McGovern Dole International Food for Education and Child Nutrition Program and Food for Progress Program, 63387-63406 [E8-25186]
Download as PDF
63387
Proposed Rules
Federal Register
Vol. 73, No. 207
Friday, October 24, 2008
This section of the FEDERAL REGISTER
contains notices to the public of the proposed
issuance of rules and regulations. The
purpose of these notices is to give interested
persons an opportunity to participate in the
rule making prior to the adoption of the final
rules.
DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
48 CFR Part 470
Commodity Credit Corporation
7 CFR Parts 1496 and 1499
Foreign Agricultural Service
7 CFR Part 1599
RIN 0551–AA78
McGovern Dole International Food for
Education and Child Nutrition Program
and Food for Progress Program
Foreign Agricultural Service
and Commodity Credit Corporation,
USDA.
ACTION: Proposed rule.
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
AGENCY:
SUMMARY: This proposed rule would
amend the regulations to administer the
Food for Progress (FFPr) Program and
the McGovern-Dole International Food
for Education and Child Nutrition
Program (McGovern-Dole Program) by
making revisions to provide greater
clarity with respect to all aspects of the
program with specific emphasis on the
eligibility requirements that a
participant must meet, and the actions
that must be undertaken by a participant
in order to receive assistance under
these programs, including the reports
that are filed by program participants
with the Foreign Agricultural Service
(FAS). This proposed rule would also
amend the Agriculture Acquisition
Regulation (AGAR), to specify the
criteria that is used in determining
whether a commodity that is procured
under these programs and under
domestic feeding programs
administered by USDA is considered to
be a commodity that is a product of the
United States. The purpose of these
amendments is to improve efficiency of
the programs and make it more clear to
participants what they must do to meet
eligibility requirements.
DATES: We will consider comments that
we receive by December 8, 2008.
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
We invite you to submit
comments on this proposed rule. In
your comment, include the volume,
date, and page number of this issue of
the Federal Register. You may submit
comments by any of the following
methods:
• E-Mail: PPDED@fas.usda.gov and/or
Babette.Gainor@fas.usda.gov.
• Fax: (202) 690–0251.
• Mail to: Babette Gainor, Deputy
Director, Food Assistance Division,
Foreign Agricultural Service, U.S.
Department of Agriculture, Stop 1034,
1400 Independence Avenue, SW.,
Washington, DC 20250–1034.
• Hand Delivery or Courier: 1250
Maryland Avenue, SW., Suite 400,
Washington, DC 20024.
• Federal eRulemaking Portal: Go to
https://www.regulations.gov. Follow the
online instructions for submitting
comments.
Comments may be inspected in Suite
400 of the Portals Building, 1250
Maryland Avenue, SW., Washington,
DC, between 8 a.m. and 4:30 p.m.,
Monday through Friday, except
holidays. A copy of this proposed rule
is available through the FAS home page
at https://www.fas.usda.gov/foodaid.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Babette Gainor at (202) 720–4221, or
e-mail: Babette.Gainor@fas.usda.gov.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
ADDRESSES:
7 CFR Part 1496—Procurement of
Commodities for Foreign Donation
This proposed rule amends the
current regulations governing the
procurement of commodities for use in
international food assistance and
developmental programs, and to move
those regulations to a different section
of the CFR.
Personnel of the Farm Service Agency
(FSA) acquire commodities for use by
the Foreign Agricultural Service (FAS)
for use in international food assistance
and developmental programs. These
commodities are procured in conformity
with the Federal Acquisition Regulation
(FAR), as supplemented by the AGAR
found in 48 CFR Chapter 4. In addition,
regulations at 7 CFR part 1496 set forth
provisions applicable to the acquisition
of commodities to carry out activities
under the McGovern-Dole Program,
FFPr Program, and Title II of the Food
For Peace Act, (Pub. L. 83–480, or
referred to as Pub. L. 480). Title II
procurements are done on behalf of the
PO 00000
Frm 00001
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
U. S. Agency for International
Development (USAID) by FSA. The
regulations at 7 CFR part 1496 were
amended at 72 FR 6450, on February 12,
2007, in order to adopt new procedures
regarding the evaluation of bids
submitted in the procurement of
commodities. This proposed rule would
move the current regulations at 7 CFR
part 1496 to a new part in the AGAR,
48 CFR Chapter 4, part 470, and delete
and revise obsolete provisions in 7 CFR
part 1496. This rule also proposes minor
‘‘housekeeping’’ changes to clarify those
regulations.
The substantive changes to this
section of the regulations proposed in
this rule are intended to make the
procurement process more efficient and
responsive. The U. S. Government
Accountability Office (GAO) issued a
report in April 2007, entitled FOREIGN
ASSISTANCE—Various Challenges
Impede the Efficiency and Effectiveness
of U.S. Food Aid. Among the findings in
this report is that current contracting
provisions produce a ‘‘bunching of
contracts’’ that result in increased
program costs (GAO Report, pg. 23).
USDA shares the overall concerns set
forth in the GAO report about the need
to improve efficiency in contracting to
improve program delivery and is
engaged in a continuing process to
revise its contracting procedures to have
the benefit of increased flexibility
afforded under the FAR. Accordingly,
this proposed rule would amend these
regulations to ensure that USDA may
fully utilize all types of acquisition
contracts that are authorized by the
FAR. And, as noted below, under this
proposed rule USDA would have the
option of procuring freight directly from
carriers as opposed to doing so
indirectly through program participants.
Such procurements would be done in
accordance with the FAR, including the
AGAR.
Changes to 7 CFR Parts 1499 and
1599—Foreign Donation Programs and
McGovern-Dole International Food for
Education and Child Nutrition Program
The regulations in 7 CFR part 1499,
Foreign Donation Programs, are used by
FAS, on behalf of the Commodity Credit
Corporation (CCC), in the
administration of the FFPr Program. The
regulations in 7 CFR part 1599,
McGovern-Dole International Food for
Education and Child Nutrition Program,
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
63388
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
are used by FAS in the administration
of the McGovern-Dole Program. Many of
the provisions of these regulations have
not been reviewed or updated since
their issuance in 1996 and 2001,
respectively. The changes proposed in
this rule are largely technical in nature
to improve the efficiency and
effectiveness of the programs. The
following is a discussion of the major
proposed amendments.
In 2006, FAS initiated an agency-wide
reorganization. Following the
completion of this reorganization in
2007, FAS began to evaluate how
programs are implemented in light of
the organizational changes. Concurrent
with this process, the GAO Report was
issued. As a result of this review, taking
into account the findings in the GAO
Report, USDA proposed changes to
these regulations that are designed to
improve the delivery of assistance under
these programs by removing obsolete
provisions; consolidating reporting
requirements applicable to participants;
and providing greater flexibility in the
settlement of claims that arise under the
program. For example, the proposed
rule would set forth with greater clarity
the responsibilities of a participant in
the event unanticipated actions occur
that involve the protection of
commodities provided to the participant
by FAS or CCC and would provide
greater latitude with respect to the
actions of the participant in such a
situation.
One of the criticisms in the GAO
report is related to the ‘‘lengthy claims
process’’ that exists under current
regulations (GAO Report, pg. 27). While
the report focused on transportation
claims, USDA is also concerned about
the timely resolution of all claims that
arise under the program. Under current
regulations, generally, for cargo claims:
(1) If the claim is less than $100 no
action is necessary; (2) if the claim is
between $100 and $300, no action is
necessary if the participant determines
that costs of collection would exceed
the likely recovery costs; (3) if the
recovery on a claim is less than $200,
the participant may retain the recovery;
and (4) if the recovery on a claim is
more than $200, the participant may
retain either $200 plus 10 percent of the
difference between $200 and the total
amount of the claim up to $500, or the
actual amount of collection costs
(excluding attorney fees and collection
agency fees). Other provisions of the
current regulations generally require
that a participant assign all rights to a
claim to FAS or CCC, as appropriate. In
most instances, all recoveries are
retained by one of these agencies except
in cases where the participant may have
expended its own funds for ocean
transportation, in which case the
recovery is shared with such
participant.
This process reflects neither the
actual costs of collection of claims nor
the logistical issues attendant to claims
that occur outside of the United States.
This process was instituted on the
premise that carriers and other entities
would be more likely to make payments
to the United States if a claim had been
assigned to it as opposed to requiring a
participant pursue collection. Also,
when this process was originally
established, the vast majority of food aid
shipments were in the form of bulk
commodities. Now, however, a
significant quantity of commodities is
shipped in containers and there is a
significant reduction in the dollar
amount of individual losses as such
losses are generally limited to one
container, or a small number of
containers, as opposed to losses in large
bulk grain shipments. The following
charts set forth cargo claim collection
activity for the FFPr Program and the
McGovern-Dole Program over the past
four fiscal years (note the amount of
recovery in a fiscal year represents
amounts recovered in that year for
claims established in that year and
preceding years):
FOOD FOR PROGRESS PROGRAM
Claims
collected
Fiscal year
2004
2005
2006
2007
Claims established (number)
.........................................................................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................................................................
$313,686
64,766
257,832
65,638
$468,747
20,414
369,215
126,098
(67)
(47)
(55)
(5)
4-Year Totals ....................................................................................................................................................
701,922
984,474
(174)
MCGOVERN-DOLE FOOD FOR EDUCATION AND CHILD NUTRITION PROGRAM
Claims
collected
Fiscal year
.........................................................................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................................................................
.........................................................................................................................................................................
$15,075
50,397
96,760
18,977
$19,792 (12)
56,824 (32)
106,925 (44)
20,989
(8)
4-year Totals .....................................................................................................................................................
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
2004
2005
2006
2007
Claims established (number)
181,209
204,530
Taking into account the small number
of claims and the extremely small
average amount of claims that were
established (FFPr Program—$5,657 and
McGovern-Dole Program—$2,230) and
the costs attributable for salaries and
expenses of USDA employees, this
current system is not cost-effective.
Further, with respect to non-cargo
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
claims, if such claims arise in a foreign
country after the liability of the carrier
ends, any litigation which may be
required to effectuate collection must be
brought in the country where the claim
arose. In such a situation, assignment of
the claim to FAS or CCC for collection
is simply not feasible.
PO 00000
Frm 00002
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
(96)
This process is predicated upon the
current manner in which freight
contracts are entered into for the
delivery of commodities made available
under FFPr Program and the McGovernDole Program. Generally, the current
regulations envision that the program
participant will be reimbursed for the
cost of obtaining freight and that the
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
freight contract is between the program
participant and the carrier. In reality, as
the programs have evolved over many
years, the program participant obtains
potential bids from prospective carriers
and these bids are provided to FSA
who, as set forth in 7 CFR part 1496,
utilizes a sophisticated computer
program to analyze the freight bids in
conjunction with the various bids
obtained in the procurement of
commodities to ascertain which
combination of carrier bids and
commodity bids produces the lowest
landed cost of delivery of the
commodity to a foreign destination.
Thus, the selection of the carrier bid
ultimately rests with USDA. Once the
carrier is determined, the program
participant executes, in most instances,
a contract with the carrier. As the
contract is between the carrier and the
program participant, any claim that the
participant has against the carrier is the
participant’s cause of action and not
that of CCC or FAS. The current
regulations provide that the program
participant must assign this private
cause of action to CCC or FAS as a
condition of program participation.
Questions have been raised concerning
whether the freight acquisition process
is compliant with the FAR and whether
CCC and FAS should be accepting
private causes of action for collection
purposes. Accordingly, this proposed
rule would provide that in obtaining
freight contracts, FAS or CCC, as
applicable, would obtain the freight
contracts in accordance with the FAR.
This would eliminate the need for any
program participant to assign a claim to
FAS or CCC. The regulations, as
amended, would also provide for the
option for FSA or CCC to allow a
program participant to obtain freight but
assignment of these claims would, as a
general rule, be eliminated. The
program participant would be
responsible for claim collections and
would be allowed to retain any recovery
of the claim, except the expenditure of
the recovered funds would be limited to
carrying out an activity authorized by
the program under which the
commodities had been provided to the
participant.
The current regulations for these
programs require all participants to
submit various reports to FAS on a
semi-annual basis and to file other
reports upon the occurrence of certain
events. These reports are required to be
filed in four different offices within FAS
and with two different offices within
FSA, and in some cases must also be
´
filed with the Agricultural Attache or
Agricultural Counselor of FAS with
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
responsibility for the country where the
agreement is implemented. In other
cases, a report is required only to be
´
filed with the Agricultural Attache or
Agricultural Counselor. Several of these
offices referred to in the regulations
have been either renamed or eliminated,
so the current regulations are obsolete.
Accordingly, this rule proposes to revise
these regulations to remove all
references to specific offices and a
generic reference to either FAS or CCC
would be used. The identification of the
location where a report would be
required to be filed would be specified
in the agreement. FAS expects that in
all, or substantially all, instances these
reports will be filed with one office in
FAS. To the extent other USDA officials
need the information contained in the
reports, FAS would be responsible for
dissemination of the material to
appropriate officials.
Further, in addition to streamlining
the location for reports submission, FAS
intends to incorporate a greater
emphasis on performance based
reporting which will allow FAS to
highlight the accomplishments achieved
by participants under food aid
programs, which will, in turn, allow
FAS to provide funding to those projects
that achieve greater results.
It has been the practice of FAS, acting
on behalf of CCC, to administer section
1110(h) of the Food For Progress Act
which addresses the prohibitions
against the resale and transshipment of
donated commodities to apply only to
the party with whom CCC directly
enters into an agreement. This means
that the participant is required to ship,
distribute and/or monetize (sell) the
donated commodities in the targeted
country. Once the initial distribution
and/or monetization transaction has
taken place by the participant, FAS
considers the program participant to be
in compliance with section 1110(h). In
accordance with section 1110(j) of this
Act, it has also been the practice of FAS
to permit multi-country agreements
under the programs whereby CCC
delivers donated commodities to one
country and activities to fulfill the
agreement objectives are carried out in
another. This rule proposes to amend
the regulations at 7 CFR part 1499 to
address these types of situations.
Previously, 7 CFR part 1499 had been
used to regulate and administer
activities authorized by Section 416(b)
of the Agricultural Act of 1949 (Section
416(b) program) in addition to the FFPr
Program. Reference to the Section 416(b)
Program has been removed from this
part due to the fact that in order for
activities to be conducted under this
program the Secretary of Agriculture
PO 00000
Frm 00003
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
63389
must determine that commodities will
be made available under Section 416(b).
Accordingly, FAS has determined that it
is more appropriate to announce any
future availability of commodities under
Section 416(b) through a Federal
Register notice. Upon the
announcement of commodity
availability for Section 416(b) activities,
FAS may decide to use this part to
administer such availability; this
decision also would be announced in
the Federal Register notice at that time.
Proposed New 48 CFR Part 470
The acquisition by USDA of
agricultural commodities and ocean
freight, along with other services, is
governed by procurement statutes
generally applicable to all activities of
USDA. The regulations used to
implement these statutes are set forth in
the FAR. But, there are several statutes
that contain provisions that are
specifically applicable to the
international food assistance and
development programs and domestic
food assistance programs.
With respect to the international
programs, section 402 of Pub. L. 480 sets
forth the definition of an ‘‘agricultural
commodity’’ for use under that Act and
the FFPr Act and section 3107(a) of the
Farm Security and Rural Investment Act
of 2002 sets forth a similar definition of
an ‘‘agricultural commodity.’’ Generally,
these two provisions require the use of
commodities produced in the United
States. A similar approach has
historically been used in the acquisition
of commodities for use in domestic
feeding programs. In some instances,
additives such as vitamins and spices
are not available from U.S sources and
in some instances the commodity which
is being procured is normally stored in
a commingled manner without any way
to ascertain the country of origin.
Accordingly, this rule proposes that the
AGAR would be revised to set forth in
48 CFR part 470 the definition of an
agricultural commodity and would
reflect the current practices of USDA in
this regard.
Commodities provided under the
FFPr Program and the McGovern-Dole
Program are delivered to foreign
destinations through the acquisition of
freight which is ultimately paid for from
funds from these programs. The
regulations at 7 CFR part 1496 require
that the government will determine
which combination of commodity bids
and bids for ocean freight rates results
in the lowest-landed cost of delivery of
the commodity to the foreign
destination. The government generally
will award the contact for the purchase
of the commodity that results in the
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
63390
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
lowest-landed cost and would be
transported in compliance with cargo
preference requirements under
regulations prescribed by the Maritime
Administration. ‘‘Lowest landed cost’’
refers to the requirement that, in the
delivery of U.S. agricultural
commodities under international food
assistance and developmental programs,
the United States shall generally use the
combination of ocean freight contracts
and commodity acquisition contracts
that results in the lowest cost of delivery
of the product to the desired
destination. This requirement is based
upon provisions in section 901(b) of the
Merchant Marine Act, 1936.
Accordingly, this specific provision of
law is used in the procurement of
freight and agricultural commodities
and, to the extent the provisions of this
section conflict with the more general
provisions of the Competition in
Contracting Act, the provisions of
section 901(b) of the Merchant Marine
Act, 1936 prevail.
The application of section 901(b) of
the Merchant Marine Act, 1936, when
considered with other provisions of that
Act, results in a complex review of
numerous offers for freight and
commodities. In a very simple example,
in the shipment of commodities, several
U.S. port locations may provide viable
services and the ocean freight contract
cost from one port may be less costly
than the cost of using two other U.S.
ports. However, the cost of delivery of
U.S. agricultural product to the U.S.
port with the lowest attendant freight
cost may be considerably greater than
the costs of delivery of the commodities
to other U.S. ports. Thus, in order to
ensure that the lowest total cost is
obtained, USDA reviews a myriad of
potential freight and commodity
contract costs for each delivery of
commodities to a foreign destination. In
order to have all USDA acquisition
related regulations in one location, 48
CFR Chapter 4, this proposed rule
would move the current regulations at 7
CFR part 1496 to 48 CFR part 470 but
the regulations would not be amended
regarding the current process used to
ascertain the lowest landed cost for
these contracts. Only the removal of
obsolete references and editorial
changes would be made.
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
Executive Order 12866
This proposed rule has been
determined to be not significant under
E.O. 12866, as amended by E.O. 13422,
and was therefore not reviewed by the
Office of Management and Budget
(OMB).
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
Regulatory Flexibility Act
Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995
The Regulatory Flexibility Act does
not apply to this rule because FAS is not
required by 5 U.S.C. 553 or any other
law to publish a notice of proposed
rulemaking with respect to the subject
of this.
In accordance with the Paperwork
Reduction Act of 1995, FAS has
previously received approval from the
Office of Management and Budget
(OMB) with respect to the information
collection required to support these
programs. The Information Collection is
described below:
Title: Food Donation Programs (Food
for Progress, Section 416(b), and
McGovern-Dole International Food for
Education and Child Nutrition).
OMB Control Number: 0551–0035.
Environmental Assessment
FAS has determined that this
proposed rule does not constitute a
major State or Federal action that would
significantly affect the human or natural
environment consistent with the
National Environmental Policy Act
(NEPA) 40 CFR part 1502.4, Major
Federal actions requiring the
preparation of Environmental Impact
Statements; and Compliance with NEPA
implementing the regulations of the
Council on Environmental Quality, 40
CFR parts 1500–1508. Therefore no
environmental assessment or
environmental impact statement will be
prepared.
Executive Order 12988
This rule has been reviewed under
E.O. 12988. This rule is not retroactive
and it does not preempt State or local
laws, regulations, or policies unless they
present an irreconcilable conflict with
this rule. This rule would not be
retroactive.
E-Government Act Compliance
FAS is committed to complying with
the E-Government Act, to promote the
use of the Internet and other
information technologies to provide
increased opportunities for citizen
access to Government information and
services, and for other purposes. The
forms, regulations, and other
information collection activities
required to be utilized by a person
subject to this rule are available at
https://www.fas.usda.gov.
List of Subjects
7 CFR Part 1496
Agricultural commodities, Food
assistance programs, Foreign aid,
Government procurement.
Executive Order 12372
7 CFR Part 1499
This program is not subject to E. O.
12372, which requires
intergovernmental consultation with
State and local officials. See the notice
related to 7 CFR part 3015, subpart V,
published at 48 FR 29115 (June 24,
1983).
Agricultural commodities, Food
assistance programs, Foreign aid.
Executive Order 13132
Government procurement, Reporting
and recordkeeping requirements.
