Withholding Under Internal Revenue Code Section 3402(t), 74082-74096 [E8-28789]
Download as PDF
74082
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 235 / Friday, December 5, 2008 / Proposed Rules
Authority for This Rulemaking
Title 49 of the United States Code
specifies the FAA’s authority to issue
rules on aviation safety. Subtitle I,
Section 106, describes the authority of
the FAA Administrator. Subtitle VII,
Aviation Programs, describes in more
detail the scope of the Agency’s
authority.
We are issuing this rulemaking under
the authority described in Subtitle VII,
Part A, Subpart III, Section 44701,
‘‘General requirements.’’ Under that
section, Congress charges the FAA with
promoting safe flight of civil aircraft in
air commerce by prescribing regulations
for practices, methods, and procedures
the Administrator finds necessary for
safety in air commerce. This regulation
is within the scope of that authority
because it addresses an unsafe condition
that is likely to exist or develop on
products identified in this rulemaking
action.
Regulatory Findings
We have determined that this
proposed AD would not have federalism
implications under Executive Order
13132. This proposed AD would not
have a substantial direct effect on the
States, on the relationship between the
national Government and the States, or
on the distribution of power and
responsibilities among the various
levels of government.
For the reasons discussed above, I
certify that the proposed regulation:
1. Is not a ‘‘significant regulatory
action’’ under Executive Order 12866;
2. Is not a ‘‘significant rule’’ under the
DOT Regulatory Policies and Procedures
(44 FR 11034, February 26, 1979); and
3. Will not have a significant
economic impact, positive or negative,
on a substantial number of small entities
under the criteria of the Regulatory
Flexibility Act.
We prepared a regulatory evaluation
of the estimated costs to comply with
this proposed AD and placed it in the
AD docket. See the ADDRESSES section
for a location to examine the regulatory
evaluation.
dwashington3 on PROD1PC60 with PROPOSALS
List of Subjects in 14 CFR Part 39
Air transportation, Aircraft, Aviation
safety, Incorporation by reference,
Safety.
The Proposed Amendment
Accordingly, under the authority
delegated to me by the Administrator,
the FAA proposes to amend 14 CFR part
39 as follows:
VerDate Aug<31>2005
14:59 Dec 04, 2008
Jkt 217001
PART 39—AIRWORTHINESS
DIRECTIVES
1. The authority citation for part 39
continues to read as follows:
Authority: 49 U.S.C. 106(g), 40113, 44701.
§ 39.13
[Amended]
2. The Federal Aviation
Administration (FAA) amends § 39.13
by adding the following new
airworthiness directive (AD):
Boeing: Docket No. FAA–2008–1275;
Directorate Identifier 2007–NM–167–AD.
Comments Due Date
(a) The FAA must receive comments on
this AD action by January 20, 2009.
Affected ADs
(b) None
Applicability
(c) This AD applies to Boeing Model 737–
100, –200, –200C, –300, –400, and –500
series airplanes, certificated in any category;
as identified in Boeing Alert Service Bulletin
737–53A1269, dated May 17, 2007.
Unsafe Condition
(d) This AD results from a report indicating
that cracks were found in the backup
intercostals and upper sill web of the forward
airstair doorway. We are issuing this AD to
detect and correct fatigue cracking of the
backup intercostals and upper sill web of the
forward airstair doorway, which could result
in a rapid loss of cabin pressure.
Compliance
(e) You are responsible for having the
actions required by this AD performed within
the compliance times specified, unless the
actions have already been done.
Inspections
(f) At the applicable compliance times and
repeat intervals listed in the tables of
paragraph 1.E., ‘‘Compliance,’’ of Boeing
Alert Service Bulletin 737–53A1269, dated
May 17, 2007 (hereafter ‘‘the service
bulletin’’), except as provided by paragraphs
(f)(1), (f)(2), and (f)(3) of this AD: Do
repetitive detailed and high frequency eddy
current inspections to detect cracks of the
backup intercostals and the upper sill of the
forward airstair doorway, and applicable
corrective actions by accomplishing all the
applicable actions specified in the
Accomplishment Instructions of the service
bulletin. Do the applicable corrective actions
before further flight.
(1) Where the service bulletin specifies a
compliance time from the release date of the
service bulletin, this AD requires compliance
within the specified compliance time after
the effective date of this AD.
(2) Where the columns identified as
‘‘Airplane Flight Cycles’’ in the tables of the
service bulletin specify less than 45,000 total
flight cycles for certain actions, this AD
affects airplanes having less than or equal to
45,000 total flight cycles.
(3) Where the columns identified as
‘‘Repeat Interval’’ in the tables of the service
PO 00000
Frm 00012
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
bulletin specify an interval of 4,500 flight
cycles for all conditions, this AD requires
repetitive inspections only if no crack is
found during any inspection required by
paragraph (f) of this AD.
Optional Terminating Action
(g) Accomplishing the backup intercostal
repair/preventative modification and/or the
upper door sill web repair, in accordance
with the Accomplishment Instructions of
Boeing Alert Service Bulletin 737–53A1269,
dated May 17, 2007, ends all the
corresponding repetitive inspection
requirements of paragraph (f) of this AD.
Alternative Methods of Compliance
(AMOCs)
(h)(1) The Manager, Seattle Aircraft
Certification Office (ACO), FAA, ATTN:
Howard Hall, Aerospace Engineer, Airframe
Branch, ANM–120S, FAA, Seattle ACO, 1601
Lind Avenue, SW., Renton, Washington
98057–3356; telephone (917) 917–6430; fax
(425) 917–6590; has the authority to approve
AMOCs for this AD, if requested using the
procedures found in 14 CFR 39.19.
(2) To request a different method of
compliance or a different compliance time
for this AD, follow the procedures in 14 CFR
39.19. Before using any approved AMOC on
any airplane to which the AMOC applies,
notify your appropriate principal inspector
(PI) in the FAA Flight Standards District
Office (FSDO), or lacking a PI, your local
FSDO.
(3) An AMOC that provides an acceptable
level of safety may be used for any repair
required by this AD, if it is approved by an
Authorized Representative for the Boeing
Commercial Airplanes Delegation Option
Authorization Organization who has been
authorized by the Manager, Seattle ACO,
FAA, to make those findings. For a repair
method to be approved, the repair must meet
the certification basis of the airplane, and the
approval must specifically refer to this AD.
Issued in Renton, Washington on
November 26, 2008.
Ali Bahrami,
Manager, Transport Airplane Directorate,
Aircraft Certification Service.
[FR Doc. E8–28819 Filed 12–4–08; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4910–13–P
DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY
Internal Revenue Service
26 CFR Part 31
[REG–158747–06]
RIN 1545–BG45
Withholding Under Internal Revenue
Code Section 3402(t)
AGENCY: Internal Revenue Service (IRS),
Treasury.
ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking.
SUMMARY: This document contains
proposed regulations relating to
E:\FR\FM\05DEP1.SGM
05DEP1
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 235 / Friday, December 5, 2008 / Proposed Rules
dwashington3 on PROD1PC60 with PROPOSALS
withholding under section 3402(t) of the
Internal Revenue Code (Code). The
proposed regulations reflect changes in
the law made by the Tax Increase
Prevention and Reconciliation Act of
2005 that require Federal, State, and
local government entities to withhold
income tax when making payments to
persons providing property or services.
These proposed regulations provide
guidance to assist the government
entities in complying with section
3402(t). The regulations also provide
certain guidance to persons receiving
payments for property or services from
government entities. This document
also contains proposed amendments to
regulations under sections 3406, 6011,
6051, 6071, and 6302 of the Code.
DATES: Written or electronic comments
and requests for a public hearing must
be received by March 5, 2009.
ADDRESSES: Send submissions to:
CC:PA:LPD:PR (REG–158747–06), room
5205, Internal Revenue Service, PO Box
7604, Ben Franklin Station, Washington,
DC 20044. Submissions may be handdelivered Monday through Friday
between the hours of 8 a.m. and 4 p.m.
to CC:PA:LPD:PR (REG–158747–06),
Courier’s Desk, Internal Revenue
Service, 1111 Constitution Avenue,
NW., Washington, DC, or sent
electronically via the Federal
eRulemaking Portal at https://
www.regulations.gov/ (IRS REG–
158747–06).
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Concerning these proposed regulations,
Jean Casey, (202) 622–6040; concerning
submissions of comments or to request
a public hearing, Richard Hurst at
Richard.A.Hurst@irscounsel.treas.gov or
(202) 622–7180 (not toll-free numbers).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Background
This document contains proposed
amendments to 26 CFR part 31 under
section 3402(t) of the Code. This
document also contains proposed
amendments to 26 CFR part 31 under
sections 3406, 6011, 6051, 6071, and
6302 of the Code.
Section 3402(t) of the Code was added
by section 511 of the Tax Increase
Prevention and Reconciliation Act of
2005, Public Law 109–222 (TIPRA), 120
Stat. 345, which was enacted into law
on May 17, 2006. Section 3402(t)(1)
provides that the Government of the
United States, every State, every
political subdivision thereof, and every
instrumentality of the foregoing
(including multi-State agencies) making
any payment to any person providing
any property or services (including any
payment made in connection with a
VerDate Aug<31>2005
14:59 Dec 04, 2008
Jkt 217001
government voucher or certificate
program which functions as a payment
for property or services) shall deduct
and withhold from such payment a tax
in an amount equal to 3 percent of such
payment. Under the statute, section
3402(t) applies to payments made after
December 31, 2010.
Exceptions to section 3402(t)
withholding are contained in section
3402(t)(2). Section 3402(t)(2) provides
that section 3402(t) withholding shall
not apply to any payment—
(A) Except as provided in section
3402(t)(2)(B), which is subject to
withholding under any other provision
of chapter 24 (Collection of Income Tax
at Source on Wages, sections 3401
through 3406) or chapter 3 (Withholding
of Tax on Nonresident Aliens and
Foreign Corporations, sections 1441
through 1464) of the Code;
(B) Which is subject to withholding
under section 3406 (backup
withholding) and from which amounts
are being withheld under such section;
(C) Of interest;
(D) For real property;
(E) To any government entity subject
to the requirements of section 3402(t)(1),
any tax-exempt entity, or any foreign
government;
(F) Made pursuant to a classified or
confidential contract described in
section 6050M(e)(3);
(G) Made by a political subdivision of
a State (or any instrumentality thereof)
which makes less than $100,000,000 of
such payments annually;
(H) Which is in connection with a
public assistance or public welfare
program for which eligibility is
determined by a needs or income test;
and
(I) To any government employee not
otherwise excludable with respect to his
or her services as an employee.
Section 3402(t)(3) provides for the
coordination of section 3402(t) with
other Code sections. Section 3402(t)(3)
provides that, for purposes of sections
3403 and 3404 and for purposes of so
much of subtitle F (except section 7205)
as relates to chapter 24, payments to any
person for property or services which
are subject to withholding shall be
treated as if such payments were wages
paid by an employer to an employee.
The legislative history in connection
with section 3402(t) indicates that ‘‘[t]he
withholding requirement applies
regardless of whether the government
entity making such payment is the
recipient of the property or services.’’
H.R. Conf. Rep. No.109–455, 109th
Cong., 2d Sess. at 300 (2006). Further,
the conference report also provides,
with respect to the exception provided
by section 3402(t)(2)(H), that ‘‘payments
PO 00000
Frm 00013
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
74083
under government programs to provide
health care or other services that are not
based on the needs or income of the
recipients are subject to withholding,
including programs where eligibility is
based on the age of the beneficiary.’’
H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 109–455 at page
301. In addition, with respect to section
3402(t)(2)(A), the conference report
states that section 3402(t) withholding
‘‘does not apply to payments of wages
or to any other payment with respect to
which mandatory (e.g., U.S.-source
income of foreign taxpayers) or
voluntary (e.g., unemployment benefits)
withholding applies under present
law.’’ H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 109–455 at
page 301. The origins of the provision
indicate that it was conceived to address
tax noncompliance. See also, ‘‘Options
to Improve Tax Compliance and Reform
Tax Expenditures’’ (JCS–2–05), Joint
Committee on Taxation, Jan. 27, 2005.
Notice 2008–38, 2008–13 IRB 683,
published by the IRS on March 31,
2008, invited public comments
regarding guidance under section
3402(t). In particular, Notice 2008–38
requested comments on the application
of section 3402(t) to credit cards and
payment cards, payments to payees not
subject to United States taxation,
passthrough entities in which a
government entity is a partner or owner,
government contractors and
subcontractors, and de minimis
payments. The Notice also requested
comments on when and how amounts
withheld under section 3402(t) should
be transmitted to the IRS. See
§ 601.601(d)(2)(ii)(b).
Many comments were received in
response to Notice 2008–38, and the
comments were taken into consideration
in developing the proposed regulations.
Explanation of Provisions
The proposed regulations provide
rules about which government entities
are subject to the requirement of section
3402(t) withholding, which payments
are subject to section 3402(t)
withholding (and which are excepted
from such withholding), when
withholding is required on such
payments, and how government entities
pay and report the tax to the IRS. The
proposed regulations also include
transition rules providing relief from
liability for the tax imposed by section
3402(t) with respect to payments under
existing contracts. The proposed
regulations also provide temporary
relief from penalties and interest if a
government entity makes a good faith
effort but fails to withhold on payments
as required under section 3402(t).
The regulations provide guidance
primarily on what government entities
E:\FR\FM\05DEP1.SGM
05DEP1
74084
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 235 / Friday, December 5, 2008 / Proposed Rules
dwashington3 on PROD1PC60 with PROPOSALS
need to do to comply so that they can
make timely preparations. The Treasury
Department and IRS anticipate issuing
further guidance to address questions
raised by taxpayers who expect to
receive payments subject to section
3402(t) withholding from government
entities including, but not limited to,
how to claim credits and how to claim
the benefit of statutory exemptions from
withholding under section 3402(t).
Although some commenters requested
that the Treasury Department and IRS
issue guidance exempting payments
from withholding where the 3-percent
rate for withholding prescribed under
section 3402(t) is expected to exceed
either the profit margin in the taxpayer’s
industry or the income tax the taxpayer
will owe for reasons particular to the
taxpayer’s business, the Treasury
Department and IRS have determined
that exemptions of this type would be
contrary to the requirements of the
statute. Commenters also requested that
they be permitted to credit amounts
withheld under section 3402(t) against
Federal taxes other than income taxes,
such as employment taxes. Consistent
with the statute’s purpose of addressing
income tax noncompliance, the
Treasury Department and IRS propose
to allow credits to be claimed only
against income tax.
Government Entities Subject to Section
3402(t)
Section 3402(t)(1) applies to ‘‘the
Government of the United States, every
State, every political subdivision
thereof, and every instrumentality of the
foregoing.’’ Section 3402(t) does not
restrict the term the Government of the
United States in any manner. Therefore,
the entire Federal government,
including the executive branch, the
legislative branch, and the judicial
branch, is subject to the requirements of
section 3402(t). Thus, Congress, the
Administrative Office of the United
States Courts, the Executive Office of
the President, Federal agencies, and all
other components of the Federal
government are included in the
definition of Government of the United
States and are required to withhold
under section 3402(t).
The term State includes the District of
Columbia. See section 7701(a)(10) of the
Code. For purposes of section 3402(t),
the term State does not include Indian
tribal governments. Section 7871(a)
prescribes when an Indian tribal
government is to be treated as a State
under the Code, and section 7871(a)
does not provide that Indian tribal
governments will be treated as States for
purposes of section 3402(t).
Consequently, the term political
VerDate Aug<31>2005
14:59 Dec 04, 2008
Jkt 217001
subdivision also does not include a
subdivision of an Indian tribal
government. See section 7871(a) and (d).
Accordingly, because Indian tribal
governments and their subdivisions are
not among the listed government
entities subject to section 3402(t),
payments by Indian tribal governments
and their subdivisions are not subject to
the withholding requirements of section
3402(t).
The definition of political subdivision
in the proposed regulations follows the
definition in the section 103 regulations.
Section 1.103–1(b) of the Income Tax
Regulations provides, in part, that the
term political subdivision denotes any
division of any State or local
government unit that is a municipal
corporation or that has been delegated
the right to exercise part of the
sovereign power of the unit.
Although the Code makes references
to government instrumentalities in
multiple sections, the Code and
regulations do not currently provide a
definition of instrumentality. In Rev.
Rul. 57–128, 1957–1 CB 311, the IRS
adopted a six-factor test for use in
determining what is an instrumentality
of a State or a political subdivision
thereof for purposes of an exception
from the requirement to pay tax under
the Federal Insurance Contributions Act
(FICA). The factors are: (1) Whether the
organization is used for a government
purpose and performs a government
function; (2) whether performance of its
function is on behalf of one or more
States or political subdivisions; (3)
whether there are any private interests
involved, or whether the States or
political subdivisions involved have the
powers and interests of an owner; (4)
whether control and supervision of the
organization is vested in public
authority or authorities; (5) if express or
implied statutory or other authority is
necessary for the creation and/or use of
such an instrumentality, and whether
such authority exists; and (6) the degree
of financial autonomy and the source of
its operating expenses. A number of
revenue rulings published by the IRS
illustrate the application of this test.
See, for example, Rev. Rul. 65–26,
1965–1 CB 444; Rev. Rul. 65–196, 1965–
2 CB 388; and Rev. Rul. 69–453, 1969–
2 CB 182. See § 601.601(d)(2)(ii)(b). The
Treasury Department and IRS invite
comments on use of the same or a
similar test for purposes of section
3402(t).
Persons Subject to Withholding Under
Section 3402(t)
Section 3402(t) applies to government
payments to ‘‘persons’’ providing any
property or services. Section 7701(a)(1)
PO 00000
Frm 00014
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
of the Code provides that, when used in
the Code, where not otherwise distinctly
expressed or manifestly incompatible
with the intent thereof, the term person
shall be construed to mean and include
an individual, a trust, estate,
partnership, association, company, or
corporation. Because no alternative
definition of person is provided in
section 3402(t), the definition in section
7701(a)(1) and the regulations under
section 7701(a)(1) applies. Therefore,
section 3402(t) withholding can apply to
payments for property or services to
individuals, trusts, estates, partnerships,
associations, companies, or
corporations.
