Current through August 26, 2024
(1) APPLICABILITY
AND DESIGNATION OF AFFECTED FACILITY.
(a) The
affected facility to which the provisions of this section apply is each wood
heater manufactured on or after July 1, 1988, or sold at retail on or after
July 1, 1990. The provisions of this section do not apply to wood heaters
constructed prior to July 1, 1988, that are or have been owned by a
noncommercial owner for personal use.
(b) Each affected facility shall comply with
the applicable emission limits in sub. (3) unless exempted under par. (e), (f),
(g) or (h).
(e) Affected facilities
manufactured in the U.S. for export are exempt from the applicable emission
limits of sub. (3) and the requirements of sub. (4).
(f) A wood heater used for research and
development purposes that is never offered for sale or sold is exempt from the
applicable emission limits of sub. (3) and the requirements of sub. (4). No
more than 50 wood heaters manufactured per model line may be exempted for this
purpose.
(g) A coal-only heater is
exempt from the applicable emission limits of sub. (3) and the requirements of
sub. (4).
(h) The following are not
affected facilities and are not subject to this section:
1. Open masonry fireplaces constructed on
site.
2. Boilers,
3. Furnaces, and
4. Cookstoves.
(i) Modification or reconstruction, as
defined in ss.
NR 440.14 and 440.15, does not, by itself, make a
wood heater an affected facility under this section.
(2) DEFINITIONS. As used in this section,
terms not defined in this subsection have the meanings given in s.
NR 440.02.
(a) "At
retail" means the sale by a commercial owner of a wood heater to the ultimate
purchaser.
(b) "Boiler" means a
solid burning appliance used primarily for heating spaces, other than the space
where the appliance is located, by the distribution through pipes of a gas or
fluid heated in the appliance. The appliance shall be tested and listed as a
boiler under accepted American or Canadian safety testing codes. A manufacturer
may request an exemption in writing from the administrator by stating why the
testing and listing requirement is not practicable and by demonstrating that
this appliance is otherwise a boiler.
(c) "Coal-only heater" means an enclosed,
coal-burning appliance capable of space heating, or domestic water heating,
which has all of the following characteristics:
1. An opening for emptying ash that is
located near the bottom or the side of the appliance.
2. A system that admits air primarily up and
through the fuel bed.
3. A grate or
other similar device for shaking or disturbing the fuel bed or power-driven
mechanical stoker.
4. Installation
instructions that state that the use of wood in stove, except for coal ignition
purposes, is prohibited by law, and
5. The model is listed by a nationally
recognized safety-testing laboratory for use of coal only, except for coal
ignition purposes.
(d)
"Commercial owner" means any person who owns or controls a wood heater in the
course of the manufacture, importation, distribution, or sale of the wood
heater.
(e) "Cookstove" means a
wood-fired appliance that is designed primarily for cooking food and that has
the following characteristics:
1. An oven,
with a volume of 0.028 cubic meters (1 cubic foot) or greater, and an oven
rack,
2. A device for measuring
oven temperatures,
3. A flame path
that is routed around the oven,
4.
A shaker grate,
5. An ash
pan,
6. An ash clean-out door below
the oven, and
7. The absence of a
fan or heat channels to dissipate heat from the appliance.
(f) "Furnace" means a solid fuel burning
appliance that is designed to be located outside of ordinary living areas and
that warms spaces other than the space where the appliance is located by the
distribution of air heated in the appliance through ducts. The appliance shall
be tested and listed as a furnace under accepted American or Canadian safety
testing codes unless exempted from this provision by the administrator. A
manufacturer may request an exemption in writing from the administrator by
stating why the testing and listing requirement is not practicable and by
demonstrating that the appliance is otherwise a furnace.
(g) "Manufactured" means completed and ready
for shipment (whether or not packaged).
(h) "Manufacturer" means any person who
constructs or imports a wood heater.
(i) "Model line" means all wood heaters
offered for sale by a single manufacturer that are similar in all material
respects.
(j) "Representative
affected facility" means an individual wood heater that is similar in all
material respects to other wood heaters within the model line it
represents.
(k) "Sale" means the
transfer of ownership or control, except that transfer of control may not
constitute a sale for purposes of sub. (1) (f).
(L) "Similar in all material respects" means
that the construction materials, exhaust and inlet air system and other design
features are within the allowed tolerances for components identified in sub.
(4) (k).
(m) "Wood heater" means an
enclosed woodburning appliance capable of and intended for space heating or
domestic water heating that meets all of the following criteria:
1. An air-to-fuel ratio in the combustion
chamber averaging less than 35-to-1 as determined by the test procedure
prescribed in sub. (5), performed at an accredited laboratory,
2. A usable firebox volume of less than 0.57
cubic meter (20 cubic feet).
3. A
minimum burn rate less than 5 kg/hr (11 lb/hr) as determined by the test
procedure prescribed in sub. (5) performed at an accredited
laboratory.
4. A maximum weight of
800 kg (1,760 lb). In determining the weight of an appliance for these
purposes, fixtures and devices that are normally sold separately, such as flue
pipe, chimney, and masonry components that are not an integral part of the
appliance or heat distribution ducting, may not be included.
(3) STANDARDS FOR
PARTICULATE MATTER. Unless exempted under sub. (1), each affected facility:
(b) Manufactured on or after July 1, 1990, or
sold at retail on or after July 1, 1992, shall comply with the following
particulate matter emission limits as determined by the test methods and
procedures in sub. (5):
1. An affected
facility equipped with a catalytic combustor may not discharge into the
atmosphere any gases which contain particulate matter in excess of a weighted
average of 4.1 g/hr (0.009 lb/hr). Particulate emissions during any test run at
any burn rate that is required to be used in the weighted average may not
exceed the value calculated for "C" (rounded to 2 significant figures)
calculated using the following equation:
a. At
burn rates less than or equal to 2.82 kg/hr (6.2 lb/hr),
C = K1 BR +
K2
where:
BR is the burn rate in kg/hr (lb/hr)
K1 = 3.55g/kg (0.00355 lb/lb)
K2 = 4.98 g/hr (0.0011 lb/hr)
b. At burn rates greater than 2.82 kg/hr,
(6.2 lb/hr), C = 15 g/hr (0.033 lb/hr).
2. An affected facility not equipped with a
catalytic combustor may not discharge into the atmosphere any gases which
contain particulate matter in excess of a weighted average of 7.5 g/hr (0.017
lb/hr). Particulate emissions may not exceed 15 g/hr (0.033 lb/hr) during any
test run at a burn rate less than or equal to 1.5 kg/hr (3.3 lb/hr) that is
required to be used in the weighted average, and particulate emissions may not
exceed 18 g/hr (0.040 lb/hr) during any test burn at a burn rate greater than
1.5 kg/hr (3.3 lb/hr) that is required to be used in the weighted
average.
(4)
COMPLIANCE AND CERTIFICATION.
(a) For each
model line, compliance with applicable emission limits may be determined based
on testing of representative affected facilities within the model
line.
