Current through Register Vol. 49, No. 18, September 16, 2024
(1) General
Provisions and Authority. This rule is promulgated under the rulemaking
authority granted to the Department of Social Services (DSS) pursuant to
section
660.017, RSMo.
Pursuant to Article I V, Section 37 of the Missouri
Constitution, the director of the Department of Social Services is
charged with promoting improved health and other social services to the
citizens of the state as provided by law. Section 660.010.2, RSMo authorizes
the DSS director to coordinate the state's programs devoted to those who are
unable to provide for themselves and for victims of social disadvantage.
Section 660.012.2, RSMo also entrusts the DSS director with the duty to use the
resources allocated to the department to provide comprehensive programs and
leadership in order to improve services and economical operations. To that end,
the DSS director has determined that the transfer of the State Technical
Assistance Team (STAT) from the Division of Family Services (DFS) to the
Division of Legal Services (DLS) improves the efficiency and economical
operations of resources and maximizes services to the citizens of this state.
This rule recognizes that the transfer of STAT from DFS to DLS has been
accomplished and such rule also provides a mechanism for the promulgation of
procedures setting forth the function, general organization and operation of
the State Technical Assistance Team. As a unit of the Division of Legal
Services, STAT is responsible for performing its duties related to child
fatality review pursuant to sections
210.192
to
210.196,
RSMo and its duties related to providing assistance to multidisciplinary teams
and law enforcement agencies in investigating and prosecuting cases involving
child abuse, child neglect, child sexual abuse, child exploitation or child
fatality as prescribed in sections
660.520
to 660.527, RSMo. In performing its CFRP mission, STAT is responsible for
providing training, expertise and assistance to county CFRP panels for the
review of child fatalities including establishing procedures for the
preparation and submission of a Final Report by CFRP panels as reflected in
subsection (4)(K) of this rule.
(2)
Definitions.
(A) Child abuse means any
physical injury or emotional abuse inflicted on a child other than by
accidental means by another person, except that discipline, including spanking,
administered in a reasonable manner, shall not be construed to be
abuse.
(B) Child exploitation means
allowing, permitting or encouraging a child, under the age of eighteen years,
to engage in prostitution or sexual conduct, as defined by state law, by a
person responsible for the child's welfare or any other person involved in the
act, and allowing, permitting, encouraging or engaging in the obscene or
pornographic photographing, filming or depicting of a child, under the age of
eighteen years, or the possession of such items, as those acts are defined by
state law, by a person responsible for the child's welfare or any other person
involved in the act.
(C) Child
fatality means the death of a child under the age of eighteen years as a result
of any natural, intentional or unintentional act.
(D) Child neglect means the failure to
provide, by those responsible for the care, custody and control of the child,
the proper or necessary support, education as required by law, nutrition or
medical, surgical or any other care necessary for the child's
well-being.
(E) Child sexual abuse
means to engage in sexual intercourse or deviate sexual intercourse with a
child or any touching of a child with the genitals, or any touching of the
genitals, or anus of the child by another person, when the child is a person
under the age of seventeen years.
(3) State Technical Assistance Team.
(A) The State Technical Assistance Team shall
assist in the investigation of child abuse, child neglect, child sexual abuse,
child exploitation or child fatality cases upon the request of:
1. A local law enforcement agency;
2. Prosecuting attorney;
3. Division of Family Services
staff;
4. A representative of the
family courts;
5. Medical
examiner;
6. Coroner; or
7. Juvenile officer.
(B) Upon being requested to assist in an
investigation, the State Technical Assistance Team shall notify all parties
specified in subsection (3)(A) of STAT's involvement in the investigation via
U.S. Postal Service.
(C) Where
STAT's assistance has been requested by a local law enforcement agency, STAT
investigators, certified as peace officers by the director of the Department of
Public Safety pursuant to Chapter 590, RSMo shall be deemed to be peace
officers within the jurisdiction of the requesting law enforcement agency,
while acting at the request of the law enforcement agency. The power of arrest
of a STAT investigator, acting as a peace officer, shall be limited to offenses
involving child abuse, child neglect, child sexual abuse, child exploitation or
child fatality.
