Revisions to Rules Authorizing the Operation of Low Power Auxiliary Stations in the 698-806 MHz Band; Public Interest Spectrum Coalition, Petition for Rulemaking Regarding Low Power Auxiliary Stations, Including Wireless Microphones, and the Digital Television Transition, 3622-3639 [2010-1216]
Download as PDF
3622
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
N.J.A.C. 7:27B–3.2. Sampling and analytical
protocol: acceptable test methods
N.J.A.C. 7:27B–3.3. Operating conditions
during the test
N.J.A.C. 7:27B–3.4. Sampling facilities
N.J.A.C. 7:27B–3.5. Source operations and
applicable test methods
N.J.A.C. 7:27B–3.6. Procedures for the
determinations of vapor pressures of a
single known VOC or mixtures of known
and/or unknown VOC
N.J.A.C. 7:27B–3.7. Procedures for the direct
measurement of volatile organic
compounds using a flame ionization
detector (FID), a photoionization detector
(PID) or a non-dispersive infrared analyzer
(NDIR)
N.J.A.C. 7:27B–3.8. Procedures for the direct
measurement of volatile organic
compounds using a gas chromatograph
(GC) with a flame ionization detector (FID)
or other suitable detector
N.J.A.C. 7:27B–3.9. Procedures for the
sampling and remote analysis of known
volatile organic compounds using a gas
chromatograph (GC) with a flame
ionization detector (FID) or other suitable
detector
N.J.A.C. 7:27B–3.10. Procedures for the
determination of volatile organic
compounds in surface coating formulations
N.J.A.C. 7:27B–3.11. Procedures for the
determination of volatile organic
compounds emitted from transfer
operations using a flame ionization
detector (FID) or non-dispersive infrared
analyzer (NDIR)
N.J.A.C. 7:27B–3.12. Procedures for the
determination of volatile organic
compounds in cutback and emulsified
asphalts
N.J.A.C. 7:27B–3.13. Procedures for the
determination of leak tightness of gasoline
delivery vessels
N.J.A.C. 7:27B–3.14. Procedures for the direct
detection of fugitive volatile organic
compound leaks
N.J.A.C. 7:27B–3.15. Procedures for the direct
detection of fugitive volatile organic
compound leaks from gasoline tank trucks
and vapor collection systems using a
combustible gas detector
N.J.A.C. 7:27B–3.18. Test methods and
sources incorporated by reference.
*
*
*
*
*
[FR Doc. 2010–1111 Filed 1–21–10; 8:45 am]
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
BILLING CODE 6560–50–P
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS
COMMISSION
47 CFR Parts 2, 15, and 74
[WT Docket Nos. 08–166, 08–167, and ET
Docket No. 10–24; FCC 10–16]
Revisions to Rules Authorizing the
Operation of Low Power Auxiliary
Stations in the 698–806 MHz Band;
Public Interest Spectrum Coalition,
Petition for Rulemaking Regarding
Low Power Auxiliary Stations,
Including Wireless Microphones, and
the Digital Television Transition
Federal Communications
Commission.
ACTION: Final rule.
AGENCY:
SUMMARY: In this Report and Order, the
Commission establishes a deadline for
wireless microphones and other low
power auxiliary stations to cease
operation in the 700 MHz Band. The
Commission also adopts an early
clearing mechanism by which 700 MHz
public safety and commercial licensees
can provide notice that they are
initiating operations in the 700 MHz
Band. In addition, the Commission
prohibits the manufacture, import, sale,
lease, offer for sale or lease, or shipment
of wireless microphones and other low
power auxiliary stations intended for
use in the 700 MHz Band. With regard
to users who are not eligible for, or who
do not hold part 74, Subpart H license
authorizations, the Commission waive
its part 15 rules for a limited period.
Finally, the Commission adopts certain
disclosure requirements under which
manufacturers, dealers, distributors, and
other entities that sell or lease these
devices must display a consumer
disclosure at the point of sale or lease.
DATES: Effective January 22, 2010,
except for §§ 15.216, 74.802(e)(2), and
74.851(h) and (i), which contains
information collection requirements that
have not been approved by OMB. The
FCC will publish a document in the
Federal Register announcing the
effective date.
ADDRESSES: You may submit comments,
identified by WT Docket No. 08–166,
08–167 and ET Docket No. 10–24, by
any of the following methods:
• Federal eRulemaking Portal: https://
www.regulations.gov. Follow the
instructions for submitting comments.
• Federal Communications
Commission’s Web site: https://
www.fcc.gov/cgb/ecfs/. Follow the
instructions for submitting comments.
• Mail: Filings can be sent by hand or
messenger delivery, by commercial
overnight courier, or by first-class or
overnight U.S. Postal Service mail
PO 00000
Frm 00008
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
(although the Commission continues to
experience delays in receiving U.S.
Postal Service mail). All filings must be
addressed to the Commission’s
Secretary, Office of the Secretary,
Federal Communications Commission.
• People with Disabilities: Contact the
FCC to request reasonable
accommodations (accessible format
documents, sign language interpreters,
CART, etc.) by e-mail: FCC504@fcc.gov
or phone: 202–418–0530 or TTY: 202–
418–0432.
For detailed instructions for submitting
comments and additional information
on the rulemaking process, see the
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION section of
this document.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: For
further information, contact Paul D’Ari,
Wireless Telecommunications Bureau,
(202) 418–1550, e-mail
Paul.Dari@fcc.gov, or Hugh L. Van Tuyl,
Office of Engineering and Technology,
(202) 418–7506, e-mail
Hugh.VanTuyl@fcc.gov.
This is a
summary of the Commission’s rules
noted in the Report and Order and
Further Notice of Proposed Rulemaking
in WT Docket Nos. 08–166 and 08–167,
ET Docket No. 10–24 and FCC 10–16,
adopted January 14, 2010, and released
on January 15, 2010. This summary
should be read with its companion
document, the Further Notice of
Proposed Rulemaking (FNPRM)
summary published elsewhere in this
issue of the Federal Register. The full
text of the Report and Order and
FNPRM is available for public
inspection and copying during business
hours in the FCC Reference Information
Center, Portals II, 445 12th Street, SW.,
Room CY–A257, Washington, DC 20554.
It also may be purchased from the
Commission’s duplicating contractor at
Portals II, 445 12th Street, SW., Room
CY–B402, Washington, DC 20554; the
contractor’s Web site, https://
www.bcpiweb.com; or by calling (800)
378–3160, facsimile (202) 488–5563, or
e-mail FCC@BCPIWEB.com. Copies of
the public notice also may be obtained
via the Commission’s Electronic
Comment Filing System (ECFS) by
entering the docket numbers, WT
Docket No. 08–166, WT Docket No. 08–
167, and ET Docket No. 10–24.
Additionally, the complete item is
available on the Federal
Communications Commission’s Web
site at https://www.fcc.gov.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
22JAR1
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
Synopsis of the Report and Order
Section of the Report and Order and
Notice of Proposed Rulemaking
I. Introduction
1. In this Report and Order and
FNPRM, the Commission takes action to
ensure that public safety and
commercial licensees can operate in the
700 MHz Band without interference,
while providing entities currently
operating wireless microphones in the
band with an opportunity to relocate to
other bands. In particular, the
Commission ensures that these devices
are cleared from the 700 MHz Band no
later than June 12, 2010, consistent with
the Commission’s long-standing goal of
making this spectrum fully available for
use by public safety and commercial
licensees, and the customers that they
serve in the band. The Commission also
authorizes, for the first time, the use of
wireless microphones, on an unlicensed
basis, by entities not currently eligible
to obtain licenses. The Commission
does this by waiver based on its
longstanding unlicensed device rules,
which have proved highly successful in
permitting the use of low-power
wireless devices. In addition, the
Commission adopts a number of
safeguards designed to ensure both that
consumers understand their rights and
obligations in operating wireless
microphones and that wireless
microphones are operated in
compliance with our rules and policies.
Finally, in the FNPRM the Commission
seeks to refine and update its rules
governing the use of wireless
microphones, seeking comment on a
range of issues concerning the operation
of these devices in the core TV bands.
2. More specifically, in this Report
and Order, the Commission adopt the
following requirements:
• The Commission prohibits the
manufacture, import, sale, lease, offer
for sale or lease, or shipment of wireless
microphones and other low power
auxiliary stations intended for use in the
700 MHz Band in the United States,
effective upon the publication of the
rules in the Federal Register, and adopt
related marketing and other
requirements.
• The Commission requires that all
low power auxiliary stations, including
wireless microphones, cease operations
in the 700 MHz Band no later than June
12, 2010, one year from the end of the
DTV transition.
• The Commission provides for an
early clearing mechanism that, to the
extent that a public safety or
commercial licensee will be initiating
operations in the 700 MHz Band on
specified frequencies and particular
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
markets before June 12, 2010, permits a
licensee to require users of low power
auxiliary stations, including wireless
microphones to cease operations 60
days after notice.
• The Commission stresses that the
operations of low power auxiliary
stations, including wireless
microphones, in the 700 MHz Band
must cease immediately if at any time
users of these devices cause harmful
interference to a 700 MHz public safety
or commercial licensee.
• With respect to unauthorized
operations of wireless microphones and
other low power auxiliary stations, the
Commission waives its part 15 rules for
a limited period to permit unauthorized
users of wireless microphones and other
low power auxiliary stations to operate
on an unlicensed basis under part 15
pursuant to certain specified technical
requirements—in the 700 MHz Band
until June 12, 2010, and in the core ‘‘TV
bands’’ until the effective date of the
Commission’s actions in response to the
FNPRM.
3. In addition, in this Report and
Order the Commission takes various
actions to ensure that consumers are
better informed about its rules and
policies concerning wireless
microphones, which should facilitate
compliance with those rules:
• The Commission establishes
disclosure requirements to make certain
that buyers of wireless microphone
equipment understand the limitations
on their use of such equipment. For
instance, manufacturers, dealers,
distributors, and other entities that sell
or lease these devices will have to
display a consumer disclosure at the
point of sale or lease informing
consumers of the conditions that apply
to the operation of wireless
microphones in the core TV bands.
• As part of the Commissions
consumer outreach plan, the
Commission will release consumer
publications, including a Consumer Fact
Sheet, that inform the public of its
decisions in this Report and Order and
of the need to clear the 700 MHz Band
so that the spectrum can be used for the
provision of new public safety and
commercial services.
• The Commission will work with
organizations whose memberships
include wireless microphone users so
that they help the Commission inform
all affected users of its decisions in this
Report and Order, particularly the need
to clear the 700 MHz Band.
• The Commission will assist
consumers, including those who have
previously purchased wireless
microphones that operate in the 700
MHz Band, by posting information on
PO 00000
Frm 00009
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
3623
its Web site and by making information
available from the Commission’s
consumer service representatives
through a toll-free number at the
Commission’s call center.
• The Commission will make
available via its Web site and its call
center information regarding which
wireless microphones are 700 MHz
wireless microphones, what options
may be available if consumers do have
700 MHz microphones, and how to
contact wireless microphone
manufacturers to obtain additional
information. Information concerning the
Commissions decision today will be
posted on its Web site at www.fcc.gov/
cgb/wirelessmicrophones.
4. Finally, in the FNPRM, the
Commission take the following actions:
• The Commission proposes to revise
its rules to provide that low power
wireless audio devices, including
wireless microphones, may be operated
as unlicensed devices under part 15 of
the rules in the core TV bands.
• The Commission proposes technical
rules to apply to low power wireless
audio devices, including wireless
microphones, operating in the core TV
bands on an unlicensed basis under part
15 of the rules.
• The Commission seeks comment on
whether, and to what extent, eligibility
for obtaining licenses to operate low
power auxiliary stations, including
wireless microphones, under part 74
should be expanded, and on whether
the Commission should revise part 90 to
facilitate wireless microphone use.
The Commission seeks comment on
possible longer-term approaches for the
operation of wireless microphones.
Consistent with the Commissions
broader efforts to manage this country’s
spectrum resources as effectively and
efficiently as possible, the Commission
here seek comment on possible longterm reform, based in part on
technological innovation such as digital
technology, that would enable wireless
microphones to operate more efficiently
and with improved immunity to
harmful interference, thereby increasing
the availability of spectrum for wireless
microphone and other uses.
II. Report and Order
5. In this Report and Order, the
Commission establishes a firm deadline
of June 12, 2010 (one year from the end
of the DTV transition) for wireless
microphones and other low power
auxiliary stations to cease operation in
the 700 MHz Band. The Commission
also adopts an early clearing mechanism
by which 700 MHz public safety and
commercial licensees can provide notice
that they are initiating operations in the
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
22JAR1
3624
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
700 MHz Band. The operators of
wireless microphones and other low
power auxiliary stations must clear the
band within 60 days after such notice.
In addition, the Commission prohibits
the manufacture, import, sale, lease,
offer for sale or lease, or shipment of
wireless microphones and other low
power auxiliary stations intended for
use in the 700 MHz Band.
6. With regard to users who are not
eligible for, or who do not hold part 74,
Subpart H license authorizations, the
Commission waive its part 15 rules for
a limited period to permit all such users
to operate on an unlicensed basis
subject to a number of conditions in the
700 MHz Band until June 12, 2010 and
in the core TV bands while the
Commission consider issues raised in
the FNPRM. In addition, the
Commission adopts certain disclosure
requirements under which
manufacturers, dealers, distributors, and
other entities that sell or lease these
devices must display a consumer
disclosure at the point of sale or lease
informing consumers of the conditions
that apply to the operation of wireless
microphones and other low power
auxiliary stations.
A. Low Power Auxiliary Station
Operations in the 700 MHz Band After
the End of the DTV Transition
7. In order to make the 700 MHz Band
fully available to public safety and
commercial licensees, the Commission
is revising our rules to clarify that low
power auxiliary stations, including
wireless microphones, will no longer be
allowed to operate in the 700 MHz Band
except under the specified conditions,
and for the limited time period, as
adopted herein. Specifically, the
Commission establishes a ‘‘hard’’ date of
June 12, 2010—one year from the date
of the DTV transition—by which all
operations of such devices by all users
(including unauthorized users) must
have ceased in the band. In addition, the
Commission will require that operations
of these devices cease earlier than that
date, pursuant to certain notification
procedures, in those areas where 700
MHz public safety or commercial
licensees are or will be entering and
operating in the band prior to June 12,
2010. Finally, the Commission
underscores that, if at any time users of
low power auxiliary stations cause
harmful interference to a 700 MHz
public safety or commercial licensee,
those users must cease operations in the
band immediately. The Commission
finds that this approach best balances
the interests of public safety and
commercial licensees to operate without
interference while providing entities
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
currently operating low power auxiliary
stations in the 700 MHz Band with a
reasonable amount of time to remove
their operations from the band and
relocate them to other bands. In
addition, the Commission outlines
below our consumer outreach plan to
provide users with information
concerning their use of low power
auxiliary station devices as they
transition from the 700 MHz Band.
8. Need To Clear the Band. Based on
the record, the Commission finds that
the Commission needs to be expeditious
in establishing time frames and
procedures for clearing wireless
microphones from the 700 MHz band on
our path to providing an interferencefree environment for new services in the
700 MHz Band, especially public safety
services that are used to protect safety
of life, health, or property. The
Commission finds that low power
auxiliary stations could interfere with
public safety and commercial base and
mobile receivers. Such interference
raises the potential for a disruption of
vital public safety services and
commercial services. As V–COMM
comments, low power auxiliary stations
can operate at similar power levels, and
are authorized at even higher power
levels (250 milliwatts), compared with
the power levels at which public safety
devices are expected to operate (200
milliwatts). These power levels
employed by the respective devices
pose a significant risk of co-channel
interference and would be strong
enough to disrupt the operations of both
public safety and commercial mobiles
and base station receivers in the 700
MHz Band. The risk of interference also
is present to commercial and public
safety systems when the wireless
microphones and other low power
auxiliary stations are operated at lower
power levels, including as low as 10
milliwatts. This risk of interference
supports the Commission’s
determination to prohibit operation of
low power auxiliary stations in the 700
MHz Band. In addition, interference
from low power auxiliary stations
would lead to relatively large ‘‘dead
zones’’ around such devices, resulting in
effective loss of coverage to commercial
and public safety mobiles and portable
devices. The Commission finds the
potential for such a result raises a
significant threat of interference, which
is particularly disturbing when
considering that this could occur in
public safety spectrum while being used
to protect the safety of life, health, or
property. In addition, the Commission
notes the potential for interference to
wireless microphone and other low
PO 00000
Frm 00010
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
power auxiliary station operations by
commercial and public safety
operations.
9. In addition to co-channel
interference, the record indicates that
low power auxiliary stations have the
potential to cause additional
interference, such as adjacent band
interference, due to out-of-band
emissions (OOBE) and intermodulation
interference caused by emissions from
multiple devices. These emissions and
intermodulation products may
potentially be strong enough to cause
interference to commercial and public
safety base stations and mobile devices.
Intermodulation interference can occur
when multiple low power auxiliary
station transmitters are combined or
used in close proximity with each other.
Thus, commercial or public safety
operations can receive interference at
venues where multiple low power
auxiliary station transmitters are used,
such as at concerts or sporting events.
V–COMM, for example, indicates that
interference can occur in a wide variety
of settings, and also discusses its own
experience with co-channel interference
in the 700 MHz Band caused by low
power auxiliary stations. This potential
for interference further supports
prohibiting the operation of such
devices, including wireless
microphones, in the 700 MHz Band.
10. Clearing the 700 MHz Band is
consistent with the Commission’s
previous findings relating to use of the
700 MHz Band in connection with the
DTV transition. When the Commission
in 2001 adopted rules for commercial
services in a portion of the 700 MHz
Band, it declined to grant a request filed
by SBE that the Commission ‘‘afford
continued secondary status to part 74
low power broadcast auxiliary devices
(such as wireless microphones)
operating in the Lower 700 MHz Band,
and to establish a new service in part 95
of our Rules to accommodate their use.’’
The Commission observed that insofar
that the ‘‘Lower 700 MHz Band will host
extensive broadcast use throughout the
DTV transition, it is unlikely that new
licensees will rapidly occupy the band
to the extent that users of the low power
broadcast auxiliary devices of the type
SBE discusses will have to immediately
cease all operation.’’ Thus, it
contemplated that low power broadcast
auxiliary devices would be losing their
secondary status and would have to
vacate the band upon completion of the
DTV transition in a particular local
market.
11. In addition, the Commission in
2002 expressly excluded from the 700
MHz Band wireless video assist devices,
which are another type of part 74,
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
22JAR1
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
Subpart H low power auxiliary station
device, because of the reallocation of TV
Channels 52–69 to wireless services,
including public safety services. The
Commission stated that ‘‘[wireless video
assist devices] will not be allowed to
use * * * [Channels 52–69] in the
UHF–TV band due to a recent spectrum
reallocation of those channels to uses
other than broadcasting.’’ Also, in 2006
the Commission determined in the TV
White Spaces proceeding that the new
low power, unlicensed devices under
consideration there will not be
permitted to operate on TV Channels
52–69. The Commission stated that the
spectrum ‘‘ha[s] been reallocated for
services other than broadcast television
and will no longer be part of the TV
bands after the transition.’’
12. The Commission concludes that
parties have had time to know, and
reason to believe, that authorized low
power auxiliary stations would not be
allowed to operate in the 700 MHz Band
at the end of the DTV transition. The
DTV Act was enacted over three years
ago, and the Commission, as noted
above, has on various occasions
indicated that the 700 MHz Band would
not be a permanent home for low power
auxiliary stations, including wireless
microphones. Further, a number of
manufacturers warned their customers
on their Web sites that, after the end of
the DTV transition, frequencies in the
700 MHz Band will no longer be
available for wireless microphone use
under the Commission’s rules. There
has been adequate lead time for low
power auxiliary station users, including
wireless microphone users, and
equipment manufacturers to anticipate
and take measures to prepare for the
reasonably anticipated consequences
resulting from the end of the DTV
transition, including the availability of
the spectrum for public safety and other
uses and the need for entities operating
low power auxiliary stations to vacate
the 700 MHz Band. Moreover, the need
to ensure interference-free operations in
the 700 MHz Band as soon as is
practicable, particularly for public
safety operations, compels the
Commission to act to prohibit further
use of the band for these wireless
microphone and other low power
auxiliary station users. Nevertheless, as
the Commission discuss below, a short
transition period may prevent
unnecessary disruption of wireless
microphone operations and allow an
orderly transition to other spectrum.