(b) Any manufacturer of an
affected facility may apply to the administrator for a certificate of
compliance for a model line. The application shall be in writing to: Stationary
Source Compliance Division (EN-341), U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 401
M Street SW, Washington DC 20460, Attention: Wood Heater Program. The
manufacturer shall submit 2 complete copies of the application and attachments.
The application shall be signed by the manufacturer, or an authorized
representative, and shall contain the following:
1. The model name and/or design
number,
2. Two color photographs of
the tested unit, one showing a front view and the other, a side view.
3.
a. Engineering drawings and specifications of
components that may affect emissions, including specifications for each
component listed in par. (k). Manufacturers may use complete assembly or design
drawings that have been prepared for other purposes, but should designate on
the drawings the dimensions of each component listed in par. (k). Manufacturers
shall identify tolerances of components of the tested unit listed in par. (k)
2. that are different from those specified in that paragraph, and show that
such tolerances may not reasonably be anticipated to cause wood heaters in the
model line to exceed the applicable emission limits.
b. A statement whether the firebox or any
firebox component (other than one listed in par. (k) 3.) will be composed of
different material from the material used for the firebox or firebox component
in the wood heater on which certification testing was performed and a
description of any such differences.
c. For applications to certify a model line
of catalytic wood heaters to meet the emission limits in sub. (3) (b), a
statement describing the manufacturer's program to ensure consistency in the
size of any gap in the catalyst bypass mechanism. The statement shall describe,
in narrative form, the components of the system that affect the size of the
gap, any specifications for critical dimensions of any such components, and the
procedure the manufacturer will use to ensure consistency in the size of the
catalyst bypass gap.
4.
All documentation pertaining to a valid certification test, including the
complete test report and, for all test runs: raw data sheets, laboratory
technician notes, calculations, and test results. Documentation shall include
the items specified in the applicable test methods. Recommended formats and
guidance materials are available from the administrator.
5. For catalytic wood heaters, a copy of the
catalytic combustor warranty,
6. A
statement that the manufacturer will conduct a quality assurance program for
the model line which satisfies the requirements of par. (o).
7. A statement describing how the tested unit
was sealed by the laboratory after the completion of certification testing,
and
8. A statement that the
manufacturer will notify the accredited laboratory if the application for
certification is granted, within 30 days of receipt of notification from the
U.S. environmental protection agency.
9. Statements that the wood heaters
manufactured under this certificate will be:
a. Similar in all material respects to the
wood heater submitted for certification testing, and
b. Will be labeled as prescribed in sub.
(7).
10. For catalytic
wood heaters, a statement that the warranty, access and inspection, and
temperature monitoring provisions in pars. (c), (d), and (m) will be
met.
11. A statement that the
manufacturer will comply with the recordkeeping and reporting requirements in
sub. (8).
12. A written estimate of
the number of wood heaters that the manufacturer anticipates will be produced
annually for the first 2 production years. Compliance with this provision may
be obtained by designating one of the following ranges:
a. Less than 2,500,
b. 2,500 to 4,999,
c. 5,000 to 9,999,
d. 10,000 to 49,999,
e. 50,000 or greater; and
13. At the beginning of each test
run in a certification test series, 2 photographs of the fuel load: One before
and one after it is placed in the wood heater. One of the photographs shall
show the front view of the wood load and the other shall show the side
view.
14. For manufacturers seeking
certification of model lines under sub. (4) (e) to meet the emission limits in
sub. (3) (b), a statement that the manufacturer has entered into a contract
with an accredited laboratory which satisfied the requirements of par.
(g).
(c) If the affected
facility is a catalytic wood heater, the warranty for the catalytic combustor
shall include the replacement of the combustor and any prior replacement
combustor without charge to the consumer for:
1. Two years from the date the consumer
purchased the heater for any defects in workmanship or materials that prevent
the combustor from functioning when installed and operated properly in the wood
heater, and
2. Three years from the
date the consumer purchased the heater for thermal crumbling or disintegration
of the substrate material for heaters manufactured after July 1,
1990.
(d) The
manufacturer of an affected facility equipped with a catalytic combustor shall
provide for a means to allow the owner to gain access readily to the catalyst
for inspection or replacement purposes and shall document in the application
for certification how the catalyst is replaced.
(e)
1. The
administrator shall issue a certificate of compliance for a model line if he or
she determines, based on all information submitted by the applicant and any
other relevant information available, that all of the following requirements
have been met:
a. A valid certification test
has demonstrated that the wood heater representative of the model line complies
with the applicable particulate emission limits in sub. (3),
b. Any tolerances or materials for components
listed in par. (k) 2. or 3. that are different from those specified in those
paragraphs may not reasonably be anticipated to cause wood heaters in the model
line to exceed the applicable emission limits.
c. The requirements of pars. (b), (c), (d),
and (m) have been met. The program described under par. (b) 3. c. shall be
deemed a tolerance specified in the certified design.
2. Upon denying certification under this
paragraph, the administrator shall give written notice to the manufacturer
setting forth the basis for the determination.
(f) To be valid, a certification test shall
be:
1. Announced to the administrator in
accordance with sub. (5) (e),
2.
Conducted by a testing laboratory accredited by the administrator pursuant to
sub. (6),
3. Conducted on a wood
heater similar in all material respects to other wood heaters of the model line
that is to be certified, and
4.
Conducted in accordance with the test methods and procedure specified in sub.
(5).
(g) To have a wood
heater model certified under sub. (4) (e) to meet the emission limits in sub.
(3) (b), a manufacturer shall enter into a contract with the accredited
laboratory that performed the certification test, under which the laboratory
will:
1. Conduct the random compliance audit
test at no cost to the manufacturer if the U.S. environmental protection agency
selects that laboratory to conduct the test, or
2. Pay the manufacturer the reasonable cost
of a random compliance audit test (as determined by the U.S. environmental
protection agency) if the U.S. environmental protection agency selects any
other laboratory to conduct the test.
(i) An applicant for certification may apply
for a waiver of the requirement to submit the results of a certification test
pursuant to par. (b) 4., if the wood heaters of the model line are similar in
all material respects to another model line that has already been issued a
certificate of compliance. A manufacturer that seeks a waiver of certification
testing shall identify the model line that has been certified, and shall submit
a copy of an agreement with the owner of the design permitting the applicant to
produce wood heaters of that design.
(j)
1.
Unless revoked sooner by the administrator, a certificate of compliance shall
be valid for 5 years from the date of issuance, for a model line certified as
meeting emission limits in sub. (3) (b).
2. Upon application for renewal of
certification by the manufacturer, the administrator may waive the requirement
for certification testing upon determining that the model line continues to
meet the requirements for certification in par. (e), or that a waiver of
certification is otherwise appropriate.
3. Upon waiving certificate testing under
subd. 2., the administrator shall give written notice to the manufacturer
setting forth the basis for the determination.
