Proposed Information Collection; Comment Request; 2018 End-to-End Census Test-Peak Operations, 15486-15492 [2017-06171]
Download as PDF
15486
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 59 / Wednesday, March 29, 2017 / Notices
bring CFRP grant application review
related matters to the attention of the
Panel may file written statements with
the Panel staff before or after each day
of the meeting. Written comments and
time requests for oral comments must be
sent to the person listed under FOR
FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT.
A summary of the meeting will be
posted on the Web site listed above
within 45 days after the meeting.
Meeting Accommodations: If you are
a person requiring reasonable
accommodation, please make requests
in advance for sign language
interpreting, assistive listening devices
or other reasonable accommodation for
access to the facility or proceedings by
contacting the person listed in the
section titled FOR FURTHER INFORMATION
CONTACT. All reasonable
accommodation requests are managed
on a case by case basis.
Dated: March 16, 2017.
Jeanne M. Higgins,
Acting Associate Deputy Chief, National
Forest System.
[FR Doc. 2017–06130 Filed 3–28–17; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 3411–15–P
DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
Forest Service
Siskiyou (OR) Resource Advisory
Committee
Forest Service, USDA.
Notice of meeting.
AGENCY:
ACTION:
The Siskiyou (OR) Resource
Advisory Committee (RAC) will meet in
Brookings, Oregon. The committee is
authorized under the Secure Rural
Schools and Community SelfDetermination Act (the Act) and
operates in compliance with the Federal
Advisory Committee Act. The purpose
of the committee is to improve
collaborative relationships and to
provide advice and recommendations to
the Forest Service concerning projects
and funding consistent with Title II of
the Act. RAC information can be found
at the following Web site: https://
www.fs.usda.gov/main/pts/
specialprojects/racweb.
DATES: The meeting will be held on the
following dates and times:
• April 24, 2017, at 10:00 a.m. to 4:30
p.m., and
• April 25, 2017, at 8:30 a.m. to 4:30
p.m.
All RAC meetings are subject to
cancellation. For status of meeting prior
to attendance, please contact the person
listed under FOR FURTHER INFORMATION
CONTACT.
mstockstill on DSK3G9T082PROD with NOTICES
SUMMARY:
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:54 Mar 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
The meeting will be held at
Best Western Plus Beachfront Inn, South
Conference Room, 16008 Boat Basin
Road, Brookings, Oregon.
Written comments may be submitted
as described under SUPPLEMENTARY
INFORMATION. All comments, including
names and addresses when provided,
are placed in the record and are
available for public inspection and
copying. The public may inspect
comments received at Rogue RiverSiskiyou National Forest (NF)
Supervisor’s Office. Please call ahead to
facilitate entry into the building.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Virginia Gibbons, RAC Coordinator, by
phone at 541–618–2113 or via email at
vgibbons@fs.fed.us.
Individuals who use
telecommunication devices for the deaf
(TDD) may call the Federal Information
Relay Service (FIRS) at 1–800–877–8339
between 8:00 a.m. and 8:00 p.m.,
Eastern Standard Time, Monday
through Friday.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
The purpose of the meeting is to:
1. Review project proposals, and
2. Make project recommendations for
Title II Funds.
The meeting is open to the public.
The agenda will include time for people
to make oral statements of three minutes
or less. Individuals wishing to make an
oral statement should request in writing
by April 7, 2017, to be scheduled on the
agenda. Anyone who would like to
bring related matters to the attention of
the committee may file written
statements with the committee staff
before or after the meeting. Written
comments and requests for time to make
oral comments must be sent to Virginia
Gibbons, RAC Coordinator, Rogue RiverSiskiyou NF Supervisor’s Office, 3040
Biddle Road, Medford, Oregon 97525;
by email to vgibbons@fs.fed.us, or via
facsimile to 541–618–2144.
Meeting Accommodations: If you are
a person requiring reasonable
accommodation, please make requests
in advance for sign language
interpreting, assistive listening devices,
or other reasonable accommodation. For
access to the facility or proceedings,
please contact the person listed in the
section titled FOR FURTHER INFORMATION
CONTACT. All reasonable
accommodation requests are managed
on a case by case basis.
ADDRESSES:
Dated: March 7, 2017.
Jeanne M. Higgins,
Acting Associate Deputy Chief, National
Forest System.
[FR Doc. 2017–06137 Filed 3–28–17; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 3411–15–P
PO 00000
Frm 00006
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
Census Bureau
Proposed Information Collection;
Comment Request; 2018 End-to-End
Census Test—Peak Operations
U.S. Census Bureau,
Commerce.
ACTION: Notice.
AGENCY:
The Department of
Commerce, as part of its continuing
effort to reduce paperwork and
respondent burden, invites the general
public and other Federal agencies to
take this opportunity to comment on
proposed and/or continuing information
collections, as required by the
Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995.
DATES: To ensure consideration, written
comments must be submitted on or
before May 30, 2017.
ADDRESSES: Direct all written comments
to Jennifer Jessup, Departmental
Paperwork Clearance Officer,
Department of Commerce, Room 6616,
14th and Constitution Avenue NW.,
Washington, DC 20230 (or via the
Internet at PRAcomments@doc.gov).
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Requests for additional information or
copies of the information collection
instrument(s) and instructions should
be directed to Robin A. Pennington,
Census Bureau, HQ–2K281N,
Washington, DC 20233; (301) 763–8132
(or via email at robin.a.pennington@
census.gov).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
SUMMARY:
I. Abstract
During the years preceding the 2020
Census, the Census Bureau will pursue
its commitment to reduce the costs of
conducting a decennial census while
maintaining our commitment to quality.
In 2018, the Census Bureau will be
performing the 2018 End-to-End Census
Test. This last major test before the 2020
Census is designed to (1) test and
validate 2020 Census operations,
procedures, systems, and field
infrastructure to ensure proper
integration and conformance with
requirements, and (2) produce
prototypes of geographic and data
products.
The 2018 End-to-End Census Test will
encompass operations and systems
related to (1) Address Canvassing; (2)
Optimizing Self-Response, including
contact strategies, questionnaire
content, and language support; (3)
Update Enumerate, including technical
and operational testing; (4) Nonresponse
Followup, including technological and
operational improvements; and (5)
E:\FR\FM\29MRN1.SGM
29MRN1
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 59 / Wednesday, March 29, 2017 / Notices
mstockstill on DSK3G9T082PROD with NOTICES
Group Quarters, including technological
and operational testing. The operations
other than Address Canvassing are
referred to collectively as Peak
Operations, because they are the
enumeration data collection operations
of the census. These operations are the
focus of this package.
The Address Canvassing operation
((1) from the above), beginning in the
summer of 2017, is the first operation in
the 2018 End-to-End Census Test and
was included in a separate Address
Canvassing Operation package due to
timing considerations.
New approaches to the design of the
2020 Census are classified into four key
innovation areas. These areas have been
the subject of Census Bureau testing this
decade to identify methodological
improvements, technological advances,
and possibilities for cost savings over
repeating the design of the 2010 Census.
One of these innovation areas is
Optimizing Self-Response, which is
focused on improving methods for
increasing the number of people who
take advantage of self-response options.
Optimizing Self-Response
The 2018 End-to-End Census Test is
designed to evaluate several strategies to
optimize the rate at which the public
self-responds to the census, which
would reduce costs of the census by
decreasing the workload for following
up at nonresponding units. Previous
Census Bureau tests have resulted in the
design of contact strategies, two of
which will be in use during this test for
the purpose of gathering additional
metrics and making comparisons on a
number of indicators. Either or both of
these strategies may be included in the
design of the 2020 Census, depending
on a variety of factors.
Internet First is the primary mail
contact strategy proposed for the 2020
Census and has been used in Census
Bureau research and testing efforts since
2012. (In prior tests, this strategy was
called Internet Push.) This strategy
includes the mailing of a letter inviting
respondents to complete the
questionnaire online, two follow-up
reminders, and then if necessary, a
mailed paper questionnaire.
Internet Choice includes a paper
questionnaire in the first mailing, along
with an invitation to complete the
questionnaire online, providing a choice
of Internet or paper response from the
beginning of the contact strategy.
In addition, the 2018 End-to-End
Census Test provides the Census Bureau
with an opportunity to enhance the user
experience, performance, and
functionality of the Internet selfresponse instrument compared to prior
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:54 Mar 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
Census Tests this decade. Improvements
including expanded language
capabilities will support the goal of
optimizing self-response by providing
an easy, quick, and safe experience for
respondents, and ensure that the
resulting response data and paradata
provide required information to followup and data processing operations.
The Census Bureau plans to study the
following in the 2018 End-to-End
Census Test:
• Comparing the self-response rates
between the Internet First and the
Internet Choice panels.
• Comparing item-level response by
panel and by mode, including in the
Update Enumerate and Group Quarters
enumeration operations, both of which
will be fielded for the first time this
decade.
