Current through Register Vol. 49, No. 9, September, 2024
Section 1.
Definitions.
1.1 "Act" means the
Arkansas Scholarship Lottery Act.
1.2 "ALC" means the Arkansas Lottery
Commission.
1.3 "Addendum" or
"Addenda" means an addition or deletion to, a material change in or general
interest explanation of a solicitation document.
1.4 "Advantageous" means in the ALC's
interests, as assessed according to the judgment of the ALC.
1.5 "Award" means either the act or
occurrence of the ALC's identification of the person with whom the ALC will
enter into a contract.
1.6 "Bid"
means a response to an Invitation to Bid.
1.7 "Bidder" means a person that submits a
bid in response to an Invitation to Bid.
1.8 "Closing" means the date and time
announced in a solicitation document as the deadline for submitting
offers.
1.9 "Commission" or
"Commissioners" means the member(s) of the ALC as appointed under Ark. Code
Ann. §
23-115-202.
1.10 "Contract" means all types of state
agreements, regardless of what they may be called, for the purchase, lease,
rental or other acquisition of goods and services and for the disposal of
surplus commodities and services not otherwise exempt.
1.11 "Contract Price" means as the context
requires:
(a) The maximum payments that the
ALC will make under a contract if the contractor fully performs under the
contract;
(b) The maximum
not-to-exceed amount of payments specified in the contract; or
(c) The unit prices for goods and services
set forth in the contract.
1.12 "Contractor" means the person with whom
the ALC enters into a contract.
1.13 "Director" means the director of the
ALC.
1.14 "Emergency" means
circumstances that:
(a) Could not have been
reasonably foreseen; and
(b)
Require prompt execution of a contract to remedy the condition; and
(c) Meet one of the following two conditions:
(1) The circumstances create a substantial
risk of loss or revenue, damage or interruption of services or substantial
threat to property, public health, welfare or safety when the circumstances
could not have been reasonably foreseen; or
(2) The circumstances require immediate and
decisive action to protect the security, credibility, or Integrity of the
Lottery or a lottery game.
1.15 "Goods and Services" or "Goods or
Services" means supplies, equipment, materials and services including personal
services and any personal property, including any tangible, intangible and
intellectual property and rights and licenses in relation thereto, that the ALC
is authorized by law to procure.
1.16 "Information Technology Contract" means
a contract for the acquisition, disposal, repair, maintenance or modification
of hardware, software or services for computers or
telecommunications.
1.17
"Invitation to Bid" or "ITB" means all documents, whether attached or
incorporated by reference, used for soliciting bids using a competitive bidding
process in which specifications, price and delivery (or project completion)
will be the predominant award criteria.
1.18 "Lottery" means any game of chance
approved by the ALC pursuant to the Arkansas Scholarship Lottery Act.
1.19 "Major Procurement" or "Major
Procurement Contract" means a contract for a gaming product or service costing
more than seventy-five thousand dollars ($75,000) including without limitation:
(a) A major advertising contract;
(b) An annuity contract;
(c) A prize payment agreement;
(d) A consulting service;
(e) Lottery equipment;
(f) Tickets; and
(g) Any other product and service unique to
lotteries.
1.20 "Major
Procurement Contract" does not include a material, supply, equipment, or
service common to the ordinary operations of the ALC. When the cost of a
proposed contract for a gaming product or service is to be paid in whole or in
part on a contingent basis, the ALC shall estimate the value of the proposed
contract to determine whether it is a major procurement contract.
1.21 "Offer" means a response to a
solicitation document.
1.22
"Offeror" means a person who submits an offer.
1.23 "Person" means an individual,
corporation, business trust, estate, trust, partnership, limited liability
company, association, joint venture, governmental agency, public corporation or
any other legal or commercial entity.
1.24 "Personal Services" means the services
or type of services performed under a personal services contract.
1.25 "Personal Services Contract" means a
contract or member of a class of contracts whose primary purpose is to acquire
specialized skills, knowledge and resources in the application of technical or
scientific expertise, or the exercise of professional, artistic or management
discretion or judgment, including, without limitation, a contract for the
services of an accountant, educator, information technology or other
consultant, broadcaster or artist (including a photographer, filmmaker,
painter, or sculptor.)
1.26
"Proposal" means a response to a Request for Proposal.
1.27 "Proposer" means a person that submits a
proposal in response to a Request for Proposal.
1.28 "Request for Proposal" or "RFP" means
all documents, whether attached or incorporated by reference, used for
soliciting proposals using a competitive proposal process in which price is not
the sole determining factor for contract award.
1.29 "Request for Qualifications" or "RFQ"
means a solicitation document requiring submittal of qualifications or
specialized expertise in response to the scope of work or services required and
does not require pricing.
1.30
"Responsible Bidder/Proposer/Offeror" means a vendor who submits a bid, offer,
quote or proposal in response to a solicitation and who, in the reasonable
opinion of the ALC:
(a) Is able and is
otherwise qualified in all respects to perform fully the contract requirements
without delay; and
(b) Has the
integrity and reliability which will assure good faith performance.
1.31 "Responsive
Bidder/Proposer/Offeror" (also "Responsive Bid" "Responsive Offer" or
"Responsive Proposal" as applicable) means an offer that substantially complies
in all material respects with applicable solicitation document requirements.
When used alone, "Responsive" means having the characteristics of substantially
complying in all material respects with applicable solicitation document
requirements.
1.32 'Scope" means
the range and attributes of the goods or services described in the applicable
solicitation document, or if no solicitation document, In the
contract.
1.33 'Signed" or
'Signature" means any mark, word or symbol attached to or logically associated
with a document and executed or adopted by a person, with the intent to be
bound.
1.34 'Solicitation" means
all documents, whether attached or incorporated by reference, utilized for
soliciting bids, offers, quotes, or proposals with respect to a particular
major procurement.
1.35
'Solicitation Document" means an Invitation to Bid, Request for Proposal or
other document issued to invite offers from prospective contractors.
1.36 'Specification" means any description of
the physical or functional characteristics or of the nature of goods or
services, including any requirement for inspecting, testing or preparing goods
or services for delivery and the quantities of materials to be furnished under
a contract. Specifications generally will state the result to be obtained and
may, on occasion, describe the method and manner of doing the work to be
performed.
1.37 "Vendor" means a
person who provides or proposes to provide goods or services to the ALC under a
major procurement contract. Vendor does not include:
(a) An employee of the ALC;
(b) A retailer; or
(c) A state agency or
instrumentality.
