Public Transportation on Indian Reservations Program; Tribal Transit Program, 46959-46973 [06-6911]
Download as PDF
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 157 / Tuesday, August 15, 2006 / Notices
and its grant program is available at
www.bywaysonline.org.
Respondents: An estimated total of
60, to include 50 State Departments of
Transportation, the District of Columbia
and Puerto Rico, Federal Land
Management Agencies, State and local
governments, non-profit agencies and
Tribal Governments. It is estimated that
400 applications will be received
annually.
Frequency: Annual.
Estimated Average Burden per
Response: 40 hours.
Estimated Total Annual Burden
Hours: 16,000 hours.
Electronic Access: Internet users may
access all comments received by the
U.S. DOT Dockets, Room PL–401, by
using the universal resource locator
(URL): https://dms.dot.gov, 24 hours
each day, 365 days each year. Please
follow the instructions online for more
information and help.
Authority: The Paperwork Reduction Act
of 1995; 44 U.S.C. Chapter 35, as amended;
and 49 CFR 1.48.
Issued on: August 9, 2006.
James R. Kabel,
Chief, Management Programs and Analysis
Division.
[FR Doc. E6–13394 Filed 8–14–06; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4910–22–P
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
Federal Transit Administration
[Docket No. FTA–2006–24143]
Public Transportation on Indian
Reservations Program; Tribal Transit
Program
Federal Transit Administration
(FTA), DOT.
ACTION: Notice of funding availability:
Solicitation of grant applications for FY
2006 tribal Transit Program Funds.
mstockstill on PROD1PC61 with NOTICES
AGENCY:
SUMMARY: This Notice accomplishes
several purposes. First, the U.S.
Department of Transportation, Federal
Transit Administration (FTA)
summarizes and responds to written
comments FTA received in response to
a March 22, 2006, Federal Register
Notice regarding proposed grant
program provisions for this new
program and to oral comments FTA
received during two announced public
meetings on this program that were held
on April 4, 2006, in Denver, Colorado,
and on April 7, 2006, in Kansas City,
Missouri. Second, this Notice
announces the availability of funds in
fiscal year (FY) 2006 for the Public
Transportation on Indian Reservations
VerDate Aug<31>2005
15:41 Aug 14, 2006
Jkt 208001
Program, a new program authorized by
the Safe, Accountable, Flexible,
Efficient Transportation Equity Act: A
Legacy for Users. Finally, this Notice
announces a national solicitation for
applications, with grantees and projects
to be selected on a competitive basis;
the grant terms and conditions that will
apply to this new program; and grant
application procedures and selection
criteria for FY 2006 projects.
ADDRESSES: This announcement is
available on the FTA’s Web site at:
https://www.fta.dot.gov. FTA will
announce final selections on the Web
site and in the Federal Register. A
synopsis of this announcement will be
posted on the governmentwide
electronic grants Web site at: https://
www.GRANTS.GOV. Applications may
be submitted in one of three ways:
electronically through GRANTS.GOV, in
hard copy to Federal Transit
Administration, 400 Seventh Street,
SW., Room 9315,Washington, DC 20590,
Attention: Lorna R. Wilson; or sending
by e-mail to fta.tribalprogram@dot.gov.
DATES: Complete applications for Public
Transportation on Indian Reservations
Program grants must be submitted in
hard copy to the FTA, via e-mail by
October 16, 2006, or submitted
electronically through the
GRANTS.GOV Web site by October 16,
2006. Anyone intending to apply
electronically should initiate the
process of registering on the
GRANTS.GOV site immediately to
ensure completion of registration before
the deadline for submission. FTA will
announce grant selections in the
Federal Register when the competitive
selection process is complete.
Applicants should be aware that
materials sent through the U.S. Postal
Service are subject to significant delays
in delivery due to the security screening
process. Use of courier or express
delivery services is recommended if
unable to apply electronically.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Contact the appropriate FTA regional
Tribal Liaison (Appendix A) for
application-specific information and
issues. For general program information,
contact Lorna R. Wilson, Office of
Transit Programs, (202) 366-2053,
e-mail: Lorna.Wilson@dot.gov. A TDD is
available at 1–800–877–8339 (TDD/
FIRS).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Table of Contents
I. Overview
II. Background
III. Comments and Responses
A. Process and Criteria
B. Terms and Conditions
PO 00000
Frm 00071
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
46959
C. Other Issues
IV. Funding Opportunity Description
A. Authorized Funding for FY2006
B. Background
V. Award Information
VI. Eligibility Information
A. Eligible Applicants
B. Eligible Projects
VII. Cost Sharing or Matching
VIII. Terms and Conditions
IX. Application Submission Information
X. Guidelines for Preparing Grant
Application
XI. Application Content
A. Application Information
B. Technical, Legal, and Financial Capacity
C. Project Information
D. Application Evaluation Criteria
E. Submission Dates
F. Intergovernmental Review
G. Funding Restrictions
H. Other Submission Requirements
XII. Application Review Process
A. Competitive Selection Process
B. Evaluation Criteria
1. Criterion 1: Project Planning and
Coordination
2. Criterion 2: Demonstration of Need
3. Criterion 3: Benefits of Project
4. Criterion 4. Financial Commitment and
Operating Capacity
C. Proposals for Planning Grants
D. Review and Selection Process
XIII. Award Information
XIV. Other Information
A. Technical Assistance
B. Standard Assurances
C. Reporting
D. Agency Contacts
Appendices
Appendix A. FTA Regional Offices and
Tribal Liaison
Appendix B. Federal Fiscal Years 2006 and
2007 Certifications and Assurances for
the Federal Transit Administration
Public Transportation on Indian
Reservations Program
Appendix C. Technical Assistance
Contacts
I. Overview
Section 3013 of SAFETEA–LU
amended 49 U.S.C. 5311(c) by
establishing the Public Transportation
on Indian Reservations Program
(hereinafter referred to as the Tribal
Transit Program). This new program
authorizes direct grants ‘‘under such
terms and conditions as may be
established by the Secretary’’ to Indian
tribes for any purpose eligible under
FTA’s Nonurbanized Area Formula
Program, 49 U.S.C. 5311. The funding
level authorized for this new program
will increase from $8 million in FY
2006 to $15 million in FY 2009. The
Conference Report to SAFETEA–LU
indicated that the funds set aside for
Indian tribes in the Tribal Transit
Program are not meant to replace or
reduce funds that Indian tribes receive
from States through FTA’s
Nonurbanized Area Formula Program.
E:\FR\FM\15AUN1.SGM
15AUN1
46960
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 157 / Tuesday, August 15, 2006 / Notices
II. Background
FTA published a Notice in the
Federal Register dated November 30,
2005 (70 FR 71950), ‘‘FTA Transit
Program Changes, Authorized Funding
Levels and Implementation of the Safe,
Accountable, Flexible, Efficient
Transportation Equity Act: A Legacy for
Users: Notice’’ which announced
changes to current FTA programs and
new programs, including the Tribal
Transit Program. In the November 30,
2005, Federal Register Notice, FTA set
forth and requested public comments on
the proposed basis for formula
apportionment for the Tribal Transit
Program, eligible grant purposes, and
proposed program requirements.
On March 22, 2006, FTA published a
Notice in the Federal Register (71 FR
14618), ‘‘Public Transportation on
Indian Reservations Program (49 U.S.C.
5311(c)(1): Notice of Public Meetings,
Proposed Grant Program Provisions;
Notice.’’ FTA responded to comments
that were received from the public in
response to the November 30, 2005
Federal Register Notice, and requested
additional comment on the following
issues: the proposed basis for allocating
funds; grantee eligibility; eligible
purposes for grant funds; proposed
terms and conditions for the grant
program, and local share options. The
Notice also announced two one-day
outreach meetings on the Tribal Transit
Program. The comment period on the
March 22, 2006, Federal Register Notice
ended on April 21, 2006, but comments
submitted after that date were
considered.
mstockstill on PROD1PC61 with NOTICES
III. Comments and Responses
FTA received 28 written comments in
response to the March 22, 2006, Federal
Register Notice and additional oral
comments were received from the
Indian tribes and other organizations at
the two public outreach meetings that
were held in April 2006. A summary of
the oral comments were placed in the
docket for this Notice. All of the written
and oral comments received by FTA
during the comment period can be
divided into the following categories: (a)
The process and the criteria that should
be established by FTA to allocate
funding under the Tribal Transit
Program; (b) the terms and conditions
that should be applied to grants
awarded under the Tribal Transit
Program, which includes the proposed
options for local match; and (c) other
issues that were not specifically
proposed or addressed in the March 22,
2006 Federal Register Notice. The
comments received from the Indian
tribes and others were generally very
VerDate Aug<31>2005
15:41 Aug 14, 2006
Jkt 208001
favorable to the establishment and
implementation of this new program
and proposed program requirements.
However, the Indian tribes and others
strongly disagreed with some of FTA’s
proposals in the March 22, 2006,
Federal Register Notice. The Indian
tribes also offered recommendations and
changes to FTA’s proposals based on
their unique perspective and experience
in providing public transportation on
Indian reservations.
In addition, to further ensure an
equitable distribution of funds in this
new program, FTA will separately
evaluate proposals under the following
three categories: (1) Start-up operations;
(2) enhancements or expansions of
existing transit services; and (3) transit
planning and/or operational planning
grants. The application process will also
allow a tribal government to apply for
multiple years of funding, subject to the
availability of appropriations.
A. Process and Criteria
B. Terms and Conditions
Comment: There was a clear
consensus that strongly disagreed with
FTA’s interpretation of section 5311(c)
prohibiting the use of funds in the
Tribal Transit Program for planning
purposes. Commenters argued that the
statute permits funds in the Tribal
Transit Program to be used for any
purpose eligible under section 5311.
The commenters stated that other
subsections of section 5311 permit the
use of section 5311 funds for planning.
Therefore, planning should be an
eligible purpose under section 5311(c).
Response: FTA’s interpretation that
planning was not an eligible use of
Tribal Transit Program funds was based
on the program’s history. As originally
enacted, Nonurbanized Area Formula
Program funds could be used only for
capital and operating purposes.
Although planning was permitted under
certain situations set forth in
subsections (e) and (f) of section 5311,
FTA viewed the limited eligibility of
planning in these subsections as an
exception to the general rule that
planning was not an eligible purpose. It
followed that ‘‘any purpose eligible
under [section 5311]’’ meant that
section 5311(c)(1) funds could only be
used for capital and operating purposes.
Based on the comments submitted to
the docket from the Indian tribes and
other organizations, and comments
heard at the two public outreach
meetings held in April 2006 concerning
the issue that planning should be
eligible under this new program, FTA
reviewed section 5311(c), as amended
by SAFETEA-LU, to determine whether
a more expansive interpretation of the
statute might be justified. Under a
general rule of statutory construction
that gives weight to the plain meaning
of a statute, we construe the word ‘‘any’’
in section 5311(c)(1) to be synonymous
with ‘‘all’’ eligible purposes under
section 5311. This rule of statutory
construction is consistent with U.S.
Supreme Court decisions which have
long held that there is no more
persuasive evidence of the purpose of a
statute than the words by which the
legislature undertook to give expression
The March 22, 2006, Federal Register
Notice proposed a single annual
competitive selection process to fund
both new and existing tribal transit
systems and suggested not establishing
minimum or maximum awards. In
addition, the Notice proposed the
following five criteria that would be
evaluated and rated by FTA in making
an award selection: Demonstration of
need; benefits of the project; adequacy
of project planning; financial
commitment; and coordination. The
Indian tribes were mostly in agreement
on FTA’s proposal to make single
annual competitive selections for
awards under the Tribal Transit
Program. However, there were divergent
comments received concerning the
criteria proposed by FTA for project
funding under this new program. We
will address the comments that were
submitted by the Indian tribes and
others in the following section of this
document.
Comment: There were multiple
comments concerning FTA’s proposal
for allocating funds in this new
program. Several comments from small
Indian tribes observed that FTA’s
criteria appeared to be biased in favor of
existing tribal transit systems.
Comments from larger Indian tribes
stated that the criteria should be based
on established transit systems or for
tribes that have identified their transit
needs in the Tribal Transportation
Improvement Program. Other comments
suggested an additional criterion that
would consider the reasonableness of
the amount requested or that projects
should be funded for multiple years to
ensure successful implementation of
transit projects.
Response: FTA will ensure that there
will be an equitable distribution of
funds in this new program for eligible
transit projects that are planned,
constructed, or operated by the Indian
tribes. FTA has decided to include the
following four criteria: project planning
and coordination; demonstration of
need; benefits of project; and financial
commitment and operating capacity.
PO 00000
Frm 00072
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
E:\FR\FM\15AUN1.SGM
15AUN1
mstockstill on PROD1PC61 with NOTICES
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 157 / Tuesday, August 15, 2006 / Notices
to its wishes. U.S. v. American Trucking
Ass’ns., 310 U.S. 534, 543 (1940). By
applying this rule of statutory
construction, FTA has determined that
a broader interpretation of this statute
will more effectively carry out the
purpose of this new program. FTA
therefore interprets Section 5311(c) to
allow funds apportioned to Indian tribes
to be used for ‘‘any’’ purpose identified
under section 5311, which includes
planning activities.
FTA notes, however, that because
section 5311(c)(1) also states that the
Tribal Transit Program funds are to be
apportioned under such terms and
conditions established by FTA, FTA has
the discretion to limit the amount of
funds available for each eligible purpose
under this program. Accordingly, FTA
will limit the amount of funds that are
available for planning in the Tribal
Transit Program to 15 percent of the
grant award. In addition, for grants that
are exclusively for planning purposes,
FTA will limit the amount of funds to
$25,000 per applicant.
Comment: Many of the Indian tribes,
and several State Departments of
Transportation, commented on FTA’s
proposal for planning requirements.
They disagreed with FTA’s proposal
that Tribal Transportation Improvement
Plans (TTIP) or Long Range
Transportation Plans be attached or
included in the Statewide
Transportation Improvement Program
(STIP). The State DOT’s specifically
contended that a TTIP which did not
meet various legal requirements (e.g.,
public participation, fiscally
constrained plans) could potentially
disqualify the State’s STIP process.
Therefore, they suggested that this
proposed planning requirement be
omitted entirely or, alternatively, that
the TTIP be attached to a STIP for
informational purposes only and that
the TTIP not be considered a formal part
of the STIP.
Response: FTA agrees with this
concern. FTA recognizes that Indian
tribes are not subject to Federal
planning requirements. To require the
attachment of tribal transportation plans
to a STIP could not only cause
unnecessary delay to the grant making
process but also potentially invalidate
the State’s STIP. Accordingly, FTA will
not require Indian tribes to attach tribal
transportation plans to a STIP. However,
because it would assist both the Indian
tribes and State Departments of
Transportation to coordinate and assess
their planned transportation projects,
FTA encourages Indian tribes, for
informational purposes only, to submit
a copy of their tribal transportation
VerDate Aug<31>2005
15:41 Aug 14, 2006
Jkt 208001
plans to State Departments of
Transportation.
Comment: Many comments were
received from the Indian tribes on FTA’s
two proposed options for local share.
Most of the comments opposed both
options and recommended that FTA
eliminate the local share requirement.
Others generally favored a 20 percent
local match for both capital and
operating expenses.
Response: FTA’s first option proposed
a Federal share of 80 percent and a local
share of 20 percent for both capital and
operating assistance projects. The
second option proposed the highest
Federal share allowed under the Title 23
Section sliding scale for States with
large public lands. The second option
would thus allow a Federal share of 95
percent for capital projects and a federal
share of 60 percent for operating
assistance projects. Under both of the
two proposed options, FTA believes that
a Tribal financial contribution was
important to register commitment to
projects. However, FTA recognizes that
many Indian tribes have limited
financial resources. In fact, because
tribes often lack financial resources,
other Federal assistance programs, such
as the Federal Highway Administration
Indian Reservations Road program,
require no Tribal contribution. Since
these concerns outweigh FTA’s interest
in a financial expression of a tribal
commitment to the program, FTA will
not require a non-Federal matching
share for Tribal Transit Program grants.
FTA believes that the intent of this new
program will be more quickly achieved
without a tribal share matching
requirement.
Comment: Two commenters disagreed
with FTA’s proposal not to apply the
labor protective provisions in 49 U.S.C.
section 5333(b) to grants under this new
program. It was argued that the Tribal
Transit Program is a program under
section 5311 (which is subject to
statutory labor protections) and there is
no indication that Congress specifically
intended for section 5333(b) labor
protections to not apply to this new
program.
Response: FTA stated in the March
22, 2006 Federal Register Notice that
direct grants from FTA to Indian tribes
do not involve State-subrecipient
relationships. Therefore, the
administrative procedures the U.S.
Department of Labor (DOL) uses to
apply the section 5311 special warranty
do not apply.
Accordingly, FTA proposed not to
apply the labor protective provisions of
49 U.S.C. 5333(b) to this new program.
However, FTA is aware that DOL is
currently initiating a Notice of Proposed
PO 00000
Frm 00073
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
46961
Rulemaking to revise its labor protective
arrangements for all FTA grants
(including the special warranty that is
applied in the section 5311 program).