• Measuring the effects of
incorporating additional household
contact strategies to encourage selfresponse, including letter and postcard
reminders.
Nonresponse Followup
The 2018 End-to-End Census Test will
allow the Census Bureau to continue to
refine, optimize, and assess the
operational procedures and technical
design of the Nonresponse Followup
(NRFU) operation. The NRFU operation
is a field operation for determining
housing unit status (occupied, vacant, or
delete) and for gathering the
enumeration data at addresses for which
no self-response was received. This test
will build upon the results of previous
field tests this decade where the NRFU
operation has been conducted. In
particular, NRFU is now a fullyautomated operation, whereas it was
performed using paper materials in the
2010 Census. For this test, the Census
Bureau will examine:
• Operational procedures.
Æ Testing continued refinements to
the field data collection instrument for
enumeration, particularly where
previous testing has shown potential
problems in our question branching or
issues with the interview software user
interface. The Census Bureau will
critically assess navigation within the
instrument via debriefing sessions for
field enumerators after operations
complete.
Æ Continuing refinement of our
methods for enumerating multi-unit
structures, particularly identifying
vacant households in multi-units with a
minimal number of contact attempts,
thereby minimizing respondent burden.
Æ Continuing refinement of
procedures for interviewing proxy
respondents to gather information from
hard-to-enumerate households.
PO 00000
Frm 00007
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
15487
Æ Continuing refinement of processes
used to detect and deter falsification by
field enumerators.
Æ Continuing evaluation of
enumerator training procedures and
materials, including both online training
modules and classroom training.
Æ Integrating a Field Verification
assignment into the NRFU workload.
The Field Verification cases are
intended to verify the existence and
location of certain types of selfresponses that were received without a
preassigned census identification code,
called a User ID.
Æ Integrating into NRFU the ability to
designate an area for an earlier NRFU
operation in order to enumerate college
and university students living in offcampus housing before the end of the
spring semester.
• Technical design.
Æ Continuing refinement of the
management alerts to identify
potentially problematic field behavior in
real time.
Æ Continuing refinement of the
optimization and routing algorithms
used to make daily NRFU field
assignments.
Æ Continuing work to integrate into
the Census Bureau’s enterprise data
collection systems.
Update Enumerate (UE)
The Update Enumerate (UE) operation
as planned for the 2020 Census is
significantly changed from the UE
operation that was used in the 2010
Census at about one percent of all
addresses. At root, the UE methodology
is designed for areas that require an
enumeration methodology other than
self-response followed by NRFU. The
current design capitalizes on 2020
Census methodological improvements
such as Internet Self-Response,
automated field operations, and an
approach to collect responses without a
User ID that is greatly expanded in
scale. The 2020 Census UE operation
combines address listing methodologies
with person enumeration
methodologies. UE is conducted mostly
in geographic areas that have one or
more of the following characteristics:
• Do not have city-style addresses
like 123 Main Street.
• Do not receive mail through citystyle addresses.
• Receive mail at post office boxes
rather than at their physical address.
• Have unique challenges associated
with accessibility, such as dirt roads or
seasonal access.
• Have recently been affected by
natural disasters.
• Have high concentrations of
seasonally vacant housing.
E:\FR\FM\29MRN1.SGM
29MRN1
15488
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 59 / Wednesday, March 29, 2017 / Notices
mstockstill on DSK3G9T082PROD with NOTICES
The following objectives are being
tested for Update Enumerate:
• Integrating listing and enumeration
operations and systems.
• Evaluating the impact on cost and
quality of the UE contact strategy on
enumerator productivity and efficiency.
• Testing refinements to the field data
collection instrument for enumeration,
especially for atypical situations, such
as movers.
• Testing field supervisor to
enumerator ratios.
Group Quarters (GQ):
The 2018 End-to-End Census Test will
inform Census Bureau technological and
operational planning and design for the
enumeration of the population residing
in Group Quarters (GQs). GQs are living
quarters where people who are typically
unrelated have group living
arrangements and frequently are
receiving some type of service. College
dormitories and nursing homes are
examples of GQs. To date, some smallscale testing has been done to test
electronic transmission of GQ’s
enumeration responses. The 2018 Endto-End Census Test expands on these
results to allow the opportunity to
evaluate procedures and technologies
for conducting GQ enumeration
operations. The set of operations
planned for GQ enumeration is GQ
Advance Contact, Service-Based
Enumeration, and, finally, GQ
Enumeration. These operations have
been used in previous censuses. The GQ
Advance Contact is an operation where
facility contact and planning data are
collected, including the ability of the
GQ facility to provide electronic records
for the enumeration. Service-Based
Enumeration has the objective of
counting individuals who will not be
enumerated at a living quarter but are
receiving some type of service. The GQ
Enumeration is the final stage of
enumerating individuals residing at the
GQ.
• Operational procedures.
Æ Testing updated procedures for
handling newly discovered GQs during
field operations.
Æ Continuing testing of the various
GQ operations, process flows, estimated
staffing levels, supporting processes,
and workload estimates.
Æ Continuing refinement of
procedures for linking paper
questionnaire response records
collected by multiple enumerators
during enumeration at a single GQ.
Æ Continuing evaluation and
refinement of the optimal enumerator to
GQ ratios for multiple GQ types.
Æ Testing multiple modes of
enumeration.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:54 Mar 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
• Technical design.
Æ Testing the use of electronic
methodologies to:
D Create the initial universe for the
GQ Advance Contact.
D Conduct In-Office GQ Advance
Contact.
D Update the GQ frame prior to GQ
enumeration.
D Accept electronically transmitted
response data in multiple formats.
Æ Integrating GQ operations with
listing and enumeration operations and
systems.
Content
The Census Bureau recognizes that
OMB is continuing to lead the
discussion among federal agencies and
other stakeholders on race/ethnicity
from the perspective of data collection
and dissemination guidance and
standards, and that the final
determination has not been made on the
format of the race/ethnicity question for
the 2020 Census. If it is determined that
the combined race/ethnicity question
format may be used for the 2020 Census
(versus the separate race and Hispanic
Origin questions used for the 2010
Census), it will be crucial for the Census
Bureau to ensure that critical operations
are fully prepared to go into production
for the 2020 Census using the combined
question. Therefore, the 2018 End-toEnd Census Test data collection
operations will utilize the combined
race/ethnicity question version (that
includes a Middle Eastern or North
African category) to further its analysis
and understanding of mode differences
for the race/ethnicity responses before
deploying the 2020 Census
questionnaire.
• Internet Self-Response: Continue
testing the combined race/ethnicity
question under the further
enhancements of the Internet SelfResponse instrument for the 2018 Endto-End Census Test in regards to user
experience, performance, and
functionality; ensure that the resulting
response data and paradata meet the
requirements of follow-up and data
processing operations; and test
expanded language capabilities on the
instrument, as the introduction of
additional language options contributes
to additional paths to analyze the
paradata and response data.
• Nonresponse Followup: Continue
testing the combined race/ethnicity
question under the further
enhancements of the field enumeration
instrument; assess enumerators’
experience with the field enumeration
instrument and their navigation of the
race/ethnicity question within the
instrument. Input will be gathered
PO 00000
Frm 00008
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
during the post-operation field
enumerator debriefing sessions.
• Update Enumerate and Group
Quarters: Examine the 2018 End-to-End
Census Test results by mode, including
Update Enumerate and Group Quarters
operations, which will be fielded for the
first time this decade.
II. Method of Collection
Test Sites
The 2018 End-to-End Census Test will
take place in three sites within the
continental United States: Pierce
County, Washington; Providence
County, Rhode Island; and the
Bluefield-Beckley-Oak Hill, West
Virginia area. These locations offer
particular characteristics that support
the Census Bureau’s testing goals,
including: various types of addresses
(such as city-style, rural, and location
description-only); population with
varying demographics (such as age, race,
and language spoken at home); variety
of housing types (such as single-units,
multi-units, vacant units, GQs, and
mobile homes); varied levels of Internet
access and usage; various time zones;
and challenging environmental
conditions (such as weather extremes,
rough terrain).
Self-Response:
The housing units in the areas
selected for inclusion in the 2018 Endto-End Census Test will be contacted by
mail and invited to complete their
questionnaire via the Internet.
Optimizing Self-Response contact
methods include follow-on letter and
postcard reminders. The Census Bureau
will also test strategies for delivering
paper questionnaires to households that
do not or cannot respond online, as
measured by low Internet connectivity
or low Internet usage rates.
