Provisions Pertaining to Certain Investments in the United States by Foreign Persons, 50174-50211 [2019-20099]
Download as PDF
50174
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY
Office of Investment Security
31 CFR Part 800
RIN 1505–AC64
Provisions Pertaining to Certain
Investments in the United States by
Foreign Persons
Office of Investment Security,
Department of the Treasury
ACTION: Proposed rule.
AGENCY:
This proposed rule would
replace the current regulations that
implement section 721 of the Defense
Production Act of 1950, as amended by
the Foreign Investment Risk Review
Modernization Act of 2018 (FIRRMA).
While this proposed rule retains many
provisions of the existing regulations, a
number of substantive changes are
proposed, primarily to implement
FIRRMA.
SUMMARY:
Written comments must be
received by October 24, 2019.
The Department of the Treasury is
considering holding during the
comment period a teleconference
regarding the proposed rule for
members of the public. Information
about any public teleconference,
including the date, time, and how to
attend, will be published on the
Department of the Treasury website at
https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/
international/the-committee-on-foreigninvestment-in-the-united-states-cfius.
ADDRESSES: Written comments on this
proposed rule may be submitted
through one of two methods:
• Electronic Submission: Comments
may be submitted electronically through
the Federal government eRulemaking
portal at https://www.regulations.gov.
Electronic submission of comments
allows the commenter maximum time to
prepare and submit a comment, ensures
timely receipt, and enables the
Department of the Treasury to make the
comments available to the public. Please
note that comments submitted through
https://www.regulations.gov will be
public, and can be viewed by members
of the public.
• Mail: Send to U.S. Department of
the Treasury, Attention: Thomas Feddo,
Deputy Assistant Secretary for
Investment Security, 1500 Pennsylvania
Avenue NW, Washington, DC 20220.
In general, the Department of the
Treasury will post all comments to
https://www.regulations.gov without
change, including any business or
personal information provided, such as
names, addresses, email addresses, or
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
DATES:
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
telephone numbers. All comments
received, including attachments and
other supporting material, will be part
of the public record and subject to
public disclosure. You should only
submit information that you wish to
make publicly available.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: For
questions about this proposed rule,
contact: Laura Black, Director of
Investment Security Policy and
International Relations; Meena R.
Sharma, Deputy Director of Investment
Security Policy and International
Relations; David Shogren, Senior Policy
Advisor; or Alexander Sevald, Senior
Policy Advisor, at U.S. Department of
the Treasury, 1500 Pennsylvania
Avenue NW, Washington, DC 20220;
telephone: (202) 622–3425; email:
CFIUS.FIRRMA@treasury.gov.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Background
A. The Statute
The Foreign Investment Risk Review
Modernization Act of 2018 (FIRRMA),
Subtitle A of Title XVII of Public Law
115–232, 132 Stat. 2173, which amends
section 721 (section 721) of the Defense
Production Act of 1950, as amended
(DPA), requires the issuance of
regulations implementing its provisions.
In Executive Order 13456, 73 FR 4677
(Jan. 23, 2008), the President directs the
Secretary of the Treasury to issue
regulations implementing section 721.
This proposed rule is being issued
pursuant to that authority.
FIRRMA was passed by Congress as
H.R. 5515 and was enacted on August
13, 2018. Prior to the enactment of
FIRRMA, section 721 authorized the
President, acting through the Committee
on Foreign Investment in the United
States (CFIUS or the Committee), to
review mergers, acquisitions, and
takeovers by or with any foreign person
which could result in foreign control of
any person engaged in interstate
commerce in the United States, to
determine the effects of such
transactions on the national security of
the United States.
FIRRMA maintains the Committee’s
jurisdiction over any transaction which
could result in foreign control of any
U.S. business, and broadens the
authorities of the President and CFIUS
under section 721 to address national
security concerns arising from certain
investments and real estate transactions.
Additionally, FIRRMA modernizes
CFIUS’s processes to better enable
timely and effective reviews of
transactions falling under its
jurisdiction (which FIRRMA describes
as ‘‘covered transactions’’). In enacting
PO 00000
Frm 00002
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
FIRRMA, Congress acknowledged the
important role of foreign investment in
the U.S. economy and reiterated its
support of the United States’ open
investment policy, consistent with the
protection of national security. A brief
summary of key provisions of FIRRMA,
as relevant for this rulemaking, follows.
FIRRMA expands and clarifies the
jurisdiction of the Committee by
explicitly adding four types of
transactions as covered transactions in
the DPA: (1) The purchase or lease by,
or concession to, a foreign person of
certain real estate in the United States;
(2) non-controlling ‘‘other investments’’
that afford a foreign person an equity
interest in and specified access to
information in the possession of, rights
in, or involvement in the
decisionmaking of certain U.S.
businesses involved in certain critical
technologies, critical infrastructure, or
sensitive personal data; (3) any change
in a foreign person’s rights if such
change could result in foreign control of
a U.S. business or an other investment
in certain U.S. businesses; and (4) any
other transaction, transfer, agreement, or
arrangement, the structure of which is
designed or intended to evade or
circumvent the application of section
721. With respect to the Committee’s
expanded jurisdiction over certain real
estate transactions and other
investments, FIRRMA instructs the
Committee to specify criteria to limit the
application of that expansion of
jurisdiction to certain categories of
foreign persons. The proposed rule
addresses all of these types of covered
transactions except for real estate
transactions, which are the subject of a
separate and concurrent rulemaking.
In addition to expanding the
Committee’s jurisdiction, FIRRMA
prescribes certain process changes.
FIRRMA allows parties to submit an
abbreviated filing for any covered
transaction through a declaration, as an
alternative to CFIUS’s traditional
voluntary notice, both of which are
discussed below. Declarations will
allow parties to submit basic
information regarding a transaction in
an abbreviated form that should
generally not exceed five pages in
length. FIRRMA also sets forth an
abbreviated timeframe for the
Committee to respond to submitted
declarations.
FIRRMA introduces a mandatory
declaration requirement in certain
circumstances. Specifically, FIRRMA
creates a mandatory declaration
requirement for certain covered
transactions where a foreign government
has a substantial interest. Additionally,
FIRRMA authorizes CFIUS to mandate
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
through regulations the submitting of a
declaration for covered transactions
involving certain U.S. businesses that
produce, design, test, manufacture,
fabricate, or develop one or more critical
technologies. In both cases, parties have
the option of filing a notice rather than
submitting a declaration if they so
choose.
FIRRMA also codifies certain
processes related to the Committee’s
authority to identify non-notified and
non-declared transactions.
FIRRMA permits a party to a
transaction to stipulate that a
transaction is a covered transaction and,
as relevant, a foreign governmentcontrolled transaction. A party can
make a stipulation in either a notice or
a declaration. If a party makes a
stipulation in a notice, CFIUS must
provide comments on or accept the
notice no later than 10 business days
after the date of the filing.
Additionally, FIRRMA extends the
timing of the review period for
transactions filed as notices from 30
days to 45 days and allows the Secretary
of the Treasury to grant one 15-day
extension of the 45-day investigation
period in ‘‘extraordinary
circumstances.’’ These provisions were
made effective in a rulemaking on
October 11, 2018. 83 FR 51316. FIRRMA
establishes a 30-day review period for
transactions submitted as declarations.
The notice and declarations processes
are discussed in further detail below.
B. Effective Date of Certain Provisions
Congress divided FIRRMA’s
provisions into two categories: Those
effective immediately and those that
become effective no later than February
13, 2020.
Specifically, section 1727(a) of
FIRRMA lists the provisions that
became effective immediately upon
enactment of the statute. A number of
the immediately effective provisions
required revisions to the CFIUS
regulations existing at that time at part
800 of title 31 of the Code of Federal
Regulations. On October 11, 2018, the
Department of the Treasury published
an interim rule implementing the
immediately effective provisions of, and
making updates consistent with,
FIRRMA. 83 FR 51316. That interim
rule was intended to provide clarity
regarding the processes and procedures
of the Committee pending the full
implementation of FIRRMA. The
interim rule provided for a public
comment period of 30 days. One
comment was received and is discussed
below.
Section 1727(b) of FIRRMA delayed
the effectiveness of any provision of
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
FIRRMA not specified in section 1727(a)
until the earlier of: (1) The date that is
18 months after the date of enactment of
FIRRMA (i.e., February 13, 2020); or (2)
the date that is 30 days after publication
in the Federal Register of a
determination by the chairperson of the
Committee that the regulations,
organizational structure, personnel, and
other resources necessary to administer
the new provisions are in place. The
proposed regulations in this notice are
intended to fully implement the
provisions of FIRRMA, with the
exception of (1) CFIUS’s new
jurisdiction over certain real estate
transactions, (2) CFIUS’s new authority
to impose filing fees, and (3) CFIUS’s
authority to mandate declarations for
certain transactions involving critical
technologies, each of which is the
subject of a separate rulemaking, as
discussed below.
Notwithstanding section 1727(b),
section 1727(c) of FIRRMA authorizes
CFIUS to conduct one or more pilot
programs to implement any authority
provided pursuant to any provision of,
or amendment made by, FIRRMA that
did not take effect immediately upon
enactment. On October 11, 2018, the
Department of the Treasury published
an interim rule setting forth the scope
of, and procedures for, a pilot program
to review certain transactions involving
foreign persons and critical technologies
(Pilot Program Interim Rule). 83 FR
51322. That Pilot Program Interim Rule,
which went into effect on November 10,
2018, established mandatory
declarations for certain transactions
involving investments by foreign
persons in certain U.S. businesses that
produce, design, test, manufacture,
fabricate, or develop one or more critical
technologies. The Pilot Program Interim
Rule provided for a public comment
period of 30 days, and a number of
comments were received. As discussed
below, the Committee is still
considering those comments and the
scope of mandatory declarations for
covered transactions involving critical
technologies. The Department of the
Treasury expects to address in the final
rule the comments previously received
on the Pilot Program Interim Rule and
any new comments provided in
response to this proposed rule.
C. Structure of FIRRMA Rulemaking
and This Proposed Rule
Consistent with CFIUS processes
generally, the proposed rule reflects
extensive consultation with CFIUS
member agencies, as well as other
relevant agencies. The proposed rule
retains many of the basic features of the
existing regulations, while
PO 00000
Frm 00003
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
50175
implementing the changes that FIRRMA
made to CFIUS’s jurisdiction and
process.
Given the number of revisions, the
proposed rule amends and restates part
800 in its entirety. Although the new
part 800 is being restated here in full,
many of the provisions of the prior part
800 are not being materially modified.
The Committee will consider all
comments provided to the proposed
rule, but is particularly interested in
receiving comments relating to the new
provisions and revisions being proposed
here and outlined below, rather than
comments relating to the text of part 800
that has not been changed.
In updating part 800 to incorporate
CFIUS’s new jurisdiction over noncontrolling other investments (which
this rule describes as ‘‘covered
investments’’), certain conforming edits
were made to existing provisions. For
example, the coverage section in subpart
C of the proposed rule on ‘‘covered
control transactions’’ is based on the
‘‘covered transactions’’ section in the
existing part 800 regulations and
provides examples of the different bases
of jurisdiction over control transactions
and covered investments. In that
respect, there is also now a covered
investment section within the coverage
subpart for the new jurisdiction. Finally,
the proposed rule incorporates the
changes made to part 800 in the interim
rule published in October 2018, and
updates certain other provisions.
This proposed rule does not
implement the authority FIRRMA
provided to the Committee to review the
purchase or lease by, or concession to,
a foreign person of certain real estate in
the United States. A concurrent
proposed rule implements such
authority under a separate part 802
within title 31 of the CFR. The
Department of the Treasury determined
that the technical and procedural
aspects of CFIUS’s review of
transactions involving real estate are
sufficiently distinct from those related
to control transactions and covered
investments to warrant separate
rulemaking.
Parties should be aware that certain
transactions that are not covered
transactions under this proposed rule
could potentially be covered real estate
transactions under the proposed part
802 real estate regulations.
FIRRMA authorizes the Committee to
assess and collect fees with respect to
covered transactions for which a written
notice is filed, and the Committee is
considering how to implement this
authority. The proposed rule also does
not address filing fees. The Department
of the Treasury will publish a separate
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
50176
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
proposed rule regarding fees at a later
date.
The proposed rule does not modify
the regulations currently at 31 CFR part
801, which sets forth the Pilot Program
Interim Rule. CFIUS continues to
evaluate the Pilot Program Interim Rule,
and the Department of the Treasury
welcomes comments on the retention of
the mandatory declaration aspect of the
Pilot Program Interim Rule for certain
transactions involving critical
technologies. The Department of the
Treasury received comments regarding
the Pilot Program Interim Rule from a
variety of commenters and expects to
address these comments in the final rule
associated with this proposed rule.
The proposed rule seeks to provide
clarity to the business and investment
communities with respect to the types
of U.S. businesses that are covered
under FIRRMA’s other investment
authority. Given the level of specificity
provided in certain provisions of the
proposed rule, the pace of technological
development, the evolving use of data,
and the evolving national security
landscape more generally, the
Department of the Treasury anticipates
that it will periodically review, and as
necessary, make changes to the
regulations, consistent with applicable
law.
II. Discussion of Proposed Rule
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
A. Subpart A—General
The following discussion describes
several key changes to subpart A.
Section 800.102—Risk-based analysis.
FIRRMA requires that any
determination of the Committee to
suspend a covered transaction, to refer
a covered transaction to the President,
or to negotiate, enter into or impose, or
enforce any agreement or condition with
respect to a covered transaction, be
based on a risk-based analysis,
conducted by the Committee, of the
effects on the national security of the
United States of the covered transaction,
which must include an assessment of
the threat, vulnerabilities, and
consequences to national security
related to the transaction. The proposed
rule includes definitions of the terms
‘‘threat,’’ ‘‘vulnerabilities,’’ and
‘‘consequences to national security’’
used in risk-based analyses undertaken
by the Committee.
Section 800.104—Applicability rule.
The proposed rule clarifies the existing
applicability rule. The proposed rule
also removes the provision previously
found at § 800.103(b)(4) that established
applicability to a transaction based
upon a Committee determination that a
commitment had been made.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
B. Subpart B—Definitions
Several key changes to the existing
part 800 definitions and several key new
definitions that are broadly applicable
to both control transactions and covered
investments are discussed immediately
below. Certain new definitions that are
applicable to specific substantive areas
regarding covered investments are
discussed in the applicable subsections
below.
Section 800.203—Business day. The
proposed rule modifies the definition
for ‘‘business day’’ to exclude days
where there U.S. Office of Personnel
Management has announced the closure
of Federal offices in the Washington, DC
area. The proposed rule also addresses
the impact on certain timing
requirements where a submission is
received after 5 p.m. (Eastern Time).
Section 800.206—Completion date.
The proposed rule includes a definition
for ‘‘completion date.’’ The proposed
rule clarifies that, in the event that a
covered transaction will be effectuated
through multiple or staged closings, the
completion date is the earliest date on
which any transfer of interest or change
in rights that constitutes a covered
transaction occurs.
Section 800.207—Contingent equity
interest. FIRRMA uses the term
‘‘contingent equity interest’’ in the
definition of investment. The proposed
rule eliminates the term ‘‘convertible
voting instrument’’ in the existing part
800 in light of the new definition of
‘‘contingent equity interest.’’ The
proposed rule also updates the
references in the timing rule at
§ 800.308.
Section 800.214—Critical
infrastructure. The proposed rule
revises the definition for ‘‘critical
infrastructure’’ to conform to the
language in FIRRMA. As discussed
further below, however, for the
purposes of an other investment,
FIRRMA requires CFIUS to specify a
subset of critical infrastructure.
Section 800.252—U.S. business. The
proposed rule revises the definition for
‘‘U.S. business’’ to conform to the
definition in FIRRMA.
C. Covered Investments
The proposed rule implements
CFIUS’s authority, provided under
FIRRMA, to review an investment by a
foreign person in certain types of U.S.
businesses that affords the foreign
person certain access to information in
the possession of, rights in, or
involvement in the decisionmaking of
certain U.S. businesses but that does not
afford the foreign person control over
the U.S. business. The proposed rule
PO 00000
Frm 00004
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
uses the term ‘‘covered investments’’ for
these investments, as defined in
§ 800.211.
The types of access, rights, or
involvement that could give rise to a
covered investment are set forth in
§ 800.211(b). That section implements
the definitions in FIRRMA describing
transactions that afford the foreign
person (1) access to material non-public
technical information in the possession
of the U.S. business, (2) membership or
observer rights on the board of directors
(or equivalent body) of the U.S.
business, or (3) any involvement in
substantive decisionmaking of the U.S.
business regarding certain actions
related to critical technologies, critical
infrastructure, or sensitive personal
data. The proposed rule further defines
‘‘material non-public technical
information’’ (see § 800.233) and
‘‘substantive decisionmaking’’ (see
§ 800.245).
The types of businesses in which an
investment may constitute a covered
investment are those that have certain
involvement in critical technologies,
critical infrastructure, and sensitive
personal data, as further described
below and in the proposed rule. These
businesses are referred to as ‘‘TID U.S.
businesses’’ in the proposed rule (see
§ 800.248). ‘‘TID’’ is an acronym for
Technology, Infrastructure, and Data.
FIRRMA, moreover, limits such covered
investments to those made in an
unaffiliated business. Thus, the
proposed rule adds a definition for
‘‘unaffiliated TID U.S. business,’’ which
excludes entities in which the foreign
person already holds a majority of the
voting interest or the right to appoint
the majority of the entity’s board or
equivalent governing body.
Notably, CFIUS retains jurisdiction
over any transaction through which any
foreign person could acquire control of
any U.S. business, regardless of whether
the transaction involves critical
technology, critical infrastructure, or
sensitive personal data.
In connection with the new
jurisdiction over covered investments,
FIRRMA requires that the Committee
prescribe regulations to limit its
application to the investments of certain
categories of foreign persons. This
proposed rule implements this
requirement by ‘‘excepting’’ certain
foreign persons from the provisions
relating to covered investments if the
foreign persons meet specified criteria.
It also includes clarifications contained
in FIRRMA regarding the treatment of
certain investments through investment
funds and an exception specified in
FIRRMA for investments involving air
carriers.
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
1. Covered Investments Involving
Critical Technology
FIRRMA expands CFIUS’s
jurisdiction to include covered
investments by a foreign person in an
unaffiliated U.S. business that produces,
designs, tests, manufactures, fabricates,
or develops one or more critical
technologies.
Section 800.215—Critical
technologies. The proposed rule defines
‘‘critical technologies’’ consistent with
the language in FIRRMA. Subpart (f) of
FIRRMA’s definition of critical
technology, as set out in this proposed
rule, captures emerging and
foundational technologies controlled
pursuant to section 1758 of the Export
Control Reform Act of 2018 (ECRA),
Subtitle B of Title XVII of Public Law
115–232. Pursuant to ECRA, the Bureau
of Industry and Security within the
Department of Commerce identifies and
places export controls on specified
emerging and foundational
technologies. As technologies become
controlled pursuant to rulemaking
under ECRA, they will automatically be
covered under the definition of ‘‘critical
technologies’’ under part 800.
As noted above, CFIUS will continue
to have authority to review any
transaction that could result in control
by a foreign person of any U.S. business,
including a U.S. business with
technology, critical or otherwise, and
export controlled or otherwise.
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
2. Covered Investments Involving
Critical Infrastructure
FIRRMA expands CFIUS’s
jurisdiction to include covered
investments by a foreign person in an
unaffiliated U.S. business that ‘‘owns,
operates, manufactures, supplies, or
services critical infrastructure.’’
FIRRMA requires that the regulations
implementing this provision limit the
application of covered investment
jurisdiction to a subset of critical
infrastructure that must be specified in
the regulations. Moreover, FIRRMA
specifically provides that any definition
of ‘‘critical infrastructure’’ established
under any provision of law other than
section 721 is not determinative for the
purposes of section 721, including this
proposed rule. Similarly, the subset of
critical infrastructure identified in
appendix A is not intended to alter the
definition of ‘‘critical infrastructure’’ as
used in any other regulatory regime or
context.
Section 800.212—Covered investment
critical infrastructure. The proposed
rule identifies the subset of critical
infrastructure that is relevant for the
Committee’s jurisdiction over covered
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
investments through a list of specific
types of infrastructure in appendix A.
As noted above, the Department of the
Treasury anticipates periodically
revising the regulations, potentially
including revisions to this list. To
distinguish this subset of critical
infrastructure from critical
infrastructure more broadly, this
proposed rule creates a new term,
‘‘covered investment critical
infrastructure’’ (see § 800.212).
As noted above, FIRRMA describes,
subject to the regulations implementing
this provision, a U.S. business that falls
under other investment jurisdiction
with respect to critical infrastructure as
one that ‘‘owns, operates, manufactures,
supplies, or services’’ the subset of
critical infrastructure. This proposed
rule refers to these activities as
‘‘functions.’’ In furtherance of FIRRMA’s
requirement to limit the application of
other investment jurisdiction regarding
critical infrastructure, the proposed rule
sets forth which functions apply to each
enumerated specific type of covered
investment critical infrastructure. The
proposed rule therefore links the
relevant functions with the enumerated
specific types of covered investment
critical infrastructure in appendix A.
Column 1 of appendix A lists the
covered investment critical
infrastructure and Column 2 lists the
relevant functions that apply to
enumerated specific types of covered
investment critical infrastructure.
Appendix A is integral to the
proposed rule and key to determining
whether a U.S. business is a TID U.S.
business for purposes of critical
infrastructure covered investment
jurisdiction. Only a U.S. business that
performs one of the specified functions
listed in Column 2 of appendix A with
respect to the enumerated specific type
of covered investment infrastructure
listed in Column 1 is a TID U.S.
business for purposes of critical
infrastructure covered investments. The
proposed rule also clarifies the meaning
of certain of the functions listed in
FIRRMA.
Section 800.235—Own. The proposed
rule defines ‘‘own’’ solely for the
purpose of Column 2 of appendix A,
which in turn determines which owners
of covered investment critical
infrastructure are TID U.S. businesses
for purposes of covered investment
jurisdiction. The term limits owners to
only those of U.S. businesses that
directly possess the systems or assets
constituting the applicable covered
investment critical infrastructure.
Sections 800.232—Manufacture;
800.242—Service; and 800.246—
Supply. The proposed rule also defines
PO 00000
Frm 00005
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
50177
‘‘manufacture,’’ ‘‘service,’’ and
‘‘supply.’’ It does not define ‘‘operate’’
given the commonly understood
meaning of that term.
Importantly, appendix A only applies
to the subset of critical infrastructure
subject to covered investment
jurisdiction, and is not applicable in any
other context. Appendix A implements
FIRRMA’s direction to identify a subset
of critical infrastructure for purposes of
covered investments and therefore does
not modify the definition of critical
infrastructure as it applies to CFIUS’s
jurisdiction more broadly over control
transactions.
As noted above, CFIUS will continue
to have authority to review any
transaction that could result in control
by a foreign person of any U.S. business,
regardless of whether the U.S. business
involves critical infrastructure as
broadly defined by FIRRMA or the
narrower subset of covered investment
critical infrastructure introduced in this
proposed rule.
3. Covered Investments Involving
Sensitive Personal Data
FIRRMA expands CFIUS’s
jurisdiction to include covered
investments by a foreign person in an
unaffiliated U.S. business that maintains
or collects sensitive personal data of
U.S. citizens that ‘‘may be exploited in
a manner that threatens to harm
national security.’’
Section 800.241—Sensitive personal
data. To implement this provision, the
proposed rule sets forth a detailed
definition for ‘‘sensitive personal data.’’
The Committee anticipates periodically
revising the regulations, potentially
including revisions to this definition.
Given that most companies collect
some type of data on individuals, the
proposed rule protects national security
while attempting to minimize any
chilling effect on beneficial foreign
investment by focusing on the
sensitivity of the data itself, as well as
the sensitivity of the population about
whom the data is maintained or
collected. In particular, the proposed
rule identifies specific categories of data
that constitute sensitive personal data
only if the U.S. business (a) targets or
tailors its products or services to
sensitive U.S. Government personnel or
contractors, (b) maintains or collects
such data on greater than one million
individuals, or (c) has a demonstrated
business objective to maintain or collect
such data on greater than one million
individuals and such data is an
integrated part of the U.S. business’s
primary products or services. The
proposed definition also includes all
genetic information and generally carves
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
50178
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
out data pertaining to a U.S. business’s
own employees.
The proposed rule defines ‘‘targets or
tailors’’ (see § 800.247) and provides
examples of businesses that meet the
definition. By focusing on U.S.
businesses that target or tailor their
products or services to these potentially
sensitive populations, the Committee
expects to review transactions involving
U.S. businesses that are more likely to
have sensitive personal data concerning
such individuals. Even if a U.S.
business does not target or tailor its
products or services to such individuals,
however, if the U.S. business maintains
or collects data on a large number of
individuals, it is more likely to capture
data on sensitive populations. The
proposed threshold of one million
accounts for this possibility. Similarly,
if a U.S. business is a data-driven
company that plans to maintain or
collect sensitive personal data on a large
number of individuals in the future, as
demonstrated by the U.S. business’s
statements or actions, it may capture
data on sensitive populations.
Section 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(A)—This
section describes certain financial data
that could be used to determine if an
individual is experiencing financial
hardship. The types of data the
proposed rule seeks to capture include
bank account statements or detailed
financial information included in an
application for a home mortgage or
credit card. Information regarding
ordinary consumer transactions, such as
a record of a credit card purchase at a
retail establishment, would not
generally fall into this category.
Section 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(B)—This
section describes information that is
collected by consumer reporting
agencies, such as an individual’s credit
score, or summaries of debts and
payment histories. Many companies
periodically receive information about
an individual’s credit from a consumer
reporting agency, and
§ 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(B) generally excludes
these companies from its scope if they
receive a limited set of the information,
such as a credit score, for the legitimate
purposes described in the Fair Credit
Reporting Act.
Section 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(C)—This
section describes data contained in
certain types of personal insurance
applications, many of which contain
detailed personal information related to
financial status and health.
Section 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(D)—This
section describes health-related data.
Section 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(E)—This
section describes non-public electronic
communications, including email,
which may include all manner of
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
sensitive information, but only if the
U.S. business is providing
communications platforms used by
third parties. For example, email
communications between a U.S.
business and its own customers would
not be covered. Rather, this section
describes the situation where a U.S.
business offers email, chat, or messaging
services, a primary purpose of which is
to allow third parties to communicate
with each other.
Section 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(F)—This
section describes geolocation data that
is often collected by mobile mapping
applications, GPS services, or wireless
communications providers.
Section 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(G)—This
section describes data that is generated
by companies that provide biometric
identification services.
Section 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(H)–(J)—
These sections describes certain data
that is held by companies, typically
government contractors, that issue
official government identification cards
or process personnel security
clearances.
Section 800.227—Identifiable data;
§ 800.239—Personal identifier. The
proposed rule also includes a definition
of ‘‘identifiable data.’’ In some cases, a
U.S. business may maintain or collect
the data described in
§ 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(A)–(J), but it is not
possible to attribute such data to any
specific individual. For example, a U.S.
business may store health records on its
servers, but those records are encrypted
such that only a third party in
possession of the encryption key can
read the data. The U.S. business in these
circumstances would not be
maintaining or collecting sensitive
personal data. The proposed rule makes
clear, however, that identifiable data is
not limited to data that includes an
individual’s name or other obvious
identifier, but rather includes any
personal identifier, as defined in
§ 800.239.
Finally, § 800.241(a)(2) describes
genetic information, as defined pursuant
to the regulations implementing HIPAA.
Unlike the categories described in
sections 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(A)–(J), the
requirement that the U.S. business target
or tailor to certain U.S. Government
personnel or contractors, maintain or
collect data on greater than one million
individuals, or have a demonstrated
business objective to maintain or collect
such data on greater than one million
individuals if such data is an integrated
part of the U.S. business’s primary
products or services as well as the
requirement that the data be
identifiable, does not apply to genetic
information.
PO 00000
Frm 00006
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
As noted above, CFIUS will continue
to have authority to review any
transaction that could result in control
by a foreign person of any U.S. business,
regardless of whether the U.S. business
maintains or collects sensitive personal
data.
4. Country Specification for Covered
Investments
FIRRMA requires CFIUS to specify
criteria to limit the application of
FIRRMA’s expanded jurisdiction over
other investments to certain categories
of foreign persons. The proposed rule
addresses FIRRMA’s requirement
through three new defined terms,
‘‘excepted investor,’’ ‘‘excepted foreign
state,’’ and ‘‘minimum excepted
ownership,’’ which operate together to
exclude from CFIUS’s jurisdiction
covered investments by certain foreign
persons who meet certain criteria
establishing sufficiently close ties to
certain foreign states. Sections 800.220,
800.219, and 800.234 define excepted
investor, excepted foreign state, and
minimum excepted ownership,
respectively.
Section 800.220—Excepted investor.
The proposed rule sets forth a narrow
definition of excepted investor in the
interest of protecting national security,
in light of increasingly complex
ownership structures, and to prevent
foreign persons from circumventing
CFIUS’s jurisdiction. Thus, the criteria
specified in § 800.220 require that a
foreign person have a substantial
connection (e.g., nationality of ultimate
beneficial owners and place of
incorporation) to one or more particular
foreign states in order to be deemed an
excepted investor. Note that foreign
persons who have violated, or whose
parents or subsidiaries have violated,
certain U.S. laws, executive orders,
regulations, orders, directives, or
licenses, or who have submitted a
material misstatement or omission in a
CFIUS notice or declaration or violated
a material provision of a mitigation
agreement, among other things, will not
be considered excepted investors.
Additionally, note that a foreign person
who is an excepted investor at the time
of the transaction, but, who, for up to
three years after the completion date,
fails to meet to certain criteria, is
deemed not to be an excepted investor
and the transaction is thus subject to
CFIUS jurisdiction as a covered
investment. Any member of the
Committee may file an agency notice of
the transaction for up to one year (and
the Chairperson of the Committee for up
to three years in extraordinary
circumstances).
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
Section 800.219—Excepted foreign
state. The rule proposes that the
excepted foreign state definition operate
as a two-factor conjunctive test. First,
the foreign state must be included in a
defined group of eligible foreign states,
which will be separately published on
the Department of the Treasury website.
As this is a new concept with
potentially significant implications for
the national security of the United
States, CFIUS initially intends to
designate a limited number of eligible
foreign states. CFIUS plans to review
this group in the future and potentially
expand the number of eligible foreign
states.
Second, in furtherance of CFIUS’s
efforts to encourage partner countries to
implement robust processes to review
foreign investment in their countries
and to increase cooperation with the
United States, the Secretary of the
Treasury, with the agreement of a supermajority of Committee member
agencies, will also make a
determination, as described in subpart J,
for each eligible foreign state as to
whether such foreign state has
established and is effectively utilizing a
robust process to assess foreign
investments for national security risks
and to facilitate coordination with the
United States on matters relating to
investment security. In making these
determinations, CFIUS will consider
factors that will be made available on
the Department of the Treasury website.
The Committee is considering delaying
the effectiveness of this requirement in
order to provide the eligible foreign
states time to enhance their foreign
investment review processes and
bilateral cooperation. Any such
determinations identifying a foreign
state as an excepted foreign state will be
published in the Federal Register and
incorporated into the Committee’s list of
excepted foreign states, which will be
made available on the Department of the
Treasury website.
D. Subpart C—Coverage
Subpart C of the proposed rule
includes provisions that describe with
particularity transactions that are, or are
not, covered control transactions
(§ 800.301–302). Similar provisions
address covered investments
(§ 800.303–304). The proposed rule
contains numerous examples in this
subpart to clarify the coverage of certain
transactions.
Section 800.305—Incremental
acquisitions. Under the existing
§ 800.204(e), ‘‘[a]ny transaction in
which a foreign person acquires an
additional interest in a U.S. business
that was previously the subject of a
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
covered transaction for which the
Committee concluded all action under
section 721 shall not be deemed to be
a transaction that could result in foreign
control over that U.S. business (i.e., it is
not a covered transaction).’’ This
provision was introduced when the
scope of CFIUS’s jurisdiction included
only transactions that could result in
foreign control of a U.S. business and
when the only means to file was by
filing a written notice. This proposed
rule moves the provision to Subpart C
and clarifies that a transaction shall not
be deemed to be a covered transaction
if a foreign person acquires an
additional interest in a U.S. business
over which the same foreign person or
any of its direct or indirect whollyowned subsidiaries previously acquired
direct control in the U.S. business in a
covered control transaction for which
the Committee concluded all action
under Section 721 on the basis of a
notice. It further clarifies that this
provision does not apply to incremental
acquisitions in a U.S. business by a
foreign person that had not previously
acquired control of the U.S. business
nor to a transaction for which the
Committee had concluded all action
under section 721 on the basis of a
declaration. In other words, the
incremental acquisition rule does not
apply where the initial transaction was
submitted only as declaration or was a
covered investment.
Section 800.307—Specific
clarifications for investment funds. The
proposed rule implements provisions in
FIRRMA relating to investment funds.
Specifically, it clarifies that, in the
context of an indirect investment by a
foreign person in an unaffiliated TID
U.S. business through an investment
fund that affords the foreign person (or
a designee of the foreign person)
membership as a limited partner or
equivalent on an advisory board or
committee of the fund, where all of the
criteria in § 800.307 are satisfied, a
limited partner’s membership on the
investment fund’s advisory board or
committee does not in and of itself
render the foreign person’s indirect
investment in an unaffiliated TID U.S.
business a covered investment.
E. Subpart D—Declarations
FIRRMA introduces an abbreviated
filing process through the submission of
a declaration, which allows parties to
submit basic information regarding a
transaction to the Committee. A
declaration may be submitted for any
covered transaction and, in certain
cases, is mandated. Parties may choose
to file a notice in lieu of declaration to
PO 00000
Frm 00007
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
50179
satisfy a mandatory declaration
requirement.
Declarations differ from notices in
three key ways. First, declarations are
shorter in length, generally not
exceeding five pages. As part of the Pilot
Program Interim Rule, CFIUS developed
a standard fillable declaration form for
parties to use when submitting a
transaction for review. To facilitate the
submission of declarations under the
proposed rule, CFIUS intends to
maintain a standard fillable form,
making certain modifications to the
form for use with respect to different
types of transactions. Parties will be
able to use the form to submit voluntary
and mandatory declarations to the
Committee.
Second, the timeline for the
Committee to take action on
declarations is shorter than for notices.
FIRRMA provides CFIUS up to 30 days
to respond to a declaration. This differs
from the timeline for notices, which is
45 days for a review and an additional
45 days for an investigation, with a
possibility of a 15-day extension in
‘‘extraordinary circumstances.’’
Third, FIRRMA provides CFIUS with
several potential responses to a
declaration, and CFIUS need not make
a final determination with respect to
action under section 721 on the basis of
a declaration.
1. Mandatory Declarations
Section 800.401—Mandatory
declarations. The proposed rule
implements FIRRMA’s requirement for
mandatory declarations for certain
transactions in which a foreign person
obtains a ‘‘substantial interest’’ in a U.S.
business where a foreign government in
turn holds a ‘‘substantial interest’’ in the
foreign person. The proposed rule
defines the term substantial interest
with respect to a person’s ability to
influence the actions of another person
in a manner that has the potential,
directly or indirectly, to impair the
national security of the United States. In
most cases, the foreign person best
placed to influence a U.S. business—
and therefore exploit any vulnerability
in a U.S. business—is the foreign person
with the closest relationship to the U.S.
business. With respect to an investment
involving multiple tiers of investing
entities, this foreign person is very
frequently the one that sits closest to the
U.S. business on the post-closing
organizational chart. This entity, when
compared to other entities higher in the
organizational chart, often has a greater
ability to interact directly with—and
therefore influence—the U.S. business,
both from a corporate governance
perspective as well as an operational
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
50180
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
a transaction that is the subject of a
declaration until such time as the
Committee’s assessment of the
declaration has been completed (see
§ 800.501(j)).
Section 800.404—Contents of
declarations. The proposed rule sets
forth the information that is required in
a declaration, consistent with FIRRMA’s
requirement that CFIUS establish
declarations as ‘‘abbreviated notices that
would not generally exceed five pages
in length.’’ As part of a declaration,
parties may voluntarily stipulate that
the transaction is a covered transaction
and, if so, whether the transaction is a
foreign-government controlled
transaction.
Section 800.405—Beginning of 30-day
assessment period. The proposed rule
requires that the Committee take action
on a declaration within 30 days of the
Committee’s receipt of the declaration
from the Staff Chairperson. One
distinction from the provisions
regarding declarations in the Pilot
Program Interim Rule is that the
proposed rule explicitly provides that
the Staff Chairperson may invite parties
to a declaration to attend a meeting with
Committee Staff to discuss and clarify
issues pertaining to the transaction that
is the subject of the declaration.
Section 800.406—Rejection,
disposition, or withdrawal of
declarations. The proposed rule
provides that the Committee may reject
a declaration if it is incomplete, there is
a material change in the transaction that
has been notified, information comes to
light that contradicts material
information provided by the parties in
the declaration, or parties to a submitted
declaration fail to provide information
2. Voluntary Declarations
requested by the Committee within two
business days of the request (unless
Section 800.402—Voluntary
such timeframe is extended by the Staff
declarations. The proposed rule
Chairperson). The proposed rule also
implements FIRRMA’s provision
establishes procedures for parties to
enabling parties to choose to file a
withdraw a declaration, and makes clear
declaration with CFIUS instead of a
that parties may not submit more than
written notice.
one declaration for the same or
3. Procedures and Contents for
substantially similar transaction without
Declarations
approval from the Staff Chairperson.
Section 800.407—Committee actions.
Section 800.403—Procedures for
declarations. The proposed rule outlines The proposed rule implements
FIRRMA’s mandate that the Committee
the process under which parties submit
take one of four actions in response to
a declaration. The contents and
a declaration: (1) Request that the
procedures for submitting mandatory
and voluntary declarations are identical. parties file a notice; (2) inform the
parties that CFIUS cannot complete
In order to submit a declaration, the
action under section 721 on the basis of
parties need to provide the information
the declaration, and that they may file
required by § 800.404, including
a notice to seek written notification
certifications. The rule does not permit
parties to submit a declaration regarding from the Committee that the Committee
has concluded all action under section
a transaction that is also the subject of
721 with respect to the transaction; (3)
a notice without written approval from
initiate a unilateral review of the
the Staff Chairperson. Conversely,
transaction through an agency notice; or
parties may not file a notice regarding
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
perspective. The proposed rule therefore
establishes in § 800.244(a) the voting
interest threshold for substantial interest
between a foreign person and U.S.
business at a 25 percent voting interest,
direct or indirect, and between a foreign
government and a foreign person at a 49
percent or greater voting interest, direct
or indirect. For purposes of determining
the percentage of voting interest held
indirectly by one entity in another, the
rule establishes that any voting interest
of a parent entity in a subsidiary entity
will be deemed to be a 100 percent
voting interest. The proposed rule also
clarifies in § 800.244(b) how the voting
interest in a limited partnership is to be
calculated. The proposed rule does not
provide for a waiver of this requirement.
As discussed above, CFIUS is
considering whether to continue the
mandatory declaration requirement
under the Pilot Program Interim Rule,
which requires declarations for covered
control transactions and covered
investments in certain U.S. businesses
with critical technologies involved in
one or more of 27 specified industries.
Section 800.401(e)(2). FIRRMA also
provides that, for mandatory
declarations, the Committee can require
that a declaration be submitted up to 45
days prior to the completion of the
transaction. Under the proposed rule,
mandatory declarations would need to
be submitted to CFIUS at least 30 days
in advance of the completion date.
Section 800.401(d). Where there is a
mandatory declaration requirement,
parties may choose to submit a written
notice at least 30 days prior to the
completion date of the transaction
instead of a declaration.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
PO 00000
Frm 00008
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
(4) notify the parties that CFIUS has
concluded all action under section 721.
F. Subpart E—Notices
The proposed rule does not make
significant changes to the procedures
and requirements for notices.
Section 800.502(o)—Contents of
voluntary notices. FIRRMA allows
parties to ‘‘stipulate’’ that the
transaction is a covered transaction and,
as relevant, a foreign governmentcontrolled transaction. FIRRMA directs
the Committee to provide comments or
accept the notice within 10 business
days from the submission date of the
draft or formal written notice in cases
where the transaction parties have
stipulated that the transaction is a
covered transaction. In addition,
stipulating control reduces certain
information requirements, and will
allow the Committee to more quickly
turn to reviewing the substance of the
transaction. (See § 800.502(j)(2).) In
making a stipulation, parties
acknowledge that the Committee and
the President are entitled to rely on such
stipulation in determining whether the
transaction is a covered transaction and/
or a foreign government-controlled
transaction, and parties making a
stipulation waive the right to challenge
any such determination. Neither the
Committee nor the President is bound
by any such stipulation, nor does any
such stipulation limit the ability of the
Committee or the President to act on
any authority provided under section
721, with respect to any covered
transaction.
Section 800.502(c)(1)(xi) and
(c)(3)(ix)–(xi)—Contents of voluntary
notices. The rule proposes additions to
the information requirements to require
submission of information necessary to
analyze covered investments. A few
additional changes to the information
requirements have been introduced for
clarity and to include information that
CFIUS determined was necessary based
on experience.
Section 800.503—Beginning of 45-day
review period. FIRRMA changes the
timeframe for CFIUS’s review of a
transaction filed as a notice, extending
it from 30 days to 45 days. This change
was one of the immediately effective
provisions of FIRRMA that was
implemented through the interim rule
published at 83 FR 51316. The proposed
rule, consistent with the interim rule,
incorporates that timing change.
G. Subpart G—Finality of Action
FIRRMA maintains that a covered
transaction that has been notified to
CFIUS as a notice and on which CFIUS
has concluded action under section 721
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
after determining that there are no
unresolved national security concerns,
qualifies for a ‘‘safe harbor,’’ and
extends the same treatment to
transactions submitted as a declaration.
This means that, unless a party to a
transaction submitted false or
misleading material information or
omitted material information, and
subject to compliance with the terms of
any mitigation agreement entered into
with or conditions imposed by CFIUS,
the transaction can proceed without the
possibility of subsequent suspension or
prohibition under section 721. A
covered transaction on which CFIUS
has not concluded action does not
qualify for the safe harbor, and CFIUS
has the authority to initiate review of
the transaction on its own, even after
the transaction has been completed,
which CFIUS may choose to do if it
believes the transaction presents
national security considerations.
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
H. Subpart I—Penalties and Damages
The Department of the Treasury
amended the penalty provisions of its
regulations in the interim rule
published at 83 FR 51316, which
updated CFIUS’s penalties provision
consistent with revisions made to
section 721 by FIRRMA. The proposed
rule adopts the revisions from the
interim rule and makes certain other
updates to subpart I.
Section 800.901—Penalties and
damages. The proposed rule, consistent
with the interim rule, removes the
qualifier ‘‘intentionally or through gross
negligence’’ with respect to a material
misstatement or omission in the context
of the imposition of civil penalties.
These revisions did not, and do not,
apply to material misstatements,
omissions, or certifications made prior
to the interim rule’s effective date
(October 11, 2018), or to violations
occurring after the implementation of
the interim rule of a material provision
of a mitigation agreements or material
conditions of an order entered into or
imposed prior to the implementation of
the interim rule.
Section 800.902—Effect of lack of
compliance. The proposed rule,
consistent with the interim rule,
includes a provision authorizing the
Committee to negotiate a remediation
plan for lack of compliance with a
mitigation agreement or condition
entered into or imposed under section
721(l), require filings for future covered
transactions for five years, or seek
injunctive relief, in addition to other
available remedies.
The proposed rule includes certain
other modifications to subpart I,
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
including with respect to how penalties
are calculated, imposed, and enforced.
III. Public Comments
The Department of the Treasury
received one comment to the interim
rule. The commenter sought additional
information about what circumstances
the Committee believes would warrant a
15-day extension of an investigation in
order ‘‘to protect the national security of
the United States.’’
Response: The interim rule provides
that where a Committee member
requests to extend an investigation, that
request must include a description,
‘‘with particularity, [of] the
extraordinary circumstances that
warrant the Chairperson extending the
investigation.’’ 31 CFR 800.506.
Accordingly, whether ‘‘extraordinary
circumstances’’ exist depends on the
specific facts of a particular
investigation, and are difficult to
generalize. While we understand the
commenter’s interest in additional
information from the Committee, at this
time we are not considering altering or
expanding on the extraordinary
circumstances provisions relating to a
15-day extension of an investigation in
part 800.
IV. Rulemaking Requirements
Executive Order 12866
These regulations are not subject to
the general requirements of Executive
Order 12866, which covers review of
regulations by the Office of Information
and Regulatory Affairs in the Office of
Management and Budget, because they
relate to a foreign affairs function of the
United States, pursuant to section
3(d)(2) of that order.
Paperwork Reduction Act
The collections of information
contained in this notice of proposed
rulemaking have been submitted to the
Office of Management and Budget for
review in accordance with the
Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (44
U.S.C. 3507(d)) (PRA).
Comments on the collection of
information should be sent to the Office
of Management and Budget, Attn: Desk
Officer for the Department of the
Treasury, Office of Information and
Regulatory Affairs, Washington, DC
20503, or via email to OIRA_
Submission@omb.eop.gov, with copies
to Thomas Feddo, Deputy Assistant
Secretary for Investment Security, U.S.
Department of the Treasury, 1500
Pennsylvania Avenue NW, Washington,
DC 20220. Comments on the collection
of information should be received by
November 25, 2019.
PO 00000
Frm 00009
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
50181
In accordance with 5 CFR
1320.8(d)(1), the Department of the
Treasury is soliciting comments from
members of the public concerning this
collection of information to:
(1) Evaluate whether the proposed
collection of information is necessary
for the proper performance of the
functions of the agency, including
whether the information will have
practical utility;
(2) Evaluate the accuracy of the
agency’s estimate of the burden of the
proposed collection of information;
(3) Enhance the quality, utility, and
clarity of the information to be
collected; and
(4) Minimize the burden of the
collection of information on those who
are to respond; including through the
use of appropriate automated collection
techniques or other forms of information
technology.
The burden of the information
collections in this proposed rule is
estimated as follows:
For Notices
Estimated total annual reporting and/
or recordkeeping burden: 26,000 hours.
Estimated average annual burden per
respondent: 130 hours.
Estimated number of respondents:
200 per year.
Estimated annual frequency of
responses: Not applicable.
For Declarations
Estimated total annual reporting and/
or recordkeeping burden: 11,000 hours.
Estimated average annual burden per
respondent: 20 hours.
Estimated number of respondents:
550 per year.
Estimated annual frequency of
responses: Not applicable.
Under the PRA, an agency may not
conduct or sponsor, and a person is not
required to respond to, a collection of
information unless it displays a valid
control number assigned by the Office of
Management and Budget.
Initial Regulatory Flexibility Analysis
The Regulatory Flexibility Act (5
U.S.C. 601 et seq.) (RFA) generally
requires an agency to prepare a
regulatory flexibility analysis unless the
agency certifies that the rule will not,
once implemented, have a significant
economic impact on a substantial
number of small entities. The RFA
applies whenever an agency is required
to publish a general notice of proposed
rulemaking under section 553(b) of the
Administrative Procedure Act (5 U.S.C.
553) (APA), or any other law. As set
forth below, because regulations issued
pursuant to the DPA, such as these
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
50182
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
regulations, are not subject to the APA,
or another law requiring the publication
of a general notice of proposed
rulemaking, the RFA does not apply.
The proposed rule implements
section 721 of the DPA. Section 709(a)
of the DPA provides that the regulations
issued under it are not subject to the
rulemaking requirements of the APA.
Section 709(b)(1) instead provides that
any regulation issued under the DPA be
published in the Federal Register and
opportunity for public comment be
provided for not less than 30 days.
Section 709(b)(3) of the DPA also
provides that all comments received
during the public comment period be
considered and the publication of the
final regulation contain written
responses to such comments. Consistent
with the plain text of the DPA,
legislative history confirms that
Congress intended that regulations
under the DPA be exempt from the
notice and comment provisions of the
APA and instead provided that the
agency include a statement that
interested parties were consulted in the
formulation of the final regulation. See
H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 102–1028, at 42
(1992) and H.R. Rep. No. 102–208 pt. 1,
at 28 (1991). The limited public
participation procedures described in
the DPA do not require a general notice
of proposed rulemaking as set forth in
the RFA. Further, the mechanisms for
publication and public participation are
sufficiently different to distinguish the
DPA procedures from a rule that
requires a general notice of proposed
rulemaking. In providing the President
with expanded authority to suspend or
prohibit the acquisition, merger, or
takeover of, or certain other investments
in, a U.S. business by a foreign person
if such a transaction would threaten to
impair the national security of the
United States, Congress could not have
contemplated that regulations
implementing such authority would be
subject to RFA analysis. For these
reasons, the RFA does not apply to these
regulations.
Notwithstanding the inapplicability of
the RFA, the Department of the Treasury
has undertaken an analysis of the
proposed rule’s potential impact on
small businesses in the United States.
While the Department of the Treasury
believes that the proposed rule likely
would not have a ‘‘significant economic
impact on a substantial number of small
entities’’ (5 U.S.C. 605(b)), the
Department of the Treasury does not
have complete data at this time to make
this determination, and therefore invites
the public to comment on its analysis.
As discussed above, the proposed rule
expands the jurisdiction of the
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
Committee to include additional types
of transactions not previously subject to
CFIUS review. Additionally, the
Committee will retain its existing
jurisdiction over any transaction
through which any foreign person could
acquire control of any U.S. business.
Accordingly, the proposed rule may
impact any U.S. business, including a
small U.S. business that engages in a
covered transaction.
There is no single source for
information on the number of small U.S.
businesses that receive foreign
investment (direct or indirect),
including those involved with critical
technologies, critical infrastructure, or
sensitive personal data, such that they
would be directly impacted by this rule.
However, the Bureau of Economic
Analysis (BEA) within the Department
of Commerce collects, on an annual
basis, data on new foreign direct
investment in the United States through
its Survey of New Foreign Direct
Investment in the United States (Form
BE-13). While these data are selfreported, and include only direct
investments in U.S. businesses in which
the foreign person acquires at least 10
percent of the voting shares (and
consequently, do not capture
investments below 10 percent, which
may nevertheless be covered
transactions), they nonetheless provide
relevant information on a category of
U.S. businesses that receive foreign
investment, some of which may be
covered by the proposed rule.
According to the BEA, in 2018, the
most current year for which data is
available, foreign persons obtained at
least a 10 percent voting share in 832
U.S. businesses. U.S. Bureau of
Economic Analysis, ‘‘Number of
Investments Initiated in 2018,
Distribution of Planned Total
Expenditures, Size by Type of
Investment,’’ https://apps.bea.gov/
international/xls/Table15-14-15-16-1718.xls (last visited September 11, 2019).
The BEA only reports the general size of
the investment transaction, not the type
of the U.S. business involved, nor
whether the U.S. business is considered
a ‘‘small business’’ by the Small
Business Administration (SBA), which
defines small businesses based on
annual revenue or number of
employees. The smallest foreign
investment transactions that the BEA
reports are those with a dollar value
below $50 million. While not all U.S.
businesses receiving a foreign
investment of less than $50 million are
considered ‘‘small’’ for the purposes of
the RFA, many might be, and the
number of U.S. businesses receiving
foreign investments of less than $50
PO 00000
Frm 00010
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
million can serve as a proxy for the
number of transactions involving small
U.S. businesses that might be subject to
CFIUS’s jurisdiction.
Of the above mentioned 832 U.S.
businesses receiving foreign investment
in 2018, 576 were involved in
transactions valued at less than $50
million. Although this figure is under
inclusive because it does not capture all
transactions that could potentially fall
under the proposed rule, it also is over
inclusive because it is not limited to any
particular type of U.S. business. We
believe the figure of 576 is the best
estimate based on the available data of
the number of small U.S. businesses that
may be impacted by this rule.
According to the SBA, there are 30.2
million small businesses (defined as
‘‘firms employing fewer than 500
employees’’) in the United States.
https://www.sba.gov/sites/default/files/
advocacy/2018-Small-Business-ProfilesUS.pdf. If approximately 600 small U.S.
businesses will be potentially impacted
by this rule, then the rule may
potentially impact less than one percent
of all small U.S. businesses.
Accordingly, the Department of the
Treasury does not believe the rule will
impact a ‘‘substantial number of small
entities.’’
Nonetheless, the proposed rule
includes provisions that would reduce
the costs to all businesses, including
small businesses. For example, the
availability of a shorter declaration for
covered transactions may result in
smaller cost to entities than having to
prepare a lengthier notice. Additionally,
having a fillable form for declarations
may reduce some of the cost for parties.
The Department of the Treasury seeks
information and comment on the types
and number of small entities potentially
impacted by this proposed rule. If
necessary, the Department of the
Treasury will undertake a final
regulatory flexibility analysis in the
final rule.
List of Subjects in 31 CFR Part 800
Foreign investments in the United
States, Investigations, Investments,
Investment companies, National
defense, Reporting and Recordkeeping
requirements.
For the reasons set forth in the
preamble, the Department of the
Treasury proposes to revise part 800 of
title 31 of the Code of Federal
Regulations, to read as follows:
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
800.302 Transactions that are not covered
control transactions.
800.303 Transactions that are covered
investments.
800.304 Transactions that are not covered
investments.
800.305 Incremental acquisitions.
800.306 Lending transactions.
800.307 Specific clarifications for
investment funds.
800.308 Timing rule for a contingent equity
interest.
PART 800—REGULATIONS
PERTAINING TO CERTAIN
INVESTMENTS IN THE UNITED
STATES BY FOREIGN PERSONS
Subpart A—General
Sec.
800.101
800.102
800.103
800.104
Scope.
Risk-based analysis.
Effect on other law.
Applicability rule.
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
Subpart B—Definitions
800.201 Aggregated data.
800.202 Anonymized data.
800.203 Business day.
800.204 Certification.
800.205 Committee; Chairperson of the
Committee; Staff Chairperson.
800.206 Completion date.
800.207 Contingent equity interest.
800.208 Control.
800.209 Conversion.
800.210 Covered control transaction.
800.211 Covered investment.
800.212 Covered investment critical
infrastructure.
800.213 Covered transaction.
800.214 Critical infrastructure.
800.215 Critical technologies.
800.216 Effective date.
800.217 Encrypted data.
800.218 Entity.
800.219 Excepted foreign state.
800.220 Excepted investor.
800.221 Foreign entity.
800.222 Foreign government.
800.223 Foreign government-controlled
transaction.
800.224 Foreign national.
800.225 Foreign person.
800.226 Hold.
800.227 Identifiable data.
800.228 Investment.
800.229 Investment fund.
800.230 Involvement.
800.231 Lead agency.
800.232 Manufacture.
800.233 Material nonpublic technical
information.
800.234 Minimum excepted ownership.
800.235 Own.
800.236 Parent. 800.237 Party to a
transaction.
800.238 Person. 800.239 Personal identifier.
800.240 Section 721.
800.241 Sensitive personal data.
800.242 Service.
800.243 Solely for the purpose of passive
investment.
800.244 Substantial interest.
800.245 Substantive decisionmaking.
800.246 Supply.
800.247 Targets or tailors.
800.248 TID U.S. business.
800.249 Transaction.
800.250 Unaffiliated TID U.S. business.
800.251 United States.
800.252 U.S. business.
800.253 U.S. national.
800.254 Voting interest.
Subpart C—Coverage
800.301 Transactions that are covered
control transactions.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
Subpart D—Declarations
800.401 Mandatory declarations.
800.402 Voluntary declarations.
800.403 Procedures for declarations.
800.404 Contents of declarations.
800.405 Beginning of 30-day assessment
period.