(k)
1. A
model line shall be recertified whenever any change is made in the design
submitted pursuant to par. (b) 3. that is presumed to affect the particulate
emission rate for that model line. The administrator may waive this requirement
upon written request by the manufacturer, if he or she determines that the
change may not reasonably be anticipated to cause wood heaters in the model
line to exceed the applicable emission limits. The granting of such a waiver
does not relieve the manufacturer of any compliance obligations under this
section.
2. Any change in the
indicated tolerances of any of the following components (where such components
are applicable) is presumed to affect particulate emissions if that change
exceeds ± 0.64 cm (± 1/4 inch) for any linear dimension and " 5%
for any cross-sectional area relating to air introduction systems and catalyst
bypass gaps unless other dimensions and cross-sectional areas are previously
approved by the administrator under par. (e) 1. b.
a. Firebox: Dimensions,
b. Air introduction systems: Cross-sectional
area of restrictive air inlets, outlets, and location, and method of
control,
c. Baffles: Dimensions and
locations,
d.
Refractory/insulation: Dimensions and location,
e. Catalyst: Dimensions and
location,
f. Catalyst bypass
mechanism and, for model lines certified to meet the emissions limits in sub.
(3) (b) catalyst bypass gap tolerances (when bypass mechanism is in closed
position): Dimensions, cross-sectional area, and location,
g. Flue gas exit: Dimensions and
location,
h. Door and catalyst
bypass gaskets: Dimensions and fit,
i. Outer shielding and coverings: Dimensions
and location,
j. Fuel feed system:
For wood heaters that are designed primarily to burn wood pellets and other
wood heaters equipped with a fuel feed system, the fuel feed rate, auger motor
design and power rating, and the angle of the auger to the firebox,
and
k. Forced air combustion
system: For wood heaters so equipped, the location and horsepower of blower
motors and the fan blade size.
3. Any change in the materials used for the
following components is presumed to affect emissions:
a. Refractory/insulation or
b. Door and catalyst bypass
gaskets.
4. A change in
the make, model, or composition of a catalyst is presumed to affect emissions,
unless the change has been approved in advance by the administrator, based on
test data that demonstrate that the replacement catalyst is equivalent to or
better than the original catalyst in terms of particulate emission reduction.
(L)
1. The administrator may revoke certification
if he or she determines that the wood heaters being produced in that model line
do not comply with the requirements of this section or sub. (3). Such a
determination shall be based on all available evidence, including:
a. Test data from a retesting of the original
unit on which the certification test was conducted,
b. A finding that the certification test was
not valid. The finding shall be based on problems or irregularities with the
certification test or its documentation, but may be supplemented by other
information.
c. A finding that the
labeling of the wood heater does not comply with the requirements of par.
(f),
d. Failure by the manufacturer
to comply with reporting and recordkeeping requirements under sub.
(8),
e. Physical examination
showing that a significant percentage of production units inspected are not
similar in all material respects to the representative affected facility
submitted for testing, or
f.
Failure of the manufacturer to conduct a quality assurance program in
conformity with par. (o).
2. Revocation of certification under this
paragraph may not take effect until the manufacturer concerned has been given
written notice by the administrator setting forth the basis for the proposed
determination and an opportunity to request a hearing under sub.
(10).
3. Determination to revoke
certification based upon audit testing shall be made only in accordance with
par. (p).
(m) A
catalytic wood heater shall be equipped with a permanent provision to
accommodate a commercially available temperature sensor which can monitor
combustor gas stream temperatures within or immediately downstream, i.e. within
2.54 centimeters (1 inch), of the combustor surface.
(n) Any manufacturer of an affected facility
subject under sub. (1) (b) to the applicable emission limits of this section
that does not belong to a model line certified under this section shall cause
that facility to be tested in an accredited laboratory in accordance with par.
(f) 1., 2. and 4. before it leaves the manufacturer's possession and shall
report the results to the administrator.
(o)
1. For
each certified model line, the manufacturer shall conduct a quality assurance
program which satisfies the following requirements:
2. Except as provided in subd. 5., the
manufacturer or authorized representative shall inspect at least one from every
150 units produced within a model line to determine that the wood heater is
within applicable tolerances for all components that affect emissions as listed
in par. (k) 2.
3.
a. Except as provided in subd. 3. c. or 5.,
the manufacturer or authorized representative shall conduct an emission test on
a randomly selected affected facility produced within a model line certified
under par. (e) on the following schedule:
If weighted average
certification test results were - | If yearly production
per model is - |
<2500 | >=2500 |
70% or less of
standard............................... | When directed by EPA, not to
exceed once every 10,000 stoves. | Every 10,000 stoves or trien-nially
(whichever is more frequent). |
Within 30% of standard
.............................. | Every 5,000 stoves. | Every
5,000 stoves or annually (whichever is more frequent). |
b.
Emission tests shall be conducted in conformity with sub. (5) (a) using either
approved method for measuring particulate matter as provided in sub. (5). The
manufacturer shall notify the U.S. environmental protection agency by U.S. mail
that an emissions test required pursuant to this paragraph will be conducted
within one week of the mailing of the notification.
c. If the manufacturer stated pursuant to
par. (b) 3. that the firebox or any firebox component would be composed of a
different material than the material used in the wood heater on which
certification testing was performed, the first test shall be performed before
1,000 wood heaters are produced. The manufacturer shall submit a report of the
results of this emission test to the administrator within 45 days of the
completion of testing.
4. The manufacturer shall take remedial
measures, as appropriate, when inspection or testing pursuant to this paragraph
indicates that affected facilities within the model line are not within
applicable tolerances or do not comply with applicable emission limits.
Manufacturers shall record the problem identified, the extent of the problem,
the remedial measures taken, and the effect of such remedial measures as
projected by the manufacturer or determined by any additional testing.
5.
a. If 2 consecutive passing tests are
conducted under either subd. 2. or 3., the required frequency of testing under
the applicable paragraph shall be modified as follows: Skip every other
required test.
b. If 5 consecutive
passing tests are conducted under the modified schedule provided for in subd.
5. a., the required frequency of testing under the applicable paragraph shall
be further modified as follows: Skip 3 consecutive required tests after each
required test that is conducted.
c.
Testing shall resume on the frequency specified in subd. 2. or 3. as
applicable, if a test failure results during any test conducted under a
modified schedule.
6. If
emissions tests under this paragraph are conducted at an altitude different
from the altitude at which certification tests were conducted, and are not
conducted under pressurized conditions, the results shall be adjusted for
altitude.
(p)
1.
a. The
administrator shall after July 1, 1990, select for random compliance audit
testing certified wood heater model lines that have not already been subject to
a random compliance audit under this paragraph. The administrator may not
select more than one model line under this program for every 5 model lines for
which certification is granted under par. (e) to meet the emission limits in
sub. (3) (b). No accredited laboratory may test or bear the expense of testing,
as provided in the contract described in par. (g), more than one model line
from every 5 model lines tested by the laboratory for which certification was
granted. The administrator shall use a procedure that ensures that the
selection process is random.
b. The
administrator may, by means of a neutral selection scheme, select model lines
certified under par. (b) or (e), for selective enforcement audit testing under
this paragraph. Prior to July 1, 1990, the administrator shall only select a
model line for a selective enforcement audit on the basis of information
indicating that affected facilities within the model line may exceed the
applicable emission limit in sub. (3).