Also, although Congress chose not to
apply section 5333(b) to several other
new programs enacted in SAFETEA-LU,
Congress amended section 5311(i) to
apply section 5333(b) ‘‘if the Secretary
of Labor utilizes a special warranty that
provides a fair and equitable
arrangement to protect the interests of
employees.’’ Congress did not exempt
the Tribal Transit Program from this
requirement. FTA therefore intends to
apply the special warranty to the Tribal
Transit Program in the future. However,
FTA will postpone the application of
the special warranty arrangement to the
Tribal Transit Program until DOL adopts
procedures for the new program.
Comment: Several comments
questioned the applicability of Federal
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise
(DBE) regulations, 49 CFR part 26, to
Indian tribes.
Response: The U.S. Department of
Transportation’s DBE regulation
requires a grant recipient to implement
a DBE program and to establish annual
DBE goals for all contracting
opportunities, except for vehicle
procurements, where Federal financial
assistance exceeds $250,000. However,
due to the relatively small size of the
grants that will be awarded under this
new program and to streamline program
requirements for this new program to
the benefit of Indian tribes, FTA has
determined that the FTA DBE
regulation, 49 CFR part 26, will not
apply to the Tribal Transit Program.
Comment: A few comments were
received from Indian tribes regarding
FTA’s interpretation and application of
the Civil Rights Act of 1964 to tribal
employment rights ordinances (TEROs),
which provide for Indian preference in
employment and contracting.
Response: FTA will not require Indian
tribes under this new program to
comply with FTA’s program-specific
guidance for Title VI and Title VII of the
Civil Rights Act of 1964. Title VI of the
Civil Rights Act prohibits
discrimination on the basis of race,
color, and national origin in programs
and activities receiving Federal
financial assistance. Title VII of the
Civil Rights Act prohibits
discrimination in employment in any
business on the basis of race, color,
religion, sex, or national origin. Indian
tribes are specifically excluded from the
definition of an ‘‘employer’’ under the
Act. Thus, to the extent that TEROs are
consistent with federal statutes that
authorize a general preference for
Indians in employment or contracting
E:\FR\FM\15AUN1.SGM
15AUN1
mstockstill on PROD1PC61 with NOTICES
46962
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 157 / Tuesday, August 15, 2006 / Notices
for Federally funded work on or around
Indian reservations, FTA will of course
comply with applicable law. However,
although Indian tribes will not be
subject to FTA’s program-specific
requirements under Title VI and Title
VII of the Civil Rights Act, Indian tribes
under the Tribal Transit Program will
nonetheless still be subject to the
provisions of Title VI and Title VII of
the Civil Rights Act, unless they are
specifically exempt from the Act.
C. Other
Comment: A number of the Indian
tribes commented on the obligation of
FTA to properly consult with the Indian
tribes on a government-to-government
basis for this new program in
accordance with Presidential executive
orders and U.S. Department of
Transportation procedures.
Response: FTA recognizes that the
Federal government has a unique legal
relationship with Indian Indian tribes.
When FTA implements a program that
might have substantial direct effects on
the Indian tribes or on the sovereignty
of the Indian tribes, FTA must consult
and coordinate using established
principles. These principles are set forth
in Presidential Executive Order 13175,
‘‘Consultation and Coordination with
Indian Tribal Governments,’’ November
6, 2000, and U.S. Department of
Transportation Order 5301.1,
‘‘Department of Transportation
Programs, Policies, and Procedures
affecting American Indians, Alaska
Natives and tribes for programs affecting
Indian tribal governments.’’
During the development of policies
and procedures for the Tribal Transit
Program, FTA consulted and
coordinated with the Indian tribes
consistent with these Executive Orders.
Specifically, FTA announced and
invited comments from the Indian tribes
concerning the Tribal Transit Program
in two separate Federal Register
Notices. The first Federal Register
Notice, (70 FR 71950), ‘‘FTA Transit
Program Changes, Authorized Funding
Levels and Implementation of the Safe,
Accountable, Flexible, Efficient
Transportation Equity Act: A Legacy for
Users: Notice,’’ was published on
November 30, 2005. This first Notice
invited comment from the Indian tribes
and others on the proposed basis for
formula apportionment for the Tribal
Transit Program, eligible grant purposes,
and proposed program requirements. A
second Federal Register Notice,
published on March 22, 2006,
responded to comments received from
the Indian tribes on the November 30,
2005 Notice. The second Notice further
solicited comments from the Indian
tribes and others on FTA’s proposed
VerDate Aug<31>2005
15:41 Aug 14, 2006
Jkt 208001
basis and criteria to allocate funding
under this new program, proposed
eligible activities, and proposed grant
requirements. The second Notice also
announced two one-day public outreach
meetings on the Tribal Transit Program.
In the two public meetings held in
Denver, Colorado, and Kansas City,
Missouri, FTA presented its proposals
as set forth in the March 22, 2006 Notice
and received further comments from the
Indian tribes in attendance. In addition,
prior to the March 22, 2006, Notice,
FTA conducted several national
teleconferences with the Indian tribes to
obtain their input and views on issues
concerning the development and
implementation of the Tribal Transit
Program.
Comment: Although FTA did not
solicit comments, or propose guidance,
on the following issue, several Indian
tribes suggested that FTA should
administer grants under this program in
a manner that is either the same or
similar to contracts and agreements
under the Indian Self-Determination
and Education Assistance Act
(ISDEAA).
Response: FTA recognizes Indian
tribes as sovereign governments that can
independently administer certain
Federal government programs as
authorized by the ISDEAA. Although
the statutory authority to enter into
contracts with Indian tribes under
ISDEAA does not include the FTA, FTA
is nonetheless implementing this new
program in a manner consistent with the
principles of self-determination that are
embodied in ISDEAA. To do so, FTA is
streamlining and omitting many of the
U.S. Department of Transportation and
FTA regulatory requirements that apply
to other FTA programs as authorized in
SAFETEA–LU. FTA will make grants
directly to Indian Indian tribes. The
Tribal Transit grants will not be
administered by the Bureau of Indian
Affairs or any other Federal agency.
Comment: A few commenters
indicated that Indian tribes should not
be required to comply with the intercity
bus service provisions in section
5311(f).
Response: FTA agrees with these
comments. We do not intend to require
tribes to spend 15 percent of funds
received under the Tribal Transit
Program for intercity bus service. This
section 5311(f) requirement only applies
to section 5311 funds that are
apportioned to the States, and not to
section 5311 funds disbursed directly to
tribes under the Tribal Transit Program.
Therefore, Indian tribes that are
recipients of funds under the Tribal
Transit Program are not required to
expend any part of those funds for
PO 00000
Frm 00074
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
intercity bus service. However, Indian
tribes may use Tribal Transit program
funds for purposes eligible under
section 5311(f).
Comment: One commenter inquired
whether a regional transit district,
which is a political body within a State,
would be able to apply for grants under
the Tribal Transit Program on behalf of
several Indian tribes.
Response: As defined in section
5311(a), as amended by SAFETEA–LU,
a recipient means a ‘‘State or Indian
tribe that receives a Federal transit
program grant directly from the Federal
Government.’’ Indian tribes, in
accordance with this definition, are thus
eligible direct recipients of funds under
this new program. Under this statutory
definition, however, a local government,
such as a regional transit district, would
not be eligible to be a direct recipient
and therefore a regional transit district
or any other local government could not
directly apply for grants on behalf of
Indian tribes under the Tribal Transit
Program. Although local governments
will not be eligible direct recipients
under this new program, Indian tribes
may enter into intergovernmental
agreements with local governments for
the purpose of assisting Indian tribes in
grant-related administrative
requirements, such as grant preparation,
grant reporting, etc.
Comment: Some commenters strongly
encouraged FTA to provide funding for
technical and planning assistance to
tribal transit programs through the
seven (7) Tribal Technical Assistance
Programs (TTAP) because SAFETEA–
LU authorized an increased funding
level for FTA’s Rural Technical
Assistance Program.
Response: FTA’s Rural Transit
Assistance Program (RTAP) provides
funding to assist in training and
technical assistance projects and other
support services for transit operators in
nonurbanized areas. The RTAP program
provides an annual allocation to each
State in conjunction with the State’s
administration of the section 5311
formula assistance program. Because
TTAPs are experienced in technical
assistance to the tribes, FTA will
encourage States to work with TTAP
centers to provide technical assistance
to tribes. FTA is currently creating a
partnership between the TTAPs and the
National RTAP.
Comment: Commenters requested
FTA to either exclude or limit the
eligibility of indirect costs for funds
received under the Tribal Transit
Program. They maintained that high
indirect cost rates of many tribes would
dampen the program’s benefits.
E:\FR\FM\15AUN1.SGM
15AUN1
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 157 / Tuesday, August 15, 2006 / Notices
Response: FTA agrees with this
comment. FTA has determined that the
eligible indirect costs will be limited to
10 percent of each Tribal Transit grant
award.
Comment: One commenter inquired
whether an Indian tribe that is within an
urbanized area would be eligible to
receive funds under the Tribal Transit
Program.
Response: The Tribal Transit Program
is a program established under the
section 5311 program. The purpose of
the section 5311 program is to carry out
transit projects in rural areas. The
general authority for the section 5311
program is set forth in subsection (b)
which provides that FTA may award
grants to recipients located in areas
other than urbanized areas (i.e., areas
with a population less than 50,000).
Therefore, because the set aside of
section 5311 funds for the Tribal Transit
Program is authorized by statute only
for areas other than urbanized areas (i.e.,
rural areas), an Indian tribe that is
located within an urbanized area would
not be eligible to receive funds under
the Tribal Transit Program.
IV. Funding Opportunity Description
A. Authorized Funding for FY 2006
The Tribal Transit Program was
established by section 3013 of
SAFETEA-LU. This section authorized
$45 million from the Nonurbanized
Area Formula Grants Program (49 U.S.C.
5311) for FY 2006–FY 2009 to be
apportioned for grants directly to Indian
tribes. The actual amount each year is
subject to the availability of
appropriations. Under the Tribal Transit
Program, Indian tribes are eligible direct
recipients. The funds are to be
apportioned for grants to Indian tribes
for any purpose eligible under the
Nonurbanized Area Formula Program
(section 5311). In FY 2006, $7.92
million is available for allocation to
projects selected through the process
announced in this Notice.
mstockstill on PROD1PC61 with NOTICES
B. Background
Prior to SAFETEA-LU, the section
5311 program did not include a separate
public transit program for tribes.
Instead, tribes were eligible under the
section 5311 program as subrecipients.
SAFETEA-LU has now authorized a
Tribal Transit Program and has
authorized eligible tribes to be direct
recipients of section 5311 Program
funds. As expressed in the Conference
Report for SAFETEA-LU, it is the intent
of Congress that funds for the Tribal
Transit Program not replace or reduce
funds tribes receive from States under
the section 5311 program.
VerDate Aug<31>2005
15:41 Aug 14, 2006
Jkt 208001
V. Award Information
The number and amount of awards
will be determined by a competitive
process. However, funding is available
for start up services, enhancements or
expansion of existing transit services,
and for planning studies and
operational planning. Approximately
25% of the funding is set aside for start
up grants. Planning grants will be
limited to $25,000 per applicant.
Multiple year projects will be
considered for funding, subject to the
availability of annual appropriations.
VI. Eligibility Information
A. Eligible Applicants
Eligible direct recipients include
federally-recognized Indian tribes or
Alaska Native villages, groups, or
communities as identified by the Bureau
of Indian Affairs (BIA) in the U.S.
Department of the Interior. To be
eligible recipients, tribes must have the
requisite legal, financial and technical
capabilities to receive and administer
Federal funds under this program.
B. Eligible Projects
Tribal Transit Program funds may be
used for any purpose authorized under
section 5311. This means that grants can
be awarded to recipients located in rural
and small urban areas with populations
under 50,000 not identified as an
urbanized area by the Bureau of the
Census for public transportation capital
projects, operating costs of equipment
and facilities for use in public
transportation, planning, and the
acquisition of public transportation
services, including service agreements
with private providers of public
transportation services. Service funded
under this program must be designed to
be accessible to members of the general
public who have disabilities.
Coordinated human service
transportation that primarily serves
elderly persons and persons with
disabilities, but which is not restricted
from carrying other members of the
public, is considered available to the
general public if it is marketed as public
transportation.
VII. Cost Sharing or Matching
No cost sharing is required for this
program; the Federal grant may fund up
to 100 percent of eligible project costs.
However, FTA encourages tribes to
leverage the program funds and
demonstrate commitment to the project
through in-kind contributions and use
of other funding sources that are
available to support public
transportation service.
PO 00000
Frm 00075
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
46963
VIII. Terms and Conditions
Section 3013 of SAFETEA-LU
amended 49 U.S.C. 5311(c) by
authorizing funds for the Tribal Transit
Program ‘‘under such terms and
conditions as may be established by the
Secretary.’’ Pursuant to this
discretionary statutory authority in
SAFETEA-LU, FTA published a Notice
dated March 22, 2006, in the Federal
Register (71 FR 14618), ‘‘Public
Transportation on Indian Reservations
Program (49 U.S.C. 5311(c)(1): Notice of
Public Meetings, Proposed Grant
Program Provisions,’’ and proposed
certain statutory and regulatory terms
and conditions that should apply to
grants awarded under this new program.
The statutory and regulatory terms and
conditions that were proposed by FTA
for the Tribal Transit Program pertained
only to U.S. Department of
Transportation and FTA requirements.
As we indicated in the March 22, 2006,
Federal Register Notice, FTA does not
possess the authority to waive crosscutting or government-wide statutory
and regulatory requirements (e.g.,
National Environmental Policy Act).
However, to the extent permitted by law
and in recognition of the unique status
and autonomy of Indian Indian tribes,
FTA has made every effort in
establishing the terms and conditions to
balance the objective of this new
program, which will directly benefit
transit projects for Indian tribes, with
other national objectives (e.g., safety)
that are important not only to Indian
tribes but also to the general public.
FTA received a substantial number of
comments from Indian tribes and other
groups concerning certain proposed
terms and conditions for the Tribal
Transit Program and FTA’s responses to
these comments were specifically
addressed earlier in this Notice.
However, except for a few proposed
terms and conditions, such as FTA’s
proposal that Tribal transportation plans
be attached or included on a STIP, the
comments for the most part reflected a
consensus that was in agreement with
FTA’s proposed terms and conditions
for this new program. Therefore, after
careful review and consideration of the
comments received from Indian tribes
and others, FTA has established
appropriate grant requirements for the
Tribal Transit Program. These specific
terms and conditions are set forth in a
new FTA Master Agreement for the
Tribal Transit Program. This Master
Agreement is available on FTA’s Web
site at https://www.fta.dot.gov/
17861_18441_ENG_HTML.htm.
The following terms and conditions,
which were initially proposed in the
E:\FR\FM\15AUN1.SGM
15AUN1
mstockstill on PROD1PC61 with NOTICES
46964
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 157 / Tuesday, August 15, 2006 / Notices
March 22, 2006, Federal Register
Notice, apply to the Tribal Transit
Program:
1. Common Grant Rule (49 CFR Part
18), ‘‘Uniform Administrative
Requirements for Grants and
Cooperative Agreements to State and
Local Governments.’’ This is a
government-wide regulation that applies
to all Federal assistance programs.
2. Civil Rights Act of 1964. Unless
Indian tribes are specifically exempted
from civil rights statutes, compliance
with civil rights statutes will be
required, including compliance with
equity in service. However, Indian tribes
will not be required to comply with
FTA program-specific guidance for Title
VI and Title VII.
3. Section 504 and ADA requirements
in 49 CFR parts 27, 37, and 38. These
are government-wide requirements that
apply to all Federal programs.
4. Drug and Alcohol Testing
requirements (49 CFR part 655). FTA
will apply this requirement because it
addresses a national safety issue for
operators of public transportation.
5. National Environmental Policy Act.
This is a government-wide requirement
that applies to all Federal programs.
6. Charter Service and School Bus
transportation requirements in 49 CFR
parts 604 and 605. The definition of
‘‘public transportation’’ in 49 U.S.C.
5302 specifically excludes school bus
and charter service.
7. National Transit Database (NTD)
Reporting requirement. 49 U.S.C. 5335
requires NTD reporting for all direct
recipients of section 5311 funds. The
Tribal Transit Program is a section 5311
program that will provide funds directly
to Indian tribes and this reporting
requirement will therefore apply.
8. Bus Testing (49 CFR 665)
requirement. To ensure that vehicles
acquired under this program will meet
adequate safety and operational
standards, this requirement will apply.