The Commission’s determination in this
Report and Order balances the
requirements of those using low power
auxiliary stations in the 700 MHz Band
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
with the needs of new 700 MHz
licensees to access the spectrum in a
timely fashion.
13. Transition Date. In order to
provide current low power auxiliary
station users a reasonable opportunity to
remove their systems from the 700 MHz
band, the Commission find that
allowing them to continue to operate in
the 700 MHz Band for a limited period
of time under certain conditions serves
the public interest. The Commission
finds that all entities currently operating
low power auxiliary stations in the 700
MHz Band must vacate the band by June
12, 2010. This deadline of June 12,
2010, coupled with the obligation to
cease operations earlier pursuant to
notice, as described below, strikes the
best balance between the needs of
public safety and commercial licensees
to operate without interference in the
700 MHz Band with the concern that
entities currently operating low power
auxiliary station devices in the 700 MHz
Band have sufficient time to remove
their operations from the band and
relocate them to other bands.
14. With respect to the timing for
requiring that users of low power
auxiliary stations cease operating in the
700 MHz Band, the revised rules
provide that entities operating low
power auxiliary stations may continue
those operations in the 700 MHz Band
as late as June 12, 2010, subject to the
conditions set forth in this Report and
Order. In setting June 12, 2010, as the
latest possible date for these entities to
transition from the 700 MHz Band
under the conditions adopted in this
Report and Order, the Commission
recognizes that low power auxiliary
station users should have a short period
to transition their operations not already
transitioned out of the 700 MHz Band,
which should prevent unnecessary
disruption of wireless microphone
operations. The record supports a
transition period for users of low power
auxiliary stations to remove their
operations out of the 700 MHz Band, but
commenters differ on the length of this
period.
15. The Commission finds that the
transition period and process that the
Commission adopts, which terminates
on June 12, 2010, is a reasonable period
for those parties that may need to
continue to operate in the band and will
ensure that this spectrum is cleared on
a timely and orderly basis for use by
public safety and commercial wireless
services. The Commission also finds
that these requirements, coupled with
the notice procedures described herein,
will adequately address any concerns
that the operation of low power
auxiliary stations in the 700 MHz Band
PO 00000
Frm 00011
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
3625
will cause interference to public safety
and commercial 700 MHz Band
licensees with the end of the DTV
transition. Although entities operating
low power auxiliary stations will have
until June 12, 2010 to complete their
exit from the band and their migration
to other bands where they would be
authorized to operate, subject to the
conditions the Commission adopts
herein, the Commission nevertheless
encourage such users to cease
operations in the 700 MHz Band as soon
as possible. In addition, the Commission
finds that the public interest is served
by applying the transition procedures
that the Commission adopts in this
Report and Order to users of low power
auxiliary stations that do not hold a
license. This finding is based upon the
Commission’s determination that the
public interest will be served by
allowing this use in this limited context
for the limited duration discussed
herein.
16. While the Commission agrees with
MSTV/NAB that low power auxiliary
station licensees authorized to operate
in the 700 MHz should be afforded some
opportunity to migrate out of the band,
the Commission cannot agree with the
time frame they suggest, given the
potential for interference with public
safety and commercial broadband
licensees and the clear determination in
Congress’s enactment of the DTV Act of
2005 that the 700 MHz band would no
longer be a broadcast band in the near
term. In addition, the Commission is not
persuaded that low power auxiliary
station licensees, many of which are
associated with high-power broadcast
stations that have had significant notice
of the need to vacate the 700 MHz band
on a timely basis, should have a
different and longer timeframe to vacate
the 700 MHz Band than other users in
the band, as proposed by MSTV. In
addition to the need to clear the band
because of the potential for interference,
the Commission is concerned that
adding another layer of complexity—
establishing a different set of band
clearing rules for a particular subset of
users—is likely to add significantly to
consumer confusion as well as to
undermine the Commissions efforts to
clear the 700 MHz Band. On this issue,
the Commission’s judgment is that
keeping a single, uniform nationwide
date, rather than adopting two separate
transition dates, is essential to clearing
the 700 MHz Band in a timely, orderly,
and effective fashion in a manner that
is equitable to all the affected parties.
The Commission also is not persuaded
of the need for a shorter timeframe, such
as a February 18, 2010, hard date as
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
22JAR1
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
3626
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
suggested by CTIA, Verizon Wireless,
and several public safety groups. As
discussed above, the Commission is
placing operating limitations on low
power auxiliary station users and
adopting notification procedures that
enable new 700 MHz licensees to clear
the band of low power auxiliary station
users in markets in which they will be
operating. Further, the Commission
notes that, based on the record and
publicly available information, it is
anticipated that there will be only
limited rollout of new commercial
services in the 700 MHz Band prior to
mid-year 2010. To the extent that
spectrum in the 700 MHz Band needs to
be clear of low power auxiliary station
use for the initiation of new operations,
which includes system testing or trials,
the Commission is adopting a clearing
mechanism that provides for a 60-day
notification process. Accordingly, the
Commission finds the additional oneyear period after the end of the DTV
transition during which these low
power auxiliary station users may
continue to operate in the 700 MHz
Band provides a reasonable amount of
time for those entities to migrate from
the band, yet also allows for the new
700 MHz licensees to access the
spectrum in order to provide new
services to the public.
17. Early Clearing. In addition to
setting June 12, 2010, for the clearing of
the 700 MHz Band by wireless
microphones, the Commission also
provides procedures for clearing low
power auxiliary station operations in
the 700 MHz Band prior to that time to
the extent that a public safety or
commercial licensee has initiated, or
will be initiating, operations in the 700
MHz Band in particular market(s) before
that date. Wireless microphones will be
required to cease operations before June
12, 2010, only after they have been
provided 60 days’ advance notification,
as set forth below.
18. The notification process will work
as follows. During the transition period,
which will end on June 12, 2010, a 700
MHz commercial or public safety
licensee may notify the Commission
that it will be initiating operations on
specified frequencies in particular
market(s). The wireless operations
initiated by the public safety or 700
MHz commercial licensees can include
system testing or trials. Upon such
notification, the Wireless
Telecommunications Bureau or the
Public Safety and Homeland Security
Bureau will issue a public notice that
will be available on the Commission’s
Web site and that identifies the affected
market area(s). Users of low power
auxiliary stations, including wireless
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
microphone users, in those areas must
cease operation within 60 days of the
release of the notice. The Commission’s
Web site will provide a central location
for the low power auxiliary station users
to find information on markets in which
700 MHz licensees are beginning
operations prior to June 12, 2010. In
addition, any 700 MHz commercial or
public safety licensee may, at its option,
notify any entity operating low power
auxiliary stations of its intention to
initiate operations on specified
frequencies in the market in which the
low power auxiliary station user is
operating. Upon receipt of such notice,
the low power auxiliary station user in
the affected market area must cease
operation within 60 days. For entities
that have already initiated such
operations, these entities may, upon the
effective date of this order, follow the
same notifications procedures,
triggering the same 60-day cessation
obligation for users of low power
auxiliary stations.
19. In the event that both of these
notice provisions are used to provide
notice to a particular user of a low
power auxiliary station(s), the user will
be required to cease operations in the
market(s) in accordance with whichever
notice provides for earlier termination
of such operations. This process should
place only a limited burden on public
safety and commercial licensees, which
have the primary rights to use 700 MHz
Band spectrum. Further, as noted above,
notwithstanding any early clearing
mechanisms adopted herein, low power
auxiliary station users that cause
harmful interference to a 700 MHz
commercial or public safety licensee
must cease operations immediately
consistent with the Commission’s rules
for secondary use. The Commission also
intends to be in continuous
communication with the public safety
community to ascertain the extent of
public safety use of the 700 MHz Band
to help ensure that public safety
agencies are able to operate free from
harmful interference.
20. Other Arguments. The
Commission is not persuaded by certain
commenters that the Commission
should delay the transitioning of low
power auxiliary stations and
discontinue our efforts to clear the 700
MHz Band of wireless microphones for
public safety and commercial use
because some LPTV stations, TV
translators, and Class A stations are
continuing to operate in the 700 MHz
Band after the transition. The
Commission need to establish
expeditious time frames and procedures
for clearing wireless microphones from
the 700 MHz band on the Commission’s
PO 00000
Frm 00012
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
path to providing an interference-free
environment for new services in the 700
MHz Band, especially public safety
services that are used to protect safety
of life, health, or property.
Considerations affecting broadcast
services other than full-power television
broadcast operations should not delay
the clearing of wireless microphones.
21. The Commission also declines to
adopt Nady’s proposal that our
transition plan should provide for the
negotiation of relocation. As stated
above, entities currently operating low
power auxiliary stations, including
wireless microphones, may continue to
operate in the 700 MHz Band until June
12, 2010, subject to the conditions set
forth in this Report and Order.
Accordingly, the Commission is
allowing them to operate in the 700
MHz Band for some time during the
transition period. These operators,
however, must accept interference from
other licensees in the band and must not
cause interference to 700 MHz licensees
during this transition period, and also
are subject to the other conditions the
Commission adopt herein, including the
requirement to cease operations under
the early clearing notification
procedures.
22. The Commission denies as well
the requests by WCA and PISC that the
Commission not provide a transition but
adopt a waiver procedure for licensed
wireless microphone operations in the
700 MHz Band after the end of the DTV
transition. The Commission finds that
the waiver procedures requested by
these parties are not necessary. First,
parties may always request a waiver
under the general waiver provisions in
our rules. Second, the Commission does
not find that a separate waiver provision
is warranted because of our
determination to allow a limited
transition period during which users
may operate low power auxiliary
stations. The Commission is making
clear in its rules that entities operating
low power auxiliary stations, including
wireless microphones, in the 700 MHz
Band may continue to operate on those
frequencies until June 12, 2010, subject
to the conditions adopted herein. Some
operations by low power auxiliary
station users in the band may be
required to end prior to that time under
the 60-day notice procedure that the
Commission is adopting. The
Commission therefore denies their
requests that the Commission adopt a
waiver procedure for authorized
wireless microphones and other low
power auxiliary stations operating in the
700 MHz Band.
23. Furthermore, the Commission
finds that the steps the Commission is
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
22JAR1
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
taking in this order sufficiently address
arguments raised by some parties that
there is insufficient spectrum for
wireless microphone users outside of
the 700 MHz Band, or that replacement
spectrum should be made available for
wireless microphone operations. As
explained elsewhere in this Report and
Order, the Commission is adopting an
approach that will permit wireless
microphone operations to continue on a
temporary basis in the 700 MHz Band
and in the core TV bands while the
Commission considers final rules on the
issues addressed in the FNPRM. Under
the first step for moving ahead under
this approach, the Commission is
waiving its part 15 rules to permit
unauthorized wireless microphone
users to operate in the 700 MHz Band
on an unlicensed basis until June 12,
2010, and to permit operation of
wireless microphones in the core TV
bands on the same unlicensed basis
until the effective date of the rules that
will be adopted in response to the
FNPRM. Under the next step, the
Commission proposes and seeks
comment in the FNPRM on specific
rules for operation of wireless
microphones under part 15 of the rules
in the TV bands, and the Commission
seeks comment on some expansion of
the licensee eligibility for part 74 low
power auxiliary stations. The
Commission also seeks comment on
possible revisions to its part 90 rules for
licensed operation of wireless
microphones. The FNPRM will allow
the Commission to consider the use of
certain spectrum outside of the 700
MHz Band by wireless microphones,
and provides a reasonable and efficient
path forward to examine the future of
wireless microphone operations.
24. Finally, the Commission
concludes that the steps the
Commission has taken in this Report
and Order are sufficient to address
concerns that the presence of low power
auxiliary station users operating in the
700 MHz Band would impede the
ability of 700 MHz commercial licensees
to comply with their build-out
requirements such that they should be
granted additional time to meet these
requirements. Given that the steps the
Commission take enable these 700 MHz
licensees to begin operating in areas in
the band based on the licensees’ own
timetables, the Commission finds that
these licensees’ ability to meet their
build-out obligations will not be
hampered by interference from low
power auxiliary stations, and the
Commission reject proposals to delay
implementation of 700 MHz
construction requirements. For these
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
same reasons, the Commission also
rejects MetroPCS’s argument that a
delay in clearing the band could
constitute a de facto modification of its
licenses.
25. The rules adopted in this Report
and Order with respect to the clearing
of the 700 MHz Band by June 12, 2010
and the early clearing procedures will
take effect upon the publication of a
summary of this Report and Order in the
Federal Register. The Commission finds
that there is good cause for departure
from the 30-day delay in the effective
date under the Administrative
Procedure Act. In this Report and Order,
the Commission is taking steps to
expedite the availability of
unencumbered spectrum for public
safety and new commercial licensees, in
order that such licensees will be able to
operate without interference in the 700
MHz Band. The Commission finds that
under these circumstances, a further
delay in the effective date of the clearing
procedure rules would be contrary to
the public interest.
B. Prohibition of the Manufacture,
Import, Sale, Lease, Offer for Sale or
Lease, or Shipment of 700 MHz Band
Low Power Auxiliary Stations
26. The Commission revises its rules
to prohibit the manufacture, import,
sale, lease, offer for sale or lease, or
shipment of low power auxiliary
stations for operation in the 700 MHz
Band in the United States, effective
upon the publication of a summary of
this Report and Order in the Federal
Register. The Commission finds that
this prohibition serves the public
interest because it will provide greater
assurance that the 700 MHz Band will
be made available to public safety and
new commercial licensees.
27. The Communications Act of 1934,
as amended, authorizes the Commission
‘‘consistent with the public interest,
convenience, and necessity, [to] make
reasonable regulations * * * governing
the interference potential of devices
which in their operation are capable of
emitting radio frequency energy by
radiation, conduction, or other means in
sufficient degree to cause harmful
interference to radio communications’’
and these regulations ‘‘shall be
applicable to the manufacture, import,
sale, offer for sale, or shipment of such
devices * * *, and to the use of such
devices.’’ The Act further provides that
‘‘[n]o person shall manufacture, import,
sell, offer for sale, or ship devices
* * *, or use devices, which fail to
comply with regulations promulgated
pursuant to this section.’’
28. The Commissions decision to
prohibit the manufacture, import, sale,
PO 00000
Frm 00013
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
3627
lease, offer for sale or lease, or shipment
of low power auxiliary stations that
operate in the 700 MHz Band is
necessary to ensure that new services in
this valuable spectrum will be provided
without interruption to benefit all
Americans. Public safety agencies are
already making use of the 700 MHz
Band, and deployment of additional
public safety systems is expected to
proceed at a rapid pace. Commercial
wireless providers are currently
preparing to deploy advanced systems
that will support new and faster
wireless broadband services, once the
spectrum is available at the conclusion
of the DTV transition.
29. This prohibition is a reasonable
corollary to the Commission’s decision
in this Report and Order to prohibit the
operation of low power auxiliary
stations in the 700 MHz Band
permanently after June 12, 2010, subject
to conditions that would require their
operation to cease at an earlier date.
Since low power auxiliary station
equipment will no longer be allowed to
operate in the 700 MHz Band after June
12, 2010, the Commission must also
prohibit the manufacture, sale, and all
other steps that would make wireless
microphones available for use in the 700
MHz Band. The prohibition on
manufacture, sale, and lease of devices
addresses concerns about the potential
for increased interference to 700 MHz
licensees, including public safety users,
by decreasing the number of devices
available for use in the band. For the
same reason, it also addresses concerns
about the proliferation of unauthorized
uses in the band. The Commission notes
that Shure, one of the largest
manufacturers of wireless microphone
equipment, states that it no longer
manufactures 700 MHz equipment for
use in the U.S., and that AudioTechnica, another large manufacturer of
wireless microphones, ceased
development of new 700 MHz
equipment approximately eight years
ago. In addition, allowing the sale or
lease of devices that can operate in the
700 MHz Band is inconsistent with our
goal of taking all steps necessary to
make this spectrum available both to
public safety and commercial licensees.
30. The Commission rejects
Sennheiser’s argument that the
Commission delays the implementation
of the ban on the marketing of devices.
The Commission neither agrees that the
lead time for implementation of the ban
is unreasonable, nor that the
Commission must wait for actual
interference to occur. As the
Commission discusses in this section, in
adopting the ban the Commission is
particularly concerned with the use of
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
22JAR1
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
3628
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
the spectrum at a time when the
spectrum is to be available for new
licensees and new services. Moreover,
contrary to Sennheiser’s assertions, and
as the Commission discusses elsewhere
in this Report and Order, the
Commission finds that sufficient notice
was provided indicating that the use of
the 700 MHz Band by wireless
microphones and other low power
auxiliary stations would no longer be
authorized. Elsewhere in this Report
and Order, the Commission finds that
entities operating low power auxiliary
stations in the 700 MHz Band must
cease operations of those devices in the
band after June 12, 2010, subject to the
early clearing conditions set forth in this
Report and Order. Therefore, it would
not serve the public interest to permit
the manufacturing and marketing of
equipment that can be used in the 700
MHz Band beyond June 12, 2010, and
earlier where the clearing mechanisms
the Commission are adopting are
utilized.
31. Consistent with the arguments of
Shure and Sennheiser, the Commission
does not prohibit manufacturers from
manufacturing low power auxiliary
stations, including wireless
microphones, for export. The provisions
of Section 302 of the Act, as amended,
which addresses, among other matters,
the prohibition of the manufacture,
import, sale, offer for sale, or shipment
of devices, are not applicable to ‘‘devices
or home electronic equipment and
systems manufactured solely for export.
* * *’’ Accordingly, the Commission
clarifies that its decision today to
prohibit the manufacture, import, sale,
lease, offer for sale or lease, or shipment
of low power auxiliary stations that
operate in the 700 MHz Band is not
applicable to devices manufactured
solely for export. Finally, the
Commission revises its rules to require
that any person who manufactures,
sells, leases, or offers for sale or lease
low power auxiliary stations, including
wireless microphones, that are destined
for non-U.S. markets and that are
capable of operating in the 700 MHz
Band shall include labeling in all sales,
marketing, and packaging materials,
including online materials, related to
such devices. The labeling must make
clear that the devices cannot be used in
the United States. The Commission
finds that this rule is consistent with the
public interest, convenience, and
necessity.
32. To protect consumers in the
United States, and to help ensure that
no wireless microphones and other low
power auxiliary stations that operate in
the 700 MHz Band continue to be made
available for use in contravention of our
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
efforts to remove those devices from the
band in the United States, the
Commission require retailers to remove
from display (including online display)
any low power auxiliary stations,
including wireless microphones, that
can operate in the 700 MHz Band, as
well as any marketing material that does
not comply with the requirements
adopted herein.
33. The rules relating to the
prohibition on the manufacture, import,
sale, lease, offer for sale or lease, or
shipment of low power auxiliary
stations that operate in the 700 MHz
Band will take effect upon the
publication of a summary of this Report
and Order in the Federal Register,
except the labeling requirement for
devices manufactured solely for export.
The Commission finds that there is good
cause for departure from the 30-day
delay in the effective date under the
Administrative Procedure Act. In this
Report and Order, the Commission is
taking steps to expedite the availability
of unencumbered spectrum for public
safety and new commercial licensees
consistent with the Commission’s longstanding goal of making the spectrum
fully available for those licensees.
Under these circumstances, the
Commission finds that a delay in the
effective date of the prohibition would
be contrary to the public interest. With
respect to the labeling requirement for
devices manufactured solely for export,
the Commission find that this
requirement should take effect 90 days
after release of this Report and Order
(i.e., April 15, 2010). This period
provides sufficient time for entities that
manufacture, sell, lease, or offer for sale
or lease low power auxiliary stations
that are destined for non-U.S. markets
and that are capable of operating in the
700 MHz Band to comply with this
labeling requirement.
