(1)
Batching Review Process
(a) Pursuant to O.C.G.A. §
31-6-43(e), the
Department may limit the time periods during which it will accept applications
for the following health care facilities and/or services: skilled nursing
facilities; intermediate care facilities; home health agencies, open heart
surgical services, pediatric cardiac catheterization and open heart services,
perinatal services, freestanding birthing centers, psychiatric and substance
abuse services, comprehensive inpatient physical rehabilitation services,
ambulatory surgical services, positron emission tomography services, and
megavoltage radiation therapy services. Limitation of the time periods shall be
to only such times after the Department has determined there is an unmet need
for such facilities and/or services, or will accept applications pursuant to
any service- specific need standard exceptions. The Department shall make a
determination as to whether or not there is an unmet need for each type of
facility at least every six (6) months and shall notify those requesting such
notification of that determination. No application for the services listed
above will be accepted for review by the Department except as provided for
pursuant to Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. r.
111-2-2-.08(1). For
purposes of batching only, the applications entered into the one hundred twenty
(120) day review period shall be evaluated according to the data used to
publish the unmet need, or to accept applications pursuant to any
service-specific need standard exceptions, for the particular service at issue,
for those services listed above, and not the latest available data at the time
of decision, as is the case with all non-batched applications.
(b) Upon the determination of an unmet need
for a particular facility/service in a given service area, the Department shall
provide notice indicating which applications will be considered in that
particular batching cycle to all interested parties requesting notice of that
determination. It shall be the sole and exclusive responsibility of the
interested party to notify the Department in writing of that party's desire to
be informed of the Department's unmet need determination(s) for batching
purposes. The Department's notice shall contain the unmet need for the type of
facility/service in the given service area(s) and shall also contain the
pertinent time frames and deadlines for submission of notices of intent to
apply, for submission of applications, and the review of such
applications.
(c) All parties
interested in applying for the particular unmet need in a given service area
must notify the Department of that party's intent to apply.
1. The notice must be in writing, submitted
via the Department's web portal, and must address specifically the type of
unmet need and service area(s) for which the applicant intends to
apply.
2. The notice of intent must
be received by the Department no later than the close of business on the
thirtieth (30th) calendar day following the date that the Department publishes
the determination of unmet need. In the event that the thirtieth (30th)
calendar day falls on either a weekend or a legal holiday, the thirtieth (30th)
calendar day shall become automatically the next business day that is neither a
weekend nor a legal holiday.
3.
Notwithstanding any other relevant provisions within this Rule, the notice of
intent to apply must be received by the Department either before or
simultaneously with the submission of the actual application in accordance with
the notice of intent deadline.
4.
In the event that the Department fails to receive the notice of intent to apply
by the stated deadline, the interested party shall be disqualified
automatically from applying during that batching cycle.
(d) Subject to the proper submission of a
notice of intent to apply, any interested party shall use the Department's web
portal to submit an application no later than 12:00 P.M. on the sixtieth (60th)
calendar day following the date that the Department publishes the determination
of unmet need. In the event that the sixtieth (60th) calendar day falls either
on a weekend or a legal holiday, the sixtieth (60th) calendar day shall become
automatically the next business day that is neither a weekend nor a legal
holiday. For purposes of batching only, all properly submitted applications
will be deemed received on the sixtieth (60th) day, regardless of the actual
date of submission.
(e) For the
purposes of batching only, an application which has been deemed received
according to (d) above, will only be deemed properly submitted and complete if
the following requirements, in addition to the requirements of Ga. Comp. R.
& Regs. r.
111-2-2-.06(5), are
met:
1. The appropriate Certification
Statement (an applicable service-specific related checklist) is submitted
simultaneously with the original application; and
2. All of the items addressed in the
Certification Statement are provided, as certified, with the original
application.
(f) In the
event that an application is deemed in receipt by (d) above, but is not deemed
to be properly submitted and complete by (e) above by 12:00 PM on the sixtieth
(60th) calendar day following the date that the Department publishes the
determination of unmet need (in the event that the sixtieth (60th) calendar day
falls either on a weekend or a legal holiday, the sixtieth (60th) calendar day
shall become automatically the next business day that is neither a weekend nor
a legal holiday), the application will be disqualified from the batching
review.
