Public Housing Capital Fund Program, 6654-6682 [2011-2303]
Download as PDF
6654
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND
URBAN DEVELOPMENT
24 CFR Parts 903, 905, 941, 968, 969
[Docket No. FR–5236–P–01]
RIN–2577–AC50
Public Housing Capital Fund Program
Office of the Assistant
Secretary for Public and Indian
Housing, HUD.
ACTION: Proposed rule.
AGENCY:
This proposed rule combines
and streamlines the former legacy
public housing modernization
programs, including the Comprehensive
Grant Program (CGP), the
Comprehensive Improvement
Assistance Program (CIAP), and the
Public Housing Development Program
(which encompasses mixed-finance
development), into the Capital Fund
Program (CFP). This rule proposes a
change to the Public Housing Agency
Annual Plan regulation to incorporate
the definition of qualified public
housing agencies (PHAs), which was
mandated by the Housing and Economic
Recovery Act (HERA) of 2008, and to
decouple or separate the CFP
informational requirements from the
PHA Annual Plan requirements. Also
proposed is the ability for PHAs to
request a total development cost (TDC)
exception for integrated utility
management, capital planning, and
other capital and management activities
that maximize energy conservation and
efficiency, including green construction
and retrofits, which include windows;
heating system replacements; wall
insulation; site-based generation;
advanced energy savings technologies,
including renewable energy generation;
and other such retrofits.
The structure of the proposed Public
Housing Capital Fund Program
regulation is described in section IV of
the SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION.
Several regulations would be eliminated
with the implementation of this rule,
along with the issuance of new and/or
revised CFP forms, including the CFP
Annual Statement/Performance and
Evaluation Report (form HUD–50075.1),
CFP 5-Year Action Plan (form HUD–
50075.2), and the CFP Annual
Contributions Contract (ACC)
Amendment, as well as a new
guidebook.
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
SUMMARY:
DATES:
Comments Due Date: April 8,
2011.
Interested persons are
invited to submit comments regarding
this proposed rule to the Regulations
ADDRESSES:
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
Division, Office of General Counsel,
Department of Housing and Urban
Development, 451 7th Street, SW.,
Room 10276, Washington, DC 20410–
0500. Communications must refer to the
above docket number and title. There
are two methods for submitting public
comments. All submissions must refer
to the above docket number and title.
1. Submission of Comments by Mail.
Comments may be submitted by mail to
the Regulations Division, Office of
General Counsel, Department of
Housing and Urban Development, 451
7th Street, SW., Room 10276,
Washington, DC 20410–0500.
2. Electronic Submission of
Comments. Interested persons may
submit comments electronically through
the Federal eRulemaking Portal at
https://www.regulations.gov. HUD
strongly encourages commenters to
submit comments electronically.
Electronic submission of comments
allows the commenter maximum time to
prepare and submit a comment, ensures
timely receipt by HUD, and enables
HUD to make them immediately
available to the public. Comments
submitted electronically through the
https://www.regulations.gov Web site can
be viewed by other commenters and
interested members of the public.
Commenters should follow the
instructions provided on that site to
submit comments electronically.
Note: To receive consideration as public
comments, comments must be submitted
through one of the two methods specified
above. Again, all submissions must refer to
the docket number and title of the rule.
No Facsimile Comments. Facsimile
(FAX) comments are not acceptable.
Public Inspection of Public
Comments. All properly submitted
comments and communications
submitted to HUD will be available for
public inspection and copying between
8 a.m. and 5 p.m. weekdays at the above
address. Due to security measures at the
HUD Headquarters building, an advance
appointment to review the public
comments must be scheduled by calling
the Regulations Division at 202–402–
3055 (this is not a toll-free number).
Individuals with speech or hearing
impairments may access this number
via TTY by calling the Federal
Information Relay Service, toll free, at
800–877–8339. Copies of all comments
submitted are available for inspection
and downloading at https://www.
regulations.gov.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Jeffrey Riddel, Director, Office of Capital
Improvements, Office of Public and
Indian Housing, Department of Housing
and Urban Development, 451 7th Street,
PO 00000
Frm 00002
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
SW., Washington, DC 20410–8000;
telephone number 202–708–1640 (this
is not a toll-free number). Hearing- or
speech-impaired individuals may access
this number through TTY by calling the
toll-free Federal Information Relay
Service at 800–877–8339.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Background
Section 9(d) of the U.S. Housing Act
of 1937 (1937 Act) (42 U.S.C. 1437g(d))
provides for a ‘‘Capital Fund’’ for the
purpose of making assistance available
to PHAs to carry out capital and
management improvement activities.
Section 9(d)(2) of the 1937 Act (42
U.S.C. 1437g(d)(2)) requires HUD to
develop a formula for determining the
amount of assistance provided to PHAs
from the Capital Fund for a federal fiscal
year (FFY). The formula ‘‘shall include’’
a mechanism to reward PHA
performance. As required by statute, the
Capital Fund formula (CF formula) was
developed through negotiated
rulemaking and promulgated through a
final rule, published on March 16, 2000
(65 FR 14422), with certain minor
amendments to remove some incorrect,
unnecessary dates adopted by final rule
published on May 2, 2000 (65 FR
25446).
Section 9(g) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C.
1437g(g)) provides for a certain amount
of flexibility in the use of Capital Fund
amounts. For PHAs other than small
PHAs (that is, those with fewer than 250
units of public housing), a PHA may use
up to 20 percent of its Capital Fund for
activities that are eligible activities for
the Operating Fund under section 9(e)
of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437g(e)).
Small PHAs that meet certain statutory
criteria related to operating and
maintaining their public housing in
safe, clean, and healthy condition may
use 100 percent of their Capital Fund
amounts for any statutorily eligible use
under the Operating Fund.
Section 9(g)(3) of the 1937 Act (42
U.S.C. 1437g(g)(3)) imposes limitations
on the use of the Capital Fund or
Operating Fund for new construction.
Generally, the CF formula shall not
provide PHAs funding for the purpose
of constructing public housing units
(which includes acquisition), if the
construction would result in a net
increase from the number of housing
units owned, operated, or assisted by
the PHA on October 1, 1999. PHAs may
use their CF formula amounts to
construct units in excess of the ‘‘net
increase’’ limitation, if the units are
available and affordable to low-income
families (42 U.S.C. 1437g(g)(3)(B)). The
1937 Act provides two exceptions to the
‘‘net increase’’ limitation on the CF
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
formula. One is where the funding for
additional units is for a mixed-finance
project (42 U.S.C. 1437g(g)(3)(C)(i)). The
second exception is where the cost of
the useful life of the project is less than
the estimated cost of providing tenantbased assistance under the Housing
Choice Voucher program (42 U.S.C.
1437g(g)(3)(C)(ii)).
Section 9(j) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C.
1437g(j)) provides for penalties for slow
obligation and expenditure of Capital
Funds. Generally, a PHA is required to
obligate funds received under section 9
of the 1937 Act within 24 months of the
date on which the funds become
available or within 24 months of the
date on which the PHA accumulates
enough funds to undertake
modernization, substantial
rehabilitation, or construction of units
(42 U.S.C. 1437g(j)(1)). Under section
9(j)(2)(B) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C.
1437g(j)(2)(B)), a PHA ‘‘shall disregard’’
this requirement with respect to
unobligated amounts the total of which
do not exceed 10 percent of the original
allocation of Capital Funds to the PHA.
Additionally, PHAs must expend their
Capital Fund assistance within 4 years
after the date on which the funds
became available for obligation (42
U.S.C. 1437g(j)(5)). HUD may extend the
time periods for obligation of Capital
Funds for specific reasons listed in the
statute and established by HUD by
notice published in the Federal Register
(42 U.S.C. 1437g(j)(2), 42 U.S.C.
1437g(j)(5)(A)). The statute lists
potential sanctions for failure to comply
with the obligation and expenditure
deadlines, including withholding of
funds, penalties applied to future grants,
reallocation of funds to high-performing
PHAs, and recapture (42 U.S.C.
1437g(j)(3), 42 U.S.C. 1437g(j)(6)).
Regulations implementing the
obligation and expenditure
requirements were published on August
1, 2003 (68 FR 45731). These regulations
are currently codified at 24 CFR
905.120, and would be moved to
§ 905.306 by this proposed rulemaking.
Former section 9(k) of the 1937 Act
(42 U.S.C. 1437g(k)) provided for a fund
reserve for emergency, natural disasters,
and litigation needs, and for a set-aside
for Operation Safe Home. Section 2804
of Title VII (Small Public Housing
Authorities Paperwork Reduction Act)
of Division B of the HERA (Pub. L. 110–
289, approved July 30, 2008) removed
section 9(k) of the 1937 Act.
Section 2702 of the Small Public
Housing Authorities Paperwork
Reduction Act amends section 5A of the
1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437c–1), to
provide that certain PHAs, called
‘‘qualified public housing agencies,’’ are
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
not required to file the PHA Annual
Plan called for in section 5A(b)(1) of the
1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437c–1(b)(1)).
Qualified PHAs under section 2702 are
those that administer 550 or fewer
units—considered as the sum of all the
public housing units and vouchers
under section 8(o) of the 1937 Act (42
U.S.C. 1437f(o)) administered by a
PHA—and are not designated as a
troubled PHA under section 6(j)(2), and
do not have a failing score under the
Section 8 Management Assessment
Program (SEMAP) during the prior 12
months.
Such PHAs must still submit a PHA
5-Year Plan, file the civil rights
certification under 42 U.S.C. 1437c–
1(d)(16), and consult with, and consider
the recommendations of, the resident
advisory board at the annual hearing
required of such agencies regarding any
changes to the goals, objectives, and
policies of that PHA. The CFP (and
previous CIAP and CGP) have always
had separate informational
requirements, but some of these were
combined with the PHA Annual and 5Year Plan. However, with the changes
made to the PHA Annual Plan and the
need to have grant reporting in
compliance with CFP and other federal
reporting requirements, the CFP
informational requirements will be
decoupled or separated from the PHA
Annual Plan submissions.
II. Overview of the Capital Fund
Program
This rule proposes to revise the
regulations governing the use of
assistance made available under the
Capital Fund in 24 CFR part 905.
Assistance under the Capital Fund is a
primary, regular source of funding made
available by HUD to a PHA for
modernization and development of
public housing and other capital
activities. This rule also proposes to
replace and remove several other
regulations that currently govern a
PHA’s use of HUD assistance,
specifically: 24 CFR part 941, entitled
‘‘Public Housing Development’’; 24 CFR
part 968, entitled ‘‘Public Housing
Modernization’’; and 24 CFR part 969,
entitled ‘‘PHA-Owned Projects—
Continued Operation as Low-Income
Housing After Completion of Debt
Service.’’ In the case of part 969, which
provides for the continued operation of
housing as public housing for the 10year period after the last receipt of
operating subsidy, sections 9(e)(3) and
9(m) of the 1937 Act, along with the
Annual Contributions Contract (ACC),
as amended and approved by HUD,
serve the same purpose, making the
PO 00000
Frm 00003
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
6655
separate regulations in 24 CFR part 969
no longer necessary.
Although HUD established the CF
formula in 2000, HUD continued to rely
on CFP requirements found in the
regulations in these other parts of 24
CFR, to the extent that these
requirements were not superseded by
statutory requirements.
III. Overview of the Changes to the PHA
Annual Plan
This regulation modifies 24 CFR
903.3(a) to incorporate the definition of
a qualified PHA provided in section
2702 of HERA. HERA exempts qualified
PHAs from the requirement of section
5(A) of the 1937 Act to submit a PHA
Annual Plan.
IV. This Proposed Rule
To meet the objective of revising and
consolidating the requirements
governing the use of Capital Funds, as
discussed in Section II of this preamble,
this proposed rule would revise 24 CFR
part 905 to establish new subparts A
through H.
A. Subpart A
Subpart A of this proposed part 905
would provide a general introduction
and definitions. Section 905.100(a) and
(b) would state the purpose of the part
905 regulations and provide a general
description of the CFP. Section
905.100(c) would establish employment,
contracting, and close-out requirements.
Section 905.102 would address the
applicability of the part 905 regulations.
Section 905.104 would require that all
HUD approvals be in writing from
officials designated to grant such
approvals. Section 905.106 would state
that noncompliance with this part or
any other applicable requirements may
subject a PHA and its partners to
sanctions provided elsewhere in part
905. Section 905.108 would provide a
number of program-specific definitions.
The following are definitions relating
to the Capital Fund Program and
proposed to be included in the
definition section of the part 905
regulations: ‘‘Additional Project Costs,’’
‘‘Accessible,’’ ‘‘Capital Fund,’’ ‘‘Capital
Fund Annual Contributions Contract
Amendment (CF ACC Amendment),’’
‘‘Capital Fund Program Fee,’’
‘‘Community Renewal Costs,’’
‘‘Cooperation Agreement,’’ ‘‘Date of Full
Availability (DOFA),’’ ‘‘Emergency
Work,’’ ‘‘Expenditure,’’ ‘‘Federal Fiscal
Year (FFY),’’ ‘‘Force Account Labor,’’
‘‘Fungibility,’’ ‘‘Housing Construction
Cost (HCC),’’ ‘‘Line of Credit Control
system (LOCCS),’’ ‘‘Mixed Finance
Modernization,’’ ‘‘Natural Disaster,’’
‘‘Obligation,’’ ‘‘Open Grant,’’ ‘‘Operating
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
6656
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
Fund,’’ ‘‘PIH Information Center (PIC),’’
‘‘Public Housing Agency (PHA),’’ ‘‘Public
Housing Project,’’ ‘‘Public Housing
Assessment System (PHAS),’’ ‘‘Public
Housing Development,’’ ‘‘Public Housing
Requirements,’’ ‘‘Reasonable Cost,’’
‘‘Reconfiguration,’’ and ‘‘Uniform
Federal Accessibility Standards
(UFAS).’’ Other definitions specifically
related to public housing development
are proposed to be placed in subpart F,
which will address development
activities.
‘‘Capital Fund Program Fee’’ is defined
as the amount up to 10 percent of the
annual Capital Fund grant under this
regulation that may be set aside for
administrative costs for an asset
management PHA. These costs are
associated with the Central Office Cost
Center’s (COCC) oversight and
management of the CFP. These costs
include duties related to general capital
planning, preparing of the Annual Plan,
processing of LOCCS, preparing reports,
drawing of funds, budgeting,
accounting, and procuring of
construction and other miscellaneous
contracts.
PHAs that have not converted to asset
management may expend up to 10
percent of the Capital Fund grant on
their administrative costs.
Administrative costs exclude any costs
related to lead-based paint or asbestos
testing, in-house architectural or
engineering work, or special
administrative costs required under
state or local law, unless approved by
HUD.
‘‘Reasonable cost’’ is defined in the
regulation as ‘‘An amount to rehabilitate
or modernize an existing structure that
is not greater than 90 percent of the TDC
for a new development of the same
structure type, number and size of units
in the same market area.’’ Section
905.314(g), modernization cost limits,
states that a PHA is prohibited from
modernizing an existing public housing
development that cannot be modernized
for 90 percent of TDC. The Office of
Public Housing uses other cost
limitation standards for voluntary
conversion and for Section 18
demolition. For mandatory conversion
(24 CFR part 972 subpart B), which
relates to developments of 250 or more
dwelling units with a significant (15
percent) vacancy rate over 3 years, the
cost standard is whether it is more
expensive to operate the development as
public housing than to provide tenant
based assistance. For 24 CFR part 970,
the description of major problems
indicative of obsolescence includes a
cost standard of 62 percent of TDC for
elevator structure and 57.14 percent of
TDC for all other types of structures.
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
HUD is requesting that the public
consider these varying cost limitations
and provide the Department with
comments on whether the standard of
90 percent of TDC, which is
incorporated in this proposed
rulemaking, is the best cost limitation to
use for the modernization of existing
public housing.
B. Subpart B
Subpart B would describe Capital
Fund eligible activities and ineligible
activities. Section 905.200 lists the
eligible costs, which include, but are not
limited to, development, financing, and
modernization of public housing
projects; capital planning; preparation
of the annual statement; vacancy
reduction; making units and common
areas accessible; nonroutine
maintenance; resident self sufficiency,
security and safety; relocation and
mobility counseling; costs for approved
homeownership programs; conduct of
an energy audit when there are not
sufficient operating funds and the
energy audit is part of a new
modernization program for energy
efficiency, including the use of Energy
Star items; certain administrative costs;
monitoring of LOCCS; the preparation of
reports; the new Capital Fund program
fee that can be attributed to the Central
Office Cost Center; and emergency
activities.
This proposed rule would incorporate
energy standards at §§ 905.200(b)(6)(ii),
905.200(b)(14), 905.312(b)(1),
905.312(c)(3), 905.312(d), 905.314(c),
and 905.316(e). The standards include
those in 42 U.S.C. 12709 as amended by
section 153 of the Energy Policy Act of
2005, Public Law 109–58 (these
standards include the 2006 International
Energy Conservation Code and ASHRAE
90.1–2004), and the Energy Star
requirement for appliances in section
152 of the Energy Policy Act of 2005. In
addition, § 905.200(b)(14) of this
proposed rule incorporates energy
efficiency standards from 42 U.S.C.
1437g(d)(1)(K), as added by section 151
of the Energy Policy Act of 2005, which
makes it an eligible use of the capital
fund to increase energy efficiency by
such means as the Secretary of HUD
determines are appropriate. Public
comment is sought as to how energy
efficiency should be measured, as well
as what specific uses of the Capital
Fund would increase energy efficiency.
Since HERA removed the
authorization of the emergency set-aside
under section 9(k) of the 1937 Act
(42 U.S.C. 1437g(k)), this proposed rule
would remove the regulatory provisions
related to section 9(k).
PO 00000
Frm 00004
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
Proposed § 905.202 would list the
activities and costs that would be
ineligible under the CFP. These include,
but are not limited to, costs not
included in the PHA’s CFP 5-Year
Action Plan; luxury items such as
amenities beyond what is customary in
the community; costs that would be
eligible but for the fact that they are in
excess of the amount directly
attributable to the public housing units,
when the physical or management
improvement will benefit programs
other than public housing; direct
provision of social services; costs that
are funded by another source, so there
would be duplicate funding; and any
other costs that HUD may determine on
a case-by-case basis.
Proposed § 905.204 would include
regulations on funding for emergencies
and natural disasters. Under this
section, HUD will look to ensure, in
both situations, that a PHA uses other
legally available funds, including
unobligated Capital Funds, before using
funds from the set-aside for disasters
and emergencies. Disasters and
emergencies are, however, by nature
unexpected and unpredictable, so it is
also necessary for HUD to exercise caseby-case discretion to ensure that disaster
needs and other housing needs of the
PHA’s residents are and will continue to
be met. It should be noted that both
HUD’s 2009 (Title II, Pub. L. 111–8) and
2010 (Division A, Title II, Pub. L. 111–
117) Appropriations Acts made a
limited amount of Capital Funds
available for emergencies and natural
disasters, and specifically excluded
Capital Funds from being used for
Presidentially declared disasters under
the Stafford Act (42 U.S.C. 5121 et seq.).
See also PIH Notice 2010–14, available
at https://www.hud.gov/offices/pih/
publications/notices/10/pih2010-14.pdf.
Former § 905.10(b), Emergency
Reserve and Use of Amounts, would be
removed from the proposed rule. The
Capital Fund formula, which was
previously found in § 905.10, is in
§ 905.400 of this proposed rulemaking.
However, this proposed rule retains the
procedures for awarding emergency and
natural disaster grants, if provision is
made for a set-aside for emergencies and
natural disasters in an annual
Appropriations Act.
C. Subpart C
Subpart C of this proposed rule would
include the CFP requirements found in
24 CFR part 968 (public housing
modernization) and 24 CFR 905.120
(penalties for slow expenditure or
obligation of Capital Funds), as those
sections are codified as of the date of
this proposed rule. This rule would
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
establish CFP submission requirements
for both qualified and nonqualified
PHAs, as defined in Title VII of HERA
section 2702. Submission requirements
include, but are not limited to, the
Physical Needs Assessment (PNA), the
budget, and various certifications.
The new requirement for projectbased PNAs for all properties in the
PHA’s inventory is intended to support
effective property-based planning and
the transition to asset management.
Completion of the PNA will provide
PHAs with critical information on the
physical condition of each project in its
inventory and assist the PHAs to
identify and prioritize work items in the
Annual Statement and the 5-Year
Action Plan. The proposed rule would
require that the PNA be completed by
the PHA and be submitted to the Field
Office at a time required by HUD.
The proposed rule would require that
the other CFP submission requirements,
including the budget and the
certifications, be submitted in a format
prescribed by HUD at the time that the
PHA submits its signed CFP ACC
Amendment for its CFP grant(s). Except
in the case of emergency work, the PHA
shall not spend Capital Funds on any
work that is not included in an
approved CFP 5-Year Action Plan and
any approved amendments. Proposed
§ 905.300(b)(5) describes HUD review of
the CFP submissions for compliance
with the public housing program
requirements. The PHA’s budget must
be approved by the PHA’s Board of
Commissioners, but does not require
HUD approval. The CFP 5-Year Action
Plan, which is a component of the 5Year Plan required under part 903,
continues to be required for all PHAs,
both qualified and nonqualified.
Proposed § 905.300(b)(8) would
address performance and evaluation
reports. Proposed § 905.300(b)(4) would
govern other formal requirements for
qualified and nonqualified PHAs, such
as the requirement that the PHA consult
with the Resident Advisory Board(s)
and conduct annual public hearings.
Proposed § 905.302 would require
PHAs to submit the CF ACC
Amendment by a specified date. Late
submittal does not affect a PHA’s
requirement to obligate and expend its
Capital Fund by the dates established by
HUD. If HUD does not receive the
signed and dated CF ACC Amendment
by the submission deadline, the PHA
will receive the Capital Fund grant for
that year; however, the PHA will have
less than 24 months to obligate 90
percent of the Capital Fund grant and
less than 48 months to expend those
funds, because the PHA’s obligation
start date and disbursement end date for
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
these grants will remain as previously
established by HUD.
Proposed § 905.304 requires public
housing developed or modernized with
Capital Funds to be operated in
accordance with the CF ACC
Amendment. Under proposed
§ 905.304(a)(1), projects developed with
Capital Funds must have a covenant
requiring them to be operated as public
housing for a 40-year period beginning
on the date on which the project
becomes available for occupancy, as
required by section 9(d)(3)(A) of the
1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437g(d)(3)(A)).
Under proposed § 905.304(a)(2), projects
modernized with Capital Funds will
have an additional use restriction for a
20-year period that begins on the latest
date that modernization is completed, as
required by section 9(d)(3)(B) of the
1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437g(d)(3)(B)).
Under proposed § 905.304(a)(3), projects
developed that receive Operating Fund
assistance shall generally have a
covenant to operate under requirements
applicable to public housing for a
10-year period beginning upon the
conclusion of the fiscal year for which
such amounts were provided. In
accordance with the ACC, existing
Declarations of Trust, and section 30 of
the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C.1437z–2),
proposed § 905.304(b) imposes a HUD
approval requirement on any potential
liens or security interests in public
housing assets.
The requirements for obligation and
expenditure of Capital Funds would be
in proposed § 905.306. These
requirements include the statutory time
limits on expenditure found in section
9(j) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437g(j)),
as well as penalties for failure to
obligate Capital Funds in a timely
manner. This section also provides
information on the criteria for
requesting an extension to the obligation
deadline.
Section 905.308 would list federal
requirements applicable to all Capital
Fund modernization, development, and
financing activities, including, but not
limited to, relocation of residents, wage
rates, environmental requirements,
section 504 compliance, and lead-based
paint poisoning prevention.
Proposed § 905.310 would require
that the PHA initiate a fund requisition
from HUD only when the funds are due
and payable, unless HUD authorizes
another method of payment of such
advances, which includes working
capital advances, or reimbursement as
authorized by 24 CFR 85.21.
Proposed § 905.312 would incorporate
the design and construction
requirements, which are currently found
in 24 CFR 941.203. The standards in
PO 00000
Frm 00005
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
6657
proposed § 905.312(a) are similar to
those in currently codified 24 CFR
941.203(a), with the primary difference
being that the proposed § 905.312 would
require structures ‘‘to be consistent
with’’ the neighborhoods they occupy,
rather than requiring them to ‘‘improve
or harmonize with’’ the neighborhoods.
Additionally, proposed § 905.312, like
currently codified § 941.203(b), would
require that all development comply
with a national building code in
addition to the applicable state and
local laws, codes, ordinances, and
regulations. The proposed rule also
specifically addresses accessibility
requirements among the federal
requirements with which compliance is
required at proposed § 905.312(b)(4).
The proposed rule would apply design
and construction standards to
modernization, as well as to
development, in proposed § 905.312(c).
In § 905.312(c)(3), HUD refers to
including cost-effective energy
conservation measures as identified in
the PHA’s most recent updated energy
audit in the design, rehabilitation and
construction of public housing
development. The Department is
seeking public comment, particularly
from PHAs, on what cost-effectiveness
test(s) should be used when deciding
whether an energy conservation
measure identified in the energy audit
should be implemented or not. Issues
for public comment include but are not
limited to the following:
(1) The measurement basis for cost
effectiveness; i.e., whether to use the
total cost of the energy improvement
versus the incremental cost of the
energy improvement;
(2) Are opportunity costs figured into
this calculation (e.g., the incremental
cost of the energy improvement versus
the cost of various alternative uses of
the money);
(3) Do such calculations include any
expected increase in energy costs; and
(4) The period of time over which the
cost of the improvement would be
realized, such as the manufacturer’s
estimated useful life versus actual time
in service.
Your comments will assist HUD to
develop important guidance to PHAs
that will assist them in determining the
most cost-effective energy conservation
measures to fund from among the many
identified in the PHAs’ respective
energy audits.
Proposed § 905.314 establishes cost
limits for public housing projects,
including details about how the TDC
and housing construction cost (HCC)
limits are calculated. Modernization
costs are limited to 90 percent of the
TDC; if modernization costs exceed that
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
6658
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
limit, the project will not be
modernized. Also proposed in
§ 905.314(c)(1) is the ability for PHAs to
request a TDC exception for integrated
utility management, capital planning,
and other capital and management
activities that maximize energy
conservation and efficiency, including
green construction and retrofits, which
include windows; heating system
replacements; wall insulation; sitebased generation; advanced energy
savings technologies, including
renewable energy generation; and other
such retrofits. HUD has the statutory
authority to grant such a TDC exception
pursuant to 42 U.S.C. 1437d(b).
For TDC exceptions for integrated
utility management, capital planning,
and other capital and management
activities that maximize energy
conservation and efficiency identified in
§ 905.314(c)(1), the Department will
require that the requesting PHA submit
a detailed list of the planned energy
conservation improvements, an
explanation and justification for the
proposed energy conservation
improvements, and the estimated costs
for HUD review. In addition, PHAs
requesting an exception of the TDC will
be required to submit to HUD an
independent cost certification from a
third party such as a licensed accredited
architect. These materials will be
reviewed by HUD and approved on a
case-by-case basis. The Department is
seeking public comment on what cost
effectiveness test(s) HUD should apply
when reviewing TDC requests for this
exception.
Proposed § 905.314(h) sets
administrative cost limits for
modernization at 10 percent of the
annual Capital Fund grant, excluding
costs related to lead-based paint or
asbestos testing, in-house architectural
or engineering work, or other special
administrative costs, unless approved
by HUD. Proposed § 905.314(h) sets the
administrative cost limits for
development work with Capital Fund
and RHF grants at 3 percent of the total
project budget or, with HUD’s approval,
up to 6 percent of the total project
budget. For a PHA that is under asset
management, this administrative cost
limit of 10 percent includes the Capital
Fund Program fee. This limitation
reflects the priority HUD places on use
of the Capital Fund for development
and modernization.
Proposed § 905.314(j) proposes to
reduce the threshold for management
improvements from 20 percent to 10
percent over a 3-year period. Under the
current CFP a large housing authority (a
PHA with 250 or more units in
management) could use as much as 50
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
percent of a Capital Fund (CF) formula
grant (i.e., 20 percent for management
improvements, 10 percent for
administrative costs, and up to 20
percent for operations) for costs not
associated with physical improvements
of the development. The Department
will not be able to fund the estimated
modernization needs (as determined in
the Capital Needs of the Public Housing
Stock in 1998: Formula Capital Study)
if such a high percentage of the Capital
Fund appropriation is used for purposes
other than modernization or
development of public housing units.