The Census Bureau will continue to
test Non-ID Processing methodology as
another strategy for Optimizing SelfResponse. A User ID that links to a
unique housing unit is on many of the
mailed materials, but respondents can
also submit a response without using
the ID, particularly on the Internet or
telephone. Non-ID Processing refers to
address matching and geocoding for
census responses that lack this
preassigned census ID. This processing
allows such responses to be linked up
with the associated census enumeration
data and can occur through automated
or clerical procedures. Additionally, the
2018 End-to-End Census Test will allow
the Census Bureau to continue to
develop the capability to conduct realtime Non-ID Processing, where a
respondent is prompted interactively
E:\FR\FM\29MRN1.SGM
29MRN1
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 59 / Wednesday, March 29, 2017 / Notices
mstockstill on DSK3G9T082PROD with NOTICES
(while they are still online filling out
the form) for additional address and
location information if the provided
address cannot be matched through
automation to an address with a User
ID.
This test will allow the Census
Bureau to understand better the
requirements related to scalability of
planned systems and to determine
metrics for each of the Non-ID
Processing steps. If the address match is
not resolved during the initial
automated or real-time processing,
Census Bureau staff will attempt
manually to match or geocode the
address. It is estimated that about two
percent of the overall non-ID
respondents will be contacted via
telephone as part of the manual
matching process. Non-ID Processing
also includes an office-based address
verification (OBAV) component. OBAV
uses available geographic reference
materials to verify the existence and
location of an address. OBAV is
performed in an effort to avoid the more
costly fieldwork. However, any address
that is worked in OBAV but cannot be
verified in OBAV will be sent to Field
Verification (discussed in more detail
below as a suboperation of NRFU).
Additionally, with the Re-collect
component, a sample of self-response
cases are selected for re-contact, which
may occur through centralized phone
contract or in-field enumeration. Recollect is intended to validate the
information from a respondent,
confirming the existence of the address
and the people enumerated at that
address. Re-collect is also one aspect of
fraud detection.
Content
Decades of research on different race/
ethnicity question designs have shown
that individual identities can be
impacted by societal changes, attitudes,
and perceptions. The 2018 End-to-End
Census Test design can help us
understand whether respondent
reporting of racial/ethnic identities is
impacted by the types of data that the
Census Bureau is collecting (e.g.,
detailed race/ethnic responses and new
categories), as well as whether or not
respondent privacy concerns and
expectations for data protection are
addressed and the process is trusted by
the general public.
It will be crucial for the Census
Bureau to ensure that critical operations
are fully prepared to go into production
for the 2020 Census using the combined
question, if it is determined that the
combined race/ethnicity question
format may be used for the 2020 Census.
The Census Bureau plans to deploy the
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:54 Mar 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
combined race/ethnicity question
version (that includes a Middle Eastern
or North African category) during the
2018 End-to-End Census Test to further
examine:
• Item nonresponse to the combined
race and ethnicity question (with
detailed checkboxes, with respect to the
reporting of major race/ethnic categories
(e.g., White, Black, Asian, etc.) that is
similar to the question the Census
Bureau used in the 2015 National
Content Test and is based on results
from the 2010 Census Race and
Hispanic Origin Alternative
Questionnaire Experiment (Compton, et
al., 2012).
Research has found that, over time,
there have been a growing number of
people who do not identify with any of
the race categories, and this means that
an increasing number of respondents
have been classified as ‘‘Some Other
Race.’’ The combined question format
with detailed checkboxes attempts to
help improve the accuracy of these data.
• Levels of overall race/ethnicity
reporting (e.g., White, Hispanic, Black,
etc.), as well as detailed reporting levels
for these groups (e.g., German, Mexican,
Jamaican, etc.).
• Levels of overall race/ethnicity
reporting within the new category
Middle Eastern or North African
(MENA), as well as levels of detailed
MENA reporting for respondents of
Middle Eastern and North African
heritage.
• Match rates between individual
racial/ethnic responses in the 2018 Endto-End Census Test and responses in
previous census records (e.g., 2010
Census Hispanic origin/race data; ACS
ancestry, race, Hispanic origin data).
This exploration aims to focus on the
comparison of race/ethnicity reporting
in different social environments to
understand what people have reported
in the past compared to what they are
reporting in the present. A growing
number of people find the current race
and ethnicity categories confusing.
The 2018 End-to-End Census Test will
be an important opportunity to
experiment with different imputation
procedures to ascertain which approach
yields the best overall imputation
results for missing data with a combined
race/ethnicity question. The 2018 Endto-End Census Test will enable
researchers to ascertain which records
to utilize (e.g., Ancestry, Hispanic
origin, Race), and in what hierarchy
they should be used for imputation.
With the expanded language options for
the 2018 End-to-End Census Test,
response data from detailed write-in
fields (such as those on the combined
race/ethnicity question) will also need
PO 00000
Frm 00009
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
15489
to be output, processed, coded, edited,
and tabulated, as well as translated if
provided in non-English languages.
Additionally, data products and
dissemination is a critical objective of
the 2018 End-to-End Census Test. The
question format used in data collection
and processing is also the source of the
redistricting tabulation, and the Census
Bureau must be prepared to meet the
needs of the states as well as 2020
Census data users, if it is determined
that the combined race/ethnicity
question format will be used for the
2020 Census. The Census Bureau
believes that the results of the 2018 Endto-End Census Test will help inform our
growing body of knowledge regarding
the combined race/ethnicity question
and the collection of major group
responses and detailed race/ethnicity
responses.
As previously stated, the Census
Bureau recognizes that OMB is
continuing to lead the discussion among
federal agencies and other stakeholders
on race/ethnicity from the perspective
of data collection and dissemination
guidance and standards, and that the
final determination has not been made
on the format of the race/ethnicity
question for the 2020 Census. In the
event that the 2020 Census does not
proceed with the combined race/
ethnicity question, the Census Bureau is
prepared to make necessary adjustments
to deploy the separate Race and
Hispanic Origin questions by consulting
the various versions of the separate Race
and Hispanic Origin questions that were
tested during the 2015 National Content
Test. The Census Bureau will properly
configure all downstream operations—
such as response processing and data
tabulation, imputation, analysis, and
data dissemination—to ensure a
successful deployment of the race/
ethnicity question(s) regardless of the
question format.
Language Services
Individuals of Limited English
Proficiency (LEP) require language
assistance in order to complete their
census questionnaires. The Census
Bureau has identified the largest LEP
populations in the United States using
American Community Survey data and
has established a program for providing
non-English materials for census tests
and the decennial census. For the 2018
End-to-End Census Test, Internet selfresponse and telephone assistance will
be available in English, Spanish,
Chinese, Vietnamese, Korean, Russian,
Arabic, and Tagalog. Paper
questionnaires, mailing materials, field
data collection instruments and field
E:\FR\FM\29MRN1.SGM
29MRN1
15490
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 59 / Wednesday, March 29, 2017 / Notices
data collection materials will be
available in English and Spanish.
Nonresponse Followup (NRFU)
For all housing unit addresses
included in the test universe, if no
response is received by a specified date,
the address will be included in the
universe for the NRFU portion of the
test. In NRFU, enumerators will attempt
to follow up at addresses for which no
self-response was received to determine
their status and to collect their data for
addresses determined to be occupied.
To allow sufficient time for selfresponse, the NRFU operation begins in
mid-May. However, some students who
reside in off-campus housing units will
have left the campus area by the time
NRFU begins. Early NRFU is conducted
starting in April in blocks near colleges
and universities with a high percentage
of off-campus housing to enumerate at
these units while students are still in
town.
The Census Bureau will conduct
NRFU with mobile devices. The devices
will utilize a secure Census Bureauprovided enumeration application
solution for conducting the NRFU field
data collection.
mstockstill on DSK3G9T082PROD with NOTICES
Nonresponse Followup Reinterview
(NRFU–RI)
A sample of the cases enumerated via
NRFU will be selected for reinterview
(RI). This NRFU–RI operation is
intended to help pinpoint possible cases
of enumerator falsification. The Census
Bureau will test centralized phone
contacts of the NRFU–RI cases before
sending them to an enumerator in the
field, providing potential cost avoidance
opportunities. Enumerators working
NRFU–RI cases will use the same
mobile devices and software as for the
NRFU cases.
Field Verification (FV)
Households that self-respond to the
Census without a User ID with
addresses that cannot be either matched
to our address frame or verified in NonID Processing may be sent to a Field
Verification operation, performed by
NRFU enumerators. This suboperation
is designed for verification that the
housing unit exists, confirmation of the
census block location for the address,
and if possible, collection of Global
Positioning System coordinates to
facilitate accurate determination of the
census block.
Update Enumerate (UE)
Update Enumerate for the 2018 Endto-End Census Test will test the four
planned components of the operation:
Update Enumerate Production, Update
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:54 Mar 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
Enumerate Listing Quality Control (QC),
Update Enumerate Followup, and
Update Enumerate Reinterview. In
addition to the field operation, the
Census Bureau will test mailing out an
invitation package to those housing
units with a mailable address to
generate self-response before the
operation begins. Mailable addresses
will constitute only a small percentage
of the addresses in these areas. If a
household self-responds, the UE
fieldworker (enumerator) will not need
to enumerate that house while listing
the geographic area. This is a cost
savings to Update Enumerate since the
enumerator will not have to spend time
collecting these data.