(g) The batching review
cycle will be conducted in the following manner:
1. The batching review cycle shall be one
hundred and twenty (120) days in duration. As a result, no party participating
in the batching review process, including the Department, shall either request
or be granted an extension of time past the one hundred and twentieth (120th)
day.
2. The first day of the
batching review cycle shall be the day upon which all properly submitted
applications are deemed to be received. [See Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. r.
111-2-2-.08(1)(d)
above.]
3. On or before the
sixtieth (60th) day of the batching review cycle, the Department shall provide
the applicant(s) an opportunity to meet with the Department. The Department
will describe any issues with the application and provide an opportunity to the
applicant(s) to amend or withdraw the application or to submit additional
information. Any and all additional information must be submitted on or before
the seventy-fifth (75th) day of the batching review cycle. The sixty (60) day
meeting with the applicant(s) is restricted to the Department and the
applicant(s). Parties opposing an application(s) may not attend or participate
in an applicant sixty (60) day meeting.
4. Any party who is opposed to one or more
applications submitted during a batching cycle must submit a notice of
opposition via the Department's web portal, on the form provided by the
Department, no later than the sixtieth (60th) day of the batching review cycle.
The notice must contain the information specified by the form. The notice of
opposition form submission shall also include one signed original of the
written vendor lobbyist certification required by Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. r.
111-1-2-.03(2). The
notice of opposition must not contain the substantive arguments against a
particular application.
Those parties who are opposed to an application will be given
an opportunity to meet with the Department at a time and place specified by the
Department after a review of the opposition notices. The opposition meeting,
provided for by O.C.G.A. §
31-6-43(h), shall
be held no earlier than the ninetieth (90th) day of the batching review cycle.
The applicant(s) shall be entitled to attend the opposition meeting. Only one
designated person on behalf of each party opposed to a particular application
will be allowed to speak on behalf of the opposition to said application at the
opposition meeting. The time period provided for that opposition spokesperson
shall be determined in the sole discretion of the Department. The applicant(s)
will not be allowed to speak in rebuttal of the opposition remarks at the
opposition meeting. The Department shall make no formal substantive comments
regarding the review of the application(s) at the opposition meeting. The
opposition parties shall submit via the Department's web portal, substantive
written comments and arguments regarding the nature of their opposition to the
particular project. The opposition parties must provide one copy of the
substantive opposition comments to the applicant at the opposition meeting. In
order for an opposing party to have standing to appeal an adverse decision
pursuant to O.C.G.A. §
31-6-44, such party must attend
and participate in an opposition meeting. Substantive opposition comments must
pertain to only one application and one applicant. In no case shall the
Department accept substantive opposition comments that concerns multiple
applicants or applications.
Letters of support for a particular application must be
submitted pursuant to and in compliance with Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. r.
111-2-2-.06(6) via
the Department's web portal and can be submitted no later than the one
hundredth (100th) day of the batching review cycle.
5. Applicants shall be given the opportunity
to respond to the substantive opposition comments made orally and submitted in
writing at the opposition meeting. The last day for the applicant(s) to submit
final amendments to the application and/or to respond to the opposition meeting
comments, shall be the one hundred and tenth (110th) day of the batching review
cycle. The Department reserves the right, but is not required to, ask the
applicant(s) for information in response to the substantive opposition
comments. If the Department asks the applicant for information as a result of
the comments provided at the opposition meeting, the applicant must submit the
information requested no later than the one hundred and tenth (110th) day of
the batching review cycle.
6. No
later than the one hundred and twentieth (120th) day of the batching review
cycle, the Department shall provide written notification of its decision to
issue or deny a Certificate of Need to the pertinent applicant(s).
(h) In evaluating batched
applications, if any or all of the batched applications equally meet the
statutory considerations, priority consideration will be given to a comparison
of the applications with regard to:
1. The
past and present records of the facility, and other existing facilities in
Georgia, if any, owned by the same parent organization, regarding the provision
of service to all segments of the population, particularly including Medicare,
Medicaid, minority patients and those patients with limited or no ability to
pay;
2. Specific services to be
offered;
3. Appropriateness of the
site, i.e., the accessibility to the population to be served, availability of
utilities, transportation systems, adequacy of size, cost of acquisition, and
cost to develop;
4. Demonstrated
readiness to implement the project, including commitment of
financing;
5. Patterns of past
performance, if any, of the applicants in implementing previously approved
projects in a timely fashion;
6.