A comprehensive list and description
for all of the statutory and regulatory
terms and conditions that will apply to
the Tribal Transit Program are set forth
in FTA’s Master Agreement for the
Tribal Transit Program available on
FTA’s Web site at: https://
www.fta.dot.gov/
17861_18441_ENG_HTML.htm. In
addition, as part of their application for
grant award, tribes that are selected for
award will be required to sign the
Certifications and Assurances for the
fiscal year in which they apply for a
grant. The Certifications and Assurances
are set forth for informational purposes
in Appendix B of this Notice. Notably,
FTA has required each applicant to
submit certifications and assurances for
VerDate Aug<31>2005
15:41 Aug 14, 2006
Jkt 208001
each fiscal year in which the applicant
seeks funding and an award is made.
But because less than two months
remain before the end of fiscal year
2006, FTA will treat certifications and
assurances submitted by an Indian tribe
in either fiscal year 2006 or 2007 as
having fulfilled Federal certification and
assurance requirements for Tribal
Transit Program applications submitted
and awards made in both fiscal years
2006 and 2007.
4. Description of public transportation
services currently provided by tribe, if
any, including areas served.
5. Name of person (s) authorized to
apply on behalf of tribe (signed
transmittal letter should accompany
application if submitted in hard copy or
e-mail).
IX. Application and Submission
Information
Indian tribes that cannot demonstrate
adequate capacity in technical, legal and
financial areas will not be considered
for funding. Every application must
describe the tribe’s technical, legal, and
financial capacity to implement the
proposed project (see attached
Appendix B, Section B).
1. Legal Capacity: Provide
documentation or other evidence to
show that the applicant is a Federally
Recognized tribe. Also, who is the
authorized representative to execute
legal agreements with FTA on behalf of
the Indian tribes? If currently operating
transit service, does the Indian tribes
have appropriate Federal or State
operating authority?
2. Technical Capacity: Give examples
of the tribe’s management of other
Federal projects. What resources does
the tribal government have to
implement a transit project?
3. Financial Capacity: Does the Indian
tribes have adequate financial systems
in place to receive and manage a Federal
grant? Describe the tribal government’s
financial systems and controls.
This announcement includes all of
the information that a tribal government
will need to apply for competitive
selection. It is available on the FTA Web
site at https://www.fta.dot.gov. FTA will
announce final selections on the Web
site and in the Federal Register. A
synopsis of this announcement will be
posted on the government-wide
electronic grants Web site at https://
www.GRANTS.GOV.
X. Guidelines for Preparing Grant
Application
FTA is conducting a national
solicitation for applications under the
Tribal Transit Program. Project selection
will be made on a competitive basis.
FTA will divide the applications into
three categories for the purpose of
reviewing and selecting projects to be
funded:
A. Start ups—applications for funding
of new transit service;
B. Existing transit services—
applications for funding of
enhancements or expansion of
existing transit services; and
C. Planning—applications for funding of
planning studies and operational
planning
The application should provide
information on all items for which
Indian tribes are requesting funding in
FY 2006, and indicate the specific
category in which the tribe is applying.
XI. Application Content
A. Applicant Information
1. Name of federally-recognized tribe
and, if appropriate, the specific tribal
agency submitting the application.
2. Dun and Bradstreet (D&B) Data
Universal Numbering System (DUNS)
number if available. (Note: if selected,
applicant will be required to provide
DUNS number prior to grant award and
DUNS number is required for
submitting through GRANTS.GOV).
3. Contact information for notification
of project selection: Contact name,
address, and fax and phone number.
PO 00000
Frm 00076
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
B. Technical, Legal, and Financial
Capacity To Implement the Proposed
Project
C. Project Information
1. Budget: Provide the Federal amount
requested for each purpose for which
funds are sought and any funding from
other sources that will be provided. If
applying for a multi year project (not to
exceed 4 years), show annual request for
each year by budget line item.
2. Project Description: Indicate the
category for which funding is requested
i.e., start-ups, enhancements or
replacements of existing transit services
or planning studies or operational
planning grants to address project
development i.e. development of
vehicle and equipment specifications
and provide a summary description of
the proposed project and how it will be
implemented (e.g. number and type of
vehicles, service area, schedules, type of
services, fixed route or demand
responsive, route miles (if fixed route)
and size of service area, major origins
and destinations, population served,
and whether the tribe provide the
service directly or contract for services?
How will vehicles be maintained?
E:\FR\FM\15AUN1.SGM
15AUN1
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 157 / Tuesday, August 15, 2006 / Notices
3. Project Timeline: Include
significant milestones such as date of
contract for purchase of vehicle(s),
actual or expected delivery date of
vehicles, and service start up dates.
D. Application Evaluation Criteria
Applications for funding of transit
services should address the application
criteria based on project to be funded
(for more detail see section XII)
1. Criterion 1: Project Planning and
Coordination.
2. Criterion 2: Demonstration of Need.
3. Criterion 3: Benefits of Project.
4. Criterion 4: Financial Commitment
and Operating Capacity.
Applications for planning grants
should address the criteria in section
XII, C of this Notice.
E. Submission Dates and Times
Complete applications for Tribal
Transit Program must be submitted in
one of the three ways: electronically
through GRANTS.GOV, in hard copy to
Federal Transit Administration, 400
Seventh Street, SW., Room
9311,Washington, DC 20590, Attention:
Lorna R. Wilson; or sending by e-mail
to fta.tribalprogram@dot.gov. by October
16, 2006 or submitted electronically
through the GRANTS.GOV Web site by
the same date. FTA will announce grant
selections when the competitive
selection process is complete.
F. Intergovernmental Review
This program is not subject to
Executive Order (EO) 12372,
‘‘Intergovernmental Review of Federal
Programs.’’
G. Funding Restrictions
mstockstill on PROD1PC61 with NOTICES
Only applications from eligible
recipients for eligible activities will be
considered for funding (see section VI).
Due to funding limitations, applicants
that are selected for funding may receive
less than the amount requested. The
application process will allow an tribal
government to apply for multiple years
of funding not to exceed four years,
subject to the availability of annual
appropriations. Up to $2 million will be
made available for start up or new
systems, no more than $25,000 will be
awarded per planning grant. The
remaining funds will be made available
for applications for funding of
enhancements or expansion of existing
transit service.
H. Other Submission Requirements
Applicants submitting hard copies
should submit 3 copies of their project
proposal application to the Federal
Transit Administration, 400 Seventh
Street, SW., Room 9311, Washington,
VerDate Aug<31>2005
15:41 Aug 14, 2006
Jkt 208001
DC 20059, Attention Lorna Wilson, or
apply electronically through the
government wide electronic grant
application portal at
www.GRANTS.GOV. Alternatively
applications may be submitted as an
attachment to mailbox:
fta.tribalprogram@dot.gov. If applying
by e-mail, fax signature documents to
202–366–7951, Attention: Lorna Wilson.
XII. Application Review Process
A. Competitive Selection Process
FTA will divide applications into
three categories. The three evaluation
categories are as follows:
• Start-ups—applications for funding
of new transit service.
• Existing transit services—
applications for funding of
enhancements or expansion of existing
transit services.
• Planning—applications for funding
of transit planning studies and/or
operational planning.
Applications will be grouped into
their respective category for review and
scoring purposes. Applications for
planning will be evaluated using a pass/
fail system, whereas start-up and
existing transit services applications
will be scored based on the evaluation
criteria to determine rank for funding
award determination purposes. An
applicant can receive up to 25 points for
each evaluation criteria.
FTA intends to award the full amount
of funding available in FY 2006 for the
Tribal Transit Program. FTA encourages
applicants to review the evaluation
criteria and all other related application
information prior to preparation of
application. Applicants may receive
technical assistance for application
development by contacting their FTA
regional Tribal liaison, TTAP center, or
the National RTAP office. Contact
information for technical assistance can
be found in Appendix C.
B. Evaluation Criteria for Start-up and
Existing Transit Service Proposals
The use of quantitative data and
estimates, whenever possible, improves
the proposal’s clarity in comparison to
all the evaluation criteria.
1. Criterion 1: Project Planning and
Coordination (25 points)
In this section, the applicant should
describe how the proposed project was
developed and demonstrate that there is
a sound basis for the project and that it
is ready to implement if funded.
Information may vary depending on
whether the tribe has a formal plan that
includes transit.
a. Applicants without a formal plan
that includes transit are advised to
PO 00000
Frm 00077
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
46965
consider and address the following
areas:
i. Provide a detailed project
description including the proposed
service, vehicle and facility needs and
other pertinent characteristics of the
proposed service implementation.
ii. Identify existing transportation
services available to the tribe and
discuss whether the proposed project
will provide opportunities to coordinate
service with existing transit services
including human service agencies,
intercity bus services, or other public
transit providers.
iii. Discuss the level of support either
by the community and/or tribal
government for the proposed project.
iv. Describe the implementation
schedule for the proposed project
including time frame, staffing,
procurement, etc.
b. Applicants with a formal transit
plan are advised to consider and
address the following areas:
i. Describe the planning document
and/or the planning process conducted
to identify the proposed project.
ii. Describe how the mobility and
client access needs of tribal human
service agencies were considered in the
planning.
iii. Describe what opportunities for
public participation were provided in
the planning process and how the
proposed transit service or existing
service has been coordinated with
transportation provided for the clients
of human service agencies, with
intercity bus transportation in the area,
or with any other rural public transit
providers.
iv. Describe how the proposed service
complements rather than duplicates any
currently available services.
v. Describe the implementation
schedule for the proposed project,
including time frame, staffing,
procurements, etc.
vi. Describe any other planning or
coordination efforts that were not
mentioned above.
Based on the information provided as
discussed in the above section,
proposals will be rated on the following:
i. How sound is the basis for the
proposed project?
ii. Is the project ready to implement?
2. Criterion 2: Demonstration of Need
(25 points)
In this section, the application should
demonstrate the transit needs of the
tribe and discuss how the proposed
transit improvements will address the
identified transit needs of the tribe.
Applications may include information
such as destinations and services not
currently accessible by transit, need for
E:\FR\FM\15AUN1.SGM
15AUN1
46966
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 157 / Tuesday, August 15, 2006 / Notices
access to jobs or health care, special
needs of the elderly and individuals
with disabilities, income-based
community needs, or other mobility
needs.
Based on the information provided
the proposals will be rated on the
following:
a. What is the demonstrated need for
the project?
b. How well does the project reduce
the need?
3. Criterion 3: Benefits of Project (25
points)
In this section applications should
identify expected project benefits.
Possible examples include increased
ridership and daily trips, improved
service, improved operations and
coordination, and economic benefits to
the community.
Benefits can be demonstrated by
identifying the population of tribal
members and non-tribal members in the
proposed project service area and
estimating the number of daily, one-way
trips the transit service will provide and
the number of individual riders. There
may be many other, less quantifiable,
benefits to the tribe and surrounding
community from this project. Please
document, explain or show the benefits
in whatever format is reasonable to
present them.
Proposals will be rated on the basis of:
a. Improved transit efficiency or
increased ridership;
b. Improved mobility for the tribe;
c. Improved access to important
destinations
d. Expected average cost per trip on the
proposed service.
e. Other qualitative benefits.
mstockstill on PROD1PC61 with NOTICES
4. Criterion 4: Financial Commitment
and Operating Capacity (25 points)
In this section, the application should
identify any other funding sources used
by the tribe to support existing or
proposed transit services, including
human service transportation funding,
Indian Reservation Roads, or other FTA
programs such as Job Access and
Reverse Commute (JARC), New
Freedom, section 5311, section 5310, or
section 5309 bus and bus facilities
funding.
For existing services, the application
should show how Tribal Transit
Program funding will supplement (not
duplicate or replace) current funding
sources. If the transit system was
previously funded under section 5311
through the State’s apportionment,
describe how requested Tribal Transit
Program funding will expand available
services.
VerDate Aug<31>2005
15:41 Aug 14, 2006
Jkt 208001
Describe any other resources the tribe
will contribute to the project, including
in-kind contributions, commitments of
support from local businesses,
donations of land or equipment, and
human resources. To what extent does
the new project or funding for existing
service leverage other funding?
The tribe should show its ability to
manage programs by demonstrating the
existing programs it administers, in any
area of expertise such as human
services.
Points will be awarded based on the
degree to which:
a. The project deploys new services or
complements existing services.
b. Tribal Transit Program funding
does not replace existing funding.
c. Tribe has or will provide nonfinancial support to project.
d. Tribe has demonstrated the ability
to provide other services or manage
other programs.
e. Project funds are used in
coordination with other services for
efficient utilization of funds.
C. Evaluation Criteria for Planning
Grants Proposals
Criterion: Need for Study
For planning grants the applications
should describe in no more than three
pages the need for and a general scope
of the proposed study.
Based on the information provided,
proposals will be rated pass/fail based
on the following:
a. Is the tribe committed to planning
for transit?
b. Is the scope of the proposed study
for tribal transit?
D. Review and Selection Process
Each application will be screened by
a panel of members including FTA
headquarters regional staff, and
representatives of the Indian
Reservations Roads Program.
Incomplete or non-responsive
applications will be disqualified. FTA
will make an effort to award a grant to
every qualified applicant.
XIII. Award Administration
Information
FTA will award grants directly to
Federally recognized Indian tribes for
the projects selected through this
competition. Following publication of
the selected recipients, projects, and
amounts, FTA regional staff will assist
the successful applicants to prepare an
electronic application for grant award.
At that time, the tribe will be required
to sign the Certification and Assurances
contained in Appendix B. The Master
Agreement is available on FTA’s Web
PO 00000
Frm 00078
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
site at https://www.fta.dot.gov/
17861_18441_ENG_HTML.htm.
Applicants that are selected for grant
awards under the Tribal Transit
Program will be required to formally
designate, by resolution or other formal
tribal action, an authorized
representative who will have the
authority to execute grant agreements on
behalf of the Indian tribes with FTA and
who will also have the authority on
behalf of the Indian tribes to execute
FTA’s Annual List of Certifications and
Assurances.
FTA will notify all applicants, both
those selected for funding and those not
selected, when the competitive selection
process is complete. Projects selected
for funding will be published in a
Federal Register Notice.
XIV. Other
A. Technical Assistance
Technical assistance regarding these
requirements is available from each FTA
regional office. The regional offices will
contact those applicants selected for
funding regarding procedures for
making the required certifications and
assurances to FTA before grants are
made and will provide assistance in
preparing the documentation necessary
for grant award.
B. Certifications and Assurances
Applicants that are selected and
formally notified of FTA’s intention to
award a grant under the Tribal Transit
Program will be required to complete
and execute FTA’s Annual List of
Certification and Assurances in
accordance with the procedures
described in this Notice of Funding
Availability. The Annual List of
Certifications and Assurances is
attached in Appendix B for
informational purposes only.
C. Reporting
49 U.S.C. 5335 National Transit
Database requires NTD reporting for all
direct recipients of section 5311 funds
including tribes. Specific procedures
and data requirements for tribes have
not yet been developed and will be
provided to grantees at a later date.
Annual progress reports and financial
status reports will be required of all
grantees.
D. Agency Contact(s)
Contact the appropriate FTA regional
Tribal Liaison (Appendix A) for
application-specific information and
issues for general program information,
contact Lorna R. Wilson, Office of
Transit Programs, (202) 366-2053,
e-mail: Lorna.Wilson@dot.gov. A TDD is
E:\FR\FM\15AUN1.SGM
15AUN1
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 157 / Tuesday, August 15, 2006 / Notices
available at 1–800–877–8339 (TDD/
FIRS).
Issued in Washington, DC, this 8th day of
August 2006.
Sandra K. Bushue,
Deputy Administrator.
mstockstill on PROD1PC61 with NOTICES
Appendix A—FTA Regional Offices and
Tribal Transit Liaisons
Region I—Massachusetts, Rhode
Island, Connecticut, New Hampshire,
Vermont and Maine, Richard H. Doyle,
FTA Regional Administrator, Volpe
National Transportation Systems Center,
Kendall Square, 55 Broadway, Suite
920, Cambridge, MA 02142–1093,
Phone: (617) 494–2055, Fax: (617) 494–
2865, Regional Tribal Liaison: Judi
Molloy.
Region II—New York, New Jersey,
Virgin Islands, Letitia Thompson, FTA
Regional Administrator, One Bowling
Green, Room 429, New York, NY
10004–1415, Phone: (212) 668–2170,
Fax: (212) 668–2136, Regional Tribal
Liaison: Rebecca Reyes-Alicea.
Region III—Pennsylvania, Maryland,
Virginia, West Virginia, Delaware,
Washington, DC, Susan Borinsky, FTA
Regional Administrator, 1760 Market
Street, Suite 500, Philadelphia, PA
19103–4124, Phone: (215) 656–7100,
Fax: (215) 656–7260.
Region IV—Georgia, North Carolina,
South Carolina, Florida, Mississippi,
Tennessee, Kentucky, Alabama, Puerto
Rico, Yvette G. Taylor, FTA Regional
Administrator, 61 Forsyth Street, S.W.,
Suite 17T50, Atlanta, GA 30303, Phone:
(404) 562–3500, Fax: (404) 562–3505,
Regional Tribal Liaisons: Jamie Pfister
and James Garland.