Update Enumerate (UE) Production
Enumerators will visit specific
geographic areas to identify every place
where people could live or stay,
comparing what they see on the ground
to the existing census address list. The
enumerator will update the address list,
either verify or correct the address and
location information, and classify each
living quarter (LQ) as a housing unit
(HU) or group quarter (GQ). If the LQ is
classified as a GQ, it will be designated
for enumeration within the GQ
operations.
Enumerators will attempt to conduct
an interview for each housing unit that
has not yet self-responded. If someone
answers the door, the enumerator will
provide a Confidentiality Notice and ask
questions to verify or update the
address. The enumerator will then ask
if there are any additional LQs in the
structure or on the property. If there are
additional LQs, the enumerators will
collect/update that information. The
enumerator will then interview the
respondent for the household using the
questionnaire on the mobile device.
If no one is home at a housing unit
that has not self-responded, the
enumerator will leave a Notice of Visit
inviting a respondent for each
household to go online with a User ID
to complete the 2018 End-to-End Census
Test. The Notice of Visit will also
include the phone number for Census
Questionnaire Assistance (CQA) if the
respondent has any questions or would
prefer to respond to the survey on the
telephone. In the 2018 End-to-End
Census Test, a paper questionnaire
rather than a Notice of Visit will be left
with a random set of addresses in order
to test the impact on self-response rates.
This operation has never been tested for
the census before, and this data will
help determine the best strategies to use
in the 2020 Census.
PO 00000
Frm 00010
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
Update Enumerate Listing QC
A sample of addresses listed via UE
production will be selected for UE
Listing QC. The intention of this
operation is to help us pinpoint possible
cases of enumerator falsification or error
in address listing. UE Listing QC will
use the Census Bureau’s listing software
on mobile devices to recollect listing
data to be used for a comparison.
Update Enumerate Followup
The UE operation will have a UE
Followup component for those
households that were not enumerated
on the first visit and have not yet selfresponded. UE enumerators will
conduct the operation using the NRFU
enumeration application on a Census
Bureau provided mobile device.
Update Enumerate Reinterview (UE RI)
A sample of cases enumerated via UE
production or UE Followup will be
selected for reinterview. The intention
of this operation is to help us pinpoint
possible cases of enumerator
falsification of enumeration data. The
Census Bureau will test centralized
phone contacts of the UE RI cases before
sending them to an enumerator in the
field, providing potential cost avoidance
opportunities. Enumerators working UE
RI cases will use the same mobile
devices and software as for the UE and
NRFU cases.
Group Quarters Advance Contact
The GQ Advance Contact operation
will contact Group Quarters prior to
enumeration. In an in-office Advance
Contact, GQs will be contacted to verify
information such as: Preferred modes of
enumeration, expected population on
Census Day, and whether there are
available electronic response data
records the Census Bureau could use for
the enumeration. Census Bureau staff at
local Census offices will follow-up with
GQs by phone, email, and in-person to
obtain the necessary pre-enumeration
information.
Group Quarters Service-Based
Enumeration (SBE)
Enumerators will conduct SBE at
selected shelters, soup kitchens, and
nonsheltered outdoor locations,
providing an opportunity to test new
response collection procedures on a
larger scale than has been tested so far
this decade.
Group Quarters Enumeration (GQE)
GQE will involve multiple modes of
enumeration. During the 2018 End-toEnd Census Test, electronic response for
GQs will be tested on a broad scale to
determine if there are gains in efficiency
E:\FR\FM\29MRN1.SGM
29MRN1
15491
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 59 / Wednesday, March 29, 2017 / Notices
through self-response. Use of the
automated enumeration device is an
additional technology to be tested in
GQE. For GQs that request paper-based
enumeration, enumerators will perform
drop off and pickup of paper forms,
which are completed by selfenumeration.
Group Quarters QC
A sample of cases that have been
enumerated via GQE will be selected for
reinterview. This operation is intended
to help us pinpoint possible cases of
enumerator falsification.
Coverage Improvement
Coverage Improvement is conducted
to resolve potential erroneous
enumerations and omissions from the
initial self-response data collection and
from all field enumeration data
collections. Coverage questions are
included in both the self-response and
NRFU instruments to aid in the
identification of coverage follow-up
cases. In-office follow-up includes
evaluating usual-home-elsewhere
address data from GQ enumerations,
and assessing the potential person
duplication, as identified through
person matching on collected data. For
cases where in-office processes do not
yield a resolution, field and/or
telephone follow-up with the
respondent will occur.
In addition, a prototype of the
Redistricting Data Program output will
be delivered. Ensuring these interfaces
meet the requirements for data
tabulation will be a crucial step in
preparing to tabulate the test data.
The design of this data product and
its dissemination is a critical final
objective of the 2018 End-to-End Census
Test, as the Census Bureau must be
prepared to meet the needs of various
stakeholders for 2020 Census data.
Response Processing and Data
Tabulation
OMB Control Number: 0607–XXXX.
Form Number(s): Paper and electronic
questionnaires; numbers to be
determined.
Type of Review: Regular submission.
Affected Public: Households/
Individuals.
Estimated Number of Respondents:
With the addition of expanded
language options, response data from
detailed write-in fields, such as those on
the combined race/ethnicity question,
will need to be translated, output,
processed, coded, edited, and tabulated.
III. Data
TEST SITES—PIERCE COUNTY, WASHINGTON; PROVIDENCE COUNTY, RHODE ISLAND; AND THE BLUEFIELD-BECKLEY-OAK
HILL, WEST VIRGINIA AREA
Estimated
time per
response
(minutes)
Estimated
number of
respondents
Operation or category
Total burden
hours
337,000
323,000
30,685
10
10
10
56,167
53,833
5,114
Self-Response Subtotal .................................................................................................
690,685
........................
115,114
Geographic Area Focused on Update Enumerate:
Update Enumerate Production .............................................................................................
Update Enumerate Listing QC .............................................................................................
Update Enumerate Followup ................................................................................................
Update Enumerate Reinterview ...........................................................................................
Update Enumerate Subtotal .................................................................................................
96,000
9,600
48,000
9,600
163,200
12
5
10
10
........................
19,200
800
8,000
1,600
29,600
Group Quarters:
GQ Advance Contact (facility) ..............................................................................................
GQ SBE—facility contact .....................................................................................................
GQ SBE—person contact ....................................................................................................
GQ Enumeration—facility contact ........................................................................................
GQ Enumeration—person contact .......................................................................................
Group Quarters QC ..............................................................................................................
1,200
100
4,000
1,100
55,000
110
10
10
10
10
10
5
200
17
667
183
9,167
9
Group Quarters Subtotal ...............................................................................................
61,510
........................
10,243
Non-ID Processing Phone Followup ....................................................................................
Re-collect ..............................................................................................................................
Field Verification ...................................................................................................................
Coverage Improvement ........................................................................................................
337
16,000
421
15,420
5
10
2
10
28
2,667
14
2,570
Totals ......................................................................................................................
mstockstill on DSK3G9T082PROD with NOTICES
Geographic Area Focused on Self-Response:
Internet/Telephone/Paper .....................................................................................................
Nonresponse Followup .........................................................................................................
Nonresponse Followup Reinterview .....................................................................................
947,573
........................
160,236
Self-Response by Internet/Telephone/
Paper: 337,000 respondents.
Nonresponse Followup: 323,000
respondents.
Nonresponse Followup Reinterview:
30,685 respondents.
Update Enumerate Production: 96,000
respondents.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:54 Mar 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
Update Enumerate Listing QC: 9,600
respondents.
Update Enumerate Followup: 48,000
respondents.
Update Enumerate Reinterview: 9,600
respondents.
Group Quarters Advance Contact
(facility): 1,200 respondents.
PO 00000
Frm 00011
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
Group Quarters Service-Based
Enumeration—facility contact: 100
respondents.
Group Quarters Service-Based
Enumeration—person contact: 4,000
respondents.
Group Quarters Enumeration—facility
contact: 1,100 respondents.
E:\FR\FM\29MRN1.SGM
29MRN1
15492
Federal Register / Vol. 82, No. 59 / Wednesday, March 29, 2017 / Notices
Group Quarters Enumeration—person
contact: 55,000 respondents.
Group Quarters QC: 110 respondents.
Non-ID Processing Phone Followup:
337 respondents.
Re-collect: 16,000 respondents.
Field Verification: 421 respondents.
Coverage Improvement: 15,420
respondents.
Total: 947,573 Contacts.
Estimated Time per Response:
Self-Response by Internet/Telephone/
Paper: 10 minutes per response.
Nonresponse Followup: 10 minutes
per response.
