Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP): Disaster Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (D-SNAP), 28738-28758 [2016-10923]
Download as PDF
28738
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
(7) Are there regulations, reporting
requirements, or regulatory processes
that are unnecessarily complicated or
could be streamlined to achieve
regulatory objectives in more efficient
ways?
(8) Are there rules or reporting
requirements that have been overtaken
by technological developments? Can
new technologies be leveraged to
modify, streamline, or do away with
existing regulatory or reporting
requirements?
(9) How can the Department best
obtain and consider accurate, objective
information and data about the costs,
burdens, and benefits of existing
regulations? Are there existing sources
of data the Department can use to
evaluate the post-promulgation effects
of regulations over time? We invite
interested parties to provide data that
may be in their possession that
documents the costs, burdens, and
benefits of existing requirements.
(10) Are there regulations that are
working well that can be expanded or
used as a model to fill gaps in other
DOE regulatory programs?
The Department notes that this RFI is
issued solely for information and
program-planning purposes. Responses
to this RFI do not bind DOE to any
further actions related to the response.
All submissions will be made publically
available on https://www.regulations.gov.
Issued in Washington, DC on May 3, 2016.
Steven P. Croley,
General Counsel.
[FR Doc. 2016–10956 Filed 5–9–16; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 6450–01–P
DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
Food and Nutrition Service
7 CFR Parts 272, 274, and 280
[FNS 2015–0021]
RIN 0584–AE00
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance
Program (SNAP): Disaster
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance
Program (D–SNAP)
Food and Nutrition Service,
USDA.
ACTION: Proposed rule.
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
AGENCY:
This proposed rule would
amend the Supplemental Nutrition
Assistance Program (SNAP) (formerly
the Food Stamp Program) regulations to
establish procedures for planning,
requesting and operating a Disaster
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance
SUMMARY:
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
Program (D–SNAP). The rulemaking is
necessary to implement a section of the
Food and Nutrition Act of 2008. This
rulemaking also addresses a section of
the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief
and Emergency Assistance Act of 1988
and accompanying Executive Order
12673, which provides the authority for
the Department to determine the need
for SNAP assistance during a
presidentially-declared disaster.
DATES: Written comments on this
proposed rule must be received on or
before July 11, 2016.
ADDRESSES: The Food and Nutrition
Service (FNS) invites interested persons
to submit comments on this proposed
rule. Comments may be submitted by
any of the following methods:
Federal eRulemaking Portal: Preferred
method. Go to https://
www.regulations.gov; follow the online
instructions for submitting comments
on Docket FNS 2015–0021.
FAX: Submit comments by facsimile
transmission to (703) 305–2486,
attention: Sasha Gersten-Paal.
Mail: Send comments to Sasha
Gersten-Paal, Branch Chief, Certification
Policy Branch, Program Development
Division, Supplemental Nutrition
Assistance Program, Food and Nutrition
Service, 3101 Park Center Drive, Room
812, Alexandria, Virginia, 22302, (703)
305–2507.
Hand Delivery or Courier: Deliver
comments to Sasha Gersten-Paal at the
above address.
Additional electronic filing
information: You may download a copy
of this rule from www.fns.usda.gov/
SNAP. You may also comment via the
Internet at the same address. Please
include ATTENTION RIN: 0584–AE00
in the subject line and your name and
address in the message. If you do not
receive a confirmation that we have
received your comment please call
Sasha Gersten-Paal at 703–305–2507.
All comments on this proposed rule
will be included in the record and will
be made available to the public. Please
be advised that the substance of the
comments and the identity of the
individuals or entities submitting the
comments will be subject to public
disclosure. FNS will make the
comments publicly available on the
Internet via https://www.regulations.gov.
All submissions will be available for
public inspection at the office of FNS
during regular business hours (8:30 a.m.
to 5:00 p.m., Monday through Friday) at
3101 Park Center Drive, Room 810,
Alexandria, Virginia 22302–1594.
Written comments on this proposed
rule should be specific, confined to
issues pertinent to the rule, and should
PO 00000
Frm 00003
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
explain the reason for any change you
recommend. Where possible, you
should reference the specific section or
paragraph you are addressing. We may
not consider or include in the
Administrative Record that supports the
final rulemaking comments that we
receive after the close of the comment
period or comments delivered to an
address other than that listed above. We
will make available all comments for
public inspection, including, name,
address and other contact information of
respondents. If you wish to request that
we consider withholding your name,
address, or other contact information
from public review or from disclosure
under the Freedom of Information Act,
you must state this prominently at the
beginning of your comment. We will
honor requests for confidentiality on a
case-by-case basis to the extent allowed
by law. We will make available for
public inspection in their entirety all
submissions from organizations or
businesses, and from individuals
identifying themselves as
representatives or officials of
organizations or businesses.
For
further information concerning this
Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM)
you may contact Sasha Gersten-Paal,
Branch Chief, Certification Policy
Branch, Program Development Division,
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance
Program, 3101 Park Center Drive, Room
810, Alexandria, Virginia, 22302, or by
email at Sasha.Gersten-Paal@
fns.usda.gov.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Background
The basic premise underlying the D–
SNAP and this proposed rule is that
when a disaster occurs (and after
commercial channels of food
distribution are operating again) there is
an increased and immediate need for
nutrition assistance for families that
have suffered loss of income and/or
incurred additional costs due to the
disaster. SNAP is not designed to take
disaster-related expenses into account
in determining eligibility. SNAP
eligibility requirements typically do not
match the sudden (but temporary) needs
of households affected by disaster, and
SNAP’s procedural requirements make
it difficult for States to handle the large
number of people suddenly in need of
immediate assistance. Thus, it may be
necessary to implement a D–SNAP that
uses a different set of rules to determine
need and issue benefits.
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
How D–SNAP Currently Operates
D–SNAP provides temporary food
assistance for households affected by a
disaster when there is a Presidential
disaster declaration that includes the
provision of individual assistance.
Currently, D–SNAP provides one month
of benefits to eligible disaster survivors
and can facilitate the issuance of
supplemental SNAP benefits for
currently certified households. To be
eligible for D–SNAP, a household must
live (or in some cases, work) in the
identified disaster area, have been
affected by the disaster, and meet
certain D–SNAP eligibility criteria. D–
SNAP is designed for situations where
a large number of households have
disaster-related expenses not
contemplated when an individual
applies for SNAP.
The primary responsibility for
providing emergency food assistance
rests with the State agency. Currently,
utilizing FNS Guidance, State agencies
design their own D–SNAP Plan,
evaluate the need for a D–SNAP or
another feeding program should a
disaster strike, submit to FNS a detailed
request to operate a D–SNAP, effectively
implement the D–SNAP, ensure
program integrity in D–SNAP
operations, submit daily reports,
perform post-disaster reviews and report
their findings to FNS.
What acronyms or abbreviations are
used in this supplementary discussion
of the proposed provisions?
In the discussion of the proposed
provisions in this rule, we use the
following acronyms or other
abbreviations to stand in for certain
words or phrases:
Acronym,
abbreviation,
or symbol
Phrase
Code of Federal Regulations ..........................................................................................................................................................
United States Code .........................................................................................................................................................................
Disaster Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program ....................................................................................................................
Electronic Benefit Transfer .............................................................................................................................................................
Individual Assistance ......................................................................................................................................................................
Federal Register .............................................................................................................................................................................
Federal Fiscal Year .........................................................................................................................................................................
Food and Nutrition Act of 2008 ......................................................................................................................................................
Food and Nutrition Service .............................................................................................................................................................
Secretary of Agriculture ..................................................................................................................................................................
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program ..................................................................................................................................
U. S. Department of Agriculture .....................................................................................................................................................
Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act ...............................................................................................
Federal Emergency Management Agency .....................................................................................................................................
Legislation and Regulations
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
What authorities does the Department
have regarding disasters?
FNS can provide disaster nutrition
assistance in three ways:
• Provide USDA purchased foods for
shelters and other mass feeding sites (42
U.S.C. 5180);
• Provide USDA commodity (food)
assistance for distribution directly to
households in need in certain limited
circumstances (42 U.S.C.5180);
• Approve a State D–SNAP operation
and provide funding for 100 percent of
disaster benefits and 50 percent of State
administrative costs. FNS supports the
State’s efforts to provide D–SNAP
benefits by providing policy guidance,
training, and technical assistance to
State agencies as they plan, implement,
and assess their D–SNAP activities (42
U.S.C. 5179).
All three types of assistance may be
needed for disaster victims throughout
or at different points of time following
the disaster. However, households
cannot simultaneously receive both D–
SNAP benefits and commodity
assistance.
Under the Stafford Act the President
is authorized to declare a ‘‘major
disaster’’ when requested to do so by the
Governor of a state stuck by a natural
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
disaster. The President may direct
Federal agencies to support States’
response efforts and assist in the
distribution of food and other
consumable supplies.
After consultation with FEMA, the
Secretary also has the authority to
establish temporary emergency
standards of eligibility for victims of a
disaster if they are in need of temporary
food assistance, and commercial
channels of food distribution were
disrupted, but have again become
available. FNS has generally approved
States’ requests for D–SNAP under
Stafford Act authority when areas
affected by disasters have received a
Presidential disaster declaration that
includes an individual assistance
declaration, since this establishes the
need for assistance at the household
level.
What does legislation say about D–
SNAP?
The Stafford Act provides the
Secretary of Agriculture with the
authority to operate a D–SNAP when
affected areas have received a
Presidential major disaster declaration
for individual assistance (IA) and when
commercial channels of food
distribution are available. Section (5)(h)
of the Act provides the Secretary with
PO 00000
Frm 00004
Fmt 4702
28739
Sfmt 4702
CFR.
U.S.C.
D–SNAP.
EBT.
IA.
FR.
FY.
Act.
FNS.
the Secretary.
SNAP.
the Department.
Stafford Act.
FEMA.
the authority to establish temporary
emergency standards of eligibility for
households who are survivors of a
disaster that disrupts commercial
channels of food distribution, after those
channels have been restored. The Act
requires that the Secretary establish a
disaster task force to assist States in the
implementation and operation of a D–
SNAP and send members to the disaster
site if cost-effective. The Act also
requires that the regulations address
replacement benefits for households
currently certified in SNAP that
experience food loss, and provides for
the adjustment of issuance and
reporting requirements in the D–SNAP.
Under Section 11(e)(14) of the Act, as
part of a State agency’s overall Plan of
Operation, the State agency is required
to specify a plan for providing SNAP for
households that are victims of a disaster
and that such plan shall include, but not
be limited to, procedures for informing
the public about the disaster program
and how to apply for its benefits. The
plan should also give consideration to
coordinating efforts with other Federal
and private relief agencies, as well as
local government officials.
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
28740
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
Has the Department previously
published rules for D–SNAP?
The Department published the
interim rule in 1981, at 46 FR 8922–01
(January 27, 1981) (amended in 1991
and 2005), which established the
Department’s authority to approve
temporary emergency standards of
eligibility for disaster victims without
regard to Section 4(c) of the Act or the
procedures set forth in the
Administrative Procedure Act (5 U.S.C.
553). Based on this authority, as
disasters have occurred, the Department
has approved the specific procedures to
be used, depending on the
circumstances of each particular
disaster. The procedures in the interim
rulemaking (that was never published as
a final rule) for certifying disasteraffected households and issuing D–
SNAP benefits initially served as a basis
for D–SNAP guidance to States. FNS
guidance has since evolved and has
been updated as necessary based on
experience and States’ needs.
Would this proposed rule address the
‘‘Disaster Task Force’’ discussed in the
Act?
The proposed rule does not address
the D–SNAP task force. FNS employs
staff at its national office and in its
regional offices that work with State
staff, and coordinate with other Federal
agencies in preparing for disasters. FNS
staff assists with D–SNAP operations as
appropriate, including going on-site in
many instances. While these staffs
change over time in response to the
need for disaster-related activity, they
constitute the flexible type of task force
contemplated by the Act. Thus, there is
no need to regulate this provision of the
Act.
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
What do the current interim regulations
for D–SNAP say?
The interim regulations currently in
effect state that:
• The Secretary shall, after
consultation with the official
empowered to exercise the authority
provided for by the Stafford Act,
establish temporary emergency
standards of eligibility for the duration
of the emergency for households who
are victims of a disaster which disrupts
commercial channels of food
distribution, if such households are in
need of temporary food assistance and
if commercial channels of food
distribution have again become
available to meet the temporary food
needs of such households.
• Such standards as are prescribed for
individual emergencies may be
promulgated without regard to section
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
4(c) of this Act or the procedures set
forth in 5 U.S.C. 553.
• In addition to establishing
temporary emergency standards of
eligibility, the Secretary shall provide
for emergency allotments to eligible
households to replace food destroyed in
a disaster. Such emergency allotments
would be equal to the value of the food
actually lost in such disaster but not
greater than the applicable maximum
monthly allotment for the household
size.
• The Secretary may also approve
alternate methods for issuing food
stamp benefits during a disaster when
reliance on Electronic Benefits Transfer
(EBT) systems is impracticable.
What has the Department learned using
this authority?
The Department has learned several
lessons over the years. First, each
disaster situation is different and it is
important to provide States flexibility in
requesting a D–SNAP that will meet the
needs of the disaster victims and is
compatible with the State’s plans and
administration. Second, disaster
planning and preparation are critical to
a timely and well coordinated response
to different disaster situations. Third,
State monitoring and reporting on
program operations and integrity must
be integrated into the planning and
implementation of any D–SNAP.
What aspects of the D–SNAP does the
proposed rule address?
This proposed rule primarily
addresses several aspects of the D–
SNAP, including:
• The development of a Disaster Plan
• Circumstances necessary for approval
of a D–SNAP
• Required content of the State request
to FNS for a D–SNAP
• The basic eligibility and benefit
policy for participation in D–SNAP
• The application processing
requirements for D–SNAP
• Policy regarding currently certified
SNAP participants residing in disaster
areas
• Monitoring State D–SNAP operations
• State Reporting on D–SNAP (both
during and at the conclusion of
disaster operations)
Does this proposed rule establish
detailed operating and policy
requirements for all D–SNAP
operations?
This proposed rule is intended to
provide as much flexibility as possible
in the design of each D–SNAP operation
while establishing consistent rules for
requesting, monitoring and reporting on
the D–SNAP. The reason for this is the
PO 00000
Frm 00005
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
varied and unpredictable nature of each
disaster. While there are similarities
among disasters, each set of
circumstances is different enough that
any attempt to limit State and FNS
flexibility could cause delays in Federal
and State response time in providing
benefits to the victims of disasters.
Thus, regulations that inherently seek to
standardize policy and procedures,
regardless of specific circumstances, can
become problematic when the
circumstances call for flexibility. In this
proposal, the Department provides a
basic framework for D–SNAP that sets
clear expectations for State and local
administrators while still allowing as
much flexibility as possible.
Furthermore, the Department is
attempting to provide responsible fiscal
controls of the disaster benefits while
ensuring that benefits are provided to
eligible applicants during disasters.
Does FNS provide additional direction
or guidance regarding D–SNAP?
Yes, FNS provides detailed guidance
which can be found on the FNS Web
site at https://www.fns.usda.gov/
disasters/response/D–SNAP_Handbook/
D–SNAP_handbook.pdf. This guidance
is based upon lessons learned by FNS
and States’ best practices in several
types of disasters. It is designed to assist
States in all aspects of the D–SNAP.
Adherence to this guidance can improve
preparedness, expedite approval of
requests and reduce the potential for
waste and fraud in D–SNAP operations.
When is it appropriate to request D–
SNAP?
D–SNAP timing varies with the
unique circumstances of each disaster,
but begins after there has been a
Presidentially-declared disaster for IA
and commercial channels of food
distribution have been restored so
families are able to purchase and
prepare food.
What is IA?
IA is financial or direct assistance to
individuals and families whose property
has been damaged or destroyed as a
result of a Presidentially-declared
disaster, and whose losses are not
covered by insurance. The decision to
designate an area as eligible for IA is
made by FEMA. The IA is intended to
help households with critical expenses
that cannot be covered in other ways.
FNS proposes to approve the
operation of D–SNAP under Stafford
Act authority when affected areas have
received a Presidential disaster
declaration for IA because receipt of an
individual assistance declaration is
indicative of households’ need for food
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
assistance in the affected area. However,
since D–SNAP is intended to meet
households’ immediate needs, States
would be required to implement D–
SNAP within a reasonable time period
following the IA declaration. FNS is
reluctant to approve requests for D–
SNAP that are made after the immediate
need for food assistance has passed.
How is D–SNAP funded?
FNS provides 100 percent of disaster
benefits and 50 percent of State
administrative costs.
What is a State’s responsibilities in D–
SNAP?
The Department proposes that the
primary responsibility for providing
emergency food assistance continue to
rest with the States. State agencies
would continue to design their own D–
SNAP Plan, evaluate the need for a D–
SNAP or another feeding program when
a disaster strikes, submit a detailed
request to FNS to operate a D–SNAP,
effectively implement the D–SNAP,
ensure program integrity in D–SNAP
operations, submit daily reports,
perform post-disaster reviews, and
report their findings to FNS.
Basic D–SNAP Policies
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
How do D–SNAP non-financial
eligibility criteria differ from SNAP?
Eligibility criteria vary depending
upon the disaster, the demographics of
the affected jurisdictions and States’ D–
SNAP requests. FNS has exercised its
disaster authority to waive SNAP
eligibility restrictions, streamline States’
D–SNAP operations and ensure that
families in the affected areas are served
as efficiently as possible.
How is the allotment calculated in D–
SNAP?
D–SNAP provides a full month’s
allotment to disaster affected
households who may not normally
qualify for or participate in SNAP. The
allotment for a household is equal to the
maximum monthly allotment for the
household size provided under SNAP.
D–SNAP allotments are updated
yearly and available on the FNS Web
site. In order to serve disaster affected
households already participating in
SNAP and residing in areas approved to
operate a D–SNAP, States may
supplement the SNAP benefit up to the
maximum allotment for the household
size.
What is the D–SNAP ‘‘Application
Period’’?
The Department proposes that States
may only accept applications for D–
SNAP benefits from households not
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
participating in SNAP and requests for
supplements only from households
currently certified in SNAP during the
approved application period. FNS has
generally approved application periods
of 7 consecutive days (business days at
the State’s option), though States have
the option to request more or fewer days
in the D–SNAP request. FNS proposes
to continue with this approach. The
State should also inform FNS, as part of
the D–SNAP request, whether
applications will be accepted on
Saturday and/or Sunday. If the State is
accepting requests for supplements from
households currently certified in SNAP
over the phone and mailing the forms to
the household, the required affidavit
attesting to the loss of food purchased
with SNAP benefits must requested
during the application period.
What is a D–SNAP ‘‘Benefit Period’’?
The Department proposes that the
benefit period be a 30-day period
approved by FNS for each D–SNAP. The
benefit period is the period during
which disaster-related expenses are to
be counted; the start date is used to
determine household composition and
resources. Only income received,
expenses incurred and resources that
are accessible during the benefit period
are considered in determining D–SNAP
eligibility. The benefit period begins on
the first date of the disaster generally
referred to as the ‘‘Incident Period’’
identified in the Presidential Disaster
Declaration.
Can the Application and Benefit Periods
be modified?
The Department proposes that any
modifications to a D–SNAP be approved
by FNS in writing. For example, if a
State agency determines that the initial
benefit period requested is not
appropriate, it may request a
modification of the benefit period start/
end dates. This could, for example,
accommodate disaster related expenses
incurred in preparation for the disaster.
However, once the application period
has commenced the benefit period
could not be changed. Doing so would
introduce unnecessary complexity and
potential inequity into the D–SNAP.
If demand for D–SNAP benefits
increases or remains high during the
initially approved application period,
FNS may consider a State’s request for
an extension of the application period.
States requesting an extension should
address the ongoing demand for
assistance and any program integrity
concerns in their request.
PO 00000
Frm 00006
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
28741
What are the basic eligibility criteria for
D–SNAP?
To be eligible for D–SNAP, the
Department proposes that an applicant
household must first meet basic criteria,
including: (1) Residency; (2) Household
Composition; (3) Adverse effects due to
the disaster; and (4) Income
requirements.
How is residency determined?
Under this proposed rule, the
household must have lived in the
disaster area at the time of the disaster.
However, States may also choose to
extend eligibility to those who worked
in the disaster area at the time of the
disaster. When submitting their D–
SNAP requests, States should specify if
they will serve households that (a) lived
in the disaster area, or (b) lived or
worked in the disaster area.
How is household composition
established?
The Department proposes that D–
SNAP household composition be
established based upon persons who
live, purchase food, and prepare meals
together on the date of the first day of
the disaster benefit period, which will
be considered to be the earliest date that
households are in need. This
rulemaking proposes that the benefit
period begin on the date of the disaster
or the date of any mandatory evacuation
preceding the disaster.
What is an adverse effect?
The Department proposes that
disaster-related adverse effects include
three categories:
Æ Loss or inaccessibility of income
involving a reduction or termination of
income, or a significant delay in receipt
of income.
Æ Inaccessibility of liquid resources,
including situations in which the
household is unable to access cash
resources for a portion of the disaster
benefit period.
Æ Disaster related expenses that the
household has incurred during the
disaster benefit period that result from
the effects of the disaster.
The FNS Disaster SNAP Guidance
provides specific expenses that shall be
considered disaster related, and States
can propose other reasonable expenses
in their disaster request.
How is household income dealt with for
D–SNAP?
The Department proposes that the
income of households that meet the
residency, household composition and
adverse effect criteria be measured
against the D–SNAP gross income limit
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
28742
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
(DGIL) in order to determine eligibility.
The DGIL is explained below.
Unlike SNAP, which includes
separate tests for income and resources,
the Department proposes that D–SNAP
would group income and resources
together under one test. This is the
method that is already being used in D–
SNAP. To determine a household’s D–
SNAP income:
• Add all income received or
expected to be received during the
benefit period to accessible liquid
resources (liquid resources include cash
on hand, and funds in accessible
checking and saving accounts on the
first day of the benefit period);
• Subtract the value of unreimbursed
disaster related expenses incurred
during the disaster benefit period from
the income/liquid resource amount (any
reimbursements received or anticipated
to be received by the household during
the benefit period, including insurance
and FEMA payments would reduce the
allowable disaster-related expense
amount); and
• Compare the result compared to the
DGIL and if it is less than or equal to
the DGIL, the household would be
eligible for D–SNAP benefits.
What is the Department proposing to
include as D–SNAP income?
The Department proposes that D–
SNAP income would be the net (takehome) pay of all household members
during the benefit period, including:
• Wages a household actually
receives after taxes and all other payroll
withholding (including contributions to
401(k) or other inaccessible accounts,
automatic payments to creditors, etc.);
• Public assistance payments or other
unearned income; and
• Net self-employment income.
As determined by the State agency,
income that has been delayed for a
substantial portion of the benefit period
due to the disaster would be considered
inaccessible.
For example, household X consists of
four people who are not currently
participating in SNAP. Their household
was impacted by the disaster and they
apply for D–SNAP. One individual is
employed and receives monthly takehome pay of $1200, after payroll taxes
and health insurance premium are taken
out. The other individual receives $850
in TANF benefits each month. The
household’s total income for D–SNAP
purposes is $1200 + $850 = $2050.
What is the Department proposing to
exclude as D–SNAP resources?
The Department proposes that the
following be deemed as not accessible
liquid resources:
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
• Retirement accounts;
• Disaster insurance payments;
• Disaster assistance received or
expected to be received during the
benefit period; and
• Payments from Federal, state or
county/local government agencies or
disaster assistance organizations
(including disaster-related
Unemployment Compensation).
Inaccessible liquid resources would
also include otherwise liquid resources
that are temporarily inaccessible (for
instance, because a bank with a
household’s certificate of deposit is
closed due to the disaster) during the
benefit period. In the Department’s
experience, this is an infrequent
occurrence, as households can usually
access their resources via online
banking or ATMs even if bank branches
are closed in the affected area. For
example, on the day the disaster struck,
household X had $50 in cash, and $250
in its checking account, with an
additional $300 in a savings account.
The funds in these accounts are
accessible. The household has applied
for FEMA assistance for the property
damage it incurred. The household’s
total accessible liquid resources are $50
+ $250 + $300 = $600, since the FEMA
assistance will not be received before
the benefit period ends. Their
household’s total accessible liquid
resources are $50 + $250 + $300 = $600.
How is the DGIL calculated?
The Department proposes to calculate
each year’s disaster gross income limit
by adding together the SNAP maximum
monthly net income limit, the SNAP
maximum standard income deduction
amount, and the SNAP maximum
capped shelter expense deduction for
each household size. Together, these
amounts establish a simplified process
to determine if households are in need
of assistance that is grounded in the
SNAP income methodology and
standards for determining eligibility.
For household X in the above examples,
the total D–SNAP ‘‘income’’ of $2650
($2050 + $600), would be compared to
the DGIL for a household of four to
determine eligibility for D–SNAP.
How is the requirement that households
purchase food applied?
The Department proposes that, to be
eligible, households must either plan on
purchasing food during the disaster
benefit period, or have already
purchased food during the benefit
period. This would clearly apply to
most households, other than with very
large disasters where households may
remain in shelters and be served
PO 00000
Frm 00007
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
through congregate feeding throughout
the benefit period.
What are disaster-related expenses?
These are expenses that the
household has incurred during the
disaster benefit period due to the
disaster. Eligible expenses would
include the following, plus any other
reasonable disaster-related expenses
determined by the State agency:
• Home or business repairs
• Temporary shelter expenses
• Evacuation expenses
• Home/business property protection
• Medical expenses due to personal
injury
• Disaster-related funeral expenses
• Expenses related to replacing
necessary personal and household
items, such as clothing, appliances,
tools, and educational materials
• Fuel for primary heating source
• Clean-up items expense
• Disaster-damaged vehicle expenses
• Storage expenses
• Food lost in the disaster
Are all disaster-related expenses
deductible?
In the past, all of the above expenses
would be deductible if they have been
or are anticipated be paid during the
benefit period unless the household
receives or anticipates receiving a
reimbursement for these expenses
during the benefit period, in which case
only any remaining obligation expense
is deductible. The Department’s practice
to date has been only to allow a
deduction for expenses which are paid
during the benefit period. Consequently,
bills paid by credit card or other
payments over time have not been
allowed as deductions. The Department
is now proposing to allow deductions
for expenses that are incurred during
the benefit period even if those
expenses will be paid after the benefit
period. The Department believes that
this policy would be more equitable
since households that incur similar
disaster related expenses should not be
treated differently simply because they
pay using a credit card instead of cash
or a check. The Department is interested
in receiving comments on this proposed
change.
What options do States have in
determining deductions?
In conjunction with the options
discussed below, the Department
proposes that States may also choose to
consider households that have
experienced food loss as their only
disaster-related expense to be eligible
for the D–SNAP. The State would use
available information such as power
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
outage maps showing affected homes or
zip codes to determine if allowing
eligibility based upon food-loss alone is
appropriate. Households reporting
excessively large amounts of food loss,
or any other questionable information,
would be referred to fraud investigators
or senior staff for further review.
This proposed rule would provide
States the following two options in
determining if households have
disaster-related expenses and the
amount of the expense to use in
determining D–SNAP income. The
option selected would be identified in
the State’s D–SNAP request.
• Use of the disaster-related expenses
identified above and in the FNS Disaster
SNAP Guidance. Under this option,
states may choose to have food-loss only
or food loss plus one additional disaster
related expense in order to be eligible.
• Use of a Disaster Standard Expense
Deduction (DSED). For households with
$100 or more in deductible disasterrelated expenses (including food loss),
the DSED would be added to the
disaster gross income limit and
households whose take-home pay plus
available liquid resources is less than or
equal to this amount (DSED+DISASTER
GROSS INCOME LIMIT) would qualify
for D–SNAP benefits. Because the DSED
is designed to capture food loss along
with other disaster-related expenses,
such as loss of income and damage to
or destruction of property, as noted
earlier, it could not be applied to cases
in which food loss is the only disasterrelated expense.
The DSED that has been used by
several States is based upon information
gathered from actual disaster-related
expenses reported in a prior D–SNAP.