Region V—Illinois, Indiana, Ohio,
Wisconsin, Minnesota, Michigan,
Marisol R. Simon, FTA Regional
Administrator, 200 West Adams Street,
Suite 320, Chicago, IL 60606–5232,
Phone: (312) 353–2789, Fax: (312) 886–
0351, Regional Tribal Liaisons: Victor
Austin and William Wheeler.
Region VI—Texas, New Mexico,
Louisiana, Arkansas, Oklahoma, Robert
Patrick, FTA Regional Administrator,
819 Taylor Street, Room 8A36, Ft.
Worth, TX 76102, Phone: (817) 978–
0550, Fax: (817) 978–0575, Regional
Tribal Liaison: Lynn Hayes.
Region VII—Iowa, Nebraska, Kansas,
Missouri, Mokhtee Ahmad, FTA
Regional Administrator, 901 Locust
Street, Suite 404, Kansas City, MO
64106, Phone: (816) 329–3920, Fax:
(816) 329–3921, Regional Tribal
Liaisons: Joni Roeseler and Cathy
Monroe.
Region VIII—Colorado, North Dakota,
South Dakota, Montana, Wyoming,
Utah, Lee Waddleton, FTA Regional
VerDate Aug<31>2005
15:41 Aug 14, 2006
Jkt 208001
Administrator, 12300 West Dakota
Avenue, Suite 310, Lakewood, CO
80228–2583, Phone: (720) 963–3300,
Fax: (720) 963–3333, Regional Tribal
Liaisons: Jennifer Stewart and David
Beckhouse.
Region IX—California, Arizona,
Nevada, Hawaii, American Samoa,
Guam, Leslie Rogers, FTA Regional
Administrator, 201 Mission Street, Suite
1650, San Francisco, CA 94105–1831,
Phone: (415) 744–3133, Fax: (415) 744–
2726, Regional Tribal Liaison: Donna
Turchie.
Region X—Washington, Oregon,
Idaho, Alaska, Richard Krochalis, FTA
Regional Administrator, Jackson Federal
Building, 915 Second Avenue, Suite
3142, Seattle, WA 98174–1002, Phone:
(206) 220–7954, Fax: (206) 220–7959,
Regional Tribal Liaisons: Bill Ramos
and Annette Clothier.
Appendix B—Federal Fiscal Years 2006
and 2007 Certifications and Assurances
for the Federal Transit Administration
Tribal Transit Program
In accordance with 49 U.S.C. 5323(n),
the following certifications and
assurances have been compiled for the
Federal Transit Administration (FTA)
Public Transportation on Indian
Reservation Program (Tribal Transit
Program) authorized by 49 U.S.C.
5311(c)(1). It is customary for FTA to
require each applicant to submit
certifications and assurances for each
fiscal year in which the applicant seeks
funding. But because less than two
months remain before the end of Federal
Fiscal Year 2006, FTA will treat
certifications and assurances submitted
by an Indian tribe in either Federal
Fiscal Year 2006 or 2007 applicable to
applications for Tribal Transit Program
assistance submitted and awards made
in Federal Fiscal Years 2006 and 2007.
The Indian tribe, as an eligible
applicant for Tribal Transit Program
assistance, understands and agrees that
these certifications and assurances are
pre-award requirements and do not
encompass all statutory and regulatory
requirements that may apply to the
Indian tribe or its Project. A
comprehensive list of those
requirements will be contained in the
Grant Agreement including the Master
Agreement accompanying an award
under the Tribal Transit Program.
FTA and the Indian tribe also
understand and agree that not every
certification and assurance will apply to
every Project for which FTA provides
Federal financial assistance through the
Tribal Transit Program. The type of
Project will determine which
requirements apply. For example FTA
believes that the following requirements
PO 00000
Frm 00079
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
46967
within the listed certifications and
assurances will have limited, if any,
impact:
1. Many provisions required by the
Office of Management and Budget
(OMB) set forth in Certification F
involve requirements that in most cases
will not be invoked, such as:
a. Title III of the Uniform Relocation
and Real Property Acquisition Policies
Act, as amended, and implementing
U.S. DOT regulations will apply only
when the Indian tribe acquires real
property with FTA assistance.
b. Title II of the Uniform Relocation
and Real Property Acquisition Policies
Act, as amended, and implementing
U.S. DOT regulations will apply only
when the Indian tribe’s project requires
relocation of a person or business; and
the Lead-Based Paint Poisoning
Prevention Act is invoked only in
connection with residential
construction, not likely to take place
under the Tribal Transit Program
c. The Flood Disaster Protection Act
applies to projects in flood hazard areas.
d. Only for construction projects will
the Davis-Bacon Act, Seismic Safety
regulations, and OMB engineering
supervision requirements apply.
e. Many environmental protection
requirements are limited to the specific
problem addressed by the statute. If, for
example, the project will not affect
endangered species, the requirements of
the Endangered Species Act will not be
invoked.
2. With respect to Certification H,
‘‘Bus Testing,’’ only if the Indian tribe
acquires the first bus of a new bus
model or the first bus of a new major
configuration of a new bus will FTA’s
Bus Testing requirements be invoked.
Except to the extent that FTA
determines otherwise in writing, each
Indian tribe that applies for Tribal
Transit Program assistance, however,
must provide all certifications and
assurance set forth below. FTA may not
award any Federal assistance under the
Tribal Transit Program until the Indian
tribe provides these certifications and
assurances.
A. Assurance of Authority of the Indian
Tribe and Its Representative
The authorized representative of the
Indian tribe and the attorney who sign
these certifications, assurances, and
agreements affirm that both the Indian
tribe and its authorized representative
have adequate authority under Federal
and Indian tribal law, regulations, or bylaws to:
(1) Execute and file the application for
Federal assistance on behalf of the
Indian tribe;
E:\FR\FM\15AUN1.SGM
15AUN1
46968
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 157 / Tuesday, August 15, 2006 / Notices
(2) Execute and file the required
certifications, assurances, and
agreements on behalf of the Indian tribe
binding the Indian tribe; and
(3) Execute grant agreements with
FTA on behalf of the Indian tribe.
B. Standard Assurances
The Indian tribe assures that it will
comply with all applicable Federal laws
and regulations in carrying out any
project supported by an FTA grant. The
Indian tribe agrees that it is under a
continuing obligation to comply with
the terms and conditions of the Grant
Agreement issued for its project with
FTA. The Indian tribe recognizes that
Federal laws and regulations may be
modified from time to time and those
modifications may affect project
implementation. The Indian tribe
understands that Presidential executive
orders and Federal directives, including
Federal policies and program guidance
may be issued concerning matters
affecting the Indian tribe or its project.
The Indian tribe agrees that the most
recent Federal laws, regulations, and
directives will apply to the project,
unless FTA issues a written
determination otherwise.
mstockstill on PROD1PC61 with NOTICES
C. The Indian Tribe’s Capacity To
Comply With Relevant Section 5311
Requirements
The Indian tribe assures that:
(1) It has or will have the necessary
legal, financial, and managerial
capability to apply for, receive, and
disburse Federal assistance authorized
for 49 U.S.C. 5311; and to carry out each
project, including the safety and
security aspects of that project;
(2) It has or will have satisfactory
continuing control over the use of
project equipment and facilities;
(3) The project equipment and
facilities will be adequately maintained;
and
(4) Its project will achieve maximum
feasible coordination with
transportation service assisted by other
Federal sources.
D. Nondiscrimination Assurance
As required by Title VI of the Civil
Rights Act of 1964, as amended, 42
U.S.C. 2000d, and by U.S. DOT
regulations, ‘‘Nondiscrimination in
Federally-Assisted Programs of the
Department of Transportation—
Effectuation of Title VI of the Civil
Rights Act,’’ 49 CFR part 21 at 21.7, the
Indian tribe assures that it will comply
with all requirements imposed by or
issued pursuant to 42 U.S.C. 2000d, and
49 CFR part 21, so that no person in the
United States, on the basis of race, color,
or national origin, will be excluded from
VerDate Aug<31>2005
15:41 Aug 14, 2006
Jkt 208001
participation in, be denied the benefits
of, or otherwise be subjected to
discrimination in any program or
activity (particularly in the level and
quality of transportation services and
transportation-related benefits) for
which the Indian tribe receives Federal
assistance awarded by the U.S. DOT or
FTA.
Specifically, during the period in
which Federal assistance is extended to
the project, or project property is used
for a purpose for which the Federal
assistance is extended or for another
purpose involving the provision of
similar services or benefits, or as long as
the Indian tribe retains ownership or
possession of the project property,
whichever is longer, the Indian tribe
assures that:
(1) Each project will be conducted,
property acquisitions will be
undertaken, and project facilities will be
operated in accordance with all
applicable requirements imposed by or
issued pursuant to 42 U.S.C. 2000d, and
49 CFR part 21, and understands that
this assurance extends to its entire
facility and to facilities operated in
connection with the project.
(2) It will promptly take the necessary
actions to effectuate this assurance,
including notifying the public that
complaints of discrimination in the
provision of transportation-related
services or benefits may be filed with
U.S. DOT or FTA. Upon request by U.S.
DOT or FTA, the Indian tribe assures
that it will submit the required
information pertaining to its compliance
with these provisions.
(3) It will include in each
subagreement, property transfer
agreement, third party contract, third
party subcontract, or participation
agreement adequate provisions to
extend the requirements imposed by or
issued pursuant to 42 U.S.C. 2000d and
49 CFR part 21 to other parties involved
therein including any subrecipient,
transferee, third party contractor, third
party subcontractor at any level,
successor in interest, or any other
participant in the project.
(4) Should it transfer real property,
structures, or improvements financed
with Federal assistance provided by
FTA to another party, any deeds and
instruments recording the transfer of
that property shall contain a covenant
running with the land assuring
nondiscrimination for the period during
which the property is used for a purpose
for which the Federal assistance is
extended or for another purpose
involving the provision of similar
services or benefits.
(5) The United States has a right to
seek judicial enforcement with regard to
PO 00000
Frm 00080
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
any matter arising under the Act,
regulations, and this assurance.
(6) It will make any changes in its
Title VI implementing procedures as
U.S. DOT or FTA may request to
achieve compliance with the
requirements imposed by or issued
pursuant to 42 U.S.C. 2000d and 49 CFR
part 21.
E. Assurance of Nondiscrimination on
the Basis of Disability
As required by U.S. DOT regulations,
‘‘Nondiscrimination on the Basis of
Handicap in Programs and Activities
Receiving or Benefiting from Federal
Financial Assistance,’’ at 49 CFR 27.9,
the Indian tribe assures that, as a
condition to the approval or extension
of any Federal assistance awarded by
FTA to construct any facility, obtain any
rolling stock or other equipment,
undertake studies, conduct research, or
to participate in or obtain any benefit
from any program administered by FTA,
no otherwise qualified person with a
disability shall be, solely by reason of
that disability, excluded from
participation in, denied the benefits of,
or otherwise subjected to discrimination
in any program or activity receiving or
benefiting from Federal assistance
administered by the FTA or any entity
within U.S. DOT. The Indian tribe
assures that project implementation and
operations so assisted will comply with
all applicable requirements of U.S. DOT
regulations implementing the
Rehabilitation Act of 1973, as amended,
29 U.S.C. 794, et seq., and the
Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990,
as amended, 42 U.S.C. 12101 et seq.,
and implementing U.S. DOT regulations
at 49 CFR parts 27, 37, and 38, and any
other applicable Federal laws that may
be enacted or Federal regulations that
may be promulgated.
F. U.S. Office of Management and
Budget (OMB) Assurances
Consistent with OMB assurances set
forth in SF–424B and SF–424D, the
Indian tribe assures that, with respect to
itself and its project, the Indian tribe:
(1) Has the legal authority to apply for
Federal assistance and the institutional,
managerial, and financial capability to
ensure proper planning, management,
and completion of the project described
in its application;
(2) Will give FTA, the Comptroller
General of the United States, and, if
appropriate, the state, through any
authorized representative, access to and
the right to examine all records, books,
papers, or documents related to the
award; and will establish a proper
accounting system in accordance with
E:\FR\FM\15AUN1.SGM
15AUN1
mstockstill on PROD1PC61 with NOTICES
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 157 / Tuesday, August 15, 2006 / Notices
generally accepted accounting standards
or agency directives;
(3) Will establish safeguards to
prohibit employees from using their
positions for a purpose that constitutes
or presents the appearance of personal
or organizational conflict of interest or
personal gain;
(4) Will initiate and complete the
work within the applicable project time
periods following receipt of FTA
approval;
(5) Will comply with all applicable
Federal statutes relating to
nondiscrimination including, but not
limited to:
(a) Title VI of the Civil Rights Act, 42
U.S.C. 2000d, which prohibits
discrimination on the basis of race,
color, or national origin;
(b) Title IX of the Education
Amendments of 1972, as amended, 20
U.S.C. 1681 through 1683, and 1685
through 1687, and U.S. DOT
regulations, ‘‘Nondiscrimination on the
Basis of Sex in Education Programs or
Activities Receiving Federal Financial
Assistance,’’ 49 CFR part 25, which
prohibit discrimination on the basis of
sex;
(c) Section 504 of the Rehabilitation
Act of 1973, as amended, 29 U.S.C. 794,
which prohibits discrimination on the
basis of disability;
(d) The Age Discrimination Act of
1975, as amended, 42 U.S.C. 6101
through 6107, which prohibits
discrimination on the basis of age;
(e) The Drug Abuse Office and
Treatment Act of 1972, Pub. L. 92–255,
March 21, 1972, and amendments
thereto, 21 U.S.C. 1174 et seq. relating
to nondiscrimination on the basis of
drug abuse;
(f) The Comprehensive Alcohol Abuse
and Alcoholism Prevention Act of 1970,
Pub. L. 91–616, Dec. 31, 1970, and
amendments thereto, 42 U.S.C. 4581 et
seq. relating to nondiscrimination on
the basis of alcohol abuse or alcoholism;
(g) The Public Health Service Act of
1912, as amended, 42 U.S.C. 290dd-3
and 290ee-3, related to confidentiality of
alcohol and drug abuse patient records;
(h) Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act,
42 U.S.C. 3601 et seq., relating to
nondiscrimination in the sale, rental, or
financing of housing; and
(i) Any other nondiscrimination
statute(s) that may apply to the project;
(6) To the extent applicable, will
comply with, or has complied with, the
requirements of Titles II and III of the
Uniform Relocation Assistance and Real
Property Acquisition Policies Act of
1970, as amended, (Uniform Relocation
Act) 42 U.S.C. 4601 et seq., which,
among other things, provide for fair and
equitable treatment of persons displaced
VerDate Aug<31>2005
15:41 Aug 14, 2006
Jkt 208001
or persons whose property is acquired
as a result of Federal or federally
assisted programs. These requirements
apply to all interests in real property
acquired for project purposes and
displacement caused by the project
regardless of Federal participation in
any purchase. As required by sections
210 and 305 of the Uniform Relocation
Act, 42 U.S.C. 4630 and 4655, and by
U.S. DOT regulations, ‘‘Uniform
Relocation Assistance and Real Property
Acquisition for Federal and Federally
Assisted Programs,’’ 49 CFR 24.4, the
Indian tribe assures that it has the
requisite authority under its applicable
tribal government law to comply with
the requirements of the Uniform
Relocation Act, 42 U.S.C. 4601 et seq.,
and U.S. DOT regulations, ‘‘Uniform
Relocation Assistance and Real Property
Acquisition for Federal and Federally
Assisted Programs,’’ 49 CFR part 24, and
will comply with that Act or has
complied with that Act and those
implementing regulations, including but
not limited to the following:
(a) The Indian tribe will adequately
inform each affected person of the
benefits, policies, and procedures
provided for in 49 CFR part 24;
(b) The Indian tribe will provide fair
and reasonable relocation payments and
assistance as required by 42 U.S.C.
4622, 4623, and 4624; 49 CFR part 24;
and any applicable FTA procedures, to
or for families, individuals,
partnerships, corporations, or
associations displaced as a result of any
project financed with FTA assistance;
(c) The Indian tribe will provide
relocation assistance programs offering
the services described in 42 U.S.C. 4625
to such displaced families, individuals,
partnerships, corporations, or
associations in the manner provided in
49 CFR part 24;
(d) Within a reasonable time before
displacement, the Indian tribe will make
available comparable replacement
dwellings to displaced families and
individuals as required by 42 U.S.C.