When CGP was established more than
20 years ago, the Department
established a threshold to allow for 20
percent of the Capital Fund grant to be
used to fund resident activities and
other administrative expenses needed to
support the physical improvements
funded by the modernization program.
Since the initiation of the CIAP and
CGP, other programs such as the
Resident Opportunities and Supportive
Services (ROSS) program and
Community and Supportive Services, a
component of the HOPE VI program,
have been established to fund services
that enable residents to become self
sufficient and/or improve their quality
of life. In addition to these programs,
section 9(g) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C.
1437g(g)) allows large PHAs to use up
to 20 percent of a Capital Fund grant for
operating costs, while small PHAs have
complete flexibility to use their entire
Capital Fund grant for operating costs
(§ 905.314(l) of this proposed rule). With
this flexibility to use Capital Fund for
operations, it is no longer necessary to
have such a high threshold for funding
management improvements.
Proposed § 905.314(k) covers resident
management corporation (RMC)
activities. RMCs are authorized under
section 20 of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C.
1437r). Under section 20(c) of the 1937
Act (42 U.S.C. 1437r(c)), a PHA may
provide a portion of its Capital Funds to
an RMC for the purpose of performing
eligible activities (under certain
conditions, RMCs can be directly
funded without going through the PHA
(see 42 U.S.C. 1437r(e)). The proposed
rule would provide that the PHA will
not retain any of the Capital Funds
unless the PHA contractually agrees to
do so with the RMC.
Proposed § 905.314(j) provides for the
HUD-approved use of force account
labor. High-performing PHAs would not
require HUD approval for this purpose.
Proposed § 905.316 of the proposed
rule establishes contracting
requirements. This section generally
requires compliance with 24 CFR 85.36.
Proposed § 905.316(d) requires that,
PO 00000
Frm 00006
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
notwithstanding the bonding
requirements of 24 CFR 85.36(h), for
each contract over $100,000, the
contractor shall provide a bid guarantee
equivalent to 5 percent of the bid price
plus one of five acceptable forms of
bond listed.
Section 905.318 of the proposed rule
would require the PHA to obtain a title
insurance policy before taking title to
any and all sites and properties acquired
with Capital Funds. Section 905.318
also would require recordation of the
deed as prescribed by HUD.
Proposed § 905.320 would impose
contract administration duties on the
PHA for work performed using Capital
Funds. The PHA must inspect the work
and determine when it is acceptable,
and shall pay a contractor only for work
that the PHA has inspected and
accepted.
Proposed § 905.322 would require
that the fiscal closeout of a Capital Fund
project requires the submission of a cost
certificate; and an audit, if applicable.
Proposed § 905.322 also would require
the submission of a performance and
evaluation (P&E) report that describes
the progress on open Capital Fund
grants, which is currently required by
24 CFR 968.330. If the PHA does not
submit the cost certificate and P&E
report in a timely manner as specified
in the regulation, HUD may, after
notifying the PHA, impose restrictions
on the PHA’s Capital Fund grants.
Proposed § 905.322(c) would provide
that the cost certificate is also subject to
audit. For PHAs that are exempt from
audit, HUD would review and approve
the cost certificate based on available
information regarding the Capital Fund
grant. Proposed § 905.322(e) would
provide that all Capital Funds in excess
of the actual cost incurred for the grant
are subject to recapture.
Proposed § 905.324 would require
certain data reporting by PHAs.
Proposed § 905.326 would require
PHAs to keep full and complete records
of each Capital Fund grant.
D. Subpart D
Subpart D would incorporate, in
proposed § 905.400, the regulations that
establish the CF formula, currently
codified in § 905.10, with the exception
of reference to the emergency reserve
fund, which was removed by HERA, as
discussed above.
The CF formula was initially
established by final rule published on
March 16, 2000 (65 FR 14422), and that
formula is not proposed to be changed
by this rule. Terminology would be
updated to reflect the change to asset
management and project-level
accounting. In April 2008, PIC was
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
realigned to reflect the reorganization of
developments into projects. In order to
avoid resulting changes in DOFA dates
that otherwise could have affected
certain PHAs, § 905.400 (d)(6) of this
rule proposes to freeze the
determination of modernization need as
of FFY 2008 and then make adjustments
based on changes in inventory. The end
result is that there is no substantive
change to the formula or the resulting
allocation of Capital Funds, and hence
the formula, which was originally
established through a statutory
negotiated rulemaking process, is
presented here for the sake of
completeness only and not for public
comment. However, HUD will accept
comment on the aforementioned
technical changes reflecting asset
management.
Since the Study of the Modernization
Needs of the Public and Indian Housing
Stock, prepared by Abt Associates Inc.,
in 1988, the Department has demolished
more than 100,000 units of severely
distressed public housing and funded a
significant amount of modernization in
public housing. Subsequently, the
Department has already funded 10 years
of replacement housing grants for the
severely distressed public housing that
was removed from the public housing
inventory. Section 905.400(j) proposes a
transition from a 10-year-long RHF
program to a 5-year RHF program for
PHAs that remove units from the
inventory based on demolition or
disposition. The transition to a 5-year
RHF program would be effective in FFY
2011 for PHAs that removed units from
the inventory in FFY 2010. In FFY 2011,
any PHA that began receiving RHF in
FFY 2010 based on demolition or
disposition that occurred in FFY 2009
and earlier will receive the remainder of
its first increment and be eligible for a
second increment. Subsequently, PHAs
that are already receiving RHF funding
in FFY 2011 will not be negatively
impacted by the transition because they
will receive the total 10 years of RHF
funding and will be eligible to receive
RHF funding for units removed from
inventory for the sale of homeownership
as described in § 905.400(j)(1). Also,
beginning in FFY 2011, PHAs will be
eligible to receive RHF funding for units
removed from inventory for the sale of
homeownership as described in
§ 905.400(j)(1) and be allowed to use
RHF grants to fund development of
either public housing rental or
homeownership units. The Department
is soliciting comments from PHAs and
the PHA interest groups on this
proposal to change the RHF funding.
Proposed § 905.400(k) provides for a
performance award factor similar to
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
currently codified § 905.10(j). The
provisions of currently codified
§ 905.10(k) on eligible costs would be
moved to proposed § 905.200.
E. Subpart E
Subpart E would address the use of
Capital Funds for financing. This
subpart is reserved for the regulation
entitled ‘‘Use of Public Housing Capital
and Operating Funds for Financing
Activities’’ that is the subject of a
separate rulemaking. (See final rule
published on October 21, 2010, at 75 FR
65198.)
F. Subpart F
Subpart F would contain the
development requirements, including
those related to mixed-finance projects.
These requirements would be moved to
subpart F from 24 CFR part 941.
Program requirements including the
limitation on costs and site and
neighborhood standards are described
in § 905.602. The Department has not
made any substantive changes to the site
and neighborhood standards found at
§ 941.202. Definitions specifically
related to public housing development
are found in § 905.604(b). This subpart
also proposes certain deviations from
applicable requirements as HUD is
permitted to do by regulation in the case
of mixed-finance projects under section
35(h) of the 1937 Act, 42 U.S.C. 1437z–
7(h). Section 905.604(l), which pertains
to closing materials and other
documents, and § 905.604(m), which
addresses subsidy layering, are reserved
to address the revised regulations that
are the subject of the rulemaking
entitled ‘‘Streamlining of Mixed Finance
Applications,’’ which was published as
a proposed rule in the Federal Register
on December 27, 2006. Development,
with regards to homeownership, will be
addressed by a separate rulemaking.
G. Subpart G
Subpart G would state that the PHA
may not pledge, mortgage, or enter into
a transaction that uses public housing
assets without written HUD approval.
H. Subpart H
Subpart H would address PHA
compliance with Capital Fund
requirements, and HUD review and
sanction for noncompliance with HUD
contracts and regulations.
V. Findings and Certifications
Paperwork Reduction Act
The information collection
requirements contained in this rule have
been approved by the Office of
Management and Budget (OMB) under
the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995
PO 00000
Frm 00007
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
6659
(44 U.S.C. 3501–3520) and given OMB
control numbers 2577–0157 and 2577–
0226. In accordance with the Paperwork
Reduction Act, an agency may not
conduct or sponsor, and a person is not
required to respond to, a collection of
information, unless the collection
displays a currently valid OMB control
number.
Regulatory Planning and Review
OMB reviewed this rule under
Executive Order 12866 (entitled
‘‘Regulatory Planning and Review’’).
This rule was determined to be a
‘‘significant regulatory action’’ as
defined in section 3(f) of the Order
(although not an economically
significant regulatory action under the
Order).
The rule would not have any direct
financial impact on the level of funding
for the CFP, but has the potential to
create some financial transfers among
program participants. However, the total
amount of transfer is estimated to be
less than $100 million annually.
The rule would gradually phase down
the dollar threshold for management
improvements, from up to 20 percent to
up to 10 percent of a PHA’s CF formula
grant over a period of 3 fiscal years. On
average, PHAs use approximately 8
percent of their Capital Fund grants on
management improvements, with many
PHAs using considerably less and large
PHAs of more than 250 units using 9
percent. In 2008, $2.38 billion in
formula funds were distributed to PHAs.
If all PHAs were using the full 20
percent permitted under the current
rule, a 10 percent reduction in the
management improvement threshold
would indicate that about $238 million
would be reprogrammed for other
eligible activities and would constitute
a transfer from one group of
stakeholders that traditionally received
management improvement funds, to
other CFP eligible activities and
stakeholders, without any impact on
funding. However, given that the actual
rate of usage is below 10 percent, this
program requirement would not result
in any transfers.
The rule would also phase down the
allocation of funds for the RHF from a
10-year RHF to a 5-year RHF. In 2008,
a total of 294 PHAs received RHF funds.
That year, 251 PHAs funded under the
CF formula received $97,936,944 RHF
first increment funding, and 123 PHAs
received $112,825,095 RHF second
increment funding. Five years after the
implementation of the RHF phasedown, the $113 million second
increment funding would be eliminated
and redistributed by formula to all 3,138
eligible PHAs, creating a transfer, but
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
6660
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
one only among PHAs. However, HUD
has already funded more than 10 years
of RHF to assist PHAs that demolished
over 100,000 units of severely distressed
public housing; thus, the need for RHF
has significantly decreased. The phasedown also grandfathers all PHAs that
are receiving first- or second-increment
RHF as of Fiscal Year (FY) 2010,
minimizing the impact.
This rule, if implemented as
proposed, would also have significant
benefits. This rule updates and
consolidates the CFP regulations and
related regulations having to do with the
use of Capital Funds for development
and modernization, as well as
regulations for continuing operation of
low-income housing after completion of
debt service. In addition, the rule
proposes to codify recent statutory
requirements enacted in HERA. The
benefits of the rule such as regulatory
consolidation, program clarification,
removal of obsolete references, and
enhanced efficiencies make the rule
necessary. Although HUD established
the CF formula in 2000, HUD has
continued to rely on CFP requirements
to the extent that these requirements
were not superseded by statutory
requirements.
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act
Title II of the Unfunded Mandates
Reform Act of 1995 (2 U.S.C. 1531–
1538) (UMRA) establishes requirements
for federal agencies to assess the effects
of their regulatory actions on state,
local, and tribal governments and the
private sector. This rule does not
impose any federal mandate on any
state, local, or tribal government or the
private sector within the meaning of
UMRA.
Environmental Impact
A Finding of No Significant Impact
with respect to the environment has
been made in accordance with HUD
regulations at 24 CFR part 50, which
implement section 102(2)(C) of the
National Environmental Policy Act of
1969 (42 U.S.C. 4332(2)(C)). The
Finding of No Significant Impact is
available for public inspection between
the hours of 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. weekdays
in the Regulations Division, Office of
General Counsel, Department of
Housing and Urban Development, 451
7th Street, SW., Room 10276,
Washington, DC 20410–0500. Due to
security measures at the HUD
Headquarters building, an advance
appointment to review the docket file
must be scheduled by calling the
Regulations Division at 202–708–3055
(this is not a toll-free number). Hearingor speech-impaired individuals may
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
access this number through TTY by
calling the toll-free Federal Information
Relay Service at 800–877–8339.
Regulatory Flexibility Act
The Regulatory Flexibility Act (RFA)
(5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.) generally requires
an agency to conduct a regulatory
flexibility analysis of any rule subject to
notice and comment rulemaking
requirements, unless the agency certifies
that the rule will not have a significant
economic impact on a substantial
number of small entities. This rule
reflects the transition from PHA-wide
accounting to an asset management
model, and therefore changes some of
the language regarding the CF formula
to reflect the new accounting model.
The only significant change in the CF
formula calculation is a proposal to
limit the number of years a PHA is
eligible to receive RHF grants to replace
units removed from the inventory by
demolition, disposition, or
homeownership, from 10 years to
5 years. The CF formula amount that is
freed up because of fewer RHF grants
will cause an increase in the amount of
Capital Funds available to the
remainder of the PHAs, which includes
a large number of small PHAs. Since
most small PHAs do not demolish or
dispose of a significant number of
public housing units, reducing RHF
eligibility to 5 years should benefit
small PHAs. Therefore, the undersigned
certifies that this rule will not have a
significant economic impact on a
substantial number of small entities,
and an initial regulatory flexibility
analysis is not required.
Notwithstanding the determination
that this rule would not have a
significant impact on a substantial
number of small entities, HUD
specifically invites any comments
regarding any less burdensome
alternatives to this rule that will meet
HUD’s objectives as described in this
preamble.
Executive Order 13132, Federalism
Executive Order 13132 (entitled
‘‘Federalism’’) prohibits, to the extent
practicable and permitted by law, an
agency from promulgating a regulation
that has federalism implications and
either imposes substantial direct
compliance costs on state and local
governments and is not required by
statute or preempts state law, unless the
relevant requirements of section 6 of the
Executive Order are met. This rule does
not have federalism implications and
does not impose substantial direct
compliance costs on state and local
governments or preempt state law
PO 00000
Frm 00008
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
within the meaning of the Executive
Order.
Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance
Number
The Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance numbers for 24 CFR parts
905, 941, 968, and 969 are 14.850,
14.872, 14.882, 14.883.
List of Subjects
24 CFR Part 903
Administrative practice and
procedure, Public housing, Reporting
and recordkeeping requirements.
24 CFR Part 905
Grant programs—housing and
community development, Public
housing, Reporting and recordkeeping
requirements.
24 CFR Part 941
Grant programs—housing and
community development, Loan
programs—housing and community
development, Public housing.
24 CFR Part 968
Grant programs—housing and
community development, Loan
programs—housing and community
development, Public housing, Reporting
and recordkeeping requirements.
24 CFR Part 969
Grant programs—housing and
community development, Low and
moderate income housing, Public
housing.
Accordingly, for the reasons stated in
the preamble, under the authority of 42
U.S.C. 3535(d), HUD proposes to amend
24 CFR chapter IX as follows:
PART 903—PUBLIC HOUSING
AGENCY PLANS
1. The authority citation for part 903
is revised to read as follows:
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 1437c; 42 U.S.C.
1437c–1; Pub. L. 110–289; 42 U.S.C. 3535d.
2. Revise § 903.3 to read as follows:
§ 903.3 What is the purpose of this
subpart?
(a) This subpart specifies the
requirements for PHA plans, required by
section 5A of the United States Housing
Act of 1937 (42 U.S.C. 1437c–1) (the
Act), as amended.
(b) Title VII of the Housing and
Economic Reform Act, Public Law 110–
289, section 2702, amends 42 U.S.C.
1437c–1(b) to provide qualified public
housing agencies (PHAs) an exemption
from the requirement of section 5A of
the Act to submit an annual PHA Plan.
The term ‘‘qualified public housing
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
agency’’ has the meaning stated in
section 2702(a)(3)(C) of Pub. L. 110–289.
HUD will make available a list of the
qualified PHAs on a quarterly basis.
3. Revise part 905 to read as follows:
PART 905—THE PUBLIC HOUSING
CAPITAL FUND PROGRAM
Subpart A—General
Sec.
905.100 Purpose, general description, and
other requirements.
905.102 Applicability.
905.104 HUD approvals.
905.106 Compliance.
905.108 Definitions.
Subpart B—Eligible Activities
905.200
905.202
905.204
Eligible activities.
Ineligible activities and costs.
Emergencies and natural disasters.
Subpart C—General Program Requirements
905.300 Capital fund submission
requirements.
905.302 Timely submission of the CF ACC
amendment by the PHA.
905.304 CF ACC term and covenant to
operate.
905.306 Obligations and expenditure of
Capital Fund grants.
905.308 Federal requirements applicable to
all capital fund activities.
905.310 Disbursements from HUD.
905.312 Design and construction.
905.314 Cost and other limitations.
905.316 Procurement and contract
requirements.
905.318 Title and deed.
905.320 Contract administration and
acceptance of work.
905.322 Fiscal closeout.
905.324 Data reporting requirements.
905.326 Records.
Subpart D—Capital Fund Formula
905.400
Capital Fund formula (CF formula).
Subpart E—Use of Capital Funds for
Financing [Reserved]
Subpart F—Development Requirements
905.600 General.
905.602 Program requirements.
905.604 Mixed-finance development.
905.606 Development proposal.
905.608 Site or property acquisition
proposal.
905.610 Technical processing.
905.612 Disbursement of capital funds—
predevelopment costs.
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Subpart G—Other Security Interests
905.700
Other security interests.
Subpart H—Compliance, HUD Review,
Penalties, and Sanctions
905.800
905.802
905.804
Compliance.
HUD review of PHA performance.
Sanctions.
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 1437g and 3535(d);
Pub. L. 110–289.
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
Subpart A—General
§ 905.100 Purpose, general description,
and other requirements.
(a) Purpose. The Public Housing
Capital Fund Program (Capital Fund
Program or CFP) provides financial
assistance to public housing agencies
(PHAs) and resident management
corporations (RMC) (pursuant to 24 CFR
964.225) to make improvements to
existing public housing. The CFP also
provides financial assistance to develop
public housing, including mixedfinance developments that contain
public housing units.
(b) General description. Congress
appropriates amounts for the Capital
Fund in HUD’s annual appropriations.
In order to receive a Capital Fund grant,
the PHA must:
(1) Validate project-level information
in HUD’s data systems, as prescribed by
HUD;
(2) Have an approved CFP 5-Year
Action Plan;
(3) Enter into a Capital Fund Annual
Contributions Contract (CF ACC)
Amendment to the PHA’s Annual
Contributions Contract (as defined in
24 CFR 5.403) with HUD; and
(4) Provide a written certification and
counsel’s opinion that all property
receiving Capital Fund assistance is
under a currently effective Declaration
of Trust and is in compliance with the
CF ACC and the Act.
(c) Informational requirements.
Section 905.300 of this part describes
the information to be submitted to HUD
for the CFP. HUD uses the Capital Fund
formula set forth in § 905.400 of this
part, along with data provided by the
PHA and other information, including,
but not limited to, the High Performance
information from the Real Estate
Assessment Center (REAC) and location
cost indices, to determine each PHA’s
annual grant amount. HUD notifies each
PHA of the amount of the grant and
provides a CF ACC Amendment that
must be signed by the PHA and
executed by HUD in order for the PHA
to access the grant. After HUD executes
the CF ACC Amendment, the PHA may
draw down funds for eligible costs that
have been described in its CFP Annual
Statement/Performance and Evaluation
Report or CFP 5-Year Action Plan.
(d) Eligible activities. Eligible Capital
Fund costs and activities as further
described in subpart B of this part
include, but are not limited to, making
physical improvements to the public
housing stock and developing public
housing units to be added to the existing
inventory. With HUD approval, a PHA
may also leverage its public housing
inventory by borrowing additional
PO 00000
Frm 00009
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
6661
capital on the private market and
pledging a portion of its annual Capital
Funds for debt service in accordance
with § 905.500.
(e) Obligation and expenditure
requirements. A PHA must obligate and
expend its Capital Funds in accordance
with § 905.306. The PHA will directly
employ labor, either temporarily or
permanently, to perform work (force
account) or contract for the required
work in accordance with 24 CFR part
85. Upon completion of the work, the
PHA must submit an Actual
Modernization Cost Certificate (AMCC)
or Actual Development Cost Certificate
(ADCC) and a final Performance and
Evaluation Report (in accordance with
§ 905.322) to HUD to close out each
Capital Fund grant.
(f) Financing and development.
Section 905.500 of this part regulates
financing activities using Capital Funds
and Operating Funds. Section 905.600
of this part contains the development
requirements, including those related to
mixed-finance development formerly
found in 24 CFR part 941. Section
905.700 of this part describes the
criteria for the use of Capital Funds for
other security interest. Section 905.800
of this part addresses PHA compliance
with Capital Fund requirements and
HUD capability for review and sanction
for noncompliance.
§ 905.102
Applicability.
All PHAs that have public housing
units under an Annual Contributions
Contract as described in 24 CFR 5.403
are eligible to receive Capital Funds.
§ 905.104
HUD approvals.
All HUD approvals required in this
part must be in writing and from an
official designated to grant such
approval.
§ 905.106
Compliance.
PHAs or owner/management entities
or their partners are required to comply
with all applicable provisions of this
part. Execution of the CF ACC
Amendment, submissions required by
this part, and disbursement of Capital
Fund grants from HUD are individually
and collectively deemed to be the PHA’s
certification that it is in compliance
with the provisions of this part and all
other Public Housing Program
Requirements. Noncompliance with any
provision of this part or other applicable
requirements may subject the PHA and/
or its partners to sanctions contained in
§ 905.804.
§ 905.108
Definitions.
The following definitions apply to
this part:
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
6662
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
1937 Act. The term ‘‘1937 Act’’ is
defined in 24 CFR 5.100.
Accessible. As defined in 24 CFR 8.3.
Additional Project Costs. The sum of
the following HUD-approved costs
related to the development of a public
housing project:
(1) Costs for the demolition or
remediation of environmental hazards
associated with public housing units
that will not be rebuilt on the original
site; and
(2) Extraordinary site costs that have
been verified by an independent state
registered, licensed engineer (e.g.,
removal of underground utility systems;
replacement of off-site underground
utility systems; extensive rock and/or
soil removal and replacement; and
amelioration of unusual site conditions
such as unusual slopes, terraces, water
catchments, lakes, etc.). These costs are
not subject to the Total Development
Cost (TDC) limit, but are included in the
maximum project cost as stated in
§ 905.314(b).
Capital Fund (CF). The fund
established under 42 U.S.C. 1437g(d).
Capital Fund Annual Contributions
Contract Amendment (CF ACC). A
contract under the 1937 Act between
HUD and the PHA containing the terms
and conditions under which the
Department assists the PHA in
providing decent, safe, and sanitary
housing for low-income families. The
CF ACC must be in a form prescribed by
HUD, under which HUD agrees to
provide assistance in the development,
modernization, and/or operation of a
low-income housing project under the
1937 Act and the PHA agrees to
modernize and operate the project in
compliance with all Public Housing
Requirements.
Capital Fund Program Fee. The
Capital Fund Program Fee covers costs
associated with the Central Office Cost
Center’s (COCC) oversight and
management of the Capital Fund
Program. These costs include duties
related to general capital planning,
preparing of the Annual Plan,
processing of the Line of Credit Control
System (LOCCS), preparation of reports,
drawing of funds, budgeting,
accounting, and procurement of
construction and other miscellaneous
contracts. The Capital Fund Program
Fee is the administrative cost for
managing Capital Fund grants for PHAs
subject to asset management, which is
subject to the regulatory limitation of 10
percent of the annual capital fund grant.
Community Renewal Costs. Public
housing capital assistance may be used
to pay for Community Renewal Costs in
an amount equivalent to the difference
between the Housing Construction Costs
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
(HCCs) paid for with public housing
capital assistance and the TDC limit.
Cooperation Agreement. An
agreement, in a form prescribed by
HUD, between a PHA and the applicable
local governing body or bodies that
assures exemption from real and
personal property taxes, provides for
local support and services for the
development and operation of public
housing, and provides for PHA
payments in lieu of taxes (PILOT).
Date of Full Availability (DOFA). The
last day of the month in which
substantially all (95 percent or more) of
the units in a public housing project are
available for occupancy.
Emergency Work. Capital Fund
related physical work items that if not
done pose an immediate threat to the
health or safety of residents, and which
must be completed within one year of
funding. Management Improvements are
not eligible as emergency work and
therefore must be covered by the CFP 5Year Action Plan before the PHA may
carry them out.
Expenditure. Capital Funds disbursed
to the PHA to pay for obligations
incurred in connection with work
included in a HUD approved CFP 5Year Action Plan. Total funds expended
means cash actually disbursed and does
not include retainage.
Federal Fiscal Year (FFY). The
Federal Fiscal Year begins each year on
October 1 and ends on September 30 of
the following year.
Force Account Labor. Labor employed
directly by the PHA on either a
permanent or a temporary basis.
Fungibility. As it relates to the Capital
Fund Program, fungibility allows the
PHA to substitute work items between
any of the years within the latest
approved CFP 5-Year Action Plan,
without prior HUD approval.
Housing Construction Cost (HCC). The
sum of the following HUD-approved
costs related to the development of a
public housing project: Dwelling unit
hard costs (including construction and
equipment), builder’s overhead and
profit, the cost of extending utilities
from the street to the public housing
project, finish landscaping, and the
payment of Davis-Bacon wage rates.
Line of Credit Control System
(LOCCS). LOCCS-Web is an intranet
version of LOCCS for HUD personnel.
eLOCCS is the Internet link to LOCCS
data for HUD business partners.
Mixed-Finance Modernization. Use of
the mixed-finance method of
development to modernize public
housing projects.
Natural Disaster. An extraordinary
event, affecting only one or few PHAs,
but excluding Presidentially declared
PO 00000
Frm 00010
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
emergencies and major disasters under
the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief
and Emergency Assistance Act, 42
U.S.C. 5121 et seq.
Obligation. A binding agreement for
work or financing that will result in
outlays, immediately or in the future.
All obligations must be incorporated
within the HUD-approved CFP 5-Year
Action Plan. This includes funds
obligated by the PHA for work to be
performed by contract labor (i.e.,
contract award), or by force account
labor (i.e., work actually started by PHA
employees). Capital Funds identified in
the PHA’s CFP 5-Year Action Plan to be
transferred to operations are obligated
by PHAs once the funds have been
budgeted and drawn down by the PHA.
Once these funds are drawn down they
are subject to the requirements of 24
CFR part 990.
Open Grant. Any grant for which a
cost certificate has not been submitted
and has not reached fiscal closeout as
described in § 905.322.
Operating Fund. Assistance provided
under 24 CFR part 990 pursuant to
section 9(e) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C.
1437g(e)) for the purpose of operation
and management of public housing.
PIH Information Center (PIC). PIH’s
current system for recording data
concerning: The public housing
inventory, the characteristics of public
housing and Housing Choice Voucher
assisted families, the characteristics of
PHAs, and performance measurement of
housing authorities receiving Housing
Choice Voucher funding.
Public Housing Agency (PHA). Any
State, county, municipality, or other
governmental entity or public body or
agency or instrumentality of these
entities that is authorized to engage or
assist in the development or operation
of public housing under this part.
Public Housing Assessment System
(PHAS). The assessment system under
24 CFR part 902 for measuring the
properties and PHA management
performance in essential housing
operations, including rewards for strong
performers and consequences for poor
performers.
Public Housing Development. Any or
all undertakings necessary for planning,
land acquisition, demolition,
construction, or equipment in
connection with a public housing
project.
Public Housing Project. The term
‘‘public housing’’ means low-income
housing, and all necessary
appurtenances thereto, assisted under
the 1937 Act, other than Section 8. The
term ‘‘public housing’’ includes dwelling
units in a mixed-finance project that are
assisted by a public housing agency
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
with Capital Fund or Operating Fund
assistance. When used in reference to
public housing, the term ‘‘project’’
means housing developed, acquired, or
assisted by a public housing agency
under the 1937 Act, and the
improvement of any such housing.
Public Housing Requirements. All
requirements applicable to public
housing including, but not limited to,
the 1937 Act; HUD regulations; the CF
ACC, including amendments; HUD
notices; and all applicable federal
statutes, executive orders, and
regulatory requirements, as these
requirements may be amended from
time to time.
