Credit for Carbon Oxide Sequestration, 34050-34075 [2020-11907]
Download as PDF
34050
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
and/or requests for a public hearing,
Regina L. Johnson at (202) 317–5177
(not toll-free numbers).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY
Internal Revenue Service
26 CFR Part 1
Background
[REG–112339–19]
RIN 1545–BP42
Credit for Carbon Oxide Sequestration
Internal Revenue Service (IRS),
Treasury.
ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking.
AGENCY:
This document contains
proposed regulations regarding the
credit for carbon oxide sequestration
under section 45Q of the Internal
Revenue Code (Code). These proposed
regulations will affect persons who
physically or contractually ensure the
capture and disposal of qualified carbon
oxide, use of qualified carbon oxide as
a tertiary injectant in a qualified
enhanced oil or natural gas recovery
project, or utilization of qualified carbon
oxide in a manner that qualifies for the
credit.
DATES: Written or electronic comments
and requests for a public hearing must
be received by August 3, 2020. Requests
for a public hearing must be submitted
as prescribed in the ‘‘Comments and
Requests for a Public Hearing’’ section.
ADDRESSES: Commenters are strongly
encouraged to submit public comments
electronically. Submit electronic
submissions via the Federal
eRulemaking Portal at
www.regulations.gov (indicate IRS and
REG–112339–19) by following the
online instructions for submitting
comments. Once submitted to the
Federal eRulemaking Portal, comments
cannot be edited or withdrawn. The IRS
expects to have limited personnel
available to process public comments
that are submitted on paper through
mail. Until further notice, any
comments submitted on paper will be
considered to the extent practicable.
The Department of the Treasury
(Treasury Department) and the IRS will
publish for public availability any
comment submitted electronically, and
to the extent practicable on paper, to its
public docket.
Send paper submissions to:
CC:PA:LPD:PR (REG–112339–19), Room
5203, Internal Revenue Service, P.O.
Box 7604, Ben Franklin Station,
Washington, DC 20044.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Concerning the proposed regulations,
Maggie Stehn of the Office of Associate
Chief Counsel (Passthroughs & Special
Industries) at (202) 317–6853;
concerning submissions of comments
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
SUMMARY:
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
This document contains proposed
amendments to the Income Tax
Regulations (26 CFR part 1) under
section 45Q of the Code (proposed
regulations).
Section 45Q was enacted on October
3, 2008, by section 115 of Division B of
the Energy Improvement and Extension
Act of 2008, Public Law 110–343, 122
Stat. 3765, 3829, to provide a credit for
the sequestration of carbon oxide. On
February 17, 2009, section 45Q was
amended by section 1131 of Division B
of the American Recovery and
Reinvestment Tax Act of 2009, Public
Law 111–5, 123 Stat. 115, 325. Section
45Q was further amended on December
19, 2014, by section 209(j)(1) of Division
A of the Tax Increase Prevention Act of
2014, Public Law 113–295, 128 Stat.
4010, 4030, and most recently on
February 9, 2018, by section 41119 of
Division D of the Bipartisan Budget Act
of 2018 (BBA), Public Law 115–123, 132
Stat. 64, 162, to encourage the
construction and use of carbon capture
and sequestration projects.
On May 20, 2019, the IRS published
Notice 2019–32, 2019–21 I.R.B. 1187.
The notice requested general comments
on issues arising under section 45Q, as
well as specific comments concerning
secure geological storage, the
measurement of qualified carbon oxide,
the recapture of the benefit of the credit
for carbon oxide sequestration, the types
of utilization that qualify for the credit,
the beginning of construction,
partnership arrangements, definitions of
terms, and other issues related to the
credit. The IRS received 116 comments
from industry participants,
environmental groups, and other
stakeholders.
In response to comments submitted
pursuant to Notice 2019–32, on March
9, 2020, the Treasury Department and
the IRS published Revenue Procedure
2020–12, 2020–11 I.R.B. 511, and Notice
2020–12, 2020–11 I.R.B. 495. Revenue
Procedure 2020–12 provides a safe
harbor under which the IRS will treat
partnerships as properly allocating the
section 45Q credit in accordance with
section 704(b). Notice 2020–12 provides
guidance on the determination of when
construction has begun on a qualified
facility or on carbon capture equipment
that may be eligible for the section 45Q
credit. As requested by commenters, the
safe harbor in Revenue Procedure 2020–
12 and the rules in Notice 2020–12 are
PO 00000
Frm 00002
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
similar to those provided in prior
guidance.
Pursuant to section 45Q(h), the
Secretary of the Treasury or his delegate
(Secretary) may prescribe such
regulations and other guidance as may
be necessary or appropriate to carry out
section 45Q, including regulations or
other guidance to (i) ensure proper
allocation under section 45Q(a) for
qualified carbon oxide captured by a
taxpayer during the taxable year ending
after the date of the enactment of the
BBA, and (ii) determine whether a
facility satisfies the requirements under
section 45Q(d)(1).
Summary of Comments and
Explanation of Provisions
1. General Credit Provisions
a. Credit Amount in General
Section 45Q(a)(1) allows a credit of
$20 per metric ton of qualified carbon
oxide (i) captured by the taxpayer using
carbon capture equipment which is
originally placed in service at a
qualified facility before the date of the
enactment of the BBA (February 9,
2018); (ii) disposed of by the taxpayer in
secure geological storage; and (iii)
neither used by the taxpayer as a tertiary
injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or
natural gas recovery project nor utilized
in a manner described in section
45Q(f)(5).
Section 45Q(a)(2) allows a credit of
$10 per metric ton of qualified carbon
oxide (i) captured by the taxpayer using
carbon capture equipment which is
originally placed in service at a
qualified facility before February 9,
2018; and (ii) either (A) used by the
taxpayer as a tertiary injectant in a
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas
recovery project and disposed of by the
taxpayer in secure geological storage; or
(B) utilized by the taxpayer in a manner
described in section 45Q(f)(5).
Section 45Q(a)(3) allows a credit of
the applicable dollar amount (as
determined under section 45Q(b)(1)) per
metric ton of qualified carbon oxide (i)
captured by the taxpayer using carbon
capture equipment which is originally
placed in service at a qualified facility
on or after February 9, 2018, during the
12-year period beginning on the date the
equipment was originally placed in
service; (ii) disposed of by the taxpayer
in secure geological storage; and (iii)
neither used by the taxpayer as a tertiary
injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or
natural gas recovery project nor utilized
in a manner described in section
45Q(f)(5).
Section 45Q(a)(4) allows a credit of
the applicable dollar amount (as
determined under section 45Q(b)(1)) per
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
metric ton of qualified carbon oxide (i)
captured by the taxpayer using carbon
capture equipment which is originally
placed in service at a qualified facility
on or after February 9, 2018, during the
12-year period beginning on the date the
equipment was originally placed in
service; and (ii) either (A) used by the
taxpayer as a tertiary injectant in a
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas
recovery project and disposed of by the
taxpayer in secure geological storage, or
(B) utilized by the taxpayer in a manner
described in section 45Q(f)(5).
Section 45Q(b)(1)(A)(i)(I) and (ii)(I)
provides that the applicable dollar
amount for activities under section
45Q(a)(3) for any taxable year beginning
in a calendar year (1) after 2016 and
before 2027 is an amount equal to the
dollar amount established by linear
interpolation between $22.66 and $50
for each calendar year during such
period, and (2) after 2026 is an amount
equal to the product of $50 and the
inflation adjustment factor for such
calendar year determined under section
43(b)(3)(B) for such calendar year,
determined by substituting ‘‘2025’’ for
‘‘1990.’’
Section 45Q(b)(1)(A)(i)(II) and (ii)(II)
provides that the applicable dollar
amount for activities under section
45Q(d)(4) for any taxable year beginning
in a calendar year (1) after 2016 and
before 2027 is an amount equal to the
dollar amount established by linear
interpolation between $12.83 and $35
for each calendar year during such
period, and (2) after 2026 is an amount
equal to the product of $35 and the
inflation adjustment factor for such
calendar year determined under section
43(b)(3)(B) for such calendar year,
determined by substituting ‘‘2025’’ for
‘‘1990.’’ Section 45Q(b)(1)(B) provides
that the applicable dollar amount
determined under section 45Q(b)(1)(A)
is rounded to the nearest cent.
Section 45Q(b)(2) provides a method
to compute the amount of qualified
carbon oxide captured at a qualified
facility that was placed in service before
February 9, 2018, and for which
additional carbon capture equipment is
placed in service on or after February 9,
2018. For purposes of section
45Q(a)(1)(A) and (2)(A), the amount of
qualified carbon oxide that is captured
by the taxpayer is equal to the lesser of
(i) the total amount of qualified carbon
oxide captured at such facility for the
taxable year, or (ii) the total amount of
the carbon dioxide capture capacity of
the carbon capture equipment in service
at such facility on February 8, 2018 (the
day before the date of enactment of the
BBA). For purposes of section
45Q(a)(3)(A) and (4)(A), the amount of
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
qualified carbon oxide captured by the
taxpayer is an amount (not less than
zero) equal to the excess of (i) the total
amount of qualified carbon oxide
captured at such facility for the taxable
year, over (ii) the total amount of the
carbon dioxide capture capacity of the
carbon capture equipment in service at
such facility on February 8, 2018. These
proposed regulations explain the
difference between a physical
modification or equipment addition that
results in an increase in the carbon
dioxide capture capacity of existing
carbon capture equipment, which will
be treated as newly placed in service,
and a mere increase in the amount of
carbon dioxide captured by existing
carbon capture equipment, which will
not be treated as newly placed in
service.
Pursuant to section 45Q(b)(3), a
taxpayer may elect to have the dollar
amounts applicable under section
45Q(a)(1) or (2) apply in lieu of the
dollar amounts applicable under section
45Q(a)(3) or (4) for each metric ton of
qualified carbon oxide which is
captured by the taxpayer using carbon
capture equipment which is originally
placed in service at a qualified facility
on or after February 9, 2018. These
proposed regulations provide that the
election will apply to all metric tons of
qualified carbon oxide captured by the
taxpayer at the qualified facility for the
full 12-year credit period.
Section 45Q(f)(6)(A) provides that for
any taxable year in which an applicable
facility captures not less than 500,000
metric tons of qualified carbon oxide,
the person described in section
45Q(f)(3)(A)(ii) may elect to have such
applicable facility, and any carbon
capture equipment placed in service at
such applicable facility, deemed as
having been placed in service on
February 9, 2018. The term ‘‘applicable
facility’’ means a qualified facility (i)
which was placed in service before
February 9, 2018, and (ii) for which no
taxpayer claimed a section 45Q credit
for any taxable year ending before
February 9, 2018.
Section 45Q(f)(7) provides that in the
case of any taxable year beginning in a
calendar year after 2009, there is
substituted for each dollar amount
contained in section 45Q(a)(1) and (2)
an amount equal to the product of (i)
such dollar amount, multiplied by (ii)
the inflation adjustment factor for such
calendar year determined under section
43(b)(3)(B) for such calendar year,
determined by substituting ‘‘2008’’ for
‘‘1990.’’
Section 45Q(g) provides that in the
case of any carbon capture equipment
placed in service before February 9,
PO 00000
Frm 00003
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
34051
2018, the section 45Q credit applies
with respect to qualified carbon oxide
captured using such equipment before
the end of the calendar year in which
the Secretary, in consultation with the
Administrator of the Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA), certifies that a
total of 75,000,000 metric tons of
qualified carbon oxide have been taken
into account in accordance with former
section 45Q(a) (as in effect before
February 9, 2018) and sections 45Q(a)(1)
and (2).
These proposed regulations reflect the
statutory provisions relating to credit
amounts.
b. Contractually Ensuring Capture and
Disposal, Injection, or Utilization of
Qualified Carbon Oxide
Section 45Q(f)(3)(A)(i) provides that
in the case of qualified carbon oxide
captured using carbon capture
equipment which is originally placed in
service at a qualified facility before
February 9, 2018, the section 45Q credit
is attributable to the person that
captures and physically or contractually
ensures the disposal through secure
geological storage (referred to as
disposal), use for tertiary injection and
disposal through secure geological
storage (referred to as injection) or
utilization in a manner consistent with
section 45Q(f)(5) (referred to as
utilization).
Section 45Q(f)(3)(A)(ii) provides that
in the case of qualified carbon oxide
captured using carbon capture
equipment which is originally placed in
service at a qualified facility on or after
February 9, 2018, the section 45Q credit
is attributable to the person that owns
the carbon capture equipment and
physically or contractually ensures the
capture and disposal, injection, or
utilization of such qualified carbon
oxide.
Commenters requested that the
Treasury Department and the IRS clarify
which contract provisions are necessary
to contractually ensure the capture and
disposal, injection, or utilization of
qualified carbon oxide. Several
commenters requested broad guidance
on commercially reasonable terms
rather than specifying exact language.
One commenter requested guidance
regarding the assurance of capture,
remedies, guarantees, and the
prevention of leakage.
In response, the proposed regulations
provide a framework for the types of
contracts, terms, and reporting
requirements that will demonstrate the
contractual assurance of the capture and
disposal, injection, or utilization of
qualified carbon oxide. The proposed
regulations provide that a taxpayer may
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
34052
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
enter into multiple contracts with
multiple parties for the disposal,
injection, or utilization of qualified
carbon oxide. For example, a taxpayer
that captures qualified carbon oxide
may contract with one party to dispose
of a portion of its captured qualified
carbon oxide in a deep saline formation,
with another party to use another
portion of its captured qualified carbon
oxide as a tertiary injectant in multiple
enhanced oil recovery (EOR) sites, and
with several parties to utilize the
remaining portion of its captured
qualified carbon oxide. The existence of
each contract and the parties involved
must be reported to the IRS on an
annual basis on Form 8933, Carbon
Oxide Sequestration Credit (or successor
forms, or pursuant to instructions and
other guidance). For contracts for the
disposal of carbon oxide or use as a
tertiary injectant in enhanced oil or
natural gas recovery, the following
information must be included:
Identifying information (name of
operator, field, unit and reservoir), the
location (county and state) and the
identification number assigned to the
facility by the EPA’s electronic
Greenhouse Gas Reporting Tool (eGGRT ID number). The e-GGRT ID
number will allow the IRS to reconcile
information with data reported to the
EPA’s Greenhouse Gas Reporting
Program (GHGRP) and otherwise receive
technical assistance from the EPA.
The proposed regulations require
taxpayers to contractually ensure the
disposal, injection, or utilization of
qualified carbon oxide in a binding
written contract that includes
commercially reasonable terms that
provides for enforcement. The proposed
regulations provide that taxpayers may
include information regarding how
much carbon oxide the parties agree to
dispose of, inject, or utilize in their
contracts. Contracts may also include
various other specific provisions
relating to enforcement, such as longterm liability provisions, indemnity
provisions, or penalties for breach of
contract or liquidated damages. While
the proposed regulations require that
the contract include a mechanism for
enforcement, no specific enforcementrelated provision, or other particular
kind of enforcement provision, are
mandated by these proposed
regulations. This is consistent with
allowing contracting parties to tailor
their agreements to a wide variety of
business needs and circumstances.
Under the proposed regulations, a
taxpayer does not elect to allow all or
a portion of the section 45Q credit to
any of the contracting parties merely by
contracting with that party to ensure the
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
disposal, injection, or utilization of
qualified carbon oxide. Any election to
allow all or a portion of the credit to
another taxpayer must be made
separately in the manner provided in
these proposed regulations.
c. Election To Allow the Credit to
Another Taxpayer
Section 45Q(f)(3)(B) provides that a
person that is entitled to claim the
credit under section 45Q(f)(3)(A)(i) or
section 45Q(f)(3)(A)(ii) may elect to
allow the person that disposes of the
qualified carbon oxide, utilizes the
qualified carbon oxide, or uses the
qualified carbon oxide as a tertiary
injectant to claim the credit (section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election).
Commenters requested guidance
regarding the section 45Q(f)(3)(B)
election. Commenters generally sought
to maximize the ability of the taxpayer
to whom the section 45Q credit is
attributable (electing taxpayer) to make
the section 45Q credit allowable to one
or more other taxpayers (credit
claimants) pursuant to the section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election. Commenters also
generally requested that guidance
provide that section 45Q(f)(3)(B)
elections may be made on an annual
basis. One commenter requested that
guidance provide for a broader range of
permissible credit claimants, including
an owner, operator, service company,
supplier, partner, or tax equity or other
project finance participant.
One commenter suggested that the
section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election should be
made in the taxable year that the
qualified carbon oxide is disposed of,
utilized, or used as a tertiary injectant.
The commenter recommended that the
election procedures follow the
procedures for making a section
338(h)(10) election. Further,
commenters suggested that Forms 8933
should be filed by all parties to the
section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election with their
respective tax returns for the taxable
year in which the qualifying activity is
completed.
Other commenters suggested that a
taxpayer should make a section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election for a taxable year
by attaching a statement to a timely filed
income tax return (including
extensions) for the taxable year. Further,
commenters suggested that a taxpayer
should be permitted to make a section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election for a portion of the
section 45Q credit. The portion allowed
to a credit claimant would be specified
in the electing taxpayer’s annual
election as a percentage of the total
credit claimed.
One commenter noted that when a
taxpayer makes a section 45Q(f)(3)(B)
PO 00000
Frm 00004
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
election, the electing taxpayer should no
longer claim the section 45Q credit
subject to the election. To ensure
compliance with this rule, the
commenter suggested that the guidance
and the relevant tax forms (i.e., Form
8933) require coordination between the
electing taxpayer and the credit
claimant. For example, the credit
claimant could be required to include a
copy of the electing taxpayer’s section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election to allow the credit.
In response to these comments, the
proposed regulations provide guidance
regarding who may make a section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election and the time and
manner for making a section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election. The proposed
regulations also provide that section
45Q(f)(3)(B) elections must be made on
an annual basis no later than the time
prescribed by law (including
extensions) for filing the Federal income
tax return or Form 1065 and may not be
made on an amended Federal income
tax return. However, a section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election may be made on an
amended Federal income tax return, an
amended Form 1065 or an
administrative adjustment request under
section 6227 of the Code (AAR), for any
taxable year ending after February 9,
2018, but not for taxable years beginning
after June 2, 2020.
The proposed regulations also set
forth information to be provided as part
of a section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election,
requiring both an electing taxpayer and
a credit claimant to include a Form 8933
(or successor forms, or pursuant to
instructions and other guidance) with
its timely filed Federal income tax
return or Form 1065, U.S. Return of
Partnership Income (including
extensions) as applicable. An electing
taxpayer must provide each credit
claimant with a copy of the electing
taxpayer’s Form 8933, and each credit
claimant must attach that copy of the
electing taxpayer’s Form 8933 to its own
Form 8933.
The proposed regulations further
provide that section 45Q(f)(3)(B)
elections may be made for all or a
portion of the available section 45Q
credit and may be made for a single or
multiple credit claimants. If an electing
taxpayer elects to allow multiple credit
claimants to claim section 45Q credits,
the proposed regulations provide that
the maximum amount of section 45Q
credits allowable to each credit claimant
is proportional to the amount of
qualified carbon oxide disposed of,
utilized, or used as a tertiary injectant
by the credit claimant. In addition, as
provided in Revenue Procedure 2020–
23, 2020–18 I.R.B.1 (April 27, 2020), the
exception applies regarding the time to
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
file an amended return by a partnership
subject to the centralized partnership
audit regime enacted as part of the BBA
(BBA partnership) for the 2018 and 2019
taxable years. The amended Federal
income tax return or the amended Form
1065 must be filed, in no event, later
than the applicable period of limitations
on assessment for the taxable year for
which the amended Federal income tax
return or Form 1065 is being filed. In
the case of a BBA partnership that
chooses not to file an amended Form
1065 as permitted under Revenue
Procedure 2020–23, the BBA
partnership may make a late election by
filing an AAR on or before October 15,
2021, but in no event, later than the
applicable period of limitations on
making adjustments under section 6235
for the reviewed year, as defined in
§ 301.6241–1(a)(8) of the Procedure and
Administration Regulations (26 CFR
part 301).
d. Amended Returns
Taxpayers may claim section 45Q
credits on an amended Federal income
tax return, an amended Form 1065, or
an AAR, as applicable, for taxable years
beginning on or after February 9, 2018,
provided that the requirements
described in the proposed regulations
are satisfied. In addition, as provided in
Revenue Procedure 2020–23, the
exception applies regarding the time to
file an amended return by a BBA
partnership for the 2018 and 2019
taxable years. The amended Federal
income tax return or the amended Form
1065 must be filed, in no event, later
than the applicable period of limitations
on assessment for the taxable year for
which the amended Federal income tax
return or Form 1065 is being filed. In
the case of a BBA partnership that
chooses not to file an amended Form
1065 as permitted under Revenue
Procedure 2020–23, the BBA
partnership may make a late election by
filing an AAR on or before October 15,
2021, but in no event, later than the
applicable period of limitations on
making adjustments under section 6235
for the reviewed year, as defined in
§ 301.6241–1(a)(8) of the Procedure and
Administration Regulations (26 CFR
part 301). However, section 45Q(f)(3)(B)
elections may not be made on amended
returns for taxable years beginning after
the date of issuance of these proposed
regulations.
2. Definitions
a. Qualified Carbon Oxide
Section 45Q(c) provides that
‘‘qualified carbon oxide’’ means (A) any
carbon dioxide which (i) is captured
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
from an industrial source by carbon
capture equipment which is originally
placed in service before February 9,
2018; (ii) would otherwise be released
into the atmosphere as industrial
emission of greenhouse gas or lead to
such release; and (iii) is measured at the
source of capture and verified at the
point of disposal, injection, or
utilization; (B) any carbon dioxide or
other carbon oxide which (i) is captured
from an industrial source by carbon
capture equipment which is originally
placed in service on or after February 9,
2018; (ii) would otherwise be released
into the atmosphere as industrial
emission of greenhouse gas or lead to
such release; and (iii) is measured at the
source of capture and verified at the
point of disposal, injection, or
utilization; or (C) in the case of a direct
air capture facility, any carbon dioxide
which (i) is captured directly from
ambient air; and (ii) is measured at the
source of capture and verified at the
point of disposal, injection, or
utilization.
While ‘‘qualified carbon oxide’’
includes the initial deposit of captured
carbon oxide used as a tertiary injectant,
section 45Q(c)(2) provides that the term
does not include carbon oxide that is
recaptured, recycled, and re-injected as
part of the qualified enhanced oil or
natural gas recovery process.
Additionally, section 45Q(f)(1) provides
that the section 45Q credit apples only
with respect to qualified carbon oxide
the capture and disposal, injection, or
utilization of which is within the United
States (within the meaning of section
638(1)), or a possession of the United
States (within the meaning of section
638(2)).
Commenters suggested generally that
the statutory definition of qualified
carbon oxide is sufficient, and did not
seek additional clarification. The
Treasury Department and the IRS agree
that the statutory definition of qualified
carbon oxide is clear due to the broad
acceptance and use of the term by
industry participants, environmental
groups, and stakeholders. Therefore, the
proposed regulations generally conform
to the statutory definition of qualified
carbon oxide, including the provision
that only qualified carbon oxide
captured and disposed of, injected, or
utilized within the United States or a
possession of the United States is taken
into account. Therefore, the proposed
regulations generally conform to the
statutory definition of qualified carbon
oxide, including the provision that only
qualified carbon oxide captured and
disposed of, injected, or utilized within
the United States or a possession of the
United States is taken into account.
PO 00000
Frm 00005
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
34053
b. Carbon Capture Equipment
Section 45Q does not define carbon
capture equipment. One commenter
suggested that carbon capture
equipment be broadly defined as, ‘‘any
system that but for its presence and
application, the carbon oxides captured
at a qualifying industrial facility and on
which a section 45Q credit is earned
would have been vented into the
atmosphere.’’ Another commenter
suggested that the definition allow for
maximum flexibility to encompass a
complete configuration of equipment
including separate units, processing
units, processing plants, pipe, buildings,
pumps, compressors, meters, facilities,
motors, fixtures, materials, and
machinery, and all other improvements
used for the purpose of: (1) Separating
and/or capturing carbon dioxide that
would otherwise be released into the
atmosphere from a qualifying facility;
(2) compressing or otherwise increasing
the pressure of carbon dioxide; or (3)
transporting, disposing, injecting, and/
or utilizing qualified carbon oxide.
Finally, some commenters suggested
that the definition of carbon capture
equipment should be limited to the
equipment that functions to capture the
carbon oxides from any industrial
source. The commenters explained that
once the carbon oxides are captured,
equipment having a separate function
such as compression, liquefaction,
transportation, or pumping, should not
be included in the definition of carbon
capture equipment.
The Treasury Department and the IRS
agree that carbon capture equipment
generally should be defined in terms of
its functionality. The proposed
regulations provide that in general,
carbon capture equipment includes all
components of property that are used to
capture or process carbon oxide until
the carbon oxide is transported for
disposal, injection, or utilization.
Further, the proposed regulations list
specific items that are included in, or
excluded from the definition of carbon
capture equipment. Components of
property related to the function of
capturing carbon oxides, such as
components of property necessary to
compress, treat, process, liquefy, or
pump carbon oxides, are included
within the definition of carbon capture
equipment. Components of property
related to transporting carbon oxides for
disposal, injection, or utilization are not
included in the general definition.
c. Qualified Facility
Section 45Q(d) provides that
‘‘qualified facility’’ means any industrial
facility or direct air capture facility, the
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
34054
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
construction of which begins before
January 1, 2024, and (i) the construction
of carbon capture equipment begins
before such date; or (ii) the original
planning and design for such facility
includes installation of carbon capture
equipment. In addition, a qualified
facility must capture: (i) In the case of
a facility which emits not more than
500,000 metric tons of carbon oxide into
the atmosphere during the taxable year,
not less than 25,000 metric tons of
qualified carbon oxide during the
taxable year which is utilized in a
manner described in section 45Q(f)(5)
(Section 45Q(d)(2)(A) Facility); (ii) in
the case of an electricity generating
facility which is not a Section
45Q(d)(2)(A) Facility (Section
45Q(d)(2)(B) Facility), not less than
500,000 metric tons of qualified carbon
oxide during the taxable year; or (iii) in
the case of a direct air capture facility
or any facility which is not a Section
45Q(d)(2)(A) Facility or a Section
45Q(d)(2)(B) Facility, not less than
100,000 metric tons of qualified carbon
oxide during the taxable year.
Some commenters requested that the
proposed regulations incorporate the
‘‘80/20 Rule’’ set forth in Rev. Rul. 94–
31, 1994–1 C.B. 16, which held that for
section 45 purposes a facility that
contains some used property would still
qualify as originally placed in service,
provided the fair market value of the
used property is not more than 20
percent of the facility’s total value.
Commenters requested the inclusion of
this rule because the section 45Q credit
amounts depend on whether carbon
capture equipment is placed in service
before February 9, 2018, or on or after
that date.
The proposed regulations adopt the
80/20 Rule and provide that a qualified
facility or carbon capture equipment
may qualify as originally placed in
service even though it contains some
used components of property, provided
the fair market value of the used
components of property is not more
than 20 percent of the qualified facility
or carbon capture equipment’s total
value (the cost of the new components
of property plus the value of the used
components of property). For purposes
of the 80/20 Rule, the cost of a new
qualified facility or carbon capture
equipment includes all properly
capitalized costs of the new qualified
facility or carbon capture equipment.
Solely for purposes of the 80/20 Rule,
properly capitalized costs of a new
qualified facility or carbon capture
equipment may, at the option of the
taxpayer, include the cost of new
equipment for a pipeline owned and
used exclusively by that taxpayer to
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
transport carbon oxides captured from
that taxpayer’s qualified facility that
would otherwise be emitted into the
atmosphere.
d. Industrial Facility
Section 45Q does not define the term
‘‘industrial facility.’’ Commenters
suggested that an ‘‘industrial facility’’
should be defined as a facility that
produces a carbon oxide stream from a
fuel combustion source, a
manufacturing process, or a fugitive
carbon oxide-emission source that,
absent capture and disposal, injection,
or utilization, would otherwise be
released into the atmosphere. They also
recommended that the term not include
a facility that produces carbon dioxide
through carbon dioxide production
wells at natural carbon dioxide-bearing
formations. This definition is consistent
with the definition of industrial facility
provided in section 3.03 of Notice 2020–
12. The proposed regulations adopt this
definition.
e. Direct Air Capture Facility
Section 45Q(e)(1) provides that the
term ‘‘direct air capture facility’’ means
any facility which uses carbon capture
equipment to capture carbon dioxide
directly from the ambient air, except the
term does not include any facility which
captures carbon dioxide that is
deliberately released from naturally
occurring subsurface springs or using
natural photosynthesis.
Generally, commenters did not
request that the definition of ‘‘direct air
capture facility’’ be clarified. One
commenter suggested that ‘‘direct air
capture facility’’ include certain algae.
Although section 45Q(f)(5)(A)(i)
provides that photosynthesis or
chemosynthesis is a permitted type of
utilization of qualified carbon oxide, the
statutory definition of a ‘‘direct air
capture facility’’ excludes any facility
that captures carbon dioxide using
natural photosynthesis. Therefore, the
proposed regulations do not adopt the
commenter’s suggestion.
3. Secure Geological Storage
Section 45Q(f)(2) provides that the
Secretary, in consultation with the
Administrator of the EPA, the Secretary
of Energy, and the Secretary of the
Interior, must establish regulations for
determining adequate security measures
for the geological storage of qualified
carbon oxide under section 45Q(a) such
that the qualified carbon oxide does not
escape into the atmosphere. Such term
includes storage at deep saline
formations, oil and gas reservoirs, and
unminable coal seams under such
PO 00000
Frm 00006
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
conditions as the Secretary may
determine under such regulations.
Injection of carbon oxide into any
underground reservoir, onshore or
offshore under submerged lands within
the territorial jurisdiction of States,
requires the operator to comply with
Underground Injection Control (UIC)
program regulations and to obtain the
appropriate UIC well permits. Under 40
CFR 146.5 (Classification of injection
wells) Class II may be an appropriate
UIC well permit for wells which inject
fluids (including carbon dioxide)
brought to the surface in connection
with conventional oil or natural gas
production and may be commingled
with waste waters from gas plants that
are an integral part of production
operations, unless those fluids are
classified as a hazardous waste at the
time of injection, and for wells which
inject fluids (including carbon oxides)
for enhanced recovery of oil or natural
gas. Class VI is an appropriate UIC well
permit for wells that are not
experimental in nature that are used for
geologic sequestration of carbon dioxide
beneath the lowermost formation
containing an underground source of
drinking water; or, for wells used for
geologic sequestration of carbon dioxide
that have been granted a waiver of the
injection depth requirements pursuant
to requirements at 40 CFR 146.95; or, for
wells used for geologic sequestration of
carbon dioxide that have received an
expansion to the areal extent of an
existing Class II enhanced oil recovery
or enhanced gas recovery aquifer
exemption pursuant to §§ 146.4 and
144.7(d) of 40 CFR.
Operators that inject carbon dioxide
underground are also subject to the
EPA’s GHGRP requirements set forth at
40 CFR part 98. Under 40 CFR part 98
subpart RR (Geologic Sequestration of
Carbon Dioxide source category,
referred to as subpart RR), certain
facilities, including UIC Class VI wells,
are required to report basic information
on carbon dioxide received for injection,
develop and implement an EPAapproved site-specific Monitoring,
Reporting, and Verification Plan (MRV
Plan), and report the amount of carbon
dioxide geologically sequestered using a
mass balance approach and annual
monitoring activities. Under 40 CFR
part 98 subpart UU (Injection of Carbon
Dioxide source category, referred to as
subpart UU), all other facilities that
inject carbon dioxide underground such
as for EOR or any other purpose, are
required to report basic information on
carbon dioxide received for injection.
Facilities that conduct EOR are not
required by 40 CFR part 98 to report
under subpart RR unless (1) the owner
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
or operator chooses to opt into subpart
RR or, (2) the facility holds a UIC Class
VI permit for the well or group of wells
used for EOR. Annual reports that are
submitted under 40 CFR part 98 to the
EPA’s GHGRP undergo verification by
the EPA, and non-confidential data from
these reports are published on the EPA’s
website.
Commenters noted that Form 8933
defines ‘‘secure geological storage’’ for
purposes of section 45Q as requiring
approval by the EPA of an MRV Plan.
Thus, meeting the Form 8933 conditions
would be achieved currently by
receiving either (i) a UIC Class VI permit
plus an EPA-approved MRV Plan,
which UIC Class VI permit holders are
already required to have because they
are subject to subpart RR; or (ii) a UIC
Class II permit plus an EPA-approved
MRV Plan. The Form 8933 requirement
that UIC Class II permit holders receive
an approved MRV Plan for purposes of
the section 45Q credit creates an
additional burden on such holders.
Some commenters expressed concern
that being required to opt into subpart
RR may create a misalignment with state
mineral property and natural resource
conservation laws, as well as accepted
industry practices and commercial
arrangements. Therefore, the
commenters generally requested that the
Treasury Department and the IRS
provide alternatives to opting into
subpart RR for demonstrating secure
geological storage for EOR projects.
Many commenters suggested that a
standard adopted by the International
Organization for Standardization (ISO)
and endorsed by the American National
Standards Institute (ANSI), CSA/ANSI
ISO 27916:19, ‘‘Carbon Dioxide Capture,
Transportation and Geological Storage—
Carbon Dioxide Storage Using Enhanced
Oil Recovery (CO2-EOR),’’ is a viable
alternative to subpart RR for
establishing secure geological storage for
the use of qualified carbon oxide for
EOR.
The CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19
standard was developed for the purpose
of quantifying and documenting the
total carbon dioxide that is stored in
association with EOR. In general,
reporting under CSA/ANSI ISO
27916:19 uses mass balance accounting,
has established reporting and
documentation requirements, and
includes requirements for documenting
a monitoring program and a
containment assurance plan.
Some of the commenters advocating
for the application of the CSA/ANSI ISO
27916:19 standard emphasized the
importance and need for public
acceptance and input, transparent
public filings, credible third-party
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
audits and certifications, and
government oversight and enforcement.
For example, some commenters
suggested that the proposed regulations
require that all relevant documentation
of the amount of qualified carbon oxide
stored for purposes of the section 45Q
credit be retained and made available
for public review and the total quantity
of qualified carbon oxide stored for
long-term containment be reported
annually. The Treasury Department and
the IRS appreciate the importance of
shared and open information in this
context and encourage transparency.
However, there is no statutory
requirement in section 45Q for
taxpayers, Federal agencies, or industry
groups to pubicly display this
information or otherwise make it
available. In addition, the IRS is itself
limited in what it can disclose because
of the rules prohibiting the public
disclosure of taxpayer information
under section 6103.
Some commenters also requested that
the Treasury Department and the IRS
recognize the standards for secure
geological storage required by
government entities with regulatory
primacy, and also recommended that
states be allowed to certify the secure
geological storage of qualified carbon
oxide. The commenters noted that the
EPA has approved primary enforcement
authority (primacy) for UIC Class II
wells for more than half the states.
Primacy permits a state, tribe, or
territory to implement and oversee its
own EPA approved program. One
commenter requested that the IRS
clarify that a valid UIC Class VI permit
issued under the authority of the EPA
includes permits issued by a state that
has received final approval from the
EPA of its primacy application under
section 1422 of the Safe Water Drinking
Act to implement a Class VI UIC
Program. The commenter also suggested
that use of an accounting methodology
consistent with the mass balance
equation under subpart RR be adequate
to establish secure geological storage.
The Treasury Department and the IRS,
in consultation with the EPA, DOE, and
the Department of Interior (Interior
Department), agree that providing CSA/
ANSI ISO 27916:19 as an alternative for
UIC Class II wells is a viable
quantification methodology that is
appropriate for these purposes. Both
subpart RR and CSA/ANSI ISO
27916:19 require an assessment and
monitoring of potential leakage
pathways; quantification of inputs,
losses and storage through a mass
balance approach; and documentation
of steps and approaches. Operators of
UIC Class II wells that follow the CSA/
PO 00000
Frm 00007
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
34055
ANSI ISO 27916:19 standard could elect
to report to the EPA’s GHGRP under
subpart RR but would not be required to
do so. Rather, they could continue to
report to the EPA under subpart UU.
The Treasury Department and the IRS,
in consultation with the EPA, DOE, and
the Interior Department, disagree with
suggestions to allow the reporting rules
promulgated by states as an alternative
to subpart RR or CSA/ANSI ISO
27916:19. Reporting rules among states
are not uniform and states may have
different reporting requirements and
different governing bodies to whom
carbon dioxide injection projects are
required to report. Adopting such rules
would not promote uniformity, and
would increase the administrative
burden on the IRS significantly.
Consequently, the proposed
regulations allow the CSA/ANSI ISO
27916:19 standard as an alternative to
subpart RR for UIC Class II wells using
qualified carbon oxide for EOR, but do
not allow standards set by states as an
alternative to subpart RR. In addition,
the proposed regulations do not provide
for an alternative to subpart RR
reporting for UIC Class VI wells because
all UIC Class VI wells are already
subject to subpart RR reporting
requirements. A taxpayer that reported
volumes of carbon oxide to the EPA
pursuant to subpart RR may self-certify
the volume of carbon oxide claimed for
purposes of section 45Q. Alternatively,
if a taxpayer determined volumes
pursuant to CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19,
the taxpayer may prepare
documentation as outlined in CSA/
ANSI 27916:2019 internally, but such
documentation must be provided to a
qualified independent engineer or
geologist, who then must certify that the
documentation provided, including the
mass balance calculations as well as
information regarding monitoring and
containment assurance, is accurate and
complete.
4. Utilization of Qualified Carbon Oxide
Section 45Q(f)(5)(A) provides that
‘‘utilization of qualified carbon oxide’’
means (i) the fixation of such qualified
carbon oxide through photosynthesis or
chemosynthesis, such as through the
growing of algae or bacteria; (ii) the
chemical conversion of such qualified
carbon oxide to a material or chemical
compound in which such qualified
carbon oxide is securely stored; or (iii)
the use of such qualified carbon oxide
for any other purpose for which a
commercial market exists (with the
exception of use as a tertiary injectant
in a qualified enhanced oil or natural
gas recovery project), as determined by
the Secretary.
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
34056
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
Section 45Q(f)(5)(B) provides a
methodology to determine the amount
of qualified carbon oxide utilized by the
taxpayer. Such amount is equal to the
metric tons of qualified carbon oxide
which the taxpayer demonstrates, based
upon an analysis of lifecycle greenhouse
gas emissions and subject to such
requirements as the Secretary, in
consultation with the Secretary of
Energy and the Administrator of the
EPA, determines appropriate, were (i)
captured and permanently isolated from
the atmosphere, or (ii) displaced from
being emitted into the atmosphere,
through use of a process described in
section 45Q(f)(5)(A). The term ‘‘lifecycle
greenhouse gas emissions’’ has the same
meaning given such term under
subparagraph (H) of section 211(o)(1) of
the Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C.
7545(o)(1)(H)), as in effect on February
9, 2018, except that ‘‘product’’ is
substituted for ‘‘fuel’’ each place it
appears in such subparagraph.
Commenters generally sought
guidance about the methodologies
required to prepare an acceptable life
cycle analysis (LCA) that demonstrates
the amount of qualified carbon oxide
utilized, as well as the boundaries
required for the LCA.
One commenter requested that
guidance establish clear guidelines for
the preparation of an LCA by applicants
to demonstrate the net reduction or
avoidance of carbon dioxide achieved
through its utilization by the taxpayer.
Because LCA requires selection of
comparative data, the commenter
recommended that the LCA undergo a
review by a third party, determined by
the IRS, to assess the reasonableness of
the assumptions, factors and
calculations used by the applicant.
Other commenters suggested using
the Greenhouse Gases, Regulated
Emissions, and Energy Use in
Transportation (GREET) model, or an
adaptation of it adopted by the
California Air Resources Board, to
perform LCA of transportation fuels,
and further suggested using both a basic
method and a safe harbor method. The
GREET model is a tool that examines
the life-cycle impacts of vehicle
technologies, fuels, products, and
energy systems. It provides a
transparent platform through which
energy and vehicle producers,
researchers, and regulators can evaluate
energy and environmental effects of
vehicle technologies and energy and
product systems. For any given energy
and vehicle system, GREET can
calculate total energy consumption
(non-renewable and renewable),
emissions of air pollutants, emissions of
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
greenhouse gases, and water
consumption.
One commenter suggested that the
LCA, as reviewed by the relevant
governmental agency, should determine
whether any release of embodied
qualified carbon oxide is possible for a
specific utilization project. If so, the
commenter recommended that recapture
be addressed in the LCA. The
commenter requested guidance
regarding the types of LCA models that
are appropriate, and recommended the
GREET model.
Another commenter suggested that
the IRS should not adopt a specific
methodology or approach to calculating
lifecycle emissions. Instead, the
commenter recommended that guidance
make clear that models that are
acceptable to the EPA will also be
acceptable for purposes of section 45Q.
The commenter suggested that the LCA
model for section 45Q purposes should
be one that is recognized by the EPA
based on its use in the Renewable Fuel
Standard or other program administered
by the EPA. The commenter further
recommended that if the capture and
utilization of carbon oxides also
generates other greenhouse gas
detriments, such as an increase in
emissions over the base case, those
greenhouse gases caused by the
utilization should be adjusted to
account for the relative global warming
potential. Similarly, if the capture and
utilization of carbon oxides reduce
greenhouse gas emissions over the base
case, the commenter argued that those
benefits should also be credited.
