Supplemental Revenue Assistance Payments Program, 68480-68498 [E9-30632]
Download as PDF
68480
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
before parties may file suit in court
challenging this rule.
National Environmental Policy Act
An environmental assessment and
finding of no significant impact have
been prepared for this final rule. The
environmental assessment provides a
basis for the conclusion that the removal
of certain rinderpest and FMD-related
prohibitions and restrictions on the
importation into the United States of
ruminants, or fresh (chilled or frozen)
meat or other products of ruminants,
from the Republic of Korea will not
have a significant impact on the quality
of the human environment. Based on
the finding of no significant impact, the
Administrator of the Animal and Plant
Health Inspection Service has
determined that an environmental
impact statement need not be prepared.
The environmental assessment and
finding of no significant impact were
prepared in accordance with: (1) The
National Environmental Policy Act of
1969 (NEPA), as amended (42 U.S.C.
4321 et seq.), (2) regulations of the
Council on Environmental Quality for
implementing the procedural provisions
of NEPA (40 CFR parts 1500-1508), (3)
USDA regulations implementing NEPA
(7 CFR part 1b), and (4) APHIS’ NEPA
Implementing Procedures (7 CFR part
372).
The environmental assessment and
finding of no significant impact may be
viewed on the Regulations.gov Web
site.3 Copies of the environmental
assessment and finding of no significant
impact are also available for public
inspection at USDA, room 1141, South
Building, 14th Street and Independence
Avenue SW., Washington, DC, between
8 a.m. and 4:30 p.m., Monday through
Friday, except holidays. Persons
wishing to inspect copies are requested
to call ahead on (202) 690-2817 to
facilitate entry into the reading room. In
addition, copies may be obtained by
writing to the individual listed under
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT.
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
Paperwork Reduction Act
This final rule contains no
information collection or recordkeeping
requirements under the Paperwork
Reduction Act of 1995 (44 U.S.C. 3501
et seq.).
List of Subjects in 9 CFR Part 94
Animal diseases, Imports, Livestock,
Meat and meat products, Milk, Poultry
and poultry products, Reporting and
recordkeeping requirements.
■ Accordingly, we are amending 9 CFR
part 94 as follows:
3
See footnote 1.
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
PART 94—RINDERPEST, FOOT-ANDMOUTH DISEASE, EXOTIC
NEWCASTLE DISEASE, AFRICAN
SWINE FEVER, CLASSICAL SWINE
FEVER, SWINE VESICULAR DISEASE,
AND BOVINE SPONGIFORM
ENCEPHALOPATHY: PROHIBITED
AND RESTRICTED IMPORTATIONS
1. The authority citation for part 94
continues to read as follows:
■
Authority: 7 U.S.C. 450, 7701-7772, 77817786, and 8301-8317; 21 U.S.C. 136 and
136a; 31 U.S.C. 9701; 7 CFR 2.22, 2.80, and
371.4.
§ 94.1
[Amended]
2. In § 94.1, paragraph (a)(2) is
amended by adding the words
‘‘Republic of Korea,’’ after the word
‘‘Japan,’’.
■
§ 94.11
[Amended]
3. In § 94.11, paragraph (a) is amended
by adding the words ‘‘Republic of
Korea,’’ after the word ‘‘Japan,’’.
■
Done in Washington, DC, this 16th day
of December 2009.
Kevin Shea
Acting Administrator, Animal and Plant
Health Inspection Service.
[FR Doc. E9–30668 Filed 12–24–09: 12:36
pm]
BILLING CODE: 3410–34–S
DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
Farm Service Agency
7 CFR Part 760
RIN 0560–AH90
Supplemental Revenue Assistance
Payments Program
Farm Service Agency, USDA.
Final rule.
AGENCY:
ACTION:
SUMMARY: This rule implements specific
requirements for the new Supplemental
Revenue Assistance Payments Program
(SURE) authorized by the Food,
Conservation, and Energy Act of 2008
(the 2008 Farm Bill). SURE provides
disaster assistance to eligible
participants who have experienced
qualifying crop production losses, or
crop quality losses, or both, occurring in
crop year 2008 through September 30,
2011. All crops for which crop
insurance or noninsured crop disaster
assistance program (NAP) coverage is
available are eligible crops for SURE. To
be eligible for SURE payments,
participants must meet a risk
management purchase requirement,
with some exceptions, and have
PO 00000
Frm 00004
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
suffered a qualifying loss due to
disaster. A qualifying loss is a loss of at
least 10 percent of a crop of economic
significance on a participant’s farm in a
disaster county (a county for which a
Secretarial disaster declaration has been
issued or a county contiguous to such a
county), or on a participant’s farm with
an overall loss greater than 50 percent
of normal production (expected revenue
for all crops on the farm) due to disaster.
This rule specifies how a qualifying loss
is determined, how SURE payments are
calculated, and how and when
participants may apply for payment.
DATES: Effective Date: December 22,
2009.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Steven J. Peterson, Branch Chief,
Disaster Assistance Branch, Production,
Emergencies, and Compliance Division;
Farm Service Agency; United States
Department of Agriculture, STOP 0517,
1400 Independence Avenue, SW.,
Washington, DC 20250–0517; telephone
(202) 720–5172; e-mail
Steve.Peterson@wdc.usda.gov. Persons
with disabilities who require alternative
means of communication (Braille, large
print, audio tape, etc.) should contact
the USDA Target Center at (202) 720–
2600 (voice and TDD).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Background
This rule implements specific
requirements for the SURE program
authorized by the 2008 Farm Bill (Pub.
L. 110–246) and amendments to the
2008 Farm Bill contained in the
Consolidated Security, Disaster
Assistance, and Continuing
Appropriations Act, 2009 (Pub. L. 110–
329), an Act to Amend the Commodity
Provisions of the Food, Conservation,
and Energy Act of 2008 and for other
purposes (Pub. L. 110–398), and the
American Recovery and Reinvestment
Act of 2009 (Pub. L. 111–005, the
Recovery Act). The basic core of the
SURE program is specified in the 2008
Farm Bill. With the exception of the
Recovery Act, the subsequent
amendments were technical in nature;
the amendments are discussed below.
Sections 12033 and 15101 of the 2008
Farm Bill authorize the Secretary of
Agriculture (Secretary) to provide
assistance to eligible participants with
certain crop losses. Under this
authority, FSA is establishing SURE, a
new permanent disaster assistance
program, providing payments to eligible
participants who suffered a qualifying
loss and who met the risk management
purchase requirement.
FSA will administer SURE using
funds from the Agricultural Disaster
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
Relief Trust Fund established under
section 902 of the Trade Act of 1974 (19
U.S.C. 2497a), as specified in the 2008
Farm Bill. The disaster assistance
programs authorized by the 2008 Farm
Bill are permanent or ‘‘standing’’
disaster assistance programs, some of
which have similar scope to previous ad
hoc programs. The programs are
provided for in two separate places in
the 2008 Farm Bill. First, section 12033
adds a new section 531 to the Federal
Crop Insurance Act (7 U.S.C. 1501–
1524). Second, section 15101 adds
sections 901, 902, and 903 to the Trade
Act of 1974. The provisions of the two
sections as enacted are identical except
that the Trade Act of 1974 provisions
contain the Trust Fund provisions. The
two sections of the 2008 Farm Bill are
considered to be interchangeable for the
purposes of this rule.
SURE is one of five new standing
disaster programs authorized by the
2008 Farm Bill. The five new programs
are:
• Livestock Indemnity Program (LIP);
• Livestock Forage Disaster Program
(LFP);
• Emergency Assistance for
Livestock, Honey Bees, and Farm-Raised
Fish (ELAP);
• Supplemental Revenue Assistance
Payments Program (SURE); and
• Tree Assistance Program (TAP).
The programs are being implemented
through separate rulemakings;
regulations for each of the programs will
be implemented in separate subparts of
7 CFR part 760. This rule implements
SURE in 7 CFR part 760, subpart G. The
LIP final rule, which was published in
the Federal Register on July 2, 2009 (74
FR 31567–31578) implemented LIP in 7
CFR part 760, subpart E, and
implemented general provisions
applicable to more than one program in
7 CFR part 760, subpart B. The ELAP
and LFP final rule, which was
published in the Federal Register on
September 11, 2009 (74 FR 46665–
46683) implemented ELAP in 7 CFR
part 760, subpart C, and implemented
LFP in 7 CFR part 760, subpart D.
SURE covers some expected revenue
or production losses not covered under
other Supplemental Agricultural
Disaster Assistance programs
established by the 2008 Farm Bill. For
example, losses to catfish, crawfish, and
other aquaculture species are not
covered by LIP, but are covered under
SURE because they are eligible for NAP
coverage. In other cases, losses are
covered by the other programs but not
by SURE. For example, losses to honey
bees due to colony collapse disorder are
covered by ELAP but not by SURE.
Livestock, feed emergency, and grazing
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
losses are not covered by SURE but are
covered by LIP, ELAP, and LFP. Losses
to tree crops (apples, citrus) are covered
by SURE, while losses to trees that
produce crops are covered by TAP.
Legislative Amendments to the SURE
Program
Technical amendments made by
legislation enacted after the 2008 Farm
Bill included a clarification of terms and
some newly defined terms, added the 10
percent actual production loss
minimum of an economically significant
crop to be a qualifying loss, excluded
subsequently planted crops in most
cases, specified that regional variations
should be considered consistent with
crop insurance and NAP in establishing
average market prices, and allowed
additional waivers or exceptions to the
risk management purchase requirement
for certain years.
The Recovery Act amendments
allowed an additional waiver for the
2008 crop year only under certain
situations and increased the amount of
assistance for 2008 qualifying losses. It
also authorized the Secretary discretion
to provide equitable treatment for
participants suffering multi-year losses
and for participants who lacked access
to insurance or NAP.
Terms Used in This Rule
This final rule uses the words
‘‘producers’’ and ‘‘participants.’’
Producers may apply for SURE.
Participants are those producers that
meet the requirements to be eligible
producers to receive SURE payments.
Sections 12033 and 15101 of the 2008
Farm Bill include the words assistance,
benefits, compensation, relief, and
payments. The form of SURE assistance,
benefit, relief, or compensation for
eligible participants is a payment
calculated as specified in this rule.
Therefore, this rule uses the word
payment to represent the assistance,
benefit, relief, and compensation that
participants will receive.
One part of the payment calculation is
the guarantee or ‘‘SURE guarantee’’,
which is a ‘‘guaranteed’’ level of
revenue for the farm based on the
planted or prevented planted acres, the
yield, past production history, and the
level of crop insurance selected, among
other things. The SURE payment is
based on 60 percent of the difference
between this guarantee and the total
revenue on the farm as calculated in
accordance with the 2008 Farm Bill.
In general, the word ‘‘production’’
represents the quantity or amount of a
crop produced (or harvested). In some
terms that include the word
‘‘production’’ it represents the dollar
PO 00000
Frm 00005
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
68481
value or the price of the crop, such as
‘‘normal production on the farm’’ which
is defined in this rule. Because the
production for the farm is the total of all
the crops produced on the farm, which
may be measured in different physical
units, the total production of multiple
crops on a farm is most sensibly
represented in terms of dollar value
rather than (for example) using bushels
as the unit of measure for production on
a farm that produces corn, hay, and
catfish.
This rule defines ‘‘salvage value’’ as
the dollar amount or equivalent value
when the commodity cannot be sold in
any recognized market for that crop. For
example, popcorn that does not meet
the standards for popcorn would have
‘‘salvage value’’ as livestock feed.
The word ‘‘crop’’ and ‘‘commodity’’
were used in the 2008 Farm Bill. This
rule generally uses ‘‘crop,’’ except in
cases where ‘‘commodity’’ must be used
to be consistent with other regulations
and programs.
Definitions
This rule includes terms defined or
otherwise used in the 2008 Farm Bill as
required to implement the SURE
program. In some instances, terms
defined in the 2008 Farm Bill have been
modified based on agency interpretation
and to add further clarity. For example,
the term ‘‘disaster county’’ appears in
the 2008 Farm Bill and specifies that a
disaster county, in addition to meaning
a county included in a Secretarial
natural disaster declaration, or a county
contiguous to such county, is any farm
having actual production less than 50
percent of normal during a crop year.
These regulations make clear that one
farm having a loss of 50 percent or more
does not make the farm or the county or
counties in which the farm is or are
located an actual disaster county.
Rather, the disaster county term is
defined to only include those counties
that have a Secretarial natural disaster
declaration or a county contiguous to
such county (without regard to
participant or farm losses).
Other clarifications to definitions in
the 2008 Farm Bill include using
consistent words and terms as specified
in this rule, adding information such as
citations, or otherwise clarifying the
definition. For example, this involves
using the word ‘‘crop’’ instead of the
word ‘‘commodity’’ where appropriate,
consistent references to ‘‘crop
insurance’’ and ‘‘crop insurance
indemnity,’’ and ‘‘participant’’ instead
of ‘‘producer.’’
The definition of the term ‘‘actual
production history yield’’ in the 2008
Farm Bill uses the term ‘‘weighted.’’ The
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
68482
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
definition in this rule refers to an
average instead of a weighted average.
We did this to clarify that the weighting
is done as part of the calculation of the
SURE yield; the actual production
history yield data from the NAP or RMA
program is actual yield data, not
weighted.
The definition of ‘‘actual production
on the farm’’ was expanded to
specifically include the calculation
information, which was referred to in
the definition in the 2008 Farm Bill. The
definition deleted the term ‘‘value of all
crops produced on the farm’’ as it would
have been redundant because the
calculations specify a component is the
price of the crop or the value of
inventory. The definition was also
expanded to specify how value loss
crops would be included in the
calculation.
The definition of ‘‘adjusted actual
production history yield’’ was expanded
to specify the minimum amount, and
specify that it is the ‘‘average of the
production history’’ instead of the
‘‘actual production history,’’ to clarify
that since the Farm Bill also specified
that 4 years of production history are
taken into account, that clearly should
be an average rather than a sum.
The definition of ‘‘adjusted NAP
yield’’ was expanded to specify the
minimum amount, and specifying that it
is the ‘‘average of the production
history’’, rather than the NAP yield, to
be consistent with the ways ‘‘yield’’ and
‘‘production history’’ are used in other
terms in this rule.
The definition of ‘‘counter-cyclical
program payment yield’’ was clarified to
cite FSA implementing regulations
instead of citing various sections of
legislation.
‘‘Crop of economic significance’’ is
defined in the 2008 Farm Bill as having
a uniform meaning given it by the
Secretary for certain purposes as
specifically required by the 2008 Farm
Bill. In this rule, a crop of economic
significance means one that has
contributed at least 5 percent of the total
expected revenue of all of the
participant’s crops on the farm. That
would appear to be a fair level at which
a farmer might forego risk management
measures because of the relative size of
the crop. At this time, however, no
dollar expectation has been set so as to
require that the farm have expected
marketings of a certain level to qualify
a crop for SURE. However, the crop
must be one which is the subject of
normal marketings.
The definition of ‘‘farm’’ was clarified
such that ‘‘for sale’’ means ‘‘for normal
commercial sale’’ and was revised for
aquaculture based on the requirements
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
for the Aquaculture Grant Program, as
specified in the Recovery Act. ‘‘Normal’’
commercial sale in this regard would
mean sales in the normal channels of
commerce and would not include, for
example, ‘‘sales’’ to family members or
sales from hobby farms.
The definition of ‘‘noninsurable crop’’
specifies that the crop is a
‘‘commercially produced crop’’ because
NAP covered crops are commercially
produced crops for which crop
insurance is not available.
Some terms defined in this rule are
terms used in the 2008 Farm Bill, but
are not defined in the 2008 Farm Bill.
For example, the term ‘‘actual crop
acreage’’ is not defined in the 2008 Farm
Bill; however, for the purpose of SURE,
the term ‘‘actual crop acreage’’ is
defined to mean that it includes all
acreage of each crop planted or intended
to be planted on a farm. As is explained
below, the term ‘‘farm’’ is generally
defined expansively in SURE to include
all farming interests in which a
producer has an interest, no matter
where located. Another example is
‘‘appraised production,’’ which, when
applicable, will be used in determining
a farm’s production or revenue. The
term is defined in this rule as
production determined by FSA, or an
insurance provider approved by FCIC,
that was unharvested, but which was
determined to reflect the crop’s yield
potential at the time of appraisal.
‘‘Aquaculture’’ is defined to mean the
reproduction and rearing of aquatic
species in controlled or selected
environments as specified in part 1437
of this title.
SURE Compared to Previous Disaster
Programs
Some important differences between
SURE and previous programs are that
SURE payments are based on multi-crop
farm revenue, rather than losses to a
single crop, and that SURE is a
‘‘permanent’’ or ‘‘standing’’ program, for
losses in the time period covered in the
2008 Farm Bill (coverage begins with
the 2008 crop, and losses after
September 30, 2011 are not covered).
Previous ad hoc crop disaster programs
were typically limited to specific crops
damaged or destroyed during a specific
period of time in specific locations. In
contrast to previous programs that
addressed losses to particular crops,
SURE is an umbrella type of farm
revenue program that compliments and
augments protections that participants
have from various risk management
purchases. Under previous crop disaster
programs, producers typically requested
assistance for particular farm numbers,
or units. Under SURE, a participant’s
PO 00000
Frm 00006
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
assistance will be based on a ‘‘whole
farm,’’ which means the aggregation of
all crops in all counties in which the
participant has an interest that were
planted or intended to be planted for
harvest. Participants must have been
entitled to an ownership share of the
crop; contract growers are not eligible
participants for SURE unless they had
an ownership share and meet all other
eligibility criteria.
Payments will not be based on losses
to individual crops, although a loss of
a crop of economic significance is an
eligibility requirement.
Funding for the previous ad hoc crop
disaster programs was limited and
subject to a specific appropriation.
Funding for SURE is provided through
the Agricultural Disaster Relief Trust
Fund and payments will be distributed
to eligible participants as they qualify
for assistance.
Unlike some FSA and Commodity
Credit Corporation (CCC) programs,
participants do not need to pre-enroll or
sign up in advance (prior to the loss) for
SURE coverage in order to be eligible.
Participants who believe they may be
eligible for a SURE payment who satisfy
all eligibility criteria can submit an
application for payment. Such
application will be reviewed to
determine if the participant meets such
eligibility criteria.
Qualifying Loss
To receive SURE payments,
participants must have had a qualifying
loss. That means eligible participants
must have at least a 10 percent loss of
one crop of economic significance due
to disaster on either:
(1) A farm in a disaster county (a
county for which a Secretarial disaster
designation has been issued or in a
county contiguous to a county with a
Secretarial disaster designation), or
(2) A farm not located in a disaster
county or a county contiguous to such
a designated disaster county, that has an
overall production loss greater than or
equal to 50 percent of the normal
production on the farm (expected
revenue for all crops on the farm) due
to disaster.
A ‘‘crop of economic significance’’ is
one that generates or was expected to
generate at least 5 percent of the total
expected revenue of all of the crops on
the participant’s farm for the current
year. While other FSA programs may
use a higher percentage threshold in
order to determine whether a crop is
economically significant, SURE defines
crop of economic significance as having
at least 5 percent or more of the total
expected revenue from all of the
participant’s crops on the farm and
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
thereby increases the likelihood that
participants will have economically
significant crops and be eligible for
SURE.
A ‘‘disaster county’’ is one where
there has been a Secretarial disaster
declaration; it includes counties
contiguous to such counties declared a
disaster. Other kinds of disaster
declarations or designations, such as a
Presidential disaster declaration, are not
relevant to SURE, according to the terms
of the 2008 Farm Bill.
A farm includes all the crop acreage
in all the counties where a participant
has planted crops or intended to plant
crops for harvest for commercial sale or
on-farm livestock feeding. For
aquaculture and honey, a farm includes
all the acreage used for all aquaculture
species, bees, and beehives intended to
be harvested for sale by the eligible
participant in all counties.