For the reasons set out in the
preamble, under the authority of 5
U.S.C. 553; 15 U.S.C. 714b and 714c, 7
CFR parts 1496, 1499, 1599 and 48 CFR
part 470 are proposed to be amended as
follows:
The policies contained in this rule do
not have any substantial direct effect on
states, on the relationship between the
national government and the states, or
on the distribution of power and
responsibilities among the various
levels of government. Nor does this rule
impose substantial direct compliance
costs on state and local governments.
Therefore, consultation with the states
is not required.
Unfunded Mandates
Although we are publishing this as a
proposed rule, Title II of the Unfunded
Mandates Reform Act of 1995 (UMRA)
does not apply to this rule because FSA
and FAS are not required by 5 U.S.C.
553 or any other law to publish a notice
of proposed rulemaking for the subject
of this rule. Further, this rule contains
no unfunded mandates as defined in
sections 202 and 205 of UMRA.
PO 00000
Frm 00004
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
7 CFR Part 1599
Agricultural commodities, Exports,
Foreign aid.
48 CFR Part 470
PART 1496—[REMOVED]
1. 7 CFR part 1496 is removed.
2. Revise part 1499 to read as follows:
PART 1499—FOOD FOR PROGRESS
PROGRAM
Sec.
1499.1
1499.2
1499.3
1499.4
1499.5
1499.6
1499.7
1499.8
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
General statement.
Definitions.
Eligibility determination.
Application process.
Agreements.
Payments.
Transportation of goods.
Entry and handling of commodities.
24OCP1
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
1499.9 Damage to and loss of commodities.
1499.10 Claims for damage to or loss of
commodities.
1499.11 Use of commodities and sales
proceeds.
1499.12 Subrecipients.
1499.13 Recordkeeping and reporting
requirements.
1499.14 Noncompliance with an agreement.
1499.15 Suspension, termination, and
closeout of agreements.
1499.16 Appeals.
1499.17 Paperwork Reduction Act.
Authority: 7 U.S.C. 1736o; and 15 U.S.C.
714b and 714c.
§ 1499.1
General Statement.
(a) This part sets forth the general
terms and conditions governing the
donation of commodities by the
Commodity Credit Corporation (CCC) to
participants in the Food for Progress
Program (FFPr). Under FFPr,
participants use the donated
commodities or proceeds from the sale
of such commodities to implement
activities in a foreign country pursuant
to an agreement with CCC. The Foreign
Agricultural Service (FAS) of the
Department of Agriculture (USDA)
administers FFPr on behalf of CCC.
(b) In addition to the provisions of
this part, other regulations of general
application issued by USDA, including
the regulations set forth in Chapter 30
of this title, are applicable to the FFPr.
All provisions of the CCC Charter Act
(15 U.S.C. 714 et seq.) and any other
statutory provisions that are generally
applicable to CCC are applicable to FFPr
and the regulations set forth in this part.
(c) This part shall not apply to a
donation by CCC to a foreign
government or an intergovernmental
agency or organization (such as the
United Nations’ World Food Program)
under FFPr.
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
§ 1499.2
Definitions.
The following definitions are
applicable to this part:
Activity mean a project to be carried
out by a participant, directly or through
a subrecipient, to fulfill the objectives of
an agreement.
Agreement mean a legally binding
agreement entered into between CCC
and a participant to implement
activities under FFPr.
CCC mean the Commodity Credit
Corporation and includes any official of
the United States delegated the
responsibility to act on behalf of CCC.
Commodities mean U.S. agricultural
commodities or products of U.S.
agricultural commodities.
CCC-provided funds means U.S.
dollars provided under an agreement to
a participant for expenses for the
internal transportation, storage and
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
handling of the donated commodities,
expenses involved in the administration
and monitoring of the activities under
the agreement, and technical assistance
related to the monetization of donated
commodities.
Donated commodities means the
commodities donated by CCC to a
participant under an agreement. The
term may include donated commodities
that are used to produce a further
processed product for use under the
agreement.
FAS means the Foreign Agricultural
Service acting on behalf of CCC.
FFPr means the Food for Progress
Program.
Force majeure is a common clause in
contracts, exempting the parties for nonfulfillment of their obligations as a
result of conditions beyond their
control, such as earthquakes, floods or
war.
Income means interest earned on sale
proceeds and other resources received
by a participant, other than sale
proceeds, as a result of carrying out an
agreement. The term may include
resources from VAT refunds, activity
fees, interest on loans, and others.
Participant means an entity with
which CCC has entered into an
agreement.
Subrecipient means a legal entity that
receives donated commodities, income,
sale proceeds or other resources from a
participant for the purpose of
implementing in the targeted country
activities described in a FFPr agreement
and that is accountable to such
participant for the use of such
commodities, funds, or resources. The
term may include foreign or
international organizations (such as
agencies of the United Nations) at the
discretion of FAS.
Sale proceeds mean funds received by
a participant from the sale of donated
commodities.
Targeted country means the country
in which activities are implemented
under an agreement.
§ 1499.3
Eligibility determination.
(a) An entity will be eligible to
become a participant only after FAS
determines that the entity has:
(1) Organizational experience in
implementing and managing grants, and
the capability and personnel to develop,
implement, monitor, report on, and
provide accountability for activities in
accordance with this part;
(2) Experience working in the
proposed targeted country;
(3) Adequate financial framework to
implement the activities the entity
proposes to carry out under FFPr. In
order to determine whether the entity is
PO 00000
Frm 00005
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
63391
financially responsible, FAS may
require it to submit corporate policies
and financial materials that have been
audited or otherwise reviewed by a
third party;
(4) A person or agent located in the
United States with respect to which
service of judicial process may be
obtained by FAS on behalf of the entity;
and
(5) An operating financial account in
the proposed targeted country, or a
satisfactory explanation for not having
such an account and a description of
how a FFPr agreement would be
administered without such an account.
(b) In determining whether an entity
will be eligible to be a participant, FAS
may consider the entity’s previous
compliance or noncompliance with the
provisions of this part and part 1599 of
this title. FAS may consider matters
such as whether the entity corrected
deficiencies in the implementation of an
agreement in a timely manner and
whether the entity has timely and
accurately filed reports and other
submissions that are required to be filed
with FAS and other agencies of the
United States.
§ 1499.4
Application process.
(a) An entity seeking to enter into an
agreement with CCC shall submit an
application, in accordance with this
section, that sets forth its proposal to
carry out activities under FFPr in the
proposed target country. An application
shall contain the items specified in
paragraph (b) of this section and shall be
submitted electronically to FAS at the
address set forth at https://
www.fas.usda.gov. An entity that has
not yet met the eligibility requirements
in § 1499.3 may submit an application,
but FAS will not enter into an
agreement with an entity until FAS had
made a determination of eligibility
under § 1499.3.
(b) An applicant shall include the
following items in its application:
(1) A completed Form SF–424, which
is a standard application for Federal
assistance;
(2) An introduction that contains the
elements specified in paragraph (c) of
this section; and
(3) A plan of operation that contains
the elements specified in paragraph (d)
of this section.
(c) The introduction shall include:
(1) An explanation of the need for the
food aid in the targeted country and
how the applicant’s proposed activities
would address that need;
(2) Information regarding the
applicant’s ability to become registered
and operate in the targeted country;
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
63392
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
(3) Information about the applicant’s
past food aid projects; and
(4) A budget that details the amount
of any sale proceeds, income, and CCCprovided funds that the applicant
proposes to use to fund:
(i) Administrative costs;
(ii) Inland transportation, storage and
handling costs; and
(iii) Activity costs.
(d) A plan of operation shall include:
(1) The name of the targeted country
where the proposed activities would be
implemented;
(2) The kind, quantity, and proposed
use of the commodities requested, and
any commodities that would be
acceptable substitutions therefore, and
the proposed delivery schedule;
(3) If monetization or barter is
proposed:
(i) The quantity of the requested
commodities that would be sold or
bartered;
(ii) The amount of sale proceeds
anticipated;
(iii) The amount of income expected
to be generated;
(iv) The anticipated monetization
completion date;
(v) The goods or services to be
generated from the barter of the
requested commodities; and
(vi) The value of the goods or services
anticipated to be generated from the
barter of the requested commodities.
(4) A list of each of the activities that
would be implemented, with a brief
statement of the objectives to be
accomplished under each activity;
(5) For each proposed activity, the
targeted geographic area, anticipated
beneficiaries, and methods that the
applicant would use to choose such
beneficiaries, including obtaining and
considering statistics on poverty levels,
food deficits, and any other required
items set forth on the FAS Web site at
https://www.fas.usda.gov.
(6) For each proposed activity:
(i) An explanation of whether the
activity would be carried out through
the distribution of the requested
commodities or funded by sale
proceeds, income, or a combination
thereof; and
(ii) The amount of commodities, sale
proceeds, or income requested to carry
out such activity; and
(iii) A detailed description of the
activity, including the steps involved in
its implementation and the anticipated
completion date;
(7) Any cash or non-cash
contributions that the applicant expects
to receive from non-CCC sources that:
(i) Are critical to the implementation
of the proposed activities; or
(ii) Enhance the implementation of
the activities;
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
(8) Any subrecipient that would be
involved and a description of each
subrecipient’s responsibilities and its
capability to perform responsibilities;
(9) Any governmental or
nongovernmental entities that would be
involved and the extent to which FFPr
will strengthen or increase the
capabilities of such entities to further
economic development in the targeted
country;
(10) The method by which the
applicant intends to inform
beneficiaries of an activity about the
source of the requested commodities or
funding for the activity and, where the
beneficiaries will be receiving the
commodities directly, how to prepare
and use them properly;
(11) Established baselines, a timeline,
and proposed outcomes that would
enable FAS to measure the applicant’s
progress towards achieving the
objectives of proposed activities;
(12) If the proposed activities would
involve the use of sale proceeds or
income:
(i) The process that the applicant
would use to sell the requested
commodities, including steps the
applicant would take to use, to the
extent possible, the private sector in the
monetization process; and
(ii) The procedures that the applicant
would use to assure that sale proceeds
and income are received and deposited
into a separate, interest-bearing account
and disbursed from such account for use
only in accordance with the agreement;
(13) A description of how the
requested commodities would be
transported from the receiving port to
the point at which distribution is made
to the beneficiaries and a description of
any port, transportation, storage, and
warehouse facilities that would be used
with sufficient detail to demonstrate
that they would be adequate to handle
the requested commodities without
undue spoilage or waste;
(14) Any reprocessing or repackaging
of the requested commodities that
would take place prior to the
distribution, sale or barter by the
participant;
(15) The action the applicant would
take to ensure that any commodities to
be distributed to beneficiaries, rather
than sold, would be imported and
distributed free from all customs, duties,
tolls, and taxes;
(16) A plan that shows how the
requested commodities could be
imported and distributed without a
disruptive impact upon production,
prices and marketing of the same or like
products in the country where they will
be delivered, and the extent to which
any sale or barter of the requested
PO 00000
Frm 00006
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
commodities would displace or interfere
with any sales that may otherwise be
made by the applicant or any other
entity in the country where they will be
delivered; and
(17) Any additional required items set
forth on the FAS Web site at https://
www.fas.usda.gov.
§ 1499.5
Agreements.
(a) After FAS approves an applicant’s
proposal, FAS will develop an
agreement in consultation with the
applicant. The agreement will set forth
the obligations of CCC and the
participant. A participant must comply
with the terms of the agreement to
receive assistance.
(b) A participant shall not use
donated commodities, sale proceeds,
income or CCC-provided funds for any
activity or any expenses incurred by the
participant prior to the date of the
agreement or after the agreement is
suspended or terminated.
(c) The agreement will include a
budget that sets forth the maximum
amounts of sale proceeds and CCCprovided funds that may be expended
for various purposes under the
agreement. A participant may make
adjustments to this budget without prior
approval from FAS only as specified in
the agreement.
(d) Prior to providing any donated
commodities or CCC-provided funds to
a participant under an agreement, FAS
may require the participant to complete
a training program administered by FAS
that is designed to ensure that the
participant is aware of, and has the
capacity to complete all required
reporting and audit functions set forth
in this part.
(e) A participant will be prohibited
from using CCC-provided funds to
acquire goods and services either
directly or indirectly through another
party from certain countries that will be
specified in the agreement. Any
violation of this provision of the
agreement will be a basis for immediate
termination by CCC of the agreement in
addition to the imposition of any other
applicable civil and criminal penalties.
(f) The agreement will prohibit the
sale or transshipment of the donated
commodities to a country not specified
in the agreement for so long as such
donated commodities are controlled by
the participant.
(g) CCC may enter into a multicountry
agreement in which donated
commodities are delivered to one
country and activities are carried out in
another.
(h) CCC may provide donated
commodities and CCC-provided funds
under a multiyear agreement contingent
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
upon the availability of commodities
and funds.
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
§ 1499.6
Payments.
(a) If the participant arranges for
transportation in accordance with
§ 1499.7(b)(2), and the participant seeks
payment directly, the participant shall
submit the following documents to FAS
in the manner set forth in the
agreement:
(1) A signed copy of the completed
Form CCC–512;
(2) The original on-board bills of
lading indicating the freight rate and
signed by the originating carrier;
(3) For all non-containerized cargoes:
(i) A signed copy of the Federal Grain
Inspection Service (FGIS) Official
Stowage Examination Certificate (Vessel
Hold Certificate);
(ii) A signed copy of the National
Cargo Bureau Certificate of Readiness
(Vessel Hold Inspection Certificate; and
(iii) A signed copy of the National
Cargo Bureau Certificate of Loading;
(4) For all containerized cargoes a
copy of the FGIS Container Condition
Inspection Certificate;
(5) A signed copy of liner booking
note or charter party covering ocean
transportation of cargo;
(6) In the case of charter shipments,
a signed notice of arrival at first
discharge port, unless FAS has
determined that circumstances of force
majeure have prevented the vessel’s
arrival at the first port of discharge;
(7) A request by the participant for
reimbursement of freight, survey costs,
and other expenses approved by CCC
indicating the amount due and
accompanied by a certification from the
carrier or other parties that payments
have been received from the participant;
and
(8) A document on letterhead and
signed by an officer or agent of the
participant specifying the name of the
entity to receive payment; the bank ABA
number to which payment is to be
made; the account number for the
deposit at the bank; the participant’s
taxpayer identification number; and the
type of the account into which the
payment will be deposited.
(b) If the participant arranges for
transportation in accordance with
§ 1499.7(b)(2), and the participant has
used a freight forwarder, the participant
shall cause the freight forwarder to
submit the documents specified in
§ 1499.6(a) in order to receive payment
from CCC.
(c) In no case will CCC reimburse a
participant for demurrage costs or pay
demurrage to any other entity.
(d) If FAS has agreed to pay the costs
of transporting, storing, and distributing
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
the donated commodities from the
designated port or point of entry, the
participant will be reimbursed in the
manner as set forth in the agreement.
(e) If the agreement authorizes the
payment of CCC-provided funds, CCC
will pay this to the participant on a
reimbursement for expenses basis,
except as provided in paragraph (f)(1) of
this section. The participant shall
request the payment of CCC-provided
funds to reimburse it for authorized
expenses in the manner set forth in the
agreement.
(f)(1) A participant may request an
advance of the amount of funds
specified in the agreement. FAS will not
approve any request for an advance:
(i) Received earlier than 60 days after
the date of a previous advance made in
connection with the same agreement,
and
(ii) If any required reports, as
specified in § 1499.13 and in the
agreement, are more than six months in
arrears.
(2) Except as may otherwise be
provided in the agreement, the
participant shall deposit and maintain
in a bank account located in the United
States all funds advanced by CCC. The
account shall be interest-bearing, unless
the exceptions in § 3019.22(k) of this
title apply, or FAS determines that this
requirement would constitute an undue
burden. The participant shall remit
semi-annually to CCC any interest
earned on the advanced funds. The
participant shall, no later than 10 days
after the end of each calendar quarter,
submit a financial statement to FAS
accounting for all funds advanced and
all interest earned.
(3) The participant shall return to CCC
any funds that are advanced by CCC if
such funds have not been obligated as
of the 180th day after the advance was
made. Such funds and interest shall be
transferred to FAS within 30 days of
such date.
(g) If a participant is required to pay
funds to CCC in connection with an
agreement, the participant shall make
such payment in U.S. dollars, unless
otherwise approved in advance by FAS.
(h) Suppliers of commodities shall
seek payment for goods according to the
purchase contract with CCC.
§ 1499.7
Transportation of goods.
(a) Shipments of donated
commodities are subject to the
requirements of 46 U.S.C. 55305 and
55314, regarding carriage on U.S.-flag
vessels.
(b) Transportation of donated
commodities and other goods such as
bags that may be provided by CCC
under FFPr will be acquired under a
PO 00000
Frm 00007
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
63393
specific agreement in the manner
determined by FAS. Such transportation
will be acquired by:
(1) CCC in accordance with the
Federal Acquisition Regulations (FAR),
USDA’s procurement regulations set
forth in chapter 4 of title 48 of the Code
of Federal Regulations (the AGAR) and
directives issued by the Director, Office
of Procurement and Property
Management, USDA; or
(2) The participant, with
reimbursement by CCC, in the manner
specified in the agreement.
(c) Participants that acquire
transportation in accordance with
paragraph (b)(2) of this section, may use
the services of a licensed freight
forwarder that:
(1) Demonstrates at least three years
experience in freight forwarding and
booking services;
(2) Is accredited or authorized to act
as a licensed freight forwarder;
(3) Has the capability to work with the
participant to plan, implement, and
monitor the logistics involved in
transporting the donated commodities;
(4) Provides three years of audited
financial statements to the participant
that demonstrates sound financial
standing; and
(5) Would not have a conflict of
interest in carrying out the freight
forwarder duties. To assist FAS in
determining whether there is a potential
conflict of interest, the participant must
submit to FAS a certification indicating
that the freight forwarder:
(i) Is not engaged in, and will not
engage in, supplying commodities or
furnishing ocean transportation or ocean
transportation-related services for
commodities provided under the
participant’s Food for Progress program;
and
(ii) Is not affiliated with and not made
arrangements to give or receive any
payment, kickback, or illegal benefit in
connection with its selection as an agent
of the participant.
(d) Participants responsible for
transportation under § 1499.7(b)(2) shall
declare in the transportation contract
the point at which the ocean carrier to
take custody of commodity to be
transported.
§ 1499.8 Entry and handling of
commodities.
(a) The participant shall make all
necessary arrangements for receiving the
donated commodities in the targeted
country, including obtaining
appropriate approvals for entry and
transit. The participant shall store and
maintain the donated commodities in
good condition from the time of delivery
at the port of entry or the point of
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
63394
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
receipt from the originating carrier until
their distribution, sale or barter.
(b) The participant shall, as provided
in the agreement, arrange for
transporting, storing, and distributing
the donated commodities from the
designated point and time where title to
the commodity passes to the participant
by contracting directly with suppliers of
services, as set forth in the agreement.
(c)(1) If a participant arranges for the
packaging or repackaging of donated
commodities that are to be distributed,
the participant shall ensure that the
packaging:
(i) Is plainly labeled in the language
of the targeted country;
(ii) Contains the name of the donated
commodities;
(iii) Includes a statement indicating
that the donated commodities are
furnished by the people of the United
States of America; and
(iv) Includes a statement indicating
that the donated commodities shall not
be sold, exchanged or bartered.
(2) If a participant arranges for the
reprocessing and repackaging of
donated commodities that are to be
distributed, the participant shall ensure
that the packaging:
(i) Is plainly labeled in the language
of the targeted country;
(ii) Contains the name of the
reprocessed product;
(iii) Includes a statement indicating
that the reprocessed product was made
with commodities furnished by the
people of the United States of America;
and,
(iv) Includes a statement indicating
that the reprocessed product shall not
be sold, exchanged or bartered;
(3) If a participant distributes donated
commodities that are not packaged, the
participant shall, to the extent
practicable, display:
(i) Banners, posters or other media
informing the public of the name and
source of the donated commodities; and
(ii) A statement that the donated
commodities may not be sold,
exchanged, or bartered.
(d) A participant shall arrange with
the government of the targeted country
that all donated commodities to be
distributed will be imported and
distributed free from all customs, duties,
tolls, and taxes. A participant is
encouraged to make similar
arrangements, where possible, with the
government of the country where
donated commodities to be sold or
bartered are delivered.
§ 1499.9 Damage to or loss of
commodities.
(a) FAS will be responsible for the
donated commodities prior to the
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
transfer of title to the commodities to
the participant. The participant will be
responsible for the donated
commodities following the transfer of
title to the commodities to the
participant. The title will transfer at the
time and place specified in the
agreement.
