Current through Reg. 49, No. 38; September 20, 2024
(a) Purpose. The
purpose of this section is to establish procedures for hearing public comment
at Governing Board meetings open to the public held by the Texas Department of
Housing and Community Affairs in accordance with §
2306.032(f)
and §
2306.066(d)
of the Tex. Gov't Code.
(b)
Procedures for taking public comment.
(1) At
each meeting open to the public the Governing Board (Board) shall provide
opportunity for members of the public to make:
(A) General public comment after the Board
has taken action on all posted agenda items on which it intends to take action,
general public comment on matters of relevance to the Department's business, or
requests that the Board place specific items on future agendas for
consideration. It is the prerogative of the Board Chair to place reasonable
limits on public comment. Handouts of printed materials are permitted only as
provided for in paragraph (6) of this subsection; and
(B) Specific public comment on each posted
agenda item after the presentation made by Department staff and motions made by
the Board. For purposes of this rule, the Board may consider the staff's
presentation to be staff's written presentation in the Board's meeting book
posted on the Department's website, or additional printed materials only as
provided for in paragraph (6) of this subsection.
(2) The opportunity for general public
comment under paragraph (1)(A) of this subsection may not be used to advocate
for or against any specific action relating to any posted item or for or
against any pending application. The opportunity for any such testimony is to
be limited to the appointed time when action on such matter is requested to be
formally considered as a posted agenda item as described in paragraph (1)(B) of
this subsection.
(3) At the time
general or specific public comment is taken, speakers should be prepared to
come promptly to the podium or other place designated for speakers. They may,
if they wish, agree among themselves on an order in which they will speak, or
this may be directed by the Board Chair. If a large number of speakers wish to
testify, the Chair may, in his or her reasonable discretion, establish
appropriate limits on the total amount of time to be devoted to testimony on
any given item or items. As each individual speaker begins his or her
testimony, they must state on the record their name and on whose behalf they
are speaking, and sign in on a sheet provided by staff to indicate the correct
spelling of their name and on whose behalf they are speaking.
(4) Individuals present at the meeting, who
wish to register their position for or against a posted agenda item, but do not
wish to speak, may do so by submitting a comment registration form with the
secretary of the meeting, or another person designated by the Board Chair. The
comment registration form must state the commenter's name, whom they represent,
the action item to which their comment relates, their position, and must be
signed by the commenter. At the end of the public comment on the item the Board
Chair will have registered positions for and against read into the record. It
is the Board Chair's discretion to determine if similar comments submitted are
aggregated and reported as a total number providing their position, as opposed
to reading all names into the record.
(5) Additional limits on public comment.
(A) The Board Chair, in her/his sole
discretion, may additionally limit the number and length of presentations of
public comment, both general and specific, at any time during a meeting based
on a consideration of:
(i) the number of
persons wishing to give public comment;
(ii) the number of agenda items to be
heard;
(iii) the time available for
the meeting; and
(iv) the risk of
losing a quorum of Board members.
(B) If the Board Chair limits presentations,
she or he will not limit them in a manner that inappropriately favors a
particular point of view.
(C) The
Board Chair may, in her or his reasonable discretion, grant deference to
elected officials and other persons who have traveled great distances.
Deference to elected officials may include, but is not limited to reading
letters from elected officials to the Board into the record.
(6) Presenting printed materials.
An individual providing testimony to the Board may provide printed materials
only if they are provided as outlined in subparagraphs (A) - (C) of this
paragraph:
(A) In order to ensure that members
of the Board and the public are given an opportunity to review any such
materials, they must be provided to the Department staff not less than five
business days prior to the meeting at which they are to be. This is to enable
staff to post them on the Department's website not later than the third day
before the date of the meeting, as provided for in Tex. Gov't Code §
2306.032(c).
They must be made available in Adobe Acrobat (pdf) electronic format;
(B) Department staff will post such materials
to the Department's website no later than the third day before the meeting at
which they are to be used;
(C) In
exceptional circumstances the Board Chair may, in her/his sole discretion, and
only after giving Board members an opportunity to object, allow materials to be
provided at a meeting in hard copy format provided:
(i) they are delivered to staff prior to the
start of the meeting so that staff may log in the materials and the Board Chair
may review for acceptance under this subsection. Materials may not be handed
directly by the public to a Board member on the dais;
(ii) they are not so voluminous as to cause
inordinate delay while members of the Board and public review them;
(iii) they are provided in hard copy format
to all members of the public in attendance;
(iv) they are also provided to staff in Adobe
Acrobat (pdf) format for inclusion in the electronic records of Board materials
available to the public via the Department's website; and
(v) if the materials involve large size
photos, maps, charts, or other information to be displayed for the Board, an
identical copy must be displayed to the public attendees.
(D) Persons seeking allowance of written
materials under paragraph (6)(C) of this subsection should be aware that their
proffered materials may be disallowed, and they should always be prepared to
proceed with a verbal presentation within the time constraints for public
speaking at Board meetings.
(E) If
materials submitted relate to a competitive Application under any Department
program, including Chapters 11 and 13 of this title (relating to Qualified
Allocation Plan (QAP) and Multifamily Direct Loan Rule, respectively), such
materials provided under either subparagraphs (A) or (C) of this paragraph may
be prohibited from presentation to the Board under applicable rules or
statute.
(c) To
the extent that subsection (b) of this section, or the Board Chair, place
limitations on the amount of time that a member of the public may address the
Board, a member of the public who addresses the Board through an interpreter
will be given at least twice the amount of time as a member of the public who
does not require the assistance of an interpreter in order to ensure that
non-English speakers receive the same opportunity to address the
Board.