A farm not located in a ‘‘disaster
county’’ may still be eligible for SURE
if it incurs, during a crop year, a
qualifying loss of production in which
the actual production on the farm is less
than 50 percent of the normal
production of the farm. Such loss
threshold is per farm, not per crop on
a farm. The actual total production for
the participant’s farm, as measured by
revenue from all crops and locations,
must be less than 50 percent of the
normal expected production to be a
qualifying loss. A loss of 50 percent of
one crop, or losses on one part of a farm
where the farm has crops in several
locations, will not necessarily be a
qualifying loss if the other crops or
locations or both had a less severe loss.
For this category of qualifying loss,
there is no requirement for a disaster
declaration.
Risk Management Purchase
Requirement
To be eligible for SURE payments,
producers must meet certain risk
management purchase requirements,
with some exceptions. Those
requirements are specified in 7 CFR part
760 subpart B, and apply to SURE.
The risk management purchase
requirements specify that eligible
participants must have purchased
insurance for each insurable crop; a few
exceptions allowed by the 2008 Farm
Bill are discussed later in this section.
An ‘‘insurable commodity’’ means an
agricultural commodity for which the
producer on the farm is eligible to
obtain a policy or plan of insurance
under the Federal Crop Insurance Act
(FCIA) from the USDA’s Risk
Management Agency (RMA). A
‘‘noninsurable commodity’’ means a
crop for which the eligible producers on
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
a farm are eligible to obtain assistance
through FSA’s noninsured crop disaster
assistance program (NAP). In general, to
be eligible for SURE payments,
participants must have obtained crop
insurance or NAP coverage, as may be
applicable, for all of their crops.
Producers who did not purchase
required coverage are not eligible for
benefits unless an exception applies.
Certain waivers for ‘‘socially
disadvantaged farmers and ranchers,’’ as
well as ‘‘limited resource farmers and
ranchers,’’ and ‘‘beginning farmers or
ranchers’’ are provided by the 2008
Farm Bill.
For the 2008 crop year, otherwise
eligible producers who paid a certain
buy-in fee were provided an exemption
from the risk management purchase
requirement that would otherwise apply
if the buy-in fee was paid by September
16, 2008. By an amendment to the 2008
Farm Bill, a second buy-in permitted
participants to buy in for the 2008 crop
year from February 17, 2009, up to May
18, 2009 to meet the risk management
purchase requirement; however, the
participant had to agree to buy crop
insurance or NAP for the next crop year
for the crops to which the buy-in
applied. The buy-in fee was equal to the
cost of the minimal catastrophic
insurance coverage or NAP coverage,
but did not, as with other buy-in
exemptions in SURE, entitle the
participant to such insurance or NAP
coverage. Also, an amendment to the
2008 Farm Bill allows a 2009 crop buyin if the 2009 Federal Crop Insurance
Corporation (FCIC) sales closing date for
a crop was prior to August 14, 2008. The
deadline for the 2009 crop buy-in was
January 12, 2009. In addition to these
provisions, section 531(g)(5) of the FCIA
(and the corresponding provisions of the
Trade Act of 1974; 7 U.S.C. 1531(g) and
19 U.S.C. 2497(g), respectively) have
some more general provisions allowing
the Secretary discretion to grant
equitable relief to certain persons who
lack coverage. The buy-in fees were
different for 2008 and 2009.
Specifically for SURE, and not for the
other disaster programs, there are also
the following ‘‘de minimis’’ exceptions
to the risk management purchase
requirement:
(1) Where a portion of the total
acreage of a farm of the eligible
producer is used to produce a crop that
is not of economic significance on the
farm, and
(2) Crops for which the required
administrative fee to purchase NAP
coverage for that crop on a particular
farm exceeds 10 percent of the value of
that coverage.
PO 00000
Frm 00007
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
68483
If a participant elects not to purchase
risk management coverage for the crop
because of one of the de minimis
exceptions, such crop will not be
included in the SURE guarantee and
revenue calculations. The participant
must elect the de minimis exception as
part of the application for SURE
payment.
If a producer is ineligible or otherwise
barred from the risk management
insurance program or NAP because of
past violations and those insurance
programs would otherwise be available
to that producer absent such violations,
that producer will also be ineligible for
SURE.
Other circumstances preventing a
producer from obtaining risk
management coverage may be addressed
on a case-by-case basis, and the
Secretary or designee may determine a
participant eligible for SURE even if
FCIA or NAP coverage was not timely
obtained. Section 760.106 ‘‘Equitable
Relief’’ provides for such relief. For
example, equitable relief may, at FSA’s
discretion, be considered for
participants who failed to meet the
requirements of this rule because the
2008 Farm Bill was enacted after the
closing date for purchasing the
applicable insurance. Another example
may be relief for a participant who made
a late planting decision due to weatherrelated causes. Relief will not be
considered or granted for producers
who are in the RMA ineligibility
tracking system. In connection with
equitable relief, however, producers
have no entitlement to relief that is
discretionary in nature and FSA’s
refusal to consider such relief or to grant
a particular form of relief that is not
particularly mandated by the 2008 Farm
Bill or the program regulations will not
be construed to be an adverse decision
under either part 11 or 780 of this title.
If an RMA pilot or Adjusted Gross
Revenue insurance program was the
only insurance available in that area for
that crop, buying that insurance
program for that crop will ‘‘count’’ as
meeting the risk management purchase
requirement for that crop. However,
producers are not required to purchase
pilot or AGR insurance program
coverage in order to meet the risk
management purchase requirement.
Rather, producers can elect not to obtain
pilot or AGR insurance program
coverage and meet the risk management
purchase requirement by obtaining
either NAP coverage or by paying the
buy-in fee, as may be applicable.
Eligible Crops
Eligible crops include FCIC insured
commodities and crops covered by
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
68484
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
NAP, excluding acreage intended for
grazing. (Grazing losses are covered by
LFP, in regulations codified in 7 CFR
part 760 subpart D.) SURE does not
cover crops covered under LFP or ELAP.
NAP is available for crops that are
commercially produced for which the
catastrophic level of crop insurance
coverage is not available. Crops that are
not grown commercially are not eligible
for either crop insurance or NAP and
therefore are not eligible for SURE. All
crops for which a policy or plan of crop
insurance or NAP coverage is available
are eligible for production losses. Most
crops are also eligible for quality losses
except for value loss crops 1 and some
specialty crops 2 because of the way
normal losses are measured for those
crops.
Producers who did not obtain risk
management coverage for all eligible
crops on a farm are ineligible for
payment under SURE even if some
crops had risk management coverage,
unless an exception or waiver applies.
For example, if a producer’s farm
produces insured corn and insured
soybeans, and also hay, to be eligible for
SURE payment, it is necessary for the
producer to either buy insurance or
NAP coverage on the hay or have made
a ‘‘buy-in,’’ when such option was
available as specified in subpart B of
part 760. Producers who meet all the
statutory conditions of eligibility,
including risk management coverage,
will qualify for payment. A producer
who does not meet the risk management
purchase requirement will not be
eligible. A lack of eligibility is not a
compliance issue; rather, such producer
has merely failed to satisfy a statutory
condition of eligibility.
In the case of a participant who met
the risk management purchase
requirement by purchasing crop
insurance or NAP, the calculation of the
SURE farm revenue and guarantee is
based on the insured or NAP crops. For
participants who are eligible through
waivers and buy-ins, the calculation
will explicitly exclude crops that would
not be eligible for insurance or NAP.
Therefore, there are provisions in this
rule that exclude, for example,
volunteer crops from the revenue or
guarantee calculation. For participants
who purchased crop insurance or NAP,
those crops would clearly not be
included because they were not insured
(and cannot be insured). However, these
provisions are in the rule to address the
1 Value loss crops ineligible for quality losses
include aquaculture, floriculture, mushrooms,
ginseng root, ornamental nursery, Christmas trees,
and turfgrass sod.
2 Specialty crops ineligible for quality losses
include honey and maple sap.
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
situation of calculating the farm revenue
or guarantee of a participant who is
eligible through a waiver or buy-in.
Similarly, this rule excludes from the
SURE guarantee and revenue
calculation crops grown on land that is
not eligible for crop insurance or NAP.
For a participant who purchased crop
insurance or NAP, those crops would
clearly not be included because they
were not insured (and cannot be
insured). However, these provisions are
in the rule to address the situation of
calculating the farm revenue or
guarantee of a participant who is
eligible through a waiver or buy-in.
Independent of risk management
purchase requirements and de minimis
exceptions, certain items or losses are
not covered for any participant and will
not be included in payment calculation.
These include home gardens, losses to
crops that were not intended to be
harvested in the applicable crop year,
and losses to biomass byproducts of the
crop such as corn stover or wheat straw.
Payment Limitations and Other General
Requirements
All counties, owners, contract
growers, lessees, crops, and losses must
meet the eligibility criteria provided in
this rule. False certifications will result
in a denial of program eligibility and
payments. General eligibility
requirements, as specified in §§ 760.101
through 760.117, including
recordkeeping requirements and
required compliance with Highly
Erodible Land Conservation and
Wetland Conservation provisions, are
similar to those for the previous ad hoc
crop disaster programs and are
applicable to SURE.
The 2008 Farm Bill limits how much
a participant may receive from FSA
disaster assistance programs.
• In applying payment limitations for
2008, no person, as defined and
determined by the regulations in 7 CFR
part 1400 in effect for 2008, may receive
more than $100,000 total per crop year
under ELAP, LFP, LIP and SURE
combined.
• For 2009 through 2011, no person
or legal entity (excluding a joint venture
or general partnership), as defined and
determined by the regulations in 7 CFR
part 1400 may receive, directly or
indirectly, more than $100,000 total per
crop year under ELAP, LFP, LIP and
SURE combined.
For the payment limits, both indirect
and direct benefits are counted by
attribution such that the total amount of
payments is attributed to a person by
taking into account the direct and
indirect ownership interests of the
person in a legal entity that is eligible
PO 00000
Frm 00008
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
to receive payments. In the case of a
legal entity, the same payment is
attributed to the direct payee in the full
amount and those that have an indirect
interest to the amount of that indirect
interest. For example, under the
attribution rules that apply to these
programs, assume:
• Corporation A is in line to receive
a $100,000 SURE payment,
• Corporation A is owned 50 percent
by Individual A and 50 percent by
Corporation B, and
• Corporation B is owned by
Individual B with a 30 percent interest
and by Individual C with a 70 percent
interest.
If so, Corporation A, for payment
limitation purposes would be
considered to have received $100,000
and Individual C (who owns 70 percent
of Corporation B, which owns 50
percent of Corporation A) would be
considered to have indirectly benefitted
by the amount of $35,000 (50 percent
times 70 percent of the $100,000). Even
though no part of the $100,000 was
actually paid to Individual C, the
$35,000 would count against Individual
C’s overall payment limitation from all
sources and farms. Assume now that
Individual C was already at the
maximum payment limit. If so,
Individual C would not have been
eligible to receive $35,000; as a result,
the payment to Corporation A would be
reduced by $35,000.
The amount of any payment for which
a participant may be eligible from the
SURE program will be commensurately
reduced by any amount received by the
participant for the same or any similar
loss from any Federal disaster assistance
program. Such disaster programs
include USDA conservation programs
that pay for replanting or replacing
plants damaged by disaster.
Aquaculture producers who received
assistance under the Aquaculture Grant
Program 3 will not be eligible for SURE
assistance on those species of
aquaculture for which a grant payment
was received. Indemnities or NAP
payments issued for losses of the
species will, however, count on the
revenue side of the SURE payment
calculation. Participants cannot receive
SURE assistance for the same loss under
ELAP, LIP, LFP or TAP.
Provisions for both pay limits and for
limits related to an individual’s or
entity’s adjusted gross income were
contained in the administrative subparts
of part 760 (discussed above, previously
3 The Aquaculture Grant Program was authorized
by the Recovery Act and implemented through a
notice of Funds Availability published in the
Federal Register on June 2, 2009 (74 FR 26363–
26365).
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
issued to implement other Farm Bill
disaster assistance programs) and
generally the administration of those
limitations will follow general
regulations in 7 CFR part 1400. In
applying the limitation on average
adjusted gross income (AGI) for 2008, an
individual or entity is ineligible for
SURE payment if the individual’s or
entity’s average annual AGI for 2005,
2006, and 2007 exceeded $2.5 million,
under the provisions in 7 CFR part 1400
in effect for 2008. For 2009 through
2011, the average AGI limitation
provisions in 7 CFR part 1400
applicable to CCC commodity programs
also apply to SURE. As specified in the
2008 Farm Bill, for 2009 through 2011,
a person or legal entity with an average
adjusted gross nonfarm income, as
defined in 7 CFR 1400.3, that exceeds
$500,000 for the relevant period, which
is the 3 taxable years preceding the most
immediately preceding complete taxable
year, as determined by CCC, will not be
eligible to receive payments under these
programs. Likewise, if a person with an
indirect interest in a legal entity has an
average nonfarm AGI over $500,000,
then the payment to the legal entity will
be commensurately reduced as
calculated based on the percent of
interest in the legal entity receiving the
payment. For example, continuing with
the assumptions in the example above,
if Individual B had an average AGI that
was over the limit, then the payment to
Corporation A will be reduced by 15
percent (Individual B’s 30 percent
interest in Corporation B times
Corporation B’s 50 percent interest in
Corporation A).
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
Payment and average AGI limits will
be determined under regulations
specified in 7 CFR part 1400 for CCC
commodity programs. The SURE
program is not a CCC program, but the
CCC regulations in 7 CFR part 1400 are
adopted for this program.
The relevant AGI period for SURE and
the other disaster assistance programs
for 2008 is the 3 calendar years that
precede the program year involved
which are 2005, 2006 and 2007.
However, beginning with 2009, the AGI
period is the 3 taxable years preceding
the most immediately preceding
complete taxable year, as determined by
CCC. For SURE, the program year is the
year that corresponds to the relevant
crop year. This program will be
administered by crop year and most
times the crop year for all crops is easily
indentified because both the year of the
planting and the year of the harvesting
are the same or at least the calendar year
of the harvesting is the same
nationwide. The Deputy Administrator
will be the ultimate arbiter of which
production fits in which ‘‘crop year’’ for
purposes of SURE calculations. The
crop year concept in some limited cases
can involve a loss that occurs in a
different calendar year than the calendar
year whose number corresponds to the
crop year. For example, wheat for the
2009 crop year can be planted in the fall
of 2008 and be damaged or lost during
2008. SURE payments related to such a
loss would be made for the 2009 crop
year wheat, because the intent was to
harvest this wheat in 2009.
Production losses are, in general,
determined by calendar year of harvest,
but the payment limitation is for a crop
PO 00000
Frm 00009
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
68485
year. Also, the national average market
price (NAMP) for a marketing year may
not be available until the fall of the
following crop year, so the SURE
payment may often be calculated and
paid in a different (later) calendar year
than the actual year of loss or losses.
The regulations in 7 CFR 1400.105
specify how payments will be attributed
and how far the attribution will go.
Attribution will be tracked through four
levels of ownership in legal entities. The
2008 Farm Bill removed the previous ‘‘3
entity rule,’’ so a person can now
receive benefits attributed through an
unlimited number of entities, subject to
the payment limits and the rules of
attribution described in this final rule
and in 7 CFR part 1400.
In addition, the 2008 Farm Bill
imposes limitations of payments to
foreign persons. Those limits are
specified in the regulations in § 760.103.
Payment Calculation—Overview
The SURE guarantee cannot exceed 90
percent of the total expected revenue for
the crops on the farm. Depending on the
level of insurance coverage the
participant elects, the SURE guarantee
for a specific participant may be less
than 90 percent of the expected revenue.
In general, the higher the level of
insurance coverage purchased, the
higher the SURE guarantee. A
participant who purchases the
minimum insurance required by this
part and meets all other eligibility
requirements will be eligible for SURE,
but the SURE guarantee will reflect that
minimal level of coverage.
BILLING CODE 3410–05–P
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
BILLING CODE 3410–05–C
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
The following is an example of how
a SURE payment is calculated for a
participant with two crops; corn insured
with FCIC crop insurance and alfalfa
with NAP coverage. After the example,
the general SURE payment calculation
formula is discussed.
SURE Guarantee Calculation Example
for 2009 Through 2011 Crop Years
The SURE program guarantee
calculation for insured corn in this
example is as follows: Assume 100
payment acres times an assumed 100
bushels per acre (SURE yield) times
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
$4.00 per bushel (price election) times
70 percent (coverage level) times 115
percent (SURE multiplier) equals
$32,200.
The program guarantee calculation for
alfalfa with NAP coverage in this
example is as follows: assume 100
payment acres times an assumed 4.0
tons per acre (SURE yield) times an
assumed $70 per ton (NAP established
price) times 50 percent times 120
percent (SURE multiplier) equals
$16,800.
The SURE guarantee is: $32,200 (corn)
plus $16,800 (alfalfa) equals $49,000.
PO 00000
Frm 00010
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
The SURE guarantee is limited to 90
percent of the sum of the expected
revenue for each crop on the farm.
Expected revenue for corn is: 100
payment acres times 100 bushels per
acre (SURE yield) times $4.00 (price)
equals $40,000. For alfalfa: 100 payment
acres times 4.0 tons per acre (SURE
yield) times $70 (NAP established price)
equals $28,000.
The expected revenue is: $40,000
(corn) plus $28,000 (alfalfa) equals
$68,000.
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
ER28DE09.001
68486
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
Total expected revenue $68,000 times
90 percent equals $61,200 (SURE
guarantee cap).
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
Total Farm Revenue Calculation
Example for 2008 Through 2011 Crop
Years
Revenue for the insured corn in this
example is based on a 60 percent loss
in production that the participant
experienced for this crop, which in the
example resulted in a 40 bushel yield.
For the purpose of the example, NAMP
for insured corn in the State is $4.00 per
bushel. Assume, too, a freeze also
affected this corn, which resulted in a
quality adjustment of 90 percent to
account for extra moisture, which is
applied to the price. Therefore, the
estimated actual value for this crop is
$4.00 (NAMP) times 90 percent (quality
adjustment) equals $3.60 times 4,000
bushels (actual production of the
payment acres) equals $14,400.
Revenue for the alfalfa in this
example is based on a 25 percent loss
in production that the participant
experienced for this crop, which
resulted in a 3 ton yield. For the
purpose of the example, NAMP for
alfalfa in the State is $70. There is no
quality adjustment for the alfalfa crop.
Therefore, estimated actual value for the
alfalfa crop is $70 (NAMP capped at 100
percent of the NAP established price) ×
300 tons (actual production of the
payment acres) equals $21,000.
Total farm revenue for this participant
is $14,400 (corn) + $21,000 (alfalfa)
equals $35,400.
The SURE payment for this
participant would be: $49,000 (SURE
guarantee) ¥ $35,400 (total farm
revenue) = $13,600 times 60 percent
equals $8,160.
SURE Payment Example for 2008
Through 2011 Crop Years
The SURE payment will be calculated
based on the difference between a
program guarantee and farm revenue as
determined for a participant’s farm. The
SURE program guarantee for a specific
participant is based on the participant’s
risk management purchases. The SURE
calculation of revenue is based on an
applicant’s actual production and
NAMP for the commodities produced,
as well as a number of other revenue
sources such as farm program or NAP
payments and insurance indemnities. In
general, because SURE is intended to
enhance or augment risk management
purchases, participants who elect higher
amounts of coverage will see greater
SURE benefits, compared to those who
elect lesser amounts of coverage. Under
SURE, the crop insurance indemnity
that is counted in the SURE revenue
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
calculation is after subtracting producerpaid premiums for crop insurance in an
amount not to exceed the crop
insurance indemnity paymenton a per
unit basis.
The SURE payment is 60 percent of
the difference between the SURE
guarantee and the total farm revenue. If
total farm revenue is below the SURE
guarantee, the participant will be
eligible for a payment based on the
amount of the shortfall. In general,
except for additional 2008 assistance
made available by the Recovery Act, the
SURE guarantee for insurable crops is
determined by multiplying:
• The number of planted and
prevented planted acres, times
• The higher of either the adjusted
actual production history yield or
counter-cyclical yield, times
• The coverage level, times
• The price determined by the
percentage of the crop insurance price
elected by the participant, times
• 115 percent (1.15).