800.406 Rejection, disposition, or
withdrawal of declarations.
800.407 Committee actions.
Subpart E—Notices
800.501 Procedures for notices.
800.502 Contents of voluntary notices.
800.503 Beginning of a 45-day review
period.
800.504 Deferral, rejection, or disposition of
certain voluntary notices.
800.505 Determination of whether to
undertake an investigation.
800.506 Determination not to undertake an
investigation.
800.507 Commencement of investigation.
800.508 Completion or termination of
investigation and report to the President.
800.509 Withdrawal of notices.
Subpart F—Committee Procedures
800.601 General.
800.602 Role of the Secretary of Labor.
800.603 Materiality.
800.604 Tolling of deadlines during lapse
in appropriations.
Subpart G—Finality of Action
800.701 Finality of actions under section
721.
Subpart H—Provision and Handling of
Information
800.801 Obligation of parties to provide
information.
800.802 Confidentiality.
Subpart I—Penalties and Damages
800.901 Penalties and damages.
800.902 Effect of lack of compliance.
Subpart J—Foreign National Security
Investment Review Regimes
800.1001 Determinations.
800.1002 Effect of determinations.
Appendix A to Part 800—Covered
investment critical infrastructure and
functions related to covered investment
critical infrastructure
Authority: 50 U.S.C. 4565; E.O. 11858, as
amended, 73 FR 4677.
Subpart A—General
§ 800.101
Scope.
(a) Section 721 of title VII of the
Defense Production Act of 1950 (50
PO 00000
Frm 00011
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
50183
U.S.C. 4565), as amended, authorizes
the President to suspend or prohibit any
covered transaction, when, in the
President’s judgment, there is credible
evidence that leads the President to
believe that the foreign person engaging
in a covered transaction might take
action that threatens to impair the
national security of the United States,
and when provisions of law other than
section 721 and the International
Emergency Economic Powers Act (50
U.S.C. 1701–1706), do not, in the
judgment of the President, provide
adequate and appropriate authority for
the President to protect the national
security in the matter before the
President. Section 721 also authorizes
the Committee to review covered
transactions and to mitigate any risk to
the national security of the United
States that arises as a result of such
transactions.
(b) This part implements regulations
pertaining to covered transactions as
defined in § 800.213 of this part.
Regulations pertaining to covered real
estate transactions are addressed in part
802 of this title.
§ 800.102
Risk-based analysis.
Any determination of the Committee
with respect to a covered transaction to
suspend, refer to the President, or to
negotiate, enter into or impose, or
enforce any agreement or condition
under section 721 shall be based on a
risk-based analysis, conducted by the
Committee, of the effects on the national
security of the United States of the
covered transaction. Any such riskbased analysis shall include credible
evidence demonstrating the risk and an
assessment of the threat, vulnerabilities,
and consequences to national security
related to the transaction. For purposes
of this part, any such analysis of risk
shall include and be informed by
consideration of the following elements:
(a) The threat, which is a function of
the intent and capability of a foreign
person to take action to impair the
national security of the United States;
(b) The vulnerabilities, which are the
extent to which the nature of the U.S.
business presents susceptibility to
impairment of national security; and
(c) The consequences to national
security, which are the potential effects
on national security that could
reasonably result from the exploitation
of the vulnerabilities by the threat actor.
§ 800.103
Effect on other law.
Nothing in this part shall be
construed as altering or affecting any
other authority, process, regulation,
investigation, enforcement measure, or
review provided by or established under
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
50184
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
any other provision of federal law,
including without limitation the
International Emergency Economic
Powers Act, or any other authority of
the President or the Congress under the
Constitution of the United States.
§ 800.104
Applicability rule.
(a) Except as provided in paragraphs
(b) and (c) of this section and otherwise
in this part, the regulations in this part
apply from [EFFECTIVE DATE OF
FINAL RULE].
(b) For any transaction for which the
following has occurred before
[EFFECTIVE DATE OF FINAL RULE],
the corresponding provisions of the
regulations in this part that were in
effect the day before [EFFECTIVE DATE
OF FINAL RULE] will apply:
(1) The completion date;
(2) The parties to the transaction have
executed a binding written agreement,
or other binding document, establishing
the material terms of the transaction;
(3) A party has made a public offer to
shareholders to buy shares of a U.S.
business; or
(4) A shareholder has solicited
proxies in connection with an election
of the board of directors of a U.S.
business or an owner or holder of a
contingent equity interest has requested
the conversion of the contingent equity
interest.
(c) For any transaction that, between
November 10, 2018 and [EFFECTIVE
DATE], fell within the scope of part 801
of this title, the regulations in part 801
will continue to apply.
Note 1 to § 800.104: See subpart I
(Penalties and Damages) of this part for
specific applicability rules pertaining to that
subpart.
Subpart B—Definitions
§ 800.201
Aggregated data.
The term aggregated data means data
that have been combined or collected
together in summary or other form such
that the data cannot be identified with
any individual.
§ 800.202
Anonymized data.
The term anonymized data means
data from which all personal identifiers
have been completely removed.
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
§ 800.203
Business day.
The term business day means Monday
through Friday, except the legal public
holidays specified in 5 U.S.C. 6103, any
day declared to be a holiday by federal
statute or executive order, or any day
with respect to which the U.S. Office of
Personnel Management has announced
that Federal agencies in the Washington,
DC, area are closed to the public. For
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
purposes of calculating any deadline
imposed by this part triggered by the
submission of a party to a transaction
under § 800.401(e)(2) or § 800.501(i),
any submissions received after 5 p.m.
Eastern Time are deemed to be
submitted on the next business day.
Note 1 to § 800.203: See § 800.604
regarding the tolling of deadlines during a
lapse in appropriations.
§ 800.204
Certification.
Note 1 to § 800.204: A sample certification
may be found at the Committee’s section of
the Department of the Treasury website,
currently available at https://
home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/
international/the-committee-on-foreigninvestment-in-the-united-states-cfius.
Frm 00012
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
The term Committee means the
Committee on Foreign Investment in the
United States. The Chairperson of the
Committee is the Secretary of the
Treasury. The Staff Chairperson of the
Committee is the Department of the
Treasury official so designated by the
Secretary of the Treasury or by the
Secretary’s designee.
§ 800.206
(a) The term certification means a
written statement signed by the chief
executive officer or other duly
authorized designee of a party filing a
notice, declaration, or information,
certifying under the penalties provided
in the False Statements Accountability
Act of 1996, as amended (18 U.S.C.
1001) that the notice, declaration, or
information filed:
(1) Fully complies with the
requirements of section 721, the
regulations in this part, and any
agreement or condition entered into
with the Committee or any member of
the Committee, and
(2) Is accurate and complete in all
material respects, as it relates to:
(i) The transaction, and
(ii) The party providing the
certification, including its parents,
subsidiaries, and any other related
entities described in the notice,
declaration, or information.
(b) For purposes of this section, a duly
authorized designee is:
(1) In the case of a partnership, any
general partner thereof;
(2) In the case of a corporation, any
officer or director thereof;
(3) In the case of any entity lacking
partners, officers, or directors, any
individual within the organization
exercising executive functions similar to
those of a general partner of a
partnership or an officer or director of
a corporation; and
(4) In the case of an individual, such
individual or his or her legal
representative.
(c) In each case described in
paragraphs (b)(1) through (4) of this
section, such designee must possess
actual authority to make the
certification on behalf of the party filing
a notice, declaration, or information.
PO 00000
§ 800.205 Committee; Chairperson of the
Committee; Staff Chairperson.
Completion date.
The term completion date means,
with respect to a transaction, the earliest
date upon which any ownership
interest, including a contingent equity
interest, is conveyed, assigned,
delivered, or otherwise transferred to a
person, or a change in rights that could
result in a covered control transaction or
covered investment occurs.
Note 1 to § 800.206: See § 800.308
regarding the timing rule for a contingent
equity interest.
§ 800.207
Contingent equity interest.
The term contingent equity interest
means a financial instrument that
currently does not constitute an equity
interest but is convertible into, or
provides the right to acquire, an equity
interest upon the occurrence of a
contingency or defined event.
§ 800.208
Control.
(a) The term control means the power,
direct or indirect, whether or not
exercised, through the ownership of a
majority or a dominant minority of the
total outstanding voting interest in an
entity, board representation, proxy
voting, a special share, contractual
arrangements, formal or informal
arrangements to act in concert, or other
means, to determine, direct, or decide
important matters affecting an entity; in
particular, but without limitation, to
determine, direct, take, reach, or cause
decisions regarding the following
matters, or any other similarly
important matters affecting an entity:
(1) The sale, lease, mortgage, pledge,
or other transfer of any of the tangible
or intangible principal assets of the
entity, whether or not in the ordinary
course of business;
(2) The reorganization, merger, or
dissolution of the entity;
(3) The closing, relocation, or
substantial alteration of the production,
operational, or research and
development facilities of the entity;
(4) Major expenditures or
investments, issuances of equity or debt,
or dividend payments by the entity, or
approval of the operating budget of the
entity;
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
(5) The selection of new business
lines or ventures that the entity will
pursue;
(6) The entry into, termination, or
non-fulfillment by the entity of
significant contracts;
(7) The policies or procedures of the
entity governing the treatment of nonpublic technical, financial, or other
proprietary information of the entity;
(8) The appointment or dismissal of
officers or senior managers or in the
case of a partnership, the general
partner;
(9) The appointment or dismissal of
employees with access to critical
technology or other sensitive technology
or classified U.S. Government
information; or
(10) The amendment of the Articles of
Incorporation, constituent agreement, or
other organizational documents of the
entity with respect to the matters
described in paragraphs (a)(1) through
(9) of this section.
(b) In examining questions of control
in situations where more than one
foreign person has an ownership
interest in an entity, consideration will
be given to factors such as whether the
foreign persons are related or have
formal or informal arrangements to act
in concert, whether they are agencies or
instrumentalities of the national or
subnational governments of a single
foreign state, and whether a given
foreign person and another person that
has an ownership interest in the entity
are both controlled by any of the
national or subnational governments of
a single foreign state.
(c) The following minority
shareholder protections shall not in
themselves be deemed to confer control
over an entity:
(1) The power to prevent the sale or
pledge of all or substantially all of the
assets of an entity or a voluntary filing
for bankruptcy or liquidation;
(2) The power to prevent an entity
from entering into contracts with
majority investors or their affiliates;
(3) The power to prevent an entity
from guaranteeing the obligations of
majority investors or their affiliates;
(4) The power to purchase an
additional interest in an entity to
prevent the dilution of an investor’s pro
rata interest in that entity in the event
that the entity issues additional
instruments conveying interests in the
entity;
(5) The power to prevent the change
of existing legal rights or preferences of
the particular class of stock held by
minority investors, as provided in the
relevant corporate documents governing
such shares; and
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
(6) The power to prevent the
amendment of the Articles of
Incorporation, constituent agreement, or
other organizational documents of an
entity with respect to the matters
described in paragraphs (c)(1) through
(5) of this section.
(d) The Committee will consider, on
a case-by-case basis, whether minority
shareholder protections other than those
listed in paragraph (c) of this section do
not confer control over an entity.
(e) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A is a U.S.
business. A U.S. investor owns 50 percent of
the voting interest in Corporation A, and the
remaining voting interest is owned in equal
shares by five unrelated foreign investors.
The foreign investors jointly financed their
investment in Corporation A and vote as a
single block on matters affecting Corporation
A. The foreign investors have an informal
arrangement to act in concert with regard to
Corporation A, and, as a result, the foreign
investors control Corporation A.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as in Example
1 of this section with regard to the
composition of Corporation A’s shareholders.
The foreign investors in Corporation A have
no contractual or other commitments to act
in concert, and have no informal
arrangements to do so. Assuming no other
relevant facts, the foreign investors do not
control Corporation A.
(3) Example 3. Corporation A, a foreign
person, is a private equity fund that routinely
acquires equity interests in companies and
manages them for a period of time.
Corporation B is a U.S. business. In addition
to its acquisition of seven percent of
Corporation B’s voting shares, Corporation A
acquires the right to terminate significant
contracts of Corporation B. Corporation A
controls Corporation B.
(4) Example 4. Corporation A, a foreign
person, acquires a nine percent interest in the
shares of Corporation B, a U.S. business. As
part of the transaction, Corporation A also
acquires certain veto rights that determine
important matters affecting Corporation B,
including the right to veto the dismissal of
senior executives of Corporation B.
Corporation A controls Corporation B.
(5) Example 5. Corporation A, a foreign
person, acquires a thirteen percent interest in
the shares of Corporation B, a U.S. business,
and the right to appoint one member of
Corporation B’s seven-member Board of
Directors. Corporation A receives minority
shareholder protections listed in § 800.208(c)
but receives no other positive or negative
rights with respect to Corporation B.
Assuming no other relevant facts,
Corporation A does not control Corporation
B.
(6) Example 6. Corporation A, a foreign
person, acquires a twenty percent interest in
the shares of Corporation B, a U.S. business.
Corporation A has negotiated an irrevocable
passivity agreement that completely
precludes it from controlling Corporation B.
Corporation A does, however, receive the
right to prevent Corporation B from entering
into contracts with majority investors or their
PO 00000
Frm 00013
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
50185
affiliates and to prevent Corporation B from
guaranteeing the obligations of majority
investors or their affiliates. Assuming no
other relevant facts, Corporation A does not
control Corporation B.
(7) Example 7. Limited Partnership A
comprises two limited partners, each of
which holds 49 percent of the interest in the
partnership, and a general partner, which
holds two percent of the interest. The general
partner has sole authority to determine,
direct, and decide all important matters
affecting the partnership and a fund operated
by the partnership. The general partner alone
controls Limited Partnership A and the fund.
(8) Example 8. Same facts as in Example
7 of this section, except that each of the
limited partners has the authority to veto
major investments proposed by the general
partner and to choose the fund’s
representatives on the boards of the fund’s
portfolio companies. The general partner and
the limited partners each have control over
Limited Partnership A and the fund.
Note 1 to § 800.208: See § 800.302(b)
regarding the Committee’s treatment of
transactions in which a foreign person holds
or acquires ten percent or less of the
outstanding voting interest in a U.S. business
solely for the purpose of passive investment.
See § 800.303 regarding the Committee’s
treatment of transactions that do not result in
control over a U.S. business by a foreign
person, but may be covered investments. See
§ 800.305 regarding the Committee’s
treatment of a subsequent transaction
involving a foreign person that previously
acquired control of the U.S. business.
§ 800.209
Conversion.
The term conversion means the
exercise of a right inherent in the
ownership or holding of a particular
financial instrument to exchange any
such instrument for an equity interest.
§ 800.210
Covered control transaction.
The term covered control transaction
means any transaction that is proposed
or pending after August 23, 1988, by or
with any foreign person that could
result in foreign control of any U.S.
business, including without limitation
such a transaction carried out through a
joint venture.
§ 800.211
Covered investment.
The term covered investment means
an investment, direct or indirect, by a
foreign person other than an excepted
investor in an unaffiliated TID U.S.
business that is proposed or pending
after [EFFECTIVE DATE OF FINAL
RULE], and that:
(a) Is not a covered control
transaction; and
(b) Affords the foreign person:
(1) Access to any material nonpublic
technical information in the possession
of the TID U.S. business;
(2) Membership or observer rights on
the board of directors or equivalent
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
50186
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
governing body of the TID U.S. business
or the right to nominate an individual
to a position on the board of directors
or equivalent governing body of the TID
U.S. business; or
(3) Any involvement, other than
through voting of shares, in substantive
decisionmaking of the TID U.S. business
regarding:
(i) The use, development, acquisition,
safekeeping, or release of sensitive
personal data of U.S. citizens
maintained or collected by the TID U.S.
business;
(ii) The use, development,
acquisition, or release of critical
technologies; or
(iii) The management, operation,
manufacture, or supply of covered
investment critical infrastructure.
(c) Notwithstanding paragraphs (a)
and (b) of this section, no investment
involving an air carrier, as defined in 49
U.S.C. 40102(a)(2), that holds a
certificate issued under 49 U.S.C. 41102
shall be a covered investment.
§ 800.212 Covered investment critical
infrastructure.
The term covered investment critical
infrastructure means, in the context of a
particular covered investment, the
systems and assets, whether physical or
virtual, set forth in Column 1 of
appendix A to part 800.
§ 800.213
Covered transaction.
The term covered transaction means
any of the following:
(a) A covered control transaction;
(b) A covered investment;
(c) A change in the rights that a
foreign person has with respect to a U.S.
business in which the foreign person
has an investment, if that change could
result in a covered control transaction or
a covered investment; or
(d) Any other transaction, transfer,
agreement, or arrangement, the structure
of which is designed or intended to
evade or circumvent the application of
section 721.
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
Note 1 to § 800.213: Any transaction
described in (a) through (d) of this section
that arises pursuant to a bankruptcy
proceeding or other form of default on debt
is a covered transaction. See also § 800.306
for the treatment of certain lending
transactions.
§ 800.214
Critical infrastructure.
The term critical infrastructure
means, in the context of a particular
covered control transaction, systems
and assets, whether physical or virtual,
so vital to the United States that the
incapacity or destruction of such
systems or assets would have a
debilitating impact on national security.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
§ 800.215
Critical technologies.
The term critical technologies means
the following:
(a) Defense articles or defense services
included on the United States
Munitions List (USML) set forth in the
International Traffic in Arms
Regulations (ITAR) (22 CFR parts 120–
130);
(b) Items included on the Commerce
Control List set forth in Supplement No.
1 to part 774 of the Export
Administration Regulations (EAR) (15
CFR parts 730–774), and controlled—
(1) Pursuant to multilateral regimes,
including for reasons relating to
national security, chemical and
biological weapons proliferation,
nuclear nonproliferation, or missile
technology; or
(2) For reasons relating to regional
stability or surreptitious listening;
(c) Specially designed and prepared
nuclear equipment, parts and
components, materials, software, and
technology covered by 10 CFR part 810
(relating to assistance to foreign atomic
energy activities);
(d) Nuclear facilities, equipment, and
material covered by 10 CFR part 110
(relating to export and import of nuclear
equipment and material);
(e) Select agents and toxins covered
by 7 CFR part 331, 9 CFR part 121, or
42 CFR part 73; and
(f) Emerging and foundational
technologies controlled pursuant to
section 1758 of the Export Control
Reform Act of 2018 (50 U.S.C. 4817).
§ 800.216
Effective date.
The term effective date means
[EFFECTIVE DATE OF FINAL RULE].
§ 800.217
Encrypted data.
The term encrypted data means data
to which National Institute of Standards
and Technology (NIST)-allowed
cryptographic techniques, as identified
in the most current NIST special
publication 800–175B, or superseding
publication, have been applied.
§ 800.218
Entity.
The term entity means any branch,
partnership, group or sub-group,
association, estate, trust, corporation or
division of a corporation, or
organization (whether or not organized
under the laws of any State or foreign
state); assets (whether or not organized
as a separate legal entity) operated by
any one of the foregoing as a business
undertaking in a particular location or
for particular products or services; and
any government (including a foreign
national or subnational government, the
U.S. Government, a subnational
government within the United States,
PO 00000
Frm 00014
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
and any of their respective departments,
agencies, or instrumentalities). (See
examples in § 800.301(g)(5) through (14)
and § 800.302(g)(5) through (10).)
§ 800.219
Excepted foreign state.
The term excepted foreign state
means each foreign state from time to
time identified by the Chairperson of
the Committee, with the agreement of
two-thirds of the voting members of the
Committee, and, beginning on [TWO
YEARS AFTER EFFECTIVE DATE OF
FINAL RULE] with respect to which the
Chairperson of the Committee has made
a determination pursuant to
§ 800.1001(a).
Note 1 to § 800.219: The name of each
foreign state identified by the Chairperson of
the Committee as an excepted foreign state
will be published in a notice in the Federal
Register and incorporated into the
Committee’s list of excepted foreign states.
§ 800.220
Excepted investor.
(a) The term excepted investor means
a foreign person who is, as of the
completion date and subject to
paragraphs (c) and (d) of this section:
(1) A foreign national who is a
national of one or more excepted foreign
states and is not also a national of any
foreign state that is not an excepted
foreign state;
(2) A foreign government of an
excepted foreign state; or
(3) A foreign entity that meets each of
the following conditions with respect to
itself and each of its parents (if any):
(i) Such entity is organized under the
laws of an excepted foreign state or in
the United States;
(ii) Such entity has its principal place
of business in an excepted foreign state
or the United States;
(iii) Each member or observer of the
board of directors or similar body of
such entity is a U.S. national or, if a
foreign national, is a national of one or
more excepted foreign states and is not
also a national of any foreign state that
is not an excepted foreign state;
(iv) Any foreign person that
individually holds, or each foreign
person that is part of a group of foreign
persons that, in the aggregate, holds,
five percent or more of the outstanding
voting interest of such entity; holds the
right to five percent or more of the
profits of such entity; holds the right in
the event of dissolution to five percent
or more of the assets of such entity; or
could exercise control over such entity,
is:
(A) A foreign national who is a
national of one or more excepted foreign
states and is not also a national of any
foreign state that is not an excepted
foreign state;
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
(B) A foreign government of an
excepted foreign state; or
(C) A foreign entity that is organized
under the laws of an excepted foreign
state and has its principal place of
business in an excepted foreign state or
in the United States; and
(v) The minimum excepted ownership
of such entity is held, individually or in
the aggregate, by one or more persons
each of whom is:
(A) Not a foreign person;
(B) A foreign national who is a
national of one or more excepted foreign
states and is not also a national of any
foreign state that is not an excepted
foreign state;
(C) A foreign government of an
excepted foreign state; or
(D) A foreign entity that is organized
under the laws of an excepted foreign
state and has its principal place of
business in an excepted foreign state or
in the United States.
(b) When more than one person holds
an ownership interest in an entity, in
determining whether the ownership
interests of such persons should be
aggregated for purposes of paragraph
(a)(3)(iv) of this section, consideration
will be given to factors such as whether
the persons holding the ownership
interests are related or have formal or
informal arrangements to act in concert,
whether they are agencies or
instrumentalities of the national or
subnational governments of a single
foreign state, and whether a given
foreign person and another foreign
person that has an ownership interest in
the entity are both controlled by any of
the national or subnational governments
of a single foreign state.
(c) Notwithstanding paragraph (a) of
this section, a foreign person is not an
excepted investor with respect to a
transaction if:
(1) In the five years prior to the
completion date of the transaction the
foreign person or any of its parents or
subsidiaries:
(i) Has received written notice from
the Committee that it has submitted a
material misstatement or omission in a
notice or declaration or made a false
certification under this part or parts 801
or 802 of this title;
(ii) Has received written notice from
the Committee that it has violated a
material provision of a mitigation
agreement entered into with, material
condition imposed by, or an order
issued by, the Committee or a lead
agency under section 721(l);
(iii) Has been subject to action by the
President under section 721(d);
(iv) Has:
(A) Received a written Finding of
Violation or Penalty Notice imposing a
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
civil monetary penalty from the
Department of the Treasury Office of
Foreign Assets Control (OFAC); or
(B) Entered into a settlement
agreement with OFAC with respect to
apparent violations of U.S. sanctions
laws administered by OFAC, including
without limitation the International
Emergency Economic Powers Act, the
Trading With the Enemy Act, the
Foreign Narcotics Kingpin Designation
Act, each as amended, or of any
executive order, regulation, order,
directive, or license issued pursuant
thereto;
(v) Has received a written notice of
debarment from the Department of State
Directorate of Defense Trade Controls,
as described in 22 CFR parts 127 and
128;
(vi) Has been a respondent or party in
a final order, including a settlement
order, issued by the Department of
Commerce Bureau of Industry and
Security (BIS) regarding violations of
U.S. export control laws administered
by BIS, including without limitation the
Export Control Reform Act of 2018
(Title XVII, Subtitle B of Pub. L. 115–
232, 132 Stat. 2208, 50 U.S.C. 4801, et
seq.), the EAR, or of any executive
order, regulation, order, directive, or
license issued pursuant thereto;
(vii) Has received a final decision
from the Department of Energy National
Nuclear Security Administration
imposing a civil penalty with respect to
a violation of section 57 b. of the Atomic
Energy Act of 1954, as implemented
under 10 CFR part 810; or
(viii) Has been convicted of a crime
under, or has entered into a deferred
prosecution agreement or nonprosecution agreement with the
Department of Justice with respect to a
violation of, any felony crime in any
jurisdiction within the United States; or
(2) The foreign person or any of its
parents or subsidiaries is, on the date on
which the parties to the transaction first
execute a binding written agreement, or
other binding document, establishing
the material terms of the transaction,
listed on either the BIS Unverified List
or Entity List in 15 CFR part 744.
(d) Irrespective of whether the foreign
person satisfies the criteria in
paragraphs (a)(1), (2), or (3)(i) through
(iii) of this section as of the completion
date, if at any time during the three-year
period following the completion date,
the foreign person no longer meets all
the criteria set forth in paragraphs (a)(1),
(2), or (3)(i) through (iii) of this section,
the foreign person is not an excepted
investor with respect to the transaction
from the completion date onward. This
paragraph does not apply when an
excepted investor no longer meets any
PO 00000
Frm 00015
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
50187
of the criteria solely due to a rescission
of a determination under § 800.1001(b)
or if a particular foreign state otherwise
ceases to be an excepted foreign state.
(e) A foreign person may waive its
status as an excepted investor with
respect to a transaction at any time by
submitting a declaration pursuant to
§ 800.403 or filing a notice pursuant to
§ 800.501 regarding the transaction in
which it explicitly waives such status.
In such case, the foreign person will be
deemed not to be an excepted investor
and the provisions of Subpart D or E, as
applicable, will apply.
Note 1 to § 800.220: See § 800.501(c)(2)
regarding an agency notice where a foreign
person is not an excepted investor solely due
to § 800.220(d).
§ 800.221
Foreign entity.
(a) The term foreign entity means any
branch, partnership, group or sub-group,
association, estate, trust, corporation or
division of a corporation, or
organization organized under the laws
of a foreign state if either its principal
place of business is outside the United
States or its equity securities are
primarily traded on one or more foreign
exchanges.
(b) Notwithstanding paragraph (a) of
this section, any branch, partnership,
group or sub-group, association, estate,
trust, corporation or division of a
corporation, or organization that
demonstrates that a majority of the
equity interest in such entity is
ultimately owned by U.S. nationals is
not a foreign entity.
§ 800.222
Foreign government.
The term foreign government means
any government or body exercising
governmental functions, other than the
U.S. Government or a subnational
government of the United States. The
term includes, but is not limited to,
national and subnational governments,
including their respective departments,
agencies, and instrumentalities.
§ 800.223 Foreign government-controlled
transaction.
The term foreign governmentcontrolled transaction means any
covered control transaction that could
result in control of a U.S. business by
a foreign government or a person
controlled by or acting on behalf of a
foreign government.
§ 800.224
Foreign national.
The term foreign national means any
individual other than a U.S. national.
§ 800.225
Foreign person.
(a) The term foreign person means:
(1) Any foreign national, foreign
government, or foreign entity; or
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
50188
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
(2) Any entity over which control is
exercised or exercisable by a foreign
national, foreign government, or foreign
entity.
(b) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A is organized
under the laws of a foreign state and is
engaged in business only outside the United
States. All of its shares are held by
Corporation X, which solely controls
Corporation A. Corporation X is organized in
the United States and is wholly owned and
controlled by U.S. nationals. Assuming no
other relevant facts, Corporation A, although
organized and only operating outside the
United States, is not a foreign person.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as in the first
sentence of Example 1 of this section. The
government of the foreign state under whose
laws Corporation A is organized exercises
control over Corporation A because a law
establishing Corporation A gives the foreign
state the right to appoint Corporation A’s
board members. Corporation A is a foreign
person.
(3) Example 3. Corporation A is organized
in the United States, is engaged in interstate
commerce in the United States, and is
controlled by Corporation X. Corporation X
is organized under the laws of a foreign state,
its principal place of business is located
outside the United States, and 50 percent of
its shares are held by foreign nationals and
50 percent of its shares are held by U.S.
nationals. Both Corporation A and
Corporation X are foreign persons.
Corporation A is also a U.S. business.
(4) Example 4. Corporation A is organized
under the laws of a foreign state and is
owned and controlled by a foreign national.
A branch of Corporation A engages in
interstate commerce in the United States.
Corporation A (including its branch) is a
foreign person. The branch is also a U.S.
business.
(5) Example 5. Corporation A is a
corporation organized under the laws of a
foreign state and its principal place of
business is located outside the United States.
Forty-five percent of the voting interest in
Corporation A is owned in equal shares by
numerous unrelated foreign investors, none
of whom has control. The foreign investors
have no formal or informal arrangement to
act in concert with regard to Corporation A
with any other holder of voting interest in
Corporation A. Corporation A demonstrates
that the remainder of the voting interest in
Corporation A is held by U.S. nationals.
Assuming no other relevant facts,
Corporation A is not a foreign person.
(6) Example 6. Same facts as Example 5 of
this section, except that one of the foreign
investors controls Corporation A. Assuming
no other relevant facts, Corporation A is not
a foreign entity pursuant to § 800.221(b), but
it is a foreign person because it is controlled
by a foreign person.
§ 800.226
Hold.
The terms hold(s) and holding mean
legal or beneficial ownership, whether
direct or indirect, whether through
fiduciaries, agents, or other means.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
§ 800.227
Identifiable data.
The term identifiable data means data
that can be used to distinguish or trace
an individual’s identity, including
without limitation through the use of
any personal identifier. For the
avoidance of doubt, aggregated data or
anonymized data is identifiable data if
any party to the transaction has, or as
a result of the transaction will have, the
ability to disaggregate or de-anonymize
the data, or if the data is otherwise
capable of being used to distinguish or
trace an individual’s identity.
Identifiable data does not include
encrypted data, unless the U.S. business
that maintains or collects the encrypted
data has the means to de-encrypt the
data so as to distinguish or trace an
individual’s identity.
§ 800.228
Investment.
The term investment means the
acquisition of equity interest, including
contingent equity interest.
§ 800.229
Investment fund.
The term investment fund means any
entity that is an ‘‘investment company,’’
as defined in section 3(a) of the
Investment Company Act of 1940 (15
U.S.C. 80a–1 et seq.), or would be an
‘‘investment company’’ but for one or
more of the exemptions provided in
section 3(b) or 3(c) thereunder.
§ 800.230
Involvement.
The term involvement means the right
or ability to participate, whether or not
exercised, including without limitation
by doing any of the following:
(a) Providing input into a final
decision;
(b) Consulting with or providing
advice to a decisionmaker;
(c) Exercising special approval or veto
rights;
(d) Participating on a committee with
decisionmaking authority; or
(e) Advising on the appointment
officers or selecting employees who are
engaged in substantive decisionmaking.
§ 800.231
Lead agency.
The term lead agency means the
Department of the Treasury and any
other agency designated by the
Chairperson of the Committee to have
primary responsibility, on behalf of the
Committee, for the specific activity for
which the Chairperson designates it as
a lead agency, including without
limitation all or a portion of an
assessment, a review, an investigation,
or the negotiation or monitoring of a
mitigation agreement or condition.
§ 800.232
Manufacture.
Solely for the purposes of Column 2
of appendix A to part 800, the term
PO 00000
Frm 00016
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
manufacture means to produce or
reproduce, whether physically or
virtually.
§ 800.233 Material nonpublic technical
information.
(a) The term material nonpublic
technical information means
information that:
(1) Provides knowledge, know-how,
or understanding not available in the
public domain, of the design, location,
or operation of critical infrastructure,
including without limitation
vulnerability information such as that
related to physical security or
cybersecurity; or
(2) Is not available in the public
domain and is necessary to design,
fabricate, develop, test, produce, or
manufacture a critical technology,
including without limitation processes,
techniques, or methods;
(b) The term material nonpublic
technical information does not include
financial information regarding the
performance of an entity.
(c) Example: Corporation A, a foreign
person that is not an excepted investor,
proposes to acquire a four percent, noncontrolling equity interest in
Corporation B. Corporation B is a U.S.
business that services an industrial
control system utilized by an interstate
oil pipeline that has the capacity to
transport 600,000 barrels per day of
crude oil (ICS B). ICS B is covered
investment critical infrastructure as set
forth in Column 1 of appendix A to part
800. The source code for ICS B is not
available in the public domain.
Pursuant to the terms of the investment,
Corporation A will have access to the
source code for ICS B. The proposed
investment therefore affords
Corporation A access to material
nonpublic technical information in the
possession Corporation B regarding the
design and operation of covered
investment critical infrastructure.
§ 800.234
Minimum excepted ownership.
The term minimum excepted
ownership means:
(a) With respect to an entity whose
equity securities are primarily traded on
an exchange in an excepted foreign state
or the United States, a majority of its
voting interest, the right to a majority of
its profits, and the right in the event of
dissolution to a majority of its assets;
and
(b) With respect to an entity whose
equity securities are not primarily
traded on an exchange in an excepted
foreign state or the United States, 90
percent or more of its voting interest,
the right to 90 percent or more of its
profits, and the right in the event of
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
dissolution to 90 percent or more of its
assets.
§ 800.235
Own.
Solely for the purposes of Column 2
of appendix A to part 800, the term own
means to directly possess the applicable
covered investment critical
infrastructure.
§ 800.236
Parent.
(a) The term parent means a person
who or which directly or indirectly:
(1) Holds or will hold at least 50
percent of the outstanding voting
interest in an entity; or
(2) Holds or will hold the right to at
least 50 percent of the profits of an
entity, or has or will have the right in
the event of the dissolution to at least
50 percent of the assets of that entity.
(b) Any entity that meets the
conditions of paragraph (a)(1) or (2) of
this section with respect to another
entity (i.e., the intermediate parent) is
also a parent of any other entity of
which the intermediate parent is a
parent.
(c) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation P holds 50
percent of the voting interest in Corporations
R and S. Corporation R holds 40 percent of
the voting interest in Corporation X;
Corporation S holds 50 percent of the voting
interest in Corporation Y, which in turn
holds 50 percent of the voting interest in
Corporation Z. Corporation P is a parent of
Corporations R, S, Y, and Z, but not of
Corporation X. Corporation S is a parent of
Corporation Y and Z, and Corporation Y is
a parent of Corporation Z.
(2) Example 2. Corporation A holds
warrants which when exercised will entitle
it to vote 50 percent of the outstanding shares
of Corporation B. Corporation A is a parent
of Corporation B.
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
§ 800.237
(a) The term party to a transaction
means:
(1) In the case of an acquisition of an
ownership interest in an entity, the
person acquiring the ownership interest,
the person from which such ownership
interest is acquired, and the entity
whose ownership interest is being
acquired, without regard to any person
providing brokerage or underwriting
services for the transaction;
(2) In the case of a merger, the
surviving entity, and the entity or
entities that are merged into that entity
as a result of the transaction;
(3) In the case of a consolidation, the
entities being consolidated, and the new
consolidated entity;
(4) In the case of a proxy solicitation,
the person soliciting proxies, and the
person who issued the voting interest;
(5) In the case of the acquisition or
conversion of contingent equity
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
§ 800.238
Person.
The term person means any
individual or entity.
§ 800.239
Personal identifier.
The term personal identifier means
name, physical address, email address,
social security number, phone number,
or other information that identifies a
specific individual.
§ 800.240
Party to a transaction.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
interests, the issuer and the person
holding the contingent equity interests;
(6) In the case of a change in rights
that a person has with respect to an
entity in which that person has an
investment, the person whose rights
change as a result of the transaction and
the entity to which those rights apply;
(7) In the case of a transfer, agreement,
arrangement, or any other type of
transaction, the structure of which is
designed or intended to evade or
circumvent the application of section
721, any person that participates in such
transfer, agreement, arrangement, or
other type of transaction;
(8) In the case of any other type of
transaction, any person who is in a role
comparable to that of a person described
in paragraphs (a)(1) through (7) of this
section; and
(9) In all cases, each party that
submitted a declaration or notice to the
Committee regarding a transaction.
(b) For purposes of section 721(l), the
term party to a transaction includes any
affiliate of any party described in
paragraphs (a)(1) through (9) of this
section that the Committee, or a lead
agency acting on behalf of the
Committee, determines is relevant to
mitigating a risk to the national security
of the United States.
Section 721.
The term section 721 means section
721 of title VII of the Defense
Production Act of 1950 (50 U.S.C. 4565),
as amended.
§ 800.241
Sensitive personal data.
(a) The term sensitive personal data
means, except as provided in paragraph
(b) of this section:
(1) Identifiable data that is:
(i) Maintained or collected by a U.S.
business that:
(A) Targets or tailors products or
services to any U.S. executive branch
agency or military department with
intelligence, national security, or
homeland security responsibilities, or to
personnel and contractors thereof;
(B) Has maintained or collected such
data on greater than one million
individuals at any point over the
preceding twelve (12) months; or
(C) Has a demonstrated business
objective to maintain or collect such
PO 00000
Frm 00017
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
50189
data on greater than one million
individuals and such data is an
integrated part of the U.S. business’s
primary products or services; and
(ii) Within any of the following
categories:
(A) Data that could be used to analyze
or determine an individual’s financial
distress or hardship;
(B) The set of data in a consumer
report, as defined pursuant to 15 U.S.C.
1681a, unless such data is obtained from
a consumer reporting agency for one or
more purposes identified in 15 U.S.C.
1681b(a) and such data is not
substantially similar to the full contents
of a consumer file as defined pursuant
to 15 U.S.C. 1681a.;
(C) The set of data in an application
for health insurance, long-term care
insurance, professional liability
insurance, mortgage insurance, or life
insurance;
(D) Data relating to the physical,
mental, or psychological health
condition of an individual;
(E) Non-public electronic
communications, including without
limitation email, messaging, or chat
communications, between or among
users of a U.S. business’s products or
services if a primary purpose of such
product or service is to facilitate thirdparty user communications;
(F) Geolocation data collected using
positioning systems, cell phone towers,
or WiFi access points such as via a
mobile application, vehicle GPS, other
onboard mapping tool, or wearable
electronic device;
(G) Biometric enrollment data
including without limitation facial,
voice, retina/iris, and palm/fingerprint
templates;
(H) Data stored and processed for
generating a state or federal government
identification card;
(I) Data concerning U.S. Government
personnel security clearance status; or
(J) The set of data in an application for
a U.S. Government personnel security
clearance or an application for
employment in a position of public
trust; and
(2) Genetic information, as defined
pursuant to 45 CFR 160.103.
(b) The term sensitive personal data
shall not include, regardless of the
applicability of the criteria described in
paragraph (a) of this section:
(1) Data maintained or collected by a
U.S. business concerning the employees
of that U.S. business, unless the data
pertains to employees of U.S.
Government contractors who hold U.S.
Government personnel security
clearances; or
(2) Data that is a matter of public
record, such as court records or other
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
50190
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
government records that are generally
available to the public.
§ 800.242
Service.
Solely for the purposes of Column 2
of appendix A to part 800, the term
service means to repair, maintain,
refurbish, replace, overhaul, or update.
§ 800.243 Solely for the purpose of
passive investment.
(a) Ownership interests are held or
acquired solely for the purpose of
passive investment if the person holding
or acquiring such interests does not plan
or intend to exercise control and—
(1) Is not afforded any rights that if
exercised would constitute control;
(2) Does not acquire any access,
rights, or involvement specified
§ 800.211(b);
(3) Does not possess or develop any
purpose other than passive investment;
and
(4) Does not take any action
inconsistent with holding or acquiring
such interests solely for the purpose of
passive investment. (See § 800.302(b).)
(b) Example: Corporation A, a foreign
person, acquires a voting interest in
Corporation B, a U.S. business. In
addition to the voting interest,
Corporation A negotiates the right to
appoint a member of Corporation B’s
Board of Directors. The acquisition by
Corporation A of a voting interest in
Corporation B is not solely for the
purpose of passive investment.
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
§ 800.244
Substantial interest.
(a) The term substantial interest
means a voting interest, direct or
indirect, of 25 percent or more by a
foreign person in a U.S. business and a
voting interest, direct or indirect, of 49
percent or more by a foreign government
in a foreign person.
(b) In the case of entity organized as
a limited partnership, a foreign
government will be considered to have
a substantial interest in such
partnership if either:
(1) It holds 49 percent or more of the
voting interest in the general partner; or
(2) It is a limited partner and holds 49
percent or more of the voting interest of
the limited partners.
(c) For purposes of determining the
percentage of voting interest held
indirectly by one entity in another
entity, any voting interest of a parent
will be deemed to be a 100 percent
voting interest in any entity of which it
is a parent.
§ 800.245
Substantive decisionmaking.
(a) The term substantive
decisionmaking means the process
through which decisions regarding
significant matters affecting an entity
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
are undertaken, including without
limitation, as applicable:
(1) Pricing, sales, and specific
contracts, including without limitation
the license, sale, or transfer of sensitive
personal data to any third party,
including without limitation pursuant
to a customer, vendor, or joint venture
agreement;
(2) Supply arrangements;
(3) Corporate strategy and business
development;
(4) Research and development,
including without limitation location
and budget allocation;
(5) Manufacturing locations;
(6) Access to critical technologies,
covered investment critical
infrastructure, material nonpublic
technical information, or sensitive
personal data, including without
limitation pursuant to a customer,
vendor, or joint venture agreement;
(7) Physical and cyber security
protocols, including without limitation
the storage and protection of critical
technologies, covered investment
critical infrastructure, or sensitive
personal data;
(8) Practices, policies, and procedures
governing the collection, use, or storage
of sensitive personal data, including
without limitation:
(i) The establishment or maintenance
of, or changes to, the architecture of
information technology systems and
networks used in collecting or
maintaining sensitive personal data; or
(ii) Privacy policies and agreements
for individuals from whom sensitive
personal data is collected setting forth
parameters regarding whether and how
sensitive personal data may be
collected, maintained, accessed, or
disseminated; or
(9) Strategic partnerships.
(b) The term substantive
decisionmaking does not include
strictly administrative decisions.
(c) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, a foreign
person that is not an excepted investor,
proposes to acquire a four percent, noncontrolling equity interest in Corporation B.
Corporation B is an unaffiliated TID U.S.
business that operates a container terminal at
a strategic seaport within the National Port
Readiness Network (Terminal B). Pursuant to
the terms of the investment, Corporation A
will have approval rights over which
customers may utilize Terminal B. The
proposed investment therefore affords
Corporation A involvement in substantive
decisionmaking of Corporation B regarding
the management, operation, manufacture, or
supply of covered investment critical
infrastructure.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as Example 1 of
this section, except that instead of customer
approval rights, Corporation A has the right
PO 00000
Frm 00018
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
to decide whether to claim certain tax credits
with respect to Terminal B on its own
income tax filing, which prevents
Corporation B from claiming such credits.
Assuming no other relevant facts, the
proposed investment does not afford
Corporation A involvement in substantive
decisionmaking of Corporation B regarding
the management, operation, manufacture, or
supply of covered investment critical
infrastructure.
§ 800.246
Supply.
Solely for the purposes of Column 2
of appendix A to part 800, the term
supply means to provide third-party
physical or cyber security.
§ 800.247
Targets or tailors.
(a) The term targets or tailors means
customizing products or services for use
by a person or group of persons or
actively marketing to or soliciting a
person or group of persons.
(b) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, a U.S.
business, operates facilities throughout the
United States that offer healthcare-related
products and services. Some of Corporation
A’s facilities are located within metropolitan
areas that also include U.S. military facilities.
Absent additional relevant facts, Corporation
A does not target or tailor its products or
services for purposes of § 800.241(a)(1)(i)(A).
(2) Example 2. Same facts as Example 2 of
this section, except that Corporation A
operates a facility on the premises of a U.S.
military facility. Corporation A targets or
tailors its products or services for purposes
of § 800.241(a)(1)(i)(A).
(3) Example 3. Corporation A, a U.S.
business, offers a discount to all customers
that are employed in the public sector
broadly, including active duty U.S. military
personnel. Absent additional relevant facts,
Corporation A does not target or tailor its
products or services for purposes of
§ 800.241(a)(1)(i)(A).
(4) Example 4. Same facts as Example 3 of
this section, except that Corporation A offers
a discount solely to uniformed U.S. military
personnel or distributes marketing materials
that promote the particular usefulness of
Corporation A’s products to military
personnel. Corporation A targets or tailors its
products or services for purposes of
§ 800.241(a)(1)(i)(A).
§ 800.248
TID U.S. business.
The term TID U.S. business means
any U.S. business that:
(a) Produces, designs, tests,
manufactures, fabricates, or develops
one or more critical technologies;
(b) Performs the functions as set forth
in Column 2 of appendix A to part 800
with respect to covered investment
critical infrastructure; or
(c) Maintains or collects, directly or
indirectly, sensitive personal data of
U.S. citizens.
(d) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, a U.S.
business, operates a munitions plant in the
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
United States that produces a variety of
military grade explosives. Some of the
explosives manufactured by Corporation A
are subject to export controls because they
are listed on the USML. Corporation A
manufactures critical technologies and is
therefore a TID U.S. business.
(2) Example 2. Facility A is a crude oil
storage facility with the capacity to hold 50
million barrels of crude oil. Corporation A is
a U.S. business that operates Facility A.
Corporation B is a U.S. business that
provides third-party physical security to
Facility A by guarding the gate to Facility A
and patrolling the fence surrounding Facility
A. Corporation C produces the fencing used
by Facility A. Corporation D produces the
commercially available off-the-shelf cyber
security software utilized in Facility A.
Corporation E provides third-party cyber
security to Facility by running Facility A’s
cyber security defenses. Facility A is covered
investment critical infrastructure as set forth
in Column 1 of appendix A to part 800.
Corporation A, Corporation B, and
Corporation E each perform one of the
functions as set forth in Column 2 of
appendix A to part 800 with respect to
Facility A and each is therefore a TID U.S.
business. Assuming no other relevant facts,
neither Corporation C nor Corporation D
perform one of the functions as set forth in
Column 2 of appendix A to part 800 with
respect to Facility A and neither is therefore
a TID U.S. business.
(3) Example 3. Pipeline A is an interstate
natural gas pipeline with an outside diameter
of 36 inches. Corporation A is a U.S. business
that owns Pipeline A. Corporation B is a U.S.
business that manufactures the pipe
segments with an outside diameter of 36
inches that are used in Pipeline A. Pipeline
A is covered investment critical
infrastructure as set forth in Column 1 of
appendix A to part 800. Corporation A
performs one of the functions as set forth in
Column 2 of appendix A to part 800 with
respect to Pipeline A and is therefore a TID
U.S. business. Assuming no other relevant
facts, Corporation B does not perform one of
the functions as set forth in Column 2 of
appendix A to part 800 with respect to
Pipeline A and is therefore not a TID U.S.
business.
(4) Example 4. IXP A is an internet
exchange point that supports public peering.
Corporation A is a U.S. business that operates
IXP A. Corporation B is a U.S. business that
maintains the physical premises of IXP A.
IXP A is covered investment critical
infrastructure as set forth in Column 1 of
appendix A to part 800. Corporation A
performs one of the functions as set forth in
Column 2 of appendix A to part 800 with
respect to IXP A and is therefore a TID U.S.
business. Assuming no other relevant facts,
Corporation B does not perform one of the
functions as set forth in Column 2 of
appendix A to part 800 with respect to IXP
A and is therefore not a TID U.S. business.
(5) Example 5. SCADA System A is a
supervisory control and data acquisition
system utilized by a public water system, as
defined in section 1401(4) of the Safe
Drinking Water Act (42 U.S.C. 300f(4)(A)), as
amended, that regularly serves 15,000
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
individuals. Corporation A is a U.S. business
that produces SCADA System A by building
the hardware and integrating all the software.
Corporation B is a U.S. business that
produces commercially available off-the-shelf
software that is sold to Corporation A and
used as a component in SCADA System A.
SCADA System A is covered investment
critical infrastructure as set forth in Column
1 of appendix A to part 800. Corporation A,
as the manufacturer of SCADA System A,
performs one of the functions as set forth in
Column 2 of appendix A to part 800 with
respect to SCADA System A and is therefore
a TID U.S. business. Assuming no other
relevant facts, Corporation B does not
perform one of the functions as set forth in
Column 2 of appendix A to part 800 with
respect to SCADA System A and is therefore
not a TID U.S. business.
(6) Example 6. Same facts as Example 5 of
this section. Corporation B later releases a
patch that updates the commercially
available off-the-shelf software that is a
component of SCADA System A. As the
software is only a component of SCADA
System A, the software itself is not covered
investment critical infrastructure as set forth
in Column 1 of appendix A to part 800.
Assuming no other relevant facts,
Corporation B does not perform one of the
functions as set forth in Column 2 of
appendix A to part 800 with respect to
SCADA System A and is therefore not a TID
U.S. business.
(7) Example 7. Alloy A is a steel alloy
containing two percent manganese.
Corporation A is a U.S. business that
manufactures Alloy A in Facility A by
melting the constituent metals. Facility A is
in the United States. Corporation B is a U.S.
business that purchases Alloy A from
Corporation A and resells it to a prime
contractor of the Department of Defense.
Facility A is covered investment critical
infrastructure as set forth in Column 1 of
appendix A to part 800. Corporation A
performs one of the functions as set forth in
Column 2 of appendix A to part 800 with
respect to Alloy A and is therefore a TID U.S.
business. Assuming no other relevant facts,
Corporation B does not perform one of the
functions as set forth in Column 2 of
appendix A to part 800 with respect to Alloy
A and is therefore not a TID U.S. business.
(8) Example 8. Corporation A, a U.S.
business, is a credit reporting agency and
maintains consumer reports on greater than
one million individuals. Corporation A
maintains sensitive personal data and is
therefore a TID U.S. business.
(9) Example 9. Same facts as in Example
8 of this section, except that Corporation A
maintains the sensitive personal data through
its subsidiary, Corporation X. Corporation A
is a TID U.S. business because it indirectly
maintains sensitive personal data.
Corporation X is also a TID U.S. business
because it directly maintains sensitive
personal data.
§ 800.249
Transaction.
The term transaction means any of
the following, whether proposed or
completed:
PO 00000
Frm 00019
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
50191
(a) A merger, acquisition, or takeover,
including without limitation:
(1) The acquisition of an ownership
interest in an entity;
(2) The acquisition of proxies from
holders of a voting interest in an entity;
(3) A merger or consolidation;
(4) The formation of a joint venture;
or
(5) A long-term lease or concession
arrangement under which a lessee (or
equivalent) makes substantially all
business decisions concerning the
operation of a leased entity (or
equivalent), as if it were the owner;
(b) An investment; or
(c) The conversion of a contingent
equity interest.
(d) Example. Corporation A, a foreign
person, signs a concession agreement to
operate the toll road business of
Corporation B, a U.S. business, for 99
years. Corporation B, however, is
required under the agreement to
perform safety and security functions
with respect to the business and to
monitor compliance by Corporation A
with the operating requirements of the
agreement on an ongoing basis.
Corporation B may terminate the
agreement or impose other penalties for
breach of these operating requirements.
Assuming no other relevant facts, this is
not a transaction.
Note 1 to § 800.249: See § 800.308
regarding factors the Committee will consider
in determining whether to include the access,
rights, or involvement to be acquired by a
foreign person upon the conversion of
contingent equity interests as part of the
Committee’s analysis of whether a
transaction that involves such interests is a
covered transaction.
§ 800.250
Unaffiliated TID U.S. business.
The term unaffiliated TID U.S.
business means, with respect to a
foreign person, a TID U.S. business in
which that foreign person does not
directly hold more than 50 percent of
the outstanding voting interest or have
the right to appoint more than half of
the members of the board of directors or
equivalent governing body.
§ 800.251
United States.
The term United States or U.S. means
the United States of America, the States
of the United States, the District of
Columbia, and any commonwealth,
territory, dependency, or possession of
the United States, or any subdivision of
the foregoing, and includes the Outer
Continental Shelf, as defined in the
Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act, as
amended (43 U.S.C. 1331(a)). For
purposes of these regulations and their
examples, an entity organized under the
laws of the United States of America,
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
50192
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
one of the States, the District of
Columbia, or a commonwealth,
territory, dependency, or possession of
the United States is an entity organized
‘‘in the United States.’’
§ 800.252
U.S. business.
(a) The term U.S. business means any
entity, irrespective of the nationality of
the persons that control it, engaged in
interstate commerce in the United
States.
(b) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A is organized
under the laws of a foreign state and is
wholly owned and controlled by a foreign
national. It engages in interstate commerce in
the United States through a branch or
subsidiary. Its branch or subsidiary is a U.S.
business. Corporation A and its branch or
subsidiary is each also a foreign person
should any of them engage in a transaction
involving a U.S. business.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as in the first
sentence of Example 1 of this section.
Corporation A, however, does not have a
branch office, subsidiary, or fixed place of
business in the United States. It exports and
licenses technology to an unrelated company
in the United States. Assuming no other
relevant facts, Corporation A is not a U.S.
business.
(3) Example 3. Corporation A, a company
organized under the laws of a foreign state,
is wholly owned and controlled by
Corporation X. Corporation X is organized in
the United States and is wholly owned and
controlled by U.S. nationals. Corporation A
does not have a branch office, subsidiary, or
fixed place of business in the United States.
It exports goods to Corporation X and to
unrelated companies in the United States.
Assuming no other relevant facts,
Corporation A is not a U.S. business.
§ 800.253
U.S. national.
The term U.S. national means an
individual who is a U.S. citizen or an
individual who, although not a U.S.
citizen, owes permanent allegiance to
the United States.
§ 800.254
Voting interest.
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
The term voting interest means any
interest in an entity that entitles the
owner or holder of that interest to vote
for the election of directors of the entity
(or, with respect to unincorporated
entities, individuals exercising similar
functions) or to vote on other matters
affecting the entity.
Subpart C—Coverage
§ 800.301 Transactions that are covered
control transactions.
Transactions that are covered control
transactions include, without limitation:
(a) A transaction which, irrespective
of the actual arrangements for control
provided for in the terms of the
transaction, results or could result in
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
control of a U.S. business by a foreign
person. (See the examples in
§ 800.301(g)(1),(2), and (3).)
(b) A transaction in which a foreign
person conveys its control of a U.S.
business to another foreign person. (See
the example in § 800.301(g)(4).)
(c) A transaction that results or could
result in control by a foreign person of
any part of an entity or of assets, if such
part of an entity or assets constitutes a
U.S. business. (See § 800.302(c) and the
examples in § 800.301(g)(5) through
(14).)
(d) A joint venture in which the
parties enter into a contractual or other
similar arrangement, including an
agreement on the establishment of a
new entity, but only if one or more of
the parties contributes a U.S. business
and a foreign person could control that
U.S. business by means of the joint
venture. (See the examples in
§ 800.301(g)(15) through (17).)
(e) A change in the rights that a
foreign person has with respect to a U.S.
business in which the foreign person
has an investment, if that change could
result in foreign control of the U.S.
business. (See the example in
§ 800.301(g)(18).)
(f) A transaction the structure of
which is designed to evade or
circumvent the application of section
721. (See the example in
§ 800.301(g)(19).)
(g) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, a foreign
person, proposes to purchase all of the shares
of Corporation X, which is a U.S. business.
As the sole owner, Corporation A will have
the right to elect directors and appoint other
primary officers of Corporation X, and those
directors will have the right to make
decisions about the closing and relocation of
particular production facilities and the
termination of significant contracts. The
directors also will have the right to propose
to Corporation A, the sole shareholder, the
dissolution of Corporation X and the sale of
its principal assets. The proposed transaction
is a covered control transaction.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as in Example
1 of this section, except that Corporation A
plans to retain the existing directors of
Corporation X, all of whom are U.S.
nationals. Although Corporation A may
choose not to exercise its power to elect new
directors for Corporation X, Corporation A
nevertheless will have that exercisable
power. The proposed transaction is a covered
control transaction.