One commenter sought guidance on
the boundaries for LCA to determine
displacement of carbon dioxide and
recommended that lifecycle emissions
include the entirety of the lifecycle.
Several commenters expressed the
view that an MRV Plan or any
accredited LCA performed by a
qualified firm as determined by the IRS
could be suitable for establishing
boundaries for lifecycle emissions for
qualified carbon oxide utilization.
Further, commenters suggested that
there should be contractual proof to
track the supply chain and ensure that
the MRV Plan is followed according to
the annual LCA.
Some commenters suggested that
guidance require EOR operators to
provide a full lifecycle greenhouse gas
emissions analysis that, like the
requirements for utilization, includes all
stages of product and feedstock
production and distribution, from
feedstock generation or extraction
through the distribution and delivery
and use of the finished product to the
ultimate consumer. The commenters
PO 00000
Frm 00008
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
requested that the IRS make public all
lifecycle emissions calculations.
One commenter made the following
suggestions. First, taxpayers should use
an independent consulting firm or other
similar independent entity to undertake
the LCA. Second, taxpayers should
insure that an LCA model is realistic
and has been used widely by the LCA
industry. Third, an LCA must be
commercially available to anyone and
must be able to be examined in any
audit by the IRS. Fourth, taxpayers
should use an LCA that compares a base
case of making the product produced by
utilization without carbon capture to the
modeled utilization case using qualified
carbon oxide to determine what
greenhouse gases were displaced from
being emitted into the atmosphere.
Finally, taxpayers must use an LCA
which models all ‘‘greenhouse gases’’ as
defined in the Clean Air Act in
determining the net impact of such
greenhouse gases generated or reduced
in utilization of qualified carbon oxide.
One commenter suggested that the
IRS should provide a safe harbor for
taxpayers that retain a third-party firm
to undertake the LCA. However, the
commenter stated that while a safe
harbor would be helpful, third-party
verification should not be mandatory, as
many taxpayers may have sufficient
engineering expertise in-house and
some smaller projects may not support
the extra cost of third-party verification.
In response to the commenters, the
proposed regulations conform the
definition of utilization to the statutory
definition. The Treasury Department
and the IRS, in consultation with the
EPA and the DOE, concluded that the
LCA must be in writing and either
performed or verified by a
professionally-licensed third party that
uses generally-accepted standard
practices of quantifying the greenhouse
gas emissions of a product or process
and comparing that impact to a baseline.
In particular, the analysis must contain
documentation consistent with the
International Organization for
Standardization (ISO) 14044:2006,
‘‘Environmental management—Life
cycle assessment—Requirements and
Guidelines,’’ as well as a statement
documenting the qualifications of the
third party. Although the section 45Q
credit is only available with respect to
qualified carbon oxides, all greenhouse
gas emissions are taken into account
under this analysis. The proposed
regulations require a taxpayer to submit
an LCA report to the IRS and the DOE.
The LCA will be subject to a technical
review by the DOE, and the IRS, in
consultation with the DOE and the EPA,
will determine whether to approve the
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
LCA. The Treasury Department and the
IRS request comments on how to
achieve consistency in boundaries and
baselines so that similarly situated
taxpayers will be treated consistently.
The Treasury Department and the IRS
are willing to consider issuing guidance
on particular fact patterns.
The proposed regulations do not
define commercial markets or provide
for Standards of Lifecycle Analysis. The
Treasury Department and the IRS
continue to study these issues and
request comments.
5. Credit Recapture
Section 45Q(f)(4) directs the Secretary
to provide regulations for recapturing
the benefit of any section 45Q credit
allowable with respect to any qualified
carbon oxide which ceases to be
captured, disposed of, or used as a
tertiary injectant in a manner consistent
with the requirements of section 45Q.
Commenters sought guidance about
the method for measuring the amount of
leaked qualified carbon oxide subject to
recapture (recapture amount), the
method for calculating recapture, and
the open period during which a
recapture event may occur (recapture
period).
All of these issues require a definition
of the recapture period. The proposed
regulations provide that the recapture
period begins on the date of the first
injection of qualified carbon oxide for
disposal in secure geological storage or
use as a tertiary injectant and ends the
earlier of five years after the last taxable
year in which the taxpayer claimed a
section 45Q credit or the date
monitoring ends under subpart RR
requirements or the CSA/ANSI ISO
27916:19 standard.
For clarity we will describe two subportions of the recapture period, the
‘‘post-credit-claiming period’’ and the
‘‘lookback period’’. The ‘‘post-creditclaiming period’’ is the period after the
end of the twelve year credit period
during which a leak can result in
recapture, whereas the ‘‘lookback
period’’ is the portion of the recapture
period during which the IRS can look
back after a leakage event to recapture
credits. Most commenters supported a
lookback period of three to five years.
Commenters generally suggested that
if a recapture event occurs with respect
to storage of qualified carbon oxide,
then the taxpayer must add the
recapture amount to the amount of tax
due in the taxable year in which the
recapture event occurs, as opposed to
attributing the leak to past tax years and
amending those returns.
Commenters also suggested that a
recapture event should occur when
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
qualified carbon oxide, for which a
section 45Q credit has been allowed,
ceases to be stored in secure geological
storage if the amount of leakage of
qualified carbon oxide in a taxable year
exceeds the amount of qualified carbon
oxide stored in that same taxable year.
In other words, they suggested that a
leak would first offset the immediate tax
year’s claimed credits and then be an
addition to tax, as opposed to auditing
and amending past tax returns.
One commenter stated that the
standard for measuring recapture of the
section 45Q credit should be the mass
balance calculations that are used for
determining the amount of qualified
carbon oxide stored in secure geological
storage. The commenter noted that these
mass balance calculations effectively
establish a last-in/first-out (LIFO)
accounting method that assumes current
year releases offset current year
injections for the qualified carbon oxide
that is in secure geological storage.
Several commenters requested a safe
harbor for recapture, providing that
recapture will not apply so long as the
injection operator is operating in
compliance with any standards set by
the Treasury Department and the IRS for
secure geological storage of the qualified
carbon oxide. These commenters
asserted that if the injection operator is
in compliance with the secure
geological storage standards at the time
of a release, any release or leakage of the
qualified carbon oxide would be offset
by current year injections of qualified
carbon oxide. If the injection operator is
not operating in compliance with the
standards for secure geological storage
at the time of the release, the
commenters recommended that any
recapture be calculated on a LIFO basis
against previously taken section 45Q
credits when the injection operator was
in compliance with the secure
geological storage standards.
The proposed regulations do not
provide a recapture safe harbor, but do
limit the recapture period similar to the
recapture provisions for investment
credit property under section 50(a)(1).
Specifically, the proposed regulations
provide that any recapture amount will
be accounted for in the taxable year that
it is identified and reported. If, during
the recapture period, a taxpayer,
operator, or regulatory agency
determines that qualified carbon oxide
has leaked to the atmosphere, the
taxpayer will have a recapture amount
if the leaked amount of qualified carbon
oxide exceeds the amount of qualified
carbon dioxide disposed of in secure
geological storage or used as a tertiary
injectant in that taxable year. That
excess amount of leaked qualified
PO 00000
Frm 00009
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
34057
carbon oxide will be recaptured at a
credit rate calculated on a LIFO basis
(that is, the excess leaked qualified
carbon oxide will be deemed
attributable first to the first preceding
year, then to second preceding year, and
then up to the fifth preceding year) to
simplify the calculation of the recapture
amount.
The taxpayer must add the amount of
the recaptured section 45Q tax credit to
the amount of tax due in the taxable
year in which the recapture event
occurs. Consistent with this five-year
lookback period, the proposed
regulations provide that the post-creditclaiming period ends the earlier of (i)
five years after the last taxable year in
which the taxpayer claimed a section
45Q credit or (ii) the date monitoring
ends under the requirements of the
subpart RR standard or the CSA/ANSI
ISO 27916:19 standard.
The proposed regulations also provide
that in the event of a recapture event
with respect to a secure geological
storage location in which the stored
qualified carbon oxide had been
captured from more than one unit of
carbon capture equipment that was not
under common ownership, the
recapture amount must be allocated
among the taxpayers that own the
multiple units of carbon capture
equipment pro rata on the basis of the
amount of qualified carbon oxide
captured from each of the multiple units
of carbon capture equipment.
Similarly, the proposed regulations
provide that in the event of a recapture
event where the leaked amount of
qualified carbon oxide is deemed
attributable to qualified carbon oxide
with respect to which multiple
taxpayers claimed section 45Q credit
amounts, the recapture amount is
allocated on a pro rata basis among the
taxpayers that claimed the section 45Q
credits.
The proposed regulations provide a
limited exception to recapture in the
event of a leakage of qualified carbon
oxide resulting from actions not related
to the selection, operation, or
maintenance of the storage facility, such
as volcanic activity or a terrorist attack.
Finally, the proposed regulations
provide that if qualified carbon oxide is
deliberately removed from a secure
storage site, a recapture event occurs in
the year in which the qualified carbon
oxide is removed from its original
storage.
As noted in section 4.08 of Revenue
Procedure 2020–12, a taxpayer may
obtain third-party recapture insurance
to protect against recapture.
The Treasury Department and the IRS
request comments on how to apply the
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
34058
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
recapture provisions to section 45Q
credits that are carried forward to future
taxable years due to insuffificent income
tax liability in the current taxable year.
Effect on Other Documents
Sections 1 through 5 of Notice 2009–
83, 2009–2 C.B. 588, as modified by
Notice 2011–25, 2011–1 C.B. 604, are
obsoleted. The remaining sections of
Notice 2009–83 provide reporting and
recordkeeping requirements associated
with the limitation on credits available
under former section 45Q(a) (as in effect
before February 9, 2018) and sections
45Q(a)(1) and (2). After the end of the
calendar year in which the Secretary, in
consultation with the Administrator of
the EPA, certifies that a total of
75,000,000 metric tons of qualified
carbon oxide have been taken into
account under former section 45Q(a) (as
in effect before February 9, 2018) and
sections 45Q(a)(1) and (2), the
remaining sections of Notice 2009–83
will be obsoleted.
Proposed Effective/Applicability Date
The regulations are proposed to apply
to taxable years beginning on or after the
date the Treasury decision adopting
these regulations as final regulations is
published in the Federal Register.
However, taxpayers may choose to
apply the final regulations for taxable
years beginning on or after February 9,
2018, and before the date the Treasury
decision adopting these regulations as
final regulations is published in the
Federal Register. See section 7805(b)(7).
Alternatively, taxpayers may rely on
these proposed regulations for taxable
years beginning on or after February 9,
2018, and before the date the Treasury
decision adopting these regulations as
final regulations is published in the
Federal Register, provided the
taxpayers follow the proposed
regulations in their entirety and in a
consistent manner.
Statement of Availability for IRS
Documents
For copies of recently issued Revenue
Procedures, Revenue Rulings, Notices,
and other guidance published in the
Internal Revenue Bulletin, please visit
the IRS website at https://www.irs.gov.
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
Special Analyses
I. Regulatory Planning and Review—
Economic Analysis
Executive Orders 13563, 13771, and
12866 direct agencies to assess costs and
benefits of available regulatory
alternatives and, if regulation is
necessary, to select regulatory
approaches that maximize net benefits
(including potential economic,
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
environmental, public health and safety
effects, distributive impacts, and
equity). Executive Order 13563
emphasizes the importance of
quantifying both costs and benefits, of
reducing costs, of harmonizing rules,
and of promoting flexibility. The
preliminary E.O. 13771 designation is
deregulatory.
These regulations have been
designated by the Office of Management
and Budget’s Office of Information and
Regulatory Affairs (OIRA) as
economically significant under
Executive Order 12866 pursuant to the
Memorandum of Agreement (April 11,
2018) between the Treasury Department
and the Office of Management and
Budget regarding review of tax
regulations.
A. Background and Overview
Section 45Q was enacted on October
3, 2008, by section 115 of Division B of
the Energy Improvement and Extension
Act of 2008, Public Law 110–343, 122
Stat. 3765, 3829, to provide a credit for
the sequestration of carbon dioxide. On
February 17, 2009, section 45Q was
amended by section 1131 of Division B
of the American Recovery and
Reinvestment Tax Act of 2009, Public
Law 111–5, 123 Stat. 115, 325. Section
45Q was further amended on December
19, 2014, by section 209(j)(1) of Division
A of the Tax Increase Prevention Act of
2014, Public Law 113–295, 128 Stat.
4010, 4030, and most recently on
February 9, 2018, by section 41119 of
Division D of the Bipartisan Budget Act
of 2018 (BBA), Public Law 115–123, 132
Stat. 64, 162.
On May 20, 2019, the IRS published
Notice 2019–32, 2019–21 I.R.B. 1187.
The notice requested general comments
on issues arising under section 45Q, as
well as specific comments concerning
the secure geological storage and
measurement of qualified carbon oxide,
and the recapture of the benefit of the
credit for carbon oxide sequestration.
The IRS received 116 comments from
industry members, environmental
groups, and other stakeholders.
In addition, the Treasury Department
and the IRS published Revenue
Procedure 2020–12, 2020–11 I.R.B. 511,
and Notice 2020–12, 2020–11 I.R.B. 495.
Revenue Procedure 2020–12 provides a
safe harbor under which the IRS will
treat partnerships as properly allocating
the section 45Q credit in accordance
with section 704(b). Notice 2020–12
provides guidance on the determination
of when construction has begun on a
qualified facility or on carbon capture
equipment that may be eligible for the
section 45Q credit.
PO 00000
Frm 00010
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
Section 45Q generally allows a credit
of an amount per metric ton of qualified
carbon oxide captured by the taxpayer
using carbon capture equipment. This
qualified carbon oxide must be captured
according to the statute in one of three
general manners. First, it may be
disposed of in secure geological storage.
This would occur if it were injected into
a geologic formation, such as a deep
saline formation, an oil and gas
reservoir, or an unminable coal seam.
Second, the qualified carbon oxide
may be used as a tertiary injectant in a
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas
recovery project and disposed of in
secure geological storage. A ‘‘tertiary
injectant’’ is qualified carbon oxide that
is injected into and stored in a qualified
enhanced oil or natural gas recovery
project and contributes to the extraction
of crude oil or natural gas.
Third, the qualified carbon oxide may
be ‘‘utilized’’ by fixing it through
photosynthesis or chemosynthesis,
converting it to a material or chemical
compound in which it is securely
stored, or using it for any other purpose
for which a commercial market exists.
‘‘Utilization’’ generally means the
qualified carbon oxide was captured
and permanently isolated from the
atmosphere, or displaced from being
emitted into the atmosphere.
Calculation of the amount utilized is
based on an analysis of lifecycle
greenhouse gas emissions.
The amount of the credit depends on
the date the carbon capture equipment
is placed in service and whether the
qualified carbon oxide is disposed of in
secure storage, injected, or utilized.
Different rules and credit amounts apply
to qualified carbon oxide capture
projects placed in service before and
after the date the enactment of the BBA
on February 9, 2018. Based on annual
reports filed with the IRS as of May,
2019, the aggregate amount of qualified
carbon oxide taken into account for
purposes of section 45Q was 62,740,171
metric tons. This is an increase of
2,972,247 metric tons from the
preceding year.1 According to data
reported to the EPA’s Greenhouse Gas
Reporting Program (GHGRP), there were
65 enhanced oil recovery (EOR) projects
operating in the U.S. in 2018. As of
2019, the National Petroleum Council,
an oil and natural gas advisory
committee to the Secretary of Energy,
reports that there were 10 carbon
capture, utilization, and storage projects
in the United States. DOE models
project that the section 45Q credit may
1 These data are available in Notice 2018–40,
2018–20 I.R.B. 583, and Notice 2019–31, 2019–20
I.R.B. 1181.
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
result in the sequestration of
approximately 570 million metric tons
of carbon oxides between 2018 and
2036.
B. Need for Regulation
The proposed regulations provide
guidance regarding the application of
section 45Q. Section 45Q requires
regulations for determining adequate
security measures for the secure
geological storage of qualified carbon
oxide such that it does not escape into
the atmosphere, standards for recapture
of section 45Q credits, and standards for
carbon oxide utilization.
C. Economic Analysis
1. Baseline
The Treasury Department and the IRS
have assessed the economic impacts of
the final regulations relative to a noaction baseline reflecting anticipated
Federal income tax-related behavior in
the absence of these regulations.
2. Economic Rationale for Issuing
Guidance for the 2018 BBA
The Treasury Department and the IRS
anticipate that the issuance of guidance
pertaining to section 45Q will provide
greater clarity in definitions than the
alternative of having no further
descriptions than the statute; more
flexibility in methods to establish
qualifications for the credit relative to
prior guidance; and more transparency
regarding business arrangements related
to the section 45Q credit relative to the
baseline. These features may lower
compliance burden and increase
economic investment by lowering
regulatory barriers to entry, compared to
a baseline of having only the statue and
not the regulations.
3. Economic Analysis of Specific
Provisions
The final regulations embody certain
regulatory decisions that reflect
necessary regulatory discretion. These
decisions specify more fully how the
section 45Q credit is to be implemented.
i. Standard for Secure Geological
Storage
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
a. Background
Section 45Q(f)(2) provides that the
Secretary, in consultation with the
Administrator of the EPA, the Secretary
of Energy, and the Secretary of the
Interior, must establish regulations for
determining adequate security measures
for the secure geological storage of
qualified carbon oxide under section
45Q such that qualified carbon oxide
does not escape into the atmosphere.
Such term includes storage at deep
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
saline formations, oil and gas reservoirs,
and unminable coal seams under such
conditions as the Secretary may
determine under such regulations.
Under existing law, injection of
carbon oxide into any underground
reservoir requires the operator to
comply with EPA’s Underground
Injection Control (UIC) program
regulations and to obtain the
appropriate UIC well permits. The UIC
program is designed to protect
underground sources of drinking water
from underground injection. Operators
that inject carbon dioxide underground
are also subject to the EPA’s GHGRP
requirements set forth at 40 CFR part 98.
Under 40 CFR part 98, facilities that
inject carbon dioxide underground for
long-term containment of carbon
dioxide in subsurface geologic
formations are specifically subject to 40
CFR part 98 subpart RR (Geologic
Sequestration of Carbon Dioxide source
category, referred to as subpart RR).
Facilities that are subject to subpart RR,
including UIC Class VI wells, are
required to report basic information on
carbon dioxide received for injection,
develop and implement an EPAapproved site-specific Monitoring,
Reporting, and Verification Plan (MRV
Plans); and report the amount of carbon
dioxide geologically sequestered using a
mass balance approach and annual
monitoring activities.
Facilities that inject carbon dioxide
underground for the purposes of
enhanced oil (EOR) and gas recovery or
any other purpose other than geologic
sequestration are required to report
basic information on carbon dioxide
received for injection under 40 CFR part
98 subpart UU (Injection of Carbon
Dioxide source category, referred to as
subpart UU). At present, the EPA does
not generally require facilities that
conduct EOR to report under subpart
RR. However, the owner or operator
may voluntarily choose to opt in to
subpart RR. For both subparts RR and
UU, annual reports are submitted under
40 CFR part 98 to the EPA’s GHGRP and
undergo verification by the EPA. Nonconfidential data from these reports are
published on the EPA’s website.
b. Comments Received
Commenters noted that in order to
qualify for section 45Q credits, IRS
Form 8933 defines ‘‘secure geological
storage’’ as requiring approval by the
EPA of an MRV Plan under 40 CFR part
98 subpart RR. Thus, meeting the Form
8933 conditions would currently be
achieved by receiving either (i) a UIC
Class VI permit plus an EPA-approved
MRV Plan, which UIC Class VI permit
holders are already required to have
PO 00000
Frm 00011
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
34059
because they are subject to subpart RR;
or (ii) a UIC Class II permit plus an EPAapproved MRV Plan, which requires
UIC Class II permit holders to opt in to
subpart RR. In this manner, the Form
8933 requirement that UIC Class II
permit holders receive an approved
MRV Plan creates an additional burden
on such holders because– it requires
them to opt in to subpart RR to receive
section 45Q credits. In addition, some
commenters expressed concern that a
requirement that they opt in to subpart
RR, in addition to being a
supplementary requirement, may create
a misalignment with state mineral
property and natural resource
conservation laws.
Commenters supported the continued
use of subpart RR, but most commenters
sought an alternative method in
addition to subpart RR. Many of these
commenters considered the subpart RR
requirements burdensome, for the
reasons noted immediately above.
Many commenters suggested that a
standard adopted by the International
Organization for Standardization (ISO)
and endorsed by the American National
Standards Institute (ANSI), CSA/ANSI
ISO 27916:19 standard, ‘‘Carbon dioxide
capture, transportation and geological
storage—Carbon dioxide storage using
enhanced oil recovery (CO2-EOR),’’
(CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19) is a viable
alternative to subpart RR for
establishing secure geological storage for
the use of qualified carbon oxide for
EOR.
The CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 was
developed for the purpose of
quantifying and documenting the total
carbon dioxide that is stored in
association with carbon dioxide-EOR. In
general, reporting under CSA/ANSI ISO
27916:19 (i) uses mass balance
accounting, (ii) has established
reporting and documentation
requirements, and (iii) includes
requirements for documenting a
monitoring program and a containment
assurance plan. ANSI, a not-for-profit
organization dedicated to supporting the
U.S. voluntary standards and
conformity assessment system, adopted
the CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 standard in
2019.
c. Regulatory Alternatives and Analysis
The Treasury Department and the IRS
considered three options for defining
standards for secure geological storage:
(i) The requirements set forth in 40 CFR
part 98 subpart RR; (ii) an election for
the taxpayer to comply with either the
subpart RR standards or the
requirements set forth in CSA/ANSI ISO
27916:19 and (iii) other alternatives to
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
34060
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
subpart RR, including allowing use of
state programs.
In evaluating option (ii), the Treasury
Department and the IRS, in consultation
with the EPA, the DOE, and the Interior
Department, agree with commenters that
CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 is a viable
quantification methodology that is
adequate for the intent and purpose of
the statute. Both subpart RR and CSA/
ANSI ISO 27916:19 require an
assessment and monitoring of potential
leakage pathways; quantification of
inputs, losses and storage through a
mass balance approach; and
documentation of steps and approaches.
Under option (ii), operators of UIC Class
II wells that follow the CSA/ANSI ISO
27916:19 standard could elect to report
under subpart RR but would not be
required to do so. Rather, they could
continue to report to the EPA under
subpart UU.
The Treasury Department and the IRS,
in consultation with the EPA, the DOE,
and the Interior Department, disagree
with commenter suggestions to allow
the reporting rules promulgated by
states as an alternative to subpart RR or
CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19. Reporting
rules among states are not uniform and
states may have different reporting
requirements and different governing
bodies to whom carbon dioxide
injection projects are required to report.
The adoption of such rules by the
Treasury Department and the IRS would
substantially increase the administrative
burden on the IRS. The Treasury
Department and the IRS did not attempt
to determine to what extent particular
states’ standards would fulfill the intent
and purpose of the statute.
The ability for taxpayers to elect to
use the CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19
standard instead of subpart RR could
yield economic differences in three
ways. First, if the two standards are
different in their costs of compliance,
then allowing a choice allows EOR
project operators to choose the less
costly standard. This would reduce
costs of compliance and regulatory
burden. Second, to the extent that the
difference in compliance costs between
the two standards is high and that
difference is a significant portion of
start-up costs, then allowing a less
expensive standard might lead to more
investment and more new projects.
Third, operators can use the option that
best aligns with their project goals and
timeframes. The Treasury Department
and the IRS project that compliance
costs for some taxpayers may be lower
under the CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19
standard than under subpart RR. Some
commenters stated that subpart RR may
create a misalignment for UIC Class II
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
wells with both state mineral property
and natural resource conservation laws;
and that such potential misalignment
would be costly to taxpayers. This
stated misalignment would not be
implicated with the use of the ISO
standards.
The Treasury Department and the IRS
recognize that the two standards differ
in terms of who would be responsible
for reviewing and approving a
sequestration plan and for identifying
leakage once a project is in place. In
addition, the standards differ because
unless otherwise required by law, the
CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 standard does
not require public reports of the amount
of qualified carbon oxide sequestered,
whereas the subpart RR standard does
entail the public provision of such data.
The Treasury Department and the IRS
did not attempt to analyze the economic
consequences of these differences.
The Treasury Department and the IRS
did not attempt to provide quantitative
estimates of the difference in
compliance costs between the CSA/
ANSI ISO 27916:19 standard and a
regulatory alternative of requiring only
subpart RR because suitable data are not
readily available at this level of detail.
Further, the Treasury Department and
IRS did not attempt to estimate the
effects of compliance cost differences on
investment or sequestration.
The Treasury Department and the IRS
solicit comments on these findings and
particularly solicit data, models, or
other evidence that could enhance the
rigor with which the final regulations
are developed.
ii. Credit Recapture
Section 45Q(f)(4) requires the
Treasury Department and the IRS to
promulgate regulations to provide for
the recapture of section 45Q credits in
the event of leakage. ‘‘Recapture’’ refers
to the repayment of the tax credits
claimed, and not to the capturing of CO2
that may have leaked from the project
after being injected.
In response to Notice 2019–32, 2019–
21 I.R.B. 1187, several commenters
requested clarification regarding credit
recapture, including (i) when the tax
would be due in relation to the year of
a recapture event, (ii) how long the IRS
can ‘‘look back’’ to recapture credits in
the event of leakage (lookback period),
and (iii) the length of time after ceasing
to claim credits during which a leakage
event would lead to recapture of credits.
All of these issues require a definition
of the recapture period. The proposed
regulations provide that the recapture
period begins on the date of the first
injection of qualified carbon oxide for
disposal in secure geological storage or
PO 00000
Frm 00012
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
use as a tertiary injectant and ends the
earlier of five years after the last taxable
year in which the taxpayer claimed a
section 45Q credit or the date
monitoring ends under subpart RR
requirements or the CSA/ANSI ISO
27916:19 standard.
For clarity we will describe two subportions of the recapture period, the
‘‘post-credit-claiming period’’ and the
‘‘lookback period’’. The ‘‘post-creditclaiming period’’ is the lesser of 5 years
after the last taxable year in which the
taxpayer claimed a section 45Q credit or
the date monitoring ends under subpart
RR requirements or the CSA/ANSI ISO
27916:19 standard. Depending on the
project’s individual requirements, the
post-credit-claiming period is therefore
between zero and five years. Whereas
the ‘‘lookback period’’ is the portion of
the recapture period during which the
IRS can look back after a leakage event
to recapture credits. Most commenters
supported a lookback period of three to
five years.
A leakage event that leads to
recapture of credits can occur any time
during the recapture period. A leakage
event that occurs after the recapture
period would not lead to recapture of
credits.
The proposed regulations provide that
any recapture amount will be accounted
for in the taxable year that it is
identified and reported. The amount of
credits that can be recaptured in the
event of leakage depends on the length
of the lookback period and the amount
of the leakage.
If, during the recapture period, it is
determined that qualified carbon oxide
has leaked to the atmosphere, the
taxpayer will have a recapture amount
if the leaked amount of qualified carbon
oxide exceeds the amount of qualified
carbon dioxide disposed of in secure
geological storage or used as a tertiary
injectant in that taxable year. That
excess amount of leaked qualified
carbon oxide will be recaptured at a
credit rate calculated on a LIFO basis
(that is, such excess leaked qualified
carbon oxide will be deemed
attributable first to the first preceding
year, then to second preceding year, and
so forth up to five years) for ease of
administration. The taxpayer must add
the amount of the recaptured section
45Q tax credit to the amount of tax due
in the taxable year in which the
recapture event occurs. This rule
applies regardless of whether the project
injected qualified carbon oxide in the
taxable year.
In response to Notice 2019–32,
commenters expressed concerns with
how long the length of a lookback
period after the project operator stops
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
claiming section 45Q credits (for
example, if the project is finished or the
period for claiming credits ends) that a
leakage event can lead to recapture.
Commenters were concerned that
investors would deem the risk too high
to invest if the end of the recapture
period extended too long after the final
year of claiming section 45Q credits. To
address this concern the proposed
regulations provide that the recapture
period begins on the date of first
injection of qualified carbon oxide for
disposal in secure geological storage or
use as a tertiary injectant and ends the
earlier of three years after the last
taxable year in which the taxpayer
claimed a section 45Q credit or the date
monitoring ends under subpart RR
requirements or the CSA/ANSI ISO
27916:19 standard.
The Treasury Department and the IRS
considered alternative specifications for
the lookback period other than five
years. Open-ended or undefined
lookback periods would increase the
financial risk associated with the project
and dissuade investors, particularly for
projects for which the section 45Q
credit would constitute a sizeable share
of revenue. The proposed regulations,
by allowing for a specific and finite
lookback period, will encourage more
investment in projects relative to an
unspecified or infinite period. The
Treasury Department and the IRS, in
consultation with the EPA, the DOE,
and the Interior Department, have
determined that for the period after the
lookback period, existing environmental
regulations and standards will ensure
integrity consistent with the intent and
purpose of the statute.
In examining possible lookback
periods, the Treasury Department and
the IRS have not developed a
quantitative model to incorporate the
costs of monitoring and the probability
of leakage along with the tax
administration burden involved in the
lookback period.
The Treasury Department and the IRS
welcome comments on the length of the
lookback period and particularly solicit
data, models, or other evidence that
could enhance the rigor with which the
final regulations are developed.
iii. Utilization of Qualified Carbon
Oxide
Section 45Q(f)(5)(A) provides that
‘‘utilization of qualified carbon oxide’’
means (i) the fixation of such qualified
carbon oxide through photosynthesis or
chemosynthesis, such as through the
growing of algae or bacteria; (ii) the
chemical conversion of such qualified
carbon oxide to a material or chemical
compound in which such qualified
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
carbon oxide is securely stored; or (iii)
the use of such qualified carbon oxide
for any other purpose for which a
commercial market exists (with the
exception of use as a tertiary injectant
in a qualified enhanced oil or natural
gas recovery project), as determined by
the Secretary.
Section 45Q(f)(5)(B) provides a
methodology to determine the amount
of qualified carbon oxide utilized by the
taxpayer. Such amount is equal to the
metric tons of qualified carbon oxide
which the taxpayer demonstrates, based
upon an analysis of lifecycle greenhouse
gas emissions and subject to such
requirements as the Secretary, in
consultation with the Secretary of
Energy and the Administrator of the
EPA, determines appropriate, were (i)
captured and permanently isolated from
the atmosphere, or (ii) displaced from
being emitted into the atmosphere,
through use of a process described in
section 45Q(f)(5)(A). The term ‘‘lifecycle
greenhouse gas emissions’’ has the same
meaning given such term under
subparagraph (H) of section 211(o)(1) of
the Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C.
7545(o)(1)(H)), as in effect on the date of
enactment of the BBA on February 9,
2018, except that ‘‘product’’ is
substituted for ‘‘fuel’’ each place it
appears in such subparagraph.
The term ‘‘lifecycle greenhouse gas
emissions’’ means the aggregate quantity
of greenhouse gas emissions (including
direct emissions and significant indirect
emissions such as significant emissions
from land use changes), related to the
full product lifecycle, including all
stages of product and feedstock
production and distribution, from
feedstock generation or extraction
through the distribution and delivery
and use of the finished product to the
ultimate consumer, where the mass
values for all greenhouse gases are
adjusted to account for their relative
global warming potential.
Commenters proposed multiple
methods for the Treasury Department
and the IRS to allow for calculating
‘‘utilization’’ of qualified carbon oxide.
The proposed regulations provide
clarifications regarding: (i) Standards for
the lifecycle analysis (LCA) of emissions
that were captured or displaced for
purposes of section 45Q(f)(5)(B); and (ii)
the agency with responsibility to review
the LCA.
The Treasury Department and the IRS,
in consultation with the EPA and the
DOE, have determined that the LCA
must be in writing and either performed
or verified by a professionally-licensed
third party that uses generally-accepted
standard practices of quantifying the
greenhouse gas emissions of a product
PO 00000
Frm 00013
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
34061
or process and comparing that impact to
a baseline. In particular, the analysis
must contain documentation consistent
with the International Organization for
Standardization (ISO) 14044:2006,
‘‘Environmental management—Life
cycle assessment—Requirements and
Guidelines,’’ as well as a statement
documenting the qualifications of the
third party.
The proposed regulations require a
taxpayer submit an LCA report to the
IRS and the DOE prior to the taxpayer
claiming the section 45Q credit. The
LCA will be subject to a technical
review by the DOE, and the IRS, in
consultation with the DOE and the EPA,
will determine whether to approve the
LCA.
The proposed regulations provide
greater clarity and examples for
calculating qualified carbon oxide
utilization. This enhanced clarity
should increase transparency and lower
compliance burden. In addition, the
proposed regulations allow for oversight
of the LCA plans by a third party, the
DOE, and the IRS (in consultation with
the DOE and the EPA); evaluation and
approval of the plans before the
taxpayer claims the credit will
potentially reduce taxpayer compliance
costs and IRS administrative costs.
Following industry-specific standards
will also increase clarity in qualifying
for the section 45Q credit.
The proposed regulations provide an
economic gain arising from enhanced
clarity regarding the rules of the section
45Q credit within the context of the
intent and purpose of the statute. The
Treasury Department and the IRS
project that this clarity will encourage
additional investment in carbon oxide
utilization projects relative to the noaction baseline. The Treasury
Department and the IRS have not
estimated this gain because we do not
have readily available data or models to
predict (i) the interpretations that
taxpayers might have made in the
absence of this guidance, and (ii) the
effect of such guidance on the
investment that taxpayers would make,
relative to alternative regulatory
approaches or the no-action baseline.
The Treasury Department and the IRS
solicit comments on the economic
consequences of these decisions and
particularly solicit data, models, or
other evidence that could enhance the
rigor with which the final regulations
are developed.
II. Paperwork Reduction Act
The collection of information in these
proposed regulations with respect to
section 45Q are in proposed § 1.45Q–
1(e), § 1.45Q–1(h)(3)(iv), § 1.45Q–
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
34062
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
1(h)(2)(v), and § 1.45Q–2(h)(2), § 1.45Q–
3(d), and § 1.45Q–4(c)(1).
The collection of information in
proposed § 1.45Q–1(e) is an election to
have the dollar amounts applicable
under § 1.45Q–1(b) apply in lieu of the
dollar amounts applicable under
§ 1.45Q–1(d) for each metric ton of
qualified carbon oxide that a taxpayer
captures using carbon capture
equipment which is originally placed in
service at a qualified facility on or after
February 9, 2018. A new section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election must be made for
each taxable year that the taxpayer
wishes to allow a credit claimant to
claim section 45Q credits. The election
must be made on a Form 8933 (or
successor forms, or pursuant to
instructions and other guidance), and
applies to all metric tons of qualified
carbon oxide captured by the taxpayer
at the qualified facility throughout the
full 12-year credit period. The IRS is
contemplating making additional
changes to the Form 8933 to take these
proposed regulations into account.
The collection of information in
proposed § 1.45Q–1(h)(3)(iv) is an
election that a taxpayer (electing
taxpayer) eligible for the section 45Q
credit may make to allow the person
that disposes of the qualified carbon
oxide, utilizes the qualified carbon
oxide, or uses the qualified carbon oxide
as a tertiary injectant to claim the credit
(credit claimant). The electing taxpayer
that makes the section 45Q(f)(3)(B)
election must file a statement of election
containing the information described in
§ 1.45Q–1(h)(3)(iv) with the electing
taxpayer’s Federal income tax return or
Form 1065 for each taxable year in
which the credit arises. The section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election must be made in
accordance with Form 8933 (or
successor forms, or pursuant to
instructions and other guidance) no
later than the time prescribed by law
(including extensions) for filing the
Federal income tax return for the year
in which the credit arises. The election
may not be filed with an amended
Federal income tax return, an amended
Form 1065, or an AAR, as applicable,
after the prescribed date (including
extensions) for filing the original
Federal income tax return or Form 1065
for the year, with the exception of
amended Federal income tax returns,
amended Forms 1065, or AARs, as
applicable, for any taxable year ending
after February 9, 2018, and before
taxable years beginning after the date of
issuance of this proposed regulation.
New section 45Q(f)(3)(B) elections must
be made for each taxable year that the
electing taxpayer wishes to allow credit
claimants to claim section 45Q credits.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
The IRS is contemplating making
additional changes to the Form 8933 to
take these proposed regulations into
account.
The collection of information in
proposed § 1.45Q–1(h)(2)(v) requires
that if a taxpayer enters into a binding
written contract with a third party that
physically carries out the disposal,
injection, or utilization of qualified
carbon oxide, the existence of each
contract and the parties involved must
be reported to the IRS annually on a
Form 8933 (or successor forms, or
pursuant to instructions and other
guidance) by each party to the contract,
regardless of the party claiming the
credit. The IRS is contemplating making
additional changes to the Form 8933 to
take these proposed regulations into
account.
The collection of information in
proposed § 1.45Q–2(h)(2) requires that a
taxpayer that claims a section 45Q
credit for qualified carbon oxide that is
captured and then used as a tertiary
injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or
natural gas recovery project certify such
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas
recovery project as required under
§ 1.43–3. This requires that the taxpayer
obtain a petroleum engineer’s
certification under § 1.43–3(a)(3) for
each project that must be attached to a
Form 8933 (or successor forms, or
pursuant to instructions and other
guidance) and filed not later than the
last date prescribed by law (including
extensions) for filing the operator’s or
designated owner’s Federal income tax
return or Form 1065 for the first taxable
year in which qualified carbon oxide is
injected into the reservoir. If a section
45Q credit is claimed on an amended
Federal income tax return, an amended
Form 1065, or an AAR, as applicable,
the petroleum engineer’s certification
will be treated as filed timely if it is
attached to a Form 8933 that is
submitted with such amended federal
income tax return, amended Form 1065,
or AAR. With respect to a section 45Q
credit that is claimed on a timely filed
Federal income tax return or Form 1065
for a taxable year ending after February
9, 2018 and beginning before the date of
issuance of this proposed regulation, for
which the petroleum engineer’s
certification was not submitted, the
petroleum engineer’s certification will
be treated as filed timely if it is attached
to an amended Form 8933 for any
taxable year ending after February 9,
2018, but not for taxable years beginning
after June 2, 2020. Additionally, the
taxpayer is required to provide an
operator’s continued certification under
§ 1.43–3(b)(3) for each project that must
be attached to a Form 8933 (or successor
PO 00000
Frm 00014
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
forms, or pursuant to instructions and
other guidance) and filed not later than
the last date prescribed by law
(including extensions) for filing the
operator’s or designated owner’s Federal
income tax return or Form 1065 for
taxable years after the taxable year for
which the petroleum engineer’s
certification is filed but not after the
taxable year in which injection activity
ceases and all injection wells are
plugged and abandoned. The IRS is
contemplating making additional
changes to the Form 8933 to take these
proposed regulations into account.
The collection of information in
proposed § 1.45Q–3(d) requires a
taxpayer that claims a section 45Q
credit for qualified carbon oxide that is
captured and then used as a tertiary
injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or
natural gas recovery project to certify
the volume of carbon oxide claimed for
purposes of section 45Q. A taxpayer that
reported volumes of carbon oxide to the
EPA pursuant to subpart RR may selfcertify the volume of carbon oxide
claimed for purposes of section 45Q.
Alternatively, if the taxpayer
determined volumes pursuant to CSA/
ANSI ISO 27916:19, a taxpayer may
prepare documentation as outlined in
CSA/ANSI 27916:2019 internally, but
such documentation must be provided
to a qualified independent engineer or
geologist, who then must certify that the
documentation provided, including the
mass balance calculations as well as
information regarding monitoring and
containment assurance is accurate and
complete. Taxpayers that capture carbon
oxide giving rise to the section 45Q
credit must file Form 8933 (or successor
forms, or pursuant to instructions and
other guidance) with a timely filed tax
return, including extensions. Taxpayers
that dispose of, inject, or utilize
qualified carbon oxide must also file
Form 8933 (or successor forms, or
pursuant to instructions and other
guidance) with a timely filed F Federal
income tax return or Form 1065,
including extensions. The IRS is
contemplating making additional
changes to the Form 8933 to take these
proposed regulations into account.
The collection of information in
proposed § 1.45Q–4(c)(1) requires a
taxpayer that utilizes qualified carbon
oxide to measure the amount of carbon
oxide captured and utilized through a
combination of direct measurement and
life cycle analysis (LCA). The
measurement and written LCA report
must be performed by or verified by an
independent third party. The report
must contain documentation consistent
with the International Organization for
Standardization (ISO) 14044:2006,
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
‘‘Environmental management—Life
cycle assessment—Requirements and
Guidelines,’’ as well as a statement
documenting the qualifications of the
third party, including proof of
appropriate professional license or
foreign equivalent, and an affidavit from
the third-party stating that it is
independent from the taxpayer. The
taxpayer must submit the written LCA
report to the IRS and the DOE. The LCA
will be subject to a technical review by
the DOE, and the IRS, in consultation
with the DOE and the EPA, will
determine whether to approve the LCA.
For purposes of the Paperwork
Reduction Act of 1995 (51087 U.S.C.
3507(d)) (PRA), the reporting burden
associated with proposed § 1.45Q–1(e),
§ 1.45Q–1(h)(3)(iv), § 1.45Q–1(h)(2)(v),
§ 1.45Q–2(h)(2), § 1.45Q–3(d), and
§ 1.45Q–4(c)(1) will be reflected in the
IRS Paperwork Reduction Act
Submission for the Form 8933 (OMB
control numbers 1545–0123 and 1545–
2132). The IRS is anticipating making
revisions to Form 8933 to take these
proposed regulations into account. The
Treasury Department and the IRS
request comments on all aspects of
information collection burdens related
to the proposed regulations. In addition,
when available, drafts of IRS forms are
posted for comment at www.irs.gov/
draftforms.
