Family Violence Prevention and Services Programs, 61889-61915 [2015-25726]
Download as PDF
Vol. 80
Wednesday,
No. 198
October 14, 2015
Part II
Department of Health and Human Services
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Administration for Children and Families
45 CFR Part 1370
Family Violence Prevention and Services Programs; Proposed Rule
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
PO 00000
Frm 00001
Fmt 4717
Sfmt 4717
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
61890
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND
HUMAN SERVICES
RIN 0970–AC62
Family Violence Prevention and
Services Programs
Family and Youth Services
Bureau (FYSB), Administration on
Children, Youth and Families (ACYF),
Administration for Children and
Families (ACF), Department of Health
and Human Services (HHS).
ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking.
AGENCY:
The Administration for
Children and Families proposes to
revise regulations applying to the
Family Violence Prevention and
Services Programs. These proposed
revisions would update existing rules to
reflect statutory changes, would update
procedures for soliciting and awarding
grants, and would make other changes
to increase clarity and reduce potential
confusion over statutory and regulatory
standards. The proposed revisions
would codify standards already used by
the program in the Funding Opportunity
Announcements and awards, in
technical assistance, in reporting
requirements, and in sub-regulatory
guidance.
SUMMARY:
In order to be considered,
comments on this proposed rule must
be received on or before December 14,
2015. Current Family Violence
Prevention and Services regulations
remain in effect until this NPRM
becomes final.
ADDRESSES: You may submit comments,
identified by [docket number and using/
or RIN number], by any of the following
methods: (1) Electronically via the
Federal eRulemaking Portal at https://
www.regulations.gov or (2) by mail to
the Associate Commissioner, Family
and Youth Services Bureau,
Administration for Children and
Families, 1250 Maryland Ave. SW.,
Washington, DC 20024.
Instructions: All submissions received
must include the agency name and
docket number or Regulatory
Information Number (RIN) for this
rulemaking. All comments received will
be posted without change to
www.regulations.gov, including any
personal information provided. For
detailed instructions on submitting
comments and additional information
on the rulemaking process, see the
‘‘Public Participation’’ heading of the
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
IV. Background
Pursuant to the Administrative
Procedure Act, the Department allows a
period of time for members of the public
to comment on proposed rules. In this
case we will allow 60 days for
comments. In making any modifications
to this notice of proposed rulemaking,
we are not required to consider
comments received beyond the 60-day
comment period. To make sure your
comments are addressed fully, we
suggest the following:
• Be specific;
• Address only issues raised by the
proposed rule, not the provisions of the
law itself;
• Explain reasons for any objections
or recommended changes;
• Propose appropriate alternatives;
and
• Reference the specific section of the
notice of the proposed rulemaking being
addressed.
As the President proclaimed during
the 2014 National Domestic Violence
Awareness Month, ‘‘Domestic violence
affects every American. It harms our
communities, weakens the foundation
of our Nation, and hurts those we love
most . . . we acknowledge the progress
made in reducing these shameful
crimes, embrace the basic human right
to be free from violence and abuse, and
recognize that more work remains until
every individual is able to live free from
fear.’’1 Programs and services funded by
the Family Violence Prevention and
Services Act (‘‘FVPSA’’) are critical
pieces in the Administration’s fight to
end domestic violence.
FVPSA authorizes three formula grant
programs and other discretionary grant
programs administered by the Family
and Youth Services Bureau (FYSB),
Administration on Children, Youth and
Families (ACFY), Administration for
Children and Families (ACF), in the
Department of Health and Human
Services (HHS). These programs
comprise the primary Federal funding
stream dedicated to the support of
emergency shelter and supportive
services for victims of family violence,
domestic violence, or dating violence,
and their dependents. The FVPSA also
authorizes additional activities
conducted through grants, including but
not limited to grants for research,
evaluation, and service projects; grants
for a national domestic violence hotline,
including evaluation; grants for
specialized services to abused parents
and their children; grants for State
Kenneth E. Noyes, J.D., Senior Program
Specialist, (202) 205–7891,
kenneth.noyes@acf.hhs.gov. Deaf and
hearing impaired individuals may call
the Federal Dual Party Relay Service at
1–800–977–8339 between 8:30 a.m. and
7 p.m. Eastern time.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
45 CFR Part 1370
VerDate Sep<11>2014
II. Public Participation
section of
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Administration for Children and
Families
DATES:
This proposed regulation is published
under the authority granted to the
Secretary of Health and Human Services
by the Family Violence Prevention and
Services Act (FVPSA), 42 U.S.C.
10404(a)(4), as most recently amended
by the Child Abuse Prevention and
Treatment (CAPTA) Reauthorization Act
of 2010 (Public Law (Pub. L.) 111–320).
consistency with definitions used by
other HHS components.
The section-by-section analysis is
organized to follow the framework of 45
CFR part 1370. It proposes revisions or
additions to the current rule in the
following areas:
• Stated purposes of the program;
• significant terms used in the
program;
• other Federal requirements;
• requirements that apply to all
family violence prevention and services
grants;
• eligibility for grants;
• application procedures; and
• other issues that may arise in the
administration of the FVPSA program.
In addition to program-wide
standards, specific standards are
proposed for each of the major grant
programs authorized under the Family
Violence Prevention and Services Act.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
this document.
I. Statutory Authority
III. Organization of the NPRM
The preamble to this proposed rule is
organized as follows:
• Background;
• Consultation and the development
of the NPRM;
• Scope of the proposed rule; and
• Section-by-section discussion of the
regulatory provisions.
The use of the word(s) ‘‘propose’’ or
‘‘we propose’’ throughout the NPRM is
meant to remind readers that this
document is proposed as revised
regulatory guidance. The language used
should not be construed to mean that
statutory definitions and provisions are
being changed but rather more fully
explained and clarified within the
context of the programming and services
laid out in the statute, and to ensure
PO 00000
Frm 00002
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
1 https://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/
2014/09/30/presidential-proclamation-nationaldomestic-violence-awareness-month-201.
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
resource centers to reduce disparities in
domestic violence in States with high
proportions of Indian (including Alaska
Native) or Native Hawaiian populations;
and, grants for national and special
issue resource centers and technical
assistance and training relating to family
violence, domestic violence, and dating
violence. The Formula Grants to States
Program (hereafter referred to as the
State Grant Program) awards grants to
States, the Grants for Indian Tribes
Program (hereafter referred to as the
Tribal Grant Program) awards grants to
Tribes or Tribal organizations and
Alaska Native Villages, and the Grants
to State Domestic Violence Coalitions
Program (hereafter referred to as
Coalitions Grant Program) awards grants
to statewide, nongovernmental,
nonprofit 501(c)(3), private, domestic
violence organizations. The proposed
rule covers all of these activities.
The National and Special Issue
Resource Centers and Training and
Technical Assistance Centers’ Programs
(hereafter referred to as Resource
Centers, Special Issue Resource Centers
and Culturally-Specific Special Issue
Resource Centers) provide resource
information, training, and technical
assistance to improve the capacity of
individuals, organizations,
governmental entities, and communities
to prevent family violence, domestic
violence, and dating violence and to
provide effective intervention services.
The CAPTA Reauthorization Act of
2010 reauthorized and made a number
of changes to the FVPSA (see also 42
U.S.C. 10401 et seq.). These changes
include:
(1) Expanded purpose areas to include
family violence, domestic violence and
dating violence (42. U.S.C. 10401(b));
(2) an expanded definitions section to
clarify statutory language (42 U.S.C.
10402);
(3) expanded authority of the
Secretary to promulgate regulations and
guidance as necessary and updated the
Secretary’s authority to coordinate
programs across the Department and
with other Federal agencies, provide for
and coordinate research and evaluation,
and develop effective policies to address
the needs of adult and youth victims of
family violence, domestic violence and
dating violence (42 U.S.C. 10404(a) and
(b));
(4) a new State Formula grant
requirement to provide specialized
services for children exposed to family
violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence, underserved populations, and
victims who are members of racial and
ethnic minority populations (42 U.S.C.
10406(a)(3));
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
(5) nondisclosure of confidential or
private information provisions that are
consistent with the provisions of the
Violence Against Women Act (VAWA)
(42 U.S.C. 10406(c)(5));
(6) requirement that a Tribally
designated official be named in Tribal
applications for administration of grant
programs (42 U.S.C. 10407(a)(1));
(7) clarification that administrative
costs are limited to no more than 5% of
State formula grants (42 U.S.C.
10407(a)(2)(B)(i));
(8) additional requirements to
strengthen the consultation between
States and State Domestic Violence
Coalitions (42 U.S.C. 10407(a)(2)(D));
(9) changes to statutory language in
the State grants and sub-grants section
that requires funds to be used for
providing immediate shelter and
supportive services for adult and youth
victims of family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence (and their
dependents), and that may provide
prevention services (42 U.S.C. 10408(a)
and (b));
(10) expanded eligibility of the types
of nonprofit private organizations that
may receive State sub-grants to include
community-based organizations and
Tribal organizations, in addition to
faith-based and charitable organizations,
and voluntary associations (42 U.S.C.
10408(c)(1));
(11) a new provision that expands
entities eligible for State formula subgrantee funding to include partnerships
of two or more agencies or organizations
that have a documented history of
effective work concerning family
violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence and an agency or organization
that has a demonstrated history of
serving populations in their
communities, including providing
culturally appropriate services (42
U.S.C. 10408(c)(2);
(12) clarification that the receipt of
supportive services must be accepted
voluntarily and that no condition may
be applied for the receipt of emergency
shelter (42 U.S.C. 10408(d)(2));
(13) a new requirement for Federal
consultation with Tribal governments in
the planning of grants for Indian Tribes
(42 U.S.C. 10409(a));
(14) a requirement for two national
resource centers on domestic violence,
including one national Indian resource
center to address domestic violence and
safety for Indian women (42 U.S.C.
10410);
(15) a requirement for at least seven
special issue resource centers including
three focused on enhancing domestic
violence intervention and prevention
efforts for victims of domestic violence
who are members of racial and ethnic
PO 00000
Frm 00003
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
61891
minority groups to enhance the cultural
and linguistic relevancy of service
delivery (42 U.S.C. 10410);
(16) a provision giving the Secretary
the discretionary authority to award
grants to State resource centers to
reduce Tribal disparities in domestic
violence in eligible States (42 U.S.C.
§ 10410);
(17) clarification of the activities of
State Domestic Violence Coalitions (42
U.S.C. 10411);
(18) new opt-out provisions for
certain coalition activities if annual
assurances are provided by Coalitions
that the activities are being provided
and coordinated under other specific
Federal funding streams (42 U.S.C.
10411(e));
(19) a requirement that the Secretary
establish a new program for specialized
services for abused parents and their
children with discretionary authority to
make grants (42 U.S.C. 10412); such
specialized services may include but are
not limited to: providing direct
counseling that is developmentally and
age appropriate and culturally and
linguistically appropriate to victims and
their children, including services that
are coordinated with services provided
by the child welfare system; and, to
provide services for non-abusing parents
to support those parents’ roles as
caregivers and their role in responding
to the social, emotional, and
developmental needs of their children;
(20) clarification that a grant to one or
more private entities may be made for
ongoing operation of the National
Domestic Violence Hotline that serves
adult and youth victims of family
violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence (42 U.S.C. 10413(a)); including,
allowing the provision of hotline
services to youth victims of domestic
violence or dating violence who are
minors through a national teen dating
violence hotline (42 U.S.C.
10413(d)(2)(G)). This notice of proposed
rulemaking would revise regulations
applying to the Family Violence
Prevention and Services Programs,
except for the Domestic Violence
Prevention Enhancement and
Leadership Through Alliances Program
(DELTA) contained in Section 314 of the
Family Violence Prevention and
Services Act (FVPSA—codified in 42
U.S.C. 10414), which is separately
funded and administered by the Centers
for Disease Control and Prevention,
Division of Violence Prevention.
While we have already implemented
most of these provisions through the
Funding Opportunity Announcements,
technical assistance and training, and
Information Memoranda issuances, this
proposed rule would allow us to
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
61892
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
integrate these legislative requirements
into our codified rules. In addition, it
would bring our codified regulations,
last updated on February 22, 1996 (61
FR 6791), into conformity with the
administrative and managerial
procedures we already use in
compliance with FVPSA. We do not
propose to codify every provision of the
statute. Finally, the proposed rule
identifies a number of important
linkages between the FVPSA programs
and those programs conducted by the
Department of Justice and authorized by
VAWA. For example, both statutes
contain strict prohibitions against
disclosure of confidential or private
information to ensure the safety of
persons receiving services.
V. Consultation and the Development of
the NPRM
It is our intent in this section of the
NPRM preamble to highlight the various
meetings and consultations, among
many other activities we conducted,
that assisted in the development of the
NPRM. To support our statutory
responsibilities for administering the
State and Coalition formula grants,
contingent upon available funding, we
host either an annual or bi-annual, joint
grantee meeting of the State FVPSA
funding administrators and the State
Domestic Violence Coalitions. The
grantee meeting facilitates partnership
building between the respective State
and Coalition cohorts and across all
States and Coalitions, shares and
promotes best practices related to the
provision of prevention and
intervention services for victims of
family, domestic, and dating violence
(with speakers, lecturers, and facilitators
on a broad range of issues in the field),
and provides program guidance on
implementing the statutory
requirements of the FVPSA. These
meetings provide important
opportunities for Federal, State, and
private staff to engage with each other
to learn about and address issues of
intersecting importance, including
issues such as protecting victim/
survivor confidentiality that are
addressed in this proposed rule.
The National Resource Centers,
Special Issue Resource Centers, and
Culturally-Specific Special Issue
Resource Centers comprise what is
known as the FVPSA Domestic Violence
Resource Network (DVRN). The DVRN
convenes every one to two years to
share and promote evidence-informed
and best practices about prevention and
intervention services for victims of
family, domestic, and dating violence.
Expert speakers and lecturers present on
a broad range of subject matter
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
important to the field. ACF also
provides program guidance on
implementing statutory requirements at
the meetings.
ACF funded Tribal administrators,
advocates, and leaders also are
convened annually, contingent upon
funding. The Tribal grantee meeting
allows grantees to provide and receive
technical assistance and training. Issues
addressed and best practices shared are
most commonly related to service
delivery; new initiatives; business
needs; funding issues; information
exchange; collaborations ranging from
service delivery models to police
response; cultural sensitivity; advocacy;
and the statutory requirements of the
FVPSA.
ACF also hosts annual Tribal
consultations. Tribal consultations
discuss ACF programs and Tribal
priorities and to build meaningful
relationships with Federally recognized
Tribes. The consultations solicit
recommendations and/or mutual
understanding from Tribal government
leaders on issues ranging from funding
availability to departmental priorities.
In addition, ACF staff participates in
annual Tribal consultations sponsored
by the Department of Justice Office on
Violence Against Women. The purpose
of those consultations is to engage in a
government-to-government dialogue
between the United States Government
and the leaders from Indian Tribal
governments on how to best enhance
the safety of Alaska Natives and
American Indians and reduce domestic
violence, dating violence, sexual
assault, and stalking committed against
them. The consultations also solicit
recommendations from Tribal
government leaders on administering
grant funds.
Finally, development of the NPRM
included ongoing analyses of formula
and discretionary grantees’ annual
performance reports as well as site visit
reports and desk reviews. Information
gleaned from these sources helped to
identify grantees’ successes and
challenges implementing FVPSA
requirements and, therefore, informed
the NPRM development process.
VI. Scope of the Proposed Rule
This rule proposes to revise existing
regulatory standards to help improve
the administration of the FVPSA, to
provide greater clarity and transparency
to ACF’s implementation of the statute,
and to bring the program regulation into
conformance with statutory provisions.
All grantees will be expected to
comply with standards and other
requirements upon the final rule’s
effective date. To assist grantees with
PO 00000
Frm 00004
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
compliance, we will provide guidance
on best practices for implementing the
standards and revised requirements. We
also plan to conduct technical
assistance to help grantees understand
and implement changes.
This proposed rule also makes
technical changes to existing program
rules to correct outdated provisions. It
proposes to revise our regulatory
provisions on making awards to reflect
current program priorities and onsite
review and monitoring procedures.
VII. Section-by-Section Discussion of
the Regulatory Provisions
We propose to revise 45 Part 1370 to
add a Subpart A for general provisions,
add a Subpart B for State and Indian
Tribal grants, add a Subpart C for State
Domestic Violence Coalition grants, and
add a Subpart D for Discretionary grants
and contracts. We also propose to add
a new table of contents to this part.
Subpart A—General Provisions
Section 1370.1 What are the purposes
of the Family Violence Prevention and
Services Act programs?
We propose to add § 1370.1 under
new Subpart A, and to revise it to reflect
the statute’s current purposes found at
42 U.S.C. 10401(b). One major
difference from the existing regulation is
new language expanding purpose areas
to include family violence, domestic
violence, and dating violence.
Specifically, the new purposes are:
assist States and Indian Tribes in efforts
to increase public awareness about, and
primary and secondary prevention of,
family violence, domestic violence, and
dating violence; assist States and Indian
Tribes in efforts to provide immediate
shelter and supportive services for
victims of family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence, and their
dependents; provide for a national
domestic violence hotline; and provide
for technical assistance and training
relating to family violence, domestic
violence, and dating violence programs
to States and Indian Tribes, local public
agencies (including law enforcement
agencies, courts, and legal, social
service, and healthcare professionals in
public agencies), nonprofit private
organizations (including faith-based and
charitable organizations, communitybased organizations and voluntary
associations), Tribal organizations, and
other persons seeking such assistance
and training.
Section 1370.2 What definitions apply
to these programs?
We propose to add § 1370.2 under
new Subpart A and revise it to include
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
definitions of significant terms found in
the statute at 42 U.S.C. 10402 and used
in current operating practices. The
definitions are intended to reflect
important terms in the statute and
important practices in the
administration of the program. In some
instances, we do not repeat the statutory
definition verbatim but rather propose a
regulatory definition that we believe is
fully consistent with the statutory
definition, but will provide clarity to the
field and other interested stakeholders.
The definitions section applies to all
grants and contracts under the FVPSA.
We welcome comments on all proposed
definitions; however, we are
constrained by the statutory definitions
in the FVPSA. Note that many of these
are longstanding definitions resulting
from FVPSA reauthorization in 2010
and are already included in the Funding
Opportunity Announcements.
We propose to include the statutory
definition of ‘‘dating violence,’’ an
important addition to the scope of
persons protected under the FVPSA.
The statute defines it as ‘‘violence
committed by a person who is or has
been in a social relationship of a
romantic or intimate nature with the
victim and where the existence of such
a relationship shall be determined based
on a consideration of the following
factors: the length of the relationship,
the type of relationship, and the
frequency of interaction between the
persons involved in the relationship.’’
This definition reflects the definition
also found in Section 40002(a) of
VAWA (as amended), as required by
FVPSA. Dating violence may also
include violence against older
individuals and those with disabilities
when the violence meets the applicable
definition.
We propose to include the statutory
definition of ‘‘domestic violence.’’
Section 10402(3) of the FVPSA defines
‘‘domestic violence’’ as felony or
misdemeanor crimes of violence
committed by a current or former
spouse or intimate partner of the victim,
by a person with whom the victim
shares a child in common, by a person
who is cohabitating with or has
cohabitated with the victim as a spouse
or intimate partner, by a person
similarly situated to a spouse of the
victim under the domestic or family
violence laws of the jurisdiction
receiving grant monies, or by any other
person against an adult or youth victim
who is protected from that person’s acts
under the domestic or family violence
laws of the jurisdiction. This definition
also reflects the statutory definition of
‘‘domestic violence’’ found in Section
40002(a) of VAWA (as amended). Older
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
individuals and those with disabilities
who meet these criteria are also
included within this term’s definition.
We also propose that the definition of
‘‘domestic violence’’ will also include,
but will not be limited to, acts or acts
constituting intimidation, control,
coercion and coercive control,
emotional and psychological abuse and
behavior, expressive and psychological
aggression, harassment, tormenting
behavior, and disturbing or alarming
behavior. The Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention (CDC) in its
National Intimate Partner and Sexual
Violence Survey, 2014 Report (Breiding,
M.J., Chen J., & Black, M.C. (2014),
Intimate Partner Violence in the United
States-2010. Atlanta, GA: National
Center for Injury Prevention) describes
intimate partner violence, which is
commonly used interchangeably with
the term ‘‘domestic violence,’’ to
include psychological aggression and
expressive aggression (such as name
calling, insulting or humiliating an
intimate partner) and coercive control,
which includes behaviors that are
intended to monitor, control or threaten
an intimate partner.
Moreover, several states have
broadened their definitions of
‘‘domestic violence’’ or similar terms to
describe a range of behaviors commonly
understood as abusive behavior within
spousal and intimate partner
relationships. For example, Maine
legislatively defines ‘‘abuse’’ within
family, household, or dating partner
relationships to include (among other
factors), threatening, harassing or
tormenting behavior.’’ ME. Rev. Stat.
Ann. tit. 19–A § 4002 (2009). The state
also defines other behavior as ‘‘abuse’’
such as following the plaintiff/[alleged
victim] repeatedly and without
reasonable cause; or, being in the
vicinity of the plaintiff’s home, school,
business or place of employment both
repeatedly and without reasonable
cause. Id. In Cole v. Cole, 2008 ME 4,
940 A.2d 194, 2008 Me, Lexus 6 (2008),
a District court issued a protection from
abuse order to the wife and the parties’
child, pursuant to Me. Rev. Stat. Ann.
tit. 19–A, § 4002(C), because the
husband had a longstanding pattern of
controlling, intimidating, and
threatening conduct toward his wife.
The State of New Hampshire includes
‘‘harassment’’ in the definition of
‘‘abuse’’, by including (among other
factors) when a person: (a) Makes a
telephone call, whether or not a
conversation ensues, with no legitimate
communicative purpose or without
disclosing his or her identity and with
a purpose to annoy, abuse, threaten, or
alarm another; or (b) makes repeated
PO 00000
Frm 00005
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
61893
communications at extremely
inconvenient hours or in offensively
coarse language with a purpose to annoy
or alarm another; or (c) insults, taunts,
or challenges another in a manner likely
to provoke a violent or disorderly
response. N.H. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 173–
B:1(I)(g); 644:4 (2009).
Another State, Hawaii, provides as
one definition of ‘‘domestic abuse’’
within the context of a romantic or
intimate relationship (among others) as
‘‘extreme psychological abuse’’
mean[ing] an intentional or knowing
course of conduct directed at an
individual that seriously alarms or
disturbs consistently or continually
bothers the individual, and that serves
no legitimate purpose. HAW.
REV.STAT. § 586–1(1) (2009).
Given the continuum of behaviors
constituting ‘‘domestic violence’’
identified in FVPSA, and the broader
protections embodied in State and other
jurisdictional law, ACF will interpret
‘‘domestic violence’’ as inclusive of
additional acts recognized in other
Federal, State, local, and tribal laws, as
well as acts in other Federal regulatory
and sub-regulatory guidance. Note that
this definition is not intended to be
interpreted more restrictively than
FVPSA and VAWA but rather to be
inclusive of other, more expansive
definitions.
We propose to include the statutory
definition of ‘‘family violence’’ found at
Section 10402(4) of the FVPSA. ‘‘Family
violence’’ means any act or threatened
act of violence, including any forceful
detention of an individual, that results
or threatens to result in physical injury
and is committed by a person against
another individual (including an older
individual), to or with whom such
person is related by blood or marriage,
or is or was otherwise legally related, or
is or was lawfully residing. We would
note that since 2013, the Funding
Opportunity Announcements have
included LGBTQ individuals as an
underserved population with no
reference to marital status. For the last
nine years and pursuant to the FVPSA
definition of family violence, ACF has
required grantees, sub-grantees, and
contractors to provide services to
LGBTQ individuals regardless of marital
status. Additionally, defining family
violence to encompass same-sex
spouses is consistent with the Supreme
Court’s decision in Obergefell v.
Hodges, which held that same-sex
marriages are entitled to equal treatment
under the law. All FVPSA-funded
grantees and contractors are required to
serve program recipients regardless of
whether an individual may be married
to a person of the opposite or same sex.
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
61894
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
Please note that this guidance is not a
change in previous grantee guidance as
survivors of intimate partner violence,
regardless of marital status, have always
been eligible for FVPSA-funded services
and programming.
Further, ‘‘family violence’’ has
become a term used interchangeably
with ‘‘domestic violence’’ by both the
field, and Congress, when describing the
violence experienced between intimate
partners and the programs and services
utilized by those impacted by such
violence. In 1984 when FVPSA was first
named and authorized, the term ‘‘family
violence’’ was commonly used as
synonymous with ‘‘domestic violence’’
(violence between intimate partners).
However, ‘‘family violence’’ is still often
used more broadly to encompass the
diverse forms of violence that occur
within families, including child
maltreatment, ‘‘domestic violence’’ and
elder abuse. For clarity and in keeping
with the historical FVPSA ‘‘family
violence’’ interpretation, the term will
continue to be used more narrowly and
as interchangeable with ‘‘domestic
violence.’’
Additionally, the legislative history of
the 2010 FVPSA Reauthorization is
replete with descriptive language citing
‘‘domestic violence,’’ ‘‘domestic
violence service providers,’’ and
‘‘domestic violence victims’’ while only
briefly referencing ‘‘family violence’’ in
the Senate Committee’s legislative
explanation. CAPTA Reauthorization
Act of 2010, 111 S. Rpt. 378 Title IV—
Family Violence Prevention and
Services Act, 17–19 (December 18,
2010). The Committee Report discusses
multiple FVPSA sections using only the
term ‘‘domestic violence’’ when
describing, for example, the role of
religious and faith-based communities
in working with domestic violence
service providers to support victims. Id.
at 111 S. Rpt. 378, 17. In discussing the
role of a coordinated community
response, the report states ‘‘the
committee intends that ‘‘coordinated
community response’’ means an
organized effort, such as a task force,
(or) coordinating council . . .
representing an array of service
providers responding to the needs of
domestic violence populations in such
area.’’ Id. at 111 S. Rpt. 378, 18. The
Committee Report goes on to estimate
FVPSA costs and primarily focuses on
‘‘domestic violence’’ by reporting that
‘‘[FVPSA] would help States prevent
domestic violence, provide services to
people who have suffered from such
violence, and assist with technical
assistance and training at the State and
Local levels.’’ Id. at 111 S. Rpt. 378, 20.
In the same paragraph and in the
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
context of discussing domestic violence,
the report also cites the Congressional
Budget Office’s estimation of total costs
and references ‘‘family violence
prevention’’ only once as compared to
the repeated use of ‘‘domestic violence’’
throughout the report.
Moreover, the Catalogue of Federal
Domestic Assistance (CFDA) has
historically described FVPSA grant
programs as ‘‘Family Violence
Prevention and Services/Battered
Women’s Shelters—Grants to States and
Indian Tribes’’ (93.671) and ‘‘Family
Violence Prevention and Services/
Battered Women’s Shelters—Grants to
State Domestic Violence Coalitions’’
(93.591). ‘‘Battered Women’s Shelters’’
has been a commonly used term since
the 1970’s to identify safe housing and
refuge for victims of domestic violence.
Recently, however, the CFDA program
descriptions were approved to more
clearly reflect the continuing intent to
fund domestic violence programs with
FVPSA funding. Accordingly, the CFDA
descriptions are now: ‘‘Family Violence
Prevention and Services/Domestic
Violence Shelter and Supportive
Services’’ (93.671); ‘‘Family Violence
Prevention and Services/State Domestic
Violence Coalitions’’ (93.591); and,
‘‘Family Violence Prevention and
Services/Discretionary’’ (93.592).
Additionally, the ACF Congressional
Justification uses the same ‘‘Battered
Women’s Shelters’’ nomenclature and
describes that FVPSA-funded services
are used to support ‘‘domestic violence’’
programs and services even though the
term ‘‘family violence’’ also is
interchangeably used in the description
of programming. Therefore, the
definition of family violence proposed
here reflects the definition long used by
the Department and indicated by its
interchangeable use in the FVPSA
statute and by the domestic violence
field and Congress.
A very important requirement in the
current statute revolves around
protecting victims of violence from
further abuse through non-disclosure of
‘‘personally identifying information.’’
We propose to define the term using the
statutory definition in FVPSA Section
10402(7), which references and
incorporates the VAWA definition.
Personally identifying information is
proposed to be defined as individually
identifying information for or about an
individual including information likely
to disclose the location of a victim of
domestic violence, dating violence,
sexual assault, or stalking, regardless of
whether the information is encoded,
encrypted, hashed, or otherwise
protected, including, (A) a first and last
name; (B) a home or other physical
PO 00000
Frm 00006
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
address; (C) contact information
(including a postal, email or Internet
protocol address, or telephone or
facsimile number); (D) a social security
number, driver license number, passport
number, or student identification
number; and (E) any other information,
including date of birth, racial or ethnic
background, or religious affiliation, that
would serve to identify any individual.
Note that information remains
personally identifying even if physically
protected through locked filing cabinets
or electronically protected through
encryption.
Additionally, there are FVPSAspecific waiver and consent
requirements for the non-disclosure of
confidential or private information as
well as provisions for the release of
information to law enforcement, child
welfare agencies, aggregate data releases
by grantees, and for the release of
personally identifying information of
victims who also are minors (42 U.S.C.
10405(c)(5)). All grantees are required to
comply with these requirements which
are included in this NPRM in Section
1370.4.
Primary prevention was included as a
statutory purpose for the first time in
the 2010 amendments to the FVPSA
statute but not defined. Primary
prevention focuses on strategies to stop
both first-time perpetration and firsttime victimization. Primary prevention
also is defined by the CDC as ‘‘stopping
intimate partner violence before it
occurs’’ (https://www.cdc.gov/
violenceprevention/deltafocus/).
Primary prevention may work by
modifying the events, conditions,
situations, or exposure to influences
that result in the initiation of intimate
partner violence and associated injuries,
disabilities, and deaths. Examples of
primary prevention could include:
‘‘school-based violence prevention
curricula, programs aimed at mitigating
the effects on children of witnessing
intimate partner violence, community
campaigns designed to alter norms and
values conducive to intimate partner
violence, worksite prevention programs,
and training and education in parenting
skills and self-esteem enhancement.’’ 61
FR 27879 (1996), Coordinated
Community Responses to Prevent
Intimate Partner Violence; Notice of
Availability of Funds for Fiscal Year
1996 (HHS/CDC). Therefore, we propose
to use the CDC definition of ‘‘primary
prevention’’ to mean strategies, policies,
and programs to stop both first-time
perpetration and first-time
victimization. Primary prevention is
stopping intimate partner violence
before it occurs.
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
We propose to define ‘‘primarypurpose domestic violence provider’’ as
one that operates a project of
demonstrated effectiveness carried out
by a nonprofit, nongovernmental,
private entity, Tribe, or Tribal
organization, that has as its project’s
primary-purpose the operation of
shelters and supportive services for
victims of domestic violence and their
dependents; or provides counseling,
advocacy, or self-help services to
victims of domestic violence. Territorial
Domestic Violence Coalitions may
include government-operated domestic
violence projects as ‘‘primary-purpose’’
providers for complying with the
membership requirement, provided that
Territorial Coalitions can document
providing training, technical assistance,
and capacity-building of communitybased and privately operated projects to
provide shelter and supportive services
to victims of family, domestic, or dating
violence, with the intention of
recruiting such projects as members
once they are sustainable as primarypurpose domestic violence service
providers. This definition is not in
FVPSA, however, we propose to
describe the undefined term in FVPSA
Section 10402(11)(A), based upon
program experience and consistent with
the priority for State formula funding
provided in FVPSA Section
10407(a)(2)(B)(iii).
‘Secondary prevention’ was also
added to the purpose of the FVPSA
statute but not defined. The World
Health Organization’s World Report on
Violence and Health, 2002:1–21,
describes ‘‘secondary prevention’’ as
approaches that focus on the more
immediate responses to violence. The
HHS CDC’s Division of Violence
Prevention also uses this definition in
practice and incorporates both risk and
protective factors to promote the
efficacy of secondary prevention efforts.
Therefore, we propose to include the
CDC’s definition of ‘‘secondary
prevention’’ that means identifying risk
factors or problems that may lead to
future family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence, and taking
the necessary actions to eliminate the
risk factors and the potential problem.
The objective is to create opportunities
to identify potential problems and to
intervene as soon as possible to prevent
the problem from recurring or
progressing. Services for children
exposed to domestic violence exemplify
one type of secondary prevention. By
developing targeted strategies for
children who have been exposed to
violence, secondary prevention efforts
can reduce the likelihood of such
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
children becoming victims or
perpetrators of future violence.
Among the most important services
under these programs is the provision of
shelter to victims of family, domestic,
and dating violence. We propose to use
the statutory definition of ‘‘shelter,’’
which is the provision of temporary
refuge and supportive services in
compliance with applicable State law or
regulations governing the provision, on
a regular basis, of shelter, safe homes,
meals, and supportive services to
victims of family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence, and their
dependents. We also propose to include
in this definition emergency shelter and
immediate shelter, which may include
scattered-site housing, which is defined
as property with multiple locations
around a local jurisdiction or state.
Temporary refuge is not defined in
FVPSA and we propose that it includes
residential services, including shelter
and off-site services such as hotel or
motel vouchers, which is not
transitional or permanent housing.
Should other jurisdictional laws conflict
with this definition of temporary refuge,
the definition which provides more
expansive housing accessibility governs.
Under the FVPSA, grants are made to
States and U.S. Territories. We propose
to include the definition of ‘‘State’’ as
defined in the statute. FVPSA defines
‘‘State’’ as each of the several States, the
District of Columbia, the
Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, Guam,
American Samoa, the United States
Virgin Islands, and the Commonwealth
of the Northern Mariana Islands. The
statute makes one exception to this
definition for State formula grants, and
provides for a different allotment of
funds for Guam, American Samoa, the
United Statesi Virgin Islands, and the
Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana
Islands. These four territories receive a
smaller share of funding because of their
relatively small populations.
The purpose of State Domestic
Violence Coalitions is to provide
education, support, and technical
assistance to domestic violence service
providers in their respective States to
enable the providers to establish and
maintain shelter and supportive services
for victims of domestic violence and
their dependents (including multigenerational families, e.g. grandparents
or others impacted by witnessing the
violence and dependent on the victim);
and serve as information
clearinghouses, primary points of
contact, and resource centers on
domestic violence for the States and
support the development of polices,
protocols, and procedures to enhance
domestic violence intervention and
PO 00000
Frm 00007
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
61895
prevention in the States. One grant is
awarded to one HHS-designated
Coalition in each State and Territory
each year. It should be noted that the
identified Territories in this section also
are designated one Coalition per
Territory. We propose to include a
definition of and to define a State
Domestic Violence Coalition (Coalition)
as: A statewide, nongovernmental,
nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization whose
membership includes a majority of the
primary-purpose domestic violence
service providers in the State; whose
board membership is representative of
these primary-purpose domestic
violence service providers, and which
may include representatives of the
communities in which the services are
being provided in the State; that
provides education, support, and
technical assistance to such service
providers; and that serves as an
information clearinghouse, primary
point of contact, and resource center on
domestic violence for the State and
supports the development of policies,
protocols and procedures to enhance
domestic violence intervention and
prevention in the State/Territory.
FVPSA provides for supportive
services targeted directly to the needs of
victims for safety and assistance in
reclaiming their agency, autonomy and
well-being. We propose to include a
definition of ‘‘supportive services,’’
which we define as services for adult
and youth victims of family violence,
domestic violence, or dating violence,
and their dependents that are designed
to meet the needs of such victims and
their dependents for short-term,
transitional, or long-term safety and
recovery. Our proposed definition
includes those services identified in
FVPSA Section 10408(b)(1)(G), but is
not limited to: Direct and/or referralbased advocacy on behalf of victims and
their dependents, counseling, case
management, employment services,
referrals, transportation services, legal
advocacy or assistance, child care
services, health, behavioral health and
preventive health services, culturally
appropriate services, and other services
that assist victims or their dependents
in recovering from the effects of the
violence. Supportive services may be
directly provided by grantees and/or by
providing advocacy or referrals to assist
victims in accessing such services.