Payments Subject to Section 3402(t)
Withholding
The proposed regulations provide that
a payment subject to withholding arises
when the government entity or its
payment administrator pays a person for
providing property or services. Under
the proposed rules, the withholding
requirements of section 3402(t) will not
apply to any payment that is less than
the payment threshold amount, which is
$10,000. The Treasury Department and
IRS are proposing this payment
threshold of $10,000 because the burden
of withholding on smaller transactions
is likely to be substantial and outweigh
the benefits of increased withholding.
This threshold corresponds to a
minimum withholding of $300.
Under the proposed rules, multiple
payments made by a government entity
to any person generally would not be
aggregated in determining whether the
payment threshold amount has been
met. However, the proposed regulations
provide an anti-abuse rule to ensure that
the payment threshold is not
manipulated to avoid the required
withholding. If a government entity
divides a payment into two or more
separate payments primarily to avoid
the payment threshold for one or more
payments, the separate payments would
be treated as one payment made on the
date that the first payment was made for
purposes of this rule. For example, if a
government entity is scheduled to make
a contractual payment to a person for
landscaping services of $15,000 on July
2, 2011, but divides the payment into
payments of $7,000 and $8,000 made on
July 1, 2011, and July 2, 2011,
respectively, the government entity
would be treated as having made a
single payment of $15,000 on July 1,
2011. This anti-abuse rule would not
apply if the primary reason for division
into separate payments is unrelated to
section 3402(t).
If a government entity makes a single
payment of $10,000 or more to any
E:\FR\FM\05DEP1.SGM
05DEP1
dwashington3 on PROD1PC60 with PROPOSALS
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 235 / Friday, December 5, 2008 / Proposed Rules
person for more than one property or
service provided by that person, the
government entity would be required to
withhold on the payment. For example,
if a person bills a government entity
$5,000 each day for seven days for
services provided each day, but the
government entity makes one payment
of $35,000 in satisfaction of these bills,
the payment threshold is applied to the
$35,000 payment.
Many commenters requested guidance
on how the requirements of section
3402(t) apply to prime contractors and
subcontractors. Under the proposed
rules, if a government entity or its
payment administrator makes a
payment to a person that is subject to
withholding under section 3402(t), no
subsequent transfer of cash or property
by that person to another person is
treated as a payment for section 3402(t)
purposes. Thus, if the government entity
enters into a contract with a prime
contractor for property and services, and
that prime contractor separately
contracts with subcontractors for
delivery of certain property and
services, then withholding under
section 3402(t) applies only to payments
by the government entity or its payment
administrator to the prime contractor,
and does not apply to successive
payments by the prime contractor to its
subcontractors.
The proposed regulations apply to
payments made by the government
entity or its payment administrator. For
purposes of the proposed regulations, a
payment administrator is any person
that acts with respect to a payment
solely as an agent for a government
entity by making the payment on behalf
of the government entity to a person
providing property or services to, or on
behalf of, the government entity.
Transfers of funds from a government
entity to a payment administrator to be
used by the payment administrator, on
the government entity’s behalf, to pay
persons for providing property or
services are not payments subject to
withholding under section 3402(t).
However, if the government entity pays
the payment administrator a fee for its
services, the government entity would
treat the fee as a payment subject to
withholding. The government entity is
liable for the withholding required and
responsible for all related reporting
regardless of whether the government
entity or its payment administrator
makes the payment and regardless of
when the payment for property or
services is made under this section.
Credit Card Payments
Many commenters questioned how
the requirements of section 3402(t)
VerDate Aug<31>2005
14:59 Dec 04, 2008
Jkt 217001
apply to payments made by government
credit card or payment card. Under the
proposed regulations, when a
government entity or its payment
administrator uses a credit card or
payment card to pay a person for
providing property or services, payment
occurs at the point of sale when the
government credit card or payment card
is tendered and not when the
government entity pays the credit card
company. The government entity is
liable for the withholding and reporting
associated with the payment, and this
liability is not transferred to any other
party involved in the credit card or
payment card transaction, including,
but not limited to, the acquiring bank,
the issuing bank, or the credit card
association. (The acquiring bank may be
separately required to report amounts it
pays under new section 6050W, which
was enacted as part of the Housing
Assistance Tax Act of 2008, Div. C of
Pub. L. 110–289.)
Section 3402(t)(2)(A)—Payments
Subject to Withholding Under Chapter 3
or Chapter 24 and Section
3402(t)(2)(B)—Payments From Which
Backup Withholding Is Withheld
Section 3402(t)(2)(A) provides an
exception from the requirement of
section 3402(t) for amounts that are
subject to withholding under some other
provision of chapter 3 or chapter 24
(other than section 3406). Thus,
payments that are subject to
withholding under the wage
withholding regime or the regime for
withholding of tax on nonresident
aliens and foreign corporations are
exempt from withholding under section
3402(t). Furthermore, consistent with
the legislative history, amounts for
which the payee may elect withholding
are exempt from withholding under
section 3402(t), regardless of whether
the payee in fact makes such an
election. These payments include: (1)
Unemployment compensation as
defined in section 85(b) (section
3402(p)(2)); (2) social security benefits
as defined in section 86(d) (section
3402(p)(1)(C)(i)); (3) any payment
referred to in the second sentence of
section 451(d) that is treated as
insurance proceeds, relating to certain
disaster payments received under the
Agricultural Act of 1949, as amended, or
Title II of the Disaster Assistance Act of
1988 (section 3402(p)(1)(C)(ii)); (4) any
amount that is includible in gross
income under section 77(a), relating to
amounts received as loans from the
Commodity Credit Corporation that the
taxpayer has elected to treat as income
(section 3402(p)(1)(C)(iii)); and (5) any
payment of an annuity to an individual.
PO 00000
Frm 00015
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
74085
A special rule applies for payments
subject to backup withholding. Section
3402(t)(2)(B) provides that a payment
that is subject to 28 percent withholding
under section 3406 (backup
withholding) is not excepted from the
requirement of 3 percent withholding
under section 3402(t) unless backup
withholding is actually being deducted
from the payment. Thus, if backup
withholding is required with respect to
a payment made by a government entity
and the government entity performs
backup withholding on the payment,
section 3402(t) does not apply. If the
government entity fails to backup
withholding on such a payment, the
government entity would remain liable
for backup withholding regardless of
whether it imposed withholding under
section 3402(t) with respect to the
payment. Proposed amendments to the
regulations under section 3406 clarify
that if backup withholding is required,
withholding under section 3402(t) is not
required.
Under the proposed regulations,
payments made to nonresident aliens or
foreign individuals that are exempt from
United States taxation pursuant to a
treaty would be exempt from
withholding under section 3402(t)
because such payments are subject to
withholding absent application of the
treaty. Specifically, absent a treaty,
United States source fixed or
determinable, annual or periodical
(FDAP) income paid to a nonresident
alien individual or foreign corporation
is subject to withholding under chapter
3, except for income that is effectively
connected with a U.S. trade or business
(other than compensation for personal
services) pursuant to sections 1441 and
1442. Relevant examples of FDAP
include salaries, compensation and
emoluments.
Imposing a new withholding
requirement on nonresident aliens and
foreign corporations that owe no United
States tax would serve no purpose.
Foreign persons that are exempt from
withholding under sections 1441 and
1442 by reason of an income tax treaty
are not the source of the tax
noncompliance problem that section
3402(t) was enacted to address. Further,
our existing documentation procedures
are intended to ensure that those
claiming treaty benefits are in fact
entitled to treaty benefits. See, for
example, Form W–8BEN, ‘‘Certificate of
Foreign Status of Beneficial Owner for
United States Tax Withholding,’’ and
Form 8233, ‘‘Exemption From
Withholding on Compensation for
Independent (and Certain Dependent)
Personal Services of a Nonresident
Alien Individual.’’ Accordingly, the
E:\FR\FM\05DEP1.SGM
05DEP1
74086
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 235 / Friday, December 5, 2008 / Proposed Rules
proposed regulations under section
3402(t) provide that the ‘‘subject to
withholding under chapter 3’’ exception
in section 3402(t)(2)(A) applies to
payments with respect to which a
foreign person claims a zero rate of tax
under an income tax treaty. Thus, if a
foreign person furnishes documentation
establishing entitlement to an
exemption from withholding under
chapter 3 by reason of an income tax
treaty, government entities would not be
required to withhold under section
3402(t) from payments to such person.
Section 3402(t)(2)(C)—Interest
Section 3402(t)(2)(C) provides that
payments of interest are exempt from
withholding. The proposed regulations
do not provide a definition of interest.
The Treasury Department and IRS
request comments concerning whether a
definition of interest is needed and if so,
what that definition should be.
dwashington3 on PROD1PC60 with PROPOSALS
Section 3402(t)(2)(D)—Payments for
Real Property
Section 3402(t)(2)(D) provides that
payments for real property are not
subject to section 3402(t). Because the
exception is not limited to payments for
fee ownership, the proposed regulations
provide that payments for real property
include payments for leasing real
property and leasehold improvements.
Commenters asked whether real
property included payments made
under contracts for the construction of
buildings or other public works. Neither
the statute itself nor the legislative
history defines ‘‘real property’’ for
purposes of section 3402(t).
The proposed regulations adopt the
position that payments for the
construction of buildings or public
works are not payments for real
property excepted by section
3402(t)(2)(D). Payments for the
construction of a building are payments
for services to build the building and
personal property to be used in the
construction of the building rather than
payments for real property. This
position is consistent with statutes
governing construction contracts of the
Federal government. See, for example,
40 U.S.C. 3131–3134 (the ‘‘Miller Act’’).
Section 3402(t)(2)(E)—Payments to
Government Entities Subject to Section
3402(t), Tax-Exempt Organizations, and
Foreign Governments
Section 3402(t)(2)(E) provides
exceptions from section 3402(t)
withholding for payments to any
government entity subject to the
requirements of section 3402(t)(1),
payments to any tax-exempt entity, and
payments to any foreign government.
VerDate Aug<31>2005
14:59 Dec 04, 2008
Jkt 217001
The determination of whether an entity
is a government entity such that
payments it receives are exempt
parallels the determination whether the
entity is a government entity required to
withhold on payments it makes. Thus,
if a government entity is required to
withhold under section 3402(t)(1),
payments to that government entity are
not subject to withholding under section
3402(t). The proposed regulations also
clarify that, even if no withholding is
required on payments from a
government entity because the
government entity qualifies for the
exception of section 3402(t)(2)(G) for
political subdivisions and
instrumentalities making total payments
of less than $100 million (discussed
later in this preamble), payments to that
government entity are not subject to
withholding.
The proposed regulations define the
term tax-exempt entity for purposes of
section 3402(t)(2)(E) as any organization
exempt from federal income tax under
section 501(a) as an organization
described in section 501(c), 501(d), or
section 401(a).
Section 3402(t)(2)(F)—Payments Made
Pursuant to a Classified or Confidential
Contract
Section 3402(t)(2)(F) provides an
exception from section 3402(t)
withholding for payments made
pursuant to a classified or confidential
contract described in section
6050M(e)(3). Section 6050M(e)(3)
describes a contract between a Federal
executive agency and another person
if—
(A) The fact of the existence of such
contract or the subject matter of such
contract has been designated and clearly
marked or clearly represented, pursuant
to the provisions of Federal law or an
Executive order, as requiring a specific
degree of protection against
unauthorized disclosure for reasons of
national security, or
(B) The head of such Federal
executive agency (or his designee),
pursuant to regulations issued by such
agency, determines, in writing, that
filing the required return under section
6050M (related to information returns
required to be filed by any Federal
executive agency with respect to
persons receiving contracts) would
interfere with the effective conduct of a
confidential law enforcement or foreign
counterintelligence activity.
PO 00000
Frm 00016
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
Section 3402(t)(2)(G)—The Exception
for Political Subdivisions and
Instrumentalities Making Total
Payments Under $100,000,000
Section 3402(t)(2)(G) provides that
payments made by certain smaller
government entities are not subject to
withholding under section 3402(t).
Specifically, a political subdivision of a
State (or any instrumentality thereof)
that makes less than $100,000,000 of
payments for property or services
annually (other than for payroll or of
another type exempt from withholding
under these proposed regulations) is not
required to withhold under section
3402(t) on any of its payments. The
proposed regulations provide a simple
rule for determining before each year
starts whether the exception provided
by section 3402(t)(2)(G) applies to a
given political subdivision or
instrumentality. The determination
would be based on the payments made
during the accounting year of the
political subdivision or instrumentality
ending with or within the second
preceding calendar year. For example,
to determine whether the political
subdivision or instrumentality is subject
to withholding with respect to payments
made in 2011, the proposed regulations
would look to whether payments made
by the political subdivision or
instrumentality for its accounting year
ending with or within the calendar year
2009 equaled or exceeded $100,000,000.
For this purpose, the accounting year is
considered to be the year used by the
political subdivision or instrumentality
to keep its accounting books and
determine budgets. In most cases,
political subdivisions and
instrumentalities would be able to make
a reasonably accurate estimate whether
the exception applies before the end of
the accounting year ending in 2009
based on budgetary projections.
However, in cases where the payments
are expected to be near the $100,000,000
threshold, the time between the end of
the accounting year in 2009, when a
definitive determination could be made,
and December 31, 2010, should give the
political subdivision or instrumentality
sufficient time to prepare for
withholding under section 3402(t) for
payments made in 2011.
In determining whether the political
subdivision or instrumentality has made
$100,000,000 of total payments, the
proposed regulations would require that
all payments for property and services
made during the accounting year be
considered with the exception of those
payments qualifying for any of the
exceptions provided by § 31.3402(t)–4(a)
through (l) of the proposed regulations.
E:\FR\FM\05DEP1.SGM
05DEP1
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 235 / Friday, December 5, 2008 / Proposed Rules
For this purpose, payments that are less
than the $10,000 payment threshold
count toward the $100,000,000 test.
This exception provided by section
3402(t)(2)(G) does not apply to the
United States Government, States, or
instrumentalities of the United States
Government or States.
The Treasury Department and IRS
request comments on the application of
section 3402(t)(2)(G), particularly with
regard to whether the rules for
determining whether the exception
applies would provide adequate time to
modify systems for compliance with
section 3402(t), whether a special rule
should be considered allowing the
averaging of multiple accounting years
for political subdivisions and
instrumentalities that have unusually
high expenditures in a given accounting
year, and whether the determination of
total payments under the proposed
regulations is practicable.
dwashington3 on PROD1PC60 with PROPOSALS
Section 3402(t)(2)(H)—Payments in
Connection with a Public Welfare or
Public Assistance Plan
Section 3402(t)(2)(H) provides an
exception from section 3402(t)
withholding for any payment in
connection with a public assistance or
public welfare program for which
eligibility is determined by a needs or
income test. The proposed regulations
adopt a broad definition of in
connection with to include payments
made to third parties under a public
assistance or public welfare program for
the benefit of the recipient of benefits
under the program. The proposed
regulations also are consistent with the
legislative history in providing that a
program for which eligibility is
determined under a needs or income
test does not include a program under
which eligibility is based on age only
(for example, Medicare). The proposed
regulations provide that, for purposes of
this exception, a program providing
disaster relief to victims of a natural or
other disaster is considered to be a
program for which eligibility is
determined under a needs test.
Section 3402(t)(2)(I)—Payments to a
Government Employee With Respect to
Services as an Employee
Section 3402(t)(2)(I) provides an
exception from section 3402(t)
withholding for payments to any
government employee not otherwise
excludable with respect to the
employee’s services as an employee.
The proposed regulations broadly
interpret this exception to exclude from
section 3402(t) withholding any form of
compensation that is paid to the
employee or on the employee’s behalf.
VerDate Aug<31>2005
14:59 Dec 04, 2008
Jkt 217001
For example, the proposed regulations
exclude employer contributions to
employee benefit and deferred
compensation plans as well as employee
contributions to such plans. This
exception applies to any payments by
an employer for fringe benefits or
deferred compensation to, or for the
benefit of, an employee.
The proposed regulations provide that
the section 3402(t)(2)(I) exclusion from
section 3402(t) withholding also applies
to: (a) Travel reimbursements paid by a
government entity to a government
employee under accountable plans
within the meaning of section 62(c) for
the individual employee’s travel,
lodging, and meal expenses; and (b) the
government employee’s payments to
third parties that provide travel,
lodging, and meals that are reimbursable
under such travel reimbursement plans.
Most payments for individual travel,
lodging, and meal expenses would fall
beneath the $10,000 payment threshold.
Nevertheless, this exception may be
significant in determining whether the
government entity making the payments
qualifies for the exception under section
3402(t)(2)(G) for political subdivisions
of a State (or their instrumentalities)
making payments under $100,000,000,
as payments under section 3402(t)(2)(I)
are excluded when calculating the total
amount of payments.
Section 31.3401(a)–4(a) of the
Employment Tax Regulations provides
that if a reimbursement or other expense
allowance arrangement meets the
requirements of section 62(c) and
§ 1.62–2 and the expenses are
substantiated within a reasonable period
of time, payments made under the
arrangement that do not exceed the
substantiated expenses are treated as
paid under an accountable plan and are
not wages. Thus, these payments would
qualify for the exception under section
3402(t)(2)(I).
By comparison, if the travel
reimbursement or payment by the
employer is not paid under an
accountable plan, the reimbursement
would be treated as paid under a
nonaccountable plan. Payments to the
employee under a nonaccountable plan
are includible in gross income and
wages and subject to income tax
withholding under section 3402(a).
Thus, such payments would be
excepted from withholding under
section 3402(t) by section 3402(t)(2)(A).
Exception for Certain Payments
Received by Nonresident Alien
Individuals and Foreign Corporations
In general, in the case of a
nonresident alien individual or a foreign
corporation (foreign person), sections
PO 00000
Frm 00017
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
74087
872(a) and 882(b) provide that gross
income for United States income tax
purposes consists of (1) gross income
derived from sources within the United
States; and (2) gross income derived
from sources outside the United States
(foreign source income), but only if it is
effectively connected with a trade or
business within the United States. The
source of income is determined under
sections 861 through 865. The source of
income derived from the performance of
services is the place where the services
are performed as provided in sections
861(a)(3) and 862(a)(3), whereas the
source of income from the purchase and
sale of inventory property (other than
unprocessed timber) is the location
where the sale takes place as described
in § 1.861–7(c) of the Income Tax
Regulations (see also sections 861(a)(6)
and 862(a)(6)). Therefore, if a foreign
person provides services or sells
inventory property in a foreign country,
it will have no United States income tax
liability with respect to the income
earned from providing the services or
selling the property—even to a United
States government entity—provided that
the income is not effectively connected
with the conduct of a trade or business
within the United States.