In general, except for additional 2008
assistance made available by the
Recovery Act, the SURE guarantee for
noninsurable crops is determined by
multiplying:
• The number of planted and
prevented planted acres, times
• the higher of either the actual
production history yield or the countercyclical yield, times
• 50 percent (yield coverage under
NAP), times
• the NAP price, times
• 120 percent (1.20).
This rule specifies how the basic
formula will be adjusted to address a
number of specific situations. Those
situations include, but are not limited
to, adjustments for situations such as:
• If a participant was exempt from the
risk management purchase requirement,
the participant’s SURE yield will be
determined by the FSA county
committee using 65 percent of the
higher of the counter-cyclical program
yield or the FCIC or county expected
yield for the crop as established by the
Deputy Administrator.
• If a participant’s policy or plan of
insurance provides for an adjustment in
the liability, such as in the case of
prevented or late planting, that
adjustment will be used in calculating
the SURE guarantee.
• If a participant’s NAP coverage
provides for an adjustment in the level
of assistance, such as for unharvested
crops or prevented or late planting, that
adjustment will be used in calculating
the SURE guarantee.
• If the farm is in an approved
multiple cropping or double-cropping
area and both crops suffer losses, both
PO 00000
Frm 00011
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
68487
crops may be eligible for the calculation
of disaster assistance if appropriate
documentation is provided. In most
cases, only the first or initial crop is
eligible and will be used in calculating
the SURE guarantee and revenue.
• For 2008 only, and only under
certain situations where the producer
met certain requirements, the Recovery
Act provides for changes to the
percentages used to calculate the
guarantee, such that the multiplier is
changed from 115 percent to 120
percent and from 120 percent to 125
percent, respectively. These percentages
are used in the comparison calculation
to determine the amount of the SURE
payment; the Recovery Act specifies the
two calculations for the comparison and
requires that the greater amount be
used. Using the NAP calculation with
the 125 percent will never result in
being the greater amount; therefore, the
calculation in the regulation uses the
other calculation in the comparison,
which uses 120 percent.
Socially disadvantaged producers,
limited resource producers, and
beginning farmers and ranchers who did
not purchase risk management coverage
will be eligible for the same level of
assistance as participants who satisfied
the purchase requirement by obtaining
the minimum level of coverage
available, which is generally
catastrophic or ‘‘CAT’’ coverage for
insured crops or the standard NAP level
of coverage for noninsured crops.
Equitable consideration will be
provided for instances involving nonyield based crop insurance policies. For
RMA ‘‘pilot’’ insured crops, having
either pilot or NAP coverage on
applicable crops would meet the risk
management purchase requirement. The
payment formulas in this rule are
intended to treat similarly situated
participants consistently and equitably.
However, participants having similar
losses on the same or similar crops may
not necessarily receive the same
payment.
National Average Market Price (NAMP)
The Deputy Administrator will
determine NAMP for each crop in a
marketing year, taking into account the
best information available that the
Deputy Administrator believes is
relevant to such decision. The 2008
Farm Bill specifies that the Secretary
will adjust NAMP to reflect average
quality discounts applied to the local or
regional market price of a crop.
Adjustments will be made at the State
and county levels to account for crop
value that is affected by quality or is
reduced due to excessive high moisture
content resulting from a disaster-related
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
68488
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
condition. Quality adjustments will
require participants to provide verifiable
evidence of production that details the
extent of the quality loss for a specific
quantity. Test evidence to support the
need for quality adjustments, in
addition to meeting all the requirements
of § 760.641, must have been completed
by January 1 of the year following
harvest.
For a crop for which an eligible
participant on a farm receives assistance
under NAP, NAMP will be not more
than the price of the crop established
under NAP. As determined by the
Deputy Administrator, NAMP will be
derived using data from the National
Agricultural Statistics Service and other
sources, and will consist of only one
nationwide NAMP for the crop. NAMP
may be adjusted, as determined by the
Deputy Administrator, to reflect
regional variations in a manner
consistent with FCIA or NAP. NAMPs
may be adjusted by FSA State
committees, in accordance with
procedures set out by the Deputy
Administrator to recognize average
quality loss factors that are reflected in
market by region. In general,
adjustments will be made at the State
level for counties or portions of
counties. The NAMP will be established
on a harvested basis, not including costs
of transportation, storage, processing,
marketing, or other post-harvest
expenses, as determined by FSA.
In all cases, matters such as NAMPs
and other program provisions that apply
generally, which are not established or
determined in response to individual
participant applications, are not and
will not be individually appealable or
contestable. Participants have the right
to challenge administrative decisions
made in response to their particular
applications; however, they cannot
appeal general program provisions such
as average prices, average yields,
NAMPs, or factors used for similarly
situated participants, as specified in 7
CFR 760.110.
Treatment of Value Loss Crops
Production methods and risk
management of value loss crops, such as
ornamental nursery and aquaculture, are
significantly different than for yieldbased crops. Where a yield-based crop
is harvested and marketed in a single
crop year or marketing year, the
participant’s inventory of the typical
value loss crop fluctuates, sometimes
rapidly, in the course of normal
business operations. The total value of
the inventory fluctuates for reasons that
may be unrelated to a disaster or to a
farm’s expected annual revenue or
production.
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
SURE payment eligibility for value
loss crops will be determined based on
inventory and losses at the time of the
disaster and only for the losses due to
that disaster. This is in contrast to other
types of crops, where the SURE
guarantee will typically be based on
several years of production history. The
guarantee for value loss crops will be
based on the inventory on hand
immediately before the disaster and the
revenue used for the payment
calculation will be based on the
inventory immediately after the disaster.
Daily inventory records required for
NAP or crop insurance will typically be
sufficient for documenting losses for
SURE payment eligibility. All other
inventory not marketed immediately
prior to and after the disaster event are
not relevant for SURE purposes and will
not be counted as part of the guarantee
or as farm revenue. Further, farm
revenue will not be adjusted for market
price declines due to the complexity in
determining average market prices by
species for value loss crops. Quality will
also not be further considered in
determining revenue. These provisions
are consistent with insurance policies
and NAP for value loss crops.
For value loss crops, the SURE
guarantee will be based on the level of
insurance coverage selected, as with
other crops. For example, if a
participant had $100,000 value of value
loss crop inventory immediately before
the disaster or event and had elected an
insurance coverage level of 70 percent,
the SURE payment would be calculated
on 60 percent of the difference between
the dollar value of inventory
immediately after disaster ($0 in this
example for a total loss) and the SURE
guarantee of $80,500 ($100,000 times 70
percent coverage level times 115
percent). If the participant was already
paid $70,000 in crop insurance
indemnity over the cost of the producerpaid premiums for the farm, as specified
in this rule (which counts as revenue),
then SURE would pay 60 percent of the
difference between the SURE guarantee
for the participant ($80,500) and the
$70,000 indemnity. In this case, 60
percent of $10,500 equals $6,300.
Application and Certification of
Interests Deadline
There is no pre-sign-up or preenrollment required for SURE, but
participants must submit a complete
application in order to be eligible to
receive payment. The application for
payment will serve as the participant’s
certification of eligibility and interests.
FSA will use these certifications to
determine payment eligibility.
Participants must submit an application
PO 00000
Frm 00012
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
by March 1 of the calendar year two
years after the crop year of the loss. For
example, for the 2009 crop year, the
SURE application including
certification of interests must be
submitted to the FSA county office by
March 1, 2011.
Lack of Access
The 2008 Farm Bill, as amended by
the Recovery Act, contains a lack of
access provision that authorizes
discretion to the Secretary to provide
assistance to participants who suffered
a 2008 production loss due to a natural
cause, except as specified in the
Recovery Act. Under that provision,
assistance may be provided to producers
that did not have access to a policy or
plan of insurance or did not qualify for
a written agreement because one or
more farming practices, which the
Secretary has determined are good
farming practices, differ significantly
from practices of producers of the same
crop in other regions of the United
States, and were not eligible for NAP
coverage. The Deputy Administrator has
the authority to exercise this discretion
as needed, but it is understood that the
scope of this provision is very limited.
Whether the Deputy Administrator
exercises this authority or not is not a
relief determination for an individual
program participant based on particular
facts but a discretionary determination
of general effect. Accordingly, it is
FSA’s position that such determinations
are not subject to administrative appeal
either within FSA or before the National
Appeal Division of the Department.
Multi-Year Losses
The 2008 Farm Bill, as amended by
the Recovery Act, authorized the
Secretary to provide equitable treatment
as the Secretary considers appropriate
for eligible participants on a farm that
suffered production losses in the 2008
crop year that result in multi-year
production losses. In order to be
consistent with policies or plans of risk
management coverage available to the
majority of crops that are likely to be
included in the SURE farm, and due to
the complexity and potential problems
of calculating multi-year losses on both
the farm guarantee and revenue sides, as
well as the difficulty in determining
whether events in any one crop year
were significant enough to result in
multi-year losses, the Secretary has
elected not to implement any
discretionary provisions for multi-year
losses under SURE at this time.
Notice and Comment
The 2008 Consolidated Security,
Disaster Assistance, and Continuing
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
Appropriations Act (Pub. L. 110–329)
made section 1601(c)(2) of the 2008
Farm Bill applicable in implementing
section 12033 of the 2008 Farm Bill. To
the extent relevant, the exemptions
granted by section 1601(c)(2) of the 2008
Farm Bill apply, we believe, to the
corresponding provision enacted in
section 15101 since they are identical
except for the provisions for funding in
section 15101, which do not appear at
all in section 12033. Otherwise, the
provisions of Public Law 110–329
would have no meaning. Therefore,
these regulations are exempt from the
notice and comment requirements of the
Administrative Procedures Act (5 U.S.C.
553), as specified in section 1601(c)(2)
of the 2008 Farm Bill, which requires
that the regulations be promulgated and
administered without regard to the
notice and comment provisions of
section 553 of title 5 of the United States
Code or the Statement of Policy of the
Secretary of Agriculture effective July
24, 1971, (36 FR 13804) relating to
notices of proposed rulemaking and
public participation in rulemaking.
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
Executive Order 12866
The Office of Management and Budget
(OMB) designated this rule as
economically significant under
Executive Order 12866 and, therefore,
OMB reviewed this final rule. A costbenefit assessment of this rule is
summarized below and is available from
the contact information above.
Summary of Economic Impacts
SURE payments for 2008 through
2011 are expected to total $3.4 billion,
an average of $0.85 billion per crop
year, which represents both the cost of
the program and the benefit to
participants. This is less than the
average of $1.14 billion per year for
previous ad hoc crop disaster programs
from 1998 to 2007. This estimate for
SURE was estimated by taking the cost
of ad hoc crop disaster programs from
1998 to 2007 and adjusting that cost for
predicted cash value of crop production
for 2008 through 2011 and for the
specific eligibility requirements for
SURE.
Although crop prices are expected to
continue rising, potentially resulting in
greater costs for SURE than for previous
programs, the overall costs for SURE are
expected to be less than to the cost of
previous ad hoc disaster programs
because, unlike ad hoc disaster
programs, SURE, in general, is
additional compensation for established
losses under crop insurance or NAP.
SURE is not a benefit that replaces or
duplicates previously received crop
insurance or NAP payments, although
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
68489
the crop insurance indemnity that is
counted in the SURE revenue
calculation is after subtracting producerpaid premiums for crop insurance in an
amount not to exceed the crop
insurance indemnity payment. This
provision has been included in the rule
because the 2008 Farm Bill exempts
program indemnities from the
calculation of the farm’s revenue for
purposes of comparing that revenue
with the program guarantee. Often, the
premium is simply deducted from the
indemnity rather than paid outright and
it is FSA’s view that the 2008 Farm Bill
contemplated the ‘‘indemnity’’ to mean
the net revenue paid to the farmer as
that would reflect the actual positive
effect of that recovery on revenue. This
does not suggest in any way that
premiums that do not result in a
indemnity payment or other farm costs
should be deducted, but rather is an
accommodation of what it believed to be
the perceived intent of this specific
provision in the 2008 Farm Bill
addressing indemnities.
Also, SURE payments are based on
farm revenue losses, rather than losses
in particular crops or individual units,
so participants with losses in one crop
but not others may or may not qualify
for a SURE payment.
The SURE guarantee cap is 90 percent
of expected revenue, while previous
programs had a cap of 95 percent of
normal crop value.
part 3015, subpart V, published in the
Federal Register on June 24, 1983 (48
FR 29115).
Regulatory Flexibility Act
This rule is not subject to the
Regulatory Flexibility Act since FSA is
not required to publish a notice of
proposed rulemaking for this rule.
This rule contains no Federal
mandates under the regulatory
provisions of Title II of the Unfunded
Mandates Reform Act of 1995 (UMRA)
for State, local, and tribal governments
or the private sector. In addition, FSA
was not required to publish a notice of
proposed rule making for this rule.
Therefore, this rule is not subject to the
requirements of sections 202 and 205 of
UMRA.
Environmental Review
The environmental impacts of this
rule have been considered in a manner
consistent with the provisions of the
National Environmental Policy Act
(NEPA), 42 U.S.C. 4321–4347, the
regulations of the Council on
Environmental Quality (40 CFR parts
1500–1508), and FSA regulations for
compliance with NEPA (7 CFR part
799). FSA has determined that the
combination of discretionary and nondiscretionary provisions of this Rule
would not constitute a major Federal
action that would significantly affect the
quality of the human environment, and
therefore, no environmental assessment
or environmental impact statement will
be prepared.
Executive Order 12372
This program is not subject to
Executive Order 12372, which requires
consultation with State and local
officials. See the notice related to 7 CFR
PO 00000
Frm 00013
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
Executive Order 12988
The rule has been reviewed in
accordance with Executive Order 12988.
The provisions of this rule preempt
State laws to the extent such laws are
inconsistent with the provisions of this
rule. Before any judicial action may be
brought concerning the provisions of
this rule, the administrative remedies
must be exhausted.
Executive Order 13132
The policies contained in this rule do
not have any substantial direct effect on
States, on the relationship between the
national government and States, or on
the distribution of power and
responsibilities among various levels of
government. Nor does this rule impose
substantial direct compliance costs on
State and local governments. Therefore,
consultation with States was not
required.
Executive Order 13175
The policies contained in this rule do
not impose substantial unreimbursed
direct compliance costs on Indian tribal
governments or have tribal implications
that preempt tribal law.
Unfunded Mandates
Small Business Regulatory Enforcement
Fairness Act of 1996 (SBREFA)
This rule has been determined to be
Major under SBREFA (Pub. L. 104–121).
SBREFA normally requires that an
agency delay the effective date of a
major rule for 60 days from the date of
publication to allow for Congressional
review. Section 808 of SBREFA allows
an agency to make a major regulation
effective immediately if the agency finds
there is good cause to do so. FSA finds
that it would be contrary to the public
interest to delay implementation of this
rule because it would significantly delay
assistance to the many people affected
by the disasters addressed by this rule.
Therefore, this rule is effective
immediately.
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
68490
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
Federal Assistance Programs
This rule applies to the following
Federal assistance program that is not
listed in the Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance: 10.090–SURE.
760.641 Adjustments made to NAMP to
reflect loss of quality.
760.650 Calculating SURE.
Paperwork Reduction Act
The regulations in this rule are
exempt from the requirements of the
Paperwork Reduction Act (44 U.S.C.
Chapter 35), as specified in section
1601(c)(2) of the 2008 Farm Bill, which
provides that these regulations be
promulgated and administered without
regard to the Paperwork Reduction Act.
§ 760.601
E-Government Act Compliance
FSA is committed to complying with
the E-Government Act, to promote the
use of the Internet and other
information technologies to provide
increased opportunities for citizen
access to government information and
services, and for other purposes.
List of Subjects in 7 CFR Part 760
Dairy products, Indemnity payments,
Pesticide and pests, Reporting and
recordkeeping requirements.
■ For the reasons discussed above, the
Farm Service Agency, USDA, amends 7
CFR part 760 as follows:
PART 760—INDEMNITY PAYMENT
PROGRAMS
1. The authority citation for part 760
continues to read as follows:
■
Authority: 7 U.S.C. 4501, 7 U.S.C. 1531,
16 U.S.C. 3801, note, and 19 U.S.C. 2497;
Title III, Pub. L. 109–234, 120 Stat. 474; and
Title IX, Pub. L. 110–28, 121 Stat. 211.
■
2. Add subpart G to read as follows:
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
Subpart G—Supplemental Revenue
Assistance Payments Program
Sec.
760.601 Applicability.
760.602 Definitions.
760.610 Participant eligibility.
760.611 Qualifying losses, eligible causes
and types of loss.
760.613 De minimis exception.
760.614 Lack of access.
760.620 Time and method of application
and certification of interests.
760.621 Requirement to report acreage and
production.
760.622 Incorrect or false producer
certification evidence.
760.631 SURE guarantee calculation.
760.632 Payment acres.
760.633 2008 SURE guarantee calculation.
760.634 SURE guarantee for value loss
crops.
760.635 Total farm revenue.
760.636 Expected revenue.
760.637 Determination of production.
760.638 Determination of SURE yield.
760.640 National average market price.
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
Subpart G—Supplemental Revenue
Assistance Payments Program
Applicability.
(a) This subpart specifies the terms
and conditions of the Supplemental
Revenue Assistance Payments Program
(SURE).
(b) Assistance in the form of SURE
payments is available for crop losses
occurring in the crop year 2008 through
September 30, 2011, caused by disaster
as determined by the Secretary.
(c) SURE provides disaster assistance
to eligible participants on farms in:
(1) Disaster counties designated by the
Secretary, which also includes counties
contiguous to such declared disaster
counties, if the participant incurred
actual production losses of at least 10
percent to at least one crop of economic
significance on the farm; and
(2) Any county, if the participant
incurred eligible total crop losses of
greater than or equal to 50 percent of the
normal production on the farm, as
measured by revenue, including a loss
of at least 10 percent to at least one crop
of economic significance on the farm.
(d) Subject to the provisions in
subpart B of this part, SURE payments
will be issued on 60 percent of the
difference between the SURE guarantee
and total farm revenue, calculated using
the National Average Market Price as
specified in this subpart.
§ 760.602
Definitions.
(a) The following definitions apply to
all determinations made under this
subpart.
(b) The terms defined in parts 718,
1400, and 1437 of this title and subpart
B of this part will be applicable, except
where those definitions conflict with
the definitions set forth in this section
In the event that a definition in any of
those parts conflicts with the definitions
set forth in this subpart, the definitions
in this subpart apply. Any additional
conflicts will be resolved by the Deputy
Administrator.
Actual crop acreage means all acreage
for each crop planted or intended to be
planted on the farm.
Actual production history yield means
the average of the actual production
history yields for each insurable or
noninsurable crop as calculated under
the Federal Crop Insurance Act (FCIA)
(7 U.S.C. 1501–1524) or Noninsured
Crop Disaster Assistance Program (NAP)
as set forth in part 1437 of this title,
respectively. FSA will use the actual
production history yield data provided
PO 00000
Frm 00014
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
for crop insurance or NAP, if available,
in the SURE payment calculation.
Actual production on the farm means,
unless the Deputy Administrator
determines that the context requires
otherwise, the sum obtained by adding:
(1) For each insurable crop on the
farm, excluding value loss crops, the
product obtained by multiplying:
(i) 100 percent of the per unit price for
the crop used to calculate a crop
insurance indemnity for the applicable
crop insurance if a crop insurance
indemnity is triggered. If a price is not
available, then the price is 100 percent
of the NAP established price for the
crop, times
(ii) The relevant per unit quantity of
the crop produced on the farm, adjusted
for quality losses, plus
(2) For each noninsurable crop on the
farm, excluding value loss crops, the
product obtained by multiplying:
(i) 100 percent of the per unit NAP
established price for the crop, times
(ii) The relevant per unit quantity of
the crop produced on the farm, adjusted
for quality losses, plus
(3) For value loss crops, the value of
inventory immediately after the disaster.