2. The administrator shall randomly select
for audit testing 5 production wood heaters from each model line selected under
this paragraph. These wood heaters shall be selected from completed units ready
for shipment from the manufacturer's facility (whether or not the units are in
a package or container). The wood heaters shall be sealed upon selection and
remain sealed until they are tested or until the audit is completed. The wood
heaters shall be numbered in the order that they were selected.
3.
a. The
administrator shall test, or direct the manufacturer to test, the first of the
5 wood heaters selected under subd. 2. in a laboratory accredited under sub.
(6) that is selected pursuant to subd. 4.
b. The expense of the random compliance audit
test shall be the responsibility of the wood heater manufacturer. A
manufacturer may require the laboratory that performed the certification test
to bear the expense of a random compliance audit test by means of the contract
required under par. (g). If the laboratory with which the manufacturer had a
contract has ceased business due to bankruptcy or is otherwise legally unable
to honor the contract, the administrator may not select any of that
manufacturer's model lines for which certification testing has been conducted
by that laboratory for a random compliance audit test.
c. The test shall be conducted using the same
test method and procedure used to obtain certification. If the certification
test consisted of more than one particulate sampling test method, the
administrator may use either one of these methods for the purpose of audit
testing. If the test is performed in a pressure vessel, air pressure in the
pressure vessel shall be maintained within 1% of the average of the barometric
pressures recorded for each individual test run used to calculate the weighted
average emission rate for the certification test. The administrator shall
notify the manufacturer at least one week prior to any test under this
paragraph, and allow the manufacturer or authorized representatives to observe
the test.
4.
a. Except as provided in this paragraph, the
administrator may select any accredited laboratory for audit testing. The
following contains a nesting potential redrafting situation
b. The administrator shall select the
accredited laboratory that performed the test used to obtain certification for
audit testing, until the administrator has amended this section to allow
testing at another laboratory. If another laboratory is selected pursuant to
this subdivision, and the overall precisions of the test method and procedure
is greater than "1 gram per hour (± 0.0022 lb per hour) of the weighted
average at laboratories below 304 meters (1,000 feet) elevation (or
equivalent), the interlaboratory component of the precision shall be added to
the applicable emissions standard for the purposes of this
subdivision.
c. The administrator
may not select an accredited laboratory that is located at an elevation more
than 152 meters (500 feet) higher than the elevation of the laboratory which
performed the test used to obtain certification, unless the audit test is
performed in a pressure vessel.
5.
a. If
emissions from a wood heater tested under subd. 3. exceed the applicable
weighted average emission limit by more than 50%, the administrator shall so
notify the manufacturer that certification for that model line is suspended
effective 72 hours from the receipt of the notice, unless the suspension notice
is withdrawn by the administrator. The suspension shall remain in effect until
withdrawn by the administrator, or 30 days from its effective date if a
revocation notice under subd. 5. b. is not issued within that period, or the
date of final agency action on revocation, whichever occurs earlier. The
following contains a nested potential redrafting situation
b.
1) If
emissions from a wood heater tested under subd. 3. exceed the applicable
weighted average emission limit, the administrator shall notify the
manufacturer that certification is revoked for that model line.
2) A revocation notice under subd. 5. b. 1)
shall become final and effective 60 days after receipt by the manufacturer,
unless it is withdrawn, a hearing is requested under sub. (10) or the deadline
for requesting a hearing is extended.
3) The administrator may extend the deadline
for requesting a hearing for up to 60 days for good cause.
4) A manufacturer may extend the deadline for
requesting a hearing for up to 6 months, by agreeing to a voluntary suspension
of certification.
c.
Any notification under subd. 5.
a. or
b. shall include a copy of a
preliminary test report from the accredited laboratory. The accredited
laboratory shall provide a preliminary test report to the administrator within
10 days of the completion of testing, if a wood heater exceeds the applicable
emission limit in sub. (3). The laboratory shall provide the administrator and
the manufacturer, within 30 days of the completion of testing, all
documentation pertaining to the test, including the complete test report and
raw data sheets, laboratory technician notes, and test results for all test
runs.
d. Upon receiving
notification of a test failure under subd. 5. b. the manufacturer may submit
some or all of the remaining 4 wood heaters selected under subd. 2. for testing
at the manufacturer's own expense, in the order they were selected by the
administrator, at the laboratory that performed the emissions test for the
administrator.
e. Whether or not
the manufacturer proceeds under subd. 5. d., the manufacturer may submit any
relevant information to the administrator, including any other test data
generated pursuant to this section. The manufacturer shall pay the expense of
any testing performed for him or her.
f. The administrator shall withdraw any
notice issued under subd. 5. b. if tests under subd. 5. d. show either:
1) That all 4 wood heaters tested for the
manufacturer met the applicable weighted average emission limits, or
2) That the second and third wood heaters
selected met the applicable weighted average emission limits and the average of
all 3 weighted averages, including the original audit test, was below the
applicable weighted average emission limits.
g. The administrator may withdraw any
proposed revocation, if the administrator finds that an audit test failure has
been rebutted by information submitted by the manufacturer under subd. 5. d. or
e. or by any other relevant information available to the
administrator.
h. Any withdrawal of
a proposed revocation shall be accompanied by a document setting forth its
basis.
(5) TEST METHODS AND PROCEDURES. Test methods
and procedures in 40 CFR part 60, Appendix A, incorporated by reference in s.
NR 440.17, except as provided under s.
NR 440.08(2), shall be used to determine
compliance with the standards and requirements for certification under subs.
(3) and (4) as follows:
(a) Method 28 shall
be used to establish the certification test conditions and the particulate
matter weighted emission values.
(b) Emission concentrations may be measured
with either:
1. Method 5G if a dilution
tunnel sampling location is used, or
2. Method 5H if a stack location is
used.
(c) Method 28A
shall be used to determine that a wood combustion unit qualifies under the
definition of wood heater in sub. (2) (m). If such a determination is
necessary, this test shall be conducted by an accredited laboratory.
(e)
1. The
manufacturer of an affected facility shall notify the administrator of the date
that certification testing is scheduled to begin. A notice from the testing lab
containing the information required in sub. (4) (f) 1. may be used to satisfy
this requirement. This notice shall be submitted at least 30 days before the
start of testing. The notification of testing shall be in writing, and include
the manufacturer's name and address, the testing laboratory's name, the model
name and number or, if unavailable, some other way to distinguish between
models, and the dates of testing.
2. Any emission testing conducted on the wood
heater for which notice was delivered shall be presumed to be certification
testing if such testing occurs on or after the scheduled date of testing and
before a test report is submitted to the administrator. If certification
testing is interrupted for more than 24 hours, the laboratory shall notify the
administrator by telephone, as soon as practicable, and also by letter, stating
why the testing was interrupted and when it is expected to be
resumed.