Accordingly, the proposed regulations
exclude such payments made to foreign
persons from 3-percent withholding
under section 3402(t). For
administrative reasons, subjecting these
foreign source payments to withholding
under 3402(t) would be unduly
burdensome to the foreign persons
receiving such payments and the IRS.
The foreign persons, most of whom are
not presently United States income tax
filers, would have to get taxpayer
identification numbers (TINs) and file
refund claims. Likewise, the IRS would
have to issue TINs, process the claims,
and refund all of the funds collected.
Withholding on foreign source
payments to foreign persons has no
potential to reduce tax noncompliance
because the potential income resulting
from the payments is not subject to
United States income taxation.
Procedures to be followed by
government entities and foreign persons
for purposes of claiming this exception
from section 3402(t) withholding will be
issued at a later date.
Exception for Payments to Indian Tribal
Governments
Indian tribal governments are not
subject to United States income tax.
Subjecting payments made by
government entities to Indian tribal
governments to withholding under
section 3402(t) would be unduly
burdensome for the same reasons
E:\FR\FM\05DEP1.SGM
05DEP1
74088
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 235 / Friday, December 5, 2008 / Proposed Rules
dwashington3 on PROD1PC60 with PROPOSALS
discussed above with respect to certain
payments made to foreign persons.
Therefore, the proposed regulations
except these payments from 3-percent
withholding under section 3402(t).
Deposits and Reporting of Amounts
Withheld Under Section 3402(t)
In determining rules for reporting
amounts withheld under section
3402(t), the Treasury Department and
IRS have considered the administrative
burden on government entities imposed
by reporting, the need for payees to
receive timely and accurate information
about the amounts withheld, and the
need for IRS systems to process the
information reported. Many comments
reflected a preference for using an
existing system and adapting current
forms and procedures to accommodate
section 3402(t) withholding, rather than
creating a new system and forms for
such withholding. The commenters
indicated that using an existing system
would ease compliance by government
entities and would ease the processing
of the payment and reporting of such
tax.
The Treasury Department and IRS
believe the existing procedure for
reporting nonwage withholding on
Form 945, ‘‘Annual Return of Withheld
Federal Income Tax,’’ and reporting
payments subject to withholding on
Form 1099–MISC, ‘‘Miscellaneous
Income,’’ with slight modifications to
existing forms, would provide the most
satisfactory method of payment and
reporting. Because most government
entities have a system for issuing Form
1099–MISC, using this system with
modifications for reporting section
3402(t) withholding should ease
compliance. Additionally, using Form
1099–MISC would give payees the
information they need to timely file
their income tax returns claiming credit
for the withholding. Because this system
would be similar to the system used
currently for reporting and paying
nonwage income tax withholding, the
IRS would be able to process the
withholding timely and on a costeffective basis.
Accordingly, the proposed
amendments to the regulations under
section 6011 provide that payors
required to withhold amounts under
section 3402(t) must file Form 945
reporting the amounts withheld.
Proposed amendments to the
regulations under section 6302 further
provide that the amounts withheld
under section 3402(t) must be deposited
and reported in the same manner as
other nonwage withheld amounts, such
as withholding on gambling winnings
and pensions. Pursuant to existing
VerDate Aug<31>2005
14:59 Dec 04, 2008
Jkt 217001
regulations, such amounts are treated as
if they were employment taxes for
purposes of the deposit rules, but are
subject to special rules for determining
the payor’s deposit schedule, as
provided in § 31.6302–4.
Additionally, proposed amendments
to regulations under section 6051
provide that payors required to
withhold amounts under section 3402(t)
must file information returns and
furnish payee statements on Form 1099–
MISC reporting such payments and tax
withheld. Because this reporting would
be done pursuant to regulations under
section 6051, the exceptions provided in
the regulations under section 6041
relating to Form 1099 would not apply
(for example, the exception for
payments to corporations).
Payments for Jury Duty, Utilities, and
Fuel Surcharges
Commenters asked whether jury duty
pay is subject to withholding under
section 3402(t). Jury duty pay generally
will not meet the $10,000 payment
threshold provided in the proposed
regulations. No special rule for jury duty
pay is provided.
Commenters also requested guidance
about utility payments. Rates for utility
services are generally prescribed
through a State regulatory process.
Commenters expressed concern about
the consequences of paying something
less than the regulatorily prescribed rate
to the utility. In fact, utility
companies—like all persons receiving
payments subject to withholding under
section 3402(t)—would be paid the full
amount charged, albeit in the form of a
combination of a cash payment and a
deposit of tax made to the IRS.
Therefore, unless otherwise excepted,
utility payments are subject to
withholding under section 3402(t) on
the same basis as payments for other
property and services.
Commenters also requested that fuel
surcharges be exempted from
withholding, arguing that a fuel
surcharge provided under a contract is
merely a cost recovery mechanism used
to garner the lowest possible rates for
the government by controlling volatile
cost components in bid calculations.
Although the use of separately stated
charges for certain costs may well serve
this purpose in contracting, section
3402(t) provides no exception for fuel
surcharges or any other separately stated
cost item. Section 3402(t) requires
withholding on payments made
regardless of how the payee may apply
them against costs. Therefore, the
proposed regulations do not provide an
exception for payments allocated to fuel
PO 00000
Frm 00018
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
surcharges or any other separately stated
costs.
Application of Section 3402(t) to
Passthrough Entities
Commenters requested guidance with
respect to the application of section
3402(t) where either the payor or the
payee is a partnership or S corporation
(‘‘passthrough entities’’). With respect to
payments from a passthrough entity, the
proposed regulations provide that such
payments are not generally subject to
withholding under section 3402(t)
unless 80 percent or more of the
passthrough entity is owned by
government entities that are required to
withhold under section 3402(t)(1). With
respect to payments to a passthrough
entity, the proposed regulations provide
that such payments are generally subject
to withholding under section 3402(t)
unless 80 percent or more of the
passthrough entity is owned by persons
described in section 3402(t)(2)(E)
(government entities required to
withhold under section 3402(t)(1), taxexempt entities, and foreign
governments). An 80-percent threshold
is consistent with similar thresholds in
various areas of the tax law. See, for
example, section 775(b)(3) and
§§ 1.414(c)–2(b)(2) and 301.7701(i)–
1(d)(3)(i)(A). The proposed regulations
also provide that, as a general rule,
whether a passthrough entity is subject
to section 3402(t) is determined on the
first day of the entity’s taxable year. The
Treasury Department and IRS believe
that this general rule simplifies
compliance and administration by
requiring one annual determination of
whether a passthrough entity’s
payments are subject to withholding
under section 3402(t). However, the
proposed regulations provide that any
manipulation of the ownership
percentage with an intent to avoid
application of section 3402(t) would be
recharacterized as appropriate to reflect
the actual ownership percentage.
Effective Date and Transition Relief for
Existing Contracts
The proposed regulations provide that
the regulations will generally be
effective for payments made after the
later of December 31, 2010, or the date
that is 6 months after the publication of
final regulations. Commenters
questioned whether section 3402(t)
would apply to payments made under
contracts in existence prior to the
effective date of section 3402(t). They
noted that many government entities are
party to multi-year contracts. These
contracts did not contemplate the
withholding of income tax from
payments under the contracts. Future
E:\FR\FM\05DEP1.SGM
05DEP1
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 235 / Friday, December 5, 2008 / Proposed Rules
dwashington3 on PROD1PC60 with PROPOSALS
contracts can address the withholding
requirement and its effect on the
contractor’s cash flow. Accordingly, the
proposed regulations provide that
payments made under written binding
contracts in effect on the later of
December 31, 2010, or the date that is
6 months after the publication of final
regulations are not subject to
withholding under section 3402(t),
unless such contract is materially
modified. Payments pursuant to
contracts entered into after the later of
December 31, 2010, or the date that is
6 months after the publication of final
regulations will be subject to section
3402(t).
Under the proposed regulations, if
there is a material modification to an
existing contract after the later of the
effective date of the legislation or six
months after the issuance of final
regulations under section 3402(t), the
contract would cease to be an existing
contract for purposes of this transition
relief and payments under the contract
would become subject to the
withholding requirements of section
3402(t). The Treasury Department and
IRS are considering whether contracts
that contain the option of renewal
should be considered new contracts as
of the date of renewal. The final
regulations may provide that a contract
that is renewable as of a certain date is
treated as a new contract on the first
date the contract is renewed. The
Treasury Department and IRS request
comments on how option terms in
contracts, including, but not limited to,
options to renew, should affect the
transition relief for payments under
written binding contracts.
Credit Against Income Tax
The Treasury Department and IRS
received numerous comments from
taxpayers expecting to receive payments
subject to section 3402(t) withholding.
Most of these comments asked how
taxpayers would take the credit for the
section 3402(t) withholding. Section 31
provides the general crediting rule for
withholding of income tax. Specifically,
section 31(a)(1) provides that ‘‘[t]he
amount withheld as tax under chapter
24 shall be allowed to the recipient of
the income as a credit against the tax
imposed by this subtitle.’’ Chapter 24
includes section 3402(t), and section
31(a)(1) is in subtitle A, income taxes.
Thus, by its terms, section 31(a)(1)
applies to persons who have had
income tax withheld from a payment
pursuant to section 3402(t) and allows
a credit against income tax only.
Section 31(a)(2) provides the general
rule on the timing of the allowance of
the credit: ‘‘The amount so withheld
VerDate Aug<31>2005
14:59 Dec 04, 2008
Jkt 217001
during any calendar year shall be
allowed as a credit for the taxable year
beginning in such calendar year. If more
than one taxable year begins in a
calendar year, such amount shall be
allowed as a credit for the last taxable
year so beginning.’’ Thus, absent a
special rule, the rule of section 31(a)(2)
generally applies for purposes of
withholdings required under chapter 24,
which includes section 3402(t).
Section 31(c) provides a special rule
solely for backup withholding. Under
section 31(c), any credit allowed by
section 31(a) for backup withholding
under section 3406 must be allowed for
the taxable year of the recipient of the
income in which the income is received.
Congress did not provide a similar
exception for the timing of the credit for
section 3402(t) withholding. Section
31(c) is limited by its terms to section
3406 withholding only. Thus, the
general rule of section 31(a)(2) applies
to section 3402(t) withholding rather
than the special rule of section 31(c).
The effect of section 31(a)(2) is that
fiscal year taxpayers may be entitled to
take credit for withholding under
section 3402(t) only in a taxable year
subsequent to the taxable year in which
the amount was withheld. For example,
if amounts were withheld under section
3402(t) from a June 30 fiscal year
taxpayer during the period from January
1, 2011, to June 30, 2011, the taxpayer
will be entitled to take credit for the
withheld tax on its income tax return for
the fiscal year ending June 30, 2012,
rather than its income tax return for the
fiscal year ending June 30, 2011.
The Treasury Department and IRS
recognize that, in the case of fiscal year
taxpayers, the application of the rule in
section 31(a)(2) requiring that the credit
be taken in the second of two possible
taxable years may be burdensome for
taxpayers. The Treasury Department
and IRS request comments on what
impact the timing rule in section
31(a)(2) described above for income tax
credits will have on taxpayers that have
tax withheld under section 3402(t).
Crediting Against Estimated Income Tax
Liability
Taxpayers may take into account the
income tax withheld under section
3402(t) and allowed as a credit under
section 31 in determining estimated tax
liability pursuant to sections 6654 and
6655. With respect to individual
taxpayers, section 6654(g)(1) provides
that, for purposes of determining the
application of the penalty for an
individual’s failure to pay estimated tax,
the amount of the credit allowed under
section 31 for the taxable year shall be
deemed a payment of estimated tax. As
PO 00000
Frm 00019
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
74089
with other income tax withheld, an
individual recipient may account for
income tax withheld in computing
estimated income tax liability on Form
1040–ES, ‘‘Estimated Tax for
Individuals.’’ Because most individuals
are calendar year taxpayers, the section
3402(t) withholding would generally be
treated as a payment of estimated tax for
the same calendar year, and the
individual’s liability for other payments
of estimated tax for that year would be
reduced. However, if the individual is a
fiscal year taxpayer, the individual may
not take into account the withholding
for estimated tax purposes until the
fiscal year that begins in the calendar
year in which the tax is withheld.
Similar rules apply to corporate
taxpayers. In determining the amount of
estimated tax required to be paid to
avoid the section 6655 penalty
applicable to corporations for failure to
pay estimated tax, section 6655(g)(1)(B)
provides in effect that credits against tax
under section 31 are taken into account.
Thus, corporate taxpayers can also take
into account the amount of credit
allowed under section 31(a) in
determining income tax liability and in
computing estimated income tax
liability. As with individual taxpayers,
corporate taxpayers on a fiscal year
could have the problem of delay in
taking account of the credit if
withholding occurs in the part of the
calendar year before the beginning of
the fiscal year that begins in that
calendar year.
Credit Against Employment Taxes or
Other Taxes
Many commenters requested that
taxpayers be allowed to take credit for
section 3402(t) withholding with respect
to employment taxes or other taxes. The
statute directs that crediting follow the
rules under section 31(a), which provide
for crediting against income tax. Where
the statute permits income tax payments
to be treated as employment tax
payments, or vice versa, it makes
specific provision for that treatment.
See, for example, section 3507(d)
(providing for the treatment of advance
payments of the earned income credit as
payments of the income tax withholding
and FICA liability of the employer);
section 3510(b) (providing that domestic
employment taxes are treated as taxes
due for estimated tax purposes under
section 6654); and section 31(b)
(providing for the crediting against
income tax of the special refund of
social security tax under section 6413(c)
applicable when an employee receives
wages from two or more employers in
excess of the social security tax
contribution and benefit base). The
E:\FR\FM\05DEP1.SGM
05DEP1
74090
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 235 / Friday, December 5, 2008 / Proposed Rules
Code does not provide for withholding
under section 3402(t) to be treated as
payments of the taxpayer’s employment
tax liability.
dwashington3 on PROD1PC60 with PROPOSALS
Rate of Income Tax Withholding
Some taxpayers requested that the
Treasury Department and IRS provide
for lower withholding rates for
taxpayers with lower profit margins or
lower marginal income tax rates. The
statute provides for a uniform 3-percent
rate of withholding. Thus, the proposed
regulations apply withholding at the 3percent rate to all payments for services
and property from which withholding
under section 3402(t) is required to be
made.
Liability for Section 3402(t) Withholding
in the Event of Failure To Withhold
If a government entity fails to
withhold the tax imposed by section
3402(t), section 3403 applies. Under
section 3402(t)(3) and section 3403, the
government entity is generally liable for
the payment of the tax to the IRS unless
it can prove that the payee has paid its
income tax liability.
Section 3403 provides that the
employer shall be liable for the payment
of tax required to be deducted and
withheld under chapter 24, and shall
not be liable to any person for the
amount of any such payment.
Section 31.3403–1 of the Employment
Tax Regulations provides that every
employer required to deduct and
withhold the tax under section 3402
from the wages of an employee is liable
for the payment of such tax whether or
not it is collected from the employee by
the employer. If, for example, the
employer deducts less than the correct
amount of tax, or if the employer fails
to deduct any part of the tax, the
employer is nevertheless liable for the
correct amount of the tax. Section
3402(t)(3) provides that for purposes of
section 3403, payments to any person
for property or services that are subject
to withholding under section 3402(t) are
treated as if such payments were wages
paid by an employer to an employee.
Thus, sections 3402(t)(3) and 3403
establish the liability of the government
entity for the amount of the tax imposed
by section 3402(t) if it fails to withhold.
However, section 3402(d) provides an
exception to the entity’s liability for
income tax withholding in certain cases.
Under this exception, if the entity
required to withhold fails to do so, and
thereafter the tax is paid, the tax will
not be collected from the entity that
failed to withhold. Thus, for purposes of
section 3402(t), the government entity
generally will be liable if it fails to
withhold unless it is able to
VerDate Aug<31>2005
14:59 Dec 04, 2008
Jkt 217001
demonstrate, consistent with IRS
procedures, that the taxpayer reported
the amounts that were subject to
withholding on its income tax return
and paid the income tax due.
Transition Rule for Penalties and
Interest on Underpayments
The proposed regulations provide a
special transition rule for a government
entity’s liability for interest and
penalties with respect to the failure to
pay the tax on payments for property
and services made before January 1,
2012. Under the transition rule, a
government entity would not be liable
for penalties and interest with respect to
liability for withholding imposed by
section 3402(t), on payments for
property or services made before
January 1, 2012, if the entity made a
good faith effort to comply with the
requirements of section 3402(t).
However, this transition rule would not
provide relief from liability for the
amount of tax required to be withheld
under section 3402(t).
Proposed Effective Date
These regulations are proposed to
apply to payments made after the later
of December 31, 2010, or six months
after the date of publication of final
regulations. In addition, the regulations
will not apply to payments under
contracts existing on the later of
December 31, 2010, or six months after
the date of publication of final
regulations.
Special Analyses
It has been determined that this notice
of proposed rulemaking is not a
significant regulatory action as defined
in Executive Order 12866. Therefore, a
regulatory assessment is not required. It
also has been determined that section
553(b) of the Administrative Procedure
Act (5 U.S.C. chapter 5) does not apply
to this regulation, and because the
regulation does not impose a collection
of information on small entities, the
Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C.
chapter 6) does not apply. Pursuant to
section 7805(f) of the Internal Revenue
Code, this regulation has been
submitted to the Chief Counsel for
Advocacy of the Small Business
Administration for comment on its
impact on small business.
Comments and Requests for Public
Hearing
Before these proposed regulations are
adopted as final regulations,
consideration will be given to any
written (a signed original and eight (8)
copies) or electronic comments that are
timely submitted to the IRS. All
PO 00000
Frm 00020
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
comments will be available for public
inspection and copying. A public
hearing will be scheduled if requested
in writing by any person that timely
submits written or electronic comments.