Adjusted actual production history
yield means a yield that will not be less
than the participant’s actual production
history yield for a year and:
(1) In the case of an eligible
participant on a farm that has at least 4
years of actual production history for an
insurable crop that are established other
than pursuant to section 508(g)(4)(B) of
FCIA, the average of the production
history for the eligible participant
without regard to any yields established
under that section;
(2) In the case of an eligible
participant on a farm that has less than
4 years of actual production history for
an insurable crop, of which one or more
were established pursuant to section
508(g)(4)(B) of FCIA, the average of the
production history for the eligible
participant as calculated without
including the lowest of the yields
established pursuant to section
508(g)(4)(B) of FCIA; or
(3) In all other cases, the actual
production history yield of the eligible
participant on a farm.
Adjusted NAP yield means a yield
that will not be less than the
participant’s actual production history
yield for NAP for a year and:
(1) In the case of an eligible
participant on a farm that has at least 4
years of actual production history under
NAP that are not replacement yields, the
average of the production history
without regard to any replacement
yields;
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
(2) In the case of an eligible
participant on a farm that has less than
4 years of actual production history
under NAP that are not replacement
yields, the average of the production
history without including the lowest of
replacement yields; or
(3) In all other cases, the actual
production history yield of the eligible
participant on the farm under NAP.
Administrative fee means a fixed fee
payable by a participant for NAP or crop
insurance coverage, including buy-in
fees, based on the number of covered
crops under NAP or insurance under
FCIA.
Appraised production means
production determined by FSA, or an
insurance provider approved by FCIC,
that was unharvested, but which was
determined to reflect the crop’s yield
potential at the time of appraisal. An
appraisal may be provided in terms of
a potential value of the crop.
Aquaculture means the reproduction
and rearing of aquatic species as
specified in part 1437 of this title in
controlled or selected environments.
Brownout means a disruption of
electrical or other similar power source
for any reason. A brownout, although it
may indirectly have an adverse effect on
crops, is not a disaster for the purposes
of this subpart and losses caused by a
brownout will not be considered a
qualifying loss.
Catastrophic risk protection (CAT)
means the minimum level of coverage
offered by the Risk Management Agency
(RMA) for crop insurance. CAT is
further specified in parts 402 and 1437
of this title.
Counter-cyclical program payment
yield means the weighted average
payment yield established under part
1412, subpart C of this title.
County expected yield means an
estimated yield, expressed in a specific
unit of measure equal to the average of
the most recent five years of official
county yields established by FSA,
excluding the years with the highest and
lowest yields, respectively.
Crop insurance indemnity means, for
the purpose of this subpart, the net
payment to a participant excluding the
value of the premium for crop losses
covered under crop insurance
administered in accordance with FCIA
by RMA.
Crop of economic significance means
any crop, as defined in this subpart that
contributed, or, if the crop is not
successfully produced, would have
contributed or is expected to contribute,
5 percent or more of the total expected
revenue from all of a participant’s crops
on a farm.
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
Crop year means as determined by the
Deputy Administrator for a commodity
on a nationwide basis the calendar year
in which the crop is normally harvested
or, where more than one calendar year
is involved, the calendar year in which
the majority of the crop would have
been harvested. For crops on which
catastrophic risk protection, as defined
in this section, is available, the crop
year will be as defined as in such
coverage. Crop year determinations by
the Deputy Administrator will be final
in all cases and, because these are
matters of general applicability, will not
considered by the Farm Service Agency
to be subject to administrative appeal.
Determined acreage or determined
production means the amount of acres
or production for a farm established by
a representative of FSA by use of
appropriate means such as official
acreage, digitizing and planimetering
areas on the photograph or other
photographic image, or computations
from scaled dimensions or ground
measurements. In the case of
production, any production established
by a representative of FSA through
audit, review, measurement, appraisal,
or other acceptable means of
determining production, as determined
by FSA.
Disaster means damaging weather,
including drought, excessive moisture,
hail, freeze, tornado, hurricane,
typhoon, excessive wind, excessive
heat, weather-related saltwater
intrusion, weather-related irrigation
water rationing, or any combination
thereof and adverse natural occurrences
such as earthquakes or volcanic
eruptions. Disaster includes a related
condition that occurs as a result of the
damaging weather or adverse natural
occurrence and exacerbates the
condition of the crop, such as disease
and insect infestation. It does not
include brownouts or power failures.
Disaster county means a county
included in the geographic area covered
by a qualifying natural disaster
designation under section 321(a) of the
Consolidated Farm and Rural
Development Act (7 U.S.C. 1961(a)) and
for SURE, the term ‘‘disaster county’’
also includes a county contiguous to a
county declared a disaster by the
Secretary; however, farms not in a
disaster county may qualify under SURE
where for the relevant period, as
determined under this subpart, the
actual production on a farm is less than
50 percent of the normal production on
the farm.
Double-cropping means, as
determined by the Deputy
Administrator on a regional basis,
planting for harvest a crop of a different
PO 00000
Frm 00015
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
68491
commodity on the same acres in cycle
with another crop in a 12-month period
in an area where such double-cropping
is considered normal, or could be
considered to be normal, for all growers
and under normal growing conditions
and normal agricultural practices for the
region and being able to repeat the same
cycle in the following 12-month period.
Farm means, for the purposes of
determining SURE eligibility, the
entirety of all crop acreage in all
counties that a producer planted or
intended to be planted for harvest for
normal commercial sale or on-farm
livestock feeding, including native and
improved grassland intended for haying.
In the case of aquaculture, except for
species for which an Aquaculture Grant
Program payment was received, the
term ‘‘farm’’ includes all acreage used
for all aquatic species being produced in
all counties that the producer intended
to harvest for normal commercial sale.
In the case of honey, the term ‘‘farm’’
means all bees and beehives in all
counties that the participant intended to
be harvested for a honey crop for normal
commercial sale.
FCIC means the Federal Crop
Insurance Corporation, a wholly owned
Government Corporation operated and
managed by USDA RMA.
FSA means the Farm Service Agency.
Harvested means:
(1) For insurable crops, harvested is as
defined according to the applicable crop
insurance policy administered in
accordance with FCIA by RMA;
(2) For NAP-covered single harvest
crops, a mature crop that has been
removed from the field, either by hand
or mechanically;
(3) For noninsurable crops with
potential multiple harvests in one year
or one crop harvested over multiple
years, that the participant has, by hand
or mechanically, removed at least one
mature crop from the field during the
crop year; or
(4) For mechanically harvested
noninsurable crops, that the mature
crop has been removed from the field
and placed in or on a truck or other
conveyance, except hay is considered
harvested when in the bale, whether
removed from the field or not. Grazing
of land will not be considered harvested
for the purpose of determining an
unharvested or prevented planting
payment factor.
Initial crop means a first crop planted
for which assistance is provided under
this subpart.
Insurable crop means an agricultural
commodity (excluding livestock) for
which the participant on a farm is
eligible to obtain a policy or plan of
crop insurance administered in
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
68492
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
accordance with FCIA by RMA. Such a
crop for which the participant
purchased insurance from RMA is
referred to as an insured crop.
Insurance is available means when
crop information is contained in RMA’s
county actuarial documents for a
particular crop and a policy or plan of
insurance administered in accordance
with FCIA by RMA. If the Adjusted
Gross Revenue Plan of crop insurance
was the only plan of insurance available
for the crop in the county in the
applicable crop year, insurance is
considered not available for that crop. If
an AGR plan or a pilot plan was the
only plan available, producers are not
required to purchase it to meet the risk
management purchase requirement, but
it will satisfy the risk management
purchase requirement. In that case, the
other ways to meet the requirement
would be, if all the requirements of this
subpart are met, a buy-in or NAP.
Intended use means the original use
for which a crop or a commodity is
grown and produced.
Marketing year means the 12 months
immediately following the established
final harvest date of the crop of a
commodity, as determined by the
Deputy Administrator, and not an
individual participant’s final harvest
date. FSA will use the marketing year
determined by NASS, when available.
Maximum average loss level means
the maximum level of crop loss that will
be used in calculating SURE payments
for a participant without reliable or
verifiable production records as defined
in this section. Loss levels are expressed
in either a percent of loss or a yield per
acre, and reflect the amount of
production that a participant should
have produced considering the eligible
disaster conditions in the area or
county, as determined by the FSA
county committee in accordance with
instructions issued by the Deputy
Administrator.
Multi-use crop means a crop intended
for more than one use during the
calendar year such as grass harvested for
seed, hay, or grazing.
Multiple planting means the planting
for harvest of the same crop in more
than one planting period in a crop year
on the same or different acreage. This is
also sometimes referred in this rule as
multiple cropping.
NAMP means the national average
market price determined in accordance
with §§ 760.640 and 760.641.
NASS is the USDA National
Agricultural Statistics Service.
Noninsurable crop means a
commercially produced crop for which
the eligible participants on a farm may
obtain coverage under NAP.
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
Noninsured Crop Disaster Assistance
Program or NAP means the FSA
program carried out under 7 U.S.C.
7333, as specified in part 1437 of this
title.
Normal production on the farm
means, for purposes of the revenue
calculations of this subpart, the sum of
the expected revenue for all crops on
the farm. It is stated in terms of revenue,
because different crops may have
different units of measure.
Planted acreage means land in which
seed, plants, or trees have been placed,
appropriate for the crop and planting
method, at a correct depth, into a seed
bed that has been properly prepared for
the planting method and production
practice normal to the area, as
determined by the FSA county
committee.
Prevented planting means the
inability to plant an eligible crop with
proper equipment during the planting
period as a result of a disaster, as
determined by FSA. All prevented
planted cropland must meet conditions
provided in § 718.103 of this chapter.
Additionally, all insured crops must
satisfy the provisions of prevented
planting provided in § 457.8 of this title.
Price election means, for an insured
crop, the crop insurance price elected
by the participant multiplied by the
percentage of price elected by the
participant.
Production means quantity of a crop
or commodity produced on the farm
expressed in a specific unit of measure
including, but not limited to, bushels or
pounds and used to determine the
normal production on a farm. Normal
production for the whole farm is stated
in terms of revenue, because different
crops may have different units of
measure.
Qualifying loss means a 10 percent
loss of at least one crop of economic
significance due to disaster and on a
farm that is either:
(1) Located in a disaster county (a
county for which a Secretarial disaster
designation has been issued or in a
county contiguous to a county that has
received a Secretarial disaster
designation), or
(2) If not located in any disaster
county or county contiguous to such a
county, but has an overall loss greater
than or equal to 50 percent of normal
production on the farm (expected
revenue for all crops on the farm) due
to disaster.
Qualifying natural disaster
designation means a natural disaster
designated by the Secretary for
production losses under section 321(a)
of the Consolidated Farm and Rural
Development Act (7 U.S.C. 1961(a)).
PO 00000
Frm 00016
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
Related condition means, with respect
to a disaster, a condition that causes
deterioration of a crop such as insect
infestation, plant disease, or aflatoxin
that is accelerated or exacerbated as a
result of damaging weather, as
determined by the Deputy
Administrator.
Reliable production records means
evidence provided by the participant to
the FSA county office that FSA
determines is adequate to substantiate
the amount of production reported
when verifiable records are not
available, including copies of receipts,
ledgers of income, income statements,
deposit slips, register tapes, invoices for
custom harvesting, records to verify
production costs, contemporaneous
measurements, truck scale tickets, and
contemporaneous diaries. When the
term ‘‘acceptable production records’’ is
used in this rule, it may be either
reliable or verifiable production records,
as defined in this section.
Reported acreage or production
means information obtained from the
participant or the participant’s agent, on
a form prescribed by FSA or through
insurance records.
RMA means the Risk Management
Agency.
Salvage value means the dollar
amount or equivalent for the quantity of
the commodity that cannot be marketed
or sold in any recognized market for the
crop.
Secretary means the Secretary of
Agriculture.
State means a State; the District of
Columbia, the Commonwealth of Puerto
Rico, and any other territory or
possession of the United States.
Subsequent crop means any crop
planted after an initial crop, on the same
land, during the same crop year.
SURE means the Supplemental
Revenue Assistance Payments Program.
Unit of measure means:
(1) For all insurable crops, the FCIC
established unit of measure;
(2) For all noninsurable crops, if
available, the established unit of
measure used for the NAP price and
yield;
(3) For aquatic species, a standard
unit of measure such as gallons, pounds,
inches or pieces, established by the FSA
State committee for all aquatic species
or varieties;
(4) For turfgrass sod, a square yard;
(5) For maple sap, a gallon; and
(6) For all other crops, the smallest
unit of measure that lends itself to the
greatest level of accuracy, as determined
by the FSA State committee.
USDA means United States
Department of Agriculture.
Value loss crop has the meaning
specified in part 1437, subpart D of this
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
title. Unless otherwise announced by
FSA, value loss crops for SURE include
aquaculture, floriculture, ornamental
nursery, Christmas trees, mushrooms,
ginseng, and turfgrass sod.
Verifiable production records mean
evidence that is used to substantiate the
amount of production reported and that
can be verified by FSA through an
independent source.
Volunteer stand means plants that
grow from seed residue or are
indigenous or are not planted. Volunteer
plants may sprout from seeds left
behind during a harvest of a previous
crop; be unintentionally introduced to
land by wind, birds, or fish; or be
inadvertently mixed into a crop’s
growing medium.
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
§ 760.610
Participant eligibility.
(a) In addition to meeting the
eligibility requirements of § 760.103, a
participant must meet all of the
following conditions:
(1) All insurable crops on the
participant’s farm must be covered by
crop insurance administered by RMA in
accordance with FCIA, and all
noninsured crops must be covered
under NAP, as specified in § 760.104,
unless the participant meets the
requirements in either § 760.105 or
§ 760.107. At the discretion of FSA, the
equitable relief provisions in § 760.106
may apply.
(2) Crop losses must have occurred in
crop year 2008 and subsequent crop
years through September 30, 2011, as a
result of disaster as defined in
§ 760.602, and must have occurred in
the particular crop year for which
benefits are sought under this subpart.
(3) A qualifying loss as defined in
§ 760.602 must have occurred.
(4) The participant must have been in
compliance with the Highly Erodible
Land Conservation and Wetland
Conservation provisions of part 12 of
this title, for 2008 and subsequent crop
years through September 30, 2011, as
applicable, and must not otherwise be
barred from receiving benefits or
payments under part 12 of this title or
any other law.
(5) The participant must not be
ineligible or otherwise barred from the
requisite risk management insurance
programs or NAP because of past
violations where those insurance
programs or NAP would otherwise be
available absent such violations.
(6) The participant must have an
entitlement to an ownership share of the
crop and also assume production and
market risks associated with the
production of the crop. In the event the
crop was planted but not produced,
participants must have an ownership
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
share of the crop that would have been
produced.
(i) Any verbal or written contract that
precludes the grower from having an
ownership share renders the grower
ineligible for payments under this
subpart.
(ii) Growers growing eligible crops
under contract are not eligible
participants under this subpart unless
the grower has an ownership share of
the crop.
(b) In the event that a producer is
determined not to be an eligible
producer of a crop in accordance with
this section, such crop will be
disregarded in determining the
producer’s production or eligibility for
payments under this subpart. However,
any insurance, farm program, or NAP
payments received by the producer on
such crop will count as farm revenue if
that producer is an eligible participant
as a producer of other crops.
(c) Participants may not receive
payments with respect to volunteer
stands of crops. Volunteer stands will
not be considered in either the
calculation of revenue or of the SURE
guarantee.
(d) A deceased applicant or an
applicant that is a dissolved entity that
suffered losses prior to the death or the
dissolution that met all eligibility
criteria prior to death or dissolution
may be eligible for payments for such
losses if an authorized representative
signs the application for payment. Proof
of authority to sign for the deceased
participant or dissolved entity must be
provided. If a participant is now a
dissolved general partnership or joint
venture, all members of the general
partnership or joint venture at the time
of dissolution or their duly authorized
representatives must sign the
application for payment. Eligibility of
such participant will be determined, as
it is for other participants, based upon
ownership share and risk in producing
the crop.
(e) Participants receiving payments
under the Emergency Assistance for
Livestock, Honey Bees, and Farm-Raised
Fish Program (ELAP) as specified in
subpart C of this part are not eligible to
receive payments under SURE for the
same loss.
(f) Participants with a farming interest
in multiple counties who apply for
SURE payment based on a Secretarial
disaster designation must have a 10
percent loss of a crop of economic
significance located in at least one
disaster county, as defined in this
subpart, to be eligible for SURE.
PO 00000
Frm 00017
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
68493
§ 760.611 Qualifying losses, eligible
causes and types of loss.
(a) Eligible causes of loss are disasters
which cause types of losses where the
crop could not be planted or where crop
production was adversely affected in
quantity, quality, or both. A qualifying
loss, as defined in this subpart, must be
the result of a disaster.
(b) A loss will not be considered a
qualifying loss if any of the following
apply:
(1) The cause of the loss was not the
result of disaster;
(2) The cause of loss was due to poor
management decisions or poor farming
practices, as determined by the FSA
county committee on a case-by-case
basis;
(3) The cause of loss was due to
failure of the participant to re-seed or
replant to the same crop in a county
where it is customary to re-seed or
replant after a loss before the final
planting date;
(4) The cause of loss was due to water
contained or released by any
governmental, public, or private dam or
reservoir project if an easement exists
on the acreage affected by the
containment or release of the water;
(5) The cause of loss was due to
conditions or events occurring outside
of the applicable crop year growing
season; or
(6) The cause of loss was due to a
brownout.
(c) The following types of loss,
regardless of whether they were the
result of a disaster, are not qualifying
losses:
(1) Losses to crops not intended for
harvest in the applicable crop year;
(2) Losses of by-products resulting
from processing or harvesting a crop,
such as, but not limited to, cotton seed,
peanut shells, wheat or oat straw, or
corn stalks or stovers;
(3) Losses to home gardens; or to a
crop subject to a de minimis election
according to § 760.613;
(4) Losses of crops that were grazed
or, if prevented from being planted, had
the intended use of grazing; or
(5) Losses of first year seeding for
forage production, or immature fruit
crops.
(d) The following losses of ornamental
nursery stock are not a qualifying loss:
(1) Losses caused by a failure of
power supply or brownout as defined in
§ 760.602;
(2) Losses caused by the inability to
market nursery stock as a result of
quarantine, boycott, or refusal of a buyer
to accept production;
(3) Losses caused by fires that are not
the result of disaster;
(4) Losses affecting crops where
weeds and other forms of undergrowth
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
68494
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
in the vicinity of nursery stock have not
been controlled; or
(5) Losses caused by the collapse or
failure of buildings or structures.
(e) The following losses for honey,
where the honey production by colonies
or bees was diminished, are not a
qualifying loss:
(1) Losses caused by the
unavailability of equipment or the
collapse or failure of equipment or
apparatus used in the honey operation;
(2) Losses caused by improper storage
of honey;
(3) Losses caused by bee feeding;
(4) Losses caused by the application
of chemicals;
(5) Losses caused by theft or fire not
caused by a natural condition including,
but not limited to, arson or vandalism;
(6) Losses caused by the movement of
bees by the participant or any other
legal entity or person;
(7) Losses caused by disease or pest
infestation of the colonies, unless
approved by the Secretary;
(8) Losses of income from pollinators;
or
(9) Losses of equipment or facilities.
§ 760.613
De minimis exception.
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
(a) Participants seeking the de
minimis exception to the risk
management purchase requirements of
this subpart, must certify:
(1) That a specific crop on the farm is
not a crop of economic significance on
the farm; or
(2) That the administrative fee
required for the purchase of NAP
coverage for a crop exceeds 10 percent
of the value of that coverage.
(b) To be eligible for a de minimis
exception to the risk management
purchase requirement in § 760.104, the
participant must elect such exception at
the same time the participant files the
application for payment and the
certification of interests, as specified in
§ 760.620, and specify the crop or crops
for which the participant is requesting
such exception.
