Solicitation of Federal Civilian and Uniformed Service Personnel for Contributions to Private Voluntary Organizations-Eligibility and Public Accountability Standards, 67276-67290 [E6-19628]
Download as PDF
67276
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 223 / Monday, November 20, 2006 / Rules and Regulations
OFFICE OF PERSONNEL
MANAGEMENT
5 CFR Part 950
RIN 3206–AL05
Solicitation of Federal Civilian and
Uniformed Service Personnel for
Contributions to Private Voluntary
Organizations—Eligibility and Public
Accountability Standards
Office of Personnel
Management.
ACTION: Final rule.
sroberts on PROD1PC70 with RULES
AGENCY:
SUMMARY: The Office of Personnel
Management (OPM) is issuing final
regulations concerning the Combined
Federal Campaign (CFC). These final
regulations are being issued as part of
OPM’s effort to modernize the CFC and
to realize administrative efficiencies.
They were designed to address the
current and future environment of the
CFC where the electronic transmission
of information will be more routine. As
such, these regulations update the
criteria for CFC eligibility, streamline
the charity application process, ease the
administrative burden on the local
campaigns, promote the use of
electronic technology in the
administration of the CFC, and expand
opportunities during disasters and
emergencies for Federal donors to
contribute to all charities participating
in the CFC regardless of location.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Mark W. Lambert by telephone at (202)
606–2564; by FAX at (202) 606–5056; or
by e-mail at cfc@opm.gov.
DATES: These regulations are effective
November 20, 2006.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: Pursuant
to 5 U.S.C. 553(d)(3), the Director of the
Office of Personnel Management finds
good cause to waive the 30 day effective
date for these regulations. Many
national/international organizations
including federations, federation
members, and independent
organizations, are beginning to prepare
for filling out their 2007 CFC
applications for submission to OPM in
January 2007. If those organizations
begin that process under the current
regulations, then are required to revise
those applications pursuant to these
revised regulations, resources may be
needlessly expended, there will be
confusion in revising applications, and
some applicants who would be eligible
under the revised regulations might not
apply under the current regulations.
Finally, there will be confusion and
resource implications for OPM to begin
the review process when applications
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:36 Nov 17, 2006
Jkt 211001
may need to be withdrawn or revised if
the regulations were not to become
effective until mid December or later.
OPM is issuing final regulations
concerning eligibility provisions and
administrative requirements governing
the participation of organizations and
the administration of the CFC. These
final regulations present a balanced
approach to the current and anticipated
future needs of the CFC and continue
the tradition of accountability in the
CFC by providing Federal donors with
assurances that CFC participating
charities provide real services and are
fiscally accountable. OPM encourages
stakeholders and non-profit sector
institutions with an oversight mission to
collaborate to ensure that all charities
are fully accountable to the public they
serve. OPM will continue to emphasize
the importance of providing complete,
accurate, and timely financial reports to
donors, regulators and the public, and
will support donors by providing them
with information to evaluate the
charities of their choice.
On June 29, 2006 (71 FR 37003), OPM
issued comprehensive proposed
regulations to revise the procedures
governing the solicitation of Federal
civilian and uniformed services
personnel at the workplace for
contributions to private non-profit
organizations. That workplace
solicitation is known as the CFC,
administered by OPM under the
authority of Executive Order 12353
(March 23, 1982) as amended by
Executive Order 12404 (February 10,
1983). The proposed regulations were
issued to reduce the burden on
applicant charitable organizations
seeking to qualify for the CFC, simplify
the administrative process of
determining whether charitable
organizations are eligible to participate
in the CFC, and facilitate modernization
of the CFC. The proposed regulations
are available at https://
a257.g.akamaitech.net/7/257/2422/
01jan20061800/edocket.access.gpo.gov/
2006/pdf/06–5795.pdf.
In this final rule, OPM addresses the
comments received on the proposed
rules set forth at 5 CFR part 950. The 45
day public comment period ended
August 14, 2006. A total of 415
comments were received from
participating CFC organizations,
Principal Combined Fund
Organizations, members of Local
Federal Coordinating Committees,
individuals and a Federal government
agency.
PO 00000
Frm 00002
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
Eligibility Provisions and Public
Accountability Standards
Under the existing CFC regulations,
there were 16 core eligibility and public
accountability standards and 3 core
administrative requirements that a
charitable organization was required to
satisfy in order to participate in the
CFC. These appeared in the form of
certifications in the annual CFC
application. Many of the standards
required specific documentation, such
as audited financial statements and an
annual report to demonstrate
compliance. OPM had proposed
removing eight of these standards,
including the requirement that
participating organizations’
administrative and fundraising expenses
not exceed 25 percent of its total
revenue. OPM had proposed modifying
some of the remaining standards to
eliminate documented proof of
compliance. The standards of eligibility
and accountability being adopted by
OPM in this Final Rule are summarized
as follows:
1. Section 950.202(a)—National List
Eligibility Requirements—Certify that
the applicant organization provides or
conducts real services, benefits,
assistance, or program activities, in 15
or more different states or a foreign
country over the 3 year period
immediately preceding the start of the
year involved. The proposed regulation
set forth that a detailed schedule would
be required as part of the application
that described activities in each state or
foreign country in each year. In
addition, OPM clarified the types of
information that it would consider
acceptable to determine that real
services are provided or to accurately
determine the individuals or entities
who benefit from the services. In
addition, OPM proposed adding a
statement to clarify that de minimis
services, benefits, assistance, or other
program activities in any state or foreign
country would not be accepted as a
basis for eligibility. One organization
and one individual commented with a
concern that OPM’s attempt to clarify
the eligibility requirements would still
result in limited additional guidance for
charities, federations, and OPM
personnel. Both comments
recommended that OPM amend the
regulations to adopt an extensive list of
factors against which OPM could
evaluate whether an organization has
made a clear showing of actual services,
benefits, assistance or activities
provided in each state or foreign
country and also suggested criteria that
OPM should adopt to define what
constitutes substantial services. OPM
E:\FR\FM\20NOR3.SGM
20NOR3
sroberts on PROD1PC70 with RULES
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 223 / Monday, November 20, 2006 / Rules and Regulations
carefully considered these comments
but is not accepting these
recommendations and the Final Rule
will adopt the proposed regulation.
OPM believes that the most appropriate
vehicle for any additional guidance in
this area is through use of the existing
CFC administrative memoranda process
and through additional instructions in
how to complete the annual CFC
application.
2. Section 950.202(b)—National List
Eligibility Requirements—Certify that
the applicant organization is recognized
by the Internal Revenue Service as taxexempt under 26 U.S.C. 501(c)(3) and to
which contributions are tax-deductible
pursuant to 26 U.S.C. 170(c)(2) and that
the organization is classified as a public
charity under 26 U.S.C. 509(a). OPM
proposed this revision to clarify that
applicant organizations must be public
charities, not private foundations, or
exclusively government units or
instrumentalities thereof. There were no
comments on this proposal and OPM is
adopting this change as proposed.
3. Section 950.203(a)(1)—Public
Accountability Standards—Certify that
the applicant organization is a human
health and welfare organization
providing services, benefits, or
assistance to, or conducting activities
affecting, human health and welfare. No
changes were proposed to this standard
and it remains the same as the existing
regulation.
4. Section 950.203(a)(2)—Public
Accountability Standards—Certify that
the applicant organization accounts for
its funds in accordance with generally
accepted accounting principles and that
an audit of the organization’s fiscal
operations is completed annually by an
independent certified public accountant
in accordance with generally accepted
auditing standards. Under the proposed
rule, applicants would no longer have
been required to actually submit a copy
of a recent audit with the application.
OPM also proposed to require a
certification that the organization had
an audit only if it sought CFC
participation on the national/
international or international parts of
the charity list and if it reported
$250,000 or more in revenue on its IRS
Form 990. OPM proposed to exempt
from the audit requirement applicant
organizations seeking to participate in
the CFC at the local level that reported
revenue of less than $250,000.
Numerous comments were received
both in support of and against this
proposal. Those opposed argued that
reducing the number of CFC charities
that are independently audited would
increase the risk of fiscal
mismanagement on the part of such
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:36 Nov 17, 2006
Jkt 211001
charities and could increase the number
of applications for inclusion in the CFC.
Those in favor noted that the cost of an
audit imposes a disproportionate
burden on smaller, local charitable
organizations.
OPM has considered these various
concerns. OPM agrees that by requiring
charities with revenues over $250,000
seeking to participate in a local
campaign to submit audited financial
statements with the application Federal
donors will have additional assurances
that such organization is fiscally
accountable. OPM is also retaining the
existing regulatory requirement that
organizations seeking to participate on
the national/international and
international parts of the charity list,
regardless of their revenues, certify that
they account for funds in accordance
with generally accepted accounting
principles, have an audit of their
financial statements conducted by an
independent certified public accountant
in accordance with generally accepted
auditing standards, and submit a copy
of their audited financial statements. In
a departure from the existing regulation,
organizations seeking local participation
will be required to make those same
certifications and submit a copy of their
audited financial statements only if
their revenues are over $250,000.
Organizations with revenues between
$100,000 and $250,000 seeking local
participation will be required to certify
that they account for funds in
accordance with generally accepted
accounting principles and have an audit
of their financial statements conducted
by an independent certified public
accountant in accordance with generally
accepted auditing standards, but will
not be required to submit the audited
financial statements with their
application. Charities with revenues less
than $100,000 seeking local
participation will be required to certify
that they have adequate financial
controls in place, in form or substance
as specified by OPM, but will not be
required to submit these with their
application.
5. Section 950.203(a)(3)—Public
Accountability Standards—Certify that
it prepares and submits to the IRS a
complete copy of the organization’s IRS
Form 990 or that it is not required to
submit an IRS Form 990, and provide a
completed copy of the organization’s
IRS Form 990, including signature, with
the CFC application regardless of
whether or not the IRS requires the
organization to file this form. OPM
proposed to revise this standard to
require a certification in addition to
having the applicant submit a copy of
the completed IRS Form 990 together
PO 00000
Frm 00003
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
67277
with supplemental statements and
Schedule A with the application. OPM
also proposed to no longer routinely
check to determine whether the IRS
Form 990 revenues and expenses
reported reconcile with the audited
financial statements since this
reconciliation is required to be
performed by the organization on the
IRS Form 990 in Parts IV–A and IV–B.
Comments opposing the proposed rule
noted that the level of CFC
accountability would be lowered if the
previously required reconciliation
between the IRS Form 990 and the
audited financials were removed.
Comments in favor of the proposed
change suggested that the current
reconciliation statement that
organizations are required to provide on
the IRS Form 990 should be sufficient
to qualify for participation in the CFC.
One organization pointed out that
efforts by leading nonprofit
infrastructure organizations to achieve
greater consistency in financial
reporting standards for the charitable
sector are the most appropriate vehicle
to promote improved reporting to the
IRS and should not be used as a means
to exclude charities from the CFC. OPM
agrees with the comments in favor and
will adopt the proposed regulation in
the final rule.
6. Section 950.203(a)(4)—Public
Accountability Standards—Provide a
computation of the organization’s
percentage of total support and revenue
spent on administrative and
fundraising. This percentage shall be
computed from information on the IRS
Form 990, submitted pursuant to
existing regulations at section
950.203(a)(3), by adding the amount
spent on ‘‘management and general’’
(line 14) to ‘‘fundraising’’ (line 15) and
then dividing the sum by ‘‘total
revenue’’ (line 12). No substantive
changes were proposed to this standard.
The references to specific lines of the
IRS Form 990 were removed, in
anticipation of future changes to the
Form by the IRS and the proposed
regulation will be adopted in the final
rule.
7. Section 950.203(a)(5)—Public
Accountability Standards—Certify that
the organization is directed by an active
and responsible governing body whose
members have no material conflict of
interest and a majority of which serve
without compensation. No changes were
proposed to this standard. One
commenter suggested that CFC charities
be required to provide the names and
terms of their governing board and dates
of prior year board meetings. OPM notes
that under the current CFC regulations,
the Director currently has the discretion
E:\FR\FM\20NOR3.SGM
20NOR3
sroberts on PROD1PC70 with RULES
67278
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 223 / Monday, November 20, 2006 / Rules and Regulations
to request this information as deemed
necessary.
8. Section 950.203(a)(6)—Public
Accountability Standards—Certify that
the organization’s fundraising practices
prohibit the sale or lease of its CFC
contributor lists. OPM proposed
removing this standard. Due to the
number of public comments that
claimed this could undermine donor
confidence in the CFC, OPM is
withdrawing this proposed regulation
and will retain the existing regulation.
9. Section 950.203(a)(7)—Public
Accountability Standards—Certify that
the applicant organization’s publicity
and promotional activities are based
upon its actual program and operations,
are truthful and non-deceptive, and
make no exaggerated or misleading
claims. OPM had proposed to remove
this standard. A majority of comments
favored retention of this certification as
a precaution against abuse by applicant
organizations and as a possible
enforcement tool in cases of use of
deceptive methods to mislead donors.
OPM is withdrawing the proposed
regulation and will retain its existing
regulation.
10. Section 950.203(a)(8)—Public
Accountability Standards—Certify that
contributions are effectively used for the
announced purposes of the charitable
organization. No changes were proposed
to this standard.
11. Section 950.203(a)(12)—Public
Accountability Standards—Provide a
statement that the certifying official is
authorized by the organization to certify
and affirm all statements required for
inclusion on the national list. No
changes were proposed to this standard.
12. Section 950.203(a)(13)—Public
Accountability Standards—Provide a
statement in 25 words or less describing
the program activities of the charitable
organization. As proposed, this
provision is being removed as an
eligibility standard, but is retained as an
administrative requirement in section
950.401(g)(2) and will be required from
each charitable organization completing
the CFC application. One commenter
proposed that OPM specify that the 25word statement is not permitted to be
misleading. OPM points out that section
950.203(a)(7) of the existing CFC
regulation, which will be retained in the
Final Rule, requires that organizations
certify that their publicity and
promotional activities are truthful and
non-deceptive. OPM believes that
section 950.203(a)(13) is more
appropriate as an administrative
requirement. The proposed change is
therefore adopted in the final rule.
13. Section 950.605—Sanctions
Compliance Certification—Each
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:36 Nov 17, 2006
Jkt 211001
federation, federation member and
unaffiliated organization applying for
participation in the CFC must, as a
condition of participation, complete a
certification that it is in compliance
with all statutes, Executive orders, and
regulations restricting or prohibiting
U.S. persons from engaging in
transactions and dealings with
countries, entities or individuals subject
to economic sanctions administered by
the U.S. Department of the Treasury’s
Office of Foreign Assets Control
(OFAC). No changes were proposed to
this certification.
Current Eligibility and Public
Accountability Standards Removed in
the Final Rule
1. Section 950.202(c)—National List
Eligibility Requirements—Certify that
the organization has no expenses
connected with lobbying and attempts
to influence voting or legislation at the
local, State, or Federal level or
alternatively, that those expenses would
classify the organization as a tax-exempt
organization under 26 U.S.C. 501(h).
The majority of comments broadly
supported OPM’s proposed removal of
this standard because the existing
regulatory requirement has been
misconstrued by some as prohibiting
permissible advocacy by charities
participating in the CFC.
Given the interrelatedness of items 2
and 3, and the comments received, the
analysis follows after item 3—Section
950.203(a)(4)(ii).
2. Section 950.203(a)(4)(i)—Public
Accountability Standards—If an
organization’s administrative and
fundraising expenses exceed 25 percent
of its total support and revenue, it must
certify that its actual expenses for
administration and fundraising are
reasonable under all the circumstances
presented. It must provide an
explanation with its CFC application
and also include a formal plan to reduce
these expenses below 25 percent.
3. Section 950.203(a)(4)(ii)—Public
Accountability Standards—The Director
may reject any application from an
organization with fundraising and
administrative expenses in excess of 25
percent of total support and revenue,
unless the organization demonstrates to
the satisfaction of the Director that its
actual expenses for those purposes and
its plan to reduce them are reasonable
under the circumstances.
A significant majority of comments on
these requirements opposed OPM’s
proposal to remove the 25 percent
administrative and fundraising rates
(AFR) threshold and the explanation
and reduction plan requirements as a
condition of participation in the CFC.
PO 00000
Frm 00004
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
The commenters argued that allowing a
charity, regardless of its AFR ratio, to
participate in the CFC would result in
an expansive increase in the number of
applicant organizations applying to the
CFC. Commenters noted that such
increase could significantly raise the
costs to manage the application process
and increase local campaign expenses to
produce larger brochures. Many
comments suggested that OPM should
instead increase the acceptable AFR
threshold to 35 percent, consistent with
the standards commonly used by
stakeholders in the charitable
community. Other comments stated that
the existing regulation should be
retained and that OPM should not
expect that donors would have the
capability or resources to conduct their
own research regarding an
organization’s AFR. One national
organization commenter supported the
elimination of the AFR standard as long
as information about these expenses is
readily made available to donors. That
same organization suggested that OPM
require applicant organizations with
AFRs that exceed 35 percent to also
include an explanation or rationale for
the higher expenditures.
