Current through Register Vol. 49, No. 18, September 16, 2024
PURPOSE: This rule sets forth procedures by which the
Division of Child Support Enforcement conducts hearings before its designated
hearing officers to resolve disputes between the division and persons from whom
the division is seeking to establish an obligation for child support or collect
an established obligation.
(1) Definitions. As used in this rule-
(A) Absent parent means the noncustodial
parent;
(B) Administrative process
hearing means a hearing to dispute a Notice and Finding of Financial
Responsibility issued by the division or a hearing concerning a motion to
modify an administrative order under section
454.500,
RSMo;
(C) Agency means the
Department of Social Services and its employees;
(D) Case means the proceeding in which a
dispute between an absent parent and the division has been or is in the process
of being resolved, including all division records, facts and statements in
evidence and all findings and conclusions made;
(E) Client means the custodial parent who is
receiving Division of Child Support Enforcement services;
(F) Consumer reporting agency means a credit
bureau;
(G) Division means the
Division of Child Support Enforcement and its employees;
(H) Division representative means an
employee, attorney or designated representative who appears in an
administrative proceeding on behalf of the division;
(I) General hearing request means an
administrative hearing to resolve a dispute with the division arising from the
absent parent's receipt of-1) notification of a lottery interception under
section
454.505,
RSMo and Missouri's right to set off under common law, 2) an administrative
order on an existing order under section
454.476,
RSMo, 3) a notification of referral to a consumer credit bureau under section
454.512,
RSMo, 4) a claim of abatement in the support obligation under section
452.340,
RSMo or 5) a claim involving the age of majority under section
452.340,
RSMo;
(J) Hearing request means a
request made by an absent parent, personally or through a representative,
according to the procedures set forth under this rule and applicable Missouri
statutes;
(K) Internal Revenue
Service (IRS) administrative review means an administrative hearing to
challenge a preintercept notice sent by the federal Office of Child Support
Enforcement to the absent parent or to challenge an intercept notice sent by
the United States IRS to the absent parent. This hearing request may also be
made on any other preintercept notice sent by the division as long as it
involves the interception of a federal tax refund;
(L) Issue means a question of fact disputed
by the absent parent, the division or the custodial parent, the determination
of which is material to a decision in the case;
(M) Submitting state means the state that
submitted the absent parent's name to the Internal Revenue Service for
intercept of all or part of any tax refund for a specific year;
(N) Tax refund intercept hearing means a
hearing to contest the interception by the division of an absent parent's
Missouri tax refund under section
143.784,
RSMo; and
(O) Unreimbursed
assistance means the total amount of Aid to Families with Dependent Children
(AFDC) received by the client less any support paid to and retained by the
state.
(2)
Administrative Process Hearing Requests.
(A)
To make a valid request for a hearing, the absent parent or his/her
representative must send to the division a written request for an
administrative process hearing within twenty (20) calendar days after the date
upon which the Notice and Finding of Financial Responsibility was
hand-delivered to the absent parent by a division representative, or served on
the absent parent in a manner prescribed for service of process in a civil
action, or by a duly authorized process server appointed by the director or by
certified mail, return receipt requested.
(B) The absent parent's request for an
administrative process hearing will not be effective unless it is sent or
delivered to the division according to the instructions on the Notice and
Finding of Financial Responsibility the absent parent has received.
(C) Within two (2) division working days
after it receives an absent parent's request for an administrative process
hearing, the division shall send to the absent parent a written acknowledgment
of the hearing request.
(D) If the
division determines that the absent parent is not entitled to an administrative
process hearing, it shall send the absent parent a written notice that his/her
request for an administrative process hearing has been denied. The division may
deny a request for an administrative process hearing for any one (1) of the
following reasons:
1. The absent parent's
hearing request is based solely on issues that have previously been litigated
and decided by a court of law;
2.
The hearing request was sent to the division more than twenty (20) calendar
days after the Notice and Finding of Financial Responsibility was
hand-delivered to the absent parent by a division representative, or was served
on the absent parent in a manner prescribed for service of process in a civil
action, or by a duly authorized process server appointed by the director or by
certified mail, return receipt requested; or
3. The absent parent's request for
administrative process hearing is based solely on issues which cannot be
decided in an administrative process hearing including, but not limited to,
visitation, legal custody and nonpaternity.
(E) If the division discovers an error in the
case that materially affects the Notice and Finding of Financial Responsibility
after the notice has been sent to the absent parent, the division shall
communicate the nature of this error and corrected information to the absent
parent. In cases in which a second Notice and Finding of Financial
Responsibility has been sent to the absent parent before the absent parent has
requested a hearing, the absent parent will have an additional ten (10)
calendar days to file a timely request for hearing with the division. The
additional ten (10) calendar days will be counted from the twentieth day after
service of the first Notice and Finding of Financial Responsibility on the
absent parent.