(c) FSA will not consider the value of
any crop elected under paragraph (b) of
this section in calculating both the
SURE guarantee and the total farm
revenue.
(d) All provisions of this subpart
apply in the event a participant does not
obtain an exception according to this
section.
§ 760.614
Lack of Access.
In addition to other provisions for
eligibility provided for in this part, the
Deputy Administrator may provide
assistance to participants who suffered
2008 production losses that meet the
lack of access provisions in 19 U.S.C.
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
2497(g)(7)(F), where deemed
appropriate, and consistent with the
statutory provision. Such a
determination to exercise that authority,
and the terms on which to exercise that
authority, will be considered to be a
determination of general effect, not a
‘‘relief’’ determination, and will not be
considered by the Farm Service Agency
to be appealable administratively either
within FSA or before the National
Appeals Division.
§ 760.620 Time and method of application
and certification of interests.
(a) Each producer interested in
obtaining a SURE payment must file an
application for payment and provide an
accurate certification of interests. The
application will be on a form prescribed
by FSA and will require information or
certifications from the producer
regarding any other assistance, payment,
or grant benefit the producer has
received for any of the producer’s crops
or interests on a farm as defined in this
subpart; regardless of whether the crop
or interest is covered in the farm’s SURE
guarantee according to § 760.631. The
producer’s certification of interests will
help FSA establish whether the
producer is an eligible participant.
(b) Eligible participants with a
qualifying loss as defined in this subpart
must submit an application for payment
and certification of interests by March 1
of the calendar year that is two years
after the relevant corresponding
calendar year for the crop year which
benefits are sought to be eligible for
payment (for example, the final date to
submit an application for a SURE
payment for the 2009 crop year will be
March 1, 2011). Producers who do not
submit the application by that date will
not be eligible for payment.
(c) To the extent available and
practicable, FSA will assist participants
with information regarding their
interests in a farm, as of the date of
certification, based on information
already available to FSA from various
sources. However, the participant is
solely responsible for providing an
accurate certification from which FSA
can determine the participant’s farm
interests for the purposes of this
program. As determined appropriate by
FSA, failure of a participant to provide
an accurate certification of interests as
part of the application may render the
participant ineligible for any assistance
under SURE.
(d) To elect a de minimis exception to
the risk management purchase
requirement for a crop or crops, the
participant must meet the requirements
specified in § 760.613. When electing a
de minimis exception, the participant
PO 00000
Frm 00018
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
must specify the crops for which the
exception is requested and provide the
certification and supporting
documentation for that exception at the
time the application and certification of
interests is filed with FSA.
§ 760.621 Requirement to report acreage
and production.
(a) As a condition of eligibility for
payment under this subpart,
participants must submit an accurate
and timely report of all cropland, noncropland, prevented planting, and
subsequent crop acreage and production
for the farm in all counties.
(b) Acreage and production reports
that have been submitted to FSA for
NAP or to RMA for crop insurance
purposes may satisfy the requirement of
paragraph (a) of this section provided
that the participant’s certification of
interests submitted as required by
§ 760.620 corresponds to the report
requirements in paragraph (a) of this
section, as determined by the FSA
county committee.
(c) Reports of production submitted
for NAP or FCIA purposes must satisfy
the requirements of NAP or FCIA, as
applicable. In all other cases, in order
for production reports or appraisals to
be considered acceptable for SURE,
production reports and appraisals must
meet the requirements set forth in part
1437 of this title.
(d) In any case where production
reports or an appraisal is not acceptable,
maximum loss provisions apply as
specified in § 760.637.
§ 760.622 Incorrect or false producer
production evidence.
(a) If production evidence, including
but not limited to acreage and
production reports, provided by a
participant is false or incorrect, as
determined by the FSA county
committee at any time after an
application for payment is made, the
FSA county committee will determine
whether:
(1) The participant submitting the
production evidence acted in good faith
or took action to defeat the purposes of
the program, such that the information
provided was intentionally false or
incorrect.
(2) The same false, incorrect, or
unacceptable production evidence was
submitted for payment(s) under crop
insurance or NAP, and if so, for NAP
covered crops, make any NAP program
adjustments according to § 1437.15 of
this title.
(b) If the FSA county committee
determines that the production evidence
submitted is false, incorrect, or
unacceptable, and the participant who
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
submitted the evidence did not act in
good faith or took action to defeat the
purposes of the program, the provisions
of § 760.109, including a denial of future
program benefits, will apply. The
Deputy Administrator may take further
action, including, but not limited to,
making further payment reductions or
requiring refunds or taking other legal
action.
(c) If the FSA county committee
determines that the production evidence
is false, incorrect, or unacceptable, but
the participant who submitted the
evidence acted in good faith, payment
may be adjusted and a refund may be
required.
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
§ 760.631
SURE guarantee calculation.
(a) Except as otherwise provided in
this part, the SURE guarantee for a farm
is the sum obtained by adding the dollar
amounts calculated in paragraphs (a)(1)
through (a)(3) of this section.
(1) For each insurable crop on the
farm except for value loss crops, 115
percent of the product obtained by
multiplying together:
(i) The price election. If a price
election was not made or a participant
is eligible as specified in §§ 760.105,
760.106, or 760.107, then the percentage
of price will be 55 percent of the NAP
established price;
(ii) The payment acres determined
according to § 760.632;
(iii) The SURE yield as calculated
according to § 760.638; and
(iv) The coverage level elected by the
participant. If a coverage level was not
elected or a participant is eligible as
specified in §§ 760.105, 760.106, or
760.107, a coverage level of 50 percent
will be used in the calculation.
(2) For each noninsurable crop on a
farm except for value loss crops, 120
percent of the product obtained by
multiplying:
(i) 100 percent of the NAP established
price for the crop;
(ii) The payment acres determined
according to § 760.632;
(iii) The SURE yield calculated
according to § 760.638; and
(iv) 50 percent.
(3) The guarantee for value loss crops
as calculated according to § 760.634.
(4) In the case of an insurable crop for
which crop insurance provides for an
adjustment in the guarantee liability, or
indemnity, such as in the case of
prevented planting, that adjustment will
be used in determining the guarantee for
the insurable crop.
(5) In the case of a noninsurable crop
for which NAP provides for an
adjustment in the level of assistance,
such as in the case of unharvested
crops, that adjustment will be used for
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
determining the guarantee for the
noninsurable crop.
(b) Those participants who are eligible
according to §§ 760.105, 760.106, or
760.107 who do not have crop insurance
or NAP coverage will have their SURE
guarantee calculated based on
catastrophic risk protection or NAP
coverage available for those crops.
(c) FSA will not include in the SURE
guarantee the value of any crop that has
a de minimis exception, according to
§ 760.613.
(d) For crops where coverage may
exist under both crop insurance and
NAP, such as for pasture, rangeland,
and forage, adjustments to the guarantee
will be the product obtained by
multiplying the county expected yield
for that crop times:
(1) 115 percent;
(2) 100 percent of the NAP established
price;
(3) The payment acres determined
according to § 760.632;
(4) The SURE yield calculated
according to § 760.638; and
(5) The coverage level elected by the
participant.
(e) Participants who do not have a
SURE yield as specified in § 760.638
will have a yield determined for them
by the Deputy Administrator.
(f) The SURE guarantee may not be
greater than 90 percent of the sum of the
expected revenue for each of the crops
on a farm, as determined by the Deputy
Administrator.
§ 760.632
Payment acres.
(a) Payment acres as calculated in this
section are used in determining both
total farm revenue and the SURE
guarantee for a farm. Payment acreage
will be calculated using the lesser of the
reported or determined acres shown to
have been planted or prevented from
being planted to a crop.
(b) Initial crop acreage will be the
payment acreage for SURE, unless the
provisions for subsequent crops in this
section are met. Subsequently planted
or prevented planted acre acreage is
considered acreage for SURE only if the
provisions of this section are met. All
plantings of an annual or biennial crop
are considered the same as a planting of
an initial crop in tropical regions as
defined in part 1437, subpart F, of this
title.
(c) In cases where there is double
cropped acreage, each crop may be
included in the acreage for SURE only
if the specific crops are either insured
crops eligible for double cropping
according to RMA or approved by the
FSA State committee as eligible double
cropping practices in accordance with
procedures approved by the Deputy
Administrator.
PO 00000
Frm 00019
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
68495
(d) Except for insured crops,
participants with double cropped
acreage not meeting the criteria in
paragraph (c) of this section may have
such acreage included in the acreage for
SURE on more than one crop only if the
participant submits verifiable records
establishing a history of carrying out a
successful double cropping practice on
the specific crops for which payment is
requested.
(e) Participants having multiple
plantings may have each planting
included in the SURE guarantee only if
the planting meets the requirements of
part 1437 of this title and all other
provisions of this subpart are satisfied.
(f) Provisions of part 718 of this title
specifying what is considered prevented
planting and how it must be
documented and reported will apply to
this payment acreage for SURE.
(g) Subject to the provisions of this
subpart, the FSA county committee will:
(1) Use the most accurate data
available when determining planted and
prevented planted acres; and
(2) Disregard acreage of a crop
produced on land that is not eligible for
crop insurance or NAP.
(h) For any crop acreage for which
crop insurance or NAP coverage is
canceled, those acres will no longer be
considered the initial crop and will,
therefore, no longer be eligible for
SURE.
(i) Notwithstanding any other
provisions of these or other applicable
regulations that relate to tolerance in
part 718 of this title, if a farm has a crop
that has both FSA and RMA acreage for
insured crops, payment acres for the
SURE guarantee calculation will be
based on acres for which an indemnity
was received if RMA acres do not differ
from FSA acres by more than the larger
of 5 percent or 10 acres not to exceed
50 acres. If the difference between FSA
and RMA acres is more than the larger
of 5 percent or 10 acres not to exceed
50 acres, then the payment acres for the
SURE guarantee will be calculated using
RMA acres. In that case, the participant
will be notified of the discrepancy and
that refunds of unearned payments may
be required after FSA and RMA
reconcile acreage data.
§ 760.633 2008 SURE guarantee
calculation.
(a) For a participant who is eligible
due to the 2008 buy-in waiver for risk
management purchase under the
provisions of § 760.105(c), the SURE
guarantee for their farm for the 2008
crop will be calculated according to
§ 760.631, or according to § 760.634 for
value loss crops, with the exception that
the:
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
68496
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
(1) Price election in § 760.631(a)(1)(i)
is 100 percent of the NAP established
price for the crop;
(2) Coverage level in
§ 760.631(a)(1)(iv) is 70 percent; and
(3) The percent specified in
§ 760.631(a)(2)(iv) is 70 percent instead
of 50 percent; and
(4) Coverage level used in
§ 760.634(a)(1)(ii) is 70 percent; and
(5) The percent specified in
§ 760.634(a)(2)(ii) is 70 percent instead
of 50 percent.
(b) For those 2008 crops that meet the
requirements of §§ 760.104, 760.105(a),
760.106, or 760.107, the SURE guarantee
will be the higher of:
(1) The guarantee calculated
according to § 760.631, or according to
§ 760.634 for value loss crops, with the
exception that the percent specified in
§§ 760.631(a)(1) and 760.634(a)(1) will
be 120 percent instead of 115 percent;
(2) The guarantee calculated
according to § 760.631, or according to
§ 760.634 for value loss crops, will be
used with the exception that the:
(i) Price election in § 760.631(a)(1)(i)
is 100 percent of the NAP established
price for the crop; and
(ii) Coverage level in
§§ 760.631(a)(1)(iv) and 760.634(a)(1)(ii)
will be 70 percent; and
(iii) The percent specified in
§§ 760.631(a)(2)(iv) and 760.634(a)(2)(ii)
will be 70 percent instead of 50 percent.
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
§ 760.634
crops.
SURE guarantee for value loss
(a) The SURE guarantee for value loss
crops will be the sum of the amounts
calculated in paragraphs (a)(1) and (a)(2)
of this section, except as otherwise
specified.
(1) For each insurable crop on the
farm, 115 percent of the product
obtained by multiplying:
(i) The value of inventory
immediately prior to disaster, and
(ii) The coverage level elected by the
participant. If a coverage level was not
elected or a participant is eligible as
specified in §§ 760.106 or 760.107, a
coverage level of 27.5 percent will be
used in the calculation.
(2) For each noninsurable crop on the
farm, 120 percent of the product
obtained by multiplying:
(i) The value of inventory
immediately prior to a disaster, and
(ii) 50 percent.
(b) Aquaculture participants who
received assistance under the
Aquaculture Grant Program (Pub. L.
111–5) will not be eligible for SURE
assistance on those species for which a
grant benefit was received under the
Aquaculture Grant Program for feed
losses associated with that species.
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
(c) In the case of an insurable value
loss crop for which crop insurance
provides for an adjustment in the
guarantee, liability, or indemnity, such
as in the case of inventory exceeding
peak inventory value, the adjustment
will be used in determining the SURE
guarantee for the insurable crop.
(d) In the case of a noninsurable value
loss crop for which NAP provides for an
adjustment in the level of assistance,
such as in the case of unharvested field
grown inventory, the adjustment will be
used in determining the SURE guarantee
for the noninsurable crop.
§ 760.635
Total farm revenue.
(a) For the purpose of SURE payment
calculation, total farm revenue will
equal the sum obtained by adding the
amounts calculated in paragraphs (a)(1)
through (a)(12) of this section.
(1) The estimated actual value for
each crop produced on a farm, except
for value loss crops, which equals the
product obtained by multiplying:
(i) The actual production of the
payment acres for each crop on a farm
for purposes of determining losses
under FCIA or NAP; and
(ii) NAMP, as calculated for the
marketing year as specified in § 760.640
and as adjusted if required as specified
in § 760.641.
(2) The estimated actual value for
each value loss crop produced on a farm
that equals the value of inventory
immediately after disaster.
(3) 15 percent of the amount of any
direct payments made to the participant
under part 1412 of this title.
(4) The total amount of any countercyclical and average crop revenue
election payments made to the
participant under part 1412 of this title.
(5) The total amount of any loan
deficiency payments, marketing loan
gains, and marketing certificate gains
made to the participant under parts
1421 and 1434 of this title.
(6) The amount of payments for
prevented planting.
(7) The amount of crop insurance
indemnities.
(8) The amount of NAP payments
received.
(9) The value of any guaranteed
payments made to a participant in lieu
of production pursuant to an agreement
or contract, if the crop is included in the
SURE guarantee.
(10) Salvage value for any crops
salvaged.
(11) The value of any other disaster
assistance payments provided by the
Federal Government for the same loss
for which the eligible participant
applied for SURE.
(12) For crops for which the eligible
participant received a waiver under the
PO 00000
Frm 00020
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
provisions of § 760.105(c) or obtained
relief according to § 760.106, the value
determined by FSA based on what the
participant would have received,
irrespective of any other provision, if
NAP or crop insurance coverage had
been obtained.
(b) Sale of plant parts or by-products,
such as straw, will not be counted as
farm revenue.
(c) For value loss crops:
(1) Other inventory on hand or
marketed at some time other than
immediately prior to and immediately
after the disaster event are irrelevant for
revenue purposes and will not be
counted as revenue for SURE.
(2) Revenue will not be adjusted for
market loss.
(3) Quality losses will not be
considered in determining revenue.
(4) In no case will market price
declines in value loss crops, due to any
cause, be considered in the calculation
of payments for those crops.
§ 760.636
Expected revenue.
The expected revenue for each crop
on a farm is:
(a) For each insurable crop, except
value loss crops, the product obtained
by multiplying:
(1) The SURE yield as specified in
§ 760.638;
(2) The payment acres as specified in
§ 760.632; and
(3) 100 percent of the price for the
crop used to calculate a crop insurance
indemnity for an applicable policy of
insurance if a crop insurance indemnity
is triggered. If a price is not available,
then the price is 100 percent of the NAP
established price for the crop, and
(b) For each noninsurable crop, except
value loss crops, the product obtained
by multiplying
(1) The SURE yield as specified in
§ 760.638;
(2) The payment acres as specified in
§ 760.632; and
(3) 100 percent of the NAP price.
(c) For each value loss crop, the value
of inventory immediately prior to the
disaster.
§ 760.637
Determination of production.
(a) Except for value loss crops,
production for the purposes of this part
includes all harvested, appraised, and
assigned production for the payment
acres determined according to
§ 760.632.
(b) The FSA county committee will
use the best available data to determine
production, including RMA and NAP
loss records and yields for insured and
noninsured crops.
(c) The production of any eligible
crop harvested more than once in a crop
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
year will include the total harvested
production from all harvests.
(d) Crop production losses occurring
in tropical regions, as defined in part
1437, subpart F of this chapter, will be
based on a crop year beginning on
January 1 and ending on December 31
of the same calendar year. All crop
harvests in tropical regions that take
place between those dates will be
considered a single crop.
(e) Any record of an appraisal of crop
production conducted by RMA or FSA
through a certified loss adjustor will be
used if available. Unharvested appraised
production will be included in the
calculation of revenue under SURE. If
the unharvested appraised crop is
subsequently harvested for the original
intended use, the larger of the actual or
appraised production will be used to
determine payment.
(1) If no appraisal is available, the
participant is required to submit
verifiable or reliable production
evidence.
(2) If the participant does not have
verifiable or reliable production
evidence, the FSA county committee
will use the higher of the participant’s
crop certification or the maximum
average loss level to determine the
participant’s crop production losses.
(f) Production will be adjusted based
on a whole grain equivalent, as
established by FSA, for all crops with an
intended use of grain, but harvested as
silage, cobbage, or hay, cracked, rolled,
or crimped.
(g) For crops sold in a market that is
not a recognized market for that crop
and has no established county expected
yield and NAMP, the quantity of such
crops will not be considered
production; rather, 100 percent of the
salvage value will be included in the
revenue calculation.
(h) Production from different counties
that is commingled on the farm before
it was a matter of record and cannot be
separated by using records or other
means acceptable to FSA will have the
NAMP prorated to each respective
county by FSA. Commingled production
may be attributed to the applicable
county, if the participant made the
location of production of a crop a matter
of record before commingling, if the
participant does either of the following:
(1) Provides copies of verifiable
documents showing that production of
the crop was purchased, acquired, or
otherwise obtained from the farm in that
county; or
(2) Had the farm’s production in that
county measured in a manner
acceptable to the FSA county
committee.
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
(i) The FSA county committee will
assign production for the purpose of
NAMP for the farm if the FSA county
committee determines that the
participant failed to provide verifiable
or reliable production records.
(j) If RMA loss records are not
available, or if the FSA county
committee determines that the RMA
loss records as reported by the insured
participant appear to be questionable or
incomplete, or if the FSA county
committee makes inquiry, then
participants are responsible for:
(1) Retaining and providing, when
required, the best available verifiable
and reliable production records
available for the crops;
(2) Summarizing all the production
evidence;
(3) Accounting for the total amount of
production for the crop on a farm,
whether or not records reflect this
production;
(4) Providing the information in a
manner that can be easily understood by
the FSA county committee; and
(5) Providing supporting
documentation if the FSA county
committee has reason to question the
disaster event or that all production has
been taken into account.
(k) The participant must supply
verifiable or reliable production records
to substantiate production to the FSA
county committee. If the eligible crop
was sold or otherwise disposed of
through commercial channels,
acceptable production records include:
Commercial receipts; settlement sheets;
warehouse ledger sheets or load
summaries; or appraisal information
from a loss adjuster acceptable to FSA.
If the eligible crop was farm-stored,
sold, fed to livestock, or disposed of by
means other than commercial channels,
acceptable production records for these
purposes include: Truck scale tickets;
appraisal information from a loss
adjuster acceptable to FSA;
contemporaneous reliable diaries; or
other documentary evidence, such as
contemporaneous reliable
measurements. Determinations of
reliability with respect to this paragraph
will take into account, as appropriate,
the ability of the agency to verify the
evidence as well as the similarity of the
evidence to reports or data received by
FSA for the crop or similar crops. Other
factors deemed relevant may also be
taken into account.