As proposed in this rulemaking, only
households with actual, unreimbursed
disaster-related expenses equal to or
greater than $100 would qualify for the
DSED. Households with deductible
disaster-related expenses that fall below
the $100 threshold would have their
eligibility determined using their actual
expenses. If a household has disaster
expenses which exceed the DSED for its
size, the State may, at its option, use
actual expenses to determine eligibility.
How is food loss in a disaster addressed
in the proposed rule?
The Department proposes that the loss
of food due to the disaster be considered
a disaster-related expense and that
including ‘‘food loss alone’’ as a
criterion for eligibility be optional and
be addressed in the D–SNAP request to
FNS. It is important to note that
households currently certified in SNAP
can always request the replacement of
lost food that was purchased with their
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
SNAP benefits under standard SNAP
rules. Food lost or spoiled due to the
disaster or extended power outage is
always considered a disaster expense.
What verification is required in a D–
SNAP?
The Department proposes that
verification rules be eased (relative to
SNAP) to reduce administrative burdens
and to reflect the reality that due to the
nature of a disaster, households and
eligibility workers may not have access
to usual verification sources. Proposed
verification requirements for D–SNAP
in the proposed rule are three-tiered:
• Identity must be verified;
• Verification of residency and
household composition must be
attempted in all cases, and must be
pursued if questionable; and
• Loss/inaccessibility of income or
liquid resources and food loss must be
verified if questionable.
Such verification shall be performed
in accordance with the requirements at
7 CFR 273.2(f).
What requirements are proposed
regarding duplicate participation
The Department proposes that States
check for duplicate information up front
or accept applications and inform
applicants that eligibility is contingent
upon a subsequent duplicate check.
States would be required to screen all
household members for duplicate
participation in:
• D–SNAP and SNAP
• D–SNAP and disaster commodity
food assistance
• Multiple D–SNAPs with overlapping
benefit periods
• Approved D–SNAP and denied D–
SNAP applicants (to identify
attempted duplicate participation)
Disaster Plan
What does the rule propose requiring in
States’ disaster plans?
The Department proposes in
§ 280.1(b) that the State Disaster Plan
must include the following information:
• Agencies and Responsibilities. This
would identify State and Federal
government agencies with
responsibilities for disaster assistance,
including a description of
responsibilities for each agency.
• Points of Contact. This would
provide names, positions, and phone
numbers of county/local, State and
Federal government officials, and their
back-ups, who are key contact persons
during a disaster (including the State
agency disaster coordinator).
• Community Partners and Roles.
This would identify private disaster
PO 00000
Frm 00008
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
28743
relief agencies within the State, such as
the Red Cross, Salvation Army, or
community groups, and a description of
their roles in D–SNAP implementation.
• Staffing and Resources. This would
identify staffing and related resources
available to assist in a disaster, and how
they will be mobilized to target disaster
areas in need. It would also explain how
the State/counties will manage the
increased administrative burden
associated with running a D–SNAP and
SNAP operations simultaneously.
• Application System. This would
describe application systems to be used
for D–SNAP household management,
including any workarounds to the SNAP
system, considerations associated with
running SNAP and D–SNAP operations
concurrently, compliance with D–SNAP
reporting requirements, etc.
• Issuance System. This would
describe benefit issuance systems to be
used for D–SNAP household
management.
• EBT Card Stock. This would
identify EBT card stock available, type
of cards to be used, steps and timeline
for ordering additional cards, and any
special procedures or resources that will
be needed to meet SNAP and D–SNAP
issuance timeframes.
• Application Sites. This would
describe site selection procedures,
including potential application/issuance
sites for disasters that vary in size and
scope, and any agreements in place with
those locations. If D–SNAP will operate
out of local offices, it would explain
how application sites will handle
running D–SNAP and SNAP
concurrently.
• Data. This would identify general
demographic data that can help the
agency tailor its response to a disaster.
It would identify resources and contact
information for disaster impact data,
including preliminary data assessments,
flood maps, or electrical outage data.
• Public Information and Outreach.
This would describe public information
strategy to ensure that timely, accurate
information reaches eligible households.
It would outline roles, expectations, and
responsibilities of any SNAP outreach
partners included in the State Outreach
Plan that will assist with D–SNAP.
• Retailer Communication. This
would describe procedures to notify
retailers of new waivers (see discussion
of the potential for hot foods below) and
new D–SNAP households.
• Procedures to Reduce Applicant
Hardship. This would outline steps the
State will take to reduce hardship for D–
SNAP applicants and SNAP caseload,
including provisions for security,
human needs, language services,
elderly/disabled, etc.
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
28744
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
• Certification Process. This would
describe the specifics of the certification
process, including potential application
sites, staffing, separation of eligibility
and issuance, and how application sites
will manage large crowds. If online
applications are to be used by workers
or households, the plan would describe
that process and back-up systems in
place if the online system is not
available.
• Use of a DSED and the income
limits.
• Reasonable Accommodations for
Individuals with Disabilities. This
would describe what special
accommodations will be made for
individuals with disabilities at the
application and issuance sites. This
section may also include special
accommodations to provide program
access to individuals with disabilities
beyond those required at application
and issuance sites, such as
transportation services or home visits,
as determined by the State agency on a
case by case basis, but without imposing
an undue burden on the State agency.
• Household Materials. This would
include sample household application
and household notices in various
languages.
• Issuance Process. This would
describe how benefits will be made
available within 72 hours of D–SNAP
application and how to ensure
continuation of SNAP certification,
issuance, and other actions
concurrently. It would indicate how the
State will monitor stock levels and
ensure sufficient EBT card stock. It
would describe EBT card on-site or mail
issuance procedures and reconciliation,
as well as security procedures,
including how D–SNAP benefits will be
tracked separately from SNAP benefit
issuance. Plans would need to adhere to
FNS reconciliation guidelines so
benefits posted to accounts can be
compared to benefits issued by the State
eligibility system.
• Security and Fraud Prevention
Plan. This would describe how the State
will ensure security and mitigate the
risk of fraud, including a specific plan
for handling applications submitted by
State agency employees, procedures for
handling questionable applications,
process for checking all household
members for duplicate participation,
and any onsite security.
• Disaster Reporting and Post-Disaster
Review Report. This would describe
procedures to ensure that required
federal reporting and post-disaster
review report will be complete and
timely. This would include daily
reporting.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
Disaster plans should also address
any circumstances unique to the State
which may affect D–SNAP operations,
including: Coordination of resources
among County-level administrations;
serving isolated populations, the
development of ‘‘work-arounds’’ to
allow SNAP systems to accommodate
D–SNAP operations; and, contingency
plans for local offices located in flood
plains or otherwise subject to closure.
Conforming amendments are
proposed in 7 CFR 272.2(a), 272.2(d),
and 272.2(e) to acknowledge the
Disaster component of the State
agency’s overall State plan.
How often should the D–SNAP Plan be
updated?
To ensure that necessary advance
preparations are current, the
Department proposes in § 280.1(b) of
this rulemaking that State agencies be
required to review their existing
Disaster Plan on at least an annual basis
and submit a revision, if a substantive
change is being made, or a notice of no
substantive change, for FNS approval by
the 15th of August each year or another
negotiated due date approved by FNS.
As specified in § 280.8(f), State agencies
would be required to amend the plan if
deficiencies are found in a D–SNAP
post-disaster review. If plans are not
changed from the prior submissions,
States would be able to submit letters to
this affect rather that a complete plan.
What training is required related to the
D–SNAP plan?
The Department proposes that, at a
minimum, States be required to provide
D–SNAP training to management in
each SNAP local office and call center.
While FNS encourages that training be
as complete and inclusive as practical,
at least one manager (perhaps a D–
SNAP coordinator) from each SNAP
office must be included in whatever
training the State deems appropriate.
What State System requirements are
there related to D–SNAP preparations?
While there is a variety of
programming that could be in place to
be ready in preparation for a disaster
and improve operational efficiency,
each State is expected to make such
choices based upon their administrative
needs and system capabilities. The
exception to this general expectation is
that the Department proposes to require
that every State have the ability to check
for duplicate participation for all
household members, as well as conduct
reconciliation of D–SNAP benefits and
generate the reports required by this
rule. This includes being able to track
disaster benefits separately from SNAP
PO 00000
Frm 00009
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
benefit issuance. States would also need
to have a method in place to allow for
tracking of multiple D–SNAPs
simultaneously should they be struck by
two disasters within a short timeframe.
States also must adhere to FNS
reconciliation requirements so that they
can compare benefits posted to accounts
to benefits issued by the State eligibility
system.
Requesting D–SNAP
What is required in the D–SNAP
request?
The Department proposes that D–
SNAP requests be submitted with a
signed cover memorandum from the
State that includes a thorough
explanation of the components listed
below. Well-documented requests can
be considered and approved more
quickly—clearly a priority in a disaster
situation. It is proposed that each D–
SNAP request include:
• A description of the disaster—what
happened, dates it occurred, the affected
area.
• The geographic area and
explanation of any differences between
the area included in the presidential
declaration and the requested area in
which to operate the D–SNAP.
• The start and end dates of the
application period. If it will be
staggered, give dates for each county/
area. Note if application sites will be
open over the weekend or for extended
hours.
• The start and end dates of the 30day benefit period. The start of the
benefit period should generally match
the first day of the ‘‘incident period’’ on
the disaster declaration. If not, the State
should explain the reason for the
difference.
• Whether a DSED is being used and
how it is structured.
• Whether only households that lived
in the disaster area will be eligible for
D–SNAP or if households that worked
in the disaster area will also be eligible.
• Whether ‘‘food loss alone’’ will be
a criterion for eligibility.
• Whether supplements will be
automatic or individual (by affidavit of
disaster) for currently participating
SNAP households. If automatic, the
request would need to describe who is
eligible and include supporting data.
Supporting data may include but is not
limited to an estimate of the value of
issuances for automatic supplements. If
individual, the request would need to
include information on the process for
requesting supplements—by phone/mail
affidavit, electronically, or in person at
a local office/D–SNAP application site.
• The estimated total number of
people, homes, businesses, etc.,
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
impacted by the disaster, as well as
estimates of anticipated D–SNAP
applicants and number of currently
certified SNAP households expected to
be served, along with an explanation of
how the estimates were derived.
• A description of issuance
procedures, the number of EBT cards on
hand, and plans for requesting,
receiving, and distributing additional
cards as needed. The request would
need to indicate whether D–SNAP cards
can be replaced if lost or stolen.
• A description of the plans for
publicity, application sites, and
security/crowd control.
• Plans for utilizing staff from other
program areas, counties, or States, as
appropriate. The request would need to
indicate number of staff available and
how staff/supervisors will be distributed
among the application sites.
• A description of application sites,
security/crowd control, and procedures
to ensure program access and reasonable
accommodation for persons with
disabilities.
• A description of when and how
program information will be
disseminated to the public. This would
include a list of partner organizations
involved and describe the
responsibilities of each, including role
of volunteers, if applicable. It is
important that sufficient time be
allowed to notify the public prior to the
start of the program. Examples of
partner activities include providing D–
SNAP information on behalf of the State
or providing onsite application
assistance.
• A description of the fraud
prevention strategies and security
measures in place.
• A description of the recipient claim
procedures and thresholds to be
followed if they differ from regulations
at § 273.18 or the State’s FNS-approved
procedures for handling recipient
claims in SNAP.
• A description of the procedures that
will be used for identifying and
handling applications by State agency/
State employees.
• Draft press releases, sample
application, preliminary damage
assessments, and map of disaster area.
In addition to these required items,
other supporting documentation may be
included.
When should requests for D–SNAP be
submitted?
Since the purpose of D–SNAP is to
meet households’ immediate needs, the
request should be submitted to allow for
implementation of D–SNAP within a
reasonable amount of time following the
IA declaration. In addition, it should be
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
submitted to FNS at least several days
prior to the planned implementation
date to allow time for FNS review and
approval. Most importantly, the State
should allow sufficient time to
effectively publicize the availability of
D–SNAP for the affected population
prior to implementation. The
Department is interested in receiving
comments on whether there is a need to
establish a standard time frame for
submission of requests for D–SNAP
relative to the projected implementation
date.
What changes can be made to the D–
SNAP after implementation?
Sometimes, States’ approved requests
for D–SNAP need modification. As with
the initial submission, the Department
is proposing that States must submit
written, signed requests for changes to
an approved D–SNAP. These requests,
and their corresponding approvals,
would generally be approved more
quickly than the initial waiver, since
much of the information about the
disaster is already known. The three
most likely types of changes to the D–
SNAP are listed below, along with an
explanation of each.
Expansion—After initial approval, a
State may want to expand operations
because an additional county is in need
of the program. While the application
period in the expanded area may differ
from what was originally approved, the
benefit period will generally remain the
same. In such cases, the State should
submit to FNS a request for expansion,
detailing the impact of the disaster in
the new area, the application period,
and the anticipated number of
applicants and currently certified SNAP
households that will be served. If the
benefit period will change, for example,
because flooding due to the same storms
struck another County at a later date, the
new benefit period’s dates and
justification should also be included.
Extension—In some cases, States may
find that their initial application period
is not sufficient to serve all eligible
households, and so they may wish to
request that the application period be
extended. Requests to extend the D–
SNAP application period must be
submitted with sufficient time for FNS
review and approval prior to the end of
the initial application period and must
be accompanied with justification of the
need for additional time. Once the
application period has ended and
operations have closed, further
extensions would not be permitted.
Modification—A request to change an
aspect of the D–SNAP other than those
mentioned above is known as a
modification. Most modifications,
PO 00000
Frm 00010
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
28745
including any that would affect
applicant eligibility, can only be made
prior to the start of the application
period to ensure that the eligibility
criteria are applied equitably to all
applicants. Occasionally, modifications
may be made after D–SNAP operations
have begun, such as when a State that
was originally approved for individual
supplements decides to issue automatic
supplements in a certain area. Because
of the limited window of time in which
most modifications can be requested,
FNS encourages State agencies to
carefully consider their program options
prior to submitting the initial request.
Are there other waivers that must be
requested separate from the D–SNAP
request?
There are operational and policy
issues that, while are related to the
disaster situation, are not included
under the authority of the D–SNAP and
so are not addressed in this proposed
rule. The one exception is the extension
of the timeframe to report a loss and
request replacement of food purchased
with SNAP benefits as addressed below.
While this proposed rule only addresses
the waiver for Timely Reporting of Food
Loss, three additional waivers are also
discussed, for informational purposes
only, because they are the most
frequently requested and approved
relative to D–SNAP operations.
Timely Household Reporting of Food
Loss—SNAP regulations at § 274.6
require that replacement issuances be
provided to current SNAP recipients
only if a household reports a loss of
food purchased with SNAP benefits to
the State within 10 days of the date the
food is destroyed in a household
misfortune. This waiver has allowed the
State agency to extend the amount of
time households have to report the loss
of food purchased with SNAP benefits
beyond 10 days. The Department
proposes to change the reporting
timeframe for the loss of food purchased
with SNAP benefits from 10 days to 30
days when the President issues a major
disaster declaration for IA. In all other
cases, the 10-day timeframe would
remain intact.
Automatic/Mass Replacements—Per
SNAP regulations at § 274.6,
replacement benefits are available (by
affidavit) to SNAP households anytime
they experience an adverse effect
causing them to lose food purchased
with their benefits. This waiver allows
the automatic replacement of a certain
percentage of a household’s benefit
(depending on the time of the month,
the State’s benefits issuance cycle, and
the type of disaster) for all participating
households within the disaster area,
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
28746
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
without the need to submit individual
requests. This waiver may be granted
without a D–SNAP approval or IA
designation. This waiver does not
remove the responsibility of local offices
to process individual affidavits before or
after the waiver implementation as
required by § 274.6(a).
Hot Foods—A waiver of the hot foods
exclusion in the Act allows SNAP
households to purchase hot, prepared
foods at authorized retailers with their
EBT cards. FNS has the authority to
grant this waiver provided that an IA
declaration has been issued. The
coverage of this waiver may extend to
areas beyond those that received D–
SNAP approval if households that lived
in the disaster area have been displaced
or temporarily relocated to other parts of
the State.
Expunging D–SNAP benefits—State
agencies may request to use a shorter
timeframe (typically 90 days) for
expunging benefits for D–SNAP-only
households. Following the
implementation of the Food and
Nutrition Act of 2008, Pub. L. 110–246,
this waiver requires approval from FNS.
State agencies that wish to implement
this waiver must submit it along with
their D–SNAP requests. Any State
operating under this waiver must inform
D–SNAP-only households of the
timeframe for expunging benefits. This
waiver may only be used when the State
has received approval to operate a D–
SNAP and an IA declaration has been
issued. A prerequisite for this waiver is
the ability of the State automated system
to identify the disaster cases and
benefits separately from SNAP cases
(this is required for FNS reporting as
well).
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
Issuance and Reconciliation
What are the Issuance requirements in
D–SNAP?
The Department proposes to require
that each State be prepared to issue D–
SNAP benefits through its EBT system
during an emergency. As noted earlier,
EBT issuance is also proposed as a
required component of State Disaster
Plans. As such, a State’s D–SNAP
issuance plan should incorporate
procedures for:
• Ensuring that approved households
have benefits available, including EBT
cards, and Personal Identification
Numbers (PINs), and that their benefits
are available no more than 72 hours
from when the application was filed,
unless there is questionable information
on the application that requires
verification. In these latter situations the
State may extend the 72-hour time
frame for making benefits available to
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
no more than a total of seven days from
the date of application.
• Accessing sufficient card stock to
operate a D–SNAP.
• Replacing households EBT cards
that are lost in a disaster as soon as
possible but within the card
replacement timeframes required at 7
CFR 274.6(b). If the normal EBT
replacement process is to mail the
replacement card to the household’s
home, and the disaster response
requires card delivery to a disaster
issuance site or alternative address in a
non-disaster area, the State must be able
to override the EBT system.
What does the rule require regarding
replacing EBT Cards for currently
certified SNAP households?
The Department proposes that when
SNAP households lose their EBT cards
in a disaster, the EBT disaster system
design have procedures for providing
currently certified SNAP cases with
replacement cards as soon as possible,
but always within the card replacement
timeframes required at 7 CFR 274.6(b).
Specifically, current SNAP regulations
require State agencies to make
replacement EBT cards available for
pick up, or to place the card in the mail,
within two business days following
notice by the household to the State
agency that the card has been lost,
stolen or damaged. However, under a D–
SNAP situation, the Department
proposes to require State agencies to
make reasonable efforts to replace EBT
cards sooner if possible; the Department
is not requiring a specific or more
stringent timeframe for making card
replacements under D–SNAP situations
in order to provide States and their EBT
processors some flexibility in
unpredictable situations. However, the
Department also wishes to ensure that
clients receive their cards as soon as
possible under circumstances in which
the household may have not only lost
their card, but all their food as well. The
Department welcomes comments on
whether or not a more specific and
stricter card replacement timeframe
should be implemented for D–SNAP
situations.
What are the D–SNAP reconciliation
requirements?
The Department is proposing that the
State be required to develop a system for
reconciling both cards and benefits.
Cards shipped from a central location
would be required to be tracked until
distributed locally to households. Each
issuance site would be required to
maintain a beginning and ending
inventory and track new cards received,
total cards available, and cards issued.
PO 00000
Frm 00011
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
If the State assigns PINs, they must also
account for PIN mailers or envelopes to
ensure adequate security, except when
the PIN is formulated by some other
means, such as from the Primary
Account Number (which is a number on
the EBT card and encoded onto the card
to identify the State and EBT account
holder.) The State would also be
required to:
• Reconcile the number of cards setup with EBT accounts and the number
of cards issued and then research and
explain any discrepancies;
• Track D–SNAP benefits separately
from SNAP benefit issuance; and
• Adhere to FNS reconciliation
guidelines so that they can compare
benefits posted to accounts with
benefits issued by the State eligibility
system.
Currently Certified SNAP Households
How does the SNAP work during a
disaster?
The Department recognizes that SNAP
households will often need replacement
benefits or supplements. As noted
earlier in the discussion of the D–SNAP
request, currently certified SNAP
households are not eligible for D–SNAP,
but those affected by the disaster are
generally eligible for a supplemental
issuance.
What are supplements?
Supplements are additional benefits
issued to SNAP households affected by
the disaster in amounts that bring the
households’ benefit level up to the
maximum allotment for their household
size. Supplemental benefits provide
parity between new D–SNAP
households and SNAP households. By
virtue of their participation in SNAP,
the food needs of SNAP households are
already known. The request to issue
individual or automatic supplements
(see below), and the supporting
justification, must be included in the
State’s D–SNAP request. By addressing
the needs for SNAP households
immediately, and prior to the start of D–
SNAP operations, overcrowding of
SNAP participants seeking service at D–
SNAP locations can be minimized.
What is the difference between
individual and automatic supplements?
Under this proposed rule, the State
agency must decide if it is most
appropriate to issue supplemental
benefits on an individual basis, via the
filing of an affidavit by the household,
or automatically, to all currently
certified SNAP households in a
designated area. To obtain an individual
supplement, households are required to
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
complete an affidavit of disaster impact.
For this reason, individual supplements
work best in areas where there is a
small-scale disaster and applicant
volume is not anticipated being very
high. For individual supplements to be
effective, the State agency must have the
capacity to handle the individual
requests for supplements, and issue the
supplemental benefits, while it is also
taking D–SNAP applications.
Automatic supplements are additional
benefits issued to all currently certified
SNAP households in a defined
geographic area and are appropriate
when the majority of that area is
impacted by a disaster. They are
intended to help SNAP households deal
with the impact of the disaster and
generally work best when the State
agency is able to clearly identify areas
in which households share the adverse
effects of the disaster, such as the loss
of electrical power. Automatic issuance
can help the State agency quickly and
efficiently meet the needs of SNAP
households, while freeing up staff and
resources to direct toward the
population of new D–SNAP applicants.
The Department is proposing that
States include their desire to issue
automatic supplements in their D–
SNAP requests and demonstrate their
ability to effectively target the benefits
to geographic areas that were heavily
impacted by the disaster. Any SNAP
households not designated to receive
automatic supplements, that were living
in the area approved to operate D–SNAP
and experienced disaster losses, may
still request supplemental benefits via
an affidavit of disaster. As with
replacements benefits (discussed
below), requests for automatic
supplements must be accompanied by
supporting data which indicates that a
majority of the population in a given
area has suffered an adverse effect as a
result of the disaster. States should work
closely with FNS to determine how to
best find, use and evaluate available
information in a post-disaster situation.
This can include information from
power companies, flood maps, or FEMA
assessments.
Can already certified SNAP households
obtain replacement benefits?
Replacement benefits are always
available on an individual basis to
SNAP households that lose food
purchased with their benefits in a
household misfortune. However,
replacement issuances shall be provided
to current SNAP recipients only if a
household reports a loss of food
purchased with SNAP benefits orally or
in writing to the State within 10 days of
the date the food is destroyed in a
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
household misfortune. The Department
is proposing that the 10-day timeframe
to report a loss of food purchased with
SNAP benefits be extended to 30 days
when there is a major disaster declared
under 7 CFR part 280. Reports will be
considered timely if made to the State
agency within 30 days of the date the
food is destroyed. Household
misfortunes such as mass power outages
and flood and structural damage would
qualify. In all other cases, the 10-day
timeframe to report a loss of food would
remain the same.
How do automatic/mass replacements
work in D–SNAP?
As discussed earlier, the automatic/
mass replacement requires a waiver that
allows a State agency to replace a
portion/percentage of currently certified
households’ monthly SNAP allotments
in a disaster without the requirement
that a household request a replacement
individually, and travel to a local office
to sign an affidavit of disaster. With this
option/waiver, households would not
have the added burden of signing
paperwork and local offices would not
have to process cases manually for each
household needing a benefit
replacement.
As with automatic supplements,
approval of the mass replacement
waiver typically requires a majority of
the residences in the disaster area
(county, zip code) to have lost power or
be in another way affected by the
disaster, resulting in the loss of food
purchased with their benefits. Outages
of four hours or more are typically
considered. The replacement percentage
is not fixed and generally depends on
the time of the month in which the
disaster took place as well as the State’s
issuance schedule. The extent and type
of disaster (e.g., flooding or power
outages), perishables/non-perishables,
and consumption, are also factors in
determining the percentage of benefits
to be replaced. In preparing requests for
mass replacements, States need to assess
the extent of the losses and provide
justification for the percentage they
request. Further, a mass replacement
waiver does not remove the
responsibility of local offices to process
individual affidavits before or after the
waiver implementation as required by 7
CFR 274.6(a).
Reporting
What does the proposed rule require in
the daily reports?
The Department proposes that States
operating a D–SNAP submit a daily
report to FNS. Daily reports are used to
monitor progress, troubleshoot problem
PO 00000
Frm 00012
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
28747
areas, inform FNS policy officials,
ensure that adequate funds are available
in States’ letters of credit and provide
information to allow responses to
inquiries from the media and other
government agencies. The State agency
would be required to begin submitting
reports on the day following the first
day of D–SNAP operations and continue
submitting the reports on a daily basis
until all applications are processed. FNS
is proposing that all States utilize a
daily reporting template provided by
FNS in its D–SNAP guidance. Data
would be submitted by county, as
indicated in the template provided in
FNS’ D–SNAP guidance. The reports
would contain:
1. Number of D–SNAP applications
received
2. Number of new D–SNAP
households approved
3. Number of new D–SNAP persons
approved
4. Number of SNAP households
receiving supplements
5. Number of people previously
certified for SNAP approved for
supplements
6. Number of new D–SNAP
households denied
7. Number of SNAP households
receiving replacement issuance
8. Value of new D–SNAP benefits
approved
9. Value of SNAP supplements
approved
10. Value of SNAP replacement
issuance
11. Average benefit per new D–SNAP
household
12. Average benefit per SNAP
household
13. Any additional information the
State believes FNS should be aware of
In addition to the quantitative data
above, the inclusion of any qualitative
information on challenges the State may
have encountered with the daily reports
will help keep State and Federal
policymakers up to date on the situation
on the ground.
What other D–SNAP reports does the
proposed rule require?
In addition to the daily report, the
Department proposes that the following
be required from States with approved
D–SNAPs:
Form FNS–292B, Report of
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance
Program Benefit Issuance for Disaster
Relief—Within 45 days of the
termination of a D–SNAP operation, the
State agency would be required to
submit its final disaster figures on form
FNS–292B. All reports would be
submitted electronically in the Food
Programs Reporting System (FPRS).
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
28748
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
Form FNS 292B would contain the
following issuance data for D–SNAP
operations:
• Number of new households issued
D–SNAP benefits
• Total number of new persons issued
D–SNAP benefits
• Number of households certified in
SNAP that were issued supplements
• Total value of benefits issued to D–
SNAP households and supplements
issued to SNAP households.
The FNS–292B report would not
include the value of any replacements
issued. States would report the value of
replacements on the FNS 388 Monthly
Issuance Report.
Form FNS–388, Monthly Issuance
Report—Form FNS–388 would reflect
disaster issuance and participation
figures, including replacement benefits.
Replacement benefits should be
reported for the month for which they
are intended.
Form FNS–209, Status of Claims
Against Households Report—In the
remarks section of the FNS–209, State
agencies would be required to indicate
the number of D–SNAP claims
established and collected. D–SNAP
claims must be identified on backup
documentation in accounting systems
for form FNS–209.
• Form FNS–46, Issuance
Reconciliation Report—States would be
required to report D–SNAP issuance and
returns in the Issuance and Returns
section of form FNS–46. Forms FNS–46
and FNS–388 should reconcile with the
reported net issuance.
Post-disaster Report—The Department
is proposing that a post-disaster review
report be required and that it be
comprised of four parts: Comprehensive
review, individual case reviews,
problem analysis, and proposed
improvements to the disaster plan. The
comprehensive review should begin
with an overview of the D–SNAP
operation, including where and when it
took place, how it was staffed, and the
total number of applications approved
and amount of benefits issued. The State
should then describe the systems or
methods employed, document any
major issues (i.e. problems or
challenges) encountered in any of the
areas below, and discuss the
interventions used to address those
issues.