Reasonable cost. An amount to
rehabilitate or modernize an existing
structure that is not greater than 90
percent of the TDC for a new
development of the same structure type,
number, and size of units in the same
market area. Reasonable costs are also
determined with consideration of HUD
regulations including 24 CFR part 85
and OMB Circular A–87.
Reconfiguration. The altering of the
interior space of buildings (e.g., moving
or removing interior walls to change the
design, sizes, or number of units)
without demolition, as defined in 24
CFR 970.5.
Uniform Federal Accessibility
Standards (UFAS). As defined in 24
CFR 8.32.
Subpart B—Eligible Activities
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
§ 905.200
Eligible activities.
(a) General. Eligible activities include
only items specified in an approved CFP
5-Year Action Plan as identified in
§ 905.300, or approved by HUD for
emergency and natural disaster
assistance.
(b) Eligible activities. Eligible
activities include the development,
financing, and modernization of public
housing projects, including the
redesign, reconstruction, and
reconfiguration of public housing sites
and buildings (including accessible
design and construction of accessibility
improvements) and the development of
mixed-finance projects, including the
following:
(1) Modernization. Modernization
means the activities identified in
§ 905.200(a), except those activities
associated with the development of
public housing;
(2) Development. Development refers
to activities and related costs to add
units to a PHA’s public housing
inventory under § 905.600, including:
Construction and acquisition with or
without rehabilitation; any and all
undertakings necessary for planning,
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
design, financing, land acquisition,
demolition, construction, or equipment,
including development of public
housing units, and buildings, facilities,
and/or related appurtenances (i.e.,
nondwelling facilities/spaces).
Development of mixed-finance projects
include the provision of public housing
through a regulatory and operating
agreement, master contract, individual
lease, condominium or cooperative
agreement, or equity interest.
(3) Financing. Debt and financing
costs (e.g., origination fees, interest)
incurred by PHAs for development or
modernization of PHA projects that
involves the use of Capital Funds,
including, but not limited to:
(i) Mixed Finance as described in
§ 905.604;
(ii) The Capital Fund Financing
Program (CFFP) as described in
§ 905.500; and
(iii) Any other use authorized by the
Secretary under section 30 of the 1937
Act (42 U.S.C. 1437).
(4) Vacancy reduction. Physical
improvements to reduce the number of
units that are vacant. Not included are
costs for routine vacant unit turnaround
such as painting, cleaning, and minor
repairs. Vacancy reduction activities
must be remedies to a defined vacancy
problem detailed in a vacancy reduction
program included in the PHA’s CFP 5Year Action Plan.
(5) Nonroutine maintenance. Work
items that ordinarily would be
performed on a regular basis in the
course of maintenance of property, but
have become substantial in scope
because they have been postponed and
involve expenditures that would
otherwise materially distort the level
trend of maintenance expenses. These
activities also include the replacement
of obsolete utility systems and dwelling
equipment.
(6) Planned code compliance.
Building code compliance includes
design and physical improvement costs
associated with:
(i) Correcting violations of local code
or the Uniform Physical Condition
Standards (UPCS) under the Public
Housing Assessment System (PHAS),
and
(ii) A national building code, such as
those developed by the International
Code Council or the National Fire
Protection Association; and the 2006
International Energy Conservation Code
(IECC), or ASHRAE 90.1–2004 for
multifamily high-rises (four stories or
higher), or a successor energy code or
standard that has been adopted by HUD
pursuant to 42 U.S.C. 12709 or other
relevant authority.
PO 00000
Frm 00011
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
6663
(7) Management improvements.
Activities that are project-specific or
PHA-wide noncapital improvements
needed to upgrade the operation of the
PHA’s projects, including upgrading
operations to maximize energy
conservation to sustain physical
improvements at those projects, or
correct management deficiencies. Such
activities include, but are not limited to,
the following costs:
(i) Training for PHA personnel in
operations and procedures;
(ii) Improvement of resident programs
and services, including resident and
project security, and resident selection
and eviction;
(iii) Activities that assure or foster
equal opportunity; and
(iv) Resident management costs not
covered by the Operating Fund include,
but are not limited to:
(A) The cost of technical assistance to
a resident council or RMC to assess
feasibility of carrying out management
functions for a specific development or
developments;
(B) The cost to train residents in skills
directly related to the operation and
management of the development(s) for
potential employment by the RMC;
(C) The cost to train RMC board
members in community organization,
board development, and leadership; and
the cost of the formation of an RMC; and
(D) When carrying out management
improvement activities, the PHA shall
give priority to correcting deficiencies
under PHAS before expending Capital
Funds on other management
improvements, except for activities
necessary to address emergency work or
statutory or court-ordered deadlines.
(8) Resident self-sufficiency.
(i) Economic Self-Sufficiency Costs.
These include costs for resident job
training and resident business
development activities to enable
residents and their businesses to carry
out Capital Fund-assisted activities.
HUD encourages PHAs, to the greatest
extent feasible, to hire residents as
trainees, apprentices, or employees to
carry out activities under this part, and
to contract with resident-owned
businesses as required by Section 3 of
the Housing and Community
Development Act of 1968, 12 U.S.C.
1701u.
(ii) Resident Participation Costs.
These are costs that promote more
effective resident participation in the
operation of the PHA in its Capital Fund
activities to the extent not covered by
$25 per unit, per month, from the
Operating Fund. They include costs for
staff support, outreach, training,
meeting and office space, childcare,
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
6664
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
transportation, and access to computers
that are modest and reasonable.
(iii) Economic Self-Sufficiency.
Capital expenditures to facilitate
programs to improve the empowerment
and economic self-sufficiency of public
housing residents.
(9) Demolition and reconfiguration.
(i) The costs to demolish dwelling
units or nondwelling facilities approved
by HUD, where required, and other
related costs for activities such as
relocation, clearing, and grading the site
after demolition, and subsequent site
improvements to benefit the remaining
portion of the existing public housing
property, as applicable.
(ii) The costs to develop dwelling
units or nondwelling facilities approved
by HUD, where required, and other
related costs for activities such as
relocation, clearing, and grading the site
prior to development.
(iii) The costs to reconfigure existing
dwelling units to units with different
bedroom sizes or to a nondwelling use.
(10) Resident relocation and mobility
counseling. Relocation and other
assistance (e.g., reasonable out-of-pocket
expenses incurred in connection with
temporary relocation, including the cost
of moving to and from temporary
housing and any increase in monthly
rent/utility costs) for permanent or
temporary relocation, as a direct result
of modernization, development,
rehabilitation, demolition,
reconfiguration, or acquisition.
(11) Security and safety. Capital
expenditures to improve the security
and safety of residents.
(12) Homeownership. Activities
associated with approved
homeownership, such as:
(i) The cost of a study to assess the
feasibility of converting rental to
homeownership units and the
preparation of an application for the
conversion to homeownership or sale of
units;
(ii) Construction or acquisition of
units;
(iii) Downpayment assistance;
(iv) Closing cost assistance;
(v) Subordinate mortgage loans;
(vi) Construction or permanent
financing such as write downs for new
construction, or acquisition with or
without rehabilitation; and
(vii) Other activities in support of the
above primary homeownership
activities, including but not limited to:
(A) Demolition to make way for new
construction;
(B) Abatement of environmentally
hazardous materials;
(C) Relocation assistance and mobility
counseling;
(D) Homeownership counseling;
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
(E) Site improvements; or
(F) Administrative and marketing
costs;
(13) Capital Fund related legal costs
(e.g., legal costs related to preparing
property descriptions for the
Declaration on Trust, zoning,
permitting, environmental review,
procurement, and contracting).
(14) Energy efficiency. Allowed costs
include:
(i) Energy audit or updated energy
audit to the extent operating funds are
not available and the energy audit is
included within a modernization
program.
(ii) Integrated utility management and
capital planning to maximize energy
conservation and efficiency measures.
(iii) Energy conservation measures
identified in a PHA’s most recently
updated energy audit.
(iv) Improvement of energy and wateruse efficiency by installing fixtures and
fittings that conform to the American
Society of Mechanical Engineers/
American National Standards Institute
standards A112.19.2–1998 and
A112.18.1–2000, or any revision thereto,
applicable at the time of installation,
and by increasing energy efficiency and
water conservation by such other means
as the Secretary determines are
appropriate.
(v) The installation and the use of
Energy Star appliances whenever energy
systems, devices, and appliances are
replaced, unless it is not cost-effective
to do so, in accordance with Section 152
of the Energy Policy Act of 2005, 42
U.S.C. 15841.
(vi) Utility and energy management
system automation, and metering
activities, including changing
mastermeter systems if installed as a
part of a modernization activity to
upgrade utility systems, e.g. electric,
water, or gas systems of the PHA
consistent with the requirements of 24
CFR part 965.
(15) Administrative costs. Any
administrative costs, including salaries
and employee benefit contributions,
other than the Capital Fund Program
Fee, must be related to a specific public
housing development or modernization
project and detailed in the CFP 5-Year
Action Plan.
(16) Audit. Costs of the annual audit
attributable to the portion of the audit
covering the CFP in accordance with
§ 905.322(c).
(17) Capital Fund Program Fee. This
fee covers costs associated with
oversight and management of the CFP
attributable to the HUD-accepted COCC
as described in 24 CFR part 990 subpart
H. These costs include duties related to
capital planning, preparing the CFP
PO 00000
Frm 00012
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
Annual Statement/Performance and
Evaluation Report, preparing the CFP 5Year Action Plan, monitoring of LOCCS,
preparing reports, drawing of funds,
budgeting, accounting, and procuring of
construction and other miscellaneous
contracts. This fee is not intended to
cover costs associated with construction
supervisory and inspection functions
that are considered a front-line cost of
the project.
(18) Emergency activities. Capital
Fund related activities identified as
emergency work, as defined in
§ 905.108, whether or not the need is
indicated in the CFP 5-Year Action
Plan.
§ 905.202
Ineligible activities and costs.
The following are ineligible activities
and costs for the Capital Fund Program:
(a) Costs not associated with a public
housing project or development, as
defined in § 905.604(b)(1);
(b) Activities and costs not included
in the PHA’s CFP 5-Year Action Plan;
(c) Improvements or purchases that
are not modest in design and cost
because they include amenities,
materials, and design in excess of what
is customary for the locality;
(d) Any costs not authorized as
outlined in OMB Circular A–87,
codified at 2 CFR part 225, including,
but not limited to, indirect
administrative costs and
indemnification;
(e) Public housing operating
assistance, except as provided in
§ 905.314(l);
(f) Direct provision of social services
through either force account or contract
labor;
(g) Eligible costs that are in excess of
the amount directly attributable to the
public housing units when the physical
or management improvements,
including salaries and employee
benefits and contributions, will benefit
programs other than public housing,
such as Section 8 housing choice
voucher or local revitalization programs;
(h) Eligible cost that is funded by
another source and would result in
duplicate funding; and
(i) Any other activities and costs that
HUD may determine on a case-by-case
basis.
§ 905.204 Emergencies and natural
disasters.
(a) General. PHAs are required by the
CF ACC to carry various types of
insurance to protect it from loss. In most
cases, insurance coverage will be the
primary source of funding to pay repair
or replacement costs associated with
emergencies and natural disasters.
Where the Department’s Annual
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
Appropriations Act requires a set aside
from the Capital Fund appropriation for
emergencies and natural disasters, the
procedures in this section apply.
(b) Estimate required. An independent
estimate of damage and repair cost is
required as a part of the final natural
disaster application. For natural
disasters, the assessment must identify
damage specifically caused by the
natural disaster from other repairs. The
set aside can be used only to pay costs
to repair or replace a public housing
project damaged as a result of the
natural disaster, not for nonroutine
maintenance or other improvements.
(c) Emergencies and natural disasters.
An emergency is an unforeseen or
unpreventable event or occurrence that
poses an immediate threat to the health
and safety of the residents that must be
corrected within one year of funding. A
natural disaster for purposes of the
Capital Fund reserve is a nonPresidentially declared disaster. In the
event an emergency or natural disaster
arises, HUD may require a PHA to use
any other source that may legally be
available, including unobligated Capital
Funds, prior to providing emergency or
natural disaster funds from the set aside.
The Department will review, on a caseby-case basis, requests for emergency
and natural disaster funding from PHAs
that have unobligated Capital Funds.
(d) Procedure to request emergency or
natural disaster funds. To obtain
emergency or natural disaster funds, a
PHA shall submit a written request in
the form and manner prescribed by
HUD. In instances where the PHA
requires immediate relief to preserve the
property and safety of the residents, the
PHA may submit a preliminary request
outlined in § 905.204(f). Subsequently,
the PHA is required to complete and
submit the remaining information
outlined in § 905.204(g), at a time
prescribed by HUD.
(e) Procedure to request preliminary
natural disaster grant for immediate
preservation. A PHA may request a
preliminary grant only for costs
necessary for immediate preservation of
the property and protection of the
residents. The application should
include the reasonable identification of
damage and preservation costs as
determined by the PHA. An
independent assessment will be
required when the PHA submits the
final request or when the PHA
reconciles the preliminary application
grant with the actual amounts received
from the Federal Emergency
Management Agency (FEMA), insurance
carriers, and other natural disaster relief
sources. Regardless of whether further
funding from the set aside is requested,
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
at a time specified by HUD, the PHA
will be expected to provide a
reconciliation of all funds received, to
ensure that the PHA does not receive
duplicate funding.
(f) Procedure for final request of
emergency or natural disaster funds. In
the request the PHA shall:
(1) Identify the public housing
project(s) with the emergency or natural
disaster condition(s).
(2) Identify and provide the date of
the:
(i) Conditions that present an
unforeseen or unpreventable threat to
the health, life, or safety of residents in
the case of emergencies; or
(ii) Natural disaster (e.g., hurricane,
tornado, etc.).
(3) Describe the activities that will be
undertaken to correct the emergency or
the conditions caused by the natural
disaster and the estimated cost.
(4) Provide an independent
assessment of the extent of and the cost
to correct the condition. The assessment
must be specific as to the damage and
costs associated with the emergency or
natural disaster.
(5) Provide a copy of a currently
effective Declaration of Trust covering
the property and an opinion of counsel
that there are no preexisting liens or
other encumbrances on the property.
(6) Demonstrate that without the
requested funds from the set aside the
PHA does not have adequate funds
available to correct the emergency
condition(s).
(7) Identify all other sources of
available funds (e.g., insurance
proceeds, FEMA).
(8) Any other material required by
HUD.
(g) HUD Action. HUD shall review all
requests for emergency or natural
disaster funds. If HUD determines that
a PHA’s request meets the requirements
of this section, HUD shall approve the
request subject to the availability of
funds in the set aside, in the order in
which requests are received and are
determined approvable.
(h) Submission of the CF ACC. Upon
being provided with a CF ACC
Amendment from HUD, the PHA must
sign and date the CF ACC Amendment
and return it to HUD by the date
established by HUD. HUD will execute
the signed and dated CF ACC
Amendment submitted by the PHA.
Subpart C—General Program
Requirements
§ 905.300 Capital fund submission
requirements.
(a) General. Unless otherwise stated,
the requirements in this section apply to
PO 00000
Frm 00013
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
6665
both qualified Public Housing Agencies
(as described in § 903.3) and nonqualified Public Housing Agencies. Each
PHA must complete a comprehensive
physical needs assessment (PNA) to be
submitted at a time and in a format
prescribed by HUD. The PHA shall use
the PNA to identify and prioritize work
to be performed with Capital Funds at
each project.
(b) Capital Fund program submission
requirements. At the time that the PHA
submits the ACC Amendment(s) for its
Capital Fund Grants(s) to HUD, the PHA
must also submit the following items:
(1) Budget. The Capital Fund Budget,
including attachments, shall be
prepared by a PHA using the form(s)
prescribed by HUD. The PHA’s budget
must be approved by the PHA’s Board
of Commissioners; it does not require
HUD approval. Work items listed in the
budget must include, but are not limited
to the following:
(i) Where a PHA has an approved
Capital Fund Financing Program (CFFP)
loan, debt service payments for the
grants from which the payments are
scheduled;
(ii) Where a PHA has an approved
CFFP loan, the PHA shall also include
all work and costs, including debt
service payments, in the CFP 5-Year
Action Plan. Work associated with the
use of financing proceeds will be
reported separately in the CFP Annual
Statement/Performance and Evaluation
Report; or
(iii) Work affecting health and safety
and compliance with regulatory
requirements such as section 504 of the
Rehabilitation Act of 1973 and HUD’s
implementing regulations at 24 CFR part
8, and the lead-based paint poisoning
prevention standards at 24 CFR part 35,
before major systems (e.g., heating, roof,
etc.) and other costs of lower priority.
(2) Certifications required for receipt
of Capital Fund grants. The PHA is also
required to submit various certifications
to HUD, in a form prescribed by HUD,
including, but not limited to:
(i) Certification of PIC Data;
(ii) Standard Form—Disclosure of
Lobbying Activities;
(iii) Standard Form—Drug Free
Workplace;
(iv) Civil Rights Compliance in a form
prescribed by HUD; and
(v) Compliance with Public Hearing
Requirements.
(3) Public hearing and Resident
Advisory Board requirements. A PHA
must annually conduct a public hearing
and consult with the Resident Advisory
Board of the PHA to discuss either the
PHA Annual Plan, or any changes to the
goals, objectives, and policies of the
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
6666
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
qualified PHA, in order to solicit public
comment.
(4) Qualified and non-qualified PHAs.
(i) Qualified PHAs, as described in 24
CFR 903.3, are required to comply with
the requirements in the Housing and
Economic Recovery Act (HERA), Public
Law 110–289 (approved July 30, 2008),
section 2702.
(ii) Non-Qualified PHAs are required
to comply with the requirements of 24
CFR part 903.
(5) HUD review for compliance. The
CFP submission requirements must
meet the requirements of this part as
well as the Public Housing Program
Requirements as defined in § 905.108.
PHAs are required to revise or correct
information that is not in compliance,
and HUD has the authority to impose
administrative sanctions until the
appropriate revisions are made. HUD
will review the CFP submission
requirements to determine whether:
(i) All of the information that is
required to be submitted is included;
(ii) The information is consistent with
the needs identified in the PNA and
data available to HUD; and
(iii) There are any issues of
compliance with applicable laws,
regulations, or contract requirements
that have not been addressed with the
proposed use of the Capital Fund.
(6) Time frame for submission of
requirements. The requirements
identified in § 905.300(b) must be
submitted to HUD in a format
prescribed by HUD at the time that the
PHA submits its signed CF ACC
Amendment.
(7) CFP 5-Year Action Plan covering
large capital items for all PHAs.
(i) Content. The CFP 5-Year Action
Plan must describe the capital
improvements necessary to ensure longterm physical and social viability of the
PHA’s public housing developments,
including the capital improvements to
be undertaken with the 5-year period,
their estimated costs, and any other
information required for participation in
the CFP as prescribed by HUD. Except
in the case of emergency work, the PHA
shall not spend Capital Funds on any
work that is not included in an
approved CFP 5-Year Action Plan and
its amendments.
(ii) Submission. The PHA must
submit a CFP 5-Year Action Plan at least
once every 5 years. The PHA may
choose to update its CFP 5-Year Action
Plan every year. The PHA shall indicate
whether its CFP 5-Year Action Plan is
fixed or rolling.
(iii) PHAs making amendments to the
CFP 5-Year Action Plan must follow the
requirements in 24 CFR 903.21.
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
(iv) HUD Review and Approval. PHA
submission and HUD Approval
requirements for the CFP 5-Year Action
Plan must be made pursuant to 24 CFR
part 903. In any given year that a PHA
does not have an approved CFP 5-Year
Action Plan, the Capital Fund grant(s)
for these PHAs will be reserved and
obligated; however, the PHA will not
have access to those funds until its CFP
5-Year Action Plan is approved by HUD.
(8) Performance and Evaluation
Report.
(i) All PHAs must prepare a CFP
Annual Statement/Performance and
Evaluation Report at a time and in a
format prescribed by HUD. These
reports shall be retained on file for all
grants for which a final Actual
Modernization Cost Certificate (AMCC)
or an Actual Development Cost
Certificate (ADCC) has not been
submitted. A final Performance and
Evaluation Report must be submitted in
accordance with 24 CFR 905.322, at the
time the PHA submits its AMCC or
ADCC.
(ii) PHAs that are designated as
Troubled under PHAS or the Section 8
Management Assessment Program
(SEMAP), and/or were identified as
noncompliant with section 9(j)
obligation and expenditure
requirements during the fiscal year,
shall submit their CFP Annual
Statement/Performance and Evaluation
Reports to HUD for review and
approval.
(iii) All other PHAs that are not
designated as Troubled under PHAS,
and were in compliance with section
9(j) obligation and expenditure
requirements during the fiscal year,
shall prepare a CFP Annual Statement/
Performance and Evaluation report for
all open grants and shall retain the
report(s) on file at PHA to be available
to HUD upon request.
§ 905.302 Timely submission of the CF
ACC amendment by the PHA.
Upon being provided with a CF ACC
Amendment from HUD, the PHA must
sign and date the CF ACC Amendment
and return it to HUD by the date
established. HUD will execute the
signed and dated CF ACC Amendment
submitted by the PHA. If HUD does not
receive the signed and dated
Amendment by the submission
deadline, the PHA will receive the
Capital Fund grant for that year;
however, it will have less than 24
months to obligate 90 percent of the
Capital Fund grant and less than 48
months to expend these funds because
the PHA’s obligation start date and
disbursement end date for these grants
PO 00000
Frm 00014
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
will remain as previously established by
HUD.
§ 905.304
operate.
CF ACC term and covenant to
(a) Period of obligation to operate as
public housing. The PHA shall operate
all public housing projects in
accordance with the CF ACC, as
amended, and applicable HUD
regulations for the statutorily prescribed
period. These periods shall be
evidenced by a recorded Declaration of
Trust on all public housing property. If
the PHA uses Capital Funds to develop
public housing or to modernize existing
public housing, the CF ACC term and
the covenant to operate those projects
are as follows:
(1) Development activities. Each
public housing project developed using
Capital Funds shall establish a restricted
use covenant to operate under the terms
and conditions applicable to public
housing for a 40-year period that begins
on the date on which the project
becomes available for occupancy, as
determined by HUD.
(2) Modernization activities. For PHAs
that receive Capital Fund assistance, the
execution of each new CF ACC
Amendment establishes an additional
20-year period that begins on the latest
date on which modernization is
completed, except that the additional
20-year period does not apply to a
project that receives Capital Fund
assistance only for management
improvements.
(3) Operating fund. Any public
housing project developed that receives
Operating Fund assistance shall have a
covenant to operate under requirements
applicable to public housing for a 10year period beginning upon the
conclusion of the fiscal year for which
such amounts were provided, except for
such shorter period as permitted by
HUD by an exception.
(b) Mortgage or security interests. The
PHA shall not allow any mortgages or
security interests in public housing
assets, including under section 30 of the
1937 Act, without prior written
approval from HUD.
(c) Applicability of latest expiration
date. All public housing subject to this
part or required by law shall be
maintained and operated as public
housing as prescribed until the latest
expiration date provided in section
9(d)(3) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C.
1437g(d)(3)) or any other provision of
law or regulation mandating the
operation of the housing as public
housing, or under terms and conditions
applicable to public housing, for a
specified period of time.
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
§ 905.306 Obligation and expenditure of
Capital Fund grants.
(a) Obligation. A PHA shall obligate
each Capital Fund grant, including
formula grants, Replacement Housing
Factor (RHF) grants, and natural disaster
grants, no later than 24 months, and
emergency grants no later than 12
months after the date on which the
funds become available to the PHA for
obligation, except as provided in
paragraphs (c) and (d) of this section.
However, a PHA with unobligated funds
from a grant shall disregard this
requirement for up to not more than 10
percent of the originally allocated funds
from that grant. The funds become
available to the PHA when HUD
executes the CF ACC Amendment. With
HUD approval, the PHA can accumulate
RHF grants for up to 5 years or until it
has adequate funds to undertake
replacement housing. The PHA shall
obligate 90 percent of the RHF grant
within 24 months from the date that the
PHA accumulates adequate funds,
except as provided in paragraph (c) of
this section.
(b) Items and costs. For funds to be
considered obligated, all items and costs
must meet the criteria for an obligation
in § 905.108.
(c) Extension to obligation
requirement. The PHA may request an
extension of the obligation deadline,
and HUD may grant an extension for a
period of up to 12 months, based on:
(1) The size of the PHA;
(2) The complexity of the CFP of the
PHA;
(3) Any limitation on the ability of the
PHA to obligate the amounts allocated
for the PHA from the Capital Fund in a
timely manner as a result of state or
local law; or
(4) Any other factors that HUD
determines to be relevant.
(d) HUD extension for other reasons.
HUD may extend the obligation
deadline for a PHA for such a period as
HUD determines to be necessary, if HUD
determines that the failure of the PHA
to obligate assistance in a timely manner
is attributable to:
(1) Litigation;
(2) Delay in obtaining approvals from
the Federal Government or a state or
local government that is not the fault of
the PHA;
(3) Compliance with environmental
assessment and abatement
requirements;
(4) Relocating residents;
(5) An event beyond the control of the
PHA; or
(6) Any other reason established by
HUD by Notice in the Federal Register.
(e) Failure to obligate. (1) For any
month during the fiscal year, HUD shall
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
withhold all new Capital Fund grants,
including RHF grants, from any PHA
that has unobligated funds in violation
of § 905.306(a). The penalty will be
imposed once the violations of
§ 905.306(a) are known. The PHA may
cure the noncompliance by:
(i) Requesting in writing that HUD
recapture the unobligated balance of the
grant; or
(ii) Continuing to obligate funds for
the grant in noncompliance until the
noncompliance is cured.
(2) After the PHA has cured the
noncompliance, HUD will release the
withheld Capital Fund grant(s) minus a
penalty of 1/12th of the grant for each
month of noncompliance.
(f) Expenditure. The PHA shall
expend all grant funds within 48
months after the date on which funds
become available, as described in
§ 905.306(a). The deadline to expend
funds may be extended only by the
period of time of a HUD-approved
extension of the obligation deadline. No
other extensions of the expenditure
deadline will be granted. All funds not
expended will be recaptured.
§ 905.308 Federal requirements applicable
to all capital fund activities.
(a) The PHA shall comply with the
requirements of 24 CFR part 5 (General
HUD Program Requirements; Waivers),
24 CFR part 85 (Administrative
Requirements for Grants and
Cooperative Agreements to State, Local
and Federally Recognized Indian Tribal
Governments), and this part.
(b) The PHA shall also comply with
the following program requirements.
(1) Nondiscrimination and equal
opportunity. The PHA shall comply
with all applicable nondiscrimination
and equal opportunity requirements,
including, but not limited to, the
Department’s generally applicable
nondiscrimination and equal
opportunity requirements at 24 CFR
5.105(a) and the Architectural Barriers
Act of 1968, 42 U.S.C. 4151 et seq., and
its implementing regulations at 24 CFR
parts 40 and 41. The PHA shall
affirmatively further fair housing in its
use of funds under this part, which
includes but is not limited to addressing
modernization and development in the
completion of requirements at 24 CFR
903.7(o).
(2) Environmental requirements. All
activities under this part are subject to
an environmental review by a
responsible entity under HUD’s
environmental regulations at 24 CFR
part 58 and must comply with the
requirements of the National
Environmental Policy Act of 1969
(NEPA) (42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.) and the
PO 00000
Frm 00015
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
6667
related laws and authorities listed at 24
CFR 58.5. HUD may make a finding in
accordance with 24 CFR 58.11 and may
perform the environmental review itself
under the provisions of 24 CFR part 50.
In those cases where HUD performs the
environmental review under 24 CFR
part 50, it will do so before approving
a proposed project, and will comply
with the requirements of NEPA and the
related requirements at 24 CFR 50.4.
(3) Wage rates. (i) Davis-Bacon wage
rates. For all work or contracts
exceeding $2,000 in connection with
development activities or modernization
activities (except for nonroutine
maintenance work, as defined in
§ 905.200(b)(5) of this part), all laborers
and mechanics employed on the
construction, alteration, or repair shall
be paid not less than the wages
prevailing in the locality, as determined
by the Secretary of Labor pursuant to
the Davis-Bacon Act (40 U.S.C. 3142).