4625(c)(3);
(e) The Indian tribe will carry out the
relocation process in such manner as to
provide displaced persons with uniform
and consistent services, and will make
available replacement housing in the
same range of choices with respect to
such housing to all displaced persons
regardless of race, color, religion, or
national origin;
(f) In acquiring real property, the
Indian tribe will be guided to the
greatest extent practicable under state
law, by the real property acquisition
policies of 42 U.S.C. 4651 and 4652;
(g) The Indian tribe will pay or
reimburse property owners for
PO 00000
Frm 00081
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
46969
necessary expenses as specified in 42
U.S.C. 4653 and 4654, with the
understanding that FTA will provide
Federal financial assistance for the
Indian tribe’s eligible costs of providing
payments for those expenses, as
required by 42 U.S.C. 4631;
(h) The Indian tribe will execute such
amendments to third party contracts
and subagreements financed with FTA
assistance and execute, furnish, and be
bound by such additional documents as
FTA may determine necessary to
effectuate or implement the assurances
provided herein; and
(i) The Indian tribe agrees to make
these assurances part of or incorporate
them by reference into any third party
contract or subagreement, or any
amendments thereto, relating to any
project financed by FTA involving
relocation or land acquisition and
provide in any affected document that
these relocation and land acquisition
provisions shall supersede any
conflicting provisions;
(7) To the extent applicable, will
comply with the Davis-Bacon Act, as
amended, 40 U.S.C. 3141 et seq., the
Copeland ‘‘Anti-Kickback’’ Act, as
amended, 18 U.S.C. 874, and the
Contract Work Hours and Safety
Standards Act, as amended, 40 U.S.C.
3701 et seq., regarding labor standards
for federally assisted projects;
(8) To the extent applicable, will
comply with the flood insurance
purchase requirements of section 102(a)
of the Flood Disaster Protection Act of
1973, as amended, 42 U.S.C. 4012a(a),
requiring the Indian tribe and its
subrecipients in a special flood hazard
area to participate in the program and
purchase flood insurance if the total
cost of insurable construction and
acquisition is $10,000 or more;
(9) To the extent applicable, will
comply with the Lead-Based Paint
Poisoning Prevention Act, 42 U.S.C.
4831(b), which prohibits the use of leadbased paint in the construction or
rehabilitation of residence structures;
(10) To the extent applicable, will not
dispose of, modify the use of, or change
the terms of the real property title or
other interest in the site and facilities on
which a construction project supported
with FTA assistance takes place without
permission and instructions from FTA;
(11) To the extent required by FTA,
will record the Federal interest in the
title of real property, and will include
a covenant in the title of real property
acquired in whole or in part with
Federal assistance funds to assure
nondiscrimination during the useful life
of the project;
(12) To the extent applicable, will
comply with FTA provisions concerning
E:\FR\FM\15AUN1.SGM
15AUN1
mstockstill on PROD1PC61 with NOTICES
46970
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 157 / Tuesday, August 15, 2006 / Notices
the drafting, review, and approval of
construction plans and specifications of
any construction project supported with
FTA assistance. As required by U.S.
DOT regulations, ‘‘Seismic Safety,’’ 49
CFR 41.117(d), before accepting delivery
of any building financed with FTA
assistance, it will obtain a certificate of
compliance with the seismic design and
construction requirements of 49 CFR
part 41;
(13) To the extent applicable, will
provide and maintain competent and
adequate engineering supervision at the
construction site of any project
supported with FTA assistance to
ensure that the complete work conforms
with the approved plans and
specifications, and will furnish progress
reports and such other information as
may be required by FTA or the state;
(14) To the extent applicable, will
comply with any applicable
environmental standards that may be
prescribed to implement the following
Federal laws and executive orders:
(a) Institution of environmental
quality control measures under the
National Environmental Policy Act of
1969, as amended, 42 U.S.C. 4321
through 4335 and Executive Order No.
11514, as amended, 42 U.S.C. 4321 note;
(b) Notification of violating facilities
pursuant to Executive Order No. 11738,
42 U.S.C. 7606 note;
(c) Protection of wetlands pursuant to
Executive Order No. 11990, 42 U.S.C.
4321 note;
(d) Evaluation of flood hazards in
floodplains in accordance with
Executive Order No. 11988, 42 U.S.C.
4321 note;
(e) Assurance of project consistency
with the approved state management
program developed pursuant to the
requirements of the Coastal Zone
Management Act of 1972, as amended,
16 U.S.C. 1451 through 1465;
(f) Conformity of Federal actions to
State (Clean Air) Implementation Plans
under section 176(c) of the Clean Air
Act of 1955, as amended, 42 U.S.C. 7401
through 7671q;
(g) Protection of underground sources
of drinking water under the Safe
Drinking Water Act of 1974, as
amended, 42 U.S.C. 300f through 300j–
6;
(h) Protection of endangered species
under the Endangered Species Act of
1973, as amended, 16 U.S.C. 1531
through 1544; and
(i) Environmental protections for
Federal transportation programs,
including, but not limited to,
protections for parks, recreation areas,
or wildlife or waterfowl refuges of
national, state, local, or tribal
government significance or any land
VerDate Aug<31>2005
15:41 Aug 14, 2006
Jkt 208001
from a historic site of national, state,
local, or tribal government significance
to be used in a transportation project as
required by 49 U.S.C. 303(b) and 303(c);
(j) Protection of the components of the
national wild and scenic rivers systems,
as required under the Wild and Scenic
Rivers Act of 1968, as amended, 16
U.S.C. 1271 through 1287; and
(k) Provision of assistance to FTA in
complying with section 106 of the
National Historic Preservation Act of
1966, as amended, 16 U.S.C. 470f; with
the Archaeological and Historic
Preservation Act of 1974, as amended,
16 U.S.C. 469 through 469c ; and with
Executive Order No. 11593
(identification and protection of historic
properties), 16 U.S.C. 470 note;
(15) Because a tribal government is
not covered by the Hatch Act, the Indian
tribe is not required to comply with the
requirements of the Hatch Act, 5 U.S.C.
1501 through 1508 and 7324 through
7326, which limit the political activities
of state and local agencies and their
officers and employees whose primary
employment activities are financed in
whole or part with Federal funds
including a Federal grant agreement
except, in accordance with 49 U.S.C.
5307(k)(2) and 23 U.S.C. 142(g), the
Hatch Act does not apply to a
nonsupervisory employee of a public
transportation system (or of any other
agency or entity performing related
functions) receiving FTA assistance to
whom that Act does not otherwise
apply;
(16) To the extent applicable, will
comply with the National Research Act,
Pub. L. 93–348, July 12, 1974, as
amended, 42 U.S.C. 289 et seq., and U.S.
DOT regulations, ‘‘Protection of Human
Subjects,’’ 49 CFR part 11, regarding the
protection of human subjects involved
in research, development, and related
activities supported by Federal
assistance;
(17) To the extent applicable, will
comply with the Laboratory Animal
Welfare Act of 1966, as amended, 7
U.S.C. 2131 et seq., and U.S.
Department of Agriculture regulations,
‘‘Animal Welfare,’’ 9 CFR subchapter A,
parts 1, 2, 3, and 4, regarding the care,
handling, and treatment of warm
blooded animals held or used for
research, teaching, or other activities
supported by Federal assistance;
(18) Will have performed the financial
and compliance audits as required by
the Single Audit Act Amendments of
1996, 31 U.S.C. 7501 et seq., OMB
Circular A–133, ‘‘Audits of States, Local
Governments, and Non-Profit
Organizations,’’ Revised, and the most
recent applicable OMB A–133
PO 00000
Frm 00082
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
Compliance Supplement provisions for
the U.S. DOT; and
(19) To the extent applicable, will
comply with all applicable provisions of
all other Federal laws, regulations, and
directives governing the project, except
to the extent that FTA has expressly
approved otherwise in writing.
G. Procurement Compliance
In accordance with 49 CFR
18.36(g)(3)(ii), the Indian tribe certifies
that its procurement system will comply
with the requirements of 49 CFR 18.36,
or will inform FTA promptly that its
procurement system does not comply
with 49 CFR 18.36.
H. Bus Testing
As required by 49 U.S.C. 5318 and
FTA regulations, ‘‘Bus Testing,’’ at 49
CFR 665.7, the Indian tribe certifies that,
before expending any Federal assistance
to acquire the first bus of any new bus
model or any bus model with a new
major change in configuration or
components, or before authorizing final
acceptance of that bus (as described in
49 CFR part 665), the bus model:
A. Will have been tested at FTA’s bus
testing facility; and
B. Will have received a copy of the
test report prepared on the bus model.
I. Charter Service Agreement
(1) As required by 49 U.S.C. 5323(d)
and (g) and FTA regulations, ‘‘Charter
Service,’’ at 49 CFR 604.7, the Indian
tribe agrees that it and each subrecipient
and third party contractor at any tier
will:
(a) Provide charter service that uses
equipment or facilities acquired with
Federal assistance authorized under 49
U.S.C. chapter 53 (except 49 U.S.C. 5310
or 5317), or under 23 U.S.C. 133 or 142
for transportation projects, only to the
extent that there are no private charter
service operators willing and able to
provide the charter service that it or its
subrecipients or third party contractors
at any tier desire to provide, unless one
or more of the exceptions in 49 CFR
604.9 applies; and
(b) Comply with the requirements of
49 CFR part 604 before providing any
charter service using equipment or
facilities acquired with Federal
assistance authorized under 49 U.S.C.
chapter 53 (except 49 U.S.C. 5310 or
5317), or under 23 U.S.C. 133 or 142 for
transportation projects.
(2) The Indian tribe understands that:
(a) The requirements of 49 CFR part
604 will apply to any charter service it
or its subrecipients or third party
contractors provide,
E:\FR\FM\15AUN1.SGM
15AUN1
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 157 / Tuesday, August 15, 2006 / Notices
(b) The definitions of 49 CFR part 604
will apply to this Charter Service
Agreement, and
(c) A violation of this Charter Service
Agreement may require corrective
measures and imposition of penalties,
including debarment from the receipt of
further Federal assistance for
transportation.
(b) The definitions of 49 CFR part 605
will apply to this School Transportation
Agreement, and
(c) A violation of this School
Transportation Agreement may require
corrective measures and imposition of
penalties, including debarment from the
receipt of further Federal assistance for
transportation.
J. School Transportation Agreement
K. Demand Responsive Service
mstockstill on PROD1PC61 with NOTICES
(1) As required by 49 U.S.C. 5323(f)
and (g) and FTA regulations at 49 CFR
605.14, the Indian tribe agrees that it
and each subrecipient or third party
contractor at any tier will:
(a) Engage in school transportation
operations in competition with private
school transportation operators only to
the extent permitted by 49 U.S.C.
5323(f) and (g), and Federal regulations;
and
(b) Comply with the requirements of
49 CFR part 605 before providing any
school transportation using equipment
or facilities acquired with Federal
assistance authorized under 49 U.S.C.
chapter 53 or under 23 U.S.C. 133 or
142 for transportation projects.
(2) The Indian tribe understands that:
(a) The requirements of 49 CFR part
605 will apply to any school
transportation service it or its
subrecipients or third party contractors
provide,
VerDate Aug<31>2005
15:41 Aug 14, 2006
Jkt 208001
As required by U.S. DOT regulations,
‘‘Transportation Services for Individuals
with Disabilities (ADA),’’ at 49 CFR
37.77(d), the Indian tribe certifies that
its demand responsive service offered to
individuals with disabilities, including
individuals who use wheelchairs, is
equivalent to the level and quality of
service offered to individuals without
disabilities. When the Indian tribe’s
service is viewed in its entirety, the
Indian tribe’s service for individuals
with disabilities is provided in the most
integrated setting feasible and is
equivalent with respect to: (1) Response
time, (2) fares, (3) geographic service
area, (4) hours and days of service, (5)
restrictions on trip purpose, (6)
availability of information and
reservation capability, and (7)
constraints on capacity or service
availability.
PO 00000
L. Alcohol Misuse and Prohibited Drug
Use
As required by FTA regulations,
‘‘Prevention of Alcohol Misuse and
Prohibited Drug Use in Transit
Operations,’’ at 49 CFR part 655, subpart
I, the Indian tribe certifies that it has
established and implemented an alcohol
misuse and anti-drug program, and has
complied with or will comply with all
applicable requirements of FTA
regulations, ‘‘Prevention of Alcohol
Misuse and Prohibited Drug Use in
Transit Operations,’’ 49 CFR part 655.
M. National Intelligent Transportation
Systems Architecture and Standards
If the Indian tribe’s project involves
the acquisition of an Intelligent
Transportation System (ITS), defined as
technology or system of technologies
that provides or significantly contribute
to the provision of one or more ITS user
services as defined in the National ITS
Architecture, the Indian tribe will use
its best efforts to ensure that any
Intelligent Transportation System
solutions used in its Project do not
preclude interface with other Intelligent
Transportation Systems in the Region.
(See FTA Notice, ‘‘FTA National ITS
Architecture Policy on Transit Projects’’
66 FR 1455 et seq. January 8, 2001 and
other FTA Program Guidance that may
be issued.)
BILLING CODE 4910–57–C
Frm 00083
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
46971
E:\FR\FM\15AUN1.SGM
15AUN1
VerDate Aug<31>2005
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 157 / Tuesday, August 15, 2006 / Notices
15:41 Aug 14, 2006
Jkt 208001
PO 00000
Frm 00084
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4725
E:\FR\FM\15AUN1.SGM
15AUN1
EN15AU06.026
mstockstill on PROD1PC61 with NOTICES
46972
Federal Register / Vol. 71, No. 157 / Tuesday, August 15, 2006 / Notices
Appendix C—Technical Assistance
Contacts
46973
TTAP-Michigan
TTAP-Oklahoma
TTAP-Alaska
Alaska Tribal Technical Assistance
Program, NW & AK TTAP, 329 Harbor
Dr. #208, Sitka, AK 99835, Contact: Dan
Moreno, Telephone: (800) 399–6376,
Fax: (907) 747–5032, E-mail:
dmoreno@mail.ewu.edu, Web:
www.ewu.edu/TTAP.
Tribal Technical Assistance Program,
301–E Dillman Hall, Michigan
Technological University, 1400
Townsend Dr., Houghton, MI 49931–
1295, Contact: Bernard D. Alkire,
Telephone: (888) 230–0688, Fax: (906)
487–1834, E-mail: balkire@mtu.edu,
Web: https://www.ttap.mtu.edu.
TTAP-North Dakota
Tribal Technical Assistance Program
at Oklahoma State University,
Oklahoma State University, 5202 N.
Richmond Hills Road, Stillwater, OK
74078–0001, Contact: James Self,
Telephone: (405) 744–6049, Fax: (405)
744–7268, E-mail: jim.self@okstate.edu,
Web: https://ttap.okstate.edu.
National RTAP (National Rural
Transit Assistance Program), E-mail:
nationalrtap@apwa.net, https://
www.nationalrtap.org/, Dave Barr 202–
218–6722, Community Transportation
Association of America), The Resource
Center—1800–891–0590, https://
www.ctaa.org/.
Tribal Technical Assistance Program
(TTAP) Centers
TTAP-California
TTAP-California-Nevada, The
National Center for American Indian
Enterprise Development, 11138 Valley
Mall, Suite 200, El Monte, CA 91731,
Contact: Lee Bigwater, Telephone: (626)
350–4446, Fax: (626) 442–7115.
BILLING CODE 4910–57–P
Jkt 208001
Northwest Tribal Technical
Assistance Program, Eastern
Washington University Department of
Urban Planning, Public & Health
Administration, 216 Isle Hall, Cheney,
WA 99004, Contact: David Frey,
Telephone: (800) 583–3187, Fax: (509)
359–7485, E-mail: rrolland@ewu.edu,
Web: www.ewu.edu/TTAP.
PO 00000
Frm 00085
Fmt 4703
Sfmt 4703
E:\FR\FM\15AUN1.SGM
15AUN1
EN15AU06.027
mstockstill on PROD1PC61 with NOTICES
Tribal Technical Assistance Program
at Colorado State University, Rockwell
Hall, Rm. 321, Colorado State
University, Fort Collins, CO 80523–
1276, Contact: Ronald Hall, Telephone:
(800) 262–7623, Fax: (970) 491–3502, Email: ronald.hall@colostate.edu, Web:
https://ttap.colostate.edu/.
15:41 Aug 14, 2006
[FR Doc. 06–6911 Filed 8–14–06; 8:45 am]
TTAP-NW
TTAP-Colorado
VerDate Aug<31>2005
Northern Plains Tribal Technical
Assistance Program, United Tribes
Technical College, 3315 University
Drive, Bismarck, ND 58504, Contact:
Dennis Trusty, Telephone: (701) 255–
3285 ext. 1262, Fax: (701) 530–0635, Email: nddennis@hotmail.com or
dtrusty@uttc.edu, Web: https://
www.uttc.edu/organizations/ttap/
ttap.asp.
Agencies
[Federal Register Volume 71, Number 157 (Tuesday, August 15, 2006)]
[Notices]
[Pages 46959-46973]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Printing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 06-6911]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
Federal Transit Administration
[Docket No. FTA-2006-24143]
Public Transportation on Indian Reservations Program; Tribal
Transit Program
AGENCY: Federal Transit Administration (FTA), DOT.
ACTION: Notice of funding availability: Solicitation of grant
applications for FY 2006 tribal Transit Program Funds.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: This Notice accomplishes several purposes. First, the U.S.