• Certification systems
• Fraud control
• Issuance
• Public information and outreach
• Program accessibility
• Security
The Department is proposing that
individual case reviews include: A
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
sample of approved D–SNAP cases; a
sample of actions taken to deny
applications for D–SNAP benefits; and a
review of all approved applications for
State agency employees. The review of
approved cases would include: A case
record review; an interview with the
participant; verification of each element
of eligibility for the State’s D–SNAP
program including identity, residency,
income, household size and disaster
related expenses; a determination of
eligibility for disaster assistance; and an
analysis of errors.
The Department proposes that States
with 10,000 or more approved D–SNAP
households (excluding State employees)
select a sample of 400 approved cases
for review. States with less than 10,000
but more than 300 approved D–SNAP
households would select a sample of
between 300 and 400 cases as shown
below. States with 300 or fewer
households would review all cases.
Approved D–SNAP
households (N)
10,000 and over ........
300 to 9,999 ..............
Under 300 .................
Minimum sample size
(n)
n = 400.
n = 300 + [0. 01031
(N¥300)].
n = all cases.
The Department is proposing that a
sample of 100 denied D–SNAP
applications be reviewed to identify
errors made in not providing benefits to
eligible households. If there are fewer
than 100 denied applications, all denied
applications would be reviewed.
Finally, the Department is proposing
that States be required to review 100
percent of all State agency employee
applications—approved and denied.
For all three types of case reviews, no
cases would be dropped from the review
results for any reason and the State
would be required to report information
gathered from all case reviews.
State agencies would be required to
submit the post disaster report
containing the results of the reviews, the
problem analysis, and proposed
improvements (that would be included
in their next D–SNAP plan submission)
within 6 months of the close of each D–
SNAP operation.
Integrity
Along with the duplicate
participation and verification discussed
above, the Department proposes that
additional safeguards should be built
into D–SNAP operations.
What does the proposed rule require
regarding fraud prevention?
An important aspect of fraud
prevention is appropriate internal
controls. To ensure that only eligible
PO 00000
Frm 00013
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
households receive benefits and that the
amount of benefits issued is accurate,
the Department is proposing that States
operating a D–SNAP be required to:
• Input information for all household
members into the eligibility
determination system to prevent
individuals from obtaining benefits as a
member of more than one household.
• Input denied applications into the
eligibility determination system each
day, so that households that are denied
and later reapply are detected and
referred to fraud prevention staff. Note
that such households may be eligible if
their circumstances have changed.
• Check for duplicate participation by
any individual applying for D–SNAP
using onsite or offsite computer
databases (or in disasters with very few
applicants, hardcopy participant lists).
Update computer database participant
lists every day.
• Refer households without required
verification or with inconsistent
information to onsite investigators or
highly-experienced staff for review.
What does the proposed rule require
concerning employee fraud?
The Department recognizes that State
agency employees may be legitimately
eligible for D–SNAP benefits. States
should take care to balance
encouragement of eligible employees to
apply for program benefits with the risk
of employee fraud. The Department
proposes that States be required to take
these special measures to prevent
employee fraud:
• Use separation of duties for
certification and issuance.
• Include a question on the D–SNAP
application asking if anyone in the
household (or its authorized
representative) is employed by the State,
State SNAP agency, or County, if
applicable.
• Utilize supervisors or investigators
to conduct employee certification
interviews.
• Audit all State agency employee
applications and publicize that policy.
The proposed rule would require the
State to review all applications from its
employees and to communicate that to
employees up front.
Are D–SNAP cases subject to quality
control (QC) reviews?
Since the rules governing the
determination of D–SNAP benefits differ
significantly from the SNAP, D–SNAP
cases are not subject to QC review and
are not included when determining
SNAP timeliness and payment accuracy
rates. This is specified in 7CFR 275.11(f)
(1). This is why the Department is
proposing that States be required to
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
conduct a comprehensive review of
general program performance and
reviews of individual cases.
What are the D–SNAP recipient claims
collection requirements?
The Department is proposing that if a
household receives D–SNAP benefits to
which it was not entitled, the State
agency must establish a claim against
the household consistent with the
claims collection requirements of SNAP
regulations. Claims must be established
as soon as possible after the close of the
disaster operation. States may also
either follow their FNS-approved
procedures and thresholds for
establishing claims in SNAP for claims
arising from D–SNAP, or include
alternate procedures or thresholds in
their D–SNAP request.
If a claim is established against a
household for an overpayment of SNAP
benefits, the Department proposes that
this amount may not be collected from
the D–SNAP allotment. However, claims
based upon D–SNAP over-issuances can
be collected through a repayment
agreement or through offsets against
SNAP issuances.
D–SNAP Close Out
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
What happens after D–SNAP operations
end?
The Department proposes that close
out of D–SNAP Operations includes the
following:
• Close out the D–SNAP application/
issuance sites;
• Transition eligible cases to SNAP;
• Submit issuance reporting and
reconciliation;
• Pursue fair hearings, claims and
restored benefits; and
• Submit post-disaster report.
What are the fair hearings requirements
in a D–SNAP?
The proposed rule would require that:
• Any household who applied for D–
SNAP benefits and was denied benefits
may request a fair hearing;
• A household which has requested a
fair hearing is entitled to an immediate
onsite supervisory review;
• Households not satisfied with the
outcome of this review retain the right
to request a fair hearing through the
normal process; and
• The number of fair hearings is
reported on form FNS–366B, Program
Activity Statement.
Are households entitled to restored
benefits in D–SNAP?
SNAP regulations require State
agencies to issue restored benefits to
households when benefits were lost due
to an agency error and when a denial of
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
benefits is subsequently reversed. The
Department proposes that this
requirement also apply to D–SNAP
benefits; State agencies should follow
their normal procedures for issuance in
such cases. The State’s eligibility system
must clearly indicate that an issuance
was a restored D–SNAP benefit.
Executive Order 12866 and Executive
Order 13563
Executive Orders 12866 and 13563
direct agencies to assess all costs and
benefits of available regulatory
alternatives and, if regulation is
necessary, to select regulatory
approaches that maximize net benefits
(including potential economic,
environmental, public health and safety
effects, distributive impacts, and
equity). Executive Order 13563
emphasizes the importance of
quantifying both costs and benefits, of
reducing costs, of harmonizing rules,
and of promoting flexibility.
This proposed rule has been
designated a not significant regulatory
action. Accordingly, the rule has not
been reviewed by the Office of
Management and Budget.
Regulatory Impact Analysis
This proposed rule has been
designated as not significant by OMB,
therefore, no Regulatory Impact
Analysis is required.
Regulatory Flexibility Act
The Regulatory Flexibility Act (5
U.S.C. 601–612) requires Agencies to
analyze the impact of rulemaking on
small entities and consider alternatives
that would minimize any significant
impacts on small entities. Pursuant to
that review, FNS Administrator, Audrey
Rowe, has certified that this proposed
rule would not have a significant impact
on small entities. State agencies that
administer SNAP will be affected to the
extent they choose to implement major
changes in program operations. State
agencies will also be affected to the
extent they perform ME reviews of large,
medium and small project areas.
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act
Title II of the Unfunded Mandates
Reform Act of 1995 (UMRA), Public
Law 104–4, establishes requirements for
Federal agencies to assess the effects of
their regulatory actions on State, local
and tribal governments and the private
sector. Under section 202 of the UMRA,
the Department generally must prepare
a written statement, including a cost
benefit analysis, for proposed and final
rules with ‘‘Federal mandates’’ that may
result in expenditures by State, local or
tribal governments, in the aggregate, or
PO 00000
Frm 00014
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
28749
the private sector, of $146 million or
more (when adjusted for 2015 inflation;
GDP deflator source: Table 1.1.9 at
https://www.bea.gov/iTable) in any one
year. When such a statement is needed
for a rule, Section 205 of the UMRA
generally requires the Department to
identify and consider a reasonable
number of regulatory alternatives and
adopt the most cost effective or least
burdensome alternative that achieves
the objectives of the rule.
This rule does not contain Federal
mandates (under the regulatory
provisions of Title II of the UMRA) for
State, local and Tribal governments or
the private sector of $146 million or
more in any one year. Thus, the rule is
not subject to the requirements of
sections 202 and 205 of the UMRA.
Executive Order 12372
SNAP is listed in the Catalog of
Federal Domestic Assistance under No.
10.551. For the reasons set forth in the
final rule in 7 CFR part 3015, subpart V
and related notice (48 FR 29115, June
24, 1983), this Program is excluded from
the scope of Executive Order 12372,
which requires intergovernmental
consultation with State and local
officials.
Federalism Impact Statement
Executive Order 13132 requires
Federal agencies to consider the impact
of their regulatory actions on State and
local governments. Where such actions
have federalism implications, agencies
are directed to provide a statement for
inclusion in the preamble to the
regulations describing the agency’s
considerations in terms of the three
categories called for under section
(6)(b)(2)(B) of Executive Order 13132.
FNS has considered the impact of this
rule on State and local governments and
has determined that this rule does not
have federalism implications. This
proposed rule does not impose
substantial or direct compliance costs
on State and local governments.
Therefore, under Section 6(b) of the
Executive order, a federalism summary
impact statement is not required.
Prior Consultation With State Officials
While FNS did not seek direct
consultation with State officials on this
proposed rule, FNS staff works with
several different States’ staff on D–
SNAP requests and operations every
year. This has provided valuable
feedback on the need for flexibility in
program design and operations. In
addition, FNS regional offices host
periodic training meetings and review
States’ D–SNAP plans. These
interactions provide insights into the
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
28750
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
challenges States face and are reflected
in this proposed rule.
Nature of Concerns and the Need To
Issue This Rule
The primary intent of this NPRM is to
improve clarity for States in their
planning for and requests to implement
a D–SNAP. This should help ensure
timely approval of requests and
improved Federal/State coordination in
responding to disaster situations. The
NPRM is also intended to inform States
of their responsibilities in reporting and
monitoring D–SNAP. The USDA Office
of Inspector General has recommended
publication of regulations for the D–
SNAP to improve controls over D–SNAP
operations and reduce the potential for
threats to program integrity.
Extent to Which We Meet Those
Concerns
The Department believes that the
proposals in this rulemaking would
provide the necessary clarity and
structure for D–SNAP planning,
requests, and reporting while
maintaining the needed flexibility for
States. In drafting this NPRM, FNS
considered its impact on State and local
agencies. In addition, the Department is
seeking comments on those areas of
discretion and will use those comments
to inform its decision making before
issuing final regulations.
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
Executive Order 12988
This proposed rule has been reviewed
under Executive Order 12988, Civil
Justice Reform. This proposed rule,
when published as a final rule, is
intended to have preemptive effect with
respect to any State or local laws,
regulations or policies which conflict
with its provisions or which would
otherwise impede its full
implementation. This proposed rule is
not intended to have retroactive
applicability unless so specified in the
‘‘Effective Date’’ paragraph of the final
rule. Prior to any judicial challenge to
the provisions of this rulemaking or the
application of its provisions, all
applicable administrative procedures
must be exhausted.
Executive Order 13175
This proposed rule has been reviewed
in accordance with the requirements of
Executive Order 13175, ‘‘Consultation
and Coordination with Indian Tribal
Governments.’’ Executive Order 13175
requires Federal agencies to consult and
coordinate with tribes on a governmentto-government basis on policies that
have tribal implications, including
regulations, legislative comments or
proposed legislation, and other policy
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
statements or actions that have
substantial direct effects on one or more
Indian tribes, on the relationship
between the Federal Government and
Indian tribes, or on the distribution of
power and responsibilities between the
Federal Government and Indian tribes.
FNS has assessed the impact of this
proposed rule on Indian tribes and
determined that this rule does not, to
our knowledge, have Tribal implications
that require tribal consultation under
EO 13175. On February 18, 2015 the
agency held a webinar for tribal
participation and comments. During the
comment period, FNS did not receive
any comments on the proposed rule. If
a Tribe requests consultation, FNS will
work with the Office of Tribal Relations
to ensure meaningful consultation is
provided for those changes, additions
and modifications identified herein that
are not expressly mandated by Congress.
Civil Rights Impact Analysis
FNS has reviewed this proposed rule
in accordance with the Department
Regulation 4300–4, ‘‘Civil Rights Impact
Analysis,’’ to identify and address any
major civil rights impacts the rule might
have on minorities, women, and persons
with disabilities. After a careful review
of the rule’s intent and provisions, and
the characteristics of SNAP participants,
FNS has determined that an important
impact of this proposed rule will be to
help alleviate the adverse effects of
disasters on certain protected classes.
All data available to FNS indicate that
protected individuals have the same
opportunity to participate in D–SNAP as
non-protected individuals. FNS
specifically prohibits the State and local
government agencies that administer
SNAP from engaging in actions that
discriminate based on race, color,
national origin, gender, age, disability,
marital or family status (SNAP’s
nondiscrimination policy can be found
at 7 CFR 272.6 (a)). Where State
agencies have options, and they choose
to implement a certain provision, they
must implement it in such a way that it
complies with the regulations at 7 CFR
272.6.
Paperwork Reduction Act
The Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995
(44 U.S.C. Chap. 35; see 5 CFR part
1320) requires that the Office of
Management and Budget (OMB)
approve all collections of information
by a Federal agency from the public
before they can be implemented.
Respondents are not required to respond
to any collection of information unless
it displays a current valid OMB control
number. This proposed rule contains
requirements that are subject to review
PO 00000
Frm 00015
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
and approval by OMB; therefore, FNS
has submitted a new information
collection request under OMB Control
No: 0584–NEW Supplemental Nutrition
Assistance Program (SNAP): Disaster
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance
Program (D–SNAP) Plans, Procedures,
and Reports which contains the
proposed reporting burden from
adoption of the proposals in the rule, for
OMB’s review and approval. The
estimated burden for the information
collections in the proposed rulemaking
accompanying this request will be
merged into the approved OMB Control
Numbers listed in the following
sections, contingent upon OMB
approval. When the information
collection requirements have been
approved, FNS will publish a separate
action in the Federal Register
announcing OMB’s approval. The D–
SNAP certification burden for State
participation is included in the
currently approved reporting burden
under the OMB Control No. 0584–0064,
SNAP: Applications, Periodic Reports,
and Notices (expiration date: 4/30/
2016), which includes all information
collection activities associated with the
certification of participating and
applicant households. Under SNAP
regulations, States are responsible for
designing their own forms (this burden
is included in OMB No. 0584–0064 and
will not be duplicated here) including
the application for D–SNAP assistance
used by individual households. The
burden associated with Statewide D–
SNAP plans is included in the currently
approved burden for OMB Control No.
0584–0083, SNAP: Operating
Guidelines, Forms, and Waivers,
Program and Budget Summary
Statement (expiration date 04/30/2017),
which includes all the information
collection activities associated with the
preparation, review, and submission of
updated D–SNAP plans by State
agencies. The burden associated with
the submission of State agency requests
to operate a D–SNAP to FNS is included
under the currently approved burden for
OMB Control No. 0584–0336, SNAP:
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance for
Victims of Disaster (expiration date 11/
30/2015).
Comments are invited on: (a) Whether
the proposed collection of information
is necessary for the proper performance
of the functions of the agency, including
whether the information shall have
practical utility; (b) the accuracy of the
agency’s estimate of the burden of the
proposed collection of information,
including the validity of the
methodology and assumptions used; (c)
ways to enhance the quality, utility, and
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
clarity of the information to be
collected; and (d) ways to minimize the
burden of the collection of information
on those who are to respond, including
use of appropriate automated,
electronic, mechanical, or other
technological collection techniques or
other forms of information technology.
Send comments to the Office of
Information and Regulatory Affairs,
OMB, attention: Desk Officer for FNS,
Washington, DC 20503. Please also send
a copy of your comments to Sasha
Gersten-Paal, Branch Chief, Certification
Policy Branch, Food and Nutrition
Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture,
3101 Park Center Drive, Alexandria, VA
22302. For further information, or for
copies of the information collection
package, please contact Sasha GerstenPaal at the above address or via email
at Gersten-Paal@fns.usda.gov.
All responses to this notice will be
summarized and included in the request
for OMB approval. All comments will
also become a matter of public record.
These proposed changes are contingent
upon OMB approval under the
Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995.
When the information collection
requirements have been approved, FNS
will publish a separate action in the
Federal Register announcing OMB’s
approval.
Comments on the information
collection pursuant to this proposed
rule must be received by July 11, 2016.
Title: Supplemental Nutrition
Assistance Program (SNAP): Disaster
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance
Program (D–SNAP) Plans, Procedures,
and Reports.
OMB Number: 0584–NEW.
Expiration Date: N/A.
Type of Request: Information
Collection Request.
Abstract: The Disaster Relief and
Emergency Assistance Act (1974), as
amended by the Robert T. Stafford
Disaster Relief and Assistance Act
(1988) (enclosed), and Section (5)(h) of
the Food and Nutrition Act of 2008 (the
Act) provides the Secretary of
Agriculture with the authority to
establish temporary emergency
standards of eligibility for households
who are survivors of a disaster that
disrupts commercial channels of food
distribution after those channels have
been restored.
This proposed rule would establish
the requirements for planning,
requesting and monitoring D–SNAP
while maintaining State flexibility in
program design within the basic
eligibility requirements for D–SNAP.
This information collection accounts for
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
information that State agencies are
required to provide to FNS in support
of a request to operate a D–SNAP. As
this proposed rule merely codifies
practices State agencies already
perform, it will have minimal impact on
the State agency workloads.
Respondents: 53 State agencies.
Estimated Number of Responses per
Respondent: 53 annual reviews of D–
SNAP plan; 5 updates of D–SNAP plan;
9 D–SNAP requests; 45 D–SNAP daily
reports; 9 D–SNAP post-Disaster reports.
The Department is proposing in this
rulemaking that States would be
required to review their existing
Disaster Plan on at least an annual basis,
and when applicable, submit a revision
or a notice of no change, by the 15th of
August each year. As the majority of
States have already prepared disaster
plans, the Department estimates that it
will take an average of 6.58 staff hours
per State each year to review their
Disaster Plans, for a total burden of 349
hours (53 States × 1 time annually = 53
total annual response × 6.58 hours = 349
hours). The Department further
estimates that on average five of these
States will update their plans and
require an additional 2.5 hours to do so,
for an annual total of 12.5 burden hours.
Once approved by OMB, this proposed
burden will be merged with the
currently approved burden for OMB
Control No. 0584–0083, SNAP:
Operating Guidelines, Forms, and
Waivers, Program and Budget Summary
Statement (expiration date 04/30/2017),
which includes all the information
collection activities associated with the
preparation, review, and submission of
updated D–SNAP plans by State
agencies.
The number of disasters that occur
annually and the average number of
households affected by the disasters
cannot be predicted. For example,
during the period from fiscal year 2009
through fiscal year 2014, the number of
State requests for disaster programs
ranged from 3 to 23 requests per year.
However, the Department estimates an
average of 9 State agencies will submit
1 D–SNAP request per year to operate
D–SNAPs for a total annual request of
9 applications per year. A D–SNAP
request normally contains a request to
waive the normal SNAP operating
procedures and outlines the State’s
proposed procedures including:
Description of incident; geographic area;
application period; benefit period;
eligibility criteria; currently certified
SNAP households eligibility; affected
population; electronic benefit card
issuance process; logistical plans for D–
PO 00000
Frm 00016
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
28751
SNAP rollout; staffing; public
information outreach; duplicate
participation check process; fraud
prevention strategies; and employee
application procedures. It is estimated
that preparation of a request under the
proposed rule will require
approximately 10 staff hours for each
State, for a total of 90 burden hours.
Once approved by OMB, this proposed
burden will be merged with the
currently approved burden for OMB
Control No. 0584–0083, SNAP:
Operating Guidelines, Forms, and
Waivers, Program and Budget Summary
Statement (expiration date 04/30/2017).
In addition, the Department is
proposing that States operating a D–
SNAP must submit a daily report to
FNS. Daily reports are used to monitor
progress, troubleshoot problem areas,
inform FNS policy officials, ensure that
adequate funds are available, and
respond to inquiries from the media and
other government agencies. The State
agency should begin submitting reports
on the day following the first day of D–
SNAP operations and continue
submitting the reports on a daily basis
until the end of the application period—
typically five days. It is estimated that
0.5 hours will be required to prepare
each daily report. Therefore, the burden
would be 22.5 total hours for these
reports (nine disasters × five reports x
0.5 hours = 22.5). The Department
further proposes that a post-disaster
report be submitted that includes four
parts: a comprehensive review,
individual case reviews, problem
analysis, and proposed improvements. It
is estimated that this report will require
0.5 hours to complete so the total
burden for nine disaster reports would
be 4.5 hours. FNS will not require a
standardized form or specific format for
daily reports or post-disaster reports,
due to the dynamic nature of emergency
situations and the need to quickly
respond to conditions on the ground.
Once approved by OMB, this proposed
burden will be merged with the
currently approved burden for OMB
Control No. 0584–0083, SNAP:
Operating Guidelines, Forms, and
Waivers, Program and Budget Summary
Statement (expiration date 04/30/2017).
No new recordkeeping burden is
estimated.
The average burden per respondent is
summarized in the following chart, with
an estimated total annual burden of 478
hours. However as noted above, States
have been performing many of these
practices for years, so the actual new
burden would be significantly less.
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
28752
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
Section of
Regulation
280.1
280.1
280.3
280.8
280.8
Requirement or burden activity
States
responding per
year
Responses
per
respondent
Number of
responses
Hours per
response
Total burden
hours
....................
....................
....................
....................
....................
Annual review of D–SNAP Plan ........
Revision of D–SNAP plan .................
D–SNAP Request ..............................
D–SNAP Daily report .........................
D–SNAP Post Disaster Report ..........
53
5
9
9
9
1
1
1
5
1
53
5
9
45
9
6.58
2.5
10
0.5
0.5
348.7
12.5
90
22.5
4.5
Totals ............
............................................................
53
2.28
121
3.95
478
E-Government Act Compliance
FNS is committed to complying with
the E-Government Act of 2002 (Pub. L
107–347) to promote the use of the
Internet and other information
technologies that provide increased
opportunities for citizen access to
government information and services
and for other purposes.
List of Subjects
7 CFR Part 272
Alaska, Civil rights, Supplemental
Nutrition Assistance Program, Grant
programs—social programs, Penalties,
Reporting and recordkeeping
requirements, Unemployment
compensation, Wages.
7 CFR Part 274
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance
Program, Grant programs—social
programs, Reporting and recordkeeping
requirements.
7 CFR Part 280
Emergency food assistance for victims
of disasters.
For reasons set forth in the preamble,
7 CFR parts 272, 274, and 280 are
proposed to be amended as follows:
PART 272—REQUIREMENTS FOR
PARTICIPATING STATE AGENCIES
1. The authority citation for part 272
continues to read as follows:
■
Authority: 7 U.S.C. 2011–2036.
2. In § 272.2 revise paragraph (a)(2),
(d)(1)(ii), and (e)(5) to read as follows:
■
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
§ 272.2
Plan of operation.
(a) * * *
(2) Content. The basic components of
the State Plan of Operation (‘‘the Plan’’)
are the Federal/State Agreement, the
Budget Projection Statement, and the
Program Activity Statement. In addition,
certain attachments to the Plan are
specified in this section and in § 272.3.
The requirements for the basic
components and attachments are
specified in § 272.2(c) and § 272.2(d),
respectively. The Federal/State
Agreement is the legal agreement
between the State and the Department of
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
Agriculture. This Agreement is the
means by which the State elects to
operate the Supplemental Nutrition
Assistance Program and to administer
the program in accordance with the
Food and Nutrition Act of 2008 and the
FNS-approved State Plan of Operation.
The Budget Projection Statement and
Program Activity Statement provide
information on the number of actions
and amounts budgeted for various
functional areas, such as certification
and issuance. The Plan’s attachments
include the Quality Control Sample
Plan, the Disaster Plan, the Employment
and Training Plan, the optional
Nutrition Education Plan, the optional
plan for Program informational
activities directed to low-income
households, the optional plan for
intercepting Unemployment
Compensation (UC) benefits for
collecting claims for intentional
Program violations, the Systematic
Alien Verification for Entitlements
(SAVE) Plan, and the plan for the State
Income and Eligibility Verification
System. The State agency shall either
include the Workfare Plan in its State
Plan of Operation or append the
Workfare Plan to the State Plan of
Operation, as appropriate, in accordance
with § 273.22(b)(3) of this chapter. The
Workfare Plan shall be submitted
separately, in accordance with
§ 273.22(b)(1) of this chapter. The ADP/
CIS Plan is considered part of the State
Plan of Operation but is submitted
separately as prescribed under
§ 272.2(e)(8). State agencies and/or
political subdivisions selected to
operate a Simplified Application/
Standardized Benefit Project shall
include that Project’s Work Plan in the
State Plan of Operation. The Plan’s
attachments shall also include the Mail
Issuance Loss Reporting Level Plan.
*
*
*
*
*
(d) * * *
(1) * * *
(ii) Disaster Plan as required by
§ 280.1(b) of this chapter, or certification
that a previously submitted Disaster
Plan has been reviewed and remains
current;
*
*
*
*
*
PO 00000
Frm 00017
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
(e) * * *
(5) Disaster plan. State agencies shall
review their existing disaster plan on at
least an annual basis and submit a
revision, if necessary, or a notice of no
change, by the 15th of August (or as
negotiated by individual states) each
year for FNS approval.
*
*
*
*
*
PART 274—ISSUANCE AND USE OF
PROGRAM BENEFITS
3. The authority citation for part 274
continues to read as follows:
■
Authority: 7 U.S.C. 2011–2036.
4. Revise § 274.6 (a)(3)(i) to read as
follows:
■
§ 274.6 Replacement issuances and cards
to households.
(a) * * *
(3) * * *
(i) Replacement issuances shall be
provided only if a household timely
reports a loss orally or in writing. When
the loss is a Presidentially-declared
disaster (with or without individual
assistance) the report shall be
considered timely if it is made to the
State agency within 30 days of the date
food purchased with Program benefits is
destroyed in the disaster. When the loss
is the result of other household
misfortune, the report shall be
considered timely if it is made to the
State agency within 10 days of the date
food purchased with Program benefits is
destroyed.
*
*
*
*
*
PART 280—DISASTER
SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION
ASSISTANCE PROGRAM (D–SNAP)
5. Revise the part heading to read as
set out above.
■ 6. Revise part 280 to read as follows:
■
PART 280—DISASTER
SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION
ASSISTANCE PROGRAM (D–SNAP)
Sec.
280.1
280.2
280.3
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
Purpose.
Eligibility and benefits.
Disaster request.
10MYP1
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
280.4 Application processing and
certification periods.
280.5 Households participating in the
SNAP when D–SNAP is operating.
280.6 Reconciliation.
280.7 Post disaster review and corrections.
280.8 D–SNAP reporting.
Authority: 7 U.S.C. 2011–2036.
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
§ 280.1
Purpose.
(a) This section establishes the
requirements for planning, requesting,
operating, and reporting on a D–SNAP.
In addition, the appropriate Food and
Nutrition Service directives and
guidance provide additional detail and
direction on the steps States should take
to prepare for an emergency situation,
and the procedures States should
employ in operating D–SNAP.
(b) Planning for D–SNAP. State
agencies shall review their existing
disaster plan on at least an annual basis
and submit a revision, if necessary, or
a notice of no change, by the 15th of
August (or as negotiated by individual
states) each year for FNS approval; this
submission shall be an attachment of
the Plan of Operation as provided in
§ 272.2 of this chapter. As specified in
§ 280.8(f), FNS will require State
agencies to amend the plan if
deficiencies are found in a D–SNAP
post-disaster review. The plan shall
include:
(1) Identification of Federal and State
government agencies involved in
disaster relief activities in the State
during a disaster, as well as a
description of responsibilities for each
agency.
(2) Key points of contact. Provide
names, positions, and phone numbers of
county/local, State, and Federal
government officials and their back-ups
who are key contact persons during a
disaster (including the State agency
disaster coordinator).
(3) Community partners. Identify
private disaster relief agencies within
the State such as the Red Cross,
Salvation Army, or community groups
and a description of their role in D–
SNAP implementation.