The current status of the Paperwork
Reduction Act submissions related to
the section 45Q credit is provided in the
following table. The section 45Q
provisions are included in aggregated
burden estimates for the OMB control
numbers listed below which, in the case
of 1545–0123, represents a total
estimated burden time, including all
other related forms and schedules for
corporations, of 3.157 billion hours and
total estimated monetized costs of
$58.148 billion ($2017). The burden
estimates provided in the OMB control
numbers are aggregate amounts that
relate to the entire package of forms
associated with the OMB control
Form
Type of filer
OMB No(s).
Form 8933 ..............
Business .................
1545–2132
Form 8933 ..............
Business (NEW
Model).
1545–0123
34063
number, and will in the future include
but not isolate the estimated burden of
only the section 45Q requirements.
These numbers are therefore unrelated
to the future calculations needed to
assess the burden imposed by the
proposed regulations. No burden
estimates specific to the proposed
regulations are currently available. The
Treasury Department has not estimated
the burden, including that of any new
information collections, related to the
requirements under the proposed
regulations. Those estimates would
capture both changes made to section
45Q by the BBA and those that arise out
of discretionary authority exercised in
the proposed regulations. The Treasury
Department and the IRS request
comments on all aspects of information
collection burdens related to the
proposed regulations.
When available, drafts of IRS forms
are posted for comment at www.irs.gov/
draftforms.
Status
Sixty-day notice published in the Federal Register on 10/21/19 (84 FR 56283).
Public comment period closed on 12/20/19. Thirty-day notice published in the
Federal Register on 1/31/20 (85 FR 5776). Public comment period closed on
3/2/20. OIRA approval is pending.
Sixty-day notice published in the Federal Register on 9/30/19 (84 FR 51718).
Public Comment period closed on 11/29/19. Thirty-day notice published in the
Federal Register on 12/19/19 (84 FR 69825). Public Comment period closed
on 1/21/20. Approved by OIRA on 1/30/20.
Link: https://hs-www-federalregister-gov.tickly.io/documents/2019/10/21/2019-22844/proposed-collection-comment-requestfor-form-8933.
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
III. Regulatory Flexibility Act
The Regulatory Flexibility Act (5
U.S.C. 601 et seq.) (RFA) imposes
certain requirements with respect to
Federal rules that are subject to the
notice and comment requirements of
section 553(b) of the Administrative
Procedure Act (5 U.S.C. 551 et seq.) and
that are likely to have a significant
economic impact on a substantial
number of small entities. Unless an
agency determines that a proposal is not
likely to have a significant economic
impact on a substantial number of small
entities, section 603 of the RFA requires
the agency to present an initial
regulatory flexibility analysis (IRFA) of
the proposed rule. The Treasury
Department and the IRS have not
determined whether the proposed rule,
when finalized, will likely have a
significant economic impact on a
substantial number of small entities.
This determination requires further
study. However, because there is a
possibility of significant economic
impact on a substantial number of small
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
entities, an IRFA is provided in these
proposed regulations. The Treasury
Department and the IRS invite
comments on both the number of
entities affected and the economic
impact on small entities.
Pursuant to section 7805(f), this
notice of proposed rulemaking has been
submitted to the Chief Counsel of
Advocacy of the Small Business
Administration for comment on its
impact on small business.
1. Need for and Objectives of the Rule
The proposed regulations will provide
greater clarity to taxpayers for purposes
of claiming the section 45Q credit for
the capture and disposal, injection, or
utilization of qualified carbon oxide.
The proposed rule is expected to
encourage taxpayers to invest in carbon
capture technologies. Thus, the
Treasury Department and the IRS intend
and expect that the proposed rule will
deliver benefits across the economy that
will beneficially impact various
industries and reduce emissions of
carbon oxides that would otherwise be
PO 00000
Frm 00015
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
released into the atmosphere as
industrial emission of greenhouse gasses
or lead to such release.
2. Affected Small Entities
The Small Business Administration
estimates in its 2018 Small Business
Profile that 99.9 percent of United States
businesses meet its definition of a small
business. The applicability of these
proposed regulations does not depend
on the size of the business, as defined
by the Small Business Administration.
As described more fully in the preamble
to this proposed regulation and in this
IRFA, these rules may affect a variety of
different businesses across serval
different industries.
The section 45Q credit incentivizes
three different categories of activities
related to captured carbon oxide. First,
the section 45Q credit is available to
taxpayers who capture carbon oxide and
dispose of it in secure geological
storage. This would occur if it were
injected into a geological formation,
such as a deep saline formation, an oil
and gas reservoir, or an unminable coal
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
34064
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
seam. The taxpayer claiming the credit
for carbon oxide that is securely stored
can be either the taxpayer who owns the
capture equipment, or if an election is
made, the taxpayer who disposes of the
carbon oxide.
Second, the section 45Q credit is also
available for carbon oxide captured and
used as a tertiary injectant in a qualified
enhanced oil or natural gas recovery
project and disposed of in secure
geological storage. The taxpayer
claiming the credit for carbon oxide that
is used as a tertiary injectant in
enhanced oil recovery projects can be
either the taxpayer who owns the
capture equipment, or if an election is
made, the taxpayer who uses the carbon
oxide as a tertiary injectant in a
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas
recovery project.
And third, the section 45Q credit is
available for carbon oxide ‘‘utilized’’ by
fixing it through photosynthesis or
chemosynthesis, converted to a material
or chemical compound in which it is
securely stored, or used for any other
purpose for which a commercial market
exists. The taxpayer claiming the credit
for utilization of carbon oxide can be
either the taxpayer who owns the
carbon capture equipment, or if an
election is made, the taxpayer who
utilizes the carbon oxide.
Because the potential credit claimants
in all three of these scenarios can vary,
including potential tax equity investors
from the financial services sector as
credit claimants, it is difficult to
estimate at this time the impact of these
proposed regulations, if any, on small
businesses.
The Treasury Department and the IRS
expect to receive more information on
the impact on small businesses through
comments on this proposed rule and
again when taxpayers start to claim the
section 45Q credit using the guidance
and procedures provided in these
proposed regulations.
3. Impact of the Rule
The proposed regulations will allow
taxpayers to plan investments and
transactions based on the ability to
claim the section 45Q credit. The
increased use of the section 45Q credit
may lead to increased investment in
infrastructure to transport carbon
dioxide, and increased development of
carbon capture technologies. In
addition, the increased use of the
section 45Q credit will incentivize the
development of technologies for
utilization of carbon oxide. The
recordkeeping and reporting
requirements will increase for taxpayers
that claim the section 45Q credit. This
includes costs associated with the
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
taxpayer filing the Form 8933, as well
as required election statements and
maintaining records to substantiate
carbon capture of carbon oxide, disposal
in secure geological storage, use as a
tertiary injectant in a qualified
enhanced oil or natural gas recovery
project and disposal in secure geological
storage, or utilization. Each taxpayer
will be required to file a separate Form
8933 for each year that a section 45Q
credit is claimed or that an election is
made with respect to a section 45Q
credit. Although the Treasury
Department and the IRS do not have
sufficient data to determine precisely
the likely extent of the increased costs
of compliance, the estimated burden of
complying with the recordkeeping and
reporting requirements are described in
the Paperwork Reduction Act section of
the preamble.
4. Alternatives Considered
As described in more detail in the
Regulatory Impact Analysis of this
preamble, the Treasury Department and
the IRS considered alternatives to the
proposed regulations. For example, in
providing rules related to how to
demonstrate secure geological storage in
the case of tertiary injection and
disposal through secure geological
storage, the Treasury Department and
the IRS considered whether to (i)
require compliance with subpart RR, (ii)
allow use of subpart RR or CSA/ANSI
ISO 27916:19, or (iii) other alternatives
to subpart RR including use of state
programs. Commenters to Notice 2019–
32, 2019–21 I.R.B. 1187, consistently
recommended CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19
as a potential alternative to subpart RR.
The Treasury Department and the IRS,
in consultation with the DOE, the EPA
and the Interior Department, agreed
that, in the case of tertiary injection and
disposal through secure geological
storage, allowing the use of subpart RR
or CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 would
sufficiently demonstrate secure
geological storage for purposes of the
statutory requirement, without creating
or imposing undue burdens on
taxpayers.
5. Duplicative, Overlapping, or
Conflicting Federal Rules
The proposed rule would not
duplicate, overlap, or conflict with any
relevant Federal rules. As discussed
above, the proposed rule would merely
provide procedures and definitions to
allow taxpayers to claim the section 45Q
credit. The Treasury Department and
the IRS invite input from interested
members of the public about identifying
and avoiding overlapping, duplicative,
or conflicting requirements.
PO 00000
Frm 00016
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
Comments and Requests for a Public
Hearing
Before these proposed regulations are
adopted as final regulations,
consideration will be given to any
comments that are submitted timely to
the IRS as prescribed in this preamble
under the ADDRESSES heading. The
Treasury Department and the IRS
request comments on all aspects of the
proposed regulations. Specifically, in
section 4 of the Summary of Comments
and Explanation of Provisions, the
Treasury Department and the IRS
request specific comments on how to
achieve consistency in boundaries and
baselines so that similarly situated
taxpayers will be treated consistently.
The Treasury Department and the IRS
also request specific comments
regarding the definition of commercial
markets and standards for Lifecycle
Analysis. Additionally, in section 5 of
the Summary of Comments and
Explanation of Provisions, the Treasury
Department and the IRS request specific
comments on how to apply the
recapture provisions to section 45Q
credits that are carried forward to future
taxable years due to insuffificent income
tax liability in the current taxable year.
Any electronic comments submitted,
and to the extent practicable any paper
comments submitted, will be made
available at www.regulations.gov or
upon request. A public hearing will be
scheduled if requested in writing by any
person who timely submits electronic or
written comments as prescribed in this
preamble under the ‘‘DATES’’ heading.
Requests for a public hearing are also
encouraged to be made electronically. If
a public hearing is scheduled, notice of
the date and time for the public hearing
will be published in the Federal
Register. Announcement 2020–4, 2020–
17 IRB 1, provides that until further
notice, public hearings conducted by
the IRS will be held telephonically. Any
telephonic hearing will be made
accessible to people with disabilities.
IV. Unfunded Mandates Reform Act
Section 202 of the Unfunded
Mandates Reform Act of 1995 requires
that agencies assess anticipated costs
and benefits and take certain other
actions before issuing a final rule that
includes any Federal mandate that may
result in expenditures in any one year
by a state, local, or tribal government, in
the aggregate, or by the private sector, of
$100 million in 1995 dollars, updated
annually for inflation. In 2018, that
threshold is approximately $150
million. This rule does not include any
Federal mandate that may result in
expenditures by state, local, or tribal
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
governments, or by the private sector in
excess of that threshold.
V. Executive Order 13132: Federalism
Executive Order 13132 (entitled
Federalism) prohibits an agency (to the
extent practicable and permitted by law)
from promulgating any regulation that
has federalism implications, unless the
agency meets the consultation and
funding requirements of section 6 of the
Executive Order, if the rule either
imposes substantial, direct compliance
costs on state and local governments,
and is not required by statute, or
preempts state law. This proposed rule
does not have federalism implications
and does not impose substantial direct
compliance costs on state and local
governments or preempt state law
within the meaning of the Executive
Order.
Drafting Information
The principal author of the proposed
regulations is Maggie Stehn of the Office
of Associate Chief Counsel
(Passthroughs & Special Industries).
However, other personnel from the
Treasury Department and the IRS
participated in the development of the
proposed regulations.
List of Subjects
26 CFR Part 1
Income taxes, Reporting and
recordkeeping requirements.
Proposed Amendments to the
Regulations
Accordingly, 26 CFR part 1 is
proposed to be amended as follows:
PART 1—INCOME TAXES
Paragraph 1. The authority citation
for part 1 is amended by adding entries
in numerical order to read in part as
follows:
■
Authority: 26 U.S.C. 7805 * * *
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
*
*
*
*
*
Section 1.45Q–1 also issued under 26
U.S.C. 45Q.
Section 1.45Q–2 also issued under 26
U.S.C. 45Q(c), (d), and (e).
Section 1.45Q–3 also issued under 26
U.S.C. 45Q(f)(2).
Section 1.45Q–4 also issued under 26
U.S.C. 45Q(f)(5).
Section 1.45Q–5 also issued under 26
U.S.C. 45Q(f)(4).
*
*
*
*
*
■ Par. 2. Sections 1.45Q–0, 1.45Q–1,
1.45Q–2, 1.45Q–3, 1.45Q–4, and 1.45Q–
5 are added to read as follows:
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
§ 1.45Q–0
Table of Contents.
This section lists the captions
contained in §§ 1.45Q–1 through 1.45Q–
5.
§ 1.45Q–1 Credit for Carbon Oxide
Sequestration.
(a) In general.
(b) Credit amount for carbon capture
equipment originally placed in service before
February 9, 2018.
(c) Credit amount for carbon capture
equipment originally placed in service on or
after February 9, 2018.
(d) Applicable dollar amount.
(1) Applicable dollar amount for any
taxable year beginning in a calendar year
after 2016 and before 2027 for qualified
carbon oxide not used as a tertiary injectant
or utilized.
(2) Applicable dollar amount for any
taxable year beginning in a calendar year
after 2026 for qualified carbon oxide not used
as a tertiary injectant or utilized.
(3) Applicable dollar amount for any
taxable year beginning in a calendar year
after 2016 and before 2027 for qualified
carbon oxide used as a tertiary injectant or
utilized.
(4) Applicable dollar amount for any
taxable year beginning in a calendar year
after 2026 for qualified carbon oxide used as
a tertiary injectant or utilized.
(e) Election to apply the $10 and $20 credit
amounts in lieu of the applicable dollar
amounts.
(f) Application of section 45Q for certain
carbon capture equipment placed in service
before February 9, 2018.
(g) Installation of additional carbon capture
equipment.
(1) Allocation of section 45Q credits for
facilities installing additional carbon capture
equipment.
(2) Additional carbon capture equipment.
(3) New carbon capture equipment.
(4) Examples.
(i) Example 1.
(ii) Example 2.
(iii) Example 3.
(h) Eligibility for the section 45Q credit.
(1) Person to whom the section 45Q credit
is attributable.
(i) Equipment placed in service before
February 9, 2018.
(ii) Equipment placed in service on or after
February 9, 2018.
(iii) Reporting.
(2) Contractually ensuring disposal,
injection, or utilization of qualified carbon
oxide.
(i) Binding written contract.
(ii) Multiple binding written contracts
permitted.
(iii) Contract provisions.
(iv) Reporting of contract information.
(v) Relationship with election to allow
section 45Q credit.
(3) Election to allow the section 45Q credit
to another taxpayer.
(i) Example.
(ii) Time and manner of making election.
(iii) Annual election.
(iv) Required information.
(v) Requirements for credit claimant.
(i) Applicability date.
PO 00000
Frm 00017
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
34065
§ 1.45Q–2 Definitions for Purposes of
§§ 1.45Q–1 through 1.45Q–5.
(a) Qualified carbon oxide.
(b) Recycled carbon oxide.
(c) Carbon capture equipment.
(1) Use of carbon capture equipment.
(2) Carbon capture equipment components.
(3) Excluded components.
(i) In general.
(ii) Calculation.
(iii) Consequences.
(d) Industrial facility.
(1) Exclusion.
(2) Industrial source.
(3) Manufacturing process.
(4) Example.
(e) Electricity generating facility.
(f) Direct air capture facility.
(g) Qualified facility.
(1) Emissions and capture requirements.
(2) Examples.
(i) Example 1.
(ii) Example 2.
(iii) Example 3.
(3) Annualization of first-year qualified
carbon oxide emission and capture amounts.
(4) Election for applicable facilities.
(i) Applicable facility.
(ii) Time and manner of making election.
(iii) Retroactive credit revocations.
(5) Retrofitted qualified facility or carbon
capture equipment (80/20 Rule).
(h) Qualified enhanced oil or natural gas
recovery project.
(1) Application of §§ 1.43–2 and 1.43–3.
(2) Required certification.
(3) Natural gas.
(4) Timely filing of petroleum engineer’s
certification.
(5) Carbon oxide injected in oil reservoirs.
(6) Tertiary injectant.
(i) Section 45Q credit.
(j) Applicability date.
§ 1.45Q–3 Secure Geological Storage.
(a) In general.
(b) Requirements for secure geological
storage.
(c) Documentation.
(d) Certification.
(e) Failure to submit complete
documentation or certification.
(f) Applicability date.
§ 1.45Q–4 Utilization of Qualified Carbon
Oxide.
(a) In general.
(b) Measurement.
(c) Lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions and
lifecycle analysis.
(1) In general.
(2) Measurement.
(3) Approval of the LCA.
(4) [Reserved]
(d)–(e) [Reserved]
(f) Applicability date.
§ 1.45Q–5 Recapture of Credit.
(a) Recapture event.
(b) Ceases to be captured, disposed of, or
used as a tertiary injectant.
(c) Leaked amount of qualified carbon
oxide.
(d) Recaptured qualified carbon oxide.
(e) Recapture amount.
(f) Recapture period.
(g) Application of recapture.
(1) In general.
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
34066
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
(2) Calculation.
(3) Multiple units.
(4) Multiple taxpayers.
(5) Reporting.
(6) Examples.
(i) Example 1.
(ii) Example 2.
(iii) Example 3.
(iv) Example 4.
(v) Example 5.
(vi) Example 6.
(h) Recapture in the event of intentional
removal from storage.
(i) Limited exceptions.
(j) Applicability date.
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
§ 1.45Q–1 Credit for Carbon Oxide
Sequestration.
(a) In general. For purposes of section
38 of the Internal Revenue Code (Code),
the carbon oxide sequestration credit is
determined under section 45Q of the
Code and this section. Generally, the
amount of the section 45Q credit and
the party that is eligible to claim the
credit depend on whether the taxpayer
captures qualified carbon oxide using
carbon capture equipment originally
placed in service at a qualified facility
before February 9, 2018, or on or after
February 9, 2018, and whether the
taxpayer disposes of the qualified
carbon oxide in secure geological
storage without using it as a tertiary
injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or
natural gas recovery project (disposal),
uses it as a tertiary injectant in a
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas
recovery project and disposes of it in
secure geological storage (injection), or
utilizes it in a manner described in
section 45Q(f)(5) and § 1.45Q–4
(utilization). The section 45Q credit
applies only with respect to qualified
carbon oxide the capture and disposal,
injection, or utilization of which is
within the United States (within the
meaning of section 638(1) of the Code)
or a possession of the United States
(within the meaning of section 638(2)).
(b) Credit amount for carbon capture
equipment originally placed in service
before February 9, 2018. For carbon
capture equipment originally placed in
service at a qualified facility before
February 9, 2018, the amount of credit
determined under section 45Q(a) and
this section is the sum of—
(1) $20 per metric ton of qualified
carbon oxide that is—
(i) Captured by the taxpayer at the
qualified facility and disposed of by the
taxpayer in secure geological storage,
and
(ii) Not used by the taxpayer as a
tertiary injectant in a qualified
enhanced oil or natural gas recovery
project or utilized by the taxpayer in a
manner described in section 45Q(f)(5)
and § 1.45Q–4, and
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
(2) $10 per metric ton of qualified
carbon oxide that is—
(i) Captured by the taxpayer at the
qualified facility and used by the
taxpayer as a tertiary injectant in a
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas
recovery project, and disposed of by the
taxpayer in secure geological storage, or
(ii) Captured by the taxpayer at the
qualified facility and utilized by the
taxpayer in a manner described in
section 45Q(f)(5) and § 1.45Q–4.
(3) Inflation Adjustment. In the case
of any taxable year beginning in a
calendar year after 2009, there is
substituted for each dollar amount
contained in paragraphs (b)(1) and (b)(2)
of this section an amount equal to the
product of—
(i) Such dollar amount, multiplied by
(ii) The inflation adjustment factor for
such calendar year determined under
section 43(b)(3)(B) for such calendar
year, determined by substituting ‘‘2008’’
for ‘‘1990.’’
(c) Credit amount for carbon capture
equipment originally placed in service
on or after February 9, 2018. For carbon
capture equipment originally placed in
service at a qualified facility on or after
February 9, 2018, the amount of credit
determined under sections 45Q(a)(3)
and (4) and this section is the sum of—
(1) The applicable dollar amount (as
determined under paragraphs (d)(1) and
(d)(2) of this section) per metric ton of
qualified carbon oxide that is captured
during the 12-year period beginning on
the date the equipment was originally
placed in service, and is—
(i) Disposed of by the taxpayer in
secure geological storage, and
(ii) Not used by the taxpayer as a
tertiary injectant in a qualified
enhanced oil or natural gas recovery
project or utilized by the taxpayer in a
manner described in sections 45Q(f)(5)
and § 1.45Q–4; and
(2) The applicable dollar amount (as
determined under paragraphs (d)(3) and
(d)(4) of this section) per metric ton of
qualified carbon oxide that is captured
during the 12-year period beginning on
the date the equipment as originally
placed in service and is—
(i) Used by the taxpayer as a tertiary
injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or
natural gas recovery project and
disposed of by the taxpayer in secure
geological storage, or
(ii) Utilized by the taxpayer in a
manner described in sections 45Q(f)(5)
and § 1.45Q–4.
(d) Applicable dollar amount. In
general, the applicable dollar amount
depends on whether section 45Q(a)(3)
and paragraph (c)(1) of this section
applies or section 45Q(a)(4) and
paragraph (c)(2) of this section applies,
PO 00000
Frm 00018
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
and whether the taxable year begins in
a calendar year after 2016 and before
2027.
(1) Applicable dollar amount for any
taxable year beginning in a calendar
year after 2016 and before 2027 for
qualified carbon oxide not used as a
tertiary injectant or utilized. For
purposes of section 45Q(a)(3) and
paragraph (c)(1) of this section, the
applicable dollar amount for each
taxable year beginning in a calendar
year after 2016 and before 2027 is:
Year
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
2025
2026
......................................
......................................
......................................
......................................
......................................
......................................
......................................
......................................
......................................
......................................
Applicable
dollar amount
$22.66
25.70
28.74
31.77
34.81
37.85
40.89
43.92
46.96
50.00
(2) Applicable dollar amount for any
taxable year beginning in a calendar
year after 2026 for qualified carbon
oxide not used as a tertiary injectant or
utilized. For purposes of section
45Q(a)(3) and paragraph (c)(1) of this
section, the applicable dollar amount for
any taxable year beginning in any
calendar year after 2026 is an amount
equal to the product of $50 and the
inflation adjustment factor for the
calendar year determined under section
43(b)(3)(B) for the calendar year,
determined by substituting ‘‘2025’’ for
‘‘1990.’’
(3) Applicable dollar amount for any
taxable year beginning in a calendar
year after 2016 and before 2027 for
qualified carbon oxide used as a tertiary
injectant or utilized. For purposes of
section 45Q(a)(4) and paragraph (c)(2) of
this section, the applicable dollar
amount for each taxable year beginning
in a calendar year after 2016 and before
2027 is:
Year
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
2025
2026
......................................
......................................
......................................
......................................
......................................
......................................
......................................
......................................
......................................
......................................
Applicable
dollar amount
$12.83
15.29
17.76
20.22
22.68
25.15
27.61
30.07
32.54
35.00
(4) Applicable dollar amount for any
taxable year beginning in a calendar
year after 2026 for qualified carbon
oxide used as a tertiary injectant or
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
utilized. For purposes of section
45Q(a)(4) and paragraph (c)(2) of this
section, the applicable dollar amount for
any taxable year beginning in any
calendar year after 2026, is an amount
equal to the product of $35 and the
inflation adjustment factor for such
calendar year determined under section
43(b)(3)(B) for such calendar year,
determined by substituting ‘‘2025’’ for
‘‘1990.’’
(e) Election to apply the $10 and $20
credit amounts in lieu of the applicable
dollar amounts. For purposes of
determining the carbon oxide
sequestration credit under this section,
a taxpayer may elect to have the dollar
amounts applicable under section
45Q(a)(1) or (2) and paragraph (b) of this
section apply in lieu of the dollar
amounts applicable under section
45Q(a)(3) or (4) and paragraph (d) of this
section for each metric ton of qualified
carbon oxide which is captured by the
taxpayer using carbon capture
equipment which is originally placed in
service at a qualified facility on or after
February 9, 2018. The election must be
made on a Form 8933, Carbon Oxide
Sequestration Credit (or successor
forms, or pursuant to instructions and
other guidance), and applies to all
metric tons of qualified carbon oxide
captured by the taxpayer at the qualified
facility throughout the full 12-year
credit period.
(f) Application of section 45Q for
certain carbon capture equipment
placed in service before February 9,
2018. In the case of any carbon capture
equipment placed in service before
February 9, 2018, the credits under
section 45Q(a)(1) and (a)(2) and
paragraphs (b)(1) and (b)(2) of this
section apply with respect to qualified
carbon oxide captured using such
equipment before the end of the
calendar year in which the Secretary, in
consultation with the Administrator of
the Environmental Protection Agency
(EPA), certifies that, during the period
beginning after October 3, 2008, a total
of 75,000,000 metric tons of qualified
carbon oxide have been taken into
account in accordance with section
45Q(a), as in effect on February 9, 2018,
and section 45Q(a)(1) and (2). In
general, a taxpayer may not claim
credits under section 45Q(a)(1) and
(a)(2) in taxable years after the year in
which the 75,000,000 metric ton limit is
reached with respect to carbon capture
equipment placed in service before
February 9, 2018. However, see § 1.45Q–
2(g)(4) regarding the election for
applicable facilities to treat certain
carbon capture equipment as having
been placed in service on February 9,
2018.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
(g) Installation of additional carbon
capture equipment. In general, a facility
that placed carbon capture equipment in
service before February 9, 2018, is
entitled to the credit amounts for
property placed in service before
February 9, 2018, subject to the
limitations under paragraph (f) of this
section. The same facility may place
additional carbon capture equipment in
service on or after February 9, 2018. The
additional carbon capture equipment is
eligible to qualify for the section 45Q
credit amounts for equipment placed in
service on or after February 9, 2018.
(1) Allocation of section 45Q credits
for facilities installing additional carbon
capture equipment. In the case of a
qualified facility placed in service
before February 9, 2018, for which
additional carbon capture equipment is
placed in service on or after February 9,
2018, the amount of qualified carbon
oxide which is captured by the taxpayer
is equal to—
(i) For purposes of section
45Q(a)(1)(A) and (2)(A), and paragraphs
(b)(1) and (b)(2) of this section, the
lesser of the total amount of qualified
carbon oxide captured at such facility
for the taxable year, or the total amount
of the carbon dioxide capture capacity
of the carbon capture equipment in
service at such facility on February 8,
2018, and
(ii) For purposes of section
45Q(a)(3)(A) and (4)(A), and paragraphs
(c)(1) and (c)(2) of this section, an
amount (not less than zero) equal to the
excess of the total amount of qualified
carbon oxide captured at such facility
for the taxable year, over the total
amount of the carbon dioxide capture
capacity of the carbon capture
equipment in service at such facility on
February 8, 2018.
(2) Additional carbon capture
equipment. A physical modification or
equipment addition that results in an
increase in the carbon dioxide capture
capacity of existing carbon capture
equipment constitutes the installation of
additional carbon capture equipment.
Merely increasing the amount of carbon
dioxide captured by existing carbon
capture equipment, even if it operated
above the carbon dioxide capture
capacity, does not constitute the
installation of additional carbon capture
equipment.
(3) New carbon capture equipment.
The cost of a physical modification or
equipment addition with a cost that
satisfies the 80/20 Rule in § 1.45Q–
2(g)(5) constitutes the installation of
new carbon capture equipment rather
than the installation of additional
carbon capture equipment.
PO 00000
Frm 00019
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
34067
(4) Examples. The following examples
illustrate the rules of this paragraph (g):
(i) Example 1. Taxpayer X owns qualifying
facility QF. In 2017, X placed in service three
units of carbon capture equipment—CC1,
CC2, and CC3—to capture carbon dioxide
emitted by QF. Each of CC1, CC2, and CC3
are capable of capturing 50,000 metric tons
of carbon dioxide. In 2017, X enters into a
binding written contract with Y to provide
100,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide
annually for Y to dispose of in secure
geological storage. X operates CC1 and CC2
to capture carbon dioxide pursuant to the
binding written contract with Y, leaving CC3
idle. In 2020, X enters into a binding written
contract with Z to provide 50,000 metric tons
of carbon dioxide annually for Z to dispose
of in secure geological storage. X operates
CC3 to capture carbon dioxide pursuant to
the binding written contract with Z. CC3 is
not additional carbon capture equipment
under § 1.45Q–1(g)(2). As a result, any
section 45Q credits attributable to the carbon
dioxide captured by CC3 and disposed of by
Z are calculated under section 45Q(a)(1) and
§ 1.45Q–1(b)(1), and are subject to the
75,000,000 metric ton limitation described in
section 45Q(g) and § 1.45Q–1(f).
(ii) Example 2. Assume the same facts as
in Example 1, except that in 2019, X makes
a physical modification to upgrade CC3 that
results in the ability of CC3 to capture
100,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide. The
physical modification to upgrade CC3 does
not satisfy the 80/20 Rule in § 1.45Q–2(g)(5).
In 2020 X enters into a binding written
contract with Z to provide 100,000 metric
tons of carbon dioxide annually for Z to
dispose of in secure geological storage. X
operates CC3 to capture carbon dioxide
pursuant to the binding written contract with
Z. Because the carbon dioxide capture
capacity of CC3 was 50,000 metric tons of
carbon dioxide before the physical
modification and 100,000 metric tons of
carbon dioxide after the physical
modification, the physical modification to
upgrade CC3 is considered the installation of
additional carbon capture equipment under
§ 1.45Q–1(g)(2). As a result, any section 45Q
credits attributable to the first 50,000 metric
tons of carbon dioxide captured by CC3 and
disposed of by Z are calculated under section
45Q(a)(1) and § 1.45Q–1(b)(1), and are subject
to the 75,000,000 metric ton limitation
described in section 45Q(g) and § 1.45Q–1(f).
Any section 45Q credits attributable to
additional carbon dioxide captured by CC3
and disposed of by Z in excess of those first
50,000 metric tons are calculated under
section 45Q(a)(4) and § 1.45Q–1(c)(2), and are
not subject to the 75,000,000 metric ton
limitation described in section 45Q(g) and
§ 1.45Q–1(f).
(iii) Example 3. Assume the same facts as
in Example 2, except that the physical
modification to upgrade CC3 satisfies the 80/
20 Rule in § 1.45Q–2(g)(5). The physical
modification to upgrade CC3 is considered
the installation of new carbon capture
equipment under § 1.45Q–1(g)(2) and
§ 1.45Q–1(g)(3). As a result, any section 45Q
credits attributable to carbon dioxide
captured by CC3 and disposed of by Z are
calculated under section 45Q(a)(4) and
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
34068
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
§ 1.45Q–1(c)(2), and are not subject to the
75,000,000 metric ton limitation described in
section 45Q(g) and § 1.45Q–1(f).
(h) Eligibility for the section 45Q
credit. The following rules determine
who may claim the section 45Q credit.
(1) Person to whom the section 45Q
credit is attributable. In general, the
person to whom the credit is
attributable is the person who may
claim the credit. Except as provided in
§ 1.45Q–1(h)(3), the section 45Q credit
is attributable to the following
persons—
(i) Equipment placed in service before
February 9, 2018. In the case of
qualified carbon oxide captured using
carbon capture equipment that is
originally placed in service at a
qualified facility before February 9,
2018, the section 45Q credit is
attributable to the person that captures
and physically or contractually ensures
the disposal, injection, or utilization of
such qualified carbon oxide.
(ii) Equipment placed in service on or
after February 9, 2018. In the case of
qualified carbon oxide captured using
carbon capture equipment that is
originally placed in service at a
qualified facility on or after February 9,
2018, the section 45Q credit is
attributable to the person that owns the
carbon capture equipment and
physically or contractually ensures the
capture and disposal, injection, or
utilization of such qualified carbon
oxide.
(iii) Reporting. The taxpayer
described in § 1.45Q–1(h)(1) as eligible
to claim the section 45Q credit must
claim the credit on a Form 8933 (or
successor forms, or pursuant to
instructions and other guidance) with
the taxpayer’s Federal income tax return
or Form 1065 for each taxable year for
which the taxpayer is eligible. The
taxpayer must provide the name and
location of the qualified facilities at
which the qualified carbon oxide was
captured. If the taxpayer is claiming the
section 45Q credit on an amended
Federal income tax return, an amended
Form 1065, or an AAR, as applicable,
the taxpayer must state AMENDED
RETURN FOR SECTION 45Q CREDIT at
the top of the amended Federal income
tax return, the amended Form 1065, or
the AAR, as applicable. In addition, as
provided in Revenue Procedure 2020–
23, 2020–18 I.R.B. 749 (see
§ 601.601(d)(2)(i)(b) and (ii) of this
chapter), the exception applies
regarding the time to file an amended
return by a BBA partnership for the
2018 and 2019 taxable years. The
amended Federal income tax return or
the amended Form 1065 must be filed,
in no event, later than the applicable
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
period of limitations on assessment for
the taxable year for which the amended
Federal income tax return or Form 1065
is being filed. In the case of a BBA
partnership that chooses not to file an
amended Form 1065 as permitted under
Revenue Procedure 2020–23, the BBA
partnership may make a late election by
filing an AAR on or before October 15,
2021, but in no event, later than the
applicable period of limitations on
making adjustments under section 6235
for the reviewed year, as defined in
§ 301.6241–1(a)(8) of the Procedure and
Administration Regulations (26 CFR
part 301).
(2) Contractually ensuring disposal,
injection, or utilization of qualified
carbon oxide. A taxpayer is not required
to physically carry out the disposal,
injection, or utilization of qualified
carbon oxide to claim the section 45Q
credit if the taxpayer contractually
ensures in a binding written contract
that the party that physically carries out
the disposal, injection, or utilization of
the qualified carbon oxide does so in the
manner required under section 45Q and
these regulations.
(i) Binding written contract. A written
contract is binding only if it is
enforceable under State law against both
the taxpayer and the party that
physically carries out the disposal,
injection, or utilization of the qualified
carbon oxide, or a predecessor or
successor of either, and does not limit
damages to a specified amount.
(ii) Multiple binding written contracts
permitted. A taxpayer may enter into
multiple binding written contracts with
multiple parties for the disposal,
injection, or utilization of qualified
carbon oxide.
(iii) Contract provisions. Contracts
ensuring the disposal, injection, or
utilization of qualified carbon oxide—
(A) Must include commercially
reasonable terms and provide for
enforcement of the party’s obligation to
perform the disposal, injection, or
utilization of the qualified carbon oxide;
(B) May, but are not required to,
include long-term liability provisions,
indemnity provisions, penalties for
breach of contract, or liquidated
damages provisions;
(C) May, but are not required to,
include information including how
many metric tons of qualified carbon
oxide the parties agree to dispose of,
inject, or utilize;
(D) May, but are not required to,
include minimum quantities that the
parties agree to dispose of, inject, or
utilize;
(E) Must, in the case of qualified
carbon oxide that is intended to be
disposed of in secure geological storage
PO 00000
Frm 00020
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
and not used as a tertiary injectant in a
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas
recovery project, obligate the disposing
party to comply with §§ 1.45Q–3(b)(1)
and 1.45Q–3(c), and, in the case of a
recapture event, promptly inform the
capturing party of all information that is
pertinent to the recapture (i.e., location
of leak, quantity of qualified carbon
oxide leaked, dollar value of section
45Q credit attributable to leaked
qualified carbon oxide) of section 45Q
credits as listed in § 1.45Q–5;
(F) Must, for qualified carbon oxide
that is intended to be used as a tertiary
injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or
natural gas recovery, obligate the
disposing party to comply with § 1.45Q–
3(b)(1) or (2) and § 1.45Q–3(c), and in
the case of a recapture event, promptly
inform the capturing party of all
information that is pertinent to
recapture of the section 45Q credit as
listed in § 1.45Q–5; and
(G) Must, for qualified carbon oxide
that is intended to be utilized in a
manner specified in § 1.45Q–4, obligate
the utilizing party to comply with
§ 1.45Q–4.
(iv) Reporting of contract information.
The existence of each contract and the
parties involved must be reported to the
IRS annually on a Form 8933 (or
successor forms, or pursuant to
instructions and other guidance) by
each party to the contract, regardless of
the party claiming the credit. In
addition to any information stated as
required on Form 8933 (or successor
forms, or pursuant to instructions and
other guidance), the report must include
the following information—
(A) The name and taxpayer
identification number of the taxpayer to
whom the credit is attributable;
(B) The name and taxpayer
identification number of each party with
whom the taxpayer has entered into a
contract to ensure the disposal,
injection, or utilization of qualified
carbon oxide;
(C) The number of metric tons of
qualified carbon oxide each contracting
party disposes of, injects, or utilizes on
behalf of the contracting taxpayer each
taxable year for reporting to the IRS; and
(D) For contracts for the disposal of
qualified carbon oxide in secure
geological storage or the use of qualified
carbon oxide as a tertiary injectant in
enhanced oil or natural gas recovery, the
name of the operator, the field, unit, and
reservoir, location by county and state,
and identification number assigned to
the facility by the EPA’s electronic
Greenhouse Gas Reporting Tool (eGGRT ID number) for submission of the
facility’s 40 CFR part 98 annual reports.
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
(v) Relationship with election to allow
section 45Q credit. A taxpayer does not
elect to allow all or a portion of the
credit to any of the contracting parties
merely by contracting with that party to
ensure the disposal, injection, or
utilization of qualified carbon oxide.
Any election to allow all or a portion of
the credit to be claimed by another party
must be made separately pursuant to
§ 1.45Q–1(h)(3).
(3) Election to allow the section 45Q
credit to another taxpayer. The taxpayer
described in § 1.45Q–1(h)(1) as eligible
to claim section 45Q credits may elect
to allow the person that disposes of the
qualified carbon oxide, utilizes the
qualified carbon oxide, or uses the
qualified carbon oxide as a tertiary
injectant to claim the credit (credit
claimant). The taxpayer that makes the
election (electing taxpayer) may not
claim any section 45Q credits that are
allowable to a credit claimant. An
electing taxpayer may elect to allow a
credit claimant to claim the full amount
or a partial amount of section 45Q
credits arising during the taxable year.
An electing taxpayer may elect to allow
a single credit claimant or multiple
credit claimants to claim section 45Q
credits in the same taxable year. If an
electing taxpayer elects to allow
multiple credit claimants to claim
section 45Q credits, the maximum
amount of section 45Q credits allowable
to each credit claimant is proportional
to the amount of qualified carbon oxide
disposed of, utilized, or used as a
tertiary injectant by the credit claimant.
A credit claimant may receive
allowances of section 45Q credits from
multiple electing taxpayers in the same
taxable year.
(i) Example. Electing Taxpayer, E, captures
100 metric tons of qualified carbon oxide
with carbon capture equipment that was
placed in service in 2017. E contracts with
two companies, A and B, for the disposal of
the qualified carbon oxide. The capture and
disposal of the qualified carbon oxide makes
E eligible for a section 45Q credit at a rate
of $10 per metric ton, for a total section 45Q
credit of $1,000. E contractually ensures that
A will dispose of 30 metric tons of qualified
carbon oxide and that B will dispose of 70
metric tons of qualified carbon oxide. E may
make a section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election to allow
up to $300 of section 45Q credit to A and up
to $700 of section 45Q credit to B, equal to
the value of the number of metric tons each
party has contracted to ensure disposal,
multiplied by the credit value of the metric
tons disposed of.
(ii) Time and manner of making
election. The taxpayer described
§ 1.45Q–1(h)(1) makes a section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election by filing a
statement of election containing the
information described in § 1.45Q–
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
1(h)(3)(iv) with the taxpayer’s Federal
income tax return or Form 1065 for each
taxable year in which the credit arises.
The section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election must
be made in accordance with Form 8933
(or successor forms, or pursuant to
instructions and other guidance) no
later than the time prescribed by law
(including extensions) for filing the
Federal income tax return or Form 1065
for the year in which the credit arises.
The election may not be filed with an
amended Federal income tax return, an
amended Form 1065, or an AAR, as
applicable, after the prescribed date
(including extensions) for filing the
original Federal income tax return or
Form 1065 for the year, with the
exception of amended Federal income
tax returns, amended Forms 1065, or
AARs, as applicable, for any taxable
year ending after February 9, 2018, but
not for taxable years beginning after the
date of issuance of this proposed
regulation. In addition, as provided in
Revenue Procedure 2020–23, the
exception applies regarding the time to
file an amended return by a partnership
subject to the centralized partnership
audit regime enacted as part of the BBA
(BBA partnership) for the 2018 and 2019
taxable years. The amended Federal
income tax return or the amended Form
1065 must be filed, in no event, later
than the applicable period of limitations
on assessment for the taxable year for
which the amended Federal income tax
return or Form 1065 is being filed. In
the case of a BBA partnership that
chooses not to file an amended Form
1065 as permitted under Revenue
Procedure 2020–23, the BBA
partnership may make a late election by
filing an AAR on or before October 15,
2021, but in no event, later than the
applicable period of limitations on
making adjustments under section 6235
for the reviewed year, as defined in
§ 301.6241–1(a)(8) of the Procedure and
Administration Regulations (26 CFR
part 301).