While OPM carefully considered this
matter, OPM is adopting its proposed
regulation in the final rule and is
removing the 25 percent AFR ceiling as
an eligibility standard. The issue of
obtaining a specific AFR in order to
participate, the subjective nature of
OPM’s determination regarding an
acceptable explanation of a high AFR,
and the determination of the merits of
the proposed reduction plan have
caused an administrative burden on
OPM staff. Much of the litigation
affecting the CFC in the past several
years have centered on this issue,
resulting in a substantial resource drain
on OPM staff, including the Office of
CFC Operations. OPM believes that
Federal donors are capable of
determining what their acceptable AFR
levels should be for charities they
consider supporting. In the interest of
ensuring that potential Federal donors
are informed of participating
organizations’ AFR, OPM will continue
to calculate and publish the AFR of
participating charities by listing the
AFR in CFC information including the
charity lists that are distributed to the
donor. OPM will add a statement to all
CFC Brochures that will note that OPM,
as well as the philanthropic community
at large, remains concerned about
excessive AFR levels. The Brochure will
inform the CFC donor that the
philanthropic community generally
considers an AFR in excess of 35% to
E:\FR\FM\20NOR3.SGM
20NOR3
sroberts on PROD1PC70 with RULES
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 223 / Monday, November 20, 2006 / Rules and Regulations
be problematic and that potential CFC
donors should carefully review the
circumstances applicable to the
potential charities of their choice to be
certain they fully understand and accept
the AFR situations for such charities
before donating to them.
OPM believes that Federal donors
should have an opportunity to donate to
a wide range of charitable organizations
and should not be limited in their
choices to those charities with AFRs of
a specific rate, so long as the AFR
information is available to them to make
an informed decision. OPM encourages
Federal donors to be knowledgeable
about those charities to which they
choose to donate. OPM already requires
organizations to provide their World
Wide Web address, if available, where
donors can research the organization.
Many local campaigns also provide
donors with electronic access to
information from and about
participating organizations. As the CFC
continues to modernize and more
donors have more information available
through the internet, donors can have
unlimited references on most
organizations. OPM is retaining the rule
as it was proposed.
4. Section 950.203(a)(9)—Public
Accountability Standards—Certify
under which governmental entity the
charitable organization is chartered,
incorporated or organized
(Congressionally chartered or the state
in which it is registered). OPM proposed
to remove this standard. There were five
comments which opposed the proposed
removal of this standard. The comments
noted that this information was not a
burden to collect and could be used to
obtain additional information on the
organization. OPM believes that any
such additional information can be
obtained from the application itself or
from contacting the organization
directly. OPM will adopt the proposed
regulation in the final rule and will
remove this eligibility standard.
5. Section 950.203(a)(10)—Public
Accountability Standards—Certify that
the organization has received no more
than 80 percent of its total support and
revenues from government sources as
computed by dividing line 1c by line 12
from the IRS Form 990 submitted
pursuant to section 950.203(a)(3). Many
comments agreed with OPM’s proposed
removal of this standard. Two
organizations favored retaining this
certification based on the rationale that
the spirit of the CFC is to make the
charitable donations of Federal
employees available to qualified
charities, while keeping out of the CFC
those organizations which already have
stable funding and are, in essence,
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:36 Nov 17, 2006
Jkt 211001
providing government supported
services. Two other organizations agreed
with removing the standard, but
requested that any such organizations be
denoted with an asterisk in the CFC
donor brochure to alert donors that they
received more than 80 percent of their
funding from government sources. OPM
believes that the existing requirement
has served to exclude legitimate
organizations interested in diversifying
their sources of support from
participation in the CFC. OPM will
remove this standard in the final rule as
proposed.
6. Section 950.203(a)(11)—Public
Accountability Standards—Certify that
the organization prepares and makes
available to the public upon request an
annual report that includes a full
description of the organization’s
activities and supporting services and
identifies its directors and chief
administrative personnel. OPM
proposed to remove this standard
because a significant portion of the
information sought in the annual report
is already the subject of a certification
or obtained as a result of other eligibility
requirements and public accountability
standards contained in sections
950.202(a) and 950.203(a)(3). A number
of comments were received both
supporting and opposing the proposed
rule change. One comment in favor
argued that with an increasing number
of organizations using expanded online
resources to present information, the
proposed rule change would encourage
more organizations to present their
information on-line. Comments against
OPM’s proposed regulation claimed that
requiring an applicant to provide a copy
of its annual report enhances
accountability and transparency. OPM
believes that the annual report is not an
essential component of the application,
particularly since the application
requires a detailed description of
services, benefits or activities which are
carefully reviewed to determine
eligibility. OPM agrees that donors
should be encouraged to access this
information online whenever possible
or otherwise obtain an annual report
directly from the charity. OPM adopts
the proposed regulation in its final rule.
Changes corresponding to these
changes in eligibility and public
accountability requirements also are
being made to the eligibility
requirements for the local part of the
charity list contained in section
950.204, and national and local
federation standards set forth at sections
950.301, and 950.303. As proposed,
national, international and local
federations are required to submit
documents to demonstrate compliance
PO 00000
Frm 00005
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
67279
with the audit, financial, governance
and annual report requirements. These
requirements are clarified in sections
950.301(e)(2) and 950.303(e)(2).
Federations provide services to 15 or
more member organizations. Services
include the receipt and distribution of
funds through the CFC. Because
federations handle approximately 80
percent of all funds distributed through
the CFC, the documented evidence of
compliance for federations will
continue to be required.
7. Section 950.204(b)(1)(ii)—OPM has
decided not to proceed with the
proposed change that would require
statewide services to be provided over a
3 year period, and has withdrawn that
change from the final rule.
Miscellaneous Administrative Changes
In addition to changes and
modifications to the eligibility standards
described above, OPM proposed other
CFC administrative changes to clarify
CFC procedures, address areas of
concern noted over the years by OPM
and stakeholders, and to better
recognize the use of electronic
technology in the administration of the
CFC. Except where noted, comments
received on the following proposed
regulatory changes supported such
changes. Given the substantive concerns
regarding two of the proposed
administrative changes, involving
solicitation of contractor personnel on
Federal premises and the relationships
between national organizations and
their bona fide local affiliates, OPM is
withdrawing the proposed regulation
and retaining the regulations as they
previously existed with minor clarifying
changes. These issues are described in
greater detail in the next section.
Proposed changes being adopted in
the final regulations:
1. Various changes modifying
references associated with the use of
paper-based information and processes
such that these new terms apply within
an electronic CFC environment.
2. Section 950.101 includes a revised
definition of ‘‘Charity List’’ to be
consistent with section 950.401(g)(2).
Throughout the CFC regulations, OPM
has revised the terms ‘‘National and
International Lists’’ to use the terms
‘‘National/International’’ and
‘‘International’’ to be consistent with the
definition of ‘‘Charity List’’ in section
950.101 and the provisions of section
950.401(g)(2).
3. Current section 950.102(a) limits
the annual solicitation of donors to a six
week period between September 1 and
December 15. One commenter stated
that the six week period should be
retained. OPM believes that eliminating
E:\FR\FM\20NOR3.SGM
20NOR3
sroberts on PROD1PC70 with RULES
67280
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 223 / Monday, November 20, 2006 / Rules and Regulations
the requirement of a specific six week
period is in the best interests of the
campaign and will allow local campaign
leadership to determine the appropriate
length of the solicitation that must still
occur between September 1 and
December 15.
4. Current section § 950.102(c) states
that the Director exercises general
supervision over all operations of the
CFC, and takes all necessary steps to
ensure the achievement of campaign
objectives. OPM will adopt as the final
rule the proposed rule that clarifies and
specifically articulates the Director’s
authority to perform audits and
investigations of all CFC activities, and
resolve any identified issues resulting
from such audits and investigations.
5. Current section 950.103(f) describes
a six week period for soliciting donors
similar to that described in item (2)
above. Corresponding proposed changes
are adopted in the final rule.
6. Current section 950.103(h) states
that a Federal employee may participate
in a local CFC campaign only if that
employee’s official duty station is
located within the geographic
boundaries of that campaign. OPM
proposed a modification to allow for
contributions to organizations outside of
an employee’s official duty station in
the cases of emergencies and disasters
as defined in section 950.102(a), upon
approval by the Director. OPM further
proposed to give the Director authority
to remove all geographic restrictions
under any circumstances at some future
date upon the implementation of
appropriate technology. Because OPM
anticipates such elimination of these
geographic restrictions on giving at
some point in the future, local eligibility
based on adjacency and statewide
presence will no longer be necessary
and will be eliminated upon
implementation of appropriate
electronic technology to be announced
by the Director at some future date,
without the need for a new proposed
regulatory proposal. Also see related
changes proposed to section
950.204(b)(1). OPM retains these
provisions in the proposed rule.
A number of comments expressed
concern over OPM’s plans to manage
the flow of contributions during large
scale emergencies or disasters and one
organization suggested that OPM should
study the impact of this provision on
the structure and costs of the campaign.
A disaster relief organization
recommended that in the event of a
major disaster, a separate campaign for
disaster relief should be conducted
concurrently with the regular CFC in
order to distinguish better the
contributions designated for disaster
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:36 Nov 17, 2006
Jkt 211001
relief activities. OPM will consider this
suggestion but does not believe that
adoption of the proposed regulation
would preclude the implementation of
such a separate disaster campaign since
the Director currently exercises general
supervision over all operations of the
CFC and has the authority to take all
necessary steps to ensure the
achievement of campaign objectives.
Therefore, there is no need to specify
the handling of the campaign during
times of emergency or disaster beyond
the authority already available, and
OPM is adopting the rule as proposed.
7. Current section 950.104(b)(6)
encourages local Federal agencies to
appoint loaned executives to assist in
the campaign and grant administrative
leave to all loaned executives
appointed. OPM is adopting the
proposed rule that will clarify that
Federal agencies should not place
loaned executives on administrative
leave since the CFC activities are
considered part of the official duties of
the Federal employee loaned to assist in
the CFC.
8. Current section 950.104(c) states
that the LFCC must annually solicit
applications for the PCFO via public
notice. OPM proposed to remove the
requirement for an annual application
and allow LFCCs to enter into multiyear agreements, at their discretion.
OPM also proposed the removal of the
requirement to solicit the PCFO
applications via a public notice and to
provide the LFCC discretion as to how
to announce the solicitation as long as
it reaches the audience of prospective
applicants. OPM will adopt these
provisions in the final rule.
9. Current section 950.106(a) states
the amount a PCFO may recover for
campaign expenses shall not exceed 10
percent of the estimated budget. OPM
adopts the proposed regulation,
correcting an error in this section which
would state that the recovery amount
should not exceed 110 percent of the
estimated budget.
10. Current section 950.109 describes
certain conflicts of interest for Federal
employees who serve as an LFCC
member or fundraising coordinator.
OPM proposed to add clarifying
language regarding LFCC members not
being able to serve in their official
capacity on the board of directors of the
non-profit organization that administers
the CFC in its local area. This situation
was addressed in administrative
guidance at CFC Memorandum 2002–
15. OPM is adopting this proposed
revision in the final rule.
11. Current sections 950.201(a)(1) and
(2) discuss eligibility for national
organizations to be included on the
PO 00000
Frm 00006
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
national list. OPM proposed adding
references for international
organizations, which must also meet
these criteria, and clarifying the
Director’s ability to consider corrective
action regarding any prior violation of
regulation or directive, sanction, or
penalty, as appropriate, prior to
determining eligibility. OPM is adopting
these proposed revisions in the final
rule.
12. Consistent with changes set forth
above in paragraph 6, above, current
section 950.204(b)(1) is modified to
allow for the Director to provide for
elimination of adjacency and statewide
presence eligibility requirements
commencing with the implementation
of appropriate electronic technology.
See related changes adopted in section
950.103(h). In addition, OPM clarifies
this section to define more clearly an
adjacent local campaign. A number of
comments were received opposing this
proposed change, noting a concern that
statewide charities and adjacent
charities will lose contributions if they
are not included in the charity list, and
donors will be affected if they lose the
opportunity to contribute to charities of
their choice. OPM notes that the current
adjacency and statewide eligibility
criteria will remain in place until
appropriate technology exists to permit
donors to make contributions without
geographic restriction. OPM does not
intend that there would be any gap
period during which a potential donor
would be deprived of an opportunity to
donate to an eligible charity during the
transition from the current rule to the
elimination of geographic boundaries.
OPM believes that the cost efficiencies
inherent in the use of appropriate
technology will only be realized by
strongly encouraging the use of online
electronic listings. OPM also
acknowledges that some form of paper
charity list may be needed to reach
certain donors that may not have access
to computers. In these circumstances,
OPM will issue appropriate guidance to
facilitate a full listing of all eligible
charities within the geographic area.
OPM is adopting this provision in the
final rule.
13. Current section 950.204(b)(2)(iii)
is being amended to add Guam, the
Commonwealth of Northern Mariana
Islands, and American Samoa to the list
of U.S. territories whose charities may
be exempt from the requirements of
§ 950.202(b). A number of comments
pointed out that local organizations
based in these territories do not
generally participate in the CFC because
they are not granted this exception.
OPM determined that local non-profit
organizations based in U.S. territories
E:\FR\FM\20NOR3.SGM
20NOR3
sroberts on PROD1PC70 with RULES
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 223 / Monday, November 20, 2006 / Rules and Regulations
are entitled to similar privileges as those
in Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands,
provided they meet all other required
eligibility requirements.
14. Current section 950.204(e) is being
revised to remove the 15 day period for
LFCCs to make eligibility decisions and
providing instead that the decisions
must be made as of a date determined
by OPM and published in the annual
CFC calendar.
15. OPM proposed adding a new
subsection to section 950.204(g) that
clarifies the LFCC’s ability to consider
corrective action regarding any prior
violation of regulation or directive,
applying an appropriate sanction or
penalty, as appropriate, prior to
determining eligibility of local
organizations. OPM is as adopting the
proposal in the final rule.
16. Current section 950.301(a) states
that the Director may recognize national
and international federations that
conform to eligibility and accountability
standards. OPM proposed clarifying the
Director’s ability to consider corrective
action regarding any prior violation of
regulation or directive applying an
appropriate sanction or penalty, as
appropriate, prior to determining
eligibility of national and international
federations. OPM is as adopting the
proposal in the final rule.
17. Current section 950.301(c) states
that an organization may apply for
inclusion as a national CFC federation if
the applicant federation has 15 or more
member organizations each of which
meet the eligibility criteria of sections
950.202 and 950.203. A national
federation must provide copies of
applications for all of its members in the
initial year that it applies to participate
in the CFC as a federation, but needs to
submit copies of applications after the
initial year only at OPM’s request. OPM
proposed to add clarifying language that
the federation itself does not count
among the 15 or more members
organizations required to receive
federation status. Four comments stated
that the federation itself should count as
one of the 15 members. OPM believes
that the federation itself should not be
included as one of those 15 member
organizations, and is adopting the
proposed clarification in the final rule.
18. Current section 950.301(d)
discusses the role of national and
international federations. OPM
proposed a terminology change from
‘‘decertification’’ to ‘‘withdrawal of
federation status’’ to conform to a
terminology change proposed in section
950.603(a). Numerous commenters
indicated that they opposed this change
as well as the changes regarding
sanctions and penalties in section
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:36 Nov 17, 2006
Jkt 211001
950.603(a). The commenters did not
believe the proposed change provided
an adequate appeal process. OPM notes
that it did not change the sanctions and
penalty requirements in the proposed
rule. The proposed changes simply
clarified and consolidated the many
sections that dealt with penalties and
sanctions into a single section at section
950.603(a). The requirements are those
required by Federal law and OPM is
adopting the proposed changes in the
final rule.
19. Current section 950.301(e)(2)
requires national and international
federations to certify that their financial
activities conform to generally accepted
accounting principles (GAAP) and that
they are annually audited by an
independent certified public accountant
in accordance with generally accepted
auditing standards (GAAS). That section
further requires a copy of the audited
financial statements and that the audit
must verify that the federation is
honoring designations made to each
member organization. Finally, the
current regulation waives the audit
requirement for newly created
federations operating for less than a
year. OPM proposed to clarify and
simplify the regulatory language to
apply to all eligibility requirements and
public accountability standards,
contained in sections 950.202 and
950.203 and required of independent
organizations and federation members,
to the national and international
federations. OPM does not view this as
a substantive change and is adopting the
proposal in the final rule.
20. Current section 950.301(e)(2)(iii)
requires national and international
federations to disclose important
administrative expense information to
the CFC and donors in its annual report.
One organization suggested that OPM
should consider the differences in
accounting systems used by federations
and establish a standard reporting
system. OPM agrees that this could be
of potential value and will consider this
as an area for future administrative
review. OPM is retaining the provision
as proposed.
21. Current section 950.303(a) states
that the LFCC must approve local
federations that conform to eligibility
and public accountability standards.