If a public hearing is scheduled, notice
of the date, time, and place for the
hearing will be published in the Federal
Register.
Drafting Information
The principal author of these
proposed regulations is A.G. Kelley,
Office of the Division Counsel/Associate
Chief Counsel (Tax Exempt and
Government Entities). However, other
personnel from the IRS and the Treasury
Department participated in their
development.
List of Subjects in 26 CFR Part 31
Employment taxes, Income taxes,
Penalties, Pensions, Railroad retirement,
Reporting and recordkeeping
requirements, Social Security,
Unemployment compensation.
Proposed Amendments to the
Regulations
Accordingly, 26 CFR part 31 is
proposed to be amended as follows:
PART 31—EMPLOYMENT TAXES AND
COLLECTION OF INCOME TAX AT
SOURCE
Paragraph 1. The authority citation
for part 31 continues to read in part as
follows:
Authority: 26 U.S.C. 7805 * * *
Par. 2. The following §§ 31.3402(t)–0,
31.3402(t)–1, 31.3402(t)–2, 31.3402(t)–3,
31.3402(t)–4, and 31.3402(t)–5 are
added, § 31.3402(t)–6 is added and
reserved, and § 31.3402(t)–7 is added to
read as follows:
§ 31.3402(t)–0 Outline of the Government
withholding regulations.
This section lists paragraphs
contained in §§ 31.3402(t)–1 through
31.3402(t)–5, and § 31.3402(t)–7.
§ 31.3402(t)–1 Withholding requirements
on certain payments made by government
entities.
(a) In general.
(b) Special rules.
(c) Deposit and reporting
requirements.
(d) Effective/applicability date.
§ 31.3402(t)–2 Government entities
required to withhold under section 3402(t).
(a) In general.
(b) Government of the United States.
(c) State.
(d) Political Subdivision.
(e) [Reserved].
(f) Possessions of the United States.
E:\FR\FM\05DEP1.SGM
05DEP1
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 235 / Friday, December 5, 2008 / Proposed Rules
(c) Good faith exception for interest
and penalties on payments before
January 1, 2012.
(g) Passthrough entities.
(h) Small entity exception.
(i) Effective/applicability date.
§ 31.3402(t)–3
withholding.
Payments subject to
§ 31.3402(t)–1 Withholding requirement on
certain payments made by government
entities.
(a) In general.
(b) Payment threshold of $10,000.
(c) No withholding on successive
payments.
(d) Payments made through a
payment administrator or to a
contractor.
(e) Payments by credit card or
payment card.
(f) Examples.
(g) Effective/applicability date.
§ 31.3402(t)–4 Certain payments excepted
from withholding.
(a) Payments subject to withholding
under chapter 3 or chapter 24 (other
than section 3406).
(b) Payments subject to withholding
under section 3406 with backup
withholding deducted.
(c) [Reserved].
(d) Payments for real property.
(e) Payments to government entities,
tax-exempt organizations, and foreign
governments.
(f) Payments made pursuant to a
classified or confidential contract.
(g) Exception for political
subdivisions or instrumentalities thereof
making less than $100,000,000 of
payments for property or services
annually.
(h) Payments made in connection
with a public assistance or public
welfare program.
(i) Payments made to any government
employee with respect to his or her
services.
(j) Payments received by nonresident
alien individuals and foreign
corporations.
(k) Payments to Indian tribal
governments.
(l) Payments in emergency or disaster
situations.
(m) Effective/applicability date.
§ 31.3402(t)–5
entities.
Application to passthrough
dwashington3 on PROD1PC60 with PROPOSALS
(a) In general.
(b) Definitions.
(c) Payments from a passthrough
entity.
(d) Payments to a passthrough entity.
(e) Effective/applicability date.
§ 31.3402(t)–6 Crediting of tax withheld
under section 3402(t) [Reserved].
§ 31.3402(t)–7
rules.
Effective date and transition
(a) General rule.
(b) Exception for payments made
under existing written binding
contracts.
VerDate Aug<31>2005
14:59 Dec 04, 2008
Jkt 217001
(a) In general. Except as provided in
§§ 31.3402(t)–3(b) and 31.3402(t)–4, the
Government of the United States, every
State, every political subdivision
thereof, and every instrumentality of the
foregoing (including multi-State
agencies) making any payment to any
person providing any property or
services shall deduct and withhold from
such payment a tax in an amount equal
to 3 percent of such payment.
(b) Special rules. See § 31.3402(t)–2
for government entities required to
withhold under this section,
§ 31.3402(t)–3 for what constitutes a
payment to a person for property or
services and when such payment is
deemed to occur for purposes of this
section, and § 31.3402(t)–4 for payments
that are excepted from withholding
under this section.
(c) Deposit and reporting
requirements. See § 31.6302–4 for
deposit requirements with respect to
withholding under section 3402(t). See
§§ 31.6011(a)–4(b) and 31.6051–5 for the
reporting requirements with respect to
withholding under section 3402(t).
(d) Effective/applicability date. (1)
Except as provided in paragraph (d)(2)
of this section, this section is effective
for payments by the Government of the
United States, every State, every
political subdivision thereof, and every
instrumentality of the foregoing
(including multi-State agencies) to any
person providing property or services
made after the later of December 31,
2010, or the date that is 6 months after
the date of publication in the Federal
Register of final regulations under
section 3402(t).
(2) Payments made under a written
binding contract that was in effect on
the later of December 31, 2010, or the
date that is 6 months after the
publication in the Federal Register of
final regulations under section 3402(t),
are not subject to the withholding
requirements of this section. The
preceding sentence does not apply to
payments made under any contract that
is materially modified after the later of
December 31, 2010, or the date that is
6 months after the date of publication in
the Federal Register of final regulations
under section 3402(t).
§ 31.3402(t)–2 Government entities
required to withhold under section 3402(t).
(a) In general. The requirement to
withhold under section 3402(t) and
PO 00000
Frm 00021
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
74091
§ 31.3402(t)–1(a) applies to the
Government of the United States (see
paragraph (b) of this section) and every
State (see paragraph (c) of this section),
as well as instrumentalities of the
foregoing. The requirement also applies
to political subdivisions of every State
(see paragraph (d) of this section), and
their instrumentalities, unless the small
entity exception of § 31.3402(t)–4(g)
applies.
(b) Government of the United States.
The Government of the United States
includes the legislative branch, the
judicial branch, and the executive
branch, and all components of the
United States Government. Thus,
departments and agencies are included
within the definition of United States
Government.
(c) State. The term State includes the
District of Columbia. However, an
Indian tribal government is not
considered a State for purposes of
section 3402(t) and § 31.3402(t)–1(a).
See section 7871(a).
(d) Political subdivision. The term
political subdivision for purposes of
section 3402(t) and § 31.3402(t)–1(a) is
defined as a political subdivision within
the meaning of § 1.103–1(b) of this
chapter, except that a subdivision of an
Indian tribal government is not
considered a political subdivision. See
section 7871(a) and (d).
(e) [Reserved].
(f) Possessions of the United States.
For purposes of section 3402(t) and
§ 31.3402(t)–1(a), the government of a
possession or territory of the United
States is not treated as a government
entity subject to the withholding
requirements of section 3402(t)(1).
(g) Passthrough entities. See
§ 31.3402(t)–5(c) for the treatment of
payments from certain passthrough
entities as subject to the withholding
requirements of § 31.3402(t)–1.
(h) Small entity exception. See
§ 31.3402(t)–4(g) for the exception from
the withholding requirements of
§ 31.3402(t)–1 for political subdivisions
and instrumentalities thereof making
less than $100,000,000 of payments for
property or services annually.
(i) Effective/applicability date. This
section is effective the later of January
1, 2011, or the date that is 6 months
after the date of publication in the
Federal Register of final regulations
under section 3402(t).
§ 31.3402(t)–3
withholding.
Payments subject to
(a) In general. A payment is subject to
withholding for purposes of
§§ 31.3402(t)–1 through 31.3402(t)–7
when paid by a government entity to
any person, as defined in § 301.7701–
E:\FR\FM\05DEP1.SGM
05DEP1
dwashington3 on PROD1PC60 with PROPOSALS
74092
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 235 / Friday, December 5, 2008 / Proposed Rules
6(a) of this chapter, for property or
services. If, however, the government
entity uses a payment administrator to
pay a person for property or services,
payment occurs when the payment
administrator pays such person. The
government entity subject to the
withholding requirements of
§ 31.3402(t)–1 is liable for the
withholding required and responsible
for all related reporting regardless of
whether the government entity or its
payment administrator makes the
payment for property or services.
(b) Payment threshold of $10,000—(1)
In general. The term payment threshold
means an amount equal to $10,000. The
withholding requirements of
§ 31.3402(t)–1 will not apply to any
payment that is less than the payment
threshold. Whether a payment is equal
to or in excess of the payment threshold
is determined when the payment is
made.
(2) Payment threshold applied per
payment. If a government entity makes
a single payment to a person for
property or services combining charges
for more than one transaction with the
person, the determination of whether
the payment threshold provided by
paragraph (b)(1) of this section applies
will be based on the amount of the
single payment, rather than the amount
attributable to each separate transaction.
Thus, if a government entity makes a
single payment of $10,000 or more to a
person, the government entity will be
required to withhold on the payment,
even if the payment is for more than one
property or service. The same rule
applies if a government entity enters
into multiple transactions with a single
person, each of which would result in
a payment of less than $10,000 if paid
separately, but elects to make a single
payment covering all the transactions
such that the aggregated payment is
$10,000 or more. Under these
circumstances, the government entity is
required to withhold on the aggregated
payment.
(3) Anti-abuse rule. If a government
entity or payment administrator divides
a payment or payments to any person
for property or services into two or more
payments primarily to avoid the $10,000
payment threshold provided in
paragraph (b)(1) of this section on one
or more of these payments, the divided
payments will be treated as a single
payment made on the date that the first
of these payments is made.
(c) No withholding on successive
payments. If a government entity or its
payment administrator makes a
payment that is subject to the
withholding requirements of
§ 31.3402(t)–1 to a person, no
VerDate Aug<31>2005
14:59 Dec 04, 2008
Jkt 217001
subsequent transfer of cash or property
from that payment by such person to
another person is treated as a payment
subject to withholding for purposes of
§§ 31.3402(t)–1 through 31.3402(t)–7.
(d) Payments made through a
payment administrator or to a
contractor—(1) Definition—For
purposes of this section—
(i) A payment administrator is any
person that acts with respect to a
payment solely as an agent for a
government entity by making the
payment on behalf of the government
entity to a person providing property or
services to, or on behalf of, the
government entity.
(ii) A payment administrator is treated
as a person providing property or
services for purposes of the withholding
requirements of section 3402(t) to the
extent it receives a fee from the
government entity for its services as a
payment administrator for the
government entity.
(2) Payments to a contractor. If a
person provides property or services to
a government entity under a contract
and is not a payment administrator, the
person, who is in privity with the
government entity, is treated as the
person providing property or services
subject to withholding under section
3402(t) for all payments received from
the government entity, regardless of
whether some payments the person
receives relate to invoices for property
or services provided by subcontractors.
(3) Application of payment threshold.
Where a government entity uses a
payment administrator to make a
payment, the determination of whether
the payment meets the payment
threshold is made at the time the
payment administrator makes the
payment to the person providing
property or services. If a government
entity makes one transfer of funds to a
payment administrator that is composed
of a fee to compensate the payment
administrator for its services and other
funds that are to be paid to persons
providing property or services, the
determination of whether the payment
threshold is met on the portion that is
the fee is made at the time of the transfer
of funds to the payment administrator.
(e) Payments by credit card or
payment card. For purposes of section
3402(t), a payment made by a
government entity by credit card or
payment card to a person for property
or services occurs when the credit card
or payment card is tendered at the point
of sale. The government entity is liable
for withholding under section 3402(t)
and reporting associated with such
withholding. See section 6050W of the
Internal Revenue Code for separate
PO 00000
Frm 00022
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
reporting obligations imposed on the
acquiring bank of the person receiving
payment by credit card or payment card.
(f) Examples. This section is
illustrated by the following examples:
Example 1. (i) Prime contractor X has a
contract with a government entity to provide
services and property to the government
entity. X contracts with numerous
subcontractors to provide services and
property in connection with the contract.
While the engagement of any particular
subcontractor is subject to approval by the
government entity, the subcontractors are not
parties to the contract between X and the
government entity, and the government
entity is not a party to the contracts between
X and subcontractors. Under its contract with
the government entity, X submits an invoice
for $48,000 for providing services and
property to the government entity, including
charges for services and property provided by
two subcontractors, M and N. The invoice
reflects charges of $16,000 for M and $2,000
for N. The government entity pays X the
entire amount of the invoice in one payment
of $48,000. X pays M for M’s billed portion
of the invoice in a single payment of $16,000,
and X pays N for N’s billed portion of the
invoice in a single payment of $2,000.
(ii) Under the facts of this Example 1, X is
the person providing property or services to,
or for the benefit of, the government entity
with respect to the entire amount of the
$48,000 payment under the invoice,
including the charges for services or property
provided by its subcontractors M and N. X is
not a payment administrator (as defined in
paragraph (d)(1)(i) of this section) because X
is not making payments solely as an agent of
the government entity to persons providing
property or services. Instead, X makes
payments to subcontractors M and N
pursuant to X’s separate contracts with these
subcontractors to which the government
entity is not a party. Therefore, under
paragraphs (a) and (d)(2) of this section, the
entire amount of the $48,000 payment to X
under the invoice, including the charges for
services and property provided by its
subcontractors M and N, is the payment
subject to withholding for purposes of
section 3402(t).
(iii) Under paragraph (b)(1) of this section,
the determination whether the payment
meets the payment threshold is based on the
entire amount of the payment from the
government entity to X. Withholding under
section 3402(t) applies to the government
entity’s $48,000 payment to X because the
payment meets the payment threshold and is
not otherwise excepted from section 3402(t)
withholding. Thus, the payment is subject to
withholding of 3 percent, or $1,440.
(iv) Payments made by X to the
subcontractors, M and N, are not payments
by the government entity or its payment
administrator. Thus, X’s $16,000 payment to
M and X’s $2,000 payment to N for services
or property under the contract are not subject
to withholding under section 3402(t). See
paragraphs (c) and (d)(2) of this section.
(v) The government entity is liable for the
$1,440 withholding required under section
3402(t) on its payment to X and is
E:\FR\FM\05DEP1.SGM
05DEP1
dwashington3 on PROD1PC60 with PROPOSALS
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 235 / Friday, December 5, 2008 / Proposed Rules
responsible for the related reporting required
under § 31.6051–5. See paragraph (a) of this
section. X is the person receiving the
payment for purposes of reporting under
§ 31.6051–5. Thus, the government entity is
responsible for providing X with a Form 1099
including the entire amount of the payment
($48,000) and the entire amount of the
withholding ($1,440).
Example 2. (i) Z has a contract with a
government entity to make payments as an
agent of the government entity to persons
providing services or property to, or on
behalf of, the government entity. The only
services Z provides under the contract are its
services in acting as an agent for the
government entity in making payments to
persons providing property or services to, or
on behalf of, the government. The
government entity transfers funds of $71,000
to Z, which includes a fee of $1,000 to Z for
its services as an agent under the contract. Z
then makes payments of the $70,000
remainder of the funds to persons providing
property or services to, or on behalf of, the
government entity, including a single
payment of $18,000 to P and a single
payment of $7,000 to R.
(ii) Under the facts of this Example 2, Z is
a payment administrator (as defined in
paragraph (d)(1)(i) of this section) because Z
makes payments solely as an agent for the
government entity to persons providing
property or services to, or on behalf of, the
government entity. Under paragraphs (a) and
(d) of this section, Z is not treated as a person
providing property or services with respect to
$70,000 of the transfer of funds (the amount
of the funds to be paid to persons providing
property or services to, or on behalf of, the
government entity). Because Z is not treated
as a person providing property or services
with respect to this $70,000 portion of the
funds, this portion of the transfer of funds by
the government entity to Z is not subject to
withholding under section 3402(t) when
transferred to Z.
(iii) Under paragraph (d)(1)(ii) of this
section, the payment administrator is treated
as a person providing property or services
with respect to the portion of the $71,000
fund transfer that is a fee for its services as
a payment administrator, or $1,000. Under
paragraph (d)(3) of this section, the
determination of whether the payment
threshold is met with respect to the fee
portion of the payment from the government
entity to Z is made at the time of the payment
from the government entity to Z. Because the
$1,000 fee portion of the payment falls
beneath the $10,000 payment threshold,
withholding under section 3402(t) is not
required with respect to that portion of the
payment.
(iv) P and R are persons providing services
or property to, or on behalf of, the
government entity with respect to the
payments they receive from Z.
(v) Withholding is required under section
3402(t) on the payment by Z, a payment
administrator, to a person providing property
or services to, or on behalf of, a government
entity provided the payment meets the
payment threshold and is not otherwise
excepted. Under paragraph (d)(3) of this
section, the determination of whether the
VerDate Aug<31>2005
14:59 Dec 04, 2008
Jkt 217001
payment threshold is met on the payment Z
makes to a person providing property or
services is made at the time Z pays the
person providing property or services. Under
the facts of this Example 2, Z’s payment to
P of $18,000 meets the payment threshold,
and therefore withholding of $540 under
section 3402(t) applies. Z’s payment to R of
$7,000 does not meet the payment threshold,
and therefore, no withholding under section
3402(t) is required.
(vi) The government entity, not Z, is liable
for any withholding required under section
3402(t) on the payments from Z to persons
providing property or services. Also, the
government entity, not Z, is responsible for
any reporting required under § 31.6051–5 on
the payment from Z to persons providing
property or services. See paragraph (a) of this
section. Each person providing property or
services with respect to which withholding is
required, not Z, is the person receiving the
payment for purposes of the reporting
required under § 31.6051–5 if withholding
under section 3402(t) applies. Thus, the
government entity is responsible for issuing
P a Form 1099 reflecting the amount of the
payment from Z to P of $18,000 and the
amount of withholding of $540.