1.38
"Vendor" includes a corporation whose stock is publicly traded and that is the
parent company of the contracting party in a major procurement
contract.
1.39 "Work" means the
furnishing of all materials, equipment, labor and incidentals necessary to
successfully complete any individual requirement in a contract and successful
completion of all duties and obligations imposed by the contract.
1.40 "Written" or "Writing" means
conventional paper documents, whether handwritten, typewritten or printed, in
contrast to spoken words. It also includes electronic transmissions or
facsimile documents when required by applicable law or permitted by a
solicitation document or contract.
Section 3.
Solicitations.
3.1
Generally.
A. The provisions of this
section are applicable to all solicitations of procurement contracts regardless
of the procurement method used by the ALC. All solicitations shall detail:
1. Terms and conditions clearly detailing the
requirements for the response to the solicitation, including the schedule for
submitting and evaluating responses to solicitations as well as contract
language in the event of award;
2.
Where more than one item is specified, whether the ALC will have the right to
accept proposals either on the basis of each individual item, a group of items,
or total of all items; and
3. Any
requirement for a performance bond.
B. Unless the solicitation specifically
permits offers of used or reconditioned items, all solicitations shall be
deemed to require that all materials, supplies, and equipment offered and
furnished must be new and not reconditioned.
3.2
Limitations Regarding Submissions
of Solicitations,A. The ALC is
committed to a competitive procurement process that maintains the highest level
of integrity. Therefore, no communication outside the procurement process
initiated by vendors, their attorneys, representatives, or others promoting
their position, other than normal business activities not associated with the
procurement, will be allowed with any officer, employee, or member of, or
consultant or advisor to, the ALC. Any attempt to influence any employees,
officers, consultants, advisors or ALC members of the ALC with respect to a
procurement, whether such attempt is oral or written, formal or informal, is
strictly prohibited and will result in disqualification.
B. All bids, offers, quotes or proposals and
the contracts resulting from solicitations are subject to the requirements of
and must comply with the Act, regardless of whether or not specifically
addressed in either the solicitations or the proposal. All potential vendors
shall read and be familiar with the Act, a copy of which may be obtained
through a link on the ALC's web site.
C. The ALC shall not under any circumstance
be responsible for any expenses incurred by a vendor in preparing and
submitting a proposal.
D. All
materials submitted to the ALC by vendors shall upon submission become the
property of the ALC and may be used as the ALC deems appropriate.
E. From the time a solicitation is issued
until either (a) six (6) months after the award of a contract or (b) the
rejection of all bids, offer, quotes, or proposals received by the ALC, vendors
are prohibited from officially or unofficially making any employment offer or
proposing any business arrangement whatsoever to any ALC employee, officer, or
ALC member.
3,3 Signature Required. Each bid, offer, quote, or
proposal must be signed by the vendor's authorized agent. If a joint proposal
that includes multiple vendors is submitted, it must define completely the
responsibilities that each entity is proposing to undertake, as well as the
proposed responsibilities of each subcontractor of each entity. The proposal
must be signed by an authorized officer or agent of each entity. In addition,
the ALC reserves the right, in its sole discretion, to require an authorized
officer or agent of each subcontractor, or each subcontractor that is expected
to provide a specified amount of the procured product or service, to sign the
proposal. Such requirement shall be clearly set forth in the solicitation. The
proposal must designate a single authorized official from one of the entities
to serve as the sole point of contact between the ALC and the responding joint
venture, strategic partnership, or prime contractor team. Any contract
resulting from a joint proposal must be signed by an authorized officer or
agent of each entity. In addition, the ALC reserves the right, in its sole
discretion, to require an authorized officer or agent of each subcontractor, or
each subcontractor that is expected to provide a specified amount of the
procured product or service, to sign any such contract. Such requirement, or
the possibility of such requirement, shall be clearly set forth in the
solicitation.
3.4
Addenda to Solicitation Documents.
The ALC reserves the right to make changes to any solicitation by
issuance of a written addendum or amendment. The ALC may issue any such
addendum or amendment at any time prior to entering a contract regarding the
applicable major procurement. Any addendum or amendment will be posted on the
ALC's web page, and notice of the same shall be communicated, via facsimile, to
all vendors who requested and were sent a copy of the applicable solicitation
or who have submitted a bid, offer, quote, or proposal in respect of such
solicitation. An offeror shall provide written acknowledgement of receipt of
all issued addenda with Its offer, unless the ALC otherwise specifies in the
addenda.
3.5
Cancellation,
Rejection, and Delay of a Solicitation.
A. Generally. Any procurement described in a
solicitation document may be cancelled, or any or all offers may be rejected in
whole or in part, when the cancellation or rejection is in the best interest of
the ALC as determined by the ALC. The reasons for the cancellation or rejection
must be made a part of the solicitation file. The ALC is not liable to any
offeror for any loss or expense caused by or resulting from the cancellation or
rejection of a solicitation document, offer, or award.
B. Offer Findings. The ALC shall reject an
offer upon the ALC's finding that the offer:
1. Is contingent upon the ALC's acceptance of
terms and conditions (including specifications) that differ from the
solicitation document;
2. Takes
exceptions to terms and conditions (including specifications) set forth in the
solicitation document;
3. Attempts
to prevent public disclosure of matters in contravention of the terms and
conditions of the solicitation document or in contravention of applicable
law;
4. Offers goods or services
that fail to meet the specifications of the solicitation document;
5. Is late;
6. Is not In substantial compliance with the
solicitation document requirements; or
7. Is not in substantial compliance with all
prescribed public procurement procedures.
C. Offeror Findings. The ALC shall reject an
offer upon the ALC's finding that the offeror:
1. Has been debarred pursuant to Section
3.9;
2. Has not properly executed bid or proposal
security as required by the solicitation document; or
3. Is non-responsible.
D. Disposition of Offers.
1. Prior to Closing: If the ALC cancels a
solicitation prior to closing, the ALC shall return all offers it received to
offerors unopened, provided the offeror submitted its offer in a hard copy
format with a clearly visible return address. If there is no return address on
the envelope, the ALC shall open the offer to determine the source and then
return it to the offeror.
2. After
Closing: If the ALC cancels a solicitation after closing, the ALC shall keep
the offers in the procurement file.
3. Rejection of All Offers: If the ALC
rejects all offers, the ALC shall keep all offers in the procurement
file.
3.6
Discovery. The ALC reserves the right to obtain any information
from any lawful source as required by the Act and regarding the past business
history, practices, and abilities of vendors, their officers, directors,
employees, owners, team members, partners, or subcontractors. Such information
may be taken into consideration in evaluation of the proposals.