Nonresponse Followup Reinterview:
10 minutes per response.
Update Enumerate Production: 12
minutes per response.
Update Enumerate Listing QC: 5
minutes per response.
Update Enumerate Followup: 10
minutes per response.
Update Enumerate Reinterview: 10
minutes per response.
Group Quarters Advance Contact: 10
minutes per response.
Group Quarters Service-based
Enumeration: 10 minutes per response.
Group Quarters Enumeration: 10
minutes per response.
Group Quarters QC: 5 minutes per
response.
Non-ID Processing Phone Followup: 5
minutes per response.
Re-collect: 10 minutes per response.
Field Verification: 2 minutes per
response.
Coverage Improvement: 10 minutes
per response.
Estimated Total Annual Burden
Hours: 160,236 hours.
Estimated Total Annual Cost to
Public: There are no costs to
respondents other than their time to
participate in this data collection.
Respondent’s Obligation: Mandatory.
Legal Authority: Title 13 U.S.C.
Sections 141, 191 and 193.
mstockstill on DSK3G9T082PROD with NOTICES
IV. Request for Comments
Comments are invited on: (a) Whether
the proposed collection of information
is necessary for the proper performance
of the functions of the agency, including
whether the information shall have
practical utility; (b) the accuracy of the
agency’s estimate of the burden
(including hours and cost) of the
proposed collection of information; (c)
ways to enhance the quality, utility, and
VerDate Sep<11>2014
16:54 Mar 28, 2017
Jkt 241001
clarity of the information to be
collected; and (d) ways to minimize the
burden of the collection of information
on respondents, including through the
use of automated collection techniques
or other forms of information
technology.
Comments submitted in response to
this notice will be summarized and/or
included in the request for OMB
approval of this information collection;
they also will become a matter of public
record.
Sheleen Dumas,
PRA Departmental Lead, Office of the Chief
Information Officer.
[FR Doc. 2017–06171 Filed 3–28–17; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 3510–07–P
DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
Bureau of Economic Analysis
Meeting of Bureau of Economic
Analysis Advisory Committee
Bureau of Economic Analysis,
Economics and Statistics
Administration, Department of
Commerce.
ACTION: Notice of public meeting.
AGENCY:
Pursuant to the Federal
Advisory Committee Act (Pub. L. 92–
463 as amended by Pub. L. 94–409, Pub.
L. 96–523, Pub. L. 97–375 and Pub. L.
105–153), we are announcing a meeting
of the Bureau of Economic Analysis
Advisory Committee. The meeting will
focus on the ongoing challenges of
measuring prices in the 21st century
and address upcoming plans for the
national economic accounts.
DATES: Friday, May 12, 2017. The
meeting will begin at 9:00 a.m. and
adjourn at 3:30 p.m.
ADDRESSES: The meeting will take place
at the Suitland Federal Center, which is
located at 4600 Silver Hill Road,
Suitland, MD 20746.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Dondi Staunton, Senior Advisor, U.S.
Department of Commerce, Bureau of
Economic Analysis, Suitland, MD
20746; telephone number: (301) 278–
9798.
Public Participation: This meeting is
open to the public. Because of security
procedures, anyone planning to attend
the meeting must contact Dondi
SUMMARY:
PO 00000
Frm 00012
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
Staunton of BEA at (301) 278–9798 in
advance. The meeting is physically
accessible to people with disabilities.
Requests for foreign language
interpretation or other auxiliary aids
should be directed to Dondi Staunton at
(301) 278–9798.
The
Committee was established September
2, 1999. The Committee advises the
Director of BEA on matters related to the
development and improvement of BEA’s
national, regional, industry, and
international economic accounts,
especially in areas of new and rapidly
growing economic activities arising
from innovative and advancing
technologies, and provides
recommendations from the perspectives
of the economics profession, business,
and government. This will be the
Committee’s twenty-ninth meeting.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Dated: March 20, 2017.
Brian C. Moyer,
Director, Bureau of Economic Analysis.
[FR Doc. 2017–06204 Filed 3–28–17; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 3510–06–P
DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
Economic Development Administration
Notice of Petitions by Firms for
Determination of Eligibility To Apply
for Trade Adjustment Assistance
Economic Development
Administration, Department of
Commerce.
AGENCY:
Notice and opportunity for
public comment.
ACTION:
Pursuant to Section 251 of the Trade
Act 1974, as amended (19 U.S.C. 2341
et seq.), the Economic Development
Administration (EDA) has received
petitions for certification of eligibility to
apply for Trade Adjustment Assistance
from the firms listed below.
Accordingly, EDA has initiated
investigations to determine whether
increased imports into the United States
of articles like or directly competitive
with those produced by each of these
firms contributed importantly to the
total or partial separation of the firm’s
workers, or threat thereof, and to a
decrease in sales or production of each
petitioning firm.
E:\FR\FM\29MRN1.SGM
29MRN1
Agencies
[Federal Register Volume 82, Number 59 (Wednesday, March 29, 2017)]
[Notices]
[Pages 15486-15492]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2017-06171]
=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
Census Bureau
Proposed Information Collection; Comment Request; 2018 End-to-End
Census Test--Peak Operations
AGENCY: U.S. Census Bureau, Commerce.
ACTION: Notice.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: The Department of Commerce, as part of its continuing effort
to reduce paperwork and respondent burden, invites the general public
and other Federal agencies to take this opportunity to comment on
proposed and/or continuing information collections, as required by the
Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995.
DATES: To ensure consideration, written comments must be submitted on
or before May 30, 2017.
ADDRESSES: Direct all written comments to Jennifer Jessup, Departmental
Paperwork Clearance Officer, Department of Commerce, Room 6616, 14th
and Constitution Avenue NW., Washington, DC 20230 (or via the Internet
at PRAcomments@doc.gov).
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Requests for additional information or
copies of the information collection instrument(s) and instructions
should be directed to Robin A. Pennington, Census Bureau, HQ-2K281N,
Washington, DC 20233; (301) 763-8132 (or via email at
robin.a.pennington@census.gov).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Abstract
During the years preceding the 2020 Census, the Census Bureau will
pursue its commitment to reduce the costs of conducting a decennial
census while maintaining our commitment to quality. In 2018, the Census
Bureau will be performing the 2018 End-to-End Census Test. This last
major test before the 2020 Census is designed to (1) test and validate
2020 Census operations, procedures, systems, and field infrastructure
to ensure proper integration and conformance with requirements, and (2)
produce prototypes of geographic and data products.
The 2018 End-to-End Census Test will encompass operations and
systems related to (1) Address Canvassing; (2) Optimizing Self-
Response, including contact strategies, questionnaire content, and
language support; (3) Update Enumerate, including technical and
operational testing; (4) Nonresponse Followup, including technological
and operational improvements; and (5)
[[Page 15487]]
Group Quarters, including technological and operational testing. The
operations other than Address Canvassing are referred to collectively
as Peak Operations, because they are the enumeration data collection
operations of the census. These operations are the focus of this
package.
The Address Canvassing operation ((1) from the above), beginning in
the summer of 2017, is the first operation in the 2018 End-to-End
Census Test and was included in a separate Address Canvassing Operation
package due to timing considerations.
New approaches to the design of the 2020 Census are classified into
four key innovation areas. These areas have been the subject of Census
Bureau testing this decade to identify methodological improvements,
technological advances, and possibilities for cost savings over
repeating the design of the 2010 Census. One of these innovation areas
is Optimizing Self-Response, which is focused on improving methods for
increasing the number of people who take advantage of self-response
options.
Optimizing Self-Response
The 2018 End-to-End Census Test is designed to evaluate several
strategies to optimize the rate at which the public self-responds to
the census, which would reduce costs of the census by decreasing the
workload for following up at nonresponding units. Previous Census
Bureau tests have resulted in the design of contact strategies, two of
which will be in use during this test for the purpose of gathering
additional metrics and making comparisons on a number of indicators.
Either or both of these strategies may be included in the design of the
2020 Census, depending on a variety of factors.
Internet First is the primary mail contact strategy proposed for
the 2020 Census and has been used in Census Bureau research and testing
efforts since 2012. (In prior tests, this strategy was called Internet
Push.) This strategy includes the mailing of a letter inviting
respondents to complete the questionnaire online, two follow-up
reminders, and then if necessary, a mailed paper questionnaire.
Internet Choice includes a paper questionnaire in the first
mailing, along with an invitation to complete the questionnaire online,
providing a choice of Internet or paper response from the beginning of
the contact strategy.
In addition, the 2018 End-to-End Census Test provides the Census
Bureau with an opportunity to enhance the user experience, performance,
and functionality of the Internet self-response instrument compared to
prior Census Tests this decade. Improvements including expanded
language capabilities will support the goal of optimizing self-response
by providing an easy, quick, and safe experience for respondents, and
ensure that the resulting response data and paradata provide required
information to follow-up and data processing operations.
