Notice of Inquiry and Request for Comments on the Topic of Facilitating Access to Copyrighted Works for the Blind or Persons With Other Disabilities; Notice of Public Meeting, 13268-13270 [E9-6637]

Agencies

• Library of Congress
• Copyright Office
• Copyright Office, Library of Congress

[Federal Register Volume 74, Number 57 (Thursday, March 26, 2009)]
[Notices]
[Pages 13268-13270]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Printing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: E9-6637]


=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

LIBRARY OF CONGRESS

Copyright Office


Notice of Inquiry and Request for Comments on the Topic of 
Facilitating Access to Copyrighted Works for the Blind or Persons With 
Other Disabilities; Notice of Public Meeting

AGENCY: United States Copyright Office, Library of Congress.

ACTION: Notice of inquiry and request for comments; notice of public 
meeting.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The United States Copyright Office (Copyright Office) and the 
United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) seek comment on the 
topic of facilitating access to copyrighted works for ``blind or 
persons with other disabilities'' \1\ in connection with a forthcoming 
meeting of the Standing Committee on Copyright and Related Rights of 
the World Intellectual Property Organization. Interested parties are 
invited to submit comments on the topics outlined in the supplementary 
information section of this notice. The Copyright Office and USPTO also 
announce a public meeting on the same topic.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \1\ Various terms are used formally and informally throughout 
the world. When inquiring about experiences within the United 
States, the term used in this Notice of Inquiry is that which 
appears in U.S. copyright law. See 17 U.S.C. 121(d)(2). There, the 
term ``blind or persons with other disabilities'' is defined to 
include individuals who are eligible or who may qualify in 
accordance with the Act entitled ``An Act to provide books for the 
adult blind,'' approved March 3, 1931 (2 U.S.C. 135a; 46 Stat. 
1487).

DATES: Initial comments on the Notice of Inquiry and Request for 
Comments are due on April 21, 2009. Reply comments are due on May 4, 
2009. The public meeting will be held Monday, May 18, 2009, from 9:30 
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
a.m. to 5:30 p.m.

ADDRESSES: 

Notice of Inquiry and Request for Comments

    If hand-delivered by a private party, an original and five copies 
of a comment or a reply comment should be brought to the Library of 
Congress, U.S. Copyright Office, Public Information Office, Room LM-
401, 101 Independence Avenue, SE., Washington, DC 20559, between 8:30 
a.m. and 5 p.m. The envelope should be addressed as follows: Office of 
Policy and International Affairs, U.S. Copyright Office. If delivered 
by a commercial courier, an original and five copies of a comment or 
reply comment must be delivered to the Congressional Courier Acceptance 
Site (CCAS) located at 2nd and D Streets, NE., Washington, DC, between 
8:30 a.m. and 4 p.m. The envelope should be addressed as follows: 
Office of Policy and International Affairs, U.S. Copyright Office, Room 
LM-403, James Madison Building, 101 Independence Avenue, SE., 
Washington, DC 20559. Please note that CCAS will not accept delivery by 
means of overnight delivery services such as Fedex, United Parcel 
Service, or DHL. If sent by mail (including overnight delivery using 
U.S. Postal Service Express Mail), an original and five copies of a 
comment or reply comment should be addressed to U.S. Copyright Office, 
Office of Policy and International Affairs, Copyright GC/I & R, P.O. 
Box 70400, Washington, DC 20024.

Public Meeting

    The public meeting will be held in the Montpelier Room of the 
Library of Congress, James Madison Building, 6th Floor, 101 
Independence Avenue, SE., Washington, DC 20559. The process for 
submitting requests to attend and observe or participate in the 
meeting, as well as the agenda, will be published on the Web site of 
the U.S. Copyright Office no later than April 8, 2009.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Maria Pallante, Associate Register, 
Policy and International Affairs, or Michele Woods, Senior Counsel for 
Policy and International Affairs, by telephone at 202-707-1027, by 
facsimile at 202-707-8366 or by electronic mail at mpall@loc.gov or 
mwoo@loc.gov.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: 