C. Procedures To Modify Licenses
34. For the reasons set forth above, the
Commission concludes that the public
interest would be best served by
clarifying that entities operating low
power auxiliary stations, including
wireless microphones, in the 700 MHz
Band may continue to operate in that
band until June 12, 2010, but only under
the conditions adopted in this Report
and Order. Accordingly, through this
rulemaking proceeding, the Commission
hereby modifies the licenses of all low
power auxiliary stations that authorize
operation in the 700 MHz Band (i.e.,
698–806 MHz) to delete the
authorization to operate on this
particular spectrum, effective June 12,
2010. In the event that any low power
auxiliary station must cease operations
PO 00000
Frm 00014
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
prior to June 12, 2010 under the clearing
mechanisms the Commission adopts in
the Report and Order, then the license
relating to that low power auxiliary
station will be modified automatically
without Commission action to delete the
authorization to operate on the 700 MHz
Band effective on the date that
operations are required to cease in the
band. In taking this action, the
Commission implements its decisions to
ensure that the effective use of the 700
MHz Band by public safety and
commercial licensees at the end of the
DTV transition is not compromised, and
that these new licensees will be able to
operate free from interference by low
power auxiliary stations operating in the
700 MHz Band.
35. Most low power auxiliary station
licensees that are authorized to operate
in the 700 MHz Band are also
authorized to operate in a number of
other bands that are specified in Section
74.802 of the Commission rules. These
multiple band licensees may continue to
operate in other bands identified in
their licenses without further
Commission action. Those licensees,
however, whose current authorization
limits them in whole or in significant
part to operations in the 700 MHz Band
can be accommodated with the use of
spectrum from other spectrum bands
that are available for low power
auxiliary station operations under
Section 74.802 of the rules. Such
licensees may wish to consult with a
local Society of Broadcast Engineers
(SBE) coordinator to identify suitable
spectrum from the core TV bands that
are available for low power auxiliary
station operations under Section 74.802
of the rules. Once replacement spectrum
has been identified, as a matter of
administrative convenience, the
licensee should file an application to
modify its authorization to include the
identified frequencies. This will enable
the Wireless Telecommunications
Bureau (Bureau) to modify the affected
license in conformance with the revised
rules adopted in this order.
D. Unlicensed Operation of Wireless
Microphones Under Part 15; Waivers
36. The Commission concludes that it
serves the public interest to waive two
of its part 15 rules, to permit
unauthorized users of low power
auxiliary stations, including wireless
microphones, to operate on an
unlicensed basis under part 15 pursuant
to certain specified technical
requirements, in the 700 MHz Band
until June 12, 2010 and in the core TV
bands until the effective date of
Commission action taken in response to
the FNPRM. The Commission
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
22JAR1
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
anticipates that such unlicensed
operations in the core TV bands
pursuant to waiver will remain in place
only for a short period of time, as the
Commission intends to act
expeditiously on its proposal to
promulgate final rules that would
authorize these operations on a
permanent basis. Accordingly, the
Commission waives Sections 15.201(b)
and 15.209(a) of our part 15 technical
rules. These waivers will permit entities
that operate wireless microphones in
the 700 MHz Band without the required
license to continue those operations
subject to the band clearing mechanisms
that the Commission adopts in this
Report and Order, and permit them to
relocate their operations to the core TV
bands on the same part 15 unlicensed
basis. The waivers also will permit
operation of wireless microphones
outside of the 700 MHz Band without
the required authorization. The
operation of wireless microphones in
the 700 MHz Band under these limited
term waivers will be subject to the band
clearing mechanisms the Commission
adopts in this Report and Order. Thus,
all entities may continue operating
wireless microphones in the 700 MHz
Band until June 12, 2010, unless they
must cease operations sooner under the
early band clearing mechanisms
discussed above. During the temporary
waiver period, any entity that chooses to
operate a wireless microphone under
these waivers must comply with the
waiver conditions, including
compliance with specified technical
requirements that are identical to those
the Commission is proposing in the
FNPRM for the operation of wireless
microphones under part 15. See
Amendment of Part 101 of the
Commission’s Rules to Accommodate
39 Megahertz Channels in the 6525–
6875 MHz Band; Amendment of Part
101 of the Commission’s Rules to
Provide for Conditional Authorization
on Additional Channels in the 21.8–22.0
GHz and 23.0–23.2 GHz Band; Fixed
Wireless Communications Coalition
Request for Waiver, Notice of Proposed
Rulemaking and Order in WTB Docket
No. 09–114 and RM–11417, at paras.
23–24 (released Jun. 29, 2009) (granting
request for waiver of Section
101.31(b)(vii) to allow for conditional
authority under conditions that were
proposed as rule changes in the NPRM
portion of the decision).
37. Under these waivers, wireless
microphones may be operated as part 15
devices without a license in the 700
MHz Band under the conditions
adopted in this Report and Order, and
they can also operate in the core TV
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
bands. Operation under these waivers is
subject to the following conditions.
First, the wireless microphones must
comply with specified technical
requirements under part 15, which are
the same technical rules that the
Commission is proposing in the FNPRM
for wireless microphone operations
under part 15 (as set forth in Appendix
E, below). Second, the devices must be
certificated under the rules applicable to
certification under our part 74, Subpart
H rules. Third, the devices shall not
cause harmful interference and must
accept any interference received
pursuant to Section 15.5 of our Rules.
Finally, users operating in the 700 MHz
Band must comply with the conditions
for continued operation in that band
during the transition period, including
the early clearing procedures discussed
above. The waivers will be effective
upon the release of the Report and
Order.
38. Section 1.3 of the Commission’s
rules provides that ‘‘[a]ny provision of
the rules may be waived by the
Commission on its own motion or on
petition if good cause therefore is
shown’’ subject to the provisions of the
APA and its own rules. A waiver is
appropriate when ‘‘particular facts
would make strict compliance
inconsistent with the public interest.’’ A
waiver cannot undermine the purposes
of the rule, and there must be a stronger
public interest benefit in granting the
waiver than in applying the rule. As
discussed below, the Commission finds
that good cause exists to waive Sections
15.201(b) and 15.209(a) of our part 15
technical rules in order to allow
operation of wireless microphones in
the 700 MHz Band and the core TV
bands for a limited period.
39. The Commission is allowing
operation of wireless microphones
under these waivers to use a power of
up to 50 milliwatts. The waivers should
allow wireless microphones to operate
outside of the 700 MHz Band in a
manner that is largely consistent with
their current operations. While part 74
rules permit wireless microphones to
operate on VHF TV channels with a
power level to the antenna of 50
milliwatts and on UHF channels with a
power level of 250 milliwatts, two
equipment manufacturers indicate that
the actual power levels for most
wireless microphones operating in the
700 MHz Band are in the 10–50
milliwatts range. We also note that a
large majority of wireless microphones
are certificated to operate with a power
level of 50 milliwatts or less. These
appear to be the most popular devices
because the 50 milliwatts or less is
sufficient for most uses and extends
PO 00000
Frm 00015
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
3629
battery life. While some wireless
microphones operate at power levels of
250 milliwatts, it appears most of these
devices are used for professional
applications requiring a longer
operating range with a short duration of
operation, such as electronic news
gathering or movie production users
that hold part 74 authorizations. In this
regard, the Commission notes that
devices authorized under part 74 as low
power auxiliary stations are ‘‘intended
to transmit over distances of
approximately 100 meters’’ and may
operate with a power level of 250
milliwatts. The Commission anticipates
that wireless microphones operating up
to 50 milliwatts under the terms of this
waiver would transmit over a shorter
distance. Therefore, the Commission
believes that the operations that the
Commission is allowing under the
waivers will effectively accommodate
users that are currently unauthorized.
The Commission is not extending the
waiver to permit these wireless
microphone users to operate at power
levels higher than 50 milliwatts
because, unless operated on a licensed
basis pursuant to part 74 requirements,
use of these devices generally poses a
greater interference risk to TV band
licensees. Only Part 74 licensees are
permitted to operate their devices at
power levels higher than 50 milliwatts.
40. The Commission recognizes,
however, that there may be instances
where operation at a power level higher
than 50 milliwatts may be needed and
can be allowed without causing
interference. The Commission finds that
such instances should be evaluated
based on their individual facts and
circumstances to ensure that
interference will not occur. The
Commission therefore grants delegated
authority to the Office of Engineering
and Technology and Wireless
Telecommunications Bureau to modify
the limited waiver of the part 15 rules
on a case-by-case basis to permit entities
to operate wireless microphones at
power levels higher than 50 mW where
it can be shown there is no significant
risk of harmful interference to other
users of the spectrum, particularly to TV
broadcast service.
41. The Commission finds that good
cause for a limited waiver exists in this
particular case, given the totality of the
circumstances including the short-term
nature of these waivers and the need to
facilitate clearing of the 700 MHz band
for use by the public safety and
commercial licensees. For the same
reasons that the Commission finds good
cause exists for granting this waiver, as
discussed in this Report and Order, the
Commission has determined that there
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
22JAR1
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
3630
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
would be good cause under Section
553(b)(3)(B) of the APA, 5 U.S.C.
553(b)(3)(B), for establishing interim
rules that permit the same range of
operations as the waiver. The
Commission also finds that it serves the
public interest to provide access to other
spectrum for entities that are operating
wireless microphones in the 700 MHz
Band while this rulemaking is pending.
Our primary goal in this proceeding is
to clear all wireless microphones from
the 700 MHz Band, thereby simplifying
the process of making this spectrum
fully available for public safety and
commercial broadband licensees. In
order to attain this goal, the Commission
intends to have any wireless
microphone user, authorized or not,
transition out of the 700 MHz band and
onto other available frequencies no later
than June 12, 2010. Granting these
waivers will allow currently
unauthorized users that vacate the 700
MHz Band to operate in the 700 MHz
Band temporarily under the umbrella of
unlicensed part 15 operation. At the
same time, the conditions the
Commission imposes serve the public
interest intent behind each of the two
specific part 15 rules being waived,
which is to prevent interference to
authorized radio services. The power
limits, minimum co-channel TV
broadcast station distance provisions,
specific frequency operation, and out-ofband emissions limits established
herein provide safeguards to ensure that
the policy objectives served by Sections
15.201(b) and 15.209(a) are met. Finally,
the Commission notes that any
operation of wireless microphones
pursuant to the waivers is subject to the
Section 15.5 interference restrictions.
Taken together, these safeguards ensure
that any operation done pursuant to the
waivers will not undermine the
purposes of, and public interest
protected by, Sections 15.201(b) and
15.209(a).
42. The record in this proceeding
includes a number of comments that
describe the need for and the
significance of wireless microphones in
providing quality audio technology for
performances and programs in theaters,
classrooms, lecture halls, houses of
worship, stadiums, and other venues.
The Commission finds that temporarily
waiving these two rules in order to
permit the continued operation of
wireless microphones, including
wireless microphones that are used for
these purposes, pending our final
decisions of the issues raised in the
FNPRM will provide this Commission
with the opportunity to develop a full
and balanced record before it adopts
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
final, comprehensive rules that address
the operation of wireless microphones
by those entities that lack the required
license. In addition, the Commission
notes that some entities will be
acquiring new wireless microphone
equipment to operate in bands outside
of the 700 MHz Band to replace their
existing equipment, while some
equipment that operates in the 700 MHz
Band may be capable of being modified
to operate in the core TV band
spectrum. The waivers permitting
operations will allow at least some of
these users to make informed decisions
with respect to new equipment
purchases, or where applicable the
modification of existing equipment,
until the issues raised in the FNPRM are
resolved. The Commission emphasizes
that there are a variety of unique facts
surrounding grant of this waiver, and
the Commission does not anticipate that
the Commission will soon encounter
such a convergence of factors as these to
warrant the type of accommodation
afforded here.
43. While the Commission finds good
cause for granting the limited term
waivers, as discussed above, we stress
that these waivers are temporary and
that the granting of these waivers will
not prejudice the outcome of this
proceeding or otherwise limit the
Commission’s choices therein. Under
this approach, the Commission will be
able to compile a record and consider
more fully the issues and proposals in
response to the FNPRM concerning
currently unauthorized users of wireless
microphones, including whether to
expand eligibility for licenses under
part 74.
44. In order to address the potential
for interference from the operation of
wireless microphones in the core TV
Bands, the Commission requires that all
wireless microphones operating under
the waivers are subject to the same
technical limitations that the
Commission is proposing in the FNPRM
for the operation of ‘‘Wireless Audio
Devices’’ under part 15. These technical
rules provide for distances from existing
co-channel TV broadcast stations,
specific frequency operation, power
limits, and out-of-band emissions. In
addition, the unlicensed operators of
wireless microphones that operate
under the waivers will be subject to the
restrictions in part 15 of the rules. The
immediate and potential future harm to
current TV band licensees of continued
widespread use of previously
unauthorized wireless microphones
appears to be negligible, in light of the
conditions the Commission is imposing
on the waivers, including that the
wireless microphones must comply
PO 00000
Frm 00016
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
with the specified technical
requirements (consistent with those
proposed for part 15 wireless
microphone operations in the core TV
bands, as set forth in the proposed rules)
and that they must not cause harmful
interference to licensed TV band users.
The Commission notes that licensees
that operate low power auxiliary
devices under part 74 authorization will
still receive interference protection with
respect to wireless microphones that
will be operating through these
temporary waivers as unlicensed
devices.
45. Given the actions the Commission
is taking today, the Commission does
not adopt PISC’s remaining proposals,
including that the Commission provide
a ‘‘general amnesty’’ to certain
unauthorized wireless microphone
users. The Commission finds that
various steps that the Commission is
taking today appropriately address, on a
going forward basis, the issues relating
to the proliferation and use of wireless
microphones that have not heretofore
been authorized. Finally, the
Commission does not rule at this time
on PISC’s proposal to create a General
Wireless Microphone Service that
would be licensed by rule pursuant to
Section 307(e) of the Act. The
Commission does not address at this
time questions relating to the
unauthorized use of wireless
microphones prior to our actions today.
The Commission instead seeks to
address its concerns in the order that
considers the issues set forth in the
FNPRM.
E. Disclosure Requirements and
Consumer Outreach
46. Based on this record, the
Commission adopts certain measures,
including point-of-sale disclosure
requirements, to address concerns
regarding a lack of consumer awareness
of our rules, so that the Commission can
best ensure the operation of wireless
microphones and other low power
auxiliary stations in conformance with
the relevant policies and rules.
Specifically, the Commission adopts a
disclosure requirement for anyone
selling, leasing, or offering for sale or
lease wireless microphones or other low
power auxiliary stations that operate in
the core TV spectrum. Under this
requirement, manufacturers, dealers,
distributors, and other entities that sell
or lease these devices will have to
display a Consumer Disclosure, at the
point of sale or lease, informing
consumers of the conditions that apply
to the operation of wireless
microphones in the core TV bands
during the temporary waiver period.
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
22JAR1
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
This disclosure requirement will apply
until the effective date of the final rules
addressing the issues raised in the
FNPRM. In addition, the Commission
will implement a comprehensive
consumer outreach program that will
include a Consumer Fact Sheet and
other consumer publications, as well as
other steps on the part of the
Commission, to complement the
expected outreach and education efforts
on the part of low power auxiliary
station manufacturers.
47. Disclosure Requirement. The
Commission requires anyone selling,
leasing, or offering for sale or lease
wireless microphones or other low
power auxiliary stations that operate in
the core TV bands to provide certain
written disclosures to consumers. These
entities must display the Consumer
Disclosure, the text of which will be
developed by the Commission staff, at
the point of sale or lease, in a clear,
conspicuous, and readily legible
manner. In addition, the Consumer
Disclosure must be displayed on the
Web site of the manufacturer (even in
the event the manufacturer does not sell
wireless microphones directly to the
public) and of dealers, distributors,
retailers, and anyone else selling or
leasing the devices.
48. The Commission takes this step in
recognition that a significant number of
currently unauthorized users of wireless
microphones and other low power
auxiliary stations in the 700 MHz Band
may have to purchase new equipment to
transition into the core TV bands
pursuant to temporary waivers. The
Commission is intention in requiring
display of the Consumer Disclosure is to
make certain that these users
understand their rights and obligations
regarding the use of low power auxiliary
stations in the core TV bands. For
example, wireless microphone
purchasers will need to know that they
must not operate the device at a power
level in excess of 50 milliwatts or in
situations where it may cause harmful
interference, and that they must accept
any interference received from other
devices. The Consumer Disclosure
should help assure that purchasers of
low power auxiliary stations operate
their devices in a manner in compliance
with the Commission’s rules and
policies and thereby do not cause
interference to authorized radio services
in the core TV bands.
49. The Commission finds that the
only practicable way to ensure that
users receive this information is to
require clear disclosure at the point of
sale or lease, and on manufacturer and
distributor Web sites. A number of
parties in comments and ex parte filings
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
have urged the Commission to adopt
labeling requirements so that users of
wireless microphones and other low
power auxiliary stations will be aware
of eligibility requirements and other
restrictions for the use of those devices.
The Commission agrees with these
parties that disclosure requirements are
necessary to ensure compliance with the
Commissions rules and to help
consumers operate the equipment in a
manner that does not cause interference.
50. The Commission delegates
authority to the Wireless
Telecommunications Bureau and the
Consumer and Governmental Affairs
Bureau to prepare the specific language
that must be used in the Consumer
Disclosure and publish it in the Federal
Register.
51. There is more than one way in
which the point-of-sale Consumer
Disclosure may be provided to potential
purchasers or lessees of wireless
microphones, but, as discussed above,
each of them must satisfy all the
requirements set out above, including
that the disclosure be provided in
writing at the point of sale in a clear,
conspicuous, and readily legible
manner. One way to fulfill this
disclosure requirement would be to
display the Consumer Disclosure in a
prominent manner on the product box
by using a label (either printed onto the
box or otherwise affixed to the box), a
sticker, or other means. Another way to
fulfill the disclosure requirement would
be to display the text immediately
adjacent to each low power auxiliary
station offered for sale or lease and
clearly associated with the model to
which it pertains. For wireless
microphones offered online or via direct
mail or catalog, the disclosure must be
prominently displayed in close
proximity to the images and
descriptions of each wireless
microphone. This requirement will
remain in effect until the effective date
of final rules adopted in response to the
FNPRM.
52. The Commission will require
manufacturers, dealers, distributors, and
other entities that sell or lease wireless
microphone devices for operation in the
core TV bands to comply with the
disclosure requirements no later than
February 28, 2010, and the Commission
encourages these entities to provide
consumers with the required
information earlier. In this Report and
Order, the Commission is taking steps to
ensure that low power auxiliary
stations, including wireless
microphones, are cleared from the 700
MHz Band no later than June 12, 2010,
so that public safety and commercial
licensees will be able to operate without
PO 00000
Frm 00017
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
3631
interference in the band. As noted
above, many currently unauthorized
users of wireless microphones and other
low power auxiliary stations in the 700
MHz Band will have to purchase or
lease new equipment to transition into
the core TV bands, and the consumer
disclosure will provide information on
the operation of those devices in the
core TV bands. The Commission finds
that delaying the effective date of the
disclosure rules until some later time
would be contrary to the public interest.
53. Consumer Outreach. In addition,
the Commission finds that several
means should be employed to provide
as much notice as possible to users of
the need to clear the 700 MHz Band of
low power auxiliary stations, including
wireless microphones.
54. The Commission will release
consumer publications, including a
Consumer Fact Sheet and answers to
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs),
that inform the public of the
Commissions decisions in this Report
and Order. Specifically, the Consumer
Fact Sheet will serve the public interest
by explaining the need to clear the 700
MHz Band in order that the spectrum
can be used for the provision of new
public safety and commercial services.
