Current through Register Vol. 39, No. 6, September 16, 2024
(a) When a person
presenting to vote checks in at a voting site, an election official shall ask
the voter to show photo identification in accordance with G.S. 163-166.16 and
this Rule. The election official shall examine any photo identification
provided by the person presenting to vote and shall determine the following:
(1) The photo identification is of the type
acceptable for voting purposes pursuant to G.S. 163-166.16(a). A valid United
States passport book or passport card is acceptable pursuant to G.S.
163-166.16(a)(1)c.
(2) The
photograph appearing on the photo identification bears a reasonable resemblance
to the person presenting to vote. A reasonable resemblance is a similarity in
appearance such that an ordinary person would conclude that the photograph on
the identification is more likely than not the person presenting to vote. The
election official shall make this determination based on the totality of the
circumstances, bearing in mind that there are many reasons that a person's
appearance could change (such as, for illustrative purposes only, changes in
hair, facial hair, or weight; or the effects of medical conditions, aging, or
medical treatment). The election official shall also be guided by the purpose
of the photo identification requirement, which is to confirm the person
presenting to vote is the registered voter on the voter registration
records.
(3) The name appearing on
the photo identification is the same as or substantially equivalent to the name
contained in the voter's voter registration record. The election official shall
make this determination based on the totality of the circumstances, construing
all evidence, along with any explanation or documentation voluntarily offered
by the person presenting to vote, in the light most favorable to that person.
The election official shall consider the name appearing on the photo
identification to be substantially equivalent to the name contained in the
registration record if differences are attributable to a reasonable
explanation, which shall include but is not limited to one or more of the
following reasons:
(A) Omission or inclusion
of one or more parts of the name (such as, for illustrative purposes only, Mary
Beth Smith versus Beth Smith, or Patrick Todd Jackson, Jr. versus Patrick Todd
Jackson, or Maria Guzman-Santana versus Maria Guzman);
(B) Use of a variation or nickname rather
than a formal name (such as, for illustrative purposes only, Bill versus
William, or Sue versus Susanne);
(C) Use of an initial in place of one or more
parts of a given name (such as, for illustrative purposes only, A.B. Sanchez
versus Aaron B. Sanchez);
(D) Use
of a former name, including maiden names (such as, for illustrative purposes
only, Emily Jones versus Emily Gibson), or a variation that includes or omits a
hyphenation or hyphen (such as, for illustrative purposes only, Chantell D.
Jacobson- Smith versus Chantell D. Jacobson or Chantell D. Jacobson Smith), an
accent (such as, for illustrative purposes only, José Muñoz
versus Jose Munoz), or an apostrophe (such as, for illustrative purposes only,
Andrea D'Antonio versus Andrea Dantonio);
(E) Ordering of names (such as, for
illustrative purposes only, Maria Eva Garcia Lopez versus Maria E. Lopez-
Garcia); or
(F) Variation in
spelling or typographical errors (such as, for illustrative purposes only,
Dennis McCarthy versus Denis McCarthy, or Aarav Robertson versus Aarav
Robertsson).
If a voter is casting a provisional ballot because the voter's
record does not appear in the poll book, the election official shall instead
compare the name on the photo identification with the name provided by the
voter on the provisional ballot application.
(b) The election official checking
in the person presenting to vote, when examining the photo identification of
that person, shall not require the voter to provide any evidence regarding the
identification apart from the identification itself. If the face of the person
presenting to vote is covered to such an extent that the election official
cannot determine reasonable resemblance under Subparagraph (a)(2) of this Rule,
then the election official shall inform the voter that the face covering is
preventing the official from determining that the photo on the identification
is that of the voter and shall offer the voter the option to briefly remove the
face covering. If the voter chooses not to remove the covering, then the
election official shall enter a challenge in accordance with Subparagraph
(d)(3) of this Rule.
(c)
Differences between the address appearing on the photo identification of a
person presenting to vote and the address contained in the registration record
of that person shall not be considered as evidence that the photographic
identification fails to meet the requirements of G.S. 163-166.16 or this
Rule.
(d) After examining the photo
identification according to Paragraphs (a) through (c) of this Rule, the
election official shall proceed as follows:
(1) If the election official determines that
the photo identification meets all the requirements of Paragraph (a) of this
Rule, then the election official shall allow than identification is not an
acceptable type of photo identification under Subparagraph (a)(1) of this Rule
person to vote pursuant to G.S. 163-166.7.
(2) If the election official determines that
the photo identification is not an acceptable type of photo identification
under Subparagraph (a)(1) of this Rule, the election official shall inform the
person presenting to vote of the reasons for that determination (such as, for
illustrative purposes only, that the photo identification is not on the list of
student identifications approved by the State Board of Elections) and shall
invite the person to provide any other photo identification that is acceptable
under Subparagraph (a)(1) of this Rule that the person may have. If the person
presenting to vote does not produce photo identification that meets all the
requirements of Subparagraph (a)(1) of this Rule, then the election official
shall inform the person presenting to vote of both options to vote by
provisional ballot in accordance with Paragraph (e) of this Rule.