OPM proposed to clarify the LFCC’s
ability to consider corrective action
regarding any prior violation of
regulation or directive, sanction, or
penalty, as appropriate, prior to
determining eligibility of local
federations. OPM adopts this proposal
in the final rule.
22. Current section 950.303(c) is the
same requirement for local federations
PO 00000
Frm 00007
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
67281
as that described for section 950.301(c)
regarding national federations. OPM is
adopting in the final rule the
clarification that the local federation
itself does not count among the 15 or
more members required to receive
federation status.
23. Current section 950.303(d) sets
forth the role of local federations. OPM
will adopt in the final rule a
terminology change from
‘‘decertification’’ to ‘‘withdrawal of
federation status’’ to conform to a
terminology change in section
950.603(a).
24. Section 950.303(e)(2) sets forth the
same requirement for local federations
as that is described above applicable to
section 950.301(e)(2). The changes
adopted for national and international
federations also are adopted for local
federations in the final rule.
25. Section 950.303(e)(2)(iii) sets forth
the same requirement for local
federations as that described above in
section 950.301(e)(2)(iii) for national
and international federations. OPM will
adopt this requirement in the final rule.
26. Current section 950.401(g)(3)
states that each national and
international federation and charitable
organization will be assigned a code
number by OPM and each local
federation and local charitable
organization will be assigned code
numbers by the LFCC. OPM is
modifying this regulation to facilitate
alternative mechanisms by which OPM
may assign charity codes. A number of
comments expressed concerns over the
manner in which OPM is planning to
implement a re-coding of the charities,
as part of the development of a
centralized national CFC list. One
comment indicated that OPM has
already begun the implementation of
such re-coding process by officially
announcing that OPM will be assigning
both national and local code numbers
and requiring that LFCCs notify
charities accordingly. OPM notes that
while the planning for the assignment of
new codes for all CFC charities has
begun, the official assignment of codes
will not occur before these final
regulations are implemented. OPM
further notes that it has had extensive
consultation with stakeholders on the
need for a new coding structure and the
limitations that the existing regulation
imposes on the structure of the
campaign. OPM is adopting the
proposed modification in the final rule.
27. Current sections 950.401(i) and (j)
are being amended to provide that local
affiliates of a national organization, not
separately incorporated, still can be
determined locally eligible using the
national organization’s IRS tax-exempt
E:\FR\FM\20NOR3.SGM
20NOR3
sroberts on PROD1PC70 with RULES
67282
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 223 / Monday, November 20, 2006 / Rules and Regulations
determination letter and audited
financial statements accompanied with
a certification that the local affiliate
operates as a bona-fide chapter or
affiliate in good standing of the national
organization and that the affiliate is
covered by the national organization’s
501(c)(3) tax exemption, IRS Form 990
and audited financial statements. The
affiliate must provide a pro forma IRS
Form 990, page 1 and Part V only, for
CFC purposes in addition to the other
documents required under section
950.204.
28. Current section 950.601 governs
the release of donor names and
addresses and the transmittal of this
information to designated charities.
OPM proposed changing the terms
‘‘names and address’’ to ‘‘information,’’
to allow other donor information to be
released, such as contribution amount
and home email address. Numerous
comments supported this change but
suggested that clear ‘‘opt-in, opt-out’’
choices be given to donors. A number of
comments opposed this change in light
of the proposed change to remove the
prohibition against sale or lease of
contributor lists in section 950.203(a)(6).
However, since OPM is retaining the
current regulatory prohibition against
sale or lease of contributor lists in
section 950.203(a)(6), and will not adopt
the proposed change, OPM does not
believe there is substantial disagreement
with this proposed change in section
950.601 and will adopt that change in
the final rule.
29. Current section 950.604 specifies
that federations, PCFOs and other
participants shall retain documents
pertinent to the campaign for three
campaign years. OPM proposed to
clarify that three campaign years is
actually three completed campaign
periods and is not based on calendar
years. OPM is adopting this clarification
in the final rule.
30. Current section 950.801(a)(1)
specifies the period during which OPM
will accept applications from
organizations seeking to be listed on the
national and international parts of the
charity list. OPM proposed to modify
this section to replace it with a period
to be determined by the Director. OPM
will create, maintain, and issue a CFC
calendar of events each year to define
the applicable time periods. Initially,
OPM will provide for a specific 60calendar day period between December
and February as the period during
which OPM will accept applications.
OPM adopts this modification in the
final rule.
31. Current section 950.801(a)(2)
states that within 35 calendar days of
the closing date for the receipt of annual
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:36 Nov 17, 2006
Jkt 211001
applications, the Director will notify
each national and international
applicant of the results of the
application review. OPM proposed to
remove the defined 35 day requirement
and annually publish an anticipated
date for notification on the calendar of
events that OPM will maintain. OPM is
adopting this provision in the final rule.
32. Current section 950.801(a)(3)
states that the LFCC must select the
PCFO no later than March 15 each year.
OPM proposed to remove the reference
to March 15 and state that the LFCC
must select the PCFO no later than a
date to be determined annually by OPM.
OPM will provide the date in its annual
CFC calendar of events and initially set
the date as February 15 to allow
campaigns to begin early planning for
the campaign beginning after the
effective date of these regulations. OPM
is adopting this provision in the final
rule.
33. Current section 950.801(a)(4)
requires the Director to issue a national
and international list of eligible
organizations by June 30. OPM
proposed to remove the specific date
and state the requirement by a date
annually determined by the Director.
Several comments indicated that given
the impact on all campaigns of the
timely release by OPM of the national
and international parts of the charity
list, that a regulatory adjusted deadline
would be preferred. One comment
recommended that OPM change the date
for issuance from June 30 to July 30 to
be consistent with current actual
practice. OPM believes that future
release of the national and international
parts of the charity list and the
screening of charities will be expedited
by improved technology and
administrative improvements in these
regulations and the use of a specific
deadline in regulation will impose an
unnecessary constraint. OPM is
adopting the proposed change in the
final rule.
34. Current section 950.801(b)
requires the Director to annually issue a
timetable for accepting and processing
national and international applications.
OPM proposed to modify this section to
specify that the Director will create,
maintain and issue annually a CFC
calendar of events with specific dates
that include the accepting and
processing of national and international
applications as well as other significant
CFC dates. A majority of comments
expressed concern that without
regulatory deadlines, local campaigns
could not plan adequately or hold OPM
accountable for the release of the
national and international parts of the
charity list. The proposed CFC calendar
PO 00000
Frm 00008
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
will be official CFC guidance and OPM
believes it will be sufficient to allow for
adequate local administration of the
campaigns. In addition, OPM does not
anticipate significant changes to any of
the dates being removed from the
regulations and will provide the annual
calendar well in advance of the annual
campaign and time for selection of the
PCFO for any campaign. Local
campaigns will have adequate time to
plan for the campaign based on the
issuance of the CFC calendar of dates.
OPM is adopting the provision in the
final rule.
35. Current 950.901(f)(1) requires the
remittance checks sent by payroll offices
to the PCFO each pay period to be
accompanied by a statement identifying
the agency, the dates of the pay period
and the total number of employee
deductions. OPM proposed to add the
pay period number to the information
required to be on this statement. OPM
is adopting this provision in the final
rule.
36. Current sections 950.901(i)(1) and
(i)(2) each contain specific dates for the
PCFO to notify charitable organizations
of the amount of pledged contributions
(currently no later than February 15)
and to begin its periodic distributions to
charitable organizations. OPM proposed
to remove the specific dates referenced
in the regulation and provide that these
actions will occur no later than a date
to be determined annually by OPM.
OPM will publish the dates in its annual
CFC calendar of events. Initially, OPM
plans to extend the notification date to
March 15. OPM proposed to remove the
requirement for monthly payments and
allow all campaigns to make quarterly
payments beginning no later than April
1. Several comments noted that some
small organizations could be adversely
affected by quarterly payments. OPM
notes that the PCFO will continue to
have the option of retaining the monthly
payments and is adopting the proposed
provisions in the final rule
37. Current sections 950.105(e),
950.302(c), 950.302(d), 950.304(c),
950.304(d), 950.403, and 950.603 all
provide for certain penalties and
sanctions for federations, unaffiliated
organizations, and PCFOs. OPM
proposed to clarify and combine these
penalties and sanctions into one new
section 950.603 and remove the other
references from the regulations.
Numerous commenters indicated that
they did not agree with the changes in
section 950.603(a) because they did not
provide an adequate appeal process.
OPM notes that it did not change the
sanctions and penalty requirements in
the proposed rule. The proposed
changes simply clarified and
E:\FR\FM\20NOR3.SGM
20NOR3
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 223 / Monday, November 20, 2006 / Rules and Regulations
sroberts on PROD1PC70 with RULES
consolidated the many sections that
dealt with penalties and sanctions into
a single section 950.603(a). The
requirements are those required by
Federal law and OPM will adopt these
changes in the final rule.
the audited financial statements for the
national organization, but must submit
page 1 and Part V of a pro forma IRS
Form 990 used to calculate the AFR.
Proposed Regulations Withdrawn in
Favor of Existing Regulations
1. Current section 950.103(g) prohibits
solicitation of contractor personnel,
credit union employees and other
persons employed on Federal premises,
and retired Federal employees but
allows these individuals an opportunity
to participate in the CFC by making
single contribution. OPM’s proposal to
revise this rule by eliminating
restrictions against the solicitation of
the above personnel received extensive
comments from the Office of
Government Ethics (OGE). In particular,
the OGE stated that the proposed rule
did not specify any standards governing
the circumstances under which the
solicitations may occur. OPM agrees this
is an issue that requires additional study
and is not adopting the portion of the
proposed rule that would have allowed
the solicitation of non-Federal
personnel. OPM will retain the existing
regulation in order to have more time to
re-examine this issue, while clarifying
that donations offered by non-Federal
personnel must be accepted. OPM
adopts the portion of the proposed rule
that allows for other electronic means of
contributing, including credit cards,
upon approval by the Director.
2. Sections 950.204(b)(2)(iii) and
(b)(2)(iv) were proposed additions to the
regulations intended to recognize
financial relationships between national
organizations and their bona fide local
affiliates and to remove certain
requirements depending on how those
relationships were structured. OPM
received numerous comments opposing
the proposed changes which pointed to
the emerging trends among national
charitable organization structures to
operate as single corporations with
affiliates. OPM is not adopting the
proposed regulations and will retain a
slightly modified version of the existing
regulatory language as its final rule.
OPM has modified section 950.401(i) to
clarify that local chapters/affiliate
organizations must satisfy CFC
eligibility criteria and must
independently demonstrate services and
accountability through the submission
of independent documentation as
required in sections 950.202, 950,203 or
950.204, except that a chapter or
affiliate that is part of a single
corporation or part of a group
exemption may rely on the 26 U.S.C.
501(c)(3) tax-exempt determination and
I certify that this regulation will not
have a significant economic impact on
a substantial number of small entities.
Charitable organizations applying to the
CFC have an existing, independent
obligation to comply with the eligibility
and public accountability standards
contained in current CFC regulations.
Streamlining these standards will be
less burdensome.
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:36 Nov 17, 2006
Jkt 211001
Regulatory Flexibility Act
Executive Order 12866, Regulatory
Review
This rule has been reviewed by the
Office of Management and Budget in
accordance with Executive Order 12866.
List of Subjects in 5 CFR Part 950
Administrative practice and
procedures, Charitable contributions,
Government employees, Military
personnel, Nonprofit organizations, and
Reporting and recordkeeping
requirements.
Office of Personnel Management.
Linda M. Springer,
Director
Accordingly, OPM amends 5 CFR part
950 as follows:
I
PART 950—SOLICITATION OF
FEDERAL CIVILIAN AND UNIFORMED
SERVICE PERSONNEL FOR
CONTRIBUTIONS TO PRIVATE
VOLUNTARY ORGANIZATIONS
1. The authority citation for part 950
continues to read as follows:
I
Authority: E.O. 12353 (March 23, 1982), 47
FR 12785 (March 25, 1982). 3 CFR, 1982
Comp., p. 139. E.O. 12404 (February 10,
1983), 48 FR 6685 (February 15, 1983), Pub.
L. 100–202, and Pub. L. 102–393 (5 U.S.C.
1101 Note).
2. Amend part 950 as follows:
a. Remove the words ‘‘brochure’’ and
‘‘brochures’’ and add in their place
‘‘Charity List’’ and ‘‘Charity Lists’’,
respectively, wherever they appear;
I b. Remove the words ‘‘card’’ and
‘‘cards’’ and add in their place ‘‘form’’
and ‘‘forms’’, respectively, wherever
they appear; and
I c. Remove the words ‘‘materials’’,
‘‘pamphlet’’, and ‘‘pamphlets’’ and add
in their place ‘‘information’’ wherever
they appear.
I
I
3. In § 950.101:
a. Remove the definition of Campaign
Year;
I
I
PO 00000
Frm 00009
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
67283
b. Add the definitions of Campaign
Period, Charity List, and Independent
Organization in alphabetical order; and
I c. In the definition of International
General Designation Option remove the
word ‘‘campaign’’.
The additions read as follows:
I
§ 950.101
Definitions.
*
*
*
*
*
Campaign Period means generally a
24 month period beginning with the
selection of a Principal Combined Fund
Organization (PCFO) or renewal of the
existing PCFO’s agreement with a Local
Federal Coordinating Committee (LFCC)
and ending with the final disbursements
to charitable organizations participating
in a local campaign.
Charity List means the official list of
charities approved by OPM and the
LFCC for inclusion in the CFC within a
given geographic solicitation area. The
Charity List will consist of three parts:
the National/International part, the
International part, and the Local part.
Organizations that provide services,
benefits, assistance, or program
activities in 15 or more different states
or a foreign country can choose to be
listed on either the International or
National/International part, except for
members of a federation, which must be
listed with the federation. Organizations
that provide services, benefits,
assistance, or program activities in 15 or
more different states but no foreign
countries will be listed on the National/
International part. All qualifying local
organizations within a CFC geographic
solicitation area will be listed on the
Local part associated with the campaign
for that local CFC area.
*
*
*
*
*
Independent Organization means a
charitable organization that is not a
member of a federation for the purposes
of the Combined Federal Campaign.
*
*
*
*
*
4. In § 950.102 amend paragraph (a)
by removing the text ‘‘6 week’’ from the
second sentence, and amend paragraph
(c) by adding two sentences at the end
of the paragraph to read as follows:
I
§ 950.102 Scope of the Combined Federal
Campaign.
*
*
*
*
*
(c) * * * OPM has the authority to
audit, investigate, and report on the
administration of any campaign, the
organization that administers the
campaign, and any national,
international and local federation,
federation member or independent
organization that participates in the
campaign for compliance with these
regulations. The Director resolves any
E:\FR\FM\20NOR3.SGM
20NOR3
67284
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 223 / Monday, November 20, 2006 / Rules and Regulations
§ 950.104 Local Federal Coordinating
Committee responsibilities.
5. In § 950.103, revise paragraphs (f),
(g) and (h) to read as follows:
I
§ 950.103
Establishing a local campaign.
*
*
*
*
*
(f) Each year the LFCC must establish
the time period during which CFC
solicitation may take place. The
solicitation may not begin before
September 1 and in no event will it
extend beyond December 15 of each
year.
(g) Current Federal civilian and active
duty military employees may be
solicited for contributions using payroll
deduction, checks, money orders, or
cash, or by electronic means, including
credit cards, as approved by the
Director. Contractor personnel, credit
union employees and other persons
present on Federal premises, as well as
retired Federal employees, may make
single contributions to the CFC through
checks, money orders, or cash, or by
electronic means, including credit
cards, as approved by the Director.
These non-Federal personnel may not
be solicited, but donations offered by
such persons must be accepted by the
local campaigns.
(h) A Federal employee whose official
duty station is outside the geographic
boundaries of an established CFC may
not be solicited in that CFC. A Federal
employee may participate in a particular
CFC only if that employee’s official duty
station is located within the geographic
boundaries of that CFC. This restriction
may be discontinued upon
implementation of appropriate
electronic technology that allows
removal of the need for geographic
restrictions on giving as determined by
the Director. Upon a showing of
extraordinary circumstances, as
determined in the sole discretion of the
Director, Federal employees may
contribute in support of victims in cases
of emergencies and disasters defined in
§ 950.102(a) outside the geographic
boundaries of their participating CFC.
Such contributions can be check, money
order, or cash or by electronic means,
including credit cards, as approved by
the Director, but shall not be made
through payroll deduction.
6. Amend § 950.104 as follows:
a. In paragraphs (b)(4) and (b)(5),
remove the word ‘‘local’’; and
I b. Revise paragraphs (b)(6) and (c) to
read as follows:
The revisions read as follows:
sroberts on PROD1PC70 with RULES
I
I
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:36 Nov 17, 2006
Jkt 211001
I
*
issues reported and determines
sanctions or penalties, as warranted
under § 950.603.