(D) STAT shall
assist county multidisciplinary teams in the development and implementation of
protocols for the investigation and prosecution of child abuse, child neglect,
child sexual abuse, child exploitation or child fatality cases.
(E) All reports and records made and
maintained by the STAT or local law enforcement relating to criminal
investigations conducted pursuant to this section, including arrests, shall be
available in the same manner as law enforcement records, as set forth in
sections
610.100
to
610.200,
RSMo, and to the individuals identified in subdivision (13) of subsection 2 of
section
210.150,
RSMo.
(F) An individual identified
in subdivision (13) of subsection 2 of section
210.150,
RSMo, is a person who is a tenure-track or full-time research faculty member at
an accredited institution of higher education engaged in scholarly research and
who has the permission of the director of the Department of Social Services.
Prior to the release of any identifying information the director of the DSS
shall require the researcher to present a plan for maintaining the
confidentiality of the identifying information. The researcher shall be
prohibited from releasing the identifying information of individual
cases.
(G) All other records shall
be available in the same manner as provided in section
210.150,
RSMo. Nothing in this section shall preclude the release of findings or
information about cases which resulted in a child fatality or near fatality.
Such release is at the sole discretion of the director of the Department of
Social Services, based upon the review of the potential harm to other children
with the immediate family.
(4) Local (County) Child Fatality Review
Program (CFRP) Panels.
(A) The prosecuting
attorney or circuit attorney shall convene a local CFRP panel in each of the
state's one hundred fourteen counties and St. Louis City to review suspicious
child deaths.
(B) The Department of
Social Services (DSS) shall convene a state CFRP panel appointed by the
director of DSS to identify systemic problems and submit findings and
recommendations on ways to prevent further child deaths.
(C) The local CFRP panel will review all
deaths of children less than eighteen years of age at the time of their death
where one or more of the following factors are present:
1. Sudden, unexplained death of a child under
age one year;
2.
Unexplained/undetermined manner;
3.
DFS reports on decedent or other persons in the residence;
4. Decedent in DFS custody;
5. Possible inadequate supervision of the
decedent;
6. Possible malnutrition
or delay in seeking medical care;
7. Possible suicide;
8. Possible inflicted injury;
9. Firearm injury;
10. Injury not witnessed by person in charge
of child at time of injury;
11.
Confinement;
12.
Suspicious/criminal activity;
13.
Drowning;
14. Suffocation or
strangulation;
15.
Poison/chemical/drug ingestion;
16.
Severe unexplained injury;
17.
Pedestrian/bicycle/driveway injury;
18. Drug/alcohol-related vehicular
injury;
19. Suspected sexual
assault;
20. Fire injury;
21. Autopsy by certified child death
pathologist;
22. Panel discretion;
or
23. Other suspicious findings
(injuries such as electrocution, crush or fall).
(D) The local CFRP panel at least shall
review the following information on all suspicious deaths:
1. Findings from interviews, history or
death-scene investigation;
2.
Physical evidence at the scene of injury, death, or both;
3. Findings from physical and medical
examinations;
4. Findings from
autopsy, radiological examination and laboratory evaluation;
5. Reports of investigation/evaluation;
and
6. Relevant past history/agency
involvement.
(E) The
director of DSS shall appoint regional coordinators to serve as resources to
local CFRP panels. The regional coordinators will provide the following
services:
1. Consultation and technical
assistance;
2. Training;
and
3. Reviewing forms and provide
recommendations on procedures developed by local panels.
(F) Initially, all panel members will be
appointed by the prosecuting attorney. Subsequent appointments will be made by
the chairperson. All members who represent a governmental agency defined as
mandatory in this section will serve as long as they hold the position which
made them eligible for appointment to the local CFRP panel. All other members
shall serve a term which is defined in the procedures developed by the local
panel. The local procedures also shall define the selection and removal
processes for non-core members. The chairperson shall be elected by the review
panel. The chairperson and all other members may be reappointed for consecutive
terms. The local CFRP panel shall include, but not be limited to, the following
core members:
1. The prosecuting or circuit
attorney;
2. Medical
examiner/coroner;
3. A law
enforcement officer;
4. A
representative of the DFS;
5. A
provider of public health services;
6. A representative of the juvenile court;
and
7. A representative of
emergency medical services.