(ii) HUD-determined wage rates. For
all operations work and contracts,
including routine and nonroutine
maintenance work (as defined in
§ 905.200(b)(5) of this part), all laborers
and mechanics employed shall be paid
not less than the wages prevailing in the
locality, as determined or adopted by
HUD pursuant to section 12(a) of the
1937 Act, 42 U.S.C. 1437j(a).
(iii) State wage rates. Preemption of
state prevailing wage rates as provided
at 24 CFR 965.101.
(iv) Volunteers. The prevailing wage
requirements of this section do not
apply to volunteers performing
development, modernization, or
nonroutine maintenance work under the
conditions set out in 24 CFR part 70.
(4) Technical wage rates. All
architects, technical engineers,
draftsmen, and technicians (other than
volunteers under the conditions set out
in 24 CFR part 70) employed in a
development or modernization project
shall be paid not less than the wages
prevailing in the locality, as determined
or adopted (subsequent to a
determination under applicable state or
local law) by HUD.
(5) Lead-based paint poisoning
prevention. The PHA shall comply with
the Lead-Based Paint Poisoning
Prevention Act (LPPPA) (42 U.S.C. 4821
et seq.), the Residential Lead-Based
Paint Hazard Reduction Act (42 U.S.C.
4851 et seq.), and the Lead Safe Housing
Rule and the Lead Disclosure Rule at 24
CFR part 35.
(6) Fire safety. A PHA shall comply
with the requirements of section 31 of
the Federal Fire Prevention and Control
Act of 1974 (15 U.S.C. 2227).
(7) Flood insurance and floodplain
requirements. The PHA will not engage
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
6668
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
in the acquisition, construction, or
improvement of a public housing
project located in an area that has been
identified by the Federal Emergency
Management Agency (FEMA) as having
special flood hazards, unless:
(i) The requirements of 24 CFR part
55, Floodplain Management, have been
met, including a determination by a
responsible entity under 24 CFR part 58
or by HUD under 24 CFR part 50 that
there is no practicable alternative to
locating in an area of special flood
hazards; and the minimization of
unavoidable adverse impacts.
(ii) Flood insurance on the building is
obtained in compliance with the Flood
Disaster Protection Act of 1973 (42
U.S.C. 4001 et seq.); and
(iii) The community in which the area
is situated is participating in the
National Flood Insurance Program in
accordance with 44 CFR parts 59
through 79, or less than one year has
passed since FEMA notification
regarding flood hazards.
(8) Coastal barriers. In accordance
with the Coastal Barriers Resources Act
(16 U.S.C. 3501 et seq.), no financial
assistance under this part may be made
available within the Coastal Barrier
Resources System.
(9) Displacement, relocation, and real
property acquisition. All acquisition or
rehabilitation activities carried out
under the Capital Fund, including
acquisition of any property for
development, shall comply with the
Uniform Relocation Assistance and Real
Property Acquisition Policies Act of
1970 (URA) (42 U.S.C. 4601–4655) and
with implementing regulations at 49
CFR part 24. Demolition or disposition
under section 9(d)(4) is covered by the
section 18 relocation provisions at 24
CFR 970.21.
(10) Procurement and contract
requirement. PHAs and their contractors
shall comply with Section 3 of the
Housing and Community Development
Act of 1968 (12 U.S.C. 1701u) and
HUD’s implementing rules at 24 CFR
part 135.
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
§ 905.310
Disbursements from HUD.
(a) The PHA shall initiate a fund
requisition from HUD only when funds
are due and payable, unless HUD
approves another payment schedule as
authorized by 24 CFR 85.21.
(b) The PHA shall maintain detailed
disbursement records to document
eligible expenditure (e.g., contracts or
other applicable documents), in a form
and manner prescribed by HUD.
§ 905.312
Design and construction.
The PHA shall meet the following
design and construction standards, as
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
applicable, for all development and
modernization.
(a) Physical structures shall be
designed, constructed, and equipped to
be consistent with the neighborhoods
they occupy; meet contemporary
standards of modest design, comfort,
and livability; promote security;
maximize energy conservation; and be
attractive and marketable to the people
they are intended to serve.
(b) All development projects shall be
designed and constructed in compliance
with:
(1) A national building code, such as
those developed by the International
Code Council or the National Fire
Protection Association; and the 2006
International Energy Conservation Code
(IECC), or ASHRAE 90.1–2004 for
multifamily high-rises (four stories or
higher), or a successor energy code or
standard that has been adopted by HUD
pursuant to 42 U.S.C. 12709 or other
relevant authority;
(2) Applicable state and local laws,
codes, ordinances, and regulations;
(3) Other federal requirements,
including fire protection and safety
standards implemented under section
31 of the Fire Administration
Authorization Act of 1992, 15 U.S.C.
2227 and HUD minimum property
standards (e.g., 24 CFR part 200,
subpart S);
(4) Accessibility Requirements as
required by Section 504 of the
Rehabilitation Act (29 U.S.C. 794) and
implementing regulations at 24 CFR part
8; Title II of the Americans with
Disabilities Act (42 U.S.C. 12101 et seq.)
and implementing regulations at 28 CFR
part 35; and, if applicable, the Fair
Housing Act (42 U.S.C. 3601–3619) and
implementing regulations at 24 CFR part
100; and
(5) High-rise elevator structure
specifications. A high-rise elevator
structure shall not be provided for
families with children regardless of
density, unless the PHA demonstrates
and HUD determines that there is no
practical alternative, where projectbased Section 8 assistance under 42
U.S.C. 1437f(o)(13) is provided through
a Housing Assistance Payment (HAP)
contract, in which case the assistance
may be provided to a high-rise elevator
building, including one occupied by
families with children, without review
and approval of the contract by the
Secretary.
(c) All modernization projects shall be
designed and constructed in compliance
with:
(1) The modernization standards as
prescribed by HUD;
(2) Accessibility requirements as
required by Section 504 of the
PO 00000
Frm 00016
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
Rehabilitation Act (29 U.S.C. 794) and
implementing regulations at 24 CFR part
8; Title II of the Americans with
Disabilities Act (42 U.S.C. 12101 et seq.)
and implementing regulations at 28 CFR
part 35; and, if applicable, the Fair
Housing Act (42 U.S.C. 3601–3619) and
implementing regulations at 24 CFR part
100; and
(3) Cost-effective energy conservation
measures, identified in the PHA’s most
recently updated energy audit,
conducted pursuant to 24 CFR part 965,
subpart C.
(d) PHAs shall use appliances that are
Energy Star products or Federal Energy
Management Program-designed
products, unless the PHA determines
that the purchase of these appliances is
not cost-effective.
§ 905.314
Cost and other limitations.
(a) Eligible administrative costs.
Where the physical or management
improvement costs will benefit
programs other than Public Housing,
such as the Housing Choice Voucher
program or local revitalization
programs, eligible administrative costs
are limited to the amount directly
attributable to the public housing
program.
(b) Maximum project cost. The
maximum project cost represents the
total amount of public housing capital
assistance used in connection with the
development of a public housing
project, and includes:
(1) Project costs that are subject to the
TDC limit (i.e., HCC and Community
Renewal Costs); and
(2) Project costs that are not subject to
the TDC limit (i.e., Additional Project
Costs). The total project cost to be
funded with public housing capital
assistance, as set forth in the proposal
and as approved by HUD, becomes the
maximum project cost stated in the CF
ACC Amendment. Upon completion of
the project, the actual project cost is
determined based upon the amount of
public housing capital assistance
expended for the project, and this
becomes the maximum project cost for
purposes of the CF ACC Amendment.
(c) TDC limit. (1) The Capital Fund
may not be used to pay for Housing
Construction Cost (HCC) and
Community Renewal Costs in excess of
the TDC limit, as determined under
paragraph (b)(2) of this section.
However, HOPE VI grantees will be
eligible to request a TDC exception for
public housing and HOPE VI funds
awarded in FFY 1996 and prior years.
However, PHAs may also request a TDC
exception for integrated utility
management, capital planning, and
other capital and management activities
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
that maximize energy conservation and
efficiency, including green construction
and retrofits, which include windows;
heating system replacements; wall
insulation; site-based generation;
advanced energy savings technologies,
including renewable energy generation;
and other such retrofits. HUD will apply
a cost-effectiveness test to ensure that
up-front expenditures due to the
exception would be justified by future
cost savings when deciding whether to
grant a TDC waiver under this section.
(2) Determination of TDC limit. HUD
will determine the TDC for a public
housing project as follows:
(i) Step 1: Unit construction cost
guideline. HUD will first determine the
applicable ‘‘construction cost guideline,’’
averaging the current construction costs
as listed in two nationally recognized
residential construction cost indices for
publicly bid construction of a good and
sound quality for specific bedroom sizes
and structure types. The two indices
HUD will use for this purpose are the
R.S. Means cost index for construction
of ‘‘average’’ quality and the Marshall &
Swift cost index for construction of
‘‘good’’ quality. HUD has the discretion
to change the cost indices to other such
indices that reflect comparable housing
construction quality through a notice
published in the Federal Register.
(ii) Step 2: Bedroom size and structure
types. The construction cost guideline is
then multiplied by the number of units
for each bedroom size and structure
type.
(iii) Step 3: Elevator and non-elevator
type structures. HUD will then multiply
the resulting amounts from step 2 by 1.6
for elevator type structures and by 1.75
for non-elevator type structures.
(iv) Step 4: TDC limit. The TDC limit
for a project is calculated by adding the
resulting amounts from step 3 for all the
public housing units in the project.
(3) Costs not subject to the TDC limit.
Additional Project Costs are not subject
to the TDC limit, which is described in
paragraph (c) of this section.
(4) Funds not subject to the TDC limit.
A PHA may use funding sources not
subject to the TDC limit (e.g.,
Community Development Block Grant
(CDBG) funds, low-income tax credits,
private donations, private financing,
etc.) to cover project costs that exceed
the TDC limit or the HCC limit
described in paragraph (c) of this
section. Such funds, however, may not
be used for items that would result in
substantially increased operating,
maintenance, or replacement costs, and
must meet the requirements of section
102 of the Department of Housing and
Urban Development Reform Act of 1989
(Pub. L. 101–235, approved December
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
15, 1989) (42 U.S.C. 3545). These funds
must be included in the project
development cost budget.
(d) Housing Construction Costs (HCC).
(1) General. A PHA may not use
Capital Funds to pay for HCC in excess
of the amount determined under
paragraph (c)(2) of this section.
(2) Determination of HCC limit. HUD
will determine the HCC limit as listed
in at least two nationally recognized
residential construction cost indices for
publicly bid construction of a good and
sound quality for specific bedroom sizes
and structure types. The two indices
HUD will use for this purpose are the
R.S. Means cost index for construction
of ‘‘average’’ quality and the Marshal &
Swift cost index for construction of
‘‘good’’ quality. HUD has the discretion
to change the cost indices to other such
indices that reflect comparable housing
construction quality through a notice
published in the Federal Register. The
resulting construction cost guideline is
then multiplied by the number of public
housing units in the project based upon
bedroom size and structure type. The
HCC limit for a project is calculated by
adding the resulting amounts for all
public housing units in the project.
(3) The HCC limit is not applicable to
the acquisition of existing housing,
whether or not such housing will be
rehabilitated. The TDC limit is
applicable to such acquisition.
(e) Community Renewal Costs. Capital
Funds may be used to pay for
Community Renewal Costs in an
amount equivalent to the difference
between the HCC paid for with public
housing capital assistance and the TDC
limit.
(f) Rehabilitation of existing public
housing projects. The HCC limit is not
applicable to the rehabilitation of
existing Public Housing Projects. The
TDC limit for modernization of existing
public housing is 90 percent of the TDC
limit as determined under § 905.314(c).
This limitation does not apply to the
rehabilitation of any property acquired
pursuant to § 905.600.
(g) Modernization cost limits. If the
modernization costs are more than 90
percent of the TDC, then the project
shall not be modernized. Capital Funds
shall not be expended to modernize an
existing public housing development
that fails to meet the HUD definition of
reasonable cost found in § 905.108,
except for:
(1) Emergency work;
(2) Essential maintenance necessary to
keep a public housing project habitable
until the demolition or disposition
application is approved; or
PO 00000
Frm 00017
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
6669
(3) The costs of maintaining the safety
and security of a site that is undergoing
demolition.
(h) Administrative cost limits and
Capital Fund Program Fee.
(1) Administrative cost limits (for
non-asset management PHAs).
(i) Modernization. The PHA shall not
budget or expend more than 10 percent
of its annual Capital Fund grant on
administrative costs, in accordance with
its CFP 5-Year Action Plan. The 10
percent limit excludes any costs related
to lead-based paint or asbestos testing,
in-house Architectural and Engineering
work, or other special administrative
costs required by state or local law.
(ii) Development. For development
work with Capital Fund and RHF grants,
the administrative cost limit is 3 percent
of the total project budget, or, with
HUD’s approval, up to 6 percent of the
total project budget.
(2) Capital Fund Program Fee (for
asset management PHAs). For a PHA
that is under asset management, the
Capital Fund Program Fee and
administrative costs limits are the same.
For the Capital Fund Program Fee, a
PHA may charge a management fee of
up to 10 percent of the annual CFP
formula grant(s) amount, excluding
emergency and disaster grants and also
excluding any costs related to leadbased paint or asbestos testing, in-house
Architectural and Engineering work, or
other special administrative costs
required by state or local law. The
Capital Fund Program Fee for
development work funded with Capital
Fund and RHF grants is 3 percent of the
total project budget, or, with HUD
approval, up to 6 percent of the total
project budget.
(i) Management improvement cost
limits. A PHA shall not budget nor use
more than 20 percent of its annual
Capital Fund grant for management
improvement costs identified in its CFP
5-Year Action Plan through FY 2010. In
FFY 2011, a PHA shall not budget nor
use more than 16 percent for
management improvements for grants
awarded in that fiscal year; for FFY
2012, a PHA shall not budget nor use
more than 13 percent for grants awarded
in that year; and for FFY 2013 and
thereafter, a PHA shall not budget nor
use more than 10 percent for grants
awarded. Management improvements
are an eligible expense for PHAs
participating in Asset Management.
(j) Types of labor. A PHA may use
force account labor for development and
modernization activities if included in a
HUD-approved CFP 5-Year Action Plan.
HUD approval to use force account labor
is not required when the PHA is
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
6670
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
designated as a High Performer under
PHAS.
(k) RMC activities. When the entire
development, financing, or
modernization activity, including the
planning and architectural design, is
administered by an RMC, the PHA shall
not retain any portion of the Capital
Funds for any administrative or other
reason unless the PHA and the RMC
provide otherwise by contract.
(l) Capital Funds for operating costs.
A PHA may use Capital Funds for
operating costs only if it is included in
the HUD-approved CFP 5-Year Action
Plan and limited as described in
paragraphs (l)(1) and (2) of this section.
Capital Funds identified in the CFP 5Year Action Plan to be transferred to
operations are obligated once the funds
have been budgeted and drawn down by
the PHA. Once such transfer of funds
occurs, the PHA must follow the
requirements of 24 CFR part 990 with
respect to those funds.
(1) Large PHAs. A PHA with 250 or
more units may use no more than 20
percent of its annual Capital Fund grant
for activities that are eligible under the
Operating Fund at 24 CFR part 990.
(2) Small PHAs. A PHA with less than
250 units, that is not designated as
troubled under PHAS, may use up to
100 percent of its annual Capital Fund
grant for activities that are eligible
under the Operating Fund at 24 CFR
part 990, except that the PHA must have
determined that there are no debt
service payments, significant Capital
Fund needs, or emergency needs that
must be met prior to transferring 100
percent of its funds to operating
expenses.
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
§ 905.316 Procurement and contract
requirements.
(a) General. PHAs shall comply with
24 CFR 85.36, and HUD implementing
instructions, for all capital activities
including modernization and
development except as provided in
paragraph (c) in this section.
(b) Contracts. The PHA shall use all
contract forms prescribed by HUD. If a
form is not prescribed, the PHA may use
any Office of Management and Budget
(OMB) approved form that contains all
applicable federal requirements and
contract clauses.
(c) Mixed-finance development
projects. Mixed-finance development
partners may be selected in accordance
with the 24 CFR 905.604. Contracts and
other agreements with mixed-finance
development partners must specify that
they comply with the requirements of
§§ 905.602 and 905.604.
(d) Assurances of completion.
Notwithstanding 24 CFR 85.36(h), for
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
each construction contract over
$100,000, the contractor shall furnish
the PHA with the following:
(1) A bid guarantee from each bidder
equivalent to 5 percent of the bid price;
and
(2) One of the following:
(i) A performance bond and payment
bond for 100 percent of the contract
price;
(ii) A performance bond and a
payment bond, each for 50 percent or
more of the contract price;
(iii) A 20 percent cash escrow;
(iv) A 25 percent irrevocable letter of
credit with terms acceptable to HUD, or
(v) Any other payment method
acceptable to HUD.
(e) Procurement of recovered
materials. PHAs that are state agencies
and agencies of a political subdivision
of a state that are using assistance under
this part for procurement, and any
person contracting with such PHAs with
respect to work performed under an
assisted contract, must comply with the
requirements of section 6002 of the
Solid Waste Disposal Act, as amended
by the Resource Conservation and
Recovery Act. In accordance with
section 6002, these agencies and
persons must procure items designated
in guidelines of the Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) at 40 CFR part
247 that contain the highest percentage
of recovered material practicable,
consistent with maintaining a
satisfactory level of competition, where
the purchase price of the item exceeds
$10,000 or the value of the quantity
acquired in preceding fiscal year
exceeded $10,000; must procure solid
waste management services in a manner
that maximizes energy and resource
recovery; and must have established an
affirmative procurement program for
procurement of recovered materials
identified in the EPA guidelines.
§ 905.318
Title and deed.
The PHA shall obtain a title insurance
policy that guarantees the title is good
and marketable before taking title to any
and all sites and properties acquired
with Capital Funds. The PHA shall
record within 90 days the deed and
Declaration of Trust in the form and in
the manner prescribed by HUD. The
PHA shall at all times maintain a
recorded Declaration of Trust in the
form and manner prescribed by HUD on
all public housing projects covering the
term required by this part.
§ 905.320 Contract administration and
acceptance of work.
(a) Contract administration. The PHA
is responsible, in accordance with 24
CFR 85.36, for all contractual and
PO 00000
Frm 00018
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
administrative issues arising out of their
procurements. The PHA shall maintain
full and complete records on the history
of each procurement transaction.
(b) Inspection and acceptance. The
PHA or owner, in the case of mixed
finance, shall carry out inspections of
work in progress and goods delivered,
as necessary, to ensure compliance with
existing contracts. If, upon inspection,
the PHA determines that the work and/
or goods are complete, satisfactory and,
as applicable, otherwise undamaged,
except for any work that is appropriate
for delayed completion, the PHA shall
accept the work. The PHA shall
determine any hold-back for items of
delayed completion and the amount due
and payable for the work that has been
accepted, including any conditions
precedent to payment that are stated in
the construction contract or contract of
sale. The contractor shall be paid for
items only after the PHA inspects and
accepts that work.
(c) Guarantees and warranties. The
PHA or owner, in the case of mixed
finance, shall specify the guaranty
period and amounts to be withheld, as
applicable, and shall provide that all
contractor, manufacturer, and supplier
warranties required by the construction
and modernization documents shall be
assigned to the PHA. The PHA shall
inspect each dwelling unit and the
overall project approximately 3 months
after the beginning of the project
guaranty period, 3 months before its
expiration, and at other times as may be
necessary to exercise its rights before
expiration of any warranties. The PHA
shall require repair or replacement of all
defective items prior to the expiration of
the guaranty or warranty periods.
(d) Notification of completion. The
PHA shall require that all contractors
and developers notify the PHA in
writing when the contract work,
including any approved off-site work,
will be completed and ready for
inspection.
§ 905.322
Fiscal closeout.
(a) General. Each Capital Fund grant
and/or development project is subject to
fiscal closeout. Fiscal closeout includes
the submission of a cost certificate; an
audit, if applicable; a final Performance
and Evaluation Report; and HUD
approval of the cost certificate.
(b) Submission of cost certificate.
(1) When an approved development or
modernization activity is completed or
when HUD terminates the activity, the
PHA must submit to HUD the:
(i) Actual Development Cost
Certificate (ADCC) within 12 months.
For purposes of the CF ACC, costs
incurred between the completion of the
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
development and DOFA becomes the
actual development cost; and
(ii) Actual Modernization Cost
Certificate (AMCC) for each grant, no
later than 12 months after the
expenditure deadline but no earlier than
the obligation end date. A PHA with
under 250 units with an approved CFP
5-Year Action Plan for use of 100
percent of the Capital Fund Grant in
Operations may submit the cost
certificate any time after the funds have
been budgeted to operations and
withdrawn, as described in § 905.314(l).
(2) If the PHA does not submit the
cost certificate and the final CFP Annual
Statement/Performance and Evaluation
Report within the period prescribed in
this section, HUD may impose
restrictions on open Capital Fund
grants, e.g., establish review thresholds,
set the grant to ‘‘auto review’’ (HUD
automatically reviews it on a periodic
basis), or suspend grants, until the cost
certificate for the affected grant is
submitted. These restrictions may be
imposed by HUD after notification of
the PHA.
(c) Audit. The cost certificate is a
financial statement subject to audit
pursuant to 24 CFR 85.26. After
submission of the cost certificate to
HUD, the PHA shall provide the cost
certificate to its independent public
auditor (IPA) as part of its annual audit.
After audit, the PHA will notify HUD of
the grants included in the audit, any
exceptions noted by the PHA auditor,
and the schedule to complete corrective
actions recommended by the auditor.
(d) Review and approval. For PHAs
exempt from the audit requirements,
HUD will review and approve the cost
certificate based on available
information regarding the Capital Fund
grant. For PHAs subject to an audit,
HUD will review the information from
the annual audit provided by the PHA
and approve the certificate after all
exceptions, if any, have been resolved.
(e) Recapture. All Capital Funds in
excess of the actual cost incurred for the
grant are subject to recapture. Any funds
awarded to the PHA that are returned or
any funds taken back from the PHA in
a fiscal year after the grant was awarded
are subject to recapture.
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
§ 905.324
Data reporting requirements.
The PHA shall provide, at minimum,
the following data reports, at a time and
in a form prescribed by HUD:
(a) The Performance and Evaluation
Report as described in § 905.300(b)(8);
(b) Updates on the PHA’s building
and unit data as required by HUD;
(c) Reports of obligation and
expenditure; and
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
(d) Any other information required for
participation in the Capital Fund
Program.
§ 905.326
Records.
(a) The PHA will maintain full and
complete records of the history of each
Capital Fund grant, including, but not
limited to, CFP 5-Year Action Plans,
procurement, contracts, obligations, and
expenditures.
(b) The PHA shall retain all
documents related to the activities for
which the Capital Fund grant was
received for 5 years after HUD approves
either the actual development or
modernization cost certificate, unless a
longer period is required by applicable
law.
(c) HUD and its duly authorized
representatives shall have full and free
access to all PHA offices, facilities,
books, documents, and records,
including the right to audit and make
copies.
Subpart D—Capital Fund Formula
§ 905.400
formula).
Capital Fund formula (CF
(a) General. This section describes the
formula for allocating Capital Funds to
PHAs.
(b) Formula allocation based on
relative needs. HUD shall allocate
Capital Funds to the PHAs in
accordance with the CF formula. The CF
formula measures the existing
modernization needs and accrual needs
of PHAs.
(c) Allocation for existing
modernization needs under the CF
formula. HUD shall allocate one-half of
the available Capital Fund amount
based on the relative existing
modernization needs of PHAs,
determined in accordance with
paragraph (d) of this section.
(d) PHAs with 250 or more units in
FFY 1999, except the New York City and
Chicago Housing Authorities. The
estimates of the existing modernization
needs for these PHAs shall be based on
the following:
(1) Objective measurable data
concerning the following PHA,
community, and project characteristics
applied to each project:
(i) The average number of bedrooms
in the units in a project (Equation coefficient: 4604.7);
(ii) The total number of units in a
project (Equation co-efficient: 10.17);
(iii) The proportion of units in a
project in buildings completed in 1978
or earlier. In the case of acquired
projects, HUD will use the DOFA unless
the PHA provides HUD with the actual
date of construction completion. When
PO 00000
Frm 00019
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
6671
the PHA provides the actual date of
construction completion, HUD will use
that date (or, for scattered sites, the
average dates of construction of all the
buildings), subject to a 50-year cap.
(Equation co-efficient: 4965.4);
(iv) The cost index of rehabilitating
property in the area (Equation coefficient: ¥10608);
(v) The extent to which the units of
a project were in a nonmetropolitan area
as defined by the United States Bureau
of the Census (Census Bureau) during
FFY 1996 (Equation co-efficient:
2703.9);
(vi) The PHA is located in the
Southern census region, as defined by
the Census Bureau (Equation coefficient: ¥269.4);
(vii) The PHA is located in the
Western census region, as defined by
the Census Bureau (Equation coefficient: ¥1709.5);
(viii) The PHA is located in the
Midwest census region as defined by the
Census Bureau (Equation co-efficient:
246.2); and
(2) An equation constant of 13851.
(i) Newly constructed units. Units
with a DOFA date of October 1, 1991,
or after, shall be considered to have a
zero existing modernization need.
(ii) Acquired projects. Projects
acquired by a PHA with a DOFA date
of October 1, 1991, or after, shall be
considered to have a zero existing
modernization need.
(3) For New York City and Chicago
Housing Authorities, based on a large
sample of direct inspections. Prior to the
cost calibration in paragraph (d)(5) of
this section, the number used for the
existing modernization need of family
projects shall be $16,680 in New York
and $24,286 in Chicago, and the number
for elderly projects shall be $14,622 in
New York and $16,912 in Chicago.
(i) Newly constructed units. Units
with a DOFA date of October 1, 1991,
or after, shall be considered to have a
zero existing modernization need.
(ii) Acquired projects. Projects
acquired by a PHA with a DOFA date
of October 1, 1991, or after, shall be
considered to have a zero existing
modernization need.
(4) PHAs with fewer than 250 units in
FFY 1999. The estimates of the existing
modernization need shall be based on
the following:
(i) Objective measurable data
concerning the PHA, community, and
project characteristics applied to each
project:
(A) The average number of bedrooms
in the units in a project. (Equation
coefficient: 1427.1);
(B) The total number of units in a
project. (Equation coefficient: 24.3);
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
6672
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
(C) The proportion of units in a
project in buildings completed in 1978
or earlier. In the case of acquired
projects, HUD shall use the DOFA date
unless the PHA provides HUD with the
actual date of construction completion,
in which case HUD shall use the actual
date of construction completion (or, for
scattered sites, the average dates of
construction of all the buildings),
subject to a 50-year cap. (Equation
coefficient: ¥1389.7);
(D) The cost index of rehabilitating
property in the area, as of FFY 1999.
(Equation coefficient: ¥20163);
(E) The extent to which the units of
a project were in a nonmetropolitan area
as defined by the Census Bureau during
FFY 1996. (Equation coefficient:
6157.7);
(F) The PHA is located in the
Southern census region, as defined by
the Census Bureau. (Equation
coefficient: 4379.2);
(G) The PHA is located in the Western
census region, as defined by the Census
Bureau. (Equation coefficient: 3747.7);
(H) The PHA is located in the
Midwest census region as defined by the
Census Bureau. (Equation coefficient:
¥2073.5); and
(ii) An equation constant of 24762.
(A) Newly constructed units. Units
with a DOFA date of October 1, 1991,
or after, shall be considered to have a
zero existing modernization need.
(B) Acquired projects. Projects
acquired by a PHA with a DOFA date
of October 1, 1991, or after, shall be
considered by HUD to have a zero
existing modernization need.
(5) Calibration of existing
modernization need for cost index of
rehabilitating property in the area. The
estimated existing modernization need
determined under paragraphs (d)(1),
(d)(2), or (d)(3) of this section shall be
adjusted by the values of the cost index
of rehabilitating property in the area.
(6) Freezing of the determination of
existing modernization need. FFY 2008
is the last fiscal year that HUD will
calculate the existing modernization
need. The existing modernization need
will be frozen for all developments at
the calculation as of FFY 2008 and will
be adjusted for changes in the inventory
and paragraph (d)(4) of this section.