The Consumer Fact Sheet will explain
that entities currently operating low
power auxiliary stations, including
wireless microphones, may continue to
operate in the 700 MHz Band until June
12, 2010, subject to the conditions set
forth in this Report and Order,
including the early clearing
mechanisms. The Consumer Fact Sheet
will provide information concerning the
early clearing mechanisms for the 700
MHz Band that the Commission is
adopting in this Report and Order. It
will also inform the public how to use
the Commission’s Web site to view
public notices that identify the markets
in which 700 MHz licensees are
initiating operations. In addition, the
Consumer Fact Sheet will provide
information concerning our decision to
prohibit the manufacture, import, sale,
lease, offer for sale or lease, or shipment
of low power auxiliary stations for
operation in the 700 MHz Band in the
United States. The Commission also
will provide on its Web site answers to
FAQs relating to this proceeding.
55. Commission staff also will
identify and contact organizations that
represent entities that are known to be
users of low power auxiliary stations,
including wireless microphones in the
700 MHz Band, including groups that
represent theaters, houses of worship,
and sporting venues. The Commission
will inform these entities of its
decisions in this Report and Order,
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
22JAR1
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
3632
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
particularly the need to clear the 700
MHz Band in order that the spectrum
can be used for the provision of new
public safety and commercial services.
56. Further, the Commission expects
all manufacturers of wireless
microphones and other low power
auxiliary stations to make significant
efforts to ensure that all users of such
equipment capable of operating in the
700 MHz Band are fully informed of the
decisions in this Report and Order.
Specifically, the Commission expects
these manufacturers, at a minimum, to
ensure that these users are informed of
the need to clear the 700 MHz Band in
order that the spectrum can be used for
the provision of new public safety and
commercial services. Manufacturers also
should inform users of wireless
microphones and other low power
auxiliary stations that they may
continue to operate in the 700 MHz
Band until June 12, 2010, but only
subject to the conditions set forth in this
Report and Order, including the early
clearing mechanisms. Further, the
Commission expects all manufacturers
to contact dealers, distributors, and
anyone else who has purchased wireless
microphones and other low power
auxiliary stations, and inform them of
the Commissions decisions in this
Report and Order to help clear the 700
MHz Band. Manufacturers should also
provide information on the decisions in
this Report and Order to any users that
have filed warranty registrations for 700
MHz Band equipment with the
manufacturer. The Commission also
expects manufacturers to post this
information on their Web sites and
include it in all of their sales literature.
In addition, the Commission urges all
manufacturers to extend their rebate
offers and trade-in programs for any 700
MHz Band low power auxiliary stations,
including wireless microphones, and
widely publicize these programs to
ensure that all users of wireless
microphones are fully informed. To the
extent manufacturers do not offer a
rebate or trade-in program for 700 MHz
Band low power auxiliary stations, the
Commission strongly encourage them to
create or re-establish such programs. In
contacting dealers and distributors, the
Commission expects manufacturers to
inform these entities that they should:
(1) Inform all customers who have
purchased low power auxiliary stations,
including wireless microphones, that
are capable of operating in the 700 MHz
Band of our decision to clear the 700
MHz Band of such devices; (2) post such
and (4) provide information in sales
literature, including on their Web sites,
on the availability of any manufacturer
rebate offerings and trade-in programs
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
related to low power auxiliary stations
operating in the 700 MHz Band; and
that they must comply with the
disclosure requirements that we are
adopting in this Report and Order.
III. Procedural Matters
Final Regulatory Flexibility Act Analysis
57. As required by the Regulatory
Flexibility Act of 1980 (‘‘RFA’’), the
Commission has prepared a Final
Regulatory Flexibility Analysis
(‘‘FRFA’’) relating to this Report and
Order. Although Section 213 of the
Consolidated Appropriations Act 2000
provides that the RFA shall not apply to
the rules and competitive bidding
procedures for frequencies in the 746–
806 MHz Band, the Commission
nevertheless believes that it would serve
the public interest to analyze the
possible significant economic impact of
the policy and rule changes in this band
on small entities. Accordingly, the
FRFA includes an analysis of this
impact in connection with all spectrum
that falls within the scope of the Report
and Order, including spectrum in the
746–806 MHz Band.
Final Regulatory Flexibility Analysis
58. As required by the Regulatory
Flexibility Act of 1980, as amended
(RFA), the Federal Communications
Commission (Commission) included an
Initial Regulatory Flexibility Analysis
(IRFA) of the possible significant
economic impact on a substantial
number of small entities of the policies
and rules considered in the Notice in
WT Docket No. 08–166 and WT Docket
No. 08–167. The Commission sought
written public comment on the Notice,
including comment on the IRFA. This
Final Regulatory Flexibility Analysis
(FRFA) conforms to the RFA.
59. Although Section 213 of the
Consolidated Appropriations Act of
2000 provides that the RFA shall not
apply to the rules and competitive
bidding procedures for frequencies in
the 746–806 MHz Band, the
Commission believes that it would serve
the public interest to analyze the
possible significant economic impact of
the proposed policy and rule changes in
this band on small entities. Accordingly,
this FRFA contains an analysis of this
impact in connection with all spectrum
that falls within the scope of the Report
and Order, including spectrum in the
746–806 MHz Band.
A. Need for, and Objectives of, the Rules
60. As noted in the Report and Order,
the DTV Act set a firm date by which
the 700 MHz Band (698–806 MHz),
currently occupied by television
PO 00000
Frm 00018
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
broadcasters in TV Channels 52–69,
must be vacated to allow for use of the
spectrum by public safety and
commercial wireless services. In the
DTV Delay Act, which was enacted on
February 11, 2009, Congress extended
the DTV transition deadline from
February 17, 2009, to June 12, 2009. In
the Report and Order, the Commission
takes several actions relating to the
operation of low power auxiliary
stations, including wireless
microphones, in the 700 MHz Band, that
are designed to ensure that these
devices are cleared from the 700 MHz
Band in order that, consistent with the
Commission’s long-standing goals, this
spectrum is made fully available for use
by the public safety and commercial
licensees, and the customers that they
serve, in the band following the DTV
transition.
61. In the Report and Order, the
Commission determines that entities
currently operating part 74 low power
auxiliary stations, including wireless
microphones, in the 700 MHz Band will
not have the right to operate on those
frequencies except pursuant to certain
specified conditions and only for a
limited transition period of no more
than one year from end of the DTV
transition (June 12, 2010). In adopting
this transition period, the Commission
seeks to balance the needs of public
safety and commercial licensees to
operate without interference in the 700
MHz Band with the concern that entities
currently operating low power auxiliary
stations in the 700 MHz Band have
sufficient time to remove their
operations from the band and relocate to
other bands. Furthermore, in certain
areas, it may be necessary to end the
transitional operations of low power
auxiliary stations in the 700 MHz Band
prior to that time, where public safety
and commercial licensees are entering
the 700 MHz Band. Specifically, to the
extent that a 700 MHz public safety or
commercial licensee chooses to notify
the Commission that it will be initiating
operations on specified frequencies in
particular market(s), the Commission
will issue a public notice to inform
users of low power auxiliary stations in
the 700 MHz Band in those market(s)
that they will be required to cease
operations within 60 days after such
notice is issued. Alternatively, any 700
MHz public safety or commercial
licensee may, at its option, notify any
user of low power auxiliary stations of
its intention to initiate operations on
specified frequencies in the market in
which the low power auxiliary station
user is operating. Upon receipt of such
notice, the entity operating low power
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
22JAR1
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
auxiliary stations in the affected market
area must cease operation within 60
days. Finally, the Report and Order
underscores that if, at any time during
this transition period, users of low
power auxiliary stations cause harmful
interference to a 700 MHz public safety
or commercial licensee, those users
must cease operations in the band
immediately.
62. Through this determination in the
Report and Order, the Commission is
acting to ensure that these low power
auxiliary stations are cleared from the
700 MHz Band in order to make this
spectrum fully available for use by the
public safety and commercial licensees.
This determination respecting operation
of wireless microphones in the 700 MHz
Band also is consistent with the
Commission’s previous concerns about
the potential for interference in the band
because low power auxiliary stations
could interfere with public safety and
commercial base and mobile receivers.
Such interference raises the potential for
a disruption of vital public safety
services and commercial services.
63. Consistent with the Commission’s
goal of ensuring that 700 MHz Band
spectrum is available for public safety
and commercial users following the
DTV transition, the Report and Order
prohibits the manufacture, import, sale,
offer for sale, or shipment of low power
auxiliary stations designed to operate in
the 700 MHz Band in the United States
at any time following the publication of
a summary of the Report and Order in
the Federal Register. The Report and
Order adopts additional marketing and
labeling requirements designed to
prevent the continued sale and
distribution of low power auxiliary
stations that operate in the 700 MHz
Band. This prohibition is not applicable
to devices manufactured solely for
export. The prohibition on manufacture,
import, sale, and shipment of low power
auxiliary stations designed to operate in
the 700 MHz Band in the United States
serves the public interest by providing
greater assurance that the 700 MHz
Band will be made available to public
safety and new commercial licensees.
The Commission finds that good cause
exists to have this prohibition take effect
on less than 30 days notice in order to
expedite the availability of
unencumbered spectrum for public
safety and new commercial licensees
consistent with the statutory directive
that the DTV transition end as of June
12, 2009.
64. The Report and Order also
modifies the licenses of all low power
auxiliary station licensees that currently
are authorized to operate in the 700
MHz Band, removing any part of the
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
authorization pertaining to the band,
subject to the condition that if a licensee
is unable to cease operations in the band
by that date, it may continue to operate
under its existing authorization within
the transition limitations adopted in the
Report and Order. The Commission
takes this action to ensure that the
effective use of the 700 MHz Band by
public safety and commercial licensees
after the end of the DTV transition is not
compromised, and that these new
licensees will be able to operate free
from interference by low power
auxiliary stations operating in the 700
MHz Band. The Commission also adopts
procedures whereby existing low power
auxiliary station licensees currently
operating in the 700 MHz Band can
have their licenses modified should it
be necessary to add to their
authorizations other spectrum bands
that are available for low power
auxiliary station operations under the
rules.
B. Summary of Significant Issues Raised
by Public Comments in Response to the
IRFA
65. Nady Systems, Inc. (Nady)
indicates that its comments also address
the IRFA. In its comments, Nady
addresses the suggestion by PISC that
the Commission should order all
wireless microphone manufacturers that
engaged in illegal marketing to pay the
cost of replacing microphone systems
for those wireless microphone operators
required to cease operation in the 700
MHz Band after the end of the DTV
transition. Nady comments that a
gradual migration of wireless
microphone users out of the 700 MHz
Band strikes a reasonable balance that
protects competing interests, and
comments that the Commission should
provide a transition that includes
voluntary negotiations between parties.
According to Nady, the majority of
wireless microphone manufacturers are
‘‘small entities’’ which ‘‘would go
bankrupt if they had to finance
migration of all wireless microphones
operating in the 700 MHz Band.’’ Nady
also comments that wireless
microphones will be migrating to the
‘‘white spaces’’ below the 700 MHz
Band, and that these microphones
require protection from interference by
emerging technologies in the white
spaces. A number of commenters,
including Nady, argue that a delay in
the effective date of the ban is needed
to prevent unnecessary disruption of
operations and costs, and the
Commission has adopted a short time
period for low power auxiliary station
users to transition their operations out
of the 700 MHz Band. Many
PO 00000
Frm 00019
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
3633
commenters addressed issues regarding
the use of wireless microphones without
the required license.
C. Description and Estimate of the
Number of Small Entities to Which the
Rules Will Apply
66. The RFA directs agencies to
provide a description of, and, where
feasible, an estimate of, the number of
small entities that may be affected by
the proposed rules, if adopted. The RFA
generally defines the term ‘‘small entity’’
as having the same meaning as the terms
‘‘small business,’’ ‘‘small organization,’’
and ‘‘small governmental jurisdiction.’’
In addition, the term ‘‘small business’’
has the same meaning as the term ‘‘small
business concern’’ under the Small
Business Act. A ‘‘small business
concern’’ is one which: (1) Is
independently owned and operated; (2)
is not dominant in its field of operation;
and (3) satisfies any additional criteria
established by the Small Business
Administration (SBA).
67. When identifying small entities
that could be affected by the
Commission’s new rules, this FRFA
provides information describing the
number of small entities that currently
hold low power auxiliary station
licenses, as well as estimates of the
number of small entities that currently
manufacture low power auxiliary
stations. In order to analyze the total
number of potentially affected small
entities, the Commission estimates the
number of small entities that may be
affected by the rule changes adopted in
the Report and Order.
68. Nationwide, there are a total of
approximately 29.6 million small
businesses, according to the SBA. A
‘‘small organization’’ is generally ‘‘any
not-for-profit enterprise which is
independently owned and operated and
is not dominant in its field.’’
Nationwide, as of 2002, there were
approximately 1.6 million small
organizations. The term ‘‘small
governmental jurisdiction’’ is defined
generally as ‘‘governments of cities,
towns, townships, villages, school
districts, or special districts, with a
population of less than fifty thousand.’’
Census Bureau data for 2002 indicate
that there were 87,525 local
governmental jurisdictions in the
United States. The Commission
estimates that, of this total, 84,377
entities were ‘‘small governmental
jurisdictions.’’ Thus, the Commission
estimates that most governmental
jurisdictions are small.
69. In the Report and Order, the
Commission concludes that low power
auxiliary stations authorized under part
74 of our rules—including wireless
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
22JAR1
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
3634
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
microphones—will not be permitted to
operate in the 700 MHz Band after the
DTV transition. The Commission also
concludes to prohibit the manufacture,
import, sale, offer for sale, or shipment
of devices that operate as low power
auxiliary stations in the 700 MHz Band,
effective upon the publication of a
summary of the Report and Order in the
Federal Register. Under Section 74.832
of the Commission’s rules, only certain
entities may be issued licenses
authorizing the use of low power
auxiliary stations. In particular, these
entities fall within the following
categories: (1) Licensees of AM, FM, TV,
or International broadcast stations or
low power TV stations; (2) broadcast
network entities; (3) certain cable
television system operators; (4) motion
picture and television program
producers as defined in the rules; and
(5) certain entities with specified
interests in Broadband Radio Service
(BRS) Educational Broadcast Service
(EBS) licenses, i.e., BRS licensees
(formerly licensees and conditional
licensees of stations in the Multipoint
Distribution Service and Multi-channel
Multipoint Distribution Service), or
entities that hold an executed lease
agreement with a BRS licensee or
conditional licensee or entities that hold
an executed lease agreement with an
Educational Broadcast Service (formerly
Instructional Television Fixed Service)
licensee or permittee.
70. Radio Stations. This Economic
Census category ‘‘comprises
establishments primarily engaged in
broadcasting aural programs by radio to
the public. Programming may originate
in their own studio, from an affiliated
network, or from external sources.’’ The
SBA has established a small business
size standard for this category, which is:
such firms having $7.0 million or less in
annual receipts. According to
Commission staff review of BIA
Publications, Inc.’s Master Access Radio
Analyzer Database on March 31, 2005,
about 10,840 (95%) of 11,410
commercial radio stations had revenues
of $6 million or less. Therefore, the
majority of such entities are small
entities.
71. The Commission notes, however,
that in assessing whether a business
concern qualifies as small under the
above size standard, business
affiliations must be included. In
addition, to be determined to be a ‘‘small
business,’’ the entity may not be
dominant in its field of operation. The
Commission notes that it is difficult at
times to assess these criteria in the
context of media entities, and our
estimate of small businesses may
therefore be over-inclusive.
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
72. Television Broadcasting. The
Census Bureau defines this category as
follows: ‘‘This industry comprises
establishments primarily engaged in
broadcasting images together with
sound. These establishments operate
television broadcasting studios and
facilities for the programming and
transmission of programs to the public.’’
The SBA has created a small business
size standard for Television
Broadcasting entities, which is: such
firms having $14.0 million or less in
annual receipts. The Commission has
estimated the number of licensed
commercial television stations to be
1,379. In addition, according to
Commission staff review of the BIA
Publications, Inc.’s Master Access
Television Analyzer Database on March
30, 2007, about 986 of an estimated
1,374 commercial television stations (or
approximately 72 percent) had revenues
of $13 million or less. The Commission
therefore estimates that the majority of
commercial television broadcasters are
small entities.
73. The Commission notes, however,
that in assessing whether a business
concern qualifies as small under the
above definition, business (control)
affiliations must be included. The
Commission’s estimate, therefore, likely
overstates the number of small entities
that might be affected by our action,
because the revenue figure on which it
is based does not include or aggregate
revenues from affiliated companies. In
addition, an element of the definition of
‘‘small business’’ is that the entity not be
dominant in its field of operation. The
Commission is unable at this time to
define or quantify the criteria that
would establish whether a specific
television station is dominant in its field
of operation. Accordingly, the estimate
of small businesses to which rules may
apply does not exclude any television
station from the definition of a small
business on this basis and is therefore
possibly over-inclusive to that extent.
74. In addition, the Commission has
estimated the number of licensed
noncommercial educational (NCE)
television stations to be 380. These
stations are non-profit, and therefore
considered to be small entities. There
are also 2,295 low power television
stations (LPTV). Given the nature of this
service, we will presume that all LPTV
licensees qualify as small entities under
the above SBA small business size
standard.
75. Cable Television Distribution
Services. Since 2007, these services
have been defined within the broad
economic census category of Wired
Telecommunications Carriers; that
category is defined as follows: ‘‘This
PO 00000
Frm 00020
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
industry comprises establishments
primarily engaged in operating and/or
providing access to transmission
facilities and infrastructure that they
own and/or lease for the transmission of
voice, data, text, sound, and video using
wired telecommunications networks.
Transmission facilities may be based on
a single technology or a combination of
technologies.’’ The SBA has developed a
small business size standard for this
category, which is: all such firms having
1,500 or fewer employees. To gauge
small business prevalence for these
cable services we must, however, use
current census data that are based on
the previous category of Cable and
Other Program Distribution and its
associated size standard; that size
standard was: all such firms having
$13.5 million or less in annual receipts.
According to Census Bureau data for
2002, there were a total of 1,191 firms
in this previous category that operated
for the entire year. Of this total, 1,087
firms had annual receipts of under $10
million, and 43 firms had receipts of
$10 million or more but less than $25
million. Thus, the majority of these
firms can be considered small.
76. Cable Companies and Systems.
The Commission has also developed its
own small business size standards, for
the purpose of cable rate regulation.
Under the Commission’s rules, a ‘‘small
cable company’’ is one serving 400,000
or fewer subscribers, nationwide.
Industry data indicate that, of 1,076
cable operators nationwide, all but
eleven are small under this size
standard. In addition, under the
Commission’s rules, a ‘‘small system’’ is
a cable system serving 15,000 or fewer
subscribers. Industry data indicate that,
of 7,208 systems nationwide, 6,139
systems have fewer than 10,000
subscribers, and an additional 379
systems have 10,000–19,999
subscribers. Thus, under this second
size standard, most cable systems are
small.
77. Cable System Operators. The
Communications Act of 1934, as
amended, also contains a size standard
for small cable system operators, which
is ‘‘a cable operator that, directly or
through an affiliate, serves in the
aggregate fewer than 1 percent of all
subscribers in the United States and is
not affiliated with any entity or entities
whose gross annual revenues in the
aggregate exceed $250,000,000.’’ The
Commission has determined that an
operator serving fewer than 677,000
subscribers shall be deemed a small
operator, if its annual revenues, when
combined with the total annual
revenues of all its affiliates, do not
exceed $250 million in the aggregate.
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
22JAR1
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
Industry data indicate that, of 1,076
cable operators nationwide, all but ten
are small under this size standard. We
note that the Commission neither
requests nor collects information on
whether cable system operators are
affiliated with entities whose gross
annual revenues exceed $250 million,
and therefore we are unable to estimate
more accurately the number of cable
system operators that would qualify as
small under this size standard.
78. Motion Picture and Video
Producers. This economic census
category comprises ‘‘establishments
primarily engaged in producing, or
producing and distributing motion
pictures, videos, television programs, or
television commercials.’’ The SBA has
developed a small business size
standard for firms within this category,
which is: Firms with $27 million or less
in annual receipts. According to Census
Bureau data for 2002, there were 7,772
firms in this category that operated for
the entire year. Of this total, 7,685 firms
had annual receipts of under $25
million and 45 firms had annual
receipts of $25 million to $49,999,999.