(b) A participant shall immediately
inform FAS, in the manner set forth in
the agreement, of any damage to or loss
of the donated commodities that occurs
following the transfer of title to the
commodities to the participant. The
participant shall take all steps necessary
to protect its interests and the interests
of CCC with respect to any damage to
or loss of the donated commodities that
occurs after title has been transferred to
the participant.
(c) If the donated commodities are
damaged or lost during the time that
they are in the care of the carrier:
(1) And either FAS or the participant
engages the services of an independent
cargo surveyor, the surveyor will
provide to FAS and the participant any
report, narrative chronology or other
commentary that it prepares;
(2) FAS and the participant will
provide to each other the names and
addresses of any individuals known to
be present at the time of discharge or
during the survey who can verify the
quantity of damaged or lost
commodities;
(3) And the participant engages the
services of the surveyor, CCC will
reimburse the participant for the
reasonable costs, as determined by FAS,
of the survey, unless:
(i) The participant was required by
the agreement to pay for the survey;
(ii) The survey was a delivery survey
and the surveyor did not also prepare a
discharge survey; or
(iii) The survey was not conducted
contemporaneously with the discharge
of the vessel, unless FAS determines
that such action was justified under the
circumstances;
(4) Any survey obtained by the
participant shall, to the extent
practicable, be conducted jointly by the
surveyor, the participant, the carrier,
and the survey report shall be signed by
all parties;
(5) And the damage or loss occurred
with respect to a bulk grain shipment,
if the agreement provides that the
participant is responsible for survey and
outturn reports, the participant shall
obtain the services of an independent
cargo surveyor to:
(i) Observe the discharge of the cargo;
(ii) Report on discharging methods,
including scale type, calibrations and
any other factor that may affect the
accuracy of scale weights, and, if scales
PO 00000
Frm 00008
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
are not used, state the reason therefore
and describe the actual method used to
determine weight;
(iii) Estimate the quantity of cargo, if
any, lost during discharge through
carrier negligence;
(iv) Advise on the quality of
sweepings;
(v) Obtain copies of port or vessel
records, if possible, showing the
quantity discharged; and
(vi) Notify the participant
immediately if the surveyor has reason
to believe that the correct quantity was
not discharged or if additional services
are necessary to protect the cargo; and,
(6) And the damage or loss occurred
with respect to a container shipment, if
the agreement provides that the
participant is responsible for survey and
outturn reports, the participant shall
obtain the services of an independent
cargo surveyor to list the container
numbers and seal numbers shown on
the containers, indicate whether the
seals were intact at the time the
containers were opened, and note
whether the containers were in any way
damaged.
(d) If the value of any damaged
donated commodities is in excess of
$1,000, the participant shall
immediately arrange for an inspection
by a public health official or other
competent authority approved by FAS
and provide to FAS a certification by
such public health official or other
competent authority regarding the exact
quantity and condition of the damaged
commodities. The participant shall
inform FAS of the results of the
inspection and indicate whether the
damaged commodities are:
(1) Fit for the use authorized in the
agreement and, if so, whether there has
been a diminution in quality; or
(2) Unfit for the use authorized in the
agreement.
(e)(1) If the participant has title to the
donated commodities, the participant
shall arrange for the recovery of that
portion of the donated commodities
designated as suitable for the use
authorized in the agreement. The
participant shall dispose of donated
commodities that are unfit for such use
in the following order of priority:
(i) Sale for the most appropriate use,
i.e., animal feed, fertilizer, industrial
use, or another use approved by FAS, at
the highest obtainable price;
(ii) Donation to a governmental or
charitable organization for use as animal
feed or for other non-food use; or
(iii) Destruction of the commodities if
they are unfit for any use, in such
manner as to prevent their use for any
purpose.
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
(2) The participant shall arrange for
all U.S. Government markings to be
obliterated or removed before the
donated commodities are transferred by
sale or donation.
(f) A participant may retain any
proceeds generated by the disposal of
the donated commodities in accordance
with paragraph (e)(1) of this section, and
shall use the proceeds for expenses
related to the disposal of the donated
commodities and for activities specified
in the agreement.
(g) The participant shall notify FAS
immediately and provide detailed
information about the actions taken in
accordance with paragraph (e)(1) of this
section, including the quantities, values
and dispositions used to handle
commodities determined to be unfit.
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
§ 1499.10 Claims for damage to or loss of
commodities.
(a) FAS will be responsible for claims
arising out of damage to or loss of a
quantity of the donated commodities
prior to the transfer of title to the
commodities to the participant.
(b) If the value of the damaged or lost
donated commodities is estimated to be
$20,000 or more and the title to the
commodities has transferred to the
participant, the participant will be
responsible for:
(1) Initiating a claim arising out of
such damage or loss, including actions
relating to collections pursuant to
commercial insurance contracts; and
(2) Notifying FAS immediately and
providing detailed information about
the circumstances surrounding such
damage or loss, the quantity of damaged
or lost donated commodities, and the
value of the damage or loss.
(c) If the value of the damaged or lost
donated commodities is estimated to be
less than $20,000, the participant will
be responsible for providing detailed
information about the damage or loss in
the next report required to be filed
under § 1499.13(c) and shall not be
required to initiate a claim collection
action.
(d)(1) The value of a claim for lost
donated commodities shall be
determined on the basis of the
commodity acquisition, transportation,
and related costs incurred by CCC with
respect to such commodities.
(2) The value of a claim for damaged
donated commodities shall be
determined on the basis of the
commodity acquisition, transportation,
and related costs incurred by CCC with
respect to such commodities, less any
funds generated if such commodities are
sold in accordance with § 1499.9(e)(1).
(e) If FAS determines that a
participant is not exercising due
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
diligence in the pursuit of a claim, FAS
may require the participant to assign its
rights to pursue the claim to FAS.
(f)(1) The participant may retain any
funds obtained as a result of a claims
collection action initiated by it in
accordance with this section, or
recovered pursuant to any insurance
policy or other similar form of
indemnification, but such funds shall
only be expended for purposes
approved in advance by FAS.
(2) FAS will retain any funds obtained
as a result of a claims collection action
initiated by it under this section;
provided, however, that if the
participant paid for the freight or a
portion thereof, FAS will use a portion
of such funds to reimburse the
participant for such expense on a
prorated basis.
§ 1499.11 Use of commodities and sale
proceeds.
(a) A participant must use the donated
commodities in accordance with the
agreement.
(b) A participant shall not permit the
distribution, handling, or allocation of
donated commodities on the basis of
political affiliation, geographic location,
or the ethnic, tribal or religious identity
of affiliation of the potential consumers
or beneficiaries.
(c) A participant shall not permit the
distribution, handling, or allocation of
donated commodities by the military
forces or any government or insurgent
group without the specific authorization
of FAS.
(d) A participant may sell or barter
donated commodities only if such sale
or barter is provided for in the
agreement or the participant is
disposing of damaged commodities as
specified in § 1499.9. The participant
shall sell the donated commodities at a
reasonable market price in the economy
where the sale occurs. The participant
shall use any sale proceeds, income, or
goods or services derived from the sale
or barter of the donated commodities
only as provided in the agreement.
(e) The participant shall retain copies
of and make available to FAS all barter
receipts, contracts or other documents
related to the barter of the donated
commodities and the services or goods
derived from such barter, for a
minimum of 24 months after the
agreement has been terminated or
closed out.
(f) The participant shall deposit all
sale proceeds and income into a
separate, interest-bearing account unless
the exceptions in § 3019.22(k) of this
title apply, the account is in a country
where the laws or customs prohibit the
payment of interest, or FAS determines
PO 00000
Frm 00009
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
63395
that this requirement would constitute
an undue burden.
(g) A participant may use sale
proceeds or income to purchase real or
personal property only if local law
permits the participant to retain title to
such property. However, the participant
shall not use sale proceeds or income to
pay for the acquisition, development,
construction, alteration or upgrade of
real property that is:
(1) Owned or managed by a church or
other organization engaged exclusively
in religious pursuits; or
(2) Used in whole or in part for
sectarian purposes, except that a
participant may use sale proceeds or
income to pay for repairs to or
rehabilitation of a structure located on
such real property to the extent
necessary to avoid spoilage or loss of
donated commodities, but only if such
structure is not used in whole or in part
for any religious or sectarian purposes
while the donated commodities are
stored in it. If such use is not
specifically provided for in the
agreement, such use may only occur
after receipt of written approval from
FAS.
(h) A participant shall endeavor to
comply with §§ 3019.41 through
3019.43 of this title when procuring
goods and services and when engaging
in construction work to implement the
agreement. The participant shall also
establish procedures to prevent fraud.
The participant shall enter into a
written contract with each provider of
goods, services or construction work
that requires the provider to maintain
adequate records to account for all
donated commodities or funds or both
provided to the provider by the
participant and to submit periodic
reports to the participant. The
participant shall submit a copy of the
signed contracts to FAS.
§ 1499.12
Subrecipients.
(a) If provided for in the agreement, a
participant may utilize the services of a
subrecipient to implement activities
under this agreement. The participant
shall enter into a written subagreement
with the subrecipient, and provide a
copy of such subagreement to FAS, in
the manner set forth in the agreement,
prior to the transfer of any donated
commodities, sale proceeds, income or
CCC-provided funds to the subrecipient.
Such written subagreement shall require
the subrecipient to pay to the
participant the value of any donated
commodities, sale proceeds, income, or
CCC-provided cash funds that is not
used in accordance with the
subagreement, or are lost, damaged, or
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
63396
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
misused as a result of the subrecipient’s
failure to exercise reasonable care.
(b) If a participant demonstrates to
FAS that it is not feasible to enter into
a subagreement with a subrecipient,
FAS may grant approval to proceed
without a subagreement; provided,
however, that the participant must
obtain such approval from FAS prior to
transferring any donated commodities,
sale proceeds, income, or CCC-provided
funds to the subrecipient.
(c) The participant shall monitor the
actions of a subrecipient as necessary to
ensure that donated commodities or
funds provided to the subrecipient are
used for authorized purposes in
compliance with applicable laws and
regulations and the agreement and that
performance goals are achieved. The
participant shall provide in the
subagreement that the subrecipient must
comply with applicable provisions of
the regulations set forth in Chapter 30
of this title.
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
§ 1499.13 Recordkeeping and reporting
requirements.
(a) A program participant shall retain
records and permit access to records in
accordance with the requirements of
§ 3019.53 of this title. The date of
submission of the final expenditure
report, as referenced in § 3019.53(b) of
this title, shall be the final date of
submission of the forms required by
paragraphs (c)(1) and (2) of this section
as prescribed by FAS.
(b) A participant shall, within 30 days
after export of all or a portion of the
donated commodities, submit evidence
of such export to FAS, in the manner set
forth in the agreement. The evidence
may be submitted through an electronic
media approved by FAS or by providing
the carrier’s on board bill of lading. The
evidence of export must show the kind
and quantity of commodities exported,
the date of export, and the country
where commodities were delivered.
(c)(1) A participant shall submit to
FAS information, using a form as
prescribed by FAS, covering the receipt,
handling and disposition of the donated
commodities. Such report shall be
submitted to FAS, by the dates and for
the reporting periods specified in the
program agreement, until all of the
donated commodities have been
distributed, sold or bartered and such
disposition has been reported to FAS.
(2) If the agreement authorizes the
sale or barter of donated commodities,
the participant shall submit to FAS
information, using a form as prescribed
by FAS, covering the receipt and use of
sale proceeds and income, and in the
case of bartered commodities, covering
the services and goods derived from the
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
barter of donated commodities. Such
reports shall be submitted to FAS, by
the dates and for the reporting periods
specified in the agreement, until all of
the generated sales proceeds and
income have been disbursed and
reported to FAS. When reporting
financial information, the participant
shall include the amounts in U.S.
dollars and the exchange rate.
(3) The participant shall provide to
FAS additional information or reports
relating to the agreement if requested by
FAS.
(4) The participant shall report, in the
manner specified in the agreement, its
progress, measured against established
baselines, towards achieving the
objectives of the activities under the
agreement.
(d) A participant shall submit to FAS,
in the manner specified in the
agreement, an annual audit in
accordance with § 3019.26 of this title.
If FAS requires an audit with respect to
a particular agreement, and CCC
provides funds for this purpose,
participant shall arrange for such audit
and shall submit to FAS, in the manner
specified in the agreement, an annual
financial audit of the agreement.
(e)(1) A participant shall, as provided
in the agreement, submit to FAS interim
and final evaluations of the
implementation of the agreement.
Unless otherwise provided in the
agreement, the evaluations shall be
submitted at the mid-point and endpoint of the implementation period. The
participant shall arrange for the
evaluations to be conducted by an
independent third party that:
(i) Is financially and legally separate
from the participant’s organization;
(ii) Has staff with demonstrated
knowledge, analytical capability,
language skills and experience in
conducting evaluations of development
programs involving agriculture,
education, and nutrition;
(iii) Uses acceptable analytical
frameworks such as comparison with
non-project areas, surveys, involvement
of stakeholders in the evaluation, and
statistical analyses;
(iv) Uses local consultants, as
appropriate, to conduct portions of the
evaluation;
(v) Provides a detailed outline of the
evaluation, major task, and specific
schedules prior to initiating the
evaluation.
(2) Receipt by FAS of the evaluations
referred to in paragraph (1) of this
section, is a condition of retaining funds
received to carry out the evaluations.
(f) Participants shall submit to FAS
the financial reports and information
outlined in § 3019.52 of this title. The
PO 00000
Frm 00010
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
agreement will specify the acceptable
forms and time requirements for
submission.
§ 1499.14 Noncompliance with an
agreement.
If a participant fails to comply with a
term of an agreement, FAS may take one
or more of the enforcement actions set
forth in § 3019.62 of this title and, if,
appropriate, initiate a claim against the
participant. FAS may also initiate a
claim against a participant if the
donated commodities are damaged or
lost or the sale proceeds, income, of
CCC-provided funds are lost due to an
action or omission of the participant.
§ 1499.15 Suspension, termination, and
closeout of agreements.
(a) An agreement may be suspended
or terminated by CCC if it determines
that:
(1) The continuation of the assistance
provided under this agreement is no
longer necessary or desirable; or
(2) Storage facilities are inadequate to
prevent spoilage or waste, or
distribution of the donated commodities
will result in substantial disincentive to,
or interference with, domestic
production or marketing in the targeted
country.
(b) An agreement may be terminated
in accordance with § 3019.61 of this
title. If an agreement is terminated, the
participant shall:
(1) Be responsible for the safety of any
undistributed donated commodities and
dispose of such commodities only as
agreed to by FAS; and
(2) Follow the closeout procedures in
§§ 3019.71 through 3019.73 of this title
will apply to the closeout of an
agreement.
(c) An agreement will be considered
completed when CCC and the
participant have fulfilled their
responsibilities under the agreement or
the agreement has been terminated. The
procedures in §§ 3019.71 through
3019.73 of this title will apply to the
closeout of an agreement.
§ 1499.16
Appeals
A participant may appeal a
determination arising under this part to
FAS. Such appeal will be in writing and
submitted to the FAS official and in the
manner set forth in the agreement. The
participant will be given an opportunity
to have a hearing before a final decision
is made regarding its appeal.
§ 1499.17
Paperwork Reduction Act.
The information collection
requirements contained in this
regulation have been approved by the
Office of Management and Budget under
provisions of 44 U.S.C. Chapter 35 and
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
have been assigned OMB Numbers
0551–0035.
3. Revise part 1599 to read as follows:
PART 1599—McGOVERN-DOLE
INTERNATIONAL FOOD FOR
EDUCATION AND CHILD NUTRITION
PROGRAM
Sec.
1599.1 General statement.
1599.2 Definitions.
1599.3 Eligibility determination.
1599.4 Application process.
1599.5 Agreements.
1599.6 Payments.
1599.7 Transportation of goods.
1599.8 Entry and handling of commodities.
1599.9 Damage to and loss of commodities.
1599.10 Claims for damage to or loss of
commodities.
1599.11 Use of commodities and sales
proceeds.
1599.12 Subrecipients.
1599.13 Recordkeeping and reporting
requirements.
1599.14 Noncompliance with an agreement.
1599.15 Suspension, termination, and
closeout of agreements.
1599.16 Appeals.
1599.17 Paperwork Reduction Act.
Authority: 7 U.S.C. 1736o–1.
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
§ 1599.1
General Statement.
(a) This part sets forth the general
terms and conditions governing the
donation of commodities by the Foreign
Agricultural Service (FAS) to
participants in the McGovern-Dole
International Food for Education and
Child Nutrition Program (McGovernDole Program). Under the McGovernDole Program, participants use the
donated commodities, FAS-provided
funds, and/or proceeds from the sale of
donated commodities to implement
activities in a foreign country pursuant
to an agreement with FAS. In cases
where the agreement is funded with
Commodity Credit Corporation (CCC)
resources, the Foreign Agricultural
Service (FAS) of the Department of
Agriculture (USDA) will administer the
McGovern-Dole Program on behalf of
CCC.
(b) In addition to the provisions of
this part, other regulations of general
application issued by USDA, including
the regulations set forth in Chapter 30
of this title, are applicable to the
McGovern-Dole Program.
(c) This part shall not apply to a
donation by FAS to a foreign
government or an intergovernmental
agency or organization (such as the
United Nations’ World Food Program)
under the McGovern-Dole Program.
§ 1599.2
Definitions.
The following definitions are
applicable to this part:
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
Activity means a project to be carried
out by a participant, directly or through
a subrecipient, to fulfill the objectives of
an agreement.
Agreement means a legally binding
agreement entered into between FAS
and a participant to implement
activities under the McGovern-Dole
Program.
CCC means the Commodity Credit
Corporation and includes any official of
the United States delegated the
responsibility to act on behalf of CCC.
Commodities mean U.S. agricultural
commodities or products of U.S.
agricultural commodities.
FAS-provided funds mean U.S.
dollars provided under an agreement to
a participant for expenses for the
internal transportation, storage and
handling of the donated commodities,
expenses involved in the administration
and monitoring of the activities under
the agreement, expenses to carry out
activities that enhance the effectiveness
of the commodities, and technical
assistance to develop school feeding
programs and determine nutritional
composition of school meals.
Donated commodities mean the
commodities donated by FAS to a
participant under an agreement. The
term may include donated commodities
that are used to produce a further
processed product for use under the
agreement.
FAS means the Foreign Agricultural
Service of the United States Department
of Agriculture.
Force majeure is a common clause in
contracts, exempting the parties for nonfulfillment of their obligations as a
result of conditions beyond their
control, such as earthquakes, floods or
war.
Income means interest earned on sale
proceeds and other resources received
by a participant, other than sale
proceeds, as a result of carrying out an
agreement. The term may include
resources from VAT refunds, activity
fees, interest on loans, and others.
McGovern-Dole Program means the
McGovern-Dole International Food for
Education and Child Nutrition Program.
Participant means an entity with
which FAS has entered into an
agreement.
Sale proceeds mean funds received by
a participant from the sale of donated
commodities.
Subrecipient means a legal entity that
receives donated commodities, income,
sale proceeds or other resources from a
participant for the purpose of
implementing in the targeted country
activities described in a McGovern-Dole
Program agreement and that is
accountable to such participant for the
PO 00000
Frm 00011
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
63397
use of such commodities, funds, or
resources. The term may include foreign
or international organizations (such as
agencies of the United Nations) at the
discretion of FAS.
Targeted country means the country
in which activities are implemented
under an agreement.
§ 1599.3
Eligibility determination.
(a) An entity will be eligible to
become a participant only after FAS
determines that the entity has:
(1) Organizational experience in
implementing and managing grants, and
the capability and personnel to develop,
implement, monitor, report on, and
provide accountability for activities in
accordance with this part;
(2) Experience working in the
proposed targeted country;
(3) Adequate financial framework to
implement the activities the entity
proposes to carry out under McGovernDole Program. In order to determine
whether the entity is financially
responsible, FAS may require it to
submit corporate policies and financial
materials that have been audited or
otherwise reviewed by a third party;
(4) A person or agent located in the
United States with respect to which
service of judicial process may be
obtained by FAS on behalf of the entity;
and
(5) An operating financial account in
the proposed targeted country, or a
satisfactory explanation for not having
such an account and a description of
how a McGovern-Dole Program
agreement would be administered
without such an account.