(F) After the
division has sent the absent parent an acknowledgment of the hearing request,
either the division or the absent parent may request a conference to reach
agreement. The request, whether initiated by the absent parent or the division,
will be conducted according to the following procedures:
1. If the absent parent is represented by
legal counsel, the request or consent in writing to a conference being held
must be made by the legal counsel;
2. The conference may proceed whether or not
division legal counsel is present unless the counsel's absence is objected to
by the absent parent's legal counsel; and
3. An administrative process hearing need not
be held if all disputed matters are resolved at a conference to reach agreement
before the hearing. This agreement must have the absent parent's written
consent (on advice of legal counsel, if represented) and the consent of the
division's client to the extent that the client's interests may be affected.
The division's client or his/her legal counsel may be included in the
conference to reach agreement.
(G) An administrative process hearing may be
held to resolve a motion for modification of an existing administrative process
order of support and will be held according to the same procedures as set forth
in this rule for administrative process hearings, except time limitations for
requests. A hearing may be requested on a motion for modification by the
division, the client or the absent parent. When an administrative process
hearing has been requested by any of these parties, the division shall not deny
a request for hearing. A conference to reach agreement may be conducted as in
other administrative process hearings.
(3) Missouri Tax Refund Intercept Hearings.
(A) The absent parent must request a Missouri
tax refund intercept hearing within thirty (30) calendar days after the
Missouri Department of Revenue mails a Notice of Tax Refund Intercept to the
absent parent.
(B) To be valid, the
absent parent's request for a Missouri tax refund intercept hearing must be
made in writing and delivered to the division according to the instructions
contained in the Notice of Tax Refund Intercept. Separate instructions are sent
to the nondebtor taxpayer (spouse) to receive his/her apportionment either by
requesting it in writing or by having it automatically apportioned and sent by
the Department of Revenue.
(C) The
division, upon receipt of a non-debtor spouse's written request for
apportionment, shall send an apportionment calculation request to the Missouri
Department of Revenue. The division shall send an acknowledgment to the
nondebtor spouse that his/her apportionment request has been forwarded to the
Department of Revenue. The division shall also send notice of the apportioned
amount to the nondebtor spouse with instructions that s/he may request a
hearing if s/he disagrees with the amount of the apportionment.
(D) If the nondebtor spouse's apportionment
will be sent automatically to him/her, the division shall send to the nondebtor
spouse notification of the apportioned amount and notice that s/he may request
a hearing if s/he disagrees with the amount of apportionment.
(E) The division must receive a nondebtor
spouse's request for an apportionment hearing no more than thirty (30) calendar
days after the day upon which the division mailed or delivered to the nondebtor
spouse notification of the apportioned amount.
(F) If the request for a Missouri tax refund
intercept hearing appears to have been made jointly by the absent parent and
the absent parent's spouse who is requesting apportionment, the agency hearing
officer may hold the tax refund intercept hearing and the apportionment hearing
as a joint proceeding. At the discretion of the agency hearing officer and upon
the request of the division, the absent parent or his/her spouse, the agency
hearing officer may grant a severance of the joint proceeding and have separate
proceedings on the two (2) issues. A request from any party may be denied by
the agency hearing officer unless failure to separate the proceedings could
clearly prejudice the debtor-taxpayer or his/her spouse.
(G) Within two (2) division working days
after the division receives a request for hearing from an absent parent or a
nondebtor spouse, the division shall send acknowledgment of the hearing request
to the requesting party.
(H) The
division may deny the request for hearing, but only if the denial is sent to
the absent parent within ten (10) calendar days after the request for hearing
is received. The division may deny a request for a Missouri tax refund
intercept hearing for any one (1) of the following reasons:
1) The hearing request is not
timely,
2) the hearing request
solely raises issues which have been previously decided by a court of law
or
3) the hearing request solely
raises issues that cannot be determined in an administrative proceeding. These
issues include, but are not limited to, visitation, legal custody and
nonpaternity.
(I) Any
party to the Missouri tax refund intercept proceeding, after the division's
acknowledgment of the hearing request is sent, may request a conference to
reach agreement. If the absent parent or the non-debtor spouse is represented
by legal counsel, the conference may not be held without the approval or
agreement of all legal counsel. If a conference to reach agreement is held and
a written agreement among all affected parties results, it will not be
necessary for an administrative Missouri tax refund intercept hearing to be
held in the case.