3. A manufacturer or
laboratory may change the date that testing is scheduled to begin by notifying
the administrator at least 14 days before the start of testing. Notification of
schedule change shall be made at least 2 working days prior to the originally
scheduled test date. This notice of rescheduling shall be made by telephone or
other expeditious means and shall be documented in writing and sent
concurrently.
4. A model line may
be withdrawn from testing before the certification test is complete, provided
the wood heater is sealed in accordance with sub. (6) (g). The manufacturer
shall notify the administrator 30 days before the resumption of
testing.
5. The manufacturer or
laboratory shall notify the administrator if a test is not completed within the
time allotted as set forth in the notice of testing. The notification shall be
made by the end of the allotted testing period by telephone or other
expeditious means, and documented in writing sent concurrently, and shall
contain the dates when the test will be resumed. Unless otherwise approved by
the administrator, failure to conduct a certification test as scheduled without
notifying the administrator of any schedule change 14 days prior to the
schedule or revised test dates will result in voiding the notification. In the
case of a voided notification, the manufacturer shall provide the administrator
with a second notification at least 30 days prior to the new test dates. The
administrator may waive the requirement for advance notice for test
resumptions.
(f) The
testing laboratory shall allow the manufacturer to observe certification
testing. However, manufacturers may not involve themselves in the conduct of
the test after the pretest burn (as defined by Method 28) has begun.
Communications between the manufacturer and laboratory personnel regarding
operation of the wood heater shall be limited to written communications
transmitted prior to the first pretest burn of the certification series.
Written communications between the manufacturer and laboratory personnel may be
exchanged during the certification test only if deviations from the test
procedures are observed that constitute improper conduct of the test. All
communications shall be included in the test documentation required to be
submitted under sub. (4) (b) 4. and shall be consistent with instructions
provided in the owner's manual required under sub. (7) (k), except to the
extent that they address details of the certification tests that would not be
relevant to owners.
(6)
LABORATORY ACCREDITATION.
(a)
1. A laboratory may apply for accreditation
by the administrator to conduct wood heater certifications tests pursuant to
sub. (4). The application shall be in writing to: Emission Measurement Branch
(MD-13), U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, North
Carolina 27711, Attn: Wood Heater Laboratory Accreditation.
2. If accreditation is denied under this
section, the administrator shall give written notice to the laboratory setting
forth the basis for the determination.
(b) In order for a test laboratory to qualify
for accreditation the laboratory shall:
1.
Submit its written application providing the information related to laboratory
equipment and management and technical experience of laboratory personnel.
Applications from laboratories shall establish that:
a. Laboratory personnel have a total of one
year of relevant experience in particulate measurement, including at least 3
months experience in measuring particulate emissions from wood
heaters,
b. The laboratory has the
equipment necessary to perform testing in accordance with either sub. (5) (b)
1. or 2., and
c. Laboratory
personnel have experience in test management or laboratory
management.
2. Have no
conflict of interest and receive no financial benefit from the outcome of
certification testing conducted pursuant to sub. (4).
3. Agree to enter into a contract as
described in sub. (4) (g) with each wood heater manufacturer for whom a
certification test has been performed.
5. Demonstrate proficiency to achieve
reproducible results with at least one test method and procedure in sub. (5)
(b) by:
a. Performing a test consisting of at
least 8 test runs (2 in each of the 4 burn rate categories) on a wood heater
identified by the administrator,
b.
Providing the administrator at least 30 days prior notice of the test to afford
the administrator the opportunity to have an observer present, and
c. Submitting to the administrator all
documentation pertaining to the test including a complete test report and raw
data sheets, laboratory technical notes, and test results for all test
runs.
6. Be located in
the continental United States.
7.
Agree to participate annually in a proficiency testing program conducted by the
administrator.
8. Agree to allow
the administrator access to observe certification testing.
9. Agree to comply with reporting and
recordkeeping requirements that affect testing laboratories.
10. Agree to accept the reasonable cost of a
random compliance audit test (as determined by the administrator) if it is
selected to conduct the random compliance audit test of a model line originally
tested for certification at another laboratory.
(e)
1. The
administrator may revoke the U.S. environmental protection agency laboratory
accreditation if he or she determines that the laboratory:
a. No longer satisfies the requirements for
accreditation in par. (b),
b. Does
not follow required procedures or practices,
c. Had falsified data or otherwise
misrepresented emission data,
e.
Failed to participate in a proficiency testing program, in accordance with its
commitment under par. (b) 5., or
f.
Failed to seal the wood heater in accordance with par. (g).
2. Revocation of accreditation
under this paragraph may not take effect until the laboratory concerned has
been given written notice by the administrator setting forth the basis for the
proposed determination and an opportunity for a hearing under sub. (10).
However, if revocation is ultimately upheld, all tests conducted by the
laboratory after written notice was given may, at the discretion of the
administrator, be declared invalid.
(f) Unless revoked sooner, a certificate of
accreditation granted by the administrator shall be valid for 5 years from the
date of issuance, for certificates issued under par. (b).
(g) A laboratory accredited by the
administrator shall seal any wood heater on which it performed certification
tests, immediately upon completion or suspension of certification testing, by
using a laboratory-specific seal.
(7) PERMANENT LABEL, TEMPORARY LABEL AND
OWNER'S MANUAL.
(a)
1. Each affected facility manufactured on or
after July 1, 1988, or offered for sale at retail on or after July 1, 1990,
shall have a permanent label affixed to it that meets the requirements of this
subsection.
2. Except for wood
heaters subject to sub. (1) (e), (f) or (g), the permanent label shall contain
the following information:
a. Month and year
of manufacture,
b. Model name or
number, and
c. Serial
number.
3. The permanent
label shall:
a. Be affixed in a readily
visible or accessible location,
b.
Be at least 8.9 cm long and 5.1 cm wide (31/2 inches long and 2 inches
wide).
c. Be made of a material
expected to last the lifetime of the wood heater,
d. Present required information in a manner
so that it is likely to remain legible for the lifetime of the wood
heater.
e. Be affixed in such a
manner that it cannot be removed from the appliance without damage to the
label.
4. The permanent
label may be combined with any other label, as long as the required information
is displayed, and the integrity of the permanent label is not
compromised.
(b) If the
wood heater belongs to a model line certified under sub. (4) and has not been
found to exceed the applicable emission limits or tolerances through quality
assurance testing, one of the following statements, as appropriate, shall
appear on the permanent label:
State of Wisconsin
DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES
Certified to comply with July, 1988, particulate emission
standards
Not approved for sale after June 30, 1992,
or
State of Wisconsin
DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES
Certified to comply with July, 1990, particulate emission
standards.
(d) Any label
statement under par. (b) constitutes a representation by the manufacturer as to
any wood heater that bears it that:
1.
Certification was in effect at the time the wood heater left the possession of
the manufacturer,
2. The
manufacturer was, at the time the label was affixed, conducting a quality
assurance program in conformity with sub. (4) (o),
3. As to any wood heater individually tested
for emissions by the manufacturer under sub. (4) (o) 3., that it met the
applicable emissions limits, and
4.