(3) Example 3. Corporation A, a foreign
person, proposes to purchase 50 percent of
the shares in Corporation X, a U.S. business,
from Corporation B, also a U.S. business.
Corporation B would retain the other 50
percent of the shares in Corporation X, and
Corporation A and Corporation B would
contractually agree that Corporation A would
not exercise its voting and other rights for ten
PO 00000
Frm 00020
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
years. The proposed transaction is a covered
control transaction.
(4) Example 4. Corporation X is a U.S.
business, but is wholly owned and controlled
by Corporation Y, a foreign person.
Corporation Z, also a foreign person, but not
related to Corporation Y, seeks to acquire
Corporation X from Corporation Y. The
proposed transaction is a covered control
transaction because it could result in control
of Corporation X, a U.S. business, by another
foreign person, Corporation Z.
(5) Example 5. Corporation X, a foreign
person, has a branch office located in the
United States. Corporation A, a foreign
person, proposes to buy that branch office.
The proposed transaction is a covered control
transaction.
(6) Example 6. Corporation A, a foreign
person, buys a branch office located entirely
outside the United States of Corporation Y,
which is incorporated in the United States.
Assuming no other relevant facts, the branch
office of Corporation Y is not a U.S. business,
and the transaction is not a covered control
transaction.
(7) Example 7. Corporation A, a foreign
person, makes a start-up, or ‘‘greenfield,’’
investment in the United States. That
investment involves activities such as the
foreign person separately arranging for the
financing of and the construction of a plant
to make a new product, buying supplies and
inputs, hiring personnel, and purchasing the
necessary technology. The investment
involves incorporating a newly formed
subsidiary of the foreign person. Assuming
no other relevant facts, Corporation A will
not have acquired a U.S. business, and its
greenfield investment is not a covered
control transaction. However, this transaction
may be subject to the provisions of part 802
of this title, which addresses certain
transactions concerning real estate.
(8) Example 8. Corporation A, a foreign
person, intends to make an early-stage
investment in a start-up company in the
United States. Prior to the investment by the
foreign person, the start-up has incorporated,
established a domain name, hired personnel,
developed business plans, sought financing,
rented office space, and engaged in other
activities that constitute interstate commerce
in the United States, without the
involvement of the foreign person. As a result
of the investment, Corporation A could
control the U.S. business. Under these facts,
Corporation A is acquiring a U.S. business
and the proposed transaction is a covered
control transaction.
(9) Example 9. Corporation A, a foreign
person, purchases substantially all of the
assets of Corporation B. Corporation B, which
is incorporated in the United States, was in
the business of producing industrial
equipment, but stopped producing and
selling such equipment one week before
Corporation A purchased substantially all of
its assets. At the time of the transaction,
Corporation B continued to have employees
on its payroll, maintained know-how in
producing the industrial equipment it
previously produced, and maintained
relationships with its prior customers, all of
which were transferred to Corporation A. The
acquisition of substantially all of the assets
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
of Corporation B by Corporation A is a
covered control transaction.
(10) Example 10. Corporation X, a foreign
person, seeks to acquire from Corporation A,
a U.S. business, an empty warehouse facility
located in the United States. The acquisition
would be limited to the physical facility, and
would not include customer lists, intellectual
property, or other proprietary information, or
other intangible assets or the transfer of
personnel. Assuming no other relevant facts,
the facility is not an entity and therefore not
a U.S. business, and the proposed acquisition
of the facility is not a covered control
transaction. However, this transaction may be
subject to the provisions of part 802 of this
title, which addresses certain transactions
concerning real estate.
(11) Example 11. Same facts as Example 6
of this section, except that, in addition to the
proposed acquisition of Corporation A’s
warehouse facility, Corporation X would
acquire the personnel, customer list,
equipment, and inventory management
software used to operate the facility. Under
these facts, Corporation X is acquiring a U.S.
business, and the proposed acquisition is a
covered control transaction.
(12) Example 12. Corporation A, a foreign
person, seeks to acquire from Corporation X,
a U.S. business, certain tangible and
intangible assets that Corporation X operates
as a business in the United States.
Corporation A intends to use the assets to
establish a business undertaking in a foreign
country. Under these facts, Corporation X is
acquiring a U.S. business, and the proposed
acquisition is a covered control transaction.
(13) Example 13. Corporation A, a foreign
person, seeks to acquire from Corporation X,
a U.S. business, proprietary software
developed by Corporation X. The acquisition
would be limited to the software and would
not include customer lists, marketing
material, or other proprietary information;
any other tangible or intangible assets; or the
transfer of personnel. Assuming no other
relevant facts, the software does not
constitute an entity and therefore not a U.S.
business, and the proposed acquisition of the
software is not a covered control transaction.
(14) Example 14. Same facts as Example 9
of this section, except that, in addition to the
proposed acquisition of Corporation X’s
proprietary software, Corporation A would
acquire Corporation X’s customer lists,
advertising and promotional material,
branding, trademarks, domain names, and
internet presence. Under these facts,
Corporation A is acquiring a U.S. business,
and the proposed acquisition is a covered
control transaction.
(15) Example 15. Corporation A, a foreign
person, and Corporation X, a U.S. business,
form a separate corporation, JV Corporation,
to which Corporation A contributes only cash
and Corporation X contributes a U.S.
business. Each owns 50 percent of the shares
of JV Corporation and, under the Articles of
Incorporation of JV Corporation, both
Corporation A and Corporation X have veto
power over all of the matters affecting JV
Corporation identified under § 800.208,
giving them both control over JV Corporation.
The place of incorporation of JV Corporation
is not relevant to the determination of
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
whether the transaction is a covered control
transaction. The formation of JV Corporation
is a covered control transaction.
(16) Example 16. Corporation A, a foreign
person, and Corporation X, a U.S. business,
form a separate corporation, JV Corporation,
to which Corporation A contributes funding
and managerial and technical personnel,
while Corporation X contributes certain land
and equipment that do not in this example
constitute a U.S. business. Corporations A
and X each have a 50 percent interest in the
joint venture. Assuming no other relevant
facts, the formation of JV Corporation is not
a covered control transaction. However, this
transaction may be subject to the provisions
of part 802 of this title, which addresses
certain transactions concerning real estate.
(17) Example 17. Same facts as Example 2
of this section, except that, in addition to
contributing certain land and equipment,
Corporation X also contributes intellectual
property, other proprietary information, and
other intangible assets, that together with the
land and equipment constitute a U.S.
business, to JV Corporation. Under these
facts, Corporation X has contributed a U.S.
business, and the formation of JV Corporation
is a covered control transaction.
(18) Example 18. Corporation A, a foreign
person, holds a 10 percent ownership interest
in Corporation X, a U.S. business.
Corporation X subsequently provides
Corporation A the right to appoint the Chief
Executive Officer and the Chief Technical
Officer of Corporation X. Corporation A does
not acquire any additional ownership interest
in Corporation X. The change in rights is a
covered control transaction.
(19) Example 19. Corporation A is
organized under the laws of a foreign state
and is wholly owned and controlled by a
foreign national. With a view towards
circumventing section 721, Corporation A
transfers money to a U.S. citizen, who,
pursuant to informal arrangements with
Corporation A and on its behalf, purchases
all the shares in Corporation X, a U.S.
business. The transaction is a covered control
transaction.
§ 800.302 Transactions that are not
covered control transactions.
Transactions that are not covered
control transactions include, without
limitation:
(a) A stock split or pro rata stock
dividend that does not involve a change
in control. (See the example in
§ 800.302(g)(1).)
(b) A transaction that results in a
foreign person holding ten percent or
less of the outstanding voting interest in
a U.S. business (regardless of the dollar
value of the interest so acquired), but
only if the transaction is solely for the
purpose of passive investment. (See
§ 800.243 and the examples in
§ 800.302(g)(2) through (4).)
(c) An acquisition of any part of an
entity or of assets, if such part of an
entity or assets do not constitute a U.S.
business. (See § 800.301(c) and the
examples in § 800.302(g)(5) through
(10).)
PO 00000
Frm 00021
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
50193
(d) An acquisition of securities by a
person acting as a securities
underwriter, in the ordinary course of
business and in the process of
underwriting.
(e) An acquisition pursuant to a
condition in a contract of insurance
relating to fidelity, surety, or casualty
obligations if the contract was made by
an insurer in the ordinary course of
business.
(f) A change in the rights that a
foreign person has with respect to a U.S.
business in which that foreign person
has an investment, if that change could
not result in foreign control of the U.S.
business. (See the example in
§ 800.302(g)(11).)
(g) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, a foreign
person, holds 10,000 shares of Corporation B,
a U.S. business, constituting ten percent of
the stock of Corporation B. Corporation B
pays a 2-for-1 stock dividend. As a result of
this stock split, Corporation A holds 20,000
shares of Corporation B, still constituting ten
percent of the stock of Corporation B.
Assuming no other relevant facts, the
acquisition of additional shares is not a
covered control transaction.
(2) Example 2. In an open market purchase
solely for the purpose of passive investment,
Corporation A, a foreign person, acquires
seven percent of the voting securities of
Corporation X, which is a U.S. business.
Assuming no other relevant facts, the
acquisition of the securities is not a covered
control transaction.
(3) Example 3. Corporation A, a foreign
person, acquires nine percent of the voting
shares of Corporation X, a U.S. business.
Corporation A also negotiates contractual
rights that give it the power to control
important matters of Corporation X. The
acquisition by Corporation A of the voting
shares of Corporation X is not solely for the
purpose of passive investment and is a
covered control transaction.
(4) Example 4. Corporation A, a foreign
person, acquires five percent of the voting
shares in Corporation B, a U.S. business. In
addition to the securities, Corporation A
obtains the right to appoint one out of eleven
seats on Corporation B’s Board of Directors.
The acquisition by Corporation A of
Corporation B’s securities is not solely for the
purpose of passive investment. Whether the
transaction is a covered control transaction
would depend on whether Corporation A
obtains control of Corporation B as a result
of the transaction. See § 800.303 for
transactions that are covered investments.
(5) Example 5. Corporation A, a foreign
person, acquires, from separate U.S.
nationals: products held in inventory; land,
and; machinery for export. Assuming no
other relevant facts, Corporation A has not
acquired a U.S. business, and this acquisition
is not a covered control transaction.
(6) Example 6. Corporation X, a U.S.
business, produces armored personnel
carriers in the United States. Corporation A,
a foreign person, seeks to acquire the annual
production of those carriers from Corporation
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
50194
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
X under a long-term contract. Assuming no
other relevant facts, this transaction is not a
covered control transaction.
(7) Example 7. Same facts as Example 2 of
this section, except that Corporation X, a U.S.
business, has developed important
technology in connection with the
production of armored personnel carriers.
Corporation A seeks to negotiate an
agreement under which it would be licensed
to manufacture using that technology.
Assuming no other relevant facts, neither the
proposed acquisition of technology pursuant
to that license agreement, nor the actual
acquisition, is a covered control transaction.
(8) Example 8. Same facts as Example 2 of
this section, except that Corporation A enters
into a contractual arrangement to acquire the
entire armored personnel carrier business
operations of Corporation X, including
production facilities, customer lists,
technology, and staff, which together
constitute a U.S. business. This transaction is
a covered control transaction.
(9) Example 9. Same facts as Example 2 of
this section, except that Corporation X
suspended all activities of its armored
personnel carrier business a year ago and
currently is in bankruptcy proceedings.
Existing equipment provided by Corporation
X is being serviced by another company,
which purchased the service contracts from
Corporation X. The business’s production
facilities are idle but still in working
condition, some of its key former employees
have agreed to return if the business is
resuscitated, and its technology and customer
and vendor lists are still current. Corporation
X’s personnel carrier business constitutes a
U.S. business, and its purchase by
Corporation A is a covered control
transaction.
(10) Example 10. Same facts as Example 2
of this section, except that Corporation A and
Corporation X establish a joint venture that
will be controlled by Corporation A to
manufacture armored personnel carriers
outside the United States, and Corporation X
contributes assets constituting a U.S.
business, including intellectual property and
other intangible assets required to
manufacture the armored personnel carriers,
to the joint venture. Corporation X has
contributed a U.S. business to the joint
venture, and the establishment of the joint
venture is a covered control transaction.
(11) Example 11. Corporation A, a foreign
person, holds a 10 percent ownership interest
in Corporation X, a U.S. business.
Corporation A and Corporation X enter into
a contractual arrangement pursuant to which
Corporation A gains the right to purchase an
additional interest in Corporation X to
prevent the dilution of Corporation A’s pro
rata interest in Corporation X in the event
that Corporation X issues additional
instruments conveying interests in
Corporation X. Corporation A does not
acquire any additional rights or ownership
interest in Corporation X pursuant to the
contractual arrangement. Assuming no other
relevant facts, the transaction is not a covered
control transaction.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
§ 800.303 Transactions that are covered
investments.
Transactions that are covered
investments include, without limitation:
(a) A transaction that meets the
requirements of § 800.211 irrespective of
the percentage of voting interest
acquired. (See the examples in
§ 800.303(f)(1) through (3).)
(b) A transaction that meets the
requirements of § 800.211, irrespective
of the fact that the Committee
concluded all action under section 721
for a previous covered investment by
the same foreign person in the same TID
U.S. business, where such transaction
involves the acquisition of access,
rights, or involvement specified in
§ 800.211 in addition to those notified to
the Committee in the transaction for
which the Committee previously
concluded action. (See the example in
§ 800.303(f)(4).)
(c) A transaction that meets the
requirements of § 800.211, irrespective
of the fact that the critical technology
produced, designed, tested,
manufactured, fabricated, or developed
by the TID U.S. business became
controlled pursuant to section 1758 of
the Export Control Reform Act of 2018
after the effective date, unless any of the
criteria set forth in § 800.104(b) are
satisfied with respect to the transaction
prior to the critical technology
becoming controlled. (See the example
in § 800.303(f)(5).)
(d) A change in the rights that a
foreign person has with respect to a U.S.
business in which the foreign person
has an investment, if that change could
result in a covered investment. (See the
example in § 800.303(f)(6).)
(e) A transaction the structure of
which is designed to evade or
circumvent the application of section
721. (See the example in
§ 800.303(f)(7).)
(f) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, a foreign
person who is not an excepted investor,
proposes to acquire a four percent, noncontrolling equity interest in Corporation B.
Corporation B is a U.S. business that
manufactures a critical technology.
Corporation B is therefore a TID U.S.
business. Pursuant to the terms of the
investment, a designee of Corporation A will
have the right to observe the meetings of the
board of directors of Corporation B. The
proposed transaction is a covered
investment.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as Example 1 of
this section, except that, pursuant to the
terms of the investment, instead of observer
rights, Corporation A has consultation rights
with respect to Corporation B’s licensing of
a critical technology to third parties.
Corporation A is therefore involved in
substantive decisionmaking with respect to
PO 00000
Frm 00022
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
Corporation B and the proposed transaction
is a covered investment.
(3) Example 3. Corporation A is a foreign
person that is an excepted investor.
Corporation B, a foreign person that is not an
excepted investor, owns a three percent, noncontrolling equity interest in Corporation A.
Corporation A proposes to acquire a four
percent, non-controlling equity interest in
Corporation C, an unaffiliated TID U.S.
business. Pursuant to the terms of the
investment in Corporation C and Corporation
A’s governance documents, Corporation A
and Corporation B will each have access to
material nonpublic technical information in
Corporation C’s possession. The transaction
is a covered investment because Corporation
B is making an investment that will result in
access to material nonpublic technical
information pursuant to § 800.211(b).
(4) Example 4. The Committee concludes
all action under section 721 with respect to
a covered investment by Corporation A, a
foreign person who is not an excepted
investor, in which Corporation A acquires a
four percent, non-controlling equity interest
with access to material non-public
information in Corporation B, an unaffiliated
TID U.S. business. One year later,
Corporation A proposes to acquire an
additional five percent equity interest in
Corporation B, resulting in Corporation A
holding a nine percent, non-controlling
equity interest in Corporation B. Pursuant to
the terms of the additional investment,
Corporation A will receive the right to
appoint a member to the board of directors
of Corporation B. The proposed transaction is
a covered investment because the transaction
involves both an acquisition of an equity
interest in an unaffiliated TID U.S. business
and a new right under § 800.211.
(5) Example 5. Corporation A, a foreign
person who is not an excepted investor, has
executed a binding written agreement
establishing the material terms of a proposed
non-controlling investment in Corporation B,
an unaffiliated TID U.S. business. The
proposed investment will afford Corporation
A access to material nonpublic technical
information in the possession of Corporation
B. The only controlled technology produced,
designed, tested, manufactured, fabricated, or
developed by Corporation B became
controlled pursuant to section 1758 of the
Export Control Reform Act of 2018 after the
effective date but prior to the date upon
which the binding written agreement
establishing the material terms of the
investment was executed. The proposed
transaction is a covered investment.
(6) Example 6. Corporation A, a foreign
person who is not an excepted investor,
holds a four percent non-controlling
ownership interest in Corporation X, an
unaffiliated TID U.S. business, but
Corporation A was not afforded any of the
access, rights, or involvement specified in
§ 800.211(b) at the time of its investment.
Corporation A subsequently gains the right to
appoint a member of the board of directors
of Corporation X. Assuming no other relevant
facts, the transaction is a covered investment.
(7) Example 7. Corporation A is organized
under the laws of a foreign state, is wholly
owned and controlled by a foreign national,
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
and is not an excepted investor. With a view
towards circumventing section 721,
Corporation A transfers money to a U.S.
citizen, who, pursuant to informal
arrangements with Corporation A and on its
behalf, makes a non-controlling minority
equity investment in Corporation X, an
unaffiliated TID U.S. business that maintains
and collects sensitive personal data on U.S.
citizens. In connection with the investment,
the U.S. citizen is afforded the right to be
involved in substantive decisionmaking
regarding the release of sensitive personal
data of U.S. citizens maintained by
Corporation X. The transaction is a covered
investment.
§ 800.304 Transactions that are not
covered investments.
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
Transactions that are not covered
investments include, without limitation:
(a) An investment by a foreign person
in an unaffiliated TID U.S. business that
does not afford the foreign person any
of the access, rights, or involvement
specified in § 800.211(b). (See the
examples in § 800.304(f)(1) and (2).)
(b) An investment by a foreign person
who is an excepted investor in an
unaffiliated TID U.S. business. (See the
example in § 800.304(f)(3).)
(c) A transaction that results or could
result in control by a foreign person of
an unaffiliated TID U.S. business. (See
the example in § 800.304(f)(4).)
(d) A stock split or pro rata stock
dividend that does not afford the foreign
person any of the access, rights, or
involvement specified in § 800.211(b).
(See the example in § 800.304(f)(5).)
(e) An acquisition of securities by a
person acting as a securities
underwriter, in the ordinary course of
business and in the process of
underwriting.
(f) Examples:
(1) Example 1. In an open market purchase
solely for the purpose of passive investment,
Corporation A, a foreign person who is not
an excepted investor, acquires seven percent
of the voting securities of Corporation X, an
unaffiliated TID U.S. business. Assuming no
other relevant facts, the acquisition of the
securities is not a covered investment.
(2) Example 2. The Committee concluded
all action under section 721 with respect to
a covered investment in which Corporation
A, a foreign person who is not an excepted
investor, acquired a four percent, noncontrolling equity interest with board
observer rights in Corporation B, an
unaffiliated TID U.S. business. One year
later, Corporation A proposes to acquire an
additional five percent equity interest in
Corporation B, which would result in
Corporation A holding a nine percent, noncontrolling equity interest in Corporation B.
The proposed investment does not afford
Corporation A any additional access, rights,
or involvement with respect to Corporation
B, including the access, rights, or
involvement specified in § 800.211(b).
Assuming no other relevant facts, the
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
proposed transaction is not a covered
investment.
(3) Example 3. Corporation A, a foreign
person who is an excepted investor, proposes
to acquire a four percent, non-controlling
equity interest in Corporation B, an
unaffiliated TID U.S. business. Pursuant to
the terms of the investment, a designee of
Corporation A will have the right to observe
the meetings of the board of directors of
Corporation B. Assuming no other relevant
facts, the proposed transaction is not a
covered investment.
(4) Example 4. Corporation A, a foreign
person who is an excepted investor, proposes
to purchase all of the shares of Corporation
B, an unaffiliated TID U.S. business. As the
sole owner, Corporation A will have the right
to elect directors and appoint other primary
officers of Corporation B. Assuming no other
relevant facts, the proposed transaction is not
a covered investment. It is, however, a
covered control transaction. Whether
Corporation A is an excepted investor or
whether Corporation B is an unaffiliated TID
U.S. business are not relevant to the
determination of whether the transaction is a
covered control transaction. (See § 800.301).
(5) Example 5. Corporation A, a foreign
person who is not an excepted investor,
holds 10,000 shares and board observer rights
in Corporation B, an unaffiliated TID U.S.
business, constituting ten percent of the stock
of Corporation B. Corporation B pays a 2-for1 stock dividend. As a result of this stock
split, Corporation A holds 20,000 shares of
Corporation B, still constituting ten percent
of the stock of Corporation B. The proposed
investment does not afford Corporation A
any additional access, rights, or involvement
with respect to Corporation B, including
those specified in § 800.211(b). Assuming no
other relevant facts, the acquisition of
additional shares is not a covered
investment.
§ 800.305
Incremental acquisitions.
(a) Any transaction in which a foreign
person acquires an additional interest in
a U.S. business over which the same
foreign person, or any of its direct or
indirect wholly-owned subsidiaries,
previously acquired direct control in the
U.S. business in a covered control
transaction for which the Committee
concluded all action under section 721
on the basis of a notice filed pursuant
to § 800.501 shall not be deemed to be
a covered transaction. If, however, a
foreign person that did not acquire
control of the U.S. business in the prior
transaction is a party to the later
transaction, the later transaction may be
a covered transaction.
(b) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, a foreign
person, directly acquires a 40 percent interest
and important rights with respect to
Corporation B, a U.S. business. The
documentation pertaining to the transaction
gives no indication that Corporation A’s
interest in Corporation B may increase at a
later date. Corporation A and Corporation B
file a voluntary notice of the transaction with
PO 00000
Frm 00023
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
50195
the Committee. Following its review of the
transaction, the Committee informs the
parties that the notified transaction is a
covered control transaction, and concludes
action under section 721. Three years later,
Corporation A acquires the remainder of the
voting interest in Corporation B. Assuming
no other relevant facts, because the
Committee, on the basis of the notice
submitted by the parties, concluded all
action with respect to Corporation A’s earlier
direct investment in the same U.S. business,
and because no other foreign person is a
party to this subsequent transaction, this
subsequent transaction is not a covered
transaction.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as Example 1 of
this section, except that Corporation A and
Corporation B file a declaration of the
transaction, rather than a notice, with the
Committee, and the Committee concluded all
action on the basis of the declaration. The
subsequent transaction may be a covered
transaction, depending on the specific facts
and circumstances.
§ 800.306
Lending transactions.
(a) The extension of a loan or a similar
financing arrangement by a foreign
person to a U.S. business, regardless of
whether accompanied by the creation in
favor of the foreign person of a secured
interest over securities or other assets of
the U.S. business, shall not, by itself,
constitute a covered transaction.
(1) The Committee will accept notices
or declarations concerning a loan or a
similar financing arrangement that does
not, by itself, constitute a covered
transaction only at the time that,
because of imminent or actual default or
other condition, there is a significant
possibility that the foreign person may
obtain control of a U.S. business, or
acquire equity interest and access,
rights, or involvement specified in
§ 800.211(b) over a TID U.S. business, as
a result of the default or other condition.
(2) Where the Committee accepts a
notice or declaration concerning a loan
or a similar financing arrangement
pursuant to paragraph (a)(1) of this
section, and a party to the transaction is
a foreign person that makes loans in the
ordinary course of business, the
Committee will take into account
whether the foreign person has made
any arrangements to transfer
management decisions, or day-to-day
control over the U.S. business to U.S.
nationals for purposes of determining
whether such loan or financing
arrangement constitutes a covered
transaction.
(b) Notwithstanding paragraph (a) of
this section, a loan or a similar
financing arrangement through which a
foreign person acquires an interest in
profits of a U.S. business, the right to
appoint members of the board of
directors of the U.S. business, or other
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
50196
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
comparable financial or governance
rights characteristic of an equity
investment but not of a typical loan may
constitute a covered transaction.
(c) An acquisition of voting interest in
or assets of a U.S. business by a foreign
person upon default or other condition
involving a loan or a similar financing
arrangement does not constitute a
covered transaction, provided that the
loan was made by a syndicate of banks
in a loan participation where the foreign
lender (or lenders) in the syndicate:
(1) Needs the majority consent of the
U.S. participants in the syndicate to take
action, and cannot on its own initiate
any action vis-a`-vis the debtor; or
(2) Does not have a lead role in the
syndicate, and is subject to a provision
in the loan or financing documents
limiting its ability to control the debtor
such that control for purposes of
§ 800.208 could not be acquired.
(d) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, which is a
U.S. business, borrows funds from
Corporation B, a bank organized under the
laws of a foreign state and controlled by
foreign persons. As a condition of the loan,
Corporation A agrees not to sell or pledge its
principal assets to any person. Assuming no
other relevant facts, this lending arrangement
does not alone constitute a covered
transaction.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as in Example
1 of this section, except that Corporation A
defaults on its loan from Corporation B and
seeks bankruptcy protection. Corporation A
has no funds with which to satisfy
Corporation B’s claim, which is greater than
the value of Corporation A’s principal assets.
Corporation B’s secured claim constitutes the
only secured claim against Corporation A’s
principal assets, creating a high probability
that Corporation B will receive title to
Corporation A’s principal assets, which
constitute a U.S. business. Assuming no
other relevant facts, the Committee would
accept a notice of the impending bankruptcy
court adjudication transferring control of
Corporation A’s principal assets to
Corporation B, which would constitute a
covered control transaction.
(3) Example 3. Corporation A, a foreign
bank, makes a loan to Corporation B, a U.S.
business. The loan documentation extends to
Corporation A rights in Corporation B that
are characteristic of an equity investment but
not of a typical loan, including dominant
minority representation on the board of
directors of Corporation B and the right to be
paid dividends by Corporation B. This loan
is a covered control transaction.
(4) Example 4. Same facts as in Example
3 of this section, except that Corporation B
is an unaffiliated TID U.S. business and the
loan documentation extends to Corporation
A’s involvement in substantive
decisionmaking with respect to Corporation
B. Whether the loan is a covered control
transaction would depend on whether
Corporation A obtains control of Corporation
B as a result of the loan, but, if it could not
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
result in Corporation A’s control of
Corporation B, this loan is a covered
investment.
§ 800.307 Specific clarifications for
investment funds.
(a) Notwithstanding § 800.303, an
indirect investment by a foreign person
in a TID U.S. business through an
investment fund that affords the foreign
person (or a designee of the foreign
person) membership as a limited partner
or equivalent on an advisory board or a
committee of the fund shall not be
considered a covered investment with
respect to the foreign person if:
(1) The fund is managed exclusively
by a general partner, a managing
member, or an equivalent;
(2) The foreign person is not the
general partner, managing member, or
equivalent;
(3) The advisory board or committee
does not have the ability to approve,
disapprove, or otherwise control:
(i) Investment decisions of the
investment fund; or
(ii) Decisions made by the general
partner, managing member, or
equivalent related to entities in which
the investment fund is invested;
(4) The foreign person does not
otherwise have the ability to control the
investment fund, including without
limitation the authority:
(i) To approve, disapprove, or
otherwise control investment decisions
of the investment fund;
(ii) To approve, disapprove, or
otherwise control decisions made by the
general partner, managing member, or
equivalent related to entities in which
the investment fund is invested; or
(iii) To unilaterally dismiss, prevent
the dismissal of, select, or determine the
compensation of the general partner,
managing member, or equivalent;
(5) The foreign person does not have
access to material nonpublic technical
information as a result of its
participation on the advisory board or
committee; and
(6) The investment does not afford the
foreign person any of the access, rights,
or involvement specified in
§ 800.211(b).
(b) For the purposes of paragraphs
(a)(3) and (4) of this section, and except
as provided in paragraph (c) of this
section, a waiver of a potential conflict
of interest, a waiver of an allocation
limitation, or a similar activity,
applicable to a transaction pursuant to
the terms of an agreement governing an
investment fund shall not be considered
to constitute control of investment
decisions of the investment fund or
decisions relating to entities in which
the investment fund is invested.
PO 00000
Frm 00024
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
(c) In extraordinary circumstances,
the Committee may consider the waiver
of a potential conflict of interest, the
waiver of an allocation limitation, or a
similar activity, applicable to a
transaction pursuant to the terms of an
agreement governing an investment
fund, to constitute control of investment
decisions of the investment fund or
decisions relating to entities in which
the investment fund is invested.
(d) Example: Limited Partner A, a
foreign person, is a limited partner in an
investment fund that invests in
Corporation B, an unaffiliated TID U.S.
business. The investment fund is
managed exclusively by a general
partner, who is not a foreign person.
The investment affords Limited Partner
A membership on an advisory board of
the investment fund. The advisory
board provides industry expertise,
assists with the sourcing of transactions,
and votes on the compensation of the
general partner, but it does not control
investment decisions of the fund or
decisions made by the general partner
related to entities in which the fund is
invested. Limited Partner A does not
otherwise have the ability to control the
fund. Limited Partner A’s investment in
Corporation B does not afford it access
to any material nonpublic technical
information in the possession of
Corporation B, the right to be a member
or observer, or to nominate a member or
observer, to the board of Corporation B,
nor any involvement in the substantive
decisionmaking of Corporation B.
Assuming no other facts, the investment
by Limited Partner A is not a covered
investment.
§ 800.308 Timing rule for a contingent
equity interest.
(a) For purposes of determining
whether to include the rights that a
holder of contingent equity interest will
acquire upon conversion of, or exercise
of a right provided by, those interests in
the Committee’s analysis of whether a
notified transaction is a covered
transaction, the Committee will
consider factors that include:
(1) The imminence of conversion or
satisfaction of contingent conditions;
(2) Whether conversion or satisfaction
of contingent conditions depends on
factors within the control of the
acquiring party; and
(3) Whether the amount of interest
and the rights that would be acquired
upon conversion or satisfaction of
contingent conditions can be reasonably
determined at the time of acquisition.
(b) When the Committee, applying
paragraph (a) of this section, determines
that the rights that the holder will
acquire upon conversion or satisfaction
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
of contingent condition will not be
included in the Committee’s analysis of
whether a notified transaction is a
covered transaction, the Committee will
disregard the contingent equity interest
for purposes of that transaction except
to the extent that they convey
immediate rights to the holder with
respect to the entity that issued the
interest.
(c) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, a foreign
person, notifies the Committee that it intends
to buy common stock and debentures of
Corporation X, a U.S. business. By their
terms, the debentures are convertible into
common stock only upon the occurrence of
an event the timing of which is not in the
control of Corporation A, and the number of
common shares that would be acquired upon
conversion cannot now be determined.
Assuming no other relevant facts, the
Committee will disregard the debentures in
the course of its covered transaction analysis
at the time that Corporation A acquires the
debentures. In the event that it determines
that the acquisition of the common stock is
not a covered transaction, the Committee will
so inform the parties. Once the conversion of
the instruments becomes imminent, it may be
appropriate for the Committee to consider the
rights that would result from the conversion
and whether the conversion is a covered
transaction. The conversion of those
debentures into common stock could be a
covered transaction, depending on what
percentage of Corporation X’s voting
securities Corporation A would receive and
what powers those securities would confer
on Corporation A.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as Example 1 of
this section, except that the debentures at
issue are convertible at the sole discretion of
Corporation A after six months, and if
converted, would represent a 50 percent
interest in Corporation X. The Committee
may consider the rights that would result
from the conversion as part of its analysis.
Subpart D—Declarations
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
§ 800.401
Mandatory declarations.
(a) Except as provided in paragraph
(c) or (d) of this section, the parties to
a transaction described in paragraph (b)
of this section shall submit to the
Committee a declaration with
information regarding the transaction in
accordance with § 800.403.
(b) A covered transaction that results
in the acquisition of a substantial
interest in a TID U.S. business by a
foreign person in which a foreign
government has a substantial interest.
(c) The submission of a declaration
shall not be required pursuant to
paragraph (b) of this section with
respect to an investment by an
investment fund if:
(1) The fund is managed exclusively
by a general partner, a managing
member, or an equivalent;
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
(2) The general partner, managing
member, or equivalent that exclusively
manages the fund is not a foreign
person; and
(3) The investment fund satisfies,
with respect to any foreign person with
membership as a limited partner on an
advisory board or a committee of the
fund, the criteria specified in
§ 800.307(a)(3) and (4);
(d) Notwithstanding paragraph (a) of
this section, parties to a covered
transaction may elect to submit a
written notice pursuant to subpart E of
this part regarding the transaction
instead of a declaration.
(e) Parties shall submit to the
Committee the declaration required
pursuant to paragraph (a) of this section,
or a written notice pursuant to
paragraph (d) of this section, no later
than:
(1) [EFFECTIVE DATE OF FINAL
RULE], or promptly thereafter, if the
completion date of the transaction is
between [EFFECTIVE DATE OF FINAL
RULE] and [DATE WHICH IS 30 DAYS
AFTER THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF
FINAL RULE]; or
(2) Thirty days before the completion
date of the transaction, if the completion
date of the transaction is after [DATE
THAT IS 30 DAYS AFTER THE
EFFECTIVE DATE OF FINAL RULE].
(f) Notwithstanding paragraph (e)(2)
of this section, the parties to a covered
transaction may complete a transaction
subject to a mandatory declaration or
notice under this section at any time
after having been informed in writing by
the Committee that the Committee has
concluded all action under section 721
or that the Committee is not able to
complete action pursuant to
§ 800.807(a)(2).
(g) In the event that the Committee
rejects or permits a withdrawal of a
declaration or notice required under
section, the parties shall not complete
the transaction earlier than 30 days after
the date of the resubmission, except
with the written approval of the Staff
Chairperson.
§ 800.402
Voluntary declarations.
Except as otherwise prohibited under
§ 800.403(e), a party to any proposed or
completed transaction may submit to
the Committee a declaration regarding
the transaction in accordance with the
procedures and requirements set forth
in § 800.403 and § 800.404 instead of a
written notice.
§ 800.403
Procedures for declarations.
(a) A party or parties shall submit a
declaration of a covered transaction
pursuant to § 800.401 or § 800.402 by
submitting electronically the
PO 00000
Frm 00025
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
50197
information set out in § 800.404,
including the certifications required
thereunder, to the Staff Chairperson in
accordance with the submission
instructions on the Committee’s section
of the Department of the Treasury
website at https://home.treasury.gov/
policy-issues/international/thecommittee-on-foreign-investment-in-theunited-states-cfius.
(b) No communications other than
those described in paragraph (a) of this
section shall constitute the submission
of a declaration for purposes of section
721.
(c) Information and other
documentary material submitted to the
Committee pursuant to this section shall
be considered to have been filed with
the President or the President’s designee
for purposes of section 721(c) and
§ 800.802.
(d) Persons filing a declaration shall,
during the time that the matter is
pending before the Committee,
promptly advise the Staff Chairperson of
any material changes in plans, facts, or
circumstances addressed in the
declaration, and any material change in
information provided or required to be
provided to the Committee under
§ 800.404. Unless the Committee rejects
the declaration on the basis of such
material changes in accordance with
§ 800.406(a)(2)(i), such changes shall
become part of the declaration filed by
such persons under § 800.403, and the
certification required under § 800.405(d)
shall apply to such changes.
(e) Parties to a covered transaction
that have filed with the Committee a
written notice regarding a transaction
pursuant to § 800.501 may not submit to
the Committee a declaration regarding
the same transaction or a substantially
similar transaction without the written
approval of the Staff Chairperson.
§ 800.404
Contents of declarations.
(a) The party or parties submitting a
declaration of a covered transaction
pursuant to § 800.403 shall provide the
information set out in this section,
which must be accurate and complete
with respect to all parties and to the
transaction. (See also paragraphs (d) and
(e) of this section.)
(b) If fewer than all the parties to a
transaction submit a declaration, the
Committee may, at its discretion,
request that the parties to the
transaction file a written notice of the
transaction under § 800.501, if the Staff
Chairperson determines that the
information provided by the submitting
party or parties in the declaration is
insufficient for the Committee to assess
the transaction.
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
50198
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
(c) Subject to paragraph (e) of this
section, a declaration submitted
pursuant to § 800.403 shall describe or
provide, as applicable:
(1) The name of the foreign person(s)
and U.S. business(es) that are parties to,
or, in applicable cases, the subject of the
transaction, as well as the name,
telephone number, and email address of
the primary point of contact for each
party.
(2) The following information
regarding the transaction in question,
including:
(i) A brief description of the rationale
and nature of the transaction, including
its structure (e.g., share purchase,
merger, asset purchase);
(ii) The percentage of voting interest
acquired and the resulting aggregate
voting interest held by the foreign
person and its affiliates;
(iii) The percentage of economic
interest acquired and the resulting
aggregate economic interest held by the
foreign person and its affiliates;
(iv) Whether the U.S. business has
multiple classes of ownership;
(v) The total transaction value in U.S.
dollars;
(vi) The actual or expected
completion date of the transaction;
(vii) All sources of financing for the
transaction; and
(viii) A copy of the definitive
documentation of the transaction, or if
none exists, the document establishing
the material terms of the transaction.
(3) The following:
(i) A statement as to whether a party
to the transaction is stipulating that the
transaction is a covered transaction and
a description of the basis for the
stipulation; and
(ii) A statement as to whether a party
to the transaction is stipulating that the
transaction is a foreign governmentcontrolled transaction and a description
of the basis for the stipulation.
(4) A statement as to whether the
foreign person will acquire any of the
following with respect to the U.S.
business:
(i) Access to any material nonpublic
technical information in the possession
of the U.S. business, and if so, a brief
explanation of the type of access and
type of information;
(ii) Membership, observer rights, or
nomination rights as set forth in
§ 800.211(b)(2), and if so, a statement as
to the composition of the board or other
body both before and after the
completion date of the transaction;
(iii) Any involvement, other than
through voting shares, in substantive
decisionmaking of the U.S. business
regarding critical infrastructure, critical
technologies, or sensitive personal data
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
as set forth in § 800.211(b)(3), and if so,
a statement as to the involvement in
such substantive decisionmaking; or
(iv) Any rights that could result in the
foreign person acquiring control of the
U.S. business and, if any, a brief
explanation of these rights.
(5) The following information
regarding the covered transaction U.S.
business:
(i) Website address;
(ii) Principal place of business;
(iii) Place of incorporation or
organization; and
(iv) A list of the addresses or
geographic coordinates (to at least the
fourth decimal) of all locations of the
U.S. business, including the U.S.
business’ headquarters, facilities, and
operating locations.
(6) With respect to the U.S. business
that is the subject of the transaction and
any entity of which that U.S. business
is a parent, a brief summary of their
respective business activities, as, for
example, set forth in annual reports, and
the product or service categories of
each, including the applicable six-digit
North American Industry Classification
System (NAICS) Codes, Commercial and
Government Entity Code (CAGE Code)
assigned by the Department of Defense,
and any applicable Dun and Bradstreet
identification (DUNS) numbers assigned
to the U.S. business.
(7) A statement as to whether the U.S.
business produces, designs, tests,
manufactures, fabricates, or develops
one or more critical technologies.
(8) A statement as to whether the U.S.
business performs any of the functions
with respect to covered investment
critical infrastructure as set forth in
Column 2 of appendix A to part 800.
(9) A statement as to whether the U.S.
business maintains or collects sensitive
personal data on U.S. citizens.
(10) A statement as to whether the
U.S. business has any contracts
(including any subcontracts, if known)
that are currently in effect or were in
effect within the past three years with
any U.S. Government agency or
component, or in the past 10 years if the
contract included access to personally
identifiable information of U.S.
Government personnel. If so, provide an
annex listing such contracts, including
the name of the U.S. Government
agency or component, the delivery order
number or contract number, the primary
contractor (if the U.S. business is a
subcontractor), the start date, and the
estimated completion date.
(11) A statement as to whether the
U.S. business has any contracts
(including any subcontracts, if known)
that are currently in effect or were in
effect within the past five years
PO 00000
Frm 00026
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
involving information, technology, or
data that is classified under Executive
Order 12958, as amended.
(12) A statement as to whether the
U.S. business has received any grant or
other funding from the Department of
Defense or the Department of Energy, or
participated in or collaborated on any
defense or energy program or product
involving one or more critical
technologies or critical infrastructure
within the past five years.
(13) A statement as to whether the
U.S. business participated in a Defense
Production Act Title III Program (50
U.S.C. 4501, et seq.) within the past
seven years.
(14) A statement as to whether the
U.S. business has received or placed
priority rated contracts or orders under
the Defense Priorities and Allocations
System (DPAS) regulation (15 CFR part
700), and the level(s) of priority of such
contracts or orders (DX or DO) within
the past three years.
(15) The name of the ultimate parent
of the foreign person.
(16) The principal place of business
and address of the foreign person,
ultimate parent and ultimate owner of
such parent.
(17) Complete organizational charts,
both pre- and post-transaction,
including information that identifies the
name, principal place of business and
place of incorporation or other legal
organization (for entities), nationality
(for individuals), and ownership
percentage (expressed in terms of both
voting and economic interest, if
different) for each of the following:
(i) The immediate parent, the ultimate
parent, and each intermediate parent, if
any, of each foreign person that is a
party to the transaction;
(ii) Where the ultimate parent is a
private company, the ultimate owner(s)
of such parent;
(iii) Where the ultimate parent is a
public company, any shareholder with
an interest of greater than five percent
in such parent; and
(iv) The U.S. business that is the
subject of the transaction, both before
and after completion of the transaction.
(18) Information regarding all foreign
government ownership in the foreign
person’s ownership structure, including
nationality and percentage of
ownership, as well as any rights that a
foreign government holds, directly or
indirectly, with respect to the foreign
person.
(19) With respect to the foreign person
that is party to the transaction and any
of its parents, as applicable, a brief
summary of their respective business
activities, as, for example, set forth in
annual reports.
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
(20) A statement as to whether any
party to the transaction has been party
to another transaction previously
notified or submitted to the Committee,
and the case number assigned by the
Committee regarding such
transaction(s).
(21) A statement (including relevant
jurisdiction and criminal case law
number or legal citation) as to whether
the U.S. business, the foreign person, or
any parent or subsidiary of the foreign
person has been convicted in the last
ten years of a crime in any jurisdiction.
(22) If applicable, a description
(which may group similar items into
general product categories) of the items,
their uses, and a list of any relevant
classifications for the critical
technologies that the U.S. business
produces, designs, tests, manufactures,
fabricates, or develops.
(23) If applicable, a statement as to
which functions set forth in Column 2
of appendix A to part 800 that the U.S.
business performs with respect to
covered investment critical
infrastructure, including a description
of such functions and the applicable
covered investment critical
infrastructure.
(24) If applicable:
(i) The category or categories of
sensitive personal data, as specified at
§ 800.241, that the U.S. business
maintains or collects, or intends to
maintain or collect;
(ii) The approximate number of total
unique individuals from whom
sensitive personal data is currently
maintained, and has been collected over
the last 12 months;
(iii) Whether the U.S. business targets
or tailors its products or services to U.S.
Government personnel or contractors
from whom it maintains or collects
sensitive personal data.
(d) Each party submitting a
declaration shall provide a certification
of the information contained in the
declaration consistent with § 800.204 of
this chapter. A sample certification may
be found on the Committee’s section of
the Department of the Treasury website
at https://home.treasury.gov/policyissues/international/the-committee-onforeign-investment-in-the-united-statescfius.
(e) A party that offers a stipulation
pursuant to paragraph (c)(3) of this
section acknowledges that the
Committee and the President are
entitled to rely on such stipulation in
determining whether the transaction is
a covered investment, a covered control
transaction, or a foreign governmentcontrolled transaction for the purposes
of section 721 and all authorities
thereunder, and waives the right to
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
challenge any such determination.
Neither the Committee nor the President
is bound by any such stipulation, nor
does any such stipulation limit the
ability of the Committee or the President
to act on any authority provided under
section 721 with respect to any covered
transaction.
§ 800.405
period.
Beginning of 30-day assessment
(a) Upon receipt of a declaration
submitted pursuant to § 800.403, the
Staff Chairperson shall promptly inspect
the declaration and shall promptly
notify in writing all parties to a
transaction that have submitted a
declaration that:
(1) The Staff Chairperson has
accepted the declaration and circulated
the declaration to the Committee, and
the date on which the assessment
described in paragraph (b) of this
section begins; or
(2) The Staff Chairperson has
determined not to accept the declaration
and circulate the declaration to the
Committee because the declaration is
incomplete, and an explanation of the
material respects in which the
declaration is incomplete.
(b) A 30-day period for assessment of
a covered transaction that is the subject
of a declaration shall commence on the
date on which the declaration is
received by the Committee from the
Staff Chairperson. Such period shall end
no later than the thirtieth day after it has
commenced, or if the thirtieth day is not
a business day, no later than the next
business day after the thirtieth day.
(c) During the 30-day assessment
period, the Staff Chairperson may invite
the parties to a covered transaction to
attend a meeting with the Committee
staff to discuss and clarify issues
pertaining to the transaction.
(d) If the Committee notifies the
parties to a transaction that have
submitted a declaration pursuant to
§ 800.403 that the Committee intends to
conclude all action under section 721
with respect to that transaction, each
party that has submitted additional
information subsequent to the original
declaration shall file a certification as
described in § 800.204. A sample
certification may be found on the
Committee’s section of the Department
of the Treasury website at https://
home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/
international/the-committee-on-foreigninvestment-in-the-united-states-cfius.
(e) If a party fails to provide the
certification required under paragraph
(d) of this section, the Committee may,
at its discretion, take any of the actions
under § 800.407.
PO 00000
Frm 00027
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
50199
§ 800.406 Rejection, disposition, or
withdrawal of declarations.
(a) The Committee, acting through the
Staff Chairperson, may:
(1) Reject any declaration that does
not comply with § 800.404 and so
inform the parties promptly in writing;
(2) Reject any declaration at any time,
and so inform the parties promptly in
writing, if, after the declaration has been
submitted and before the Committee has
taken one of the actions specified in
§ 800.407:
(i) There is a material change in the
covered transaction as to which a
declaration has been submitted; or
(ii) Information comes to light that
contradicts material information
provided in the declaration by the party
(or parties); or
(3) Reject any declaration at any time
after the declaration has been submitted,
and so inform the parties promptly in
writing, if the party (or parties) that
submitted the declaration does not
provide follow-up information
requested by the Staff Chairperson
within two business days of the request,
or within a longer time frame if the
party (or parties) so request in writing
and the Staff Chairperson grants that
request in writing.
(b) The Staff Chairperson shall notify
the parties that submitted a declaration
when the Committee has found that the
transaction that is the subject of a
declaration is not a covered transaction.
(c) Parties to a transaction that have
submitted a declaration pursuant to
§ 800.403 may request in writing, at any
time prior to the Committee taking
action under § 800.407, that such
declaration be withdrawn. Such request
shall be directed to the Staff
Chairperson and shall state the reasons
why the request is being made and state
whether the transaction that is the
subject of the declaration is being fully
and permanently abandoned. An official
of the Department of the Treasury will
promptly advise the parties to the
transaction in writing of the
Committee’s decision.
(d) The Committee may not request or
recommend that a declaration be
withdrawn and refiled, except to permit
parties to a covered transaction to
correct material errors or omissions, or
describe material changes to the
transaction, in the declaration submitted
with respect to that covered transaction.
(e) A party (or parties) may not submit
more than one declaration for the same
or a substantially similar transaction
without approval from the Staff
Chairperson.
Note 1 to § 800.406: See § 800.403(e)
regarding the prohibition on submitting a
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
50200
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
declaration regarding the same transaction or
a substantially similar transaction for which
a written notice has been filed without the
approval of the Staff Chairperson.
§ 800.407
Committee actions.
(a) Upon receiving a declaration
submitted pursuant to § 800.403 with
respect to a covered transaction, the
Committee may, at the discretion of the
Committee:
(1) Request that the parties to the
transaction file a written notice
pursuant to subpart E;
(2) Inform the parties to the
transaction that the Committee is not
able to conclude action under section
721 with respect to the transaction on
the basis of the declaration and that the
parties may file a written notice
pursuant to subpart E to seek written
notification from the Committee that the
Committee has concluded all action
under section 721 with respect to the
transaction;
(3) Initiate a unilateral review of the
transaction under § 800.501(c); or
(4) Notify the parties in writing that
the Committee has concluded all action
under section 721 with respect to the
transaction.
(b) The Committee shall take action
under paragraph (a) of this section
within the time period set forth in
§ 800.405(b).
Subpart E—Notices
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
§ 800.501
Procedures for notices.
(a) A party or parties to a proposed or
completed transaction may file a
voluntary notice of the transaction with
the Committee. Voluntary notice to the
Committee is filed by sending an
electronic copy of the notice that
includes, in English, the information set
out in § 800.502, including the
certification required under paragraph
(l) of that section. For electronic
submission instructions, see the
Committee’s section of the Department
of the Treasury website, currently
available at https://home.treasury.gov/
policy-issues/international/thecommittee-on-foreign-investment-in-theunited-states-cfius.
(b) If the Committee determines that
a transaction for which no voluntary
notice has been filed under paragraph
(a) of this section may be a covered
transaction and may raise national
security considerations, the Staff
Chairperson, acting on the
recommendation of the Committee, may
request the parties to the transaction to
provide to the Committee the
information necessary to determine
whether the transaction is a covered
transaction, and if the Committee
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
determines that the transaction is a
covered transaction, to file a notice
under paragraph (a) of such covered
transaction.
(c) With respect to any transaction:
(1) Subject to paragraph (c)(2) of this
section, any member of the Committee,
or his designee at or above the Under
Secretary or equivalent level, may file
an agency notice to the Committee
through the Staff Chairperson regarding
a transaction if:
(i) That member has reason to believe
that the transaction is a covered
transaction and may raise national
security considerations and:
(A) The Committee has not informed
the parties to such transaction in writing
that the Committee has concluded all
action under section 721 with respect to
such transaction; and
(B) The President has not announced
a decision not to exercise the President’s
authority under section 721(d) with
respect to such transaction; or
(ii) The transaction is a covered
transaction and:
(A) The Committee has informed the
parties to such transaction in writing
that the Committee has concluded all
action under section 721 with respect to
such transaction, or the President has
announced a decision not to exercise
the President’s authority under section
721(d) with respect to such transaction;
and
(B) Either:
(1) A party to such transaction
submitted false or misleading material
information to the Committee in
connection with the Committee’s
consideration of such transaction or
omitted material information, including
material documents, from information
submitted to the Committee; or
(2) A party to such transaction or the
entity resulting from consummation of
such transaction materially breaches a
mitigation agreement or condition
described in section 721(l)(3)(A), such
breach is certified to the Committee by
the lead department or agency
monitoring and enforcing such
agreement or condition as a material
breach, and the Committee determines
that there are no other adequate and
appropriate remedies or enforcement
tools available to address such breach.
(2)(i) That is an investment where a
foreign person is not an excepted
investor due to the application of
§ 800.220(d), any member of the
Committee, or his designee at or above
the Under Secretary or equivalent level,
may file an agency notice to the
Committee through the Staff
Chairperson regarding such investment
if:
PO 00000
Frm 00028
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
(A) That member has reason to believe
that the transaction is a covered
transaction and may raise national
security considerations;
(B) The Committee has not informed
the parties to such transaction in writing
that the Committee has concluded all
action under section 721 with respect to
such transaction; and
(C) The President has not announced
a decision not to exercise the President’s
authority under section 721(d) with
respect to such transaction.
(ii) No notice filed pursuant to this
paragraph (c)(2) shall be made with
respect to a transaction more than one
year after the completion date of the
transaction, unless the Chairperson of
the Committee determines, in
consultation with other members of the
Committee, that because the foreign
person no longer meets all the criteria
set forth in § 800.220(a)(1), (2), or (3)(i)
through (iii) the transaction may
threaten to impair the national security
of the United States, and in no event
shall an agency notice under this
paragraph be made with respect to such
a transaction more than three years after
the completion date of the transaction.
(d) Notices filed under paragraph (c)
of this section are deemed accepted
upon their receipt by the Staff
Chairperson. No agency notice under
paragraph (c)(1) of this section shall be
made with respect to a transaction more
than three years after the completion
date of the transaction, unless the
Chairperson of the Committee, in
consultation with other members of the
Committee, files such an agency notice.
(e) No communications other than
those described in paragraphs (a) and (c)
of this section shall constitute the filing
or submitting of a notice for purposes of
section 721.
(f) Upon receipt of the electronic copy
of a notice filed under paragraph (a) of
this section, including the certification
required by § 800.502(l), the Staff
Chairperson shall promptly inspect
such notice for completeness.
(g) Parties to a transaction are
encouraged to consult with the
Committee in advance of filing a notice
and, in appropriate cases, to file with
the Committee a draft notice or other
appropriate documents to aid the
Committee’s understanding of the
transaction and to provide an
opportunity for the Committee to
request additional information to be
included in the notice. Any such prenotice consultation should take place, or
any draft notice should be provided, at
least five business days before the filing
of a voluntary notice. All information
and documentary material made
available to the Committee pursuant to
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
this paragraph shall be considered to
have been filed with the President or the
President’s designee for purposes of
section 721(c) and § 800.802.
(h) Information and other
documentary material provided by the
parties to the Committee after the filing
of a voluntary notice under this section
shall be part of the notice, and shall be
subject to the certification requirements
of § 800.502(m).
(i) For any voluntarily submitted draft
or formal written notice that includes a
stipulation pursuant to section
§ 800.502(o) that a transaction is a
covered transaction, the Committee
shall provide comments on a draft or
formal written notice or accept a formal
written notice of a covered transaction
not later than the date that is 10
business days after the date of
submission of the draft or formal written
notice.
(j) No party to a transaction may file
a notice pursuant to paragraph (a) of this
section if the transaction has been
subject to a declaration submitted
pursuant to subpart D and the
Committee has not yet taken action with
respect to the transaction pursuant to
§ 800.407.
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
§ 800.502
Contents of voluntary notices.
(a) If the parties to a transaction file
a voluntary notice, they shall provide in
detail the information set out in this
section, which must be accurate and
complete with respect to all parties and
to the transaction. (See also paragraph
(l) of this section and § 800.204
regarding certification requirements.)
(b) If fewer than all the parties to a
transaction file a voluntary notice, for
example in the case of a hostile
takeover, each notifying party shall
provide the information set out in this
section with respect to itself and, to the
extent known or reasonably available to
it, with respect to each non-notifying
party.