Thus, under this category and
associated small business size standard,
the majority of firms can be considered
small.
79. Broadband Radio Service
(formerly Multipoint Distribution
Service) and Educational Broadband
Service (formerly Instructional
Television Fixed Service). Multichannel
Multipoint Distribution Service (MMDS)
systems, often referred to as ‘‘wireless
cable,’’ transmit video programming to
subscribers using the microwave
frequencies of the Multipoint
Distribution Service (MDS) and
Instructional Television Fixed Service
(ITFS). In its BRS/EBS Report and Order
in WT Docket No. 03–66, the
Commission comprehensively reviewed
its policies and rules relating to the
ITFS and MDS services, and replaced
the MDS with the Broadband Radio
Service and ITFS with the Educational
Broadband Service in a new band plan
at 2495–2690 MHz. In connection with
the 1996 MDS auction, the Commission
defined ‘‘small business’’ as an entity
that, together with its affiliates, has
average gross annual revenues that are
not more than $40 million for the
preceding three calendar years. The
SBA has approved of this standard.
80. In addition, the SBA has
developed a small business size
standard for Cable and Other Program
Distribution, which is: all such firms
having $13.5 million or less in annual
receipts. According to Census Bureau
data for 2002, there were a total of 1,191
firms in this category that operated for
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
the entire year. Of this total, 1,087 firms
had annual receipts of under $10
million, and 43 firms had receipts of
$10 million or more but less than $25
million. Thus, under this size standard,
the majority of firms can be considered
small.
81. Low Power Auxiliary Device
Manufacturers: Radio and Television
Broadcasting and Wireless
Communications Equipment
Manufacturing. The Census Bureau
defines this category as follows: ‘‘This
industry comprises establishments
primarily engaged in manufacturing
radio and television broadcast and
wireless communications equipment.
Examples of products made by these
establishments are: transmitting and
receiving antennas, cable television
equipment, GPS equipment, pagers,
cellular phones, mobile
communications equipment, and radio
and television studio and broadcasting
equipment.’’ The SBA has developed a
small business size standard for Radio
and Television Broadcasting and
Wireless Communications Equipment
Manufacturing, which is: all such firms
having 750 or fewer employees.
According to Census Bureau data for
2002, there were a total of 1,041
establishments in this category that
operated for the entire year. Of this
total, 1,010 had employment of less than
500, and an additional 13 had
employment of 500 to 999. Thus, under
this size standard, the majority of firms
can be considered small.
82. Low Power Auxiliary Device
Manufacturers: Other Communications
Equipment Manufacturing. The Census
Bureau defines this category as follows:
‘‘This industry comprises establishments
primarily engaged in manufacturing
communications equipment (except
telephone apparatus, and radio and
television broadcast, and wireless
communications equipment).’’ The SBA
has developed a small business size
standard for Other Communications
Equipment Manufacturing, which is: all
such firms having 750 or fewer
employees. According to Census Bureau
data for 2002, there were a total of 503
establishments in this category that
operated for the entire year. Of this
total, 493 had employment below 500,
and an additional 7 had employment of
500 to 999. Thus, under this size
standard, the majority of firms can be
considered small.
83. Radio, Television, and Other
Electronics Stores. The Census Bureau
defines this economic census category
as follows: ‘‘This U.S. industry
comprises: (1) Establishments known as
consumer electronics stores primarily
engaged in retailing a general line of
PO 00000
Frm 00021
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
3635
new consumer-type electronic products;
(2) establishments specializing in
retailing a single line of consumer-type
electronic products (except computers);
or (3) establishments primarily engaged
in retailing these new electronic
products in combination with repair
services.’’ The SBA has developed a
small business size standard for Radio,
Television, and Other Electronics
Stores, which is: all such firms having
$8 million or less in annual receipts.
According to Census Bureau data for
2002, there were 10,380 firms in this
category that operated for the entire
year. Of this total, 10,080 firms had
annual sales of under $5 million, and
177 firms had sales of $5 million or
more but less than $10 million. Thus,
the majority of firms in this category can
be considered small.
D. Description of Projected Reporting,
Recordkeeping, and Other Compliance
Requirements for Small Entities
84. The Report and Order adopts
transition procedures for entities that
have not been able to migrate their
operations of low power auxiliary
stations out of the 700 MHz Band by the
effective date of the new rules. During
a one-year transition period from the
end of the DTV transition, to the extent
that a 700 MHz public safety or
commercial licensee chooses to notify
the Commission that it will be initiating
operations on specified frequencies in
particular market(s), the Commission
will issue a public notice providing that
users of low power auxiliary stations in
the 700 MHz Band in those market(s)
will be required to cease operations
within 60 days after such notice is
issued. Alternatively, any 700 MHz
commercial or public safety licensee
may, at its option, notify any user of low
power auxiliary stations of its intention
to initiate operations on specified
frequencies in the market in which the
low power auxiliary station user is
operating. Upon receipt of such notice,
the entity operating low power auxiliary
stations in the affected market area must
cease operation within 60 days.
85. To protect consumers in the
United States, and to help ensure that
no wireless microphones and other low
power auxiliary stations that operate in
the 700 MHz Band continue to be made
available for use in the United States,
the Report and Order requires retailers
to remove from display (including
online display) any low power auxiliary
stations, including wireless
microphones, that can operate in the
700 MHz Band, as well as any marketing
material that does not comply with the
requirements adopted herein.
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
22JAR1
3636
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
86. Current licensees with authority
under part 74, Subpart H to operate low
power auxiliary stations in the 700 MHz
Band whose current authorization limits
them in whole or in significant part to
operations in the 700 MHz Band can be
accommodated with the use of spectrum
from other spectrum bands that are
available for low power auxiliary station
operations under Section 74.802 of the
rules. Once replacement spectrum has
been identified, as a matter of
administrative convenience, the
licensee should file an application to
modify its authorization to include the
identified frequencies.
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
E. Steps Taken To Minimize Significant
Economic Impact on Small Entities, and
Significant Alternatives Considered
87. The RFA requires an agency to
describe any significant, specifically
small business alternatives that it has
considered in reaching its proposed
approach, which may include the
following four alternatives (among
others): ‘‘(1) the establishment of
differing compliance or reporting
requirements or timetables that take into
account the resources available to small
entities; (2) the clarification,
consolidation, or simplification of
compliance or reporting requirements
under the rule for small entities; (3) the
use of performance, rather than design,
standards; and (4) and exemption from
coverage of the rule, or any part thereof,
for small entities.’’
88. In the Report and Order, the
Commission adopts a single set of rules
for all operators and manufacturers of
low power auxiliary stations (including
those operators and manufacturers that
are small entities). The Commission
decides on a single set of rules in
accordance with its objective of limiting
potential interference on the 700 MHz
Band to ensure that it is available for
public safety and commercial wireless
services as of June 12, 2009. In the
Report and Order, the Commission
concludes to amend its rules to make
clear that none of the entities currently
operating low power auxiliary stations,
including wireless microphones, within
the 700 MHz Band will have the right
to do so after the end of the DTV
transition because such operations
could cause harmful interference to new
wireless services in the band,
particularly public safety operations. To
adopt a separate set of rules for small
entities could undermine the
Commission’s objective of establishing
an unencumbered 700 MHz Band for
use by public safety and commercial
wireless services after the end of the
DTV transition.
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
89. The rules adopted in the Report
and Order may have a significant
economic impact on a substantial
number of small entities. For example,
the Commission has determined to
amend its rules to provide that low
power auxiliary stations licensed under
part 74 of the rules (including those
operated by small entities) no longer
have a right to operate in the 700 MHz
Band after the effective date of the rules
adopted in the Report and Order. The
Commission modifies the licenses of all
low power auxiliary station licensees
that currently are authorized to operate
in the 700 MHz Band to remove this
part of the authorization and prohibit
such operations in the 700 MHz Band
after the effective date of the new rules,
as conditioned in the Report and Order.
The Commission also concludes to
prohibit the manufacture, import, sale,
offer for sale, or shipment of devices
that operate as low power auxiliary
stations in the 700 MHz Band, effective
upon publication of a summary of the
Report and Order in the Federal
Register. This ban includes the
manufacture, import, sale, offer for sale,
or shipment of such devices by small
entities, and the requirements for
complying with these rules would be
the same for both large and small
entities. To the extent that small entities
feel this compliance burden more, we
have, as noted herein in Section D and
below, provided a transition period to
lessen this burden.
90. In the Report and Order, the
Commission takes several steps to
minimize the economic impact of its
rules on operators of low power
auxiliary stations in the 700 MHz Band
(including those operators which are
small entities). For example, the
Commission recognizes that not all
entities operating low power auxiliary
stations in the 700 MHz Band may
succeed, despite their best efforts, in
removing their operations from the band
by the date of the new rules and finds
that a transition period is appropriate
for these users. This limited right
terminates one year from the end of the
DTV transition, subject to the transition
procedures. All users of low power
auxiliary stations must cease operations
in the band immediately if they cause
harmful interference to 700 MHz public
safety and commercial licensees. To the
extent that a 700 MHz public safety or
commercial licensee chooses to notify
the Commission that it will be initiating
operations on specified frequencies in
particular market(s), the Commission
will issue a public notice providing that
users of low power auxiliary stations in
the 700 MHz Band in those market(s)
PO 00000
Frm 00022
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
will be required to cease operations
within 60 days after such notice is
issued. Alternatively, any 700 MHz
commercial or public safety licensee
may, at its option, notify any user of low
power auxiliary stations of its intention
to initiate operations on specified
frequencies in the market in which the
low power auxiliary station user is
operating. Upon receipt of such notice,
the entity operating low power auxiliary
stations in the affected market area must
cease operation within 60 days.
Alternative procedures that the
Commission did not adopt include a
longer transition period that may have
had an impact on small entities.
91. These transition procedures will
apply both to licensed low power
auxiliary stations and users of low
power auxiliary stations in the 700 MHz
Band that that did not obtain the
required license. By making the
procedures available to entities that
have not had the required license, it is
likely that many small entities will be
provided with authority to operate on a
limited basis, which has not previously
been made available to them. The
Commission also concludes that it
serves the public interest to waive two
of our part 15 rules, to permit
unauthorized users of low power
auxiliary stations, including wireless
microphones, to operate on an
unlicensed basis under Part 15 pursuant
to certain specified technical
requirements, in the 700 MHz Band
until June 12, 2010 and in the core TV
bands until the effective date of the
rules that will be adopted in response to
the FNPRM.
92. In addition, the Commission finds
that those licensees whose current
authorization limits them in whole or in
significant part to operations in the 700
MHz Band can be accommodated with
the use of spectrum from other spectrum
bands that are available for low power
auxiliary station operations under
Section 74.802 of the rules. The Report
and Order notes that such licensees may
wish to consult with a local Society of
Broadcast Engineers (SBE) coordinator
to identify suitable spectrum from other
spectrum bands that are available for
low power auxiliary station operations
under the rules. Once replacement
spectrum has been identified, as a
matter of administrative convenience
the licensee should file an application
to modify its authorization to include
the identified frequencies. This will
enable the Wireless
Telecommunications Bureau to modify
the license in conformance with the
revised rules adopted in the Report and
Order.
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
22JAR1
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
93. The Report and Order rejects an
alternative proposal for a general
amnesty for unauthorized wireless
microphone users. The Commission
permits wireless microphone users
currently operating in the 700 MHz
Band, which include many currently
unauthorized users, to remain in the
band for a limited period of time subject
to specific transition procedures, while
also permitting many currently
unauthorized users the opportunity, on
a going-forward basis, to locate wireless
microphone operations in the TV band
spectrum. In addition, the Report and
Order declines to pursue the
investigation requested by PISC.
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
F. Report to Congress
1. The Commission will send a copy
of the Report and Order, including this
FRFA, in a report to be sent to Congress
and the Government Accountability
Office pursuant to the Congressional
Review Act. In addition, the
Commission will send a copy of the
Report and Order, including this FRFA,
to the Chief Counsel for Advocacy of the
SBA. A copy of the Report and Order
and FRFA (or summaries thereof) will
also be published in the Federal
Register.
information collection under the PRA.
In addition, the consumer disclosure
requirements for anyone selling, leasing,
or offering for sale or lease low power
auxiliary stations that operate in the
core TV bands constitute a new
information collection under the PRA.
The Commission is submitting a request
to OMB for approval of these rules
under the emergency clearance
provisions of the PRA. Accordingly, the
information collections adopted in this
Report and Order will become effective
as follows. The information collections
associated with the procedures for early
clearing of the 700 MHz Band will
become effective upon publication of a
summary of this Report and Order in the
Federal Register or upon OMB
approval, whichever is later. The
labeling requirements for 700 MHz Band
equipment destined for export will
become effective 90 days after release of
this Report and Order (i.e., April 15,
2010), subject to OMB approval, and the
consumer disclosure requirements will
become effective on February 28, 2010,
subject to OMB approval.
Congressional Review Act
96. The Commission will include a
copy of this Report and Order and
FNPRM in a report to be sent to
Final Paperwork Reduction Act Analysis
Congress and the Government
94. The Report and Order contains
Accountability Office pursuant to the
new information collection
Congressional Review Act, see 5 U.S.C.
requirements subject to the Paperwork
801(a)(1)(A).
Reduction Act of 1995 (PRA), Public
IV. Ordering Clauses
Law 104–13. It will be submitted to the
97. Accordingly, it is ordered,
Office of Management and Budget
(OMB) for review under Section 3507(d) pursuant to Sections 1, 2, 4(i), 4(j), 301,
302, 303, 304, 307, 308, 309, 316, 332,
of the PRA. OMB, the general public,
and other Federal agencies are invited to 336, and 337 of the Communications
Act of 1934, as amended, 47 U.S.C. 151,
comment on the new or modified
152, 154(i), 154(j), 301, 302a, 303, 304,
information collection requirements
307, 308, 309, 316, 332, 336, and 337,
contained in this proceeding. In
that this Report and Order in WT Docket
addition, pursuant to the Small
No. 08–166, WT Docket No. 08–167, and
Business Paperwork Relief Act of 2002,
ET Docket No. 10–24 is adopted, that
Public Law 107–198, see 44 U.S.C.
parts 2, 15, and 74 of the Commission’s
3506(c)(4), the Commission seek
rules, 47 CFR parts 2, 15, and 74 are
specific comment on how the
amended as set forth in the final rules,
Commission might ‘‘further reduce the
and that the requirements of this Report
information collection burden for small
and Order and the amended rules shall
business concerns with fewer than 25
become effective upon the publication
employees.’’
of a summary of the Report and Order
95. The Commission finds that there
in the Federal Register, except as
is good cause to seek emergency OMB
follows with respect to the information
approval in order that the new
collections: § 74.802(e) in the final rules
information collections adopted in this
shall become effective upon publication
Report and Order may take effect as
of a summary of the Report and Order
soon as possible. The procedures under
in the Federal Register; § 15.216 in the
which public safety and commercial
final rules shall become effective on
licensees may provide notice of their
February 28, 2010; § 74.851(h) in the
intention to initiate wireless operations
final rules shall become effective 90
constitute a new information collection
days after release of this Report and
under the PRA. The labeling
Order (i.e., April 15, 2010), and these
requirements for 700 MHz Band
information collections are subject to
equipment destined for non-U.S.
OMB approval. With respect to
markets also constitute a new
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
PO 00000
Frm 00023
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
3637
information collections subject to OMB
approval, the Commission will issue a
public notice announcing the date upon
which these provisions shall become
effective following receipt of such
approval.
98. It is further ordered that, pursuant
to authority in Section 1.3 of the
Commission’s rules, 47 CFR 1.3, and
Sections 4(i), 302, 303(e), and 303(r) of
the Communications Act of 1934, as
amended, 47 U.S.C. 154(i), 302, 303(e),
and 303(r), Sections 15.201(b) and
15.209(a) of the Commission’s rules, 47
CFR 15.201(b), 15.209(a), are waived,
consistent with the terms of this Report
and Order. This action is effective upon
release of this Report and Order.
99. It is further ordered that, pursuant
to Section 5(c) of the Communications
Act of 1934, as amended, 47 U.S.C.
155(c), the Wireless
Telecommunications Bureau, Public
Safety and Homeland Security Bureau,
and Consumer and Governmental
Affairs Bureau are granted delegated
authority to implement the policies set
forth in this Report and Order and the
rules, as revised, set forth in the final
rules hereto.
100. It is further ordered that,
pursuant to Section 5(c) of the
Communications Act of 1934, as
amended, 47 U.S.C. 155(c), the Wireless
Telecommunications Bureau and
Consumer and Governmental Affairs
Bureau are granted delegated authority
to prepare the specific language that
must be used in the Consumer
Disclosure, as set forth in this Report
and Order and the rules in the final
rules, and publish it in the Federal
Register.
101. It is further ordered that,
pursuant to Section 5(c) of the
Communications Act of 1934, as
amended, 47 U.S.C. 155(c), the Office of
Engineering and Technology and the
Wireless Telecommunications Bureau
are granted delegated authority to
address requests to modify the limited
waiver of Sections 15.201(b) and
15.209(a) of the Commission’s rules, 47
CFR 15.201(b), 15.209(a), as set forth in
this Report and Order, on a case-by-case
basis to permit entities that are
operating without a license
authorization to operate low power
auxiliary stations at power levels higher
than 50 milliwatts.
102. It is further ordered that the
Commission’s Consumer and
Governmental Affairs Bureau, Reference
Information Center, shall send a copy of
this Report and Order, including the
Final Regulatory Flexibility Analysis, to
the Chief Counsel for Advocacy of the
Small Business Administration.
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
22JAR1
3638
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
103. It is further ordered that the
Commission shall send a copy of this
Report and Order and Further Notice of
Proposed Rulemaking in a report to be
sent to Congress and the Government
Accountability Office pursuant to the
Congressional Review Act, see 5 U.S.C.
801(a)(1)(A).
List of Subjects
47 CFR Part 2
Communications equipment,
Reporting and recordkeeping
requirements.
PART 15—RADIO FREQUENCY
DEVICES
For the reasons discussed in the
preamble, the Federal Communications
Commission amends 47 CFR parts 2, 15,
and 74 as follows:
PART 2—FREQUENCY ALLOCATIONS
AND RADIO TREATY MATTERS;
GENERAL RULES AND REGULATIONS
1. The authority citation for part 2
continues to read as follows:
■
Authority: 47 U.S.C. 154, 302a, 303, and
336, unless otherwise noted.
2. Section 2.106, Table of Frequency
Allocations, is amended by revising
footnotes NG115 and NG159 to read as
follows:
■
Table of Frequency Allocations.
*
NON-FEDERAL GOVERNMENT (NG)
FOOTNOTES
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
*
*
*
*
*
NG115 In the bands 54–72 MHz, 76–
88 MHz, 174–216 MHz, 470–608 MHz,
and 614–698 MHz, wireless
microphones and wireless assist video
devices may be authorized on a noninterference basis, subject to the terms
and conditions set forth in 47 CFR part
74, subpart H.
*
*
*
*
*
NG159 Any full-power television
licensee that holds a television
broadcast license to operate between
698 and 806 megahertz (TV channels
52–69) shall be entitled to protection
from harmful interference through June
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
Authority: 47 U.S.C. 154, 302a, 303, 307,
336(f), 336(h) and 554.
■
§ 15.216 Disclosure Requirements for
wireless microphones and other low power
auxiliary stations capable of operating in
the core TV bands.
■
*
5. The authority citation for part 74 is
revised to read as follows:
■
4. Part 15 is amended by adding
§ 15.216 to read as follows:
Final Rules
*
PART 74—EXPERIMENTAL RADIO,
AUXILIARY, SPECIAL BROADCAST
AND OTHER PROGRAM
DISTRIBUTIONAL SERVICES
■
Federal Communications Commission.
Marlene H. Dortch,
Secretary.
*
Appendix to § 15.216—[Reserved]
Authority: 47 U.S.C. 154, 302a, 303, 304,
307, 336, and 544a.