*
*
*
*
*
§ 950.106
*
*
*
*
(b) * * *
(6) Encouraging local Federal agencies
to appoint loaned executives to assist in
the campaign. CFC loaned executives’
time should be charged to regular
working hours. It is not appropriate to
place a CFC loaned executive on
administrative leave, leave without pay,
or annual leave. Federal loaned
executives are prohibited from working
on non-CFC fundraising activities
during duty hours.
*
*
*
*
*
(c) The LFCC must select a PCFO to
act as its fiscal agent and campaign
coordinator on the basis of presentations
made to the LFCC as described in
§ 950.105(c). The LFCC may, in its
discretion, select a PCFO to serve in that
role for up to three campaign periods,
subject to renewal each year following
a review of performance as defined in
§ 950.105. The LFCC must consider the
capacity of the organization to manage
an efficient and effective campaign, its
history of public accountability, use of
funds, truthfulness and accuracy in
solicitations, and sound governance and
fiscal management practices as the
primary factors in selecting a PCFO. The
LFCC must solicit applications on a
competitive basis for the PCFO no later
than a date to be determined by OPM
and, if the LFCC exercises discretion to
enter into a multi-year arrangement,
upon completion of the multi-year term.
The LFCC shall solicit applications via
outreach activities including: Public
notice in newspapers, postings on Web
sites, advertising in trade journals,
dissemination among participating CFC
organizations and federations, and/or
outreach through local or state nonprofit
associations and training centers, among
others. The PCFO application period
must be open a minimum of 21 calendar
days. Costs incurred for soliciting
applications must be added to the PCFO
budget as an administrative cost.
§ 950.105
[Amended]
7. Amend § 950.105 as follows:
a. In paragraph (b), remove the word
‘‘printed’’ in the second sentence and
add in its place the word ‘‘developed’’;
I b. In paragraph (d)(3), remove the
word ‘‘address’’ and add in its place
‘‘contact information’’;
I c. In paragraph (d)(6), add the text ‘‘,
contact information and contribution
amounts’’ after the word ‘‘names’’;
I d. In paragraph (d)(10), remove the
word ‘‘reprinting’’ and add in its place
‘‘reproduction and/or reissuing’’ and
remove the number ‘‘10’’ and add in its
place ‘‘110’’; and
I
I
PO 00000
Frm 00010
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
e. Remove paragraph (e).
[Amended]
8. In § 950.106, amend paragraph (a)
by removing the number ‘‘10’’ and
adding in its place ‘‘110.’’
I
§ 950.109
[Amended]
9. In § 950.109, amend the first
sentence by adding the words ‘‘serve in
any official capacity in any organization
that serves as the PCFO of the local CFC,
or’’ before the word ‘‘participate’’.
I 10. Amend § 950.201 as follows:
I a. Revise the section heading;
I b. Revise paragraphs (a)(1) through
(c)(3).
The amendments to § 950.201 read as
follows:
I
§ 950.201
National/international eligibility.
(a) * * *
(1) Determine the timetable and other
procedures regarding application for
inclusion in the National/International
and International parts of the Charity
List.
(2) Determine which organizations
among those that apply qualify to be
included in the National/International
and International parts of the Charity
List and then provide these parts of the
Charity List of qualified organizations to
all local campaigns. In order to
determine whether an organization may
participate in the campaign, the Director
may request evidence of corrective
action regarding any prior violation of
regulation or directive, sanction, or
penalty, as appropriate. The Director
retains the ultimate authority to decide
whether the organization has
demonstrated, to the Director’s
satisfaction, that the organization has
taken appropriate corrective action.
Failure to demonstrate satisfactory
corrective action or to respond to the
Director’s request for information within
10 business days of the date of the
request may result in a determination
that the organization will not be
included in the Charity List.
(b) The National/International and
International parts of the Charity List
shall be included in the Charity List in
accordance with these regulations. The
Charity List will include each
organization’s CFC code and other
information as determined by OPM.
These CFC codes must be verbatim
reproduced in the Charity List.
(c) An organization on the National/
International or International parts of
the Charity List may elect to be removed
from the applicable part of the Charity
List and have its local affiliate or
subunit listed on the Local part of the
Charity List of organizations in its stead.
For the local affiliate or subunit to be
E:\FR\FM\20NOR3.SGM
20NOR3
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 223 / Monday, November 20, 2006 / Rules and Regulations
listed in lieu of the organization on the
National/International or International
parts, the following procedures must be
followed:
(1) The organization must send a
letter to the local affiliate or subunit in
that particular geographic CFC, waiving
its listing on the National/International
or International part of the Charity List
so that its eligible local affiliate or
subunit listed in the Local part of the
Charity List in that geographic CFC will
appear as that organization’s sole listing
in the Charity List.
(2) The local affiliate or subunit will
include in its application to the LFCC a
copy of the letter authorizing the
removal of the organization from the
National/International or International
part of the Charity List, as well as all the
required materials for completing a local
organization application.
(3) Upon finding the local
organization eligible, the waiver letter
from the organization on the National/
International or International part
authorizes the LFCC to delete that
organization from the National/
International or International part of the
Charity List.
Organizations that issue student
scholarships or fellowships must
indicate the state in which the recipient
resides, not the state of the school or
place of fellowship. Mere dissemination
of information does not demonstrate
acceptable provision of real services.
While it is not expected that an
organization maintain an office in each
state or foreign country, a clear showing
must be made of the actual services,
benefits, assistance or activities
provided in each state or foreign
country. De minimis services, benefits,
assistance, or other program activities in
any state or foreign country will not be
accepted as a basis for qualification as
a national or international organization.
(b) Certify that it is an organization
recognized by the Internal Revenue
Service as tax exempt under 26 U.S.C.
501(c)(3) to which contributions are
deductible under 26 U.S.C. § 170(c)(2)
and that the organization is further
classified as a public charity under 26
U.S.C. § 509(a). A copy of the letter(s)
from the Internal Revenue Service
granting tax exempt and public charity
status must be included in the
organization’s application.
11. Revise § 950.202 to read as
follows:
I
I
I
sroberts on PROD1PC70 with RULES
§ 950.202 National/international eligibility
requirements.
(a) Certify that it provides or conducts
real services, benefits, assistance, or
program activities, in 15 or more
different states or a foreign country over
the 3 year period immediately preceding
the start of the year involved. This
requirement cannot be met on the sole
basis of services provided through an
‘‘800’’ telephone number or by
disseminating information and
publications via the U.S. Postal Service,
the internet, or a combination thereof. A
schedule listing a detailed description
of the services in each state (minimum
15) or foreign countries (minimum 1),
including the year of service, must be
included with the CFC application. The
schedule must make a clear showing of
national or international presence.
Broad descriptions of services and
identical repetitive narratives will not
be accepted in the sole discretion of
OPM if they do not allow OPM to
adequately determine that real services
were provided or to accurately
determine the individuals or entities
who benefited. Providing listings of
affiliated groups does not sufficiently
demonstrate provision of real services
by the applicant. Location of residence
of organization members or location of
residence of visitors to a facility does
not substantiate provision of services.
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:36 Nov 17, 2006
Jkt 211001
12. Amend § 950.203 as follows:
a. Remove paragraphs (a)(9) through
(a)(11), and (a)(13) and redesignate
paragraph (a)(12) as (a)(9);
I b. In paragraph (a) introductory text,
remove the words ‘‘national list’’ in the
first sentence;
I c. In paragraph (a)(1), remove the
second sentence;
I d. Revise paragraphs (a)(2) through
(a)(4); and
I e. In the newly redesignated
paragraph (a)(9), remove the phrase
‘‘national list’’ and add the phrase
‘‘Charity List’’ in its place.
The revisions read as follows:
§ 950.203
Public accountability standards.
(a) * * *
(2) Certify that it accounts for its
funds on an accrual basis (cash,
modified cash, modified accrual and
any other methods of accounting are not
acceptable) in accordance with
generally accepted accounting
principles and that an audit of its fiscal
operations is completed annually by an
independent certified public accountant
in accordance with generally accepted
auditing standards. A copy of the
organization’s most recent annual
audited financial statements must be
included with the application. The
audited financial statements must cover
the fiscal period ending not more than
18 months prior to the January of the
year of the campaign for which the
organization is applying. For example,
PO 00000
Frm 00011
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
67285
the audited financial statements
included in the 2007 application must
cover the fiscal period ending on or after
June 30, 2005.
(3) Certify that it prepares and
submits to the IRS a complete copy of
the organization’s IRS Form 990 or that
it is not required to prepare and submit
an IRS Form 990 to the IRS. Provide a
completed copy of the organization’s
IRS Form 990 submitted to the IRS
covering a fiscal period ending not more
than 18 months prior to the January of
the year of the campaign for which the
organization is applying, including
signature, supplemental statements and
Schedule A, with the application, or if
not required to file an IRS Form 990,
provide a pro forma IRS Form 990 page
1 and Part V only. IRS Forms 990EZ,
990PF, and comparable forms are not
acceptable substitutes. The IRS Form
990 and audited financial statements
must cover the same fiscal period.
(4) Provide a computation of the
organization’s percentage of total
support and revenue spent on
administrative and fundraising. This
percentage shall be computed from
information on the IRS Form 990
submitted pursuant to § 950.203(a)(3).
*
*
*
*
*
13. Amend § 950.204 as follows:
a. Revise the section heading;
b. In paragraphs (a) and (b)
introductory text, remove the word
‘‘local’’;
I c. Revise paragraph (b)(1);
I d. Revise paragraph (b)(2)(ii) and
(b)(2)(iii);
I e. Revise paragraph (e);
I f. In paragraph (f), remove the word
‘‘print’’ from the first sentence and add
in its place ‘‘produce’’ and remove the
word ‘‘campaign’’ from the first
sentence the first time it appears; and
I g. Add new paragraph (g).
The revisions and addition read as
follows:
I
I
I
§ 950.204
Local eligibility.
*
*
*
*
*
(b) * * *
(1) An organization must demonstrate
to the satisfaction of the LFCC of the
appropriate local campaign, that it has
a substantial local presence in the
geographical area covered by the local
campaign, a substantial local presence
in the geographical area covered by an
adjacent local campaign, or substantial
statewide presence. Eligibility to
participate in an adjoining campaign on
the basis of adjacency or statewide
presence may be discontinued upon
implementation of appropriate
electronic technology that allows
removal of the need for geographic
E:\FR\FM\20NOR3.SGM
20NOR3
sroberts on PROD1PC70 with RULES
67286
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 223 / Monday, November 20, 2006 / Rules and Regulations
restrictions on giving as determined by
the Director.
(i) Substantial local presence is
defined as a staffed facility, office or
portion of a residence dedicated
exclusively to that organization,
available to members of the public
seeking its services or benefits. The
facility must be open at least 15 hours
a week and have a telephone dedicated
exclusively to the organization. The
office may be staffed by volunteers.
Substantial local presence cannot be
met on the basis of services provided
solely through an ‘‘800’’ telephone
number, the internet, the U.S. Postal
Service or a combination thereof.
(ii) An adjacent local campaign is
defined as a local campaign whose
geographic border touches the
geographic border of another local
campaign. Participation in a local
campaign via an adjacency
determination does not grant the
organization a substantial local presence
in the adjacent local campaign and
participating via adjacency cannot be
used to establish adjacency to local
campaigns bordering the adjacent
campaign area.
(iii) Substantial statewide presence is
defined as providing or conducting real
services, benefits, assistance or program
activities covering 30 percent of a state’s
geographic boundaries or providing or
conducting real services, benefits,
assistance or program activities affecting
30 percent of a state’s population.
Substantial statewide presence cannot
be met on the basis of services provided
solely through an ‘‘800’’ telephone
number, the internet, the U.S. Postal
Service or a combination thereof.
(2) * * *
(ii) A local charitable organization
with annual revenue of less than
$100,000 reported on its IRS Form 990
or pro form IRS Form 990 submitted to
the CFC is not required to undergo an
audit or to submit audited financial
statements. Rather, the organization
must certify that it has controls in place
to ensure that funds are properly
accounted for and that it can provide
accurate and timely financial
information to interested parties. A local
organization with annual revenue of at
least $100,000 but less than $250,000
must certify that it accounts for its funds
on an accrual basis in accordance with
generally accepted accounting
principles and that an audit of its fiscal
operations is completed annually as
described in section 950.203(a)(2), but
such organization does not have to
submit a copy of its audited financial
statements with its CFC application,
unless requested to do so by the LFCC
or Director.
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:36 Nov 17, 2006
Jkt 211001
(iii) An organization seeking local
eligibility in Puerto Rico, the U.S. Virgin
Islands, the Commonwealth of Northern
Mariana Islands, American Samoa, or
Guam is exempt from the requirements
of § 950.202(b), but the organization
must include with its CFC application
the appropriate documentation from its
governing authority demonstrating its
status as a charitable organization.
*
*
*
*
*
(e) Local eligibility determinations.
The LFCC shall communicate its
eligibility decisions by a date to be
determined by OPM as part of the
annual timetable issued by the Director
under § 950.801(b). Denial of the
application by the LFCC must be sent
via U.S. Postal Service certified or
registered mail with a return receipt
requested. Approvals may be sent via
U.S. Postal Service regular first class
mail. Applicants denied eligibility may
appeal in accordance with § 950.205.
*
*
*
*
*
(g) In order to determine whether an
organization may participate in the
campaign, the LFCC may request
evidence of corrective action regarding
any prior violation of regulation or
directive, sanction, or penalty, as
appropriate. The LFCC will decide
whether the organization has
demonstrated, to the LFCC’s
satisfaction, that the organization has
taken appropriate corrective action.
Failure to demonstrate satisfactory
corrective action or to respond to the
LFCC’s request for information within
10 business days of the date of the
request may result in a determination
that the organization will not be
included in the local part of the Charity
List.
§ 950.205
[Amended]
14. In § 950.205, amend paragraph
(c)(4) by removing the word ‘‘and’’ and
adding to the end of the sentence the
text ‘‘and supporting information to
justify the reversal of the original
decision’’.
I
15. Amend § 950.301 as follows:
a. Revise the section heading and
paragraph (a);
I b. Revise paragraph (c);
I c. In paragraph (d), remove the word
‘‘decertification’’ in the last sentence
and add in its place the words
‘‘withdrawal of federation status’’;
I d. In paragraph (e) introductory text,
add the words ‘‘or international’’ after
the word ‘‘national’’;
I e. In paragraph (e)(1), remove the
word ‘‘national list’’ and add the words
‘‘National or International part of the
Charity List’’ in its place; and
I
I
PO 00000
Frm 00012
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
I
f. Revise paragraph (e)(2).
The revisions read as follows:
§ 950.301 National and international
federations eligibility.
(a) The Director may recognize
national and international federations
that conform to the requirements and
are eligible to receive designations. The
Director may from time to time place a
moratorium on the recognition of
national and international federations.
In order to determine whether the
Director will recognize a national or
international federation, the Director
may request evidence of corrective
action regarding any prior violation of
regulation or directive, sanction, or
penalty, as appropriate. The Director
retains the ultimate authority to decide
whether the federation has
demonstrated, to the Director’s
satisfaction, that the federation has
taken appropriate corrective action.
Failure to demonstrate satisfactory
corrective action or to respond to the
Director’s request for information within
10 business days of the date of the
request may result in a determination
that the federation will not be included
in the Charity List.
*
*
*
*
*
(c) An organization may apply to the
Director for inclusion as a national or
international federation to participate in
the CFC if the applicant has, as
members of the proposed federation, 15
or more charitable organizations, in
addition to the federation itself, that
meet the eligibility criteria of §§ 950.202
and 950.203. The initial year an
organization applies for federation
status, it must submit the applications
of all its proposed member
organizations in addition to the
federation application. A federation
must re-establish eligibility each year,
however only the applications of its
new and former members that were not
within the federation, as a CFC
participant, in the previous year’s
campaign need accompany the annual
federation application once an
organization has obtained federation
status, unless additional member
applications are requested by the
Director.
*
*
*
*
*
(e) * * *
(2) That it meets the eligibility
requirements and public accountability
standards contained in §§ 950.202 and
950.203. The federation can
demonstrate that it has met the
eligibility requirement in § 950.202(a)
either through its own services, benefits,
assistance or program activities or
through its 15 members’ activities.
E:\FR\FM\20NOR3.SGM
20NOR3
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 223 / Monday, November 20, 2006 / Rules and Regulations
(i) The federation must complete the
certification set forth at § 950.203(a)(2)
without regard to the amount of revenue
reported on its IRS Form 990 and must
provide a copy of its audited financial
statements. The audited financial
statements provided must verify that the
federation is honoring designations
made to each member organization by
distributing a proportionate share of
receipts based on donor designations to
each member. The audit requirement is
waived for newly created federations
operating for less than a year as
determined from the date of its IRS taxexemption letter to the closing date of
the CFC application period.
(ii) The federation must provide a
listing of its board of directors,
beginning and ending dates of each
member’s current term of office, and the
board’s meeting dates and locations for
the year prior to the year of the
campaign for which the organization is
applying.
