The proper application of infection control principles will
minimize any risk of transmission of Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) from
Health Care Worker to patients, patient to Health Care Workers, or patient to
patient. HIV infection alone does not justify or support limiting a Health Care
Worker's professional duties. The current assessment of the risk that infected
Health Care Workers will transmit HIV to patients during invasive procedures
does not justify mandatory testing of Health Care Workers. Limitations, if any,
should be determined on a case-by-case basis after consideration of the factors
that influence transmission risk, including inability and/or unwillingness to
comply with infection control standards and/or functional impairments which
interfere with the job performance of the Health Care Worker.
(1) Definitions - For the purpose of these
regulations, the terms used herein are defined as follows:
(a) Chief Medical Officer - the state health
officer, or his designee, appointed by the commissioner of health, who is
responsible for and advises the Commissioner and department on all matters of
state health policy, including public health.
(b) Commissioner - the Commissioner of Health
or his designee.
(c) Health Care
Worker (HCW) - Any orthopedic physician assistant whose activities involve
contact with patients or with blood or other body fluids in a health care
setting, including students, residents and trainees.
(d) Hospital HIV Confidential Expert Review
Panel (Hospital HIV Review Panel) - As established by Tennessee Department of
Health rules 1200-14-03-.01 to .03 this is a Tennessee hospital committee,
appointed by the hospital Chief of Staff, composed and functioning in
accordance with the guidelines of the American Hospital Association and the
provisions of Tennessee Code Annotated, Section 63-6-219 which is convened with
the purpose of establishing practice standards, on a case by case basis, for
any HIV infected HCW, employed at or practicing their profession in the
hospital, at the HCW's request.
(e)
Tennessee Department of Health HIV Confidential Expert Review Panel (TDH HIV
Review Panel) - As established by Tennessee Department of health rules
1200-14-03-.01 to .03 this is a Tennessee Department of Health committee,
appointed by the Chief Medical Officer of the State, which is convened with the
purpose of establishing practice standards for any HIV infected HCW.
(f) Universal Precautions - an approach to
infection control according to which all human blood and certain human body
fluids are to be treated as if known to be infectious for HIV and/or other
blood-borne pathogens. In order to prevent the transmission of blood-borne
infections, Universal Precautions requires the blanket implementation of
infection control procedures, including, in regard to the use and disposal of
needles and other sharp instruments, appropriate care and proper utilization of
handwashing and protective barriers. Guidelines for Universal Precautions are
published by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and can be
found in CDC Recommendations For Prevention of HIV Transmission In Health-Care
Settings. [MMWR 1987; 36 (suppl. no. 2S) pp 1-18s] and CDC Update: Universal
Precautions For Prevention of Transmission of Human Immunodeficiency Virus,
Hepatitis B Virus, and Other Bloodborne Pathogens In Health Care Settings.
[MMWR 1988; 37: pp 377-82, 387-8,] or their successor publications and/or more
current updates.
(2)
Administration and Implementation of the Policy
(a) All HCW's shall adhere to Universal
Precautions in the provision of health care services. HCW's must comply with
current guidelines for disinfection and sterilization of reusable devices used
in medical procedures. All HCW's shall receive periodic training in infection
control procedures, including Universal Precautions.
(b) All HCW's are encouraged to undergo
personal assessments to determine their need for HIV testing. These assessments
should include consideration of known high- risk behavior as well as risks
associated with health care-related occupational exposure. If they are at risk,
HCW's should determine their HIV status in order to protect and improve their
health and to receive appropriate counseling. The decision to be tested for HIV
is the responsibility of the individual HCW.
(c) Pursuant to Tennessee Department of
Health rule 1200-14-03-.03, the Chief Medical Officer of the State of Tennessee
will, at the request of an HIV infected HCW, convene an expert review panel to
provide advice and give guidelines for assuring patient safety in the provision
of the HCW's health care services.
(d) Pursuant to Tennessee Department of
Health rule 1200-14-03-.03, the Chief Medical Officer of the State of Tennessee
may, at the request of an HIV infected HCW, allow a Tennessee licensed hospital
to convene a hospital based Hospital HIV Review Panel to provide advice and
give guidelines for assuring patient safety in the provision of the HCW's
health care services in lieu of presenting the matter to the TDH HIV Review
Panel. All records and information held by the hospital for review by this
panel relating to known or suspected cases of infection with HIV in any HCW are
strictly confidential, shall not be released or made public by the Department
or the hospital or the Hospital HIV Review Panel upon subpoena, court order,
discovery, search warrant or otherwise, except as may be authorized under
T.C.A. §§
10-7-504(a), 63-6-219 or 68-10-113.