(4) SNAP staffing and resources.
Identify staffing and related resources
available to assist in a disaster and how
they will be mobilized to target disaster
areas in need. Explain how the State/
counties will manage the increased
administrative burden associated with
running a D–SNAP and SNAP
operations simultaneously.
(5) D–SNAP application system
development. Describe application
systems to be used for D–SNAP
household management, including any
workarounds to the SNAP system,
considerations associated with running
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
SNAP and D–SNAP operations
concurrently, compliance with D–SNAP
reporting requirements, etc.
(6) Issuance system. Describe the
issuance systems to be used for D–SNAP
household management.
(7) EBT card stock. Identify EBT card
stock available, type of cards to be used,
steps and timeline for ordering
additional cards, and any special
procedures or resources that will be
needed to meet SNAP and D–SNAP
issuance timeframes, including having
cards available at D–SNAP certification
sites.
(8) Application sites. Describe site
selection procedures, including
potential application/issuance sites for
disasters that vary in size and scope and
any agreements in place with those
locations. If D–SNAP will operate out of
local offices, explain how application
sites will handle running D–SNAP and
SNAP concurrently.
(9) Demographic data. Identify
general demographic data that can help
the agency tailor its response to a
disaster. Identify resources for disaster
impact data, including preliminary data
assessments, flood maps, or electrical
outage data.
(10) Public information and outreach.
Describe public information strategy to
ensure that timely, accurate information
reaches households potentially eligible
for D–SNAP benefits. Outline roles,
expectations, and responsibilities of any
SNAP outreach partners included in the
State Outreach Plan that will assist with
D–SNAP.
(11) Retailer communication. Describe
procedures to notify retailers of new
waivers (see discussion of the potential
for hot foods, below) and new D–SNAP
households.
(12) Procedures to reduce applicant
hardship. Outline steps States will take
to reduce hardship for D–SNAP
applicants and the already certified
SNAP caseload, including provisions for
security, human needs, language
services, etc.
(13) Certification process. Describe
the specifics of the certification process
including potential application sites,
staffing, separation of eligibility and
issuance, how application sites will
manage large crowds, and plans for
ensuring access to persons with
disabilities, the elderly and other
vulnerable populations. If online preregistrations are to be used by workers
or households, describe that process and
back-up systems in place if technical
issues are encountered.
(14) DSED. Include if the DSED will
be used and, if so, specify the income
limits.
PO 00000
Frm 00018
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
28753
(15) Household materials. Include
sample household application and
household notices.
(16) Issuance process. Describe how
benefits will be made available within
72 hours of D–SNAP application and
how to ensure continuation of SNAP
certification, issuance, and other actions
concurrently. Indicate how the State
will monitor stock levels and ensure
sufficient EBT card stock. Describe EBT
card reconciliation and security
procedures, including tracking D–SNAP
benefits separately from SNAP benefit
issuance and adherence to FNS
reconciliation guidelines, so that
benefits posted to accounts can be
compared to benefits issued by the State
eligibility system.
(17) Security and fraud prevention
plans. Describe how States will ensure
security and mitigate the risk of fraud,
including a specific plan for handling
applications submitted by State agency
employees, procedures for handling
questionable applications, and process
for checking all household members for
duplicate participation.
(18) Disaster reporting and postdisaster review report. Describe
procedures to ensure that required
federal reporting and post-disaster
review reports will be complete and
timely.
(19) Reasonable accommodations for
individuals with disabilities. Describe
what special accommodations will be
made for individuals with disabilities at
application and issuance sites.
(20) Circumstances unique to the
State which may affect D–SNAP
operations, including: coordination of
resources among County-level
administrations, how to serve isolated
or homebound populations,
development of procedural
modifications to allow SNAP systems to
accommodate D–SNAP operations, and
contingency plans for local offices
located in flood plains or otherwise
subject to closure.
(c) Training. The State shall issue
instructions and provide training to
project area offices on the handling of
disaster assistance operations to ensure
prior understanding of disaster
procedures and prompt action upon
issuance of a disaster declaration. At a
minimum, States shall provide D–SNAP
training to at least one manager (perhaps
a D–SNAP coordinator) from each SNAP
local office and call center in the State.
(d) State Systems Requirements for D–
SNAP. State automated systems shall
have the ability to:
(1) Check for duplicate participation
as required in § 280.4(e).
(2) Meet FNS reconciliation
requirements that D–SNAP benefits
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
28754
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
posted to accounts be compared to
benefits issued by the State eligibility
system.
(3) Generate the reports required in
§ 280.8. States systems shall have the
ability to track disaster benefits
separately from SNAP benefit issuance.
States systems shall have the ability to
allow tracking of multiple D–SNAPs
simultaneously, if the State is struck by
two disasters within a short timeframe.
(e) EBT Systems and D–SNAP. Each
State shall be prepared to issue D–SNAP
benefits through its EBT system during
a disaster. The EBT system shall have
the ability to coordinate with the State’s
eligibility system and the State’s EBT
contractor’s system. A State’s D–SNAP
issuance plan shall incorporate
procedures for:
(1) Ensuring that approved
households have benefits available,
including EBT cards and PINs no more
than 72 hours from when the
application was filed, unless there is
questionable information on the
application that requires verification. If
there is questionable information, the
State may extend the 72-hour time
frame for making cards and benefits
available to no more than a total of
seven days from the date of application.
(2) Accessing sufficient EBT card
stock to operate a D–SNAP.
(3) Replacing households EBT cards
that are lost in a disaster as soon as
possible but within the card
replacement timeframes required at 7
CFR 274.6(b). If the normal EBT
replacement process is to mail the
replacement card to the household’s
home, and the disaster response
requires card delivery to a disaster
issuance site or alternative address in a
non-disaster area, the State must be able
to override the EBT system.
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
§ 280.2
Eligibility and benefits.
(a) Eligibility. To be eligible for D–
SNAP during a disaster a household
must meet all of the following criteria:
(1) At the time of the disaster, the
household must have been residing
within the geographical area authorized
for disaster procedures at the time of the
disaster. Such a household may be
certified for disaster issuance even
though it presently is occupying
temporary accommodations outside of
the disaster area (although it would
need to come to the certification site to
be certified for D–SNAP). States may
also choose to extend eligibility to those
who worked in the disaster area at the
time of the disaster. When States submit
their D–SNAP requests, they should
specify if they will serve only
households that lived in the disaster
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
area, or either lived or worked in the
disaster area.
(2) The household will purchase food
and prepare meals during the disaster
benefit period. A household residing in
a temporary shelter which is providing
all its meals shall be ineligible.
(3) The household has experienced at
least one of the following adverse effects
of the disaster: loss or inaccessibility of
income, inaccessibility of liquid
resources, or disaster-related expenses.
At the State’s option, households whose
only disaster-related expense is food
loss may be considered otherwise
eligible for D–SNAP. States electing this
option must indicate it in their D–SNAP
request.
(i) Loss or inaccessibility of income
involves a reduction or termination of
income or a significant delay in receipt
of income. This could occur, for
example, if a disaster has caused a place
of employment to close or reduce its
work days, if paychecks or other
payments are lost or destroyed, if there
is a significant delay in the issuance of
paychecks, or if the work location is
inaccessible due to the disaster.
(ii) Inaccessibility of liquid resources
includes situations in which the
household is unable to access cash
resources for a portion of the disaster
benefit period.
(iii) Regarding disaster-related
expenses that the household has
incurred during the disaster benefit
period that result from the effects of the
disaster: the FNS Disaster SNAP
Guidance provides the specific expenses
that shall be considered disaster-related,
but States can request FNS approval of
other reasonable expenses in their
disaster request.
(b) Determining income. (1) To be
eligible to receive D–SNAP benefits, a
household’s net income received or
expected to be received during the
benefit period, in addition to its
accessible liquid resources, minus any
disaster-related expenses, shall not
exceed the disaster gross income limit.
(2) Accessible liquid resources are
determined on the first day of the
benefit period; any funds received
during the remainder of the benefit
period will be counted as income.
Accessible liquid resources include cash
on hand, and funds in accessible
checking and saving accounts on the
first day of the benefit period.
Accessible liquid resources do not
include:
(i) Retirement accounts;
(ii) Disaster insurance payments;
(iii) Disaster assistance received or
expected to be received during the
benefit period; and
PO 00000
Frm 00019
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
(iv) Payments from Federal, state or
county/local government agencies or
disaster assistance organizations
(including disaster-related
Unemployment Compensation).
(3) The most recent disaster gross
income limit calculated by FNS shall be
used to determine the maximum
allowable income for each household
size. The disaster gross income limit is
calculated by adding together the
maximum monthly net income limit,
the maximum standard income
deduction amount, and the maximum
capped shelter expense deduction for
each household size.
(c) D–SNAP deductions. (1) Disasterrelated expenses are deductible if they
have been incurred during the disaster
period. If the household receives or
anticipates receiving a reimbursement
for these expenses during the disaster
period, only remaining expense
amounts shall be deductible.
(2) States shall elect one of the
following options to determine if
households have disaster-related
expenses and the amount of the expense
to use in determining D–SNAP income.
The option selected shall be identified
in the State’s D–SNAP request:
(i) Use of actual disaster-related
expenses identified in the Disaster
SNAP Guidance referenced in paragraph
(a)(3)(iii) of this section. Households
shall be screened to verify their
residence in the affected area. Under
this option, the State may require that
households experience at least one
disaster-related expense other than or in
addition to food-loss in order to be
eligible for the D–SNAP, while still
considering food-loss in calculating a
household’s cumulative disaster-related
expenses. Alternatively, the State may
choose to consider households that have
experienced food loss alone as their
disaster-related expense to be otherwise
eligible for the D–SNAP.
(ii) Use of a Disaster Standard
Expense Deduction (DSED.) For
households with $100 or more in
deductible disaster-related expenses, the
DSED shall be added to the disaster
gross income limit, and households
whose take-home pay plus available
liquid resources is less than or equal to
this amount (DSED + the disaster gross
income limit) shall qualify for D–SNAP
benefits. The DSED shall not be applied
to any household if food loss is their
only disaster-related expense.
(3) A State using ‘‘food loss alone’’ in
paragraph (c)(2)(i) of this section shall
verify using available information such
as power outage maps showing affected
homes or zip codes. The use of this
information should be widely
publicized and households shall be
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
SNAP cannot respond to the temporary
food needs due to the number of
affected households.
(2) The request shall be submitted
when the affected community and State
agency have recovered to allow for an
effective administration of the D–SNAP
(as determined by the State agency),
including training for D–SNAP
operations. The request must be
submitted to allow for implementation
of D–SNAP within a reasonable time
period following the Individual
Assistance declaration. The planned
implementation date shall also allow
sufficient time for the State to publicly
notify the affected population in the
disaster area of the availability of D–
SNAP.
(b) Content of request. Requests must
be submitted with a signed cover
memorandum from the State and
include thorough explanations of the
following components:
(1) A description the disaster—what
happened, the date the disaster began,
and the affected area.
(2) The geographic area (list of the
project areas affected), and explain any
differences between the area included in
the presidential declaration (if
applicable) and the requested area in
which to operate the D–SNAP.
(3) A draft press release, sample
application, preliminary damage
assessments, and map of disaster area.
In addition to these required items,
other supporting documentation may be
included.
(4) The start and end dates of the
application period. If the application
period will be staggered, give dates for
each county/area. Note if application
sites will be open over the weekend or
for extended hours.
(5) The start and end dates of the 30day benefit period. The start of the
benefit period should generally match
the first day of the ‘‘incident period’’ on
the disaster declaration. If not, then the
State should explain the reason for the
difference.
(6) Identification of any options the
State has chosen, including whether or
not food loss only will be a qualifying
expense, and if households that worked
but did not live in the disaster area will
be eligible.
§ 280.3 Disaster request.
(7) Whether only households that
(a) Requests for D–SNAP. (1) The State lived in the disaster area will be eligible
agency may request authorization from
for D–SNAP, or if households that only
FNS to implement temporary D–SNAP
worked in the disaster area will also be
procedures when all or part of a SNAP
eligible.
project area as defined in 7 CFR 271.2
(8) Whether a DSED is being used. If
has been struck by a disaster,
so, include the income limits.
commercial channels of food
(9) Whether ‘‘food loss alone’’ will be
distribution are available, there is a
included as a criterion for eligibility.
(10) Whether supplements will be
Presidentially-declared disaster that
includes Individual Assistance (IA), and automatic or individual (by affidavit) for
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
screened upon arrival to verify their
residence in the affected area.
Households reporting excessively large
amounts of food loss, or any other
questionable information, shall be
referred to fraud investigators or senior
staff for further review.
(d) Benefit period and benefit amount.
(1) Households meeting the eligibility
criteria in § 280.2(a) through (c) shall
receive the full SNAP allotment for their
household size as provided under
SNAP. SNAP allotments are updated
yearly and available on the FNS Web
site. For households already on SNAP
and residing in an approved D–SNAP
area that incur a disaster-related
expense and submit an affidavit to that
effect, States shall supplement their
SNAP benefits to bring them up to the
maximum allotment for their household
size.
(2) Household size and composition is
established as of the first day of the
disaster benefit period. The household
includes those people living together,
and purchasing and preparing food
together at the time of a disaster. D–
SNAP household does not include those
people with whom applicants are
temporarily staying due to the disaster.
(3) The benefit period is the 30-day
period approved by FNS for each D–
SNAP, except in extraordinary
circumstances as determined and
approved by FNS. The benefit period is
the period during which disaster-related
expenses are to be counted; it is also the
start date used to determine household
composition and resources. Only
income received, expenses incurred and
resources that are accessible during the
benefit period are considered in
determining D–SNAP eligibility. The
benefit period shall begin on the date of
the disaster or the date of any
mandatory evacuation preceding the
disaster. This date is generally the first
day of the ‘‘Incident Period’’ provided
by the Presidential Disaster Declaration.
State agencies needing to modify dates
from those in their approved D–SNAP
request must seek FNS approval to do
so. States requesting an extension must
address the ongoing demand for
assistance and program integrity
concerns.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
PO 00000
Frm 00020
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
28755
currently certified SNAP households. If
automatic, describe who is eligible and
include supporting data. Also, indicate
an estimate of the value of issuances for
automatic supplements. Requests for
automatic supplements must be
accompanied by supporting data which
indicate that a majority of the
population in a given area has suffered
an adverse effect as a result of the
disaster. If individual supplements are
to be used, include information on the
process for requesting supplements—by
phone/mail affidavit, electronically, or
in person at local office/D–SNAP
application site.
(11) The estimated total number of
people, homes, businesses, etc.
impacted by the disaster; estimates of
anticipated D–SNAP applicants; number
of currently certified SNAP households
to be served; and explanation of how
both estimates were derived.
(12) A description of issuance
procedures, the number of EBT cards on
hand, and plans for requesting,
receiving, and distributing additional
cards as needed.
(13) A description of application sites,
security/crowd control, and procedures
to ensure program access and reasonable
accommodation for persons with
disabilities.
(14) Plans for utilizing staff from other
program areas, counties, or States, as
appropriate. Indicate number of staff
available and how staff/supervisors will
be distributed among the application
sites.
(15) A description of how program
information, including eligibility
criteria and application sites, will be
disseminated to the public. List partner
organizations involved and describe the
responsibilities of each, including role
of volunteers, if applicable. Examples of
partner activities include spreading D–
SNAP information on behalf of the State
or providing onsite application
assistance. Sufficient time shall be
allowed to notify the public prior to the
start of the program.
(16) A description of the recipient
claim procedures and thresholds to be
followed if they differ from either SNAP
regulations at § 273.18 of this chapter or
the State’s FNS approved procedures for
handling recipient claims in SNAP.
(17) A description of the procedures
that will be used for identifying and
handling applications by State agency/
State employees.
(18) A description of the fraud
prevention strategies and security
measures in place.
(c) Changes to an approved D–SNAP.
(1) When a State believes that a
modification to an approved D–SNAP
request is necessary, it shall submit a
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
28756
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
written request to change its approved
D–SNAP.
(2) Expansion of D–SNAP. To expand
the geographic coverage of an approved
D–SNAP, a State shall submit a request
to FNS for expansion, detailing the
impact of the disaster in the new area,
the application period, and the
anticipated number of applicants and
currently certified SNAP households
that will be served. If the benefit period
will also change, then the new benefit
periods dates and justification for doing
so shall also be included.
(3) Extension to a D–SNAP. In some
cases, States may find that their initial
application period is not sufficient to
serve all eligible households, and they
may wish to request that the application
period be extended. Requests to extend
the D–SNAP application period shall be
submitted to FNS with sufficient time
for it to review and approve the request
prior to the end of the initial application
period; requests shall include
justification of the need for additional
time.
(3) Other Modifications to D–SNAP.
Other modifications, including any that
would affect applicant eligibility, shall
only be made prior to the start of the
application period to ensure that the
eligibility criteria are applied equitably
to all applicants. Occasionally,
modifications may be made after D–
SNAP operations have begun, such as
when a State that was originally
approved for individual supplements
decides to issue automatic supplements
in a certain area. However, once the
application period has commenced, the
benefit period cannot be modified.
Because of the limited window of time
in which most modifications can be
requested, States should carefully
consider their program options prior to
submitting the initial request.
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
§ 280.4 Application processing and
certification periods.
(a) Period for processing applications.
(1) States shall only accept applications
for D–SNAP benefits from new
households, and requests for
supplements from currently certified
SNAP households, during the approved
application period.
(2) If the State is accepting requests
for supplements from currently certified
SNAP households over the phone and
mailing the affidavit forms to the
household, the request for an affidavit
must be received during the D–SNAP
application period.
(3) Application periods shall last 7
days, though States retain the option to
request more or fewer days as they deem
appropriate to the circumstances. The
State should provide its rationale for
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
any deviation from the 7-day
application period in its D–SNAP
request. The State should also inform
FNS, in its D–SNAP request, whether
applications will be accepted on
Saturday and/or Sunday.
(b) Interviews. (1) All D–SNAP
applicants or their authorized
representatives are required to have a
face-to-face interview. Exceptions to the
face-to-face interview shall only be
made for individuals with disabilities
that preclude visiting an application
site. States should use screening
techniques prior to the interview to
identify those households which do not
meet required eligibility criteria, such as
having been adversely affected by the
disaster. The interview shall be
conducted as an official discussion of
household circumstances; however, it
shall be designed to quickly process the
application. If an applicant household
does not meet the D–SNAP eligibility
standards, the household shall be
informed of the potential availability of
benefits under SNAP.
(2) The D–SNAP interview shall be
conducted by State agency merit system
personnel.
(3) The individual interviewed must
be a member of the household or an
authorized representative. The
household may be accompanied to the
interview by anyone of its choice. The
interviewer shall review the information
that appears on the application to
resolve unclear or incomplete
information with the household.
(c) Certification period. Households
shall be assigned certification periods
that coincide with the disaster benefit
period. If the benefit period is one
month, then income over this full
month period shall be counted, disasterrelated expenses that are incurred over
this full month period shall be
deducted, and the monthly SNAP
maximum income limit for the
appropriate household size shall equal
the disaster eligibility limit. If the
disaster benefit period is for half of a
month, then income over the half-month
period shall be counted, disaster-related
expenses incurred over this period shall
be deducted, and the disaster eligibility
limit shall be one half of the monthly
SNAP limit for size of the household.
(d) Benefit availability. The State
agency shall act promptly on all
applications and make benefits
available, including EBT cards and
PINs, to eligible households that
complete the D–SNAP application
process no later than 72 hours following
their filing of the application, unless the
information provided by the applicant is
deemed questionable. When
information is found to be questionable,
PO 00000
Frm 00021
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
the State shall resolve the issue(s) to
determine eligibility, and make benefits
available within 7 days following the
filing of the application or deny the
application.
(e) Screening for duplicate
participation during disasters. States
shall develop a system to detect
duplicate applications for D–SNAP.
States shall either check for duplicate
information up front, or may accept
applications and inform applicants that
eligibility is contingent upon a
subsequent check for duplicates. States
shall check for duplicate participation
using onsite or offsite computer
databases, but shall include all
individuals included on each
application. States shall update
computer databases on a daily basis
throughout the application period.
States shall screen D–SNAP
applications for duplicate participation
with:
(1) SNAP.
(2) Household disaster distribution of
USDA Foods.
(3) Other D–SNAPs with overlapping
benefit periods.
(4) Already approved D–SNAP
applications.
(5) Denied D–SNAP applicants (to
identify attempted duplicate
participation).
(f) D–SNAP verification requirements.
To expedite the certification for D–
SNAP, the State agency shall use the
procedures specified in this paragraph
rather than the standard SNAP
verification required by § 273.2(f). The
applicant’s identity shall be verified.
Examples of acceptable verification
which the household may provide
include, but are not limited to: A
driver’s license, work or school ID, voter
registration card, birth certificate, or, a
collateral contact. Residency and
household composition at the time of
the disaster shall be verified where
possible, and must be verified if
questionable. In some situations (such
as in the case of a household that
arrived in the area just prior to the
disaster), verification of residency may
not be possible. When residency that is
questionable cannot be verified despite
the efforts of the State agency and the
household, the household shall not be
denied D–SNAP solely for this reason.
Loss/inaccessibility of income or liquid
resources and food loss shall be verified
if questionable.
(g) Applications from state and
county employees. State and local staff
may be entitled to D–SNAP benefits and
shall be subject to the same eligibility
criteria as any other applicant. States
shall incorporate the following internal
controls into their disaster operations.
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
(1) Certification and issuance duties
shall be handled by different staff.
(2) A question shall be included on
the D–SNAP application asking if
anyone in the applicant household (or
its authorized representative) is
employed by the State or local SNAP
agency.
(3) Supervisors or investigators shall
conduct employee certification
interviews.
(4) States shall audit all employee
applications and inform employees of
this policy in advance of implementing
the D–SNAP.
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
§ 280.5 Households participating in the
SNAP when D–SNAP is operating.
(a) SNAP shall continue to operate
during the disaster benefit period and
shall continue to process applications
and make eligibility determinations in
the normal manner in accordance with
parts 273 and 274 of the SNAP
regulations in this chapter. Households
currently certified for SNAP benefits
may be eligible for supplemental
benefits.
(b) Disaster supplements. (1) When D–
SNAP is approved and operating in a
given jurisdiction, supplements shall be
issued to currently certified SNAP
households affected by the disaster in
that jurisdiction that bring their benefit
level up to the maximum allotment for
their household size. States shall issue
supplemental benefits on an individual
basis, via the filing of an affidavit of
disaster loss by the household, or
automatically to all currently certified
SNAP households in a designated area.
By virtue of their participation in SNAP
such households need not appear in
person at the D–SNAP site.
(2) To obtain an individual
supplement, households shall complete
an affidavit of disaster loss.
(3) States’ requests to issue automatic
supplements and the supporting
justification shall be included in the
State’s D–SNAP request. States shall
specify their decision to issue automatic
supplements and must be able to show
that they can effectively target the
benefits to geographic areas that were
heavily impacted by the disaster.
Currently certified SNAP households
not receiving automatic issuance but
who were living in the disaster area and
experienced disaster losses may still
request supplemental benefits via an
individual affidavit of disaster.
(c) Replacements. As provided in
§ 274.6, replacement benefits are always
available to SNAP households that file
an affidavit that they have experienced
an adverse effect causing them to lose
food purchased with their benefits.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
§ 280.6
Reconciliation.
(a) EBT cards. Cards shipped from a
central location shall be tracked until
distributed locally to households. Each
issuance site shall maintain a beginning
and ending inventory and track new
cards received, total cards available, and
cards issued. If the State assigns
Personal Identification Numbers (PINs),
they must also account for PIN mailers
or envelopes to ensure adequate
security, except when the PIN is
formulated from the Primary Account
Number. The State shall reconcile the
number of cards set-up with EBT
accounts and the number of cards
issued to identify and resolve any
discrepancies.
(b) D–SNAP issuances. States shall
track D–SNAP benefits separately from
SNAP benefit issuance and adhere to
FNS reconciliation guidelines so that
they can compare benefits posted to
accounts to benefits issued by the State
eligibility system.
§ 280.7 Post disaster review and
corrections.
(a) States shall conduct a
comprehensive review and individual
case reviews. Based upon a problem
analysis of the findings from these
reviews, the State shall modify its
disaster plan.
(1) The comprehensive review should
begin with an overview of the D–SNAP
operation, including where and when it
took place, how it was staffed, and the
total number of applications approved
and amount of benefits issued. The State
should then examine the systems or
methods employed, document any
major problems or challenges
encountered, and discuss the
interventions used to solve those issues
in the following areas:
(i) Certification systems;
(ii) Fraud control;
(iii) Issuance;
(iv) Public information and outreach;
(v) Program accessibility;
(vi) Security.
(2)(i) The State agency shall conduct
a post-disaster review of disaster
certification activities by selecting and
reviewing a sample of individual cases
that applied for D–SNAP. The review of
certified cases shall include: A case
record review; an interview with the
participant; verification of each element
of eligibility for the State’s D–SNAP
program including identity, residency,
income, household size and disaster
related expenses; a determination of
eligibility for disaster assistance; and an
analysis of errors.
(ii) States with 10,000 or more
approved D–SNAP households shall
select a sample of 400 approved cases
PO 00000
Frm 00022
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
28757
for review. States with less than 10,000
but more than 300 approved D–SNAP
households shall select a sample of
between 300 and 400 cases as shown
below. States with 300 or fewer would
review all cases.
Approved D–
SNAP households (N)
10,000 and
over.
300 to 9,999 ...
Under 300 ......
Minimum sample size (n)
n = 400
n = 300 + [0.01031(N¥300)]
n = all cases
(iii) A sample of 100 denied D–SNAP
applications shall be reviewed to
identify errors made in not providing
benefits to eligible households. If there
are fewer than 100 denied applications,
all denied applications would be
reviewed.
(iv) If a State uses a random sample,
the State shall identify this in the post
disaster report described and include
the following information:
(A) The number of cases or in the
sample universe;
(B) A description of the sample frame
and how it was constructed;
(C) The sample size selected;
(D) The number of sample cases
completed; and
(E) The findings from the sample
cases completed.
(3) States shall review all State agency
employee applications—approved and
denied.
(4) For all case reviews, no cases shall
be dropped for any reason and the State
shall report information gathered from
all case reviews.
(5) State agencies shall submit the
post disaster report containing the
results of the reviews, the problem
analysis, and proposed improvements
within 6 months of the close of each D–
SNAP operation.
(b) Fair hearings requirements in a D–
SNAP. Any household who applied for
D–SNAP benefits and was denied may
request a fair hearing. A household
which has requested a fair hearing shall
be offered an immediate onsite
supervisory review. Households that are
not satisfied with the outcome of the
supervisory review retain the right to
request a fair hearing in accordance
with § 273.15 of this chapter.
(c) Restored benefits from D–SNAP.
States shall issue restored benefits to
households when an incorrect denial of
benefits is subsequently corrected. The
issuance system shall clearly note that
such corrected issuances were restored
benefits.
(d) D–SNAP recipient claims
collection requirements. States shall
establish a claim against the household
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
28758
Federal Register / Vol. 81, No. 90 / Tuesday, May 10, 2016 / Proposed Rules
consistent with the claims collection
requirements of SNAP regulations at
§ 273.18 of this chapter. Claims shall be
established as soon as possible after the
close of the disaster operation. States
may also follow their FNS-approved
procedures and thresholds for
establishing claims in SNAP for claims
arising from D–SNAP, or may include
any alternate procedures or thresholds
in their D–SNAP request. However, if a
claim is established against a household
for an overpayment of SNAP benefits,
this amount may not be collected from
the D–SNAP issuance.
ehiers on DSK5VPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS
§ 280.8
D–SNAP reporting.
(a) D–SNAP daily reports. States
operating a D–SNAP shall report to FNS
on a daily basis. States shall begin
submitting reports on the day following
the first day of D–SNAP operations and
continue submitting the reports on a
daily basis until all applications are
processed. States shall use a daily
reporting template provided by FNS.