(e) Allocation for accrual needs under
the CF formula. HUD shall allocate the
other half of the remaining Capital Fund
amount based on the relative accrual
needs of PHAs, determined in
accordance with this paragraph of this
section.
(1) PHAs with 250 or more units,
except the New York City and Chicago
Housing Authorities. The estimates of
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
the accrual need shall be based on the
following:
(i) Objective measurable data
concerning the following PHA,
community, and project characteristics
applied to each project:
(A) The average number of bedrooms
in the units in a project. (Equation
coefficient: 324.0);
(B) The extent to which the buildings
in a project average fewer than 5 units.
(Equation coefficient: 93.3);
(C) The age of a project, as determined
by the DOFA date. In the case of
acquired projects, HUD shall use the
DOFA date unless the PHA provides
HUD with the actual date of
construction completion, in which case
HUD shall use the actual date of
construction (or, for scattered sites, the
average dates of construction of all the
buildings), subject to a 50-year cap.
(Equation coefficient: ¥7.8);
(D) Whether the development is a
family project. (Equation coefficient:
184.5);
(E) The cost index of rehabilitating
property in the area. (Equation
coefficient: ¥252.8);
(F) The extent to which the units of
a project were in a nonmetropolitan area
as defined by the Census Bureau during
FFY 1996. (Equation coefficient:
¥121.3);
(G) PHA size of 6,600 or more units
in FFY 1999. (Equation coefficient:
¥150.7);
(H) The PHA is located in the
Southern census region, as defined by
the Census Bureau. (Equation
coefficient: 28.4);
(I) The PHA is located in the Western
census region, as defined by the Census
Bureau. (Equation coefficient: ¥116.9);
(J) The PHA is located in the Midwest
census region as defined by the Census
Bureau. (Equation coefficient: 60.7); and
(ii) An equation constant of 1371.9.
(2) For the New York City and
Chicago Housing Authorities, based on
a large sample of direct inspections.
Prior to the cost calibration in paragraph
(e)(4) of this section the number used for
the accrual need of family developments
is $1,395 in New York, and $1,251 in
Chicago, and the number for elderly
developments is $734 in New York and
$864 in Chicago.
(3) PHAs with fewer than 250 units.
The estimates of the accrual need shall
be based on the following:
(i) Objective measurable data
concerning the following PHA,
community, and project characteristics
applied to each project:
(A) The average number of bedrooms
in the units in a project. (Equation
coefficient: 325.5);
PO 00000
Frm 00020
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
(B) The extent to which the buildings
in a project average fewer than 5 units.
(Equation coefficient: 179.8);
(C) The age of a project, as determined
by the DOFA date. In the case of
acquired projects, HUD shall use the
DOFA date unless the PHA provides
HUD with the actual date of
construction completion. When
provided with the actual date of
construction completion, HUD shall use
this date (or, for scattered sites, the
average dates of construction of all the
buildings), subject to a 50-year cap.
(Equation coefficient: ¥9.0);
(D) Whether the project is a family
development. (Equation coefficient:
59.3);
(E) The cost index of rehabilitating
property in the area. (Equation
coefficient: ¥1570.5);
(F) The extent to which the units of
a project were in a nonmetropolitan area
as defined by the Census Bureau during
FFY 1996. (Equation coefficient:
¥122.9);
(G) The PHA is located in the
Southern census region, as defined by
the Census Bureau. (Equation
coefficient: ¥564.0);
(H) The PHA is located in the Western
census region, as defined by the Census
Bureau. (Equation coefficient: ¥29.6);
(I) The PHA is located in the Midwest
census region as defined by the Census
Bureau. (Equation coefficient: ¥418.3);
and
(ii) An equation constant of 3193.6.
(4) Calibration of accrual need for the
cost index of rehabilitating property in
the area. The estimated accrual need
determined under either paragraph
(e)(2) or (e)(3) of this section shall be
adjusted by the values of the cost index
of rehabilitation.
(f) Calculation of number of units.
(1) General. For purposes of
determining the number of a PHA’s
public housing units and the relative
modernization needs of PHAs:
(i) HUD shall count as one unit:
(A) Each public housing and section
23 bond-financed CF unit, except that
each existing unit under the Turnkey III
program shall count as one-fourth of a
unit. Units receiving operating subsidy
only shall not be counted.
(B) Each existing unit under the
Mutual Help program.
(ii) HUD shall add to the overall unit
count any units that the PHA adds to its
inventory when the units are under CF
ACC amendment and have reached
DOFA by the date that HUD establishes
for the FFY in which the CF formula is
being run (hereafter called the
‘‘reporting date’’). New CF units and
reaching DOFA after the reporting date
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
shall be counted for CF formula
purposes in the following FFY.
(2) Replacement units. Replacement
units newly constructed on or after
October 1, 1998, that replace units in a
project funded in FFY 1999 by the
Comprehensive Grant formula system or
the Comprehensive Improvement
Assistance Program (CIAP) formula
system shall be given a new CF ACC
number as a separate project and shall
be treated as a newly constructed
development as outlined in § 905.600.
(3) Reconfiguration of units.
Reconfiguration of units may cause the
need to be calculated by the new
configuration based on the formula
characteristics in the building and unit’s
module of PIC (refer to the formula
sections here). The unit counts will be
determined by the CF units existing
after the reconfiguration.
(4) Reduction of units. For a project
losing units as a result of demolition
and disposition, the number of units on
which the CF formula is based shall be
the number of units reported as eligible
for Capital Funds as of the reporting
date. Units are eligible for funding until
they are removed due to demolition and
disposition in accordance with a
schedule approved by HUD.
(g) Computation of formula shares
under the CF formula. (1) Total
estimated existing modernization need.
The total estimated existing
modernization need of a PHA under the
CF formula is the result of multiplying
for each project the PHA’s total number
of formula units by its estimated
existing modernization need per unit, as
determined by paragraph (d) of this
section, and calculating the sum of these
estimated project needs.
(2) Total accrual need. The total
accrual need of a PHA under the CF
formula is the result of multiplying for
each project the PHA’s total number of
formula units by its estimated accrual
need per unit, as determined by
paragraph (e) of this section, and
calculating the sum of these estimated
accrual needs.
(3) PHA’s formula share of existing
modernization need. A PHA’s formula
share of existing modernization need
under the CF formula is the PHA’s total
estimated existing modernization need
divided by the total existing
modernization need of all PHAs.
(4) PHA’s formula share of accrual
need. A PHA’s formula share of accrual
need under the CF formula is the PHA’s
total estimated accrual need divided by
the total existing accrual need of all
PHAs.
(5) PHA’s formula share of capital
need. A PHA’s formula share of capital
need under the CF formula is the
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
average of the PHA’s share of existing
modernization need and its share of
accrual need (by which method each
share is weighted 50 percent).
(h) CF formula capping. (1) For units
that are eligible for funding under the
CF formula (including replacement
housing units discussed below), a PHA’s
CF formula share shall be its share of
capital need, as determined under the
CF formula, subject to the condition that
no PHA’s CF formula share for units
funded under CF formula can be less
than 94 percent of its formula share had
the FFY 1999 formula system been
applied to these CF formula eligible
units. The FFY 1999 formula system is
based upon the FFY 1999
Comprehensive Grant formula system
for PHAs with 250 or more units in FFY
1999 and upon the FFY 1999
Comprehensive Improvement
Assistance Program (CIAP) formula
system for PHAs with fewer than 250
units in FFY 1999.
(2) For a Moving to Work (MTW) PHA
whose MTW agreement provides that its
CF formula share is to be calculated in
accordance with the previously existing
formula, the PHA’s CF formula share,
during the term of the MTW agreement,
may be approximately the formula share
that the PHA would have received had
the FFY 1999 formula funding system
been applied to the CF formula eligible
units.
(i) RHF to reflect formula need for
developments with demolition, or
disposition occurring on or after
October 1, 1998.
(1) RHF generally. PHAs that have a
reduction in the number of units
attributable to demolition or disposition
of units during the period (reflected in
data maintained by HUD) that lowers
the formula unit count for the CFF
calculation qualify for application of a
replacement housing factor, subject to
satisfaction of criteria stated in
paragraph (i)(5) of this section
(2) When applied. The RHF will be
added, where applicable:
(i) For the first 5 years after the
reduction of units described in
paragraph (i)(1) of this section; and
(ii) For an additional 5 years if the
planning, leveraging, obligation, and
expenditure requirements are met. As a
prior condition of a PHA’s receipt of
additional funds for replacement
housing provided for the second 5-year
period or any portion thereof, a PHA
must obtain a firm commitment of
substantial additional funds other than
public housing funds for replacement
housing, as determined by HUD.
(3) Computation of RHF. The RHF
consists of the difference between the
CFF share without the CFF share
PO 00000
Frm 00021
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
6673
reduction of units attributable to
demolition or disposition, and the CFF
share that resulted after the reduction of
units attributable to demolition or
disposition.
(4) Replacement housing funding in
FFY 1998 and 1999. Units that received
replacement housing funding in FFY
1998 will be treated as if they had
received 2 years of replacement housing
funding by FFY 2000. Units that
received replacement housing funding
in FFY 1999 will be treated as if they
had received one year of replacement
housing funding as of FFY 2000.
(5) PHA Eligibility for the RHF. A
PHA is eligible for this factor only if the
PHA satisfies the following criteria:
(i) The PHA requests the application
of the replacement housing factor;
(ii) The PHA will use the funding in
question only for replacement housing;
(iii) The PHA will use the restored
funding that results from the use of the
replacement factor to provide
replacement housing in accordance with
the PHA’s 5-Year Plan, as approved by
HUD under part 903 of this chapter;
(iv) The PHA has not received
funding for public housing units that
will replace the lost units under Public
Housing Development, and Major
Reconstruction of Obsolete Public
Housing, HOPE VI, or programs that
otherwise provide for replacement with
public housing units;
(v) The PHA, if designated troubled
by HUD, and not already under the
direction of HUD or an appointed
receiver, in accordance with part 902 of
this chapter, uses an Alternative
Management Entity as defined in part
902 of this chapter, for development of
replacement housing and complies with
any applicable provisions of its
Memorandum of Agreement executed
with HUD under that part; and
(vi) The PHA undertakes any
development of replacement housing in
accordance with applicable HUD
requirements and regulations.
(6) Failure to provide replacement
housing in a timely fashion.
(i) A PHA will be subject to the
actions described in paragraph (i)(7)(ii)
of this section if the PHA does not:
(A) Use the restored funding that
results from the use of the RHF to
provide replacement housing in a timely
fashion as provided in paragraph (i)(7)(i)
of this section and in accordance with
applicable HUD requirements and
regulations, and
(B) Make reasonable progress on such
use of the funding, in accordance with
applicable HUD requirements and
regulations.
(ii) If a PHA fails to act as described
in paragraph (i)(6)(i) of this section,
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
6674
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
HUD will require appropriate corrective
action under these regulations, may
recapture and reallocate the funds, or
may take other appropriate action.
(7) Requirement to obligate and
expend RHF funds within specified
period.
(i) In addition to the requirements
otherwise applicable to obligation and
expenditure of funds, PHAs are required
to obligate assistance received as a
result of the RHF within:
(A) 24 months from the date that
funds become available to the PHA; or
(B) With specific HUD approval, 24
months from the date that the PHA
accumulates adequate funds to
undertake replacement housing.
(ii) To the extent the PHA has not
obligated any funds provided as a result
of the RHF within the time frames
required by this paragraph, or has not
expended such funds within a
reasonable time, HUD shall reduce the
amount of funds to be provided to the
PHA as a result of the application of the
second 5 years of the replacement
housing factor.
(j) RHF to reflect formula need for
developments with demolition,
disposition, or sale for homeownership
occurring on or after October 1, 2009.
(1) RHF generally. In FFY 2011 and
thereafter, PHAs that have a reduction
in the number of units occurring in FFY
2010 and attributable to demolition,
disposition, or sale of homeownership
under section 32 of the U.S. Housing
Act of 1937, 42 U.S.C. 1437z–4 (section
32), or former section 5(h) of the U.S.
Housing Act of 1937 (42 U.S.C. 1437c(h)
(1994) (former section 5(h)), HOPE I, or
as otherwise approved by HUD, but
excluding homeownership under
Turnkey III, are automatically eligible to
receive RHF grants for a 5-year period,
subject to the criteria stated in
paragraph (j)(4) of this section. The
funding reductions attributable to
homeownership apply in instances
where the units proposed for
homeownership under section 32,
former section 5(h), HOPE I, or as
otherwise approved by HUD have been
in the public housing inventory for a
minimum of 5 years.
(2) When applied. The RHF will be
added, where applicable, for 5 years
after the reduction of units described in
paragraph (j)(1) of this section.
(3) Computation of RHF. The RHF
consists of the difference between the
CFF share without the CFF share
reduction of units attributable to
demolition, disposition, or sale for
homeownership under section 32,
former section 5(h), HOPE I or as
otherwise approved by HUD and the
CFF share that resulted after the
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
reduction of units attributable to
demolition, disposition, or sale for
homeownership under section 32,
former section 5(h), HOPE I, or as
otherwise approved by HUD.
(4) PHA eligibility for the RHF. A PHA
is eligible for this factor only if the PHA
satisfies the following criteria:
(i) The PHA will automatically
receive the RHF for reduction of units
in accordance with (j)(1), unless the
PHA rejects the RHF funding for that
fiscal year in writing;
(ii) The PHA will use the funding in
question for replacement housing, i.e.,
development of public housing rental
and/or homeownership units;
(iii) The PHA will use the restored
funding that results from the use of the
replacement factor to provide
replacement housing in accordance with
the PHA’s CFP 5-Year Action Plan.
(iv) The PHA has not received
funding for public housing units that
will replace the lost units under Public
Housing Development, and Major
Reconstruction of Obsolete Public
Housing, HOPE VI, or programs that
otherwise provide for replacement with
public housing units;
(v) The PHA, if designated troubled
by HUD, and not already under the
direction of HUD or an appointed
receiver, in accordance with part 902 of
this chapter, uses an Alternative
Management Entity, as defined in part
902 of this chapter, for development of
replacement housing and complies with
any applicable provisions of its
Memorandum of Agreement executed
with HUD under that part; and
(vi) The PHA undertakes any
development of replacement housing in
accordance with applicable HUD
requirements and regulations.
(5) Failure to provide replacement
housing in a timely fashion.
(i) A PHA will be subject to the
actions described in paragraph (j)(6)(ii)
of this section if the PHA does not:
(A) Use the restored funding that
results from the use of the RHF to
provide replacement housing in a timely
fashion as provided in paragraph (j)(6)(i)
of this section and in accordance with
applicable HUD requirements and
regulations, and
(B) Make reasonable progress on such
use of the funding, in accordance with
applicable HUD requirements and
regulations.
(ii) If a PHA fails to act as described
in paragraph (j)(5)(i) of this section,
HUD will require appropriate corrective
action under these regulations, may
recapture and reallocate the funds, or
may take other appropriate action.
PO 00000
Frm 00022
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
(6) Requirement to obligate and
expend RHF funds within specified
period.
(i) In addition to the requirements
otherwise applicable to obligation and
expenditure of funds, PHAs are required
to obligate funds received as a result of
the RHF within:
(A) 24 months from the date that
funds become available to the PHA; or
(B) With specific HUD approval, 24
months from the date that the PHA
accumulates adequate funds to
undertake replacement housing.
(ii) To the extent the PHA has not
obligated any funds provided as a result
of the RHF within the time frames
required by this paragraph, or expended
such funds within a reasonable time
frame, HUD shall reduce the amount of
funds to be provided to the PHA.
(k) Performance reward factor.
(1) High performer. A PHA that is
designated a high performer under the
PHA’s most recent final PHAS score
may receive a performance bonus that
is:
(i) 3 percent above its base formula
amount in the first 5 years these awards
are given (for any year in this 5-year
period in which the performance reward
is earned); or
(ii) 5 percent above its base formula
amount in future years (for any year in
which the performance reward is
earned);
(2) Condition. The performance bonus
is subject only to the condition that no
PHA will lose more than 5 percent of its
base formula amount as a result of the
redistribution of funding from non-high
performers to high performers.
(3) Redistribution. The total amount of
Capital Funds that HUD has recaptured
or not allocated to PHAs as a sanction
for violation of expenditure and
obligation requirements shall be
allocated to the PHAs that are
designated high performers under
PHAS.
Subpart E—Use of Capital Funds for
Financing [Reserved]
Subpart F—Development
Requirements
§ 905.600
General.
(a) Applicability. This subpart F
applies to the development of public
housing units to be included under an
ACC and receive Capital and/or
Operating Funds. PHAs must comply
with all of the requirements in this part,
as applicable. Pursuant to § 905.106,
when a PHA or owner/management
entities and its partners submit and
execute a development proposal and, if
applicable, a site acquisition proposal,
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
and submit an executed ACC
Amendment covering those same units,
it is deemed to have certified by those
executed submissions its past, current,
and future compliance with this
subpart. Noncompliance with any
provision of this part or other applicable
statutes or regulations, or the ACC,
Amendment, and any Amendment
thereto may subject the PHA and/or its
partners to sanctions contained in
§ 905.804.
(b) Description. A PHA may develop
public housing through the construction
of new units or the acquisition of
existing units that may or may not
require rehabilitation prior to
occupancy. As noted in paragraph (c) of
this section, a PHA may use a variety of
funding sources to develop public
housing. When developing new public
housing with Capital Funds, pursuant to
24 CFR 905.304, the term of the ACC
Amendment will be 40 years. However,
a PHA may develop a mixed-financed
project with no public housing funds
used for construction of the units and
receive only Operating Fund assistance
for an ACC term, as determined by HUD
pursuant to section 9(e) of the 1937 Act
(42 U.S.C. 1437(g)(e) and 24 CFR
905.604(k)).
(c) Capital Fund Financing. For
Capital Fund Financing, only the
general development process will be as
follows:
(1) The PHA must include any public
housing development in its CFP 5-Year
Action Plan.
(2) After approval of the CFP 5-Year
Action Plan by HUD, the PHA will
contract for services necessary to
develop the project.
(d) All financing. For all financing,
the general development process will be
as follows:
(1) The PHA or partner will locate
properties and/or sites, prepare plans
and specifications, and obtain HUD
approval of the site acquisition and
development proposals.
(2) Upon HUD approval of the
development proposal, HUD and the
PHA must execute the ACC Amendment
and the PHA will enter the applicable
project information into HUD’s data
systems. The PHA may request
predevelopment funding necessary for
preparation of the development
proposal, as described in § 905.612(a).
(3) After HUD approval of the
development and/or site acquisition
proposals, the PHA and/or its partner
will acquire sites and/or properties, and
record the Declaration of Trust/
Declaration of Restrictive Covenants for
all properties acquired. After HUD
approval of the development proposal,
the PHA and/or its partner will solicit
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
construction bids, and award contracts
and construct the units.
(4) Upon completion of the project,
the PHA will establish the DOFA. After
the DOFA, the PHA will submit a cost
certificate to HUD attesting to the actual
cost of the project that will be subject to
audit.
(e) Funding sources. A PHA may
engage in development activities using
any one or a combination of the
following sources of funding:
(1) Capital Funds;
(2) HOPE VI funds;
(3) Proceeds from the sale of units
under a homeownership program in
accordance with 24 CFR part 906;
(4) Proceeds resulting from the
disposition of PHA-owned land or
improvements;
(5) Private financing used in
accordance with § 905.604, Mixed
Financed Development;
(6) Capital Fund Financing Program
(CFFP) proceeds under § 905.500;
(7) Operating Funds pursuant to an
Operating Fund Financing Program
(OFFP) approved by HUD pursuant to
24 CFR part 990; and
(8) Funds available from any other
source.
§ 905.602
Program requirements.
(a) Local cooperation. Except as
provided under § 905.604(d) for mixedfinance projects, the PHA must enter
into a Cooperation Agreement with the
applicable local governing body that
includes sufficient authority to cover
the public housing being developed
under this subpart, or provide an
opinion of counsel that the existing,
amended, or supplementary cooperation
agreement between the jurisdiction and
the PHA includes the project or
development.
(b) New construction limitation. These
requirements apply to the construction
of public housing and are not applicable
to development of public housing
through the acquisition of existing
housing. All proposed new construction
projects must meet both of the following
requirements:
(1) Limitation on the number of units.
A PHA may not use Capital Funds to
pay for the construction cost of public
housing units if such construction
would result in a net increase in the
number of public housing units that the
PHA owned, assisted, or operated on
October 1, 1999. A PHA may develop
public housing units in excess of the
limitation if:
(i) The units are available and
affordable to eligible low-income
families and the CF formula does not
provide additional funding for the
specific purpose of allowing
PO 00000
Frm 00023
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
6675
construction and operation of such
excess units; or
(ii) The units are part of a mixedfinance project or otherwise leverage
significant additional investment, and
the cost of the useful life of the projects
is less than the estimated cost of
providing tenant-based assistance under
section 8(o) of the 1937 Act.
(2) Limitations on cost. A PHA may
not construct public housing unless the
cost of construction is less than the cost
of acquisition or acquisition and
rehabilitation of existing units,
including the amount required to
establish, as necessary, an upfront
reserve for replacement accounts for
major repairs. A PHA shall provide
evidence of compliance with this
subpart either by:
(i) Demonstrating through a cost
comparison that the cost of new
construction in the neighborhood where
the PHA proposes to construct the
housing is less than the cost of
acquisition of existing housing with or
without rehabilitation in the same
neighborhood; or
(ii) Documenting that there is
insufficient existing housing in the
neighborhood to acquire.
(c) Federalization. Existing PHAowned nonpublic housing properties
financed with or without city or state
funds may not be federalized, as
described in section 9(n) of the 1937 Act
(see 42 U.S.C. 1437g(n)), under a public
housing CF ACC under this part, or by
any other means.
(d) Site and neighborhood standards.
Each proposed site to be newly acquired
for a public housing project or for
construction or rehabilitation of public
housing must be reviewed and approved
by the Field Office as meeting the
following standards, as applicable:
(1) The site must be adequate in size,
exposure, and contour to accommodate
the number and type of units proposed.
Adequate utilities (e.g., water, sewer,
gas, and electricity) and streets shall be
available to service the site.
(2) The site and neighborhood shall be
suitable to facilitating and furthering
full compliance with the applicable
provisions of Title VI of the Civil Rights
Act of 1964, Title VIII of the Civil Rights
Act of 1968, Executive Order 11063, and
HUD regulations issued under these
statutes.
(3) The site for new construction shall
not be located in an area of minority
concentration unless:
(i) There are sufficient, comparable
opportunities outside the areas of
minority concentration for housing
minority families in the income range
that are to be served by the proposed
project; or
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
6676
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
(ii) The project is necessary to meet
overriding housing needs that cannot
otherwise feasibly be met in that
housing market area. ‘‘Overriding
housing needs’’ shall not serve as the
basis for determining that a site is
acceptable if the only reason that these
needs cannot otherwise feasibly be met
is that, due to discrimination because of
race, color, religion, creed, sex,
disability, familial status, or national
origin, sites outside areas of minority
concentration are unavailable.
(4) The site for new construction shall
not be located in a racially mixed area
if the project will cause a significant
increase in the proportion of minority to
nonminority residents in the area.
(5) Notwithstanding the foregoing,
after demolition of public housing units
a PHA may construct public housing
units on the original public housing site
or in the same neighborhood if the
number of replacement public housing
units is significantly fewer than the
number of units demolished. One of the
following criteria must be satisfied:
(i) The number of public housing
units being constructed is not more than
50 percent of the number of units in the
original development; or
(ii) In the case of replacing an
occupied development, the number of
public housing units being constructed
is the minimum number needed to
house current residents that want to
remain at the site, so long as the number
of units is significantly fewer than the
number being demolished; or
(iii) The public housing units being
constructed constitute no more than 25
units.
(6) The site shall promote greater
choice of housing opportunities and
avoid undue concentration of assisted
persons in areas containing a high
proportion of low-income persons.
(7) The site shall be free from adverse
environmental conditions, natural or
manmade, such as: Toxic or
contaminated soils and substances;
mudslide or other unstable soil
conditions; flooding; septic tank
backups or other sewage hazards;
harmful air pollution or excessive
smoke or dust; excessive noise or
vibration from vehicular traffic; insect,
rodent or vermin infestation; or fire
hazards. The neighborhood shall not be
seriously detrimental to family life. It
shall not be filled with substandard
dwellings nor shall other undesirable
elements predominate, unless there is a
concerted program in progress to
remedy the undesirable conditions.
(8) Through the use of public
transportation, the site shall be
accessible to social, recreational,
educational, commercial, health
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
facilities, health services, and other
municipal facilities and services that are
at least equivalent to those typically
found in neighborhoods consisting
largely of similar unassisted standard
housing.
(9) Through the use of public
transportation, the site shall be
accessible to a range of jobs for lowincome workers and for other needs.
(10) The project may not be built on
a site that has occupants unless the
relocation requirements at
§ 905.308(b)(9) are met.
(11) The site shall not be in an area
that HUD has identified as having
special flood hazards and in which the
sale of flood insurance has been made
available under the National Flood
Insurance Act of 1968, unless the
development is covered by flood
insurance required by the Flood Disaster
Protection Act of 1973 and meets all
applicable HUD standards and local
requirements.
§ 905.604
Mixed-finance development.
(a) General. A PHA may use a
combination of private financing and/or
other public funds and Capital Funds to
develop public housing units. There are
many potential scenarios for ownership
and transaction structures, ranging from
the PHA or its partner(s) holding no
ownership interest, a partial ownership
interest, or 100 percent of the ownership
of public housing units that are to be
developed.
(1) PHAs and/or their partner(s) may
choose to enter into a partnership or
other contractual arrangement with a
third entity for the mixed-financed
development and/or ownership of
public housing units. If this entity has
primary responsibility along with the
PHA for the development of these units,
it is referred to for purposes of this
subpart as the PHA’s ‘‘partner.’’ The
entity, other than the PHA itself that
ultimately owns the public housing
units, whether or not the PHA retains an
ownership interest, is referred to as the
‘‘owner entity.’’
(2) The resulting ‘‘mixed-financed’’
developments may consist of 100
percent public housing units or may
consist of public and nonpublic housing
units. The term ‘‘mixed-finance
development’’ applies to all projects
developed by an owner entity regardless
of whether there is a combination of
private or other public sources. The
term ‘‘mixed-finance modernization’’
applies to public housing projects
modernized using the mixed-finance
method. Projects developed by
ownership entities that are modernized
using the mixed-finance method shall
maintain the DOFA that existed prior to
PO 00000
Frm 00024
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
mixed-finance modernization. Projects
modernizing using the mixed-finance
method shall have a covenant to
maintain and operate the project as
public housing pursuant to 24 CFR
905.304(a)(2). In addition, if a PHA
decides to limit the term of the ACC by
receiving Operating Fund or Capital
Fund Only assistance, as described in
§ 905.600(b) and (c), it must follow the
general development procedures
discussed in this subpart.
(b) Definitions applicable to this
section—(1) Development. A housing
facility consisting of public housing
units and that may also consist of
nonpublic housing units, that has been
developed, or that will be developed,
using mixed-finance strategies under
this subpart.
(2) Mixed-finance. The use of publicly
and/or privately financed sources of
funds for development under this
subpart, owned by an owner entity of
public housing units.
(3) Owner entity. The owner entity is
the entity that will own the public units,
if the PHA holds less than 100 percent
of the ownership interest. The owner
entity may be a partnership in which
the PHA owns a partnership interest.
(4) Participating party. Any person,
firm, corporation, or public or private
entity that:
(i) Agrees to provide financial or other
resources to carry out the approved
proposal or specified activities in the
proposal; or
(ii) Otherwise participates in the
development and/or operation of the
public housing units and will receive
funds derived from HUD with respect to
such participation. The term
‘‘participating party’’ includes an owner
entity or partner.
(5) Partner. A third-party entity with
which the PHA has entered into a
partnership or other contractual
arrangement to provide for the mixedfinance development of public housing
units pursuant to this subpart. The
Partner has primary responsibility with
the PHA for the development and
operation of public housing units under
the terms of the approved proposal and
in compliance with the applicable
Public Housing Requirements.