47 CFR Part 74
Communications equipment,
Reporting and recordkeeping
requirements.
*
(even in the event such persons do not
sell low power auxiliary stations
directly to the public).
(b) The consumer disclosure text
described in paragraph (a)(1) of this
section is set out in an appendix to this
section.
3. The authority citation for part 15
continues to read as follows:
§ 74.802
(a) Any person who manufactures,
sells, leases, or offers for sale or lease,
low power auxiliary stations capable of
operating in the core TV bands
(channels 2–51, excluding channel 37)
is subject to the following disclosure
requirements: (1) Such persons must
display the consumer disclosure text, as
specified by the Wireless
Telecommunications Bureau and the
Consumer and Governmental Affairs
Bureau, at the point of sale or lease of
each such low power auxiliary station.
The text must be displayed in a clear,
conspicuous, and readily legible
manner. One way to fulfill the
requirement in this section is to display
the consumer disclosure text in a
prominent manner on the product box
by using a label (either printed onto the
box or otherwise affixed to the box), a
sticker, or other means. Another way to
fulfill this requirement is to display the
text immediately adjacent to each low
power auxiliary station offered for sale
or lease and clearly associated with the
model to which it pertains.
(2) If such persons offer such low
power auxiliary stations via direct mail,
catalog, or electronic means, they shall
prominently display the consumer
disclosure text in close proximity to the
images and descriptions of each such
low power auxiliary station. The text
should be in a size large enough to be
clear, conspicuous, and readily legible,
consistent with the dimensions of the
advertisement or description.
(3) If such persons have Web sites
pertaining to these low power auxiliary
stations, the consumer disclosure text
must be displayed there in a clear,
conspicuous, and readily legible manner
(a) * * *
614.000–698.000 MHz
944.000–952.000 MHz
(b) * * *
(3) 470.000–608.000 MHz and
614.000–698.000 MHz.
All zones 113 km (70 miles)
*
*
*
*
*
(e) Clearing mechanisms for the 700
MHz Band. This section sets forth
provisions relating to the transition of
low power auxiliary stations operating
at 698–806 MHz (700 MHz band).
(1) Any low power auxiliary station
that operates at frequencies in the 700
MHz band while transitioning its
operations out of that band must not
cause harmful interference and must
accept interference from any
commercial or public safety wireless
licensees in the 700 MHz band.
(2) Any low power auxiliary station
that operates at frequencies in the 700
MHz band will have until no later than
June 12, 2010 to transition its operations
completely out of the 700 MHz band,
subject to the following. During this
transition period, any commercial or
public safety licensee in the 700 MHz
band may choose one or both of the
following voluntary methods to notify
low power auxiliary stations:
(i) Any commercial or public safety
licensee in the 700 MHz band may
notify the Commission that it has
initiated or will be initiating operations
on specified frequencies in a particular
market(s) in the 700 MHz band. The
wireless operations initiated by the
commercial or public safety 700 MHz
licensees may include system testing or
trials. Following receipt of the
notification, the Commission will issue
■
47 CFR Part 15
Communications equipment,
Labeling, and Reporting and
recordkeeping requirements.
§ 2.106
12, 2009, and may not operate at that
frequency after June 12, 2009. Auxiliary
broadcast stations other than low power
auxiliary stations (i.e., low-power TV
stations, translator stations, booster
stations, and TV auxiliary (backup)
facilities) may continue to operate
indefinitely in the band 698–806 MHz
on a secondary basis to all other stations
operating in that band.
*
*
*
*
*
PO 00000
Frm 00024
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
6. Section 74.802 is amended by
revising the last two entries in
paragraph (a); revising paragraph (b)(3),
and by adding paragraph (e), to read as
follows:
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
Frequency assignment.
22JAR1
Federal Register / Vol. 75, No. 14 / Friday, January 22, 2010 / Rules and Regulations
a public notice providing that operators
of low power auxiliary stations,
including wireless microphones, in the
700 MHz band in those market(s) will be
required to cease operations within 60
days after the Commission’s notice is
released.
(ii) Any commercial or public safety
licensee in the 700 MHz band may
notify any low power auxiliary station
users operating in the 700 MHz band
that it has initiated or will be initiating
operations on specified frequencies in
the market in which the low power
auxiliary station is operating. The
wireless operations initiated by the
commercial or public safety 700 MHz
licensees may include system testing or
trials. Upon receipt of such notice, the
low power auxiliary station in the
affected market area must cease
operation within 60 days.
(iii) In the event that both of these
notice provisions in paragraphs (e)(2)(i)
and (ii) of this section are used with
respect to a particular low power
auxiliary station, the low power
auxiliary station will have to cease
operations in the market(s) in
accordance with whichever notice
provides for earlier termination of its
operations.
(3) Notwithstanding this 60 day notice
requirement, any low power auxiliary
station that causes harmful interference
to any commercial or public safety 700
MHz licensee must cease operations
immediately, consistent with the rules
for secondary use.
■ 7. Section 74.851 is amended by
revising the heading and adding new
paragraphs (g), (h), and (i) to read as
follows:
§ 74.851 Certification of equipment;
prohibition on manufacture, import, sale,
lease, offer for sale or lease, or shipment of
devices that operate in the 700 MHz Band;
labeling for 700 MHz band equipment
destined for non-U.S. markets; disclosure
for the core TV bands.
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
*
*
*
*
*
(g) No person shall manufacture,
import, sell, lease, offer for sale or lease,
or ship low power auxiliary stations that
are capable of operating in the 700 MHz
band (698–806 MHz). This prohibition
does not apply to devices manufactured
solely for export.
(h) Any person who manufactures,
sells, leases, or offers for sale or lease
low power auxiliary stations, including
wireless microphones, that are destined
for non-U.S. markets and that are
capable of operating in the 700 MHz
band shall include labeling and make
clear in all sales, marketing, and
packaging materials, including online
materials, relating to such devices that
VerDate Nov<24>2008
14:41 Jan 21, 2010
Jkt 220001
the devices cannot be operated in the
U.S.
(i) Any person, whether such person
is a wholesaler or a retailer, who
manufactures, sells, leases, or offers for
sale or lease low power auxiliary
stations that operate in the core TV
bands (channels 2–51, excluding
channel 37) is subject to the disclosure
requirements in § 15.216 of this chapter.
■ 8. Section 74.861 is amended by
revising paragraph (e)(1)(ii) to read as
follows:
§ 74.861
Technical requirements.
*
*
*
*
*
(e) * * *
(1) * * *
(ii) 470–608 and 614–698 MHz
bands—250 mW
*
*
*
*
*
[FR Doc. 2010–1216 Filed 1–21–10; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 6712–01–P
FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS
COMMISSION
47 CFR Part 15
[WT Docket Nos. 08–166, 08–167, and ET
Docket No. 10–24; DA 10–92]
Revisions to Rules Authorizing the
Operation of Low Power Auxiliary
Stations in the 698–806 MHz Band;
Public Interest Spectrum Coalition,
Petition for Rulemaking Regarding
Low Power Auxiliary Stations,
Including Wireless Microphones, and
the Digital Television Transition
AGENCY: Federal Communications
Commission.
ACTION: Final rule.
SUMMARY: In this order, Wireless
Telecommunications Bureau and
Consumer and Governmental Affairs
Bureau of the Federal Communications
Commission adopt the specific language
that must be used in the consumer
disclosure that is required by Section
15.216 of Appendix B in the Wireless
Microphone Report and Order.1
DATES: This rule amends § 15.216,
which contains information collection
requirements that have not been
approved by OMB. The FCC will
1 Revisions to Rules Authorizing the Operation of
Low Power Auxiliary Stations in the 698–806 MHz
Band; Public Interest Spectrum Coalition, Petition
for Rulemaking Regarding Low Power Auxiliary
Stations, Including Wireless Microphones, and the
Digital Television Transition; Amendment of Parts
15, 74 and 90 of the Commission’s Rules Regarding
Low Power Auxiliary Stations, Including Wireless
Microphones, WT Docket Nos. 08–166, 08–167, ET
Docket Nos. 10–24, Report and Order and Further
Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, FCC 10–16 at para.
99 (rel. October 15, 2010) (‘‘Wireless Microphone
Report and Order’’).
PO 00000
Frm 00025
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
3639
publish a document in the Federal
Register announcing the effective date.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: This is a
summary of the Order in WT Docket
Nos. 08–166 and 08–167, ET Docket No.
10–24 and DA 10–92, adopted January
15, 2010, and released on January 15,
2010. In this order, the Wireless
Telecommunications Bureau and
Consumer and Governmental Affairs
Bureau of the Federal Communications
Commission adopt the specific language
that must be used in the consumer
disclosure that is required by Section
15.216 of Appendix B in the Wireless
Microphone Report and Order.2 This
disclosure requirement is applicable to
persons who manufacture, sell, lease, or
offer for sale or lease low power
auxiliary stations, including wireless
microphones, capable of operating in
the core TV bands (channels 2–51,
excluding channel 37).
Order
1. On January 14, 2010, the
Commission adopted a Wireless
Microphone Report and Order.3 In the
Wireless Microphone Report and Order,
the Commission took action to ensure
that low power auxiliary stations,
including wireless microphones, are
cleared from the 700 MHz Band (689–
806 MHz) so that public safety and
commercial licensees can operate in the
band without interference. The
Commission adopted a new rule,
Section 15.216, which provides that any
person who manufactures, sells, leases,
or offers for sale or lease wireless
microphones and other low power
auxiliary stations capable of operating
in the core TV bands must display a
consumer disclosure text.4
2. The Commission delegated
authority to the Wireless
Telecommunications Bureau and the
Consumer and Governmental Affairs
Bureau to adopt the specific language
that must be used in the consumer
disclosure that is required by Section
15.216 of Appendix B in the Wireless
Microphone Report and Order.5 The
Wireless Telecommunications Bureau
2 Revisions to Rules Authorizing the Operation of
Low Power Auxiliary Stations in the 698–806 MHz
Band; Public Interest Spectrum Coalition, Petition
for Rulemaking Regarding Low Power Auxiliary
Stations, Including Wireless Microphones, and the
Digital Television Transition; Amendment of Parts
15, 74 and 90 of the Commission’s Rules Regarding
Low Power Auxiliary Stations, Including Wireless
Microphones, WT Docket Nos. 08–166, 08–167, ET
Docket Nos. 10–24, Report and Order and Further
Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, FCC 10–16 at para.
99 (rel. October 15, 2010) (‘‘Wireless Microphone
Report and Order’’).
3 Id.
4 See id., Appendix B.
5 Id. at para. 99.
E:\FR\FM\22JAR1.SGM
22JAR1
Agencies
[Federal Register Volume 75, Number 14 (Friday, January 22, 2010)]
[Rules and Regulations]
[Pages 3622-3639]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Printing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2010-1216]
=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
47 CFR Parts 2, 15, and 74
[WT Docket Nos. 08-166, 08-167, and ET Docket No. 10-24; FCC 10-16]
Revisions to Rules Authorizing the Operation of Low Power
Auxiliary Stations in the 698-806 MHz Band; Public Interest Spectrum
Coalition, Petition for Rulemaking Regarding Low Power Auxiliary
Stations, Including Wireless Microphones, and the Digital Television
Transition
AGENCY: Federal Communications Commission.
ACTION: Final rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: In this Report and Order, the Commission establishes a
deadline for wireless microphones and other low power auxiliary
stations to cease operation in the 700 MHz Band. The Commission also
adopts an early clearing mechanism by which 700 MHz public safety and
commercial licensees can provide notice that they are initiating
operations in the 700 MHz Band. In addition, the Commission prohibits
the manufacture, import, sale, lease, offer for sale or lease, or
shipment of wireless microphones and other low power auxiliary stations
intended for use in the 700 MHz Band. With regard to users who are not
eligible for, or who do not hold part 74, Subpart H license
authorizations, the Commission waive its part 15 rules for a limited
period. Finally, the Commission adopts certain disclosure requirements
under which manufacturers, dealers, distributors, and other entities
that sell or lease these devices must display a consumer disclosure at
the point of sale or lease.
DATES: Effective January 22, 2010, except for Sec. Sec. 15.216,
74.802(e)(2), and 74.851(h) and (i), which contains information
collection requirements that have not been approved by OMB. The FCC
will publish a document in the Federal Register announcing the
effective date.
ADDRESSES: You may submit comments, identified by WT Docket No. 08-166,
08-167 and ET Docket No. 10-24, by any of the following methods:
Federal eRulemaking Portal: https://www.regulations.gov.
Follow the instructions for submitting comments.
Federal Communications Commission's Web site: https://www.fcc.gov/cgb/ecfs/. Follow the instructions for submitting comments.
Mail: Filings can be sent by hand or messenger delivery,
by commercial overnight courier, or by first-class or overnight U.S.
Postal Service mail (although the Commission continues to experience
delays in receiving U.S. Postal Service mail). All filings must be
addressed to the Commission's Secretary, Office of the Secretary,
Federal Communications Commission.
People with Disabilities: Contact the FCC to request
reasonable accommodations (accessible format documents, sign language
interpreters, CART, etc.) by e-mail: FCC504@fcc.gov or phone: 202-418-
0530 or TTY: 202-418-0432.
For detailed instructions for submitting comments and additional
information on the rulemaking process, see the SUPPLEMENTARY
INFORMATION section of this document.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: For further information, contact Paul
D'Ari, Wireless Telecommunications Bureau, (202) 418-1550, e-mail
Paul.Dari@fcc.gov, or Hugh L. Van Tuyl, Office of Engineering and
Technology, (202) 418-7506, e-mail Hugh.VanTuyl@fcc.gov.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: This is a summary of the Commission's rules
noted in the Report and Order and Further Notice of Proposed Rulemaking
in WT Docket Nos. 08-166 and 08-167, ET Docket No. 10-24 and FCC 10-16,
adopted January 14, 2010, and released on January 15, 2010. This
summary should be read with its companion document, the Further Notice
of Proposed Rulemaking (FNPRM) summary published elsewhere in this
issue of the Federal Register. The full text of the Report and Order
and FNPRM is available for public inspection and copying during
business hours in the FCC Reference Information Center, Portals II, 445
12th Street, SW., Room CY-A257, Washington, DC 20554. It also may be
purchased from the Commission's duplicating contractor at Portals II,
445 12th Street, SW., Room CY-B402, Washington, DC 20554; the
contractor's Web site, https://www.bcpiweb.com; or by calling (800) 378-
3160, facsimile (202) 488-5563, or e-mail FCC@BCPIWEB.com. Copies of
the public notice also may be obtained via the Commission's Electronic
Comment Filing System (ECFS) by entering the docket numbers, WT Docket
No. 08-166, WT Docket No. 08-167, and ET Docket No. 10-24.
Additionally, the complete item is available on the Federal
Communications Commission's Web site at https://www.fcc.gov.
[[Page 3623]]
Synopsis of the Report and Order Section of the Report and Order and
Notice of Proposed Rulemaking
I. Introduction
1. In this Report and Order and FNPRM, the Commission takes action
to ensure that public safety and commercial licensees can operate in
the 700 MHz Band without interference, while providing entities
currently operating wireless microphones in the band with an
opportunity to relocate to other bands. In particular, the Commission
ensures that these devices are cleared from the 700 MHz Band no later
than June 12, 2010, consistent with the Commission's long-standing goal
of making this spectrum fully available for use by public safety and
commercial licensees, and the customers that they serve in the band.
The Commission also authorizes, for the first time, the use of wireless
microphones, on an unlicensed basis, by entities not currently eligible
to obtain licenses. The Commission does this by waiver based on its
longstanding unlicensed device rules, which have proved highly
successful in permitting the use of low-power wireless devices. In
addition, the Commission adopts a number of safeguards designed to
ensure both that consumers understand their rights and obligations in
operating wireless microphones and that wireless microphones are
operated in compliance with our rules and policies. Finally, in the
FNPRM the Commission seeks to refine and update its rules governing the
use of wireless microphones, seeking comment on a range of issues
concerning the operation of these devices in the core TV bands.
2. More specifically, in this Report and Order, the Commission
adopt the following requirements:
The Commission prohibits the manufacture, import, sale,
lease, offer for sale or lease, or shipment of wireless microphones and
other low power auxiliary stations intended for use in the 700 MHz Band
in the United States, effective upon the publication of the rules in
the Federal Register, and adopt related marketing and other
requirements.
The Commission requires that all low power auxiliary
stations, including wireless microphones, cease operations in the 700
MHz Band no later than June 12, 2010, one year from the end of the DTV
transition.
The Commission provides for an early clearing mechanism
that, to the extent that a public safety or commercial licensee will be
initiating operations in the 700 MHz Band on specified frequencies and
particular markets before June 12, 2010, permits a licensee to require
users of low power auxiliary stations, including wireless microphones
to cease operations 60 days after notice.
The Commission stresses that the operations of low power
auxiliary stations, including wireless microphones, in the 700 MHz Band
must cease immediately if at any time users of these devices cause
harmful interference to a 700 MHz public safety or commercial licensee.
With respect to unauthorized operations of wireless
microphones and other low power auxiliary stations, the Commission
waives its part 15 rules for a limited period to permit unauthorized
users of wireless microphones and other low power auxiliary stations to
operate on an unlicensed basis under part 15 pursuant to certain
specified technical requirements--in the 700 MHz Band until June 12,
2010, and in the core ``TV bands'' until the effective date of the
Commission's actions in response to the FNPRM.
3. In addition, in this Report and Order the Commission takes
various actions to ensure that consumers are better informed about its
rules and policies concerning wireless microphones, which should
facilitate compliance with those rules:
The Commission establishes disclosure requirements to make
certain that buyers of wireless microphone equipment understand the
limitations on their use of such equipment. For instance,
manufacturers, dealers, distributors, and other entities that sell or
lease these devices will have to display a consumer disclosure at the
point of sale or lease informing consumers of the conditions that apply
to the operation of wireless microphones in the core TV bands.
As part of the Commissions consumer outreach plan, the
Commission will release consumer publications, including a Consumer
Fact Sheet, that inform the public of its decisions in this Report and
Order and of the need to clear the 700 MHz Band so that the spectrum
can be used for the provision of new public safety and commercial
services.
The Commission will work with organizations whose
memberships include wireless microphone users so that they help the
Commission inform all affected users of its decisions in this Report
and Order, particularly the need to clear the 700 MHz Band.
The Commission will assist consumers, including those who
have previously purchased wireless microphones that operate in the 700
MHz Band, by posting information on its Web site and by making
information available from the Commission's consumer service
representatives through a toll-free number at the Commission's call
center.
The Commission will make available via its Web site and
its call center information regarding which wireless microphones are
700 MHz wireless microphones, what options may be available if
consumers do have 700 MHz microphones, and how to contact wireless
microphone manufacturers to obtain additional information. Information
concerning the Commissions decision today will be posted on its Web
site at www.fcc.gov/cgb/wirelessmicrophones.
4. Finally, in the FNPRM, the Commission take the following
actions:
The Commission proposes to revise its rules to provide
that low power wireless audio devices, including wireless microphones,
may be operated as unlicensed devices under part 15 of the rules in the
core TV bands.
The Commission proposes technical rules to apply to low
power wireless audio devices, including wireless microphones, operating
in the core TV bands on an unlicensed basis under part 15 of the rules.
The Commission seeks comment on whether, and to what
extent, eligibility for obtaining licenses to operate low power
auxiliary stations, including wireless microphones, under part 74
should be expanded, and on whether the Commission should revise part 90
to facilitate wireless microphone use.
The Commission seeks comment on possible longer-term approaches for the
operation of wireless microphones. Consistent with the Commissions
broader efforts to manage this country's spectrum resources as
effectively and efficiently as possible, the Commission here seek
comment on possible long-term reform, based in part on technological
innovation such as digital technology, that would enable wireless
microphones to operate more efficiently and with improved immunity to
harmful interference, thereby increasing the availability of spectrum
for wireless microphone and other uses.