(g) Effective/applicability date. This
section is effective for payments by the
Government of the United States, every
State, every political subdivision
thereof, and every instrumentality of the
foregoing (including multi-State
agencies) to any person providing
property or services made after the later
of December 31, 2010, or the date that
is 6 months after the date of publication
in the Federal Register of final
regulations under section 3402(t).
§ 31.3402(t)–4 Certain payments excepted
from withholding.
(a) Payments subject to withholding
under chapter 3 or chapter 24 (other
than section 3406)—(1) In general.
Payments are excepted from
withholding under section § 31.3402(t)–
1(a) if they are subject to withholding
under chapter 3 of the Internal Revenue
Code (Code) or under sections 3401
through 3405 of the Code (other than
section 3402(t)).
(2) Payments subject to withholding
under chapter 3. Payments subject to
withholding under chapter 3 include
those payments that are subject to, but
exempt from, withholding under
chapter 3 on the ground that the
payments are exempt from United States
income tax pursuant to an income tax
convention to which the United States
is a party.
(3) Payments subject to withholding at
election of payee. For purposes of this
exception from section 3402(t),
payments for which the payee may elect
withholding are exempt from
withholding under § 31.3402(t)–1(a)
regardless of whether the payee in fact
PO 00000
Frm 00023
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
74093
makes such an election. These payments
include—
(i) Unemployment compensation as
defined in section 85(b) (see section
3402(p)(2));
(ii) Social security benefits as defined
in section 86(d) (see section
3402(p)(1)(C)(i));
(iii) Any payment referred to in the
second sentence of section 451(d) that is
treated as insurance proceeds, relating
to certain disaster payments received
under the Agricultural Act of 1949, as
amended, or Title II of the Disaster
Assistance Act of 1988 (see section
3402(p)(1)(C)(ii));
(iv) Any amount that is includible in
gross income under section 77(a),
relating to amounts received as loans
from the Commodity Credit Corporation
that the taxpayer has elected to treat as
income (see section 3402(p)(1)(C)(iii));
and
(v) Any payment of an annuity to an
individual.
(b) Payments subject to withholding
under section 3406 with backup
withholding deducted. A payment is not
subject to withholding under section
3402(t) if the payment is subject to
withholding under section 3406,
relating to backup withholding, and if
backup withholding is actually being
withheld from such payment.
(c) [Reserved].
(d) Payments for real property.
Payments for real property are not
subject to the withholding requirements
of § 31.3402(t)–1. For purposes of this
exception, the term payments for real
property includes the purchase and the
leasing of real property. However,
payments for the construction of
buildings or other public works projects,
such as bridges or roads, are not
payments for real property.
(e) Payments to government entities,
tax-exempt organizations, and foreign
governments—(1) Government entities.
Payments are not subject to withholding
under section 3402(t) if the payments
are made to government entities that are
subject to the withholding requirements
of section 3402(t)(1) pursuant to
§ 31.3402(t)–2. For purposes of this
exception, payments to government
entities that qualify for the exception for
political subdivisions and
instrumentalities making less than
$100,000,000 of payments for property
and services annually, as provided by
section 3402(t)(2)(G) and paragraph (g)
of this section, are treated as payments
to government entities that are subject to
the withholding requirements of section
3402(t)(1).
(2) Tax-exempt organizations.
Payments to an organization that is
exempt from taxation under section
E:\FR\FM\05DEP1.SGM
05DEP1
dwashington3 on PROD1PC60 with PROPOSALS
74094
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 235 / Friday, December 5, 2008 / Proposed Rules
501(a) as an organization described in
section 501(c), 501(d), or 401(a) are not
subject to withholding under section
3402(t).
(3) Foreign governments. Payments to
foreign governments are not subject to
withholding under section 3402(t). For
purposes of this paragraph (e), a
government of a possession or territory
of the United States is treated as a
foreign government.
(f) Payments made pursuant to a
classified or confidential contract.
Payments made pursuant to a classified
or confidential contract described in
section 6050M(e)(3) are not subject to
withholding under section 3402(t).
(g) Exception for political
subdivisions or instrumentalities thereof
making less than $100,000,000 of
payments for property or services
annually—(1) In general. Section 3402(t)
withholding is not required on
payments made by a political
subdivision of a State (or any
instrumentality of a political
subdivision of a State) that makes less
than $100,000,000 of payments for
property or services annually.
(2) Determination of whether an entity
is a political subdivision of a State. The
determination of whether an entity is a
political subdivision of a State is made
under § 31.3402(t)–2(d).
(3) Determination of whether a
political subdivision or instrumentality
makes less than $100,000,000 of
payments for property or services
annually. The determination of whether
the exception provided by paragraph
(g)(1) of this section applies is made for
each calendar year. For purposes of any
calendar year, the determination of
whether a political subdivision or
instrumentality makes less than
$100,000,000 of payments for property
or services annually is based on the total
payments made by the entity for
property or services in the entity’s
accounting year ending with or within
the second preceding calendar year. For
purposes of this paragraph (g), payments
that would have qualified for the
exceptions from withholding under
§ 31.3402(t)–4(a) through (l) had these
regulations been in effect shall not be
included in calculating the total
payments made. However, payments
that would have been excepted from
withholding only because such
payments were less than the $10,000
payment threshold contained in
§ 31.3402(t)–3(b) are included in
calculating the total payments for
purposes of this paragraph (g). Also,
payments that were not subject to
withholding under section 3402(t)
solely based on the effective date rules
or transition rules contained in
VerDate Aug<31>2005
14:59 Dec 04, 2008
Jkt 217001
§ 31.3402(t)–1(d), § 31.3402(t)–2(i),
§ 31.3402(t)–3(g), § 31.3402(t)–4(m),
§ 31.3402(t)–5(e), or § 31.3402(t)–7 are
included in calculating total payments
for purposes of this paragraph (g). For
purposes of this determination, the
accounting year refers to the fiscal year
(consisting of 12 months) or calendar
year used by the government entity in
setting its budgets and keeping its
accounting books. If a political
subdivision or instrumentality was not
in existence in the second preceding
calendar year or if no 12-month
accounting year exists ending in the
second preceding calendar year, the
determination of whether this exception
applies for a calendar year shall be
based on the total payments as projected
for the accounting year consisting of 12
months ending in that calendar year.
(4) Example. (i) Government entity X,
which qualifies as a political subdivision or
instrumentality thereof for the calendar years
2011 and 2012, uses a fiscal year ending June
30 to determine its budgets and to keep its
accounting books. During its fiscal year
ending June 30, 2009, X made payments to
persons for property and services of
$200,000,000, including $102,000,000 of
payments that would have been excepted
under § 31.3402(t)–4(a) through (l) if section
3402(t) had been in effect.
(ii) During its fiscal year ending June 30,
2010, X made payments for property and
services of $210,000,000, including
$106,000,000 that would have been excepted
under § 31.3402(t)–4(a) through (l) if section
3402(t) had been in effect. In addition, during
the fiscal year ending June 30, 2010, X made
$15,000,000 of payments that were below the
payment threshold of $10,000 in
§ 31.3402(t)–3(b) if section 3402(t) had been
in effect.
(iii) For the calendar year 2011, X
determines whether it is eligible for the
exception provided by this paragraph (g)
based on the total payments X made for its
accounting year ending June 30, 2009.
Because total payments for this purpose
exclude payments that would be excepted
under § 31.3402(t)–4(a) through (l), total
payments were $200,000,000 less
$102,000,000, or $98,000,000. Therefore, for
calendar year 2011, X would qualify for the
exception provided by this paragraph (g), and
would not be required to withhold under
section 3402(t).
(iv) For the calendar year 2012, X
determines whether it is eligible for the
exception provided by this paragraph (g)
based on the total payments it made for its
accounting year ending June 30, 2010.
Because total payments for this purpose
exclude payments that would have been
excepted under § 31.3402(t)–4(a) through (l),
but include payments below the payment
threshold of $10,000 provided under
§ 31.3402(t)–3(b), total payments were
$210,000,000 less $106,000,000, or
$104,000,000. Therefore, for calendar year
2012, X would not qualify for the exception
provided by this paragraph (g) and would be
required to withhold under section 3402(t).
PO 00000
Frm 00024
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
(h) Payments made in connection
with a public assistance or public
welfare program—(1) In general. Section
3402(t) withholding shall not apply to
payments made in connection with a
public assistance or public welfare
program for which eligibility is
determined by a needs or income test.
(2) Needs or income test. Eligibility
for a public assistance or public welfare
program is not considered to be
determined by a needs or income test if
eligibility for the program is based
solely on the age of the beneficiary. A
public assistance program providing
disaster relief to victims of a natural or
other disaster is considered to be a
program for which eligibility is
determined under a needs test.
Payments under government programs
to provide health care or other services
that are not based on the needs or
income of the recipient are subject to
section 3402(t) withholding, including
programs where eligibility is based on
the age of the beneficiary.
(3) Payments to third parties. The
exception provided by this paragraph
(h) also applies to payments made to
third parties to provide benefits to
beneficiaries under a public assistance
or public welfare program for which
eligibility is determined by a needs or
income test.
(i) Payments made to any government
employee with respect to his or her
services. Section 3402(t) withholding
shall not apply to payments made to any
government employee with respect to
his or her services as an employee of the
government. This exception applies to
contributions to deferred compensation
plans on behalf of an employee,
contributions to employee benefit plans
on behalf of an employee, fringe benefits
provided to employees, and payments to
employees under accountable plans for
the individual travel expenses of the
employee. This exception also applies
to payments made by the government
employee under accountable plans to
providers of the employee’s travel,
meals, and lodging when the
government employee is traveling on
government business.
(j) Payments received by nonresident
alien individuals and foreign
corporations. Section 3402(t)
withholding shall not apply to any
payment received by a nonresident alien
individual or foreign corporation
(foreign person) for providing services
or property if the payment is derived
from sources outside the United States,
as determined under sections 861, 862,
863, and 865, and is not effectively
connected with the conduct of a trade
or business within the United States by
the foreign person.
E:\FR\FM\05DEP1.SGM
05DEP1
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 235 / Friday, December 5, 2008 / Proposed Rules
(k) Payments to Indian tribal
governments. Section 3402(t)
withholding shall not apply to any
payment made to an Indian tribal
government or its political subdivisions.
(l) Payments in emergency or disaster
situations. The Secretary may provide
by publication in the Internal Revenue
Bulletin (see § 601.601(d)(2)(ii)(b) of this
chapter) for additional exceptions from
section 3402(t) withholding for certain
payments made in an emergency or
disaster situation if the Secretary
determines that withholding from the
payments would impede a government
entity’s efforts to respond to the
emergency or disaster.
(m) Effective/applicability date. This
section is effective for payments by the
Government of the United States, every
State, every political subdivision
thereof, and every instrumentality of the
foregoing (including multi-State
agencies) to any person providing
property or services made after the later
of December 31, 2010, or the date that
is 6 months after the date of publication
in the Federal Register of final
regulations under section 3402(t).
dwashington3 on PROD1PC60 with PROPOSALS
§ 31.3402(t)–5
entities.
Application to passthrough
(a) In general. This section sets forth
rules that provide that section 3402(t)(1)
does not apply to payments made by
passthrough entities except as described
in paragraph (c) of this section. In
addition, the rules provide that section
3402(t)(1) applies to payments made to
passthrough entities except as described
in paragraph (d) of this section.
(b) Definitions. The following
definitions set forth the meaning of
certain terms for purposes of this
section:
(1) Passthrough entity. The term
passthrough entity means a partnership
(for Federal income tax purposes) or an
S corporation.
(2) Owner. The term owner means a
partner (for Federal income tax
purposes) or an S corporation
shareholder.
(3) Ownership percentage. The term
ownership percentage means an owner’s
interest, as a percentage, in partnership
profits or capital (whichever is greater)
in the case of a partnership, or an
owner’s interest, as a percentage, in S
corporation stock in the case of an S
corporation.
(4) Testing day. The term testing day
refers to the first day of a passthrough
entity’s taxable year.
(c) Payments from a passthrough
entity—(1) General rule. Section
3402(t)(1) shall not apply to payments
made by passthrough entities during the
VerDate Aug<31>2005
14:59 Dec 04, 2008
Jkt 217001
taxable year, except as provided in
paragraph (c)(2) of this section.
(2) Exception. Section 3402(t)(1) shall
apply to any payment during the taxable
year from a passthrough entity if the
aggregate ownership percentage held,
directly or indirectly, in the entity on
the testing day by government entities
described in section 3402(t)(1) is at least
80 percent. For purposes of this
paragraph (c)(2), any manipulation of
the ownership percentage with an intent
to avoid application of section 3402(t)
will be recharacterized as appropriate to
reflect the actual ownership percentage.
(d) Payments to a passthrough
entity—(1) General rule. Section
3402(t)(1) shall apply to payments made
to passthrough entities during the
taxable year, except as provided in
paragraph (d)(2) of this section.
(2) Exception. Section 3402(t)(1) shall
not apply to any payment during a
taxable year to a passthrough entity if
the aggregate ownership percentage
held, directly or indirectly, in the entity
on the testing day by persons described
in section 3402(t)(2)(E) is at least 80
percent. For purposes of this paragraph
(d)(2), any manipulation of the
ownership percentage with an intent to
avoid application of section 3402(t) will
be recharacterized as appropriate to
reflect the actual ownership percentage.
(e) Effective/applicability date. This
section is effective for payments by the
Government of the United States, every
State, every political subdivision
thereof, and every instrumentality of the
foregoing (including multi-State
agencies) to any person providing
property or services made after the later
of December 31, 2010, or the date that
is 6 months after the date of publication
in the Federal Register of final
regulations under section 3402(t).
§ 31.3402(t)–6 Crediting of tax withheld
under section 3402(t).
[Reserved].
§ 31.3402(t)–7
rules.
Effective date and transition
(a) General Rule. Except as provided
in paragraph (b) of this section, the
requirement to withhold under
§ 31.3402(t)–1(a) applies to payments
made after the later of December 31,
2010, or the date that is 6 months after
the date of publication in the Federal
Register of final regulations under
section 3402(t).
(b) Exception for payments made
under existing written binding contracts.
Payments made under a written binding
contract that was in effect on the later
of December 31, 2010, or the date that
is 6 months after the date of publication
in the Federal Register of final
PO 00000
Frm 00025
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
74095
regulations under section 3402(t), are
not subject to the withholding
requirements in § 31.3402(t)–1. The
preceding sentence does not apply to
payments made under any contract that
is materially modified after the later of
December 31, 2010, or the date that is
6 months after the date of publication in
the Federal Register of final regulations
under section 3402(t).
(c) Good faith exception for interest
and penalties on payments made before
January 1, 2012. Government entities
that make a good faith effort to comply
with the provisions of these regulations
will not be liable for penalties and
interest with respect to income tax
withholding under section 3402(t) that
the government entity failed to withhold
from payments made before January 1,
2012. However, this provision shall not
relieve the government entity of liability
for income tax that it failed to withhold.
See, however, § 31.3402(d)–1.
Par. 3. Section 31.3406(g)–2 is
amended by adding paragraphs (h) and
(i) to read as follows:
§ 31.3406(g)–2 Exception for reportable
payment for which withholding is otherwise
required.
*
*
*
*
*
(h) Certain payments made by
government entities. A government
entity that is required to withhold both
on reportable payments pursuant to
section 3406(a) and on certain payments
pursuant to section 3402(t), must
comply with the withholding
requirements of section 3406, and not
section 3402(t), with respect to a
payment to which both types of
withholding would apply. Pursuant to
section 3402(t)(2)(B), withholding under
section 3402(t) shall not apply if
amounts are being withheld under
section 3406 with respect to a payment.
If a government entity fails to withhold
as required under section 3406, the
payment will not be deemed to be
subject to withholding under another
provision of the Code for purposes of
this paragraph (h). Thus, even if the
government entity withholds on such
payment pursuant to section 3402(t), it
will remain liable for the amount
required to be withheld under section
3406.
(i) Effective/applicability date.
Paragraph (h) relating to certain
payments made by government entities
applies to payments made by
government entities under section
3402(t) made after the later of December
31, 2010, or the date that is 6 months
after the date of publication in the
Federal Register of final regulations
under section 3402(t).
E:\FR\FM\05DEP1.SGM
05DEP1
74096
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 235 / Friday, December 5, 2008 / Proposed Rules
Par. 4. Section 31.6011(a)–4 is
amended by adding paragraphs (b)(6)
and (d) to read as follows:
§ 31.6011(a)–4
withheld.
Returns of income tax
*
*
*
*
*
(b) * * *
(6) Certain payments made by
government entities subject to
withholding under section 3402(t).
*
*
*
*
*
(d) Effective/applicability date.
Paragraph (b)(6) relating to certain
payments made by government entities
subject to withholding under section
3402(t) applies to payments made by
government entities under section
3402(t) made after the later of December
31, 2010, or the date that is 6 months
after the date of publication in the
Federal Register of final regulations
under section 3402(t).
Par. 5. Section 31.6051–5 is added to
read as follows:
dwashington3 on PROD1PC60 with PROPOSALS
§ 31.6051–5 Statement and information
return required in case of withholding by
government entities.
14:59 Dec 04, 2008
Jkt 217001
§ 31.6071(a)–1 Time for filing returns and
other documents.
*
(a) Statements required from
government entities. Every government
entity required to deduct and withhold
tax under section 3402(t) must furnish
to the payee a written statement
containing the information required by
paragraph (d) of this section.
(b) Information returns required from
government entities. Every government
entity required to furnish a payee
statement under paragraph (a) of this
section must file a duplicate of such
statement with the Secretary. Such
duplicate shall constitute an
information return.
(c) Prescribed form. The prescribed
form for the statement required by this
section is Form 1099–MISC,
‘‘Miscellaneous Income.’’
(d) Information required. Each
statement on Form 1099–MISC must
show the following—
(1) The name, address, and taxpayer
identification number of the person
receiving the payment subject to
withholding under section 3402(t);
(2) The amount of the payment
withheld upon;
(3) The amount of tax deducted and
withheld under section 3402(t);
(4) The name, address, and taxpayer
identification number of the government
entity filing the form;
(5) A legend stating that such amount
is being reported to the Internal
Revenue Service; and
(6) Such other information as is
required by the form.