(iii) The federation must certify that it
prepares and makes available to the
public, upon request, an annual report
that includes a full description of the
organization’s activities and supporting
services and identifies its directors and
chief administrative personnel. The
federation must provide a copy of its
most recently completed annual report
covering the fiscal period ending not
more than 18 months prior to January of
the campaign year to which the
federation is applying or the preceding
calendar year. The annual report must
also include an accurate description of
the federation’s membership dues and/
or service charges received by the
federation from the charitable
organizations participating as members.
The information must clearly present
the amounts raised, the sources of
contributions, the cost of fundraising,
and how costs are recovered from
donations.
*
*
*
*
*
16. Amend § 950.302 as follows:
a. Revise the section heading;
b. In paragraph (a), add the words
‘‘and international’’ after the word
‘‘National’’;
I c. Revise paragraph (c); and
I d. Remove paragraphs (d) and (e).
The revision reads as follows:
I
I
I
§ 950.302 Responsibilities of national and
international federations.
sroberts on PROD1PC70 with RULES
*
*
*
*
*
(c) Each federation, as fiscal agent for
its member organizations, must ensure
that Federal employee designations are
honored in that each member
organization receives its proportionate
share of receipts based on the results of
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:36 Nov 17, 2006
Jkt 211001
each individual campaign. The
proportionate share of receipts is
determined by donor designations to the
individual member organization as
compared to total campaign
designations.
17. Amend § 950.303 as follows:
a. Revise paragraph (a);
b. Revise paragraph (c);
c. In paragraph (d), remove the word
‘‘decertification’’ in the last sentence
and add in its place the words
‘‘withdrawal of federation status’’; and
I d. Revise paragraph (e)(2).
The revisions read as follows:
I
I
I
I
§ 950.303
Local federations’ eligibility.
(a) LFCC’s must approve local
federations that meet the applicable
requirements, except that in order to
determine whether the LFCC must
recognize a local federation, the LFCC
may request evidence of corrective
action regarding any prior violation of
regulation or directive, sanction, or
penalty, as appropriate. A local
federation that has been notified that it
will not be included on the Local part
of the Charity List because of failure to
correct a prior violation may appeal the
LFCC’s decision to the Director in
accordance with § 950.205(b). The
Director retains the ultimate authority to
decide whether the local federation has
demonstrated, to the Director’s
satisfaction, that the local federation has
taken appropriate corrective action.
Failure to demonstrate satisfactory
corrective action or to respond to a
request by the LFCC or Director for
information within 10 business days of
the date of the request may result in a
determination that the local federation
will not be included in the Local part of
the Charity List.
*
*
*
*
*
(c) An organization may apply to the
LFCC for inclusion as a local federation
to participate in the CFC if the applicant
has as members of the proposed
federation 15 or more charitable
organizations, in addition to the
federation itself, that meet the eligibility
criteria of §§ 950.202, 950.203 and
950.204. The initial year an organization
applies for federation status, it must
submit to the LFCC applications of all
its proposed member organizations in
addition to the federation application. A
federation must re-establish eligibility
each year, however only the
applications of its new and former
members that were not within the
federation, as a CFC participant, in the
previous year’s campaign need
accompany the annual federation
application once an organization has
obtained federation status, unless
PO 00000
Frm 00013
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
67287
additional member applications are
requested by the LFCC.
*
*
*
*
*
(e) * * *
(2) That it meets the eligibility
requirements contained in § 950.204
(including eligibility requirements and
public accountability standards of
§§ 950.202 and 950.203 that are
incorporated by reference). The
federation can demonstrate that it has
met the eligibility requirement in
§ 950.204(b)(1) either through its own
services, benefits, assistance or program
activities or through its 15 members’
activities.
(i) The federation must complete the
certification set forth at § 950.203(a)(2)
without regard to the amount of revenue
reported on its IRS Form 990 and must
provide a copy of its audited financial
statements. The audited financial
statements provided must verify that the
federation is honoring designations
made to each member organization by
distributing a proportionate share of
receipts based on donor designations to
each member. The audit requirement is
waived for newly created federations
operating for less than a year as
determined from the date of its IRS taxexemption letter to the closing date of
the CFC application period.
(ii) The federation must provide a
listing of its board of directors,
beginning and ending dates of each
member’s current term of office, and the
board’s meeting dates and locations for
the year prior to the year of the
campaign for which the organization is
applying.
(iii) The federation must certify that it
prepares and makes available to the
public, upon request, an annual report
that includes a full description of the
organization’s activities and supporting
services and identifies its directors and
chief administrative personnel. The
federation must provide a copy of its
most recently completed annual report
covering the fiscal year ending not more
than 18 months prior to January of the
campaign year to which the federation
is applying or the preceding calendar
year. The annual report must also
include an accurate description of the
federation’s membership dues and/or
service charges received by the
federation from the charitable
organizations participating as members.
The information must clearly present
the amounts raised, the sources of
contributions, the cost of fundraising,
and how costs are recovered from
donations.
*
*
*
*
*
E:\FR\FM\20NOR3.SGM
20NOR3
67288
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 223 / Monday, November 20, 2006 / Rules and Regulations
18. In § 950.304, revise paragraph (c)
and remove paragraphs (d) and (e) to
read as follows:
I
§ 950.304 Responsibilities of local
federations.
*
*
*
*
*
(c) Each federation, as fiscal agent for
its member organizations, must ensure
that Federal employee designations are
honored in that each member
organization receives its proportionate
share of receipts based on the results of
each individual campaign. The
proportionate share of receipts is
determined by donor designations to the
individual member organization as
compared to total campaign
designations.
19. Amend § 950.401 as follows:
a. In paragraph (a), remove the word
‘‘printed’’ in the second sentence and
add in its place ‘‘developed’’;
I b. In the first sentence of paragraph
(e), add the words ‘‘source of’’ after the
word ‘‘official’’, remove the word
‘‘package’’, and add the words ‘‘either in
hard copy or electronic format’’ after the
word ‘‘available’’;
I c. In paragraph (f), remove the word
‘‘package’’ in the first and second
sentences and add in its place ‘‘design’’;
I d. Revise the introductory paragraph
of (g)(1);
I e. Revise paragraphs (g)(2) through (j);
and
I f. In paragraph (k), remove the word
‘‘year’’ and add in its place ‘‘period’’,
and add to the end of the sentence the
text ‘‘or if the LFCC can demonstrate to
the satisfaction of the Director that it
can make the same information
available electronically without
disrupting donor opportunities to
contribute.’’
The revisions read as follows:
I
I
§ 950.401 Campaign and publicity
information.
sroberts on PROD1PC70 with RULES
*
*
*
*
*
(g) * * *
(1) OPM will include in the annual
distribution of the National/
International and International parts of
the Charity List explicit instructions for
the production of the Charity List and
language to be reproduced verbatim in
the introductory section. The general
information provided will include:
*
*
*
*
*
(2) Following the introductory
section, the Charity List will consist of
three parts—the National/International,
the International, and the Local. The
order of these three parts will be
annually rotated in accordance with
OPM instructions. The National/
International and International parts
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:36 Nov 17, 2006
Jkt 211001
will consist of faithful reproductions of
the parts of National/International and
International organizations, including
federations, provided by OPM. The
third part, the Local part, is determined
by the LFCC. The order of listing of the
federated and independent
organizations within the three separate
parts will be determined by random
drawing. The order of organizations
within each federation will be
determined by the federation. The order
within the National/International,
International and Local independent
groups will be alphabetical. Absent
specific instructions from OPM to the
contrary, each participating organization
and federated group listing must
include a description, not to exceed 25
words, of its services and programs,
plus a telephone number for the Federal
donor to request further information
about the group’s services, benefits, and
administrative expenses. Each listing
will include the organization’s
administration and fundraising
percentage as calculated pursuant to
§ 950.203(a)(4). Neither the percentage
of administrative and fundraising
expenses, nor the telephone number
count toward the 25-word statement.
(3) Each federation and charitable
organization will be assigned a code in
a manner determined by the Director. At
the beginning of each federated group’s
listing will be the federation’s name,
code number, 25-word statement,
percentage of administrative and
fundraising expenses, and telephone
number. The sections of the Charity List
where the independent organizations
are listed will begin with the titles
National/International Independent
Organizations, International
Independent Organizations and Local
Independent Organizations,
respectively.
(h) Omission of an eligible charitable
organization from the Charity List may
require that the Charity List be corrected
and reissued. Such an omission must be
reported to OPM immediately upon
discovery. The Director or LFCC may
direct that the cost of such correction
and reissue be borne by the PCFO or
charged to CFC administrative expenses.
(i) Listing of National and Local
Affiliate. Listing of a national
organization, as well as its local affiliate
organization, is permitted. Each national
or local organization must individually
meet all of the eligibility criteria and
submit independent documentation as
required in § 950.202, § 950.203 or
§ 950.204 to be included in the Charity
List, except that a local affiliate of a
national organization that is not
separately incorporated, in lieu of its
own 26 U.S.C. 501(c)(3) tax exemption
PO 00000
Frm 00014
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
letter and, to the extent required by
§ 950.204(b)(2)(ii), audited financial
statements, may submit the national
organization’s 26 U.S.C. 501(c)(3) tax
exemption letter and audited financial
statements, but must provide its own
pro forma IRS Form 990, page 1 and Part
V only, for CFC purposes. The local
organization must submit a certification
from the Chief Executive Officer (CEO)
or CEO equivalent of the national
organization stating that it operates as a
bonafide chapter or affiliate in good
standing of the national organization
and is covered by the national
organization’s 26 U.S.C. 501(c)(3) tax
exemption, IRS Form 990 and audited
financial statements. A national
organization may waive its listing in the
National/International or International
parts of the Charity List in favor of its
local affiliate by following the
procedures set forth in § 950.201(c).
(j) Multiple Listing Prohibited. Except
as provided in paragraph (i) of this
section, once an organization is deemed
eligible, it is entitled to only one listing
in the Charity List, regardless of the
number of federations to which that
organization belongs.
*
*
*
*
*
20. Amend § 950.402 as follows:
a. In paragraph (a), remove the word
‘‘year’’ and add in its place ‘‘period’’;
I b. In paragraph (c), add to the end of
the second sentence the text ‘‘, except in
cases of emergencies or disasters as
approved by the Director’’, and add a
new third sentence; and
I c. In paragraph (d), revise the last
sentence.
The addition and revision read as
follows:
I
I
§ 950.402
Pledge Form.
*
*
*
*
*
(c) * * * This restriction does not
apply upon implementation of
electronic technology that removes the
geographic restrictions on giving as
announced by the Director.
(d) * * * For example, if an employee
indicates a total gift of $100 on the
pledge form, but designates $50 to one
organization and $25 to each of three
other organizations, the PCFO must
adjust the pledges proportionately by
entering a pledge of $40 to the first
organization and $20 to each of the
three other organizations.
§ 950.403
I
[Removed]
21. Remove § 950.403.
22. Revise § 950.601 to read as
follows:
I
E:\FR\FM\20NOR3.SGM
20NOR3
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 223 / Monday, November 20, 2006 / Rules and Regulations
§ 950.601 Release of contributor
information.
(a) The pledge form, designed
pursuant to § 950.402, must allow a
contributor to indicate if the contributor
does wish his or her name, contribution
amount, and home contact information
forwarded to the charitable organization
or organizations designated. A PCFO’s
failure to honor a contributor’s wish
may result in the PCFO being
sanctioned or penalized as provided for
in § 950.603(a).
(b) The pledge form shall permit a
contributor to specify which
information, if any, he or she wishes
released to organizations receiving his
or her donations.
(c) It is the responsibility of the PCFO
to forward the contributor information
for those who have indicated that they
wish this information released to the
recipient organization directly, if the
organization is independent, and to the
organization’s federation if the
organization is a member of a
federation. The PCFO may not sell or
make any other use of this information.
23. In § 950.602, revise paragraph (b)
to read as follows:
I
§ 950.602
Solicitation methods.
*
*
*
*
*
(b) Special CFC fundraising events,
such as raffles, lotteries, auctions, bake
sales, carnivals, athletic events, or other
activities not specifically provided for
in these regulations are permitted
during the campaign period if approved
by the appropriate agency head or
government official, consistent with
agency ethics regulations. CFC special
fundraising events should be
undertaken in the spirit of generating
interest in the CFC and be open to all
individuals without regard to whether
an individual participates in the CFC.
Chances to win must be disassociated
from amount of contributions, if any.
Raffle prizes should be modest in nature
and value. Examples of appropriate
raffle prizes may include opportunities
for lunch with Agency Officials, agency
parking spaces for a specific time
period, and gifts of minimal financial
value. Any special CFC fundraising
event and prize or gift should be
approved in advance by the Agency’s
ethics official.
*
*
*
*
*
24. In § 950.603, revise the section
heading and paragraph (a) to read as
follows:
sroberts on PROD1PC70 with RULES
I
§ 950.603
Sanctions and penalties.
(a)(1) The Director may impose
sanctions or penalties on a federation,
charitable organization or PCFO for
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:36 Nov 17, 2006
Jkt 211001
violating these regulations, other
applicable provisions of law, or any
directive or instruction from the
Director. The Director will determine
the appropriate sanction and/or penalty,
up to and including expulsion from the
CFC. In determining the appropriate
sanction and/or penalty, the Director
will consider previous violations, harm
to Federal employee confidence in the
CFC, and any other relevant factors. The
Director may bar a federation or
charitable organization from serving as
PCFO, for a period not to exceed one
campaign period, if it is determined that
that the federation or charitable
organization has violated any provisions
of these regulations. A federation,
charitable organization or PCFO will be
notified in writing of the Director’s
intent to sanction and/or penalize and
will have 10 business days from the date
of receipt of the notice to submit a
written response. The Director’s final
decision will be communicated in
writing to the federation, charitable
organization, or PCFO, with a copy to
the appropriate LFCC.
(2) The Director may withdraw
federation status with respect to a
national, international or local
federation that makes a false
certification or fails to comply with any
directive of the Director, or to respond
in a timely fashion to a request by the
Director or LFCC for information or
cooperation, including with respect to
an investigation or in the settlement of
disbursements. The LFCC may
recommend the withdrawal of
federation status with respect to a local
federation. As stated in §§ 950.301(d)
and 950.303(d), failure to meet
minimum federation eligibility
requirements shall not be deemed to be
a withdrawal of federation status subject
to a hearing on the record. Eligibility
decisions shall follow the procedures in
§§ 950.301(f) and 950.303(f). A
federation will be notified in writing of
the Director’s intent to withdraw
federation status for a period of up to
one campaign period and will have 10
business days from the date of receipt of
the notice to submit a written response.
On receipt of the response, or in the
absence of a timely response, the
Director or representative shall set a
date, time, and place for a hearing. The
federation shall be notified at least 10
business days in advance of the hearing.
A hearing shall be conducted by a
hearing officer designated by the
Director unless it is waived in writing
by the federation. After the hearing is
held, or after the Director’s receipt of the
federation’s written waiver of the
hearing, the Director shall make a final
PO 00000
Frm 00015
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
67289
decision on the record, taking into
consideration the recommendation
submitted by the hearing officer. The
Director’s final decision will be
communicated in writing to the
federation, with a copy to the
appropriate LFCC.
(3) A federation, charitable
organization or PCFO sanctioned or
penalized under any provision of these
regulations must demonstrate to the
satisfaction of the Director that it has
taken corrective action to resolve the
reason for sanction and/or penalty and
has implemented reasonable and
appropriate controls to ensure that the
situation will not occur again prior to
being allowed to participate in
subsequent CFCs and/or serving as a
PCFO for a campaign.
*
*
*
*
*
25. Revise § 950.604 to read as
follows:
I
§ 950.604
Records retention.
Federations, PCFOs and other
participants in the CFC shall retain
documents pertinent to the campaign
for at least three completed campaign
periods. For example, documentation
regarding the 2006 campaign must be
retained through the completion of the
2007, 2008 and 2009 campaign periods
(i.e. until early 2011). Documents
requested by OPM must be made
available within 10 business days of the
request.
26. Amend § 950.801 as follows:
a. Revise paragraphs (a)(1) through (4);
and
I b. In paragraph (b), add the words
‘‘and international’’ in the first sentence
after the word ‘‘national’’, and add a
new second sentence.
The revisions and addition read as
follows:
I
I
§ 950.801
Campaign schedule.
(a) * * *
(1) During a period between December
and January, as determined by the
Director, OPM will accept applications
from organizations seeking to be listed
on the National/International and
International parts of the Charity List.
(2) The Director will determine a date
after the closing of the receipt of
applications by which the Director will
issue notices to each national and
international applicant organization of
the results of the Director’s review. The
date will be part of the annual timetable
issued by the Director under
§ 950.801(b).
(3) Local Federal Coordinating
Committees must select a PCFO no later
than a date to be determined by OPM.
The date will be part of the annual
E:\FR\FM\20NOR3.SGM
20NOR3
67290
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 223 / Monday, November 20, 2006 / Rules and Regulations
timetable issued by the Director under
§ 950.801(b).