(b) In determining whether an entity
will be eligible to be a participant, FAS
may consider the entity’s previous
compliance or noncompliance with the
provisions of this part and part 1499 of
this title. FAS may consider matters
such as whether the entity corrected
deficiencies in the implementation of an
agreement in a timely manner and
whether the entity has timely and
accurately filed reports and other
submissions that are required to be filed
with FAS and other agencies of the
United States.
§ 1599.4
Application process.
(a) An entity seeking to enter into an
agreement with FAS shall submit an
application, in accordance with this
section, that sets forth its proposal to
carry out activities under the McGovernDole Program in the proposed target
country. An application shall contain
the items specified in paragraph (b) of
this section, and shall be submitted
electronically to FAS at the address set
forth at https://www.fas.usda.gov. An
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
63398
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
entity that has not yet met the eligibility
requirements in § 1599.3 may submit an
application, but FAS will not enter into
an agreement with an entity until FAS
had made a determination of eligibility
under § 1599.3.
(b) An applicant shall include the
following items in its application:
(1) A completed Form SF–424, which
is a standard application for Federal
assistance;
(2) An introduction that contains the
elements specified in paragraph (c) of
this section; and
(3) A plan of operation that contains
the elements specified in paragraph (d)
of this section.
(c) The introduction shall include:
(1) An explanation of the need for the
food aid in the targeted country and
how the applicant’s proposed activities
would address that need;
(2) Reasons for the need for a school
feeding program in the targeted country,
including the following:
(i) Country’s current school feeding
operations, if they exist, length and
sessions of a typical school year, along
with current funding resources;
(ii) Any information regarding teacher
training, community infrastructure
(PTAs), health, nutrition, and water and
sanitation information;
(3) Information regarding the
applicant’s ability to become registered
and operate in the targeted country;
(4) Information about the applicant’s
past food aid projects;
(5) Methods used to involve
indigenous institutions as well as local
communities and governments in the
development and implementation of the
programs and activities to foster local
capacity building and leadership;
(6) A budget that details the amount
of any sale proceeds, income, and FASprovided funds that the applicant
proposes to use to fund:
(i) Administrative costs;
(ii) Inland transportation, storage and
handling costs; and
(iii) Activity costs;
(7) Provide a statement verifying the
government’s commitment to work
toward, through a national action plan,
the goals of the World Declaration on
Education for All convened in 1990 in
Jomtien, Thailand, and the follow-up
Dakar Framework for Action of the
World Education Forum, convened in
2000; and,
(8) Steps that will be taken to
continue the program activities after
termination of the program agreement to
address sustainability of all, or portions
of the program, including a description
of:
(i) How the program participant or
another entity will sustain the benefits
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
of education, enrollment, and
attendance of children in schools in the
targeted communities; and
(ii) The estimated time necessary for
the program to graduate and be
sustained by the recipient country or
other organizations without additional
assistance under the program.
(d) A plan of operation shall include:
(1) The name of the targeted country
where the proposed activities would be
implemented;
(2) The kind, quantity, and proposed
use of the commodities requested, and
any commodities that would be
acceptable substitutions therefore, and
the proposed delivery schedule;
(3) If monetization or barter is
proposed:
(i) The quantity of the requested
commodities that would be sold or
bartered;
(ii) The amount of sale proceeds
anticipated;
(iii) The amount of income expected
to be generated;
(iv) The anticipated monetization
completion date;
(v) The goods or services to be
generated from the barter of the
requested commodities;
(vi) The value of the goods or services
anticipated to be generated from the
barter of the requested commodities;
and
(vii) A justification of why
monetization provides a greater benefit
to the program than the receipt of FASprovided funds to carry out activities.
(4) A list of each of the activities that
would be implemented, with a brief
statement of the objectives to be
accomplished under each activity;
(5) For each proposed activity, the
targeted geographic area, anticipated
beneficiaries, and methods that the
applicant would use to choose such
beneficiaries, including obtaining and
considering statistics on poverty levels,
food deficits, literacy rates, and any
other required items set forth on the
FAS Web site at https://
www.fas.usda.gov.
(6) For each proposed activity:
(i) An explanation of whether the
activity would be carried out through
the distribution of the requested
commodities or funded by FASprovided funds, sale proceeds, income,
or a combination thereof; and
(ii) The amount of commodities, FASprovided funds, sale proceeds, or
income requested to carry out such
activity; and
(iii) A detailed description of the
activity, including the steps involved in
its implementation and the anticipated
completion date;
PO 00000
Frm 00012
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
(7) Any cash or non-cash
contributions that the applicant expects
to receive from non-FAS sources that:
(i) Are critical to the implementation
of the proposed activities; or
(ii) Enhance the implementation of
the activities;
(8) Any subrecipient that would be
involved and a description of each
subrecipient’s responsibilities and its
capability to perform responsibilities;
(9) Any governmental or
nongovernmental entities that would be
involved and the extent to which the
McGovern-Dole Program will strengthen
or increase the capabilities of such
entities to further educational and
economic development in the targeted
country;
(10) The method by which the
applicant intends to inform
beneficiaries of an activity about the
source of the requested commodities or
funding for the activity and, where the
beneficiaries will be receiving the
commodities directly, how to prepare
and use them properly;
(11) Established baselines, a timeline,
and proposed outcomes that would
enable FAS to measure the applicant’s
progress towards achieving the
objectives of proposed activities and the
McGovern-Dole Program objective that
include:
(i) Increased enrollment and
attendance rates, especially for girls;
(ii) Improved student achievement
levels through improvements in the
learning environment;
(iii) Improved maternal, child and
student health and nutrition;
(iv) Attracting non-FAS contributions
to development activities;
(v) Enabling community support for
infrastructure development; and
(vi) Increased government and
community support in education;
(12) If the proposed activities would
involve the use of sale proceeds or
income:
(i) The process that the applicant
would use to sell the requested
commodities, including steps the
applicant would take to use, to the
extent possible, the private sector in the
monetization process; and
(ii) The procedures that the applicant
would use to assure that sale proceeds
and income are received and deposited
into a separate, interest-bearing account
and disbursed from such account for use
only in accordance with the agreement;
(13) A description of how the
requested commodities would be
transported from the receiving port to
the point at which distribution is made
to the beneficiaries and a description of
any port, transportation, storage, and
warehouse facilities that would be used
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
with sufficient detail to demonstrate
that they would be adequate to handle
the requested commodities without
undue spoilage or waste;
(14) Any reprocessing or repackaging
of the requested commodities that
would take place prior to the
distribution, sale or barter by the
participant;
(15) The action the applicant would
take to ensure that any commodities to
be distributed to beneficiaries, rather
than sold, would be imported and
distributed free from all customs, duties,
tolls, and taxes;
(16) A plan that shows how the
requested commodities could be
imported and distributed without a
disruptive impact upon production,
prices and marketing of the same or like
products in the country where they will
be delivered, and the extent to which
any sale or barter of the requested
commodities would displace or interfere
with any sales that may otherwise be
made by the applicant or any other
entity in the country where they will be
delivered; and
(17) Any additional required items set
forth on the FAS Web site at https://
www.fas.usda.gov.
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
§ 1599.5
Agreements.
(a) After FAS approves an applicant’s
proposal, FAS will develop an
agreement in consultation with the
applicant. The agreement will set forth
the obligations of FAS and the
participant. A participant must comply
with the terms of the agreement to
receive assistance.
(b) A participant shall not use
donated commodities, sale proceeds,
income or FAS-provided funds for any
activity or any expenses incurred by the
participant prior to the date of the
agreement or after the agreement is
suspended or terminated.
(c) The agreement will include a
budget that sets forth the maximum
amounts of sale proceeds and FASprovided funds that may be expended
for various purposes under the
agreement. A participant may make
adjustments to this budget without prior
approval from FAS only as specified in
the agreement.
(d) Prior to providing any donated
commodities or FAS-provided funds to
a participant under an agreement, FAS
may require the participant to complete
a training program administered by FAS
that is designed to ensure that the
participant is aware of, and has the
capacity to complete all required
reporting and audit functions set forth
in this part.
(e) A participant will be prohibited
from using FAS-provided funds to
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
acquire goods and services either
directly or indirectly through another
party from certain countries that will
specified in the agreement. Any
violation of this provision of the
agreement will be a basis for immediate
termination by FAS of the agreement in
addition to the imposition of any other
applicable civil and criminal penalties.
(f) The agreement will prohibit the
sale or transshipment of the donated
commodities to a country not specified
in the agreement for so long as such
donated commodities are controlled by
the participant.
(g) FAS may enter into a multicountry
agreement in which donated
commodities are delivered to one
country and activities are carried out in
another.
(h) FAS may provide donated
commodities and FAS-provided funds
under a multiyear agreement contingent
upon the availability of commodities
and funds.
§ 1599.6
Payments.
(a) If the participant arranges for
transportation in accordance with
§ 1599.7(b)(2), and the participant seeks
payment directly, the participant shall
submit the following documents to FAS
in the manner set forth in the
agreement:
(1) A signed copy of the completed
Form CCC–512;
(2) The original on-board bills of
lading indicating the freight rate and
signed by the originating carrier;
(3) For all non-containerized cargoes:
(i) A signed copy of the Federal Grain
Inspection Service (FGIS) Official
Stowage Examination Certificate (Vessel
Hold Certificate);
(ii) A signed copy of the National
Cargo Bureau Certificate of Readiness
(Vessel Hold Inspection Certificate);
and,
(iii) A signed copy of the National
Cargo Bureau Certificate of Loading;
(4) For all containerized cargoes s
copy of the FGIS Container Condition
Inspection Certificate;
(5) A signed copy of liner booking
note or charter party covering ocean
transportation of cargo;
(6) In the case of charter shipments,
a signed notice of arrival at first
discharge port, unless FAS has
determined that circumstances of force
majeure have prevented the vessel’s
arrival at the first port of discharge;
(7) A request by the participant for
reimbursement of freight, survey costs,
and other expenses approved by FAS
indicating the amount due and
accompanied by a certification from the
carrier or other parties that payments
have been received from the participant;
and
PO 00000
Frm 00013
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
63399
(8) A document on letterhead and
signed by an officer or agent of the
participant specifying the name of the
entity to receive payment; the bank ABA
number to which payment is to be
made; the account number for the
deposit at the bank; the participant’s
taxpayer identification number; and the
type of the account into which the
payment will be deposited.
(b) If the participant arranges for
transportation in accordance with
§ 1599.7(b)(2), and the participant has
used a freight forwarder, the participant
shall cause the freight forwarder to
submit the documents specified in
§ 1599.6(a) in order to receive payment
from FAS.
(c) In no case will FAS reimburse a
participant for demurrage costs or pay
demurrage to any other entity.
(d) If FAS has agreed to pay the costs
of transporting, storing, and distributing
the donated commodities from the
designated port or point of entry, the
participant will be reimbursed in the
manner as set forth in the agreement.
(e) If the agreement authorizes the
payment of FAS-provided funds, FAS
will pay this to the participant on a
reimbursement for expenses basis,
except as provided in paragraph (f)(1) of
this section. The participant shall
request the payment of FAS-provided
funds to reimburse it for authorized
expenses in the manner set forth in the
agreement.
(f)(1) A participant may request an
advance of the amount of funds
specified in the agreement. FAS will not
approve any request for an advance:
(i) Received earlier than 60 days after
the date of a previous advance made in
connection with the same agreement,
and
(ii) If any required reports, as
specified in § 1499.13 and in the
agreement, are more than six months in
arrears.
(2) Except as may otherwise be
provided in the agreement, the
participant shall deposit and maintain
in a bank account located in the United
States all funds advanced by FAS. The
account shall be interest-bearing, unless
the exceptions in § 3019.22(k) of this
title apply, or FAS determines that this
requirement would constitute an undue
burden. The participant shall remit
semi-annually to FAS any interest
earned on the advanced funds. The
participant shall, no later than 10 days
after the end of each calendar quarter,
submit a financial statement to FAS
accounting for all funds advanced and
all interest earned.
(3) The participant shall return to FAS
any funds that are advanced by FAS if
such funds have not been obligated as
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
63400
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
of the 180th day after the advance was
made. Such funds and interest shall be
transferred to FAS within 30 days of
such date.
(g) If a participant is required to pay
funds to FAS in connection with an
agreement, the participant shall make
such payment in U.S. dollars, unless
otherwise approved in advance by FAS.
(h) Suppliers of commodities shall
seek payment for goods according to the
purchase contract.
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
§ 1599.7
Transportation of goods.
(a) Shipments of donated
commodities are subject to the
requirements of 46 U.S.C. 55305 and
55314, regarding carriage on U.S.-flag
vessels.
(b) Transportation of donated
commodities and other goods such as
bags that may be provided by FAS
under the McGovern-Dole Program will
be acquired under a specific agreement
in the manner determined by FAS. Such
transportation will be acquired by:
(1) FAS in accordance with the
Federal Acquisition Regulations (FAR),
USDA’s procurement regulations set
forth in chapter 4 of title 48 of the Code
of Federal Regulations (the AGAR) and
directives issued by the Director, Office
of Procurement and Property
Management, USDA; or
(2) The participant, with
reimbursement by FAS, in the manner
specified in the agreement.
(c) Participants that acquire
transportation in accordance with
paragraph (b)(2) of this section, may use
the services of a licensed freight
forwarder that:
(1) Demonstrates at least three years
experience in freight forwarding and
booking services;
(2) Is accredited or authorized to act
as a licensed freight forwarder;
(3) Has the capability to work, with
the participant to plan, implement, and
monitor the logistics involved in
transporting the donated commodities;
(4) Provides three years of audited
financial statements to the participant
that demonstrates sound financial
standing; and
(5) Would not have a conflict of
interest in carrying out the freight
forwarder duties. To assist FAS in
determining whether there is a potential
conflict of interest, the participant must
submit to FAS a certification indicating
that the freight forwarder:
(i) Is not engaged in, and will not
engage in, supplying commodities or
furnishing ocean transportation or ocean
transportation-related services for
commodities provided under the
participant’s McGovern-Dole program;
and
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
(ii) Is not affiliated with and not made
arrangements to give or receive any
payment, kickback, or illegal benefit in
connection with its selection as an agent
of the participant.
(d) Participants responsible for
transportation under § 1599.7(b)(2) shall
declare in the transportation contract
the point at which the ocean carrier is
to take custody of commodity to be
transported.
§ 1599.8 Entry and handling of
commodities.
(a) The participant shall make all
necessary arrangements for receiving the
donated commodities in the targeted
country, including obtaining
appropriate approvals for entry and
transit. The participant shall store and
maintain the donated commodities in
good condition from the time of delivery
at the port of entry or the point of
receipt from the originating carrier until
their distribution, sale or barter.
(b) The participant shall, as provided
in the agreement, arrange for
transporting, storing, and distributing
the donated commodities from the
designated point and time where title to
the commodity passes to the participant
or by contracting directly with suppliers
of services, as set forth in the agreement.
(c)(1) If a participant arranges for the
packaging or repackaging of donated
commodities that are to be distributed,
the participant shall ensure that the
packaging:
(i) Is plainly labeled in the language
of the targeted country;
(ii) Contains the name of the donated
commodities;
(iii) Includes a statement indicating
that the donated commodities are
furnished by the people of the United
States of America; and
(iv) Includes a statement indicating
that the donated commodities shall not
be sold, exchanged or bartered.
(2) If a participant arranges for the
reprocessing and repackaging of
donated commodities that are to be
distributed, the participant shall ensure
that the packaging:
(i) Is plainly labeled in the language
of the targeted country;
(ii) Contains the name of the
reprocessed product;
(iii) Includes a statement indicating
that the reprocessed product was made
with commodities furnished by the
people of the United States of America;
and.
(iv) Includes a statement indicating
that the reprocessed product shall not
be sold, exchanged or bartered;
(3) If a participant distributes donated
commodities that are not packaged, the
participant shall, to the extent
practicable, display:
PO 00000
Frm 00014
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
(i) Banners, posters or other media
informing the public of the name and
source of the donated commodities; and
(ii) A statement that the donated
commodities may not be sold,
exchanged, or bartered.
(e) A participant shall arrange with
the government of the targeted country
that all donated commodities to be
distributed will be imported and
distributed free from all customs, duties,
tolls, and taxes. A participant is
encouraged to make similar
arrangements, where possible, with the
government of the country where
donated commodities to be sold or
bartered are delivered.
§ 1599.9 Damage to or loss of
commodities.
(a) FAS will be responsible for the
donated commodities prior to the
transfer of title to the commodities to
the participant. The participant will be
responsible for the donated
commodities following the transfer of
title to the commodities to the
participant. The title will transfer at the
time specified in the agreement.
(b) A participant shall immediately
inform FAS, in the manner set forth in
the agreement, of any damage to or loss
of the donated commodities that occurs
following the transfer of title to the
commodities to the participant. The
participant shall take all steps necessary
to protect its interests and the interests
of FAS with respect to any damage to
or loss of the donated commodities that
occurs after title has been transferred to
the participant.
(c) If the donated commodities are
damaged or lost during the time that
they are in the care of the carrier:
(1) And either FAS or the participant
engages the services of an independent
cargo surveyor, the surveyor will
provide to FAS and the participant any
report, narrative chronology or other
commentary that it prepares;
(2) FAS and the participant will
provide to each other the names and
addresses of any individuals known to
be present at the time of discharge or
during the survey who can verify the
quantity of damaged or lost
commodities;
(3) And the participant engages the
services of the surveyor; FAS will
reimburse the participant for the
reasonable costs, as determined by FAS,
of the survey, unless:
(i) The participant was required by
the agreement to pay for the survey;
(ii) The survey was a delivery survey
and the surveyor did not also prepare a
discharge survey; or
(iii) The survey was not conducted
contemporaneously with the discharge
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
of the vessel, unless FAS determines
that such action was justified under the
circumstances;
(4) Any survey obtained by the
participant shall, to the extent
practicable, be conducted jointly by the
surveyor, the participant, the carrier,
and the survey report shall be signed by
all parties;
(5) And the damage or loss occurred
with respect to a bulk grain shipment,
if the agreement provides that the
participant is responsible for survey and
outturn reports, the participant shall
obtain the services of an independent
cargo surveyor to:
(i) Observe the discharge of the cargo;
(ii) Report on discharging methods,
including scale type, calibrations and
any other factor that may affect the
accuracy of scale weights, and, if scales
are not used, state the reason therefore
and describe the actual method used to
determine weight;
(iii) Estimate the quantity of cargo, if
any, lost during discharge through
carrier negligence;
(iv) Advise on the quality of
sweepings;
(v) Obtain copies of port or vessel
records, if possible, showing the
quantity discharged; and
(vi) Notify the participant
immediately if the surveyor has reason
to believe that the correct quantity was
not discharged or if additional services
are necessary to protect the cargo; and
(6) And the damage or loss occurred
with respect to a container shipment, if
the agreement provides that the
participant is responsible for survey and
outturn reports, the participant shall
obtain the services of an independent
cargo surveyor to list the container
numbers and seal numbers shown on
the containers, indicate whether the
seals were intact at the time the
containers were opened, and note
whether the containers were in any way
damaged.
(d) If the value of any damaged
donated commodities is in excess of
$1,000, the participant shall
immediately arrange for an inspection
by a public health official or other
competent authority approved by FAS
and provide to FAS a certification by
such public health official or other
competent authority regarding the exact
quantity and condition of the damaged
commodities. The participant shall
inform FAS of the results of the
inspection and indicate whether the
damaged commodities are:
(1) Fit for the use authorized in the
agreement and, if so, whether there has
been a diminution in quality; or
(2) Unfit for the use authorized in the
agreement.
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
(e)(1) If the participant has title to the
donated commodities, the participant
shall arrange for the recovery of that
portion of the donated commodities
designated as suitable for the use
authorized in the agreement. The
participant shall dispose of donated
commodities that are unfit for such use
in the following order of priority:
(i) Sale for the most appropriate use,
i.e., animal feed, fertilizer, industrial
use, or another use approved by FAS, at
the highest obtainable price;
(ii) Donation to a governmental or
charitable organization for use as animal
feed or for other non-food use; or
(iii) Destruction of the commodities if
they are unfit for any use, in such
manner as to prevent their use for any
purpose.
(2) The participant shall arrange for
all U.S. Government markings to be
obliterated or removed before the
donated commodities are transferred by
sale or donation.
(f) A participant may retain any
proceeds generated by the disposal of
the donated commodities in accordance
with paragraph (e) of this section, and
shall use the proceeds for expenses
related to the disposal of the donated
commodities and for activities specified
in the agreement.