(J) The agency
hearing officer shall give notice of the date, time and place of the Missouri
tax refund intercept hearing to the absent parent, the nondebtor spouse, or
both, in case of a joint hearing. The notice will be in writing and will be
sent to any legal counsel known by the division to be representing any of the
parties in the case. Within three (3) division working days after the division
receives notice from the hearing officer of a scheduled Missouri tax refund
intercept hearing, the division shall calculate the amount of any arrearage
which has accrued between the time of the tax refund intercept and the most
recent ordered payment date. The division shall send notice, at least ten (10)
days before the hearing, of the amount of the additional arrearage to the
absent parent and to the absent parent's legal counsel, if the absent parent is
known to be represented by legal counsel in the proceeding. The additional
arrearage will be included in the tax refund intercept proceeding, and it will
be within the agency hearing officer's discretion to determine whether the late
receipt of the additional arrearage notice has prejudiced the absent parent's
ability to defend. In no event may the agency hearing officer separate the tax
refund intercept and the additional arrearage into issues for separate
hearings. If the absent parent, either individually or by and through legal
counsel, does not request a continuance and elects to proceed with the
scheduled hearing, the absent parent will be deemed to have waived any
objection to the timeliness of the receipt of the notice of additional accrued
arrearage.
(4) IRS
Administrative Review.
(A) The absent parent
shall have the right to an administrative review for the purpose of contesting
the stated amount of arrearage certified by the division to the United States
IRS for federal tax refund intercept and collection.
(B) A preintercept notice will be sent to the
absent parent by either the federal Office of Child Support Enforcement or the
division if the absent parent was certified for intercept on or before October
1 of the calendar year. The notice will contain the following information:
1. The absent parent's right to contest the
division's determination that past-due support is owed or the amount of
past-due support submitted;
2. The
absent parent's right to an administrative review by the submitting state or,
at the absent parent's request, the state where the order was entered upon
which the referral to the United States IRS was based;
3. The procedures and time allowed for
contacting the division to request an administrative review;
4. The right of the absent parent's spouse
(if a joint return is filed) to protect his/her apportioned share of the tax
refund and the steps the spouse must take in order to receive the share of the
refund which may be payable to him/her; and
5. The amount of the certified
arrearage.
(C) The
preintercept notice, whether sent by the division or the federal Office of
Child Support Enforcement, will have the division's local office address and
telephone number as the return address and will instruct that requests for
administrative reviews must be sent to the division's local office by the date
listed in the notice.
(D) The
intercept notice, sent by the United States IRS at the time of actual
intercept, will also have the division's local office and telephone number as
the return address and will instruct the absent parent to contact that office
if s/he has questions. A request for an administrative review at this time must
be made within thirty (30) days of the date of mailing under Chapter 536, RSMo.
The intercept notice must be presented at the administrative review as proof
that the absent parent's request was made within the thirty (30)-day time
limit. An administrative review request will be denied if the taxpayer
requested an administrative review at the time of the preintercept notice for
the same tax year.
(E) Within two
(2) division working days after the division receives a request from an absent
parent for an administrative review of a federal tax refund intercept
certification (pre-intercept notice), the division shall send a written
acknowledgment of the request. This will apply whether the request is received
orally in person, orally on the telephone or in writing. If the request is not
made within the time specified in the preintercept notice, the division shall
send written notice that the request for administrative review is
denied.
(F) The administrative
review will be conducted by either an agency hearing officer or a division
employee.
(5) General
Hearing Request-Administrative Order on an Existing Order.
(A) An absent parent may contest the issuance
of an administrative order on an existing order or the withholding order issued
under it by requesting a hearing according to instructions given to the absent
parent in the Notice of Withholding.
1. To be
valid, the absent parent's request for hearing must be received by the division
within fourteen (14) calendar days after the date on which the absent parent
received the Notice of Withholding.
2. If the absent parent requests a hearing,
the withholding will continue unless the absent parent posts a security bond in
the amount as stated in the Notice of Withholding.
(B) The division, within two (2) division
working days, shall send the absent parent an acknowledgment of the hearing
request. If the hearing request was not timely sent by the absent parent, the
division shall send a written denial of the request for hearing in lieu of the
acknowledgment of the hearing request.
(C) The division shall notify the client of
the hearing when-
1. The client has an
interest in the arrearage (that is, the arrearage is more than the amount of
the unreimbursed public assistance);
2. The client's testimony is needed for the
division to defend the withholding;
3. The case is nonpublic assistance, or a
combination of paragraphs (5)(C)1.-3.