(G) If the county of residence,
illness/injury/event or death are different, the CFRP panel in the county where
the illness/injury/event occurred shall review the death.
1. The activated review panel may communicate
with the chairperson of the CFRP panel in the county of residence and death, if
different, to request necessary information.
2. The review panel in the county of death,
residence, or both, may choose to review the death.
3. The Coroner/Medical Examiner Data Report
(Data Form 1), which is hereby incorporated by reference as part of this rule,
must be completed on all children ages birth through seventeen (0-17) who die
in Missouri, regardless of state of residence.
4. Children injured out of state, who die in
Missouri, may be reviewed at the sole discretion of the county panel,
regardless of state of residence.
(H) The panel members will hold all
information obtained in the course of a review in the strictest confidence and
will not discuss or disclose any information regarding any case, except as
permitted by applicable statutes.
(I) DLS will not reimburse or compensate a
county CFRP panel for expenses associated with review panel business. Expenses
may be reimbursed consistent with state travel rules and limitations for
required participation of DLS panel members in training. DFS will be
responsible for payment of expenses, subject to state travel rules and
limitations, and compensation for its employees who are members of a review
panel.
(J) The following process
will be followed by the county CFRP panels:
1. Any police officer, sheriff, law
enforcement officer or official, physician, coroner/medical examiner, funeral
director, hospital personnel or any person having knowledge that a person less
than eighteen years of age has died, shall notify the coroner or medical
examiner immediately in the county of injury.
A. If the coroner or medical examiner in the
county of death or residence is notified of a death, s/he shall notify the
coroner or medical examiner immediately in the county of illness/injury/event,
if different.
B. If the coroner or
medical examiner in the county of illness/injury/event determines that the
death of the person under age eighteen does not exhibit any suspicious
circumstances as described in this section, the panel chairperson will be
responsible for cosigning Data Form 1, which is incorporated by reference as
part of this rule, and shall forward the form within forty-eight hours to the
DSS, ST A T . I f the chairperson disagrees with the coroner or medical
examiner regarding the nature of the death and desires a review, the review
panel can be activated.
C. The
coroner or medical examiner in the county of illness/injury/event shall notify
a certified child death pathologist to determine the need for an autopsy. If
there is disagreement, the certified child death pathologist shall make the
determination, unless the CFRP panel, within twelve (12) hours, decides against
the certified child death pathologist;
D. If the coroner or medical examiner
determines that the child died from natural causes while under medical care,
such coroner or medical examiner shall notify DFS (Central Registry Unit,
"Child Abuse/Neglect Hotline"-800-392-3738). In all other cases, the medical
examiner or coroner shall immediately notify DFS of the child's death, as
required by section
58.452,
RSMo.
2. The coroner or
medical examiner in the county of illness/injury/event shall notify the
chairperson of the CFRP panel immediately if the death is suspicious;
3. Upon notification, the chairperson will
activate the review panel within twenty-four hours to review the death.
A. Each member of the panel shall share
information and records available to that panel member.
B. Each review panel shall operate the review
based on procedures developed by the panel and based on guidelines and
protocols developed by the DSS;
4. The review panel shall determine, at a
minimum:
A. The place where the
injury/illness causing a death occurred;
B. The manner and circumstances of the
death;
C. Actions taken by the
agencies/persons involved with the child and his/her family;
D. The identification of any siblings or
other children in the home of the deceased child and whether they require
protection; and
E. The
identification of local systemic issues or policies which enhance or detract
from efforts to assist in the investigation, treatment or prevention of
fatalities; and
5. The
chairperson of the local CFRP panel will complete Data Form 2, which is
incorporated by reference as part of this rule, and forward it through to the
DSS, ST A T , f o r linkage with death certificates. This form must be sent
within sixty (60) days of the date of death.
(K) Final Report.
1. In all cases reviewed by a CFRP panel, the
CFRP shall, after completing the review, prepare a Final Report which shall
consist of a summary of prevention conclusions and recommendations. The Final
Report shall be submitted on a form referred to as the Child Fatality Review
Panel Final Report (or Final Report), which is incorporated by reference as
part of this rule. Pursuant to section 210.192.3, RSMo 2000 the Final Report
issued by the panel is a public record and may be obtained by submitting a
written request to the following address: State Technical Assistance Team,
Division of Legal Services, 2724 Merchants Drive, Jefferson City, MO
65109.
