Wisconsin Administrative Code
Department of Natural Resources
NR 400-499 - Environmental Protection - Air Pollution Control
Chapter NR 466 - National emission standards for hazardous air pollutants for printing and flexible substrate surface coating processes
Subchapter III - Paper and Other Web Coating
Section NR 466.25 - Requirements for showing compliance
Current through August 26, 2024
(1) SUMMARY. A summary of how you shall demonstrate compliance with the emission standards follows:
Compliance Demonstration
If you choose to demonstrate compliance by: |
Then you shall demonstrate that: |
Using these procedures: |
(a) Use of "as-purchased" compliant coating materials. |
1. Each coating material used at an existing affected source does not exceed 0.04 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating material, and each coating material used at a new affected source does not exceed 0.016 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating material as purchased; or 2. Each coating material used at an existing affected source does not exceed 0.2 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating solids, and each coating material used at a new affected source does not exceed 0.08 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating solids as purchased. |
Follow the procedures set out in sub. (2). Follow the procedures set out in sub. (2). |
(b) Use of "as-applied" compliant coating materials. |
1. Each coating material used at an existing affected source does not exceed 0.04 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating material, and each coating material used at a new affected source does not exceed 0.016 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating material as applied; or 2. Each coating material used at an existing affected source does not exceed 0.2 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating solids, and each coating material used at a new affected source does not exceed 0.08 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating solids as applied; or |
Follow the procedures set out in sub. (3) (a). Use either Equation 1a or b of this section to determine compliance with s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 2. in accordance with sub. (3) (e) 1. Follow the procedures set out in sub. (3) (b). Use Equations 2 and 3 of this section to determine compliance with s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 3. in accordance with sub. (3) (e) 1. |
3. Monthly average of all coating materials used at an existing affected source does not exceed 0.04 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating material, and monthly average of all coating materials used at a new affected source does not exceed 0.016 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating material as applied on a monthly average basis; or |
Follow the procedures set out in sub. (3) (c). Use Equation 4 of this section to determine compliance with s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 2. in accordance with sub. (3) (e) 2. |
|
4. Monthly average of all coating materials used at an existing affected source does not exceed 0.2 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating solids, and monthly average of all coating materials used at a new affected source does not exceed 0.08 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating solids as applied on a monthly average basis. |
Follow the procedures set out in sub. (3) (d). Use Equation 5 of this section to determine compliance with s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 3. in accordance with sub. (3) (e) 2. |
|
(c) Tracking total monthly organic HAP applied. |
Total monthly organic HAP applied does not exceed the calculated limit based on emission limitations. |
Follow the procedures set out in sub. (4). Show that total monthly HAP applied, calculated using Equation 6 of this section, is less than the equivalent allowable organic HAP calculated using Equation 13a or b of this section. |
(d) Use of a capture system and control device. |
1. Overall organic HAP control efficiency is equal to 95% at an existing affected source and 98% at a new affected source on a monthly basis; or oxidizer outlet organic HAP concentration is no greater than 20 ppmv by compound and capture efficiency is 100%; or operating parameters are continuously monitored; or |
Follow the procedures set out in sub. (5) to determine compliance with s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 1. according to sub. (9) if using a solvent recovery device or sub. (10) if a using control device and CPMS or sub. (11) if using an oxidizer. |
2. Overall organic HAP emission rate does not exceed 0.2 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating solids for an existing affected source or 0.08 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating solids for a new affected source on a monthly average as-applied basis; or |
Follow the procedures set out in sub. (6) to determine compliance with s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 3. according to sub. (9) if using a solvent recovery device or sub. (11) if using an oxidizer. |
|
3. Overall organic HAP emission rate does not exceed 0.04 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating material for an existing affected source or 0.016 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating material for a new affected source on a monthly average as-applied basis; or |
Follow the procedures set out in sub. (7) to determine compliance with s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 2. according to sub. (9) if using a solvent recovery device or sub. (11) if using an oxidizer. |
|
4. Overall organic HAP emission rate does not exceed the calculated limit based on emission limitations. |
Follow the procedures set out in sub. (8). Show that the monthly organic HAP emission rate is less than the equivalent allowable organic HAP emission rate calculated using Equation 13a or b of this section. Calculate the monthly organic HAP emission rate according to sub. (9) if using a solvent recovery device or sub. (11) if using an oxidizer. |
|
(e) Use of multiple capture devices, multiple control devices or both. |
1. Overall organic HAP control efficiency is equal to 95% at an existing affected source and 98% at a new affected source on a monthly basis; or |
Follow the procedures set out in sub. (5) to determine compliance with s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 1. according to sub. (5) (a) or (b). |
2. Average equivalent organic HAP emission rate does not exceed 0.2 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating solids for an existing affected source or 0.08 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating solids for a new affected source on a monthly average as-applied basis; or |
