1. Traffic density, including concentration
of fishing vessels or any other vessels, requires that vessels slacken speed
under Inland Navigation Rule 6(a)(ii) (33 U.S.C. §2006) as adopted by
Section 327.33, F.S. or
2. The traffic density establishes a
significant risk of collision or a significant threat to boating
safety.
3. Unsafe levels of vessel
traffic density or congestion for purposes of this subsection shall be
considered based upon one or more of the following:
a. Accident reports - The following reports
of boating accidents will be considered if prepared contemporaneously with the
boating accident being reported and if such reports establish that vessel
traffic congestion or the speed, wake, or operation of a vessel involved in the
accident was a primary contributing factor in the accident:
(I) Florida Boating Accident Investigation
Reports, FWCDLE form146 or Florida Boating Accident Self Reports, FWCDLE
form146C both of which are incorporated by reference in Rule
68D-21.004(7),
F.A.C. and may be obtained from Boating and Waterways Section, 620 South
Meridian Street, Tallahassee, FL 32399-1600; or any official United States
Coast Guard report form pertaining to boating accidents or
casualty
b. Multiple
Uniform Boating Citations issued on citation forms supplied by the Commission
as provided in Section
327.74, F.S., or written
warnings if the violation alleged in the citation or warning is related to the
cited vessel's speed, wake, or operation. Citations and written warnings
unrelated to vessel speed, wake, or operation will not be considered, nor will
verbal warnings. In no event will citations or written warnings issued for
violations of Chapter 328, or Sections
327.50,
327.53,
327.54,
327.65,
327.66, F.S., be
considered.
c. Vessel traffic
studies substantially demonstrating that vessel traffic congestion or the
speed, wake, or operation of vessels in the area create unsafe levels of vessel
traffic congestion, a significant risk of collision, or a significant threat to
boating safety. The Commission will accept and review vessel traffic studies
under this rule. Video surveillance made during a vessel traffic study shall
include a corresponding log documenting the number of vessels, vessel types,
examples of careless or reckless operation of vessels, navigation rule
violations, actions taken to avoid collisions, unsafe vessel speeds, near
misses of navigational hazards by vessels, or any other specific criteria the
applicant wants considered, along with relevant video time stamps for each
item.
(I) . When vessel traffic studies alone
are relied upon to establish a boating restricted area, the Commission shall
rely on documentation of vessel traffic within the area for a minimum of
fourteen (14) consecutive days.
(II) . Vessel traffic studies will not be
considered unless they identify the number of vessels transiting the proposed
boating restricted area each hour for no less than six hours out of each
twenty-four-hour period documented and identify the area of the study by
longitude and latitude. When this minimum threshold is met, the Commission will
evaluate the area taking all other relevant factors into consideration,
including width of the waterway, vessel types using the waterway, navigational
hazards, and will also consider evidence provided demonstrating the existence
of conditions specific to the proposed boating restricted area impacting vessel
traffic or vessel operations.
(III)
. In assessing the creditability of a vessel traffic study, the following
factors (as applicable) shall be among those considered:
(A) . Whether the study's methodology can be
or has been tested (i.e., whether the study's methodology can be challenged in
some objective sense, or whether it is instead simply a subjective, conclusory
approach that cannot reasonably be assessed for reliability);
(B) . Whether the study's methodology has
been subject to peer review and publication;
(C) . The known or potential rate of error of
the study's methodology;
(D) . The
existence and maintenance of standards and controls; and,
(E) . Whether the methodology has been
generally accepted in the scientific community.
d. Other creditable data. For the purposes of
this subparagraph, "other creditable data" means facts or data that are of a
type reasonably relied upon by experts in the fields of boating safety,
maritime safety, navigation safety, ports and waterways safety assessments, or
vessel traffic management, as contemplated in section
90.704,
F.S.