(4) The Director will issue the
National/International and International
parts of the Charity List to all local
campaigns by a date to be determined
by OPM. The date will be part of the
annual timetable issued by the Director
under § 950.801(b).
*
*
*
*
*
(b) * * * The Director will issue the
timetable for a campaign period no later
than October 31 of the year preceding
the campaign period.
27. Amend § 950.901 as follows:
a. In paragraph (c)(1), remove the text
‘‘printed or purchased from a central
source’’ and add in its place
‘‘reproduced’’, and remove the word
‘‘distributed’’ and add in its place
‘‘made available’’;
sroberts on PROD1PC70 with RULES
I
I
VerDate Aug<31>2005
17:36 Nov 17, 2006
Jkt 211001
b. In paragraph (c)(2), add the word
‘‘paper’’ after the word ‘‘each’’, and add
the text ‘‘or an acceptable electronic
version’’ after the word ‘‘authorization’’;
I c. In paragraph (f)(1), add the text
‘‘pay period number,’’ after the word
‘‘period,’’; and
I d. Revise paragraphs (i)(1) and (i)(2);
The revisions read as follows:
I
§ 950.901
Payroll allotment.
*
*
*
*
*
(i) * * *
(1) The PCFO shall notify the
federations, national and international
organizations, and local organizations as
soon as practicable after the completion
of the campaign, but in no case later
than a date to be determined by OPM,
of the amounts, if any, designated to
them and their member agencies and of
the amounts of the undesignated funds,
PO 00000
Frm 00016
Fmt 4701
Sfmt 4700
if any, allocated to them. The date will
be part of the annual timetable issued by
the Director under § 950.801(b).
(2) The PCFO is responsible for the
accuracy of disbursements it transmits
to recipients. It shall transmit
disbursements at least quarterly, minus
the approved proportionate share for
administrative cost reimbursement and
the PCFO fee set forth in § 950.106. It
shall remit the contributions to each
organization or to the federation, if any,
of which the organization is a member.
The PCFO will distribute all CFC
receipts beginning April 1, and
quarterly thereafter. At the close of each
disbursement period, the PCFO’s CFC
account shall have a balance of zero.
*
*
*
*
*
[FR Doc. E6–19628 Filed 11–17–06; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 6325–46–P
E:\FR\FM\20NOR3.SGM
20NOR3
Agencies
[Federal Register Volume 71, Number 223 (Monday, November 20, 2006)]
[Rules and Regulations]
[Pages 67276-67290]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Printing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: E6-19628]
[[Page 67275]]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Part III
Office of Personnel Management
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
5 CFR Part 950
Solicitation of Federal Civilian and Uniformed Service Personnel for
Contributions to Private Voluntary Organizations--Eligibility and
Public Accountability Standards; Final Rule
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 223 / Monday, November 20, 2006 /
Rules and Regulations
[[Page 67276]]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
OFFICE OF PERSONNEL MANAGEMENT
5 CFR Part 950
RIN 3206-AL05
Solicitation of Federal Civilian and Uniformed Service Personnel
for Contributions to Private Voluntary Organizations--Eligibility and
Public Accountability Standards
AGENCY: Office of Personnel Management.
ACTION: Final rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: The Office of Personnel Management (OPM) is issuing final
regulations concerning the Combined Federal Campaign (CFC). These final
regulations are being issued as part of OPM's effort to modernize the
CFC and to realize administrative efficiencies. They were designed to
address the current and future environment of the CFC where the
electronic transmission of information will be more routine. As such,
these regulations update the criteria for CFC eligibility, streamline
the charity application process, ease the administrative burden on the
local campaigns, promote the use of electronic technology in the
administration of the CFC, and expand opportunities during disasters
and emergencies for Federal donors to contribute to all charities
participating in the CFC regardless of location.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Mark W. Lambert by telephone at (202)
606-2564; by FAX at (202) 606-5056; or by e-mail at cfc@opm.gov.
DATES: These regulations are effective November 20, 2006.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: Pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 553(d)(3), the Director
of the Office of Personnel Management finds good cause to waive the 30
day effective date for these regulations. Many national/international
organizations including federations, federation members, and
independent organizations, are beginning to prepare for filling out
their 2007 CFC applications for submission to OPM in January 2007. If
those organizations begin that process under the current regulations,
then are required to revise those applications pursuant to these
revised regulations, resources may be needlessly expended, there will
be confusion in revising applications, and some applicants who would be
eligible under the revised regulations might not apply under the
current regulations. Finally, there will be confusion and resource
implications for OPM to begin the review process when applications may
need to be withdrawn or revised if the regulations were not to become
effective until mid December or later.
OPM is issuing final regulations concerning eligibility provisions
and administrative requirements governing the participation of
organizations and the administration of the CFC. These final
regulations present a balanced approach to the current and anticipated
future needs of the CFC and continue the tradition of accountability in
the CFC by providing Federal donors with assurances that CFC
participating charities provide real services and are fiscally
accountable. OPM encourages stakeholders and non-profit sector
institutions with an oversight mission to collaborate to ensure that
all charities are fully accountable to the public they serve. OPM will
continue to emphasize the importance of providing complete, accurate,
and timely financial reports to donors, regulators and the public, and
will support donors by providing them with information to evaluate the
charities of their choice.
On June 29, 2006 (71 FR 37003), OPM issued comprehensive proposed
regulations to revise the procedures governing the solicitation of
Federal civilian and uniformed services personnel at the workplace for
contributions to private non-profit organizations. That workplace
solicitation is known as the CFC, administered by OPM under the
authority of Executive Order 12353 (March 23, 1982) as amended by
Executive Order 12404 (February 10, 1983). The proposed regulations
were issued to reduce the burden on applicant charitable organizations
seeking to qualify for the CFC, simplify the administrative process of
determining whether charitable organizations are eligible to
participate in the CFC, and facilitate modernization of the CFC. The
proposed regulations are available at https://a257.g.akamaitech.net/7/
257/2422/01jan20061800/edocket.access.gpo.gov/2006/pdf/06-5795.pdf.
In this final rule, OPM addresses the comments received on the
proposed rules set forth at 5 CFR part 950. The 45 day public comment
period ended August 14, 2006. A total of 415 comments were received
from participating CFC organizations, Principal Combined Fund
Organizations, members of Local Federal Coordinating Committees,
individuals and a Federal government agency.
Eligibility Provisions and Public Accountability Standards
Under the existing CFC regulations, there were 16 core eligibility
and public accountability standards and 3 core administrative
requirements that a charitable organization was required to satisfy in
order to participate in the CFC. These appeared in the form of
certifications in the annual CFC application. Many of the standards
required specific documentation, such as audited financial statements
and an annual report to demonstrate compliance. OPM had proposed
removing eight of these standards, including the requirement that
participating organizations' administrative and fundraising expenses
not exceed 25 percent of its total revenue. OPM had proposed modifying
some of the remaining standards to eliminate documented proof of
compliance. The standards of eligibility and accountability being
adopted by OPM in this Final Rule are summarized as follows:
1. Section 950.202(a)--National List Eligibility Requirements--
Certify that the applicant organization provides or conducts real
services, benefits, assistance, or program activities, in 15 or more
different states or a foreign country over the 3 year period
immediately preceding the start of the year involved. The proposed
regulation set forth that a detailed schedule would be required as part
of the application that described activities in each state or foreign
country in each year. In addition, OPM clarified the types of
information that it would consider acceptable to determine that real
services are provided or to accurately determine the individuals or
entities who benefit from the services. In addition, OPM proposed
adding a statement to clarify that de minimis services, benefits,
assistance, or other program activities in any state or foreign country
would not be accepted as a basis for eligibility. One organization and
one individual commented with a concern that OPM's attempt to clarify
the eligibility requirements would still result in limited additional
guidance for charities, federations, and OPM personnel. Both comments
recommended that OPM amend the regulations to adopt an extensive list
of factors against which OPM could evaluate whether an organization has
made a clear showing of actual services, benefits, assistance or
activities provided in each state or foreign country and also suggested
criteria that OPM should adopt to define what constitutes substantial
services. OPM
[[Page 67277]]
carefully considered these comments but is not accepting these
recommendations and the Final Rule will adopt the proposed regulation.
OPM believes that the most appropriate vehicle for any additional
guidance in this area is through use of the existing CFC administrative
memoranda process and through additional instructions in how to
complete the annual CFC application.
2. Section 950.202(b)--National List Eligibility Requirements--
Certify that the applicant organization is recognized by the Internal
Revenue Service as tax-exempt under 26 U.S.C. 501(c)(3) and to which
contributions are tax-deductible pursuant to 26 U.S.C. 170(c)(2) and
that the organization is classified as a public charity under 26 U.S.C.
509(a). OPM proposed this revision to clarify that applicant
organizations must be public charities, not private foundations, or
exclusively government units or instrumentalities thereof. There were
no comments on this proposal and OPM is adopting this change as
proposed.
3. Section 950.203(a)(1)--Public Accountability Standards--Certify
that the applicant organization is a human health and welfare
organization providing services, benefits, or assistance to, or
conducting activities affecting, human health and welfare. No changes
were proposed to this standard and it remains the same as the existing
regulation.
4. Section 950.203(a)(2)--Public Accountability Standards--Certify
that the applicant organization accounts for its funds in accordance
with generally accepted accounting principles and that an audit of the
organization's fiscal operations is completed annually by an
independent certified public accountant in accordance with generally
accepted auditing standards. Under the proposed rule, applicants would
no longer have been required to actually submit a copy of a recent
audit with the application. OPM also proposed to require a
certification that the organization had an audit only if it sought CFC
participation on the national/international or international parts of
the charity list and if it reported $250,000 or more in revenue on its
IRS Form 990. OPM proposed to exempt from the audit requirement
applicant organizations seeking to participate in the CFC at the local
level that reported revenue of less than $250,000. Numerous comments
were received both in support of and against this proposal. Those
opposed argued that reducing the number of CFC charities that are
independently audited would increase the risk of fiscal mismanagement
on the part of such charities and could increase the number of
applications for inclusion in the CFC. Those in favor noted that the
cost of an audit imposes a disproportionate burden on smaller, local
charitable organizations.
OPM has considered these various concerns. OPM agrees that by
requiring charities with revenues over $250,000 seeking to participate
in a local campaign to submit audited financial statements with the
application Federal donors will have additional assurances that such
organization is fiscally accountable. OPM is also retaining the
existing regulatory requirement that organizations seeking to
participate on the national/international and international parts of
the charity list, regardless of their revenues, certify that they
account for funds in accordance with generally accepted accounting
principles, have an audit of their financial statements conducted by an
independent certified public accountant in accordance with generally
accepted auditing standards, and submit a copy of their audited
financial statements. In a departure from the existing regulation,
organizations seeking local participation will be required to make
those same certifications and submit a copy of their audited financial
statements only if their revenues are over $250,000. Organizations with
revenues between $100,000 and $250,000 seeking local participation will
be required to certify that they account for funds in accordance with
generally accepted accounting principles and have an audit of their
financial statements conducted by an independent certified public
accountant in accordance with generally accepted auditing standards,
but will not be required to submit the audited financial statements
with their application. Charities with revenues less than $100,000
seeking local participation will be required to certify that they have
adequate financial controls in place, in form or substance as specified
by OPM, but will not be required to submit these with their
application.
5. Section 950.203(a)(3)--Public Accountability Standards--Certify
that it prepares and submits to the IRS a complete copy of the
organization's IRS Form 990 or that it is not required to submit an IRS
Form 990, and provide a completed copy of the organization's IRS Form
990, including signature, with the CFC application regardless of
whether or not the IRS requires the organization to file this form. OPM
proposed to revise this standard to require a certification in addition
to having the applicant submit a copy of the completed IRS Form 990
together with supplemental statements and Schedule A with the
application. OPM also proposed to no longer routinely check to
determine whether the IRS Form 990 revenues and expenses reported
reconcile with the audited financial statements since this
reconciliation is required to be performed by the organization on the
IRS Form 990 in Parts IV-A and IV-B. Comments opposing the proposed
rule noted that the level of CFC accountability would be lowered if the
previously required reconciliation between the IRS Form 990 and the
audited financials were removed. Comments in favor of the proposed
change suggested that the current reconciliation statement that
organizations are required to provide on the IRS Form 990 should be
sufficient to qualify for participation in the CFC. One organization
pointed out that efforts by leading nonprofit infrastructure
organizations to achieve greater consistency in financial reporting
standards for the charitable sector are the most appropriate vehicle to
promote improved reporting to the IRS and should not be used as a means
to exclude charities from the CFC. OPM agrees with the comments in
favor and will adopt the proposed regulation in the final rule.
6. Section 950.203(a)(4)--Public Accountability Standards--Provide
a computation of the organization's percentage of total support and
revenue spent on administrative and fundraising. This percentage shall
be computed from information on the IRS Form 990, submitted pursuant to
existing regulations at section 950.203(a)(3), by adding the amount
spent on ``management and general'' (line 14) to ``fundraising'' (line
15) and then dividing the sum by ``total revenue'' (line 12). No
substantive changes were proposed to this standard. The references to
specific lines of the IRS Form 990 were removed, in anticipation of
future changes to the Form by the IRS and the proposed regulation will
be adopted in the final rule.
7. Section 950.203(a)(5)--Public Accountability Standards--Certify
that the organization is directed by an active and responsible
governing body whose members have no material conflict of interest and
a majority of which serve without compensation. No changes were
proposed to this standard. One commenter suggested that CFC charities
be required to provide the names and terms of their governing board and
dates of prior year board meetings. OPM notes that under the current
CFC regulations, the Director currently has the discretion
[[Page 67278]]
to request this information as deemed necessary.
8. Section 950.203(a)(6)--Public Accountability Standards--Certify
that the organization's fundraising practices prohibit the sale or
lease of its CFC contributor lists. OPM proposed removing this
standard. Due to the number of public comments that claimed this could
undermine donor confidence in the CFC, OPM is withdrawing this proposed
regulation and will retain the existing regulation.
9. Section 950.203(a)(7)--Public Accountability Standards--Certify
that the applicant organization's publicity and promotional activities
are based upon its actual program and operations, are truthful and non-
deceptive, and make no exaggerated or misleading claims. OPM had
proposed to remove this standard. A majority of comments favored
retention of this certification as a precaution against abuse by
applicant organizations and as a possible enforcement tool in cases of
use of deceptive methods to mislead donors. OPM is withdrawing the
proposed regulation and will retain its existing regulation.
10. Section 950.203(a)(8)--Public Accountability Standards--Certify
that contributions are effectively used for the announced purposes of
the charitable organization. No changes were proposed to this standard.
11. Section 950.203(a)(12)--Public Accountability Standards--
Provide a statement that the certifying official is authorized by the
organization to certify and affirm all statements required for
inclusion on the national list. No changes were proposed to this
standard.
12. Section 950.203(a)(13)--Public Accountability Standards--
Provide a statement in 25 words or less describing the program
activities of the charitable organization. As proposed, this provision
is being removed as an eligibility standard, but is retained as an
administrative requirement in section 950.401(g)(2) and will be
required from each charitable organization completing the CFC
application. One commenter proposed that OPM specify that the 25-word
statement is not permitted to be misleading. OPM points out that
section 950.203(a)(7) of the existing CFC regulation, which will be
retained in the Final Rule, requires that organizations certify that
their publicity and promotional activities are truthful and non-
deceptive. OPM believes that section 950.203(a)(13) is more appropriate
as an administrative requirement. The proposed change is therefore
adopted in the final rule.
13. Section 950.605--Sanctions Compliance Certification--Each
federation, federation member and unaffiliated organization applying
for participation in the CFC must, as a condition of participation,
complete a certification that it is in compliance with all statutes,
Executive orders, and regulations restricting or prohibiting U.S.
persons from engaging in transactions and dealings with countries,
entities or individuals subject to economic sanctions administered by
the U.S. Department of the Treasury's Office of Foreign Assets Control
(OFAC). No changes were proposed to this certification.
Current Eligibility and Public Accountability Standards Removed in the
Final Rule
1. Section 950.202(c)--National List Eligibility Requirements--
Certify that the organization has no expenses connected with lobbying
and attempts to influence voting or legislation at the local, State, or
Federal level or alternatively, that those expenses would classify the
organization as a tax-exempt organization under 26 U.S.C. 501(h). The
majority of comments broadly supported OPM's proposed removal of this
standard because the existing regulatory requirement has been
misconstrued by some as prohibiting permissible advocacy by charities
participating in the CFC.
Given the interrelatedness of items 2 and 3, and the comments
received, the analysis follows after item 3--Section 950.203(a)(4)(ii).
2. Section 950.203(a)(4)(i)--Public Accountability Standards--If an
organization's administrative and fundraising expenses exceed 25
percent of its total support and revenue, it must certify that its
actual expenses for administration and fundraising are reasonable under
all the circumstances presented. It must provide an explanation with
its CFC application and also include a formal plan to reduce these
expenses below 25 percent.