(iii) Annual election. A new section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election must be made
annually.
(iv) Required information. For the
election to be valid, the election
statement of the electing taxpayer on
Form 8933 (or successor forms, or
pursuant to instructions and other
guidance) under § 1.45Q–1(h)(3)(ii)
must indicate that an election is being
made under section 45Q(f)(3)(B). The
electing taxpayer must provide each
credit claimant with a copy of the
electing taxpayer’s Form 8933 (or
successor forms, or pursuant to
instructions and other guidance). The
electing taxpayer must, in addition to
any information required on Form 8933
PO 00000
Frm 00021
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
34069
(or successor forms, or pursuant to
instructions and other guidance), set
forth the following information—
(A) The electing taxpayer’s name,
address, taxpayer identification number,
location, and e-GGRT ID number(s) (if
available) of each qualified facility
where carbon oxide was captured;
(B) The full amount of credit
attributable to the taxpayer prior to the
election;
(C) The name, address, and taxpayer
identification number of each credit
claimant, and the location and e-GGRT
ID number(s) (if available) of each
secure geological storage facility where
the qualified carbon oxide is disposed of
or injected;
(D) The dollar amount of section 45Q
credits the taxpayer is allowing each
credit claimant to claim and the
corresponding metric tons of qualified
carbon oxide; and
(E) The dollar amount of section 45Q
credits retained by the electing taxpayer
and the corresponding metric tons of
qualified carbon oxide.
(v) Requirements for section 45Q
credit claimant. For a section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election to be valid, the
section 45Q credit claimant must
include the following information on
Form 8933 (or successor forms, or
pursuant to instructions and other
guidance) with its timely filed Federal
income tax return or Form 1065
(including extensions)—
(A) The name, address, taxpayer
identification number of the credit
claimant;
(B) The name, address, and taxpayer
identification number of each taxpayer
making an election under section
45Q(f)(3)(B) to allow the credit to the
credit claimant;
(C) The location and e-GGRT ID
number(s) (if available) of each qualified
facility where carbon oxide was
captured;
(D) The location and e-GGRT ID
number(s) (if available) of each secure
geological storage facility where the
qualified carbon oxide is disposed of or
injected;
(E) The full dollar amount of section
45Q credits attributable to each electing
taxpayer prior to the election and the
corresponding metric tons of carbon
oxide;
(F) The dollar amount of section 45Q
credits that each electing taxpayer is
allowing the credit claimant to claim
and the corresponding metric tons of
carbon oxide; and
(G) A copy of the electing taxpayer’s
Form 8933 (or successor forms, or
pursuant to instructions and other
guidance).
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
34070
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
(i) Applicability date. This section
applies to taxable years beginning after
[date final regulations are published in
the Federal Register]. Taxpayers may
choose to apply this section for taxable
years beginning on or after February 9,
2018, provided the taxpayer applies this
section and §§ 1.45Q–2, 1.45Q–3,
1.45Q–4, and 1.45Q–5 in their entirety
and in a consistent manner.
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
§ 1.45Q–2 Definitions for Purposes of
§§ 1.45Q–1 through 1.45Q–5.
(a) Qualified carbon oxide. The term
qualified carbon oxide means—
(1) Any carbon dioxide which—
(i) Is captured from an industrial
source by carbon capture equipment
which is originally placed in service
before February 9, 2018,
(ii) Would otherwise be released into
the atmosphere as industrial emission of
greenhouse gas or lead to such release,
and
(iii) Is measured at the source of
capture and verified at the point of
disposal, injection, or utilization; or
(2) Any carbon dioxide or other
carbon oxide which—
(i) Is captured from an industrial
source by carbon capture equipment
which is originally placed in service on
or after February 9, 2018,
(ii) Would otherwise be released into
the atmosphere as industrial emission of
greenhouse gas or lead to such release,
and
(iii) Is measured at the source of
capture and verified at the point of
disposal, injection, or utilization; or
(3) In the case of a direct air capture
facility, any carbon dioxide that is
captured directly from the ambient air
and is measured at the source of capture
and verified at the point of disposal,
injection, or utilization.
(b) Recycled carbon oxide. The term
qualified carbon oxide includes the
initial deposit of captured carbon oxide
used as a tertiary injectant. Qualified
carbon oxide does not include carbon
oxide that is recaptured, recycled, and
re-injected as part of the enhanced oil or
natural gas recovery process.
(c) Carbon capture equipment. In
general, carbon capture equipment
includes all components of property
that are used to capture or process
carbon oxide until the carbon oxide is
transported for disposal, injection, or
utilization.
(1) Use of carbon capture equipment.
Carbon capture equipment is equipment
used for the purpose of—
(i) Separating, purifying, drying, and/
or capturing carbon oxide that would
otherwise be released into the
atmosphere from an industrial facility;
(ii) Removing carbon oxide from the
atmosphere via direct air capture; or
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
(iii) Compressing or otherwise
increasing the pressure of carbon oxide.
(2) Carbon capture equipment
components. Carbon capture equipment
generally includes components of
property necessary to compress, treat,
process, liquefy, pump or perform some
other physical action to capture
qualified carbon oxide. Components of
carbon capture equipment include, but
are not limited to, absorbers,
compressors, conditioners, cooling
towers, dehydration equipment,
dehydration systems, electrostatic
filtration, engines, filters, fixtures,
glycol contractors, heat exchangers,
liquefaction equipment, lube oil
systems, machinery, materials,
membranes, meters, monitoring
equipment, motors, mounting
equipment, pipes, power generators and
regenerators, pressure vessels and other
vessels, processing equipment,
processing plants, processing units,
pumps, reboilers, recycling units,
scrubbers, separation vessels, solvent
pumps, sorbent vessels, specially
designed flue gas ducts, support
structures, tracking equipment, treating
equipment, turbines, water wash
equipment, and other carbon oxide
related equipment.
(3) Excluded components.
Components of carbon capture
equipment do not include pipelines,
branch lines, or land and marine
transport vessels used for transporting
captured qualified carbon oxide for
disposal, injection, or utilization.
However, a gathering and distribution
system that collects carbon oxide
captured from a qualified facility or
multiple facilities that constitute a
single project (as described in section
8.01 of Notice 2020–12, 2020–11 I.R.B.
495 (see § 601.601(d)(2)(ii) of this
chapter)) for the purpose of transporting
that carbon oxide away from the
qualified facility or single project to a
pipeline used to transport carbon oxide
from multiple taxpayers or projects is
carbon capture equipment.
(d) Industrial facility. An industrial
facility is a facility that produces a
carbon oxide stream from a fuel
combustion source or fuel cell, a
manufacturing process, or a fugitive
carbon oxide emission source that,
absent capture and disposal, would
otherwise be released into the
atmosphere as industrial emission of
greenhouse gas or lead to such release.
(1) Exclusion. An industrial facility
does not include a facility that produces
carbon dioxide from carbon dioxide
production wells at natural carbon
dioxide-bearing formations or a
naturally occurring subsurface spring. A
deposit of natural gas that contains less
PO 00000
Frm 00022
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
than 10 percent carbon dioxide by
volume is not a natural carbon dioxidebearing formation. For other deposits,
whether a well is producing from a
natural carbon dioxide-bearing
formation is based on all the facts and
circumstances.
(2) Industrial source. An industrial
source is an emission of carbon oxide
from an industrial facility.
(3) Manufacturing process. A
manufacturing process is a process
involving the manufacture of products,
other than carbon oxide, that are
intended to be sold at a profit, or are
used for a commercial purpose. All facts
and circumstances with respect to the
process and products are to be taken
into account.
(4) Example. The following example
illustrates the rules of paragraph (a) and
(d)(3) of this section:
(i) A natural underground reservoir
contains a gas that is comprised of 50 percent
carbon dioxide and 50 percent methane by
volume. The raw gas is not usable without
the application of a separation process to
create two gases that are primarily carbon
dioxide and methane. Taxpayer B constructs
processing equipment that separates the raw
gas into qualified carbon oxide and methane.
The carbon dioxide is sold to a third party
for use in a qualified enhanced oil recovery
project. Some of the methane is used as fuel
to power the processing equipment. The
remainder of the methane is injected into the
reservoir. The injection will increase the
ultimate recovery of carbon dioxide. The
injected methane can be produced later from
the reservoir. At the end of the taxable year
the taxpayer has not secured a contract to sell
methane and does not have any plans to use
the methane for a commercial purpose.
Because carbon dioxide is the only product
manufactured that is intended to be sold at
a profit or used for a commercial purpose, the
separation process applied to the gases is not
a manufacturing process within the meaning
of paragraph (d)(3). The carbon dioxide
captured by the process is not qualified
carbon oxide.
(e) Electricity generating facility. An
electricity generating facility is a facility
described in section 45Q(d)(2)(A) or (B)
of the Internal Revenue Code (Code) and
is subject to depreciation under MACRS
Asset Class 49.11(Electric Utility
Hydraulic Production Plant), 49.12
(Electric Utility Nuclear Production
Plant), 49.13 (Electric Utility Steam
Production Plant), or 49.15 (Electric
Utility Combustion Turbine Production
Plant).
(f) Direct air capture facility. A direct
air capture facility means any facility
that uses carbon capture equipment to
capture carbon oxide directly from the
ambient air. It does not include any
facility that captures carbon dioxide that
is deliberately released from naturally
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
occurring subsurface springs or using
natural photosynthesis.
(g) Qualified facility. A qualified
facility means any industrial facility,
electricity generating facility, or direct
air capture facility, the construction of
which begins before January 1, 2024,
and either at which construction of
carbon capture equipment begins before
that date, or the original planning and
design for which includes installation of
carbon capture equipment, and at which
carbon capture equipment is placed in
service that captures the requisite
annual thresholds of carbon oxide
described in paragraph (g)(1) of this
section. See Notice 2020–12, 2020–11
I.R.B. 495 (see § 601.601(d)(2)(ii) of this
chapter), for guidance on the
determination of when construction has
begun on a qualified facility or on
carbon capture equipment.
(1) Emissions and capture
requirements. The facility must
capture—
(i) In the case of a facility, other than
a direct air capture facility, which emits
not more than 500,000 metric tons of
carbon oxide into the atmosphere
during the taxable year, at least 25,000
metric tons of qualified carbon oxide
during the taxable year which is utilized
in a manner consistent with section
45Q(f)(5) and § 1.45Q–4 (Section
45Q(d)(2)(A) Facility);
(ii) In the case of an electricity
generating facility which is not a
Section 45Q(d)(2)(A) Facility (Section
45Q(d)(2)(B) Facility), not less than
500,000 metric tons of qualified carbon
during the taxable year; and
(iii) In the case of a direct air capture
facility or other facility that is not a
Section 45Q(d)(2)(A) Facility or a
Section 45Q(d)(2)(B) Facility, at least
100,000 metric tons of qualified carbon
oxide during the taxable year.
(2) Examples. The following examples
illustrate the rules of paragraph (g) of
this section:
(i) Example 1. During the taxable year, an
ethanol plant emits 200,000 metric tons of
carbon dioxide. Equipment located at the
facility captures 35,000 metric tons of carbon
dioxide, all of which are utilized in a manner
consistent with section 45Q(f)(5) and
§ 1.45Q–4. The ethanol plant is a qualified
facility during the taxable year because it met
the requirement to capture at least 25,000
metric tons of qualified carbon oxide during
the taxable year which were utilized in a
manner consistent with section 45Q(f)(5) and
§ 1.45Q–4.
(ii) Example 2. During the taxable year an
electricity generating facility emits 600,000
metric tons of carbon dioxide. Equipment
located at the facility captures 50,000 metric
tons of carbon dioxide, all of which are
utilized in a manner consistent with section
45Q(f)(5) and § 1.45Q–4, and 400,000 metric
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
tons of carbon dioxide, all of which are
properly disposed of in secure geological
storage. The total amount of carbon dioxide
captured during the taxable year is 450,000
metric tons. The electricity generating facility
is not a qualified facility during the taxable
year because it did not meet the requirement
to capture not less than 500,000 metric tons
of qualified carbon during the taxable year.
(iii) Example 3. During the taxable year, a
cement manufacturing plant emits 110,000
metric tons of carbon dioxide. Equipment
located at the plant captures 10,000 metric
tons of carbon dioxide, all of which are
utilized in a manner consistent with section
45Q(f)(5) and § 1.45Q–4, and 90,000 metric
tons of carbon dioxide, all of which are
properly disposed of in secure geological
storage. The total amount of carbon dioxide
captured during the taxable year is 100,000
metric tons. The cement manufacturing plant
is a qualified facility during the taxable year
because it met the requirement to capture at
least 100,000 metric tons of qualified carbon
oxide during the taxable year.
(3) Annualization of first-year
qualified carbon oxide emission and
capture amounts—(i) In general. For the
year in which carbon capture equipment
is placed in service at a qualified
facility, annualization of the amount of
qualified carbon oxide emitted and
captured is permitted to determine if the
threshold requirements under paragraph
(g)(1) of this section are satisfied. Such
annualization may result in a facility
being deemed to satisfy the threshold
requirements under paragraph (g)(1) of
this section for the year and may permit
a taxpayer to claim section 45Q credits
even though the amount of qualified
carbon oxide emitted or captured in its
first year is less than the threshold
requirements under paragraph (g)(1) of
this section.
(ii) Calculation. Annualization is only
be available for the first year in which
the carbon capture equipment is placed
in service at the qualified facility.
Annualized amounts must be calculated
by—
(A) Determining the amount of
qualified carbon oxide emitted and
captured during the taxable year in
which the carbon capture equipment
was placed in service at the qualified
facility,
(B) Dividing the amount of qualified
carbon emitted or captured by the
number of days in the tax year
beginning with the date on which the
carbon capture equipment was placed in
service at the qualified facility and
ending with the last day of the taxable
year; and
(C) Multiplying by 365.
(iii) Consequences. If the annualized
amounts of qualified carbon oxide
emitted and captured as calculated
under this formula meet the threshold
requirements under paragraph (g)(1) of
PO 00000
Frm 00023
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
34071
this section, the threshold requirements
under paragraph (g)(1) of this section are
deemed satisfied for the taxable year in
which the carbon capture equipment
was placed in service at the qualified
facility. The taxpayer may be eligible for
a section 45Q credit for that taxable year
but must calculate the credit based on
actual amounts of qualified carbon
oxide captured and disposed of,
injected, or utilized during the taxable
year.
(4) Election for applicable facilities. In
the case of an applicable facility, for any
taxable year during which such facility
captures not less than 500,000 metric
tons of qualified carbon oxide, the
person described in section
45Q(f)(3)(A)(ii) and § 1.45Q–1(h)(1),
may elect to have such facility, and any
carbon capture equipment placed in
service at such facility, deemed as
having been placed in service on
February 9, 2018 (section 45Q(f)(6)
election).
(i) Applicable facility. An applicable
facility means a qualified facility
described in section 45Q(f)(6) and
§ 1.45Q–2(g)(4)(i) that was placed in
service before February 9, 2018, for
which no taxpayer claimed a section
45Q credit for qualified carbon oxide
captured at the facility for any taxable
year ending before February 9, 2018.
(ii) Time and manner of making
election. The taxpayer described
§ 1.45Q–1(h)(1) makes a section
45Q(f)(6) election by filing a statement
of election with the taxpayer’s income
tax return for each taxable year in which
the credit arises. The section 45Q(f)(6)
election must be made in accordance
with Form 8933 (or successor forms, or
pursuant to instructions and other
guidance) with the taxpayer’s income
tax return for the taxable year in which
the taxpayer makes the section 45Q(f)(6)
election. The statement of election must,
in addition to any information required
on Form 8933 (or successor forms, or
pursuant to instructions and other
guidance), set forth the electing
taxpayer’s name, address, taxpayer
identification number, location, and
e-GGRT ID number(s) (if available) of
the applicable facility.
(iii) Retroactive credit revocations. A
taxpayer may not file an amended
Federal income tax return, an amended
Form 1065, or an AAR, as applicable,
for any taxable year ending before
February 9, 2018, to revoke a prior claim
of section 45Q credits.
(5) Retrofitted qualified facility or
carbon capture equipment (80/20 Rule).
A qualified facility or carbon capture
equipment may qualify as originally
placed in service even if it contains
some used components of property,
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
34072
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
provided the fair market value of the
used components of property is not
more than 20 percent of the qualified
facility or carbon capture equipment’s
total value (the cost of the new
components of property plus the value
of the used components of property)
(80/20 Rule). For purposes of the 80/20
Rule, the cost of a new qualified facility
or carbon capture equipment includes
all properly capitalized costs of the new
qualified facility or carbon capture
equipment. Solely for purposes of the
80/20 Rule, properly capitalized costs of
a new qualified facility or carbon
capture equipment may, at the option of
the taxpayer, include the cost of new
equipment for a pipeline owned and
used exclusively by that taxpayer to
transport carbon oxides captured from
that taxpayer’s qualified facility that
would otherwise be emitted into the
atmosphere.
(h) Qualified enhanced oil or natural
gas recovery project. The term qualified
enhanced oil or natural gas recovery
project has the same meaning as
qualified enhanced oil recovery project
under section 43(c)(2) of the Code and
§ 1.43–2, by substituting crude oil or
natural gas for crude oil in section
43(c)(2)(A)(i) and §§ 1.43–2 and 1.43–3.
(1) Application of §§ 1.43–2 and 1.43–
3. For purposes of applying §§ 1.43–2
and 1.43–3 with respect to a qualified
enhanced oil or natural gas recovery
project, the term enhanced oil or natural
gas recovery is substituted for enhanced
oil recovery, and the term oil or natural
gas is substituted for oil.
(2) Required certification. The
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas
recovery project must be certified under
§ 1.43–3. For purposes of a natural gas
project—
(i) The petroleum engineer’s
certification under § 1.43–3(a)(3) and
the operator’s continued certification of
a project under § 1.43–3(b)(3) must
include an additional statement that the
certification is for purposes of the
section 45Q carbon oxide sequestration
tax credit;
(ii) The petroleum engineer’s
certification must be attached to a Form
8933 (or successor forms, or pursuant to
instructions and other guidance) and
filed not later than the last date
prescribed by law (including
extensions) for filing the operator’s or
designated owner’s Federal income tax
return or Form 1065 for the first taxable
year in which qualified carbon oxide is
injected into the reservoir; and
(iii) The operator’s continued
certification of a project must be
attached to a Form 8933 (or successor
forms, or pursuant to instructions and
other guidance) and filed not later than
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
the last date prescribed by law
(including extensions) for filing the
operator’s or designated owner’s Federal
income tax return or Form 1065 for
taxable years after the taxable year for
which the petroleum engineer’s
certification is filed but not after the
taxable year in which injection activity
ceases and all injection wells are
plugged and abandoned.
(3) Natural gas. Natural gas has the
same meaning as under section
613A(e)(2) of the Code.
(4) Timely filing of petroleum
engineer’s certification. For purposes of
this paragraph (h), if a section 45Q
credit is claimed on an amended
Federal income tax return, an amended
Form 1065, or an AAR, as applicable,
the petroleum engineer’s certification
will be treated as filed timely if it is
attached to a Form 8933 that is
submitted with such amended Federal
income tax return, amended Form 1065,
or AAR. With respect to a section 45Q
credit that is claimed on a timely filed
Federal income tax return or Form 1065
for a taxable year ending after February
9, 2018 and beginning before the date of
issuance of this proposed regulation, for
which the petroleum engineer’s
certification was not submitted the
petroleum engineer’s certification will
be treated as filed timely if it is attached
to an amended Form 8933 for any
taxable year ending after February 9,
2018, but not for taxable years beginning
after the date of issuance of these
proposed regulations.
(5) Carbon oxide injected in oil
reservoir. Carbon oxide that is injected
into an oil reservoir that is not a
qualified enhanced oil recovery project
under section 43(c)(2) due to
circumstances such as the first injection
of a tertiary injectant occurring before
1991, or because a petroleum engineer’s
certification was not timely filed, cannot
be treated as qualified carbon oxide,
disposed of in secure geological storage,
or utilized in a manner described in
section 45Q(f)(5). This rule will not
apply to an oil reservoir if—
(i) The reservoir permanently ceased
oil production;
(ii) The operator has obtained an EPA
UIC class VI permit; and
(iii) The operator complies with 40
CFR part 98 subpart RR.
(6) Tertiary Injectant. For purposes of
section 45Q, a tertiary injectant is
qualified carbon oxide that is injected
into and stored in a qualified enhanced
oil or natural gas recovery project and
contributes to the extraction of crude oil
or natural gas. The term tertiary
injectant has the same meaning as used
within section 193(b)(1) of the Code.
PO 00000
Frm 00024
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
(i) Section 45Q credit. The term
section 45Q credit means the carbon
oxide sequestration credit determined
under section 45Q of the Internal
Revenue Code and § 1.45Q–1.
(j) Applicability date. This section
applies to taxable years beginning after
[date final regulations are published in
the Federal Register]. Taxpayers may
choose to apply this section for taxable
years beginning on or after February 9,
2018, provided the taxpayer applies this
section and §§ 1.45Q–1, 1.45Q–3,
1.45Q–4, and 1.45Q–5 in their entirety
and in a consistent manner.
§ 1.45Q–3
Secure Geological Storage.
(a) In general. To qualify for the
section 45Q credit, a taxpayer must
either physically or contractually
dispose of captured qualified carbon
oxide in secure geological storage in the
manner provided in § 1.45Q–3(b) or
utilize qualified carbon oxide in a
manner conforming with section
45Q(f)(5) of the Internal Revenue Code
and § 1.45Q–4. Secure geological storage
includes, but is not limited to, storage
at deep saline formations, oil and gas
reservoirs, and unminable coal seams.
(b) Requirements for secure geological
storage. For purposes of the section 45Q
credit, qualified carbon oxide is
considered disposed of by the taxpayer
in secure geological storage such that
the qualified carbon oxide does not
escape into the atmosphere if the
qualified carbon oxide is—
(1) Stored, and not used as a tertiary
injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or
natural gas recovery project, in
compliance with applicable
requirements under 40 CFR part 98
subpart RR; or
(2) Used as a tertiary injectant in a
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas
recovery project and stored in
compliance with applicable
requirements under 40 CFR part 98
subpart RR, or the International
Organization for Standardization (ISO)
standards endorsed by the American
National Standards Institute (ANSI)
under CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19, Carbon
dioxide capture, transportation and
geological storage—Carbon dioxide
storage using enhanced oil recovery
(CO2-EOR).
(3) Injected into a well that complies
with applicable Underground Injection
Control regulations onshore or offshore
under submerged lands within the
territorial jurisdiction of States.
(c) Documentation. Documentation
must be filed in accordance with Form
8933 (or successor forms, or pursuant to
instructions and other guidance).
(d) Certification. For qualified
enhanced oil or natural gas recovery
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
projects in which the taxpayer reported
volumes of carbon oxide to the EPA
pursuant to 40 CFR part 98 subpart RR,
the taxpayer may self-certify the volume
of carbon oxide claimed for purposes of
section 45Q. For qualified enhanced oil
or natural gas recovery projects in
which the taxpayer determined volumes
pursuant to CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19, a
taxpayer may prepare documentation as
outlined in CSA/ANSI 27916:19
internally, but such documentation
must be provided to a qualified
independent engineer or geologist, who
then must certify that the
documentation provided, including the
mass balance calculations as well as
information regarding monitoring and
containment assurance, is accurate and
complete. Certifications must be made
annually. For any leaked amount of
qualified carbon oxide (as defined in
§ 1.45Q–5(c)) that is determined
pursuant to CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19,
the certification must also include a
statement that the quantity was
determined in accordance with sound
engineering principles. Taxpayers that
capture qualified carbon oxide giving
rise to the section 45Q credit must file
Form 8933 (or successor forms, or
pursuant to instructions and other
guidance) with a timely filed Federal
income tax return or Form 1065,
including extensions or for the purpose
of this rule, amendments to Federal
income tax returns, Forms 1065, or on
AARs, as applicable. Taxpayers that
dispose of, inject, or utilize qualified
carbon oxide must also file Form 8933
(or successor forms, or pursuant to
instructions and other guidance) with a
timely filed Federal income tax return
or Form 1065, including extensions or
for the purpose of this rule,
amendments to Federal income tax
returns, Forms 1065, or on AARs, as
applicable. If the volume of carbon
oxide certified and reported is a
negative amount, see § 1.45Q–5 for rules
regarding recapture.
(e) Failure to submit complete
documentation or certification. No
section 45Q credit is allowed for any
taxable year for which the taxpayer
(including credit claimants) has failed to
timely submit complete documentation
and certification that is required by this
regulation or Form 8933 (or successor
forms, or pursuant to instructions and
other guidance). The credit will be
allowed only for a taxable year for
which complete documentation and
certification has been timely submitted.
Certifications for each taxable year must
be submitted by the due date of the
federal income tax return or Form 1065
on which the section 45Q credit is
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
claimed, including extensions. If a
section 45Q credit is claimed on an
amended Federal income tax return, an
amended Form 1065, or an AAR, as
applicable, certifications may also be
submitted with such amended Federal
income tax return, amended Form 1065,
or AAR. If a section 45Q credit was
claimed on a timely filed Federal
income tax return or Form 1065 for a
taxable year ending after February 9,
2018, and beginning before the date of
issuance of this proposed regulation, for
which certifications were not submitted,
such certifications may be submitted
with an amended Federal income tax
return, an amended Form 1065, or an
AAR, as applicable, for the taxable year
in which the section 45Q credit was
claimed.
(f) Applicability date. This section
applies to taxable years beginning after
[date final regulations are published in
the Federal Register]. Taxpayers may
choose to apply this section for taxable
years beginning on or after February 9,
2018, provided the taxpayer applies this
section and §§ 1.45Q–1, 1.45Q–2,
1.45Q–4, and 1.45Q–5 in their entirety
and in a consistent manner.
§ 1.45Q–4
Oxide.
Utilization of Qualified Carbon
(a) In general. For purposes of this
section, utilization of qualified carbon
oxide means—
(1) The fixation of qualified carbon
oxide through photosynthesis or
chemosynthesis, such as through the
growing of algae or bacteria,
(2) The chemical conversion of such
qualified carbon oxide to a material or
chemical compound in which such
qualified carbon oxide is securely
stored, or
(3) The use of such qualified carbon
oxide for any other purpose for which
a commercial market exists (with the
exception of use as a tertiary injectant
in a qualified enhanced oil or natural
gas recovery project), as determined by
the Secretary of the Treasury or his
delegate.
(b) Measurement. For purposes of
determining the amount of qualified
carbon oxide utilized by the taxpayer
under § 1.45Q–1(b)(2)(ii) and (c)(2)(ii),
such amount is equal to the metric tons
of qualified carbon oxide which the
taxpayer demonstrates, based upon an
analysis of lifecycle greenhouse gas
emissions (LCA), were—
(1) Captured and permanently
isolated from the atmosphere (isolated),
or
(2) Displaced from being emitted into
the atmosphere through use of a process
described in paragraph (a) of this
section (displaced).
PO 00000
Frm 00025
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
34073
(c) Lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions
and lifecycle analysis—(1) In general.
For purposes of paragraph (b) of this
section, the term lifecycle greenhouse
gas emissions means the aggregate
quantity of greenhouse gas emissions
(including direct emissions and
significant indirect emissions such as
significant emissions from land use
changes) related to the full product
lifecycle, including all stages of product
and feedstock production and
distribution, from feedstock generation
or extraction through the distribution
and delivery and use of the finished
product to the ultimate consumer,
where the mass values for all
greenhouse gases are adjusted to
account for their relative global
warming potential according to Table
A–1 of 40 CFR part 98 subpart A.
(2) Measurement. The taxpayer
measures the amount of carbon oxide
captured and utilized through a
combination of direct measurement and
LCA. The measurement and written
LCA report must be performed by or
verified by an independent third-party.
The report must contain documentation
consistent with the International
Organization for Standardization (ISO)
14044:2006, ‘‘Environmental
management—Life cycle assessment—
Requirements and Guidelines,’’ as well
as a statement documenting the
qualifications of the third-party,
including proof of appropriate U.S. or
foreign professional license, and an
affidavit from the third-party stating that
it is independent from the taxpayer.
(3) Approval of the LCA. The taxpayer
must submit the written LCA report
required by paragraph (c)(1) of this
section to the IRS and the Department
of Energy (DOE). The LCA will be
subject to a technical review by the
DOE, and the IRS, in consultation with
the DOE and the Environmental
Protection Agency, will determine
whether to approve the LCA.
(4) [Reserved]
(d)–(e) [Reserved]
(f) Applicability date. This section
applies to taxable years beginning after
[date final regulations are published in
the Federal Register]. Taxpayers may
choose to apply this section for taxable
years beginning on or after February 9,
2018, provided the taxpayer applies this
section and §§ 1.45Q–1, 1.45Q–2,
1.45Q–3, and 1.45Q–5 in their entirety
and in a consistent manner.
§ 1.45Q–5
Recapture of Credit.
(a) Recapture event. A recapture event
occurs when qualified carbon oxide for
which a section 45Q credit has been
claimed ceases to be captured, disposed
of, or used as a tertiary injectant during
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
34074
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
the recapture period. Recapture events
are determined separately for each
project involving capture, disposal, or
use of qualified carbon oxide as a
tertiary injectant.
(b) Ceases to be captured, disposed of,
or used as a tertiary injectant. Qualified
carbon oxide ceases to be captured,
disposed of, or used as a tertiary
injectant if the leaked amount of
qualified carbon oxide in the taxable
year exceeds the amount of qualified
carbon oxide disposed of in secure
geological storage or used as a tertiary
injectant in that same taxable year.
(c) Leaked amount of qualified carbon
oxide. When a taxpayer, operator, or
regulatory agency determines that
qualified carbon oxide has leaked to the
atmosphere, the taxpayer must quantify
the metric tons of qualified carbon oxide
that has leaked to the atmosphere
pursuant to the requirements of 40 CFR
part 98 subpart RR or CSA/ANSI ISO
27916:19. The quantity determined
pursuant to CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19
must be certified by a qualified
independent engineer or geologist,
including a statement that the quantity
was determined in accordance with
sound engineering principles. The
Internal Revenue Service will consider
all available facts, and may consult with
the relevant regulatory agency, in
verifying the amount of qualified carbon
oxide that has leaked to the atmosphere.
That amount is the leaked amount of
qualified carbon oxide.
(d) Recaptured qualified carbon
oxide. The quantity of recaptured
qualified carbon oxide (in metric tons)
is the amount by which the leaked
amount of qualified carbon oxide
exceeds the amount of qualified carbon
oxide disposed of in secure geological
storage or used as a tertiary injectant in
the taxable year.
(e) Recapture amount. The recapture
amount is equal to the product of the
quantity of recaptured qualified carbon
oxide (in metric tons) and the
appropriate statutory credit rate.
(f) Recapture period. The recapture
period begins on the date of first
injection of qualified carbon oxide for
disposal in secure geological storage or
use as a tertiary injectant. The recapture
period ends on the earlier of five years
after the last taxable year in which the
taxpayer claimed a section 45Q credit or
the date monitoring ends under the
requirements of the standards described
in § 1.45Q–3(b)(1) or (b)(2).
(g) Application of recapture. (1) In
general. Any recapture amount must be
taken into account in the taxable year in
which it is identified and reported. If
the leaked amount of qualified carbon
oxide does not exceed the amount of
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
qualified carbon oxide disposed of in
secure geological storage or used as a
tertiary injectant in the taxable year
reported, there is no recapture amount
and no further adjustments to prior
taxable years are needed. The taxpayer
must add the recapture amount to the
amount of tax due in the taxable year in
which the recapture event occurs.
(2) Calculation. Recapture amounts
are to be calculated on a last-in-first-out
basis (LIFO), such that the leaked
amount of qualified carbon oxide that
exceeds the amount of qualified carbon
oxide disposed of in secure geological
storage or used as a tertiary injectant in
the current taxable year will be deemed
attributable first to the prior taxable
year, then to taxable year before that,
and then up to a maximum of the fifth
preceding year.
(3) Multiple Units. In the event of a
recapture event in which the leaked
qualified carbon oxide had been
captured from multiple units of carbon
capture equipment that were not under
common ownership, the recapture
amount must be allocated on a pro rata
basis among the multiple units of
carbon capture equipment. Each
taxpayer that claimed a section 45Q
credit with respect to one or more of
such units of carbon capture equipment
is responsible for adding the recapture
amount to their amount of tax due in the
taxable year in which the recapture
event occurs.
(4) Multiple Taxpayers. In the event of
a recapture event where the leaked
amount of qualified carbon oxide is
deemed attributable to qualified carbon
oxide with respect to which multiple
taxpayers claimed section 45Q credit
amounts (for example, if ownership of
the carbon capture equipment was
transferred, or if a taxpayer made an
election under section 45Q(f)(3)(B) of
the Internal Revenue Code to allow one
or more credit claimants to claim a
portion of the section 45Q credit), the
recapture amount must be allocated on
a pro rata basis among the taxpayers that
claimed the section 45Q credits with
respect to the qualified carbon oxide
that the leaked qualified carbon oxide is
deemed attributable to.
(5) Reporting. If a recapture event
occurs during a project’s recapture
period, any taxpayer that claimed a
section 45Q credit for that project must
report the following information on a
Form 8933 (or successor forms, or
pursuant to instructions and other
guidance) filed with that taxpayer’s
Federal income tax return or Form 1065
for the taxable year for which the
recapture event occurred—
(i) The recapture amount (as defined
in § 1.45Q–5(e));
PO 00000
Frm 00026
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
(ii) The quantity of leaked qualified
carbon oxide (in metric tons) (as defined
in § 1.45Q–5(c));
(iii) The statutory credit rate at which
the section 45Q credits were originally
calculated; and
(iv) A statement that describes how
the taxpayer became aware of the
recapture event, how the leaked amount
was determined, and the identity and
involvement of any regulatory agencies.
(6) Examples. The following examples
illustrate the principles of this
paragraph (g):
(i) Example 1. (A) A owns direct air
capture Facility X. No other taxpayer has
owned Facility X, and A has never allowed
another taxpayer to claim any section 45Q
credits with respect to qualified carbon oxide
captured by Facility X. Facility X captured
100,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide in each
of 2021, 2022, and 2023. All captured carbon
dioxide was sold to B for use a tertiary
injectant in a qualified enhanced oil recovery
project. B provided contractual assurance
that the carbon dioxide would be sequestered
in secure geological storage. A claimed
section 45Q credit amounts of $2,268,000 in
2021, $2,515,000 in 2022, and $2,761,000 in
2023 using the statutory rates in § 1.45Q–
1(d)(3). In 2024, A captured and sold another
100,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide to B,
which B used as a tertiary injectant in a
qualified enhanced oil recovery project. In
late 2024, B determined that 10,000 metric
tons of carbon dioxide injected during 2021
had leaked from the containment area of the
reservoir and will eventually migrate to the
atmosphere.
(B) Because the leakage determined in 2024
(10,000 metric tons) did not exceed the
amount stored in 2024 (100,000 metric tons),
a recapture event did not occur in 2024. A’s
section 45Q credit for 2024 is $2,706,300 (net
90,000 metric tons of qualified carbon oxide
captured and used as a tertiary injectant
multiplied by the statutory credit rate for
2024 of $30.07).
(ii) Example 2. (A) Assume same facts as
in Example 1. Additionally, in 2025, B
determines that 190,000 metric tons of
carbon dioxide injected in 2021 and 2022
have leaked and will eventually migrate to
the atmosphere. No injection of carbon
dioxide takes place in 2025.
(B) Because the leakage determined in 2025
(190,000 metric tons) exceeds the amount
stored in 2025 (0 metric tons), a recapture
event occurred in 2025. A’s credit for 2025
is $0 because the net amount of carbon
dioxide captured and used as a tertiary
injectant in 2025 was 0 metric tons. The 2025
recapture amount is calculated by
multiplying the 190,000 metric tons of
recaptured qualified carbon oxide by the
appropriate statutory credit rate using the
LIFO method. The first 90,000 metric tons of
recaptured qualified carbon oxide is deemed
attributable to 2024, and is recaptured at the
2024 statutory rate of $30.07 per metric ton.
The remaining 100,000 metric tons of
recaptured qualified carbon oxide are
deemed attributable to 2023. The credits
attributable to 2023 are recaptured at the
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
Federal Register / Vol. 85, No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 / Proposed Rules
2023 statutory rate of $27.61 per metric ton.
Thus, the total recapture amount is
$5,467,300, and is added to A’s tax due for
2025.
(iii) Example 3. (A) Assume the same facts
as in Example 2, except that A sells Facility
X to C on January 1, 2024. C sells 100,000
metric tons of carbon dioxide captured by
Facility X to B for use as a tertiary injectant
in a qualified enhanced oil recovery project.
Thus, C claims a section 45Q credit in 2024
of $2,706,300 (net 90,000 metric tons of
qualified carbon oxide captured and used as
a tertiary injectant multiplied by the statutory
credit rate for 2024 of $30.07).
(B) The total recapture amount in 2025 is
the same $5,467,300 as in Example 2, but is
allocated between A and C. The first 90,000
metric tons of recaptured qualified carbon
oxide are deemed attributable to 2024. The
credits that are attributable to 2024 are
recaptured at the 2024 statutory rate of
$30.07 per ton (for a recapture amount of
$2,706,300). Because C claimed that amount
of section 45Q credit in 2024, a recapture
amount of $2,706,300 is added to C’s tax due
for 2025. The remaining 100,000 metric tons
of recaptured qualified carbon oxide are
deemed attributable to 2023. The credits that
are attributable to 2023 are recaptured at the
2023 statutory rate of $27.61 per ton (for a
recapture amount of $2,761,000). Because A
claimed that amount of section 45Q credit in
2023, a recapture amount of $2,761,000 is
added to A’s tax due for 2025.
(iv) Example 4. (A) Assume the same facts
as in Example 2, except that in 2023 A made
a section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election to allow B to
claim one-half of the section 45Q credit for
2023. A and B each claimed $1,380,500 of
section 45Q credit in 2023 (50,000 metric
tons each multiplied by the 2023 statutory
rate of $27.61).
(B) The total recapture amount in 2025 is
the same $5,467,300 as in Example 2, but is
allocated among A and B. The first 90,000
metric tons of recaptured qualified carbon
oxide is deemed attributable to 2024. The
section 45Q credit amounts attributable to
2024 are recaptured at the 2024 statutory rate
of $30.07 per ton (for a recapture amount of
$2,706,300). Because A claimed that amount
of section 45Q credit in 2024, $2,706,300 is
added to A’s tax due for 2025. The remaining
100,000 metric tons of recaptured qualified
carbon oxide is deemed attributable to 2023.
The section 45Q credit amounts attributable
to 2023 are recaptured at the 2023 statutory
rate of $27.61 per ton (for a recapture amount
of $2,761,000). Because A and B each
claimed half of that amount ($1,380,500) of
section 45Q credit in 2023, $1,380,500 is
added to both A’s and B’s tax due for 2025.
Thus, a recapture amount of $4,086,800 is
added to A’s tax due for 2025, and a
recapture amount of $1,380,500 is added to
B’s tax due for 2025.
(v) Example 5. (A) Assume the same facts
as in Example 2, except that the 100,000
metric tons of carbon dioxide sold to B in
2021, 2022, 2023, and 2024 for use as a
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:47 Jun 01, 2020
Jkt 250001
tertiary injectant in a qualified enhanced oil
recovery project were captured equally
(50,000 metric tons per year) from qualified
facilities owned by J and K. Neither J nor K
made a section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election to allow
B to claim the credit.
(B) Because the leakage determined in 2024
(10,000 metric tons) did not exceed the
amount used as a tertiary injectant in 2024
(100,000 metric tons) a recapture event did
not occur in 2024. The total amount of
section 45Q credit for 2024 is $2,706,300 (net
90,000 metric tons of qualified carbon oxide
captured and used as a tertiary injectant
multiplied by the statutory credit rate for
2024 of $30.07). J and K may each claim half
of this amount of section 45Q credit
($1,353,150) in 2024.
(C) The total recapture amount in 2025 is
the same $5,467,300 as in Example 2, but is
allocated between J and K. The section 45Q
credit amounts relating to the first 90,000
metric tons of recaptured qualified carbon
oxide are deemed attributable to 2024 and are
recaptured at the 2024 statutory rate of
$30.07 per ton (for a recapture amount of
$2,706,300). Because J and K each claimed
half of that amount ($1,353,150) of section
45Q credit in 2024, $1,353,150 is added to
both J’s and K’s tax due for 2025. The section
45Q credit amounts relating to the remaining
100,000 metric tons of recaptured qualified
carbon oxide are deemed attributable to 2023
and are recaptured at the 2023 statutory rate
of $27.61 per ton (for a recapture amount of
$2,761,000). Because J and K each claimed
half of that amount ($1,380,500) of section
45Q credit in 2023, an additional $1,380,500
is added to both J’s and Ks tax due for 2025.
Thus, a total recapture amount of $2,733,650
is added to both J’s and K’s tax due for 2025.