(D) After the division has sent the absent
parent an acknowledgment of the hearing request, either the division or the
absent parent may request a conference to reach an agreement. The request for a
conference, whether initiated by the absent parent or the division, will be
conducted as follows:
1. If the absent parent
is represented by legal counsel in the case, the legal counsel must either make
the request or consent in writing to a conference being held;
2. The conference to reach agreement may
proceed whether or not division legal counsel is present unless the counsel's
absence is objected to by the absent parent's legal counsel; or
3. An administrative process hearing need not
be held if all matters in dispute are resolved at a conference to reach
agreement prior to the hearing. Any resolution must have the written consent of
the absent parent (on advice of legal counsel, if represented) and the client
to the extent that the client's interests may be affected. The client, his/her
legal counsel, or both, may be included in the conference to reach agreement,
or a combination of paragraphs (5)(D)1.-3.
(6) General Hearing Request-Lottery
Intercept.
(A) An absent parent may contest
interception of lottery winnings by requesting a hearing according to
instructions given in the absent parent's notice of intercept. The absent
parent's request for a hearing must be received by the division within twenty
(20) calendar days of the date the absent parent received the notice, if
hand-delivered, or of the date of mailing.
(B) Upon receipt by the division of a timely
request for hearing from the absent parent, the division, within two (2)
division working days, shall send an acknowledgment of the hearing request to
the absent parent. If the hearing request has not been timely sent by the
absent parent, the division shall send a written denial of the request for
hearing in lieu of the acknowledgment of the hearing request.
(C) The division may intercept lottery
winnings on an AFDC case which does not have an order establishing the child
support obligation. When an intercept is made, the division shall send the
absent parent a Notification of Lottery Setoff/No Order and a Notice and
Finding of Financial Responsibility-Special.
(D) An absent parent may request a hearing to
address both the issues of the lottery intercept and the administrative
order.
(E) An absent parent may
also request a hearing when the division has intercepted lottery winnings on a
non-AFDC case where the order establishing the obligation has been rendered by
a court in a foreign state or where a foreign state has obtained an
administrative order.
(F) Within
two (2) division working days after the receipt by the division of the absent
parent's timely hearing request to contest a lottery intercept in a non-AFDC
case, the division shall send the absent parent a notice of acknowledgment of
the hearing request. In cases where the absent parent's hearing request was not
timely received by the division, the division shall send notice that the
hearing request has been denied in lieu of the acknowledgment of the hearing
request.
(G) The division shall
notify the client of the pending hearing when-
1. The client has an interest in the
arrearage (that is, the arrearage is more than the unreimbursed amount of
public assistance);
2. A current
support obligation is being determined in the hearing;
3. The client's testimony, in the judgment of
the division, is needed in order to fully conduct the hearing; or
4. The case is nonpublic assistance, or a
combination of (6)(G)1.-4.
(7) General Hearing Request-Consumer
Reporting Agency (CRA).
(A) An absent parent
may request a hearing to contest the accuracy of the arrearage information
provided on the division's notice informing the absent parent that his/her
support debt will be referred to a CRA.
(B) The absent parent shall be deemed to have
received proper notice of the agency's planned referral to a CRA when the
absent parent has received written notification of the planned referral and a
statement of his/her support debt.
(C) To be valid, the absent parent's hearing
request must be received by the division in writing no more than twenty (20)
calendar days after the date the notice of the planned CRA referral was mailed
to the absent parent.
(D) Within
two (2) division working days after the division's receipt of the absent
parent's written hearing request, the division shall send written
acknowledgment of the request. If the absent parent's hearing request was not
timely received by the division, the division shall send written notice that
the hearing request has been denied in lieu of the acknowledgment of the
hearing request.
(E) After the
division acknowledges receipt of the hearing request, the division may contact
the absent parent in an effort to reach an agreement on the arrearage amount.
If the absent parent is not contacted, or if an agreement is not reached within
ten (10) division working days, the absent parent's request will be forwarded
for scheduling of an administrative hearing.
(F) The division may notify the client of the
pending CRA referral hearing when-
1. The
client has an interest in the arrearage (that is, the arrearage is more than
the amount of the unreimbursed public assistance);
2. The client's testimony will be needed in
order for the division to defend the referral; or
3. The case is nonpublic assistance, or a
combination of (7)(D)1.-3.
(8) General Hearing Request-Abatement Claim.
(A) An absent parent may request a hearing to
contest the division's notice to the absent parent that the client does not
agree with the absent parent's claim of an extended period of physical custody
of the child(ren) which would cause a reduction or abatement in the child
support obligation under an administrative process order.
(B) To be valid, the division must receive
the absent parent's hearing request within thirty (30) calendar days from the
date of mailing of the notice of abatement disagreement sent to the absent
parent.