The Census Bureau plans to study the following in the 2018 End-to-
End Census Test:
Comparing the self-response rates between the Internet
First and the Internet Choice panels.
Comparing item-level response by panel and by mode,
including in the Update Enumerate and Group Quarters enumeration
operations, both of which will be fielded for the first time this
decade.
Measuring the effects of incorporating additional
household contact strategies to encourage self-response, including
letter and postcard reminders.
Nonresponse Followup
The 2018 End-to-End Census Test will allow the Census Bureau to
continue to refine, optimize, and assess the operational procedures and
technical design of the Nonresponse Followup (NRFU) operation. The NRFU
operation is a field operation for determining housing unit status
(occupied, vacant, or delete) and for gathering the enumeration data at
addresses for which no self-response was received. This test will build
upon the results of previous field tests this decade where the NRFU
operation has been conducted. In particular, NRFU is now a fully-
automated operation, whereas it was performed using paper materials in
the 2010 Census. For this test, the Census Bureau will examine:
Operational procedures.
[cir] Testing continued refinements to the field data collection
instrument for enumeration, particularly where previous testing has
shown potential problems in our question branching or issues with the
interview software user interface. The Census Bureau will critically
assess navigation within the instrument via debriefing sessions for
field enumerators after operations complete.
[cir] Continuing refinement of our methods for enumerating multi-
unit structures, particularly identifying vacant households in multi-
units with a minimal number of contact attempts, thereby minimizing
respondent burden.
[cir] Continuing refinement of procedures for interviewing proxy
respondents to gather information from hard-to-enumerate households.
[cir] Continuing refinement of processes used to detect and deter
falsification by field enumerators.
[cir] Continuing evaluation of enumerator training procedures and
materials, including both online training modules and classroom
training.
[cir] Integrating a Field Verification assignment into the NRFU
workload. The Field Verification cases are intended to verify the
existence and location of certain types of self-responses that were
received without a preassigned census identification code, called a
User ID.
[cir] Integrating into NRFU the ability to designate an area for an
earlier NRFU operation in order to enumerate college and university
students living in off-campus housing before the end of the spring
semester.
Technical design.
[cir] Continuing refinement of the management alerts to identify
potentially problematic field behavior in real time.
[cir] Continuing refinement of the optimization and routing
algorithms used to make daily NRFU field assignments.
[cir] Continuing work to integrate into the Census Bureau's
enterprise data collection systems.
Update Enumerate (UE)
The Update Enumerate (UE) operation as planned for the 2020 Census
is significantly changed from the UE operation that was used in the
2010 Census at about one percent of all addresses. At root, the UE
methodology is designed for areas that require an enumeration
methodology other than self-response followed by NRFU. The current
design capitalizes on 2020 Census methodological improvements such as
Internet Self-Response, automated field operations, and an approach to
collect responses without a User ID that is greatly expanded in scale.
The 2020 Census UE operation combines address listing methodologies
with person enumeration methodologies. UE is conducted mostly in
geographic areas that have one or more of the following
characteristics:
Do not have city-style addresses like 123 Main Street.
Do not receive mail through city-style addresses.
Receive mail at post office boxes rather than at their
physical address.
Have unique challenges associated with accessibility, such
as dirt roads or seasonal access.
Have recently been affected by natural disasters.
Have high concentrations of seasonally vacant housing.
[[Page 15488]]
The following objectives are being tested for Update Enumerate:
Integrating listing and enumeration operations and
systems.
Evaluating the impact on cost and quality of the UE
contact strategy on enumerator productivity and efficiency.
Testing refinements to the field data collection
instrument for enumeration, especially for atypical situations, such as
movers.
Testing field supervisor to enumerator ratios.
Group Quarters (GQ):
The 2018 End-to-End Census Test will inform Census Bureau
technological and operational planning and design for the enumeration
of the population residing in Group Quarters (GQs). GQs are living
quarters where people who are typically unrelated have group living
arrangements and frequently are receiving some type of service. College
dormitories and nursing homes are examples of GQs. To date, some small-
scale testing has been done to test electronic transmission of GQ's
enumeration responses. The 2018 End-to-End Census Test expands on these
results to allow the opportunity to evaluate procedures and
technologies for conducting GQ enumeration operations. The set of
operations planned for GQ enumeration is GQ Advance Contact, Service-
Based Enumeration, and, finally, GQ Enumeration. These operations have
been used in previous censuses. The GQ Advance Contact is an operation
where facility contact and planning data are collected, including the
ability of the GQ facility to provide electronic records for the
enumeration. Service-Based Enumeration has the objective of counting
individuals who will not be enumerated at a living quarter but are
receiving some type of service. The GQ Enumeration is the final stage
of enumerating individuals residing at the GQ.
Operational procedures.
[cir] Testing updated procedures for handling newly discovered GQs
during field operations.
[cir] Continuing testing of the various GQ operations, process
flows, estimated staffing levels, supporting processes, and workload
estimates.
[cir] Continuing refinement of procedures for linking paper
questionnaire response records collected by multiple enumerators during
enumeration at a single GQ.
[cir] Continuing evaluation and refinement of the optimal
enumerator to GQ ratios for multiple GQ types.
[cir] Testing multiple modes of enumeration.
Technical design.
[cir] Testing the use of electronic methodologies to:
[ssquf] Create the initial universe for the GQ Advance Contact.
[ssquf] Conduct In-Office GQ Advance Contact.
[ssquf] Update the GQ frame prior to GQ enumeration.
[ssquf] Accept electronically transmitted response data in multiple
formats.
[cir] Integrating GQ operations with listing and enumeration
operations and systems.
Content
The Census Bureau recognizes that OMB is continuing to lead the
discussion among federal agencies and other stakeholders on race/
ethnicity from the perspective of data collection and dissemination
guidance and standards, and that the final determination has not been
made on the format of the race/ethnicity question for the 2020 Census.
If it is determined that the combined race/ethnicity question format
may be used for the 2020 Census (versus the separate race and Hispanic
Origin questions used for the 2010 Census), it will be crucial for the
Census Bureau to ensure that critical operations are fully prepared to
go into production for the 2020 Census using the combined question.
Therefore, the 2018 End-to-End Census Test data collection operations
will utilize the combined race/ethnicity question version (that
includes a Middle Eastern or North African category) to further its
analysis and understanding of mode differences for the race/ethnicity
responses before deploying the 2020 Census questionnaire.
Internet Self-Response: Continue testing the combined
race/ethnicity question under the further enhancements of the Internet
Self-Response instrument for the 2018 End-to-End Census Test in regards
to user experience, performance, and functionality; ensure that the
resulting response data and paradata meet the requirements of follow-up
and data processing operations; and test expanded language capabilities
on the instrument, as the introduction of additional language options
contributes to additional paths to analyze the paradata and response
data.
Nonresponse Followup: Continue testing the combined race/
ethnicity question under the further enhancements of the field
enumeration instrument; assess enumerators' experience with the field
enumeration instrument and their navigation of the race/ethnicity
question within the instrument. Input will be gathered during the post-
operation field enumerator debriefing sessions.
Update Enumerate and Group Quarters: Examine the 2018 End-
to-End Census Test results by mode, including Update Enumerate and
Group Quarters operations, which will be fielded for the first time
this decade.
II. Method of Collection
Test Sites
The 2018 End-to-End Census Test will take place in three sites
within the continental United States: Pierce County, Washington;
Providence County, Rhode Island; and the Bluefield-Beckley-Oak Hill,
West Virginia area. These locations offer particular characteristics
that support the Census Bureau's testing goals, including: various
types of addresses (such as city-style, rural, and location
description-only); population with varying demographics (such as age,
race, and language spoken at home); variety of housing types (such as
single-units, multi-units, vacant units, GQs, and mobile homes); varied
levels of Internet access and usage; various time zones; and
challenging environmental conditions (such as weather extremes, rough
terrain).
Self-Response:
The housing units in the areas selected for inclusion in the 2018
End-to-End Census Test will be contacted by mail and invited to
complete their questionnaire via the Internet. Optimizing Self-Response
contact methods include follow-on letter and postcard reminders. The
Census Bureau will also test strategies for delivering paper
questionnaires to households that do not or cannot respond online, as
measured by low Internet connectivity or low Internet usage rates.
The Census Bureau will continue to test Non-ID Processing
methodology as another strategy for Optimizing Self-Response. A User ID
that links to a unique housing unit is on many of the mailed materials,
but respondents can also submit a response without using the ID,
particularly on the Internet or telephone. Non-ID Processing refers to
address matching and geocoding for census responses that lack this
preassigned census ID. This processing allows such responses to be
linked up with the associated census enumeration data and can occur
through automated or clerical procedures. Additionally, the 2018 End-
to-End Census Test will allow the Census Bureau to continue to develop
the capability to conduct real-time Non-ID Processing, where a
respondent is prompted interactively
[[Page 15489]]
(while they are still online filling out the form) for additional
address and location information if the provided address cannot be
matched through automation to an address with a User ID.
