Current through Register Vol. 50, No. 9, September 20, 2024
A.
Surgical Decompression is well-established, generally accepted, and widely used
and includes open and endoscopic techniques. There is good evidence that
surgery is more effective than splinting in producing long-term symptom relief
and normalization of median nerve conduction velocity.
1. Endoscopic and open techniques can be used
based on the experience and discretion of the surgeon.
2. Indications for Surgery include positive
history, abnormal electrodiagnostic studies, and/or failure of conservative
management. Job modification should be considered prior to surgery. Please
refer to the "Job Site Alteration" section for additional information on job
modification.
3. Surgery as an
Initial Therapy. Surgery should be considered as an initial therapy in
situations where:
a. Median nerve trauma has
occurred; "acute carpal tunnel syndrome", or
b. Electrodiagnostic evidence of moderate to
severe neuropathy. EMG findings showing evidence of acute or chronic motor
denervation suggest the possibility that irreversible damage may be
occurring.
4. Surgery
may be considered in cases where electrodiagnostic testing is normal. A second
opinion from a hand surgeon is strongly recommended. The following criteria
should be considered in deciding whether to proceed with surgery:
a. the patient experiences significant
temporary relief following steroid injection into the carpal tunnel;
or
b. the patient has failed 3 to 6
months of conservative treatment including work site change; and
c. psychosocial factors have been addressed
through psychological screening requirements as defined "Adjunctive Testing" in
this Section; and
d. the patient's
signs and symptoms are specific for carpal tunnel syndrome
5. Suggested parameters for return-to-work
are:
Time Frame
|
Activity Level
|
2 Days
|
Return to Work with Restrictions on utilizing the
affected extremity
|
2-3 Weeks
|
Sedentary and non-repetitive work
|
4-6 Weeks
|
Case-by-case basis
|
6-12 Weeks
|
Heavy Labor, forceful and repetitive
|
NOTE: All return-to-work decisions are based upon
clinical outcome.
B. Neurolysis has not been proven
advantageous for carpal tunnel syndrome. Internal neurolysis should never be
done. Very few indications exist for external neurolysis.
C. Tenosynovectomy has not proven to be of
benefit in carpal tunnel syndrome.
D. Consideration for Repeat Surgery
1. The single most important factor in
predicting symptomatic improvement following carpal tunnel release is the
severity of preoperative neuropathy. Patients with moderate electrodiagnostic
abnormalities have better results than those with either very severe or no
abnormalities. Incomplete cutting of the transverse carpal ligament or
iatrogenic injury to the median nerve are rare. If median nerve symptoms do not
improve following initial surgery or symptoms improve initially and then recur,
but are unresponsive to non-operative therapy (see Therapeutic Procedures,
Non-Operative) consider the following:
a.
Recurrent synovitis;
b. Repetitive
work activities may be causing "dynamic" CTS;
c. Scarring;
d. Work-up of systemic diseases
2. A second opinion by a hand
surgeon or qualified surgeon in treating peripheral nerve disorders is required
if repeat surgery is contemplated. The decision to undertake repeat surgery
must factor in all of the above possibilities. Results of surgery for recurrent
carpal tunnel syndrome vary widely depending on the etiology of recurrent
symptoms.
E.
Post-Operative Treatment.
1. Considerations
for post-operative therapy are:
a.
Immobilization : There is some evidence showing that immediate mobilization of
the wrist following surgery is associated with less scar pain and faster return
to work. Final decisions regarding the need for splinting post-operatively
should be left to the discretion of the treating physician based upon his/her
understanding of the surgical technique used and the specific conditions of the
patient.
b. Home Program : It is
generally accepted that all patients should receive a home therapy protocol
involving stretching, ROM, scar care, and resistive exercises. Patients should
be encouraged to use the hand as much as possible for daily activities,
allowing pain to guide their activities.
c. Supervised Therapy Program: may be helpful
in patients who do not show functional improvements post-operatively or in
patients with heavy or repetitive job activities. The therapy program may
include some of the generally accepted elements of soft tissue healing and
return to function:
i. Soft tissue
healing/remodeling: May be used after the incision has healed. It may include
all of the following: evaluation, whirlpool, electrical stimulation, soft
tissue mobilization, scar compression pad, heat/cold application, splinting or
edema control may be used as indicated. Following wound healing, ultrasound and
iontophoresis with Sodium Chloride (NaCl) may be considered for soft tissue
remodeling. Diathermy is a non-acceptable adjunct.
ii. Return to function: Range of motion,
therapeutic exercises and stretching exercises, strengthening, activity of
daily living adaptations, joint protection instruction, posture/body mechanics
education; worksite modifications may be indicated.
(a). Time to produce effect: two- to four
weeks
(b). Frequency: two- to three
times/week
(c). Optimum duration:
four- to six weeks
(d). Maximum
duration: eight weeks
AUTHORITY
NOTE: Promulgated in accordance with
R.S.
23:1203.1.