Background

    The United States is a Member State of the World Intellectual 
Property Organization (WIPO) and an active member of the Standing 
Committee on Copyright and Related Rights (SCCR). At recent meetings of 
the SCCR, WIPO facilitated discussions on the topic of copyright 
limitations and exceptions, including limitations and exceptions for 
``blind, visually impaired and other reading-disabled persons.'' \2\ At 
its next meeting (May 25-29, 2009), the SCCR will continue to consider 
this topic, among others, and will exchange information and experiences 
in order to deepen its collective understanding of the issues. As part 
of the process, the SCCR is looking to the copyright limitations and 
exceptions that are currently available for the benefit of the blind, 
visually impaired and other reading-disabled persons around the world, 
and has invited Member States to provide supplementary information 
regarding their national laws and experiences.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    \2\ This term appears in some relevant WIPO documents. See e.g. 
``Conclusions of the SCCR,'' November 5-7, 2008, at https://www.wipo.int/edocs/mdocs/copyright/en/sccr_17/sccr_17_www_112533.pdf (last visited on March 20, 2009).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

    In preparation for the meeting, the Copyright Office and the USPTO 
have been gathering relevant information. To date, the Copyright Office 
and USPTO have participated in a series of informal meetings and 
conference calls (primarily with stakeholders from the blind community, 
but also with representatives of the library, book publishing, 
software, motion picture, and nonprofit sectors) in which multiple 
specific issues have been identified and a number of common points have 
emerged.
    On the basis of these preliminary discussions, the Copyright Office 
and the USPTO understand that blind and other persons with disabilities 
in the United States navigate many complex challenges when it comes to 
accessing copyrighted works. Common refrains include delays in 
obtaining accessible texts (with timeliness of accessible materials a 
particular problem for students at all levels), compatibility problems 
between available formats and the hardware devices employed by the 
reader, and inconsistencies in the quality and accuracy of the 
available, reformatted works. At the international level, the Copyright 
Office and the USPTO were made aware of the existing framework through 
which accessible works move across borders (i.e. through private 
agreement and interlibrary

[[Page 13269]]

programs), as well as some of the difficulties the framework presents.

Possible Actions

    Through discussions with stakeholders and previous meetings of the 
SCCR, the Copyright Office and USPTO are aware of some measures that 
might be appropriate for action at the national or international levels 
(through Member States, WIPO or other mechanisms). Such possible 
actions include the following: (1) Developing standardized 
accessibility formats and other technical norms; (2) establishing 
trusted intermediaries to coordinate resources, eliminate unnecessary 
duplication of accessible works, and ensure best practices; (3) 
providing technical assistance, coordination, and educational outreach; 
(4) promoting market-based solutions achieved through private sector 
copyright licenses or other agreements; and (5) developing binding or 
non-binding international instruments, including a treaty that would 
establish minimum requirements for limitations and exceptions for 
blind, visually impaired and other reading-disabled persons. The 
Copyright Office and the USPTO are interested in learning how these 
areas of focus might address existing difficulties with access to 
copyright works, whether applied alone or in combination with each 
other. Suggestions as to measures not covered above are also welcome.
    Please note that WIPO posts various documents from its meetings on 
its Web site, including reports and agendas related to the 
consideration of copyright limitations and exceptions. Documents from 
SCCR meetings that included consideration of this issue can be found by 
starting at https://www.wipo.int/meetings/en/topic.jsp?group_id=62 and 
following the link to information for each specific meeting. A study on 
copyright limitations and exceptions for the visually impaired can be 
found at https://www.wipo.int/meetings/en/doc_details.jsp?doc_id=75696.

Subjects of Inquiry

    At this time, in order to allow further opportunity for interested 
persons to provide their views, the Copyright Office and the USPTO are 
seeking comment on several focused topics related to the provision of 
access to copyrighted works for blind and other persons with 
disabilities. Unless otherwise specified, the focus of the inquiry is 
the experiences of interested parties residing or doing business in the 
United States. Nevertheless, parties should not feel constrained from 
describing transnational experiences and situations if they are 
illustrative of a problem or success.

A. Experiences of Persons Within the United States With Respect To 
Accessing U.S. Works or Sharing Accessible Copies Within the United 
States