Follow the procedures set out in sub. (6) to determine compliance with s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 3. according to sub. (14). |
|
3. Average equivalent organic HAP emission rate does not exceed 0.04 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating material for an existing affected source or 0.016 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating material for a new affected source on a monthly average as-applied basis; or |
Follow the procedures set out in sub. (7) to determine compliance with s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 2. according to sub. (14). |
|
4. Average equivalent organic HAP emission rate does not exceed the calculated limit based on emission limitations. |
Follow the procedures set out in sub. (8). Show that the monthly organic HAP emission rate is less than the equivalent allowable organic HAP emission rate calculated using Equation 13a or b of this section according to sub. (14). |
|
(f) Use of a combination of compliant coatings and control devices. |
1. Average equivalent organic HAP emission rate does not exceed 0.2 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating solids for an existing affected source or 0.08 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating solids for a new affected source on a monthly average as-applied basis; or |
Follow the procedures set out in sub. (6) to determine compliance with s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 3. according to sub. (14). |
2. Average equivalent organic HAP emission rate does not exceed 0.04 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating material for an existing affected source or 0.016 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating material for a new affected source on a monthly average as-applied basis; or |
Follow the procedures set out in sub. (7) to determine compliance with s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 2. according to sub. (14). |
|
3. Average equivalent organic HAP emission rate does not exceed the calculated limit based on emission limitations. |
Follow the procedures set out in sub. (8). Show that the monthly organic HAP emission rate is less than the equivalent allowable organic HAP emission rate calculated using Equation 13a or b of this section according to sub. (14). |
(2) AS-PURCHASED "COMPLIANT" COATING MATERIALS.
(3) AS-APPLIED "COMPLIANT" COATING MATERIALS. If you comply by using coating materials that meet the emission standards in s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 2. or 3. as-applied, you shall demonstrate compliance by following one of the procedures in pars. (a) to (d). You shall determine compliance in accordance with par. (e).
where:
Cahi is the monthly average, as-applied, organic HAP content of coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Chi is the organic HAP content of coating material, i, as-purchased, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Mi is the mass of as-purchased coating material, i, applied in a month, kg
q is the number of different materials added to the coating material
Chij is the organic HAP content of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Mij is the mass of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, in a month, kg
Mi is the mass of as-purchased coating material, i, applied in a month, kg
where:
Cavi is the monthly average, as-applied, volatile organic content of coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Cvi is the volatile organic content of coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Mi is the mass of as-purchased coating material, i, applied in a month, kg
q is the number of different materials added to the coating material
Cvij is the volatile organic content of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Mij is the mass of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, in a month, kg
where:
Csi is the coating solids content of coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Mi is the mass of as-purchased coating material, i, applied in a month, kg
q is the number of different materials added to the coating material
Csij is the coating solids content of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, expressed as a mass-fraction, kg/kg
Mij is the mass of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, in a month, kg
where:
Hsi is the as-applied, organic HAP to coating solids ratio of coating material, i
Cahi is the monthly average, as-applied, organic HAP content of coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Casi is the monthly average, as-applied, coating solids content of coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
where:
HL is the monthly average, as-applied, organic HAP content of all coating materials applied, expressed as kg organic HAP per kg of coating material applied
p is the number of different coating materials applied in a month
Chi is the organic HAP content of coating material, i, as-purchased, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Mi is the mass of as-purchased coating material, i, applied in a month, kg
q is the number of different materials added to the coating material
Chij is the organic HAP content of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Mij is the mass of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, in a month, kg
Mvret is the mass of volatile matter retained in the coated web after curing or drying, or otherwise not emitted to the atmosphere, kg. The value of this term will be zero in all cases except where you choose to take into account the volatile matter retained in the coated web or otherwise not emitted to the atmosphere for the compliance demonstration procedures in this section.
where:
Hs is the monthly average, as-applied, organic HAP to coating solids ratio, kg of organic HAP per kg of coating solids applied
p is the number of different coating materials applied in a month
Chi is the organic HAP content of coating material, i, as-purchased, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Mi is the mass of as-purchased coating material, i, applied in a month, kg
q is the number of different materials added to the coating material
Chij is the organic HAP content of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Mij is the mass of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, in a month, kg
Mvret is the mass of volatile matter retained in the coated web after curing or drying, or otherwise not emitted to the atmosphere, kg. The value of this term will be zero in all cases except where you choose to take into account the volatile matter retained in the coated web or otherwise not emitted to the atmosphere for the compliance demonstration procedures in this section.