This test will allow the Census Bureau to understand better the
requirements related to scalability of planned systems and to determine
metrics for each of the Non-ID Processing steps. If the address match
is not resolved during the initial automated or real-time processing,
Census Bureau staff will attempt manually to match or geocode the
address. It is estimated that about two percent of the overall non-ID
respondents will be contacted via telephone as part of the manual
matching process. Non-ID Processing also includes an office-based
address verification (OBAV) component. OBAV uses available geographic
reference materials to verify the existence and location of an address.
OBAV is performed in an effort to avoid the more costly fieldwork.
However, any address that is worked in OBAV but cannot be verified in
OBAV will be sent to Field Verification (discussed in more detail below
as a suboperation of NRFU).
Additionally, with the Re-collect component, a sample of self-
response cases are selected for re-contact, which may occur through
centralized phone contract or in-field enumeration. Re-collect is
intended to validate the information from a respondent, confirming the
existence of the address and the people enumerated at that address. Re-
collect is also one aspect of fraud detection.
Content
Decades of research on different race/ethnicity question designs
have shown that individual identities can be impacted by societal
changes, attitudes, and perceptions. The 2018 End-to-End Census Test
design can help us understand whether respondent reporting of racial/
ethnic identities is impacted by the types of data that the Census
Bureau is collecting (e.g., detailed race/ethnic responses and new
categories), as well as whether or not respondent privacy concerns and
expectations for data protection are addressed and the process is
trusted by the general public.
It will be crucial for the Census Bureau to ensure that critical
operations are fully prepared to go into production for the 2020 Census
using the combined question, if it is determined that the combined
race/ethnicity question format may be used for the 2020 Census. The
Census Bureau plans to deploy the combined race/ethnicity question
version (that includes a Middle Eastern or North African category)
during the 2018 End-to-End Census Test to further examine:
Item nonresponse to the combined race and ethnicity
question (with detailed checkboxes, with respect to the reporting of
major race/ethnic categories (e.g., White, Black, Asian, etc.) that is
similar to the question the Census Bureau used in the 2015 National
Content Test and is based on results from the 2010 Census Race and
Hispanic Origin Alternative Questionnaire Experiment (Compton, et al.,
2012).
Research has found that, over time, there have been a growing
number of people who do not identify with any of the race categories,
and this means that an increasing number of respondents have been
classified as ``Some Other Race.'' The combined question format with
detailed checkboxes attempts to help improve the accuracy of these
data.
Levels of overall race/ethnicity reporting (e.g., White,
Hispanic, Black, etc.), as well as detailed reporting levels for these
groups (e.g., German, Mexican, Jamaican, etc.).
Levels of overall race/ethnicity reporting within the new
category Middle Eastern or North African (MENA), as well as levels of
detailed MENA reporting for respondents of Middle Eastern and North
African heritage.
Match rates between individual racial/ethnic responses in
the 2018 End-to-End Census Test and responses in previous census
records (e.g., 2010 Census Hispanic origin/race data; ACS ancestry,
race, Hispanic origin data). This exploration aims to focus on the
comparison of race/ethnicity reporting in different social environments
to understand what people have reported in the past compared to what
they are reporting in the present. A growing number of people find the
current race and ethnicity categories confusing.
The 2018 End-to-End Census Test will be an important opportunity to
experiment with different imputation procedures to ascertain which
approach yields the best overall imputation results for missing data
with a combined race/ethnicity question. The 2018 End-to-End Census
Test will enable researchers to ascertain which records to utilize
(e.g., Ancestry, Hispanic origin, Race), and in what hierarchy they
should be used for imputation. With the expanded language options for
the 2018 End-to-End Census Test, response data from detailed write-in
fields (such as those on the combined race/ethnicity question) will
also need to be output, processed, coded, edited, and tabulated, as
well as translated if provided in non-English languages.
Additionally, data products and dissemination is a critical
objective of the 2018 End-to-End Census Test. The question format used
in data collection and processing is also the source of the
redistricting tabulation, and the Census Bureau must be prepared to
meet the needs of the states as well as 2020 Census data users, if it
is determined that the combined race/ethnicity question format will be
used for the 2020 Census. The Census Bureau believes that the results
of the 2018 End-to-End Census Test will help inform our growing body of
knowledge regarding the combined race/ethnicity question and the
collection of major group responses and detailed race/ethnicity
responses.
As previously stated, the Census Bureau recognizes that OMB is
continuing to lead the discussion among federal agencies and other
stakeholders on race/ethnicity from the perspective of data collection
and dissemination guidance and standards, and that the final
determination has not been made on the format of the race/ethnicity
question for the 2020 Census. In the event that the 2020 Census does
not proceed with the combined race/ethnicity question, the Census
Bureau is prepared to make necessary adjustments to deploy the separate
Race and Hispanic Origin questions by consulting the various versions
of the separate Race and Hispanic Origin questions that were tested
during the 2015 National Content Test. The Census Bureau will properly
configure all downstream operations--such as response processing and
data tabulation, imputation, analysis, and data dissemination--to
ensure a successful deployment of the race/ethnicity question(s)
regardless of the question format.
Language Services
Individuals of Limited English Proficiency (LEP) require language
assistance in order to complete their census questionnaires. The Census
Bureau has identified the largest LEP populations in the United States
using American Community Survey data and has established a program for
providing non-English materials for census tests and the decennial
census. For the 2018 End-to-End Census Test, Internet self-response and
telephone assistance will be available in English, Spanish, Chinese,
Vietnamese, Korean, Russian, Arabic, and Tagalog. Paper questionnaires,
mailing materials, field data collection instruments and field
[[Page 15490]]
data collection materials will be available in English and Spanish.
Nonresponse Followup (NRFU)
For all housing unit addresses included in the test universe, if no
response is received by a specified date, the address will be included
in the universe for the NRFU portion of the test. In NRFU, enumerators
will attempt to follow up at addresses for which no self-response was
received to determine their status and to collect their data for
addresses determined to be occupied.
To allow sufficient time for self-response, the NRFU operation
begins in mid-May. However, some students who reside in off-campus
housing units will have left the campus area by the time NRFU begins.
Early NRFU is conducted starting in April in blocks near colleges and
universities with a high percentage of off-campus housing to enumerate
at these units while students are still in town.
The Census Bureau will conduct NRFU with mobile devices. The
devices will utilize a secure Census Bureau-provided enumeration
application solution for conducting the NRFU field data collection.
Nonresponse Followup Reinterview (NRFU-RI)
A sample of the cases enumerated via NRFU will be selected for
reinterview (RI). This NRFU-RI operation is intended to help pinpoint
possible cases of enumerator falsification. The Census Bureau will test
centralized phone contacts of the NRFU-RI cases before sending them to
an enumerator in the field, providing potential cost avoidance
opportunities. Enumerators working NRFU-RI cases will use the same
mobile devices and software as for the NRFU cases.
Field Verification (FV)
Households that self-respond to the Census without a User ID with
addresses that cannot be either matched to our address frame or
verified in Non-ID Processing may be sent to a Field Verification
operation, performed by NRFU enumerators. This suboperation is designed
for verification that the housing unit exists, confirmation of the
census block location for the address, and if possible, collection of
Global Positioning System coordinates to facilitate accurate
determination of the census block.
Update Enumerate (UE)
Update Enumerate for the 2018 End-to-End Census Test will test the
four planned components of the operation: Update Enumerate Production,
Update Enumerate Listing Quality Control (QC), Update Enumerate
Followup, and Update Enumerate Reinterview. In addition to the field
operation, the Census Bureau will test mailing out an invitation
package to those housing units with a mailable address to generate
self-response before the operation begins. Mailable addresses will
constitute only a small percentage of the addresses in these areas. If
a household self-responds, the UE fieldworker (enumerator) will not
need to enumerate that house while listing the geographic area. This is
a cost savings to Update Enumerate since the enumerator will not have
to spend time collecting these data.
Update Enumerate (UE) Production
Enumerators will visit specific geographic areas to identify every
place where people could live or stay, comparing what they see on the
ground to the existing census address list. The enumerator will update
the address list, either verify or correct the address and location
information, and classify each living quarter (LQ) as a housing unit
(HU) or group quarter (GQ). If the LQ is classified as a GQ, it will be
designated for enumeration within the GQ operations.
Enumerators will attempt to conduct an interview for each housing
unit that has not yet self-responded. If someone answers the door, the
enumerator will provide a Confidentiality Notice and ask questions to
verify or update the address. The enumerator will then ask if there are
any additional LQs in the structure or on the property. If there are
additional LQs, the enumerators will collect/update that information.
The enumerator will then interview the respondent for the household
using the questionnaire on the mobile device.