(l) If no verifiable or reliable
production records are available, the
FSA county committee will use the
higher of the participant’s certification
or the maximum average loss level to
determine production.
PO 00000
Frm 00021
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
68497
(m) Participants must provide all
records for any production of a crop that
is grown with an arrangement,
agreement, or contract for guaranteed
payment.
(n) FSA may verify the production
evidence submitted with records on file
at the warehouse, gin, or other entity
that received or may have received the
reported production.
§ 760.638
Determination of SURE yield.
(a) Except for value loss crops as
specified in § 760.634, a SURE yield
will be determined for each crop, type,
and intended use on a farm, using the
higher of the participant’s weighted:
(1) Adjusted actual production history
yield as determined in paragraph (b) of
this section; or
(2) Counter-cyclical yield as
determined in paragraph (c) of this
section.
(b) The adjusted actual production
history yield, as defined in § 760.602,
will be weighted by the applicable crop
year total planted and prevented
planted acres, by crop, type, and
intended use for each county. RMA data
will be used for calculating the SURE
yield for insured crops.
(c) The counter-cyclical yield for a
crop on a farm will be weighted based
on total planted and prevented planted
acres in the county for the current crop
year.
(d) Participants who do not purchase
crop insurance or NAP coverage, but
who are otherwise eligible for payment,
will have a SURE yield determined by
the FSA county committee as follows:
(1) A weighted yield, based on
planted and prevented planted acres,
the location county, crop type, and
intended use, will be determined at 65
percent of the county expected yield for
each crop.
(2) The SURE yield will be the higher
of the yield calculated using the method
in paragraph (d)(1) of this section or the
weighted counter-cyclical yield as
determined in paragraph (c) of this
section.
(e) For those participants with crop
insurance but without an adjusted
actual production history yield, a SURE
yield will be determined by the
applicable FSA county committee. This
paragraph will apply in the case where
the insurance policy does not require an
actual production history yield, or
where a participant has no production
history.
§ 760.640
National average market price.
(a) The Deputy Administrator will
establish the National Average Market
Price (NAMP) using the best sources
available, as determined by the Deputy
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
68498
Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 247 / Monday, December 28, 2009 / Rules and Regulations
Administrator, which may include, but
are not limited to, data from NASS,
Cooperative Extension Service,
Agricultural Marketing Service, crop
insurance, and NAP.
(b) NAMP may be adjusted by the
FSA State committee, in accordance
with instructions issued by the Deputy
Administrator and as specified in
§ 760.641, to recognize average quality
loss factors that are reflected in the
market by county or part of a county.
(c) With respect to a crop for which
an eligible participant on a farm
receives assistance under NAP, the
NAMP will not exceed the price of the
crop established under NAP.
(d) To the extent practicable, the
NAMP will be established on a
harvested basis without the inclusion of
transportation, storage, processing,
marketing, or other post-harvest
expenses, as determined by FSA.
(e) NAMP may be adjusted by the FSA
State committee, as authorized by The
Deputy Administrator, to reflect
regional variations in price consistent
with those prices established under the
FCIA or NAP.
erowe on DSK5CLS3C1PROD with RULES
§ 760.641 Adjustments made to NAMP to
reflect loss of quality.
(a) The Deputy Administrator will
authorize FSA county committees, with
FSA State committee concurrence, to
adjust NAMP for a county or part of a
county:
(1) To reflect the average quality
discounts applied to the local or
regional market price of a crop due to
a reduction in the intrinsic
characteristics of the production
resulting from adverse weather, as
determined annually by the State office
of the FSA; or
(2) To account for a crop for which
the value is reduced due to excess
moisture resulting from a disaster
related condition.
(3) For adjustments specified in
paragraphs (a)(1) and (a)(2) of this
section, an adjustment factor that
represents the regional or local price
received for the crop in the county will
be calculated by the FSA State
committee. The adjustment factor will
be based on the average actual market
price compared to NAMP.
(b) For adjustments made under
paragraph (a) of this section,
participants must provide verifiable
evidence of actual or appraised
production, clearly indicating an
average loss of value caused by poor
quality or excessive moisture that meets
or exceeds the quality adjustment for
the county or part of a county
established in paragraph (a)(3) of this
section to be eligible to receive the
VerDate Nov<24>2008
10:44 Dec 24, 2009
Jkt 220001
quality-adjusted NAMP as part of their
SURE payment calculation. In order to
be considered at all for the purpose of
quality adjustments, the verifiable
evidence of production must itself detail
the extent of the quality loss for a
specific quantity. With regard to test
evidence, in addition to meeting all the
requirements of this section, tests must
have been completed by January 1 of the
year following harvest.
§ 760.650
Calculating SURE.
(a) Subject to the provision of this
subpart, SURE payments for crop losses
in crop year 2008 and subsequent crop
years will be calculated as the amount
equal to 60 percent of the difference
between:
(1) The SURE guarantee, as specified
in § 760.631, 760.633 or 760.634 of this
subpart, and
(2) The total farm revenue, as
specified in § 760.635.
(b) In addition to the other provisions
of this subpart and subpart B of this
part, SURE payments may be adjusted
downward as necessary to insure
compliance with the payment
limitations in subpart B and to insure
that payments do not exceed the
maximum amount specified in
§ 760.108(a)(1) or (b)(1) or otherwise
exceed the perceived intent of 19 U.S.C.
2497(j). Such adjustments can include,
but are not limited to, adjustments to
insure that there is no duplication of
benefits as specified in § 760.108(c).
Signed in Washington, DC, December 18,
2009.
Jonathan W. Coppess,
Administrator, Farm Service Agency.
[FR Doc. E9–30632 Filed 12–22–09; 4:15 pm]
BILLING CODE 3410–05–P
NUCLEAR REGULATORY
COMMISSION
10 CFR Part 50
Domestic Licensing of Production and
Utilization Facilities
CFR Correction
In Title 10 of the Code of Federal
Regulations, Parts 1 to 50, revised as of
January 1, 2009, on page 913, in § 50.72,
reinstate the text of footnote 1 to read
as follows:
1 Other requirements for immediate
notification of the NRC by licensed operating
nuclear power reactors are contained
elsewhere in this chapter, in particular
§§ 20.1906, 20.2202, 50.36, 72.216, and
73.71.
[FR Doc. E9–30739 Filed 12–24–09; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 1505–01–D
PO 00000
Frm 00022
Fmt 4700
Sfmt 4700
FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM
12 CFR Part 203
[Regulation C; Docket No. 1379]
Home Mortgage Disclosure
AGENCY: Board of Governors of the
Federal Reserve System.
ACTION: Final rule; staff commentary.
SUMMARY: The Board is publishing a
final rule amending the staff
commentary that interprets the
requirements of Regulation C (Home
Mortgage Disclosure) to reflect no
change in the asset-size exemption
threshold for depository institutions
based on the annual percentage change
in the Consumer Price Index for Urban
Wage Earners and Clerical Workers
(CPIW). The exemption threshold
remains $39 million. The CPIW
decreased by 0.98 percent during the
twelve-month period ending in
November 2009, but this change is too
small to warrant any reduction in the
exemption threshold pursuant to
Regulation C. Therefore, depository
institutions with assets of $39 million or
less as of December 31, 2009 are exempt
from collecting data in 2010.
DATES: Effective January 1, 2010.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: John
C. Wood, Counsel, Division of
Consumer and Community Affairs, at
(202) 452–3667; for users of
Telecommunications Device for the Deaf
(TDD) only, contact (202) 263–4869.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The Home
Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA; 12
U.S.C. 2801 et seq.) requires most
mortgage lenders located in
metropolitan areas to collect data about
their housing-related lending activity.
Annually, lenders must report those
data to their federal supervisory
agencies and make the data available to
the public. The Board’s Regulation C (12
CFR part 203) implements HMDA.
Prior to 1997, HMDA exempted
depository institutions with assets
totaling $10 million or less, as of the
preceding year-end. Provisions of the
Economic Growth and Regulatory
Paperwork Reduction Act of 1996
(codified at 12 U.S.C. 2808(b)) amended
HMDA to expand the exemption for
small depository institutions. The
statutory amendment increased the
asset-size exemption threshold by
requiring a one-time adjustment of the
$10 million figure based on the
percentage by which the CPIW for 1996
exceeded the CPIW for 1975, and it
provided for annual adjustments
thereafter based on the annual
percentage increase in the CPIW. The
E:\FR\FM\28DER1.SGM
28DER1
Agencies
[Federal Register Volume 74, Number 247 (Monday, December 28, 2009)]
[Rules and Regulations]
[Pages 68480-68498]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Printing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: E9-30632]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
Farm Service Agency
7 CFR Part 760
RIN 0560-AH90
Supplemental Revenue Assistance Payments Program
AGENCY: Farm Service Agency, USDA.
ACTION: Final rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: This rule implements specific requirements for the new
Supplemental Revenue Assistance Payments Program (SURE) authorized by
the Food, Conservation, and Energy Act of 2008 (the 2008 Farm Bill).
SURE provides disaster assistance to eligible participants who have
experienced qualifying crop production losses, or crop quality losses,
or both, occurring in crop year 2008 through September 30, 2011. All
crops for which crop insurance or noninsured crop disaster assistance
program (NAP) coverage is available are eligible crops for SURE. To be
eligible for SURE payments, participants must meet a risk management
purchase requirement, with some exceptions, and have suffered a
qualifying loss due to disaster. A qualifying loss is a loss of at
least 10 percent of a crop of economic significance on a participant's
farm in a disaster county (a county for which a Secretarial disaster
declaration has been issued or a county contiguous to such a county),
or on a participant's farm with an overall loss greater than 50 percent
of normal production (expected revenue for all crops on the farm) due
to disaster. This rule specifies how a qualifying loss is determined,
how SURE payments are calculated, and how and when participants may
apply for payment.
DATES: Effective Date: December 22, 2009.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Steven J. Peterson, Branch Chief,
Disaster Assistance Branch, Production, Emergencies, and Compliance
Division; Farm Service Agency; United States Department of Agriculture,
STOP 0517, 1400 Independence Avenue, SW., Washington, DC 20250-0517;
telephone (202) 720-5172; e-mail Steve.Peterson@wdc.usda.gov. Persons
with disabilities who require alternative means of communication
(Braille, large print, audio tape, etc.) should contact the USDA Target
Center at (202) 720-2600 (voice and TDD).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Background
This rule implements specific requirements for the SURE program
authorized by the 2008 Farm Bill (Pub. L. 110-246) and amendments to
the 2008 Farm Bill contained in the Consolidated Security, Disaster
Assistance, and Continuing Appropriations Act, 2009 (Pub. L. 110-329),
an Act to Amend the Commodity Provisions of the Food, Conservation, and
Energy Act of 2008 and for other purposes (Pub. L. 110-398), and the
American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (Pub. L. 111-005, the
Recovery Act). The basic core of the SURE program is specified in the
2008 Farm Bill. With the exception of the Recovery Act, the subsequent
amendments were technical in nature; the amendments are discussed
below.
Sections 12033 and 15101 of the 2008 Farm Bill authorize the
Secretary of Agriculture (Secretary) to provide assistance to eligible
participants with certain crop losses. Under this authority, FSA is
establishing SURE, a new permanent disaster assistance program,
providing payments to eligible participants who suffered a qualifying
loss and who met the risk management purchase requirement.
FSA will administer SURE using funds from the Agricultural Disaster
[[Page 68481]]
Relief Trust Fund established under section 902 of the Trade Act of
1974 (19 U.S.C. 2497a), as specified in the 2008 Farm Bill. The
disaster assistance programs authorized by the 2008 Farm Bill are
permanent or ``standing'' disaster assistance programs, some of which
have similar scope to previous ad hoc programs. The programs are
provided for in two separate places in the 2008 Farm Bill. First,
section 12033 adds a new section 531 to the Federal Crop Insurance Act
(7 U.S.C. 1501-1524). Second, section 15101 adds sections 901, 902, and
903 to the Trade Act of 1974. The provisions of the two sections as
enacted are identical except that the Trade Act of 1974 provisions
contain the Trust Fund provisions. The two sections of the 2008 Farm
Bill are considered to be interchangeable for the purposes of this
rule.
SURE is one of five new standing disaster programs authorized by
the 2008 Farm Bill. The five new programs are:
Livestock Indemnity Program (LIP);
Livestock Forage Disaster Program (LFP);
Emergency Assistance for Livestock, Honey Bees, and Farm-
Raised Fish (ELAP);
Supplemental Revenue Assistance Payments Program (SURE);
and
Tree Assistance Program (TAP).
The programs are being implemented through separate rulemakings;
regulations for each of the programs will be implemented in separate
subparts of 7 CFR part 760. This rule implements SURE in 7 CFR part
760, subpart G. The LIP final rule, which was published in the Federal
Register on July 2, 2009 (74 FR 31567-31578) implemented LIP in 7 CFR
part 760, subpart E, and implemented general provisions applicable to
more than one program in 7 CFR part 760, subpart B. The ELAP and LFP
final rule, which was published in the Federal Register on September
11, 2009 (74 FR 46665-46683) implemented ELAP in 7 CFR part 760,
subpart C, and implemented LFP in 7 CFR part 760, subpart D.
SURE covers some expected revenue or production losses not covered
under other Supplemental Agricultural Disaster Assistance programs
established by the 2008 Farm Bill. For example, losses to catfish,
crawfish, and other aquaculture species are not covered by LIP, but are
covered under SURE because they are eligible for NAP coverage. In other
cases, losses are covered by the other programs but not by SURE. For
example, losses to honey bees due to colony collapse disorder are
covered by ELAP but not by SURE. Livestock, feed emergency, and grazing
losses are not covered by SURE but are covered by LIP, ELAP, and LFP.
Losses to tree crops (apples, citrus) are covered by SURE, while losses
to trees that produce crops are covered by TAP.
Legislative Amendments to the SURE Program
Technical amendments made by legislation enacted after the 2008
Farm Bill included a clarification of terms and some newly defined
terms, added the 10 percent actual production loss minimum of an
economically significant crop to be a qualifying loss, excluded
subsequently planted crops in most cases, specified that regional
variations should be considered consistent with crop insurance and NAP
in establishing average market prices, and allowed additional waivers
or exceptions to the risk management purchase requirement for certain
years.
The Recovery Act amendments allowed an additional waiver for the
2008 crop year only under certain situations and increased the amount
of assistance for 2008 qualifying losses. It also authorized the
Secretary discretion to provide equitable treatment for participants
suffering multi-year losses and for participants who lacked access to
insurance or NAP.
Terms Used in This Rule
This final rule uses the words ``producers'' and ``participants.''
Producers may apply for SURE. Participants are those producers that
meet the requirements to be eligible producers to receive SURE
payments.
Sections 12033 and 15101 of the 2008 Farm Bill include the words
assistance, benefits, compensation, relief, and payments. The form of
SURE assistance, benefit, relief, or compensation for eligible
participants is a payment calculated as specified in this rule.
Therefore, this rule uses the word payment to represent the assistance,
benefit, relief, and compensation that participants will receive.
One part of the payment calculation is the guarantee or ``SURE
guarantee'', which is a ``guaranteed'' level of revenue for the farm
based on the planted or prevented planted acres, the yield, past
production history, and the level of crop insurance selected, among
other things. The SURE payment is based on 60 percent of the difference
between this guarantee and the total revenue on the farm as calculated
in accordance with the 2008 Farm Bill.
In general, the word ``production'' represents the quantity or
amount of a crop produced (or harvested). In some terms that include
the word ``production'' it represents the dollar value or the price of
the crop, such as ``normal production on the farm'' which is defined in
this rule. Because the production for the farm is the total of all the
crops produced on the farm, which may be measured in different physical
units, the total production of multiple crops on a farm is most
sensibly represented in terms of dollar value rather than (for example)
using bushels as the unit of measure for production on a farm that
produces corn, hay, and catfish.
This rule defines ``salvage value'' as the dollar amount or
equivalent value when the commodity cannot be sold in any recognized
market for that crop. For example, popcorn that does not meet the
standards for popcorn would have ``salvage value'' as livestock feed.
The word ``crop'' and ``commodity'' were used in the 2008 Farm
Bill. This rule generally uses ``crop,'' except in cases where
``commodity'' must be used to be consistent with other regulations and
programs.
Definitions
This rule includes terms defined or otherwise used in the 2008 Farm
Bill as required to implement the SURE program. In some instances,
terms defined in the 2008 Farm Bill have been modified based on agency
interpretation and to add further clarity. For example, the term
``disaster county'' appears in the 2008 Farm Bill and specifies that a
disaster county, in addition to meaning a county included in a
Secretarial natural disaster declaration, or a county contiguous to
such county, is any farm having actual production less than 50 percent
of normal during a crop year. These regulations make clear that one
farm having a loss of 50 percent or more does not make the farm or the
county or counties in which the farm is or are located an actual
disaster county. Rather, the disaster county term is defined to only
include those counties that have a Secretarial natural disaster
declaration or a county contiguous to such county (without regard to
participant or farm losses).
Other clarifications to definitions in the 2008 Farm Bill include
using consistent words and terms as specified in this rule, adding
information such as citations, or otherwise clarifying the definition.
For example, this involves using the word ``crop'' instead of the word
``commodity'' where appropriate, consistent references to ``crop
insurance'' and ``crop insurance indemnity,'' and ``participant''
instead of ``producer.''
The definition of the term ``actual production history yield'' in
the 2008 Farm Bill uses the term ``weighted.'' The
[[Page 68482]]
definition in this rule refers to an average instead of a weighted
average. We did this to clarify that the weighting is done as part of
the calculation of the SURE yield; the actual production history yield
data from the NAP or RMA program is actual yield data, not weighted.
The definition of ``actual production on the farm'' was expanded to
specifically include the calculation information, which was referred to
in the definition in the 2008 Farm Bill. The definition deleted the
term ``value of all crops produced on the farm'' as it would have been
redundant because the calculations specify a component is the price of
the crop or the value of inventory. The definition was also expanded to
specify how value loss crops would be included in the calculation.
The definition of ``adjusted actual production history yield'' was
expanded to specify the minimum amount, and specify that it is the
``average of the production history'' instead of the ``actual
production history,'' to clarify that since the Farm Bill also
specified that 4 years of production history are taken into account,
that clearly should be an average rather than a sum.
The definition of ``adjusted NAP yield'' was expanded to specify
the minimum amount, and specifying that it is the ``average of the
production history'', rather than the NAP yield, to be consistent with
the ways ``yield'' and ``production history'' are used in other terms
in this rule.
The definition of ``counter-cyclical program payment yield'' was
clarified to cite FSA implementing regulations instead of citing
various sections of legislation.
``Crop of economic significance'' is defined in the 2008 Farm Bill
as having a uniform meaning given it by the Secretary for certain
purposes as specifically required by the 2008 Farm Bill. In this rule,
a crop of economic significance means one that has contributed at least
5 percent of the total expected revenue of all of the participant's
crops on the farm. That would appear to be a fair level at which a
farmer might forego risk management measures because of the relative
size of the crop. At this time, however, no dollar expectation has been
set so as to require that the farm have expected marketings of a
certain level to qualify a crop for SURE. However, the crop must be one
which is the subject of normal marketings.
The definition of ``farm'' was clarified such that ``for sale''
means ``for normal commercial sale'' and was revised for aquaculture
based on the requirements for the Aquaculture Grant Program, as
specified in the Recovery Act. ``Normal'' commercial sale in this
regard would mean sales in the normal channels of commerce and would
not include, for example, ``sales'' to family members or sales from
hobby farms.
The definition of ``noninsurable crop'' specifies that the crop is
a ``commercially produced crop'' because NAP covered crops are
commercially produced crops for which crop insurance is not available.