(e) The review panel may recommend
modification of procedures, notification of patients, or monitoring of
restrictions if the panel determines that a significant risk of transmission to
patients may exist. The recommendations of the review panel will then be set
out in a written agreement and, if agreed to by the HCW, such agreement will be
evidenced by the HCW's signature.
1. If the
infected HCW is dissatisfied with the recommendation of the Hospital HIV Review
Panel, the HCW may appeal to the TDH HIV Review Panel for a de novo
evaluation.
2. If the infected HCW
is dissatisfied with the recommendation of the TDH HIV Review Panel, the HCW
may request a contested case hearing before the Commissioner, in the manner
provided by the terms of the Tennessee Uniform Administrative Procedures Act
(UAPA), Title 4, Chapter 5 of the Tennessee Code Annotated.
3. Willful or knowing or repeated rejection
or violation of the panel's recommendations by the HCW, or inability to follow
the panel's recommendation because of mental or physical disease or defect,
shall be reported to the Tennessee Department of Health Division of Health
Related Boards as indicated by the evaluation, for appropriate disciplinary
action.
(f) In
determining the advisability of voluntary HIV testing and in evaluating the
medical practices of an infected HCW, the expert review panel and/or the
individual HCW should refer to the current disease control guidelines
established by the CDC and disease control standards recognized by national
professional medical organizations. In addition, the panel should refer to the
following:
1. Many procedures pose negligible
risk to the patient of exposure to infection through the HCW's blood when
performed using standard infection control techniques, including Universal
Precautions. Examples of these procedures include: physical examinations; blood
pressure checks; eye examinations; phlebotomy; administration of intramuscular,
intradermal or subcutaneous injections (i.e., vaccinations); needle biopsies,
needle aspirations or lumbar punctures; angiographic procedures; vaginal, oral
or rectal exams; endoscopic and bronchoscopic procedures; and insertion or
maintenance of peripheral and central intravascular lines, nasogastric tubes,
endotracheal tubes, rectal tubes or urinary catheters. Even if a HCW were to
sustain an injury while performing these procedures, it is highly unlikely that
the patient would be exposed to the HCW's blood. Thus, no restriction on
performance of these procedures are necessary provided that standard infection
control practices are used.
2.
Those HCW's for whom HIV counseling and testing has been previously recommended
by the Public Health Services (PHS), due to occupational or non-occupational
exposure to HIV, are encouraged to voluntarily ascertain their HIV antibody
status. HCW's (1) who are infected with HIV, and (2) who perform surgical or
obstetrical procedures that involve entry into tissues, cavities, or organs,
should not continue to perform those procedures until they have sought counsel
from the expert review panel.
3.
Among the items the review panel should consider, on an individual basis, in
evaluation of an HIV seropositive HCW are the following:
(i) Whether the HCW performs procedures in
which injury could result in contamination of a patient's body cavity,
subcutaneous tissues, or muccous membranes by the HCW's blood (e.g., procedures
in which hands may be in contact with sharp instruments, objects, or sharp
tissues inside a patient's body cavity, particularly when the hands are not
completely visible);
(ii) Factors
affecting the performance of procedures by the individual HCW (e.g., techniques
used, skill and experience, and compliance with recommended infection control
practices); and
(iii) The medical
condition of the HCW (e.g., the presence of physical conditions or mental
impairment that may interfere with the HCW's ability to perform these
procedures safely).
4.
Depending upon its individualized evaluation, the panel should determine
whether or under what circumstances the HCW may continue to perform or be
restricted from performing procedures. In some circumstances, the panel may
recommend modification and monitoring or procedures performed by the HCW to
decrease the risk.
(i) If the panel determines
that this HCW's performance of all or certain procedures poses a significant
risk of infection to patients, and such significant risk cannot be eliminated
by reasonable accommodation, then the HCW should be restricted from performing
such procedures.
(ii) If the panel
determines that the HCW's performance does not pose a significant risk for
infection of patients during the procedures within HCW's scope of practice,
then no restrictions are indicated. Hence, notification of the patient
regarding HCW's infection status prior to the performance of such procedures is
not necessary.
(g) HCW's whose practices are modified
because of their HIV infection status should, whenever possible, be provided
opportunities to continue appropriate patient-care activities. Career
counseling and job retraining should be encouraged to promote the continued use
of the HCW's talents, knowledge and skills.