any class or classes of 
persons, securities, or transactions from any provisions of the Act, or 
any rule thereunder, if such exemption is necessary or appropriate in 
the public interest and consistent with the protection of investors and 
the purposes fairly intended by the policy and provisions of the Act. 
Applicants state that the requested relief meets this standard for the 
reasons discussed below.

IV. Arguments in Support of the Requested Relief

    13. Applicants assert that, from the perspective of the 
shareholder, the role of the Sub-Advisers is substantially equivalent 
to the limited role of the individual portfolio managers employed by an 
investment adviser to a traditional investment company. Applicants also 
assert that the shareholders expect the Adviser, subject to review and 
approval of the Board, to select a Sub-Adviser who is in the best 
position to achieve the Sub-Advised Fund's investment objective. 
Applicants believe that permitting the Adviser to perform the duties 
for which the shareholders of the Sub-Advised Fund are paying the 
Adviser--the selection, oversight and evaluation of the Sub-Adviser--
without incurring unnecessary delays or expenses of convening special 
meetings of shareholders is appropriate and in the interest of the 
Fund's shareholders, and will allow such Fund to operate more 
efficiently. Applicants state that each Investment Advisory Agreement 
will continue to be fully subject to section 15(a) of the Act and 
approved by the relevant Board, including a majority of the Independent 
Trustees, in the manner required by section 15(a) and 15(c) of the Act.
    14. Applicants submit that the requested relief meets the standards 
for relief under section 6(c) of the Act. Applicants state that the 
operation of the Sub-Advised Fund in the manner described in the 
Application must be approved by shareholders of that Fund before it may 
rely on the requested relief. Applicants also state that the proposed 
conditions to the requested relief are designed to address any 
potential conflicts of interest or economic incentives, and provide 
that shareholders are informed when new Sub-Advisers are hired.
    15. Applicants contend that, in the circumstances described in the 
application, a proxy solicitation to approve the appointment of new 
Sub-Advisers provides no more meaningful information to shareholders 
than the proposed Multi-manager Information Statement. Applicants state 
that, accordingly, they believe the requested relief is necessary or 
appropriate in the public interest, and consistent with the protection 
of investors and the purposes fairly intended by the policy and 
provisions of the Act.
    16. With respect to the relief permitting Aggregate Fee Disclosure, 
Applicants assert that disclosure of the individual fees paid to the 
Sub-Advisers does not serve any meaningful purpose. Applicants contend 
that the primary reasons for requiring disclosure of individual fees 
paid to Sub-Advisers are to inform shareholders of expenses to be 
charged by a particular Sub-Advised Fund and to enable shareholders to 
compare the fees to those of other comparable investment companies. 
Applicants believe that the requested relief satisfies these objectives 
because the Sub-Advised Fund's overall advisory fee will be fully 
disclosed and, therefore, shareholders will know what the Sub-Advised 
Fund's fees and expenses are and will be able to compare the advisory 
fees a Sub-Advised Fund is charged to those of other investment 
companies. In addition, Applicants assert that the requested relief 
would benefit shareholders of the Sub-Advised Fund because it would 
improve the Adviser's ability to negotiate the fees paid to Sub-
Advisers. In particular, Applicants state that if the Adviser is not 
required to disclose the Sub-Advisers' fees to the public, the Adviser 
may be able to negotiate rates that are below a Sub-Adviser's 
``posted'' amounts. Applicants assert that the relief will also 
encourage Sub-Advisers to negotiate lower sub-advisory fees with the 
Adviser if the lower fees are not required to be made public.

V. Relief for Affiliated Sub-Advisers

    17. The Commission has granted the requested relief with respect to 
Wholly-Owned and Non-Affiliated Sub-Advisers through numerous exemptive 
orders. The Commission also has extended the requested relief to 
Affiliated Sub-Advisers.\11\ Applicants state that although the 
Adviser's judgment in recommending a Sub-Adviser can be affected by 
certain conflicts, they do not warrant denying the extension of the 
requested relief to Affiliated Sub-Advisers. Specifically, the Adviser 
faces those conflicts in allocating fund assets between itself and a 
Sub-Adviser, and across Sub-Advisers, as it has an interest in 
considering the benefit it will receive, directly or indirectly, from 
the fee the Sub-Advised Fund pays for the management of those assets. 
Applicants also state that to the extent the Adviser has a conflict of 
interest with respect to the selection of an Affiliated Sub-Adviser, 
the proposed conditions are protective of shareholder interests by 
ensuring the Board's independence and providing the Board with the 
appropriate resources and

[[Page 63305]]

information to monitor and address conflicts.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \11\ See Carillon Series Trust and Carillon Tower Advisers, 
Inc., Investment Company Act Rel. Nos. 33464 (May 2, 2019) (notice) 
and 33494 (May 29, 2019) (order).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    18. With respect to the relief permitting Aggregate Fee Disclosure, 
Applicants assert that it is appropriate to disclose only aggregate 
fees paid to Affiliated Sub-Advisers for the same reasons that similar 
relief has been granted previously with respect to Wholly-Owned and 
Non-Affiliated Sub-Advisers.