(vi) Example 6. (A) M owns Industrial
Facility Z. No other taxpayer has ever owned
Z, and M has never allowed another taxpayer
to claim any section 45Q credits with respect
to qualified carbon oxide captured from Z. M
captured 1,000,000 metric tons of carbon
dioxide annually in each of 2017, 2018, 2019,
2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, and 2025. All
captured carbon dioxide was sold to N for
use a tertiary injectant in a qualified
enhanced oil recovery project. N provided
contractual assurance that the carbon dioxide
would be sequestered in secure geological
storage. M claimed section 45Q credit
amounts of $12,830,000 in 2017, $15,209,000
in 2018, $17,760,000 in 2019, $20,220,000 in
2020, $22,680,000 in 2021, $25,150,000 in
2022, $27,610,000 in 2023, $30,070,000 in
2024, and $32,540,000 in 2025 using the
statutory rates in § 1.45Q–1(d)(3). No
injection of carbon oxides takes place in
2026. In 2026, N determined that 6,200,000
metric tons of carbon dioxide previously
injected had leaked from the containment
area of the reservoir and will eventually
migrate to the atmosphere.
(B) Because the leakage determined in 2025
(6,200,000 metric tons) exceed the amount
stored in 2026 (0 metric tons) a recapture
event occurred in 2026. A’s credit for 2026
PO 00000
Frm 00027
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 9990
34075
is $0 because the net amount of carbon
dioxide captured and used as a tertiary
injectant in 2026 was 0 metric tons. The 2026
recapture amount is calculated by
multiplying the 6,200,000 metric tons of
recaptured qualified carbon oxide by the
appropriate statutory credit rate using the
LIFO method. The first 1,000,000 metric tons
of recaptured qualified carbon oxide is
deemed attributable to 2025, and is
recaptured at the 2025 statutory rate of
$32.54 per metric ton. The next 1,000,000
metric tons of recaptured qualified carbon
oxide is deemed attributable to 2024, and is
recaptured at the 2024 statutory rate of
$30.07 per metric ton. The next 1,000,000
metric tons of recaptured qualified carbon
oxide is deemed attributable to 2024, and is
recaptured at the 2023 statutory rate of
$27.16 per metric ton. The next 1,000,000
metric tons of recaptured qualified carbon
oxide is deemed attributable to 2022, and is
recaptured at the 2022 statutory rate of
$25.15 per metric ton. The next 1,000,000
metric tons of recaptured qualified carbon
oxide is deemed attributable to 2021, and is
recaptured at the 2021 statutory rate of
$22.68 per metric ton. The remaining
1,200,000 metric tons are not subject to
recapture because of the five-year lookback
limit in § 1.45Q–1(g)(2). Thus, the total
recapture amount is $138,050,000, and is
added to A’s tax due for 2026.
(h) Recapture in the event of
intentional removal from storage. If
qualified carbon oxide for which a
credit has been claimed is deliberately
removed from a secure geological
storage site, then a recapture event
would occur in the year in which the
qualified carbon oxide is removed from
the storage site pursuant to § 1.45Q–5(a).
(i) Limited exceptions. A recapture
event is not triggered in the event of a
loss of containment of qualified carbon
oxide resulting from actions not related
to the selection, operation, or
maintenance of the storage facility, such
as volcanic activity or terrorist attack.
(j) Applicability date. This section
applies to taxable years beginning after
[date final regulations are published in
the Federal Register]. Taxpayers may
choose to apply this section for taxable
years beginning on or after February 9,
2018, provided the taxpayer applies this
section and sections 1.45Q–1, 1.45Q–2,
1.45Q–3, and 1.45Q–4 in their entirety
and in a consistent manner.
Sunita Lough,
Deputy Commissioner for Services and
Enforcement.
[FR Doc. 2020–11907 Filed 5–29–20; 11:15 am]
BILLING CODE 4830–01–P
E:\FR\FM\02JNP3.SGM
02JNP3
Agencies
[Federal Register Volume 85, Number 106 (Tuesday, June 2, 2020)]
[Proposed Rules]
[Pages 34050-34075]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2020-11907]
[[Page 34049]]
Vol. 85
Tuesday,
No. 106
June 2, 2020
Part IV
Department of the Treasury
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Internal Revenue Service
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
26 CFR Part 1
Credit for Carbon Oxide Sequestration; Proposed Rule
Federal Register / Vol. 85 , No. 106 / Tuesday, June 2, 2020 /
Proposed Rules
[[Page 34050]]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY
Internal Revenue Service
26 CFR Part 1
[REG-112339-19]
RIN 1545-BP42
Credit for Carbon Oxide Sequestration
AGENCY: Internal Revenue Service (IRS), Treasury.
ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: This document contains proposed regulations regarding the
credit for carbon oxide sequestration under section 45Q of the Internal
Revenue Code (Code). These proposed regulations will affect persons who
physically or contractually ensure the capture and disposal of
qualified carbon oxide, use of qualified carbon oxide as a tertiary
injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project,
or utilization of qualified carbon oxide in a manner that qualifies for
the credit.
DATES: Written or electronic comments and requests for a public hearing
must be received by August 3, 2020. Requests for a public hearing must
be submitted as prescribed in the ``Comments and Requests for a Public
Hearing'' section.
ADDRESSES: Commenters are strongly encouraged to submit public comments
electronically. Submit electronic submissions via the Federal
eRulemaking Portal at www.regulations.gov (indicate IRS and REG-112339-
19) by following the online instructions for submitting comments. Once
submitted to the Federal eRulemaking Portal, comments cannot be edited
or withdrawn. The IRS expects to have limited personnel available to
process public comments that are submitted on paper through mail. Until
further notice, any comments submitted on paper will be considered to
the extent practicable. The Department of the Treasury (Treasury
Department) and the IRS will publish for public availability any
comment submitted electronically, and to the extent practicable on
paper, to its public docket.
Send paper submissions to: CC:PA:LPD:PR (REG-112339-19), Room 5203,
Internal Revenue Service, P.O. Box 7604, Ben Franklin Station,
Washington, DC 20044.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Concerning the proposed regulations,
Maggie Stehn of the Office of Associate Chief Counsel (Passthroughs &
Special Industries) at (202) 317-6853; concerning submissions of
comments and/or requests for a public hearing, Regina L. Johnson at
(202) 317-5177 (not toll-free numbers).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Background
This document contains proposed amendments to the Income Tax
Regulations (26 CFR part 1) under section 45Q of the Code (proposed
regulations).
Section 45Q was enacted on October 3, 2008, by section 115 of
Division B of the Energy Improvement and Extension Act of 2008, Public
Law 110-343, 122 Stat. 3765, 3829, to provide a credit for the
sequestration of carbon oxide. On February 17, 2009, section 45Q was
amended by section 1131 of Division B of the American Recovery and
Reinvestment Tax Act of 2009, Public Law 111-5, 123 Stat. 115, 325.
Section 45Q was further amended on December 19, 2014, by section
209(j)(1) of Division A of the Tax Increase Prevention Act of 2014,
Public Law 113-295, 128 Stat. 4010, 4030, and most recently on February
9, 2018, by section 41119 of Division D of the Bipartisan Budget Act of
2018 (BBA), Public Law 115-123, 132 Stat. 64, 162, to encourage the
construction and use of carbon capture and sequestration projects.
On May 20, 2019, the IRS published Notice 2019-32, 2019-21 I.R.B.
1187. The notice requested general comments on issues arising under
section 45Q, as well as specific comments concerning secure geological
storage, the measurement of qualified carbon oxide, the recapture of
the benefit of the credit for carbon oxide sequestration, the types of
utilization that qualify for the credit, the beginning of construction,
partnership arrangements, definitions of terms, and other issues
related to the credit. The IRS received 116 comments from industry
participants, environmental groups, and other stakeholders.
In response to comments submitted pursuant to Notice 2019-32, on
March 9, 2020, the Treasury Department and the IRS published Revenue
Procedure 2020-12, 2020-11 I.R.B. 511, and Notice 2020-12, 2020-11
I.R.B. 495. Revenue Procedure 2020-12 provides a safe harbor under
which the IRS will treat partnerships as properly allocating the
section 45Q credit in accordance with section 704(b). Notice 2020-12
provides guidance on the determination of when construction has begun
on a qualified facility or on carbon capture equipment that may be
eligible for the section 45Q credit. As requested by commenters, the
safe harbor in Revenue Procedure 2020-12 and the rules in Notice 2020-
12 are similar to those provided in prior guidance.
Pursuant to section 45Q(h), the Secretary of the Treasury or his
delegate (Secretary) may prescribe such regulations and other guidance
as may be necessary or appropriate to carry out section 45Q, including
regulations or other guidance to (i) ensure proper allocation under
section 45Q(a) for qualified carbon oxide captured by a taxpayer during
the taxable year ending after the date of the enactment of the BBA, and
(ii) determine whether a facility satisfies the requirements under
section 45Q(d)(1).
Summary of Comments and Explanation of Provisions
1. General Credit Provisions
a. Credit Amount in General
Section 45Q(a)(1) allows a credit of $20 per metric ton of
qualified carbon oxide (i) captured by the taxpayer using carbon
capture equipment which is originally placed in service at a qualified
facility before the date of the enactment of the BBA (February 9,
2018); (ii) disposed of by the taxpayer in secure geological storage;
and (iii) neither used by the taxpayer as a tertiary injectant in a
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project nor utilized in
a manner described in section 45Q(f)(5).
Section 45Q(a)(2) allows a credit of $10 per metric ton of
qualified carbon oxide (i) captured by the taxpayer using carbon
capture equipment which is originally placed in service at a qualified
facility before February 9, 2018; and (ii) either (A) used by the
taxpayer as a tertiary injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or natural
gas recovery project and disposed of by the taxpayer in secure
geological storage; or (B) utilized by the taxpayer in a manner
described in section 45Q(f)(5).
Section 45Q(a)(3) allows a credit of the applicable dollar amount
(as determined under section 45Q(b)(1)) per metric ton of qualified
carbon oxide (i) captured by the taxpayer using carbon capture
equipment which is originally placed in service at a qualified facility
on or after February 9, 2018, during the 12-year period beginning on
the date the equipment was originally placed in service; (ii) disposed
of by the taxpayer in secure geological storage; and (iii) neither used
by the taxpayer as a tertiary injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or
natural gas recovery project nor utilized in a manner described in
section 45Q(f)(5).
Section 45Q(a)(4) allows a credit of the applicable dollar amount
(as determined under section 45Q(b)(1)) per
[[Page 34051]]
metric ton of qualified carbon oxide (i) captured by the taxpayer using
carbon capture equipment which is originally placed in service at a
qualified facility on or after February 9, 2018, during the 12-year
period beginning on the date the equipment was originally placed in
service; and (ii) either (A) used by the taxpayer as a tertiary
injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project
and disposed of by the taxpayer in secure geological storage, or (B)
utilized by the taxpayer in a manner described in section 45Q(f)(5).
Section 45Q(b)(1)(A)(i)(I) and (ii)(I) provides that the applicable
dollar amount for activities under section 45Q(a)(3) for any taxable
year beginning in a calendar year (1) after 2016 and before 2027 is an
amount equal to the dollar amount established by linear interpolation
between $22.66 and $50 for each calendar year during such period, and
(2) after 2026 is an amount equal to the product of $50 and the
inflation adjustment factor for such calendar year determined under
section 43(b)(3)(B) for such calendar year, determined by substituting
``2025'' for ``1990.''
Section 45Q(b)(1)(A)(i)(II) and (ii)(II) provides that the
applicable dollar amount for activities under section 45Q(d)(4) for any
taxable year beginning in a calendar year (1) after 2016 and before
2027 is an amount equal to the dollar amount established by linear
interpolation between $12.83 and $35 for each calendar year during such
period, and (2) after 2026 is an amount equal to the product of $35 and
the inflation adjustment factor for such calendar year determined under
section 43(b)(3)(B) for such calendar year, determined by substituting
``2025'' for ``1990.'' Section 45Q(b)(1)(B) provides that the
applicable dollar amount determined under section 45Q(b)(1)(A) is
rounded to the nearest cent.
Section 45Q(b)(2) provides a method to compute the amount of
qualified carbon oxide captured at a qualified facility that was placed
in service before February 9, 2018, and for which additional carbon
capture equipment is placed in service on or after February 9, 2018.
For purposes of section 45Q(a)(1)(A) and (2)(A), the amount of
qualified carbon oxide that is captured by the taxpayer is equal to the
lesser of (i) the total amount of qualified carbon oxide captured at
such facility for the taxable year, or (ii) the total amount of the
carbon dioxide capture capacity of the carbon capture equipment in
service at such facility on February 8, 2018 (the day before the date
of enactment of the BBA). For purposes of section 45Q(a)(3)(A) and
(4)(A), the amount of qualified carbon oxide captured by the taxpayer
is an amount (not less than zero) equal to the excess of (i) the total
amount of qualified carbon oxide captured at such facility for the
taxable year, over (ii) the total amount of the carbon dioxide capture
capacity of the carbon capture equipment in service at such facility on
February 8, 2018. These proposed regulations explain the difference
between a physical modification or equipment addition that results in
an increase in the carbon dioxide capture capacity of existing carbon
capture equipment, which will be treated as newly placed in service,
and a mere increase in the amount of carbon dioxide captured by
existing carbon capture equipment, which will not be treated as newly
placed in service.
Pursuant to section 45Q(b)(3), a taxpayer may elect to have the
dollar amounts applicable under section 45Q(a)(1) or (2) apply in lieu
of the dollar amounts applicable under section 45Q(a)(3) or (4) for
each metric ton of qualified carbon oxide which is captured by the
taxpayer using carbon capture equipment which is originally placed in
service at a qualified facility on or after February 9, 2018. These
proposed regulations provide that the election will apply to all metric
tons of qualified carbon oxide captured by the taxpayer at the
qualified facility for the full 12-year credit period.
Section 45Q(f)(6)(A) provides that for any taxable year in which an
applicable facility captures not less than 500,000 metric tons of
qualified carbon oxide, the person described in section
45Q(f)(3)(A)(ii) may elect to have such applicable facility, and any
carbon capture equipment placed in service at such applicable facility,
deemed as having been placed in service on February 9, 2018. The term
``applicable facility'' means a qualified facility (i) which was placed
in service before February 9, 2018, and (ii) for which no taxpayer
claimed a section 45Q credit for any taxable year ending before
February 9, 2018.
Section 45Q(f)(7) provides that in the case of any taxable year
beginning in a calendar year after 2009, there is substituted for each
dollar amount contained in section 45Q(a)(1) and (2) an amount equal to
the product of (i) such dollar amount, multiplied by (ii) the inflation
adjustment factor for such calendar year determined under section
43(b)(3)(B) for such calendar year, determined by substituting ``2008''
for ``1990.''
Section 45Q(g) provides that in the case of any carbon capture
equipment placed in service before February 9, 2018, the section 45Q
credit applies with respect to qualified carbon oxide captured using
such equipment before the end of the calendar year in which the
Secretary, in consultation with the Administrator of the Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA), certifies that a total of 75,000,000 metric
tons of qualified carbon oxide have been taken into account in
accordance with former section 45Q(a) (as in effect before February 9,
2018) and sections 45Q(a)(1) and (2).
These proposed regulations reflect the statutory provisions
relating to credit amounts.
b. Contractually Ensuring Capture and Disposal, Injection, or
Utilization of Qualified Carbon Oxide
Section 45Q(f)(3)(A)(i) provides that in the case of qualified
carbon oxide captured using carbon capture equipment which is
originally placed in service at a qualified facility before February 9,
2018, the section 45Q credit is attributable to the person that
captures and physically or contractually ensures the disposal through
secure geological storage (referred to as disposal), use for tertiary
injection and disposal through secure geological storage (referred to
as injection) or utilization in a manner consistent with section
45Q(f)(5) (referred to as utilization).
Section 45Q(f)(3)(A)(ii) provides that in the case of qualified
carbon oxide captured using carbon capture equipment which is
originally placed in service at a qualified facility on or after
February 9, 2018, the section 45Q credit is attributable to the person
that owns the carbon capture equipment and physically or contractually
ensures the capture and disposal, injection, or utilization of such
qualified carbon oxide.
Commenters requested that the Treasury Department and the IRS
clarify which contract provisions are necessary to contractually ensure
the capture and disposal, injection, or utilization of qualified carbon
oxide. Several commenters requested broad guidance on commercially
reasonable terms rather than specifying exact language. One commenter
requested guidance regarding the assurance of capture, remedies,
guarantees, and the prevention of leakage.
In response, the proposed regulations provide a framework for the
types of contracts, terms, and reporting requirements that will
demonstrate the contractual assurance of the capture and disposal,
injection, or utilization of qualified carbon oxide. The proposed
regulations provide that a taxpayer may
[[Page 34052]]
enter into multiple contracts with multiple parties for the disposal,
injection, or utilization of qualified carbon oxide. For example, a
taxpayer that captures qualified carbon oxide may contract with one
party to dispose of a portion of its captured qualified carbon oxide in
a deep saline formation, with another party to use another portion of
its captured qualified carbon oxide as a tertiary injectant in multiple
enhanced oil recovery (EOR) sites, and with several parties to utilize
the remaining portion of its captured qualified carbon oxide. The
existence of each contract and the parties involved must be reported to
the IRS on an annual basis on Form 8933, Carbon Oxide Sequestration
Credit (or successor forms, or pursuant to instructions and other
guidance). For contracts for the disposal of carbon oxide or use as a
tertiary injectant in enhanced oil or natural gas recovery, the
following information must be included: Identifying information (name
of operator, field, unit and reservoir), the location (county and
state) and the identification number assigned to the facility by the
EPA's electronic Greenhouse Gas Reporting Tool (e-GGRT ID number). The
e-GGRT ID number will allow the IRS to reconcile information with data
reported to the EPA's Greenhouse Gas Reporting Program (GHGRP) and
otherwise receive technical assistance from the EPA.
The proposed regulations require taxpayers to contractually ensure
the disposal, injection, or utilization of qualified carbon oxide in a
binding written contract that includes commercially reasonable terms
that provides for enforcement. The proposed regulations provide that
taxpayers may include information regarding how much carbon oxide the
parties agree to dispose of, inject, or utilize in their contracts.
Contracts may also include various other specific provisions relating
to enforcement, such as long-term liability provisions, indemnity
provisions, or penalties for breach of contract or liquidated damages.
While the proposed regulations require that the contract include a
mechanism for enforcement, no specific enforcement-related provision,
or other particular kind of enforcement provision, are mandated by
these proposed regulations. This is consistent with allowing
contracting parties to tailor their agreements to a wide variety of
business needs and circumstances.
Under the proposed regulations, a taxpayer does not elect to allow
all or a portion of the section 45Q credit to any of the contracting
parties merely by contracting with that party to ensure the disposal,
injection, or utilization of qualified carbon oxide. Any election to
allow all or a portion of the credit to another taxpayer must be made
separately in the manner provided in these proposed regulations.
c. Election To Allow the Credit to Another Taxpayer
Section 45Q(f)(3)(B) provides that a person that is entitled to
claim the credit under section 45Q(f)(3)(A)(i) or section
45Q(f)(3)(A)(ii) may elect to allow the person that disposes of the
qualified carbon oxide, utilizes the qualified carbon oxide, or uses
the qualified carbon oxide as a tertiary injectant to claim the credit
(section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election).
Commenters requested guidance regarding the section 45Q(f)(3)(B)
election. Commenters generally sought to maximize the ability of the
taxpayer to whom the section 45Q credit is attributable (electing
taxpayer) to make the section 45Q credit allowable to one or more other
taxpayers (credit claimants) pursuant to the section 45Q(f)(3)(B)
election. Commenters also generally requested that guidance provide
that section 45Q(f)(3)(B) elections may be made on an annual basis. One
commenter requested that guidance provide for a broader range of
permissible credit claimants, including an owner, operator, service
company, supplier, partner, or tax equity or other project finance
participant.
One commenter suggested that the section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election
should be made in the taxable year that the qualified carbon oxide is
disposed of, utilized, or used as a tertiary injectant. The commenter
recommended that the election procedures follow the procedures for
making a section 338(h)(10) election. Further, commenters suggested
that Forms 8933 should be filed by all parties to the section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election with their respective tax returns for the taxable
year in which the qualifying activity is completed.
Other commenters suggested that a taxpayer should make a section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election for a taxable year by attaching a statement to a
timely filed income tax return (including extensions) for the taxable
year. Further, commenters suggested that a taxpayer should be permitted
to make a section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election for a portion of the section
45Q credit. The portion allowed to a credit claimant would be specified
in the electing taxpayer's annual election as a percentage of the total
credit claimed.
One commenter noted that when a taxpayer makes a section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election, the electing taxpayer should no longer claim the
section 45Q credit subject to the election. To ensure compliance with
this rule, the commenter suggested that the guidance and the relevant
tax forms (i.e., Form 8933) require coordination between the electing
taxpayer and the credit claimant. For example, the credit claimant
could be required to include a copy of the electing taxpayer's section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election to allow the credit.
In response to these comments, the proposed regulations provide
guidance regarding who may make a section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election and the
time and manner for making a section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election. The
proposed regulations also provide that section 45Q(f)(3)(B) elections
must be made on an annual basis no later than the time prescribed by
law (including extensions) for filing the Federal income tax return or
Form 1065 and may not be made on an amended Federal income tax return.
However, a section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election may be made on an amended
Federal income tax return, an amended Form 1065 or an administrative
adjustment request under section 6227 of the Code (AAR), for any
taxable year ending after February 9, 2018, but not for taxable years
beginning after June 2, 2020.
The proposed regulations also set forth information to be provided
as part of a section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election, requiring both an electing
taxpayer and a credit claimant to include a Form 8933 (or successor
forms, or pursuant to instructions and other guidance) with its timely
filed Federal income tax return or Form 1065, U.S. Return of
Partnership Income (including extensions) as applicable. An electing
taxpayer must provide each credit claimant with a copy of the electing
taxpayer's Form 8933, and each credit claimant must attach that copy of
the electing taxpayer's Form 8933 to its own Form 8933.
The proposed regulations further provide that section 45Q(f)(3)(B)
elections may be made for all or a portion of the available section 45Q
credit and may be made for a single or multiple credit claimants. If an
electing taxpayer elects to allow multiple credit claimants to claim
section 45Q credits, the proposed regulations provide that the maximum
amount of section 45Q credits allowable to each credit claimant is
proportional to the amount of qualified carbon oxide disposed of,
utilized, or used as a tertiary injectant by the credit claimant. In
addition, as provided in Revenue Procedure 2020-23, 2020-18 I.R.B.1
(April 27, 2020), the exception applies regarding the time to
[[Page 34053]]
file an amended return by a partnership subject to the centralized
partnership audit regime enacted as part of the BBA (BBA partnership)
for the 2018 and 2019 taxable years. The amended Federal income tax
return or the amended Form 1065 must be filed, in no event, later than
the applicable period of limitations on assessment for the taxable year
for which the amended Federal income tax return or Form 1065 is being
filed. In the case of a BBA partnership that chooses not to file an
amended Form 1065 as permitted under Revenue Procedure 2020-23, the BBA
partnership may make a late election by filing an AAR on or before
October 15, 2021, but in no event, later than the applicable period of
limitations on making adjustments under section 6235 for the reviewed
year, as defined in Sec. 301.6241-1(a)(8) of the Procedure and
Administration Regulations (26 CFR part 301).
d. Amended Returns
Taxpayers may claim section 45Q credits on an amended Federal
income tax return, an amended Form 1065, or an AAR, as applicable, for
taxable years beginning on or after February 9, 2018, provided that the
requirements described in the proposed regulations are satisfied. In
addition, as provided in Revenue Procedure 2020-23, the exception
applies regarding the time to file an amended return by a BBA
partnership for the 2018 and 2019 taxable years. The amended Federal
income tax return or the amended Form 1065 must be filed, in no event,
later than the applicable period of limitations on assessment for the
taxable year for which the amended Federal income tax return or Form
1065 is being filed. In the case of a BBA partnership that chooses not
to file an amended Form 1065 as permitted under Revenue Procedure 2020-
23, the BBA partnership may make a late election by filing an AAR on or
before October 15, 2021, but in no event, later than the applicable
period of limitations on making adjustments under section 6235 for the
reviewed year, as defined in Sec. 301.6241-1(a)(8) of the Procedure
and Administration Regulations (26 CFR part 301). However, section
45Q(f)(3)(B) elections may not be made on amended returns for taxable
years beginning after the date of issuance of these proposed
regulations.
2. Definitions
a. Qualified Carbon Oxide
Section 45Q(c) provides that ``qualified carbon oxide'' means (A)
any carbon dioxide which (i) is captured from an industrial source by
carbon capture equipment which is originally placed in service before
February 9, 2018; (ii) would otherwise be released into the atmosphere
as industrial emission of greenhouse gas or lead to such release; and
(iii) is measured at the source of capture and verified at the point of
disposal, injection, or utilization; (B) any carbon dioxide or other
carbon oxide which (i) is captured from an industrial source by carbon
capture equipment which is originally placed in service on or after
February 9, 2018; (ii) would otherwise be released into the atmosphere
as industrial emission of greenhouse gas or lead to such release; and
(iii) is measured at the source of capture and verified at the point of
disposal, injection, or utilization; or (C) in the case of a direct air
capture facility, any carbon dioxide which (i) is captured directly
from ambient air; and (ii) is measured at the source of capture and
verified at the point of disposal, injection, or utilization.
While ``qualified carbon oxide'' includes the initial deposit of
captured carbon oxide used as a tertiary injectant, section 45Q(c)(2)
provides that the term does not include carbon oxide that is
recaptured, recycled, and re-injected as part of the qualified enhanced
oil or natural gas recovery process. Additionally, section 45Q(f)(1)
provides that the section 45Q credit apples only with respect to
qualified carbon oxide the capture and disposal, injection, or
utilization of which is within the United States (within the meaning of
section 638(1)), or a possession of the United States (within the
meaning of section 638(2)).
Commenters suggested generally that the statutory definition of
qualified carbon oxide is sufficient, and did not seek additional
clarification. The Treasury Department and the IRS agree that the
statutory definition of qualified carbon oxide is clear due to the
broad acceptance and use of the term by industry participants,
environmental groups, and stakeholders. Therefore, the proposed
regulations generally conform to the statutory definition of qualified
carbon oxide, including the provision that only qualified carbon oxide
captured and disposed of, injected, or utilized within the United
States or a possession of the United States is taken into account.
Therefore, the proposed regulations generally conform to the statutory
definition of qualified carbon oxide, including the provision that only
qualified carbon oxide captured and disposed of, injected, or utilized
within the United States or a possession of the United States is taken
into account.
b. Carbon Capture Equipment
Section 45Q does not define carbon capture equipment. One commenter
suggested that carbon capture equipment be broadly defined as, ``any
system that but for its presence and application, the carbon oxides
captured at a qualifying industrial facility and on which a section 45Q
credit is earned would have been vented into the atmosphere.'' Another
commenter suggested that the definition allow for maximum flexibility
to encompass a complete configuration of equipment including separate
units, processing units, processing plants, pipe, buildings, pumps,
compressors, meters, facilities, motors, fixtures, materials, and
machinery, and all other improvements used for the purpose of: (1)
Separating and/or capturing carbon dioxide that would otherwise be
released into the atmosphere from a qualifying facility; (2)
compressing or otherwise increasing the pressure of carbon dioxide; or
(3) transporting, disposing, injecting, and/or utilizing qualified
carbon oxide.
Finally, some commenters suggested that the definition of carbon
capture equipment should be limited to the equipment that functions to
capture the carbon oxides from any industrial source. The commenters
explained that once the carbon oxides are captured, equipment having a
separate function such as compression, liquefaction, transportation, or
pumping, should not be included in the definition of carbon capture
equipment.
The Treasury Department and the IRS agree that carbon capture
equipment generally should be defined in terms of its functionality.
The proposed regulations provide that in general, carbon capture
equipment includes all components of property that are used to capture
or process carbon oxide until the carbon oxide is transported for
disposal, injection, or utilization. Further, the proposed regulations
list specific items that are included in, or excluded from the
definition of carbon capture equipment. Components of property related
to the function of capturing carbon oxides, such as components of
property necessary to compress, treat, process, liquefy, or pump carbon
oxides, are included within the definition of carbon capture equipment.
Components of property related to transporting carbon oxides for
disposal, injection, or utilization are not included in the general
definition.
c. Qualified Facility
Section 45Q(d) provides that ``qualified facility'' means any
industrial facility or direct air capture facility, the
[[Page 34054]]
construction of which begins before January 1, 2024, and (i) the
construction of carbon capture equipment begins before such date; or
(ii) the original planning and design for such facility includes
installation of carbon capture equipment. In addition, a qualified
facility must capture: (i) In the case of a facility which emits not
more than 500,000 metric tons of carbon oxide into the atmosphere
during the taxable year, not less than 25,000 metric tons of qualified
carbon oxide during the taxable year which is utilized in a manner
described in section 45Q(f)(5) (Section 45Q(d)(2)(A) Facility); (ii) in
the case of an electricity generating facility which is not a Section
45Q(d)(2)(A) Facility (Section 45Q(d)(2)(B) Facility), not less than
500,000 metric tons of qualified carbon oxide during the taxable year;
or (iii) in the case of a direct air capture facility or any facility
which is not a Section 45Q(d)(2)(A) Facility or a Section 45Q(d)(2)(B)
Facility, not less than 100,000 metric tons of qualified carbon oxide
during the taxable year.
Some commenters requested that the proposed regulations incorporate
the ``80/20 Rule'' set forth in Rev. Rul. 94-31, 1994-1 C.B. 16, which
held that for section 45 purposes a facility that contains some used
property would still qualify as originally placed in service, provided
the fair market value of the used property is not more than 20 percent
of the facility's total value. Commenters requested the inclusion of
this rule because the section 45Q credit amounts depend on whether
carbon capture equipment is placed in service before February 9, 2018,
or on or after that date.
The proposed regulations adopt the 80/20 Rule and provide that a
qualified facility or carbon capture equipment may qualify as
originally placed in service even though it contains some used
components of property, provided the fair market value of the used
components of property is not more than 20 percent of the qualified
facility or carbon capture equipment's total value (the cost of the new
components of property plus the value of the used components of
property). For purposes of the 80/20 Rule, the cost of a new qualified
facility or carbon capture equipment includes all properly capitalized
costs of the new qualified facility or carbon capture equipment. Solely
for purposes of the 80/20 Rule, properly capitalized costs of a new
qualified facility or carbon capture equipment may, at the option of
the taxpayer, include the cost of new equipment for a pipeline owned
and used exclusively by that taxpayer to transport carbon oxides
captured from that taxpayer's qualified facility that would otherwise
be emitted into the atmosphere.
d. Industrial Facility
Section 45Q does not define the term ``industrial facility.''
Commenters suggested that an ``industrial facility'' should be defined
as a facility that produces a carbon oxide stream from a fuel
combustion source, a manufacturing process, or a fugitive carbon oxide-
emission source that, absent capture and disposal, injection, or
utilization, would otherwise be released into the atmosphere. They also
recommended that the term not include a facility that produces carbon
dioxide through carbon dioxide production wells at natural carbon
dioxide-bearing formations. This definition is consistent with the
definition of industrial facility provided in section 3.03 of Notice
2020-12. The proposed regulations adopt this definition.
e. Direct Air Capture Facility
Section 45Q(e)(1) provides that the term ``direct air capture
facility'' means any facility which uses carbon capture equipment to
capture carbon dioxide directly from the ambient air, except the term
does not include any facility which captures carbon dioxide that is
deliberately released from naturally occurring subsurface springs or
using natural photosynthesis.
Generally, commenters did not request that the definition of
``direct air capture facility'' be clarified. One commenter suggested
that ``direct air capture facility'' include certain algae. Although
section 45Q(f)(5)(A)(i) provides that photosynthesis or chemosynthesis
is a permitted type of utilization of qualified carbon oxide, the
statutory definition of a ``direct air capture facility'' excludes any
facility that captures carbon dioxide using natural photosynthesis.
Therefore, the proposed regulations do not adopt the commenter's
suggestion.
3. Secure Geological Storage
Section 45Q(f)(2) provides that the Secretary, in consultation with
the Administrator of the EPA, the Secretary of Energy, and the
Secretary of the Interior, must establish regulations for determining
adequate security measures for the geological storage of qualified
carbon oxide under section 45Q(a) such that the qualified carbon oxide
does not escape into the atmosphere. Such term includes storage at deep
saline formations, oil and gas reservoirs, and unminable coal seams
under such conditions as the Secretary may determine under such
regulations.
Injection of carbon oxide into any underground reservoir, onshore
or offshore under submerged lands within the territorial jurisdiction
of States, requires the operator to comply with Underground Injection
Control (UIC) program regulations and to obtain the appropriate UIC
well permits. Under 40 CFR 146.5 (Classification of injection wells)
Class II may be an appropriate UIC well permit for wells which inject
fluids (including carbon dioxide) brought to the surface in connection
with conventional oil or natural gas production and may be commingled
with waste waters from gas plants that are an integral part of
production operations, unless those fluids are classified as a
hazardous waste at the time of injection, and for wells which inject
fluids (including carbon oxides) for enhanced recovery of oil or
natural gas. Class VI is an appropriate UIC well permit for wells that
are not experimental in nature that are used for geologic sequestration
of carbon dioxide beneath the lowermost formation containing an
underground source of drinking water; or, for wells used for geologic
sequestration of carbon dioxide that have been granted a waiver of the
injection depth requirements pursuant to requirements at 40 CFR 146.95;
or, for wells used for geologic sequestration of carbon dioxide that
have received an expansion to the areal extent of an existing Class II
enhanced oil recovery or enhanced gas recovery aquifer exemption
pursuant to Sec. Sec. 146.4 and 144.7(d) of 40 CFR.
Operators that inject carbon dioxide underground are also subject
to the EPA's GHGRP requirements set forth at 40 CFR part 98. Under 40
CFR part 98 subpart RR (Geologic Sequestration of Carbon Dioxide source
category, referred to as subpart RR), certain facilities, including UIC
Class VI wells, are required to report basic information on carbon
dioxide received for injection, develop and implement an EPA-approved
site-specific Monitoring, Reporting, and Verification Plan (MRV Plan),
and report the amount of carbon dioxide geologically sequestered using
a mass balance approach and annual monitoring activities. Under 40 CFR
part 98 subpart UU (Injection of Carbon Dioxide source category,
referred to as subpart UU), all other facilities that inject carbon
dioxide underground such as for EOR or any other purpose, are required
to report basic information on carbon dioxide received for injection.
Facilities that conduct EOR are not required by 40 CFR part 98 to
report under subpart RR unless (1) the owner
[[Page 34055]]
or operator chooses to opt into subpart RR or, (2) the facility holds a
UIC Class VI permit for the well or group of wells used for EOR. Annual
reports that are submitted under 40 CFR part 98 to the EPA's GHGRP
undergo verification by the EPA, and non-confidential data from these
reports are published on the EPA's website.
Commenters noted that Form 8933 defines ``secure geological
storage'' for purposes of section 45Q as requiring approval by the EPA
of an MRV Plan. Thus, meeting the Form 8933 conditions would be
achieved currently by receiving either (i) a UIC Class VI permit plus
an EPA-approved MRV Plan, which UIC Class VI permit holders are already
required to have because they are subject to subpart RR; or (ii) a UIC
Class II permit plus an EPA-approved MRV Plan. The Form 8933
requirement that UIC Class II permit holders receive an approved MRV
Plan for purposes of the section 45Q credit creates an additional
burden on such holders. Some commenters expressed concern that being
required to opt into subpart RR may create a misalignment with state
mineral property and natural resource conservation laws, as well as
accepted industry practices and commercial arrangements. Therefore, the
commenters generally requested that the Treasury Department and the IRS
provide alternatives to opting into subpart RR for demonstrating secure
geological storage for EOR projects.
Many commenters suggested that a standard adopted by the
International Organization for Standardization (ISO) and endorsed by
the American National Standards Institute (ANSI), CSA/ANSI ISO
27916:19, ``Carbon Dioxide Capture, Transportation and Geological
Storage--Carbon Dioxide Storage Using Enhanced Oil Recovery
(CO2-EOR),'' is a viable alternative to subpart RR for
establishing secure geological storage for the use of qualified carbon
oxide for EOR.
The CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 standard was developed for the purpose of
quantifying and documenting the total carbon dioxide that is stored in
association with EOR. In general, reporting under CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19
uses mass balance accounting, has established reporting and
documentation requirements, and includes requirements for documenting a
monitoring program and a containment assurance plan.
Some of the commenters advocating for the application of the CSA/
ANSI ISO 27916:19 standard emphasized the importance and need for
public acceptance and input, transparent public filings, credible
third-party audits and certifications, and government oversight and
enforcement. For example, some commenters suggested that the proposed
regulations require that all relevant documentation of the amount of
qualified carbon oxide stored for purposes of the section 45Q credit be
retained and made available for public review and the total quantity of
qualified carbon oxide stored for long-term containment be reported
annually. The Treasury Department and the IRS appreciate the importance
of shared and open information in this context and encourage
transparency. However, there is no statutory requirement in section 45Q
for taxpayers, Federal agencies, or industry groups to pubicly display
this information or otherwise make it available. In addition, the IRS
is itself limited in what it can disclose because of the rules
prohibiting the public disclosure of taxpayer information under section
6103.
Some commenters also requested that the Treasury Department and the
IRS recognize the standards for secure geological storage required by
government entities with regulatory primacy, and also recommended that
states be allowed to certify the secure geological storage of qualified
carbon oxide. The commenters noted that the EPA has approved primary
enforcement authority (primacy) for UIC Class II wells for more than
half the states. Primacy permits a state, tribe, or territory to
implement and oversee its own EPA approved program. One commenter
requested that the IRS clarify that a valid UIC Class VI permit issued
under the authority of the EPA includes permits issued by a state that
has received final approval from the EPA of its primacy application
under section 1422 of the Safe Water Drinking Act to implement a Class
VI UIC Program. The commenter also suggested that use of an accounting
methodology consistent with the mass balance equation under subpart RR
be adequate to establish secure geological storage.
The Treasury Department and the IRS, in consultation with the EPA,
DOE, and the Department of Interior (Interior Department), agree that
providing CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 as an alternative for UIC Class II
wells is a viable quantification methodology that is appropriate for
these purposes. Both subpart RR and CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 require an
assessment and monitoring of potential leakage pathways; quantification
of inputs, losses and storage through a mass balance approach; and
documentation of steps and approaches. Operators of UIC Class II wells
that follow the CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 standard could elect to report to
the EPA's GHGRP under subpart RR but would not be required to do so.
Rather, they could continue to report to the EPA under subpart UU.
The Treasury Department and the IRS, in consultation with the EPA,
DOE, and the Interior Department, disagree with suggestions to allow
the reporting rules promulgated by states as an alternative to subpart
RR or CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19. Reporting rules among states are not
uniform and states may have different reporting requirements and
different governing bodies to whom carbon dioxide injection projects
are required to report. Adopting such rules would not promote
uniformity, and would increase the administrative burden on the IRS
significantly.
Consequently, the proposed regulations allow the CSA/ANSI ISO
27916:19 standard as an alternative to subpart RR for UIC Class II
wells using qualified carbon oxide for EOR, but do not allow standards
set by states as an alternative to subpart RR. In addition, the
proposed regulations do not provide for an alternative to subpart RR
reporting for UIC Class VI wells because all UIC Class VI wells are
already subject to subpart RR reporting requirements. A taxpayer that
reported volumes of carbon oxide to the EPA pursuant to subpart RR may
self-certify the volume of carbon oxide claimed for purposes of section
45Q. Alternatively, if a taxpayer determined volumes pursuant to CSA/
ANSI ISO 27916:19, the taxpayer may prepare documentation as outlined
in CSA/ANSI 27916:2019 internally, but such documentation must be
provided to a qualified independent engineer or geologist, who then
must certify that the documentation provided, including the mass
balance calculations as well as information regarding monitoring and
containment assurance, is accurate and complete.
4. Utilization of Qualified Carbon Oxide
Section 45Q(f)(5)(A) provides that ``utilization of qualified
carbon oxide'' means (i) the fixation of such qualified carbon oxide
through photosynthesis or chemosynthesis, such as through the growing
of algae or bacteria; (ii) the chemical conversion of such qualified
carbon oxide to a material or chemical compound in which such qualified
carbon oxide is securely stored; or (iii) the use of such qualified
carbon oxide for any other purpose for which a commercial market exists
(with the exception of use as a tertiary injectant in a qualified
enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project), as determined by the
Secretary.
[[Page 34056]]
Section 45Q(f)(5)(B) provides a methodology to determine the amount
of qualified carbon oxide utilized by the taxpayer. Such amount is
equal to the metric tons of qualified carbon oxide which the taxpayer
demonstrates, based upon an analysis of lifecycle greenhouse gas
emissions and subject to such requirements as the Secretary, in
consultation with the Secretary of Energy and the Administrator of the
EPA, determines appropriate, were (i) captured and permanently isolated
from the atmosphere, or (ii) displaced from being emitted into the
atmosphere, through use of a process described in section 45Q(f)(5)(A).
The term ``lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions'' has the same meaning
given such term under subparagraph (H) of section 211(o)(1) of the
Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C. 7545(o)(1)(H)), as in effect on February 9,
2018, except that ``product'' is substituted for ``fuel'' each place it
appears in such subparagraph.
Commenters generally sought guidance about the methodologies
required to prepare an acceptable life cycle analysis (LCA) that
demonstrates the amount of qualified carbon oxide utilized, as well as
the boundaries required for the LCA.
One commenter requested that guidance establish clear guidelines
for the preparation of an LCA by applicants to demonstrate the net
reduction or avoidance of carbon dioxide achieved through its
utilization by the taxpayer. Because LCA requires selection of
comparative data, the commenter recommended that the LCA undergo a
review by a third party, determined by the IRS, to assess the
reasonableness of the assumptions, factors and calculations used by the
applicant.