3. Section 950.203(a)(4)(ii)--Public Accountability Standards--The
Director may reject any application from an organization with
fundraising and administrative expenses in excess of 25 percent of
total support and revenue, unless the organization demonstrates to the
satisfaction of the Director that its actual expenses for those
purposes and its plan to reduce them are reasonable under the
circumstances.
A significant majority of comments on these requirements opposed
OPM's proposal to remove the 25 percent administrative and fundraising
rates (AFR) threshold and the explanation and reduction plan
requirements as a condition of participation in the CFC. The commenters
argued that allowing a charity, regardless of its AFR ratio, to
participate in the CFC would result in an expansive increase in the
number of applicant organizations applying to the CFC. Commenters noted
that such increase could significantly raise the costs to manage the
application process and increase local campaign expenses to produce
larger brochures. Many comments suggested that OPM should instead
increase the acceptable AFR threshold to 35 percent, consistent with
the standards commonly used by stakeholders in the charitable
community. Other comments stated that the existing regulation should be
retained and that OPM should not expect that donors would have the
capability or resources to conduct their own research regarding an
organization's AFR. One national organization commenter supported the
elimination of the AFR standard as long as information about these
expenses is readily made available to donors. That same organization
suggested that OPM require applicant organizations with AFRs that
exceed 35 percent to also include an explanation or rationale for the
higher expenditures.
While OPM carefully considered this matter, OPM is adopting its
proposed regulation in the final rule and is removing the 25 percent
AFR ceiling as an eligibility standard. The issue of obtaining a
specific AFR in order to participate, the subjective nature of OPM's
determination regarding an acceptable explanation of a high AFR, and
the determination of the merits of the proposed reduction plan have
caused an administrative burden on OPM staff. Much of the litigation
affecting the CFC in the past several years have centered on this
issue, resulting in a substantial resource drain on OPM staff,
including the Office of CFC Operations. OPM believes that Federal
donors are capable of determining what their acceptable AFR levels
should be for charities they consider supporting. In the interest of
ensuring that potential Federal donors are informed of participating
organizations' AFR, OPM will continue to calculate and publish the AFR
of participating charities by listing the AFR in CFC information
including the charity lists that are distributed to the donor. OPM will
add a statement to all CFC Brochures that will note that OPM, as well
as the philanthropic community at large, remains concerned about
excessive AFR levels. The Brochure will inform the CFC donor that the
philanthropic community generally considers an AFR in excess of 35% to
[[Page 67279]]
be problematic and that potential CFC donors should carefully review
the circumstances applicable to the potential charities of their choice
to be certain they fully understand and accept the AFR situations for
such charities before donating to them.
OPM believes that Federal donors should have an opportunity to
donate to a wide range of charitable organizations and should not be
limited in their choices to those charities with AFRs of a specific
rate, so long as the AFR information is available to them to make an
informed decision. OPM encourages Federal donors to be knowledgeable
about those charities to which they choose to donate. OPM already
requires organizations to provide their World Wide Web address, if
available, where donors can research the organization. Many local
campaigns also provide donors with electronic access to information
from and about participating organizations. As the CFC continues to
modernize and more donors have more information available through the
internet, donors can have unlimited references on most organizations.
OPM is retaining the rule as it was proposed.
4. Section 950.203(a)(9)--Public Accountability Standards--Certify
under which governmental entity the charitable organization is
chartered, incorporated or organized (Congressionally chartered or the
state in which it is registered). OPM proposed to remove this standard.
There were five comments which opposed the proposed removal of this
standard. The comments noted that this information was not a burden to
collect and could be used to obtain additional information on the
organization. OPM believes that any such additional information can be
obtained from the application itself or from contacting the
organization directly. OPM will adopt the proposed regulation in the
final rule and will remove this eligibility standard.
5. Section 950.203(a)(10)--Public Accountability Standards--Certify
that the organization has received no more than 80 percent of its total
support and revenues from government sources as computed by dividing
line 1c by line 12 from the IRS Form 990 submitted pursuant to section
950.203(a)(3). Many comments agreed with OPM's proposed removal of this
standard. Two organizations favored retaining this certification based
on the rationale that the spirit of the CFC is to make the charitable
donations of Federal employees available to qualified charities, while
keeping out of the CFC those organizations which already have stable
funding and are, in essence, providing government supported services.
Two other organizations agreed with removing the standard, but
requested that any such organizations be denoted with an asterisk in
the CFC donor brochure to alert donors that they received more than 80
percent of their funding from government sources. OPM believes that the
existing requirement has served to exclude legitimate organizations
interested in diversifying their sources of support from participation
in the CFC. OPM will remove this standard in the final rule as
proposed.
6. Section 950.203(a)(11)--Public Accountability Standards--Certify
that the organization prepares and makes available to the public upon
request an annual report that includes a full description of the
organization's activities and supporting services and identifies its
directors and chief administrative personnel. OPM proposed to remove
this standard because a significant portion of the information sought
in the annual report is already the subject of a certification or
obtained as a result of other eligibility requirements and public
accountability standards contained in sections 950.202(a) and
950.203(a)(3). A number of comments were received both supporting and
opposing the proposed rule change. One comment in favor argued that
with an increasing number of organizations using expanded online
resources to present information, the proposed rule change would
encourage more organizations to present their information on-line.
Comments against OPM's proposed regulation claimed that requiring an
applicant to provide a copy of its annual report enhances
accountability and transparency. OPM believes that the annual report is
not an essential component of the application, particularly since the
application requires a detailed description of services, benefits or
activities which are carefully reviewed to determine eligibility. OPM
agrees that donors should be encouraged to access this information
online whenever possible or otherwise obtain an annual report directly
from the charity. OPM adopts the proposed regulation in its final rule.
Changes corresponding to these changes in eligibility and public
accountability requirements also are being made to the eligibility
requirements for the local part of the charity list contained in
section 950.204, and national and local federation standards set forth
at sections 950.301, and 950.303. As proposed, national, international
and local federations are required to submit documents to demonstrate
compliance with the audit, financial, governance and annual report
requirements. These requirements are clarified in sections
950.301(e)(2) and 950.303(e)(2). Federations provide services to 15 or
more member organizations. Services include the receipt and
distribution of funds through the CFC. Because federations handle
approximately 80 percent of all funds distributed through the CFC, the
documented evidence of compliance for federations will continue to be
required.
7. Section 950.204(b)(1)(ii)--OPM has decided not to proceed with
the proposed change that would require statewide services to be
provided over a 3 year period, and has withdrawn that change from the
final rule.
Miscellaneous Administrative Changes
In addition to changes and modifications to the eligibility
standards described above, OPM proposed other CFC administrative
changes to clarify CFC procedures, address areas of concern noted over
the years by OPM and stakeholders, and to better recognize the use of
electronic technology in the administration of the CFC. Except where
noted, comments received on the following proposed regulatory changes
supported such changes. Given the substantive concerns regarding two of
the proposed administrative changes, involving solicitation of
contractor personnel on Federal premises and the relationships between
national organizations and their bona fide local affiliates, OPM is
withdrawing the proposed regulation and retaining the regulations as
they previously existed with minor clarifying changes. These issues are
described in greater detail in the next section.
Proposed changes being adopted in the final regulations:
1. Various changes modifying references associated with the use of
paper-based information and processes such that these new terms apply
within an electronic CFC environment.
2. Section 950.101 includes a revised definition of ``Charity
List'' to be consistent with section 950.401(g)(2). Throughout the CFC
regulations, OPM has revised the terms ``National and International
Lists'' to use the terms ``National/International'' and
``International'' to be consistent with the definition of ``Charity
List'' in section 950.101 and the provisions of section 950.401(g)(2).
3. Current section 950.102(a) limits the annual solicitation of
donors to a six week period between September 1 and December 15. One
commenter stated that the six week period should be retained. OPM
believes that eliminating
[[Page 67280]]
the requirement of a specific six week period is in the best interests
of the campaign and will allow local campaign leadership to determine
the appropriate length of the solicitation that must still occur
between September 1 and December 15.
4. Current section Sec. 950.102(c) states that the Director
exercises general supervision over all operations of the CFC, and takes
all necessary steps to ensure the achievement of campaign objectives.
OPM will adopt as the final rule the proposed rule that clarifies and
specifically articulates the Director's authority to perform audits and
investigations of all CFC activities, and resolve any identified issues
resulting from such audits and investigations.
5. Current section 950.103(f) describes a six week period for
soliciting donors similar to that described in item (2) above.
Corresponding proposed changes are adopted in the final rule.
6. Current section 950.103(h) states that a Federal employee may
participate in a local CFC campaign only if that employee's official
duty station is located within the geographic boundaries of that
campaign. OPM proposed a modification to allow for contributions to
organizations outside of an employee's official duty station in the
cases of emergencies and disasters as defined in section 950.102(a),
upon approval by the Director. OPM further proposed to give the
Director authority to remove all geographic restrictions under any
circumstances at some future date upon the implementation of
appropriate technology. Because OPM anticipates such elimination of
these geographic restrictions on giving at some point in the future,
local eligibility based on adjacency and statewide presence will no
longer be necessary and will be eliminated upon implementation of
appropriate electronic technology to be announced by the Director at
some future date, without the need for a new proposed regulatory
proposal. Also see related changes proposed to section 950.204(b)(1).
OPM retains these provisions in the proposed rule.
A number of comments expressed concern over OPM's plans to manage
the flow of contributions during large scale emergencies or disasters
and one organization suggested that OPM should study the impact of this
provision on the structure and costs of the campaign. A disaster relief
organization recommended that in the event of a major disaster, a
separate campaign for disaster relief should be conducted concurrently
with the regular CFC in order to distinguish better the contributions
designated for disaster relief activities. OPM will consider this
suggestion but does not believe that adoption of the proposed
regulation would preclude the implementation of such a separate
disaster campaign since the Director currently exercises general
supervision over all operations of the CFC and has the authority to
take all necessary steps to ensure the achievement of campaign
objectives. Therefore, there is no need to specify the handling of the
campaign during times of emergency or disaster beyond the authority
already available, and OPM is adopting the rule as proposed.
7. Current section 950.104(b)(6) encourages local Federal agencies
to appoint loaned executives to assist in the campaign and grant
administrative leave to all loaned executives appointed. OPM is
adopting the proposed rule that will clarify that Federal agencies
should not place loaned executives on administrative leave since the
CFC activities are considered part of the official duties of the
Federal employee loaned to assist in the CFC.
8. Current section 950.104(c) states that the LFCC must annually
solicit applications for the PCFO via public notice. OPM proposed to
remove the requirement for an annual application and allow LFCCs to
enter into multi-year agreements, at their discretion. OPM also
proposed the removal of the requirement to solicit the PCFO
applications via a public notice and to provide the LFCC discretion as
to how to announce the solicitation as long as it reaches the audience
of prospective applicants. OPM will adopt these provisions in the final
rule.
9. Current section 950.106(a) states the amount a PCFO may recover
for campaign expenses shall not exceed 10 percent of the estimated
budget. OPM adopts the proposed regulation, correcting an error in this
section which would state that the recovery amount should not exceed
110 percent of the estimated budget.
10. Current section 950.109 describes certain conflicts of interest
for Federal employees who serve as an LFCC member or fundraising
coordinator. OPM proposed to add clarifying language regarding LFCC
members not being able to serve in their official capacity on the board
of directors of the non-profit organization that administers the CFC in
its local area. This situation was addressed in administrative guidance
at CFC Memorandum 2002-15. OPM is adopting this proposed revision in
the final rule.
11. Current sections 950.201(a)(1) and (2) discuss eligibility for
national organizations to be included on the national list. OPM
proposed adding references for international organizations, which must
also meet these criteria, and clarifying the Director's ability to
consider corrective action regarding any prior violation of regulation
or directive, sanction, or penalty, as appropriate, prior to
determining eligibility. OPM is adopting these proposed revisions in
the final rule.
12. Consistent with changes set forth above in paragraph 6, above,
current section 950.204(b)(1) is modified to allow for the Director to
provide for elimination of adjacency and statewide presence eligibility
requirements commencing with the implementation of appropriate
electronic technology. See related changes adopted in section
950.103(h). In addition, OPM clarifies this section to define more
clearly an adjacent local campaign. A number of comments were received
opposing this proposed change, noting a concern that statewide
charities and adjacent charities will lose contributions if they are
not included in the charity list, and donors will be affected if they
lose the opportunity to contribute to charities of their choice. OPM
notes that the current adjacency and statewide eligibility criteria
will remain in place until appropriate technology exists to permit
donors to make contributions without geographic restriction. OPM does
not intend that there would be any gap period during which a potential
donor would be deprived of an opportunity to donate to an eligible
charity during the transition from the current rule to the elimination
of geographic boundaries. OPM believes that the cost efficiencies
inherent in the use of appropriate technology will only be realized by
strongly encouraging the use of online electronic listings. OPM also
acknowledges that some form of paper charity list may be needed to
reach certain donors that may not have access to computers. In these
circumstances, OPM will issue appropriate guidance to facilitate a full
listing of all eligible charities within the geographic area. OPM is
adopting this provision in the final rule.
13. Current section 950.204(b)(2)(iii) is being amended to add
Guam, the Commonwealth of Northern Mariana Islands, and American Samoa
to the list of U.S. territories whose charities may be exempt from the
requirements of Sec. 950.202(b). A number of comments pointed out that
local organizations based in these territories do not generally
participate in the CFC because they are not granted this exception. OPM
determined that local non-profit organizations based in U.S.
territories
[[Page 67281]]
are entitled to similar privileges as those in Puerto Rico and the
Virgin Islands, provided they meet all other required eligibility
requirements.
14. Current section 950.204(e) is being revised to remove the 15
day period for LFCCs to make eligibility decisions and providing
instead that the decisions must be made as of a date determined by OPM
and published in the annual CFC calendar.
15. OPM proposed adding a new subsection to section 950.204(g) that
clarifies the LFCC's ability to consider corrective action regarding
any prior violation of regulation or directive, applying an appropriate
sanction or penalty, as appropriate, prior to determining eligibility
of local organizations. OPM is as adopting the proposal in the final
rule.
16. Current section 950.301(a) states that the Director may
recognize national and international federations that conform to
eligibility and accountability standards. OPM proposed clarifying the
Director's ability to consider corrective action regarding any prior
violation of regulation or directive applying an appropriate sanction
or penalty, as appropriate, prior to determining eligibility of
national and international federations. OPM is as adopting the proposal
in the final rule.
17. Current section 950.301(c) states that an organization may
apply for inclusion as a national CFC federation if the applicant
federation has 15 or more member organizations each of which meet the
eligibility criteria of sections 950.202 and 950.203. A national
federation must provide copies of applications for all of its members
in the initial year that it applies to participate in the CFC as a
federation, but needs to submit copies of applications after the
initial year only at OPM's request. OPM proposed to add clarifying
language that the federation itself does not count among the 15 or more
members organizations required to receive federation status. Four
comments stated that the federation itself should count as one of the
15 members. OPM believes that the federation itself should not be
included as one of those 15 member organizations, and is adopting the
proposed clarification in the final rule.
18. Current section 950.301(d) discusses the role of national and
international federations. OPM proposed a terminology change from
``decertification'' to ``withdrawal of federation status'' to conform
to a terminology change proposed in section 950.603(a). Numerous
commenters indicated that they opposed this change as well as the
changes regarding sanctions and penalties in section 950.603(a). The
commenters did not believe the proposed change provided an adequate
appeal process. OPM notes that it did not change the sanctions and
penalty requirements in the proposed rule. The proposed changes simply
clarified and consolidated the many sections that dealt with penalties
and sanctions into a single section at section 950.603(a). The
requirements are those required by Federal law and OPM is adopting the
proposed changes in the final rule.
19. Current section 950.301(e)(2) requires national and
international federations to certify that their financial activities
conform to generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and that
they are annually audited by an independent certified public accountant
in accordance with generally accepted auditing standards (GAAS). That
section further requires a copy of the audited financial statements and
that the audit must verify that the federation is honoring designations
made to each member organization. Finally, the current regulation
waives the audit requirement for newly created federations operating
for less than a year. OPM proposed to clarify and simplify the
regulatory language to apply to all eligibility requirements and public
accountability standards, contained in sections 950.202 and 950.203 and
required of independent organizations and federation members, to the
national and international federations. OPM does not view this as a
substantive change and is adopting the proposal in the final rule.
20. Current section 950.301(e)(2)(iii) requires national and
international federations to disclose important administrative expense
information to the CFC and donors in its annual report. One
organization suggested that OPM should consider the differences in
accounting systems used by federations and establish a standard
reporting system. OPM agrees that this could be of potential value and
will consider this as an area for future administrative review. OPM is
retaining the provision as proposed.
21. Current section 950.303(a) states that the LFCC must approve
local federations that conform to eligibility and public accountability
standards. OPM proposed to clarify the LFCC's ability to consider
corrective action regarding any prior violation of regulation or
directive, sanction, or penalty, as appropriate, prior to determining
eligibility of local federations. OPM adopts this proposal in the final
rule.
