Current through September 24, 2024
(1) General
(a) This rule is promulgated to establish
guidelines and procedures by which applicants investigate and remediate sites
to preserve the right to seek reimbursement of expenses from the
DCERF.
(b) This rule applies to all
applicants.
(c) Nothing in this
rule shall be construed to prohibit the implementation of initial abatement and
site stabilization measures upon the discovery of a release of drycleaning
solvent. The costs of such measures may be DCERF eligible regardless of
compliance with this rule, in accordance with subparagraph (3)(c) of Rule
0400-15-03-.08.
(2) Application for Entry into the
DCERP
(a) Persons wishing to apply for entry
into the DCERP and reimbursement of costs from the DCERF for eligible expenses
shall first submit an application for the Commissioner's review and
approval.
(b) An application must
be submitted by the applicant to the Commissioner in a format determined by the
Commissioner. The application shall be complete, legible, and accurate, and
shall include the following:
1. All
applications shall contain verification that the subject facility is currently
registered with the Department, that all applicable fees and surcharges are
paid, and that the facility is not included in a site that has been accepted
into the voluntary cleanup oversight and assistance program pursuant to T.C.A.
§ 68-212-224.
2. For both
active and abandoned facilities, any known past recorded incidents of
noncompliance shall be referenced in the application (for example, any previous
inspection letters or orders from the Commissioner or a local department of
health that documented violations). If the facility is active, the application
shall also contain verification that the facility is in compliance with Rule
0400-15-03-.04.
3. In all applications, a person with
appropriate legal authority shall grant the applicant, the applicant's DCAC(s),
and the Commissioner the right of ingress and egress to the facility to perform
the activities authorized by the DCERP.
4. Applications for active facilities or
abandoned facilities (where the application is filed by the operator of the
drycleaning facility) must either:
(i)
Include a certification by the operator that the operator has full legal
authority to authorize the Commissioner's access of the facility for all
solvent impact assessments and response actions; or
(ii) If the operator lacks such legal
authority, the application must be filed jointly by the operator and the
property owner. The applicant(s) shall designate the person who will receive
DCERF reimbursement under the DCERP and the applicant's point of contact
concerning the application.
5. Applications for abandoned facilities
(filed by the impacted third parties) must be filed jointly by the impacted
third party and the property owner if other than the impacted third party. The
applicant must certify to the best of their knowledge that the facility meets
all requirements for DCERF eligibility. The applicants shall designate the
person who will receive DCERF reimbursement under the DCERP and the applicant's
point of contact concerning the application.
6. An impacted third party who is not the
real property owner of the facility may file an application, without other
signatories, if a previous application has been filed and accepted for the
facility which grants ingress and egress. If no previous application has been
filed and approved for the facility the impacted third party must file an
application jointly with the real property owner.
7. Any other information requested by the
Commissioner.
(c) The
Commissioner shall confirm in writing to the applicant that an application has
been received and identify any alleged deficiencies. Subject to the
availability of funds in the DCERF, and after receipt and evaluation of a
complete application, the Commissioner shall notify the applicant to proceed
with a facility inspection if the site is an active facility. The Commissioner
may also require a facility inspection of an abandoned facility. Based on the
applicant's DCERF eligibility certification in the application, the facility
inspection shall preliminarily be considered a DCERF eligible expense, subject
to the appropriate deductible.
(3) If a facility inspection is required by
the Commissioner, the applicant's DCAC shall perform the facility inspection.
At a minimum, the facility inspection shall include a records review and an
on-site inspection. The records review shall include, but not necessarily be
limited to, solvent purchases, waste handling practices, equipment maintenance
and repair, equipment upgrades, and other items requested by the Commissioner.
The on-site inspection shall include, but not necessarily be limited to,
evaluation of equipment, operations, containment, solvent storage, waste
disposal, signs or evidence of a release, compliance with BMPs, and other items
requested by the Commissioner. The applicant shall submit a facility inspection
report to the Commissioner in a format and according to a schedule determined
by the Commissioner. A facility may be re-inspected by Department
staff.