(g) The participant shall notify FAS
immediately and provide detailed
information about the actions taken in
accordance with paragraph (e) of this
section, including the quantities, values
and dispositions used to handle
commodities determined to be unfit.
§ 1599.10 Claims for damage to or loss of
commodities.
(a) FAS will be responsible for claims
arising out of damage to or loss of a
quantity of the donated commodities
prior to the transfer of title to the
commodities to the participant.
(b) If the value of the damaged or lost
donated commodities is estimated to be
$20,000 or more and the title to the
commodities has transferred to the
participant, the participant will be
responsible for:
(1) Initiating a claim arising out of
such damage or loss, including actions
relating to collections pursuant to
commercial insurance contracts; and
(2) Notifying FAS immediately and
providing detailed information about
the circumstances surrounding such
damage or loss, the quantity of damaged
or lost donated commodities, and the
value of the damage or loss.
(c) If the value of the damaged or lost
donated commodities is estimated to be
less than $20,000, the participant will
be responsible for providing detailed
information about the damage or loss in
PO 00000
Frm 00015
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
63401
the next report required to be filed
under § 1599.13(c) and shall not be
required to initiate a claim collection
action.
(d)(1) The value of a claim for lost
donated commodities shall be
determined on the basis of the
commodity acquisition, transportation,
and related costs incurred by FAS with
respect to such commodities.
(2) The value of a claim for damaged
donated commodities shall be
determined on the basis of the
commodity acquisition, transportation,
and related costs incurred by FAS with
respect to such commodities, less any
funds generated if such commodities are
sold in accordance with § 1599.9(e)(1).
(e) If FAS determines that a
participant is not exercising due
diligence in the pursuit of a claim, FAS
may require the participant to assign its
rights to pursue the claim to FAS.
(f)(1) The participant may retain any
funds obtained as a result of a claims
collection action initiated by it in
accordance with this section, or
recovered pursuant to any insurance
policy or other similar form of
indemnification, but such funds shall
only be expended for purposes
approved in advance by FAS.
(2) FAS will retain any funds obtained
as a result of a claims collection action
initiated by it under this section;
provided, however, that if the
participant paid for the freight or a
portion thereof, FAS will use a portion
of such funds to reimburse the
participant for such expense on a
prorated basis.
§ 1599.11 Use of commodities and sale
proceeds.
(a) A participant must use the donated
commodities in accordance with the
agreement.
(b) A participant shall not permit the
distribution, handling, or allocation of
donated commodities on the basis of
political affiliation, geographic location,
or the ethnic, tribal or religious identity
of affiliation of the potential consumers
or beneficiaries.
(c) A participant shall not permit the
distribution, handling, or allocation of
donated commodities by the military
forces or any government or insurgent
group without the specific authorization
of FAS.
(d) A participant may sell or barter
donated commodities only if such sale
or barter is provided for in the
agreement or the participant is
disposing of damaged commodities as
specified in § 1599.9. The participant
shall sell the donated commodities at a
reasonable market price in the economy
where the sale occurs. The participant
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
63402
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
shall use any sale proceeds, income, or
goods or services derived from the sale
or barter of the donated commodities
only as provided in the agreement.
(e) The participant shall retain copies
of and make available to FAS all barter
receipts, contracts or other documents
related to the barter of the donated
commodities and the services or goods
derived from such barter, for a
minimum of 24 months after the
agreement has been terminated or
closed out.
(f) The participant shall deposit all
sale proceeds and income into a
separate, interest-bearing account unless
the exceptions in § 3019.22(k) of this
title apply, the account is in a country
where the laws or customs prohibit the
payment of interest, or FAS determines
that this requirement would constitute
an undue burden.
(g) A participant may use sale
proceeds or income to purchase real or
personal property only if local law
permits the participant to retain title to
such property. However, the participant
shall not use sale proceeds or income to
pay for the acquisition, development,
construction, alteration or upgrade of
real property that is:
(1) Owned or managed by a church or
other organization engaged exclusively
in religious pursuits; or
(2) Used in whole or in part for
sectarian purposes, except that a
participant may use sale proceeds or
income to pay for repairs to or
rehabilitation of a structure located on
such real property to the extent
necessary to avoid spoilage or loss of
donated commodities, but only if such
structure is not used in whole or in part
for any religious or sectarian purposes
while the donated commodities are
stored in it. If such use is not
specifically provided for in the
agreement, such use may only occur
after receipt of written approval from
FAS.
(h) A participant shall endeavor to
comply with §§ 3019.41 through
3019.43 of this title when procuring
goods and services and when engaging
in construction work to implement the
agreement. The participant shall also
establish procedures to prevent fraud.
The participant shall enter into a
written contract with each provider of
goods, services or construction work
that requires the provider to maintain
adequate records to account for all
donated commodities or funds or both
provided to the provider by the
participant and to submit periodic
reports to the participant. The
participant shall submit a copy of the
signed contracts to FAS.
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
§ 1599.12
Subrecipients.
(a) If provided for in the agreement, a
participant may utilize the services of a
subrecipient to implement activities
under this agreement. The participant
shall enter into a written subagreement
with the subrecipient, and provide a
copy of such subagreement to FAS, in
the manner set forth in the agreement,
prior to the transfer of any donated
commodities, sale proceeds, income or
FAS-provided funds to the subrecipient.
Such written subagreement shall require
the subrecipient to pay to the
participant the value of any donated
commodities, sale proceeds, income, or
FAS-provided cash funds that is not
used in accordance with the
subagreement, or are lost, damaged, or
misused as a result of the subrecipient’s
failure to exercise reasonable care.
(b) If a participant demonstrates to
FAS that it is not feasible to enter into
a subagreement with a subrecipient,
FAS may grant approval to proceed
without a subagreement; provided,
however, that the participant must
obtain such approval from FAS prior to
transferring any donated commodities,
sale proceeds, income, or FAS-provided
funds to the subrecipient.
(c) The participant shall monitor the
actions of a subrecipient as necessary to
ensure that donated commodities or
funds provided to the subrecipient are
used for authorized purposes in
compliance with applicable laws and
regulations and the agreement and those
performance goals are achieved. The
participant shall provide in the
subagreement that the subrecipient must
comply with applicable provisions of
the regulations set forth in Chapter 30
of this title.
§ 1599.13 Recordkeeping and reporting
requirements.
(a) A program participant shall retain
records and permit access to records in
accordance with the requirements of
§ 3019.53 of this title. The date of
submission of the final expenditure
report, as referenced in § 3019.53(b) of
this title, shall be the final date of
submission of the forms required by
paragraphs (c)(1) and (2) of this section,
as prescribed by FAS.
(b) A participant shall, within 30 days
after export of all or a portion of the
donated commodities, submit evidence
of such export to FAS, in the manner set
forth in the agreement. The evidence
may be submitted through an electronic
media approved by FAS or by providing
the carrier’s on board bill of lading. The
evidence of export must show the kind
and quantity of commodities exported,
the date of export, and the country
where commodities were delivered.
PO 00000
Frm 00016
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
(c)(1) A participant shall submit to
FAS information, using a form as
prescribed by FAS, covering the receipt,
handling and disposition of the donated
commodities. Such report shall be
submitted to FAS, by the dates and for
the reporting periods specified in the
program agreement, until all of the
donated commodities have been
distributed, sold or bartered and such
disposition has been reported to FAS.
(2) If the agreement authorizes the
sale or barter of donated commodities,
the participant shall submit to FAS
information, using a form as prescribed
by FAS, covering the receipt and use of
sale proceeds and income, and in the
case of bartered commodities, covering
the services and goods derived from the
barter of donated commodities. Such
reports shall be submitted to FAS, by
the dates and for the reporting periods
specified in the agreement, until all of
the generated sales proceeds and
income have been disbursed and
reported to FAS. When reporting
financial information, the participant
shall include the amounts in U.S.
dollars and the exchange rate.
(3) The participant shall provide to
FAS additional information or reports
relating to the agreement if requested by
FAS.
(4) The participant shall report, in the
manner specified in the agreement, its
progress, measured against established
baselines, towards achieving the
objectives of the activities under the
agreement.
(d) A participant shall submit to FAS,
in the manner specified in the
agreement, an annual audit in
accordance with § 3019.26 of this title.
If FAS requires an audit with respect to
a particular agreement, and FAS
provides funds for this purpose,
participant shall arrange for such audit
and shall submit to FAS, in the manner
specified in the agreement, an annual
financial audit of the agreement.
(e)(1) A participant shall, as provided
in the agreement, submit to FAS interim
and final evaluations of the
implementation of the agreement.
Unless otherwise provided in the
agreement, the evaluations shall be
submitted at the mid-point and endpoint of the implementation period. The
participant shall arrange for the
evaluations to be conducted by an
independent third party that:
(i) Is financially and legally separate
from the participant’s organization;
(ii) Has staff with demonstrated
knowledge, analytical capability,
language skills and experience in
conducting evaluations of development
programs involving agriculture,
education, and nutrition;
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
(iii) Uses acceptable analytical
frameworks such as comparison with
non-project areas, surveys, involvement
of stakeholders in the evaluation, and
statistical analyses;
(iv) Uses local consultants, as
appropriate, to conduct portions of the
evaluation;
(v) Provides a detailed outline of the
evaluation, major task, and specific
schedules prior to initiating the
evaluation.
(2) Receipt by FAS of the evaluations
referred to in paragraph (e)(1) of this
section, is a condition of retaining funds
received to carry out the evaluations.
(f) Participants shall submit to FAS
the financial reports and information
outlined in § 3019.52 of this title. The
agreement will specify the acceptable
forms and time requirements for
submission.
§ 1599.14 Noncompliance with an
agreement.
If a participant fails to comply with a
term of an agreement, FAS may take one
or more of the enforcement actions set
forth in § 3019.62 of this title and, if,
appropriate, initiate a claim against the
participant. FAS may also initiate a
claim against a participant if the
donated commodities are damaged or
lost or the sale proceeds, income, or
FAS-provided funds are lost due to an
action or omission of the participant.
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
§ 1599.15 Suspension, termination, and
closeouts of agreements.
(a) An agreement may be suspended
or terminated by FAS if it determines
that:
(1) The continuation of the assistance
provided under this agreement is no
longer necessary or desirable; or
(2) Storage facilities are inadequate to
prevent spoilage or waste, or
distribution of the donated commodities
will result in substantial disincentive to,
or interference with, domestic
production or marketing in the targeted
country.
(b) An agreement may be terminated
in accordance with § 3019.61 of this
title. If an agreement is terminated, the
participant shall:
(1) Be responsible for the safety of any
undistributed donated commodities and
dispose of such commodities only as
agreed to by FAS; and
(2) Follow the closeout procedures in
§§ 3019.71 through 3019.73 of this title,
which will apply to the closeout of an
agreement.
(c) An agreement will be considered
completed when FAS and the
participant have fulfilled their
responsibilities under the agreement or
the agreement has been terminated. The
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
procedures in §§ 3019.71 through
3019.73 of this title will apply to the
closeout of an agreement.
§ 1599.16
Appeals
A participant may appeal a
determination arising under this part to
FAS. Such appeal will be in writing and
submitted to the FAS official and in the
manner set forth in the agreement. The
participant will be given an opportunity
to have a hearing before a final decision
is made regarding its appeal.
§ 1599.17
Paperwork Reduction Act.
The information collection
requirements contained in this
regulation have been approved by the
Office of Management and Budget under
provisions of 44 U.S.C. Chapter 35 and
have been assigned OMB Numbers
0551–0035.
4. Amend 48 CFR Chapter 4 by adding
part 470 to read as follows:
CHAPTER 4—DEPARTMENT OF
AGRICULTURE
PART 470—COMMODITY
ACQUISITIONS
Sec.
470.000 Scope of part.
470.101 Definitions.
470.102 Policy.
470.103 United States origin of agricultural
products.
470.200 [Reserved]
470.201 Acquisition of commodities and
freight shipment for Foreign Agricultural
Service programs.
470.202. Acquisition of commodities for
United States Agency for International
Development (USAID) programs.
470.203 Cargo preference.
Authority: 5 U.S.C. 301; 7 U.S.C. 1691
through 1726b; 1731 through 1736g–3;
1736o; 1736o–1; 40 U.S.C. 121(c); 46 U.S.C.
53305, 55314 and 55316.
470.000
Scope of part.
This part sets forth the policies,
procedures and requirements governing
the procurement of agricultural
commodities by the Department of
Agriculture for use:
(a) Under any domestic feeding and
assistance program administered by the
Food and Nutrition Service; and
(b) Under Title II of the Food For
Peace Act (7 U.S.C. 1721 et seq.); the
Food for Progress Act of 1985; the
McGovern-Dole International Food for
Education and Child Nutrition Program;
and any other international food
assistance program.
470.101
Definitions.
Additives means spices, vitamins,
micronutrients, desiccants, and
preservatives when added to an
agricultural commodity product.
PO 00000
Frm 00017
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
63403
Commingled product means grains,
oilseeds, rice, pulses, other similar
commodities and the products of such
commodities, when such commodity or
product is normally stored on a
commingled basis in such a manner that
the commodity or product produced in
the United States can not be readily
distinguished from a commodity or
product not produced in the United
States.
Department means the Department of
Agriculture.
Food and Nutrition Service means
such agency located within the
Department of Agriculture.
Foreign Agriculture Service means
such agency located within the
Department of Agriculture.
Free alongside ship (f.a.s.) means
delivery free of expense to the
Government delivered alongside the
ocean vessel and within reach of its
loading tackle at the specified location
of shipment.
Grantee organization means an
organization which will receive
commodities from the United States
Agency for International Development
under Title II of the Food for Peace Act
(7 U.S.C. 1721 et seq.) or from the
Foreign Agricultural Service under the
Food for Progress Act of 1985; the
McGovern-Dole International Food for
Education and Child Nutrition Program;
and any other international food
assistance program.
Intermodal bridge-point means an
inland location where cargo is received
by a carrier and is then moved to a
coastal port for loading.
Last contract lay day means the last
day specified in an ocean freight
contract by which the carriage of goods
must start for contract performance.
Lowest landed cost means, as
authorized by 46 U.S.C. 55314(c), with
respect to an agricultural product
acquired under this part, the lowest
aggregate cost for the acquisition of such
product and the shipment of such
product to a foreign destination.
Multi-trip voyage charter means the
charter of an ocean carrier in which the
carrier will stop at two or more ports to
discharge cargo.
470.102
Policy.
(a) It is the policy of the Department
to follow the policies and procedures set
forth in the Federal Acquisition
Regulation (FAR) as supplemented by
the Agriculture Acquisition Regulation,
including this part, in the procurement
of agricultural commodities and
products of agricultural commodities
that are used in domestic feeding and
international feeding and development
programs.
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
63404
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
(b) To the maximum extent possible,
the use of electronic submission of
solicitation-related documents shall be
used with respect to the acquisition of
agricultural commodities and related
freight; however, to the extent that a
solicitation allows for the submission of
written information in addition to
information in an electronic format and
there is a discrepancy in such
submissions, the information submitted
in a written format shall prevail unless
the electronic submission states that a
specific existing written term is
superseded by the electronic
submission.
(c) With respect to the acquisition of
freight for the shipment of agricultural
commodities and products of
agricultural commodities, the provisions
of the FAR, including part 47, shall be
utilized and various types of services to
be obtained may include multi-trip
voyage charters.
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
470.103 United States origin of agricultural
products.
(a) As provided by 7 U.S.C. 1732(2)
and 17360–1(a) commodities and the
products of agricultural commodities
acquired for use in international feeding
and development programs shall be
products of United States origin.
(b) Commodities and the products of
agricultural commodities acquired for
use by the Food and Nutrition Service
shall be a product of the United States,
except as may otherwise be required by
law, and shall be considered to be such
a product if it is grown, processed, and
otherwise prepared for sale or
distribution exclusively in the United
States except with respect to additives.
Additives from non-domestic sources
will be allowed to be utilized as a
United States product if such additives
are not otherwise:
(1) Produced in the United States; or
(2) Commercially available at fair and
reasonable prices in the United States
from domestic sources.
(c) A commingled product shall be
considered to be a product of the United
States if, during the contract
performance period specified in a
solicitation, the contractor procures a
quantity of the product that is of United
States origin in a quantity equal to or
more than the quantity to be delivered
under the solicitation.
(d) With respect to the procurement of
products derived from animals, such
products shall not be considered
products of the United States if the
animal from which the product was
obtained:
(1) Entered the United States from a
foreign country; and
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
(2) Was delivered directly to a
processing plant for processing.
470.200
[Reserved]
470.201 Acquisition of commodities and
freight shipment for Foreign Agricultural
Service programs.
(a) Lowest Landed Cost and Delivery
Considerations.
(1) Except as provided in paragraphs
(a)(3) and (4) of this section, in contracts
for the Foreign Agricultural Service for
commodities and related freight
shipment for delivery to foreign
destinations, the contracting officer
shall consider the lowest landed cost of
delivering the commodity to the
intended destination. This lowest
landed cost determination will be
calculated on the basis of rates and
service for that portion of the
commodities being purchased that is
determined is necessary and practicable
to meet 46 U.S.C. 55314(c)(3) and cargo
preference requirements and on an
overall (foreign and U.S. flag) basis for
the remaining portion of the
commodities being procured and the
additional factors set forth in this
section. Accordingly, the solicitations
issued with respect to a commodity
procurement or a related freight
procurement will specify that in the
event an offer submitted by a party is
the lowest offered price, the contracting
officer reserves the right to reject such
offer if the acceptance of another offer
for the commodity or related freight,
when combined with other offers for
commodities or related freight, results
in a lower landed cost to the
Department.
(2) The Department may contact any
port prior to award to determine the
port’s cargo handling capabilities,
including the adequacy of the port to
receive, accumulate, handle, store, and
protect the cargo. Factors considered in
this determination may include, but not
be limited to, the adequacy of building
structures, proper ventilation, freedom
from insects and rodents, cleanliness,
and overall good housekeeping and
warehousing practices. The Department
may consider the use of another coastal
range or port if a situation exists at a
port that may adversely affect the ability
of the Department to have the
commodity delivered in a safe and
timely manner. Such situations include:
(i) A port is congested;
(ii) Port facilities are overloaded;
(iii) A vessel would not be able to
dock and load cargo without delay;
(iv) Labor disputes or lack of labor
may prohibit the loading of the cargo
onboard a vessel in a timely manner; or
(v) Other similar situation that may
adversely affect the ability of the
PO 00000
Frm 00018
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
Department to have the commodity
delivered in a timely manner.
(3) Use of Other Than Lowest Landed
Cost. In order to ensure that
commodities are delivered in a timely
fashion to foreign destinations and
without damage, the contracting officer
may award an acquisition without
regard to the lowest land cost process
set forth in paragraph (a)(1) of this
section, if:
(i) The solicitation specifies that the
lowest land cost process will not be
followed in the completion of the
contract; or
(ii) After issuance of the solicitation,
it is determined that:
(A) Internal strife at the foreign
destination or urgent humanitarian
conditions threatens the lives of persons
at the foreign destination;
(B) A specific port’s cargo handling
capabilities (including the adequacy of
the port to receive, accumulate, handle,
store, and protect commodities) and
other similar factors may adversely
affect the delivery of such commodities
through damage or untimely delivery.
Such similar factors include, but are not
limited to: port congestion; overloaded
facilities at the port; vessels not being
able to dock and load cargo without
delay due to conditions at the port;
labor disputes or lack of labor may
prohibit the loading of the cargo
onboard a vessel in a timely manner;
and the existence of inadequate or
unsanitary warehouse and other
supporting facilities;
(C) The total transit time of a carrier,
as it relates to a final delivery date at the
foreign destination may impair the
ability of the Department to achieve
timely delivery of the commodity;
(D) Other similar situations arise that
materially affect the administration of
the program for which the commodity
or freight is being procured; or
(E) The contracting officer determines
that extenuating circumstances preclude
awards on the basis of lowest-landed
cost, or that efficiency and cost-savings
justify use of types of ocean service that
would not involve an analysis of freight.
However, in all such cases, commodities
would be transported in compliance
with cargo preference requirements.
Examples of extenuating circumstances
are events such as internal strife at the
foreign destination or urgent
humanitarian conditions threatening the
lives of persons at the foreign
destination. Other types of services may
include, but are not limited to, multitrip voyage charters, indefinite delivery/
indefinite quantity (IDIQ), delivery cost
and freight (C & F), delivery cost
insurance and freight (CIF), and indexed
ocean freight costs.