As to any wood heater individually inspected for tolerances under sub. (4) (o)
2., that the wood heater is within applicable tolerances.
(e) If an affected facility is exempt from
the emission limits in sub. (3), the following statement shall appear on the
permanent label:
State of Wisconsin
DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES
Not certified. Approved for sale until June 30,
1991.
(f)
1. If an affected facility is manufactured in
the state of Wisconsin for export, the following statement shall appear on the
permanent label:
State of Wisconsin
DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES
Export stove. May not be operated within the United
States.
2. If an affected
facility is manufactured for use for research and development purposes as
provided in sub. (1)(f), the following statement shall appear on the permanent
label:
State of Wisconsin
DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES
Not certified. Research Stove.
Not approved for sale.
3. If an appliance is a coal-only heater as
defined in sub. (1), the following statement shall appear on the permanent
label:
State of Wisconsin
DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES
This heater is only for burning coal.
Use of any other solid fuel except for coal ignition
purposes is a violation of law.
(g)
Any affected facility that does not qualify for labeling under any of pars. (b)
through (f), shall bear one of the following labels:
1. If the test conducted under sub. (4) (n)
indicates that the facility does not meet applicable emissions limits:
State of Wisconsin
DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
Not certified. Does not meet DNR particulate emission
standards.
IT IS AGAINST THE LAW TO OPERATE THIS WOOD HEATER.
2. If the test conducted under sub.
(4) (n) indicates that the facility does meet applicable emissions limits:
State of Wisconsin
DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES
Not certified. Meets DNR particulate emission
standards.
3. If the facility
has not been tested as required by sub. (4) (e).
State of Wisconsin
DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
Not certified. Not tested. Not approved for sale.
IT IS AGAINST THE LAW TO OPERATE THIS WOOD HEATER.
(h) For affected facilities equipped with
catalytic combustors, the following statement shall appear on the permanent
label:
This wood heater contains a catalytic combustor, which
needs periodic inspection and replacement for proper operation. Consult owner's
manual for further information. It is against the law to operate this wood
heater in a manner inconsistent with operating instructions in the owner's
manual or if the catalytic element is deactivated or removed.
(i) An affected facility permanently labeled
under par. (b) shall have attached to it a temporary label that shall contain
only the following:
1. A statement indicating
the compliance status of the model. The statement shall be one of the
statements provided in 40 CFR part 60, Appendix I, Sectio n 2.2.1, incorporated
by reference in s.
NR 440.17. Instructions on the statement to select are
provided in 40 CFR part 60 in Appendix I, incorporated by reference in s.
NR 440.17.
2.
A graphic presentation of the composite particulate matter emission rate as
determined in the certification test. The method for presenting this
information is provided in 40 CFR part 60, Appendix I, Section 2.2.2,
incorporated by reference in s.
NR 440.17.
3.
A graphic presentation of the overall thermal efficiency of the model. The
method for presenting this information is provided in 40 CFR part 60, Appendix
I, Section 2.2.3, incorporated by reference in s.
NR 440.17. At the discretion of the manufacturer, either
the actual measured efficiency of the model or its estimated efficiency may be
used for purposes of this paragraph. The actual efficiency is the efficiency
measured in tests conducted pursuant to 40 CFR 670.534(d) . The estimated
efficiency shall be 72% if the model is catalyst-equipped and 63% if the model
is not catalyst equipped, and 78% if the model is designed to burn wood pellets
for fuel.
4. A numerical expression
of the heat output range of the unit, in British thermal units per hour
(Btu/hr) rounded to the nearest 100 Btu/hr.
a.
If the manufacturer elects to report the overall efficiency of the model based
on test results pursuant to subd. 3., the manufacturer shall report the heat
output range measured during the efficiency test. If an accessory device is
used in the certification test to achieve any low burn rate criterion specified
in this section, and if this accessory device is not sold as a part of the wood
heater, the heat output range shall be determined using the formula in subd. 4.
b. based upon the lowest sustainable burn rate achieved without the accessory
device.
b. If the manufacturer
elects to use the estimated efficiency as provided in subd. 3., the
manufacturer shall estimate the heat output of the model as follows:
See PDF for
diagram
where:
HOE is the estimated heat output in Btu/hr
HV is the heating value of fuel, 19,140 Btu/kg (8,700
Btu/lb)
BR is the burn rate of dry test fuel, kg/hr (lb/hr)
5. Statements regarding
the importance of operation and maintenance. Instructions regarding which
statements shall be used are provided in 40 CFR part 60, Appendix I, Section
2., incorporated by reference in s.
NR 440.17; and
6. The manufacturer and the identification of
the model.
(j)
1. An affected facility permanently labeled
under par. (e), (f) 3. or (g) shall have attached to it a temporary label that
shall contain only the information provided for in 40 CFR part 60, Appendix I,
section 2.3, 2.4 or 2.5, as applicable, incorporated by reference in s.
NR 440.17.
2.
The temporary label of an affected facility permanently labeled under par. (b),
(e), (f) 3. or (g) shall:
a. Be affixed to a
location on the wood heater that is readily seen and accessible when the wood
heater is offered for sale to consumers by any commercial owner;
b. Not be combined with any other label or
information;
c. Be attached to the
wood heater in such a way that it can be easily removed by the consumer upon
purchase, except that the label on wood heaters displayed by a commercial owner
may have an adhesive backing or other means to preserve the label to prevent
its removal or destruction;
d. Be
printed on 90 pound bond paper in black ink with a white background except that
those for models that are not otherwise exempted which do not meet the
applicable emission limits, or have not been tested pursuant to this section,
shall be on a red background as described in 40 CFR part 60, Appendix I,
Section 2.5, incorporated by reference in s.
NR 440.17;
e.
Have dimensions of 12.7 centimeters by 17.8 centimeters (5 inches by 7 inches)
as described in 40 CFR part 60, Appendix I, section 2.1, incorporated by
reference in s.
NR 440.17(1);
f. Have wording, presentation of the graphic
data, and typography as presented in 40 CFR part 60, Appendix I, incorporated
by reference in s.
NR 440.17.
(k)
1. Each
affected facility offered for sale by a commercial owner shall be accompanied
by an owner's manual that shall contain the information listed in subds.
2. (pertaining to installation)
and
3. (pertaining to operation
and maintenance). The information shall be adequate to enable consumers to
achieve optimal emissions performance. The information shall also be consistent
with the operating instructions provided by the manufacturer to the laboratory
for operating the wood heater during certification testing, except for details
of the certification test that would not be relevant to the ultimate
purchaser.
2. Installation
information in the owner's manual shall state the requirements for achieving
proper draft.