Some terms defined in this rule are terms used in the 2008 Farm
Bill, but are not defined in the 2008 Farm Bill. For example, the term
``actual crop acreage'' is not defined in the 2008 Farm Bill; however,
for the purpose of SURE, the term ``actual crop acreage'' is defined to
mean that it includes all acreage of each crop planted or intended to
be planted on a farm. As is explained below, the term ``farm'' is
generally defined expansively in SURE to include all farming interests
in which a producer has an interest, no matter where located. Another
example is ``appraised production,'' which, when applicable, will be
used in determining a farm's production or revenue. The term is defined
in this rule as production determined by FSA, or an insurance provider
approved by FCIC, that was unharvested, but which was determined to
reflect the crop's yield potential at the time of appraisal.
``Aquaculture'' is defined to mean the reproduction and rearing of
aquatic species in controlled or selected environments as specified in
part 1437 of this title.
SURE Compared to Previous Disaster Programs
Some important differences between SURE and previous programs are
that SURE payments are based on multi-crop farm revenue, rather than
losses to a single crop, and that SURE is a ``permanent'' or
``standing'' program, for losses in the time period covered in the 2008
Farm Bill (coverage begins with the 2008 crop, and losses after
September 30, 2011 are not covered). Previous ad hoc crop disaster
programs were typically limited to specific crops damaged or destroyed
during a specific period of time in specific locations. In contrast to
previous programs that addressed losses to particular crops, SURE is an
umbrella type of farm revenue program that compliments and augments
protections that participants have from various risk management
purchases. Under previous crop disaster programs, producers typically
requested assistance for particular farm numbers, or units. Under SURE,
a participant's assistance will be based on a ``whole farm,'' which
means the aggregation of all crops in all counties in which the
participant has an interest that were planted or intended to be planted
for harvest. Participants must have been entitled to an ownership share
of the crop; contract growers are not eligible participants for SURE
unless they had an ownership share and meet all other eligibility
criteria.
Payments will not be based on losses to individual crops, although
a loss of a crop of economic significance is an eligibility
requirement.
Funding for the previous ad hoc crop disaster programs was limited
and subject to a specific appropriation. Funding for SURE is provided
through the Agricultural Disaster Relief Trust Fund and payments will
be distributed to eligible participants as they qualify for assistance.
Unlike some FSA and Commodity Credit Corporation (CCC) programs,
participants do not need to pre-enroll or sign up in advance (prior to
the loss) for SURE coverage in order to be eligible. Participants who
believe they may be eligible for a SURE payment who satisfy all
eligibility criteria can submit an application for payment. Such
application will be reviewed to determine if the participant meets such
eligibility criteria.
Qualifying Loss
To receive SURE payments, participants must have had a qualifying
loss. That means eligible participants must have at least a 10 percent
loss of one crop of economic significance due to disaster on either:
(1) A farm in a disaster county (a county for which a Secretarial
disaster designation has been issued or in a county contiguous to a
county with a Secretarial disaster designation), or
(2) A farm not located in a disaster county or a county contiguous
to such a designated disaster county, that has an overall production
loss greater than or equal to 50 percent of the normal production on
the farm (expected revenue for all crops on the farm) due to disaster.
A ``crop of economic significance'' is one that generates or was
expected to generate at least 5 percent of the total expected revenue
of all of the crops on the participant's farm for the current year.
While other FSA programs may use a higher percentage threshold in order
to determine whether a crop is economically significant, SURE defines
crop of economic significance as having at least 5 percent or more of
the total expected revenue from all of the participant's crops on the
farm and
[[Page 68483]]
thereby increases the likelihood that participants will have
economically significant crops and be eligible for SURE.
A ``disaster county'' is one where there has been a Secretarial
disaster declaration; it includes counties contiguous to such counties
declared a disaster. Other kinds of disaster declarations or
designations, such as a Presidential disaster declaration, are not
relevant to SURE, according to the terms of the 2008 Farm Bill.
A farm includes all the crop acreage in all the counties where a
participant has planted crops or intended to plant crops for harvest
for commercial sale or on-farm livestock feeding. For aquaculture and
honey, a farm includes all the acreage used for all aquaculture
species, bees, and beehives intended to be harvested for sale by the
eligible participant in all counties.
A farm not located in a ``disaster county'' may still be eligible
for SURE if it incurs, during a crop year, a qualifying loss of
production in which the actual production on the farm is less than 50
percent of the normal production of the farm. Such loss threshold is
per farm, not per crop on a farm. The actual total production for the
participant's farm, as measured by revenue from all crops and
locations, must be less than 50 percent of the normal expected
production to be a qualifying loss. A loss of 50 percent of one crop,
or losses on one part of a farm where the farm has crops in several
locations, will not necessarily be a qualifying loss if the other crops
or locations or both had a less severe loss. For this category of
qualifying loss, there is no requirement for a disaster declaration.
Risk Management Purchase Requirement
To be eligible for SURE payments, producers must meet certain risk
management purchase requirements, with some exceptions. Those
requirements are specified in 7 CFR part 760 subpart B, and apply to
SURE.
The risk management purchase requirements specify that eligible
participants must have purchased insurance for each insurable crop; a
few exceptions allowed by the 2008 Farm Bill are discussed later in
this section. An ``insurable commodity'' means an agricultural
commodity for which the producer on the farm is eligible to obtain a
policy or plan of insurance under the Federal Crop Insurance Act (FCIA)
from the USDA's Risk Management Agency (RMA). A ``noninsurable
commodity'' means a crop for which the eligible producers on a farm are
eligible to obtain assistance through FSA's noninsured crop disaster
assistance program (NAP). In general, to be eligible for SURE payments,
participants must have obtained crop insurance or NAP coverage, as may
be applicable, for all of their crops.
Producers who did not purchase required coverage are not eligible
for benefits unless an exception applies. Certain waivers for
``socially disadvantaged farmers and ranchers,'' as well as ``limited
resource farmers and ranchers,'' and ``beginning farmers or ranchers''
are provided by the 2008 Farm Bill.
For the 2008 crop year, otherwise eligible producers who paid a
certain buy-in fee were provided an exemption from the risk management
purchase requirement that would otherwise apply if the buy-in fee was
paid by September 16, 2008. By an amendment to the 2008 Farm Bill, a
second buy-in permitted participants to buy in for the 2008 crop year
from February 17, 2009, up to May 18, 2009 to meet the risk management
purchase requirement; however, the participant had to agree to buy crop
insurance or NAP for the next crop year for the crops to which the buy-
in applied. The buy-in fee was equal to the cost of the minimal
catastrophic insurance coverage or NAP coverage, but did not, as with
other buy-in exemptions in SURE, entitle the participant to such
insurance or NAP coverage. Also, an amendment to the 2008 Farm Bill
allows a 2009 crop buy-in if the 2009 Federal Crop Insurance
Corporation (FCIC) sales closing date for a crop was prior to August
14, 2008. The deadline for the 2009 crop buy-in was January 12, 2009.
In addition to these provisions, section 531(g)(5) of the FCIA (and the
corresponding provisions of the Trade Act of 1974; 7 U.S.C. 1531(g) and
19 U.S.C. 2497(g), respectively) have some more general provisions
allowing the Secretary discretion to grant equitable relief to certain
persons who lack coverage. The buy-in fees were different for 2008 and
2009.
Specifically for SURE, and not for the other disaster programs,
there are also the following ``de minimis'' exceptions to the risk
management purchase requirement:
(1) Where a portion of the total acreage of a farm of the eligible
producer is used to produce a crop that is not of economic significance
on the farm, and
(2) Crops for which the required administrative fee to purchase NAP
coverage for that crop on a particular farm exceeds 10 percent of the
value of that coverage.
If a participant elects not to purchase risk management coverage
for the crop because of one of the de minimis exceptions, such crop
will not be included in the SURE guarantee and revenue calculations.
The participant must elect the de minimis exception as part of the
application for SURE payment.
If a producer is ineligible or otherwise barred from the risk
management insurance program or NAP because of past violations and
those insurance programs would otherwise be available to that producer
absent such violations, that producer will also be ineligible for SURE.
Other circumstances preventing a producer from obtaining risk
management coverage may be addressed on a case-by-case basis, and the
Secretary or designee may determine a participant eligible for SURE
even if FCIA or NAP coverage was not timely obtained. Section 760.106
``Equitable Relief'' provides for such relief. For example, equitable
relief may, at FSA's discretion, be considered for participants who
failed to meet the requirements of this rule because the 2008 Farm Bill
was enacted after the closing date for purchasing the applicable
insurance. Another example may be relief for a participant who made a
late planting decision due to weather-related causes. Relief will not
be considered or granted for producers who are in the RMA ineligibility
tracking system. In connection with equitable relief, however,
producers have no entitlement to relief that is discretionary in nature
and FSA's refusal to consider such relief or to grant a particular form
of relief that is not particularly mandated by the 2008 Farm Bill or
the program regulations will not be construed to be an adverse decision
under either part 11 or 780 of this title.
If an RMA pilot or Adjusted Gross Revenue insurance program was the
only insurance available in that area for that crop, buying that
insurance program for that crop will ``count'' as meeting the risk
management purchase requirement for that crop. However, producers are
not required to purchase pilot or AGR insurance program coverage in
order to meet the risk management purchase requirement. Rather,
producers can elect not to obtain pilot or AGR insurance program
coverage and meet the risk management purchase requirement by obtaining
either NAP coverage or by paying the buy-in fee, as may be applicable.
Eligible Crops
Eligible crops include FCIC insured commodities and crops covered
by
[[Page 68484]]
NAP, excluding acreage intended for grazing. (Grazing losses are
covered by LFP, in regulations codified in 7 CFR part 760 subpart D.)
SURE does not cover crops covered under LFP or ELAP. NAP is available
for crops that are commercially produced for which the catastrophic
level of crop insurance coverage is not available. Crops that are not
grown commercially are not eligible for either crop insurance or NAP
and therefore are not eligible for SURE. All crops for which a policy
or plan of crop insurance or NAP coverage is available are eligible for
production losses. Most crops are also eligible for quality losses
except for value loss crops \1\ and some specialty crops \2\ because of
the way normal losses are measured for those crops.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ Value loss crops ineligible for quality losses include
aquaculture, floriculture, mushrooms, ginseng root, ornamental
nursery, Christmas trees, and turfgrass sod.
\2\ Specialty crops ineligible for quality losses include honey
and maple sap.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Producers who did not obtain risk management coverage for all
eligible crops on a farm are ineligible for payment under SURE even if
some crops had risk management coverage, unless an exception or waiver
applies. For example, if a producer's farm produces insured corn and
insured soybeans, and also hay, to be eligible for SURE payment, it is
necessary for the producer to either buy insurance or NAP coverage on
the hay or have made a ``buy-in,'' when such option was available as
specified in subpart B of part 760. Producers who meet all the
statutory conditions of eligibility, including risk management
coverage, will qualify for payment. A producer who does not meet the
risk management purchase requirement will not be eligible. A lack of
eligibility is not a compliance issue; rather, such producer has merely
failed to satisfy a statutory condition of eligibility.
In the case of a participant who met the risk management purchase
requirement by purchasing crop insurance or NAP, the calculation of the
SURE farm revenue and guarantee is based on the insured or NAP crops.
For participants who are eligible through waivers and buy-ins, the
calculation will explicitly exclude crops that would not be eligible
for insurance or NAP. Therefore, there are provisions in this rule that
exclude, for example, volunteer crops from the revenue or guarantee
calculation. For participants who purchased crop insurance or NAP,
those crops would clearly not be included because they were not insured
(and cannot be insured). However, these provisions are in the rule to
address the situation of calculating the farm revenue or guarantee of a
participant who is eligible through a waiver or buy-in. Similarly, this
rule excludes from the SURE guarantee and revenue calculation crops
grown on land that is not eligible for crop insurance or NAP. For a
participant who purchased crop insurance or NAP, those crops would
clearly not be included because they were not insured (and cannot be
insured). However, these provisions are in the rule to address the
situation of calculating the farm revenue or guarantee of a participant
who is eligible through a waiver or buy-in.
Independent of risk management purchase requirements and de minimis
exceptions, certain items or losses are not covered for any participant
and will not be included in payment calculation. These include home
gardens, losses to crops that were not intended to be harvested in the
applicable crop year, and losses to biomass byproducts of the crop such
as corn stover or wheat straw.
Payment Limitations and Other General Requirements
All counties, owners, contract growers, lessees, crops, and losses
must meet the eligibility criteria provided in this rule. False
certifications will result in a denial of program eligibility and
payments. General eligibility requirements, as specified in Sec. Sec.
760.101 through 760.117, including recordkeeping requirements and
required compliance with Highly Erodible Land Conservation and Wetland
Conservation provisions, are similar to those for the previous ad hoc
crop disaster programs and are applicable to SURE.
The 2008 Farm Bill limits how much a participant may receive from
FSA disaster assistance programs.
In applying payment limitations for 2008, no person, as
defined and determined by the regulations in 7 CFR part 1400 in effect
for 2008, may receive more than $100,000 total per crop year under
ELAP, LFP, LIP and SURE combined.
For 2009 through 2011, no person or legal entity
(excluding a joint venture or general partnership), as defined and
determined by the regulations in 7 CFR part 1400 may receive, directly
or indirectly, more than $100,000 total per crop year under ELAP, LFP,
LIP and SURE combined.
For the payment limits, both indirect and direct benefits are
counted by attribution such that the total amount of payments is
attributed to a person by taking into account the direct and indirect
ownership interests of the person in a legal entity that is eligible to
receive payments. In the case of a legal entity, the same payment is
attributed to the direct payee in the full amount and those that have
an indirect interest to the amount of that indirect interest. For
example, under the attribution rules that apply to these programs,
assume:
Corporation A is in line to receive a $100,000 SURE
payment,
Corporation A is owned 50 percent by Individual A and 50
percent by Corporation B, and
Corporation B is owned by Individual B with a 30 percent
interest and by Individual C with a 70 percent interest.
If so, Corporation A, for payment limitation purposes would be
considered to have received $100,000 and Individual C (who owns 70
percent of Corporation B, which owns 50 percent of Corporation A) would
be considered to have indirectly benefitted by the amount of $35,000
(50 percent times 70 percent of the $100,000). Even though no part of
the $100,000 was actually paid to Individual C, the $35,000 would count
against Individual C's overall payment limitation from all sources and
farms. Assume now that Individual C was already at the maximum payment
limit. If so, Individual C would not have been eligible to receive
$35,000; as a result, the payment to Corporation A would be reduced by
$35,000.
The amount of any payment for which a participant may be eligible
from the SURE program will be commensurately reduced by any amount
received by the participant for the same or any similar loss from any
Federal disaster assistance program. Such disaster programs include
USDA conservation programs that pay for replanting or replacing plants
damaged by disaster. Aquaculture producers who received assistance
under the Aquaculture Grant Program \3\ will not be eligible for SURE
assistance on those species of aquaculture for which a grant payment
was received. Indemnities or NAP payments issued for losses of the
species will, however, count on the revenue side of the SURE payment
calculation. Participants cannot receive SURE assistance for the same
loss under ELAP, LIP, LFP or TAP.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\ The Aquaculture Grant Program was authorized by the Recovery
Act and implemented through a notice of Funds Availability published
in the Federal Register on June 2, 2009 (74 FR 26363-26365).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Provisions for both pay limits and for limits related to an
individual's or entity's adjusted gross income were contained in the
administrative subparts of part 760 (discussed above, previously
[[Page 68485]]
issued to implement other Farm Bill disaster assistance programs) and
generally the administration of those limitations will follow general
regulations in 7 CFR part 1400. In applying the limitation on average
adjusted gross income (AGI) for 2008, an individual or entity is
ineligible for SURE payment if the individual's or entity's average
annual AGI for 2005, 2006, and 2007 exceeded $2.5 million, under the
provisions in 7 CFR part 1400 in effect for 2008. For 2009 through
2011, the average AGI limitation provisions in 7 CFR part 1400
applicable to CCC commodity programs also apply to SURE. As specified
in the 2008 Farm Bill, for 2009 through 2011, a person or legal entity
with an average adjusted gross nonfarm income, as defined in 7 CFR
1400.3, that exceeds $500,000 for the relevant period, which is the 3
taxable years preceding the most immediately preceding complete taxable
year, as determined by CCC, will not be eligible to receive payments
under these programs. Likewise, if a person with an indirect interest
in a legal entity has an average nonfarm AGI over $500,000, then the
payment to the legal entity will be commensurately reduced as
calculated based on the percent of interest in the legal entity
receiving the payment. For example, continuing with the assumptions in
the example above, if Individual B had an average AGI that was over the
limit, then the payment to Corporation A will be reduced by 15 percent
(Individual B's 30 percent interest in Corporation B times Corporation
B's 50 percent interest in Corporation A).
Payment and average AGI limits will be determined under regulations
specified in 7 CFR part 1400 for CCC commodity programs. The SURE
program is not a CCC program, but the CCC regulations in 7 CFR part
1400 are adopted for this program.
The relevant AGI period for SURE and the other disaster assistance
programs for 2008 is the 3 calendar years that precede the program year
involved which are 2005, 2006 and 2007. However, beginning with 2009,
the AGI period is the 3 taxable years preceding the most immediately
preceding complete taxable year, as determined by CCC. For SURE, the
program year is the year that corresponds to the relevant crop year.
This program will be administered by crop year and most times the crop
year for all crops is easily indentified because both the year of the
planting and the year of the harvesting are the same or at least the
calendar year of the harvesting is the same nationwide. The Deputy
Administrator will be the ultimate arbiter of which production fits in
which ``crop year'' for purposes of SURE calculations. The crop year
concept in some limited cases can involve a loss that occurs in a
different calendar year than the calendar year whose number corresponds
to the crop year. For example, wheat for the 2009 crop year can be
planted in the fall of 2008 and be damaged or lost during 2008. SURE
payments related to such a loss would be made for the 2009 crop year
wheat, because the intent was to harvest this wheat in 2009.
Production losses are, in general, determined by calendar year of
harvest, but the payment limitation is for a crop year. Also, the
national average market price (NAMP) for a marketing year may not be
available until the fall of the following crop year, so the SURE
payment may often be calculated and paid in a different (later)
calendar year than the actual year of loss or losses.
The regulations in 7 CFR 1400.105 specify how payments will be
attributed and how far the attribution will go. Attribution will be
tracked through four levels of ownership in legal entities. The 2008
Farm Bill removed the previous ``3 entity rule,'' so a person can now
receive benefits attributed through an unlimited number of entities,
subject to the payment limits and the rules of attribution described in
this final rule and in 7 CFR part 1400.
In addition, the 2008 Farm Bill imposes limitations of payments to
foreign persons. Those limits are specified in the regulations in Sec.
760.103.
Payment Calculation--Overview
The SURE guarantee cannot exceed 90 percent of the total expected
revenue for the crops on the farm. Depending on the level of insurance
coverage the participant elects, the SURE guarantee for a specific
participant may be less than 90 percent of the expected revenue. In
general, the higher the level of insurance coverage purchased, the
higher the SURE guarantee. A participant who purchases the minimum
insurance required by this part and meets all other eligibility
requirements will be eligible for SURE, but the SURE guarantee will
reflect that minimal level of coverage.
BILLING CODE 3410-05-P
[[Page 68486]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR28DE09.001
BILLING CODE 3410-05-C
The following is an example of how a SURE payment is calculated for
a participant with two crops; corn insured with FCIC crop insurance and
alfalfa with NAP coverage. After the example, the general SURE payment
calculation formula is discussed.
SURE Guarantee Calculation Example for 2009 Through 2011 Crop Years
The SURE program guarantee calculation for insured corn in this
example is as follows: Assume 100 payment acres times an assumed 100
bushels per acre (SURE yield) times $4.00 per bushel (price election)
times 70 percent (coverage level) times 115 percent (SURE multiplier)
equals $32,200.
The program guarantee calculation for alfalfa with NAP coverage in
this example is as follows: assume 100 payment acres times an assumed
4.0 tons per acre (SURE yield) times an assumed $70 per ton (NAP
established price) times 50 percent times 120 percent (SURE multiplier)
equals $16,800.
The SURE guarantee is: $32,200 (corn) plus $16,800 (alfalfa) equals
$49,000.