Csi is the coating solids content of coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Csij is the coating solids content of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, expressed as a mass-fraction, kg/kg
(4) MONTHLY ALLOWABLE ORGANIC HAP APPLIED. Demonstrate that the total monthly organic HAP applied as determined by Equation 6 is less than the calculated equivalent allowable organic HAP as determined by Equation 13a or b in sub. (12) (e):
where:
Hm is the total monthly organic HAP applied, kg
p is the number of different coating materials applied in a month
Chi is the organic HAP content of coating material, i, as-purchased, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Mi is the mass of as-purchased coating material, i, applied in a month, kg
q is the number of different materials added to the coating material
Chij is the organic HAP content of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Mij is the mass of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, in a month, kg
Mvret is the mass of volatile matter retained in the coated web after curing or drying, or otherwise not emitted to the atmosphere, kg. The value of this term will be zero in all cases except where you choose to take into account the volatile matter retained in the coated web or otherwise not emitted to the atmosphere for the compliance demonstration procedures in this section.
(5) CAPTURE AND CONTROL TO REDUCE EMISSIONS TO NO MORE THAN ALLOWABLE LIMIT. To reduce emissions to no more than the allowable limit in s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 1., operate a capture system and control device and demonstrate an overall organic HAP control efficiency of at least 95% at an existing affected source and at least 98% at a new affected source for each month, or operate a capture system and oxidizer so that an outlet organic HAP concentration of no greater than 20 ppmv by compound on a dry basis is achieved as long as the capture efficiency is 100% as detailed in s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 4. Unless one of the cases described in par. (a), (b) or (c) applies to the affected source, you shall either demonstrate compliance in accordance with the procedure in sub. (9) when emissions from the affected source are controlled by a solvent recovery device, or the procedure in sub. (11) when emissions are controlled by an oxidizer or demonstrate compliance for a web coating line by operating each capture system and each control device and continuous parameter monitoring according to the procedures in sub. (10).
(6) CAPTURE AND CONTROL TO ACHIEVE MASS FRACTION OF COATING SOLIDS APPLIED LIMIT. To achieve the mass fraction of coating solids applied limit in s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 3., operate a capture system and control device and limit the organic HAP emission rate from an existing affected source to no more than 0.20 kg of organic HAP emitted per kg of coating solids applied, and from a new affected source to no more than 0.08 kg of organic HAP emitted per kg of coating solids applied as determined on a monthly average as-applied basis. If the affected source operates more than one capture system, more than one control device, one or more never-controlled work stations or one or more intermittently-controlled work stations, you shall demonstrate compliance in accordance with the provisions of sub. (14). Otherwise, you shall demonstrate compliance following the procedure in sub. (9) when emissions from the affected source are controlled by a solvent recovery device or the procedure in sub. (11) when emissions are controlled by an oxidizer.
(7) CAPTURE AND CONTROL TO ACHIEVE MASS FRACTION LIMIT. To achieve the mass fraction limit in s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 2., operate a capture system and control device and limit the organic HAP emission rate to no more than 0.04 kg of organic HAP emitted per kg of coating material applied at an existing affected source, and no more than 0.016 kg of organic HAP emitted per kg of coating material applied at a new affected source as determined on a monthly average as-applied basis. If the affected source operates more than one capture system, more than one control device, one or more never-controlled work stations or one or more intermittently-controlled work stations, then you shall demonstrate compliance in accordance with the provisions of sub. (14). Otherwise, you shall demonstrate compliance following the procedure in sub. (9) when emissions from the affected source are controlled by a solvent recovery device or the procedure in sub. (11) when emissions are controlled by an oxidizer.
(8) CAPTURE AND CONTROL TO ACHIEVE ALLOWABLE EMISSION RATE. Operate a capture system and control device and limit the monthly organic HAP emissions to less than the allowable emissions as calculated in accordance with sub. (12). If the affected source operates more than one capture system, more than one control device, one or more never-controlled work stations or one or more intermittently-controlled work stations, then you shall demonstrate compliance in accordance with the provisions of sub. (14). Otherwise, the owner or operator shall demonstrate compliance following the procedure in sub. (9) when emissions from the affected source are controlled by a solvent recovery device or the procedure in sub. (11) when emissions are controlled by an oxidizer.