Other commenters suggested using the Greenhouse Gases, Regulated
Emissions, and Energy Use in Transportation (GREET) model, or an
adaptation of it adopted by the California Air Resources Board, to
perform LCA of transportation fuels, and further suggested using both a
basic method and a safe harbor method. The GREET model is a tool that
examines the life-cycle impacts of vehicle technologies, fuels,
products, and energy systems. It provides a transparent platform
through which energy and vehicle producers, researchers, and regulators
can evaluate energy and environmental effects of vehicle technologies
and energy and product systems. For any given energy and vehicle
system, GREET can calculate total energy consumption (non-renewable and
renewable), emissions of air pollutants, emissions of greenhouse gases,
and water consumption.
One commenter suggested that the LCA, as reviewed by the relevant
governmental agency, should determine whether any release of embodied
qualified carbon oxide is possible for a specific utilization project.
If so, the commenter recommended that recapture be addressed in the
LCA. The commenter requested guidance regarding the types of LCA models
that are appropriate, and recommended the GREET model.
Another commenter suggested that the IRS should not adopt a
specific methodology or approach to calculating lifecycle emissions.
Instead, the commenter recommended that guidance make clear that models
that are acceptable to the EPA will also be acceptable for purposes of
section 45Q. The commenter suggested that the LCA model for section 45Q
purposes should be one that is recognized by the EPA based on its use
in the Renewable Fuel Standard or other program administered by the
EPA. The commenter further recommended that if the capture and
utilization of carbon oxides also generates other greenhouse gas
detriments, such as an increase in emissions over the base case, those
greenhouse gases caused by the utilization should be adjusted to
account for the relative global warming potential. Similarly, if the
capture and utilization of carbon oxides reduce greenhouse gas
emissions over the base case, the commenter argued that those benefits
should also be credited.
One commenter sought guidance on the boundaries for LCA to
determine displacement of carbon dioxide and recommended that lifecycle
emissions include the entirety of the lifecycle.
Several commenters expressed the view that an MRV Plan or any
accredited LCA performed by a qualified firm as determined by the IRS
could be suitable for establishing boundaries for lifecycle emissions
for qualified carbon oxide utilization. Further, commenters suggested
that there should be contractual proof to track the supply chain and
ensure that the MRV Plan is followed according to the annual LCA.
Some commenters suggested that guidance require EOR operators to
provide a full lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions analysis that, like
the requirements for utilization, includes all stages of product and
feedstock production and distribution, from feedstock generation or
extraction through the distribution and delivery and use of the
finished product to the ultimate consumer. The commenters requested
that the IRS make public all lifecycle emissions calculations.
One commenter made the following suggestions. First, taxpayers
should use an independent consulting firm or other similar independent
entity to undertake the LCA. Second, taxpayers should insure that an
LCA model is realistic and has been used widely by the LCA industry.
Third, an LCA must be commercially available to anyone and must be able
to be examined in any audit by the IRS. Fourth, taxpayers should use an
LCA that compares a base case of making the product produced by
utilization without carbon capture to the modeled utilization case
using qualified carbon oxide to determine what greenhouse gases were
displaced from being emitted into the atmosphere. Finally, taxpayers
must use an LCA which models all ``greenhouse gases'' as defined in the
Clean Air Act in determining the net impact of such greenhouse gases
generated or reduced in utilization of qualified carbon oxide.
One commenter suggested that the IRS should provide a safe harbor
for taxpayers that retain a third-party firm to undertake the LCA.
However, the commenter stated that while a safe harbor would be
helpful, third-party verification should not be mandatory, as many
taxpayers may have sufficient engineering expertise in-house and some
smaller projects may not support the extra cost of third-party
verification.
In response to the commenters, the proposed regulations conform the
definition of utilization to the statutory definition. The Treasury
Department and the IRS, in consultation with the EPA and the DOE,
concluded that the LCA must be in writing and either performed or
verified by a professionally-licensed third party that uses generally-
accepted standard practices of quantifying the greenhouse gas emissions
of a product or process and comparing that impact to a baseline. In
particular, the analysis must contain documentation consistent with the
International Organization for Standardization (ISO) 14044:2006,
``Environmental management--Life cycle assessment--Requirements and
Guidelines,'' as well as a statement documenting the qualifications of
the third party. Although the section 45Q credit is only available with
respect to qualified carbon oxides, all greenhouse gas emissions are
taken into account under this analysis. The proposed regulations
require a taxpayer to submit an LCA report to the IRS and the DOE. The
LCA will be subject to a technical review by the DOE, and the IRS, in
consultation with the DOE and the EPA, will determine whether to
approve the
[[Page 34057]]
LCA. The Treasury Department and the IRS request comments on how to
achieve consistency in boundaries and baselines so that similarly
situated taxpayers will be treated consistently. The Treasury
Department and the IRS are willing to consider issuing guidance on
particular fact patterns.
The proposed regulations do not define commercial markets or
provide for Standards of Lifecycle Analysis. The Treasury Department
and the IRS continue to study these issues and request comments.
5. Credit Recapture
Section 45Q(f)(4) directs the Secretary to provide regulations for
recapturing the benefit of any section 45Q credit allowable with
respect to any qualified carbon oxide which ceases to be captured,
disposed of, or used as a tertiary injectant in a manner consistent
with the requirements of section 45Q.
Commenters sought guidance about the method for measuring the
amount of leaked qualified carbon oxide subject to recapture (recapture
amount), the method for calculating recapture, and the open period
during which a recapture event may occur (recapture period).
All of these issues require a definition of the recapture period.
The proposed regulations provide that the recapture period begins on
the date of the first injection of qualified carbon oxide for disposal
in secure geological storage or use as a tertiary injectant and ends
the earlier of five years after the last taxable year in which the
taxpayer claimed a section 45Q credit or the date monitoring ends under
subpart RR requirements or the CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 standard.
For clarity we will describe two sub-portions of the recapture
period, the ``post-credit-claiming period'' and the ``lookback
period''. The ``post-credit-claiming period'' is the period after the
end of the twelve year credit period during which a leak can result in
recapture, whereas the ``lookback period'' is the portion of the
recapture period during which the IRS can look back after a leakage
event to recapture credits. Most commenters supported a lookback period
of three to five years.
Commenters generally suggested that if a recapture event occurs
with respect to storage of qualified carbon oxide, then the taxpayer
must add the recapture amount to the amount of tax due in the taxable
year in which the recapture event occurs, as opposed to attributing the
leak to past tax years and amending those returns.
Commenters also suggested that a recapture event should occur when
qualified carbon oxide, for which a section 45Q credit has been
allowed, ceases to be stored in secure geological storage if the amount
of leakage of qualified carbon oxide in a taxable year exceeds the
amount of qualified carbon oxide stored in that same taxable year. In
other words, they suggested that a leak would first offset the
immediate tax year's claimed credits and then be an addition to tax, as
opposed to auditing and amending past tax returns.
One commenter stated that the standard for measuring recapture of
the section 45Q credit should be the mass balance calculations that are
used for determining the amount of qualified carbon oxide stored in
secure geological storage. The commenter noted that these mass balance
calculations effectively establish a last-in/first-out (LIFO)
accounting method that assumes current year releases offset current
year injections for the qualified carbon oxide that is in secure
geological storage.
Several commenters requested a safe harbor for recapture, providing
that recapture will not apply so long as the injection operator is
operating in compliance with any standards set by the Treasury
Department and the IRS for secure geological storage of the qualified
carbon oxide. These commenters asserted that if the injection operator
is in compliance with the secure geological storage standards at the
time of a release, any release or leakage of the qualified carbon oxide
would be offset by current year injections of qualified carbon oxide.
If the injection operator is not operating in compliance with the
standards for secure geological storage at the time of the release, the
commenters recommended that any recapture be calculated on a LIFO basis
against previously taken section 45Q credits when the injection
operator was in compliance with the secure geological storage
standards.
The proposed regulations do not provide a recapture safe harbor,
but do limit the recapture period similar to the recapture provisions
for investment credit property under section 50(a)(1). Specifically,
the proposed regulations provide that any recapture amount will be
accounted for in the taxable year that it is identified and reported.
If, during the recapture period, a taxpayer, operator, or regulatory
agency determines that qualified carbon oxide has leaked to the
atmosphere, the taxpayer will have a recapture amount if the leaked
amount of qualified carbon oxide exceeds the amount of qualified carbon
dioxide disposed of in secure geological storage or used as a tertiary
injectant in that taxable year. That excess amount of leaked qualified
carbon oxide will be recaptured at a credit rate calculated on a LIFO
basis (that is, the excess leaked qualified carbon oxide will be deemed
attributable first to the first preceding year, then to second
preceding year, and then up to the fifth preceding year) to simplify
the calculation of the recapture amount.
The taxpayer must add the amount of the recaptured section 45Q tax
credit to the amount of tax due in the taxable year in which the
recapture event occurs. Consistent with this five-year lookback period,
the proposed regulations provide that the post-credit-claiming period
ends the earlier of (i) five years after the last taxable year in which
the taxpayer claimed a section 45Q credit or (ii) the date monitoring
ends under the requirements of the subpart RR standard or the CSA/ANSI
ISO 27916:19 standard.
The proposed regulations also provide that in the event of a
recapture event with respect to a secure geological storage location in
which the stored qualified carbon oxide had been captured from more
than one unit of carbon capture equipment that was not under common
ownership, the recapture amount must be allocated among the taxpayers
that own the multiple units of carbon capture equipment pro rata on the
basis of the amount of qualified carbon oxide captured from each of the
multiple units of carbon capture equipment.
Similarly, the proposed regulations provide that in the event of a
recapture event where the leaked amount of qualified carbon oxide is
deemed attributable to qualified carbon oxide with respect to which
multiple taxpayers claimed section 45Q credit amounts, the recapture
amount is allocated on a pro rata basis among the taxpayers that
claimed the section 45Q credits.
The proposed regulations provide a limited exception to recapture
in the event of a leakage of qualified carbon oxide resulting from
actions not related to the selection, operation, or maintenance of the
storage facility, such as volcanic activity or a terrorist attack.
Finally, the proposed regulations provide that if qualified carbon
oxide is deliberately removed from a secure storage site, a recapture
event occurs in the year in which the qualified carbon oxide is removed
from its original storage.
As noted in section 4.08 of Revenue Procedure 2020-12, a taxpayer
may obtain third-party recapture insurance to protect against
recapture.
The Treasury Department and the IRS request comments on how to
apply the
[[Page 34058]]
recapture provisions to section 45Q credits that are carried forward to
future taxable years due to insuffificent income tax liability in the
current taxable year.
Effect on Other Documents
Sections 1 through 5 of Notice 2009-83, 2009-2 C.B. 588, as
modified by Notice 2011-25, 2011-1 C.B. 604, are obsoleted. The
remaining sections of Notice 2009-83 provide reporting and
recordkeeping requirements associated with the limitation on credits
available under former section 45Q(a) (as in effect before February 9,
2018) and sections 45Q(a)(1) and (2). After the end of the calendar
year in which the Secretary, in consultation with the Administrator of
the EPA, certifies that a total of 75,000,000 metric tons of qualified
carbon oxide have been taken into account under former section 45Q(a)
(as in effect before February 9, 2018) and sections 45Q(a)(1) and (2),
the remaining sections of Notice 2009-83 will be obsoleted.
Proposed Effective/Applicability Date
The regulations are proposed to apply to taxable years beginning on
or after the date the Treasury decision adopting these regulations as
final regulations is published in the Federal Register. However,
taxpayers may choose to apply the final regulations for taxable years
beginning on or after February 9, 2018, and before the date the
Treasury decision adopting these regulations as final regulations is
published in the Federal Register. See section 7805(b)(7).
Alternatively, taxpayers may rely on these proposed regulations for
taxable years beginning on or after February 9, 2018, and before the
date the Treasury decision adopting these regulations as final
regulations is published in the Federal Register, provided the
taxpayers follow the proposed regulations in their entirety and in a
consistent manner.
Statement of Availability for IRS Documents
For copies of recently issued Revenue Procedures, Revenue Rulings,
Notices, and other guidance published in the Internal Revenue Bulletin,
please visit the IRS website at https://www.irs.gov.
Special Analyses
I. Regulatory Planning and Review--Economic Analysis
Executive Orders 13563, 13771, and 12866 direct agencies to assess
costs and benefits of available regulatory alternatives and, if
regulation is necessary, to select regulatory approaches that maximize
net benefits (including potential economic, environmental, public
health and safety effects, distributive impacts, and equity). Executive
Order 13563 emphasizes the importance of quantifying both costs and
benefits, of reducing costs, of harmonizing rules, and of promoting
flexibility. The preliminary E.O. 13771 designation is deregulatory.
These regulations have been designated by the Office of Management
and Budget's Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs (OIRA) as
economically significant under Executive Order 12866 pursuant to the
Memorandum of Agreement (April 11, 2018) between the Treasury
Department and the Office of Management and Budget regarding review of
tax regulations.
A. Background and Overview
Section 45Q was enacted on October 3, 2008, by section 115 of
Division B of the Energy Improvement and Extension Act of 2008, Public
Law 110-343, 122 Stat. 3765, 3829, to provide a credit for the
sequestration of carbon dioxide. On February 17, 2009, section 45Q was
amended by section 1131 of Division B of the American Recovery and
Reinvestment Tax Act of 2009, Public Law 111-5, 123 Stat. 115, 325.
Section 45Q was further amended on December 19, 2014, by section
209(j)(1) of Division A of the Tax Increase Prevention Act of 2014,
Public Law 113-295, 128 Stat. 4010, 4030, and most recently on February
9, 2018, by section 41119 of Division D of the Bipartisan Budget Act of
2018 (BBA), Public Law 115-123, 132 Stat. 64, 162.
On May 20, 2019, the IRS published Notice 2019-32, 2019-21 I.R.B.
1187. The notice requested general comments on issues arising under
section 45Q, as well as specific comments concerning the secure
geological storage and measurement of qualified carbon oxide, and the
recapture of the benefit of the credit for carbon oxide sequestration.
The IRS received 116 comments from industry members, environmental
groups, and other stakeholders.
In addition, the Treasury Department and the IRS published Revenue
Procedure 2020-12, 2020-11 I.R.B. 511, and Notice 2020-12, 2020-11
I.R.B. 495. Revenue Procedure 2020-12 provides a safe harbor under
which the IRS will treat partnerships as properly allocating the
section 45Q credit in accordance with section 704(b). Notice 2020-12
provides guidance on the determination of when construction has begun
on a qualified facility or on carbon capture equipment that may be
eligible for the section 45Q credit.
Section 45Q generally allows a credit of an amount per metric ton
of qualified carbon oxide captured by the taxpayer using carbon capture
equipment. This qualified carbon oxide must be captured according to
the statute in one of three general manners. First, it may be disposed
of in secure geological storage. This would occur if it were injected
into a geologic formation, such as a deep saline formation, an oil and
gas reservoir, or an unminable coal seam.
Second, the qualified carbon oxide may be used as a tertiary
injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project
and disposed of in secure geological storage. A ``tertiary injectant''
is qualified carbon oxide that is injected into and stored in a
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project and contributes
to the extraction of crude oil or natural gas.
Third, the qualified carbon oxide may be ``utilized'' by fixing it
through photosynthesis or chemosynthesis, converting it to a material
or chemical compound in which it is securely stored, or using it for
any other purpose for which a commercial market exists. ``Utilization''
generally means the qualified carbon oxide was captured and permanently
isolated from the atmosphere, or displaced from being emitted into the
atmosphere. Calculation of the amount utilized is based on an analysis
of lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions.
The amount of the credit depends on the date the carbon capture
equipment is placed in service and whether the qualified carbon oxide
is disposed of in secure storage, injected, or utilized. Different
rules and credit amounts apply to qualified carbon oxide capture
projects placed in service before and after the date the enactment of
the BBA on February 9, 2018. Based on annual reports filed with the IRS
as of May, 2019, the aggregate amount of qualified carbon oxide taken
into account for purposes of section 45Q was 62,740,171 metric tons.
This is an increase of 2,972,247 metric tons from the preceding
year.\1\ According to data reported to the EPA's Greenhouse Gas
Reporting Program (GHGRP), there were 65 enhanced oil recovery (EOR)
projects operating in the U.S. in 2018. As of 2019, the National
Petroleum Council, an oil and natural gas advisory committee to the
Secretary of Energy, reports that there were 10 carbon capture,
utilization, and storage projects in the United States. DOE models
project that the section 45Q credit may
[[Page 34059]]
result in the sequestration of approximately 570 million metric tons of
carbon oxides between 2018 and 2036.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ These data are available in Notice 2018-40, 2018-20 I.R.B.
583, and Notice 2019-31, 2019-20 I.R.B. 1181.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
B. Need for Regulation
The proposed regulations provide guidance regarding the application
of section 45Q. Section 45Q requires regulations for determining
adequate security measures for the secure geological storage of
qualified carbon oxide such that it does not escape into the
atmosphere, standards for recapture of section 45Q credits, and
standards for carbon oxide utilization.
C. Economic Analysis
1. Baseline
The Treasury Department and the IRS have assessed the economic
impacts of the final regulations relative to a no-action baseline
reflecting anticipated Federal income tax-related behavior in the
absence of these regulations.
2. Economic Rationale for Issuing Guidance for the 2018 BBA
The Treasury Department and the IRS anticipate that the issuance of
guidance pertaining to section 45Q will provide greater clarity in
definitions than the alternative of having no further descriptions than
the statute; more flexibility in methods to establish qualifications
for the credit relative to prior guidance; and more transparency
regarding business arrangements related to the section 45Q credit
relative to the baseline. These features may lower compliance burden
and increase economic investment by lowering regulatory barriers to
entry, compared to a baseline of having only the statue and not the
regulations.
3. Economic Analysis of Specific Provisions
The final regulations embody certain regulatory decisions that
reflect necessary regulatory discretion. These decisions specify more
fully how the section 45Q credit is to be implemented.
i. Standard for Secure Geological Storage
a. Background
Section 45Q(f)(2) provides that the Secretary, in consultation with
the Administrator of the EPA, the Secretary of Energy, and the
Secretary of the Interior, must establish regulations for determining
adequate security measures for the secure geological storage of
qualified carbon oxide under section 45Q such that qualified carbon
oxide does not escape into the atmosphere. Such term includes storage
at deep saline formations, oil and gas reservoirs, and unminable coal
seams under such conditions as the Secretary may determine under such
regulations.
Under existing law, injection of carbon oxide into any underground
reservoir requires the operator to comply with EPA's Underground
Injection Control (UIC) program regulations and to obtain the
appropriate UIC well permits. The UIC program is designed to protect
underground sources of drinking water from underground injection.
Operators that inject carbon dioxide underground are also subject to
the EPA's GHGRP requirements set forth at 40 CFR part 98.
Under 40 CFR part 98, facilities that inject carbon dioxide
underground for long-term containment of carbon dioxide in subsurface
geologic formations are specifically subject to 40 CFR part 98 subpart
RR (Geologic Sequestration of Carbon Dioxide source category, referred
to as subpart RR). Facilities that are subject to subpart RR, including
UIC Class VI wells, are required to report basic information on carbon
dioxide received for injection, develop and implement an EPA-approved
site-specific Monitoring, Reporting, and Verification Plan (MRV Plans);
and report the amount of carbon dioxide geologically sequestered using
a mass balance approach and annual monitoring activities.
Facilities that inject carbon dioxide underground for the purposes
of enhanced oil (EOR) and gas recovery or any other purpose other than
geologic sequestration are required to report basic information on
carbon dioxide received for injection under 40 CFR part 98 subpart UU
(Injection of Carbon Dioxide source category, referred to as subpart
UU). At present, the EPA does not generally require facilities that
conduct EOR to report under subpart RR. However, the owner or operator
may voluntarily choose to opt in to subpart RR. For both subparts RR
and UU, annual reports are submitted under 40 CFR part 98 to the EPA's
GHGRP and undergo verification by the EPA. Non-confidential data from
these reports are published on the EPA's website.
b. Comments Received
Commenters noted that in order to qualify for section 45Q credits,
IRS Form 8933 defines ``secure geological storage'' as requiring
approval by the EPA of an MRV Plan under 40 CFR part 98 subpart RR.
Thus, meeting the Form 8933 conditions would currently be achieved by
receiving either (i) a UIC Class VI permit plus an EPA-approved MRV
Plan, which UIC Class VI permit holders are already required to have
because they are subject to subpart RR; or (ii) a UIC Class II permit
plus an EPA-approved MRV Plan, which requires UIC Class II permit
holders to opt in to subpart RR. In this manner, the Form 8933
requirement that UIC Class II permit holders receive an approved MRV
Plan creates an additional burden on such holders because- it requires
them to opt in to subpart RR to receive section 45Q credits. In
addition, some commenters expressed concern that a requirement that
they opt in to subpart RR, in addition to being a supplementary
requirement, may create a misalignment with state mineral property and
natural resource conservation laws.
Commenters supported the continued use of subpart RR, but most
commenters sought an alternative method in addition to subpart RR. Many
of these commenters considered the subpart RR requirements burdensome,
for the reasons noted immediately above.
Many commenters suggested that a standard adopted by the
International Organization for Standardization (ISO) and endorsed by
the American National Standards Institute (ANSI), CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19
standard, ``Carbon dioxide capture, transportation and geological
storage--Carbon dioxide storage using enhanced oil recovery
(CO2-EOR),'' (CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19) is a viable alternative
to subpart RR for establishing secure geological storage for the use of
qualified carbon oxide for EOR.
The CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 was developed for the purpose of
quantifying and documenting the total carbon dioxide that is stored in
association with carbon dioxide-EOR. In general, reporting under CSA/
ANSI ISO 27916:19 (i) uses mass balance accounting, (ii) has
established reporting and documentation requirements, and (iii)
includes requirements for documenting a monitoring program and a
containment assurance plan. ANSI, a not-for-profit organization
dedicated to supporting the U.S. voluntary standards and conformity
assessment system, adopted the CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 standard in 2019.
c. Regulatory Alternatives and Analysis
The Treasury Department and the IRS considered three options for
defining standards for secure geological storage: (i) The requirements
set forth in 40 CFR part 98 subpart RR; (ii) an election for the
taxpayer to comply with either the subpart RR standards or the
requirements set forth in CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 and (iii) other
alternatives to
[[Page 34060]]
subpart RR, including allowing use of state programs.
In evaluating option (ii), the Treasury Department and the IRS, in
consultation with the EPA, the DOE, and the Interior Department, agree
with commenters that CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 is a viable quantification
methodology that is adequate for the intent and purpose of the statute.
Both subpart RR and CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 require an assessment and
monitoring of potential leakage pathways; quantification of inputs,
losses and storage through a mass balance approach; and documentation
of steps and approaches. Under option (ii), operators of UIC Class II
wells that follow the CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 standard could elect to
report under subpart RR but would not be required to do so. Rather,
they could continue to report to the EPA under subpart UU.
The Treasury Department and the IRS, in consultation with the EPA,
the DOE, and the Interior Department, disagree with commenter
suggestions to allow the reporting rules promulgated by states as an
alternative to subpart RR or CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19. Reporting rules
among states are not uniform and states may have different reporting
requirements and different governing bodies to whom carbon dioxide
injection projects are required to report. The adoption of such rules
by the Treasury Department and the IRS would substantially increase the
administrative burden on the IRS. The Treasury Department and the IRS
did not attempt to determine to what extent particular states'
standards would fulfill the intent and purpose of the statute.
The ability for taxpayers to elect to use the CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19
standard instead of subpart RR could yield economic differences in
three ways. First, if the two standards are different in their costs of
compliance, then allowing a choice allows EOR project operators to
choose the less costly standard. This would reduce costs of compliance
and regulatory burden. Second, to the extent that the difference in
compliance costs between the two standards is high and that difference
is a significant portion of start-up costs, then allowing a less
expensive standard might lead to more investment and more new projects.
Third, operators can use the option that best aligns with their project
goals and timeframes. The Treasury Department and the IRS project that
compliance costs for some taxpayers may be lower under the CSA/ANSI ISO
27916:19 standard than under subpart RR. Some commenters stated that
subpart RR may create a misalignment for UIC Class II wells with both
state mineral property and natural resource conservation laws; and that
such potential misalignment would be costly to taxpayers. This stated
misalignment would not be implicated with the use of the ISO standards.
The Treasury Department and the IRS recognize that the two
standards differ in terms of who would be responsible for reviewing and
approving a sequestration plan and for identifying leakage once a
project is in place. In addition, the standards differ because unless
otherwise required by law, the CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 standard does not
require public reports of the amount of qualified carbon oxide
sequestered, whereas the subpart RR standard does entail the public
provision of such data. The Treasury Department and the IRS did not
attempt to analyze the economic consequences of these differences.
The Treasury Department and the IRS did not attempt to provide
quantitative estimates of the difference in compliance costs between
the CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 standard and a regulatory alternative of
requiring only subpart RR because suitable data are not readily
available at this level of detail. Further, the Treasury Department and
IRS did not attempt to estimate the effects of compliance cost
differences on investment or sequestration.
The Treasury Department and the IRS solicit comments on these
findings and particularly solicit data, models, or other evidence that
could enhance the rigor with which the final regulations are developed.
ii. Credit Recapture
Section 45Q(f)(4) requires the Treasury Department and the IRS to
promulgate regulations to provide for the recapture of section 45Q
credits in the event of leakage. ``Recapture'' refers to the repayment
of the tax credits claimed, and not to the capturing of CO2
that may have leaked from the project after being injected.
In response to Notice 2019-32, 2019-21 I.R.B. 1187, several
commenters requested clarification regarding credit recapture,
including (i) when the tax would be due in relation to the year of a
recapture event, (ii) how long the IRS can ``look back'' to recapture
credits in the event of leakage (lookback period), and (iii) the length
of time after ceasing to claim credits during which a leakage event
would lead to recapture of credits.
All of these issues require a definition of the recapture period.
The proposed regulations provide that the recapture period begins on
the date of the first injection of qualified carbon oxide for disposal
in secure geological storage or use as a tertiary injectant and ends
the earlier of five years after the last taxable year in which the
taxpayer claimed a section 45Q credit or the date monitoring ends under
subpart RR requirements or the CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 standard.
For clarity we will describe two sub-portions of the recapture
period, the ``post-credit-claiming period'' and the ``lookback
period''. The ``post-credit-claiming period'' is the lesser of 5 years
after the last taxable year in which the taxpayer claimed a section 45Q
credit or the date monitoring ends under subpart RR requirements or the
CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 standard. Depending on the project's individual
requirements, the post-credit-claiming period is therefore between zero
and five years. Whereas the ``lookback period'' is the portion of the
recapture period during which the IRS can look back after a leakage
event to recapture credits. Most commenters supported a lookback period
of three to five years.
A leakage event that leads to recapture of credits can occur any
time during the recapture period. A leakage event that occurs after the
recapture period would not lead to recapture of credits.
The proposed regulations provide that any recapture amount will be
accounted for in the taxable year that it is identified and reported.
The amount of credits that can be recaptured in the event of leakage
depends on the length of the lookback period and the amount of the
leakage.
If, during the recapture period, it is determined that qualified
carbon oxide has leaked to the atmosphere, the taxpayer will have a
recapture amount if the leaked amount of qualified carbon oxide exceeds
the amount of qualified carbon dioxide disposed of in secure geological
storage or used as a tertiary injectant in that taxable year. That
excess amount of leaked qualified carbon oxide will be recaptured at a
credit rate calculated on a LIFO basis (that is, such excess leaked
qualified carbon oxide will be deemed attributable first to the first
preceding year, then to second preceding year, and so forth up to five
years) for ease of administration. The taxpayer must add the amount of
the recaptured section 45Q tax credit to the amount of tax due in the
taxable year in which the recapture event occurs. This rule applies
regardless of whether the project injected qualified carbon oxide in
the taxable year.
In response to Notice 2019-32, commenters expressed concerns with
how long the length of a lookback period after the project operator
stops
[[Page 34061]]
claiming section 45Q credits (for example, if the project is finished
or the period for claiming credits ends) that a leakage event can lead
to recapture. Commenters were concerned that investors would deem the
risk too high to invest if the end of the recapture period extended too
long after the final year of claiming section 45Q credits. To address
this concern the proposed regulations provide that the recapture period
begins on the date of first injection of qualified carbon oxide for
disposal in secure geological storage or use as a tertiary injectant
and ends the earlier of three years after the last taxable year in
which the taxpayer claimed a section 45Q credit or the date monitoring
ends under subpart RR requirements or the CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19
standard.
The Treasury Department and the IRS considered alternative
specifications for the lookback period other than five years. Open-
ended or undefined lookback periods would increase the financial risk
associated with the project and dissuade investors, particularly for
projects for which the section 45Q credit would constitute a sizeable
share of revenue. The proposed regulations, by allowing for a specific
and finite lookback period, will encourage more investment in projects
relative to an unspecified or infinite period. The Treasury Department
and the IRS, in consultation with the EPA, the DOE, and the Interior
Department, have determined that for the period after the lookback
period, existing environmental regulations and standards will ensure
integrity consistent with the intent and purpose of the statute.
In examining possible lookback periods, the Treasury Department and
the IRS have not developed a quantitative model to incorporate the
costs of monitoring and the probability of leakage along with the tax
administration burden involved in the lookback period.
The Treasury Department and the IRS welcome comments on the length
of the lookback period and particularly solicit data, models, or other
evidence that could enhance the rigor with which the final regulations
are developed.
iii. Utilization of Qualified Carbon Oxide
Section 45Q(f)(5)(A) provides that ``utilization of qualified
carbon oxide'' means (i) the fixation of such qualified carbon oxide
through photosynthesis or chemosynthesis, such as through the growing
of algae or bacteria; (ii) the chemical conversion of such qualified
carbon oxide to a material or chemical compound in which such qualified
carbon oxide is securely stored; or (iii) the use of such qualified
carbon oxide for any other purpose for which a commercial market exists
(with the exception of use as a tertiary injectant in a qualified
enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project), as determined by the
Secretary.
Section 45Q(f)(5)(B) provides a methodology to determine the amount
of qualified carbon oxide utilized by the taxpayer. Such amount is
equal to the metric tons of qualified carbon oxide which the taxpayer
demonstrates, based upon an analysis of lifecycle greenhouse gas
emissions and subject to such requirements as the Secretary, in
consultation with the Secretary of Energy and the Administrator of the
EPA, determines appropriate, were (i) captured and permanently isolated
from the atmosphere, or (ii) displaced from being emitted into the
atmosphere, through use of a process described in section 45Q(f)(5)(A).
The term ``lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions'' has the same meaning
given such term under subparagraph (H) of section 211(o)(1) of the
Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C. 7545(o)(1)(H)), as in effect on the date of
enactment of the BBA on February 9, 2018, except that ``product'' is
substituted for ``fuel'' each place it appears in such subparagraph.
The term ``lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions'' means the aggregate
quantity of greenhouse gas emissions (including direct emissions and
significant indirect emissions such as significant emissions from land
use changes), related to the full product lifecycle, including all
stages of product and feedstock production and distribution, from
feedstock generation or extraction through the distribution and
delivery and use of the finished product to the ultimate consumer,
where the mass values for all greenhouse gases are adjusted to account
for their relative global warming potential.
Commenters proposed multiple methods for the Treasury Department
and the IRS to allow for calculating ``utilization'' of qualified
carbon oxide. The proposed regulations provide clarifications
regarding: (i) Standards for the lifecycle analysis (LCA) of emissions
that were captured or displaced for purposes of section 45Q(f)(5)(B);
and (ii) the agency with responsibility to review the LCA.
The Treasury Department and the IRS, in consultation with the EPA
and the DOE, have determined that the LCA must be in writing and either
performed or verified by a professionally-licensed third party that
uses generally-accepted standard practices of quantifying the
greenhouse gas emissions of a product or process and comparing that
impact to a baseline. In particular, the analysis must contain
documentation consistent with the International Organization for
Standardization (ISO) 14044:2006, ``Environmental management--Life
cycle assessment--Requirements and Guidelines,'' as well as a statement
documenting the qualifications of the third party.
The proposed regulations require a taxpayer submit an LCA report to
the IRS and the DOE prior to the taxpayer claiming the section 45Q
credit. The LCA will be subject to a technical review by the DOE, and
the IRS, in consultation with the DOE and the EPA, will determine
whether to approve the LCA.
The proposed regulations provide greater clarity and examples for
calculating qualified carbon oxide utilization. This enhanced clarity
should increase transparency and lower compliance burden. In addition,
the proposed regulations allow for oversight of the LCA plans by a
third party, the DOE, and the IRS (in consultation with the DOE and the
EPA); evaluation and approval of the plans before the taxpayer claims
the credit will potentially reduce taxpayer compliance costs and IRS
administrative costs. Following industry-specific standards will also
increase clarity in qualifying for the section 45Q credit.
The proposed regulations provide an economic gain arising from
enhanced clarity regarding the rules of the section 45Q credit within
the context of the intent and purpose of the statute. The Treasury
Department and the IRS project that this clarity will encourage
additional investment in carbon oxide utilization projects relative to
the no-action baseline. The Treasury Department and the IRS have not
estimated this gain because we do not have readily available data or
models to predict (i) the interpretations that taxpayers might have
made in the absence of this guidance, and (ii) the effect of such
guidance on the investment that taxpayers would make, relative to
alternative regulatory approaches or the no-action baseline.
The Treasury Department and the IRS solicit comments on the
economic consequences of these decisions and particularly solicit data,
models, or other evidence that could enhance the rigor with which the
final regulations are developed.
II. Paperwork Reduction Act
The collection of information in these proposed regulations with
respect to section 45Q are in proposed Sec. 1.45Q-1(e), Sec. 1.45Q-
1(h)(3)(iv), Sec. 1.45Q-
[[Page 34062]]
1(h)(2)(v), and Sec. 1.45Q-2(h)(2), Sec. 1.45Q-3(d), and Sec. 1.45Q-
4(c)(1).
The collection of information in proposed Sec. 1.45Q-1(e) is an
election to have the dollar amounts applicable under Sec. 1.45Q-1(b)
apply in lieu of the dollar amounts applicable under Sec. 1.45Q-1(d)
for each metric ton of qualified carbon oxide that a taxpayer captures
using carbon capture equipment which is originally placed in service at
a qualified facility on or after February 9, 2018. A new section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election must be made for each taxable year that the
taxpayer wishes to allow a credit claimant to claim section 45Q
credits. The election must be made on a Form 8933 (or successor forms,
or pursuant to instructions and other guidance), and applies to all
metric tons of qualified carbon oxide captured by the taxpayer at the
qualified facility throughout the full 12-year credit period. The IRS
is contemplating making additional changes to the Form 8933 to take
these proposed regulations into account.
The collection of information in proposed Sec. 1.45Q-1(h)(3)(iv)
is an election that a taxpayer (electing taxpayer) eligible for the
section 45Q credit may make to allow the person that disposes of the
qualified carbon oxide, utilizes the qualified carbon oxide, or uses
the qualified carbon oxide as a tertiary injectant to claim the credit
(credit claimant). The electing taxpayer that makes the section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election must file a statement of election containing the
information described in Sec. 1.45Q-1(h)(3)(iv) with the electing
taxpayer's Federal income tax return or Form 1065 for each taxable year
in which the credit arises. The section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election must be
made in accordance with Form 8933 (or successor forms, or pursuant to
instructions and other guidance) no later than the time prescribed by
law (including extensions) for filing the Federal income tax return for
the year in which the credit arises. The election may not be filed with
an amended Federal income tax return, an amended Form 1065, or an AAR,
as applicable, after the prescribed date (including extensions) for
filing the original Federal income tax return or Form 1065 for the
year, with the exception of amended Federal income tax returns, amended
Forms 1065, or AARs, as applicable, for any taxable year ending after
February 9, 2018, and before taxable years beginning after the date of
issuance of this proposed regulation. New section 45Q(f)(3)(B)
elections must be made for each taxable year that the electing taxpayer
wishes to allow credit claimants to claim section 45Q credits. The IRS
is contemplating making additional changes to the Form 8933 to take
these proposed regulations into account.
The collection of information in proposed Sec. 1.45Q-1(h)(2)(v)
requires that if a taxpayer enters into a binding written contract with
a third party that physically carries out the disposal, injection, or
utilization of qualified carbon oxide, the existence of each contract
and the parties involved must be reported to the IRS annually on a Form
8933 (or successor forms, or pursuant to instructions and other
guidance) by each party to the contract, regardless of the party
claiming the credit. The IRS is contemplating making additional changes
to the Form 8933 to take these proposed regulations into account.
The collection of information in proposed Sec. 1.45Q-2(h)(2)
requires that a taxpayer that claims a section 45Q credit for qualified
carbon oxide that is captured and then used as a tertiary injectant in
a qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project certify such
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project as required
under Sec. 1.43-3. This requires that the taxpayer obtain a petroleum
engineer's certification under Sec. 1.43-3(a)(3) for each project that
must be attached to a Form 8933 (or successor forms, or pursuant to
instructions and other guidance) and filed not later than the last date
prescribed by law (including extensions) for filing the operator's or
designated owner's Federal income tax return or Form 1065 for the first
taxable year in which qualified carbon oxide is injected into the
reservoir. If a section 45Q credit is claimed on an amended Federal
income tax return, an amended Form 1065, or an AAR, as applicable, the
petroleum engineer's certification will be treated as filed timely if
it is attached to a Form 8933 that is submitted with such amended
federal income tax return, amended Form 1065, or AAR. With respect to a
section 45Q credit that is claimed on a timely filed Federal income tax
return or Form 1065 for a taxable year ending after February 9, 2018
and beginning before the date of issuance of this proposed regulation,
for which the petroleum engineer's certification was not submitted, the
petroleum engineer's certification will be treated as filed timely if
it is attached to an amended Form 8933 for any taxable year ending
after February 9, 2018, but not for taxable years beginning after June
2, 2020. Additionally, the taxpayer is required to provide an
operator's continued certification under Sec. 1.43-3(b)(3) for each
project that must be attached to a Form 8933 (or successor forms, or
pursuant to instructions and other guidance) and filed not later than
the last date prescribed by law (including extensions) for filing the
operator's or designated owner's Federal income tax return or Form 1065
for taxable years after the taxable year for which the petroleum
engineer's certification is filed but not after the taxable year in
which injection activity ceases and all injection wells are plugged and
abandoned. The IRS is contemplating making additional changes to the
Form 8933 to take these proposed regulations into account.
The collection of information in proposed Sec. 1.45Q-3(d) requires
a taxpayer that claims a section 45Q credit for qualified carbon oxide
that is captured and then used as a tertiary injectant in a qualified
enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project to certify the volume of
carbon oxide claimed for purposes of section 45Q. A taxpayer that
reported volumes of carbon oxide to the EPA pursuant to subpart RR may
self-certify the volume of carbon oxide claimed for purposes of section
45Q. Alternatively, if the taxpayer determined volumes pursuant to CSA/
ANSI ISO 27916:19, a taxpayer may prepare documentation as outlined in
CSA/ANSI 27916:2019 internally, but such documentation must be provided
to a qualified independent engineer or geologist, who then must certify
that the documentation provided, including the mass balance
calculations as well as information regarding monitoring and
containment assurance is accurate and complete. Taxpayers that capture
carbon oxide giving rise to the section 45Q credit must file Form 8933
(or successor forms, or pursuant to instructions and other guidance)
with a timely filed tax return, including extensions. Taxpayers that
dispose of, inject, or utilize qualified carbon oxide must also file
Form 8933 (or successor forms, or pursuant to instructions and other
guidance) with a timely filed F Federal income tax return or Form 1065,
including extensions. The IRS is contemplating making additional
changes to the Form 8933 to take these proposed regulations into
account.
The collection of information in proposed Sec. 1.45Q-4(c)(1)
requires a taxpayer that utilizes qualified carbon oxide to measure the
amount of carbon oxide captured and utilized through a combination of
direct measurement and life cycle analysis (LCA). The measurement and
written LCA report must be performed by or verified by an independent
third party. The report must contain documentation consistent with the
International Organization for Standardization (ISO) 14044:2006,
[[Page 34063]]
``Environmental management--Life cycle assessment--Requirements and
Guidelines,'' as well as a statement documenting the qualifications of
the third party, including proof of appropriate professional license or
foreign equivalent, and an affidavit from the third-party stating that
it is independent from the taxpayer. The taxpayer must submit the
written LCA report to the IRS and the DOE. The LCA will be subject to a
technical review by the DOE, and the IRS, in consultation with the DOE
and the EPA, will determine whether to approve the LCA.
For purposes of the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (51087 U.S.C.
3507(d)) (PRA), the reporting burden associated with proposed Sec.
1.45Q-1(e), Sec. 1.45Q-1(h)(3)(iv), Sec. 1.45Q-1(h)(2)(v), Sec.
1.45Q-2(h)(2), Sec. 1.45Q-3(d), and Sec. 1.45Q-4(c)(1) will be
reflected in the IRS Paperwork Reduction Act Submission for the Form
8933 (OMB control numbers 1545-0123 and 1545-2132). The IRS is
anticipating making revisions to Form 8933 to take these proposed
regulations into account. The Treasury Department and the IRS request
comments on all aspects of information collection burdens related to
the proposed regulations. In addition, when available, drafts of IRS
forms are posted for comment at www.irs.gov/draftforms.
The current status of the Paperwork Reduction Act submissions
related to the section 45Q credit is provided in the following table.