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
(4) If a contracting officer determines
that action may be appropriate under
paragraph (a)(3) of this section, prior to
the acceptance of any applicable offer,
the contracting officer will provide to
the Head of Contacting Activity
Designee a written request to obtain
commodities and freight in a manner
other than on a lowest landed cost basis
consistent with Title 48 of the Code of
Federal Regulations. This request shall
include a statement of the reasons for
not using lowest landed cost basis. The
Head of the Contracting Activity
Designee, or the designee one level
above the contracting officer, may either
accept or reject this request and shall
document this determination.
(b) Multiple Offers or Delivery Points.
If more than one offer for the sale of
commodities is received or more than
one delivery point has been designated
in such offers, in order to achieve a
combination of a freight rate and
commodity award that produces the
lowest landed cost for the delivery of
the commodity to the foreign
destination, the contracting officer shall
evaluate offers submitted on a delivery
point by delivery point basis; however,
consideration shall be given to
prioritized ocean transport service in
determining lowest landed cost.
(c) Freight Shipping and Rates. (1) In
determining the lowest-landed cost, the
Department shall use the freight rates
offered in response to solicitations
issued by the Department or, if
applicable, the grantee organization.
(2) Freight rates offered must be
submitted as specified in the solicitation
issued by the Department or, if
applicable, the grantee organization.
Any such solicitation issued by a
grantee organization must contain the
following elements:
(i) If directed by the Department,
include a closing time for the receipt of
written freight offers and state that late
written freight offers will not be
considered;
(ii) Provide that freight offers are
required to have a canceling date no
later than the last contract lay day
specified in the solicitation;
(iii) Provide the same deadline for
receipt of written freight offers from
both U.S. flag vessel and non-U.S. flag
vessels; and
(iv) Be received and opened prior to
any related offer for acquisition of
commodities to be shipped.
(3) The Department may require
organizations that will receive
commodities from the Department to
submit information relating to the
capacity of a United States port, or, if
applicable, a terminal, prior to the
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
acquisition of such commodities or
freight.
(d) If the Department is not the party
procuring freight with respect to a
shipment of an agricultural commodity
for delivery to a foreign destination, the
organization that will receive
commodities from the Department, or its
shipping agent, shall be notified by the
Department of the vessel freight rate
used in determining the commodity
contract award and the organization will
be responsible for finalizing the charter
or booking contract with the vessel
representing the freight rate.
470.202 Acquisition of commodities for
United States Agency for International
Development (USAID) programs.
(a) Lowest Landed Cost and Delivery
Considerations. (1) Except as provided
in paragraphs (a)(3) and (e)(2) of this
section, with respect to the acquisition
of agricultural commodities for delivery
to foreign destinations and related
freight to transport such commodities
under Title II of Pub. L. 480, contracts
will be entered into in a manner that
will result in the lowest landed cost of
such commodity delivery to the
intended destination. This lowest
landed cost determination shall be
calculated on the basis of rates and
service for that portion of the
commodities being purchased that is
determined is necessary and practicable
to meet 46 U.S.C. 55314(c)(3) and cargo
preference requirements and on an
overall (foreign and U.S. flag) basis for
the remaining portion of the
commodities being procured and the
additional factors set forth in this
section. Accordingly, the solicitations
issued with respect to a commodity
procurement or a freight procurement
will specify that in the event an offer
submitted by a party is the lowest
offered price, the contracting officer
reserves the right to reject such offer if
the acceptance of another offer for the
commodity or freight, when combined
with other offers for commodities or
freight, results in a lower landed cost to
USAID.
(2) The Department may contact any
port prior to award to determine the
port’s cargo handling capabilities,
including the adequacy of the port to
receive, accumulate, handle, store, and
protect the cargo. Factors which will be
considered in this determination will
include, but not be limited to, the
adequacy of building structures, proper
ventilation, freedom from insects and
rodents, cleanliness, and overall good
housekeeping and warehousing
practices. The Department may consider
the use of another coastal range or port
if a situation exists at a port that may
PO 00000
Frm 00019
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
63405
adversely affect the ability of the
Department of Agriculture to have the
commodity delivered in a safe and/or
timely manner. Such situations include:
(i) A port is congested;
(ii) Port facilities are overloaded;
(iii) A vessel would not be able to
dock and load cargo without delay;
(iv) Labor disputes or lack of labor
may prohibit the loading of the cargo
onboard a vessel in a timely manner; or
(v) Other similar situation that may
adversely affect the ability of the
Department of Agriculture to have the
commodity delivered in a timely
manner.
(3) Use of Other than Lowest Landed
Cost. In order to ensure that
commodities are delivered in a timely
fashion to foreign destinations and
without damage, the Department of
Agriculture may complete an
acquisition without regard to the lowest
land cost process set forth in paragraph
(a)(1) of this section, if:
(i) The solicitation specifies that the
lowest land cost process will not be
followed in the completion of the
contract; or
(ii) After issuance of the solicitation,
it is determined that:
(A) Internal strife at the foreign
destination or urgent humanitarian
conditions threatens the lives of persons
at the foreign destination;
(B) A specific port’s cargo handling
capabilities (including the adequacy of
the port to receive, accumulate, handle,
store, and protect commodities) and
other similar factors will adversely
affect the delivery of such commodities
without damage or in a timely manner.
Such similar factors include, but are not
limited to: port congestion; overloaded
facilities at the port; vessels would not
be able to dock and load cargo without
delay; labor disputes or lack of labor
may prohibit the loading of the cargo
onboard a vessel in a timely manner;
and the existence of inadequate or
unsanitary warehouse and other
supporting facilities;
(C) The total transit time of a carrier,
as it relates to a final delivery date at the
foreign destination may impair the
ability of the Department of Agriculture
to achieve timely delivery of the
commodity; or
(D) Other similar situations arise that
materially affect the administration of
the program for which the commodity
or freight is being procured.
(4) If the contracting officer
determines that action may be
appropriate under paragraph (a)(3) of
this section, prior to the acceptance of
any applicable offer, the contracting
officer shall provide to the head of
contacting activity designee and to
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
rwilkins on PROD1PC63 with RULES
63406
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 / Proposed Rules
USAID, a written request to obtain
commodities and freight in a manner
other than on a lowest landed cost basis.
This request shall include a statement of
the reasons for not using lowest landed
cost basis. The head of contracting
authority designee, or one level above
the contracting officer, with the
concurrence of USAID, shall, on an
expedited basis, either accept or reject
this request and shall document this
determination in writing and provide a
copy to USAID.
(b) Freight Shipping and Rates. (1) In
determining lowest-landed cost as
specified in paragraph (a) of this
section, the Department shall use vessel
rates offered in response to solicitations
issued by USAID or grantee
organizations receiving commodities
under 7 U.S.C. 1731 et seq.
(2) USAID may require, or direct a
grantee organization to require, an ocean
carrier to submit offers electronically
through a Web-based system maintained
by the Department. If electronic
submissions are required, the
Department may, at its discretion,
accept corrections to such submissions
that are submitted in a written form
other than by use of such Web-based
system.
(c) The contracting officer shall
consider total transit time, as it relates
to a final delivery date, in order to
satisfy Title II program requirements.
(d)(1) Commodities offered for
delivery free alongside ship to Great
Lakes port range or intermodal bridgepoint Great Lakes port range that
represent the overall (foreign and U.S.
flag) lowest landed cost will be awarded
on a lowest landed cost basis. Tonnage
allocated on this basis will not be
reevaluated on a lowest landed cost
U.S.-flag basis unless the contracting
officer determines that 25 percent of the
total annual tonnage of bagged,
processed or fortified commodities
furnished under 7 U.S.C. 1731 et seq.
has been, or will be, transported from
the Great Lakes port range during that
fiscal year.
(2) The contracting officer shall
consider commodity offers as offers for
delivery ‘‘intermodal bridge-point Great
Lakes port range’’ only if:
(i) The offer specifies delivery at a
marine cargo-handling facility that is
capable of loading ocean going vessels
at a Great Lakes port, as well as loading
ocean going conveyances such as barges
and container vans, and
(ii) The commodities will be moved
from one transportation conveyance to
another at such a facility.
(e) Multiple Awards or Delivery
Points. (1) If more than one offer for the
sale of commodities is received or more
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:11 Oct 23, 2008
Jkt 217001
than one delivery point has been
designated in such offers, in order to
achieve a combination of a freight rate
and commodity award that produces the
lowest landed cost for the delivery of
the commodity to the foreign
destination, the contracting officer shall
evaluate offers submitted on a delivery
point by delivery point basis; however,
consideration shall be given to
prioritized ocean transport service in
determining lowest landed cost.
(2) The contracting officer may
determine that extenuating
circumstances preclude awards on the
basis of lowest landed cost. However, in
all such cases, commodities may be
transported in compliance with cargo
preference requirements as determined
by USAID.
(3) The contracting officer shall notify
USAID or, if applicable, the grantee
organization, that its shipping agent will
be notified of the vessel freight rate used
in determining the commodity contract
award. The grantee organization or
USAID will be responsible for finalizing
the charter or booking contract with the
vessel representing the freight rate so
used.
470.203
Cargo preference.
An agency having responsibility
under this subpart shall administer its
programs, with respect to this subpart,
in accordance with regulations
prescribed by the Secretary of the
Department of Transportation.
Michael W. Yost,
Executive Vice President, Commodity Credit
Corporation, and Administrator, Foreign
Agricultural Service.
[FR Doc. E8–25186 Filed 10–23–08; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 3410–10–P
FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE
CORPORATION
12 CFR Part 360
Processing of Deposit Accounts in the
Event of an Insured Depository
Institution Failure and Large-Bank
Deposit Insurance Determination
Modernization; Limited Opportunity To
Resubmit Comment
Federal Deposit Insurance
Corporation (FDIC).
ACTION: Notice of limited opportunity to
resubmit comment.
AGENCY:
SUMMARY: The FDIC invites the
commenter who filed a public comment
at https://www.regulations.gov on April
14, 2008, relating to the FDIC’s Notice
of Proposed Rulemaking involving
‘‘Processing of Deposit Accounts in the
PO 00000
Frm 00020
Fmt 4702
Sfmt 4702
Event of an Insured Depository
Institution Failure and Large-Bank
Deposit Insurance Determination
Modernization’’ to resubmit to the FDIC
his or her comment relating to this
action. We are taking this action because
due to a technical software error, a
public comment submitted via https://
www.regulations.gov was not
transmitted to the FDIC. Therefore, the
FDIC will provide this commenter with
a limited opportunity to resubmit his or
her comment to the FDIC on or before
November 24, 2008.
DATES: The commenter whose comment
was not transmitted to the FDIC in
accordance with the situation described
above may resubmit his or her comment
on or before November 24, 2008.
ADDRESSES: The affected commenter
may submit his or her comment by any
of the following methods:
• Federal eRulemaking Portal: https://
www.regulations.gov. Follow the
instructions for submitting comments.
• Agency Web Site: https://
www.FDIC.gov/regulations/laws/federal.
Follow instructions for submitting
comments on the FDIC’s Web Site.
• E-mail: Comments@FDIC.gov.
Include ‘‘Resubmitted Comments’’ in
the subject line of the message.
• Mail: Robert E. Feldman, Executive
Secretary, Attention: Comments, Federal
Deposit Insurance Corporation, 550 17th
Street, NW., Washington, DC 20429
• Hand Delivery/Courier: Guard
Station at the rear of the 550 17th Street
Building (located on F Street) on
business days between 7 a.m. and 5 p.m.
(EST).
• Public Inspection: All comments
received will be posted without change
to https://www.fdic.gov/regulations/laws/
federal/ including any personal
information provided. Paper copies of
public comments may be ordered from
the Public Information Center by
telephone at (877) 275–3342 or (703)
562–2200.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: A.
Ann Johnson, Counsel, Legal Division,
(202) 898–3573 or aajohnson@fdic.gov.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: In January
2003, the interagency eRulemaking
Program launched https://
www.regulations.gov to provide citizens
with an online portal to learn about
proposed regulations and to submit
their comments on the rulemaking
process. For the first time, American
citizens could access and comment on
all proposed Federal regulations from a
single Web site.
A software problem at
https://www.regulations.gov resulted in
the non-transmittal of public comments
to some federal agencies from March 22,
E:\FR\FM\24OCP1.SGM
24OCP1
Agencies
[Federal Register Volume 73, Number 207 (Friday, October 24, 2008)]
[Proposed Rules]
[Pages 63387-63406]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Printing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: E8-25186]
========================================================================
Proposed Rules
Federal Register
________________________________________________________________________
This section of the FEDERAL REGISTER contains notices to the public of
the proposed issuance of rules and regulations. The purpose of these
notices is to give interested persons an opportunity to participate in
the rule making prior to the adoption of the final rules.
========================================================================
Federal Register / Vol. 73, No. 207 / Friday, October 24, 2008 /
Proposed Rules
[[Page 63387]]
DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
48 CFR Part 470
Commodity Credit Corporation
7 CFR Parts 1496 and 1499
Foreign Agricultural Service
7 CFR Part 1599
RIN 0551-AA78
McGovern Dole International Food for Education and Child
Nutrition Program and Food for Progress Program
AGENCY: Foreign Agricultural Service and Commodity Credit Corporation,
USDA.
ACTION: Proposed rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: This proposed rule would amend the regulations to administer
the Food for Progress (FFPr) Program and the McGovern-Dole
International Food for Education and Child Nutrition Program (McGovern-
Dole Program) by making revisions to provide greater clarity with
respect to all aspects of the program with specific emphasis on the
eligibility requirements that a participant must meet, and the actions
that must be undertaken by a participant in order to receive assistance
under these programs, including the reports that are filed by program
participants with the Foreign Agricultural Service (FAS). This proposed
rule would also amend the Agriculture Acquisition Regulation (AGAR), to
specify the criteria that is used in determining whether a commodity
that is procured under these programs and under domestic feeding
programs administered by USDA is considered to be a commodity that is a
product of the United States. The purpose of these amendments is to
improve efficiency of the programs and make it more clear to
participants what they must do to meet eligibility requirements.
DATES: We will consider comments that we receive by December 8, 2008.
ADDRESSES: We invite you to submit comments on this proposed rule. In
your comment, include the volume, date, and page number of this issue
of the Federal Register. You may submit comments by any of the
following methods:
E-Mail: PPDED@fas.usda.gov and/or
Babette.Gainor@fas.usda.gov.
Fax: (202) 690-0251.
Mail to: Babette Gainor, Deputy Director, Food Assistance
Division, Foreign Agricultural Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture,
Stop 1034, 1400 Independence Avenue, SW., Washington, DC 20250-1034.
Hand Delivery or Courier: 1250 Maryland Avenue, SW., Suite
400, Washington, DC 20024.
Federal eRulemaking Portal: Go to https://
www.regulations.gov. Follow the online instructions for submitting
comments.
Comments may be inspected in Suite 400 of the Portals Building,
1250 Maryland Avenue, SW., Washington, DC, between 8 a.m. and 4:30
p.m., Monday through Friday, except holidays. A copy of this proposed
rule is available through the FAS home page at https://www.fas.usda.gov/
foodaid.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Babette Gainor at (202) 720-4221, or
e-mail: Babette.Gainor@fas.usda.gov.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
7 CFR Part 1496--Procurement of Commodities for Foreign Donation
This proposed rule amends the current regulations governing the
procurement of commodities for use in international food assistance and
developmental programs, and to move those regulations to a different
section of the CFR.
Personnel of the Farm Service Agency (FSA) acquire commodities for
use by the Foreign Agricultural Service (FAS) for use in international
food assistance and developmental programs. These commodities are
procured in conformity with the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR),
as supplemented by the AGAR found in 48 CFR Chapter 4. In addition,
regulations at 7 CFR part 1496 set forth provisions applicable to the
acquisition of commodities to carry out activities under the McGovern-
Dole Program, FFPr Program, and Title II of the Food For Peace Act,
(Pub. L. 83-480, or referred to as Pub. L. 480). Title II procurements
are done on behalf of the U. S. Agency for International Development
(USAID) by FSA. The regulations at 7 CFR part 1496 were amended at 72
FR 6450, on February 12, 2007, in order to adopt new procedures
regarding the evaluation of bids submitted in the procurement of
commodities. This proposed rule would move the current regulations at 7
CFR part 1496 to a new part in the AGAR, 48 CFR Chapter 4, part 470,
and delete and revise obsolete provisions in 7 CFR part 1496. This rule
also proposes minor ``housekeeping'' changes to clarify those
regulations.
The substantive changes to this section of the regulations proposed
in this rule are intended to make the procurement process more
efficient and responsive. The U. S. Government Accountability Office
(GAO) issued a report in April 2007, entitled FOREIGN ASSISTANCE--
Various Challenges Impede the Efficiency and Effectiveness of U.S. Food
Aid. Among the findings in this report is that current contracting
provisions produce a ``bunching of contracts'' that result in increased
program costs (GAO Report, pg. 23). USDA shares the overall concerns
set forth in the GAO report about the need to improve efficiency in
contracting to improve program delivery and is engaged in a continuing
process to revise its contracting procedures to have the benefit of
increased flexibility afforded under the FAR. Accordingly, this
proposed rule would amend these regulations to ensure that USDA may
fully utilize all types of acquisition contracts that are authorized by
the FAR. And, as noted below, under this proposed rule USDA would have
the option of procuring freight directly from carriers as opposed to
doing so indirectly through program participants. Such procurements
would be done in accordance with the FAR, including the AGAR.
Changes to 7 CFR Parts 1499 and 1599--Foreign Donation Programs and
McGovern-Dole International Food for Education and Child Nutrition
Program
The regulations in 7 CFR part 1499, Foreign Donation Programs, are
used by FAS, on behalf of the Commodity Credit Corporation (CCC), in
the administration of the FFPr Program. The regulations in 7 CFR part
1599, McGovern-Dole International Food for Education and Child
Nutrition Program,
[[Page 63388]]
are used by FAS in the administration of the McGovern-Dole Program.
Many of the provisions of these regulations have not been reviewed or
updated since their issuance in 1996 and 2001, respectively. The
changes proposed in this rule are largely technical in nature to
improve the efficiency and effectiveness of the programs. The following
is a discussion of the major proposed amendments.
In 2006, FAS initiated an agency-wide reorganization. Following the
completion of this reorganization in 2007, FAS began to evaluate how
programs are implemented in light of the organizational changes.
Concurrent with this process, the GAO Report was issued. As a result of
this review, taking into account the findings in the GAO Report, USDA
proposed changes to these regulations that are designed to improve the
delivery of assistance under these programs by removing obsolete
provisions; consolidating reporting requirements applicable to
participants; and providing greater flexibility in the settlement of
claims that arise under the program. For example, the proposed rule
would set forth with greater clarity the responsibilities of a
participant in the event unanticipated actions occur that involve the
protection of commodities provided to the participant by FAS or CCC and
would provide greater latitude with respect to the actions of the
participant in such a situation.
One of the criticisms in the GAO report is related to the ``lengthy
claims process'' that exists under current regulations (GAO Report, pg.
27). While the report focused on transportation claims, USDA is also
concerned about the timely resolution of all claims that arise under
the program. Under current regulations, generally, for cargo claims:
(1) If the claim is less than $100 no action is necessary; (2) if the
claim is between $100 and $300, no action is necessary if the
participant determines that costs of collection would exceed the likely
recovery costs; (3) if the recovery on a claim is less than $200, the
participant may retain the recovery; and (4) if the recovery on a claim
is more than $200, the participant may retain either $200 plus 10
percent of the difference between $200 and the total amount of the
claim up to $500, or the actual amount of collection costs (excluding
attorney fees and collection agency fees). Other provisions of the
current regulations generally require that a participant assign all
rights to a claim to FAS or CCC, as appropriate. In most instances, all
recoveries are retained by one of these agencies except in cases where
the participant may have expended its own funds for ocean
transportation, in which case the recovery is shared with such
participant.