(c) A voluntary notice filed pursuant
to § 800.501 shall describe or provide, as
applicable:
(1) The transaction in question,
including:
(i) A summary setting forth the
essentials of the transaction, including a
statement of the purpose of the
transaction, and its scope, both within
and outside of the United States;
(ii) The nature of the transaction, for
example, whether the acquisition is by
merger, consolidation, the purchase of
voting interest, or otherwise;
(iii) The name, United States address
(if any), website address (if any),
nationality (for individuals) or place of
incorporation or other legal organization
(for entities), and address of the
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
principal place of business of each
foreign person that is a party to the
transaction;
(iv) The name, address, website
address (if any), principal place of
business, and place of incorporation or
other legal organization of the U.S.
business that is the subject of the
transaction;
(v) The name, address, and nationality
(for individuals) or place of
incorporation or other legal organization
(for entities) of:
(A) The immediate parent, the
ultimate parent, and each intermediate
parent, if any, of the foreign person that
is a party to the transaction;
(B) Where the ultimate parent is a
private company, the ultimate owner(s)
of such parent; and
(C) Where the ultimate parent is a
public company, any shareholder with
an interest of greater than five percent
in such parent;
(vi) The name, address, website
address (if any), and nationality (for
individuals) or place of incorporation or
other legal organization (for entities) of
each person that will control the U.S.
business being acquired;
(vii) The expected date for completion
of the transaction, or the date it was
completed;
(viii) A good faith approximation of
the net value of the interest acquired in
the U.S. business in U.S. dollars, as of
the date of the notice;
(ix) The name of any and all financial
institutions involved in the transaction,
including as advisors, underwriters, or a
source of financing for the transaction;
(x) A copy of any partnership
agreements, integration agreements, or
other side agreements relating to the
transaction;
(xi) A statement as to whether the
foreign person will acquire any of the
following in the U.S. business:
(A) Access to any material nonpublic
technical information in the possession
of the U.S. business, and if so, a brief
explanation of the type of access and
type of information;
(B) Membership, observer rights, or
nomination rights as set forth in
§ 800.211(b)(2), and if so, a statement as
to the composition of the board or other
body both before and after the
completion date of the transaction;
(C) Any involvement, other than
through voting shares, in substantive
decisionmaking of the U.S. business
regarding critical infrastructure, critical
technologies, or sensitive personal data
as set forth in § 800.211(b)(3);
(2) With respect to a transaction
structured as an acquisition of assets of
a U.S. business, a detailed description of
the assets of the U.S. business being
PO 00000
Frm 00029
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
50201
acquired, including the approximate
value of those assets in U.S. dollars;
(3) With respect to the U.S. business
that is the subject of the transaction and
any entity of which that U.S. business
is a parent (unless that entity is
excluded from the scope of the
transaction):
(i) Their respective business activities,
as, for example, set forth in annual
reports, and the product or service
categories of each, including an estimate
of U.S. market share for such product or
service categories and the methodology
used to determine market share, a list of
direct competitors for those primary
product or service categories, and their
NAICS Code, if any;
(ii) The street address (and mailing
address, if different) within the United
States and website address (if any) of
each facility that is manufacturing
classified or unclassified products or
producing services described in
paragraph (c)(3)(v) of this section, and
their respective CAGE Codes, their
DUNS number;
(iii) Each contract (identified by
agency and number) that is currently in
effect or was in effect within the past
five years with any agency of the U.S.
Government involving any information,
technology, or data that is classified
under Executive Order 12958, as
amended, its estimated final completion
date, and the name, office, and
telephone number of the contracting
official;
(iv) Any other contract (identified by
agency and number) that is currently in
effect or was in effect within the past
three years with any U.S. Government
agency or component with national
defense, homeland security, or other
national security responsibilities,
including law enforcement
responsibility as it relates to defense,
homeland security, or national security,
its estimated final completion date, and
the name, office, and telephone number
of the contracting official;
(v) Any products or services
(including research and development):
(A) That it supplies, directly or
indirectly, to any agency of the U.S.
Government, including as a prime
contractor or first tier subcontractor, a
supplier to any such prime contractor or
subcontractor, or, if known by the
parties filing the notice, a subcontractor
at any tier; and
(B) If known by the parties filing the
notice, for which it is a single qualified
source (i.e., other acceptable suppliers
are readily available to be so qualified)
or a sole source (i.e., no other supplier
has needed technology, equipment, and
manufacturing process capabilities) for
any such agencies and whether there are
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
50202
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
other suppliers in the market that are
available to be so qualified;
(vi) Any products or services
(including research and development)
that:
(A) It supplies to third parties and it
knows are rebranded by the purchaser
or incorporated into the products of
another entity, and the names or brands
under which such rebranded products
or services are sold; and
(B) In the case of services, it provides
on behalf of, or under the name of,
another entity, and the name of any
such entities;
(vii) For the prior three years—
(A) A list of priority rated contracts or
orders under DPAS regulation that the
U.S. business that is the subject of the
transaction has received and the level of
priority of such contracts or orders
(‘‘DX’’ or ‘‘DO’’); and
(B) A list of such priority rated
contracts or orders that the U.S.
business has placed with other entities
and the level of priority of such
contracts or orders, and the acquiring
party’s plan to ensure that any new
entity formed at the completion of the
notified transaction (or the U.S.
business, if no new entity is formed)
complies with the DPAS regulations;
(viii) A description and copy of the
cyber security plan, if any, that will be
used to protect against cyber attacks on
the operation, design, and development
of the U.S. business’s services,
networks, systems, data storage
(including the collection or
maintenance of sensitive personal data),
and facilities;
(ix) A description of whether the U.S.
business performs any of the functions,
if any, as set forth in Column 2 of
appendix A to part 800. This statement
shall include a description of such
functions, including the applicable
covered investment critical
infrastructure;
(x) A description of whether it
produces, designs, tests, manufactures,
fabricates, or develops one or more
critical technologies;
(xi) A description of whether it
maintains or collects sensitive personal
data, including:
(A) The category or categories of
sensitive personal data specified in
§ 800.241 that the U.S. business
maintains or collects or intends to
maintain or collect;
(B) For each category of sensitive
personal data, the approximate number
of total unique persons from whom the
sensitive personal data is currently
maintained or has been collected during
the previous three years, if known;
(C) A description of how the U.S.
business targets or tailors its products or
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
services to U.S. Government personnel
or contractors (as described in
§ 800.247) about whom it collects
sensitive personal data, if applicable;
(D) The commercial rationale of the
U.S. business for maintaining or
collecting such sensitive personal data
and a description of how the U.S.
business uses and protects such
sensitive personal data, including a
description of how decisions regarding
the use of sensitive personal data are
made, and by whom;
(E) A description of the U.S.
business’s policies and practices
regarding the sale, license, or transfer of,
or grant of access to, sensitive personal
data to third parties, including a copy of
any notice provided to customers
regarding the use and transfer of
sensitive personal data;
(F) A description of the U.S.
business’s policies and practices
regarding retention of sensitive personal
data; and
(G) Any plans by the foreign party to
the transaction to alter any of the
foregoing;
(4) Whether the U.S. business that is
being acquired produces or trades in:
(i) Items that are subject to the EAR
and, if so, a description (which may
group similar items into general product
categories) of the items and a list of the
relevant commodity classifications set
forth on the CCL (i.e., Export Control
Classification Numbers (ECCNs) or
EAR99 designation);
(ii) Defense articles and defense
services, and related technical data
covered by the USML in the ITAR, and,
if so, the category of the USML; articles
and services for which commodity
jurisdiction requests (22 CFR 120.4) are
pending; and articles and services
(including those under development)
that may be designated or determined in
the future to be defense articles or
defense services pursuant to 22 CFR
120.3;
(iii) Products and technology that are
subject to export authorization
administered by the Department of
Energy (10 CFR part 810), or export
licensing requirements administered by
the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (10
CFR part 110);
(iv) Select Agents and Toxins (7 CFR
part 331, 9 CFR part 121, and 42 CFR
part 73); or
(v) Emerging and foundational
technologies controlled pursuant to
section 1758 of the Export Control
Reform Act of 2018 (codified at 50
U.S.C. 4817);
(5) Whether the U.S. business that is
the subject of the transaction:
(i) Possesses any licenses, permits, or
other authorizations other than those
PO 00000
Frm 00030
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
under the regulatory authorities listed in
paragraph (c)(4) of this section that have
been granted by an agency of the U.S.
Government (if applicable,
identification of the relevant licenses
shall be provided); or
(ii) Has technology that has military
applications (if so, an identification of
such technology and a description of
such military applications shall be
included);
(6) With respect to the foreign person
engaged in the transaction and its
parents:
(i) The business or businesses of the
foreign person and its ultimate parent,
as such businesses are described, for
example, in annual reports, and the
CAGE codes, NAICS codes, and DUNS
numbers, if any, for such businesses;
(ii) The plans of the foreign person for
the U.S. business with respect to:
(A) Reducing, eliminating, or selling
research and development facilities;
(B) Changing product quality;
(C) Shutting down or moving outside
of the United States facilities that are
within the United States;
(D) Consolidating or selling product
lines or technology;
(E) Modifying or terminating contracts
referred to in paragraphs (c)(3)(iii) and
(iv) of this section; or
(F) Eliminating domestic supply by
selling products solely to non-domestic
markets;
(iii) Whether the foreign person is
controlled by or acting on behalf of a
foreign government, including without
limitation as an agent or representative,
or in some similar capacity, and if so,
the identity of the foreign government;
(iv) Whether a foreign government or
a person controlled by or acting on
behalf of a foreign government:
(A) Has or controls ownership
interests, including contingent equity
interest, of the acquiring foreign person
or any parent of the acquiring foreign
person, and if so, the nature and amount
of any such interests, and with regard to
contingent equity interest, the terms and
timing of conversion;
(B) Has the right or power to appoint
any of the principal officers or the
members of the board of directors
(including other persons who perform
the duties usually associated with such
titles) of the foreign person that is a
party to the transaction or any parent of
that foreign person;
(C) Holds any other contingent
interest (for example, such as might
arise from a lending transaction) in the
foreign acquiring party and, if so, the
rights that are covered by this
contingent interest, and the manner in
which they would be enforced; or
(D) Has any other affirmative or
negative rights or powers that could be
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
relevant to the Committee’s
determination of whether the notified
transaction is a foreign governmentcontrolled transaction, and if there are
any such rights or powers, their source
(for example, a ‘‘golden share,’’
shareholders agreement, contract,
statute, or regulation) and the
mechanics of their operation;
(v) Any formal or informal
arrangements among foreign persons
that hold an ownership interest in the
foreign person that is a party to the
transaction or between such foreign
person and other foreign persons to act
in concert on particular matters
affecting the U.S. business that is the
subject of the transaction, and provide
a copy of any documents that establish
those rights or describe those
arrangements;
(vi) For each member of the board of
directors or similar body (including
external directors and other persons
who perform the duties usually
associated with such titles) and officers
(including president, senior vice
president, executive vice president, and
other persons who perform duties
normally associated with such titles) of
the acquiring foreign person engaged in
the transaction and its immediate,
intermediate, and ultimate parents, and
for any individual having an ownership
interest of five percent or more in the
acquiring foreign person engaged in the
transaction and in the foreign person’s
ultimate parent, the following
information:
(A) A curriculum vitae or similar
professional synopsis, provided as part
of the main notice, and
(B) The following ‘‘personal identifier
information,’’ which, for privacy
reasons, and to ensure limited
distribution, shall be set forth in a
separate document, not in the main
notice:
(1) Full name (last, first, middle
name);
(2) All other names and aliases used;
(3) Business address;
(4) Country and city of residence;
(5) Date of birth, in the format MM/
DD/YYYY;
(6) Place of birth;
(7) U.S. Social Security number
(where applicable);
(8) National identity number,
including nationality, date and place of
issuance, and expiration date (where
applicable);
(9) U.S. or foreign passport number (if
more than one, all must be fully
disclosed), nationality, date and place of
issuance, and expiration date and, if a
U.S. visa holder, the visa type and
number, date and place of issuance, and
expiration date; and
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
(10) Dates and nature of foreign
government and foreign military service
(where applicable), other than military
service at a rank below the top two noncommissioned ranks of the relevant
foreign country; and
(vii) The following ‘‘business
identifier information’’ for the
immediate, intermediate, and ultimate
parents of the foreign person engaged in
the transaction, including their main
offices and branches:
(A) Business name, including all
names under which the business is
known to be or has been doing business;
(B) Business address;
(C) Business phone number, website
address, and email address; and
(D) Employer identification number or
other domestic tax or corporate
identification number.
(d) The voluntary notice shall list any
filings with, or reports to, agencies of
the U.S. Government that have been or
will be made with respect to the
transaction prior to its completion,
indicating the agencies concerned, the
nature of the filing or report, the date on
which it was filed or the estimated date
by which it will be filed, and a relevant
contact point and/or telephone number
within the agency, if known.
(1) Example: Corporation A, a foreign
person, intends to acquire Corporation
X, which is wholly owned and
controlled by a U.S. national and which
has a Facility Security Clearance under
the Department of Defense Industrial
Security Program. See Department of
Defense, ‘‘Industrial Security
Regulation,’’ DOD 5220.22–R, and
‘‘Industrial Security Manual for
Safeguarding Classified Information,’’
DOD 5220.22–M. Corporation X
accordingly files a revised Form DD SF–
328, and enters into discussions with
the Defense Security Service about
effectively insulating its facilities from
the foreign person. Corporation X may
also have made filings with the U.S.
Securities and Exchange Commission,
the Department of Commerce, the
Department of State, or other federal
departments and agencies. Paragraph (d)
of this section requires that certain
specific information about these filings
be reported to the Committee in a
voluntary notice.
(e) In the case of the establishment of
a joint venture in which one or more of
the parties is contributing a U.S.
business, information for the voluntary
notice shall be prepared on the
assumption that the foreign person that
is party to the joint venture has made an
acquisition of the existing U.S. business
that the other party to the joint venture
is contributing or transferring to the
joint venture. The voluntary notice shall
PO 00000
Frm 00031
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
50203
describe the name and address of the
joint venture and the entities that
established, or are establishing, the joint
venture.
(f) In the case of the acquisition of
some but not all of the assets of an
entity, paragraph (c) of this section
requires submission of the specified
information only with respect to the
assets of the entity that have been or are
proposed to be acquired.
(g) Persons filing a voluntary notice
shall, with respect to the foreign person
that is a party to the transaction, its
immediate parent, the U.S. business that
is the subject of the transaction, and
each entity of which the foreign person
is a parent, append to the voluntary
notice the most recent annual report of
each such entity, in English. Separate
reports are not required for any entity
whose financial results are included
within the consolidated financial results
stated in the annual report of any parent
of any such entity, unless the
transaction involves the acquisition of a
U.S. business whose parent is not being
acquired, in which case the notice shall
include the most recent audited
financial statement of the U.S. business
that is the subject of the transaction. If
a U.S. business does not prepare an
annual report and its financial results
are not included within the
consolidated financial results stated in
the annual report of a parent, the filing
shall include, if available, the entity’s
most recent audited financial statement
(or, if an audited financial statement is
not available, the unaudited financial
statement).
(h) Persons filing a voluntary notice
shall, during the time that the matter is
pending before the Committee or the
President, promptly advise the Staff
Chairperson of any material changes in
plans, facts and circumstances
addressed in the notice, and information
provided or required to be provided to
the Committee under this section, and
shall file amendments to the notice to
reflect such material changes. Such
amendments shall become part of the
notice filed by such persons under
§ 800.501, and the certifications
required under paragraphs (l) and (m) of
this section shall apply to such
amendments.
(i) Persons filing a voluntary notice
shall include a copy of the most recent
asset or stock purchase agreement or
other document establishing the agreed
terms of the transaction.
(j) Persons filing a voluntary notice
shall include:
(1) Complete organizational charts,
both pre- and post-transaction,
including without limitation,
information that identifies the name,
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
50204
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
principal place of business and place of
incorporation or other legal organization
(for entities), nationality (for
individuals), and ownership percentage
(expressed in terms of both voting and
economic interest, if different) for each
of the following:
(i) The immediate parent, the ultimate
parent, and each intermediate parent, if
any, of each foreign person that is a
party to the transaction;
(ii) Where the ultimate parent is a
private company, the ultimate owner(s)
of such parent;
(iii) Where the ultimate parent is a
public company, any shareholder with
an interest of greater than five percent
in such parent; and
(iv) The U.S. business that is the
subject of the transaction, both before
and after completion of the transaction;
and
(2) The opinion of the person
regarding whether:
(i) It is a foreign person;
(ii) It is controlled by a foreign
government;
(iii) A foreign government holds a
substantial interest in the foreign person
that is party to the transaction; and
(iv) The transaction has resulted or
could result in a covered control
transaction or a covered investment, and
the reasons for its view, focusing in
particular on any powers (for example,
by virtue of a shareholders agreement,
contract, statute, or regulation) that the
foreign person will have with regard to
the U.S. business, and how those
powers can or will be exercised, or any
other access, rights, or involvement the
foreign person will have in a U.S.
business with respect to critical
technologies, critical infrastructure, or
sensitive personal data.
(k) Persons filing a voluntary notice
shall include information as to whether:
(1) Any party to the transaction is, or
has been, a party to a mitigation
agreement entered into or condition
imposed under section 721, and if so,
shall specify the date and purpose of
such agreement or condition and the
U.S. Government signatories; and
(2) Any party to the transaction
(including such party’s parents,
subsidiaries, or entities under common
control with the party) has been a party
to a transaction previously notified to
the Committee.
(l) Each party filing a voluntary notice
shall provide a certification of the notice
consistent with § 800.204. A sample
certification may be found on the
Committee’s section of the Department
of the Treasury website, currently
available at https://home.treasury.gov/
policy-issues/international/the-
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
committee-on-foreign-investment-in-theunited-states-cfius.
(m) At the conclusion of a review or
investigation, each party that has filed
additional information subsequent to
the original notice shall file a final
certification. (See § 800.204.) A sample
certification may be found at the
Committee’s section of the Department
of the Treasury website, currently
available at https://home.treasury.gov/
policy-issues/international/thecommittee-on-foreign-investment-in-theunited-states-cfius.
(n) Parties filing a voluntary notice
shall include with the notice a list
identifying each document provided as
part of the notice, including all
documents provided as attachments or
exhibits to the narrative response.
(o) A party filing a voluntary notice
may stipulate that the transaction is a
covered transaction and, if the party
stipulates that the transaction is a
covered transaction, that the transaction
is a foreign government-controlled
transaction. A stipulation offered by any
party pursuant to this section must be
accompanied by a detailed description
of the basis for the stipulation. The
required description of the basis shall
include, but is not limited to, discussion
of all relevant information responsive to
paragraphs (c)(6)(iii) through (v) of this
section. A party that offers such a
stipulation acknowledges that the
Committee and the President are
entitled to rely on such stipulation in
determining whether the transaction is
a covered transaction, a foreign
government-controlled transaction, and/
or subject to mandatory declaration or
notice for the purposes of section 721
and all authorities thereunder, and
waives the right to challenge any such
determination. Neither the Committee
nor the President is bound by any such
stipulation, nor does any such
stipulation limit the ability of the
Committee or the President to act on
any authority provided under section
721 with respect to any covered
transaction.
§ 800.503
period.
Beginning of a 45-day review
(a) The Staff Chairperson of the
Committee shall accept a voluntary
notice the next business day after the
Staff Chairperson has:
(1) Determined that the notice
complies with § 800.502; and
(2) Disseminated the notice to all
members of the Committee.
(b) A 45-day period for review of a
transaction shall commence on the date
on which the voluntary notice has been
accepted, agency notice has been
received by the Staff Chairperson of the
PO 00000
Frm 00032
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
Committee, or the Chairperson of the
Committee has requested a notice
pursuant to § 800.501(b). Such review
shall end no later than the forty-fifth
day after it has commenced, or if the
forty-fifth day is not a business day, no
later than the next business day after the
forty-fifth day.
(c) The Staff Chairperson shall
promptly advise in writing all parties to
a transaction that have filed a voluntary
notice of:
(1) The acceptance of the notice;
(2) The date on which the review
begins; and
(3) The designation of any lead agency
or agencies.
(d) Within two business days after
receipt of an agency notice by the Staff
Chairperson, the Staff Chairperson shall
send written advice of such notice to the
parties to the transaction that is subject
to the notice. Such written advice shall
identify the date on which the review
began.
(e) The Staff Chairperson shall
promptly circulate to all Committee
members any draft pre-filing notice, any
agency notice, any complete notice, and
any subsequent information filed by the
parties.
§ 800.504 Deferral, rejection, or disposition
of certain voluntary notices.
(a) The Committee, acting through the
Staff Chairperson, may:
(1) Reject any voluntary notice that
does not comply with § 800.501 or
§ 800.502 and so inform the parties
promptly in writing;
(2) Reject any voluntary notice at any
time, and so inform the parties promptly
in writing, if, after the notice has been
submitted and before action by the
Committee or the President has been
concluded:
(i) There is a material change in the
transaction as to which notification has
been made; or
(ii) Information comes to light that
contradicts material information
provided in the notice by the parties;
(3) Reject any voluntary notice at any
time after the notice has been accepted,
and so inform the parties promptly in
writing, if the party or parties that have
submitted the voluntary notice do not
provide follow-up information
requested by the Staff Chairperson
within three business days of the
request, or within a longer time frame if
the parties so request in writing and the
Staff Chairperson grants that request in
writing; or
(4) Reject any voluntary notice before
the conclusion of a review or
investigation, and so inform the parties
promptly in writing, if one of the parties
submitting the voluntary notice has not
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
submitted the final certification
required by § 800.502(m).
(b) Notwithstanding the authority of
the Staff Chairperson under paragraph
(a) of this section to reject an incomplete
notice, the Staff Chairperson may defer
acceptance of the notice, and the
beginning of the review period specified
by § 800.503, to obtain any information
required under this section that has not
been submitted by the notifying party or
parties or other parties to the
transaction. Where necessary to obtain
such information, the Staff Chairperson
may inform any non-notifying party or
parties that notice has been filed with
respect to a proposed transaction
involving the party, and request that
certain information required under this
section, as specified by the Staff
Chairperson, be provided to the
Committee within seven days after
receipt of the Staff Chairperson’s
request.
(c) The Staff Chairperson shall notify
the parties when the Committee has
found that the transaction that is the
subject of a voluntary notice is not a
covered transaction.
(d) Examples:
(1) Example 1. The Staff Chairperson
receives a joint notice from Corporation A, a
foreign person, and Corporation X, a
company that is owned and controlled by
U.S. nationals, with respect to Corporation
A’s intent to purchase all of the shares of
Corporation X. The joint notice does not
contain any information described under
§ 800.502 concerning classified materials and
products or services supplied to the U.S.
military services. The Staff Chairperson may
reject the notice or defer the start of the
review period until the parties have supplied
the omitted information.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as in the first
sentence of Example 1 of this section, except
that the joint notice indicates that
Corporation A does not intend to purchase
Corporation X’s Division Y, which is engaged
in classified work for a U.S. Government
agency. Corporations A and X notify the
Committee on the 40th day of the 45-day
notice period that Division Y will also be
acquired by Corporation A. This fact
constitutes a material change with respect to
the transaction as originally notified, and the
Staff Chairperson may reject the notice.
(3) Example 3. The Staff Chairperson
receives a joint notice by Corporation A, a
foreign person, and Corporation X, a U.S.
business, indicating that Corporation A
intends to purchase five percent of the voting
securities of Corporation X. Under the
particular facts and circumstances presented,
the Committee concludes that Corporation
A’s purchase of this interest in Corporation
X could not result in a covered investment
in or foreign control of Corporation X. The
Staff Chairperson shall advise the parties in
writing that the transaction as presented is
not subject to section 721.
(4) Example 4. The Staff Chairperson
receives a voluntary notice involving the
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
acquisition by Company A, a foreign person,
of the entire interest in Company X, a U.S.
business. The notice mentions the
involvement of a second foreign person in
the transaction, Company B, but states that
Company B is merely a passive investor in
the transaction. During the course of the
review, the parties provide information that
clarifies that Company B has the right to
appoint two members of Company X’s board
of directors. This information contradicts the
material assertion in the notice that Company
B is a passive investor. The Committee may
reject this notice without concluding review
under section 721.
§ 800.505 Determination of whether to
undertake an investigation.
(a) After a review of a notified
transaction under § 800.503, the
Committee shall undertake an
investigation of any transaction that it
has determined to be a covered
transaction if:
(1) A member of the Committee (other
than a member designated as ex officio
under section 721(k)) advises the Staff
Chairperson that the member believes
that the transaction threatens to impair
the national security of the United
States and that the threat has not been
mitigated; or
(2) The lead agency recommends, and
the Committee concurs, that an
investigation be undertaken.
(b) The Committee shall also
undertake, after a review of a covered
transaction under § 800.503, an
investigation to determine the effects on
national security of any covered
transaction that:
(1) Is a foreign government-controlled
transaction; or
(2) Would result in control by a
foreign person of critical infrastructure
of or within the United States, if the
Committee determines that the
transaction could impair the national
security and such impairment has not
been mitigated.
(c) The Committee shall undertake an
investigation as described in paragraph
(b) of this section unless the
Chairperson of the Committee (or the
Deputy Secretary of the Treasury) and
the head of any lead agency (or his or
her delegee at the deputy level or
equivalent) designated by the
Chairperson determine on the basis of
the review that the covered transaction
will not impair the national security of
the United States.
§ 800.506 Determination not to undertake
an investigation.
If the Committee determines, during
the review period described in
§ 800.503, not to undertake an
investigation of a notified covered
transaction, action under section 721
shall be concluded. An official at the
PO 00000
Frm 00033
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
50205
Department of the Treasury shall
promptly inform the parties to a covered
transaction in writing of a determination
of the Committee not to undertake an
investigation and to conclude action
under section 721.
§ 800.507 Commencement of
investigation.
(a) If it is determined that an
investigation should be undertaken,
such investigation shall commence no
later than the end of the review period
described in § 800.503.
(b) An official of the Department of
the Treasury shall promptly inform the
parties to a covered transaction in
writing of the commencement of an
investigation.
§ 800.508 Completion or termination of
investigation and report to the President.
(a) Subject to paragraph (e) of this
section, the Committee shall complete
an investigation no later than the fortyfifth day after the date the investigation
commences, or, if the forty-fifth day is
not a business day, no later than the
next business day after the forty-fifth
day.
(b) Upon completion or termination of
any investigation, the Committee shall
send a report to the President requesting
the President’s decision if:
(1) The Committee recommends that
the President suspend or prohibit the
transaction;
(2) The Committee is unable to reach
a decision on whether to recommend
that the President suspend or prohibit
the transaction; or
(3) The Committee requests that the
President make a determination with
regard to the transaction.
(c) In circumstances when the
Committee sends a report to the
President requesting the President’s
decision with respect to a covered
transaction, such report shall include
information relevant to sections
721(d)(4)(A) and (B), and shall present
the Committee’s recommendation. If the
Committee is unable to reach a decision
to present a single recommendation to
the President, the Chairperson of the
Committee shall submit a report of the
Committee to the President setting forth
the differing views and presenting the
issues for decision.
(d) Upon completion or termination of
an investigation, if the Committee
determines to conclude all deliberative
action under section 721 with regard to
a notified covered transaction without
sending a report to the President, action
under section 721 shall be concluded.
An official at the Department of the
Treasury shall promptly advise the
parties to such a transaction in writing
of a determination to conclude action.
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
50206
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
(e) In extraordinary circumstances,
the Chairperson may, upon a written
request signed by the head of a lead
agency, extend an investigation for one
15-day period. A request to extend an
investigation must describe, with
particularity, the extraordinary
circumstances that warrant the
Chairperson extending the investigation.
The authority of the head of a lead
agency to request the extension of an
investigation may not be delegated to
any person other than the deputy head
(or equivalent thereof) of the lead
agency. If the Chairperson extends an
investigation pursuant to this paragraph
with respect to a covered transaction,
the Committee shall promptly notify the
parties to the transaction of the
extension.
(f) For purposes of paragraph (e) of
this section, ‘‘extraordinary
circumstances’’ means circumstances
for which extending an investigation is
necessary and the appropriate course of
action due to a force majeure event or
to protect the national security of the
United States.
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
§ 800.509
Withdrawal of notices.
(a) A party (or parties) to a transaction
that has filed notice under § 800.501(a)
may request in writing, at any time prior
to conclusion of all action under section
721, that such notice be withdrawn.
Such request shall be directed to the
Staff Chairperson and shall state the
reasons why the request is being made.
Such requests will ordinarily be
granted, unless otherwise determined by
the Committee. An official of the
Department of the Treasury will
promptly advise the parties to the
transaction in writing of the
Committee’s decision.
(b) Any request to withdraw an
agency notice by the agency that filed it
shall be in writing and shall be effective
only upon approval by the Committee.
An official of the Department of the
Treasury shall advise the parties to the
transaction in writing of the
Committee’s decision to approve the
withdrawal request within two business
days of the Committee’s decision.
(c) In any case where a request to
withdraw a notice is granted under
paragraph (a) of this section:
(1) The Staff Chairperson, in
consultation with the Committee, shall
establish, as appropriate:
(i) A process for tracking actions that
may be taken by any party to the
covered transaction before notice is
refiled under § 800.501; and
(ii) Interim protections to address
specific national security concerns with
the transaction identified during the
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
review or investigation of the
transaction.
(2) The Staff Chairperson shall specify
a time frame, as appropriate, for the
parties to resubmit a notice and shall
advise the parties of that time frame in
writing.
(d) A notice of a transaction that is
submitted pursuant to paragraph (c)(2)
of this section shall be deemed a new
notice for purposes of the regulations in
this part, including § 800.701.
Subpart F—Committee Procedures
§ 800.601
General.
(a) In any assessment, review, or
investigation of a covered transaction,
the Committee should consider the
factors specified in section 721(f) and,
as appropriate, require parties to
provide to the Committee the
information necessary to consider such
factors. The Committee’s assessment,
review, or investigation (if necessary)
shall examine, as appropriate, whether:
(1) The transaction is a covered
transaction;
(2) There is credible evidence to
support a belief that any foreign person
party to a covered transaction might
take action that threatens to impair the
national security of the United States;
and
(3) Provisions of law, other than
section 721 and the International
Emergency Economic Powers Act,
provide adequate and appropriate
authority to protect the national security
of the United States.
(b) During an assessment, review, or
investigation, the Staff Chairperson may
invite the parties to a notified
transaction to attend a meeting with the
Committee staff to discuss and clarify
issues pertaining to the transaction.
During an investigation, a party to the
transaction under investigation may
request a meeting with the Committee
staff; such a request ordinarily will be
granted.
(c) The Staff Chairperson shall be the
point of contact for receiving material
filed with the Committee, including
notices.
(d) Where more than one lead agency
is designated, communications on
material matters between a party to the
transaction and a lead agency shall
include all lead agencies designated
with regard to those matters.
(e) The parties’ description of a
transaction in a declaration or notice
does not limit the ability of the
Committee to, as appropriate, assess,
review, or investigate, or exercise any
other authorities available under section
721 with respect to any covered
transaction that the Committee
PO 00000
Frm 00034
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
identifies as having been notified to the
Committee based upon the facts set
forth in the declaration or notice, any
additional information provided to the
Committee subsequent to the original
declaration or notice, or any other
information available to the Committee.
§ 800.602
Role of the Secretary of Labor.
In response to a request from the
Chairperson of the Committee, the
Secretary of Labor shall identify for the
Committee any risk mitigation
provisions proposed to or by the
Committee that would violate U.S.
employment laws or require a party to
violate U.S. employment laws. The
Secretary of Labor shall serve no policy
role on the Committee.
§ 800.603
Materiality.
The Committee generally will not
consider as material minor inaccuracies,
omissions, or changes relating to
financial or commercial factors not
having a bearing on national security.
§ 800.604 Tolling of deadlines during lapse
in appropriations.
Any deadline or time limitation under
subparts D or E imposed on the
Committee shall be tolled during a lapse
in appropriations.
Subpart G—Finality of Action
§ 800.701
721.
Finality of actions under section
(a) All authority available to the
President or the Committee under
section 721(d), including without
limitation divestment authority, shall
remain available at the discretion of the
President with respect to:
(1) Covered control transactions
proposed or pending on or after August
23, 1988;
(2) Transactions that, between
November 10, 2018, and [EFFECTIVE
DATE], fell within the scope of part 801
of this title; and
(3) Covered investments proposed or
pending after the effective date.
(b) Subject to § 800.501(c)(1)(ii), such
authority shall not be exercised if:
(1) The Committee, through its Staff
Chairperson, has advised a party (or the
parties) in writing that a particular
transaction with respect to which a
voluntary notice or a declaration has
been filed is not a covered transaction;
(2) The parties to the transaction have
been advised in writing pursuant to
§ 800.407(a)(4), § 800.506, or
§ 800.508(d) that the Committee has
concluded all action under section 721
with respect to the covered transaction;
or
(3) The President has previously
announced, pursuant to section 721(d),
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
his decision not to exercise his authority
under section 721 with respect to the
covered transaction.
(c) Divestment or other relief under
section 721 shall not be available with
respect to transactions that were
completed prior to August 23, 1988.
Subpart H—Provision and Handling of
Information
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
§ 800.801 Obligation of parties to provide
information.
(a) Parties to a transaction that is
notified or declared under subparts D or
E, or a transaction for which no notice
or declaration has been submitted and
for which the Staff Chairperson has
requested information to assess whether
the transaction is a covered transaction,
shall provide information to the Staff
Chairperson that will enable the
Committee to conduct a full assessment,
review, and/or investigation of the
proposed transaction, and shall
promptly advise the Staff Chairperson of
any material changes in plans or
information pursuant to § 800.403(d) or
§ 800.502(h). If deemed necessary by the
Committee, information may be
obtained from parties to a transaction or
other persons through subpoena or
otherwise, pursuant to the Defense
Production Act Reauthorization of 2003,
as amended, Public Law 108–195 (50
U.S.C. 4555(a)).
(b) Documentary materials or
information required or requested to be
filed with the Committee under this part
shall be submitted in English.
Supplementary materials, such as
annual reports, written in a foreign
language, shall be submitted in certified
English translation.
(c) Any information filed with the
Committee in connection with any
action for which a report is required
pursuant to section 721(l)(3)(B) with
respect to the implementation of a
mitigation agreement or condition
described in section 721(l)(1)(A) shall be
accompanied by a certification that
complies with the requirements of
section 721(n) and § 800.204. A sample
certification may be found at the
Committee’s section of the Department
of the Treasury website, currently
available at https://home.treasury.gov/
policy-issues/international/thecommittee-on-foreign-investment-in-theunited-states-cfius.
§ 800.802
Confidentiality.
(a) Except as provided in paragraph
(b) of this section, any information or
documentary material submitted or filed
with the Committee pursuant to this
part, including information or
documentary material filed pursuant to
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
§ 800.501(g) shall be exempt from
disclosure under the Freedom of
Information Act, as amended (5 U.S.C.
552, et seq.), and no such information or
documentary material may be made
public.
(b) Paragraph (a) of this section shall
not prohibit disclosure of the following:
(1) Information relevant to any
administrative or judicial action or
proceeding;
(2) Information to Congress or to any
duly authorized committee or
subcommittee of Congress;
(3) Information important to the
national security analysis or actions of
the Committee to any domestic
governmental entity, or to any foreign
governmental entity of a United States
ally or partner, under the exclusive
direction and authorization of the
Chairperson, only to the extent
necessary for national security
purposes, and subject to appropriate
confidentiality and classification
requirements; or
(4) Information that the parties have
consented to be disclosed to third
parties.
(c) This section shall continue to
apply with respect to information and
documentary material submitted or filed
with the Committee in any case where:
(1) Action has concluded under
section 721 concerning a notified
transaction;
(2) A request to withdraw a notice or
a declaration is granted under § 800.509
or § 800.406(c), respectively, or where a
notice or a declaration has been rejected
under § 800.504(a) or § 800.406(a),
respectively;
(3) The Committee determines that a
notified or declared transaction is not a
covered transaction; or
(4) Such information or documentary
material was filed pursuant to subpart D
and the parties do not subsequently file
a notice pursuant to subpart E.
(d) Nothing in paragraph (a) of this
section shall be interpreted to prohibit
the public disclosure by a party of
documentary material or information
that it has submitted or filed with the
Committee. Any such documentary
material or information so disclosed
may subsequently be reflected in the
public statements of the Chairperson,
who is authorized to communicate with
the public and the Congress on behalf of
the Committee, or of the Chairperson’s
designee.
(e) The provisions of the Defense
Production Act Reauthorization of 2003,
as amended (50 U.S.C. 4555(d)) relating
to fines and imprisonment shall apply
with respect to the disclosure of
information or documentary material
PO 00000
Frm 00035
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
50207
filed with the Committee under these
regulations.
Subpart I—Penalties and Damages
§ 800.901
Penalties and damages.
(a) Any person who submits a
material misstatement or omission in a
declaration or notice, or makes a false
certification under § 800.404, § 800.405,
or § 800.502 may be liable to the United
States for a civil penalty not to exceed
$250,000 per violation. The amount of
the penalty imposed for a violation shall
be based on the nature of the violation.
(b) Any person who fails to comply
with the requirements of § 800.401 may
be liable to the United States for a civil
penalty not to exceed $250,000 per
violation or the value of the transaction,
whichever is greater. The amount of the
penalty imposed for a violation shall be
based on the nature of the violation.
(c) Any person who, after October 11,
2018, violates, intentionally or through
gross negligence, a material provision of
a mitigation agreement entered into
before October 11, 2018 with, a material
condition imposed before October 11,
2018 by, or an order issued before
October 11, 2018 by, the United States
under section 721(l) may be liable to the
United States for a civil penalty not to
exceed $250,000 per violation or the
value of the transaction, whichever is
greater. Any person who violates a
material provision of a mitigation
agreement entered into on or after
October 11, 2018 with, a material
condition imposed on or after October
11, 2018 by, or an order issued on or
after October 11, 2018 by, the United
States under section 721(l) may be liable
to the United States for a civil penalty
not to exceed $250,000 per violation or
the value of the transaction, whichever
is greater. The amount of the penalty
imposed for a violation shall be based
on the nature of the violation.
(d) A mitigation agreement entered
into or amended under section 721(l)
after December 22, 2008, may include a
provision providing for liquidated or
actual damages for breaches of the
agreement. The Committee shall set the
amount of any liquidated damages as a
reasonable assessment of the harm to
the national security that could result
from a breach of the agreement. Any
mitigation agreement containing a
liquidated damages provision shall
include a provision specifying that the
Committee will consider the severity of
the breach in deciding whether to seek
a lesser amount than that stipulated in
the agreement.
(e) A determination to impose
penalties under paragraphs (a) through
(c) of this section must be made by the
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
50208
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
Committee. Notice of the penalty,
including a written explanation of the
penalized conduct and the amount of
the penalty, shall be sent to the
penalized party electronically and by
U.S. mail.
(f) Upon receiving notice of the
imposition of a penalty under
paragraphs (a) through (c) of this
section, the penalized party may, within
15 days of receipt of the notice of the
penalty, submit a petition for
reconsideration to the Staff Chairperson,
including a defense, justification, or
explanation for the penalized conduct.
The Committee will review the petition
and issue a final decision within 15
days of receipt of the petition.
(g) The penalties and damages
authorized in paragraphs (a) through (d)
of this section may be recovered in a
civil action brought by the United States
in federal district court.
(h) Section 2 of the False Statements
Accountability Act of 1996, as amended
(18 U.S.C. 1001), shall apply to all
information provided to the Committee
under section 721, including by any
party to a covered transaction.
(i) The penalties and damages
available under this section are without
prejudice to other penalties, civil or
criminal, available under law.
(j) The imposition of a civil monetary
penalty or damages pursuant to these
regulations creates a debt due to the
U.S. Government. The Department of
the Treasury may take action to collect
the penalty or damages assessed if not
paid within the time prescribed by the
Committee and notified to the
applicable party or parties. In addition
or instead, the matter may be referred to
the Department of Justice for
appropriate action to recover the
penalty or damages.
§ 800.902
Effect of lack of compliance.
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
(a) If, at any time after a mitigation
agreement or condition is entered into
or imposed under section 721(l), the
Committee or a lead agency in
coordination with the Staff Chairperson,
as the case may be, determines that a
party or parties to the agreement or
condition are not in compliance with
the terms of the agreement or condition,
the Committee or a lead agency, in
coordination with the Staff Chairperson
may, in addition to the authority of the
Committee to impose penalties pursuant
to section 721(h) and to unilaterally
initiate a review of any covered
transaction pursuant to section
721(b)(1)(D)(iii):
(1) Negotiate a plan of action for the
party or parties to remediate the lack of
compliance, with failure to abide by the
plan or otherwise remediate the lack of
compliance serving as the basis for the
Committee to find a material breach of
the agreement or condition;
(2) Require that the party or parties
submit a written notice or declaration
under clause (i) of section 721(b)(1)(C)
with respect to a covered transaction
initiated after the date of the
determination of noncompliance and
before the date that is five years after the
date of the determination to the
Committee to initiate a review of the
transaction under section 721(b); or
(3) Seek injunctive relief.
Subpart J—Foreign National Security
Investment Review Regimes
§ 800.1001
Determinations.
(a) The Chairperson of the Committee,
with the agreement of two-thirds of the
voting members of the Committee, may
determine at any time that a foreign
state has established and is effectively
utilizing a robust process to analyze
foreign investments for national security
risks and to facilitate coordination with
the United States on matters relating to
investment security.
(b) The Chairperson of the Committee
may rescind a determination under
paragraph (a) of this section if the
Chairperson of the Committee
determines, with the agreement of twothirds of the voting members of the
Committee, that such a rescission is
appropriate.
(c) The Chairperson of the Committee
shall publish a notice of any
determination or rescission of a
determination under paragraph (a) or (b)
of this section, respectively, in the
Federal Register.
§ 800.1002
Effect of determinations.
(a) A determination under
§ 800.1001(a) shall take effect
immediately upon publication of a
notice of such determination under
§ 800.1001(c) and remain in effect
unless rescinded pursuant to paragraph
(b) of this section.
(b) A rescission of a determination
under § 800.1001(b) shall take effect on
the date specified in the notice
published under § 800.1001(c).
(c) A determination under
§ 800.1001(a) does not apply to any
transaction for which a declaration or
notice has been accepted by the Staff
Chairperson pursuant to § 800.405(a)(1)
or § 800.503(a), respectively.
(d) A rescission of a determination
under § 800.1001(b) does not apply to
any transaction for which:
(1) The completion date is prior to the
date upon which the rescission of a
determination under paragraph (b) of
this section becomes effective; or
(2) The following has occurred before
publication of the rescission of
determination under § 800.1001(c):
(i) The parties to the transaction have
executed a binding written agreement,
or other binding document, establishing
the material terms of the transaction that
is ultimately consummated;
(ii) A party has made a public offer to
shareholders to buy shares of a U.S.
business; or
(iii) A shareholder has solicited
proxies in connection with an election
of the board of directors of a U.S.
business or has requested the
conversion of convertible voting
securities.
Appendix A to Part 800—Covered
Investment Critical Infrastructure and
Functions Related to Covered
Investment Critical Infrastructure
Column 1—Covered investment critical
infrastructure
Column 2—Functions related to covered
investment critical infrastructure
(i) Any:
(a) internet protocol network that has access to every other internet
protocol network solely via settlement-free peering; or
(b) telecommunications service or information service, each as defined
in section 3(a)(2) of the Communications Act of 1934 (47 U.S.C.
153), as amended, or fiber optic cable that directly serves any military installation identified in § 802.229.
(ii) Any internet exchange point that supports public peering.
(i) Own or operate any:
(a) internet protocol network that has access to every other internet
protocol network solely via settlement-free peering; or
(b) telecommunications service or information service, each as defined
in section 3(a)(2) of the Communications Act of 1934 (47 U.S.C.
153), as amended, or fiber optic cable that directly serves any military installation identified in § 802.229.
(ii) Own or operate any internet exchange point that supports public
peering.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
PO 00000
Frm 00036
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
Column 1—Covered investment critical
infrastructure
Column 2—Functions related to covered
investment critical infrastructure
(iii) Any submarine cable system requiring a license pursuant to section
1 of the Cable Landing Licensing Act of 1921 (47 U.S.C. 34), as
amended, which includes any associated submarine cable, submarine cable landing facilities, and any facility that performs network
management, monitoring, maintenance, or other operational functions for such submarine cable system.
(iv) Any submarine cable, landing facility, or facility that performs network management, monitoring, maintenance, or other operational
function that is part of a submarine cable system described above in
item (iii) of Column 1 of appendix A to part 800.
(v) Any data center that is collocated at a submarine cable landing
point, landing station, or termination station.
(vi) Any satellite or satellite system providing services directly to the
Department of Defense or any component thereof.
(vii) Any industrial resource other than commercially available off-theshelf items, as defined in section 4203(a) of the National Defense
Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 1996 (41 U.S.C. 104), as amended,
that is manufactured or operated for a Major Defense Acquisition
Program, as defined in section 7(b)(2)(A) of the Defense Technical
Corrections Act of 1987 (10 U.S.C. 2430), as amended, or a Major
System, as defined in 10 U.S.C. 2302d, as amended and:
(iii) Own or operate any submarine cable system requiring a license
pursuant to section 1 of the Cable Landing Licensing Act of 1921 (47
U.S.C. 34), as amended, which includes any associated submarine
cable, submarine cable landing facilities, and any facility that performs network management, monitoring, maintenance, or other operational functions for such submarine cable system.
(iv) Supply or service any submarine cable, landing facility, or facility
that performs network management, monitoring, maintenance, or
other operational function that is part of a submarine cable system
described above in item (iii) of Column 1 of appendix A to part 800.
(v) Own or operate any data center that is collocated at a submarine
cable landing point, landing station, or termination station.
(vi) Own or operate any satellite or satellite system providing services
directly to the Department of Defense or any component thereof.
(vii) As applicable, manufacture any industrial resource other than commercially available off-the-shelf items, as defined in section 4203(a)
of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 1996 (41
U.S.C. 104), as amended, or operate any industrial resource that is
a facility, in each case, for a Major Defense Acquisition Program, as
defined in section 7(b)(2)(A) of the Defense Technical Corrections
Act of 1987 (10 U.S.C. 2430), as amended, or a Major System, as
defined in 10 U.S.C. 2302d, as amended and:
(a) the U.S. business is a ‘‘single source,’’ ‘‘sole source,’’ or ‘‘strategic
multisource,’’ to the extent the U.S. business has been notified of
such status; or
(b) the industrial resource:
(1) requires 12 months or more to manufacture; or
(2) is a ‘‘long lead’’ item, to the extent the U.S. business has been notified that such industrial resource is a ‘‘long lead’’ item.
(viii) Manufacture any industrial resource, other than commercially
available off-the-shelf items, as defined in section 4203(a) of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 1996 (41 U.S.C.
104), as amended, pursuant to a ‘‘DX’’ priority rated contract or order
under the Defense Priorities and Allocations System regulation (15
CFR part 700, as amended) within 24 months of the transaction in
question.
(ix) Manufacture any of the following in the United States:
(a) specialty metal, as defined in section 842(a)(1)(i) of the John Warner National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2007 (10
U.S.C. 2533b), as amended;
(b) covered material, as defined in 10 U.S.C. 2533c, as amended;
(c) chemical weapons antidote contained in automatic injectors, as described in 10 U.S.C. 2534, as amended; or
(d) carbon, alloy, and armor steel plate that is in Federal Supply Class
9515 or is described by specifications of the American Society for
Testing Materials or the American Iron and Steel Institute.
(x) As applicable, manufacture any industrial resource other than commercially available off-the-shelf items, as defined in 41 U.S.C. 104,
as amended, or operate any industrial resource that is a facility, in
each case, that has been funded, in whole or in part, by any of the
following sources within 60 months of the transaction in question:
(a) Defense Production Act of 1950 Title III program (50 U.S.C. 4501,
et seq.), as amended;
(b) Industrial Base Fund pursuant to section 896(b)(1) of the Ike Skelton National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2011 (10
U.S.C. 2508), as amended;
(c) Rapid Innovation Fund pursuant to section 1073 of Ike Skelton National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2011 (10 U.S.C.
2359a), as amended;
(d) Manufacturing Technology Program pursuant to 10 U.S.C. 2521, as
amended;
(e) Defense Logistics Agency Warstopper Program, as described in
DLA Instruction 1212, Industrial Capabilities Program—Manage the
WarStopper Program; or
(f) Defense Logistics Agency Surge and Sustainment contract, as described in Subpart 17.93 of the Defense Logistics Acquisition Directive.
(xi) Own or operate any system, including facilities, for the generation,
transmission, distribution, or storage of electric energy comprising
the bulk-power system, as defined in section 215(a)(1) of the Federal
Power Act (16 U.S.C. 824o(a)(1)), as amended.
(a) the U.S. business is a ‘‘single source,’’ ‘‘sole source,’’ or ‘‘strategic
multisource,’’ to the extent the U.S. business has been notified of
such status; or
(b) the industrial resource:
(1) requires 12 months or more to manufacture; or
(2) is a ‘‘long lead’’ item, to the extent the U.S. business has been notified that such industrial resource is a ‘‘long lead’’ item.
(viii) Any industrial resource, other than commercially available off-theshelf items, as defined in section 4203(a) of the National Defense
Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 1996 (41 U.S.C. 104), as amended,
that is manufactured pursuant to a ‘‘DX’’ priority rated contract or
order under the Defense Priorities and Allocations System regulation
(15 CFR part 700, as amended) in the preceding 24 months.
(ix) Any facility in the United States that manufactures:
(a) specialty metal, as defined in section 842(a)(1)(i) of the John Warner National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2007 (10
U.S.C. 2533b), as amended;
(b) covered material, as defined in 10 U.S.C. 2533c, as amended;
(c) chemical weapons antidote contained in automatic injectors, as described in 10 U.S.C. 2534, as amended; or
(d) carbon, alloy, and armor steel plate that is in Federal Supply Class
9515 or is described by specifications of the American Society for
Testing Materials or the American Iron and Steel Institute.
(x) Any industrial resource other than commercially available off-theshelf items, as defined in 41 U.S.C. 104, as amended, that has been
funded, in whole or in part, by any of the following sources in the last
60 months:
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
50209
(a) Defense Production Act of 1950 Title III program (50 U.S.C. 4501,
et seq.), as amended;
(b) Industrial Base Fund pursuant to section 896(b)(1) of the Ike Skelton National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2011 (10
U.S.C. 2508), as amended;
(c) Rapid Innovation Fund pursuant to section 1073 of Ike Skelton National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2011 (10 U.S.C.
2359a), as amended;
(d) Manufacturing Technology Program pursuant to 10 U.S.C. 2521, as
amended;
(e) Defense Logistics Agency Warstopper Program, as described in
DLA Instruction 1212, Industrial Capabilities Program—Manage the
WarStopper Program; or
(f) Defense Logistics Agency Surge and Sustainment contract, as described in Subpart 17.93 of the Defense Logistics Acquisition Directive.
(xi) Any system, including facilities, for the generation, transmission,
distribution, or storage of electric energy comprising the bulk-power
system, as defined in section 215(a)(1) of the Federal Power Act (16
U.S.C. 824o(a)(1)), as amended.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
PO 00000
Frm 00037
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
50210
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
Column 1—Covered investment critical
infrastructure
Column 2—Functions related to covered
investment critical infrastructure
(xii) Any electric storage resource, as defined in 18 CFR § 35.28(b)(9),
as amended, that is physically connected to the bulk-power system.
(xii) Own or operate any electric storage resource, as defined in 18
CFR § 35.28(b)(9), as amended, that is physically connected to the
bulk-power system.
(xiii) Own or operate any facility that provides electric power generation, transmission, distribution, or storage directly to or located on
any military installation identified in § 802.229.
(xiv) Manufacture or service any industrial control system utilized by:
(a) system comprising the bulk-power system as described above in
item (xi) of Column 1 of appendix A to part 800; or
(b) a facility directly serving any military installation as described above
in item (xiii) of Column 1 of appendix A to part 800.
(xv) Own or operate:
(a) any individual refinery with the capacity to produce 300,000 or more
barrels per day (or equivalent) of refined oil or gas products; or
(b) one or more refineries with the capacity to produce, in the aggregate, 500,000 or more barrels per day (or equivalent) of refined oil or
gas products.
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
(xiii) Any facility that provides electric power generation, transmission,
distribution, or storage directly to or located on any military installation identified in § 802.229.
(xiv) Any industrial control system utilized by:
(a) system comprising the bulk-power system as described above in
item (xi) of Column 1 of appendix A to part 800; or
(b) a facility directly serving any military installation as described above
in item (xiii) of Column 1 of appendix A to part 800.
(xv) Any:
(a) any individual refinery with the capacity to produce 300,000 or more
barrels per day (or equivalent) of refined oil or gas products; or
(b) collection of one or more refineries owned or operated by a single
U.S. business with the capacity to produce, in the aggregate,
500,000 or more barrels per day (or equivalent) of refined oil or gas
products.
(xvi) Any crude oil storage facility with the capacity to hold 30 million
barrels or more of crude oil.
(xvii) Any:
(a) liquefied natural gas (LNG) import or export terminal requiring.
(1) approval pursuant to section 3(e) of the Natural Gas Act (15 U.S.C.
717b(e)), as amended, or
(2) a license pursuant to section 4 of the Deepwater Port Act of 1974
(33 U.S.C. 1503), as amended; or
(b) natural gas underground storage facility or LNG peak-shaving facility requiring a certificate of public convenience and necessity pursuant to section 7 of the Natural Gas Act (15 U.S.C. 717f), as amended.
(xviii) Any financial market utility that the Financial Stability Oversight
Council has designated as systemically important pursuant to section
804 of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection
Act (12 U.S.C. 5463), as amended.
(xix) Any exchange registered under section 6 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (15 U.S.C. 78f), as amended, that facilitates
trading in any national market system security, as defined in 17 CFR
§ 242.600, as amended, and which exchange during at least four of
the preceding six calendar months had:
(a) with respect to all national market system securities that are not options, ten percent or more of the average daily dollar volume reported by applicable transaction reporting plans; or
(b) with respect to all listed options, fifteen percent or more of the average daily dollar volume reported by applicable national market system plans for reporting transactions in listed options.
(xx) Any technology service provider in the Significant Service Provider
Program of the Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council
that provides core processing services.
(xxi) Any rail line and associated connector line designated as part of
the Department of Defense’s Strategic Rail Corridor Network.
(xxii) Any interstate oil pipeline that:
(a) has the capacity to transport:
(1) 500,000 barrels per day or more of crude oil, or
(2) 90 million gallons per day or more of refined petroleum product; or
(b) directly serves the strategic petroleum reserve, as defined in section 152 of the Energy Policy and Conservation Act (42 U.S.C.
6232), as amended.
(xxiii) Any interstate natural gas pipeline with an outside diameter of 20
or more inches.
(xxiv) Any industrial control system utilized by:
(a) an interstate oil pipeline as described above in item (xxii) of Column
1 of appendix A to part 800; or
(b) an interstate natural gas pipeline as described above in item (xxiii)
of Column 1 of appendix A to part 800.
(xxv) Any airport identified in § 802.201.
(xxvi) Any:
(a) maritime port identified in § 802.228; or
(b) any individual terminal at such maritime ports.
(xxvii) Any public water system, as defined in section 1401(4) of the
Safe Drinking Water Act (42 U.S.C. 300f(4)(A)), as amended, or
treatment works, as defined in section 212(2)(A) of the Clean Water
Act (33 U.S.C. 1292(2)), as amended, which:
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
PO 00000
Frm 00038
Fmt 4701
(xvi) Own or operate any crude oil storage facility with the capacity to
hold 30 million barrels or more of crude oil.
(xvii) Own or operate any:
(a) liquefied natural gas (LNG) import or export terminal requiring:
(1) approval pursuant to section 3(e) of the Natural Gas Act (15 U.S.C.