Data should be submitted by county, as
indicated in the template. The daily
reports must capture the new D–SNAP
and SNAP issuance data listed in
paragraphs (a)(1) through (13) of this
section:
(1) Number of D–SNAP applications
received;
(2) Number of new D–SNAP
households approved;
(3) Number of new D–SNAP persons
approved;
(4) Number of SNAP households
receiving supplements;
(5) Number of people previously
certified for SNAP approved for
supplements;
(6) Number of new D–SNAP
households denied;
(7) Number of SNAP households
receiving replacement issuance;
(8) Value of new D–SNAP benefits
approved;
(9) Value of SNAP supplements
approved;
(10) Value of SNAP replacement
issuance;
(11) Average benefit per new D–SNAP
household;
(12) Average benefit per SNAP
household; and
(13) Any additional information the
State believes FNS should be aware of.
(b) FNS–292B, Report of
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance
Program Benefit Issuance for Disaster
Relief. Within 45 days of the
termination of a D–SNAP operation, the
State agency shall submit the FNS–
292B. This report shall be submitted
electronically in the Food Programs
Reporting System (FPRS). The FNS
292B shall contain the following
issuance data for D–SNAP operations:
VerDate Sep<11>2014
15:20 May 09, 2016
Jkt 238001
(1) Number of new households issued
D–SNAP benefits.
(2) Total number of new persons
issued D–SNAP benefits.
(3) Number of households certified in
SNAP that were issued supplements.
(4) Total value of benefits issued to
new households and supplements
issued to previously certified SNAP
households.
(c) Form FNS–388, Monthly Issuance
Report. The FNS–388 shall include
issuance and participation figures for
new D–SNAP households and
previously certified SNAP households
receiving disaster supplements and/or
replacements. Replacement benefits
shall be reported for the month for
which they are intended.
(d) Form FNS–209, Status of Claims
Against Households Report. In the
remarks section of the FNS–209, States
shall indicate the number of claims
established and collected against D–
SNAP benefits. D–SNAP claims must be
identified on backup documentation in
the accounting systems for the FNS–
209.
(e) Form FNS–46, Issuance
Reconciliation Report. The FNS–46
shall include issuance and participation
figures for new D–SNAP households
and SNAP households receiving disaster
supplements and/or replacements. The
FNS–46 and FNS–388 should reconcile
with the reported net issuance.
(f) Post-disaster Report. The postdisaster review report shall be
comprised of four parts: The
comprehensive review, individual
reviews, problem analysis, and
proposed improvements to the disaster
plan. States shall submit the postdisaster report containing the reviews,
the problem analysis, and proposed
improvements within 6 months of the
close of each D–SNAP operation.
Dated: May 2, 2016.
Telora T. Dean,
Acting Administrator, Food and Nutrition
Service.
[FR Doc. 2016–10923 Filed 5–9–16; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 3410–30–P
PO 00000
Frm 00023
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
Animal and Plant Health Inspection
Service
7 CFR Part 319
[Docket No. APHIS–2014–0092]
RIN 0579–AE17
Importation of Lemons From
Northwest Argentina
Animal and Plant Health
Inspection Service, USDA.
ACTION: Proposed rule.
AGENCY:
We are proposing to amend
the fruits and vegetables regulations to
allow the importation of lemons from
northwest Argentina into the
continental United States. As a
condition of entry, lemons from
northwest Argentina would have to be
produced in accordance with a systems
approach that would include
requirements for importation in
commercial consignments; registration
and monitoring of places of production
and packinghouses; pest-free places of
production; grove sanitation,
monitoring, and pest control practices;
treatment with a surface disinfectant; lot
identification; and inspection for
quarantine pests by the Argentine
national plant protection organization.
Additionally, lemons from northwest
Argentina would have to be harvested
green and within a certain time period,
or treated for Medfly in accordance with
an approved treatment schedule.
Lemons from northwest Argentina
would also be required to be
accompanied by a phytosanitary
certificate with an additional
declaration stating that the lemons have
been inspected and found to be free of
quarantine pests and were produced in
accordance with the proposed
requirements. This action would allow
for the importation of lemons from
northwest Argentina into the United
States while continuing to provide
protection against the introduction of
quarantine pests.
DATES: We will consider all comments
that we receive on or before July 11,
2016.
ADDRESSES: You may submit comments
by either of the following methods:
• Federal eRulemaking Portal: Go to
https://www.regulations.gov/
#!docketDetail;D=APHIS-2014-0092.
• Postal Mail/Commercial Delivery:
Send your comments to Docket No.
APHIS–2014–0092, Regulatory Analysis
and Development, PPD, APHIS, Station
3A–03.8, 4700 River Road Unit 118,
Riverdale, MD 20737–1238.
SUMMARY:
E:\FR\FM\10MYP1.SGM
10MYP1
Agencies
[Federal Register Volume 81, Number 90 (Tuesday, May 10, 2016)]
[Proposed Rules]
[Pages 28738-28758]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2016-10923]
=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
Food and Nutrition Service
7 CFR Parts 272, 274, and 280
[FNS 2015-0021]
RIN 0584-AE00
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP): Disaster
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (D-SNAP)
AGENCY: Food and Nutrition Service, USDA.
ACTION: Proposed rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: This proposed rule would amend the Supplemental Nutrition
Assistance Program (SNAP) (formerly the Food Stamp Program) regulations
to establish procedures for planning, requesting and operating a
Disaster Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (D-SNAP). The
rulemaking is necessary to implement a section of the Food and
Nutrition Act of 2008. This rulemaking also addresses a section of the
Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act of 1988
and accompanying Executive Order 12673, which provides the authority
for the Department to determine the need for SNAP assistance during a
presidentially-declared disaster.
DATES: Written comments on this proposed rule must be received on or
before July 11, 2016.
ADDRESSES: The Food and Nutrition Service (FNS) invites interested
persons to submit comments on this proposed rule. Comments may be
submitted by any of the following methods:
Federal eRulemaking Portal: Preferred method. Go to https://www.regulations.gov; follow the online instructions for submitting
comments on Docket FNS 2015-0021.
FAX: Submit comments by facsimile transmission to (703) 305-2486,
attention: Sasha Gersten-Paal.
Mail: Send comments to Sasha Gersten-Paal, Branch Chief,
Certification Policy Branch, Program Development Division, Supplemental
Nutrition Assistance Program, Food and Nutrition Service, 3101 Park
Center Drive, Room 812, Alexandria, Virginia, 22302, (703) 305-2507.
Hand Delivery or Courier: Deliver comments to Sasha Gersten-Paal at
the above address.
Additional electronic filing information: You may download a copy
of this rule from www.fns.usda.gov/SNAP. You may also comment via the
Internet at the same address. Please include ATTENTION RIN: 0584-AE00
in the subject line and your name and address in the message. If you do
not receive a confirmation that we have received your comment please
call Sasha Gersten-Paal at 703-305-2507.
All comments on this proposed rule will be included in the record
and will be made available to the public. Please be advised that the
substance of the comments and the identity of the individuals or
entities submitting the comments will be subject to public disclosure.
FNS will make the comments publicly available on the Internet via
https://www.regulations.gov.
All submissions will be available for public inspection at the
office of FNS during regular business hours (8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.,
Monday through Friday) at 3101 Park Center Drive, Room 810, Alexandria,
Virginia 22302-1594.
Written comments on this proposed rule should be specific, confined
to issues pertinent to the rule, and should explain the reason for any
change you recommend. Where possible, you should reference the specific
section or paragraph you are addressing. We may not consider or include
in the Administrative Record that supports the final rulemaking
comments that we receive after the close of the comment period or
comments delivered to an address other than that listed above. We will
make available all comments for public inspection, including, name,
address and other contact information of respondents. If you wish to
request that we consider withholding your name, address, or other
contact information from public review or from disclosure under the
Freedom of Information Act, you must state this prominently at the
beginning of your comment. We will honor requests for confidentiality
on a case-by-case basis to the extent allowed by law. We will make
available for public inspection in their entirety all submissions from
organizations or businesses, and from individuals identifying
themselves as representatives or officials of organizations or
businesses.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: For further information concerning
this Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) you may contact Sasha
Gersten-Paal, Branch Chief, Certification Policy Branch, Program
Development Division, Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, 3101
Park Center Drive, Room 810, Alexandria, Virginia, 22302, or by email
at Sasha.Gersten-Paal@fns.usda.gov.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Background
The basic premise underlying the D-SNAP and this proposed rule is
that when a disaster occurs (and after commercial channels of food
distribution are operating again) there is an increased and immediate
need for nutrition assistance for families that have suffered loss of
income and/or incurred additional costs due to the disaster. SNAP is
not designed to take disaster-related expenses into account in
determining eligibility. SNAP eligibility requirements typically do not
match the sudden (but temporary) needs of households affected by
disaster, and SNAP's procedural requirements make it difficult for
States to handle the large number of people suddenly in need of
immediate assistance. Thus, it may be necessary to implement a D-SNAP
that uses a different set of rules to determine need and issue
benefits.
[[Page 28739]]
How D-SNAP Currently Operates
D-SNAP provides temporary food assistance for households affected
by a disaster when there is a Presidential disaster declaration that
includes the provision of individual assistance. Currently, D-SNAP
provides one month of benefits to eligible disaster survivors and can
facilitate the issuance of supplemental SNAP benefits for currently
certified households. To be eligible for D-SNAP, a household must live
(or in some cases, work) in the identified disaster area, have been
affected by the disaster, and meet certain D-SNAP eligibility criteria.
D-SNAP is designed for situations where a large number of households
have disaster-related expenses not contemplated when an individual
applies for SNAP.
The primary responsibility for providing emergency food assistance
rests with the State agency. Currently, utilizing FNS Guidance, State
agencies design their own D-SNAP Plan, evaluate the need for a D-SNAP
or another feeding program should a disaster strike, submit to FNS a
detailed request to operate a D-SNAP, effectively implement the D-SNAP,
ensure program integrity in D-SNAP operations, submit daily reports,
perform post-disaster reviews and report their findings to FNS.
What acronyms or abbreviations are used in this supplementary
discussion of the proposed provisions?
In the discussion of the proposed provisions in this rule, we use
the following acronyms or other abbreviations to stand in for certain
words or phrases:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Acronym, abbreviation, or
Phrase symbol
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Code of Federal Regulations............. CFR.
United States Code...................... U.S.C.
Disaster Supplemental Nutrition D-SNAP.
Assistance Program.
Electronic Benefit Transfer............. EBT.
Individual Assistance................... IA.
Federal Register........................ FR.
Federal Fiscal Year..................... FY.
Food and Nutrition Act of 2008.......... Act.
Food and Nutrition Service.............. FNS.
Secretary of Agriculture................ the Secretary.
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance SNAP.
Program.
U. S. Department of Agriculture......... the Department.
Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Stafford Act.
Emergency Assistance Act.
Federal Emergency Management Agency..... FEMA.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Legislation and Regulations
What authorities does the Department have regarding disasters?
FNS can provide disaster nutrition assistance in three ways:
Provide USDA purchased foods for shelters and other mass
feeding sites (42 U.S.C. 5180);
Provide USDA commodity (food) assistance for distribution
directly to households in need in certain limited circumstances (42
U.S.C.5180);
Approve a State D-SNAP operation and provide funding for
100 percent of disaster benefits and 50 percent of State administrative
costs. FNS supports the State's efforts to provide D-SNAP benefits by
providing policy guidance, training, and technical assistance to State
agencies as they plan, implement, and assess their D-SNAP activities
(42 U.S.C. 5179).
All three types of assistance may be needed for disaster victims
throughout or at different points of time following the disaster.
However, households cannot simultaneously receive both D-SNAP benefits
and commodity assistance.
Under the Stafford Act the President is authorized to declare a
``major disaster'' when requested to do so by the Governor of a state
stuck by a natural disaster. The President may direct Federal agencies
to support States' response efforts and assist in the distribution of
food and other consumable supplies.
After consultation with FEMA, the Secretary also has the authority
to establish temporary emergency standards of eligibility for victims
of a disaster if they are in need of temporary food assistance, and
commercial channels of food distribution were disrupted, but have again
become available. FNS has generally approved States' requests for D-
SNAP under Stafford Act authority when areas affected by disasters have
received a Presidential disaster declaration that includes an
individual assistance declaration, since this establishes the need for
assistance at the household level.
What does legislation say about D-SNAP?
The Stafford Act provides the Secretary of Agriculture with the
authority to operate a D-SNAP when affected areas have received a
Presidential major disaster declaration for individual assistance (IA)
and when commercial channels of food distribution are available.
Section (5)(h) of the Act provides the Secretary with the authority to
establish temporary emergency standards of eligibility for households
who are survivors of a disaster that disrupts commercial channels of
food distribution, after those channels have been restored. The Act
requires that the Secretary establish a disaster task force to assist
States in the implementation and operation of a D-SNAP and send members
to the disaster site if cost-effective. The Act also requires that the
regulations address replacement benefits for households currently
certified in SNAP that experience food loss, and provides for the
adjustment of issuance and reporting requirements in the D-SNAP.
Under Section 11(e)(14) of the Act, as part of a State agency's
overall Plan of Operation, the State agency is required to specify a
plan for providing SNAP for households that are victims of a disaster
and that such plan shall include, but not be limited to, procedures for
informing the public about the disaster program and how to apply for
its benefits. The plan should also give consideration to coordinating
efforts with other Federal and private relief agencies, as well as
local government officials.
[[Page 28740]]
Has the Department previously published rules for D-SNAP?
The Department published the interim rule in 1981, at 46 FR 8922-01
(January 27, 1981) (amended in 1991 and 2005), which established the
Department's authority to approve temporary emergency standards of
eligibility for disaster victims without regard to Section 4(c) of the
Act or the procedures set forth in the Administrative Procedure Act (5
U.S.C. 553). Based on this authority, as disasters have occurred, the
Department has approved the specific procedures to be used, depending
on the circumstances of each particular disaster. The procedures in the
interim rulemaking (that was never published as a final rule) for
certifying disaster-affected households and issuing D-SNAP benefits
initially served as a basis for D-SNAP guidance to States. FNS guidance
has since evolved and has been updated as necessary based on experience
and States' needs.
Would this proposed rule address the ``Disaster Task Force'' discussed
in the Act?
The proposed rule does not address the D-SNAP task force. FNS
employs staff at its national office and in its regional offices that
work with State staff, and coordinate with other Federal agencies in
preparing for disasters. FNS staff assists with D-SNAP operations as
appropriate, including going on-site in many instances. While these
staffs change over time in response to the need for disaster-related
activity, they constitute the flexible type of task force contemplated
by the Act. Thus, there is no need to regulate this provision of the
Act.
What do the current interim regulations for D-SNAP say?
The interim regulations currently in effect state that:
The Secretary shall, after consultation with the official
empowered to exercise the authority provided for by the Stafford Act,
establish temporary emergency standards of eligibility for the duration
of the emergency for households who are victims of a disaster which
disrupts commercial channels of food distribution, if such households
are in need of temporary food assistance and if commercial channels of
food distribution have again become available to meet the temporary
food needs of such households.
Such standards as are prescribed for individual
emergencies may be promulgated without regard to section 4(c) of this
Act or the procedures set forth in 5 U.S.C. 553.
In addition to establishing temporary emergency standards
of eligibility, the Secretary shall provide for emergency allotments to
eligible households to replace food destroyed in a disaster. Such
emergency allotments would be equal to the value of the food actually
lost in such disaster but not greater than the applicable maximum
monthly allotment for the household size.
The Secretary may also approve alternate methods for
issuing food stamp benefits during a disaster when reliance on
Electronic Benefits Transfer (EBT) systems is impracticable.
What has the Department learned using this authority?
The Department has learned several lessons over the years. First,
each disaster situation is different and it is important to provide
States flexibility in requesting a D-SNAP that will meet the needs of
the disaster victims and is compatible with the State's plans and
administration. Second, disaster planning and preparation are critical
to a timely and well coordinated response to different disaster
situations. Third, State monitoring and reporting on program operations
and integrity must be integrated into the planning and implementation
of any D-SNAP.
What aspects of the D-SNAP does the proposed rule address?
This proposed rule primarily addresses several aspects of the D-
SNAP, including:
The development of a Disaster Plan
Circumstances necessary for approval of a D-SNAP
Required content of the State request to FNS for a D-SNAP
The basic eligibility and benefit policy for participation in
D-SNAP
The application processing requirements for D-SNAP
Policy regarding currently certified SNAP participants
residing in disaster areas
Monitoring State D-SNAP operations
State Reporting on D-SNAP (both during and at the conclusion
of disaster operations)
Does this proposed rule establish detailed operating and policy
requirements for all D-SNAP operations?
This proposed rule is intended to provide as much flexibility as
possible in the design of each D-SNAP operation while establishing
consistent rules for requesting, monitoring and reporting on the D-
SNAP. The reason for this is the varied and unpredictable nature of
each disaster. While there are similarities among disasters, each set
of circumstances is different enough that any attempt to limit State
and FNS flexibility could cause delays in Federal and State response
time in providing benefits to the victims of disasters. Thus,
regulations that inherently seek to standardize policy and procedures,
regardless of specific circumstances, can become problematic when the
circumstances call for flexibility. In this proposal, the Department
provides a basic framework for D-SNAP that sets clear expectations for
State and local administrators while still allowing as much flexibility
as possible. Furthermore, the Department is attempting to provide
responsible fiscal controls of the disaster benefits while ensuring
that benefits are provided to eligible applicants during disasters.
Does FNS provide additional direction or guidance regarding D-SNAP?
Yes, FNS provides detailed guidance which can be found on the FNS
Web site at https://www.fns.usda.gov/disasters/response/D-SNAP_Handbook/D-SNAP_handbook.pdf. This guidance is based upon lessons learned by FNS
and States' best practices in several types of disasters. It is
designed to assist States in all aspects of the D-SNAP. Adherence to
this guidance can improve preparedness, expedite approval of requests
and reduce the potential for waste and fraud in D-SNAP operations.
When is it appropriate to request D-SNAP?
D-SNAP timing varies with the unique circumstances of each
disaster, but begins after there has been a Presidentially-declared
disaster for IA and commercial channels of food distribution have been
restored so families are able to purchase and prepare food.
What is IA?
IA is financial or direct assistance to individuals and families
whose property has been damaged or destroyed as a result of a
Presidentially-declared disaster, and whose losses are not covered by
insurance. The decision to designate an area as eligible for IA is made
by FEMA. The IA is intended to help households with critical expenses
that cannot be covered in other ways.
FNS proposes to approve the operation of D-SNAP under Stafford Act
authority when affected areas have received a Presidential disaster
declaration for IA because receipt of an individual assistance
declaration is indicative of households' need for food
[[Page 28741]]
assistance in the affected area. However, since D-SNAP is intended to
meet households' immediate needs, States would be required to implement
D-SNAP within a reasonable time period following the IA declaration.
FNS is reluctant to approve requests for D-SNAP that are made after the
immediate need for food assistance has passed.
How is D-SNAP funded?
FNS provides 100 percent of disaster benefits and 50 percent of
State administrative costs.
What is a State's responsibilities in D-SNAP?
The Department proposes that the primary responsibility for
providing emergency food assistance continue to rest with the States.
State agencies would continue to design their own D-SNAP Plan, evaluate
the need for a D-SNAP or another feeding program when a disaster
strikes, submit a detailed request to FNS to operate a D-SNAP,
effectively implement the D-SNAP, ensure program integrity in D-SNAP
operations, submit daily reports, perform post-disaster reviews, and
report their findings to FNS.
Basic D-SNAP Policies
How do D-SNAP non-financial eligibility criteria differ from SNAP?
Eligibility criteria vary depending upon the disaster, the
demographics of the affected jurisdictions and States' D-SNAP requests.
FNS has exercised its disaster authority to waive SNAP eligibility
restrictions, streamline States' D-SNAP operations and ensure that
families in the affected areas are served as efficiently as possible.
How is the allotment calculated in D-SNAP?
D-SNAP provides a full month's allotment to disaster affected
households who may not normally qualify for or participate in SNAP. The
allotment for a household is equal to the maximum monthly allotment for
the household size provided under SNAP.
D-SNAP allotments are updated yearly and available on the FNS Web
site. In order to serve disaster affected households already
participating in SNAP and residing in areas approved to operate a D-
SNAP, States may supplement the SNAP benefit up to the maximum
allotment for the household size.
What is the D-SNAP ``Application Period''?
The Department proposes that States may only accept applications
for D-SNAP benefits from households not participating in SNAP and
requests for supplements only from households currently certified in
SNAP during the approved application period. FNS has generally approved
application periods of 7 consecutive days (business days at the State's
option), though States have the option to request more or fewer days in
the D-SNAP request. FNS proposes to continue with this approach. The
State should also inform FNS, as part of the D-SNAP request, whether
applications will be accepted on Saturday and/or Sunday. If the State
is accepting requests for supplements from households currently
certified in SNAP over the phone and mailing the forms to the
household, the required affidavit attesting to the loss of food
purchased with SNAP benefits must requested during the application
period.
What is a D-SNAP ``Benefit Period''?
The Department proposes that the benefit period be a 30-day period
approved by FNS for each D-SNAP. The benefit period is the period
during which disaster-related expenses are to be counted; the start
date is used to determine household composition and resources. Only
income received, expenses incurred and resources that are accessible
during the benefit period are considered in determining D-SNAP
eligibility. The benefit period begins on the first date of the
disaster generally referred to as the ``Incident Period'' identified in
the Presidential Disaster Declaration.
Can the Application and Benefit Periods be modified?
The Department proposes that any modifications to a D-SNAP be
approved by FNS in writing. For example, if a State agency determines
that the initial benefit period requested is not appropriate, it may
request a modification of the benefit period start/end dates. This
could, for example, accommodate disaster related expenses incurred in
preparation for the disaster. However, once the application period has
commenced the benefit period could not be changed. Doing so would
introduce unnecessary complexity and potential inequity into the D-
SNAP.
If demand for D-SNAP benefits increases or remains high during the
initially approved application period, FNS may consider a State's
request for an extension of the application period. States requesting
an extension should address the ongoing demand for assistance and any
program integrity concerns in their request.
What are the basic eligibility criteria for D-SNAP?
To be eligible for D-SNAP, the Department proposes that an
applicant household must first meet basic criteria, including: (1)
Residency; (2) Household Composition; (3) Adverse effects due to the
disaster; and (4) Income requirements.
How is residency determined?
Under this proposed rule, the household must have lived in the
disaster area at the time of the disaster. However, States may also
choose to extend eligibility to those who worked in the disaster area
at the time of the disaster. When submitting their D-SNAP requests,
States should specify if they will serve households that (a) lived in
the disaster area, or (b) lived or worked in the disaster area.
How is household composition established?
The Department proposes that D-SNAP household composition be
established based upon persons who live, purchase food, and prepare
meals together on the date of the first day of the disaster benefit
period, which will be considered to be the earliest date that
households are in need. This rulemaking proposes that the benefit
period begin on the date of the disaster or the date of any mandatory
evacuation preceding the disaster.
What is an adverse effect?
The Department proposes that disaster-related adverse effects
include three categories:
[cir] Loss or inaccessibility of income involving a reduction or
termination of income, or a significant delay in receipt of income.
[cir] Inaccessibility of liquid resources, including situations in
which the household is unable to access cash resources for a portion of
the disaster benefit period.
[cir] Disaster related expenses that the household has incurred
during the disaster benefit period that result from the effects of the
disaster.
The FNS Disaster SNAP Guidance provides specific expenses that
shall be considered disaster related, and States can propose other
reasonable expenses in their disaster request.
How is household income dealt with for D-SNAP?
The Department proposes that the income of households that meet the
residency, household composition and adverse effect criteria be
measured against the D-SNAP gross income limit
[[Page 28742]]
(DGIL) in order to determine eligibility. The DGIL is explained below.
Unlike SNAP, which includes separate tests for income and
resources, the Department proposes that D-SNAP would group income and
resources together under one test. This is the method that is already
being used in D-SNAP. To determine a household's D-SNAP income:
Add all income received or expected to be received during
the benefit period to accessible liquid resources (liquid resources
include cash on hand, and funds in accessible checking and saving
accounts on the first day of the benefit period);
Subtract the value of unreimbursed disaster related
expenses incurred during the disaster benefit period from the income/
liquid resource amount (any reimbursements received or anticipated to
be received by the household during the benefit period, including
insurance and FEMA payments would reduce the allowable disaster-related
expense amount); and
Compare the result compared to the DGIL and if it is less
than or equal to the DGIL, the household would be eligible for D-SNAP
benefits.
What is the Department proposing to include as D-SNAP income?
The Department proposes that D-SNAP income would be the net (take-
home) pay of all household members during the benefit period,
including:
Wages a household actually receives after taxes and all
other payroll withholding (including contributions to 401(k) or other
inaccessible accounts, automatic payments to creditors, etc.);
Public assistance payments or other unearned income; and
Net self-employment income.
As determined by the State agency, income that has been delayed for
a substantial portion of the benefit period due to the disaster would
be considered inaccessible.
For example, household X consists of four people who are not
currently participating in SNAP. Their household was impacted by the
disaster and they apply for D-SNAP. One individual is employed and
receives monthly take-home pay of $1200, after payroll taxes and health
insurance premium are taken out. The other individual receives $850 in
TANF benefits each month. The household's total income for D-SNAP
purposes is $1200 + $850 = $2050.
What is the Department proposing to exclude as D-SNAP resources?
The Department proposes that the following be deemed as not
accessible liquid resources:
Retirement accounts;
Disaster insurance payments;
Disaster assistance received or expected to be received
during the benefit period; and
Payments from Federal, state or county/local government
agencies or disaster assistance organizations (including disaster-
related Unemployment Compensation).
Inaccessible liquid resources would also include otherwise liquid
resources that are temporarily inaccessible (for instance, because a
bank with a household's certificate of deposit is closed due to the
disaster) during the benefit period. In the Department's experience,
this is an infrequent occurrence, as households can usually access
their resources via online banking or ATMs even if bank branches are
closed in the affected area. For example, on the day the disaster
struck, household X had $50 in cash, and $250 in its checking account,
with an additional $300 in a savings account. The funds in these
accounts are accessible. The household has applied for FEMA assistance
for the property damage it incurred. The household's total accessible
liquid resources are $50 + $250 + $300 = $600, since the FEMA
assistance will not be received before the benefit period ends. Their
household's total accessible liquid resources are $50 + $250 + $300 =
$600.
How is the DGIL calculated?
The Department proposes to calculate each year's disaster gross
income limit by adding together the SNAP maximum monthly net income
limit, the SNAP maximum standard income deduction amount, and the SNAP
maximum capped shelter expense deduction for each household size.
Together, these amounts establish a simplified process to determine if
households are in need of assistance that is grounded in the SNAP
income methodology and standards for determining eligibility. For
household X in the above examples, the total D-SNAP ``income'' of $2650
($2050 + $600), would be compared to the DGIL for a household of four
to determine eligibility for D-SNAP.
How is the requirement that households purchase food applied?
The Department proposes that, to be eligible, households must
either plan on purchasing food during the disaster benefit period, or
have already purchased food during the benefit period. This would
clearly apply to most households, other than with very large disasters
where households may remain in shelters and be served through
congregate feeding throughout the benefit period.
What are disaster-related expenses?
These are expenses that the household has incurred during the
disaster benefit period due to the disaster. Eligible expenses would
include the following, plus any other reasonable disaster-related
expenses determined by the State agency:
Home or business repairs
Temporary shelter expenses
Evacuation expenses
Home/business property protection
Medical expenses due to personal injury
Disaster-related funeral expenses
Expenses related to replacing necessary personal and household
items, such as clothing, appliances, tools, and educational materials
Fuel for primary heating source
Clean-up items expense
Disaster-damaged vehicle expenses
Storage expenses
Food lost in the disaster
Are all disaster-related expenses deductible?