3.7
Pre-Closing Modifications or
Withdrawal of Offers.A. An offeror may
modify its offer in writing prior to closing. An offeror shall prepare and
submit any modifications to its offer to the ALC. The last offer received by
the ALC prior to closing will supersede any previous offers received unless the
offer is identified by the offeror as an alternate offer.
B. Change in Circumstance: Each offeror is
under a continuing obligation to notify the ALC following the submission of a
proposal of any changes to the information, data, or facts submitted in their
response that could reasonably be expected to affect the ALC's consideration of
the proposal.
C. Withdrawals: An
offeror may withdraw its offer by written notice submitted on the offeror's
letterhead, signed by an authorized representative of the offeror, delivered to
the ALC and received by the ALC prior to closing. The offeror or authorized
representative of the offeror may also withdraw its offer in person prior to
closing, upon presentation of appropriate identification and evidence of
authority satisfactory to the ALC. After the solicitation deadline, a vendor
may withdraw its bid, offer, quote, or proposal, or other response or a portion
thereof only upon a written determination by the ALC that there is an obvious
error in such response and where the enforcement of the response would impose
an unconscionable hardship on the vendor. A reduction or diminution in profit
margin shall not be deemed an unconscionable hardship under this
subsection.
3.8
Mistakes.A. Generally. To protect the
Integrity of the competitive procurement process and to assure fair treatment
of offerors, the ALC shall carefully consider whether to permit waiver or
correction for mistakes.
B. ALC's
Treatment of Mistakes. The ALC shall not allow an offeror to correct or
withdraw an offer for an error of judgment. If the ALC discovers certain
mistakes in an offer after closing, but before award of the contract, the ALC
may take the following action:
1. Minor
Informality: The ALC may waive, or permit an offeror to correct a minor
informality. A minor informality Is a matter of form rather than substance when
it Is evident on the face of the offer, or an insignificant mistake that can be
waived or corrected without prejudice to other offerors. Examples of minor
informalities include, but are not limited to, an offeror's failure to:
a. Return the correct number of signed offers
or the correct number of other documents required by the solicitation
document;
b. Sign the offer in the
designated block, provided a signature appears elsewhere In the offer,
evidencing an intent to be bound;and
c. Acknowledge receipt of an addendum to the
solicitation document, provided that it is clear on the face of the offer that
the offeror received the addendum and Intended to be bound by its terms; or the
addendum involved did not affect price, quality or delivery.
2. Clerical Error: The ALC may
correct a clerical error if the error is evident on the face of the offer or
other documents submitted with the offer, and the offeror confirms the ALC's
correction in writing. A clerical error is an offeror's error in transcribing
its offer. Examples include typographical mistakes, errors in extending unit
prices, transposition errors, arithmetical errors, and instances in which the
intended correct unit or amount is evident by simple arithmetic calculations.
In the event of a discrepancy, unit prices shall prevail over extended
prices.
3. Burden of Proof: The ALC
may permit an offeror to withdraw an offer based on one or more clerical errors
in the offer only if the offeror shows with objective proof and by clear and
convincing evidence:
a. The nature of the
error;
b. That the error is not a
minor informality under this subsection or an error of judgment;
c. That the error cannot be corrected or
waived under subsection B of this section;
d. That the offeror acted in good faith in
submitting an offer that contained the claimed error and in claiming that
alleged error in the offer exists;
e. That the offeror acted without gross
negligence in submitting an offer that contained a claimed error;
f. That the offeror will suffer substantial
detriment if the ALC does not grant the offeror permission to withdraw the
offer;
g. That the ALC's status has
not changed so significantly that relief from the forfeiture will work a
substantial hardship on the ALC; and
h. That the offeror promptly gave notice of
the claimed error to the ALC.
4. Withdrawing Offers after Closing: The
criteria in subsection
3.7(C) of these
rules shall determine whether the ALC will permit an offeror to withdraw its
offer after closing. This criteria also shall apply to the question of whether
the ALC will permit an offeror to withdraw without forfeiture of its bid bond
(or other bid or proposal security), or without liability to the ALC based on
the difference between the amount of the offeror's offer and the amount of the
contract actually awarded by the ALC, whether by award to the next lowest
responsive and responsible offeror the most advantageous and responsible
offeror, or by resort to a new solicitation.
C. Rejection for Mistakes: The ALC shall
reject an offer in which a mistake is evident on the face of the offer and the
intended correct offer is not evident or cannot be substantiated from documents
submitted with the offer.
D.
Identification of Mistakes after Award: The procedures and criteria set forth
above are offeror's only opportunity to correct mistakes or withdraw offers
because of a mistake. Following award, an offeror is bound by its offer, and
may only withdraw its offer or rescind a contract entered into pursuant to the
extent permitted by these rules and applicable law.
3.9
Debarment of Prospective
Offerors.
A. Generally. The Lottery
may debar a prospective offeror from consideration for award of ALC contracts
for the reasons listed in subsection B of these rules after providing the
prospective offeror with notice and a reasonable opportunity to be
heard.
B. Factors for
Consideration. A prospective offeror may be debarred from consideration for
award of ALC contracts if:
1. The prospective
offeror has committed a violation of a material contract provision. A violation
may include but is not limited to a failure to perform the terms of a contract
or an unsatisfactory performance in accordance with the terms of the contract.
However, a failure to perform or unsatisfactory performance caused by acts
beyond the control of the contractor may not be considered to be a basis for
debarment.
2. The prospective
offeror has been convicted of a criminal offense resulting from obtaining or
attempting to obtain a public or private contract or subcontract or resulting
from the performance of such contract or subcontract.
3. The prospective offeror has been convicted
under state or federal statutes of embezzlement, theft, forgery, bribery,
falsification or destruction of records, receiving stolen property or any other
offense Indicating a lack of business integrity or business honesty that
currently, seriously and directly affects the prospective offeror's
responsibility as a contractor or that the ALC determines may affect the
honesty, fairness, integrity or security of the ALC or any Lottery
games.
4. The prospective offeror
has been convicted under state or federal antitrust statutes.
5. The prospective offeror does not carry
worker's compensation or unemployment insurance as required by
statute.
C. Period of
Debarment. The ALC shall determine the period of debarment of a prospective
offeror, however, the period shall not exceed three years.
D. Responsibility. Notwithstanding the
limitation on the term for debarment in subsection C of section
3.9, the ALC may determine that a
previously debarred offeror is not responsible prior to contract
award.
