Current through Register Vol. 24-18, September 15, 2024
Appropriate methods to design water crossing structures are
available in the department's Water Crossing Design
Guidelines, or other published manuals and guidelines. A list of
approved manuals and guidelines is on the department's web site.
This section applies only to water crossings over
fish-bearing waters. Crossings on nonfish bearing streams must be designed to
pass wood and sediment expected in the stream reach to reduce the risk of
catastrophic failure of the crossing. Water crossing structures on nonfish
bearing streams in the forest environment that are designed to pass the
100-year flood flow and debris likely to be encountered meet this
standard.
An HPA is required for all construction or repair/
replacement of any structure that crosses a stream, river, or other water body
regardless of the location of the proposed work relative to the OHWL of state
waters. An HPA is also required for bridge painting and other maintenance where
there is potential for paint, sandblasting material, sediments, or bridge parts
to fall into the water. An HPA is not required for utility crossings attached
to bridge structures.
(1)
Description: Water crossings are structures constructed to
facilitate the movement of people, animals, or materials across or over rivers
and other water bodies. These structures include bridges, culverts, fords, and
conduits. This section covers bridges, culverts, and fords; WAC
220-660-270 covers conduits.
Generally, people use bridges to cross over larger streams and rivers, or over
unstable channels; they use culverts to cross over smaller streams and they use
fords when other stream crossing options would result in a greater impact to
fish life and the habitat that supports fish life.
(2)
Fish life concerns:
(a) A person must design water crossing
structures in fish-bearing streams to allow fish to move freely through them at
all flows when fish are expected to move. All water crossings must retain
upstream and downstream connection in order to maintain expected channel
processes. These processes include the movement and distribution of wood and
sediment and shifting channel patterns. Water crossings that are too small in
relation to the stream can block or alter these processes, although some
encroachment of the flood plain and channel migration zone will be approved
when it can be shown that such encroachment has minimal impacts to fish life
and habitat that supports fish life.
(b) Fords have a high potential to generate
and deliver sediment and may impede fish passage. However, under limited
circumstances, fords are appropriate when they provide better protection to
fish life and habitat that supports fish life than other water crossing
structures.
(3)
Permanent water crossing structures - Generally:
(a) The water crossing design must provide
unimpeded passage for all species of adult and juvenile fishes. Passage is
assumed when there are no barriers due to behavioral impediments, excessive
water slope, drop or velocity, shallow flow, lack of surface flow,
uncharacteristically coarse bed material, and other related
conditions.
(b) The design of the
water crossing structure must follow mitigation sequencing to prevent
measurable unmitigated impacts to the expected channel functions and processes
found at the site. The department will make an exception where there are
human-made features in the flood plain that are outside the control of the
applicant and they are unlikely to be removed. By complying with the provisions
under subsections (4) and (6) of this section, the applicant is assumed to
provide these processes and functions.
(c) If channelization, encroachment, or other
human-made changes have degraded the channel in the vicinity of the crossing,
the design must have a similar slope and cross section expected under common
conditions in the reach.
(i) Similar slope:
The slope should be that of a stable channel that would fit within the
geomorphic context of the reach.
(ii) Similar cross section: The cross section
under or within the water crossing must have a channel bed width, a thalweg,
and any overbank area that match the expected stream measurements in order to
limit main channel velocity and scour to prevailing conditions.
(d) A person may propose one of
the following alternative crossing design methods instead of complying with the
provisions under subsections (4) and (6) of this section:
(i) A person can design a water crossing
using any design methodology approved by the department if the method
specifically addresses fish passage, the protection of the habitat that
supports fish life, and the maintenance of expected channel processes defined
by the site conditions.
(ii) A
person may use an alternative design for an individual crossing on a
case-by-case basis. To be approved, the alternative plan must include: Project
objectives with performance measures, inspection schedule, maintenance
triggers, and a contingency plan should the project fail to meet performance
measures. Inspection must include compliance monitoring of performance measures
after construction with an additional inspection three years after
construction. Monitoring reports are required for these two inspections. The
contingency plan is activated when the project fails to meet performance
measures after the three-year inspection.
