Current through Register Vol. 47, No. 13, December 25, 2024
(1)
Statement of purpose. It
is the purpose of the commission, in adopting these rules to promote the
efficient enforcement of the Act. To this end, the commission will use referral
and deferral agreements to encourage agencies with similar powers and
jurisdiction to:
a. Develop procedures with
remedies necessary to ensure the protection of rights secured by the Iowa Civil
Rights Act.
b. Increase the
efficiency of their operations.
c.
Cooperate more fully with the commission in the sharing of data and resources,
and
d. Coordinate investigations
and conciliations with the commission in order to eliminate needless
duplication.
(2)
Definitions.
a.
"Agency" refers to any agency of municipal government established by
ordinance for the purpose of eliminating discrimination on any basis protected
by the Act or any state or federal governmental unit with jurisdiction over
allegations of discrimination that is capable of obtaining remedies similar to
those obtainable by the commission.
b.
"Referral" means the
process by which the commission cross-files a charge of discrimination with a
referral agency, which extinguishes the legal ability of the commission to
process the charge; provided, however, that the referral agency accepts the
referred charge and that the commission has the reciprocal right to accept or
reject charges cross-filed by the referral agency.
c.
"Referral agency " means
any agency of local government that has been awarded that status by contract
with the commission.
d.
"Deferral" refers to the process whereby the commission
notifies an agency of local, state, or federal government that a complaint has
been filed with the commission and that the commission will postpone its
investigative activities for a period of 60 days while the deferral agency
investigates and attempts to resolve the matter Extensions of this time period
may be granted by the commission or the executive director when just cause is
shown by the agency for the time extension requested.
e.
"Deferral agency" means
any agency so designated by contract pursuant to these rules.
(3)
Procedure for
obtaining referral status.
a.
Guidelines for designation. The executive director will
evaluate the applications of agencies and may designate agencies as referral
agencies where they conform to the following guidelines:
(1) The agency should have professional staff
to enable it to comprehensively investigate complaints and to ensure the
processing of the charges expeditiously.
(2) The ordinance or enabling legislation
under which the agency is established must provide at a minimum the same rights
and remedies to discrimination as available under the Act, and
(3) The enabling legislation of the agency
shall provide, at a minimum, that the agency may hold public hearings, issue
cease and desist orders, and award damages to injured parties which shall
include, but are not limited to, actual damages.
b.
Application. Any agency
desiring to be designated as a referral agency by the commission may send a
letter of application to the executive director of the commission. Attached to
the application must be a copy of the agency's enabling ordinance, a list of
its investigatory personnel, the average number of hours worked by each per
week, and a report for the previous 12-month period detailing the following:
(1) The number of cases filed with the
agency,
(2) The number of probable
cause and no probable cause findings,
(3) The number of cases successfully
conciliated,
(4) The number of
cases taken to public hearing,
(5)
The average length of time spent investigating each case,
(6) The cumulative remedies obtained for the
previous 12-month period and average remedy obtained per case,
(7) An assessment of the quality of the
agency's investigation,
(8) The
agency's standards to preserve quality investigations, and
(9) The status of the agency's
caseload.
c.
Rejection of application. Where the executive director
determines that an agency does not qualify as a referral agency, the director
shall so inform the agency in writing along with the reasons for the agency's
rejection.
If the reasons for the agency's rejection are corrected, the
agency will then be designated as a referral agency. The executive director's
decision may be appealed to the commission at its subsequent regular
meeting.
d.
Designation and contract. Where the executive director
determines that an agency is qualified as a referral agency, the director will
prepare a contract between the commission and the agency containing the terms
on which cases will be referred. Upon execution of the contract, the executive
director will designate the agency as a referral agency.
e.
Terms of the referral
contract. The referral contract shall be negotiated with the referral
agency, but shall include the following:
(1)
Terms prohibiting a complainant who has filed with the commission from
cross-filing with a referral agency and vice versa,
(2) Terms permitting the commission to refer
complaints filed with it to a referral agency for processing and vice
versa,
(3) Terms prohibiting the
commission from processing a charge referred to and accepted by the referral
agency and vice versa,
(4) Terms
permitting the commission or a referral agency to reject a charge referred to
it for processing,
(5) Terms ending
the contract after two years, subject to renegotiation, and
(6) Any other terms mutually agreed
upon.