(6) PHA instrumentality. An
Instrumentality is an entity related to
the PHA whose assets, operations, and
management are legally and effectively
controlled by the PHA, and through
which PHA functions or policies are
implemented, and which utilizes public
housing funds or public housing assets
for the purpose of carrying out public
housing development functions of the
PHA. For the Department’s purposes, an
Instrumentality assumes the role of the
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
PHA and is the PHA under the Public
Housing Requirements for purposes of
implementing public housing
development activities and programs.
Instrumentalities must be authorized to
act for and to assume such
responsibilities. In addition, an
Instrumentality must abide by the
Public Housing Requirements that
would be applicable to the PHA.
(c) Structure of projects. Each mixedfinance project shall be developed in a
manner that:
(1) Ensures the continued operation of
public housing in accordance with all
Public Housing Requirements; and
(2) Will bear the approximate same
proportion to the total number of units
in the mixed-financed project as the
value of the total financial commitment
provided by the PHA bears to the total
financial commitment of the project, or
shall not be less than the number of
units that could have been developed
under the conventional public housing
program with the assistance, or as
otherwise approved by the Secretary.
(d) Process. Development of a mixedfinance project under this subpart is
similar to the development of public
housing financed entirely with Capital
Funds. PHAs will be expected to submit
development and site acquisition
proposals as identified in §§ 905.606
and 905.608. There are unique
provisions applicable to mixed-finance
projects that are further explained in
this section.
(e) Local cooperation. A PHA may
elect to exempt all public housing units
in a mixed-finance project from
provisions under section 6(d) of the Act
and from the finding of need and
cooperative agreement provisions under
sections 5(e)(1)(ii) and (e)(2) of the Act,
42 U.S.C. 1437c(e)(1)(ii) and (e)(2), and
instead subject units to local real estate
taxes, but only if the development of the
units is not inconsistent with the
jurisdiction’s comprehensive housing
affordability strategy. If no election is
made, the Cooperation Agreement as
provided in 905.602(a) is required.
(f) Conflicts. In the event of a conflict
between the requirements for a mixedfinance project and other requirements
of this subpart, the mixed-finance
public housing requirements shall
apply, unless HUD determines
otherwise in writing.
(g) HUD approval. For purposes of
this section only, any action or approval
that is required by HUD pursuant to the
requirements set forth in this section
shall be construed to mean HUD
Headquarters, unless the Field Office is
authorized in writing by Headquarters
to carry out a specific function in this
section.
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
(h) Irrevocable financial commitment.
Irrevocability of funds means that
binding legal documents, such as loan
agreements, mortgages/deeds of trust,
partnership agreements or operating
agreements or similar documents
committing funds have been executed
by the applicable parties, though
disbursement of such funds may be
subject to meeting progress milestones,
the absence of default, and other
commercially reasonable conditions
precedent under such documents. For
projects involving revolving loan funds,
the irrevocability of funds means that
funds in an amount identified to HUD
as the maximum revolving loan have
been committed pursuant to legally
binding documents, though
disbursement of such funds may be
subject to meeting progress milestones,
the absence of default, and other
commercially reasonable conditions
precedent under such documents. The
PHA must ensure the availability of the
participating party or parties’ financing,
the amount and source of financing
committed to the proposal by the
participating party or parties, and the
irrevocability of those funds.
(1) To ensure the irrevocable nature of
the committed funds, the PHA shall:
Review the legal documents committing
such funds to ensure that the progress
milestones and conditions precedent
contained in such contracts are
commercially reasonable, as commonly
accepted by the industry; that the PHA
and/or its ownership entity are ready,
willing, and able to attain such
milestones and comply with such
preconditions; and confirm, after
conducting sufficient due diligence, that
such documents are properly executed
by persons or entities legally authorized
to bind the entity committing such
funds.
(2) The PHA is not required to ensure
the availability of funds by enforcing
documents to which it is not a party.
(3) The PHA may certify as to the
irrevocability of funds through the
submission of an opinion of the PHA’s
counsel attesting that counsel has
examined the availability of the
participating party or parties’ financing,
and the amount and source of financing
committed to the proposal by the
participating party or parties, and has
determined that such financing has been
irrevocably committed by the
participating party or parties for use in
carrying out the proposal, and that such
commitment is in the amount required
under the terms of the proposal.
(i) Comparability. Public housing
units built in a mixed-financed
development must be comparable in
size, location, external appearance, and
PO 00000
Frm 00025
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
6677
distribution to nonpublic housing units
within the development.
(j) Mixed-finance procurement. The
requirements of 24 CFR part 85 and 24
CFR 905.316 are applicable to this
subpart with the following exceptions:
(1) PHA may select a development
partner using competitive proposals
procedures for qualifications-based
procurement, subject to negotiation of
fair and reasonable compensation, and
compliance with TDC and other
applicable cost limitations;
(2) An owner entity (which, as a
private entity, would normally not be
subject to 24 CFR part 85) shall be
required to comply with 24 CFR part 85
if HUD determines that the PHA or PHA
Instrumentality or either of their
members or employees exercises
significant decision-making functions
within the owner entity with respect to
managing the development of the
proposed units. HUD may, on a case-bycase basis, exempt such an owner entity
from the need to comply with 24 CFR
part 85 if it determines that the owner
entity has developed an acceptable
alternative procurement plan.
(k) Operating Fund and Capital Fund
only assistance. (1) General. PHAs and
their partners may develop public
housing without the use of Capital
Funds but for which the PHA agrees to
provide only Operating Fund assistance.
These Operating Fund-only newly
developed units will be included in the
calculation of the Capital Fund formula
in § 905.400. Where the PHA elects in
the future to use Capital Funds for
modernization of Operating Fund only
units, the PHA must sign an ACC
Amendment with a 20-year use
restriction and record a Declaration of
Trust in accordance with § 905.304. In
addition, PHAs and their partners may
develop public housing without the use
of Operating Funds but for which the
HUD and the PHA agree to provide only
Capital Fund assistance for the
development of new units, or, annually,
in the future, for modernization and
capital improvements, and the PHA
must sign an ACC Amendment with a
40-year use restriction for development
of new units and a 20-year use
restriction for modernization and capital
improvements and record a Declaration
of Trust in accordance with § 905.304.
(2) ACC Term and Formula. (i) The
term of the mixed-finance ACC
amendment will be determined based
on the assistance as provided in
§ 905.304. For units constructed with
the benefit of public housing capital
assistance, there shall be no disposition
of the public housing units without the
prior written approval of HUD during a
40-year period and the public housing
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
6678
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
units shall be maintained and operated
in accordance with all applicable Public
Housing Requirements (including the
ACC), as required by section 9(d)(3) of
the Act, 42 U.S.C. 1437g(d)(3), as those
requirements may be amended from
time to time. For Operating Fund only
units, there shall be no disposition of
the public housing units without the
prior written approval of HUD during,
and for 10 years after the end of, the
period in which the public housing
units receive operating subsidy from the
PHA, as required by 42 U.S.C.
1437g(e)(3), as those requirements may
be amended from time to time. For units
modernized with Capital Funds, the
PHA would have to execute an ACC
Amendment providing for no
disposition of the public housing units
without the prior written approval of
HUD during a 20-year period, and the
public housing units shall be
maintained and operated in accordance
with all applicable Public Housing
Requirements (including the ACC), as
required by 42 U.S.C. 1437g(d)(3), as
those requirements may be amended
from time to time.
(ii) If the PHA is no longer able to
provide Operating Fund assistance, the
PHA (on behalf of the owner entity) may
request to terminate the CF ACC early.
Where the ACC is terminated early, the
PHA must provide the resident with a
decent, safe, sanitary, and affordable
unit to which he or she can relocate,
which may include a public housing
unit in another development or a
Housing Choice Voucher, and pay for
the tenant’s reasonable moving costs.
The URA is not applicable in this
situation.
(3) Procedures. PHAs and their
partners will develop Operating Fund
only or Capital Fund only projects in
accordance with this part by submitting
development proposals, site acquisition
proposals, and closing documents,
except that the development proposals
submitted, pursuant to § 905.606, need
only address § 905.606(a), (b) (c), (j), (k),
and (l). Upon HUD approval of the
development proposal and closing
documents, the PHA and HUD will
execute a Mixed-Finance Amendment to
the ACC for Operating Fund only or
Capital Fund only assistance projects.
(l) [Reserved]
(m) [Reserved]
(n) Mixed-finance operations—
Deviation from HUD requirements
pursuant to section 35 (h) of the 1937
Act.
(1) An entity that develops, owns, and
operates a mixed-finance development
in which 20 percent or more of the units
are for the rental of nonpublic housing
may include a provision in the
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
agreement that it may deviate from the
requirements of the Mixed-Finance ACC
and applicable public housing
regulations regarding rents and income
eligibility, as provided in paragraph
(n)(2) of this section, only when there is
a reduction in appropriations under
section 9(e) of the 1937 Act (see 42
U.S.C. 1437g(e)), or any other change in
law preventing the PHA from providing
Operating Funds as provided in its
contractual agreement with the entity.
(2) Allowable deviations. The
agreement may provide for deviations
from Public Housing Requirements as
follows:
(i) Increased public housing tenant
rents, to the extent necessary to preserve
the viability of units.
(ii) The owner entity rents vacant
public housing units to persons who
earn more than 80 percent of the
adjusted median income (AMI) or to
persons who are paying more than 30
percent adjusted income for rent.
(iii) If an owner determines that the
amount of income being generated after
renting the vacant public housing units
is still insufficient to cover the projected
shortfall in operating subsidies and if
the owner has expended all operating
subsidy reserve funds put aside for such
eventuality, the owner may give written
notice to the public housing residents
that the owner intends to increase the
rent being charged for the unit. In this
case, the owner may increase the
amount of the public housing rent above
the amount established under section 3
of the Act, 42 U.S.C. 1437a, but any
increased rental charges must be strictly
limited to the amount needed to meet
the projected shortfall in operating
subsidies.
(iv) If, after notifying public housing
residents of a proposed rent increase
under § 905.604(n)(2)(iii) of this section,
the resident is unable to remain in the
unit because the new rent is more than
40 percent of the tenant’s income, the
PHA must provide the resident with a
decent, safe, sanitary, and affordable
unit to which he or she can relocate,
which may include a public housing
unit in another development or a
Housing Choice Voucher, and pay for
the tenant’s reasonable moving costs.
The URA is not applicable in this
situation. Pending the tenant’s
relocation to another unit, the owner
may not evict the tenant for
nonpayment of rent if the reason for the
eviction is the resident’s inability to pay
the incremental increase in rent under
§ 905.604(n)(2)(iii) of this section.
(v) The owner must have included in
each of its leases with public housing
residents in the mixed-finance
development a disclosure that the
PO 00000
Frm 00026
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
residents may be required to pay a
higher rent for the unit, or to relocate to
another unit, and specific conditions
under which a higher rent might be
charged; that is, a change in subsidy
under section 9 of the Act, 42 U.S.C.
1437g, or other applicable law.
(3) Alternative management plan. If
the agreement between the PHA and the
entity contains a provision permitting a
deviation from the Public Housing
Requirements pursuant to section 35(h)
of the 1937 Act and this part, the
alternative management plan between
the PHA and the entity must be
approved by HUD before the
implementation of such plan. The plan
must contain the following:
(i) A statement describing the owner’s
reasons for invoking the alternative
management plan (and, if the plan is
being invoked because of changes in
applicable law(s), a statement as to how
the statutory changes will materially
affect the viability of the public housing
units);
(ii) An explanation of the owner’s
proposed remedies including, but not
limited to:
(A) How the owner will select the
residents (including a statement of their
income levels) and units to be affected
by the proposed remedies;
(B) The number and income levels of
the families proposed to be admitted to
those public housing units;
(C) The owner’s timetable for
implementing the proposed remedies in
the alternative management plan;
(iii) An amended agreement between
the Owner and PHA that includes
provisions ensuring that:
(A) The alternative management plan
is reevaluated and approved annually
by HUD to ensure that implementation
of the remedies continues to be
appropriate;
(B) The owner complies with the
requirements of this part in its
management and operation of the public
housing units following the invocation
of remedies;
(C) The owner returns to the PHA any
income that is generated by the public
housing units in excess of the owner’s
expenses on behalf of those units, as a
result of its invocation of remedies;
(D) The owner reinstates all Public
Housing Requirements (including rent
and income eligibility requirements)
with respect to the original number of
public housing units and number of
bedrooms, in the mixed-finance
development following the PHA’s
reinstatement of operating subsidies at
the level originally agreed to in the
regulatory and operating agreement; and
(E) The owner provides written notice
to each of the public housing residents
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
in the mixed-finance development of its
intention to invoke remedies under a
submitted alternative management plan.
Such notice must comply with all
relevant federal, state, and local
substantive and procedural
requirements and, at a minimum, must
provide public housing residents with
90 days advance notice of any proposal
to increase rents or to relocate public
housing residents to alternative housing.
(iv) Additional evidence. The PHA
must provide documentation that:
(A) The revenues being generated by
the public housing units (in
combination with the reduced
allocation of operating subsidy) are
inadequate to cover the reasonable and
necessary operating expenses of the
public housing units;
(B) The deficit in operating revenues
is attributable solely to the reduction in
operating subsidy for the public housing
units;
(C) A demonstration that the PHA
cannot meet its contractual obligation;
(D) The reduction in appropriations
under section 9 of the 1937 Act or other
changes in applicable law materially
affects the viability of the public
housing units; and
(E) The owner has attempted to offset
the impact of reduced operating
subsidies, or changes in applicable law,
by expending more than 50 percent of
the funds from any operating reserve
that may have been established on
behalf of the public housing units.
(4) HUD review. HUD will review the
alternative management plan to ensure
that the plan meets the requirements of
this subpart, and that any proposed
deviation from standard Public Housing
Requirements will be implemented only
to the extent necessary to preserve the
viability of the public housing units,
while maintaining the low-income
character of the units to the maximum
extent practicable. HUD will complete
its review of the alternative management
plan and provide a decision within 30
days of its receipt. HUD may disapprove
a PHA’s request, made on behalf of the
owner, to invoke or continue remedies
under the alternative management plan
for any of the following reasons:
(i) That the circumstances upon
which the owner’s request to invoke
remedies under the plan are premised
do not qualify in accordance with
section 35(h) of the Act (42 U.S.C.
1437z–7(h)), as determined by HUD, or
that the original circumstances that
triggered the remedies no longer
continue to apply;
(ii) In HUD’s sole discretion, the
owner’s proposed deviation(s) from
standard Public Housing Requirements
are not limited to the maximum extent
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
practicable to preserving the viability of
the public housing units and
maintaining the low-income character of
those units;
(iii) HUD has factual information
available to it that contradicts the PHA’s
and/or the owner’s assertions that each
of the required preconditions for
invoking remedies has been satisfied; or
(iv) HUD has evidence that the
proposed alternative management plan
is not in compliance with the civil
rights laws, including the requirement
to affirmatively further fair housing.
(5) HUD reevaluation and reapproval.
HUD reevaluation and reapproval of the
alternative management plan is required
annually once an owner has invoked
remedies under an alternative
management plan, in order to ensure
that the circumstances originally
triggering the need for such remedies, as
well as the scope of the remedies,
remain valid and appropriate.
§ 905.606
Development proposal.
(a) In order to develop any public
housing, including mixed-finance
public housing for rental occupancy, the
PHA shall submit a development
proposal, in the form prescribed by
HUD. The development proposal shall
include some or all of the following
documentation, as deemed necessary by
HUD. Failure to submit and obtain HUD
approval may result in the Capital
Funds used in conjunction with the
project being deemed to be ineligible
expenses. In determining the amount of
information to be submitted by the PHA,
HUD shall consider whether the
documentation is required for HUD to
carry out mandatory statutory,
regulatory, or Executive Order reviews;
the quality of the PHA’s past
performance in implementing
development projects under this part;
and the PHA’s demonstrated
administrative capability.
(b) Project description. A description
of the proposed project, including the
proposed development method (e.g.,
mixed-finance, new construction,
acquisition); the household type (e.g.,
family, elderly); number and type of
units (with bedroom breakout and
count) of public and nonpublic housing
units, if applicable; the method of
completing construction, including the
extent to which the PHA shall use force
account labor and use of procured
contractors; schematic drawings of the
proposed building and unit plans; and
the types and size of nondwelling space
to be provided. For new construction
projects, the PHA must include
determinations required under
§ 905.602. If the project involves the
acquisition of existing properties less
PO 00000
Frm 00027
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
6679
than 2 years old, the PHA must include
an attestation from the PHA and owner
that the property was not constructed
with the intent that it would be sold to
the PHA or that the property was
constructed in compliance with all
applicable requirements (e.g., DavisBacon wage rates, accessibility, etc.).
(c) Site information. An identification
and description of the proposed site,
site plan, and neighborhood, and a
neighborhood map shall be contained in
the development proposal and must
meet the site and neighborhood
standards required under § 905.602(d).
(d) Participant description.
Identification of participating parties
and a description of the activities to be
undertaken by each of the participating
parties and the PHA; and legal and
business relationships between the PHA
and each of the participating parties, as
applicable.
(e) Development project schedule. A
schedule for the development project
that includes each major stage of
development through and including the
submission of an Actual Development
Cost Certificate to HUD.
(f) Accessibility. A PHA must provide
sufficient information for HUD to
determine that dwelling units and other
public housing facilities meet
accessibility requirements specified at
§ 905.312, including, but not limited to,
the number, location, and bedroom size
distribution of UFAS-accessible
dwelling units.
(g) Project costs.
(1) Budgets. The PHA shall submit a
budget in the form prescribed by HUD
reflecting the total cost from all sources
based on the schematic drawings,
outline specifications, and construction
cost estimate. For mixed-financed
projects, the PHA shall submit a budget
for the construction period, a draw
schedule identifying the timing of
construction financing contributions
from all sources, and a separate budget
showing the permanent financing in the
project
(2) TDC comparison. A calculation of
the TDC subject to § 905.314.
(3) Financing. A PHA must submit a
detailed description of all financing
necessary for the implementation of the
project, specifying the sources. In
addition, HUD may require all
documents relating to the financing
(e.g., loan agreements, notes, etc.) and
establishment of project reserves.
(4) Safe harbor standards. HUD will
review the project terms when receiving
development proposals, budgets, and/or
other documents that contain negotiated
terms. In order to expedite the mixedfinance review process and control
costs, HUD may make available safe
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
6680
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
harbor and maximum fee ranges for a
number of costs. If a project is at or
below a safe harbor standard, no further
review will be required by HUD. If a
project is above a safe harbor standard,
additional review by HUD will be
necessary. In order to approve terms
above the safe harbor, the PHA must
demonstrate to HUD in writing that the
negotiated terms are appropriate for the
level of risk involved in the project, the
scope of work, any specific
circumstances of the development, and
the local or national market for the
services provided.
(h) Operating pro-forma/Operating
Fund methodology. Projects shall
submit a 10-year operating pro-forma
including all assumptions to assure that
operating expenses do not exceed
operating income. For mixed-finance
development, the PHA must describe its
methodology for providing and
distributing operating subsidy to the
owner entity for the public housing
units.
(i) Local cooperation agreement.
Documentation regarding local
cooperation agreement in accordance
with 905.602(a) or 905.604(e) for mixedfinance transactions.
(j) Environmental requirements. All
activities under this part are subject to
an environmental review by a
responsible entity under HUD’s
environmental regulations at 24 CFR
part 58 and must comply with the
requirements of the National
Environmental Policy Act of 1969
(NEPA) (42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.) and the
related laws and authorities listed at 24
CFR 58.5. HUD may make a finding in
accordance with § 58.11 of this title and
may perform the environmental review
itself under the provisions of 24 CFR
part 50. In those cases where HUD
performs the environmental review
under 24 CFR part 50, it will do so
before approving a proposed project,
and will comply with the requirements
of NEPA and the related requirements at
24 CFR 50.4.
(k) Relocation. Information
concerning any displacement of the site
occupants, including identification of
each person displaced, the distribution
plan for notices, and anticipated cost
and source of funding for relocation
assistance in accordance with § 905.308
(b)(9). If displacement is due to a HUDapproved demolition or disposition of
existing public housing, no submission
will be required, since relocation was
required to be addressed prior to
demolition/disposition HUD approval.
(l) Market analysis. For a mixedfinance development that includes
nonpublic housing units, the PHA must
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
include an analysis of the projected
market for the proposed project.
(m) Program income and fees. HUD
will require the PHA to disclose
information on program income and
fees the PHA or its affiliate or
instrumentality receives.
(n) Additional HUD-requested
information. PHAs are required to
provide any additional information that
HUD may need to determine whether it
can approve the proposal.
§ 905.608 Site or property acquisition
proposal.
(a) When a PHA determines that it is
necessary to acquire land or property
using the Capital Fund for the
development of public housing prior to
approval of the Development Proposal,
the PHA shall submit a site/property
acquisition proposal to HUD for review
and approval in accordance with 24
CFR 905.610. If site or property will be
purchased at closing, then the items
stated in paragraphs (e) and (f) of this
section need to be included in the
development proposal. The acquisition
of a site or property for additional
public housing is subject to
requirements contained in
§ 905.308(b)(9). The site acquisition
proposal shall include the following:
(b) Justification. A justification for
acquiring property prior to Development
Proposal submission.
(c) Description. A description of the
property (i.e., proposed site or project)
to be acquired.
(d) Project description; site and
neighborhood standards. An
identification and description of the
proposed project, site plan, and
neighborhood, together with
information sufficient to enable HUD to
determine that the proposed site meets
the site and neighborhood standards at
§ 905.602(d).
(e) Zoning. Documentation that the
proposed project is permitted by current
zoning ordinances or regulations or
evidence to indicate that needed
rezoning is likely and will not delay the
project.
(f) Appraisal. Documentation attesting
that an appraisal of the proposed
property by an independent, statecertified appraiser has been conducted
and that the acquisition is in
compliance with § 905.308(b)(9). The
purchase price of the site/property may
not exceed the appraised value without
HUD approval.
(g) Schedule. A schedule of the
activities to be carried out by the PHA.
(h) Environmental assessment. An
environmental review or request for
HUD to perform the environmental
review pursuant to § 905.308(b)(2).
PO 00000
Frm 00028
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
(i) Relocation. Information concerning
any displacement of the site occupants,
including identification of each person
displaced, the distribution plan for
notices, and anticipated cost and source
of funding for relocation assistance in
accordance with § 905.308(b)(9). If
displacement is due to a HUD-approved
demolition or disposition of existing
public housing, no submission will be
required since relocation was required
to be addressed prior to HUD approval
of the demolition or disposition.
§ 905.610
Technical processing.
(a) Review. HUD shall review all
development proposals and site/
property acquisition proposals for
compliance with the statutory,
Executive Order, and regulatory
requirements applicable to the
development of public housing. In
addition, HUD shall conduct any
necessary statutory and Executive Order
reviews with respect to each proposal.
For mixed-finance proposals, HUD’s
review will evaluate whether the
proposed sources and uses of funds are
eligible and reasonable, and whether the
financing and other documentation
establish to HUD’s satisfaction that the
development is viable and structured so
as to adequately protect the federal
investment of funds in the development.
For this purpose, HUD will consider the
PHA’s proposed methodology for
allocating operating subsidies on behalf
of the public housing units, the
projected revenue to be generated by
any nonpublic housing units in a
mixed-finance development, and the
10-year operating pro-forma and other
information contained in the proposal.
If public housing development funds are
to be used to pay for more than the pro
rata cost of common area improvements,
HUD will evaluate the proposal to
ensure that:
(1) On a per-unit basis (taking into
consideration the number of public
housing units for which funds have
been reserved) the PHA will not exceed
TDC limits; and
(2) Common area improvements will
benefit the residents of the development
in a mixed-finance project.
(b) Approval. If HUD determines that
a proposal is approvable, upon approval
of the Request for Release of Funds and
the environmental certification
submitted in accordance with 24 CFR
part 58, HUD shall notify the PHA in
writing of its approval. The HUD
approval will include the CF ACC for
signature and return by the PHA for
execution by HUD. Until HUD approves
a proposal, a PHA may only draw down
funds for costs for materials and
services related to proposal preparation
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
and predevelopment costs approved by
HUD.
(c) Amendments to approved
development proposals. The PHA shall
amend any approved development
proposal to which a material change is
made. HUD’s review and approval is
required for all amendments to
approved development proposals. HUD
defines a material change as:
(1) A change in the number of units;
(2) A change in the number of
bedrooms by an increase/decrease of
more than 10 percent;
(3) A change in cost or financing by
an increase/decrease of more than 10
percent;
(4) A change in the site; or
(5) A schedule change that results in
a PHA’s failure to meet obligation and
expenditure deadlines.
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
§ 905.612 Disbursement of capital funds—
predevelopment costs.
(a) Predevelopment Costs. After
inclusion of a new development project
in the HUD-approved CFP 5-Year
Action Plan and the development has
been entered into applicable HUD data
systems, the PHA may request funding
for predevelopment expenses. Failure to
request and obtain HUD approval for
predevelopment assistance may result
in the costs associated with the new
project being deemed ineligible costs.
Predevelopment funds may be approved
by HUD in accordance with the
following requirements:
(1) Predevelopment assistance may be
used to pay for materials and services
related to proposal development and
may also be used to pay for costs related
to the demolition of units on a proposed
site or for preliminary development
work.
(2) For non-mixed-finance projects,
predevelopment funding up to 5 percent
does not require HUD approval. HUD
shall determine on a case-by-case basis
that a higher amount that may be drawn
down by a PHA to pay for necessary and
reasonable preliminary development
costs, based upon a consideration of the
nature and scope of activities proposed
to be carried out by the PHA. For mixedfinance projects, all funding for
predevelopment must be reviewed and
approved by HUD.
(3) Before a request for
predevelopment assistance may be
approved, the PHA must provide to
HUD information and documentation
specified in §§ 905.606 and 905.608 as
HUD deems appropriate.
(4) The requirements in § 905.612(b)
to disburse funds for mixed-finance
projects in an approved ratio to other
public and private housing do not apply
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
to disbursement of predevelopment
funds.
(b) Standard drawdown requirements.
(1) General. If HUD determines that
the proposed development is
approvable, it may execute with the
PHA a CF ACC Amendment, or mixedfinance amendment to the CF ACC, as
applicable, to provide funds for the
purposes, and in the amounts approved
by HUD. Upon approval of the
development proposal and all necessary
documentation evidencing and
implementing the development plan,
the PHA may disburse amounts as are
necessary and consistent with the
approved development and site
acquisition proposal without further
HUD approval, unless HUD determines
that such approval is necessary. Once
HUD approves the acquisition plan, the
PHA may request funds for acquisition
activities. Each Capital Fund
disbursement from HUD is deemed to be
an attestation of compliance by the PHA
with the requirements of this part, as
prescribed in § 905.106. If HUD
determines that the PHA is in
noncompliance with any provision of
this part, the PHA may be subject to the
sanctions in subpart H, § 905.800 of this
part.
(2) Mixed-finance projects. Upon HUD
approval of final, fully executed and,
where appropriate, recorded closing
documents submitted pursuant to
§ 905.604(l), the PHA may disburse
funds from HUD only in an approved
ratio to other public and private funds,
in accordance with a disbursement
schedule prepared by the PHA and
approved by HUD. The ratio applies to
the overall project and not to each
drawdown. The PHA will release funds
to its partner consistent with § 905.316.
Subpart G—Other Security Interests
§ 905.700
Other security interests.
(a) The PHA may not pledge,
mortgage, enter into a transaction that
provides recourse to public housing
assets, or otherwise grant a security
interest in any public housing project,
portion thereof, or other property of the
PHA without written approval of HUD.
(b) The PHA shall submit the request
in the form and manner prescribed by
HUD.
(c) HUD shall consider:
(1) The ability of the PHA to complete
the financing, the improvements, and
repay the financing;
(2) The reasonableness of the
provisions in the proposal; or
(3) Any other factors HUD deems
appropriate.
PO 00000
Frm 00029
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4702
6681
Subpart H—Compliance, HUD Review,
Penalties, and Sanctions
§ 905.800
Compliance.
As provided in § 905.106, PHAs or
other owner/management entities and
their partners are required to comply
with all applicable provisions of this
part. Execution of the CF ACC
Amendment received from the PHA,
submissions required by this part, and
disbursement of Capital Fund grants
from HUD are individually and
collectively deemed to be the PHA’s
certification that it is in compliance
with the provisions of this part and all
other Public Housing Program
Requirements. Noncompliance with any
provision of this part or other applicable
requirements may subject the PHA and/
or its partners to sanctions contained in
§ 905.804.