Another important program focus is
on ‘‘underserved populations,’’ which
we propose to use the FVPSA definition
in Section 10402(14), specifically
referencing and incorporating the
VAWA definition, to define as
populations who face barriers in
accessing and using victim services, and
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
61896
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
populations underserved because of
geographic location, religion, sexual
orientation, gender identity,
underserved racial and ethnic
populations, and populations
underserved because of special needs
including language barriers, disabilities,
immigration status, and age. Note that
regarding age, the FVPSA-defined terms
of family violence, domestic violence,
and dating violence do not impose age
limitations on victims or their
dependents that may be served in
FVPSA-funded programs; elders and
adolescents are also included in these
definitions and we do not propose to
place age limits in these categories. We
also propose to include in this
definition individuals with criminal
histories due to victimization and
individuals with substance abuse and
mental health issues based on program
experience and victims’ needs identified
by grantees. The proposed definition
also includes, as allowed by FVPSA,
other population categories determined
by the Secretary or the Secretary’s
designee to be underserved.
We welcome comments on all these
definitions and on ways to clarify any
ambiguities or improve any elements.
We are, however, constrained
substantially by the FVPSA in departing
significantly from most of the wording
we propose because the proposed
regulatory definitions come from the
FVPSA and best practices identified
from the field.
Section 1370.3 What government-wide
and HHS-wide regulations apply to
these programs?
The current rule contains no list of
the other rules and regulations that
apply to recipients of program funds.
These applicable rules include, for
example, regulations concerning civil
rights obligations of grant recipients and
regulations concerning fraud, waste, and
abuse by grant recipients. We propose to
revise § 1370.3 under new subpart A to
include a list of those rules that most
commonly apply to grantees and
contractors under all or most HHS
programs, including FVPSA. This new
list does not attempt to list all of the
Federal laws and regulations (e.g.,
provisions of the Internal Revenue Code
regarding non-profit status) that pertain
to organizations that may be grant
awardees. The provisions we list here
are not all administered through ACF
(though the agency may in some
instances assist in their enforcement),
but are for the most part administered
by other HHS components or by other
Federal agencies that set the conditions
and enforcement mechanisms that apply
to those provisions, and that determine
VerDate Sep<11>2014
18:25 Oct 13, 2015
Jkt 238001
whether and in what circumstances
grant-related penalties may apply.
Section 1370.4 What confidentiality
requirements apply to these programs?
We propose to add § 1370.4 under
Part A and revise it to include language
regarding confidentiality requirements
that apply to all FVPSA programs. The
essential purpose of these requirements,
which are in the FVPSA (42 U.S.C.
10406(c)(5)) and in VAWA (42 U.S.C.
13925(a)(20) and (b)(2)) is to protect
victims of domestic violence from being
identified, located, or harmed by the
perpetrators of violence and others
working to assist perpetrators in gaining
access to victims. These protections are
robust. Grantees and subgrantees are
directly prohibited from disclosing any
personally identifiable information (as
defined in this NPRM Section 1370.2).
We propose to use the FVPSA
requirements for the non-disclosure of
confidential or private information. In
paragraph (a), we propose that in order
to ensure the safety of adult, youth, and
child victims of family violence,
domestic violence, or dating violence,
and their families, grantees and
subgrantees under this title shall protect
the confidentiality and privacy of such
victims and their families.
In paragraph (a), we propose that
grantees and subgrantees shall not: (1)
Disclose any personally identifying
information collected in connection
with services requested (including
services utilized or denied), through
grantees’ and subgrantees’ programs; or
(2) reveal personally identifying
information without informed, written,
reasonably time-limited consent by the
person about whom information is
sought, whether for this program or any
other Federal or State grant program.
In paragraph (b), we propose that
consent shall be given by the person,
except in the case of an unemancipated
minor, the minor and the minor’s parent
or guardian or in the case of an
individual with a guardian, the
individual’s guardian. Consent may not
be given by the abuser or suspected
abuser of the minor or individual with
a guardian, or the abuser or suspected
abuser of the other parent of the minor.
In paragraph (c), we propose that if
release of information described in
paragraphs (a) and (b) is compelled by
statutory or court mandate grantees and
subgrantees shall make reasonable
attempts to provide notice to victims
affected by the release of the
information and grantees and
subgrantees shall take steps necessary to
protect the privacy and safety of the
persons affected by the release of the
information.
PO 00000
Frm 00008
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
In paragraph (d), we propose that
grantees and subgrantees may share: (1)
Nonpersonally identifying information,
in the aggregate, regarding services to
their clients and demographic
nonpersonally identifying information
in order to comply with Federal, State,
or tribal reporting, evaluation, or data
collection requirements; (2) courtgenerated information and law
enforcement-generated information
contained in secure, governmental
registries for protective order
enforcement purposes; and (3) law
enforcement- and prosecution-generated
information necessary for law
enforcement and prosecution purposes.
To further explain, in meeting
reporting, evaluation, or data collection
requirements, grantees may not disclose
individual data, but only nonidentifying aggregate data. If the release
of information is compelled by statutory
or court mandate, grantees and subgrantees shall make reasonable attempts
to provide notice to victims affected by
the release of the information and
grantees and sub-grantees shall take
steps necessary to protect the privacy
and safety of the persons affected by the
release of the information. Service
providers, including those in co-located
facilities such as Family Justice Centers,
can share information about a client
upon her/his request if the client signs
a waiver that is limited in time and
scope, reasonably responsive to
individual circumstances, to coordinate
and execute a specific service or
request. A reasonably time-limited
release is determined by an individual’s
safety and other needs as identified by
the individual. Reasonably time-limited
releases may be loosely standardized if
grantees are addressing the similar
needs of victims who are similarly
situated; however, standardization
should be rare since individual victims’
circumstances are the guiding factor
when determining the reasonableness
and time limitations of required written
releases. For example, victims residing
in shelter are often receiving the
services of other providers and/or are
being referred by shelters to other
providers. To ensure coordinated
services, FVPSA-funded shelter grantees
have been known to standardize form
releases under such circumstances
between organizations to help support
efficiency and staff work flow. However,
even this kind of standardization often
includes and requires additional
individualized instructions and
limitations depending upon a victim’s
safety and other needs.
Funders and licensing agencies (i.e.,
fire code inspectors, state licensing
inspectors, etc.) reviewing shelter
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
performance or operations cannot view
identifying client files. Any information
shared must have all personally
identifying information redacted. HHS
will continue to offer technical
assistance to States who are seeking a
balance between oversight and
confidentiality. These requirements
directly track the statute (42 U.S.C.
10406(c)(5)) and there is very little
discretion available to the Department,
or to grantees or subgrantees. There are
also additional provisions in the
regulatory text which mirror statutory
requirements for the consent of
unemancipated minors. In this regard,
consent shall be given by the person,
except in the case of an unemancipated
minor it shall be given by both the
minor and the minor’s parent or
guardian; or in the case of an individual
with a guardian it shall be given by the
individual’s guardian. A parent or
guardian may not give consent if: he or
she is the abuser or suspected abuser of
the minor or individual with a guardian;
or, the abuser or suspected abuser of the
other parent of the minor. We also
propose along these lines that
reasonable accommodation be made to
those who may be unable, due to
disability or other functional limitation,
to provide consent in writing. This
slightly varies the statutory definition,
though it is not intended as a
substitution, to ensure that those with
disabilities have a meaningful
alternative to providing informed
consent if they are otherwise
incapacitated. If additional clarification
would be useful in the rule, we
welcome suggestions. We will issue
guidance addressing any future
situations that may present problems of
interpretation. We also will use National
Resource Centers, State Domestic
Violence Coalitions, and Training and
Technical Assistance Grants to assist
service providers in meeting these
requirements and in dealing with other
Federal, State, Tribal or local agencies
that may seek protected information.
These regulations do not supersede
stronger protections that may be
provided by Federal, State, Tribal or
local laws.
Pursuant to FVPSA Section
10406(c)(5)(H), we note that our
proposed language also protects the
addresses of shelter facilities with
confidential locations, except with
written authorization of the person or
persons responsible for operation of the
shelter. To date there have been no
issues reported to FYSB regarding this
requirement except when Tribal nations
are geographically isolated thereby
making confidentiality nearly
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
impossible. Tribal leaders often utilize
FVPSA funds to transport victims from
isolated to more populated areas where
victims have greater access to necessary
services especially when confidentiality
cannot be maintained within very
confined and remote areas. In these
circumstances, it is not uncommon that
a Tribe may utilize most of its FVPSA
grant on transportation. We welcome
comments especially from Tribes and
tribal organizations, as well as
concerned others, about how
confidentiality may be more effectively
maintained given these very challenging
situations.
Section 1370.5 What additional nondiscrimination requirements apply to
these programs?
We propose to add § 1370.5 under
new Subpart A and revise it to include
non-discrimination requirements that
apply uniquely to FVPSA programs.
These are in addition to broad
government-wide or HHS-wide civil
rights protections in regulations
concerning discrimination on the basis
of race, color, national origin, disability,
and age that apply to all HHS grantees,
including FVPSA grantees (see the list
of other regulations that apply to these
programs in § 1370.3 of this proposed
rule). FVPSA contains broad
prohibitions against discrimination on
the basis of sex or religion in FVPSA
programs, and we propose to codify in
regulation these prohibitions. The HHS
Office for Civil Rights (OCR) enforces
FVPSA’s broad prohibitions against
discrimination, including on the basis of
sex or religion, under delegated
authority from the Secretary. In
addition, our proposed language says
that FVPSA State and Tribal Formula
grant-funded services must be provided
without imposing eligibility criteria,
and without requiring documentation
for eligibility (see the Domestic Violence
Fact Sheet on Access to HHS-Funded
Services for Immigrant Survivors of
Domestic Violence, at https://
www.hhs.gov/ocr/civilrights/resources/
specialtopics/origin/
domesticviolencefactsheet.html). Our
proposed language also includes the
FVPSA’s prohibition against placing
conditions on receipt of emergency
shelter or requiring participation in
supportive services.
Prohibition Against Discrimination on
the Basis of Sex or Religion
In paragraph (a), we propose to codify
in regulation FVPSA’s broad
prohibitions against discrimination on
the basis of sex or religion. Under its
delegated authority, OCR enforces these
prohibitions. Consistent with the usual
PO 00000
Frm 00009
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
61897
approaches to defining civil rights
obligations in Federal regulations, we
do not propose to elaborate in regulatory
text all the situations to which the
FVPSA’s protections against
discrimination on the basis of sex or
religion might apply. However,
consistent with our longstanding policy
in Funding Opportunity
Announcements and reliance on
regulatory guidance issued by the
Department of Housing and Urban
Development amending 24 CFR parts 5,
200, 203, 236, 400, 570, 574, 882, 891,
and 982, published in the Federal
Register/Vol. 77, No. 23/Friday,
February 3, 2012, we interpret the
prohibition against discrimination on
the basis of sex as also prohibiting
discrimination on the basis of gender
identity.
As a result, FVPSA grantees must
provide comparable services to victims
regardless of sex or gender. This
includes not only providing access to
services for male victims of family,
domestic, and dating violence, but also
making sure not to limit services for
victims with adolescent sons (up to the
age of majority), and LGBTQ victims.
Victims and their sons must be
sheltered or housed together unless they
request otherwise. Historically, most
services have been provided to women
because they are the overwhelming
majority of victims, are more likely to
suffer serious injuries and other impacts
of the violence, and have been the
primary demographic seeking services.
As such, services have been mostly
tailored to address the unique needs of
female survivors. However, there are
male victims of these crimes who
deserve access to safety from their
offenders and services to help them
rebuild their lives free from violence.
FVPSA states, ‘‘no person shall on the
ground of sex or religion be excluded
from participation in, be denied the
benefits of, or be subject to
discrimination under, any program or
activity in whole or in part with funds
made available under this chapter.
Nothing in this chapter shall require any
such program or activity to include any
individual in any program or activity
without taking into consideration that
individual’s sex in those certain
instances where sex is a bona fide
occupational qualification or
programmatic factor reasonably
necessary to the normal or safe
operation of that particular program or
activity’’ (42 U.S.C. § 10406(c)(2)(B)).
For clarification, we propose that the
‘‘normal and safe operation’’ of a
program or activity be that which is
essential and safe for operations.
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
61898
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
This statutory directive should not be
interpreted to eliminate programming or
services tailored to the unique needs of
individuals served by FVPSA grantees,
sub-grantees, contractors and/or vendors
provided they are not based on illegal
sex classifications. Moreover,
programmatic access must be assured
for all victims of family, domestic, and
dating violence, and responses to
individual victims should be traumainformed, victim-defined, and culturally
relevant, which may involve providing
specialized services and supports. We
do not propose to define in regulation
what is or is not allowed in precise
circumstances.
If a shelter can reasonably separate
the sexes in a manner which allows for
single sex bedrooms and bathrooms and
the essential and safe operation of the
particular program is not substantially
compromised, it is reasonable to
provide such separation. Essential
services are those required by the grant,
which are funded to support the longterm social and emotional well-being of
victims and their dependents. If the
essential or safe operation of the
program or activity would be
substantially compromised, alternative,
equivalent shelter and services should
be offered as practicable. For instance,
a male victim could be offered a hotel
placement and provided supportive
services at the shelter.
Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender
and Questioning (LGBTQ) individuals
must also have access to FVPSA-funded
shelter and non-residential programs.
LGBTQ survivors face unique
challenges accessing programs due to
victimization often resulting from the
intersection of bias and multiple
oppressions as well as the limited
understanding of providers in delivering
welcoming and culturally-appropriate
services. Examples include those of gay
men who may have difficulty accessing
shelter services because domestic
violence shelters were founded and
grew within the framework of the
battered women’s movement. Transwomen face service barriers because
providers are often confounded by an
individual’s apparent biological sex
which may contradict perceived or
actual gender. Programmatic
accessibility for transgender survivors
must be afforded to meet individual
needs like those provided to all
survivors. For the purpose of assigning
a beneficiary to sex-segregated or sexspecific services, the recipient should
ask a transgender beneficiary which
group or services the beneficiary wishes
to join. The recipient may not, however,
ask questions about the beneficiary’s
anatomy or medical history or make
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
inappropriate demands for identity
documents. ACF requires that a FVPSA
grantee, subgrantee, contractor, or
vendor that makes decisions about
eligibility for or placement into singlesex emergency shelters or other facilities
place a potential victim (or current
victim/client seeking a new assignment)
in a shelter or other appropriate
placement that corresponds to the
gender with which the person identifies,
taking health and safety concerns into
consideration. A victim’s/client’s or
potential victim’s/client’s own views
with respect to personal health and
safety must be given serious
consideration in making the placement.
For instance, if the potential victim/
client requests to be placed based on his
or her sex assigned at birth, ACF
requires that the provider place the
individual in accordance with that
request, consistent with health, safety,
and privacy concerns. ACF also requires
that a provider not make an assignment
or re- assignment based on complaints
of another person when the sole stated
basis of the complaint is a victim/client
or potential victim/client’s nonconformance with gender stereotypes.
Additionally, LGBTQ individuals
seeking refuge at domestic violence
shelters may experience homophobia or
bias or may confront the invisibility of
their experiences in the form of
advertising and resource materials that
only address heterosexual domestic
violence. Therefore, programmatic
accessibility for LGBTQ survivors must
be afforded to meet individual needs
like those provided to all other
survivors.
With respect to religion, the religion,
religious beliefs or religious practices of
a client should not be a relevant factor
in providing or denying services.
Religious practices must not be imposed
upon victims. Dietary practices dictated
by particular religious beliefs may
require some reasonable
accommodation in cooking or feeding
arrangements for particular clients as
practicable.
Prohibition Against Requiring
Documentation for Eligibility
In paragraph (b), we propose a
prohibition against requiring
documentation for eligibility. Battered
immigrants face unique challenges
accessing services and often face
conflicting eligibility requirements in
FVPSA-funded programs as noted at
https://www.hhs.gov/ocr/civilrights/
resources/specialtopics/origin/
domesticviolencefactsheet.html.
Pursuant to HHS guidance originally
published in 2001 and updated in
August, 2012, recipients of Federal
PO 00000
Frm 00010
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
financial assistance must ensure that
their programs and activities normally
provided in English are accessible to
Limited English Proficient persons and
do not discriminate on the basis of
national origin in violation of Title VI of
the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (see also
§ 1370.3, Executive Order 13166).
Battered immigrant victims and
survivors of domestic violence must not
face additional burdens to accessing
FVPSA-funded services when they often
lack knowledge of, or receive
misinformation, of U.S. laws. They also
are often isolated from family and
community and face significant
employment and economic challenges.
Programs must ensure that battered
immigrants, for example, are not
required to provide documentation
because FVPSA has no immigration
restrictions and its services do not
qualify as a Federal public benefit
pursuant to the Personal Responsibility
and Work Opportunity Reconciliation
Act of 1996,’’ Public Law 104–193
(August 22, 1996), as amended by the
‘‘Illegal Immigration Reform and
Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996,’’
Public Law 104–208 (September 30,
1996).
Other FVPSA Programmatic
Accessibility Guidance
Human trafficking often
simultaneously occurs in the context of
intimate relationships between
perpetrators of trafficking/domestic/
intimate partner violence and those who
are victimized by such crimes. In the
spirit of the Federal Strategic Action
Plan on Services for Victims of Human
Trafficking in the United States 2013–
2017, FVPSA-funded programs are
strongly encouraged to safely screen for
and identify victims of human
trafficking who are also victims or
survivors of intimate partner/domestic
violence and provide services that
support their unique needs. FVPSA
services can also support trafficked
victims who are not experiencing
domestic or intimate partner violence as
long as victims and survivors of
domestic/intimate partner violence are
prioritized first by FVPSA grantees.
Additionally, covered entities should
be aware of additional nondiscrimination grant conditions that
may be applicable under the Violence
Against Women Reauthorization Act of
2013. For more information on these
requirements, please see the Department
of Justice’s April 2014 document,
‘‘Frequently Asked Questions:
Nondiscrimination Grant Conditions in
the Violence Against Women
Reauthorization Act of 2013,’’April
2014, available at: https://
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/ovw/
legacy/2014/06/20/faqs-ngc-vawa.pdf.
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Voluntary Services
This new section also contains
proposed language in paragraph (c) from
FVPSA (section 308(d)) prohibiting
grantees or subgrantees either from
imposing any conditions on the receipt
of emergency shelter, or from requiring
the acceptance of supportive services.
All such services must be voluntarily
accepted by program participants. The
prohibition on imposing ‘‘conditions’’ is
intended to prohibit shelters from
applying inappropriate screening
mechanisms, such as criminal
background checks or sobriety
requirements. Similarly, the receipt of
shelter should not be conditioned on
participation in other services, such as
counseling, parenting classes, or lifeskills classes. We do not intend these
provisions to preempt State law, in any
case where a State may impose some
legal requirement to protect the safety
and welfare of all shelter residents. In
the case of an apparent conflict with
State or Federal laws, case-by-case
determinations will be made. In general,
when two or more laws apply, a grantee
must meet the highest standard in any
of those laws. Nor are these provisions
intended to deny a shelter the ability to
manage its services and secure the
safety of all shelter residents should, for
example, a client become violent or
abusive to other clients. We welcome
comments on this provision.
Enforcement
OCR is charged with enforcing the
prohibitions against discrimination on
the basis of sex and religion in FVSPA.
We note that under Federal civil rights
laws administered by the Department,
OCR uses a variety of techniques,
including conducting investigations,
negotiating agreements with covered
entities, and issuing violation letters of
findings where warranted, to enforce
applicable civil rights laws, with the
aim of achieving voluntary compliance.
We would expect that similar practices
will be used for investigating any
complaints made under these proposed
requirements.
For situations that fall outside of the
authority of OCR, we intend to handle
exceptional situations, in cases where
service providers cannot directly and
easily solve the problem, through
informal guidance and, as appropriate,
case-specific advice. FVPSA does
provide, however, for more severe
remedies including withholding FVPSA
grant awards until the problem is
resolved or denying future Federal
funding. We also would expect to use
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
National/Special Issue Resource Centers
and Culturally-Specific Special Issue
Resource Centers, State Domestic
Violence Coalitions, and Training and
Technical Assistance Grants to provide
advice to service providers on dealing
with any patterns of problems that may
emerge. We welcome comments on
these proposals.
Section 1370.6 What requirements for
reports and evaluations apply to these
programs?
We propose to add to new Subpart A
a new section (§ 1370.6) explicitly
requiring any recipient of grants or
contracts under the FVPSA to provide
performance reports to the Secretary.
Such reports are already required and
the proposed regulatory text merely
confirms the important role they play in
evaluating grantee performance. In order
to clarify requirements that have been
questioned in the past, we propose to
require that American Samoa, the
Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana
Islands, Guam, and the U.S. Virgin
Islands follow all reporting
requirements applicable to the States
and Tribes, Puerto Rico, and the District
of Columbia and to provide required
reports directly to the Division of
Family Violence Prevention and
Services within FYSB, unless otherwise
communicated to the grantees. These
requirements supplement, and do not
replace the Territorial reporting
requirements of the ACF Office of
Community Services in its
administration of Consolidated Block
Grants as part of the Social Services
Block Grants program.
Subpart B—State and Indian Tribal
Grants
Section 1370.10 What additional
requirements apply to State and Indian
Tribal grants?
The existing rule at § 1370.2 contains
a brief paragraph stating that State and
Tribal grantees ‘‘must meet the statutory
requirements of the Act and all
applicable regulations.’’ We propose to
add a new Subpart B addressing the
formula grants awarded to States and
Tribes. Under Subpart B, we propose to
add § 1370.10 which would include the
most important requirements applicable
to these formula grants. These proposals
track the statute. However, they do not
contain all of the specific detail of
FVPSA, but simply describe the basic
purposes, procedures, and activities that
are expected for State and Tribal
grantees, respectively. They also
describe the information expected in
grant applications. Because there are
important differences between State and
PO 00000
Frm 00011
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
61899
Tribal grants, we have described them
separately.
Importantly, these proposed
provisions focus on planning,
consultation, and coordinating activities
that we expect of these grantees and
which are statutory priorities in FVPSA
Sections 10407, 10408, and 10409. They
focus on protection, and require
documentation of the law or procedures
(typically restraining orders or orders of
protection) by which the State or Tribe
has implemented for the eviction of an
abusive spouse or intimate partner from
a shared household. In addition to the
FVPSA requirement we propose to
require that such procedures must
include not only family violence, but
also domestic or dating violence, an
expansion of scope met by most but not
all existing State statutes. In order to
allow States time to modify existing
statutes, we propose that the effective
date for this provision be two legislative
sessions after these proposed rules are
made final (all other provisions would
be effective sixty days after issuance of
the final rule.) As currently indicated in
the Funding Opportunity
Announcements we also propose to
specifically require documentation of
policies and procedures to ensure the
confidentiality of client records. Finally,
these provisions provide for the use of
the Funding Opportunity
Announcements and other program
guidance to provide additional details
and procedures that apply to these
grants. We welcome comments on these
proposed provisions.
In paragraph (a), consistent with
FVPSA, we propose requiring that
States consult with and provide for the
participation of Coalitions in the
planning and monitoring of the
distribution and administration of
subgrant programs and projects; active
Coalition participation is envisioned in
these processes. States and Coalitions
have complementary roles within the
FVPSA framework because States use
FVPSA funds to support programs and
projects often carried out by a
significant portion of the memberships
of Coalitions. Coalitions’ FVPSAmandated roles include training and
technical assistance that frequently
mirror the support needed to effectively
manage FVPSA-funded programs and
services as found in FVPSA Section
10408. States, by virtue of their roles as
funders, must both ensure that
subgrantees comply with Federal laws,
regulations and guidance as well as
promote programming that effectively
supports the safety, security and social
and emotional well-being of victims and
their dependents; Funding Opportunity
Announcements have for several years
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
61900
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
identified these requirements. To
support the requirements in FVPSA
Section 10407(a)(2)(D) Coalitions are
critical to supporting States’ roles as
funders and must effectively participate
in subgrantee award processes and
States’ planning processes to fully
understand States’ expectations and
subgrantee requirements. At a minimum
to further FVPSA requirements, we
expect that States and Coalitions will
work together to determine grant
priorities based upon jointly identified
needs; to identify strategies to address
needs; to define mutual expectations
regarding programmatic performance
and monitoring; and to implement an
annual collaboration plan that
incorporates concrete steps for
accomplishing these tasks. All of these
requirements are either found in the
Funding Opportunity Announcements
dating back to FVPSA reauthorization in
2010 or have been discussed in grantee
meetings and other informal
communications via FYSB listservs. We
welcome comments on these
requirements.
The FVPSA includes Tribes in these
proposed processes but this rule is not
intended to encroach upon Tribal
sovereignty. We, however, envision
similar processes for Tribes, States, and
Coalitions that support coordination
and collaboration when feasible and
appropriate. We especially welcome
comments from Tribes and Coalitions
about this provision.
Pursuant to FVPSA Section 10411,
one role of Coalitions is to identify
statewide gaps in services and the most
effective way to meet identified gaps
and other problems is by conducting
needs assessments. We propose that
States and Coalitions must work closely
to undertake joint planning so that
funding is leveraged successfully to
implement FVPSA requirements in
Sections 10407 and 10411. We also
propose that Tribal and other
underserved populations are invited
and encouraged to participate in State
planning and Coalition needs
assessments. It is essential that the full
spectrum of domestic violence service
providers, including Tribes, Tribal
organizations and other culturallyspecific, community-based
organizations have significant input into
decision-making processes that support
State planning and Coalition needs
assessments as found in FVPSA
Sections 10407, 10408, and 10411. So
that States are continually aware of
subgrantees’ training and technical
assistance needs as well as intersecting
systems challenges impacting service
provision, they must involve Coalitions
in program planning and subgrantee
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
monitoring. We expect that States and
Coalitions will meet regularly to
coordinate training and technical
assistance; to address ongoing
programmatic challenges; and to
implement best practices in victim
services. We encourage pre- and postaward meetings to substantively address
and respond to States’ identified
priorities; to assess systems and
programmatic impacts as a result of
States’ priorities and funding decisions;
and to assess subgrantee performance.
We propose these additional
requirements to complement those in
FVPSA. We invite public comment on
these areas.
FVPSA also requires that States and
Tribes involve community-based
organizations that primarily serve
culturally-specific, underserved
communities and determine how such
organizations can assist the States and
Tribes in serving the needs of all
communities. To fulfill these
obligations, we expect and propose that
States and Tribes will encourage the
participation of underserved
communities, including older
individuals and those with disabilities,
in planning. If States and Tribes use
special councils, committees or other
mechanisms to accomplish planning,
we also propose that they identify and
invite underserved, culturally specific
organizations and/or community
representatives to participate in these
bodies to fully embrace both specific
FVPSA-requirements (sections 10407,
10408, and 10409) and the spirit of the
law. Emphasis also should be placed on
building the capacity of culturally
specific organizations to assist in both
providing services and in identifying
the needs of underserved populations.
We envision that States will involve
Coalitions in this planning as they
routinely engage in community
organizing and partner with
organizations that support both the
identification and leadership of
underserved communities. We invite
Tribes to partner with Coalitions to help
in this capacity as well. We encourage
public comment and advice on what
mechanisms States and Tribes might use
to accomplish these purposes, to
describe any successful models they
have identified to achieve these
purposes, and to advise us on how best
accomplish these goals. We particularly
seek input from Tribes on how best to
address underserved communities
within the Tribe, and what types of
processes would be helpful. Tribes are
themselves considered underserved,
culturally specific communities, and we
do not interpret FVPSA as infringing
PO 00000
Frm 00012
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
upon Tribal sovereignty or as intending
to create burdensome or meaningless
requirements on the Tribes.
Additionally, in paragraph (a), to
complement FVPSA requirements to
build capacity in culturally-specific
organizations, we expect that
specialized services will be available to
support the specific needs of their
communities. While traditional/
mainstream FVPSA-funded programs
are generally accessible to all people in
compliance with Federal, State, and
local law, unique expertise regarding
the needs of underserved and
historically marginalized populations
lies within those communities. We
propose to require States, in their
funding processes, to address the needs
of underserved, racial and ethnic
minorities including Tribal populations,
and people with disabilities and their
families, with an emphasis on funding
organizations that can meet unique
needs including culturally relevant and
linguistically appropriate services.
These requirements have both been
addressed in the Funding Opportunity
Announcements as well as grantee
meetings within the last 5 years. Jointly
using multiple Federal and State
funding streams may accomplish these
purposes and we expect that States will
make significant efforts to create
awareness of FVPSA funding for
culturally-specific communities and
Tribes, including training and technical
assistance that supports organizations
serving those communities in the
FVPSA application and grant award
processes. FVPSA funding is not
intended to just support traditionallyfunded organizations. However, it is
intended to support core shelter and
supportive services (see FVPSA section
10401). It is not the intent of these
regulations to change this important
priority. The needs of culturally specific
organizations and communities,
including Tribes, are not, however,
mutually exclusive from the need for
core services; they are complementary.
Moreover, providing truly accessible
services to culturally-specific
communities often means that the
leadership, management and staff of
FVPSA funded, subgrantee programs
should reflect the diversity of the
populations seeking services, including
people with disabilities and their
families, and other underserved
populations. We therefore propose,
pursuant to FVPSA Sections 10407 and
10408, that States take steps to address
these priorities and specifically describe
them in their annual applications.
Partnering with Coalitions and
culturally-specific community based
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
organizations in these areas is especially
critical. Public comment is welcome on
these issues.
State Applications
Requirements for applications made
by States are outlined under proposed
1370.10 section (b). As required in
FVPSA Section 10407(a)(1), a State
application must be submitted by the
Chief Executive of the State and signed
by the Chief Executive Officer or the
Chief Program Official designated as
responsible for the administration of
FVPSA.
Under paragraph (b)(1), and as
indicated in the Funding Opportunity
Announcements as well as to fulfill
FVPSA requirements, we propose that
the State application include the name
of the State agency, the name and
contact information for the Chief
Program Official designated as
responsible for the administration of
funds under FVPSA and coordination of
related programs within the State, and
the name and contact information for a
contact person if different from the
Chief Program Official.
Under proposed paragraph (b)(2),
pursuant to the Funding Opportunity
Announcements and to fulfill FVPSA
requirements, the State application must
include a plan describing in detail how
the needs of underserved populations
will be met. This includes, under
proposed paragraph (b)(2)(i),
identification of which populations in
the State are underserved, a description
of those that are being targeted for
outreach and services, and a brief
explanation of why those populations
were selected to receive outreach and
services. As States undertake the
process of identifying underserved,
culturally-specific communities in their
respective State, we expect that they
will consult data generated from Federal
and State census counts as well as other
demographic information. Information
on specific details will be provided in
FOAs and other guidance. In addition,
this paragraph includes a requirement
regarding how often the State revisits
the identification and selection of the
populations to be served with FVPSA
funding (not to exceed three years). For
example, we propose that at least every
three years States must identify
population shifts or changes to assist in
meaningful delivery of culturallyspecific services and the involvement of
potential new planning partners or
explain why these steps are
unnecessary. State applications must
document this process. We strongly
encourage that State plans be reassessed
on a triennial basis or that an
explanation be included in the State’s
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
application regarding why reassessment
is unnecessary. These requirements are
proposed to fulfill FVPSA and the
Funding Opportunity Announcements
to support the provision of services to
underserved populations. We welcome
comments on these provisions.
Under proposed paragraph (b)(2)(ii),
we also propose in order to fulfill
FVPSA requirements and those found in
the Funding Opportunity
Announcements that the State
application’s plan describing how the
needs of underserved populations will
be met include a description of the
outreach plan, including the domestic
violence training to be provided, the
means for providing technical assistance
and support, and the leadership role
played by those representing and
serving the underserved populations in
question.
Under proposed paragraph (b)(2)(iii),
we also include a requirement for a
description of the specific services to be
provided or enhanced, such as new
shelters or services, improved access to
shelters or services, or new services for
underserved populations, as defined in
this NPRM Section 1370.2, such as
victims from communities of color,
immigrant victims, victims with
disabilities, or older individuals. This
proposed requirement is intended to
fulfill FVPSA requirements and reflect
provisions in the Funding Opportunity
Announcements.
Finally, under proposed paragraph
(b)(2)(iv) to fulfill FVPSA requirements
and those found in the Funding
Opportunity Announcements, we
propose that the State application’s plan
describing how the needs of
underserved populations will be met
include a description of the public
information component of the State’s
outreach program, including the
elements of the program that are used to
explain domestic violence, the most
effective and safe ways to seek help, and
tools to identify available resources.
In subsection 1370.10(b)(3), we
propose to fulfill FVPSA requirements
and the provisions in the Funding
Opportunity Announcements that each
State application contain a description
of the process and procedures used to
involve the State Domestic Violence
Coalition, knowledgeable individuals,
and interested organizations, including
those serving or representing
underserved communities in the State
planning process.
In paragraph (4) of this subsection, we
propose to fulfill FVPSA requirements
and those found in the Funding
Opportunity Announcements by
requiring that each State application
contain documentation of planning,
PO 00000
Frm 00013
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
61901
consultation with and participation of
the State Domestic Violence Coalition in
the administration and distribution of
FVPSA programs, projects, and grant
funds awarded to the State.
In paragraph (5) pursuant to FVPSA
Section 10407(a)(2)(c) we propose that a
description of the procedures used to
assure an equitable distribution of
grants and grant funds within the State
and between urban and rural areas, as
defined by the Census Bureau, within
the State. The U.S. Census Bureau
(USCB) defines (and FYSB defers to and
incorporates this definition) two types
of ‘‘urban’’ areas: (1) Urbanized areas of
50,000 or more people; and (2) ‘‘urban
clusters’’ of at least 2,500 and less than
50,000 people. The USCB explains that
‘‘rural’’ encompasses all population,
housing, and territory not included
within an ‘‘urban’’ area as ‘‘rural’’. The
plan should describe how funding
allocations will address the needs of
underserved communities. Other
Federal, State, local, and private funds
may be considered in determining
compliance. We also propose to require
States, in their funding processes, to
address the needs of underserved, racial
and ethnic minorities including Tribal
populations, and people with
disabilities and their families, with an
emphasis on funding organizations that
can meet unique needs including
culturally relevant and linguistically
appropriate services.
In paragraph (6) we propose in order
to fulfill FVPSA requirements that a
State’s application include: A
description of how the State plans to
use the grant funds including a State
plan developed in consultation with
State and Tribal Domestic Violence
Coalitions and representatives of
underserved and culturally specific
communities; a description of the target
populations; of the number of shelters to
be funded; of the number of nonresidential programs to be funded; of the
services the State will provide; and of
the expected results from the use of the
grant funds. To fulfill these
requirements, it is critically important
that States work with Coalitions and
Tribes to solicit their feedback on
program effectiveness which may
include recommendations such as
establishing program standards and
participating in program monitoring.
In paragraph (7) we propose pursuant
to FVPSA Section 10407(a)(2)(H) to
require that State applications include a
copy of the law or procedures, such as
a process for obtaining an order of
protection that the State has
implemented for the eviction of an
abusive spouse or other intimate,
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
61902
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
domestic, or dating partner from a
shared household or residence.
In paragraph (8) we propose pursuant
to FVPSA Section 10408(b)(2) to require
that State applications include an
assurance that not less than 70 percent
of the funds distributed by a State to
sub-recipients shall be distributed to
entities for the primary purpose of
providing immediate shelter and
supportive services to adult and youth
victims of family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence, and their
dependents, and that not less than 25
percent of the funds distributed by a
State to sub-recipients shall be
distributed to entities for the purpose of
providing supportive services and
prevention services (these percentages
may overlap with respect to supportive
services but are not included in the 5
percent cap applicable to State
administrative costs). No grant shall be
made under this section to an entity
other than a State unless the entity
agrees that, with respect to the costs to
be incurred by the entity in carrying out
the program or project for which the
grant is awarded, the entity will make
available (directly or through donations
from public or private entities) nonFederal contributions in an amount that
is not less than $1 for every $5 of
Federal funds provided under the grant.
The non-Federal contributions required
under this paragraph may be in cash or
in kind.