(4) Fund Eligibility
Determination
(a) After review of the
application and facility inspection, the Commissioner shall notify applicants
in writing of the Commissioner's determination on acceptance into the DCERP and
DCERF eligibility. If the applicant is denied entry into the DCERP or DCERF,
the notification shall include the reasons for denial. The reasons for denial
shall include:
1. The applicant does not meet
the definition of a current or prior owner or operator of an active or
abandoned drycleaning facility, in-state wholesale distribution facility, or an
impacted third party;
2. The
facility does not meet the definition of an abandoned or active drycleaning
facility, or in-state wholesale distribution facility, or the facility is
ineligible pursuant to T.C.A. 68-217-107(c);
3. Failure of an abandoned or active
drycleaning facility or in-state wholesale distribution facility to have been
registered during any active operations after June 13, 1995;
4. Failure to pay all applicable registration
fees, penalties, and interest;
5.
Failure to pay all applicable surcharges and penalties;
6. Failure to implement applicable BMPs at a
drycleaning facility or in-state wholesale distribution facility;
7. Failure to conduct an appropriate facility
inspection;
8. Failure to comply
with the proper facility closure procedures in accordance with this
rule;
9. The facility is included
in a site that has been accepted into the Department's voluntary cleanup
oversight and assistance program pursuant to T.C.A. §
68-212-224;
10. The facility has
already accrued costs or is subject to a pending or final enforcement action
pursuant to the Hazardous Waste Management Acts of 1977 or 1983, Title 68,
Chapter 212; or
11. Failure to
comply with other requirements of this chapter or the Act.
(b) If fees, surcharges, interest, or
penalties have not been paid, the applicant will not be accepted into the DCERP
and will not be eligible for reimbursement of response costs other than the
initial facility inspection until all money owed has been paid.
(c) If applicable BMPs have not been
implemented, the applicant will not be accepted into the DCERP and will not be
eligible for reimbursement of response costs other than the initial facility
inspection. If the applicant corrects any deficiencies, the applicant may be
accepted into the DCERP and may be eligible for fund reimbursement for any
releases that the applicant can demonstrate, to the satisfaction of the
Commissioner, to have occurred after the date the deficiencies were corrected.
The applicant may request follow-up inspections after correcting deficiencies.
However, all facility inspections subsequent to the initial facility inspection
conducted at the applicant's request will not be DCERF reimbursable.
(d) Real Property Owner as Impacted Third
Party
1. Notwithstanding the fact that the
facility inspection reveals that applicable BMPs have not been implemented, an
impacted third party that has never operated the facility and that is the real
property owner of the facility will remain eligible for reimbursement of
response costs beyond the initial facility inspection unless:
(i) Such party:
(I) Had actual knowledge of the operator's
failure to implement BMPs prior to the release, and
(II) Failed to notify the Department of such
operator's failure within 60 days of such knowledge; or
(ii) Such party failed to make a good faith
effort to require the operator's compliance with applicable BMP requirements.
For purposes of this rule, a good faith effort to require the operator's
compliance with applicable BMPs means that the real property owner:
(I) At the first reasonable opportunity,
imposes an obligation under the lease or other contractual agreement on the
operator to comply with applicable BMPs; and
(II) Takes any other reasonable action to
encourage implementation of BMPs by the operator.
2. Notwithstanding compliance with
the provisions of part 1. of this subparagraph, where the facility inspection
or other documentation or investigation reveals that applicable BMPs have not
been implemented, in order for an impacted third party who is the real property
owner of the site to remain eligible for DCERF reimbursement:
(i) The site must be an abandoned facility;
or
(ii) The impacted third party
must terminate the tenancy of the operator of the drycleaning
facility.
3. Eligibility
for DCERF reimbursement of the real property owner of the site shall not
relieve the facility operator from liability for any release under any other
law or for third party claims.
4.