(C) Within two (2) division
working days after the division's receipt of the absent parent's hearing
request, the division shall send written acknowledgment of the request. If the
absent parent's request for a hearing was not timely received, the division
shall send written notice to the absent parent that the hearing request has
been denied in lieu of the acknowledgment of the hearing request.
(D) The division shall notify the client of
the pending hearing in all cases.
(E) A hearing request will not be accepted
for an abatement hearing on a judicial child support order.
(9) General Hearing-Termination of
Support.
(A) An absent parent may request a
hearing to contest the division's notice to the absent parent that the client
or caretaker has provided information that the child is over age eighteen (18)
and meets the requirements for continuing current support stated in section
452.340,
RSMo.
(B) Within two (2) division
working days after the division's receipt of the absent parent's hearing
request, the division shall send written acknowledgment of the
request.
(C) The division shall
notify the client of the pending hearing in all cases.
(D) The sole issue addressed at the hearing
will be the claimed school attendance or non-attendance by the child(ren) over
age eighteen (18).
(E) A hearing
request under this section will be granted only on an administrative child
support order entered pursuant to Chapter 454, RSMo; provided:
1. The order specifies a per child amount;
or
2. In the case of a multiple
child order, only one (1) child is receiving or is arguably entitled to receive
support at the time of the hearing request.
(F) This section does not preclude the
division from considering termination of support issues in conjunction with the
review and modification of an existing child support order as specified in
13
CSR 30-4.020.
(10) Continuances.
(A) In any administrative hearing under this
rule, continuances may be granted only by the agency hearing officer assigned
to the case or the hearing officer's supervisor. The agency hearing officer (or
supervisor), at the hearing officer's discretion, may grant a continuance
freely upon the first request for a continuance from any party.
(B) If a party requesting a continuance
previously has been granted a continuance, the agency hearing officer shall
grant a continuance only upon a clear and present showing that substantive
rights of a party in interest will be severely prejudiced by the denial of the
request for continuance or for good cause. For the purposes of this rule, good
cause will be when-
1. The legal counsel of
any necessary party has, in fact, a scheduling conflict with any judicial
body;
2. Illness or other
significant emergency prohibits the attendance at the hearing of any necessary
party or his/her legal counsel; or
3. The division's client does not appear for
the hearing and the division has determined that the client's presence is
necessary for the proceeding. A continuance shall be granted in these
circumstances only when the division, more than ten (10) calendar days prior to
the hearing, has requested that a subpoena for the client's attendance be
issued.
(11)
Mailing.
(A) In any proceeding under this
rule, the agency hearing officer may enter a decision in default against any
party who has failed to appear or failed to perform a necessary act in the
course of the proceeding. It shall be the absent parent's responsibility to
update the proper mailing address for notices issued by the agency hearing
officer including, but not limited to, hearing notices, continuance notices and
hearing decisions.
(B) The valid
entry of a decision in default by the agency hearing officer may be made in all
cases, subject to the defaulting party's right to move that the decision in
default be set aside for good cause, but only if the defaulting party gives
notice of the good cause to the agency hearing officer in writing within ten
(10) calendar days after the default decision is mailed to the absent
parent.
(C) Any notice sent
registered mail, with a return receipt requested, whose delivery is refused or
any other mailing whose delivery is refused, will constitute delivery and
notice under the meaning of this rule. Any notice mailed to the last-known
address of any party in interest will be deemed valid delivery of that
notice.
(D) Unless otherwise
specified in this rule, all time limits shall be counted beginning with the day
following the day upon which the written notice in question was
mailed.
(E) A written hearing
request mailed to the division, which is postmarked within the time frames
given in this rule, will constitute receipt by the division within the
applicable time frame.
(12) Service of a Motion to Modify.
(A) In any administrative hearing proceeding
under this rule, when a party is seeking to modify an administrative process
order under section
454.500,
RSMo, it will be the moving party's responsibility to serve the motion on or
otherwise give valid notice to all other parties necessary to the
proceeding.
(B) When an absent
parent, with due diligence, has attempted to make delivery or service of a
motion to modify upon the client, the absent parent may apply to the division
to have service made upon the client by the division. The service may be made
by the division or it may be referred to the agency hearing officer to perfect
the service.
(C) When an absent
parent seeks to have service made upon the client by the division or the
hearing officer and the absent parent's attempt at service has been by means of
personal delivery, the attempts at personal delivery must be verified by
affidavit giving the time, dates and places where personal service was
attempted.
*Original authority: 454.400, RSMo 1982, amended 1985,
1986, 1990, 1993.