Past record, if any, of the applicant facility, and other existing facilities
owned by the same parent organization, if any, in meeting licensure
requirements and factors relevant to providing accessible, quality health
care;
7. Evidence of attention to
factors of cost containment, which do not diminish the quality of care or
safety of the patient, but which demonstrate sincere efforts to avoid
significant costs unrelated to patient care; and
8. Past compliance, if any, with survey and
post-approval reporting requirements and indigent and charity care
commitments.
(i) In the
event of a favorable decision, the Department's notification letter shall serve
as the Certificate of Need. The date of the decision shall be the date on the
notification letter of the Department. The decision shall be to approve or deny
the application(s) as submitted or as amended by the applicant(s) during the
course of the batching review cycle, whichever is applicable. The effective
date of the Certificate shall be the decision or approval date if not appealed.
If administratively appealed in a timely fashion, the effective date of the
Certificate shall be the date of final resolution of any administrative
hearing. The Department may stay the effective date of a project appealed
through judicial process at the request of any party to such appeal or upon the
Department's own initiative. Any determination by the Department to stay the
effective date will be based upon sound health planning principles. If the
Department stays the effective date of a project appealed through judicial
process, the effective date shall be the date of final resolution of any
judicial appeal.
(j) The decision
letter shall contain at least the following:
1. A detailed statement of the findings
related to each applicable consideration and standard relevant to the decision
to issue or deny a Certificate of Need; and
2. Information pertaining to the availability
of an appeal hearing.
(k)
A copy of the notification letter shall be sent to the applicant(s), to the
appropriate Regional Development Center and to the chief elected official of
the applicable county and municipal government, if any. The Department's
decision shall be subject to the provisions of the Open Records Act.
(l) Appeals of the Decision of the Department
shall be in accordance with the Rules promulgated by the Certificate of Need
Appeal Panel found in Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. Chapter 274.
(2)
Alternative Healthcare
Models
(a)
Applicability.
1. For Certificate of Need purposes,
Alternative Healthcare Models are defined as new and/or innovative models of
providing new or existing institutional health services delivered in a proposed
or existing healthcare facility.
2.
For Certificate of Need purposes, the applicant for an Alternative Healthcare
Model CON will be as follows:
(i) If the
service(s) will be provided within a single healthcare facility, the owner of
that facility will be the applicant;
(ii) If the service(s) will be provided
within two or more healthcare facilities that are part of a healthcare services
network, the owner(s) of the facility(ies) in which the service(s) will be
provided will be the co-applicant(s).
3. The Department shall evaluate the
performance of the Alternative Healthcare Model according to the scope as
defined by the Department decision and the standards set forth in these Rules.
If after a review the Department determines that the Alternative Healthcare
Model does not meet the defined scope or expected standards, the Department may
either immediately revoke the Certificate of Need or grant a specified time
period during which the Alternative Healthcare Model must meet the defined
scope and the expected standards or lose its Certificate of Need.
(b)
Definitions
1. "Alternative healthcare model" means a new
and/or innovative model of providing new or existing institutional health
service(s) delivered in or through a healthcare facility(ies) and/or healthcare
services networks.
2. "Authorized
service" means a Department sanctioned Alternative Healthcare Model, which is
either existing or approved. An existing service is an authorized service,
which has become operational, and an approved service is an authorized service,
which has not yet become operational.
3. "Board" means the Board of Community
Health.
4. "Health care facility",
as defined at O.C.G.A. §
31-6-2(17), means
hospitals; destination cancer hospitals; other special care units, including
but not limited to podiatric facilities; skilled nursing facilities;
intermediate care facilities; personal care homes of at least twenty-five (25)
beds; ambulatory surgical or obstetrical facilities; freestanding emergency
departments or facilities not located on a hospital's primary campus; health
maintenance organizations; home health agencies; diagnostic, treatment, or
rehabilitative centers, but only to the extent that O.C.G.A. §
31-6-40(a)(3) or
(7) or both are applicable thereto.
5. "Healthcare services network" means a
collaborative arrangement that consists of at least one healthcare facility
plus one or more physician groups and/or one or more third party payers, or a
collaborative arrangement that includes at least two or more healthcare
facilities.