§ 905.802 HUD review of PHA
performance.
(a) HUD Determination. HUD shall
review the PHA’s performance in
completing work in accordance with
this part at least annually. HUD may
make such other reviews when and as
it determines necessary. When
conducting such a review, HUD shall, at
minimum, make the following
determinations:
(1) HUD shall determine whether the
PHA has carried out its activities under
this part in a timely manner and in
accordance with its CFP 5-Year Action
Plan and other applicable requirements.
(2) HUD shall determine whether the
PHA has a continuing capacity to carry
out its Capital Fund activities in a
timely manner.
(3) HUD shall determine whether the
PHA has accurately reported its
obligation and expenditures in a timely
manner.
(4) HUD shall determine whether the
PHA has accurately reported required
building and unit data for the
calculation of the formula.
(5) HUD shall determine whether the
PHA has obtained approval for any
CFFP or OFFP proposal and any PHA
development proposal.
(b) [Reserved]
§ 905.804
Sanctions.
(a) If at any time, HUD finds that a
PHA has failed to comply substantially
with any provision of this part, HUD
may impose one or a combination of
sanctions, as it determines is necessary.
Sanctions associated with failure to
obligate or expend in a timely manner
are specified at § 905.306. Other
possible sanctions for noncompliance
by the PHA that HUD may impose
include, but are not limited to the
following:
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
6682
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 / Proposed Rules
jlentini on DSKJ8SOYB1PROD with PROPOSALS2
(1) Issue a corrective action order at
any time by notifying the PHA of the
specific program requirements that the
PHA has violated, and specifying that
any of the corrective actions listed in
this section must be taken. Any
corrective action ordered by HUD shall
become a condition of the CF ACC.
(2) Reimburse from non-HUD sources.
(3) Limit, withhold, reduce, or
terminate Capital Fund or Operating
Fund assistance.
(4) Issue a Limited Denial of
Participation or Debar responsible PHA
officials pursuant to 24 CFR part 24,
subpart J.
(5) Withhold assistance to the PHA
under section 8 of the Act, 42 U.S.C.
1437f.
VerDate Mar<15>2010
16:33 Feb 04, 2011
Jkt 223001
(6) Declare a breach of the CF ACC
with respect to some or all of the PHA’s
functions.
(7) Take any other corrective action or
sanction, as HUD deems necessary.
(b) Right to Appeal. Before taking any
action described in paragraph (a) of this
section, HUD shall notify the PHA and
provide an opportunity, within a
prescribed period of time, to present any
arguments or additional facts and data
concerning the proposed action to the
Assistant Secretary for Public and
Indian Housing
PART 941—[REMOVED]
PART 968—[REMOVED]
5. Remove part 968, consisting of
§§ 968.101–968.435.
PART 969—[REMOVED]
6. Remove part 969, consisting of
§§ 969.101–969.107.
Dated: December 23, 2010.
Sandra B. Henriquez,
Assistant Secretary for Public and Indian
Housing.
[FR Doc. 2011–2303 Filed 2–4–11; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4210–67–P
4. Remove part 941, consisting of
§§ 941.101–941.616.
PO 00000
Frm 00030
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 9990
E:\FR\FM\07FEP2.SGM
07FEP2
Agencies
[Federal Register Volume 76, Number 25 (Monday, February 7, 2011)]
[Proposed Rules]
[Pages 6654-6682]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Printing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2011-2303]
[[Page 6653]]
Vol. 76
Monday,
No. 25
February 7, 2011
Part II
Department of Housing and Urban Development
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
24 CFR Parts 903, 905, 941 et al.
Public Housing Capital Fund Program; Proposed Rule
Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 25 / Monday, February 7, 2011 /
Proposed Rules
[[Page 6654]]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT
24 CFR Parts 903, 905, 941, 968, 969
[Docket No. FR-5236-P-01]
RIN-2577-AC50
Public Housing Capital Fund Program
AGENCY: Office of the Assistant Secretary for Public and Indian
Housing, HUD.
ACTION: Proposed rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: This proposed rule combines and streamlines the former legacy
public housing modernization programs, including the Comprehensive
Grant Program (CGP), the Comprehensive Improvement Assistance Program
(CIAP), and the Public Housing Development Program (which encompasses
mixed-finance development), into the Capital Fund Program (CFP). This
rule proposes a change to the Public Housing Agency Annual Plan
regulation to incorporate the definition of qualified public housing
agencies (PHAs), which was mandated by the Housing and Economic
Recovery Act (HERA) of 2008, and to decouple or separate the CFP
informational requirements from the PHA Annual Plan requirements. Also
proposed is the ability for PHAs to request a total development cost
(TDC) exception for integrated utility management, capital planning,
and other capital and management activities that maximize energy
conservation and efficiency, including green construction and
retrofits, which include windows; heating system replacements; wall
insulation; site-based generation; advanced energy savings
technologies, including renewable energy generation; and other such
retrofits.
The structure of the proposed Public Housing Capital Fund Program
regulation is described in section IV of the SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION.
Several regulations would be eliminated with the implementation of this
rule, along with the issuance of new and/or revised CFP forms,
including the CFP Annual Statement/Performance and Evaluation Report
(form HUD-50075.1), CFP 5-Year Action Plan (form HUD-50075.2), and the
CFP Annual Contributions Contract (ACC) Amendment, as well as a new
guidebook.
DATES: Comments Due Date: April 8, 2011.
ADDRESSES: Interested persons are invited to submit comments regarding
this proposed rule to the Regulations Division, Office of General
Counsel, Department of Housing and Urban Development, 451 7th Street,
SW., Room 10276, Washington, DC 20410-0500. Communications must refer
to the above docket number and title. There are two methods for
submitting public comments. All submissions must refer to the above
docket number and title.
1. Submission of Comments by Mail. Comments may be submitted by
mail to the Regulations Division, Office of General Counsel, Department
of Housing and Urban Development, 451 7th Street, SW., Room 10276,
Washington, DC 20410-0500.
2. Electronic Submission of Comments. Interested persons may submit
comments electronically through the Federal eRulemaking Portal at
https://www.regulations.gov. HUD strongly encourages commenters to
submit comments electronically. Electronic submission of comments
allows the commenter maximum time to prepare and submit a comment,
ensures timely receipt by HUD, and enables HUD to make them immediately
available to the public. Comments submitted electronically through the
https://www.regulations.gov Web site can be viewed by other commenters
and interested members of the public. Commenters should follow the
instructions provided on that site to submit comments electronically.
Note: To receive consideration as public comments, comments
must be submitted through one of the two methods specified above.
Again, all submissions must refer to the docket number and title of
the rule.
No Facsimile Comments. Facsimile (FAX) comments are not acceptable.
Public Inspection of Public Comments. All properly submitted
comments and communications submitted to HUD will be available for
public inspection and copying between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. weekdays at the
above address. Due to security measures at the HUD Headquarters
building, an advance appointment to review the public comments must be
scheduled by calling the Regulations Division at 202-402-3055 (this is
not a toll-free number). Individuals with speech or hearing impairments
may access this number via TTY by calling the Federal Information Relay
Service, toll free, at 800-877-8339. Copies of all comments submitted
are available for inspection and downloading at https://www.regulations.gov.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Jeffrey Riddel, Director, Office of
Capital Improvements, Office of Public and Indian Housing, Department
of Housing and Urban Development, 451 7th Street, SW., Washington, DC
20410-8000; telephone number 202-708-1640 (this is not a toll-free
number). Hearing- or speech-impaired individuals may access this number
through TTY by calling the toll-free Federal Information Relay Service
at 800-877-8339.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Background
Section 9(d) of the U.S. Housing Act of 1937 (1937 Act) (42 U.S.C.
1437g(d)) provides for a ``Capital Fund'' for the purpose of making
assistance available to PHAs to carry out capital and management
improvement activities. Section 9(d)(2) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C.
1437g(d)(2)) requires HUD to develop a formula for determining the
amount of assistance provided to PHAs from the Capital Fund for a
federal fiscal year (FFY). The formula ``shall include'' a mechanism to
reward PHA performance. As required by statute, the Capital Fund
formula (CF formula) was developed through negotiated rulemaking and
promulgated through a final rule, published on March 16, 2000 (65 FR
14422), with certain minor amendments to remove some incorrect,
unnecessary dates adopted by final rule published on May 2, 2000 (65 FR
25446).
Section 9(g) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437g(g)) provides for a
certain amount of flexibility in the use of Capital Fund amounts. For
PHAs other than small PHAs (that is, those with fewer than 250 units of
public housing), a PHA may use up to 20 percent of its Capital Fund for
activities that are eligible activities for the Operating Fund under
section 9(e) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437g(e)). Small PHAs that meet
certain statutory criteria related to operating and maintaining their
public housing in safe, clean, and healthy condition may use 100
percent of their Capital Fund amounts for any statutorily eligible use
under the Operating Fund.
Section 9(g)(3) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437g(g)(3)) imposes
limitations on the use of the Capital Fund or Operating Fund for new
construction. Generally, the CF formula shall not provide PHAs funding
for the purpose of constructing public housing units (which includes
acquisition), if the construction would result in a net increase from
the number of housing units owned, operated, or assisted by the PHA on
October 1, 1999. PHAs may use their CF formula amounts to construct
units in excess of the ``net increase'' limitation, if the units are
available and affordable to low-income families (42 U.S.C.
1437g(g)(3)(B)). The 1937 Act provides two exceptions to the ``net
increase'' limitation on the CF
[[Page 6655]]
formula. One is where the funding for additional units is for a mixed-
finance project (42 U.S.C. 1437g(g)(3)(C)(i)). The second exception is
where the cost of the useful life of the project is less than the
estimated cost of providing tenant-based assistance under the Housing
Choice Voucher program (42 U.S.C. 1437g(g)(3)(C)(ii)).
Section 9(j) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437g(j)) provides for
penalties for slow obligation and expenditure of Capital Funds.
Generally, a PHA is required to obligate funds received under section 9
of the 1937 Act within 24 months of the date on which the funds become
available or within 24 months of the date on which the PHA accumulates
enough funds to undertake modernization, substantial rehabilitation, or
construction of units (42 U.S.C. 1437g(j)(1)). Under section 9(j)(2)(B)
of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437g(j)(2)(B)), a PHA ``shall disregard''
this requirement with respect to unobligated amounts the total of which
do not exceed 10 percent of the original allocation of Capital Funds to
the PHA. Additionally, PHAs must expend their Capital Fund assistance
within 4 years after the date on which the funds became available for
obligation (42 U.S.C. 1437g(j)(5)). HUD may extend the time periods for
obligation of Capital Funds for specific reasons listed in the statute
and established by HUD by notice published in the Federal Register (42
U.S.C. 1437g(j)(2), 42 U.S.C. 1437g(j)(5)(A)). The statute lists
potential sanctions for failure to comply with the obligation and
expenditure deadlines, including withholding of funds, penalties
applied to future grants, reallocation of funds to high-performing
PHAs, and recapture (42 U.S.C. 1437g(j)(3), 42 U.S.C. 1437g(j)(6)).
Regulations implementing the obligation and expenditure requirements
were published on August 1, 2003 (68 FR 45731). These regulations are
currently codified at 24 CFR 905.120, and would be moved to Sec.
905.306 by this proposed rulemaking.
Former section 9(k) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437g(k)) provided
for a fund reserve for emergency, natural disasters, and litigation
needs, and for a set-aside for Operation Safe Home. Section 2804 of
Title VII (Small Public Housing Authorities Paperwork Reduction Act) of
Division B of the HERA (Pub. L. 110-289, approved July 30, 2008)
removed section 9(k) of the 1937 Act.
Section 2702 of the Small Public Housing Authorities Paperwork
Reduction Act amends section 5A of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437c-1), to
provide that certain PHAs, called ``qualified public housing
agencies,'' are not required to file the PHA Annual Plan called for in
section 5A(b)(1) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437c-1(b)(1)). Qualified
PHAs under section 2702 are those that administer 550 or fewer units--
considered as the sum of all the public housing units and vouchers
under section 8(o) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437f(o)) administered by
a PHA--and are not designated as a troubled PHA under section 6(j)(2),
and do not have a failing score under the Section 8 Management
Assessment Program (SEMAP) during the prior 12 months.
Such PHAs must still submit a PHA 5-Year Plan, file the civil
rights certification under 42 U.S.C. 1437c-1(d)(16), and consult with,
and consider the recommendations of, the resident advisory board at the
annual hearing required of such agencies regarding any changes to the
goals, objectives, and policies of that PHA. The CFP (and previous CIAP
and CGP) have always had separate informational requirements, but some
of these were combined with the PHA Annual and 5-Year Plan. However,
with the changes made to the PHA Annual Plan and the need to have grant
reporting in compliance with CFP and other federal reporting
requirements, the CFP informational requirements will be decoupled or
separated from the PHA Annual Plan submissions.
II. Overview of the Capital Fund Program
This rule proposes to revise the regulations governing the use of
assistance made available under the Capital Fund in 24 CFR part 905.
Assistance under the Capital Fund is a primary, regular source of
funding made available by HUD to a PHA for modernization and
development of public housing and other capital activities. This rule
also proposes to replace and remove several other regulations that
currently govern a PHA's use of HUD assistance, specifically: 24 CFR
part 941, entitled ``Public Housing Development''; 24 CFR part 968,
entitled ``Public Housing Modernization''; and 24 CFR part 969,
entitled ``PHA-Owned Projects--Continued Operation as Low-Income
Housing After Completion of Debt Service.'' In the case of part 969,
which provides for the continued operation of housing as public housing
for the 10-year period after the last receipt of operating subsidy,
sections 9(e)(3) and 9(m) of the 1937 Act, along with the Annual
Contributions Contract (ACC), as amended and approved by HUD, serve the
same purpose, making the separate regulations in 24 CFR part 969 no
longer necessary.
Although HUD established the CF formula in 2000, HUD continued to
rely on CFP requirements found in the regulations in these other parts
of 24 CFR, to the extent that these requirements were not superseded by
statutory requirements.
III. Overview of the Changes to the PHA Annual Plan
This regulation modifies 24 CFR 903.3(a) to incorporate the
definition of a qualified PHA provided in section 2702 of HERA. HERA
exempts qualified PHAs from the requirement of section 5(A) of the 1937
Act to submit a PHA Annual Plan.
IV. This Proposed Rule
To meet the objective of revising and consolidating the
requirements governing the use of Capital Funds, as discussed in
Section II of this preamble, this proposed rule would revise 24 CFR
part 905 to establish new subparts A through H.
A. Subpart A
Subpart A of this proposed part 905 would provide a general
introduction and definitions. Section 905.100(a) and (b) would state
the purpose of the part 905 regulations and provide a general
description of the CFP. Section 905.100(c) would establish employment,
contracting, and close-out requirements. Section 905.102 would address
the applicability of the part 905 regulations. Section 905.104 would
require that all HUD approvals be in writing from officials designated
to grant such approvals. Section 905.106 would state that noncompliance
with this part or any other applicable requirements may subject a PHA
and its partners to sanctions provided elsewhere in part 905. Section
905.108 would provide a number of program-specific definitions.
The following are definitions relating to the Capital Fund Program
and proposed to be included in the definition section of the part 905
regulations: ``Additional Project Costs,'' ``Accessible,'' ``Capital
Fund,'' ``Capital Fund Annual Contributions Contract Amendment (CF ACC
Amendment),'' ``Capital Fund Program Fee,'' ``Community Renewal
Costs,'' ``Cooperation Agreement,'' ``Date of Full Availability
(DOFA),'' ``Emergency Work,'' ``Expenditure,'' ``Federal Fiscal Year
(FFY),'' ``Force Account Labor,'' ``Fungibility,'' ``Housing
Construction Cost (HCC),'' ``Line of Credit Control system (LOCCS),''
``Mixed Finance Modernization,'' ``Natural Disaster,'' ``Obligation,''
``Open Grant,'' ``Operating
[[Page 6656]]
Fund,'' ``PIH Information Center (PIC),'' ``Public Housing Agency
(PHA),'' ``Public Housing Project,'' ``Public Housing Assessment System
(PHAS),'' ``Public Housing Development,'' ``Public Housing
Requirements,'' ``Reasonable Cost,'' ``Reconfiguration,'' and ``Uniform
Federal Accessibility Standards (UFAS).'' Other definitions
specifically related to public housing development are proposed to be
placed in subpart F, which will address development activities.
``Capital Fund Program Fee'' is defined as the amount up to 10
percent of the annual Capital Fund grant under this regulation that may
be set aside for administrative costs for an asset management PHA.
These costs are associated with the Central Office Cost Center's (COCC)
oversight and management of the CFP. These costs include duties related
to general capital planning, preparing of the Annual Plan, processing
of LOCCS, preparing reports, drawing of funds, budgeting, accounting,
and procuring of construction and other miscellaneous contracts.
PHAs that have not converted to asset management may expend up to
10 percent of the Capital Fund grant on their administrative costs.
Administrative costs exclude any costs related to lead-based paint or
asbestos testing, in-house architectural or engineering work, or
special administrative costs required under state or local law, unless
approved by HUD.
``Reasonable cost'' is defined in the regulation as ``An amount to
rehabilitate or modernize an existing structure that is not greater
than 90 percent of the TDC for a new development of the same structure
type, number and size of units in the same market area.'' Section
905.314(g), modernization cost limits, states that a PHA is prohibited
from modernizing an existing public housing development that cannot be
modernized for 90 percent of TDC. The Office of Public Housing uses
other cost limitation standards for voluntary conversion and for
Section 18 demolition. For mandatory conversion (24 CFR part 972
subpart B), which relates to developments of 250 or more dwelling units
with a significant (15 percent) vacancy rate over 3 years, the cost
standard is whether it is more expensive to operate the development as
public housing than to provide tenant based assistance. For 24 CFR part
970, the description of major problems indicative of obsolescence
includes a cost standard of 62 percent of TDC for elevator structure
and 57.14 percent of TDC for all other types of structures. HUD is
requesting that the public consider these varying cost limitations and
provide the Department with comments on whether the standard of 90
percent of TDC, which is incorporated in this proposed rulemaking, is
the best cost limitation to use for the modernization of existing
public housing.
B. Subpart B
Subpart B would describe Capital Fund eligible activities and
ineligible activities. Section 905.200 lists the eligible costs, which
include, but are not limited to, development, financing, and
modernization of public housing projects; capital planning; preparation
of the annual statement; vacancy reduction; making units and common
areas accessible; nonroutine maintenance; resident self sufficiency,
security and safety; relocation and mobility counseling; costs for
approved homeownership programs; conduct of an energy audit when there
are not sufficient operating funds and the energy audit is part of a
new modernization program for energy efficiency, including the use of
Energy Star items; certain administrative costs; monitoring of LOCCS;
the preparation of reports; the new Capital Fund program fee that can
be attributed to the Central Office Cost Center; and emergency
activities.
This proposed rule would incorporate energy standards at Sec. Sec.
905.200(b)(6)(ii), 905.200(b)(14), 905.312(b)(1), 905.312(c)(3),
905.312(d), 905.314(c), and 905.316(e). The standards include those in
42 U.S.C. 12709 as amended by section 153 of the Energy Policy Act of
2005, Public Law 109-58 (these standards include the 2006 International
Energy Conservation Code and ASHRAE 90.1-2004), and the Energy Star
requirement for appliances in section 152 of the Energy Policy Act of
2005. In addition, Sec. 905.200(b)(14) of this proposed rule
incorporates energy efficiency standards from 42 U.S.C. 1437g(d)(1)(K),
as added by section 151 of the Energy Policy Act of 2005, which makes
it an eligible use of the capital fund to increase energy efficiency by
such means as the Secretary of HUD determines are appropriate. Public
comment is sought as to how energy efficiency should be measured, as
well as what specific uses of the Capital Fund would increase energy
efficiency.
Since HERA removed the authorization of the emergency set-aside
under section 9(k) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437g(k)), this proposed
rule would remove the regulatory provisions related to section 9(k).
Proposed Sec. 905.202 would list the activities and costs that
would be ineligible under the CFP. These include, but are not limited
to, costs not included in the PHA's CFP 5-Year Action Plan; luxury
items such as amenities beyond what is customary in the community;
costs that would be eligible but for the fact that they are in excess
of the amount directly attributable to the public housing units, when
the physical or management improvement will benefit programs other than
public housing; direct provision of social services; costs that are
funded by another source, so there would be duplicate funding; and any
other costs that HUD may determine on a case-by-case basis.
Proposed Sec. 905.204 would include regulations on funding for
emergencies and natural disasters. Under this section, HUD will look to
ensure, in both situations, that a PHA uses other legally available
funds, including unobligated Capital Funds, before using funds from the
set-aside for disasters and emergencies. Disasters and emergencies are,
however, by nature unexpected and unpredictable, so it is also
necessary for HUD to exercise case-by-case discretion to ensure that
disaster needs and other housing needs of the PHA's residents are and
will continue to be met. It should be noted that both HUD's 2009 (Title
II, Pub. L. 111-8) and 2010 (Division A, Title II, Pub. L. 111-117)
Appropriations Acts made a limited amount of Capital Funds available
for emergencies and natural disasters, and specifically excluded
Capital Funds from being used for Presidentially declared disasters
under the Stafford Act (42 U.S.C. 5121 et seq.). See also PIH Notice
2010-14, available at https://www.hud.gov/offices/pih/publications/notices/10/pih2010-14.pdf.
Former Sec. 905.10(b), Emergency Reserve and Use of Amounts, would
be removed from the proposed rule. The Capital Fund formula, which was
previously found in Sec. 905.10, is in Sec. 905.400 of this proposed
rulemaking. However, this proposed rule retains the procedures for
awarding emergency and natural disaster grants, if provision is made
for a set-aside for emergencies and natural disasters in an annual
Appropriations Act.
C. Subpart C
Subpart C of this proposed rule would include the CFP requirements
found in 24 CFR part 968 (public housing modernization) and 24 CFR
905.120 (penalties for slow expenditure or obligation of Capital
Funds), as those sections are codified as of the date of this proposed
rule. This rule would
[[Page 6657]]
establish CFP submission requirements for both qualified and
nonqualified PHAs, as defined in Title VII of HERA section 2702.
Submission requirements include, but are not limited to, the Physical
Needs Assessment (PNA), the budget, and various certifications.
The new requirement for project-based PNAs for all properties in
the PHA's inventory is intended to support effective property-based
planning and the transition to asset management. Completion of the PNA
will provide PHAs with critical information on the physical condition
of each project in its inventory and assist the PHAs to identify and
prioritize work items in the Annual Statement and the 5-Year Action
Plan. The proposed rule would require that the PNA be completed by the
PHA and be submitted to the Field Office at a time required by HUD.
The proposed rule would require that the other CFP submission
requirements, including the budget and the certifications, be submitted
in a format prescribed by HUD at the time that the PHA submits its
signed CFP ACC Amendment for its CFP grant(s). Except in the case of
emergency work, the PHA shall not spend Capital Funds on any work that
is not included in an approved CFP 5-Year Action Plan and any approved
amendments. Proposed Sec. 905.300(b)(5) describes HUD review of the
CFP submissions for compliance with the public housing program
requirements. The PHA's budget must be approved by the PHA's Board of
Commissioners, but does not require HUD approval. The CFP 5-Year Action
Plan, which is a component of the 5-Year Plan required under part 903,
continues to be required for all PHAs, both qualified and nonqualified.
Proposed Sec. 905.300(b)(8) would address performance and
evaluation reports. Proposed Sec. 905.300(b)(4) would govern other
formal requirements for qualified and nonqualified PHAs, such as the
requirement that the PHA consult with the Resident Advisory Board(s)
and conduct annual public hearings.
Proposed Sec. 905.302 would require PHAs to submit the CF ACC
Amendment by a specified date. Late submittal does not affect a PHA's
requirement to obligate and expend its Capital Fund by the dates
established by HUD. If HUD does not receive the signed and dated CF ACC
Amendment by the submission deadline, the PHA will receive the Capital
Fund grant for that year; however, the PHA will have less than 24
months to obligate 90 percent of the Capital Fund grant and less than
48 months to expend those funds, because the PHA's obligation start
date and disbursement end date for these grants will remain as
previously established by HUD.
Proposed Sec. 905.304 requires public housing developed or
modernized with Capital Funds to be operated in accordance with the CF
ACC Amendment. Under proposed Sec. 905.304(a)(1), projects developed
with Capital Funds must have a covenant requiring them to be operated
as public housing for a 40-year period beginning on the date on which
the project becomes available for occupancy, as required by section
9(d)(3)(A) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437g(d)(3)(A)). Under proposed
Sec. 905.304(a)(2), projects modernized with Capital Funds will have
an additional use restriction for a 20-year period that begins on the
latest date that modernization is completed, as required by section
9(d)(3)(B) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437g(d)(3)(B)). Under proposed
Sec. 905.304(a)(3), projects developed that receive Operating Fund
assistance shall generally have a covenant to operate under
requirements applicable to public housing for a 10-year period
beginning upon the conclusion of the fiscal year for which such amounts
were provided. In accordance with the ACC, existing Declarations of
Trust, and section 30 of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C.1437z-2), proposed
Sec. 905.304(b) imposes a HUD approval requirement on any potential
liens or security interests in public housing assets.
The requirements for obligation and expenditure of Capital Funds
would be in proposed Sec. 905.306. These requirements include the
statutory time limits on expenditure found in section 9(j) of the 1937
Act (42 U.S.C. 1437g(j)), as well as penalties for failure to obligate
Capital Funds in a timely manner. This section also provides
information on the criteria for requesting an extension to the
obligation deadline.
Section 905.308 would list federal requirements applicable to all
Capital Fund modernization, development, and financing activities,
including, but not limited to, relocation of residents, wage rates,
environmental requirements, section 504 compliance, and lead-based
paint poisoning prevention.
Proposed Sec. 905.310 would require that the PHA initiate a fund
requisition from HUD only when the funds are due and payable, unless
HUD authorizes another method of payment of such advances, which
includes working capital advances, or reimbursement as authorized by 24
CFR 85.21.
Proposed Sec. 905.312 would incorporate the design and
construction requirements, which are currently found in 24 CFR 941.203.
The standards in proposed Sec. 905.312(a) are similar to those in
currently codified 24 CFR 941.203(a), with the primary difference being
that the proposed Sec. 905.312 would require structures ``to be
consistent with'' the neighborhoods they occupy, rather than requiring
them to ``improve or harmonize with'' the neighborhoods.
Additionally, proposed Sec. 905.312, like currently codified Sec.
941.203(b), would require that all development comply with a national
building code in addition to the applicable state and local laws,
codes, ordinances, and regulations. The proposed rule also specifically
addresses accessibility requirements among the federal requirements
with which compliance is required at proposed Sec. 905.312(b)(4). The
proposed rule would apply design and construction standards to
modernization, as well as to development, in proposed Sec. 905.312(c).
In Sec. 905.312(c)(3), HUD refers to including cost-effective
energy conservation measures as identified in the PHA's most recent
updated energy audit in the design, rehabilitation and construction of
public housing development. The Department is seeking public comment,
particularly from PHAs, on what cost-effectiveness test(s) should be
used when deciding whether an energy conservation measure identified in
the energy audit should be implemented or not. Issues for public
comment include but are not limited to the following:
(1) The measurement basis for cost effectiveness; i.e., whether to
use the total cost of the energy improvement versus the incremental
cost of the energy improvement;
(2) Are opportunity costs figured into this calculation (e.g., the
incremental cost of the energy improvement versus the cost of various
alternative uses of the money);
(3) Do such calculations include any expected increase in energy
costs; and
(4) The period of time over which the cost of the improvement would
be realized, such as the manufacturer's estimated useful life versus
actual time in service.
Your comments will assist HUD to develop important guidance to PHAs
that will assist them in determining the most cost-effective energy
conservation measures to fund from among the many identified in the
PHAs' respective energy audits.
Proposed Sec. 905.314 establishes cost limits for public housing
projects, including details about how the TDC and housing construction
cost (HCC) limits are calculated. Modernization costs are limited to 90
percent of the TDC; if modernization costs exceed that
[[Page 6658]]
limit, the project will not be modernized. Also proposed in Sec.