In the past, all of the above expenses would be deductible if they
have been or are anticipated be paid during the benefit period unless
the household receives or anticipates receiving a reimbursement for
these expenses during the benefit period, in which case only any
remaining obligation expense is deductible. The Department's practice
to date has been only to allow a deduction for expenses which are paid
during the benefit period. Consequently, bills paid by credit card or
other payments over time have not been allowed as deductions. The
Department is now proposing to allow deductions for expenses that are
incurred during the benefit period even if those expenses will be paid
after the benefit period. The Department believes that this policy
would be more equitable since households that incur similar disaster
related expenses should not be treated differently simply because they
pay using a credit card instead of cash or a check. The Department is
interested in receiving comments on this proposed change.
What options do States have in determining deductions?
In conjunction with the options discussed below, the Department
proposes that States may also choose to consider households that have
experienced food loss as their only disaster-related expense to be
eligible for the D-SNAP. The State would use available information such
as power
[[Page 28743]]
outage maps showing affected homes or zip codes to determine if
allowing eligibility based upon food-loss alone is appropriate.
Households reporting excessively large amounts of food loss, or any
other questionable information, would be referred to fraud
investigators or senior staff for further review.
This proposed rule would provide States the following two options
in determining if households have disaster-related expenses and the
amount of the expense to use in determining D-SNAP income. The option
selected would be identified in the State's D-SNAP request.
Use of the disaster-related expenses identified above and
in the FNS Disaster SNAP Guidance. Under this option, states may choose
to have food-loss only or food loss plus one additional disaster
related expense in order to be eligible.
Use of a Disaster Standard Expense Deduction (DSED). For
households with $100 or more in deductible disaster-related expenses
(including food loss), the DSED would be added to the disaster gross
income limit and households whose take-home pay plus available liquid
resources is less than or equal to this amount (DSED+DISASTER GROSS
INCOME LIMIT) would qualify for D-SNAP benefits. Because the DSED is
designed to capture food loss along with other disaster-related
expenses, such as loss of income and damage to or destruction of
property, as noted earlier, it could not be applied to cases in which
food loss is the only disaster-related expense.
The DSED that has been used by several States is based upon
information gathered from actual disaster-related expenses reported in
a prior D-SNAP. As proposed in this rulemaking, only households with
actual, unreimbursed disaster-related expenses equal to or greater than
$100 would qualify for the DSED. Households with deductible disaster-
related expenses that fall below the $100 threshold would have their
eligibility determined using their actual expenses. If a household has
disaster expenses which exceed the DSED for its size, the State may, at
its option, use actual expenses to determine eligibility.
How is food loss in a disaster addressed in the proposed rule?
The Department proposes that the loss of food due to the disaster
be considered a disaster-related expense and that including ``food loss
alone'' as a criterion for eligibility be optional and be addressed in
the D-SNAP request to FNS. It is important to note that households
currently certified in SNAP can always request the replacement of lost
food that was purchased with their SNAP benefits under standard SNAP
rules. Food lost or spoiled due to the disaster or extended power
outage is always considered a disaster expense.
What verification is required in a D-SNAP?
The Department proposes that verification rules be eased (relative
to SNAP) to reduce administrative burdens and to reflect the reality
that due to the nature of a disaster, households and eligibility
workers may not have access to usual verification sources. Proposed
verification requirements for D-SNAP in the proposed rule are three-
tiered:
Identity must be verified;
Verification of residency and household composition must
be attempted in all cases, and must be pursued if questionable; and
Loss/inaccessibility of income or liquid resources and
food loss must be verified if questionable.
Such verification shall be performed in accordance with the
requirements at 7 CFR 273.2(f).
What requirements are proposed regarding duplicate participation
The Department proposes that States check for duplicate information
up front or accept applications and inform applicants that eligibility
is contingent upon a subsequent duplicate check. States would be
required to screen all household members for duplicate participation
in:
D-SNAP and SNAP
D-SNAP and disaster commodity food assistance
Multiple D-SNAPs with overlapping benefit periods
Approved D-SNAP and denied D-SNAP applicants (to identify
attempted duplicate participation)
Disaster Plan
What does the rule propose requiring in States' disaster plans?
The Department proposes in Sec. 280.1(b) that the State Disaster
Plan must include the following information:
Agencies and Responsibilities. This would identify State
and Federal government agencies with responsibilities for disaster
assistance, including a description of responsibilities for each
agency.
Points of Contact. This would provide names, positions,
and phone numbers of county/local, State and Federal government
officials, and their back-ups, who are key contact persons during a
disaster (including the State agency disaster coordinator).
Community Partners and Roles. This would identify private
disaster relief agencies within the State, such as the Red Cross,
Salvation Army, or community groups, and a description of their roles
in D-SNAP implementation.
Staffing and Resources. This would identify staffing and
related resources available to assist in a disaster, and how they will
be mobilized to target disaster areas in need. It would also explain
how the State/counties will manage the increased administrative burden
associated with running a D-SNAP and SNAP operations simultaneously.
Application System. This would describe application
systems to be used for D-SNAP household management, including any
workarounds to the SNAP system, considerations associated with running
SNAP and D-SNAP operations concurrently, compliance with D-SNAP
reporting requirements, etc.
Issuance System. This would describe benefit issuance
systems to be used for D-SNAP household management.
EBT Card Stock. This would identify EBT card stock
available, type of cards to be used, steps and timeline for ordering
additional cards, and any special procedures or resources that will be
needed to meet SNAP and D-SNAP issuance timeframes.
Application Sites. This would describe site selection
procedures, including potential application/issuance sites for
disasters that vary in size and scope, and any agreements in place with
those locations. If D-SNAP will operate out of local offices, it would
explain how application sites will handle running D-SNAP and SNAP
concurrently.
Data. This would identify general demographic data that
can help the agency tailor its response to a disaster. It would
identify resources and contact information for disaster impact data,
including preliminary data assessments, flood maps, or electrical
outage data.
Public Information and Outreach. This would describe
public information strategy to ensure that timely, accurate information
reaches eligible households. It would outline roles, expectations, and
responsibilities of any SNAP outreach partners included in the State
Outreach Plan that will assist with D-SNAP.
Retailer Communication. This would describe procedures to
notify retailers of new waivers (see discussion of the potential for
hot foods below) and new D-SNAP households.
Procedures to Reduce Applicant Hardship. This would
outline steps the State will take to reduce hardship for D-SNAP
applicants and SNAP caseload, including provisions for security, human
needs, language services, elderly/disabled, etc.
[[Page 28744]]
Certification Process. This would describe the specifics
of the certification process, including potential application sites,
staffing, separation of eligibility and issuance, and how application
sites will manage large crowds. If online applications are to be used
by workers or households, the plan would describe that process and
back-up systems in place if the online system is not available.
Use of a DSED and the income limits.
Reasonable Accommodations for Individuals with
Disabilities. This would describe what special accommodations will be
made for individuals with disabilities at the application and issuance
sites. This section may also include special accommodations to provide
program access to individuals with disabilities beyond those required
at application and issuance sites, such as transportation services or
home visits, as determined by the State agency on a case by case basis,
but without imposing an undue burden on the State agency.
Household Materials. This would include sample household
application and household notices in various languages.
Issuance Process. This would describe how benefits will be
made available within 72 hours of D-SNAP application and how to ensure
continuation of SNAP certification, issuance, and other actions
concurrently. It would indicate how the State will monitor stock levels
and ensure sufficient EBT card stock. It would describe EBT card on-
site or mail issuance procedures and reconciliation, as well as
security procedures, including how D-SNAP benefits will be tracked
separately from SNAP benefit issuance. Plans would need to adhere to
FNS reconciliation guidelines so benefits posted to accounts can be
compared to benefits issued by the State eligibility system.
Security and Fraud Prevention Plan. This would describe
how the State will ensure security and mitigate the risk of fraud,
including a specific plan for handling applications submitted by State
agency employees, procedures for handling questionable applications,
process for checking all household members for duplicate participation,
and any onsite security.
Disaster Reporting and Post-Disaster Review Report. This
would describe procedures to ensure that required federal reporting and
post-disaster review report will be complete and timely. This would
include daily reporting.
Disaster plans should also address any circumstances unique to the
State which may affect D-SNAP operations, including: Coordination of
resources among County-level administrations; serving isolated
populations, the development of ``work-arounds'' to allow SNAP systems
to accommodate D-SNAP operations; and, contingency plans for local
offices located in flood plains or otherwise subject to closure.
Conforming amendments are proposed in 7 CFR 272.2(a), 272.2(d), and
272.2(e) to acknowledge the Disaster component of the State agency's
overall State plan.
How often should the D-SNAP Plan be updated?
To ensure that necessary advance preparations are current, the
Department proposes in Sec. 280.1(b) of this rulemaking that State
agencies be required to review their existing Disaster Plan on at least
an annual basis and submit a revision, if a substantive change is being
made, or a notice of no substantive change, for FNS approval by the
15th of August each year or another negotiated due date approved by
FNS. As specified in Sec. 280.8(f), State agencies would be required
to amend the plan if deficiencies are found in a D-SNAP post-disaster
review. If plans are not changed from the prior submissions, States
would be able to submit letters to this affect rather that a complete
plan.
What training is required related to the D-SNAP plan?
The Department proposes that, at a minimum, States be required to
provide D-SNAP training to management in each SNAP local office and
call center. While FNS encourages that training be as complete and
inclusive as practical, at least one manager (perhaps a D-SNAP
coordinator) from each SNAP office must be included in whatever
training the State deems appropriate.
What State System requirements are there related to D-SNAP
preparations?
While there is a variety of programming that could be in place to
be ready in preparation for a disaster and improve operational
efficiency, each State is expected to make such choices based upon
their administrative needs and system capabilities. The exception to
this general expectation is that the Department proposes to require
that every State have the ability to check for duplicate participation
for all household members, as well as conduct reconciliation of D-SNAP
benefits and generate the reports required by this rule. This includes
being able to track disaster benefits separately from SNAP benefit
issuance. States would also need to have a method in place to allow for
tracking of multiple D-SNAPs simultaneously should they be struck by
two disasters within a short timeframe. States also must adhere to FNS
reconciliation requirements so that they can compare benefits posted to
accounts to benefits issued by the State eligibility system.
Requesting D-SNAP
What is required in the D-SNAP request?
The Department proposes that D-SNAP requests be submitted with a
signed cover memorandum from the State that includes a thorough
explanation of the components listed below. Well-documented requests
can be considered and approved more quickly--clearly a priority in a
disaster situation. It is proposed that each D-SNAP request include:
A description of the disaster--what happened, dates it
occurred, the affected area.
The geographic area and explanation of any differences
between the area included in the presidential declaration and the
requested area in which to operate the D-SNAP.
The start and end dates of the application period. If it
will be staggered, give dates for each county/area. Note if application
sites will be open over the weekend or for extended hours.
The start and end dates of the 30-day benefit period. The
start of the benefit period should generally match the first day of the
``incident period'' on the disaster declaration. If not, the State
should explain the reason for the difference.
Whether a DSED is being used and how it is structured.
Whether only households that lived in the disaster area
will be eligible for D-SNAP or if households that worked in the
disaster area will also be eligible.
Whether ``food loss alone'' will be a criterion for
eligibility.
Whether supplements will be automatic or individual (by
affidavit of disaster) for currently participating SNAP households. If
automatic, the request would need to describe who is eligible and
include supporting data. Supporting data may include but is not limited
to an estimate of the value of issuances for automatic supplements. If
individual, the request would need to include information on the
process for requesting supplements--by phone/mail affidavit,
electronically, or in person at a local office/D-SNAP application site.
The estimated total number of people, homes, businesses,
etc.,
[[Page 28745]]
impacted by the disaster, as well as estimates of anticipated D-SNAP
applicants and number of currently certified SNAP households expected
to be served, along with an explanation of how the estimates were
derived.
A description of issuance procedures, the number of EBT
cards on hand, and plans for requesting, receiving, and distributing
additional cards as needed. The request would need to indicate whether
D-SNAP cards can be replaced if lost or stolen.
A description of the plans for publicity, application
sites, and security/crowd control.
Plans for utilizing staff from other program areas,
counties, or States, as appropriate. The request would need to indicate
number of staff available and how staff/supervisors will be distributed
among the application sites.
A description of application sites, security/crowd
control, and procedures to ensure program access and reasonable
accommodation for persons with disabilities.
A description of when and how program information will be
disseminated to the public. This would include a list of partner
organizations involved and describe the responsibilities of each,
including role of volunteers, if applicable. It is important that
sufficient time be allowed to notify the public prior to the start of
the program. Examples of partner activities include providing D-SNAP
information on behalf of the State or providing onsite application
assistance.
A description of the fraud prevention strategies and
security measures in place.
A description of the recipient claim procedures and
thresholds to be followed if they differ from regulations at Sec.
273.18 or the State's FNS-approved procedures for handling recipient
claims in SNAP.
A description of the procedures that will be used for
identifying and handling applications by State agency/State employees.
Draft press releases, sample application, preliminary
damage assessments, and map of disaster area. In addition to these
required items, other supporting documentation may be included.
When should requests for D-SNAP be submitted?
Since the purpose of D-SNAP is to meet households' immediate needs,
the request should be submitted to allow for implementation of D-SNAP
within a reasonable amount of time following the IA declaration. In
addition, it should be submitted to FNS at least several days prior to
the planned implementation date to allow time for FNS review and
approval. Most importantly, the State should allow sufficient time to
effectively publicize the availability of D-SNAP for the affected
population prior to implementation. The Department is interested in
receiving comments on whether there is a need to establish a standard
time frame for submission of requests for D-SNAP relative to the
projected implementation date.
What changes can be made to the D-SNAP after implementation?
Sometimes, States' approved requests for D-SNAP need modification.
As with the initial submission, the Department is proposing that States
must submit written, signed requests for changes to an approved D-SNAP.
These requests, and their corresponding approvals, would generally be
approved more quickly than the initial waiver, since much of the
information about the disaster is already known. The three most likely
types of changes to the D-SNAP are listed below, along with an
explanation of each.
Expansion--After initial approval, a State may want to expand
operations because an additional county is in need of the program.
While the application period in the expanded area may differ from what
was originally approved, the benefit period will generally remain the
same. In such cases, the State should submit to FNS a request for
expansion, detailing the impact of the disaster in the new area, the
application period, and the anticipated number of applicants and
currently certified SNAP households that will be served. If the benefit
period will change, for example, because flooding due to the same
storms struck another County at a later date, the new benefit period's
dates and justification should also be included.
Extension--In some cases, States may find that their initial
application period is not sufficient to serve all eligible households,
and so they may wish to request that the application period be
extended. Requests to extend the D-SNAP application period must be
submitted with sufficient time for FNS review and approval prior to the
end of the initial application period and must be accompanied with
justification of the need for additional time. Once the application
period has ended and operations have closed, further extensions would
not be permitted.
Modification--A request to change an aspect of the D-SNAP other
than those mentioned above is known as a modification. Most
modifications, including any that would affect applicant eligibility,
can only be made prior to the start of the application period to ensure
that the eligibility criteria are applied equitably to all applicants.
Occasionally, modifications may be made after D-SNAP operations have
begun, such as when a State that was originally approved for individual
supplements decides to issue automatic supplements in a certain area.
Because of the limited window of time in which most modifications can
be requested, FNS encourages State agencies to carefully consider their
program options prior to submitting the initial request.
Are there other waivers that must be requested separate from the D-SNAP
request?
There are operational and policy issues that, while are related to
the disaster situation, are not included under the authority of the D-
SNAP and so are not addressed in this proposed rule. The one exception
is the extension of the timeframe to report a loss and request
replacement of food purchased with SNAP benefits as addressed below.
While this proposed rule only addresses the waiver for Timely Reporting
of Food Loss, three additional waivers are also discussed, for
informational purposes only, because they are the most frequently
requested and approved relative to D-SNAP operations.
Timely Household Reporting of Food Loss--SNAP regulations at Sec.
274.6 require that replacement issuances be provided to current SNAP
recipients only if a household reports a loss of food purchased with
SNAP benefits to the State within 10 days of the date the food is
destroyed in a household misfortune. This waiver has allowed the State
agency to extend the amount of time households have to report the loss
of food purchased with SNAP benefits beyond 10 days. The Department
proposes to change the reporting timeframe for the loss of food
purchased with SNAP benefits from 10 days to 30 days when the President
issues a major disaster declaration for IA. In all other cases, the 10-
day timeframe would remain intact.
Automatic/Mass Replacements--Per SNAP regulations at Sec. 274.6,
replacement benefits are available (by affidavit) to SNAP households
anytime they experience an adverse effect causing them to lose food
purchased with their benefits. This waiver allows the automatic
replacement of a certain percentage of a household's benefit (depending
on the time of the month, the State's benefits issuance cycle, and the
type of disaster) for all participating households within the disaster
area,
[[Page 28746]]
without the need to submit individual requests. This waiver may be
granted without a D-SNAP approval or IA designation. This waiver does
not remove the responsibility of local offices to process individual
affidavits before or after the waiver implementation as required by
Sec. 274.6(a).
Hot Foods--A waiver of the hot foods exclusion in the Act allows
SNAP households to purchase hot, prepared foods at authorized retailers
with their EBT cards. FNS has the authority to grant this waiver
provided that an IA declaration has been issued. The coverage of this
waiver may extend to areas beyond those that received D-SNAP approval
if households that lived in the disaster area have been displaced or
temporarily relocated to other parts of the State.
Expunging D-SNAP benefits--State agencies may request to use a
shorter timeframe (typically 90 days) for expunging benefits for D-
SNAP-only households. Following the implementation of the Food and
Nutrition Act of 2008, Pub. L. 110-246, this waiver requires approval
from FNS. State agencies that wish to implement this waiver must submit
it along with their D-SNAP requests. Any State operating under this
waiver must inform D-SNAP-only households of the timeframe for
expunging benefits. This waiver may only be used when the State has
received approval to operate a D-SNAP and an IA declaration has been
issued. A prerequisite for this waiver is the ability of the State
automated system to identify the disaster cases and benefits separately
from SNAP cases (this is required for FNS reporting as well).
Issuance and Reconciliation
What are the Issuance requirements in D-SNAP?
The Department proposes to require that each State be prepared to
issue D-SNAP benefits through its EBT system during an emergency. As
noted earlier, EBT issuance is also proposed as a required component of
State Disaster Plans. As such, a State's D-SNAP issuance plan should
incorporate procedures for:
Ensuring that approved households have benefits available,
including EBT cards, and Personal Identification Numbers (PINs), and
that their benefits are available no more than 72 hours from when the
application was filed, unless there is questionable information on the
application that requires verification. In these latter situations the
State may extend the 72-hour time frame for making benefits available
to no more than a total of seven days from the date of application.
Accessing sufficient card stock to operate a D-SNAP.
Replacing households EBT cards that are lost in a disaster
as soon as possible but within the card replacement timeframes required
at 7 CFR 274.6(b). If the normal EBT replacement process is to mail the
replacement card to the household's home, and the disaster response
requires card delivery to a disaster issuance site or alternative
address in a non-disaster area, the State must be able to override the
EBT system.
What does the rule require regarding replacing EBT Cards for currently
certified SNAP households?
The Department proposes that when SNAP households lose their EBT
cards in a disaster, the EBT disaster system design have procedures for
providing currently certified SNAP cases with replacement cards as soon
as possible, but always within the card replacement timeframes required
at 7 CFR 274.6(b). Specifically, current SNAP regulations require State
agencies to make replacement EBT cards available for pick up, or to
place the card in the mail, within two business days following notice
by the household to the State agency that the card has been lost,
stolen or damaged. However, under a D-SNAP situation, the Department
proposes to require State agencies to make reasonable efforts to
replace EBT cards sooner if possible; the Department is not requiring a
specific or more stringent timeframe for making card replacements under
D-SNAP situations in order to provide States and their EBT processors
some flexibility in unpredictable situations. However, the Department
also wishes to ensure that clients receive their cards as soon as
possible under circumstances in which the household may have not only
lost their card, but all their food as well. The Department welcomes
comments on whether or not a more specific and stricter card
replacement timeframe should be implemented for D-SNAP situations.
What are the D-SNAP reconciliation requirements?
The Department is proposing that the State be required to develop a
system for reconciling both cards and benefits. Cards shipped from a
central location would be required to be tracked until distributed
locally to households. Each issuance site would be required to maintain
a beginning and ending inventory and track new cards received, total
cards available, and cards issued. If the State assigns PINs, they must
also account for PIN mailers or envelopes to ensure adequate security,
except when the PIN is formulated by some other means, such as from the
Primary Account Number (which is a number on the EBT card and encoded
onto the card to identify the State and EBT account holder.) The State
would also be required to:
Reconcile the number of cards set-up with EBT accounts and
the number of cards issued and then research and explain any
discrepancies;
Track D-SNAP benefits separately from SNAP benefit
issuance; and
Adhere to FNS reconciliation guidelines so that they can
compare benefits posted to accounts with benefits issued by the State
eligibility system.
Currently Certified SNAP Households
How does the SNAP work during a disaster?
The Department recognizes that SNAP households will often need
replacement benefits or supplements. As noted earlier in the discussion
of the D-SNAP request, currently certified SNAP households are not
eligible for D-SNAP, but those affected by the disaster are generally
eligible for a supplemental issuance.
What are supplements?
Supplements are additional benefits issued to SNAP households
affected by the disaster in amounts that bring the households' benefit
level up to the maximum allotment for their household size.
Supplemental benefits provide parity between new D-SNAP households and
SNAP households. By virtue of their participation in SNAP, the food
needs of SNAP households are already known. The request to issue
individual or automatic supplements (see below), and the supporting
justification, must be included in the State's D-SNAP request. By
addressing the needs for SNAP households immediately, and prior to the
start of D-SNAP operations, overcrowding of SNAP participants seeking
service at D-SNAP locations can be minimized.
What is the difference between individual and automatic supplements?
Under this proposed rule, the State agency must decide if it is
most appropriate to issue supplemental benefits on an individual basis,
via the filing of an affidavit by the household, or automatically, to
all currently certified SNAP households in a designated area. To obtain
an individual supplement, households are required to
[[Page 28747]]
complete an affidavit of disaster impact. For this reason, individual
supplements work best in areas where there is a small-scale disaster
and applicant volume is not anticipated being very high. For individual
supplements to be effective, the State agency must have the capacity to
handle the individual requests for supplements, and issue the
supplemental benefits, while it is also taking D-SNAP applications.
Automatic supplements are additional benefits issued to all
currently certified SNAP households in a defined geographic area and
are appropriate when the majority of that area is impacted by a
disaster. They are intended to help SNAP households deal with the
impact of the disaster and generally work best when the State agency is
able to clearly identify areas in which households share the adverse
effects of the disaster, such as the loss of electrical power.
Automatic issuance can help the State agency quickly and efficiently
meet the needs of SNAP households, while freeing up staff and resources
to direct toward the population of new D-SNAP applicants.
The Department is proposing that States include their desire to
issue automatic supplements in their D-SNAP requests and demonstrate
their ability to effectively target the benefits to geographic areas
that were heavily impacted by the disaster. Any SNAP households not
designated to receive automatic supplements, that were living in the
area approved to operate D-SNAP and experienced disaster losses, may
still request supplemental benefits via an affidavit of disaster. As
with replacements benefits (discussed below), requests for automatic
supplements must be accompanied by supporting data which indicates that
a majority of the population in a given area has suffered an adverse
effect as a result of the disaster. States should work closely with FNS
to determine how to best find, use and evaluate available information
in a post-disaster situation. This can include information from power
companies, flood maps, or FEMA assessments.
Can already certified SNAP households obtain replacement benefits?
Replacement benefits are always available on an individual basis to
SNAP households that lose food purchased with their benefits in a
household misfortune. However, replacement issuances shall be provided
to current SNAP recipients only if a household reports a loss of food
purchased with SNAP benefits orally or in writing to the State within
10 days of the date the food is destroyed in a household misfortune.
The Department is proposing that the 10-day timeframe to report a loss
of food purchased with SNAP benefits be extended to 30 days when there
is a major disaster declared under 7 CFR part 280. Reports will be
considered timely if made to the State agency within 30 days of the
date the food is destroyed. Household misfortunes such as mass power
outages and flood and structural damage would qualify. In all other
cases, the 10-day timeframe to report a loss of food would remain the
same.
How do automatic/mass replacements work in D-SNAP?
As discussed earlier, the automatic/mass replacement requires a
waiver that allows a State agency to replace a portion/percentage of
currently certified households' monthly SNAP allotments in a disaster
without the requirement that a household request a replacement
individually, and travel to a local office to sign an affidavit of
disaster. With this option/waiver, households would not have the added
burden of signing paperwork and local offices would not have to process
cases manually for each household needing a benefit replacement.
As with automatic supplements, approval of the mass replacement
waiver typically requires a majority of the residences in the disaster
area (county, zip code) to have lost power or be in another way
affected by the disaster, resulting in the loss of food purchased with
their benefits. Outages of four hours or more are typically considered.
The replacement percentage is not fixed and generally depends on the
time of the month in which the disaster took place as well as the
State's issuance schedule. The extent and type of disaster (e.g.,
flooding or power outages), perishables/non-perishables, and
consumption, are also factors in determining the percentage of benefits
to be replaced. In preparing requests for mass replacements, States
need to assess the extent of the losses and provide justification for
the percentage they request. Further, a mass replacement waiver does
not remove the responsibility of local offices to process individual
affidavits before or after the waiver implementation as required by 7
CFR 274.6(a).
Reporting
What does the proposed rule require in the daily reports?
The Department proposes that States operating a D-SNAP submit a
daily report to FNS. Daily reports are used to monitor progress,
troubleshoot problem areas, inform FNS policy officials, ensure that
adequate funds are available in States' letters of credit and provide
information to allow responses to inquiries from the media and other
government agencies. The State agency would be required to begin
submitting reports on the day following the first day of D-SNAP
operations and continue submitting the reports on a daily basis until
all applications are processed. FNS is proposing that all States
utilize a daily reporting template provided by FNS in its D-SNAP
guidance. Data would be submitted by county, as indicated in the
template provided in FNS' D-SNAP guidance. The reports would contain:
1. Number of D-SNAP applications received
2. Number of new D-SNAP households approved
3. Number of new D-SNAP persons approved
4. Number of SNAP households receiving supplements
5. Number of people previously certified for SNAP approved for
supplements
6. Number of new D-SNAP households denied
7. Number of SNAP households receiving replacement issuance
8. Value of new D-SNAP benefits approved
9. Value of SNAP supplements approved
10. Value of SNAP replacement issuance
11. Average benefit per new D-SNAP household
12. Average benefit per SNAP household
13. Any additional information the State believes FNS should be
aware of
In addition to the quantitative data above, the inclusion of any
qualitative information on challenges the State may have encountered
with the daily reports will help keep State and Federal policymakers up
to date on the situation on the ground.
What other D-SNAP reports does the proposed rule require?
In addition to the daily report, the Department proposes that the
following be required from States with approved D-SNAPs:
Form FNS-292B, Report of Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program
Benefit Issuance for Disaster Relief--Within 45 days of the termination
of a D-SNAP operation, the State agency would be required to submit its
final disaster figures on form FNS-292B. All reports would be submitted
electronically in the Food Programs Reporting System (FPRS).
[[Page 28748]]
Form FNS 292B would contain the following issuance data for D-SNAP
operations:
Number of new households issued D-SNAP benefits
Total number of new persons issued D-SNAP benefits
Number of households certified in SNAP that were issued
supplements
Total value of benefits issued to D-SNAP households and
supplements issued to SNAP households.
The FNS-292B report would not include the value of any replacements
issued. States would report the value of replacements on the FNS 388
Monthly Issuance Report.
Form FNS-388, Monthly Issuance Report--Form FNS-388 would reflect
disaster issuance and participation figures, including replacement
benefits. Replacement benefits should be reported for the month for
which they are intended.
Form FNS-209, Status of Claims Against Households Report--In the
remarks section of the FNS-209, State agencies would be required to
indicate the number of D-SNAP claims established and collected. D-SNAP
claims must be identified on backup documentation in accounting systems
for form FNS-209.
Form FNS-46, Issuance Reconciliation Report--States would
be required to report D-SNAP issuance and returns in the Issuance and
Returns section of form FNS-46. Forms FNS-46 and FNS-388 should
reconcile with the reported net issuance.