In paragraph (9) pursuant to FVPSA
Section 10406(c)(5) we propose
requiring that State applications include
documentation of policies, procedures
and protocols that ensure individual
identifiers of client records will not be
used when providing statistical data on
program activities and program services
or in the course of grant monitoring, that
the confidentiality of records pertaining
to any individual provided family
violence prevention or intervention
services by any program or entity
supported under the FVPSA will be
strictly maintained, and the address or
location of any shelter supported under
the FVPSA will not be made public
without the written authorization of the
person or persons responsible for the
operation of such shelter.
Our final proposed requirement, in
paragraph (10), would require that State
applications include additional
agreements, assurances, and
information, in such form, and
submitted in such manner as the
Funding Opportunity Announcement
and related program guidance prescribe.
State Coalitions and Tribal Coalitions
are specifically designated statutory
participants pursuant to FVPSA
Section10407(b)(3) in determining
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
whether State grantees and subgrantees
are fulfilling the goals and activities in
their respective State applications/plans
and complying with FVPSA grant
conditions. To fulfill these
requirements, it is critically important
that States work with Coalitions and
Tribes to solicit their feedback on
program effectiveness which may
include recommendations such as
establishing program standards and
participating in program monitoring.
Public comment is invited on the best
way to fulfill these statutory
requirements.
Tribal Applications
Finally, we note that there are some
proposed regulatory provisions that are
specific to Tribes and we have outlined
these in proposed § 1370.10(c). In
paragraph (c), we propose that that the
application from a Tribe or Tribal
Organization be signed by a Tribally
Designated Official, such as the Tribal
Chairperson or Chief Executive Officer,
as required in FVPSA Section 10410
and applicable Funding Opportunity
Announcements. We also propose in
paragraph (c)(1) to require that
applications from Tribal Consortia or
other joint Tribal applications include a
copy of a current Tribal resolution or an
equivalent document that verifies Tribal
approval of the application being
submitted as also required in the
Funding Opportunity Announcements.
We propose that the resolution or other
document should state that the
designated organization or agency has
the authority to submit an application
on behalf of the individuals in the
Tribe(s) and to administer programs and
activities funded pursuant to the
FVPSA. We also propose that the
resolution or equivalent document must
specify the name(s) of each Tribe and,
if Tribal resolutions are the vehicles to
support applications from Tribal
Consortia or other joint Tribal
applications, that a representative of
each Tribe signs the resolution. We also
propose to require that the service areas
proposed by Tribes in their
applications, be specifically delineated.
In proposed paragraph (c)(2) we
propose as indicated in the Funding
Opportunity Announcements requiring
that each Tribal application also contain
a description of the procedures designed
to involve knowledgeable individuals
and interested organizations in
providing services under the FVPSA.
For example, knowledgeable
individuals and interested organizations
may include Tribal officials or social
services staff involved in child abuse or
family violence prevention, Tribal law
enforcement officials, representatives of
PO 00000
Frm 00014
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
Tribal or State Domestic Violence
Coalitions, and operators of domestic
violence shelters and service programs.
Proposed paragraph (c)(3) requires
that Tribal applications pursuant to the
current Funding Opportunity
Announcement also include a
description of the applicant’s operation
of and/or capacity to carry out a family
violence prevention and services
program. Ways this information can be
demonstrated include evidence of: (i)
The current operation of a shelter, safe
house, or domestic violence prevention
program; (ii) the establishment of joint
or collaborative service agreements with
a local public agency or a private, nonprofit agency for the operation of family
violence prevention and intervention
activities or services; or (iii) the
operation of social services programs as
evidenced by receipt of grants or
contracts awarded under Indian Child
Welfare grants from the Bureau of
Indian Affairs; Child Welfare Services
grants under Title IV–B of the Social
Security Act; or Family Preservation
and Family Support grants under Title
IV–B of the Social Security Act.
Proposed paragraph (c)(4), pursuant to
the current Funding Opportunity
Announcement, would require Tribal
applications to include a description of
the services to be provided, how the
applicant organizations plans to use the
grant funds to provide the direct
services, to whom the services will be
provided, and the expected results of
the services.
Proposed paragraph (c)(5) pursuant to
FVPSA Section 10407(a)(2)(H) would
require Tribal applications to include
documentation of the law or procedure
which has been implemented for the
eviction of an abusing spouse or other
intimate, domestic, or dating partner
from a shared household or residence.
Proposed paragraph (c)(6) pursuant to
FVPSA Section 10406(c)(5) would
require Tribal applications to include
documentation of the policies and
procedures developed and
implemented, including copies of the
policies and procedures, to ensure that
individual identifiers of client records
will not be used when providing
statistical data on program activities and
program services or in the course of
grant monitoring and that the
confidentiality of records pertaining to
any individual provided domestic
violence prevention or intervention
services by any FVPSA-supported
program will be strictly maintained. If a
FVPSA grantee or subgrantee fails to
comply with these requirements,
additional programmatic support and
technical assistance will be provided by
the FYSB program staff and FVPSA-
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
funded technical assistance providers to
avoid an interruption or defunding. As
identified in section 1370.4, Tribes often
have significant confidentiality
challenges due to geographic isolation
and, therefore, we welcome comments
from Tribes on this section.
The final requirement for Tribal
applications, proposed paragraph (c)(7),
would require such applications to
include agreements, assurances, and
information, in such form, and
submitted in such manner, as the
Funding Opportunity Announcement
and related program guidance prescribe.
We do not believe that these
provisions impose any additional
burden on Tribes, but welcome
comments.
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Subpart C—State Domestic Violence
Coalition Grants
Section 1370.20 What additional
requirements apply to State Domestic
Violence Coalitions?
The current rule, in § 1370.3, contains
provisions for Coalition Grants. Each
State and Territory has a domestic
violence Coalition that receives FVPSA
funding as the HHS-designated
statewide domestic violence Coalition.
These Coalitions provide an essential
role in the domestic violence field, and
only one per State can be funded under
the FVPSA. We propose to add
§ 1370.20 under new Subpart C. Our
proposed provisions focus in more
detail than the current rule on the
planning, consultation, and
coordinating activities than the statute
now expects of these grantees. In
particular, in paragraph (b)(1), pursuant
to FVPSA we propose to require that
membership include representatives of a
majority of the primary-purpose
domestic violence service providers
operating within the State or Territory
(see the proposed definition of primarypurpose discussed earlier in this
preamble). In paragraph (b)(2) we
propose that Coalitions’ Boards of
Directors also must be representative of
the membership comprised of the
primary-purpose domestic violence
service providers in their respective
States and Territories and also may
include community members. Boards of
Directors composed of member
representatives and community
members are highly encouraged so that
Coalition boards have the cross-sector
expertise to ensure Coalitions have
strong organizational infrastructures,
including Boards of Directors that
support the long-term programmatic and
financial sustainability of Coalitions.
Financial sustainability of Coalitions, as
independent, autonomous non-profit
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
organizations, also must be supported
by their membership comprised of the
primary-purpose domestic violence
service providers in the respective
States and Territories, including those
member representatives on the
Coalitions’ Boards of Directors.
Coalitions’ financial sustainability also
is critical to the programmatic and fiscal
success of their members and these
priorities should not be interpreted to
conflict with the same or
complimentary priorities of their
domestic violence service provider
member constituents.
State and Territorial Domestic
Violence Coalitions play a unique role
in assisting Federal, State and local
governments, victim service providers,
including Tribes and Tribal
organizations, and the private sector in
coordinating and developing policies
and procedures, conducting outreach
and public awareness, and providing
training and technical assistance. We,
therefore, propose in section (c) that
Coalitions demonstrate in the annual
application their competencies in
provision of programming and other
functions necessary under FVPSA (42
U.S.C. 10402(11) and 10411). Coalitions
also would be required to collaborate
with Indian Tribes and Tribal
organizations (and corresponding
Alaska Native and Native Hawaiian
groups or communities) to address the
needs of American Indian, Alaska
Native, and Native Hawaiian victims of
family violence, domestic violence, or
dating violence, if such Tribes and
organizations exist within a given State
and are willing to work with the
Coalition. It is, therefore, especially
important that Coalitions include Tribes
and Tribal organizations in their
membership structures where possible.
As outlined in proposed (c)(1)(i)–
(viii), Coalitions also are required to
have demonstrated capacity to
coordinate with multiple systems to
encourage appropriate and
comprehensive responses that promote
the support and safety needs of adult
and youth victims of family, domestic,
or dating violence. Demonstrated
capacity may include but is not limited
to: Identifying successful efforts that
support child welfare agencies’
identification and support of victims
during intake processes; creation of
membership standards that enhance
victim safety and fully require training
and technical assistance for compliance
with federal housing, disability, and sex
discrimination laws and regulations;
and, training judicial personnel on
trauma-informed courtroom practice.
Such systems include but are not
limited to: Public and mental health;
PO 00000
Frm 00015
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
61903
law enforcement; courts/judiciary; child
protective services, to include custody
and visitation issues impacting victims
within child welfare systems; protection
and advocacy systems; housing; social
welfare; private enterprise; and, aging
and disability systems to develop
appropriate responses for older
individuals and individuals with
disabilities. Under proposed paragraph
(c)(1), Coalitions also must, in the
annual applications for funding, have
documented experience in
administering Federal grants supporting
these programmatic areas or have a
documented history of active
participation in the respective statutory
program areas enunciated in 42 U.S.C.
10411(c)(1) and (2)(A) and (B). If a
Coalition receives VAWA STOP
(Services, Training, Officers,
Prosecutors grant program—42 U.S.C.
3796gg(c)(1)) funding for Coalitions and
utilizes that funding for programming
and activities to address domestic
violence and law enforcement, the
courts/judiciary, and/or child protective
services, including child custody and
visitation in child welfare cases, it does
not have to spend FVPSA funds on
these activities. Instead, in its annual
application, it must provide an annual
assurance that such activities are
conducted with VAWA STOP Coalition
funding and such activities must be
described in the application.
Under proposed paragraph (d), we
outline that nothing in this section
limits the ability of a Coalition to use
non-Federal or other Federal funding
sources to conduct required functions,
provided that if the Coalition uses funds
received under section 2001(c)(1) of the
Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets
Act of 1968 to perform the functions
described in subsections (2)(iv) and (v)
in lieu of funds provided under the
FVPSA, it shall provide an annual
assurance to the Secretary that it is
using such funds, and that it is
coordinating the activities conducted
under this section with those of the
State’s activities under Part T of title I
of the Omnibus Crime Control and Safe
Streets Act of 1968.
Coalition Designation
In paragraph (e) we propose that in
cases in which two or more
organizations seek designation, the
designation of each State’s and
Territory’s individual Coalition is
within the exclusive discretion of HHS.
The Department will determine which
applicant best fits statutory criteria,
with particular attention paid to the
applicant’s documented history of
effective work, support of primarypurpose programs and programs that
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
61904
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
serve racial and ethnic minority
populations and underserved
populations (including but not limited
to those representing older individuals
and people with disabilities, LGBTQ
populations, and the Limited English
Proficient), coordination and
collaboration with the State or
Territorial government, and capacity to
accomplish the FVPSA mandated role of
a Coalition. As of the publication of this
rule, Coalitions for all 56 State and
Territorial Coalitions have been HHS
designated.
In paragraph (f), we propose that if a
Coalition becomes financially insolvent,
ceases to represent the majority of
primary purpose programs, is disbarred
from receiving Federal funding, or can
no longer meet the statutory
requirements of the FVPSA despite
technical assistance provided, the
Department may reopen the application
process for that State’s Coalition
designation. Because Coalitions are
intended to effectively represent diverse
victims and service providers in their
States, HHS would engage with
domestic violence service providers and
State leaders to inform their decision
about which alternative organizations
could be considered eligible.
As described in Subpart B, we
propose that Coalitions be required to
identify gaps in services and the most
effective ways to meet identified gaps
and other problems. We also propose
that Coalitions participate in planning
and monitoring of the distribution of
subgrants within the States and in the
administration of grant programs and
projects. In conducting needs
assessments, we propose to require that
Coalitions and States work in
partnership on the statutorily required
FVPSA State planning process to
involve representatives from
underserved and racial and ethnic
minority populations to plan, assess,
and voice the needs of the communities
they represent. Coalitions are expected
to assist States in identifying
underrepresented communities and
culturally-specific community based
organizations in State planning and to
work with States to unify planning and
needs assessment efforts so that
comprehensive and culturally-specific
services are provided. We also propose
through the inclusion of the populations
targeted to place emphasis on building
the capacity of culturally-specific
services and programs.
Subpart D—Discretionary Grants and
Contracts
The existing rule contains brief
paragraphs on two types of
discretionary grants (information and
VerDate Sep<11>2014
18:25 Oct 13, 2015
Jkt 238001
technical assistance and public
information campaign grants), in
§ 1370.4, and § 1370.5. We propose to
add a new Subpart D covering all
discretionary grants and contracts. This
new subpart would address separately
National Resource Centers and Training
and Technical Assistance Grants
(§ 1370.30), grants for State resource
centers to reduce disparities in domestic
violence in States with high proportions
of American Indian (including Alaska
Native) or Native Hawaiian population
(§ 1370.30), grants for specialized
services for abused parents and their
children (§ 1370.31), and the National
Domestic Violence Hotline (§ 1370.32).
These new sections primarily reflect
statutory requirements, the evolution of
the program and the focus of FVPSA.
These proposed provisions also focus
on the unique planning, consultation,
and coordinating activities that we
expect of each type of grantee. Finally,
these provisions provide for the use of
the Funding Opportunity
Announcements and other program
guidance to provide additional details
and procedures that apply to these
grants. We welcome comments on these
provisions.
We propose adding a new heading to
be titled ‘‘Subpart D—Discretionary
Grants and Contracts’’.
Section 1370.30 What National
Resource Centers and Training and
Technical Assistance grant programs
are available and what requirements
apply?
We propose to add § 1370.30 to
Subpart D. National Resource Centers
and Training and Technical Assistance
Center grants, pursuant to FVPSA
Section 10410, are to provide resource
information, training, and technical
assistance to improve the capacity of
individuals, organizations,
governmental entities, and communities
to prevent family violence, domestic
violence, and dating violence and to
provide effective intervention services.
They fund national, special issue, and
culturally-specific resource centers
addressing key areas of domestic
violence intervention and prevention,
and may include State resource centers
to reduce disparities in domestic
violence in States with high proportions
of Native American (including Alaska
Native or Native Hawaiian) populations
and to support training and technical
assistance that address emerging issues
related to family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence, to entities
demonstrating expertise in these areas.
Grants may be made for five specific
grants.
PO 00000
Frm 00016
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
The first is the National Resource
Center on Domestic Violence which
offers a comprehensive array of
technical assistance and training
resources to Federal, State, and local
governmental agencies, domestic
violence service providers, communitybased organizations, and other
professionals and interested parties,
related to domestic violence service
programs and research, including
programs and research related to victims
and their children who are exposed to
domestic violence as well as older
individuals and those with disabilities.
The grantee also will maintain a central
resource library in order to collect,
prepare, analyze, and disseminate
information and statistics related to the
incidence and prevention of family
violence and domestic violence; and the
provision of shelter, supportive services,
and prevention services to adult and
youth victims of domestic violence,
including older individuals and those
with disabilities (including services to
prevent repeated incidents of violence).
The second grant is for a National
Indian Resource Center Addressing
Domestic Violence and Safety for Indian
Women which offers a comprehensive
array of technical assistance and
training resources to Indian Tribes and
Tribal organizations, specifically
designed to enhance the capacity of the
Tribes and Tribal organizations to
respond to domestic violence and
increase the safety of Indian women.
The grantee also will enhance the
intervention and prevention efforts of
Indian Tribes and Tribal organizations
to respond to domestic violence and
increase the safety of Indian women,
and coordinate activities with other
Federal agencies, offices, and grantees
that address the needs of American
Indians, Alaska Natives, and Native
Hawaiians that experience domestic
violence.
The third grant is for special issue
resource centers to provide national
information, training, and technical
assistance to State and local domestic
violence service providers. Each special
issue resource center shall focus on
enhancing domestic violence
intervention and prevention efforts in at
least one of the following areas: (1)
Response of the criminal and civil
justice systems to domestic violence
victims, which may include the
response to the use of the self-defense
plea by domestic violence victims and
the issuance and use of protective
orders; (2) response of child protective
service agencies to victims of domestic
violence and their dependents and child
custody issues in domestic violence
cases; (3) response of the
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
interdisciplinary health care system to
victims of domestic violence and access
to health care resources for victims of
domestic violence; (4) response of
mental health systems, domestic
violence service programs, and other
related systems and programs to victims
of domestic violence and to their
children who are exposed to domestic
violence.
The fourth grant is for CulturallySpecific Special Issue Resource Centers
that enhance domestic violence
intervention and prevention efforts for
victims of domestic violence who are
members of racial and ethnic minority
groups; and will enhance the cultural
and linguistic relevancy of service
delivery, resource utilization, policy,
research, technical assistance,
community education, and prevention
initiatives.
The fifth grant is for State resource
centers to provide statewide
information, training, and technical
assistance to Indian Tribes, Tribal
organizations, and local domestic
violence service organizations serving
Native Americans (including Alaska
Natives and Native Hawaiians) in a
culturally sensitive and relevant
manner. These centers shall: (1) Offer a
comprehensive array of technical
assistance and training resources to
Indian Tribes, Tribal organizations, and
providers of services to Native
Americans (including Alaska Natives
and Native Hawaiians) specifically
designed to enhance the capacity of the
Tribes, organizations, and providers to
respond to domestic violence; (2)
coordinate all projects and activities
with the National Indian Resource
Center Addressing Domestic Violence
and Safety for Indian Women, including
projects and activities that involve
working with State and local
governments to enhance their capacity
to understand the unique needs of
Native Americans (including Alaska
Natives and Native Hawaiians); and (3)
provide comprehensive community
education and domestic violence
prevention initiatives in a culturally
sensitive and relevant manner.
Eligibility for the State resource center
grant program is contingent upon being
located in a State with high proportions
of Indian or Native Hawaiian
populations. Eligible entities shall be
located in a State in which the
population of Indians (including Alaska
Natives) and Native Hawaiians exceeds
10 percent of the total population of the
State; or, be an Indian Tribe, Tribal
organization or a Native Hawaiian
organization that focuses primarily on
issues of domestic violence among
Indians or Native Hawaiians; or, be an
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
institution of higher education; and,
demonstrate the ability to serve all
regions of the State, including
underdeveloped areas and areas that are
geographically distant from population
centers. Additionally, eligible entities
shall offer training and technical
assistance and capacity-building
resources in States where the
population of Indians (including Alaska
Natives) and Native Hawaiians exceeds
2.5 percent of the total population of the
State.
Under section (f), we propose that
other discretionary grants may be
awarded to support training and
technical assistance that address
emerging issues related to family
violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence, to entities demonstrating
related experience.
Under section (g) we propose that, to
receive a grant under any part of this
section, an entity shall submit an
application that shall meet such
eligibility standards as are prescribed in
the FVPSA and contains such
agreements, assurances, and
information, in such form, and
submitted in such manner as the
Funding Opportunity Announcement
and related program guidance prescribe.
Under section (h), we propose that all
grant recipients should create a plan to
ensure effective communication and
meaningful access to domestic violence
program services for victims of domestic
violence with Limited English
Proficiency (LEP), which should
include: How to respond to individuals
with LEP, and how to use appropriate
interpretation and translation services,
including best practices for using
taglines. Taglines are short statements in
non-English languages informing
persons with LEP how to access
language assistance services; how to
respond to individuals with
communication-related disabilities and
how to provide appropriate auxiliary
aids and services, including qualified
interpreters and information in alternate
formats, to people with disabilities. The
use of the term ‘‘Limited English
Proficient’’ is not meant to be
interpreted as a substitution for the
statutory language ‘‘non-English’’
speaking individuals but rather to be
consistent with HHS Office for Civil
Rights guidance applicable to all HHSfunded programs. Please see https://
www.hhs.gov/ocr/civilrights/resources/
specialtopics/lep/.
PO 00000
Frm 00017
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
61905
Section 1370.31 What additional
requirements apply to grants for
specialized services for abused parents
and their children?
We propose to add new § 1370.31 to
Subpart D. Consistent with 42 U.S.C.
10412, grants provided for specialized
services for abused parents and their
children are intended to expand the
capacity of family violence, domestic
violence, and dating violence service
programs and community-based
programs to prevent future domestic
violence by addressing, in an
appropriate manner, the needs of
children exposed to family violence,
domestic violence, or dating violence.
To be eligible an entity must be a local
agency, a nonprofit private organization
(including faith-based and charitable
organizations, community-based
organizations, and voluntary
associations), or a Tribal organization,
with a demonstrated record of serving
victims of family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence and their
children.
Consistent with 42 U.S.C. 10412(c), in
paragraph (b)(1) we propose that, in
order to be eligible to receive a grant
under this section, an entity shall
submit an application that includes a
complete description of the applicant’s
plan for providing specialized services
for abused parents and their children.
This should include descriptions of how
the entity will prioritize the safety of,
and confidentiality of information about
victims of family violence, victims of
domestic violence, and victims of dating
violence and their children. It also
should address how the entity will
provide developmentally appropriate
and age-appropriate services, and
culturally and linguistically appropriate
services, to the victims and children.
Finally, it should describe how the
entity will ensure that professionals
working with the children receive the
training and technical assistance
appropriate and relevant to the unique
needs of children exposed to family
violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence.
Consistent with 42 U.S.C. 10412(d), in
paragraph (b)(2), we propose that the
application should demonstrate that the
applicant has the ability to provide
direct counseling, appropriate services,
and advocacy on behalf of victims of
family violence, domestic violence, or
dating violence and their children,
including coordination with services
provided by the child welfare system.
In paragraph (b)(3), we propose that
the application also should demonstrate
that the applicant can effectively
provide services for non-abusing parents
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
61906
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
to support those parents’ roles as
caregivers and their roles in responding
to the social, emotional, and
developmental needs of their children.
Consistent with 42 U.S.C. 10412(d)(2),
in paragraph (c) we propose that eligible
applicants may use funds under a grant
pursuant to this section that: (1)
Demonstrates a capacity to provide early
childhood development and mental
health services; (2) shows the ability to
coordinate activities with and provide
technical assistance to communitybased organizations serving victims of
family violence, domestic violence, or
dating violence or children exposed to
family violence, domestic violence, or
dating violence; and (3) shows the
capacity to provide additional services
and referrals to services for children,
including child care, transportation,
educational support, respite care,
supervised visitation, or other necessary
services.
Finally, in paragraph (c)(4), we
propose that the application must
contain such agreements, assurances,
and information, in such form, and
submitted in such manner as the
Funding Opportunity Announcement
and related program guidance prescribe.
If Congressional appropriations in any
fiscal year for the entirety of programs
covered by this proposed rule (exclusive
of the National Domestic Violence
Hotline which receives a separate
appropriation) exceed $130 million, not
less than 25 percent of such excess
funds shall be made available to carry
out this grant program. If appropriations
reach this threshold, HHS will specify
funding levels in future Funding
Opportunity Announcements.
Section 1370.32 What additional
requirements apply to National
Domestic Violence Hotline grants?
We propose to add new § 1370.32 to
Subpart D. Consistent with 42 U.S.C.
10413, the National Domestic Hotline
grants are for one or more private
entities to provide for the ongoing
operation of a 24-hour, national, tollfree telephone hotline to provide
information and assistance to adult and
youth victims of family violence,
domestic violence, or dating violence,
family and household members of such
victims, and persons affected by the
victimization.
We propose to add a definition of
‘‘telephone’’ as used in the context of
‘‘telephone hotline’’ so that the term
appropriately reflects evolving
technological advances impacting
telephone usage and the multiple ways
in which telephone hotlines operate and
are most responsive to hotline callers or
users. According to the Pew Research
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
Internet and American Life Project
‘‘some 83% of American adults own cell
phones and three-quarters of them
(73%) send and receive text messages.
Young adults are the most avid texters
by a wide margin. Cell owners between
the ages of 18 and 24 exchange an
average of 109.5 messages on a normal
day—that works out to more than 3,200
texts per month—and the typical or
median cell owner in this age group
sends or receives 50 messages per day
(or 1500 messages per month).’’ We
therefore propose to add a definition of
‘‘telephone’’ as used in the context of
‘‘telephone hotline’’ so that the term
appropriately reflects evolving
technological advances impacting
telephone usage and the multiple ways
in which telephone hotlines operate and
are most responsive to hotline callers or
users. We propose ‘‘telephone’’ to be
defined as a communications device
that permits two or more callers or users
to engage in transmitted analog, digital,
short message service (SMS), cellular/
wireless, laser, cable/broadband,
internet, voice-over internet protocol
(IP) or other communications, including
telephone, smartphone, chat, text, voice
recognition, or other technological
means which connects callers or users
together. The traditional analog
telephone may soon become outdated
technology that does not provide
appropriate and safe services for callers
or users, nor does it reflect that users
may not be ‘‘calling’’ telephone hotlines
as traditionally understood. As a result,
current FVPSA language may prevent
grantees responsible for operating
emerging or changing technologies that
serve victims of family, domestic, and
dating violence from incorporating
cutting-edge software and hardware that
simultaneously advance with
technology trends and user interfaces.
Under proposed paragraph (c), to be
consistent with 42 U.S.C. 10413(d), we
propose that in order to be eligible to
receive a grant under this section, an
entity shall submit an application that
includes a complete description of the
applicant’s plan for the operation of a
national domestic violence hotline,
including descriptions of:
(1) The training program for hotline
personnel, including technology
training to ensure that all persons
affiliated with the hotline are able to
effectively operate any technological
systems used by the hotline, and are
familiar with effective communication
and meaningful access requirements, to
ensure access for all, including people
who are Limited English Proficient and
people with disabilities;
(2) the hiring criteria and
qualifications for hotline personnel;
PO 00000
Frm 00018
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
(3) the methods for the creation,
maintenance, and updating of a resource
database;
(4) a plan for publicizing the
availability of the hotline;
(5) a plan for providing service to
Limited English Proficient callers,
including service through hotline
personnel who are qualified to interpret
for Limited English Proficient
individuals;
(6) a plan for facilitating access to the
hotline by persons with disabilities,
including persons with hearing
impairments; and
(7) a plan for providing assistance and
referrals to youth victims of domestic
violence and for victims of dating
violence who are minors, which may be
carried out through a national teen
dating violence hotline.
The application also must
demonstrate:
(1) That the applicant has recognized
expertise in the area of family violence,
domestic violence, or dating violence
and a record of high quality service to
victims of family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence, including a
demonstration of support from advocacy
groups and State Domestic Violence
Coalitions;
(2) that the applicant has the capacity
and the expertise to maintain a domestic
violence hotline and a comprehensive
database of service providers;
(3) the applicants’ ability to provide
information and referrals for callers,
directly connect callers to service
providers, and employ crisis
interventions meeting the standards of
family violence, domestic violence, and
dating violence providers;
(4) that the applicant has a
commitment to diversity and to the
provision of services to underserved
populations, including to ethnic, racial,
and Limited English Proficient
individuals, in addition to older
individuals and individuals with
disabilities;
(5) that the applicant follows
comprehensive quality assurance
practices.
Finally, the application must contain
such agreements, information, and
assurances, including nondisclosure of
confidential or personally identifiable
information, in such form, and
submitted in such manner as the
Funding Opportunity Announcement
and related program guidance prescribe.
In accordance with 42 U.S.C. 10413(f),
under section (d) we propose that the
entity receiving a grant under this
section shall submit a performance
report to the Secretary at such time as
reasonably required by the Secretary
that shall describe the activities that
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
have been carried out with grant funds,
contain an evaluation of the
effectiveness of such activities, and
provide additional information as the
Secretary may reasonably require.
Nor does this proposed rule meet any of
the other criteria for significance under
these Executive Orders. This proposed
rule has been reviewed by the Office of
Management and Budget.
VIII. Impact Analysis
Congressional Review
Paperwork Reduction Act
This proposed rule is not a major rule
(economic effects of $100 million or
more) as defined in the Congressional
Review Act.
This proposed rule contains no new
information collection requirements.
There is an existing requirement for
grantees to provide performance
progress reports under Office of
Management and Budget approval
number 0970–0280. Grantees are also
required to submit an application and
annual financial status report. Nothing
in this proposed rule would require
changes in the current requirements, all
of which have been approved by the
Office of Management and Budget under
the provisions of the Paperwork
Reduction Act.
Regulatory Flexibility Act
The Secretary certifies under 5 U.S.C.
605(b), as enacted by the Regulatory
Flexibility Act (Pub. L. 96–354), that
this proposed rule will not result in a
significant economic impact on a
substantial number of small entities. We
have not proposed any new
requirements that would have such an
effect. Our proposed standards would
almost entirely conform to the existing
statutory requirements and existing
practices in the program. In particular,
we have proposed imposing only a few
new processes, procedural, or
documentation requirements that are
not encompassed within the existing
rule, existing Funding Opportunity
Announcements, or existing information
collection requirements. None of these
would impose consequential burdens on
grantees. Accordingly, an Initial
Regulatory Flexibility Analysis is not
required.
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Regulatory Impact Analysis
Executive Order 12866 and 13563
require that regulations be drafted to
ensure that they are consistent with the
priorities and principles set forth in
these Executive Orders, including
imposing the least burden on society,
written in plain language and easy to
understand, and seeking to improve the
actual results of regulatory
requirements. The Department has
determined that this proposed rule is
consistent with these priorities and
principles. The Executive Orders
require a Regulatory Impact Analysis for
proposed or final rules with an annual
economic impact of $100 million or
more. Nothing in this proposed rule
approaches effects of this magnitude.
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
Federalism Review
Executive Order 13132, Federalism,
requires that Federal agencies consult
with State and local government
officials in the development of
regulatory policies with Federalism
implications. This proposed rule will
not have substantial direct impact on
the States, on the relationship between
the Federal government and the States,
or on the distribution of power and
responsibilities among the various
levels of government. Therefore, in
accordance with the Executive Order we
have determined that this proposed rule
does not have sufficient Federalism
implications to warrant the preparation
of a Federalism summary impact
statement.
Family Impact Review
Section 654 of the Treasury and
General Government Appropriations
Act of 1999 (Pub. L. 105–277) requires
Federal agencies to issue a Family
Policymaking Assessment for any rule
that may affect family well-being. This
proposed rule would not have any new
or adverse impact on the autonomy or
integrity of the family as an institution.
Like the existing rule and existing
program practices, it directly supports
family well-being. Since we propose no
changes that would affect this policy
priority, we have concluded that it is
not necessary to prepare a Family
Policymaking Assessment.
List of Subjects in 45 CFR 1370
Administrative practice and
procedure, Domestic violence, Grant
Programs—Social Programs, Reporting
and recordkeeping requirements,
Technical assistance.
(Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance
Program Numbers 93.671 Family Violence
Prevention and Services/Battered Women’s
Shelters—Grants to States and Indian Tribes
and 93.591 Family Violence Prevention and
Services/Battered Women’s Shelters—Grants
to State Domestic Violence Coalitions)
PO 00000
Frm 00019
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
61907
Dated: March 24, 2015.
Mark H. Greenberg,
Acting Assistant Secretary for Children and
Families.
Approved: March 26, 2015.
Sylvia M. Burwell,
Secretary.
Editorial note: This document was
received for publication by the Office of
the Federal Register on October 5, 2015.
For the reasons set forth in the
preamble, title 45 CFR part 1370 is
proposed to be amended as follows:
PART 1370—FAMILY VIOLENCE
PREVENTION AND SERVICES
PROGRAMS
1. The authority citation for part 1370
continues to read as follows:
■ 2. Revise §§ 1370.1 through 1370.5
and add § 1370.6 under a new subpart
A to read as follows:
■
Subpart A—General Provisions
Sec.
1370.1 What are the purposes of Family
Violence Prevention and Services Act
Programs?
1370.2 What definitions apply to these
programs?
1370.3 What Government-wide and HHSwide regulations apply to these
programs?
1370.4 What confidentiality requirements
apply to these programs?
1370.5 What additional non-discrimination
requirements apply to these programs?
1370.6 What requirements for reports and
evaluations apply to these programs?
§ 1370.1 What are the purposes of the
Family Violence Prevention and Services
Act Programs?
This part addresses sections 301
through 313 of the Family Violence
Prevention and Services Act (FVPSA),
as amended, and codified at 42 U.S.C.
10401 et seq. FVPSA authorizes the
Secretary to implement programs for the
purposes of increasing public awareness
about and preventing family violence,
domestic violence, and dating violence;
providing immediate shelter and
supportive services for victims of family
violence, domestic violence, and dating
violence and their dependents;
providing for technical assistance and
training relating to family violence,
domestic violence, and dating violence
programs; providing for State Domestic
Violence Coalitions; providing
specialized services for abused parents
and their children; and operating a
national domestic violence hotline.
FVPSA emphasizes both primary, and
secondary, prevention of violence.
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
61908
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
§ 1370.2 What definitions apply to these
programs?
For the purposes of this part:
Dating violence means violence
committed by a person who is or has
been in a social relationship of a
romantic or intimate nature with the
victim and where the existence of such
a relationship shall be determined based
on a consideration of the following
factors: the length of the relationship,
the type of relationship, and the
frequency of interaction between the
persons involved in the relationship.
This definition reflects the definition
also found in Section 40002(a) of
VAWA (as amended), as required by
FVPSA. Additionally, dating violence
may include violence against older
individuals and those with disabilities
when the violence meets the applicable
definition.
Domestic violence means felony or
misdemeanor crimes of violence
committed by a current or former
spouse or intimate partner of the victim,
by a person with whom the victim
shares a child in common, by a person
who is cohabitating with or has
cohabitated with the victim as a spouse
or intimate partner, by a person
similarly situated to a spouse of the
victim under the domestic or family
violence laws of the jurisdiction
receiving grant monies, or by any other
person against an adult or youth victim
who is protected from that person’s acts
under the domestic or family violence
laws of the jurisdiction. This definition
also reflects the statutory definition of
‘‘domestic violence’’ found in Section
40002(a) of VAWA (as amended). Older
individuals and those with disabilities
who otherwise meet the criteria herein
are also included within this term’s
definition. This definition will also
include but will not be limited to acts
or acts constituting intimidation,
control, coercion and coercive control,
emotional and psychological abuse and
behavior, expressive and psychological
aggression, harassment, tormenting
behavior, disturbing or alarming
behavior, and additional acts recognized
in other Federal, State, local and tribal
laws as well as acts in other Federal
regulatory or sub-regulatory guidance.
This definition is not intended to be
interpreted more restrictively than
FVPSA and VAWA but rather to be
inclusive of other, more expansive
definitions.
Family violence means any act or
threatened act of violence, including
any forceful detention of an individual,
that results or threatens to result in
physical injury and is committed by a
person against another individual
(including an older individual), to or
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
with whom such person is related by
blood or marriage, or is or was
otherwise legally related, or is or was
lawfully residing. All FVPSA-funded
grantees and contractors are required to
serve program recipients regardless of
whether an individual may be married
to a person of the opposite or same sex.
Please note that this guidance is not a
change in previous grantee guidance as
survivors of intimate partner violence,
regardless of marital status, have always
been eligible for FVPSA-funded services
and programming.
Personally identifying information is:
(1) Individually identifying
information for or about an individual
including information likely to disclose
the location of a victim of domestic
violence, dating violence, sexual
assault, or stalking, regardless of
whether the information is encoded,
encrypted, hashed, or otherwise
protected, including:
(i) A first and last name;
(ii) A home or other physical address;
(iii) Contact information (including a
postal, email or Internet protocol
address, or telephone or facsimile
number);
(iv) A social security number, driver
license number, passport number, or
student identification number; and
(v) Any other information, including
date of birth, racial or ethnic
background, or religious affiliation, that
would serve to identify any individual.
(2) Note that information remains
personally identifying even if physically
protected through locked filing cabinets
or electronically protected through
encryption.
Primary prevention means strategies,
policies, and programs to stop both firsttime perpetration and first-time
victimization. Primary prevention is
stopping intimate partner violence
before it occurs.
Primary-purpose domestic violence
provider means a provider that operates
a project of demonstrated effectiveness
carried out by a nonprofit,
nongovernmental, private entity, Tribe
or Tribal organization that has as its
project’s primary-purpose the operation
of shelters and supportive services for
victims of domestic violence and their
dependents; or provides counseling,
advocacy, or self-help services to
victims of domestic violence. Territorial
Domestic Violence Coalitions may
include government-operated domestic
violence projects as ‘‘primary-purpose’’
providers for complying with the
membership requirement, provided that
Territorial Coalitions can document
providing training, technical assistance,
and capacity-building of communitybased and privately operated projects to
PO 00000
Frm 00020
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
provide shelter and supportive services
to victims of family, domestic, or dating
violence, with the intention of
recruiting such projects as members
once they are sustainable as primarypurpose domestic violence service
providers.
Secondary prevention means
identifying risk factors or problems that
may lead to future family violence,
domestic violence, or dating violence,
and taking the necessary actions to
eliminate the risk factors and the
potential problem.
Shelter means the provision of
temporary refuge and supportive
services in compliance with applicable
State law or regulations governing the
provision, on a regular basis, of shelter,
safe homes, meals, and supportive
services to victims of family violence,
domestic violence, or dating violence,
and their dependents. This definition
also includes emergency shelter and
immediate shelter, which may include
scattered-site housing, which is defined
as property with multiple locations
around a local jurisdiction or state.
Temporary refuge includes a residential
service, including shelter and off-site
services such as hotel or motel
vouchers, which is not transitional or
permanent housing. Should other
jurisdictional laws conflict with this
definition of temporary refuge, the
definition which provides more
expansive housing accessibility governs.
State means each of the several States,
the District of Columbia, the
Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, and,
except as otherwise provided in statute,
Guam, American Samoa, the United
States Virgin Islands, and the
Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana
Islands.
State Domestic Violence Coalition
means a statewide, non-governmental,
nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization whose
membership includes a majority of the
primary-purpose domestic violence
providers in the State; whose board
membership is representative of these
primary-purpose domestic violence
service providers and which may
include representatives of the
communities in which the services are
being provided in the State; that
provides education, support, and
technical assistance to such providers;
and that serves as an information
clearinghouse, primary point of contact,
and resource center on domestic
violence for the State and supports the
development of policies, protocols, and
procedures to enhance domestic
violence intervention and prevention in
the State.
Supportive services means services for
adult and youth victims of family
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence, and their dependents, that are
designed to meet the needs of such
victims and their dependents for shortterm, transitional, or long-term safety
and recovery. Supportive services
includes those services identified in
FVPSA Section 10408(b)(1)(G), but is
not limited to: Direct and/or referralbased advocacy on behalf of victims and
their dependents, counseling, case
management, employment services,
referrals, transportation services, legal
advocacy or assistance, childcare
services, health, behavioral health and
preventive health services, culturally
appropriate services, and other services
that assist victims or their dependents
in recovering from the effects of the
violence. Supportive services may be
directly provided by grantees and/or by
providing advocacy or referrals to assist
victims in accessing such services.
Underserved populations means
populations who face barriers in
accessing and using victim services, and
includes populations underserved
because of geographic location, religion,
sexual orientation, gender identity,
underserved racial and ethnic
populations, and populations
underserved because of special needs
including language barriers, disabilities,
immigration status, and age. Individuals
with criminal histories due to
victimization and individuals with
substance abuse and mental health
issues are also included in this
definition. This definition also includes
other population categories determined
by the Secretary or the Secretary’s
designee to be underserved.
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
§ 1370.3 What Government-wide and HHSwide regulations apply to these programs?
(a) A number of government-wide and
HHS regulations apply or potentially
apply to all grantees. These include but
are not limited to:
(1) 2 CFR part 182—Government-wide
Requirements for Drug Free Workplaces;
(2) 2 CFR part 376—Nonprocurement
Debarment and Suspension;
(3) 45 CFR part 16—Procedures of the
Departmental Grant Appeals Board;
(4) 45 CFR part 30—Claims
Collection;
(5) 45 CFR part 46—Protection of
Human Subjects;
(6) 45 CFR part 75—Uniform
Administrative Requirements, Cost
Principles and Audit Requirements for
HHS Awards;
(7) 45 CFR part 80—
Nondiscrimination Under Programs
Receiving Federal Assistance Through
the Department of Health and Human
Services Effectuation of Title VI of the
Civil Rights Act of 1964;
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
(8) 45 CFR part 81—Practice and
Procedure for Hearings under part 80;
(9) 45 CFR part 84—
Nondiscrimination on the Basis of
Handicap in Programs or Activities
Receiving Federal Financial Assistance;
(10) 45 CFR part 86—
Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Sex
in Education Programs or Activities
Receiving Federal Financial Assistance;
(11) 45 CFR part 87—Equal Treatment
for Faith-Based Organizations;
(12) 45 CFR part 91—
Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Age
in Programs or Activities Receiving
Federal Financial Assistance for HHS;
and
(13) 45 CFR part 93—New
Restrictions on Lobbying.
(b) A number of government-wide and
HHS regulations apply to all
contractors. These include but are not
limited to:
(1) 48 CFR Chapter 1—Federal
Acquisition Regulations; and
(2) 48 CFR Chapter 3—Federal
Acquisition Regulations—Department of
Health and Human Services.
§ 1370.4 What confidentiality requirements
apply to these programs?
(a) In order to ensure the safety of
adult, youth, and child victims of family
violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence, and their families, grantees
and subgrantees under this title shall
protect the confidentiality and privacy
of such victims and their families.
Subject to paragraphs (c), (d), and (e) of
this section, grantees and subgrantees
shall not—
(1) Disclose any personally
identifying information (as defined in
§ 1370.2) collected in connection with
services requested (including services
utilized or denied) through grantees’
and subgrantees’ programs; or
(2) Reveal personally identifying
information without informed, written,
reasonably time-limited consent by the
person about whom information is
sought, whether for this program or any
other Federal or State grant program.
(b) Consent shall be given by the
person, except in the case of an
unemancipated minor it shall be given
by both the minor and the minor’s
parent or guardian; or in the case of an
individual with a guardian it shall be
given by the individual’s guardian. A
parent or guardian may not give consent
if: He or she is the abuser or suspected
abuser of the minor or individual with
a guardian; or, the abuser or suspected
abuser of the other parent of the minor.
Reasonable accommodation shall also
be made to those who may be unable,
due to disability or other functional
limitation, to provide consent in
writing.
PO 00000
Frm 00021
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
61909
(c) If the release of information
described in paragraphs (a) and (b) of
this section is compelled by statutory or
court mandate:
(1) Grantees and sub-grantees shall
make reasonable attempts to provide
notice to victims affected by the release
of the information; and
(2) Grantees and sub-grantees shall
take steps necessary to protect the
privacy and safety of the persons
affected by the release of the
information.
(d) Grantees and sub-grantees may
share:
(1) Nonpersonally identifying
information, in the aggregate, regarding
services to their clients and
demographic non-personally identifying
information in order to comply with
Federal, State, or Tribal reporting,
evaluation, or data collection
requirements;
(2) Court-generated information and
law enforcement-generated information
contained in secure, governmental
registries for protective order
enforcement purposes; and
(3) Law enforcement- and
prosecution-generated information
necessary for law enforcement and
prosecution purposes.
(e) Nothing in this section prohibits a
grantee or subgrantee from reporting
abuse and neglect, as those terms are
defined by law, where mandated or
expressly permitted by the State or
Indian Tribe involved.
(f) Nothing in this section shall be
construed to supersede any provision of
any Federal, State, Tribal, or local law
that provides greater protection than
this section for victims of family
violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence.
(g) The address or location of any
shelter facility assisted that maintains a
confidential location shall, except with
written authorization of the person or
persons responsible for the operation of
such shelter, not be made public.
§ 1370.5 What additional nondiscrimination requirements apply to these
programs?
(a) No person shall on the ground of
sex or religion be excluded from
participation in, be denied the benefits
of, or be subject to discrimination
under, any program or activity funded
in whole or in part through FVPSA.
FVPSA grantees must provide
comparable services to victims
regardless of sex or gender. This
includes not only providing access to
services for male victims of family,
domestic, and dating violence, but also
making sure not to limit services for
victims with adolescent sons (up to the
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
61910
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
age of majority). Victims and their
adolescent sons must be sheltered or
housed together unless requested
otherwise or unless the factors or
considerations identified in the
paragraph directly below require an
exception to this general rule.
(b) However, no such program or
activity is required to include an
individual in such program or activity
without taking into consideration that
individual’s sex in those certain
instances where sex is a bona fide
occupational qualification or a
programmatic factor reasonably
necessary to the essential or safe
operation of that particular program or
activity. If a shelter can reasonably
separate the sexes in a manner which
allows for single sex bedrooms and
bathrooms and the essential and safe
operation of the particular program is
not substantially compromised, it is
reasonable to provide such separation. If
the essential or safe operation of the
program or activity would be
substantially compromised, alternative,
equivalent shelter and services should
be offered as practicable. Adult male
victims should be offered hotel
placements and provided supportive
services at the shelter if shelter space is
not available or if it is otherwise
determined that the operation of the
program or activity would be
substantially compromised. Victims’
adolescent male sons, as previously
discussed must be housed with the
abused parent seeking shelter or
services unless otherwise requested, or
unless there are specific, individual
factors or circumstances, that by placing
a victim in shelter with their son
substantially compromise the essential
or safe operations of the program.
(c) LGBTQ individuals must have
access to FVPSA-funded shelter and
nonresidential programs. Programmatic
accessibility for LGBTQ survivors must
be afforded to meet individual needs
like those provided to all other
survivors. For the purpose of assigning
a beneficiary to sex-segregated or sexspecific services, the recipient should
ask a transgender beneficiary which
group or services the beneficiary wishes
to join. The recipient may not, however,
ask questions about the beneficiary’s
anatomy or medical history or make
demands for identity documents. ACF
requires that a FVPSA grantee,
subgrantee, contractor, or vendor that
makes decisions about eligibility for or
placement into single-sex emergency
shelters or other facilities will place a
potential victim (or current victim/
client seeking a new assignment) in a
shelter or other appropriate placement
that corresponds to the gender with
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
which the person identifies, taking
health and safety concerns into
consideration. A victim’s/client’s or
potential victim’s/client’s own views
with respect to personal health and
safety must be given serious
consideration in making the placement.
For instance, if the potential victim/
client requests to be placed based on his
or her sex assigned at birth, ACF
requires that the provider will place the
individual in accordance with that
request, consistent with health, safety,
and privacy concerns. ACF also requires
that a provider will not make an
assignment or re-assignment based on
complaints of another person when the
sole stated basis of the complaint is a
victim/client or potential victim/client’s
non-conformance with gender
stereotypes.
(d) With respect to religion, religious
beliefs or religious practices shall not be
imposed on program recipients. Dietary
practices dictated by particular religious
beliefs may require some reasonable
accommodation in cooking or feeding
arrangements for particular clients as
practicable. Finally, human trafficking
victims may receive FVPSA-funded
services as long as victims of domestic
and intimate partner violence are
prioritized first by FVPSA grantees.
(e) State and Tribal Formula grantfunded services must be provided
without requiring documentation for
eligibility given the multiple access
barriers faced by battered immigrants.
(f) All requirements in this section
shall not be construed as affecting any
legal remedy provided under any other
provision of law. The Secretary shall
enforce the provisions of all
requirements in this section in
accordance with section 602 of the Civil
Rights Act of 1964 (42 U.S.C. 2000d–1).
Section 603 of the Civil Rights Act of
1964 (42 U.S.C. 2000d–2) shall apply
with respect to any action taken by the
Secretary to enforce this section.
(g) No condition may be imposed by
grantees or subgrantees for the receipt of
emergency shelter, unless a State
imposes a legal requirement to protect
the safety and welfare of all shelter
residents, and receipt of all supportive
services shall be voluntary. Nothing in
this requirement prohibits shelter
operators from preventing violence or
abuse or securing the safety of all shelter
residents. In the case of an apparent
conflict with State or Federal laws, caseby-case determinations will be made.
§ 1370.6 What requirements for reports
and evaluations apply to these programs?
Each entity receiving a grant or
contract under these programs shall
submit a performance report to the
PO 00000
Frm 00022
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
Secretary at such time as required by the
Secretary. Such performance report
shall describe the activities that have
been carried out, contain an evaluation
of the effectiveness of such activities,
and provide such additional
information as the Secretary may
require. American Samoa, the
Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana
Islands, Guam, and the U.S. Virgin
Islands are required to report directly to
the Division of Family Violence
Prevention and Services within FYSB
and follow all reporting requirements
applicable to States, Puerto Rico, and
the District of Columbia, unless
otherwise communicated to grantees.
These requirements supplement, and do
not replace the Territorial reporting
requirements of the ACF Office of
Community Services in its
administration of the Consolidated
Block Grants as part of the Social
Services Block Grant program.
■ 3. Add subpart B, consisting of
§ 1370.10, to read as follows:
Subpart B—State and Indian Tribal
Grants
§ 1370.10 What additional requirements
apply to State and Indian Tribal grants?
(a) These grants assist States and
Tribes to support the establishment,
maintenance, and expansion of
programs and projects to prevent
incidents of family violence, domestic
violence, and dating violence; to
provide immediate shelter, supportive
services, and access to communitybased programs for victims of family
violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence, and their dependents; and to
provide specialized services for children
exposed to family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence, underserved populations, and victims who are
members of racial and ethnic minority
populations. States must consult with
and provide for the participation of
State and Tribal Domestic Violence
Coalitions in the planning and
monitoring of the distribution and
administration of subgrant programs
and projects. Tribes should be involved
in these processes where appropriate
but this rule is not intended to encroach
upon Tribal sovereignty. States and
Tribes must involve community-based
organizations that primarily serve
culturally specific, underserved
communities and to determine how
such organizations can assist the States
and Tribes in serving the unmet needs
of the underserved community. States
also must consult with and provide for
the participation of State and Tribal
Domestic Violence Coalitions in State
planning and coordinate such planning
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
with needs assessments to identify
service gaps or problems and develop
appropriate responsive plans and
programs. Similar processes for Tribes
and Coalitions that support
coordination and collaboration are
expected when feasible and appropriate
with deference to Tribal sovereignty as
previously indicated.
(b) A State application must be
submitted by the Chief Executive of the
State and signed by the Chief Executive
Officer or the Chief Program Official
designated as responsible for the
administration of FVPSA. Each
application must contain the following
information or documentation:
(1) The name of the State agency, the
name and contact information for the
Chief Program Official designated as
responsible for the administration of
funds under FVPSA and coordination of
related programs within the State, and
the name and contact information for a
contact person if different from the
Chief Program Official.
(2) A plan describing in detail how
the needs of underserved populations
will be met, including:
(i) Identification of which populations
in the State are underserved, a
description of those that are being
targeted for outreach and services, and
a brief explanation of why those
populations were selected to receive
outreach and services, including how
often the State revisits the identification
and selection of the populations to be
served with FVPSA funding. States
must review their State demographics at
least every three years or explain why
this process in unnecessary;
(ii) A description of the outreach plan,
including the domestic violence training
to be provided, the means for providing
technical assistance and support, and
the leadership role played by those
representing and serving the
underserved populations in question;
(iii) A description of the specific
services to be provided or enhanced,
such as new shelters or services,
improved access to shelters or services,
or new services for underserved
populations such as victims from
communities of color, immigrant
victims, victims with disabilities, or
older individuals; and
(iv) A description of the public
information component of the State’s
outreach program, including the
elements of the program that are used to
explain domestic violence, the most
effective and safe ways to seek help, and
tools to identify available resources.
(3) A description of the process and
procedures used to involve the State
Domestic Violence Coalition,
knowledgeable individuals, and
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
interested organizations, including
those serving or representing
underserved communities in the State
planning process.
(4) Documentation of planning,
consultation with and participation of
the State Domestic Violence Coalition in
the administration and distribution of
FVPSA programs, projects, and grant
funds awarded to the State.
(5) A description of the procedures
used to assure an equitable distribution
of grants and grant funds within the
State and between urban and rural
areas, as defined by the Census Bureau,
within the State. The plan should
describe how funding processes and
allocations will address the needs of the
underserved, racial and ethnic
minorities including Tribal populations,
and people with disabilities and their
families, with an emphasis on funding
organizations that can meet unique
needs including culturally relevant and
linguistically appropriate services.
Other Federal, State, local, and private
funds may be considered in determining
compliance.
(6) A description of how the State
plans to use the grant funds including
a State plan developed in consultation
with State and Tribal Domestic Violence
Coalitions and representatives of
underserved and culturally specific
communities; a description of the target
populations; of the number of shelters to
be funded; of the number of nonresidential programs to be funded; of the
services the State will provide; and of
the expected results from the use of the
grant funds. To fulfill these
requirements, it is critically important
that States work with Coalitions and
Tribes to solicit their feedback on
program effectiveness which may
include recommendations such as
establishing program standards and
participating in program monitoring.
(7) A copy of the law or procedures,
such as a process for obtaining an order
of protection that the State has
implemented for the eviction of an
abusive spouse or other intimate,
domestic, or dating partner from a
shared household or residence. This
requirement includes family violence,
domestic violence, and dating violence.
(8) An assurance that not less than 70
percent of the funds distributed by a
State to sub-recipients shall be
distributed to entities for the primary
purpose of providing immediate shelter
and supportive services to adult and
youth victims of family violence,
domestic violence, or dating violence,
and their dependents, and that not less
than 25 percent of the funds distributed
by a State to sub-recipients shall be
distributed to entities for the purpose of
PO 00000
Frm 00023
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
61911
providing supportive services and
prevention services (these percentages
may overlap with respect to supportive
services but are not included in the 5
percent cap applicable to State
administrative costs). No grant shall be
made under this section to an entity
other than a State unless the entity
agrees that, with respect to the costs to
be incurred by the entity in carrying out
the program or project for which the
grant is awarded, the entity will make
available (directly or through donations
from public or private entities) nonFederal contributions in an amount that
is not less than $1 for every $5 of
Federal funds provided under the grant.
The non-Federal contributions required
under this paragraph may be in cash or
in kind.
(9) Documentation of policies,
procedures and protocols that ensure
individual identifiers of client records
will not be used when providing
statistical data on program activities and
program services or in the course of
grant monitoring, that the
confidentiality of records pertaining to
any individual provided family violence
prevention or intervention services by
any program or entity supported under
the FVPSA will be strictly maintained,
and the address or location of any
shelter supported under the FVPSA will
not be made public without the written
authorization of the person or persons
responsible for the operation of such
shelter; and
(10) Such additional agreements,
assurances, and information, in such
form, and submitted in such manner as
the Funding Opportunity
Announcement and related program
guidance prescribe.
(c) An application from a Tribe or
Tribal Organization must be submitted
by the Chief Executive Officer or Tribal
Chairperson of the applicant
organization. Each application must
contain the following information or
documentation:
(1) A copy of a current Tribal
resolution or an equivalent document
that verifies Tribal approval of the
application being submitted. The
resolution or other document should
state that the designated organization or
agency has the authority to submit an
application on behalf of the individuals
in the Tribe(s) and to administer
programs and activities funded pursuant
to the FVPSA. The resolution or
equivalent document must specify the
name(s) of the Tribe(s) represented and
the service area for the intended grant
services. If Tribal resolutions are the
vehicles to support applications from
Tribal Consortia or other joint Tribal
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
61912
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
applications, a representative from each
Tribe must sign the application.
(2) A description of the procedures
designed to involve knowledgeable
individuals and interested organizations
in providing services under the FVPSA.
For example, knowledgeable
individuals and interested organizations
may include Tribal officials or social
services staff involved in child abuse or
family violence prevention, Tribal law
enforcement officials, representatives of
Tribal or State Domestic Violence
Coalitions, and operators of domestic
violence shelters and service programs.
(3) A description of the applicant’s
operation of and/or capacity to carry out
a family violence prevention and
services program. This might be
demonstrated in ways such as:
(i) The current operation of a shelter,
safe house, or domestic violence
prevention program;
(ii) The establishment of joint or
collaborative service agreements with a
local public agency or a private, nonprofit agency for the operation of family
violence prevention and intervention
activities or services; or
(iii) The operation of social services
programs as evidenced by receipt of
grants or contracts awarded under
Indian Child Welfare grants from the
Bureau of Indian Affairs; Child Welfare
Services grants under Title IV–B of the
Social Security Act; or Family
Preservation and Family Support grants
under Title IV–B of the Social Security
Act.
(4) A description of the services to be
provided, how the applicant
organization plans to use the grant
funds to provide the direct services, to
whom the services will be provided,
and the expected results of the services.
(5) Documentation of the law or
procedure which has been implemented
for the eviction of an abusing spouse or
other intimate, domestic, or dating
partner from a shared household or
residence.
(6) Documentation of the policies and
procedures developed and
implemented, including copies of the
policies and procedures, to ensure that
individual identifiers of client records
will not be used when providing
statistical data on program activities and
program services or in the course of
grant monitoring and that the
confidentiality of records pertaining to
any individual provided domestic
violence prevention or intervention
services by any FVPSA-supported
program will be strictly maintained.
(7) Such agreements, assurances, and
information, in such form, and
submitted in such manner as the
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
Funding Opportunity Announcement
and related program guidance prescribe.
■ 4. Add subpart C, consisting of
§ 1370.20, to read as follows:
Subpart C—State Domestic Violence
Coalition Grants
§ 1370.20 What additional requirements
apply to State Domestic Violence
Coalitions?
(a) State Domestic Violence Coalitions
reflect a Federal commitment to
reducing domestic violence; to urge
States, localities, cities, and the private
sector to become involved in State and
local planning towards an integrated
service delivery approach that meets the
needs of all victims, including those in
underserved communities; to provide
for technical assistance and training
relating to domestic violence programs;
and to increase public awareness about
and prevention of domestic violence
and increase the quality and availability
of shelter and supportive services for
victims of domestic violence and their
dependents.
(b) To be eligible to receive a grant
under this section, an organization shall
be a statewide, non-governmental, nonprofit 501(c)(3) domestic violence
Coalition, designated as such by the
Department. To obtain this designation
the organization must meet the
following criteria:
(1) The membership must include
representatives from a majority of the
primary-purpose programs for victims of
domestic violence operating within the
State (a Coalition also may include
representatives of Indian Tribes and
Tribal organizations as defined in the
Indian Self-Determination and
Education Assistance Act);
(2) The Board membership of the
Coalition must be representative, though
not exclusively composed, of such
programs, and may include
representatives of communities in
which the services are being provided in
the State;
(3) Financial sustainability of
Coalitions, as independent, autonomous
non-profit organizations, also must be
supported by their membership,
including those member representatives
on the Coalitions’ Boards of Directors;
(4) The purpose of the Coalition must
be to provide services, community
education, and technical assistance to
domestic violence programs in order to
establish and maintain shelter and
supportive services for victims of
domestic violence and their children.
(c) To apply for a grant under this
section, an organization shall submit an
annual application that:
(1) Includes a complete description of
the applicant’s plan for the operation of
PO 00000
Frm 00024
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
a State Domestic Violence Coalition,
including documentation that the
Coalition’s work will demonstrate the
ability to conduct appropriately all
activities described in this section.
Demonstrated ability or capacity may
include but is not limited to: Identifying
successful efforts that support child
welfare agencies’ identification and
support of victims during intake
processes; creation of membership
standards that enhance victim safety
and fully require training and technical
assistance for compliance with federal
housing, disability, and sex
discrimination laws and regulations;
and, training judicial personnel on
trauma-informed courtroom practice.
Coalitions must also have documented
experience in administering Federal
grants to conduct the activities of a
Coalition or a documented history of
active participation in:
(i) Working with local family
violence, domestic violence, and dating
violence service programs and providers
of direct services to encourage
appropriate and comprehensive
responses to family violence, domestic
violence, and dating violence against
adults or youth within the State
involved, including providing training
and technical assistance and conducting
State needs assessments and participate
in planning and monitoring of the
distribution of subgrants within the
States and in the administration of grant
programs and projects;
(ii) In conducting needs assessments,
Coalitions and States must work in
partnership on the statutorily required
FVPSA State planning process to
involve representatives from
underserved and racial and ethnic
minority populations to plan, assess and
voice the needs of the communities they
represent. Coalitions will assist States in
identifying underrepresented
communities and culturally-specific
community based organizations in State
planning and to work with States to
unify planning and needs assessment
efforts so that comprehensive and
culturally-specific services are
provided. The inclusion of the
populations targeted will emphasize
building the capacity of culturallyspecific services and programs.
(iii) Working in collaboration with
service providers and community-based
organizations to address the needs of
family violence, domestic violence, and
dating violence victims, and their
dependents, who are members of racial
and ethnic minority populations and
underserved populations;
(iv) Collaborating with and providing
information to entities in such fields as
housing, health care, mental health,
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
social welfare, or business to support
the development and implementation of
effective policies, protocols, and
programs that address the safety and
support needs of adult and youth
victims of family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence;
(v) Encouraging appropriate responses
to cases of family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence against
adults or youth, including by working
with judicial and law enforcement
agencies;
(vi) Working with family law judges,
criminal court judges, child protective
service agencies, and children’s
advocates to develop appropriate
responses to child custody and
visitation issues in cases of child
exposure to family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence and in cases
in which family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence is present
and child abuse is present;
(vii) Working with protection and
advocacy systems, and aging and
disability systems to develop
appropriate responses for older
individuals and individuals with
disabilities;
(viii) Providing information to the
public about prevention of family
violence, domestic violence, and dating
violence, including information targeted
to underserved populations; and
(ix) Collaborating with Indian Tribes
and Tribal organizations (and
corresponding Native Hawaiian groups
or communities) to address the needs of
Indian (including Alaska Native) and
Native Hawaiian victims of family
violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence, as applicable in the State;
(2) Contains such agreements,
assurances, and information, in such
form, and submitted in such manner as
the Funding Opportunity
Announcement and related program
guidance prescribe.
(d) Nothing in this section limits the
ability of a Coalition to use non-Federal
or other Federal funding sources to
conduct required functions, provided
that if the Coalition uses funds received
under section 2001(c)(1) of the Omnibus
Crime Control and Safe Streets Act of
1968 to perform the functions described
in FVPSA section 311(e) in lieu of funds
provided under the FVPSA, it shall
provide an annual assurance to the
Secretary that it is using such funds,
and that it is coordinating the activities
conducted under this section with those
of the State’s activities under Part T of
title I of the Omnibus Crime Control and
Safe Streets Act of 1968.
(e) In cases in which two or more
organizations seek designation, the
designation of each State’s individual
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
Coalition is within the exclusive
discretion of HHS. HHS will determine
which applicant best fits statutory
criteria, with particular attention paid to
the applicant’s documented history of
effective work, support of primarypurpose programs and programs that
serve racial and ethnic minority
populations and underserved
populations, coordination and
collaboration with the State
government, and capacity to accomplish
the FVPSA mandated role of a Coalition.
(f) Regarding FVPSA funding, in cases
where a Coalition financially or
otherwise dissolves, the designation of a
new Coalition is within the exclusive
discretion of HHS. HHS will work with
domestic violence service providers,
community stakeholders, State leaders,
and representatives of underserved and
culturally specific communities to
identify an existing organization that
can serve as the Coalition or to develop
a new organization. The new Coalition
must reapply for designation and
funding following steps determined by
the Secretary. HHS will determine
whether the applicant fits the statutory
criteria, with particular attention paid to
the applicant’s documented history of
effective work, support of primarypurpose programs and programs that
serve racial and ethnic minority
populations and undeserved
communities, coordination and
collaboration with the State
government, and capacity to accomplish
the FVPSA mandated role of a Coalition.
■ 5. Add Subpart D to read as follows:
Subpart D—Discretionary Grants and
Contracts
Sec.
1370.30 What National Resource Centers
and Training and Technical Assistance
grant programs are available and what
requirements apply?
1370.31 What additional requirements
apply to specialized services for abused
parents and their children?
1370.32 What additional requirements
apply to National Domestic Violence
Hotline grants?
§ 1370.30 What National Resource Center
and Training and Technical Assistance
grant programs are available and what
additional requirements apply?
(a) These grants are to provide
resource information, training, and
technical assistance to improve the
capacity of individuals, organizations,
governmental entities, and communities
to prevent family violence, domestic
violence, and dating violence and to
provide effective intervention services.
They fund national, special issue, and
culturally-specific resource centers
addressing key areas of domestic
PO 00000
Frm 00025
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
61913
violence intervention and prevention,
and may include State resource centers
to reduce disparities in domestic
violence in States with high proportions
of Native American (including Alaska
Native or Native Hawaiian) populations
and to support training and technical
assistance that address emerging issues
related to family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence, to entities
demonstrating expertise in these areas.
Grants may be made for:
(1) A National Resource Center on
Domestic Violence which will conduct
the following activities:
(i) Offer a comprehensive array of
technical assistance and training
resources to Federal, State, and local
governmental agencies, domestic
violence service providers, communitybased organizations, and other
professionals and interested parties,
related to domestic violence service
programs and research, including
programs and research related to victims
and their children who are exposed to
domestic violence as well as older
individuals and those with disabilities;
and
(ii) Maintain a central resource library
in order to collect, prepare, analyze, and
disseminate information and statistics
related to the incidence and prevention
of family violence and domestic
violence; and the provision of shelter,
supportive services, and prevention
services to adult and youth victims of
domestic violence (including services to
prevent repeated incidents of violence).
(2) A National Indian Resource Center
Addressing Domestic Violence and
Safety for Indian Women which will
conduct the following activities:
(i) Offer a comprehensive array of
technical assistance and training
resources to Indian Tribes and Tribal
organizations, specifically designed to
enhance the capacity of the Tribes and
Tribal organizations to respond to
domestic violence and increase the
safety of Indian women; and
(ii) Enhance the intervention and
prevention efforts of Indian Tribes and
Tribal organizations to respond to
domestic violence and increase the
safety of Indian women, and
(iii) To coordinate activities with
other Federal agencies, offices, and
grantees that address the needs of
American Indians, Alaska Natives, and
Native Hawaiians that experience
domestic violence.
(3) Special issue resource centers to
provide national information, training,
and technical assistance to State and
local domestic violence service
providers. Each special issue resource
center shall focus on enhancing
domestic violence intervention and
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
61914
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
prevention efforts in at least one of the
following areas:
(i) Response of the criminal and civil
justice systems to domestic violence
victims, which may include the
response to the use of the self-defense
plea by domestic violence victims and
the issuance and use of protective
orders;
(ii) Response of child protective
service agencies to victims of domestic
violence and their dependents and child
custody issues in domestic violence
cases;
(iii) Response of the interdisciplinary
health care system to victims of
domestic violence and access to health
care resources for victims of domestic
violence;
(iv) Response of mental health
systems, domestic violence service
programs, and other related systems and
programs to victims of domestic
violence and to their children who are
exposed to domestic violence.
(4) Culturally-Specific Special Issue
Resource Centers enhance domestic
violence intervention and prevention
efforts for victims of domestic violence
who are members of racial and ethnic
minority groups, to enhance the cultural
and linguistic relevancy of service
delivery, resource utilization, policy,
research, technical assistance,
community education, and prevention
initiatives.
(5) State resource centers to provide
statewide information, training, and
technical assistance to Indian Tribes,
Tribal organizations, and local domestic
violence service organizations serving
Native Americans (including Alaska
Natives and Native Hawaiians) in a
culturally sensitive and relevant
manner. These centers shall:
(i) Offer a comprehensive array of
technical assistance and training
resources to Indian Tribes, Tribal
organizations, and providers of services
to Native Americans (including Alaska
Natives and Native Hawaiians)
specifically designed to enhance the
capacity of the Tribes, organizations,
and providers to respond to domestic
violence;
(ii) Coordinate all projects and
activities with the National Indian
Resource Center Addressing Domestic
Violence and Safety for Indian Women,
including projects and activities that
involve working with State and local
governments to enhance their capacity
to understand the unique needs of
Native Americans (including Alaska
Natives and Native Hawaiians); and
(iii) Provide comprehensive
community education and domestic
violence prevention initiatives in a
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
culturally sensitive and relevant
manner.
(iv) Be located in a State with high
proportions of Indian or Native
Hawaiian populations. Eligible entities
shall be located in a State in which the
population of Indians (including Alaska
Natives) and Native Hawaiians exceeds
10 percent of the total population of the
State; or, be an Indian tribe, Tribal
organization or a Native Hawaiian
organization that focuses primarily on
issues of domestic violence among
Indians or Native Hawaiians; or, be an
institution of higher education; and,
demonstrate the ability to serve all
regions of the State, including
underdeveloped areas and areas that are
geographically distant from population
centers. Additionally, eligible entities
shall offer training and technical
assistance and capacity-building
resources in States where the
population of Indians (including Alaska
Natives) and Native Hawaiians exceeds
2.5 percent of the total population of the
State.
(6) Other discretionary purposes to
support training and technical
assistance that address emerging issues
related to family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence, to entities
demonstrating related experience.
(b) To receive a grant under any part
of this section, an entity shall submit an
application that shall meet such
eligibility standards as are prescribed in
the FVPSA and contains such
agreements, assurances, and
information, in such form, and
submitted in such manner as the
Funding Opportunity Announcement
and related program guidance prescribe.
(c) Grant recipients are required to
comply with Title VI of the Civil Rights
Act of 1964 and Section 504 of the
Rehabilitation Act of 1973. To effectuate
such compliance, grant recipients
should create a plan to ensure effective
communication and meaningful access,
including:
(1) How to respond to individuals
with Limited English Proficiency, and
how to use appropriate interpretation
and translation services, including best
practices for using taglines. Taglines are
short statements in non-English
languages informing persons who are
Limited English Proficient on how to
access language assistance services.
(2) How to respond to individuals
with communication-related disabilities
and how to provide appropriate
auxiliary aids and services, including
qualified interpreters and information in
alternate formats, to people with
disabilities.
PO 00000
Frm 00026
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
§ 1370.31 What additional requirements
apply to grants for specialized services for
abused parents and their children?
(a) These grants serve to expand the
capacity of family violence, domestic
violence, and dating violence service
programs and community-based
programs to prevent future domestic
violence by addressing, in an
appropriate manner, the needs of
children exposed to family violence,
domestic violence, or dating violence.
To be eligible an entity must be a local
agency, a nonprofit private organization
(including faith-based and charitable
organizations, community-based
organizations, and voluntary
associations), or a Tribal organization,
with a demonstrated record of serving
victims of family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence and their
children.
(b) To be eligible to receive a grant
under this section, an entity shall
submit an application that:
(1) Includes a complete description of
the applicant’s plan for providing
specialized services for abused parents
and their children, including
descriptions of:
(i) How the entity will prioritize the
safety of, and confidentiality of
information about victims of family
violence, victims of domestic violence,
and victims of dating violence and their
children;
(ii) How the entity will provide
developmentally appropriate and ageappropriate services, and culturally and
linguistically appropriate services, to
the victims and children; and
(iii) How the entity will ensure that
professionals working with the children
receive the training and technical
assistance appropriate and relevant to
the unique needs of children exposed to
family violence, domestic violence, or
dating violence.
(2) Demonstrates that the applicant
has the ability to provide direct
counseling, appropriate service, and
advocacy on behalf of victims of family
violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence and their children, including
coordination with services provided by
the child welfare system;
(3) Demonstrates that the applicant
can effectively provide services for
nonabusing parents to support those
parents’ roles as caregivers and their
roles in responding to the social,
emotional, and developmental needs of
their children;
(c) Eligible applicants may use funds
under a grant pursuant to this section
that:
(1) Demonstrates a capacity to provide
early childhood development and
mental health services;
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
Federal Register / Vol. 80, No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 / Proposed Rules
(2) Shows the ability to coordinate
activities with and provide technical
assistance to community-based
organizations serving victims of family
violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence or children exposed to family
violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence; and
(3) Shows the capacity to provide
additional services and referrals to
services for children, including child
care, transportation, educational
support, respite care, supervised
visitation, or other necessary services;
and
(4) Contains such agreements,
assurances, and information, in such
form, and submitted in such manner as
the Funding Opportunity
Announcement and related program
guidance prescribe.
(d) If Congressional appropriations in
any fiscal year for the entirety of
programs covered in this part (exclusive
of the National Domestic Violence
Hotline which receives a separate
appropriation) exceed $130 million, not
less than 25 percent of such excess
funds shall be made available to carry
out this grant program. If appropriations
reach this threshold, HHS will specify
funding levels in future Funding
Opportunity Announcements.
§ 1370.32 What additional requirements
apply to National Domestic Violence Hotline
grants?
tkelley on DSK3SPTVN1PROD with PROPOSALS2
(a) These grants are for one or more
private entities to provide for the
ongoing operation of a 24-hour,
national, toll-free telephone hotline to
provide information and assistance to
adult and youth victims of family
violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence, family and household
members of such victims, and persons
affected by the victimization.
(b) Telephone is defined as a
communications device that permits
two or more callers or users to engage
in transmitted analog, digital, short
VerDate Sep<11>2014
21:37 Oct 10, 2015
Jkt 238001
message service (SMS), cellular/
wireless, laser, cable/broadband,
internet, voice-over internet protocol
(IP) or other communications, including
telephone, smartphone, chat, text, voice
recognition, or other technological
means which connects callers or users
together.
(c) To be eligible to receive a grant
under this section, an entity shall
submit an application that:
(1) Includes a complete description of
the applicant’s plan for the operation of
a national domestic violence telephone
hotline, including descriptions of:
(i) The training program for hotline
personnel, including technology
training to ensure that all persons
affiliated with the hotline are able to
effectively operate any technological
systems used by the hotline, and are
familiar with effective communication
and meaningful access requirements, to
ensure access for all, including people
who are Limited English Proficient and
people with disabilities;
(ii) The hiring criteria and
qualifications for hotline personnel;
(iii) The methods for the creation,
maintenance, and updating of a resource
database;
(iv) A plan for publicizing the
availability of the hotline;
(v) A plan for providing service to
Limited English Proficient callers,
including service through hotline
personnel who are qualified to interpret
in non-English languages;
(vi) A plan for facilitating access to
the hotline by persons with disabilities,
including persons with hearing
impairments; and
(vii) A plan for providing assistance
and referrals to youth victims of
domestic violence and for victims of
dating violence who are minors, which
may be carried out through a national
teen dating violence hotline.
(2) Demonstrates that the applicant
has recognized expertise in the area of
PO 00000
Frm 00027
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 9990
61915
family violence, domestic violence, or
dating violence and a record of high
quality service to victims of family
violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence, including a demonstration of
support from advocacy groups and State
Domestic Violence Coalitions;
(3) Demonstrates that the applicant
has the capacity and the expertise to
maintain a domestic violence hotline
and a comprehensive database of service
providers;
(4) Demonstrates the ability to provide
information and referrals for callers,
directly connect callers to service
providers, and employ crisis
interventions meeting the standards of
family violence, domestic violence, and
dating violence providers;
(5) Demonstrates that the applicant
has a commitment to diversity and to
the provision of services to underserved
populations, including to ethnic, racial,
and Limited English Proficient
individuals, in addition to older
individuals and individuals with
disabilities;
(6) Demonstrates that the applicant
follows comprehensive quality
assurance practices; and
(7) Contains such agreements,
information, and assurances, including
nondisclosure of confidential or private
information, in such form, and
submitted in such manner as the
Funding Opportunity Announcement
and related program guidance prescribe.
(d) The entity receiving a grant under
this section shall submit a performance
report to the Secretary at such time as
reasonably required by the Secretary
that shall describe the activities that
have been carried out with grant funds,
contain an evaluation of the
effectiveness of such activities, and
provide additional information as the
Secretary may reasonably require.
[FR Doc. 2015–25726 Filed 10–9–15; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4184–01–P
E:\FR\FM\14OCP2.SGM
14OCP2
Agencies
[Federal Register Volume 80, Number 198 (Wednesday, October 14, 2015)]
[Proposed Rules]
[Pages 61889-61915]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2015-25726]
[[Page 61889]]
Vol. 80
Wednesday,
No. 198
October 14, 2015
Part II
Department of Health and Human Services
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Administration for Children and Families
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
45 CFR Part 1370
Family Violence Prevention and Services Programs; Proposed Rule
Federal Register / Vol. 80 , No. 198 / Wednesday, October 14, 2015 /
Proposed Rules
[[Page 61890]]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES
Administration for Children and Families
45 CFR Part 1370
RIN 0970-AC62
Family Violence Prevention and Services Programs
AGENCY: Family and Youth Services Bureau (FYSB), Administration on
Children, Youth and Families (ACYF), Administration for Children and
Families (ACF), Department of Health and Human Services (HHS).
ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: The Administration for Children and Families proposes to
revise regulations applying to the Family Violence Prevention and
Services Programs. These proposed revisions would update existing rules
to reflect statutory changes, would update procedures for soliciting
and awarding grants, and would make other changes to increase clarity
and reduce potential confusion over statutory and regulatory standards.
The proposed revisions would codify standards already used by the
program in the Funding Opportunity Announcements and awards, in
technical assistance, in reporting requirements, and in sub-regulatory
guidance.
DATES: In order to be considered, comments on this proposed rule must
be received on or before December 14, 2015. Current Family Violence
Prevention and Services regulations remain in effect until this NPRM
becomes final.
ADDRESSES: You may submit comments, identified by [docket number and
using/or RIN number], by any of the following methods: (1)
Electronically via the Federal eRulemaking Portal at https://www.regulations.gov or (2) by mail to the Associate Commissioner,
Family and Youth Services Bureau, Administration for Children and
Families, 1250 Maryland Ave. SW., Washington, DC 20024.
Instructions: All submissions received must include the agency name
and docket number or Regulatory Information Number (RIN) for this
rulemaking. All comments received will be posted without change to
www.regulations.gov, including any personal information provided. For
detailed instructions on submitting comments and additional information
on the rulemaking process, see the ``Public Participation'' heading of
the SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION section of this document.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Kenneth E. Noyes, J.D., Senior Program
Specialist, (202) 205-7891, kenneth.noyes@acf.hhs.gov. Deaf and hearing
impaired individuals may call the Federal Dual Party Relay Service at
1-800-977-8339 between 8:30 a.m. and 7 p.m. Eastern time.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Statutory Authority
This proposed regulation is published under the authority granted
to the Secretary of Health and Human Services by the Family Violence
Prevention and Services Act (FVPSA), 42 U.S.C. 10404(a)(4), as most
recently amended by the Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment (CAPTA)
Reauthorization Act of 2010 (Public Law (Pub. L.) 111-320).
II. Public Participation
Pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act, the Department allows
a period of time for members of the public to comment on proposed
rules. In this case we will allow 60 days for comments. In making any
modifications to this notice of proposed rulemaking, we are not
required to consider comments received beyond the 60-day comment
period. To make sure your comments are addressed fully, we suggest the
following:
Be specific;
Address only issues raised by the proposed rule, not the
provisions of the law itself;
Explain reasons for any objections or recommended changes;
Propose appropriate alternatives; and
Reference the specific section of the notice of the
proposed rulemaking being addressed.
III. Organization of the NPRM
The preamble to this proposed rule is organized as follows:
Background;
Consultation and the development of the NPRM;
Scope of the proposed rule; and
Section-by-section discussion of the regulatory
provisions.
The use of the word(s) ``propose'' or ``we propose'' throughout the
NPRM is meant to remind readers that this document is proposed as
revised regulatory guidance. The language used should not be construed
to mean that statutory definitions and provisions are being changed but
rather more fully explained and clarified within the context of the
programming and services laid out in the statute, and to ensure
consistency with definitions used by other HHS components.
The section-by-section analysis is organized to follow the
framework of 45 CFR part 1370. It proposes revisions or additions to
the current rule in the following areas:
Stated purposes of the program;
significant terms used in the program;
other Federal requirements;
requirements that apply to all family violence prevention
and services grants;
eligibility for grants;
application procedures; and
other issues that may arise in the administration of the
FVPSA program.
In addition to program-wide standards, specific standards are
proposed for each of the major grant programs authorized under the
Family Violence Prevention and Services Act.
IV. Background
As the President proclaimed during the 2014 National Domestic
Violence Awareness Month, ``Domestic violence affects every American.
It harms our communities, weakens the foundation of our Nation, and
hurts those we love most . . . we acknowledge the progress made in
reducing these shameful crimes, embrace the basic human right to be
free from violence and abuse, and recognize that more work remains
until every individual is able to live free from fear.''\1\ Programs
and services funded by the Family Violence Prevention and Services Act
(``FVPSA'') are critical pieces in the Administration's fight to end
domestic violence.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ https://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2014/09/30/presidential-proclamation-national-domestic-violence-awareness-month-201.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
FVPSA authorizes three formula grant programs and other
discretionary grant programs administered by the Family and Youth
Services Bureau (FYSB), Administration on Children, Youth and Families
(ACFY), Administration for Children and Families (ACF), in the
Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). These programs comprise
the primary Federal funding stream dedicated to the support of
emergency shelter and supportive services for victims of family
violence, domestic violence, or dating violence, and their dependents.
The FVPSA also authorizes additional activities conducted through
grants, including but not limited to grants for research, evaluation,
and service projects; grants for a national domestic violence hotline,
including evaluation; grants for specialized services to abused parents
and their children; grants for State
[[Page 61891]]
resource centers to reduce disparities in domestic violence in States
with high proportions of Indian (including Alaska Native) or Native
Hawaiian populations; and, grants for national and special issue
resource centers and technical assistance and training relating to
family violence, domestic violence, and dating violence. The Formula
Grants to States Program (hereafter referred to as the State Grant
Program) awards grants to States, the Grants for Indian Tribes Program
(hereafter referred to as the Tribal Grant Program) awards grants to
Tribes or Tribal organizations and Alaska Native Villages, and the
Grants to State Domestic Violence Coalitions Program (hereafter
referred to as Coalitions Grant Program) awards grants to statewide,
nongovernmental, nonprofit 501(c)(3), private, domestic violence
organizations. The proposed rule covers all of these activities.
The National and Special Issue Resource Centers and Training and
Technical Assistance Centers' Programs (hereafter referred to as
Resource Centers, Special Issue Resource Centers and Culturally-
Specific Special Issue Resource Centers) provide resource information,
training, and technical assistance to improve the capacity of
individuals, organizations, governmental entities, and communities to
prevent family violence, domestic violence, and dating violence and to
provide effective intervention services.
The CAPTA Reauthorization Act of 2010 reauthorized and made a
number of changes to the FVPSA (see also 42 U.S.C. 10401 et seq.).
These changes include:
(1) Expanded purpose areas to include family violence, domestic
violence and dating violence (42. U.S.C. 10401(b));
(2) an expanded definitions section to clarify statutory language
(42 U.S.C. 10402);
(3) expanded authority of the Secretary to promulgate regulations
and guidance as necessary and updated the Secretary's authority to
coordinate programs across the Department and with other Federal
agencies, provide for and coordinate research and evaluation, and
develop effective policies to address the needs of adult and youth
victims of family violence, domestic violence and dating violence (42
U.S.C. 10404(a) and (b));
(4) a new State Formula grant requirement to provide specialized
services for children exposed to family violence, domestic violence, or
dating violence, underserved populations, and victims who are members
of racial and ethnic minority populations (42 U.S.C. 10406(a)(3));
(5) nondisclosure of confidential or private information provisions
that are consistent with the provisions of the Violence Against Women
Act (VAWA) (42 U.S.C. 10406(c)(5));
(6) requirement that a Tribally designated official be named in
Tribal applications for administration of grant programs (42 U.S.C.
10407(a)(1));
(7) clarification that administrative costs are limited to no more
than 5% of State formula grants (42 U.S.C. 10407(a)(2)(B)(i));
(8) additional requirements to strengthen the consultation between
States and State Domestic Violence Coalitions (42 U.S.C.
10407(a)(2)(D));
(9) changes to statutory language in the State grants and sub-
grants section that requires funds to be used for providing immediate
shelter and supportive services for adult and youth victims of family
violence, domestic violence, or dating violence (and their dependents),
and that may provide prevention services (42 U.S.C. 10408(a) and (b));
(10) expanded eligibility of the types of nonprofit private
organizations that may receive State sub-grants to include community-
based organizations and Tribal organizations, in addition to faith-
based and charitable organizations, and voluntary associations (42
U.S.C. 10408(c)(1));
(11) a new provision that expands entities eligible for State
formula sub-grantee funding to include partnerships of two or more
agencies or organizations that have a documented history of effective
work concerning family violence, domestic violence, or dating violence
and an agency or organization that has a demonstrated history of
serving populations in their communities, including providing
culturally appropriate services (42 U.S.C. 10408(c)(2);
(12) clarification that the receipt of supportive services must be
accepted voluntarily and that no condition may be applied for the
receipt of emergency shelter (42 U.S.C. 10408(d)(2));
(13) a new requirement for Federal consultation with Tribal
governments in the planning of grants for Indian Tribes (42 U.S.C.
10409(a));
(14) a requirement for two national resource centers on domestic
violence, including one national Indian resource center to address
domestic violence and safety for Indian women (42 U.S.C. 10410);
(15) a requirement for at least seven special issue resource
centers including three focused on enhancing domestic violence
intervention and prevention efforts for victims of domestic violence
who are members of racial and ethnic minority groups to enhance the
cultural and linguistic relevancy of service delivery (42 U.S.C.
10410);
(16) a provision giving the Secretary the discretionary authority
to award grants to State resource centers to reduce Tribal disparities
in domestic violence in eligible States (42 U.S.C. Sec. 10410);
(17) clarification of the activities of State Domestic Violence
Coalitions (42 U.S.C. 10411);
(18) new opt-out provisions for certain coalition activities if
annual assurances are provided by Coalitions that the activities are
being provided and coordinated under other specific Federal funding
streams (42 U.S.C. 10411(e));
(19) a requirement that the Secretary establish a new program for
specialized services for abused parents and their children with
discretionary authority to make grants (42 U.S.C. 10412); such
specialized services may include but are not limited to: providing
direct counseling that is developmentally and age appropriate and
culturally and linguistically appropriate to victims and their
children, including services that are coordinated with services
provided by the child welfare system; and, to provide services for non-
abusing parents to support those parents' roles as caregivers and their
role in responding to the social, emotional, and developmental needs of
their children;
(20) clarification that a grant to one or more private entities may
be made for ongoing operation of the National Domestic Violence Hotline
that serves adult and youth victims of family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence (42 U.S.C. 10413(a)); including, allowing
the provision of hotline services to youth victims of domestic violence
or dating violence who are minors through a national teen dating
violence hotline (42 U.S.C. 10413(d)(2)(G)). This notice of proposed
rulemaking would revise regulations applying to the Family Violence
Prevention and Services Programs, except for the Domestic Violence
Prevention Enhancement and Leadership Through Alliances Program (DELTA)
contained in Section 314 of the Family Violence Prevention and Services
Act (FVPSA--codified in 42 U.S.C. 10414), which is separately funded
and administered by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
Division of Violence Prevention.
While we have already implemented most of these provisions through
the Funding Opportunity Announcements, technical assistance and
training, and Information Memoranda issuances, this proposed rule would
allow us to
[[Page 61892]]
integrate these legislative requirements into our codified rules. In
addition, it would bring our codified regulations, last updated on
February 22, 1996 (61 FR 6791), into conformity with the administrative
and managerial procedures we already use in compliance with FVPSA. We
do not propose to codify every provision of the statute. Finally, the
proposed rule identifies a number of important linkages between the
FVPSA programs and those programs conducted by the Department of
Justice and authorized by VAWA. For example, both statutes contain
strict prohibitions against disclosure of confidential or private
information to ensure the safety of persons receiving services.
V. Consultation and the Development of the NPRM
It is our intent in this section of the NPRM preamble to highlight
the various meetings and consultations, among many other activities we
conducted, that assisted in the development of the NPRM. To support our
statutory responsibilities for administering the State and Coalition
formula grants, contingent upon available funding, we host either an
annual or bi-annual, joint grantee meeting of the State FVPSA funding
administrators and the State Domestic Violence Coalitions. The grantee
meeting facilitates partnership building between the respective State
and Coalition cohorts and across all States and Coalitions, shares and
promotes best practices related to the provision of prevention and
intervention services for victims of family, domestic, and dating
violence (with speakers, lecturers, and facilitators on a broad range
of issues in the field), and provides program guidance on implementing
the statutory requirements of the FVPSA. These meetings provide
important opportunities for Federal, State, and private staff to engage
with each other to learn about and address issues of intersecting
importance, including issues such as protecting victim/survivor
confidentiality that are addressed in this proposed rule.
The National Resource Centers, Special Issue Resource Centers, and
Culturally-Specific Special Issue Resource Centers comprise what is
known as the FVPSA Domestic Violence Resource Network (DVRN). The DVRN
convenes every one to two years to share and promote evidence-informed
and best practices about prevention and intervention services for
victims of family, domestic, and dating violence. Expert speakers and
lecturers present on a broad range of subject matter important to the
field. ACF also provides program guidance on implementing statutory
requirements at the meetings.
ACF funded Tribal administrators, advocates, and leaders also are
convened annually, contingent upon funding. The Tribal grantee meeting
allows grantees to provide and receive technical assistance and
training. Issues addressed and best practices shared are most commonly
related to service delivery; new initiatives; business needs; funding
issues; information exchange; collaborations ranging from service
delivery models to police response; cultural sensitivity; advocacy; and
the statutory requirements of the FVPSA.
ACF also hosts annual Tribal consultations. Tribal consultations
discuss ACF programs and Tribal priorities and to build meaningful
relationships with Federally recognized Tribes. The consultations
solicit recommendations and/or mutual understanding from Tribal
government leaders on issues ranging from funding availability to
departmental priorities.
In addition, ACF staff participates in annual Tribal consultations
sponsored by the Department of Justice Office on Violence Against
Women. The purpose of those consultations is to engage in a government-
to-government dialogue between the United States Government and the
leaders from Indian Tribal governments on how to best enhance the
safety of Alaska Natives and American Indians and reduce domestic
violence, dating violence, sexual assault, and stalking committed
against them. The consultations also solicit recommendations from
Tribal government leaders on administering grant funds.
Finally, development of the NPRM included ongoing analyses of
formula and discretionary grantees' annual performance reports as well
as site visit reports and desk reviews. Information gleaned from these
sources helped to identify grantees' successes and challenges
implementing FVPSA requirements and, therefore, informed the NPRM
development process.
VI. Scope of the Proposed Rule
This rule proposes to revise existing regulatory standards to help
improve the administration of the FVPSA, to provide greater clarity and
transparency to ACF's implementation of the statute, and to bring the
program regulation into conformance with statutory provisions.
All grantees will be expected to comply with standards and other
requirements upon the final rule's effective date. To assist grantees
with compliance, we will provide guidance on best practices for
implementing the standards and revised requirements. We also plan to
conduct technical assistance to help grantees understand and implement
changes.
This proposed rule also makes technical changes to existing program
rules to correct outdated provisions. It proposes to revise our
regulatory provisions on making awards to reflect current program
priorities and onsite review and monitoring procedures.
VII. Section-by-Section Discussion of the Regulatory Provisions
We propose to revise 45 Part 1370 to add a Subpart A for general
provisions, add a Subpart B for State and Indian Tribal grants, add a
Subpart C for State Domestic Violence Coalition grants, and add a
Subpart D for Discretionary grants and contracts. We also propose to
add a new table of contents to this part.
Subpart A--General Provisions
Section 1370.1 What are the purposes of the Family Violence Prevention
and Services Act programs?
We propose to add Sec. 1370.1 under new Subpart A, and to revise
it to reflect the statute's current purposes found at 42 U.S.C.
10401(b). One major difference from the existing regulation is new
language expanding purpose areas to include family violence, domestic
violence, and dating violence. Specifically, the new purposes are:
assist States and Indian Tribes in efforts to increase public awareness
about, and primary and secondary prevention of, family violence,
domestic violence, and dating violence; assist States and Indian Tribes
in efforts to provide immediate shelter and supportive services for
victims of family violence, domestic violence, or dating violence, and
their dependents; provide for a national domestic violence hotline; and
provide for technical assistance and training relating to family
violence, domestic violence, and dating violence programs to States and
Indian Tribes, local public agencies (including law enforcement
agencies, courts, and legal, social service, and healthcare
professionals in public agencies), nonprofit private organizations
(including faith-based and charitable organizations, community-based
organizations and voluntary associations), Tribal organizations, and
other persons seeking such assistance and training.
Section 1370.2 What definitions apply to these programs?
We propose to add Sec. 1370.2 under new Subpart A and revise it to
include
[[Page 61893]]
definitions of significant terms found in the statute at 42 U.S.C.
10402 and used in current operating practices. The definitions are
intended to reflect important terms in the statute and important
practices in the administration of the program. In some instances, we
do not repeat the statutory definition verbatim but rather propose a
regulatory definition that we believe is fully consistent with the
statutory definition, but will provide clarity to the field and other
interested stakeholders. The definitions section applies to all grants
and contracts under the FVPSA. We welcome comments on all proposed
definitions; however, we are constrained by the statutory definitions
in the FVPSA. Note that many of these are longstanding definitions
resulting from FVPSA reauthorization in 2010 and are already included
in the Funding Opportunity Announcements.
We propose to include the statutory definition of ``dating
violence,'' an important addition to the scope of persons protected
under the FVPSA. The statute defines it as ``violence committed by a
person who is or has been in a social relationship of a romantic or
intimate nature with the victim and where the existence of such a
relationship shall be determined based on a consideration of the
following factors: the length of the relationship, the type of
relationship, and the frequency of interaction between the persons
involved in the relationship.'' This definition reflects the definition
also found in Section 40002(a) of VAWA (as amended), as required by
FVPSA. Dating violence may also include violence against older
individuals and those with disabilities when the violence meets the
applicable definition.
We propose to include the statutory definition of ``domestic
violence.'' Section 10402(3) of the FVPSA defines ``domestic violence''
as felony or misdemeanor crimes of violence committed by a current or
former spouse or intimate partner of the victim, by a person with whom
the victim shares a child in common, by a person who is cohabitating
with or has cohabitated with the victim as a spouse or intimate
partner, by a person similarly situated to a spouse of the victim under
the domestic or family violence laws of the jurisdiction receiving
grant monies, or by any other person against an adult or youth victim
who is protected from that person's acts under the domestic or family
violence laws of the jurisdiction. This definition also reflects the
statutory definition of ``domestic violence'' found in Section 40002(a)
of VAWA (as amended). Older individuals and those with disabilities who
meet these criteria are also included within this term's definition.
We also propose that the definition of ``domestic violence'' will
also include, but will not be limited to, acts or acts constituting
intimidation, control, coercion and coercive control, emotional and
psychological abuse and behavior, expressive and psychological
aggression, harassment, tormenting behavior, and disturbing or alarming
behavior. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) in its
National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey, 2014 Report
(Breiding, M.J., Chen J., & Black, M.C. (2014), Intimate Partner
Violence in the United States-2010. Atlanta, GA: National Center for
Injury Prevention) describes intimate partner violence, which is
commonly used interchangeably with the term ``domestic violence,'' to
include psychological aggression and expressive aggression (such as
name calling, insulting or humiliating an intimate partner) and
coercive control, which includes behaviors that are intended to
monitor, control or threaten an intimate partner.
Moreover, several states have broadened their definitions of
``domestic violence'' or similar terms to describe a range of behaviors
commonly understood as abusive behavior within spousal and intimate
partner relationships. For example, Maine legislatively defines
``abuse'' within family, household, or dating partner relationships to
include (among other factors), threatening, harassing or tormenting
behavior.'' ME. Rev. Stat. Ann. tit. 19-A Sec. 4002 (2009). The state
also defines other behavior as ``abuse'' such as following the
plaintiff/[alleged victim] repeatedly and without reasonable cause; or,
being in the vicinity of the plaintiff's home, school, business or
place of employment both repeatedly and without reasonable cause. Id.
In Cole v. Cole, 2008 ME 4, 940 A.2d 194, 2008 Me, Lexus 6 (2008), a
District court issued a protection from abuse order to the wife and the
parties' child, pursuant to Me. Rev. Stat. Ann. tit. 19-A, Sec.
4002(C), because the husband had a longstanding pattern of controlling,
intimidating, and threatening conduct toward his wife.
The State of New Hampshire includes ``harassment'' in the
definition of ``abuse'', by including (among other factors) when a
person: (a) Makes a telephone call, whether or not a conversation
ensues, with no legitimate communicative purpose or without disclosing
his or her identity and with a purpose to annoy, abuse, threaten, or
alarm another; or (b) makes repeated communications at extremely
inconvenient hours or in offensively coarse language with a purpose to
annoy or alarm another; or (c) insults, taunts, or challenges another
in a manner likely to provoke a violent or disorderly response. N.H.
Rev. Stat. Ann. Sec. 173-B:1(I)(g); 644:4 (2009).
Another State, Hawaii, provides as one definition of ``domestic
abuse'' within the context of a romantic or intimate relationship
(among others) as ``extreme psychological abuse'' mean[ing] an
intentional or knowing course of conduct directed at an individual that
seriously alarms or disturbs consistently or continually bothers the
individual, and that serves no legitimate purpose. HAW. REV.STAT. Sec.
586-1(1) (2009).
Given the continuum of behaviors constituting ``domestic violence''
identified in FVPSA, and the broader protections embodied in State and
other jurisdictional law, ACF will interpret ``domestic violence'' as
inclusive of additional acts recognized in other Federal, State, local,
and tribal laws, as well as acts in other Federal regulatory and sub-
regulatory guidance. Note that this definition is not intended to be
interpreted more restrictively than FVPSA and VAWA but rather to be
inclusive of other, more expansive definitions.
We propose to include the statutory definition of ``family
violence'' found at Section 10402(4) of the FVPSA. ``Family violence''
means any act or threatened act of violence, including any forceful
detention of an individual, that results or threatens to result in
physical injury and is committed by a person against another individual
(including an older individual), to or with whom such person is related
by blood or marriage, or is or was otherwise legally related, or is or
was lawfully residing. We would note that since 2013, the Funding
Opportunity Announcements have included LGBTQ individuals as an
underserved population with no reference to marital status. For the
last nine years and pursuant to the FVPSA definition of family
violence, ACF has required grantees, sub-grantees, and contractors to
provide services to LGBTQ individuals regardless of marital status.
Additionally, defining family violence to encompass same-sex spouses is
consistent with the Supreme Court's decision in Obergefell v. Hodges,
which held that same-sex marriages are entitled to equal treatment
under the law. All FVPSA-funded grantees and contractors are required
to serve program recipients regardless of whether an individual may be
married to a person of the opposite or same sex.
[[Page 61894]]
Please note that this guidance is not a change in previous grantee
guidance as survivors of intimate partner violence, regardless of
marital status, have always been eligible for FVPSA-funded services and
programming.
Further, ``family violence'' has become a term used interchangeably
with ``domestic violence'' by both the field, and Congress, when
describing the violence experienced between intimate partners and the
programs and services utilized by those impacted by such violence. In
1984 when FVPSA was first named and authorized, the term ``family
violence'' was commonly used as synonymous with ``domestic violence''
(violence between intimate partners). However, ``family violence'' is
still often used more broadly to encompass the diverse forms of
violence that occur within families, including child maltreatment,
``domestic violence'' and elder abuse. For clarity and in keeping with
the historical FVPSA ``family violence'' interpretation, the term will
continue to be used more narrowly and as interchangeable with
``domestic violence.''
Additionally, the legislative history of the 2010 FVPSA
Reauthorization is replete with descriptive language citing ``domestic
violence,'' ``domestic violence service providers,'' and ``domestic
violence victims'' while only briefly referencing ``family violence''
in the Senate Committee's legislative explanation. CAPTA
Reauthorization Act of 2010, 111 S. Rpt. 378 Title IV--Family Violence
Prevention and Services Act, 17-19 (December 18, 2010). The Committee
Report discusses multiple FVPSA sections using only the term ``domestic
violence'' when describing, for example, the role of religious and
faith-based communities in working with domestic violence service
providers to support victims. Id. at 111 S. Rpt. 378, 17. In discussing
the role of a coordinated community response, the report states ``the
committee intends that ``coordinated community response'' means an
organized effort, such as a task force, (or) coordinating council . . .
representing an array of service providers responding to the needs of
domestic violence populations in such area.'' Id. at 111 S. Rpt. 378,
18. The Committee Report goes on to estimate FVPSA costs and primarily
focuses on ``domestic violence'' by reporting that ``[FVPSA] would help
States prevent domestic violence, provide services to people who have
suffered from such violence, and assist with technical assistance and
training at the State and Local levels.'' Id. at 111 S. Rpt. 378, 20.
In the same paragraph and in the context of discussing domestic
violence, the report also cites the Congressional Budget Office's
estimation of total costs and references ``family violence prevention''
only once as compared to the repeated use of ``domestic violence''
throughout the report.
Moreover, the Catalogue of Federal Domestic Assistance (CFDA) has
historically described FVPSA grant programs as ``Family Violence
Prevention and Services/Battered Women's Shelters--Grants to States and
Indian Tribes'' (93.671) and ``Family Violence Prevention and Services/
Battered Women's Shelters--Grants to State Domestic Violence
Coalitions'' (93.591). ``Battered Women's Shelters'' has been a
commonly used term since the 1970's to identify safe housing and refuge
for victims of domestic violence. Recently, however, the CFDA program
descriptions were approved to more clearly reflect the continuing
intent to fund domestic violence programs with FVPSA funding.
Accordingly, the CFDA descriptions are now: ``Family Violence
Prevention and Services/Domestic Violence Shelter and Supportive
Services'' (93.671); ``Family Violence Prevention and Services/State
Domestic Violence Coalitions'' (93.591); and, ``Family Violence
Prevention and Services/Discretionary'' (93.592). Additionally, the ACF
Congressional Justification uses the same ``Battered Women's Shelters''
nomenclature and describes that FVPSA-funded services are used to
support ``domestic violence'' programs and services even though the
term ``family violence'' also is interchangeably used in the
description of programming. Therefore, the definition of family
violence proposed here reflects the definition long used by the
Department and indicated by its interchangeable use in the FVPSA
statute and by the domestic violence field and Congress.
A very important requirement in the current statute revolves around
protecting victims of violence from further abuse through non-
disclosure of ``personally identifying information.'' We propose to
define the term using the statutory definition in FVPSA Section
10402(7), which references and incorporates the VAWA definition.
Personally identifying information is proposed to be defined as
individually identifying information for or about an individual
including information likely to disclose the location of a victim of
domestic violence, dating violence, sexual assault, or stalking,
regardless of whether the information is encoded, encrypted, hashed, or
otherwise protected, including, (A) a first and last name; (B) a home
or other physical address; (C) contact information (including a postal,
email or Internet protocol address, or telephone or facsimile number);
(D) a social security number, driver license number, passport number,
or student identification number; and (E) any other information,
including date of birth, racial or ethnic background, or religious
affiliation, that would serve to identify any individual. Note that
information remains personally identifying even if physically protected
through locked filing cabinets or electronically protected through
encryption.
Additionally, there are FVPSA-specific waiver and consent
requirements for the non-disclosure of confidential or private
information as well as provisions for the release of information to law
enforcement, child welfare agencies, aggregate data releases by
grantees, and for the release of personally identifying information of
victims who also are minors (42 U.S.C. 10405(c)(5)). All grantees are
required to comply with these requirements which are included in this
NPRM in Section 1370.4.
Primary prevention was included as a statutory purpose for the
first time in the 2010 amendments to the FVPSA statute but not defined.
Primary prevention focuses on strategies to stop both first-time
perpetration and first-time victimization. Primary prevention also is
defined by the CDC as ``stopping intimate partner violence before it
occurs'' (https://www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention/deltafocus/). Primary
prevention may work by modifying the events, conditions, situations, or
exposure to influences that result in the initiation of intimate
partner violence and associated injuries, disabilities, and deaths.
Examples of primary prevention could include: ``school-based violence
prevention curricula, programs aimed at mitigating the effects on
children of witnessing intimate partner violence, community campaigns
designed to alter norms and values conducive to intimate partner
violence, worksite prevention programs, and training and education in
parenting skills and self-esteem enhancement.'' 61 FR 27879 (1996),
Coordinated Community Responses to Prevent Intimate Partner Violence;
Notice of Availability of Funds for Fiscal Year 1996 (HHS/CDC).
Therefore, we propose to use the CDC definition of ``primary
prevention'' to mean strategies, policies, and programs to stop both
first-time perpetration and first-time victimization. Primary
prevention is stopping intimate partner violence before it occurs.
[[Page 61895]]
We propose to define ``primary-purpose domestic violence provider''
as one that operates a project of demonstrated effectiveness carried
out by a nonprofit, nongovernmental, private entity, Tribe, or Tribal
organization, that has as its project's primary-purpose the operation
of shelters and supportive services for victims of domestic violence
and their dependents; or provides counseling, advocacy, or self-help
services to victims of domestic violence. Territorial Domestic Violence
Coalitions may include government-operated domestic violence projects
as ``primary-purpose'' providers for complying with the membership
requirement, provided that Territorial Coalitions can document
providing training, technical assistance, and capacity-building of
community-based and privately operated projects to provide shelter and
supportive services to victims of family, domestic, or dating violence,
with the intention of recruiting such projects as members once they are
sustainable as primary-purpose domestic violence service providers.
This definition is not in FVPSA, however, we propose to describe the
undefined term in FVPSA Section 10402(11)(A), based upon program
experience and consistent with the priority for State formula funding
provided in FVPSA Section 10407(a)(2)(B)(iii).
`Secondary prevention' was also added to the purpose of the FVPSA
statute but not defined. The World Health Organization's World Report
on Violence and Health, 2002:1-21, describes ``secondary prevention''
as approaches that focus on the more immediate responses to violence.
The HHS CDC's Division of Violence Prevention also uses this definition
in practice and incorporates both risk and protective factors to
promote the efficacy of secondary prevention efforts. Therefore, we
propose to include the CDC's definition of ``secondary prevention''
that means identifying risk factors or problems that may lead to future
family violence, domestic violence, or dating violence, and taking the
necessary actions to eliminate the risk factors and the potential
problem. The objective is to create opportunities to identify potential
problems and to intervene as soon as possible to prevent the problem
from recurring or progressing. Services for children exposed to
domestic violence exemplify one type of secondary prevention. By
developing targeted strategies for children who have been exposed to
violence, secondary prevention efforts can reduce the likelihood of
such children becoming victims or perpetrators of future violence.
Among the most important services under these programs is the
provision of shelter to victims of family, domestic, and dating
violence. We propose to use the statutory definition of ``shelter,''
which is the provision of temporary refuge and supportive services in
compliance with applicable State law or regulations governing the
provision, on a regular basis, of shelter, safe homes, meals, and
supportive services to victims of family violence, domestic violence,
or dating violence, and their dependents. We also propose to include in
this definition emergency shelter and immediate shelter, which may
include scattered-site housing, which is defined as property with
multiple locations around a local jurisdiction or state. Temporary
refuge is not defined in FVPSA and we propose that it includes
residential services, including shelter and off-site services such as
hotel or motel vouchers, which is not transitional or permanent
housing. Should other jurisdictional laws conflict with this definition
of temporary refuge, the definition which provides more expansive
housing accessibility governs.
Under the FVPSA, grants are made to States and U.S. Territories. We
propose to include the definition of ``State'' as defined in the
statute. FVPSA defines ``State'' as each of the several States, the
District of Columbia, the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, Guam, American
Samoa, the United States Virgin Islands, and the Commonwealth of the
Northern Mariana Islands. The statute makes one exception to this
definition for State formula grants, and provides for a different
allotment of funds for Guam, American Samoa, the United
Statesi Virgin Islands, and the Commonwealth of the Northern
Mariana Islands. These four territories receive a smaller share of
funding because of their relatively small populations.
The purpose of State Domestic Violence Coalitions is to provide
education, support, and technical assistance to domestic violence
service providers in their respective States to enable the providers to
establish and maintain shelter and supportive services for victims of
domestic violence and their dependents (including multi-generational
families, e.g. grandparents or others impacted by witnessing the
violence and dependent on the victim); and serve as information
clearinghouses, primary points of contact, and resource centers on
domestic violence for the States and support the development of
polices, protocols, and procedures to enhance domestic violence
intervention and prevention in the States. One grant is awarded to one
HHS-designated Coalition in each State and Territory each year. It
should be noted that the identified Territories in this section also
are designated one Coalition per Territory. We propose to include a
definition of and to define a State Domestic Violence Coalition
(Coalition) as: A statewide, nongovernmental, nonprofit 501(c)(3)
organization whose membership includes a majority of the primary-
purpose domestic violence service providers in the State; whose board
membership is representative of these primary-purpose domestic violence
service providers, and which may include representatives of the
communities in which the services are being provided in the State; that
provides education, support, and technical assistance to such service
providers; and that serves as an information clearinghouse, primary
point of contact, and resource center on domestic violence for the
State and supports the development of policies, protocols and
procedures to enhance domestic violence intervention and prevention in
the State/Territory.
FVPSA provides for supportive services targeted directly to the
needs of victims for safety and assistance in reclaiming their agency,
autonomy and well-being. We propose to include a definition of
``supportive services,'' which we define as services for adult and
youth victims of family violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence, and their dependents that are designed to meet the needs of
such victims and their dependents for short-term, transitional, or
long-term safety and recovery. Our proposed definition includes those
services identified in FVPSA Section 10408(b)(1)(G), but is not limited
to: Direct and/or referral-based advocacy on behalf of victims and
their dependents, counseling, case management, employment services,
referrals, transportation services, legal advocacy or assistance, child
care services, health, behavioral health and preventive health
services, culturally appropriate services, and other services that
assist victims or their dependents in recovering from the effects of
the violence. Supportive services may be directly provided by grantees
and/or by providing advocacy or referrals to assist victims in
accessing such services.
Another important program focus is on ``underserved populations,''
which we propose to use the FVPSA definition in Section 10402(14),
specifically referencing and incorporating the VAWA definition, to
define as populations who face barriers in accessing and using victim
services, and
[[Page 61896]]
populations underserved because of geographic location, religion,
sexual orientation, gender identity, underserved racial and ethnic
populations, and populations underserved because of special needs
including language barriers, disabilities, immigration status, and age.
Note that regarding age, the FVPSA-defined terms of family violence,
domestic violence, and dating violence do not impose age limitations on
victims or their dependents that may be served in FVPSA-funded
programs; elders and adolescents are also included in these definitions
and we do not propose to place age limits in these categories. We also
propose to include in this definition individuals with criminal
histories due to victimization and individuals with substance abuse and
mental health issues based on program experience and victims' needs
identified by grantees. The proposed definition also includes, as
allowed by FVPSA, other population categories determined by the
Secretary or the Secretary's designee to be underserved.
We welcome comments on all these definitions and on ways to clarify
any ambiguities or improve any elements. We are, however, constrained
substantially by the FVPSA in departing significantly from most of the
wording we propose because the proposed regulatory definitions come
from the FVPSA and best practices identified from the field.
Section 1370.3 What government-wide and HHS-wide regulations apply to
these programs?
The current rule contains no list of the other rules and
regulations that apply to recipients of program funds. These applicable
rules include, for example, regulations concerning civil rights
obligations of grant recipients and regulations concerning fraud,
waste, and abuse by grant recipients. We propose to revise Sec. 1370.3
under new subpart A to include a list of those rules that most commonly
apply to grantees and contractors under all or most HHS programs,
including FVPSA. This new list does not attempt to list all of the
Federal laws and regulations (e.g., provisions of the Internal Revenue
Code regarding non-profit status) that pertain to organizations that
may be grant awardees. The provisions we list here are not all
administered through ACF (though the agency may in some instances
assist in their enforcement), but are for the most part administered by
other HHS components or by other Federal agencies that set the
conditions and enforcement mechanisms that apply to those provisions,
and that determine whether and in what circumstances grant-related
penalties may apply.
Section 1370.4 What confidentiality requirements apply to these
programs?
We propose to add Sec. 1370.4 under Part A and revise it to
include language regarding confidentiality requirements that apply to
all FVPSA programs. The essential purpose of these requirements, which
are in the FVPSA (42 U.S.C. 10406(c)(5)) and in VAWA (42 U.S.C.
13925(a)(20) and (b)(2)) is to protect victims of domestic violence
from being identified, located, or harmed by the perpetrators of
violence and others working to assist perpetrators in gaining access to
victims. These protections are robust. Grantees and subgrantees are
directly prohibited from disclosing any personally identifiable
information (as defined in this NPRM Section 1370.2). We propose to use
the FVPSA requirements for the non-disclosure of confidential or
private information. In paragraph (a), we propose that in order to
ensure the safety of adult, youth, and child victims of family
violence, domestic violence, or dating violence, and their families,
grantees and subgrantees under this title shall protect the
confidentiality and privacy of such victims and their families.
In paragraph (a), we propose that grantees and subgrantees shall
not: (1) Disclose any personally identifying information collected in
connection with services requested (including services utilized or
denied), through grantees' and subgrantees' programs; or (2) reveal
personally identifying information without informed, written,
reasonably time-limited consent by the person about whom information is
sought, whether for this program or any other Federal or State grant
program.
In paragraph (b), we propose that consent shall be given by the
person, except in the case of an unemancipated minor, the minor and the
minor's parent or guardian or in the case of an individual with a
guardian, the individual's guardian. Consent may not be given by the
abuser or suspected abuser of the minor or individual with a guardian,
or the abuser or suspected abuser of the other parent of the minor.
In paragraph (c), we propose that if release of information
described in paragraphs (a) and (b) is compelled by statutory or court
mandate grantees and subgrantees shall make reasonable attempts to
provide notice to victims affected by the release of the information
and grantees and subgrantees shall take steps necessary to protect the
privacy and safety of the persons affected by the release of the
information.
In paragraph (d), we propose that grantees and subgrantees may
share: (1) Nonpersonally identifying information, in the aggregate,
regarding services to their clients and demographic nonpersonally
identifying information in order to comply with Federal, State, or
tribal reporting, evaluation, or data collection requirements; (2)
court-generated information and law enforcement-generated information
contained in secure, governmental registries for protective order
enforcement purposes; and (3) law enforcement- and prosecution-
generated information necessary for law enforcement and prosecution
purposes.
To further explain, in meeting reporting, evaluation, or data
collection requirements, grantees may not disclose individual data, but
only non-identifying aggregate data. If the release of information is
compelled by statutory or court mandate, grantees and sub-grantees
shall make reasonable attempts to provide notice to victims affected by
the release of the information and grantees and sub-grantees shall take
steps necessary to protect the privacy and safety of the persons
affected by the release of the information. Service providers,
including those in co-located facilities such as Family Justice
Centers, can share information about a client upon her/his request if
the client signs a waiver that is limited in time and scope, reasonably
responsive to individual circumstances, to coordinate and execute a
specific service or request. A reasonably time-limited release is
determined by an individual's safety and other needs as identified by
the individual. Reasonably time-limited releases may be loosely
standardized if grantees are addressing the similar needs of victims
who are similarly situated; however, standardization should be rare
since individual victims' circumstances are the guiding factor when
determining the reasonableness and time limitations of required written
releases. For example, victims residing in shelter are often receiving
the services of other providers and/or are being referred by shelters
to other providers. To ensure coordinated services, FVPSA-funded
shelter grantees have been known to standardize form releases under
such circumstances between organizations to help support efficiency and
staff work flow. However, even this kind of standardization often
includes and requires additional individualized instructions and
limitations depending upon a victim's safety and other needs.
Funders and licensing agencies (i.e., fire code inspectors, state
licensing inspectors, etc.) reviewing shelter
[[Page 61897]]
performance or operations cannot view identifying client files. Any
information shared must have all personally identifying information
redacted. HHS will continue to offer technical assistance to States who
are seeking a balance between oversight and confidentiality. These
requirements directly track the statute (42 U.S.C. 10406(c)(5)) and
there is very little discretion available to the Department, or to
grantees or subgrantees. There are also additional provisions in the
regulatory text which mirror statutory requirements for the consent of
unemancipated minors. In this regard, consent shall be given by the
person, except in the case of an unemancipated minor it shall be given
by both the minor and the minor's parent or guardian; or in the case of
an individual with a guardian it shall be given by the individual's
guardian. A parent or guardian may not give consent if: he or she is
the abuser or suspected abuser of the minor or individual with a
guardian; or, the abuser or suspected abuser of the other parent of the
minor. We also propose along these lines that reasonable accommodation
be made to those who may be unable, due to disability or other
functional limitation, to provide consent in writing. This slightly
varies the statutory definition, though it is not intended as a
substitution, to ensure that those with disabilities have a meaningful
alternative to providing informed consent if they are otherwise
incapacitated. If additional clarification would be useful in the rule,
we welcome suggestions. We will issue guidance addressing any future
situations that may present problems of interpretation. We also will
use National Resource Centers, State Domestic Violence Coalitions, and
Training and Technical Assistance Grants to assist service providers in
meeting these requirements and in dealing with other Federal, State,
Tribal or local agencies that may seek protected information. These
regulations do not supersede stronger protections that may be provided
by Federal, State, Tribal or local laws.
Pursuant to FVPSA Section 10406(c)(5)(H), we note that our proposed
language also protects the addresses of shelter facilities with
confidential locations, except with written authorization of the person
or persons responsible for operation of the shelter. To date there have
been no issues reported to FYSB regarding this requirement except when
Tribal nations are geographically isolated thereby making
confidentiality nearly impossible. Tribal leaders often utilize FVPSA
funds to transport victims from isolated to more populated areas where
victims have greater access to necessary services especially when
confidentiality cannot be maintained within very confined and remote
areas. In these circumstances, it is not uncommon that a Tribe may
utilize most of its FVPSA grant on transportation. We welcome comments
especially from Tribes and tribal organizations, as well as concerned
others, about how confidentiality may be more effectively maintained
given these very challenging situations.
Section 1370.5 What additional non-discrimination requirements apply to
these programs?
We propose to add Sec. 1370.5 under new Subpart A and revise it to
include non-discrimination requirements that apply uniquely to FVPSA
programs. These are in addition to broad government-wide or HHS-wide
civil rights protections in regulations concerning discrimination on
the basis of race, color, national origin, disability, and age that
apply to all HHS grantees, including FVPSA grantees (see the list of
other regulations that apply to these programs in Sec. 1370.3 of this
proposed rule). FVPSA contains broad prohibitions against
discrimination on the basis of sex or religion in FVPSA programs, and
we propose to codify in regulation these prohibitions. The HHS Office
for Civil Rights (OCR) enforces FVPSA's broad prohibitions against
discrimination, including on the basis of sex or religion, under
delegated authority from the Secretary. In addition, our proposed
language says that FVPSA State and Tribal Formula grant-funded services
must be provided without imposing eligibility criteria, and without
requiring documentation for eligibility (see the Domestic Violence Fact
Sheet on Access to HHS-Funded Services for Immigrant Survivors of
Domestic Violence, at https://www.hhs.gov/ocr/civilrights/resources/specialtopics/origin/domesticviolencefactsheet.html). Our proposed
language also includes the FVPSA's prohibition against placing
conditions on receipt of emergency shelter or requiring participation
in supportive services.
Prohibition Against Discrimination on the Basis of Sex or Religion
In paragraph (a), we propose to codify in regulation FVPSA's broad
prohibitions against discrimination on the basis of sex or religion.
Under its delegated authority, OCR enforces these prohibitions.
Consistent with the usual approaches to defining civil rights
obligations in Federal regulations, we do not propose to elaborate in
regulatory text all the situations to which the FVPSA's protections
against discrimination on the basis of sex or religion might apply.
However, consistent with our longstanding policy in Funding Opportunity
Announcements and reliance on regulatory guidance issued by the
Department of Housing and Urban Development amending 24 CFR parts 5,
200, 203, 236, 400, 570, 574, 882, 891, and 982, published in the
Federal Register/Vol. 77, No. 23/Friday, February 3, 2012, we interpret
the prohibition against discrimination on the basis of sex as also
prohibiting discrimination on the basis of gender identity.
As a result, FVPSA grantees must provide comparable services to
victims regardless of sex or gender. This includes not only providing
access to services for male victims of family, domestic, and dating
violence, but also making sure not to limit services for victims with
adolescent sons (up to the age of majority), and LGBTQ victims. Victims
and their sons must be sheltered or housed together unless they request
otherwise. Historically, most services have been provided to women
because they are the overwhelming majority of victims, are more likely
to suffer serious injuries and other impacts of the violence, and have
been the primary demographic seeking services. As such, services have
been mostly tailored to address the unique needs of female survivors.
However, there are male victims of these crimes who deserve access to
safety from their offenders and services to help them rebuild their
lives free from violence. FVPSA states, ``no person shall on the ground
of sex or religion be excluded from participation in, be denied the
benefits of, or be subject to discrimination under, any program or
activity in whole or in part with funds made available under this
chapter. Nothing in this chapter shall require any such program or
activity to include any individual in any program or activity without
taking into consideration that individual's sex in those certain
instances where sex is a bona fide occupational qualification or
programmatic factor reasonably necessary to the normal or safe
operation of that particular program or activity'' (42 U.S.C. Sec.
10406(c)(2)(B)). For clarification, we propose that the ``normal and
safe operation'' of a program or activity be that which is essential
and safe for operations.
[[Page 61898]]
This statutory directive should not be interpreted to eliminate
programming or services tailored to the unique needs of individuals
served by FVPSA grantees, sub-grantees, contractors and/or vendors
provided they are not based on illegal sex classifications. Moreover,
programmatic access must be assured for all victims of family,
domestic, and dating violence, and responses to individual victims
should be trauma-informed, victim-defined, and culturally relevant,
which may involve providing specialized services and supports. We do
not propose to define in regulation what is or is not allowed in
precise circumstances.
If a shelter can reasonably separate the sexes in a manner which
allows for single sex bedrooms and bathrooms and the essential and safe
operation of the particular program is not substantially compromised,
it is reasonable to provide such separation. Essential services are
those required by the grant, which are funded to support the long-term
social and emotional well-being of victims and their dependents. If the
essential or safe operation of the program or activity would be
substantially compromised, alternative, equivalent shelter and services
should be offered as practicable. For instance, a male victim could be
offered a hotel placement and provided supportive services at the
shelter.
Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Questioning (LGBTQ)
individuals must also have access to FVPSA-funded shelter and non-
residential programs. LGBTQ survivors face unique challenges accessing
programs due to victimization often resulting from the intersection of
bias and multiple oppressions as well as the limited understanding of
providers in delivering welcoming and culturally-appropriate services.
Examples include those of gay men who may have difficulty accessing
shelter services because domestic violence shelters were founded and
grew within the framework of the battered women's movement. Trans-women
face service barriers because providers are often confounded by an
individual's apparent biological sex which may contradict perceived or
actual gender. Programmatic accessibility for transgender survivors
must be afforded to meet individual needs like those provided to all
survivors. For the purpose of assigning a beneficiary to sex-segregated
or sex-specific services, the recipient should ask a transgender
beneficiary which group or services the beneficiary wishes to join. The
recipient may not, however, ask questions about the beneficiary's
anatomy or medical history or make inappropriate demands for identity
documents. ACF requires that a FVPSA grantee, subgrantee, contractor,
or vendor that makes decisions about eligibility for or placement into
single-sex emergency shelters or other facilities place a potential
victim (or current victim/client seeking a new assignment) in a shelter
or other appropriate placement that corresponds to the gender with
which the person identifies, taking health and safety concerns into
consideration. A victim's/client's or potential victim's/client's own
views with respect to personal health and safety must be given serious
consideration in making the placement. For instance, if the potential
victim/client requests to be placed based on his or her sex assigned at
birth, ACF requires that the provider place the individual in
accordance with that request, consistent with health, safety, and
privacy concerns. ACF also requires that a provider not make an
assignment or re- assignment based on complaints of another person when
the sole stated basis of the complaint is a victim/client or potential
victim/client's non-conformance with gender stereotypes.
Additionally, LGBTQ individuals seeking refuge at domestic violence
shelters may experience homophobia or bias or may confront the
invisibility of their experiences in the form of advertising and
resource materials that only address heterosexual domestic violence.
Therefore, programmatic accessibility for LGBTQ survivors must be
afforded to meet individual needs like those provided to all other
survivors.
With respect to religion, the religion, religious beliefs or
religious practices of a client should not be a relevant factor in
providing or denying services. Religious practices must not be imposed
upon victims. Dietary practices dictated by particular religious
beliefs may require some reasonable accommodation in cooking or feeding
arrangements for particular clients as practicable.
Prohibition Against Requiring Documentation for Eligibility
In paragraph (b), we propose a prohibition against requiring
documentation for eligibility. Battered immigrants face unique
challenges accessing services and often face conflicting eligibility
requirements in FVPSA-funded programs as noted at https://www.hhs.gov/ocr/civilrights/resources/specialtopics/origin/domesticviolencefactsheet.html. Pursuant to HHS guidance originally
published in 2001 and updated in August, 2012, recipients of Federal
financial assistance must ensure that their programs and activities
normally provided in English are accessible to Limited English
Proficient persons and do not discriminate on the basis of national
origin in violation of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (see
also Sec. 1370.3, Executive Order 13166). Battered immigrant victims
and survivors of domestic violence must not face additional burdens to
accessing FVPSA-funded services when they often lack knowledge of, or
receive misinformation, of U.S. laws. They also are often isolated from
family and community and face significant employment and economic
challenges. Programs must ensure that battered immigrants, for example,
are not required to provide documentation because FVPSA has no
immigration restrictions and its services do not qualify as a Federal
public benefit pursuant to the Personal Responsibility and Work
Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996,'' Public Law 104-193 (August
22, 1996), as amended by the ``Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant
Responsibility Act of 1996,'' Public Law 104-208 (September 30, 1996).
Other FVPSA Programmatic Accessibility Guidance
Human trafficking often simultaneously occurs in the context of
intimate relationships between perpetrators of trafficking/domestic/
intimate partner violence and those who are victimized by such crimes.
In the spirit of the Federal Strategic Action Plan on Services for
Victims of Human Trafficking in the United States 2013-2017, FVPSA-
funded programs are strongly encouraged to safely screen for and
identify victims of human trafficking who are also victims or survivors
of intimate partner/domestic violence and provide services that support
their unique needs. FVPSA services can also support trafficked victims
who are not experiencing domestic or intimate partner violence as long
as victims and survivors of domestic/intimate partner violence are
prioritized first by FVPSA grantees.
Additionally, covered entities should be aware of additional non-
discrimination grant conditions that may be applicable under the
Violence Against Women Reauthorization Act of 2013. For more
information on these requirements, please see the Department of
Justice's April 2014 document, ``Frequently Asked Questions:
Nondiscrimination Grant Conditions in the Violence Against Women
Reauthorization Act of 2013,''April 2014, available at: https://
[[Page 61899]]
www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/ovw/legacy/2014/06/20/faqs-ngc-
vawa.pdf.
Voluntary Services
This new section also contains proposed language in paragraph (c)
from FVPSA (section 308(d)) prohibiting grantees or subgrantees either
from imposing any conditions on the receipt of emergency shelter, or
from requiring the acceptance of supportive services. All such services
must be voluntarily accepted by program participants. The prohibition
on imposing ``conditions'' is intended to prohibit shelters from
applying inappropriate screening mechanisms, such as criminal
background checks or sobriety requirements. Similarly, the receipt of
shelter should not be conditioned on participation in other services,
such as counseling, parenting classes, or life-skills classes. We do
not intend these provisions to preempt State law, in any case where a
State may impose some legal requirement to protect the safety and
welfare of all shelter residents. In the case of an apparent conflict
with State or Federal laws, case-by-case determinations will be made.
In general, when two or more laws apply, a grantee must meet the
highest standard in any of those laws. Nor are these provisions
intended to deny a shelter the ability to manage its services and
secure the safety of all shelter residents should, for example, a
client become violent or abusive to other clients. We welcome comments
on this provision.
Enforcement
OCR is charged with enforcing the prohibitions against
discrimination on the basis of sex and religion in FVSPA. We note that
under Federal civil rights laws administered by the Department, OCR
uses a variety of techniques, including conducting investigations,
negotiating agreements with covered entities, and issuing violation
letters of findings where warranted, to enforce applicable civil rights
laws, with the aim of achieving voluntary compliance. We would expect
that similar practices will be used for investigating any complaints
made under these proposed requirements.
For situations that fall outside of the authority of OCR, we intend
to handle exceptional situations, in cases where service providers
cannot directly and easily solve the problem, through informal guidance
and, as appropriate, case-specific advice. FVPSA does provide, however,
for more severe remedies including withholding FVPSA grant awards until
the problem is resolved or denying future Federal funding. We also
would expect to use National/Special Issue Resource Centers and
Culturally-Specific Special Issue Resource Centers, State Domestic
Violence Coalitions, and Training and Technical Assistance Grants to
provide advice to service providers on dealing with any patterns of
problems that may emerge. We welcome comments on these proposals.
Section 1370.6 What requirements for reports and evaluations apply to
these programs?
We propose to add to new Subpart A a new section (Sec. 1370.6)
explicitly requiring any recipient of grants or contracts under the
FVPSA to provide performance reports to the Secretary. Such reports are
already required and the proposed regulatory text merely confirms the
important role they play in evaluating grantee performance. In order to
clarify requirements that have been questioned in the past, we propose
to require that American Samoa, the Commonwealth of the Northern
Mariana Islands, Guam, and the U.S. Virgin Islands follow all reporting
requirements applicable to the States and Tribes, Puerto Rico, and the
District of Columbia and to provide required reports directly to the
Division of Family Violence Prevention and Services within FYSB, unless
otherwise communicated to the grantees. These requirements supplement,
and do not replace the Territorial reporting requirements of the ACF
Office of Community Services in its administration of Consolidated
Block Grants as part of the Social Services Block Grants program.
Subpart B--State and Indian Tribal Grants
Section 1370.10 What additional requirements apply to State and Indian
Tribal grants?
The existing rule at Sec. 1370.2 contains a brief paragraph
stating that State and Tribal grantees ``must meet the statutory
requirements of the Act and all applicable regulations.'' We propose to
add a new Subpart B addressing the formula grants awarded to States and
Tribes. Under Subpart B, we propose to add Sec. 1370.10 which would
include the most important requirements applicable to these formula
grants. These proposals track the statute. However, they do not contain
all of the specific detail of FVPSA, but simply describe the basic
purposes, procedures, and activities that are expected for State and
Tribal grantees, respectively. They also describe the information
expected in grant applications. Because there are important differences
between State and Tribal grants, we have described them separately.
Importantly, these proposed provisions focus on planning,
consultation, and coordinating activities that we expect of these
grantees and which are statutory priorities in FVPSA Sections 10407,
10408, and 10409. They focus on protection, and require documentation
of the law or procedures (typically restraining orders or orders of
protection) by which the State or Tribe has implemented for the
eviction of an abusive spouse or intimate partner from a shared
household. In addition to the FVPSA requirement we propose to require
that such procedures must include not only family violence, but also
domestic or dating violence, an expansion of scope met by most but not
all existing State statutes. In order to allow States time to modify
existing statutes, we propose that the effective date for this
provision be two legislative sessions after these proposed rules are
made final (all other provisions would be effective sixty days after
issuance of the final rule.) As currently indicated in the Funding
Opportunity Announcements we also propose to specifically require
documentation of policies and procedures to ensure the confidentiality
of client records. Finally, these provisions provide for the use of the
Funding Opportunity Announcements and other program guidance to provide
additional details and procedures that apply to these grants. We
welcome comments on these proposed provisions.
In paragraph (a), consistent with FVPSA, we propose requiring that
States consult with and provide for the participation of Coalitions in
the planning and monitoring of the distribution and administration of
subgrant programs and projects; active Coalition participation is
envisioned in these processes. States and Coalitions have complementary
roles within the FVPSA framework because States use FVPSA funds to
support programs and projects often carried out by a significant
portion of the memberships of Coalitions. Coalitions' FVPSA-mandated
roles include training and technical assistance that frequently mirror
the support needed to effectively manage FVPSA-funded programs and
services as found in FVPSA Section 10408. States, by virtue of their
roles as funders, must both ensure that subgrantees comply with Federal
laws, regulations and guidance as well as promote programming that
effectively supports the safety, security and social and emotional
well-being of victims and their dependents; Funding Opportunity
Announcements have for several years
[[Page 61900]]
identified these requirements. To support the requirements in FVPSA
Section 10407(a)(2)(D) Coalitions are critical to supporting States'
roles as funders and must effectively participate in subgrantee award
processes and States' planning processes to fully understand States'
expectations and subgrantee requirements. At a minimum to further FVPSA
requirements, we expect that States and Coalitions will work together
to determine grant priorities based upon jointly identified needs; to
identify strategies to address needs; to define mutual expectations
regarding programmatic performance and monitoring; and to implement an
annual collaboration plan that incorporates concrete steps for
accomplishing these tasks. All of these requirements are either found
in the Funding Opportunity Announcements dating back to FVPSA
reauthorization in 2010 or have been discussed in grantee meetings and
other informal communications via FYSB listservs. We welcome comments
on these requirements.
The FVPSA includes Tribes in these proposed processes but this rule
is not intended to encroach upon Tribal sovereignty. We, however,
envision similar processes for Tribes, States, and Coalitions that
support coordination and collaboration when feasible and appropriate.
We especially welcome comments from Tribes and Coalitions about this
provision.
Pursuant to FVPSA Section 10411, one role of Coalitions is to
identify statewide gaps in services and the most effective way to meet
identified gaps and other problems is by conducting needs assessments.
We propose that States and Coalitions must work closely to undertake
joint planning so that funding is leveraged successfully to implement
FVPSA requirements in Sections 10407 and 10411. We also propose that
Tribal and other underserved populations are invited and encouraged to
participate in State planning and Coalition needs assessments. It is
essential that the full spectrum of domestic violence service
providers, including Tribes, Tribal organizations and other culturally-
specific, community-based organizations have significant input into
decision-making processes that support State planning and Coalition
needs assessments as found in FVPSA Sections 10407, 10408, and 10411.
So that States are continually aware of subgrantees' training and
technical assistance needs as well as intersecting systems challenges
impacting service provision, they must involve Coalitions in program
planning and subgrantee monitoring. We expect that States and
Coalitions will meet regularly to coordinate training and technical
assistance; to address ongoing programmatic challenges; and to
implement best practices in victim services. We encourage pre- and
post-award meetings to substantively address and respond to States'
identified priorities; to assess systems and programmatic impacts as a
result of States' priorities and funding decisions; and to assess
subgrantee performance. We propose these additional requirements to
complement those in FVPSA. We invite public comment on these areas.
FVPSA also requires that States and Tribes involve community-based
organizations that primarily serve culturally-specific, underserved
communities and determine how such organizations can assist the States
and Tribes in serving the needs of all communities. To fulfill these
obligations, we expect and propose that States and Tribes will
encourage the participation of underserved communities, including older
individuals and those with disabilities, in planning. If States and
Tribes use special councils, committees or other mechanisms to
accomplish planning, we also propose that they identify and invite
underserved, culturally specific organizations and/or community
representatives to participate in these bodies to fully embrace both
specific FVPSA-requirements (sections 10407, 10408, and 10409) and the
spirit of the law. Emphasis also should be placed on building the
capacity of culturally specific organizations to assist in both
providing services and in identifying the needs of underserved
populations. We envision that States will involve Coalitions in this
planning as they routinely engage in community organizing and partner
with organizations that support both the identification and leadership
of underserved communities. We invite Tribes to partner with Coalitions
to help in this capacity as well. We encourage public comment and
advice on what mechanisms States and Tribes might use to accomplish
these purposes, to describe any successful models they have identified
to achieve these purposes, and to advise us on how best accomplish
these goals. We particularly seek input from Tribes on how best to
address underserved communities within the Tribe, and what types of
processes would be helpful. Tribes are themselves considered
underserved, culturally specific communities, and we do not interpret
FVPSA as infringing upon Tribal sovereignty or as intending to create
burdensome or meaningless requirements on the Tribes.
Additionally, in paragraph (a), to complement FVPSA requirements to
build capacity in culturally-specific organizations, we expect that
specialized services will be available to support the specific needs of
their communities. While traditional/mainstream FVPSA-funded programs
are generally accessible to all people in compliance with Federal,
State, and local law, unique expertise regarding the needs of
underserved and historically marginalized populations lies within those
communities. We propose to require States, in their funding processes,
to address the needs of underserved, racial and ethnic minorities
including Tribal populations, and people with disabilities and their
families, with an emphasis on funding organizations that can meet
unique needs including culturally relevant and linguistically
appropriate services. These requirements have both been addressed in
the Funding Opportunity Announcements as well as grantee meetings
within the last 5 years. Jointly using multiple Federal and State
funding streams may accomplish these purposes and we expect that States
will make significant efforts to create awareness of FVPSA funding for
culturally-specific communities and Tribes, including training and
technical assistance that supports organizations serving those
communities in the FVPSA application and grant award processes. FVPSA
funding is not intended to just support traditionally-funded
organizations. However, it is intended to support core shelter and
supportive services (see FVPSA section 10401). It is not the intent of
these regulations to change this important priority. The needs of
culturally specific organizations and communities, including Tribes,
are not, however, mutually exclusive from the need for core services;
they are complementary. Moreover, providing truly accessible services
to culturally-specific communities often means that the leadership,
management and staff of FVPSA funded, subgrantee programs should
reflect the diversity of the populations seeking services, including
people with disabilities and their families, and other underserved
populations. We therefore propose, pursuant to FVPSA Sections 10407 and
10408, that States take steps to address these priorities and
specifically describe them in their annual applications. Partnering
with Coalitions and culturally-specific community based
[[Page 61901]]
organizations in these areas is especially critical. Public comment is
welcome on these issues.
State Applications
Requirements for applications made by States are outlined under
proposed 1370.10 section (b). As required in FVPSA Section 10407(a)(1),
a State application must be submitted by the Chief Executive of the
State and signed by the Chief Executive Officer or the Chief Program
Official designated as responsible for the administration of FVPSA.
Under paragraph (b)(1), and as indicated in the Funding Opportunity
Announcements as well as to fulfill FVPSA requirements, we propose that
the State application include the name of the State agency, the name
and contact information for the Chief Program Official designated as
responsible for the administration of funds under FVPSA and
coordination of related programs within the State, and the name and
contact information for a contact person if different from the Chief
Program Official.
Under proposed paragraph (b)(2), pursuant to the Funding
Opportunity Announcements and to fulfill FVPSA requirements, the State
application must include a plan describing in detail how the needs of
underserved populations will be met. This includes, under proposed
paragraph (b)(2)(i), identification of which populations in the State
are underserved, a description of those that are being targeted for
outreach and services, and a brief explanation of why those populations
were selected to receive outreach and services. As States undertake the
process of identifying underserved, culturally-specific communities in
their respective State, we expect that they will consult data generated
from Federal and State census counts as well as other demographic
information. Information on specific details will be provided in FOAs
and other guidance. In addition, this paragraph includes a requirement
regarding how often the State revisits the identification and selection
of the populations to be served with FVPSA funding (not to exceed three
years). For example, we propose that at least every three years States
must identify population shifts or changes to assist in meaningful
delivery of culturally-specific services and the involvement of
potential new planning partners or explain why these steps are
unnecessary. State applications must document this process. We strongly
encourage that State plans be reassessed on a triennial basis or that
an explanation be included in the State's application regarding why
reassessment is unnecessary. These requirements are proposed to fulfill
FVPSA and the Funding Opportunity Announcements to support the
provision of services to underserved populations. We welcome comments
on these provisions.
Under proposed paragraph (b)(2)(ii), we also propose in order to
fulfill FVPSA requirements and those found in the Funding Opportunity
Announcements that the State application's plan describing how the
needs of underserved populations will be met include a description of
the outreach plan, including the domestic violence training to be
provided, the means for providing technical assistance and support, and
the leadership role played by those representing and serving the
underserved populations in question.
Under proposed paragraph (b)(2)(iii), we also include a requirement
for a description of the specific services to be provided or enhanced,
such as new shelters or services, improved access to shelters or
services, or new services for underserved populations, as defined in
this NPRM Section 1370.2, such as victims from communities of color,
immigrant victims, victims with disabilities, or older individuals.
This proposed requirement is intended to fulfill FVPSA requirements and
reflect provisions in the Funding Opportunity Announcements.
Finally, under proposed paragraph (b)(2)(iv) to fulfill FVPSA
requirements and those found in the Funding Opportunity Announcements,
we propose that the State application's plan describing how the needs
of underserved populations will be met include a description of the
public information component of the State's outreach program, including
the elements of the program that are used to explain domestic violence,
the most effective and safe ways to seek help, and tools to identify
available resources.
In subsection 1370.10(b)(3), we propose to fulfill FVPSA
requirements and the provisions in the Funding Opportunity
Announcements that each State application contain a description of the
process and procedures used to involve the State Domestic Violence
Coalition, knowledgeable individuals, and interested organizations,
including those serving or representing underserved communities in the
State planning process.
In paragraph (4) of this subsection, we propose to fulfill FVPSA
requirements and those found in the Funding Opportunity Announcements
by requiring that each State application contain documentation of
planning, consultation with and participation of the State Domestic
Violence Coalition in the administration and distribution of FVPSA
programs, projects, and grant funds awarded to the State.
In paragraph (5) pursuant to FVPSA Section 10407(a)(2)(c) we
propose that a description of the procedures used to assure an
equitable distribution of grants and grant funds within the State and
between urban and rural areas, as defined by the Census Bureau, within
the State. The U.S. Census Bureau (USCB) defines (and FYSB defers to
and incorporates this definition) two types of ``urban'' areas: (1)
Urbanized areas of 50,000 or more people; and (2) ``urban clusters'' of
at least 2,500 and less than 50,000 people. The USCB explains that
``rural'' encompasses all population, housing, and territory not
included within an ``urban'' area as ``rural''. The plan should
describe how funding allocations will address the needs of underserved
communities. Other Federal, State, local, and private funds may be
considered in determining compliance. We also propose to require
States, in their funding processes, to address the needs of
underserved, racial and ethnic minorities including Tribal populations,
and people with disabilities and their families, with an emphasis on
funding organizations that can meet unique needs including culturally
relevant and linguistically appropriate services.
In paragraph (6) we propose in order to fulfill FVPSA requirements
that a State's application include: A description of how the State
plans to use the grant funds including a State plan developed in
consultation with State and Tribal Domestic Violence Coalitions and
representatives of underserved and culturally specific communities; a
description of the target populations; of the number of shelters to be
funded; of the number of non-residential programs to be funded; of the
services the State will provide; and of the expected results from the
use of the grant funds. To fulfill these requirements, it is critically
important that States work with Coalitions and Tribes to solicit their
feedback on program effectiveness which may include recommendations
such as establishing program standards and participating in program
monitoring.
In paragraph (7) we propose pursuant to FVPSA Section
10407(a)(2)(H) to require that State applications include a copy of the
law or procedures, such as a process for obtaining an order of
protection that the State has implemented for the eviction of an
abusive spouse or other intimate,
[[Page 61902]]
domestic, or dating partner from a shared household or residence.
In paragraph (8) we propose pursuant to FVPSA Section 10408(b)(2)
to require that State applications include an assurance that not less
than 70 percent of the funds distributed by a State to sub-recipients
shall be distributed to entities for the primary purpose of providing
immediate shelter and supportive services to adult and youth victims of
family violence, domestic violence, or dating violence, and their
dependents, and that not less than 25 percent of the funds distributed
by a State to sub-recipients shall be distributed to entities for the
purpose of providing supportive services and prevention services (these
percentages may overlap with respect to supportive services but are not
included in the 5 percent cap applicable to State administrative
costs). No grant shall be made under this section to an entity other
than a State unless the entity agrees that, with respect to the costs
to be incurred by the entity in carrying out the program or project for
which the grant is awarded, the entity will make available (directly or
through donations from public or private entities) non-Federal
contributions in an amount that is not less than $1 for every $5 of
Federal funds provided under the grant. The non-Federal contributions
required under this paragraph may be in cash or in kind.
In paragraph (9) pursuant to FVPSA Section 10406(c)(5) we propose
requiring that State applications include documentation of policies,
procedures and protocols that ensure individual identifiers of client
records will not be used when providing statistical data on program
activities and program services or in the course of grant monitoring,
that the confidentiality of records pertaining to any individual
provided family violence prevention or intervention services by any
program or entity supported under the FVPSA will be strictly
maintained, and the address or location of any shelter supported under
the FVPSA will not be made public without the written authorization of
the person or persons responsible for the operation of such shelter.
Our final proposed requirement, in paragraph (10), would require
that State applications include additional agreements, assurances, and
information, in such form, and submitted in such manner as the Funding
Opportunity Announcement and related program guidance prescribe.
State Coalitions and Tribal Coalitions are specifically designated
statutory participants pursuant to FVPSA Section10407(b)(3) in
determining whether State grantees and subgrantees are fulfilling the
goals and activities in their respective State applications/plans and
complying with FVPSA grant conditions. To fulfill these requirements,
it is critically important that States work with Coalitions and Tribes
to solicit their feedback on program effectiveness which may include
recommendations such as establishing program standards and
participating in program monitoring. Public comment is invited on the
best way to fulfill these statutory requirements.
Tribal Applications
Finally, we note that there are some proposed regulatory provisions
that are specific to Tribes and we have outlined these in proposed
Sec. 1370.10(c). In paragraph (c), we propose that that the
application from a Tribe or Tribal Organization be signed by a Tribally
Designated Official, such as the Tribal Chairperson or Chief Executive
Officer, as required in FVPSA Section 10410 and applicable Funding
Opportunity Announcements. We also propose in paragraph (c)(1) to
require that applications from Tribal Consortia or other joint Tribal
applications include a copy of a current Tribal resolution or an
equivalent document that verifies Tribal approval of the application
being submitted as also required in the Funding Opportunity
Announcements. We propose that the resolution or other document should
state that the designated organization or agency has the authority to
submit an application on behalf of the individuals in the Tribe(s) and
to administer programs and activities funded pursuant to the FVPSA. We
also propose that the resolution or equivalent document must specify
the name(s) of each Tribe and, if Tribal resolutions are the vehicles
to support applications from Tribal Consortia or other joint Tribal
applications, that a representative of each Tribe signs the resolution.
We also propose to require that the service areas proposed by Tribes in
their applications, be specifically delineated.
In proposed paragraph (c)(2) we propose as indicated in the Funding
Opportunity Announcements requiring that each Tribal application also
contain a description of the procedures designed to involve
knowledgeable individuals and interested organizations in providing
services under the FVPSA. For example, knowledgeable individuals and
interested organizations may include Tribal officials or social
services staff involved in child abuse or family violence prevention,
Tribal law enforcement officials, representatives of Tribal or State
Domestic Violence Coalitions, and operators of domestic violence
shelters and service programs.
Proposed paragraph (c)(3) requires that Tribal applications
pursuant to the current Funding Opportunity Announcement also include a
description of the applicant's operation of and/or capacity to carry
out a family violence prevention and services program. Ways this
information can be demonstrated include evidence of: (i) The current
operation of a shelter, safe house, or domestic violence prevention
program; (ii) the establishment of joint or collaborative service
agreements with a local public agency or a private, non-profit agency
for the operation of family violence prevention and intervention
activities or services; or (iii) the operation of social services
programs as evidenced by receipt of grants or contracts awarded under
Indian Child Welfare grants from the Bureau of Indian Affairs; Child
Welfare Services grants under Title IV-B of the Social Security Act; or
Family Preservation and Family Support grants under Title IV-B of the
Social Security Act.
Proposed paragraph (c)(4), pursuant to the current Funding
Opportunity Announcement, would require Tribal applications to include
a description of the services to be provided, how the applicant
organizations plans to use the grant funds to provide the direct
services, to whom the services will be provided, and the expected
results of the services.
Proposed paragraph (c)(5) pursuant to FVPSA Section 10407(a)(2)(H)
would require Tribal applications to include documentation of the law
or procedure which has been implemented for the eviction of an abusing
spouse or other intimate, domestic, or dating partner from a shared
household or residence.
Proposed paragraph (c)(6) pursuant to FVPSA Section 10406(c)(5)
would require Tribal applications to include documentation of the
policies and procedures developed and implemented, including copies of
the policies and procedures, to ensure that individual identifiers of
client records will not be used when providing statistical data on
program activities and program services or in the course of grant
monitoring and that the confidentiality of records pertaining to any
individual provided domestic violence prevention or intervention
services by any FVPSA-supported program will be strictly maintained. If
a FVPSA grantee or subgrantee fails to comply with these requirements,
additional programmatic support and technical assistance will be
provided by the FYSB program staff and FVPSA-
[[Page 61903]]
funded technical assistance providers to avoid an interruption or
defunding. As identified in section 1370.4, Tribes often have
significant confidentiality challenges due to geographic isolation and,
therefore, we welcome comments from Tribes on this section.
The final requirement for Tribal applications, proposed paragraph
(c)(7), would require such applications to include agreements,
assurances, and information, in such form, and submitted in such
manner, as the Funding Opportunity Announcement and related program
guidance prescribe.
We do not believe that these provisions impose any additional
burden on Tribes, but welcome comments.
Subpart C--State Domestic Violence Coalition Grants
Section 1370.20 What additional requirements apply to State Domestic
Violence Coalitions?
The current rule, in Sec. 1370.3, contains provisions for
Coalition Grants. Each State and Territory has a domestic violence
Coalition that receives FVPSA funding as the HHS-designated statewide
domestic violence Coalition. These Coalitions provide an essential role
in the domestic violence field, and only one per State can be funded
under the FVPSA. We propose to add Sec. 1370.20 under new Subpart C.
Our proposed provisions focus in more detail than the current rule on
the planning, consultation, and coordinating activities than the
statute now expects of these grantees. In particular, in paragraph
(b)(1), pursuant to FVPSA we propose to require that membership include
representatives of a majority of the primary-purpose domestic violence
service providers operating within the State or Territory (see the
proposed definition of primary-purpose discussed earlier in this
preamble). In paragraph (b)(2) we propose that Coalitions' Boards of
Directors also must be representative of the membership comprised of
the primary-purpose domestic violence service providers in their
respective States and Territories and also may include community
members. Boards of Directors composed of member representatives and
community members are highly encouraged so that Coalition boards have
the cross-sector expertise to ensure Coalitions have strong
organizational infrastructures, including Boards of Directors that
support the long-term programmatic and financial sustainability of
Coalitions. Financial sustainability of Coalitions, as independent,
autonomous non-profit organizations, also must be supported by their
membership comprised of the primary-purpose domestic violence service
providers in the respective States and Territories, including those
member representatives on the Coalitions' Boards of Directors.
Coalitions' financial sustainability also is critical to the
programmatic and fiscal success of their members and these priorities
should not be interpreted to conflict with the same or complimentary
priorities of their domestic violence service provider member
constituents.
State and Territorial Domestic Violence Coalitions play a unique
role in assisting Federal, State and local governments, victim service
providers, including Tribes and Tribal organizations, and the private
sector in coordinating and developing policies and procedures,
conducting outreach and public awareness, and providing training and
technical assistance. We, therefore, propose in section (c) that
Coalitions demonstrate in the annual application their competencies in
provision of programming and other functions necessary under FVPSA (42
U.S.C. 10402(11) and 10411). Coalitions also would be required to
collaborate with Indian Tribes and Tribal organizations (and
corresponding Alaska Native and Native Hawaiian groups or communities)
to address the needs of American Indian, Alaska Native, and Native
Hawaiian victims of family violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence, if such Tribes and organizations exist within a given State
and are willing to work with the Coalition. It is, therefore,
especially important that Coalitions include Tribes and Tribal
organizations in their membership structures where possible.
As outlined in proposed (c)(1)(i)-(viii), Coalitions also are
required to have demonstrated capacity to coordinate with multiple
systems to encourage appropriate and comprehensive responses that
promote the support and safety needs of adult and youth victims of
family, domestic, or dating violence. Demonstrated capacity may include
but is not limited to: Identifying successful efforts that support
child welfare agencies' identification and support of victims during
intake processes; creation of membership standards that enhance victim
safety and fully require training and technical assistance for
compliance with federal housing, disability, and sex discrimination
laws and regulations; and, training judicial personnel on trauma-
informed courtroom practice. Such systems include but are not limited
to: Public and mental health; law enforcement; courts/judiciary; child
protective services, to include custody and visitation issues impacting
victims within child welfare systems; protection and advocacy systems;
housing; social welfare; private enterprise; and, aging and disability
systems to develop appropriate responses for older individuals and
individuals with disabilities. Under proposed paragraph (c)(1),
Coalitions also must, in the annual applications for funding, have
documented experience in administering Federal grants supporting these
programmatic areas or have a documented history of active participation
in the respective statutory program areas enunciated in 42 U.S.C.
10411(c)(1) and (2)(A) and (B). If a Coalition receives VAWA STOP
(Services, Training, Officers, Prosecutors grant program--42 U.S.C.
3796gg(c)(1)) funding for Coalitions and utilizes that funding for
programming and activities to address domestic violence and law
enforcement, the courts/judiciary, and/or child protective services,
including child custody and visitation in child welfare cases, it does
not have to spend FVPSA funds on these activities. Instead, in its
annual application, it must provide an annual assurance that such
activities are conducted with VAWA STOP Coalition funding and such
activities must be described in the application.
Under proposed paragraph (d), we outline that nothing in this
section limits the ability of a Coalition to use non-Federal or other
Federal funding sources to conduct required functions, provided that if
the Coalition uses funds received under section 2001(c)(1) of the
Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets Act of 1968 to perform the
functions described in subsections (2)(iv) and (v) in lieu of funds
provided under the FVPSA, it shall provide an annual assurance to the
Secretary that it is using such funds, and that it is coordinating the
activities conducted under this section with those of the State's
activities under Part T of title I of the Omnibus Crime Control and
Safe Streets Act of 1968.
Coalition Designation
In paragraph (e) we propose that in cases in which two or more
organizations seek designation, the designation of each State's and
Territory's individual Coalition is within the exclusive discretion of
HHS. The Department will determine which applicant best fits statutory
criteria, with particular attention paid to the applicant's documented
history of effective work, support of primary-purpose programs and
programs that
[[Page 61904]]
serve racial and ethnic minority populations and underserved
populations (including but not limited to those representing older
individuals and people with disabilities, LGBTQ populations, and the
Limited English Proficient), coordination and collaboration with the
State or Territorial government, and capacity to accomplish the FVPSA
mandated role of a Coalition. As of the publication of this rule,
Coalitions for all 56 State and Territorial Coalitions have been HHS
designated.
In paragraph (f), we propose that if a Coalition becomes
financially insolvent, ceases to represent the majority of primary
purpose programs, is disbarred from receiving Federal funding, or can
no longer meet the statutory requirements of the FVPSA despite
technical assistance provided, the Department may reopen the
application process for that State's Coalition designation. Because
Coalitions are intended to effectively represent diverse victims and
service providers in their States, HHS would engage with domestic
violence service providers and State leaders to inform their decision
about which alternative organizations could be considered eligible.
As described in Subpart B, we propose that Coalitions be required
to identify gaps in services and the most effective ways to meet
identified gaps and other problems. We also propose that Coalitions
participate in planning and monitoring of the distribution of subgrants
within the States and in the administration of grant programs and
projects. In conducting needs assessments, we propose to require that
Coalitions and States work in partnership on the statutorily required
FVPSA State planning process to involve representatives from
underserved and racial and ethnic minority populations to plan, assess,
and voice the needs of the communities they represent. Coalitions are
expected to assist States in identifying underrepresented communities
and culturally-specific community based organizations in State planning
and to work with States to unify planning and needs assessment efforts
so that comprehensive and culturally-specific services are provided. We
also propose through the inclusion of the populations targeted to place
emphasis on building the capacity of culturally-specific services and
programs.
Subpart D--Discretionary Grants and Contracts
The existing rule contains brief paragraphs on two types of
discretionary grants (information and technical assistance and public
information campaign grants), in Sec. 1370.4, and Sec. 1370.5. We
propose to add a new Subpart D covering all discretionary grants and
contracts. This new subpart would address separately National Resource
Centers and Training and Technical Assistance Grants (Sec. 1370.30),
grants for State resource centers to reduce disparities in domestic
violence in States with high proportions of American Indian (including
Alaska Native) or Native Hawaiian population (Sec. 1370.30), grants
for specialized services for abused parents and their children (Sec.
1370.31), and the National Domestic Violence Hotline (Sec. 1370.32).
These new sections primarily reflect statutory requirements, the
evolution of the program and the focus of FVPSA.
These proposed provisions also focus on the unique planning,
consultation, and coordinating activities that we expect of each type
of grantee. Finally, these provisions provide for the use of the
Funding Opportunity Announcements and other program guidance to provide
additional details and procedures that apply to these grants. We
welcome comments on these provisions.
We propose adding a new heading to be titled ``Subpart D--
Discretionary Grants and Contracts''.
Section 1370.30 What National Resource Centers and Training and
Technical Assistance grant programs are available and what requirements
apply?
We propose to add Sec. 1370.30 to Subpart D. National Resource
Centers and Training and Technical Assistance Center grants, pursuant
to FVPSA Section 10410, are to provide resource information, training,
and technical assistance to improve the capacity of individuals,
organizations, governmental entities, and communities to prevent family
violence, domestic violence, and dating violence and to provide
effective intervention services. They fund national, special issue, and
culturally-specific resource centers addressing key areas of domestic
violence intervention and prevention, and may include State resource
centers to reduce disparities in domestic violence in States with high
proportions of Native American (including Alaska Native or Native
Hawaiian) populations and to support training and technical assistance
that address emerging issues related to family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence, to entities demonstrating expertise in
these areas. Grants may be made for five specific grants.
The first is the National Resource Center on Domestic Violence
which offers a comprehensive array of technical assistance and training
resources to Federal, State, and local governmental agencies, domestic
violence service providers, community-based organizations, and other
professionals and interested parties, related to domestic violence
service programs and research, including programs and research related
to victims and their children who are exposed to domestic violence as
well as older individuals and those with disabilities. The grantee also
will maintain a central resource library in order to collect, prepare,
analyze, and disseminate information and statistics related to the
incidence and prevention of family violence and domestic violence; and
the provision of shelter, supportive services, and prevention services
to adult and youth victims of domestic violence, including older
individuals and those with disabilities (including services to prevent
repeated incidents of violence).
The second grant is for a National Indian Resource Center
Addressing Domestic Violence and Safety for Indian Women which offers a
comprehensive array of technical assistance and training resources to
Indian Tribes and Tribal organizations, specifically designed to
enhance the capacity of the Tribes and Tribal organizations to respond
to domestic violence and increase the safety of Indian women. The
grantee also will enhance the intervention and prevention efforts of
Indian Tribes and Tribal organizations to respond to domestic violence
and increase the safety of Indian women, and coordinate activities with
other Federal agencies, offices, and grantees that address the needs of
American Indians, Alaska Natives, and Native Hawaiians that experience
domestic violence.
The third grant is for special issue resource centers to provide
national information, training, and technical assistance to State and
local domestic violence service providers. Each special issue resource
center shall focus on enhancing domestic violence intervention and
prevention efforts in at least one of the following areas: (1) Response
of the criminal and civil justice systems to domestic violence victims,
which may include the response to the use of the self-defense plea by
domestic violence victims and the issuance and use of protective
orders; (2) response of child protective service agencies to victims of
domestic violence and their dependents and child custody issues in
domestic violence cases; (3) response of the
[[Page 61905]]
interdisciplinary health care system to victims of domestic violence
and access to health care resources for victims of domestic violence;
(4) response of mental health systems, domestic violence service
programs, and other related systems and programs to victims of domestic
violence and to their children who are exposed to domestic violence.
The fourth grant is for Culturally-Specific Special Issue Resource
Centers that enhance domestic violence intervention and prevention
efforts for victims of domestic violence who are members of racial and
ethnic minority groups; and will enhance the cultural and linguistic
relevancy of service delivery, resource utilization, policy, research,
technical assistance, community education, and prevention initiatives.
The fifth grant is for State resource centers to provide statewide
information, training, and technical assistance to Indian Tribes,
Tribal organizations, and local domestic violence service organizations
serving Native Americans (including Alaska Natives and Native
Hawaiians) in a culturally sensitive and relevant manner. These centers
shall: (1) Offer a comprehensive array of technical assistance and
training resources to Indian Tribes, Tribal organizations, and
providers of services to Native Americans (including Alaska Natives and
Native Hawaiians) specifically designed to enhance the capacity of the
Tribes, organizations, and providers to respond to domestic violence;
(2) coordinate all projects and activities with the National Indian
Resource Center Addressing Domestic Violence and Safety for Indian
Women, including projects and activities that involve working with
State and local governments to enhance their capacity to understand the
unique needs of Native Americans (including Alaska Natives and Native
Hawaiians); and (3) provide comprehensive community education and
domestic violence prevention initiatives in a culturally sensitive and
relevant manner. Eligibility for the State resource center grant
program is contingent upon being located in a State with high
proportions of Indian or Native Hawaiian populations. Eligible entities
shall be located in a State in which the population of Indians
(including Alaska Natives) and Native Hawaiians exceeds 10 percent of
the total population of the State; or, be an Indian Tribe, Tribal
organization or a Native Hawaiian organization that focuses primarily
on issues of domestic violence among Indians or Native Hawaiians; or,
be an institution of higher education; and, demonstrate the ability to
serve all regions of the State, including underdeveloped areas and
areas that are geographically distant from population centers.
Additionally, eligible entities shall offer training and technical
assistance and capacity-building resources in States where the
population of Indians (including Alaska Natives) and Native Hawaiians
exceeds 2.5 percent of the total population of the State.
Under section (f), we propose that other discretionary grants may
be awarded to support training and technical assistance that address
emerging issues related to family violence, domestic violence, or
dating violence, to entities demonstrating related experience.
Under section (g) we propose that, to receive a grant under any
part of this section, an entity shall submit an application that shall
meet such eligibility standards as are prescribed in the FVPSA and
contains such agreements, assurances, and information, in such form,
and submitted in such manner as the Funding Opportunity Announcement
and related program guidance prescribe.
Under section (h), we propose that all grant recipients should
create a plan to ensure effective communication and meaningful access
to domestic violence program services for victims of domestic violence
with Limited English Proficiency (LEP), which should include: How to
respond to individuals with LEP, and how to use appropriate
interpretation and translation services, including best practices for
using taglines. Taglines are short statements in non-English languages
informing persons with LEP how to access language assistance services;
how to respond to individuals with communication-related disabilities
and how to provide appropriate auxiliary aids and services, including
qualified interpreters and information in alternate formats, to people
with disabilities. The use of the term ``Limited English Proficient''
is not meant to be interpreted as a substitution for the statutory
language ``non-English'' speaking individuals but rather to be
consistent with HHS Office for Civil Rights guidance applicable to all
HHS-funded programs. Please see https://www.hhs.gov/ocr/civilrights/resources/specialtopics/lep/.
Section 1370.31 What additional requirements apply to grants for
specialized services for abused parents and their children?
We propose to add new Sec. 1370.31 to Subpart D. Consistent with
42 U.S.C. 10412, grants provided for specialized services for abused
parents and their children are intended to expand the capacity of
family violence, domestic violence, and dating violence service
programs and community-based programs to prevent future domestic
violence by addressing, in an appropriate manner, the needs of children
exposed to family violence, domestic violence, or dating violence. To
be eligible an entity must be a local agency, a nonprofit private
organization (including faith-based and charitable organizations,
community-based organizations, and voluntary associations), or a Tribal
organization, with a demonstrated record of serving victims of family
violence, domestic violence, or dating violence and their children.
Consistent with 42 U.S.C. 10412(c), in paragraph (b)(1) we propose
that, in order to be eligible to receive a grant under this section, an
entity shall submit an application that includes a complete description
of the applicant's plan for providing specialized services for abused
parents and their children. This should include descriptions of how the
entity will prioritize the safety of, and confidentiality of
information about victims of family violence, victims of domestic
violence, and victims of dating violence and their children. It also
should address how the entity will provide developmentally appropriate
and age-appropriate services, and culturally and linguistically
appropriate services, to the victims and children. Finally, it should
describe how the entity will ensure that professionals working with the
children receive the training and technical assistance appropriate and
relevant to the unique needs of children exposed to family violence,
domestic violence, or dating violence.
Consistent with 42 U.S.C. 10412(d), in paragraph (b)(2), we propose
that the application should demonstrate that the applicant has the
ability to provide direct counseling, appropriate services, and
advocacy on behalf of victims of family violence, domestic violence, or
dating violence and their children, including coordination with
services provided by the child welfare system.
In paragraph (b)(3), we propose that the application also should
demonstrate that the applicant can effectively provide services for
non-abusing parents
[[Page 61906]]
to support those parents' roles as caregivers and their roles in
responding to the social, emotional, and developmental needs of their
children.
Consistent with 42 U.S.C. 10412(d)(2), in paragraph (c) we propose
that eligible applicants may use funds under a grant pursuant to this
section that: (1) Demonstrates a capacity to provide early childhood
development and mental health services; (2) shows the ability to
coordinate activities with and provide technical assistance to
community-based organizations serving victims of family violence,
domestic violence, or dating violence or children exposed to family
violence, domestic violence, or dating violence; and (3) shows the
capacity to provide additional services and referrals to services for
children, including child care, transportation, educational support,
respite care, supervised visitation, or other necessary services.
Finally, in paragraph (c)(4), we propose that the application must
contain such agreements, assurances, and information, in such form, and
submitted in such manner as the Funding Opportunity Announcement and
related program guidance prescribe.
If Congressional appropriations in any fiscal year for the entirety
of programs covered by this proposed rule (exclusive of the National
Domestic Violence Hotline which receives a separate appropriation)
exceed $130 million, not less than 25 percent of such excess funds
shall be made available to carry out this grant program. If
appropriations reach this threshold, HHS will specify funding levels in
future Funding Opportunity Announcements.
Section 1370.32 What additional requirements apply to National Domestic
Violence Hotline grants?
We propose to add new Sec. 1370.32 to Subpart D. Consistent with
42 U.S.C. 10413, the National Domestic Hotline grants are for one or
more private entities to provide for the ongoing operation of a 24-
hour, national, toll-free telephone hotline to provide information and
assistance to adult and youth victims of family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence, family and household members of such
victims, and persons affected by the victimization.
We propose to add a definition of ``telephone'' as used in the
context of ``telephone hotline'' so that the term appropriately
reflects evolving technological advances impacting telephone usage and
the multiple ways in which telephone hotlines operate and are most
responsive to hotline callers or users. According to the Pew Research
Internet and American Life Project ``some 83% of American adults own
cell phones and three-quarters of them (73%) send and receive text
messages. Young adults are the most avid texters by a wide margin. Cell
owners between the ages of 18 and 24 exchange an average of 109.5
messages on a normal day--that works out to more than 3,200 texts per
month--and the typical or median cell owner in this age group sends or
receives 50 messages per day (or 1500 messages per month).'' We
therefore propose to add a definition of ``telephone'' as used in the
context of ``telephone hotline'' so that the term appropriately
reflects evolving technological advances impacting telephone usage and
the multiple ways in which telephone hotlines operate and are most
responsive to hotline callers or users. We propose ``telephone'' to be
defined as a communications device that permits two or more callers or
users to engage in transmitted analog, digital, short message service
(SMS), cellular/wireless, laser, cable/broadband, internet, voice-over
internet protocol (IP) or other communications, including telephone,
smartphone, chat, text, voice recognition, or other technological means
which connects callers or users together. The traditional analog
telephone may soon become outdated technology that does not provide
appropriate and safe services for callers or users, nor does it reflect
that users may not be ``calling'' telephone hotlines as traditionally
understood. As a result, current FVPSA language may prevent grantees
responsible for operating emerging or changing technologies that serve
victims of family, domestic, and dating violence from incorporating
cutting-edge software and hardware that simultaneously advance with
technology trends and user interfaces.
Under proposed paragraph (c), to be consistent with 42 U.S.C.
10413(d), we propose that in order to be eligible to receive a grant
under this section, an entity shall submit an application that includes
a complete description of the applicant's plan for the operation of a
national domestic violence hotline, including descriptions of:
(1) The training program for hotline personnel, including
technology training to ensure that all persons affiliated with the
hotline are able to effectively operate any technological systems used
by the hotline, and are familiar with effective communication and
meaningful access requirements, to ensure access for all, including
people who are Limited English Proficient and people with disabilities;
(2) the hiring criteria and qualifications for hotline personnel;
(3) the methods for the creation, maintenance, and updating of a
resource database;
(4) a plan for publicizing the availability of the hotline;
(5) a plan for providing service to Limited English Proficient
callers, including service through hotline personnel who are qualified
to interpret for Limited English Proficient individuals;
(6) a plan for facilitating access to the hotline by persons with
disabilities, including persons with hearing impairments; and
(7) a plan for providing assistance and referrals to youth victims
of domestic violence and for victims of dating violence who are minors,
which may be carried out through a national teen dating violence
hotline.
The application also must demonstrate:
(1) That the applicant has recognized expertise in the area of
family violence, domestic violence, or dating violence and a record of
high quality service to victims of family violence, domestic violence,
or dating violence, including a demonstration of support from advocacy
groups and State Domestic Violence Coalitions;
(2) that the applicant has the capacity and the expertise to
maintain a domestic violence hotline and a comprehensive database of
service providers;
(3) the applicants' ability to provide information and referrals
for callers, directly connect callers to service providers, and employ
crisis interventions meeting the standards of family violence, domestic
violence, and dating violence providers;
(4) that the applicant has a commitment to diversity and to the
provision of services to underserved populations, including to ethnic,
racial, and Limited English Proficient individuals, in addition to
older individuals and individuals with disabilities;
(5) that the applicant follows comprehensive quality assurance
practices.
Finally, the application must contain such agreements, information,
and assurances, including nondisclosure of confidential or personally
identifiable information, in such form, and submitted in such manner as
the Funding Opportunity Announcement and related program guidance
prescribe.
In accordance with 42 U.S.C. 10413(f), under section (d) we propose
that the entity receiving a grant under this section shall submit a
performance report to the Secretary at such time as reasonably required
by the Secretary that shall describe the activities that
[[Page 61907]]
have been carried out with grant funds, contain an evaluation of the
effectiveness of such activities, and provide additional information as
the Secretary may reasonably require.
VIII. Impact Analysis
Paperwork Reduction Act
This proposed rule contains no new information collection
requirements. There is an existing requirement for grantees to provide
performance progress reports under Office of Management and Budget
approval number 0970-0280. Grantees are also required to submit an
application and annual financial status report. Nothing in this
proposed rule would require changes in the current requirements, all of
which have been approved by the Office of Management and Budget under
the provisions of the Paperwork Reduction Act.
Regulatory Flexibility Act
The Secretary certifies under 5 U.S.C. 605(b), as enacted by the
Regulatory Flexibility Act (Pub. L. 96-354), that this proposed rule
will not result in a significant economic impact on a substantial
number of small entities. We have not proposed any new requirements
that would have such an effect. Our proposed standards would almost
entirely conform to the existing statutory requirements and existing
practices in the program. In particular, we have proposed imposing only
a few new processes, procedural, or documentation requirements that are
not encompassed within the existing rule, existing Funding Opportunity
Announcements, or existing information collection requirements. None of
these would impose consequential burdens on grantees. Accordingly, an
Initial Regulatory Flexibility Analysis is not required.
Regulatory Impact Analysis
Executive Order 12866 and 13563 require that regulations be drafted
to ensure that they are consistent with the priorities and principles
set forth in these Executive Orders, including imposing the least
burden on society, written in plain language and easy to understand,
and seeking to improve the actual results of regulatory requirements.
The Department has determined that this proposed rule is consistent
with these priorities and principles. The Executive Orders require a
Regulatory Impact Analysis for proposed or final rules with an annual
economic impact of $100 million or more. Nothing in this proposed rule
approaches effects of this magnitude. Nor does this proposed rule meet
any of the other criteria for significance under these Executive
Orders. This proposed rule has been reviewed by the Office of
Management and Budget.
Congressional Review
This proposed rule is not a major rule (economic effects of $100
million or more) as defined in the Congressional Review Act.
Federalism Review
Executive Order 13132, Federalism, requires that Federal agencies
consult with State and local government officials in the development of
regulatory policies with Federalism implications. This proposed rule
will not have substantial direct impact on the States, on the
relationship between the Federal government and the States, or on the
distribution of power and responsibilities among the various levels of
government. Therefore, in accordance with the Executive Order we have
determined that this proposed rule does not have sufficient Federalism
implications to warrant the preparation of a Federalism summary impact
statement.
Family Impact Review
Section 654 of the Treasury and General Government Appropriations
Act of 1999 (Pub. L. 105-277) requires Federal agencies to issue a
Family Policymaking Assessment for any rule that may affect family
well-being. This proposed rule would not have any new or adverse impact
on the autonomy or integrity of the family as an institution. Like the
existing rule and existing program practices, it directly supports
family well-being. Since we propose no changes that would affect this
policy priority, we have concluded that it is not necessary to prepare
a Family Policymaking Assessment.
List of Subjects in 45 CFR 1370
Administrative practice and procedure, Domestic violence, Grant
Programs--Social Programs, Reporting and recordkeeping requirements,
Technical assistance.
(Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance Program Numbers 93.671
Family Violence Prevention and Services/Battered Women's Shelters--
Grants to States and Indian Tribes and 93.591 Family Violence
Prevention and Services/Battered Women's Shelters--Grants to State
Domestic Violence Coalitions)
Dated: March 24, 2015.
Mark H. Greenberg,
Acting Assistant Secretary for Children and Families.
Approved: March 26, 2015.
Sylvia M. Burwell,
Secretary.
Editorial note: This document was received for publication by the
Office of the Federal Register on October 5, 2015.
For the reasons set forth in the preamble, title 45 CFR part 1370
is proposed to be amended as follows:
PART 1370--FAMILY VIOLENCE PREVENTION AND SERVICES PROGRAMS
0
1. The authority citation for part 1370 continues to read as follows:
0
2. Revise Sec. Sec. 1370.1 through 1370.5 and add Sec. 1370.6 under a
new subpart A to read as follows:
Subpart A--General Provisions
Sec.
1370.1 What are the purposes of Family Violence Prevention and
Services Act Programs?
1370.2 What definitions apply to these programs?
1370.3 What Government-wide and HHS-wide regulations apply to these
programs?
1370.4 What confidentiality requirements apply to these programs?
1370.5 What additional non-discrimination requirements apply to
these programs?
1370.6 What requirements for reports and evaluations apply to these
programs?
Sec. 1370.1 What are the purposes of the Family Violence Prevention
and Services Act Programs?
This part addresses sections 301 through 313 of the Family Violence
Prevention and Services Act (FVPSA), as amended, and codified at 42
U.S.C. 10401 et seq. FVPSA authorizes the Secretary to implement
programs for the purposes of increasing public awareness about and
preventing family violence, domestic violence, and dating violence;
providing immediate shelter and supportive services for victims of
family violence, domestic violence, and dating violence and their
dependents; providing for technical assistance and training relating to
family violence, domestic violence, and dating violence programs;
providing for State Domestic Violence Coalitions; providing specialized
services for abused parents and their children; and operating a
national domestic violence hotline. FVPSA emphasizes both primary, and
secondary, prevention of violence.
[[Page 61908]]
Sec. 1370.2 What definitions apply to these programs?
For the purposes of this part:
Dating violence means violence committed by a person who is or has
been in a social relationship of a romantic or intimate nature with the
victim and where the existence of such a relationship shall be
determined based on a consideration of the following factors: the
length of the relationship, the type of relationship, and the frequency
of interaction between the persons involved in the relationship. This
definition reflects the definition also found in Section 40002(a) of
VAWA (as amended), as required by FVPSA. Additionally, dating violence
may include violence against older individuals and those with
disabilities when the violence meets the applicable definition.
Domestic violence means felony or misdemeanor crimes of violence
committed by a current or former spouse or intimate partner of the
victim, by a person with whom the victim shares a child in common, by a
person who is cohabitating with or has cohabitated with the victim as a
spouse or intimate partner, by a person similarly situated to a spouse
of the victim under the domestic or family violence laws of the
jurisdiction receiving grant monies, or by any other person against an
adult or youth victim who is protected from that person's acts under
the domestic or family violence laws of the jurisdiction. This
definition also reflects the statutory definition of ``domestic
violence'' found in Section 40002(a) of VAWA (as amended). Older
individuals and those with disabilities who otherwise meet the criteria
herein are also included within this term's definition. This definition
will also include but will not be limited to acts or acts constituting
intimidation, control, coercion and coercive control, emotional and
psychological abuse and behavior, expressive and psychological
aggression, harassment, tormenting behavior, disturbing or alarming
behavior, and additional acts recognized in other Federal, State, local
and tribal laws as well as acts in other Federal regulatory or sub-
regulatory guidance. This definition is not intended to be interpreted
more restrictively than FVPSA and VAWA but rather to be inclusive of
other, more expansive definitions.
Family violence means any act or threatened act of violence,
including any forceful detention of an individual, that results or
threatens to result in physical injury and is committed by a person
against another individual (including an older individual), to or with
whom such person is related by blood or marriage, or is or was
otherwise legally related, or is or was lawfully residing. All FVPSA-
funded grantees and contractors are required to serve program
recipients regardless of whether an individual may be married to a
person of the opposite or same sex. Please note that this guidance is
not a change in previous grantee guidance as survivors of intimate
partner violence, regardless of marital status, have always been
eligible for FVPSA-funded services and programming.
Personally identifying information is:
(1) Individually identifying information for or about an individual
including information likely to disclose the location of a victim of
domestic violence, dating violence, sexual assault, or stalking,
regardless of whether the information is encoded, encrypted, hashed, or
otherwise protected, including:
(i) A first and last name;
(ii) A home or other physical address;
(iii) Contact information (including a postal, email or Internet
protocol address, or telephone or facsimile number);
(iv) A social security number, driver license number, passport
number, or student identification number; and
(v) Any other information, including date of birth, racial or
ethnic background, or religious affiliation, that would serve to
identify any individual.
(2) Note that information remains personally identifying even if
physically protected through locked filing cabinets or electronically
protected through encryption.
Primary prevention means strategies, policies, and programs to stop
both first-time perpetration and first-time victimization. Primary
prevention is stopping intimate partner violence before it occurs.
Primary-purpose domestic violence provider means a provider that
operates a project of demonstrated effectiveness carried out by a
nonprofit, nongovernmental, private entity, Tribe or Tribal
organization that has as its project's primary-purpose the operation of
shelters and supportive services for victims of domestic violence and
their dependents; or provides counseling, advocacy, or self-help
services to victims of domestic violence. Territorial Domestic Violence
Coalitions may include government-operated domestic violence projects
as ``primary-purpose'' providers for complying with the membership
requirement, provided that Territorial Coalitions can document
providing training, technical assistance, and capacity-building of
community-based and privately operated projects to provide shelter and
supportive services to victims of family, domestic, or dating violence,
with the intention of recruiting such projects as members once they are
sustainable as primary-purpose domestic violence service providers.
Secondary prevention means identifying risk factors or problems
that may lead to future family violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence, and taking the necessary actions to eliminate the risk
factors and the potential problem.
Shelter means the provision of temporary refuge and supportive
services in compliance with applicable State law or regulations
governing the provision, on a regular basis, of shelter, safe homes,
meals, and supportive services to victims of family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence, and their dependents. This definition
also includes emergency shelter and immediate shelter, which may
include scattered-site housing, which is defined as property with
multiple locations around a local jurisdiction or state. Temporary
refuge includes a residential service, including shelter and off-site
services such as hotel or motel vouchers, which is not transitional or
permanent housing. Should other jurisdictional laws conflict with this
definition of temporary refuge, the definition which provides more
expansive housing accessibility governs.
State means each of the several States, the District of Columbia,
the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, and, except as otherwise provided in
statute, Guam, American Samoa, the United States Virgin Islands, and
the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands.
State Domestic Violence Coalition means a statewide, non-
governmental, nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization whose membership
includes a majority of the primary-purpose domestic violence providers
in the State; whose board membership is representative of these
primary-purpose domestic violence service providers and which may
include representatives of the communities in which the services are
being provided in the State; that provides education, support, and
technical assistance to such providers; and that serves as an
information clearinghouse, primary point of contact, and resource
center on domestic violence for the State and supports the development
of policies, protocols, and procedures to enhance domestic violence
intervention and prevention in the State.
Supportive services means services for adult and youth victims of
family
[[Page 61909]]
violence, domestic violence, or dating violence, and their dependents,
that are designed to meet the needs of such victims and their
dependents for short-term, transitional, or long-term safety and
recovery. Supportive services includes those services identified in
FVPSA Section 10408(b)(1)(G), but is not limited to: Direct and/or
referral-based advocacy on behalf of victims and their dependents,
counseling, case management, employment services, referrals,
transportation services, legal advocacy or assistance, childcare
services, health, behavioral health and preventive health services,
culturally appropriate services, and other services that assist victims
or their dependents in recovering from the effects of the violence.
Supportive services may be directly provided by grantees and/or by
providing advocacy or referrals to assist victims in accessing such
services.
Underserved populations means populations who face barriers in
accessing and using victim services, and includes populations
underserved because of geographic location, religion, sexual
orientation, gender identity, underserved racial and ethnic
populations, and populations underserved because of special needs
including language barriers, disabilities, immigration status, and age.
Individuals with criminal histories due to victimization and
individuals with substance abuse and mental health issues are also
included in this definition. This definition also includes other
population categories determined by the Secretary or the Secretary's
designee to be underserved.
Sec. 1370.3 What Government-wide and HHS-wide regulations apply to
these programs?
(a) A number of government-wide and HHS regulations apply or
potentially apply to all grantees. These include but are not limited
to:
(1) 2 CFR part 182--Government-wide Requirements for Drug Free
Workplaces;
(2) 2 CFR part 376--Nonprocurement Debarment and Suspension;
(3) 45 CFR part 16--Procedures of the Departmental Grant Appeals
Board;
(4) 45 CFR part 30--Claims Collection;
(5) 45 CFR part 46--Protection of Human Subjects;
(6) 45 CFR part 75--Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost
Principles and Audit Requirements for HHS Awards;
(7) 45 CFR part 80--Nondiscrimination Under Programs Receiving
Federal Assistance Through the Department of Health and Human Services
Effectuation of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964;
(8) 45 CFR part 81--Practice and Procedure for Hearings under part
80;
(9) 45 CFR part 84--Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Handicap in
Programs or Activities Receiving Federal Financial Assistance;
(10) 45 CFR part 86--Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Sex in
Education Programs or Activities Receiving Federal Financial
Assistance;
(11) 45 CFR part 87--Equal Treatment for Faith-Based Organizations;
(12) 45 CFR part 91--Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Age in
Programs or Activities Receiving Federal Financial Assistance for HHS;
and
(13) 45 CFR part 93--New Restrictions on Lobbying.
(b) A number of government-wide and HHS regulations apply to all
contractors. These include but are not limited to:
(1) 48 CFR Chapter 1--Federal Acquisition Regulations; and
(2) 48 CFR Chapter 3--Federal Acquisition Regulations--Department
of Health and Human Services.
Sec. 1370.4 What confidentiality requirements apply to these
programs?
(a) In order to ensure the safety of adult, youth, and child
victims of family violence, domestic violence, or dating violence, and
their families, grantees and subgrantees under this title shall protect
the confidentiality and privacy of such victims and their families.
Subject to paragraphs (c), (d), and (e) of this section, grantees and
subgrantees shall not--
(1) Disclose any personally identifying information (as defined in
Sec. 1370.2) collected in connection with services requested
(including services utilized or denied) through grantees' and
subgrantees' programs; or
(2) Reveal personally identifying information without informed,
written, reasonably time-limited consent by the person about whom
information is sought, whether for this program or any other Federal or
State grant program.
(b) Consent shall be given by the person, except in the case of an
unemancipated minor it shall be given by both the minor and the minor's
parent or guardian; or in the case of an individual with a guardian it
shall be given by the individual's guardian. A parent or guardian may
not give consent if: He or she is the abuser or suspected abuser of the
minor or individual with a guardian; or, the abuser or suspected abuser
of the other parent of the minor. Reasonable accommodation shall also
be made to those who may be unable, due to disability or other
functional limitation, to provide consent in writing.
(c) If the release of information described in paragraphs (a) and
(b) of this section is compelled by statutory or court mandate:
(1) Grantees and sub-grantees shall make reasonable attempts to
provide notice to victims affected by the release of the information;
and
(2) Grantees and sub-grantees shall take steps necessary to protect
the privacy and safety of the persons affected by the release of the
information.
(d) Grantees and sub-grantees may share:
(1) Nonpersonally identifying information, in the aggregate,
regarding services to their clients and demographic non-personally
identifying information in order to comply with Federal, State, or
Tribal reporting, evaluation, or data collection requirements;
(2) Court-generated information and law enforcement-generated
information contained in secure, governmental registries for protective
order enforcement purposes; and
(3) Law enforcement- and prosecution-generated information
necessary for law enforcement and prosecution purposes.
(e) Nothing in this section prohibits a grantee or subgrantee from
reporting abuse and neglect, as those terms are defined by law, where
mandated or expressly permitted by the State or Indian Tribe involved.
(f) Nothing in this section shall be construed to supersede any
provision of any Federal, State, Tribal, or local law that provides
greater protection than this section for victims of family violence,
domestic violence, or dating violence.
(g) The address or location of any shelter facility assisted that
maintains a confidential location shall, except with written
authorization of the person or persons responsible for the operation of
such shelter, not be made public.
Sec. 1370.5 What additional non-discrimination requirements apply to
these programs?
(a) No person shall on the ground of sex or religion be excluded
from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subject to
discrimination under, any program or activity funded in whole or in
part through FVPSA. FVPSA grantees must provide comparable services to
victims regardless of sex or gender. This includes not only providing
access to services for male victims of family, domestic, and dating
violence, but also making sure not to limit services for victims with
adolescent sons (up to the
[[Page 61910]]
age of majority). Victims and their adolescent sons must be sheltered
or housed together unless requested otherwise or unless the factors or
considerations identified in the paragraph directly below require an
exception to this general rule.
(b) However, no such program or activity is required to include an
individual in such program or activity without taking into
consideration that individual's sex in those certain instances where
sex is a bona fide occupational qualification or a programmatic factor
reasonably necessary to the essential or safe operation of that
particular program or activity. If a shelter can reasonably separate
the sexes in a manner which allows for single sex bedrooms and
bathrooms and the essential and safe operation of the particular
program is not substantially compromised, it is reasonable to provide
such separation. If the essential or safe operation of the program or
activity would be substantially compromised, alternative, equivalent
shelter and services should be offered as practicable. Adult male
victims should be offered hotel placements and provided supportive
services at the shelter if shelter space is not available or if it is
otherwise determined that the operation of the program or activity
would be substantially compromised. Victims' adolescent male sons, as
previously discussed must be housed with the abused parent seeking
shelter or services unless otherwise requested, or unless there are
specific, individual factors or circumstances, that by placing a victim
in shelter with their son substantially compromise the essential or
safe operations of the program.
(c) LGBTQ individuals must have access to FVPSA-funded shelter and
nonresidential programs. Programmatic accessibility for LGBTQ survivors
must be afforded to meet individual needs like those provided to all
other survivors. For the purpose of assigning a beneficiary to sex-
segregated or sex-specific services, the recipient should ask a
transgender beneficiary which group or services the beneficiary wishes
to join. The recipient may not, however, ask questions about the
beneficiary's anatomy or medical history or make demands for identity
documents. ACF requires that a FVPSA grantee, subgrantee, contractor,
or vendor that makes decisions about eligibility for or placement into
single-sex emergency shelters or other facilities will place a
potential victim (or current victim/client seeking a new assignment) in
a shelter or other appropriate placement that corresponds to the gender
with which the person identifies, taking health and safety concerns
into consideration. A victim's/client's or potential victim's/client's
own views with respect to personal health and safety must be given
serious consideration in making the placement. For instance, if the
potential victim/client requests to be placed based on his or her sex
assigned at birth, ACF requires that the provider will place the
individual in accordance with that request, consistent with health,
safety, and privacy concerns. ACF also requires that a provider will
not make an assignment or re-assignment based on complaints of another
person when the sole stated basis of the complaint is a victim/client
or potential victim/client's non-conformance with gender stereotypes.
(d) With respect to religion, religious beliefs or religious
practices shall not be imposed on program recipients. Dietary practices
dictated by particular religious beliefs may require some reasonable
accommodation in cooking or feeding arrangements for particular clients
as practicable. Finally, human trafficking victims may receive FVPSA-
funded services as long as victims of domestic and intimate partner
violence are prioritized first by FVPSA grantees.
(e) State and Tribal Formula grant-funded services must be provided
without requiring documentation for eligibility given the multiple
access barriers faced by battered immigrants.
(f) All requirements in this section shall not be construed as
affecting any legal remedy provided under any other provision of law.
The Secretary shall enforce the provisions of all requirements in this
section in accordance with section 602 of the Civil Rights Act of 1964
(42 U.S.C. 2000d-1). Section 603 of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (42
U.S.C. 2000d-2) shall apply with respect to any action taken by the
Secretary to enforce this section.
(g) No condition may be imposed by grantees or subgrantees for the
receipt of emergency shelter, unless a State imposes a legal
requirement to protect the safety and welfare of all shelter residents,
and receipt of all supportive services shall be voluntary. Nothing in
this requirement prohibits shelter operators from preventing violence
or abuse or securing the safety of all shelter residents. In the case
of an apparent conflict with State or Federal laws, case-by-case
determinations will be made.
Sec. 1370.6 What requirements for reports and evaluations apply to
these programs?
Each entity receiving a grant or contract under these programs
shall submit a performance report to the Secretary at such time as
required by the Secretary. Such performance report shall describe the
activities that have been carried out, contain an evaluation of the
effectiveness of such activities, and provide such additional
information as the Secretary may require. American Samoa, the
Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands, Guam, and the U.S. Virgin
Islands are required to report directly to the Division of Family
Violence Prevention and Services within FYSB and follow all reporting
requirements applicable to States, Puerto Rico, and the District of
Columbia, unless otherwise communicated to grantees. These requirements
supplement, and do not replace the Territorial reporting requirements
of the ACF Office of Community Services in its administration of the
Consolidated Block Grants as part of the Social Services Block Grant
program.
0
3. Add subpart B, consisting of Sec. 1370.10, to read as follows:
Subpart B--State and Indian Tribal Grants
Sec. 1370.10 What additional requirements apply to State and Indian
Tribal grants?
(a) These grants assist States and Tribes to support the
establishment, maintenance, and expansion of programs and projects to
prevent incidents of family violence, domestic violence, and dating
violence; to provide immediate shelter, supportive services, and access
to community-based programs for victims of family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence, and their dependents; and to provide
specialized services for children exposed to family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence, under-served populations, and victims who
are members of racial and ethnic minority populations. States must
consult with and provide for the participation of State and Tribal
Domestic Violence Coalitions in the planning and monitoring of the
distribution and administration of subgrant programs and projects.
Tribes should be involved in these processes where appropriate but this
rule is not intended to encroach upon Tribal sovereignty. States and
Tribes must involve community-based organizations that primarily serve
culturally specific, underserved communities and to determine how such
organizations can assist the States and Tribes in serving the unmet
needs of the underserved community. States also must consult with and
provide for the participation of State and Tribal Domestic Violence
Coalitions in State planning and coordinate such planning
[[Page 61911]]
with needs assessments to identify service gaps or problems and develop
appropriate responsive plans and programs. Similar processes for Tribes
and Coalitions that support coordination and collaboration are expected
when feasible and appropriate with deference to Tribal sovereignty as
previously indicated.
(b) A State application must be submitted by the Chief Executive of
the State and signed by the Chief Executive Officer or the Chief
Program Official designated as responsible for the administration of
FVPSA. Each application must contain the following information or
documentation:
(1) The name of the State agency, the name and contact information
for the Chief Program Official designated as responsible for the
administration of funds under FVPSA and coordination of related
programs within the State, and the name and contact information for a
contact person if different from the Chief Program Official.
(2) A plan describing in detail how the needs of underserved
populations will be met, including:
(i) Identification of which populations in the State are
underserved, a description of those that are being targeted for
outreach and services, and a brief explanation of why those populations
were selected to receive outreach and services, including how often the
State revisits the identification and selection of the populations to
be served with FVPSA funding. States must review their State
demographics at least every three years or explain why this process in
unnecessary;
(ii) A description of the outreach plan, including the domestic
violence training to be provided, the means for providing technical
assistance and support, and the leadership role played by those
representing and serving the underserved populations in question;
(iii) A description of the specific services to be provided or
enhanced, such as new shelters or services, improved access to shelters
or services, or new services for underserved populations such as
victims from communities of color, immigrant victims, victims with
disabilities, or older individuals; and
(iv) A description of the public information component of the
State's outreach program, including the elements of the program that
are used to explain domestic violence, the most effective and safe ways
to seek help, and tools to identify available resources.
(3) A description of the process and procedures used to involve the
State Domestic Violence Coalition, knowledgeable individuals, and
interested organizations, including those serving or representing
underserved communities in the State planning process.
(4) Documentation of planning, consultation with and participation
of the State Domestic Violence Coalition in the administration and
distribution of FVPSA programs, projects, and grant funds awarded to
the State.
(5) A description of the procedures used to assure an equitable
distribution of grants and grant funds within the State and between
urban and rural areas, as defined by the Census Bureau, within the
State. The plan should describe how funding processes and allocations
will address the needs of the underserved, racial and ethnic minorities
including Tribal populations, and people with disabilities and their
families, with an emphasis on funding organizations that can meet
unique needs including culturally relevant and linguistically
appropriate services. Other Federal, State, local, and private funds
may be considered in determining compliance.
(6) A description of how the State plans to use the grant funds
including a State plan developed in consultation with State and Tribal
Domestic Violence Coalitions and representatives of underserved and
culturally specific communities; a description of the target
populations; of the number of shelters to be funded; of the number of
non-residential programs to be funded; of the services the State will
provide; and of the expected results from the use of the grant funds.
To fulfill these requirements, it is critically important that States
work with Coalitions and Tribes to solicit their feedback on program
effectiveness which may include recommendations such as establishing
program standards and participating in program monitoring.
(7) A copy of the law or procedures, such as a process for
obtaining an order of protection that the State has implemented for the
eviction of an abusive spouse or other intimate, domestic, or dating
partner from a shared household or residence. This requirement includes
family violence, domestic violence, and dating violence.
(8) An assurance that not less than 70 percent of the funds
distributed by a State to sub-recipients shall be distributed to
entities for the primary purpose of providing immediate shelter and
supportive services to adult and youth victims of family violence,
domestic violence, or dating violence, and their dependents, and that
not less than 25 percent of the funds distributed by a State to sub-
recipients shall be distributed to entities for the purpose of
providing supportive services and prevention services (these
percentages may overlap with respect to supportive services but are not
included in the 5 percent cap applicable to State administrative
costs). No grant shall be made under this section to an entity other
than a State unless the entity agrees that, with respect to the costs
to be incurred by the entity in carrying out the program or project for
which the grant is awarded, the entity will make available (directly or
through donations from public or private entities) non-Federal
contributions in an amount that is not less than $1 for every $5 of
Federal funds provided under the grant. The non-Federal contributions
required under this paragraph may be in cash or in kind.
(9) Documentation of policies, procedures and protocols that ensure
individual identifiers of client records will not be used when
providing statistical data on program activities and program services
or in the course of grant monitoring, that the confidentiality of
records pertaining to any individual provided family violence
prevention or intervention services by any program or entity supported
under the FVPSA will be strictly maintained, and the address or
location of any shelter supported under the FVPSA will not be made
public without the written authorization of the person or persons
responsible for the operation of such shelter; and
(10) Such additional agreements, assurances, and information, in
such form, and submitted in such manner as the Funding Opportunity
Announcement and related program guidance prescribe.
(c) An application from a Tribe or Tribal Organization must be
submitted by the Chief Executive Officer or Tribal Chairperson of the
applicant organization. Each application must contain the following
information or documentation:
(1) A copy of a current Tribal resolution or an equivalent document
that verifies Tribal approval of the application being submitted. The
resolution or other document should state that the designated
organization or agency has the authority to submit an application on
behalf of the individuals in the Tribe(s) and to administer programs
and activities funded pursuant to the FVPSA. The resolution or
equivalent document must specify the name(s) of the Tribe(s)
represented and the service area for the intended grant services. If
Tribal resolutions are the vehicles to support applications from Tribal
Consortia or other joint Tribal
[[Page 61912]]
applications, a representative from each Tribe must sign the
application.
(2) A description of the procedures designed to involve
knowledgeable individuals and interested organizations in providing
services under the FVPSA. For example, knowledgeable individuals and
interested organizations may include Tribal officials or social
services staff involved in child abuse or family violence prevention,
Tribal law enforcement officials, representatives of Tribal or State
Domestic Violence Coalitions, and operators of domestic violence
shelters and service programs.
(3) A description of the applicant's operation of and/or capacity
to carry out a family violence prevention and services program. This
might be demonstrated in ways such as:
(i) The current operation of a shelter, safe house, or domestic
violence prevention program;
(ii) The establishment of joint or collaborative service agreements
with a local public agency or a private, non- profit agency for the
operation of family violence prevention and intervention activities or
services; or
(iii) The operation of social services programs as evidenced by
receipt of grants or contracts awarded under Indian Child Welfare
grants from the Bureau of Indian Affairs; Child Welfare Services grants
under Title IV-B of the Social Security Act; or Family Preservation and
Family Support grants under Title IV-B of the Social Security Act.
(4) A description of the services to be provided, how the applicant
organization plans to use the grant funds to provide the direct
services, to whom the services will be provided, and the expected
results of the services.
(5) Documentation of the law or procedure which has been
implemented for the eviction of an abusing spouse or other intimate,
domestic, or dating partner from a shared household or residence.
(6) Documentation of the policies and procedures developed and
implemented, including copies of the policies and procedures, to ensure
that individual identifiers of client records will not be used when
providing statistical data on program activities and program services
or in the course of grant monitoring and that the confidentiality of
records pertaining to any individual provided domestic violence
prevention or intervention services by any FVPSA-supported program will
be strictly maintained.
(7) Such agreements, assurances, and information, in such form, and
submitted in such manner as the Funding Opportunity Announcement and
related program guidance prescribe.
0
4. Add subpart C, consisting of Sec. 1370.20, to read as follows:
Subpart C--State Domestic Violence Coalition Grants
Sec. 1370.20 What additional requirements apply to State Domestic
Violence Coalitions?
(a) State Domestic Violence Coalitions reflect a Federal commitment
to reducing domestic violence; to urge States, localities, cities, and
the private sector to become involved in State and local planning
towards an integrated service delivery approach that meets the needs of
all victims, including those in underserved communities; to provide for
technical assistance and training relating to domestic violence
programs; and to increase public awareness about and prevention of
domestic violence and increase the quality and availability of shelter
and supportive services for victims of domestic violence and their
dependents.
(b) To be eligible to receive a grant under this section, an
organization shall be a statewide, non-governmental, non-profit
501(c)(3) domestic violence Coalition, designated as such by the
Department. To obtain this designation the organization must meet the
following criteria:
(1) The membership must include representatives from a majority of
the primary-purpose programs for victims of domestic violence operating
within the State (a Coalition also may include representatives of
Indian Tribes and Tribal organizations as defined in the Indian Self-
Determination and Education Assistance Act);
(2) The Board membership of the Coalition must be representative,
though not exclusively composed, of such programs, and may include
representatives of communities in which the services are being provided
in the State;
(3) Financial sustainability of Coalitions, as independent,
autonomous non-profit organizations, also must be supported by their
membership, including those member representatives on the Coalitions'
Boards of Directors;
(4) The purpose of the Coalition must be to provide services,
community education, and technical assistance to domestic violence
programs in order to establish and maintain shelter and supportive
services for victims of domestic violence and their children.
(c) To apply for a grant under this section, an organization shall
submit an annual application that:
(1) Includes a complete description of the applicant's plan for the
operation of a State Domestic Violence Coalition, including
documentation that the Coalition's work will demonstrate the ability to
conduct appropriately all activities described in this section.
Demonstrated ability or capacity may include but is not limited to:
Identifying successful efforts that support child welfare agencies'
identification and support of victims during intake processes; creation
of membership standards that enhance victim safety and fully require
training and technical assistance for compliance with federal housing,
disability, and sex discrimination laws and regulations; and, training
judicial personnel on trauma-informed courtroom practice. Coalitions
must also have documented experience in administering Federal grants to
conduct the activities of a Coalition or a documented history of active
participation in:
(i) Working with local family violence, domestic violence, and
dating violence service programs and providers of direct services to
encourage appropriate and comprehensive responses to family violence,
domestic violence, and dating violence against adults or youth within
the State involved, including providing training and technical
assistance and conducting State needs assessments and participate in
planning and monitoring of the distribution of subgrants within the
States and in the administration of grant programs and projects;
(ii) In conducting needs assessments, Coalitions and States must
work in partnership on the statutorily required FVPSA State planning
process to involve representatives from underserved and racial and
ethnic minority populations to plan, assess and voice the needs of the
communities they represent. Coalitions will assist States in
identifying underrepresented communities and culturally-specific
community based organizations in State planning and to work with States
to unify planning and needs assessment efforts so that comprehensive
and culturally-specific services are provided. The inclusion of the
populations targeted will emphasize building the capacity of
culturally-specific services and programs.
(iii) Working in collaboration with service providers and
community-based organizations to address the needs of family violence,
domestic violence, and dating violence victims, and their dependents,
who are members of racial and ethnic minority populations and
underserved populations;
(iv) Collaborating with and providing information to entities in
such fields as housing, health care, mental health,
[[Page 61913]]
social welfare, or business to support the development and
implementation of effective policies, protocols, and programs that
address the safety and support needs of adult and youth victims of
family violence, domestic violence, or dating violence;
(v) Encouraging appropriate responses to cases of family violence,
domestic violence, or dating violence against adults or youth,
including by working with judicial and law enforcement agencies;
(vi) Working with family law judges, criminal court judges, child
protective service agencies, and children's advocates to develop
appropriate responses to child custody and visitation issues in cases
of child exposure to family violence, domestic violence, or dating
violence and in cases in which family violence, domestic violence, or
dating violence is present and child abuse is present;
(vii) Working with protection and advocacy systems, and aging and
disability systems to develop appropriate responses for older
individuals and individuals with disabilities;
(viii) Providing information to the public about prevention of
family violence, domestic violence, and dating violence, including
information targeted to underserved populations; and
(ix) Collaborating with Indian Tribes and Tribal organizations (and
corresponding Native Hawaiian groups or communities) to address the
needs of Indian (including Alaska Native) and Native Hawaiian victims
of family violence, domestic violence, or dating violence, as
applicable in the State;
(2) Contains such agreements, assurances, and information, in such
form, and submitted in such manner as the Funding Opportunity
Announcement and related program guidance prescribe.
(d) Nothing in this section limits the ability of a Coalition to
use non-Federal or other Federal funding sources to conduct required
functions, provided that if the Coalition uses funds received under
section 2001(c)(1) of the Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets Act of
1968 to perform the functions described in FVPSA section 311(e) in lieu
of funds provided under the FVPSA, it shall provide an annual assurance
to the Secretary that it is using such funds, and that it is
coordinating the activities conducted under this section with those of
the State's activities under Part T of title I of the Omnibus Crime
Control and Safe Streets Act of 1968.
(e) In cases in which two or more organizations seek designation,
the designation of each State's individual Coalition is within the
exclusive discretion of HHS. HHS will determine which applicant best
fits statutory criteria, with particular attention paid to the
applicant's documented history of effective work, support of primary-
purpose programs and programs that serve racial and ethnic minority
populations and underserved populations, coordination and collaboration
with the State government, and capacity to accomplish the FVPSA
mandated role of a Coalition.
(f) Regarding FVPSA funding, in cases where a Coalition financially
or otherwise dissolves, the designation of a new Coalition is within
the exclusive discretion of HHS. HHS will work with domestic violence
service providers, community stakeholders, State leaders, and
representatives of underserved and culturally specific communities to
identify an existing organization that can serve as the Coalition or to
develop a new organization. The new Coalition must reapply for
designation and funding following steps determined by the Secretary.
HHS will determine whether the applicant fits the statutory criteria,
with particular attention paid to the applicant's documented history of
effective work, support of primary-purpose programs and programs that
serve racial and ethnic minority populations and undeserved
communities, coordination and collaboration with the State government,
and capacity to accomplish the FVPSA mandated role of a Coalition.
0
5. Add Subpart D to read as follows:
Subpart D--Discretionary Grants and Contracts
Sec.
1370.30 What National Resource Centers and Training and Technical
Assistance grant programs are available and what requirements apply?
1370.31 What additional requirements apply to specialized services
for abused parents and their children?
1370.32 What additional requirements apply to National Domestic
Violence Hotline grants?
Sec. 1370.30 What National Resource Center and Training and Technical
Assistance grant programs are available and what additional
requirements apply?
(a) These grants are to provide resource information, training, and
technical assistance to improve the capacity of individuals,
organizations, governmental entities, and communities to prevent family
violence, domestic violence, and dating violence and to provide
effective intervention services. They fund national, special issue, and
culturally-specific resource centers addressing key areas of domestic
violence intervention and prevention, and may include State resource
centers to reduce disparities in domestic violence in States with high
proportions of Native American (including Alaska Native or Native
Hawaiian) populations and to support training and technical assistance
that address emerging issues related to family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence, to entities demonstrating expertise in
these areas. Grants may be made for:
(1) A National Resource Center on Domestic Violence which will
conduct the following activities:
(i) Offer a comprehensive array of technical assistance and
training resources to Federal, State, and local governmental agencies,
domestic violence service providers, community-based organizations, and
other professionals and interested parties, related to domestic
violence service programs and research, including programs and research
related to victims and their children who are exposed to domestic
violence as well as older individuals and those with disabilities; and
(ii) Maintain a central resource library in order to collect,
prepare, analyze, and disseminate information and statistics related to
the incidence and prevention of family violence and domestic violence;
and the provision of shelter, supportive services, and prevention
services to adult and youth victims of domestic violence (including
services to prevent repeated incidents of violence).
(2) A National Indian Resource Center Addressing Domestic Violence
and Safety for Indian Women which will conduct the following
activities:
(i) Offer a comprehensive array of technical assistance and
training resources to Indian Tribes and Tribal organizations,
specifically designed to enhance the capacity of the Tribes and Tribal
organizations to respond to domestic violence and increase the safety
of Indian women; and
(ii) Enhance the intervention and prevention efforts of Indian
Tribes and Tribal organizations to respond to domestic violence and
increase the safety of Indian women, and
(iii) To coordinate activities with other Federal agencies,
offices, and grantees that address the needs of American Indians,
Alaska Natives, and Native Hawaiians that experience domestic violence.
(3) Special issue resource centers to provide national information,
training, and technical assistance to State and local domestic violence
service providers. Each special issue resource center shall focus on
enhancing domestic violence intervention and
[[Page 61914]]
prevention efforts in at least one of the following areas:
(i) Response of the criminal and civil justice systems to domestic
violence victims, which may include the response to the use of the
self-defense plea by domestic violence victims and the issuance and use
of protective orders;
(ii) Response of child protective service agencies to victims of
domestic violence and their dependents and child custody issues in
domestic violence cases;
(iii) Response of the interdisciplinary health care system to
victims of domestic violence and access to health care resources for
victims of domestic violence;
(iv) Response of mental health systems, domestic violence service
programs, and other related systems and programs to victims of domestic
violence and to their children who are exposed to domestic violence.
(4) Culturally-Specific Special Issue Resource Centers enhance
domestic violence intervention and prevention efforts for victims of
domestic violence who are members of racial and ethnic minority groups,
to enhance the cultural and linguistic relevancy of service delivery,
resource utilization, policy, research, technical assistance, community
education, and prevention initiatives.
(5) State resource centers to provide statewide information,
training, and technical assistance to Indian Tribes, Tribal
organizations, and local domestic violence service organizations
serving Native Americans (including Alaska Natives and Native
Hawaiians) in a culturally sensitive and relevant manner. These centers
shall:
(i) Offer a comprehensive array of technical assistance and
training resources to Indian Tribes, Tribal organizations, and
providers of services to Native Americans (including Alaska Natives and
Native Hawaiians) specifically designed to enhance the capacity of the
Tribes, organizations, and providers to respond to domestic violence;
(ii) Coordinate all projects and activities with the National
Indian Resource Center Addressing Domestic Violence and Safety for
Indian Women, including projects and activities that involve working
with State and local governments to enhance their capacity to
understand the unique needs of Native Americans (including Alaska
Natives and Native Hawaiians); and
(iii) Provide comprehensive community education and domestic
violence prevention initiatives in a culturally sensitive and relevant
manner.
(iv) Be located in a State with high proportions of Indian or
Native Hawaiian populations. Eligible entities shall be located in a
State in which the population of Indians (including Alaska Natives) and
Native Hawaiians exceeds 10 percent of the total population of the
State; or, be an Indian tribe, Tribal organization or a Native Hawaiian
organization that focuses primarily on issues of domestic violence
among Indians or Native Hawaiians; or, be an institution of higher
education; and, demonstrate the ability to serve all regions of the
State, including underdeveloped areas and areas that are geographically
distant from population centers. Additionally, eligible entities shall
offer training and technical assistance and capacity-building resources
in States where the population of Indians (including Alaska Natives)
and Native Hawaiians exceeds 2.5 percent of the total population of the
State.
(6) Other discretionary purposes to support training and technical
assistance that address emerging issues related to family violence,
domestic violence, or dating violence, to entities demonstrating
related experience.
(b) To receive a grant under any part of this section, an entity
shall submit an application that shall meet such eligibility standards
as are prescribed in the FVPSA and contains such agreements,
assurances, and information, in such form, and submitted in such manner
as the Funding Opportunity Announcement and related program guidance
prescribe.
(c) Grant recipients are required to comply with Title VI of the
Civil Rights Act of 1964 and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of
1973. To effectuate such compliance, grant recipients should create a
plan to ensure effective communication and meaningful access,
including:
(1) How to respond to individuals with Limited English Proficiency,
and how to use appropriate interpretation and translation services,
including best practices for using taglines. Taglines are short
statements in non-English languages informing persons who are Limited
English Proficient on how to access language assistance services.
(2) How to respond to individuals with communication-related
disabilities and how to provide appropriate auxiliary aids and
services, including qualified interpreters and information in alternate
formats, to people with disabilities.
Sec. 1370.31 What additional requirements apply to grants for
specialized services for abused parents and their children?
(a) These grants serve to expand the capacity of family violence,
domestic violence, and dating violence service programs and community-
based programs to prevent future domestic violence by addressing, in an
appropriate manner, the needs of children exposed to family violence,
domestic violence, or dating violence. To be eligible an entity must be
a local agency, a nonprofit private organization (including faith-based
and charitable organizations, community-based organizations, and
voluntary associations), or a Tribal organization, with a demonstrated
record of serving victims of family violence, domestic violence, or
dating violence and their children.
(b) To be eligible to receive a grant under this section, an entity
shall submit an application that:
(1) Includes a complete description of the applicant's plan for
providing specialized services for abused parents and their children,
including descriptions of:
(i) How the entity will prioritize the safety of, and
confidentiality of information about victims of family violence,
victims of domestic violence, and victims of dating violence and their
children;
(ii) How the entity will provide developmentally appropriate and
age-appropriate services, and culturally and linguistically appropriate
services, to the victims and children; and
(iii) How the entity will ensure that professionals working with
the children receive the training and technical assistance appropriate
and relevant to the unique needs of children exposed to family
violence, domestic violence, or dating violence.
(2) Demonstrates that the applicant has the ability to provide
direct counseling, appropriate service, and advocacy on behalf of
victims of family violence, domestic violence, or dating violence and
their children, including coordination with services provided by the
child welfare system;
(3) Demonstrates that the applicant can effectively provide
services for nonabusing parents to support those parents' roles as
caregivers and their roles in responding to the social, emotional, and
developmental needs of their children;
(c) Eligible applicants may use funds under a grant pursuant to
this section that:
(1) Demonstrates a capacity to provide early childhood development
and mental health services;
[[Page 61915]]
(2) Shows the ability to coordinate activities with and provide
technical assistance to community-based organizations serving victims
of family violence, domestic violence, or dating violence or children
exposed to family violence, domestic violence, or dating violence; and
(3) Shows the capacity to provide additional services and referrals
to services for children, including child care, transportation,
educational support, respite care, supervised visitation, or other
necessary services; and
(4) Contains such agreements, assurances, and information, in such
form, and submitted in such manner as the Funding Opportunity
Announcement and related program guidance prescribe.
(d) If Congressional appropriations in any fiscal year for the
entirety of programs covered in this part (exclusive of the National
Domestic Violence Hotline which receives a separate appropriation)
exceed $130 million, not less than 25 percent of such excess funds
shall be made available to carry out this grant program. If
appropriations reach this threshold, HHS will specify funding levels in
future Funding Opportunity Announcements.
Sec. 1370.32 What additional requirements apply to National Domestic
Violence Hotline grants?
(a) These grants are for one or more private entities to provide
for the ongoing operation of a 24-hour, national, toll-free telephone
hotline to provide information and assistance to adult and youth
victims of family violence, domestic violence, or dating violence,
family and household members of such victims, and persons affected by
the victimization.
(b) Telephone is defined as a communications device that permits
two or more callers or users to engage in transmitted analog, digital,
short message service (SMS), cellular/wireless, laser, cable/broadband,
internet, voice-over internet protocol (IP) or other communications,
including telephone, smartphone, chat, text, voice recognition, or
other technological means which connects callers or users together.
(c) To be eligible to receive a grant under this section, an entity
shall submit an application that:
(1) Includes a complete description of the applicant's plan for the
operation of a national domestic violence telephone hotline, including
descriptions of:
(i) The training program for hotline personnel, including
technology training to ensure that all persons affiliated with the
hotline are able to effectively operate any technological systems used
by the hotline, and are familiar with effective communication and
meaningful access requirements, to ensure access for all, including
people who are Limited English Proficient and people with disabilities;
(ii) The hiring criteria and qualifications for hotline personnel;
(iii) The methods for the creation, maintenance, and updating of a
resource database;
(iv) A plan for publicizing the availability of the hotline;
(v) A plan for providing service to Limited English Proficient
callers, including service through hotline personnel who are qualified
to interpret in non-English languages;
(vi) A plan for facilitating access to the hotline by persons with
disabilities, including persons with hearing impairments; and
(vii) A plan for providing assistance and referrals to youth
victims of domestic violence and for victims of dating violence who are
minors, which may be carried out through a national teen dating
violence hotline.
(2) Demonstrates that the applicant has recognized expertise in the
area of family violence, domestic violence, or dating violence and a
record of high quality service to victims of family violence, domestic
violence, or dating violence, including a demonstration of support from
advocacy groups and State Domestic Violence Coalitions;
(3) Demonstrates that the applicant has the capacity and the
expertise to maintain a domestic violence hotline and a comprehensive
database of service providers;
(4) Demonstrates the ability to provide information and referrals
for callers, directly connect callers to service providers, and employ
crisis interventions meeting the standards of family violence, domestic
violence, and dating violence providers;
(5) Demonstrates that the applicant has a commitment to diversity
and to the provision of services to underserved populations, including
to ethnic, racial, and Limited English Proficient individuals, in
addition to older individuals and individuals with disabilities;
(6) Demonstrates that the applicant follows comprehensive quality
assurance practices; and
(7) Contains such agreements, information, and assurances,
including nondisclosure of confidential or private information, in such
form, and submitted in such manner as the Funding Opportunity
Announcement and related program guidance prescribe.
(d) The entity receiving a grant under this section shall submit a
performance report to the Secretary at such time as reasonably required
by the Secretary that shall describe the activities that have been
carried out with grant funds, contain an evaluation of the
effectiveness of such activities, and provide additional information as
the Secretary may reasonably require.
[FR Doc. 2015-25726 Filed 10-9-15; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4184-01-P