905.314(c)(1) is the ability for PHAs to request a TDC exception for
integrated utility management, capital planning, and other capital and
management activities that maximize energy conservation and efficiency,
including green construction and retrofits, which include windows;
heating system replacements; wall insulation; site-based generation;
advanced energy savings technologies, including renewable energy
generation; and other such retrofits. HUD has the statutory authority
to grant such a TDC exception pursuant to 42 U.S.C. 1437d(b).
For TDC exceptions for integrated utility management, capital
planning, and other capital and management activities that maximize
energy conservation and efficiency identified in Sec. 905.314(c)(1),
the Department will require that the requesting PHA submit a detailed
list of the planned energy conservation improvements, an explanation
and justification for the proposed energy conservation improvements,
and the estimated costs for HUD review. In addition, PHAs requesting an
exception of the TDC will be required to submit to HUD an independent
cost certification from a third party such as a licensed accredited
architect. These materials will be reviewed by HUD and approved on a
case-by-case basis. The Department is seeking public comment on what
cost effectiveness test(s) HUD should apply when reviewing TDC requests
for this exception.
Proposed Sec. 905.314(h) sets administrative cost limits for
modernization at 10 percent of the annual Capital Fund grant, excluding
costs related to lead-based paint or asbestos testing, in-house
architectural or engineering work, or other special administrative
costs, unless approved by HUD. Proposed Sec. 905.314(h) sets the
administrative cost limits for development work with Capital Fund and
RHF grants at 3 percent of the total project budget or, with HUD's
approval, up to 6 percent of the total project budget. For a PHA that
is under asset management, this administrative cost limit of 10 percent
includes the Capital Fund Program fee. This limitation reflects the
priority HUD places on use of the Capital Fund for development and
modernization.
Proposed Sec. 905.314(j) proposes to reduce the threshold for
management improvements from 20 percent to 10 percent over a 3-year
period. Under the current CFP a large housing authority (a PHA with 250
or more units in management) could use as much as 50 percent of a
Capital Fund (CF) formula grant (i.e., 20 percent for management
improvements, 10 percent for administrative costs, and up to 20 percent
for operations) for costs not associated with physical improvements of
the development. The Department will not be able to fund the estimated
modernization needs (as determined in the Capital Needs of the Public
Housing Stock in 1998: Formula Capital Study) if such a high percentage
of the Capital Fund appropriation is used for purposes other than
modernization or development of public housing units. When CGP was
established more than 20 years ago, the Department established a
threshold to allow for 20 percent of the Capital Fund grant to be used
to fund resident activities and other administrative expenses needed to
support the physical improvements funded by the modernization program.
Since the initiation of the CIAP and CGP, other programs such as the
Resident Opportunities and Supportive Services (ROSS) program and
Community and Supportive Services, a component of the HOPE VI program,
have been established to fund services that enable residents to become
self sufficient and/or improve their quality of life. In addition to
these programs, section 9(g) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437g(g))
allows large PHAs to use up to 20 percent of a Capital Fund grant for
operating costs, while small PHAs have complete flexibility to use
their entire Capital Fund grant for operating costs (Sec. 905.314(l)
of this proposed rule). With this flexibility to use Capital Fund for
operations, it is no longer necessary to have such a high threshold for
funding management improvements.
Proposed Sec. 905.314(k) covers resident management corporation
(RMC) activities. RMCs are authorized under section 20 of the 1937 Act
(42 U.S.C. 1437r). Under section 20(c) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C.
1437r(c)), a PHA may provide a portion of its Capital Funds to an RMC
for the purpose of performing eligible activities (under certain
conditions, RMCs can be directly funded without going through the PHA
(see 42 U.S.C. 1437r(e)). The proposed rule would provide that the PHA
will not retain any of the Capital Funds unless the PHA contractually
agrees to do so with the RMC.
Proposed Sec. 905.314(j) provides for the HUD-approved use of
force account labor. High-performing PHAs would not require HUD
approval for this purpose.
Proposed Sec. 905.316 of the proposed rule establishes contracting
requirements. This section generally requires compliance with 24 CFR
85.36. Proposed Sec. 905.316(d) requires that, notwithstanding the
bonding requirements of 24 CFR 85.36(h), for each contract over
$100,000, the contractor shall provide a bid guarantee equivalent to 5
percent of the bid price plus one of five acceptable forms of bond
listed.
Section 905.318 of the proposed rule would require the PHA to
obtain a title insurance policy before taking title to any and all
sites and properties acquired with Capital Funds. Section 905.318 also
would require recordation of the deed as prescribed by HUD.
Proposed Sec. 905.320 would impose contract administration duties
on the PHA for work performed using Capital Funds. The PHA must inspect
the work and determine when it is acceptable, and shall pay a
contractor only for work that the PHA has inspected and accepted.
Proposed Sec. 905.322 would require that the fiscal closeout of a
Capital Fund project requires the submission of a cost certificate; and
an audit, if applicable. Proposed Sec. 905.322 also would require the
submission of a performance and evaluation (P&E) report that describes
the progress on open Capital Fund grants, which is currently required
by 24 CFR 968.330. If the PHA does not submit the cost certificate and
P&E report in a timely manner as specified in the regulation, HUD may,
after notifying the PHA, impose restrictions on the PHA's Capital Fund
grants. Proposed Sec. 905.322(c) would provide that the cost
certificate is also subject to audit. For PHAs that are exempt from
audit, HUD would review and approve the cost certificate based on
available information regarding the Capital Fund grant. Proposed Sec.
905.322(e) would provide that all Capital Funds in excess of the actual
cost incurred for the grant are subject to recapture.
Proposed Sec. 905.324 would require certain data reporting by
PHAs.
Proposed Sec. 905.326 would require PHAs to keep full and complete
records of each Capital Fund grant.
D. Subpart D
Subpart D would incorporate, in proposed Sec. 905.400, the
regulations that establish the CF formula, currently codified in Sec.
905.10, with the exception of reference to the emergency reserve fund,
which was removed by HERA, as discussed above.
The CF formula was initially established by final rule published on
March 16, 2000 (65 FR 14422), and that formula is not proposed to be
changed by this rule. Terminology would be updated to reflect the
change to asset management and project-level accounting. In April 2008,
PIC was
[[Page 6659]]
realigned to reflect the reorganization of developments into projects.
In order to avoid resulting changes in DOFA dates that otherwise could
have affected certain PHAs, Sec. 905.400 (d)(6) of this rule proposes
to freeze the determination of modernization need as of FFY 2008 and
then make adjustments based on changes in inventory. The end result is
that there is no substantive change to the formula or the resulting
allocation of Capital Funds, and hence the formula, which was
originally established through a statutory negotiated rulemaking
process, is presented here for the sake of completeness only and not
for public comment. However, HUD will accept comment on the
aforementioned technical changes reflecting asset management.
Since the Study of the Modernization Needs of the Public and Indian
Housing Stock, prepared by Abt Associates Inc., in 1988, the Department
has demolished more than 100,000 units of severely distressed public
housing and funded a significant amount of modernization in public
housing. Subsequently, the Department has already funded 10 years of
replacement housing grants for the severely distressed public housing
that was removed from the public housing inventory. Section 905.400(j)
proposes a transition from a 10-year-long RHF program to a 5-year RHF
program for PHAs that remove units from the inventory based on
demolition or disposition. The transition to a 5-year RHF program would
be effective in FFY 2011 for PHAs that removed units from the inventory
in FFY 2010. In FFY 2011, any PHA that began receiving RHF in FFY 2010
based on demolition or disposition that occurred in FFY 2009 and
earlier will receive the remainder of its first increment and be
eligible for a second increment. Subsequently, PHAs that are already
receiving RHF funding in FFY 2011 will not be negatively impacted by
the transition because they will receive the total 10 years of RHF
funding and will be eligible to receive RHF funding for units removed
from inventory for the sale of homeownership as described in Sec.
905.400(j)(1). Also, beginning in FFY 2011, PHAs will be eligible to
receive RHF funding for units removed from inventory for the sale of
homeownership as described in Sec. 905.400(j)(1) and be allowed to use
RHF grants to fund development of either public housing rental or
homeownership units. The Department is soliciting comments from PHAs
and the PHA interest groups on this proposal to change the RHF funding.
Proposed Sec. 905.400(k) provides for a performance award factor
similar to currently codified Sec. 905.10(j). The provisions of
currently codified Sec. 905.10(k) on eligible costs would be moved to
proposed Sec. 905.200.
E. Subpart E
Subpart E would address the use of Capital Funds for financing.
This subpart is reserved for the regulation entitled ``Use of Public
Housing Capital and Operating Funds for Financing Activities'' that is
the subject of a separate rulemaking. (See final rule published on
October 21, 2010, at 75 FR 65198.)
F. Subpart F
Subpart F would contain the development requirements, including
those related to mixed-finance projects. These requirements would be
moved to subpart F from 24 CFR part 941. Program requirements including
the limitation on costs and site and neighborhood standards are
described in Sec. 905.602. The Department has not made any substantive
changes to the site and neighborhood standards found at Sec. 941.202.
Definitions specifically related to public housing development are
found in Sec. 905.604(b). This subpart also proposes certain
deviations from applicable requirements as HUD is permitted to do by
regulation in the case of mixed-finance projects under section 35(h) of
the 1937 Act, 42 U.S.C. 1437z-7(h). Section 905.604(l), which pertains
to closing materials and other documents, and Sec. 905.604(m), which
addresses subsidy layering, are reserved to address the revised
regulations that are the subject of the rulemaking entitled
``Streamlining of Mixed Finance Applications,'' which was published as
a proposed rule in the Federal Register on December 27, 2006.
Development, with regards to homeownership, will be addressed by a
separate rulemaking.
G. Subpart G
Subpart G would state that the PHA may not pledge, mortgage, or
enter into a transaction that uses public housing assets without
written HUD approval.
H. Subpart H
Subpart H would address PHA compliance with Capital Fund
requirements, and HUD review and sanction for noncompliance with HUD
contracts and regulations.
V. Findings and Certifications
Paperwork Reduction Act
The information collection requirements contained in this rule have
been approved by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) under the
Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (44 U.S.C. 3501-3520) and given OMB
control numbers 2577-0157 and 2577-0226. In accordance with the
Paperwork Reduction Act, an agency may not conduct or sponsor, and a
person is not required to respond to, a collection of information,
unless the collection displays a currently valid OMB control number.
Regulatory Planning and Review
OMB reviewed this rule under Executive Order 12866 (entitled
``Regulatory Planning and Review''). This rule was determined to be a
``significant regulatory action'' as defined in section 3(f) of the
Order (although not an economically significant regulatory action under
the Order).
The rule would not have any direct financial impact on the level of
funding for the CFP, but has the potential to create some financial
transfers among program participants. However, the total amount of
transfer is estimated to be less than $100 million annually.
The rule would gradually phase down the dollar threshold for
management improvements, from up to 20 percent to up to 10 percent of a
PHA's CF formula grant over a period of 3 fiscal years. On average,
PHAs use approximately 8 percent of their Capital Fund grants on
management improvements, with many PHAs using considerably less and
large PHAs of more than 250 units using 9 percent. In 2008, $2.38
billion in formula funds were distributed to PHAs. If all PHAs were
using the full 20 percent permitted under the current rule, a 10
percent reduction in the management improvement threshold would
indicate that about $238 million would be reprogrammed for other
eligible activities and would constitute a transfer from one group of
stakeholders that traditionally received management improvement funds,
to other CFP eligible activities and stakeholders, without any impact
on funding. However, given that the actual rate of usage is below 10
percent, this program requirement would not result in any transfers.
The rule would also phase down the allocation of funds for the RHF
from a 10-year RHF to a 5-year RHF. In 2008, a total of 294 PHAs
received RHF funds. That year, 251 PHAs funded under the CF formula
received $97,936,944 RHF first increment funding, and 123 PHAs received
$112,825,095 RHF second increment funding. Five years after the
implementation of the RHF phase-down, the $113 million second increment
funding would be eliminated and redistributed by formula to all 3,138
eligible PHAs, creating a transfer, but
[[Page 6660]]
one only among PHAs. However, HUD has already funded more than 10 years
of RHF to assist PHAs that demolished over 100,000 units of severely
distressed public housing; thus, the need for RHF has significantly
decreased. The phase-down also grandfathers all PHAs that are receiving
first- or second-increment RHF as of Fiscal Year (FY) 2010, minimizing
the impact.
This rule, if implemented as proposed, would also have significant
benefits. This rule updates and consolidates the CFP regulations and
related regulations having to do with the use of Capital Funds for
development and modernization, as well as regulations for continuing
operation of low-income housing after completion of debt service. In
addition, the rule proposes to codify recent statutory requirements
enacted in HERA. The benefits of the rule such as regulatory
consolidation, program clarification, removal of obsolete references,
and enhanced efficiencies make the rule necessary. Although HUD
established the CF formula in 2000, HUD has continued to rely on CFP
requirements to the extent that these requirements were not superseded
by statutory requirements.
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act
Title II of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 (2 U.S.C.
1531-1538) (UMRA) establishes requirements for federal agencies to
assess the effects of their regulatory actions on state, local, and
tribal governments and the private sector. This rule does not impose
any federal mandate on any state, local, or tribal government or the
private sector within the meaning of UMRA.
Environmental Impact
A Finding of No Significant Impact with respect to the environment
has been made in accordance with HUD regulations at 24 CFR part 50,
which implement section 102(2)(C) of the National Environmental Policy
Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4332(2)(C)). The Finding of No Significant
Impact is available for public inspection between the hours of 8 a.m.
and 5 p.m. weekdays in the Regulations Division, Office of General
Counsel, Department of Housing and Urban Development, 451 7th Street,
SW., Room 10276, Washington, DC 20410-0500. Due to security measures at
the HUD Headquarters building, an advance appointment to review the
docket file must be scheduled by calling the Regulations Division at
202-708-3055 (this is not a toll-free number). Hearing- or speech-
impaired individuals may access this number through TTY by calling the
toll-free Federal Information Relay Service at 800-877-8339.
Regulatory Flexibility Act
The Regulatory Flexibility Act (RFA) (5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.)
generally requires an agency to conduct a regulatory flexibility
analysis of any rule subject to notice and comment rulemaking
requirements, unless the agency certifies that the rule will not have a
significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities.
This rule reflects the transition from PHA-wide accounting to an asset
management model, and therefore changes some of the language regarding
the CF formula to reflect the new accounting model. The only
significant change in the CF formula calculation is a proposal to limit
the number of years a PHA is eligible to receive RHF grants to replace
units removed from the inventory by demolition, disposition, or
homeownership, from 10 years to 5 years. The CF formula amount that is
freed up because of fewer RHF grants will cause an increase in the
amount of Capital Funds available to the remainder of the PHAs, which
includes a large number of small PHAs. Since most small PHAs do not
demolish or dispose of a significant number of public housing units,
reducing RHF eligibility to 5 years should benefit small PHAs.
Therefore, the undersigned certifies that this rule will not have a
significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities,
and an initial regulatory flexibility analysis is not required.
Notwithstanding the determination that this rule would not have a
significant impact on a substantial number of small entities, HUD
specifically invites any comments regarding any less burdensome
alternatives to this rule that will meet HUD's objectives as described
in this preamble.
Executive Order 13132, Federalism
Executive Order 13132 (entitled ``Federalism'') prohibits, to the
extent practicable and permitted by law, an agency from promulgating a
regulation that has federalism implications and either imposes
substantial direct compliance costs on state and local governments and
is not required by statute or preempts state law, unless the relevant
requirements of section 6 of the Executive Order are met. This rule
does not have federalism implications and does not impose substantial
direct compliance costs on state and local governments or preempt state
law within the meaning of the Executive Order.
Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance Number
The Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance numbers for 24 CFR parts
905, 941, 968, and 969 are 14.850, 14.872, 14.882, 14.883.
List of Subjects
24 CFR Part 903
Administrative practice and procedure, Public housing, Reporting
and recordkeeping requirements.
24 CFR Part 905
Grant programs--housing and community development, Public housing,
Reporting and recordkeeping requirements.
24 CFR Part 941
Grant programs--housing and community development, Loan programs--
housing and community development, Public housing.
24 CFR Part 968
Grant programs--housing and community development, Loan programs--
housing and community development, Public housing, Reporting and
recordkeeping requirements.
24 CFR Part 969
Grant programs--housing and community development, Low and moderate
income housing, Public housing.
Accordingly, for the reasons stated in the preamble, under the
authority of 42 U.S.C. 3535(d), HUD proposes to amend 24 CFR chapter IX
as follows:
PART 903--PUBLIC HOUSING AGENCY PLANS
1. The authority citation for part 903 is revised to read as
follows:
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 1437c; 42 U.S.C. 1437c-1; Pub. L. 110-289;
42 U.S.C. 3535d.
2. Revise Sec. 903.3 to read as follows:
Sec. 903.3 What is the purpose of this subpart?
(a) This subpart specifies the requirements for PHA plans, required
by section 5A of the United States Housing Act of 1937 (42 U.S.C.
1437c-1) (the Act), as amended.
(b) Title VII of the Housing and Economic Reform Act, Public Law
110-289, section 2702, amends 42 U.S.C. 1437c-1(b) to provide qualified
public housing agencies (PHAs) an exemption from the requirement of
section 5A of the Act to submit an annual PHA Plan. The term
``qualified public housing
[[Page 6661]]
agency'' has the meaning stated in section 2702(a)(3)(C) of Pub. L.
110-289. HUD will make available a list of the qualified PHAs on a
quarterly basis.
3. Revise part 905 to read as follows:
PART 905--THE PUBLIC HOUSING CAPITAL FUND PROGRAM
Subpart A--General
Sec.
905.100 Purpose, general description, and other requirements.
905.102 Applicability.
905.104 HUD approvals.
905.106 Compliance.
905.108 Definitions.
Subpart B--Eligible Activities
905.200 Eligible activities.
905.202 Ineligible activities and costs.
905.204 Emergencies and natural disasters.
Subpart C--General Program Requirements
905.300 Capital fund submission requirements.
905.302 Timely submission of the CF ACC amendment by the PHA.
905.304 CF ACC term and covenant to operate.
905.306 Obligations and expenditure of Capital Fund grants.
905.308 Federal requirements applicable to all capital fund
activities.
905.310 Disbursements from HUD.
905.312 Design and construction.
905.314 Cost and other limitations.
905.316 Procurement and contract requirements.
905.318 Title and deed.
905.320 Contract administration and acceptance of work.
905.322 Fiscal closeout.
905.324 Data reporting requirements.
905.326 Records.
Subpart D--Capital Fund Formula
905.400 Capital Fund formula (CF formula).
Subpart E--Use of Capital Funds for Financing [Reserved]
Subpart F--Development Requirements
905.600 General.
905.602 Program requirements.
905.604 Mixed-finance development.
905.606 Development proposal.
905.608 Site or property acquisition proposal.
905.610 Technical processing.
905.612 Disbursement of capital funds--predevelopment costs.
Subpart G--Other Security Interests
905.700 Other security interests.
Subpart H--Compliance, HUD Review, Penalties, and Sanctions
905.800 Compliance.
905.802 HUD review of PHA performance.
905.804 Sanctions.
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 1437g and 3535(d); Pub. L. 110-289.
Subpart A--General
Sec. 905.100 Purpose, general description, and other requirements.
(a) Purpose. The Public Housing Capital Fund Program (Capital Fund
Program or CFP) provides financial assistance to public housing
agencies (PHAs) and resident management corporations (RMC) (pursuant to
24 CFR 964.225) to make improvements to existing public housing. The
CFP also provides financial assistance to develop public housing,
including mixed-finance developments that contain public housing units.
(b) General description. Congress appropriates amounts for the
Capital Fund in HUD's annual appropriations. In order to receive a
Capital Fund grant, the PHA must:
(1) Validate project-level information in HUD's data systems, as
prescribed by HUD;
(2) Have an approved CFP 5-Year Action Plan;
(3) Enter into a Capital Fund Annual Contributions Contract (CF
ACC) Amendment to the PHA's Annual Contributions Contract (as defined
in 24 CFR 5.403) with HUD; and
(4) Provide a written certification and counsel's opinion that all
property receiving Capital Fund assistance is under a currently
effective Declaration of Trust and is in compliance with the CF ACC and
the Act.
(c) Informational requirements. Section 905.300 of this part
describes the information to be submitted to HUD for the CFP. HUD uses
the Capital Fund formula set forth in Sec. 905.400 of this part, along
with data provided by the PHA and other information, including, but not
limited to, the High Performance information from the Real Estate
Assessment Center (REAC) and location cost indices, to determine each
PHA's annual grant amount. HUD notifies each PHA of the amount of the
grant and provides a CF ACC Amendment that must be signed by the PHA
and executed by HUD in order for the PHA to access the grant. After HUD
executes the CF ACC Amendment, the PHA may draw down funds for eligible
costs that have been described in its CFP Annual Statement/Performance
and Evaluation Report or CFP 5-Year Action Plan.
(d) Eligible activities. Eligible Capital Fund costs and activities
as further described in subpart B of this part include, but are not
limited to, making physical improvements to the public housing stock
and developing public housing units to be added to the existing
inventory. With HUD approval, a PHA may also leverage its public
housing inventory by borrowing additional capital on the private market
and pledging a portion of its annual Capital Funds for debt service in
accordance with Sec. 905.500.
(e) Obligation and expenditure requirements. A PHA must obligate
and expend its Capital Funds in accordance with Sec. 905.306. The PHA
will directly employ labor, either temporarily or permanently, to
perform work (force account) or contract for the required work in
accordance with 24 CFR part 85. Upon completion of the work, the PHA
must submit an Actual Modernization Cost Certificate (AMCC) or Actual
Development Cost Certificate (ADCC) and a final Performance and
Evaluation Report (in accordance with Sec. 905.322) to HUD to close
out each Capital Fund grant.
(f) Financing and development. Section 905.500 of this part
regulates financing activities using Capital Funds and Operating Funds.
Section 905.600 of this part contains the development requirements,
including those related to mixed-finance development formerly found in
24 CFR part 941. Section 905.700 of this part describes the criteria
for the use of Capital Funds for other security interest. Section
905.800 of this part addresses PHA compliance with Capital Fund
requirements and HUD capability for review and sanction for
noncompliance.
Sec. 905.102 Applicability.
All PHAs that have public housing units under an Annual
Contributions Contract as described in 24 CFR 5.403 are eligible to
receive Capital Funds.
Sec. 905.104 HUD approvals.
All HUD approvals required in this part must be in writing and from
an official designated to grant such approval.
Sec. 905.106 Compliance.
PHAs or owner/management entities or their partners are required to
comply with all applicable provisions of this part. Execution of the CF
ACC Amendment, submissions required by this part, and disbursement of
Capital Fund grants from HUD are individually and collectively deemed
to be the PHA's certification that it is in compliance with the
provisions of this part and all other Public Housing Program
Requirements. Noncompliance with any provision of this part or other
applicable requirements may subject the PHA and/or its partners to
sanctions contained in Sec. 905.804.
Sec. 905.108 Definitions.
The following definitions apply to this part:
[[Page 6662]]
1937 Act. The term ``1937 Act'' is defined in 24 CFR 5.100.
Accessible. As defined in 24 CFR 8.3.
Additional Project Costs. The sum of the following HUD-approved
costs related to the development of a public housing project:
(1) Costs for the demolition or remediation of environmental
hazards associated with public housing units that will not be rebuilt
on the original site; and
(2) Extraordinary site costs that have been verified by an
independent state registered, licensed engineer (e.g., removal of
underground utility systems; replacement of off-site underground
utility systems; extensive rock and/or soil removal and replacement;
and amelioration of unusual site conditions such as unusual slopes,
terraces, water catchments, lakes, etc.). These costs are not subject
to the Total Development Cost (TDC) limit, but are included in the
maximum project cost as stated in Sec. 905.314(b).
Capital Fund (CF). The fund established under 42 U.S.C. 1437g(d).
Capital Fund Annual Contributions Contract Amendment (CF ACC). A
contract under the 1937 Act between HUD and the PHA containing the
terms and conditions under which the Department assists the PHA in
providing decent, safe, and sanitary housing for low-income families.
The CF ACC must be in a form prescribed by HUD, under which HUD agrees
to provide assistance in the development, modernization, and/or
operation of a low-income housing project under the 1937 Act and the
PHA agrees to modernize and operate the project in compliance with all
Public Housing Requirements.
Capital Fund Program Fee. The Capital Fund Program Fee covers costs
associated with the Central Office Cost Center's (COCC) oversight and
management of the Capital Fund Program. These costs include duties
related to general capital planning, preparing of the Annual Plan,
processing of the Line of Credit Control System (LOCCS), preparation of
reports, drawing of funds, budgeting, accounting, and procurement of
construction and other miscellaneous contracts. The Capital Fund
Program Fee is the administrative cost for managing Capital Fund grants
for PHAs subject to asset management, which is subject to the
regulatory limitation of 10 percent of the annual capital fund grant.
Community Renewal Costs. Public housing capital assistance may be
used to pay for Community Renewal Costs in an amount equivalent to the
difference between the Housing Construction Costs (HCCs) paid for with
public housing capital assistance and the TDC limit.
Cooperation Agreement. An agreement, in a form prescribed by HUD,
between a PHA and the applicable local governing body or bodies that
assures exemption from real and personal property taxes, provides for
local support and services for the development and operation of public
housing, and provides for PHA payments in lieu of taxes (PILOT).
Date of Full Availability (DOFA). The last day of the month in
which substantially all (95 percent or more) of the units in a public
housing project are available for occupancy.
Emergency Work. Capital Fund related physical work items that if
not done pose an immediate threat to the health or safety of residents,
and which must be completed within one year of funding. Management
Improvements are not eligible as emergency work and therefore must be
covered by the CFP 5-Year Action Plan before the PHA may carry them
out.
Expenditure. Capital Funds disbursed to the PHA to pay for
obligations incurred in connection with work included in a HUD approved
CFP 5-Year Action Plan. Total funds expended means cash actually
disbursed and does not include retainage.
Federal Fiscal Year (FFY). The Federal Fiscal Year begins each year
on October 1 and ends on September 30 of the following year.
Force Account Labor. Labor employed directly by the PHA on either a
permanent or a temporary basis.
Fungibility. As it relates to the Capital Fund Program, fungibility
allows the PHA to substitute work items between any of the years within
the latest approved CFP 5-Year Action Plan, without prior HUD approval.
Housing Construction Cost (HCC). The sum of the following HUD-
approved costs related to the development of a public housing project:
Dwelling unit hard costs (including construction and equipment),
builder's overhead and profit, the cost of extending utilities from the
street to the public housing project, finish landscaping, and the
payment of Davis-Bacon wage rates.
Line of Credit Control System (LOCCS). LOCCS-Web is an intranet
version of LOCCS for HUD personnel. eLOCCS is the Internet link to
LOCCS data for HUD business partners.
Mixed-Finance Modernization. Use of the mixed-finance method of
development to modernize public housing projects.
Natural Disaster. An extraordinary event, affecting only one or few
PHAs, but excluding Presidentially declared emergencies and major
disasters under the Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency
Assistance Act, 42 U.S.C. 5121 et seq.
Obligation. A binding agreement for work or financing that will
result in outlays, immediately or in the future. All obligations must
be incorporated within the HUD-approved CFP 5-Year Action Plan. This
includes funds obligated by the PHA for work to be performed by
contract labor (i.e., contract award), or by force account labor (i.e.,
work actually started by PHA employees). Capital Funds identified in
the PHA's CFP 5-Year Action Plan to be transferred to operations are
obligated by PHAs once the funds have been budgeted and drawn down by
the PHA. Once these funds are drawn down they are subject to the
requirements of 24 CFR part 990.
Open Grant. Any grant for which a cost certificate has not been
submitted and has not reached fiscal closeout as described in Sec.
905.322.
Operating Fund. Assistance provided under 24 CFR part 990 pursuant
to section 9(e) of the 1937 Act (42 U.S.C. 1437g(e)) for the purpose of
operation and management of public housing.
PIH Information Center (PIC). PIH's current system for recording
data concerning: The public housing inventory, the characteristics of
public housing and Housing Choice Voucher assisted families, the
characteristics of PHAs, and performance measurement of housing
authorities receiving Housing Choice Voucher funding.
Public Housing Agency (PHA). Any State, county, municipality, or
other governmental entity or public body or agency or instrumentality
of these entities that is authorized to engage or assist in the
development o