The section 45Q provisions are included in aggregated burden estimates
for the OMB control numbers listed below which, in the case of 1545-
0123, represents a total estimated burden time, including all other
related forms and schedules for corporations, of 3.157 billion hours
and total estimated monetized costs of $58.148 billion ($2017). The
burden estimates provided in the OMB control numbers are aggregate
amounts that relate to the entire package of forms associated with the
OMB control number, and will in the future include but not isolate the
estimated burden of only the section 45Q requirements. These numbers
are therefore unrelated to the future calculations needed to assess the
burden imposed by the proposed regulations. No burden estimates
specific to the proposed regulations are currently available. The
Treasury Department has not estimated the burden, including that of any
new information collections, related to the requirements under the
proposed regulations. Those estimates would capture both changes made
to section 45Q by the BBA and those that arise out of discretionary
authority exercised in the proposed regulations. The Treasury
Department and the IRS request comments on all aspects of information
collection burdens related to the proposed regulations.
When available, drafts of IRS forms are posted for comment at
www.irs.gov/draftforms.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Form Type of filer OMB No(s). Status
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Form 8933............................. Business................. 1545-2132 Sixty-day notice published in
the Federal Register on 10/
21/19 (84 FR 56283). Public
comment period closed on 12/
20/19. Thirty-day notice
published in the Federal
Register on 1/31/20 (85 FR
5776). Public comment period
closed on 3/2/20. OIRA
approval is pending.
Form 8933............................. Business (NEW Model)..... 1545-0123 Sixty-day notice published in
the Federal Register on 9/30/
19 (84 FR 51718). Public
Comment period closed on 11/
29/19. Thirty-day notice
published in the Federal
Register on 12/19/19 (84 FR
69825). Public Comment
period closed on 1/21/20.
Approved by OIRA on 1/30/20.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Link: https://hs-www-federalregister-gov.tickly.io/documents/2019/10/21/2019-22844/proposed-collection-comment-request-for-form-8933.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
III. Regulatory Flexibility Act
The Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.) (RFA) imposes
certain requirements with respect to Federal rules that are subject to
the notice and comment requirements of section 553(b) of the
Administrative Procedure Act (5 U.S.C. 551 et seq.) and that are likely
to have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small
entities. Unless an agency determines that a proposal is not likely to
have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small
entities, section 603 of the RFA requires the agency to present an
initial regulatory flexibility analysis (IRFA) of the proposed rule.
The Treasury Department and the IRS have not determined whether the
proposed rule, when finalized, will likely have a significant economic
impact on a substantial number of small entities. This determination
requires further study. However, because there is a possibility of
significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities,
an IRFA is provided in these proposed regulations. The Treasury
Department and the IRS invite comments on both the number of entities
affected and the economic impact on small entities.
Pursuant to section 7805(f), this notice of proposed rulemaking has
been submitted to the Chief Counsel of Advocacy of the Small Business
Administration for comment on its impact on small business.
1. Need for and Objectives of the Rule
The proposed regulations will provide greater clarity to taxpayers
for purposes of claiming the section 45Q credit for the capture and
disposal, injection, or utilization of qualified carbon oxide. The
proposed rule is expected to encourage taxpayers to invest in carbon
capture technologies. Thus, the Treasury Department and the IRS intend
and expect that the proposed rule will deliver benefits across the
economy that will beneficially impact various industries and reduce
emissions of carbon oxides that would otherwise be released into the
atmosphere as industrial emission of greenhouse gasses or lead to such
release.
2. Affected Small Entities
The Small Business Administration estimates in its 2018 Small
Business Profile that 99.9 percent of United States businesses meet its
definition of a small business. The applicability of these proposed
regulations does not depend on the size of the business, as defined by
the Small Business Administration. As described more fully in the
preamble to this proposed regulation and in this IRFA, these rules may
affect a variety of different businesses across serval different
industries.
The section 45Q credit incentivizes three different categories of
activities related to captured carbon oxide. First, the section 45Q
credit is available to taxpayers who capture carbon oxide and dispose
of it in secure geological storage. This would occur if it were
injected into a geological formation, such as a deep saline formation,
an oil and gas reservoir, or an unminable coal
[[Page 34064]]
seam. The taxpayer claiming the credit for carbon oxide that is
securely stored can be either the taxpayer who owns the capture
equipment, or if an election is made, the taxpayer who disposes of the
carbon oxide.
Second, the section 45Q credit is also available for carbon oxide
captured and used as a tertiary injectant in a qualified enhanced oil
or natural gas recovery project and disposed of in secure geological
storage. The taxpayer claiming the credit for carbon oxide that is used
as a tertiary injectant in enhanced oil recovery projects can be either
the taxpayer who owns the capture equipment, or if an election is made,
the taxpayer who uses the carbon oxide as a tertiary injectant in a
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project.
And third, the section 45Q credit is available for carbon oxide
``utilized'' by fixing it through photosynthesis or chemosynthesis,
converted to a material or chemical compound in which it is securely
stored, or used for any other purpose for which a commercial market
exists. The taxpayer claiming the credit for utilization of carbon
oxide can be either the taxpayer who owns the carbon capture equipment,
or if an election is made, the taxpayer who utilizes the carbon oxide.
Because the potential credit claimants in all three of these
scenarios can vary, including potential tax equity investors from the
financial services sector as credit claimants, it is difficult to
estimate at this time the impact of these proposed regulations, if any,
on small businesses.
The Treasury Department and the IRS expect to receive more
information on the impact on small businesses through comments on this
proposed rule and again when taxpayers start to claim the section 45Q
credit using the guidance and procedures provided in these proposed
regulations.
3. Impact of the Rule
The proposed regulations will allow taxpayers to plan investments
and transactions based on the ability to claim the section 45Q credit.
The increased use of the section 45Q credit may lead to increased
investment in infrastructure to transport carbon dioxide, and increased
development of carbon capture technologies. In addition, the increased
use of the section 45Q credit will incentivize the development of
technologies for utilization of carbon oxide. The recordkeeping and
reporting requirements will increase for taxpayers that claim the
section 45Q credit. This includes costs associated with the taxpayer
filing the Form 8933, as well as required election statements and
maintaining records to substantiate carbon capture of carbon oxide,
disposal in secure geological storage, use as a tertiary injectant in a
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project and disposal in
secure geological storage, or utilization. Each taxpayer will be
required to file a separate Form 8933 for each year that a section 45Q
credit is claimed or that an election is made with respect to a section
45Q credit. Although the Treasury Department and the IRS do not have
sufficient data to determine precisely the likely extent of the
increased costs of compliance, the estimated burden of complying with
the recordkeeping and reporting requirements are described in the
Paperwork Reduction Act section of the preamble.
4. Alternatives Considered
As described in more detail in the Regulatory Impact Analysis of
this preamble, the Treasury Department and the IRS considered
alternatives to the proposed regulations. For example, in providing
rules related to how to demonstrate secure geological storage in the
case of tertiary injection and disposal through secure geological
storage, the Treasury Department and the IRS considered whether to (i)
require compliance with subpart RR, (ii) allow use of subpart RR or
CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19, or (iii) other alternatives to subpart RR
including use of state programs. Commenters to Notice 2019-32, 2019-21
I.R.B. 1187, consistently recommended CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19 as a
potential alternative to subpart RR. The Treasury Department and the
IRS, in consultation with the DOE, the EPA and the Interior Department,
agreed that, in the case of tertiary injection and disposal through
secure geological storage, allowing the use of subpart RR or CSA/ANSI
ISO 27916:19 would sufficiently demonstrate secure geological storage
for purposes of the statutory requirement, without creating or imposing
undue burdens on taxpayers.
5. Duplicative, Overlapping, or Conflicting Federal Rules
The proposed rule would not duplicate, overlap, or conflict with
any relevant Federal rules. As discussed above, the proposed rule would
merely provide procedures and definitions to allow taxpayers to claim
the section 45Q credit. The Treasury Department and the IRS invite
input from interested members of the public about identifying and
avoiding overlapping, duplicative, or conflicting requirements.
Comments and Requests for a Public Hearing
Before these proposed regulations are adopted as final regulations,
consideration will be given to any comments that are submitted timely
to the IRS as prescribed in this preamble under the ADDRESSES heading.
The Treasury Department and the IRS request comments on all aspects of
the proposed regulations. Specifically, in section 4 of the Summary of
Comments and Explanation of Provisions, the Treasury Department and the
IRS request specific comments on how to achieve consistency in
boundaries and baselines so that similarly situated taxpayers will be
treated consistently. The Treasury Department and the IRS also request
specific comments regarding the definition of commercial markets and
standards for Lifecycle Analysis. Additionally, in section 5 of the
Summary of Comments and Explanation of Provisions, the Treasury
Department and the IRS request specific comments on how to apply the
recapture provisions to section 45Q credits that are carried forward to
future taxable years due to insuffificent income tax liability in the
current taxable year.
Any electronic comments submitted, and to the extent practicable
any paper comments submitted, will be made available at
www.regulations.gov or upon request. A public hearing will be scheduled
if requested in writing by any person who timely submits electronic or
written comments as prescribed in this preamble under the ``DATES''
heading. Requests for a public hearing are also encouraged to be made
electronically. If a public hearing is scheduled, notice of the date
and time for the public hearing will be published in the Federal
Register. Announcement 2020-4, 2020-17 IRB 1, provides that until
further notice, public hearings conducted by the IRS will be held
telephonically. Any telephonic hearing will be made accessible to
people with disabilities.
IV. Unfunded Mandates Reform Act
Section 202 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 requires
that agencies assess anticipated costs and benefits and take certain
other actions before issuing a final rule that includes any Federal
mandate that may result in expenditures in any one year by a state,
local, or tribal government, in the aggregate, or by the private
sector, of $100 million in 1995 dollars, updated annually for
inflation. In 2018, that threshold is approximately $150 million. This
rule does not include any Federal mandate that may result in
expenditures by state, local, or tribal
[[Page 34065]]
governments, or by the private sector in excess of that threshold.
V. Executive Order 13132: Federalism
Executive Order 13132 (entitled Federalism) prohibits an agency (to
the extent practicable and permitted by law) from promulgating any
regulation that has federalism implications, unless the agency meets
the consultation and funding requirements of section 6 of the Executive
Order, if the rule either imposes substantial, direct compliance costs
on state and local governments, and is not required by statute, or
preempts state law. This proposed rule does not have federalism
implications and does not impose substantial direct compliance costs on
state and local governments or preempt state law within the meaning of
the Executive Order.
Drafting Information
The principal author of the proposed regulations is Maggie Stehn of
the Office of Associate Chief Counsel (Passthroughs & Special
Industries). However, other personnel from the Treasury Department and
the IRS participated in the development of the proposed regulations.
List of Subjects
26 CFR Part 1
Income taxes, Reporting and recordkeeping requirements.
Proposed Amendments to the Regulations
Accordingly, 26 CFR part 1 is proposed to be amended as follows:
PART 1--INCOME TAXES
0
Paragraph 1. The authority citation for part 1 is amended by adding
entries in numerical order to read in part as follows:
Authority: 26 U.S.C. 7805 * * *
* * * * *
Section 1.45Q-1 also issued under 26 U.S.C. 45Q.
Section 1.45Q-2 also issued under 26 U.S.C. 45Q(c), (d), and (e).
Section 1.45Q-3 also issued under 26 U.S.C. 45Q(f)(2).
Section 1.45Q-4 also issued under 26 U.S.C. 45Q(f)(5).
Section 1.45Q-5 also issued under 26 U.S.C. 45Q(f)(4).
* * * * *
0
Par. 2. Sections 1.45Q-0, 1.45Q-1, 1.45Q-2, 1.45Q-3, 1.45Q-4, and
1.45Q-5 are added to read as follows:
Sec. 1.45Q-0 Table of Contents.
This section lists the captions contained in Sec. Sec. 1.45Q-1
through 1.45Q-5.
Sec. 1.45Q-1 Credit for Carbon Oxide Sequestration.
(a) In general.
(b) Credit amount for carbon capture equipment originally placed
in service before February 9, 2018.
(c) Credit amount for carbon capture equipment originally placed
in service on or after February 9, 2018.
(d) Applicable dollar amount.
(1) Applicable dollar amount for any taxable year beginning in a
calendar year after 2016 and before 2027 for qualified carbon oxide
not used as a tertiary injectant or utilized.
(2) Applicable dollar amount for any taxable year beginning in a
calendar year after 2026 for qualified carbon oxide not used as a
tertiary injectant or utilized.
(3) Applicable dollar amount for any taxable year beginning in a
calendar year after 2016 and before 2027 for qualified carbon oxide
used as a tertiary injectant or utilized.
(4) Applicable dollar amount for any taxable year beginning in a
calendar year after 2026 for qualified carbon oxide used as a
tertiary injectant or utilized.
(e) Election to apply the $10 and $20 credit amounts in lieu of
the applicable dollar amounts.
(f) Application of section 45Q for certain carbon capture
equipment placed in service before February 9, 2018.
(g) Installation of additional carbon capture equipment.
(1) Allocation of section 45Q credits for facilities installing
additional carbon capture equipment.
(2) Additional carbon capture equipment.
(3) New carbon capture equipment.
(4) Examples.
(i) Example 1.
(ii) Example 2.
(iii) Example 3.
(h) Eligibility for the section 45Q credit.
(1) Person to whom the section 45Q credit is attributable.
(i) Equipment placed in service before February 9, 2018.
(ii) Equipment placed in service on or after February 9, 2018.
(iii) Reporting.
(2) Contractually ensuring disposal, injection, or utilization
of qualified carbon oxide.
(i) Binding written contract.
(ii) Multiple binding written contracts permitted.
(iii) Contract provisions.
(iv) Reporting of contract information.
(v) Relationship with election to allow section 45Q credit.
(3) Election to allow the section 45Q credit to another
taxpayer.
(i) Example.
(ii) Time and manner of making election.
(iii) Annual election.
(iv) Required information.
(v) Requirements for credit claimant.
(i) Applicability date.
Sec. 1.45Q-2 Definitions for Purposes of Sec. Sec. 1.45Q-1 through
1.45Q-5.
(a) Qualified carbon oxide.
(b) Recycled carbon oxide.
(c) Carbon capture equipment.
(1) Use of carbon capture equipment.
(2) Carbon capture equipment components.
(3) Excluded components.
(i) In general.
(ii) Calculation.
(iii) Consequences.
(d) Industrial facility.
(1) Exclusion.
(2) Industrial source.
(3) Manufacturing process.
(4) Example.
(e) Electricity generating facility.
(f) Direct air capture facility.
(g) Qualified facility.
(1) Emissions and capture requirements.
(2) Examples.
(i) Example 1.
(ii) Example 2.
(iii) Example 3.
(3) Annualization of first-year qualified carbon oxide emission
and capture amounts.
(4) Election for applicable facilities.
(i) Applicable facility.
(ii) Time and manner of making election.
(iii) Retroactive credit revocations.
(5) Retrofitted qualified facility or carbon capture equipment
(80/20 Rule).
(h) Qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project.
(1) Application of Sec. Sec. 1.43-2 and 1.43-3.
(2) Required certification.
(3) Natural gas.
(4) Timely filing of petroleum engineer's certification.
(5) Carbon oxide injected in oil reservoirs.
(6) Tertiary injectant.
(i) Section 45Q credit.
(j) Applicability date.
Sec. 1.45Q-3 Secure Geological Storage.
(a) In general.
(b) Requirements for secure geological storage.
(c) Documentation.
(d) Certification.
(e) Failure to submit complete documentation or certification.
(f) Applicability date.
Sec. 1.45Q-4 Utilization of Qualified Carbon Oxide.
(a) In general.
(b) Measurement.
(c) Lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions and lifecycle analysis.
(1) In general.
(2) Measurement.
(3) Approval of the LCA.
(4) [Reserved]
(d)-(e) [Reserved]
(f) Applicability date.
Sec. 1.45Q-5 Recapture of Credit.
(a) Recapture event.
(b) Ceases to be captured, disposed of, or used as a tertiary
injectant.
(c) Leaked amount of qualified carbon oxide.
(d) Recaptured qualified carbon oxide.
(e) Recapture amount.
(f) Recapture period.
(g) Application of recapture.
(1) In general.
[[Page 34066]]
(2) Calculation.
(3) Multiple units.
(4) Multiple taxpayers.
(5) Reporting.
(6) Examples.
(i) Example 1.
(ii) Example 2.
(iii) Example 3.
(iv) Example 4.
(v) Example 5.
(vi) Example 6.
(h) Recapture in the event of intentional removal from storage.
(i) Limited exceptions.
(j) Applicability date.
Sec. 1.45Q-1 Credit for Carbon Oxide Sequestration.
(a) In general. For purposes of section 38 of the Internal Revenue
Code (Code), the carbon oxide sequestration credit is determined under
section 45Q of the Code and this section. Generally, the amount of the
section 45Q credit and the party that is eligible to claim the credit
depend on whether the taxpayer captures qualified carbon oxide using
carbon capture equipment originally placed in service at a qualified
facility before February 9, 2018, or on or after February 9, 2018, and
whether the taxpayer disposes of the qualified carbon oxide in secure
geological storage without using it as a tertiary injectant in a
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project (disposal), uses
it as a tertiary injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or natural gas
recovery project and disposes of it in secure geological storage
(injection), or utilizes it in a manner described in section 45Q(f)(5)
and Sec. 1.45Q-4 (utilization). The section 45Q credit applies only
with respect to qualified carbon oxide the capture and disposal,
injection, or utilization of which is within the United States (within
the meaning of section 638(1) of the Code) or a possession of the
United States (within the meaning of section 638(2)).
(b) Credit amount for carbon capture equipment originally placed in
service before February 9, 2018. For carbon capture equipment
originally placed in service at a qualified facility before February 9,
2018, the amount of credit determined under section 45Q(a) and this
section is the sum of--
(1) $20 per metric ton of qualified carbon oxide that is--
(i) Captured by the taxpayer at the qualified facility and disposed
of by the taxpayer in secure geological storage, and
(ii) Not used by the taxpayer as a tertiary injectant in a
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project or utilized by
the taxpayer in a manner described in section 45Q(f)(5) and Sec.
1.45Q-4, and
(2) $10 per metric ton of qualified carbon oxide that is--
(i) Captured by the taxpayer at the qualified facility and used by
the taxpayer as a tertiary injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or
natural gas recovery project, and disposed of by the taxpayer in secure
geological storage, or
(ii) Captured by the taxpayer at the qualified facility and
utilized by the taxpayer in a manner described in section 45Q(f)(5) and
Sec. 1.45Q-4.
(3) Inflation Adjustment. In the case of any taxable year beginning
in a calendar year after 2009, there is substituted for each dollar
amount contained in paragraphs (b)(1) and (b)(2) of this section an
amount equal to the product of--
(i) Such dollar amount, multiplied by
(ii) The inflation adjustment factor for such calendar year
determined under section 43(b)(3)(B) for such calendar year, determined
by substituting ``2008'' for ``1990.''
(c) Credit amount for carbon capture equipment originally placed in
service on or after February 9, 2018. For carbon capture equipment
originally placed in service at a qualified facility on or after
February 9, 2018, the amount of credit determined under sections
45Q(a)(3) and (4) and this section is the sum of--
(1) The applicable dollar amount (as determined under paragraphs
(d)(1) and (d)(2) of this section) per metric ton of qualified carbon
oxide that is captured during the 12-year period beginning on the date
the equipment was originally placed in service, and is--
(i) Disposed of by the taxpayer in secure geological storage, and
(ii) Not used by the taxpayer as a tertiary injectant in a
qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project or utilized by
the taxpayer in a manner described in sections 45Q(f)(5) and Sec.
1.45Q-4; and
(2) The applicable dollar amount (as determined under paragraphs
(d)(3) and (d)(4) of this section) per metric ton of qualified carbon
oxide that is captured during the 12-year period beginning on the date
the equipment as originally placed in service and is--
(i) Used by the taxpayer as a tertiary injectant in a qualified
enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project and disposed of by the
taxpayer in secure geological storage, or
(ii) Utilized by the taxpayer in a manner described in sections
45Q(f)(5) and Sec. 1.45Q-4.
(d) Applicable dollar amount. In general, the applicable dollar
amount depends on whether section 45Q(a)(3) and paragraph (c)(1) of
this section applies or section 45Q(a)(4) and paragraph (c)(2) of this
section applies, and whether the taxable year begins in a calendar year
after 2016 and before 2027.
(1) Applicable dollar amount for any taxable year beginning in a
calendar year after 2016 and before 2027 for qualified carbon oxide not
used as a tertiary injectant or utilized. For purposes of section
45Q(a)(3) and paragraph (c)(1) of this section, the applicable dollar
amount for each taxable year beginning in a calendar year after 2016
and before 2027 is:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Applicable
Year dollar amount
------------------------------------------------------------------------
2017.................................................... $22.66
2018.................................................... 25.70
2019.................................................... 28.74
2020.................................................... 31.77
2021.................................................... 34.81
2022.................................................... 37.85
2023.................................................... 40.89
2024.................................................... 43.92
2025.................................................... 46.96
2026.................................................... 50.00
------------------------------------------------------------------------
(2) Applicable dollar amount for any taxable year beginning in a
calendar year after 2026 for qualified carbon oxide not used as a
tertiary injectant or utilized. For purposes of section 45Q(a)(3) and
paragraph (c)(1) of this section, the applicable dollar amount for any
taxable year beginning in any calendar year after 2026 is an amount
equal to the product of $50 and the inflation adjustment factor for the
calendar year determined under section 43(b)(3)(B) for the calendar
year, determined by substituting ``2025'' for ``1990.''
(3) Applicable dollar amount for any taxable year beginning in a
calendar year after 2016 and before 2027 for qualified carbon oxide
used as a tertiary injectant or utilized. For purposes of section
45Q(a)(4) and paragraph (c)(2) of this section, the applicable dollar
amount for each taxable year beginning in a calendar year after 2016
and before 2027 is:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Applicable
Year dollar amount
------------------------------------------------------------------------
2017.................................................... $12.83
2018.................................................... 15.29
2019.................................................... 17.76
2020.................................................... 20.22
2021.................................................... 22.68
2022.................................................... 25.15
2023.................................................... 27.61
2024.................................................... 30.07
2025.................................................... 32.54
2026.................................................... 35.00
------------------------------------------------------------------------
(4) Applicable dollar amount for any taxable year beginning in a
calendar year after 2026 for qualified carbon oxide used as a tertiary
injectant or
[[Page 34067]]
utilized. For purposes of section 45Q(a)(4) and paragraph (c)(2) of
this section, the applicable dollar amount for any taxable year
beginning in any calendar year after 2026, is an amount equal to the
product of $35 and the inflation adjustment factor for such calendar
year determined under section 43(b)(3)(B) for such calendar year,
determined by substituting ``2025'' for ``1990.''
(e) Election to apply the $10 and $20 credit amounts in lieu of the
applicable dollar amounts. For purposes of determining the carbon oxide
sequestration credit under this section, a taxpayer may elect to have
the dollar amounts applicable under section 45Q(a)(1) or (2) and
paragraph (b) of this section apply in lieu of the dollar amounts
applicable under section 45Q(a)(3) or (4) and paragraph (d) of this
section for each metric ton of qualified carbon oxide which is captured
by the taxpayer using carbon capture equipment which is originally
placed in service at a qualified facility on or after February 9, 2018.
The election must be made on a Form 8933, Carbon Oxide Sequestration
Credit (or successor forms, or pursuant to instructions and other
guidance), and applies to all metric tons of qualified carbon oxide
captured by the taxpayer at the qualified facility throughout the full
12-year credit period.
(f) Application of section 45Q for certain carbon capture equipment
placed in service before February 9, 2018. In the case of any carbon
capture equipment placed in service before February 9, 2018, the
credits under section 45Q(a)(1) and (a)(2) and paragraphs (b)(1) and
(b)(2) of this section apply with respect to qualified carbon oxide
captured using such equipment before the end of the calendar year in
which the Secretary, in consultation with the Administrator of the
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), certifies that, during the
period beginning after October 3, 2008, a total of 75,000,000 metric
tons of qualified carbon oxide have been taken into account in
accordance with section 45Q(a), as in effect on February 9, 2018, and
section 45Q(a)(1) and (2). In general, a taxpayer may not claim credits
under section 45Q(a)(1) and (a)(2) in taxable years after the year in
which the 75,000,000 metric ton limit is reached with respect to carbon
capture equipment placed in service before February 9, 2018. However,
see Sec. 1.45Q-2(g)(4) regarding the election for applicable
facilities to treat certain carbon capture equipment as having been
placed in service on February 9, 2018.
(g) Installation of additional carbon capture equipment. In
general, a facility that placed carbon capture equipment in service
before February 9, 2018, is entitled to the credit amounts for property
placed in service before February 9, 2018, subject to the limitations
under paragraph (f) of this section. The same facility may place
additional carbon capture equipment in service on or after February 9,
2018. The additional carbon capture equipment is eligible to qualify
for the section 45Q credit amounts for equipment placed in service on
or after February 9, 2018.
(1) Allocation of section 45Q credits for facilities installing
additional carbon capture equipment. In the case of a qualified
facility placed in service before February 9, 2018, for which
additional carbon capture equipment is placed in service on or after
February 9, 2018, the amount of qualified carbon oxide which is
captured by the taxpayer is equal to--
(i) For purposes of section 45Q(a)(1)(A) and (2)(A), and paragraphs
(b)(1) and (b)(2) of this section, the lesser of the total amount of
qualified carbon oxide captured at such facility for the taxable year,
or the total amount of the carbon dioxide capture capacity of the
carbon capture equipment in service at such facility on February 8,
2018, and
(ii) For purposes of section 45Q(a)(3)(A) and (4)(A), and
paragraphs (c)(1) and (c)(2) of this section, an amount (not less than
zero) equal to the excess of the total amount of qualified carbon oxide
captured at such facility for the taxable year, over the total amount
of the carbon dioxide capture capacity of the carbon capture equipment
in service at such facility on February 8, 2018.
(2) Additional carbon capture equipment. A physical modification or
equipment addition that results in an increase in the carbon dioxide
capture capacity of existing carbon capture equipment constitutes the
installation of additional carbon capture equipment. Merely increasing
the amount of carbon dioxide captured by existing carbon capture
equipment, even if it operated above the carbon dioxide capture
capacity, does not constitute the installation of additional carbon
capture equipment.
(3) New carbon capture equipment. The cost of a physical
modification or equipment addition with a cost that satisfies the 80/20
Rule in Sec. 1.45Q-2(g)(5) constitutes the installation of new carbon
capture equipment rather than the installation of additional carbon
capture equipment.
(4) Examples. The following examples illustrate the rules of this
paragraph (g):
(i) Example 1. Taxpayer X owns qualifying facility QF. In 2017,
X placed in service three units of carbon capture equipment--CC1,
CC2, and CC3--to capture carbon dioxide emitted by QF. Each of CC1,
CC2, and CC3 are capable of capturing 50,000 metric tons of carbon
dioxide. In 2017, X enters into a binding written contract with Y to
provide 100,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide annually for Y to
dispose of in secure geological storage. X operates CC1 and CC2 to
capture carbon dioxide pursuant to the binding written contract with
Y, leaving CC3 idle. In 2020, X enters into a binding written
contract with Z to provide 50,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide
annually for Z to dispose of in secure geological storage. X
operates CC3 to capture carbon dioxide pursuant to the binding
written contract with Z. CC3 is not additional carbon capture
equipment under Sec. 1.45Q-1(g)(2). As a result, any section 45Q
credits attributable to the carbon dioxide captured by CC3 and
disposed of by Z are calculated under section 45Q(a)(1) and Sec.
1.45Q-1(b)(1), and are subject to the 75,000,000 metric ton
limitation described in section 45Q(g) and Sec. 1.45Q-1(f).
(ii) Example 2. Assume the same facts as in Example 1, except
that in 2019, X makes a physical modification to upgrade CC3 that
results in the ability of CC3 to capture 100,000 metric tons of
carbon dioxide. The physical modification to upgrade CC3 does not
satisfy the 80/20 Rule in Sec. 1.45Q-2(g)(5). In 2020 X enters into
a binding written contract with Z to provide 100,000 metric tons of
carbon dioxide annually for Z to dispose of in secure geological
storage. X operates CC3 to capture carbon dioxide pursuant to the
binding written contract with Z. Because the carbon dioxide capture
capacity of CC3 was 50,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide before the
physical modification and 100,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide
after the physical modification, the physical modification to
upgrade CC3 is considered the installation of additional carbon
capture equipment under Sec. 1.45Q-1(g)(2). As a result, any
section 45Q credits attributable to the first 50,000 metric tons of
carbon dioxide captured by CC3 and disposed of by Z are calculated
under section 45Q(a)(1) and Sec. 1.45Q-1(b)(1), and are subject to
the 75,000,000 metric ton limitation described in section 45Q(g) and
Sec. 1.45Q-1(f). Any section 45Q credits attributable to additional
carbon dioxide captured by CC3 and disposed of by Z in excess of
those first 50,000 metric tons are calculated under section
45Q(a)(4) and Sec. 1.45Q-1(c)(2), and are not subject to the
75,000,000 metric ton limitation described in section 45Q(g) and
Sec. 1.45Q-1(f).
(iii) Example 3. Assume the same facts as in Example 2, except
that the physical modification to upgrade CC3 satisfies the 80/20
Rule in Sec. 1.45Q-2(g)(5). The physical modification to upgrade
CC3 is considered the installation of new carbon capture equipment
under Sec. 1.45Q-1(g)(2) and Sec. 1.45Q-1(g)(3). As a result, any
section 45Q credits attributable to carbon dioxide captured by CC3
and disposed of by Z are calculated under section 45Q(a)(4) and
[[Page 34068]]
Sec. 1.45Q-1(c)(2), and are not subject to the 75,000,000 metric
ton limitation described in section 45Q(g) and Sec. 1.45Q-1(f).
(h) Eligibility for the section 45Q credit. The following rules
determine who may claim the section 45Q credit.
(1) Person to whom the section 45Q credit is attributable. In
general, the person to whom the credit is attributable is the person
who may claim the credit. Except as provided in Sec. 1.45Q-1(h)(3),
the section 45Q credit is attributable to the following persons--
(i) Equipment placed in service before February 9, 2018. In the
case of qualified carbon oxide captured using carbon capture equipment
that is originally placed in service at a qualified facility before
February 9, 2018, the section 45Q credit is attributable to the person
that captures and physically or contractually ensures the disposal,
injection, or utilization of such qualified carbon oxide.
(ii) Equipment placed in service on or after February 9, 2018. In
the case of qualified carbon oxide captured using carbon capture
equipment that is originally placed in service at a qualified facility
on or after February 9, 2018, the section 45Q credit is attributable to
the person that owns the carbon capture equipment and physically or
contractually ensures the capture and disposal, injection, or
utilization of such qualified carbon oxide.
(iii) Reporting. The taxpayer described in Sec. 1.45Q-1(h)(1) as
eligible to claim the section 45Q credit must claim the credit on a
Form 8933 (or successor forms, or pursuant to instructions and other
guidance) with the taxpayer's Federal income tax return or Form 1065
for each taxable year for which the taxpayer is eligible. The taxpayer
must provide the name and location of the qualified facilities at which
the qualified carbon oxide was captured. If the taxpayer is claiming
the section 45Q credit on an amended Federal income tax return, an
amended Form 1065, or an AAR, as applicable, the taxpayer must state
AMENDED RETURN FOR SECTION 45Q CREDIT at the top of the amended Federal
income tax return, the amended Form 1065, or the AAR, as applicable. In
addition, as provided in Revenue Procedure 2020-23, 2020-18 I.R.B. 749
(see Sec. 601.601(d)(2)(i)(b) and (ii) of this chapter), the exception
applies regarding the time to file an amended return by a BBA
partnership for the 2018 and 2019 taxable years. The amended Federal
income tax return or the amended Form 1065 must be filed, in no event,
later than the applicable period of limitations on assessment for the
taxable year for which the amended Federal income tax return or Form
1065 is being filed. In the case of a BBA partnership that chooses not
to file an amended Form 1065 as permitted under Revenue Procedure 2020-
23, the BBA partnership may make a late election by filing an AAR on or
before October 15, 2021, but in no event, later than the applicable
period of limitations on making adjustments under section 6235 for the
reviewed year, as defined in Sec. 301.6241-1(a)(8) of the Procedure
and Administration Regulations (26 CFR part 301).
(2) Contractually ensuring disposal, injection, or utilization of
qualified carbon oxide. A taxpayer is not required to physically carry
out the disposal, injection, or utilization of qualified carbon oxide
to claim the section 45Q credit if the taxpayer contractually ensures
in a binding written contract that the party that physically carries
out the disposal, injection, or utilization of the qualified carbon
oxide does so in the manner required under section 45Q and these
regulations.
(i) Binding written contract. A written contract is binding only if
it is enforceable under State law against both the taxpayer and the
party that physically carries out the disposal, injection, or
utilization of the qualified carbon oxide, or a predecessor or
successor of either, and does not limit damages to a specified amount.
(ii) Multiple binding written contracts permitted. A taxpayer may
enter into multiple binding written contracts with multiple parties for
the disposal, injection, or utilization of qualified carbon oxide.
(iii) Contract provisions. Contracts ensuring the disposal,
injection, or utilization of qualified carbon oxide--
(A) Must include commercially reasonable terms and provide for
enforcement of the party's obligation to perform the disposal,
injection, or utilization of the qualified carbon oxide;
(B) May, but are not required to, include long-term liability
provisions, indemnity provisions, penalties for breach of contract, or
liquidated damages provisions;
(C) May, but are not required to, include information including how
many metric tons of qualified carbon oxide the parties agree to dispose
of, inject, or utilize;
(D) May, but are not required to, include minimum quantities that
the parties agree to dispose of, inject, or utilize;
(E) Must, in the case of qualified carbon oxide that is intended to
be disposed of in secure geological storage and not used as a tertiary
injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project,
obligate the disposing party to comply with Sec. Sec. 1.45Q-3(b)(1)
and 1.45Q-3(c), and, in the case of a recapture event, promptly inform
the capturing party of all information that is pertinent to the
recapture (i.e., location of leak, quantity of qualified carbon oxide
leaked, dollar value of section 45Q credit attributable to leaked
qualified carbon oxide) of section 45Q credits as listed in Sec.
1.45Q-5;
(F) Must, for qualified carbon oxide that is intended to be used as
a tertiary injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or natural gas
recovery, obligate the disposing party to comply with Sec. 1.45Q-
3(b)(1) or (2) and Sec. 1.45Q-3(c), and in the case of a recapture
event, promptly inform the capturing party of all information that is
pertinent to recapture of the section 45Q credit as listed in Sec.
1.45Q-5; and
(G) Must, for qualified carbon oxide that is intended to be
utilized in a manner specified in Sec. 1.45Q-4, obligate the utilizing
party to comply with Sec. 1.45Q-4.
(iv) Reporting of contract information. The existence of each
contract and the parties involved must be reported to the IRS annually
on a Form 8933 (or successor forms, or pursuant to instructions and
other guidance) by each party to the contract, regardless of the party
claiming the credit. In addition to any information stated as required
on Form 8933 (or successor forms, or pursuant to instructions and other
guidance), the report must include the following information--
(A) The name and taxpayer identification number of the taxpayer to
whom the credit is attributable;
(B) The name and taxpayer identification number of each party with
whom the taxpayer has entered into a contract to ensure the disposal,
injection, or utilization of qualified carbon oxide;
(C) The number of metric tons of qualified carbon oxide each
contracting party disposes of, injects, or utilizes on behalf of the
contracting taxpayer each taxable year for reporting to the IRS; and
(D) For contracts for the disposal of qualified carbon oxide in
secure geological storage or the use of qualified carbon oxide as a
tertiary injectant in enhanced oil or natural gas recovery, the name of
the operator, the field, unit, and reservoir, location by county and
state, and identification number assigned to the facility by the EPA's
electronic Greenhouse Gas Reporting Tool (e-GGRT ID number) for
submission of the facility's 40 CFR part 98 annual reports.
[[Page 34069]]
(v) Relationship with election to allow section 45Q credit. A
taxpayer does not elect to allow all or a portion of the credit to any
of the contracting parties merely by contracting with that party to
ensure the disposal, injection, or utilization of qualified carbon
oxide. Any election to allow all or a portion of the credit to be
claimed by another party must be made separately pursuant to Sec.
1.45Q-1(h)(3).
(3) Election to allow the section 45Q credit to another taxpayer.
The taxpayer described in Sec. 1.45Q-1(h)(1) as eligible to claim
section 45Q credits may elect to allow the person that disposes of the
qualified carbon oxide, utilizes the qualified carbon oxide, or uses
the qualified carbon oxide as a tertiary injectant to claim the credit
(credit claimant). The taxpayer that makes the election (electing
taxpayer) may not claim any section 45Q credits that are allowable to a
credit claimant. An electing taxpayer may elect to allow a credit
claimant to claim the full amount or a partial amount of section 45Q
credits arising during the taxable year. An electing taxpayer may elect
to allow a single credit claimant or multiple credit claimants to claim
section 45Q credits in the same taxable year. If an electing taxpayer
elects to allow multiple credit claimants to claim section 45Q credits,
the maximum amount of section 45Q credits allowable to each credit
claimant is proportional to the amount of qualified carbon oxide
disposed of, utilized, or used as a tertiary injectant by the credit
claimant. A credit claimant may receive allowances of section 45Q
credits from multiple electing taxpayers in the same taxable year.
(i) Example. Electing Taxpayer, E, captures 100 metric tons of
qualified carbon oxide with carbon capture equipment that was placed
in service in 2017. E contracts with two companies, A and B, for the
disposal of the qualified carbon oxide. The capture and disposal of
the qualified carbon oxide makes E eligible for a section 45Q credit
at a rate of $10 per metric ton, for a total section 45Q credit of
$1,000. E contractually ensures that A will dispose of 30 metric
tons of qualified carbon oxide and that B will dispose of 70 metric
tons of qualified carbon oxide. E may make a section 45Q(f)(3)(B)
election to allow up to $300 of section 45Q credit to A and up to
$700 of section 45Q credit to B, equal to the value of the number of
metric tons each party has contracted to ensure disposal, multiplied
by the credit value of the metric tons disposed of.
(ii) Time and manner of making election. The taxpayer described
Sec. 1.45Q-1(h)(1) makes a section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election by filing a
statement of election containing the information described in Sec.
1.45Q-1(h)(3)(iv) with the taxpayer's Federal income tax return or Form
1065 for each taxable year in which the credit arises. The section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election must be made in accordance with Form 8933 (or
successor forms, or pursuant to instructions and other guidance) no
later than the time prescribed by law (including extensions) for filing
the Federal income tax return or Form 1065 for the year in which the
credit arises. The election may not be filed with an amended Federal
income tax return, an amended Form 1065, or an AAR, as applicable,
after the prescribed date (including extensions) for filing the
original Federal income tax return or Form 1065 for the year, with the
exception of amended Federal income tax returns, amended Forms 1065, or
AARs, as applicable, for any taxable year ending after February 9,
2018, but not for taxable years beginning after the date of issuance of
this proposed regulation. In addition, as provided in Revenue Procedure
2020-23, the exception applies regarding the time to file an amended
return by a partnership subject to the centralized partnership audit
regime enacted as part of the BBA (BBA partnership) for the 2018 and
2019 taxable years. The amended Federal income tax return or the
amended Form 1065 must be filed, in no event, later than the applicable
period of limitations on assessment for the taxable year for which the
amended Federal income tax return or Form 1065 is being filed. In the
case of a BBA partnership that chooses not to file an amended Form 1065
as permitted under Revenue Procedure 2020-23, the BBA partnership may
make a late election by filing an AAR on or before October 15, 2021,
but in no event, later than the applicable period of limitations on
making adjustments under section 6235 for the reviewed year, as defined
in Sec. 301.6241-1(a)(8) of the Procedure and Administration
Regulations (26 CFR part 301).
(iii) Annual election. A new section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election must be
made annually.
(iv) Required information. For the election to be valid, the
election statement of the electing taxpayer on Form 8933 (or successor
forms, or pursuant to instructions and other guidance) under Sec.
1.45Q-1(h)(3)(ii) must indicate that an election is being made under
section 45Q(f)(3)(B). The electing taxpayer must provide each credit
claimant with a copy of the electing taxpayer's Form 8933 (or successor
forms, or pursuant to instructions and other guidance). The electing
taxpayer must, in addition to any information required on Form 8933 (or
successor forms, or pursuant to instructions and other guidance), set
forth the following information--
(A) The electing taxpayer's name, address, taxpayer identification
number, location, and e-GGRT ID number(s) (if available) of each
qualified facility where carbon oxide was captured;
(B) The full amount of credit attributable to the taxpayer prior to
the election;
(C) The name, address, and taxpayer identification number of each
credit claimant, and the location and e-GGRT ID number(s) (if
available) of each secure geological storage facility where the
qualified carbon oxide is disposed of or injected;
(D) The dollar amount of section 45Q credits the taxpayer is
allowing each credit claimant to claim and the corresponding metric
tons of qualified carbon oxide; and
(E) The dollar amount of section 45Q credits retained by the
electing taxpayer and the corresponding metric tons of qualified carbon
oxide.