Department of Transportation, Federal Transit Administration (FTA)
summarizes and responds to written comments FTA received in response to
a March 22, 2006, Federal Register Notice regarding proposed grant
program provisions for this new program and to oral comments FTA
received during two announced public meetings on this program that were
held on April 4, 2006, in Denver, Colorado, and on April 7, 2006, in
Kansas City, Missouri. Second, this Notice announces the availability
of funds in fiscal year (FY) 2006 for the Public Transportation on
Indian Reservations Program, a new program authorized by the Safe,
Accountable, Flexible, Efficient Transportation Equity Act: A Legacy
for Users. Finally, this Notice announces a national solicitation for
applications, with grantees and projects to be selected on a
competitive basis; the grant terms and conditions that will apply to
this new program; and grant application procedures and selection
criteria for FY 2006 projects.
ADDRESSES: This announcement is available on the FTA's Web site at:
https://www.fta.dot.gov. FTA will announce final selections on the Web
site and in the Federal Register. A synopsis of this announcement will
be posted on the governmentwide electronic grants Web site at: https://
www.GRANTS.GOV. Applications may be submitted in one of three ways:
electronically through GRANTS.GOV, in hard copy to Federal Transit
Administration, 400 Seventh Street, SW., Room 9315,Washington, DC
20590, Attention: Lorna R. Wilson; or sending by e-mail to
fta.tribalprogram@dot.gov.
DATES: Complete applications for Public Transportation on Indian
Reservations Program grants must be submitted in hard copy to the FTA,
via e-mail by October 16, 2006, or submitted electronically through the
GRANTS.GOV Web site by October 16, 2006. Anyone intending to apply
electronically should initiate the process of registering on the
GRANTS.GOV site immediately to ensure completion of registration before
the deadline for submission. FTA will announce grant selections in the
Federal Register when the competitive selection process is complete.
Applicants should be aware that materials sent through the U.S.
Postal Service are subject to significant delays in delivery due to the
security screening process. Use of courier or express delivery services
is recommended if unable to apply electronically.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Contact the appropriate FTA regional
Tribal Liaison (Appendix A) for application-specific information and
issues. For general program information, contact Lorna R. Wilson,
Office of Transit Programs, (202) 366-2053, e-mail:
Lorna.Wilson@dot.gov. A TDD is available at 1-800-877-8339 (TDD/FIRS).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Table of Contents
I. Overview
II. Background
III. Comments and Responses
A. Process and Criteria
B. Terms and Conditions
C. Other Issues
IV. Funding Opportunity Description
A. Authorized Funding for FY2006
B. Background
V. Award Information
VI. Eligibility Information
A. Eligible Applicants
B. Eligible Projects
VII. Cost Sharing or Matching
VIII. Terms and Conditions
IX. Application Submission Information
X. Guidelines for Preparing Grant Application
XI. Application Content
A. Application Information
B. Technical, Legal, and Financial Capacity
C. Project Information
D. Application Evaluation Criteria
E. Submission Dates
F. Intergovernmental Review
G. Funding Restrictions
H. Other Submission Requirements
XII. Application Review Process
A. Competitive Selection Process
B. Evaluation Criteria
1. Criterion 1: Project Planning and Coordination
2. Criterion 2: Demonstration of Need
3. Criterion 3: Benefits of Project
4. Criterion 4. Financial Commitment and Operating Capacity
C. Proposals for Planning Grants
D. Review and Selection Process
XIII. Award Information
XIV. Other Information
A. Technical Assistance
B. Standard Assurances
C. Reporting
D. Agency Contacts
Appendices
Appendix A. FTA Regional Offices and Tribal Liaison
Appendix B. Federal Fiscal Years 2006 and 2007 Certifications
and Assurances for the Federal Transit Administration Public
Transportation on Indian Reservations Program
Appendix C. Technical Assistance Contacts
I. Overview
Section 3013 of SAFETEA-LU amended 49 U.S.C. 5311(c) by
establishing the Public Transportation on Indian Reservations Program
(hereinafter referred to as the Tribal Transit Program). This new
program authorizes direct grants ``under such terms and conditions as
may be established by the Secretary'' to Indian tribes for any purpose
eligible under FTA's Nonurbanized Area Formula Program, 49 U.S.C. 5311.
The funding level authorized for this new program will increase from $8
million in FY 2006 to $15 million in FY 2009. The Conference Report to
SAFETEA-LU indicated that the funds set aside for Indian tribes in the
Tribal Transit Program are not meant to replace or reduce funds that
Indian tribes receive from States through FTA's Nonurbanized Area
Formula Program.
[[Page 46960]]
II. Background
FTA published a Notice in the Federal Register dated November 30,
2005 (70 FR 71950), ``FTA Transit Program Changes, Authorized Funding
Levels and Implementation of the Safe, Accountable, Flexible, Efficient
Transportation Equity Act: A Legacy for Users: Notice'' which announced
changes to current FTA programs and new programs, including the Tribal
Transit Program. In the November 30, 2005, Federal Register Notice, FTA
set forth and requested public comments on the proposed basis for
formula apportionment for the Tribal Transit Program, eligible grant
purposes, and proposed program requirements.
On March 22, 2006, FTA published a Notice in the Federal Register
(71 FR 14618), ``Public Transportation on Indian Reservations Program
(49 U.S.C. 5311(c)(1): Notice of Public Meetings, Proposed Grant
Program Provisions; Notice.'' FTA responded to comments that were
received from the public in response to the November 30, 2005 Federal
Register Notice, and requested additional comment on the following
issues: the proposed basis for allocating funds; grantee eligibility;
eligible purposes for grant funds; proposed terms and conditions for
the grant program, and local share options. The Notice also announced
two one-day outreach meetings on the Tribal Transit Program. The
comment period on the March 22, 2006, Federal Register Notice ended on
April 21, 2006, but comments submitted after that date were considered.
III. Comments and Responses
FTA received 28 written comments in response to the March 22, 2006,
Federal Register Notice and additional oral comments were received from
the Indian tribes and other organizations at the two public outreach
meetings that were held in April 2006. A summary of the oral comments
were placed in the docket for this Notice. All of the written and oral
comments received by FTA during the comment period can be divided into
the following categories: (a) The process and the criteria that should
be established by FTA to allocate funding under the Tribal Transit
Program; (b) the terms and conditions that should be applied to grants
awarded under the Tribal Transit Program, which includes the proposed
options for local match; and (c) other issues that were not
specifically proposed or addressed in the March 22, 2006 Federal
Register Notice. The comments received from the Indian tribes and
others were generally very favorable to the establishment and
implementation of this new program and proposed program requirements.
However, the Indian tribes and others strongly disagreed with some of
FTA's proposals in the March 22, 2006, Federal Register Notice. The
Indian tribes also offered recommendations and changes to FTA's
proposals based on their unique perspective and experience in providing
public transportation on Indian reservations.
A. Process and Criteria
The March 22, 2006, Federal Register Notice proposed a single
annual competitive selection process to fund both new and existing
tribal transit systems and suggested not establishing minimum or
maximum awards. In addition, the Notice proposed the following five
criteria that would be evaluated and rated by FTA in making an award
selection: Demonstration of need; benefits of the project; adequacy of
project planning; financial commitment; and coordination. The Indian
tribes were mostly in agreement on FTA's proposal to make single annual
competitive selections for awards under the Tribal Transit Program.
However, there were divergent comments received concerning the criteria
proposed by FTA for project funding under this new program. We will
address the comments that were submitted by the Indian tribes and
others in the following section of this document.
Comment: There were multiple comments concerning FTA's proposal for
allocating funds in this new program. Several comments from small
Indian tribes observed that FTA's criteria appeared to be biased in
favor of existing tribal transit systems. Comments from larger Indian
tribes stated that the criteria should be based on established transit
systems or for tribes that have identified their transit needs in the
Tribal Transportation Improvement Program. Other comments suggested an
additional criterion that would consider the reasonableness of the
amount requested or that projects should be funded for multiple years
to ensure successful implementation of transit projects.
Response: FTA will ensure that there will be an equitable
distribution of funds in this new program for eligible transit projects
that are planned, constructed, or operated by the Indian tribes. FTA
has decided to include the following four criteria: project planning
and coordination; demonstration of need; benefits of project; and
financial commitment and operating capacity.
In addition, to further ensure an equitable distribution of funds
in this new program, FTA will separately evaluate proposals under the
following three categories: (1) Start-up operations; (2) enhancements
or expansions of existing transit services; and (3) transit planning
and/or operational planning grants. The application process will also
allow a tribal government to apply for multiple years of funding,
subject to the availability of appropriations.
B. Terms and Conditions
Comment: There was a clear consensus that strongly disagreed with
FTA's interpretation of section 5311(c) prohibiting the use of funds in
the Tribal Transit Program for planning purposes. Commenters argued
that the statute permits funds in the Tribal Transit Program to be used
for any purpose eligible under section 5311. The commenters stated that
other subsections of section 5311 permit the use of section 5311 funds
for planning. Therefore, planning should be an eligible purpose under
section 5311(c).
Response: FTA's interpretation that planning was not an eligible
use of Tribal Transit Program funds was based on the program's history.
As originally enacted, Nonurbanized Area Formula Program funds could be
used only for capital and operating purposes. Although planning was
permitted under certain situations set forth in subsections (e) and (f)
of section 5311, FTA viewed the limited eligibility of planning in
these subsections as an exception to the general rule that planning was
not an eligible purpose. It followed that ``any purpose eligible under
[section 5311]'' meant that section 5311(c)(1) funds could only be used
for capital and operating purposes.
Based on the comments submitted to the docket from the Indian
tribes and other organizations, and comments heard at the two public
outreach meetings held in April 2006 concerning the issue that planning
should be eligible under this new program, FTA reviewed section
5311(c), as amended by SAFETEA-LU, to determine whether a more
expansive interpretation of the statute might be justified. Under a
general rule of statutory construction that gives weight to the plain
meaning of a statute, we construe the word ``any'' in section
5311(c)(1) to be synonymous with ``all'' eligible purposes under
section 5311. This rule of statutory construction is consistent with
U.S. Supreme Court decisions which have long held that there is no more
persuasive evidence of the purpose of a statute than the words by which
the legislature undertook to give expression
[[Page 46961]]
to its wishes. U.S. v. American Trucking Ass'ns., 310 U.S. 534, 543
(1940). By applying this rule of statutory construction, FTA has
determined that a broader interpretation of this statute will more
effectively carry out the purpose of this new program. FTA therefore
interprets Section 5311(c) to allow funds apportioned to Indian tribes
to be used for ``any'' purpose identified under section 5311, which
includes planning activities.
FTA notes, however, that because section 5311(c)(1) also states
that the Tribal Transit Program funds are to be apportioned under such
terms and conditions established by FTA, FTA has the discretion to
limit the amount of funds available for each eligible purpose under
this program. Accordingly, FTA will limit the amount of funds that are
available for planning in the Tribal Transit Program to 15 percent of
the grant award. In addition, for grants that are exclusively for
planning purposes, FTA will limit the amount of funds to $25,000 per
applicant.
Comment: Many of the Indian tribes, and several State Departments
of Transportation, commented on FTA's proposal for planning
requirements. They disagreed with FTA's proposal that Tribal
Transportation Improvement Plans (TTIP) or Long Range Transportation
Plans be attached or included in the Statewide Transportation
Improvement Program (STIP). The State DOT's specifically contended that
a TTIP which did not meet various legal requirements (e.g., public
participation, fiscally constrained plans) could potentially disqualify
the State's STIP process. Therefore, they suggested that this proposed
planning requirement be omitted entirely or, alternatively, that the
TTIP be attached to a STIP for informational purposes only and that the
TTIP not be considered a formal part of the STIP.
Response: FTA agrees with this concern. FTA recognizes that Indian
tribes are not subject to Federal planning requirements. To require the
attachment of tribal transportation plans to a STIP could not only
cause unnecessary delay to the grant making process but also
potentially invalidate the State's STIP. Accordingly, FTA will not
require Indian tribes to attach tribal transportation plans to a STIP.
However, because it would assist both the Indian tribes and State
Departments of Transportation to coordinate and assess their planned
transportation projects, FTA encourages Indian tribes, for
informational purposes only, to submit a copy of their tribal
transportation plans to State Departments of Transportation.
Comment: Many comments were received from the Indian tribes on
FTA's two proposed options for local share. Most of the comments
opposed both options and recommended that FTA eliminate the local share
requirement. Others generally favored a 20 percent local match for both
capital and operating expenses.
Response: FTA's first option proposed a Federal share of 80 percent
and a local share of 20 percent for both capital and operating
assistance projects. The second option proposed the highest Federal
share allowed under the Title 23 Section sliding scale for States with
large public lands. The second option would thus allow a Federal share
of 95 percent for capital projects and a federal share of 60 percent
for operating assistance projects. Under both of the two proposed
options, FTA believes that a Tribal financial contribution was
important to register commitment to projects. However, FTA recognizes
that many Indian tribes have limited financial resources. In fact,
because tribes often lack financial resources, other Federal assistance
programs, such as the Federal Highway Administration Indian
Reservations Road program, require no Tribal contribution. Since these
concerns outweigh FTA's interest in a financial expression of a tribal
commitment to the program, FTA will not require a non-Federal matching
share for Tribal Transit Program grants. FTA believes that the intent
of this new program will be more quickly achieved without a tribal
share matching requirement.
Comment: Two commenters disagreed with FTA's proposal not to apply
the labor protective provisions in 49 U.S.C. section 5333(b) to grants
under this new program. It was argued that the Tribal Transit Program
is a program under section 5311 (which is subject to statutory labor
protections) and there is no indication that Congress specifically
intended for section 5333(b) labor protections to not apply to this new
program.
Response: FTA stated in the March 22, 2006 Federal Register Notice
that direct grants from FTA to Indian tribes do not involve State-
subrecipient relationships. Therefore, the administrative procedures
the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) uses to apply the section 5311
special warranty do not apply.
Accordingly, FTA proposed not to apply the labor protective
provisions of 49 U.S.C. 5333(b) to this new program. However, FTA is
aware that DOL is currently initiating a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking
to revise its labor protective arrangements for all FTA grants
(including the special warranty that is applied in the section 5311
program). Also, although Congress chose not to apply section 5333(b) to
several other new programs enacted in SAFETEA-LU, Congress amended
section 5311(i) to apply section 5333(b) ``if the Secretary of Labor
utilizes a special warranty that provides a fair and equitable
arrangement to protect the interests of employees.'' Congress did not
exempt the Tribal Transit Program from this requirement. FTA therefore
intends to apply the special warranty to the Tribal Transit Program in
the future. However, FTA will postpone the application of the special
warranty arrangement to the Tribal Transit Program until DOL adopts
procedures for the new program.
Comment: Several comments questioned the applicability of Federal
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) regulations, 49 CFR part 26, to
Indian tribes.
Response: The U.S. Department of Transportation's DBE regulation
requires a grant recipient to implement a DBE program and to establish
annual DBE goals for all contracting opportunities, except for vehicle
procurements, where Federal financial assistance exceeds $250,000.
However, due to the relatively small size of the grants that will be
awarded under this new program and to streamline program requirements
for this new program to the benefit of Indian tribes, FTA has
determined that the FTA DBE regulation, 49 CFR part 26, will not apply
to the Tribal Transit Program.
Comment: A few comments were received from Indian tribes regarding
FTA's interpretation and application of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 to
tribal employment rights ordinances (TEROs), which provide for Indian
preference in employment and contracting.
Response: FTA will not require Indian tribes under this new program
to comply with FTA's program-specific guidance for Title VI and Title
VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Title VI of the Civil Rights Act
prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, and national
origin in programs and activities receiving Federal financial
assistance. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act prohibits discrimination
in employment in any business on the basis of race, color, religion,
sex, or national origin. Indian tribes are specifically excluded from
the definition of an ``employer'' under the Act. Thus, to the extent
that TEROs are consistent with federal statutes that authorize a
general preference for Indians in employment or contracting
[[Page 46962]]
for Federally funded work on or around Indian reservations, FTA will of
course comply with applicable law. However, although Indian tribes will
not be subject to FTA's program-specific requirements under Title VI
and Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, Indian tribes under the Tribal
Transit Program will nonetheless still be subject to the provisions of
Title VI and Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, unless they are
specifically exempt from the Act.
C. Other
Comment: A number of the Indian tribes commented on the obligation
of FTA to properly consult with the Indian tribes on a government-to-
government basis for this new program in accordance with Presidential
executive orders and U.S. Department of Transportation procedures.
Response: FTA recognizes that the Federal government has a unique
legal relationship with Indian Indian tribes. When FTA implements a
program that might have substantial direct effects on the Indian tribes
or on the sovereignty of the Indian tribes, FTA must consult and
coordinate using established principles. These principles are set forth
in Presidential Executive Order 13175, ``Consultation and Coordination
with Indian Tribal Governments,'' November 6, 2000, and U.S. Department
of Transportation Order 5301.1, ``Department of Transportation
Programs, Policies, and Procedures affecting American Indians, Alaska
Natives and tribes for programs affecting Indian tribal governments.''