2. The CFRP panel's Final
Report will be forwarded directly to the State Technical Assistance Team,
prevention coordinator, within ten (10) days of the CFRP panel review, except
in cases where criminal charges are being considered or pending. In those
cases, the final report of the panel will be due within ten (10) days after a
criminal indictment or information is filed in the case or the local panel
chair is notified of the prosecutor's decision not to file charges.
3. The prevention coordinator will be a
direct liaison with all CFRP panels, maintaining a prevention resource
repository, and providing guidance and facilitation in the implementation of
appropriate prevention strategies and responses.
4. Separate from data collected, the
prevention coordinator will track the effectiveness of various prevention
responses to specific risks, and will make this information available to the
state CFRP panel and appropriate supporting agencies.
(5) State Child Fatality Review
Panel.
(A) The state CFRP panel shall be
composed of a minimum of seven members. All members will be appointed by the
director of the DSS.
1. Members mandated by
this rule to be members of this panel may serve as long as they hold the
position which made them eligible for appointment.
2. The DSS shall establish procedures which
define the terms for all members, reasons for the removal of members from the
panel and how members will be appointed in the future.
3. The chairperson and all members may be
reappointed for consecutive terms.
(B) The director of DSS shall appoint the
following persons to serve on the state CFRP panel:
1. A prosecuting attorney or circuit
attorney;
2. A coroner or medical
examiner;
3. A law enforcement
officer or official;
4. A
representative from DFS;
5. A
provider of public health care services;
6. A representative from the Department of
Health;
7. A representative of the
juvenile court; and
8. A
representative of emergency medical services.
(C) Other members of the state CFRP panel may
include persons from the following agencies/groups:
1. Division of Youth Services;
2. Attorney General;
3. Missouri Juvenile Justice
Association;
4. A physician
experienced in examining and treating abused/neglected children;
5. Department of Mental Health;
6. Department of Public Safety;
7. Department of Elementary and Secondary
Education;
8. Department of
Corrections; and
9. Any other
professionals or citizens with special interest in child abuse and
neglect.
(D) The state
CFRP panel will meet at least biannually. DLS may reimburse the members who are
not division employees for reasonable expenses, consistent with state travel
rules and limitations for expenses associated with review panel business held
outside their county of residence, but will not provide for any other
compensation. DFS will be responsible for the reimbursement of expenses,
subject to state travel rules and limitations, and compensation for its
employees on the panel.
(E) The
state CFRP panel shall review and discuss all relevant materials submitted by
the local panels and the state implementation team. The purpose of the review
will be to:
1. Review the findings of the
county CFRP panels to determine the frequency and cause of child fatalities
throughout the state;
2. Identify
the appropriateness and comprehensiveness of current statutes, policies and
procedures relevant to the management of fatal abuse/neglect cases;
3. Review data collected by the DSS, STAT to
determine the accuracy of identification of fatally abused and neglected
children;
4. Review reports on the
status of the operations of the county CFRP panels; and
5. Recommend prevention strategies after
reviewing statewide trends and actions suggested by local panels.
(F) The panel members will hold
all information obtained in the course of a review in the strictest confidence
and will not discuss or disclose any information regarding any case, except as
permitted by applicable statutes.
(G) DSS and the state CFRP panel annually
shall evaluate the following factors related to the work of the local CFRP
panels:
1. Number of reviews;
2. Geographic area of reviews;
3. Results of reviews; and
4. Necessary amendments to the rules. (H) The
state CFRP panel shall submit findings and recommendations to the director of
DSS, the governor, the speaker of the house of representatives, the president
pro tempore of the senate, and the children's services
commission, juvenile officers and chairperson of the local CFRP panels. At a
minimum, the findings shall address the following issues:
1. The number of child fatality cases
reviewed by county panels;
2.
Nonidentifying characteristics for perpetrators;
3. Nonidentifying characteristics for
deceased children;
4. The number of
fatalities by cause(s) of death and whether death was attributable to child
abuse/neglect;
5. Effectiveness of
local panels; and
*Original authority: Please see the Missouri Revised
Statutes 2000.