This process reflects neither the actual costs of collection of
claims nor the logistical issues attendant to claims that occur outside
of the United States. This process was instituted on the premise that
carriers and other entities would be more likely to make payments to
the United States if a claim had been assigned to it as opposed to
requiring a participant pursue collection. Also, when this process was
originally established, the vast majority of food aid shipments were in
the form of bulk commodities. Now, however, a significant quantity of
commodities is shipped in containers and there is a significant
reduction in the dollar amount of individual losses as such losses are
generally limited to one container, or a small number of containers, as
opposed to losses in large bulk grain shipments. The following charts
set forth cargo claim collection activity for the FFPr Program and the
McGovern-Dole Program over the past four fiscal years (note the amount
of recovery in a fiscal year represents amounts recovered in that year
for claims established in that year and preceding years):
Food For Progress Program
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Claims
Fiscal year Claims established
collected (number)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
2004..................................... $313,686 $468,747 (67)
2005..................................... 64,766 20,414 (47)
2006..................................... 257,832 369,215 (55)
2007..................................... 65,638 126,098 (5)
------------------------------
4-Year Totals........................ 701,922 984,474 (174)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
McGovern-Dole Food for Education and Child Nutrition Program
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Claims
Fiscal year Claims established
collected (number)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
2004..................................... $15,075 $19,792 (12)
2005..................................... 50,397 56,824 (32)
2006..................................... 96,760 106,925 (44)
2007..................................... 18,977 20,989 (8)
------------------------------
4-year Totals........................ 181,209 204,530 (96)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Taking into account the small number of claims and the extremely
small average amount of claims that were established (FFPr Program--
$5,657 and McGovern-Dole Program--$2,230) and the costs attributable
for salaries and expenses of USDA employees, this current system is not
cost-effective. Further, with respect to non-cargo claims, if such
claims arise in a foreign country after the liability of the carrier
ends, any litigation which may be required to effectuate collection
must be brought in the country where the claim arose. In such a
situation, assignment of the claim to FAS or CCC for collection is
simply not feasible.
This process is predicated upon the current manner in which freight
contracts are entered into for the delivery of commodities made
available under FFPr Program and the McGovern-Dole Program. Generally,
the current regulations envision that the program participant will be
reimbursed for the cost of obtaining freight and that the
[[Page 63389]]
freight contract is between the program participant and the carrier. In
reality, as the programs have evolved over many years, the program
participant obtains potential bids from prospective carriers and these
bids are provided to FSA who, as set forth in 7 CFR part 1496, utilizes
a sophisticated computer program to analyze the freight bids in
conjunction with the various bids obtained in the procurement of
commodities to ascertain which combination of carrier bids and
commodity bids produces the lowest landed cost of delivery of the
commodity to a foreign destination. Thus, the selection of the carrier
bid ultimately rests with USDA. Once the carrier is determined, the
program participant executes, in most instances, a contract with the
carrier. As the contract is between the carrier and the program
participant, any claim that the participant has against the carrier is
the participant's cause of action and not that of CCC or FAS. The
current regulations provide that the program participant must assign
this private cause of action to CCC or FAS as a condition of program
participation. Questions have been raised concerning whether the
freight acquisition process is compliant with the FAR and whether CCC
and FAS should be accepting private causes of action for collection
purposes. Accordingly, this proposed rule would provide that in
obtaining freight contracts, FAS or CCC, as applicable, would obtain
the freight contracts in accordance with the FAR. This would eliminate
the need for any program participant to assign a claim to FAS or CCC.
The regulations, as amended, would also provide for the option for FSA
or CCC to allow a program participant to obtain freight but assignment
of these claims would, as a general rule, be eliminated. The program
participant would be responsible for claim collections and would be
allowed to retain any recovery of the claim, except the expenditure of
the recovered funds would be limited to carrying out an activity
authorized by the program under which the commodities had been provided
to the participant.
The current regulations for these programs require all participants
to submit various reports to FAS on a semi-annual basis and to file
other reports upon the occurrence of certain events. These reports are
required to be filed in four different offices within FAS and with two
different offices within FSA, and in some cases must also be filed with
the Agricultural Attach[eacute] or Agricultural Counselor of FAS with
responsibility for the country where the agreement is implemented. In
other cases, a report is required only to be filed with the
Agricultural Attach[eacute] or Agricultural Counselor. Several of these
offices referred to in the regulations have been either renamed or
eliminated, so the current regulations are obsolete. Accordingly, this
rule proposes to revise these regulations to remove all references to
specific offices and a generic reference to either FAS or CCC would be
used. The identification of the location where a report would be
required to be filed would be specified in the agreement. FAS expects
that in all, or substantially all, instances these reports will be
filed with one office in FAS. To the extent other USDA officials need
the information contained in the reports, FAS would be responsible for
dissemination of the material to appropriate officials.
Further, in addition to streamlining the location for reports
submission, FAS intends to incorporate a greater emphasis on
performance based reporting which will allow FAS to highlight the
accomplishments achieved by participants under food aid programs, which
will, in turn, allow FAS to provide funding to those projects that
achieve greater results.
It has been the practice of FAS, acting on behalf of CCC, to
administer section 1110(h) of the Food For Progress Act which addresses
the prohibitions against the resale and transshipment of donated
commodities to apply only to the party with whom CCC directly enters
into an agreement. This means that the participant is required to ship,
distribute and/or monetize (sell) the donated commodities in the
targeted country. Once the initial distribution and/or monetization
transaction has taken place by the participant, FAS considers the
program participant to be in compliance with section 1110(h). In
accordance with section 1110(j) of this Act, it has also been the
practice of FAS to permit multi-country agreements under the programs
whereby CCC delivers donated commodities to one country and activities
to fulfill the agreement objectives are carried out in another. This
rule proposes to amend the regulations at 7 CFR part 1499 to address
these types of situations.
Previously, 7 CFR part 1499 had been used to regulate and
administer activities authorized by Section 416(b) of the Agricultural
Act of 1949 (Section 416(b) program) in addition to the FFPr Program.
Reference to the Section 416(b) Program has been removed from this part
due to the fact that in order for activities to be conducted under this
program the Secretary of Agriculture must determine that commodities
will be made available under Section 416(b). Accordingly, FAS has
determined that it is more appropriate to announce any future
availability of commodities under Section 416(b) through a Federal
Register notice. Upon the announcement of commodity availability for
Section 416(b) activities, FAS may decide to use this part to
administer such availability; this decision also would be announced in
the Federal Register notice at that time.
Proposed New 48 CFR Part 470
The acquisition by USDA of agricultural commodities and ocean
freight, along with other services, is governed by procurement statutes
generally applicable to all activities of USDA. The regulations used to
implement these statutes are set forth in the FAR. But, there are
several statutes that contain provisions that are specifically
applicable to the international food assistance and development
programs and domestic food assistance programs.
With respect to the international programs, section 402 of Pub. L.
480 sets forth the definition of an ``agricultural commodity'' for use
under that Act and the FFPr Act and section 3107(a) of the Farm
Security and Rural Investment Act of 2002 sets forth a similar
definition of an ``agricultural commodity.'' Generally, these two
provisions require the use of commodities produced in the United
States. A similar approach has historically been used in the
acquisition of commodities for use in domestic feeding programs. In
some instances, additives such as vitamins and spices are not available
from U.S sources and in some instances the commodity which is being
procured is normally stored in a commingled manner without any way to
ascertain the country of origin. Accordingly, this rule proposes that
the AGAR would be revised to set forth in 48 CFR part 470 the
definition of an agricultural commodity and would reflect the current
practices of USDA in this regard.
Commodities provided under the FFPr Program and the McGovern-Dole
Program are delivered to foreign destinations through the acquisition
of freight which is ultimately paid for from funds from these programs.
The regulations at 7 CFR part 1496 require that the government will
determine which combination of commodity bids and bids for ocean
freight rates results in the lowest-landed cost of delivery of the
commodity to the foreign destination. The government generally will
award the contact for the purchase of the commodity that results in the
[[Page 63390]]
lowest-landed cost and would be transported in compliance with cargo
preference requirements under regulations prescribed by the Maritime
Administration. ``Lowest landed cost'' refers to the requirement that,
in the delivery of U.S. agricultural commodities under international
food assistance and developmental programs, the United States shall
generally use the combination of ocean freight contracts and commodity
acquisition contracts that results in the lowest cost of delivery of
the product to the desired destination. This requirement is based upon
provisions in section 901(b) of the Merchant Marine Act, 1936.
Accordingly, this specific provision of law is used in the procurement
of freight and agricultural commodities and, to the extent the
provisions of this section conflict with the more general provisions of
the Competition in Contracting Act, the provisions of section 901(b) of
the Merchant Marine Act, 1936 prevail.
The application of section 901(b) of the Merchant Marine Act, 1936,
when considered with other provisions of that Act, results in a complex
review of numerous offers for freight and commodities. In a very simple
example, in the shipment of commodities, several U.S. port locations
may provide viable services and the ocean freight contract cost from
one port may be less costly than the cost of using two other U.S.
ports. However, the cost of delivery of U.S. agricultural product to
the U.S. port with the lowest attendant freight cost may be
considerably greater than the costs of delivery of the commodities to
other U.S. ports. Thus, in order to ensure that the lowest total cost
is obtained, USDA reviews a myriad of potential freight and commodity
contract costs for each delivery of commodities to a foreign
destination. In order to have all USDA acquisition related regulations
in one location, 48 CFR Chapter 4, this proposed rule would move the
current regulations at 7 CFR part 1496 to 48 CFR part 470 but the
regulations would not be amended regarding the current process used to
ascertain the lowest landed cost for these contracts. Only the removal
of obsolete references and editorial changes would be made.
Executive Order 12866
This proposed rule has been determined to be not significant under
E.O. 12866, as amended by E.O. 13422, and was therefore not reviewed by
the Office of Management and Budget (OMB).
Regulatory Flexibility Act
The Regulatory Flexibility Act does not apply to this rule because
FAS is not required by 5 U.S.C. 553 or any other law to publish a
notice of proposed rulemaking with respect to the subject of this.
Environmental Assessment
FAS has determined that this proposed rule does not constitute a
major State or Federal action that would significantly affect the human
or natural environment consistent with the National Environmental
Policy Act (NEPA) 40 CFR part 1502.4, Major Federal actions requiring
the preparation of Environmental Impact Statements; and Compliance with
NEPA implementing the regulations of the Council on Environmental
Quality, 40 CFR parts 1500-1508. Therefore no environmental assessment
or environmental impact statement will be prepared.
Executive Order 12988
This rule has been reviewed under E.O. 12988. This rule is not
retroactive and it does not preempt State or local laws, regulations,
or policies unless they present an irreconcilable conflict with this
rule. This rule would not be retroactive.
Executive Order 12372
This program is not subject to E. O. 12372, which requires
intergovernmental consultation with State and local officials. See the
notice related to 7 CFR part 3015, subpart V, published at 48 FR 29115
(June 24, 1983).
Executive Order 13132
The policies contained in this rule do not have any substantial
direct effect on states, on the relationship between the national
government and the states, or on the distribution of power and
responsibilities among the various levels of government. Nor does this
rule impose substantial direct compliance costs on state and local
governments. Therefore, consultation with the states is not required.
Unfunded Mandates
Although we are publishing this as a proposed rule, Title II of the
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 (UMRA) does not apply to this rule
because FSA and FAS are not required by 5 U.S.C. 553 or any other law
to publish a notice of proposed rulemaking for the subject of this
rule. Further, this rule contains no unfunded mandates as defined in
sections 202 and 205 of UMRA.
Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995
In accordance with the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995, FAS has
previously received approval from the Office of Management and Budget
(OMB) with respect to the information collection required to support
these programs. The Information Collection is described below:
Title: Food Donation Programs (Food for Progress, Section 416(b),
and McGovern-Dole International Food for Education and Child
Nutrition).
OMB Control Number: 0551-0035.
E-Government Act Compliance
FAS is committed to complying with the E-Government Act, to promote
the use of the Internet and other information technologies to provide
increased opportunities for citizen access to Government information
and services, and for other purposes. The forms, regulations, and other
information collection activities required to be utilized by a person
subject to this rule are available at https://www.fas.usda.gov.
List of Subjects
7 CFR Part 1496
Agricultural commodities, Food assistance programs, Foreign aid,
Government procurement.
7 CFR Part 1499
Agricultural commodities, Food assistance programs, Foreign aid.
7 CFR Part 1599
Agricultural commodities, Exports, Foreign aid.
48 CFR Part 470
Government procurement, Reporting and recordkeeping requirements.
For the reasons set out in the preamble, under the authority of 5
U.S.C. 553; 15 U.S.C. 714b and 714c, 7 CFR parts 1496, 1499, 1599 and
48 CFR part 470 are proposed to be amended as follows:
PART 1496--[REMOVED]
1. 7 CFR part 1496 is removed.
2. Revise part 1499 to read as follows:
PART 1499--FOOD FOR PROGRESS PROGRAM
Sec.
1499.1 General statement.
1499.2 Definitions.
1499.3 Eligibility determination.
1499.4 Application process.
1499.5 Agreements.
1499.6 Payments.
1499.7 Transportation of goods.
1499.8 Entry and handling of commodities.
[[Page 63391]]
1499.9 Damage to and loss of commodities.
1499.10 Claims for damage to or loss of commodities.
1499.11 Use of commodities and sales proceeds.
1499.12 Subrecipients.
1499.13 Recordkeeping and reporting requirements.
1499.14 Noncompliance with an agreement.
1499.15 Suspension, termination, and closeout of agreements.
1499.16 Appeals.
1499.17 Paperwork Reduction Act.
Authority: 7 U.S.C. 1736o; and 15 U.S.C. 714b and 714c.
Sec. 1499.1 General Statement.
(a) This part sets forth the general terms and conditions governing
the donation of commodities by the Commodity Credit Corporation (CCC)
to participants in the Food for Progress Program (FFPr). Under FFPr,
participants use the donated commodities or proceeds from the sale of
such commodities to implement activities in a foreign country pursuant
to an agreement with CCC. The Foreign Agricultural Service (FAS) of the
Department of Agriculture (USDA) administers FFPr on behalf of CCC.
(b) In addition to the provisions of this part, other regulations
of general application issued by USDA, including the regulations set
forth in Chapter 30 of this title, are applicable to the FFPr. All
provisions of the CCC Charter Act (15 U.S.C. 714 et seq.) and any other
statutory provisions that are generally applicable to CCC are
applicable to FFPr and the regulations set forth in this part.
(c) This part shall not apply to a donation by CCC to a foreign
government or an intergovernmental agency or organization (such as the
United Nations' World Food Program) under FFPr.
Sec. 1499.2 Definitions.
The following definitions are applicable to this part:
Activity mean a project to be carried out by a participant,
directly or through a subrecipient, to fulfill the objectives of an
agreement.
Agreement mean a legally binding agreement entered into between CCC
and a participant to implement activities under FFPr.
CCC mean the Commodity Credit Corporation and includes any official
of the United States delegated the responsibility to act on behalf of
CCC.
Commodities mean U.S. agricultural commodities or products of U.S.
agricultural commodities.
CCC-provided funds means U.S. dollars provided under an agreement
to a participant for expenses for the internal transportation, storage
and handling of the donated commodities, expenses involved in the
administration and monitoring of the activities under the agreement,
and technical assistance related to the monetization of donated
commodities.
Donated commodities means the commodities donated by CCC to a
participant under an agreement. The term may include donated
commodities that are used to produce a further processed product for
use under the agreement.
FAS means the Foreign Agricultural Service acting on behalf of CCC.
FFPr means the Food for Progress Program.
Force majeure is a common clause in contracts, exempting the
parties for non-fulfillment of their obligations as a result of
conditions beyond their control, such as earthquakes, floods or war.
Income means interest earned on sale proceeds and other resources
received by a participant, other than sale proceeds, as a result of
carrying out an agreement. The term may include resources from VAT
refunds, activity fees, interest on loans, and others.
Participant means an entity with which CCC has entered into an
agreement.
Subrecipient means a legal entity that receives donated
commodities, income, sale proceeds or other resources from a
participant for the purpose of implementing in the targeted country
activities described in a FFPr agreement and that is accountable to
such participant for the use of such commodities, funds, or resources.
The term may include foreign or international organizations (such as
agencies of the United Nations) at the discretion of FAS.
Sale proceeds mean funds received by a participant from the sale of
donated commodities.
Targeted country means the country in which activities are
implemented under an agreement.
Sec. 1499.3 Eligibility determination.
(a) An entity will be eligible to become a participant only after
FAS determines that the entity has:
(1) Organizational experience in implementing and managing grants,
and the capability and personnel to develop, implement, monitor, report
on, and provide accountability for activities in accordance with this
part;
(2) Experience working in the proposed targeted country;
(3) Adequate financial framework to implement the activities the
entity proposes to carry out under FFPr. In order to determine whether
the entity is financially responsible, FAS may require it to submit
corporate policies and financial materials that have been audited or
otherwise reviewed by a third party;
(4) A person or agent located in the United States with respect to
which service of judicial process may be obtained by FAS on behalf of
the entity; and
(5) An operating financial account in the proposed targeted
country, or a satisfactory explanation for not having such an account
and a description of how a FFPr agreement would be administered without
such an account.
(b) In determining whether an entity will be eligible to be a
participant, FAS may consider the entity's previous compliance or
noncompliance with the provisions of this part and part 1599 of this
title. FAS may consider matters such as whether the entity corrected
deficiencies in the implementation of an agreement in a timely manner
and whether the entity has timely and accurately filed reports and
other submissions that are required to be filed with FAS and other
agencies of the United States.
Sec. 1499.4 Application process.
(a) An entity seeking to enter into an agreement with CCC shall
submit an application, in accordance with this section, that sets forth
its proposal to carry out activities under FFPr in the proposed target
country. An application shall contain the items specified in paragraph
(b) of this section and shall be submitted electronically to FAS at the
address set forth at https://www.fas.usda.gov. An entity that has not
yet met the eligibility requirements in Sec. 1499.3 may submit an
application, but FAS will not enter into an agreement with an entity
until FAS had made a determination of eligibility under Sec. 1499.3.
(b) An applicant shall include the following items in its
application:
(1) A completed Form SF-424, which is a standard application for
Federal assistance;
(2) An introduction that contains the elements specified in
paragraph (c) of this section; and
(3) A plan of operation that contains the elements specified in
paragraph (d) of this section.
(c) The introduction shall include:
(1) An explanation of the need for the food aid in the targeted
country and how the applicant's proposed activities would address that
need;
(2) Information regarding the applicant's ability to become
registered and operate in the targeted country;
[[Page 63392]]
(3) Information about the applicant's past food aid projects; and
(4) A budget that details the amount of any sale proceeds, income,
and CCC-provided funds that the applicant proposes to use to fund:
(i) Administrative costs;
(ii) Inland transportation, storage and handling costs; and
(iii) Activity costs.
(d) A plan of operation shall include:
(1) The name of the targeted country where the proposed activities
would be implemented;
(2) The kind, quantity, and proposed use of the commodities
requested, and any commodities that would be acceptable substitutions
therefore, and the proposed delivery schedule;
(3) If monetization or barter is proposed:
(i) The quantity of the requested commodities that would be sold or
bartered;
(ii) The amount of sale proceeds anticipated;
(iii) The amount of income expected to be generated;
(iv) The anticipated monetization completion date;
(v) The goods or services to be generated from the barter of the
requested commodities; and
(vi) The value of the goods or services anticipated to be generated
from the barter of the requested commodities.
(4) A list of each of the activities that would be implemented,
with a brief statement of the objectives to be accomplished under each
activity;
(5) For each proposed activity, the targeted geographic area,
anticipated beneficiaries, and methods that the applicant would use to
choose such beneficiaries, including obtaining and considering
statistics on poverty levels, food deficits, and any other required
items set forth on the FAS Web site at https://www.fas.usda.gov.