If no one is home at a housing unit that has not self-responded,
the enumerator will leave a Notice of Visit inviting a respondent for
each household to go online with a User ID to complete the 2018 End-to-
End Census Test. The Notice of Visit will also include the phone number
for Census Questionnaire Assistance (CQA) if the respondent has any
questions or would prefer to respond to the survey on the telephone. In
the 2018 End-to-End Census Test, a paper questionnaire rather than a
Notice of Visit will be left with a random set of addresses in order to
test the impact on self-response rates. This operation has never been
tested for the census before, and this data will help determine the
best strategies to use in the 2020 Census.
Update Enumerate Listing QC
A sample of addresses listed via UE production will be selected for
UE Listing QC. The intention of this operation is to help us pinpoint
possible cases of enumerator falsification or error in address listing.
UE Listing QC will use the Census Bureau's listing software on mobile
devices to recollect listing data to be used for a comparison.
Update Enumerate Followup
The UE operation will have a UE Followup component for those
households that were not enumerated on the first visit and have not yet
self-responded. UE enumerators will conduct the operation using the
NRFU enumeration application on a Census Bureau provided mobile device.
Update Enumerate Reinterview (UE RI)
A sample of cases enumerated via UE production or UE Followup will
be selected for reinterview. The intention of this operation is to help
us pinpoint possible cases of enumerator falsification of enumeration
data. The Census Bureau will test centralized phone contacts of the UE
RI cases before sending them to an enumerator in the field, providing
potential cost avoidance opportunities. Enumerators working UE RI cases
will use the same mobile devices and software as for the UE and NRFU
cases.
Group Quarters Advance Contact
The GQ Advance Contact operation will contact Group Quarters prior
to enumeration. In an in-office Advance Contact, GQs will be contacted
to verify information such as: Preferred modes of enumeration, expected
population on Census Day, and whether there are available electronic
response data records the Census Bureau could use for the enumeration.
Census Bureau staff at local Census offices will follow-up with GQs by
phone, email, and in-person to obtain the necessary pre-enumeration
information.
Group Quarters Service-Based Enumeration (SBE)
Enumerators will conduct SBE at selected shelters, soup kitchens,
and nonsheltered outdoor locations, providing an opportunity to test
new response collection procedures on a larger scale than has been
tested so far this decade.
Group Quarters Enumeration (GQE)
GQE will involve multiple modes of enumeration. During the 2018
End-to-End Census Test, electronic response for GQs will be tested on a
broad scale to determine if there are gains in efficiency
[[Page 15491]]
through self-response. Use of the automated enumeration device is an
additional technology to be tested in GQE. For GQs that request paper-
based enumeration, enumerators will perform drop off and pickup of
paper forms, which are completed by self-enumeration.
Group Quarters QC
A sample of cases that have been enumerated via GQE will be
selected for reinterview. This operation is intended to help us
pinpoint possible cases of enumerator falsification.
Coverage Improvement
Coverage Improvement is conducted to resolve potential erroneous
enumerations and omissions from the initial self-response data
collection and from all field enumeration data collections. Coverage
questions are included in both the self-response and NRFU instruments
to aid in the identification of coverage follow-up cases. In-office
follow-up includes evaluating usual-home-elsewhere address data from GQ
enumerations, and assessing the potential person duplication, as
identified through person matching on collected data. For cases where
in-office processes do not yield a resolution, field and/or telephone
follow-up with the respondent will occur.
Response Processing and Data Tabulation
With the addition of expanded language options, response data from
detailed write-in fields, such as those on the combined race/ethnicity
question, will need to be translated, output, processed, coded, edited,
and tabulated. In addition, a prototype of the Redistricting Data
Program output will be delivered. Ensuring these interfaces meet the
requirements for data tabulation will be a crucial step in preparing to
tabulate the test data.
The design of this data product and its dissemination is a critical
final objective of the 2018 End-to-End Census Test, as the Census
Bureau must be prepared to meet the needs of various stakeholders for
2020 Census data.
III. Data
OMB Control Number: 0607-XXXX.
Form Number(s): Paper and electronic questionnaires; numbers to be
determined.
Type of Review: Regular submission.
Affected Public: Households/Individuals.
Estimated Number of Respondents:
Test Sites--Pierce County, Washington; Providence County, Rhode Island; and the Bluefield-Beckley-Oak Hill, West
Virginia Area
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Estimated
Estimated time per Total burden
Operation or category number of response hours
respondents (minutes)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Geographic Area Focused on Self-Response:
Internet/Telephone/Paper.................................... 337,000 10 56,167
Nonresponse Followup........................................ 323,000 10 53,833
Nonresponse Followup Reinterview............................ 30,685 10 5,114
-----------------------------------------------
Self-Response Subtotal.................................. 690,685 .............. 115,114
-----------------------------------------------
Geographic Area Focused on Update Enumerate:
Update Enumerate Production................................. 96,000 12 19,200
Update Enumerate Listing QC................................. 9,600 5 800
Update Enumerate Followup................................... 48,000 10 8,000
Update Enumerate Reinterview................................ 9,600 10 1,600
Update Enumerate Subtotal................................... 163,200 .............. 29,600
-----------------------------------------------
Group Quarters:
GQ Advance Contact (facility)............................... 1,200 10 200
GQ SBE--facility contact.................................... 100 10 17
GQ SBE--person contact...................................... 4,000 10 667
GQ Enumeration--facility contact............................ 1,100 10 183
GQ Enumeration--person contact.............................. 55,000 10 9,167
Group Quarters QC........................................... 110 5 9
-----------------------------------------------
Group Quarters Subtotal................................. 61,510 .............. 10,243
-----------------------------------------------
Non-ID Processing Phone Followup............................ 337 5 28
Re-collect.................................................. 16,000 10 2,667
Field Verification.......................................... 421 2 14
Coverage Improvement........................................ 15,420 10 2,570
-----------------------------------------------
Totals.............................................. 947,573 .............. 160,236
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Self-Response by Internet/Telephone/Paper: 337,000 respondents.
Nonresponse Followup: 323,000 respondents.
Nonresponse Followup Reinterview: 30,685 respondents.
Update Enumerate Production: 96,000 respondents.
Update Enumerate Listing QC: 9,600 respondents.
Update Enumerate Followup: 48,000 respondents.
Update Enumerate Reinterview: 9,600 respondents.
Group Quarters Advance Contact (facility): 1,200 respondents.
Group Quarters Service-Based Enumeration--facility contact: 100
respondents.
Group Quarters Service-Based Enumeration--person contact: 4,000
respondents.
Group Quarters Enumeration--facility contact: 1,100 respondents.
[[Page 15492]]
Group Quarters Enumeration--person contact: 55,000 respondents.
Group Quarters QC: 110 respondents.
Non-ID Processing Phone Followup: 337 respondents.
Re-collect: 16,000 respondents.
Field Verification: 421 respondents.
Coverage Improvement: 15,420 respondents.
Total: 947,573 Contacts.
Estimated Time per Response:
Self-Response by Internet/Telephone/Paper: 10 minutes per response.
Nonresponse Followup: 10 minutes per response.
Nonresponse Followup Reinterview: 10 minutes per response.
Update Enumerate Production: 12 minutes per response.
Update Enumerate Listing QC: 5 minutes per response.
Update Enumerate Followup: 10 minutes per response.
Update Enumerate Reinterview: 10 minutes per response.
Group Quarters Advance Contact: 10 minutes per response.
Group Quarters Service-based Enumeration: 10 minutes per response.
Group Quarters Enumeration: 10 minutes per response.
Group Quarters QC: 5 minutes per response.
Non-ID Processing Phone Followup: 5 minutes per response.
Re-collect: 10 minutes per response.
Field Verification: 2 minutes per response.
Coverage Improvement: 10 minutes per response.
Estimated Total Annual Burden Hours: 160,236 hours.
Estimated Total Annual Cost to Public: There are no costs to
respondents other than their time to participate in this data
collection.
Respondent's Obligation: Mandatory.
Legal Authority: Title 13 U.S.C. Sections 141, 191 and 193.
IV. Request for Comments
Comments are invited on: (a) Whether the proposed collection of
information is necessary for the proper performance of the functions of
the agency, including whether the information shall have practical
utility; (b) the accuracy of the agency's estimate of the burden
(including hours and cost) of the proposed collection of information;
(c) ways to enhance the quality, utility, and clarity of the
information to be collected; and (d) ways to minimize the burden of the
collection of information on respondents, including through the use of
automated collection techniques or other forms of information
technology.
Comments submitted in response to this notice will be summarized
and/or included in the request for OMB approval of this information
collection; they also will become a matter of public record.
Sheleen Dumas,
PRA Departmental Lead, Office of the Chief Information Officer.
[FR Doc. 2017-06171 Filed 3-28-17; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 3510-07-P