22. Current section 950.303(c) is the same requirement for local
federations as that described for section 950.301(c) regarding national
federations. OPM is adopting in the final rule the clarification that
the local federation itself does not count among the 15 or more members
required to receive federation status.
23. Current section 950.303(d) sets forth the role of local
federations. OPM will adopt in the final rule a terminology change from
``decertification'' to ``withdrawal of federation status'' to conform
to a terminology change in section 950.603(a).
24. Section 950.303(e)(2) sets forth the same requirement for local
federations as that is described above applicable to section
950.301(e)(2). The changes adopted for national and international
federations also are adopted for local federations in the final rule.
25. Section 950.303(e)(2)(iii) sets forth the same requirement for
local federations as that described above in section 950.301(e)(2)(iii)
for national and international federations. OPM will adopt this
requirement in the final rule.
26. Current section 950.401(g)(3) states that each national and
international federation and charitable organization will be assigned a
code number by OPM and each local federation and local charitable
organization will be assigned code numbers by the LFCC. OPM is
modifying this regulation to facilitate alternative mechanisms by which
OPM may assign charity codes. A number of comments expressed concerns
over the manner in which OPM is planning to implement a re-coding of
the charities, as part of the development of a centralized national CFC
list. One comment indicated that OPM has already begun the
implementation of such re-coding process by officially announcing that
OPM will be assigning both national and local code numbers and
requiring that LFCCs notify charities accordingly. OPM notes that while
the planning for the assignment of new codes for all CFC charities has
begun, the official assignment of codes will not occur before these
final regulations are implemented. OPM further notes that it has had
extensive consultation with stakeholders on the need for a new coding
structure and the limitations that the existing regulation imposes on
the structure of the campaign. OPM is adopting the proposed
modification in the final rule.
27. Current sections 950.401(i) and (j) are being amended to
provide that local affiliates of a national organization, not
separately incorporated, still can be determined locally eligible using
the national organization's IRS tax-exempt
[[Page 67282]]
determination letter and audited financial statements accompanied with
a certification that the local affiliate operates as a bona-fide
chapter or affiliate in good standing of the national organization and
that the affiliate is covered by the national organization's 501(c)(3)
tax exemption, IRS Form 990 and audited financial statements. The
affiliate must provide a pro forma IRS Form 990, page 1 and Part V
only, for CFC purposes in addition to the other documents required
under section 950.204.
28. Current section 950.601 governs the release of donor names and
addresses and the transmittal of this information to designated
charities. OPM proposed changing the terms ``names and address'' to
``information,'' to allow other donor information to be released, such
as contribution amount and home email address. Numerous comments
supported this change but suggested that clear ``opt-in, opt-out''
choices be given to donors. A number of comments opposed this change in
light of the proposed change to remove the prohibition against sale or
lease of contributor lists in section 950.203(a)(6). However, since OPM
is retaining the current regulatory prohibition against sale or lease
of contributor lists in section 950.203(a)(6), and will not adopt the
proposed change, OPM does not believe there is substantial disagreement
with this proposed change in section 950.601 and will adopt that change
in the final rule.
29. Current section 950.604 specifies that federations, PCFOs and
other participants shall retain documents pertinent to the campaign for
three campaign years. OPM proposed to clarify that three campaign years
is actually three completed campaign periods and is not based on
calendar years. OPM is adopting this clarification in the final rule.
30. Current section 950.801(a)(1) specifies the period during which
OPM will accept applications from organizations seeking to be listed on
the national and international parts of the charity list. OPM proposed
to modify this section to replace it with a period to be determined by
the Director. OPM will create, maintain, and issue a CFC calendar of
events each year to define the applicable time periods. Initially, OPM
will provide for a specific 60-calendar day period between December and
February as the period during which OPM will accept applications. OPM
adopts this modification in the final rule.
31. Current section 950.801(a)(2) states that within 35 calendar
days of the closing date for the receipt of annual applications, the
Director will notify each national and international applicant of the
results of the application review. OPM proposed to remove the defined
35 day requirement and annually publish an anticipated date for
notification on the calendar of events that OPM will maintain. OPM is
adopting this provision in the final rule.
32. Current section 950.801(a)(3) states that the LFCC must select
the PCFO no later than March 15 each year. OPM proposed to remove the
reference to March 15 and state that the LFCC must select the PCFO no
later than a date to be determined annually by OPM. OPM will provide
the date in its annual CFC calendar of events and initially set the
date as February 15 to allow campaigns to begin early planning for the
campaign beginning after the effective date of these regulations. OPM
is adopting this provision in the final rule.
33. Current section 950.801(a)(4) requires the Director to issue a
national and international list of eligible organizations by June 30.
OPM proposed to remove the specific date and state the requirement by a
date annually determined by the Director. Several comments indicated
that given the impact on all campaigns of the timely release by OPM of
the national and international parts of the charity list, that a
regulatory adjusted deadline would be preferred. One comment
recommended that OPM change the date for issuance from June 30 to July
30 to be consistent with current actual practice. OPM believes that
future release of the national and international parts of the charity
list and the screening of charities will be expedited by improved
technology and administrative improvements in these regulations and the
use of a specific deadline in regulation will impose an unnecessary
constraint. OPM is adopting the proposed change in the final rule.
34. Current section 950.801(b) requires the Director to annually
issue a timetable for accepting and processing national and
international applications. OPM proposed to modify this section to
specify that the Director will create, maintain and issue annually a
CFC calendar of events with specific dates that include the accepting
and processing of national and international applications as well as
other significant CFC dates. A majority of comments expressed concern
that without regulatory deadlines, local campaigns could not plan
adequately or hold OPM accountable for the release of the national and
international parts of the charity list. The proposed CFC calendar will
be official CFC guidance and OPM believes it will be sufficient to
allow for adequate local administration of the campaigns. In addition,
OPM does not anticipate significant changes to any of the dates being
removed from the regulations and will provide the annual calendar well
in advance of the annual campaign and time for selection of the PCFO
for any campaign. Local campaigns will have adequate time to plan for
the campaign based on the issuance of the CFC calendar of dates. OPM is
adopting the provision in the final rule.
35. Current 950.901(f)(1) requires the remittance checks sent by
payroll offices to the PCFO each pay period to be accompanied by a
statement identifying the agency, the dates of the pay period and the
total number of employee deductions. OPM proposed to add the pay period
number to the information required to be on this statement. OPM is
adopting this provision in the final rule.
36. Current sections 950.901(i)(1) and (i)(2) each contain specific
dates for the PCFO to notify charitable organizations of the amount of
pledged contributions (currently no later than February 15) and to
begin its periodic distributions to charitable organizations. OPM
proposed to remove the specific dates referenced in the regulation and
provide that these actions will occur no later than a date to be
determined annually by OPM. OPM will publish the dates in its annual
CFC calendar of events. Initially, OPM plans to extend the notification
date to March 15. OPM proposed to remove the requirement for monthly
payments and allow all campaigns to make quarterly payments beginning
no later than April 1. Several comments noted that some small
organizations could be adversely affected by quarterly payments. OPM
notes that the PCFO will continue to have the option of retaining the
monthly payments and is adopting the proposed provisions in the final
rule
37. Current sections 950.105(e), 950.302(c), 950.302(d),
950.304(c), 950.304(d), 950.403, and 950.603 all provide for certain
penalties and sanctions for federations, unaffiliated organizations,
and PCFOs. OPM proposed to clarify and combine these penalties and
sanctions into one new section 950.603 and remove the other references
from the regulations. Numerous commenters indicated that they did not
agree with the changes in section 950.603(a) because they did not
provide an adequate appeal process. OPM notes that it did not change
the sanctions and penalty requirements in the proposed rule. The
proposed changes simply clarified and
[[Page 67283]]
consolidated the many sections that dealt with penalties and sanctions
into a single section 950.603(a). The requirements are those required
by Federal law and OPM will adopt these changes in the final rule.
Proposed Regulations Withdrawn in Favor of Existing Regulations
1. Current section 950.103(g) prohibits solicitation of contractor
personnel, credit union employees and other persons employed on Federal
premises, and retired Federal employees but allows these individuals an
opportunity to participate in the CFC by making single contribution.
OPM's proposal to revise this rule by eliminating restrictions against
the solicitation of the above personnel received extensive comments
from the Office of Government Ethics (OGE). In particular, the OGE
stated that the proposed rule did not specify any standards governing
the circumstances under which the solicitations may occur. OPM agrees
this is an issue that requires additional study and is not adopting the
portion of the proposed rule that would have allowed the solicitation
of non-Federal personnel. OPM will retain the existing regulation in
order to have more time to re-examine this issue, while clarifying that
donations offered by non-Federal personnel must be accepted. OPM adopts
the portion of the proposed rule that allows for other electronic means
of contributing, including credit cards, upon approval by the Director.
2. Sections 950.204(b)(2)(iii) and (b)(2)(iv) were proposed
additions to the regulations intended to recognize financial
relationships between national organizations and their bona fide local
affiliates and to remove certain requirements depending on how those
relationships were structured. OPM received numerous comments opposing
the proposed changes which pointed to the emerging trends among
national charitable organization structures to operate as single
corporations with affiliates. OPM is not adopting the proposed
regulations and will retain a slightly modified version of the existing
regulatory language as its final rule. OPM has modified section
950.401(i) to clarify that local chapters/affiliate organizations must
satisfy CFC eligibility criteria and must independently demonstrate
services and accountability through the submission of independent
documentation as required in sections 950.202, 950,203 or 950.204,
except that a chapter or affiliate that is part of a single corporation
or part of a group exemption may rely on the 26 U.S.C. 501(c)(3) tax-
exempt determination and the audited financial statements for the
national organization, but must submit page 1 and Part V of a pro forma
IRS Form 990 used to calculate the AFR.
Regulatory Flexibility Act
I certify that this regulation will not have a significant economic
impact on a substantial number of small entities. Charitable
organizations applying to the CFC have an existing, independent
obligation to comply with the eligibility and public accountability
standards contained in current CFC regulations. Streamlining these
standards will be less burdensome.
Executive Order 12866, Regulatory Review
This rule has been reviewed by the Office of Management and Budget
in accordance with Executive Order 12866.
List of Subjects in 5 CFR Part 950
Administrative practice and procedures, Charitable contributions,
Government employees, Military personnel, Nonprofit organizations, and
Reporting and recordkeeping requirements.
Office of Personnel Management.
Linda M. Springer,
Director
0
Accordingly, OPM amends 5 CFR part 950 as follows:
PART 950--SOLICITATION OF FEDERAL CIVILIAN AND UNIFORMED SERVICE
PERSONNEL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS TO PRIVATE VOLUNTARY ORGANIZATIONS
0
1. The authority citation for part 950 continues to read as follows:
Authority: E.O. 12353 (March 23, 1982), 47 FR 12785 (March 25,
1982). 3 CFR, 1982 Comp., p. 139. E.O. 12404 (February 10, 1983), 48
FR 6685 (February 15, 1983), Pub. L. 100-202, and Pub. L. 102-393 (5
U.S.C. 1101 Note).
0
2. Amend part 950 as follows:
0
a. Remove the words ``brochure'' and ``brochures'' and add in their
place ``Charity List'' and ``Charity Lists'', respectively, wherever
they appear;
0
b. Remove the words ``card'' and ``cards'' and add in their place
``form'' and ``forms'', respectively, wherever they appear; and
0
c. Remove the words ``materials'', ``pamphlet'', and ``pamphlets'' and
add in their place ``information'' wherever they appear.
0
3. In Sec. 950.101:
0
a. Remove the definition of Campaign Year;
0
b. Add the definitions of Campaign Period, Charity List, and
Independent Organization in alphabetical order; and
0
c. In the definition of International General Designation Option remove
the word ``campaign''.
The additions read as follows:
Sec. 950.101 Definitions.
* * * * *
Campaign Period means generally a 24 month period beginning with
the selection of a Principal Combined Fund Organization (PCFO) or
renewal of the existing PCFO's agreement with a Local Federal
Coordinating Committee (LFCC) and ending with the final disbursements
to charitable organizations participating in a local campaign.
Charity List means the official list of charities approved by OPM
and the LFCC for inclusion in the CFC within a given geographic
solicitation area. The Charity List will consist of three parts: the
National/International part, the International part, and the Local
part. Organizations that provide services, benefits, assistance, or
program activities in 15 or more different states or a foreign country
can choose to be listed on either the International or National/
International part, except for members of a federation, which must be
listed with the federation. Organizations that provide services,
benefits, assistance, or program activities in 15 or more different
states but no foreign countries will be listed on the National/
International part. All qualifying local organizations within a CFC
geographic solicitation area will be listed on the Local part
associated with the campaign for that local CFC area.
* * * * *
Independent Organization means a charitable organization that is
not a member of a federation for the purposes of the Combined Federal
Campaign.
* * * * *
0
4. In Sec. 950.102 amend paragraph (a) by removing the text ``6 week''
from the second sentence, and amend paragraph (c) by adding two
sentences at the end of the paragraph to read as follows:
Sec. 950.102 Scope of the Combined Federal Campaign.
* * * * *
(c) * * * OPM has the authority to audit, investigate, and report
on the administration of any campaign, the organization that
administers the campaign, and any national, international and local
federation, federation member or independent organization that
participates in the campaign for compliance with these regulations. The
Director resolves any
[[Page 67284]]
issues reported and determines sanctions or penalties, as warranted
under Sec. 950.603.
* * * * *
0
5. In Sec. 950.103, revise paragraphs (f), (g) and (h) to read as
follows:
Sec. 950.103 Establishing a local campaign.
* * * * *
(f) Each year the LFCC must establish the time period during which
CFC solicitation may take place. The solicitation may not begin before
September 1 and in no event will it extend beyond December 15 of each
year.
(g) Current Federal civilian and active duty military employees may
be solicited for contributions using payroll deduction, checks, money
orders, or cash, or by electronic means, including credit cards, as
approved by the Director. Contractor personnel, credit union employees
and other persons present on Federal premises, as well as retired
Federal employees, may make single contributions to the CFC through
checks, money orders, or cash, or by electronic means, including credit
cards, as approved by the Director. These non-Federal personnel may not
be solicited, but donations offered by such persons must be accepted by
the local campaigns.
(h) A Federal employee whose official duty station is outside the
geographic boundaries of an established CFC may not be solicited in
that CFC. A Federal employee may participate in a particular CFC only
if that employee's official duty station is located within the
geographic boundaries of that CFC. This restriction may be discontinued
upon implementation of appropriate electronic technology that allows
removal of the need for geographic restrictions on giving as determined
by the Director. Upon a showing of extraordinary circumstances, as
determined in the sole discretion of the Director, Federal employees
may contribute in support of victims in cases of emergencies and
disasters defined in Sec. 950.102(a) outside the geographic boundaries
of their participating CFC. Such contributions can be check, money
order, or cash or by electronic means, including credit cards, as
approved by the Director, but shall not be made through payroll
deduction.
0
6. Amend Sec. 950.104 as follows:
0
a. In paragraphs (b)(4) and (b)(5), remove the word ``local''; and
0
b. Revise paragraphs (b)(6) and (c) to read as follows:
The revisions read as follows:
Sec. 950.104 Local Federal Coordinating Committee responsibilities.
* * * * *
(b) * * *
(6) Encouraging local Federal agencies to appoint loaned executives
to assist in the campaign. CFC loaned executives' time should be
charged to regular working hours. It is not appropriate to place a CFC
loaned executive on administrative leave, leave without pay, or annual
leave. Federal loaned executives are prohibited from working on non-CFC
fundraising activities during duty hours.
* * * * *
(c) The LFCC must select a PCFO to act as its fiscal agent and
campaign coordinator on the basis of presentations made to the LFCC as
described in Sec. 950.105(c). The LFCC may, in its discretion, select
a PCFO to serve in that role for up to three campaign periods, subject
to renewal each year following a review of performance as defined in
Sec. 950.105. The LFCC must consider the capacity of the organization
to manage an efficient and effective campaign, its history of public
accountability, use of funds, truthfulness and accuracy in
solicitations, and sound governance and fiscal management practices as
the primary factors in selecting a PCFO. The LFCC must solicit
applications on a competitive basis for the PCFO no later than a date
to be determined by OPM and, if the LFCC exercises discretion to enter
into a multi-year arrangement, upon completion of the multi-year term.
The LFCC shall solicit applications via outreach activities including:
Public notice in newspapers, postings on Web sites, advertising in
trade journals, dissemination among participating CFC organizations and
federations, and/or outreach through local or state nonprofit
associations and training centers, among others. The PCFO application
period must be open a minimum of 21 calendar days. Costs incurred for
soliciting applications must be added to the PCFO budget as an
administrative cost.
Sec. 950.105 [Amended]
0
7. Amend Sec. 950.105 as follows:
0
a. In paragraph (b), remove the word ``printed'' in the second sentence
and add in its place the word ``developed'';
0
b. In paragraph (d)(3), remove the word ``address'' and add in its
place ``contact information'';
0
c. In paragraph (d)(6), add the text ``, cont