E. Imputed Knowledge. The
ALC may attribute improper conduct of a person or its affiliate or affiliates
having a contract with a prospective offeror to the prospective offeror for
purposes of debarment where the impropriety occurred in connection with the
person's duty for on behalf of, or with the knowledge, approval, or
acquiescence of, the prospective offeror.
F. Limited Participation. The ALC may allow a
debarred person to participate in a competitive process and contracts on a
limited basis during the debarment period upon written determination by the
Director that participation is advantageous to the ALC. The determination shall
specify the factors on which it is based and define the extent of the limits
imposed.
G. Decision.
1. The Director shall issue a written
decision to debar a prospective offeror under these rules. The decision must:
a. State the reasons for the debarment;
and
b. Inform the debarred
prospective offeror of the appeal rights of the prospective offeror under
subsection H of Section 3.9.
2. The ALC shall send a copy of the decision
immediately to the debarred prospective offeror by certified mail, return
receipt requested, or by personal service.
H. Appeal.
1. The procedure for appeal from the ALC's
debarment of a prospective offeror under these rules shall be In accordance
with this section.
2. Upon receipt
of a notice from the ALC of a decision to debar under these rules, a
prospective offeror that wishes to appeal the decision shall, within three
business days after receipt of the decision, notify the Director that the
prospective offeror appeals the decision and requests a hearing as provided in
this section.
3. Upon receipt of
the prospective offeror's notice of appeal and request for hearing, the
Director shall promptly notify the prospective offeror appealing of the time
and place of the hearing. The Director shall conduct the hearing and decide the
appeal within thirty Days after receiving the notice from the prospective
offeror. The Director shall set forth In writing the reasons for the hearing
decision.
4. At the hearing, the
Director shall consider de novo the notice of debarment, the reasons listed in
Section 3.9(B) of these
rules on which the ALC based the debarment, and any evidence provided by the
ALC and the prospective offeror.
5.
The decision of the Director is final and may only be appealed pursuant to the
procedures set forth in Section
5.8 of these Rules.
3.11
Inspection
of Solicitation Records.A. All data,
materials, and documentation originated and prepared for the ALC pursuant to
solicitations shall belong exclusively to the ALC and may be available to the
public in accordance with these rules and the provisions of Ark. Code Ann.
§
23-115-404.
Under no circumstances will the ALC be liable to any vendor or to any other
person or entity, for any disclosure of any trade secret or confidential
information.
B. Upon the ALC's
issuance of a notice of intent to award a major procurement contract, the ALC's
procurement files for such major procurement will be open for public
inspection. Notwithstanding the foregoing, (a) the ALC shall not be required to
make available for public inspection information protected by or otherwise not
required to be disclosed pursuant to applicable law, or these rules; and (b)
the ALC may delay making its procurement files available to the public for such
reasonable period of time as the ALC determines is necessary for it to redact
or otherwise secure that portion of its procurement files that will not be made
available to the public. The ALC's procurement records that are made available
to the public shall be available for inspection during the ALC's regular office
hours.
3.12
Pre-Solicitation Process. Whenever the ALC wants to evaluate the
availability, durability, adaptability, or other specifications of goods or
services in advance of seeking to procure such goods or services, the Director
may elect to utilize a pre-solicitation process to identify potential offerors
or possible solutions to the need being addressed. The Director may opt to use
any or all of the following methods to acquire information:
(a) Oral presentations;
(b) Pre-solicitation notices;
(c) Pre-solicitation conferences;
(d) Requests for information;
(e) Site visits; or
(f) Any other method the Director deems
appropriate in his or her discretion.
Section 4.
Source Selection.
4.1
Generally. The ALC will
generally conduct a competitive process for goods or services by issuing a
solicitation document. The ALC shall award contracts for goods or services by
one of the source selection methods in this section subject to the following
exceptions:
(a) Small Procurements. Any
procurement of goods or services not exceeding five thousand dollars ($5,000)
may be awarded without a competitive process. All small procurements will be
obtained according to Ark. Code Ann. §
19-11-231.
(b) Intermediate Procurements. Any
procurement of goods or services between five thousand dollars ($5000) and
seventy-five thousand dollars ($75,000) shall be governed by Arkansas Code Ann.
§
19-11-201 et
seq. Contracts in which the purchase price exceeds five thousand ($5,000)
dollars and is less than or equal to twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) may
be awarded by either competitive bidding procedures or competitively sealed
bidding procedures. Any contract amount over twenty-five thousand dollars
($25,000) will be awarded by competitively sealed bidding procedures unless
specifically exempt in statute.
4.2
Sole-Source Procurements.
A. For purposes of these rules, "sole-source
procurements" means those procurements which, by virtue of the performance
specification, are available from a single source. Brand name or design
specifications shall not be sufficient explanation for sole source. Such
procurements may include but shall not be limited to:
1. Requirements of performance compatibility
with existing commodities or services; or
2. Repairs involving hidden damage.
B. Procurements under this section
shall be approved in advance by the Commission.
C. Request for approval shall be made in
writing and shall include in the justification:
1. A copy of the purchase order or
requisition;
2. Why the service is
needed;
3. The methods used to
determine that a lack of responsible/responsive competition exists for the
service;
4. How it was determined
that the provider possesses exclusive capabilities;
5. Why the service is unique;
6. Whether or not there are patent or
proprietary rights which make the required service unavailable from other
sources;
7. What the agency would
do if the provider/service were no longer available, and
8. Any program considerations which make the
use of a "sole source" critical to the successful completion of the agency's
task.
4.3
Requests for Proposals.A. The
provisions of this subsection shall be applicable solely to solicitations of
major procurement contracts by means of an RFP.
B. Issuance of RFP. The ALC shall prepare and
issue an RFP and evaluate proposals in accordance with this subsection. Failure
by the ALC to comply with any technical requirement of this subsection shall
not alone be deemed a defect requiring re-issuance of the RFP or rejection of
all bids, offers, quotes, or proposals, such decision remaining in the
discretion of the ALC.
C. RFP
Document. An RFP shall set forth provisions including:
1. A clear description of the scope of
products and services. The technical requirements, scope, and other essential
requirements shall be in sufficient detail to minimize the likelihood of
requests by vendors for clarification;
2. Complete directions about making
proposals;
3. An RFP schedule of
events that specifies all deadline requirements. Vendors must be given a
reasonable time, as determined by the ALC, to consider the required scope of
products and services and the proposal evaluation factors before proposals must
be submitted;
4. RFP requirements
and proposal restrictions;
5. A
description of the factors that will be used to evaluate the proposals. Factors
may include but are not limited to vendor qualifications, experience, technical
approach, minority-owned business or female-owned business participation, and
cost; and
6. A declaration of
certain contract terms and conditions which shall be required by the
ALC.