717b(e)), as amended, or
(2) a license pursuant to section 4 of the Deepwater Port Act of 1974
(33 U.S.C. 1503), as amended; or
(b) natural gas underground storage facility or LNG peak-shaving facility requiring a certificate of public convenience and necessity pursuant to section 7 of the Natural Gas Act (15 U.S.C. 717f), as amended.
(xviii) Own or operate any financial market utility that the Financial Stability Oversight Council has designated as systemically important
pursuant to section 804 of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and
Consumer Protection Act (12 U.S.C. 5463), as amended.
(xix) Own or operate any exchange registered under section 6 of the
Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (15 U.S.C. 78f), as amended, that
facilitates trading in any national market system security, as defined
in 17 CFR § 242.600, as amended, and which exchange during at
least four of the preceding six calendar months had:
(a) with respect to all national market system securities that are not options, ten percent or more of the average daily dollar volume reported by applicable transaction reporting plans; or
(b) with respect to all listed options, fifteen percent or more of the average daily dollar volume reported by applicable national market system plans for reporting transactions in listed options.
(xx) Own or operate any technology service provider in the Significant
Service Provider Program of the Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council that provides core processing services.
(xxi) Own or operate any rail line and associated connector line designated as part of the Department of Defense’s Strategic Rail Corridor Network.
(xxii) Own or operate any interstate oil pipeline that:
(a) has the capacity to transport:
(1) 500,000 barrels per day or more of crude oil, or
(2) 90 million gallons per day or more of refined petroleum product; or
(b) directly serves the strategic petroleum reserve, as defined in section 152 of the Energy Policy and Conservation Act (42 U.S.C.
6232), as amended.
(xxiii) Own or operate any interstate natural gas pipeline with an outside diameter of 20 or more inches.
(xxiv) Manufacture or service any industrial control system utilized by:
(a) an interstate oil pipeline as described above in item (xxii) of Column
1 of appendix A to part 800; or
(b) an interstate natural gas pipeline as described above in item (xxiii)
of Column 1 of appendix A to part 800.
(xxv) Own or operate any airport identified in § 802.201.
(xxvi) Own or operate any:
(a) maritime port identified in § 802.228; or
(b) any individual terminal at such maritime ports.
(xxvii) Own or operate any public water system, as defined in section
1401(4) of the Safe Drinking Water Act (42 U.S.C. 300f(4)(A)), as
amended, or treatment works, as defined in section 212(2)(A) of the
Clean Water Act (33 U.S.C. 1292(2)), as amended, which:
Sfmt 4700
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 / Proposed Rules
Column 1—Covered investment critical
infrastructure
Column 2—Functions related to covered
investment critical infrastructure
(a) regularly serves 10,000 individuals or more, or
(b) directly serves any military installation identified in § 802.229.
(xxviii) Any industrial control system utilized by a public water system
or treatment works as described above in item (xxvii) of Column 1 of
appendix A to part 800.
(a) regularly serves 10,000 individuals or more, or
(b) directly serves any military installation identified in § 802.229.
(xxviii) Manufacture or service any industrial control system utilized by
a public water system or treatment works as described above in item
(xxvii) of Column 1 of appendix A to part 800.
Dated: September 11, 2019.
Thomas Feddo,
Deputy Assistant Secretary for Investment
Security.
[FR Doc. 2019–20099 Filed 9–17–19; 4:15 pm]
BILLING CODE 4810–25–P
khammond on DSKJM1Z7X2PROD with PROPOSALS3
50211
VerDate Sep<11>2014
17:44 Sep 23, 2019
Jkt 247001
PO 00000
Frm 00039
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 9990
E:\FR\FM\24SEP3.SGM
24SEP3
Agencies
[Federal Register Volume 84, Number 185 (Tuesday, September 24, 2019)]
[Proposed Rules]
[Pages 50174-50211]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2019-20099]
[[Page 50173]]
Vol. 84
Tuesday,
No. 185
September 24, 2019
Part IV
Department of the Treasury
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Office of Investment Security
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
31 CFR Part 800
Provisions Pertaining to Certain Investments in the United States by
Foreign Persons; Proposed Rule
Federal Register / Vol. 84 , No. 185 / Tuesday, September 24, 2019 /
Proposed Rules
[[Page 50174]]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY
Office of Investment Security
31 CFR Part 800
RIN 1505-AC64
Provisions Pertaining to Certain Investments in the United States
by Foreign Persons
AGENCY: Office of Investment Security, Department of the Treasury
ACTION: Proposed rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: This proposed rule would replace the current regulations that
implement section 721 of the Defense Production Act of 1950, as amended
by the Foreign Investment Risk Review Modernization Act of 2018
(FIRRMA). While this proposed rule retains many provisions of the
existing regulations, a number of substantive changes are proposed,
primarily to implement FIRRMA.
DATES: Written comments must be received by October 24, 2019.
The Department of the Treasury is considering holding during the
comment period a teleconference regarding the proposed rule for members
of the public. Information about any public teleconference, including
the date, time, and how to attend, will be published on the Department
of the Treasury website at https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/international/the-committee-on-foreign-investment-in-the-united-states-cfius.
ADDRESSES: Written comments on this proposed rule may be submitted
through one of two methods:
Electronic Submission: Comments may be submitted
electronically through the Federal government eRulemaking portal at
https://www.regulations.gov. Electronic submission of comments allows
the commenter maximum time to prepare and submit a comment, ensures
timely receipt, and enables the Department of the Treasury to make the
comments available to the public. Please note that comments submitted
through https://www.regulations.gov will be public, and can be viewed
by members of the public.
Mail: Send to U.S. Department of the Treasury, Attention:
Thomas Feddo, Deputy Assistant Secretary for Investment Security, 1500
Pennsylvania Avenue NW, Washington, DC 20220.
In general, the Department of the Treasury will post all comments
to https://www.regulations.gov without change, including any business
or personal information provided, such as names, addresses, email
addresses, or telephone numbers. All comments received, including
attachments and other supporting material, will be part of the public
record and subject to public disclosure. You should only submit
information that you wish to make publicly available.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: For questions about this proposed
rule, contact: Laura Black, Director of Investment Security Policy and
International Relations; Meena R. Sharma, Deputy Director of Investment
Security Policy and International Relations; David Shogren, Senior
Policy Advisor; or Alexander Sevald, Senior Policy Advisor, at U.S.
Department of the Treasury, 1500 Pennsylvania Avenue NW, Washington, DC
20220; telephone: (202) 622-3425; email: [email protected].
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Background
A. The Statute
The Foreign Investment Risk Review Modernization Act of 2018
(FIRRMA), Subtitle A of Title XVII of Public Law 115-232, 132 Stat.
2173, which amends section 721 (section 721) of the Defense Production
Act of 1950, as amended (DPA), requires the issuance of regulations
implementing its provisions. In Executive Order 13456, 73 FR 4677 (Jan.
23, 2008), the President directs the Secretary of the Treasury to issue
regulations implementing section 721. This proposed rule is being
issued pursuant to that authority.
FIRRMA was passed by Congress as H.R. 5515 and was enacted on
August 13, 2018. Prior to the enactment of FIRRMA, section 721
authorized the President, acting through the Committee on Foreign
Investment in the United States (CFIUS or the Committee), to review
mergers, acquisitions, and takeovers by or with any foreign person
which could result in foreign control of any person engaged in
interstate commerce in the United States, to determine the effects of
such transactions on the national security of the United States.
FIRRMA maintains the Committee's jurisdiction over any transaction
which could result in foreign control of any U.S. business, and
broadens the authorities of the President and CFIUS under section 721
to address national security concerns arising from certain investments
and real estate transactions. Additionally, FIRRMA modernizes CFIUS's
processes to better enable timely and effective reviews of transactions
falling under its jurisdiction (which FIRRMA describes as ``covered
transactions''). In enacting FIRRMA, Congress acknowledged the
important role of foreign investment in the U.S. economy and reiterated
its support of the United States' open investment policy, consistent
with the protection of national security. A brief summary of key
provisions of FIRRMA, as relevant for this rulemaking, follows.
FIRRMA expands and clarifies the jurisdiction of the Committee by
explicitly adding four types of transactions as covered transactions in
the DPA: (1) The purchase or lease by, or concession to, a foreign
person of certain real estate in the United States; (2) non-controlling
``other investments'' that afford a foreign person an equity interest
in and specified access to information in the possession of, rights in,
or involvement in the decisionmaking of certain U.S. businesses
involved in certain critical technologies, critical infrastructure, or
sensitive personal data; (3) any change in a foreign person's rights if
such change could result in foreign control of a U.S. business or an
other investment in certain U.S. businesses; and (4) any other
transaction, transfer, agreement, or arrangement, the structure of
which is designed or intended to evade or circumvent the application of
section 721. With respect to the Committee's expanded jurisdiction over
certain real estate transactions and other investments, FIRRMA
instructs the Committee to specify criteria to limit the application of
that expansion of jurisdiction to certain categories of foreign
persons. The proposed rule addresses all of these types of covered
transactions except for real estate transactions, which are the subject
of a separate and concurrent rulemaking.
In addition to expanding the Committee's jurisdiction, FIRRMA
prescribes certain process changes. FIRRMA allows parties to submit an
abbreviated filing for any covered transaction through a declaration,
as an alternative to CFIUS's traditional voluntary notice, both of
which are discussed below. Declarations will allow parties to submit
basic information regarding a transaction in an abbreviated form that
should generally not exceed five pages in length. FIRRMA also sets
forth an abbreviated timeframe for the Committee to respond to
submitted declarations.
FIRRMA introduces a mandatory declaration requirement in certain
circumstances. Specifically, FIRRMA creates a mandatory declaration
requirement for certain covered transactions where a foreign government
has a substantial interest. Additionally, FIRRMA authorizes CFIUS to
mandate
[[Page 50175]]
through regulations the submitting of a declaration for covered
transactions involving certain U.S. businesses that produce, design,
test, manufacture, fabricate, or develop one or more critical
technologies. In both cases, parties have the option of filing a notice
rather than submitting a declaration if they so choose.
FIRRMA also codifies certain processes related to the Committee's
authority to identify non-notified and non-declared transactions.
FIRRMA permits a party to a transaction to stipulate that a
transaction is a covered transaction and, as relevant, a foreign
government-controlled transaction. A party can make a stipulation in
either a notice or a declaration. If a party makes a stipulation in a
notice, CFIUS must provide comments on or accept the notice no later
than 10 business days after the date of the filing.
Additionally, FIRRMA extends the timing of the review period for
transactions filed as notices from 30 days to 45 days and allows the
Secretary of the Treasury to grant one 15-day extension of the 45-day
investigation period in ``extraordinary circumstances.'' These
provisions were made effective in a rulemaking on October 11, 2018. 83
FR 51316. FIRRMA establishes a 30-day review period for transactions
submitted as declarations. The notice and declarations processes are
discussed in further detail below.
B. Effective Date of Certain Provisions
Congress divided FIRRMA's provisions into two categories: Those
effective immediately and those that become effective no later than
February 13, 2020.
Specifically, section 1727(a) of FIRRMA lists the provisions that
became effective immediately upon enactment of the statute. A number of
the immediately effective provisions required revisions to the CFIUS
regulations existing at that time at part 800 of title 31 of the Code
of Federal Regulations. On October 11, 2018, the Department of the
Treasury published an interim rule implementing the immediately
effective provisions of, and making updates consistent with, FIRRMA. 83
FR 51316. That interim rule was intended to provide clarity regarding
the processes and procedures of the Committee pending the full
implementation of FIRRMA. The interim rule provided for a public
comment period of 30 days. One comment was received and is discussed
below.
Section 1727(b) of FIRRMA delayed the effectiveness of any
provision of FIRRMA not specified in section 1727(a) until the earlier
of: (1) The date that is 18 months after the date of enactment of
FIRRMA (i.e., February 13, 2020); or (2) the date that is 30 days after
publication in the Federal Register of a determination by the
chairperson of the Committee that the regulations, organizational
structure, personnel, and other resources necessary to administer the
new provisions are in place. The proposed regulations in this notice
are intended to fully implement the provisions of FIRRMA, with the
exception of (1) CFIUS's new jurisdiction over certain real estate
transactions, (2) CFIUS's new authority to impose filing fees, and (3)
CFIUS's authority to mandate declarations for certain transactions
involving critical technologies, each of which is the subject of a
separate rulemaking, as discussed below.
Notwithstanding section 1727(b), section 1727(c) of FIRRMA
authorizes CFIUS to conduct one or more pilot programs to implement any
authority provided pursuant to any provision of, or amendment made by,
FIRRMA that did not take effect immediately upon enactment. On October
11, 2018, the Department of the Treasury published an interim rule
setting forth the scope of, and procedures for, a pilot program to
review certain transactions involving foreign persons and critical
technologies (Pilot Program Interim Rule). 83 FR 51322. That Pilot
Program Interim Rule, which went into effect on November 10, 2018,
established mandatory declarations for certain transactions involving
investments by foreign persons in certain U.S. businesses that produce,
design, test, manufacture, fabricate, or develop one or more critical
technologies. The Pilot Program Interim Rule provided for a public
comment period of 30 days, and a number of comments were received. As
discussed below, the Committee is still considering those comments and
the scope of mandatory declarations for covered transactions involving
critical technologies. The Department of the Treasury expects to
address in the final rule the comments previously received on the Pilot
Program Interim Rule and any new comments provided in response to this
proposed rule.
C. Structure of FIRRMA Rulemaking and This Proposed Rule
Consistent with CFIUS processes generally, the proposed rule
reflects extensive consultation with CFIUS member agencies, as well as
other relevant agencies. The proposed rule retains many of the basic
features of the existing regulations, while implementing the changes
that FIRRMA made to CFIUS's jurisdiction and process.
Given the number of revisions, the proposed rule amends and
restates part 800 in its entirety. Although the new part 800 is being
restated here in full, many of the provisions of the prior part 800 are
not being materially modified. The Committee will consider all comments
provided to the proposed rule, but is particularly interested in
receiving comments relating to the new provisions and revisions being
proposed here and outlined below, rather than comments relating to the
text of part 800 that has not been changed.
In updating part 800 to incorporate CFIUS's new jurisdiction over
non-controlling other investments (which this rule describes as
``covered investments''), certain conforming edits were made to
existing provisions. For example, the coverage section in subpart C of
the proposed rule on ``covered control transactions'' is based on the
``covered transactions'' section in the existing part 800 regulations
and provides examples of the different bases of jurisdiction over
control transactions and covered investments. In that respect, there is
also now a covered investment section within the coverage subpart for
the new jurisdiction. Finally, the proposed rule incorporates the
changes made to part 800 in the interim rule published in October 2018,
and updates certain other provisions.
This proposed rule does not implement the authority FIRRMA provided
to the Committee to review the purchase or lease by, or concession to,
a foreign person of certain real estate in the United States. A
concurrent proposed rule implements such authority under a separate
part 802 within title 31 of the CFR. The Department of the Treasury
determined that the technical and procedural aspects of CFIUS's review
of transactions involving real estate are sufficiently distinct from
those related to control transactions and covered investments to
warrant separate rulemaking.
Parties should be aware that certain transactions that are not
covered transactions under this proposed rule could potentially be
covered real estate transactions under the proposed part 802 real
estate regulations.
FIRRMA authorizes the Committee to assess and collect fees with
respect to covered transactions for which a written notice is filed,
and the Committee is considering how to implement this authority. The
proposed rule also does not address filing fees. The Department of the
Treasury will publish a separate
[[Page 50176]]
proposed rule regarding fees at a later date.
The proposed rule does not modify the regulations currently at 31
CFR part 801, which sets forth the Pilot Program Interim Rule. CFIUS
continues to evaluate the Pilot Program Interim Rule, and the
Department of the Treasury welcomes comments on the retention of the
mandatory declaration aspect of the Pilot Program Interim Rule for
certain transactions involving critical technologies. The Department of
the Treasury received comments regarding the Pilot Program Interim Rule
from a variety of commenters and expects to address these comments in
the final rule associated with this proposed rule.
The proposed rule seeks to provide clarity to the business and
investment communities with respect to the types of U.S. businesses
that are covered under FIRRMA's other investment authority. Given the
level of specificity provided in certain provisions of the proposed
rule, the pace of technological development, the evolving use of data,
and the evolving national security landscape more generally, the
Department of the Treasury anticipates that it will periodically
review, and as necessary, make changes to the regulations, consistent
with applicable law.
II. Discussion of Proposed Rule
A. Subpart A--General
The following discussion describes several key changes to subpart
A.
Section 800.102--Risk-based analysis. FIRRMA requires that any
determination of the Committee to suspend a covered transaction, to
refer a covered transaction to the President, or to negotiate, enter
into or impose, or enforce any agreement or condition with respect to a
covered transaction, be based on a risk-based analysis, conducted by
the Committee, of the effects on the national security of the United
States of the covered transaction, which must include an assessment of
the threat, vulnerabilities, and consequences to national security
related to the transaction. The proposed rule includes definitions of
the terms ``threat,'' ``vulnerabilities,'' and ``consequences to
national security'' used in risk-based analyses undertaken by the
Committee.
Section 800.104--Applicability rule. The proposed rule clarifies
the existing applicability rule. The proposed rule also removes the
provision previously found at Sec. 800.103(b)(4) that established
applicability to a transaction based upon a Committee determination
that a commitment had been made.
B. Subpart B--Definitions
Several key changes to the existing part 800 definitions and
several key new definitions that are broadly applicable to both control
transactions and covered investments are discussed immediately below.
Certain new definitions that are applicable to specific substantive
areas regarding covered investments are discussed in the applicable
subsections below.
Section 800.203--Business day. The proposed rule modifies the
definition for ``business day'' to exclude days where there U.S. Office
of Personnel Management has announced the closure of Federal offices in
the Washington, DC area. The proposed rule also addresses the impact on
certain timing requirements where a submission is received after 5 p.m.
(Eastern Time).
Section 800.206--Completion date. The proposed rule includes a
definition for ``completion date.'' The proposed rule clarifies that,
in the event that a covered transaction will be effectuated through
multiple or staged closings, the completion date is the earliest date
on which any transfer of interest or change in rights that constitutes
a covered transaction occurs.
Section 800.207--Contingent equity interest. FIRRMA uses the term
``contingent equity interest'' in the definition of investment. The
proposed rule eliminates the term ``convertible voting instrument'' in
the existing part 800 in light of the new definition of ``contingent
equity interest.'' The proposed rule also updates the references in the
timing rule at Sec. 800.308.
Section 800.214--Critical infrastructure. The proposed rule revises
the definition for ``critical infrastructure'' to conform to the
language in FIRRMA. As discussed further below, however, for the
purposes of an other investment, FIRRMA requires CFIUS to specify a
subset of critical infrastructure.
Section 800.252--U.S. business. The proposed rule revises the
definition for ``U.S. business'' to conform to the definition in
FIRRMA.
C. Covered Investments
The proposed rule implements CFIUS's authority, provided under
FIRRMA, to review an investment by a foreign person in certain types of
U.S. businesses that affords the foreign person certain access to
information in the possession of, rights in, or involvement in the
decisionmaking of certain U.S. businesses but that does not afford the
foreign person control over the U.S. business. The proposed rule uses
the term ``covered investments'' for these investments, as defined in
Sec. 800.211.
The types of access, rights, or involvement that could give rise to
a covered investment are set forth in Sec. 800.211(b). That section
implements the definitions in FIRRMA describing transactions that
afford the foreign person (1) access to material non-public technical
information in the possession of the U.S. business, (2) membership or
observer rights on the board of directors (or equivalent body) of the
U.S. business, or (3) any involvement in substantive decisionmaking of
the U.S. business regarding certain actions related to critical
technologies, critical infrastructure, or sensitive personal data. The
proposed rule further defines ``material non-public technical
information'' (see Sec. 800.233) and ``substantive decisionmaking''
(see Sec. 800.245).
The types of businesses in which an investment may constitute a
covered investment are those that have certain involvement in critical
technologies, critical infrastructure, and sensitive personal data, as
further described below and in the proposed rule. These businesses are
referred to as ``TID U.S. businesses'' in the proposed rule (see Sec.
800.248). ``TID'' is an acronym for Technology, Infrastructure, and
Data. FIRRMA, moreover, limits such covered investments to those made
in an unaffiliated business. Thus, the proposed rule adds a definition
for ``unaffiliated TID U.S. business,'' which excludes entities in
which the foreign person already holds a majority of the voting
interest or the right to appoint the majority of the entity's board or
equivalent governing body.
Notably, CFIUS retains jurisdiction over any transaction through
which any foreign person could acquire control of any U.S. business,
regardless of whether the transaction involves critical technology,
critical infrastructure, or sensitive personal data.
In connection with the new jurisdiction over covered investments,
FIRRMA requires that the Committee prescribe regulations to limit its
application to the investments of certain categories of foreign
persons. This proposed rule implements this requirement by
``excepting'' certain foreign persons from the provisions relating to
covered investments if the foreign persons meet specified criteria. It
also includes clarifications contained in FIRRMA regarding the
treatment of certain investments through investment funds and an
exception specified in FIRRMA for investments involving air carriers.
[[Page 50177]]
1. Covered Investments Involving Critical Technology
FIRRMA expands CFIUS's jurisdiction to include covered investments
by a foreign person in an unaffiliated U.S. business that produces,
designs, tests, manufactures, fabricates, or develops one or more
critical technologies.
Section 800.215--Critical technologies. The proposed rule defines
``critical technologies'' consistent with the language in FIRRMA.
Subpart (f) of FIRRMA's definition of critical technology, as set out
in this proposed rule, captures emerging and foundational technologies
controlled pursuant to section 1758 of the Export Control Reform Act of
2018 (ECRA), Subtitle B of Title XVII of Public Law 115-232. Pursuant
to ECRA, the Bureau of Industry and Security within the Department of
Commerce identifies and places export controls on specified emerging
and foundational technologies. As technologies become controlled
pursuant to rulemaking under ECRA, they will automatically be covered
under the definition of ``critical technologies'' under part 800.
As noted above, CFIUS will continue to have authority to review any
transaction that could result in control by a foreign person of any
U.S. business, including a U.S. business with technology, critical or
otherwise, and export controlled or otherwise.
2. Covered Investments Involving Critical Infrastructure
FIRRMA expands CFIUS's jurisdiction to include covered investments
by a foreign person in an unaffiliated U.S. business that ``owns,
operates, manufactures, supplies, or services critical
infrastructure.'' FIRRMA requires that the regulations implementing
this provision limit the application of covered investment jurisdiction
to a subset of critical infrastructure that must be specified in the
regulations. Moreover, FIRRMA specifically provides that any definition
of ``critical infrastructure'' established under any provision of law
other than section 721 is not determinative for the purposes of section
721, including this proposed rule. Similarly, the subset of critical
infrastructure identified in appendix A is not intended to alter the
definition of ``critical infrastructure'' as used in any other
regulatory regime or context.
Section 800.212--Covered investment critical infrastructure. The
proposed rule identifies the subset of critical infrastructure that is
relevant for the Committee's jurisdiction over covered investments
through a list of specific types of infrastructure in appendix A. As
noted above, the Department of the Treasury anticipates periodically
revising the regulations, potentially including revisions to this list.
To distinguish this subset of critical infrastructure from critical
infrastructure more broadly, this proposed rule creates a new term,
``covered investment critical infrastructure'' (see Sec. 800.212).
As noted above, FIRRMA describes, subject to the regulations
implementing this provision, a U.S. business that falls under other
investment jurisdiction with respect to critical infrastructure as one
that ``owns, operates, manufactures, supplies, or services'' the subset
of critical infrastructure. This proposed rule refers to these
activities as ``functions.'' In furtherance of FIRRMA's requirement to
limit the application of other investment jurisdiction regarding
critical infrastructure, the proposed rule sets forth which functions
apply to each enumerated specific type of covered investment critical
infrastructure. The proposed rule therefore links the relevant
functions with the enumerated specific types of covered investment
critical infrastructure in appendix A. Column 1 of appendix A lists the
covered investment critical infrastructure and Column 2 lists the
relevant functions that apply to enumerated specific types of covered
investment critical infrastructure.
Appendix A is integral to the proposed rule and key to determining
whether a U.S. business is a TID U.S. business for purposes of critical
infrastructure covered investment jurisdiction. Only a U.S. business
that performs one of the specified functions listed in Column 2 of
appendix A with respect to the enumerated specific type of covered
investment infrastructure listed in Column 1 is a TID U.S. business for
purposes of critical infrastructure covered investments. The proposed
rule also clarifies the meaning of certain of the functions listed in
FIRRMA.
Section 800.235--Own. The proposed rule defines ``own'' solely for
the purpose of Column 2 of appendix A, which in turn determines which
owners of covered investment critical infrastructure are TID U.S.
businesses for purposes of covered investment jurisdiction. The term
limits owners to only those of U.S. businesses that directly possess
the systems or assets constituting the applicable covered investment
critical infrastructure.
Sections 800.232--Manufacture; 800.242--Service; and 800.246--
Supply. The proposed rule also defines ``manufacture,'' ``service,''
and ``supply.'' It does not define ``operate'' given the commonly
understood meaning of that term.
Importantly, appendix A only applies to the subset of critical
infrastructure subject to covered investment jurisdiction, and is not
applicable in any other context. Appendix A implements FIRRMA's
direction to identify a subset of critical infrastructure for purposes
of covered investments and therefore does not modify the definition of
critical infrastructure as it applies to CFIUS's jurisdiction more
broadly over control transactions.
As noted above, CFIUS will continue to have authority to review any
transaction that could result in control by a foreign person of any
U.S. business, regardless of whether the U.S. business involves
critical infrastructure as broadly defined by FIRRMA or the narrower
subset of covered investment critical infrastructure introduced in this
proposed rule.
3. Covered Investments Involving Sensitive Personal Data
FIRRMA expands CFIUS's jurisdiction to include covered investments
by a foreign person in an unaffiliated U.S. business that maintains or
collects sensitive personal data of U.S. citizens that ``may be
exploited in a manner that threatens to harm national security.''
Section 800.241--Sensitive personal data. To implement this
provision, the proposed rule sets forth a detailed definition for
``sensitive personal data.'' The Committee anticipates periodically
revising the regulations, potentially including revisions to this
definition.
Given that most companies collect some type of data on individuals,
the proposed rule protects national security while attempting to
minimize any chilling effect on beneficial foreign investment by
focusing on the sensitivity of the data itself, as well as the
sensitivity of the population about whom the data is maintained or
collected. In particular, the proposed rule identifies specific
categories of data that constitute sensitive personal data only if the
U.S. business (a) targets or tailors its products or services to
sensitive U.S. Government personnel or contractors, (b) maintains or
collects such data on greater than one million individuals, or (c) has
a demonstrated business objective to maintain or collect such data on
greater than one million individuals and such data is an integrated
part of the U.S. business's primary products or services. The proposed
definition also includes all genetic information and generally carves
[[Page 50178]]
out data pertaining to a U.S. business's own employees.
The proposed rule defines ``targets or tailors'' (see Sec.
800.247) and provides examples of businesses that meet the definition.
By focusing on U.S. businesses that target or tailor their products or
services to these potentially sensitive populations, the Committee
expects to review transactions involving U.S. businesses that are more
likely to have sensitive personal data concerning such individuals.
Even if a U.S. business does not target or tailor its products or
services to such individuals, however, if the U.S. business maintains
or collects data on a large number of individuals, it is more likely to
capture data on sensitive populations. The proposed threshold of one
million accounts for this possibility. Similarly, if a U.S. business is
a data-driven company that plans to maintain or collect sensitive
personal data on a large number of individuals in the future, as
demonstrated by the U.S. business's statements or actions, it may
capture data on sensitive populations.
Section 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(A)--This section describes certain
financial data that could be used to determine if an individual is
experiencing financial hardship. The types of data the proposed rule
seeks to capture include bank account statements or detailed financial
information included in an application for a home mortgage or credit
card. Information regarding ordinary consumer transactions, such as a
record of a credit card purchase at a retail establishment, would not
generally fall into this category.
Section 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(B)--This section describes information
that is collected by consumer reporting agencies, such as an
individual's credit score, or summaries of debts and payment histories.
Many companies periodically receive information about an individual's
credit from a consumer reporting agency, and Sec. 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(B)
generally excludes these companies from its scope if they receive a
limited set of the information, such as a credit score, for the
legitimate purposes described in the Fair Credit Reporting Act.
Section 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(C)--This section describes data contained
in certain types of personal insurance applications, many of which
contain detailed personal information related to financial status and
health.
Section 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(D)--This section describes health-related
data.
Section 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(E)--This section describes non-public
electronic communications, including email, which may include all
manner of sensitive information, but only if the U.S. business is
providing communications platforms used by third parties. For example,
email communications between a U.S. business and its own customers
would not be covered. Rather, this section describes the situation
where a U.S. business offers email, chat, or messaging services, a
primary purpose of which is to allow third parties to communicate with
each other.
Section 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(F)--This section describes geolocation
data that is often collected by mobile mapping applications, GPS
services, or wireless communications providers.
Section 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(G)--This section describes data that is
generated by companies that provide biometric identification services.
Section 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(H)-(J)--These sections describes certain
data that is held by companies, typically government contractors, that
issue official government identification cards or process personnel
security clearances.
Section 800.227--Identifiable data; Sec. 800.239--Personal
identifier. The proposed rule also includes a definition of
``identifiable data.'' In some cases, a U.S. business may maintain or
collect the data described in Sec. 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(A)-(J), but it is
not possible to attribute such data to any specific individual. For
example, a U.S. business may store health records on its servers, but
those records are encrypted such that only a third party in possession
of the encryption key can read the data. The U.S. business in these
circumstances would not be maintaining or collecting sensitive personal
data. The proposed rule makes clear, however, that identifiable data is
not limited to data that includes an individual's name or other obvious
identifier, but rather includes any personal identifier, as defined in
Sec. 800.239.
Finally, Sec. 800.241(a)(2) describes genetic information, as
defined pursuant to the regulations implementing HIPAA. Unlike the
categories described in sections 800.241(a)(1)(ii)(A)-(J), the
requirement that the U.S. business target or tailor to certain U.S.
Government personnel or contractors, maintain or collect data on
greater than one million individuals, or have a demonstrated business
objective to maintain or collect such data on greater than one million
individuals if such data is an integrated part of the U.S. business's
primary products or services as well as the requirement that the data
be identifiable, does not apply to genetic information.
As noted above, CFIUS will continue to have authority to review any
transaction that could result in control by a foreign person of any
U.S. business, regardless of whether the U.S. business maintains or
collects sensitive personal data.
4. Country Specification for Covered Investments
FIRRMA requires CFIUS to specify criteria to limit the application
of FIRRMA's expanded jurisdiction over other investments to certain
categories of foreign persons. The proposed rule addresses FIRRMA's
requirement through three new defined terms, ``excepted investor,''
``excepted foreign state,'' and ``minimum excepted ownership,'' which
operate together to exclude from CFIUS's jurisdiction covered
investments by certain foreign persons who meet certain criteria
establishing sufficiently close ties to certain foreign states.
Sections 800.220, 800.219, and 800.234 define excepted investor,
excepted foreign state, and minimum excepted ownership, respectively.
Section 800.220--Excepted investor. The proposed rule sets forth a
narrow definition of excepted investor in the interest of protecting
national security, in light of increasingly complex ownership
structures, and to prevent foreign persons from circumventing CFIUS's
jurisdiction. Thus, the criteria specified in Sec. 800.220 require
that a foreign person have a substantial connection (e.g., nationality
of ultimate beneficial owners and place of incorporation) to one or
more particular foreign states in order to be deemed an excepted
investor. Note that foreign persons who have violated, or whose parents
or subsidiaries have violated, certain U.S. laws, executive orders,
regulations, orders, directives, or licenses, or who have submitted a
material misstatement or omission in a CFIUS notice or declaration or
violated a material provision of a mitigation agreement, among other
things, will not be considered excepted investors. Additionally, note
that a foreign person who is an excepted investor at the time of the
transaction, but, who, for up to three years after the completion date,
fails to meet to certain criteria, is deemed not to be an excepted
investor and the transaction is thus subject to CFIUS jurisdiction as a
covered investment. Any member of the Committee may file an agency
notice of the transaction for up to one year (and the Chairperson of
the Committee for up to three years in extraordinary circumstances).
[[Page 50179]]
Section 800.219--Excepted foreign state. The rule proposes that the
excepted foreign state definition operate as a two-factor conjunctive
test. First, the foreign state must be included in a defined group of
eligible foreign states, which will be separately published on the
Department of the Treasury website. As this is a new concept with
potentially significant implications for the national security of the
United States, CFIUS initially intends to designate a limited number of
eligible foreign states. CFIUS plans to review this group in the future
and potentially expand the number of eligible foreign states.
Second, in furtherance of CFIUS's efforts to encourage partner
countries to implement robust processes to review foreign investment in
their countries and to increase cooperation with the United States, the
Secretary of the Treasury, with the agreement of a super-majority of
Committee member agencies, will also make a determination, as described
in subpart J, for each eligible foreign state as to whether such
foreign state has established and is effectively utilizing a robust
process to assess foreign investments for national security risks and
to facilitate coordination with the United States on matters relating
to investment security. In making these determinations, CFIUS will
consider factors that will be made available on the Department of the
Treasury website. The Committee is considering delaying the
effectiveness of this requirement in order to provide the eligible
foreign states time to enhance their foreign investment review
processes and bilateral cooperation. Any such determinations
identifying a foreign state as an excepted foreign state will be
published in the Federal Register and incorporated into the Committee's
list of excepted foreign states, which will be made available on the
Department of the Treasury website.
D. Subpart C--Coverage
Subpart C of the proposed rule includes provisions that describe
with particularity transactions that are, or are not, covered control
transactions (Sec. 800.301-302). Similar provisions address covered
investments (Sec. 800.303-304). The proposed rule contains numerous
examples in this subpart to clarify the coverage of certain
transactions.
Section 800.305--Incremental acquisitions. Under the existing Sec.
800.204(e), ``[a]ny transaction in which a foreign person acquires an
additional interest in a U.S. business that was previously the subject
of a covered transaction for which the Committee concluded all action
under section 721 shall not be deemed to be a transaction that could
result in foreign control over that U.S. business (i.e., it is not a
covered transaction).'' This provision was introduced when the scope of
CFIUS's jurisdiction included only transactions that could result in
foreign control of a U.S. business and when the only means to file was
by filing a written notice. This proposed rule moves the provision to
Subpart C and clarifies that a transaction shall not be deemed to be a
covered transaction if a foreign person acquires an additional interest
in a U.S. business over which the same foreign person or any of its
direct or indirect wholly-owned subsidiaries previously acquired direct
control in the U.S. business in a covered control transaction for which
the Committee concluded all action under Section 721 on the basis of a
notice. It further clarifies that this provision does not apply to
incremental acquisitions in a U.S. business by a foreign person that
had not previously acquired control of the U.S. business nor to a
transaction for which the Committee had concluded all action under
section 721 on the basis of a declaration. In other words, the
incremental acquisition rule does not apply where the initial
transaction was submitted only as declaration or was a covered
investment.
Section 800.307--Specific clarifications for investment funds. The
proposed rule implements provisions in FIRRMA relating to investment
funds. Specifically, it clarifies that, in the context of an indirect
investment by a foreign person in an unaffiliated TID U.S. business
through an investment fund that affords the foreign person (or a
designee of the foreign person) membership as a limited partner or
equivalent on an advisory board or committee of the fund, where all of
the criteria in Sec. 800.307 are satisfied, a limited partner's
membership on the investment fund's advisory board or committee does
not in and of itself render the foreign person's indirect investment in
an unaffiliated TID U.S. business a covered investment.
E. Subpart D--Declarations
FIRRMA introduces an abbreviated filing process through the
submission of a declaration, which allows parties to submit basic
information regarding a transaction to the Committee. A declaration may
be submitted for any covered transaction and, in certain cases, is
mandated. Parties may choose to file a notice in lieu of declaration to
satisfy a mandatory declaration requirement.
Declarations differ from notices in three key ways. First,
declarations are shorter in length, generally not exceeding five pages.
As part of the Pilot Program Interim Rule, CFIUS developed a standard
fillable declaration form for parties to use when submitting a
transaction for review. To facilitate the submission of declarations
under the proposed rule, CFIUS intends to maintain a standard fillable
form, making certain modifications to the form for use with respect to
different types of transactions. Parties will be able to use the form
to submit voluntary and mandatory declarations to the Committee.
Second, the timeline for the Committee to take action on
declarations is shorter than for notices. FIRRMA provides CFIUS up to
30 days to respond to a declaration. This differs from the timeline for
notices, which is 45 days for a review and an additional 45 days for an
investigation, with a possibility of a 15-day extension in
``extraordinary circumstances.''
Third, FIRRMA provides CFIUS with several potential responses to a
declaration, and CFIUS need not make a final determination with respect
to action under section 721 on the basis of a declaration.
1. Mandatory Declarations
Section 800.401--Mandatory declarations. The proposed rule
implements FIRRMA's requirement for mandatory declarations for certain
transactions in which a foreign person obtains a ``substantial
interest'' in a U.S. business where a foreign government in turn holds
a ``substantial interest'' in the foreign person. The proposed rule
defines the term substantial interest with respect to a person's
ability to influence the actions of another person in a manner that has
the potential, directly or indirectly, to impair the national security
of the United States. In most cases, the foreign person best placed to
influence a U.S. business--and therefore exploit any vulnerability in a
U.S. business--is the foreign person with the closest relationship to
the U.S. business. With respect to an investment involving multiple
tiers of investing entities, this foreign person is very frequently the
one that sits closest to the U.S. business on the post-closing
organizational chart. This entity, when compared to other entities
higher in the organizational chart, often has a greater ability to
interact directly with--and therefore influence--the U.S. business,
both from a corporate governance perspective as well as an operational
[[Page 50180]]
perspective. The proposed rule therefore establishes in Sec.
800.244(a) the voting interest threshold for substantial interest
between a foreign person and U.S. business at a 25 percent voting
interest, direct or indirect, and between a foreign government and a
foreign person at a 49 percent or greater voting interest, direct or
indirect. For purposes of determining the percentage of voting interest
held indirectly by one entity in another, the rule establishes that any
voting interest of a parent entity in a subsidiary entity will be
deemed to be a 100 percent voting interest. The proposed rule also
clarifies in Sec. 800.244(b) how the voting interest in a limited
partnership is to be calculated. The proposed rule does not provide for
a waiver of this requirement.
As discussed above, CFIUS is considering whether to continue the
mandatory declaration requirement under the Pilot Program Interim Rule,
which requires declarations for covered control transactions and
covered investments in certain U.S. businesses with critical
technologies involved in one or more of 27 specified industries.
Section 800.401(e)(2). FIRRMA also provides that, for mandatory
declarations, the Committee can require that a declaration be submitted
up to 45 days prior to the completion of the transaction. Under the
proposed rule, mandatory declarations would need to be submitted to
CFIUS at least 30 days in advance of the completion date.
Section 800.401(d). Where there is a mandatory declaration
requirement, parties may choose to submit a written notice at least 30
days prior to the completion date of the transaction instead of a
declaration.
2. Voluntary Declarations
Section 800.402--Voluntary declarations. The proposed rule
implements FIRRMA's provision enabling parties to choose to file a
declaration with CFIUS instead of a written notice.
3. Procedures and Contents for Declarations
Section 800.403--Procedures for declarations. The proposed rule
outlines the process under which parties submit a declaration. The
contents and procedures for submitting mandatory and voluntary
declarations are identical. In order to submit a declaration, the
parties need to provide the information required by Sec. 800.404,
including certifications. The rule does not permit parties to submit a
declaration regarding a transaction that is also the subject of a
notice without written approval from the Staff Chairperson. Conversely,
parties may not file a notice regarding a transaction that is the
subject of a declaration until such time as the Committee's assessment
of the declaration has been completed (see Sec. 800.501(j)).
Section 800.404--Contents of declarations. The proposed rule sets
forth the information that is required in a declaration, consistent
with FIRRMA's requirement that CFIUS establish declarations as
``abbreviated notices that would not generally exceed five pages in
length.'' As part of a declaration, parties may voluntarily stipulate
that the transaction is a covered transaction and, if so, whether the
transaction is a foreign-government controlled transaction.
Section 800.405--Beginning of 30-day assessment period. The
proposed rule requires that the Committee take action on a declaration
within 30 days of the Committee's receipt of the declaration from the
Staff Chairperson. One distinction from the provisions regarding
declarations in the Pilot Program Interim Rule is that the proposed
rule explicitly provides that the Staff Chairperson may invite parties
to a declaration to attend a meeting with Committee Staff to discuss
and clarify issues pertaining to the transaction that is the subject of
the declaration.
Section 800.406--Rejection, disposition, or withdrawal of
declarations. The proposed rule provides that the Committee may reject
a declaration if it is incomplete, there is a material change in the
transaction that has been notified, information comes to light that
contradicts material information provided by the parties in the
declaration, or parties to a submitted declaration fail to provide
information requested by the Committee within two business days of the
request (unless such timeframe is extended by the Staff Chairperson).
The proposed rule also establishes procedures for parties to withdraw a
declaration, and makes clear that parties may not submit more than one
declaration for the same or substantially similar transaction without
approval from the Staff Chairperson.
Section 800.407--Committee actions. The proposed rule implements
FIRRMA's mandate that the Committee take one of four actions in
response to a declaration: (1) Request that the parties file a notice;
(2) inform the parties that CFIUS cannot complete action under section
721 on the basis of the declaration, and that they may file a notice to
seek written notification from the Committee that the Committee has
concluded all action under section 721 with respect to the transaction;
(3) initiate a unilateral review of the transaction through an agency
notice; or (4) notify the parties that CFIUS has concluded all action
under section 721.
F. Subpart E--Notices
The proposed rule does not make significant changes to the
procedures and requirements for notices.
Section 800.502(o)--Contents of voluntary notices. FIRRMA allows
parties to ``stipulate'' that the transaction is a covered transaction
and, as relevant, a foreign government-controlled transaction. FIRRMA
directs the Committee to provide comments or accept the notice within
10 business days from the submission date of the draft or formal
written notice in cases where the transaction parties have stipulated
that the transaction is a covered transaction. In addition, stipulating
control reduces certain information requirements, and will allow the
Committee to more quickly turn to reviewing the substance of the
transaction. (See Sec. 800.502(j)(2).) In making a stipulation,
parties acknowledge that the Committee and the President are entitled
to rely on such stipulation in determining whether the transaction is a
covered transaction and/or a foreign government-controlled transaction,
and parties making a stipulation waive the right to challenge any such
determination. Neither the Committee nor the President is bound by any
such stipulation, nor does any such stipulation limit the ability of
the Committee or the President to act on any authority provided under
section 721, with respect to any covered transaction.
Section 800.502(c)(1)(xi) and (c)(3)(ix)-(xi)--Contents of
voluntary notices. The rule proposes additions to the information
requirements to require submission of information necessary to analyze
covered investments. A few additional changes to the information
requirements have been introduced for clarity and to include
information that CFIUS determined was necessary based on experience.
Section 800.503--Beginning of 45-day review period. FIRRMA changes
the timeframe for CFIUS's review of a transaction filed as a notice,
extending it from 30 days to 45 days. This change was one of the
immediately effective provisions of FIRRMA that was implemented through
the interim rule published at 83 FR 51316. The proposed rule,
consistent with the interim rule, incorporates that timing change.
G. Subpart G--Finality of Action
FIRRMA maintains that a covered transaction that has been notified
to CFIUS as a notice and on which CFIUS has concluded action under
section 721
[[Page 50181]]
after determining that there are no unresolved national security
concerns, qualifies for a ``safe harbor,'' and extends the same
treatment to transactions submitted as a declaration. This means that,
unless a party to a transaction submitted false or misleading material
information or omitted material information, and subject to compliance
with the terms of any mitigation agreement entered into with or
conditions imposed by CFIUS, the transaction can proceed without the
possibility of subsequent suspension or prohibition under section 721.
A covered transaction on which CFIUS has not concluded action does not
qualify for the safe harbor, and CFIUS has the authority to initiate
review of the transaction on its own, even after the transaction has
been completed, which CFIUS may choose to do if it believes the
transaction presents national security considerations.
H. Subpart I--Penalties and Damages
The Department of the Treasury amended the penalty provisions of
its regulations in the interim rule published at 83 FR 51316, which
updated CFIUS's penalties provision consistent with revisions made to
section 721 by FIRRMA. The proposed rule adopts the revisions from the
interim rule and makes certain other updates to subpart I.
Section 800.901--Penalties and damages. The proposed rule,
consistent with the interim rule, removes the qualifier ``intentionally
or through gross negligence'' with respect to a material misstatement
or omission in the context of the imposition of civil penalties. These
revisions did not, and do not, apply to material misstatements,
omissions, or certifications made prior to the interim rule's effective
date (October 11, 2018), or to violations occurring after the
implementation of the interim rule of a material provision of a
mitigation agreements or material conditions of an order entered into
or imposed prior to the implementation of the interim rule.
Section 800.902--Effect of lack of compliance. The proposed rule,
consistent with the interim rule, includes a provision authorizing the
Committee to negotiate a remediation plan for lack of compliance with a
mitigation agreement or condition entered into or imposed under section
721(l), require filings for future covered transactions for five years,
or seek injunctive relief, in addition to other available remedies.
The proposed rule includes certain other modifications to subpart
I, including with respect to how penalties are calculated, imposed, and
enforced.
III. Public Comments
The Department of the Treasury received one comment to the interim
rule. The commenter sought additional information about what
circumstances the Committee believes would warrant a 15-day extension
of an investigation in order ``to protect the national security of the
United States.''
Response: The interim rule provides that where a Committee member
requests to extend an investigation, that request must include a
description, ``with particularity, [of] the extraordinary circumstances
that warrant the Chairperson extending the investigation.'' 31 CFR
800.506. Accordingly, whether ``extraordinary circumstances'' exist
depends on the specific facts of a particular investigation, and are
difficult to generalize. While we understand the commenter's interest
in additional information from the Committee, at this time we are not
considering altering or expanding on the extraordinary circumstances
provisions relating to a 15-day extension of an investigation in part
800.
IV. Rulemaking Requirements
Executive Order 12866
These regulations are not subject to the general requirements of
Executive Order 12866, which covers review of regulations by the Office
of Information and Regulatory Affairs in the Office of Management and
Budget, because they relate to a foreign affairs function of the United
States, pursuant to section 3(d)(2) of that order.
Paperwork Reduction Act
The collections of information contained in this notice of proposed
rulemaking have been submitted to the Office of Management and Budget
for review in accordance with the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (44
U.S.C. 3507(d)) (PRA).
Comments on the collection of information should be sent to the
Office of Management and Budget, Attn: Desk Officer for the Department
of the Treasury, Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs,
Washington, DC 20503, or via email to [email protected], with
copies to Thomas Feddo, Deputy Assistant Secretary for Investment
Security, U.S. Department of the Treasury, 1500 Pennsylvania Avenue NW,
Washington, DC 20220. Comments on the collection of information should
be received by November 25, 2019.
In accordance with 5 CFR 1320.8(d)(1), the Department of the
Treasury is soliciting comments from members of the public concerning
this collection of information to:
(1) Evaluate whether the proposed collection of information is
necessary for the proper performance of the functions of the agency,
including whether the information will have practical utility;
(2) Evaluate the accuracy of the agency's estimate of the burden of
the proposed collection of information;
(3) Enhance the quality, utility, and clarity of the information to
be collected; and
(4) Minimize the burden of the collection of information on those
who are to respond; including through the use of appropriate automated
collection techniques or other forms of information technology.
The burden of the information collections in this proposed rule is
estimated as follows:
For Notices
Estimated total annual reporting and/or recordkeeping burden:
26,000 hours.
Estimated average annual burden per respondent: 130 hours.
Estimated number of respondents: 200 per year.
Estimated annual frequency of responses: Not applicable.
For Declarations
Estimated total annual reporting and/or recordkeeping burden:
11,000 hours.
Estimated average annual burden per respondent: 20 hours.
Estimated number of respondents: 550 per year.
Estimated annual frequency of responses: Not applicable.
Under the PRA, an agency may not conduct or sponsor, and a person
is not required to respond to, a collection of information unless it
displays a valid control number assigned by the Office of Management
and Budget.
Initial Regulatory Flexibility Analysis
The Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.) (RFA)
generally requires an agency to prepare a regulatory flexibility
analysis unless the agency certifies that the rule will not, once
implemented, have a significant economic impact on a substantial number
of small entities. The RFA applies whenever an agency is required to
publish a general notice of proposed rulemaking under section 553(b) of
the Administrative Procedure Act (5 U.S.C. 553) (APA), or any other
law. As set forth below, because regulations issued pursuant to the
DPA, such as these
[[Page 50182]]
regulations, are not subject to the APA, or another law requiring the
publication of a general notice of proposed rulemaking, the RFA does
not apply.
The proposed rule implements section 721 of the DPA. Section 709(a)
of the DPA provides that the regulations issued under it are not
subject to the rulemaking requirements of the APA. Section 709(b)(1)
instead provides that any regulation issued under the DPA be published
in the Federal Register and opportunity for public comment be provided
for not less than 30 days. Section 709(b)(3) of the DPA also provides
that all comments received during the public comment period be
considered and the publication of the final regulation contain written
responses to such comments. Consistent with the plain text of the DPA,
legislative history confirms that Congress intended that regulations
under the DPA be exempt from the notice and comment provisions of the
APA and instead provided that the agency include a statement that
interested parties were consulted in the formulation of the final
regulation. See H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 102-1028, at 42 (1992) and H.R.
Rep. No. 102-208 pt. 1, at 28 (1991). The limited public participation
procedures described in the DPA do not require a general notice of
proposed rulemaking as set forth in the RFA. Further, the mechanisms
for publication and public participation are sufficiently different to
distinguish the DPA procedures from a rule that requires a general
notice of proposed rulemaking. In providing the President with expanded
authority to suspend or prohibit the acquisition, merger, or takeover
of, or certain other investments in, a U.S. business by a foreign
person if such a transaction would threaten to impair the national
security of the United States, Congress could not have contemplated
that regulations implementing such authority would be subject to RFA
analysis. For these reasons, the RFA does not apply to these
regulations.
Notwithstanding the inapplicability of the RFA, the Department of
the Treasury has undertaken an analysis of the proposed rule's
potential impact on small businesses in the United States. While the
Department of the Treasury believes that the proposed rule likely would
not have a ``significant economic impact on a substantial number of
small entities'' (5 U.S.C. 605(b)), the Department of the Treasury does
not have complete data at this time to make this determination, and
therefore invites the public to comment on its analysis.
As discussed above, the proposed rule expands the jurisdiction of
the Committee to include additional types of transactions not
previously subject to CFIUS review. Additionally, the Committee will
retain its existing jurisdiction over any transaction through which any
foreign person could acquire control of any U.S. business. Accordingly,
the proposed rule may impact any U.S. business, including a small U.S.
business that engages in a covered transaction.
There is no single source for information on the number of small
U.S. businesses that receive foreign investment (direct or indirect),
including those involved with critical technologies, critical
infrastructure, or sensitive personal data, such that they would be
directly impacted by this rule. However, the Bureau of Economic
Analysis (BEA) within the Department of Commerce collects, on an annual
basis, data on new foreign direct investment in the United States
through its Survey of New Foreign Direct Investment in the United
States (Form BE[hyphen]13). While these data are self-reported, and
include only direct investments in U.S. businesses in which the foreign
person acquires at least 10 percent of the voting shares (and
consequently, do not capture investments below 10 percent, which may
nevertheless be covered transactions), they nonetheless provide
relevant information on a category of U.S. businesses that receive
foreign investment, some of which may be covered by the proposed rule.
According to the BEA, in 2018, the most current year for which data
is available, foreign persons obtained at least a 10 percent voting
share in 832 U.S. businesses. U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis,
``Number of Investments Initiated in 2018, Distribution of Planned
Total Expenditures, Size by Type of Investment,'' https://apps.bea.gov/international/xls/Table15-14-15-16-17-18.xls (last visited September
11, 2019). The BEA only reports the general size of the investment
transaction, not the type of the U.S. business involved, nor whether
the U.S. business is considered a ``small business'' by the Small
Business Administration (SBA), which defines small businesses based on
annual revenue or number of employees. The smallest foreign investment
transactions that the BEA reports are those with a dollar value below
$50 million. While not all U.S. businesses receiving a foreign
investment of less than $50 million are considered ``small'' for the
purposes of the RFA, many might be, and the number of U.S. businesses
receiving foreign investments of less than $50 million can serve as a
proxy for the number of transactions involving small U.S. businesses
that might be subject to CFIUS's jurisdiction.
Of the above mentioned 832 U.S. businesses receiving foreign
investment in 2018, 576 were involved in transactions valued at less
than $50 million. Although this figure is under inclusive because it
does not capture all transactions that could potentially fall under the
proposed rule, it also is over inclusive because it is not limited to
any particular type of U.S. business. We believe the figure of 576 is
the best estimate based on the available data of the number of small
U.S. businesses that may be impacted by this rule.
According to the SBA, there are 30.2 million small businesses
(defined as ``firms employing fewer than 500 employees'') in the United
States. https://www.sba.gov/sites/default/files/advocacy/2018-Small-Business-Profiles-US.pdf. If approximately 600 small U.S. businesses
will be potentially impacted by this rule, then the rule may
potentially impact less than one percent of all small U.S. businesses.
Accordingly, the Department of the Treasury does not believe the rule
will impact a ``substantial number of small entities.''
Nonetheless, the proposed rule includes provisions that would
reduce the costs to all businesses, including small businesses. For
example, the availability of a shorter declaration for covered
transactions may result in smaller cost to entities than having to
prepare a lengthier notice. Additionally, having a fillable form for
declarations may reduce some of the cost for parties.
The Department of the Treasury seeks information and comment on the
types and number of small entities potentially impacted by this
proposed rule. If necessary, the Department of the Treasury will
undertake a final regulatory flexibility analysis in the final rule.
List of Subjects in 31 CFR Part 800
Foreign investments in the United States, Investigations,
Investments, Investment companies, National defense, Reporting and
Recordkeeping requirements.
For the reasons set forth in the preamble, the Department of the
Treasury proposes to revise part 800 of title 31 of the Code of Federal
Regulations, to read as follows:
[[Page 50183]]
PART 800--REGULATIONS PERTAINING TO CERTAIN INVESTMENTS IN THE
UNITED STATES BY FOREIGN PERSONS
Subpart A--General
Sec.