(e) Time for furnishing statements.
The statement must be furnished to the
VerDate Aug<31>2005
payee no later than January 31 of the
year following the calendar year in
which the payment subject to
withholding was made.
(f) Cross references. For provisions
relating to the time for filing the
information returns required by this
section and to extensions of the time for
filing, see §§ 31.6071(a)–1(a)(3) and
1.6081–1(b)(3), respectively. For
penalties applicable to failure to file
information returns and furnish payee
statements, see sections 6721 through
6724.
(g) Effective/applicability date. This
section is effective on the later of
January 1, 2011, or the date that is 6
months after the date of publication in
the Federal Register of final regulations
under section 3402(t).
Par. 6. Section 31.6071(a)–1 is
amended by revising paragraph (a)(3)(i)
to read as follows:
*
*
*
*
(3) Information returns—(i) General
rule. Each information return in respect
of wages as defined in the Federal
Insurance Contributions Act or of
income tax withheld from wages which
is required to be made under § 31.6051–
2 or of income tax withheld from
payments by government entities as
required under § 31.6051–5 shall be
filed on or before the last day of
February (March 31 if filed
electronically) of the year following the
calendar year for which it is made,
except that, if a tax return under
§ 31.6011(a)–5(a) is filed as a final
return for a period ending prior to
December 31, the information statement
shall be filed on or before the last day
of the second calendar month following
the period for which the tax return is
filed.
*
*
*
*
*
Par. 7. Section 31.6302–1 is amended
by adding paragraph (e)(1)(iii)(E) and
revising paragraph (n) to read as
follows:
§ 31.6302–1 Federal tax deposit rules for
withheld income taxes and taxes under the
Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA)
attributable to payments made after
December 31, 1992.
*
*
*
*
*
(e) * * * (1) * * *
(iii) * * *
(E) Certain payments made by
government entities under section
3402(t); and
*
*
*
*
*
(n) Effective/applicability date. Except
for the deposit of employment taxes
attributable to payments made by
PO 00000
Frm 00026
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
government entities under section
3402(t), §§ 31.6302–1 through 31.6302–
3 apply with respect to the deposit of
employment taxes attributable to
payments made after December 31,
1992. Section 31.6302–1(e)(1)(iii)(E)
applies with respect to the deposit of
employment taxes attributable to
payments made by government entities
under section 3402(t) made after the
later of December 31, 2010, or the date
that is 6 months after the date of
publication in the Federal Register of
final regulations under section 3402(t).
Par. 8. Section 31.6302–4 is amended
by revising paragraph (b)(5) and adding
paragraphs (b)(6) and (e) to read as
follows:
§ 31.6302–4 Federal tax deposit rules for
withheld income taxes attributable to
nonpayroll payments made after December
31, 1993.
*
*
*
*
*
(b) * * *
(5) Amounts withheld under section
3406, relating to backup withholding
with respect to reportable payments;
and
(6) Amounts withheld under section
3402(t), relating to certain payments
made by government entities.
*
*
*
*
*
(e) Effective/applicability date.
Paragraph (b)(6) relating to certain
payments made by government entities
applies to payments made by
government entities under section
3402(t) made after the later of December
31, 2010, or the date that is 6 months
after the date of publication in the
Federal Register of final regulations
under section 3402(t).
Linda E. Stiff,
Deputy Commissioner for Services and
Enforcement.
[FR Doc. E8–28789 Filed 12–4–08; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4830–01–P
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
AGENCY
40 CFR Part 52
[EPA–R01–OAR–2008–0194; A–1–FRL–
8718–1]
Approval and Promulgation of Air
Quality Implementation Plans;
Connecticut; Enhanced Vehicle
Inspection and Maintenance Program
AGENCY: Environmental Protection
Agency (EPA).
ACTION: Proposed rule.
SUMMARY: The EPA is proposing to
approve a State Implementation Plan
E:\FR\FM\05DEP1.SGM
05DEP1
Agencies
[Federal Register Volume 73, Number 235 (Friday, December 5, 2008)]
[Proposed Rules]
[Pages 74082-74096]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Printing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: E8-28789]
=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY
Internal Revenue Service
26 CFR Part 31
[REG-158747-06]
RIN 1545-BG45
Withholding Under Internal Revenue Code Section 3402(t)
AGENCY: Internal Revenue Service (IRS), Treasury.
ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: This document contains proposed regulations relating to
[[Page 74083]]
withholding under section 3402(t) of the Internal Revenue Code (Code).
The proposed regulations reflect changes in the law made by the Tax
Increase Prevention and Reconciliation Act of 2005 that require
Federal, State, and local government entities to withhold income tax
when making payments to persons providing property or services. These
proposed regulations provide guidance to assist the government entities
in complying with section 3402(t). The regulations also provide certain
guidance to persons receiving payments for property or services from
government entities. This document also contains proposed amendments to
regulations under sections 3406, 6011, 6051, 6071, and 6302 of the
Code.
DATES: Written or electronic comments and requests for a public hearing
must be received by March 5, 2009.
ADDRESSES: Send submissions to: CC:PA:LPD:PR (REG-158747-06), room
5205, Internal Revenue Service, PO Box 7604, Ben Franklin Station,
Washington, DC 20044. Submissions may be hand-delivered Monday through
Friday between the hours of 8 a.m. and 4 p.m. to CC:PA:LPD:PR (REG-
158747-06), Courier's Desk, Internal Revenue Service, 1111 Constitution
Avenue, NW., Washington, DC, or sent electronically via the Federal
eRulemaking Portal at https://www.regulations.gov/ (IRS REG-158747-06).
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Concerning these proposed regulations,
Jean Casey, (202) 622-6040; concerning submissions of comments or to
request a public hearing, Richard Hurst at
Richard.A.Hurst@irscounsel.treas.gov or (202) 622-7180 (not toll-free
numbers).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Background
This document contains proposed amendments to 26 CFR part 31 under
section 3402(t) of the Code. This document also contains proposed
amendments to 26 CFR part 31 under sections 3406, 6011, 6051, 6071, and
6302 of the Code.
Section 3402(t) of the Code was added by section 511 of the Tax
Increase Prevention and Reconciliation Act of 2005, Public Law 109-222
(TIPRA), 120 Stat. 345, which was enacted into law on May 17, 2006.
Section 3402(t)(1) provides that the Government of the United States,
every State, every political subdivision thereof, and every
instrumentality of the foregoing (including multi-State agencies)
making any payment to any person providing any property or services
(including any payment made in connection with a government voucher or
certificate program which functions as a payment for property or
services) shall deduct and withhold from such payment a tax in an
amount equal to 3 percent of such payment. Under the statute, section
3402(t) applies to payments made after December 31, 2010.
Exceptions to section 3402(t) withholding are contained in section
3402(t)(2). Section 3402(t)(2) provides that section 3402(t)
withholding shall not apply to any payment--
(A) Except as provided in section 3402(t)(2)(B), which is subject
to withholding under any other provision of chapter 24 (Collection of
Income Tax at Source on Wages, sections 3401 through 3406) or chapter 3
(Withholding of Tax on Nonresident Aliens and Foreign Corporations,
sections 1441 through 1464) of the Code;
(B) Which is subject to withholding under section 3406 (backup
withholding) and from which amounts are being withheld under such
section;
(C) Of interest;
(D) For real property;
(E) To any government entity subject to the requirements of section
3402(t)(1), any tax-exempt entity, or any foreign government;
(F) Made pursuant to a classified or confidential contract
described in section 6050M(e)(3);
(G) Made by a political subdivision of a State (or any
instrumentality thereof) which makes less than $100,000,000 of such
payments annually;
(H) Which is in connection with a public assistance or public
welfare program for which eligibility is determined by a needs or
income test; and
(I) To any government employee not otherwise excludable with
respect to his or her services as an employee.
Section 3402(t)(3) provides for the coordination of section 3402(t)
with other Code sections. Section 3402(t)(3) provides that, for
purposes of sections 3403 and 3404 and for purposes of so much of
subtitle F (except section 7205) as relates to chapter 24, payments to
any person for property or services which are subject to withholding
shall be treated as if such payments were wages paid by an employer to
an employee.
The legislative history in connection with section 3402(t)
indicates that ``[t]he withholding requirement applies regardless of
whether the government entity making such payment is the recipient of
the property or services.'' H.R. Conf. Rep. No.109-455, 109th Cong., 2d
Sess. at 300 (2006). Further, the conference report also provides, with
respect to the exception provided by section 3402(t)(2)(H), that
``payments under government programs to provide health care or other
services that are not based on the needs or income of the recipients
are subject to withholding, including programs where eligibility is
based on the age of the beneficiary.'' H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 109-455 at
page 301. In addition, with respect to section 3402(t)(2)(A), the
conference report states that section 3402(t) withholding ``does not
apply to payments of wages or to any other payment with respect to
which mandatory (e.g., U.S.-source income of foreign taxpayers) or
voluntary (e.g., unemployment benefits) withholding applies under
present law.'' H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 109-455 at page 301. The origins of
the provision indicate that it was conceived to address tax
noncompliance. See also, ``Options to Improve Tax Compliance and Reform
Tax Expenditures'' (JCS-2-05), Joint Committee on Taxation, Jan. 27,
2005.
Notice 2008-38, 2008-13 IRB 683, published by the IRS on March 31,
2008, invited public comments regarding guidance under section 3402(t).
In particular, Notice 2008-38 requested comments on the application of
section 3402(t) to credit cards and payment cards, payments to payees
not subject to United States taxation, passthrough entities in which a
government entity is a partner or owner, government contractors and
subcontractors, and de minimis payments. The Notice also requested
comments on when and how amounts withheld under section 3402(t) should
be transmitted to the IRS. See Sec. 601.601(d)(2)(ii)(b).
Many comments were received in response to Notice 2008-38, and the
comments were taken into consideration in developing the proposed
regulations.
Explanation of Provisions
The proposed regulations provide rules about which government
entities are subject to the requirement of section 3402(t) withholding,
which payments are subject to section 3402(t) withholding (and which
are excepted from such withholding), when withholding is required on
such payments, and how government entities pay and report the tax to
the IRS. The proposed regulations also include transition rules
providing relief from liability for the tax imposed by section 3402(t)
with respect to payments under existing contracts. The proposed
regulations also provide temporary relief from penalties and interest
if a government entity makes a good faith effort but fails to withhold
on payments as required under section 3402(t).
The regulations provide guidance primarily on what government
entities
[[Page 74084]]
need to do to comply so that they can make timely preparations. The
Treasury Department and IRS anticipate issuing further guidance to
address questions raised by taxpayers who expect to receive payments
subject to section 3402(t) withholding from government entities
including, but not limited to, how to claim credits and how to claim
the benefit of statutory exemptions from withholding under section
3402(t). Although some commenters requested that the Treasury
Department and IRS issue guidance exempting payments from withholding
where the 3-percent rate for withholding prescribed under section
3402(t) is expected to exceed either the profit margin in the
taxpayer's industry or the income tax the taxpayer will owe for reasons
particular to the taxpayer's business, the Treasury Department and IRS
have determined that exemptions of this type would be contrary to the
requirements of the statute. Commenters also requested that they be
permitted to credit amounts withheld under section 3402(t) against
Federal taxes other than income taxes, such as employment taxes.
Consistent with the statute's purpose of addressing income tax
noncompliance, the Treasury Department and IRS propose to allow credits
to be claimed only against income tax.
Government Entities Subject to Section 3402(t)
Section 3402(t)(1) applies to ``the Government of the United
States, every State, every political subdivision thereof, and every
instrumentality of the foregoing.'' Section 3402(t) does not restrict
the term the Government of the United States in any manner. Therefore,
the entire Federal government, including the executive branch, the
legislative branch, and the judicial branch, is subject to the
requirements of section 3402(t). Thus, Congress, the Administrative
Office of the United States Courts, the Executive Office of the
President, Federal agencies, and all other components of the Federal
government are included in the definition of Government of the United
States and are required to withhold under section 3402(t).
The term State includes the District of Columbia. See section
7701(a)(10) of the Code. For purposes of section 3402(t), the term
State does not include Indian tribal governments. Section 7871(a)
prescribes when an Indian tribal government is to be treated as a State
under the Code, and section 7871(a) does not provide that Indian tribal
governments will be treated as States for purposes of section 3402(t).
Consequently, the term political subdivision also does not include a
subdivision of an Indian tribal government. See section 7871(a) and
(d). Accordingly, because Indian tribal governments and their
subdivisions are not among the listed government entities subject to
section 3402(t), payments by Indian tribal governments and their
subdivisions are not subject to the withholding requirements of section
3402(t).
The definition of political subdivision in the proposed regulations
follows the definition in the section 103 regulations. Section 1.103-
1(b) of the Income Tax Regulations provides, in part, that the term
political subdivision denotes any division of any State or local
government unit that is a municipal corporation or that has been
delegated the right to exercise part of the sovereign power of the
unit.
Although the Code makes references to government instrumentalities
in multiple sections, the Code and regulations do not currently provide
a definition of instrumentality. In Rev. Rul. 57-128, 1957-1 CB 311,
the IRS adopted a six-factor test for use in determining what is an
instrumentality of a State or a political subdivision thereof for
purposes of an exception from the requirement to pay tax under the
Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA). The factors are: (1)
Whether the organization is used for a government purpose and performs
a government function; (2) whether performance of its function is on
behalf of one or more States or political subdivisions; (3) whether
there are any private interests involved, or whether the States or
political subdivisions involved have the powers and interests of an
owner; (4) whether control and supervision of the organization is
vested in public authority or authorities; (5) if express or implied
statutory or other authority is necessary for the creation and/or use
of such an instrumentality, and whether such authority exists; and (6)
the degree of financial autonomy and the source of its operating
expenses. A number of revenue rulings published by the IRS illustrate
the application of this test. See, for example, Rev. Rul. 65-26, 1965-1
CB 444; Rev. Rul. 65-196, 1965-2 CB 388; and Rev. Rul. 69-453, 1969-2
CB 182. See Sec. 601.601(d)(2)(ii)(b). The Treasury Department and IRS
invite comments on use of the same or a similar test for purposes of
section 3402(t).
Persons Subject to Withholding Under Section 3402(t)
Section 3402(t) applies to government payments to ``persons''
providing any property or services. Section 7701(a)(1) of the Code
provides that, when used in the Code, where not otherwise distinctly
expressed or manifestly incompatible with the intent thereof, the term
person shall be construed to mean and include an individual, a trust,
estate, partnership, association, company, or corporation. Because no
alternative definition of person is provided in section 3402(t), the
definition in section 7701(a)(1) and the regulations under section
7701(a)(1) applies. Therefore, section 3402(t) withholding can apply to
payments for property or services to individuals, trusts, estates,
partnerships, associations, companies, or corporations.
Payments Subject to Section 3402(t) Withholding
The proposed regulations provide that a payment subject to
withholding arises when the government entity or its payment
administrator pays a person for providing property or services. Under
the proposed rules, the withholding requirements of section 3402(t)
will not apply to any payment that is less than the payment threshold
amount, which is $10,000. The Treasury Department and IRS are proposing
this payment threshold of $10,000 because the burden of withholding on
smaller transactions is likely to be substantial and outweigh the
benefits of increased withholding. This threshold corresponds to a
minimum withholding of $300.
Under the proposed rules, multiple payments made by a government
entity to any person generally would not be aggregated in determining
whether the payment threshold amount has been met. However, the
proposed regulations provide an anti-abuse rule to ensure that the
payment threshold is not manipulated to avoid the required withholding.
If a government entity divides a payment into two or more separate
payments primarily to avoid the payment threshold for one or more
payments, the separate payments would be treated as one payment made on
the date that the first payment was made for purposes of this rule. For
example, if a government entity is scheduled to make a contractual
payment to a person for landscaping services of $15,000 on July 2,
2011, but divides the payment into payments of $7,000 and $8,000 made
on July 1, 2011, and July 2, 2011, respectively, the government entity
would be treated as having made a single payment of $15,000 on July 1,
2011. This anti-abuse rule would not apply if the primary reason for
division into separate payments is unrelated to section 3402(t).
If a government entity makes a single payment of $10,000 or more to
any
[[Page 74085]]
person for more than one property or service provided by that person,
the government entity would be required to withhold on the payment. For
example, if a person bills a government entity $5,000 each day for
seven days for services provided each day, but the government entity
makes one payment of $35,000 in satisfaction of these bills, the
payment threshold is applied to the $35,000 payment.
Many commenters requested guidance on how the requirements of
section 3402(t) apply to prime contractors and subcontractors. Under
the proposed rules, if a government entity or its payment administrator
makes a payment to a person that is subject to withholding under
section 3402(t), no subsequent transfer of cash or property by that
person to another person is treated as a payment for section 3402(t)
purposes. Thus, if the government entity enters into a contract with a
prime contractor for property and services, and that prime contractor
separately contracts with subcontractors for delivery of certain
property and services, then withholding under section 3402(t) applies
only to payments by the government entity or its payment administrator
to the prime contractor, and does not apply to successive payments by
the prime contractor to its subcontractors.
The proposed regulations apply to payments made by the government
entity or its payment administrator. For purposes of the proposed
regulations, a payment administrator is any person that acts with
respect to a payment solely as an agent for a government entity by
making the payment on behalf of the government entity to a person
providing property or services to, or on behalf of, the government
entity. Transfers of funds from a government entity to a payment
administrator to be used by the payment administrator, on the
government entity's behalf, to pay persons for providing property or
services are not payments subject to withholding under section 3402(t).
However, if the government entity pays the payment administrator a fee
for its services, the government entity would treat the fee as a
payment subject to withholding. The government entity is liable for the
withholding required and responsible for all related reporting
regardless of whether the government entity or its payment
administrator makes the payment and regardless of when the payment for
property or services is made under this section.