D. RFP Review and
Approval. Each RFP must be reviewed and approved by the Director prior to
publication against the criteria of sound business principles, adequacy of the
scope of products and services description, and adequacy of the RFP's assurance
of:
1. Fairness to potential
vendors;
2. Achievement of
procurement objectives; and
3.
Protection of the ALC's interests.
E. RFP Publication. The ALC shall publish
each RFP solicitation on the ALC's web page, and, if desired by the ALC, the
Arkansas Office of State Procurement web site established for such
solicitations. Notice of the solicitation may also be published in any
newspaper or other relevant trade publication. The ALC shall further solicit
interest in each RFP by sending a formal notice of such or notice that the
specific RFP has been released to a documented list of potential vendors and if
the list of potential vendors are comprised mainly of Arkansas businesses, such
notice must be published in a newspaper with statewide circulation. The ALC
shall compile the list of potential vendors from those known to the ALC's
staff. The ALC shall determine the number of vendors to include on the list by
considering the nature of the procurement, the anticipated amount of the
resulting contract, and the number of known vendors. To the extent practicable,
the ALC will strive to compile lists of potential offerors which are
minority-owned businesses, and female-owned businesses; the ALC will actively
solicit bids from such businesses or otherwise make such businesses aware of
opportunities to bid for major procurement contracts. The ALC is not required
to send a solicitation notice to more than a total of three (3) vendors;
provided however, that the ALC may send a solicitation notice to fewer than
three (3) vendors, if, In the opinion of the Director, fewer than three (3)
vendors are qualified. A general or standing request for notice of all
solicitations of a given type shall not suffice as a request for a specific
solicitation and shall create no obligation on the ALC.
F. The ALC shall require each proposer to
submit the cost proposal component of the proposal in a sealed and labeled
envelope separate from the technical proposal component. The purpose is to
allow the cost component to be evaluated separately from the technical
component.
1. The cost proposals shall not be
opened until after the evaluation of the technical component is completed.
After the technical proposal evaluation is completed, the cost proposals shall
be opened and evaluated, and the total evaluation of the proposals will then be
based on the criteria established in the applicable RFP.
2. Any proposal which fails to adequately
separate the cost proposal components from the technical proposal may be
considered non-responsive and rejected by the ALC.
G. The ALC shall communicate, clarify, and
negotiate In the best Interests of the ALC, provided that all communication Is
conducted In a manner so as not to disclose any information that would give one
or more vendors unfair advantage or unfairly enable one or more vendors to
Improve their proposal. Specifically, negotiations will only be permitted with
the vendor whose bid, offer, quote, or proposal Is the highest rated bid,
offer, quote, or proposal. In the event that negotiations with the highest
rated vendor fall to result In a contract, or If for any other reason a
contract with such vendor Is not executed, the ALC may conduct negotiations
with the second highest vendor and so forth until a contract Is successfully
executed.
H. The ALC shall have the
right, at its sole discretion, to amend an RFP in writing at any
time.
I. The ALC shall have the
right, at its sole discretion, to reject any and all proposals.
1. Any proposal that does not meet the
requirements of an RFP may be considered to be non-responsive, and the proposal
may be rejected.
2. Any proposal
that restricts the rights of the ALC or otherwise qualifies the proposal may be
considered to be non-responsive, and the proposal may be rejected.
J. The ALC has the right, at its
sole discretion, to cancel an RFP In Its entirety and to reissue or not reissue
an RFP.
K. Evaluation and Award.
Proposals shall be evaluated In accordance with the solicitation and in such a
manner as to reasonably assure that all proposals are impartially considered
and ALC requirements are adequately met.
1.
Proposals shall be evaluated by a committee established by the
Director.
2. Prior to reviewing
proposals, each proposal evaluation committee member shall review a list of
vendors making proposals, determine If a conflict of Interest exists with a
potential vendor, and sign a statement of whether or not the member has a
potential conflict of Interest. The statement shall be retained as procurement
file documentation.
3. Proposals
shall be evaluated in accordance with the evaluation criteria set forth In the
solicitation.
4. Neither the
technical proposal, nor the cost, or any other single criterion shall be the
only criterion for a major procurement contract award recommendation. Rather,
evaluations shall be conducted and criteria shall be established to select
proposals that provide the greatest overall value, the greatest long-term
benefit to the State of Arkansas, the greatest integrity for the ALC, and the
best services and products for the public. However, specific factors may be set
forth in the applicable solicitation as criteria for determining whether a
vendor who submits a bid, offer, quote, or proposal in response to that
solicitation is a responsible bidder/proposer and which proposals shall be
considered responsive to the RFP.
5. Pricing discounts for payment within
certain time periods or in cash shall not be considered in evaluating
bids.
6. Only signed, sealed bids
delivered prior to the date and time of bid opening shall be
accepted.
7. The past performance
of a bidder/proposer/offeror on a state contract may be used by the ALC to
determine whether the bidder/proposer/offeror is "responsible". Past
performance must be supported by written documentation not greater than three
(3) years old. Reports, memos, and files may be in electronic form. Past
performance may be positive or negative. Past performance on contracts from
other Arkansas state agencies may also be used for evaluation. Supporting
documentation should be provided. Past performance evaluation should not take
the place of suspension or debarment procedures.
8. In the event of a tie bid, the person
responsible for awarding a major procurement contract must ensure that all
offers meet specifications. An award will be made by flip of a coin. The coin
flip will be done in the presence of a witness by the person responsible for
awarding the contract. The witness must be an employee of the State of
Arkansas. A documentation of the coin flip must be included on the tabulation
or bid history sheet and be signed by both parties and the witness.
4.4
Requests for
Qualifications.A. The provisions of
this subsection will be applicable solely to solicitations of major procurement
contracts by means of an RFQ.
B.
The request for qualifications procurement method is used when the
qualifications or specialized expertise of the vendor is the most important
factor in selection.