800.101 Scope.
800.102 Risk-based analysis.
800.103 Effect on other law.
800.104 Applicability rule.
Subpart B--Definitions
800.201 Aggregated data.
800.202 Anonymized data.
800.203 Business day.
800.204 Certification.
800.205 Committee; Chairperson of the Committee; Staff Chairperson.
800.206 Completion date.
800.207 Contingent equity interest.
800.208 Control.
800.209 Conversion.
800.210 Covered control transaction.
800.211 Covered investment.
800.212 Covered investment critical infrastructure.
800.213 Covered transaction.
800.214 Critical infrastructure.
800.215 Critical technologies.
800.216 Effective date.
800.217 Encrypted data.
800.218 Entity.
800.219 Excepted foreign state.
800.220 Excepted investor.
800.221 Foreign entity.
800.222 Foreign government.
800.223 Foreign government-controlled transaction.
800.224 Foreign national.
800.225 Foreign person.
800.226 Hold.
800.227 Identifiable data.
800.228 Investment.
800.229 Investment fund.
800.230 Involvement.
800.231 Lead agency.
800.232 Manufacture.
800.233 Material nonpublic technical information.
800.234 Minimum excepted ownership.
800.235 Own.
800.236 Parent. 800.237 Party to a transaction.
800.238 Person. 800.239 Personal identifier.
800.240 Section 721.
800.241 Sensitive personal data.
800.242 Service.
800.243 Solely for the purpose of passive investment.
800.244 Substantial interest.
800.245 Substantive decisionmaking.
800.246 Supply.
800.247 Targets or tailors.
800.248 TID U.S. business.
800.249 Transaction.
800.250 Unaffiliated TID U.S. business.
800.251 United States.
800.252 U.S. business.
800.253 U.S. national.
800.254 Voting interest.
Subpart C--Coverage
800.301 Transactions that are covered control transactions.
800.302 Transactions that are not covered control transactions.
800.303 Transactions that are covered investments.
800.304 Transactions that are not covered investments.
800.305 Incremental acquisitions.
800.306 Lending transactions.
800.307 Specific clarifications for investment funds.
800.308 Timing rule for a contingent equity interest.
Subpart D--Declarations
800.401 Mandatory declarations.
800.402 Voluntary declarations.
800.403 Procedures for declarations.
800.404 Contents of declarations.
800.405 Beginning of 30-day assessment period.
800.406 Rejection, disposition, or withdrawal of declarations.
800.407 Committee actions.
Subpart E--Notices
800.501 Procedures for notices.
800.502 Contents of voluntary notices.
800.503 Beginning of a 45-day review period.
800.504 Deferral, rejection, or disposition of certain voluntary
notices.
800.505 Determination of whether to undertake an investigation.
800.506 Determination not to undertake an investigation.
800.507 Commencement of investigation.
800.508 Completion or termination of investigation and report to the
President.
800.509 Withdrawal of notices.
Subpart F--Committee Procedures
800.601 General.
800.602 Role of the Secretary of Labor.
800.603 Materiality.
800.604 Tolling of deadlines during lapse in appropriations.
Subpart G--Finality of Action
800.701 Finality of actions under section 721.
Subpart H--Provision and Handling of Information
800.801 Obligation of parties to provide information.
800.802 Confidentiality.
Subpart I--Penalties and Damages
800.901 Penalties and damages.
800.902 Effect of lack of compliance.
Subpart J--Foreign National Security Investment Review Regimes
800.1001 Determinations.
800.1002 Effect of determinations.
Appendix A to Part 800--Covered investment critical infrastructure
and functions related to covered investment critical infrastructure
Authority: 50 U.S.C. 4565; E.O. 11858, as amended, 73 FR 4677.
Subpart A--General
Sec. 800.101 Scope.
(a) Section 721 of title VII of the Defense Production Act of 1950
(50 U.S.C. 4565), as amended, authorizes the President to suspend or
prohibit any covered transaction, when, in the President's judgment,
there is credible evidence that leads the President to believe that the
foreign person engaging in a covered transaction might take action that
threatens to impair the national security of the United States, and
when provisions of law other than section 721 and the International
Emergency Economic Powers Act (50 U.S.C. 1701-1706), do not, in the
judgment of the President, provide adequate and appropriate authority
for the President to protect the national security in the matter before
the President. Section 721 also authorizes the Committee to review
covered transactions and to mitigate any risk to the national security
of the United States that arises as a result of such transactions.
(b) This part implements regulations pertaining to covered
transactions as defined in Sec. 800.213 of this part. Regulations
pertaining to covered real estate transactions are addressed in part
802 of this title.
Sec. 800.102 Risk-based analysis.
Any determination of the Committee with respect to a covered
transaction to suspend, refer to the President, or to negotiate, enter
into or impose, or enforce any agreement or condition under section 721
shall be based on a risk-based analysis, conducted by the Committee, of
the effects on the national security of the United States of the
covered transaction. Any such risk-based analysis shall include
credible evidence demonstrating the risk and an assessment of the
threat, vulnerabilities, and consequences to national security related
to the transaction. For purposes of this part, any such analysis of
risk shall include and be informed by consideration of the following
elements:
(a) The threat, which is a function of the intent and capability of
a foreign person to take action to impair the national security of the
United States;
(b) The vulnerabilities, which are the extent to which the nature
of the U.S. business presents susceptibility to impairment of national
security; and
(c) The consequences to national security, which are the potential
effects on national security that could reasonably result from the
exploitation of the vulnerabilities by the threat actor.
Sec. 800.103 Effect on other law.
Nothing in this part shall be construed as altering or affecting
any other authority, process, regulation, investigation, enforcement
measure, or review provided by or established under
[[Page 50184]]
any other provision of federal law, including without limitation the
International Emergency Economic Powers Act, or any other authority of
the President or the Congress under the Constitution of the United
States.
Sec. 800.104 Applicability rule.
(a) Except as provided in paragraphs (b) and (c) of this section
and otherwise in this part, the regulations in this part apply from
[EFFECTIVE DATE OF FINAL RULE].
(b) For any transaction for which the following has occurred before
[EFFECTIVE DATE OF FINAL RULE], the corresponding provisions of the
regulations in this part that were in effect the day before [EFFECTIVE
DATE OF FINAL RULE] will apply:
(1) The completion date;
(2) The parties to the transaction have executed a binding written
agreement, or other binding document, establishing the material terms
of the transaction;
(3) A party has made a public offer to shareholders to buy shares
of a U.S. business; or
(4) A shareholder has solicited proxies in connection with an
election of the board of directors of a U.S. business or an owner or
holder of a contingent equity interest has requested the conversion of
the contingent equity interest.
(c) For any transaction that, between November 10, 2018 and
[EFFECTIVE DATE], fell within the scope of part 801 of this title, the
regulations in part 801 will continue to apply.
Note 1 to Sec. 800.104: See subpart I (Penalties and Damages)
of this part for specific applicability rules pertaining to that
subpart.
Subpart B--Definitions
Sec. 800.201 Aggregated data.
The term aggregated data means data that have been combined or
collected together in summary or other form such that the data cannot
be identified with any individual.
Sec. 800.202 Anonymized data.
The term anonymized data means data from which all personal
identifiers have been completely removed.
Sec. 800.203 Business day.
The term business day means Monday through Friday, except the legal
public holidays specified in 5 U.S.C. 6103, any day declared to be a
holiday by federal statute or executive order, or any day with respect
to which the U.S. Office of Personnel Management has announced that
Federal agencies in the Washington, DC, area are closed to the public.
For purposes of calculating any deadline imposed by this part triggered
by the submission of a party to a transaction under Sec. 800.401(e)(2)
or Sec. 800.501(i), any submissions received after 5 p.m. Eastern Time
are deemed to be submitted on the next business day.
Note 1 to Sec. 800.203: See Sec. 800.604 regarding the tolling
of deadlines during a lapse in appropriations.
Sec. 800.204 Certification.
(a) The term certification means a written statement signed by the
chief executive officer or other duly authorized designee of a party
filing a notice, declaration, or information, certifying under the
penalties provided in the False Statements Accountability Act of 1996,
as amended (18 U.S.C. 1001) that the notice, declaration, or
information filed:
(1) Fully complies with the requirements of section 721, the
regulations in this part, and any agreement or condition entered into
with the Committee or any member of the Committee, and
(2) Is accurate and complete in all material respects, as it
relates to:
(i) The transaction, and
(ii) The party providing the certification, including its parents,
subsidiaries, and any other related entities described in the notice,
declaration, or information.
(b) For purposes of this section, a duly authorized designee is:
(1) In the case of a partnership, any general partner thereof;
(2) In the case of a corporation, any officer or director thereof;
(3) In the case of any entity lacking partners, officers, or
directors, any individual within the organization exercising executive
functions similar to those of a general partner of a partnership or an
officer or director of a corporation; and
(4) In the case of an individual, such individual or his or her
legal representative.
(c) In each case described in paragraphs (b)(1) through (4) of this
section, such designee must possess actual authority to make the
certification on behalf of the party filing a notice, declaration, or
information.
Note 1 to Sec. 800.204: A sample certification may be found at
the Committee's section of the Department of the Treasury website,
currently available at https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/international/the-committee-on-foreign-investment-in-the-united-states-cfius.
Sec. 800.205 Committee; Chairperson of the Committee; Staff
Chairperson.
The term Committee means the Committee on Foreign Investment in the
United States. The Chairperson of the Committee is the Secretary of the
Treasury. The Staff Chairperson of the Committee is the Department of
the Treasury official so designated by the Secretary of the Treasury or
by the Secretary's designee.
Sec. 800.206 Completion date.
The term completion date means, with respect to a transaction, the
earliest date upon which any ownership interest, including a contingent
equity interest, is conveyed, assigned, delivered, or otherwise
transferred to a person, or a change in rights that could result in a
covered control transaction or covered investment occurs.
Note 1 to Sec. 800.206: See Sec. 800.308 regarding the timing
rule for a contingent equity interest.
Sec. 800.207 Contingent equity interest.
The term contingent equity interest means a financial instrument
that currently does not constitute an equity interest but is
convertible into, or provides the right to acquire, an equity interest
upon the occurrence of a contingency or defined event.
Sec. 800.208 Control.
(a) The term control means the power, direct or indirect, whether
or not exercised, through the ownership of a majority or a dominant
minority of the total outstanding voting interest in an entity, board
representation, proxy voting, a special share, contractual
arrangements, formal or informal arrangements to act in concert, or
other means, to determine, direct, or decide important matters
affecting an entity; in particular, but without limitation, to
determine, direct, take, reach, or cause decisions regarding the
following matters, or any other similarly important matters affecting
an entity:
(1) The sale, lease, mortgage, pledge, or other transfer of any of
the tangible or intangible principal assets of the entity, whether or
not in the ordinary course of business;
(2) The reorganization, merger, or dissolution of the entity;
(3) The closing, relocation, or substantial alteration of the
production, operational, or research and development facilities of the
entity;
(4) Major expenditures or investments, issuances of equity or debt,
or dividend payments by the entity, or approval of the operating budget
of the entity;
[[Page 50185]]
(5) The selection of new business lines or ventures that the entity
will pursue;
(6) The entry into, termination, or non-fulfillment by the entity
of significant contracts;
(7) The policies or procedures of the entity governing the
treatment of non-public technical, financial, or other proprietary
information of the entity;
(8) The appointment or dismissal of officers or senior managers or
in the case of a partnership, the general partner;
(9) The appointment or dismissal of employees with access to
critical technology or other sensitive technology or classified U.S.
Government information; or
(10) The amendment of the Articles of Incorporation, constituent
agreement, or other organizational documents of the entity with respect
to the matters described in paragraphs (a)(1) through (9) of this
section.
(b) In examining questions of control in situations where more than
one foreign person has an ownership interest in an entity,
consideration will be given to factors such as whether the foreign
persons are related or have formal or informal arrangements to act in
concert, whether they are agencies or instrumentalities of the national
or subnational governments of a single foreign state, and whether a
given foreign person and another person that has an ownership interest
in the entity are both controlled by any of the national or subnational
governments of a single foreign state.
(c) The following minority shareholder protections shall not in
themselves be deemed to confer control over an entity:
(1) The power to prevent the sale or pledge of all or substantially
all of the assets of an entity or a voluntary filing for bankruptcy or
liquidation;
(2) The power to prevent an entity from entering into contracts
with majority investors or their affiliates;
(3) The power to prevent an entity from guaranteeing the
obligations of majority investors or their affiliates;
(4) The power to purchase an additional interest in an entity to
prevent the dilution of an investor's pro rata interest in that entity
in the event that the entity issues additional instruments conveying
interests in the entity;
(5) The power to prevent the change of existing legal rights or
preferences of the particular class of stock held by minority
investors, as provided in the relevant corporate documents governing
such shares; and
(6) The power to prevent the amendment of the Articles of
Incorporation, constituent agreement, or other organizational documents
of an entity with respect to the matters described in paragraphs (c)(1)
through (5) of this section.
(d) The Committee will consider, on a case-by-case basis, whether
minority shareholder protections other than those listed in paragraph
(c) of this section do not confer control over an entity.
(e) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A is a U.S. business. A U.S. investor
owns 50 percent of the voting interest in Corporation A, and the
remaining voting interest is owned in equal shares by five unrelated
foreign investors. The foreign investors jointly financed their
investment in Corporation A and vote as a single block on matters
affecting Corporation A. The foreign investors have an informal
arrangement to act in concert with regard to Corporation A, and, as
a result, the foreign investors control Corporation A.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as in Example 1 of this section with
regard to the composition of Corporation A's shareholders. The
foreign investors in Corporation A have no contractual or other
commitments to act in concert, and have no informal arrangements to
do so. Assuming no other relevant facts, the foreign investors do
not control Corporation A.
(3) Example 3. Corporation A, a foreign person, is a private
equity fund that routinely acquires equity interests in companies
and manages them for a period of time. Corporation B is a U.S.
business. In addition to its acquisition of seven percent of
Corporation B's voting shares, Corporation A acquires the right to
terminate significant contracts of Corporation B. Corporation A
controls Corporation B.
(4) Example 4. Corporation A, a foreign person, acquires a nine
percent interest in the shares of Corporation B, a U.S. business. As
part of the transaction, Corporation A also acquires certain veto
rights that determine important matters affecting Corporation B,
including the right to veto the dismissal of senior executives of
Corporation B. Corporation A controls Corporation B.
(5) Example 5. Corporation A, a foreign person, acquires a
thirteen percent interest in the shares of Corporation B, a U.S.
business, and the right to appoint one member of Corporation B's
seven-member Board of Directors. Corporation A receives minority
shareholder protections listed in Sec. 800.208(c) but receives no
other positive or negative rights with respect to Corporation B.
Assuming no other relevant facts, Corporation A does not control
Corporation B.
(6) Example 6. Corporation A, a foreign person, acquires a
twenty percent interest in the shares of Corporation B, a U.S.
business. Corporation A has negotiated an irrevocable passivity
agreement that completely precludes it from controlling Corporation
B. Corporation A does, however, receive the right to prevent
Corporation B from entering into contracts with majority investors
or their affiliates and to prevent Corporation B from guaranteeing
the obligations of majority investors or their affiliates. Assuming
no other relevant facts, Corporation A does not control Corporation
B.
(7) Example 7. Limited Partnership A comprises two limited
partners, each of which holds 49 percent of the interest in the
partnership, and a general partner, which holds two percent of the
interest. The general partner has sole authority to determine,
direct, and decide all important matters affecting the partnership
and a fund operated by the partnership. The general partner alone
controls Limited Partnership A and the fund.
(8) Example 8. Same facts as in Example 7 of this section,
except that each of the limited partners has the authority to veto
major investments proposed by the general partner and to choose the
fund's representatives on the boards of the fund's portfolio
companies. The general partner and the limited partners each have
control over Limited Partnership A and the fund.
Note 1 to Sec. 800.208: See Sec. 800.302(b) regarding the
Committee's treatment of transactions in which a foreign person
holds or acquires ten percent or less of the outstanding voting
interest in a U.S. business solely for the purpose of passive
investment. See Sec. 800.303 regarding the Committee's treatment of
transactions that do not result in control over a U.S. business by a
foreign person, but may be covered investments. See Sec. 800.305
regarding the Committee's treatment of a subsequent transaction
involving a foreign person that previously acquired control of the
U.S. business.
Sec. 800.209 Conversion.
The term conversion means the exercise of a right inherent in the
ownership or holding of a particular financial instrument to exchange
any such instrument for an equity interest.
Sec. 800.210 Covered control transaction.
The term covered control transaction means any transaction that is
proposed or pending after August 23, 1988, by or with any foreign
person that could result in foreign control of any U.S. business,
including without limitation such a transaction carried out through a
joint venture.
Sec. 800.211 Covered investment.
The term covered investment means an investment, direct or
indirect, by a foreign person other than an excepted investor in an
unaffiliated TID U.S. business that is proposed or pending after
[EFFECTIVE DATE OF FINAL RULE], and that:
(a) Is not a covered control transaction; and
(b) Affords the foreign person:
(1) Access to any material nonpublic technical information in the
possession of the TID U.S. business;
(2) Membership or observer rights on the board of directors or
equivalent
[[Page 50186]]
governing body of the TID U.S. business or the right to nominate an
individual to a position on the board of directors or equivalent
governing body of the TID U.S. business; or
(3) Any involvement, other than through voting of shares, in
substantive decisionmaking of the TID U.S. business regarding:
(i) The use, development, acquisition, safekeeping, or release of
sensitive personal data of U.S. citizens maintained or collected by the
TID U.S. business;
(ii) The use, development, acquisition, or release of critical
technologies; or
(iii) The management, operation, manufacture, or supply of covered
investment critical infrastructure.
(c) Notwithstanding paragraphs (a) and (b) of this section, no
investment involving an air carrier, as defined in 49 U.S.C.
40102(a)(2), that holds a certificate issued under 49 U.S.C. 41102
shall be a covered investment.
Sec. 800.212 Covered investment critical infrastructure.
The term covered investment critical infrastructure means, in the
context of a particular covered investment, the systems and assets,
whether physical or virtual, set forth in Column 1 of appendix A to
part 800.
Sec. 800.213 Covered transaction.
The term covered transaction means any of the following:
(a) A covered control transaction;
(b) A covered investment;
(c) A change in the rights that a foreign person has with respect
to a U.S. business in which the foreign person has an investment, if
that change could result in a covered control transaction or a covered
investment; or
(d) Any other transaction, transfer, agreement, or arrangement, the
structure of which is designed or intended to evade or circumvent the
application of section 721.
Note 1 to Sec. 800.213: Any transaction described in (a)
through (d) of this section that arises pursuant to a bankruptcy
proceeding or other form of default on debt is a covered
transaction. See also Sec. 800.306 for the treatment of certain
lending transactions.
Sec. 800.214 Critical infrastructure.
The term critical infrastructure means, in the context of a
particular covered control transaction, systems and assets, whether
physical or virtual, so vital to the United States that the incapacity
or destruction of such systems or assets would have a debilitating
impact on national security.
Sec. 800.215 Critical technologies.
The term critical technologies means the following:
(a) Defense articles or defense services included on the United
States Munitions List (USML) set forth in the International Traffic in
Arms Regulations (ITAR) (22 CFR parts 120-130);
(b) Items included on the Commerce Control List set forth in
Supplement No. 1 to part 774 of the Export Administration Regulations
(EAR) (15 CFR parts 730-774), and controlled--
(1) Pursuant to multilateral regimes, including for reasons
relating to national security, chemical and biological weapons
proliferation, nuclear nonproliferation, or missile technology; or
(2) For reasons relating to regional stability or surreptitious
listening;
(c) Specially designed and prepared nuclear equipment, parts and
components, materials, software, and technology covered by 10 CFR part
810 (relating to assistance to foreign atomic energy activities);
(d) Nuclear facilities, equipment, and material covered by 10 CFR
part 110 (relating to export and import of nuclear equipment and
material);
(e) Select agents and toxins covered by 7 CFR part 331, 9 CFR part
121, or 42 CFR part 73; and
(f) Emerging and foundational technologies controlled pursuant to
section 1758 of the Export Control Reform Act of 2018 (50 U.S.C. 4817).
Sec. 800.216 Effective date.
The term effective date means [EFFECTIVE DATE OF FINAL RULE].
Sec. 800.217 Encrypted data.
The term encrypted data means data to which National Institute of
Standards and Technology (NIST)-allowed cryptographic techniques, as
identified in the most current NIST special publication 800-175B, or
superseding publication, have been applied.
Sec. 800.218 Entity.
The term entity means any branch, partnership, group or sub-group,
association, estate, trust, corporation or division of a corporation,
or organization (whether or not organized under the laws of any State
or foreign state); assets (whether or not organized as a separate legal
entity) operated by any one of the foregoing as a business undertaking
in a particular location or for particular products or services; and
any government (including a foreign national or subnational government,
the U.S. Government, a subnational government within the United States,
and any of their respective departments, agencies, or
instrumentalities). (See examples in Sec. 800.301(g)(5) through (14)
and Sec. 800.302(g)(5) through (10).)
Sec. 800.219 Excepted foreign state.
The term excepted foreign state means each foreign state from time
to time identified by the Chairperson of the Committee, with the
agreement of two-thirds of the voting members of the Committee, and,
beginning on [TWO YEARS AFTER EFFECTIVE DATE OF FINAL RULE] with
respect to which the Chairperson of the Committee has made a
determination pursuant to Sec. 800.1001(a).
Note 1 to Sec. 800.219: The name of each foreign state
identified by the Chairperson of the Committee as an excepted
foreign state will be published in a notice in the Federal Register
and incorporated into the Committee's list of excepted foreign
states.
Sec. 800.220 Excepted investor.
(a) The term excepted investor means a foreign person who is, as of
the completion date and subject to paragraphs (c) and (d) of this
section:
(1) A foreign national who is a national of one or more excepted
foreign states and is not also a national of any foreign state that is
not an excepted foreign state;
(2) A foreign government of an excepted foreign state; or
(3) A foreign entity that meets each of the following conditions
with respect to itself and each of its parents (if any):
(i) Such entity is organized under the laws of an excepted foreign
state or in the United States;
(ii) Such entity has its principal place of business in an excepted
foreign state or the United States;
(iii) Each member or observer of the board of directors or similar
body of such entity is a U.S. national or, if a foreign national, is a
national of one or more excepted foreign states and is not also a
national of any foreign state that is not an excepted foreign state;
(iv) Any foreign person that individually holds, or each foreign
person that is part of a group of foreign persons that, in the
aggregate, holds, five percent or more of the outstanding voting
interest of such entity; holds the right to five percent or more of the
profits of such entity; holds the right in the event of dissolution to
five percent or more of the assets of such entity; or could exercise
control over such entity, is:
(A) A foreign national who is a national of one or more excepted
foreign states and is not also a national of any foreign state that is
not an excepted foreign state;
[[Page 50187]]
(B) A foreign government of an excepted foreign state; or
(C) A foreign entity that is organized under the laws of an
excepted foreign state and has its principal place of business in an
excepted foreign state or in the United States; and
(v) The minimum excepted ownership of such entity is held,
individually or in the aggregate, by one or more persons each of whom
is:
(A) Not a foreign person;
(B) A foreign national who is a national of one or more excepted
foreign states and is not also a national of any foreign state that is
not an excepted foreign state;
(C) A foreign government of an excepted foreign state; or
(D) A foreign entity that is organized under the laws of an
excepted foreign state and has its principal place of business in an
excepted foreign state or in the United States.
(b) When more than one person holds an ownership interest in an
entity, in determining whether the ownership interests of such persons
should be aggregated for purposes of paragraph (a)(3)(iv) of this
section, consideration will be given to factors such as whether the
persons holding the ownership interests are related or have formal or
informal arrangements to act in concert, whether they are agencies or
instrumentalities of the national or subnational governments of a
single foreign state, and whether a given foreign person and another
foreign person that has an ownership interest in the entity are both
controlled by any of the national or subnational governments of a
single foreign state.
(c) Notwithstanding paragraph (a) of this section, a foreign person
is not an excepted investor with respect to a transaction if:
(1) In the five years prior to the completion date of the
transaction the foreign person or any of its parents or subsidiaries:
(i) Has received written notice from the Committee that it has
submitted a material misstatement or omission in a notice or
declaration or made a false certification under this part or parts 801
or 802 of this title;
(ii) Has received written notice from the Committee that it has
violated a material provision of a mitigation agreement entered into
with, material condition imposed by, or an order issued by, the
Committee or a lead agency under section 721(l);
(iii) Has been subject to action by the President under section
721(d);
(iv) Has:
(A) Received a written Finding of Violation or Penalty Notice
imposing a civil monetary penalty from the Department of the Treasury
Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC); or
(B) Entered into a settlement agreement with OFAC with respect to
apparent violations of U.S. sanctions laws administered by OFAC,
including without limitation the International Emergency Economic
Powers Act, the Trading With the Enemy Act, the Foreign Narcotics
Kingpin Designation Act, each as amended, or of any executive order,
regulation, order, directive, or license issued pursuant thereto;
(v) Has received a written notice of debarment from the Department
of State Directorate of Defense Trade Controls, as described in 22 CFR
parts 127 and 128;
(vi) Has been a respondent or party in a final order, including a
settlement order, issued by the Department of Commerce Bureau of
Industry and Security (BIS) regarding violations of U.S. export control
laws administered by BIS, including without limitation the Export
Control Reform Act of 2018 (Title XVII, Subtitle B of Pub. L. 115-232,
132 Stat. 2208, 50 U.S.C. 4801, et seq.), the EAR, or of any executive
order, regulation, order, directive, or license issued pursuant
thereto;
(vii) Has received a final decision from the Department of Energy
National Nuclear Security Administration imposing a civil penalty with
respect to a violation of section 57 b. of the Atomic Energy Act of
1954, as implemented under 10 CFR part 810; or
(viii) Has been convicted of a crime under, or has entered into a
deferred prosecution agreement or non-prosecution agreement with the
Department of Justice with respect to a violation of, any felony crime
in any jurisdiction within the United States; or
(2) The foreign person or any of its parents or subsidiaries is, on
the date on which the parties to the transaction first execute a
binding written agreement, or other binding document, establishing the
material terms of the transaction, listed on either the BIS Unverified
List or Entity List in 15 CFR part 744.
(d) Irrespective of whether the foreign person satisfies the
criteria in paragraphs (a)(1), (2), or (3)(i) through (iii) of this
section as of the completion date, if at any time during the three-year
period following the completion date, the foreign person no longer
meets all the criteria set forth in paragraphs (a)(1), (2), or (3)(i)
through (iii) of this section, the foreign person is not an excepted
investor with respect to the transaction from the completion date
onward. This paragraph does not apply when an excepted investor no
longer meets any of the criteria solely due to a rescission of a
determination under Sec. 800.1001(b) or if a particular foreign state
otherwise ceases to be an excepted foreign state.
(e) A foreign person may waive its status as an excepted investor
with respect to a transaction at any time by submitting a declaration
pursuant to Sec. 800.403 or filing a notice pursuant to Sec. 800.501
regarding the transaction in which it explicitly waives such status. In
such case, the foreign person will be deemed not to be an excepted
investor and the provisions of Subpart D or E, as applicable, will
apply.
Note 1 to Sec. 800.220: See Sec. 800.501(c)(2) regarding an
agency notice where a foreign person is not an excepted investor
solely due to Sec. 800.220(d).
Sec. 800.221 Foreign entity.
(a) The term foreign entity means any branch, partnership, group or
sub-group, association, estate, trust, corporation or division of a
corporation, or organization organized under the laws of a foreign
state if either its principal place of business is outside the United
States or its equity securities are primarily traded on one or more
foreign exchanges.
(b) Notwithstanding paragraph (a) of this section, any branch,
partnership, group or sub-group, association, estate, trust,
corporation or division of a corporation, or organization that
demonstrates that a majority of the equity interest in such entity is
ultimately owned by U.S. nationals is not a foreign entity.
Sec. 800.222 Foreign government.
The term foreign government means any government or body exercising
governmental functions, other than the U.S. Government or a subnational
government of the United States. The term includes, but is not limited
to, national and subnational governments, including their respective
departments, agencies, and instrumentalities.
Sec. 800.223 Foreign government-controlled transaction.
The term foreign government-controlled transaction means any
covered control transaction that could result in control of a U.S.
business by a foreign government or a person controlled by or acting on
behalf of a foreign government.
Sec. 800.224 Foreign national.
The term foreign national means any individual other than a U.S.
national.
Sec. 800.225 Foreign person.
(a) The term foreign person means:
(1) Any foreign national, foreign government, or foreign entity; or
[[Page 50188]]
(2) Any entity over which control is exercised or exercisable by a
foreign national, foreign government, or foreign entity.
(b) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A is organized under the laws of a
foreign state and is engaged in business only outside the United
States. All of its shares are held by Corporation X, which solely
controls Corporation A. Corporation X is organized in the United
States and is wholly owned and controlled by U.S. nationals.
Assuming no other relevant facts, Corporation A, although organized
and only operating outside the United States, is not a foreign
person.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as in the first sentence of Example 1
of this section. The government of the foreign state under whose
laws Corporation A is organized exercises control over Corporation A
because a law establishing Corporation A gives the foreign state the
right to appoint Corporation A's board members. Corporation A is a
foreign person.
(3) Example 3. Corporation A is organized in the United States,
is engaged in interstate commerce in the United States, and is
controlled by Corporation X. Corporation X is organized under the
laws of a foreign state, its principal place of business is located
outside the United States, and 50 percent of its shares are held by
foreign nationals and 50 percent of its shares are held by U.S.
nationals. Both Corporation A and Corporation X are foreign persons.
Corporation A is also a U.S. business.
(4) Example 4. Corporation A is organized under the laws of a
foreign state and is owned and controlled by a foreign national. A
branch of Corporation A engages in interstate commerce in the United
States. Corporation A (including its branch) is a foreign person.
The branch is also a U.S. business.
(5) Example 5. Corporation A is a corporation organized under
the laws of a foreign state and its principal place of business is
located outside the United States. Forty-five percent of the voting
interest in Corporation A is owned in equal shares by numerous
unrelated foreign investors, none of whom has control. The foreign
investors have no formal or informal arrangement to act in concert
with regard to Corporation A with any other holder of voting
interest in Corporation A. Corporation A demonstrates that the
remainder of the voting interest in Corporation A is held by U.S.
nationals. Assuming no other relevant facts, Corporation A is not a
foreign person.
(6) Example 6. Same facts as Example 5 of this section, except
that one of the foreign investors controls Corporation A. Assuming
no other relevant facts, Corporation A is not a foreign entity
pursuant to Sec. 800.221(b), but it is a foreign person because it
is controlled by a foreign person.
Sec. 800.226 Hold.
The terms hold(s) and holding mean legal or beneficial ownership,
whether direct or indirect, whether through fiduciaries, agents, or
other means.
Sec. 800.227 Identifiable data.
The term identifiable data means data that can be used to
distinguish or trace an individual's identity, including without
limitation through the use of any personal identifier. For the
avoidance of doubt, aggregated data or anonymized data is identifiable
data if any party to the transaction has, or as a result of the
transaction will have, the ability to disaggregate or de-anonymize the
data, or if the data is otherwise capable of being used to distinguish
or trace an individual's identity. Identifiable data does not include
encrypted data, unless the U.S. business that maintains or collects the
encrypted data has the means to de-encrypt the data so as to
distinguish or trace an individual's identity.
Sec. 800.228 Investment.
The term investment means the acquisition of equity interest,
including contingent equity interest.
Sec. 800.229 Investment fund.
The term investment fund means any entity that is an ``investment
company,'' as defined in section 3(a) of the Investment Company Act of
1940 (15 U.S.C. 80a-1 et seq.), or would be an ``investment company''
but for one or more of the exemptions provided in section 3(b) or 3(c)
thereunder.
Sec. 800.230 Involvement.
The term involvement means the right or ability to participate,
whether or not exercised, including without limitation by doing any of
the following:
(a) Providing input into a final decision;
(b) Consulting with or providing advice to a decisionmaker;
(c) Exercising special approval or veto rights;
(d) Participating on a committee with decisionmaking authority; or
(e) Advising on the appointment officers or selecting employees who
are engaged in substantive decisionmaking.
Sec. 800.231 Lead agency.
The term lead agency means the Department of the Treasury and any
other agency designated by the Chairperson of the Committee to have
primary responsibility, on behalf of the Committee, for the specific
activity for which the Chairperson designates it as a lead agency,
including without limitation all or a portion of an assessment, a
review, an investigation, or the negotiation or monitoring of a
mitigation agreement or condition.
Sec. 800.232 Manufacture.
Solely for the purposes of Column 2 of appendix A to part 800, the
term manufacture means to produce or reproduce, whether physically or
virtually.
Sec. 800.233 Material nonpublic technical information.
(a) The term material nonpublic technical information means
information that:
(1) Provides knowledge, know-how, or understanding not available in
the public domain, of the design, location, or operation of critical
infrastructure, including without limitation vulnerability information
such as that related to physical security or cybersecurity; or
(2) Is not available in the public domain and is necessary to
design, fabricate, develop, test, produce, or manufacture a critical
technology, including without limitation processes, techniques, or
methods;
(b) The term material nonpublic technical information does not
include financial information regarding the performance of an entity.
(c) Example: Corporation A, a foreign person that is not an
excepted investor, proposes to acquire a four percent, non-controlling
equity interest in Corporation B. Corporation B is a U.S. business that
services an industrial control system utilized by an interstate oil
pipeline that has the capacity to transport 600,000 barrels per day of
crude oil (ICS B). ICS B is covered investment critical infrastructure
as set forth in Column 1 of appendix A to part 800. The source code for
ICS B is not available in the public domain. Pursuant to the terms of
the investment, Corporation A will have access to the source code for
ICS B. The proposed investment therefore affords Corporation A access
to material nonpublic technical information in the possession
Corporation B regarding the design and operation of covered investment
critical infrastructure.
Sec. 800.234 Minimum excepted ownership.
The term minimum excepted ownership means:
(a) With respect to an entity whose equity securities are primarily
traded on an exchange in an excepted foreign state or the United
States, a majority of its voting interest, the right to a majority of
its profits, and the right in the event of dissolution to a majority of
its assets; and
(b) With respect to an entity whose equity securities are not
primarily traded on an exchange in an excepted foreign state or the
United States, 90 percent or more of its voting interest, the right to
90 percent or more of its profits, and the right in the event of
[[Page 50189]]
dissolution to 90 percent or more of its assets.
Sec. 800.235 Own.
Solely for the purposes of Column 2 of appendix A to part 800, the
term own means to directly possess the applicable covered investment
critical infrastructure.
Sec. 800.236 Parent.
(a) The term parent means a person who or which directly or
indirectly:
(1) Holds or will hold at least 50 percent of the outstanding
voting interest in an entity; or
(2) Holds or will hold the right to at least 50 percent of the
profits of an entity, or has or will have the right in the event of the
dissolution to at least 50 percent of the assets of that entity.
(b) Any entity that meets the conditions of paragraph (a)(1) or (2)
of this section with respect to another entity (i.e., the intermediate
parent) is also a parent of any other entity of which the intermediate
parent is a parent.
(c) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation P holds 50 percent of the voting
interest in Corporations R and S. Corporation R holds 40 percent of
the voting interest in Corporation X; Corporation S holds 50 percent
of the voting interest in Corporation Y, which in turn holds 50
percent of the voting interest in Corporation Z. Corporation P is a
parent of Corporations R, S, Y, and Z, but not of Corporation X.
Corporation S is a parent of Corporation Y and Z, and Corporation Y
is a parent of Corporation Z.
(2) Example 2. Corporation A holds warrants which when exercised
will entitle it to vote 50 percent of the outstanding shares of
Corporation B. Corporation A is a parent of Corporation B.
Sec. 800.237 Party to a transaction.
(a) The term party to a transaction means:
(1) In the case of an acquisition of an ownership interest in an
entity, the person acquiring the ownership interest, the person from
which such ownership interest is acquired, and the entity whose
ownership interest is being acquired, without regard to any person
providing brokerage or underwriting services for the transaction;
(2) In the case of a merger, the surviving entity, and the entity
or entities that are merged into that entity as a result of the
transaction;
(3) In the case of a consolidation, the entities being
consolidated, and the new consolidated entity;
(4) In the case of a proxy solicitation, the person soliciting
proxies, and the person who issued the voting interest;
(5) In the case of the acquisition or conversion of contingent
equity interests, the issuer and the person holding the contingent
equity interests;
(6) In the case of a change in rights that a person has with
respect to an entity in which that person has an investment, the person
whose rights change as a result of the transaction and the entity to
which those rights apply;
(7) In the case of a transfer, agreement, arrangement, or any other
type of transaction, the structure of which is designed or intended to
evade or circumvent the application of section 721, any person that
participates in such transfer, agreement, arrangement, or other type of
transaction;
(8) In the case of any other type of transaction, any person who is
in a role comparable to that of a person described in paragraphs (a)(1)
through (7) of this section; and
(9) In all cases, each party that submitted a declaration or notice
to the Committee regarding a transaction.
(b) For purposes of section 721(l), the term party to a transaction
includes any affiliate of any party described in paragraphs (a)(1)
through (9) of this section that the Committee, or a lead agency acting
on behalf of the Committee, determines is relevant to mitigating a risk
to the national security of the United States.
Sec. 800.238 Person.
The term person means any individual or entity.
Sec. 800.239 Personal identifier.
The term personal identifier means name, physical address, email
address, social security number, phone number, or other information
that identifies a specific individual.
Sec. 800.240 Section 721.
The term section 721 means section 721 of title VII of the Defense
Production Act of 1950 (50 U.S.C. 4565), as amended.
Sec. 800.241 Sensitive personal data.
(a) The term sensitive personal data means, except as provided in
paragraph (b) of this section:
(1) Identifiable data that is:
(i) Maintained or collected by a U.S. business that:
(A) Targets or tailors products or services to any U.S. executive
branch agency or military department with intelligence, national
security, or homeland security responsibilities, or to personnel and
contractors thereof;
(B) Has maintained or collected such data on greater than one
million individuals at any point over the preceding twelve (12) months;
or
(C) Has a demonstrated business objective to maintain or collect
such data on greater than one million individuals and such data is an
integrated part of the U.S. business's primary products or services;
and
(ii) Within any of the following categories:
(A) Data that could be used to analyze or determine an individual's
financial distress or hardship;
(B) The set of data in a consumer report, as defined pursuant to 15
U.S.C. 1681a, unless such data is obtained from a consumer reporting
agency for one or more purposes identified in 15 U.S.C. 1681b(a) and
such data is not substantially similar to the full contents of a
consumer file as defined pursuant to 15 U.S.C. 1681a.;
(C) The set of data in an application for health insurance, long-
term care insurance, professional liability insurance, mortgage
insurance, or life insurance;
(D) Data relating to the physical, mental, or psychological health
condition of an individual;
(E) Non-public electronic communications, including without
limitation email, messaging, or chat communications, between or among
users of a U.S. business's products or services if a primary purpose of
such product or service is to facilitate third-party user
communications;
(F) Geolocation data collected using positioning systems, cell
phone towers, or WiFi access points such as via a mobile application,
vehicle GPS, other onboard mapping tool, or wearable electronic device;
(G) Biometric enrollment data including without limitation facial,
voice, retina/iris, and palm/fingerprint templates;
(H) Data stored and processed for generating a state or federal
government identification card;
(I) Data concerning U.S. Government personnel security clearance
status; or
(J) The set of data in an application for a U.S. Government
personnel security clearance or an application for employment in a
position of public trust; and
(2) Genetic information, as defined pursuant to 45 CFR 160.103.
(b) The term sensitive personal data shall not include, regardless
of the applicability of the criteria described in paragraph (a) of this
section:
(1) Data maintained or collected by a U.S. business concerning the
employees of that U.S. business, unless the data pertains to employees
of U.S. Government contractors who hold U.S. Government personnel
security clearances; or
(2) Data that is a matter of public record, such as court records
or other
[[Page 50190]]
government records that are generally available to the public.
Sec. 800.242 Service.
Solely for the purposes of Column 2 of appendix A to part 800, the
term service means to repair, maintain, refurbish, replace, overhaul,
or update.
Sec. 800.243 Solely for the purpose of passive investment.
(a) Ownership interests are held or acquired solely for the purpose
of passive investment if the person holding or acquiring such interests
does not plan or intend to exercise control and--
(1) Is not afforded any rights that if exercised would constitute
control;
(2) Does not acquire any access, rights, or involvement specified
Sec. 800.211(b);
(3) Does not possess or develop any purpose other than passive
investment; and
(4) Does not take any action inconsistent with holding or acquiring
such interests solely for the purpose of passive investment. (See Sec.
800.302(b).)
(b) Example: Corporation A, a foreign person, acquires a voting
interest in Corporation B, a U.S. business. In addition to the voting
interest, Corporation A negotiates the right to appoint a member of
Corporation B's Board of Directors. The acquisition by Corporation A of
a voting interest in Corporation B is not solely for the purpose of
passive investment.
Sec. 800.244 Substantial interest.
(a) The term substantial interest means a voting interest, direct
or indirect, of 25 percent or more by a foreign person in a U.S.
business and a voting interest, direct or indirect, of 49 percent or
more by a foreign government in a foreign person.
(b) In the case of entity organized as a limited partnership, a
foreign government will be considered to have a substantial interest in
such partnership if either:
(1) It holds 49 percent or more of the voting interest in the
general partner; or
(2) It is a limited partner and holds 49 percent or more of the
voting interest of the limited partners.
(c) For purposes of determining the percentage of voting interest
held indirectly by one entity in another entity, any voting interest of
a parent will be deemed to be a 100 percent voting interest in any
entity of which it is a parent.
Sec. 800.245 Substantive decisionmaking.
(a) The term substantive decisionmaking means the process through
which decisions regarding significant matters affecting an entity are
undertaken, including without limitation, as applicable:
(1) Pricing, sales, and specific contracts, including without
limitation the license, sale, or transfer of sensitive personal data to
any third party, including without limitation pursuant to a customer,
vendor, or joint venture agreement;
(2) Supply arrangements;
(3) Corporate strategy and business development;
(4) Research and development, including without limitation location
and budget allocation;
(5) Manufacturing locations;
(6) Access to critical technologies, covered investment critical
infrastructure, material nonpublic technical information, or sensitive
personal data, including without limitation pursuant to a customer,
vendor, or joint venture agreement;
(7) Physical and cyber security protocols, including without
limitation the storage and protection of critical technologies, covered
investment critical infrastructure, or sensitive personal data;
(8) Practices, policies, and procedures governing the collection,
use, or storage of sensitive personal data, including without
limitation:
(i) The establishment or maintenance of, or changes to, the
architecture of information technology systems and networks used in
collecting or maintaining sensitive personal data; or
(ii) Privacy policies and agreements for individuals from whom
sensitive personal data is collected setting forth parameters regarding
whether and how sensitive personal data may be collected, maintained,
accessed, or disseminated; or
(9) Strategic partnerships.
(b) The term substantive decisionmaking does not include strictly
administrative decisions.
(c) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, a foreign person that is not an
excepted investor, proposes to acquire a four percent, non-
controlling equity interest in Corporation B. Corporation B is an
unaffiliated TID U.S. business that operates a container terminal at
a strategic seaport within the National Port Readiness Network
(Terminal B). Pursuant to the terms of the investment, Corporation A
will have approval rights over which customers may utilize Terminal
B. The proposed investment therefore affords Corporation A
involvement in substantive decisionmaking of Corporation B regarding
the management, operation, manufacture, or supply of covered
investment critical infrastructure.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as Example 1 of this section, except
that instead of customer approval rights, Corporation A has the
right to decide whether to claim certain tax credits with respect to
Terminal B on its own income tax filing, which prevents Corporation
B from claiming such credits. Assuming no other relevant facts, the
proposed investment does not afford Corporation A involvement in
substantive decisionmaking of Corporation B regarding the
management, operation, manufacture, or supply of covered investment
critical infrastructure.
Sec. 800.246 Supply.
Solely for the purposes of Column 2 of appendix A to part 800, the
term supply means to provide third-party physical or cyber security.
Sec. 800.247 Targets or tailors.
(a) The term targets or tailors means customizing products or
services for use by a person or group of persons or actively marketing
to or soliciting a person or group of persons.
(b) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, a U.S. business, operates
facilities throughout the United States that offer healthcare-
related products and services. Some of Corporation A's facilities
are located within metropolitan areas that also include U.S.
military facilities. Absent additional relevant facts, Corporation A
does not target or tailor its products or services for purposes of
Sec. 800.241(a)(1)(i)(A).
(2) Example 2. Same facts as Example 2 of this section, except
that Corporation A operates a facility on the premises of a U.S.
military facility. Corporation A targets or tailors its products or
services for purposes of Sec. 800.241(a)(1)(i)(A).
(3) Example 3. Corporation A, a U.S. business, offers a discount
to all customers that are employed in the public sector broadly,
including active duty U.S. military personnel. Absent additional
relevant facts, Corporation A does not target or tailor its products
or services for purposes of Sec. 800.241(a)(1)(i)(A).
(4) Example 4. Same facts as Example 3 of this section, except
that Corporation A offers a discount solely to uniformed U.S.
military personnel or distributes marketing materials that promote
the particular usefulness of Corporation A's products to military
personnel. Corporation A targets or tailors its products or services
for purposes of Sec. 800.241(a)(1)(i)(A).
Sec. 800.248 TID U.S. business.
The term TID U.S. business means any U.S. business that:
(a) Produces, designs, tests, manufactures, fabricates, or develops
one or more critical technologies;
(b) Performs the functions as set forth in Column 2 of appendix A
to part 800 with respect to covered investment critical infrastructure;
or
(c) Maintains or collects, directly or indirectly, sensitive
personal data of U.S. citizens.
(d) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, a U.S. business, operates a
munitions plant in the
[[Page 50191]]
United States that produces a variety of military grade explosives.
Some of the explosives manufactured by Corporation A are subject to
export controls because they are listed on the USML. Corporation A
manufactures critical technologies and is therefore a TID U.S.
business.
(2) Example 2. Facility A is a crude oil storage facility with
the capacity to hold 50 million barrels of crude oil. Corporation A
is a U.S. business that operates Facility A. Corporation B is a U.S.
business that provides third-party physical security to Facility A
by guarding the gate to Facility A and patrolling the fence
surrounding Facility A. Corporation C produces the fencing used by
Facility A. Corporation D produces the commercially available off-
the-shelf cyber security software utilized in Facility A.
Corporation E provides third-party cyber security to Facility by
running Facility A's cyber security defenses. Facility A is covered
investment critical infrastructure as set forth in Column 1 of
appendix A to part 800. Corporation A, Corporation B, and
Corporation E each perform one of the functions as set forth in
Column 2 of appendix A to part 800 with respect to Facility A and
each is therefore a TID U.S. business. Assuming no other relevant
facts, neither Corporation C nor Corporation D perform one of the
functions as set forth in Column 2 of appendix A to part 800 with
respect to Facility A and neither is therefore a TID U.S. business.
(3) Example 3. Pipeline A is an interstate natural gas pipeline
with an outside diameter of 36 inches. Corporation A is a U.S.
business that owns Pipeline A. Corporation B is a U.S. business that
manufactures the pipe segments with an outside diameter of 36 inches
that are used in Pipeline A. Pipeline A is covered investment
critical infrastructure as set forth in Column 1 of appendix A to
part 800. Corporation A performs one of the functions as set forth
in Column 2 of appendix A to part 800 with respect to Pipeline A and
is therefore a TID U.S. business. Assuming no other relevant facts,
Corporation B does not perform one of the functions as set forth in
Column 2 of appendix A to part 800 with respect to Pipeline A and is
therefore not a TID U.S. business.
(4) Example 4. IXP A is an internet exchange point that supports
public peering. Corporation A is a U.S. business that operates IXP
A. Corporation B is a U.S. business that maintains the physical
premises of IXP A. IXP A is covered investment critical
infrastructure as set forth in Column 1 of appendix A to part 800.
Corporation A performs one of the functions as set forth in Column 2
of appendix A to part 800 with respect to IXP A and is therefore a
TID U.S. business. Assuming no other relevant facts, Corporation B
does not perform one of the functions as set forth in Column 2 of
appendix A to part 800 with respect to IXP A and is therefore not a
TID U.S. business.
(5) Example 5. SCADA System A is a supervisory control and data
acquisition system utilized by a public water system, as defined in
section 1401(4) of the Safe Drinking Water Act (42 U.S.C.
300f(4)(A)), as amended, that regularly serves 15,000 individuals.
Corporation A is a U.S. business that produces SCADA System A by
building the hardware and integrating all the software. Corporation
B is a U.S. business that produces commercially available off-the-
shelf software that is sold to Corporation A and used as a component
in SCADA System A. SCADA System A is covered investment critical
infrastructure as set forth in Column 1 of appendix A to part 800.
Corporation A, as the manufacturer of SCADA System A, performs one
of the functions as set forth in Column 2 of appendix A to part 800
with respect to SCADA System A and is therefore a TID U.S. business.
Assuming no other relevant facts, Corporation B does not perform one
of the functions as set forth in Column 2 of appendix A to part 800
with respect to SCADA System A and is therefore not a TID U.S.
business.
(6) Example 6. Same facts as Example 5 of this section.
Corporation B later releases a patch that updates the commercially
available off-the-shelf software that is a component of SCADA System
A. As the software is only a component of SCADA System A, the
software itself is not covered investment critical infrastructure as
set forth in Column 1 of appendix A to part 800. Assuming no other
relevant facts, Corporation B does not perform one of the functions
as set forth in Column 2 of appendix A to part 800 with respect to
SCADA System A and is therefore not a TID U.S. business.
(7) Example 7. Alloy A is a steel alloy containing two percent
manganese. Corporation A is a U.S. business that manufactures Alloy
A in Facility A by melting the constituent metals. Facility A is in
the United States. Corporation B is a U.S. business that purchases
Alloy A from Corporation A and resells it to a prime contractor of
the Department of Defense. Facility A is covered investment critical
infrastructure as set forth in Column 1 of appendix A to part 800.
Corporation A performs one of the functions as set forth in Column 2
of appendix A to part 800 with respect to Alloy A and is therefore a
TID U.S. business. Assuming no other relevant facts, Corporation B
does not perform one of the functions as set forth in Column 2 of
appendix A to part 800 with respect to Alloy A and is therefore not
a TID U.S. business.
(8) Example 8. Corporation A, a U.S. business, is a credit
reporting agency and maintains consumer reports on greater than one
million individuals. Corporation A maintains sensitive personal data
and is therefore a TID U.S. business.
(9) Example 9. Same facts as in Example 8 of this section,
except that Corporation A maintains the sensitive personal data
through its subsidiary, Corporation X. Corporation A is a TID U.S.
business because it indirectly maintains sensitive personal data.
Corporation X is also a TID U.S. business because it directly
maintains sensitive personal data.
Sec. 800.249 Transaction.
The term transaction means any of the following, whether proposed
or completed:
(a) A merger, acquisition, or takeover, including without
limitation:
(1) The acquisition of an ownership interest in an entity;
(2) The acquisition of proxies from holders of a voting interest in
an entity;
(3) A merger or consolidation;
(4) The formation of a joint venture; or
(5) A long-term lease or concession arrangement under which a
lessee (or equivalent) makes substantially all business decisions
concerning the operation of a leased entity (or equivalent), as if it
were the owner;
(b) An investment; or
(c) The conversion of a contingent equity interest.
(d) Example. Corporation A, a foreign person, signs a concession
agreement to operate the toll road business of Corporation B, a U.S.
business, for 99 years. Corporation B, however, is required under the
agreement to perform safety and security functions with respect to the
business and to monitor compliance by Corporation A with the operating
requirements of the agreement on an ongoing basis. Corporation B may
terminate the agreement or impose other penalties for breach of these
operating requirements. Assuming no other relevant facts, this is not a
transaction.
Note 1 to Sec. 800.249: See Sec. 800.308 regarding factors
the Committee will consider in determining whether to include the
access, rights, or involvement to be acquired by a foreign person
upon the conversion of contingent equity interests as part of the
Committee's analysis of whether a transaction that involves such
interests is a covered transaction.
Sec. 800.250 Unaffiliated TID U.S. business.
The term unaffiliated TID U.S. business means, with respect to a
foreign person, a TID U.S. business in which that foreign person does
not directly hold more than 50 percent of the outstanding voting
interest or have the right to appoint more than half of the members of
the board of directors or equivalent governing body.
Sec. 800.251 United States.
The term United States or U.S. means the United States of America,
the States of the United States, the District of Columbia, and any
commonwealth, territory, dependency, or possession of the United
States, or any subdivision of the foregoing, and includes the Outer
Continental Shelf, as defined in the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act,
as amended (43 U.S.C. 1331(a)). For purposes of these regulations and
their examples, an entity organized under the laws of the United States
of America,
[[Page 50192]]
one of the States, the District of Columbia, or a commonwealth,
territory, dependency, or possession of the United States is an entity
organized ``in the United States.''
Sec. 800.252 U.S. business.
(a) The term U.S. business means any entity, irrespective of the
nationality of the persons that control it, engaged in interstate
commerce in the United States.
(b) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A is organized under the laws of a
foreign state and is wholly owned and controlled by a foreign
national. It engages in interstate commerce in the United States
through a branch or subsidiary. Its branch or subsidiary is a U.S.
business. Corporation A and its branch or subsidiary is each also a
foreign person should any of them engage in a transaction involving
a U.S. business.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as in the first sentence of Example 1
of this section. Corporation A, however, does not have a branch
office, subsidiary, or fixed place of business in the United States.
It exports and licenses technology to an unrelated company in the
United States. Assuming no other relevant facts, Corporation A is
not a U.S. business.
(3) Example 3. Corporation A, a company organized under the laws
of a foreign state, is wholly owned and controlled by Corporation X.
Corporation X is organized in the United States and is wholly owned
and controlled by U.S. nationals. Corporation A does not have a
branch office, subsidiary, or fixed place of business in the United
States. It exports goods to Corporation X and to unrelated companies
in the United States. Assuming no other relevant facts, Corporation
A is not a U.S. business.
Sec. 800.253 U.S. national.
The term U.S. national means an individual who is a U.S. citizen or
an individual who, although not a U.S. citizen, owes permanent
allegiance to the United States.
Sec. 800.254 Voting interest.
The term voting interest means any interest in an entity that
entitles the owner or holder of that interest to vote for the election
of directors of the entity (or, with respect to unincorporated
entities, individuals exercising similar functions) or to vote on other
matters affecting the entity.
Subpart C--Coverage
Sec. 800.301 Transactions that are covered control transactions.
Transactions that are covered control transactions include, without
limitation:
(a) A transaction which, irrespective of the actual arrangements
for control provided for in the terms of the transaction, results or
could result in control of a U.S. business by a foreign person. (See
the examples in Sec. 800.301(g)(1),(2), and (3).)
(b) A transaction in which a foreign person conveys its control of
a U.S. business to another foreign person. (See the example in Sec.
800.301(g)(4).)
(c) A transaction that results or could result in control by a
foreign person of any part of an entity or of assets, if such part of
an entity or assets constitutes a U.S. business. (See Sec. 800.302(c)
and the examples in Sec. 800.301(g)(5) through (14).)
(d) A joint venture in which the parties enter into a contractual
or other similar arrangement, including an agreement on the
establishment of a new entity, but only if one or more of the parties
contributes a U.S. business and a foreign person could control that
U.S. business by means of the joint venture. (See the examples in Sec.
800.301(g)(15) through (17).)
(e) A change in the rights that a foreign person has with respect
to a U.S. business in which the foreign person has an investment, if
that change could result in foreign control of the U.S. business. (See
the example in Sec. 800.301(g)(18).)
(f) A transaction the structure of which is designed to evade or
circumvent the application of section 721. (See the example in Sec.
800.301(g)(19).)
(g) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, a foreign person, proposes to
purchase all of the shares of Corporation X, which is a U.S.
business. As the sole owner, Corporation A will have the right to
elect directors and appoint other primary officers of Corporation X,
and those directors will have the right to make decisions about the
closing and relocation of particular production facilities and the
termination of significant contracts. The directors also will have
the right to propose to Corporation A, the sole shareholder, the
dissolution of Corporation X and the sale of its principal assets.
The proposed transaction is a covered control transaction.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as in Example 1 of this section,
except that Corporation A plans to retain the existing directors of
Corporation X, all of whom are U.S. nationals. Although Corporation
A may choose not to exercise its power to elect new directors for
Corporation X, Corporation A nevertheless will have that exercisable
power. The proposed transaction is a covered control transaction.
(3) Example 3. Corporation A, a foreign person, proposes to
purchase 50 percent of the shares in Corporation X, a U.S. business,
from Corporation B, also a U.S. business. Corporation B would retain
the other 50 percent of the shares in Corporation X, and Corporation
A and Corporation B would contractually agree that Corporation A
would not exercise its voting and other rights for ten years. The
proposed transaction is a covered control transaction.