3. Operation and
maintenance information in the owner's manual shall include:
a. Wood loading procedures, recommendations
on wood selection, and warnings on what fuels not to use, such as treated wood,
colored paper, cardboard, solvents, trash and garbage,
b. Fire starting procedures,
c. Proper use of air controls,
d. Ash removal procedures,
e. Instructions on gasket
replacement,
f. For catalytic
models, information on the following pertaining to the catalytic combustor:
1) Procedures for achieving and maintaining
catalyst activity,
2) Maintenance
procedures,
3) Procedures for
determining deterioration or failure,
4) Procedures for replacement, and
5) Information on how to exercise warranty
rights, and
g. For
catalytic models, the following statement:
This wood heater contains a catalytic combustor, which
needs periodic inspection and replacement for proper operation. It is against
the law to operate this wood heater in a manner inconsistent with operating
instructions in this manual, or if the catalytic element is deactivated or
removed.
4. Any
manufacturer using the model language contained in 40 CFR part 60, Appendix I,
incorporated by reference in s.
NR 440.17, to satisfy any requirement of this paragraph
shall be in compliance with that requirement, provided that the particular
model language is printed in full, with only such changes as are necessary to
ensure accuracy for the particular model line.
(L) Wood heaters that are affected by this
section but that have been owned and operated by a noncommercial owner, are not
subject to pars. (j) and (k) when offered for resale.
(8) REPORTING AND RECORDKEEPING.
(a) Each manufacturer who holds a certificate
of compliance under sub. (4) (e) for a model line shall maintain records
containing the information required by this paragraph with respect to that
model line. The records and information maintained shall include:
1. For certification tests:
a. All documentation pertaining to the
certification test used to obtain certification, including the full test report
and raw data sheets, laboratory technician notes, calculations, and the test
results for all test runs.
b. Where
a model line was certified under a previous requirement and later certified
under sub. (4) (e), all documentation pertaining to the certification test used
to obtain certification in each instance.
2. For parameter inspections conducted
pursuant to sub. (4) (o) 2., information indicating the extent to which
tolerances for components that affect emissions as listed in sub. (4) (k) 2.
were inspected, and at what frequency, the results of such inspections,
remedial actions taken, if any, and any follow-up actions such as additional
inspections.
3. For emissions tests
conducted pursuant to sub. (4) (o) 3., all test reports, data sheets,
laboratory technician notes, calculations, and test results for all test runs,
the remedial actions taken, if any, and any follow-up actions such as
additional testing.
4. The number
of affected facilities that are sold each year, by certified model
line.
(b)
1. Each accredited laboratory shall maintain
records consisting of all documentation pertaining to each certification test,
including the full test report and raw data sheets, technician notes,
calculations, and the test results for all test runs.
2. Each accredited laboratory shall report to
the administrator by the 8th day of each month prior to July 1, 1990:
a. The number and identification of wood
heaters scheduled for testing and the type of testing (e.g., U.S. environmental
protection agency certification, Oregon certification, research and development
testing),
b. The estimated date on
which certification testing could commence for a wood heater, if such a test
were requested on the first day of that month,
c. The identification of the wood heaters
tested during the previous month.
3. Each accredited laboratory shall report to
the administrator within 24 hours whenever a manufacturer which has notified
the laboratory that it intends to apply for alternative certification for a
model line fails to submit on schedule a representative unit of that model line
for certification testing.
(c) Any wood heater upon which certification
tests were performed based upon which certification was granted under sub. (4)
(e) shall be retained (sealed and unaltered) at the manufacturer's facility for
as long as the model line in question is manufactured. Any such wood heater
shall be made available upon request to the administrator for inspection and
testing.
(e) Any manufacturer
seeking exemption shall maintain wood heater production records covering the
period July 1, 1987 to July 1, 1989.
(f) Each manufacturer of an affected facility
certified under sub. (4) shall submit a report to the administrator every 2
years following issuance of a certificate of compliance for each model line.
This report shall certify that no changes in the design or manufacture of this
model line have been made that require recertification under sub. (4)
(k).
(g) Each manufacturer shall
maintain records of the model and number of wood heaters exempted under sub.
(1) (f).
(h) Each commercial owner
of a wood heater previously owned by a noncommercial owner for personal use
shall maintain records of the name and address of the previous owner.
(i)
1.
Unless otherwise specified, all records required under this section shall be
maintained by the manufacturer or commercial owner of the affected facility for
a period of no less than 5 years.
2. Unless otherwise specified, all reports to
the administrator required under this section shall be made to: Stationary
Source Compliance Division (EN-341), U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 401
M Street SW, Washington DC 20460, Attention: Wood Heater Program.
3. A report to the administrator required
under this section shall be deemed to have been made when it is properly
addressed and mailed, or placed in the possession of a commercial courier
service.
(9)
PROHIBITIONS.
(a) No person may operate an
affected facility that does not have affixed to it a permanent label pursuant
to sub. (7) (b), (e), (f) 2. or 3. or (g) 2.
(b) No manufacturer may advertise for sale,
offer for sale, or sell an affected facility that:
1. Does not have affixed to it a permanent
label pursuant to sub. (7), or
2.
Has not been tested when required by sub. (4) (n).
(c) On or after July 1, 1990, no commercial
owner may advertise for sale, offer for sale, or sell an affected facility that
does not have affixed to it a permanent label pursuant to sub. (7) (b), (e),
(f) 1. or 3., or (g) 1. or 2. No person may advertise for sale, offer for sale,
or sell an affected facility labeled under sub. (7) (f) 1. except for
export.
(d)
1. No commercial owner may advertise for
sale, offer for sale or sell an affected facility permanently labeled under
sub. (7) (b) unless:
a. The affected facility
has affixed to it a removable label pursuant to sub. (7),
b. Any purchaser or transferee is provided
with an owner's manual pursuant to sub. (7) (k), and
c. Any purchaser or transferee is provided
with a copy of the catalytic combustor warranty (for affected facilities with
catalytic combustors).
2. No commercial owner may advertise for
sale, offer for sale, or sell an affected facility permanently labeled under
sub. (7) (e), (f) 3., or (g), unless the affected facility has affixed to it a
removable label pursuant to sub. (7). This prohibition does not apply to wood
heaters affected by this section that have been previously owned and operated
by a noncommercial owner.
3. A
commercial owner other than a manufacturer complies with the requirements of
this paragraph if the commercial owner:
a.
Receives the required documentation from the manufacturer or a previous
commercial owner, and
b. Provides
that documentation unaltered to any person to whom the wood heater that it
covers is sold or transferred.
(e)
1. In
any case in which the administrator revokes a certificate of compliance either
for the knowing submission of false or inaccurate information or other
fraudulent acts, or based on a finding under sub. (4) (L) 1. b. that the
certification test was not valid, the administrator may give notice of that
revocation and the grounds for it to all commercial owners.
2. From and after the date of receipt of the
notice given under subd. 1., no commercial owner may sell any wood heater
covered by the revoked certificate (other than to the manufacturer) unless one
of the following has been met:
a. The wood
heater has been tested as required by sub. (4) (n) and labeled as required by
sub. (6) (g).
b. The model line has
been recertified in accordance with this section.