II. Report and Order
5. In this Report and Order, the Commission establishes a firm
deadline of June 12, 2010 (one year from the end of the DTV transition)
for wireless microphones and other low power auxiliary stations to
cease operation in the 700 MHz Band. The Commission also adopts an
early clearing mechanism by which 700 MHz public safety and commercial
licensees can provide notice that they are initiating operations in the
[[Page 3624]]
700 MHz Band. The operators of wireless microphones and other low power
auxiliary stations must clear the band within 60 days after such
notice. In addition, the Commission prohibits the manufacture, import,
sale, lease, offer for sale or lease, or shipment of wireless
microphones and other low power auxiliary stations intended for use in
the 700 MHz Band.
6. With regard to users who are not eligible for, or who do not
hold part 74, Subpart H license authorizations, the Commission waive
its part 15 rules for a limited period to permit all such users to
operate on an unlicensed basis subject to a number of conditions in the
700 MHz Band until June 12, 2010 and in the core TV bands while the
Commission consider issues raised in the FNPRM. In addition, the
Commission adopts certain disclosure requirements under which
manufacturers, dealers, distributors, and other entities that sell or
lease these devices must display a consumer disclosure at the point of
sale or lease informing consumers of the conditions that apply to the
operation of wireless microphones and other low power auxiliary
stations.
A. Low Power Auxiliary Station Operations in the 700 MHz Band After the
End of the DTV Transition
7. In order to make the 700 MHz Band fully available to public
safety and commercial licensees, the Commission is revising our rules
to clarify that low power auxiliary stations, including wireless
microphones, will no longer be allowed to operate in the 700 MHz Band
except under the specified conditions, and for the limited time period,
as adopted herein. Specifically, the Commission establishes a ``hard''
date of June 12, 2010--one year from the date of the DTV transition--by
which all operations of such devices by all users (including
unauthorized users) must have ceased in the band. In addition, the
Commission will require that operations of these devices cease earlier
than that date, pursuant to certain notification procedures, in those
areas where 700 MHz public safety or commercial licensees are or will
be entering and operating in the band prior to June 12, 2010. Finally,
the Commission underscores that, if at any time users of low power
auxiliary stations cause harmful interference to a 700 MHz public
safety or commercial licensee, those users must cease operations in the
band immediately. The Commission finds that this approach best balances
the interests of public safety and commercial licensees to operate
without interference while providing entities currently operating low
power auxiliary stations in the 700 MHz Band with a reasonable amount
of time to remove their operations from the band and relocate them to
other bands. In addition, the Commission outlines below our consumer
outreach plan to provide users with information concerning their use of
low power auxiliary station devices as they transition from the 700 MHz
Band.
8. Need To Clear the Band. Based on the record, the Commission
finds that the Commission needs to be expeditious in establishing time
frames and procedures for clearing wireless microphones from the 700
MHz band on our path to providing an interference-free environment for
new services in the 700 MHz Band, especially public safety services
that are used to protect safety of life, health, or property. The
Commission finds that low power auxiliary stations could interfere with
public safety and commercial base and mobile receivers. Such
interference raises the potential for a disruption of vital public
safety services and commercial services. As V-COMM comments, low power
auxiliary stations can operate at similar power levels, and are
authorized at even higher power levels (250 milliwatts), compared with
the power levels at which public safety devices are expected to operate
(200 milliwatts). These power levels employed by the respective devices
pose a significant risk of co-channel interference and would be strong
enough to disrupt the operations of both public safety and commercial
mobiles and base station receivers in the 700 MHz Band. The risk of
interference also is present to commercial and public safety systems
when the wireless microphones and other low power auxiliary stations
are operated at lower power levels, including as low as 10 milliwatts.
This risk of interference supports the Commission's determination to
prohibit operation of low power auxiliary stations in the 700 MHz Band.
In addition, interference from low power auxiliary stations would lead
to relatively large ``dead zones'' around such devices, resulting in
effective loss of coverage to commercial and public safety mobiles and
portable devices. The Commission finds the potential for such a result
raises a significant threat of interference, which is particularly
disturbing when considering that this could occur in public safety
spectrum while being used to protect the safety of life, health, or
property. In addition, the Commission notes the potential for
interference to wireless microphone and other low power auxiliary
station operations by commercial and public safety operations.
9. In addition to co-channel interference, the record indicates
that low power auxiliary stations have the potential to cause
additional interference, such as adjacent band interference, due to
out-of-band emissions (OOBE) and intermodulation interference caused by
emissions from multiple devices. These emissions and intermodulation
products may potentially be strong enough to cause interference to
commercial and public safety base stations and mobile devices.
Intermodulation interference can occur when multiple low power
auxiliary station transmitters are combined or used in close proximity
with each other. Thus, commercial or public safety operations can
receive interference at venues where multiple low power auxiliary
station transmitters are used, such as at concerts or sporting events.
V-COMM, for example, indicates that interference can occur in a wide
variety of settings, and also discusses its own experience with co-
channel interference in the 700 MHz Band caused by low power auxiliary
stations. This potential for interference further supports prohibiting
the operation of such devices, including wireless microphones, in the
700 MHz Band.
10. Clearing the 700 MHz Band is consistent with the Commission's
previous findings relating to use of the 700 MHz Band in connection
with the DTV transition. When the Commission in 2001 adopted rules for
commercial services in a portion of the 700 MHz Band, it declined to
grant a request filed by SBE that the Commission ``afford continued
secondary status to part 74 low power broadcast auxiliary devices (such
as wireless microphones) operating in the Lower 700 MHz Band, and to
establish a new service in part 95 of our Rules to accommodate their
use.'' The Commission observed that insofar that the ``Lower 700 MHz
Band will host extensive broadcast use throughout the DTV transition,
it is unlikely that new licensees will rapidly occupy the band to the
extent that users of the low power broadcast auxiliary devices of the
type SBE discusses will have to immediately cease all operation.''
Thus, it contemplated that low power broadcast auxiliary devices would
be losing their secondary status and would have to vacate the band upon
completion of the DTV transition in a particular local market.
11. In addition, the Commission in 2002 expressly excluded from the
700 MHz Band wireless video assist devices, which are another type of
part 74,
[[Page 3625]]
Subpart H low power auxiliary station device, because of the
reallocation of TV Channels 52-69 to wireless services, including
public safety services. The Commission stated that ``[wireless video
assist devices] will not be allowed to use * * * [Channels 52-69] in
the UHF-TV band due to a recent spectrum reallocation of those channels
to uses other than broadcasting.'' Also, in 2006 the Commission
determined in the TV White Spaces proceeding that the new low power,
unlicensed devices under consideration there will not be permitted to
operate on TV Channels 52-69. The Commission stated that the spectrum
``ha[s] been reallocated for services other than broadcast television
and will no longer be part of the TV bands after the transition.''
12. The Commission concludes that parties have had time to know,
and reason to believe, that authorized low power auxiliary stations
would not be allowed to operate in the 700 MHz Band at the end of the
DTV transition. The DTV Act was enacted over three years ago, and the
Commission, as noted above, has on various occasions indicated that the
700 MHz Band would not be a permanent home for low power auxiliary
stations, including wireless microphones. Further, a number of
manufacturers warned their customers on their Web sites that, after the
end of the DTV transition, frequencies in the 700 MHz Band will no
longer be available for wireless microphone use under the Commission's
rules. There has been adequate lead time for low power auxiliary
station users, including wireless microphone users, and equipment
manufacturers to anticipate and take measures to prepare for the
reasonably anticipated consequences resulting from the end of the DTV
transition, including the availability of the spectrum for public
safety and other uses and the need for entities operating low power
auxiliary stations to vacate the 700 MHz Band. Moreover, the need to
ensure interference-free operations in the 700 MHz Band as soon as is
practicable, particularly for public safety operations, compels the
Commission to act to prohibit further use of the band for these
wireless microphone and other low power auxiliary station users.
Nevertheless, as the Commission discuss below, a short transition
period may prevent unnecessary disruption of wireless microphone
operations and allow an orderly transition to other spectrum. The
Commission's determination in this Report and Order balances the
requirements of those using low power auxiliary stations in the 700 MHz
Band with the needs of new 700 MHz licensees to access the spectrum in
a timely fashion.
13. Transition Date. In order to provide current low power
auxiliary station users a reasonable opportunity to remove their
systems from the 700 MHz band, the Commission find that allowing them
to continue to operate in the 700 MHz Band for a limited period of time
under certain conditions serves the public interest. The Commission
finds that all entities currently operating low power auxiliary
stations in the 700 MHz Band must vacate the band by June 12, 2010.
This deadline of June 12, 2010, coupled with the obligation to cease
operations earlier pursuant to notice, as described below, strikes the
best balance between the needs of public safety and commercial
licensees to operate without interference in the 700 MHz Band with the
concern that entities currently operating low power auxiliary station
devices in the 700 MHz Band have sufficient time to remove their
operations from the band and relocate them to other bands.
14. With respect to the timing for requiring that users of low
power auxiliary stations cease operating in the 700 MHz Band, the
revised rules provide that entities operating low power auxiliary
stations may continue those operations in the 700 MHz Band as late as
June 12, 2010, subject to the conditions set forth in this Report and
Order. In setting June 12, 2010, as the latest possible date for these
entities to transition from the 700 MHz Band under the conditions
adopted in this Report and Order, the Commission recognizes that low
power auxiliary station users should have a short period to transition
their operations not already transitioned out of the 700 MHz Band,
which should prevent unnecessary disruption of wireless microphone
operations. The record supports a transition period for users of low
power auxiliary stations to remove their operations out of the 700 MHz
Band, but commenters differ on the length of this period.
15. The Commission finds that the transition period and process
that the Commission adopts, which terminates on June 12, 2010, is a
reasonable period for those parties that may need to continue to
operate in the band and will ensure that this spectrum is cleared on a
timely and orderly basis for use by public safety and commercial
wireless services. The Commission also finds that these requirements,
coupled with the notice procedures described herein, will adequately
address any concerns that the operation of low power auxiliary stations
in the 700 MHz Band will cause interference to public safety and
commercial 700 MHz Band licensees with the end of the DTV transition.
Although entities operating low power auxiliary stations will have
until June 12, 2010 to complete their exit from the band and their
migration to other bands where they would be authorized to operate,
subject to the conditions the Commission adopts herein, the Commission
nevertheless encourage such users to cease operations in the 700 MHz
Band as soon as possible. In addition, the Commission finds that the
public interest is served by applying the transition procedures that
the Commission adopts in this Report and Order to users of low power
auxiliary stations that do not hold a license. This finding is based
upon the Commission's determination that the public interest will be
served by allowing this use in this limited context for the limited
duration discussed herein.
16. While the Commission agrees with MSTV/NAB that low power
auxiliary station licensees authorized to operate in the 700 MHz should
be afforded some opportunity to migrate out of the band, the Commission
cannot agree with the time frame they suggest, given the potential for
interference with public safety and commercial broadband licensees and
the clear determination in Congress's enactment of the DTV Act of 2005
that the 700 MHz band would no longer be a broadcast band in the near
term. In addition, the Commission is not persuaded that low power
auxiliary station licensees, many of which are associated with high-
power broadcast stations that have had significant notice of the need
to vacate the 700 MHz band on a timely basis, should have a different
and longer timeframe to vacate the 700 MHz Band than other users in the
band, as proposed by MSTV. In addition to the need to clear the band
because of the potential for interference, the Commission is concerned
that adding another layer of complexity--establishing a different set
of band clearing rules for a particular subset of users--is likely to
add significantly to consumer confusion as well as to undermine the
Commissions efforts to clear the 700 MHz Band. On this issue, the
Commission's judgment is that keeping a single, uniform nationwide
date, rather than adopting two separate transition dates, is essential
to clearing the 700 MHz Band in a timely, orderly, and effective
fashion in a manner that is equitable to all the affected parties. The
Commission also is not persuaded of the need for a shorter timeframe,
such as a February 18, 2010, hard date as
[[Page 3626]]
suggested by CTIA, Verizon Wireless, and several public safety groups.
As discussed above, the Commission is placing operating limitations on
low power auxiliary station users and adopting notification procedures
that enable new 700 MHz licensees to clear the band of low power
auxiliary station users in markets in which they will be operating.
Further, the Commission notes that, based on the record and publicly
available information, it is anticipated that there will be only
limited rollout of new commercial services in the 700 MHz Band prior to
mid-year 2010. To the extent that spectrum in the 700 MHz Band needs to
be clear of low power auxiliary station use for the initiation of new
operations, which includes system testing or trials, the Commission is
adopting a clearing mechanism that provides for a 60-day notification
process. Accordingly, the Commission finds the additional one-year
period after the end of the DTV transition during which these low power
auxiliary station users may continue to operate in the 700 MHz Band
provides a reasonable amount of time for those entities to migrate from
the band, yet also allows for the new 700 MHz licensees to access the
spectrum in order to provide new services to the public.
17. Early Clearing. In addition to setting June 12, 2010, for the
clearing of the 700 MHz Band by wireless microphones, the Commission
also provides procedures for clearing low power auxiliary station
operations in the 700 MHz Band prior to that time to the extent that a
public safety or commercial licensee has initiated, or will be
initiating, operations in the 700 MHz Band in particular market(s)
before that date. Wireless microphones will be required to cease
operations before June 12, 2010, only after they have been provided 60
days' advance notification, as set forth below.
18. The notification process will work as follows. During the
transition period, which will end on June 12, 2010, a 700 MHz
commercial or public safety licensee may notify the Commission that it
will be initiating operations on specified frequencies in particular
market(s). The wireless operations initiated by the public safety or
700 MHz commercial licensees can include system testing or trials. Upon
such notification, the Wireless Telecommunications Bureau or the Public
Safety and Homeland Security Bureau will issue a public notice that
will be available on the Commission's Web site and that identifies the
affected market area(s). Users of low power auxiliary stations,
including wireless microphone users, in those areas must cease
operation within 60 days of the release of the notice. The Commission's
Web site will provide a central location for the low power auxiliary
station users to find information on markets in which 700 MHz licensees
are beginning operations prior to June 12, 2010. In addition, any 700
MHz commercial or public safety licensee may, at its option, notify any
entity operating low power auxiliary stations of its intention to
initiate operations on specified frequencies in the market in which the
low power auxiliary station user is operating. Upon receipt of such
notice, the low power auxiliary station user in the affected market
area must cease operation within 60 days. For entities that have
already initiated such operations, these entities may, upon the
effective date of this order, follow the same notifications procedures,
triggering the same 60-day cessation obligation for users of low power
auxiliary stations.
19. In the event that both of these notice provisions are used to
provide notice to a particular user of a low power auxiliary
station(s), the user will be required to cease operations in the
market(s) in accordance with whichever notice provides for earlier
termination of such operations. This process should place only a
limited burden on public safety and commercial licensees, which have
the primary rights to use 700 MHz Band spectrum. Further, as noted
above, notwithstanding any early clearing mechanisms adopted herein,
low power auxiliary station users that cause harmful interference to a
700 MHz commercial or public safety licensee must cease operations
immediately consistent with the Commission's rules for secondary use.
The Commission also intends to be in continuous communication with the
public safety community to ascertain the extent of public safety use of
the 700 MHz Band to help ensure that public safety agencies are able to
operate free from harmful interference.
20. Other Arguments. The Commission is not persuaded by certain
commenters that the Commission should delay the transitioning of low
power auxiliary stations and discontinue our efforts to clear the 700
MHz Band of wireless microphones for public safety and commercial use
because some LPTV stations, TV translators, and Class A stations are
continuing to operate in the 700 MHz Band after the transition. The
Commission need to establish expeditious time frames and procedures for
clearing wireless microphones from the 700 MHz band on the Commission's
path to providing an interference-free environment for new services in
the 700 MHz Band, especially public safety services that are used to
protect safety of life, health, or property. Considerations affecting
broadcast services other than full-power television broadcast
operations should not delay the clearing of wireless microphones.
21. The Commission also declines to adopt Nady's proposal that our
transition plan should provide for the negotiation of relocation. As
stated above, entities currently operating low power auxiliary
stations, including wireless microphones, may continue to operate in
the 700 MHz Band until June 12, 2010, subject to the conditions set
forth in this Report and Order. Accordingly, the Commission is allowing
them to operate in the 700 MHz Band for some time during the transition
period. These operators, however, must accept interference from other
licensees in the band and must not cause interference to 700 MHz
licensees during this transition period, and also are subject to the
other conditions the Commission adopt herein, including the requirement
to cease operations under the early clearing notification procedures.
22. The Commission denies as well the requests by WCA and PISC that
the Commission not provide a transition but adopt a waiver procedure
for licensed wireless microphone operations in the 700 MHz Band after
the end of the DTV transition. The Commission finds that the waiver
procedures requested by these parties are not necessary. First, parties
may always request a waiver under the general waiver provisions in our
rules. Second, the Commission does not find that a separate waiver
provision is warranted because of our determination to allow a limited
transition period during which users may operate low power auxiliary
stations. The Commission is making clear in its rules that entities
operating low power auxiliary stations, including wireless microphones,
in the 700 MHz Band may continue to operate on those frequencies until
June 12, 2010, subject to the conditions adopted herein. Some
operations by low power auxiliary station users in the band may be
required to end prior to that time under the 60-day notice procedure
that the Commission is adopting. The Commission therefore denies their
requests that the Commission adopt a waiver procedure for authorized
wireless microphones and other low power auxiliary stations operating
in the 700 MHz Band.
23. Furthermore, the Commission finds that the steps the Commission
is
[[Page 3627]]
taking in this order sufficiently address arguments raised by some
parties that there is insufficient spectrum for wireless microphone
users outside of the 700 MHz Band, or that replacement spectrum should
be made available for wireless microphone operations. As explained
elsewhere in this Report and Order, the Commission is adopting an
approach that will permit wireless microphone operations to continue on
a temporary basis in the 700 MHz Band and in the core TV bands while
the Commission considers final rules on the issues addressed in the
FNPRM. Under the first step for moving ahead under this approach, the
Commission is waiving its part 15 rules to permit unauthorized wireless
microphone users to operate in the 700 MHz Band on an unlicensed basis
until June 12, 2010, and to permit operation of wireless microphones in
the core TV bands on the same unlicensed basis until the effective date
of the rules that will be adopted in response to the FNPRM. Under the
next step, the Commission proposes and seeks comment in the FNPRM on
specific rules for operation of wireless microphones under part 15 of
the rules in the TV bands, and the Commission seeks comment on some
expansion of the licensee eligibility for part 74 low power auxiliary
stations. The Commission also seeks comment on possible revisions to
its part 90 rules for licensed operation of wireless microphones. The
FNPRM will allow the Commission to consider the use of certain spectrum
outside of the 700 MHz Band by wireless microphones, and provides a
reasonable and efficient path forward to examine the future of wireless
microphone operations.
24. Finally, the Commission concludes that the steps the Commission
has taken in this Report and Order are sufficient to address concerns
that the presence of low power auxiliary station users operating in the
700 MHz Band would impede the ability of 700 MHz commercial licensees
to comply with their build-out requirements such that they should be
granted additional time to meet these requirements. Given that the
steps the Commission take enable these 700 MHz licensees to begin
operating in areas in the band based on the licensees' own timetables,
the Commission finds that these licensees' ability to meet their build-
out obligations will not be hampered by interference from low power
auxiliary stations, and the Commission reject proposals to delay
implementation of 700 MHz construction requirements. For these same
reasons, the Commission also rejects MetroPCS's argument that a delay
in clearing the band could constitute a de facto modification of its
licenses.
25. The rules adopted in this Report and Order with respect to the
clearing of the 700 MHz Band by June 12, 2010 and the early clearing
procedures will take effect upon the publication of a summary of this
Report and Order in the Federal Register. The Commission finds that
there is good cause for departure from the 30-day delay in the
effective date under the Administrative Procedure Act. In this Report
and Order, the Commission is taking steps to expedite the availability
of unencumbered spectrum for public safety and new commercial
licensees, in order that such licensees will be able to operate without
interference in the 700 MHz Band. The Commission finds that under these
circumstances, a further delay in the effective date of the clearing
procedure rules would be contrary to the public interest.