C. RFQ
Publication. The ALC shall publish each RFQ solicitation on the ALC's web page
and, if desired by the ALC, the Arkansas Office of State Procurement web site
established for such solicitations. Notice of the solicitation may also be
published In any newspaper or other relevant trade publication. The ALC shall
further solicit interest in each RFQ by sending a formal notice of such or
notice that the specific RFQ has been released to a documented list of
qualified vendors and if the list of potential vendors are comprised mainly of
Arkansas businesses, such notice must be published in a newspaper with
statewide circulation. The ALC shall compile the list of vendors from those
known to the ALC's staff. The ALC shall determine the number of vendors to
include on the list by considering the nature of the procurement, the
anticipated amount of the resulting contract, and the number of known vendors.
To the extent practicable, the ALC will strive to compile lists of potential
offerors which are minority-owned businesses, and female-owned businesses, and
the ALC will actively solicit bids from such businesses or otherwise make such
businesses aware of opportunities to bid for major procurement contracts. The
ALC is not required to send a solicitation notice to more than a total of three
(3) vendors; provided however, that the ALC may send a solicitation notice to
fewer than three (3) vendors. A general or standing request for notice of all
solicitations of a given type shall not suffice as a request for a specific
solicitation and shall create no obligation on the ALC.
D. The ALC shall communicate, clarify, and
negotiate in the best interests of the ALC, provided that all communication is
conducted in a manner so as not to disclose any information that would give one
or more vendors unfair advantage or unfairly enable one or more vendors to
improve their proposal.
E. The ALC
shall have the right, at its sole discretion, to amend an RFQ in writing at any
time.
F. The ALC shall have the
right, at its sole discretion, to cancel an RFQ in its entirety and to reissue
or not reissue an RFQ.
G.
Evaluation and Award. The ALC will make its initial selection based upon the
respondents' qualifications. Only after the most qualified respondent is
identified does cost become a factor in determining the award. Discussion may
be conducted with qualified vendors who, based upon qualifications submitted,
are determined to reasonably be susceptible of being selected for the purpose
of clarification to assure full understanding of, and responsiveness to the
solicitation requirements, and to obtain best and final offers.
1. Proposals shall be evaluated by a
committee established by the Director.
2. Prior to reviewing proposals, each
proposal evaluation committee member shall review a list of vendors making
proposals, determine if a conflict of interest exists with a potential vendor,
and sign a statement of whether or not the member has a potential conflict of
Interest. Said statement shall be retained as procurement file
documentation.
3. Proposals shall
be evaluated in accordance with the evaluation criteria set forth in the
solicitation.
4. Evaluations shall
be conducted and criteria shall be established to select proposals that provide
the greatest overall value, the greatest long-term benefit to the State of
Arkansas, the greatest Integrity for the ALC, and the best services and
products for the public.
5. Time
discounts or cash discounts shall not be considered.
6. Only signed, sealed responses delivered
prior to the date and time of bid opening shall be accepted.
7. The past performance of a
bidder/proposer/offeror on a state contract may be used by the ALC to determine
whether the bidder/proposer/offeror is "responsible". Past performance must be
supported by written documentation not greater than three (3) years old.
Reports, memos, and files may be in electronic form. Past performance may be
positive or negative. Past performance on contracts from other Arkansas state
agencies may also be used for evaluation. Supporting documentation should be
provided. Past performance evaluation should not take the place of suspension
or debarment procedures.
H. Compliance with this subsection. Failure
by the ALC to comply with any technical requirement of this Section
4.3 shall not alone be deemed a
defect requiring rejection of all bids, offers, quotes, or proposals, such
decision remaining in the discretion of the ALC.
4.5
Alternative Methods.
A. The ALC reserves the right to use an
alternative procurement method if that method will be more likely to:
(a) maximize the ALC's net revenue;
(b) achieve the specific business
objective or business objectives of the procurement; or
(c) aid the Director in fulfilling the
statutory mandate to operate and administer the ALC.
B. Alternative procurement methods may
include, but are not limited to, specialized vendor pre-qualifications,
multistep bids or proposals, single proposer negotiations, competitive
negotiations between two or more proposers, brand name solicitations, and
cooperative procurements. The ALC shall conduct the alternative procurement
method in accordance with the process set forth in the applicable solicitation
document.
4.6
Emergency Procurements. The Director may make emergency procurements in
accordance with Arkansas Code. Ann §19-11 -233.
Section 5.
Disputes.
5.1
Applicability. This section
shall only be applicable to major procurement contracts. Arkansas Code Ann.
§
19-11-244
shall govern all grievances with either the solicitation or the award of small
and intermediate procurements.
5.2
Filing of a Protest. '
A. Any actual or prospective bidder,
proposer, offeror, or contractor who is aggrieved in connection with the
solicitation or award of a major procurement contract may file a protest
seeking a determination with respect to any matter related to the solicitation
or award of a major procurement contract except as otherwise provided herein.
An aggrieved person who files a protest is hereinafter referred to as a
"Petitioner". Other than as expressly set forth in these rules, nothing
contained herein shall confer any rights or remedies upon any aggrieved person
or petitioner, or impose any duties or obligations upon the ALC, which are not
otherwise so conferred or imposed by the Act.
B. The protest shall be in writing, shall be
filed by delivery by hand or courier to the Director with a copy to the
Procurement Director of the ALC at the headquarters of the ALC.
C. The protest shall include the following
information:
1. The name, address, and
telephone number of the petitioner;
2. The signature of the petitioner;
3. Identification of the solicitation or
contract number that is the subject of the dispute;
4. A statement of the legal and factual
grounds supporting the position of the petitioner, including copies of relevant
documents;
5. Any other
documentation the petitioner wishes to submit in support of petitioner's
position; and
6. A statement of the
relief requested whether legal, equitable, or otherwise. If a monetary award is
requested, the amount shall be stated.
D. For a protest to be timely filed, the
original protest manually signed by the petitioner must be physically received
by the ALC within the time period prescribed in Section
5.3. Facsimile or other
electronically transmitted copies of the protest will not be
accepted.
E. The petitioner shall
be required to provide a suitable bond to the ALC in certified funds at the
time the protest is filed. The purpose of this bond is to:
1. Discourage frivolous petitions and
litigation; and
2. Assure payment
by the petitioner of the costs incurred as a result of the protest, including
reasonable attorney's fees of the ALC, employees or members of the commission,
in the event petitioner appeals and such costs are adjudged against the
petitioner pursuant to Ark. Code Ann. §
23-115-209;
and
3. Assure payment of all other
amounts for which the petitioner may be found liable, including without
limitation any loss of income to the ALC resulting from the institution of a
frivolous appeal.
F.