(9) SOLVENT RECOVERY DEVICE COMPLIANCE DEMONSTRATION. If you use a solvent recovery device to control emissions, you shall show compliance by following the procedures in either par. (a) or (b):
where:
Rv is the organic volatile matter collection and recovery efficiency, percent
Mvr is the mass of volatile matter recovered in a month, kg
Mvret is the mass of volatile matter retained in the coated web after curing or drying, or otherwise not emitted to the atmosphere, kg. The value of this term will be zero in all cases except where you choose to take into account the volatile matter retained in the coated web or otherwise not emitted to the atmosphere for the compliance demonstration procedures in this section
p is the number of different coating materials applied in a month
Cvi is the volatile organic content of coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Mi is the mass of as-purchased coating material, i, applied in a month, kg
q is the number of different materials added to the coating material
Cvij is the volatile organic content of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Mij is the mass of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, in a month, kg
where:
He is the total monthly organic HAP emitted, kg
Rv is the organic volatile matter collection and recovery efficiency, percent
p is the number of different coating materials applied in a month
Chi is the organic HAP content of coating material, i, as-purchased, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Mi is the mass of as-purchased coating material, i, applied in a month, kg
q is the number of different materials added to the coating material
Chij is the organic HAP content of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Mij is the mass of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, in a month, kg
Mvret is the mass of volatile matter retained in the coated web after curing or drying, or otherwise not emitted to the atmosphere, kg. The value of this term will be zero in all cases except where you choose to take into account the volatile matter retained in the coated web or otherwise not emitted to the atmosphere for the compliance demonstration procedures in this section.
where:
L is the mass of organic HAP emitted per mass of coating solids applied, kg/kg
He is the total monthly organic HAP emitted, kg
p is the number of different coating materials applied in a month
Csi is the coating solids content of coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Mi is the mass of as-purchased coating material, i, applied in a month, kg
q is the number of different materials added to the coating material
Csij is the coating solids content of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, expressed as a mass-fraction, kg/kg
Mij is the mass of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, in a month, kg
where:
S is the mass organic HAP emitted per mass of material applied, kg/kg
He is the total monthly organic HAP emitted, kg
p is the number of different coating materials applied in a month
Mi is the mass of as-purchased coating material, i, applied in a month, kg
q is the number of different materials added to the coating material
Mij is the mass of material, j, added to as-purchased coating material, i, in a month, kg
where:
R is the overall organic HAP control efficiency, percent
E is the organic volatile matter control efficiency of the control device, percent
CE is the organic volatile matter capture efficiency of the capture system, percent
where:
He is the total monthly organic HAP emitted, kg
R is the overall organic HAP control efficiency, percent
p is the number of different coating materials applied in a month
Cahi is the monthly average, as-applied, organic HAP content of coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Mi is the mass of as-purchased coating material, i, applied in a month, kg
Mvret is the mass of volatile matter retained in the coated web after curing or drying or otherwise not emitted to the atmosphere, kg. The value of this term will be zero in all cases except where you choose to take into account the volatile matter retained in the coated web or otherwise not emitted to the atmosphere for the compliance demonstration procedures in this section.
(10) CAPTURE AND CONTROL SYSTEM COMPLIANCE DEMONSTRATION PROCEDURES USING A CPMS. If you use an add-on control device, you shall demonstrate initial compliance for each capture system and each control device through performance tests and demonstrate continuing compliance through continuous monitoring of capture system and control device operating parameters as specified in pars. (a) to (c). Compliance shall be determined in accordance with par. (d).
(11) OXIDIZER COMPLIANCE DEMONSTRATION PROCEDURES. If you use an oxidizer to control emissions, you shall show compliance by following the procedures in par. (a) and using the applicable equations specified in par. (b) to convert the monitoring and other data into units of the selected compliance option in subs. (5) to (8). Compliance shall be determined in accordance with par. (c).