(iii) A person can use methods found in WAC
220-660-200. Fish passage
improvement structures will be approved where extreme and unusual site
conditions prevent a person from complying with the provisions in this section
provided associated impacts are adequately mitigated.
(e) To determine the average channel bed
width for water crossing structure design, a person must use at least three
typical widths (bankfull or equivalent), measured in a stream reach that is
characteristic of an alluvial or self-forming stream. A person must measure
widths that describe prevailing conditions at straight channel sections and
outside the influence of any culvert, bridge, or other artificial or unique
channel constriction.
(f) When
removing an existing crossing in preparation for a new crossing, a person must
remove all the existing components (such as approach fill, foundations,
stringers, deck, riprap, guide walls, culverts, and aprons) likely to cause
impacts to fish life and the habitat that supports fish life. The department
may approve the partial removal of certain components when leaving them has
been shown to have no measurable, or minor, impact.
(4)
Bridge design:
(a) The bridge must pass water, ice, large
wood and associated woody material, and sediment likely to move under the
bridge during the 100-year flood flows or the design flood flow approved by the
department.
(b) The waterward face
of all bridge elements that may come in contact with waters of the state
including abutments, piers, pilings, sills, foundations, aprons, wing walls,
and approach fill must be landward of the OHWL. The requirement excludes
midchannel piers and protection required at the toe of embankment in confined
channels.
(c) A bridge over a
watercourse with an active flood plain must be designed to prevent a
significant increase in the main channel average velocity (a measure of
encroachment). The bridge is defined as the main bridge span(s) plus flood
plain relief structures and approach road overtopping. This velocity must be
determined at the 100-year flood flow or the design flood flow approved by the
department. The significance threshold should be determined by considering bed
coarsening, scour, backwater, flood plain flow, and related biological and
geomorphological effects typically evaluated in a reach analysis.
(d) A person must design the bridge to
account for the lateral migration expected to occur during the bridge's
lifespan. The department will approve encroachment into the expected pathway of
lateral migration if the design follows the mitigation sequence to protect fish
life and the habitat that supports fish life.
(e) Where there are existing flood control
levees at the bridge construction site, or other structures or improvements of
value that is not the property of the bridge owner but would constrain the
construction of a bridge, the department may approve a shorter bridge span than
would otherwise be required to meet the requirements in this section.
(f) The design must have at least three feet
of clearance between the bottom of the bridge structure and the water surface
at the 100-year peak flow unless engineering justification shows a lower
clearance will allow the free passage of anticipated debris.
(g) The bridge design must minimize the need
for scour protection. Where midchannel piers are necessary, design them so no
additional scour protection is required. If scour protection is unavoidable,
the design must minimize the scour protection to the amount needed to protect
piers and abutments. The design must specify the size and placement of the
scour protection so it withstands expected peak flows.
(5)
Bridge construction:
(a) If excavation or other construction
activities take place waterward of the OHWL, the work area must be isolated
from the stream flow (if present) by using a cofferdam, bypass, or similar
structure.
(b) A person must
minimize damage to the bed and banks when placing the bridge
structure.
(c) Biotechnical slope
protection outside the bridge shadow is preferred.
(6)
Culvert design:
(a) Stream simulation design:
(i) A stream simulation culvert must be
designed and constructed to comply with the requirements of this
subsection.
(ii) The width of the
channel-bed inside a stream simulation culvert at the elevation of the stream
bed can be determined in one of two ways:
(A)
The bed width may be calculated by using any published stream simulation design
methodology approved by the department.
(B) The bed width of an individual culvert
may be determined on a case-by-case basis with an approved alternative plan
that includes project objectives, inspection, maintenance, and contingency
components. Inspection must include compliance monitoring after construction,
and effectiveness monitoring after three years. Maintenance and contingency are
triggered when project fails to meet objectives.
(iii) The stream simulation culvert must be
set at the same gradient as the prevailing stream gradient unless engineering
justification for an alternative slope is approved by the department.
(iv) The slope of the bed inside a
stream-simulation culvert must not exceed the slope of the upstream channel by
more than twenty-five percent.