(f) No person may install or
operate an affected facility except in a manner consistent with the
instructions on its permanent label and in the owner's manual pursuant to sub.
(7) (L).
(g) No person may operate
an affected facility which was originally equipped with a catalytic combustor
if the catalytic element is deactivated or removed.
(h) No person may operate an affected
facility that has been physically altered to exceed the tolerance limits of its
certificate of compliance.
(i) No
person may alter, deface, or remove any permanent label required to be affixed
pursuant to sub. (7).
(10) HEARING AND APPEAL PROCEDURES.
(a)
1. Any
manufacturer or laboratory affected by an action listed in this subdivision may
request a hearing under this subsection within 30 days following receipt of the
required notification of the action when the administrator:
a. Denies an application under sub. (4)
(e),
b. Issues a notice of
revocation of certification under sub. (4) (L),
c. Denies an application for laboratory
accreditation under sub. (6), or
d.
Issues a notice of revocation of laboratory accreditation under sub. (6)
(e).
2. When the
administrator issues a notice of revocation under sub. (4) (p), the
manufacturer may request a hearing under this subsection within the time limits
in sub. (4) (p) 5.
(b)
Any hearing request shall be in writing, shall be signed by an authorized
representative of the petitioning manufacturer or laboratory, and shall include
a statement setting forth with particularity the petitioner's objection to the
administrator's determination or proposed determination.
(c)
1. Upon
receipt of a request for a hearing under par. (a), the administrator shall
request the chief administrative law judge to designate an administrative law
judge as presiding officer for the hearing. If the chief administrative law
judge replies that no administrative law judge is available to perform this
function, the administrator shall designate a presiding officer who has not had
any prior responsibility for the matter under review, and who is not subject to
the direct control or supervision of someone who has had such responsibility.
2. The hearing shall commence as
soon as practicable at a time and place fixed by the presiding officer.
3.
a. A motion for leave to intervene in any
proceeding conducted under this section shall set forth the grounds for the
proposed intervention, the position and interest of the movant and the likely
impact that intervention will have on the expeditious progress of the
proceeding. Any person already a party to the proceeding may file an answer to
a motion to intervene, making specific reference to the factors in the
foregoing sentence and subd. 3. c. within 10 days after service of the motion
for leave to intervene.
b. A motion
for leave to intervene in a proceeding shall ordinarily be filed before the
first prehearing conference or in the absence of a prehearing conference, prior
to the setting of a time and place for a hearing. Any motion filed after that
time shall include, in addition to the information in subd. 3. a., a statement
of good cause for the failure to file in a timely manner. The intervenor shall
be bound by any agreements, arrangements and other matters previously made in
the proceeding.
c. A motion for
leave to intervene may be granted only if the movant demonstrates that his or
her presence in the proceeding would not unduly prolong or otherwise prejudice
the adjudication of the rights of the original parties, and that movant may be
adversely affected by a final order. The intervenor shall become a full party
to the proceeding upon the granting of leave to intervene.
d. Persons not parties to the proceeding may
move for leave to file amicus curiae briefs. The movant shall state his or her
interest and the reasons why the proposed amicus brief is desirable. If the
motion is granted, the presiding officer or administrator shall issue an order
setting the time for filing such brief. An amicus curia may participate in any
briefing after his or her motion is granted, and shall be served with all
briefs, reply briefs, motions and orders relating to issues to be
briefed.
4. In computing
any period of time prescribed or allowed in this section, the day of the event
from which the designated period begins to run may not be included. Saturdays,
Sundays, and federal legal holidays shall be included. When a stated time
expires on a Saturday, Sunday or legal holiday, the stated time period shall be
extended to include the next business day.
(d)
1. Upon
appointment, the presiding officer shall establish a hearing file. The file
shall consist of the notice issued by the administrator under sub. (4) (e), (L)
or (p), or (6) (a) or (e), together with any accompanying material, the request
for a hearing and the supporting data submitted therewith, and all documents
relating to the request for certification or accreditation, or the proposed
revocation of either.
2. The
hearing file shall be available for inspection by any party, to the extent
authorized by law, at the office of the presiding officer or other place
designated.
(e) Any
party may appear in person, or may be represented by counsel or by any other
duly authorized representative.
(f)
1. The presiding officer, upon the request of
any party, or at his or her discretion, may order a prehearing conference at a
time and place specified to consider the following:
a. Simplification of the issues,
b. Stipulations, admissions of fact, and the
introduction of documents,
c.
Limitation of the number of expert witnesses,
d. Possibility of agreement disposing of all
or any of the issues in dispute,
e.
Such other matters as may aid in the disposition of the hearing, including such
additional tests as may be agreed upon by the parties.
2. The results of the conference shall be
reduced to writing by the presiding officer and made part of the
record.
(g)
1. Hearings shall be conducted by the
presiding officer in an informal but orderly and expeditious manner. The
parties may offer oral or written evidence, subject to the exclusion by the
presiding officer of irrelevant, immaterial and repetitious evidence.
2. Witnesses will not be required to testify
under oath. However, the presiding officer shall call to the attention of
witnesses that their statements may be subject to penalties under
18 USC
1001 for knowingly making false statements or
representations or using false documents in any matter within the jurisdiction
of any department or agency of the United States.
3. Any witness may be examined or
cross-examined by the presiding officer, the parties, or their
representatives.
4. Hearings shall
be recorded verbatim. Copies of transcripts of proceedings may be purchased by
the applicant from the reporter.
5.
All written statements, charts, tabulations, and similar data offered in
evidence at the hearings shall, upon a showing satisfactory to the presiding
officer of their authenticity, relevancy, and materiality, be received in
evidence and shall constitute a part of the record.
(h)
1. The
presiding officer shall make an initial decision which shall include a written
findings and conclusions and the reasons or basis therefor on all the material
issues of fact, law, or discretion presented on the record. The findings,
conclusions, and written decision shall be provided to the parties and made a
part of the record. The initial decision shall become the decision of the
administrator without further proceedings unless there is an appeal to the
administrator or motion for review by the administrator. Except as provided in
subd. 3., any such appeal shall be taken within 20 days of the date the initial
decision was filed.
2. On appeal
from or review of the initial decision the administrator shall have all the
powers which he or she would have in making the initial decision including the
discretion to require or allow briefs, oral argument, the taking of additional
evidence or the remanding to the presiding officer for additional proceedings.
The decision by the administrator shall include written findings and
conclusions and the reasons or basis therefor on all the material issues of
fact, law, or discretion presented on the appeal or considered in the
review.
3. In any hearing requested
under par. (a) 2., the presiding officer shall render his initial decision
within 60 days of that request. Any appeal to the administrator shall be taken
within 10 days of the initial decision, and the administrator shall render his
decision in that appeal within 30 days of the filing of the appeal.
(11) GENERAL PROVISIONS
EXCLUSIONS. The following provisions of ch. NR 440 do not apply to this
section:
(a) Section
NR 440.07
(b) Section
NR 440.08(1), (3), (4), (5) and
(6), and
(c) Section
NR 440.15(4).