Post-disaster Report--The Department is proposing that a post-
disaster review report be required and that it be comprised of four
parts: Comprehensive review, individual case reviews, problem analysis,
and proposed improvements to the disaster plan. The comprehensive
review should begin with an overview of the D-SNAP operation, including
where and when it took place, how it was staffed, and the total number
of applications approved and amount of benefits issued. The State
should then describe the systems or methods employed, document any
major issues (i.e. problems or challenges) encountered in any of the
areas below, and discuss the interventions used to address those
issues.
Certification systems
Fraud control
Issuance
Public information and outreach
Program accessibility
Security
The Department is proposing that individual case reviews include: A
sample of approved D-SNAP cases; a sample of actions taken to deny
applications for D-SNAP benefits; and a review of all approved
applications for State agency employees. The review of approved cases
would include: A case record review; an interview with the participant;
verification of each element of eligibility for the State's D-SNAP
program including identity, residency, income, household size and
disaster related expenses; a determination of eligibility for disaster
assistance; and an analysis of errors.
The Department proposes that States with 10,000 or more approved D-
SNAP households (excluding State employees) select a sample of 400
approved cases for review. States with less than 10,000 but more than
300 approved D-SNAP households would select a sample of between 300 and
400 cases as shown below. States with 300 or fewer households would
review all cases.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Approved D-SNAP households (N) Minimum sample size (n)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
10,000 and over........................... n = 400.
300 to 9,999.............................. n = 300 + [0. 01031 (N-
300)].
Under 300................................. n = all cases.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Department is proposing that a sample of 100 denied D-SNAP
applications be reviewed to identify errors made in not providing
benefits to eligible households. If there are fewer than 100 denied
applications, all denied applications would be reviewed. Finally, the
Department is proposing that States be required to review 100 percent
of all State agency employee applications--approved and denied.
For all three types of case reviews, no cases would be dropped from
the review results for any reason and the State would be required to
report information gathered from all case reviews.
State agencies would be required to submit the post disaster report
containing the results of the reviews, the problem analysis, and
proposed improvements (that would be included in their next D-SNAP plan
submission) within 6 months of the close of each D-SNAP operation.
Integrity
Along with the duplicate participation and verification discussed
above, the Department proposes that additional safeguards should be
built into D-SNAP operations.
What does the proposed rule require regarding fraud prevention?
An important aspect of fraud prevention is appropriate internal
controls. To ensure that only eligible households receive benefits and
that the amount of benefits issued is accurate, the Department is
proposing that States operating a D-SNAP be required to:
Input information for all household members into the
eligibility determination system to prevent individuals from obtaining
benefits as a member of more than one household.
Input denied applications into the eligibility
determination system each day, so that households that are denied and
later reapply are detected and referred to fraud prevention staff. Note
that such households may be eligible if their circumstances have
changed.
Check for duplicate participation by any individual
applying for D-SNAP using onsite or offsite computer databases (or in
disasters with very few applicants, hardcopy participant lists). Update
computer database participant lists every day.
Refer households without required verification or with
inconsistent information to onsite investigators or highly-experienced
staff for review.
What does the proposed rule require concerning employee fraud?
The Department recognizes that State agency employees may be
legitimately eligible for D-SNAP benefits. States should take care to
balance encouragement of eligible employees to apply for program
benefits with the risk of employee fraud. The Department proposes that
States be required to take these special measures to prevent employee
fraud:
Use separation of duties for certification and issuance.
Include a question on the D-SNAP application asking if
anyone in the household (or its authorized representative) is employed
by the State, State SNAP agency, or County, if applicable.
Utilize supervisors or investigators to conduct employee
certification interviews.
Audit all State agency employee applications and publicize
that policy. The proposed rule would require the State to review all
applications from its employees and to communicate that to employees up
front.
Are D-SNAP cases subject to quality control (QC) reviews?
Since the rules governing the determination of D-SNAP benefits
differ significantly from the SNAP, D-SNAP cases are not subject to QC
review and are not included when determining SNAP timeliness and
payment accuracy rates. This is specified in 7CFR 275.11(f) (1). This
is why the Department is proposing that States be required to
[[Page 28749]]
conduct a comprehensive review of general program performance and
reviews of individual cases.
What are the D-SNAP recipient claims collection requirements?
The Department is proposing that if a household receives D-SNAP
benefits to which it was not entitled, the State agency must establish
a claim against the household consistent with the claims collection
requirements of SNAP regulations. Claims must be established as soon as
possible after the close of the disaster operation. States may also
either follow their FNS-approved procedures and thresholds for
establishing claims in SNAP for claims arising from D-SNAP, or include
alternate procedures or thresholds in their D-SNAP request.
If a claim is established against a household for an overpayment of
SNAP benefits, the Department proposes that this amount may not be
collected from the D-SNAP allotment. However, claims based upon D-SNAP
over-issuances can be collected through a repayment agreement or
through offsets against SNAP issuances.
D-SNAP Close Out
What happens after D-SNAP operations end?
The Department proposes that close out of D-SNAP Operations
includes the following:
Close out the D-SNAP application/issuance sites;
Transition eligible cases to SNAP;
Submit issuance reporting and reconciliation;
Pursue fair hearings, claims and restored benefits; and
Submit post-disaster report.
What are the fair hearings requirements in a D-SNAP?
The proposed rule would require that:
Any household who applied for D-SNAP benefits and was
denied benefits may request a fair hearing;
A household which has requested a fair hearing is entitled
to an immediate onsite supervisory review;
Households not satisfied with the outcome of this review
retain the right to request a fair hearing through the normal process;
and
The number of fair hearings is reported on form FNS-366B,
Program Activity Statement.
Are households entitled to restored benefits in D-SNAP?
SNAP regulations require State agencies to issue restored benefits
to households when benefits were lost due to an agency error and when a
denial of benefits is subsequently reversed. The Department proposes
that this requirement also apply to D-SNAP benefits; State agencies
should follow their normal procedures for issuance in such cases. The
State's eligibility system must clearly indicate that an issuance was a
restored D-SNAP benefit.
Executive Order 12866 and Executive Order 13563
Executive Orders 12866 and 13563 direct agencies to assess all
costs and benefits of available regulatory alternatives and, if
regulation is necessary, to select regulatory approaches that maximize
net benefits (including potential economic, environmental, public
health and safety effects, distributive impacts, and equity). Executive
Order 13563 emphasizes the importance of quantifying both costs and
benefits, of reducing costs, of harmonizing rules, and of promoting
flexibility.
This proposed rule has been designated a not significant regulatory
action. Accordingly, the rule has not been reviewed by the Office of
Management and Budget.
Regulatory Impact Analysis
This proposed rule has been designated as not significant by OMB,
therefore, no Regulatory Impact Analysis is required.
Regulatory Flexibility Act
The Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. 601-612) requires Agencies
to analyze the impact of rulemaking on small entities and consider
alternatives that would minimize any significant impacts on small
entities. Pursuant to that review, FNS Administrator, Audrey Rowe, has
certified that this proposed rule would not have a significant impact
on small entities. State agencies that administer SNAP will be affected
to the extent they choose to implement major changes in program
operations. State agencies will also be affected to the extent they
perform ME reviews of large, medium and small project areas.
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act
Title II of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 (UMRA), Public
Law 104-4, establishes requirements for Federal agencies to assess the
effects of their regulatory actions on State, local and tribal
governments and the private sector. Under section 202 of the UMRA, the
Department generally must prepare a written statement, including a cost
benefit analysis, for proposed and final rules with ``Federal
mandates'' that may result in expenditures by State, local or tribal
governments, in the aggregate, or the private sector, of $146 million
or more (when adjusted for 2015 inflation; GDP deflator source: Table
1.1.9 at https://www.bea.gov/iTable) in any one year. When such a
statement is needed for a rule, Section 205 of the UMRA generally
requires the Department to identify and consider a reasonable number of
regulatory alternatives and adopt the most cost effective or least
burdensome alternative that achieves the objectives of the rule.
This rule does not contain Federal mandates (under the regulatory
provisions of Title II of the UMRA) for State, local and Tribal
governments or the private sector of $146 million or more in any one
year. Thus, the rule is not subject to the requirements of sections 202
and 205 of the UMRA.
Executive Order 12372
SNAP is listed in the Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance under
No. 10.551. For the reasons set forth in the final rule in 7 CFR part
3015, subpart V and related notice (48 FR 29115, June 24, 1983), this
Program is excluded from the scope of Executive Order 12372, which
requires intergovernmental consultation with State and local officials.
Federalism Impact Statement
Executive Order 13132 requires Federal agencies to consider the
impact of their regulatory actions on State and local governments.
Where such actions have federalism implications, agencies are directed
to provide a statement for inclusion in the preamble to the regulations
describing the agency's considerations in terms of the three categories
called for under section (6)(b)(2)(B) of Executive Order 13132. FNS has
considered the impact of this rule on State and local governments and
has determined that this rule does not have federalism implications.
This proposed rule does not impose substantial or direct compliance
costs on State and local governments. Therefore, under Section 6(b) of
the Executive order, a federalism summary impact statement is not
required.
Prior Consultation With State Officials
While FNS did not seek direct consultation with State officials on
this proposed rule, FNS staff works with several different States'
staff on D-SNAP requests and operations every year. This has provided
valuable feedback on the need for flexibility in program design and
operations. In addition, FNS regional offices host periodic training
meetings and review States' D-SNAP plans. These interactions provide
insights into the
[[Page 28750]]
challenges States face and are reflected in this proposed rule.
Nature of Concerns and the Need To Issue This Rule
The primary intent of this NPRM is to improve clarity for States in
their planning for and requests to implement a D-SNAP. This should help
ensure timely approval of requests and improved Federal/State
coordination in responding to disaster situations. The NPRM is also
intended to inform States of their responsibilities in reporting and
monitoring D-SNAP. The USDA Office of Inspector General has recommended
publication of regulations for the D-SNAP to improve controls over D-
SNAP operations and reduce the potential for threats to program
integrity.
Extent to Which We Meet Those Concerns
The Department believes that the proposals in this rulemaking would
provide the necessary clarity and structure for D-SNAP planning,
requests, and reporting while maintaining the needed flexibility for
States. In drafting this NPRM, FNS considered its impact on State and
local agencies. In addition, the Department is seeking comments on
those areas of discretion and will use those comments to inform its
decision making before issuing final regulations.
Executive Order 12988
This proposed rule has been reviewed under Executive Order 12988,
Civil Justice Reform. This proposed rule, when published as a final
rule, is intended to have preemptive effect with respect to any State
or local laws, regulations or policies which conflict with its
provisions or which would otherwise impede its full implementation.
This proposed rule is not intended to have retroactive applicability
unless so specified in the ``Effective Date'' paragraph of the final
rule. Prior to any judicial challenge to the provisions of this
rulemaking or the application of its provisions, all applicable
administrative procedures must be exhausted.
Executive Order 13175
This proposed rule has been reviewed in accordance with the
requirements of Executive Order 13175, ``Consultation and Coordination
with Indian Tribal Governments.'' Executive Order 13175 requires
Federal agencies to consult and coordinate with tribes on a government-
to-government basis on policies that have tribal implications,
including regulations, legislative comments or proposed legislation,
and other policy statements or actions that have substantial direct
effects on one or more Indian tribes, on the relationship between the
Federal Government and Indian tribes, or on the distribution of power
and responsibilities between the Federal Government and Indian tribes.
FNS has assessed the impact of this proposed rule on Indian tribes
and determined that this rule does not, to our knowledge, have Tribal
implications that require tribal consultation under EO 13175. On
February 18, 2015 the agency held a webinar for tribal participation
and comments. During the comment period, FNS did not receive any
comments on the proposed rule. If a Tribe requests consultation, FNS
will work with the Office of Tribal Relations to ensure meaningful
consultation is provided for those changes, additions and modifications
identified herein that are not expressly mandated by Congress.
Civil Rights Impact Analysis
FNS has reviewed this proposed rule in accordance with the
Department Regulation 4300-4, ``Civil Rights Impact Analysis,'' to
identify and address any major civil rights impacts the rule might have
on minorities, women, and persons with disabilities. After a careful
review of the rule's intent and provisions, and the characteristics of
SNAP participants, FNS has determined that an important impact of this
proposed rule will be to help alleviate the adverse effects of
disasters on certain protected classes. All data available to FNS
indicate that protected individuals have the same opportunity to
participate in D-SNAP as non-protected individuals. FNS specifically
prohibits the State and local government agencies that administer SNAP
from engaging in actions that discriminate based on race, color,
national origin, gender, age, disability, marital or family status
(SNAP's nondiscrimination policy can be found at 7 CFR 272.6 (a)).
Where State agencies have options, and they choose to implement a
certain provision, they must implement it in such a way that it
complies with the regulations at 7 CFR 272.6.
Paperwork Reduction Act
The Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (44 U.S.C. Chap. 35; see 5 CFR
part 1320) requires that the Office of Management and Budget (OMB)
approve all collections of information by a Federal agency from the
public before they can be implemented. Respondents are not required to
respond to any collection of information unless it displays a current
valid OMB control number. This proposed rule contains requirements that
are subject to review and approval by OMB; therefore, FNS has submitted
a new information collection request under OMB Control No: 0584-NEW
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP): Disaster Supplemental
Nutrition Assistance Program (D-SNAP) Plans, Procedures, and Reports
which contains the proposed reporting burden from adoption of the
proposals in the rule, for OMB's review and approval. The estimated
burden for the information collections in the proposed rulemaking
accompanying this request will be merged into the approved OMB Control
Numbers listed in the following sections, contingent upon OMB approval.
When the information collection requirements have been approved, FNS
will publish a separate action in the Federal Register announcing OMB's
approval. The D-SNAP certification burden for State participation is
included in the currently approved reporting burden under the OMB
Control No. 0584-0064, SNAP: Applications, Periodic Reports, and
Notices (expiration date: 4/30/2016), which includes all information
collection activities associated with the certification of
participating and applicant households. Under SNAP regulations, States
are responsible for designing their own forms (this burden is included
in OMB No. 0584-0064 and will not be duplicated here) including the
application for D-SNAP assistance used by individual households. The
burden associated with Statewide D-SNAP plans is included in the
currently approved burden for OMB Control No. 0584-0083, SNAP:
Operating Guidelines, Forms, and Waivers, Program and Budget Summary
Statement (expiration date 04/30/2017), which includes all the
information collection activities associated with the preparation,
review, and submission of updated D-SNAP plans by State agencies. The
burden associated with the submission of State agency requests to
operate a D-SNAP to FNS is included under the currently approved burden
for OMB Control No. 0584-0336, SNAP: Supplemental Nutrition Assistance
for Victims of Disaster (expiration date 11/30/2015).
Comments are invited on: (a) Whether the proposed collection of
information is necessary for the proper performance of the functions of
the agency, including whether the information shall have practical
utility; (b) the accuracy of the agency's estimate of the burden of the
proposed collection of information, including the validity of the
methodology and assumptions used; (c) ways to enhance the quality,
utility, and
[[Page 28751]]
clarity of the information to be collected; and (d) ways to minimize
the burden of the collection of information on those who are to
respond, including use of appropriate automated, electronic,
mechanical, or other technological collection techniques or other forms
of information technology.
Send comments to the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs,
OMB, attention: Desk Officer for FNS, Washington, DC 20503. Please also
send a copy of your comments to Sasha Gersten-Paal, Branch Chief,
Certification Policy Branch, Food and Nutrition Service, U.S.
Department of Agriculture, 3101 Park Center Drive, Alexandria, VA
22302. For further information, or for copies of the information
collection package, please contact Sasha Gersten-Paal at the above
address or via email at Gersten-Paal@fns.usda.gov.
All responses to this notice will be summarized and included in the
request for OMB approval. All comments will also become a matter of
public record. These proposed changes are contingent upon OMB approval
under the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995. When the information
collection requirements have been approved, FNS will publish a separate
action in the Federal Register announcing OMB's approval.
Comments on the information collection pursuant to this proposed
rule must be received by July 11, 2016.
Title: Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP): Disaster
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (D-SNAP) Plans, Procedures,
and Reports.
OMB Number: 0584-NEW.
Expiration Date: N/A.
Type of Request: Information Collection Request.
Abstract: The Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act (1974),
as amended by the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Assistance Act
(1988) (enclosed), and Section (5)(h) of the Food and Nutrition Act of
2008 (the Act) provides the Secretary of Agriculture with the authority
to establish temporary emergency standards of eligibility for
households who are survivors of a disaster that disrupts commercial
channels of food distribution after those channels have been restored.
This proposed rule would establish the requirements for planning,
requesting and monitoring D-SNAP while maintaining State flexibility in
program design within the basic eligibility requirements for D-SNAP.
This information collection accounts for information that State
agencies are required to provide to FNS in support of a request to
operate a D-SNAP. As this proposed rule merely codifies practices State
agencies already perform, it will have minimal impact on the State
agency workloads.
Respondents: 53 State agencies.
Estimated Number of Responses per Respondent: 53 annual reviews of
D-SNAP plan; 5 updates of D-SNAP plan; 9 D-SNAP requests; 45 D-SNAP
daily reports; 9 D-SNAP post-Disaster reports.
The Department is proposing in this rulemaking that States would be
required to review their existing Disaster Plan on at least an annual
basis, and when applicable, submit a revision or a notice of no change,
by the 15th of August each year. As the majority of States have already
prepared disaster plans, the Department estimates that it will take an
average of 6.58 staff hours per State each year to review their
Disaster Plans, for a total burden of 349 hours (53 States x 1 time
annually = 53 total annual response x 6.58 hours = 349 hours). The
Department further estimates that on average five of these States will
update their plans and require an additional 2.5 hours to do so, for an
annual total of 12.5 burden hours. Once approved by OMB, this proposed
burden will be merged with the currently approved burden for OMB
Control No. 0584-0083, SNAP: Operating Guidelines, Forms, and Waivers,
Program and Budget Summary Statement (expiration date 04/30/2017),
which includes all the information collection activities associated
with the preparation, review, and submission of updated D-SNAP plans by
State agencies.
The number of disasters that occur annually and the average number
of households affected by the disasters cannot be predicted. For
example, during the period from fiscal year 2009 through fiscal year
2014, the number of State requests for disaster programs ranged from 3
to 23 requests per year. However, the Department estimates an average
of 9 State agencies will submit 1 D-SNAP request per year to operate D-
SNAPs for a total annual request of 9 applications per year. A D-SNAP
request normally contains a request to waive the normal SNAP operating
procedures and outlines the State's proposed procedures including:
Description of incident; geographic area; application period; benefit
period; eligibility criteria; currently certified SNAP households
eligibility; affected population; electronic benefit card issuance
process; logistical plans for D-SNAP rollout; staffing; public
information outreach; duplicate participation check process; fraud
prevention strategies; and employee application procedures. It is
estimated that preparation of a request under the proposed rule will
require approximately 10 staff hours for each State, for a total of 90
burden hours. Once approved by OMB, this proposed burden will be merged
with the currently approved burden for OMB Control No. 0584-0083, SNAP:
Operating Guidelines, Forms, and Waivers, Program and Budget Summary
Statement (expiration date 04/30/2017).
In addition, the Department is proposing that States operating a D-
SNAP must submit a daily report to FNS. Daily reports are used to
monitor progress, troubleshoot problem areas, inform FNS policy
officials, ensure that adequate funds are available, and respond to
inquiries from the media and other government agencies. The State
agency should begin submitting reports on the day following the first
day of D-SNAP operations and continue submitting the reports on a daily
basis until the end of the application period--typically five days. It
is estimated that 0.5 hours will be required to prepare each daily
report. Therefore, the burden would be 22.5 total hours for these
reports (nine disasters x five reports x 0.5 hours = 22.5). The
Department further proposes that a post-disaster report be submitted
that includes four parts: a comprehensive review, individual case
reviews, problem analysis, and proposed improvements. It is estimated
that this report will require 0.5 hours to complete so the total burden
for nine disaster reports would be 4.5 hours. FNS will not require a
standardized form or specific format for daily reports or post-disaster
reports, due to the dynamic nature of emergency situations and the need
to quickly respond to conditions on the ground. Once approved by OMB,
this proposed burden will be merged with the currently approved burden
for OMB Control No. 0584-0083, SNAP: Operating Guidelines, Forms, and
Waivers, Program and Budget Summary Statement (expiration date 04/30/
2017).
No new recordkeeping burden is estimated.
The average burden per respondent is summarized in the following
chart, with an estimated total annual burden of 478 hours. However as
noted above, States have been performing many of these practices for
years, so the actual new burden would be significantly less.
[[Page 28752]]
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
States
Section of Regulation Requirement or burden responding per Responses per Number of Hours per Total burden
activity year respondent responses response hours
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
280.1..................................... Annual review of D-SNAP Plan 53 1 53 6.58 348.7
280.1..................................... Revision of D-SNAP plan..... 5 1 5 2.5 12.5
280.3..................................... D-SNAP Request.............. 9 1 9 10 90
280.8..................................... D-SNAP Daily report......... 9 5 45 0.5 22.5
280.8..................................... D-SNAP Post Disaster Report. 9 1 9 0.5 4.5
rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
Totals................................ ............................ 53 2.28 121 3.95 478
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
E-Government Act Compliance
FNS is committed to complying with the E-Government Act of 2002
(Pub. L 107-347) to promote the use of the Internet and other
information technologies that provide increased opportunities for
citizen access to government information and services and for other
purposes.
List of Subjects
7 CFR Part 272
Alaska, Civil rights, Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program,
Grant programs--social programs, Penalties, Reporting and recordkeeping
requirements, Unemployment compensation, Wages.
7 CFR Part 274
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, Grant programs--social
programs, Reporting and recordkeeping requirements.
7 CFR Part 280
Emergency food assistance for victims of disasters.
For reasons set forth in the preamble, 7 CFR parts 272, 274, and
280 are proposed to be amended as follows:
PART 272--REQUIREMENTS FOR PARTICIPATING STATE AGENCIES
0
1. The authority citation for part 272 continues to read as follows:
Authority: 7 U.S.C. 2011-2036.
0
2. In Sec. 272.2 revise paragraph (a)(2), (d)(1)(ii), and (e)(5) to
read as follows:
Sec. 272.2 Plan of operation.
(a) * * *
(2) Content. The basic components of the State Plan of Operation
(``the Plan'') are the Federal/State Agreement, the Budget Projection
Statement, and the Program Activity Statement. In addition, certain
attachments to the Plan are specified in this section and in Sec.
272.3. The requirements for the basic components and attachments are
specified in Sec. 272.2(c) and Sec. 272.2(d), respectively. The
Federal/State Agreement is the legal agreement between the State and
the Department of Agriculture. This Agreement is the means by which the
State elects to operate the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program
and to administer the program in accordance with the Food and Nutrition
Act of 2008 and the FNS-approved State Plan of Operation. The Budget
Projection Statement and Program Activity Statement provide information
on the number of actions and amounts budgeted for various functional
areas, such as certification and issuance. The Plan's attachments
include the Quality Control Sample Plan, the Disaster Plan, the
Employment and Training Plan, the optional Nutrition Education Plan,
the optional plan for Program informational activities directed to low-
income households, the optional plan for intercepting Unemployment
Compensation (UC) benefits for collecting claims for intentional
Program violations, the Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements
(SAVE) Plan, and the plan for the State Income and Eligibility
Verification System. The State agency shall either include the Workfare
Plan in its State Plan of Operation or append the Workfare Plan to the
State Plan of Operation, as appropriate, in accordance with Sec.
273.22(b)(3) of this chapter. The Workfare Plan shall be submitted
separately, in accordance with Sec. 273.22(b)(1) of this chapter. The
ADP/CIS Plan is considered part of the State Plan of Operation but is
submitted separately as prescribed under Sec. 272.2(e)(8). State
agencies and/or political subdivisions selected to operate a Simplified
Application/Standardized Benefit Project shall include that Project's
Work Plan in the State Plan of Operation. The Plan's attachments shall
also include the Mail Issuance Loss Reporting Level Plan.
* * * * *
(d) * * *
(1) * * *
(ii) Disaster Plan as required by Sec. 280.1(b) of this chapter,
or certification that a previously submitted Disaster Plan has been
reviewed and remains current;
* * * * *
(e) * * *
(5) Disaster plan. State agencies shall review their existing
disaster plan on at least an annual basis and submit a revision, if
necessary, or a notice of no change, by the 15th of August (or as
negotiated by individual states) each year for FNS approval.
* * * * *
PART 274--ISSUANCE AND USE OF PROGRAM BENEFITS
0
3. The authority citation for part 274 continues to read as follows:
Authority: 7 U.S.C. 2011-2036.
0
4. Revise Sec. 274.6 (a)(3)(i) to read as follows:
Sec. 274.6 Replacement issuances and cards to households.
(a) * * *
(3) * * *
(i) Replacement issuances shall be provided only if a household
timely reports a loss orally or in writing. When the loss is a
Presidentially-declared disaster (with or without individual
assistance) the report shall be considered timely if it is made to the
State agency within 30 days of the date food purchased with Program
benefits is destroyed in the disaster. When the loss is the result of
other household misfortune, the report shall be considered timely if it
is made to the State agency within 10 days of the date food purchased
with Program benefits is destroyed.
* * * * *
PART 280--DISASTER SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM (D-
SNAP)
0
5. Revise the part heading to read as set out above.
0
6. Revise part 280 to read as follows:
PART 280--DISASTER SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM (D-
SNAP)
Sec.
280.1 Purpose.
280.2 Eligibility and benefits.
280.3 Disaster request.
[[Page 28753]]
280.4 Application processing and certification periods.
280.5 Households participating in the SNAP when D-SNAP is operating.
280.6 Reconciliation.
280.7 Post disaster review and corrections.
280.8 D-SNAP reporting.
Authority: 7 U.S.C. 2011-2036.
Sec. 280.1 Purpose.
(a) This section establishes the requirements for planning,
requesting, operating, and reporting on a D-SNAP. In addition, the
appropriate Food and Nutrition Service directives and guidance provide
additional detail and direction on the steps States should take to
prepare for an emergency situation, and the procedures States should
employ in operating D-SNAP.
(b) Planning for D-SNAP. State agencies shall review their existing
disaster plan on at least an annual basis and submit a revision, if
necessary, or a notice of no change, by the 15th of August (or as
negotiated by individual states) each year for FNS approval; this
submission shall be an attachment of the Plan of Operation as provided
in Sec. 272.2 of this chapter. As specified in Sec. 280.8(f), FNS
will require State agencies to amend the plan if deficiencies are found
in a D-SNAP post-disaster review. The plan shall include:
(1) Identification of Federal and State government agencies
involved in disaster relief activities in the State during a disaster,
as well as a description of responsibilities for each agency.
(2) Key points of contact. Provide names, positions, and phone
numbers of county/local, State, and Federal government officials and
their back-ups who are key contact persons during a disaster (including
the State agency disaster coordinator).
(3) Community partners. Identify private disaster relief agencies
within the State such as the Red Cross, Salvation Army, or community
groups and a description of their role in D-SNAP implementation.
(4) SNAP staffing and resources. Identify staffing and related
resources available to assist in a disaster and how they will be
mobilized to target disaster areas in need. Explain how the State/
counties will manage the increased administrative burden associated
with running a D-SNAP and SNAP operations simultaneously.
(5) D-SNAP application system development. Describe application
systems to be used for D-SNAP household management, including any
workarounds to the SNAP system, considerations associated with running
SNAP and D-SNAP operations concurrently, compliance with D-SNAP
reporting requirements, etc.
(6) Issuance system. Describe the issuance systems to be used for
D-SNAP household management.
(7) EBT card stock. Identify EBT card stock available, type of
cards to be used, steps and timeline for ordering additional cards, and
any special procedures or resources that will be needed to meet SNAP
and D-SNAP issuance timeframes, including having cards available at D-
SNAP certification sites.
(8) Application sites. Describe site selection procedures,
including potential application/issuance sites for disasters that vary
in size and scope and any agreements in place with those locations. If
D-SNAP will operate out of local offices, explain how application sites
will handle running D-SNAP and SNAP concurrently.
(9) Demographic data. Identify general demographic data that can
help the agency tailor its response to a disaster. Identify resources
for disaster impact data, including preliminary data assessments, flood
maps, or electrical outage data.