(v)
The stream simulation culvert must be countersunk a minimum of thirty percent
and a maximum of fifty percent of the culvert rise, but not less than two feet.
Alternative depths of culvert fill may be accepted with engineering
justification that considers channel degradation and total scour.
(vi) The median particle size of sediment
placed inside the stream-simulation culvert must be approximately twenty
percent of the median particle size found in a reference reach of the same
stream. The department may approve exceptions if the proposed alternative
sediment is appropriate for the circumstances.
(b) No-slope design:
(i) The stream channel in which a no-slope
culvert will be placed must generally have a channel bed width that is ten feet
or less and a gradient less than three percent. However, in some site-specific
situations the department may approve no-slope in channels with a gradient up
to five percent.
(ii) The length of
the culvert must not exceed seventy-five feet.
(iii) A no-slope culvert must be designed and
constructed to comply with the following requirements:
(A) The culvert is installed at a zero
gradient.
(B) The width of the
channel-bed inside a no-slope culvert at the elevation of the stream bed must
be equal to or greater than the average channel bed width.
(C) The no-slope culvert is countersunk a
minimum of twenty percent of the culvert rise at the culvert outlet downstream
and a maximum of forty-percent of the culvert rise at the culvert inlet
upstream.
(D) Combining the
requirements for culvert width and countersinking, the culvert must meet the
following requirements:
(I) For a circular
culvert, the minimum culvert diameter must be equal to or greater than the
average channel bed width plus twenty-five percent.
(II) For a culvert with an oval cross section
(elliptical, pipe arch, or "squashed" pipe) the horizontal width must be equal
to or greater than the average channel bed width plus twenty-five
percent.
(III) For a box or pipe
arch culvert, the span must be equal to or greater than the average channel bed
width.
(E) The no-slope
culvert must be filled to the depth of the countersink provided in (b)(iii)(C)
of this subsection with material similar to what is found in the adjacent
channel stream bed, unless either of the following conditions exist:
(I) The culvert is located in a wetland or in
an area where the channel-bed is predominately fine sediment and the culvert
will be backwatered; or
(II) The
culvert will fill quickly because of the high rate of sediment transported
through the culvert and will not cause excessive cutting or slumping of the
upstream channel.
(7)
Temporary culvert design
requirements:
(a) The department must
determine allowable placement of temporary culvert and time limitations based
on the specific fish resources of concern at the proposed water crossing
location.
(b) The design of the
temporary crossing must maintain structural integrity at the peak flow expected
to occur while the crossing is in place.
(c) Temporary culverts must provide unimpeded
fish passage in locations where fish passage concerns exist. In site-specific
situations, the department may approve a temporary culvert that does not meet
all fish passage criteria. These situations may include streams where there is
limited fish movement and presence, and where the use of a temporary culvert
will result in fewer adverse impacts over the long term.
(d) A person must remove the temporary
culvert and block all approaches to vehicular traffic before the HPA
expires.
(8)
Emergency culvert requirements:
(a) When there is an immediate threat to
life, the public, private property, or of environmental degradation, a culvert
may be replaced with one that is the same size or larger than the existing one.
If the emergency crossing did not have a culvert or the size is not known, the
emergency culvert should be large enough to safely pass the 100-year flood
event with consideration for debris and sediment. In extreme circumstances, the
department may approve the use of any available culvert.
(b) Fish passage must be provided at the
times of the year when fish are expected to move. If the culvert design does
not provide unimpeded fish passage, a person can use methods found in WAC
220-660-200 (fish passage
improvement structures) to pass fish until a culvert is constructed.
(9)
Culvert
construction:
(a) A person must
establish the culvert invert elevation with reference point(s) or benchmark(s)
created prior to starting work on this project. The reference point(s) must be
clearly marked and preserved for post-project compliance. Prior to backfilling,
the invert elevation, as stated on the plans, must be confirmed relative to the
reference points with at least a construction-grade leveling device (such as an
optical auto-level or laser level).
(b) A person must install the culvert in the
dry or in isolation from the stream flow by using a bypass channel or culvert,
or by pumping the stream flow around the work area. The department may grant
exception if installing the culvert in the flowing stream reduces siltation or
turbidity.