(v) Requirements for section 45Q credit claimant. For a section
45Q(f)(3)(B) election to be valid, the section 45Q credit claimant must
include the following information on Form 8933 (or successor forms, or
pursuant to instructions and other guidance) with its timely filed
Federal income tax return or Form 1065 (including extensions)--
(A) The name, address, taxpayer identification number of the credit
claimant;
(B) The name, address, and taxpayer identification number of each
taxpayer making an election under section 45Q(f)(3)(B) to allow the
credit to the credit claimant;
(C) The location and e-GGRT ID number(s) (if available) of each
qualified facility where carbon oxide was captured;
(D) The location and e-GGRT ID number(s) (if available) of each
secure geological storage facility where the qualified carbon oxide is
disposed of or injected;
(E) The full dollar amount of section 45Q credits attributable to
each electing taxpayer prior to the election and the corresponding
metric tons of carbon oxide;
(F) The dollar amount of section 45Q credits that each electing
taxpayer is allowing the credit claimant to claim and the corresponding
metric tons of carbon oxide; and
(G) A copy of the electing taxpayer's Form 8933 (or successor
forms, or pursuant to instructions and other guidance).
[[Page 34070]]
(i) Applicability date. This section applies to taxable years
beginning after [date final regulations are published in the Federal
Register]. Taxpayers may choose to apply this section for taxable years
beginning on or after February 9, 2018, provided the taxpayer applies
this section and Sec. Sec. 1.45Q-2, 1.45Q-3, 1.45Q-4, and 1.45Q-5 in
their entirety and in a consistent manner.
Sec. 1.45Q-2 Definitions for Purposes of Sec. Sec. 1.45Q-1 through
1.45Q-5.
(a) Qualified carbon oxide. The term qualified carbon oxide means--
(1) Any carbon dioxide which--
(i) Is captured from an industrial source by carbon capture
equipment which is originally placed in service before February 9,
2018,
(ii) Would otherwise be released into the atmosphere as industrial
emission of greenhouse gas or lead to such release, and
(iii) Is measured at the source of capture and verified at the
point of disposal, injection, or utilization; or
(2) Any carbon dioxide or other carbon oxide which--
(i) Is captured from an industrial source by carbon capture
equipment which is originally placed in service on or after February 9,
2018,
(ii) Would otherwise be released into the atmosphere as industrial
emission of greenhouse gas or lead to such release, and
(iii) Is measured at the source of capture and verified at the
point of disposal, injection, or utilization; or
(3) In the case of a direct air capture facility, any carbon
dioxide that is captured directly from the ambient air and is measured
at the source of capture and verified at the point of disposal,
injection, or utilization.
(b) Recycled carbon oxide. The term qualified carbon oxide includes
the initial deposit of captured carbon oxide used as a tertiary
injectant. Qualified carbon oxide does not include carbon oxide that is
recaptured, recycled, and re-injected as part of the enhanced oil or
natural gas recovery process.
(c) Carbon capture equipment. In general, carbon capture equipment
includes all components of property that are used to capture or process
carbon oxide until the carbon oxide is transported for disposal,
injection, or utilization.
(1) Use of carbon capture equipment. Carbon capture equipment is
equipment used for the purpose of--
(i) Separating, purifying, drying, and/or capturing carbon oxide
that would otherwise be released into the atmosphere from an industrial
facility;
(ii) Removing carbon oxide from the atmosphere via direct air
capture; or
(iii) Compressing or otherwise increasing the pressure of carbon
oxide.
(2) Carbon capture equipment components. Carbon capture equipment
generally includes components of property necessary to compress, treat,
process, liquefy, pump or perform some other physical action to capture
qualified carbon oxide. Components of carbon capture equipment include,
but are not limited to, absorbers, compressors, conditioners, cooling
towers, dehydration equipment, dehydration systems, electrostatic
filtration, engines, filters, fixtures, glycol contractors, heat
exchangers, liquefaction equipment, lube oil systems, machinery,
materials, membranes, meters, monitoring equipment, motors, mounting
equipment, pipes, power generators and regenerators, pressure vessels
and other vessels, processing equipment, processing plants, processing
units, pumps, reboilers, recycling units, scrubbers, separation
vessels, solvent pumps, sorbent vessels, specially designed flue gas
ducts, support structures, tracking equipment, treating equipment,
turbines, water wash equipment, and other carbon oxide related
equipment.
(3) Excluded components. Components of carbon capture equipment do
not include pipelines, branch lines, or land and marine transport
vessels used for transporting captured qualified carbon oxide for
disposal, injection, or utilization. However, a gathering and
distribution system that collects carbon oxide captured from a
qualified facility or multiple facilities that constitute a single
project (as described in section 8.01 of Notice 2020-12, 2020-11 I.R.B.
495 (see Sec. 601.601(d)(2)(ii) of this chapter)) for the purpose of
transporting that carbon oxide away from the qualified facility or
single project to a pipeline used to transport carbon oxide from
multiple taxpayers or projects is carbon capture equipment.
(d) Industrial facility. An industrial facility is a facility that
produces a carbon oxide stream from a fuel combustion source or fuel
cell, a manufacturing process, or a fugitive carbon oxide emission
source that, absent capture and disposal, would otherwise be released
into the atmosphere as industrial emission of greenhouse gas or lead to
such release.
(1) Exclusion. An industrial facility does not include a facility
that produces carbon dioxide from carbon dioxide production wells at
natural carbon dioxide-bearing formations or a naturally occurring
subsurface spring. A deposit of natural gas that contains less than 10
percent carbon dioxide by volume is not a natural carbon dioxide-
bearing formation. For other deposits, whether a well is producing from
a natural carbon dioxide-bearing formation is based on all the facts
and circumstances.
(2) Industrial source. An industrial source is an emission of
carbon oxide from an industrial facility.
(3) Manufacturing process. A manufacturing process is a process
involving the manufacture of products, other than carbon oxide, that
are intended to be sold at a profit, or are used for a commercial
purpose. All facts and circumstances with respect to the process and
products are to be taken into account.
(4) Example. The following example illustrates the rules of
paragraph (a) and (d)(3) of this section:
(i) A natural underground reservoir contains a gas that is
comprised of 50 percent carbon dioxide and 50 percent methane by
volume. The raw gas is not usable without the application of a
separation process to create two gases that are primarily carbon
dioxide and methane. Taxpayer B constructs processing equipment that
separates the raw gas into qualified carbon oxide and methane. The
carbon dioxide is sold to a third party for use in a qualified
enhanced oil recovery project. Some of the methane is used as fuel
to power the processing equipment. The remainder of the methane is
injected into the reservoir. The injection will increase the
ultimate recovery of carbon dioxide. The injected methane can be
produced later from the reservoir. At the end of the taxable year
the taxpayer has not secured a contract to sell methane and does not
have any plans to use the methane for a commercial purpose. Because
carbon dioxide is the only product manufactured that is intended to
be sold at a profit or used for a commercial purpose, the separation
process applied to the gases is not a manufacturing process within
the meaning of paragraph (d)(3). The carbon dioxide captured by the
process is not qualified carbon oxide.
(e) Electricity generating facility. An electricity generating
facility is a facility described in section 45Q(d)(2)(A) or (B) of the
Internal Revenue Code (Code) and is subject to depreciation under MACRS
Asset Class 49.11(Electric Utility Hydraulic Production Plant), 49.12
(Electric Utility Nuclear Production Plant), 49.13 (Electric Utility
Steam Production Plant), or 49.15 (Electric Utility Combustion Turbine
Production Plant).
(f) Direct air capture facility. A direct air capture facility
means any facility that uses carbon capture equipment to capture carbon
oxide directly from the ambient air. It does not include any facility
that captures carbon dioxide that is deliberately released from
naturally
[[Page 34071]]
occurring subsurface springs or using natural photosynthesis.
(g) Qualified facility. A qualified facility means any industrial
facility, electricity generating facility, or direct air capture
facility, the construction of which begins before January 1, 2024, and
either at which construction of carbon capture equipment begins before
that date, or the original planning and design for which includes
installation of carbon capture equipment, and at which carbon capture
equipment is placed in service that captures the requisite annual
thresholds of carbon oxide described in paragraph (g)(1) of this
section. See Notice 2020-12, 2020-11 I.R.B. 495 (see Sec.
601.601(d)(2)(ii) of this chapter), for guidance on the determination
of when construction has begun on a qualified facility or on carbon
capture equipment.
(1) Emissions and capture requirements. The facility must capture--
(i) In the case of a facility, other than a direct air capture
facility, which emits not more than 500,000 metric tons of carbon oxide
into the atmosphere during the taxable year, at least 25,000 metric
tons of qualified carbon oxide during the taxable year which is
utilized in a manner consistent with section 45Q(f)(5) and Sec. 1.45Q-
4 (Section 45Q(d)(2)(A) Facility);
(ii) In the case of an electricity generating facility which is not
a Section 45Q(d)(2)(A) Facility (Section 45Q(d)(2)(B) Facility), not
less than 500,000 metric tons of qualified carbon during the taxable
year; and
(iii) In the case of a direct air capture facility or other
facility that is not a Section 45Q(d)(2)(A) Facility or a Section
45Q(d)(2)(B) Facility, at least 100,000 metric tons of qualified carbon
oxide during the taxable year.
(2) Examples. The following examples illustrate the rules of
paragraph (g) of this section:
(i) Example 1. During the taxable year, an ethanol plant emits
200,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide. Equipment located at the
facility captures 35,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide, all of which
are utilized in a manner consistent with section 45Q(f)(5) and Sec.
1.45Q-4. The ethanol plant is a qualified facility during the
taxable year because it met the requirement to capture at least
25,000 metric tons of qualified carbon oxide during the taxable year
which were utilized in a manner consistent with section 45Q(f)(5)
and Sec. 1.45Q-4.
(ii) Example 2. During the taxable year an electricity
generating facility emits 600,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide.
Equipment located at the facility captures 50,000 metric tons of
carbon dioxide, all of which are utilized in a manner consistent
with section 45Q(f)(5) and Sec. 1.45Q-4, and 400,000 metric tons of
carbon dioxide, all of which are properly disposed of in secure
geological storage. The total amount of carbon dioxide captured
during the taxable year is 450,000 metric tons. The electricity
generating facility is not a qualified facility during the taxable
year because it did not meet the requirement to capture not less
than 500,000 metric tons of qualified carbon during the taxable
year.
(iii) Example 3. During the taxable year, a cement manufacturing
plant emits 110,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide. Equipment located
at the plant captures 10,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide, all of
which are utilized in a manner consistent with section 45Q(f)(5) and
Sec. 1.45Q-4, and 90,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide, all of
which are properly disposed of in secure geological storage. The
total amount of carbon dioxide captured during the taxable year is
100,000 metric tons. The cement manufacturing plant is a qualified
facility during the taxable year because it met the requirement to
capture at least 100,000 metric tons of qualified carbon oxide
during the taxable year.
(3) Annualization of first-year qualified carbon oxide emission and
capture amounts--(i) In general. For the year in which carbon capture
equipment is placed in service at a qualified facility, annualization
of the amount of qualified carbon oxide emitted and captured is
permitted to determine if the threshold requirements under paragraph
(g)(1) of this section are satisfied. Such annualization may result in
a facility being deemed to satisfy the threshold requirements under
paragraph (g)(1) of this section for the year and may permit a taxpayer
to claim section 45Q credits even though the amount of qualified carbon
oxide emitted or captured in its first year is less than the threshold
requirements under paragraph (g)(1) of this section.
(ii) Calculation. Annualization is only be available for the first
year in which the carbon capture equipment is placed in service at the
qualified facility. Annualized amounts must be calculated by--
(A) Determining the amount of qualified carbon oxide emitted and
captured during the taxable year in which the carbon capture equipment
was placed in service at the qualified facility,
(B) Dividing the amount of qualified carbon emitted or captured by
the number of days in the tax year beginning with the date on which the
carbon capture equipment was placed in service at the qualified
facility and ending with the last day of the taxable year; and
(C) Multiplying by 365.
(iii) Consequences. If the annualized amounts of qualified carbon
oxide emitted and captured as calculated under this formula meet the
threshold requirements under paragraph (g)(1) of this section, the
threshold requirements under paragraph (g)(1) of this section are
deemed satisfied for the taxable year in which the carbon capture
equipment was placed in service at the qualified facility. The taxpayer
may be eligible for a section 45Q credit for that taxable year but must
calculate the credit based on actual amounts of qualified carbon oxide
captured and disposed of, injected, or utilized during the taxable
year.
(4) Election for applicable facilities. In the case of an
applicable facility, for any taxable year during which such facility
captures not less than 500,000 metric tons of qualified carbon oxide,
the person described in section 45Q(f)(3)(A)(ii) and Sec. 1.45Q-
1(h)(1), may elect to have such facility, and any carbon capture
equipment placed in service at such facility, deemed as having been
placed in service on February 9, 2018 (section 45Q(f)(6) election).
(i) Applicable facility. An applicable facility means a qualified
facility described in section 45Q(f)(6) and Sec. 1.45Q-2(g)(4)(i) that
was placed in service before February 9, 2018, for which no taxpayer
claimed a section 45Q credit for qualified carbon oxide captured at the
facility for any taxable year ending before February 9, 2018.
(ii) Time and manner of making election. The taxpayer described
Sec. 1.45Q-1(h)(1) makes a section 45Q(f)(6) election by filing a
statement of election with the taxpayer's income tax return for each
taxable year in which the credit arises. The section 45Q(f)(6) election
must be made in accordance with Form 8933 (or successor forms, or
pursuant to instructions and other guidance) with the taxpayer's income
tax return for the taxable year in which the taxpayer makes the section
45Q(f)(6) election. The statement of election must, in addition to any
information required on Form 8933 (or successor forms, or pursuant to
instructions and other guidance), set forth the electing taxpayer's
name, address, taxpayer identification number, location, and e-GGRT ID
number(s) (if available) of the applicable facility.
(iii) Retroactive credit revocations. A taxpayer may not file an
amended Federal income tax return, an amended Form 1065, or an AAR, as
applicable, for any taxable year ending before February 9, 2018, to
revoke a prior claim of section 45Q credits.
(5) Retrofitted qualified facility or carbon capture equipment (80/
20 Rule). A qualified facility or carbon capture equipment may qualify
as originally placed in service even if it contains some used
components of property,
[[Page 34072]]
provided the fair market value of the used components of property is
not more than 20 percent of the qualified facility or carbon capture
equipment's total value (the cost of the new components of property
plus the value of the used components of property) (80/20 Rule). For
purposes of the 80/20 Rule, the cost of a new qualified facility or
carbon capture equipment includes all properly capitalized costs of the
new qualified facility or carbon capture equipment. Solely for purposes
of the 80/20 Rule, properly capitalized costs of a new qualified
facility or carbon capture equipment may, at the option of the
taxpayer, include the cost of new equipment for a pipeline owned and
used exclusively by that taxpayer to transport carbon oxides captured
from that taxpayer's qualified facility that would otherwise be emitted
into the atmosphere.
(h) Qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project. The
term qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project has the
same meaning as qualified enhanced oil recovery project under section
43(c)(2) of the Code and Sec. 1.43-2, by substituting crude oil or
natural gas for crude oil in section 43(c)(2)(A)(i) and Sec. Sec.
1.43-2 and 1.43-3.
(1) Application of Sec. Sec. 1.43-2 and 1.43-3. For purposes of
applying Sec. Sec. 1.43-2 and 1.43-3 with respect to a qualified
enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project, the term enhanced oil or
natural gas recovery is substituted for enhanced oil recovery, and the
term oil or natural gas is substituted for oil.
(2) Required certification. The qualified enhanced oil or natural
gas recovery project must be certified under Sec. 1.43-3. For purposes
of a natural gas project--
(i) The petroleum engineer's certification under Sec. 1.43-3(a)(3)
and the operator's continued certification of a project under Sec.
1.43-3(b)(3) must include an additional statement that the
certification is for purposes of the section 45Q carbon oxide
sequestration tax credit;
(ii) The petroleum engineer's certification must be attached to a
Form 8933 (or successor forms, or pursuant to instructions and other
guidance) and filed not later than the last date prescribed by law
(including extensions) for filing the operator's or designated owner's
Federal income tax return or Form 1065 for the first taxable year in
which qualified carbon oxide is injected into the reservoir; and
(iii) The operator's continued certification of a project must be
attached to a Form 8933 (or successor forms, or pursuant to
instructions and other guidance) and filed not later than the last date
prescribed by law (including extensions) for filing the operator's or
designated owner's Federal income tax return or Form 1065 for taxable
years after the taxable year for which the petroleum engineer's
certification is filed but not after the taxable year in which
injection activity ceases and all injection wells are plugged and
abandoned.
(3) Natural gas. Natural gas has the same meaning as under section
613A(e)(2) of the Code.
(4) Timely filing of petroleum engineer's certification. For
purposes of this paragraph (h), if a section 45Q credit is claimed on
an amended Federal income tax return, an amended Form 1065, or an AAR,
as applicable, the petroleum engineer's certification will be treated
as filed timely if it is attached to a Form 8933 that is submitted with
such amended Federal income tax return, amended Form 1065, or AAR. With
respect to a section 45Q credit that is claimed on a timely filed
Federal income tax return or Form 1065 for a taxable year ending after
February 9, 2018 and beginning before the date of issuance of this
proposed regulation, for which the petroleum engineer's certification
was not submitted the petroleum engineer's certification will be
treated as filed timely if it is attached to an amended Form 8933 for
any taxable year ending after February 9, 2018, but not for taxable
years beginning after the date of issuance of these proposed
regulations.
(5) Carbon oxide injected in oil reservoir. Carbon oxide that is
injected into an oil reservoir that is not a qualified enhanced oil
recovery project under section 43(c)(2) due to circumstances such as
the first injection of a tertiary injectant occurring before 1991, or
because a petroleum engineer's certification was not timely filed,
cannot be treated as qualified carbon oxide, disposed of in secure
geological storage, or utilized in a manner described in section
45Q(f)(5). This rule will not apply to an oil reservoir if--
(i) The reservoir permanently ceased oil production;
(ii) The operator has obtained an EPA UIC class VI permit; and
(iii) The operator complies with 40 CFR part 98 subpart RR.
(6) Tertiary Injectant. For purposes of section 45Q, a tertiary
injectant is qualified carbon oxide that is injected into and stored in
a qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project and
contributes to the extraction of crude oil or natural gas. The term
tertiary injectant has the same meaning as used within section
193(b)(1) of the Code.
(i) Section 45Q credit. The term section 45Q credit means the
carbon oxide sequestration credit determined under section 45Q of the
Internal Revenue Code and Sec. 1.45Q-1.
(j) Applicability date. This section applies to taxable years
beginning after [date final regulations are published in the Federal
Register]. Taxpayers may choose to apply this section for taxable years
beginning on or after February 9, 2018, provided the taxpayer applies
this section and Sec. Sec. 1.45Q-1, 1.45Q-3, 1.45Q-4, and 1.45Q-5 in
their entirety and in a consistent manner.
Sec. 1.45Q-3 Secure Geological Storage.
(a) In general. To qualify for the section 45Q credit, a taxpayer
must either physically or contractually dispose of captured qualified
carbon oxide in secure geological storage in the manner provided in
Sec. 1.45Q-3(b) or utilize qualified carbon oxide in a manner
conforming with section 45Q(f)(5) of the Internal Revenue Code and
Sec. 1.45Q-4. Secure geological storage includes, but is not limited
to, storage at deep saline formations, oil and gas reservoirs, and
unminable coal seams.
(b) Requirements for secure geological storage. For purposes of the
section 45Q credit, qualified carbon oxide is considered disposed of by
the taxpayer in secure geological storage such that the qualified
carbon oxide does not escape into the atmosphere if the qualified
carbon oxide is--
(1) Stored, and not used as a tertiary injectant in a qualified
enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project, in compliance with
applicable requirements under 40 CFR part 98 subpart RR; or
(2) Used as a tertiary injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or
natural gas recovery project and stored in compliance with applicable
requirements under 40 CFR part 98 subpart RR, or the International
Organization for Standardization (ISO) standards endorsed by the
American National Standards Institute (ANSI) under CSA/ANSI ISO
27916:19, Carbon dioxide capture, transportation and geological
storage--Carbon dioxide storage using enhanced oil recovery
(CO2-EOR).
(3) Injected into a well that complies with applicable Underground
Injection Control regulations onshore or offshore under submerged lands
within the territorial jurisdiction of States.
(c) Documentation. Documentation must be filed in accordance with
Form 8933 (or successor forms, or pursuant to instructions and other
guidance).
(d) Certification. For qualified enhanced oil or natural gas
recovery
[[Page 34073]]
projects in which the taxpayer reported volumes of carbon oxide to the
EPA pursuant to 40 CFR part 98 subpart RR, the taxpayer may self-
certify the volume of carbon oxide claimed for purposes of section 45Q.
For qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery projects in which
the taxpayer determined volumes pursuant to CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19, a
taxpayer may prepare documentation as outlined in CSA/ANSI 27916:19
internally, but such documentation must be provided to a qualified
independent engineer or geologist, who then must certify that the
documentation provided, including the mass balance calculations as well
as information regarding monitoring and containment assurance, is
accurate and complete. Certifications must be made annually. For any
leaked amount of qualified carbon oxide (as defined in Sec. 1.45Q-
5(c)) that is determined pursuant to CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19, the
certification must also include a statement that the quantity was
determined in accordance with sound engineering principles. Taxpayers
that capture qualified carbon oxide giving rise to the section 45Q
credit must file Form 8933 (or successor forms, or pursuant to
instructions and other guidance) with a timely filed Federal income tax
return or Form 1065, including extensions or for the purpose of this
rule, amendments to Federal income tax returns, Forms 1065, or on AARs,
as applicable. Taxpayers that dispose of, inject, or utilize qualified
carbon oxide must also file Form 8933 (or successor forms, or pursuant
to instructions and other guidance) with a timely filed Federal income
tax return or Form 1065, including extensions or for the purpose of
this rule, amendments to Federal income tax returns, Forms 1065, or on
AARs, as applicable. If the volume of carbon oxide certified and
reported is a negative amount, see Sec. 1.45Q-5 for rules regarding
recapture.
(e) Failure to submit complete documentation or certification. No
section 45Q credit is allowed for any taxable year for which the
taxpayer (including credit claimants) has failed to timely submit
complete documentation and certification that is required by this
regulation or Form 8933 (or successor forms, or pursuant to
instructions and other guidance). The credit will be allowed only for a
taxable year for which complete documentation and certification has
been timely submitted. Certifications for each taxable year must be
submitted by the due date of the federal income tax return or Form 1065
on which the section 45Q credit is claimed, including extensions. If a
section 45Q credit is claimed on an amended Federal income tax return,
an amended Form 1065, or an AAR, as applicable, certifications may also
be submitted with such amended Federal income tax return, amended Form
1065, or AAR. If a section 45Q credit was claimed on a timely filed
Federal income tax return or Form 1065 for a taxable year ending after
February 9, 2018, and beginning before the date of issuance of this
proposed regulation, for which certifications were not submitted, such
certifications may be submitted with an amended Federal income tax
return, an amended Form 1065, or an AAR, as applicable, for the taxable
year in which the section 45Q credit was claimed.
(f) Applicability date. This section applies to taxable years
beginning after [date final regulations are published in the Federal
Register]. Taxpayers may choose to apply this section for taxable years
beginning on or after February 9, 2018, provided the taxpayer applies
this section and Sec. Sec. 1.45Q-1, 1.45Q-2, 1.45Q-4, and 1.45Q-5 in
their entirety and in a consistent manner.
Sec. 1.45Q-4 Utilization of Qualified Carbon Oxide.
(a) In general. For purposes of this section, utilization of
qualified carbon oxide means--
(1) The fixation of qualified carbon oxide through photosynthesis
or chemosynthesis, such as through the growing of algae or bacteria,
(2) The chemical conversion of such qualified carbon oxide to a
material or chemical compound in which such qualified carbon oxide is
securely stored, or
(3) The use of such qualified carbon oxide for any other purpose
for which a commercial market exists (with the exception of use as a
tertiary injectant in a qualified enhanced oil or natural gas recovery
project), as determined by the Secretary of the Treasury or his
delegate.
(b) Measurement. For purposes of determining the amount of
qualified carbon oxide utilized by the taxpayer under Sec. 1.45Q-
1(b)(2)(ii) and (c)(2)(ii), such amount is equal to the metric tons of
qualified carbon oxide which the taxpayer demonstrates, based upon an
analysis of lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions (LCA), were--
(1) Captured and permanently isolated from the atmosphere
(isolated), or
(2) Displaced from being emitted into the atmosphere through use of
a process described in paragraph (a) of this section (displaced).
(c) Lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions and lifecycle analysis--(1)
In general. For purposes of paragraph (b) of this section, the term
lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions means the aggregate quantity of
greenhouse gas emissions (including direct emissions and significant
indirect emissions such as significant emissions from land use changes)
related to the full product lifecycle, including all stages of product
and feedstock production and distribution, from feedstock generation or
extraction through the distribution and delivery and use of the
finished product to the ultimate consumer, where the mass values for
all greenhouse gases are adjusted to account for their relative global
warming potential according to Table A-1 of 40 CFR part 98 subpart A.
(2) Measurement. The taxpayer measures the amount of carbon oxide
captured and utilized through a combination of direct measurement and
LCA. The measurement and written LCA report must be performed by or
verified by an independent third-party. The report must contain
documentation consistent with the International Organization for
Standardization (ISO) 14044:2006, ``Environmental management--Life
cycle assessment--Requirements and Guidelines,'' as well as a statement
documenting the qualifications of the third-party, including proof of
appropriate U.S. or foreign professional license, and an affidavit from
the third-party stating that it is independent from the taxpayer.
(3) Approval of the LCA. The taxpayer must submit the written LCA
report required by paragraph (c)(1) of this section to the IRS and the
Department of Energy (DOE). The LCA will be subject to a technical
review by the DOE, and the IRS, in consultation with the DOE and the
Environmental Protection Agency, will determine whether to approve the
LCA.
(4) [Reserved]
(d)-(e) [Reserved]
(f) Applicability date. This section applies to taxable years
beginning after [date final regulations are published in the Federal
Register]. Taxpayers may choose to apply this section for taxable years
beginning on or after February 9, 2018, provided the taxpayer applies
this section and Sec. Sec. 1.45Q-1, 1.45Q-2, 1.45Q-3, and 1.45Q-5 in
their entirety and in a consistent manner.
Sec. 1.45Q-5 Recapture of Credit.
(a) Recapture event. A recapture event occurs when qualified carbon
oxide for which a section 45Q credit has been claimed ceases to be
captured, disposed of, or used as a tertiary injectant during
[[Page 34074]]
the recapture period. Recapture events are determined separately for
each project involving capture, disposal, or use of qualified carbon
oxide as a tertiary injectant.
(b) Ceases to be captured, disposed of, or used as a tertiary
injectant. Qualified carbon oxide ceases to be captured, disposed of,
or used as a tertiary injectant if the leaked amount of qualified
carbon oxide in the taxable year exceeds the amount of qualified carbon
oxide disposed of in secure geological storage or used as a tertiary
injectant in that same taxable year.
(c) Leaked amount of qualified carbon oxide. When a taxpayer,
operator, or regulatory agency determines that qualified carbon oxide
has leaked to the atmosphere, the taxpayer must quantify the metric
tons of qualified carbon oxide that has leaked to the atmosphere
pursuant to the requirements of 40 CFR part 98 subpart RR or CSA/ANSI
ISO 27916:19. The quantity determined pursuant to CSA/ANSI ISO 27916:19
must be certified by a qualified independent engineer or geologist,
including a statement that the quantity was determined in accordance
with sound engineering principles. The Internal Revenue Service will
consider all available facts, and may consult with the relevant
regulatory agency, in verifying the amount of qualified carbon oxide
that has leaked to the atmosphere. That amount is the leaked amount of
qualified carbon oxide.
(d) Recaptured qualified carbon oxide. The quantity of recaptured
qualified carbon oxide (in metric tons) is the amount by which the
leaked amount of qualified carbon oxide exceeds the amount of qualified
carbon oxide disposed of in secure geological storage or used as a
tertiary injectant in the taxable year.
(e) Recapture amount. The recapture amount is equal to the product
of the quantity of recaptured qualified carbon oxide (in metric tons)
and the appropriate statutory credit rate.
(f) Recapture period. The recapture period begins on the date of
first injection of qualified carbon oxide for disposal in secure
geological storage or use as a tertiary injectant. The recapture period
ends on the earlier of five years after the last taxable year in which
the taxpayer claimed a section 45Q credit or the date monitoring ends
under the requirements of the standards described in Sec. 1.45Q-
3(b)(1) or (b)(2).
(g) Application of recapture. (1) In general. Any recapture amount
must be taken into account in the taxable year in which it is
identified and reported. If the leaked amount of qualified carbon oxide
does not exceed the amount of qualified carbon oxide disposed of in
secure geological storage or used as a tertiary injectant in the
taxable year reported, there is no recapture amount and no further
adjustments to prior taxable years are needed. The taxpayer must add
the recapture amount to the amount of tax due in the taxable year in
which the recapture event occurs.
(2) Calculation. Recapture amounts are to be calculated on a last-
in-first-out basis (LIFO), such that the leaked amount of qualified
carbon oxide that exceeds the amount of qualified carbon oxide disposed
of in secure geological storage or used as a tertiary injectant in the
current taxable year will be deemed attributable first to the prior
taxable year, then to taxable year before that, and then up to a
maximum of the fifth preceding year.
(3) Multiple Units. In the event of a recapture event in which the
leaked qualified carbon oxide had been captured from multiple units of
carbon capture equipment that were not under common ownership, the
recapture amount must be allocated on a pro rata basis among the
multiple units of carbon capture equipment. Each taxpayer that claimed
a section 45Q credit with respect to one or more of such units of
carbon capture equipment is responsible for adding the recapture amount
to their amount of tax due in the taxable year in which the recapture
event occurs.
(4) Multiple Taxpayers. In the event of a recapture event where the
leaked amount of qualified carbon oxide is deemed attributable to
qualified carbon oxide with respect to which multiple taxpayers claimed
section 45Q credit amounts (for example, if ownership of the carbon
capture equipment was transferred, or if a taxpayer made an election
under section 45Q(f)(3)(B) of the Internal Revenue Code to allow one or
more credit claimants to claim a portion of the section 45Q credit),
the recapture amount must be allocated on a pro rata basis among the
taxpayers that claimed the section 45Q credits with respect to the
qualified carbon oxide that the leaked qualified carbon oxide is deemed
attributable to.
(5) Reporting. If a recapture event occurs during a project's
recapture period, any taxpayer that claimed a section 45Q credit for
that project must report the following information on a Form 8933 (or
successor forms, or pursuant to instructions and other guidance) filed
with that taxpayer's Federal income tax return or Form 1065 for the
taxable year for which the recapture event occurred--
(i) The recapture amount (as defined in Sec. 1.45Q-5(e));
(ii) The quantity of leaked qualified carbon oxide (in metric tons)
(as defined in Sec. 1.45Q-5(c));
(iii) The statutory credit rate at which the section 45Q credits
were originally calculated; and
(iv) A statement that describes how the taxpayer became aware of
the recapture event, how the leaked amount was determined, and the
identity and involvement of any regulatory agencies.
(6) Examples. The following examples illustrate the principles of
this paragraph (g):
(i) Example 1. (A) A owns direct air capture Facility X. No
other taxpayer has owned Facility X, and A has never allowed another
taxpayer to claim any section 45Q credits with respect to qualified
carbon oxide captured by Facility X. Facility X captured 100,000
metric tons of carbon dioxide in each of 2021, 2022, and 2023. All
captured carbon dioxide was sold to B for use a tertiary injectant
in a qualified enhanced oil recovery project. B provided contractual
assurance that the carbon dioxide would be sequestered in secure
geological storage. A claimed section 45Q credit amounts of
$2,268,000 in 2021, $2,515,000 in 2022, and $2,761,000 in 2023 using
the statutory rates in Sec. 1.45Q-1(d)(3). In 2024, A captured and
sold another 100,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide to B, which B
used as a tertiary injectant in a qualified enhanced oil recovery
project. In late 2024, B determined that 10,000 metric tons of
carbon dioxide injected during 2021 had leaked from the containment
area of the reservoir and will eventually migrate to the atmosphere.
(B) Because the leakage determined in 2024 (10,000 metric tons)
did not exceed the amount stored in 2024 (100,000 metric tons), a
recapture event did not occur in 2024. A's section 45Q credit for
2024 is $2,706,300 (net 90,000 metric tons of qualified carbon oxide
captured and used as a tertiary injectant multiplied by the
statutory credit rate for 2024 of $30.07).
(ii) Example 2. (A) Assume same facts as in Example 1.
Additionally, in 2025, B determines that 190,000 metric tons of
carbon dioxide injected in 2021 and 2022 have leaked and will
eventually migrate to the atmosphere. No injection of carbon dioxide
takes place in 2025.
(B) Because the leakage determined in 2025 (190,000 metric tons)
exceeds the amount stored in 2025 (0 metric tons), a recapture event
occurred in 2025. A's credit for 2025 is $0 because the net amount
of carbon dioxide captured and used as a tertiary injectant in 2025
was 0 metric tons. The 2025 recapture amount is calculated by
multiplying the 190,000 metric tons of recaptured qualified carbon
oxide by the appropriate statutory credit rate using the LIFO
method. The first 90,000 metric tons of recaptured qualified carbon
oxide is deemed attributable to 2024, and is recaptured at the 2024
statutory rate of $30.07 per metric ton. The remaining 100,000
metric tons of recaptured qualified carbon oxide are deemed
attributable to 2023. The credits attributable to 2023 are
recaptured at the
[[Page 34075]]
2023 statutory rate of $27.61 per metric ton. Thus, the total
recapture amount is $5,467,300, and is added to A's tax due for
2025.
(iii) Example 3. (A) Assume the same facts as in Example 2,
except that A sells Facility X to C on January 1, 2024. C sells
100,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide captured by Facility X to B
for use as a tertiary injectant in a qualified enhanced oil recovery
project. Thus, C claims a section 45Q credit in 2024 of $2,706,300
(net 90,000 metric tons of qualified carbon oxide captured and used
as a tertiary injectant multiplied by the statutory credit rate for
2024 of $30.07).
(B) The total recapture amount in 2025 is the same $5,467,300 as
in Example 2, but is allocated between A and C. The first 90,000
metric tons of recaptured qualified carbon oxide are deemed
attributable to 2024. The credits that are attributable to 2024 are
recaptured at the 2024 statutory rate of $30.07 per ton (for a
recapture amount of $2,706,300). Because C claimed that amount of
section 45Q credit in 2024, a recapture amount of $2,706,300 is
added to C's tax due for 2025. The remaining 100,000 metric tons of
recaptured qualified carbon oxide are deemed attributable to 2023.
The credits that are attributable to 2023 are recaptured at the 2023
statutory rate of $27.61 per ton (for a recapture amount of
$2,761,000). Because A claimed that amount of section 45Q credit in
2023, a recapture amount of $2,761,000 is added to A's tax due for
2025.
(iv) Example 4. (A) Assume the same facts as in Example 2,
except that in 2023 A made a section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election to allow
B to claim one-half of the section 45Q credit for 2023. A and B each
claimed $1,380,500 of section 45Q credit in 2023 (50,000 metric tons
each multiplied by the 2023 statutory rate of $27.61).
(B) The total recapture amount in 2025 is the same $5,467,300 as
in Example 2, but is allocated among A and B. The first 90,000
metric tons of recaptured qualified carbon oxide is deemed
attributable to 2024. The section 45Q credit amounts attributable to
2024 are recaptured at the 2024 statutory rate of $30.07 per ton
(for a recapture amount of $2,706,300). Because A claimed that
amount of section 45Q credit in 2024, $2,706,300 is added to A's tax
due for 2025. The remaining 100,000 metric tons of recaptured
qualified carbon oxide is deemed attributable to 2023. The section
45Q credit amounts attributable to 2023 are recaptured at the 2023
statutory rate of $27.61 per ton (for a recapture amount of
$2,761,000). Because A and B each claimed half of that amount
($1,380,500) of section 45Q credit in 2023, $1,380,500 is added to
both A's and B's tax due for 2025. Thus, a recapture amount of
$4,086,800 is added to A's tax due for 2025, and a recapture amount
of $1,380,500 is added to B's tax due for 2025.
(v) Example 5. (A) Assume the same facts as in Example 2, except
that the 100,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide sold to B in 2021,
2022, 2023, and 2024 for use as a tertiary injectant in a qualified
enhanced oil recovery project were captured equally (50,000 metric
tons per year) from qualified facilities owned by J and K. Neither J
nor K made a section 45Q(f)(3)(B) election to allow B to claim the
credit.
(B) Because the leakage determined in 2024 (10,000 metric tons)
did not exceed the amount used as a tertiary injectant in 2024
(100,000 metric tons) a recapture event did not occur in 2024. The
total amount of section 45Q credit for 2024 is $2,706,300 (net
90,000 metric tons of qualified carbon oxide captured and used as a
tertiary injectant multiplied by the statutory credit rate for 2024
of $30.07). J and K may each claim half of this amount of section
45Q credit ($1,353,150) in 2024.
(C) The total recapture amount in 2025 is the same $5,467,300 as
in Example 2, but is allocated between J and K. The section 45Q
credit amounts relating to the first 90,000 metric tons of
recaptured qualified carbon oxide are deemed attributable to 2024
and are recaptured at the 2024 statutory rate of $30.07 per ton (for
a recapture amount of $2,706,300). Because J and K each claimed half
of that amount ($1,353,150) of section 45Q credit in 2024,
$1,353,150 is added to both J's and K's tax due for 2025. The
section 45Q credit amounts relating to the remaining 100,000 metric
tons of recaptured qualified carbon oxide are deemed attributable to
2023 and are recaptured at the 2023 statutory rate of $27.61 per ton
(for a recapture amount of $2,761,000). Because J and K each claimed
half of that amount ($1,380,500) of section 45Q credit in 2023, an
additional $1,380,500 is added to both J's and Ks tax due for 2025.
Thus, a total recapture amount of $2,733,650 is added to both J's
and K's tax due for 2025.
(vi) Example 6. (A) M owns Industrial Facility Z. No other
taxpayer has ever owned Z, and M has never allowed another taxpayer
to claim any section 45Q credits with respect to qualified carbon
oxide captured from Z. M captured 1,000,000 metric tons of carbon
dioxide annually in each of 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022,
2023, 2024, and 2025. All captured carbon dioxide was sold to N for
use a tertiary injectant in a qualified enhanced oil recovery
project. N provided contractual assurance that the carbon dioxide
would be sequestered in secure geological storage. M claimed section
45Q credit amounts of $12,830,000 in 2017, $15,209,000 in 2018,
$17,760,000 in 2019, $20,220,000 in 2020, $22,680,000 in 2021,
$25,150,000 in 2022, $27,610,000 in 2023, $30,070,000 in 2024, and
$32,540,000 in 2025 using the statutory rates in Sec. 1.45Q-
1(d)(3). No injection of carbon oxides takes place in 2026. In 2026,
N determined that 6,200,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide previously
injected had leaked from the containment area of the reservoir and
will eventually migrate to the atmosphere.
(B) Because the leakage determined in 2025 (6,200,000 metric
tons) exceed the amount stored in 2026 (0 metric tons) a recapture
event occurred in 2026. A's credit for 2026 is $0 because the net
amount of carbon dioxide captured and used as a tertiary injectant
in 2026 was 0 metric tons. The 2026 recapture amount is calculated
by multiplying the 6,200,000 metric tons of recaptured qualified
carbon oxide by the appropriate statutory credit rate using the LIFO
method. The first 1,000,000 metric tons of recaptured qualified
carbon oxide is deemed attributable to 2025, and is recaptured at
the 2025 statutory rate of $32.54 per metric ton. The next 1,000,000
metric tons of recaptured qualified carbon oxide is deemed
attributable to 2024, and is recaptured at the 2024 statutory rate
of $30.07 per metric ton. The next 1,000,000 metric tons of
recaptured qualified carbon oxide is deemed attributable to 2024,
and is recaptured at the 2023 statutory rate of $27.16 per metric
ton. The next 1,000,000 metric tons of recaptured qualified carbon
oxide is deemed attributable to 2022, and is recaptured at the 2022
statutory rate of $25.15 per metric ton. The next 1,000,000 metric
tons of recaptured qualified carbon oxide is deemed attributable to
2021, and is recaptured at the 2021 statutory rate of $22.68 per
metric ton. The remaining 1,200,000 metric tons are not subject to
recapture because of the five-year lookback limit in Sec. 1.45Q-
1(g)(2). Thus, the total recapture amount is $138,050,000, and is
added to A's tax due for 2026.
(h) Recapture in the event of intentional removal from storage. If
qualified carbon oxide for which a credit has been claimed is
deliberately removed from a secure geological storage site, then a
recapture event would occur in the year in which the qualified carbon
oxide is removed from the storage site pursuant to Sec. 1.45Q-5(a).
(i) Limited exceptions. A recapture event is not triggered in the
event of a loss of containment of qualified carbon oxide resulting from
actions not related to the selection, operation, or maintenance of the
storage facility, such as volcanic activity or terrorist attack.
(j) Applicability date. This section applies to taxable years
beginning after [date final regulations are published in the Federal
Register]. Taxpayers may choose to apply this section for taxable years
beginning on or after February 9, 2018, provided the taxpayer applies
this section and sections 1.45Q-1, 1.45Q-2, 1.45Q-3, and 1.45Q-4 in
their entirety and in a consistent manner.
Sunita Lough,
Deputy Commissioner for Services and Enforcement.
[FR Doc. 2020-11907 Filed 5-29-20; 11:15 am]
BILLING CODE 4830-01-P