(10) Public information and outreach. Describe public information
strategy to ensure that timely, accurate information reaches households
potentially eligible for D-SNAP benefits. Outline roles, expectations,
and responsibilities of any SNAP outreach partners included in the
State Outreach Plan that will assist with D-SNAP.
(11) Retailer communication. Describe procedures to notify
retailers of new waivers (see discussion of the potential for hot
foods, below) and new D-SNAP households.
(12) Procedures to reduce applicant hardship. Outline steps States
will take to reduce hardship for D-SNAP applicants and the already
certified SNAP caseload, including provisions for security, human
needs, language services, etc.
(13) Certification process. Describe the specifics of the
certification process including potential application sites, staffing,
separation of eligibility and issuance, how application sites will
manage large crowds, and plans for ensuring access to persons with
disabilities, the elderly and other vulnerable populations. If online
pre-registrations are to be used by workers or households, describe
that process and back-up systems in place if technical issues are
encountered.
(14) DSED. Include if the DSED will be used and, if so, specify the
income limits.
(15) Household materials. Include sample household application and
household notices.
(16) Issuance process. Describe how benefits will be made available
within 72 hours of D-SNAP application and how to ensure continuation of
SNAP certification, issuance, and other actions concurrently. Indicate
how the State will monitor stock levels and ensure sufficient EBT card
stock. Describe EBT card reconciliation and security procedures,
including tracking D-SNAP benefits separately from SNAP benefit
issuance and adherence to FNS reconciliation guidelines, so that
benefits posted to accounts can be compared to benefits issued by the
State eligibility system.
(17) Security and fraud prevention plans. Describe how States will
ensure security and mitigate the risk of fraud, including a specific
plan for handling applications submitted by State agency employees,
procedures for handling questionable applications, and process for
checking all household members for duplicate participation.
(18) Disaster reporting and post-disaster review report. Describe
procedures to ensure that required federal reporting and post-disaster
review reports will be complete and timely.
(19) Reasonable accommodations for individuals with disabilities.
Describe what special accommodations will be made for individuals with
disabilities at application and issuance sites.
(20) Circumstances unique to the State which may affect D-SNAP
operations, including: coordination of resources among County-level
administrations, how to serve isolated or homebound populations,
development of procedural modifications to allow SNAP systems to
accommodate D-SNAP operations, and contingency plans for local offices
located in flood plains or otherwise subject to closure.
(c) Training. The State shall issue instructions and provide
training to project area offices on the handling of disaster assistance
operations to ensure prior understanding of disaster procedures and
prompt action upon issuance of a disaster declaration. At a minimum,
States shall provide D-SNAP training to at least one manager (perhaps a
D-SNAP coordinator) from each SNAP local office and call center in the
State.
(d) State Systems Requirements for D-SNAP. State automated systems
shall have the ability to:
(1) Check for duplicate participation as required in Sec.
280.4(e).
(2) Meet FNS reconciliation requirements that D-SNAP benefits
[[Page 28754]]
posted to accounts be compared to benefits issued by the State
eligibility system.
(3) Generate the reports required in Sec. 280.8. States systems
shall have the ability to track disaster benefits separately from SNAP
benefit issuance. States systems shall have the ability to allow
tracking of multiple D-SNAPs simultaneously, if the State is struck by
two disasters within a short timeframe.
(e) EBT Systems and D-SNAP. Each State shall be prepared to issue
D-SNAP benefits through its EBT system during a disaster. The EBT
system shall have the ability to coordinate with the State's
eligibility system and the State's EBT contractor's system. A State's
D-SNAP issuance plan shall incorporate procedures for:
(1) Ensuring that approved households have benefits available,
including EBT cards and PINs no more than 72 hours from when the
application was filed, unless there is questionable information on the
application that requires verification. If there is questionable
information, the State may extend the 72-hour time frame for making
cards and benefits available to no more than a total of seven days from
the date of application.
(2) Accessing sufficient EBT card stock to operate a D-SNAP.
(3) Replacing households EBT cards that are lost in a disaster as
soon as possible but within the card replacement timeframes required at
7 CFR 274.6(b). If the normal EBT replacement process is to mail the
replacement card to the household's home, and the disaster response
requires card delivery to a disaster issuance site or alternative
address in a non-disaster area, the State must be able to override the
EBT system.
Sec. 280.2 Eligibility and benefits.
(a) Eligibility. To be eligible for D-SNAP during a disaster a
household must meet all of the following criteria:
(1) At the time of the disaster, the household must have been
residing within the geographical area authorized for disaster
procedures at the time of the disaster. Such a household may be
certified for disaster issuance even though it presently is occupying
temporary accommodations outside of the disaster area (although it
would need to come to the certification site to be certified for D-
SNAP). States may also choose to extend eligibility to those who worked
in the disaster area at the time of the disaster. When States submit
their D-SNAP requests, they should specify if they will serve only
households that lived in the disaster area, or either lived or worked
in the disaster area.
(2) The household will purchase food and prepare meals during the
disaster benefit period. A household residing in a temporary shelter
which is providing all its meals shall be ineligible.
(3) The household has experienced at least one of the following
adverse effects of the disaster: loss or inaccessibility of income,
inaccessibility of liquid resources, or disaster-related expenses. At
the State's option, households whose only disaster-related expense is
food loss may be considered otherwise eligible for D-SNAP. States
electing this option must indicate it in their D-SNAP request.
(i) Loss or inaccessibility of income involves a reduction or
termination of income or a significant delay in receipt of income. This
could occur, for example, if a disaster has caused a place of
employment to close or reduce its work days, if paychecks or other
payments are lost or destroyed, if there is a significant delay in the
issuance of paychecks, or if the work location is inaccessible due to
the disaster.
(ii) Inaccessibility of liquid resources includes situations in
which the household is unable to access cash resources for a portion of
the disaster benefit period.
(iii) Regarding disaster-related expenses that the household has
incurred during the disaster benefit period that result from the
effects of the disaster: the FNS Disaster SNAP Guidance provides the
specific expenses that shall be considered disaster-related, but States
can request FNS approval of other reasonable expenses in their disaster
request.
(b) Determining income. (1) To be eligible to receive D-SNAP
benefits, a household's net income received or expected to be received
during the benefit period, in addition to its accessible liquid
resources, minus any disaster-related expenses, shall not exceed the
disaster gross income limit.
(2) Accessible liquid resources are determined on the first day of
the benefit period; any funds received during the remainder of the
benefit period will be counted as income. Accessible liquid resources
include cash on hand, and funds in accessible checking and saving
accounts on the first day of the benefit period. Accessible liquid
resources do not include:
(i) Retirement accounts;
(ii) Disaster insurance payments;
(iii) Disaster assistance received or expected to be received
during the benefit period; and
(iv) Payments from Federal, state or county/local government
agencies or disaster assistance organizations (including disaster-
related Unemployment Compensation).
(3) The most recent disaster gross income limit calculated by FNS
shall be used to determine the maximum allowable income for each
household size. The disaster gross income limit is calculated by adding
together the maximum monthly net income limit, the maximum standard
income deduction amount, and the maximum capped shelter expense
deduction for each household size.
(c) D-SNAP deductions. (1) Disaster-related expenses are deductible
if they have been incurred during the disaster period. If the household
receives or anticipates receiving a reimbursement for these expenses
during the disaster period, only remaining expense amounts shall be
deductible.
(2) States shall elect one of the following options to determine if
households have disaster-related expenses and the amount of the expense
to use in determining D-SNAP income. The option selected shall be
identified in the State's D-SNAP request:
(i) Use of actual disaster-related expenses identified in the
Disaster SNAP Guidance referenced in paragraph (a)(3)(iii) of this
section. Households shall be screened to verify their residence in the
affected area. Under this option, the State may require that households
experience at least one disaster-related expense other than or in
addition to food-loss in order to be eligible for the D-SNAP, while
still considering food-loss in calculating a household's cumulative
disaster-related expenses. Alternatively, the State may choose to
consider households that have experienced food loss alone as their
disaster-related expense to be otherwise eligible for the D-SNAP.
(ii) Use of a Disaster Standard Expense Deduction (DSED.) For
households with $100 or more in deductible disaster-related expenses,
the DSED shall be added to the disaster gross income limit, and
households whose take-home pay plus available liquid resources is less
than or equal to this amount (DSED + the disaster gross income limit)
shall qualify for D-SNAP benefits. The DSED shall not be applied to any
household if food loss is their only disaster-related expense.
(3) A State using ``food loss alone'' in paragraph (c)(2)(i) of
this section shall verify using available information such as power
outage maps showing affected homes or zip codes. The use of this
information should be widely publicized and households shall be
[[Page 28755]]
screened upon arrival to verify their residence in the affected area.
Households reporting excessively large amounts of food loss, or any
other questionable information, shall be referred to fraud
investigators or senior staff for further review.
(d) Benefit period and benefit amount. (1) Households meeting the
eligibility criteria in Sec. 280.2(a) through (c) shall receive the
full SNAP allotment for their household size as provided under SNAP.
SNAP allotments are updated yearly and available on the FNS Web site.
For households already on SNAP and residing in an approved D-SNAP area
that incur a disaster-related expense and submit an affidavit to that
effect, States shall supplement their SNAP benefits to bring them up to
the maximum allotment for their household size.
(2) Household size and composition is established as of the first
day of the disaster benefit period. The household includes those people
living together, and purchasing and preparing food together at the time
of a disaster. D-SNAP household does not include those people with whom
applicants are temporarily staying due to the disaster.
(3) The benefit period is the 30-day period approved by FNS for
each D-SNAP, except in extraordinary circumstances as determined and
approved by FNS. The benefit period is the period during which
disaster-related expenses are to be counted; it is also the start date
used to determine household composition and resources. Only income
received, expenses incurred and resources that are accessible during
the benefit period are considered in determining D-SNAP eligibility.
The benefit period shall begin on the date of the disaster or the date
of any mandatory evacuation preceding the disaster. This date is
generally the first day of the ``Incident Period'' provided by the
Presidential Disaster Declaration. State agencies needing to modify
dates from those in their approved D-SNAP request must seek FNS
approval to do so. States requesting an extension must address the
ongoing demand for assistance and program integrity concerns.
Sec. 280.3 Disaster request.
(a) Requests for D-SNAP. (1) The State agency may request
authorization from FNS to implement temporary D-SNAP procedures when
all or part of a SNAP project area as defined in 7 CFR 271.2 has been
struck by a disaster, commercial channels of food distribution are
available, there is a Presidentially-declared disaster that includes
Individual Assistance (IA), and SNAP cannot respond to the temporary
food needs due to the number of affected households.
(2) The request shall be submitted when the affected community and
State agency have recovered to allow for an effective administration of
the D-SNAP (as determined by the State agency), including training for
D-SNAP operations. The request must be submitted to allow for
implementation of D-SNAP within a reasonable time period following the
Individual Assistance declaration. The planned implementation date
shall also allow sufficient time for the State to publicly notify the
affected population in the disaster area of the availability of D-SNAP.
(b) Content of request. Requests must be submitted with a signed
cover memorandum from the State and include thorough explanations of
the following components:
(1) A description the disaster--what happened, the date the
disaster began, and the affected area.
(2) The geographic area (list of the project areas affected), and
explain any differences between the area included in the presidential
declaration (if applicable) and the requested area in which to operate
the D-SNAP.
(3) A draft press release, sample application, preliminary damage
assessments, and map of disaster area. In addition to these required
items, other supporting documentation may be included.
(4) The start and end dates of the application period. If the
application period will be staggered, give dates for each county/area.
Note if application sites will be open over the weekend or for extended
hours.
(5) The start and end dates of the 30-day benefit period. The start
of the benefit period should generally match the first day of the
``incident period'' on the disaster declaration. If not, then the State
should explain the reason for the difference.
(6) Identification of any options the State has chosen, including
whether or not food loss only will be a qualifying expense, and if
households that worked but did not live in the disaster area will be
eligible.
(7) Whether only households that lived in the disaster area will be
eligible for D-SNAP, or if households that only worked in the disaster
area will also be eligible.
(8) Whether a DSED is being used. If so, include the income limits.
(9) Whether ``food loss alone'' will be included as a criterion for
eligibility.
(10) Whether supplements will be automatic or individual (by
affidavit) for currently certified SNAP households. If automatic,
describe who is eligible and include supporting data. Also, indicate an
estimate of the value of issuances for automatic supplements. Requests
for automatic supplements must be accompanied by supporting data which
indicate that a majority of the population in a given area has suffered
an adverse effect as a result of the disaster. If individual
supplements are to be used, include information on the process for
requesting supplements--by phone/mail affidavit, electronically, or in
person at local office/D-SNAP application site.
(11) The estimated total number of people, homes, businesses, etc.
impacted by the disaster; estimates of anticipated D-SNAP applicants;
number of currently certified SNAP households to be served; and
explanation of how both estimates were derived.
(12) A description of issuance procedures, the number of EBT cards
on hand, and plans for requesting, receiving, and distributing
additional cards as needed.
(13) A description of application sites, security/crowd control,
and procedures to ensure program access and reasonable accommodation
for persons with disabilities.
(14) Plans for utilizing staff from other program areas, counties,
or States, as appropriate. Indicate number of staff available and how
staff/supervisors will be distributed among the application sites.
(15) A description of how program information, including
eligibility criteria and application sites, will be disseminated to the
public. List partner organizations involved and describe the
responsibilities of each, including role of volunteers, if applicable.
Examples of partner activities include spreading D-SNAP information on
behalf of the State or providing onsite application assistance.
Sufficient time shall be allowed to notify the public prior to the
start of the program.
(16) A description of the recipient claim procedures and thresholds
to be followed if they differ from either SNAP regulations at Sec.
273.18 of this chapter or the State's FNS approved procedures for
handling recipient claims in SNAP.
(17) A description of the procedures that will be used for
identifying and handling applications by State agency/State employees.
(18) A description of the fraud prevention strategies and security
measures in place.
(c) Changes to an approved D-SNAP. (1) When a State believes that a
modification to an approved D-SNAP request is necessary, it shall
submit a
[[Page 28756]]
written request to change its approved D-SNAP.
(2) Expansion of D-SNAP. To expand the geographic coverage of an
approved D-SNAP, a State shall submit a request to FNS for expansion,
detailing the impact of the disaster in the new area, the application
period, and the anticipated number of applicants and currently
certified SNAP households that will be served. If the benefit period
will also change, then the new benefit periods dates and justification
for doing so shall also be included.
(3) Extension to a D-SNAP. In some cases, States may find that
their initial application period is not sufficient to serve all
eligible households, and they may wish to request that the application
period be extended. Requests to extend the D-SNAP application period
shall be submitted to FNS with sufficient time for it to review and
approve the request prior to the end of the initial application period;
requests shall include justification of the need for additional time.
(3) Other Modifications to D-SNAP. Other modifications, including
any that would affect applicant eligibility, shall only be made prior
to the start of the application period to ensure that the eligibility
criteria are applied equitably to all applicants. Occasionally,
modifications may be made after D-SNAP operations have begun, such as
when a State that was originally approved for individual supplements
decides to issue automatic supplements in a certain area. However, once
the application period has commenced, the benefit period cannot be
modified. Because of the limited window of time in which most
modifications can be requested, States should carefully consider their
program options prior to submitting the initial request.
Sec. 280.4 Application processing and certification periods.
(a) Period for processing applications. (1) States shall only
accept applications for D-SNAP benefits from new households, and
requests for supplements from currently certified SNAP households,
during the approved application period.
(2) If the State is accepting requests for supplements from
currently certified SNAP households over the phone and mailing the
affidavit forms to the household, the request for an affidavit must be
received during the D-SNAP application period.
(3) Application periods shall last 7 days, though States retain the
option to request more or fewer days as they deem appropriate to the
circumstances. The State should provide its rationale for any deviation
from the 7-day application period in its D-SNAP request. The State
should also inform FNS, in its D-SNAP request, whether applications
will be accepted on Saturday and/or Sunday.
(b) Interviews. (1) All D-SNAP applicants or their authorized
representatives are required to have a face-to-face interview.
Exceptions to the face-to-face interview shall only be made for
individuals with disabilities that preclude visiting an application
site. States should use screening techniques prior to the interview to
identify those households which do not meet required eligibility
criteria, such as having been adversely affected by the disaster. The
interview shall be conducted as an official discussion of household
circumstances; however, it shall be designed to quickly process the
application. If an applicant household does not meet the D-SNAP
eligibility standards, the household shall be informed of the potential
availability of benefits under SNAP.
(2) The D-SNAP interview shall be conducted by State agency merit
system personnel.
(3) The individual interviewed must be a member of the household or
an authorized representative. The household may be accompanied to the
interview by anyone of its choice. The interviewer shall review the
information that appears on the application to resolve unclear or
incomplete information with the household.
(c) Certification period. Households shall be assigned
certification periods that coincide with the disaster benefit period.
If the benefit period is one month, then income over this full month
period shall be counted, disaster-related expenses that are incurred
over this full month period shall be deducted, and the monthly SNAP
maximum income limit for the appropriate household size shall equal the
disaster eligibility limit. If the disaster benefit period is for half
of a month, then income over the half-month period shall be counted,
disaster-related expenses incurred over this period shall be deducted,
and the disaster eligibility limit shall be one half of the monthly
SNAP limit for size of the household.
(d) Benefit availability. The State agency shall act promptly on
all applications and make benefits available, including EBT cards and
PINs, to eligible households that complete the D-SNAP application
process no later than 72 hours following their filing of the
application, unless the information provided by the applicant is deemed
questionable. When information is found to be questionable, the State
shall resolve the issue(s) to determine eligibility, and make benefits
available within 7 days following the filing of the application or deny
the application.
(e) Screening for duplicate participation during disasters. States
shall develop a system to detect duplicate applications for D-SNAP.
States shall either check for duplicate information up front, or may
accept applications and inform applicants that eligibility is
contingent upon a subsequent check for duplicates. States shall check
for duplicate participation using onsite or offsite computer databases,
but shall include all individuals included on each application. States
shall update computer databases on a daily basis throughout the
application period. States shall screen D-SNAP applications for
duplicate participation with:
(1) SNAP.
(2) Household disaster distribution of USDA Foods.
(3) Other D-SNAPs with overlapping benefit periods.
(4) Already approved D-SNAP applications.
(5) Denied D-SNAP applicants (to identify attempted duplicate
participation).
(f) D-SNAP verification requirements. To expedite the certification
for D-SNAP, the State agency shall use the procedures specified in this
paragraph rather than the standard SNAP verification required by Sec.
273.2(f). The applicant's identity shall be verified. Examples of
acceptable verification which the household may provide include, but
are not limited to: A driver's license, work or school ID, voter
registration card, birth certificate, or, a collateral contact.
Residency and household composition at the time of the disaster shall
be verified where possible, and must be verified if questionable. In
some situations (such as in the case of a household that arrived in the
area just prior to the disaster), verification of residency may not be
possible. When residency that is questionable cannot be verified
despite the efforts of the State agency and the household, the
household shall not be denied D-SNAP solely for this reason. Loss/
inaccessibility of income or liquid resources and food loss shall be
verified if questionable.
(g) Applications from state and county employees. State and local
staff may be entitled to D-SNAP benefits and shall be subject to the
same eligibility criteria as any other applicant. States shall
incorporate the following internal controls into their disaster
operations.
[[Page 28757]]
(1) Certification and issuance duties shall be handled by different
staff.
(2) A question shall be included on the D-SNAP application asking
if anyone in the applicant household (or its authorized representative)
is employed by the State or local SNAP agency.
(3) Supervisors or investigators shall conduct employee
certification interviews.
(4) States shall audit all employee applications and inform
employees of this policy in advance of implementing the D-SNAP.
Sec. 280.5 Households participating in the SNAP when D-SNAP is
operating.
(a) SNAP shall continue to operate during the disaster benefit
period and shall continue to process applications and make eligibility
determinations in the normal manner in accordance with parts 273 and
274 of the SNAP regulations in this chapter. Households currently
certified for SNAP benefits may be eligible for supplemental benefits.
(b) Disaster supplements. (1) When D-SNAP is approved and operating
in a given jurisdiction, supplements shall be issued to currently
certified SNAP households affected by the disaster in that jurisdiction
that bring their benefit level up to the maximum allotment for their
household size. States shall issue supplemental benefits on an
individual basis, via the filing of an affidavit of disaster loss by
the household, or automatically to all currently certified SNAP
households in a designated area. By virtue of their participation in
SNAP such households need not appear in person at the D-SNAP site.
(2) To obtain an individual supplement, households shall complete
an affidavit of disaster loss.
(3) States' requests to issue automatic supplements and the
supporting justification shall be included in the State's D-SNAP
request. States shall specify their decision to issue automatic
supplements and must be able to show that they can effectively target
the benefits to geographic areas that were heavily impacted by the
disaster. Currently certified SNAP households not receiving automatic
issuance but who were living in the disaster area and experienced
disaster losses may still request supplemental benefits via an
individual affidavit of disaster.
(c) Replacements. As provided in Sec. 274.6, replacement benefits
are always available to SNAP households that file an affidavit that
they have experienced an adverse effect causing them to lose food
purchased with their benefits.
Sec. 280.6 Reconciliation.
(a) EBT cards. Cards shipped from a central location shall be
tracked until distributed locally to households. Each issuance site
shall maintain a beginning and ending inventory and track new cards
received, total cards available, and cards issued. If the State assigns
Personal Identification Numbers (PINs), they must also account for PIN
mailers or envelopes to ensure adequate security, except when the PIN
is formulated from the Primary Account Number. The State shall
reconcile the number of cards set-up with EBT accounts and the number
of cards issued to identify and resolve any discrepancies.
(b) D-SNAP issuances. States shall track D-SNAP benefits separately
from SNAP benefit issuance and adhere to FNS reconciliation guidelines
so that they can compare benefits posted to accounts to benefits issued
by the State eligibility system.
Sec. 280.7 Post disaster review and corrections.
(a) States shall conduct a comprehensive review and individual case
reviews. Based upon a problem analysis of the findings from these
reviews, the State shall modify its disaster plan.
(1) The comprehensive review should begin with an overview of the
D-SNAP operation, including where and when it took place, how it was
staffed, and the total number of applications approved and amount of
benefits issued. The State should then examine the systems or methods
employed, document any major problems or challenges encountered, and
discuss the interventions used to solve those issues in the following
areas:
(i) Certification systems;
(ii) Fraud control;
(iii) Issuance;
(iv) Public information and outreach;
(v) Program accessibility;
(vi) Security.
(2)(i) The State agency shall conduct a post-disaster review of
disaster certification activities by selecting and reviewing a sample
of individual cases that applied for D-SNAP. The review of certified
cases shall include: A case record review; an interview with the
participant; verification of each element of eligibility for the
State's D-SNAP program including identity, residency, income, household
size and disaster related expenses; a determination of eligibility for
disaster assistance; and an analysis of errors.
(ii) States with 10,000 or more approved D-SNAP households shall
select a sample of 400 approved cases for review. States with less than
10,000 but more than 300 approved D-SNAP households shall select a
sample of between 300 and 400 cases as shown below. States with 300 or
fewer would review all cases.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Approved D-SNAP households (N) Minimum sample size (n)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
10,000 and over........................ n = 400
300 to 9,999........................... n = 300 + [0.01031(N-300)]
Under 300.............................. n = all cases
------------------------------------------------------------------------
(iii) A sample of 100 denied D-SNAP applications shall be reviewed
to identify errors made in not providing benefits to eligible
households. If there are fewer than 100 denied applications, all denied
applications would be reviewed.
(iv) If a State uses a random sample, the State shall identify this
in the post disaster report described and include the following
information:
(A) The number of cases or in the sample universe;
(B) A description of the sample frame and how it was constructed;
(C) The sample size selected;
(D) The number of sample cases completed; and
(E) The findings from the sample cases completed.
(3) States shall review all State agency employee applications--
approved and denied.
(4) For all case reviews, no cases shall be dropped for any reason
and the State shall report information gathered from all case reviews.
(5) State agencies shall submit the post disaster report containing
the results of the reviews, the problem analysis, and proposed
improvements within 6 months of the close of each D-SNAP operation.
(b) Fair hearings requirements in a D-SNAP. Any household who
applied for D-SNAP benefits and was denied may request a fair hearing.
A household which has requested a fair hearing shall be offered an
immediate onsite supervisory review. Households that are not satisfied
with the outcome of the supervisory review retain the right to request
a fair hearing in accordance with Sec. 273.15 of this chapter.
(c) Restored benefits from D-SNAP. States shall issue restored
benefits to households when an incorrect denial of benefits is
subsequently corrected. The issuance system shall clearly note that
such corrected issuances were restored benefits.
(d) D-SNAP recipient claims collection requirements. States shall
establish a claim against the household
[[Page 28758]]
consistent with the claims collection requirements of SNAP regulations
at Sec. 273.18 of this chapter. Claims shall be established as soon as
possible after the close of the disaster operation. States may also
follow their FNS-approved procedures and thresholds for establishing
claims in SNAP for claims arising from D-SNAP, or may include any
alternate procedures or thresholds in their D-SNAP request. However, if
a claim is established against a household for an overpayment of SNAP
benefits, this amount may not be collected from the D-SNAP issuance.
Sec. 280.8 D-SNAP reporting.
(a) D-SNAP daily reports. States operating a D-SNAP shall report to
FNS on a daily basis. States shall begin submitting reports on the day
following the first day of D-SNAP operations and continue submitting
the reports on a daily basis until all applications are processed.
States shall use a daily reporting template provided by FNS. Data
should be submitted by county, as indicated in the template. The daily
reports must capture the new D-SNAP and SNAP issuance data listed in
paragraphs (a)(1) through (13) of this section:
(1) Number of D-SNAP applications received;
(2) Number of new D-SNAP households approved;
(3) Number of new D-SNAP persons approved;
(4) Number of SNAP households receiving supplements;
(5) Number of people previously certified for SNAP approved for
supplements;
(6) Number of new D-SNAP households denied;
(7) Number of SNAP households receiving replacement issuance;
(8) Value of new D-SNAP benefits approved;
(9) Value of SNAP supplements approved;
(10) Value of SNAP replacement issuance;
(11) Average benefit per new D-SNAP household;
(12) Average benefit per SNAP household; and
(13) Any additional information the State believes FNS should be
aware of.
(b) FNS-292B, Report of Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program
Benefit Issuance for Disaster Relief. Within 45 days of the termination
of a D-SNAP operation, the State agency shall submit the FNS-292B. This
report shall be submitted electronically in the Food Programs Reporting
System (FPRS). The FNS 292B shall contain the following issuance data
for D-SNAP operations:
(1) Number of new households issued D-SNAP benefits.
(2) Total number of new persons issued D-SNAP benefits.
(3) Number of households certified in SNAP that were issued
supplements.
(4) Total value of benefits issued to new households and
supplements issued to previously certified SNAP households.
(c) Form FNS-388, Monthly Issuance Report. The FNS-388 shall
include issuance and participation figures for new D-SNAP households
and previously certified SNAP households receiving disaster supplements
and/or replacements. Replacement benefits shall be reported for the
month for which they are intended.
(d) Form FNS-209, Status of Claims Against Households Report. In
the remarks section of the FNS-209, States shall indicate the number of
claims established and collected against D-SNAP benefits. D-SNAP claims
must be identified on backup documentation in the accounting systems
for the FNS-209.
(e) Form FNS-46, Issuance Reconciliation Report. The FNS-46 shall
include issuance and participation figures for new D-SNAP households
and SNAP households receiving disaster supplements and/or replacements.
The FNS-46 and FNS-388 should reconcile with the reported net issuance.
(f) Post-disaster Report. The post-disaster review report shall be
comprised of four parts: The comprehensive review, individual reviews,
problem analysis, and proposed improvements to the disaster plan.
States shall submit the post-disaster report containing the reviews,
the problem analysis, and proposed improvements within 6 months of the
close of each D-SNAP operation.
Dated: May 2, 2016.
Telora T. Dean,
Acting Administrator, Food and Nutrition Service.
[FR Doc. 2016-10923 Filed 5-9-16; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 3410-30-P