6. "Most recent year"
means the most recent calendar year prior to submission of an
application.
7. "Official
inventory" means the inventory of all authorized Alternative Healthcare Models
maintained by the Department based on CON approval and official Department
records.
8. "Official state
component plan" means the most recent document(s) that is/are most closely
related to those services being provided by the Alternative Healthcare Model.
The most recent document(s) will have been developed by the Department and
approved by the Board.
9. "State
health policies" means the most recent policies developed by the Board, which
provide a framework for the service-specific policies included within each
component of the State Health Plan. These state health policies include health
promotion, financial accessibility, least restrictive care, regionalization,
cost containment, health planning and citizen participation, healthcare
personnel, and healthcare data and information networks.
(c)
Requests for Proposals
1. Within the period of April 1 through May
31 of each year, the Board may accept abstracts describing potential
Alternative Healthcare Models, based on the recommendation of the Department.
The Board will review these abstracts, if any are solicited for that year, by
August 31 of that year and select a list of those categories for which
Alternative Healthcare Model Certificate of Need applications may be
submitted.
2. Within thirty (30)
days of the determination by the Board of the particular categories under which
Alternative Healthcare Model Certificate of Need applications may be submitted,
the Department shall provide notice of these categories to all interested
parties. The notice shall contain:
(i) the
listing of category(ies) related goals and desired outcomes and the probable
scope of services;
(ii) the
pertinent time frames and deadlines for submission of notices of intent to
apply for Alternative Healthcare Model Certificate of Need;
(iii) the pertinent time frames and deadlines
for submission of CON applications; and
(iv) the pertinent time frames and deadlines
for the review of such applications, and any related criteria for
review.
(d)
Intent to Apply
1. All parties
wanting to apply for Alternative Healthcare Model Certificates of Need under
the selected categories must notify the Department of that party's intent to
apply.
2. This notice must be:
(i) in writing, submitted via the
Department's web portal, and must address specifically the particular category
under which the applicant intends to apply;
(ii) received by the Department no later than
the close of business on the sixtieth (60th) calendar day following the date
that the Department publishes the notice of the selected categories. In the
event that the sixtieth (60th) calendar day falls on either a weekend or a
legal holiday, the sixtieth (60th) calendar day shall become automatically the
next business day that is neither a weekend nor a legal holiday;
(iii) must be received by the Department
either before or simultaneously with the submission of the actual application;
and
(iv) in the event that the
Department fails to receive the notice of intent to apply by the stated
deadline, the interested party automatically shall be disqualified from
applying during that particular review cycle.
(e)
Application Process
1. Certificate of Need applications
pertaining to the selected categories will be submitted via the Department's
web portal on or before 3:00 p.m. June 1 of the year following the year in
which the categories were selected by the Board. (Although applications may be
submitted prior to 3:00 p.m. June 1, all application will be deemed received on
June 1.) In the event that June 1 falls either on a weekend or a legal holiday,
the day of submission shall become automatically the next business day that is
neither a weekend nor a legal holiday;
2. Alternative Healthcare Model Certificate
of Need applications must comply with the requirements in Ga. Comp. R. &
Regs. r. 111-2-2-.06(2) and
(3).
3. For the purposes of Alternative Healthcare
Model Certificate of Need applications, an application will be deemed properly
submitted if the following requirements are met:
(i) a summary of the Certificate of Need
application is included to be used as information for the Board and general
public;
(ii) a Certification
Statement of Completeness is included designating under which category the
application is being submitted; and
(iii) all items addressed in the
Certification Statement of Completeness are provided with the
application.
(f)
The Review Cycle
1. The review cycle shall be automatically
one hundred and twenty (120) days in duration. As a result, no party
participating in the review process, including the Department, shall either
request or be granted an extension of time past the one hundred and twentieth
(120th) day;
2. The first day of
the review cycle shall be the day upon which all properly submitted
applications are deemed to be received as specified in Ga. Comp. R. & Regs.
r. 111-2-2-.08(2)(e)3.
3. No later than the thirtieth
(30th) day of the review cycle, the Department shall, if deemed necessary,
submit a written request to any and all pertinent applicants for clarifying
and/or supplemental information. This written request may be distributed within
a meeting of the applicant(s). The purpose of the request for clarifying and/or
supplemental information shall be to obtain information from the applicant(s)
that clarifies or supplements the initial information submitted with the
original application.