An impacted third party that is not the owner of the real property on which the
facility is located is not responsible for the failure to implement BMPs and
need not cure such failure. However, upon application by an impacted third
party who is not the owner of the real property on which the facility is
located, the Commissioner shall notify the operator of the facility and the
real property owner of the impacted third party's application and provide them
with the opportunity to apply for the DCERF within a specified time period. If
neither the operator of the facility nor the real property owner enters the
DCERP and corrects the deficiencies, the Commissioner may initiate activities
to evaluate the site under Chapter 0400-15-01 Inactive Hazardous Substance Site
Remedial Action Program. Eligibility for DCERF reimbursement of an impacted
third party that is not the owner of the real property on which the facility is
located shall not relieve the facility operator or the real property owner of
the site from liability for any release under any other law or for third party
claims, including without limitation, liability for reimbursement of response
costs paid out of the Hazardous Waste Remedial Action Fund.
(e) If any deficiencies are either
uncorrectable or not corrected within a time frame specified by the
Commissioner, the applicant may be denied DCERF access. If DCERF access is
denied, the applicant shall have 30 days from the Commissioner's mailing of the
notice to appeal the denial to the Commissioner in the manner set forth in
Section 5(a) of Rule
0400-15-03-.03. If the
Commissioner upholds the denial of DCERF access, or if an appeal is not made
within 30 days, the Commissioner may revoke the operator's Certificate of
Registration pursuant to Rule
0400-15-03-.10, notify wholesale
distributors of such revocation, and initiate activities to evaluate the site
under Chapter 0400-15-01 Inactive Hazardous Substance Site Remedial Action
Program.
(5)
Prioritization Investigation
(a) For sites
that receive a notice of DCERF eligibility, the applicant shall perform a
prioritization investigation according to a format established by the
Commissioner. The applicant shall submit a work plan; a cost proposal
including, but not limited to, a breakdown of cost by category listed in the
reimbursement request; a maximum cost that may not be exceeded in the
prioritization investigation; and a schedule for implementation of the
prioritization investigation. The applicant shall make any changes to the work
plan, cost proposal, or schedule of implementation required by the
Commissioner. Subject to the availability of funds in the DCERF, approval of
the work plan, cost proposal, and approval of the proposed schedule, the
Commissioner shall authorize implementation and notify the applicant to proceed
with the prioritization investigation. The PEP shall implement the
prioritization investigation as required by the Commissioner. Following the
prioritization investigation, the applicant shall submit the results of the
prioritization investigation to the Commissioner according to a schedule and in
a format determined by the Commissioner. The applicant may perform activities
in addition to work requested by the Commissioner at the prioritization
investigation stage; however, only activities specifically pre-approved by the
Commissioner shall be DCERF eligible expenses for the prioritization
investigation. If additional activities are performed, results of the
additional work shall be submitted to the Commissioner within 45 days of the
completion of any phase of additional activities.
(b) Once the prioritization investigation is
completed and a report is submitted to the Commissioner, the Commissioner shall
evaluate all pertinent information and make a determination for further
investigation and remediation of any release of drycleaning solvent. At the
Commissioner's discretion, a prioritization investigation may also be performed
by the Commissioner.
(6)
Prioritization for Further Investigation or Interim Action
(a) The Commissioner shall utilize the
prioritization investigation report and other applicable information to
prioritize approved sites for further investigation or interim
action.
(b) Subject to the
availability of funds in the DCERF, additional activities will be approved at
sites in accordance with the priority ranking schedule.
(c) At all stages within the DCERP, the
approval of additional work to be funded by the DCERP will be done with
consideration for the relative threats to human health and the environment
associated with each site. Sites in the DCERP are at any time subject to
reprioritization by the Commissioner based upon the receipt of additional data
that may affect the prioritization determination.
(7) Implementation of Interim Actions
(a) Interim Action
1. The Commissioner shall notify the
applicant of the Commissioner's determination of the need for interim action
within 60 days of receiving a complete prioritization investigation. Subject to
the availability of funds in the DCERF, the Commissioner shall notify the
applicant to prepare a work plan, cost proposal, and schedule of implementation
to perform interim action, which shall be submitted to the Commissioner
according to the schedule and in the format required by the Commissioner. The
applicant shall make any changes to the work plan, cost proposal, or schedule
of implementation required by the Commissioner.