(6) For each proposed activity:
(i) An explanation of whether the activity would be carried out
through the distribution of the requested commodities or funded by sale
proceeds, income, or a combination thereof; and
(ii) The amount of commodities, sale proceeds, or income requested
to carry out such activity; and
(iii) A detailed description of the activity, including the steps
involved in its implementation and the anticipated completion date;
(7) Any cash or non-cash contributions that the applicant expects
to receive from non-CCC sources that:
(i) Are critical to the implementation of the proposed activities;
or
(ii) Enhance the implementation of the activities;
(8) Any subrecipient that would be involved and a description of
each subrecipient's responsibilities and its capability to perform
responsibilities;
(9) Any governmental or nongovernmental entities that would be
involved and the extent to which FFPr will strengthen or increase the
capabilities of such entities to further economic development in the
targeted country;
(10) The method by which the applicant intends to inform
beneficiaries of an activity about the source of the requested
commodities or funding for the activity and, where the beneficiaries
will be receiving the commodities directly, how to prepare and use them
properly;
(11) Established baselines, a timeline, and proposed outcomes that
would enable FAS to measure the applicant's progress towards achieving
the objectives of proposed activities;
(12) If the proposed activities would involve the use of sale
proceeds or income:
(i) The process that the applicant would use to sell the requested
commodities, including steps the applicant would take to use, to the
extent possible, the private sector in the monetization process; and
(ii) The procedures that the applicant would use to assure that
sale proceeds and income are received and deposited into a separate,
interest-bearing account and disbursed from such account for use only
in accordance with the agreement;
(13) A description of how the requested commodities would be
transported from the receiving port to the point at which distribution
is made to the beneficiaries and a description of any port,
transportation, storage, and warehouse facilities that would be used
with sufficient detail to demonstrate that they would be adequate to
handle the requested commodities without undue spoilage or waste;
(14) Any reprocessing or repackaging of the requested commodities
that would take place prior to the distribution, sale or barter by the
participant;
(15) The action the applicant would take to ensure that any
commodities to be distributed to beneficiaries, rather than sold, would
be imported and distributed free from all customs, duties, tolls, and
taxes;
(16) A plan that shows how the requested commodities could be
imported and distributed without a disruptive impact upon production,
prices and marketing of the same or like products in the country where
they will be delivered, and the extent to which any sale or barter of
the requested commodities would displace or interfere with any sales
that may otherwise be made by the applicant or any other entity in the
country where they will be delivered; and
(17) Any additional required items set forth on the FAS Web site at
https://www.fas.usda.gov.
Sec. 1499.5 Agreements.
(a) After FAS approves an applicant's proposal, FAS will develop an
agreement in consultation with the applicant. The agreement will set
forth the obligations of CCC and the participant. A participant must
comply with the terms of the agreement to receive assistance.
(b) A participant shall not use donated commodities, sale proceeds,
income or CCC-provided funds for any activity or any expenses incurred
by the participant prior to the date of the agreement or after the
agreement is suspended or terminated.
(c) The agreement will include a budget that sets forth the maximum
amounts of sale proceeds and CCC-provided funds that may be expended
for various purposes under the agreement. A participant may make
adjustments to this budget without prior approval from FAS only as
specified in the agreement.
(d) Prior to providing any donated commodities or CCC-provided
funds to a participant under an agreement, FAS may require the
participant to complete a training program administered by FAS that is
designed to ensure that the participant is aware of, and has the
capacity to complete all required reporting and audit functions set
forth in this part.
(e) A participant will be prohibited from using CCC-provided funds
to acquire goods and services either directly or indirectly through
another party from certain countries that will be specified in the
agreement. Any violation of this provision of the agreement will be a
basis for immediate termination by CCC of the agreement in addition to
the imposition of any other applicable civil and criminal penalties.
(f) The agreement will prohibit the sale or transshipment of the
donated commodities to a country not specified in the agreement for so
long as such donated commodities are controlled by the participant.
(g) CCC may enter into a multicountry agreement in which donated
commodities are delivered to one country and activities are carried out
in another.
(h) CCC may provide donated commodities and CCC-provided funds
under a multiyear agreement contingent
[[Page 63393]]
upon the availability of commodities and funds.
Sec. 1499.6 Payments.
(a) If the participant arranges for transportation in accordance
with Sec. 1499.7(b)(2), and the participant seeks payment directly,
the participant shall submit the following documents to FAS in the
manner set forth in the agreement:
(1) A signed copy of the completed Form CCC-512;
(2) The original on-board bills of lading indicating the freight
rate and signed by the originating carrier;
(3) For all non-containerized cargoes:
(i) A signed copy of the Federal Grain Inspection Service (FGIS)
Official Stowage Examination Certificate (Vessel Hold Certificate);
(ii) A signed copy of the National Cargo Bureau Certificate of
Readiness (Vessel Hold Inspection Certificate; and
(iii) A signed copy of the National Cargo Bureau Certificate of
Loading;
(4) For all containerized cargoes a copy of the FGIS Container
Condition Inspection Certificate;
(5) A signed copy of liner booking note or charter party covering
ocean transportation of cargo;
(6) In the case of charter shipments, a signed notice of arrival at
first discharge port, unless FAS has determined that circumstances of
force majeure have prevented the vessel's arrival at the first port of
discharge;
(7) A request by the participant for reimbursement of freight,
survey costs, and other expenses approved by CCC indicating the amount
due and accompanied by a certification from the carrier or other
parties that payments have been received from the participant; and
(8) A document on letterhead and signed by an officer or agent of
the participant specifying the name of the entity to receive payment;
the bank ABA number to which payment is to be made; the account number
for the deposit at the bank; the participant's taxpayer identification
number; and the type of the account into which the payment will be
deposited.
(b) If the participant arranges for transportation in accordance
with Sec. 1499.7(b)(2), and the participant has used a freight
forwarder, the participant shall cause the freight forwarder to submit
the documents specified in Sec. 1499.6(a) in order to receive payment
from CCC.
(c) In no case will CCC reimburse a participant for demurrage costs
or pay demurrage to any other entity.
(d) If FAS has agreed to pay the costs of transporting, storing,
and distributing the donated commodities from the designated port or
point of entry, the participant will be reimbursed in the manner as set
forth in the agreement.
(e) If the agreement authorizes the payment of CCC-provided funds,
CCC will pay this to the participant on a reimbursement for expenses
basis, except as provided in paragraph (f)(1) of this section. The
participant shall request the payment of CCC-provided funds to
reimburse it for authorized expenses in the manner set forth in the
agreement.
(f)(1) A participant may request an advance of the amount of funds
specified in the agreement. FAS will not approve any request for an
advance:
(i) Received earlier than 60 days after the date of a previous
advance made in connection with the same agreement, and
(ii) If any required reports, as specified in Sec. 1499.13 and in
the agreement, are more than six months in arrears.
(2) Except as may otherwise be provided in the agreement, the
participant shall deposit and maintain in a bank account located in the
United States all funds advanced by CCC. The account shall be interest-
bearing, unless the exceptions in Sec. 3019.22(k) of this title apply,
or FAS determines that this requirement would constitute an undue
burden. The participant shall remit semi-annually to CCC any interest
earned on the advanced funds. The participant shall, no later than 10
days after the end of each calendar quarter, submit a financial
statement to FAS accounting for all funds advanced and all interest
earned.
(3) The participant shall return to CCC any funds that are advanced
by CCC if such funds have not been obligated as of the 180th day after
the advance was made. Such funds and interest shall be transferred to
FAS within 30 days of such date.
(g) If a participant is required to pay funds to CCC in connection
with an agreement, the participant shall make such payment in U.S.
dollars, unless otherwise approved in advance by FAS.
(h) Suppliers of commodities shall seek payment for goods according
to the purchase contract with CCC.
Sec. 1499.7 Transportation of goods.
(a) Shipments of donated commodities are subject to the
requirements of 46 U.S.C. 55305 and 55314, regarding carriage on U.S.-
flag vessels.
(b) Transportation of donated commodities and other goods such as
bags that may be provided by CCC under FFPr will be acquired under a
specific agreement in the manner determined by FAS. Such transportation
will be acquired by:
(1) CCC in accordance with the Federal Acquisition Regulations
(FAR), USDA's procurement regulations set forth in chapter 4 of title
48 of the Code of Federal Regulations (the AGAR) and directives issued
by the Director, Office of Procurement and Property Management, USDA;
or
(2) The participant, with reimbursement by CCC, in the manner
specified in the agreement.
(c) Participants that acquire transportation in accordance with
paragraph (b)(2) of this section, may use the services of a licensed
freight forwarder that:
(1) Demonstrates at least three years experience in freight
forwarding and booking services;
(2) Is accredited or authorized to act as a licensed freight
forwarder;
(3) Has the capability to work with the participant to plan,
implement, and monitor the logistics involved in transporting the
donated commodities;
(4) Provides three years of audited financial statements to the
participant that demonstrates sound financial standing; and
(5) Would not have a conflict of interest in carrying out the
freight forwarder duties. To assist FAS in determining whether there is
a potential conflict of interest, the participant must submit to FAS a
certification indicating that the freight forwarder:
(i) Is not engaged in, and will not engage in, supplying
commodities or furnishing ocean transportation or ocean transportation-
related services for commodities provided under the participant's Food
for Progress program; and
(ii) Is not affiliated with and not made arrangements to give or
receive any payment, kickback, or illegal benefit in connection with
its selection as an agent of the participant.
(d) Participants responsible for transportation under Sec.
1499.7(b)(2) shall declare in the transportation contract the point at
which the ocean carrier to take custody of commodity to be transported.
Sec. 1499.8 Entry and handling of commodities.
(a) The participant shall make all necessary arrangements for
receiving the donated commodities in the targeted country, including
obtaining appropriate approvals for entry and transit. The participant
shall store and maintain the donated commodities in good condition from
the time of delivery at the port of entry or the point of
[[Page 63394]]
receipt from the originating carrier until their distribution, sale or
barter.
(b) The participant shall, as provided in the agreement, arrange
for transporting, storing, and distributing the donated commodities
from the designated point and time where title to the commodity passes
to the participant by contracting directly with suppliers of services,
as set forth in the agreement.
(c)(1) If a participant arranges for the packaging or repackaging
of donated commodities that are to be distributed, the participant
shall ensure that the packaging:
(i) Is plainly labeled in the language of the targeted country;
(ii) Contains the name of the donated commodities;
(iii) Includes a statement indicating that the donated commodities
are furnished by the people of the United States of America; and
(iv) Includes a statement indicating that the donated commodities
shall not be sold, exchanged or bartered.
(2) If a participant arranges for the reprocessing and repackaging
of donated commodities that are to be distributed, the participant
shall ensure that the packaging:
(i) Is plainly labeled in the language of the targeted country;
(ii) Contains the name of the reprocessed product;
(iii) Includes a statement indicating that the reprocessed product
was made with commodities furnished by the people of the United States
of America; and,
(iv) Includes a statement indicating that the reprocessed product
shall not be sold, exchanged or bartered;
(3) If a participant distributes donated commodities that are not
packaged, the participant shall, to the extent practicable, display:
(i) Banners, posters or other media informing the public of the
name and source of the donated commodities; and
(ii) A statement that the donated commodities may not be sold,
exchanged, or bartered.
(d) A participant shall arrange with the government of the targeted
country that all donated commodities to be distributed will be imported
and distributed free from all customs, duties, tolls, and taxes. A
participant is encouraged to make similar arrangements, where possible,
with the government of the country where donated commodities to be sold
or bartered are delivered.
Sec. 1499.9 Damage to or loss of commodities.
(a) FAS will be responsible for the donated commodities prior to
the transfer of title to the commodities to the participant. The
participant will be responsible for the donated commodities following
the transfer of title to the commodities to the participant. The title
will transfer at the time and place specified in the agreement.
(b) A participant shall immediately inform FAS, in the manner set
forth in the agreement, of any damage to or loss of the donated
commodities that occurs following the transfer of title to the
commodities to the participant. The participant shall take all steps
necessary to protect its interests and the interests of CCC with
respect to any damage to or loss of the donated commodities that occurs
after title has been transferred to the participant.
(c) If the donated commodities are damaged or lost during the time
that they are in the care of the carrier:
(1) And either FAS or the participant engages the services of an
independent cargo surveyor, the surveyor will provide to FAS and the
participant any report, narrative chronology or other commentary that
it prepares;
(2) FAS and the participant will provide to each other the names
and addresses of any individuals known to be present at the time of
discharge or during the survey who can verify the quantity of damaged
or lost commodities;
(3) And the participant engages the services of the surveyor, CCC
will reimburse the participant for the reasonable costs, as determined
by FAS, of the survey, unless:
(i) The participant was required by the agreement to pay for the
survey;
(ii) The survey was a delivery survey and the surveyor did not also
prepare a discharge survey; or
(iii) The survey was not conducted contemporaneously with the
discharge of the vessel, unless FAS determines that such action was
justified under the circumstances;
(4) Any survey obtained by the participant shall, to the extent
practicable, be conducted jointly by the surveyor, the participant, the
carrier, and the survey report shall be signed by all parties;
(5) And the damage or loss occurred with respect to a bulk grain
shipment, if the agreement provides that the participant is responsible
for survey and outturn reports, the participant shall obtain the
services of an independent cargo surveyor to:
(i) Observe the discharge of the cargo;
(ii) Report on discharging methods, including scale type,
calibrations and any other factor that may affect the accuracy of scale
weights, and, if scales are not used, state the reason therefore and
describe the actual method used to determine weight;
(iii) Estimate the quantity of cargo, if any, lost during discharge
through carrier negligence;
(iv) Advise on the quality of sweepings;
(v) Obtain copies of port or vessel records, if possible, showing
the quantity discharged; and
(vi) Notify the participant immediately if the surveyor has reason
to believe that the correct quantity was not discharged or if
additional services are necessary to protect the cargo; and, (6) And
the damage or loss occurred with respect to a container shipment, if
the agreement provides that the participant is responsible for survey
and outturn reports, the participant shall obtain the services of an
independent cargo surveyor to list the container numbers and seal
numbers shown on the containers, indicate whether the seals were intact
at the time the containers were opened, and note whether the containers
were in any way damaged.
(d) If the value of any damaged donated commodities is in excess of
$1,000, the participant shall immediately arrange for an inspection by
a public health official or other competent authority approved by FAS
and provide to FAS a certification by such public health official or
other competent authority regarding the exact quantity and condition of
the damaged commodities. The participant shall inform FAS of the
results of the inspection and indicate whether the damaged commodities
are:
(1) Fit for the use authorized in the agreement and, if so, whether
there has been a diminution in quality; or
(2) Unfit for the use authorized in the agreement.
(e)(1) If the participant has title to the donated commodities, the
participant shall arrange for the recovery of that portion of the
donated commodities designated as suitable for the use authorized in
the agreement. The participant shall dispose of donated commodities
that are unfit for such use in the following order of priority:
(i) Sale for the most appropriate use, i.e., animal feed,
fertilizer, industrial use, or another use approved by FAS, at the
highest obtainable price;
(ii) Donation to a governmental or charitable organization for use
as animal feed or for other non-food use; or
(iii) Destruction of the commodities if they are unfit for any use,
in such manner as to prevent their use for any purpose.
[[Page 63395]]
(2) The participant shall arrange for all U.S. Government markings
to be obliterated or removed before the donated commodities are
transferred by sale or donation.
(f) A participant may retain any proceeds generated by the disposal
of the donated commodities in accordance with paragraph (e)(1) of this
section, and shall use the proceeds for expenses related to the
disposal of the donated commodities and for activities specified in the
agreement.
(g) The participant shall notify FAS immediately and provide
detailed information about the actions taken in accordance with
paragraph (e)(1) of this section, including the quantities, values and
dispositions used to handle commodities determined to be unfit.
Sec. 1499.10 Claims for damage to or loss of commodities.
(a) FAS will be responsible for claims arising out of damage to or
loss of a quantity of the donated commodities prior to the transfer of
title to the commodities to the participant.
(b) If the value of the damaged or lost donated commodities is
estimated to be $20,000 or more and the title to the commodities has
transferred to the participant, the participant will be responsible
for:
(1) Initiating a claim arising out of such damage or loss,
including actions relating to collections pursuant to commercial
insurance contracts; and
(2) Notifying FAS immediately and providing detailed information
about the circumstances surrounding such damage or loss, the quantity
of damaged or lost donated commodities, and the value of the damage or
loss.
(c) If the value of the damaged or lost donated commodities is
estimated to be less than $20,000, the participant will be responsible
for providing detailed information about the damage or loss in the next
report required to be filed under Sec. 1499.13(c) and shall not be
required to initiate a claim collection action.
(d)(1) The value of a claim for lost donated commodities shall be
determined on the basis of the commodity acquisition, transportation,
and related costs incurred by CCC with respect to such commodities.
(2) The value of a claim for damaged donated commodities shall be
determined on the basis of the commodity acquisition, transportation,
and related costs incurred by CCC with respect to such commodities,
less any funds generated if such commodities are sold in accordance
with Sec. 1499.9(e)(1).
(e) If FAS determines that a participant is not exercising due
diligence in the pursuit of a claim, FAS may require the participant to
assign its rights to pursue the claim to FAS.
(f)(1) The participant may retain any funds obtained as a result of
a claims collection action initiated by it in accordance with this
section, or recovered pursuant to any insurance policy or other similar
form of indemnification, but such funds shall only be expended for
purposes approved in advance by FAS.
(2) FAS will retain any funds obtained as a result of a claims
collection action initiated by it under this section; provided,
however, that if the participant paid for the freight or a portion
thereof, FAS will use a portion of such funds to reimburse the
participant for such expense on a prorated basis.
Sec. 1499.11 Use of commodities and sale proceeds.
(a) A participant must use the donated commodities in accordance
with the agreement.
(b) A participant shall not permit the distribution, handling, or
allocation of donated commodities on the basis of political
affiliation, geographic location, or the ethnic, tribal or religious
identity of affiliation of the potential consumers or beneficiaries.
(c) A participant shall not permit the distribution, handling, or
allocation of donated commodities by the military forces or any
government or insurgent group without the specific authorization of
FAS.
(d) A participant may sell or barter donated commodities only if
such sale or barter is provided for in the agreement or the participant
is disposing of damaged commodities as specified in Sec. 1499.9. The
participant shall sell the donated commodities at a reasonable market
price in the economy where the sale occurs. The participant shall use
any sale proceeds, income, or goods or services derived from the sale
or barter of the donated commodities only as provided in the agreement.
(e) The participant shall retain copies of and make available to
FAS all barter receipts, contracts or other documents related to the
barter of the donated commodities and the services or goods derived
from such barter, for a minimum of 24 months after the agreement has
been terminated or closed out.
(f) The participant shall deposit all sale proceeds and income into
a separate, interest-bearing account unless the exceptions in Sec.
3019.22(k) of this title apply, the account is in a country where the
laws or customs prohibit the payment of interest, or FAS determines
that this requirement would constitute an undue burden.
(g) A participant may use sale proceeds or income to purchase real
or personal property only if local law permits the participant to
retain title to such property. However, the participant shall not use
sale proceeds or income to pay for the acquisition, development,
construction, alteration or upgrade of real property that is:
(1) Owned or managed by a church or other organization engaged
exclusively in religious pursuits; or
(2) Used in whole or in part for sectarian purposes, except that a
participant may use sale proceeds or income to pay for repairs to or
rehabilitation of a structure located on such real property to the
extent necessary to avoid spoilage or loss of donated commodities, but
only if such structure is not used in whole or in part for any
religious or sectarian purposes while the donated commodities are
stored in it. If such use is not specifically provided for in the
agreement, such use may only occur after receipt of written approval
from FAS.
(h) A participant shall endeavor to comply with Sec. Sec. 3019.41
through 3019.43 of this title when procuring goods and services and
when engaging in construction work to implement the agreement. The
participant shall also establish procedures to prevent fraud. The
participant shall enter into a written contract with each provider of
goods, services or construction work that requires the provider to
maintain adequate records to account for all donated commodities or
funds or both provided to the provider by the participant and to submit
periodic reports to the participant. The participant shall submit a
copy of the signed contracts to FAS.
Sec. 1499.12 Subrecipients.
(a) If provided for in the agreement, a participant may utilize the
services of a subrecipient to implement activities under this
agreement. The participant shall enter into a written subagreement with
the subrecipient, and provide a copy of such subagreement to FAS, in
the manner set forth in the agreement, prior to the transfer of any
donated commodities, sale proceeds, income or CCC-provided funds to the
subrecipient. Such written subagreement shall require the subrecipient
to pay to the participant the value of any donated commodities, sale
proceeds, income, or CCC-provided cash funds that is not used in
accordance with the subagreement, or are lost, damaged, or
[[Page 63396]]
misused as a result of the subrecipient's failure to exercise
reasonable care.
(b) If a participant demonstrates to FAS that it is not feasible to
enter into a subagreement with a subrecipient, FAS may grant approval
to proceed without a subagreement; provided, however, that the
participant must obtain such approval from FAS prior to transferring
any donated commodities, sale proceeds, income, or CCC-provided funds
to the subrecipient.
(c) The participant shall monitor the actions of a subrecipient as
necessary to ensure that donated commodities or funds provided to the
subrecipient are used for authorized purposes in compliance with
applicable laws and regulations and the agreement and that performance
goals are achieved. The participant shall provide in the subagreement
that the subrecipient must comply with applicable provisions of the
regulations set forth in Chapter 30 of this title.
Sec. 1499.13 Recordkeeping and reporting requirements.
(a) A program participant shall retain records and perm