    In general, the Copyright Office and the USPTO seek to learn more 
about the experiences of the blind or persons with other disabilities 
with respect to accessing and sharing U.S. copyrighted works within the 
United States. Please reference any specific policies, practices and 
projects that exist or are emerging in the education, library and 
business sectors while considering the questions set forth below.
    1. Applicable Statutory or Regulatory Provisions: The United States 
has relevant existing limitations on exclusive rights in the Copyright 
Act. Section 121 (the so-called ``Chafee Amendment'') authorizes the 
reproduction of copyrighted works for blind or other persons with 
disabilities under certain circumstances. Section 121(a) contains 
general language providing that it is not copyright infringement ``for 
an authorized entity to reproduce or to distribute copies or 
phonorecords of a previously published, nondramatic literary work if 
such copies or phonorecords are produced or distributed in specialized 
formats exclusively for use by blind or other persons with 
disabilities.'' Section 121(c) provides a specific limitation 
applicable to publishers of ``print instructional materials for use in 
elementary or secondary schools'' so that they may create and 
distribute electronic files consistent with the Individuals with 
Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). 17 U.S.C. 21(c). Those electronic 
files must use the National Instructional Material Accessibility 
Standard (NIMAS). Id. How have the Chafee Amendment and related 
statutory and regulatory provisions worked in practice?
    2. Private Sector Initiatives: The Copyright Office and the USPTO 
are aware that book publishers have been involved in the development 
and implementation of Section 121 and other laws applicable to 
disabilities and education. What are additional ways in which the 
private sector facilitates, or plans to facilitate, access to 
copyrighted works? Please identify and describe in detail any existing 
business models, licensing schemes, or technological innovations that 
are relevant, not only for books but for other copyrighted works, e.g., 
magazines, newspapers, motion pictures, and software. To date, what has 
been the result of these efforts in terms of achieving accessible 
content? Do best practices exist? Turning to the nonprofit sector, what 
are the activities, business models, or technology platforms that have 
emerged and what has been the result to date? What if any are the 
additional projects under consideration?
    3. Library Programs: Libraries play an important role in providing 
access to copyrighted works for the blind or persons with other 
disabilities. The Library of Congress, through its National Library 
Service for the Blind and Physically Handicapped, provides Braille and 
audio materials (e.g., talking books) to eligible borrowers through 
cooperating libraries in the United States. NLS also provides 
interlibrary loan services to citizens of other countries through 
qualified libraries or other institutions in those countries. Private 
organizations, such as Bookshare, provide access to digital materials 
through an online searchable library. What other sorts of libraries or 
library services currently facilitate access to copyrighted works? What 
physical and digital delivery methods are being used? What initiatives 
have libraries taken to develop new services and to respond to evolving 
needs and technologies? What coordination exists among national and 
international library services?
    4. Standardized Formats, Programs and Devices: In recent years, 
entrepreneurs and other representatives of the blind or persons with 
other disabilities have made significant progress in efforts to upgrade 
and standardize the technical formats, programs and devices that allow 
access to books and other text. These include the talking-book format 
of DAISY (Digital Accessible Information System) that is compatible 
with screen readers, as well as stationary and portable DAISY players 
that feature synthetic-voices, and various versions of scan-and-read 
software. Paper-based Braille has evolved into digital formats that 
offer refreshable displays and nonlinear search capabilities when used 
with applicable devices. Are there additional innovations in use or 
under development today and, if so, what is their focus? What are the 
impediments, and possible solutions, for improving existing 
standardized formats, programs and devices, developing new ones, and/or 
facilitating their interoperability?
    5. Resources: To what degree is a lack of sufficient resources a 
factor in providing access to the blind or persons with other 
disabilities? What governmental, private sector, nonprofit, or 
philanthropic resources exist? What types of resources are most needed?

[[Page 13270]]

What approaches to expanding available resources are most promising? 
What objectives could be met and in what time frame if additional 
resources were available?

B. Experiences of Persons Within the United States With Respect To 
Accessing Foreign Works or Sharing Accessible Copies of U.S. Works With 
Foreign Persons

    Please comment on the experiences of the blind or persons with 
other disabilities with respect to accessing foreign works within the 
United States, or sharing accessible copies of U.S. works with 
similarly-situated persons outside the United States. What kinds of 
specific policies, practices and projects exist or are emerging in the 
education, library and business sectors? How do existing laws create 
incentives or constrain efforts? Please describe the ways in which 
technology has influenced or could assist in providing access to 
foreign works or the sharing of accessible copies. What are the legal 
or practical impediments to transnational access and how are they 
interrelated?

C. Other Comments on Facilitating and Enhancing Access to Copyrighted 
Works

    Please comment on the likely success of measures identified above 
under the subsection entitled ``Possible Actions'' under SUPPLEMENTARY 
INFORMATION. How might the measures best be leveraged, alone or in 
combination, to enhance access for the blind or other persons with 
disabilities? Are there additional governmental or private sector 
actions that might serve the objective of enhancing access to 
copyrighted works for the blind or persons with other disabilities?

    Dated: March 20, 2009.
Maria Pallante,
Associate Register for Policy & International Affairs, U.S. Copyright 
Office.
[FR Doc. E9-6637 Filed 3-25-09; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 1410-30-P