Credit Card Payments
Many commenters questioned how the requirements of section 3402(t)
apply to payments made by government credit card or payment card. Under
the proposed regulations, when a government entity or its payment
administrator uses a credit card or payment card to pay a person for
providing property or services, payment occurs at the point of sale
when the government credit card or payment card is tendered and not
when the government entity pays the credit card company. The government
entity is liable for the withholding and reporting associated with the
payment, and this liability is not transferred to any other party
involved in the credit card or payment card transaction, including, but
not limited to, the acquiring bank, the issuing bank, or the credit
card association. (The acquiring bank may be separately required to
report amounts it pays under new section 6050W, which was enacted as
part of the Housing Assistance Tax Act of 2008, Div. C of Pub. L. 110-
289.)
Section 3402(t)(2)(A)--Payments Subject to Withholding Under Chapter 3
or Chapter 24 and Section 3402(t)(2)(B)--Payments From Which Backup
Withholding Is Withheld
Section 3402(t)(2)(A) provides an exception from the requirement of
section 3402(t) for amounts that are subject to withholding under some
other provision of chapter 3 or chapter 24 (other than section 3406).
Thus, payments that are subject to withholding under the wage
withholding regime or the regime for withholding of tax on nonresident
aliens and foreign corporations are exempt from withholding under
section 3402(t). Furthermore, consistent with the legislative history,
amounts for which the payee may elect withholding are exempt from
withholding under section 3402(t), regardless of whether the payee in
fact makes such an election. These payments include: (1) Unemployment
compensation as defined in section 85(b) (section 3402(p)(2)); (2)
social security benefits as defined in section 86(d) (section
3402(p)(1)(C)(i)); (3) any payment referred to in the second sentence
of section 451(d) that is treated as insurance proceeds, relating to
certain disaster payments received under the Agricultural Act of 1949,
as amended, or Title II of the Disaster Assistance Act of 1988 (section
3402(p)(1)(C)(ii)); (4) any amount that is includible in gross income
under section 77(a), relating to amounts received as loans from the
Commodity Credit Corporation that the taxpayer has elected to treat as
income (section 3402(p)(1)(C)(iii)); and (5) any payment of an annuity
to an individual.
A special rule applies for payments subject to backup withholding.
Section 3402(t)(2)(B) provides that a payment that is subject to 28
percent withholding under section 3406 (backup withholding) is not
excepted from the requirement of 3 percent withholding under section
3402(t) unless backup withholding is actually being deducted from the
payment. Thus, if backup withholding is required with respect to a
payment made by a government entity and the government entity performs
backup withholding on the payment, section 3402(t) does not apply. If
the government entity fails to backup withholding on such a payment,
the government entity would remain liable for backup withholding
regardless of whether it imposed withholding under section 3402(t) with
respect to the payment. Proposed amendments to the regulations under
section 3406 clarify that if backup withholding is required,
withholding under section 3402(t) is not required.
Under the proposed regulations, payments made to nonresident aliens
or foreign individuals that are exempt from United States taxation
pursuant to a treaty would be exempt from withholding under section
3402(t) because such payments are subject to withholding absent
application of the treaty. Specifically, absent a treaty, United States
source fixed or determinable, annual or periodical (FDAP) income paid
to a nonresident alien individual or foreign corporation is subject to
withholding under chapter 3, except for income that is effectively
connected with a U.S. trade or business (other than compensation for
personal services) pursuant to sections 1441 and 1442. Relevant
examples of FDAP include salaries, compensation and emoluments.
Imposing a new withholding requirement on nonresident aliens and
foreign corporations that owe no United States tax would serve no
purpose. Foreign persons that are exempt from withholding under
sections 1441 and 1442 by reason of an income tax treaty are not the
source of the tax noncompliance problem that section 3402(t) was
enacted to address. Further, our existing documentation procedures are
intended to ensure that those claiming treaty benefits are in fact
entitled to treaty benefits. See, for example, Form W-8BEN,
``Certificate of Foreign Status of Beneficial Owner for United States
Tax Withholding,'' and Form 8233, ``Exemption From Withholding on
Compensation for Independent (and Certain Dependent) Personal Services
of a Nonresident Alien Individual.'' Accordingly, the
[[Page 74086]]
proposed regulations under section 3402(t) provide that the ``subject
to withholding under chapter 3'' exception in section 3402(t)(2)(A)
applies to payments with respect to which a foreign person claims a
zero rate of tax under an income tax treaty. Thus, if a foreign person
furnishes documentation establishing entitlement to an exemption from
withholding under chapter 3 by reason of an income tax treaty,
government entities would not be required to withhold under section
3402(t) from payments to such person.
Section 3402(t)(2)(C)--Interest
Section 3402(t)(2)(C) provides that payments of interest are exempt
from withholding. The proposed regulations do not provide a definition
of interest. The Treasury Department and IRS request comments
concerning whether a definition of interest is needed and if so, what
that definition should be.
Section 3402(t)(2)(D)--Payments for Real Property
Section 3402(t)(2)(D) provides that payments for real property are
not subject to section 3402(t). Because the exception is not limited to
payments for fee ownership, the proposed regulations provide that
payments for real property include payments for leasing real property
and leasehold improvements.
Commenters asked whether real property included payments made under
contracts for the construction of buildings or other public works.
Neither the statute itself nor the legislative history defines ``real
property'' for purposes of section 3402(t).
The proposed regulations adopt the position that payments for the
construction of buildings or public works are not payments for real
property excepted by section 3402(t)(2)(D). Payments for the
construction of a building are payments for services to build the
building and personal property to be used in the construction of the
building rather than payments for real property. This position is
consistent with statutes governing construction contracts of the
Federal government. See, for example, 40 U.S.C. 3131-3134 (the ``Miller
Act'').
Section 3402(t)(2)(E)--Payments to Government Entities Subject to
Section 3402(t), Tax-Exempt Organizations, and Foreign Governments
Section 3402(t)(2)(E) provides exceptions from section 3402(t)
withholding for payments to any government entity subject to the
requirements of section 3402(t)(1), payments to any tax-exempt entity,
and payments to any foreign government. The determination of whether an
entity is a government entity such that payments it receives are exempt
parallels the determination whether the entity is a government entity
required to withhold on payments it makes. Thus, if a government entity
is required to withhold under section 3402(t)(1), payments to that
government entity are not subject to withholding under section 3402(t).
The proposed regulations also clarify that, even if no withholding is
required on payments from a government entity because the government
entity qualifies for the exception of section 3402(t)(2)(G) for
political subdivisions and instrumentalities making total payments of
less than $100 million (discussed later in this preamble), payments to
that government entity are not subject to withholding.
The proposed regulations define the term tax-exempt entity for
purposes of section 3402(t)(2)(E) as any organization exempt from
federal income tax under section 501(a) as an organization described in
section 501(c), 501(d), or section 401(a).
Section 3402(t)(2)(F)--Payments Made Pursuant to a Classified or
Confidential Contract
Section 3402(t)(2)(F) provides an exception from section 3402(t)
withholding for payments made pursuant to a classified or confidential
contract described in section 6050M(e)(3). Section 6050M(e)(3)
describes a contract between a Federal executive agency and another
person if--
(A) The fact of the existence of such contract or the subject
matter of such contract has been designated and clearly marked or
clearly represented, pursuant to the provisions of Federal law or an
Executive order, as requiring a specific degree of protection against
unauthorized disclosure for reasons of national security, or
(B) The head of such Federal executive agency (or his designee),
pursuant to regulations issued by such agency, determines, in writing,
that filing the required return under section 6050M (related to
information returns required to be filed by any Federal executive
agency with respect to persons receiving contracts) would interfere
with the effective conduct of a confidential law enforcement or foreign
counterintelligence activity.
Section 3402(t)(2)(G)--The Exception for Political Subdivisions and
Instrumentalities Making Total Payments Under $100,000,000
Section 3402(t)(2)(G) provides that payments made by certain
smaller government entities are not subject to withholding under
section 3402(t). Specifically, a political subdivision of a State (or
any instrumentality thereof) that makes less than $100,000,000 of
payments for property or services annually (other than for payroll or
of another type exempt from withholding under these proposed
regulations) is not required to withhold under section 3402(t) on any
of its payments. The proposed regulations provide a simple rule for
determining before each year starts whether the exception provided by
section 3402(t)(2)(G) applies to a given political subdivision or
instrumentality. The determination would be based on the payments made
during the accounting year of the political subdivision or
instrumentality ending with or within the second preceding calendar
year. For example, to determine whether the political subdivision or
instrumentality is subject to withholding with respect to payments made
in 2011, the proposed regulations would look to whether payments made
by the political subdivision or instrumentality for its accounting year
ending with or within the calendar year 2009 equaled or exceeded
$100,000,000. For this purpose, the accounting year is considered to be
the year used by the political subdivision or instrumentality to keep
its accounting books and determine budgets. In most cases, political
subdivisions and instrumentalities would be able to make a reasonably
accurate estimate whether the exception applies before the end of the
accounting year ending in 2009 based on budgetary projections. However,
in cases where the payments are expected to be near the $100,000,000
threshold, the time between the end of the accounting year in 2009,
when a definitive determination could be made, and December 31, 2010,
should give the political subdivision or instrumentality sufficient
time to prepare for withholding under section 3402(t) for payments made
in 2011.
In determining whether the political subdivision or instrumentality
has made $100,000,000 of total payments, the proposed regulations would
require that all payments for property and services made during the
accounting year be considered with the exception of those payments
qualifying for any of the exceptions provided by Sec. 31.3402(t)-4(a)
through (l) of the proposed regulations.
[[Page 74087]]
For this purpose, payments that are less than the $10,000 payment
threshold count toward the $100,000,000 test.
This exception provided by section 3402(t)(2)(G) does not apply to
the United States Government, States, or instrumentalities of the
United States Government or States.
The Treasury Department and IRS request comments on the application
of section 3402(t)(2)(G), particularly with regard to whether the rules
for determining whether the exception applies would provide adequate
time to modify systems for compliance with section 3402(t), whether a
special rule should be considered allowing the averaging of multiple
accounting years for political subdivisions and instrumentalities that
have unusually high expenditures in a given accounting year, and
whether the determination of total payments under the proposed
regulations is practicable.
Section 3402(t)(2)(H)--Payments in Connection with a Public Welfare or
Public Assistance Plan
Section 3402(t)(2)(H) provides an exception from section 3402(t)
withholding for any payment in connection with a public assistance or
public welfare program for which eligibility is determined by a needs
or income test. The proposed regulations adopt a broad definition of in
connection with to include payments made to third parties under a
public assistance or public welfare program for the benefit of the
recipient of benefits under the program. The proposed regulations also
are consistent with the legislative history in providing that a program
for which eligibility is determined under a needs or income test does
not include a program under which eligibility is based on age only (for
example, Medicare). The proposed regulations provide that, for purposes
of this exception, a program providing disaster relief to victims of a
natural or other disaster is considered to be a program for which
eligibility is determined under a needs test.
Section 3402(t)(2)(I)--Payments to a Government Employee With Respect
to Services as an Employee
Section 3402(t)(2)(I) provides an exception from section 3402(t)
withholding for payments to any government employee not otherwise
excludable with respect to the employee's services as an employee. The
proposed regulations broadly interpret this exception to exclude from
section 3402(t) withholding any form of compensation that is paid to
the employee or on the employee's behalf. For example, the proposed
regulations exclude employer contributions to employee benefit and
deferred compensation plans as well as employee contributions to such
plans. This exception applies to any payments by an employer for fringe
benefits or deferred compensation to, or for the benefit of, an
employee.
The proposed regulations provide that the section 3402(t)(2)(I)
exclusion from section 3402(t) withholding also applies to: (a) Travel
reimbursements paid by a government entity to a government employee
under accountable plans within the meaning of section 62(c) for the
individual employee's travel, lodging, and meal expenses; and (b) the
government employee's payments to third parties that provide travel,
lodging, and meals that are reimbursable under such travel
reimbursement plans. Most payments for individual travel, lodging, and
meal expenses would fall beneath the $10,000 payment threshold.
Nevertheless, this exception may be significant in determining whether
the government entity making the payments qualifies for the exception
under section 3402(t)(2)(G) for political subdivisions of a State (or
their instrumentalities) making payments under $100,000,000, as
payments under section 3402(t)(2)(I) are excluded when calculating the
total amount of payments.
Section 31.3401(a)-4(a) of the Employment Tax Regulations provides
that if a reimbursement or other expense allowance arrangement meets
the requirements of section 62(c) and Sec. 1.62-2 and the expenses are
substantiated within a reasonable period of time, payments made under
the arrangement that do not exceed the substantiated expenses are
treated as paid under an accountable plan and are not wages. Thus,
these payments would qualify for the exception under section
3402(t)(2)(I).
By comparison, if the travel reimbursement or payment by the
employer is not paid under an accountable plan, the reimbursement would
be treated as paid under a nonaccountable plan. Payments to the
employee under a nonaccountable plan are includible in gross income and
wages and subject to income tax withholding under section 3402(a).
Thus, such payments would be excepted from withholding under section
3402(t) by section 3402(t)(2)(A).
Exception for Certain Payments Received by Nonresident Alien
Individuals and Foreign Corporations
In general, in the case of a nonresident alien individual or a
foreign corporation (foreign person), sections 872(a) and 882(b)
provide that gross income for United States income tax purposes
consists of (1) gross income derived from sources within the United
States; and (2) gross income derived from sources outside the United
States (foreign source income), but only if it is effectively connected
with a trade or business within the United States. The source of income
is determined under sections 861 through 865. The source of income
derived from the performance of services is the place where the
services are performed as provided in sections 861(a)(3) and 862(a)(3),
whereas the source of income from the purchase and sale of inventory
property (other than unprocessed timber) is the location where the sale
takes place as described in Sec. 1.861-7(c) of the Income Tax
Regulations (see also sections 861(a)(6) and 862(a)(6)). Therefore, if
a foreign person provides services or sells inventory property in a
foreign country, it will have no United States income tax liability
with respect to the income earned from providing the services or
selling the property--even to a United States government entity--
provided that the income is not effectively connected with the conduct
of a trade or business within the United States.
Accordingly, the proposed regulations exclude such payments made to
foreign persons from 3-percent withholding under section 3402(t). For
administrative reasons, subjecting these foreign source payments to
withholding under 3402(t) would be unduly burdensome to the foreign
persons receiving such payments and the IRS. The foreign persons, most
of whom are not presently United States income tax filers, would have
to get taxpayer identification numbers (TINs) and file refund claims.
Likewise, the IRS would have to issue TINs, process the claims, and
refund all of the funds collected. Withholding on foreign source
payments to foreign persons has no potential to reduce tax
noncompliance because the potential income resulting from the payments
is not subject to United States income taxation. Procedures to be
followed by government entities and foreign persons for purposes of
claiming this exception from section 3402(t) withholding will be issued
at a later date.
Exception for Payments to Indian Tribal Governments
Indian tribal governments are not subject to United States income
tax. Subjecting payments made by government entities to Indian tribal
governments to withholding under section 3402(t) would be unduly
burdensome for the same reasons
[[Page 74088]]
discussed above with respect to certain payments made to foreign
persons. Therefore, the proposed regulations except these payments from
3-percent withholding under section 3402(t).
Deposits and Reporting of Amounts Withheld Under Section 3402(t)
In determining rules for reporting amounts withheld under section
3402(t), the Treasury Department and IRS have considered the
administrative burden on government entities imposed by reporting, the
need for payees to receive timely and accurate information about the
amounts withheld, and the need for IRS systems to process the
information reported. Many comments reflected a preference for using an
existing system and adapting current forms and procedures to
accommodate section 3402(t) withholding, rather than creating a new
system and forms for such withholding. The commenters indicated that
using an existing system would ease compliance by government entities
and would ease the processing of the payment and reporting of such tax.
The Treasury Department and IRS believe the existing procedure for
reporting nonwage withholding on Form 945, ``Annual Return of Withheld
Federal Income Tax,'' and reporting payments subject to withholding on
Form 1099-MISC, ``Miscellaneous Income,'' with slight modifications to
existing forms, would provide the most satisfactory method of payment
and reporting. Because most government entities have a system for
issuing Form 1099-MISC, using this system with modifications for
reporting section 3402(t) withholding should ease compliance.
Additionally, using Form 1099-MISC would give payees the information
they need to timely file their income tax returns claiming credit for
the withholding. Because this system would be similar to the system
used currently for reporting and paying nonwage income tax withholding,
the IRS would be able to process the withholding timely and on a cost-
effective basis.
Accordingly, the proposed amendments to the regulations under
section 6011 provide that payors required to withhold amounts under
section 3402(t) must file Form 945 reporting the amounts withheld.
Proposed amendments to the regulations under section 6302 further
provide that the amounts withheld under section 3402(t) must be
deposited and reported in the same manner as other nonwage withheld
amounts, such as withholding on gambling winnings and pensions.
Pursuant to existing regulations, such amounts are treated as if they
were employment taxes for purposes of the deposit rules, but are
subject to special rules for determining the payor's deposit schedule,
as provided in Sec. 31.6302-4.
Additionally, proposed amendments to regulations under section 6051
provide that payors required to withhold amounts under section 3402(t)
must file information returns and furnish payee statements on Form
1099-MISC reporting such payments and tax withheld. Because this
reporting would be done pursuant to regulations under section 6051, the
exceptions provided in the regulations under section 6041 relating to
Form 1099 would not apply (for example, the exception for payments to
corporations).
Payments for Jury Duty, Utilities, and Fuel Surcharges
Commenters asked whether jury duty pay is subject to withholding
under section 3402(t). Jury duty pay generally will not meet the
$10,000 payment threshold provided in the proposed regulations. No
special rule for jury duty pay is provided.
Commenters also requested guidance about utility payments. Rates
for utility services are generally prescribed through a State
regulatory process. Commenters expressed concern about the consequences
of paying something less than the regulatorily prescribed rate to the
utility. In fact, utility companies--like all persons receiving
payments subject to withholding under section 3402(t)--would be paid
the full amount charged, albeit in the form of a combination of a cash
payment and a deposit of tax made to the IRS. Therefore, unless
otherwise excepted, utility payments are subject to withholding under
section 3402(t) on the same basis as payments for other property and
services.