2. Subject to the availability of funds in
the DCERF, approval of the work plan, approval of the cost proposal, and
approval of the proposed schedule, the Commissioner shall authorize
implementation and notify the applicant to proceed with the interim action. The
applicant shall implement the interim action as approved by the Commissioner.
The Commissioner may declare the applicant ineligible for reimbursement if the
interim action is not performed in accordance with the schedule and work plan
requested by the Commissioner. The Commissioner may declare the applicant
ineligible for reimbursement if the solvent impact assessment is not performed
in accordance with the schedule and work plan requested by the
Commissioner.
3. Following the
interim action, the applicant shall submit the interim action report to the
Commissioner according to a schedule and in a format determined by the
Commissioner. If the applicant or the Commissioner performed interim action at
the site, then the site will be re-prioritized for
investigation.
(b) Solvent
Impact Assessments
1. The Commissioner shall
notify the applicant of the Commissioner's determination of the need for a
solvent impact assessment within 60 days of receiving a complete prioritization
investigation. Subject to the availability of funds in the DCERF, the
Commissioner shall notify the applicant to prepare a work plan, cost proposal,
and schedule of implementation to perform the solvent impact assessment, which
shall be submitted to the Commissioner for approval according to the schedule
and in the format required by the Commissioner. The applicant shall make any
changes to the work plan, cost proposal, or schedule of implementation required
by the Commissioner.
2. Subject to
the availability of funds in the DCERF, approval of the work plan, approval of
the cost proposal, and approval of the proposed schedule, the Commissioner
shall authorize implementation and notify the applicant to proceed with the
solvent impact assessment. The applicant shall implement the solvent impact
assessment as approved by the Commissioner. Following the investigation, the
applicant shall submit the solvent impact assessment report to the Commissioner
according to a schedule and in a format determined by the Commissioner. The
Commissioner may declare the applicant ineligible for reimbursement if the
solvent impact assessment is not performed in accordance with the schedule and
work plan requested by the Commissioner.
3. Unless required by subparagraph (6)(f) of
Rule 0400-15-03-.08, minor
adjustments in the approved work plan, as required based on field or subsurface
conditions, do not require approval by the Commissioner.
(c) Supplemental Investigations
1. If the Commissioner requires the applicant
to perform supplemental investigation at the site, the applicant shall submit
an addendum work plan to conduct the necessary investigation, a cost proposal,
and schedule to the Commissioner according to the schedule and in the format
requested by the Commissioner. The applicant shall make any changes to the work
plan, cost proposal, or schedule of implementation required by the
Commissioner.
2. Subject to the
availability of funds in the DCERF, approval of the work plan, approval of the
cost proposal, and approval of the proposed schedule, the Commissioner shall
authorize implementation and notify the applicant to implement the work plan as
approved.
3. Following completion
of the supplemental investigation, the applicant shall submit the investigation
report to the Commissioner according to a schedule and in the format requested
by the Commissioner.
(d)
Investigation or Interim Action Report
An investigation or interim action report shall include a
description of activities undertaken during the investigation or interim
action, observations made, sampling results, any adjustments to the work plan,
and other information required by the Commissioner.
(8) Remedial Alternatives Study
If requested in writing by the Commissioner following the
Commissioner's review of the investigation report, the applicant shall submit a
remedial alternatives study report to the Commissioner according to a schedule
and in a format requested by the Commissioner. The remedial alternatives study
format may include a description of proposed pilot testing, response action, or
alternative remedial approaches. A cost proposal for the proposed activities
outlined in the remedial alternatives study may also be required at this
time.
(9) Remediation
Priority Ranking
(a) Based on the results of a
solvent impact assessment or interim action and other relevant factors, the
Commissioner shall rank approved sites for remediation.
(b) At all stages within the DCERP the
approval of additional work to be funded by the DCERP will be done with
consideration for the relative threats to human health and the environment
associated with each site.
(c)
Subject to the availability of funds in the DCERF, remedial actions will be
approved at sites in accordance with the remediation priority ranking schedule.
For sites which have equivalent ranking status, funds will be authorized
according to the chronological order in which the applications were
received.