(c) A person must embed
the top of footings of bottomless culverts sufficiently below potential scour
depth to prevent exposure of the footing surface and undermining.
(d) The owner(s) must maintain the culvert to
ensure it complies with subsection (3) of this section (general design
requirement for water crossing structures).
(e) If the culvert becomes a hindrance to
fish passage, the owner must obtain an HPA and provide prompt repair.
(10)
Permanent ford
design:
(a) A person must design and
maintain a ford so the ford does not create a channel constriction, impede fish
passage, block debris passage, or degrade water quality to the detriment of
fish life.
(b) The department will
authorize construction of new fords in limited situations when it is the least
impacting water crossing option. The following are examples of situations where
the department may authorize a ford:
(i)
Where there is no maintenance access during winter months or early spring and
the crossing has a high risk of failure from rain-on-snow events;
(ii) The road is seasonally inaccessible due
to snow pack, weather, or other conditions that seasonally limit access to the
water crossing structure;
(iii) The
stream has extreme seasonal flow variations and low flows during anticipated
ford use;
(iv) The channel has low
bank height and low gradient approaches;
(v) The stream has dynamic flood plains, such
as alluvial fans; or
(vi) The
stream is subject to mass wasting events, debris transport, or extreme peak
flows.
(c) Permanent
fords must not impede fish passage.
(d) Fords must be located outside of all
known or suspected fish spawning areas such as pool tailouts.
(e) Fords must only be used during periods of
no or low stream flow (whether dry or frozen) to minimize the delivery of
sediment to the stream.
(f) Vented
(grade-separated) fords are preferred over at-grade fords because there is less
aquatic disturbance and delivery of sediment and contaminants when traffic is
separated from flowing water.
(11)
Temporary ford design:
(a) The department may permit temporary fords
only during the time of year that avoids high stream flows or expected fish
spawning or migration.
(b) If fill
is associated with the driving surface of a temporary ford, it must consist of
clean washed gravel between one-quarter inch and four inches in
diameter.
(c) If the natural stream
bed is composed of material smaller than gravel, the temporary ford design must
maintain a positive separation between the watercourse bed and all fill
associated with the ford to ensure that material used in ford construction is
removable.
(12)
Ford construction:
(a) Fords
must be constructed during periods of low or no stream flow or in isolation
from flowing water.
(b) Fords must
be constructed perpendicular to the stream flow, or as close to perpendicular
as practicable.
(c) Fords must be
constructed using material approved by the department.
(d) If the stream bed does not have a firm
rock or gravel base, install clean, washed rock or gravel to reduce
sedimentation. Broken concrete and pavement or other debris should not be used
to construct hardened fords. Placement of material should be limited to the
approaches and crossing.
(e) A
person must countersink the prism of the ford below the watercourse bed. A
person must design the prism to withstand overtopping flood events, and natural
debris.
(f) Fill associated with
the driving surface of a permanent ford must consist of material that will not
attract spawning fish.
(g) A person
must protect the driving surface of ford approaches from erosion to ensure that
erodible fine silt does not enter waters of the state.
(h) Fords must be regularly inspected and
maintained to provide for fish passage and maintain water quality.
(13)
Permanent removal of a
water crossing (abandonment):
(a) When
removing a water crossing without replacing it, a person must comply with the
following provisions. In all instances a person must protect the job site from
erosion and plant vegetation as necessary to restore the banks and other areas
disturbed during construction or removal at the site.
(b) When removing temporary crossings, a
person must remove the temporary culvert, bridge, ford, and any imported fill.
The site must be restored to a similar width, depth, gradient, and substrate
composition as the channel segments upstream and downstream from the crossing.
If water-rounded granular materials were used for fill, and they are similar to
those found in the existing channel bed, the department may allow the materials
to remain on the site.
(c) When
removing permanent crossings, a person must remove all the components of a
bridge or culvert crossing (approach fill, sills, stringers, deck, riprap,
guardrails, etc.). The department may approve leaving trees or other
vegetation, fill materials when appropriate, or untreated log bridge stringers.
The site must be restored to the original contours or a configuration approved
by the department.