Failure to provide such bond with any protest will result in the dismissal of
such protest. A petitioner shall not have met the requirement in Section
5.3 to timely file a protest
unless the applicable bond accompanies the protest when it is timely filed.
This requirement does not apply to any petitioner who has already provided a
bond in the proper bond amount as part of a solicitation process.
G. The amount of the bond shall be the amount
established in the applicable solicitation. In the event that no amount is
specified in the applicable solicitation, the bond shall be seventy-five
thousand dollars ($75,000) or fifty percent (50%) of the value of the major
procurement contract amount in controversy, whichever is less.
5.3
Time for Filing a
Protest.A. Protests concerning a
solicitation.
1. A protest in regard to a
major procurement contract solicitation for which the basis for the protest is
reasonably apparent before the closing date for receipt of initial proposals
shall be filed within five (5) business days after the deadline for vendor
questions established in the solicitation. A protest in regard to any other
solicitation for which the basis for the protest is reasonably apparent before
the closing date for receipt of initial proposals shall be filed before the
closing date for receipt of initial proposals. A protest based upon a
solicitation that is reasonably apparent before the bid opening shall be filed
before bid opening.
2. Protests
based upon an amendment to any solicitation, or upon any additional information
requested or accepted by the ALC with respect to any solicitation or response
thereto, that is reasonably apparent before the closing date for receipt of
proposals or any supplemental information requested by the ALC shall be filed
within five (5) business days after the deadline for vendor questions or the
date of the amendment, whichever date is later.
3. If a protest is timely filed with the
Director and the Procurement Director of the ALC before the award of a
contract, the award of such contract may be made before a decision is rendered
on the protest.
B.
Protest concerning an award of contract.
1.
Any aggrieved person may protest the ALC's decision to award a major
procurement contract. Only persons or entities that submit a bid, offer, quote,
or proposal with respect to a major procurement solicitation for a
competitively bid major procurement contract may be considered an "Aggrieved
Person" with standing to file a protest with respect to the award of such
contract or the issuance of a notice of intent to award such
contract.
2. Any written protest
shall be filed:
a. In the case of a major
procurement contract that has not been competitively bid by the ALC, within
five (5) business days after either the ALC's issuance of a notice of intent to
award such major procurement contract or the ALC's award of such major
procurement contract is posted, published, or otherwise made publicly
available, whichever occurs first; and
b. In the case of a major procurement
contract that has been competitively bid by the ALC, within five (5) business
days after the ALC's issuance of a notice of intent to award such major
procurement contract is posted, published, or otherwise made publicly
available.
3. If a
protest seeking equitable relief regarding the award of any major procurement
contract is timely filed with the Director and the Procurement Director of the
ALC, the ALC may award and enter into such major procurement contract only if
(a) such protest has been resolved in accordance with these rules, or (b) the
ALC has made a written determination that the award of such major procurement
contract without delay is necessary to protect substantial interests of the
ALC.
C. In all other
cases pertaining to a solicitation or award of an agreement or a contract other
than those covered in subsections (A) and (B), a protest must be filed within
five (5) business days after the announcement of the ALC's decision to award is
posted, published, or otherwise made publicly available, whichever occurs
first.
D. In any other case not
covered by subsections (A) through (C), the protest must be filed within five
(5) business days after the aggrieved person knows or should have known of the
facts giving rise to the action complained of.
E. Failure to timely file a written protest
shall bar any further administrative, legal, or equitable action.
F. Failure to timely provide the applicable
bond in the amount required shall result in an untimely filing and bar any
further administrative, legal, or equitable action.
5.4
Notice to Others. In the
event a protest is filed, the Director shall immediately provide a copy of the
protest to the ALC and to the successful person or entity, if an award has been
made, or, if no award has been made, to all persons or entities who have
submitted bids or proposals.
5.5
Confidential information.A. If
the petitioner believes the protest contains material that should be withheld,
a statement advising the Procurement Director of the ALC of this fact shall
accompany the protest submission.
B. Material submitted by a petitioner shall
not be withheld from any interested party except to the extent required by
law.
5.6
Decision
by the Director.A. The Director, or a
hearing officer designated by him or her, shall have the exclusive authority to
decide all protests.
B. After
submittal of a timely protest and prior to issuance of a written decision to
that protest, the petitioner shall be afforded an opportunity to discuss with
the Director the issues giving rise to the protest.
C. Before agreeing to settle any protest by
the award of costs, the Director shall consult the Attorney General and the ALC
Staff Attorney. The award of costs shall be allowed only to compensate a
petitioner for reasonable expenses incurred in preparation and submission of a
bid or proposal for which the petitioner was wrongfully denied a contract
award. The costs which are allowable shall be those which the petitioner is
able to prove that are incurred in preparation and submission of the bid or
proposal in question, but exclude travel and production costs that may result
from participation in pre-bid conferences; attending on-site Inspections, and
demonstrations or presentations made in responding to formal solicitations
issued by the State. A petitioner may not recover profit which it anticipates
would have been made if the petitioner had been awarded the major procurement
contract. Attorney's fees associated with the filing and prosecution of the
protest are not recoverable.
D. If
the protest is not resolved by mutual agreement, the Director or hearing
officer shall issue a written decision within thirty (30) calendar days after a
protest has been filed. The decision shall include:
1. A brief description of the
claim;
2. A reference to the
pertinent contract provision;
3. A
brief statement of the factual and legal issues;
4. A statement of the Director's or hearing
officer's decision, with supporting rationale and the remedial action or award,
if any.
E. The Director
or hearing officer shall furnish a copy of the decision to the petitioner by
certified mail, return receipt requested, or by any other method that provides
written evidence of delivery, such as hand delivery by courier, express mail or
overnight express courier.
F. The
time limit for decisions set forth in subsection (D) may be extended by the
Director or Hearing Officer for good cause for a reasonable time not to exceed
thirty (30) additional calendar days. The Director or hearing officer shall
notify the petitioner in writing that the time for the issuance of a decision
has been extended and the date by which a decision will be issued.
G. If the Director or hearing officer fails
to issue a decision within the time limits set forth in subsections (D) or (F),
the petitioner may proceed as if the Director or hearing officer had issued an
adverse decision.
H. In lieu of a
written decision, the Director may, in his or her sole discretion, within
thirty (30) calendar days after a protest is filed, give written notice to the
petitioner that the protest shall be resolved by a hearing conducted by the
Director or hearing officer pursuant to the procedures for hearing set forth in
Section 5.7. Notwithstanding the
foregoing, the Commission may at any time on its own motion direct that a
protest be resolved by a hearing conducted by the Director or hearing officer
pursuant to the procedures for hearing set forth in Section
5.7.