(10)
Implementation of Remediation
(a) Based on
availability of funds in the DCERF, the site ranking, and the remediation
required, the Commissioner shall notify an applicant to prepare a work plan,
cost proposal, and schedule of implementation to perform the remediation
activities. The applicant shall make any changes or modifications to the work
plan, cost proposal, or schedule of implementation required by the
Commissioner. Subject to the availability of funds in the DCERF, approval of
the work plan, approval of the cost proposal, and approval of the proposed
schedule of implementation, the Commissioner shall authorize implementation and
notify the applicant to perform the necessary approved remedial action at the
site. The applicant shall implement the remediation plan as approved by the
Commissioner.
The Commissioner may declare an applicant ineligible for
reimbursement if a remedial action is not performed in accordance with the
schedule and work plan requested by the Commissioner.
(b) Following the implementation of the
approved work plan, the applicant shall submit to the Commissioner a
remediation report containing a description of the activities undertaken during
the remediation, observations made, sampling results, and other information
requested by the Commissioner according to a schedule and format determined by
the Commissioner. If the remediation will require long-term operation and
maintenance (O&M) or monitoring, the applicant shall submit the remediation
report after all approved activities other than O&M or monitoring have been
completed.
(c) If the remediation
requires O&M or monitoring, the applicant shall prepare an O&M or
monitoring plan according to a schedule and in the format required by the
Commissioner and submit the O&M or monitoring plan to the Commissioner. The
applicant shall make any changes or modifications to the plan required by the
Commissioner. The applicant shall implement the O&M or monitoring plan as
approved.
(11) Response
Complete Summary Letter
After all required interim action, investigation,
remediation, and other required activities are completed at the site, a
Response Complete Summary letter shall be issued to the applicant by the
Commissioner. Following issuance of this letter and reimbursement of all
authorized costs, the site shall return to non-DCERF eligible status and the
applicant may no longer receive DCERF reimbursements without reapplying for
DCERF eligibility. Nothing in this paragraph shall prevent the Commissioner
from issuing an interim status letter while O&M or monitoring at a site is
ongoing, or from continuing DCERF reimbursement of authorized costs related to
such O&M or monitoring after issuance of an interim status
letter.
(12)
Non-Reimbursement Review
(a) The DCERP may
provide oversight of registered facilities requesting review that will not be
seeking DCERF reimbursement. Prior to issuance of a Response Complete Summary
Letter, the DCERP will ensure that the investigative and remedial activities
were comparable to sites participating in the DCERP for reimbursement of
environmental response activities and that to the extent practicable were
consistent with the requirements of this chapter. The requester shall submit a
written request to the Commissioner for review or oversight and shall document
or include the following: BMP compliance; the facility is current with all
fees, surcharges, and penalties; the work has or will be performed by a DCAC;
signed acknowledgment that costs expended will not be eligible for
reimbursement from the DCERF; and that all pertinent documents and reports have
been submitted to the Commissioner. The requestor shall pay a program oversight
fee of $5,000.
(b) The Commissioner
may provide oversight of unregistered facilities requesting reviews that will
not be seeking DCERF reimbursement. The Commissioner may deny any request for a
review that is not reasonable or cost effective. Prior to issuance of a
Response Complete Summary Letter, the DCERP will ensure that the investigative
and remedial activities were comparable to sites participating in the DCERP for
reimbursement of environmental response activities and that to the extent
practicable were consistent with the requirements of this chapter. The
requester shall submit a written request to the DCERP for review or oversight
and shall include an acknowledgement that costs expended will not be eligible
for reimbursement from the DCERF and shall submit all pertinent documents and
reports related to environmental activity at the site. The requester shall pay
a program oversight fee of $5,000.
(c) Notwithstanding the request for and
provision of oversight under the DCERP pursuant to either subparagraph (a) or
(b) of this paragraph, any applicant may apply for entry of a facility in the
DCERP in accordance with this rule and proceed to comply with the requirements
of this rule; provided, that any costs incurred under oversight pursuant to
subparagraphs (a) or (b) of this paragraph shall not be reimbursable from the
DCERF.
Authority: T.C.A. §§
4-5-201, et seq., and 68-217-101,
et seq.