During the development of policies and procedures for the Tribal
Transit Program, FTA consulted and coordinated with the Indian tribes
consistent with these Executive Orders. Specifically, FTA announced and
invited comments from the Indian tribes concerning the Tribal Transit
Program in two separate Federal Register Notices. The first Federal
Register Notice, (70 FR 71950), ``FTA Transit Program Changes,
Authorized Funding Levels and Implementation of the Safe, Accountable,
Flexible, Efficient Transportation Equity Act: A Legacy for Users:
Notice,'' was published on November 30, 2005. This first Notice invited
comment from the Indian tribes and others on the proposed basis for
formula apportionment for the Tribal Transit Program, eligible grant
purposes, and proposed program requirements. A second Federal Register
Notice, published on March 22, 2006, responded to comments received
from the Indian tribes on the November 30, 2005 Notice. The second
Notice further solicited comments from the Indian tribes and others on
FTA's proposed basis and criteria to allocate funding under this new
program, proposed eligible activities, and proposed grant requirements.
The second Notice also announced two one-day public outreach meetings
on the Tribal Transit Program. In the two public meetings held in
Denver, Colorado, and Kansas City, Missouri, FTA presented its
proposals as set forth in the March 22, 2006 Notice and received
further comments from the Indian tribes in attendance. In addition,
prior to the March 22, 2006, Notice, FTA conducted several national
teleconferences with the Indian tribes to obtain their input and views
on issues concerning the development and implementation of the Tribal
Transit Program.
Comment: Although FTA did not solicit comments, or propose
guidance, on the following issue, several Indian tribes suggested that
FTA should administer grants under this program in a manner that is
either the same or similar to contracts and agreements under the Indian
Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act (ISDEAA).
Response: FTA recognizes Indian tribes as sovereign governments
that can independently administer certain Federal government programs
as authorized by the ISDEAA. Although the statutory authority to enter
into contracts with Indian tribes under ISDEAA does not include the
FTA, FTA is nonetheless implementing this new program in a manner
consistent with the principles of self-determination that are embodied
in ISDEAA. To do so, FTA is streamlining and omitting many of the U.S.
Department of Transportation and FTA regulatory requirements that apply
to other FTA programs as authorized in SAFETEA-LU. FTA will make grants
directly to Indian Indian tribes. The Tribal Transit grants will not be
administered by the Bureau of Indian Affairs or any other Federal
agency.
Comment: A few commenters indicated that Indian tribes should not
be required to comply with the intercity bus service provisions in
section 5311(f).
Response: FTA agrees with these comments. We do not intend to
require tribes to spend 15 percent of funds received under the Tribal
Transit Program for intercity bus service. This section 5311(f)
requirement only applies to section 5311 funds that are apportioned to
the States, and not to section 5311 funds disbursed directly to tribes
under the Tribal Transit Program. Therefore, Indian tribes that are
recipients of funds under the Tribal Transit Program are not required
to expend any part of those funds for intercity bus service. However,
Indian tribes may use Tribal Transit program funds for purposes
eligible under section 5311(f).
Comment: One commenter inquired whether a regional transit
district, which is a political body within a State, would be able to
apply for grants under the Tribal Transit Program on behalf of several
Indian tribes.
Response: As defined in section 5311(a), as amended by SAFETEA-LU,
a recipient means a ``State or Indian tribe that receives a Federal
transit program grant directly from the Federal Government.'' Indian
tribes, in accordance with this definition, are thus eligible direct
recipients of funds under this new program. Under this statutory
definition, however, a local government, such as a regional transit
district, would not be eligible to be a direct recipient and therefore
a regional transit district or any other local government could not
directly apply for grants on behalf of Indian tribes under the Tribal
Transit Program. Although local governments will not be eligible direct
recipients under this new program, Indian tribes may enter into
intergovernmental agreements with local governments for the purpose of
assisting Indian tribes in grant-related administrative requirements,
such as grant preparation, grant reporting, etc.
Comment: Some commenters strongly encouraged FTA to provide funding
for technical and planning assistance to tribal transit programs
through the seven (7) Tribal Technical Assistance Programs (TTAP)
because SAFETEA-LU authorized an increased funding level for FTA's
Rural Technical Assistance Program.
Response: FTA's Rural Transit Assistance Program (RTAP) provides
funding to assist in training and technical assistance projects and
other support services for transit operators in nonurbanized areas. The
RTAP program provides an annual allocation to each State in conjunction
with the State's administration of the section 5311 formula assistance
program. Because TTAPs are experienced in technical assistance to the
tribes, FTA will encourage States to work with TTAP centers to provide
technical assistance to tribes. FTA is currently creating a partnership
between the TTAPs and the National RTAP.
Comment: Commenters requested FTA to either exclude or limit the
eligibility of indirect costs for funds received under the Tribal
Transit Program. They maintained that high indirect cost rates of many
tribes would dampen the program's benefits.
[[Page 46963]]
Response: FTA agrees with this comment. FTA has determined that the
eligible indirect costs will be limited to 10 percent of each Tribal
Transit grant award.
Comment: One commenter inquired whether an Indian tribe that is
within an urbanized area would be eligible to receive funds under the
Tribal Transit Program.
Response: The Tribal Transit Program is a program established under
the section 5311 program. The purpose of the section 5311 program is to
carry out transit projects in rural areas. The general authority for
the section 5311 program is set forth in subsection (b) which provides
that FTA may award grants to recipients located in areas other than
urbanized areas (i.e., areas with a population less than 50,000).
Therefore, because the set aside of section 5311 funds for the Tribal
Transit Program is authorized by statute only for areas other than
urbanized areas (i.e., rural areas), an Indian tribe that is located
within an urbanized area would not be eligible to receive funds under
the Tribal Transit Program.
IV. Funding Opportunity Description
A. Authorized Funding for FY 2006
The Tribal Transit Program was established by section 3013 of
SAFETEA-LU. This section authorized $45 million from the Nonurbanized
Area Formula Grants Program (49 U.S.C. 5311) for FY 2006-FY 2009 to be
apportioned for grants directly to Indian tribes. The actual amount
each year is subject to the availability of appropriations. Under the
Tribal Transit Program, Indian tribes are eligible direct recipients.
The funds are to be apportioned for grants to Indian tribes for any
purpose eligible under the Nonurbanized Area Formula Program (section
5311). In FY 2006, $7.92 million is available for allocation to
projects selected through the process announced in this Notice.
B. Background
Prior to SAFETEA-LU, the section 5311 program did not include a
separate public transit program for tribes. Instead, tribes were
eligible under the section 5311 program as subrecipients. SAFETEA-LU
has now authorized a Tribal Transit Program and has authorized eligible
tribes to be direct recipients of section 5311 Program funds. As
expressed in the Conference Report for SAFETEA-LU, it is the intent of
Congress that funds for the Tribal Transit Program not replace or
reduce funds tribes receive from States under the section 5311 program.
V. Award Information
The number and amount of awards will be determined by a competitive
process. However, funding is available for start up services,
enhancements or expansion of existing transit services, and for
planning studies and operational planning. Approximately 25% of the
funding is set aside for start up grants. Planning grants will be
limited to $25,000 per applicant. Multiple year projects will be
considered for funding, subject to the availability of annual
appropriations.
VI. Eligibility Information
A. Eligible Applicants
Eligible direct recipients include federally-recognized Indian
tribes or Alaska Native villages, groups, or communities as identified
by the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) in the U.S. Department of the
Interior. To be eligible recipients, tribes must have the requisite
legal, financial and technical capabilities to receive and administer
Federal funds under this program.
B. Eligible Projects
Tribal Transit Program funds may be used for any purpose authorized
under section 5311. This means that grants can be awarded to recipients
located in rural and small urban areas with populations under 50,000
not identified as an urbanized area by the Bureau of the Census for
public transportation capital projects, operating costs of equipment
and facilities for use in public transportation, planning, and the
acquisition of public transportation services, including service
agreements with private providers of public transportation services.
Service funded under this program must be designed to be accessible to
members of the general public who have disabilities. Coordinated human
service transportation that primarily serves elderly persons and
persons with disabilities, but which is not restricted from carrying
other members of the public, is considered available to the general
public if it is marketed as public transportation.
VII. Cost Sharing or Matching
No cost sharing is required for this program; the Federal grant may
fund up to 100 percent of eligible project costs. However, FTA
encourages tribes to leverage the program funds and demonstrate
commitment to the project through in-kind contributions and use of
other funding sources that are available to support public
transportation service.
VIII. Terms and Conditions
Section 3013 of SAFETEA-LU amended 49 U.S.C. 5311(c) by authorizing
funds for the Tribal Transit Program ``under such terms and conditions
as may be established by the Secretary.'' Pursuant to this
discretionary statutory authority in SAFETEA-LU, FTA published a Notice
dated March 22, 2006, in the Federal Register (71 FR 14618), ``Public
Transportation on Indian Reservations Program (49 U.S.C. 5311(c)(1):
Notice of Public Meetings, Proposed Grant Program Provisions,'' and
proposed certain statutory and regulatory terms and conditions that
should apply to grants awarded under this new program. The statutory
and regulatory terms and conditions that were proposed by FTA for the
Tribal Transit Program pertained only to U.S. Department of
Transportation and FTA requirements. As we indicated in the March 22,
2006, Federal Register Notice, FTA does not possess the authority to
waive cross-cutting or government-wide statutory and regulatory
requirements (e.g., National Environmental Policy Act). However, to the
extent permitted by law and in recognition of the unique status and
autonomy of Indian Indian tribes, FTA has made every effort in
establishing the terms and conditions to balance the objective of this
new program, which will directly benefit transit projects for Indian
tribes, with other national objectives (e.g., safety) that are
important not only to Indian tribes but also to the general public.
FTA received a substantial number of comments from Indian tribes
and other groups concerning certain proposed terms and conditions for
the Tribal Transit Program and FTA's responses to these comments were
specifically addressed earlier in this Notice. However, except for a
few proposed terms and conditions, such as FTA's proposal that Tribal
transportation plans be attached or included on a STIP, the comments
for the most part reflected a consensus that was in agreement with
FTA's proposed terms and conditions for this new program. Therefore,
after careful review and consideration of the comments received from
Indian tribes and others, FTA has established appropriate grant
requirements for the Tribal Transit Program. These specific terms and
conditions are set forth in a new FTA Master Agreement for the Tribal
Transit Program. This Master Agreement is available on FTA's Web site
at https://www.fta.dot.gov/17861_18441_ENG_HTML.htm.
The following terms and conditions, which were initially proposed
in the
[[Page 46964]]
March 22, 2006, Federal Register Notice, apply to the Tribal Transit
Program:
1. Common Grant Rule (49 CFR Part 18), ``Uniform Administrative
Requirements for Grants and Cooperative Agreements to State and Local
Governments.'' This is a government-wide regulation that applies to all
Federal assistance programs.
2. Civil Rights Act of 1964. Unless Indian tribes are specifically
exempted from civil rights statutes, compliance with civil rights
statutes will be required, including compliance with equity in service.
However, Indian tribes will not be required to comply with FTA program-
specific guidance for Title VI and Title VII.
3. Section 504 and ADA requirements in 49 CFR parts 27, 37, and 38.
These are government-wide requirements that apply to all Federal
programs.
4. Drug and Alcohol Testing requirements (49 CFR part 655). FTA
will apply this requirement because it addresses a national safety
issue for operators of public transportation.
5. National Environmental Policy Act. This is a government-wide
requirement that applies to all Federal programs.
6. Charter Service and School Bus transportation requirements in 49
CFR parts 604 and 605. The definition of ``public transportation'' in
49 U.S.C. 5302 specifically excludes school bus and charter service.
7. National Transit Database (NTD) Reporting requirement. 49 U.S.C.
5335 requires NTD reporting for all direct recipients of section 5311
funds. The Tribal Transit Program is a section 5311 program that will
provide funds directly to Indian tribes and this reporting requirement
will therefore apply.
8. Bus Testing (49 CFR 665) requirement. To ensure that vehicles
acquired under this program will meet adequate safety and operational
standards, this requirement will apply.
A comprehensive list and description for all of the statutory and
regulatory terms and conditions that will apply to the Tribal Transit
Program are set forth in FTA's Master Agreement for the Tribal Transit
Program available on FTA's Web site at: https://www.fta.dot.gov/17861_
18441_ENG_HTML.htm. In addition, as part of their application for
grant award, tribes that are selected for award will be required to
sign the Certifications and Assurances for the fiscal year in which
they apply for a grant. The Certifications and Assurances are set forth
for informational purposes in Appendix B of this Notice. Notably, FTA
has required each applicant to submit certifications and assurances for
each fiscal year in which the applicant seeks funding and an award is
made. But because less than two months remain before the end of fiscal
year 2006, FTA will treat certifications and assurances submitted by an
Indian tribe in either fiscal year 2006 or 2007 as having fulfilled
Federal certification and assurance requirements for Tribal Transit
Program applications submitted and awards made in both fiscal years
2006 and 2007.
IX. Application and Submission Information
This announcement includes all of the information that a tribal
government will need to apply for competitive selection. It is
available on the FTA Web site at https://www.fta.dot.gov. FTA will
announce final selections on the Web site and in the Federal Register.
A synopsis of this announcement will be posted on the government-wide
electronic grants Web site at https://www.GRANTS.GOV.
X. Guidelines for Preparing Grant Application
FTA is conducting a national solicitation for applications under
the Tribal Transit Program. Project selection will be made on a
competitive basis. FTA will divide the applications into three
categories for the purpose of reviewing and selecting projects to be
funded:
A. Start ups--applications for funding of new transit service;
B. Existing transit services--applications for funding of enhancements
or expansion of existing transit services; and
C. Planning--applications for funding of planning studies and
operational planning
The application should provide information on all items for which
Indian tribes are requesting funding in FY 2006, and indicate the
specific category in which the tribe is applying.
XI. Application Content
A. Applicant Information
1. Name of federally-recognized tribe and, if appropriate, the
specific tribal agency submitting the application.
2. Dun and Bradstreet (D&B) Data Universal Numbering System (DUNS)
number if available. (Note: if selected, applicant will be required to
provide DUNS number prior to grant award and DUNS number is required
for submitting through GRANTS.GOV).
3. Contact information for notification of project selection:
Contact name, address, and fax and phone number.
4. Description of public transportation services currently provided
by tribe, if any, including areas served.
5. Name of person (s) authorized to apply on behalf of tribe
(signed transmittal letter should accompany application if submitted in
hard copy or e-mail).
B. Technical, Legal, and Financial Capacity To Implement the Proposed
Project
Indian tribes that cannot demonstrate adequate capacity in
technical, legal and financial areas will not be considered for
funding. Every application must describe the tribe's technical, legal,
and financial capacity to implement the proposed project (see attached
Appendix B, Section B).
1. Legal Capacity: Provide documentation or other evidence to show
that the applicant is a Federally Recognized tribe. Also, who is the
authorized representative to execute legal agreements with FTA on
behalf of the Indian tribes? If currently operating transit service,
does the Indian tribes have appropriate Federal or State operating
authority?
2. Technical Capacity: Give examples of the tribe's management of
other Federal projects. What resources does the tribal government have
to implement a transit project?
3. Financial Capacity: Does the Indian tribes have adequate
financial systems in place to receive and manage a Federal grant?
Describe the tribal government's financial systems and controls.
C. Project Information
1. Budget: Provide the Federal amount requested for each purpose
for which funds are sought and any funding from other sources that will
be provided. If applying for a multi year project (not to exceed 4
years), show annual request for each year by budget line item.
2. Project Description: Indicate the category for which funding is
requested i.e., start-ups, enhancements or replacements of existing
transit services or planning studies or operational planning grants to
address project development i.e. development of vehicle and equipment
specifications and provide a summary description of the proposed
project and how it will be implemented (e.g. number and type of
vehicles, service area, schedules, type of services, fixed route or
demand responsive, route miles (if fixed route) and size of service
area, major origins and destinations, population served, and whether
the tribe provide the service directly or contract for services? How
will vehicles be maintained?
[[Page 46965]]
3. Project Timeline: Include significant milestones such as date of
contract for purchase of vehicle(s), actual or expected delivery date
of vehicles, and service start up dates.
D. Application Evaluation Criteria
Applications for funding of transit services should address the
application criteria based on project to be funded (for more detail see
section XII)
1. Criterion 1: Project Planning and Coordination.
2. Criterion 2: Demonstration of Need.
3. Criterion 3: Benefits of Project.
4. Criterion 4: Financial Commitment and Operating Capacity.
Applications for planning grants should address the criteria in
section XII, C of this Notice.
E. Submission Dates and Times
Complete applications for Tribal Transit Program must be submitted
in one of the three ways: electronically through GRANTS.GOV, in hard
copy to Federal Transit Administration, 400 Seventh Street, SW., Room
9311,Washington, DC 20590, Attention: Lorna R. Wilson; or sending by e-
mail to fta.tribalprogram@dot.gov. by October 16, 2006 or submitted
electronically through the GRANTS.GOV Web site by the same date. FTA
will announce grant selections when the competitive selection process
is complete.