I. Nothing Section
5 shall prohibit a contractor who
is also an aggrieved person or petitioner from submitting an invoice to the ALC
for final payment after the work is completed and accepted.
J. Pending claims shall not delay payment for
undisputed amounts from the ALC to a contractor who is also an aggrieved person
or petitioner.
5.7
Hearing Procedures.
A. All
hearings conducted under these rules shall be conducted by the Director or by a
hearing officer designated by the Director. The decision as to whether the
Director or a hearing officer will conduct the hearing shall be in the sole
discretion of the Director. The hearing officer's actions, decisions, and
orders shall be deemed to be on behalf of the Director and effective as though
taken by the Director, subject to the appeals procedures as hereinafter
provided.
B. If the Director
determines under Section
5.6(H) that a
hearing will be used to resolve a protest, the hearing shall be held within
thirty (30) calendar days following the Director's determination. A notice
which will set forth the time, date, and location of the hearing will be sent
to the party or parties at least seven (7) calendar days before the date set
for such hearing.
C. In connection
with the hearing, the Director or hearing officer may:
1. Conduct the hearing in an informal manner
without formal rules of evidence or procedure;
2. Require each party to state, either orally
or in writing, its position concerning the factual and legal issues involved In
the hearing;
3. Require each party
to produce for examination those relevant witnesses and documents under its
control;
4. Rule on motions and
other procedural items pending before him or her, including without limitation
the methods, scope and extent of discovery available to the parties;
5. Regulate the course of the hearing and
conduct of the participants, including the imposition of reasonable time
limits;
6. Establish time limits
for submission of motions or memoranda;
7. Take official notice of any material fact
not appearing in evidence in the record, if the fact is among the traditional
matters of which judicial notice can be taken;
8. Administer oaths or
affirmations;
9. Issue subpoenas;
and
10. Join any necessary parties
to the hearing.
D. The
hearing shall be conducted before a court reporter. The petitioner shall
procure, at petitioner's own cost and on petitioner's own initiative, the court
reporting services (including the preparation of the transcript) for such
hearing. The original transcript of any such proceedings shall be submitted to
the Director or hearing officer as soon as the transcript is available, and in
no event later than five (5) calendar days following the conclusion of the
hearing, and shall be made a part of the record. The petitioner shall also
submit a copy of the transcript to all other parties to the protest as soon as
the transcript is available.
E. Any
party may appear and be represented with or without counsel at the
hearing.
F. If a hearing officer
conducts the hearing, he or she shall make a written recommendation containing
the hearing officer's ruling, in the form of a proposed decision, to the
Director, within thirty (30) calendar days after receiving an original
transcript of the hearing. If a proposed decision is received by the Director,
he or she must render a decision in writing and deliver the decision to the
parties within thirty (30) calendar days after receiving the proposed decision
from the hearing officer.
1. If the Director
receives a recommendation in a proposed decision from a hearing officer, he or
she may:
a. Accept, modify, or reject the
hearing officer's recommendation in whole or in part;
b. Return the matter to the hearing officer
with instruction;
c. Make any other
appropriate disposition; or
d.
Issue a no action response.
2. If the Director issues a no action
response, then the determination in the Proposed Decision of the hearing
officer will be deemed to be accepted by the Director.
G. If the Director conducts the hearing, he
or she must render a decision in writing and deliver the decision to the
petitioner within thirty (30) calendar days after receiving an original
transcript of the hearing.
H. The
Director's decision and any proposed decision made by a hearing officer shall
be sent to the petitioner by certified mail, return receipt requested, or any
other method by which a written business record of delivery is kept, such as
hand delivery by courier, express mail or overnight express courier.
5.8
Procedure for Filing an
Appeal to the Commission.A. A
petitioner may appeal a decision of the Director or hearing officer to the
Commission. Any appeal from a decision of the Director or hearing officer must
be filed with the Chair of the Commission at the ALC headquarters within five
(5) business days after the receipt of such decision to be considered
timely.
B. Notice of any appeal
shall also be filed with Director and the Staff Attorney of the ALC by delivery
by hand or courier to the headquarters of the ALC.
C. An appeal must be in writing and shall
contain the following:
1. Copy of the decision
of the Director or hearing officer; and
2. the basis for the precise factual or legal
error in the decision of the Director or hearing officer from which the appeal
is taken.
D. The
Commission shall notify interested parties of the appeal by certified mail,
return receipt requested, or any other method by which a written business
record of delivery Is kept, such as hand delivery by courier, express mail, or
overnight express courier within five (5) calendar days after the appeal is
filed.
E. Any interested party may
file a written brief stating its position on the appeal within five (5)
business days after receipt of such notice.
5.9
Commission's Decision.
A. The Commission may review the record
without a hearing or oral argument and issue a written decision on behalf of
the ALC. The Commissioners, pursuant to the power granted to them in Arkansas
Code Ann. §
23-115-205,
may authorize its legal committee to hear and dispose of administrative appeals
from the Director as the Committee deems appropriate, including, but not
limited to, designating one of its members to consider an act on an appeal on
behalf of the Commission. Therefore, references herein to "Commissioners" or
"Commission" shall be read to take this delegation of authority into
account.
B. The Commission may in
its sole discretion:
(1) conduct its own
review or Investigation;
(2)
conduct a de novo review in whole or in part; or
(3) allow oral argument, in the manner and
under procedures that the Commission deems appropriate under the
circumstances.
C. A copy
of the Commission's written decision will be sent to the appellant by certified
mail, return receipt requested, or any other method by which a written business
record of delivery is kept, such as hand delivery by courier, express mail or
overnight express courier. The original written decision shall be retained by
the ALC. The written decision of the Commission will be final, and no further
appeal to the ALC will be allowed.
5.10.
Judicial Review. Any
adverse final decision of the Commission issued under this section shall be
subject to judicial review pursuant to Ark. Code Ann. §
23-115-209
by any person or entity who was a party to the appeal, and the complaint
seeking review must be filed with the Pulaski County Circuit Court.
5.11
Exclusive Remedy. These
rules provide the exclusive procedure for asserting a claim against the ALC
arising out of or relating to any matter related to the procurement process for
any major procurement contract. Neither an aggrieved person, nor petitioner,
nor any other interested party has a right to any remedy against the ALC with
respect to any matter related to the procurement process for any major
procurement contract except in accordance with the procedures set forth in
these rules.