(4) Example 4. Corporation X is a U.S. business, but is wholly
owned and controlled by Corporation Y, a foreign person. Corporation
Z, also a foreign person, but not related to Corporation Y, seeks to
acquire Corporation X from Corporation Y. The proposed transaction
is a covered control transaction because it could result in control
of Corporation X, a U.S. business, by another foreign person,
Corporation Z.
(5) Example 5. Corporation X, a foreign person, has a branch
office located in the United States. Corporation A, a foreign
person, proposes to buy that branch office. The proposed transaction
is a covered control transaction.
(6) Example 6. Corporation A, a foreign person, buys a branch
office located entirely outside the United States of Corporation Y,
which is incorporated in the United States. Assuming no other
relevant facts, the branch office of Corporation Y is not a U.S.
business, and the transaction is not a covered control transaction.
(7) Example 7. Corporation A, a foreign person, makes a start-
up, or ``greenfield,'' investment in the United States. That
investment involves activities such as the foreign person separately
arranging for the financing of and the construction of a plant to
make a new product, buying supplies and inputs, hiring personnel,
and purchasing the necessary technology. The investment involves
incorporating a newly formed subsidiary of the foreign person.
Assuming no other relevant facts, Corporation A will not have
acquired a U.S. business, and its greenfield investment is not a
covered control transaction. However, this transaction may be
subject to the provisions of part 802 of this title, which addresses
certain transactions concerning real estate.
(8) Example 8. Corporation A, a foreign person, intends to make
an early-stage investment in a start-up company in the United
States. Prior to the investment by the foreign person, the start-up
has incorporated, established a domain name, hired personnel,
developed business plans, sought financing, rented office space, and
engaged in other activities that constitute interstate commerce in
the United States, without the involvement of the foreign person. As
a result of the investment, Corporation A could control the U.S.
business. Under these facts, Corporation A is acquiring a U.S.
business and the proposed transaction is a covered control
transaction.
(9) Example 9. Corporation A, a foreign person, purchases
substantially all of the assets of Corporation B. Corporation B,
which is incorporated in the United States, was in the business of
producing industrial equipment, but stopped producing and selling
such equipment one week before Corporation A purchased substantially
all of its assets. At the time of the transaction, Corporation B
continued to have employees on its payroll, maintained know-how in
producing the industrial equipment it previously produced, and
maintained relationships with its prior customers, all of which were
transferred to Corporation A. The acquisition of substantially all
of the assets
[[Page 50193]]
of Corporation B by Corporation A is a covered control transaction.
(10) Example 10. Corporation X, a foreign person, seeks to
acquire from Corporation A, a U.S. business, an empty warehouse
facility located in the United States. The acquisition would be
limited to the physical facility, and would not include customer
lists, intellectual property, or other proprietary information, or
other intangible assets or the transfer of personnel. Assuming no
other relevant facts, the facility is not an entity and therefore
not a U.S. business, and the proposed acquisition of the facility is
not a covered control transaction. However, this transaction may be
subject to the provisions of part 802 of this title, which addresses
certain transactions concerning real estate.
(11) Example 11. Same facts as Example 6 of this section, except
that, in addition to the proposed acquisition of Corporation A's
warehouse facility, Corporation X would acquire the personnel,
customer list, equipment, and inventory management software used to
operate the facility. Under these facts, Corporation X is acquiring
a U.S. business, and the proposed acquisition is a covered control
transaction.
(12) Example 12. Corporation A, a foreign person, seeks to
acquire from Corporation X, a U.S. business, certain tangible and
intangible assets that Corporation X operates as a business in the
United States. Corporation A intends to use the assets to establish
a business undertaking in a foreign country. Under these facts,
Corporation X is acquiring a U.S. business, and the proposed
acquisition is a covered control transaction.
(13) Example 13. Corporation A, a foreign person, seeks to
acquire from Corporation X, a U.S. business, proprietary software
developed by Corporation X. The acquisition would be limited to the
software and would not include customer lists, marketing material,
or other proprietary information; any other tangible or intangible
assets; or the transfer of personnel. Assuming no other relevant
facts, the software does not constitute an entity and therefore not
a U.S. business, and the proposed acquisition of the software is not
a covered control transaction.
(14) Example 14. Same facts as Example 9 of this section, except
that, in addition to the proposed acquisition of Corporation X's
proprietary software, Corporation A would acquire Corporation X's
customer lists, advertising and promotional material, branding,
trademarks, domain names, and internet presence. Under these facts,
Corporation A is acquiring a U.S. business, and the proposed
acquisition is a covered control transaction.
(15) Example 15. Corporation A, a foreign person, and
Corporation X, a U.S. business, form a separate corporation, JV
Corporation, to which Corporation A contributes only cash and
Corporation X contributes a U.S. business. Each owns 50 percent of
the shares of JV Corporation and, under the Articles of
Incorporation of JV Corporation, both Corporation A and Corporation
X have veto power over all of the matters affecting JV Corporation
identified under Sec. 800.208, giving them both control over JV
Corporation. The place of incorporation of JV Corporation is not
relevant to the determination of whether the transaction is a
covered control transaction. The formation of JV Corporation is a
covered control transaction.
(16) Example 16. Corporation A, a foreign person, and
Corporation X, a U.S. business, form a separate corporation, JV
Corporation, to which Corporation A contributes funding and
managerial and technical personnel, while Corporation X contributes
certain land and equipment that do not in this example constitute a
U.S. business. Corporations A and X each have a 50 percent interest
in the joint venture. Assuming no other relevant facts, the
formation of JV Corporation is not a covered control transaction.
However, this transaction may be subject to the provisions of part
802 of this title, which addresses certain transactions concerning
real estate.
(17) Example 17. Same facts as Example 2 of this section, except
that, in addition to contributing certain land and equipment,
Corporation X also contributes intellectual property, other
proprietary information, and other intangible assets, that together
with the land and equipment constitute a U.S. business, to JV
Corporation. Under these facts, Corporation X has contributed a U.S.
business, and the formation of JV Corporation is a covered control
transaction.
(18) Example 18. Corporation A, a foreign person, holds a 10
percent ownership interest in Corporation X, a U.S. business.
Corporation X subsequently provides Corporation A the right to
appoint the Chief Executive Officer and the Chief Technical Officer
of Corporation X. Corporation A does not acquire any additional
ownership interest in Corporation X. The change in rights is a
covered control transaction.
(19) Example 19. Corporation A is organized under the laws of a
foreign state and is wholly owned and controlled by a foreign
national. With a view towards circumventing section 721, Corporation
A transfers money to a U.S. citizen, who, pursuant to informal
arrangements with Corporation A and on its behalf, purchases all the
shares in Corporation X, a U.S. business. The transaction is a
covered control transaction.
Sec. 800.302 Transactions that are not covered control transactions.
Transactions that are not covered control transactions include,
without limitation:
(a) A stock split or pro rata stock dividend that does not involve
a change in control. (See the example in Sec. 800.302(g)(1).)
(b) A transaction that results in a foreign person holding ten
percent or less of the outstanding voting interest in a U.S. business
(regardless of the dollar value of the interest so acquired), but only
if the transaction is solely for the purpose of passive investment.
(See Sec. 800.243 and the examples in Sec. 800.302(g)(2) through
(4).)
(c) An acquisition of any part of an entity or of assets, if such
part of an entity or assets do not constitute a U.S. business. (See
Sec. 800.301(c) and the examples in Sec. 800.302(g)(5) through (10).)
(d) An acquisition of securities by a person acting as a securities
underwriter, in the ordinary course of business and in the process of
underwriting.
(e) An acquisition pursuant to a condition in a contract of
insurance relating to fidelity, surety, or casualty obligations if the
contract was made by an insurer in the ordinary course of business.
(f) A change in the rights that a foreign person has with respect
to a U.S. business in which that foreign person has an investment, if
that change could not result in foreign control of the U.S. business.
(See the example in Sec. 800.302(g)(11).)
(g) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, a foreign person, holds 10,000
shares of Corporation B, a U.S. business, constituting ten percent
of the stock of Corporation B. Corporation B pays a 2-for-1 stock
dividend. As a result of this stock split, Corporation A holds
20,000 shares of Corporation B, still constituting ten percent of
the stock of Corporation B. Assuming no other relevant facts, the
acquisition of additional shares is not a covered control
transaction.
(2) Example 2. In an open market purchase solely for the purpose
of passive investment, Corporation A, a foreign person, acquires
seven percent of the voting securities of Corporation X, which is a
U.S. business. Assuming no other relevant facts, the acquisition of
the securities is not a covered control transaction.
(3) Example 3. Corporation A, a foreign person, acquires nine
percent of the voting shares of Corporation X, a U.S. business.
Corporation A also negotiates contractual rights that give it the
power to control important matters of Corporation X. The acquisition
by Corporation A of the voting shares of Corporation X is not solely
for the purpose of passive investment and is a covered control
transaction.
(4) Example 4. Corporation A, a foreign person, acquires five
percent of the voting shares in Corporation B, a U.S. business. In
addition to the securities, Corporation A obtains the right to
appoint one out of eleven seats on Corporation B's Board of
Directors. The acquisition by Corporation A of Corporation B's
securities is not solely for the purpose of passive investment.
Whether the transaction is a covered control transaction would
depend on whether Corporation A obtains control of Corporation B as
a result of the transaction. See Sec. 800.303 for transactions that
are covered investments.
(5) Example 5. Corporation A, a foreign person, acquires, from
separate U.S. nationals: products held in inventory; land, and;
machinery for export. Assuming no other relevant facts, Corporation
A has not acquired a U.S. business, and this acquisition is not a
covered control transaction.
(6) Example 6. Corporation X, a U.S. business, produces armored
personnel carriers in the United States. Corporation A, a foreign
person, seeks to acquire the annual production of those carriers
from Corporation
[[Page 50194]]
X under a long-term contract. Assuming no other relevant facts, this
transaction is not a covered control transaction.
(7) Example 7. Same facts as Example 2 of this section, except
that Corporation X, a U.S. business, has developed important
technology in connection with the production of armored personnel
carriers. Corporation A seeks to negotiate an agreement under which
it would be licensed to manufacture using that technology. Assuming
no other relevant facts, neither the proposed acquisition of
technology pursuant to that license agreement, nor the actual
acquisition, is a covered control transaction.
(8) Example 8. Same facts as Example 2 of this section, except
that Corporation A enters into a contractual arrangement to acquire
the entire armored personnel carrier business operations of
Corporation X, including production facilities, customer lists,
technology, and staff, which together constitute a U.S. business.
This transaction is a covered control transaction.
(9) Example 9. Same facts as Example 2 of this section, except
that Corporation X suspended all activities of its armored personnel
carrier business a year ago and currently is in bankruptcy
proceedings. Existing equipment provided by Corporation X is being
serviced by another company, which purchased the service contracts
from Corporation X. The business's production facilities are idle
but still in working condition, some of its key former employees
have agreed to return if the business is resuscitated, and its
technology and customer and vendor lists are still current.
Corporation X's personnel carrier business constitutes a U.S.
business, and its purchase by Corporation A is a covered control
transaction.
(10) Example 10. Same facts as Example 2 of this section, except
that Corporation A and Corporation X establish a joint venture that
will be controlled by Corporation A to manufacture armored personnel
carriers outside the United States, and Corporation X contributes
assets constituting a U.S. business, including intellectual property
and other intangible assets required to manufacture the armored
personnel carriers, to the joint venture. Corporation X has
contributed a U.S. business to the joint venture, and the
establishment of the joint venture is a covered control transaction.
(11) Example 11. Corporation A, a foreign person, holds a 10
percent ownership interest in Corporation X, a U.S. business.
Corporation A and Corporation X enter into a contractual arrangement
pursuant to which Corporation A gains the right to purchase an
additional interest in Corporation X to prevent the dilution of
Corporation A's pro rata interest in Corporation X in the event that
Corporation X issues additional instruments conveying interests in
Corporation X. Corporation A does not acquire any additional rights
or ownership interest in Corporation X pursuant to the contractual
arrangement. Assuming no other relevant facts, the transaction is
not a covered control transaction.
Sec. 800.303 Transactions that are covered investments.
Transactions that are covered investments include, without
limitation:
(a) A transaction that meets the requirements of Sec. 800.211
irrespective of the percentage of voting interest acquired. (See the
examples in Sec. 800.303(f)(1) through (3).)
(b) A transaction that meets the requirements of Sec. 800.211,
irrespective of the fact that the Committee concluded all action under
section 721 for a previous covered investment by the same foreign
person in the same TID U.S. business, where such transaction involves
the acquisition of access, rights, or involvement specified in Sec.
800.211 in addition to those notified to the Committee in the
transaction for which the Committee previously concluded action. (See
the example in Sec. 800.303(f)(4).)
(c) A transaction that meets the requirements of Sec. 800.211,
irrespective of the fact that the critical technology produced,
designed, tested, manufactured, fabricated, or developed by the TID
U.S. business became controlled pursuant to section 1758 of the Export
Control Reform Act of 2018 after the effective date, unless any of the
criteria set forth in Sec. 800.104(b) are satisfied with respect to
the transaction prior to the critical technology becoming controlled.
(See the example in Sec. 800.303(f)(5).)
(d) A change in the rights that a foreign person has with respect
to a U.S. business in which the foreign person has an investment, if
that change could result in a covered investment. (See the example in
Sec. 800.303(f)(6).)
(e) A transaction the structure of which is designed to evade or
circumvent the application of section 721. (See the example in Sec.
800.303(f)(7).)
(f) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, a foreign person who is not an
excepted investor, proposes to acquire a four percent, non-
controlling equity interest in Corporation B. Corporation B is a
U.S. business that manufactures a critical technology. Corporation B
is therefore a TID U.S. business. Pursuant to the terms of the
investment, a designee of Corporation A will have the right to
observe the meetings of the board of directors of Corporation B. The
proposed transaction is a covered investment.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as Example 1 of this section, except
that, pursuant to the terms of the investment, instead of observer
rights, Corporation A has consultation rights with respect to
Corporation B's licensing of a critical technology to third parties.
Corporation A is therefore involved in substantive decisionmaking
with respect to Corporation B and the proposed transaction is a
covered investment.
(3) Example 3. Corporation A is a foreign person that is an
excepted investor. Corporation B, a foreign person that is not an
excepted investor, owns a three percent, non-controlling equity
interest in Corporation A. Corporation A proposes to acquire a four
percent, non-controlling equity interest in Corporation C, an
unaffiliated TID U.S. business. Pursuant to the terms of the
investment in Corporation C and Corporation A's governance
documents, Corporation A and Corporation B will each have access to
material nonpublic technical information in Corporation C's
possession. The transaction is a covered investment because
Corporation B is making an investment that will result in access to
material nonpublic technical information pursuant to Sec.
800.211(b).
(4) Example 4. The Committee concludes all action under section
721 with respect to a covered investment by Corporation A, a foreign
person who is not an excepted investor, in which Corporation A
acquires a four percent, non-controlling equity interest with access
to material non-public information in Corporation B, an unaffiliated
TID U.S. business. One year later, Corporation A proposes to acquire
an additional five percent equity interest in Corporation B,
resulting in Corporation A holding a nine percent, non-controlling
equity interest in Corporation B. Pursuant to the terms of the
additional investment, Corporation A will receive the right to
appoint a member to the board of directors of Corporation B. The
proposed transaction is a covered investment because the transaction
involves both an acquisition of an equity interest in an
unaffiliated TID U.S. business and a new right under Sec. 800.211.
(5) Example 5. Corporation A, a foreign person who is not an
excepted investor, has executed a binding written agreement
establishing the material terms of a proposed non-controlling
investment in Corporation B, an unaffiliated TID U.S. business. The
proposed investment will afford Corporation A access to material
nonpublic technical information in the possession of Corporation B.
The only controlled technology produced, designed, tested,
manufactured, fabricated, or developed by Corporation B became
controlled pursuant to section 1758 of the Export Control Reform Act
of 2018 after the effective date but prior to the date upon which
the binding written agreement establishing the material terms of the
investment was executed. The proposed transaction is a covered
investment.
(6) Example 6. Corporation A, a foreign person who is not an
excepted investor, holds a four percent non-controlling ownership
interest in Corporation X, an unaffiliated TID U.S. business, but
Corporation A was not afforded any of the access, rights, or
involvement specified in Sec. 800.211(b) at the time of its
investment. Corporation A subsequently gains the right to appoint a
member of the board of directors of Corporation X. Assuming no other
relevant facts, the transaction is a covered investment.
(7) Example 7. Corporation A is organized under the laws of a
foreign state, is wholly owned and controlled by a foreign national,
[[Page 50195]]
and is not an excepted investor. With a view towards circumventing
section 721, Corporation A transfers money to a U.S. citizen, who,
pursuant to informal arrangements with Corporation A and on its
behalf, makes a non-controlling minority equity investment in
Corporation X, an unaffiliated TID U.S. business that maintains and
collects sensitive personal data on U.S. citizens. In connection
with the investment, the U.S. citizen is afforded the right to be
involved in substantive decisionmaking regarding the release of
sensitive personal data of U.S. citizens maintained by Corporation
X. The transaction is a covered investment.
Sec. 800.304 Transactions that are not covered investments.
Transactions that are not covered investments include, without
limitation:
(a) An investment by a foreign person in an unaffiliated TID U.S.
business that does not afford the foreign person any of the access,
rights, or involvement specified in Sec. 800.211(b). (See the examples
in Sec. 800.304(f)(1) and (2).)
(b) An investment by a foreign person who is an excepted investor
in an unaffiliated TID U.S. business. (See the example in Sec.
800.304(f)(3).)
(c) A transaction that results or could result in control by a
foreign person of an unaffiliated TID U.S. business. (See the example
in Sec. 800.304(f)(4).)
(d) A stock split or pro rata stock dividend that does not afford
the foreign person any of the access, rights, or involvement specified
in Sec. 800.211(b). (See the example in Sec. 800.304(f)(5).)
(e) An acquisition of securities by a person acting as a securities
underwriter, in the ordinary course of business and in the process of
underwriting.
(f) Examples:
(1) Example 1. In an open market purchase solely for the purpose
of passive investment, Corporation A, a foreign person who is not an
excepted investor, acquires seven percent of the voting securities
of Corporation X, an unaffiliated TID U.S. business. Assuming no
other relevant facts, the acquisition of the securities is not a
covered investment.
(2) Example 2. The Committee concluded all action under section
721 with respect to a covered investment in which Corporation A, a
foreign person who is not an excepted investor, acquired a four
percent, non-controlling equity interest with board observer rights
in Corporation B, an unaffiliated TID U.S. business. One year later,
Corporation A proposes to acquire an additional five percent equity
interest in Corporation B, which would result in Corporation A
holding a nine percent, non-controlling equity interest in
Corporation B. The proposed investment does not afford Corporation A
any additional access, rights, or involvement with respect to
Corporation B, including the access, rights, or involvement
specified in Sec. 800.211(b). Assuming no other relevant facts, the
proposed transaction is not a covered investment.
(3) Example 3. Corporation A, a foreign person who is an
excepted investor, proposes to acquire a four percent, non-
controlling equity interest in Corporation B, an unaffiliated TID
U.S. business. Pursuant to the terms of the investment, a designee
of Corporation A will have the right to observe the meetings of the
board of directors of Corporation B. Assuming no other relevant
facts, the proposed transaction is not a covered investment.
(4) Example 4. Corporation A, a foreign person who is an
excepted investor, proposes to purchase all of the shares of
Corporation B, an unaffiliated TID U.S. business. As the sole owner,
Corporation A will have the right to elect directors and appoint
other primary officers of Corporation B. Assuming no other relevant
facts, the proposed transaction is not a covered investment. It is,
however, a covered control transaction. Whether Corporation A is an
excepted investor or whether Corporation B is an unaffiliated TID
U.S. business are not relevant to the determination of whether the
transaction is a covered control transaction. (See Sec. 800.301).
(5) Example 5. Corporation A, a foreign person who is not an
excepted investor, holds 10,000 shares and board observer rights in
Corporation B, an unaffiliated TID U.S. business, constituting ten
percent of the stock of Corporation B. Corporation B pays a 2-for-1
stock dividend. As a result of this stock split, Corporation A holds
20,000 shares of Corporation B, still constituting ten percent of
the stock of Corporation B. The proposed investment does not afford
Corporation A any additional access, rights, or involvement with
respect to Corporation B, including those specified in Sec.
800.211(b). Assuming no other relevant facts, the acquisition of
additional shares is not a covered investment.
Sec. 800.305 Incremental acquisitions.
(a) Any transaction in which a foreign person acquires an
additional interest in a U.S. business over which the same foreign
person, or any of its direct or indirect wholly-owned subsidiaries,
previously acquired direct control in the U.S. business in a covered
control transaction for which the Committee concluded all action under
section 721 on the basis of a notice filed pursuant to Sec. 800.501
shall not be deemed to be a covered transaction. If, however, a foreign
person that did not acquire control of the U.S. business in the prior
transaction is a party to the later transaction, the later transaction
may be a covered transaction.
(b) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, a foreign person, directly
acquires a 40 percent interest and important rights with respect to
Corporation B, a U.S. business. The documentation pertaining to the
transaction gives no indication that Corporation A's interest in
Corporation B may increase at a later date. Corporation A and
Corporation B file a voluntary notice of the transaction with the
Committee. Following its review of the transaction, the Committee
informs the parties that the notified transaction is a covered
control transaction, and concludes action under section 721. Three
years later, Corporation A acquires the remainder of the voting
interest in Corporation B. Assuming no other relevant facts, because
the Committee, on the basis of the notice submitted by the parties,
concluded all action with respect to Corporation A's earlier direct
investment in the same U.S. business, and because no other foreign
person is a party to this subsequent transaction, this subsequent
transaction is not a covered transaction.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as Example 1 of this section, except
that Corporation A and Corporation B file a declaration of the
transaction, rather than a notice, with the Committee, and the
Committee concluded all action on the basis of the declaration. The
subsequent transaction may be a covered transaction, depending on
the specific facts and circumstances.
Sec. 800.306 Lending transactions.
(a) The extension of a loan or a similar financing arrangement by a
foreign person to a U.S. business, regardless of whether accompanied by
the creation in favor of the foreign person of a secured interest over
securities or other assets of the U.S. business, shall not, by itself,
constitute a covered transaction.
(1) The Committee will accept notices or declarations concerning a
loan or a similar financing arrangement that does not, by itself,
constitute a covered transaction only at the time that, because of
imminent or actual default or other condition, there is a significant
possibility that the foreign person may obtain control of a U.S.
business, or acquire equity interest and access, rights, or involvement
specified in Sec. 800.211(b) over a TID U.S. business, as a result of
the default or other condition.
(2) Where the Committee accepts a notice or declaration concerning
a loan or a similar financing arrangement pursuant to paragraph (a)(1)
of this section, and a party to the transaction is a foreign person
that makes loans in the ordinary course of business, the Committee will
take into account whether the foreign person has made any arrangements
to transfer management decisions, or day-to-day control over the U.S.
business to U.S. nationals for purposes of determining whether such
loan or financing arrangement constitutes a covered transaction.
(b) Notwithstanding paragraph (a) of this section, a loan or a
similar financing arrangement through which a foreign person acquires
an interest in profits of a U.S. business, the right to appoint members
of the board of directors of the U.S. business, or other
[[Page 50196]]
comparable financial or governance rights characteristic of an equity
investment but not of a typical loan may constitute a covered
transaction.
(c) An acquisition of voting interest in or assets of a U.S.
business by a foreign person upon default or other condition involving
a loan or a similar financing arrangement does not constitute a covered
transaction, provided that the loan was made by a syndicate of banks in
a loan participation where the foreign lender (or lenders) in the
syndicate:
(1) Needs the majority consent of the U.S. participants in the
syndicate to take action, and cannot on its own initiate any action
vis-[agrave]-vis the debtor; or
(2) Does not have a lead role in the syndicate, and is subject to a
provision in the loan or financing documents limiting its ability to
control the debtor such that control for purposes of Sec. 800.208
could not be acquired.
(d) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, which is a U.S. business, borrows
funds from Corporation B, a bank organized under the laws of a
foreign state and controlled by foreign persons. As a condition of
the loan, Corporation A agrees not to sell or pledge its principal
assets to any person. Assuming no other relevant facts, this lending
arrangement does not alone constitute a covered transaction.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as in Example 1 of this section,
except that Corporation A defaults on its loan from Corporation B
and seeks bankruptcy protection. Corporation A has no funds with
which to satisfy Corporation B's claim, which is greater than the
value of Corporation A's principal assets. Corporation B's secured
claim constitutes the only secured claim against Corporation A's
principal assets, creating a high probability that Corporation B
will receive title to Corporation A's principal assets, which
constitute a U.S. business. Assuming no other relevant facts, the
Committee would accept a notice of the impending bankruptcy court
adjudication transferring control of Corporation A's principal
assets to Corporation B, which would constitute a covered control
transaction.
(3) Example 3. Corporation A, a foreign bank, makes a loan to
Corporation B, a U.S. business. The loan documentation extends to
Corporation A rights in Corporation B that are characteristic of an
equity investment but not of a typical loan, including dominant
minority representation on the board of directors of Corporation B
and the right to be paid dividends by Corporation B. This loan is a
covered control transaction.
(4) Example 4. Same facts as in Example 3 of this section,
except that Corporation B is an unaffiliated TID U.S. business and
the loan documentation extends to Corporation A's involvement in
substantive decisionmaking with respect to Corporation B. Whether
the loan is a covered control transaction would depend on whether
Corporation A obtains control of Corporation B as a result of the
loan, but, if it could not result in Corporation A's control of
Corporation B, this loan is a covered investment.
Sec. 800.307 Specific clarifications for investment funds.
(a) Notwithstanding Sec. 800.303, an indirect investment by a
foreign person in a TID U.S. business through an investment fund that
affords the foreign person (or a designee of the foreign person)
membership as a limited partner or equivalent on an advisory board or a
committee of the fund shall not be considered a covered investment with
respect to the foreign person if:
(1) The fund is managed exclusively by a general partner, a
managing member, or an equivalent;
(2) The foreign person is not the general partner, managing member,
or equivalent;
(3) The advisory board or committee does not have the ability to
approve, disapprove, or otherwise control:
(i) Investment decisions of the investment fund; or
(ii) Decisions made by the general partner, managing member, or
equivalent related to entities in which the investment fund is
invested;
(4) The foreign person does not otherwise have the ability to
control the investment fund, including without limitation the
authority:
(i) To approve, disapprove, or otherwise control investment
decisions of the investment fund;
(ii) To approve, disapprove, or otherwise control decisions made by
the general partner, managing member, or equivalent related to entities
in which the investment fund is invested; or
(iii) To unilaterally dismiss, prevent the dismissal of, select, or
determine the compensation of the general partner, managing member, or
equivalent;
(5) The foreign person does not have access to material nonpublic
technical information as a result of its participation on the advisory
board or committee; and
(6) The investment does not afford the foreign person any of the
access, rights, or involvement specified in Sec. 800.211(b).
(b) For the purposes of paragraphs (a)(3) and (4) of this section,
and except as provided in paragraph (c) of this section, a waiver of a
potential conflict of interest, a waiver of an allocation limitation,
or a similar activity, applicable to a transaction pursuant to the
terms of an agreement governing an investment fund shall not be
considered to constitute control of investment decisions of the
investment fund or decisions relating to entities in which the
investment fund is invested.
(c) In extraordinary circumstances, the Committee may consider the
waiver of a potential conflict of interest, the waiver of an allocation
limitation, or a similar activity, applicable to a transaction pursuant
to the terms of an agreement governing an investment fund, to
constitute control of investment decisions of the investment fund or
decisions relating to entities in which the investment fund is
invested.
(d) Example: Limited Partner A, a foreign person, is a limited
partner in an investment fund that invests in Corporation B, an
unaffiliated TID U.S. business. The investment fund is managed
exclusively by a general partner, who is not a foreign person. The
investment affords Limited Partner A membership on an advisory board of
the investment fund. The advisory board provides industry expertise,
assists with the sourcing of transactions, and votes on the
compensation of the general partner, but it does not control investment
decisions of the fund or decisions made by the general partner related
to entities in which the fund is invested. Limited Partner A does not
otherwise have the ability to control the fund. Limited Partner A's
investment in Corporation B does not afford it access to any material
nonpublic technical information in the possession of Corporation B, the
right to be a member or observer, or to nominate a member or observer,
to the board of Corporation B, nor any involvement in the substantive
decisionmaking of Corporation B. Assuming no other facts, the
investment by Limited Partner A is not a covered investment.
Sec. 800.308 Timing rule for a contingent equity interest.
(a) For purposes of determining whether to include the rights that
a holder of contingent equity interest will acquire upon conversion of,
or exercise of a right provided by, those interests in the Committee's
analysis of whether a notified transaction is a covered transaction,
the Committee will consider factors that include:
(1) The imminence of conversion or satisfaction of contingent
conditions;
(2) Whether conversion or satisfaction of contingent conditions
depends on factors within the control of the acquiring party; and
(3) Whether the amount of interest and the rights that would be
acquired upon conversion or satisfaction of contingent conditions can
be reasonably determined at the time of acquisition.
(b) When the Committee, applying paragraph (a) of this section,
determines that the rights that the holder will acquire upon conversion
or satisfaction
[[Page 50197]]
of contingent condition will not be included in the Committee's
analysis of whether a notified transaction is a covered transaction,
the Committee will disregard the contingent equity interest for
purposes of that transaction except to the extent that they convey
immediate rights to the holder with respect to the entity that issued
the interest.
(c) Examples:
(1) Example 1. Corporation A, a foreign person, notifies the
Committee that it intends to buy common stock and debentures of
Corporation X, a U.S. business. By their terms, the debentures are
convertible into common stock only upon the occurrence of an event
the timing of which is not in the control of Corporation A, and the
number of common shares that would be acquired upon conversion
cannot now be determined. Assuming no other relevant facts, the
Committee will disregard the debentures in the course of its covered
transaction analysis at the time that Corporation A acquires the
debentures. In the event that it determines that the acquisition of
the common stock is not a covered transaction, the Committee will so
inform the parties. Once the conversion of the instruments becomes
imminent, it may be appropriate for the Committee to consider the
rights that would result from the conversion and whether the
conversion is a covered transaction. The conversion of those
debentures into common stock could be a covered transaction,
depending on what percentage of Corporation X's voting securities
Corporation A would receive and what powers those securities would
confer on Corporation A.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as Example 1 of this section, except
that the debentures at issue are convertible at the sole discretion
of Corporation A after six months, and if converted, would represent
a 50 percent interest in Corporation X. The Committee may consider
the rights that would result from the conversion as part of its
analysis.
Subpart D--Declarations
Sec. 800.401 Mandatory declarations.
(a) Except as provided in paragraph (c) or (d) of this section, the
parties to a transaction described in paragraph (b) of this section
shall submit to the Committee a declaration with information regarding
the transaction in accordance with Sec. 800.403.
(b) A covered transaction that results in the acquisition of a
substantial interest in a TID U.S. business by a foreign person in
which a foreign government has a substantial interest.
(c) The submission of a declaration shall not be required pursuant
to paragraph (b) of this section with respect to an investment by an
investment fund if:
(1) The fund is managed exclusively by a general partner, a
managing member, or an equivalent;
(2) The general partner, managing member, or equivalent that
exclusively manages the fund is not a foreign person; and
(3) The investment fund satisfies, with respect to any foreign
person with membership as a limited partner on an advisory board or a
committee of the fund, the criteria specified in Sec. 800.307(a)(3)
and (4);
(d) Notwithstanding paragraph (a) of this section, parties to a
covered transaction may elect to submit a written notice pursuant to
subpart E of this part regarding the transaction instead of a
declaration.
(e) Parties shall submit to the Committee the declaration required
pursuant to paragraph (a) of this section, or a written notice pursuant
to paragraph (d) of this section, no later than:
(1) [EFFECTIVE DATE OF FINAL RULE], or promptly thereafter, if the
completion date of the transaction is between [EFFECTIVE DATE OF FINAL
RULE] and [DATE WHICH IS 30 DAYS AFTER THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF FINAL
RULE]; or
(2) Thirty days before the completion date of the transaction, if
the completion date of the transaction is after [DATE THAT IS 30 DAYS
AFTER THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF FINAL RULE].
(f) Notwithstanding paragraph (e)(2) of this section, the parties
to a covered transaction may complete a transaction subject to a
mandatory declaration or notice under this section at any time after
having been informed in writing by the Committee that the Committee has
concluded all action under section 721 or that the Committee is not
able to complete action pursuant to Sec. 800.807(a)(2).
(g) In the event that the Committee rejects or permits a withdrawal
of a declaration or notice required under section, the parties shall
not complete the transaction earlier than 30 days after the date of the
resubmission, except with the written approval of the Staff
Chairperson.
Sec. 800.402 Voluntary declarations.
Except as otherwise prohibited under Sec. 800.403(e), a party to
any proposed or completed transaction may submit to the Committee a
declaration regarding the transaction in accordance with the procedures
and requirements set forth in Sec. 800.403 and Sec. 800.404 instead
of a written notice.
Sec. 800.403 Procedures for declarations.
(a) A party or parties shall submit a declaration of a covered
transaction pursuant to Sec. 800.401 or Sec. 800.402 by submitting
electronically the information set out in Sec. 800.404, including the
certifications required thereunder, to the Staff Chairperson in
accordance with the submission instructions on the Committee's section
of the Department of the Treasury website at https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/international/the-committee-on-foreign-investment-in-the-united-states-cfius.
(b) No communications other than those described in paragraph (a)
of this section shall constitute the submission of a declaration for
purposes of section 721.
(c) Information and other documentary material submitted to the
Committee pursuant to this section shall be considered to have been
filed with the President or the President's designee for purposes of
section 721(c) and Sec. 800.802.
(d) Persons filing a declaration shall, during the time that the
matter is pending before the Committee, promptly advise the Staff
Chairperson of any material changes in plans, facts, or circumstances
addressed in the declaration, and any material change in information
provided or required to be provided to the Committee under Sec.
800.404. Unless the Committee rejects the declaration on the basis of
such material changes in accordance with Sec. 800.406(a)(2)(i), such
changes shall become part of the declaration filed by such persons
under Sec. 800.403, and the certification required under Sec.
800.405(d) shall apply to such changes.
(e) Parties to a covered transaction that have filed with the
Committee a written notice regarding a transaction pursuant to Sec.
800.501 may not submit to the Committee a declaration regarding the
same transaction or a substantially similar transaction without the
written approval of the Staff Chairperson.
Sec. 800.404 Contents of declarations.
(a) The party or parties submitting a declaration of a covered
transaction pursuant to Sec. 800.403 shall provide the information set
out in this section, which must be accurate and complete with respect
to all parties and to the transaction. (See also paragraphs (d) and (e)
of this section.)
(b) If fewer than all the parties to a transaction submit a
declaration, the Committee may, at its discretion, request that the
parties to the transaction file a written notice of the transaction
under Sec. 800.501, if the Staff Chairperson determines that the
information provided by the submitting party or parties in the
declaration is insufficient for the Committee to assess the
transaction.
[[Page 50198]]
(c) Subject to paragraph (e) of this section, a declaration
submitted pursuant to Sec. 800.403 shall describe or provide, as
applicable:
(1) The name of the foreign person(s) and U.S. business(es) that
are parties to, or, in applicable cases, the subject of the
transaction, as well as the name, telephone number, and email address
of the primary point of contact for each party.
(2) The following information regarding the transaction in
question, including:
(i) A brief description of the rationale and nature of the
transaction, including its structure (e.g., share purchase, merger,
asset purchase);
(ii) The percentage of voting interest acquired and the resulting
aggregate voting interest held by the foreign person and its
affiliates;
(iii) The percentage of economic interest acquired and the
resulting aggregate economic interest held by the foreign person and
its affiliates;
(iv) Whether the U.S. business has multiple classes of ownership;
(v) The total transaction value in U.S. dollars;
(vi) The actual or expected completion date of the transaction;
(vii) All sources of financing for the transaction; and
(viii) A copy of the definitive documentation of the transaction,
or if none exists, the document establishing the material terms of the
transaction.
(3) The following:
(i) A statement as to whether a party to the transaction is
stipulating that the transaction is a covered transaction and a
description of the basis for the stipulation; and
(ii) A statement as to whether a party to the transaction is
stipulating that the transaction is a foreign government-controlled
transaction and a description of the basis for the stipulation.
(4) A statement as to whether the foreign person will acquire any
of the following with respect to the U.S. business:
(i) Access to any material nonpublic technical information in the
possession of the U.S. business, and if so, a brief explanation of the
type of access and type of information;
(ii) Membership, observer rights, or nomination rights as set forth
in Sec. 800.211(b)(2), and if so, a statement as to the composition of
the board or other body both before and after the completion date of
the transaction;
(iii) Any involvement, other than through voting shares, in
substantive decisionmaking of the U.S. business regarding critical
infrastructure, critical technologies, or sensitive personal data as
set forth in Sec. 800.211(b)(3), and if so, a statement as to the
involvement in such substantive decisionmaking; or
(iv) Any rights that could result in the foreign person acquiring
control of the U.S. business and, if any, a brief explanation of these
rights.
(5) The following information regarding the covered transaction
U.S. business:
(i) Website address;
(ii) Principal place of business;
(iii) Place of incorporation or organization; and
(iv) A list of the addresses or geographic coordinates (to at least
the fourth decimal) of all locations of the U.S. business, including
the U.S. business' headquarters, facilities, and operating locations.
(6) With respect to the U.S. business that is the subject of the
transaction and any entity of which that U.S. business is a parent, a
brief summary of their respective business activities, as, for example,
set forth in annual reports, and the product or service categories of
each, including the applicable six-digit North American Industry
Classification System (NAICS) Codes, Commercial and Government Entity
Code (CAGE Code) assigned by the Department of Defense, and any
applicable Dun and Bradstreet identification (DUNS) numbers assigned to
the U.S. business.
(7) A statement as to whether the U.S. business produces, designs,
tests, manufactures, fabricates, or develops one or more critical
technologies.
(8) A statement as to whether the U.S. business performs any of the
functions with respect to covered investment critical infrastructure as
set forth in Column 2 of appendix A to part 800.
(9) A statement as to whether the U.S. business maintains or
collects sensitive personal data on U.S. citizens.
(10) A statement as to whether the U.S. business has any contracts
(including any subcontracts, if known) that are currently in effect or
were in effect within the past three years with any U.S. Government
agency or component, or in the past 10 years if the contract included
access to personally identifiable information of U.S. Government
personnel. If so, provide an annex listing such contracts, including
the name of the U.S. Government agency or component, the delivery order
number or contract number, the primary contractor (if the U.S. business
is a subcontractor), the start date, and the estimated completion date.
(11) A statement as to whether the U.S. business has any contracts
(including any subcontracts, if known) that are currently in effect or
were in effect within the past five years involving information,
technology, or data that is classified under Executive Order 12958, as
amended.
(12) A statement as to whether the U.S. business has received any
grant or other funding from the Department of Defense or the Department
of Energy, or participated in or collaborated on any defense or energy
program or product involving one or more critical technologies or
critical infrastructure within the past five years.
(13) A statement as to whether the U.S. business participated in a
Defense Production Act Title III Program (50 U.S.C. 4501, et seq.)
within the past seven years.
(14) A statement as to whether the U.S. business has received or
placed priority rated contracts or orders under the Defense Priorities
and Allocations System (DPAS) regulation (15 CFR part 700), and the
level(s) of priority of such contracts or orders (DX or DO) within the
past three years.
(15) The name of the ultimate parent of the foreign person.
(16) The principal place of business and address of the foreign
person, ultimate parent and ultimate owner of such parent.
(17) Complete organizational charts, both pre- and post-
transaction, including information that identifies the name, principal
place of business and place of incorporation or other legal
organization (for entities), nationality (for individuals), and
ownership percentage (expressed in terms of both voting and economic
interest, if different) for each of the following:
(i) The immediate parent, the ultimate parent, and each
intermediate parent, if any, of each foreign person that is a party to
the transaction;
(ii) Where the ultimate parent is a private company, the ultimate
owner(s) of such parent;
(iii) Where the ultimate parent is a public company, any
shareholder with an interest of greater than five percent in such
parent; and
(iv) The U.S. business that is the subject of the transaction, both
before and after completion of the transaction.
(18) Information regarding all foreign government ownership in the
foreign person's ownership structure, including nationality and
percentage of ownership, as well as any rights that a foreign
government holds, directly or indirectly, with respect to the foreign
person.
(19) With respect to the foreign person that is party to the
transaction and any of its parents, as applicable, a brief summary of
their respective business activities, as, for example, set forth in
annual reports.
[[Page 50199]]
(20) A statement as to whether any party to the transaction has
been party to another transaction previously notified or submitted to
the Committee, and the case number assigned by the Committee regarding
such transaction(s).
(21) A statement (including relevant jurisdiction and criminal case
law number or legal citation) as to whether the U.S. business, the
foreign person, or any parent or subsidiary of the foreign person has
been convicted in the last ten years of a crime in any jurisdiction.
(22) If applicable, a description (which may group similar items
into general product categories) of the items, their uses, and a list
of any relevant classifications for the critical technologies that the
U.S. business produces, designs, tests, manufactures, fabricates, or
develops.
(23) If applicable, a statement as to which functions set forth in
Column 2 of appendix A to part 800 that the U.S. business performs with
respect to covered investment critical infrastructure, including a
description of such functions and the applicable covered investment
critical infrastructure.
(24) If applicable:
(i) The category or categories of sensitive personal data, as
specified at Sec. 800.241, that the U.S. business maintains or
collects, or intends to maintain or collect;
(ii) The approximate number of total unique individuals from whom
sensitive personal data is currently maintained, and has been collected
over the last 12 months;
(iii) Whether the U.S. business targets or tailors its products or
services to U.S. Government personnel or contractors from whom it
maintains or collects sensitive personal data.
(d) Each party submitting a declaration shall provide a
certification of the information contained in the declaration
consistent with Sec. 800.204 of this chapter. A sample certification
may be found on the Committee's section of the Department of the
Treasury website at https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/international/the-committee-on-foreign-investment-in-the-united-states-cfius.
(e) A party that offers a stipulation pursuant to paragraph (c)(3)
of this section acknowledges that the Committee and the President are
entitled to rely on such stipulation in determining whether the
transaction is a covered investment, a covered control transaction, or
a foreign government-controlled transaction for the purposes of section
721 and all authorities thereunder, and waives the right to challenge
any such determination. Neither the Committee nor the President is
bound by any such stipulation, nor does any such stipulation limit the
ability of the Committee or the President to act on any authority
provided under section 721 with respect to any covered transaction.
Sec. 800.405 Beginning of 30-day assessment period.
(a) Upon receipt of a declaration submitted pursuant to Sec.
800.403, the Staff Chairperson shall promptly inspect the declaration
and shall promptly notify in writing all parties to a transaction that
have submitted a declaration that:
(1) The Staff Chairperson has accepted the declaration and
circulated the declaration to the Committee, and the date on which the
assessment described in paragraph (b) of this section begins; or
(2) The Staff Chairperson has determined not to accept the
declaration and circulate the declaration to the Committee because the
declaration is incomplete, and an explanation of the material respects
in which the declaration is incomplete.
(b) A 30-day period for assessment of a covered transaction that is
the subject of a declaration shall commence on the date on which the
declaration is received by the Committee from the Staff Chairperson.
Such period shall end no later than the thirtieth day after it has
commenced, or if the thirtieth day is not a business day, no later than
the next business day after the thirtieth day.
(c) During the 30-day assessment period, the Staff Chairperson may
invite the parties to a covered transaction to attend a meeting with
the Committee staff to discuss and clarify issues pertaining to the
transaction.
(d) If the Committee notifies the parties to a transaction that
have submitted a declaration pursuant to Sec. 800.403 that the
Committee intends to conclude all action under section 721 with respect
to that transaction, each party that has submitted additional
information subsequent to the original declaration shall file a
certification as described in Sec. 800.204. A sample certification may
be found on the Committee's section of the Department of the Treasury
website at https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/international/the-committee-on-foreign-investment-in-the-united-states-cfius.
(e) If a party fails to provide the certification required under
paragraph (d) of this section, the Committee may, at its discretion,
take any of the actions under Sec. 800.407.
Sec. 800.406 Rejection, disposition, or withdrawal of declarations.
(a) The Committee, acting through the Staff Chairperson, may:
(1) Reject any declaration that does not comply with Sec. 800.404
and so inform the parties promptly in writing;
(2) Reject any declaration at any time, and so inform the parties
promptly in writing, if, after the declaration has been submitted and
before the Committee has taken one of the actions specified in Sec.
800.407:
(i) There is a material change in the covered transaction as to
which a declaration has been submitted; or
(ii) Information comes to light that contradicts material
information provided in the declaration by the party (or parties); or
(3) Reject any declaration at any time after the declaration has
been submitted, and so inform the parties promptly in writing, if the
party (or parties) that submitted the declaration does not provide
follow-up information requested by the Staff Chairperson within two
business days of the request, or within a longer time frame if the
party (or parties) so request in writing and the Staff Chairperson
grants that request in writing.
(b) The Staff Chairperson shall notify the parties that submitted a
declaration when the Committee has found that the transaction that is
the subject of a declaration is not a covered transaction.
(c) Parties to a transaction that have submitted a declaration
pursuant to Sec. 800.403 may request in writing, at any time prior to
the Committee taking action under Sec. 800.407, that such declaration
be withdrawn. Such request shall be directed to the Staff Chairperson
and shall state the reasons why the request is being made and state
whether the transaction that is the subject of the declaration is being
fully and permanently abandoned. An official of the Department of the
Treasury will promptly advise the parties to the transaction in writing
of the Committee's decision.
(d) The Committee may not request or recommend that a declaration
be withdrawn and refiled, except to permit parties to a covered
transaction to correct material errors or omissions, or describe
material changes to the transaction, in the declaration submitted with
respect to that covered transaction.
(e) A party (or parties) may not submit more than one declaration
for the same or a substantially similar transaction without approval
from the Staff Chairperson.
Note 1 to Sec. 800.406: See Sec. 800.403(e) regarding the
prohibition on submitting a
[[Page 50200]]
declaration regarding the same transaction or a substantially
similar transaction for which a written notice has been filed
without the approval of the Staff Chairperson.
Sec. 800.407 Committee actions.
(a) Upon receiving a declaration submitted pursuant to Sec.
800.403 with respect to a covered transaction, the Committee may, at
the discretion of the Committee:
(1) Request that the parties to the transaction file a written
notice pursuant to subpart E;
(2) Inform the parties to the transaction that the Committee is not
able to conclude action under section 721 with respect to the
transaction on the basis of the declaration and that the parties may
file a written notice pursuant to subpart E to seek written
notification from the Committee that the Committee has concluded all
action under section 721 with respect to the transaction;
(3) Initiate a unilateral review of the transaction under Sec.
800.501(c); or
(4) Notify the parties in writing that the Committee has concluded
all action under section 721 with respect to the transaction.
(b) The Committee shall take action under paragraph (a) of this
section within the time period set forth in Sec. 800.405(b).
Subpart E--Notices
Sec. 800.501 Procedures for notices.
(a) A party or parties to a proposed or completed transaction may
file a voluntary notice of the transaction with the Committee.
Voluntary notice to the Committee is filed by sending an electronic
copy of the notice that includes, in English, the information set out
in Sec. 800.502, including the certification required under paragraph
(l) of that section. For electronic submission instructions, see the
Committee's section of the Department of the Treasury website,
currently available at https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/international/the-committee-on-foreign-investment-in-the-united-states-cfius.
(b) If the Committee determines that a transaction for which no
voluntary notice has been filed under paragraph (a) of this section may
be a covered transaction and may raise national security
considerations, the Staff Chairperson, acting on the recommendation of
the Committee, may request the parties to the transaction to provide to
the Committee the information necessary to determine whether the
transaction is a covered transaction, and if the Committee determines
that the transaction is a covered transaction, to file a notice under
paragraph (a) of such covered transaction.
(c) With respect to any transaction:
(1) Subject to paragraph (c)(2) of this section, any member of the
Committee, or his designee at or above the Under Secretary or
equivalent level, may file an agency notice to the Committee through
the Staff Chairperson regarding a transaction if:
(i) That member has reason to believe that the transaction is a
covered transaction and may raise national security considerations and:
(A) The Committee has not informed the parties to such transaction
in writing that the Committee has concluded all action under section
721 with respect to such transaction; and
(B) The President has not announced a decision not to exercise the
President's authority under section 721(d) with respect to such
transaction; or
(ii) The transaction is a covered transaction and:
(A) The Committee has informed the parties to such transaction in
writing that the Committee has concluded all action under section 721
with respect to such transaction, or the President has announced a
decision not to exercise the President's authority under section 721(d)
with respect to such transaction; and
(B) Either:
(1) A party to such transaction submitted false or misleading
material information to the Committee in connection with the
Committee's consideration of such transaction or omitted material
information, including material documents, from information submitted
to the Committee; or
(2) A party to such transaction or the entity resulting from
consummation of such transaction materially breaches a mitigation
agreement or condition described in section 721(l)(3)(A), such breach
is certified to the Committee by the lead department or agency
monitoring and enforcing such agreement or condition as a material
breach, and the Committee determines that there are no other adequate
and appropriate remedies or enforcement tools available to address such
breach.
(2)(i) That is an investment where a foreign person is not an
excepted investor due to the application of Sec. 800.220(d), any
member of the Committee, or his designee at or above the Under
Secretary or equivalent level, may file an agency notice to the
Committee through the Staff Chairperson regarding such investment if:
(A) That member has reason to believe that the transaction is a
covered transaction and may raise national security considerations;
(B) The Committee has not informed the parties to such transaction
in writing that the Committee has concluded all action under section
721 with respect to such transaction; and
(C) The President has not announced a decision not to exercise the
President's authority under section 721(d) with respect to such
transaction.
(ii) No notice filed pursuant to this paragraph (c)(2) shall be
made with respect to a transaction more than one year after the
completion date of the transaction, unless the Chairperson of the
Committee determines, in consultation with other members of the
Committee, that because the foreign person no longer meets all the
criteria set forth in Sec. 800.220(a)(1), (2), or (3)(i) through (iii)
the transaction may threaten to impair the national security of the
United States, and in no event shall an agency notice under this
paragraph be made with respect to such a transaction more than three
years after the completion date of the transaction.
(d) Notices filed under paragraph (c) of this section are deemed
accepted upon their receipt by the Staff Chairperson. No agency notice
under paragraph (c)(1) of this section shall be made with respect to a
transaction more than three years after the completion date of the
transaction, unless the Chairperson of the Committee, in consultation
with other members of the Committee, files such an agency notice.
(e) No communications other than those described in paragraphs (a)
and (c) of this section shall constitute the filing or submitting of a
notice for purposes of section 721.
(f) Upon receipt of the electronic copy of a notice filed under
paragraph (a) of this section, including the certification required by
Sec. 800.502(l), the Staff Chairperson shall promptly inspect such
notice for completeness.
(g) Parties to a transaction are encouraged to consult with the
Committee in advance of filing a notice and, in appropriate cases, to
file with the Committee a draft notice or other appropriate documents
to aid the Committee's understanding of the transaction and to provide
an opportunity for the Committee to request additional information to
be included in the notice. Any such pre-notice consultation should take
place, or any draft notice should be provided, at least five business
days before the filing of a voluntary notice. All information and
documentary material made available to the Committee pursuant to
[[Page 50201]]
this paragraph shall be considered to have been filed with the
President or the President's designee for purposes of section 721(c)
and Sec. 800.802.
(h) Information and other documentary material provided by the
parties to the Committee after the filing of a voluntary notice under
this section shall be part of the notice, and shall be subject to the
certification requirements of Sec. 800.502(m).
(i) For any voluntarily submitted draft or formal written notice
that includes a stipulation pursuant to section Sec. 800.502(o) that a
transaction is a covered transaction, the Committee shall provide
comments on a draft or formal written notice or accept a formal written
notice of a covered transaction not later than the date that is 10
business days after the date of submission of the draft or formal
written notice.
(j) No party to a transaction may file a notice pursuant to
paragraph (a) of this section if the transaction has been subject to a
declaration submitted pursuant to subpart D and the Committee has not
yet taken action with respect to the transaction pursuant to Sec.
800.407.
Sec. 800.502 Contents of voluntary notices.
(a) If the parties to a transaction file a voluntary notice, they
shall provide in detail the information set out in this section, which
must be accurate and complete with respect to all parties and to the
transaction. (See also paragraph (l) of this section and Sec. 800.204
regarding certification requirements.)
(b) If fewer than all the parties to a transaction file a voluntary
notice, for example in the case of a hostile takeover, each notifying
party shall provide the information set out in this section with
respect to itself and, to the extent known or reasonably available to
it, with respect to each non-notifying party.