B. Prohibition of the Manufacture, Import, Sale, Lease, Offer for Sale
or Lease, or Shipment of 700 MHz Band Low Power Auxiliary Stations
26. The Commission revises its rules to prohibit the manufacture,
import, sale, lease, offer for sale or lease, or shipment of low power
auxiliary stations for operation in the 700 MHz Band in the United
States, effective upon the publication of a summary of this Report and
Order in the Federal Register. The Commission finds that this
prohibition serves the public interest because it will provide greater
assurance that the 700 MHz Band will be made available to public safety
and new commercial licensees.
27. The Communications Act of 1934, as amended, authorizes the
Commission ``consistent with the public interest, convenience, and
necessity, [to] make reasonable regulations * * * governing the
interference potential of devices which in their operation are capable
of emitting radio frequency energy by radiation, conduction, or other
means in sufficient degree to cause harmful interference to radio
communications'' and these regulations ``shall be applicable to the
manufacture, import, sale, offer for sale, or shipment of such devices
* * *, and to the use of such devices.'' The Act further provides that
``[n]o person shall manufacture, import, sell, offer for sale, or ship
devices * * *, or use devices, which fail to comply with regulations
promulgated pursuant to this section.''
28. The Commissions decision to prohibit the manufacture, import,
sale, lease, offer for sale or lease, or shipment of low power
auxiliary stations that operate in the 700 MHz Band is necessary to
ensure that new services in this valuable spectrum will be provided
without interruption to benefit all Americans. Public safety agencies
are already making use of the 700 MHz Band, and deployment of
additional public safety systems is expected to proceed at a rapid
pace. Commercial wireless providers are currently preparing to deploy
advanced systems that will support new and faster wireless broadband
services, once the spectrum is available at the conclusion of the DTV
transition.
29. This prohibition is a reasonable corollary to the Commission's
decision in this Report and Order to prohibit the operation of low
power auxiliary stations in the 700 MHz Band permanently after June 12,
2010, subject to conditions that would require their operation to cease
at an earlier date. Since low power auxiliary station equipment will no
longer be allowed to operate in the 700 MHz Band after June 12, 2010,
the Commission must also prohibit the manufacture, sale, and all other
steps that would make wireless microphones available for use in the 700
MHz Band. The prohibition on manufacture, sale, and lease of devices
addresses concerns about the potential for increased interference to
700 MHz licensees, including public safety users, by decreasing the
number of devices available for use in the band. For the same reason,
it also addresses concerns about the proliferation of unauthorized uses
in the band. The Commission notes that Shure, one of the largest
manufacturers of wireless microphone equipment, states that it no
longer manufactures 700 MHz equipment for use in the U.S., and that
Audio-Technica, another large manufacturer of wireless microphones,
ceased development of new 700 MHz equipment approximately eight years
ago. In addition, allowing the sale or lease of devices that can
operate in the 700 MHz Band is inconsistent with our goal of taking all
steps necessary to make this spectrum available both to public safety
and commercial licensees.
30. The Commission rejects Sennheiser's argument that the
Commission delays the implementation of the ban on the marketing of
devices. The Commission neither agrees that the lead time for
implementation of the ban is unreasonable, nor that the Commission must
wait for actual interference to occur. As the Commission discusses in
this section, in adopting the ban the Commission is particularly
concerned with the use of
[[Page 3628]]
the spectrum at a time when the spectrum is to be available for new
licensees and new services. Moreover, contrary to Sennheiser's
assertions, and as the Commission discusses elsewhere in this Report
and Order, the Commission finds that sufficient notice was provided
indicating that the use of the 700 MHz Band by wireless microphones and
other low power auxiliary stations would no longer be authorized.
Elsewhere in this Report and Order, the Commission finds that entities
operating low power auxiliary stations in the 700 MHz Band must cease
operations of those devices in the band after June 12, 2010, subject to
the early clearing conditions set forth in this Report and Order.
Therefore, it would not serve the public interest to permit the
manufacturing and marketing of equipment that can be used in the 700
MHz Band beyond June 12, 2010, and earlier where the clearing
mechanisms the Commission are adopting are utilized.
31. Consistent with the arguments of Shure and Sennheiser, the
Commission does not prohibit manufacturers from manufacturing low power
auxiliary stations, including wireless microphones, for export. The
provisions of Section 302 of the Act, as amended, which addresses,
among other matters, the prohibition of the manufacture, import, sale,
offer for sale, or shipment of devices, are not applicable to ``devices
or home electronic equipment and systems manufactured solely for
export. * * *'' Accordingly, the Commission clarifies that its decision
today to prohibit the manufacture, import, sale, lease, offer for sale
or lease, or shipment of low power auxiliary stations that operate in
the 700 MHz Band is not applicable to devices manufactured solely for
export. Finally, the Commission revises its rules to require that any
person who manufactures, sells, leases, or offers for sale or lease low
power auxiliary stations, including wireless microphones, that are
destined for non-U.S. markets and that are capable of operating in the
700 MHz Band shall include labeling in all sales, marketing, and
packaging materials, including online materials, related to such
devices. The labeling must make clear that the devices cannot be used
in the United States. The Commission finds that this rule is consistent
with the public interest, convenience, and necessity.
32. To protect consumers in the United States, and to help ensure
that no wireless microphones and other low power auxiliary stations
that operate in the 700 MHz Band continue to be made available for use
in contravention of our efforts to remove those devices from the band
in the United States, the Commission require retailers to remove from
display (including online display) any low power auxiliary stations,
including wireless microphones, that can operate in the 700 MHz Band,
as well as any marketing material that does not comply with the
requirements adopted herein.
33. The rules relating to the prohibition on the manufacture,
import, sale, lease, offer for sale or lease, or shipment of low power
auxiliary stations that operate in the 700 MHz Band will take effect
upon the publication of a summary of this Report and Order in the
Federal Register, except the labeling requirement for devices
manufactured solely for export. The Commission finds that there is good
cause for departure from the 30-day delay in the effective date under
the Administrative Procedure Act. In this Report and Order, the
Commission is taking steps to expedite the availability of unencumbered
spectrum for public safety and new commercial licensees consistent with
the Commission's long-standing goal of making the spectrum fully
available for those licensees. Under these circumstances, the
Commission finds that a delay in the effective date of the prohibition
would be contrary to the public interest. With respect to the labeling
requirement for devices manufactured solely for export, the Commission
find that this requirement should take effect 90 days after release of
this Report and Order (i.e., April 15, 2010). This period provides
sufficient time for entities that manufacture, sell, lease, or offer
for sale or lease low power auxiliary stations that are destined for
non-U.S. markets and that are capable of operating in the 700 MHz Band
to comply with this labeling requirement.
C. Procedures To Modify Licenses
34. For the reasons set forth above, the Commission concludes that
the public interest would be best served by clarifying that entities
operating low power auxiliary stations, including wireless microphones,
in the 700 MHz Band may continue to operate in that band until June 12,
2010, but only under the conditions adopted in this Report and Order.
Accordingly, through this rulemaking proceeding, the Commission hereby
modifies the licenses of all low power auxiliary stations that
authorize operation in the 700 MHz Band (i.e., 698-806 MHz) to delete
the authorization to operate on this particular spectrum, effective
June 12, 2010. In the event that any low power auxiliary station must
cease operations prior to June 12, 2010 under the clearing mechanisms
the Commission adopts in the Report and Order, then the license
relating to that low power auxiliary station will be modified
automatically without Commission action to delete the authorization to
operate on the 700 MHz Band effective on the date that operations are
required to cease in the band. In taking this action, the Commission
implements its decisions to ensure that the effective use of the 700
MHz Band by public safety and commercial licensees at the end of the
DTV transition is not compromised, and that these new licensees will be
able to operate free from interference by low power auxiliary stations
operating in the 700 MHz Band.
35. Most low power auxiliary station licensees that are authorized
to operate in the 700 MHz Band are also authorized to operate in a
number of other bands that are specified in Section 74.802 of the
Commission rules. These multiple band licensees may continue to operate
in other bands identified in their licenses without further Commission
action. Those licensees, however, whose current authorization limits
them in whole or in significant part to operations in the 700 MHz Band
can be accommodated with the use of spectrum from other spectrum bands
that are available for low power auxiliary station operations under
Section 74.802 of the rules. Such licensees may wish to consult with a
local Society of Broadcast Engineers (SBE) coordinator to identify
suitable spectrum from the core TV bands that are available for low
power auxiliary station operations under Section 74.802 of the rules.
Once replacement spectrum has been identified, as a matter of
administrative convenience, the licensee should file an application to
modify its authorization to include the identified frequencies. This
will enable the Wireless Telecommunications Bureau (Bureau) to modify
the affected license in conformance with the revised rules adopted in
this order.
D. Unlicensed Operation of Wireless Microphones Under Part 15; Waivers
36. The Commission concludes that it serves the public interest to
waive two of its part 15 rules, to permit unauthorized users of low
power auxiliary stations, including wireless microphones, to operate on
an unlicensed basis under part 15 pursuant to certain specified
technical requirements, in the 700 MHz Band until June 12, 2010 and in
the core TV bands until the effective date of Commission action taken
in response to the FNPRM. The Commission
[[Page 3629]]
anticipates that such unlicensed operations in the core TV bands
pursuant to waiver will remain in place only for a short period of
time, as the Commission intends to act expeditiously on its proposal to
promulgate final rules that would authorize these operations on a
permanent basis. Accordingly, the Commission waives Sections 15.201(b)
and 15.209(a) of our part 15 technical rules. These waivers will permit
entities that operate wireless microphones in the 700 MHz Band without
the required license to continue those operations subject to the band
clearing mechanisms that the Commission adopts in this Report and
Order, and permit them to relocate their operations to the core TV
bands on the same part 15 unlicensed basis. The waivers also will
permit operation of wireless microphones outside of the 700 MHz Band
without the required authorization. The operation of wireless
microphones in the 700 MHz Band under these limited term waivers will
be subject to the band clearing mechanisms the Commission adopts in
this Report and Order. Thus, all entities may continue operating
wireless microphones in the 700 MHz Band until June 12, 2010, unless
they must cease operations sooner under the early band clearing
mechanisms discussed above. During the temporary waiver period, any
entity that chooses to operate a wireless microphone under these
waivers must comply with the waiver conditions, including compliance
with specified technical requirements that are identical to those the
Commission is proposing in the FNPRM for the operation of wireless
microphones under part 15. See Amendment of Part 101 of the
Commission's Rules to Accommodate 39 Megahertz Channels in the 6525-
6875 MHz Band; Amendment of Part 101 of the Commission's Rules to
Provide for Conditional Authorization on Additional Channels in the
21.8-22.0 GHz and 23.0-23.2 GHz Band; Fixed Wireless Communications
Coalition Request for Waiver, Notice of Proposed Rulemaking and Order
in WTB Docket No. 09-114 and RM-11417, at paras. 23-24 (released Jun.
29, 2009) (granting request for waiver of Section 101.31(b)(vii) to
allow for conditional authority under conditions that were proposed as
rule changes in the NPRM portion of the decision).
37. Under these waivers, wireless microphones may be operated as
part 15 devices without a license in the 700 MHz Band under the
conditions adopted in this Report and Order, and they can also operate
in the core TV bands. Operation under these waivers is subject to the
following conditions. First, the wireless microphones must comply with
specified technical requirements under part 15, which are the same
technical rules that the Commission is proposing in the FNPRM for
wireless microphone operations under part 15 (as set forth in Appendix
E, below). Second, the devices must be certificated under the rules
applicable to certification under our part 74, Subpart H rules. Third,
the devices shall not cause harmful interference and must accept any
interference received pursuant to Section 15.5 of our Rules. Finally,
users operating in the 700 MHz Band must comply with the conditions for
continued operation in that band during the transition period,
including the early clearing procedures discussed above. The waivers
will be effective upon the release of the Report and Order.
38. Section 1.3 of the Commission's rules provides that ``[a]ny
provision of the rules may be waived by the Commission on its own
motion or on petition if good cause therefore is shown'' subject to the
provisions of the APA and its own rules. A waiver is appropriate when
``particular facts would make strict compliance inconsistent with the
public interest.'' A waiver cannot undermine the purposes of the rule,
and there must be a stronger public interest benefit in granting the
waiver than in applying the rule. As discussed below, the Commission
finds that good cause exists to waive Sections 15.201(b) and 15.209(a)
of our part 15 technical rules in order to allow operation of wireless
microphones in the 700 MHz Band and the core TV bands for a limited
period.
39. The Commission is allowing operation of wireless microphones
under these waivers to use a power of up to 50 milliwatts. The waivers
should allow wireless microphones to operate outside of the 700 MHz
Band in a manner that is largely consistent with their current
operations. While part 74 rules permit wireless microphones to operate
on VHF TV channels with a power level to the antenna of 50 milliwatts
and on UHF channels with a power level of 250 milliwatts, two equipment
manufacturers indicate that the actual power levels for most wireless
microphones operating in the 700 MHz Band are in the 10-50 milliwatts
range. We also note that a large majority of wireless microphones are
certificated to operate with a power level of 50 milliwatts or less.
These appear to be the most popular devices because the 50 milliwatts
or less is sufficient for most uses and extends battery life. While
some wireless microphones operate at power levels of 250 milliwatts, it
appears most of these devices are used for professional applications
requiring a longer operating range with a short duration of operation,
such as electronic news gathering or movie production users that hold
part 74 authorizations. In this regard, the Commission notes that
devices authorized under part 74 as low power auxiliary stations are
``intended to transmit over distances of approximately 100 meters'' and
may operate with a power level of 250 milliwatts. The Commission
anticipates that wireless microphones operating up to 50 milliwatts
under the terms of this waiver would transmit over a shorter distance.
Therefore, the Commission believes that the operations that the
Commission is allowing under the waivers will effectively accommodate
users that are currently unauthorized. The Commission is not extending
the waiver to permit these wireless microphone users to operate at
power levels higher than 50 milliwatts because, unless operated on a
licensed basis pursuant to part 74 requirements, use of these devices
generally poses a greater interference risk to TV band licensees. Only
Part 74 licensees are permitted to operate their devices at power
levels higher than 50 milliwatts.
40. The Commission recognizes, however, that there may be instances
where operation at a power level higher than 50 milliwatts may be
needed and can be allowed without causing interference. The Commission
finds that such instances should be evaluated based on their individual
facts and circumstances to ensure that interference will not occur. The
Commission therefore grants delegated authority to the Office of
Engineering and Technology and Wireless Telecommunications Bureau to
modify the limited waiver of the part 15 rules on a case-by-case basis
to permit entities to operate wireless microphones at power levels
higher than 50 mW where it can be shown there is no significant risk of
harmful interference to other users of the spectrum, particularly to TV
broadcast service.
41. The Commission finds that good cause for a limited waiver
exists in this particular case, given the totality of the circumstances
including the short-term nature of these waivers and the need to
facilitate clearing of the 700 MHz band for use by the public safety
and commercial licensees. For the same reasons that the Commission
finds good cause exists for granting this waiver, as discussed in this
Report and Order, the Commission has determined that there
[[Page 3630]]
would be good cause under Section 553(b)(3)(B) of the APA, 5 U.S.C.
553(b)(3)(B), for establishing interim rules that permit the same range
of operations as the waiver. The Commission also finds that it serves
the public interest to provide access to other spectrum for entities
that are operating wireless microphones in the 700 MHz Band while this
rulemaking is pending. Our primary goal in this proceeding is to clear
all wireless microphones from the 700 MHz Band, thereby simplifying the
process of making this spectrum fully available for public safety and
commercial broadband licensees. In order to attain this goal, the
Commission intends to have any wireless microphone user, authorized or
not, transition out of the 700 MHz band and onto other available
frequencies no later than June 12, 2010. Granting these waivers will
allow currently unauthorized users that vacate the 700 MHz Band to
operate in the 700 MHz Band temporarily under the umbrella of
unlicensed part 15 operation. At the same time, the conditions the
Commission imposes serve the public interest intent behind each of the
two specific part 15 rules being waived, which is to prevent
interference to authorized radio services. The power limits, minimum
co-channel TV broadcast station distance provisions, specific frequency
operation, and out-of-band emissions limits established herein provide
safeguards to ensure that the policy objectives served by Sections
15.201(b) and 15.209(a) are met. Finally, the Commission notes that any
operation of wireless microphones pursuant to the waivers is subject to
the Section 15.5 interference restrictions. Taken together, these
safeguards ensure that any operation done pursuant to the waivers will
not undermine the purposes of, and public interest protected by,
Sections 15.201(b) and 15.209(a).
42. The record in this proceeding includes a number of comments
that describe the need for and the significance of wireless microphones
in providing quality audio technology for performances and programs in
theaters, classrooms, lecture halls, houses of worship, stadiums, and
other venues. The Commission finds that temporarily waiving these two
rules in order to permit the continued operation of wireless
microphones, including wireless microphones that are used for these
purposes, pending our final decisions of the issues raised in the FNPRM
will provide this Commission with the opportunity to develop a full and
balanced record before it adopts final, comprehensive rules that
address the operation of wireless microphones by those entities that
lack the required license. In addition, the Commission notes that some
entities will be acquiring new wireless microphone equipment to operate
in bands outside of the 700 MHz Band to replace their existing
equipment, while some equipment that operates in the 700 MHz Band may
be capable of being modified to operate in the core TV band spectrum.
The waivers permitting operations will allow at least some of these
users to make informed decisions with respect to new equipment
purchases, or where applicable the modification of existing equipment,
until the issues raised in the FNPRM are resolved. The Commission
emphasizes that there are a variety of unique facts surrounding grant
of this waiver, and the Commission does not anticipate that the
Commission will soon encounter such a convergence of factors as these
to warrant the type of accommodation afforded here.
43. While the Commission finds good cause for granting the limited
term waivers, as discussed above, we stress that these waivers are
temporary and that the granting of these waivers will not prejudice the
outcome of this proceeding or otherwise limit the Commission's choices
therein. Under this approach, the Commission will be able to compile a
record and consider more fully the issues and proposals in response to
the FNPRM concerning currently unauthorized users of wireless
microphones, including whether to expand eligibility for licenses under
part 74.
44. In order to address the potential for interference from the
operation of wireless microphones in the core TV Bands, the Commission
requires that all wireless microphones operating under the waivers are
subject to the same technical limitations that the Commission is
proposing in the FNPRM for the operation of ``Wireless Audio Devices''
under part 15. These technical rules provide for distances from
existing co-channel TV broadcast stations, specific frequency
operation, power limits, and out-of-band emissions. In addition, the
unlicensed operators of wireless microphones that operate under the
waivers will be subject to the restrictions in part 15 of the rules.
The immediate and potential future harm to current TV band licensees of
continued widespread use of previously unauthorized wireless
microphones appears to be negligible, in light of the conditions the
Commission is imposing on the waivers, including that the wireless
microphones must comply with the specified technical requirements
(consistent with those proposed for part 15 wireless microphone
operations in the core TV bands, as set forth in the proposed rules)
and that they must not cause harmful interference to licensed TV band
users. The Commission notes that licensees that operate low power
auxiliary devices under part 74 authorization will still receive
interference protection with respect to wireless microphones that will
be operating through these temporary waivers as unlicensed devices.
45. Given the actions the Commission is taking today, the
Commission does not adopt PISC's remaining proposals, including that
the Commission provide a ``general amnesty'' to certain unauthorized
wireless microphone users. The Commission finds that various steps that
the Commission is taking today appropriately address, on a going
forward basis, the issues relating to the proliferation and use of
wireless microphones that have not heretofore been authorized. Finally,
the Commission does not rule at this time on PISC's proposal to create
a General Wireless Microphone Service that would be licensed by rule
pursuant to Section 307(e) of the Act. The Commission does not address
at this time questions relating to the unauthorized use of wireless
microphones prior to our actions today. The Commission instead seeks to
address its concerns in the order that considers the issues set forth
in the FNPRM.
E. Disclosure Requirements and Consumer Outreach
46. Based on this record, the Commission adopts certain measures,
including point-of-sale disclosure requirements, to addre