4. No later
than the forty-fifth (45th) day of the review cycle, the applicant(s) shall, if
deemed necessary by the Department, submit their clarifying and/or supplemental
information. Failure to submit the required clarifying and/or supplemental
information by the forty-fifth (45th) day may be grounds for denial of the
application.
5. If, by the
forty-fifth (45th) day, the review indicates potential for denial of the
application(s), the Department, on or before the sixtieth (60th) day of the
review cycle, shall provide the applicant(s) an opportunity to meet with the
Department. The problems with the application(s) will be described and an
opportunity offered to amend or withdraw the application or to submit
additional information. Any and all additional information and amendments must
be submitted on or before the seventy-fifth (75th) day of the review
cycle.
6. The last day for
interested parties (including, but not limited to, competing applicant(s)
and/or existing competing health care facilities) to submit letters of support
or opposition addressing the underlying merits, or lack thereof, of any pending
application(s) shall be the eighty-fifth (85th) day of the review cycle and
must be submitted via the Department's web portal. Any letters of support
and/or opposition that are received after the eighty-fifth (85th) day of the
review cycle shall not be considered by the Department in its review of the
pertinent application(s) and the letter(s) shall not become part of the master
file compiled for the pertinent application(s).
7. The last day for applicant(s) to submit
final amendments and responses to letters of opposition shall be the one
hundred and tenth (110th) day of the review cycle.
8. No later than the one hundred and
twentieth (120th) day of the review cycle, the Department shall provide a
written letter notifying the applicant of their decision to issue or deny a
Certificate of Need to the pertinent applicant(s).
9. In the event of a favorable decision, this
letter shall serve as the Certificate of Need. The date of the decision shall
be the date on the notification letter from the Department. The decision shall
be to approve or deny the application(s) as submitted or as amended by the
applicant(s) during the course of the review cycle, whichever is
applicable.
10. The decision letter
shall contain at least the following:
(i) a
detailed statement of the findings related to each applicable consideration and
standard relevant to the decision to issue or deny a Certificate of Need;
and
(ii) information pertaining to
the availability of an appeal hearing.
11. A copy of the notification letter shall
be sent to the applicant(s), to the appropriate Regional Development Center and
to the chief elected official of the applicable county and municipal
government, if any. The Department's decision shall be subject to the
provisions of the Open Records Act.
12. Appeals of the decision of the Department
shall be in accordance with the Rules promulgated by the Certificate of Need
Appeal Panel.
(g)
Standards
1. An Alternative
Healthcare Model must be consistent with the State Health Policies adopted by
the Board.
2. An Alternative
Healthcare Model must clearly define its target population/community.
3. An Alternative Healthcare Model must:
(i) include a hypothesis(es) to be tested
within a time-limited period not to exceed five (5) years;
(ii) demonstrate, as applicable, how it will
support research, new service development, health professional education and
training, and/or affiliation with an academic center of higher learning;
and
(iii) demonstrate that the
community supports the Alternative Healthcare Model.
4. An applicant for an Alternative Healthcare
Model CON shall demonstrate the feasibility of operating the Alternative
Healthcare Model in Georgia, based on a review of the experience in other
states including the impact on health professionals of other healthcare
programs or facilities and how the project is impacted by payers and regulatory
entities.
5. An applicant for an
Alternative Healthcare Model CON shall demonstrate the potential of the
Alternative Healthcare Model to reduce healthcare costs to consumers, third
party payors and the system as a whole.
6. An applicant for an Alternative Healthcare
Model CON shall demonstrate the potential of the Alternative Healthcare Model
to maintain or improve the standards of healthcare quality in some measurable
fashion.
7. An applicant for an
Alternative Healthcare Model CON shall demonstrate the potential of the
Alternative Healthcare Model to provide increased choices or access for
consumers to a continuum of services within the target community.
8. An applicant for an Alternative Healthcare
Model CON shall demonstrate the potential of the Alternative Healthcare Model
to meet existing or emerging health status and/or health system
needs.
9. For any applicant that
meets the requirements of this Rule the Department may waive all or part of
otherwise applicable service-specific Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. r.
111-2-2-.20 et seq.