(c) A voluntary notice filed pursuant to Sec. 800.501 shall
describe or provide, as applicable:
(1) The transaction in question, including:
(i) A summary setting forth the essentials of the transaction,
including a statement of the purpose of the transaction, and its scope,
both within and outside of the United States;
(ii) The nature of the transaction, for example, whether the
acquisition is by merger, consolidation, the purchase of voting
interest, or otherwise;
(iii) The name, United States address (if any), website address (if
any), nationality (for individuals) or place of incorporation or other
legal organization (for entities), and address of the principal place
of business of each foreign person that is a party to the transaction;
(iv) The name, address, website address (if any), principal place
of business, and place of incorporation or other legal organization of
the U.S. business that is the subject of the transaction;
(v) The name, address, and nationality (for individuals) or place
of incorporation or other legal organization (for entities) of:
(A) The immediate parent, the ultimate parent, and each
intermediate parent, if any, of the foreign person that is a party to
the transaction;
(B) Where the ultimate parent is a private company, the ultimate
owner(s) of such parent; and
(C) Where the ultimate parent is a public company, any shareholder
with an interest of greater than five percent in such parent;
(vi) The name, address, website address (if any), and nationality
(for individuals) or place of incorporation or other legal organization
(for entities) of each person that will control the U.S. business being
acquired;
(vii) The expected date for completion of the transaction, or the
date it was completed;
(viii) A good faith approximation of the net value of the interest
acquired in the U.S. business in U.S. dollars, as of the date of the
notice;
(ix) The name of any and all financial institutions involved in the
transaction, including as advisors, underwriters, or a source of
financing for the transaction;
(x) A copy of any partnership agreements, integration agreements,
or other side agreements relating to the transaction;
(xi) A statement as to whether the foreign person will acquire any
of the following in the U.S. business:
(A) Access to any material nonpublic technical information in the
possession of the U.S. business, and if so, a brief explanation of the
type of access and type of information;
(B) Membership, observer rights, or nomination rights as set forth
in Sec. 800.211(b)(2), and if so, a statement as to the composition of
the board or other body both before and after the completion date of
the transaction;
(C) Any involvement, other than through voting shares, in
substantive decisionmaking of the U.S. business regarding critical
infrastructure, critical technologies, or sensitive personal data as
set forth in Sec. 800.211(b)(3);
(2) With respect to a transaction structured as an acquisition of
assets of a U.S. business, a detailed description of the assets of the
U.S. business being acquired, including the approximate value of those
assets in U.S. dollars;
(3) With respect to the U.S. business that is the subject of the
transaction and any entity of which that U.S. business is a parent
(unless that entity is excluded from the scope of the transaction):
(i) Their respective business activities, as, for example, set
forth in annual reports, and the product or service categories of each,
including an estimate of U.S. market share for such product or service
categories and the methodology used to determine market share, a list
of direct competitors for those primary product or service categories,
and their NAICS Code, if any;
(ii) The street address (and mailing address, if different) within
the United States and website address (if any) of each facility that is
manufacturing classified or unclassified products or producing services
described in paragraph (c)(3)(v) of this section, and their respective
CAGE Codes, their DUNS number;
(iii) Each contract (identified by agency and number) that is
currently in effect or was in effect within the past five years with
any agency of the U.S. Government involving any information,
technology, or data that is classified under Executive Order 12958, as
amended, its estimated final completion date, and the name, office, and
telephone number of the contracting official;
(iv) Any other contract (identified by agency and number) that is
currently in effect or was in effect within the past three years with
any U.S. Government agency or component with national defense, homeland
security, or other national security responsibilities, including law
enforcement responsibility as it relates to defense, homeland security,
or national security, its estimated final completion date, and the
name, office, and telephone number of the contracting official;
(v) Any products or services (including research and development):
(A) That it supplies, directly or indirectly, to any agency of the
U.S. Government, including as a prime contractor or first tier
subcontractor, a supplier to any such prime contractor or
subcontractor, or, if known by the parties filing the notice, a
subcontractor at any tier; and
(B) If known by the parties filing the notice, for which it is a
single qualified source (i.e., other acceptable suppliers are readily
available to be so qualified) or a sole source (i.e., no other supplier
has needed technology, equipment, and manufacturing process
capabilities) for any such agencies and whether there are
[[Page 50202]]
other suppliers in the market that are available to be so qualified;
(vi) Any products or services (including research and development)
that:
(A) It supplies to third parties and it knows are rebranded by the
purchaser or incorporated into the products of another entity, and the
names or brands under which such rebranded products or services are
sold; and
(B) In the case of services, it provides on behalf of, or under the
name of, another entity, and the name of any such entities;
(vii) For the prior three years--
(A) A list of priority rated contracts or orders under DPAS
regulation that the U.S. business that is the subject of the
transaction has received and the level of priority of such contracts or
orders (``DX'' or ``DO''); and
(B) A list of such priority rated contracts or orders that the U.S.
business has placed with other entities and the level of priority of
such contracts or orders, and the acquiring party's plan to ensure that
any new entity formed at the completion of the notified transaction (or
the U.S. business, if no new entity is formed) complies with the DPAS
regulations;
(viii) A description and copy of the cyber security plan, if any,
that will be used to protect against cyber attacks on the operation,
design, and development of the U.S. business's services, networks,
systems, data storage (including the collection or maintenance of
sensitive personal data), and facilities;
(ix) A description of whether the U.S. business performs any of the
functions, if any, as set forth in Column 2 of appendix A to part 800.
This statement shall include a description of such functions, including
the applicable covered investment critical infrastructure;
(x) A description of whether it produces, designs, tests,
manufactures, fabricates, or develops one or more critical
technologies;
(xi) A description of whether it maintains or collects sensitive
personal data, including:
(A) The category or categories of sensitive personal data specified
in Sec. 800.241 that the U.S. business maintains or collects or
intends to maintain or collect;
(B) For each category of sensitive personal data, the approximate
number of total unique persons from whom the sensitive personal data is
currently maintained or has been collected during the previous three
years, if known;
(C) A description of how the U.S. business targets or tailors its
products or services to U.S. Government personnel or contractors (as
described in Sec. 800.247) about whom it collects sensitive personal
data, if applicable;
(D) The commercial rationale of the U.S. business for maintaining
or collecting such sensitive personal data and a description of how the
U.S. business uses and protects such sensitive personal data, including
a description of how decisions regarding the use of sensitive personal
data are made, and by whom;
(E) A description of the U.S. business's policies and practices
regarding the sale, license, or transfer of, or grant of access to,
sensitive personal data to third parties, including a copy of any
notice provided to customers regarding the use and transfer of
sensitive personal data;
(F) A description of the U.S. business's policies and practices
regarding retention of sensitive personal data; and
(G) Any plans by the foreign party to the transaction to alter any
of the foregoing;
(4) Whether the U.S. business that is being acquired produces or
trades in:
(i) Items that are subject to the EAR and, if so, a description
(which may group similar items into general product categories) of the
items and a list of the relevant commodity classifications set forth on
the CCL (i.e., Export Control Classification Numbers (ECCNs) or EAR99
designation);
(ii) Defense articles and defense services, and related technical
data covered by the USML in the ITAR, and, if so, the category of the
USML; articles and services for which commodity jurisdiction requests
(22 CFR 120.4) are pending; and articles and services (including those
under development) that may be designated or determined in the future
to be defense articles or defense services pursuant to 22 CFR 120.3;
(iii) Products and technology that are subject to export
authorization administered by the Department of Energy (10 CFR part
810), or export licensing requirements administered by the Nuclear
Regulatory Commission (10 CFR part 110);
(iv) Select Agents and Toxins (7 CFR part 331, 9 CFR part 121, and
42 CFR part 73); or
(v) Emerging and foundational technologies controlled pursuant to
section 1758 of the Export Control Reform Act of 2018 (codified at 50
U.S.C. 4817);
(5) Whether the U.S. business that is the subject of the
transaction:
(i) Possesses any licenses, permits, or other authorizations other
than those under the regulatory authorities listed in paragraph (c)(4)
of this section that have been granted by an agency of the U.S.
Government (if applicable, identification of the relevant licenses
shall be provided); or
(ii) Has technology that has military applications (if so, an
identification of such technology and a description of such military
applications shall be included);
(6) With respect to the foreign person engaged in the transaction
and its parents:
(i) The business or businesses of the foreign person and its
ultimate parent, as such businesses are described, for example, in
annual reports, and the CAGE codes, NAICS codes, and DUNS numbers, if
any, for such businesses;
(ii) The plans of the foreign person for the U.S. business with
respect to:
(A) Reducing, eliminating, or selling research and development
facilities;
(B) Changing product quality;
(C) Shutting down or moving outside of the United States facilities
that are within the United States;
(D) Consolidating or selling product lines or technology;
(E) Modifying or terminating contracts referred to in paragraphs
(c)(3)(iii) and (iv) of this section; or
(F) Eliminating domestic supply by selling products solely to non-
domestic markets;
(iii) Whether the foreign person is controlled by or acting on
behalf of a foreign government, including without limitation as an
agent or representative, or in some similar capacity, and if so, the
identity of the foreign government;
(iv) Whether a foreign government or a person controlled by or
acting on behalf of a foreign government:
(A) Has or controls ownership interests, including contingent
equity interest, of the acquiring foreign person or any parent of the
acquiring foreign person, and if so, the nature and amount of any such
interests, and with regard to contingent equity interest, the terms and
timing of conversion;
(B) Has the right or power to appoint any of the principal officers
or the members of the board of directors (including other persons who
perform the duties usually associated with such titles) of the foreign
person that is a party to the transaction or any parent of that foreign
person;
(C) Holds any other contingent interest (for example, such as might
arise from a lending transaction) in the foreign acquiring party and,
if so, the rights that are covered by this contingent interest, and the
manner in which they would be enforced; or
(D) Has any other affirmative or negative rights or powers that
could be
[[Page 50203]]
relevant to the Committee's determination of whether the notified
transaction is a foreign government-controlled transaction, and if
there are any such rights or powers, their source (for example, a
``golden share,'' shareholders agreement, contract, statute, or
regulation) and the mechanics of their operation;
(v) Any formal or informal arrangements among foreign persons that
hold an ownership interest in the foreign person that is a party to the
transaction or between such foreign person and other foreign persons to
act in concert on particular matters affecting the U.S. business that
is the subject of the transaction, and provide a copy of any documents
that establish those rights or describe those arrangements;
(vi) For each member of the board of directors or similar body
(including external directors and other persons who perform the duties
usually associated with such titles) and officers (including president,
senior vice president, executive vice president, and other persons who
perform duties normally associated with such titles) of the acquiring
foreign person engaged in the transaction and its immediate,
intermediate, and ultimate parents, and for any individual having an
ownership interest of five percent or more in the acquiring foreign
person engaged in the transaction and in the foreign person's ultimate
parent, the following information:
(A) A curriculum vitae or similar professional synopsis, provided
as part of the main notice, and
(B) The following ``personal identifier information,'' which, for
privacy reasons, and to ensure limited distribution, shall be set forth
in a separate document, not in the main notice:
(1) Full name (last, first, middle name);
(2) All other names and aliases used;
(3) Business address;
(4) Country and city of residence;
(5) Date of birth, in the format MM/DD/YYYY;
(6) Place of birth;
(7) U.S. Social Security number (where applicable);
(8) National identity number, including nationality, date and place
of issuance, and expiration date (where applicable);
(9) U.S. or foreign passport number (if more than one, all must be
fully disclosed), nationality, date and place of issuance, and
expiration date and, if a U.S. visa holder, the visa type and number,
date and place of issuance, and expiration date; and
(10) Dates and nature of foreign government and foreign military
service (where applicable), other than military service at a rank below
the top two non-commissioned ranks of the relevant foreign country; and
(vii) The following ``business identifier information'' for the
immediate, intermediate, and ultimate parents of the foreign person
engaged in the transaction, including their main offices and branches:
(A) Business name, including all names under which the business is
known to be or has been doing business;
(B) Business address;
(C) Business phone number, website address, and email address; and
(D) Employer identification number or other domestic tax or
corporate identification number.
(d) The voluntary notice shall list any filings with, or reports
to, agencies of the U.S. Government that have been or will be made with
respect to the transaction prior to its completion, indicating the
agencies concerned, the nature of the filing or report, the date on
which it was filed or the estimated date by which it will be filed, and
a relevant contact point and/or telephone number within the agency, if
known.
(1) Example: Corporation A, a foreign person, intends to acquire
Corporation X, which is wholly owned and controlled by a U.S. national
and which has a Facility Security Clearance under the Department of
Defense Industrial Security Program. See Department of Defense,
``Industrial Security Regulation,'' DOD 5220.22-R, and ``Industrial
Security Manual for Safeguarding Classified Information,'' DOD 5220.22-
M. Corporation X accordingly files a revised Form DD SF-328, and enters
into discussions with the Defense Security Service about effectively
insulating its facilities from the foreign person. Corporation X may
also have made filings with the U.S. Securities and Exchange
Commission, the Department of Commerce, the Department of State, or
other federal departments and agencies. Paragraph (d) of this section
requires that certain specific information about these filings be
reported to the Committee in a voluntary notice.
(e) In the case of the establishment of a joint venture in which
one or more of the parties is contributing a U.S. business, information
for the voluntary notice shall be prepared on the assumption that the
foreign person that is party to the joint venture has made an
acquisition of the existing U.S. business that the other party to the
joint venture is contributing or transferring to the joint venture. The
voluntary notice shall describe the name and address of the joint
venture and the entities that established, or are establishing, the
joint venture.
(f) In the case of the acquisition of some but not all of the
assets of an entity, paragraph (c) of this section requires submission
of the specified information only with respect to the assets of the
entity that have been or are proposed to be acquired.
(g) Persons filing a voluntary notice shall, with respect to the
foreign person that is a party to the transaction, its immediate
parent, the U.S. business that is the subject of the transaction, and
each entity of which the foreign person is a parent, append to the
voluntary notice the most recent annual report of each such entity, in
English. Separate reports are not required for any entity whose
financial results are included within the consolidated financial
results stated in the annual report of any parent of any such entity,
unless the transaction involves the acquisition of a U.S. business
whose parent is not being acquired, in which case the notice shall
include the most recent audited financial statement of the U.S.
business that is the subject of the transaction. If a U.S. business
does not prepare an annual report and its financial results are not
included within the consolidated financial results stated in the annual
report of a parent, the filing shall include, if available, the
entity's most recent audited financial statement (or, if an audited
financial statement is not available, the unaudited financial
statement).
(h) Persons filing a voluntary notice shall, during the time that
the matter is pending before the Committee or the President, promptly
advise the Staff Chairperson of any material changes in plans, facts
and circumstances addressed in the notice, and information provided or
required to be provided to the Committee under this section, and shall
file amendments to the notice to reflect such material changes. Such
amendments shall become part of the notice filed by such persons under
Sec. 800.501, and the certifications required under paragraphs (l) and
(m) of this section shall apply to such amendments.
(i) Persons filing a voluntary notice shall include a copy of the
most recent asset or stock purchase agreement or other document
establishing the agreed terms of the transaction.
(j) Persons filing a voluntary notice shall include:
(1) Complete organizational charts, both pre- and post-transaction,
including without limitation, information that identifies the name,
[[Page 50204]]
principal place of business and place of incorporation or other legal
organization (for entities), nationality (for individuals), and
ownership percentage (expressed in terms of both voting and economic
interest, if different) for each of the following:
(i) The immediate parent, the ultimate parent, and each
intermediate parent, if any, of each foreign person that is a party to
the transaction;
(ii) Where the ultimate parent is a private company, the ultimate
owner(s) of such parent;
(iii) Where the ultimate parent is a public company, any
shareholder with an interest of greater than five percent in such
parent; and
(iv) The U.S. business that is the subject of the transaction, both
before and after completion of the transaction; and
(2) The opinion of the person regarding whether:
(i) It is a foreign person;
(ii) It is controlled by a foreign government;
(iii) A foreign government holds a substantial interest in the
foreign person that is party to the transaction; and
(iv) The transaction has resulted or could result in a covered
control transaction or a covered investment, and the reasons for its
view, focusing in particular on any powers (for example, by virtue of a
shareholders agreement, contract, statute, or regulation) that the
foreign person will have with regard to the U.S. business, and how
those powers can or will be exercised, or any other access, rights, or
involvement the foreign person will have in a U.S. business with
respect to critical technologies, critical infrastructure, or sensitive
personal data.
(k) Persons filing a voluntary notice shall include information as
to whether:
(1) Any party to the transaction is, or has been, a party to a
mitigation agreement entered into or condition imposed under section
721, and if so, shall specify the date and purpose of such agreement or
condition and the U.S. Government signatories; and
(2) Any party to the transaction (including such party's parents,
subsidiaries, or entities under common control with the party) has been
a party to a transaction previously notified to the Committee.
(l) Each party filing a voluntary notice shall provide a
certification of the notice consistent with Sec. 800.204. A sample
certification may be found on the Committee's section of the Department
of the Treasury website, currently available at https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/international/the-committee-on-foreign-investment-in-the-united-states-cfius.
(m) At the conclusion of a review or investigation, each party that
has filed additional information subsequent to the original notice
shall file a final certification. (See Sec. 800.204.) A sample
certification may be found at the Committee's section of the Department
of the Treasury website, currently available at https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/international/the-committee-on-foreign-investment-in-the-united-states-cfius.
(n) Parties filing a voluntary notice shall include with the notice
a list identifying each document provided as part of the notice,
including all documents provided as attachments or exhibits to the
narrative response.
(o) A party filing a voluntary notice may stipulate that the
transaction is a covered transaction and, if the party stipulates that
the transaction is a covered transaction, that the transaction is a
foreign government-controlled transaction. A stipulation offered by any
party pursuant to this section must be accompanied by a detailed
description of the basis for the stipulation. The required description
of the basis shall include, but is not limited to, discussion of all
relevant information responsive to paragraphs (c)(6)(iii) through (v)
of this section. A party that offers such a stipulation acknowledges
that the Committee and the President are entitled to rely on such
stipulation in determining whether the transaction is a covered
transaction, a foreign government-controlled transaction, and/or
subject to mandatory declaration or notice for the purposes of section
721 and all authorities thereunder, and waives the right to challenge
any such determination. Neither the Committee nor the President is
bound by any such stipulation, nor does any such stipulation limit the
ability of the Committee or the President to act on any authority
provided under section 721 with respect to any covered transaction.
Sec. 800.503 Beginning of a 45-day review period.
(a) The Staff Chairperson of the Committee shall accept a voluntary
notice the next business day after the Staff Chairperson has:
(1) Determined that the notice complies with Sec. 800.502; and
(2) Disseminated the notice to all members of the Committee.
(b) A 45-day period for review of a transaction shall commence on
the date on which the voluntary notice has been accepted, agency notice
has been received by the Staff Chairperson of the Committee, or the
Chairperson of the Committee has requested a notice pursuant to Sec.
800.501(b). Such review shall end no later than the forty-fifth day
after it has commenced, or if the forty-fifth day is not a business
day, no later than the next business day after the forty-fifth day.
(c) The Staff Chairperson shall promptly advise in writing all
parties to a transaction that have filed a voluntary notice of:
(1) The acceptance of the notice;
(2) The date on which the review begins; and
(3) The designation of any lead agency or agencies.
(d) Within two business days after receipt of an agency notice by
the Staff Chairperson, the Staff Chairperson shall send written advice
of such notice to the parties to the transaction that is subject to the
notice. Such written advice shall identify the date on which the review
began.
(e) The Staff Chairperson shall promptly circulate to all Committee
members any draft pre-filing notice, any agency notice, any complete
notice, and any subsequent information filed by the parties.
Sec. 800.504 Deferral, rejection, or disposition of certain voluntary
notices.
(a) The Committee, acting through the Staff Chairperson, may:
(1) Reject any voluntary notice that does not comply with Sec.
800.501 or Sec. 800.502 and so inform the parties promptly in writing;
(2) Reject any voluntary notice at any time, and so inform the
parties promptly in writing, if, after the notice has been submitted
and before action by the Committee or the President has been concluded:
(i) There is a material change in the transaction as to which
notification has been made; or
(ii) Information comes to light that contradicts material
information provided in the notice by the parties;
(3) Reject any voluntary notice at any time after the notice has
been accepted, and so inform the parties promptly in writing, if the
party or parties that have submitted the voluntary notice do not
provide follow-up information requested by the Staff Chairperson within
three business days of the request, or within a longer time frame if
the parties so request in writing and the Staff Chairperson grants that
request in writing; or
(4) Reject any voluntary notice before the conclusion of a review
or investigation, and so inform the parties promptly in writing, if one
of the parties submitting the voluntary notice has not
[[Page 50205]]
submitted the final certification required by Sec. 800.502(m).
(b) Notwithstanding the authority of the Staff Chairperson under
paragraph (a) of this section to reject an incomplete notice, the Staff
Chairperson may defer acceptance of the notice, and the beginning of
the review period specified by Sec. 800.503, to obtain any information
required under this section that has not been submitted by the
notifying party or parties or other parties to the transaction. Where
necessary to obtain such information, the Staff Chairperson may inform
any non-notifying party or parties that notice has been filed with
respect to a proposed transaction involving the party, and request that
certain information required under this section, as specified by the
Staff Chairperson, be provided to the Committee within seven days after
receipt of the Staff Chairperson's request.
(c) The Staff Chairperson shall notify the parties when the
Committee has found that the transaction that is the subject of a
voluntary notice is not a covered transaction.
(d) Examples:
(1) Example 1. The Staff Chairperson receives a joint notice
from Corporation A, a foreign person, and Corporation X, a company
that is owned and controlled by U.S. nationals, with respect to
Corporation A's intent to purchase all of the shares of Corporation
X. The joint notice does not contain any information described under
Sec. 800.502 concerning classified materials and products or
services supplied to the U.S. military services. The Staff
Chairperson may reject the notice or defer the start of the review
period until the parties have supplied the omitted information.
(2) Example 2. Same facts as in the first sentence of Example 1
of this section, except that the joint notice indicates that
Corporation A does not intend to purchase Corporation X's Division
Y, which is engaged in classified work for a U.S. Government agency.
Corporations A and X notify the Committee on the 40th day of the 45-
day notice period that Division Y will also be acquired by
Corporation A. This fact constitutes a material change with respect
to the transaction as originally notified, and the Staff Chairperson
may reject the notice.
(3) Example 3. The Staff Chairperson receives a joint notice by
Corporation A, a foreign person, and Corporation X, a U.S. business,
indicating that Corporation A intends to purchase five percent of
the voting securities of Corporation X. Under the particular facts
and circumstances presented, the Committee concludes that
Corporation A's purchase of this interest in Corporation X could not
result in a covered investment in or foreign control of Corporation
X. The Staff Chairperson shall advise the parties in writing that
the transaction as presented is not subject to section 721.
(4) Example 4. The Staff Chairperson receives a voluntary notice
involving the acquisition by Company A, a foreign person, of the
entire interest in Company X, a U.S. business. The notice mentions
the involvement of a second foreign person in the transaction,
Company B, but states that Company B is merely a passive investor in
the transaction. During the course of the review, the parties
provide information that clarifies that Company B has the right to
appoint two members of Company X's board of directors. This
information contradicts the material assertion in the notice that
Company B is a passive investor. The Committee may reject this
notice without concluding review under section 721.
Sec. 800.505 Determination of whether to undertake an investigation.
(a) After a review of a notified transaction under Sec. 800.503,
the Committee shall undertake an investigation of any transaction that
it has determined to be a covered transaction if:
(1) A member of the Committee (other than a member designated as ex
officio under section 721(k)) advises the Staff Chairperson that the
member believes that the transaction threatens to impair the national
security of the United States and that the threat has not been
mitigated; or
(2) The lead agency recommends, and the Committee concurs, that an
investigation be undertaken.
(b) The Committee shall also undertake, after a review of a covered
transaction under Sec. 800.503, an investigation to determine the
effects on national security of any covered transaction that:
(1) Is a foreign government-controlled transaction; or
(2) Would result in control by a foreign person of critical
infrastructure of or within the United States, if the Committee
determines that the transaction could impair the national security and
such impairment has not been mitigated.
(c) The Committee shall undertake an investigation as described in
paragraph (b) of this section unless the Chairperson of the Committee
(or the Deputy Secretary of the Treasury) and the head of any lead
agency (or his or her delegee at the deputy level or equivalent)
designated by the Chairperson determine on the basis of the review that
the covered transaction will not impair the national security of the
United States.
Sec. 800.506 Determination not to undertake an investigation.
If the Committee determines, during the review period described in
Sec. 800.503, not to undertake an investigation of a notified covered
transaction, action under section 721 shall be concluded. An official
at the Department of the Treasury shall promptly inform the parties to
a covered transaction in writing of a determination of the Committee
not to undertake an investigation and to conclude action under section
721.
Sec. 800.507 Commencement of investigation.
(a) If it is determined that an investigation should be undertaken,
such investigation shall commence no later than the end of the review
period described in Sec. 800.503.
(b) An official of the Department of the Treasury shall promptly
inform the parties to a covered transaction in writing of the
commencement of an investigation.
Sec. 800.508 Completion or termination of investigation and report to
the President.
(a) Subject to paragraph (e) of this section, the Committee shall
complete an investigation no later than the forty-fifth day after the
date the investigation commences, or, if the forty-fifth day is not a
business day, no later than the next business day after the forty-fifth
day.
(b) Upon completion or termination of any investigation, the
Committee shall send a report to the President requesting the
President's decision if:
(1) The Committee recommends that the President suspend or prohibit
the transaction;
(2) The Committee is unable to reach a decision on whether to
recommend that the President suspend or prohibit the transaction; or
(3) The Committee requests that the President make a determination
with regard to the transaction.
(c) In circumstances when the Committee sends a report to the
President requesting the President's decision with respect to a covered
transaction, such report shall include information relevant to sections
721(d)(4)(A) and (B), and shall present the Committee's recommendation.
If the Committee is unable to reach a decision to present a single
recommendation to the President, the Chairperson of the Committee shall
submit a report of the Committee to the President setting forth the
differing views and presenting the issues for decision.
(d) Upon completion or termination of an investigation, if the
Committee determines to conclude all deliberative action under section
721 with regard to a notified covered transaction without sending a
report to the President, action under section 721 shall be concluded.
An official at the Department of the Treasury shall promptly advise the
parties to such a transaction in writing of a determination to conclude
action.
[[Page 50206]]
(e) In extraordinary circumstances, the Chairperson may, upon a
written request signed by the head of a lead agency, extend an
investigation for one 15-day period. A request to extend an
investigation must describe, with particularity, the extraordinary
circumstances that warrant the Chairperson extending the investigation.
The authority of the head of a lead agency to request the extension of
an investigation may not be delegated to any person other than the
deputy head (or equivalent thereof) of the lead agency. If the
Chairperson extends an investigation pursuant to this paragraph with
respect to a covered transaction, the Committee shall promptly notify
the parties to the transaction of the extension.
(f) For purposes of paragraph (e) of this section, ``extraordinary
circumstances'' means circumstances for which extending an
investigation is necessary and the appropriate course of action due to
a force majeure event or to protect the national security of the United
States.
Sec. 800.509 Withdrawal of notices.
(a) A party (or parties) to a transaction that has filed notice
under Sec. 800.501(a) may request in writing, at any time prior to
conclusion of all action under section 721, that such notice be
withdrawn. Such request shall be directed to the Staff Chairperson and
shall state the reasons why the request is being made. Such requests
will ordinarily be granted, unless otherwise determined by the
Committee. An official of the Department of the Treasury will promptly
advise the parties to the transaction in writing of the Committee's
decision.
(b) Any request to withdraw an agency notice by the agency that
filed it shall be in writing and shall be effective only upon approval
by the Committee. An official of the Department of the Treasury shall
advise the parties to the transaction in writing of the Committee's
decision to approve the withdrawal request within two business days of
the Committee's decision.
(c) In any case where a request to withdraw a notice is granted
under paragraph (a) of this section:
(1) The Staff Chairperson, in consultation with the Committee,
shall establish, as appropriate:
(i) A process for tracking actions that may be taken by any party
to the covered transaction before notice is refiled under Sec.
800.501; and
(ii) Interim protections to address specific national security
concerns with the transaction identified during the review or
investigation of the transaction.
(2) The Staff Chairperson shall specify a time frame, as
appropriate, for the parties to resubmit a notice and shall advise the
parties of that time frame in writing.
(d) A notice of a transaction that is submitted pursuant to
paragraph (c)(2) of this section shall be deemed a new notice for
purposes of the regulations in this part, including Sec. 800.701.
Subpart F--Committee Procedures
Sec. 800.601 General.
(a) In any assessment, review, or investigation of a covered
transaction, the Committee should consider the factors specified in
section 721(f) and, as appropriate, require parties to provide to the
Committee the information necessary to consider such factors. The
Committee's assessment, review, or investigation (if necessary) shall
examine, as appropriate, whether:
(1) The transaction is a covered transaction;
(2) There is credible evidence to support a belief that any foreign
person party to a covered transaction might take action that threatens
to impair the national security of the United States; and
(3) Provisions of law, other than section 721 and the International
Emergency Economic Powers Act, provide adequate and appropriate
authority to protect the national security of the United States.
(b) During an assessment, review, or investigation, the Staff
Chairperson may invite the parties to a notified transaction to attend
a meeting with the Committee staff to discuss and clarify issues
pertaining to the transaction. During an investigation, a party to the
transaction under investigation may request a meeting with the
Committee staff; such a request ordinarily will be granted.
(c) The Staff Chairperson shall be the point of contact for
receiving material filed with the Committee, including notices.
(d) Where more than one lead agency is designated, communications
on material matters between a party to the transaction and a lead
agency shall include all lead agencies designated with regard to those
matters.
(e) The parties' description of a transaction in a declaration or
notice does not limit the ability of the Committee to, as appropriate,
assess, review, or investigate, or exercise any other authorities
available under section 721 with respect to any covered transaction
that the Committee identifies as having been notified to the Committee
based upon the facts set forth in the declaration or notice, any
additional information provided to the Committee subsequent to the
original declaration or notice, or any other information available to
the Committee.
Sec. 800.602 Role of the Secretary of Labor.
In response to a request from the Chairperson of the Committee, the
Secretary of Labor shall identify for the Committee any risk mitigation
provisions proposed to or by the Committee that would violate U.S.
employment laws or require a party to violate U.S. employment laws. The
Secretary of Labor shall serve no policy role on the Committee.
Sec. 800.603 Materiality.
The Committee generally will not consider as material minor
inaccuracies, omissions, or changes relating to financial or commercial
factors not having a bearing on national security.
Sec. 800.604 Tolling of deadlines during lapse in appropriations.
Any deadline or time limitation under subparts D or E imposed on
the Committee shall be tolled during a lapse in appropriations.
Subpart G--Finality of Action
Sec. 800.701 Finality of actions under section 721.
(a) All authority available to the President or the Committee under
section 721(d), including without limitation divestment authority,
shall remain available at the discretion of the President with respect
to:
(1) Covered control transactions proposed or pending on or after
August 23, 1988;
(2) Transactions that, between November 10, 2018, and [EFFECTIVE
DATE], fell within the scope of part 801 of this title; and
(3) Covered investments proposed or pending after the effective
date.
(b) Subject to Sec. 800.501(c)(1)(ii), such authority shall not be
exercised if:
(1) The Committee, through its Staff Chairperson, has advised a
party (or the parties) in writing that a particular transaction with
respect to which a voluntary notice or a declaration has been filed is
not a covered transaction;
(2) The parties to the transaction have been advised in writing
pursuant to Sec. 800.407(a)(4), Sec. 800.506, or Sec. 800.508(d)
that the Committee has concluded all action under section 721 with
respect to the covered transaction; or
(3) The President has previously announced, pursuant to section
721(d),
[[Page 50207]]
his decision not to exercise his authority under section 721 with
respect to the covered transaction.
(c) Divestment or other relief under section 721 shall not be
available with respect to transactions that were completed prior to
August 23, 1988.
Subpart H--Provision and Handling of Information
Sec. 800.801 Obligation of parties to provide information.
(a) Parties to a transaction that is notified or declared under
subparts D or E, or a transaction for which no notice or declaration
has been submitted and for which the Staff Chairperson has requested
information to assess whether the transaction is a covered transaction,
shall provide information to the Staff Chairperson that will enable the
Committee to conduct a full assessment, review, and/or investigation of
the proposed transaction, and shall promptly advise the Staff
Chairperson of any material changes in plans or information pursuant to
Sec. 800.403(d) or Sec. 800.502(h). If deemed necessary by the
Committee, information may be obtained from parties to a transaction or
other persons through subpoena or otherwise, pursuant to the Defense
Production Act Reauthorization of 2003, as amended, Public Law 108-195
(50 U.S.C. 4555(a)).
(b) Documentary materials or information required or requested to
be filed with the Committee under this part shall be submitted in
English. Supplementary materials, such as annual reports, written in a
foreign language, shall be submitted in certified English translation.
(c) Any information filed with the Committee in connection with any
action for which a report is required pursuant to section 721(l)(3)(B)
with respect to the implementation of a mitigation agreement or
condition described in section 721(l)(1)(A) shall be accompanied by a
certification that complies with the requirements of section 721(n) and
Sec. 800.204. A sample certification may be found at the Committee's
section of the Department of the Treasury website, currently available
at https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/international/the-committee-on-foreign-investment-in-the-united-states-cfius.
Sec. 800.802 Confidentiality.
(a) Except as provided in paragraph (b) of this section, any
information or documentary material submitted or filed with the
Committee pursuant to this part, including information or documentary
material filed pursuant to Sec. 800.501(g) shall be exempt from
disclosure under the Freedom of Information Act, as amended (5 U.S.C.
552, et seq.), and no such information or documentary material may be
made public.
(b) Paragraph (a) of this section shall not prohibit disclosure of
the following:
(1) Information relevant to any administrative or judicial action
or proceeding;
(2) Information to Congress or to any duly authorized committee or
subcommittee of Congress;
(3) Information important to the national security analysis or
actions of the Committee to any domestic governmental entity, or to any
foreign governmental entity of a United States ally or partner, under
the exclusive direction and authorization of the Chairperson, only to
the extent necessary for national security purposes, and subject to
appropriate confidentiality and classification requirements; or
(4) Information that the parties have consented to be disclosed to
third parties.
(c) This section shall continue to apply with respect to
information and documentary material submitted or filed with the
Committee in any case where:
(1) Action has concluded under section 721 concerning a notified
transaction;
(2) A request to withdraw a notice or a declaration is granted
under Sec. 800.509 or Sec. 800.406(c), respectively, or where a
notice or a declaration has been rejected under Sec. 800.504(a) or
Sec. 800.406(a), respectively;
(3) The Committee determines that a notified or declared
transaction is not a covered transaction; or
(4) Such information or documentary material was filed pursuant to
subpart D and the parties do not subsequently file a notice pursuant to
subpart E.
(d) Nothing in paragraph (a) of this section shall be interpreted
to prohibit the public disclosure by a party of documentary material or
information that it has submitted or filed with the Committee. Any such
documentary material or information so disclosed may subsequently be
reflected in the public statements of the Chairperson, who is
authorized to communicate with the public and the Congress on behalf of
the Committee, or of the Chairperson's designee.
(e) The provisions of the Defense Production Act Reauthorization of
2003, as amended (50 U.S.C. 4555(d)) relating to fines and imprisonment
shall apply with respect to the disclosure of information or
documentary material filed with the Committee under these regulations.
Subpart I--Penalties and Damages
Sec. 800.901 Penalties and damages.
(a) Any person who submits a material misstatement or omission in a
declaration or notice, or makes a false certification under Sec.
800.404, Sec. 800.405, or Sec. 800.502 may be liable to the United
States for a civil penalty not to exceed $250,000 per violation. The
amount of the penalty imposed for a violation shall be based on the
nature of the violation.
(b) Any person who fails to comply with the requirements of Sec.
800.401 may be liable to the United States for a civil penalty not to
exceed $250,000 per violation or the value of the transaction,
whichever is greater. The amount of the penalty imposed for a violation
shall be based on the nature of the violation.
(c) Any person who, after October 11, 2018, violates, intentionally
or through gross negligence, a material provision of a mitigation
agreement entered into before October 11, 2018 with, a material
condition imposed before October 11, 2018 by, or an order issued before
October 11, 2018 by, the United States under section 721(l) may be
liable to the United States for a civil penalty not to exceed $250,000
per violation or the value of the transaction, whichever is greater.
Any person who violates a material provision of a mitigation agreement
entered into on or after October 11, 2018 with, a material condition
imposed on or after October 11, 2018 by, or an order issued on or after
October 11, 2018 by, the United States under section 721(l) may be
liable to the United States for a civil penalty not to exceed $250,000
per violation or the value of the transaction, whichever is greater.
The amount of the penalty imposed for a violation shall be based on the
nature of the violation.
(d) A mitigation agreement entered into or amended under section
721(l) after December 22, 2008, may include a provision providing for
liquidated or actual damages for breaches of the agreement. The
Committee shall set the amount of any liquidated damages as a
reasonable assessment of the harm to the national security that could
result from a breach of the agreement. Any mitigation agreement
containing a liquidated damages provision shall include a provision
specifying that the Committee will consider the severity of the breach
in deciding whether to seek a lesser amount than that stipulated in the
agreement.
(e) A determination to impose penalties under paragraphs (a)
through (c) of this section must be made by the
[[Page 50208]]
Committee. Notice of the penalty, including a written explanation of
the penalized conduct and the amount of the penalty, shall be sent to
the penalized party electronically and by U.S. mail.
(f) Upon receiving notice of the imposition of a penalty under
paragraphs (a) through (c) of this section, the penalized party may,
within 15 days of receipt of the notice of the penalty, submit a
petition for reconsideration to the Staff Chairperson, including a
defense, justification, or explanation for the penalized conduct. The
Committee will review the petition and issue a final decision within 15
days of receipt of the petition.
(g) The penalties and damages authorized in paragraphs (a) through
(d) of this section may be recovered in a civil action brought by the
United States in federal district court.
(h) Section 2 of the False Statements Accountability Act of 1996,
as amended (18 U.S.C. 1001), shall apply to all information provided to
the Committee under section 721, including by any party to a covered
transaction.
(i) The penalties and damages available under this section are
without prejudice to other penalties, civil or criminal, available
under law.
(j) The imposition of a civil monetary penalty or damages pursuant
to these regulations creates a debt due to the U.S. Government. The
Department of the Treasury may take action to collect the penalty or
damages assessed if not paid within the time prescribed by the
Committee and notified to the applicable party or parties. In addition
or instead, the matter may be referred to the Department of Justice for
appropriate action to recover the penalty or damages.
Sec. 800.902 Effect of lack of compliance.
(a) If, at any time after a mitigation agreement or condition is
entered into or imposed under section 721(l), the Committee or a lead
agency in coordination with the Staff Chairperson, as the case may be,
determines that a party or parties to the agreement or condition are
not in compliance with the terms of the agreement or condition, the
Committee or a lead agency, in coordination with the Staff Chairperson
may, in addition to the authority of the Committee to impose penalties
pursuant to section 721(h) and to unilaterally initiate a review of any
covered transaction pursuant to section 721(b)(1)(D)(iii):
(1) Negotiate a plan of action for the party or parties to
remediate the lack of compliance, with failure to abide by the plan or
otherwise remediate the lack of compliance serving as the basis for the
Committee to find a material breach of the agreement or condition;
(2) Require that the party or parties submit a written notice or
declaration under clause (i) of section 721(b)(1)(C) with respect to a
covered transaction initiated after the date of the determination of
noncompliance and before the date that is five years after the date of
the determination to the Committee to initiate a review of the
transaction under section 721(b); or
(3) Seek injunctive relief.
Subpart J--Foreign National Security Investment Review Regimes
Sec. 800.1001 Determinations.
(a) The Chairperson of the Committee, with the agreement of two-
thirds of the voting members of the Committee, may determine at any
time that a foreign state has established and is effectively utilizing
a robust process to analyze foreign investments for national security
risks and to facilitate coordination with the United States on matters
relating to investment security.
(b) The Chairperson of the Committee may rescind a determination
under paragraph (a) of this section if the Chairperson of the Committee
determines, with the agreement of two-thirds of the voting members of
the Committee, that such a rescission is appropriate.
(c) The Chairperson of the Committee shall publish a notice of any
determination or rescission of a determination under paragraph (a) or
(b) of this section, respectively, in the Federal Register.
Sec. 800.1002 Effect of determinations.
(a) A determination under Sec. 800.1001(a) shall take effect
immediately upon publication of a notice of such determination under
Sec. 800.1001(c) and remain in effect unless rescinded pursuant to
paragraph (b) of this section.
(b) A rescission of a determination under Sec. 800.1001(b) shall
take effect on the date specified in the notice published under Sec.
800.1001(c).
(c) A determination under Sec. 800.1001(a) does not apply to any
transaction for which a declaration or notice has been accepted by the
Staff Chairperson pursuant to Sec. 800.405(a)(1) or Sec. 800.503(a),
respectively.
(d) A rescission of a determination under Sec. 800.1001(b) does
not apply to any transaction for which:
(1) The completion date is prior to the date upon which the
rescission of a determination under paragraph (b) of this section
becomes effective; or
(2) The following has occurred before publication of the rescission
of determination under Sec. 800.1001(c):
(i) The parties to the transaction have executed a binding written
agreement, or other binding document, establishing the material terms
of the transaction that is ultimately consummated;
(ii) A party has made a public offer to shareholders to buy shares
of a U.S. business; or
(iii) A shareholder has solicited proxies in connection with an
election of the board of directors of a U.S. business or has requested
the conversion of convertible voting securities.
Appendix A to Part 800--Covered Investment Critical Infrastructure and
Functions Related to Covered Investment Critical Infrastructure
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Column 2--Functions related
Column 1--Covered investment critical to covered investment
infrastructure critical infrastructure
------------------------------------------------------------------------
(i) Any: (i) Own or operate any:
(a) internet protocol network that has (a) internet protocol
access to every other internet protocol network that has access to
network solely via settlement-free every other internet
peering; or protocol network solely via
settlement-free peering; or
(b) telecommunications service or (b) telecommunications
information service, each as defined in service or information
section 3(a)(2) of the Communications Act service, each as defined in
of 1934 (47 U.S.C. 153), as amended, or section 3(a)(2) of the
fiber optic cable that directly serves Communications Act of 1934
any military installation identified in (47 U.S.C. 153), as
Sec. 802.229. amended, or fiber optic
cable that directly serves
any military installation
identified in Sec.
802.229.
(ii) Any internet exchange point that (ii) Own or operate any
supports public peering. internet exchange point
that supports public
peering.
[[Page 50209]]
(iii) Any submarine cable system requiring (iii) Own or operate any
a license pursuant to section 1 of the submarine cable system
Cable Landing Licensing Act of 1921 (47 requiring a license
U.S.C. 34), as amended, which includes pursuant to section 1 of
any associated submarine cable, submarine the Cable Landing Licensing
cable landing facilities, and any Act of 1921 (47 U.S.C. 34),
facility that performs network as amended, which includes
management, monitoring, maintenance, or any associated submarine
other operational functions for such cable, submarine cable
submarine cable system. landing facilities, and any
facility that performs
network management,
monitoring, maintenance, or
other operational functions
for such submarine cable
system.
(iv) Any submarine cable, landing (iv) Supply or service any
facility, or facility that performs submarine cable, landing
network management, monitoring, facility, or facility that
maintenance, or other operational performs network
function that is part of a submarine management, monitoring,
cable system described above in item maintenance, or other
(iii) of Column 1 of appendix A to part operational function that
800. is part of a submarine
cable system described
above in item (iii) of
Column 1 of appendix A to
part 800.
(v) Any data center that is collocated at (v) Own or operate any data
a submarine cable landing point, landing center that is collocated
station, or termination station. at a submarine cable
landing point, landing
station, or termination
station.
(vi) Any satellite or satellite system (vi) Own or operate any
providing services directly to the satellite or satellite
Department of Defense or any component system providing services
thereof. directly to the Department
of Defense or any component
thereof.
(vii) Any industrial resource other than (vii) As applicable,
commercially available off-the-shelf manufacture any industrial
items, as defined in section 4203(a) of resource other than
the National Defense Authorization Act commercially available off-
for Fiscal Year 1996 (41 U.S.C. 104), as the-shelf items, as defined
amended, that is manufactured or operated in section 4203(a) of the
for a Major Defense Acquisition Program, National Defense
as defined in section 7(b)(2)(A) of the Authorization Act for
Defense Technical Corrections Act of 1987 Fiscal Year 1996 (41 U.S.C.
(10 U.S.C. 2430), as amended, or a Major 104), as amended, or
System, as defined in 10 U.S.C. 2302d, as operate any industrial
amended and: resource that is a
facility, in each case, for
a Major Defense Acquisition
Program, as defined in
section 7(b)(2)(A) of the
Defense Technical
Corrections Act of 1987 (10
U.S.C. 2430), as amended,
or a Major System, as
defined in 10 U.S.C. 2302d,
as amended and:
(a) the U.S. business is a ``single (a) the U.S. business is a
source,'' ``sole source,'' or ``strategic ``single source,'' ``sole
multisource,'' to the extent the U.S. source,'' or ``strategic
business has been notified of such multisource,'' to the
status; or extent the U.S. business
has been notified of such
status; or
(b) the industrial resource: (b) the industrial resource:
(1) requires 12 months or more to (1) requires 12 months or
manufacture; or more to manufacture; or
(2) is a ``long lead'' item, to the extent (2) is a ``long lead'' item,
the U.S. business has been notified that to the extent the U.S.
such industrial resource is a ``long business has been notified
lead'' item. that such industrial
resource is a ``long lead''
item.
(viii) Any industrial resource, other than (viii) Manufacture any
commercially available off-the-shelf industrial resource, other
items, as defined in section 4203(a) of than commercially available
the National Defense Authorization Act off-the-shelf items, as
for Fiscal Year 1996 (41 U.S.C. 104), as defined in section 4203(a)
amended, that is manufactured pursuant to of the National Defense
a ``DX'' priority rated contract or order Authorization Act for
under the Defense Priorities and Fiscal Year 1996 (41 U.S.C.
Allocations System regulation (15 CFR 104), as amended, pursuant
part 700, as amended) in the preceding 24 to a ``DX'' priority rated
months. contract or order under the
Defense Priorities and
Allocations System
regulation (15 CFR part
700, as amended) within 24
months of the transaction
in question.
(ix) Any facility in the United States (ix) Manufacture any of the
that manufactures: following in the United
States:
(a) specialty metal, as defined in section (a) specialty metal, as
842(a)(1)(i) of the John Warner National defined in section
Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 842(a)(1)(i) of the John
2007 (10 U.S.C. 2533b), as amended; Warner National Defense
Authorization Act for
Fiscal Year 2007 (10 U.S.C.
2533b), as amended;
(b) covered material, as defined in 10 (b) covered material, as
U.S.C. 2533c, as amended; defined in 10 U.S.C. 2533c,
as amended;
(c) chemical weapons antidote contained in (c) chemical weapons
automatic injectors, as described in 10 antidote contained in
U.S.C. 2534, as amended; or automatic injectors, as
described in 10 U.S.C.
2534, as amended; or
(d) carbon, alloy, and armor steel plate (d) carbon, alloy, and armor
that is in Federal Supply Class 9515 or steel plate that is in
is described by specifications of the Federal Supply Class 9515
American Society for Testing Materials or or is described by
the American Iron and Steel Institute. specifications of the
American Society for
Testing Materials or the
American Iron and Steel
Institute.
(x) Any industrial resource other than (x) As applicable,
commercially available off-the-shelf manufacture any industrial
items, as defined in 41 U.S.C. 104, as resource other than
amended, that has been funded, in whole commercially available off-
or in part, by any of the following the-shelf items, as defined
sources in the last 60 months: in 41 U.S.C. 104, as
amended, or operate any
industrial resource that is
a facility, in each case,
that has been funded, in
whole or in part, by any of
the following sources
within 60 months of the
transaction in question:
(a) Defense Production Act of 1950 Title (a) Defense Production Act
III program (50 U.S.C. 4501, et seq.), as of 1950 Title III program
amended; (50 U.S.C. 4501, et seq.),
as amended;
(b) Industrial Base Fund pursuant to (b) Industrial Base Fund
section 896(b)(1) of the Ike Skelton pursuant to section
National Defense Authorization Act for 896(b)(1) of the Ike
Fiscal Year 2011 (10 U.S.C. 2508), as Skelton National Defense
amended; Authorization Act for
Fiscal Year 2011 (10 U.S.C.
2508), as amended;
(c) Rapid Innovation Fund pursuant to (c) Rapid Innovation Fund
section 1073 of Ike Skelton National pursuant to section 1073 of
Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year Ike Skelton National
2011 (10 U.S.C. 2359a), as amended; Defense Authorization Act
for Fiscal Year 2011 (10
U.S.C. 2359a), as amended;
(d) Manufacturing Technology Program (d) Manufacturing Technology
pursuant to 10 U.S.C. 2521, as amended; Program pursuant to 10
U.S.C. 2521, as amended;
(e) Defense Logistics Agency Warstopper (e) Defense Logistics Agency
Program, as described in DLA Instruction Warstopper Program, as
1212, Industrial Capabilities Program-- described in DLA
Manage the WarStopper Program; or Instruction 1212,
Industrial Capabilities
Program--Manage the
WarStopper Program; or
(f) Defense Logistics Agency Surge and (f) Defense Logistics Agency
Sustainment contract, as described in Surge and Sustainment
Subpart 17.93 of the Defense Logistics contract, as described in
Acquisition Directive. Subpart 17.93 of the
Defense Logistics
Acquisition Directive.
(xi) Any system, including facilities, for (xi) Own or operate any
the generation, transmission, system, including
distribution, or storage of electric facilities, for the
energy comprising the bulk-power system, generation, transmission,
as defined in section 215(a)(1) of the distribution, or storage of
Federal Power Act (16 U.S.C. 824o(a)(1)), electric energy comprising
as amended. the bulk-power system, as
defined in section
215(a)(1) of the Federal
Power Act (16 U.S.C.
824o(a)(1)), as amended.
[[Page 50210]]
(xii) Any electric storage resource, as (xii) Own or operate any
defined in 18 CFR Sec. 35.28(b)(9), as electric storage resource,
amended, that is physically connected to as defined in 18 CFR Sec.
the bulk-power system. 35.28(b)(9), as amended,
that is physically
connected to the bulk-power
system.
(xiii) Any facility that provides electric (xiii) Own or operate any
power generation, transmission, facility that provides
distribution, or storage directly to or electric power generation,
located on any military installation transmission, distribution,
identified in Sec. 802.229. or storage directly to or
located on any military
installation identified in
Sec. 802.229.
(xiv) Any industrial control system (xiv) Manufacture or service
utilized by: any industrial control
system utilized by:
(a) system comprising the bulk-power (a) system comprising the
system as described above in item (xi) of bulk-power system as
Column 1 of appendix A to part 800; or described above in item
(xi) of Column 1 of
appendix A to part 800; or
(b) a facility directly serving any (b) a facility directly
military installation as described above serving any military
in item (xiii) of Column 1 of appendix A installation as described
to part 800. above in item (xiii) of
Column 1 of appendix A to
part 800.
(xv) Any: (xv) Own or operate:
(a) any individual refinery with the (a) any individual refinery
capacity to produce 300,000 or more with the capacity to
barrels per day (or equivalent) of produce 300,000 or more
refined oil or gas products; or barrels per day (or
equivalent) of refined oil
or gas products; or
(b) collection of one or more refineries (b) one or more refineries
owned or operated by a single U.S. with the capacity to
business with the capacity to produce, in produce, in the aggregate,
the aggregate, 500,000 or more barrels 500,000 or more barrels per
per day (or equivalent) of refined oil or day (or equivalent) of
gas products. refined oil or gas
products.
(xvi) Any crude oil storage facility with (xvi) Own or operate any
the capacity to hold 30 million barrels crude oil storage facility
or more of crude oil. with the capacity to hold
30 million barrels or more
of crude oil.
(xvii) Any: (xvii) Own or operate any:
(a) liquefied natural gas (LNG) import or (a) liquefied natural gas
export terminal requiring. (LNG) import or export
terminal requiring:
(1) approval pursuant to section 3(e) of (1) approval pursuant to
the Natural Gas Act (15 U.S.C. 717b(e)), section 3(e) of the Natural
as amended, or Gas Act (15 U.S.C.
717b(e)), as amended, or
(2) a license pursuant to section 4 of the (2) a license pursuant to
Deepwater Port Act of 1974 (33 U.S.C. section 4 of the Deepwater
1503), as amended; or Port Act of 1974 (33 U.S.C.
1503), as amended; or
(b) natural gas underground storage (b) natural gas underground
facility or LNG peak-shaving facility storage facility or LNG
requiring a certificate of public peak-shaving facility
convenience and necessity pursuant to requiring a certificate of
section 7 of the Natural Gas Act (15 public convenience and
U.S.C. 717f), as amended. necessity pursuant to
section 7 of the Natural
Gas Act (15 U.S.C. 717f),
as amended.
(xviii) Any financial market utility that (xviii) Own or operate any
the Financial Stability Oversight Council financial market utility
has designated as systemically important that the Financial
pursuant to section 804 of the Dodd-Frank Stability Oversight Council
Wall Street Reform and Consumer has designated as
Protection Act (12 U.S.C. 5463), as systemically important
amended. pursuant to section 804 of
the Dodd-Frank Wall Street
Reform and Consumer
Protection Act (12 U.S.C.
5463), as amended.
(xix) Any exchange registered under (xix) Own or operate any
section 6 of the Securities Exchange Act exchange registered under
of 1934 (15 U.S.C. 78f), as amended, that section 6 of the Securities
facilitates trading in any national Exchange Act of 1934 (15
market system security, as defined in 17 U.S.C. 78f), as amended,
CFR Sec. 242.600, as amended, and which that facilitates trading in
exchange during at least four of the any national market system
preceding six calendar months had: security, as defined in 17
CFR Sec. 242.600, as
amended, and which exchange
during at least four of the
preceding six calendar
months had:
(a) with respect to all national market (a) with respect to all
system securities that are not options, national market system
ten percent or more of the average daily securities that are not
dollar volume reported by applicable options, ten percent or
transaction reporting plans; or more of the average daily
dollar volume reported by
applicable transaction
reporting plans; or
(b) with respect to all listed options, (b) with respect to all
fifteen percent or more of the average listed options, fifteen
daily dollar volume reported by percent or more of the
applicable national market system plans average daily dollar volume
for reporting transactions in listed reported by applicable
options. national market system
plans for reporting
transactions in listed
options.
(xx) Any technology service provider in (xx) Own or operate any
the Significant Service Provider Program technology service provider
of the Federal Financial Institutions in the Significant Service
Examination Council that provides core Provider Program of the
processing services. Federal Financial
Institutions Examination
Council that provides core
processing services.
(xxi) Any rail line and associated (xxi) Own or operate any
connector line designated as part of the rail line and associated
Department of Defense's Strategic Rail connector line designated
Corridor Network. as part of the Department
of Defense's Strategic Rail
Corridor Network.
(xxii) Any interstate oil pipeline that: (xxii) Own or operate any
interstate oil pipeline
that:
(a) has the capacity to transport: (a) has the capacity to
transport:
(1) 500,000 barrels per day or more of (1) 500,000 barrels per day
crude oil, or or more of crude oil, or
(2) 90 million gallons per day or more of (2) 90 million gallons per
refined petroleum product; or day or more of refined
petroleum product; or
(b) directly serves the strategic (b) directly serves the
petroleum reserve, as defined in section strategic petroleum
152 of the Energy Policy and Conservation reserve, as defined in
Act (42 U.S.C. 6232), as amended. section 152 of the Energy
Policy and Conservation Act
(42 U.S.C. 6232), as
amended.
(xxiii) Any interstate natural gas (xxiii) Own or operate any
pipeline with an outside diameter of 20 interstate natural gas
or more inches. pipeline with an outside
diameter of 20 or more
inches.
(xxiv) Any industrial control system (xxiv) Manufacture or
utilized by: service any industrial
control system utilized by:
(a) an interstate oil pipeline as (a) an interstate oil
described above in item (xxii) of Column pipeline as described above
1 of appendix A to part 800; or in item (xxii) of Column 1
of appendix A to part 800;
or
(b) an interstate natural gas pipeline as (b) an interstate natural
described above in item (xxiii) of Column gas pipeline as described
1 of appendix A to part 800. above in item (xxiii) of
Column 1 of appendix A to
part 800.
(xxv) Any airport identified in Sec. (xxv) Own or operate any
802.201. airport identified in Sec.
802.201.
(xxvi) Any: (xxvi) Own or operate any:
(a) maritime port identified in Sec. (a) maritime port identified
802.228; or in Sec. 802.228; or
(b) any individual terminal at such (b) any individual terminal
maritime ports. at such maritime ports.
(xxvii) Any public water system, as (xxvii) Own or operate any
defined in section 1401(4) of the Safe public water system, as
Drinking Water Act (42 U.S.C. defined in section 1401(4)
300f(4)(A)), as amended, or treatment of the Safe Drinking Water
works, as defined in section 212(2)(A) of Act (42 U.S.C. 300f(4)(A)),
the Clean Water Act (33 U.S.C. 1292(2)), as amended, or treatment
as amended, which: works, as defined in
section 212(2)(A) of the
Clean Water Act (33 U.S.C.
1292(2)), as amended,
which:
[[Page 50211]]
(a) regularly serves 10,000 individuals or (a) regularly serves 10,000
more, or individuals or more, or
(b) directly serves any military (b) directly serves any
installation identified in Sec. military installation
802.229. identified in Sec.
802.229.
(xxviii) Any industrial control system (xxviii) Manufacture or
utilized by a public water system or service any industrial
treatment works as described above in control system utilized by
item (xxvii) of Column 1 of appendix A to a public water system or
part 800. treatment works as
described above in item
(xxvii) of Column 1 of
appendix A to part 800.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dated: September 11, 2019.
Thomas Feddo,
Deputy Assistant Secretary for Investment Security.
[FR Doc. 2019-20099 Filed 9-17-19; 4:15 pm]
BILLING CODE 4810-25-P