(12) MONTHLY ALLOWABLE ORGANIC HAP EMISSIONS. You shall use the procedures and calculations in this subsection for determining monthly allowable organic HAP emissions for use in demonstrating compliance in accordance with subs. (4), (8), (9) (a) 10. d., (9) (b) 11. d. and (11) (c) 4. You shall determine the amount of coating material applied at greater than or equal to 20% by mass coating solids and the amount of coating material applied at less than 20% by mass coating solids. The allowable organic HAP limit shall then be calculated based on coating material applied at greater than or equal to 20% by mass coating solids complying with 0.2 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating solids at an existing affected source or 0.08 kg of organic HAP per kg of coating solids at a new affected source, and coating material applied at less than 20% by mass coating solids complying with 4% by mass organic HAP at an existing affected source and 1.6% by mass organic HAP at a new affected source by doing all of the following:
where:
Ha is the monthly allowable organic HAP emissions, kg
p is the number of different coating materials applied in a month
Mi is the mass of as-purchased coating material, i, applied in a month, kg
Gi is the mass fraction of each coating material, i, which was applied at 20% by mass or greater coating solids content, on an as-applied basis, kg/kg
Csi is the coating solids content of coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
q is the number of different materials added to the coating material
MLj is the mass of non-coating-solids-containing coating material, j, added to coating-solids-containing coating materials which were applied at less than 20% by mass coating solids content, on an as-applied basis, in a month, kg
where
Ha is the monthly allowable organic HAP emissions, kg
p is the number of different coating materials applied in a month
Mi is the mass of as-purchased coating material, i, applied in a month, kg
Gi is the mass fraction of each coating material, i, which was applied at 20% by mass or greater coating solids content, on an as-applied basis, kg/kg
Csi is the coating solids content of coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
q is the number of different materials added to the coating material
MLj is the mass of non-coating-solids-containing coating material, j, added to coating-solids-containing coating materials which were applied at less than 20% by mass coating solids content, on an as-applied basis, in a month, kg
Note: Sub. (13) was not used to maintain consistency with numbering used in parallel federal language.
(14) COMBINATIONS OF CAPTURE AND CONTROL. If you operate more than one capture system, more than one control device, one or more never-controlled work stations or one or more intermittently-controlled work stations, you shall calculate organic HAP emissions according to the procedures in pars. (a) to (d) and use the calculation procedures specified in par. (e) to convert the monitoring and other data into units of the selected control option in subs. (5) to (8). Use the procedures specified in par. (f) to demonstrate compliance.
(15) INTERMITTENTLY-CONTROLLED AND NEVER-CONTROLLED WORK STATIONS. If you have been expressly referred to this subsection by sub. (14) (a) 2., (b) 2. b. or (c) 3. b. for calculation procedures to determine organic HAP emissions for your intermittently-controlled and never-controlled work stations, you shall do all of the following:
where:
He is the total monthly organic HAP emitted, kg
p is the number of different coating materials applied in a month
MCi is the sum of the mass of coating material, i, as-applied on intermittently-controlled work stations operating in controlled mode and the mass of coating material, i, as-applied on always-controlled work stations, in a month, kg
Cahi is the monthly average, as-applied, organic HAP content of coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
Rv is the organic volatile matter collection and recovery efficiency, percent
MBi is the sum of the mass of coating material, i, as-applied on intermittently-controlled work stations operating in bypass mode and the mass of coating material, i, as-applied on never-controlled workstations, in a month, kg
Mvret is the mass of volatile matter retained in the coated web after curing or drying, or otherwise not emitted to the atmosphere, kg. The value of this term will be zero in all cases except where you choose to take into account the volatile matter retained in the coated web or otherwise not emitted to the atmosphere for the compliance demonstration procedures in this section.
where:
He is the total monthly organic HAP emitted, kg
p is the number of different coating materials applied in a month
MCi is the sum of the mass of coating material, i, as-applied on intermittently-controlled work stations operating in controlled mode and the mass of coating material, i, as-applied on always-controlled work stations, in a month, kg
Cahi is the monthly average, as-applied, organic HAP content of coating material, i, expressed as a mass fraction, kg/kg
R is the overall organic HAP control efficiency, percent
MBi is the sum of the mass of coating material, i, as-applied on intermittently-controlled work stations operating in bypass mode and the mass of coating material, i, as-applied on never-controlled work stations, in a month, kg
Mvret is the mass of volatile matter retained in the coated web after curing or drying, or otherwise not emitted to the atmosphere, kg. The value of this term will be zero in all cases except where you choose to take into account the volatile matter retained in the coated web or otherwise not emitted to the atmosphere for the compliance demonstration procedures in this section.
(16) ALWAYS-CONTROLLED WORK STATIONS WITH MORE THAN ONE CAPTURE AND CONTROL SYSTEM. If you operate more than one capture system or more than one control device and only have always-controlled work stations, you are in compliance with the emission standards in s. NR 466.23(1) (b) 1. for the month if for each web coating line or group of web coating lines controlled by a common control device you satisfy one of the following: