Homeless Emergency Assistance and Rapid Transition to Housing: Continuum of Care Program, 45421-45467 [2012-17546]
Download as PDF
Vol. 77
Tuesday,
No. 147
July 31, 2012
Part II
Department of Housing and Urban
Development
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
24 CFR Part 578
Homeless Emergency Assistance and Rapid Transition to Housing:
Continuum of Care Program; Interim Final Rule
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
PO 00000
Frm 00001
Fmt 4717
Sfmt 4717
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
45422
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND
URBAN DEVELOPMENT
24 CFR Part 578
[Docket No. FR–5476–I–01]
RIN 2506–AC29
Homeless Emergency Assistance and
Rapid Transition to Housing:
Continuum of Care Program
Office of the Assistant
Secretary for Community Planning and
Development, HUD.
ACTION: Interim rule.
AGENCY:
The Homeless Emergency
Assistance and Rapid Transition to
Housing Act of 2009 (HEARTH Act),
enacted into law on May 20, 2009,
consolidates three of the separate
homeless assistance programs
administered by HUD under the
McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance
Act into a single grant program, and
revises the Emergency Shelter Grants
program and renames it the Emergency
Solutions Grants program. The HEARTH
Act also codifies in law the Continuum
of Care planning process, a longstanding
part of HUD’s application process to
assist homeless persons by providing
greater coordination in responding to
their needs. The HEARTH Act also
directs HUD to promulgate regulations
for these new programs and processes.
This interim rule focuses on
regulatory implementation of the
Continuum of Care program, including
the Continuum of Care planning
process. The existing homeless
assistance programs that comprise the
Continuum of Care program are the
following: the Supportive Housing
program, the Shelter Plus Care program,
and the Moderate Rehabilitation/Single
Room Occupancy (SRO) program. This
rule establishes the regulations for the
Continuum of Care program, and,
through the establishment of such
regulations, the funding made available
for the Continuum of Care program in
the statute appropriating Fiscal Year
(FY) 2012 funding for HUD can more
quickly be disbursed, consistent with
the HEARTH Act requirements, and
avoid any disruption in current
Continuum of Care activities.
DATES: Effective Date: August 30, 2012.
Comment Due Date. October 1, 2012.
ADDRESSES: Interested persons are
invited to submit comments regarding
this rule to the Regulations Division,
Office of General Counsel, 451 7th
Street SW., Room 10276, Department of
Housing and Urban Development,
Washington, DC 20410–0500.
Communications must refer to the above
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
SUMMARY:
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
docket number and title. There are two
methods for submitting public
comments. All submissions must refer
to the above docket number and title.
1. Submission of Comments by Mail.
Comments may be submitted by mail to
the Regulations Division, Office of
General Counsel, Department of
Housing and Urban Development, 451
7th Street SW., Room 10276,
Washington, DC 20410–0500.
2. Electronic Submission of
Comments. Interested persons may
submit comments electronically through
the Federal eRulemaking Portal at
www.regulations.gov. HUD strongly
encourages commenters to submit
comments electronically. Electronic
submission of comments allows the
commenter maximum time to prepare
and submit a comment, ensures timely
receipt by HUD, and enables HUD to
make them immediately available to the
public. Comments submitted
electronically through the
www.regulations.gov Web site can be
viewed by other commenters and
interested members of the public.
Commenters should follow the
instructions provided on that site to
submit comments electronically.
Note: To receive consideration as public
comments, comments must be submitted
through one of the two methods specified
above. Again, all submissions must refer to
the docket number and title of the rule.
No Facsimile Comments. Facsimile
(FAX) comments are not acceptable.
Public Inspection of Public
Comments. All properly submitted
comments and communications
submitted to HUD will be available for
public inspection and copying between
8 a.m. and 5 p.m. weekdays at the above
address. Due to security measures at the
HUD Headquarters building, an advance
appointment to review the public
comments must be scheduled by calling
the Regulations Division at 202–708–
3055 (this is not a toll-free number).
Individuals with speech or hearing
impairments may access this number
through TTY by calling the Federal
Relay Service at 800–877–8339. Copies
of all comments submitted are available
for inspection and downloading at
www.regulations.gov.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Ann
Marie Oliva, Director, Office of Special
Needs Assistance Programs, Office of
Community Planning and Development,
Department of Housing and Urban
Development, 451 7th Street SW.,
Washington, DC 20410–7000; telephone
number 202–708–4300 (this is not a tollfree number). Hearing- and speechimpaired persons may access this
number through TTY by calling the
PO 00000
Frm 00002
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
Federal Relay Service at 800–877–8339
(this is a toll-free number).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Executive Summary
Purpose of and Legal Authority for This
Interim Rule
This interim rule implements the
Continuum of Care program authorized
by the Homeless Emergency Assistance
and Rapid Transition to Housing Act of
2009 (HEARTH Act). Section 1504 of
the HEARTH Act directs HUD to
establish regulations for this program.
(See 42 U.S.C. 11301.) The purpose of
the Continuum of Care program is to
promote communitywide commitment
to the goal of ending homelessness;
provide funding for efforts by nonprofit
providers, and State and local
governments to quickly rehouse
homeless individuals and families while
minimizing the trauma and dislocation
caused to homeless individuals,
families, and communities by
homelessness; promote access to and
effective utilization of mainstream
programs by homeless individuals and
families; and optimize self-sufficiency
among individuals and families
experiencing homelessness.
The HEARTH Act streamlines HUD’s
homeless grant programs by
consolidating the Supportive Housing,
Shelter Plus Care, and Single Room
Occupancy grant programs into one
grant program: The Continuum of Care
program. Local continuums of care,
which are community-based homeless
assistance program planning networks,
will apply for Continuum of Care grants.
By consolidating homeless assistance
grant programs and creating the
Continuum of Care planning process,
the HEARTH Act intended to increase
the efficiency and effectiveness of
coordinated, community-based systems
that provide housing and services to the
homeless. Through this interim final
rule, HUD will implement the
Continuum of Care program by
establishing the framework for
establishing a local continuum of care
and the process for applying for
Continuum of Care grants.
Summary of Major Provisions
The major provisions of this
rulemaking relate to how to establish
and operate a Continuum of Care, how
to apply for funds under the program,
and how to use the funds for projects
approved by HUD. These provisions are
summarized below.
1. General Provisions (Subpart A):
The Continuum of Care program
includes transitional housing,
permanent supportive housing for
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
disabled persons, permanent housing,
supportive services, and Homeless
Management Information Systems
(HMIS). To implement the program,
HUD had to define several key terms. In
particular, HUD distinguishes between
‘‘Continuum of Care,’’ ‘‘applicant,’’ and
‘‘collaborative applicant.’’ A
‘‘Continuum of Care’’ is a geographically
based group of representatives that
carries out the planning responsibilities
of the Continuum of Care program, as
set out in this regulation. These
representatives come from organizations
that provide services to the homeless, or
represent the interests of the homeless
or formerly homeless. A Continuum of
Care then designates certain
‘‘applicants’’ as the entities responsible
for carrying out the projects that the
Continuum has identified through its
planning responsibilities. A
‘‘Continuum of Care’’ also designates
one particular applicant to be a
‘‘collaborative applicant.’’ The
collaborative applicant is the only entity
that can apply for a grant from HUD on
behalf of the Continuum that the
collaborative applicant represents.
2. Establishing and Operating a
Continuum of Care (Subpart B): In order
to be eligible for funds under the
Continuum of Care program,
representatives from relevant
organizations within a geographic area
must establish a Continuum of Care.
The three major duties of a Continuum
of Care are to: (1) Operate the
Continuum of Care, (2) designate an
HMIS for the Continuum of Care, and
(3) plan for the Continuum of Care. HUD
has delineated certain operational
requirements of each Continuum to help
measure a Continuum’s overall
performance at reducing homelessness,
in addition to tracking of performance
on a project-by-project basis. In
addition, each Continuum is responsible
for establishing and operating a
centralized or coordinated assessment
system that will provide a
comprehensive assessment of the needs
of individuals and families for housing
and services. HUD has also defined the
minimum planning requirements for a
Continuum so that it coordinates and
implements a system that meets the
needs of the homeless population
within its geographic area. Continuums
are also responsible for preparing and
overseeing an application for funds.
Continuums will have to establish the
funding priorities for its geographic area
when submitting an application.
3. Application and Grant Award
Process (Subpart C): The Continuum of
Care grant award process begins with a
determination of a Continuum’s
maximum award amount. As directed
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
by statute, HUD has developed a
formula for determining award amounts
that includes the following factors: A
Continuum’s Preliminary Pro Rata Need
(PPRN) amount; renewal demand; any
additional increases in amounts for
leasing, rental assistance, and operating
costs based on Fair Market Rents,
planning and Unified Funding Agency
cost funds, and amounts available for
bonus dollars. HUD has established
selection criteria for determining which
applications will receive funding under
the Continuum of Care program.
Recipients awarded Continuum of Care
funds must satisfy several conditions
prior to executing their grant
agreements. All grants submitted for
renewal must also submit an annual
performance report. For those
applicants not awarded funding, the
process also provides an appeals
process.
4. Program Components and Eligible
Costs (Subpart D): Continuum of Care
funds may be used for projects under
five program components: Permanent
housing, transitional housing,
supportive services only, HMIS, and, in
some limited cases, homelessness
prevention. The rule further clarifies
how the following activities are
considered eligible costs under the
Continuum of Care program: Continuum
of Care planning activities, Unified
Funding Agency costs, acquisition,
rehabilitation, new construction,
leasing, rental assistance, supportive
services, operating costs, HMIS, project
administrative costs, relocation costs,
and indirect costs.
5. High-Performing Communities
(Subpart E): HUD will annually, subject
to the availability of appropriate data,
select those Continuums of Care that
best meet application requirements to be
designated a high-performing
community (HPC). An HPC may use
grant funds to provide housing
relocation and stabilization services,
and short- and/or medium-term rental
assistance to individuals and families at
risk of homelessness. This is the only
time that Continuum of Care funds may
be used to serve individuals and
families at risk of homelessness.
6. Program Requirements (Subpart F):
All recipients of Continuum of Care
funding must comply with the program
regulations and the requirements of the
Notice of Funding Availability that HUD
will issue each year. Notably, the
HEARTH Act requires that all eligible
funding costs, except leasing, must be
matched with no less than 25 percent
cash or in-kind match by the
Continuum. Other program
requirements of recipients include:
Abiding by housing quality standards
PO 00000
Frm 00003
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45423
and suitable dwelling size, assessing
supportive services on an ongoing basis,
initiating and completing approved
activities and projects within certain
timelines, and providing a formal
process for termination of assistance to
participants who violate program
requirements or conditions of
occupancy.
7. Grant Administration (Subpart G):
To effectively administer the grants,
HUD will provide technical assistance
to those who apply for Continuum of
Care funds, as well as those who are
selected for Continuum of Care funds.
After having been selected for funding,
grant recipients must satisfy certain
recordkeeping requirements so that
HUD can assess compliance with the
program requirements. For any
amendments to grants after the funds
have been awarded, HUD has
established a separate amendment
procedure. As appropriate, HUD has
also established sanctions to strengthen
its enforcement procedures.
Benefits and Costs
This interim rule is intended to help
respond to and work toward the goal of
eliminating homelessness. This interim
rule provides greater clarity and
guidance about planning and
performance review to the more than
430 existing Continuums of Care that
span all 50 states and 6 United States
territories. As reported in HUD’s Annual
Homelessness Assessment Report to
Congress, there were approximately 1.59
million homeless persons who entered
emergency shelters or transitional
housing in FY 2010. HUD serves
roughly half that many persons, nearly
800,000 annually, through its three
programs that will be consolidated into
the Continuum of Care program under
the McKinney-Vento Act as amended by
the HEARTH Act (i.e., Shelter Plus Care,
Supportive Housing Program, Single
Room Occupancy). The changes
initiated by this interim rule will
encourage Continuums of Care to
establish formal policies and review
procedures, including evaluation of the
effectiveness of their projects, by
emphasizing performance measurement
and developing performance targets for
homeless populations. HUD is confident
that this systematic review by
Continuums of Care will lead to better
use of limited resources and more
efficient service models, with the end
result of preventing and ending
homelessness.
The Consolidated and Further
Continuing Appropriations Act, 2012
(Pub. L. 112–55) appropriated
$1,593,000,000 for the Continuum of
Care and Rural Housing Stability
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
45424
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Assistance programs. Upon publication
of this rule, those FY 2012 funds will be
available for distribution, as governed
by these Continuum of Care regulations.
I. Background—HEARTH Act
On May 20, 2009, the President
signed into law ‘‘An Act to Prevent
Mortgage Foreclosures and Enhance
Mortgage Credit Availability,’’ which
became Public Law 111–22. This law
implements a variety of measures
directed toward keeping individuals
and families from losing their homes.
Division B of this law is the HEARTH
Act, which consolidates and amends
three separate homeless assistance
programs carried out under title IV of
the McKinney-Vento Homeless
Assistance Act (42 U.S.C. 11371 et seq.)
(McKinney-Vento Act) into a single
grant program that is designed to
improve administrative efficiency and
enhance response coordination and
effectiveness in addressing the needs of
homeless persons. The HEARTH Act
codifies in law and enhances the
Continuum of Care planning process,
the coordinated response to addressing
the needs of the homeless, which was
established administratively by HUD in
1995. The single Continuum of Care
program established by the HEARTH
Act consolidates the following
programs: The Supportive Housing
program, the Shelter Plus Care program,
and the Moderate Rehabilitation/Single
Room Occupancy program. The
Emergency Shelter Grants program is
renamed the Emergency Solutions
Grants program and is revised to
broaden existing emergency shelter and
homelessness prevention activities and
to add short- and medium-term rental
assistance and services to rapidly
rehouse homeless people. The HEARTH
Act also creates the Rural Housing
Stability program to replace the Rural
Homelessness Grant program.
HUD commenced the process to
implement the HEARTH Act with
rulemaking that focused on the
definition of ‘‘homeless.’’ HUD
published a proposed rule, entitled
‘‘Defining Homeless’’ on April 20, 2010
(75 FR 20541), which was followed by
a final rule that was published on
December 5, 2011 (76 FR 75994). The
Defining Homeless rule clarified and
elaborated upon the new McKinneyVento Act definitions for ‘‘homeless’’
and ‘‘homeless individual with a
disability.’’ In addition, the Defining
Homeless rule included recordkeeping
requirements related to the ‘‘homeless’’
definition. On December 5, 2011, HUD
also published an interim rule for the
Emergency Solutions Grants program
(76 FR 75954). This interim rule
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
established the program requirements
for the Emergency Solutions Grants
program and contained corresponding
amendments to the Consolidated Plan
regulations. On December 9, 2011, HUD
continued the process to implement the
HEARTH Act, with the publication of
the proposed rule titled ‘‘Homeless
Management Information Systems
Requirements’’ (76 FR 76917), which
provides for uniform technical
requirements for Homeless Management
Information Systems (HMIS), for proper
data collection and maintenance of the
database, and ensures the
confidentiality of the information in the
database. Today’s publication of the
interim rule for the Continuum of Care
program continues HUD’s
implementation of the HEARTH Act.
This rule establishes the regulatory
framework for the Continuum of Care
program and the Continuum of Care
planning process, including
requirements applicable to the
establishment of a Continuum of Care.
Prior to the amendment of the
McKinney-Vento Act by the HEARTH
Act, HUD’s competitively awarded
homeless assistance grant funds were
awarded to organizations that
participate in local homeless assistance
program planning networks referred to
as a Continuum of Care, a system
administratively established by HUD in
1995. A Continuum of Care is designed
to address the critical problem of
homelessness through a coordinated
community-based process of identifying
needs and building a system of housing
and services to address those needs. The
approach is predicated on the
understanding that homelessness is not
caused merely by a lack of shelter, but
involves a variety of underlying, unmet
needs—physical, economic, and social.
The HEARTH Act not only codified in
law the planning system known as
Continuum of Care, but consolidated the
three existing competitive homeless
assistance grant programs (Supportive
Housing, Shelter Plus Care, and Single
Room Occupancy) into the single grant
program known as the Continuum of
Care program. The consolidation of the
three existing homeless assistance
programs into the Continuum of Care
grant program and the codification in
law of the Continuum of Care planning
process are intended to increase the
efficiency and effectiveness of the
coordination of the provision of housing
and services to address the needs of the
homeless. The regulations established
by this rule are directed to carrying out
this congressional intent.
PO 00000
Frm 00004
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
II. Overview of Interim Rule
As amended by the HEARTH Act,
Subpart C of the McKinney-Vento
Homeless Assistance Act establishes the
Continuum of Care program. The
purpose of the program is to promote
communitywide commitment to the
goal of ending homelessness; provide
funding for efforts by nonprofit
providers, and State and local
governments to quickly rehouse
homeless individuals and families while
minimizing the trauma and dislocation
caused to homeless individuals,
families, and communities by
homelessness; promote access to and
effective utilization of mainstream
programs by homeless individuals and
families; and optimize self-sufficiency
among individuals and families
experiencing homelessness.
This interim rule establishes the
Continuum of Care as the planning body
responsible for meeting the goals of the
Continuum of Care program.
Additionally, in order to meet the
purpose of the HEARTH Act,
established in section 1002(b), and the
goals of ‘‘Opening Doors: Federal
Strategic Plan to Prevent and End
Homelessness,’’ the Continuum of Care
must be involved in the coordination of
other funding streams and resources—
federal, local, or private—of targeted
homeless programs and other
mainstream resources. In many
communities, the Continuum of Care is
the coordinating body, while in other
communities it is a local Interagency
Council on Homelessness (both would
be acceptable forms of coordination
under this interim rule). As noted
earlier, HUD published on December 9,
2011, a proposed rule to establish HMIS
regulations in accordance with the
HEARTH Act. However, while the
HEARTH Act directed that regulations
be established for HMIS, HMIS is not
new to many HUD grantees. Until
regulations for HMIS are promulgated in
final, grantees should continue to follow
HUD’s existing HMIS instructions and
guidance.
The following provides an overview
of the proposed rule.
General Provisions (Subpart A)
Purpose and scope. The Continuum of
Care program is designed to promote
community-wide goals to end
homelessness; provide funding to
quickly rehouse homeless individuals
(including unaccompanied youth) and
families while minimizing trauma and
dislocation to those persons; promote
access to, and effective utilization of,
mainstream programs; and optimize
self-sufficiency among individuals and
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
families experiencing homelessness.
The program is composed of transitional
housing, permanent supportive housing
for disabled persons, permanent
housing, supportive services, and HMIS.
Definitions. The interim rule adopts
the definitions of ‘‘developmental
disability,’’ ‘‘homeless,’’ ‘‘homeless
individual,’’ and ‘‘homeless person’’
established by the December 5, 2011
Defining Homeless final rule. Public
comments have already been solicited
and additional public comment is not
solicited through this rule. The
December 5, 2011, final rule was
preceded by an April 20, 2010,
proposed rule, which sought public
comment on these definitions. The final
definitions of these terms took into
consideration the public comments
received on the proposed definitions as
set out in the April 20, 2010, proposed
rule. This interim rule adopts the
definition of ‘‘at risk of homelessness’’
established by the December 5, 2011,
the Emergency Solutions Grants
program interim rule. The interim rule
sought public comment on this
definition, and additional public
comment is not being sought through
this rule.
HUD received valuable public
comment on the definition of
‘‘chronically homeless,’’ through the
public comment process on the
Emergency Solutions Grants program
interim rule. Based on public comment,
this rule for the Continuum of Care
program is not adopting the full
definition of ‘‘chronically homeless’’
that was included in the conforming
amendments to the Consolidated Plan
that were published as a part of the
Emergency Solutions Grants program
rule. Commenters raised concerns with
the meaning of the phrase ‘‘where each
homeless occasion was at least 15
days.’’ The concerns raised about this
phrase, used for the first time in a
definition of ‘‘chronically homeless,’’
has caused HUD to reconsider
proceeding to apply a definition that
includes this phrase, without further
consideration and opportunity for
comment. In this rule, HUD therefore
amends the definition of ‘‘chronically
homeless’’ in the Consolidated Plan
regulations to strike this phrase. The
removal of this phrase returns the
definition to one with which service
providers are familiar. The following
highlights key definitions used in the
Continuum of Care program regulations,
and HUD solicits comment on these
definitions.
Applicant is defined to mean an
entity that has been designated by the
Continuum of Care as eligible to apply
for assistance on behalf of that
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
Continuum. HUD highlights that the Act
does not contain different definitions for
‘‘applicant’’ and ‘‘collaborative
applicant.’’ HUD distinguishes between
the applicant(s) designated to apply for
and carry out projects (the ‘‘applicant’’)
and the collaborative applicant
designated to apply for a grant on behalf
of the Continuum of Care (the
‘‘collaborative applicant’’). Please see
below for more information on the
definition of a collaborative applicant,
which is the only entity that may apply
for and receive Continuum of Care
planning funds.
Centralized or coordinated
assessment system is defined to mean a
centralized or coordinated process
designed to coordinate program
participant intake, assessment, and
provision of referrals. A centralized or
coordinated assessment system covers
the geographic area, is easily accessed
by individuals and families seeking
housing or services, is well advertised,
and includes a comprehensive and
standardized assessment tool. This
definition establishes basic minimum
requirements for the Continuum’s
centralized or coordinated assessment
system.
Collaborative applicant is defined to
mean an eligible applicant that has been
designated by the Continuum of Care to
apply for a grant for Continuum of Care
planning funds on behalf of the
Continuum. As discussed above, the
‘‘applicant’’ is the entity(ies) designated
to apply for and carry out projects on
behalf of the Continuum. In contrast to
the definition of ‘‘applicant’’ above, the
collaborative applicant applies for a
grant to carry out the planning activities
on behalf of the Continuum of Care. The
interim rule simplifies the statutory
language in order to make the
Continuum of Care planning process
clear.
HUD highlights that its definition of
collaborative applicant does not track
the statutory definition, which is found
in section 401 of the McKinney-Vento
Act. As will be discussed in further
detail later in this preamble, the concept
of collaborative applicant, its duties and
functions, as provided in the statute, is
provided for in this rule. However, HUD
uses the term Continuum of Care to refer
to the organizations that carry out the
duties and responsibilities assigned to
the collaborative applicant, with the
exception of applying to HUD for grant
funds. The clarification is necessary in
this rule because Continuums of Care
are not required to be legal entities, but
HUD can enter into contractual
agreements with legal entities only.
Continuum of Care and Continuum
are defined to mean the group that is
PO 00000
Frm 00005
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45425
organized to carry out the
responsibilities required under this part
and that is composed of representatives
of organizations including nonprofit
homeless providers, victim service
providers, faith-based organizations,
governments, businesses, advocates,
public housing agencies, school
districts, social service providers,
mental health agencies, hospitals,
universities, affordable housing
developers, law enforcement,
organizations that serve homeless and
formerly homeless veterans, and
homeless and formerly homeless
persons. These organizations consist of
the relevant parties in the geographic
area. Continuums are expected to
include representation to the extent that
the type of organization exists within
the geographic area that the Continuum
represents and is available to participate
in the Continuum. For example, if a
Continuum of Care did not have a
university within its geographic
boundaries, then HUD would not expect
the Continuum to have representation
from a university within the
Continuum.
These organizations carry out the
responsibilities and duties established
under Subpart B of this interim rule.
The Continuum of Care, as noted above,
carries out the statutory duties and
responsibilities of a collaborative
applicant. HUD established the
Continuum of Care in 1995. Local
grantees and stakeholders are familiar
with the Continuum of Care as the
coordinating body for homeless services
and homelessness prevention activities
across the geographic area.
Consequently, HUD is maintaining the
Continuum of Care terminology, and the
rule provides for the duties and
responsibilities of a collaborative
applicant to be carried out under the
name Continuum of Care.
High-performing community is
defined to mean the geographic area
under the jurisdiction of a Continuum of
Care that has been designated as a highperforming community by HUD. Section
424 of the McKinney-Vento Act
provides that HUD shall designate, on
an annual basis, which collaborative
applicants represent high-performing
communities. Consistent with HUD’s
substitution of the term ‘‘Continuum of
Care’’ for ‘‘collaborative applicant,’’ the
definition of ‘‘high-performing
community’’ in this interim rule
provides for designation of Continuums
of Care that represent geographic areas
designated as high-performing
communities. The standards for
becoming a high-performing community
can be found in § 578.65 of this interim
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
45426
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
rule and will be discussed later in this
preamble.
Private nonprofit organization is
based on the statutory definition for
‘‘private nonprofit organization.’’ The
term ‘‘private nonprofit organization’’ is
defined in section 424 of the McKinneyVento Act as follows: ‘‘The term ‘private
nonprofit organization’ means an
organization: ‘(A) No part of the net
earnings of which inures to the benefit
of any member, founder, contributor, or
individual; (B) that has a voluntary
board; (C) that has an accounting
system, or has designated a fiscal agent
in accordance with requirements
established by the Secretary; and (D)
that practices nondiscrimination in the
provision of assistance.’ ’’ In HUD’s
regulatory definition of ‘‘private
nonprofit organization,’’ HUD clarifies
that the organization’s accounting
system must be functioning and
operated in accordance with generally
accepted accounting principles. HUD
has included this language to make
certain that accounting systems are
workable and abide by definite, accurate
standards. As reflected in the statutory
definition of ‘‘private nonprofit
organization,’’ HUD may establish
requirements for the designation of a
fiscal agent. HUD has determined that
the fiscal agent, such as a Unified
Funding Agency, a term that is also
defined in section 424 of the McKinneyVento Act, must maintain a functioning
accounting system for the organization
in accordance with generally accepted
accounting principles.
Permanent housing is consistent with
the statutory definition of ‘‘permanent
housing’’ in section 401 of the
McKinney-Vento Act, but does not track
the statutory language. HUD’s regulatory
definition of ‘‘permanent housing’’
states: ‘‘The term ‘permanent housing’
means community-based housing
without a designated length of stay, and
includes both permanent supportive
housing and rapid re-housing.’’
Additionally, in the regulatory
definition of ‘‘permanent housing,’’
HUD clarifies that to be permanent
housing, ‘‘the program participant must
be the tenant on a lease for a term of at
least one year that is renewable and is
terminable only for cause. The lease
must be renewable for terms that are a
minimum of one month long. HUD has
determined that requiring a lease for a
term of at least one year that is
renewable and terminable only for
cause, assists program participants in
obtaining stability in housing, even
when the rental assistance is temporary.
These requirements are consistent with
Section 8 requirements.
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
Specific request for comment. HUD
specifically requests comment on
requiring a lease for a term of at least
one year to be considered permanent
housing.
Project is consistent with the statutory
definition of ‘‘project’’ in section 401 of
the McKinney-Vento Act, but does not
track the statutory language. Section 401
defines ‘‘project’’ as, with respect to
activities carried out under subtitle C,
eligible activities described in section
423(a), undertaken pursuant to a
specific endeavor, such as serving a
particular population or providing a
particular resource. In HUD’s definition
of ‘‘project’’ in this interim rule, the
eligible activities described in section
423(a) of the McKinney-Vento Act have
been identified. In the regulatory text,
HUD has clarified that it is a group of
one or more of these eligible costs that
are identified as a project in an
application to HUD for Continuum of
Care funds.
Recipient is defined to mean an
applicant that signs a grant agreement
with HUD. HUD’s definition of
‘‘recipient’’ is consistent with the
statutory definition of ‘‘recipient,’’ but
does not track the statutory language.
Section 424 of the McKinney-Vento Act
defines ‘‘recipient’’ as ‘‘an eligible entity
who—(A) submits an application for a
grant under section 422 that is approved
by the Secretary; (B) receives the grant
directly from the Secretary to support
approved projects described in the
application; and (C)(i) serves as a project
sponsor for the projects; or (ii) awards
the funds to project sponsors to carry
out the projects.’’ All of the activities
specified by the statutory definition are
in the rule: (A) and (B) are contained in
the definition and (C) is covered in the
sections of the rule dealing with what a
recipient can do with grant funds.
Safe haven is based on the definition
of safe haven in the McKinney-Vento
Act prior to amendment by the
HEARTH Act. Although no longer used
in statute, HUD’s position is that the
term remains relevant for
implementation of the Continuum of
Care program and, therefore, HUD
proposes to include the term in the
Continuum of Care program regulations.
The term ‘‘safe haven’’ is used for
purposes of determining whether a
person is chronically homeless. The
housing must serve hard-to-reach
homeless persons with severe mental
illness who came from the streets and
have been unwilling or unable to
participate in supportive services. In
addition, the housing must provide
24-hour residence for eligible persons
for an unspecified period, have an
overnight capacity limited to 25 or
PO 00000
Frm 00006
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
fewer persons, and provide low-demand
services and referrals for the residents.
Subrecipient is defined to mean a
private nonprofit organization, State or
local government, or instrumentality of
a State or local government that receives
a subgrant from the recipient to operate
a project. The definition of
‘‘subrecipient’’ is consistent with the
definition of ‘‘project sponsor’’ found in
section 401 of the McKinney-Vento Act,
but does not track the statutory
language. To be consistent with the
Emergency Solutions Grants program
regulation, and also to ensure that the
relationship between the recipient and
subrecipient is clear, HUD is using the
term subrecipient, instead of project
sponsor, throughout this regulation.
Transitional housing is based on the
definition of ‘‘transitional housing’’ in
section 401 of the McKinney-Vento Act,
as follows: ‘‘The term ‘transitional
housing’ means housing, the purpose of
which is to facilitate the movement of
individuals and families experiencing
homelessness to permanent housing
within 24 months or such longer period
as the Secretary determines necessary.’’
The definition has been expanded to
distinguish this type of housing from
emergency shelter. This distinction is
necessitated by the McKinney-Vento
Act’s explicit distinction between what
activities can or cannot be funded under
the Continuum of Care program. The
regulatory definition clarifies that, to be
transitional housing, program
participants must have signed a lease or
occupancy agreement that is for a term
of at least one month and that ends in
24 months and cannot be extended.
Unified Funding Agency (UFA) means
an eligible applicant selected by the
Continuum of Care to apply for a grant
for the entire Continuum, which has the
capacity to carry out the duties
delegated to a UFA in this rule, which
is approved by HUD and to which HUD
awards a grant. HUD’s regulatory
definition of UFA departs slightly from
the statutory definition. The statutory
definition refers to the collaborative
applicant. The differences between the
statutory definition and HUD’s
regulatory definition reflect HUD’s
substitution of Continuum of Care for
collaborative applicant.
Establishing and Operating the
Continuum of Care (Subpart B)
In general. The statutory authority for
the Continuum of Care program is
section 422 of the McKinney-Vento Act.
As stated under section 1002 of the
HEARTH Act, one of the main purposes
of the HEARTH Act is to codify the
Continuum of Care planning process.
Consequently, under this interim rule,
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
HUD focuses on the rules and
responsibilities of those involved in the
Continuum of Care planning process
and describes how applications and
grant funds will be processed.
As discussed earlier in the preamble,
HUD’s interim rule provides for the
duties and functions of the collaborative
applicant found in section 401 of the
McKinney-Vento Act to be designated to
the Continuum of Care, with the
exception of applying to HUD for grant
funds. HUD chose this approach
because the Continuum might not be a
legal entity, and therefore cannot enter
into enforceable contractual agreements,
but is the appropriate body for
establishing and implementing
decisions that affect the entire
geographic area covered by the
Continuum, including decisions related
to funding. This approach allows the
Continuum to retain its duties related to
planning and prioritizing need
(otherwise designated by statute to the
collaborative applicant), while the
authority to sign a grant agreement with
HUD is designated to an eligible
applicant that can enter into a
contractual agreement. All of the duties
assigned to the Continuum are based on
the comparable duties of section 402(f)
of the McKinney-Vento Act.
Subpart B of the interim rule
identifies how Continuums of Care are
established, as well as the required
duties and functions of the Continuum
of Care.
Establishing the Continuum of Care.
In order to be eligible for funds under
the Continuum of Care program,
representatives from relevant
organizations within a geographic area
must establish a Continuum of Care. As
discussed earlier in this preamble, this
body is responsible for carrying out the
duties identified in this interim
regulation. Representatives from
relevant organizations include nonprofit
homeless assistance providers, victim
service providers, faith-based
organizations, governments, businesses,
advocates, public housing agencies,
school districts, social service providers,
mental health agencies, hospitals,
universities, affordable housing
developers, law enforcement, and
organizations that serve veterans and
homeless and formerly homeless
individuals. Where these organizations
are located within the geographic area
served by the Continuum of Care, HUD
expects a representative of the
organization to be a part of the
Continuum of Care.
Specific request for comment. HUD
specifically requests comments on
requiring Continuums of Care to have a
board that makes the decisions for the
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
Continuum. HUD requires two
characteristics for all board
compositions. These characteristics are
that the Board must be representative of
the subpopulations of homeless persons
that exist within the geographic area,
and include a homeless or formerly
homeless person. Continuums will have
2 years from the effective date of the
interim rule to establish a board that
meets the criteria established in this
section. No board member may
participate or influence discussions or
decisions concerning the award of a
grant or other financial benefits for an
organization that the member
represents.
HUD is considering four additional
characteristics for all board
compositions for incorporation in the
final rule. HUD did not implement them
at this stage in order to seek public
comment prior to implementing them as
requirements. HUD proposes that all
boards must have a chair or co-chairs;
be composed of an uneven number,
serving staggered terms; include
members from the public and private
sectors; and include a member from at
least one Emergency Solutions Grants
program (ESG) recipient’s agency
located within the Continuum’s
geographic area. HUD is requesting
comment on all of these proposed
requirements; however, HUD
specifically requests comments from
Continuums of Care and ESG recipients
on the requirement that the Board
include an ESG recipient as part of its
membership. HUD invites ESG
recipients and Continuums to share
challenges that will be encountered
when implementing this requirement.
Ensuring that ESG recipients are
represented on the Board is important to
HUD; therefore, in communities where
ESG recipients and/or Continuums do
not feel this requirement is feasible,
HUD asks commenters to provide
suggestions for how ESG recipients can
be involved in the Continuum at one of
the core decision-making levels.
Responsibilities of the Continuum of
Care. The interim rule establishes three
major duties for which the Continuum
of Care is responsible: To operate the
Continuum of Care, to designate an
HMIS for the Continuum of Care, and to
plan for the Continuum of Care.
This section of the interim rule
establishes requirements within these
three major duties.
Operating the Continuum of Care. The
interim rule provides that the
Continuum of Care must abide by
certain operational requirements. These
requirements will ensure the effective
management of the Continuum of Care
process and ensure that the process is
PO 00000
Frm 00007
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45427
inclusive and fair. HUD has established
eight duties required of the Continuum
necessary to effectively operate the
Continuum of Care. HUD has
established the specific minimum
standards for operating and managing a
Continuum of Care for two main
reasons. First, the selection criteria
established under section 427 of the
McKinney-Vento Act require HUD to
measure the Continuum of Care’s
performance in reducing homelessness
by looking at the overall performance of
the Continuum, as opposed to
measuring performance project-byproject as was done prior to the
enactment of the HEARTH Act. This
Continuum of Care performance
approach results in cooperation and
coordination among providers. Second,
because Continuums of Care will have
grants of up to 3 percent of Final Pro
Rata Need (FPRN) to be used for eligible
Continuum of Care planning costs, HUD
is requiring more formal decisionmaking and operating standards for the
Continuum of Care. This requirement
ensures that the Continuums have
appropriate funding to support planning
costs.
One of the duties established in this
interim rule is the requirement that the
Continuum establish and operate a
centralized or coordinated assessment
system that provides an initial,
comprehensive assessment of the needs
of individuals and families for housing
and services. As detailed in the
Emergency Solutions Grants program
interim rule published on December 5,
2011, through the administration of the
Rapid Re-Housing for Families
Demonstration program and the
Homelessness Prevention and Rapid ReHousing program, as well as best
practices identified in communities,
HUD has learned that centralized or
coordinated assessment systems are
important in ensuring the success of
homeless assistance and homeless
prevention programs in communities. In
particular, such assessment systems
help communities systematically assess
the needs of program participants and
effectively match each individual or
family with the most appropriate
resources available to address that
individual or family’s particular needs.
Therefore, HUD has required, through
this interim rule, each Continuum of
Care to develop and implement a
centralized or coordinated assessment
system for its geographic area. Such a
system must be designed locally in
response to local needs and conditions.
For example, rural areas will have
significantly different systems than
urban ones. While the common thread
between typical models is the use of a
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
45428
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
common assessment tool, the form,
detail, and use of that tool will vary
from one community to the next. Some
examples of centralized or coordinated
assessment systems include: A central
location or locations within a
geographic area where individuals and
families must be present to receive
homeless services; a 211 or other hotline
system that screens and directly
connects callers to appropriate homeless
housing/service providers in the area; a
‘‘no wrong door’’ approach in which a
homeless family or individual can show
up at any homeless service provider in
the geographic area but is assessed using
the same tool and methodology so that
referrals are consistently completed
across the Continuum of Care; a
specialized team of case workers that
provides assessment services to
providers within the Continuum of
Care; or in larger geographic areas, a
regional approach in which ‘‘hubs’’ are
created within smaller geographic areas.
HUD intends to develop technical
assistance materials on a range of
centralized and coordinated assessment
types, including those most appropriate
for rural areas.
HUD recognizes that imposing a
requirement for a centralized or
coordinated assessment system may
have certain costs and risks. Among the
risks that HUD wishes specifically to
address are the risks facing individuals
and families fleeing domestic violence,
dating violence, sexual assault, and
stalking. In developing the baseline
requirements for a centralized or
coordinated intake system, HUD is
considering whether victim service
providers should be exempt from
participating in a local centralized or
coordinated assessment process, or
whether victim service providers should
have the option to participate or not.
Specific request for comment. HUD
specifically seeks comment from
Continuum of Care-funded victim
service providers on this question. As
set forth in this interim rule, each
Continuum of Care is to develop a
specific policy on how its particular
system will address the needs of
individuals and families who are
fleeing, or attempting to flee, domestic
violence, dating violence, sexual
assault, or stalking, but who are seeking
shelter or services from non-victim
service providers. These policies could
include reserving private areas at an
assessment location for evaluations of
individuals or families who are fleeing,
or attempting to flee, domestic violence,
dating violence, sexual assault, or
stalking; a separate ‘‘track’’ within the
assessment framework that is
specifically designed for domestic
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
violence victims; or the location of
victim service providers with
centralized assessment teams.
HUD invites suggestions for ensuring
that the requirements it imposes
regarding centralized or coordinated
assessment systems will best help
communities use their resources
effectively and best meet the needs of all
families and individuals who need
assistance. Questions that HUD asks
commenters to specifically address are:
What barriers to accessing housing/
services might a centralized or
coordinated intake system pose to
victims of domestic violence? How can
those barriers be eliminated? What
specific measures should be
implemented to ensure safety and
confidentiality for individuals and
families who are fleeing or attempting to
flee domestic violence situations? How
should those additional standards be
implemented to ensure that victims of
domestic violence have immediate
access to housing and services without
increasing the burden on those victims?
For communities that already have
centralized or coordinated assessment
systems in place, are victims of
domestic violence and/or domestic
violence service providers integrated
into that system? Under either scenario
(they are integrated into an assessment
process or they are not integrated into
it), how does your community ensure
the safety and confidentiality of this
population, as well as access to
homeless housing and services? What
HUD-sponsored training would be
helpful to assist communities in
completing the initial assessment of
victims of domestic violence in a safe
and confidential manner?
In addition to comments addressing
the needs of victims of domestic
violence, dating violence, sexual
assault, and stalking, HUD invites
general comments on the use of a
centralized or coordinated assessment
system, particularly from those in
communities that have already
implemented one of these systems who
can share both what has worked well
and how these systems could be
improved. HUD specifically seeks
comment on any additional risks that a
centralized or coordinated assessment
system may create for victims of
domestic violence, dating violence,
sexual assault, or stalking who are
seeking emergency shelter services due
to immediate danger, regardless of
whether they are seeking services
through a victim service provider or
nonvictim service provider.
Another duty set forth in this part, is
the requirement to establish and
consistently follow written standards
PO 00000
Frm 00008
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
when administering assistance under
this part. These requirements,
established in consultation with
recipients of Emergency Solutions
Grants program funds within the
geographic area, are intended to
coordinate service delivery across the
geographic area and assist Continuums
of Care and their recipients in
evaluating the eligibility of individuals
and families consistently and
administering assistance fairly and
methodically. The written standards can
be found in § 578.7(a)(9) of this interim
rule.
Designating and operating an HMIS.
The Continuum of Care is responsible
for designating an HMIS and an eligible
applicant to manage the HMIS,
consistent with the requirements, which
will be codified in 24 CFR part 580.
This duty is listed under section
402(f)(2) of the McKinney-Vento Act. In
addition, the Continuum is responsible
for reviewing, revising, and approving a
privacy plan, security plan, and data
quality plan for the HMIS and ensuring
consistent participation of recipients
and subrecipients in the HMIS.
Continuum of Care planning. The
Continuum is responsible for
coordinating and implementing a
system for its geographic area to meet
the needs of the homeless population
and subpopulations within the
geographic area. The interim rule
defines the minimum requirements for
this systematic approach under
§ 578.7(c)(1), such as emergency
shelters, rapid rehousing, transitional
housing, permanent supportive housing,
and prevention strategies. Because there
are not sufficient resources available
through the Continuum of Care program
to prevent and end homelessness,
coordination and integration of other
funding streams, including the
Emergency Solutions Grants program
and mainstream resources, is integral to
carrying out the Continuum of Care
System.
HUD has determined that since the
Continuum of Care will be the larger
planning organization, the Continuum
of Care must develop and follow a
Continuum of Care plan that adheres,
not only to the requirements being
established by this interim rule, but to
the requirements and directions of the
most recently issued notice of funding
availability (NOFA).
While these planning duties are not
explicitly provided in section 402(f) of
the Act, HUD has included them to
facilitate and clarify the Continuum of
Care planning process. Consistent with
the goals of the HEARTH Act, HUD
strives, through this interim rule, to
provide a comprehensive, well-
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
coordinated and clear planning process,
which involves the creation of the
Continuum of Care and the duties the
Continuum of Care will have to fulfill.
Other planning duties for Continuums
established in this section of the interim
rule are planning for and conducting at
least a biennial-point-in-time count of
homeless persons within the geographic
area, conducting an annual gaps
analysis of the homeless needs and
services available within the geographic
area, providing information necessary to
complete the Consolidated Plan(s)
within the geographic area, and
consulting with State and local
government Emergency Solutions
Grants program recipients within the
Continuum of Care on the plan for
allocating Emergency Solutions Grants
program funds and reporting on and
evaluating the performance of
Emergency Solutions Grants program
recipients and subrecipients.
Preparing an application for funds. A
major function of the Continuum of Care
is preparing and overseeing an
application for funds under this part.
This section of the interim rule
establishes the duties of the Continuum
of Care related to the preparation of the
application. This section of the interim
rule establishes that the Continuum is
responsible for designing, operating,
and following a collaborative process for
the development of applications, as well
as approving the submission of
applications, in response to a NOFA
published by HUD.
The Continuum must also establish
priorities for funding projects within the
geographic area and determine the
number of applications being submitted
for funding. As previously noted in this
preamble, since the Continuum of Care
might not be a legal entity, and therefore
may not be able to enter into a
contractual agreement with HUD, the
Continuum must select one or more
eligible applicants to submit an
application for funding to HUD on its
behalf. If the Continuum of Care is an
eligible applicant, the Continuum of
Care may submit an application. If the
Continuum selects more than one
application, the Continuum must select
one eligible applicant to be the
collaborative applicant. That applicant
will collect and combine the required
application information from all of the
other eligible applicants and for all
projects within the geographic area that
the Continuum has designated. If only
one application is submitted by the
collaborative applicant, the
collaborative applicant will collect and
combine the required application
information from all projects within the
geographic area that the Continuum has
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
designated for funding. The
collaborative applicant will always be
the only applicant that can apply for
Continuum of Care planning costs. In
the case that there is one application for
projects, the recipient of the funds is
required to have signed agreements with
its subrecipients as set forth in
§ 578.23(c), and is required to monitor
and sanction subrecipients in
compliance with § 578.107.
Whether the Continuum of Care
submits the application or designates an
eligible applicant to submit the
application for funding, the Continuum
of Care retains all of its duties.
Unified Funding Agencies. To be
designated as the Unified Funding
Agency (UFA) for the Continuum of
Care, the Continuum must select the
collaborative applicant to apply to HUD
to be designated as the UFA for the
Continuum. The interim rule establishes
the criteria HUD will use when
determining whether to designate the
collaborative applicant as a UFA. These
standards were developed to ensure that
collaborative applicants have the
capacity to manage the grant and carry
out the duties in 578.11(b), and are
described below.
The duties of the UFA established in
§ 578.11 are consistent with the duties
set forth in section 402(g) of the Act.
Even if the Continuum designates a
UFA to submit the application for
funding, the Continuum of Care retains
all of its duties.
Remedial actions. Section 402(c) of
the McKinney-Vento Act gives HUD the
authority to ensure the fair distribution
of grant amounts for this program, such
as designating another body as a
collaborative applicant, replacing the
Continuum of Care for the geographic
area, or permitting other eligible entities
to apply directly for grants. Section
578.13 of this interim rule addresses the
remedial actions that may be taken.
Overview of the Application and Grant
Award Process (Subpart C)
Eligible applicants. Under this interim
rule, eligible applicants consist of
nonprofit organizations, State and local
governments, and instrumentalities of
local governments. An eligible applicant
must have been designated by the
Continuum of Care to submit an
application for grant funds under this
part. The Continuum’s designation must
state whether the Continuum is
designating more than one applicant to
apply for funds, and if it is, which
applicant is being designated the
collaborative applicant. A Continuum of
Care that is designating only one
applicant for funds must designate that
applicant to be the collaborative
PO 00000
Frm 00009
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45429
applicant. For-profit entities are not
eligible to apply for grants or to be
subrecipients of grant funds.
Section 401(10) of the McKinneyVento Act identifies that collaborative
applicants may be legal entities, and a
legal entity may include a consortium of
instrumentalities of a State or local
government that has constituted itself as
an entity. HUD has not included a
consortium in the list of eligible
applicants. As noted earlier in this
preamble, a Continuum of Care is
defined to mean a group that is
composed of representatives of
organizations across the entire
geographic area claimed by the
Continuum of Care. A Continuum is
able to combine more than one
metropolitan city or county into the
geographic area that the Continuum
represents. In essence, the Continuum of
Care acts as a consortium, and it is
therefore HUD’s position that the
inclusion of consortiums in the interim
rule would be redundant.
Determining the Continuum’s
maximum award amount. The total
amount for which a Continuum of Care
is eligible to apply and be awarded is
determined through a four-step process,
including the following factors: A
Continuum’s PPRN amount; renewal
demand; any additional increases in
amounts for leasing, rental assistance,
and operating costs based on Fair
Market Rents (FMRs); planning and
UFA cost funds; and the amounts
available for bonus dollars.
Using the formula that will be
discussed below, HUD will first
determine a Continuum of Care’s PPRN
amount, as authorized under section
427(b)(2)(B) of the McKinney-Vento Act.
This amount is the sum of the PPRN
amounts for each metropolitan city,
urban county, non-urban county, and
insular area claimed by the Continuum
of Care as part of its geographic area,
excluding any counties applying for, or
receiving funds under the Rural
Housing Stability Assistance program,
the regulations for which will be
established in 24 CFR part 579. The
PPRN for each of these areas is based
upon the ‘‘need formula’’ under
§ 579.17(a)(2) and (3). Under the
McKinney-Vento Act, HUD is required
to publish, by regulation, the formula
used to establish grant amounts. The
need formula under § 579.17(a)(2) and
(3) satisfies this requirement, and HUD
specifically seeks comment on this
formula. HUD will announce the PPRN
amounts prior to the publication of the
NOFA on its Web site.
To establish the amount on which the
need formula is run, HUD will deduct
an amount, which will be published in
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
45430
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
the NOFA, to be set aside to provide a
bonus, and the amount necessary to
fund Continuum of Care planning
activities and UFA costs from the total
funds made available for the program
each fiscal year. On this amount, HUD
will use the following process to
establish an area’s PPRN. First, 2
percent of the total funds available shall
be allocated among the four insular
areas (American Samoa, Guam, the
Commonwealth of the Northern
Marianas, and the Virgin Islands) based
upon the percentage each area received
in the previous fiscal year under section
106 of the Housing and Community
Development Act of 1974. Second, 75
percent of the remaining funds made
available shall be allocated to
metropolitan cities and urban counties
that have been funded under the
Emergency Solutions Grants program
(formerly known as the Emergency
Shelter Grants program) every year since
2004. Third, the remaining funds made
available shall be allocated to
Community Development Block Grant
(CDBG) metropolitan cities and urban
counties that have not been funded
under the Emergency Solutions Grants
program every year since 2004 and all
other counties in the United States and
Puerto Rico.
Recognizing that in some federal
fiscal years, the amount available for the
formula may be less than the amount
required to renew all existing projects
eligible for renewal in that year for at
least one year, HUD has included a
method for distributing the reduction of
funds proportionally across all
Continuums of Care in § 578.17(a)(4) of
this interim rule. HUD will publish the
total dollar amount that each
Continuum will be required to deduct
from renewal projects Continuum-wide,
and Continuums will have the authority
to determine how to administer the cuts
to projects across the Continuum.
Specific request for comment. HUD
specifically requests comment on the
method established in § 578.17(a)(4) to
reduce the total amount required to
renew all projects eligible for renewal in
that one year, for at least one year, for
each Continuum of Care when funding
is not sufficient to renew all projects
nationwide for at least one year.
The second step in determining a
Continuum’s maximum award amount
is establishing a Continuum of Care’s
‘‘renewal demand.’’ The Continuum’s
renewal demand is the sum of the
annual renewal amounts of all projects
eligible within the Continuum of Care’s
geographic area to apply for renewal in
that federal fiscal year’s competition
before any adjustments to rental
assistance, leasing, and operating line
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
items based on changes to the FMRs in
the geographic area.
Third, HUD will determine the
Continuum of Care’s Final Pro Rata
Need (FPRN), which is the higher of:
(1) PPRN, or (2) renewal demand for the
Continuum of Care. The FPRN
establishes the base for the maximum
award amount for the Continuum of
Care.
Fourth, HUD will determine the
maximum award amount. The
maximum award amount for the
Continuum of Care is the FPRN amount
plus any additional eligible amounts for
Continuum planning; establishing fiscal
controls for the Continuum; updates to
leasing, operating, and rental assistance
line items based on changes to FMR;
and the availability of any bonus
funding during the competition.
Application process. Each fiscal year,
HUD will issue a NOFA. All
applications, including applications for
grant funds, and requests for
designation as a UFA or HPC, must be
submitted to HUD in accordance with
the requirements of the NOFA and
contain such information as the NOFA
specifies. Applications may request up
to the maximum award amount for
Continuums of Care.
An applicant that is a State or a unit
of general local government must have
a HUD-approved, consolidated plan in
accordance with HUD’s Consolidated
Plan regulations in 24 CFR part 91. The
applicant must submit a certification
that the application for funding is
consistent with the HUD-approved
consolidated plan(s) in the project’s
jurisdiction(s). Applicants that are not
States or units of general local
government must submit a certification
that the application for funding is
consistent with the jurisdiction’s HUDapproved consolidated plan. The
certification must be made by the unit
of general local government or the State,
in accordance with HUD’s regulations in
24 CFR part 91, subpart F. The required
certification must be submitted by the
funding application submission
deadline announced in the NOFA.
An applicant may provide assistance
under this program only in accordance
with HUD subsidy layering
requirements in section 102 of the
Housing and Urban Development
Reform Act of 1989 (42 U.S.C. 3545). In
this interim rule, HUD clarifies that the
applicant must submit information in its
application on other sources of funding
the applicant has received, or
reasonably expects to receive, for a
proposed project or activities.
Awarding funds. HUD will review
applications in accordance with the
guidelines and procedures specified in
PO 00000
Frm 00010
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
the NOFA and award funds to recipients
through a national competition based on
selection criteria as defined in section
427 of the McKinney-Vento Act. HUD
will announce the awards and notify
selected applicants of any conditions
imposed on the awards.
Grant agreements. A recipient of a
conditionally awarded grant must
satisfy all requirements for obligation of
funds; otherwise, HUD will withdraw
its offer of the award. These conditions
include establishing site control,
providing proof of match, complying
with environmental review under
§ 578.31, and documenting financial
feasibility within the deadlines under
§ 578.21(a)(3). HUD has included in the
interim rule the deadlines for conditions
that may be extended and the reasons
for which HUD will consider an
extension.
The interim rule requires that site
control be established by each recipient
receiving funds for acquisition,
rehabilitation funding, new
construction, or operating costs, or for
providing supportive services. HUD has
determined that the time to establish
site control is 12 months for projects not
receiving new construction, acquisition,
or rehabilitation funding, as stated
under section 426(a) of the McKinneyVento Act, not 9 months as stated under
section 422(d) of the McKinney-Vento
Act, for projects receiving operating and
supportive service funds. HUD’s
determination on the time needed to
establish site control is based on
previous program policy, and the longer
time frame takes into consideration the
reality of the housing market. Projects
receiving acquisition, rehabilitation, or
new construction funding must provide
evidence of site control no later than 24
months after the announcement of grant
awards, as provided under section
422(d) of the McKinney-Vento Act.
The interim rule requires that HUD
perform an environmental review for
each property as required under HUD’s
environmental regulations in 24 CFR
part 50. All recipients of Continuum of
Care program funding under this part
must supply all available, relevant
information necessary to HUD, and
carry out mitigating measures required
by HUD. The recipient, its project
partners, and its project partner’s
contractors may not perform any eligible
activity for a project under this part, or
commit or expend HUD or local funds
for such activities until HUD has
performed an environmental review and
the recipient has received HUD
approval of the property agreements.
Executing grant agreements. If a
Continuum designates more than one
applicant for the geographic area, HUD
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
will enter into a grant agreement with
each designated recipient for which an
award is announced. If a Continuum
designates only one recipient for the
geographic area, HUD may enter into
one grant agreement with that recipient
for new awards, if any; and one grant
agreement for renewals and Continuum
of Care planning costs and UFA costs,
if any. These two grant agreements will
cover the entire geographic area, and a
default by the recipient under one of
these agreements will also constitute a
default under the other. If the
Continuum is a UFA, HUD will enter
into one grant agreement with the UFA
for new awards, if any; and one for
renewal and Continuum of Care
planning costs and UFA costs, if any.
Similarly, these two grant agreements
will cover the entire geographic area
and a default by the recipient under one
of those agreements will also constitute
a default under the other.
HUD requires the recipient to enter
into the agreement described in
§ 578.23(c). Under this agreement, the
grant recipient must agree to ensure that
the operation of the project will be in
accordance with the McKinney-Veto Act
and the requirements under this part. In
addition, the recipient must monitor
and report the progress of the projects
to the Continuum of Care and to HUD.
The recipient must ensure that
individuals and families experiencing
homelessness are involved in the
operation of the project, maintain
confidentiality of program participants,
and monitor and report matching funds
to HUD, among other requirements. The
recipient must also agree to use the
centralized or coordinated assessment
system established by the Continuum of
Care, unless the recipient or
subrecipient is a victim service
provider. Victim service providers may
choose not to use the centralized or
coordinated assessment system
provided that all victim service
providers in the area use a centralized
or coordinated assessment system that
meets HUD’s minimum requirements.
HUD has provided this optional
exception because it understands the
unique role that victim service
providers have within the Continuum of
Care.
Renewals. The interim rule provides
that HUD may fund, through the
Continuum of Care program, all projects
that were previously eligible under the
McKinney-Vento Act prior to the
enactment of the HEARTH Act. These
projects may be renewed to continue
ongoing leasing, operations, supportive
services, rental assistance, HMIS, and
administration beyond the initial
funding period even if those projects
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
would not be eligible under the
Continuum of Care program. For
projects that would no longer be eligible
under the Continuum of Care program
(e.g., safe havens), but which are serving
homeless persons; HUD wants to ensure
that housing is maintained and that
persons do not become homeless
because funding is withdrawn.
HUD may renew projects that were
submitted on time and in such manner
as required by HUD, but did not have
a total score that would allow the
project to be competitively funded. HUD
may choose to exercise this option to
ensure that homeless or formerly
homeless persons do not lose their
housing. The interim rule provides,
based on the language in section 421(e)
of the McKinney-Vento Act, that HUD
may renew the project, upon a finding
that the project meets the purposes of
the Continuum of Care program, for up
to one year and under such conditions
as HUD deems appropriate.
Annual Performance Report. The
interim rule also provides that HUD
may terminate the renewal of any grant
and require the recipient to repay the
renewal grant if the recipient fails to
submit a HUD Annual Performance
Report (APR) within 90 days of the end
of the program year or if the recipient
submits an APR that HUD deems
unacceptable or shows noncompliance
with the requirements of the grant and
this part. Section 578.103(e) of the
Continuum of Care program regulations
further clarifies that recipients receiving
grant funds for acquisition,
rehabilitation, or new construction are
expected to submit APRs for 15 years
from the date of initial occupancy or the
date of initial service provision, unless
HUD provides an exception. The
recipient’s submission of the APR helps
HUD review whether the recipient is
carrying out the project in the manner
proposed in the application. Recipients
agree to submit an APR as a condition
of their grant agreement. This
requirement allows HUD to ensure that
recipients submit APRs on grant
agreements that have expired as a
condition of receiving approval for a
new grant agreement for the renewal
project.
Appeals. The interim rule provides
certain appeal options for applicants
that were not awarded funding.
Under section 422(g) of the
McKinney-Vento Act, if more than one
collaborative applicant submits an
application covering the same
geographic area, HUD must award funds
to the application that scores the highest
score based on the selection criteria set
forth in section 427 of the Act.
Consistent with HUD’s use of the term
PO 00000
Frm 00011
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45431
Continuum of Care in the interim rule
where the statute uses collaborative
applicant, as explained earlier in the
preamble, the interim rule stipulates
that if more than one Continuum of Care
claims the same geographic area, then
HUD will award funds to the
Continuum applicant(s) whose
application(s) has the highest total score
and that no projects from the lower
scoring Continuum of Care will be
funded (and that any projects submitted
with both applications will not be
funded). To appeal HUD’s decision to
fund the competing Continuum of Care,
the applicant(s) from the lower-scoring
Continuum of Care must file the written
appeal in such form and manner as
HUD may require within 45 days of the
date of HUD’s announcement of award.
If an applicant has had a certification
of consistency with a consolidated plan
withheld, that applicant may appeal
such a decision to HUD. HUD has
established a procedure to process the
appeals and no later than 45 days after
the date of receipt of an appeal, HUD
will make a decision.
Section 422(h) of the McKinney-Vento
Act provides the authority for a solo
applicant to submit an application to
HUD and be awarded a grant by HUD
if it meets the criteria under section 427
of the McKinney-Vento Act. The interim
rule clarifies that a solo applicant must
submit its application to HUD by the
deadline established in the NOFA to be
considered for funding. The statute also
requires that HUD establish an appeal
process for organizations that attempted
to participate in the Continuum of
Care’s process and believe they were
denied the right to reasonable
participation, as reviewed in the context
of the local Continuum’s process. An
organization may submit a solo
application to HUD and appeal the
Continuum’s decision not to include it
in the Continuum’s application. If HUD
finds that the solo applicant was not
permitted to participate in the
Continuum of Care process in a
reasonable manner, then HUD may
award the grant to that solo applicant
and may direct the Continuum to take
remedial steps to ensure reasonable
participation in the future. HUD may
also reduce the award to the
Continuum’s applicant(s).
Section 422(h)(1) of the McKinneyVento Act requires that ‘‘HUD establish
a timely appeal procedure for grant
amounts awarded or denied under this
subtitle to a collaborative application.’’
The interim rule sets an appeal process
for denied or decreased funding under
§ 578.35(c). Applicants that are denied
funds by HUD, or that requested more
funds than HUD awarded, may appeal
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
45432
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
by filing a written appeal within 45 days
of the date of HUD’s announcement of
the award. HUD will notify applicant of
its decision on the appeal within 60
days of the date of HUD’s receipt of the
written appeal.
Program Components and Eligible Costs
(Subpart D)
Program components. The interim
rule provides that Continuum of Care
funds may be used for projects under
five program components: Permanent
housing, transitional housing,
supportive services only, HMIS, and, in
some cases, homelessness prevention.
Administrative costs are eligible under
all components. Where possible, the
components set forth in the Continuum
of Care program are consistent with the
components set forth under the
Emergency Solutions Grants program.
This will ease the administrative burden
on recipients of both programs and will
ensure that reporting requirements and
data quality benchmarks are
consistently established and applied to
like projects. One significant distinction
between the Emergency Solutions
Grants program and this part can be
found in the eligible activities and
administration requirements for
assistance provided under the rapid
rehousing component in this interim
rule. The significant differences
between this component in the
Emergency Solutions Grants program
and this part are discussed below.
The interim rule sets forth the costs
eligible for each program component in
§ 578.37(a). The eligible costs for
contributing data to the HMIS
designated by the Continuum of Care
are also eligible under all components.
Consistent with the definition of
permanent housing in section 401 of the
McKinney-Vento Act and § 578.3 of this
interim rule, the permanent housing
component is community-based housing
without a designated length of stay that
permits formerly homeless individuals
and families to live as independently as
possible. The interim rule clarifies that
Continuum of Care funds may be spent
on two types of permanent housing:
Permanent supportive housing for
persons with disabilities (PSH) and
rapid rehousing that provides temporary
assistance (i.e., rental assistance and/or
supportive services) to program
participants in a unit that the program
participant retains after the assistance
ends.
Although the McKinney-Vento Act
authorizes permanent housing without
supportive services, the interim rule
does not. Based on its experience with
the Supportive Housing and Shelter
Plus Care programs, HUD has
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
determined that programs should
require at least case management for
some initial period after exiting
homelessness. HUD has imposed the
requirement that rapid rehousing
include, at a minimum, monthly case
management meetings with program
participants (except where prohibited
by the Violence Against Women Act
(VAWA) and the Family Violence
Prevention and Services Act (FVPSA))
and allows for a full range of supportive
services to be provided for up to 6
months after the rental assistance stops.
Many other HUD programs, such as
Section 8 and HOME, provide housing
without supportive services to lowincome individuals and families.
With respect to rapid rehousing, the
interim rule provides that funds under
this part may be used to provide
supportive services and short-term
and/or medium-term rental assistance.
While the time frames under which a
program participant may receive shortterm or medium-term rental assistance
set forth in this part match the time
frames set forth in the Emergency
Solutions Grants program, the
supportive services available to program
participants receiving rapid rehousing
assistance under the Continuum of Care
program are not limited to housing
relocation and stabilization services as
they are in the Emergency Solutions
Grants program. Program participants
receiving rapid rehousing under this
part may receive any of the supportive
services set forth in § 578.53 during
their participation in the program. The
Continuum of Care, however, does have
the discretion to develop written
policies and procedures that limit the
services available to program
participants that better align the services
available to program participants with
those set forth in the Emergency
Solutions Grants program.
Specific request for comment. While
HUD’s experience with the Supportive
Housing and Shelter Plus Care programs
is the basis for HUD’s determination to
require case management for some
initial period after exiting homelessness,
HUD specifically welcomes comment on
other experiences with monthly case
management.
The interim rule provides that the
HMIS component is for funds that are
used by HMIS Leads only. Eligible costs
include leasing a structure in which the
HMIS is operated, operating funds to
operate a structure in which the HMIS
is operated, and HMIS costs related to
establishing, operating, and customizing
a Continuum of Care’s HMIS.
As set forth in Section 424(c) of the
McKinney-Veto Act, Continuum of Care
funds may be used only for the
PO 00000
Frm 00012
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
homelessness prevention component by
recipients in Continuums of Care that
have been designated HPCs by HUD.
Eligible activities are housing relocation
and stabilization services, and shortand/or medium-term rental assistance,
as set forth in 24 CFR 576.103,
necessary to prevent an individual or
family from becoming homeless.
Planning activities. Under this interim
rule, HUD lists eligible planning costs
for the Continuum of Care under
§ 578.39(b) and (c). HUD will allow no
more than 3 percent of the FPRN, or a
maximum amount to be established by
the NOFA, to be used for certain costs.
These costs must be related to designing
a collaborative process for an
application to HUD, evaluating the
outcomes of funded projects under the
Continuum of Care and Emergency
Solutions Grants programs, and
participating in the consolidated plan(s)
for the geographic area(s). Under section
423 of the McKinney-Vento Act, a
collaborative applicant may use no more
than 3 percent of total funds made
available to pay for administrative costs
related to Continuum of Care planning.
HUD is defining ‘‘of the total funds
made available’’ to mean FPRN, the
higher of PPRN or renewal demand, in
the interim rule. HUD has determined
that FPRN strikes the correct balance, as
it is the higher of PPRN or renewal
demand. This will help Continuums of
Care (CoC) balance: (1) Having sufficient
planning dollars to be successful in its
duties and compete for new money
(which would be the PPRN), and (2)
being able to monitor and evaluate
actual projects in operation (and plan
for renewal demand). The
administrative funds related to CoC
planning made available will be added
to a CoC’s FPRN to establish the CoCs
maximum award amount.
Unified Funding Agency Costs. Under
this interim rule, HUD lists eligible UFA
costs in § 578.41(b) and (c). Similar to
the cap on planning costs for CoC, HUD
will allow no more than 3 percent of the
FPRN, or a maximum amount to be
established by the NOFA, whichever is
less, to be used for UFA costs. This
amount is in addition to the amount
made available for CoC planning costs.
UFA costs include costs associated with
ensuring that all financial transactions
carried out under the Continuum of
Care program are conducted and records
maintained in accordance with
generally accepted accounting
principles, including arranging for an
annual survey, audit, or evaluation of
the financial records of each project
carried out by a subrecipient funded by
a grant received through the Continuum
of Care program. The funds made
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
available to UFAs related to establishing
fiscal controls will be added to a CoC’s
FPRN to establish the CoC maximum
award amount.
Leasing. Under this interim rule, grant
funds may be used to pay the costs of
leasing a structure or structures, or
portions of structures, to provide
housing or supportive services. The
interim rule further clarifies that leasing
means that the lease is between the
recipient of funds and the landlord.
HUD recognizes that some grantees
receiving funds through the Supportive
Housing Program may have been using
their leasing funds in a manner
consistent with the rental assistance
requirements established in § 578.51;
therefore, since the Continuum of Care
program authorizes both leasing and
rental assistance, the rule provides for
an allowance for projects originally
approved to carry out leasing to renew
and request funds for rental assistance,
so long as the rental assistance meets
the requirements in § 578.51. The rule
provides that a recipient of a grant
awarded under the McKinney-Vento
Act, prior to enactment of the HEARTH
Act, must apply for leasing if the lease
is between the recipient and the
landlord, notwithstanding that the grant
was awarded prior to the HEARTH Act
amendments to the McKinney-Vento
Act.
The interim rule provides that leasing
funds may not be used to lease units or
structures owned by the recipient,
subrecipient, their parent
organization(s), any other related
organization(s), or organizations that are
members of a partnership where the
partnership owns the structure, unless
HUD authorizes an exception for good
cause. The interim rule establishes
minimum requirements that a request
for an exception must include. These
exceptions are based on HUD’s
experience in administering the
Homelessness Prevention and Rapid ReHousing Program (HPRP).
The interim rule establishes that
projects for leasing may require that
program participants pay an occupancy
charge (or in the case of a sublease, rent)
of no more than 30 percent of their
income. Income must be calculated in
accordance with HUD’s regulations in
24 CFR 5.609 and 24 CFR 5.611(a).
However, the interim rule clarifies that
projects may not charge program fees.
Rental assistance. Under this interim
rule, rental assistance is an eligible cost
for permanent and transitional housing,
and this rule clarifies that the rental
assistance may be short-term, up to 3
months of rent; medium-term, for 3 to
24 months of rent; and long-term, for
longer than 24 months of rent. This
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
section provides that rental assistance
may include tenant-based, projectbased, or sponsor-based rental
assistance. This section also provides
that project-based rental assistance may
include rental assistance to preserve
existing permanent supportive housing
for homeless individuals and families.
Given that the availability of affordable
rental housing has been shown to be a
key factor in reducing homelessness, the
availability of funding for short-term,
medium-term, and long-term rental
assistance under both the Emergency
Solutions Grants program and the
Continuum of Care program is not
inefficient use of program funds, but
rather effective use of funding for an
activity that lowers the number of
homeless persons.
As noted in the above discussion of
rental housing available for funding
under the Continuum of Care program,
one eligible form of rental assistance is
tenant-based, which allows the program
participant to retain rental assistance for
another unit. The interim rule limits
this retention to within the Continuum
of Care boundaries. HUD has
determined that Continuum of Care
program funds must be used within the
Continuum’s geographic boundaries. If
program participants move outside of
the Continuum, the Continuum may pay
moving costs, security deposits, and the
first month of rent for another unit;
however, the Continuum would have to
organize assistance with the relevant
Continuum of Care for the program
participant if rental assistance is to
continue. The program participant may
be transferred to a rental assistance
program in a different Continuum
without having to become homeless
again. The recipient may also limit the
movement of the assistance to a smaller
area if this is necessary to coordinate
service delivery.
Under this interim rule, the only
exception to the limitation for retention
of tenant-based rental assistance is for
program participants who are victims of
domestic violence, dating violence,
sexual assault, or stalking. Under the
definition of ‘‘tenant-based’’ in the
McKinney-Vento Act (section 401(28) of
the McKinney-Vento Act), these
participants must have complied with
all other obligations of the program and
reasonably believe that he or she is
imminently threatened by harm from
further violence if he or she remains in
the assisted dwelling unit.
In the interim rule, HUD has clarified
that the imminent threat of harm must
be from further domestic violence,
dating violence, sexual assault, or
stalking, which would include threats
from a third party, such as a friend or
PO 00000
Frm 00013
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45433
family member of the perpetrator of the
violence. HUD requires that the program
participant provide appropriate
documentation of the original incident
of domestic violence, dating violence,
sexual assault, or stalking, and any
evidence of the current imminent threat
of harm. Examples of appropriate
documentation of the original incident
of domestic violence, dating violence,
sexual assault, or stalking include
written observation by the housing or
service provider; a letter or other
documentation from a victim service
provider, social worker, legal assistance
provider, pastoral counselor, mental
health provider, or other professional
from whom the victim has sought
assistance; or medical or dental, court,
or law enforcement records.
Documentation of reasonable belief of
further domestic violence, dating
violence, sexual assault, or stalking
includes written observation by the
housing or service provider; a letter or
other written documentation from a
victim service provider, social worker,
legal assistance provider, pastoral
counselor, mental health provider, or
other professional from whom the
victim has requested assistance; a
current restraining order, recent court
order, or other court records; or law
enforcement reports or records. The
housing or service provider may also
consider other documentation such as
emails, voicemails, text messages, social
media posts, and other communication.
Because of the particular safety
concerns surrounding victims of
domestic violence, the interim rule
provides that acceptable evidence for
both the original violence and the
reasonable belief include an oral
statement. This oral statement does not
need to be verified, but it must be
documented by a written certification
by the individual or head of household.
This provision is specific to victims of
domestic violence, dating violence,
sexual assault, and stalking who are
receiving tenant-based rental assistance
in permanent housing. This interim rule
contains other policies for moving
program participants receiving any type
of assistance under this interim rule,
including tenant-based rental assistance,
within the Continuum of Care
geographic area, or smaller geographic
area required by the provider to
coordinate service delivery. Moving
program participants outside of the
geographic area where providers can
coordinate service-delivery is
administratively difficult for providers
and makes it difficult to monitor that
program participants have access to, and
are receiving, appropriate supportive
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
45434
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
services; therefore, moves outside of the
geographic area where the provider can
effectively deliver and monitor service
coordination are allowed only under
exceptional circumstances. HUD has
established these provisions to provide
an exception and to address the
challenges that are associated with such
a move.
Based on HUD’s experience in
administering the Shelter Plus Care
program, the interim rule includes
provisions to clarify when rental
payments may continue to be made to
a landlord when the program
participant no longer resides in the unit.
For vacated units, the interim rule
provides that assistance may continue
for a maximum of 30 days from the end
of the month in which the unit was
vacated, unless the unit is occupied by
another eligible person. A person
staying in an institution for less than 90
days is not considered as having vacated
the unit. Finally, the recipient may use
grant funds, in an amount not to exceed
one month’s rent, to pay for any damage
to housing due to the action of the
program participant, one-time, per
program participant, per unit. This
assistance can be provided only at the
time the program participant exits the
housing unit.
Supportive services. Grant funds may
be used to pay eligible costs of
supportive services for the special needs
of program participants. All eligible
costs are eligible to the same extent for
program participants who are
unaccompanied homeless youth;
persons living with Human
Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)/
Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome
(AIDS) (HIV/AIDS); and victims of
domestic violence, dating violence,
sexual assault, or stalking. Any cost that
is not described as an eligible cost under
this interim rule is not an eligible cost
of providing supportive services.
Eligible costs consist of assistance with
moving costs, case management, child
care, education services, employment
assistance and job training, housing
search and counseling services, legal
services, life skills training, mental
health services, outpatient health
services, outreach services, substance
abuse treatment services, transportation,
and utility deposits.
The definition of ‘‘supportive
services’’ in section 401(27) of the
McKinney-Vento Act includes the
provision of mental health services,
trauma counseling, and victim services.
HUD has determined that victim
services are eligible as supportive
services, and are included as eligible
program costs in this interim rule.
Providers are allowed to provide
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
services specifically to victims of
domestic violence, dating violence,
sexual assault, and stalking. The eligible
costs for providing victim services are
listed as eligible costs in the supportive
services funding category. Rather than
create a new eligible line item in the
project budget, HUD has determined
that these costs can be included in the
funding categories already established.
Indirect costs. Indirect costs are
allowed as part of eligible program
costs. Programs using indirect cost
allocations must be consistent with
Office of Management and Budget
(OMB) Circulars A–87 and A–122, as
applicable. OMB Circular A–87 and the
regulations at 2 CFR part 225 pertain to
‘‘Cost Principles for State, Local, and
Indian Tribal Governments.’’ OMB
Circular A–122 and the regulations
codified at 24 CFR part 230 pertain to
‘‘Cost Principles for Non-Profit
Organizations.’’
Other costs. In addition to the eligible
costs described in this preamble, the
regulation addresses the following other
eligible costs: acquisition, rehabilitation,
new construction, operating costs,
HMIS, project administrative costs, and
relocation costs.
High-Performing Communities (Subpart
E)
Section 424 of the McKinney-Vento
Act establishes the authority for the
establishment of and requirements for
HPCs. Applications must be submitted
by the collaborative applicant at such
time and in such manner as HUD may
require and contain such information as
HUD determines necessary under
§ 578.17(b). Applications will be posted
on the HUD Web site (www.hud.gov) for
public comments. In addition to HUD’s
review of the applications, interested
members of the public will be able to
provide comment to HUD regarding the
applications.
Requirements. The Continuum of Care
must use HMIS data (HUD will publish
data standards and measurement
protocols) to determine that the
standards for qualifying as a HPC are
met. An applicant must submit a report
showing how the Continuum of Care
program funds were expended in the
prior year, and provide information that
the Continuum meets the standards for
HPCs.
Standards. In order to qualify as an
HPC, a Continuum of Care must
demonstrate through reliable data that it
meets all of the required standards. The
interim rule clarifies which standards
will be measured with reliable data from
a Continuum’s HMIS and which
standards will be measured through
reliable data from other sources and
PO 00000
Frm 00014
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
presented in a narrative form or other
format prescribed by HUD.
Continuums must use the HMIS to
demonstrate the following measures: (1)
That the mean length of homelessness
must be less than 20 days for the
Continuum’s geographic area, or the
Continuum’s mean length of episodes
for individuals and families in similar
circumstances was reduced by at least
10 percent from the preceding year; (2)
that less than 5 percent of individuals
and families that leave homelessness
become homeless again any time within
the next 2 years, or the percentage of
individuals and families in similar
circumstances who became homeless
again within 2 years after leaving
homelessness was decreased by at least
20 percent from the preceding year; and
(3) for Continuums of Care that served
homeless families with youth defined as
homeless under other federal statutes,
that 95 percent of those families did not
become homeless again within a 2-year
period following termination of
assistance and that 85 percent of those
families achieved independent living in
permanent housing for at least 2 years
following the termination of assistance.
The McKinney-Vento Act requires
that HUD set forth standards for
preventing homelessness among the
subset of those at the highest risk of
becoming homeless among those
homeless families and youth defined as
homeless under other federal statutes,
the third measure above, one of which
includes achieving independent living
in permanent housing among this
population. HUD has set forth the
standards of 95 percent and 85 percent.
HUD recognizes that these standards are
high, but standards are comparable to
the other standards in the Act, which
are high. It is HUD’s position that HPCs
should be addressing the needs of those
homeless individuals within their
communities prior to receiving
designation of a HPC and being allowed
to spend funds in accordance with
§ 578.71.
The final standard that the
Continuum must use its HMIS data to
demonstrate is provided under section
424(d)(4) of the Act. The statute requires
each homeless individual or family who
sought homeless assistance to be
included in the data system used by that
community. HUD has defined this as
bed-coverage and service-volume
coverage rates of at least 80 percent. The
documentation that each homeless
individual or family who sought
homeless assistance be included in the
HMIS is not measurable by HUD. This
type of standard would be entirely
reliant upon self-reporting.
Additionally, individuals and families
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
have the right to decline having their
data entered into the HMIS. HUD uses
bed-coverage rates and service-volume
coverage rates as a proxy for measuring
the rate of inclusion of persons who are
present for services or housing in the
HMIS. This is a measurable standard,
and HUD defines the calculation in the
HMIS rule; therefore, the measurement
will be consistent between Continuums.
Continuums must use reliable data
from other sources and presented in a
narrative form or other format
prescribed by HUD to measure two
standards: Community action and
renewing HPC status. Section 424(d)(4)
of the McKinney-Vento Act establishes
another standard for HPCs, which is
‘‘community action.’’ This statutory
section provides that communities that
compose the geographic area must have
actively encouraged homeless
individuals and families to participate
in housing and services available in the
geographic area and included each
homeless individual or family who
sought homeless assistance services in
the data system used by that community
for determining compliance. HUD has
defined ‘‘communities that compose the
geographic area’’ to mean the entire
geographic area of the Continuum. This
definition will also provide consistency
of measurement since most of HUD’s
measurements are across the entire
Continuum of Care geographic area.
HUD has further defined ‘‘actively
encourage’’ within this standard as a
comprehensive outreach plan, including
specific steps for identifying homeless
persons and referring them to
appropriate housing and services in that
geographic area. The measurement of
the last part of this standard, ‘‘each
homeless individual or family who
sought homeless assistance services in
the data system used by that
community,’’ will be measured using
reliable data from an HMIS and has
been discussed earlier in this preamble.
HUD has determined this will provide
clarity and ensure consistent
measurement across Continuums.
The interim rule provides that a
Continuum of Care that was an HPC in
the prior year and used Continuum
funds for activities described under
§ 578.71 must demonstrate that these
activities were effective at reducing the
number of persons who became
homeless in that community, to be
renewed as a HPC.
Selection. HUD will select up to 10
Continuums of Care each year that best
meet the application requirements and
the standards set forth in § 578.65.
Consistent with section 424 of the
McKinney-Vento Act, the interim rule
provides a HPC designation for the
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
grants awarded in the same competition
in which the designation is applied for
and made. The designation will be for
a period of one year.
Eligible activities. Recipients and
subrecipients in Continuums that have
been designated an HPC may use grant
funds to provide housing relocation and
stabilization services and short- and/or
medium-term rental assistance to
individuals and families at risk of
homelessness as set for in the
Emergency Solutions Grants program.
All eligible activities discussed in this
section must be effective at stabilizing
individuals and families in their current
housing, or quickly moving such
individuals and families to other
permanent housing. This is the only
time that Continuum of Care funds may
be used to serve nonhomeless
individuals and families. Recipients and
subrecipients using grant funds on these
eligible activities must follow the
written standards established by the
Continuum of Care in § 578.7(a)(9)(v),
and the recordkeeping requirements set
for the Emergency Solutions Grants
program rule.
Program Requirements (Subpart F)
All recipients of Continuum of Care
funding must comply with the program
regulations and the requirements of the
NOFA issued annually by HUD.
Matching. The HEARTH Act allows
for a new, simplified match
requirement. All eligible funding costs
except leasing must be matched with no
less than a 25 percent cash or in-kind
match. The interim rule clarifies that the
match must be provided for the entire
grant, except that recipients that are
UFAs or are the sole recipient for the
Continuum may provide the match on a
Continuum-wide basis.
For in-kind match, the
governmentwide grant requirements of
HUD’s regulations in 24 CFR 84.23 (for
private nonprofit organizations) and
85.24 (for governments) apply. The
regulations in 24 CFR parts 84 and 85
establish uniform administrative
requirements for HUD grants. The
requirements of 24 CFR part 84 apply to
subrecipients that are private nonprofit
organizations. The requirements of 24
CFR part 85 apply to the recipient and
subrecipients that are units of general
purpose local government. The match
requirement in 24 CFR 84.23 and in 24
CFR 85.24 applies to administration
funds, as well as Continuum of Care
planning costs and UFA’s financial
management costs. All match must be
spent on eligible activities as required
under subpart D of this interim rule,
except that recipients and subrecipients
PO 00000
Frm 00015
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45435
in HPCs may use match on eligible
activities described under § 578.71.
General operations. Recipients of
grant funds must provide housing or
services that comply with all applicable
State and local housing codes, licensing
requirements, and any other
requirements in the project’s
jurisdiction. In addition, this interim
rule clarifies that recipients must abide
by housing quality standards and
suitable dwelling size. Recipients must
also assess supportive services on an
ongoing basis, have residential
supervision, and provide for
participation of homeless individuals as
required under section 426(g) of the
McKinney-Vento Act.
Specific request for comment. With
respect to housing quality standards,
HUD includes in this rule the
longstanding requirement from the
Shelter Plus Care program that
recipients or subrecipients, prior to
providing assistance on behalf of a
program participant, must physically
inspect each unit to assure that the unit
meets housing quality standards. This
requirement is designed to ensure that
program participants are placed in
housing that is suitable for living.
Additionally, these requirements are
consistent with HUD’s physical
inspection requirements in its other
mainstream rental assistance programs.
Notwithstanding that this is a
longstanding requirement, HUD
welcomes comment on alternatives to
inspection of each unit that may be less
burdensome but ensure that the housing
provided to a program participant is
decent, safe, and sanitary.
Under Section 578.75, General
Operations, subsection (h), entitled
‘‘Supportive Service Agreements,’’
states that recipients and subrecipients
may require program participants to
take part in supportive services so long
as they are not disability-related
services, provided through the project as
a condition of continued participation
in the program. Examples of disabilityrelated services include, but are not
limited to, mental health services,
outpatient health services, and
provision of medication, which are
provided to a person with a disability to
address a condition caused by the
disability.
This provision further states that if
the purpose of the project is to provide
substance abuse treatment services,
recipients and subrecipients may
require program participants to take part
in such services as a condition of
continued participation in the program.
For example, if a Continuum of Care
recipient operates a transitional housing
program with substance abuse treatment
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
45436
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
services, the recipient may require
program participants to participate in
those services. By contrast, in a program
that offers services but whose purpose is
not substance abuse treatment, a
recipient may not require a person who
is an alcoholic, for example, to sign a
supportive service agreement at initial
occupancy stating that he or she will
participate in substance abuse treatment
services as a condition of occupancy.
All program participants must, however,
meet all terms and conditions of
tenancy, including lease requirements.
If, as a result of a person’s behavior
stemming from substance use, a person
violates the terms of the lease, a
recipient may consider requiring
participation in services or any other
action necessary in order for such a
person to successfully meet the
requirements of tenancy.
Finally, the interim rule clarifies that
in units where the qualifying member of
the household has died, or has been
incarcerated or institutionalized for
more than 90 days, assistance may
continue until the expiration of the
lease in effect at the time of the
qualifying member’s death,
incarceration, or institutionalization.
Displacement, relocation, and
acquisition. All recipients must ensure
that they have taken all reasonable steps
to minimize the displacement of
persons as a result of projects assisted
under this part. This section of the
interim rule is substantially revised
from the previous programs to increase
clarity and comprehension of the
directions to recipients and
subrecipients in the use of grant funds.
Timeliness standards. Recipients
must initiate approved activities and
projects promptly. Recipients of funds
for rehabilitation and new construction
must begin construction activities
within 9 months of the signing of the
grant, and such activities must be
completed within 24 months. HUD is
providing these requirements to assist
communities in meeting the obligation
and expenditure deadline historically
imposed by the annual HUD
appropriations act. HUD may reduce a
grant term to a term of one year if
implementation delays reduce the
amount of funds that can be used during
the original grant term.
Limitation on use of funds. Recipients
of funds provided under this part must
abide by any limitations that apply to
the use of such funds, such as use of
funds for explicitly religious activities.
The limitation on use of funds also
addresses limitation on uses where
religious activities may be concerned. It
is HUD’s position that faith-based
organizations are able to compete for
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
HUD funds and participate in HUD
programs on an equal footing with other
organizations; that no group of
applicants competing for HUD funds
should be subject, as a matter of
discretion, to greater or fewer
requirements than other organizations
solely because of their religious
character or affiliation, or, alternatively,
the absence of religious character or
affiliation. HUD’s general principles
regarding the equal participation of such
organizations in its programs are
codified at 24 CFR 5.109. Programspecific requirements governing faithbased activities are codified in the
regulations for the individual HUD
programs. (See, for example, 24 CFR
574.300(c), 24 CFR 582.115(c), and 24
CFR 583.150(b).)
HUD’s equal participation regulations
were prompted by Executive Order
13279, Equal Protection of the Laws for
Faith-Based and Community
Organizations, issued by President Bush
on December 12, 2002, and published in
the Federal Register on December 16,
2002 (67 FR 77141). Executive Order
13279 set forth principles and
policymaking criteria to guide federal
agencies in ensuring the equal
protection of the laws for faith-based
and community organizations.
Executive Order 13279 was amended by
Executive Order 13559 (Fundamental
Principles and Policymaking Criteria for
Partnerships With Faith-Based and
Other Neighborhood Organizations),
issued by President Obama on
November 17, 2010, and published in
the Federal Register on November 22,
2010 (75 FR 71319).
Executive Order 13559 expands on
the equal participation principles
provided in Executive Order 13279 to
strengthen the capacity of faith-based
and other neighborhood organizations to
deliver services effectively and ensure
the equal treatment of program
beneficiaries. Executive Order 13559
reiterates a key principle underlying
participation of faith-based
organizations in federally funded
activities and that is that faith-based
organizations be eligible to compete for
federal financial assistance used to
support social service programs and to
participate fully in social service
programs supported with federal
financial assistance without impairing
their independence, autonomy,
expression outside the programs in
question, or religious character.
With respect to program beneficiaries,
the Executive Order states that
organizations, in providing services
supported in whole or in part with
federal financial assistance, and in their
outreach activities related to such
PO 00000
Frm 00016
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
services, should not be allowed to
discriminate against current or
prospective program beneficiaries on
the basis of religion, a religious belief,
a refusal to hold a religious belief, or a
refusal to attend or participate in a
religious practice. The Executive Order
directs that organizations that engage in
explicitly religious activities (including
activities that involve overt religious
content such as worship, religious
instruction, or proselytization) must
perform such activities and offer such
services outside of programs that are
supported with direct federal financial
assistance (including through prime
awards or subawards), separately in
time or location from any such programs
or services supported with direct federal
financial assistance, and participation in
any such explicitly religious activities
must be voluntary for the beneficiaries
of the social service program supported
with such federal financial assistance.
For purposes of greater clarity and
comprehensibility, the Executive Order
uses the term ‘‘explicitly religious’’ in
lieu of ‘‘inherently religious.’’ The
Executive Order further directs that if a
beneficiary or prospective beneficiary of
a social service program supported by
federal financial assistance objects to
the religious character of an
organization that provides services
under the program, that organization
shall, within a reasonable time after the
date of the objection, refer the
beneficiary to an alternative provider.
Executive Order 13559 provides for
the establishment of an Interagency
Working Group on Faith-Based and
Other Neighborhood Partnerships
(Working Group) to review and evaluate
existing regulations, guidance
documents, and policies, and directs the
OMB to issue guidance to agencies on
uniform implementation following
receipt of the Working Group’s report.
On April 27, 2012, the Working Group
issued its report, recommending a
model set of regulations and guidance
for agencies to adopt.1
HUD intends to wait for OMB
guidance before initiating any
rulemaking directed to broader changes
to HUD’s existing faith-based
regulations, to ensure consistency with
faith-based regulations of other federal
agencies. However, HUD has revised its
regulatory provisions governing faithbased activities to incorporate the
principles of Executive Order 13559
pertaining to equal treatment of program
beneficiaries and to adopt terminology,
such as ‘‘explicitly religious’’ and ‘‘overt
1 The report is available at: https://
www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/uploads/
finalfaithbasedworkinggroupreport.pdf.
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
religious content,’’ that offers greater
clarity to the limitations placed on faithbased organizations when using federal
funds for their supportive services.
Additionally, HUD is putting in place
through this rulemaking the provision of
Executive Order 13559 that directs the
referral to alternative providers.
Executive Order 13559 provides that if
a beneficiary or prospective beneficiary
of a social service program supported by
federal financial assistance objects to
the religious character of an
organization that provides services
under the program, that organization
shall, within a reasonable time frame
after the date of the objection, refer the
beneficiary to an alternative provider.
While HUD will benefit from OMB
guidance on other provisions of the
Executive Order, specifically those
which the Working Group is charged to
provide recommendations, the
‘‘referral’’ provision of the Executive
Order is one that HUD believes it can
immediately put in place. HUD may,
following receipt of public comment
and further consideration of this issue,
revise how recipients and subrecipients
document the referral to other providers
when beneficiaries may assert
objections to the original provider. For
now, HUD is requiring that any
objections and any referrals be
documented in accordance with the
recordkeeping provisions of § 578.013.
This section of the interim rule also
contains limitations on the types of
eligible assistance that may not be
combined in a single structure or
housing unit. As the Continuum of Care
substantially increases the types of
assistance that may be combined in a
project from previous programs, HUD
has established standards in this section
to provide recipients with clarity about
the types of activities that may not be
carried out in a single structure or
housing unit.
Termination of assistance. The
interim rule provides that a recipient
may terminate assistance to a
participant who violates program
requirements or conditions of
occupancy. The recipient must provide
a formal process that recognizes the due
process of law. Recipients may resume
assistance to a participant whose
assistance has been terminated.
Recipients that are providing
permanent supportive housing for hardto-house populations of homeless
persons must exercise judgment and
examine all circumstances in
determining whether termination is
appropriate. Under this interim rule,
HUD has determined that a participant’s
assistance should be terminated only in
the most severe cases. HUD is carrying
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
over this requirement from the Shelter
Plus Care program.
Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity
requirements. The Continuum of Care,
as well as its members and
subrecipients, are required to comply
with applicable civil rights laws.
Section 578.93, addressing
nondiscrimination and equal
opportunity requirements, is provided
to offer greater direction to recipients
and subrecipients on the use of grant
funds. Section 578.93(a) states that the
nondiscrimination and equal
opportunity requirements set forth in 24
CFR 5.105(a) apply. This includes, but
is not limited to, the Fair Housing Act,
Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964,
Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of
1973 (Section 504), and title II of the
Americans with Disabilities Act.
Section 578.93(b) explains when
recipients and subrecipients may
exclusively serve a particular
subpopulation in transitional or
permanent housing. As part of these
requirements, recipients must also
administer programs and activities
receiving federal financial assistance in
the most integrated setting appropriate
to the needs of qualified individuals
with disabilities. This ‘‘integration
mandate’’ requires that HUD-funded
programs or activities enable
individuals with disabilities to interact
with nondisabled persons to the fullest
extent possible. In reviewing requests
for funding through the Continuum of
Care NOFA, HUD will be considering
each recipient’s proposals to provide
integrated housing to individuals with
disabilities.
There are certain situations in which
a recipient or subrecipient may limit
housing to a specific subpopulation, so
long as admission does not discriminate
against any protected class, as well as
instances where recipients or
subrecipients may limit admission or
provide a preference to certain
subpopulations of homeless persons and
families who need the specialized
services provided in the housing. For
example, § 578.93(b)(2) states that the
housing may be limited to homeless
veterans, so long as admission is not
denied based on any membership in a
protected class; e.g., homeless veterans
with families must be admitted.
Similarly, housing may be limited to
domestic violence victims and their
families or persons who are at risk of
institutionalization, so long as
admission is not denied based on any
membership in a protected class.
Section 578.93(b)(3) states that
housing may be limited to families with
children.
PO 00000
Frm 00017
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45437
Section 578.93(b)(1) states that, in
consideration of personal privacy,
housing may only be limited to a single
sex when such housing consists of a
single structure with shared bedrooms
or bathing facilities such that the
considerations of personal privacy and
the physical limitations of the
configuration of the housing make it
appropriate for the housing to be limited
to one sex.
Further, §§ 578.93(b)(4) and (5) clearly
outline instances when sex offenders or
violent offenders may be excluded from
housing, and when projects providing
sober housing may exclude persons.
HUD’s Section 504 regulations permit
housing funded under a particular
program to be reserved for persons with
a specific disability when a federal
statute or executive order specifically
authorizes such a limitation. Section
578.93(b)(6) states that if the housing is
assisted with funds under a federal
program that is limited by federal
statute or executive order to a specific
subpopulation, the housing may be
limited to that subpopulation.
Section 578.93(b)(7) provides
clarification to recipients of funds under
this part as to when a project can limit
admission to a specific subpopulation of
homeless individuals and families based
on the service package offered in the
project. To help recipients better
understand these requirements, the
following paragraphs provide a detailed
explanation of the regulatory provision,
along with a few examples.
Section 578.93(b)(7) states that
recipients may limit admission to or
provide a preference for the housing to
subpopulations of homeless persons and
families who need the specialized
supportive services that are provided in
the housing. The regulation contains the
following examples: Substance abuse
addiction treatment, domestic violence
services, or a high-intensity package
designed to meet the needs of hard-toreach homeless persons. However,
§ 578.93(b)(7) further states that while
the housing may offer services for a
particular type of disability, no
otherwise eligible individual with a
disability, or family that includes an
individual with a disability, who may
benefit from the services provided may
be excluded on the grounds that they do
not have a particular disability. Below
are general examples to offer guidance
on this subsection. Please note that
these examples are nonexhaustive, but
emphasize that the proper focus is on
the services available as part of the
Continuum of Care project as opposed
to a person’s category or subcategory of
disability. While these general
principles are offered to help clarify this
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
45438
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
section, a change in the factual scenario
may change the analysis.
One clarifying example is as follows.
A private, nonprofit organization or a
local government applies for and
receives a new grant under this part to
provide project-based rental assistance
and services, including case
management, intensive therapy
provided by a psychiatrist, and
medication management. The recipient
or subrecipient may establish a
preference for individuals who are
chronically homeless. When filling an
opening in the housing, the recipient or
subrecipient may target chronically
homeless individuals or families, but if
there are no such individuals or families
either on a waiting list or applying for
entrance to the program, the recipient or
subrecipient cannot deny occupancy to
individuals or families who apply for
entrance into the program and who may
benefit from the services provided.
When filling a vacancy in the housing,
the recipient or subrecipient, if
presented with two otherwise eligible
persons, one who is chronically
homeless and one who is not, may give
a preference to the chronically homeless
individual.
By comparison, § 578.93(b)(6)
addresses situations where Continuum
of Care funds are combined with HUD
funding for housing that may be
restricted to a specific disability. For
example, if Continuum of Care funds for
a specific project are combined with
construction or rehabilitation funding
for housing from the Housing
Opportunities for People With AIDS
program, the program may limit
eligibility for the project to persons with
HIV/AIDS and their families. An
individual or a family that includes an
individual with a disability may be
denied occupancy if the individual or at
least one member of the family does not
have HIV/AIDS.
In another example, a private,
nonprofit organization applies for and
receives Continuum of Care funds from
a local governmental entity to
rehabilitate a five-unit building, and
provides services including assistance
with daily living and mental health
services. While the nonprofit
organization intends to target and
advertise the project as offering services
for persons with developmental
disabilities, an individual with a severe
psychiatric disability who does not have
a developmental disability but who can
benefit from these services cannot be
denied.
Section 578.93(e) incorporates the
‘‘preventing involuntary family
separation’’ requirement set forth in
Section 404 of the McKinney-Veto Act
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
into this interim rule. This provision
clarifies, especially for projects where
the current policy is to deny the
admittance of a boy under the age of 18,
that denying admittance to a project
based on age and gender is no longer
permissible. HUD encourages
Continuums of Care to use their
centralized or coordinated assessment
systems to find appropriate shelter or
housing for families with male children
under the age of 18.
Specific request for comment. HUD
specifically seeks comments from
Continuum of Care-funded recipients on
this requirement. HUD invites
comments about the difficulty that
recipients are going to experience, if
any, in implementing this requirement.
In addition to comments about the
difficulties, HUD invites communities
that have already implemented this
requirement locally to describe their
methods for use in HUD’s technical
assistance materials and for posting on
the HUD Homeless Resource Exchange.
Other standards. In addition to the
program requirements described in this
preamble, the interim rule sets forth
other program requirements by which
all recipients of grant funds must abide.
These include a limitation on the use of
grant funds to serve persons defined as
homeless under other federal laws,
conflicts of interest standards, and
standards for identifying uses of
program income.
Additionally, recipients are required
to follow other federal requirements
contained in this interim rule under
§ 578.99. These include compliance
with such federal requirements as the
Coastal Barriers Resources Act, OMB
Circulars, HUD’s Lead-Based Paint
regulations, and audit requirements.
The wording of these requirements has
been substantially revised from previous
programs, with the objective being to
increase clarity and comprehension of
the directions to recipients and
subrecipients in the use of grant funds.
Administration (Subpart G)
Technical assistance. The purpose of
technical assistance under the
Continuum of Care program is to
increase the effectiveness with which
Continuums of Care, eligible applicants,
recipients, subrecipients, and UFAs
implement and administer their
Continuum of Care planning process.
Technical assistance will also improve
the capacity to prepare applications,
and prevent the separation of families in
projects funded under the Emergency
Solutions Grants, Continuum of Care,
and Rural Housing Stability Assistance
programs. Under this interim rule,
technical assistance means the transfer
PO 00000
Frm 00018
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
of skills and knowledge to entities that
may need, but do not possess, such
skills and knowledge. The assistance
may include written information, such
as papers, manuals, guides, and
brochures; person-to-person exchanges;
and training and related costs.
Therefore, as needed, HUD may
advertise and competitively select
providers to deliver technical
assistance. HUD may enter into
contracts, grants, or cooperative
agreements to implement the technical
assistance. HUD may also enter into
agreements with other federal agencies
when awarding technical assistance
funds.
Recordkeeping requirements. Grant
recipients under the Supportive
Housing Program and the Shelter Plus
Care program have always been required
to show compliance with regulations
through appropriate records. However,
the existing regulations are not specific
about the records to be maintained. The
interim rule for the Continuum of Care
program elaborates upon the
recordkeeping requirements to provide
sufficient notice and clarify the
documentation that HUD requires for
assessing compliance with the program
requirements. The recordkeeping
requirements for documenting homeless
status were published in the December
5, 2011, Defining Homeless final rule.
Because these recordkeeping
requirements already went through a 60day comment period, HUD is not
seeking further comment on these
requirements. Additionally,
recordkeeping requirements with
similar levels of specificity apply to
documentation of ‘‘at risk of
homelessness’’ and these requirements
can be found in § 576.500(c) of the
Emergency Solutions Grants program
interim rule published on December 5,
2011. Because the documentation
requirements pertaining to ‘‘at risk of
homelessness’’ were already subject to a
60-day public comment period, HUD is
not seeking additional comment on
these requirements. Further
requirements are modeled after the
recordkeeping requirements for the
HOME Investment Partnerships Program
(24 CFR 92.508) and other HUD
regulations.
Included along with these changes are
new or expanded requirements
regarding confidentiality, rights of
access to records, record retention
periods, and reporting requirements.
Most significantly, to protect the safety
and privacy of all program participants,
the Continuum of Care rule broadens
the program’s confidentiality
requirements. The McKinney-Vento Act
requires only procedures to ensure the
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
confidentiality of records pertaining to
any individual provided family violence
prevention or treatment services under
this program. The interim rule requires
written procedures to ensure the
security and confidentiality of all
records containing personally
identifying information of any
individual or family who applies for
and/or receives Continuum of Care
assistance.
Grant and project changes. The
interim rule provides that recipients of
grants may not make any significant
changes to use of grant funds without
prior HUD approval, evidenced by a
grant amendment signed by HUD and
the recipient. The interim rule provides
separate standards for determining
when a grant amendment is required for
Continuums having only one recipient,
including UFAs, and Continuums
having more than one recipient.
Additionally, the interim rule provides
contingencies that must be met before
HUD will approve the grant
amendment. These contingencies are
necessary to ensure that recipients meet
the capacity requirements established in
the NOFA and to ensure that eligible
persons within the geographic area are
better served and, since the Continuum
of Care program is a competitive
program, that the priorities established
under the NOFA continue to be met.
Any changes to an approved grant or
project that do not require a grant
amendment, as set forth in this section,
must be fully documented in the
recipient’s or subrecipient’s records.
Sanctions. The interim rule
establishes sanctions based on existing
regulations and strengthens the
enforcement procedures and array of
remedial actions and sanctions for
recipients and subrecipients of
Continuum of Care funds. These
revisions draw from the requirements at
24 CFR 85.43 and other HUD program
regulations.
Close-out. The interim rule provides
that grants must be closed out at the end
of their grant term if recipients are not
seeking renewal. Section 578.109 of this
interim rule specifies the actions that
must be taken after the closeout,
including grantee submission of
financial, final performance, or other
reports required by HUD within 90 days
of the end of the grant term. Any unused
funds must be deobligated and returned
to HUD.
The interim rule stipulates, for grants
seeking renewal, that failure to submit
final performance reports, or other
reports required by HUD within 90
days, may cause renewal funds to be
withdrawn and grant funds expended
on the renewal grant to be repaid.
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
III. Regulations for HUD Homeless
Assistance Programs Existing Prior to
Enactment of HEARTH Act
Because grants are still being
administered under the Shelter Plus
Care program and the Supportive
Housing program, the regulations for
these programs in 24 CFR parts 582, and
583, respectively, will remain in the
Code of Federal Regulations for the time
being. When no more, or very few,
grants remain under these programs,
HUD will remove the regulations in
these parts by a separate rule (if no
grants exist) or will replace them with
a savings clause, which will continue to
govern grant agreements executed prior
to the effective date of the HEARTH Act
regulations.
IV. Conforming Regulations
In addition to establishing the new
regulations for the Continuum of Care
program, HUD is amending the
following regulations, which reference
the Shelter Plus Care Program and the
Supportive Housing Program, to include
reference to the Continuum of Care
program. These regulations are the
regulations pertaining to: (1) Family
Income and Family Payment;
Occupancy Requirements for Section 8
and Public Housing, Other HUDAssisted Housing Serving Persons with
Disabilities, and Section 8 Project-Based
Assistance, the regulations for which are
in 24 CFR part 5, subpart F, specifically,
§ 5.601 (Purpose and Applicability),
paragraphs (d) and (e) of this section;
§ 5.603 (Definitions), specifically the
definition of ‘‘Responsible Entity;’’
§ 5.617 (Self-Sufficiency Incentives for
Persons with Disabilities—Disallowance
of Increase in Annual Income),
paragraph (a) of this section; (2)
Environmental Review Responsibilities
for Entities Assuming HUD
Environmental Responsibilities, the
regulations for which are in 24 CFR part
58, specifically § 58.1 (Purpose and
Applicability), paragraph (b)(3) of this
section; and (3) the Consolidated
Submissions for Community Planning
and Development Programs, the
regulations for which are in 24 CFR part
91, specifically, § 91.2 (Applicability),
paragraph (b) of this section.
V. Justification for Interim Rulemaking
In accordance with its regulations on
rulemaking at 24 CFR part 10, HUD
generally publishes its rules for advance
public comment.2 Notice and public
2 The Administrative Procedure Act (5 U.S.C.
Subchapter II) (APA), which governs federal
rulemaking, provides in section 553(a) that matters
involving a military or foreign affairs function of the
United States or a matter relating to federal agency
PO 00000
Frm 00019
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45439
procedures may be omitted, however, if
HUD determines that, in a particular
case or class of cases, notice and public
comment procedure are ‘‘impracticable,
unnecessary, or contrary to the public
interest.’’ (See 24 CFR 10.1.)
In this case, HUD has determined that
it would be contrary to the public
interest to delay promulgation of the
regulations for the Continuum of Care
program.3 Congress has provided
funding for this new program in the
Consolidated and Further Continuing
Appropriations Act, 2012 (Pub. L. 112–
55, approved November 18, 2011) (FY
2012 Appropriations Act). The FY 2012
Appropriations Act, under the account
for Homeless Assistance Grants,
appropriates not less than $1.593 billion
for the Continuum of Care and Rural
Housing Stability programs. While
many federal programs, including HUD
programs, received a reduction in
funding in the FY 2012 Appropriations
Act, Congress increased funding for
HUD’s homeless assistance grants,
including the Continuum of Care
program. Additionally, the Conference
Report accompanying the FY 2012
Appropriations Act (House Report 112–
284) states in relevant part, as follows:
‘‘The conferees express concern that
HUD continued to implement preHEARTH grant programs in FY 2011,
due to a lack of regulations. The
conferees direct HUD to publish at least
interim guidelines for the Emergency
Solutions Grants and Continuum of Care
programs this fiscal year and to
implement the new grant programs as
soon as possible so that the updated
policies and practices in HEARTH can
begin to govern the delivery of homeless
assistance funding.’’ (See Conf. Rpt. at
page 319. Emphasis added.) Given this
congressional direction, HUD is issuing
this rule providing for regulations for
the Continuum of Care program as an
interim rule. Having interim regulations
in place will allow HUD to move
forward in making FY 2012 funds
available to grantees, and avoid a
significant delay that would result from
issuance, first, of a proposed rule. As
management or personnel or to public property,
loans, grants, benefits, or contracts are exempt from
the advance notice and public comment
requirement of sections 553(b) and (c) of the APA.
In its regulations in 24 CFR 10.1, HUD has waived
the exemption for advance notice and public
comment for matters that relate to public property,
loans, grants, benefits, or contracts, and has
committed to undertake notice and comment
rulemaking for these matters.
3 Although HUD’s regulation in 24 CFR 10.1
provide that HUD will involve public participation
in its rulemaking, this regulation also provides that
notice and public procedure will be omitted if HUD
determines in a particular case or class of cases that
notice and public procedure are impracticable,
unnecessary, or contrary to the public interest.
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
45440
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
has been discussed in this preamble, the
foundation for the Continuum of Care
regulations is the criteria and
requirements provided in NOFAs for the
Continuum of Care Homeless Assistance
Grants Competition program, which
HUD has funded for more than 10 years.
Through the Continuum of Care
Homeless Assistance Grants
Competition program, HUD provided
funding for the Supportive Housing
program, the Shelter Plus Care program,
and the Section 8 Moderate
Rehabilitation Single Room Occupancy
program. The HEARTH Act
consolidated these three competitive
programs into the statutorily established
Continuum of Care program, which was
established as a single grant program.
Interim regulations will provide
certainty with respect to funding
requirements and eligible expenditures
for FY 2012, and the public comment
solicited through this interim rule will
help inform the public procedures that
HUD is contemplating in its regulations
in 24 CFR part 10, and this public
comment, in turn, will inform the final
rule that will follow this interim rule
and govern the funding years following
FY 2012.
For the reasons stated above, HUD is
issuing this rule to take immediate
effect, but welcomes all comments on
this interim rule and all comments will
be taken into consideration in the
development of the final rule.
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
VI. Findings and Certifications
Regulatory Review—Executive Orders
12866 and 13563
Under Executive Order 12866
(Regulatory Planning and Review), a
determination must be made whether a
regulatory action is significant and,
therefore, subject to review by the Office
of Management and Budget (OMB) in
accordance with the requirements of the
order. Executive Order 13563
(Improving Regulations and Regulatory
Review) directs executive agencies to
analyze regulations that are ‘‘outmoded,
ineffective, insufficient, or excessively
burdensome, and to modify, streamline,
expand, or repeal them in accordance
with what has been learned.’’ Executive
Order 13563 also directs that, where
relevant, feasible, and consistent with
regulatory objectives, and to the extent
permitted by law, agencies are to
identify and consider regulatory
approaches that reduce burdens and
maintain flexibility and freedom of
choice for the public. This rule was
determined to be a ‘‘significant
regulatory action,’’ as defined in section
3(f) of Executive Order 12866 (although
not an economically significant
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
regulatory action, as provided under
section 3(f)(1) of the Executive Order).
As has been discussed in this
preamble, this interim rule establishes
the regulations for the Continuum of
Care program, which is the HEARTH
Act’s codification of HUD’s longstanding Continuum of Care planning
process. The HEARTH Act not only
codified in law the planning system
known as Continuum of Care, but
consolidated the three existing
competitive homeless assistance grant
programs (Supportive Housing, Shelter
Plus Care, and Single Room Occupancy)
into the single grant program known as
the Continuum of Care program. As
discussed in the preceding section of
the preamble, HUD funded these three
programs for more than 10 years
through a NOFA, which was titled the
Continuum of Care Homeless Assistance
Grants Competition Program. However,
the funding of the three competitive
grant programs, although done through
a single NOFA, delineated the different
statutes and regulations that governed
each of the three programs (see, for
example, HUD’s 2008 Continuum of
Care NOFA at 73 FR 398450,
specifically page 39845). In
consolidating these three competitive
programs into a single grant program,
the HEARTH Act achieves the
administrative efficiency that HUD
strived to achieve to the extent possible,
through its administrative establishment
of the Continuum of Care planning
process. To the extent permitted by the
HEARTH Act and where feasible, the
regulations build-in flexibility for
grantees, based on experience in
administering the Continuum of Care
program to date. Given the transition
from administrative operation of the
Continuum of Care program to statutory
operation of the Continuum of Care
program, this interim rule would also
have no discernible impact upon the
economy.
The docket file is available for public
inspection in the Regulations Division,
Office of the General Counsel, Room
10276, 451 7th Street SW., Washington,
DC 20410–0500. Due to security
measures at the HUD Headquarters
building, please schedule an
appointment to review the docket file by
calling the Regulations Division at 202–
708–3055 (this is not a toll-free
number). Individuals with speech or
hearing impairments may access this
number via TTY by calling the Federal
Relay Service at 800–877–8339.
Environmental Impact
A Finding of No Significant Impact
(FONSI) with respect to the
environment has been made in
PO 00000
Frm 00020
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
accordance with HUD regulations at 24
CFR part 50, which implement section
102(2)(C) of the National Environmental
Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C.
4332(2)(C)). The Finding of No
Significant Impact is available for public
inspection between the hours of 8 a.m.
and 5 p.m. weekdays in the Regulations
Division, Office of General Counsel,
Department of Housing and Urban
Development, 451 7th Street SW., Room
10276, Washington, DC 20410–0500.
Due to security measures at the HUD
Headquarters building, please schedule
an appointment to review the FONSI by
calling the Regulations Division at 202–
708–3055 (this is not a toll-free
number). Individuals with speech or
hearing impairments may access this
number via TTY by calling the Federal
Relay Service at 800–877–8339.
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act
The Unfunded Mandates Reform Act
of 1995 (2 U.S.C. 1531–1538) (UMRA)
establishes requirements for federal
agencies to assess the effects of their
regulatory actions on State, local, and
tribal governments and on the private
sector. This interim rule does not
impose a federal mandate on any State,
local, or tribal government, or on the
private sector, within the meaning of
UMRA.
Regulatory Flexibility Act
The Regulatory Flexibility Act (5
U.S.C. 601 et seq.) generally requires an
agency to conduct a regulatory
flexibility analysis of any rule subject to
notice and comment rulemaking
requirements, unless the agency certifies
that the rule will not have a significant
economic impact on a substantial
number of small entities. This rule
solely addresses the allocation and use
of grant funds under the new
McKinney-Vento Act homeless
assistance programs, as consolidated
and amended by the HEARTH Act. As
discussed in the preamble, the majority
of the regulatory provisions proposed by
this rule track the regulatory provisions
of the Continuum of Care program, with
which prospective recipients of the
Supportive Housing program and the
Shelter Plus Care program are familiar.
Accordingly, the program requirements
should raise minimal issues because
applicants and grantees are familiar
with these requirements, and in
response to HUD’s solicitations to them
on the burden of the requirements for
the Supportive Housing program and
the Shelter Plus Care program, grantees
have not advised that such requirements
are burdensome. Therefore, HUD has
determined that this rule would not
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
have a significant economic impact on
a substantial number of small entities.
Notwithstanding HUD’s
determination that this rule will not
have a significant effect on a substantial
number of small entities, HUD
specifically invites comments regarding
any less burdensome alternatives to this
rule that will meet HUD’s objectives as
described in this preamble.
Executive Order 13132, Federalism
Executive Order 13132 (entitled
‘‘Federalism’’) prohibits an agency from
publishing any rule that has federalism
implications if the rule either imposes
45441
rule have been submitted to the Office
of Management and Budget (OMB)
under the Paperwork Reduction Act of
1995 (44 U.S.C. 3501–3520). In
accordance with the Paperwork
Reduction Act, an agency may not
conduct or sponsor, and a person is not
required to respond to, a collection of
information, unless the collection
displays a currently valid OMB control
number.
The burden of the information
collections in this interim rule is
estimated as follows:
substantial direct compliance costs on
State and local governments and is not
required by statute, or the rule preempts
State law, unless the agency meets the
consultation and funding requirements
of section 6 of the Executive Order. This
final rule does not have federalism
implications and does not impose
substantial direct compliance costs on
State and local governments nor
preempts State law within the meaning
of the Executive Order.
Paperwork Reduction Act
The information collection
requirements contained in this interim
REPORTING AND RECORDKEEPING BURDEN
Number of
respondents
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Information collection
§ 578.5(a) Establishing the CoC ..........................................
§ 578.5(b) Establishing the Board ........................................
§ 578.7(a)(1) Hold CoC Meetings ........................................
§ 578.7(a)(2) Invitation for New Members ...........................
§ 578.7(a)(4) Appoint committees ........................................
§ 578.7(a)(5) Governance charter ........................................
§ 578.7(a)(6) and (7) Monitor performance and evaluation
§ 578.7(a)(8) Centralized or coordinated assessment system ....................................................................................
§ 578.7(a)(9) Written standards ...........................................
§ 578.7(b) Designate HMIS ..................................................
§ 578.9 Application for funds ...............................................
§ 578.11(c) Develop CoC plan .............................................
§ 578.21(c) Satisfying conditions .........................................
§ 578.23 Executing grant agreements .................................
§ 578.35(b) Appeal—solo .....................................................
§ 578.35(c) Appeal—denied or decreased funding .............
§ 578.35(d) Appeal—competing CoC ..................................
§ 578.35(e) Appeal—Consolidated Plan certification ..........
§ 578.49(a)—Leasing exceptions .........................................
§ 578.65 HPC Standards .....................................................
§ 578.75(a)(1) State and local requirements—appropriate
service provision ...............................................................
§ 578.75(a)(1) State and local requirements—housing
codes ................................................................................
§ 578.75(b) Housing quality standards ................................
§ 578.75(b) Suitable dwelling size .......................................
§ 578.75(c) Meals .................................................................
§ 578.75(e) Ongoing assessment of supportive services ....
§ 578.75(f) Residential supervision ......................................
§ 578.75(g) Participation of homeless individuals ...............
§ 578.75(h) Supportive service agreements ........................
§ 578.77(a) Signed leases/occupancy agreements .............
§ 578.77(b) Calculating occupancy charges ........................
§ 578.77(c) Calculating rent .................................................
§ 578.81(a) Use restriction ...................................................
§ 578.91(a) Termination of assistance .................................
§ 578.91(b) Due process for termination of assistance .......
§ 578.95(d)—Conflict-of-Interest exceptions ........................
§ 578.103(a)(3) Documenting homelessness ......................
§ 578.103(a)(4) Documenting at risk of homelessness .......
§ 578.103(a)(5) Documenting imminent threat of harm .......
§ 578.103(a)(7) Documenting program participant records
§ 578.103(a)(7) Documenting case management ...............
§ 578.103(a)(13) Documenting faith-based activities ..........
§ 578.103(b) Confidentiality procedures ..............................
§ 578.105(a) Grant/project changes—UFAs ........................
§ 578.105(b) Grant/project changes—multiple project applicants .................................................................................
Total ..............................................................................
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
PO 00000
Response
frequency
(average)
Total annual
responses
Burden hours
per response
Total annual
hours
450
450
450
450
450
450
450
1
1
2
1
2
1
4
450
450
900
450
900
450
450
8.0
5.0
4.0
1.0
0.5
7.0
9.0
3,600
2,250
3,600
450
450
3,150
4,050
450
450
450
450
450
8,000
8,000
10
15
10
5
5
20
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
450
450
450
450
450
8,000
8,000
10
15
10
5
5
20
8.0
5.0
10.0
180.0
9.0
4.0
1.0
4.0
1.0
5.0
2.0
1.5
10.0
3,600
2,250
4,500
81,000
4,050
32,000
8,000
40
15
50
10
7.5
200
7,000
1
7,000
0.5
3,500
20
145,600
145,600
70,720
8,000
19,800
11,500
30,000
208,000
368,000
400,000
20
400
4,500
10
300,000
10,000
200
2,100,000
96,000
8,000
11,500
40
3.0
1.0
0.08
0.5
1.5
0.75
1.0
0.5
1.0
0.75
0.75
0.5
4.00
3.0
3.0
0.25
0.25
0.5
0.25
1.0
1.0
1.0
2.0
60
145,600
11,648
35,360
12,000
14,850
11,500
15,000
208,000
276,000
300,000
10
1,600
13,500
30
75,000
2,500
100
525,000
96,000
8,000
11,500
80
800
2.0
1,600
........................
........................
1,921,710.5
20
72,800
72,800
70,720
8,000
6,600
11,500
3,000
104,000
1,840
2,000
20
400
4,500
10
300,000
10,000
200
350,000
8,000
8,000
11,500
20
1
2
2
1
1
3
1
100
2
200
200
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
6
12
1
1
2
800
........................
Frm 00021
Fmt 4701
1
........................
Sfmt 4700
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
45442
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
In accordance with 5 CFR
1320.8(d)(1), HUD is soliciting
comments from members of the public
and affected agencies concerning this
collection of information to:
(1) Evaluate whether the proposed
collection of information is necessary
for the proper performance of the
functions HUD, including whether the
information will have practical utility;
(2) Evaluate the accuracy of HUD’s
estimate of the burden of the proposed
collection of information;
(3) Enhance the quality, utility, and
clarity of the information to be
collected; and
(4) Minimize the burden of the
collection of information on those who
are to respond, including through the
use of appropriate automated collection
techniques or other forms of information
technology; e.g., permitting electronic
submission of responses.
Interested persons are invited to
submit comments regarding the
information collection requirements in
this rule. Comments must refer to the
proposal by name and docket number
(FR–5476–I–01) and be sent to: HUD
Desk Officer, Office of Management and
Budget, New Executive Office Building,
Washington, DC 20503, Fax: (202) 395–
6947, and Reports Liaison Officer,
Office of the Assistant Secretary for
Community Planning and Development,
Department of Housing and Urban
Development, 451 Seventh Street SW.,
Room 7233, Washington, DC 20410–
7000.
Interested persons may submit
comments regarding the information
collection requirements electronically
through the Federal eRulemaking Portal
at https://www.regulations.gov. HUD
strongly encourages commenters to
submit comments electronically.
Electronic submission of comments
allows the commenter maximum time to
prepare and submit a comment, ensures
timely receipt by HUD, and enables
HUD to make them immediately
available to the public. Comments
submitted electronically through the
https://www.regulations.gov Web site can
be viewed by other commenters and
interested members of the public.
Commenters should follow the
instructions provided on that site to
submit comments electronically.
List of Subjects in 24 CFR Part 578
Community facilities, Continuum of
Care, Emergency solutions grants, Grant
programs—housing and community
development, Grant program—social
programs, Homeless, Rural housing,
Reporting and recordkeeping
requirements, Supportive housing
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:15 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
programs— housing and community
development, Supportive services.
Accordingly, for the reasons described
in the preamble, HUD adds part 578 to
subchapter C of chapter V of subtitle B
of 24 CFR to read as follows:
PART 578—CONTINUUM OF CARE
PROGRAM
Subpart A—General Provisions
Sec.
578.1 Purpose and scope.
578.3 Definitions.
Subpart B—Establishing and Operating a
Continuum of Care
578.5 Establishing the Continuum of Care.
578.7 Responsibilities of the Continuum of
Care.
578.9 Preparing an application for funds.
578.11 Unified Funding Agency.
578.13 Remedial action.
Subpart C—Application and Grant Award
Process
578.15 Eligible applicants.
578.17 Overview of application and grant
award process.
578.19 Application process.
578.21 Awarding funds.
578.23 Executing grant agreements.
578.25 Site control.
578.27 Consolidated plan.
578.29 Subsidy layering.
578.31 Environmental review.
578.33 Renewals.
578.35 Appeal.
Subpart D—Program Components and
Eligible Costs
578.37 Program components and uses of
assistance.
578.39 Continuum of Care planning
activities.
578.41 Unified Funding Agency costs.
578.43 Acquisition.
578.45 Rehabilitation.
578.47 New construction.
578.49 Leasing.
578.51 Rental assistance.
578.53 Supportive services.
578.55 Operating costs.
578.57 Homeless Management Information
System.
578.59 Project administrative costs.
578.61 Relocation costs.
578.63 Indirect costs.
Subpart E—High-Performing Communities
578.65 Standards.
578.67 Publication of application.
578.69 Cooperation among entities.
578.71 HPC-eligible activities.
Subpart F—Program Requirements
578.73 Matching requirements.
578.75 General operations.
578.77 Calculating occupancy charges and
rent.
578.79 Limitation on transitional housing.
578.81 Term of commitment, repayment of
grants, and prevention of undue benefits.
578.83 Displacement, relocation, and
acquisition.
578.85 Timeliness standards.
PO 00000
Frm 00022
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
578.87 Limitation on use of funds.
578.89 Limitation on use of grant funds to
serve persons defined as homeless under
other federal laws.
578.91 Termination of assistance to
program participants.
578.93 Fair Housing and Equal
Opportunity.
578.95 Conflicts of interest.
578.97 Program income.
578.99 Applicability of other federal
requirements.
Subpart G—Grant Administration
578.101 Technical assistance.
578.103 Recordkeeping requirements.
578.105 Grant and project changes.
578.107 Sanctions.
578.109 Closeout.
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 11371 et seq., 42
U.S.C. 3535(d).
Subpart A—General Provisions
§ 578.1
Purpose and scope.
(a) The Continuum of Care program is
authorized by subtitle C of title IV of the
McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance
Act (42 U.S.C. 11381–11389).
(b) The program is designed to:
(1) Promote communitywide
commitment to the goal of ending
homelessness;
(2) Provide funding for efforts by
nonprofit providers, States, and local
governments to quickly rehouse
homeless individuals (including
unaccompanied youth) and families,
while minimizing the trauma and
dislocation caused to homeless
individuals, families, and communities
by homelessness;
(3) Promote access to and effective
utilization of mainstream programs by
homeless individuals and families; and
(4) Optimize self-sufficiency among
individuals and families experiencing
homelessness.
§ 578.3
Definitions.
As used in this part:
Act means the McKinney-Vento
Homeless Assistance Act as amended
(42 U.S.C. 11371 et seq.).
Annual renewal amount means the
amount that a grant can be awarded on
an annual basis when renewed. It
includes funds only for those eligible
activities (operating, supportive
services, leasing, rental assistance,
HMIS, and administration) that were
funded in the original grant (or the
original grant as amended), less the
unrenewable activities (acquisition, new
construction, rehabilitation, and any
administrative costs related to these
activities).
Applicant means an eligible applicant
that has been designated by the
Continuum of Care to apply for
assistance under this part on behalf of
that Continuum.
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
At risk of homelessness. (1) An
individual or family who:
(i) Has an annual income below 30
percent of median family income for the
area, as determined by HUD;
(ii) Does not have sufficient resources
or support networks, e.g., family,
friends, faith-based or other social
networks, immediately available to
prevent them from moving to an
emergency shelter or another place
described in paragraph (1) of the
‘‘Homeless’’ definition in this section;
and
(iii) Meets one of the following
conditions:
(A) Has moved because of economic
reasons two or more times during the 60
days immediately preceding the
application for homelessness prevention
assistance;
(B) Is living in the home of another
because of economic hardship;
(C) Has been notified in writing that
their right to occupy their current
housing or living situation will be
terminated within 21 days of the date of
application for assistance;
(D) Lives in a hotel or motel and the
cost of the hotel or motel stay is not paid
by charitable organizations or by
federal, State, or local government
programs for low-income individuals;
(E) Lives in a single-room occupancy
or efficiency apartment unit in which
there reside more than two persons, or
lives in a larger housing unit in which
there reside more than 1.5 people per
room, as defined by the U.S. Census
Bureau;
(F) Is exiting a publicly funded
institution, or system of care (such as a
health-care facility, a mental health
facility, foster care or other youth
facility, or correction program or
institution); or
(G) Otherwise lives in housing that
has characteristics associated with
instability and an increased risk of
homelessness, as identified in the
recipient’s approved consolidated plan;
(2) A child or youth who does not
qualify as ‘‘homeless’’ under this
section, but qualifies as ‘‘homeless’’
under section 387(3) of the Runaway
and Homeless Youth Act (42 U.S.C.
5732a(3)), section 637(11) of the Head
Start Act (42 U.S.C. 9832(11)), section
41403(6) of the Violence Against
Women Act of 1994 (42 U.S.C. 14043e–
2(6)), section 330(h)(5)(A) of the Public
Health Service Act (42 U.S.C.
254b(h)(5)(A)), section 3(m) of the Food
and Nutrition Act of 2008 (7 U.S.C.
2012(m)), or section 17(b)(15) of the
Child Nutrition Act of 1966 (42 U.S.C.
1786(b)(15)); or
(3) A child or youth who does not
qualify as ‘‘homeless’’ under this
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
section, but qualifies as ‘‘homeless’’
under section 725(2) of the McKinneyVento Homeless Assistance Act (42
U.S.C. 11434a(2)), and the parent(s) or
guardian(s) of that child or youth if
living with her or him.
Centralized or coordinated
assessment system means a centralized
or coordinated process designed to
coordinate program participant intake
assessment and provision of referrals. A
centralized or coordinated assessment
system covers the geographic area, is
easily accessed by individuals and
families seeking housing or services, is
well advertized, and includes a
comprehensive and standardized
assessment tool.
Chronically homeless. (1) An
individual who:
(i) Is homeless and lives in a place not
meant for human habitation, a safe
haven, or in an emergency shelter; and
(ii) Has been homeless and living or
residing in a place not meant for human
habitation, a safe haven, or in an
emergency shelter continuously for at
least one year or on at least four separate
occasions in the last 3 years; and
(iii) Can be diagnosed with one or
more of the following conditions:
substance use disorder, serious mental
illness, developmental disability (as
defined in section 102 of the
Developmental Disabilities Assistance
Bill of Rights Act of 2000 (42 U.S.C.
15002)), post-traumatic stress disorder,
cognitive impairments resulting from
brain injury, or chronic physical illness
or disability;
(2) An individual who has been
residing in an institutional care facility,
including a jail, substance abuse or
mental health treatment facility,
hospital, or other similar facility, for
fewer than 90 days and met all of the
criteria in paragraph (1) of this
definition, before entering that facility;
or
(3) A family with an adult head of
household (or if there is no adult in the
family, a minor head of household) who
meets all of the criteria in paragraph (1)
of this definition, including a family
whose composition has fluctuated while
the head of household has been
homeless.
Collaborative applicant means the
eligible applicant that has been
designated by the Continuum of Care to
apply for a grant for Continuum of Care
planning funds under this part on behalf
of the Continuum.
Consolidated plan means the HUDapproved plan developed in accordance
with 24 CFR 91.
Continuum of Care and Continuum
means the group organized to carry out
the responsibilities required under this
PO 00000
Frm 00023
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45443
part and that is composed of
representatives of organizations,
including nonprofit homeless providers,
victim service providers, faith-based
organizations, governments, businesses,
advocates, public housing agencies,
school districts, social service providers,
mental health agencies, hospitals,
universities, affordable housing
developers, law enforcement,
organizations that serve homeless and
formerly homeless veterans, and
homeless and formerly homeless
persons to the extent these groups are
represented within the geographic area
and are available to participate.
Developmental disability means, as
defined in section 102 of the
Developmental Disabilities Assistance
and Bill of Rights Act of 2000 (42 U.S.C.
15002):
(1) A severe, chronic disability of an
individual that—
(i) Is attributable to a mental or
physical impairment or combination of
mental and physical impairments;
(ii) Is manifested before the individual
attains age 22;
(iii) Is likely to continue indefinitely;
(iv) Results in substantial functional
limitations in three or more of the
following areas of major life activity:
(A) Self-care;
(B) Receptive and expressive
language;
(C) Learning;
(D) Mobility;
(E) Self-direction;
(F) Capacity for independent living;
(G) Economic self-sufficiency.
(v) Reflects the individual’s need for
a combination and sequence of special,
interdisciplinary, or generic services,
individualized supports, or other forms
of assistance that are of lifelong or
extended duration and are individually
planned and coordinated.
(2) An individual from birth to age 9,
inclusive, who has a substantial
developmental delay or specific
congenital or acquired condition, may
be considered to have a developmental
disability without meeting three or more
of the criteria described in paragraphs
(1)(i) through (v) of the definition of
‘‘developmental disability’’ in this
section if the individual, without
services and supports, has a high
probability of meeting these criteria
later in life.
Eligible applicant means a private
nonprofit organization, State, local
government, or instrumentality of State
and local government.
Emergency shelter is defined in 24
CFR part 576.
Emergency Solutions Grants (ESG)
means the grants provided under 24
CFR part 576.
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
45444
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
Fair Market Rent (FMR) means the
Fair Market Rents published in the
Federal Register annually by HUD.
High-performing community (HPC)
means a Continuum of Care that meets
the standards in subpart E of this part
and has been designated as a highperforming community by HUD.
Homeless means:
(1) An individual or family who lacks
a fixed, regular, and adequate nighttime
residence, meaning:
(i) An individual or family with a
primary nighttime residence that is a
public or private place not designed for
or ordinarily used as a regular sleeping
accommodation for human beings,
including a car, park, abandoned
building, bus or train station, airport, or
camping ground;
(ii) An individual or family living in
a supervised publicly or privately
operated shelter designated to provide
temporary living arrangements
(including congregate shelters,
transitional housing, and hotels and
motels paid for by charitable
organizations or by federal, State, or
local government programs for lowincome individuals); or
(iii) An individual who is exiting an
institution where he or she resided for
90 days or less and who resided in an
emergency shelter or place not meant
for human habitation immediately
before entering that institution;
(2) An individual or family who will
imminently lose their primary nighttime
residence, provided that:
(i) The primary nighttime residence
will be lost within 14 days of the date
of application for homeless assistance;
(ii) No subsequent residence has been
identified; and
(iii) The individual or family lacks the
resources or support networks, e.g.,
family, friends, faith-based or other
social networks, needed to obtain other
permanent housing;
(3) Unaccompanied youth under 25
years of age, or families with children
and youth, who do not otherwise
qualify as homeless under this
definition, but who:
(i) Are defined as homeless under
section 387 of the Runaway and
Homeless Youth Act (42 U.S.C. 5732a),
section 637 of the Head Start Act (42
U.S.C. 9832), section 41403 of the
Violence Against Women Act of 1994
(42 U.S.C. 14043e–2), section 330(h) of
the Public Health Service Act (42 U.S.C.
254b(h)), section 3 of the Food and
Nutrition Act of 2008 (7 U.S.C. 2012),
section 17(b) of the Child Nutrition Act
of 1966 (42 U.S.C. 1786(b)), or section
725 of the McKinney-Vento Homeless
Assistance Act (42 U.S.C. 11434a);
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
(ii) Have not had a lease, ownership
interest, or occupancy agreement in
permanent housing at any time during
the 60 days immediately preceding the
date of application for homeless
assistance;
(iii) Have experienced persistent
instability as measured by two moves or
more during the 60-day period
immediately preceding the date of
applying for homeless assistance; and
(iv) Can be expected to continue in
such status for an extended period of
time because of chronic disabilities;
chronic physical health or mental health
conditions; substance addiction;
histories of domestic violence or
childhood abuse (including neglect); the
presence of a child or youth with a
disability; or two or more barriers to
employment, which include the lack of
a high school degree or General
Education Development (GED),
illiteracy, low English proficiency, a
history of incarceration or detention for
criminal activity, and a history of
unstable employment; or
(4) Any individual or family who:
(i) Is fleeing, or is attempting to flee,
domestic violence, dating violence,
sexual assault, stalking, or other
dangerous or life-threatening conditions
that relate to violence against the
individual or a family member,
including a child, that has either taken
place within the individual’s or family’s
primary nighttime residence or has
made the individual or family afraid to
return to their primary nighttime
residence;
(ii) Has no other residence; and
(iii) Lacks the resources or support
networks, e.g., family, friends, and faithbased or other social networks, to obtain
other permanent housing.
Homeless Management Information
System (HMIS) means the information
system designated by the Continuum of
Care to comply with the HMIS
requirements prescribed by HUD.
HMIS Lead means the entity
designated by the Continuum of Care in
accordance with this part to operate the
Continuum’s HMIS on its behalf.
Permanent housing means
community-based housing without a
designated length of stay, and includes
both permanent supportive housing and
rapid rehousing. To be permanent
housing, the program participant must
be the tenant on a lease for a term of at
least one year, which is renewable for
terms that are a minimum of one month
long, and is terminable only for cause.
Permanent supportive housing means
permanent housing in which supportive
services are provided to assist homeless
persons with a disability to live
independently.
PO 00000
Frm 00024
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
Point-in-time count means a count of
sheltered and unsheltered homeless
persons carried out on one night in the
last 10 calendar days of January or at
such other time as required by HUD.
Private nonprofit organization means
an organization:
(1) No part of the net earnings of
which inure to the benefit of any
member, founder, contributor, or
individual;
(2) That has a voluntary board;
(3) That has a functioning accounting
system that is operated in accordance
with generally accepted accounting
principles, or has designated a fiscal
agent that will maintain a functioning
accounting system for the organization
in accordance with generally accepted
accounting principles; and
(4) That practices nondiscrimination
in the provision of assistance.
A private nonprofit organization does
not include governmental organizations,
such as public housing agencies.
Program participant means an
individual (including an
unaccompanied youth) or family who is
assisted with Continuum of Care
program funds.
Project means a group of eligible
activities, such as HMIS costs, identified
as a project in an application to HUD for
Continuum of Care funds and includes
a structure (or structures) that is (are)
acquired, rehabilitated, constructed, or
leased with assistance provided under
this part or with respect to which HUD
provides rental assistance or annual
payments for operating costs, or
supportive services under this subtitle.
Recipient means an applicant that
signs a grant agreement with HUD.
Safe haven means, for the purpose of
defining chronically homeless,
supportive housing that meets the
following:
(1) Serves hard to reach homeless
persons with severe mental illness who
came from the streets and have been
unwilling or unable to participate in
supportive services;
(2) Provides 24-hour residence for
eligible persons for an unspecified
period;
(3) Has an overnight capacity limited
to 25 or fewer persons; and
(4) Provides low-demand services and
referrals for the residents.
State means each of the 50 States, the
District of Columbia, the
Commonwealth of Puerto Rico,
American Samoa, Guam, the
Commonwealth of the Northern
Marianas, and the Virgin Islands.
Subrecipient means a private
nonprofit organization, State, local
government, or instrumentality of State
or local government that receives a
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
subgrant from the recipient to carry out
a project.
Transitional housing means housing,
where all program participants have
signed a lease or occupancy agreement,
the purpose of which is to facilitate the
movement of homeless individuals and
families into permanent housing within
24 months or such longer period as
HUD determines necessary. The
program participant must have a lease
or occupancy agreement for a term of at
least one month that ends in 24 months
and cannot be extended.
Unified Funding Agency (UFA) means
an eligible applicant selected by the
Continuum of Care to apply for a grant
for the entire Continuum, which has the
capacity to carry out the duties in
§ 578.11(b), which is approved by HUD
and to which HUD awards a grant.
Victim service provider means a
private nonprofit organization whose
primary mission is to provide services
to victims of domestic violence, dating
violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
This term includes rape crisis centers,
battered women’s shelters, domestic
violence transitional housing programs,
and other programs.
Subpart B—Establishing and
Operating a Continuum of Care
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
§ 578.5
Care.
Establishing the Continuum of
(a) The Continuum of Care.
Representatives from relevant
organizations within a geographic area
shall establish a Continuum of Care for
the geographic area to carry out the
duties of this part. Relevant
organizations include nonprofit
homeless assistance providers, victim
service providers, faith-based
organizations, governments, businesses,
advocates, public housing agencies,
school districts, social service providers,
mental health agencies, hospitals,
universities, affordable housing
developers, law enforcement, and
organizations that serve veterans and
homeless and formerly homeless
individuals.
(b) The board. The Continuum of Care
must establish a board to act on behalf
of the Continuum using the process
established as a requirement by
§ 578.7(a)(3) and must comply with the
conflict-of-interest requirements at
§ 578.95(b). The board must:
(1) Be representative of the relevant
organizations and of projects serving
homeless subpopulations; and
(2) Include at least one homeless or
formerly homeless individual.
(c) Transition. Continuums of Care
shall have 2 years after August 30, 2012
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
to comply with the requirements of
paragraph (b) of this section.
§ 578.7 Responsibilities of the Continuum
of Care.
(a) Operate the Continuum of Care.
The Continuum of Care must:
(1) Hold meetings of the full
membership, with published agendas, at
least semi-annually;
(2) Make an invitation for new
members to join publicly available
within the geographic at least annually;
(3) Adopt and follow a written
process to select a board to act on behalf
of the Continuum of Care. The process
must be reviewed, updated, and
approved by the Continuum at least
once every 5 years;
(4) Appoint additional committees,
subcommittees, or workgroups;
(5) In consultation with the
collaborative applicant and the HMIS
Lead, develop, follow, and update
annually a governance charter, which
will include all procedures and policies
needed to comply with subpart B of this
part and with HMIS requirements as
prescribed by HUD; and a code of
conduct and recusal process for the
board, its chair(s), and any person acting
on behalf of the board;
(6) Consult with recipients and
subrecipients to establish performance
targets appropriate for population and
program type, monitor recipient and
subrecipient performance, evaluate
outcomes, and take action against poor
performers;
(7) Evaluate outcomes of projects
funded under the Emergency Solutions
Grants program and the Continuum of
Care program, and report to HUD;
(8) In consultation with recipients of
Emergency Solutions Grants program
funds within the geographic area,
establish and operate either a
centralized or coordinated assessment
system that provides an initial,
comprehensive assessment of the needs
of individuals and families for housing
and services. The Continuum must
develop a specific policy to guide the
operation of the centralized or
coordinated assessment system on how
its system will address the needs of
individuals and families who are
fleeing, or attempting to flee, domestic
violence, dating violence, sexual
assault, or stalking, but who are seeking
shelter or services from nonvictim
service providers. This system must
comply with any requirements
established by HUD by Notice.
(9) In consultation with recipients of
Emergency Solutions Grants program
funds within the geographic area,
establish and consistently follow
written standards for providing
PO 00000
Frm 00025
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45445
Continuum of Care assistance. At a
minimum, these written standards must
include:
(i) Policies and procedures for
evaluating individuals’ and families’
eligibility for assistance under this part;
(ii) Policies and procedures for
determining and prioritizing which
eligible individuals and families will
receive transitional housing assistance;
(iii) Policies and procedures for
determining and prioritizing which
eligible individuals and families will
receive rapid rehousing assistance;
(iv) Standards for determining what
percentage or amount of rent each
program participant must pay while
receiving rapid rehousing assistance;
(v) Policies and procedures for
determining and prioritizing which
eligible individuals and families will
receive permanent supportive housing
assistance; and
(vi) Where the Continuum is
designated a high-performing
community, as described in subpart G of
this part, policies and procedures set
forth in 24 CFR 576.400(e)(3)(vi),
(e)(3)(vii), (e)(3)(viii), and (e)(3)(ix).
(b) Designating and operating an
HMIS. The Continuum of Care must:
(1) Designate a single Homeless
Management Information System
(HMIS) for the geographic area;
(2) Designate an eligible applicant to
manage the Continuum’s HMIS, which
will be known as the HMIS Lead;
(3) Review, revise, and approve a
privacy plan, security plan, and data
quality plan for the HMIS.
(4) Ensure consistent participation of
recipients and subrecipients in the
HMIS; and
(5) Ensure the HMIS is administered
in compliance with requirements
prescribed by HUD.
(c) Continuum of Care planning. The
Continuum must develop a plan that
includes:
(1) Coordinating the implementation
of a housing and service system within
its geographic area that meets the needs
of the homeless individuals (including
unaccompanied youth) and families. At
a minimum, such system encompasses
the following:
(i) Outreach, engagement, and
assessment;
(ii) Shelter, housing, and supportive
services;
(iii) Prevention strategies.
(2) Planning for and conducting, at
least biennially, a point-in-time count of
homeless persons within the geographic
area that meets the following
requirements:
(i) Homeless persons who are living in
a place not designed or ordinarily used
as a regular sleeping accommodation for
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
45446
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
humans must be counted as unsheltered
homeless persons.
(ii) Persons living in emergency
shelters and transitional housing
projects must be counted as sheltered
homeless persons.
(iii) Other requirements established
by HUD by Notice.
(3) Conducting an annual gaps
analysis of the homeless needs and
services available within the geographic
area;
(4) Providing information required to
complete the Consolidated Plan(s)
within the Continuum’s geographic
area;
(5) Consulting with State and local
government Emergency Solutions
Grants program recipients within the
Continuum’s geographic area on the
plan for allocating Emergency Solutions
Grants program funds and reporting on
and evaluating the performance of
Emergency Solutions Grants program
recipients and subrecipients.
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
§ 578.9
Preparing an application for funds.
(a) The Continuum must:
(1) Design, operate, and follow a
collaborative process for the
development of applications and
approve the submission of applications
in response to a NOFA published by
HUD under § 578.19 of this subpart;
(2) Establish priorities for funding
projects in the geographic area;
(3) Determine if one application for
funding will be submitted for all
projects within the geographic area or if
more than one application will be
submitted for the projects within the
geographic area;
(i) If more than one application will
be submitted, designate an eligible
applicant to be the collaborative
applicant that will collect and combine
the required application information
from all applicants and for all projects
within the geographic area that the
Continuum has selected funding. The
collaborative applicant will also apply
for Continuum of Care planning
activities. If the Continuum is an
eligible applicant, it may designate
itself;
(ii) If only one application will be
submitted, that applicant will be the
collaborative applicant and will collect
and combine the required application
information from all projects within the
geographic area that the Continuum has
selected for funding and apply for
Continuum of Care planning activities;
(b) The Continuum retains all of its
responsibilities, even if it designates one
or more eligible applicants other than
itself to apply for funds on behalf of the
Continuum. This includes approving
the Continuum of Care application.
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
§ 578.11
Unified Funding Agency.
(a) Becoming a Unified Funding
Agency. To become designated as the
Unified Funding Agency (UFA) for a
Continuum, a collaborative applicant
must be selected by the Continuum to
apply to HUD to be designated as the
UFA for the Continuum.
(b) Criteria for designating a UFA.
HUD will consider these criteria when
deciding whether to designate a
collaborative applicant a UFA:
(1) The Continuum of Care it
represents meets the requirements in
§ 578.7;
(2) The collaborative applicant has
financial management systems that meet
the standards set forth in 24 CFR 84.21
(for nonprofit organizations) and 24 CFR
85.20 (for States);
(3) The collaborative applicant
demonstrates the ability to monitor
subrecipients; and
(4) Such other criteria as HUD may
establish by NOFA.
(c) Requirements. HUD-designated
UFAs shall:
(1) Apply to HUD for funding for all
of the projects within the geographic
area and enter into a grant agreement
with HUD for the entire geographic area.
(2) Enter into legally binding
agreements with subrecipients, and
receive and distribute funds to
subrecipients for all projects within the
geographic area.
(3) Require subrecipients to establish
fiscal control and accounting
procedures as necessary to assure the
proper disbursal of and accounting for
federal funds in accordance with the
requirements of 24 CFR parts 84 and 85
and corresponding OMB circulars.
(4) Obtain approval of any proposed
grant agreement amendments by the
Continuum of Care before submitting a
request for an amendment to HUD.
§ 578.13
Remedial action.
(a) If HUD finds that the Continuum
of Care for a geographic area does not
meet the requirements of the Act or its
implementing regulations, or that there
is no Continuum for a geographic area,
HUD may take remedial action to ensure
fair distribution of grant funds within
the geographic area. Such measures may
include:
(1) Designating a replacement
Continuum of Care for the geographic
area;
(2) Designating a replacement
collaborative applicant for the
Continuum’s geographic area; and
(3) Accepting applications from other
eligible applicants within the
Continuum’s geographic area.
(b) HUD must provide a 30-day prior
written notice to the Continuum and its
PO 00000
Frm 00026
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
collaborative applicant and give them
an opportunity to respond.
Subpart C—Application and Grant
Award Process
§ 578.15
Eligible applicants.
(a) Who may apply. Nonprofit
organizations, States, local governments,
and instrumentalities of State or local
governments are eligible to apply for
grants.
(b) Designation by the Continuum of
Care. Eligible applicant(s) must have
been designated by the Continuum of
Care to submit an application for grant
funds under this part. The designation
must state whether the Continuum is
designating more than one applicant to
apply for funds and, if it is, which
applicant is being designated as the
collaborative applicant. If the
Continuum is designating only one
applicant to apply for funds, the
Continuum must designate that
applicant to be the collaborative
applicant.
(c) Exclusion. For-profit entities are
not eligible to apply for grants or to be
subrecipients of grant funds.
§ 578.17 Overview of application and grant
award process.
(a) Formula. (1) After enactment of the
annual appropriations act for each fiscal
year, and issuance of the NOFA, HUD
will publish, on its Web site, the
Preliminary Pro Rata Need (PPRN)
assigned to metropolitan cities, urban
counties, and all other counties.
(2) HUD will apply the formula used
to determine PPRN established in
paragraph (a)(3) of this section, to the
amount of funds being made available
under the NOFA. That amount is
calculated by:
(i) Determining the total amount for
the Continuum of Care competition in
accordance with section 413 of the Act
or as otherwise directed by the annual
appropriations act;
(ii) From the amount in paragraph
(a)(2)(i) of this section, deducting the
amount published in the NOFA as being
set aside to provide a bonus to
geographic areas for activities that have
proven to be effective in reducing
homelessness generally or for specific
subpopulations listed in the NOFA or
achieving homeless prevention and
independent living goals established in
the NOFA and to meet policy priorities
set in the NOFA; and
(iii) Deducting the amount of funding
necessary for Continuum of Care
planning activities and UFA costs.
(3) PPRN is calculated on the amount
determined under paragraph (a)(2) of
this section by using the following
formula:
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
(i) Two percent will be allocated
among the four insular areas (American
Samoa, Guam, the Commonwealth of
the Northern Marianas, and the Virgin
Islands) on the basis of the ratio of the
population of each insular area to the
population of all insular areas.
(ii) Seventy-five percent of the
remaining amount will be allocated,
using the Community Development
Block Grant (CDBG) formula, to
metropolitan cities and urban counties
that have been funded under either the
Emergency Shelter Grants or Emergency
Solutions Grants programs in any one
year since 2004.
(iii) The amount remaining after the
allocation under paragraphs (a)(1) and
(2) of this section will be allocated,
using the CDBG formula, to
metropolitan cities and urban counties
that have not been funded under the
Emergency Solutions Grants program in
any year since 2004 and all other
counties in the United States and Puerto
Rico.
(4) If the calculation in paragraph
(a)(2) of this section results in an
amount less than the amount required to
renew all projects eligible for renewal in
that year for at least one year, after
making adjustments proportional to
increases in fair market rents for the
geographic area for leasing, operating,
and rental assistance for permanent
housing, HUD will reduce,
proportionately, the total amount
required to renew all projects eligible
for renewal in that year for at least one
year, for each Continuum of Care. HUD
will publish, via the NOFA, the total
dollar amount that every Continuum
will be required to deduct from renewal
projects Continuum-wide.
(b) Calculating a Continuum of Care’s
maximum award amount. (1) Establish
the PPRN amount. First, HUD will total
the PPRN amounts for each
metropolitan city, urban county, other
county, and insular area claimed by the
Continuum as part of its geographic
area, excluding any counties applying
for or receiving funding from the Rural
Housing Stability Assistance program
under 24 CFR part 579.
(2) Establishing renewal demand.
Next, HUD will determine the renewal
demand within the Continuum’s
geographic area. Renewal demand is the
sum of the annual renewal amounts of
all projects within the Continuum
eligible to apply for renewal in that
fiscal year’s competition, before any
adjustments to rental assistance, leasing,
and operating line items based on FMR
changes.
(3) Establishing FPRN. The higher of
PPRN or renewal demand for the
Continuum of Care is the FPRN, which
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
is the base for the maximum award
amount for the Continuum.
(4) Establishing the maximum award
amount. The maximum award amount
for the Continuum is the FPRN amount
plus any additional eligible amounts for
Continuum planning; UFA costs;
adjustments to leasing, operating and
rental assistance line items based on
changes to FMR; and available bonuses.
§ 578.19
Application process.
(a) Notice of Funding Availability.
After enactment of the annual
appropriations act for the fiscal year,
HUD will issue a NOFA in accordance
with the requirements of 24 CFR part 4.
(b) Applications. All applications to
HUD, including applications for grant
funds and requests for designation as a
UFA or HPC, must be submitted at such
time and in such manner as HUD may
require, and contain such information as
HUD determines necessary. At a
minimum, an application for grant
funds must contain a list of the projects
for which it is applying for funds; a
description of the projects; a list of the
projects that will be carried out by
subrecipients and the names of the
subrecipients; a description of the
subpopulations of homeless or at risk of
homelessness to be served by projects;
the number of units to be provided and/
or the number of persons to be served
by each project; a budget request by
project; and reasonable assurances that
the applicant, or the subrecipient, will
own or have control of a site for the
proposed project not later than the
expiration of the 12-month period
beginning upon notification of an award
for grant assistance.
§ 578.21
Awarding funds.
(a) Selection. HUD will review
applications in accordance with the
guidelines and procedures provided in
the NOFA and will award funds to
recipients through a national
competition based on selection criteria
as defined in section 427 of the Act.
(b) Announcement of awards. HUD
will announce awards and notify
selected applicants of any conditions
imposed on awards. Conditions must be
satisfied before HUD will execute a
grant agreement with the applicant.
(c) Satisfying conditions. HUD will
withdraw an award if the applicant does
not satisfy all conditions imposed on it.
Correcting all issues and conditions
attached to an award must be completed
within the time frame established in the
NOFA. Proof of site control, match,
environmental review, and the
documentation of financial feasibility
must be completed within 12 months of
the announcement of the award, or 24
PO 00000
Frm 00027
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45447
months in the case of funds for
acquisition, rehabilitation, or new
construction. The 12-month deadline
may be extended by HUD for up to 12
additional months upon a showing of
compelling reasons for delay due to
factors beyond the control of the
recipient or subrecipient.
§ 578.23
Executing grant agreements.
(a) Deadline. No later than 45 days
from the date when all conditions are
satisfied, the recipient and HUD must
execute the grant agreement.
(b) Grant agreements. (1) Multiple
applicants for one Continuum. If a
Continuum designates more than one
applicant for the geographic area, HUD
will enter into a grant agreement with
each designated applicant for which an
award is announced.
(2) One applicant for a Continuum. If
a Continuum designates only one
applicant for the geographic area, after
awarding funds, HUD may enter into a
grant agreement with that applicant for
new awards, if any, and one grant
agreement for renewals, Continuum of
Care planning, and UFA costs, if any.
These two grants will cover the entire
geographic area. A default by the
recipient under one of those grant
agreements will also be a default under
the other.
(3) Unified Funding Agencies. If a
Continuum is a UFA that HUD has
approved, then HUD will enter into one
grant agreement with the UFA for new
awards, if any, and one grant agreement
for renewals, Continuum of Care
planning and UFA costs, if any. These
two grants will cover the entire
geographic area. A default by the UFA
under one of those grant agreements
will also be a default under the other.
(c) Required agreements. Recipients
will be required to sign a grant
agreement in which the recipient agrees:
(1) To ensure the operation of the
project(s) in accordance with the
provisions of the McKinney-Veto Act
and all requirements under 24 CFR part
578;
(2) To monitor and report the progress
of the project(s) to the Continuum of
Care and HUD;
(3) To ensure, to the maximum extent
practicable, that individuals and
families experiencing homelessness are
involved, through employment,
provision of volunteer services, or
otherwise, in constructing,
rehabilitating, maintaining, and
operating facilities for the project and in
providing supportive services for the
project;
(4) To require certification from all
subrecipients that:
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
45448
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
(i) Subrecipients will maintain the
confidentiality of records pertaining to
any individual or family that was
provided family violence prevention or
treatment services through the project;
(ii) The address or location of any
family violence project assisted under
this part will not be made public, except
with written authorization of the person
responsible for the operation of such
project;
(iii) Subrecipients will establish
policies and practices that are consistent
with, and do not restrict, the exercise of
rights provided by subtitle B of title VII
of the Act and other laws relating to the
provision of educational and related
services to individuals and families
experiencing homelessness;
(iv) In the case of projects that provide
housing or services to families, that
subrecipients will designate a staff
person to be responsible for ensuring
that children being served in the
program are enrolled in school and
connected to appropriate services in the
community, including early childhood
programs such as Head Start, part C of
the Individuals with Disabilities
Education Act, and programs authorized
under subtitle B of title VII of the Act;
(v) The subrecipient, its officers, and
employees are not debarred or
suspended from doing business with the
Federal Government; and
(vi) Subrecipients will provide
information, such as data and reports, as
required by HUD; and
(5) To establish such fiscal control
and accounting procedures as may be
necessary to assure the proper disbursal
of, and accounting for grant funds in
order to ensure that all financial
transactions are conducted, and records
maintained in accordance with
generally accepted accounting
principles, if the recipient is a UFA;
(6) To monitor subrecipient match
and report on match to HUD;
(7) To take the educational needs of
children into account when families are
placed in housing and will, to the
maximum extent practicable, place
families with children as close as
possible to their school of origin so as
not to disrupt such children’s
education;
(8) To monitor subrecipients at least
annually;
(9) To use the centralized or
coordinated assessment system
established by the Continuum of Care as
set forth in § 578.7(a)(8). A victim
service provider may choose not to use
the Continuum of Care’s centralized or
coordinated assessment system,
provided that victim service providers
in the area use a centralized or
coordinated assessment system that
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
meets HUD’s minimum requirements
and the victim service provider uses
that system instead;
(10) To follow the written standards
for providing Continuum of Care
assistance developed by the Continuum
of Care, including the minimum
requirements set forth in § 578.7(a)(9);
(11) Enter into subrecipient
agreements requiring subrecipients to
operate the project(s) in accordance
with the provisions of this Act and all
requirements under 24 CFR part 578;
and
(12) To comply with such other terms
and conditions as HUD may establish by
NOFA.
§ 578.25
Site control.
(a) In general. When grant funds will
be used for acquisition, rehabilitation,
new construction, operating costs, or to
provide supportive services, the
recipient or subrecipient must
demonstrate that it has site control
within the time frame established in
section § 578.21 before HUD will
execute a grant agreement. This
requirement does not apply to funds
used for housing that will eventually be
owned or controlled by the individuals
or families served or for supportive
services provided at sites not operated
by the recipient or subrecipient.
(b) Evidence. Acceptable evidence of
site control is a deed or lease. If grant
funds will be used for acquisition,
acceptable evidence of site control will
be a purchase agreement. The owner,
lessee, and purchaser shown on these
documents must be the selected
applicant or intended subrecipient
identified in the application for
assistance.
(c) Tax credit projects. (1) Applicants
that plan to use the low-income housing
tax credit authorized under 26 U.S.C. 42
to finance a project must prove to HUD’s
satisfaction that the applicant or
subrecipient identified in the
application is in control of the limited
partnership or limited liability
corporation that has a deed or lease for
the project site.
(i) To have control of the limited
partnership, the applicant or
subrecipient must be the general partner
of the limited partnership or have a 51
percent controlling interest in that
general partner.
(ii) To have control of the limited
liability company, the applicant or
subrecipient must be the sole managing
member.
(2) If grant funds are to be used for
acquisition, rehabilitation, or new
construction, the recipient or
subrecipient must maintain control of
the partnership or corporation and must
PO 00000
Frm 00028
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
ensure that the project is operated in
compliance with law and regulation for
15 years from the date of initial
occupancy or initial service provision.
The partnership or corporation must
own the project site throughout the 15year period. If grant funds were not used
for acquisition, rehabilitation, or new
construction, then the recipient or
subrecipient must maintain control for
the term of the grant agreement and any
renewals thereof.
§ 578.27
Consolidated plan.
(a) States or units of general local
government. An applicant that is a State
or a unit of general local government
must have a HUD-approved, complete
or abbreviated, consolidated plan in
accordance with 24 CFR part 91. The
applicant must submit a certification
that the application for funding is
consistent with the HUD-approved
consolidated plan(s) for the
jurisdiction(s) in which the proposed
project will be located. Funded
applicants must certify in a grant
agreement that they are following the
HUD-approved consolidated plan.
(b) Other applicants. Applicants that
are not States or units of general local
government must submit a certification
by the jurisdiction(s) in which the
proposed project will be located that the
applicant’s application for funding is
consistent with the jurisdiction’s HUDapproved consolidated plan. The
certification must be made by the unit
of general local government or the State,
in accordance with the consistency
certification provisions under 24 CFR
part 91, subpart F. If the jurisdiction
refuses to provide a certification of
consistency, the applicant may appeal
to HUD under § 578.35.
(c) Timing of consolidated plan
certification submissions. The required
certification that the application for
funding is consistent with the HUDapproved consolidated plan must be
submitted by the funding application
submission deadline announced in the
NOFA.
§ 578.29
Subsidy layering.
HUD may provide assistance under
this program only in accordance with
HUD subsidy layering requirements in
section 102 of the Housing and Urban
Development Reform Act of 1989 (42
U.S.C. 3545) and 24 CFR part 4, subpart
A. An applicant must submit
information in its application on other
sources of governmental assistance that
the applicant has received, or
reasonably expects to receive, for a
proposed project or activities. HUD’s
review of this information is intended to
prevent excessive public assistance for
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
proposed project or activities by
combining (layering) assistance under
this program with other governmental
housing assistance from federal, State,
or local agencies, including assistance
such as tax concessions or tax credits.
§ 578.31
Environmental review.
(a) Activities under this part are
subject to environmental review by
HUD under 24 CFR part 50. The
recipient or subrecipient shall supply
all available, relevant information
necessary for HUD to perform, for each
property, any environmental review
required by 24 CFR part 50. The
recipient or subrecipient must carry out
mitigating measures required by HUD or
select an alternate eligible property.
HUD may eliminate from consideration
any application that would require an
Environmental Impact Statement.
(b) The recipient or subrecipient, its
project partners, and their contractors
may not acquire, rehabilitate, convert,
lease, repair, dispose of, demolish, or
construct property for a project under
this part, or commit or expend HUD or
local funds for such eligible activities
under this part, until HUD has
performed an environmental review
under 24 CFR part 50 and the recipient
or subrecipient has received HUD
approval of the property.
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
§ 578.33
Renewals.
(a) In general. Awards made under
this part and title IV of the Act, as in
effect before August 30, 2012 (the
Supportive Housing Program and the
Shelter Plus Care program), may be
renewed to continue ongoing leasing,
operations, supportive services, rental
assistance, HMIS, and administration
beyond the initial funding period. To be
considered for funding, recipients must
submit a request in a form specified by
HUD, must meet the requirements of
this part, and must submit the request
within the time frame established by
HUD.
(b) Length of renewal. HUD may
award up to 3 years of funds for
supportive services, leasing, HMIS, and
operating costs. Renewals of tenantbased and sponsor-based rental
assistance may be for up to one year of
rental assistance. Renewals of projectbased rental assistance may be for up to
15 years of rental assistance, subject to
availability of annual appropriations.
(c) Assistance available. (1)
Assistance during each year of a
renewal period may be for:
(i) Up to 100 percent of the amount
for supportive services and HMIS costs
in the final year of the prior funding
period;
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
(ii) Up to 100 percent of the amount
for leasing and operating in the final
year of the prior funding period
adjusted in proportion to changes in the
FMR for the geographic area; and
(iii) For rental assistance, up to 100
percent of the result of multiplying the
number and unit size(s) in the grant
agreement by the number of months in
the renewal grant term and the
applicable FMR.
(d) Review criteria. (1) Awards made
under title IV of the Act, as in effect
before August 30, 2012 are eligible for
renewal in the Continuum of Care
program even if the awardees would not
be eligible for a new grant under the
program, so long as they continue to
serve the same population and the same
number of persons or units in the same
type of housing as identified in their
most recently amended grant agreement
signed before August 30, 2012. Grants
will be renewed if HUD receives a
certification from the Continuum that
there is a demonstrated need for the
project, and HUD finds that the project
complied with program requirements
applicable before August 30, 2012. For
purposes of meeting the requirements of
this part, a project will continue to be
administered in accordance with 24
CFR 582.330, if the project received
funding under the Shelter Plus Care
program, or 24 CFR 583.325, if the
project received funding under the
Supportive Housing Program.
(2) Renewal of awards made after
August 30, 2012. Review criteria for
competitively awarded renewals made
after August 30, 2012 will be described
in the NOFA.
(e) Unsuccessful projects. HUD may
renew a project that was eligible for
renewal in the competition and was part
of an application that was not funded
despite having been submitted on time,
in the manner required by HUD, and
containing the information required by
HUD, upon a finding that the project
meets the purposes of the Continuum of
Care program. The renewal will not
exceed more than one year and will be
under such conditions as HUD deems
appropriate.
(f) Annual Performance Report
condition. HUD may terminate the
renewal of any grant and require the
recipient to repay the renewal grant if:
(1) The recipient fails to timely
submit a HUD Annual Performance
Report (APR) for the grant year
immediately prior to renewal; or
(2) The recipient submits an APR that
HUD deems unacceptable or shows
noncompliance with the requirements
of the grant and this part.
PO 00000
Frm 00029
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
§ 578.35
45449
Appeal.
(a) In general. Failure to follow the
procedures or meet the deadlines
established in this section will result in
denial of the appeal.
(b) Solo applicants. (1) Who may
appeal. Nonprofits, States, and local
governments, and instrumentalities of
State or local governments that
attempted to participate in the
Continuum of Care planning process in
the geographic area in which they
operate, that believe they were denied
the right to participate in a reasonable
manner, and that submitted a solo
application for funding by the
application deadline established in the
NOFA, may appeal the decision of the
Continuum to HUD.
(2) Notice of intent to appeal. The
solo applicant must submit a written
notice of intent to appeal, with a copy
to the Continuum, with their funding
application.
(3) Deadline for submitting proof. No
later than 30 days after the date that
HUD announces the awards, the solo
applicant shall submit in writing, with
a copy to the Continuum, all relevant
evidence supporting its claim, in such
manner as HUD may require by Notice.
(4) Response from the Continuum of
Care. The Continuum shall have 30 days
from the date of its receipt of the solo
applicant’s evidence to respond to HUD
in writing and in such manner as HUD
may require, with a copy to the solo
applicant.
(5) Decision. HUD will notify the solo
applicant and the Continuum of its
decision within 60 days of receipt of the
Continuum’s response.
(6) Funding. If HUD finds that the solo
applicant was not permitted to
participate in the Continuum of Care
planning process in a reasonable
manner, then HUD may award a grant
to the solo applicant when funds next
become available and may direct the
Continuum of Care to take remedial
steps to ensure reasonable participation
in the future. HUD may also reduce the
award to the Continuum’s applicant(s).
(c) Denied or decreased funding. (1)
Who may appeal. Eligible applicants
that are denied funds by HUD, or that
requested more funds than HUD
awarded to them, may appeal the award
by filing a written appeal, in such form
and manner as HUD may require by
Notice, within 45 days of the date of
HUD’s announcement of the award.
(2) Decision. HUD will notify the
applicant of its decision on the appeal
within 60 days of HUD’s receipt of the
written appeal. HUD will reverse a
decision only when the applicant can
show that HUD error caused the denial
or decrease.
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
45450
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
(3) Funding. Awards and increases to
awards made upon appeal will be made
from next available funds.
(d) Competing Continuums of Care.
(1) In general. If more than one
Continuum of Care claims the same
geographic area, HUD will award funds
to the Continuum applicant(s) whose
application(s) has the highest total
score. No projects will be funded from
the lower scoring Continuum. No
projects that are submitted in two or
more competing Continuum of Care
applications will be funded.
(2) Who may appeal. The designated
applicant(s) for the lower scoring
Continuum may appeal HUD’s decision
to fund the application(s) from the
competing Continuum by filing a
written appeal, in such form and
manner as HUD may require by Notice,
within 45 days of the date of HUD’s
announcement of the award.
(3) Decision. HUD will notify the
applicant(s) of its decision on the appeal
within 60 days of the date of HUD’s
receipt of the written appeal. HUD will
reverse a decision only upon a showing
by the applicant that HUD error caused
the denial.
(e) Consolidated plan certification. (1)
In general. An applicant may appeal to
HUD a jurisdiction’s refusal to provide
a certification of consistency with the
Consolidated Plan.
(2) Procedure. The applicant must
submit a written appeal with its
application to HUD and send a copy of
the appeal to the jurisdiction that
denied the certification of consistency.
The appeal must include, at a
minimum:
(i) A copy of the applicant’s request
to the jurisdiction for the certification of
consistency with the Consolidated Plan;
(ii) A copy of the jurisdiction’s
response stating the reasons for denial,
including the reasons the proposed
project is not consistent with the
jurisdiction’s Consolidated Plan in
accordance with 24 CFR 91.500(c); and
(iii) A statement of the reasons why
the applicant believes its project is
consistent with the jurisdiction’s
Consolidated Plan.
(3) Jurisdiction response. The
jurisdiction that refused to provide the
certification of consistency with the
jurisdiction’s Consolidated Plan shall
have 10 days after receipt of a copy of
the appeal to submit a written
explanation of the reasons originally
given for refusing to provide the
certification and a written rebuttal to
any claims made by the applicant in the
appeal.
(4) HUD review. (i) HUD will issue its
decision within 45 days of the date of
HUD’s receipt of the jurisdiction’s
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
response. As part of its review, HUD
will consider:
(A) Whether the applicant submitted
the request to the appropriate political
jurisdiction; and
(B) The reasonableness of the
jurisdiction’s refusal to provide the
certificate.
(ii) If the jurisdiction did not provide
written reasons for refusal, including
the reasons why the project is not
consistent with the jurisdiction’s
Consolidated Plan in its initial response
to the applicant’s request for a
certification, HUD will find for the
applicant without further inquiry or
response from the political jurisdiction.
Subpart D—Program Components and
Eligible Costs
§ 578.37 Program components and uses of
assistance.
(a) Continuum of Care funds may be
used to pay for the eligible costs listed
in § 578.39 through § 578.63 when used
to establish and operate projects under
five program components: permanent
housing; transitional housing;
supportive services only; HMIS; and, in
some cases, homelessness prevention.
Although grant funds may be used by
recipients and subrecipients in all
components for the eligible costs of
contributing data to the HMIS
designated by the Continuum of Care,
only HMIS Leads may use grant funds
for an HMIS component. Administrative
costs are eligible for all components. All
components are subject to the
restrictions on combining funds for
certain eligible activities in a single
project found in § 578.87(c). The eligible
program components are:
(1) Permanent housing (PH).
Permanent housing is community-based
housing, the purpose of which is to
provide housing without a designated
length of stay. Grant funds may be used
for acquisition, rehabilitation, new
construction, leasing, rental assistance,
operating costs, and supportive services.
PH includes:
(i) Permanent supportive housing for
persons with disabilities (PSH). PSH can
only provide assistance to individuals
with disabilities and families in which
one adult or child has a disability.
Supportive services designed to meet
the needs of the program participants
must be made available to the program
participants.
(ii) Rapid rehousing. Continuum of
Care funds may provide supportive
services, as set forth in § 578.53, and/or
short-term (up to 3 months) and/or
medium-term (for 3 to 24 months)
tenant-based rental assistance, as set
forth in § 578.51(c), as necessary to help
PO 00000
Frm 00030
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
a homeless individual or family, with or
without disabilities, move as quickly as
possible into permanent housing and
achieve stability in that housing. When
providing short-term and/or mediumterm rental assistance to program
participants, the rental assistance is
subject to § 578.51(a)(1), but not
§ 578.51(a)(1)(i) and (ii); (a)(2); (c) and
(f) through (i); and (l)(1). These projects:
(A) Must follow the written policies
and procedures established by the
Continuum of Care for determining and
prioritizing which eligible families and
individuals will receive rapid rehousing
assistance, as well as the amount or
percentage of rent that each program
participant must pay.
(B) May set a maximum amount or
percentage of rental assistance that a
program participant may receive, a
maximum number of months that a
program participant may receive rental
assistance, and/or a maximum number
of times that a program participant may
receive rental assistance. The recipient
or subrecipient may also require
program participants to share in the
costs of rent. For the purposes of
calculating rent for rapid rehousing, the
rent shall equal the sum of the total
monthly rent for the unit and, if the
tenant pays separately for utilities, the
monthly allowance for utilities
(excluding telephone) established by the
public housing authority for the area in
which the housing is located.
(C) Limit rental assistance to no more
than 24 months to a household.
(D) May provide supportive services
for no longer than 6 months after rental
assistance stops.
(E) Must re-evaluate, not less than
once annually, that the program
participant lacks sufficient resources
and support networks necessary to
retain housing without Continuum of
Care assistance and the types and
amounts of assistance that the program
participant needs to retain housing. The
recipient or subrecipient may require
each program participant receiving
assistance to notify the recipient or
subrecipient of changes in the program
participant’s income or other
circumstances (e.g., changes in
household composition) that affect the
program participant’s need for
assistance. When notified of a relevant
change, the recipient or subrecipient
must reevaluate the program
participant’s eligibility and the amount
and types of assistance that the program
participant needs.
(F) Require the program participant to
meet with a case manager not less than
once per month to assist the program
participant in ensuring long-term
housing stability. The project is exempt
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
from this requirement if the Violence
Against Women Act of 1994 (42 U.S.C.
13925 et seq.) or the Family Violence
Prevention and Services Act (42 U.S.C.
10401 et seq.) prohibits the recipient
carrying out the project from making its
housing conditional on the participant’s
acceptance of services.
(2) Transitional Housing (TH).
Transitional housing facilitates the
movement of homeless individuals and
families to PH within 24 months of
entering TH. Grant funds may be used
for acquisition, rehabilitation, new
construction, leasing, rental assistance,
operating costs, and supportive services.
(3) Supportive Service Only (SSO).
Funds may be used for acquisition,
rehabilitation, relocation costs, or
leasing of a facility from which
supportive services will be provided,
and supportive services in order to
provide supportive services to
unsheltered and sheltered homeless
persons for whom the recipient or
subrecipient is not providing housing or
housing assistance. SSO includes street
outreach.
(4) HMIS. Funds may be used by
HMIS Leads to lease a structure in
which the HMIS is operated or as
operating funds to operate a structure in
which the HMIS is operated, and for
other costs eligible in § 578.57.
(5) Homelessness prevention. Funds
may be used by recipients in
Continuums of Care-designated highperforming communities for housing
relocation and stabilization services,
and short- and/or medium-term rental
assistance, as described in 24 CFR
576.105 and 24 CFR 576.106, that are
necessary to prevent an individual or
family from becoming homeless.
(b) Uses of assistance. Funds are
available to pay for the eligible costs
listed in § 578.39 through § 578.63 when
used to:
(1) Establish new housing or new
facilities to provide supportive services;
(2) Expand existing housing and
facilities in order to increase the number
of homeless persons served;
(3) Bring existing housing and
facilities into compliance with State and
local government health and safety
standards, as described in § 578.87;
(4) Preserve existing permanent
housing and facilities that provide
supportive services;
(5) Provide supportive services for
residents of supportive housing or for
homeless persons not residing in
supportive housing;
(6) Continue funding permanent
housing when the recipient has received
funding under this part for leasing,
supportive services, operating costs, or
rental assistance;
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
(7) Establish and operate an HMIS or
comparable database; and
(8) Establish and carry out a
Continuum of Care planning process
and operate a Continuum of Care.
(c) Multiple purposes. Structures used
to provide housing, supportive housing,
supportive services, or as a facility for
HMIS activities may also be used for
other purposes. However, assistance
under this part will be available only in
proportion to the use of the structure for
supportive housing or supportive
services. If eligible and ineligible
activities are carried out in separate
portions of the same structure or in
separate structures, grant funds may not
be used to pay for more than the actual
cost of acquisition, construction, or
rehabilitation of the portion of the
structure or structures used for eligible
activities. If eligible and ineligible
activities are carried out in the same
structure, the costs will be prorated
based on the amount of time that the
space is used for eligible versus
ineligible activities.
§ 578.39 Continuum of Care planning
activities.
(a) In general. Collaborative
applicants may use up to 3 percent of
their FPRN, or a maximum amount to be
established by the NOFA, for costs of:
(1) Designing and carrying out a
collaborative process for the
development of an application to HUD;
(2) Evaluating the outcomes of
projects for which funds are awarded in
the geographic area under the
Continuum of Care and the Emergency
Solutions Grants programs; and
(3) Participating in the consolidated
plan(s) for the geographic area(s).
(b) Continuum of Care planning
activities. Eligible planning costs
include the costs of:
(1) Developing a communitywide or
regionwide process involving the
coordination of nonprofit homeless
providers, victim service providers,
faith-based organizations, governments,
businesses, advocates, public housing
agencies, school districts, social service
providers, mental health agencies,
hospitals, universities, affordable
housing developers, law enforcement,
organizations that serve veterans, and
homeless and formerly homeless
individuals;
(2) Determining the geographic area
that the Continuum of Care will serve;
(3) Developing a Continuum of Care
system;
(4) Evaluating the outcomes of
projects for which funds are awarded in
the geographic area, including the
Emergency Solutions Grants program;
PO 00000
Frm 00031
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45451
(5) Participating in the consolidated
plan(s) of the jurisdiction(s) in the
geographic area; and
(6) Preparing and submitting an
application to HUD on behalf of the
entire Continuum of Care membership,
including conducting a sheltered and
unsheltered point-in-time count and
other data collection as required by
HUD.
(c) Monitoring costs. The costs of
monitoring recipients and subrecipients
and enforcing compliance with program
requirements are eligible.
§ 578.41
Unified Funding Agency costs.
(a) In general. UFAs may use up to 3
percent of their FPRN, or a maximum
amount to be established by the NOFA,
whichever is less, for fiscal control and
accounting costs necessary to assure the
proper disbursal of, and accounting for,
federal funds awarded to subrecipients
under the Continuum of Care program.
(b) UFA costs. UFA costs include
costs of ensuring that all financial
transactions carried out under the
Continuum of Care program are
conducted and records are maintained
in accordance with generally accepted
accounting principles, including
arranging for an annual survey, audit, or
evaluation of the financial records of
each project carried out by a
subrecipient funded by a grant received
through the Continuum of Care
program.
(c) Monitoring costs. The costs of
monitoring subrecipients and enforcing
compliance with program requirements
are eligible for costs.
§ 578.43
Acquisition.
Grant funds may be used to pay up to
100 percent of the cost of acquisition of
real property selected by the recipient or
subrecipient for use in the provision of
housing or supportive services for
homeless persons.
§ 578.45
Rehabilitation.
(a) Use. Grant funds may be used to
pay up to 100 percent of the cost of
rehabilitation of structures to provide
housing or supportive services to
homeless persons.
(b) Eligible costs. Eligible
rehabilitation costs include installing
cost-effective energy measures, and
bringing an existing structure to State
and local government health and safety
standards.
(c) Ineligible costs. Grant funds may
not be used for rehabilitation of leased
property.
§ 578.47
New construction.
(a) Use. Grant funds may be used to:
(1) Pay up to 100 percent of the cost
of new construction, including the
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
45452
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
building of a new structure or building
an addition to an existing structure that
increases the floor area by 100 percent
or more, and the cost of land associated
with that construction, for use as
housing.
(2) If grant funds are used for new
construction, the applicant must
demonstrate that the costs of new
construction are substantially less than
the costs of rehabilitation or that there
is a lack of available appropriate units
that could be rehabilitated at a cost less
than new construction. For purposes of
this cost comparison, costs of
rehabilitation or new construction may
include the cost of real property
acquisition.
(b) Ineligible costs. Grant funds may
not be used for new construction on
leased property.
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
§ 578.49
Leasing.
(a) Use. (1) Where the recipient or
subrecipient is leasing the structure, or
portions thereof, grant funds may be
used to pay for 100 percent of the costs
of leasing a structure or structures, or
portions thereof, to provide housing or
supportive services to homeless persons
for up to 3 years. Leasing funds may not
be used to lease units or structures
owned by the recipient, subrecipient,
their parent organization(s), any other
related organization(s), or organizations
that are members of a partnership,
where the partnership owns the
structure, unless HUD authorized an
exception for good cause.
(2) Any request for an exception must
include the following:
(i) A description of how leasing these
structures is in the best interest of the
program;
(ii) Supporting documentation
showing that the leasing charges paid
with grant funds are reasonable for the
market; and
(iii) A copy of the written policy for
resolving disputes between the landlord
and tenant, including a recusal for
officers, agents, and staff who work for
both the landlord and tenant.
(b) Requirements. (1) Leasing
structures. When grants are used to pay
rent for all or part of a structure or
structures, the rent paid must be
reasonable in relation to rents being
charged in the area for comparable
space. In addition, the rent paid may not
exceed rents currently being charged by
the same owner for comparable
unassisted space.
(2) Leasing individual units. When
grants are used to pay rent for
individual housing units, the rent paid
must be reasonable in relation to rents
being charged for comparable units,
taking into account the location, size,
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
type, quality, amenities, facilities, and
management services. In addition, the
rents may not exceed rents currently
being charged for comparable units, and
the rent paid may not exceed HUDdetermined fair market rents.
(3) Utilities. If electricity, gas, and
water are included in the rent, these
utilities may be paid from leasing funds.
If utilities are not provided by the
landlord, these utility costs are an
operating cost, except for supportive
service facilities. If the structure is being
used as a supportive service facility,
then these utility costs are a supportive
service cost.
(4) Security deposits and first and last
month’s rent. Recipients and
subrecipients may use grant funds to
pay security deposits, in an amount not
to exceed 2 months of actual rent. An
advance payment of the last month’s
rent may be provided to the landlord in
addition to the security deposit and
payment of the first month’s rent.
(5) Occupancy agreements and
subleases. Occupancy agreements and
subleases are required as specified in
§ 578.77(a).
(6) Calculation of occupancy charges
and rent. Occupancy charges and rent
from program participants must be
calculated as provided in § 578.77.
(7) Program income. Occupancy
charges and rent collected from program
participants are program income and
may be used as provided under
§ 578.97.
(8) Transition. Beginning in the first
year awards are made under the
Continuum of Care program, renewals of
grants for leasing funds entered into
under the authority of title IV, subtitle
D of the Act as it existed before May 20,
2009, will be renewed either as grants
for leasing or as rental assistance,
depending on the characteristics of the
project. Leasing funds will be renewed
as rental assistance if the funds are used
to pay rent on units where the lease is
between the program participant and
the landowner or sublessor. Projects
requesting leasing funds will be
renewed as leasing if the funds were
used to lease a unit or structure and the
lease is between the recipient or
subrecipient and the landowner.
§ 578.51
Rental assistance.
(a) Use. (1) Grant funds may be used
for rental assistance for homeless
individuals and families. Rental
assistance cannot be provided to a
program participant who is already
receiving rental assistance, or living in
a housing unit receiving rental
assistance or operating assistance
through other federal, State, or local
sources.
PO 00000
Frm 00032
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
(i) The rental assistance may be shortterm, up to 3 months of rent; mediumterm, for 3 to 24 months of rent; or longterm, for longer than 24 months of rent
and must be administered in accordance
with the policies and procedures
established by the Continuum as set
forth in § 578.7(a)(9) and this section.
(ii) The rental assistance may be
tenant-based, project-based, or sponsorbased, and may be for transitional or
permanent housing.
(2) Grant funds may be used for
security deposits in an amount not to
exceed 2 months of rent. An advance
payment of the last month’s rent may be
provided to the landlord, in addition to
the security deposit and payment of first
month’s rent.
(b) Rental assistance administrator.
Rental assistance must be administered
by a State, unit of general local
government, or a public housing agency.
(c) Tenant-based rental assistance.
Tenant-based rental assistance is rental
assistance in which program
participants choose housing of an
appropriate size in which to reside.
When necessary to facilitate the
coordination of supportive services,
recipients and subrecipients may
require program participants to live in a
specific area for their entire period of
participation, or in a specific structure
for the first year and in a specific area
for the remainder of their period of
participation. Program participants who
are receiving rental assistance in
transitional housing may be required to
live in a specific structure for their
entire period of participation in
transitional housing.
(1) Up to 5 years worth of rental
assistance may be awarded to a project
in one competition.
(2) Program participants who have
complied with all program requirements
during their residence retain the rental
assistance if they move within the
Continuum of Care geographic area.
(3) Program participants who have
complied with all program requirements
during their residence and who have
been a victim of domestic violence,
dating violence, sexual assault, or
stalking, and who reasonably believe
they are imminently threatened by harm
from further domestic violence, dating
violence, sexual assault, or stalking
(which would include threats from a
third party, such as a friend or family
member of the perpetrator of the
violence), if they remain in the assisted
unit, and are able to document the
violence and basis for their belief, may
retain the rental assistance and move to
a different Continuum of Care
geographic area if they move out of the
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
assisted unit to protect their health and
safety.
(d) Sponsor-based rental assistance.
Sponsor-based rental assistance is
provided through contracts between the
recipient and sponsor organization. A
sponsor may be a private, nonprofit
organization, or a community mental
health agency established as a public
nonprofit organization. Program
participants must reside in housing
owned or leased by the sponsor. Up to
5 years worth of rental assistance may
be awarded to a project in one
competition.
(e) Project-based rental assistance.
Project-based rental assistance is
provided through a contract with the
owner of an existing structure, where
the owner agrees to lease the subsidized
units to program participants. Program
participants will not retain rental
assistance if they move. Up to 15 years
of rental assistance may be awarded in
one competition.
(f) Grant amount. The amount of
rental assistance in each project will be
based on the number and size of units
proposed by the applicant to be assisted
over the grant period. The amount of
rental assistance in each project will be
calculated by multiplying the number
and size of units proposed by the FMR
of each unit on the date the application
is submitted to HUD, by the term of the
grant.
(g) Rent reasonableness. HUD will
only provide rental assistance for a unit
if the rent is reasonable. The recipient
or subrecipient must determine whether
the rent charged for the unit receiving
rental assistance is reasonable in
relation to rents being charged for
comparable unassisted units, taking into
account the location, size, type, quality,
amenities, facilities, and management
and maintenance of each unit.
Reasonable rent must not exceed rents
currently being charged by the same
owner for comparable unassisted units.
(h) Payment of grant. (1) The amount
of rental assistance in each project will
be reserved for rental assistance over the
grant period. An applicant’s request for
rental assistance in each grant is an
estimate of the amount needed for rental
assistance. Recipients will make draws
from the grant funds to pay the actual
costs of rental assistance for program
participants.
(2) For tenant-based rental assistance,
on demonstration of need:
(i) Up to 25 percent of the total rental
assistance awarded may be spent in any
year of a 5-year grant term; or
(ii) A higher percentage if approved in
advance by HUD, if the recipient
provides evidence satisfactory to HUD
that it is financially committed to
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
providing the housing assistance
described in the application for the full
5-year period.
(3) A recipient must serve at least as
many program participants as shown in
its application for assistance.
(4) If the amount in each grant
reserved for rental assistance over the
grant period exceeds the amount that
will be needed to pay the actual costs
of rental assistance, due to such factors
as contract rents being lower than FMRs
and program participants being able to
pay a portion of the rent, recipients or
subrecipients may use the excess funds
for covering the costs of rent increases,
or for serving a greater number of
program participants.
(i) Vacancies. If a unit assisted under
this section is vacated before the
expiration of the lease, the assistance for
the unit may continue for a maximum
of 30 days from the end of the month
in which the unit was vacated, unless
occupied by another eligible person. No
additional assistance will be paid until
the unit is occupied by another eligible
person. Brief periods of stays in
institutions, not to exceed 90 days for
each occurrence, are not considered
vacancies.
(j) Property damage. Recipients and
subrecipients may use grant funds in an
amount not to exceed one month’s rent
to pay for any damage to housing due
to the action of a program participant.
This shall be a one-time cost per
participant, incurred at the time a
participant exits a housing unit.
(k) Resident rent. Rent must be
calculated as provided in § 578.77.
Rents collected from program
participants are program income and
may be used as provided under
§ 578.97.
(l) Leases. (1) Initial lease. For projectbased, sponsor-based, or tenant-based
rental assistance, program participants
must enter into a lease agreement for a
term of at least one year, which is
terminable for cause. The leases must be
automatically renewable upon
expiration for terms that are a minimum
of one month long, except on prior
notice by either party.
(2) Initial lease for transitional
housing. Program participants in
transitional housing must enter into a
lease agreement for a term of at least one
month. The lease must be automatically
renewable upon expiration, except on
prior notice by either party, up to a
maximum term of 24 months.
§ 578.53
Supportive services.
(a) In general. Grant funds may be
used to pay the eligible costs of
supportive services that address the
special needs of the program
PO 00000
Frm 00033
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45453
participants. If the supportive services
are provided in a supportive service
facility not contained in a housing
structure, the costs of day-to-day
operation of the supportive service
facility, including maintenance, repair,
building security, furniture, utilities,
and equipment are eligible as a
supportive service.
(1) Supportive services must be
necessary to assist program participants
obtain and maintain housing.
(2) Recipients and subrecipients shall
conduct an annual assessment of the
service needs of the program
participants and should adjust services
accordingly.
(b) Duration. (1) For a transitional
housing project, supportive services
must be made available to residents
throughout the duration of their
residence in the project.
(2) Permanent supportive housing
projects must provide supportive
services for the residents to enable them
to live as independently as is
practicable throughout the duration of
their residence in the project.
(3) Services may also be provided to
former residents of transitional housing
and current residents of permanent
housing who were homeless in the prior
6 months, for no more than 6 months
after leaving transitional housing or
homelessness, respectively, to assist
their adjustment to independent living.
(4) Rapid rehousing projects must
require the program participant to meet
with a case manager not less than once
per month as set forth in
§ 578.37(a)(1)(ii)(F), to assist the
program participant in maintaining
long-term housing stability.
(c) Special populations. All eligible
costs are eligible to the same extent for
program participants who are
unaccompanied homeless youth;
persons living with HIV/AIDS; and
victims of domestic violence, dating
violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
(d) Ineligible costs. Any cost that is
not described as an eligible cost under
this section is not an eligible cost of
providing supportive services using
Continuum of Care program funds. Staff
training and the costs of obtaining
professional licenses or certifications
needed to provide supportive services
are not eligible costs.
(e) Eligible costs.
(1) Annual Assessment of Service
Needs. The costs of the assessment
required by § 578.53(a)(2) are eligible
costs.
(2) Assistance with moving costs.
Reasonable one-time moving costs are
eligible and include truck rental and
hiring a moving company.
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
45454
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
(3) Case management. The costs of
assessing, arranging, coordinating, and
monitoring the delivery of
individualized services to meet the
needs of the program participant(s) are
eligible costs. Component services and
activities consist of:
(i) Counseling;
(ii) Developing, securing, and
coordinating services;
(iii) Using the centralized or
coordinated assessment system as
required under § 578.23(c)(9).
(iv) Obtaining federal, State, and local
benefits;
(v) Monitoring and evaluating
program participant progress;
(vi) Providing information and
referrals to other providers;
(vii) Providing ongoing risk
assessment and safety planning with
victims of domestic violence, dating
violence, sexual assault, and stalking;
and
(viii) Developing an individualized
housing and service plan, including
planning a path to permanent housing
stability.
(4) Child care. The costs of
establishing and operating child care,
and providing child-care vouchers, for
children from families experiencing
homelessness, including providing
meals and snacks, and comprehensive
and coordinated developmental
activities, are eligible.
(i) The children must be under the age
of 13, unless they are disabled children.
(ii) Disabled children must be under
the age of 18.
(iii) The child-care center must be
licensed by the jurisdiction in which it
operates in order for its costs to be
eligible.
(5) Education services. The costs of
improving knowledge and basic
educational skills are eligible.
(i) Services include instruction or
training in consumer education, health
education, substance abuse prevention,
literacy, English as a Second Language,
and General Educational Development
(GED).
(ii) Component services or activities
are screening, assessment and testing;
individual or group instruction;
tutoring; provision of books, supplies,
and instructional material; counseling;
and referral to community resources.
(6) Employment assistance and job
training. The costs of establishing and
operating employment assistance and
job training programs are eligible,
including classroom, online and/or
computer instruction, on-the-job
instruction, services that assist
individuals in securing employment,
acquiring learning skills, and/or
increasing earning potential. The cost of
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
providing reasonable stipends to
program participants in employment
assistance and job training programs is
also an eligible cost.
(i) Learning skills include those skills
that can be used to secure and retain a
job, including the acquisition of
vocational licenses and/or certificates.
(ii) Services that assist individuals in
securing employment consist of:
(A) Employment screening,
assessment, or testing;
(B) Structured job skills and jobseeking skills;
(C) Special training and tutoring,
including literacy training and prevocational training;
(D) Books and instructional material;
(E) Counseling or job coaching; and
(F) Referral to community resources.
(7) Food. The cost of providing meals
or groceries to program participants is
eligible.
(8) Housing search and counseling
services. Costs of assisting eligible
program participants to locate, obtain,
and retain suitable housing are eligible.
(i) Component services or activities
are tenant counseling; assisting
individuals and families to understand
leases; securing utilities; and making
moving arrangements.
(ii) Other eligible costs are:
(A) Mediation with property owners
and landlords on behalf of eligible
program participants;
(B) Credit counseling, accessing a free
personal credit report, and resolving
personal credit issues; and
(C) The payment of rental application
fees.
(9) Legal services. Eligible costs are
the fees charged by licensed attorneys
and by person(s) under the supervision
of licensed attorneys, for advice and
representation in matters that interfere
with the homeless individual or family’s
ability to obtain and retain housing.
(i) Eligible subject matters are child
support; guardianship; paternity;
emancipation; legal separation; orders of
protection and other civil remedies for
victims of domestic violence, dating
violence, sexual assault, and stalking;
appeal of veterans and public benefit
claim denials; landlord tenant disputes;
and the resolution of outstanding
criminal warrants.
(ii) Component services or activities
may include receiving and preparing
cases for trial, provision of legal advice,
representation at hearings, and
counseling.
(iii) Fees based on the actual service
performed (i.e., fee for service) are also
eligible, but only if the cost would be
less than the cost of hourly fees. Filing
fees and other necessary court costs are
also eligible. If the subrecipient is a
PO 00000
Frm 00034
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
legal services provider and performs the
services itself, the eligible costs are the
subrecipient’s employees’ salaries and
other costs necessary to perform the
services.
(iv) Legal services for immigration
and citizenship matters and issues
related to mortgages and
homeownership are ineligible. Retainer
fee arrangements and contingency fee
arrangements are ineligible.
(10) Life skills training. The costs of
teaching critical life management skills
that may never have been learned or
have been lost during the course of
physical or mental illness, domestic
violence, substance abuse, and
homelessness are eligible. These
services must be necessary to assist the
program participant to function
independently in the community.
Component life skills training are the
budgeting of resources and money
management, household management,
conflict management, shopping for food
and other needed items, nutrition, the
use of public transportation, and parent
training.
(11) Mental health services. Eligible
costs are the direct outpatient treatment
of mental health conditions that are
provided by licensed professionals.
Component services are crisis
interventions; counseling; individual,
family, or group therapy sessions; the
prescription of psychotropic
medications or explanations about the
use and management of medications;
and combinations of therapeutic
approaches to address multiple
problems.
(12) Outpatient health services.
Eligible costs are the direct outpatient
treatment of medical conditions when
provided by licensed medical
professionals including:
(i) Providing an analysis or
assessment of an individual’s health
problems and the development of a
treatment plan;
(ii) Assisting individuals to
understand their health needs;
(iii) Providing directly or assisting
individuals to obtain and utilize
appropriate medical treatment;
(iv) Preventive medical care and
health maintenance services, including
in-home health services and emergency
medical services;
(v) Provision of appropriate
medication;
(vi) Providing follow-up services; and
(vii) Preventive and noncosmetic
dental care.
(13) Outreach services. The costs of
activities to engage persons for the
purpose of providing immediate support
and intervention, as well as identifying
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
potential program participants, are
eligible.
(i) Eligible costs include the outreach
worker’s transportation costs and a cell
phone to be used by the individual
performing the outreach.
(ii) Component activities and services
consist of: initial assessment; crisis
counseling; addressing urgent physical
needs, such as providing meals,
blankets, clothes, or toiletries; actively
connecting and providing people with
information and referrals to homeless
and mainstream programs; and
publicizing the availability of the
housing and/or services provided
within the geographic area covered by
the Continuum of Care.
(14) Substance abuse treatment
services. The costs of program
participant intake and assessment,
outpatient treatment, group and
individual counseling, and drug testing
are eligible. Inpatient detoxification and
other inpatient drug or alcohol
treatment are ineligible.
(15) Transportation. Eligible costs are:
(i) The costs of program participant’s
travel on public transportation or in a
vehicle provided by the recipient or
subrecipient to and from medical care,
employment, child care, or other
services eligible under this section.
(ii) Mileage allowance for service
workers to visit program participants
and to carry out housing quality
inspections;
(iii) The cost of purchasing or leasing
a vehicle in which staff transports
program participants and/or staff
serving program participants;
(iv) The cost of gas, insurance, taxes,
and maintenance for the vehicle;
(v) The costs of recipient or
subrecipient staff to accompany or assist
program participants to utilize public
transportation; and
(vi) If public transportation options
are not sufficient within the area, the
recipient may make a one-time payment
on behalf of a program participant
needing car repairs or maintenance
required to operate a personal vehicle,
subject to the following:
(A) Payments for car repairs or
maintenance on behalf of the program
participant may not exceed 10 percent
of the Blue Book value of the vehicle
(Blue Book refers to the guidebook that
compiles and quotes prices for new and
used automobiles and other vehicles of
all makes, models, and types);
(B) Payments for car repairs or
maintenance must be paid by the
recipient or subrecipient directly to the
third party that repairs or maintains the
car; and
(C) The recipients or subrecipients
may require program participants to
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
share in the cost of car repairs or
maintenance as a condition of receiving
assistance with car repairs or
maintenance.
(16) Utility deposits. This form of
assistance consists of paying for utility
deposits. Utility deposits must be a onetime fee, paid to utility companies.
(17) Direct provision of services. If the
service described in paragraphs (e)(1)
through (e)(16) of this section is being
directly delivered by the recipient or
subrecipient, eligible costs for those
services also include:
(i) The costs of labor or supplies, and
materials incurred by the recipient or
subrecipient in directly providing
supportive services to program
participants; and
(ii) The salary and benefit packages of
the recipient and subrecipient staff who
directly deliver the services.
§ 578.55
Operating costs.
(a) Use. Grant funds may be used to
pay the costs of the day-to-day operation
of transitional and permanent housing
in a single structure or individual
housing units.
(b) Eligible costs. (1) The maintenance
and repair of housing;
(2) Property taxes and insurance;
(3) Scheduled payments to a reserve
for replacement of major systems of the
housing (provided that the payments
must be based on the useful life of the
system and expected replacement cost);
(4) Building security for a structure
where more than 50 percent of the units
or area is paid for with grant funds;
(5) Electricity, gas, and water;
(6) Furniture; and
(7) Equipment.
(c) Ineligible costs. Program funds
may not be used for rental assistance
and operating costs in the same project.
Program funds may not be used for the
operating costs of emergency shelterand supportive service-only facilities.
Program funds may not be used for the
maintenance and repair of housing
where the costs of maintaining and
repairing the housing are included in
the lease.
§ 578.57 Homeless Management
Information System.
(a) Eligible costs. (1) The recipient or
subrecipient may use Continuum of
Care program funds to pay the costs of
contributing data to the HMIS
designated by the Continuum of Care,
including the costs of:
(i) Purchasing or leasing computer
hardware;
(ii) Purchasing software or software
licenses;
(iii) Purchasing or leasing equipment,
including telephones, fax machines, and
furniture;
PO 00000
Frm 00035
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45455
(iv) Obtaining technical support;
(v) Leasing office space;
(vi) Paying charges for electricity, gas,
water, phone service, and high-speed
data transmission necessary to operate
or contribute data to the HMIS;
(vii) Paying salaries for operating
HMIS, including:
(A) Completing data entry;
(B) Monitoring and reviewing data
quality;
(C) Completing data analysis;
(D) Reporting to the HMIS Lead;
(E) Training staff on using the HMIS;
and
(F) Implementing and complying with
HMIS requirements;
(viii) Paying costs of staff to travel to
and attend HUD-sponsored and HUDapproved training on HMIS and
programs authorized by Title IV of the
McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance
Act;
(ix) Paying staff travel costs to
conduct intake; and
(x) Paying participation fees charged
by the HMIS Lead, as authorized by
HUD, if the recipient or subrecipient is
not the HMIS Lead.
(2) If the recipient or subrecipient is
the HMIS Lead, it may also use
Continuum of Care funds to pay the
costs of:
(i) Hosting and maintaining HMIS
software or data;
(ii) Backing up, recovering, or
repairing HMIS software or data;
(iii) Upgrading, customizing, and
enhancing the HMIS;
(iv) Integrating and warehousing data,
including development of a data
warehouse for use in aggregating data
from subrecipients using multiple
software systems;
(v) Administering the system;
(vi) Reporting to providers, the
Continuum of Care, and HUD; and
(vii) Conducting training on using the
system, including traveling to the
training.
(3) If the recipient or subrecipient is
a victim services provider, or a legal
services provider, it may use Continuum
of Care funds to establish and operate a
comparable database that complies with
HUD’s HMIS requirements.
(b) General restrictions. Activities
funded under this section must comply
with the HMIS requirements.
§ 578.59
Project administrative costs.
(a) Eligible costs. The recipient or
subrecipient may use up to 10 percent
of any grant awarded under this part,
excluding the amount for Continuum of
Care Planning Activities and UFA costs,
for the payment of project
administrative costs related to the
planning and execution of Continuum
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
45456
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
of Care activities. This does not include
staff and overhead costs directly related
to carrying out activities eligible under
§ 578.43 through § 578.57, because those
costs are eligible as part of those
activities. Eligible administrative costs
include:
(1) General management, oversight,
and coordination. Costs of overall
program management, coordination,
monitoring, and evaluation. These costs
include, but are not limited to,
necessary expenditures for the
following:
(i) Salaries, wages, and related costs of
the recipient’s staff, the staff of
subrecipients, or other staff engaged in
program administration. In charging
costs to this category, the recipient may
include the entire salary, wages, and
related costs allocable to the program of
each person whose primary
responsibilities with regard to the
program involve program
administration assignments, or the pro
rata share of the salary, wages, and
related costs of each person whose job
includes any program administration
assignments. The recipient may use
only one of these methods for each
fiscal year grant. Program
administration assignments include the
following:
(A) Preparing program budgets and
schedules, and amendments to those
budgets and schedules;
(B) Developing systems for assuring
compliance with program requirements;
(C) Developing agreements with
subrecipients and contractors to carry
out program activities;
(D) Monitoring program activities for
progress and compliance with program
requirements;
(E) Preparing reports and other
documents directly related to the
program for submission to HUD;
(F) Coordinating the resolution of
audit and monitoring findings;
(G) Evaluating program results against
stated objectives; and
(H) Managing or supervising persons
whose primary responsibilities with
regard to the program include such
assignments as those described in
paragraph (a)(1)(i)(A) through (G) of this
section.
(ii) Travel costs incurred for
monitoring of subrecipients;
(iii) Administrative services
performed under third-party contracts
or agreements, including general legal
services, accounting services, and audit
services; and
(iv) Other costs for goods and services
required for administration of the
program, including rental or purchase of
equipment, insurance, utilities, office
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
supplies, and rental and maintenance
(but not purchase) of office space.
(2) Training on Continuum of Care
requirements. Costs of providing
training on Continuum of Care
requirements and attending HUDsponsored Continuum of Care trainings.
(3) Environmental review. Costs of
carrying out the environmental review
responsibilities under § 578.31.
(b) Sharing requirement. (1) UFAs. If
the recipient is a UFA that carries out
a project, it may use up to 10 percent
of the grant amount awarded for the
project on project administrative costs.
The UFA must share the remaining
project administrative funds with its
subrecipients.
(2) Recipients that are not UFAs. If the
recipient is not a UFA, it must share at
least 50 percent of project
administrative funds with its
subrecipients.
§ 578.61
Relocation costs.
(a) In general. Relocation costs under
the Uniform Relocation Assistance and
Real Property Acquisition Policies Act
of 1970 are eligible.
(b) Eligible relocation costs. Eligible
costs are costs to provide relocation
payments and other assistance to
persons displaced by a project assisted
with grant funds in accordance with
§ 578.83.
§ 578.63
Indirect costs.
(a) In general. Continuum of Care
funds may be used to pay indirect costs
in accordance with OMB Circulars A–87
or A–122, as applicable.
(b) Allocation. Indirect costs may be
allocated to each eligible activity as
provided in subpart D, so long as that
allocation is consistent with an indirect
cost rate proposal developed in
accordance with OMB Circulars A–87 or
A–122, as applicable.
(c) Expenditure limits. The indirect
costs charged to an activity subject to an
expenditure limit under §§ 578.39,
578.41, and 578.59 must be added to the
direct costs charged for that activity
when determining the total costs subject
to the expenditure limits.
Subpart E—High-Performing
Communities
§ 578.65
Standards.
(a) In general. The collaborative
applicant for a Continuum may apply to
HUD to have the Continuum be
designated a high-performing
community (HPC). The designation
shall be for grants awarded in the same
competition in which the designation is
applied for and made.
(b) Applying for HPC designation. The
application must be submitted at such
PO 00000
Frm 00036
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
time and in such manner as HUD may
require, must use HMIS data where
required to show the standards for
qualifying are met, and must contain
such information as HUD requires,
including at a minimum:
(1) A report showing how the
Continuum of Care program funds
received in the preceding year were
expended;
(2) A specific plan for how grant
funds will be expended; and
(3) Information establishing that the
Continuum of Care meets the standards
for HPCs.
(c) Standards for qualifying as an
HPC. To qualify as an HPC, a
Continuum must demonstrate through:
(1) Reliable data generated by the
Continuum of Care’s HMIS that it meets
all of the following standards:
(i) Mean length of homelessness.
Either the mean length of episode of
homelessness within the Continuum’s
geographic area is fewer than 20 days,
or the mean length of episodes of
homelessness for individuals or families
in similar circumstances was reduced
by at least 10 percent from the
preceding federal fiscal year.
(ii) Reduced recidivism. Of
individuals and families who leave
homelessness, less than 5 percent
become homeless again at any time
within the next 2 years; or the
percentage of individuals and families
in similar circumstances who become
homeless again within 2 years after
leaving homelessness was decreased by
at least 20 percent from the preceding
federal fiscal year.
(iii) HMIS coverage. The Continuum’s
HMIS must have a bed coverage rate of
80 percent and a service volume
coverage rate of 80 percent as calculated
in accordance with HUD’s HMIS
requirements.
(iv) Serving families and youth. With
respect to Continuums that served
homeless families and youth defined as
homeless under other federal statutes in
paragraph (3) of the definition of
homeless in § 576.2:
(A) 95 percent of those families and
youth did not become homeless again
within a 2-year period following
termination of assistance; or
(B) 85 percent of those families
achieved independent living in
permanent housing for at least 2 years
following termination of assistance.
(2) Reliable data generated from
sources other than the Continuum’s
HMIS that is provided in a narrative or
other form prescribed by HUD that it
meets both of the following standards:
(i) Community action. All the
metropolitan cities and counties within
the Continuum’s geographic area have a
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
comprehensive outreach plan, including
specific steps for identifying homeless
persons and referring them to
appropriate housing and services in that
geographic area.
(ii) Renewing HPC status. If the
Continuum was designated an HPC in
the previous federal fiscal year and used
Continuum of Care grant funds for
activities described under § 578.71, that
such activities were effective at
reducing the number of individuals and
families who became homeless in that
community.
§ 578.67
Publication of application.
HUD will publish the application to
be designated an HPC through the HUD
Web site, for public comment as to
whether the Continuum seeking
designation as an HPC meets the
standards for being one.
§ 578.69
Cooperation among entities.
An HPC must cooperate with HUD in
distributing information about its
successful efforts to reduce
homelessness.
§ 578.71
HPC-eligible activities.
In addition to using grant funds for
the eligible costs described in subpart D
of this part, recipients and subrecipients
in Continuums of Care designated as
HPCs may also use grant funds to
provide housing relocation and
stabilization services and short- and/or
medium-term rental assistance to
individuals and families at risk of
homelessness as set forth in 24 CFR
576.103 and 24 CFR 576.104, if
necessary to prevent the individual or
family from becoming homeless.
Activities must be carried out in
accordance with the plan submitted in
the application. When carrying out
housing relocation and stabilization
services and short- and/or medium-term
rental assistance, the written standards
set forth in § 578.7(a)(9)(v) and
recordkeeping requirements of 24 CFR
576.500 apply.
Subpart F—Program Requirements
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
§ 578.73
Matching requirements.
(a) In general. The recipient or
subrecipient must match all grant funds,
except for leasing funds, with no less
than 25 percent of funds or in-kind
contributions from other sources. For
Continuum of Care geographic areas in
which there is more than one grant
agreement, the 25 percent match must
be provided on a grant-by-grant basis.
Recipients that are UFAs or are the sole
recipient for their Continuum, may
provide match on a Continuum-wide
basis. Cash match must be used for the
costs of activities that are eligible under
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
subpart D of this part, except that HPCs
may use such match for the costs of
activities that are eligible under
§ 578.71.
(b) Cash sources. A recipient or
subrecipient may use funds from any
source, including any other federal
sources (excluding Continuum of Care
program funds), as well as State, local,
and private sources, provided that funds
from the source are not statutorily
prohibited to be used as a match. The
recipient must ensure that any funds
used to satisfy the matching
requirements of this section are eligible
under the laws governing the funds in
order to be used as matching funds for
a grant awarded under this program.
(c) In-kind contributions. (1) The
recipient or subrecipient may use the
value of any real property, equipment,
goods, or services contributed to the
project as match, provided that if the
recipient or subrecipient had to pay for
them with grant funds, the costs would
have been eligible under Subpart D, or,
in the case of HPCs, eligible under
§ 578.71.
(2) The requirements of 24 CFR 84.23
and 85.24 apply.
(3) Before grant execution, services to
be provided by a third party must be
documented by a memorandum of
understanding (MOU) between the
recipient or subrecipient and the third
party that will provide the services.
Services provided by individuals must
be valued at rates consistent with those
ordinarily paid for similar work in the
recipient’s or subrecipient’s
organization. If the recipient or
subrecipient does not have employees
performing similar work, the rates must
be consistent with those ordinarily paid
by other employers for similar work in
the same labor market.
(i) The MOU must establish the
unconditional commitment, except for
selection to receive a grant, by the third
party to provide the services, the
specific service to be provided, the
profession of the persons providing the
service, and the hourly cost of the
service to be provided.
(ii) During the term of the grant, the
recipient or subrecipient must keep and
make available, for inspection, records
documenting the service hours
provided.
§ 578.75
General operations.
(a) State and local requirements. (1)
Housing and facilities constructed or
rehabilitated with assistance under this
part must meet State or local building
codes, and in the absence of State or
local building codes, the International
Residential Code or International
Building Code (as applicable to the type
PO 00000
Frm 00037
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45457
of structure) of the International Code
Council.
(2) Services provided with assistance
under this part must be provided in
compliance with all applicable State
and local requirements, including
licensing requirements.
(b) Housing quality standards.
Housing leased with Continuum of Care
program funds, or for which rental
assistance payments are made with
Continuum of Care program funds, must
meet the applicable housing quality
standards (HQS) under 24 CFR 982.401
of this title, except that 24 CFR
982.401(j) applies only to housing
occupied by program participants
receiving tenant-based rental assistance.
For housing rehabilitated with funds
under this part, the lead-based paint
requirements in 24 CFR part 35,
subparts A, B, J, and R apply. For
housing that receives project-based or
sponsor-based rental assistance, 24 CFR
part 35, subparts A, B, H, and R apply.
For residential property for which funds
under this part are used for acquisition,
leasing, services, or operating costs, 24
CFR part 35, subparts A, B, K, and R
apply.
(1) Before any assistance will be
provided on behalf of a program
participant, the recipient, or
subrecipient, must physically inspect
each unit to assure that the unit meets
HQS. Assistance will not be provided
for units that fail to meet HQS, unless
the owner corrects any deficiencies
within 30 days from the date of the
initial inspection and the recipient or
subrecipient verifies that all deficiencies
have been corrected.
(2) Recipients or subrecipients must
inspect all units at least annually during
the grant period to ensure that the units
continue to meet HQS.
(c) Suitable dwelling size. The
dwelling unit must have at least one
bedroom or living/sleeping room for
each two persons.
(1) Children of opposite sex, other
than very young children, may not be
required to occupy the same bedroom or
living/sleeping room.
(2) If household composition changes
during the term of assistance, recipients
and subrecipients may relocate the
household to a more appropriately sized
unit. The household must still have
access to appropriate supportive
services.
(d) Meals. Each recipient and
subrecipient of assistance under this
part who provides supportive housing
for homeless persons with disabilities
must provide meals or meal preparation
facilities for residents.
(e) Ongoing assessment of supportive
services. To the extent practicable, each
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
45458
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
project must provide supportive
services for residents of the project and
homeless persons using the project,
which may be designed by the recipient
or participants. Each recipient and
subrecipient of assistance under this
part must conduct an ongoing
assessment of the supportive services
needed by the residents of the project,
the availability of such services, and the
coordination of services needed to
ensure long-term housing stability and
must make adjustments, as appropriate.
(f) Residential supervision. Each
recipient and subrecipient of assistance
under this part must provide residential
supervision as necessary to facilitate the
adequate provision of supportive
services to the residents of the housing
throughout the term of the commitment
to operate supportive housing.
Residential supervision may include the
employment of a full- or part-time
residential supervisor with sufficient
knowledge to provide or to supervise
the provision of supportive services to
the residents.
(g) Participation of homeless
individuals. (1) Each recipient and
subrecipient must provide for the
participation of not less than one
homeless individual or formerly
homeless individual on the board of
directors or other equivalent
policymaking entity of the recipient or
subrecipient, to the extent that such
entity considers and makes policies and
decisions regarding any project,
supportive services, or assistance
provided under this part. This
requirement is waived if a recipient or
subrecipient is unable to meet such
requirement and obtains HUD approval
for a plan to otherwise consult with
homeless or formerly homeless persons
when considering and making policies
and decisions.
(2) Each recipient and subrecipient of
assistance under this part must, to the
maximum extent practicable, involve
homeless individuals and families
through employment; volunteer
services; or otherwise in constructing,
rehabilitating, maintaining, and
operating the project, and in providing
supportive services for the project.
(h) Supportive service agreement.
Recipients and subrecipients may
require the program participants to take
part in supportive services that are not
disability-related services provided
through the project as a condition of
continued participation in the program.
Examples of disability-related services
include, but are not limited to, mental
health services, outpatient health
services, and provision of medication,
which are provided to a person with a
disability to address a condition caused
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
by the disability. Notwithstanding this
provision, if the purpose of the project
is to provide substance abuse treatment
services, recipients and subrecipients
may require program participants to
take part in such services as a condition
of continued participation in the
program.
(i) Retention of assistance after death,
incarceration, or institutionalization for
more than 90 days of qualifying
member. For permanent supportive
housing projects surviving, members of
any household who were living in a unit
assisted under this part at the time of
the qualifying member’s death, longterm incarceration, or long-term
institutionalization, have the right to
rental assistance under this section until
the expiration of the lease in effect at
the time of the qualifying member’s
death, long-term incarceration, or longterm institutionalization.
§ 578.77 Calculating occupancy charges
and rent.
(a) Occupancy agreements and leases.
Recipients and subrecipients must have
signed occupancy agreements or leases
(or subleases) with program participants
residing in housing.
(b) Calculation of occupancy charges.
Recipients and subrecipients are not
required to impose occupancy charges
on program participants as a condition
of residing in the housing. However, if
occupancy charges are imposed, they
may not exceed the highest of:
(1) 30 percent of the family’s monthly
adjusted income (adjustment factors
include the number of people in the
family, age of family members, medical
expenses, and child-care expenses);
(2) 10 percent of the family’s monthly
income; or
(3) If the family is receiving payments
for welfare assistance from a public
agency and a part of the payments
(adjusted in accordance with the
family’s actual housing costs) is
specifically designated by the agency to
meet the family’s housing costs, the
portion of the payments that is
designated for housing costs.
(4) Income. Income must be
calculated in accordance with 24 CFR
5.609 and 24 CFR 5.611(a). Recipients
and subrecipients must examine a
program participant’s income initially,
and if there is a change in family
composition (e.g., birth of a child) or a
decrease in the resident’s income during
the year, the resident may request an
interim reexamination, and the
occupancy charge will be adjusted
accordingly.
(c) Resident rent. (1) Amount of rent.
(i) Each program participant on whose
behalf rental assistance payments are
PO 00000
Frm 00038
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
made must pay a contribution toward
rent in accordance with section 3(a)(1)
of the U.S. Housing Act of 1937 (42
U.S.C. 1437a(a)(1)).
(ii) Income of program participants
must be calculated in accordance with
24 CFR 5.609 and 24 CFR 5.611(a).
(2) Review. Recipients or
subrecipients must examine a program
participant’s income initially, and at
least annually thereafter, to determine
the amount of the contribution toward
rent payable by the program participant.
Adjustments to a program participant’s
contribution toward the rental payment
must be made as changes in income are
identified.
(3) Verification. As a condition of
participation in the program, each
program participant must agree to
supply the information or
documentation necessary to verify the
program participant’s income. Program
participants must provide the recipient
or subrecipient with information at any
time regarding changes in income or
other circumstances that may result in
changes to a program participant’s
contribution toward the rental payment.
§ 578.79 Limitation on transitional
housing.
A homeless individual or family may
remain in transitional housing for a
period longer than 24 months, if
permanent housing for the individual or
family has not been located or if the
individual or family requires additional
time to prepare for independent living.
However, HUD may discontinue
assistance for a transitional housing
project if more than half of the homeless
individuals or families remain in that
project longer than 24 months.
§ 578.81 Term of commitment, repayment
of grants, and prevention of undue benefits.
(a) In general. All recipients and
subrecipients receiving grant funds for
acquisition, rehabilitation, or new
construction must operate the housing
or provide supportive services in
accordance with this part, for at least 15
years from the date of initial occupancy
or date of initial service provision.
Recipient and subrecipients must
execute and record a HUD-approved
Declaration of Restrictive Covenants
before receiving payment of grant funds.
(b) Conversion. Recipients and
subrecipients carrying out a project that
provides transitional or permanent
housing or supportive services in a
structure may submit a request to HUD
to convert a project for the direct benefit
of very low-income persons. The request
must be made while the project is
operating as homeless housing or
supportive services for homeless
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
individuals and families, must be in
writing, and must include an
explanation of why the project is no
longer needed to provide transitional or
permanent housing or supportive
services. The primary factor in HUD’s
decision on the proposed conversion is
the unmet need for transitional or
permanent housing or supportive
services in the Continuum of Care’s
geographic area.
(c) Repayment of grant funds. If a
project is not operated as transitional or
permanent housing for 10 years
following the date of initial occupancy,
HUD will require repayment of the
entire amount of the grant used for
acquisition, rehabilitation, or new
construction, unless conversion of the
project has been authorized under
paragraph (b) of this section. If the
housing is used for such purposes for
more than 10 years, the payment
amount will be reduced by 20
percentage points for each year, beyond
the 10-year period in which the project
is used for transitional or permanent
housing.
(d) Prevention of undue benefits.
Except as provided under paragraph (e)
of this section, upon any sale or other
disposition of a project site that received
grant funds for acquisition,
rehabilitation, or new construction,
occurring before the 15-year period, the
recipient must comply with such terms
and conditions as HUD may prescribe to
prevent the recipient or subrecipient
from unduly benefiting from such sale
or disposition.
(e) Exception. A recipient or
subrecipient will not be required to
comply with the terms and conditions
prescribed under paragraphs (c) and (d)
of this section if:
(1) The sale or disposition of the
property used for the project results in
the use of the property for the direct
benefit of very low-income persons;
(2) All the proceeds are used to
provide transitional or permanent
housing that meet the requirements of
this part;
(3) Project-based rental assistance or
operating cost assistance from any
federal program or an equivalent State
or local program is no longer made
available and the project is meeting
applicable performance standards,
provided that the portion of the project
that had benefitted from such assistance
continues to meet the tenant income
and rent restrictions for low-income
units under section 42(g) of the Internal
Revenue Code of 1986; or
(4) There are no individuals and
families in the Continuum of Care
geographic area who are homeless, in
which case the project may serve
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
individuals and families at risk of
homelessness.
§ 578.83 Displacement, relocation, and
acquisition.
(a) Minimizing displacement.
Consistent with the other goals and
objectives of this part, recipients and
subrecipients must ensure that they
have taken all reasonable steps to
minimize the displacement of persons
(families, individuals, businesses,
nonprofit organizations, and farms) as a
result of projects assisted under this
part. ‘‘Project,’’ as used in this section,
means any activity or series of activities
assisted with Continuum of Care funds
received or anticipated in any phase of
an undertaking.
(b) Temporary relocation. (1) Existing
Building Not Assisted under Title IV of
the McKinney-Vento Act. No tenant may
be required to relocate temporarily for a
project if the building in which the
project is being undertaken or will be
undertaken is not currently assisted
under Title IV of the McKinney-Vento
Act. The absence of such assistance to
the building means the tenants are not
homeless and the tenants are therefore
not eligible to receive assistance under
the Continuum of Care program. When
a tenant moves for such a project under
conditions that cause the Uniform
Relocation Assistance and Real Property
Acquisition Policies Act of 1970 (URA),
42 U.S.C. 4601–4655, to apply, the
tenant must be treated as permanently
displaced and offered relocation
assistance and payments consistent with
paragraph (c) of this section.
(2) Existing Transitional Housing or
Permanent Housing Projects Assisted
Under Title IV of the McKinney-Vento
Act. Consistent with paragraph (c)(2)(ii)
of this section, no program participant
may be required to relocate temporarily
for a project if the person cannot be
offered a decent, safe, and sanitary unit
in the same building or complex upon
project completion under reasonable
terms and conditions. The length of
occupancy requirements in § 578.79
may prevent a program participant from
returning to the property upon
completion (See paragraph (c)(2)(iii)(D)
of this section). Any program
participant who has been temporarily
relocated for a period beyond one year
must be treated as permanently
displaced and offered relocation
assistance and payments consistent with
paragraph (c) of this section. Program
participants temporarily relocated in
accordance with the policies described
in this paragraph must be provided:
(i) Reimbursement for all reasonable
out-of-pocket expenses incurred in
connection with the temporary
PO 00000
Frm 00039
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45459
relocation, including the cost of moving
to and from the temporarily occupied
housing and any increase in monthly
rent/occupancy charges and utility
costs; and
(ii) Appropriate advisory services,
including reasonable advance written
notice of:
(A) The date and approximate
duration of the temporary relocation;
(B) The location of the suitable,
decent, safe, and sanitary dwelling to be
made available for the temporary
period;
(C) The reasonable terms and
conditions under which the program
participant will be able to occupy a
suitable, decent, safe, and sanitary
dwelling in the building or complex
upon completion of the project; and
(D) The provisions of paragraph
(b)(2)(i) of this section.
(c) Relocation assistance for displaced
persons. (1) In general. A displaced
person (defined in paragraph (c)(2) of
this section) must be provided
relocation assistance in accordance with
the requirements of the URA and
implementing regulations at 49 CFR part
24. A displaced person must be advised
of his or her rights under the Fair
Housing Act. Whenever possible,
minority persons must be given
reasonable opportunities to relocate to
decent, safe, and sanitary replacement
dwellings, not located in an area of
minority concentration, that are within
their financial means. This policy,
however, does not require providing a
person a larger payment than is
necessary to enable a person to relocate
to a comparable replacement dwelling.
See 49 CFR 24.205(c)(2)(ii)(D).
(2) Displaced person. (i) For the
purposes of paragraph (c) of this section,
the term ‘‘displaced person’’ means any
person (family, individual, business,
nonprofit organization, or farm) that
moves from real property, or moves
personal property from real property,
permanently, as a direct result of
acquisition, rehabilitation, or
demolition for a project. This includes
any permanent, involuntary move for a
project, including any permanent move
from the real property that is made:
(A) After the owner (or person in
control of the site) issues a notice to
move permanently from the property, or
refuses to renew an expiring lease, if the
move occurs after the date of the
submission by the recipient or
subrecipient of an application for
assistance to HUD (or the recipient, as
applicable) that is later approved and
funded and the recipient or subrecipient
has site control as evidenced in
accordance with § 578.25(b); or
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
45460
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
(B) After the owner (or person in
control of the site) issues a notice to
move permanently from the property, or
refuses to renew an expiring lease, if the
move occurs after the date the recipient
or subrecipient obtains site control, as
evidenced in accordance with
§ 578.25(b), if that occurs after the
application for assistance; or
(C) Before the date described under
paragraph (c)(2)(i)(A) or (B) of this
section, if the recipient or HUD
determines that the displacement
resulted directly from acquisition,
rehabilitation, or demolition for the
project; or
(D) By a tenant of a building that is
not assisted under Title IV of the
McKinney-Vento Act, if the tenant
moves after execution of the agreement
covering the acquisition, rehabilitation,
or demolition of the property for the
project; or
(ii) For the purposes of paragraph (c)
of this section, the term ‘‘displaced
person’’ means any person (family,
individual, business, nonprofit
organization, or farm) that moves from
real property, or moves personal
property from real property,
permanently, as a direct result of
acquisition, rehabilitation, or
demolition for a project. This includes
any permanent, involuntary move for a
project that is made by a program
participant occupying transitional
housing or permanent housing assisted
under Title IV of the McKinney-Vento
Act, if any one of the following three
situations occurs:
(A) The program participant moves
after execution of the agreement
covering the acquisition, rehabilitation,
or demolition of the property for the
project and is either not eligible to
return upon project completion or the
move occurs before the program
participant is provided written notice
offering the program participant an
opportunity to occupy a suitable,
decent, safe, and sanitary dwelling in
the same building or complex upon
project completion under reasonable
terms and conditions. Such reasonable
terms and conditions must include a
lease (or occupancy agreement, as
applicable) consistent with Continuum
of Care program requirements, including
a monthly rent or occupancy charge and
monthly utility costs that does not
exceed the maximum amounts
established in § 578.77; or
(B) The program participant is
required to relocate temporarily, does
not return to the building or complex,
and any one of the following situations
occurs:
(1) The program participant is not
offered payment for all reasonable out-
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
of-pocket expenses incurred in
connection with the temporary
relocation;
(2) The program participant is not
eligible to return to the building or
complex upon project completion; or
(3) Other conditions of the temporary
relocation are not reasonable; or
(C) The program participant is
required to move to another unit in the
same building or complex, and any one
of the following situations occurs:
(1) The program participant is not
offered reimbursement for all reasonable
out-of-pocket expenses incurred in
connection with the move;
(2) The program participant is not
eligible to remain in the building or
complex upon project completion; or
(3) Other conditions of the move are
not reasonable.
(iii) Notwithstanding the provisions of
paragraph (c)(2)(i) or (ii) of this section,
a person does not qualify as a
‘‘displaced person’’ if:
(A) The person has been evicted for
serious or repeated violation of the
terms and conditions of the lease or
occupancy agreement; the eviction
complied with applicable federal, State,
or local requirements (see § 578.91); and
the recipient or subrecipient determines
that the eviction was not undertaken for
the purpose of evading the obligation to
provide relocation assistance;
(B) The person moved into the
property after the submission of the
application but, before signing a lease or
occupancy agreement and commencing
occupancy, was provided written notice
of the project’s possible impact on the
person (e.g., the person may be
displaced, temporarily relocated, or
incur a rent increase) and the fact that
the person would not qualify as a
‘‘displaced person’’ (or for any
relocation assistance provided under
this section), as a result of the project;
(C) The person is ineligible under 49
CFR 24.2(a)(9)(ii));
(D) The person is a program
participant occupying transitional
housing or permanent housing assisted
under Title IV of the Act who must
move as a direct result of the length-ofoccupancy restriction under § 578.79; or
(E) HUD determines that the person
was not displaced as a direct result of
acquisition, rehabilitation, or
demolition for the project.
(iv) The recipient may request, at any
time, HUD’s determination of whether a
displacement is or would be covered
under this section.
(3) Initiation of negotiations. For
purposes of determining the formula for
computing replacement housing
payment assistance to be provided to a
displaced person pursuant to this
PO 00000
Frm 00040
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
section, if the displacement is a direct
result of privately undertaken
rehabilitation, demolition, or
acquisition of the real property,
‘‘initiation of negotiations’’ means the
execution of the agreement between the
recipient and the subrecipient, or
between the recipient (or subrecipient,
as applicable) and the person owning or
controlling the property. In the case of
an option contract to acquire property,
the initiation of negotiations does not
become effective until execution of a
written agreement that creates a legally
enforceable commitment to proceed
with the purchase, such as a purchase
agreement.
(d) Real property acquisition
requirements. Except for acquisitions
described in 49 CFR 24.101(b)(1)
through (5), the URA and the
requirements of 49 CFR part 24, subpart
B apply to any acquisition of real
property for a project where there are
Continuum of Care funds in any part of
the project costs.
(e) Appeals. A person who disagrees
with the recipient’s (or subrecipient’s, if
applicable) determination concerning
whether the person qualifies as a
displaced person, or the amount of
relocation assistance for which the
person is eligible, may file a written
appeal of that determination with the
recipient (see 49 CFR 24.10). A lowincome person who is dissatisfied with
the recipient’s determination on his or
her appeal may submit a written request
for review of that determination to the
local HUD field office.
§ 578.85
Timeliness standards.
(a) In general. Recipients must initiate
approved activities and projects
promptly.
(b) Construction activities. Recipients
of funds for rehabilitation or new
construction must meet the following
standards:
(1) Construction activities must begin
within 9 months of the later of signing
of the grant agreement or of signing an
addendum to the grant agreement
authorizing use of grant funds for the
project.
(2) Construction activities must be
completed within 24 months of signing
the grant agreement.
(3) Activities that cannot begin until
after construction activities are
completed must begin within 3 months
of the date that construction activities
are completed.
(c) Distribution. A recipient that
receives funds through this part must:
(1) Distribute the funds to
subrecipients (in advance of
expenditures by the subrecipients);
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
(2) Distribute the appropriate portion
of the funds to a subrecipient no later
than 45 days after receiving an
approvable request for such distribution
from the subrecipient; and
(3) Draw down funds at least once per
quarter of the program year, after
eligible activities commence.
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
§ 578.87
Limitation on use of funds.
(a) Maintenance of effort. No
assistance provided under this part (or
any State or local government funds
used to supplement this assistance) may
be used to replace State or local funds
previously used, or designated for use,
to assist homeless persons.
(b) Faith-based activities. (1) Equal
treatment of program participants and
program beneficiaries. (i) Program
participants. Organizations that are
religious or faith-based are eligible, on
the same basis as any other
organization, to participate in the
Continuum of Care program. Neither the
Federal Government nor a State or local
government receiving funds under the
Continuum of Care program shall
discriminate against an organization on
the basis of the organization’s religious
character or affiliation. Recipients and
subrecipients of program funds shall
not, in providing program assistance,
discriminate against a program
participant or prospective program
participant on the basis of religion or
religious belief.
(ii) Beneficiaries. In providing
services supported in whole or in part
with federal financial assistance, and in
their outreach activities related to such
services, program participants shall not
discriminate against current or
prospective program beneficiaries on
the basis of religion, a religious belief,
a refusal to hold a religious belief, or a
refusal to attend or participate in a
religious practice.
(2) Separation of explicitly religious
activities. Recipients and subrecipients
of Continuum of Care funds that engage
in explicitly religious activities,
including activities that involve overt
religious content such as worship,
religious instruction, or proselytization,
must perform such activities and offer
such services outside of programs that
are supported with federal financial
assistance separately, in time or
location, from the programs or services
funded under this part, and
participation in any such explicitly
religious activities must be voluntary for
the program beneficiaries of the HUDfunded programs or services.
(3) Religious identity. A faith-based
organization that is a recipient or
subrecipient of Continuum of Care
program funds is eligible to use such
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
funds as provided under the regulations
of this part without impairing its
independence, autonomy, expression of
religious beliefs, or religious character.
Such organization will retain its
independence from federal, State, and
local government, and may continue to
carry out its mission, including the
definition, development, practice, and
expression of its religious beliefs,
provided that it does not use direct
program funds to support or engage in
any explicitly religious activities,
including activities that involve overt
religious content, such as worship,
religious instruction, or proselytization,
or any manner prohibited by law.
Among other things, faith-based
organizations may use space in their
facilities to provide program-funded
services, without removing or altering
religious art, icons, scriptures, or other
religious symbols. In addition, a
Continuum of Care program-funded
religious organization retains its
authority over its internal governance,
and it may retain religious terms in its
organization’s name, select its board
members on a religious basis, and
include religious references in its
organization’s mission statements and
other governing documents.
(4) Alternative provider. If a program
participant or prospective program
participant of the Continuum of Care
program supported by HUD objects to
the religious character of an
organization that provides services
under the program, that organization
shall, within a reasonably prompt time
after the objection, undertake reasonable
efforts to identify and refer the program
participant to an alternative provider to
which the prospective program
participant has no objection. Except for
services provided by telephone, the
Internet, or similar means, the referral
must be to an alternate provider in
reasonable geographic proximity to the
organization making the referral. In
making the referral, the organization
shall comply with applicable privacy
laws and regulations. Recipients and
subrecipients shall document any
objections from program participants
and prospective program participants
and any efforts to refer such participants
to alternative providers in accordance
with the requirements of
§ 578.103(a)(13). Recipients shall ensure
that all subrecipient agreements make
organizations receiving program funds
aware of these requirements.
(5) Structures. Program funds may not
be used for the acquisition,
construction, or rehabilitation of
structures to the extent that those
structures are used for explicitly
religious activities. Program funds may
PO 00000
Frm 00041
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45461
be used for the acquisition,
construction, or rehabilitation of
structures only to the extent that those
structures are used for conducting
eligible activities under this part. When
a structure is used for both eligible and
explicitly religious activities, program
funds may not exceed the cost of those
portions of the acquisition, new
construction, or rehabilitation that are
attributable to eligible activities in
accordance with the cost accounting
requirements applicable to the
Continuum of Care program.
Sanctuaries, chapels, or other rooms
that a Continuum of Care programfunded religious congregation uses as its
principal place of worship, however, are
ineligible for Continuum of Care
program-funded improvements.
Disposition of real property after the
term of the grant, or any change in the
use of the property during the term of
the grant, is subject to governmentwide
regulations governing real property
disposition (see 24 CFR parts 84 and
85).
(6) Supplemental funds. If a State or
local government voluntarily
contributes its own funds to supplement
federally funded activities, the State or
local government has the option to
segregate the federal funds or
commingle them. However, if the funds
are commingled, this section applies to
all of the commingled funds.
(c) Restriction on combining funds. In
a single structure or housing unit, the
following types of assistance may not be
combined:
(1) Leasing and acquisition,
rehabilitation, or new construction;
(2) Tenant-based rental assistance and
acquisition, rehabilitation, or new
construction;
(3) Short- or medium-term rental
assistance and acquisition,
rehabilitation, or new construction;
(4) Rental assistance and leasing; or
(5) Rental assistance and operating.
(d) Program fees. Recipients and
subrecipients may not charge program
participants program fees.
§ 578.89 Limitation on use of grant funds
to serve persons defined as homeless
under other federal laws.
(a) Application requirement.
Applicants that intend to serve
unaccompanied youth and families with
children and youth defined as homeless
under other federal laws in paragraph
(3) of the homeless definition in § 576.2
must demonstrate in their application,
to HUD’s satisfaction, that the use of
grant funds to serve such persons is an
equal or greater priority than serving
persons defined as homeless under
paragraphs (1), (2), and (4) of the
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
45462
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
definition of homeless in § 576.2. To
demonstrate that it is of equal or greater
priority, applicants must show that it is
equally or more cost effective in meeting
the overall goals and objectives of the
plan submitted under section
427(b)(1)(B) of the Act, especially with
respect to children and unaccompanied
youth.
(b) Limit. No more than 10 percent of
the funds awarded to recipients within
a single Continuum of Care’s geographic
area may be used to serve such persons.
(c) Exception. The 10 percent
limitation does not apply to
Continuums in which the rate of
homelessness, as calculated in the most
recent point-in-time count, is less than
one-tenth of one percent of the total
population.
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
§ 578.91 Termination of assistance to
program participants.
(a) Termination of assistance. The
recipient or subrecipient may terminate
assistance to a program participant who
violates program requirements or
conditions of occupancy. Termination
under this section does not bar the
recipient or subrecipient from providing
further assistance at a later date to the
same individual or family.
(b) Due process. In terminating
assistance to a program participant, the
recipient or subrecipient must provide a
formal process that recognizes the rights
of individuals receiving assistance
under the due process of law. This
process, at a minimum, must consist of:
(1) Providing the program participant
with a written copy of the program rules
and the termination process before the
participant begins to receive assistance;
(2) Written notice to the program
participant containing a clear statement
of the reasons for termination;
(3) A review of the decision, in which
the program participant is given the
opportunity to present written or oral
objections before a person other than the
person (or a subordinate of that person)
who made or approved the termination
decision; and
(4) Prompt written notice of the final
decision to the program participant.
(c) Hard-to-house populations.
Recipients and subrecipients that are
providing permanent supportive
housing for hard-to-house populations
of homeless persons must exercise
judgment and examine all extenuating
circumstances in determining when
violations are serious enough to warrant
termination so that a program
participant’s assistance is terminated
only in the most severe cases.
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
§ 578.93 Fair Housing and Equal
Opportunity.
(a) Nondiscrimination and equal
opportunity requirements. The
nondiscrimination and equal
opportunity requirements set forth in 24
CFR 5.105(a) are applicable.
(b) Housing for specific
subpopulations. Recipients and
subrecipients may exclusively serve a
particular homeless subpopulation in
transitional or permanent housing if the
housing addresses a need identified by
the Continuum of Care for the
geographic area and meets one of the
following:
(1) The housing may be limited to one
sex where such housing consists of a
single structure with shared bedrooms
or bathing facilities such that the
considerations of personal privacy and
the physical limitations of the
configuration of the housing make it
appropriate for the housing to be limited
to one sex;
(2) The housing may be limited to a
specific subpopulation, so long as
admission does not discriminate against
any protected class under federal
nondiscrimination laws in 24 CFR 5.105
(e.g., the housing may be limited to
homeless veterans, victims of domestic
violence and their children, or
chronically homeless persons and
families).
(3) The housing may be limited to
families with children.
(4) If the housing has in residence at
least one family with a child under the
age of 18, the housing may exclude
registered sex offenders and persons
with a criminal record that includes a
violent crime from the project so long as
the child resides in the housing.
(5) Sober housing may exclude
persons who refuse to sign an
occupancy agreement or lease that
prohibits program participants from
possessing, using, or being under the
influence of illegal substances and/or
alcohol on the premises.
(6) If the housing is assisted with
funds under a federal program that is
limited by federal statute or Executive
Order to a specific subpopulation, the
housing may be limited to that
subpopulation (e.g., housing also
assisted with funding from the Housing
Opportunities for Persons with AIDS
program under 24 CFR part 574 may be
limited to persons with acquired
immunodeficiency syndrome or related
diseases).
(7) Recipients may limit admission to
or provide a preference for the housing
to subpopulations of homeless persons
and families who need the specialized
supportive services that are provided in
the housing (e.g., substance abuse
PO 00000
Frm 00042
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
addiction treatment, domestic violence
services, or a high intensity package
designed to meet the needs of hard-toreach homeless persons). While the
housing may offer services for a
particular type of disability, no
otherwise eligible individuals with
disabilities or families including an
individual with a disability, who may
benefit from the services provided may
be excluded on the grounds that they do
not have a particular disability.
(c) Affirmatively furthering fair
housing. A recipient must implement its
programs in a manner that affirmatively
furthers fair housing, which means that
the recipient must:
(1) Affirmatively market their housing
and supportive services to eligible
persons regardless of race, color,
national origin, religion, sex, age,
familial status, or handicap who are
least likely to apply in the absence of
special outreach, and maintain records
of those marketing activities;
(2) Where a recipient encounters a
condition or action that impedes fair
housing choice for current or
prospective program participants,
provide such information to the
jurisdiction that provided the
certification of consistency with the
Consolidated Plan; and
(3) Provide program participants with
information on rights and remedies
available under applicable federal, State
and local fair housing and civil rights
laws.
(d) Accessibility and integrative
housing and services for persons with
disabilities. Recipients and
subrecipients must comply with the
accessibility requirements of the Fair
Housing Act (24 CFR part 100), Section
504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (24
CFR part 8), and Titles II and III of the
Americans with Disabilities Act, as
applicable (28 CFR parts 35 and 36). In
accordance with the requirements of 24
CFR 8.4(d), recipients must ensure that
their program’s housing and supportive
services are provided in the most
integrated setting appropriate to the
needs of persons with disabilities.
(e) Prohibition against involuntary
family separation. The age and gender
of a child under age 18 must not be used
as a basis for denying any family’s
admission to a project that receives
funds under this part.
§ 578.95
Conflicts of interest.
(a) Procurement. For the procurement
of property (goods, supplies, or
equipment) and services, the recipient
and its subrecipients must comply with
the codes of conduct and conflict-ofinterest requirements under 24 CFR
85.36 (for governments) and 24 CFR
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
84.42 (for private nonprofit
organizations).
(b) Continuum of Care board
members. No Continuum of Care board
member may participate in or influence
discussions or resulting decisions
concerning the award of a grant or other
financial benefits to the organization
that the member represents.
(c) Organizational conflict. An
organizational conflict of interest arises
when, because of activities or
relationships with other persons or
organizations, the recipient or
subrecipient is unable or potentially
unable to render impartial assistance in
the provision of any type or amount of
assistance under this part, or when a
covered person’s, as in paragraph (d)(1)
of this section, objectivity in performing
work with respect to any activity
assisted under this part is or might be
otherwise impaired. Such an
organizational conflict would arise
when a board member of an applicant
participates in decision of the applicant
concerning the award of a grant, or
provision of other financial benefits, to
the organization that such member
represents. It would also arise when an
employee of a recipient or subrecipient
participates in making rent
reasonableness determinations under
§ 578.49(b)(2) and § 578.51(g) and
housing quality inspections of property
under § 578.75(b) that the recipient,
subrecipient, or related entity owns.
(d) Other conflicts. For all other
transactions and activities, the following
restrictions apply:
(1) No covered person, meaning a
person who is an employee, agent,
consultant, officer, or elected or
appointed official of the recipient or its
subrecipients and who exercises or has
exercised any functions or
responsibilities with respect to activities
assisted under this part, or who is in a
position to participate in a decisionmaking process or gain inside
information with regard to activities
assisted under this part, may obtain a
financial interest or benefit from an
assisted activity, have a financial
interest in any contract, subcontract, or
agreement with respect to an assisted
activity, or have a financial interest in
the proceeds derived from an assisted
activity, either for him or herself or for
those with whom he or she has
immediate family or business ties,
during his or her tenure or during the
one-year period following his or her
tenure.
(2) Exceptions. Upon the written
request of the recipient, HUD may grant
an exception to the provisions of this
section on a case-by-case basis, taking
into account the cumulative effects of
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
the criteria in paragraph (d)(2)(ii) of this
section, provided that the recipient has
satisfactorily met the threshold
requirements of paragraph (d)(2)(ii) of
this section.
(i) Threshold requirements. HUD will
consider an exception only after the
recipient has provided the following
documentation:
(A) Disclosure of the nature of the
conflict, accompanied by a written
assurance, if the recipient is a
government, that there has been public
disclosure of the conflict and a
description of how the public disclosure
was made; and if the recipient is a
private nonprofit organization, that the
conflict has been disclosed in
accordance with their written code of
conduct or other conflict-of-interest
policy; and
(B) An opinion of the recipient’s
attorney that the interest for which the
exception is sought would not violate
State or local law, or if the subrecipient
is a private nonprofit organization, the
exception would not violate the
organization’s internal policies.
(ii) Factors to be considered for
exceptions. In determining whether to
grant a requested exception after the
recipient has satisfactorily met the
threshold requirements under paragraph
(c)(3)(i) of this section, HUD must
conclude that the exception will serve
to further the purposes of the
Continuum of Care program and the
effective and efficient administration of
the recipient’s or subrecipient’s project,
taking into account the cumulative
effect of the following factors, as
applicable:
(A) Whether the exception would
provide a significant cost benefit or an
essential degree of expertise to the
program or project that would otherwise
not be available;
(B) Whether an opportunity was
provided for open competitive bidding
or negotiation;
(C) Whether the affected person has
withdrawn from his or her functions,
responsibilities, or the decision-making
process with respect to the specific
activity in question;
(D) Whether the interest or benefit
was present before the affected person
was in the position described in
paragraph (c)(1) of this section;
(E) Whether undue hardship will
result to the recipient, the subrecipient,
or the person affected, when weighed
against the public interest served by
avoiding the prohibited conflict;
(F) Whether the person affected is a
member of a group or class of persons
intended to be the beneficiaries of the
assisted activity, and the exception will
permit such person to receive generally
PO 00000
Frm 00043
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45463
the same interests or benefits as are
being made available or provided to the
group or class; and
(G) Any other relevant considerations.
§ 578.97
Program income.
(a) Defined. Program income is the
income received by the recipient or
subrecipient directly generated by a
grant-supported activity.
(b) Use. Program income earned
during the grant term shall be retained
by the recipient, and added to funds
committed to the project by HUD and
the recipient, used for eligible activities
in accordance with the requirements of
this part. Costs incident to the
generation of program income may be
deducted from gross income to calculate
program income, provided that the costs
have not been charged to grant funds.
(c) Rent and occupancy charges.
Rents and occupancy charges collected
from program participants are program
income. In addition, rents and
occupancy charges collected from
residents of transitional housing may be
reserved, in whole or in part, to assist
the residents from whom they are
collected to move to permanent
housing.
§ 578.99 Applicability of other federal
requirements.
In addition to the requirements set
forth in 24 CFR part 5, use of assistance
provided under this part must comply
with the following federal requirements:
(a) Environmental review. Activities
under this part are subject to
environmental review by HUD under 24
CFR part 50 as noted in § 578.31.
(b) Section 6002 of the Solid Waste
Disposal Act. State agencies and
agencies of a political subdivision of a
state that are using assistance under this
part for procurement, and any person
contracting with such an agency with
respect to work performed under an
assisted contract, must comply with the
requirements of Section 6003 of the
Solid Waste Disposal Act, as amended
by the Resource Conservation and
Recovery Act. In accordance with
Section 6002, these agencies and
persons must:
(1) Procure items designated in
guidelines of the Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) at 40 CFR part
247 that contain the highest percentage
of recovered materials practicable,
consistent with maintaining a
satisfactory level of competition, where
the purchase price of the item exceeds
$10,000 or the value of the quantity
acquired in the preceding fiscal year
exceeded $10,000;
(2) Procure solid waste management
services in a manner that maximizes
energy and resource recovery; and
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
45464
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
(3) Must have established an
affirmative procurement program for the
procurement of recovered materials
identified in the EPA guidelines.
(c) Transparency Act Reporting.
Section 872 of the Duncan Hunter
Defense Appropriations Act of 2009,
and additional requirements published
by the Office of Management and
Budget (OMB), requires recipients to
report subawards made either as passthrough awards, subrecipient awards, or
vendor awards in the Federal
Government Web site www.fsrs.gov or
its successor system. The reporting of
award and subaward information is in
accordance with the requirements of the
Federal Financial Assistance
Accountability and Transparency Act of
2006, as amended by section 6202 of
Public Law 110–252 and in OMB Policy
Guidance issued to the federal agencies
on September 14, 2010 (75 FR 55669).
(d) The Coastal Barrier Resources Act
of 1982 (16 U.S.C. 3501 et seq.) may
apply to proposals under this part,
depending on the assistance requested.
(e) Applicability of OMB Circulars.
The requirements of 24 CFR part 85—
Administrative Requirements for Grants
and Cooperative Agreements to State,
Local, and Federally Recognized Indian
Tribal Governments and 2 CFR part
225—Cost Principles for State, Local
and Indian Tribal Governments (OMB
Circular A–87)—apply to governmental
recipients and subrecipients except
where inconsistent with the provisions
of this part. The requirements of 24 CFR
part 84—Uniform Administrative
Requirements for Grants and
Agreements with Institutions of Higher
Education, Hospitals, and Other NonProfit Organizations; 2 CFR part 230—
Cost Principles for Non-Profit
Organizations (OMB Circular A–122);
and 2 CFR part 220—Cost Principles for
Education Institutions apply to the
nonprofit recipients and subrecipients,
except where inconsistent with the
provisions of the McKinney-Vento Act
or this part.
(f) Lead-based paint. The Lead-Based
Paint Poisoning Prevention Act (42
U.S.C. 4821–4846), the Residential
Lead-Based Paint Hazard Reduction Act
of 1992 (42 U.S.C. 4851–4856), and
implementing regulations at 24 CFR part
35, subparts A, B, H, J, K, M, and R
apply to activities under this program.
(g) Audit. Recipients and
subrecipients must comply with the
audit requirements of OMB Circular A–
133, ‘‘Audits of States, Local
Governments, and Non-profit
Organizations.’’
(h) Davis-Bacon Act. The provisions
of the Davis-Bacon Act do not apply to
this program.
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
(i) Section 3 of the Housing and
Urban Development Act. Recipients and
subrecipients must, as applicable,
comply with Section 3 of the Housing
and Urban Development Act of 1968
and its implementing regulations at 24
CFR part 135, as applicable.
Subpart G—Grant Administration
§ 578.101
Technical assistance.
(a) Purpose. The purpose of
Continuum of Care technical assistance
is to increase the effectiveness with
which Continuums of Care, eligible
applicants, recipients, subrecipients,
and UFAs implement and administer
their Continuum of Care planning
process; improve their capacity to
prepare applications; prevent the
separation of families in projects funded
under the Emergency Solutions Grants,
Continuum of Care, and Rural Housing
Stability Assistance programs; and
adopt and provide best practices in
housing and services for persons
experiencing homelessness.
(b) Defined. Technical assistance
means the transfer of skills and
knowledge to entities that may need, but
do not possess, such skills and
knowledge. The assistance may include,
but is not limited to, written
information such as papers, manuals,
guides, and brochures; person-to-person
exchanges; web-based curriculums,
training and Webinars, and their costs.
(c) Set-aside. HUD may set aside
funds annually to provide technical
assistance, either directly by HUD staff
or indirectly through third-party
providers.
(d) Awards. From time to time, as
HUD determines the need, HUD may
advertise and competitively select
providers to deliver technical
assistance. HUD may enter into
contracts, grants, or cooperative
agreements, when necessary, to
implement the technical assistance.
HUD may also enter into agreements
with other federal agencies for awarding
the technical assistance funds.
§ 578.103
Recordkeeping requirements.
(a) In general. The recipient and its
subrecipients must establish and
maintain standard operating procedures
for ensuring that Continuum of Care
program funds are used in accordance
with the requirements of this part and
must establish and maintain sufficient
records to enable HUD to determine
whether the recipient and its
subrecipients are meeting the
requirements of this part, including:
(1) Continuum of Care records. Each
collaborative applicant must keep the
following documentation related to
PO 00000
Frm 00044
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
establishing and operating a Continuum
of Care:
(i) Evidence that the Board selected by
the Continuum of Care meets the
requirements of § 578.5(b);
(ii) Evidence that the Continuum has
been established and operated as set
forth in subpart B of this part, including
published agendas and meeting
minutes, an approved Governance
Charter that is reviewed and updated
annually, a written process for selecting
a board that is reviewed and updated at
least once every 5 years, evidence
required for designating a single HMIS
for the Continuum, and monitoring
reports of recipients and subrecipients;
(iii) Evidence that the Continuum has
prepared the application for funds as set
forth in § 578.9, including the
designation of the eligible applicant to
be the collaborative applicant.
(2) Unified funding agency records.
UFAs that requested grant amendments
from HUD, as set forth in § 578.105,
must keep evidence that the grant
amendment was approved by the
Continuum. This evidence may include
minutes of meetings at which the grant
amendment was discussed and
approved.
(3) Homeless status. Acceptable
evidence of the homeless as status is set
forth in 24 CFR 576.500(b).
(4) At risk of homelessness status. For
those recipients and subrecipients that
serve persons at risk of homelessness,
the recipient or subrecipient must keep
records that establish ‘‘at risk of
homelessness’’ status of each individual
or family who receives Continuum of
Care homelessness prevention
assistance. Acceptable evidence is
found in 24 CFR 576.500(c).
(5) Records of reasonable belief of
imminent threat of harm. For each
program participant who moved to a
different Continuum of Care due to
imminent threat of further domestic
violence, dating violence, sexual
assault, or stalking under § 578.51(c)(3),
each recipient or subrecipient of
assistance under this part must retain:
(i) Documentation of the original
incidence of domestic violence, dating
violence, sexual assault, or stalking,
only if the original violence is not
already documented in the program
participant’s case file. This may be
written observation of the housing or
service provider; a letter or other
documentation from a victim service
provider, social worker, legal assistance
provider, pastoral counselor, mental
health provider, or other professional
from whom the victim has sought
assistance; medical or dental records;
court records or law enforcement
records; or written certification by the
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
program participant to whom the
violence occurred or by the head of
household.
(ii) Documentation of the reasonable
belief of imminent threat of further
domestic violence, dating violence, or
sexual assault or stalking, which would
include threats from a third-party, such
as a friend or family member of the
perpetrator of the violence. This may be
written observation by the housing or
service provider; a letter or other
documentation from a victim service
provider, social worker, legal assistance
provider, pastoral counselor, mental
health provider, or other professional
from whom the victim has sought
assistance; current restraining order;
recent court order or other court
records; law enforcement report or
records; communication records from
the perpetrator of the violence or family
members or friends of the perpetrator of
the violence, including emails,
voicemails, text messages, and social
media posts; or a written certification by
the program participant to whom the
violence occurred or the head of
household.
(6) Annual income. For each program
participant who receives housing
assistance where rent or an occupancy
charge is paid by the program
participant, the recipient or subrecipient
must keep the following documentation
of annual income:
(i) Income evaluation form specified
by HUD and completed by the recipient
or subrecipient; and
(ii) Source documents (e.g., most
recent wage statement, unemployment
compensation statement, public benefits
statement, bank statement) for the assets
held by the program participant and
income received before the date of the
evaluation;
(iii) To the extent that source
documents are unobtainable, a written
statement by the relevant third party
(e.g., employer, government benefits
administrator) or the written
certification by the recipient’s or
subrecipient’s intake staff of the oral
verification by the relevant third party
of the income the program participant
received over the most recent period; or
(iv) To the extent that source
documents and third-party verification
are unobtainable, the written
certification by the program participant
of the amount of income that the
program participant is reasonably
expected to receive over the 3-month
period following the evaluation.
(7) Program participant records. In
addition to evidence of ‘‘homeless’’
status or ‘‘at-risk-of-homelessness’’
status, as applicable, the recipient or
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
subrecipient must keep records for each
program participant that document:
(i) The services and assistance
provided to that program participant,
including evidence that the recipient or
subrecipient has conducted an annual
assessment of services for those program
participants that remain in the program
for more than a year and adjusted the
service package accordingly, and
including case management services as
provided in § 578.37(a)(1)(ii)(F); and
(ii) Where applicable, compliance
with the termination of assistance
requirement in § 578.91.
(8) Housing standards. The recipient
or subrecipient must retain
documentation of compliance with the
housing standards in § 578.75(b),
including inspection reports.
(9) Services provided. The recipient or
subrecipient must document the types
of supportive services provided under
the recipient’s program and the amounts
spent on those services. The recipient or
subrecipient must keep record that these
records were reviewed at least annually
and that the service package offered to
program participants was adjusted as
necessary.
(10) Match. The recipient must keep
records of the source and use of
contributions made to satisfy the match
requirement in § 578.73. The records
must indicate the grant and fiscal year
for which each matching contribution is
counted. The records must show how
the value placed on third party in-kind
contributions was derived. To the extent
feasible, volunteer services must be
supported by the same methods that the
organization uses to support the
allocation of regular personnel costs.
(11) Conflicts of interest. The
recipient and its subrecipients must
keep records to show compliance with
the organizational conflict-of-interest
requirements in § 578.95(c), the
Continuum of Care board conflict-ofinterest requirements in § 578.95(b), the
other conflict requirements in
§ 578.95(d), a copy of the personal
conflict-of-interest policy developed
and implemented to comply with the
requirements in § 578.95, and records
supporting exceptions to the personal
conflict-of-interest prohibitions.
(12) Homeless participation. The
recipient or subrecipient must
document its compliance with the
homeless participation requirements
under § 578.75(g).
(13) Faith-based activities. The
recipient and its subrecipients must
document their compliance with the
faith-based activities requirements
under § 578.87(b).
(14) Affirmatively Furthering Fair
Housing. Recipients and subrecipients
PO 00000
Frm 00045
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
45465
must maintain copies of their marketing,
outreach, and other materials used to
inform eligible persons of the program
to document compliance with the
requirements in § 578.93(c).
(15) Other federal requirements. The
recipient and its subrecipients must
document their compliance with the
federal requirements in § 578.99, as
applicable.
(16) Subrecipients and contractors. (i)
The recipient must retain copies of all
solicitations of and agreements with
subrecipients, records of all payment
requests by and dates of payments made
to subrecipients, and documentation of
all monitoring and sanctions of
subrecipients, as applicable.
(ii) The recipient must retain
documentation of monitoring
subrecipients, including any monitoring
findings and corrective actions required.
(iii) The recipient and its
subrecipients must retain copies of all
procurement contracts and
documentation of compliance with the
procurement requirements in 24 CFR
85.36 and 24 CFR part 84.
(17) Other records specified by HUD.
The recipient and subrecipients must
keep other records specified by HUD.
(b) Confidentiality. In addition to
meeting the specific confidentiality and
security requirements for HMIS data,
the recipient and its subrecipients must
develop and implement written
procedures to ensure:
(1) All records containing protected
identifying information of any
individual or family who applies for
and/or receives Continuum of Care
assistance will be kept secure and
confidential;
(2) The address or location of any
family violence project assisted with
Continuum of Care funds will not be
made public, except with written
authorization of the person responsible
for the operation of the project; and
(3) The address or location of any
housing of a program participant will
not be made public, except as provided
under a preexisting privacy policy of the
recipient or subrecipient and consistent
with State and local laws regarding
privacy and obligations of
confidentiality;
(c) Period of record retention. All
records pertaining to Continuum of Care
funds must be retained for the greater of
5 years or the period specified below.
Copies made by microfilming,
photocopying, or similar methods may
be substituted for the original records.
(1) Documentation of each program
participant’s qualification as a family or
individual at risk of homelessness or as
a homeless family or individual and
other program participant records must
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
45466
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
be retained for 5 years after the
expenditure of all funds from the grant
under which the program participant
was served; and
(2) Where Continuum of Care funds
are used for the acquisition, new
construction, or rehabilitation of a
project site, records must be retained
until 15 years after the date that the
project site is first occupied, or used, by
program participants.
(d) Access to records. (1) Federal
Government rights. Notwithstanding the
confidentiality procedures established
under paragraph (b) of this section,
HUD, the HUD Office of the Inspector
General, and the Comptroller General of
the United States, or any of their
authorized representatives, must have
the right of access to all books,
documents, papers, or other records of
the recipient and its subrecipients that
are pertinent to the Continuum of Care
grant, in order to make audits,
examinations, excerpts, and transcripts.
These rights of access are not limited to
the required retention period, but last as
long as the records are retained.
(2) Public rights. The recipient must
provide citizens, public agencies, and
other interested parties with reasonable
access to records regarding any uses of
Continuum of Care funds the recipient
received during the preceding 5 years,
consistent with State and local laws
regarding privacy and obligations of
confidentiality and confidentiality
requirements in this part.
(e) Reports. In addition to the
reporting requirements in 24 CFR parts
84 and 85, the recipient must collect
and report data on its use of Continuum
of Care funds in an Annual Performance
Report (APR), as well as in any
additional reports as and when required
by HUD. Projects receiving grant funds
only for acquisition, rehabilitation, or
new construction must submit APRs for
15 years from the date of initial
occupancy or the date of initial service
provision, unless HUD provides an
exception under § 578.81(e).
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
§ 578.105
Grant and project changes.
(a) For Unified Funding Agencies and
Continuums having only one recipient.
(1) The recipient may not make any
significant changes without prior HUD
approval, evidenced by a grant
amendment signed by HUD and the
recipient. Significant grant changes
include a change of recipient, a shift in
a single year of more than 10 percent of
the total amount awarded under the
grant for one approved eligible activity
category to another activity and a
permanent change in the subpopulation
served by any one project funded under
the grant, as well as a permanent
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
proposed reduction in the total number
of units funded under the grant.
(2) Approval of substitution of the
recipient is contingent on the new
recipient meeting the capacity criteria in
the NOFA under which the grant was
awarded, or the most recent NOFA.
Approval of shifting funds between
activities and changing subpopulations
is contingent on the change being
necessary to better serve eligible persons
within the geographic area and ensuring
that the priorities established under the
NOFA in which the grant was originally
awarded, or the most recent NOFA, are
met.
(b) For Continuums having more than
one recipient. (1) The recipients or
subrecipients may not make any
significant changes to a project without
prior HUD approval, evidenced by a
grant amendment signed by HUD and
the recipient. Significant changes
include a change of recipient, a change
of project site, additions or deletions in
the types of eligible activities approved
for a project, a shift of more than 10
percent from one approved eligible
activity to another, a reduction in the
number of units, and a change in the
subpopulation served.
(2) Approval of substitution of the
recipient is contingent on the new
recipient meeting the capacity criteria in
the NOFA under which the grant was
awarded, or the most recent NOFA.
Approval of shifting funds between
activities and changing subpopulations
is contingent on the change being
necessary to better serve eligible persons
within the geographic area and ensuring
that the priorities established under the
NOFA in which the grant was originally
awarded, or the most recent NOFA, are
met.
(c) Documentation of changes not
requiring a grant amendment. Any other
changes to an approved grant or project
must be fully documented in the
recipient’s or subrecipient’s records.
§ 578.107
Sanctions.
(a) Performance reviews. (1) HUD will
review the performance of each
recipient in carrying out its
responsibilities under this part, with or
without prior notice to the recipient. In
conducting performance reviews, HUD
will rely primarily on information
obtained from the records and reports
from the recipient and subrecipients, as
well as information from on-site
monitoring, audit reports, and
information generated from HUD’s
financial and reporting systems (e.g.,
LOCCS and e-snaps) and HMIS. Where
applicable, HUD may also consider
relevant information pertaining to the
recipient’s performance gained from
PO 00000
Frm 00046
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
other sources, including citizen
comments, complaint determinations,
and litigation.
(2) If HUD determines preliminarily
that the recipient or one of its
subrecipients has not complied with a
program requirement, HUD will give the
recipient notice of this determination
and an opportunity to demonstrate,
within the time prescribed by HUD and
on the basis of substantial facts and data
that the recipient has complied with the
requirements. HUD may change the
method of payment to require the
recipient to submit documentation
before payment and obtain HUD’s prior
approval each time the recipient draws
down funds. To obtain prior approval,
the recipient may be required to
manually submit its payment requests
and supporting documentation to HUD
in order to show that the funds to be
drawn down will be expended on
eligible activities in accordance with all
program requirements.
(3) If the recipient fails to demonstrate
to HUD’s satisfaction that the activities
were carried out in compliance with
program requirements, HUD may take
one or more of the remedial actions or
sanctions specified in paragraph (b) of
this section.
(b) Remedial actions and sanctions.
Remedial actions and sanctions for a
failure to meet a program requirement
will be designed to prevent a
continuation of the deficiency; to
mitigate, to the extent possible, its
adverse effects or consequences; and to
prevent its recurrence.
(1) HUD may instruct the recipient to
submit and comply with proposals for
action to correct, mitigate, and prevent
noncompliance with program
requirements, including:
(i) Preparing and following a schedule
of actions for carrying out activities and
projects affected by the noncompliance,
including schedules, timetables, and
milestones necessary to implement the
affected activities and projects;
(ii) Establishing and following a
management plan that assigns
responsibilities for carrying out the
remedial actions;
(iii) Canceling or revising activities or
projects likely to be affected by the
noncompliance, before expending grant
funds for them;
(iv) Reprogramming grant funds that
have not yet been expended from
affected activities or projects to other
eligible activities or projects;
(v) Suspending disbursement of grant
funds for some or all activities or
projects;
(vi) Reducing or terminating the
remaining grant of a subrecipient and
either reallocating those funds to other
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
Federal Register / Vol. 77, No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules and Regulations
emcdonald on DSK67QTVN1PROD with RULES2
subrecipients or returning funds to
HUD; and
(vii) Making matching contributions
before or as draws are made from the
recipient’s grant.
(2) HUD may change the method of
payment to a reimbursement basis.
(3) HUD may suspend payments to
the extent HUD determines necessary to
preclude the further expenditure of
funds for affected activities or projects.
(4) HUD may continue the grant with
a substitute recipient of HUD’s
choosing.
(5) HUD may deny matching credit for
all or part of the cost of the affected
activities and require the recipient to
make further matching contributions to
make up for the contribution
determined to be ineligible.
(6) HUD may require the recipient to
reimburse the recipient’s line of credit
in an amount equal to the funds used for
the affected activities.
(7) HUD may reduce or terminate the
remaining grant of a recipient.
(8) HUD may condition a future grant.
(9) HUD may take other remedies that
are legally available.
(c) Recipient sanctions. If the
recipient determines that a subrecipient
is not complying with a program
requirement or its subrecipient
agreement, the recipient must take one
of the actions listed in paragraphs (a)
and (b) of this section.
(d) Deobligation. HUD may deobligate
funds for the following reasons:
(1) If the timeliness standards in
§ 578.85 are not met;
(2) If HUD determines that delays
completing construction activities for a
project will mean that the funds for
VerDate Mar<15>2010
15:25 Jul 30, 2012
Jkt 226001
other funded activities cannot
reasonably be expected to be expended
for eligible costs during the remaining
term of the grant;
(3) If the actual total cost of
acquisition, rehabilitation, or new
construction for a project is less than the
total cost agreed to in the grant
agreement;
(4) If the actual annual leasing costs,
operating costs, supportive services
costs, rental assistance costs, or HMIS
costs are less than the total cost agreed
to in the grant agreement for a one-year
period;
(5) Program participants have not
moved into units within 3 months of the
time that the units are available for
occupancy; and
(6) The grant agreement may set forth
in detail other circumstances under
which funds may be deobligated and
other sanctions may be imposed.
§ 578.109
Closeout.
(a) In general. Grants will be closed
out in accordance with the requirements
of 24 CFR parts 84 and 85, and closeout
procedures established by HUD.
(b) Reports. Applicants must submit
all reports required by HUD no later
than 90 days from the date of the end
of the project’s grant term.
(c) Closeout agreement. Any
obligations remaining as of the date of
the closeout must be covered by the
terms of a closeout agreement. The
agreement will be prepared by HUD in
consultation with the recipient. The
agreement must identify the grant being
closed out, and include provisions with
respect to the following:
PO 00000
Frm 00047
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 9990
45467
(1) Identification of any closeout costs
or contingent liabilities subject to
payment with Continuum of Care
program funds after the closeout
agreement is signed;
(2) Identification of any unused grant
funds to be deobligated by HUD;
(3) Identification of any program
income on deposit in financial
institutions at the time the closeout
agreement is signed;
(4) Description of the recipient’s
responsibility after closeout for:
(i) Compliance with all program
requirements in using program income
on deposit at the time the closeout
agreement is signed and in using any
other remaining Continuum of Care
program funds available for closeout
costs and contingent liabilities;
(ii) Use of real property assisted with
Continuum of Care program funds in
accordance with the terms of
commitment and principles;
(iii) Use of personal property
purchased with Continuum of Care
program funds; and
(iv) Compliance with requirements
governing program income received
subsequent to grant closeout.
(5) Other provisions appropriate to
any special circumstances of the grant
closeout, in modification of or in
addition to the obligations in paragraphs
(c)(1) through (4) of this section.
Dated: June 28, 2012.
Mark Johnston,
Assistant Secretary for Community Planning
and Development (Acting).
[FR Doc. 2012–17546 Filed 7–30–12; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4210–67–P
E:\FR\FM\31JYR2.SGM
31JYR2
Agencies
[Federal Register Volume 77, Number 147 (Tuesday, July 31, 2012)]
[Rules and Regulations]
[Pages 45421-45467]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Printing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2012-17546]
[[Page 45421]]
Vol. 77
Tuesday,
No. 147
July 31, 2012
Part II
Department of Housing and Urban Development
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
24 CFR Part 578
Homeless Emergency Assistance and Rapid Transition to Housing:
Continuum of Care Program; Interim Final Rule
Federal Register / Vol. 77 , No. 147 / Tuesday, July 31, 2012 / Rules
and Regulations
[[Page 45422]]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT
24 CFR Part 578
[Docket No. FR-5476-I-01]
RIN 2506-AC29
Homeless Emergency Assistance and Rapid Transition to Housing:
Continuum of Care Program
AGENCY: Office of the Assistant Secretary for Community Planning and
Development, HUD.
ACTION: Interim rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: The Homeless Emergency Assistance and Rapid Transition to
Housing Act of 2009 (HEARTH Act), enacted into law on May 20, 2009,
consolidates three of the separate homeless assistance programs
administered by HUD under the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act
into a single grant program, and revises the Emergency Shelter Grants
program and renames it the Emergency Solutions Grants program. The
HEARTH Act also codifies in law the Continuum of Care planning process,
a longstanding part of HUD's application process to assist homeless
persons by providing greater coordination in responding to their needs.
The HEARTH Act also directs HUD to promulgate regulations for these new
programs and processes.
This interim rule focuses on regulatory implementation of the
Continuum of Care program, including the Continuum of Care planning
process. The existing homeless assistance programs that comprise the
Continuum of Care program are the following: the Supportive Housing
program, the Shelter Plus Care program, and the Moderate
Rehabilitation/Single Room Occupancy (SRO) program. This rule
establishes the regulations for the Continuum of Care program, and,
through the establishment of such regulations, the funding made
available for the Continuum of Care program in the statute
appropriating Fiscal Year (FY) 2012 funding for HUD can more quickly be
disbursed, consistent with the HEARTH Act requirements, and avoid any
disruption in current Continuum of Care activities.
DATES: Effective Date: August 30, 2012.
Comment Due Date. October 1, 2012.
ADDRESSES: Interested persons are invited to submit comments regarding
this rule to the Regulations Division, Office of General Counsel, 451
7th Street SW., Room 10276, Department of Housing and Urban
Development, Washington, DC 20410-0500. Communications must refer to
the above docket number and title. There are two methods for submitting
public comments. All submissions must refer to the above docket number
and title.
1. Submission of Comments by Mail. Comments may be submitted by
mail to the Regulations Division, Office of General Counsel, Department
of Housing and Urban Development, 451 7th Street SW., Room 10276,
Washington, DC 20410-0500.
2. Electronic Submission of Comments. Interested persons may submit
comments electronically through the Federal eRulemaking Portal at
www.regulations.gov. HUD strongly encourages commenters to submit
comments electronically. Electronic submission of comments allows the
commenter maximum time to prepare and submit a comment, ensures timely
receipt by HUD, and enables HUD to make them immediately available to
the public. Comments submitted electronically through the
www.regulations.gov Web site can be viewed by other commenters and
interested members of the public. Commenters should follow the
instructions provided on that site to submit comments electronically.
Note: To receive consideration as public comments, comments must
be submitted through one of the two methods specified above. Again,
all submissions must refer to the docket number and title of the
rule.
No Facsimile Comments. Facsimile (FAX) comments are not acceptable.
Public Inspection of Public Comments. All properly submitted
comments and communications submitted to HUD will be available for
public inspection and copying between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. weekdays at the
above address. Due to security measures at the HUD Headquarters
building, an advance appointment to review the public comments must be
scheduled by calling the Regulations Division at 202-708-3055 (this is
not a toll-free number). Individuals with speech or hearing impairments
may access this number through TTY by calling the Federal Relay Service
at 800-877-8339. Copies of all comments submitted are available for
inspection and downloading at www.regulations.gov.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Ann Marie Oliva, Director, Office of
Special Needs Assistance Programs, Office of Community Planning and
Development, Department of Housing and Urban Development, 451 7th
Street SW., Washington, DC 20410-7000; telephone number 202-708-4300
(this is not a toll-free number). Hearing- and speech-impaired persons
may access this number through TTY by calling the Federal Relay Service
at 800-877-8339 (this is a toll-free number).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Executive Summary
Purpose of and Legal Authority for This Interim Rule
This interim rule implements the Continuum of Care program
authorized by the Homeless Emergency Assistance and Rapid Transition to
Housing Act of 2009 (HEARTH Act). Section 1504 of the HEARTH Act
directs HUD to establish regulations for this program. (See 42 U.S.C.
11301.) The purpose of the Continuum of Care program is to promote
communitywide commitment to the goal of ending homelessness; provide
funding for efforts by nonprofit providers, and State and local
governments to quickly rehouse homeless individuals and families while
minimizing the trauma and dislocation caused to homeless individuals,
families, and communities by homelessness; promote access to and
effective utilization of mainstream programs by homeless individuals
and families; and optimize self-sufficiency among individuals and
families experiencing homelessness.
The HEARTH Act streamlines HUD's homeless grant programs by
consolidating the Supportive Housing, Shelter Plus Care, and Single
Room Occupancy grant programs into one grant program: The Continuum of
Care program. Local continuums of care, which are community-based
homeless assistance program planning networks, will apply for Continuum
of Care grants. By consolidating homeless assistance grant programs and
creating the Continuum of Care planning process, the HEARTH Act
intended to increase the efficiency and effectiveness of coordinated,
community-based systems that provide housing and services to the
homeless. Through this interim final rule, HUD will implement the
Continuum of Care program by establishing the framework for
establishing a local continuum of care and the process for applying for
Continuum of Care grants.
Summary of Major Provisions
The major provisions of this rulemaking relate to how to establish
and operate a Continuum of Care, how to apply for funds under the
program, and how to use the funds for projects approved by HUD. These
provisions are summarized below.
1. General Provisions (Subpart A): The Continuum of Care program
includes transitional housing, permanent supportive housing for
[[Page 45423]]
disabled persons, permanent housing, supportive services, and Homeless
Management Information Systems (HMIS). To implement the program, HUD
had to define several key terms. In particular, HUD distinguishes
between ``Continuum of Care,'' ``applicant,'' and ``collaborative
applicant.'' A ``Continuum of Care'' is a geographically based group of
representatives that carries out the planning responsibilities of the
Continuum of Care program, as set out in this regulation. These
representatives come from organizations that provide services to the
homeless, or represent the interests of the homeless or formerly
homeless. A Continuum of Care then designates certain ``applicants'' as
the entities responsible for carrying out the projects that the
Continuum has identified through its planning responsibilities. A
``Continuum of Care'' also designates one particular applicant to be a
``collaborative applicant.'' The collaborative applicant is the only
entity that can apply for a grant from HUD on behalf of the Continuum
that the collaborative applicant represents.
2. Establishing and Operating a Continuum of Care (Subpart B): In
order to be eligible for funds under the Continuum of Care program,
representatives from relevant organizations within a geographic area
must establish a Continuum of Care. The three major duties of a
Continuum of Care are to: (1) Operate the Continuum of Care, (2)
designate an HMIS for the Continuum of Care, and (3) plan for the
Continuum of Care. HUD has delineated certain operational requirements
of each Continuum to help measure a Continuum's overall performance at
reducing homelessness, in addition to tracking of performance on a
project-by-project basis. In addition, each Continuum is responsible
for establishing and operating a centralized or coordinated assessment
system that will provide a comprehensive assessment of the needs of
individuals and families for housing and services. HUD has also defined
the minimum planning requirements for a Continuum so that it
coordinates and implements a system that meets the needs of the
homeless population within its geographic area. Continuums are also
responsible for preparing and overseeing an application for funds.
Continuums will have to establish the funding priorities for its
geographic area when submitting an application.
3. Application and Grant Award Process (Subpart C): The Continuum
of Care grant award process begins with a determination of a
Continuum's maximum award amount. As directed by statute, HUD has
developed a formula for determining award amounts that includes the
following factors: A Continuum's Preliminary Pro Rata Need (PPRN)
amount; renewal demand; any additional increases in amounts for
leasing, rental assistance, and operating costs based on Fair Market
Rents, planning and Unified Funding Agency cost funds, and amounts
available for bonus dollars. HUD has established selection criteria for
determining which applications will receive funding under the Continuum
of Care program. Recipients awarded Continuum of Care funds must
satisfy several conditions prior to executing their grant agreements.
All grants submitted for renewal must also submit an annual performance
report. For those applicants not awarded funding, the process also
provides an appeals process.
4. Program Components and Eligible Costs (Subpart D): Continuum of
Care funds may be used for projects under five program components:
Permanent housing, transitional housing, supportive services only,
HMIS, and, in some limited cases, homelessness prevention. The rule
further clarifies how the following activities are considered eligible
costs under the Continuum of Care program: Continuum of Care planning
activities, Unified Funding Agency costs, acquisition, rehabilitation,
new construction, leasing, rental assistance, supportive services,
operating costs, HMIS, project administrative costs, relocation costs,
and indirect costs.
5. High-Performing Communities (Subpart E): HUD will annually,
subject to the availability of appropriate data, select those
Continuums of Care that best meet application requirements to be
designated a high-performing community (HPC). An HPC may use grant
funds to provide housing relocation and stabilization services, and
short- and/or medium-term rental assistance to individuals and families
at risk of homelessness. This is the only time that Continuum of Care
funds may be used to serve individuals and families at risk of
homelessness.
6. Program Requirements (Subpart F): All recipients of Continuum of
Care funding must comply with the program regulations and the
requirements of the Notice of Funding Availability that HUD will issue
each year. Notably, the HEARTH Act requires that all eligible funding
costs, except leasing, must be matched with no less than 25 percent
cash or in-kind match by the Continuum. Other program requirements of
recipients include: Abiding by housing quality standards and suitable
dwelling size, assessing supportive services on an ongoing basis,
initiating and completing approved activities and projects within
certain timelines, and providing a formal process for termination of
assistance to participants who violate program requirements or
conditions of occupancy.
7. Grant Administration (Subpart G): To effectively administer the
grants, HUD will provide technical assistance to those who apply for
Continuum of Care funds, as well as those who are selected for
Continuum of Care funds. After having been selected for funding, grant
recipients must satisfy certain recordkeeping requirements so that HUD
can assess compliance with the program requirements. For any amendments
to grants after the funds have been awarded, HUD has established a
separate amendment procedure. As appropriate, HUD has also established
sanctions to strengthen its enforcement procedures.
Benefits and Costs
This interim rule is intended to help respond to and work toward
the goal of eliminating homelessness. This interim rule provides
greater clarity and guidance about planning and performance review to
the more than 430 existing Continuums of Care that span all 50 states
and 6 United States territories. As reported in HUD's Annual
Homelessness Assessment Report to Congress, there were approximately
1.59 million homeless persons who entered emergency shelters or
transitional housing in FY 2010. HUD serves roughly half that many
persons, nearly 800,000 annually, through its three programs that will
be consolidated into the Continuum of Care program under the McKinney-
Vento Act as amended by the HEARTH Act (i.e., Shelter Plus Care,
Supportive Housing Program, Single Room Occupancy). The changes
initiated by this interim rule will encourage Continuums of Care to
establish formal policies and review procedures, including evaluation
of the effectiveness of their projects, by emphasizing performance
measurement and developing performance targets for homeless
populations. HUD is confident that this systematic review by Continuums
of Care will lead to better use of limited resources and more efficient
service models, with the end result of preventing and ending
homelessness.
The Consolidated and Further Continuing Appropriations Act, 2012
(Pub. L. 112-55) appropriated $1,593,000,000 for the Continuum of Care
and Rural Housing Stability
[[Page 45424]]
Assistance programs. Upon publication of this rule, those FY 2012 funds
will be available for distribution, as governed by these Continuum of
Care regulations.
I. Background--HEARTH Act
On May 20, 2009, the President signed into law ``An Act to Prevent
Mortgage Foreclosures and Enhance Mortgage Credit Availability,'' which
became Public Law 111-22. This law implements a variety of measures
directed toward keeping individuals and families from losing their
homes. Division B of this law is the HEARTH Act, which consolidates and
amends three separate homeless assistance programs carried out under
title IV of the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act (42 U.S.C. 11371
et seq.) (McKinney-Vento Act) into a single grant program that is
designed to improve administrative efficiency and enhance response
coordination and effectiveness in addressing the needs of homeless
persons. The HEARTH Act codifies in law and enhances the Continuum of
Care planning process, the coordinated response to addressing the needs
of the homeless, which was established administratively by HUD in 1995.
The single Continuum of Care program established by the HEARTH Act
consolidates the following programs: The Supportive Housing program,
the Shelter Plus Care program, and the Moderate Rehabilitation/Single
Room Occupancy program. The Emergency Shelter Grants program is renamed
the Emergency Solutions Grants program and is revised to broaden
existing emergency shelter and homelessness prevention activities and
to add short- and medium-term rental assistance and services to rapidly
rehouse homeless people. The HEARTH Act also creates the Rural Housing
Stability program to replace the Rural Homelessness Grant program.
HUD commenced the process to implement the HEARTH Act with
rulemaking that focused on the definition of ``homeless.'' HUD
published a proposed rule, entitled ``Defining Homeless'' on April 20,
2010 (75 FR 20541), which was followed by a final rule that was
published on December 5, 2011 (76 FR 75994). The Defining Homeless rule
clarified and elaborated upon the new McKinney-Vento Act definitions
for ``homeless'' and ``homeless individual with a disability.'' In
addition, the Defining Homeless rule included recordkeeping
requirements related to the ``homeless'' definition. On December 5,
2011, HUD also published an interim rule for the Emergency Solutions
Grants program (76 FR 75954). This interim rule established the program
requirements for the Emergency Solutions Grants program and contained
corresponding amendments to the Consolidated Plan regulations. On
December 9, 2011, HUD continued the process to implement the HEARTH
Act, with the publication of the proposed rule titled ``Homeless
Management Information Systems Requirements'' (76 FR 76917), which
provides for uniform technical requirements for Homeless Management
Information Systems (HMIS), for proper data collection and maintenance
of the database, and ensures the confidentiality of the information in
the database. Today's publication of the interim rule for the Continuum
of Care program continues HUD's implementation of the HEARTH Act.
This rule establishes the regulatory framework for the Continuum of
Care program and the Continuum of Care planning process, including
requirements applicable to the establishment of a Continuum of Care.
Prior to the amendment of the McKinney-Vento Act by the HEARTH Act,
HUD's competitively awarded homeless assistance grant funds were
awarded to organizations that participate in local homeless assistance
program planning networks referred to as a Continuum of Care, a system
administratively established by HUD in 1995. A Continuum of Care is
designed to address the critical problem of homelessness through a
coordinated community-based process of identifying needs and building a
system of housing and services to address those needs. The approach is
predicated on the understanding that homelessness is not caused merely
by a lack of shelter, but involves a variety of underlying, unmet
needs--physical, economic, and social.
The HEARTH Act not only codified in law the planning system known
as Continuum of Care, but consolidated the three existing competitive
homeless assistance grant programs (Supportive Housing, Shelter Plus
Care, and Single Room Occupancy) into the single grant program known as
the Continuum of Care program. The consolidation of the three existing
homeless assistance programs into the Continuum of Care grant program
and the codification in law of the Continuum of Care planning process
are intended to increase the efficiency and effectiveness of the
coordination of the provision of housing and services to address the
needs of the homeless. The regulations established by this rule are
directed to carrying out this congressional intent.
II. Overview of Interim Rule
As amended by the HEARTH Act, Subpart C of the McKinney-Vento
Homeless Assistance Act establishes the Continuum of Care program. The
purpose of the program is to promote communitywide commitment to the
goal of ending homelessness; provide funding for efforts by nonprofit
providers, and State and local governments to quickly rehouse homeless
individuals and families while minimizing the trauma and dislocation
caused to homeless individuals, families, and communities by
homelessness; promote access to and effective utilization of mainstream
programs by homeless individuals and families; and optimize self-
sufficiency among individuals and families experiencing homelessness.
This interim rule establishes the Continuum of Care as the planning
body responsible for meeting the goals of the Continuum of Care
program. Additionally, in order to meet the purpose of the HEARTH Act,
established in section 1002(b), and the goals of ``Opening Doors:
Federal Strategic Plan to Prevent and End Homelessness,'' the Continuum
of Care must be involved in the coordination of other funding streams
and resources--federal, local, or private--of targeted homeless
programs and other mainstream resources. In many communities, the
Continuum of Care is the coordinating body, while in other communities
it is a local Interagency Council on Homelessness (both would be
acceptable forms of coordination under this interim rule). As noted
earlier, HUD published on December 9, 2011, a proposed rule to
establish HMIS regulations in accordance with the HEARTH Act. However,
while the HEARTH Act directed that regulations be established for HMIS,
HMIS is not new to many HUD grantees. Until regulations for HMIS are
promulgated in final, grantees should continue to follow HUD's existing
HMIS instructions and guidance.
The following provides an overview of the proposed rule.
General Provisions (Subpart A)
Purpose and scope. The Continuum of Care program is designed to
promote community-wide goals to end homelessness; provide funding to
quickly rehouse homeless individuals (including unaccompanied youth)
and families while minimizing trauma and dislocation to those persons;
promote access to, and effective utilization of, mainstream programs;
and optimize self-sufficiency among individuals and
[[Page 45425]]
families experiencing homelessness. The program is composed of
transitional housing, permanent supportive housing for disabled
persons, permanent housing, supportive services, and HMIS.
Definitions. The interim rule adopts the definitions of
``developmental disability,'' ``homeless,'' ``homeless individual,''
and ``homeless person'' established by the December 5, 2011 Defining
Homeless final rule. Public comments have already been solicited and
additional public comment is not solicited through this rule. The
December 5, 2011, final rule was preceded by an April 20, 2010,
proposed rule, which sought public comment on these definitions. The
final definitions of these terms took into consideration the public
comments received on the proposed definitions as set out in the April
20, 2010, proposed rule. This interim rule adopts the definition of
``at risk of homelessness'' established by the December 5, 2011, the
Emergency Solutions Grants program interim rule. The interim rule
sought public comment on this definition, and additional public comment
is not being sought through this rule.
HUD received valuable public comment on the definition of
``chronically homeless,'' through the public comment process on the
Emergency Solutions Grants program interim rule. Based on public
comment, this rule for the Continuum of Care program is not adopting
the full definition of ``chronically homeless'' that was included in
the conforming amendments to the Consolidated Plan that were published
as a part of the Emergency Solutions Grants program rule. Commenters
raised concerns with the meaning of the phrase ``where each homeless
occasion was at least 15 days.'' The concerns raised about this phrase,
used for the first time in a definition of ``chronically homeless,''
has caused HUD to reconsider proceeding to apply a definition that
includes this phrase, without further consideration and opportunity for
comment. In this rule, HUD therefore amends the definition of
``chronically homeless'' in the Consolidated Plan regulations to strike
this phrase. The removal of this phrase returns the definition to one
with which service providers are familiar. The following highlights key
definitions used in the Continuum of Care program regulations, and HUD
solicits comment on these definitions.
Applicant is defined to mean an entity that has been designated by
the Continuum of Care as eligible to apply for assistance on behalf of
that Continuum. HUD highlights that the Act does not contain different
definitions for ``applicant'' and ``collaborative applicant.'' HUD
distinguishes between the applicant(s) designated to apply for and
carry out projects (the ``applicant'') and the collaborative applicant
designated to apply for a grant on behalf of the Continuum of Care (the
``collaborative applicant''). Please see below for more information on
the definition of a collaborative applicant, which is the only entity
that may apply for and receive Continuum of Care planning funds.
Centralized or coordinated assessment system is defined to mean a
centralized or coordinated process designed to coordinate program
participant intake, assessment, and provision of referrals. A
centralized or coordinated assessment system covers the geographic
area, is easily accessed by individuals and families seeking housing or
services, is well advertised, and includes a comprehensive and
standardized assessment tool. This definition establishes basic minimum
requirements for the Continuum's centralized or coordinated assessment
system.
Collaborative applicant is defined to mean an eligible applicant
that has been designated by the Continuum of Care to apply for a grant
for Continuum of Care planning funds on behalf of the Continuum. As
discussed above, the ``applicant'' is the entity(ies) designated to
apply for and carry out projects on behalf of the Continuum. In
contrast to the definition of ``applicant'' above, the collaborative
applicant applies for a grant to carry out the planning activities on
behalf of the Continuum of Care. The interim rule simplifies the
statutory language in order to make the Continuum of Care planning
process clear.
HUD highlights that its definition of collaborative applicant does
not track the statutory definition, which is found in section 401 of
the McKinney-Vento Act. As will be discussed in further detail later in
this preamble, the concept of collaborative applicant, its duties and
functions, as provided in the statute, is provided for in this rule.
However, HUD uses the term Continuum of Care to refer to the
organizations that carry out the duties and responsibilities assigned
to the collaborative applicant, with the exception of applying to HUD
for grant funds. The clarification is necessary in this rule because
Continuums of Care are not required to be legal entities, but HUD can
enter into contractual agreements with legal entities only.
Continuum of Care and Continuum are defined to mean the group that
is organized to carry out the responsibilities required under this part
and that is composed of representatives of organizations including
nonprofit homeless providers, victim service providers, faith-based
organizations, governments, businesses, advocates, public housing
agencies, school districts, social service providers, mental health
agencies, hospitals, universities, affordable housing developers, law
enforcement, organizations that serve homeless and formerly homeless
veterans, and homeless and formerly homeless persons. These
organizations consist of the relevant parties in the geographic area.
Continuums are expected to include representation to the extent that
the type of organization exists within the geographic area that the
Continuum represents and is available to participate in the Continuum.
For example, if a Continuum of Care did not have a university within
its geographic boundaries, then HUD would not expect the Continuum to
have representation from a university within the Continuum.
These organizations carry out the responsibilities and duties
established under Subpart B of this interim rule. The Continuum of
Care, as noted above, carries out the statutory duties and
responsibilities of a collaborative applicant. HUD established the
Continuum of Care in 1995. Local grantees and stakeholders are familiar
with the Continuum of Care as the coordinating body for homeless
services and homelessness prevention activities across the geographic
area. Consequently, HUD is maintaining the Continuum of Care
terminology, and the rule provides for the duties and responsibilities
of a collaborative applicant to be carried out under the name Continuum
of Care.
High-performing community is defined to mean the geographic area
under the jurisdiction of a Continuum of Care that has been designated
as a high-performing community by HUD. Section 424 of the McKinney-
Vento Act provides that HUD shall designate, on an annual basis, which
collaborative applicants represent high-performing communities.
Consistent with HUD's substitution of the term ``Continuum of Care''
for ``collaborative applicant,'' the definition of ``high-performing
community'' in this interim rule provides for designation of Continuums
of Care that represent geographic areas designated as high-performing
communities. The standards for becoming a high-performing community can
be found in Sec. 578.65 of this interim
[[Page 45426]]
rule and will be discussed later in this preamble.
Private nonprofit organization is based on the statutory definition
for ``private nonprofit organization.'' The term ``private nonprofit
organization'' is defined in section 424 of the McKinney-Vento Act as
follows: ``The term `private nonprofit organization' means an
organization: `(A) No part of the net earnings of which inures to the
benefit of any member, founder, contributor, or individual; (B) that
has a voluntary board; (C) that has an accounting system, or has
designated a fiscal agent in accordance with requirements established
by the Secretary; and (D) that practices nondiscrimination in the
provision of assistance.' '' In HUD's regulatory definition of
``private nonprofit organization,'' HUD clarifies that the
organization's accounting system must be functioning and operated in
accordance with generally accepted accounting principles. HUD has
included this language to make certain that accounting systems are
workable and abide by definite, accurate standards. As reflected in the
statutory definition of ``private nonprofit organization,'' HUD may
establish requirements for the designation of a fiscal agent. HUD has
determined that the fiscal agent, such as a Unified Funding Agency, a
term that is also defined in section 424 of the McKinney-Vento Act,
must maintain a functioning accounting system for the organization in
accordance with generally accepted accounting principles.
Permanent housing is consistent with the statutory definition of
``permanent housing'' in section 401 of the McKinney-Vento Act, but
does not track the statutory language. HUD's regulatory definition of
``permanent housing'' states: ``The term `permanent housing' means
community-based housing without a designated length of stay, and
includes both permanent supportive housing and rapid re-housing.''
Additionally, in the regulatory definition of ``permanent housing,''
HUD clarifies that to be permanent housing, ``the program participant
must be the tenant on a lease for a term of at least one year that is
renewable and is terminable only for cause. The lease must be renewable
for terms that are a minimum of one month long. HUD has determined that
requiring a lease for a term of at least one year that is renewable and
terminable only for cause, assists program participants in obtaining
stability in housing, even when the rental assistance is temporary.
These requirements are consistent with Section 8 requirements.
Specific request for comment. HUD specifically requests comment on
requiring a lease for a term of at least one year to be considered
permanent housing.
Project is consistent with the statutory definition of ``project''
in section 401 of the McKinney-Vento Act, but does not track the
statutory language. Section 401 defines ``project'' as, with respect to
activities carried out under subtitle C, eligible activities described
in section 423(a), undertaken pursuant to a specific endeavor, such as
serving a particular population or providing a particular resource. In
HUD's definition of ``project'' in this interim rule, the eligible
activities described in section 423(a) of the McKinney-Vento Act have
been identified. In the regulatory text, HUD has clarified that it is a
group of one or more of these eligible costs that are identified as a
project in an application to HUD for Continuum of Care funds.
Recipient is defined to mean an applicant that signs a grant
agreement with HUD. HUD's definition of ``recipient'' is consistent
with the statutory definition of ``recipient,'' but does not track the
statutory language. Section 424 of the McKinney-Vento Act defines
``recipient'' as ``an eligible entity who--(A) submits an application
for a grant under section 422 that is approved by the Secretary; (B)
receives the grant directly from the Secretary to support approved
projects described in the application; and (C)(i) serves as a project
sponsor for the projects; or (ii) awards the funds to project sponsors
to carry out the projects.'' All of the activities specified by the
statutory definition are in the rule: (A) and (B) are contained in the
definition and (C) is covered in the sections of the rule dealing with
what a recipient can do with grant funds.
Safe haven is based on the definition of safe haven in the
McKinney-Vento Act prior to amendment by the HEARTH Act. Although no
longer used in statute, HUD's position is that the term remains
relevant for implementation of the Continuum of Care program and,
therefore, HUD proposes to include the term in the Continuum of Care
program regulations. The term ``safe haven'' is used for purposes of
determining whether a person is chronically homeless. The housing must
serve hard-to-reach homeless persons with severe mental illness who
came from the streets and have been unwilling or unable to participate
in supportive services. In addition, the housing must provide 24-hour
residence for eligible persons for an unspecified period, have an
overnight capacity limited to 25 or fewer persons, and provide low-
demand services and referrals for the residents.
Subrecipient is defined to mean a private nonprofit organization,
State or local government, or instrumentality of a State or local
government that receives a subgrant from the recipient to operate a
project. The definition of ``subrecipient'' is consistent with the
definition of ``project sponsor'' found in section 401 of the McKinney-
Vento Act, but does not track the statutory language. To be consistent
with the Emergency Solutions Grants program regulation, and also to
ensure that the relationship between the recipient and subrecipient is
clear, HUD is using the term subrecipient, instead of project sponsor,
throughout this regulation.
Transitional housing is based on the definition of ``transitional
housing'' in section 401 of the McKinney-Vento Act, as follows: ``The
term `transitional housing' means housing, the purpose of which is to
facilitate the movement of individuals and families experiencing
homelessness to permanent housing within 24 months or such longer
period as the Secretary determines necessary.'' The definition has been
expanded to distinguish this type of housing from emergency shelter.
This distinction is necessitated by the McKinney-Vento Act's explicit
distinction between what activities can or cannot be funded under the
Continuum of Care program. The regulatory definition clarifies that, to
be transitional housing, program participants must have signed a lease
or occupancy agreement that is for a term of at least one month and
that ends in 24 months and cannot be extended.
Unified Funding Agency (UFA) means an eligible applicant selected
by the Continuum of Care to apply for a grant for the entire Continuum,
which has the capacity to carry out the duties delegated to a UFA in
this rule, which is approved by HUD and to which HUD awards a grant.
HUD's regulatory definition of UFA departs slightly from the statutory
definition. The statutory definition refers to the collaborative
applicant. The differences between the statutory definition and HUD's
regulatory definition reflect HUD's substitution of Continuum of Care
for collaborative applicant.
Establishing and Operating the Continuum of Care (Subpart B)
In general. The statutory authority for the Continuum of Care
program is section 422 of the McKinney-Vento Act. As stated under
section 1002 of the HEARTH Act, one of the main purposes of the HEARTH
Act is to codify the Continuum of Care planning process. Consequently,
under this interim rule,
[[Page 45427]]
HUD focuses on the rules and responsibilities of those involved in the
Continuum of Care planning process and describes how applications and
grant funds will be processed.
As discussed earlier in the preamble, HUD's interim rule provides
for the duties and functions of the collaborative applicant found in
section 401 of the McKinney-Vento Act to be designated to the Continuum
of Care, with the exception of applying to HUD for grant funds. HUD
chose this approach because the Continuum might not be a legal entity,
and therefore cannot enter into enforceable contractual agreements, but
is the appropriate body for establishing and implementing decisions
that affect the entire geographic area covered by the Continuum,
including decisions related to funding. This approach allows the
Continuum to retain its duties related to planning and prioritizing
need (otherwise designated by statute to the collaborative applicant),
while the authority to sign a grant agreement with HUD is designated to
an eligible applicant that can enter into a contractual agreement. All
of the duties assigned to the Continuum are based on the comparable
duties of section 402(f) of the McKinney-Vento Act.
Subpart B of the interim rule identifies how Continuums of Care are
established, as well as the required duties and functions of the
Continuum of Care.
Establishing the Continuum of Care. In order to be eligible for
funds under the Continuum of Care program, representatives from
relevant organizations within a geographic area must establish a
Continuum of Care. As discussed earlier in this preamble, this body is
responsible for carrying out the duties identified in this interim
regulation. Representatives from relevant organizations include
nonprofit homeless assistance providers, victim service providers,
faith-based organizations, governments, businesses, advocates, public
housing agencies, school districts, social service providers, mental
health agencies, hospitals, universities, affordable housing
developers, law enforcement, and organizations that serve veterans and
homeless and formerly homeless individuals. Where these organizations
are located within the geographic area served by the Continuum of Care,
HUD expects a representative of the organization to be a part of the
Continuum of Care.
Specific request for comment. HUD specifically requests comments on
requiring Continuums of Care to have a board that makes the decisions
for the Continuum. HUD requires two characteristics for all board
compositions. These characteristics are that the Board must be
representative of the subpopulations of homeless persons that exist
within the geographic area, and include a homeless or formerly homeless
person. Continuums will have 2 years from the effective date of the
interim rule to establish a board that meets the criteria established
in this section. No board member may participate or influence
discussions or decisions concerning the award of a grant or other
financial benefits for an organization that the member represents.
HUD is considering four additional characteristics for all board
compositions for incorporation in the final rule. HUD did not implement
them at this stage in order to seek public comment prior to
implementing them as requirements. HUD proposes that all boards must
have a chair or co-chairs; be composed of an uneven number, serving
staggered terms; include members from the public and private sectors;
and include a member from at least one Emergency Solutions Grants
program (ESG) recipient's agency located within the Continuum's
geographic area. HUD is requesting comment on all of these proposed
requirements; however, HUD specifically requests comments from
Continuums of Care and ESG recipients on the requirement that the Board
include an ESG recipient as part of its membership. HUD invites ESG
recipients and Continuums to share challenges that will be encountered
when implementing this requirement. Ensuring that ESG recipients are
represented on the Board is important to HUD; therefore, in communities
where ESG recipients and/or Continuums do not feel this requirement is
feasible, HUD asks commenters to provide suggestions for how ESG
recipients can be involved in the Continuum at one of the core
decision-making levels.
Responsibilities of the Continuum of Care. The interim rule
establishes three major duties for which the Continuum of Care is
responsible: To operate the Continuum of Care, to designate an HMIS for
the Continuum of Care, and to plan for the Continuum of Care.
This section of the interim rule establishes requirements within
these three major duties.
Operating the Continuum of Care. The interim rule provides that the
Continuum of Care must abide by certain operational requirements. These
requirements will ensure the effective management of the Continuum of
Care process and ensure that the process is inclusive and fair. HUD has
established eight duties required of the Continuum necessary to
effectively operate the Continuum of Care. HUD has established the
specific minimum standards for operating and managing a Continuum of
Care for two main reasons. First, the selection criteria established
under section 427 of the McKinney-Vento Act require HUD to measure the
Continuum of Care's performance in reducing homelessness by looking at
the overall performance of the Continuum, as opposed to measuring
performance project-by-project as was done prior to the enactment of
the HEARTH Act. This Continuum of Care performance approach results in
cooperation and coordination among providers. Second, because
Continuums of Care will have grants of up to 3 percent of Final Pro
Rata Need (FPRN) to be used for eligible Continuum of Care planning
costs, HUD is requiring more formal decision-making and operating
standards for the Continuum of Care. This requirement ensures that the
Continuums have appropriate funding to support planning costs.
One of the duties established in this interim rule is the
requirement that the Continuum establish and operate a centralized or
coordinated assessment system that provides an initial, comprehensive
assessment of the needs of individuals and families for housing and
services. As detailed in the Emergency Solutions Grants program interim
rule published on December 5, 2011, through the administration of the
Rapid Re-Housing for Families Demonstration program and the
Homelessness Prevention and Rapid Re-Housing program, as well as best
practices identified in communities, HUD has learned that centralized
or coordinated assessment systems are important in ensuring the success
of homeless assistance and homeless prevention programs in communities.
In particular, such assessment systems help communities systematically
assess the needs of program participants and effectively match each
individual or family with the most appropriate resources available to
address that individual or family's particular needs.
Therefore, HUD has required, through this interim rule, each
Continuum of Care to develop and implement a centralized or coordinated
assessment system for its geographic area. Such a system must be
designed locally in response to local needs and conditions. For
example, rural areas will have significantly different systems than
urban ones. While the common thread between typical models is the use
of a
[[Page 45428]]
common assessment tool, the form, detail, and use of that tool will
vary from one community to the next. Some examples of centralized or
coordinated assessment systems include: A central location or locations
within a geographic area where individuals and families must be present
to receive homeless services; a 211 or other hotline system that
screens and directly connects callers to appropriate homeless housing/
service providers in the area; a ``no wrong door'' approach in which a
homeless family or individual can show up at any homeless service
provider in the geographic area but is assessed using the same tool and
methodology so that referrals are consistently completed across the
Continuum of Care; a specialized team of case workers that provides
assessment services to providers within the Continuum of Care; or in
larger geographic areas, a regional approach in which ``hubs'' are
created within smaller geographic areas. HUD intends to develop
technical assistance materials on a range of centralized and
coordinated assessment types, including those most appropriate for
rural areas.
HUD recognizes that imposing a requirement for a centralized or
coordinated assessment system may have certain costs and risks. Among
the risks that HUD wishes specifically to address are the risks facing
individuals and families fleeing domestic violence, dating violence,
sexual assault, and stalking. In developing the baseline requirements
for a centralized or coordinated intake system, HUD is considering
whether victim service providers should be exempt from participating in
a local centralized or coordinated assessment process, or whether
victim service providers should have the option to participate or not.
Specific request for comment. HUD specifically seeks comment from
Continuum of Care-funded victim service providers on this question. As
set forth in this interim rule, each Continuum of Care is to develop a
specific policy on how its particular system will address the needs of
individuals and families who are fleeing, or attempting to flee,
domestic violence, dating violence, sexual assault, or stalking, but
who are seeking shelter or services from non-victim service providers.
These policies could include reserving private areas at an assessment
location for evaluations of individuals or families who are fleeing, or
attempting to flee, domestic violence, dating violence, sexual assault,
or stalking; a separate ``track'' within the assessment framework that
is specifically designed for domestic violence victims; or the location
of victim service providers with centralized assessment teams.
HUD invites suggestions for ensuring that the requirements it
imposes regarding centralized or coordinated assessment systems will
best help communities use their resources effectively and best meet the
needs of all families and individuals who need assistance. Questions
that HUD asks commenters to specifically address are: What barriers to
accessing housing/services might a centralized or coordinated intake
system pose to victims of domestic violence? How can those barriers be
eliminated? What specific measures should be implemented to ensure
safety and confidentiality for individuals and families who are fleeing
or attempting to flee domestic violence situations? How should those
additional standards be implemented to ensure that victims of domestic
violence have immediate access to housing and services without
increasing the burden on those victims? For communities that already
have centralized or coordinated assessment systems in place, are
victims of domestic violence and/or domestic violence service providers
integrated into that system? Under either scenario (they are integrated
into an assessment process or they are not integrated into it), how
does your community ensure the safety and confidentiality of this
population, as well as access to homeless housing and services? What
HUD-sponsored training would be helpful to assist communities in
completing the initial assessment of victims of domestic violence in a
safe and confidential manner?
In addition to comments addressing the needs of victims of domestic
violence, dating violence, sexual assault, and stalking, HUD invites
general comments on the use of a centralized or coordinated assessment
system, particularly from those in communities that have already
implemented one of these systems who can share both what has worked
well and how these systems could be improved. HUD specifically seeks
comment on any additional risks that a centralized or coordinated
assessment system may create for victims of domestic violence, dating
violence, sexual assault, or stalking who are seeking emergency shelter
services due to immediate danger, regardless of whether they are
seeking services through a victim service provider or nonvictim service
provider.
Another duty set forth in this part, is the requirement to
establish and consistently follow written standards when administering
assistance under this part. These requirements, established in
consultation with recipients of Emergency Solutions Grants program
funds within the geographic area, are intended to coordinate service
delivery across the geographic area and assist Continuums of Care and
their recipients in evaluating the eligibility of individuals and
families consistently and administering assistance fairly and
methodically. The written standards can be found in Sec. 578.7(a)(9)
of this interim rule.
Designating and operating an HMIS. The Continuum of Care is
responsible for designating an HMIS and an eligible applicant to manage
the HMIS, consistent with the requirements, which will be codified in
24 CFR part 580. This duty is listed under section 402(f)(2) of the
McKinney-Vento Act. In addition, the Continuum is responsible for
reviewing, revising, and approving a privacy plan, security plan, and
data quality plan for the HMIS and ensuring consistent participation of
recipients and subrecipients in the HMIS.
Continuum of Care planning. The Continuum is responsible for
coordinating and implementing a system for its geographic area to meet
the needs of the homeless population and subpopulations within the
geographic area. The interim rule defines the minimum requirements for
this systematic approach under Sec. 578.7(c)(1), such as emergency
shelters, rapid rehousing, transitional housing, permanent supportive
housing, and prevention strategies. Because there are not sufficient
resources available through the Continuum of Care program to prevent
and end homelessness, coordination and integration of other funding
streams, including the Emergency Solutions Grants program and
mainstream resources, is integral to carrying out the Continuum of Care
System.
HUD has determined that since the Continuum of Care will be the
larger planning organization, the Continuum of Care must develop and
follow a Continuum of Care plan that adheres, not only to the
requirements being established by this interim rule, but to the
requirements and directions of the most recently issued notice of
funding availability (NOFA).
While these planning duties are not explicitly provided in section
402(f) of the Act, HUD has included them to facilitate and clarify the
Continuum of Care planning process. Consistent with the goals of the
HEARTH Act, HUD strives, through this interim rule, to provide a
comprehensive, well-
[[Page 45429]]
coordinated and clear planning process, which involves the creation of
the Continuum of Care and the duties the Continuum of Care will have to
fulfill.
Other planning duties for Continuums established in this section of
the interim rule are planning for and conducting at least a biennial-
point-in-time count of homeless persons within the geographic area,
conducting an annual gaps analysis of the homeless needs and services
available within the geographic area, providing information necessary
to complete the Consolidated Plan(s) within the geographic area, and
consulting with State and local government Emergency Solutions Grants
program recipients within the Continuum of Care on the plan for
allocating Emergency Solutions Grants program funds and reporting on
and evaluating the performance of Emergency Solutions Grants program
recipients and subrecipients.
Preparing an application for funds. A major function of the
Continuum of Care is preparing and overseeing an application for funds
under this part. This section of the interim rule establishes the
duties of the Continuum of Care related to the preparation of the
application. This section of the interim rule establishes that the
Continuum is responsible for designing, operating, and following a
collaborative process for the development of applications, as well as
approving the submission of applications, in response to a NOFA
published by HUD.
The Continuum must also establish priorities for funding projects
within the geographic area and determine the number of applications
being submitted for funding. As previously noted in this preamble,
since the Continuum of Care might not be a legal entity, and therefore
may not be able to enter into a contractual agreement with HUD, the
Continuum must select one or more eligible applicants to submit an
application for funding to HUD on its behalf. If the Continuum of Care
is an eligible applicant, the Continuum of Care may submit an
application. If the Continuum selects more than one application, the
Continuum must select one eligible applicant to be the collaborative
applicant. That applicant will collect and combine the required
application information from all of the other eligible applicants and
for all projects within the geographic area that the Continuum has
designated. If only one application is submitted by the collaborative
applicant, the collaborative applicant will collect and combine the
required application information from all projects within the
geographic area that the Continuum has designated for funding. The
collaborative applicant will always be the only applicant that can
apply for Continuum of Care planning costs. In the case that there is
one application for projects, the recipient of the funds is required to
have signed agreements with its subrecipients as set forth in Sec.
578.23(c), and is required to monitor and sanction subrecipients in
compliance with Sec. 578.107.
Whether the Continuum of Care submits the application or designates
an eligible applicant to submit the application for funding, the
Continuum of Care retains all of its duties.
Unified Funding Agencies. To be designated as the Unified Funding
Agency (UFA) for the Continuum of Care, the Continuum must select the
collaborative applicant to apply to HUD to be designated as the UFA for
the Continuum. The interim rule establishes the criteria HUD will use
when determining whether to designate the collaborative applicant as a
UFA. These standards were developed to ensure that collaborative
applicants have the capacity to manage the grant and carry out the
duties in 578.11(b), and are described below.
The duties of the UFA established in Sec. 578.11 are consistent
with the duties set forth in section 402(g) of the Act. Even if the
Continuum designates a UFA to submit the application for funding, the
Continuum of Care retains all of its duties.
Remedial actions. Section 402(c) of the McKinney-Vento Act gives
HUD the authority to ensure the fair distribution of grant amounts for
this program, such as designating another body as a collaborative
applicant, replacing the Continuum of Care for the geographic area, or
permitting other eligible entities to apply directly for grants.
Section 578.13 of this interim rule addresses the remedial actions that
may be taken.
Overview of the Application and Grant Award Process (Subpart C)
Eligible applicants. Under this interim rule, eligible applicants
consist of nonprofit organizations, State and local governments, and
instrumentalities of local governments. An eligible applicant must have
been designated by the Continuum of Care to submit an application for
grant funds under this part. The Continuum's designation must state
whether the Continuum is designating more than one applicant to apply
for funds, and if it is, which applicant is being designated the
collaborative applicant. A Continuum of Care that is designating only
one applicant for funds must designate that applicant to be the
collaborative applicant. For-profit entities are not eligible to apply
for grants or to be subrecipients of grant funds.
Section 401(10) of the McKinney-Vento Act identifies that
collaborative applicants may be legal entities, and a legal entity may
include a consortium of instrumentalities of a State or local
government that has constituted itself as an entity. HUD has not
included a consortium in the list of eligible applicants. As noted
earlier in this preamble, a Continuum of Care is defined to mean a
group that is composed of representatives of organizations across the
entire geographic area claimed by the Continuum of Care. A Continuum is
able to combine more than one metropolitan city or county into the
geographic area that the Continuum represents. In essence, the
Continuum of Care acts as a consortium, and it is therefore HUD's
position that the inclusion of consortiums in the interim rule would be
redundant.
Determining the Continuum's maximum award amount. The total amount
for which a Continuum of Care is eligible to apply and be awarded is
determined through a four-step process, including the following
factors: A Continuum's PPRN amount; renewal demand; any additional
increases in amounts for leasing, rental assistance, and operating
costs based on Fair Market Rents (FMRs); planning and UFA cost funds;
and the amounts available for bonus dollars.
Using the formula that will be discussed below, HUD will first
determine a Continuum of Care's PPRN amount, as authorized under
section 427(b)(2)(B) of the McKinney-Vento Act. This amount is the sum
of the PPRN amounts for each metropolitan city, urban county, non-urban
county, and insular area claimed by the Continuum of Care as part of
its geographic area, excluding any counties applying for, or receiving
funds under the Rural Housing Stability Assistance program, the
regulations for which will be established in 24 CFR part 579. The PPRN
for each of these areas is based upon the ``need formula'' under Sec.
579.17(a)(2) and (3). Under the McKinney-Vento Act, HUD is required to
publish, by regulation, the formula used to establish grant amounts.
The need formula under Sec. 579.17(a)(2) and (3) satisfies this
requirement, and HUD specifically seeks comment on this formula. HUD
will announce the PPRN amounts prior to the publication of the NOFA on
its Web site.
To establish the amount on which the need formula is run, HUD will
deduct an amount, which will be published in
[[Page 45430]]
the NOFA, to be set aside to provide a bonus, and the amount necessary
to fund Continuum of Care planning activities and UFA costs from the
total funds made available for the program each fiscal year. On this
amount, HUD will use the following process to establish an area's PPRN.
First, 2 percent of the total funds available shall be allocated among
the four insular areas (American Samoa, Guam, the Commonwealth of the
Northern Marianas, and the Virgin Islands) based upon the percentage
each area received in the previous fiscal year under section 106 of the
Housing and Community Development Act of 1974. Second, 75 percent of
the remaining funds made available shall be allocated to metropolitan
cities and urban counties that have been funded under the Emergency
Solutions Grants program (formerly known as the Emergency Shelter
Grants program) every year since 2004. Third, the remaining funds made
available shall be allocated to Community Development Block Grant
(CDBG) metropolitan cities and urban counties that have not been funded
under the Emergency Solutions Grants program every year since 2004 and
all other counties in the United States and Puerto Rico.
Recognizing that in some federal fiscal years, the amount available
for the formula may be less than the amount required to renew all
existing projects eligible for renewal in that year for at least one
year, HUD has included a method for distributing the reduction of funds
proportionally across all Continuums of Care in Sec. 578.17(a)(4) of
this interim rule. HUD will publish the total dollar amount that each
Continuum will be required to deduct from renewal projects Continuum-
wide, and Continuums will have the authority to determine how to
administer the cuts to projects across the Continuum.
Specific request for comment. HUD specifically requests comment on
the method established in Sec. 578.17(a)(4) to reduce the total amount
required to renew all projects eligible for renewal in that one year,
for at least one year, for each Continuum of Care when funding is not
sufficient to renew all projects nationwide for at least one year.
The second step in determining a Continuum's maximum award amount
is establishing a Continuum of Care's ``renewal demand.'' The
Continuum's renewal demand is the sum of the annual renewal amounts of
all projects eligible within the Continuum of Care's geographic area to
apply for renewal in that federal fiscal year's competition before any
adjustments to rental assistance, leasing, and operating line items
based on changes to the FMRs in the geographic area.
Third, HUD will determine the Continuum of Care's Final Pro Rata
Need (FPRN), which is the higher of: (1) PPRN, or (2) renewal demand
for the Continuum of Care. The FPRN establishes the base for the
maximum award amount for the Continuum of Care.
Fourth, HUD will determine the maximum award amount. The maximum
award amount for the Continuum of Care is the FPRN amount plus any
additional eligible amounts for Continuum planning; establishing fiscal
controls for the Continuum; updates to leasing, operating, and rental
assistance line items based on changes to FMR; and the availability of
any bonus funding during the competition.
Application process. Each fiscal year, HUD will issue a NOFA. All
applications, including applications for grant funds, and requests for
designation as a UFA or HPC, must be submitted to HUD in accordance
with the requirements of the NOFA and contain such information as the
NOFA specifies. Applications may request up to the maximum award amount
for Continuums of Care.
An applicant that is a State or a unit of general local government
must have a HUD-approved, consolidated plan in accordance with HUD's
Consolidated Plan regulations in 24 CFR part 91. The applicant must
submit a certification that the application for funding is consistent
with the HUD-approved consolidated plan(s) in the project's
jurisdiction(s). Applicants that are not States or units of general
local government must submit a certification that the application for
funding is consistent with the jurisdiction's HUD-approved consolidated
plan. The certification must be made by the unit of general local
government or the State, in accordance with HUD's regulations in 24 CFR
part 91, subpart F. The required certification must be submitted by the
funding application submission deadline announced in the NOFA.
An applicant may provide assistance under this program only in
accordance with HUD subsidy layering requirements in section 102 of the
Housing and Urban Development Reform Act of 1989 (42 U.S.C. 3545). In
this interim rule, HUD clarifies that the applicant must submit
information in its application on other sources of funding the
applicant has received, or reasonably expects to receive, for a
proposed project or activities.
Awarding funds. HUD will review applications in accordance with the
guidelines and procedures specified in the NOFA and award funds to
recipients through a national competition based on selection criteria
as defined in section 427 of the McKinney-Vento Act. HUD will announce
the awards and notify selected applicants of any conditions imposed on
the awards.
Grant agreements. A recipient of a conditionally awarded grant must
satisfy all requirements for obligation of funds; otherwise, HUD will
withdraw its offer of the award. These conditions include establishing
site control, providing proof of match, complying with environmental
review under Sec. 578.31, and documenting financial feasibility within
the deadlines under Sec. 578.21(a)(3). HUD has included in the interim
rule the deadlines for conditions that may be extended and the reasons
for which HUD will consider an extension.
The interim rule requires that site control be established by each
recipient receiving funds for acquisition, rehabilitation funding, new
construction, or operating costs, or for providing supportive services.
HUD has determined that the time to establish site control is 12 months
for projects not receiving new construction, acquisition, or
rehabilitation funding, as stated under section 426(a) of the McKinney-
Vento Act, not 9 months as stated under section 422(d) of the McKinney-
Vento Act, for projects receiving operating and supportive service
funds. HUD's determination on the time needed to establish site control
is based on previous program policy, and the longer time frame takes
into consideration the reality of the housing market. Projects
receiving acquisition, rehabilitation, or new construction funding must
provide evidence of site control no later than 24 months after the
announcement of grant awards, as provided under section 422(d) of the
McKinney-Vento Act.
The interim rule requires that HUD perform an environmental review
for each property as required under HUD's environmental regulations in
24 CFR part 50. All recipients of Continuum of Care program funding
under this part must supply all available, relevant information
necessary to HUD, and carry out mitigating measures required by HUD.
The recipient, its project partners, and its project partner's
contractors may not perform any eligible activity for a project under
this part, or commit or expend HUD or local funds for such activities
until HUD has performed an environmental review and the recipient has
received HUD approval of the property agreements.
Executing grant agreements. If a Continuum designates more than one
applicant for the geographic area, HUD
[[Page 45431]]
will enter into a grant agreement with each designated recipient for
which an award is announced. If a Continuum designates only one
recipient for the geographic area, HUD may enter into one grant
agreement with that recipient for new awards, if any; and one grant
agreement for renewals and Continuum of Care planning costs and UFA
costs, if any. These two grant agreements will cover the entire
geographic area, and a default by the recipient under one of these
agreements will also constitute a default under the other. If the
Continuum is a UFA, HUD will enter into one grant agreement with the
UFA for new awards, if any; and one for renewal and Continuum of Care
planning costs and UFA costs, if any. Similarly, these two grant
agreements will cover the entire geographic area and a default by the
recipient under one of those agreements will also constitute a default
under the other.
HUD requires the recipient to enter into the agreement described in
Sec. 578.23(c). Under this agreement, the grant recipient must agree
to ensure that the operation of the project will be in accordance with
the McKinney-Veto Act and the requirements under this part. In
addition, the recipient must monitor and report the progress of the
projects to the Continuum of Care and to HUD. The recipient must ensure
that individuals and families experiencing homelessness are involved in
the operation of the project, maintain confidentiality of program
participants, and monitor and report matching funds to HUD, among other
requirements. The recipient must also agree to use the centralized or
coordinated assessment system established by the Continuum of Care,
unless the recipient or subrecipient is a victim service provider.
Victim service providers may choose not to use the centralized or
coordinated assessment system provided that all victim service
providers in the area use a centralized or coordinated assessment
system that meets HUD's minimum requirements. HUD has provided this
optional exception because it understands the unique role that victim
service providers have within the Continuum of Care.
Renewals. The interim rule provides that HUD may fund, through the
Continuum of Care program, all projects that were previously eligible
under the McKinney-Vento Act prior to the enactment of the HEARTH Act.
These projects may be renewed to continue ongoing leasing, operations,
supportive services, rental assistance, HMIS, and administration beyond
the initial funding period even if those projects would not be eligible
under the Continuum of Care program. For projects that would no longer
be eligible under the Continuum of Care program (e.g., safe havens),
but which are serving homeless persons; HUD wants to ensure that
housing is maintained and that persons do not become homeless because
funding is withdrawn.
HUD may renew projects that were submitted on time and in such
manner as required by HUD, but did not have a total score that would
allow the project to be competitively funded. HUD may choose to
exercise this option to ensure that homeless or formerly homeless
persons do not lose their housing. The interim rule provides, based on
the language in section 421(e) of the McKinney-Vento Act, that HUD may
renew the project, upon a finding that the project meets the purposes
of the Continuum of Care program, for up to one year and under such
conditions as HUD deems appropriate.
Annual Performance Report. The interim rule also provides that HUD
may terminate the renewal of any grant and require the recipient to
repay the renewal grant if the recipient fails to submit a HUD Annual
Performance Report (APR) within 90 days of the end of the program year
or if the recipient submits an APR that HUD deems unacceptable or shows
noncompliance with the requirements of the grant and this part. Section
578.103(e) of the Continuum of Care program regulations further
clarifies that recipients receiving grant funds for acquisition,
rehabilitation, or new construction are expected to submit APRs for 15
years from the date of initial occupancy or the date of initial service
provision, unless HUD provides an exception. The recipient's submission
of the APR helps HUD review whether the recipient is carrying out the
project in the manner proposed in the application. Recipients agree to
submit an APR as a condition of their grant agreement. This requirement
allows HUD to ensure that recipients submit APRs on grant agreements
that have expired as a condition of receiving approval for a new grant
agreement for the renewal project.
Appeals. The interim rule provides certain appeal options for
applicants that were not awarded funding.
Under section 422(g) of the McKinney-Vento Act, if more than one
collaborative applicant submits an application covering the same
geographic area, HUD must award funds to the application that scores
the highest score based on the selection criteria set forth in section
427 of the Act. Consistent with HUD's use of the term Continuum of Care
in the interim rule where the statute uses collaborative applicant, as
explained earlier in the preamble, the interim rule stipulates that if
more than one Continuum of Care claims the same geographic area, then
HUD will award funds to the Continuum applicant(s) whose application(s)
has the highest total score and that no projects from the lower scoring
Continuum of Care will be funded (and that any projects submitted with
both applications will not be funded). To appeal HUD's decision to fund
the competing Continuum of Care, the applicant(s) from the lower-
scoring Continuum of Care must file the written appeal in such form and
manner as HUD may require within 45 days of the date of HUD's
announcement of award.
If an applicant has had a certification of consistency with a
consolidated plan withheld, that applicant may appeal such a decision
to HUD. HUD has established a procedure to process the appeals and no
later than 45 days after the date of receipt of an appeal, HUD will
make a decision.
Section 422(h) of the McKinney-Vento Act provides the authority for
a solo applicant to submit an application to HUD and be awarded a grant
by HUD if it meets the criteria under section 427 of the McKinney-Vento
Act. The interim rule clarifies that a solo applicant must submit its
application to HUD by the deadline established in the NOFA to be
considered for funding. The statute also requires that HUD establish an
appeal process for organizations that attempted to participate in the
Continuum of Care's process and believe they were denied the right to
reasonable participation, as reviewed in the context of the local
Continuum's process. An organization may submit a solo application to
HUD and appeal the Continuum's decision not to include it in the
Continuum's application. If HUD finds that the solo applicant was not
permitted to participate in the Continuum of Care process in a
reasonable manner, then HUD may award the grant to that solo applicant
and may direct the Continuum to take remedial steps to ensure
reasonable participation in the future. HUD may also reduce the award
to the Continuum's applicant(s).
Section 422(h)(1) of the McKinney-Vento Act requires that ``HUD
establish a timely appeal procedure for grant amounts awarded or denied
under this subtitle to a collaborative application.'' The interim rule
sets an appeal process for denied or decreased funding under Sec.
578.35(c). Applicants that are denied funds by HUD, or that requested
more funds than HUD awarded, may appeal
[[Page 45432]]
by filing a written appeal within 45 days of the date of HUD's
announcement of the award. HUD will notify applicant of its decision on
the appeal within 60 days of the date of HUD's receipt of the written
appeal.
Program Components and Eligible Costs (Subpart D)
Program components. The interim rule provides that Continuum of
Care funds may be used for projects under five program components:
Permanent housing, transitional housing, supportive services only,
HMIS, and, in some cases, homelessness prevention. Administrative costs
are eligible under all components. Where possible, the components set
forth in the Continuum of Care program are consistent with the
components set forth under the Emergency Solutions Grants program. This
will ease the administrative burden on recipients of both programs and
will ensure that reporting requirements and data quality benchmarks are
consistently established and applied to like projects. One significant
distinction between the Emergency Solutions Grants program and this
part can be found in the eligible activities and administration
requirements for assistance provided under the rapid rehousing
component in this interim rule. The significant differences between
this component in the Emergency Solutions Grants program and this part
are discussed below.
The interim rule sets forth the costs eligible for each program
component in Sec. 578.37(a). The eligible costs for contributing data
to the HMIS designated by the Continuum of Care are also eligible under
all components.
Consistent with the definition of permanent housing in section 401
of the McKinney-Vento Act and Sec. 578.3 of this interim rule, the
permanent housing component is community-based housing without a
designated length of stay that permits formerly homeless individuals
and families to live as independently as possible. The interim rule
clarifies that Continuum of Care funds may be spent on two types of
permanent housing: Permanent supportive housing for persons with
disabilities (PSH) and rapid rehousing that provides temporary
assistance (i.e., rental assistance and/or supportive services) to
program participants in a unit that the program participant retains
after the assistance ends.
Although the McKinney-Vento Act authorizes permanent housing
without supportive services, the interim rule does not. Based on its
experience with the Supportive Housing and Shelter Plus Care programs,
HUD has determined that programs should require at least case
management for some initial period after exiting homelessness. HUD has
imposed the requirement that rapid rehousing include, at a minimum,
monthly case management meetings with program participants (except
where prohibited by the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) and the
Family Violence Prevention and Services Act (FVPSA)) and allows for a
full range of supportive services to be provided for up to 6 months
after the rental assistance stops. Many other HUD programs, such as
Section 8 and HOME, provide housing without supportive services to low-
income individuals and families.
With respect to rapid rehousing, the interim rule provides that
funds under this part may be used to provide supportive services and
short-term and/or medium-term rental assistance. While the time frames
under which a program participant may receive short-term or medium-term
rental assistance set forth in this part match the time frames set
forth in the Emergency Solutions Grants program, the supportive
services available to program participants receiving rapid rehousing
assistance under the Continuum of Care program are not limited to
housing relocation and stabilization services as they are in the
Emergency Solutions Grants program. Program participants receiving
rapid rehousing under this part may receive any of the supportive
services set forth in Sec. 578.53 during their participation in the
program. The Continuum of Care, however, does have the discretion to
develop written policies and procedures that limit the services
available to program participants that better align the services
available to program participants with those set forth in the Emergency
Solutions Grants program.
Specific request for comment. While HUD's experience with the
Supportive Housing and Shelter Plus Care programs is the basis for
HUD's determination to require case management for some initial period
after exiting homelessness, HUD specifically welcomes comment on other
experiences with monthly case management.
The interim rule provides that the HMIS component is for funds that
are used by HMIS Leads only. Eligible costs include leasing a structure
in which the HMIS is operated, operating funds to operate a structure
in which the HMIS is operated, and HMIS costs related to establishing,
operating, and customizing a Continuum of Care's HMIS.
As set forth in Section 424(c) of the McKinney-Veto Act, Continuum
of Care funds may be used only for the homelessness prevention
component by recipients in Continuums of Care that have been designated
HPCs by HUD. Eligible activities are housing relocation and
stabilization services, and short- and/or medium-term rental
assistance, as set forth in 24 CFR 576.103, necessary to prevent an
individual or family from becoming homeless.
Planning activities. Under this interim rule, HUD lists eligible
planning costs for the Continuum of Care under Sec. 578.39(b) and (c).
HUD will allow no more than 3 percent of the FPRN, or a maximum amount
to be established by the NOFA, to be used for certain costs. These
costs must be related to designing a collaborative process for an
application to HUD, evaluating the outcomes of funded projects under
the Continuum of Care and Emergency Solutions Grants programs, and
participating in the consolidated plan(s) for the geographic area(s).
Under section 423 of the McKinney-Vento Act, a collaborative applicant
may use no more than 3 percent of total funds made available to pay for
administrative costs related to Continuum of Care planning.
HUD is defining ``of the total funds made available'' to mean FPRN,
the higher of PPRN or renewal demand, in the interim rule. HUD has
determined that FPRN strikes the correct balance, as it is the higher
of PPRN or renewal demand. This will help Continuums of Care (CoC)
balance: (1) Having sufficient planning dollars to be successful in its
duties and compete for new money (which would be the PPRN), and (2)
being able to monitor and evaluate actual projects in operation (and
plan for renewal demand). The administrative funds related to CoC
planning made available will be added to a CoC's FPRN to establish the
CoCs maximum award amount.
Unified Funding Agency Costs. Under this interim rule, HUD lists
eligible UFA costs in Sec. 578.41(b) and (c). Similar to the cap on
planning costs for CoC, HUD will allow no more than 3 percent of the
FPRN, or a maximum amount to be established by the NOFA, whichever is
less, to be used for UFA costs. This amount is in addition to the
amount made available for CoC planning costs. UFA costs include costs
associated with ensuring that all financial transactions carried out
under the Continuum of Care program are conducted and records
maintained in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles,
including arranging for an annual survey, audit, or evaluation of the
financial records of each project carried out by a subrecipient funded
by a grant received through the Continuum of Care program. The funds
made
[[Page 45433]]
available to UFAs related to establishing fiscal controls will be added
to a CoC's FPRN to establish the CoC maximum award amount.
Leasing. Under this interim rule, grant funds may be used to pay
the costs of leasing a structure or structures, or portions of
structures, to provide housing or supportive services. The interim rule
further clarifies that leasing means that the lease is between the
recipient of funds and the landlord. HUD recognizes that some grantees
receiving funds through the Supportive Housing Program may have been
using their leasing funds in a manner consistent with the rental
assistance requirements established in Sec. 578.51; therefore, since
the Continuum of Care program authorizes both leasing and rental
assistance, the rule provides for an allowance for projects originally
approved to carry out leasing to renew and request funds for rental
assistance, so long as the rental assistance meets the requirements in
Sec. 578.51. The rule provides that a recipient of a grant awarded
under the McKinney-Vento Act, prior to enactment of the HEARTH Act,
must apply for leasing if the lease is between the recipient and the
landlord, notwithstanding that the grant was awarded prior to the
HEARTH Act amendments to the McKinney-Vento Act.
The interim rule provides that leasing funds may not be used to
lease units or structures owned by the recipient, subrecipient, their
parent organization(s), any other related organization(s), or
organizations that are members of a partnership where the partnership
owns the structure, unless HUD authorizes an exception for good cause.
The interim rule establishes minimum requirements that a request for an
exception must include. These exceptions are based on HUD's experience
in administering the Homelessness Prevention and Rapid Re-Housing
Program (HPRP).
The interim rule establishes that projects for leasing may require
that program participants pay an occupancy charge (or in the case of a
sublease, rent) of no more than 30 percent of their income. Income must
be calculated in accordance with HUD's regulations in 24 CFR 5.609 and
24 CFR 5.611(a). However, the interim rule clarifies that projects may
not charge program fees.
Rental assistance. Under this interim rule, rental assistance is an
eligible cost for permanent and transitional housing, and this rule
clarifies that the rental assistance may be short-term, up to 3 months
of rent; medium-term, for 3 to 24 months of rent; and long-term, for
longer than 24 months of rent. This section provides that rental
assistance may include tenant-based, project-based, or sponsor-based
rental assistance. This section also provides that project-based rental
assistance may include rental assistance to preserve existing permanent
supportive housing for homeless individuals and families. Given that
the availability of affordable rental housing has been shown to be a
key factor in reducing homelessness, the availability of funding for
short-term, medium-term, and long-term rental assistance under both the
Emergency Solutions Grants program and the Continuum of Care program is
not inefficient use of program funds, but rather effective use of
funding for an activity that lowers the number of homeless persons.
As noted in the above discussion of rental housing available for
funding under the Continuum of Care program, one eligible form of
rental assistance is tenant-based, which allows the program participant
to retain rental assistance for another unit. The interim rule limits
this retention to within the Continuum of Care boundaries. HUD has
determined that Continuum of Care program funds must be used within the
Continuum's geographic boundaries. If program participants move outside
of the Continuum, the Continuum may pay moving costs, security
deposits, and the first month of rent for another unit; however, the
Continuum would have to organize assistance with the relevant Continuum
of Care for the program participant if rental assistance is to
continue. The program participant may be transferred to a rental
assistance program in a different Continuum without having to become
homeless again. The recipient may also limit the movement of the
assistance to a smaller area if this is necessary to coordinate service
delivery.
Under this interim rule, the only exception to the limitation for
retention of tenant-based rental assistance is for program participants
who are victims of domestic violence, dating violence, sexual assault,
or stalking. Under the definition of ``tenant-based'' in the McKinney-
Vento Act (section 401(28) of the McKinney-Vento Act), these
participants must have complied with all other obligations of the
program and reasonably believe that he or she is imminently threatened
by harm from further violence if he or she remains in the assisted
dwelling unit.
In the interim rule, HUD has clarified that the imminent threat of
harm must be from further domestic violence, dating violence, sexual
assault, or stalking, which would include threats from a third party,
such as a friend or family member of the perpetrator of the violence.
HUD requires that the program participant provide appropriate
documentation of the original incident of domestic violence, dating
violence, sexual assault, or stalking, and any evidence of the current
imminent threat of harm. Examples of appropriate documentation of the
original incident of domestic violence, dating violence, sexual
assault, or stalking include written observation by the housing or
service provider; a letter or other documentation from a victim service
provider, social worker, legal assistance provider, pastoral counselor,
mental health provider, or other professional from whom the victim has
sought assistance; or medical or dental, court, or law enforcement
records. Documentation of reasonable belief of further domestic
violence, dating violence, sexual assault, or stalking includes written
observation by the housing or service provider; a letter or other
written documentation from a victim service provider, social worker,
legal assistance provider, pastoral counselor, mental health provider,
or other professional from whom the victim has requested assistance; a
current restraining order, recent court order, or other court records;
or law enforcement reports or records. The housing or service provider
may also consider other documentation such as emails, voicemails, text
messages, social media posts, and other communication. Because of the
particular safety concerns surrounding victims of domestic violence,
the interim rule provides that acceptable evidence for both the
original violence and the reasonable belief include an oral statement.
This oral statement does not need to be verified, but it must be
documented by a written certification by the individual or head of
household.
This provision is specific to victims of domestic violence, dating
violence, sexual assault, and stalking who are receiving tenant-based
rental assistance in permanent housing. This interim rule contains
other policies for moving program participants receiving any type of
assistance under this interim rule, including tenant-based rental
assistance, within the Continuum of Care geographic area, or smaller
geographic area required by the provider to coordinate service
delivery. Moving program participants outside of the geographic area
where providers can coordinate service-delivery is administratively
difficult for providers and makes it difficult to monitor that program
participants have access to, and are receiving, appropriate supportive
[[Page 45434]]
services; therefore, moves outside of the geographic area where the
provider can effectively deliver and monitor service coordination are
allowed only under exceptional circumstances. HUD has established these
provisions to provide an exception and to address the challenges that
are associated with such a move.
Based on HUD's experience in administering the Shelter Plus Care
program, the interim rule includes provisions to clarify when rental
payments may continue to be made to a landlord when the program
participant no longer resides in the unit. For vacated units, the
interim rule provides that assistance may continue for a maximum of 30
days from the end of the month in which the unit was vacated, unless
the unit is occupied by another eligible person. A person staying in an
institution for less than 90 days is not considered as having vacated
the unit. Finally, the recipient may use grant funds, in an amount not
to exceed one month's rent, to pay for any damage to housing due to the
action of the program participant, one-time, per program participant,
per unit. This assistance can be provided only at the time the program
participant exits the housing unit.
Supportive services. Grant funds may be used to pay eligible costs
of supportive services for the special needs of program participants.
All eligible costs are eligible to the same extent for program
participants who are unaccompanied homeless youth; persons living with
Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)/Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome
(AIDS) (HIV/AIDS); and victims of domestic violence, dating violence,
sexual assault, or stalking. Any cost that is not described as an
eligible cost under this interim rule is not an eligible cost of
providing supportive services. Eligible costs consist of assistance
with moving costs, case management, child care, education services,
employment assistance and job training, housing search and counseling
services, legal services, life skills training, mental health services,
outpatient health services, outreach services, substance abuse
treatment services, transportation, and utility deposits.
The definition of ``supportive services'' in section 401(27) of the
McKinney-Vento Act includes the provision of mental health services,
trauma counseling, and victim services. HUD has determined that victim
services are eligible as supportive services, and are included as
eligible program costs in this interim rule. Providers are allowed to
provide services specifically to victims of domestic violence, dating
violence, sexual assault, and stalking. The eligible costs for
providing victim services are listed as eligible costs in the
supportive services funding category. Rather than create a new eligible
line item in the project budget, HUD has determined that these costs
can be included in the funding categories already established.
Indirect costs. Indirect costs are allowed as part of eligible
program costs. Programs using indirect cost allocations must be
consistent with Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Circulars A-87
and A-122, as applicable. OMB Circular A-87 and the regulations at 2
CFR part 225 pertain to ``Cost Principles for State, Local, and Indian
Tribal Governments.'' OMB Circular A-122 and the regulations codified
at 24 CFR part 230 pertain to ``Cost Principles for Non-Profit
Organizations.''
Other costs. In addition to the eligible costs described in this
preamble, the regulation addresses the following other eligible costs:
acquisition, rehabilitation, new construction, operating costs, HMIS,
project administrative costs, and relocation costs.
High-Performing Communities (Subpart E)
Section 424 of the McKinney-Vento Act establishes the authority for
the establishment of and requirements for HPCs. Applications must be
submitted by the collaborative applicant at such time and in such
manner as HUD may require and contain such information as HUD
determines necessary under Sec. 578.17(b). Applications will be posted
on the HUD Web site (www.hud.gov) for public comments. In addition to
HUD's review of the applications, interested members of the public will
be able to provide comment to HUD regarding the applications.
Requirements. The Continuum of Care must use HMIS data (HUD will
publish data standards and measurement protocols) to determine that the
standards for qualifying as a HPC are met. An applicant must submit a
report showing how the Continuum of Care program funds were expended in
the prior year, and provide information that the Continuum meets the
standards for HPCs.
Standards. In order to qualify as an HPC, a Continuum of Care must
demonstrate through reliable data that it meets all of the required
standards. The interim rule clarifies which standards will be measured
with reliable data from a Continuum's HMIS and which standards will be
measured through reliable data from other sources and presented in a
narrative form or other format prescribed by HUD.
Continuums must use the HMIS to demonstrate the following measures:
(1) That the mean length of homelessness must be less than 20 days for
the Continuum's geographic area, or the Continuum's mean length of
episodes for individuals and families in similar circumstances was
reduced by at least 10 percent from the preceding year; (2) that less
than 5 percent of individuals and families that leave homelessness
become homeless again any time within the next 2 years, or the
percentage of individuals and families in similar circumstances who
became homeless again within 2 years after leaving homelessness was
decreased by at least 20 percent from the preceding year; and (3) for
Continuums of Care that served homeless families with youth defined as
homeless under other federal statutes, that 95 percent of those
families did not become homeless again within a 2-year period following
termination of assistance and that 85 percent of those families
achieved independent living in permanent housing for at least 2 years
following the termination of assistance.
The McKinney-Vento Act requires that HUD set forth standards for
preventing homelessness among the subset of those at the highest risk
of becoming homeless among those homeless families and youth defined as
homeless under other federal statutes, the third measure above, one of
which includes achieving independent living in permanent housing among
this population. HUD has set forth the standards of 95 percent and 85
percent. HUD recognizes that these standards are high, but standards
are comparable to the other standards in the Act, which are high. It is
HUD's position that HPCs should be addressing the needs of those
homeless individuals within their communities prior to receiving
designation of a HPC and being allowed to spend funds in accordance
with Sec. 578.71.
The final standard that the Continuum must use its HMIS data to
demonstrate is provided under section 424(d)(4) of the Act. The statute
requires each homeless individual or family who sought homeless
assistance to be included in the data system used by that community.
HUD has defined this as bed-coverage and service-volume coverage rates
of at least 80 percent. The documentation that each homeless individual
or family who sought homeless assistance be included in the HMIS is not
measurable by HUD. This type of standard would be entirely reliant upon
self-reporting. Additionally, individuals and families
[[Page 45435]]
have the right to decline having their data entered into the HMIS. HUD
uses bed-coverage rates and service-volume coverage rates as a proxy
for measuring the rate of inclusion of persons who are present for
services or housing in the HMIS. This is a measurable standard, and HUD
defines the calculation in the HMIS rule; therefore, the measurement
will be consistent between Continuums.
Continuums must use reliable data from other sources and presented
in a narrative form or other format prescribed by HUD to measure two
standards: Community action and renewing HPC status. Section 424(d)(4)
of the McKinney-Vento Act establishes another standard for HPCs, which
is ``community action.'' This statutory section provides that
communities that compose the geographic area must have actively
encouraged homeless individuals and families to participate in housing
and services available in the geographic area and included each
homeless individual or family who sought homeless assistance services
in the data system used by that community for determining compliance.
HUD has defined ``communities that compose the geographic area'' to
mean the entire geographic area of the Continuum. This definition will
also provide consistency of measurement since most of HUD's
measurements are across the entire Continuum of Care geographic area.
HUD has further defined ``actively encourage'' within this standard as
a comprehensive outreach plan, including specific steps for identifying
homeless persons and referring them to appropriate housing and services
in that geographic area. The measurement of the last part of this
standard, ``each homeless individual or family who sought homeless
assistance services in the data system used by that community,'' will
be measured using reliable data from an HMIS and has been discussed
earlier in this preamble. HUD has determined this will provide clarity
and ensure consistent measurement across Continuums.
The interim rule provides that a Continuum of Care that was an HPC
in the prior year and used Continuum funds for activities described
under Sec. 578.71 must demonstrate that these activities were
effective at reducing the number of persons who became homeless in that
community, to be renewed as a HPC.
Selection. HUD will select up to 10 Continuums of Care each year
that best meet the application requirements and the standards set forth
in Sec. 578.65. Consistent with section 424 of the McKinney-Vento Act,
the interim rule provides a HPC designation for the grants awarded in
the same competition in which the designation is applied for and made.
The designation will be for a period of one year.
Eligible activities. Recipients and subrecipients in Continuums
that have been designated an HPC may use grant funds to provide housing
relocation and stabilization services and short- and/or medium-term
rental assistance to individuals and families at risk of homelessness
as set for in the Emergency Solutions Grants program. All eligible
activities discussed in this section must be effective at stabilizing
individuals and families in their current housing, or quickly moving
such individuals and families to other permanent housing. This is the
only time that Continuum of Care funds may be used to serve nonhomeless
individuals and families. Recipients and subrecipients using grant
funds on these eligible activities must follow the written standards
established by the Continuum of Care in Sec. 578.7(a)(9)(v), and the
recordkeeping requirements set for the Emergency Solutions Grants
program rule.
Program Requirements (Subpart F)
All recipients of Continuum of Care funding must comply with the
program regulations and the requirements of the NOFA issued annually by
HUD.
Matching. The HEARTH Act allows for a new, simplified match
requirement. All eligible funding costs except leasing must be matched
with no less than a 25 percent cash or in-kind match. The interim rule
clarifies that the match must be provided for the entire grant, except
that recipients that are UFAs or are the sole recipient for the
Continuum may provide the match on a Continuum-wide basis.
For in-kind match, the governmentwide grant requirements of HUD's
regulations in 24 CFR 84.23 (for private nonprofit organizations) and
85.24 (for governments) apply. The regulations in 24 CFR parts 84 and
85 establish uniform administrative requirements for HUD grants. The
requirements of 24 CFR part 84 apply to subrecipients that are private
nonprofit organizations. The requirements of 24 CFR part 85 apply to
the recipient and subrecipients that are units of general purpose local
government. The match requirement in 24 CFR 84.23 and in 24 CFR 85.24
applies to administration funds, as well as Continuum of Care planning
costs and UFA's financial management costs. All match must be spent on
eligible activities as required under subpart D of this interim rule,
except that recipients and subrecipients in HPCs may use match on
eligible activities described under Sec. 578.71.
General operations. Recipients of grant funds must provide housing
or services that comply with all applicable State and local housing
codes, licensing requirements, and any other requirements in the
project's jurisdiction. In addition, this interim rule clarifies that
recipients must abide by housing quality standards and suitable
dwelling size. Recipients must also assess supportive services on an
ongoing basis, have residential supervision, and provide for
participation of homeless individuals as required under section 426(g)
of the McKinney-Vento Act.
Specific request for comment. With respect to housing quality
standards, HUD includes in this rule the longstanding requirement from
the Shelter Plus Care program that recipients or subrecipients, prior
to providing assistance on behalf of a program participant, must
physically inspect each unit to assure that the unit meets housing
quality standards. This requirement is designed to ensure that program
participants are placed in housing that is suitable for living.
Additionally, these requirements are consistent with HUD's physical
inspection requirements in its other mainstream rental assistance
programs. Notwithstanding that this is a longstanding requirement, HUD
welcomes comment on alternatives to inspection of each unit that may be
less burdensome but ensure that the housing provided to a program
participant is decent, safe, and sanitary.
Under Section 578.75, General Operations, subsection (h), entitled
``Supportive Service Agreements,'' states that recipients and
subrecipients may require program participants to take part in
supportive services so long as they are not disability-related
services, provided through the project as a condition of continued
participation in the program. Examples of disability-related services
include, but are not limited to, mental health services, outpatient
health services, and provision of medication, which are provided to a
person with a disability to address a condition caused by the
disability.
This provision further states that if the purpose of the project is
to provide substance abuse treatment services, recipients and
subrecipients may require program participants to take part in such
services as a condition of continued participation in the program. For
example, if a Continuum of Care recipient operates a transitional
housing program with substance abuse treatment
[[Page 45436]]
services, the recipient may require program participants to participate
in those services. By contrast, in a program that offers services but
whose purpose is not substance abuse treatment, a recipient may not
require a person who is an alcoholic, for example, to sign a supportive
service agreement at initial occupancy stating that he or she will
participate in substance abuse treatment services as a condition of
occupancy. All program participants must, however, meet all terms and
conditions of tenancy, including lease requirements. If, as a result of
a person's behavior stemming from substance use, a person violates the
terms of the lease, a recipient may consider requiring participation in
services or any other action necessary in order for such a person to
successfully meet the requirements of tenancy.
Finally, the interim rule clarifies that in units where the
qualifying member of the household has died, or has been incarcerated
or institutionalized for more than 90 days, assistance may continue
until the expiration of the lease in effect at the time of the
qualifying member's death, incarceration, or institutionalization.
Displacement, relocation, and acquisition. All recipients must
ensure that they have taken all reasonable steps to minimize the
displacement of persons as a result of projects assisted under this
part. This section of the interim rule is substantially revised from
the previous programs to increase clarity and comprehension of the
directions to recipients and subrecipients in the use of grant funds.
Timeliness standards. Recipients must initiate approved activities
and projects promptly. Recipients of funds for rehabilitation and new
construction must begin construction activities within 9 months of the
signing of the grant, and such activities must be completed within 24
months. HUD is providing these requirements to assist communities in
meeting the obligation and expenditure deadline historically imposed by
the annual HUD appropriations act. HUD may reduce a grant term to a
term of one year if implementation delays reduce the amount of funds
that can be used during the original grant term.
Limitation on use of funds. Recipients of funds provided under this
part must abide by any limitations that apply to the use of such funds,
such as use of funds for explicitly religious activities.
The limitation on use of funds also addresses limitation on uses
where religious activities may be concerned. It is HUD's position that
faith-based organizations are able to compete for HUD funds and
participate in HUD programs on an equal footing with other
organizations; that no group of applicants competing for HUD funds
should be subject, as a matter of discretion, to greater or fewer
requirements than other organizations solely because of their religious
character or affiliation, or, alternatively, the absence of religious
character or affiliation. HUD's general principles regarding the equal
participation of such organizations in its programs are codified at 24
CFR 5.109. Program-specific requirements governing faith-based
activities are codified in the regulations for the individual HUD
programs. (See, for example, 24 CFR 574.300(c), 24 CFR 582.115(c), and
24 CFR 583.150(b).)
HUD's equal participation regulations were prompted by Executive
Order 13279, Equal Protection of the Laws for Faith-Based and Community
Organizations, issued by President Bush on December 12, 2002, and
published in the Federal Register on December 16, 2002 (67 FR 77141).
Executive Order 13279 set forth principles and policymaking criteria to
guide federal agencies in ensuring the equal protection of the laws for
faith-based and community organizations. Executive Order 13279 was
amended by Executive Order 13559 (Fundamental Principles and
Policymaking Criteria for Partnerships With Faith-Based and Other
Neighborhood Organizations), issued by President Obama on November 17,
2010, and published in the Federal Register on November 22, 2010 (75 FR
71319).
Executive Order 13559 expands on the equal participation principles
provided in Executive Order 13279 to strengthen the capacity of faith-
based and other neighborhood organizations to deliver services
effectively and ensure the equal treatment of program beneficiaries.
Executive Order 13559 reiterates a key principle underlying
participation of faith-based organizations in federally funded
activities and that is that faith-based organizations be eligible to
compete for federal financial assistance used to support social service
programs and to participate fully in social service programs supported
with federal financial assistance without impairing their independence,
autonomy, expression outside the programs in question, or religious
character.
With respect to program beneficiaries, the Executive Order states
that organizations, in providing services supported in whole or in part
with federal financial assistance, and in their outreach activities
related to such services, should not be allowed to discriminate against
current or prospective program beneficiaries on the basis of religion,
a religious belief, a refusal to hold a religious belief, or a refusal
to attend or participate in a religious practice. The Executive Order
directs that organizations that engage in explicitly religious
activities (including activities that involve overt religious content
such as worship, religious instruction, or proselytization) must
perform such activities and offer such services outside of programs
that are supported with direct federal financial assistance (including
through prime awards or subawards), separately in time or location from
any such programs or services supported with direct federal financial
assistance, and participation in any such explicitly religious
activities must be voluntary for the beneficiaries of the social
service program supported with such federal financial assistance. For
purposes of greater clarity and comprehensibility, the Executive Order
uses the term ``explicitly religious'' in lieu of ``inherently
religious.'' The Executive Order further directs that if a beneficiary
or prospective beneficiary of a social service program supported by
federal financial assistance objects to the religious character of an
organization that provides services under the program, that
organization shall, within a reasonable time after the date of the
objection, refer the beneficiary to an alternative provider.
Executive Order 13559 provides for the establishment of an
Interagency Working Group on Faith-Based and Other Neighborhood
Partnerships (Working Group) to review and evaluate existing
regulations, guidance documents, and policies, and directs the OMB to
issue guidance to agencies on uniform implementation following receipt
of the Working Group's report. On April 27, 2012, the Working Group
issued its report, recommending a model set of regulations and guidance
for agencies to adopt.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ The report is available at: https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/uploads/finalfaithbasedworkinggroupreport.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
HUD intends to wait for OMB guidance before initiating any
rulemaking directed to broader changes to HUD's existing faith-based
regulations, to ensure consistency with faith-based regulations of
other federal agencies. However, HUD has revised its regulatory
provisions governing faith-based activities to incorporate the
principles of Executive Order 13559 pertaining to equal treatment of
program beneficiaries and to adopt terminology, such as ``explicitly
religious'' and ``overt
[[Page 45437]]
religious content,'' that offers greater clarity to the limitations
placed on faith-based organizations when using federal funds for their
supportive services. Additionally, HUD is putting in place through this
rulemaking the provision of Executive Order 13559 that directs the
referral to alternative providers. Executive Order 13559 provides that
if a beneficiary or prospective beneficiary of a social service program
supported by federal financial assistance objects to the religious
character of an organization that provides services under the program,
that organization shall, within a reasonable time frame after the date
of the objection, refer the beneficiary to an alternative provider.
While HUD will benefit from OMB guidance on other provisions of the
Executive Order, specifically those which the Working Group is charged
to provide recommendations, the ``referral'' provision of the Executive
Order is one that HUD believes it can immediately put in place. HUD
may, following receipt of public comment and further consideration of
this issue, revise how recipients and subrecipients document the
referral to other providers when beneficiaries may assert objections to
the original provider. For now, HUD is requiring that any objections
and any referrals be documented in accordance with the recordkeeping
provisions of Sec. 578.013.
This section of the interim rule also contains limitations on the
types of eligible assistance that may not be combined in a single
structure or housing unit. As the Continuum of Care substantially
increases the types of assistance that may be combined in a project
from previous programs, HUD has established standards in this section
to provide recipients with clarity about the types of activities that
may not be carried out in a single structure or housing unit.
Termination of assistance. The interim rule provides that a
recipient may terminate assistance to a participant who violates
program requirements or conditions of occupancy. The recipient must
provide a formal process that recognizes the due process of law.
Recipients may resume assistance to a participant whose assistance has
been terminated.
Recipients that are providing permanent supportive housing for
hard-to-house populations of homeless persons must exercise judgment
and examine all circumstances in determining whether termination is
appropriate. Under this interim rule, HUD has determined that a
participant's assistance should be terminated only in the most severe
cases. HUD is carrying over this requirement from the Shelter Plus Care
program.
Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity requirements. The Continuum of
Care, as well as its members and subrecipients, are required to comply
with applicable civil rights laws. Section 578.93, addressing
nondiscrimination and equal opportunity requirements, is provided to
offer greater direction to recipients and subrecipients on the use of
grant funds. Section 578.93(a) states that the nondiscrimination and
equal opportunity requirements set forth in 24 CFR 5.105(a) apply. This
includes, but is not limited to, the Fair Housing Act, Title VI of the
Civil Rights Act of 1964, Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973
(Section 504), and title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act.
Section 578.93(b) explains when recipients and subrecipients may
exclusively serve a particular subpopulation in transitional or
permanent housing. As part of these requirements, recipients must also
administer programs and activities receiving federal financial
assistance in the most integrated setting appropriate to the needs of
qualified individuals with disabilities. This ``integration mandate''
requires that HUD-funded programs or activities enable individuals with
disabilities to interact with nondisabled persons to the fullest extent
possible. In reviewing requests for funding through the Continuum of
Care NOFA, HUD will be considering each recipient's proposals to
provide integrated housing to individuals with disabilities.
There are certain situations in which a recipient or subrecipient
may limit housing to a specific subpopulation, so long as admission
does not discriminate against any protected class, as well as instances
where recipients or subrecipients may limit admission or provide a
preference to certain subpopulations of homeless persons and families
who need the specialized services provided in the housing. For example,
Sec. 578.93(b)(2) states that the housing may be limited to homeless
veterans, so long as admission is not denied based on any membership in
a protected class; e.g., homeless veterans with families must be
admitted. Similarly, housing may be limited to domestic violence
victims and their families or persons who are at risk of
institutionalization, so long as admission is not denied based on any
membership in a protected class.
Section 578.93(b)(3) states that housing may be limited to families
with children.
Section 578.93(b)(1) states that, in consideration of personal
privacy, housing may only be limited to a single sex when such housing
consists of a single structure with shared bedrooms or bathing
facilities such that the considerations of personal privacy and the
physical limitations of the configuration of the housing make it
appropriate for the housing to be limited to one sex.
Further, Sec. Sec. 578.93(b)(4) and (5) clearly outline instances
when sex offenders or violent offenders may be excluded from housing,
and when projects providing sober housing may exclude persons.
HUD's Section 504 regulations permit housing funded under a
particular program to be reserved for persons with a specific
disability when a federal statute or executive order specifically
authorizes such a limitation. Section 578.93(b)(6) states that if the
housing is assisted with funds under a federal program that is limited
by federal statute or executive order to a specific subpopulation, the
housing may be limited to that subpopulation.
Section 578.93(b)(7) provides clarification to recipients of funds
under this part as to when a project can limit admission to a specific
subpopulation of homeless individuals and families based on the service
package offered in the project. To help recipients better understand
these requirements, the following paragraphs provide a detailed
explanation of the regulatory provision, along with a few examples.
Section 578.93(b)(7) states that recipients may limit admission to
or provide a preference for the housing to subpopulations of homeless
persons and families who need the specialized supportive services that
are provided in the housing. The regulation contains the following
examples: Substance abuse addiction treatment, domestic violence
services, or a high-intensity package designed to meet the needs of
hard-to-reach homeless persons. However, Sec. 578.93(b)(7) further
states that while the housing may offer services for a particular type
of disability, no otherwise eligible individual with a disability, or
family that includes an individual with a disability, who may benefit
from the services provided may be excluded on the grounds that they do
not have a particular disability. Below are general examples to offer
guidance on this subsection. Please note that these examples are
nonexhaustive, but emphasize that the proper focus is on the services
available as part of the Continuum of Care project as opposed to a
person's category or subcategory of disability. While these general
principles are offered to help clarify this
[[Page 45438]]
section, a change in the factual scenario may change the analysis.
One clarifying example is as follows. A private, nonprofit
organization or a local government applies for and receives a new grant
under this part to provide project-based rental assistance and
services, including case management, intensive therapy provided by a
psychiatrist, and medication management. The recipient or subrecipient
may establish a preference for individuals who are chronically
homeless. When filling an opening in the housing, the recipient or
subrecipient may target chronically homeless individuals or families,
but if there are no such individuals or families either on a waiting
list or applying for entrance to the program, the recipient or
subrecipient cannot deny occupancy to individuals or families who apply
for entrance into the program and who may benefit from the services
provided. When filling a vacancy in the housing, the recipient or
subrecipient, if presented with two otherwise eligible persons, one who
is chronically homeless and one who is not, may give a preference to
the chronically homeless individual.
By comparison, Sec. 578.93(b)(6) addresses situations where
Continuum of Care funds are combined with HUD funding for housing that
may be restricted to a specific disability. For example, if Continuum
of Care funds for a specific project are combined with construction or
rehabilitation funding for housing from the Housing Opportunities for
People With AIDS program, the program may limit eligibility for the
project to persons with HIV/AIDS and their families. An individual or a
family that includes an individual with a disability may be denied
occupancy if the individual or at least one member of the family does
not have HIV/AIDS.
In another example, a private, nonprofit organization applies for
and receives Continuum of Care funds from a local governmental entity
to rehabilitate a five-unit building, and provides services including
assistance with daily living and mental health services. While the
nonprofit organization intends to target and advertise the project as
offering services for persons with developmental disabilities, an
individual with a severe psychiatric disability who does not have a
developmental disability but who can benefit from these services cannot
be denied.
Section 578.93(e) incorporates the ``preventing involuntary family
separation'' requirement set forth in Section 404 of the McKinney-Veto
Act into this interim rule. This provision clarifies, especially for
projects where the current policy is to deny the admittance of a boy
under the age of 18, that denying admittance to a project based on age
and gender is no longer permissible. HUD encourages Continuums of Care
to use their centralized or coordinated assessment systems to find
appropriate shelter or housing for families with male children under
the age of 18.
Specific request for comment. HUD specifically seeks comments from
Continuum of Care-funded recipients on this requirement. HUD invites
comments about the difficulty that recipients are going to experience,
if any, in implementing this requirement. In addition to comments about
the difficulties, HUD invites communities that have already implemented
this requirement locally to describe their methods for use in HUD's
technical assistance materials and for posting on the HUD Homeless
Resource Exchange.
Other standards. In addition to the program requirements described
in this preamble, the interim rule sets forth other program
requirements by which all recipients of grant funds must abide. These
include a limitation on the use of grant funds to serve persons defined
as homeless under other federal laws, conflicts of interest standards,
and standards for identifying uses of program income.
Additionally, recipients are required to follow other federal
requirements contained in this interim rule under Sec. 578.99. These
include compliance with such federal requirements as the Coastal
Barriers Resources Act, OMB Circulars, HUD's Lead-Based Paint
regulations, and audit requirements. The wording of these requirements
has been substantially revised from previous programs, with the
objective being to increase clarity and comprehension of the directions
to recipients and subrecipients in the use of grant funds.
Administration (Subpart G)
Technical assistance. The purpose of technical assistance under the
Continuum of Care program is to increase the effectiveness with which
Continuums of Care, eligible applicants, recipients, subrecipients, and
UFAs implement and administer their Continuum of Care planning process.
Technical assistance will also improve the capacity to prepare
applications, and prevent the separation of families in projects funded
under the Emergency Solutions Grants, Continuum of Care, and Rural
Housing Stability Assistance programs. Under this interim rule,
technical assistance means the transfer of skills and knowledge to
entities that may need, but do not possess, such skills and knowledge.
The assistance may include written information, such as papers,
manuals, guides, and brochures; person-to-person exchanges; and
training and related costs.
Therefore, as needed, HUD may advertise and competitively select
providers to deliver technical assistance. HUD may enter into
contracts, grants, or cooperative agreements to implement the technical
assistance. HUD may also enter into agreements with other federal
agencies when awarding technical assistance funds.
Recordkeeping requirements. Grant recipients under the Supportive
Housing Program and the Shelter Plus Care program have always been
required to show compliance with regulations through appropriate
records. However, the existing regulations are not specific about the
records to be maintained. The interim rule for the Continuum of Care
program elaborates upon the recordkeeping requirements to provide
sufficient notice and clarify the documentation that HUD requires for
assessing compliance with the program requirements. The recordkeeping
requirements for documenting homeless status were published in the
December 5, 2011, Defining Homeless final rule. Because these
recordkeeping requirements already went through a 60-day comment
period, HUD is not seeking further comment on these requirements.
Additionally, recordkeeping requirements with similar levels of
specificity apply to documentation of ``at risk of homelessness'' and
these requirements can be found in Sec. 576.500(c) of the Emergency
Solutions Grants program interim rule published on December 5, 2011.
Because the documentation requirements pertaining to ``at risk of
homelessness'' were already subject to a 60-day public comment period,
HUD is not seeking additional comment on these requirements. Further
requirements are modeled after the recordkeeping requirements for the
HOME Investment Partnerships Program (24 CFR 92.508) and other HUD
regulations.
Included along with these changes are new or expanded requirements
regarding confidentiality, rights of access to records, record
retention periods, and reporting requirements. Most significantly, to
protect the safety and privacy of all program participants, the
Continuum of Care rule broadens the program's confidentiality
requirements. The McKinney-Vento Act requires only procedures to ensure
the
[[Page 45439]]
confidentiality of records pertaining to any individual provided family
violence prevention or treatment services under this program. The
interim rule requires written procedures to ensure the security and
confidentiality of all records containing personally identifying
information of any individual or family who applies for and/or receives
Continuum of Care assistance.
Grant and project changes. The interim rule provides that
recipients of grants may not make any significant changes to use of
grant funds without prior HUD approval, evidenced by a grant amendment
signed by HUD and the recipient. The interim rule provides separate
standards for determining when a grant amendment is required for
Continuums having only one recipient, including UFAs, and Continuums
having more than one recipient. Additionally, the interim rule provides
contingencies that must be met before HUD will approve the grant
amendment. These contingencies are necessary to ensure that recipients
meet the capacity requirements established in the NOFA and to ensure
that eligible persons within the geographic area are better served and,
since the Continuum of Care program is a competitive program, that the
priorities established under the NOFA continue to be met. Any changes
to an approved grant or project that do not require a grant amendment,
as set forth in this section, must be fully documented in the
recipient's or subrecipient's records.
Sanctions. The interim rule establishes sanctions based on existing
regulations and strengthens the enforcement procedures and array of
remedial actions and sanctions for recipients and subrecipients of
Continuum of Care funds. These revisions draw from the requirements at
24 CFR 85.43 and other HUD program regulations.
Close-out. The interim rule provides that grants must be closed out
at the end of their grant term if recipients are not seeking renewal.
Section 578.109 of this interim rule specifies the actions that must be
taken after the closeout, including grantee submission of financial,
final performance, or other reports required by HUD within 90 days of
the end of the grant term. Any unused funds must be deobligated and
returned to HUD.
The interim rule stipulates, for grants seeking renewal, that
failure to submit final performance reports, or other reports required
by HUD within 90 days, may cause renewal funds to be withdrawn and
grant funds expended on the renewal grant to be repaid.
III. Regulations for HUD Homeless Assistance Programs Existing Prior to
Enactment of HEARTH Act
Because grants are still being administered under the Shelter Plus
Care program and the Supportive Housing program, the regulations for
these programs in 24 CFR parts 582, and 583, respectively, will remain
in the Code of Federal Regulations for the time being. When no more, or
very few, grants remain under these programs, HUD will remove the
regulations in these parts by a separate rule (if no grants exist) or
will replace them with a savings clause, which will continue to govern
grant agreements executed prior to the effective date of the HEARTH Act
regulations.
IV. Conforming Regulations
In addition to establishing the new regulations for the Continuum
of Care program, HUD is amending the following regulations, which
reference the Shelter Plus Care Program and the Supportive Housing
Program, to include reference to the Continuum of Care program. These
regulations are the regulations pertaining to: (1) Family Income and
Family Payment; Occupancy Requirements for Section 8 and Public
Housing, Other HUD-Assisted Housing Serving Persons with Disabilities,
and Section 8 Project-Based Assistance, the regulations for which are
in 24 CFR part 5, subpart F, specifically, Sec. 5.601 (Purpose and
Applicability), paragraphs (d) and (e) of this section; Sec. 5.603
(Definitions), specifically the definition of ``Responsible Entity;''
Sec. 5.617 (Self-Sufficiency Incentives for Persons with
Disabilities--Disallowance of Increase in Annual Income), paragraph (a)
of this section; (2) Environmental Review Responsibilities for Entities
Assuming HUD Environmental Responsibilities, the regulations for which
are in 24 CFR part 58, specifically Sec. 58.1 (Purpose and
Applicability), paragraph (b)(3) of this section; and (3) the
Consolidated Submissions for Community Planning and Development
Programs, the regulations for which are in 24 CFR part 91,
specifically, Sec. 91.2 (Applicability), paragraph (b) of this
section.
V. Justification for Interim Rulemaking
In accordance with its regulations on rulemaking at 24 CFR part 10,
HUD generally publishes its rules for advance public comment.\2\ Notice
and public procedures may be omitted, however, if HUD determines that,
in a particular case or class of cases, notice and public comment
procedure are ``impracticable, unnecessary, or contrary to the public
interest.'' (See 24 CFR 10.1.)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\ The Administrative Procedure Act (5 U.S.C. Subchapter II)
(APA), which governs federal rulemaking, provides in section 553(a)
that matters involving a military or foreign affairs function of the
United States or a matter relating to federal agency management or
personnel or to public property, loans, grants, benefits, or
contracts are exempt from the advance notice and public comment
requirement of sections 553(b) and (c) of the APA. In its
regulations in 24 CFR 10.1, HUD has waived the exemption for advance
notice and public comment for matters that relate to public
property, loans, grants, benefits, or contracts, and has committed
to undertake notice and comment rulemaking for these matters.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In this case, HUD has determined that it would be contrary to the
public interest to delay promulgation of the regulations for the
Continuum of Care program.\3\ Congress has provided funding for this
new program in the Consolidated and Further Continuing Appropriations
Act, 2012 (Pub. L. 112-55, approved November 18, 2011) (FY 2012
Appropriations Act). The FY 2012 Appropriations Act, under the account
for Homeless Assistance Grants, appropriates not less than $1.593
billion for the Continuum of Care and Rural Housing Stability programs.
While many federal programs, including HUD programs, received a
reduction in funding in the FY 2012 Appropriations Act, Congress
increased funding for HUD's homeless assistance grants, including the
Continuum of Care program. Additionally, the Conference Report
accompanying the FY 2012 Appropriations Act (House Report 112-284)
states in relevant part, as follows: ``The conferees express concern
that HUD continued to implement pre-HEARTH grant programs in FY 2011,
due to a lack of regulations. The conferees direct HUD to publish at
least interim guidelines for the Emergency Solutions Grants and
Continuum of Care programs this fiscal year and to implement the new
grant programs as soon as possible so that the updated policies and
practices in HEARTH can begin to govern the delivery of homeless
assistance funding.'' (See Conf. Rpt. at page 319. Emphasis added.)
Given this congressional direction, HUD is issuing this rule providing
for regulations for the Continuum of Care program as an interim rule.
Having interim regulations in place will allow HUD to move forward in
making FY 2012 funds available to grantees, and avoid a significant
delay that would result from issuance, first, of a proposed rule. As
[[Page 45440]]
has been discussed in this preamble, the foundation for the Continuum
of Care regulations is the criteria and requirements provided in NOFAs
for the Continuum of Care Homeless Assistance Grants Competition
program, which HUD has funded for more than 10 years. Through the
Continuum of Care Homeless Assistance Grants Competition program, HUD
provided funding for the Supportive Housing program, the Shelter Plus
Care program, and the Section 8 Moderate Rehabilitation Single Room
Occupancy program. The HEARTH Act consolidated these three competitive
programs into the statutorily established Continuum of Care program,
which was established as a single grant program. Interim regulations
will provide certainty with respect to funding requirements and
eligible expenditures for FY 2012, and the public comment solicited
through this interim rule will help inform the public procedures that
HUD is contemplating in its regulations in 24 CFR part 10, and this
public comment, in turn, will inform the final rule that will follow
this interim rule and govern the funding years following FY 2012.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\ Although HUD's regulation in 24 CFR 10.1 provide that HUD
will involve public participation in its rulemaking, this regulation
also provides that notice and public procedure will be omitted if
HUD determines in a particular case or class of cases that notice
and public procedure are impracticable, unnecessary, or contrary to
the public interest.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For the reasons stated above, HUD is issuing this rule to take
immediate effect, but welcomes all comments on this interim rule and
all comments will be taken into consideration in the development of the
final rule.
VI. Findings and Certifications
Regulatory Review--Executive Orders 12866 and 13563
Under Executive Order 12866 (Regulatory Planning and Review), a
determination must be made whether a regulatory action is significant
and, therefore, subject to review by the Office of Management and
Budget (OMB) in accordance with the requirements of the order.
Executive Order 13563 (Improving Regulations and Regulatory Review)
directs executive agencies to analyze regulations that are ``outmoded,
ineffective, insufficient, or excessively burdensome, and to modify,
streamline, expand, or repeal them in accordance with what has been
learned.'' Executive Order 13563 also directs that, where relevant,
feasible, and consistent with regulatory objectives, and to the extent
permitted by law, agencies are to identify and consider regulatory
approaches that reduce burdens and maintain flexibility and freedom of
choice for the public. This rule was determined to be a ``significant
regulatory action,'' as defined in section 3(f) of Executive Order
12866 (although not an economically significant regulatory action, as
provided under section 3(f)(1) of the Executive Order).
As has been discussed in this preamble, this interim rule
establishes the regulations for the Continuum of Care program, which is
the HEARTH Act's codification of HUD's long-standing Continuum of Care
planning process. The HEARTH Act not only codified in law the planning
system known as Continuum of Care, but consolidated the three existing
competitive homeless assistance grant programs (Supportive Housing,
Shelter Plus Care, and Single Room Occupancy) into the single grant
program known as the Continuum of Care program. As discussed in the
preceding section of the preamble, HUD funded these three programs for
more than 10 years through a NOFA, which was titled the Continuum of
Care Homeless Assistance Grants Competition Program. However, the
funding of the three competitive grant programs, although done through
a single NOFA, delineated the different statutes and regulations that
governed each of the three programs (see, for example, HUD's 2008
Continuum of Care NOFA at 73 FR 398450, specifically page 39845). In
consolidating these three competitive programs into a single grant
program, the HEARTH Act achieves the administrative efficiency that HUD
strived to achieve to the extent possible, through its administrative
establishment of the Continuum of Care planning process. To the extent
permitted by the HEARTH Act and where feasible, the regulations build-
in flexibility for grantees, based on experience in administering the
Continuum of Care program to date. Given the transition from
administrative operation of the Continuum of Care program to statutory
operation of the Continuum of Care program, this interim rule would
also have no discernible impact upon the economy.
The docket file is available for public inspection in the
Regulations Division, Office of the General Counsel, Room 10276, 451
7th Street SW., Washington, DC 20410-0500. Due to security measures at
the HUD Headquarters building, please schedule an appointment to review
the docket file by calling the Regulations Division at 202-708-3055
(this is not a toll-free number). Individuals with speech or hearing
impairments may access this number via TTY by calling the Federal Relay
Service at 800-877-8339.
Environmental Impact
A Finding of No Significant Impact (FONSI) with respect to the
environment has been made in accordance with HUD regulations at 24 CFR
part 50, which implement section 102(2)(C) of the National
Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4332(2)(C)). The Finding of
No Significant Impact is available for public inspection between the
hours of 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. weekdays in the Regulations Division, Office
of General Counsel, Department of Housing and Urban Development, 451
7th Street SW., Room 10276, Washington, DC 20410-0500. Due to security
measures at the HUD Headquarters building, please schedule an
appointment to review the FONSI by calling the Regulations Division at
202-708-3055 (this is not a toll-free number). Individuals with speech
or hearing impairments may access this number via TTY by calling the
Federal Relay Service at 800-877-8339.
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act
The Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 (2 U.S.C. 1531-1538)
(UMRA) establishes requirements for federal agencies to assess the
effects of their regulatory actions on State, local, and tribal
governments and on the private sector. This interim rule does not
impose a federal mandate on any State, local, or tribal government, or
on the private sector, within the meaning of UMRA.
Regulatory Flexibility Act
The Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.) generally
requires an agency to conduct a regulatory flexibility analysis of any
rule subject to notice and comment rulemaking requirements, unless the
agency certifies that the rule will not have a significant economic
impact on a substantial number of small entities. This rule solely
addresses the allocation and use of grant funds under the new McKinney-
Vento Act homeless assistance programs, as consolidated and amended by
the HEARTH Act. As discussed in the preamble, the majority of the
regulatory provisions proposed by this rule track the regulatory
provisions of the Continuum of Care program, with which prospective
recipients of the Supportive Housing program and the Shelter Plus Care
program are familiar. Accordingly, the program requirements should
raise minimal issues because applicants and grantees are familiar with
these requirements, and in response to HUD's solicitations to them on
the burden of the requirements for the Supportive Housing program and
the Shelter Plus Care program, grantees have not advised that such
requirements are burdensome. Therefore, HUD has determined that this
rule would not
[[Page 45441]]
have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small
entities.
Notwithstanding HUD's determination that this rule will not have a
significant effect on a substantial number of small entities, HUD
specifically invites comments regarding any less burdensome
alternatives to this rule that will meet HUD's objectives as described
in this preamble.
Executive Order 13132, Federalism
Executive Order 13132 (entitled ``Federalism'') prohibits an agency
from publishing any rule that has federalism implications if the rule
either imposes substantial direct compliance costs on State and local
governments and is not required by statute, or the rule preempts State
law, unless the agency meets the consultation and funding requirements
of section 6 of the Executive Order. This final rule does not have
federalism implications and does not impose substantial direct
compliance costs on State and local governments nor preempts State law
within the meaning of the Executive Order.
Paperwork Reduction Act
The information collection requirements contained in this interim
rule have been submitted to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB)
under the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (44 U.S.C. 3501-3520). In
accordance with the Paperwork Reduction Act, an agency may not conduct
or sponsor, and a person is not required to respond to, a collection of
information, unless the collection displays a currently valid OMB
control number.
The burden of the information collections in this interim rule is
estimated as follows:
Reporting and Recordkeeping Burden
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Response
Information collection Number of frequency Total annual Burden hours Total annual
respondents (average) responses per response hours
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sec. 578.5(a) Establishing 450 1 450 8.0 3,600
the CoC.......................
Sec. 578.5(b) Establishing 450 1 450 5.0 2,250
the Board.....................
Sec. 578.7(a)(1) Hold CoC 450 2 900 4.0 3,600
Meetings......................
Sec. 578.7(a)(2) Invitation 450 1 450 1.0 450
for New Members...............
Sec. 578.7(a)(4) Appoint 450 2 900 0.5 450
committees....................
Sec. 578.7(a)(5) Governance 450 1 450 7.0 3,150
charter.......................
Sec. 578.7(a)(6) and (7) 450 4 450 9.0 4,050
Monitor performance and
evaluation....................
Sec. 578.7(a)(8) Centralized 450 1 450 8.0 3,600
or coordinated assessment
system........................
Sec. 578.7(a)(9) Written 450 1 450 5.0 2,250
standards.....................
Sec. 578.7(b) Designate HMIS. 450 1 450 10.0 4,500
Sec. 578.9 Application for 450 1 450 180.0 81,000
funds.........................
Sec. 578.11(c) Develop CoC 450 1 450 9.0 4,050
plan..........................
Sec. 578.21(c) Satisfying 8,000 1 8,000 4.0 32,000
conditions....................
Sec. 578.23 Executing grant 8,000 1 8,000 1.0 8,000
agreements....................
Sec. 578.35(b) Appeal--solo.. 10 1 10 4.0 40
Sec. 578.35(c) Appeal--denied 15 1 15 1.0 15
or decreased funding..........
Sec. 578.35(d) Appeal-- 10 1 10 5.0 50
competing CoC.................
Sec. 578.35(e) Appeal-- 5 1 5 2.0 10
Consolidated Plan
certification.................
Sec. 578.49(a)--Leasing 5 1 5 1.5 7.5
exceptions....................
Sec. 578.65 HPC Standards.... 20 1 20 10.0 200
Sec. 578.75(a)(1) State and 7,000 1 7,000 0.5 3,500
local requirements--
appropriate service provision.
Sec. 578.75(a)(1) State and 20 1 20 3.0 60
local requirements--housing
codes.........................
Sec. 578.75(b) Housing 72,800 2 145,600 1.0 145,600
quality standards.............
Sec. 578.75(b) Suitable 72,800 2 145,600 0.08 11,648
dwelling size.................
Sec. 578.75(c) Meals......... 70,720 1 70,720 0.5 35,360
Sec. 578.75(e) Ongoing 8,000 1 8,000 1.5 12,000
assessment of supportive
services......................
Sec. 578.75(f) Residential 6,600 3 19,800 0.75 14,850
supervision...................
Sec. 578.75(g) Participation 11,500 1 11,500 1.0 11,500
of homeless individuals.......
Sec. 578.75(h) Supportive 3,000 100 30,000 0.5 15,000
service agreements............
Sec. 578.77(a) Signed leases/ 104,000 2 208,000 1.0 208,000
occupancy agreements..........
Sec. 578.77(b) Calculating 1,840 200 368,000 0.75 276,000
occupancy charges.............
Sec. 578.77(c) Calculating 2,000 200 400,000 0.75 300,000
rent..........................
Sec. 578.81(a) Use 20 1 20 0.5 10
restriction...................
Sec. 578.91(a) Termination of 400 1 400 4.00 1,600
assistance....................
Sec. 578.91(b) Due process 4,500 1 4,500 3.0 13,500
for termination of assistance.
Sec. 578.95(d)--Conflict-of- 10 1 10 3.0 30
Interest exceptions...........
Sec. 578.103(a)(3) 300,000 1 300,000 0.25 75,000
Documenting homelessness......
Sec. 578.103(a)(4) 10,000 1 10,000 0.25 2,500
Documenting at risk of
homelessness..................
Sec. 578.103(a)(5) 200 1 200 0.5 100
Documenting imminent threat of
harm..........................
Sec. 578.103(a)(7) 350,000 6 2,100,000 0.25 525,000
Documenting program
participant records...........
Sec. 578.103(a)(7) 8,000 12 96,000 1.0 96,000
Documenting case management...
Sec. 578.103(a)(13) 8,000 1 8,000 1.0 8,000
Documenting faith-based
activities....................
Sec. 578.103(b) 11,500 1 11,500 1.0 11,500
Confidentiality procedures....
Sec. 578.105(a) Grant/project 20 2 40 2.0 80
changes--UFAs.................
Sec. 578.105(b) Grant/project 800 1 800 2.0 1,600
changes--multiple project
applicants....................
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total...................... .............. ............... .............. .............. 1,921,710.5
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[[Page 45442]]
In accordance with 5 CFR 1320.8(d)(1), HUD is soliciting comments
from members of the public and affected agencies concerning this
collection of information to:
(1) Evaluate whether the proposed collection of information is
necessary for the proper performance of the functions HUD, including
whether the information will have practical utility;
(2) Evaluate the accuracy of HUD's estimate of the burden of the
proposed collection of information;
(3) Enhance the quality, utility, and clarity of the information to
be collected; and
(4) Minimize the burden of the collection of information on those
who are to respond, including through the use of appropriate automated
collection techniques or other forms of information technology; e.g.,
permitting electronic submission of responses.
Interested persons are invited to submit comments regarding the
information collection requirements in this rule. Comments must refer
to the proposal by name and docket number (FR-5476-I-01) and be sent
to: HUD Desk Officer, Office of Management and Budget, New Executive
Office Building, Washington, DC 20503, Fax: (202) 395-6947, and Reports
Liaison Officer, Office of the Assistant Secretary for Community
Planning and Development, Department of Housing and Urban Development,
451 Seventh Street SW., Room 7233, Washington, DC 20410-7000.
Interested persons may submit comments regarding the information
collection requirements electronically through the Federal eRulemaking
Portal at https://www.regulations.gov. HUD strongly encourages
commenters to submit comments electronically. Electronic submission of
comments allows the commenter maximum time to prepare and submit a
comment, ensures timely receipt by HUD, and enables HUD to make them
immediately available to the public. Comments submitted electronically
through the https://www.regulations.gov Web site can be viewed by other
commenters and interested members of the public. Commenters should
follow the instructions provided on that site to submit comments
electronically.
List of Subjects in 24 CFR Part 578
Community facilities, Continuum of Care, Emergency solutions
grants, Grant programs--housing and community development, Grant
program--social programs, Homeless, Rural housing, Reporting and
recordkeeping requirements, Supportive housing programs-- housing and
community development, Supportive services.
Accordingly, for the reasons described in the preamble, HUD adds
part 578 to subchapter C of chapter V of subtitle B of 24 CFR to read
as follows:
PART 578--CONTINUUM OF CARE PROGRAM
Subpart A--General Provisions
Sec.
578.1 Purpose and scope.
578.3 Definitions.
Subpart B--Establishing and Operating a Continuum of Care
578.5 Establishing the Continuum of Care.
578.7 Responsibilities of the Continuum of Care.
578.9 Preparing an application for funds.
578.11 Unified Funding Agency.
578.13 Remedial action.
Subpart C--Application and Grant Award Process
578.15 Eligible applicants.
578.17 Overview of application and grant award process.
578.19 Application process.
578.21 Awarding funds.
578.23 Executing grant agreements.
578.25 Site control.
578.27 Consolidated plan.
578.29 Subsidy layering.
578.31 Environmental review.
578.33 Renewals.
578.35 Appeal.
Subpart D--Program Components and Eligible Costs
578.37 Program components and uses of assistance.
578.39 Continuum of Care planning activities.
578.41 Unified Funding Agency costs.
578.43 Acquisition.
578.45 Rehabilitation.
578.47 New construction.
578.49 Leasing.
578.51 Rental assistance.
578.53 Supportive services.
578.55 Operating costs.
578.57 Homeless Management Information System.
578.59 Project administrative costs.
578.61 Relocation costs.
578.63 Indirect costs.
Subpart E--High-Performing Communities
578.65 Standards.
578.67 Publication of application.
578.69 Cooperation among entities.
578.71 HPC-eligible activities.
Subpart F--Program Requirements
578.73 Matching requirements.
578.75 General operations.
578.77 Calculating occupancy charges and rent.
578.79 Limitation on transitional housing.
578.81 Term of commitment, repayment of grants, and prevention of
undue benefits.
578.83 Displacement, relocation, and acquisition.
578.85 Timeliness standards.
578.87 Limitation on use of funds.
578.89 Limitation on use of grant funds to serve persons defined as
homeless under other federal laws.
578.91 Termination of assistance to program participants.
578.93 Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity.
578.95 Conflicts of interest.
578.97 Program income.
578.99 Applicability of other federal requirements.
Subpart G--Grant Administration
578.101 Technical assistance.
578.103 Recordkeeping requirements.
578.105 Grant and project changes.
578.107 Sanctions.
578.109 Closeout.
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 11371 et seq., 42 U.S.C. 3535(d).
Subpart A--General Provisions
Sec. 578.1 Purpose and scope.
(a) The Continuum of Care program is authorized by subtitle C of
title IV of the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act (42 U.S.C.
11381-11389).
(b) The program is designed to:
(1) Promote communitywide commitment to the goal of ending
homelessness;
(2) Provide funding for efforts by nonprofit providers, States, and
local governments to quickly rehouse homeless individuals (including
unaccompanied youth) and families, while minimizing the trauma and
dislocation caused to homeless individuals, families, and communities
by homelessness;
(3) Promote access to and effective utilization of mainstream
programs by homeless individuals and families; and
(4) Optimize self-sufficiency among individuals and families
experiencing homelessness.
Sec. 578.3 Definitions.
As used in this part:
Act means the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act as amended (42
U.S.C. 11371 et seq.).
Annual renewal amount means the amount that a grant can be awarded
on an annual basis when renewed. It includes funds only for those
eligible activities (operating, supportive services, leasing, rental
assistance, HMIS, and administration) that were funded in the original
grant (or the original grant as amended), less the unrenewable
activities (acquisition, new construction, rehabilitation, and any
administrative costs related to these activities).
Applicant means an eligible applicant that has been designated by
the Continuum of Care to apply for assistance under this part on behalf
of that Continuum.
[[Page 45443]]
At risk of homelessness. (1) An individual or family who:
(i) Has an annual income below 30 percent of median family income
for the area, as determined by HUD;
(ii) Does not have sufficient resources or support networks, e.g.,
family, friends, faith-based or other social networks, immediately
available to prevent them from moving to an emergency shelter or
another place described in paragraph (1) of the ``Homeless'' definition
in this section; and
(iii) Meets one of the following conditions:
(A) Has moved because of economic reasons two or more times during
the 60 days immediately preceding the application for homelessness
prevention assistance;
(B) Is living in the home of another because of economic hardship;
(C) Has been notified in writing that their right to occupy their
current housing or living situation will be terminated within 21 days
of the date of application for assistance;
(D) Lives in a hotel or motel and the cost of the hotel or motel
stay is not paid
by charitable organizations or by federal, State, or local government
programs for low-income individuals;
(E) Lives in a single-room occupancy or efficiency apartment unit
in which there reside more than two persons, or lives in a larger
housing unit in which there reside more than 1.5 people per room, as
defined by the U.S. Census Bureau;
(F) Is exiting a publicly funded institution, or system of care
(such as a health-care facility, a mental health facility, foster care
or other youth facility, or correction program or institution); or
(G) Otherwise lives in housing that has characteristics associated
with instability and an increased risk of homelessness, as identified
in the recipient's approved consolidated plan;
(2) A child or youth who does not qualify as ``homeless'' under
this section, but qualifies as ``homeless'' under section 387(3) of the
Runaway and Homeless Youth Act (42 U.S.C. 5732a(3)), section 637(11) of
the Head Start Act (42 U.S.C. 9832(11)), section 41403(6) of the
Violence Against Women Act of 1994 (42 U.S.C. 14043e-2(6)), section
330(h)(5)(A) of the Public Health Service Act (42 U.S.C.
254b(h)(5)(A)), section 3(m) of the Food and Nutrition Act of 2008 (7
U.S.C. 2012(m)), or section 17(b)(15) of the Child Nutrition Act of
1966 (42 U.S.C. 1786(b)(15)); or
(3) A child or youth who does not qualify as ``homeless'' under
this section, but qualifies as ``homeless'' under section 725(2) of the
McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act (42 U.S.C. 11434a(2)), and the
parent(s) or guardian(s) of that child or youth if living with her or
him.
Centralized or coordinated assessment system means a centralized or
coordinated process designed to coordinate program participant intake
assessment and provision of referrals. A centralized or coordinated
assessment system covers the geographic area, is easily accessed by
individuals and families seeking housing or services, is well
advertized, and includes a comprehensive and standardized assessment
tool.
Chronically homeless. (1) An individual who:
(i) Is homeless and lives in a place not meant for human
habitation, a safe haven, or in an emergency shelter; and
(ii) Has been homeless and living or residing in a place not meant
for human habitation, a safe haven, or in an emergency shelter
continuously for at least one year or on at least four separate
occasions in the last 3 years; and
(iii) Can be diagnosed with one or more of the following
conditions: substance use disorder, serious mental illness,
developmental disability (as defined in section 102 of the
Developmental Disabilities Assistance Bill of Rights Act of 2000 (42
U.S.C. 15002)), post-traumatic stress disorder, cognitive impairments
resulting from brain injury, or chronic physical illness or disability;
(2) An individual who has been residing in an institutional care
facility, including a jail, substance abuse or mental health treatment
facility, hospital, or other similar facility, for fewer than 90 days
and met all of the criteria in paragraph (1) of this definition, before
entering that facility; or
(3) A family with an adult head of household (or if there is no
adult in the family, a minor head of household) who meets all of the
criteria in paragraph (1) of this definition, including a family whose
composition has fluctuated while the head of household has been
homeless.
Collaborative applicant means the eligible applicant that has been
designated by the Continuum of Care to apply for a grant for Continuum
of Care planning funds under this part on behalf of the Continuum.
Consolidated plan means the HUD-approved plan developed in
accordance with 24 CFR 91.
Continuum of Care and Continuum means the group organized to carry
out the responsibilities required under this part and that is composed
of representatives of organizations, including nonprofit homeless
providers, victim service providers, faith-based organizations,
governments, businesses, advocates, public housing agencies, school
districts, social service providers, mental health agencies, hospitals,
universities, affordable housing developers, law enforcement,
organizations that serve homeless and formerly homeless veterans, and
homeless and formerly homeless persons to the extent these groups are
represented within the geographic area and are available to
participate.
Developmental disability means, as defined in section 102 of the
Developmental Disabilities Assistance and Bill of Rights Act of 2000
(42 U.S.C. 15002):
(1) A severe, chronic disability of an individual that--
(i) Is attributable to a mental or physical impairment or
combination of mental and physical impairments;
(ii) Is manifested before the individual attains age 22;
(iii) Is likely to continue indefinitely;
(iv) Results in substantial functional limitations in three or more
of the following areas of major life activity:
(A) Self-care;
(B) Receptive and expressive language;
(C) Learning;
(D) Mobility;
(E) Self-direction;
(F) Capacity for independent living;
(G) Economic self-sufficiency.
(v) Reflects the individual's need for a combination and sequence
of special, interdisciplinary, or generic services, individualized
supports, or other forms of assistance that are of lifelong or extended
duration and are individually planned and coordinated.
(2) An individual from birth to age 9, inclusive, who has a
substantial developmental delay or specific congenital or acquired
condition, may be considered to have a developmental disability without
meeting three or more of the criteria described in paragraphs (1)(i)
through (v) of the definition of ``developmental disability'' in this
section if the individual, without services and supports, has a high
probability of meeting these criteria later in life.
Eligible applicant means a private nonprofit organization, State,
local government, or instrumentality of State and local government.
Emergency shelter is defined in 24 CFR part 576.
Emergency Solutions Grants (ESG) means the grants provided under 24
CFR part 576.
[[Page 45444]]
Fair Market Rent (FMR) means the Fair Market Rents published in the
Federal Register annually by HUD.
High-performing community (HPC) means a Continuum of Care that
meets the standards in subpart E of this part and has been designated
as a high-performing community by HUD.
Homeless means:
(1) An individual or family who lacks a fixed, regular, and
adequate nighttime residence, meaning:
(i) An individual or family with a primary nighttime residence that
is a public or private place not designed for or ordinarily used as a
regular sleeping accommodation for human beings, including a car, park,
abandoned building, bus or train station, airport, or camping ground;
(ii) An individual or family living in a supervised publicly or
privately operated shelter designated to provide temporary living
arrangements (including congregate shelters, transitional housing, and
hotels and motels paid for by charitable organizations or by federal,
State, or local government programs for low-income individuals); or
(iii) An individual who is exiting an institution where he or she
resided for 90 days or less and who resided in an emergency shelter or
place not meant for human habitation immediately before entering that
institution;
(2) An individual or family who will imminently lose their primary
nighttime residence, provided that:
(i) The primary nighttime residence will be lost within 14 days of
the date of application for homeless assistance;
(ii) No subsequent residence has been identified; and
(iii) The individual or family lacks the resources or support
networks, e.g., family, friends, faith-based or other social networks,
needed to obtain other permanent housing;
(3) Unaccompanied youth under 25 years of age, or families with
children and youth, who do not otherwise qualify as homeless under this
definition, but who:
(i) Are defined as homeless under section 387 of the Runaway and
Homeless Youth Act (42 U.S.C. 5732a), section 637 of the Head Start Act
(42 U.S.C. 9832), section 41403 of the Violence Against Women Act of
1994 (42 U.S.C. 14043e-2), section 330(h) of the Public Health Service
Act (42 U.S.C. 254b(h)), section 3 of the Food and Nutrition Act of
2008 (7 U.S.C. 2012), section 17(b) of the Child Nutrition Act of 1966
(42 U.S.C. 1786(b)), or section 725 of the McKinney-Vento Homeless
Assistance Act (42 U.S.C. 11434a);
(ii) Have not had a lease, ownership interest, or occupancy
agreement in permanent housing at any time during the 60 days
immediately preceding the date of application for homeless assistance;
(iii) Have experienced persistent instability as measured by two
moves or more during the 60-day period immediately preceding the date
of applying for homeless assistance; and
(iv) Can be expected to continue in such status for an extended
period of time because of chronic disabilities; chronic physical health
or mental health conditions; substance addiction; histories of domestic
violence or childhood abuse (including neglect); the presence of a
child or youth with a disability; or two or more barriers to
employment, which include the lack of a high school degree or General
Education Development (GED), illiteracy, low English proficiency, a
history of incarceration or detention for criminal activity, and a
history of unstable employment; or
(4) Any individual or family who:
(i) Is fleeing, or is attempting to flee, domestic violence, dating
violence, sexual assault, stalking, or other dangerous or life-
threatening conditions that relate to violence against the individual
or a family member, including a child, that has either taken place
within the individual's or family's primary nighttime residence or has
made the individual or family afraid to return to their primary
nighttime residence;
(ii) Has no other residence; and
(iii) Lacks the resources or support networks, e.g., family,
friends, and faith-based or other social networks, to obtain other
permanent housing.
Homeless Management Information System (HMIS) means the information
system designated by the Continuum of Care to comply with the HMIS
requirements prescribed by HUD.
HMIS Lead means the entity designated by the Continuum of Care in
accordance with this part to operate the Continuum's HMIS on its
behalf.
Permanent housing means community-based housing without a
designated length of stay, and includes both permanent supportive
housing and rapid rehousing. To be permanent housing, the program
participant must be the tenant on a lease for a term of at least one
year, which is renewable for terms that are a minimum of one month
long, and is terminable only for cause.
Permanent supportive housing means permanent housing in which
supportive services are provided to assist homeless persons with a
disability to live independently.
Point-in-time count means a count of sheltered and unsheltered
homeless persons carried out on one night in the last 10 calendar days
of January or at such other time as required by HUD.
Private nonprofit organization means an organization:
(1) No part of the net earnings of which inure to the benefit of
any member, founder, contributor, or individual;
(2) That has a voluntary board;
(3) That has a functioning accounting system that is operated in
accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, or has
designated a fiscal agent that will maintain a functioning accounting
system for the organization in accordance with generally accepted
accounting principles; and
(4) That practices nondiscrimination in the provision of
assistance.
A private nonprofit organization does not include governmental
organizations, such as public housing agencies.
Program participant means an individual (including an unaccompanied
youth) or family who is assisted with Continuum of Care program funds.
Project means a group of eligible activities, such as HMIS costs,
identified as a project in an application to HUD for Continuum of Care
funds and includes a structure (or structures) that is (are) acquired,
rehabilitated, constructed, or leased with assistance provided under
this part or with respect to which HUD provides rental assistance or
annual payments for operating costs, or supportive services under this
subtitle.
Recipient means an applicant that signs a grant agreement with HUD.
Safe haven means, for the purpose of defining chronically homeless,
supportive housing that meets the following:
(1) Serves hard to reach homeless persons with severe mental
illness who came from the streets and have been unwilling or unable to
participate in supportive services;
(2) Provides 24-hour residence for eligible persons for an
unspecified period;
(3) Has an overnight capacity limited to 25 or fewer persons; and
(4) Provides low-demand services and referrals for the residents.
State means each of the 50 States, the District of Columbia, the
Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, American Samoa, Guam, the Commonwealth of
the Northern Marianas, and the Virgin Islands.
Subrecipient means a private nonprofit organization, State, local
government, or instrumentality of State or local government that
receives a
[[Page 45445]]
subgrant from the recipient to carry out a project.
Transitional housing means housing, where all program participants
have signed a lease or occupancy agreement, the purpose of which is to
facilitate the movement of homeless individuals and families into
permanent housing within 24 months or such longer period as HUD
determines necessary. The program participant must have a lease or
occupancy agreement for a term of at least one month that ends in 24
months and cannot be extended.
Unified Funding Agency (UFA) means an eligible applicant selected
by the Continuum of Care to apply for a grant for the entire Continuum,
which has the capacity to carry out the duties in Sec. 578.11(b),
which is approved by HUD and to which HUD awards a grant.
Victim service provider means a private nonprofit organization
whose primary mission is to provide services to victims of domestic
violence, dating violence, sexual assault, or stalking. This term
includes rape crisis centers, battered women's shelters, domestic
violence transitional housing programs, and other programs.
Subpart B--Establishing and Operating a Continuum of Care
Sec. 578.5 Establishing the Continuum of Care.
(a) The Continuum of Care. Representatives from relevant
organizations within a geographic area shall establish a Continuum of
Care for the geographic area to carry out the duties of this part.
Relevant organizations include nonprofit homeless assistance providers,
victim service providers, faith-based organizations, governments,
businesses, advocates, public housing agencies, school districts,
social service providers, mental health agencies, hospitals,
universities, affordable housing developers, law enforcement, and
organizations that serve veterans and homeless and formerly homeless
individuals.
(b) The board. The Continuum of Care must establish a board to act
on behalf of the Continuum using the process established as a
requirement by Sec. 578.7(a)(3) and must comply with the conflict-of-
interest requirements at Sec. 578.95(b). The board must:
(1) Be representative of the relevant organizations and of projects
serving homeless subpopulations; and
(2) Include at least one homeless or formerly homeless individual.
(c) Transition. Continuums of Care shall have 2 years after August
30, 2012 to comply with the requirements of paragraph (b) of this
section.
Sec. 578.7 Responsibilities of the Continuum of Care.
(a) Operate the Continuum of Care. The Continuum of Care must:
(1) Hold meetings of the full membership, with published agendas,
at least semi-annually;
(2) Make an invitation for new members to join publicly available
within the geographic at least annually;
(3) Adopt and follow a written process to select a board to act on
behalf of the Continuum of Care. The process must be reviewed, updated,
and approved by the Continuum at least once every 5 years;
(4) Appoint additional committees, subcommittees, or workgroups;
(5) In consultation with the collaborative applicant and the HMIS
Lead, develop, follow, and update annually a governance charter, which
will include all procedures and policies needed to comply with subpart
B of this part and with HMIS requirements as prescribed by HUD; and a
code of conduct and recusal process for the board, its chair(s), and
any person acting on behalf of the board;
(6) Consult with recipients and subrecipients to establish
performance targets appropriate for population and program type,
monitor recipient and subrecipient performance, evaluate outcomes, and
take action against poor performers;
(7) Evaluate outcomes of projects funded under the Emergency
Solutions Grants program and the Continuum of Care program, and report
to HUD;
(8) In consultation with recipients of Emergency Solutions Grants
program funds within the geographic area, establish and operate either
a centralized or coordinated assessment system that provides an
initial, comprehensive assessment of the needs of individuals and
families for housing and services. The Continuum must develop a
specific policy to guide the operation of the centralized or
coordinated assessment system on how its system will address the needs
of individuals and families who are fleeing, or attempting to flee,
domestic violence, dating violence, sexual assault, or stalking, but
who are seeking shelter or services from nonvictim service providers.
This system must comply with any requirements established by HUD by
Notice.
(9) In consultation with recipients of Emergency Solutions Grants
program funds within the geographic area, establish and consistently
follow written standards for providing Continuum of Care assistance. At
a minimum, these written standards must include:
(i) Policies and procedures for evaluating individuals' and
families' eligibility for assistance under this part;
(ii) Policies and procedures for determining and prioritizing which
eligible individuals and families will receive transitional housing
assistance;
(iii) Policies and procedures for determining and prioritizing
which eligible individuals and families will receive rapid rehousing
assistance;
(iv) Standards for determining what percentage or amount of rent
each program participant must pay while receiving rapid rehousing
assistance;
(v) Policies and procedures for determining and prioritizing which
eligible individuals and families will receive permanent supportive
housing assistance; and
(vi) Where the Continuum is designated a high-performing community,
as described in subpart G of this part, policies and procedures set
forth in 24 CFR 576.400(e)(3)(vi), (e)(3)(vii), (e)(3)(viii), and
(e)(3)(ix).
(b) Designating and operating an HMIS. The Continuum of Care must:
(1) Designate a single Homeless Management Information System
(HMIS) for the geographic area;
(2) Designate an eligible applicant to manage the Continuum's HMIS,
which will be known as the HMIS Lead;
(3) Review, revise, and approve a privacy plan, security plan, and
data quality plan for the HMIS.
(4) Ensure consistent participation of recipients and subrecipients
in the HMIS; and
(5) Ensure the HMIS is administered in compliance with requirements
prescribed by HUD.
(c) Continuum of Care planning. The Continuum must develop a plan
that includes:
(1) Coordinating the implementation of a housing and service system
within its geographic area that meets the needs of the homeless
individuals (including unaccompanied youth) and families. At a minimum,
such system encompasses the following:
(i) Outreach, engagement, and assessment;
(ii) Shelter, housing, and supportive services;
(iii) Prevention strategies.
(2) Planning for and conducting, at least biennially, a point-in-
time count of homeless persons within the geographic area that meets
the following requirements:
(i) Homeless persons who are living in a place not designed or
ordinarily used as a regular sleeping accommodation for
[[Page 45446]]
humans must be counted as unsheltered homeless persons.
(ii) Persons living in emergency shelters and transitional housing
projects must be counted as sheltered homeless persons.
(iii) Other requirements established by HUD by Notice.
(3) Conducting an annual gaps analysis of the homeless needs and
services available within the geographic area;
(4) Providing information required to complete the Consolidated
Plan(s) within the Continuum's geographic area;
(5) Consulting with State and local government Emergency Solutions
Grants program recipients within the Continuum's geographic area on the
plan for allocating Emergency Solutions Grants program funds and
reporting on and evaluating the performance of Emergency Solutions
Grants program recipients and subrecipients.
Sec. 578.9 Preparing an application for funds.
(a) The Continuum must:
(1) Design, operate, and follow a collaborative process for the
development of applications and approve the submission of applications
in response to a NOFA published by HUD under Sec. 578.19 of this
subpart;
(2) Establish priorities for funding projects in the geographic
area;
(3) Determine if one application for funding will be submitted for
all projects within the geographic area or if more than one application
will be submitted for the projects within the geographic area;
(i) If more than one application will be submitted, designate an
eligible applicant to be the collaborative applicant that will collect
and combine the required application information from all applicants
and for all projects within the geographic area that the Continuum has
selected funding. The collaborative applicant will also apply for
Continuum of Care planning activities. If the Continuum is an eligible
applicant, it may designate itself;
(ii) If only one application will be submitted, that applicant will
be the collaborative applicant and will collect and combine the
required application information from all projects within the
geographic area that the Continuum has selected for funding and apply
for Continuum of Care planning activities;
(b) The Continuum retains all of its responsibilities, even if it
designates one or more eligible applicants other than itself to apply
for funds on behalf of the Continuum. This includes approving the
Continuum of Care application.
Sec. 578.11 Unified Funding Agency.
(a) Becoming a Unified Funding Agency. To become designated as the
Unified Funding Agency (UFA) for a Continuum, a collaborative applicant
must be selected by the Continuum to apply to HUD to be designated as
the UFA for the Continuum.
(b) Criteria for designating a UFA. HUD will consider these
criteria when deciding whether to designate a collaborative applicant a
UFA:
(1) The Continuum of Care it represents meets the requirements in
Sec. 578.7;
(2) The collaborative applicant has financial management systems
that meet the standards set forth in 24 CFR 84.21 (for nonprofit
organizations) and 24 CFR 85.20 (for States);
(3) The collaborative applicant demonstrates the ability to monitor
subrecipients; and
(4) Such other criteria as HUD may establish by NOFA.
(c) Requirements. HUD-designated UFAs shall:
(1) Apply to HUD for funding for all of the projects within the
geographic area and enter into a grant agreement with HUD for the
entire geographic area.
(2) Enter into legally binding agreements with subrecipients, and
receive and distribute funds to subrecipients for all projects within
the geographic area.
(3) Require subrecipients to establish fiscal control and
accounting procedures as necessary to assure the proper disbursal of
and accounting for federal funds in accordance with the requirements of
24 CFR parts 84 and 85 and corresponding OMB circulars.
(4) Obtain approval of any proposed grant agreement amendments by
the Continuum of Care before submitting a request for an amendment to
HUD.
Sec. 578.13 Remedial action.
(a) If HUD finds that the Continuum of Care for a geographic area
does not meet the requirements of the Act or its implementing
regulations, or that there is no Continuum for a geographic area, HUD
may take remedial action to ensure fair distribution of grant funds
within the geographic area. Such measures may include:
(1) Designating a replacement Continuum of Care for the geographic
area;
(2) Designating a replacement collaborative applicant for the
Continuum's geographic area; and
(3) Accepting applications from other eligible applicants within
the Continuum's geographic area.
(b) HUD must provide a 30-day prior written notice to the Continuum
and its collaborative applicant and give them an opportunity to
respond.
Subpart C--Application and Grant Award Process
Sec. 578.15 Eligible applicants.
(a) Who may apply. Nonprofit organizations, States, local
governments, and instrumentalities of State or local governments are
eligible to apply for grants.
(b) Designation by the Continuum of Care. Eligible applicant(s)
must have been designated by the Continuum of Care to submit an
application for grant funds under this part. The designation must state
whether the Continuum is designating more than one applicant to apply
for funds and, if it is, which applicant is being designated as the
collaborative applicant. If the Continuum is designating only one
applicant to apply for funds, the Continuum must designate that
applicant to be the collaborative applicant.
(c) Exclusion. For-profit entities are not eligible to apply for
grants or to be subrecipients of grant funds.
Sec. 578.17 Overview of application and grant award process.
(a) Formula. (1) After enactment of the annual appropriations act
for each fiscal year, and issuance of the NOFA, HUD will publish, on
its Web site, the Preliminary Pro Rata Need (PPRN) assigned to
metropolitan cities, urban counties, and all other counties.
(2) HUD will apply the formula used to determine PPRN established
in paragraph (a)(3) of this section, to the amount of funds being made
available under the NOFA. That amount is calculated by:
(i) Determining the total amount for the Continuum of Care
competition in accordance with section 413 of the Act or as otherwise
directed by the annual appropriations act;
(ii) From the amount in paragraph (a)(2)(i) of this section,
deducting the amount published in the NOFA as being set aside to
provide a bonus to geographic areas for activities that have proven to
be effective in reducing homelessness generally or for specific
subpopulations listed in the NOFA or achieving homeless prevention and
independent living goals established in the NOFA and to meet policy
priorities set in the NOFA; and
(iii) Deducting the amount of funding necessary for Continuum of
Care planning activities and UFA costs.
(3) PPRN is calculated on the amount determined under paragraph
(a)(2) of this section by using the following formula:
[[Page 45447]]
(i) Two percent will be allocated among the four insular areas
(American Samoa, Guam, the Commonwealth of the Northern Marianas, and
the Virgin Islands) on the basis of the ratio of the population of each
insular area to the population of all insular areas.
(ii) Seventy-five percent of the remaining amount will be
allocated, using the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) formula,
to metropolitan cities and urban counties that have been funded under
either the Emergency Shelter Grants or Emergency Solutions Grants
programs in any one year since 2004.
(iii) The amount remaining after the allocation under paragraphs
(a)(1) and (2) of this section will be allocated, using the CDBG
formula, to metropolitan cities and urban counties that have not been
funded under the Emergency Solutions Grants program in any year since
2004 and all other counties in the United States and Puerto Rico.
(4) If the calculation in paragraph (a)(2) of this section results
in an amount less than the amount required to renew all projects
eligible for renewal in that year for at least one year, after making
adjustments proportional to increases in fair market rents for the
geographic area for leasing, operating, and rental assistance for
permanent housing, HUD will reduce, proportionately, the total amount
required to renew all projects eligible for renewal in that year for at
least one year, for each Continuum of Care. HUD will publish, via the
NOFA, the total dollar amount that every Continuum will be required to
deduct from renewal projects Continuum-wide.
(b) Calculating a Continuum of Care's maximum award amount. (1)
Establish the PPRN amount. First, HUD will total the PPRN amounts for
each metropolitan city, urban county, other county, and insular area
claimed by the Continuum as part of its geographic area, excluding any
counties applying for or receiving funding from the Rural Housing
Stability Assistance program under 24 CFR part 579.
(2) Establishing renewal demand. Next, HUD will determine the
renewal demand within the Continuum's geographic area. Renewal demand
is the sum of the annual renewal amounts of all projects within the
Continuum eligible to apply for renewal in that fiscal year's
competition, before any adjustments to rental assistance, leasing, and
operating line items based on FMR changes.
(3) Establishing FPRN. The higher of PPRN or renewal demand for the
Continuum of Care is the FPRN, which is the base for the maximum award
amount for the Continuum.
(4) Establishing the maximum award amount. The maximum award amount
for the Continuum is the FPRN amount plus any additional eligible
amounts for Continuum planning; UFA costs; adjustments to leasing,
operating and rental assistance line items based on changes to FMR; and
available bonuses.
Sec. 578.19 Application process.
(a) Notice of Funding Availability. After enactment of the annual
appropriations act for the fiscal year, HUD will issue a NOFA in
accordance with the requirements of 24 CFR part 4.
(b) Applications. All applications to HUD, including applications
for grant funds and requests for designation as a UFA or HPC, must be
submitted at such time and in such manner as HUD may require, and
contain such information as HUD determines necessary. At a minimum, an
application for grant funds must contain a list of the projects for
which it is applying for funds; a description of the projects; a list
of the projects that will be carried out by subrecipients and the names
of the subrecipients; a description of the subpopulations of homeless
or at risk of homelessness to be served by projects; the number of
units to be provided and/or the number of persons to be served by each
project; a budget request by project; and reasonable assurances that
the applicant, or the subrecipient, will own or have control of a site
for the proposed project not later than the expiration of the 12-month
period beginning upon notification of an award for grant assistance.
Sec. 578.21 Awarding funds.
(a) Selection. HUD will review applications in accordance with the
guidelines and procedures provided in the NOFA and will award funds to
recipients through a national competition based on selection criteria
as defined in section 427 of the Act.
(b) Announcement of awards. HUD will announce awards and notify
selected applicants of any conditions imposed on awards. Conditions
must be satisfied before HUD will execute a grant agreement with the
applicant.
(c) Satisfying conditions. HUD will withdraw an award if the
applicant does not satisfy all conditions imposed on it. Correcting all
issues and conditions attached to an award must be completed within the
time frame established in the NOFA. Proof of site control, match,
environmental review, and the documentation of financial feasibility
must be completed within 12 months of the announcement of the award, or
24 months in the case of funds for acquisition, rehabilitation, or new
construction. The 12-month deadline may be extended by HUD for up to 12
additional months upon a showing of compelling reasons for delay due to
factors beyond the control of the recipient or subrecipient.
Sec. 578.23 Executing grant agreements.
(a) Deadline. No later than 45 days from the date when all
conditions are satisfied, the recipient and HUD must execute the grant
agreement.
(b) Grant agreements. (1) Multiple applicants for one Continuum. If
a Continuum designates more than one applicant for the geographic area,
HUD will enter into a grant agreement with each designated applicant
for which an award is announced.
(2) One applicant for a Continuum. If a Continuum designates only
one applicant for the geographic area, after awarding funds, HUD may
enter into a grant agreement with that applicant for new awards, if
any, and one grant agreement for renewals, Continuum of Care planning,
and UFA costs, if any. These two grants will cover the entire
geographic area. A default by the recipient under one of those grant
agreements will also be a default under the other.
(3) Unified Funding Agencies. If a Continuum is a UFA that HUD has
approved, then HUD will enter into one grant agreement with the UFA for
new awards, if any, and one grant agreement for renewals, Continuum of
Care planning and UFA costs, if any. These two grants will cover the
entire geographic area. A default by the UFA under one of those grant
agreements will also be a default under the other.
(c) Required agreements. Recipients will be required to sign a
grant agreement in which the recipient agrees:
(1) To ensure the operation of the project(s) in accordance with
the provisions of the McKinney-Veto Act and all requirements under 24
CFR part 578;
(2) To monitor and report the progress of the project(s) to the
Continuum of Care and HUD;
(3) To ensure, to the maximum extent practicable, that individuals
and families experiencing homelessness are involved, through
employment, provision of volunteer services, or otherwise, in
constructing, rehabilitating, maintaining, and operating facilities for
the project and in providing supportive services for the project;
(4) To require certification from all subrecipients that:
[[Page 45448]]
(i) Subrecipients will maintain the confidentiality of records
pertaining to any individual or family that was provided family
violence prevention or treatment services through the project;
(ii) The address or location of any family violence project
assisted under this part will not be made public, except with written
authorization of the person responsible for the operation of such
project;
(iii) Subrecipients will establish policies and practices that are
consistent with, and do not restrict, the exercise of rights provided
by subtitle B of title VII of the Act and other laws relating to the
provision of educational and related services to individuals and
families experiencing homelessness;
(iv) In the case of projects that provide housing or services to
families, that subrecipients will designate a staff person to be
responsible for ensuring that children being served in the program are
enrolled in school and connected to appropriate services in the
community, including early childhood programs such as Head Start, part
C of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, and programs
authorized under subtitle B of title VII of the Act;
(v) The subrecipient, its officers, and employees are not debarred
or suspended from doing business with the Federal Government; and
(vi) Subrecipients will provide information, such as data and
reports, as required by HUD; and
(5) To establish such fiscal control and accounting procedures as
may be necessary to assure the proper disbursal of, and accounting for
grant funds in order to ensure that all financial transactions are
conducted, and records maintained in accordance with generally accepted
accounting principles, if the recipient is a UFA;
(6) To monitor subrecipient match and report on match to HUD;
(7) To take the educational needs of children into account when
families are placed in housing and will, to the maximum extent
practicable, place families with children as close as possible to their
school of origin so as not to disrupt such children's education;
(8) To monitor subrecipients at least annually;
(9) To use the centralized or coordinated assessment system
established by the Continuum of Care as set forth in Sec. 578.7(a)(8).
A victim service provider may choose not to use the Continuum of Care's
centralized or coordinated assessment system, provided that victim
service providers in the area use a centralized or coordinated
assessment system that meets HUD's minimum requirements and the victim
service provider uses that system instead;
(10) To follow the written standards for providing Continuum of
Care assistance developed by the Continuum of Care, including the
minimum requirements set forth in Sec. 578.7(a)(9);
(11) Enter into subrecipient agreements requiring subrecipients to
operate the project(s) in accordance with the provisions of this Act
and all requirements under 24 CFR part 578; and
(12) To comply with such other terms and conditions as HUD may
establish by NOFA.
Sec. 578.25 Site control.
(a) In general. When grant funds will be used for acquisition,
rehabilitation, new construction, operating costs, or to provide
supportive services, the recipient or subrecipient must demonstrate
that it has site control within the time frame established in section
Sec. 578.21 before HUD will execute a grant agreement. This
requirement does not apply to funds used for housing that will
eventually be owned or controlled by the individuals or families served
or for supportive services provided at sites not operated by the
recipient or subrecipient.
(b) Evidence. Acceptable evidence of site control is a deed or
lease. If grant funds will be used for acquisition, acceptable evidence
of site control will be a purchase agreement. The owner, lessee, and
purchaser shown on these documents must be the selected applicant or
intended subrecipient identified in the application for assistance.
(c) Tax credit projects. (1) Applicants that plan to use the low-
income housing tax credit authorized under 26 U.S.C. 42 to finance a
project must prove to HUD's satisfaction that the applicant or
subrecipient identified in the application is in control of the limited
partnership or limited liability corporation that has a deed or lease
for the project site.
(i) To have control of the limited partnership, the applicant or
subrecipient must be the general partner of the limited partnership or
have a 51 percent controlling interest in that general partner.
(ii) To have control of the limited liability company, the
applicant or subrecipient must be the sole managing member.
(2) If grant funds are to be used for acquisition, rehabilitation,
or new construction, the recipient or subrecipient must maintain
control of the partnership or corporation and must ensure that the
project is operated in compliance with law and regulation for 15 years
from the date of initial occupancy or initial service provision. The
partnership or corporation must own the project site throughout the 15-
year period. If grant funds were not used for acquisition,
rehabilitation, or new construction, then the recipient or subrecipient
must maintain control for the term of the grant agreement and any
renewals thereof.
Sec. 578.27 Consolidated plan.
(a) States or units of general local government. An applicant that
is a State or a unit of general local government must have a HUD-
approved, complete or abbreviated, consolidated plan in accordance with
24 CFR part 91. The applicant must submit a certification that the
application for funding is consistent with the HUD-approved
consolidated plan(s) for the jurisdiction(s) in which the proposed
project will be located. Funded applicants must certify in a grant
agreement that they are following the HUD-approved consolidated plan.
(b) Other applicants. Applicants that are not States or units of
general local government must submit a certification by the
jurisdiction(s) in which the proposed project will be located that the
applicant's application for funding is consistent with the
jurisdiction's HUD-approved consolidated plan. The certification must
be made by the unit of general local government or the State, in
accordance with the consistency certification provisions under 24 CFR
part 91, subpart F. If the jurisdiction refuses to provide a
certification of consistency, the applicant may appeal to HUD under
Sec. 578.35.
(c) Timing of consolidated plan certification submissions. The
required certification that the application for funding is consistent
with the HUD-approved consolidated plan must be submitted by the
funding application submission deadline announced in the NOFA.
Sec. 578.29 Subsidy layering.
HUD may provide assistance under this program only in accordance
with HUD subsidy layering requirements in section 102 of the Housing
and Urban Development Reform Act of 1989 (42 U.S.C. 3545) and 24 CFR
part 4, subpart A. An applicant must submit information in its
application on other sources of governmental assistance that the
applicant has received, or reasonably expects to receive, for a
proposed project or activities. HUD's review of this information is
intended to prevent excessive public assistance for
[[Page 45449]]
proposed project or activities by combining (layering) assistance under
this program with other governmental housing assistance from federal,
State, or local agencies, including assistance such as tax concessions
or tax credits.
Sec. 578.31 Environmental review.
(a) Activities under this part are subject to environmental review
by HUD under 24 CFR part 50. The recipient or subrecipient shall supply
all available, relevant information necessary for HUD to perform, for
each property, any environmental review required by 24 CFR part 50. The
recipient or subrecipient must carry out mitigating measures required
by HUD or select an alternate eligible property. HUD may eliminate from
consideration any application that would require an Environmental
Impact Statement.
(b) The recipient or subrecipient, its project partners, and their
contractors may not acquire, rehabilitate, convert, lease, repair,
dispose of, demolish, or construct property for a project under this
part, or commit or expend HUD or local funds for such eligible
activities under this part, until HUD has performed an environmental
review under 24 CFR part 50 and the recipient or subrecipient has
received HUD approval of the property.
Sec. 578.33 Renewals.
(a) In general. Awards made under this part and title IV of the
Act, as in effect before August 30, 2012 (the Supportive Housing
Program and the Shelter Plus Care program), may be renewed to continue
ongoing leasing, operations, supportive services, rental assistance,
HMIS, and administration beyond the initial funding period. To be
considered for funding, recipients must submit a request in a form
specified by HUD, must meet the requirements of this part, and must
submit the request within the time frame established by HUD.
(b) Length of renewal. HUD may award up to 3 years of funds for
supportive services, leasing, HMIS, and operating costs. Renewals of
tenant-based and sponsor-based rental assistance may be for up to one
year of rental assistance. Renewals of project-based rental assistance
may be for up to 15 years of rental assistance, subject to availability
of annual appropriations.
(c) Assistance available. (1) Assistance during each year of a
renewal period may be for:
(i) Up to 100 percent of the amount for supportive services and
HMIS costs in the final year of the prior funding period;
(ii) Up to 100 percent of the amount for leasing and operating in
the final year of the prior funding period adjusted in proportion to
changes in the FMR for the geographic area; and
(iii) For rental assistance, up to 100 percent of the result of
multiplying the number and unit size(s) in the grant agreement by the
number of months in the renewal grant term and the applicable FMR.
(d) Review criteria. (1) Awards made under title IV of the Act, as
in effect before August 30, 2012 are eligible for renewal in the
Continuum of Care program even if the awardees would not be eligible
for a new grant under the program, so long as they continue to serve
the same population and the same number of persons or units in the same
type of housing as identified in their most recently amended grant
agreement signed before August 30, 2012. Grants will be renewed if HUD
receives a certification from the Continuum that there is a
demonstrated need for the project, and HUD finds that the project
complied with program requirements applicable before August 30, 2012.
For purposes of meeting the requirements of this part, a project will
continue to be administered in accordance with 24 CFR 582.330, if the
project received funding under the Shelter Plus Care program, or 24 CFR
583.325, if the project received funding under the Supportive Housing
Program.
(2) Renewal of awards made after August 30, 2012. Review criteria
for competitively awarded renewals made after August 30, 2012 will be
described in the NOFA.
(e) Unsuccessful projects. HUD may renew a project that was
eligible for renewal in the competition and was part of an application
that was not funded despite having been submitted on time, in the
manner required by HUD, and containing the information required by HUD,
upon a finding that the project meets the purposes of the Continuum of
Care program. The renewal will not exceed more than one year and will
be under such conditions as HUD deems appropriate.
(f) Annual Performance Report condition. HUD may terminate the
renewal of any grant and require the recipient to repay the renewal
grant if:
(1) The recipient fails to timely submit a HUD Annual Performance
Report (APR) for the grant year immediately prior to renewal; or
(2) The recipient submits an APR that HUD deems unacceptable or
shows noncompliance with the requirements of the grant and this part.
Sec. 578.35 Appeal.
(a) In general. Failure to follow the procedures or meet the
deadlines established in this section will result in denial of the
appeal.
(b) Solo applicants. (1) Who may appeal. Nonprofits, States, and
local governments, and instrumentalities of State or local governments
that attempted to participate in the Continuum of Care planning process
in the geographic area in which they operate, that believe they were
denied the right to participate in a reasonable manner, and that
submitted a solo application for funding by the application deadline
established in the NOFA, may appeal the decision of the Continuum to
HUD.
(2) Notice of intent to appeal. The solo applicant must submit a
written notice of intent to appeal, with a copy to the Continuum, with
their funding application.
(3) Deadline for submitting proof. No later than 30 days after the
date that HUD announces the awards, the solo applicant shall submit in
writing, with a copy to the Continuum, all relevant evidence supporting
its claim, in such manner as HUD may require by Notice.
(4) Response from the Continuum of Care. The Continuum shall have
30 days from the date of its receipt of the solo applicant's evidence
to respond to HUD in writing and in such manner as HUD may require,
with a copy to the solo applicant.
(5) Decision. HUD will notify the solo applicant and the Continuum
of its decision within 60 days of receipt of the Continuum's response.
(6) Funding. If HUD finds that the solo applicant was not permitted
to participate in the Continuum of Care planning process in a
reasonable manner, then HUD may award a grant to the solo applicant
when funds next become available and may direct the Continuum of Care
to take remedial steps to ensure reasonable participation in the
future. HUD may also reduce the award to the Continuum's applicant(s).
(c) Denied or decreased funding. (1) Who may appeal. Eligible
applicants that are denied funds by HUD, or that requested more funds
than HUD awarded to them, may appeal the award by filing a written
appeal, in such form and manner as HUD may require by Notice, within 45
days of the date of HUD's announcement of the award.
(2) Decision. HUD will notify the applicant of its decision on the
appeal within 60 days of HUD's receipt of the written appeal. HUD will
reverse a decision only when the applicant can show that HUD error
caused the denial or decrease.
[[Page 45450]]
(3) Funding. Awards and increases to awards made upon appeal will
be made from next available funds.
(d) Competing Continuums of Care. (1) In general. If more than one
Continuum of Care claims the same geographic area, HUD will award funds
to the Continuum applicant(s) whose application(s) has the highest
total score. No projects will be funded from the lower scoring
Continuum. No projects that are submitted in two or more competing
Continuum of Care applications will be funded.
(2) Who may appeal. The designated applicant(s) for the lower
scoring Continuum may appeal HUD's decision to fund the application(s)
from the competing Continuum by filing a written appeal, in such form
and manner as HUD may require by Notice, within 45 days of the date of
HUD's announcement of the award.
(3) Decision. HUD will notify the applicant(s) of its decision on
the appeal within 60 days of the date of HUD's receipt of the written
appeal. HUD will reverse a decision only upon a showing by the
applicant that HUD error caused the denial.
(e) Consolidated plan certification. (1) In general. An applicant
may appeal to HUD a jurisdiction's refusal to provide a certification
of consistency with the Consolidated Plan.
(2) Procedure. The applicant must submit a written appeal with its
application to HUD and send a copy of the appeal to the jurisdiction
that denied the certification of consistency. The appeal must include,
at a minimum:
(i) A copy of the applicant's request to the jurisdiction for the
certification of consistency with the Consolidated Plan;
(ii) A copy of the jurisdiction's response stating the reasons for
denial, including the reasons the proposed project is not consistent
with the jurisdiction's Consolidated Plan in accordance with 24 CFR
91.500(c); and
(iii) A statement of the reasons why the applicant believes its
project is consistent with the jurisdiction's Consolidated Plan.
(3) Jurisdiction response. The jurisdiction that refused to provide
the certification of consistency with the jurisdiction's Consolidated
Plan shall have 10 days after receipt of a copy of the appeal to submit
a written explanation of the reasons originally given for refusing to
provide the certification and a written rebuttal to any claims made by
the applicant in the appeal.
(4) HUD review. (i) HUD will issue its decision within 45 days of
the date of HUD's receipt of the jurisdiction's response. As part of
its review, HUD will consider:
(A) Whether the applicant submitted the request to the appropriate
political jurisdiction; and
(B) The reasonableness of the jurisdiction's refusal to provide the
certificate.
(ii) If the jurisdiction did not provide written reasons for
refusal, including the reasons why the project is not consistent with
the jurisdiction's Consolidated Plan in its initial response to the
applicant's request for a certification, HUD will find for the
applicant without further inquiry or response from the political
jurisdiction.
Subpart D--Program Components and Eligible Costs
Sec. 578.37 Program components and uses of assistance.
(a) Continuum of Care funds may be used to pay for the eligible
costs listed in Sec. 578.39 through Sec. 578.63 when used to
establish and operate projects under five program components: permanent
housing; transitional housing; supportive services only; HMIS; and, in
some cases, homelessness prevention. Although grant funds may be used
by recipients and subrecipients in all components for the eligible
costs of contributing data to the HMIS designated by the Continuum of
Care, only HMIS Leads may use grant funds for an HMIS component.
Administrative costs are eligible for all components. All components
are subject to the restrictions on combining funds for certain eligible
activities in a single project found in Sec. 578.87(c). The eligible
program components are:
(1) Permanent housing (PH). Permanent housing is community-based
housing, the purpose of which is to provide housing without a
designated length of stay. Grant funds may be used for acquisition,
rehabilitation, new construction, leasing, rental assistance, operating
costs, and supportive services. PH includes:
(i) Permanent supportive housing for persons with disabilities
(PSH). PSH can only provide assistance to individuals with disabilities
and families in which one adult or child has a disability. Supportive
services designed to meet the needs of the program participants must be
made available to the program participants.
(ii) Rapid rehousing. Continuum of Care funds may provide
supportive services, as set forth in Sec. 578.53, and/or short-term
(up to 3 months) and/or medium-term (for 3 to 24 months) tenant-based
rental assistance, as set forth in Sec. 578.51(c), as necessary to
help a homeless individual or family, with or without disabilities,
move as quickly as possible into permanent housing and achieve
stability in that housing. When providing short-term and/or medium-term
rental assistance to program participants, the rental assistance is
subject to Sec. 578.51(a)(1), but not Sec. 578.51(a)(1)(i) and (ii);
(a)(2); (c) and (f) through (i); and (l)(1). These projects:
(A) Must follow the written policies and procedures established by
the Continuum of Care for determining and prioritizing which eligible
families and individuals will receive rapid rehousing assistance, as
well as the amount or percentage of rent that each program participant
must pay.
(B) May set a maximum amount or percentage of rental assistance
that a program participant may receive, a maximum number of months that
a program participant may receive rental assistance, and/or a maximum
number of times that a program participant may receive rental
assistance. The recipient or subrecipient may also require program
participants to share in the costs of rent. For the purposes of
calculating rent for rapid rehousing, the rent shall equal the sum of
the total monthly rent for the unit and, if the tenant pays separately
for utilities, the monthly allowance for utilities (excluding
telephone) established by the public housing authority for the area in
which the housing is located.
(C) Limit rental assistance to no more than 24 months to a
household.
(D) May provide supportive services for no longer than 6 months
after rental assistance stops.
(E) Must re-evaluate, not less than once annually, that the program
participant lacks sufficient resources and support networks necessary
to retain housing without Continuum of Care assistance and the types
and amounts of assistance that the program participant needs to retain
housing. The recipient or subrecipient may require each program
participant receiving assistance to notify the recipient or
subrecipient of changes in the program participant's income or other
circumstances (e.g., changes in household composition) that affect the
program participant's need for assistance. When notified of a relevant
change, the recipient or subrecipient must reevaluate the program
participant's eligibility and the amount and types of assistance that
the program participant needs.
(F) Require the program participant to meet with a case manager not
less than once per month to assist the program participant in ensuring
long-term housing stability. The project is exempt
[[Page 45451]]
from this requirement if the Violence Against Women Act of 1994 (42
U.S.C. 13925 et seq.) or the Family Violence Prevention and Services
Act (42 U.S.C. 10401 et seq.) prohibits the recipient carrying out the
project from making its housing conditional on the participant's
acceptance of services.
(2) Transitional Housing (TH). Transitional housing facilitates the
movement of homeless individuals and families to PH within 24 months of
entering TH. Grant funds may be used for acquisition, rehabilitation,
new construction, leasing, rental assistance, operating costs, and
supportive services.
(3) Supportive Service Only (SSO). Funds may be used for
acquisition, rehabilitation, relocation costs, or leasing of a facility
from which supportive services will be provided, and supportive
services in order to provide supportive services to unsheltered and
sheltered homeless persons for whom the recipient or subrecipient is
not providing housing or housing assistance. SSO includes street
outreach.
(4) HMIS. Funds may be used by HMIS Leads to lease a structure in
which the HMIS is operated or as operating funds to operate a structure
in which the HMIS is operated, and for other costs eligible in Sec.
578.57.
(5) Homelessness prevention. Funds may be used by recipients in
Continuums of Care-designated high-performing communities for housing
relocation and stabilization services, and short- and/or medium-term
rental assistance, as described in 24 CFR 576.105 and 24 CFR 576.106,
that are necessary to prevent an individual or family from becoming
homeless.
(b) Uses of assistance. Funds are available to pay for the eligible
costs listed in Sec. 578.39 through Sec. 578.63 when used to:
(1) Establish new housing or new facilities to provide supportive
services;
(2) Expand existing housing and facilities in order to increase the
number of homeless persons served;
(3) Bring existing housing and facilities into compliance with
State and local government health and safety standards, as described in
Sec. 578.87;
(4) Preserve existing permanent housing and facilities that provide
supportive services;
(5) Provide supportive services for residents of supportive housing
or for homeless persons not residing in supportive housing;
(6) Continue funding permanent housing when the recipient has
received funding under this part for leasing, supportive services,
operating costs, or rental assistance;
(7) Establish and operate an HMIS or comparable database; and
(8) Establish and carry out a Continuum of Care planning process
and operate a Continuum of Care.
(c) Multiple purposes. Structures used to provide housing,
supportive housing, supportive services, or as a facility for HMIS
activities may also be used for other purposes. However, assistance
under this part will be available only in proportion to the use of the
structure for supportive housing or supportive services. If eligible
and ineligible activities are carried out in separate portions of the
same structure or in separate structures, grant funds may not be used
to pay for more than the actual cost of acquisition, construction, or
rehabilitation of the portion of the structure or structures used for
eligible activities. If eligible and ineligible activities are carried
out in the same structure, the costs will be prorated based on the
amount of time that the space is used for eligible versus ineligible
activities.
Sec. 578.39 Continuum of Care planning activities.
(a) In general. Collaborative applicants may use up to 3 percent of
their FPRN, or a maximum amount to be established by the NOFA, for
costs of:
(1) Designing and carrying out a collaborative process for the
development of an application to HUD;
(2) Evaluating the outcomes of projects for which funds are awarded
in the geographic area under the Continuum of Care and the Emergency
Solutions Grants programs; and
(3) Participating in the consolidated plan(s) for the geographic
area(s).
(b) Continuum of Care planning activities. Eligible planning costs
include the costs of:
(1) Developing a communitywide or regionwide process involving the
coordination of nonprofit homeless providers, victim service providers,
faith-based organizations, governments, businesses, advocates, public
housing agencies, school districts, social service providers, mental
health agencies, hospitals, universities, affordable housing
developers, law enforcement, organizations that serve veterans, and
homeless and formerly homeless individuals;
(2) Determining the geographic area that the Continuum of Care will
serve;
(3) Developing a Continuum of Care system;
(4) Evaluating the outcomes of projects for which funds are awarded
in the geographic area, including the Emergency Solutions Grants
program;
(5) Participating in the consolidated plan(s) of the
jurisdiction(s) in the geographic area; and
(6) Preparing and submitting an application to HUD on behalf of the
entire Continuum of Care membership, including conducting a sheltered
and unsheltered point-in-time count and other data collection as
required by HUD.
(c) Monitoring costs. The costs of monitoring recipients and
subrecipients and enforcing compliance with program requirements are
eligible.
Sec. 578.41 Unified Funding Agency costs.
(a) In general. UFAs may use up to 3 percent of their FPRN, or a
maximum amount to be established by the NOFA, whichever is less, for
fiscal control and accounting costs necessary to assure the proper
disbursal of, and accounting for, federal funds awarded to
subrecipients under the Continuum of Care program.
(b) UFA costs. UFA costs include costs of ensuring that all
financial transactions carried out under the Continuum of Care program
are conducted and records are maintained in accordance with generally
accepted accounting principles, including arranging for an annual
survey, audit, or evaluation of the financial records of each project
carried out by a subrecipient funded by a grant received through the
Continuum of Care program.
(c) Monitoring costs. The costs of monitoring subrecipients and
enforcing compliance with program requirements are eligible for costs.
Sec. 578.43 Acquisition.
Grant funds may be used to pay up to 100 percent of the cost of
acquisition of real property selected by the recipient or subrecipient
for use in the provision of housing or supportive services for homeless
persons.
Sec. 578.45 Rehabilitation.
(a) Use. Grant funds may be used to pay up to 100 percent of the
cost of rehabilitation of structures to provide housing or supportive
services to homeless persons.
(b) Eligible costs. Eligible rehabilitation costs include
installing cost-effective energy measures, and bringing an existing
structure to State and local government health and safety standards.
(c) Ineligible costs. Grant funds may not be used for
rehabilitation of leased property.
Sec. 578.47 New construction.
(a) Use. Grant funds may be used to:
(1) Pay up to 100 percent of the cost of new construction,
including the
[[Page 45452]]
building of a new structure or building an addition to an existing
structure that increases the floor area by 100 percent or more, and the
cost of land associated with that construction, for use as housing.
(2) If grant funds are used for new construction, the applicant
must demonstrate that the costs of new construction are substantially
less than the costs of rehabilitation or that there is a lack of
available appropriate units that could be rehabilitated at a cost less
than new construction. For purposes of this cost comparison, costs of
rehabilitation or new construction may include the cost of real
property acquisition.
(b) Ineligible costs. Grant funds may not be used for new
construction on leased property.
Sec. 578.49 Leasing.
(a) Use. (1) Where the recipient or subrecipient is leasing the
structure, or portions thereof, grant funds may be used to pay for 100
percent of the costs of leasing a structure or structures, or portions
thereof, to provide housing or supportive services to homeless persons
for up to 3 years. Leasing funds may not be used to lease units or
structures owned by the recipient, subrecipient, their parent
organization(s), any other related organization(s), or organizations
that are members of a partnership, where the partnership owns the
structure, unless HUD authorized an exception for good cause.
(2) Any request for an exception must include the following:
(i) A description of how leasing these structures is in the best
interest of the program;
(ii) Supporting documentation showing that the leasing charges paid
with grant funds are reasonable for the market; and
(iii) A copy of the written policy for resolving disputes between
the landlord and tenant, including a recusal for officers, agents, and
staff who work for both the landlord and tenant.
(b) Requirements. (1) Leasing structures. When grants are used to
pay rent for all or part of a structure or structures, the rent paid
must be reasonable in relation to rents being charged in the area for
comparable space. In addition, the rent paid may not exceed rents
currently being charged by the same owner for comparable unassisted
space.
(2) Leasing individual units. When grants are used to pay rent for
individual housing units, the rent paid must be reasonable in relation
to rents being charged for comparable units, taking into account the
location, size, type, quality, amenities, facilities, and management
services. In addition, the rents may not exceed rents currently being
charged for comparable units, and the rent paid may not exceed HUD-
determined fair market rents.
(3) Utilities. If electricity, gas, and water are included in the
rent, these utilities may be paid from leasing funds. If utilities are
not provided by the landlord, these utility costs are an operating
cost, except for supportive service facilities. If the structure is
being used as a supportive service facility, then these utility costs
are a supportive service cost.
(4) Security deposits and first and last month's rent. Recipients
and subrecipients may use grant funds to pay security deposits, in an
amount not to exceed 2 months of actual rent. An advance payment of the
last month's rent may be provided to the landlord in addition to the
security deposit and payment of the first month's rent.
(5) Occupancy agreements and subleases. Occupancy agreements and
subleases are required as specified in Sec. 578.77(a).
(6) Calculation of occupancy charges and rent. Occupancy charges
and rent from program participants must be calculated as provided in
Sec. 578.77.
(7) Program income. Occupancy charges and rent collected from
program participants are program income and may be used as provided
under Sec. 578.97.
(8) Transition. Beginning in the first year awards are made under
the Continuum of Care program, renewals of grants for leasing funds
entered into under the authority of title IV, subtitle D of the Act as
it existed before May 20, 2009, will be renewed either as grants for
leasing or as rental assistance, depending on the characteristics of
the project. Leasing funds will be renewed as rental assistance if the
funds are used to pay rent on units where the lease is between the
program participant and the landowner or sublessor. Projects requesting
leasing funds will be renewed as leasing if the funds were used to
lease a unit or structure and the lease is between the recipient or
subrecipient and the landowner.
Sec. 578.51 Rental assistance.
(a) Use. (1) Grant funds may be used for rental assistance for
homeless individuals and families. Rental assistance cannot be provided
to a program participant who is already receiving rental assistance, or
living in a housing unit receiving rental assistance or operating
assistance through other federal, State, or local sources.
(i) The rental assistance may be short-term, up to 3 months of
rent; medium-term, for 3 to 24 months of rent; or long-term, for longer
than 24 months of rent and must be administered in accordance with the
policies and procedures established by the Continuum as set forth in
Sec. 578.7(a)(9) and this section.
(ii) The rental assistance may be tenant-based, project-based, or
sponsor-based, and may be for transitional or permanent housing.
(2) Grant funds may be used for security deposits in an amount not
to exceed 2 months of rent. An advance payment of the last month's rent
may be provided to the landlord, in addition to the security deposit
and payment of first month's rent.
(b) Rental assistance administrator. Rental assistance must be
administered by a State, unit of general local government, or a public
housing agency.
(c) Tenant-based rental assistance. Tenant-based rental assistance
is rental assistance in which program participants choose housing of an
appropriate size in which to reside. When necessary to facilitate the
coordination of supportive services, recipients and subrecipients may
require program participants to live in a specific area for their
entire period of participation, or in a specific structure for the
first year and in a specific area for the remainder of their period of
participation. Program participants who are receiving rental assistance
in transitional housing may be required to live in a specific structure
for their entire period of participation in transitional housing.
(1) Up to 5 years worth of rental assistance may be awarded to a
project in one competition.
(2) Program participants who have complied with all program
requirements during their residence retain the rental assistance if
they move within the Continuum of Care geographic area.
(3) Program participants who have complied with all program
requirements during their residence and who have been a victim of
domestic violence, dating violence, sexual assault, or stalking, and
who reasonably believe they are imminently threatened by harm from
further domestic violence, dating violence, sexual assault, or stalking
(which would include threats from a third party, such as a friend or
family member of the perpetrator of the violence), if they remain in
the assisted unit, and are able to document the violence and basis for
their belief, may retain the rental assistance and move to a different
Continuum of Care geographic area if they move out of the
[[Page 45453]]
assisted unit to protect their health and safety.
(d) Sponsor-based rental assistance. Sponsor-based rental
assistance is provided through contracts between the recipient and
sponsor organization. A sponsor may be a private, nonprofit
organization, or a community mental health agency established as a
public nonprofit organization. Program participants must reside in
housing owned or leased by the sponsor. Up to 5 years worth of rental
assistance may be awarded to a project in one competition.
(e) Project-based rental assistance. Project-based rental
assistance is provided through a contract with the owner of an existing
structure, where the owner agrees to lease the subsidized units to
program participants. Program participants will not retain rental
assistance if they move. Up to 15 years of rental assistance may be
awarded in one competition.
(f) Grant amount. The amount of rental assistance in each project
will be based on the number and size of units proposed by the applicant
to be assisted over the grant period. The amount of rental assistance
in each project will be calculated by multiplying the number and size
of units proposed by the FMR of each unit on the date the application
is submitted to HUD, by the term of the grant.
(g) Rent reasonableness. HUD will only provide rental assistance
for a unit if the rent is reasonable. The recipient or subrecipient
must determine whether the rent charged for the unit receiving rental
assistance is reasonable in relation to rents being charged for
comparable unassisted units, taking into account the location, size,
type, quality, amenities, facilities, and management and maintenance of
each unit. Reasonable rent must not exceed rents currently being
charged by the same owner for comparable unassisted units.
(h) Payment of grant. (1) The amount of rental assistance in each
project will be reserved for rental assistance over the grant period.
An applicant's request for rental assistance in each grant is an
estimate of the amount needed for rental assistance. Recipients will
make draws from the grant funds to pay the actual costs of rental
assistance for program participants.
(2) For tenant-based rental assistance, on demonstration of need:
(i) Up to 25 percent of the total rental assistance awarded may be
spent in any year of a 5-year grant term; or
(ii) A higher percentage if approved in advance by HUD, if the
recipient provides evidence satisfactory to HUD that it is financially
committed to providing the housing assistance described in the
application for the full 5-year period.
(3) A recipient must serve at least as many program participants as
shown in its application for assistance.
(4) If the amount in each grant reserved for rental assistance over
the grant period exceeds the amount that will be needed to pay the
actual costs of rental assistance, due to such factors as contract
rents being lower than FMRs and program participants being able to pay
a portion of the rent, recipients or subrecipients may use the excess
funds for covering the costs of rent increases, or for serving a
greater number of program participants.
(i) Vacancies. If a unit assisted under this section is vacated
before the expiration of the lease, the assistance for the unit may
continue for a maximum of 30 days from the end of the month in which
the unit was vacated, unless occupied by another eligible person. No
additional assistance will be paid until the unit is occupied by
another eligible person. Brief periods of stays in institutions, not to
exceed 90 days for each occurrence, are not considered vacancies.
(j) Property damage. Recipients and subrecipients may use grant
funds in an amount not to exceed one month's rent to pay for any damage
to housing due to the action of a program participant. This shall be a
one-time cost per participant, incurred at the time a participant exits
a housing unit.
(k) Resident rent. Rent must be calculated as provided in Sec.
578.77. Rents collected from program participants are program income
and may be used as provided under Sec. 578.97.
(l) Leases. (1) Initial lease. For project-based, sponsor-based, or
tenant-based rental assistance, program participants must enter into a
lease agreement for a term of at least one year, which is terminable
for cause. The leases must be automatically renewable upon expiration
for terms that are a minimum of one month long, except on prior notice
by either party.
(2) Initial lease for transitional housing. Program participants in
transitional housing must enter into a lease agreement for a term of at
least one month. The lease must be automatically renewable upon
expiration, except on prior notice by either party, up to a maximum
term of 24 months.
Sec. 578.53 Supportive services.
(a) In general. Grant funds may be used to pay the eligible costs
of supportive services that address the special needs of the program
participants. If the supportive services are provided in a supportive
service facility not contained in a housing structure, the costs of
day-to-day operation of the supportive service facility, including
maintenance, repair, building security, furniture, utilities, and
equipment are eligible as a supportive service.
(1) Supportive services must be necessary to assist program
participants obtain and maintain housing.
(2) Recipients and subrecipients shall conduct an annual assessment
of the service needs of the program participants and should adjust
services accordingly.
(b) Duration. (1) For a transitional housing project, supportive
services must be made available to residents throughout the duration of
their residence in the project.
(2) Permanent supportive housing projects must provide supportive
services for the residents to enable them to live as independently as
is practicable throughout the duration of their residence in the
project.
(3) Services may also be provided to former residents of
transitional housing and current residents of permanent housing who
were homeless in the prior 6 months, for no more than 6 months after
leaving transitional housing or homelessness, respectively, to assist
their adjustment to independent living.
(4) Rapid rehousing projects must require the program participant
to meet with a case manager not less than once per month as set forth
in Sec. 578.37(a)(1)(ii)(F), to assist the program participant in
maintaining long-term housing stability.
(c) Special populations. All eligible costs are eligible to the
same extent for program participants who are unaccompanied homeless
youth; persons living with HIV/AIDS; and victims of domestic violence,
dating violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
(d) Ineligible costs. Any cost that is not described as an eligible
cost under this section is not an eligible cost of providing supportive
services using Continuum of Care program funds. Staff training and the
costs of obtaining professional licenses or certifications needed to
provide supportive services are not eligible costs.
(e) Eligible costs.
(1) Annual Assessment of Service Needs. The costs of the assessment
required by Sec. 578.53(a)(2) are eligible costs.
(2) Assistance with moving costs. Reasonable one-time moving costs
are eligible and include truck rental and hiring a moving company.
[[Page 45454]]
(3) Case management. The costs of assessing, arranging,
coordinating, and monitoring the delivery of individualized services to
meet the needs of the program participant(s) are eligible costs.
Component services and activities consist of:
(i) Counseling;
(ii) Developing, securing, and coordinating services;
(iii) Using the centralized or coordinated assessment system as
required under Sec. 578.23(c)(9).
(iv) Obtaining federal, State, and local benefits;
(v) Monitoring and evaluating program participant progress;
(vi) Providing information and referrals to other providers;
(vii) Providing ongoing risk assessment and safety planning with
victims of domestic violence, dating violence, sexual assault, and
stalking; and
(viii) Developing an individualized housing and service plan,
including planning a path to permanent housing stability.
(4) Child care. The costs of establishing and operating child care,
and providing child-care vouchers, for children from families
experiencing homelessness, including providing meals and snacks, and
comprehensive and coordinated developmental activities, are eligible.
(i) The children must be under the age of 13, unless they are
disabled children.
(ii) Disabled children must be under the age of 18.
(iii) The child-care center must be licensed by the jurisdiction in
which it operates in order for its costs to be eligible.
(5) Education services. The costs of improving knowledge and basic
educational skills are eligible.
(i) Services include instruction or training in consumer education,
health education, substance abuse prevention, literacy, English as a
Second Language, and General Educational Development (GED).
(ii) Component services or activities are screening, assessment and
testing; individual or group instruction; tutoring; provision of books,
supplies, and instructional material; counseling; and referral to
community resources.
(6) Employment assistance and job training. The costs of
establishing and operating employment assistance and job training
programs are eligible, including classroom, online and/or computer
instruction, on-the-job instruction, services that assist individuals
in securing employment, acquiring learning skills, and/or increasing
earning potential. The cost of providing reasonable stipends to program
participants in employment assistance and job training programs is also
an eligible cost.
(i) Learning skills include those skills that can be used to secure
and retain a job, including the acquisition of vocational licenses and/
or certificates.
(ii) Services that assist individuals in securing employment
consist of:
(A) Employment screening, assessment, or testing;
(B) Structured job skills and job-seeking skills;
(C) Special training and tutoring, including literacy training and
pre-vocational training;
(D) Books and instructional material;
(E) Counseling or job coaching; and
(F) Referral to community resources.
(7) Food. The cost of providing meals or groceries to program
participants is eligible.
(8) Housing search and counseling services. Costs of assisting
eligible program participants to locate, obtain, and retain suitable
housing are eligible.
(i) Component services or activities are tenant counseling;
assisting individuals and families to understand leases; securing
utilities; and making moving arrangements.
(ii) Other eligible costs are:
(A) Mediation with property owners and landlords on behalf of
eligible program participants;
(B) Credit counseling, accessing a free personal credit report, and
resolving personal credit issues; and
(C) The payment of rental application fees.
(9) Legal services. Eligible costs are the fees charged by licensed
attorneys and by person(s) under the supervision of licensed attorneys,
for advice and representation in matters that interfere with the
homeless individual or family's ability to obtain and retain housing.
(i) Eligible subject matters are child support; guardianship;
paternity; emancipation; legal separation; orders of protection and
other civil remedies for victims of domestic violence, dating violence,
sexual assault, and stalking; appeal of veterans and public benefit
claim denials; landlord tenant disputes; and the resolution of
outstanding criminal warrants.
(ii) Component services or activities may include receiving and
preparing cases for trial, provision of legal advice, representation at
hearings, and counseling.
(iii) Fees based on the actual service performed (i.e., fee for
service) are also eligible, but only if the cost would be less than the
cost of hourly fees. Filing fees and other necessary court costs are
also eligible. If the subrecipient is a legal services provider and
performs the services itself, the eligible costs are the subrecipient's
employees' salaries and other costs necessary to perform the services.
(iv) Legal services for immigration and citizenship matters and
issues related to mortgages and homeownership are ineligible. Retainer
fee arrangements and contingency fee arrangements are ineligible.
(10) Life skills training. The costs of teaching critical life
management skills that may never have been learned or have been lost
during the course of physical or mental illness, domestic violence,
substance abuse, and homelessness are eligible. These services must be
necessary to assist the program participant to function independently
in the community. Component life skills training are the budgeting of
resources and money management, household management, conflict
management, shopping for food and other needed items, nutrition, the
use of public transportation, and parent training.
(11) Mental health services. Eligible costs are the direct
outpatient treatment of mental health conditions that are provided by
licensed professionals. Component services are crisis interventions;
counseling; individual, family, or group therapy sessions; the
prescription of psychotropic medications or explanations about the use
and management of medications; and combinations of therapeutic
approaches to address multiple problems.
(12) Outpatient health services. Eligible costs are the direct
outpatient treatment of medical conditions when provided by licensed
medical professionals including:
(i) Providing an analysis or assessment of an individual's health
problems and the development of a treatment plan;
(ii) Assisting individuals to understand their health needs;
(iii) Providing directly or assisting individuals to obtain and
utilize appropriate medical treatment;
(iv) Preventive medical care and health maintenance services,
including in-home health services and emergency medical services;
(v) Provision of appropriate medication;
(vi) Providing follow-up services; and
(vii) Preventive and noncosmetic dental care.
(13) Outreach services. The costs of activities to engage persons
for the purpose of providing immediate support and intervention, as
well as identifying
[[Page 45455]]
potential program participants, are eligible.
(i) Eligible costs include the outreach worker's transportation
costs and a cell phone to be used by the individual performing the
outreach.
(ii) Component activities and services consist of: initial
assessment; crisis counseling; addressing urgent physical needs, such
as providing meals, blankets, clothes, or toiletries; actively
connecting and providing people with information and referrals to
homeless and mainstream programs; and publicizing the availability of
the housing and/or services provided within the geographic area covered
by the Continuum of Care.
(14) Substance abuse treatment services. The costs of program
participant intake and assessment, outpatient treatment, group and
individual counseling, and drug testing are eligible. Inpatient
detoxification and other inpatient drug or alcohol treatment are
ineligible.
(15) Transportation. Eligible costs are:
(i) The costs of program participant's travel on public
transportation or in a vehicle provided by the recipient or
subrecipient to and from medical care, employment, child care, or other
services eligible under this section.
(ii) Mileage allowance for service workers to visit program
participants and to carry out housing quality inspections;
(iii) The cost of purchasing or leasing a vehicle in which staff
transports program participants and/or staff serving program
participants;
(iv) The cost of gas, insurance, taxes, and maintenance for the
vehicle;
(v) The costs of recipient or subrecipient staff to accompany or
assist program participants to utilize public transportation; and
(vi) If public transportation options are not sufficient within the
area, the recipient may make a one-time payment on behalf of a program
participant needing car repairs or maintenance required to operate a
personal vehicle, subject to the following:
(A) Payments for car repairs or maintenance on behalf of the
program participant may not exceed 10 percent of the Blue Book value of
the vehicle (Blue Book refers to the guidebook that compiles and quotes
prices for new and used automobiles and other vehicles of all makes,
models, and types);
(B) Payments for car repairs or maintenance must be paid by the
recipient or subrecipient directly to the third party that repairs or
maintains the car; and
(C) The recipients or subrecipients may require program
participants to share in the cost of car repairs or maintenance as a
condition of receiving assistance with car repairs or maintenance.
(16) Utility deposits. This form of assistance consists of paying
for utility deposits. Utility deposits must be a one-time fee, paid to
utility companies.
(17) Direct provision of services. If the service described in
paragraphs (e)(1) through (e)(16) of this section is being directly
delivered by the recipient or subrecipient, eligible costs for those
services also include:
(i) The costs of labor or supplies, and materials incurred by the
recipient or subrecipient in directly providing supportive services to
program participants; and
(ii) The salary and benefit packages of the recipient and
subrecipient staff who directly deliver the services.
Sec. 578.55 Operating costs.
(a) Use. Grant funds may be used to pay the costs of the day-to-day
operation of transitional and permanent housing in a single structure
or individual housing units.
(b) Eligible costs. (1) The maintenance and repair of housing;
(2) Property taxes and insurance;
(3) Scheduled payments to a reserve for replacement of major
systems of the housing (provided that the payments must be based on the
useful life of the system and expected replacement cost);
(4) Building security for a structure where more than 50 percent of
the units or area is paid for with grant funds;
(5) Electricity, gas, and water;
(6) Furniture; and
(7) Equipment.
(c) Ineligible costs. Program funds may not be used for rental
assistance and operating costs in the same project. Program funds may
not be used for the operating costs of emergency shelter- and
supportive service-only facilities. Program funds may not be used for
the maintenance and repair of housing where the costs of maintaining
and repairing the housing are included in the lease.
Sec. 578.57 Homeless Management Information System.
(a) Eligible costs. (1) The recipient or subrecipient may use
Continuum of Care program funds to pay the costs of contributing data
to the HMIS designated by the Continuum of Care, including the costs
of:
(i) Purchasing or leasing computer hardware;
(ii) Purchasing software or software licenses;
(iii) Purchasing or leasing equipment, including telephones, fax
machines, and furniture;
(iv) Obtaining technical support;
(v) Leasing office space;
(vi) Paying charges for electricity, gas, water, phone service, and
high-speed data transmission necessary to operate or contribute data to
the HMIS;
(vii) Paying salaries for operating HMIS, including:
(A) Completing data entry;
(B) Monitoring and reviewing data quality;
(C) Completing data analysis;
(D) Reporting to the HMIS Lead;
(E) Training staff on using the HMIS; and
(F) Implementing and complying with HMIS requirements;
(viii) Paying costs of staff to travel to and attend HUD-sponsored
and HUD-approved training on HMIS and programs authorized by Title IV
of the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act;
(ix) Paying staff travel costs to conduct intake; and
(x) Paying participation fees charged by the HMIS Lead, as
authorized by HUD, if the recipient or subrecipient is not the HMIS
Lead.
(2) If the recipient or subrecipient is the HMIS Lead, it may also
use Continuum of Care funds to pay the costs of:
(i) Hosting and maintaining HMIS software or data;
(ii) Backing up, recovering, or repairing HMIS software or data;
(iii) Upgrading, customizing, and enhancing the HMIS;
(iv) Integrating and warehousing data, including development of a
data warehouse for use in aggregating data from subrecipients using
multiple software systems;
(v) Administering the system;
(vi) Reporting to providers, the Continuum of Care, and HUD; and
(vii) Conducting training on using the system, including traveling
to the training.
(3) If the recipient or subrecipient is a victim services provider,
or a legal services provider, it may use Continuum of Care funds to
establish and operate a comparable database that complies with HUD's
HMIS requirements.
(b) General restrictions. Activities funded under this section must
comply with the HMIS requirements.
Sec. 578.59 Project administrative costs.
(a) Eligible costs. The recipient or subrecipient may use up to 10
percent of any grant awarded under this part, excluding the amount for
Continuum of Care Planning Activities and UFA costs, for the payment of
project administrative costs related to the planning and execution of
Continuum
[[Page 45456]]
of Care activities. This does not include staff and overhead costs
directly related to carrying out activities eligible under Sec. 578.43
through Sec. 578.57, because those costs are eligible as part of those
activities. Eligible administrative costs include:
(1) General management, oversight, and coordination. Costs of
overall program management, coordination, monitoring, and evaluation.
These costs include, but are not limited to, necessary expenditures for
the following:
(i) Salaries, wages, and related costs of the recipient's staff,
the staff of subrecipients, or other staff engaged in program
administration. In charging costs to this category, the recipient may
include the entire salary, wages, and related costs allocable to the
program of each person whose primary responsibilities with regard to
the program involve program administration assignments, or the pro rata
share of the salary, wages, and related costs of each person whose job
includes any program administration assignments. The recipient may use
only one of these methods for each fiscal year grant. Program
administration assignments include the following:
(A) Preparing program budgets and schedules, and amendments to
those budgets and schedules;
(B) Developing systems for assuring compliance with program
requirements;
(C) Developing agreements with subrecipients and contractors to
carry out program activities;
(D) Monitoring program activities for progress and compliance with
program requirements;
(E) Preparing reports and other documents directly related to the
program for submission to HUD;
(F) Coordinating the resolution of audit and monitoring findings;
(G) Evaluating program results against stated objectives; and
(H) Managing or supervising persons whose primary responsibilities
with regard to the program include such assignments as those described
in paragraph (a)(1)(i)(A) through (G) of this section.
(ii) Travel costs incurred for monitoring of subrecipients;
(iii) Administrative services performed under third-party contracts
or agreements, including general legal services, accounting services,
and audit services; and
(iv) Other costs for goods and services required for administration
of the program, including rental or purchase of equipment, insurance,
utilities, office supplies, and rental and maintenance (but not
purchase) of office space.
(2) Training on Continuum of Care requirements. Costs of providing
training on Continuum of Care requirements and attending HUD-sponsored
Continuum of Care trainings.
(3) Environmental review. Costs of carrying out the environmental
review responsibilities under Sec. 578.31.
(b) Sharing requirement. (1) UFAs. If the recipient is a UFA that
carries out a project, it may use up to 10 percent of the grant amount
awarded for the project on project administrative costs. The UFA must
share the remaining project administrative funds with its
subrecipients.
(2) Recipients that are not UFAs. If the recipient is not a UFA, it
must share at least 50 percent of project administrative funds with its
subrecipients.
Sec. 578.61 Relocation costs.
(a) In general. Relocation costs under the Uniform Relocation
Assistance and Real Property Acquisition Policies Act of 1970 are
eligible.
(b) Eligible relocation costs. Eligible costs are costs to provide
relocation payments and other assistance to persons displaced by a
project assisted with grant funds in accordance with Sec. 578.83.
Sec. 578.63 Indirect costs.
(a) In general. Continuum of Care funds may be used to pay indirect
costs in accordance with OMB Circulars A-87 or A-122, as applicable.
(b) Allocation. Indirect costs may be allocated to each eligible
activity as provided in subpart D, so long as that allocation is
consistent with an indirect cost rate proposal developed in accordance
with OMB Circulars A-87 or A-122, as applicable.
(c) Expenditure limits. The indirect costs charged to an activity
subject to an expenditure limit under Sec. Sec. 578.39, 578.41, and
578.59 must be added to the direct costs charged for that activity when
determining the total costs subject to the expenditure limits.
Subpart E--High-Performing Communities
Sec. 578.65 Standards.
(a) In general. The collaborative applicant for a Continuum may
apply to HUD to have the Continuum be designated a high-performing
community (HPC). The designation shall be for grants awarded in the
same competition in which the designation is applied for and made.
(b) Applying for HPC designation. The application must be submitted
at such time and in such manner as HUD may require, must use HMIS data
where required to show the standards for qualifying are met, and must
contain such information as HUD requires, including at a minimum:
(1) A report showing how the Continuum of Care program funds
received in the preceding year were expended;
(2) A specific plan for how grant funds will be expended; and
(3) Information establishing that the Continuum of Care meets the
standards for HPCs.
(c) Standards for qualifying as an HPC. To qualify as an HPC, a
Continuum must demonstrate through:
(1) Reliable data generated by the Continuum of Care's HMIS that it
meets all of the following standards:
(i) Mean length of homelessness. Either the mean length of episode
of homelessness within the Continuum's geographic area is fewer than 20
days, or the mean length of episodes of homelessness for individuals or
families in similar circumstances was reduced by at least 10 percent
from the preceding federal fiscal year.
(ii) Reduced recidivism. Of individuals and families who leave
homelessness, less than 5 percent become homeless again at any time
within the next 2 years; or the percentage of individuals and families
in similar circumstances who become homeless again within 2 years after
leaving homelessness was decreased by at least 20 percent from the
preceding federal fiscal year.
(iii) HMIS coverage. The Continuum's HMIS must have a bed coverage
rate of 80 percent and a service volume coverage rate of 80 percent as
calculated in accordance with HUD's HMIS requirements.
(iv) Serving families and youth. With respect to Continuums that
served homeless families and youth defined as homeless under other
federal statutes in paragraph (3) of the definition of homeless in
Sec. 576.2:
(A) 95 percent of those families and youth did not become homeless
again within a 2-year period following termination of assistance; or
(B) 85 percent of those families achieved independent living in
permanent housing for at least 2 years following termination of
assistance.
(2) Reliable data generated from sources other than the Continuum's
HMIS that is provided in a narrative or other form prescribed by HUD
that it meets both of the following standards:
(i) Community action. All the metropolitan cities and counties
within the Continuum's geographic area have a
[[Page 45457]]
comprehensive outreach plan, including specific steps for identifying
homeless persons and referring them to appropriate housing and services
in that geographic area.
(ii) Renewing HPC status. If the Continuum was designated an HPC in
the previous federal fiscal year and used Continuum of Care grant funds
for activities described under Sec. 578.71, that such activities were
effective at reducing the number of individuals and families who became
homeless in that community.
Sec. 578.67 Publication of application.
HUD will publish the application to be designated an HPC through
the HUD Web site, for public comment as to whether the Continuum
seeking designation as an HPC meets the standards for being one.
Sec. 578.69 Cooperation among entities.
An HPC must cooperate with HUD in distributing information about
its successful efforts to reduce homelessness.
Sec. 578.71 HPC-eligible activities.
In addition to using grant funds for the eligible costs described
in subpart D of this part, recipients and subrecipients in Continuums
of Care designated as HPCs may also use grant funds to provide housing
relocation and stabilization services and short- and/or medium-term
rental assistance to individuals and families at risk of homelessness
as set forth in 24 CFR 576.103 and 24 CFR 576.104, if necessary to
prevent the individual or family from becoming homeless. Activities
must be carried out in accordance with the plan submitted in the
application. When carrying out housing relocation and stabilization
services and short- and/or medium-term rental assistance, the written
standards set forth in Sec. 578.7(a)(9)(v) and recordkeeping
requirements of 24 CFR 576.500 apply.
Subpart F--Program Requirements
Sec. 578.73 Matching requirements.
(a) In general. The recipient or subrecipient must match all grant
funds, except for leasing funds, with no less than 25 percent of funds
or in-kind contributions from other sources. For Continuum of Care
geographic areas in which there is more than one grant agreement, the
25 percent match must be provided on a grant-by-grant basis. Recipients
that are UFAs or are the sole recipient for their Continuum, may
provide match on a Continuum-wide basis. Cash match must be used for
the costs of activities that are eligible under subpart D of this part,
except that HPCs may use such match for the costs of activities that
are eligible under Sec. 578.71.
(b) Cash sources. A recipient or subrecipient may use funds from
any source, including any other federal sources (excluding Continuum of
Care program funds), as well as State, local, and private sources,
provided that funds from the source are not statutorily prohibited to
be used as a match. The recipient must ensure that any funds used to
satisfy the matching requirements of this section are eligible under
the laws governing the funds in order to be used as matching funds for
a grant awarded under this program.
(c) In-kind contributions. (1) The recipient or subrecipient may
use the value of any real property, equipment, goods, or services
contributed to the project as match, provided that if the recipient or
subrecipient had to pay for them with grant funds, the costs would have
been eligible under Subpart D, or, in the case of HPCs, eligible under
Sec. 578.71.
(2) The requirements of 24 CFR 84.23 and 85.24 apply.
(3) Before grant execution, services to be provided by a third
party must be documented by a memorandum of understanding (MOU) between
the recipient or subrecipient and the third party that will provide the
services. Services provided by individuals must be valued at rates
consistent with those ordinarily paid for similar work in the
recipient's or subrecipient's organization. If the recipient or
subrecipient does not have employees performing similar work, the rates
must be consistent with those ordinarily paid by other employers for
similar work in the same labor market.
(i) The MOU must establish the unconditional commitment, except for
selection to receive a grant, by the third party to provide the
services, the specific service to be provided, the profession of the
persons providing the service, and the hourly cost of the service to be
provided.
(ii) During the term of the grant, the recipient or subrecipient
must keep and make available, for inspection, records documenting the
service hours provided.
Sec. 578.75 General operations.
(a) State and local requirements. (1) Housing and facilities
constructed or rehabilitated with assistance under this part must meet
State or local building codes, and in the absence of State or local
building codes, the International Residential Code or International
Building Code (as applicable to the type of structure) of the
International Code Council.
(2) Services provided with assistance under this part must be
provided in compliance with all applicable State and local
requirements, including licensing requirements.
(b) Housing quality standards. Housing leased with Continuum of
Care program funds, or for which rental assistance payments are made
with Continuum of Care program funds, must meet the applicable housing
quality standards (HQS) under 24 CFR 982.401 of this title, except that
24 CFR 982.401(j) applies only to housing occupied by program
participants receiving tenant-based rental assistance. For housing
rehabilitated with funds under this part, the lead-based paint
requirements in 24 CFR part 35, subparts A, B, J, and R apply. For
housing that receives project-based or sponsor-based rental assistance,
24 CFR part 35, subparts A, B, H, and R apply. For residential property
for which funds under this part are used for acquisition, leasing,
services, or operating costs, 24 CFR part 35, subparts A, B, K, and R
apply.
(1) Before any assistance will be provided on behalf of a program
participant, the recipient, or subrecipient, must physically inspect
each unit to assure that the unit meets HQS. Assistance will not be
provided for units that fail to meet HQS, unless the owner corrects any
deficiencies within 30 days from the date of the initial inspection and
the recipient or subrecipient verifies that all deficiencies have been
corrected.
(2) Recipients or subrecipients must inspect all units at least
annually during the grant period to ensure that the units continue to
meet HQS.
(c) Suitable dwelling size. The dwelling unit must have at least
one bedroom or living/sleeping room for each two persons.
(1) Children of opposite sex, other than very young children, may
not be required to occupy the same bedroom or living/sleeping room.
(2) If household composition changes during the term of assistance,
recipients and subrecipients may relocate the household to a more
appropriately sized unit. The household must still have access to
appropriate supportive services.
(d) Meals. Each recipient and subrecipient of assistance under this
part who provides supportive housing for homeless persons with
disabilities must provide meals or meal preparation facilities for
residents.
(e) Ongoing assessment of supportive services. To the extent
practicable, each
[[Page 45458]]
project must provide supportive services for residents of the project
and homeless persons using the project, which may be designed by the
recipient or participants. Each recipient and subrecipient of
assistance under this part must conduct an ongoing assessment of the
supportive services needed by the residents of the project, the
availability of such services, and the coordination of services needed
to ensure long-term housing stability and must make adjustments, as
appropriate.
(f) Residential supervision. Each recipient and subrecipient of
assistance under this part must provide residential supervision as
necessary to facilitate the adequate provision of supportive services
to the residents of the housing throughout the term of the commitment
to operate supportive housing. Residential supervision may include the
employment of a full- or part-time residential supervisor with
sufficient knowledge to provide or to supervise the provision of
supportive services to the residents.
(g) Participation of homeless individuals. (1) Each recipient and
subrecipient must provide for the participation of not less than one
homeless individual or formerly homeless individual on the board of
directors or other equivalent policymaking entity of the recipient or
subrecipient, to the extent that such entity considers and makes
policies and decisions regarding any project, supportive services, or
assistance provided under this part. This requirement is waived if a
recipient or subrecipient is unable to meet such requirement and
obtains HUD approval for a plan to otherwise consult with homeless or
formerly homeless persons when considering and making policies and
decisions.
(2) Each recipient and subrecipient of assistance under this part
must, to the maximum extent practicable, involve homeless individuals
and families through employment; volunteer services; or otherwise in
constructing, rehabilitating, maintaining, and operating the project,
and in providing supportive services for the project.
(h) Supportive service agreement. Recipients and subrecipients may
require the program participants to take part in supportive services
that are not disability-related services provided through the project
as a condition of continued participation in the program. Examples of
disability-related services include, but are not limited to, mental
health services, outpatient health services, and provision of
medication, which are provided to a person with a disability to address
a condition caused by the disability. Notwithstanding this provision,
if the purpose of the project is to provide substance abuse treatment
services, recipients and subrecipients may require program participants
to take part in such services as a condition of continued participation
in the program.
(i) Retention of assistance after death, incarceration, or
institutionalization for more than 90 days of qualifying member. For
permanent supportive housing projects surviving, members of any
household who were living in a unit assisted under this part at the
time of the qualifying member's death, long-term incarceration, or
long-term institutionalization, have the right to rental assistance
under this section until the expiration of the lease in effect at the
time of the qualifying member's death, long-term incarceration, or
long-term institutionalization.
Sec. 578.77 Calculating occupancy charges and rent.
(a) Occupancy agreements and leases. Recipients and subrecipients
must have signed occupancy agreements or leases (or subleases) with
program participants residing in housing.
(b) Calculation of occupancy charges. Recipients and subrecipients
are not required to impose occupancy charges on program participants as
a condition of residing in the housing. However, if occupancy charges
are imposed, they may not exceed the highest of:
(1) 30 percent of the family's monthly adjusted income (adjustment
factors include the number of people in the family, age of family
members, medical expenses, and child-care expenses);
(2) 10 percent of the family's monthly income; or
(3) If the family is receiving payments for welfare assistance from
a public agency and a part of the payments (adjusted in accordance with
the family's actual housing costs) is specifically designated by the
agency to meet the family's housing costs, the portion of the payments
that is designated for housing costs.
(4) Income. Income must be calculated in accordance with 24 CFR
5.609 and 24 CFR 5.611(a). Recipients and subrecipients must examine a
program participant's income initially, and if there is a change in
family composition (e.g., birth of a child) or a decrease in the
resident's income during the year, the resident may request an interim
reexamination, and the occupancy charge will be adjusted accordingly.
(c) Resident rent. (1) Amount of rent. (i) Each program participant
on whose behalf rental assistance payments are made must pay a
contribution toward rent in accordance with section 3(a)(1) of the U.S.
Housing Act of 1937 (42 U.S.C. 1437a(a)(1)).
(ii) Income of program participants must be calculated in
accordance with 24 CFR 5.609 and 24 CFR 5.611(a).
(2) Review. Recipients or subrecipients must examine a program
participant's income initially, and at least annually thereafter, to
determine the amount of the contribution toward rent payable by the
program participant. Adjustments to a program participant's
contribution toward the rental payment must be made as changes in
income are identified.
(3) Verification. As a condition of participation in the program,
each program participant must agree to supply the information or
documentation necessary to verify the program participant's income.
Program participants must provide the recipient or subrecipient with
information at any time regarding changes in income or other
circumstances that may result in changes to a program participant's
contribution toward the rental payment.
Sec. 578.79 Limitation on transitional housing.
A homeless individual or family may remain in transitional housing
for a period longer than 24 months, if permanent housing for the
individual or family has not been located or if the individual or
family requires additional time to prepare for independent living.
However, HUD may discontinue assistance for a transitional housing
project if more than half of the homeless individuals or families
remain in that project longer than 24 months.
Sec. 578.81 Term of commitment, repayment of grants, and prevention
of undue benefits.
(a) In general. All recipients and subrecipients receiving grant
funds for acquisition, rehabilitation, or new construction must operate
the housing or provide supportive services in accordance with this
part, for at least 15 years from the date of initial occupancy or date
of initial service provision. Recipient and subrecipients must execute
and record a HUD-approved Declaration of Restrictive Covenants before
receiving payment of grant funds.
(b) Conversion. Recipients and subrecipients carrying out a project
that provides transitional or permanent housing or supportive services
in a structure may submit a request to HUD to convert a project for the
direct benefit of very low-income persons. The request must be made
while the project is operating as homeless housing or supportive
services for homeless
[[Page 45459]]
individuals and families, must be in writing, and must include an
explanation of why the project is no longer needed to provide
transitional or permanent housing or supportive services. The primary
factor in HUD's decision on the proposed conversion is the unmet need
for transitional or permanent housing or supportive services in the
Continuum of Care's geographic area.
(c) Repayment of grant funds. If a project is not operated as
transitional or permanent housing for 10 years following the date of
initial occupancy, HUD will require repayment of the entire amount of
the grant used for acquisition, rehabilitation, or new construction,
unless conversion of the project has been authorized under paragraph
(b) of this section. If the housing is used for such purposes for more
than 10 years, the payment amount will be reduced by 20 percentage
points for each year, beyond the 10-year period in which the project is
used for transitional or permanent housing.
(d) Prevention of undue benefits. Except as provided under
paragraph (e) of this section, upon any sale or other disposition of a
project site that received grant funds for acquisition, rehabilitation,
or new construction, occurring before the 15-year period, the recipient
must comply with such terms and conditions as HUD may prescribe to
prevent the recipient or subrecipient from unduly benefiting from such
sale or disposition.
(e) Exception. A recipient or subrecipient will not be required to
comply with the terms and conditions prescribed under paragraphs (c)
and (d) of this section if:
(1) The sale or disposition of the property used for the project
results in the use of the property for the direct benefit of very low-
income persons;
(2) All the proceeds are used to provide transitional or permanent
housing that meet the requirements of this part;
(3) Project-based rental assistance or operating cost assistance
from any federal program or an equivalent State or local program is no
longer made available and the project is meeting applicable performance
standards, provided that the portion of the project that had benefitted
from such assistance continues to meet the tenant income and rent
restrictions for low-income units under section 42(g) of the Internal
Revenue Code of 1986; or
(4) There are no individuals and families in the Continuum of Care
geographic area who are homeless, in which case the project may serve
individuals and families at risk of homelessness.
Sec. 578.83 Displacement, relocation, and acquisition.
(a) Minimizing displacement. Consistent with the other goals and
objectives of this part, recipients and subrecipients must ensure that
they have taken all reasonable steps to minimize the displacement of
persons (families, individuals, businesses, nonprofit organizations,
and farms) as a result of projects assisted under this part.
``Project,'' as used in this section, means any activity or series of
activities assisted with Continuum of Care funds received or
anticipated in any phase of an undertaking.
(b) Temporary relocation. (1) Existing Building Not Assisted under
Title IV of the McKinney-Vento Act. No tenant may be required to
relocate temporarily for a project if the building in which the project
is being undertaken or will be undertaken is not currently assisted
under Title IV of the McKinney-Vento Act. The absence of such
assistance to the building means the tenants are not homeless and the
tenants are therefore not eligible to receive assistance under the
Continuum of Care program. When a tenant moves for such a project under
conditions that cause the Uniform Relocation Assistance and Real
Property Acquisition Policies Act of 1970 (URA), 42 U.S.C. 4601-4655,
to apply, the tenant must be treated as permanently displaced and
offered relocation assistance and payments consistent with paragraph
(c) of this section.
(2) Existing Transitional Housing or Permanent Housing Projects
Assisted Under Title IV of the McKinney-Vento Act. Consistent with
paragraph (c)(2)(ii) of this section, no program participant may be
required to relocate temporarily for a project if the person cannot be
offered a decent, safe, and sanitary unit in the same building or
complex upon project completion under reasonable terms and conditions.
The length of occupancy requirements in Sec. 578.79 may prevent a
program participant from returning to the property upon completion (See
paragraph (c)(2)(iii)(D) of this section). Any program participant who
has been temporarily relocated for a period beyond one year must be
treated as permanently displaced and offered relocation assistance and
payments consistent with paragraph (c) of this section. Program
participants temporarily relocated in accordance with the policies
described in this paragraph must be provided:
(i) Reimbursement for all reasonable out-of-pocket expenses
incurred in connection with the temporary relocation, including the
cost of moving to and from the temporarily occupied housing and any
increase in monthly rent/occupancy charges and utility costs; and
(ii) Appropriate advisory services, including reasonable advance
written notice of:
(A) The date and approximate duration of the temporary relocation;
(B) The location of the suitable, decent, safe, and sanitary
dwelling to be made available for the temporary period;
(C) The reasonable terms and conditions under which the program
participant will be able to occupy a suitable, decent, safe, and
sanitary dwelling in the building or complex upon completion of the
project; and
(D) The provisions of paragraph (b)(2)(i) of this section.
(c) Relocation assistance for displaced persons. (1) In general. A
displaced person (defined in paragraph (c)(2) of this section) must be
provided relocation assistance in accordance with the requirements of
the URA and implementing regulations at 49 CFR part 24. A displaced
person must be advised of his or her rights under the Fair Housing Act.
Whenever possible, minority persons must be given reasonable
opportunities to relocate to decent, safe, and sanitary replacement
dwellings, not located in an area of minority concentration, that are
within their financial means. This policy, however, does not require
providing a person a larger payment than is necessary to enable a
person to relocate to a comparable replacement dwelling. See 49 CFR
24.205(c)(2)(ii)(D).
(2) Displaced person. (i) For the purposes of paragraph (c) of this
section, the term ``displaced person'' means any person (family,
individual, business, nonprofit organization, or farm) that moves from
real property, or moves personal property from real property,
permanently, as a direct result of acquisition, rehabilitation, or
demolition for a project. This includes any permanent, involuntary move
for a project, including any permanent move from the real property that
is made:
(A) After the owner (or person in control of the site) issues a
notice to move permanently from the property, or refuses to renew an
expiring lease, if the move occurs after the date of the submission by
the recipient or subrecipient of an application for assistance to HUD
(or the recipient, as applicable) that is later approved and funded and
the recipient or subrecipient has site control as evidenced in
accordance with Sec. 578.25(b); or
[[Page 45460]]
(B) After the owner (or person in control of the site) issues a
notice to move permanently from the property, or refuses to renew an
expiring lease, if the move occurs after the date the recipient or
subrecipient obtains site control, as evidenced in accordance with
Sec. 578.25(b), if that occurs after the application for assistance;
or
(C) Before the date described under paragraph (c)(2)(i)(A) or (B)
of this section, if the recipient or HUD determines that the
displacement resulted directly from acquisition, rehabilitation, or
demolition for the project; or
(D) By a tenant of a building that is not assisted under Title IV
of the McKinney-Vento Act, if the tenant moves after execution of the
agreement covering the acquisition, rehabilitation, or demolition of
the property for the project; or
(ii) For the purposes of paragraph (c) of this section, the term
``displaced person'' means any person (family, individual, business,
nonprofit organization, or farm) that moves from real property, or
moves personal property from real property, permanently, as a direct
result of acquisition, rehabilitation, or demolition for a project.
This includes any permanent, involuntary move for a project that is
made by a program participant occupying transitional housing or
permanent housing assisted under Title IV of the McKinney-Vento Act, if
any one of the following three situations occurs:
(A) The program participant moves after execution of the agreement
covering the acquisition, rehabilitation, or demolition of the property
for the project and is either not eligible to return upon project
completion or the move occurs before the program participant is
provided written notice offering the program participant an opportunity
to occupy a suitable, decent, safe, and sanitary dwelling in the same
building or complex upon project completion under reasonable terms and
conditions. Such reasonable terms and conditions must include a lease
(or occupancy agreement, as applicable) consistent with Continuum of
Care program requirements, including a monthly rent or occupancy charge
and monthly utility costs that does not exceed the maximum amounts
established in Sec. 578.77; or
(B) The program participant is required to relocate temporarily,
does not return to the building or complex, and any one of the
following situations occurs:
(1) The program participant is not offered payment for all
reasonable out-of-pocket expenses incurred in connection with the
temporary relocation;
(2) The program participant is not eligible to return to the
building or complex upon project completion; or
(3) Other conditions of the temporary relocation are not
reasonable; or
(C) The program participant is required to move to another unit in
the same building or complex, and any one of the following situations
occurs:
(1) The program participant is not offered reimbursement for all
reasonable out-of-pocket expenses incurred in connection with the move;
(2) The program participant is not eligible to remain in the
building or complex upon project completion; or
(3) Other conditions of the move are not reasonable.
(iii) Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph (c)(2)(i) or (ii)
of this section, a person does not qualify as a ``displaced person''
if:
(A) The person has been evicted for serious or repeated violation
of the terms and conditions of the lease or occupancy agreement; the
eviction complied with applicable federal, State, or local requirements
(see Sec. 578.91); and the recipient or subrecipient determines that
the eviction was not undertaken for the purpose of evading the
obligation to provide relocation assistance;
(B) The person moved into the property after the submission of the
application but, before signing a lease or occupancy agreement and
commencing occupancy, was provided written notice of the project's
possible impact on the person (e.g., the person may be displaced,
temporarily relocated, or incur a rent increase) and the fact that the
person would not qualify as a ``displaced person'' (or for any
relocation assistance provided under this section), as a result of the
project;
(C) The person is ineligible under 49 CFR 24.2(a)(9)(ii));
(D) The person is a program participant occupying transitional
housing or permanent housing assisted under Title IV of the Act who
must move as a direct result of the length-of- occupancy restriction
under Sec. 578.79; or
(E) HUD determines that the person was not displaced as a direct
result of acquisition, rehabilitation, or demolition for the project.
(iv) The recipient may request, at any time, HUD's determination of
whether a displacement is or would be covered under this section.
(3) Initiation of negotiations. For purposes of determining the
formula for computing replacement housing payment assistance to be
provided to a displaced person pursuant to this section, if the
displacement is a direct result of privately undertaken rehabilitation,
demolition, or acquisition of the real property, ``initiation of
negotiations'' means the execution of the agreement between the
recipient and the subrecipient, or between the recipient (or
subrecipient, as applicable) and the person owning or controlling the
property. In the case of an option contract to acquire property, the
initiation of negotiations does not become effective until execution of
a written agreement that creates a legally enforceable commitment to
proceed with the purchase, such as a purchase agreement.
(d) Real property acquisition requirements. Except for acquisitions
described in 49 CFR 24.101(b)(1) through (5), the URA and the
requirements of 49 CFR part 24, subpart B apply to any acquisition of
real property for a project where there are Continuum of Care funds in
any part of the project costs.
(e) Appeals. A person who disagrees with the recipient's (or
subrecipient's, if applicable) determination concerning whether the
person qualifies as a displaced person, or the amount of relocation
assistance for which the person is eligible, may file a written appeal
of that determination with the recipient (see 49 CFR 24.10). A low-
income person who is dissatisfied with the recipient's determination on
his or her appeal may submit a written request for review of that
determination to the local HUD field office.
Sec. 578.85 Timeliness standards.
(a) In general. Recipients must initiate approved activities and
projects promptly.
(b) Construction activities. Recipients of funds for rehabilitation
or new construction must meet the following standards:
(1) Construction activities must begin within 9 months of the later
of signing of the grant agreement or of signing an addendum to the
grant agreement authorizing use of grant funds for the project.
(2) Construction activities must be completed within 24 months of
signing the grant agreement.
(3) Activities that cannot begin until after construction
activities are completed must begin within 3 months of the date that
construction activities are completed.
(c) Distribution. A recipient that receives funds through this part
must:
(1) Distribute the funds to subrecipients (in advance of
expenditures by the subrecipients);
[[Page 45461]]
(2) Distribute the appropriate portion of the funds to a
subrecipient no later than 45 days after receiving an approvable
request for such distribution from the subrecipient; and
(3) Draw down funds at least once per quarter of the program year,
after eligible activities commence.
Sec. 578.87 Limitation on use of funds.
(a) Maintenance of effort. No assistance provided under this part
(or any State or local government funds used to supplement this
assistance) may be used to replace State or local funds previously
used, or designated for use, to assist homeless persons.
(b) Faith-based activities. (1) Equal treatment of program
participants and program beneficiaries. (i) Program participants.
Organizations that are religious or faith-based are eligible, on the
same basis as any other organization, to participate in the Continuum
of Care program. Neither the Federal Government nor a State or local
government receiving funds under the Continuum of Care program shall
discriminate against an organization on the basis of the organization's
religious character or affiliation. Recipients and subrecipients of
program funds shall not, in providing program assistance, discriminate
against a program participant or prospective program participant on the
basis of religion or religious belief.
(ii) Beneficiaries. In providing services supported in whole or in
part with federal financial assistance, and in their outreach
activities related to such services, program participants shall not
discriminate against current or prospective program beneficiaries on
the basis of religion, a religious belief, a refusal to hold a
religious belief, or a refusal to attend or participate in a religious
practice.
(2) Separation of explicitly religious activities. Recipients and
subrecipients of Continuum of Care funds that engage in explicitly
religious activities, including activities that involve overt religious
content such as worship, religious instruction, or proselytization,
must perform such activities and offer such services outside of
programs that are supported with federal financial assistance
separately, in time or location, from the programs or services funded
under this part, and participation in any such explicitly religious
activities must be voluntary for the program beneficiaries of the HUD-
funded programs or services.
(3) Religious identity. A faith-based organization that is a
recipient or subrecipient of Continuum of Care program funds is
eligible to use such funds as provided under the regulations of this
part without impairing its independence, autonomy, expression of
religious beliefs, or religious character. Such organization will
retain its independence from federal, State, and local government, and
may continue to carry out its mission, including the definition,
development, practice, and expression of its religious beliefs,
provided that it does not use direct program funds to support or engage
in any explicitly religious activities, including activities that
involve overt religious content, such as worship, religious
instruction, or proselytization, or any manner prohibited by law. Among
other things, faith-based organizations may use space in their
facilities to provide program-funded services, without removing or
altering religious art, icons, scriptures, or other religious symbols.
In addition, a Continuum of Care program-funded religious organization
retains its authority over its internal governance, and it may retain
religious terms in its organization's name, select its board members on
a religious basis, and include religious references in its
organization's mission statements and other governing documents.
(4) Alternative provider. If a program participant or prospective
program participant of the Continuum of Care program supported by HUD
objects to the religious character of an organization that provides
services under the program, that organization shall, within a
reasonably prompt time after the objection, undertake reasonable
efforts to identify and refer the program participant to an alternative
provider to which the prospective program participant has no objection.
Except for services provided by telephone, the Internet, or similar
means, the referral must be to an alternate provider in reasonable
geographic proximity to the organization making the referral. In making
the referral, the organization shall comply with applicable privacy
laws and regulations. Recipients and subrecipients shall document any
objections from program participants and prospective program
participants and any efforts to refer such participants to alternative
providers in accordance with the requirements of Sec. 578.103(a)(13).
Recipients shall ensure that all subrecipient agreements make
organizations receiving program funds aware of these requirements.
(5) Structures. Program funds may not be used for the acquisition,
construction, or rehabilitation of structures to the extent that those
structures are used for explicitly religious activities. Program funds
may be used for the acquisition, construction, or rehabilitation of
structures only to the extent that those structures are used for
conducting eligible activities under this part. When a structure is
used for both eligible and explicitly religious activities, program
funds may not exceed the cost of those portions of the acquisition, new
construction, or rehabilitation that are attributable to eligible
activities in accordance with the cost accounting requirements
applicable to the Continuum of Care program. Sanctuaries, chapels, or
other rooms that a Continuum of Care program-funded religious
congregation uses as its principal place of worship, however, are
ineligible for Continuum of Care program-funded improvements.
Disposition of real property after the term of the grant, or any change
in the use of the property during the term of the grant, is subject to
governmentwide regulations governing real property disposition (see 24
CFR parts 84 and 85).
(6) Supplemental funds. If a State or local government voluntarily
contributes its own funds to supplement federally funded activities,
the State or local government has the option to segregate the federal
funds or commingle them. However, if the funds are commingled, this
section applies to all of the commingled funds.
(c) Restriction on combining funds. In a single structure or
housing unit, the following types of assistance may not be combined:
(1) Leasing and acquisition, rehabilitation, or new construction;
(2) Tenant-based rental assistance and acquisition, rehabilitation,
or new construction;
(3) Short- or medium-term rental assistance and acquisition,
rehabilitation, or new construction;
(4) Rental assistance and leasing; or
(5) Rental assistance and operating.
(d) Program fees. Recipients and subrecipients may not charge
program participants program fees.
Sec. 578.89 Limitation on use of grant funds to serve persons defined
as homeless under other federal laws.
(a) Application requirement. Applicants that intend to serve
unaccompanied youth and families with children and youth defined as
homeless under other federal laws in paragraph (3) of the homeless
definition in Sec. 576.2 must demonstrate in their application, to
HUD's satisfaction, that the use of grant funds to serve such persons
is an equal or greater priority than serving persons defined as
homeless under paragraphs (1), (2), and (4) of the
[[Page 45462]]
definition of homeless in Sec. 576.2. To demonstrate that it is of
equal or greater priority, applicants must show that it is equally or
more cost effective in meeting the overall goals and objectives of the
plan submitted under section 427(b)(1)(B) of the Act, especially with
respect to children and unaccompanied youth.
(b) Limit. No more than 10 percent of the funds awarded to
recipients within a single Continuum of Care's geographic area may be
used to serve such persons.
(c) Exception. The 10 percent limitation does not apply to
Continuums in which the rate of homelessness, as calculated in the most
recent point-in-time count, is less than one-tenth of one percent of
the total population.
Sec. 578.91 Termination of assistance to program participants.
(a) Termination of assistance. The recipient or subrecipient may
terminate assistance to a program participant who violates program
requirements or conditions of occupancy. Termination under this section
does not bar the recipient or subrecipient from providing further
assistance at a later date to the same individual or family.
(b) Due process. In terminating assistance to a program
participant, the recipient or subrecipient must provide a formal
process that recognizes the rights of individuals receiving assistance
under the due process of law. This process, at a minimum, must consist
of:
(1) Providing the program participant with a written copy of the
program rules and the termination process before the participant begins
to receive assistance;
(2) Written notice to the program participant containing a clear
statement of the reasons for termination;
(3) A review of the decision, in which the program participant is
given the opportunity to present written or oral objections before a
person other than the person (or a subordinate of that person) who made
or approved the termination decision; and
(4) Prompt written notice of the final decision to the program
participant.
(c) Hard-to-house populations. Recipients and subrecipients that
are providing permanent supportive housing for hard-to-house
populations of homeless persons must exercise judgment and examine all
extenuating circumstances in determining when violations are serious
enough to warrant termination so that a program participant's
assistance is terminated only in the most severe cases.
Sec. 578.93 Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity.
(a) Nondiscrimination and equal opportunity requirements. The
nondiscrimination and equal opportunity requirements set forth in 24
CFR 5.105(a) are applicable.
(b) Housing for specific subpopulations. Recipients and
subrecipients may exclusively serve a particular homeless subpopulation
in transitional or permanent housing if the housing addresses a need
identified by the Continuum of Care for the geographic area and meets
one of the following:
(1) The housing may be limited to one sex where such housing
consists of a single structure with shared bedrooms or bathing
facilities such that the considerations of personal privacy and the
physical limitations of the configuration of the housing make it
appropriate for the housing to be limited to one sex;
(2) The housing may be limited to a specific subpopulation, so long
as admission does not discriminate against any protected class under
federal nondiscrimination laws in 24 CFR 5.105 (e.g., the housing may
be limited to homeless veterans, victims of domestic violence and their
children, or chronically homeless persons and families).
(3) The housing may be limited to families with children.
(4) If the housing has in residence at least one family with a
child under the age of 18, the housing may exclude registered sex
offenders and persons with a criminal record that includes a violent
crime from the project so long as the child resides in the housing.
(5) Sober housing may exclude persons who refuse to sign an
occupancy agreement or lease that prohibits program participants from
possessing, using, or being under the influence of illegal substances
and/or alcohol on the premises.
(6) If the housing is assisted with funds under a federal program
that is limited by federal statute or Executive Order to a specific
subpopulation, the housing may be limited to that subpopulation (e.g.,
housing also assisted with funding from the Housing Opportunities for
Persons with AIDS program under 24 CFR part 574 may be limited to
persons with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome or related diseases).
(7) Recipients may limit admission to or provide a preference for
the housing to subpopulations of homeless persons and families who need
the specialized supportive services that are provided in the housing
(e.g., substance abuse addiction treatment, domestic violence services,
or a high intensity package designed to meet the needs of hard-to-reach
homeless persons). While the housing may offer services for a
particular type of disability, no otherwise eligible individuals with
disabilities or families including an individual with a disability, who
may benefit from the services provided may be excluded on the grounds
that they do not have a particular disability.
(c) Affirmatively furthering fair housing. A recipient must
implement its programs in a manner that affirmatively furthers fair
housing, which means that the recipient must:
(1) Affirmatively market their housing and supportive services to
eligible persons regardless of race, color, national origin, religion,
sex, age, familial status, or handicap who are least likely to apply in
the absence of special outreach, and maintain records of those
marketing activities;
(2) Where a recipient encounters a condition or action that impedes
fair housing choice for current or prospective program participants,
provide such information to the jurisdiction that provided the
certification of consistency with the Consolidated Plan; and
(3) Provide program participants with information on rights and
remedies available under applicable federal, State and local fair
housing and civil rights laws.
(d) Accessibility and integrative housing and services for persons
with disabilities. Recipients and subrecipients must comply with the
accessibility requirements of the Fair Housing Act (24 CFR part 100),
Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (24 CFR part 8), and
Titles II and III of the Americans with Disabilities Act, as applicable
(28 CFR parts 35 and 36). In accordance with the requirements of 24 CFR
8.4(d), recipients must ensure that their program's housing and
supportive services are provided in the most integrated setting
appropriate to the needs of persons with disabilities.
(e) Prohibition against involuntary family separation. The age and
gender of a child under age 18 must not be used as a basis for denying
any family's admission to a project that receives funds under this
part.
Sec. 578.95 Conflicts of interest.
(a) Procurement. For the procurement of property (goods, supplies,
or equipment) and services, the recipient and its subrecipients must
comply with the codes of conduct and conflict-of-interest requirements
under 24 CFR 85.36 (for governments) and 24 CFR
[[Page 45463]]
84.42 (for private nonprofit organizations).
(b) Continuum of Care board members. No Continuum of Care board
member may participate in or influence discussions or resulting
decisions concerning the award of a grant or other financial benefits
to the organization that the member represents.
(c) Organizational conflict. An organizational conflict of interest
arises when, because of activities or relationships with other persons
or organizations, the recipient or subrecipient is unable or
potentially unable to render impartial assistance in the provision of
any type or amount of assistance under this part, or when a covered
person's, as in paragraph (d)(1) of this section, objectivity in
performing work with respect to any activity assisted under this part
is or might be otherwise impaired. Such an organizational conflict
would arise when a board member of an applicant participates in
decision of the applicant concerning the award of a grant, or provision
of other financial benefits, to the organization that such member
represents. It would also arise when an employee of a recipient or
subrecipient participates in making rent reasonableness determinations
under Sec. 578.49(b)(2) and Sec. 578.51(g) and housing quality
inspections of property under Sec. 578.75(b) that the recipient,
subrecipient, or related entity owns.
(d) Other conflicts. For all other transactions and activities, the
following restrictions apply:
(1) No covered person, meaning a person who is an employee, agent,
consultant, officer, or elected or appointed official of the recipient
or its subrecipients and who exercises or has exercised any functions
or responsibilities with respect to activities assisted under this
part, or who is in a position to participate in a decision-making
process or gain inside information with regard to activities assisted
under this part, may obtain a financial interest or benefit from an
assisted activity, have a financial interest in any contract,
subcontract, or agreement with respect to an assisted activity, or have
a financial interest in the proceeds derived from an assisted activity,
either for him or herself or for those with whom he or she has
immediate family or business ties, during his or her tenure or during
the one-year period following his or her tenure.
(2) Exceptions. Upon the written request of the recipient, HUD may
grant an exception to the provisions of this section on a case-by-case
basis, taking into account the cumulative effects of the criteria in
paragraph (d)(2)(ii) of this section, provided that the recipient has
satisfactorily met the threshold requirements of paragraph (d)(2)(ii)
of this section.
(i) Threshold requirements. HUD will consider an exception only
after the recipient has provided the following documentation:
(A) Disclosure of the nature of the conflict, accompanied by a
written assurance, if the recipient is a government, that there has
been public disclosure of the conflict and a description of how the
public disclosure was made; and if the recipient is a private nonprofit
organization, that the conflict has been disclosed in accordance with
their written code of conduct or other conflict-of-interest policy; and
(B) An opinion of the recipient's attorney that the interest for
which the exception is sought would not violate State or local law, or
if the subrecipient is a private nonprofit organization, the exception
would not violate the organization's internal policies.
(ii) Factors to be considered for exceptions. In determining
whether to grant a requested exception after the recipient has
satisfactorily met the threshold requirements under paragraph (c)(3)(i)
of this section, HUD must conclude that the exception will serve to
further the purposes of the Continuum of Care program and the effective
and efficient administration of the recipient's or subrecipient's
project, taking into account the cumulative effect of the following
factors, as applicable:
(A) Whether the exception would provide a significant cost benefit
or an essential degree of expertise to the program or project that
would otherwise not be available;
(B) Whether an opportunity was provided for open competitive
bidding or negotiation;
(C) Whether the affected person has withdrawn from his or her
functions, responsibilities, or the decision-making process with
respect to the specific activity in question;
(D) Whether the interest or benefit was present before the affected
person was in the position described in paragraph (c)(1) of this
section;
(E) Whether undue hardship will result to the recipient, the
subrecipient, or the person affected, when weighed against the public
interest served by avoiding the prohibited conflict;
(F) Whether the person affected is a member of a group or class of
persons intended to be the beneficiaries of the assisted activity, and
the exception will permit such person to receive generally the same
interests or benefits as are being made available or provided to the
group or class; and
(G) Any other relevant considerations.
Sec. 578.97 Program income.
(a) Defined. Program income is the income received by the recipient
or subrecipient directly generated by a grant-supported activity.
(b) Use. Program income earned during the grant term shall be
retained by the recipient, and added to funds committed to the project
by HUD and the recipient, used for eligible activities in accordance
with the requirements of this part. Costs incident to the generation of
program income may be deducted from gross income to calculate program
income, provided that the costs have not been charged to grant funds.
(c) Rent and occupancy charges. Rents and occupancy charges
collected from program participants are program income. In addition,
rents and occupancy charges collected from residents of transitional
housing may be reserved, in whole or in part, to assist the residents
from whom they are collected to move to permanent housing.
Sec. 578.99 Applicability of other federal requirements.
In addition to the requirements set forth in 24 CFR part 5, use of
assistance provided under this part must comply with the following
federal requirements:
(a) Environmental review. Activities under this part are subject to
environmental review by HUD under 24 CFR part 50 as noted in Sec.
578.31.
(b) Section 6002 of the Solid Waste Disposal Act. State agencies
and agencies of a political subdivision of a state that are using
assistance under this part for procurement, and any person contracting
with such an agency with respect to work performed under an assisted
contract, must comply with the requirements of Section 6003 of the
Solid Waste Disposal Act, as amended by the Resource Conservation and
Recovery Act. In accordance with Section 6002, these agencies and
persons must:
(1) Procure items designated in guidelines of the Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) at 40 CFR part 247 that contain the highest
percentage of recovered materials practicable, consistent with
maintaining a satisfactory level of competition, where the purchase
price of the item exceeds $10,000 or the value of the quantity acquired
in the preceding fiscal year exceeded $10,000;
(2) Procure solid waste management services in a manner that
maximizes energy and resource recovery; and
[[Page 45464]]
(3) Must have established an affirmative procurement program for
the procurement of recovered materials identified in the EPA
guidelines.
(c) Transparency Act Reporting. Section 872 of the Duncan Hunter
Defense Appropriations Act of 2009, and additional requirements
published by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB), requires
recipients to report subawards made either as pass-through awards,
subrecipient awards, or vendor awards in the Federal Government Web
site www.fsrs.gov or its successor system. The reporting of award and
subaward information is in accordance with the requirements of the
Federal Financial Assistance Accountability and Transparency Act of
2006, as amended by section 6202 of Public Law 110-252 and in OMB
Policy Guidance issued to the federal agencies on September 14, 2010
(75 FR 55669).
(d) The Coastal Barrier Resources Act of 1982 (16 U.S.C. 3501 et
seq.) may apply to proposals under this part, depending on the
assistance requested.
(e) Applicability of OMB Circulars. The requirements of 24 CFR part
85--Administrative Requirements for Grants and Cooperative Agreements
to State, Local, and Federally Recognized Indian Tribal Governments and
2 CFR part 225--Cost Principles for State, Local and Indian Tribal
Governments (OMB Circular A-87)--apply to governmental recipients and
subrecipients except where inconsistent with the provisions of this
part. The requirements of 24 CFR part 84--Uniform Administrative
Requirements for Grants and Agreements with Institutions of Higher
Education, Hospitals, and Other Non-Profit Organizations; 2 CFR part
230--Cost Principles for Non-Profit Organizations (OMB Circular A-122);
and 2 CFR part 220--Cost Principles for Education Institutions apply to
the nonprofit recipients and subrecipients, except where inconsistent
with the provisions of the McKinney-Vento Act or this part.
(f) Lead-based paint. The Lead-Based Paint Poisoning Prevention Act
(42 U.S.C. 4821-4846), the Residential Lead-Based Paint Hazard
Reduction Act of 1992 (42 U.S.C. 4851-4856), and implementing
regulations at 24 CFR part 35, subparts A, B, H, J, K, M, and R apply
to activities under this program.
(g) Audit. Recipients and subrecipients must comply with the audit
requirements of OMB Circular A-133, ``Audits of States, Local
Governments, and Non-profit Organizations.''
(h) Davis-Bacon Act. The provisions of the Davis-Bacon Act do not
apply to this program.
(i) Section 3 of the Housing and Urban Development Act. Recipients
and subrecipients must, as applicable, comply with Section 3 of the
Housing and Urban Development Act of 1968 and its implementing
regulations at 24 CFR part 135, as applicable.
Subpart G--Grant Administration
Sec. 578.101 Technical assistance.
(a) Purpose. The purpose of Continuum of Care technical assistance
is to increase the effectiveness with which Continuums of Care,
eligible applicants, recipients, subrecipients, and UFAs implement and
administer their Continuum of Care planning process; improve their
capacity to prepare applications; prevent the separation of families in
projects funded under the Emergency Solutions Grants, Continuum of
Care, and Rural Housing Stability Assistance programs; and adopt and
provide best practices in housing and services for persons experiencing
homelessness.
(b) Defined. Technical assistance means the transfer of skills and
knowledge to entities that may need, but do not possess, such skills
and knowledge. The assistance may include, but is not limited to,
written information such as papers, manuals, guides, and brochures;
person-to-person exchanges; web-based curriculums, training and
Webinars, and their costs.
(c) Set-aside. HUD may set aside funds annually to provide
technical assistance, either directly by HUD staff or indirectly
through third-party providers.
(d) Awards. From time to time, as HUD determines the need, HUD may
advertise and competitively select providers to deliver technical
assistance. HUD may enter into contracts, grants, or cooperative
agreements, when necessary, to implement the technical assistance. HUD
may also enter into agreements with other federal agencies for awarding
the technical assistance funds.
Sec. 578.103 Recordkeeping requirements.
(a) In general. The recipient and its subrecipients must establish
and maintain standard operating procedures for ensuring that Continuum
of Care program funds are used in accordance with the requirements of
this part and must establish and maintain sufficient records to enable
HUD to determine whether the recipient and its subrecipients are
meeting the requirements of this part, including:
(1) Continuum of Care records. Each collaborative applicant must
keep the following documentation related to establishing and operating
a Continuum of Care:
(i) Evidence that the Board selected by the Continuum of Care meets
the requirements of Sec. 578.5(b);
(ii) Evidence that the Continuum has been established and operated
as set forth in subpart B of this part, including published agendas and
meeting minutes, an approved Governance Charter that is reviewed and
updated annually, a written process for selecting a board that is
reviewed and updated at least once every 5 years, evidence required for
designating a single HMIS for the Continuum, and monitoring reports of
recipients and subrecipients;
(iii) Evidence that the Continuum has prepared the application for
funds as set forth in Sec. 578.9, including the designation of the
eligible applicant to be the collaborative applicant.
(2) Unified funding agency records. UFAs that requested grant
amendments from HUD, as set forth in Sec. 578.105, must keep evidence
that the grant amendment was approved by the Continuum. This evidence
may include minutes of meetings at which the grant amendment was
discussed and approved.
(3) Homeless status. Acceptable evidence of the homeless as status
is set forth in 24 CFR 576.500(b).
(4) At risk of homelessness status. For those recipients and
subrecipients that serve persons at risk of homelessness, the recipient
or subrecipient must keep records that establish ``at risk of
homelessness'' status of each individual or family who receives
Continuum of Care homelessness prevention assistance. Acceptable
evidence is found in 24 CFR 576.500(c).
(5) Records of reasonable belief of imminent threat of harm. For
each program participant who moved to a different Continuum of Care due
to imminent threat of further domestic violence, dating violence,
sexual assault, or stalking under Sec. 578.51(c)(3), each recipient or
subrecipient of assistance under this part must retain:
(i) Documentation of the original incidence of domestic violence,
dating violence, sexual assault, or stalking, only if the original
violence is not already documented in the program participant's case
file. This may be written observation of the housing or service
provider; a letter or other documentation from a victim service
provider, social worker, legal assistance provider, pastoral counselor,
mental health provider, or other professional from whom the victim has
sought assistance; medical or dental records; court records or law
enforcement records; or written certification by the
[[Page 45465]]
program participant to whom the violence occurred or by the head of
household.
(ii) Documentation of the reasonable belief of imminent threat of
further domestic violence, dating violence, or sexual assault or
stalking, which would include threats from a third-party, such as a
friend or family member of the perpetrator of the violence. This may be
written observation by the housing or service provider; a letter or
other documentation from a victim service provider, social worker,
legal assistance provider, pastoral counselor, mental health provider,
or other professional from whom the victim has sought assistance;
current restraining order; recent court order or other court records;
law enforcement report or records; communication records from the
perpetrator of the violence or family members or friends of the
perpetrator of the violence, including emails, voicemails, text
messages, and social media posts; or a written certification by the
program participant to whom the violence occurred or the head of
household.
(6) Annual income. For each program participant who receives
housing assistance where rent or an occupancy charge is paid by the
program participant, the recipient or subrecipient must keep the
following documentation of annual income:
(i) Income evaluation form specified by HUD and completed by the
recipient or subrecipient; and
(ii) Source documents (e.g., most recent wage statement,
unemployment compensation statement, public benefits statement, bank
statement) for the assets held by the program participant and income
received before the date of the evaluation;
(iii) To the extent that source documents are unobtainable, a
written statement by the relevant third party (e.g., employer,
government benefits administrator) or the written certification by the
recipient's or subrecipient's intake staff of the oral verification by
the relevant third party of the income the program participant received
over the most recent period; or
(iv) To the extent that source documents and third-party
verification are unobtainable, the written certification by the program
participant of the amount of income that the program participant is
reasonably expected to receive over the 3-month period following the
evaluation.
(7) Program participant records. In addition to evidence of
``homeless'' status or ``at-risk-of-homelessness'' status, as
applicable, the recipient or subrecipient must keep records for each
program participant that document:
(i) The services and assistance provided to that program
participant, including evidence that the recipient or subrecipient has
conducted an annual assessment of services for those program
participants that remain in the program for more than a year and
adjusted the service package accordingly, and including case management
services as provided in Sec. 578.37(a)(1)(ii)(F); and
(ii) Where applicable, compliance with the termination of
assistance requirement in Sec. 578.91.
(8) Housing standards. The recipient or subrecipient must retain
documentation of compliance with the housing standards in Sec.
578.75(b), including inspection reports.
(9) Services provided. The recipient or subrecipient must document
the types of supportive services provided under the recipient's program
and the amounts spent on those services. The recipient or subrecipient
must keep record that these records were reviewed at least annually and
that the service package offered to program participants was adjusted
as necessary.
(10) Match. The recipient must keep records of the source and use
of contributions made to satisfy the match requirement in Sec. 578.73.
The records must indicate the grant and fiscal year for which each
matching contribution is counted. The records must show how the value
placed on third party in-kind contributions was derived. To the extent
feasible, volunteer services must be supported by the same methods that
the organization uses to support the allocation of regular personnel
costs.
(11) Conflicts of interest. The recipient and its subrecipients
must keep records to show compliance with the organizational conflict-
of-interest requirements in Sec. 578.95(c), the Continuum of Care
board conflict-of-interest requirements in Sec. 578.95(b), the other
conflict requirements in Sec. 578.95(d), a copy of the personal
conflict-of-interest policy developed and implemented to comply with
the requirements in Sec. 578.95, and records supporting exceptions to
the personal conflict-of-interest prohibitions.
(12) Homeless participation. The recipient or subrecipient must
document its compliance with the homeless participation requirements
under Sec. 578.75(g).
(13) Faith-based activities. The recipient and its subrecipients
must document their compliance with the faith-based activities
requirements under Sec. 578.87(b).
(14) Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing. Recipients and
subrecipients must maintain copies of their marketing, outreach, and
other materials used to inform eligible persons of the program to
document compliance with the requirements in Sec. 578.93(c).
(15) Other federal requirements. The recipient and its
subrecipients must document their compliance with the federal
requirements in Sec. 578.99, as applicable.
(16) Subrecipients and contractors. (i) The recipient must retain
copies of all solicitations of and agreements with subrecipients,
records of all payment requests by and dates of payments made to
subrecipients, and documentation of all monitoring and sanctions of
subrecipients, as applicable.
(ii) The recipient must retain documentation of monitoring
subrecipients, including any monitoring findings and corrective actions
required.
(iii) The recipient and its subrecipients must retain copies of all
procurement contracts and documentation of compliance with the
procurement requirements in 24 CFR 85.36 and 24 CFR part 84.
(17) Other records specified by HUD. The recipient and
subrecipients must keep other records specified by HUD.
(b) Confidentiality. In addition to meeting the specific
confidentiality and security requirements for HMIS data, the recipient
and its subrecipients must develop and implement written procedures to
ensure:
(1) All records containing protected identifying information of any
individual or family who applies for and/or receives Continuum of Care
assistance will be kept secure and confidential;
(2) The address or location of any family violence project assisted
with Continuum of Care funds will not be made public, except with
written authorization of the person responsible for the operation of
the project; and
(3) The address or location of any housing of a program participant
will not be made public, except as provided under a preexisting privacy
policy of the recipient or subrecipient and consistent with State and
local laws regarding privacy and obligations of confidentiality;
(c) Period of record retention. All records pertaining to Continuum
of Care funds must be retained for the greater of 5 years or the period
specified below. Copies made by microfilming, photocopying, or similar
methods may be substituted for the original records.
(1) Documentation of each program participant's qualification as a
family or individual at risk of homelessness or as a homeless family or
individual and other program participant records must
[[Page 45466]]
be retained for 5 years after the expenditure of all funds from the
grant under which the program participant was served; and
(2) Where Continuum of Care funds are used for the acquisition, new
construction, or rehabilitation of a project site, records must be
retained until 15 years after the date that the project site is first
occupied, or used, by program participants.
(d) Access to records. (1) Federal Government rights.
Notwithstanding the confidentiality procedures established under
paragraph (b) of this section, HUD, the HUD Office of the Inspector
General, and the Comptroller General of the United States, or any of
their authorized representatives, must have the right of access to all
books, documents, papers, or other records of the recipient and its
subrecipients that are pertinent to the Continuum of Care grant, in
order to make audits, examinations, excerpts, and transcripts. These
rights of access are not limited to the required retention period, but
last as long as the records are retained.
(2) Public rights. The recipient must provide citizens, public
agencies, and other interested parties with reasonable access to
records regarding any uses of Continuum of Care funds the recipient
received during the preceding 5 years, consistent with State and local
laws regarding privacy and obligations of confidentiality and
confidentiality requirements in this part.
(e) Reports. In addition to the reporting requirements in 24 CFR
parts 84 and 85, the recipient must collect and report data on its use
of Continuum of Care funds in an Annual Performance Report (APR), as
well as in any additional reports as and when required by HUD. Projects
receiving grant funds only for acquisition, rehabilitation, or new
construction must submit APRs for 15 years from the date of initial
occupancy or the date of initial service provision, unless HUD provides
an exception under Sec. 578.81(e).
Sec. 578.105 Grant and project changes.
(a) For Unified Funding Agencies and Continuums having only one
recipient. (1) The recipient may not make any significant changes
without prior HUD approval, evidenced by a grant amendment signed by
HUD and the recipient. Significant grant changes include a change of
recipient, a shift in a single year of more than 10 percent of the
total amount awarded under the grant for one approved eligible activity
category to another activity and a permanent change in the
subpopulation served by any one project funded under the grant, as well
as a permanent proposed reduction in the total number of units funded
under the grant.
(2) Approval of substitution of the recipient is contingent on the
new recipient meeting the capacity criteria in the NOFA under which the
grant was awarded, or the most recent NOFA. Approval of shifting funds
between activities and changing subpopulations is contingent on the
change being necessary to better serve eligible persons within the
geographic area and ensuring that the priorities established under the
NOFA in which the grant was originally awarded, or the most recent
NOFA, are met.
(b) For Continuums having more than one recipient. (1) The
recipients or subrecipients may not make any significant changes to a
project without prior HUD approval, evidenced by a grant amendment
signed by HUD and the recipient. Significant changes include a change
of recipient, a change of project site, additions or deletions in the
types of eligible activities approved for a project, a shift of more
than 10 percent from one approved eligible activity to another, a
reduction in the number of units, and a change in the subpopulation
served.
(2) Approval of substitution of the recipient is contingent on the
new recipient meeting the capacity criteria in the NOFA under which the
grant was awarded, or the most recent NOFA. Approval of shifting funds
between activities and changing subpopulations is contingent on the
change being necessary to better serve eligible persons within the
geographic area and ensuring that the priorities established under the
NOFA in which the grant was originally awarded, or the most recent
NOFA, are met.
(c) Documentation of changes not requiring a grant amendment. Any
other changes to an approved grant or project must be fully documented
in the recipient's or subrecipient's records.
Sec. 578.107 Sanctions.
(a) Performance reviews. (1) HUD will review the performance of
each recipient in carrying out its responsibilities under this part,
with or without prior notice to the recipient. In conducting
performance reviews, HUD will rely primarily on information obtained
from the records and reports from the recipient and subrecipients, as
well as information from on-site monitoring, audit reports, and
information generated from HUD's financial and reporting systems (e.g.,
LOCCS and e-snaps) and HMIS. Where applicable, HUD may also consider
relevant information pertaining to the recipient's performance gained
from other sources, including citizen comments, complaint
determinations, and litigation.
(2) If HUD determines preliminarily that the recipient or one of
its subrecipients has not complied with a program requirement, HUD will
give the recipient notice of this determination and an opportunity to
demonstrate, within the time prescribed by HUD and on the basis of
substantial facts and data that the recipient has complied with the
requirements. HUD may change the method of payment to require the
recipient to submit documentation before payment and obtain HUD's prior
approval each time the recipient draws down funds. To obtain prior
approval, the recipient may be required to manually submit its payment
requests and supporting documentation to HUD in order to show that the
funds to be drawn down will be expended on eligible activities in
accordance with all program requirements.
(3) If the recipient fails to demonstrate to HUD's satisfaction
that the activities were carried out in compliance with program
requirements, HUD may take one or more of the remedial actions or
sanctions specified in paragraph (b) of this section.
(b) Remedial actions and sanctions. Remedial actions and sanctions
for a failure to meet a program requirement will be designed to prevent
a continuation of the deficiency; to mitigate, to the extent possible,
its adverse effects or consequences; and to prevent its recurrence.
(1) HUD may instruct the recipient to submit and comply with
proposals for action to correct, mitigate, and prevent noncompliance
with program requirements, including:
(i) Preparing and following a schedule of actions for carrying out
activities and projects affected by the noncompliance, including
schedules, timetables, and milestones necessary to implement the
affected activities and projects;
(ii) Establishing and following a management plan that assigns
responsibilities for carrying out the remedial actions;
(iii) Canceling or revising activities or projects likely to be
affected by the noncompliance, before expending grant funds for them;
(iv) Reprogramming grant funds that have not yet been expended from
affected activities or projects to other eligible activities or
projects;
(v) Suspending disbursement of grant funds for some or all
activities or projects;
(vi) Reducing or terminating the remaining grant of a subrecipient
and either reallocating those funds to other
[[Page 45467]]
subrecipients or returning funds to HUD; and
(vii) Making matching contributions before or as draws are made
from the recipient's grant.
(2) HUD may change the method of payment to a reimbursement basis.
(3) HUD may suspend payments to the extent HUD determines necessary
to preclude the further expenditure of funds for affected activities or
projects.
(4) HUD may continue the grant with a substitute recipient of HUD's
choosing.
(5) HUD may deny matching credit for all or part of the cost of the
affected activities and require the recipient to make further matching
contributions to make up for the contribution determined to be
ineligible.
(6) HUD may require the recipient to reimburse the recipient's line
of credit in an amount equal to the funds used for the affected
activities.
(7) HUD may reduce or terminate the remaining grant of a recipient.
(8) HUD may condition a future grant.
(9) HUD may take other remedies that are legally available.
(c) Recipient sanctions. If the recipient determines that a
subrecipient is not complying with a program requirement or its
subrecipient agreement, the recipient must take one of the actions
listed in paragraphs (a) and (b) of this section.
(d) Deobligation. HUD may deobligate funds for the following
reasons:
(1) If the timeliness standards in Sec. 578.85 are not met;
(2) If HUD determines that delays completing construction
activities for a project will mean that the funds for other funded
activities cannot reasonably be expected to be expended for eligible
costs during the remaining term of the grant;
(3) If the actual total cost of acquisition, rehabilitation, or new
construction for a project is less than the total cost agreed to in the
grant agreement;
(4) If the actual annual leasing costs, operating costs, supportive
services costs, rental assistance costs, or HMIS costs are less than
the total cost agreed to in the grant agreement for a one-year period;
(5) Program participants have not moved into units within 3 months
of the time that the units are available for occupancy; and
(6) The grant agreement may set forth in detail other circumstances
under which funds may be deobligated and other sanctions may be
imposed.
Sec. 578.109 Closeout.
(a) In general. Grants will be closed out in accordance with the
requirements of 24 CFR parts 84 and 85, and closeout procedures
established by HUD.
(b) Reports. Applicants must submit all reports required by HUD no
later than 90 days from the date of the end of the project's grant
term.
(c) Closeout agreement. Any obligations remaining as of the date of
the closeout must be covered by the terms of a closeout agreement. The
agreement will be prepared by HUD in consultation with the recipient.
The agreement must identify the grant being closed out, and include
provisions with respect to the following:
(1) Identification of any closeout costs or contingent liabilities
subject to payment with Continuum of Care program funds after the
closeout agreement is signed;
(2) Identification of any unused grant funds to be deobligated by
HUD;
(3) Identification of any program income on deposit in financial
institutions at the time the closeout agreement is signed;
(4) Description of the recipient's responsibility after closeout
for:
(i) Compliance with all program requirements in using program
income on deposit at the time the closeout agreement is signed and in
using any other remaining Continuum of Care program funds available for
closeout costs and contingent liabilities;
(ii) Use of real property assisted with Continuum of Care program
funds in accordance with the terms of commitment and principles;
(iii) Use of personal property purchased with Continuum of Care
program funds; and
(iv) Compliance with requirements governing program income received
subsequent to grant closeout.
(5) Other provisions appropriate to any special circumstances of
the grant closeout, in modification of or in addition to the
obligations in paragraphs (c)(1) through (4) of this section.
Dated: June 28, 2012.
Mark Johnston,
Assistant Secretary for Community Planning and Development (Acting).
[FR Doc. 2012-17546 Filed 7-30-12; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4210-67-P