F. Intergovernmental Review
This program is not subject to Executive Order (EO) 12372,
``Intergovernmental Review of Federal Programs.''
G. Funding Restrictions
Only applications from eligible recipients for eligible activities
will be considered for funding (see section VI). Due to funding
limitations, applicants that are selected for funding may receive less
than the amount requested. The application process will allow an tribal
government to apply for multiple years of funding not to exceed four
years, subject to the availability of annual appropriations. Up to $2
million will be made available for start up or new systems, no more
than $25,000 will be awarded per planning grant. The remaining funds
will be made available for applications for funding of enhancements or
expansion of existing transit service.
H. Other Submission Requirements
Applicants submitting hard copies should submit 3 copies of their
project proposal application to the Federal Transit Administration, 400
Seventh Street, SW., Room 9311, Washington, DC 20059, Attention Lorna
Wilson, or apply electronically through the government wide electronic
grant application portal at www.GRANTS.GOV. Alternatively applications
may be submitted as an attachment to mailbox:
fta.tribalprogram@dot.gov. If applying by e-mail, fax signature
documents to 202-366-7951, Attention: Lorna Wilson.
XII. Application Review Process
A. Competitive Selection Process
FTA will divide applications into three categories. The three
evaluation categories are as follows:
Start-ups--applications for funding of new transit
service.
Existing transit services--applications for funding of
enhancements or expansion of existing transit services.
Planning--applications for funding of transit planning
studies and/or operational planning.
Applications will be grouped into their respective category for
review and scoring purposes. Applications for planning will be
evaluated using a pass/fail system, whereas start-up and existing
transit services applications will be scored based on the evaluation
criteria to determine rank for funding award determination purposes. An
applicant can receive up to 25 points for each evaluation criteria.
FTA intends to award the full amount of funding available in FY
2006 for the Tribal Transit Program. FTA encourages applicants to
review the evaluation criteria and all other related application
information prior to preparation of application. Applicants may receive
technical assistance for application development by contacting their
FTA regional Tribal liaison, TTAP center, or the National RTAP office.
Contact information for technical assistance can be found in Appendix
C.
B. Evaluation Criteria for Start-up and Existing Transit Service
Proposals
The use of quantitative data and estimates, whenever possible,
improves the proposal's clarity in comparison to all the evaluation
criteria.
1. Criterion 1: Project Planning and Coordination (25 points)
In this section, the applicant should describe how the proposed
project was developed and demonstrate that there is a sound basis for
the project and that it is ready to implement if funded. Information
may vary depending on whether the tribe has a formal plan that includes
transit.
a. Applicants without a formal plan that includes transit are
advised to consider and address the following areas:
i. Provide a detailed project description including the proposed
service, vehicle and facility needs and other pertinent characteristics
of the proposed service implementation.
ii. Identify existing transportation services available to the
tribe and discuss whether the proposed project will provide
opportunities to coordinate service with existing transit services
including human service agencies, intercity bus services, or other
public transit providers.
iii. Discuss the level of support either by the community and/or
tribal government for the proposed project.
iv. Describe the implementation schedule for the proposed project
including time frame, staffing, procurement, etc.
b. Applicants with a formal transit plan are advised to consider
and address the following areas:
i. Describe the planning document and/or the planning process
conducted to identify the proposed project.
ii. Describe how the mobility and client access needs of tribal
human service agencies were considered in the planning.
iii. Describe what opportunities for public participation were
provided in the planning process and how the proposed transit service
or existing service has been coordinated with transportation provided
for the clients of human service agencies, with intercity bus
transportation in the area, or with any other rural public transit
providers.
iv. Describe how the proposed service complements rather than
duplicates any currently available services.
v. Describe the implementation schedule for the proposed project,
including time frame, staffing, procurements, etc.
vi. Describe any other planning or coordination efforts that were
not mentioned above.
Based on the information provided as discussed in the above
section, proposals will be rated on the following:
i. How sound is the basis for the proposed project?
ii. Is the project ready to implement?
2. Criterion 2: Demonstration of Need (25 points)
In this section, the application should demonstrate the transit
needs of the tribe and discuss how the proposed transit improvements
will address the identified transit needs of the tribe. Applications
may include information such as destinations and services not currently
accessible by transit, need for
[[Page 46966]]
access to jobs or health care, special needs of the elderly and
individuals with disabilities, income-based community needs, or other
mobility needs.
Based on the information provided the proposals will be rated on
the following:
a. What is the demonstrated need for the project?
b. How well does the project reduce the need?
3. Criterion 3: Benefits of Project (25 points)
In this section applications should identify expected project
benefits. Possible examples include increased ridership and daily
trips, improved service, improved operations and coordination, and
economic benefits to the community.
Benefits can be demonstrated by identifying the population of
tribal members and non-tribal members in the proposed project service
area and estimating the number of daily, one-way trips the transit
service will provide and the number of individual riders. There may be
many other, less quantifiable, benefits to the tribe and surrounding
community from this project. Please document, explain or show the
benefits in whatever format is reasonable to present them.
Proposals will be rated on the basis of:
a. Improved transit efficiency or increased ridership;
b. Improved mobility for the tribe;
c. Improved access to important destinations
d. Expected average cost per trip on the proposed service.
e. Other qualitative benefits.
4. Criterion 4: Financial Commitment and Operating Capacity (25 points)
In this section, the application should identify any other funding
sources used by the tribe to support existing or proposed transit
services, including human service transportation funding, Indian
Reservation Roads, or other FTA programs such as Job Access and Reverse
Commute (JARC), New Freedom, section 5311, section 5310, or section
5309 bus and bus facilities funding.
For existing services, the application should show how Tribal
Transit Program funding will supplement (not duplicate or replace)
current funding sources. If the transit system was previously funded
under section 5311 through the State's apportionment, describe how
requested Tribal Transit Program funding will expand available
services.
Describe any other resources the tribe will contribute to the
project, including in-kind contributions, commitments of support from
local businesses, donations of land or equipment, and human resources.
To what extent does the new project or funding for existing service
leverage other funding?
The tribe should show its ability to manage programs by
demonstrating the existing programs it administers, in any area of
expertise such as human services.
Points will be awarded based on the degree to which:
a. The project deploys new services or complements existing
services.
b. Tribal Transit Program funding does not replace existing
funding.
c. Tribe has or will provide non-financial support to project.
d. Tribe has demonstrated the ability to provide other services or
manage other programs.
e. Project funds are used in coordination with other services for
efficient utilization of funds.
C. Evaluation Criteria for Planning Grants Proposals
Criterion: Need for Study
For planning grants the applications should describe in no more
than three pages the need for and a general scope of the proposed
study.
Based on the information provided, proposals will be rated pass/
fail based on the following:
a. Is the tribe committed to planning for transit?
b. Is the scope of the proposed study for tribal transit?
D. Review and Selection Process
Each application will be screened by a panel of members including
FTA headquarters regional staff, and representatives of the Indian
Reservations Roads Program. Incomplete or non-responsive applications
will be disqualified. FTA will make an effort to award a grant to every
qualified applicant.
XIII. Award Administration Information
FTA will award grants directly to Federally recognized Indian
tribes for the projects selected through this competition. Following
publication of the selected recipients, projects, and amounts, FTA
regional staff will assist the successful applicants to prepare an
electronic application for grant award. At that time, the tribe will be
required to sign the Certification and Assurances contained in Appendix
B. The Master Agreement is available on FTA's Web site at https://
www.fta.dot.gov/17861_18441_ENG_HTML.htm.
Applicants that are selected for grant awards under the Tribal
Transit Program will be required to formally designate, by resolution
or other formal tribal action, an authorized representative who will
have the authority to execute grant agreements on behalf of the Indian
tribes with FTA and who will also have the authority on behalf of the
Indian tribes to execute FTA's Annual List of Certifications and
Assurances.
FTA will notify all applicants, both those selected for funding and
those not selected, when the competitive selection process is complete.
Projects selected for funding will be published in a Federal Register
Notice.
XIV. Other
A. Technical Assistance
Technical assistance regarding these requirements is available from
each FTA regional office. The regional offices will contact those
applicants selected for funding regarding procedures for making the
required certifications and assurances to FTA before grants are made
and will provide assistance in preparing the documentation necessary
for grant award.
B. Certifications and Assurances
Applicants that are selected and formally notified of FTA's
intention to award a grant under the Tribal Transit Program will be
required to complete and execute FTA's Annual List of Certification and
Assurances in accordance with the procedures described in this Notice
of Funding Availability. The Annual List of Certifications and
Assurances is attached in Appendix B for informational purposes only.
C. Reporting
49 U.S.C. 5335 National Transit Database requires NTD reporting for
all direct recipients of section 5311 funds including tribes. Specific
procedures and data requirements for tribes have not yet been developed
and will be provided to grantees at a later date. Annual progress
reports and financial status reports will be required of all grantees.
D. Agency Contact(s)
Contact the appropriate FTA regional Tribal Liaison (Appendix A)
for application-specific information and issues for general program
information, contact Lorna R. Wilson, Office of Transit Programs, (202)
366[dash]2053, e-mail: Lorna.Wilson@dot.gov. A TDD is
[[Page 46967]]
available at 1-800-877-8339 (TDD/FIRS).
Issued in Washington, DC, this 8th day of August 2006.
Sandra K. Bushue,
Deputy Administrator.
Appendix A--FTA Regional Offices and Tribal Transit Liaisons
Region I--Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Connecticut, New Hampshire,
Vermont and Maine, Richard H. Doyle, FTA Regional Administrator, Volpe
National Transportation Systems Center, Kendall Square, 55 Broadway,
Suite 920, Cambridge, MA 02142-1093, Phone: (617) 494-2055, Fax: (617)
494-2865, Regional Tribal Liaison: Judi Molloy.
Region II--New York, New Jersey, Virgin Islands, Letitia Thompson,
FTA Regional Administrator, One Bowling Green, Room 429, New York, NY
10004-1415, Phone: (212) 668-2170, Fax: (212) 668-2136, Regional Tribal
Liaison: Rebecca Reyes-Alicea.
Region III--Pennsylvania, Maryland, Virginia, West Virginia,
Delaware, Washington, DC, Susan Borinsky, FTA Regional Administrator,
1760 Market Street, Suite 500, Philadelphia, PA 19103-4124, Phone:
(215) 656-7100, Fax: (215) 656-7260.
Region IV--Georgia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Florida,
Mississippi, Tennessee, Kentucky, Alabama, Puerto Rico, Yvette G.
Taylor, FTA Regional Administrator, 61 Forsyth Street, S.W., Suite
17T50, Atlanta, GA 30303, Phone: (404) 562-3500, Fax: (404) 562-3505,
Regional Tribal Liaisons: Jamie Pfister and James Garland.
Region V--Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Michigan,
Marisol R. Simon, FTA Regional Administrator, 200 West Adams Street,
Suite 320, Chicago, IL 60606-5232, Phone: (312) 353-2789, Fax: (312)
886-0351, Regional Tribal Liaisons: Victor Austin and William Wheeler.
Region VI--Texas, New Mexico, Louisiana, Arkansas, Oklahoma, Robert
Patrick, FTA Regional Administrator, 819 Taylor Street, Room 8A36, Ft.
Worth, TX 76102, Phone: (817) 978-0550, Fax: (817) 978-0575, Regional
Tribal Liaison: Lynn Hayes.
Region VII--Iowa, Nebraska, Kansas, Missouri, Mokhtee Ahmad, FTA
Regional Administrator, 901 Locust Street, Suite 404, Kansas City, MO
64106, Phone: (816) 329-3920, Fax: (816) 329-3921, Regional Tribal
Liaisons: Joni Roeseler and Cathy Monroe.
Region VIII--Colorado, North Dakota, South Dakota, Montana,
Wyoming, Utah, Lee Waddleton, FTA Regional Administrator, 12300 West
Dakota Avenue, Suite 310, Lakewood, CO 80228-2583, Phone: (720) 963-
3300, Fax: (720) 963-3333, Regional Tribal Liaisons: Jennifer Stewart
and David Beckhouse.
Region IX--California, Arizona, Nevada, Hawaii, American Samoa,
Guam, Leslie Rogers, FTA Regional Administrator, 201 Mission Street,
Suite 1650, San Francisco, CA 94105-1831, Phone: (415) 744-3133, Fax:
(415) 744-2726, Regional Tribal Liaison: Donna Turchie.
Region X--Washington, Oregon, Idaho, Alaska, Richard Krochalis, FTA
Regional Administrator, Jackson Federal Building, 915 Second Avenue,
Suite 3142, Seattle, WA 98174-1002, Phone: (206) 220-7954, Fax: (206)
220-7959, Regional Tribal Liaisons: Bill Ramos and Annette Clothier.
Appendix B--Federal Fiscal Years 2006 and 2007 Certifications and
Assurances for the Federal Transit Administration Tribal Transit
Program
In accordance with 49 U.S.C. 5323(n), the following certifications
and assurances have been compiled for the Federal Transit
Administration (FTA) Public Transportation on Indian Reservation
Program (Tribal Transit Program) authorized by 49 U.S.C. 5311(c)(1). It
is customary for FTA to require each applicant to submit certifications
and assurances for each fiscal year in which the applicant seeks
funding. But because less than two months remain before the end of
Federal Fiscal Year 2006, FTA will treat certifications and assurances
submitted by an Indian tribe in either Federal Fiscal Year 2006 or 2007
applicable to applications for Tribal Transit Program assistance
submitted and awards made in Federal Fiscal Years 2006 and 2007.
The Indian tribe, as an eligible applicant for Tribal Transit
Program assistance, understands and agrees that these certifications
and assurances are pre-award requirements and do not encompass all
statutory and regulatory requirements that may apply to the Indian
tribe or its Project. A comprehensive list of those requirements will
be contained in the Grant Agreement including the Master Agreement
accompanying an award under the Tribal Transit Program.
FTA and the Indian tribe also understand and agree that not every
certification and assurance will apply to every Project for which FTA
provides Federal financial assistance through the Tribal Transit
Program. The type of Project will determine which requirements apply.
For example FTA believes that the following requirements within the
listed certifications and assurances will have limited, if any, impact:
1. Many provisions required by the Office of Management and Budget
(OMB) set forth in Certification F involve requirements that in most
cases will not be invoked, such as:
a. Title III of the Uniform Relocation and Real Property
Acquisition Policies Act, as amended, and implementing U.S. DOT
regulations will apply only when the Indian tribe acquires real
property with FTA assistance.
b. Title II of the Uniform Relocation and Real Property Acquisition
Policies Act, as amended, and implementing U.S. DOT regulations will
apply only when the Indian tribe's project requires relocation of a
person or business; and the Lead-Based Paint Poisoning Prevention Act
is invoked only in connection with residential construction, not likely
to take place under the Tribal Transit Program
c. The Flood Disaster Protection Act applies to projects in flood
hazard areas.
d. Only for construction projects will the Davis-Bacon Act, Seismic
Safety regulations, and OMB engineering supervision requirements apply.
e. Many environmental protection requirements are limited to the
specific problem addressed by the statute. If, for example, the project
will not affect endangered species, the requirements of the Endangered
Species Act will not be invoked.
2. With respect to Certification H, ``Bus Testing,'' only if the
Indian tribe acquires the first bus of a new bus model or the first bus
of a new major configuration of a new bus will FTA's Bus Testing
requirements be invoked.
Except to the extent that FTA determines otherwise in writing, each
Indian tribe that applies for Tribal Transit Program assistance,
however, must provide all certifications and assurance set forth below.
FTA may not award any Federal assistance under the Tribal Transit
Program until the Indian tribe provides these certifications and
assurances.
A. Assurance of Authority of the Indian Tribe and Its Representative
The authorized representative of the Indian tribe and the attorney
who sign these certifications, assurances, and agreements affirm that
both the Indian tribe and its authorized representative have adequate
authority under Federal and Indian tribal law, regulations, or by-laws
to:
(1) Execute and file the application for Federal assistance on
behalf of the Indian tribe;
[[Page 46968]]
(2) Execute and file the required certifications, assurances, and
agreements on behalf of the Indian tribe binding the Indian tribe; and
(3) Execute grant agreements with FTA on behalf of the Indian
tribe.
B. Standard Assurances
The Indian tribe assures that it will comply with all applicable
Federal laws and regulations in carrying out any project supported by
an FTA grant. The Indian tribe agrees that it is under a continuing
obligation to comply with the terms and conditions of the Grant
Agreement issued for its project with FTA. The Indian tribe recognizes
that Federal laws and regulations may be modified from time to time and
those modifications may affect project implementation. The Indian tribe
understands that Presidential executive orders and Federal directives,
including Federal policies and program guidance may be issued
concerning matters affecting the Indian tribe or its project. The
Indian tribe agrees that the most recent Federal laws, regulations, and
directives will apply to the project, unless FTA issues a written
determination otherwise.
C. The Indian Tribe's Capacity To Comply With Relevant Section 5311
Requirements
The Indian tribe assures that:
(1) It has or will have