(4)
Procedure for obtaining deferral status.
a.
Application. Any agency
desiring to be designated as a deferral agency by the commission may send a
letter of application to the executive director of the commission. Attached to
the application must be a copy of the agency's enabling legislation or grant of
jurisdiction, a list of its personnel and statement indicating their permanent
or part-time status, their functions, and a summary of the agency's prior
efforts at preventing and eliminating discrimination. The application must also
explain how the agency is capable of obtaining remedies substantially similar
to those available under the Act.
b.
Guidelines for
designation. The executive director will evaluate the applications of
all agencies and may designate deferral agencies where the agencies conform to
the following guidelines:
(1) The agency
should have available resources to enable it to investigate complaints to
ensure processing within a reasonable period of time,
(2) The agency's enabling legislation or
grant of jurisdiction must permit it to obtain substantially the same remedies
as are available under the Act,
(3)
The agency must be able to make a diligent effort to investigate and resolve
the complaints filed with it, and
(4) The agency is capable of obtaining
remedies substantially similar to those available under the Act by informal
means.
c.
Rejection of application. Where the executive director determines that
an agency does not qualify as a deferral agency, the director shall so inform
the agency in writing along with the reasons for the agency's rejection.
If the reasons for the agency's rejection are corrected, the
agency will then be designated as a deferral agency. The executive director's
decision may be appealed to the commission at its subsequent regular
meeting.
e.
Terms of the
deferral contract. The deferral contract shall include, subject to
negotiations with the agency, the following:
(1) The commission will agree to notify the
deferral agency of all complaints filed with the commission which are within
the deferral agency's jurisdiction, except where a complainant requests in
written form that the deferral agency not be notified.
(2) The deferral agency will agree to aid all
complainants whose complaints come within the commission's jurisdiction in
completing the commission's complaint forms as well as notarizing them and
forwarding the fully executed forms to the commission where the necessity to
file a formal complaint exists. If, however, a matter may be resolved
informally more expeditiously the deferral agency will simply notify the
commission by letter of the complaint and resolution obtained. "Informally
resolved complaints" shall refer to complaints that can be resolved within ten
days.
(3) The commission will agree
to postpone its investigation for at least 60 days of any complaint filed with
a deferral agency unless otherwise agreed to by both parties. These waiver
agreements will be made on an individual case basis.
(4) The agency will agree not to disclose the
filing of a complaint or confidential information pertaining to a complaint
until the complaint has been officially set for public hearing.
(5) The commission and the deferral agency
shall share copies of all findings, case summaries, and conciliation
agreements.
(6) Where a complaint
is on file with a deferral agency, the commission will allow the deferral
agency access to the contents of the complainant's file provided that the
deferral agency allows the commission like privileges and has not previously
disclosed confidential information prior to public hearing.
(7) Photocopying of materials from commission
files for use by a deferral agency is solely at the discretion of the
commission staff, but will not be unreasonably denied. When the commission
copies from the agency's file, the agency shall be reasonably compensated for
copying costs.
(8) The commission
will give substantial weight to the findings of a deferral agency where
pertinent and relevant factual evidence exists to support those
findings.
(9) The commission will
not necessarily be bound by the agency's conclusions of law.
(10) Where a deferral agency reaches a
finding of probable cause to support an allegation of discrimination the
contract may permit the agency to pursue conciliation, or to refer the case
back to the commission for conciliation. The contract may also permit an agency
that has attempted conciliation to refer that case back to the commission for
public hearing. In no case where a case has been referred back to the
commission will it be referred back to the agency. Where a case is conciliated
or a hearing is held by the agency or the commission, both will be bound by the
final determination.
(11) The
period for which the contract will be in effect shall not exceed two years,
subject to renegotiation.
(12) The
contract may contain other terms agreed to by the parties.