(3) If the election official determines that
the photo or name on the photo identification do not satisfy Subparagraphs
(a)(2) and (a)(3) of this Rule, the election official shall inform the person
presenting to vote of the reasons for that determination and shall invite the
person to provide any other photo identification that the person may have that
is acceptable under Subparagraph (a)(1) and satisfies Subparagraphs (a)(2) and
(a)(3) of this Rule. If the person presenting to vote does not produce photo
identification that meets all the requirements of Paragraph (a) of this Rule,
then the election official shall enter a challenge pursuant to G.S. 163-87 and
immediately notify the voting site's judges of election of the challenge. The
judges of election shall then conduct a challenge hearing, in accordance with
the applicable procedures in G.S. 163-88. At the conclusion of the hearing, the
judges of election shall vote on whether the photo appearing on the photo
identification of the person presenting to vote bears a reasonable resemblance
to that person or whether the name appearing on the photo identification is the
same as or substantially equivalent to the name contained in the voter's voter
registration record, applying the same standards as the election official
initially reviewing the identification under Subparagraphs (a)(2) and (a)(3).
Each judge shall record the judge's findings in writing. Only if the judges of
election unanimously find that the photo appearing on the photo identification
does not bear a reasonable resemblance to the person presenting to vote, or
that the name appearing on the photo identification is not the same as or
substantially equivalent to the name contained in the voter's voter
registration record, the voter shall be offered both options to vote by
provisional ballot in accordance with Paragraph (e) of this Rule. Absent such a
unanimous finding, the person shall vote with a regular ballot pursuant to G.S.
163-166.7. When the judges of election conduct a challenge hearing under this
Rule and the challenge is to a curbside voter, to ensure the voting enclosure
remains properly attended, the judges may separately visit the curbside
location to assess the voter's identification.
(e) A person presenting to vote who does not
present acceptable photo identification in accordance with this Rule shall be
offered both of the following options:
(1) To
vote by provisional ballot with an affidavit claiming an exception to the
identification requirement, pursuant to G.S. 163-166.16(d). If the voter has
completed the affidavit as required in G.S. 163-166.16(d) and is otherwise
eligible to vote, the county board shall count the provisional ballot unless
the county board unanimously finds that the affidavit is false. The county
board shall substantiate any finding of falsity with grounds recorded in a
written decision, and those grounds shall be based only on facts and not
speculation. Before disapproving a voter's provisional ballot because of a
finding of falsity, the county board shall provide the voter advance notice and
an opportunity to address the county board prior to completion of the canvass
on any grounds that the county board is considering regarding the falsity of
the affidavit. The notice shall identify the specific reasons the county board
is considering the affidavit to be potentially false and inform the voter how
the voter may address the reasons for potential falsity, which shall include
the options to provide a written explanation or documentation or to address the
board at a meeting in person. The county board shall send the notice via U.S.
Mail within one business day of a county board's preliminary finding of
falsity, provided that the opportunity to be heard is at least five days from
the date of mailing. The notice shall be mailed for next-day delivery if the
opportunity to be heard is less than five days from the date of mailing. Notice
shall also be provided within one business day of a county board's preliminary
finding of falsity by any email address or phone number that the county board
possesses for the voter. The notice and opportunity to address the county board
provided for in this Subparagraph shall be offered only to those provisional
voters for whom a number of county board members equal to one less than all of
the members of the county board, or more, have identified a specific reason,
based only on facts and not speculation, to find that the affidavit claiming an
exception to the identification requirement is false.
(2) To vote by provisional ballot and then
bring to the office of the county board identification acceptable under G.S.
163-166.16 and this Rule before 5 p.m. on the business day before county
canvass. If the voter brings photo identification to the office of a county
board in a timely manner, a county board staff member shall examine the photo
identification in accordance with Paragraphs (a), (b), and (c) of this Rule.
After examining the photo identification, the staff member shall proceed as
follows:
(A) If the photo identification meets
all the requirements of Paragraph (a) of this Rule, the staff member shall
recommend approval of the provisional ballot to the county board.
(B) If the photo identification is not an
acceptable type of photo identification under Subparagraph (a)(1) of this Rule,
then the staff member shall inform the voter of the reasons for that
determination, while the voter is at the county board office, and invite the
voter to provide an acceptable photo identification in accordance with
Subparagraph (d)(2) of this Rule. If the voter does not provide acceptable
identification by 5:00 p.m. on the business day prior to the canvass, then
county board staff shall recommend disapproval of the provisional ballot to the
county board.
(C) If the photo or
name on the photo identification do not satisfy Subparagraphs (a)(2) and (a)(3)
of this Rule, then the staff member shall inform the voter of the reasons for
that determination and shall invite the voter to provide any other photo
identification that meets the requirement of Paragraph (a) of this Rule. If the
voter does not produce photo identification that meets the requirement of
Paragraph (a) of this Rule, then the staff member shall recommend disapproval
of the provisional ballot to the county board. While the voter is at the county
board office, the staff member shall inform the voter of the recommendation and
provide notice to the voter of the county board meeting at which the voter's
provisional ballot will be reviewed and considered by the county board. If the
voter appears at that meeting and desires to address the county board on
whether their photo identification meets the requirement of Paragraph (a) of
this Rule, the county board members are subject to the requirements of this
Rule in the same manner as a staff member initially examining a voter's photo
identification.
If the voter brings photo identification that is an acceptable
type of photo identification under Subparagraph (a)(1) of this Rule to the
county board office before 5 p.m. on the business day prior to the canvass, the
county board shall count the provisional ballot unless the county board
unanimously decides the photo identification presented does not satisfy
Subparagraphs (a)(2) and (a)(3) of this Rule, in which case the county board
shall record in writing the grounds for its decision.
Authority
G.S.
163-82.6A;
163-82.15;
163-166.7; NAACP v. McCrory, 831
F.3d 204 (4th Cir. 2016); 163A-1145.1; S.L.
2018-144, s. 3.1(e);
Eff. January 1, 2016;
Temporary
Amendment Eff. August 23, 2019;
Temporary Amendment Expired Eff.
June 12, 2020.