VI. Applicants' Conditions

    Applicants agree that any order granting the requested relief will 
be subject to the following conditions:
    1. Before a Sub-Advised Fund may rely on the order requested in the 
Application, the operation of the Sub-Advised Fund in the manner 
described in the Application will be, or has been, approved by a 
majority of the Sub-Advised Fund's outstanding voting securities as 
defined in the Act, or, in the case of a Sub-Advised Fund whose public 
shareholders purchase shares on the basis of a prospectus containing 
the disclosure contemplated by condition 2 below, by the initial 
shareholder before such Sub-Advised Fund's shares are offered to the 
public.
    2. The prospectus for each Sub-Advised Fund will disclose the 
existence, substance and effect of any order granted pursuant to the 
Application. In addition, each Sub-Advised Fund will hold itself out to 
the public as employing the multi-manager structure described in the 
Application. The prospectus will prominently disclose that the Adviser 
has the ultimate responsibility, subject to oversight by the Board, to 
oversee the Sub-Advisers and recommend their hiring, termination, and 
replacement.
    3. The Adviser will provide general management services to each 
Sub-Advised Fund, including overall supervisory responsibility for the 
general management and investment of the Sub-Advised Fund's assets, and 
subject to review and oversight of the Board, will (i) set the Sub-
Advised Fund's overall investment strategies, (ii) evaluate, select, 
and recommend Sub-Advisers for all or a portion of the Sub-Advised 
Fund's assets, (iii) allocate and, when appropriate, reallocate the 
Sub-Advised Fund's assets among Sub-Advisers, (iv) monitor and evaluate 
the Sub-Advisers' performance, and (v) implement procedures reasonably 
designed to ensure that Sub-Advisers comply with the Sub-Advised Fund's 
investment objective, policies and restrictions.
    4. Sub-Advised Funds will inform shareholders of the hiring of a 
new Sub-Adviser within 90 days after the hiring of the new Sub-Adviser 
pursuant to the Modified Notice and Access Procedures.
    5. At all times, at least a majority of the Board will be 
Independent Trustees, and the selection and nomination of new or 
additional Independent Trustees will be placed within the discretion of 
the then-existing Independent Trustees.
    6. Independent Legal Counsel, as defined in Rule 0-1(a)(6) under 
the Act, will be engaged to represent the Independent Trustees. The 
selection of such counsel will be within the discretion of the then-
existing Independent Trustees.
    7. Whenever a Sub-Adviser is hired or terminated, the Adviser will 
provide the Board with information showing the expected impact on the 
profitability of the Adviser.
    8. The Board must evaluate any material conflicts that may be 
present in a sub-advisory arrangement. Specifically, whenever a sub-
adviser change is proposed for a Sub-Advised Fund (``Sub-Adviser 
Change'') or the Board considers an existing Sub-Advisory Agreement as 
part of its annual review process (``Sub-Adviser Review''):
    (a) The Adviser will provide the Board, to the extent not already 
being provided pursuant to section 15(c) of the Act, with all relevant 
information concerning:
    (i) Any material interest in the proposed new Sub-Adviser, in the 
case of a Sub-Adviser Change, or the Sub-Adviser in the case of a Sub-
Adviser Review, held directly or indirectly by the Adviser or a parent 
or sister company of the Adviser, and any material impact the proposed 
Sub-Advisory Agreement may have on that interest;
    (ii) any arrangement or understanding in which the Adviser or any 
parent or sister company of the Adviser is a participant that (A) may 
have had a material effect on the proposed Sub-Adviser Change or Sub-
Adviser Review, or (B) may be materially affected by the proposed Sub-
Adviser Change or Sub-Adviser Review;
    (iii) any material interest in a Sub-Adviser held directly or 
indirectly by an officer or Trustee of the Sub-Advised Fund, or an 
officer or board member of the Adviser (other than through a pooled 
investment vehicle not controlled by such person); and
    (iv) any other information that may be relevant to the Board in 
evaluating any potential material conflicts of interest in the proposed 
Sub-Adviser Change or Sub-Adviser Review.
    (b) the Board, including a majority of the Independent Trustees, 
will make a separate finding, reflected in the Board minutes, that the 
Sub-Adviser Change or continuation after Sub-Adviser Review is in the 
best interests of the Sub-Advised Fund and its shareholders and, based 
on the information provided to the Board, does not involve a conflict 
of interest from which the Adviser, a Sub-Adviser, any officer or 
Trustee of the Sub-Advised Fund, or any officer or board member of the 
Adviser derives an inappropriate advantage.
    9. Each Sub-Advised Fund will disclose in its registration 
statement the Aggregate Fee Disclosure.
    10. In the event that the Commission adopts a rule under the Act 
providing substantially similar relief to that in the order requested 
in the Application, the requested order will expire on the effective 
date of that rule.
    11. Any new Sub-Advisory Agreement or any amendment to an existing 
Investment Advisory Agreement or Sub-Advisory Agreement that directly 
or indirectly results in an increase in the aggregate advisory fee rate 
payable by the Sub-Advised Fund will be submitted to the Sub-Advised 
Fund's shareholders for approval.

    For the Commission, by the Division of Investment Management, 
under delegated authority.
J. Matthew DeLesDernier,
Assistant Secretary.
[FR Doc. 2020-22111 Filed 10-6-20; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 8011-01-P