Commenters also requested that fuel surcharges be exempted from
withholding, arguing that a fuel surcharge provided under a contract is
merely a cost recovery mechanism used to garner the lowest possible
rates for the government by controlling volatile cost components in bid
calculations. Although the use of separately stated charges for certain
costs may well serve this purpose in contracting, section 3402(t)
provides no exception for fuel surcharges or any other separately
stated cost item. Section 3402(t) requires withholding on payments made
regardless of how the payee may apply them against costs. Therefore,
the proposed regulations do not provide an exception for payments
allocated to fuel surcharges or any other separately stated costs.
Application of Section 3402(t) to Passthrough Entities
Commenters requested guidance with respect to the application of
section 3402(t) where either the payor or the payee is a partnership or
S corporation (``passthrough entities''). With respect to payments from
a passthrough entity, the proposed regulations provide that such
payments are not generally subject to withholding under section 3402(t)
unless 80 percent or more of the passthrough entity is owned by
government entities that are required to withhold under section
3402(t)(1). With respect to payments to a passthrough entity, the
proposed regulations provide that such payments are generally subject
to withholding under section 3402(t) unless 80 percent or more of the
passthrough entity is owned by persons described in section
3402(t)(2)(E) (government entities required to withhold under section
3402(t)(1), tax-exempt entities, and foreign governments). An 80-
percent threshold is consistent with similar thresholds in various
areas of the tax law. See, for example, section 775(b)(3) and
Sec. Sec. 1.414(c)-2(b)(2) and 301.7701(i)-1(d)(3)(i)(A). The proposed
regulations also provide that, as a general rule, whether a passthrough
entity is subject to section 3402(t) is determined on the first day of
the entity's taxable year. The Treasury Department and IRS believe that
this general rule simplifies compliance and administration by requiring
one annual determination of whether a passthrough entity's payments are
subject to withholding under section 3402(t). However, the proposed
regulations provide that any manipulation of the ownership percentage
with an intent to avoid application of section 3402(t) would be
recharacterized as appropriate to reflect the actual ownership
percentage.
Effective Date and Transition Relief for Existing Contracts
The proposed regulations provide that the regulations will
generally be effective for payments made after the later of December
31, 2010, or the date that is 6 months after the publication of final
regulations. Commenters questioned whether section 3402(t) would apply
to payments made under contracts in existence prior to the effective
date of section 3402(t). They noted that many government entities are
party to multi-year contracts. These contracts did not contemplate the
withholding of income tax from payments under the contracts. Future
[[Page 74089]]
contracts can address the withholding requirement and its effect on the
contractor's cash flow. Accordingly, the proposed regulations provide
that payments made under written binding contracts in effect on the
later of December 31, 2010, or the date that is 6 months after the
publication of final regulations are not subject to withholding under
section 3402(t), unless such contract is materially modified. Payments
pursuant to contracts entered into after the later of December 31,
2010, or the date that is 6 months after the publication of final
regulations will be subject to section 3402(t).
Under the proposed regulations, if there is a material modification
to an existing contract after the later of the effective date of the
legislation or six months after the issuance of final regulations under
section 3402(t), the contract would cease to be an existing contract
for purposes of this transition relief and payments under the contract
would become subject to the withholding requirements of section
3402(t). The Treasury Department and IRS are considering whether
contracts that contain the option of renewal should be considered new
contracts as of the date of renewal. The final regulations may provide
that a contract that is renewable as of a certain date is treated as a
new contract on the first date the contract is renewed. The Treasury
Department and IRS request comments on how option terms in contracts,
including, but not limited to, options to renew, should affect the
transition relief for payments under written binding contracts.
Credit Against Income Tax
The Treasury Department and IRS received numerous comments from
taxpayers expecting to receive payments subject to section 3402(t)
withholding. Most of these comments asked how taxpayers would take the
credit for the section 3402(t) withholding. Section 31 provides the
general crediting rule for withholding of income tax. Specifically,
section 31(a)(1) provides that ``[t]he amount withheld as tax under
chapter 24 shall be allowed to the recipient of the income as a credit
against the tax imposed by this subtitle.'' Chapter 24 includes section
3402(t), and section 31(a)(1) is in subtitle A, income taxes. Thus, by
its terms, section 31(a)(1) applies to persons who have had income tax
withheld from a payment pursuant to section 3402(t) and allows a credit
against income tax only.
Section 31(a)(2) provides the general rule on the timing of the
allowance of the credit: ``The amount so withheld during any calendar
year shall be allowed as a credit for the taxable year beginning in
such calendar year. If more than one taxable year begins in a calendar
year, such amount shall be allowed as a credit for the last taxable
year so beginning.'' Thus, absent a special rule, the rule of section
31(a)(2) generally applies for purposes of withholdings required under
chapter 24, which includes section 3402(t).
Section 31(c) provides a special rule solely for backup
withholding. Under section 31(c), any credit allowed by section 31(a)
for backup withholding under section 3406 must be allowed for the
taxable year of the recipient of the income in which the income is
received. Congress did not provide a similar exception for the timing
of the credit for section 3402(t) withholding. Section 31(c) is limited
by its terms to section 3406 withholding only. Thus, the general rule
of section 31(a)(2) applies to section 3402(t) withholding rather than
the special rule of section 31(c).
The effect of section 31(a)(2) is that fiscal year taxpayers may be
entitled to take credit for withholding under section 3402(t) only in a
taxable year subsequent to the taxable year in which the amount was
withheld. For example, if amounts were withheld under section 3402(t)
from a June 30 fiscal year taxpayer during the period from January 1,
2011, to June 30, 2011, the taxpayer will be entitled to take credit
for the withheld tax on its income tax return for the fiscal year
ending June 30, 2012, rather than its income tax return for the fiscal
year ending June 30, 2011.
The Treasury Department and IRS recognize that, in the case of
fiscal year taxpayers, the application of the rule in section 31(a)(2)
requiring that the credit be taken in the second of two possible
taxable years may be burdensome for taxpayers. The Treasury Department
and IRS request comments on what impact the timing rule in section
31(a)(2) described above for income tax credits will have on taxpayers
that have tax withheld under section 3402(t).
Crediting Against Estimated Income Tax Liability
Taxpayers may take into account the income tax withheld under
section 3402(t) and allowed as a credit under section 31 in determining
estimated tax liability pursuant to sections 6654 and 6655. With
respect to individual taxpayers, section 6654(g)(1) provides that, for
purposes of determining the application of the penalty for an
individual's failure to pay estimated tax, the amount of the credit
allowed under section 31 for the taxable year shall be deemed a payment
of estimated tax. As with other income tax withheld, an individual
recipient may account for income tax withheld in computing estimated
income tax liability on Form 1040-ES, ``Estimated Tax for
Individuals.'' Because most individuals are calendar year taxpayers,
the section 3402(t) withholding would generally be treated as a payment
of estimated tax for the same calendar year, and the individual's
liability for other payments of estimated tax for that year would be
reduced. However, if the individual is a fiscal year taxpayer, the
individual may not take into account the withholding for estimated tax
purposes until the fiscal year that begins in the calendar year in
which the tax is withheld.
Similar rules apply to corporate taxpayers. In determining the
amount of estimated tax required to be paid to avoid the section 6655
penalty applicable to corporations for failure to pay estimated tax,
section 6655(g)(1)(B) provides in effect that credits against tax under
section 31 are taken into account. Thus, corporate taxpayers can also
take into account the amount of credit allowed under section 31(a) in
determining income tax liability and in computing estimated income tax
liability. As with individual taxpayers, corporate taxpayers on a
fiscal year could have the problem of delay in taking account of the
credit if withholding occurs in the part of the calendar year before
the beginning of the fiscal year that begins in that calendar year.
Credit Against Employment Taxes or Other Taxes
Many commenters requested that taxpayers be allowed to take credit
for section 3402(t) withholding with respect to employment taxes or
other taxes. The statute directs that crediting follow the rules under
section 31(a), which provide for crediting against income tax. Where
the statute permits income tax payments to be treated as employment tax
payments, or vice versa, it makes specific provision for that
treatment. See, for example, section 3507(d) (providing for the
treatment of advance payments of the earned income credit as payments
of the income tax withholding and FICA liability of the employer);
section 3510(b) (providing that domestic employment taxes are treated
as taxes due for estimated tax purposes under section 6654); and
section 31(b) (providing for the crediting against income tax of the
special refund of social security tax under section 6413(c) applicable
when an employee receives wages from two or more employers in excess of
the social security tax contribution and benefit base). The
[[Page 74090]]
Code does not provide for withholding under section 3402(t) to be
treated as payments of the taxpayer's employment tax liability.
Rate of Income Tax Withholding
Some taxpayers requested that the Treasury Department and IRS
provide for lower withholding rates for taxpayers with lower profit
margins or lower marginal income tax rates. The statute provides for a
uniform 3-percent rate of withholding. Thus, the proposed regulations
apply withholding at the 3-percent rate to all payments for services
and property from which withholding under section 3402(t) is required
to be made.
Liability for Section 3402(t) Withholding in the Event of Failure To
Withhold
If a government entity fails to withhold the tax imposed by section
3402(t), section 3403 applies. Under section 3402(t)(3) and section
3403, the government entity is generally liable for the payment of the
tax to the IRS unless it can prove that the payee has paid its income
tax liability.
Section 3403 provides that the employer shall be liable for the
payment of tax required to be deducted and withheld under chapter 24,
and shall not be liable to any person for the amount of any such
payment.
Section 31.3403-1 of the Employment Tax Regulations provides that
every employer required to deduct and withhold the tax under section
3402 from the wages of an employee is liable for the payment of such
tax whether or not it is collected from the employee by the employer.
If, for example, the employer deducts less than the correct amount of
tax, or if the employer fails to deduct any part of the tax, the
employer is nevertheless liable for the correct amount of the tax.
Section 3402(t)(3) provides that for purposes of section 3403, payments
to any person for property or services that are subject to withholding
under section 3402(t) are treated as if such payments were wages paid
by an employer to an employee.
Thus, sections 3402(t)(3) and 3403 establish the liability of the
government entity for the amount of the tax imposed by section 3402(t)
if it fails to withhold.
However, section 3402(d) provides an exception to the entity's
liability for income tax withholding in certain cases. Under this
exception, if the entity required to withhold fails to do so, and
thereafter the tax is paid, the tax will not be collected from the
entity that failed to withhold. Thus, for purposes of section 3402(t),
the government entity generally will be liable if it fails to withhold
unless it is able to demonstrate, consistent with IRS procedures, that
the taxpayer reported the amounts that were subject to withholding on
its income tax return and paid the income tax due.
Transition Rule for Penalties and Interest on Underpayments
The proposed regulations provide a special transition rule for a
government entity's liability for interest and penalties with respect
to the failure to pay the tax on payments for property and services
made before January 1, 2012. Under the transition rule, a government
entity would not be liable for penalties and interest with respect to
liability for withholding imposed by section 3402(t), on payments for
property or services made before January 1, 2012, if the entity made a
good faith effort to comply with the requirements of section 3402(t).
However, this transition rule would not provide relief from liability
for the amount of tax required to be withheld under section 3402(t).
Proposed Effective Date
These regulations are proposed to apply to payments made after the
later of December 31, 2010, or six months after the date of publication
of final regulations. In addition, the regulations will not apply to
payments under contracts existing on the later of December 31, 2010, or
six months after the date of publication of final regulations.
Special Analyses
It has been determined that this notice of proposed rulemaking is
not a significant regulatory action as defined in Executive Order
12866. Therefore, a regulatory assessment is not required. It also has
been determined that section 553(b) of the Administrative Procedure Act
(5 U.S.C. chapter 5) does not apply to this regulation, and because the
regulation does not impose a collection of information on small
entities, the Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. chapter 6) does not
apply. Pursuant to section 7805(f) of the Internal Revenue Code, this
regulation has been submitted to the Chief Counsel for Advocacy of the
Small Business Administration for comment on its impact on small
business.
Comments and Requests for Public Hearing
Before these proposed regulations are adopted as final regulations,
consideration will be given to any written (a signed original and eight
(8) copies) or electronic comments that are timely submitted to the
IRS. All comments will be available for public inspection and copying.
A public hearing will be scheduled if requested in writing by any
person that timely submits written or electronic comments. If a public
hearing is scheduled, notice of the date, time, and place for the
hearing will be published in the Federal Register.
Drafting Information
The principal author of these proposed regulations is A.G. Kelley,
Office of the Division Counsel/Associate Chief Counsel (Tax Exempt and
Government Entities). However, other personnel from the IRS and the
Treasury Department participated in their development.
List of Subjects in 26 CFR Part 31
Employment taxes, Income taxes, Penalties, Pensions, Railroad
retirement, Reporting and recordkeeping requirements, Social Security,
Unemployment compensation.
Proposed Amendments to the Regulations
Accordingly, 26 CFR part 31 is proposed to be amended as follows:
PART 31--EMPLOYMENT TAXES AND COLLECTION OF INCOME TAX AT SOURCE
Paragraph 1. The authority citation for part 31 continues to read
in part as follows:
Authority: 26 U.S.C. 7805 * * *
Par. 2. The following Sec. Sec. 31.3402(t)-0, 31.3402(t)-1,
31.3402(t)-2, 31.3402(t)-3, 31.3402(t)-4, and 31.3402(t)-5 are added,
Sec. 31.3402(t)-6 is added and reserved, and Sec. 31.3402(t)-7 is
added to read as follows:
Sec. 31.3402(t)-0 Outline of the Government withholding regulations.
This section lists paragraphs contained in Sec. Sec. 31.3402(t)-1
through 31.3402(t)-5, and Sec. 31.3402(t)-7.
Sec. 31.3402(t)-1 Withholding requirements on certain payments made
by government entities.
(a) In general.
(b) Special rules.
(c) Deposit and reporting requirements.
(d) Effective/applicability date.
Sec. 31.3402(t)-2 Government entities required to withhold under
section 3402(t).
(a) In general.
(b) Government of the United States.
(c) State.
(d) Political Subdivision.
(e) [Reserved].
(f) Possessions of the United States.
[[Page 74091]]
(g) Passthrough entities.
(h) Small entity exception.
(i) Effective/applicability date.
Sec. 31.3402(t)-3 Payments subject to withholding.
(a) In general.
(b) Payment threshold of $10,000.
(c) No withholding on successive payments.
(d) Payments made through a payment administrator or to a
contractor.
(e) Payments by credit card or payment card.
(f) Examples.
(g) Effective/applicability date.
Sec. 31.3402(t)-4 Certain payments excepted from withholding.
(a) Payments subject to withholding under chapter 3 or chapter 24
(other than section 3406).
(b) Payments subject to withholding under section 3406 with backup
withholding deducted.
(c) [Reserved].
(d) Payments for real property.
(e) Payments to government entities, tax-exempt organizations, and
foreign governments.
(f) Payments made pursuant to a classified or confidential
contract.
(g) Exception for political subdivisions or instrumentalities
thereof making less than $100,000,000 of payments for property or
services annually.
(h) Payments made in connection with a public assistance or public
welfare program.
(i) Payments made to any government employee with respect to his or
her services.
(j) Payments received by nonresident alien individuals and foreign
corporations.
(k) Payments to Indian tribal governments.
(l) Payments in emergency or disaster situations.
(m) Effective/applicability date.
Sec. 31.3402(t)-5 Application to passthrough entities.
(a) In general.
(b) Definitions.
(c) Payments from a passthrough entity.
(d) Payments to a passthrough entity.
(e) Effective/applicability date.
Sec. 31.3402(t)-6 Crediting of tax withheld under section 3402(t)
[Reserved].
Sec. 31.3402(t)-7 Effective date and transition rules.
(a) General rule.
(b) Exception for payments made under existing written binding
contracts.
(c) Good faith exception for interest and penalties on payments
before January 1, 2012.
Sec. 31.3402(t)-1 Withholding requirement on certain payments made by
government entities.
(a) In general. Except as provided in Sec. Sec. 31.3402(t)-3(b)
and 31.3402(t)-4, the Government of the United States, every State,
every political subdivision thereof, and every instrumentality of the
foregoing (including multi-State agencies) making any payment to any
person providing any property or services shall deduct and withhold
from such payment a tax in an amount equal to 3 percent of such
payment.
(b) Special rules. See Sec. 31.3402(t)-2 for government entities
required to withhold under this section, Sec. 31.3402(t)-3 for what
constitutes a payment to a person for property or services and when
such payment is deemed to occur for purposes of this section, and Sec.
31.3402(t)-4 for payments that are excepted from withholding under this
section.
(c) Deposit and reporting requirements. See Sec. 31.6302-4 for
deposit requirements with respect to withholding under section 3402(t).
See Sec. Sec. 31.6011(a)-4(b) and 31.6051-5 for the reporting
requirements with respect to withholding under section 3402(t).
(d) Effective/applicability date. (1) Except as provided in
paragraph (d)(2) of this section, this section is effective for
payments by the Government of the United States, every State, every
political subdivision thereof, and every instrumentality of the
foregoing (including multi-State agencies) to any person providing
property or services made after the later of December 31, 2010, or the
date that is 6 months after the date of publication in the Federal
Register of final regulations under section 3402(t).
(2) Payments made under a written binding contract that was in
effect on the later of December 31, 2010, or the date that is 6 months
after the publication in the Federal Register of final regulations
under section 3402(t), are not subject to the withholding requirements
of this section. The preceding sentence does not apply to payments made
under any contract that is materially modified after the later of
December 31, 2010, or the date that is 6 months after the date of
publication in the Federal Register of final regulations under section
3402(t).
Sec. 31.3402(t)-2 Government entities required to withhold under
section 3402(t).
(a) In general. The requirement to withhold under section 3402(t)
and Sec. 31.3402(t)-1(a) applies to the Government of the United
States (see paragraph (b) of this section) and every State (see
paragraph (c) of this section), as well as instrumentalities of the
foregoing. The requirement also applies to political subdivisions of
every State (see paragraph (d) of this section), and their
instrumentalities, unless the small entity exception of Sec.
31.3402(t)-4(g) applies.
(b) Government of the United States. The Government of the United
States includes the legislative branch, the judicial branch, and the
executive branch, and all components of the United States Government.
Thus, departments and agencies are included within the definition of
United States Government.
(c) State. The term State includes the District of Columbia.
However, an Indian tribal government is not considered a State for
purposes of section 3402(t) and Sec. 31.3402(t)-1(a). See section
7871(a).
(d) Political subdivi