The SURE guarantee is limited to 90 percent of the sum of the
expected revenue for each crop on the farm. Expected revenue for corn
is: 100 payment acres times 100 bushels per acre (SURE yield) times
$4.00 (price) equals $40,000. For alfalfa: 100 payment acres times 4.0
tons per acre (SURE yield) times $70 (NAP established price) equals
$28,000.
The expected revenue is: $40,000 (corn) plus $28,000 (alfalfa)
equals $68,000.
[[Page 68487]]
Total expected revenue $68,000 times 90 percent equals $61,200
(SURE guarantee cap).
Total Farm Revenue Calculation Example for 2008 Through 2011 Crop Years
Revenue for the insured corn in this example is based on a 60
percent loss in production that the participant experienced for this
crop, which in the example resulted in a 40 bushel yield. For the
purpose of the example, NAMP for insured corn in the State is $4.00 per
bushel. Assume, too, a freeze also affected this corn, which resulted
in a quality adjustment of 90 percent to account for extra moisture,
which is applied to the price. Therefore, the estimated actual value
for this crop is $4.00 (NAMP) times 90 percent (quality adjustment)
equals $3.60 times 4,000 bushels (actual production of the payment
acres) equals $14,400.
Revenue for the alfalfa in this example is based on a 25 percent
loss in production that the participant experienced for this crop,
which resulted in a 3 ton yield. For the purpose of the example, NAMP
for alfalfa in the State is $70. There is no quality adjustment for the
alfalfa crop. Therefore, estimated actual value for the alfalfa crop is
$70 (NAMP capped at 100 percent of the NAP established price) x 300
tons (actual production of the payment acres) equals $21,000.
Total farm revenue for this participant is $14,400 (corn) + $21,000
(alfalfa) equals $35,400.
The SURE payment for this participant would be: $49,000 (SURE
guarantee) - $35,400 (total farm revenue) = $13,600 times 60 percent
equals $8,160.
SURE Payment Example for 2008 Through 2011 Crop Years
The SURE payment will be calculated based on the difference between
a program guarantee and farm revenue as determined for a participant's
farm. The SURE program guarantee for a specific participant is based on
the participant's risk management purchases. The SURE calculation of
revenue is based on an applicant's actual production and NAMP for the
commodities produced, as well as a number of other revenue sources such
as farm program or NAP payments and insurance indemnities. In general,
because SURE is intended to enhance or augment risk management
purchases, participants who elect higher amounts of coverage will see
greater SURE benefits, compared to those who elect lesser amounts of
coverage. Under SURE, the crop insurance indemnity that is counted in
the SURE revenue calculation is after subtracting producer-paid
premiums for crop insurance in an amount not to exceed the crop
insurance indemnity paymenton a per unit basis.
The SURE payment is 60 percent of the difference between the SURE
guarantee and the total farm revenue. If total farm revenue is below
the SURE guarantee, the participant will be eligible for a payment
based on the amount of the shortfall. In general, except for additional
2008 assistance made available by the Recovery Act, the SURE guarantee
for insurable crops is determined by multiplying:
The number of planted and prevented planted acres, times
The higher of either the adjusted actual production
history yield or counter-cyclical yield, times
The coverage level, times
The price determined by the percentage of the crop
insurance price elected by the participant, times
115 percent (1.15).
In general, except for additional 2008 assistance made available by
the Recovery Act, the SURE guarantee for noninsurable crops is
determined by multiplying:
The number of planted and prevented planted acres, times
the higher of either the actual production history yield
or the counter-cyclical yield, times
50 percent (yield coverage under NAP), times
the NAP price, times
120 percent (1.20).
This rule specifies how the basic formula will be adjusted to
address a number of specific situations. Those situations include, but
are not limited to, adjustments for situations such as:
If a participant was exempt from the risk management
purchase requirement, the participant's SURE yield will be determined
by the FSA county committee using 65 percent of the higher of the
counter-cyclical program yield or the FCIC or county expected yield for
the crop as established by the Deputy Administrator.
If a participant's policy or plan of insurance provides
for an adjustment in the liability, such as in the case of prevented or
late planting, that adjustment will be used in calculating the SURE
guarantee.
If a participant's NAP coverage provides for an adjustment
in the level of assistance, such as for unharvested crops or prevented
or late planting, that adjustment will be used in calculating the SURE
guarantee.
If the farm is in an approved multiple cropping or double-
cropping area and both crops suffer losses, both crops may be eligible
for the calculation of disaster assistance if appropriate documentation
is provided. In most cases, only the first or initial crop is eligible
and will be used in calculating the SURE guarantee and revenue.
For 2008 only, and only under certain situations where the
producer met certain requirements, the Recovery Act provides for
changes to the percentages used to calculate the guarantee, such that
the multiplier is changed from 115 percent to 120 percent and from 120
percent to 125 percent, respectively. These percentages are used in the
comparison calculation to determine the amount of the SURE payment; the
Recovery Act specifies the two calculations for the comparison and
requires that the greater amount be used. Using the NAP calculation
with the 125 percent will never result in being the greater amount;
therefore, the calculation in the regulation uses the other calculation
in the comparison, which uses 120 percent.
Socially disadvantaged producers, limited resource producers, and
beginning farmers and ranchers who did not purchase risk management
coverage will be eligible for the same level of assistance as
participants who satisfied the purchase requirement by obtaining the
minimum level of coverage available, which is generally catastrophic or
``CAT'' coverage for insured crops or the standard NAP level of
coverage for noninsured crops. Equitable consideration will be provided
for instances involving non-yield based crop insurance policies. For
RMA ``pilot'' insured crops, having either pilot or NAP coverage on
applicable crops would meet the risk management purchase requirement.
The payment formulas in this rule are intended to treat similarly
situated participants consistently and equitably. However, participants
having similar losses on the same or similar crops may not necessarily
receive the same payment.
National Average Market Price (NAMP)
The Deputy Administrator will determine NAMP for each crop in a
marketing year, taking into account the best information available that
the Deputy Administrator believes is relevant to such decision. The
2008 Farm Bill specifies that the Secretary will adjust NAMP to reflect
average quality discounts applied to the local or regional market price
of a crop. Adjustments will be made at the State and county levels to
account for crop value that is affected by quality or is reduced due to
excessive high moisture content resulting from a disaster-related
[[Page 68488]]
condition. Quality adjustments will require participants to provide
verifiable evidence of production that details the extent of the
quality loss for a specific quantity. Test evidence to support the need
for quality adjustments, in addition to meeting all the requirements of
Sec. 760.641, must have been completed by January 1 of the year
following harvest.
For a crop for which an eligible participant on a farm receives
assistance under NAP, NAMP will be not more than the price of the crop
established under NAP. As determined by the Deputy Administrator, NAMP
will be derived using data from the National Agricultural Statistics
Service and other sources, and will consist of only one nationwide NAMP
for the crop. NAMP may be adjusted, as determined by the Deputy
Administrator, to reflect regional variations in a manner consistent
with FCIA or NAP. NAMPs may be adjusted by FSA State committees, in
accordance with procedures set out by the Deputy Administrator to
recognize average quality loss factors that are reflected in market by
region. In general, adjustments will be made at the State level for
counties or portions of counties. The NAMP will be established on a
harvested basis, not including costs of transportation, storage,
processing, marketing, or other post-harvest expenses, as determined by
FSA.
In all cases, matters such as NAMPs and other program provisions
that apply generally, which are not established or determined in
response to individual participant applications, are not and will not
be individually appealable or contestable. Participants have the right
to challenge administrative decisions made in response to their
particular applications; however, they cannot appeal general program
provisions such as average prices, average yields, NAMPs, or factors
used for similarly situated participants, as specified in 7 CFR
760.110.
Treatment of Value Loss Crops
Production methods and risk management of value loss crops, such as
ornamental nursery and aquaculture, are significantly different than
for yield-based crops. Where a yield-based crop is harvested and
marketed in a single crop year or marketing year, the participant's
inventory of the typical value loss crop fluctuates, sometimes rapidly,
in the course of normal business operations. The total value of the
inventory fluctuates for reasons that may be unrelated to a disaster or
to a farm's expected annual revenue or production.
SURE payment eligibility for value loss crops will be determined
based on inventory and losses at the time of the disaster and only for
the losses due to that disaster. This is in contrast to other types of
crops, where the SURE guarantee will typically be based on several
years of production history. The guarantee for value loss crops will be
based on the inventory on hand immediately before the disaster and the
revenue used for the payment calculation will be based on the inventory
immediately after the disaster. Daily inventory records required for
NAP or crop insurance will typically be sufficient for documenting
losses for SURE payment eligibility. All other inventory not marketed
immediately prior to and after the disaster event are not relevant for
SURE purposes and will not be counted as part of the guarantee or as
farm revenue. Further, farm revenue will not be adjusted for market
price declines due to the complexity in determining average market
prices by species for value loss crops. Quality will also not be
further considered in determining revenue. These provisions are
consistent with insurance policies and NAP for value loss crops.
For value loss crops, the SURE guarantee will be based on the level
of insurance coverage selected, as with other crops. For example, if a
participant had $100,000 value of value loss crop inventory immediately
before the disaster or event and had elected an insurance coverage
level of 70 percent, the SURE payment would be calculated on 60 percent
of the difference between the dollar value of inventory immediately
after disaster ($0 in this example for a total loss) and the SURE
guarantee of $80,500 ($100,000 times 70 percent coverage level times
115 percent). If the participant was already paid $70,000 in crop
insurance indemnity over the cost of the producer-paid premiums for the
farm, as specified in this rule (which counts as revenue), then SURE
would pay 60 percent of the difference between the SURE guarantee for
the participant ($80,500) and the $70,000 indemnity. In this case, 60
percent of $10,500 equals $6,300.
Application and Certification of Interests Deadline
There is no pre-sign-up or pre-enrollment required for SURE, but
participants must submit a complete application in order to be eligible
to receive payment. The application for payment will serve as the
participant's certification of eligibility and interests. FSA will use
these certifications to determine payment eligibility. Participants
must submit an application by March 1 of the calendar year two years
after the crop year of the loss. For example, for the 2009 crop year,
the SURE application including certification of interests must be
submitted to the FSA county office by March 1, 2011.
Lack of Access
The 2008 Farm Bill, as amended by the Recovery Act, contains a lack
of access provision that authorizes discretion to the Secretary to
provide assistance to participants who suffered a 2008 production loss
due to a natural cause, except as specified in the Recovery Act. Under
that provision, assistance may be provided to producers that did not
have access to a policy or plan of insurance or did not qualify for a
written agreement because one or more farming practices, which the
Secretary has determined are good farming practices, differ
significantly from practices of producers of the same crop in other
regions of the United States, and were not eligible for NAP coverage.
The Deputy Administrator has the authority to exercise this discretion
as needed, but it is understood that the scope of this provision is
very limited. Whether the Deputy Administrator exercises this authority
or not is not a relief determination for an individual program
participant based on particular facts but a discretionary determination
of general effect. Accordingly, it is FSA's position that such
determinations are not subject to administrative appeal either within
FSA or before the National Appeal Division of the Department.
Multi-Year Losses
The 2008 Farm Bill, as amended by the Recovery Act, authorized the
Secretary to provide equitable treatment as the Secretary considers
appropriate for eligible participants on a farm that suffered
production losses in the 2008 crop year that result in multi-year
production losses. In order to be consistent with policies or plans of
risk management coverage available to the majority of crops that are
likely to be included in the SURE farm, and due to the complexity and
potential problems of calculating multi-year losses on both the farm
guarantee and revenue sides, as well as the difficulty in determining
whether events in any one crop year were significant enough to result
in multi-year losses, the Secretary has elected not to implement any
discretionary provisions for multi-year losses under SURE at this time.
Notice and Comment
The 2008 Consolidated Security, Disaster Assistance, and Continuing
[[Page 68489]]
Appropriations Act (Pub. L. 110-329) made section 1601(c)(2) of the
2008 Farm Bill applicable in implementing section 12033 of the 2008
Farm Bill. To the extent relevant, the exemptions granted by section
1601(c)(2) of the 2008 Farm Bill apply, we believe, to the
corresponding provision enacted in section 15101 since they are
identical except for the provisions for funding in section 15101, which
do not appear at all in section 12033. Otherwise, the provisions of
Public Law 110-329 would have no meaning. Therefore, these regulations
are exempt from the notice and comment requirements of the
Administrative Procedures Act (5 U.S.C. 553), as specified in section
1601(c)(2) of the 2008 Farm Bill, which requires that the regulations
be promulgated and administered without regard to the notice and
comment provisions of section 553 of title 5 of the United States Code
or the Statement of Policy of the Secretary of Agriculture effective
July 24, 1971, (36 FR 13804) relating to notices of proposed rulemaking
and public participation in rulemaking.
Executive Order 12866
The Office of Management and Budget (OMB) designated this rule as
economically significant under Executive Order 12866 and, therefore,
OMB reviewed this final rule. A cost-benefit assessment of this rule is
summarized below and is available from the contact information above.
Summary of Economic Impacts
SURE payments for 2008 through 2011 are expected to total $3.4
billion, an average of $0.85 billion per crop year, which represents
both the cost of the program and the benefit to participants. This is
less than the average of $1.14 billion per year for previous ad hoc
crop disaster programs from 1998 to 2007. This estimate for SURE was
estimated by taking the cost of ad hoc crop disaster programs from 1998
to 2007 and adjusting that cost for predicted cash value of crop
production for 2008 through 2011 and for the specific eligibility
requirements for SURE.
Although crop prices are expected to continue rising, potentially
resulting in greater costs for SURE than for previous programs, the
overall costs for SURE are expected to be less than to the cost of
previous ad hoc disaster programs because, unlike ad hoc disaster
programs, SURE, in general, is additional compensation for established
losses under crop insurance or NAP. SURE is not a benefit that replaces
or duplicates previously received crop insurance or NAP payments,
although the crop insurance indemnity that is counted in the SURE
revenue calculation is after subtracting producer-paid premiums for
crop insurance in an amount not to exceed the crop insurance indemnity
payment. This provision has been included in the rule because the 2008
Farm Bill exempts program indemnities from the calculation of the
farm's revenue for purposes of comparing that revenue with the program
guarantee. Often, the premium is simply deducted from the indemnity
rather than paid outright and it is FSA's view that the 2008 Farm Bill
contemplated the ``indemnity'' to mean the net revenue paid to the
farmer as that would reflect the actual positive effect of that
recovery on revenue. This does not suggest in any way that premiums
that do not result in a indemnity payment or other farm costs should be
deducted, but rather is an accommodation of what it believed to be the
perceived intent of this specific provision in the 2008 Farm Bill
addressing indemnities.
Also, SURE payments are based on farm revenue losses, rather than
losses in particular crops or individual units, so participants with
losses in one crop but not others may or may not qualify for a SURE
payment.
The SURE guarantee cap is 90 percent of expected revenue, while
previous programs had a cap of 95 percent of normal crop value.
Regulatory Flexibility Act
This rule is not subject to the Regulatory Flexibility Act since
FSA is not required to publish a notice of proposed rulemaking for this
rule.
Environmental Review
The environmental impacts of this rule have been considered in a
manner consistent with the provisions of the National Environmental
Policy Act (NEPA), 42 U.S.C. 4321-4347, the regulations of the Council
on Environmental Quality (40 CFR parts 1500-1508), and FSA regulations
for compliance with NEPA (7 CFR part 799). FSA has determined that the
combination of discretionary and non-discretionary provisions of this
Rule would not constitute a major Federal action that would
significantly affect the quality of the human environment, and
therefore, no environmental assessment or environmental impact
statement will be prepared.
Executive Order 12372
This program is not subject to Executive Order 12372, which
requires consultation with State and local officials. See the notice
related to 7 CFR part 3015, subpart V, published in the Federal
Register on June 24, 1983 (48 FR 29115).
Executive Order 12988
The rule has been reviewed in accordance with Executive Order
12988. The provisions of this rule preempt State laws to the extent
such laws are inconsistent with the provisions of this rule. Before any
judicial action may be brought concerning the provisions of this rule,
the administrative remedies must be exhausted.
Executive Order 13132
The policies contained in this rule do not have any substantial
direct effect on States, on the relationship between the national
government and States, or on the distribution of power and
responsibilities among various levels of government. Nor does this rule
impose substantial direct compliance costs on State and local
governments. Therefore, consultation with States was not required.
Executive Order 13175
The policies contained in this rule do not impose substantial
unreimbursed direct compliance costs on Indian tribal governments or
have tribal implications that preempt tribal law.
Unfunded Mandates
This rule contains no Federal mandates under the regulatory
provisions of Title II of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995
(UMRA) for State, local, and tribal governments or the private sector.
In addition, FSA was not required to publish a notice of proposed rule
making for this rule. Therefore, this rule is not subject to the
requirements of sections 202 and 205 of UMRA.
Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act of 1996 (SBREFA)
This rule has been determined to be Major under SBREFA (Pub. L.
104-121). SBREFA normally requires that an agency delay the effective
date of a major rule for 60 days from the date of publication to allow
for Congressional review. Section 808 of SBREFA allows an agency to
make a major regulation effective immediately if the agency finds there
is good cause to do so. FSA finds that it would be contrary to the
public interest to delay implementation of this rule because it would
significantly delay assistance to the many people affected by the
disasters addressed by this rule. Therefore, this rule is effective
immediately.
[[Page 68490]]
Federal Assistance Programs
This rule applies to the following Federal assistance program that
is not listed in the Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance: 10.090-
SURE.
Paperwork Reduction Act
The regulations in this rule are exempt from the requirements of
the Paperwork Reduction Act (44 U.S.C. Chapter 35), as specified in
section 1601(c)(2) of the 2008 Farm Bill, which provides that these
regulations be promulgated and administered without regard to the
Paperwork Reduction Act.
E-Government Act Compliance
FSA is committed to complying with the E-Government Act, to promote
the use of the Internet and other information technologies to provide
increased opportunities for citizen access to government information
and services, and for other purposes.
List of Subjects in 7 CFR Part 760
Dairy products, Indemnity payments, Pesticide and pests, Reporting
and recordkeeping requirements.
0
For the reasons discussed above, the Farm Service Agency, USDA, amends
7 CFR part 760 as follows:
PART 760--INDEMNITY PAYMENT PROGRAMS
0
1. The authority citation for part 760 continues to read as follows:
Authority: 7 U.S.C. 4501, 7 U.S.C. 1531, 16 U.S.C. 3801, note,
and 19 U.S.C. 2497; Title III, Pub. L. 109-234, 120 Stat. 474; and
Title IX, Pub. L. 110-28, 121 Stat. 211.
0
2. Add subpart G to read as follows:
Subpart G--Supplemental Revenue Assistance Payments Program
Sec.
760.601 Applicability.
760.602 Definitions.
760.610 Participant eligibility.
760.611 Qualifying losses, eligible causes and types of loss.
760.613 De minimis exception.
760.614 Lack of access.
760.620 Time and method of application and certification of
interests.
760.621 Requirement to report acreage and production.
760.622 Incorrect or false producer certification evidence.
760.631 SURE guarantee calculation.
760.632 Payment acres.
760.633 2008 SURE guarantee calculation.
760.634 SURE guarantee for value loss crops.
760.635 Total farm revenue.
760.636 Expected revenue.
760.637 Determination of production.
760.638 Determination of SURE yield.
760.640 National average market price.
760.641 Adjustments made to NAMP to reflect loss of quality.
760.650 Calculating SURE.
Subpart G--Supplemental Revenue Assistance Payments Program
Sec. 760.601 Applicability.
(a) This subpart specifies the terms and conditions of the
Supplemental Revenue Assistance Payments Program (SURE).
(b) Assistance in the form of SURE payments is available for crop
losses occurring in the crop year 2008 through September 30, 2011,
caused by disaster as determined by the Secretary.
(c) SURE provides disaster assistance to eligible participants on
farms in:
(1) Disaster counties designated by the Secretary, which also
includes counties contiguous to such declared disaster counties, if the
participant incurred actual production losses of at least 10 percent to
at least one crop of economic significance on the f